LIVE scanner
MaineScannerMaine, as it happens.
City Hall·Penobscot County DOT Hearing

Penobscot County Commissioners Hear DOT Easement Dispute for Stillwater Property

The Penobscot County Commissioners held a hearing to determine the fair compensation for landowner David Grant regarding easements taken by the Department of Transportation for a highway improvement project on Stillwater. The session featured testimony from a state appraiser who calculated values based on square footage and rental rates, while Grant's representative challenged the methodology and argued that the loss of trees significantly impacted the property's value and rental appeal.

Key points

  • State appraiser testified that permanent easement value for Parcel 27 was $1,100.26 and Parcel 29 was $400, based on a square-footage analysis of vacant land.
  • The appraiser estimated temporary construction rights at $741 for Parcel 27 and $200 for Parcel 29, using a capitalization rate derived from mortgage lending standards.
  • Grant's representative objected to the appraiser's lack of a registered consultant license for tree valuation and argued that the loss of 18 cedar trees and two hardwood trees reduced the property's privacy and marketability.
  • A dispute arose over whether the state's failure to provide a formal before-and-after appraisal for a rental property constituted a legal violation that the commission could remedy.
  • The commission noted that the state's temporary construction area was not physically marked on the ground but was included in the compensation calculation.

Next steps

  • The commission will continue the hearing to hear further testimony from the landowner and review the submitted exhibits regarding the property's condition and valuation.

Read the full transcript

Where this came from

Penobscot County Government YouTube
The summary and transcript were made by software from the public meeting video, with names checked against the official roster, then reviewed before publishing.
Watch the meeting ↗