← Back to MaineScanner

Penobscot County Commissioners Hear DOT Easement Dispute for Stillwater Property

2026-11-05 · 4h 31m · Source: DOT Hearing 11/05/26 (Penobscot County Government YouTube)
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:02] who've been in practice [0:06] and [0:08] commissioners commission state commission. We're going to decide this dispute [0:18] is [0:21] commissioner Dave. [0:26] Thank you. Dave just told me he was given 300 last night dealing with the county budget. So [0:41] committed statute suggest that we have county commissioner [0:49] we have apprais to be employing [1:04] well and treat you well to my here is Richard Essen Brook he is the secretary for the state and he has a little bit of routine business to take care of Richard you have to Thank you. [1:30] 2026. We are in Bangor and [1:36] David Grant and two parcels one David Grant and the other name [1:48] they are 27 and 29 [1:54] project number 229501 [1:57] and it's it official name is Steve Warner [2:06] [clears throat] [2:07] Swear in [2:16] swearing. [2:23] I do. proceed. [2:27] [laughter] [2:29] Thank you. Also along [2:33] the [2:39] state took a couple of pieces of land [2:44] took ments [2:55] and what's happened to me is the state has [3:00] dam images to Mr. Grant and his C what the state believes the value of the easements is. [3:11] We're having a hearing here today so that the land owner Mr. Grant can tell us what he thinks the value is. And our job here is deciding what the number is. We don't have jurisdiction over anything else. [3:32] Site improvements related issues. That's really not what we [3:40] talk about the land is worth it was taken. And just to clarify for everyone's benefit, so the do takes what we call easements. They don't take it [3:57] and is illegal for someone else's land for some specific purpose. And so staying [4:13] an easement for the purposes of [4:17] a side dage. [4:24] So the way it works is here at this hearing is the state is going to put on an explanation of what it offered to Mr. Grant. [4:40] It will present evidence through its lawyers [4:45] and Mr. [4:49] when you're done ask [laughter] questions that you may have been said [4:57] may have questions ourselves [5:00] but when the state is done [5:04] here he's going to shrink [5:12] that the states that is So that's make it clear [5:22] which is not going to happen. [5:27] So, [5:30] does any question [5:47] just make some noise [5:51] that we need to do? Okay, this vitality [6:01] secret is a topic there to both the D and Mr. [6:09] Okay. [6:15] Good morning. Thank you, Jim Billings from the DOT. first of all, we've set up the eel in the middle here. Can everybody on the commission see that? Okay. We need it a little closer. [6:28] Bring it up closer. [6:31] And if it's okay with the commissioners, we would just have to sitting as long as [6:40] this chair. [6:42] If you need to if you think we can't say it, you want to want me to twist it just a little. That's good. Now, [6:59] next I [7:19] and [7:22] while there [7:28] was mistakes [7:31] Richard is not our secretary he is our clerk and I apologize for that what is worth you may proceed so just by way of introduction we Few people that are disabled here [8:01] is going to be witnessing first witnesses. [8:05] Okay. Any of you folks sitting way back there, if you want to bring your chairs out, feel free to do so. Okay. You don't need to stay away. [8:40] Oh, awesome. [8:43] Mr. Kelly, would you raise your eye, please? You swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. [8:51] Thank you. [8:53] All right. Tell us your name, please. [8:55] What's your job? [8:57] Principality. [8:59] And how long have you been in that job? [9:03] And what general of the job description? [9:12] to prepare and then test [9:17] the policy to [9:22] and before this position did you work for the DOT and some other [9:30] without going back to 1990s have you had other jobs at the DOT where you've had some familiarity or respons responsibility over the state right away. yes. 2003 as an assistant tech is assisted to control technician who enforce [10:07] and I move into the legal which is their [10:18] Are you familiar with [10:21] and we had to interpret those and implement [10:26] and are you familiar with the various associated this highway project? [10:32] Yes. [10:33] And if you brought I think you brought an exhibit with you today. exploded. Is that what exhibit one is? [10:44] Hey you with exhibit one and first I'll have you describe [10:53] in general just the nature of this project and what was its goal need [11:11] to end but we don't [11:16] Got it. Okay. [11:24] They call the middle of where the intersection is still [11:32] there. CD improvements also installation of pedestrian crossing heads. the radius radius turn radiuses [11:43] were improved to allow safety to access [11:53] install [12:00] and was when the DOT was analyzing deciding whether to make this project or Were there any concerns about traffic or traffic backing up anywhere? [12:31] They move through the intersection still [12:40] lower accessible and it is [12:54] [laughter] [13:07] okay. So it's a it's what separates this from McDonald's so to speak. [13:13] Okay. Thank you. [13:14] Yes sir. [13:15] All right. And the configuration that we saw out there this morning at the MW with the single left hand turning lane from College Avenue West onto Stillwater. Is that a final configuration from the DOT? [13:29] The intersection has been built a final mark in order to change the use of lanes. The oldation remains until the new section and the more comprehensive model. [13:43] And is there a reason they don't want two left hand turn lanes on distilled water going west right now? [13:48] Yeah, because they don't want the amount of traffic that [13:56] to then invade the bridge. [14:01] So the bridge project is a separate project, a separate win. Yes. So, the bridge is [14:13] and the bridge is west today. [14:19] And is that a single lane in each direction that bridge that in the future? [14:27] All right. So, when the bridge is done, what is the DO's plan with the left hand turns off college? his plan is to allow both again both lanes turning left off to enter [14:43] and then they single cross the bridge. [14:51] [14:58] could you describe the rights that were required by the department on parcels 27 and 29? [15:06] Yes. 27 29 changes [15:21] that was taken [15:25] section. Before [15:40] I forget, if your phones are not silenced yet, [15:49] I was supposed to say that again. [15:54] and so [16:01] that [16:08] and [16:11] exhibit one is a is that accurate depiction of the lay [16:20] exhibit [16:32] No. [16:33] Did you say I didn't hear what this would [16:38] Oh, you have no objection. [16:44] Thank you. So, how does the is everyone break down the square footage? What are the units on there for the lights? The evening time is is 176 plus or minus 4 and the temporary construction rates 205 plus [17:04] that's on the narrow pan of partial 297 [17:11] total [17:19] 76 [17:22] you are you able to say what the general width of the yellow area is on exhibit one moving from left to right. [17:34] The evening area is roughly 5 ft and moves lines as to the east of the edge of the property. [17:45] And so the total area that's on there I says 423 square feet. You know 27 that's the total amount of permanent rights the department took and on parcel 29 is 176 square ft of permanent rights. [17:59] Correct. [18:00] Other than that these are all temporary rights that refer to the land owner within the project. [18:12] Do you know if the elevation of the highway changed at this location change at the area where the sun is located? Essentially before it would be the output [18:30] was lower to face to create what we call and then the area of the sidewalk start [18:42] elevation changes to the house. [18:47] judgment. The state also had an extra x. [18:58] So they drop into [19:09] small [19:20] you want to dispute something said you need to wait to personality. So that's fine. You don't know. Okay. If you object to something, you would have to object to the form of question. And I did because it was a perfectly good. So your role in this part of the game is [19:50] terms of giving your story. [19:57] Miss Kelly [20:09] stand [20:24] What's the basis of your [20:25] because I want to be strong. [20:31] Okay, that's a good you can discuss that to communication. You can only object to question as being okay and I have question [20:48] this is [clears throat] two basically graph paper check each box represents food and there's a dash line and a solid line just on the top where it says the station number is 3350. 0. You see that? [21:08] What is the difference between the solid lines and the dash line? [21:12] The dash line was prior to construction. The solid lines represent the operations as they [21:19] and the number I just recited 33.50. These change as you look down at the three separate illustrations crosssections. One of those correspond [21:37] and so can you show on exhibit one where the station numbers are station numbers are here 340 you see 33 plus and then refer to your exhibit two you can see at one of the top says 33 plus 50 which would indicate the midway between 33 plus 04 [21:58] plus 0 which essentially is in the the section essentially roughly the center of the bus. So par of 27 is fully and 29 fully within the spread station 33 plus 0000 to 34 0. [22:17] I think I believe that 29 is a few feet beyond [22:22] just a few feet. [22:23] Just a few feet. And is there a distance a common distance between this the whole numbers and the station name that the department uses? [22:30] Yes, the station distance is uniform. [22:34] Okay. And so in that 100 ft distance from 33 to 34 some of these crosssections as denoted by the station underneath are represented in exhibit 2 and they would be located like this across exhibit one. [22:51] Correct. [22:54] is exhibit two clearly and accurately to show the design moves for building [23:04] two [23:09] in my presentation I'm going to show that no submit relevant information so I would [23:23] But I will bring it up. [23:26] Okay. You're objecting because you disagree with some of the information on this plan. [23:31] Yes. [23:33] well, I don't think we can prevent the state from us point of view. [23:43] No, that's fine. I'll check. I think we should note with the record that [23:50] if we sell fellow commissioners, do you have any problems in exist exhibit two? [23:59] No, I don't have any problem. You want to brush up? [24:08] Okay. So, I'm going to deny your objection and I'm going to note that it was granted over the objection of Mr. Green. [24:20] Is that okay, Mr. [24:23] M. Kelly? There's a red line on each of the crosssections on exhibit 2. Can you say what that is? [24:34] That's the new [24:38] and then [24:42] with respect to [24:47] the change is there an indication on here where the cell line is? [24:55] It's 121.60 [25:04] at the 0.1. [25:06] So from left to right there's a zero. That's the center line. Correct. Did that change on the project? [25:13] And [clears throat] so the sidewalk that was new is on Mr. Grant's side. [25:20] Yes. [25:21] And Mr. Grant's side with a red line on exhibit two. [25:30] Yeah. [25:34] Which [25:39] red lights [25:51] three, please? [25:55] Okay. [26:13] Can you identify what that is? [26:14] It is a taken as issued. [26:18] And is that what the department uses to acquire right domain? [26:22] Yes. And is it recorded on the registry of deeds? Okay. [26:25] And does that have basically have registry of deed markings on file and this is the operative notice of layout taking of this project concerning the rights required for Mr. Marina. That's [26:38] I would move to admit exhibit three. During the objection to this concern, [26:43] well the objection I have that we is this is all right is that this [26:54] suggest that they're taking all it doesn't say that they're taking it easy [27:03] response to that goes to the way goes to the wave if anything not the admissibility this is file all the state. [27:17] So we have a recorded document that is a legal document that already took the right contract. It's what the dispute is about and so it is admissible and rules of evidence which don't even so it's certainly admissible in this proceeding. If the landowner disagrees with the inventor or the legal meaning of something or he doesn't like the taking, he gets to testify about that. [27:41] I can't keep this out of evidence. And I respect that and I agree with what you've just said. Can you show me where if anywhere this document describes an as [27:56] that's once it's admitted? Yes, I was going to do that. on page three describes all fair [28:04] question [28:06] notation on the top right that's the reg notation [28:11] correct shows that it's in the registry [28:19] okay I noted your objective again [28:24] but I believe the stock is admissible because it's a public document there registry markings [28:37] which mean it's a public record document and therefore [28:46] thank you. [28:49] Yes sir. [28:51] Do you see a description of highway easement there? [28:54] And I don't want you to read this. Everybody has it in front of them. Okay. Is it not page three of exhibit three? [29:04] is your understanding of that it's a permanent right that the department has taken and underneath that it then describes the several areas by less and bounds descriptions of the most require. And is it your understanding that the easement of highway is described as the display uptaking is reflected in exhibit one as the yellow areas? [29:30] Yes. [29:31] And the department's engineers the surveyor laid this out. [29:34] Correct. [29:36] the right that has been taken on the highway easement. Does that include the right to install permanent fixtures? [29:46] It does. [29:47] And to maintain them? [29:49] It does. and to enter the property and construct, maintain and do anything consistent with utilities and the operation of a public way. [30:00] Yes. Would you next turn to the temporary construction [30:17] temporary construction island? [30:23] You have that. And is that the describing the right that was acquired as illustrated in purple on exhibit one? [30:31] Yes. [30:32] And is that a right that stays after the project or is that right sort of go away or evaporate if you will? [30:39] So is the temporary enforcement? [30:43] All right. And does that include the right during the time the rights exist to enter onto the property? [30:53] Yes. And in the second paragraph under the temporary construction rights that also includes the right to dig and bill around cut trees and basically work in the area until the project is concluded. [31:07] That's correct. [31:16] Did you take [31:19] of property? [31:20] I did. Right. Those are your two correct get in front of you. [31:44] All right. So, is 4 A partial 27 and 4 B partial 29? these Utah [31:53] sometime after most of the construction was done these pictures let's start with u there's a date on April 28th this year is that roughly when you took the pictures [32:07] and did these barely and accurately depict the condition of the property as of that date April 286 [32:14] yes [32:15] and the same or that you've attempted to get parcel 29 same day April 28, 2026. [32:25] Yes. [32:26] Do those open grass impact or be clearly? [32:33] Yes. I move a [32:39] second to [32:52] these pictures after the project was complete. [32:58] Yeah, I get it. [33:01] Okay. great. [33:08] [clears throat] [33:09] Well, that makes it easy. Thank you. [33:13] 4 A and 4 B. [33:30] and access. [33:35] No, you don't. [33:49] So, [33:52] Mr. [clears throat] [33:56] Mr. had some concerns about a puddle or some water pooling in one of his properties. Did the department take any steps to try to remedy that? [34:05] Yes. [34:15] spread of this year. [34:19] It is something we're seeing. [34:23] And so did you see it in the in the stage that Mr. Branch is complaining about? [34:28] Was there was it a wet day when it was water? Can you show us probably either on one of the photographs or ons [34:50] the face bottom of that entrance there was a puddle of water standing and wasn't flowing properly to the catch bas [35:01] and you said the contractor came back as a warranty and remedies that [35:08] and did you see it after that work? [35:10] Yes. [35:12] Yes, it is. [35:16] And is the department satisfied contracted [35:22] sign? [35:22] Yes. [35:25] Whether [35:28] Mr. Grant's either [35:41] in terms of [35:43] this next [36:12] So as the overall area [36:26] and so as part of the excavating digging when we bill in the temporary construction the department will land in the new construction with the old untouched here [36:56] and when the apartment because people's driveways changes elevation slightly. Is that something they typically try to do? Some people can still use their driveways sort of match up [37:07] Yes. [37:08] their property too. [37:10] Yes. [37:11] And did you see any work done in this area that was outside the temporary construction lines? [37:19] I don't [37:27] Okay. [37:29] Kelly [37:37] in this project are there any other easements utility [37:43] gas water that you're [37:48] well I'll say the easements taken [37:58] between [38:17] [snorts] [38:23] [38:26] you mentioned it's been said there's another lane that's been that accurate. [38:34] Is that entirely in the existing entire? [38:39] Well, I'll say that. Yeah. Well, the old was here. Yes, I would say yes. [39:16] There's no traffic. [39:40] would that be coming from college or is that [39:56] to any drainage I think you just did to stage any impact that didn't [40:05] impact that or didn't [40:25] basic [40:29] [clears throat] [40:32] question of this witness. [40:41] [clears throat] [40:46] You shall [40:48] recall [40:55] in the fall [40:59] which was [41:02] actually [41:06] the tree. [41:10] Is that correct? [41:13] And you're adding a cell screen. [41:17] Yes. [41:19] And then on [41:24] 33 + 12 [41:34] these maps are very different. I can't speak to why objects or vegetation. So, [41:43] so if there was a tree on and you didn't show it, this is an incorrect representation condition. [41:55] Look at me. I question [42:01] this attorney. [42:04] Is that correct or not? It's an incorrect representation that doesn't treason [42:16] [clears throat] [42:26] false representation. Well, it's already been admitted and it's your testimony that there was a tree in this specific crosssection 33.0.0. [42:51] [clears throat] [42:54] Yeah, sure. [42:55] Okay. So your contention is there. Can you show us where this 33.5 again? [43:08] 33 here. [43:09] Yeah. [43:10] 31 here. So somewhere this line. So it's roughly within. [43:17] Okay. Can you see that? Okay. Thank you. [43:24] Quest two unad. [43:27] You've been asked the witness questions, but the leg testify. [43:30] Okay. But I would like to put my response and ask him for unad. [43:37] Why don't you do what you supposed to do to it? We'll see where it goes. [43:40] All right. There's no testimony that a tree or [43:48] there's no test [43:51] supposed to be right now. Questionless. So there's nothing to undermine the testimony of this exhibit at this time. So I ask you not to request to unend exhibit two. This document has already been admitted as an exhibit. So, I'm going to revisit that. [44:15] then I guess it's back to ask questions. Say it again. [44:19] It's your turn to ask questions. So, you don't know. It's okay. I just haven't tried this. It should be exactly on this. Okay. This is not the time to tell us that. You're going to have as much time as you need to tell us what you don't like about the state's case [44:40] and you may think it's information is not accurate. So, we're not going to debate that right here and now. [44:48] They give their side of the story, you give your side of the story to sort through those testimony. [44:58] Understand? [44:59] Okay. [45:04] Any other questions? So this one is [45:21] you testify. [45:24] It states that you're taking a keyman instead of hunting. My originally my understanding would be that by showing exhibit three specifies aging for right away purposes [45:47] you [45:50] excuse me Mr. [45:53] I don't believe he's the lawyer, but [45:56] he did he did testify. [46:01] So, [46:02] well, he testified that this language on created a highway east. [46:08] Yes. My contention is that the original taking was taking the entire problem. [46:17] Well, I don't know anything except what's in front of me. I do know that this is the document. There's no other documents that describes the nature of what was taken from your property. And I think it does a very good job of explaining that the state is taking an easement [46:38] and not what we call decentrality. [46:41] My point is that if they presented it the if they filed an easement for highway purposes the registry that's one thing they file if they file treatment to entirely this is a file taking [47:04] yes this is the notice of layout and I this document pretty much covers everything what was taken and why and how and where. [47:18] So if your comment is you don't think this describes engagement we listen. [47:28] So has another question from you. [47:47] on your channel [48:00] within this show some vegetation within these [48:10] pictures [48:14] trees. Well, [48:18] they're not they were rope bushes, but they weren't pine trees. He was studying. [48:24] So, is that done toilet taking? [48:29] Well, it's actually [48:33] it's [48:36] so because it's created to show something and it also shows at least a fair representation of what happened. So [clears throat] let's say for example there were [48:52] five 12 in diameter of pine trees sitting in that yellow strip. Would you have a shot that [clears throat] [49:07] you know [49:21] it's a general what's [49:28] Okay. So, [49:37] you [49:44] don't have a question? [49:45] No. [49:46] Do you have any more questions? [49:49] You want to put on a testimony? I have something. [49:54] Go ahead, [49:55] Mr. Kelly. Did the department add traffic as this project or just facilitate the flow of the existing traffic? [50:03] Facilitate the current advertise to pay people to drive by this location. [50:10] And did they show every tree on the rightway plan and every [clears throat] mailbox and every item that's in the right way? [50:18] And what's the purpose of the right way? Whatever the plan to show [50:30] mainly as opposed to construction, [50:34] right? [50:50] [snorts] [50:51] Okay. You are excused. [50:54] Yes. You want to say anything about [51:03] you may [51:09] just [51:12] want to raise your hand, please. You to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth. You may proceed [51:28] work department transportation. [51:31] And what you do there right away doing that [51:38] 26 and a half plus years [51:40] at the department. [51:41] Yes, sir. annual license [51:45] and does that [51:48] education training appraisal evaluations are being [51:56] yes [52:01] to first go through hour training you have to take a state Yes. [52:18] Take courses institutes such as [52:32] every two years [52:36] and courses [52:44] over the years by highway department [52:52] association etc [52:59] we do internal training to work on maps I'm engineer but after many years you learn, you know, [53:17] can you have any special training in [53:27] Can you explain just terms [clears throat] the difference between acquisition and Okay. A whole property semi financed or bought, [53:39] right? when you're doing a an appraisal be appraisal on the call [53:49] individual you're l you have to be licensed [53:54] you have to follow those use which is standard practice [54:02] when you work for the department of transportation jurisdictional exception granted to the to some of our [54:15] we have to follow better hiring and Daniel I do work for my employer which is [54:29] this is subject to the name state board. [54:39] This is an internal appraisal [54:43] that I have done with the department for the last 27 years. I dealt with 17 [55:00] commission this time. [55:06] So I think I'm quality to do this. Did you appraise the property we're going to talk about today? The [55:13] I did as well as maybe some other propert [55:18] in this. [55:19] Yes. [55:20] Did you look at the property take a satisfaction? [55:25] Yes. I first looked at it early June [55:31] 2021, [55:33] which is five years ago. [55:36] What was the date for this? [55:38] November 15th, as far as I remember. But you [55:42] so you went about five or six months before [55:46] and I went several times in between that to do kind of sales research to [55:55] etc. go to the city and talk to the city assessor talk. [56:05] So yes, I'm showing. [56:15] Yes. [56:18] So [56:23] it's five and five. [56:27] Yes. And he's going to exhaust properties. But as far as I know, are they connected properties pre? Yes. I won't by all [56:47] this picture. [56:52] I took photos. [56:53] Do you want 25 or 26? [clears throat] [56:57] 21. [57:00] So you took these pictures when? [57:03] June 21. [57:05] Thank you. [57:11] Does anyone have any questions? [57:21] Christian. [57:43] There's so these are you're going to testify these are similar to [57:51] yes [57:54] for the most part area same size [58:03] to these pictures being [clears throat] [58:10] dispute that there were trees. [58:13] Trees. [58:14] We don't dispute that there were trees. We know there were trees. [58:17] Okay. No debate between witnesses and the state. [58:24] You can direct your question. [58:28] Well, I just keep these into [58:37] these with evidence at this hearing. Did you analyze what the properties for? [58:45] Yes. [58:48] Properties [58:50] basically [58:53] section are in our zone [58:59] change again. Mr. grant properties on the low density residential one in the district for city and the use that is being made of the property is that permitted use [59:17] he as far as I understand is it for rental [59:27] single family purposes [59:31] other uses such as schools, churches, parks. You can occupation [59:48] here [59:53] taking effect [1:00:02] people's cars. [1:00:09] didn't [1:00:17] because [1:00:27] you put it to edit [1:00:33] his mask [1:00:36] return [1:00:40] his existing uses I suggest use this and that's the digital change that [1:00:50] in only your opinion of value did you use a specific appraisal approach [1:00:57] I guess the sales approach to [1:01:01] research land sales for the whole town in the same zone or one was actually in the R2. [1:01:13] So were you comfortable with the availability of the sales to use for? [1:01:20] Yes, the sales that you describe [1:01:24] size of the lot. Auto's just down the road on the right [1:01:29] fields behind it. [1:01:34] Still a lot of revenue. And when you're looking for comparable sales on a strip tape like this, are you looking for sales of properties with businesses or buildings on them? [1:01:49] Why? [1:01:52] First of all, this is a partial It's not a full table, not taking we're looking at taking this whole house. You're interested in strip [1:02:05] also what the what the damage and the value might be the temporary. So the next step is raising this chair larger parcel the larger paras [1:02:40] in my interation there was No damages to the remaining property behind that red line. This used to not change. [1:02:52] So there's no cyber damages which means we're looking at [1:02:58] if there [1:03:01] if we raise the road 20 ft like we have in grass [1:03:07] and we're against his house with like this. Yes, in irony that there's going to be damages to that problem, but [1:03:20] just because we did put we put on with trees that did not change the size. So we're looking at a partic [1:03:38] typically on the market strips of land possible. So if you look at [1:03:46] vacant land sale similar in size [1:03:50] adjust value that 400 some odd square feet acquired multip [1:04:00] what unit did you use based on the size of the [1:04:05] square foot. So you were trying to derive a square value for a basically a piece of vacant land and a similar law supplies from a similar time period and in a similar location. Correct. And then you are allowed that what you felt for judgment was a swear price [1:04:27] sold in that time period that location and that and you ran then an opinion of value would be fairly complic [1:04:42] times the square state total [1:04:44] yes [1:04:45] and did you arrive and a damage amount with the yellow barrier on 27 that [1:05:09] you're looking at. [1:05:16] Just look at your notes. [1:05:23] Does he have a report or any [1:05:33] Okay. And so you're relying on a verbal testimony. What about these letters from [1:05:42] Scott? [1:05:53] So they're going to be part of your present. [1:06:04] says [1:06:24] break out [1:06:27] yesterday. So did you calculate the value of 42 square foot in highway eastment taken from Mr.7 [1:06:40] and what was the amount you came up with? [1:06:42] $1,100.26 [1:06:46] and was that based on the square footage times your unit value? [1:06:50] It was. What was the square foot unit value found in the area? [1:06:57] So [1:06:58] $262. [1:07:00] So in this 2021 time period, I'm going to go back and tell them sales 10 years, five years. [1:07:08] Well, in this case, the sales were relatively new. Yeah, they were year two almost. [1:07:15] Okay. So some are the same here. [1:07:17] So you had fairly temporary plan. We then looked at what the most parcels sold for divided the square came up the square price [1:07:30] if they were if the sales were slightly lariation [1:07:46] over one of my sales was maybe a here. So I adjusted [1:07:55] to [1:07:58] that status. [clears throat] [1:08:04] So you calculated $1,1828 [1:08:08] that's for the easement take and then you calculate the purple area the temporary construction for 27 [1:08:17] I did how you because it's temporary what are you trying what we're looking at is [1:08:27] in fact you look at this beliefs that state [1:08:34] with his super. [1:08:56] Okay. So, you basically looking at trying to employ Please and did you use the same where what price you used for the emental purposes [1:09:10] and then tell us your method all [1:09:15] multiplied square foot times the number of units right [1:09:19] yeah the [1:09:24] rate is 925 [1:09:30] times [1:09:33] Breathe out. [1:09:49] Okay. Yeah, that's [1:10:03] If you're in an area, [1:10:12] you typically have around 700 [clears throat] CC. So there's not a lot of comparable sales, if you will, to provide in the temporary construction. [1:10:26] Correct. [1:10:27] All right. So, you're trying to estimate the rental. [1:10:32] So, but you're multiplying unit value times the number of square feet impacted here, which is 765 square ft, right? [1:10:42] Yes. [1:10:43] And then you multiply that by a cap rate of 9.25%. [1:10:49] Which is the annual return on investment. you're testifying and I will ask him to testify strong. [1:10:59] So could you I didn't hear an answer to the question that came because it's a very specific to the thousands or hundreds. [1:11:11] Is that something from an industry manual or something you just bought and put down? Where did that number come from? [1:11:30] Like I said, we there's a formula to develop the rates using [1:11:38] market rates from [1:11:42] mortgage lending from a safe rate from what you get paid for. [1:11:52] as we wait it's called investment street. [1:11:59] So I guess what you're saying is this is some kind of number that comes out of [1:12:06] the in-house appraisal processes by mortgage lenders. [1:12:11] If I understood you correctly, [1:12:15] we're trying to get a value of trying to get rate as to what [1:12:24] that property will be. [1:12:27] Okay. Well, I understand that. But where does 9.25 come? What piece of paper, what formula would you use to arrive at that? [clears throat] It's called band investment. [1:12:44] It's a what investment? [1:12:46] Band of investment. [1:12:47] Band of investments. Could you just elaborate? Give us an executive summary of what band of investments are. It's based on [1:13:01] what they will lend money, what the rate is for [1:13:08] lending. [1:13:13] And so what I'm hearing you say if I may based on history and a lot of data you came up with this number which suggests that [1:13:28] the impact on market value for temporary construction due to less than 10 the total value [1:13:45] that strips [1:13:51] that be 30 some [1:13:56] years [1:13:58] and then you've got a multip [1:14:03] and so what did you come up with the total of the temporary construction $741 [1:14:12] is not. So that was basically [1:14:16] estimate of rental value when you place 750, [1:14:23] right? [1:14:23] And that is part of your opinion. That's part of your professional judgment on science. There's [1:14:31] the rental part. [1:14:56] So, let me ask you this question. principal, did you prepare exhibit six? [1:15:03] Yes. [1:15:10] So, you have to bear with me. I'm a math, but I'm not even that puts me in trouble. So, how do we get 184985 [1:15:22] to a total of 3410? [1:15:26] That's where I'm going to be asking. Okay. I'm sorry. So, you've got 184985 is the total for taking and then do you also compensate for any improvements the land owner had in the area we're taking that are not going to be available? [1:15:46] Yes. In this case, because they were planted trees for the most part, [1:15:53] we look at what those trees were the value. [1:16:05] So, yes. [1:16:07] And then did you break down what type of different [1:16:12] take? [1:16:15] Yes. What were their cedar trees and some as I call a volunteer? There's two hardwood trees that grow up amongst the cedar trees [1:16:26] and gravel driveway. [1:16:28] Yes. [1:16:29] And then is there a book or some market the thing you look at to determine these unit values that you've got on the six? as a guide [1:16:41] swift. [1:16:48] So that's the basis of [1:17:01] there's a gradient. [1:17:05] All right. And so did you determine a value for the speed of edge to 18 trees? [1:17:10] I did. [1:17:11] What was that? [1:17:12] 31 3,1 [1:17:17] 200 [1:17:18] the gravel driveway [1:17:23] $60. That's basically square foot. And on the $1,1826 that you paid is the highway. Did you discount that? What was it? Leasement from the B value. [1:17:40] Did you pay the same as you take? [1:17:44] I pay 100% the fee value. [1:17:48] Okay. Because essentially all of this [1:17:56] stick in the bottom of right two sticks [1:18:01] the state has control [1:18:05] whoever's coming. [1:18:08] So as a matter of [1:18:13] so he got a saying as if we had taken it with B but he retains the right. Yes. [1:18:18] Okay. Was abandoned. The land piece still was 19. [1:18:24] Yes. [1:18:26] Could you go through your calculations? Partial 29. You [clears throat] [1:18:32] use the same methodology. I assume [1:18:36] article 29 is bigger than article 27. So there was one other larger compet. [1:19:11] So yes, [1:19:23] [clears throat] [1:19:26] did you arrive at a unit value? [1:19:28] I did. [1:19:29] What was it? [1:19:30] Dollar. All right. And that was bas. And then did you multiply the 176 ft by that number to get the amount? [1:19:40] Yes. [1:19:40] And then did you do the temporary construction? Same number you did on partial 27. [1:19:45] Yes. [1:19:46] What was the improvements on 29? [1:19:52] 180. [1:19:55] So what did it pay? [1:19:59] $400. [1:20:10] This is exhibit since [1:20:15] your testimony you gave and the calculations you performed back in 2021 to arrive at whatever value. [1:20:24] Yes, it is. But I want you to move to amendments and assess as lawy [snorts] [1:20:49] package. Okay. [1:20:55] Okay. [1:20:58] Okay. [1:21:00] But I have [1:21:03] this. [1:21:04] Okay. [1:21:10] Did you think that the lack of removal of the trees affected the use of property? [1:21:17] It did not. [1:21:20] there. I think the other the other still project prior to this used before [clears throat] numerous homes up and down still water and on this project there was probably a dozen. [1:21:43] they arrest. [1:21:49] Do you you said there were no s damages on parcel [1:21:56] and did the project basically come out the way you expected? Have you seen the project any [1:22:02] did it come out at 5 years ago when did you basically had to imagine how the product was going to come out based on plans and whatnot? [1:22:10] Yes. [1:22:11] Did you see anything in the after project change your opinion of that? Did you around the time like back blow your palms like you get to see it change since you did your work in June [1:22:27] and change how value [1:22:35] so your opinion of value for what you've gone through if that's affected [1:22:45] And then I want to show you exhibit 7 A and 7B ask [1:22:55] question. [1:23:04] Yeah question [1:23:11] sports [1:23:14] either [1:23:23] Yes. [1:23:31] And is that your mind? Yes. [1:23:37] Is that a treat or a document that brings you [1:24:04] We can do it again. [1:24:09] So let me just [1:24:17] say exhibit 6 the 1849 represents the praiser's opinion of the value of the land that was became subject to highway east correct capitaliz [1:24:38] ones for the easement priority taking. [1:24:43] Okay. And there was some discussion about losing trees and whatnot. So basically what I'm seeing here is there were some cedar hedges 18 of them that you valued at 175. There were a couple of cardboard trees. How big were they? [1:25:04] you remember [clears throat] cedars or the highs [1:25:11] or land. So basically you were offering the land on the money for the land that was taken both temporarily and permanently as well as the [1:25:26] as well as this trees and hedges. [1:25:31] You recognize the 7 A7 [1:25:59] that's been [1:26:04] Who's Scottith? Scottith [1:26:18] is 7 and 7B or spawn. Basically raising the values that you just gave us to 27. [1:26:30] Yeah. So 7 A has 27 written on it. 7B has 29 written. You see that in the upper right. Yes. And so [1:26:41] excuse me. [1:26:48] Just hold on. [1:26:53] So is it the department's policy that Tim is based on your experience the property office 27 years send the land owner a communication offering and explaining the money that the department is offering for the acquisition department. [1:27:14] Well in this case Mr. Smith Mr. person [1:27:21] and the list of let's let's focus on Saturday. [1:27:31] Do you see where it says e acquisition count [1:27:39] and it has 423 square ft? [1:27:42] Yes. [1:27:43] Right. Is that correspond to the yellow area on exhibit one? [1:27:47] Yes, it does. [1:27:48] And is that the same quantity that you did along? [1:27:51] Yes, it does. [1:27:52] And then underneath that it says one head. Is that intended to mean as one tree? What's the word? [clears throat] [1:28:08] We have a [1:28:11] database [1:28:21] entry. You put in the numbers. [1:28:29] It turns out the way this is shown [1:28:35] it was done as one hedge as a union did each individual tree [1:28:44] a line chunks of tree would be 18 lines trees two more lines just a space saver basically [1:28:56] was and this was explained [1:29:00] [clears throat] [1:29:00] Is this the 7A the number one next to the hedge? Is that intended to show how many trees were taken in the acquisition? No, just [1:29:14] [1:29:17] I guess I want to admit exhibit 7 AD [1:29:25] not necessarily the truth in what they're showing but communications [1:29:36] testing [1:29:38] because we don't have Mr. Smith here. You're not offering the sort of the truth of the information, [1:29:47] right? As much as just to show us what has been offered to Mr. Grant, what are the communications, right? [1:29:58] Okay. you guys object you're going to object him to 7 [1:30:09] testified [1:30:11] just testified there was 18 trees 18 trees [1:30:18] trees this document show and this is this document isn't from Mr. This document is from Mr. Smith. Why must [1:30:34] this document this document needs to be excluded? [1:30:42] Well, based on my conversation with the data attorney, it's not being offered for the truth of the information in it as it relates to value. It is being offered to show that how much the state ultimately offered you. [1:31:03] And now the problem is with that too because Mr. Smith is also one of the reality that this property is a rental property. just heard a phrase that was saying it being rental property [1:31:25] once it's identified as mental property then it becomes a becomes a complicated evaluation evaluated [1:31:35] was in submission [1:31:39] okay again I'll draw these [1:31:44] there's not proposed to enter these. [1:31:50] You may use them on [1:32:09] treats. [1:32:14] young at first. And what do you mean? What do you mean don't at first? What happened after? [1:32:20] Well, at some point, Mr. Graham raised his voice a bit to turn around. I was going to get my plans out [1:32:36] in short. This is not [1:32:40] Did you have the information to do that? [1:32:46] [clears throat] [1:32:46] I count the trees in the sideway [1:32:51] and also took some pictures as well across the street and the neighbors to the east. And so based on the work you've done on this is your opinion here today that calculations you made [1:33:11] compensated the impact of taking [1:33:23] you [1:33:25] this witness. [1:33:29] I'm going to go back to it so I can understand [1:34:05] I believe it was [1:34:11] up against the As [1:34:25] is [1:34:29] I'm showing well. You see that? That rise of the purple line. It's about [1:34:41] That's right. There's two pictures in there. [1:34:53] You took these pictures, correct? I did. And the letter time he was snatching some pictures. [1:35:06] I don't think so. All right. [1:35:13] Couple of other details. Going back to the map, do you rely on math to tell you what the approvals are? You rely on food construction. [1:35:29] If you don't see bushes on the plan, does that mean there's no bushes? No. You see what's there? You have to see what's there. So isn't [1:35:44] [clears throat] and you did you did it through the value proposal right? No, that's generated by Okay. But in my world when it says fee acquisition, I think 100% [1:36:03] not East. Should it say Eastman? It says Eastman. [1:36:13] I don't. [1:36:17] Well, this says for the land and rights to be acquired. It says [1:36:28] nothing. [1:36:32] So we almost [1:36:57] well exactly sure when I started on parallel [1:37:03] I started off [1:37:30] the radio [1:37:34] testify that [1:37:41] change. [1:37:52] Is anyone check [1:37:55] those rates? [1:38:02] when it comes to you [1:38:06] say they had to go visit how do you get to that you talk to landscapers to get a sense of what the cost would be [1:38:20] cost is a replacement cost. [1:38:22] No we are not looking at it's a contributo value to the land. How do you how do you get to that? Well, you have to start [1:38:36] question. [1:38:52] [snorts] [1:38:57] Yes. And now you just start 100% of that. [1:39:01] Yes. Well, I mean [1:39:06] [clears throat] [1:39:11] I'll say [clears throat] [1:39:17] did you tweet that? [1:39:20] It was it was in [1:40:07] Yes. Correct. And the same may be true. Yes. [1:40:35] could be wrong about this, but it seems to me that the 2021 was pretty much the height of the co influenza or whatever it's called co problem [1:40:49] in our nation wasn't didn't co start to go through22 to generally [1:41:00] and I guess my question is between the summer of 2021 and I do you agree with me was I read in the newspapers that there was a dramatic decrease in property values during the co time period. Do you agree with that? as a general statement [1:41:26] three or four years. Yes. [1:41:32] So you don't think there would have been any change in market value. [1:41:42] No, but it seems to me that if it was just to take an example, the property was about [1:41:52] that particular year probably was [1:41:58] that just by [1:42:01] what I learned from [1:42:06] [clears throat] [1:42:09] I was looking at the [1:42:13] typically. [1:42:16] Okay. So, you didn't I think you answered his question. You just didn't consider the possible. [1:42:26] I love I love that there's any change in sales. [1:42:32] Okay. Thank you. [1:42:34] That's helpful. [1:42:37] Questions up here, [1:42:40] Mr. Grant, would you like to ask this gentleman question? [1:42:44] I would. I would. Mr. O'Brien lices a consulting. [1:42:54] isn't it true that in the state we have been solving to determine value? [1:43:05] No. [1:43:13] Is he attorney the witness at the same stop or [1:43:16] I just made that's what I did instead one word objection [1:43:23] you objecting to this question yes [1:43:30] what's the basis let me handle the objection [1:43:34] objection statement about the laws Exactly. [1:43:41] He said isn't it? [1:43:42] Well, he as he wasn't testify [1:43:48] answer. [1:43:52] Well, I think he asked question and I don't I think we can leave. [1:44:00] Any other questions of this witness? [1:44:07] Yes, I'm going to follow that same thing. [1:44:13] How can he make phrasal trees state? [1:44:24] Well, here's what I would recommend you do when it comes. I think he said I don't know and maybe he'll answer that question the same way but I think during your time it will be your burden to show us whatever law you're making and then [1:44:44] give your testimony on that. Okay. So much respectfully, does that mean I should retain Mr. Bryant here, follow that up during my awakening or will my ex be sufficient at that point? Well, I think this is your opportunity to ask him questions about his testimony [1:45:06] and u if you want to consult with your appraisal expert about questions take a recess [1:45:26] one minute. Yeah, sure. [1:45:50] Okay. [1:45:55] Yes. [1:46:01] What the software? What did you do? What did you use? [1:46:12] I've already testified that they're I thought they were worth $3,150 plus $200. So that's $3,350. So I don't know where zero method did you use for the final $3,150. [1:46:31] What did you use? You didn't specify [1:46:34] I guess Marshall Swift [1:46:39] Marshall Swift [1:46:45] that's for residential [1:46:57] yard improvement section that approach [1:47:04] Okay. What did you put in that were specifications from work? [1:47:11] It says in the report 18 plus two target trees that were not planted but I counted anyway. [1:47:20] And what did you put in for size? [1:47:27] They were I believe in Martians but under large [1:47:34] it's not me a different question. You see these trees. [1:47:50] Okay. So you just say that they were noted by this random They were all trees that have been trees. [1:48:04] They were never pulled out. But I needed to [1:48:11] eat with Mr. So [1:48:19] I was confused when he said [1:48:23] thinking they were dead. [1:48:27] Okay. So, you looked at [laughter] [1:48:35] Yeah. Tim, [1:48:42] do you think those trees or shoulders trees have to do they have any [1:48:52] marketable value against timber? [1:48:54] No. [1:48:56] I went to school with a new name for [1:49:01] Boston. We are [1:49:10] these trees. [1:49:19] These come under that category. [1:49:31] One last followup question. Did you consider the impact of the loss of the 20 trees on the privacy of the building? [1:49:46] I consider it. Yes, [1:49:48] indeed. Did you send value to it? [1:49:55] All up and down still [1:50:00] the subject. [1:50:01] Well, I that is probably true, but I don't think it's relevant. I guess what is relevant at least in my opinion is whether these trees and this building or these buildings especially the one closer to the road and a benefit that you quantify being behind some trees and [1:50:23] as opposed to exposed to a road. [1:50:28] Okay. You considered it [1:50:31] that be the aesthetic value [1:50:36] that passed. [1:50:44] Well, we have so I think we [1:50:48] thank you. [1:50:50] Okay, you guys all set this? [1:50:54] You all set? You want to read your record? ahead. [1:50:59] When you say not planted, are you trying to distinguish these trees from some other kind that will be worth? [1:51:10] Well, I said I counted them because of my introductions. [1:51:17] Is there [1:51:19] is there value [1:51:22] oral trees for example? [1:51:27] It's broken just [1:51:32] and when you said you pay you did not pay you know if you're $100 a tree is more complex than something [1:51:45] so much value flows is what a lumber [1:51:52] to come cut the tree shook it up. [1:51:59] So, and so the $200 that you paid for those retreats was in excess of that this and to are you able to tell and look at the comparable sales [1:52:14] presence or absence of trees contributes to market value. [1:52:22] I testified that there does not appear. [1:52:29] So I looked at it sailed up and down that route two core still [1:52:41] five or six years out and there was exactly the same number of sales [1:52:51] and I looked through all the pictures on soul and [1:52:58] edges of trees that are screaming. So [1:53:05] it would be hard for the press to [clears throat] play [1:53:21] you [1:53:23] sometimes make a tree or trees as you [1:53:32] This is [1:53:35] treason always [1:53:45] discussion [1:53:50] tree [1:53:52] claim that it's a sound. [1:54:01] So yes, trees have always been. So I think what your testimony was that you hadn't seen any evidence of that trees makes a difference. [1:54:27] I think [1:54:31] you might want to answer my question. Do you think the rental rate change [1:54:42] investigated that [1:54:48] looked at [1:55:02] At least one rather than back [1:55:09] because it's so close to the university. [1:55:28] Yeah. [1:55:41] from town [1:55:49] 183 [1:55:54] 183. Please [1:55:59] follow [1:56:13] very busy. So just discounting noise. Do you think that's considerate? treat them as a consideration or [1:56:24] there's been studies done on trees and it's basically doesn't [1:56:32] do you [1:56:34] no I don't just your just your test you can look so [1:56:45] that's okay [1:56:49] any other questions at this quickness, but I think participating in this hearing, I will want to bring him back up. [1:56:59] You're going to have as much time to do what you want to do. [1:57:04] Thank you. [1:57:05] Okay. You're excused as a witness. [1:57:08] I didn't want to have a discuss here at the table. it is now after 1:00. We should be here for a couple hours. [1:57:23] Mr. Gr, how long do you think it's going to take you to present? [1:57:27] Thank you. [1:57:38] So this don't let this size how long can people guess? Sometimes [1:57:53] you think [1:57:58] the extens [1:58:02] Take a hand. [1:58:17] What is your feelings continually? [1:58:37] What do you first? [1:58:55] Thank you. [1:59:02] We're just take [1:59:23] on already. [2:00:22] That makes it [2:00:43] The gods to give [2:00:56] Yes. [2:01:04] [clears throat] [2:01:25] No [2:01:36] If you can bring up an episode [2:01:51] 774 Hello. [2:02:16] Okay. Yeah. [2:02:31] Yes. [2:02:34] Yeah. [2:02:42] This would be [2:03:01] business isn't that easy. [2:03:08] You don't [2:03:30] miss Yes. [2:03:43] Here [2:03:49] is the sound of [2:03:59] [laughter] [2:04:09] so much money there. They were saying what 15% two years ago [laughter] [2:04:20] and there's another big [2:04:36] truth. [2:04:40] Yeah. [clears throat] [2:05:07] Yes. [2:05:18] I don't know. I don't know what [2:05:34] to get. [2:05:36] Oh my god. [2:05:48] Okay, appreciate it. [2:05:49] Speakers box. [2:06:03] Awesome. [2:06:17] Thank you. [2:06:31] Did you get something? [2:06:44] stand [2:06:49] last. [2:08:08] My petition is I don't want us to be eating while people are presenting. [2:08:21] just go [2:08:44] or you [2:08:49] CBC. [2:09:02] I thought that's how you spoke French. [2:09:07] She told me she says I don't know what that mean but they didn't know French. I said, "You tell that [2:09:29] they hit the [2:09:51] So, we're going to extend this break for another five minutes or so. So, [2:10:07] I think it would be [2:10:37] I think at 6 a.m. here we have a commission stay here. We had a project meeting for [2:10:48] another hour and a half back home. [2:11:02] I told him [2:11:28] to call that. [2:11:42] You really don't [2:11:49] want [2:11:55] to [2:12:02] We just change the change. [2:12:29] change the All [2:12:58] right. state. [2:13:04] How about you Mr. Mr. [2:13:18] I think it's a great idea. [2:13:22] This is [2:13:26] commercialing [2:13:36] to properties now. [2:13:43] Thank you. [2:13:49] And I understand has no further witnesses. They look chief. [2:14:01] The floor is yours. Finally, [2:14:06] whatever. [2:14:17] You want [2:14:26] me to [2:14:31] give one to [2:14:34] take that one off your desk, [2:14:41] right? Okay. I'm getting [2:14:56] to tell us your [2:15:01] you can sit but if you [2:15:06] break your do you square that the testimony you're the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth that we may proceed [2:15:21] in the in the interest of time and because [2:15:27] I would like to bring Mr. [2:15:32] Do you want him near you or do you want him closer? I think that would be good. [2:15:44] And let me bring you in, sir. [2:15:48] You promise the testimony you gave the whole [2:15:55] proceed. Tell us your name and why you're here. Tell us. [2:16:07] E L A C U H L A [2:16:30] Okay. Go ahead. [2:16:32] are you familiar with this property? [2:16:36] Yes. And did you do an appraisal property [2:16:50] back in May of 5.3 business. [2:17:01] We did not [2:17:04] [clears throat] provide. [2:17:10] We did very [2:17:19] specific area of culture and regard that [2:17:28] one certification that [2:17:33] certification to the proper certification. [2:17:38] so I'm very excited how should work. Okay. Show you [2:17:50] landscaping. [2:17:55] Yeah. [2:18:08] Yes sir. [2:18:11] [clears throat] [2:18:13] Yes. [2:18:16] Shoot. [2:18:24] Is she from Atlanta? Sorry, I missed something. [2:18:32] service [2:18:36] all this was taking place [2:18:40] and he had asked us for a place to replace these trees and we were trees there was a lot we [2:18:52] put to do that work and he found a company that works which is that quote that didn't happen. and by all indications, this is a reasonable quote from probably the only contractor in the city that could accomplish that work and source the tree. [2:19:14] And thank you, can I get to this position? [2:19:22] I'm sorry, I have to object. I log an objection. We had a 7A mark by a dot employee. It was not available for process the land owner objected to that. This witness did not appear page 113. There's no one here question this $160,000. [2:19:49] So [2:19:53] excuse me. You should interrupt him by [2:19:58] I object to the cons and witness meeting. Okay. I think he makes a good point. [2:20:09] You can't really testify about the contents of this piece of paper unless we have the offer over here to exam. [2:20:20] So you can give it to us for what it's worth. But if you want us to believe what's on this piece of paper from a man to tell us. [2:20:31] Sure. Sure. so we provide a quote for what we would be able to do. and due to the site changes that we quoted planting foot carbon which is all you could pick any space [2:20:51] and also [2:20:56] this package [2:21:11] 114 I Please [2:21:18] consider [2:21:39] your view over. Yes, sir. Those [2:21:43] are [2:21:47] fairly large. Those are only 12. [2:22:07] It's okay. I'm only mature. [2:22:15] 24 26 and you're talking about 12 [2:22:22] replace as from your perspective that's 12 foot the other one is fully grown. [2:22:30] Yes. [2:22:39] So is your testimony going to be focused on trees on market value? [2:22:47] I think I can speak to the man in which should [clears throat] be valued the kind of circumstance and also what [2:22:59] replacement of what would state is [2:23:05] about [2:23:10] 24,8 [2:23:14] So what would be grand tree? Is that what I'm reading here? [2:23:19] Yes. And that is for trees that are much smaller. [2:23:23] Oh yeah, that's three. Those are 12 foot 30,000 12T. And that's only eight of them because you can only [2:23:34] trees in the states. [2:23:49] Were you there when he planted the trees? [2:23:51] No. [2:23:52] Okay. So, I don't think you're confident. testified about how big the trees were when he played. So what you need to remember when you're in the so-called court proceeding, you can only testify on things you have seen with your own heard with your own ears, etc. [2:24:14] But if he tells you how they were, what he planted, you can't tell us that. He can. That's all. Yes. Okay. [2:24:23] Okay. [2:24:25] So let me ask you this question. [2:24:30] my recent break about 12° my [2:24:35] about 12 days [2:24:40] and I got a I got a group of Christ [2:24:46] only how many of the trees do you know [2:24:57] I would say they were all in the 25 call range. [2:25:09] And so you [2:25:20] will see the trees [2:25:28] 25 ft tall. [2:25:29] Yes. Okay. [2:25:33] And you [2:25:40] talking, listening, we're listening. [clears throat] I think there's a very large disparity in cost between what we have access to and what a true replacement cost for what was removed is. [2:25:58] So, is there a way for appraising replacement of a big tree with a small tree? [2:26:08] that would be a cost plus situation. You can't replace a big tree with a small tree and have provide the same benefits. And my understanding you compare the size for the small one to the larger one. [2:26:32] that is a would be a different method of revaluation. U which would not typically it would play into the cost of replacement. [clears throat] but this you know this is basically cost of replacement [2:26:53] situation but that's not you're not [2:26:58] two problems. One is one is not space. [2:27:08] Yes, a full 25 [2:27:12] must carry one at a time [2:27:18] to the planting site and then large amount of excavation could happen for even one single tree. [2:27:26] It would it would be physically impossible to replace these trees as they were. you would have to plant many small trees or there's no way to there's no way to replace that except you know cost plus [2:27:46] basis that is that would be to be what we would be able to but accurately represent the value [2:28:00] cost replacement content for that is cost replacement and acceptable. [2:28:11] Yes, cause on play is one of the only built by the consulting rights association which is only that will typically have any weight in a court tree. [2:28:31] Did trees provide sound visual? [2:28:35] Yes, substantially. That is a [clears throat] enormous way that people plant trees. particularly trees because they 're so dense they are very difficult to see through [clears throat] there's a ton of studies to show that [2:28:56] what is the recognized body or tree appraised [2:29:01] association [2:29:03] couple minutes ago we heard the appraisal [2:29:10] for these trees. We also heard he is not lic. [2:29:25] You can't answer the question. [2:29:29] It's outside the scope. [2:29:31] Sure. [2:29:33] He needs a lawyer to get into that. [2:29:40] Do you have to be licensed? [2:29:51] It absolutely would [2:29:55] license. [2:29:58] Well, I'm not familiar with what the license does. I think I think I can. [2:30:05] May I ask you this recognizing [2:30:12] the state requires anybody performing street work to possess a license [2:30:20] the title section? Do you know the title? [2:30:26] But that is a [2:30:27] that's your understanding of that you have license or some tree work or B in the state of [2:30:37] what is under the MR saying by statute there's a specific title section applying to this definition recognized by the state [2:30:49] yes and [2:31:00] could you please stand us back to Mr. [2:31:08] Just for clarification. I've got two documents in front of me for the record landing landscape construction with a 10B written on it on the side. My understanding is that there was an objection to that. I was sustaining and that this is not part of the regulation. I'm asking if it would be correct if he [2:31:31] Yes. [2:31:34] And I'm sorry. Just for the record, I'm now handing the key exc [2:32:04] you're you're saying there have to be a license. [2:32:09] If I were to look at standard trees and and give you a value, I would need to be a licensed arborist and that value would have to be typically the certification that would be needed is to be a registered consultant. [2:32:28] And do you have that classification? I do not [2:32:33] land. [2:32:37] This is [2:32:40] this is what is available for cost. [2:32:43] It was already landscaping is not here today to present evidence. you repeating it as a desert. so you [2:32:58] you're looking at the trees because you're not looking at the whole process, [2:33:03] right? [2:33:04] So you really don't [clears throat] say you're not judging the contributor behind a tree to the [2:33:12] right. Yeah. [2:33:16] may or may not impact the value depending on it impact anyway. [2:33:24] We don't know. [2:33:25] They may impact the value of the property but the trees themselves. [2:33:30] But so did you determine that the church were trees? [2:33:37] no we can't replace [2:33:42] it. [2:33:45] Okay. So, [2:33:48] right now as a consultant who likes it, can you walk out in the corner called landscape construction down and say, "I got a project here that I want to [2:34:07] someone's asked me to install 17 24 trees. Can you provide them and solid contract? Can you do that today? [2:34:18] yeah. Y [2:34:20] and they know they would say, "Yeah, we can do that." And then say, "Oh, this is Mr. and so you can walk out [2:34:35] and present." That's what [2:34:39] Yes. Well, excuse me, Mr. Grant. He could he can't give us the quote, expect us to believe what the quote says. Person who wrote the quote needs to be here so we can crossexamine him or her. [2:34:57] Okay? So when he goes out today, yesterday or six months ago, if he's not the company that has the knowledge, he can't testify about [2:35:11] that. He can tell me what he's [2:35:17] getting [2:35:20] because he's still [2:35:24] to provide the trees. He's That's that's his function. [2:35:28] But if he wants to enter that in a essentially a court proceeding, [2:35:34] he needs to bring in the person who wrote [2:35:38] it doesn't bring in the course person who wrote the quote. [2:35:42] Yes. [2:35:43] He can't testify about the Yes. He offered to us [2:35:54] the evidence from that. [2:36:02] It's not, excuse me, it's not going to help [2:36:11] in the next [2:36:16] while we're still hearing is taking place. You can do that. [2:36:23] Okay. So we done. [2:36:33] So what exactly is your license expertise? I'm certified for my personal international side of our culture certification [2:36:48] of its [2:36:54] to [2:37:01] that certification is one of only three represents to obtaining your registered consult. [2:37:11] Okay. Thanks. That's great. [2:37:16] Keep going. If you want to [2:37:20] That's all I need for at this time. [2:37:25] That's all I can. [2:37:27] Don't go anyway, sir. They want to ask you a few questions. You need to have your eyes. [2:37:39] Wow. Okay. So, you're you don't have the main license or certification as a registered consultant. [2:37:47] That is that is not the main issue license. That is [2:37:54] kind of organizational [2:37:59] certification that is accepting. [2:38:03] So the main license or certification you had as what again [2:38:07] that a main state license [2:38:10] main state license objects and what are you allowed to do with that or tree work [2:38:20] and what by what tree work what [2:38:23] all aspects of our culture so from pruning trees to removing trees planting trees and pretty much anything you can think of pertain to your tree. [2:38:39] So you're allowed to be a land owner [2:38:43] person or whoever you might be working on what it's going to cost to do certain work of trees. [2:38:48] Yes. [2:38:49] And you're allowed to do the [2:38:51] Yes. And then [2:38:53] Yes. Does your license allow you to give opinions of replacement cost of putting in two trees? [2:39:01] No. Which is what we have not. [2:39:05] Okay. So you're the reason I can give a quote I can give you a quote planting. I I would not be comfortable looking at your tree and saying that attorney is worth X dollars because that is a specific certification that very few people in the country. So you can't sit here today and tell this commission what Mr. [2:39:28] Gr's trees were worth in November of 2021. no sir. [2:39:33] And you can't say what they might have contributed to the value of the properties in November 2021. [2:39:44] [2:39:53] not in a quantifiable. [2:39:57] And you might have an opinion on whether it makes the property more attractive or desirable, but you can't turn that into a doll. [2:40:04] no. My opinion would be considered objective. you know, I do have a previous [2:40:13] and [2:40:16] you know there's [2:40:22] juice before they come. Yes, sir. did you talk to any of the tenants that Superman trends to either before November 2021 or not? [2:40:34] No. So, you don't know whether they pay the same with trees or without the trees? [2:40:39] No, I don't know. [2:40:42] I think that's what happens. [2:40:44] Okay. [2:40:45] Question. let me ask you other than the tree, do your service provide estimates for such things as canopy value such as privacy, sound, wind barrier, those type of protections are not directly [2:41:07] oriented toward the value of the tree itself. we don't buy value. we tend to plan things and you know we would make recommendations for you know somebody [2:41:33] that [2:41:37] my point is the requests for those value or they are part your client would translate into financial financial reality depending on the tree [2:41:58] example here [2:42:00] trees would be [2:42:05] yes that person was the person in value privacy when he think value. Does that translate in any way u reflected in your estimate or your [2:42:24] projected cost? [2:42:35] No, we don't. [2:42:39] Any [2:42:45] other testimony is with us. [2:42:55] Quick, did you prepare anything in writing for this hearing? [2:43:00] other for the work that we are. [2:43:05] Yeah. Okay. Thank you. package. [2:43:17] We should retain he did a [2:43:22] on the trees back four years ago. [2:43:26] Yes, he did. He did an appraisal [2:43:30] trees. [2:43:31] And is that [2:43:34] okay? What is that holding? We didn't have [2:43:36] this. Yeah. [2:43:40] And this would have to be entered into evidence or this would have to be [2:43:48] at the time originally [2:43:52] Mr. [2:44:01] You know, the trees and the supply, you know, [2:44:12] radio is [2:44:25] [clears throat] what ZX which is not [2:44:33] you want us to consider those as part of our decision making process. [2:44:39] Yes, sir. [2:44:40] Mr. Grant, do you want to offer that document as an exhibit? Yeah. [2:44:53] Just reence. [2:44:56] Well, relevance is [2:45:00] I guess I personally find it something. [2:45:09] Can you speak up? There's no replacement cause measure of damages in under law that is a subject of distance statutoily created body. The measure of damages this commission have more in the statute tree replacement value is not one of them. The measure of damage is this the value of property taken from a for analysis and whether there's separation [2:45:34] value to the of the property taken or activities. There's no replacement award for damages. There's no port damages. There's no incorporation title feeding or general port law trespass on [2:45:53] cross. [2:45:56] This commission is established by statue and it's laid out on the statue the sac [2:46:05] trees I would tax on the casket state that the do and every power and payment cost every tree. [2:46:20] Well, you're headed down an area outside of your statuto authorization. So, you should consider that the policy in the case of [2:46:29] I Well, thank you. My question is the scope and the scope of the definition [2:46:40] you [2:46:45] provide me that definition MS [2:46:56] does it a measure of damages put the loss I know you said it doesn't allow replacement [2:47:05] I think everything is related to value but I can pull the stat [2:47:10] and value that's what is the scope value [2:47:18] that's why [2:47:24] okay so you have a pending u what do you think areing this and you can address your concern Jim. [2:47:46] Okay, we're gonna open his objective. We're going to accept this. We're going to follow this exhibit A because they're the same numbers. You're gonna have letters. [2:48:01] Oh, the next one's going to be B. [2:48:06] Okay. So, your exhibit A has been [2:48:12] you can say as much as you want. [2:48:14] I think it's important to make the distinction between what has said as [2:48:24] replacement cost. [clears throat] replacement cost is actually not what I'm talking about the method for tree value that is by the record of the government association for finding the value of trees [2:48:44] is fox [2:48:49] so what I'm saying is that in order to determine value M branch tree network [2:49:03] is considered a valuation. [2:49:12] But I'm I'm concerned that we comply with the title and the of the law as it relates to value. The question is value that's going to be defined clearly in statute. I don't want to see that. [2:49:43] Okay. [2:49:47] Yeah. I would like us to any of us find sure. [2:49:53] to my office. Your [2:49:55] wife [2:50:06] made [2:50:06] Yeah. [2:50:15] How many copies for five copies? [2:50:18] Good guess. Thank you. All right. So, A has beened and [2:50:28] your test [2:50:32] by Mr. May 8 was [2:50:38] for this day and we did we took the office [2:50:47] now two [2:50:52] and $20,000 replacements on page 114. [2:50:59] We didn't put this in specifically because [2:51:05] it's her problem. It's the lady the other day problem and she's my neighbor. She's a she a and I knew that the state was doing this thing [2:51:18] trees [clears throat] on people's property my property also give me your estimate of that [2:51:30] makes sense to me you proposing to put this into so [2:51:40] look [2:51:51] So, if I'm not mistaken, this is in fact on page 1.4. [2:52:01] I know this isn't [2:52:04] but it's the same. It's similar to May 25th request. This [clears throat] is a little different [2:52:17] apple tree with neighbors. [2:52:24] The neighbors apple trees aren't relevant to this dispute. [2:52:31] It's not relevant to the value of this dispute. It will show up at the end of this pilot [2:52:39] operation that the state is doing I think. So going to show this is not [2:52:48] okay. Well, [2:52:52] I think that this document describing the value of apple trees use on property is not relevant because a it's not on this property grand property and earth trees there on apple trees. [2:53:13] Excellent. [2:53:14] So I if you were to offer this as an exhibit I will deny your [2:53:24] thank you. [2:53:41] Yeah, that's [2:53:47] you can continue if you wish. I can look back. I can do both. [2:53:53] So 56 [2:54:04] in [2:54:07] two stages are all seven. [2:54:15] Okay. So that elements to work. [2:54:34] Just got mentioned [2:54:39] don't have Thank you. [2:54:44] [clears throat] [2:54:47] But let not we can discuss that when we collaborate. [2:54:55] I don't want you over here. [2:55:01] Okay. [2:55:07] You can tell me you have a question. [2:55:16] as well. [2:55:39] Keep everything original. [2:55:42] to [2:55:46] Mr. [2:55:49] You. [2:56:00] Yes, sir. This was admitted. This is exhibit A. [2:56:07] Excuse [2:56:29] me. [2:56:32] You want to testify then? [2:56:37] If you're going to be describing what's in your testimon [2:56:45] [clears throat] [2:57:01] will [2:57:08] two [2:57:16] solo [2:57:28] where they basically avoid doing a before and after for [2:57:37] Medicare. [2:57:38] Okay, let me ask you this question. What is page two? [2:57:57] Yes, this is state. [2:58:04] contribution to this fun [2:58:13] because [2:58:22] they have done they have [2:58:28] lunch to deal with their [2:58:32] Well, you can talk about them if you want. Don't have that information, but we are back here by the state constitution [2:58:47] and this is not a federal issue [2:58:53] and specifically state law to this the issues before. So we are global with this as it relates to the revised statutes. [2:59:18] The consensus up here is this [2:59:23] [laughter] related phrases. [2:59:33] This document appears to be related to the [2:59:38] citizens and setting rules for they don't apply here because the federal government didn't take anything from you. [2:59:52] I have no objection to admitting any statuto or regulation citation or case citation. I don't see the need for Captain Branch to read from regulations. [3:00:10] Normally legal citation you cite a document and it's a legal citation. You don't need [3:00:17] a lot of this is what snippets [3:00:23] small of statutes and regulations [3:00:28] of a newspaper clipping this statute are we not the federal code is hundreds of pages long big CFR book so I don't object to these sites ations of statutes and rigs and stuff that's in here coming into evidence. [3:00:48] But I would say and just some title 14 statutes, they're incomplete. So to the extent that the commission is going to rely on law, they should look at the whole law, not put snippets of partial statutes and regulations. So if Cath Grant wants to save time and put in all of the statutes and regulations, I have no objection in that because I don't think they need to be in the exhibit to be sight to that. [3:01:16] But I would just ask the commission before it takes one quote of one page of 500 pages, the commission [3:01:27] trust federal. [3:01:32] consider that in the totality of the federal statute totality of federal regulations not one okay I understand your argument I guess I don't want to get documents in totality I ask this relevant my first not necessarily by commissioners is just is it relevant because it's not a federal ticket [3:01:58] the DT is mandated to follow federal laws and procedures and its right away refers to federal acquisition process and it has to certify federal highway following the federal statutes but the federal statutes allow for D's procedures in order to approve so that's why I'm having a problem with the parts of [3:02:26] the regulation don't they're bound by regations But pulling out little isolated portions. But listen, this as I look at it more carefully, this has to do when someone requests a favor. [3:02:46] It was all about waiting [3:02:50] to find out the year before. I don't believe any of this is relevant to this hearing. Said something with a quick recommended. [3:03:02] Thank you. That's exactly [3:03:06] Mr. presented he may have done. only thing that was presented to me was that little short on page thing which was in which was in fact a way and the statute wires for before and after [3:03:31] statute say what [3:03:33] which statute you say in the statute which statute [3:03:37] it's in state and it's also in federal [3:03:44] respect. You're neither a judge nor [3:03:52] especially [3:03:56] that they use they try to say it is a waluation. waiver evaluation means they don't have to do a before appraisal [3:04:13] they don't have to take into consideration all due respect sir I didn't hear say that he was making the waiver [3:04:22] presentation itself is [3:04:26] full he said he gave a full but the thing that was presented to me is not full appraise [3:04:33] okay but during this hearing I make a mistake put on a praiser an in-house appraiser who gave a verbal description to his appraisal techniques and the stuff that's usually [3:04:53] set together at least [3:04:59] show something different. But let's get back to page two. [3:05:06] This is [3:05:20] excuse me. A little bit of indulgence in most cases uncomplicated [3:05:26] value that have been considered to those unin strips of land acquisitions involving unimprovements damages [3:05:41] but significant cost. [3:05:45] So what they're saying is this imagination is if it's [3:06:05] a favor. [3:06:08] No. [3:06:08] Okay. So they didn't know they [3:06:12] didn't know [3:06:15] I do not [3:06:18] you were to present the appraisal was confidential statute [3:06:27] until [3:06:41] at least [3:06:44] that's not an argument. [3:06:46] He does not have to [3:06:52] I understand you have an appraisal [3:06:57] specific. So she's talking about this seven or seven lettering [3:07:05] to misunderstand [3:07:10] intended. It's an awful [3:07:17] I think we should talk about something I looked at page two [3:07:21] and I don't believe it's relevant. Thank you. [3:07:24] Okay, page three. [3:07:31] this is a ruling from the US Supreme Court. [3:07:44] Well, it's a summary of the whole thing, but what's your point? [3:07:51] Going to show the state intention for this problem in an attempt to destroy the trees. [3:07:59] You think that the state took this land as an attempt to destroy the trees? The state attempted first to destroy the trees and then afterwards destroyed them so that they couldn't use evaluation trees. I don't follow my understanding is the state [3:08:20] on your property. [3:08:23] They examine what was there. [3:08:30] They didn't go on your property before the start. They usually guess that's [3:08:47] well I'm not sure because we have not yet heard any evidence of flooding [3:08:55] but first section of this package is crown thinking [3:09:05] people that most pictures back that up. [3:09:13] That makes sense. [3:09:14] Okay. So, what else would be page three? [3:09:18] Page four, main statute [3:09:25] 14. Yes. What procedure? Subsection 7552 entry to land forest products. [3:09:35] This page four ornamental plants page five. Okay, let's hold on a second. The state of Maine did not trespass on [3:09:55] this [3:10:00] channel [3:10:05] radio [3:10:10] on point [3:10:13] and came [3:10:17] the United States [3:10:21] probably [3:10:49] gives it [3:10:51] It's in the statue. to the reading [3:10:58] when you flood [3:11:06] when this case it was established drainage and the state lane [3:11:14] ended that drainage filled a ditch and showed back [3:11:23] to go [3:11:27] this statute applies to the stranger [3:11:32] I don't think his governance statute unless they [3:11:46] want to show [3:11:49] you the [3:11:59] I didn't pay any attention to that. [3:12:06] Okay. Why didn't you get to the tell us about [3:12:12] I don't think has a bunch of state and federal decisions. [3:12:20] state page five [3:12:25] but someone skip monuments they did that too but I'm going to skip it [3:12:35] I don't think this statute applies [3:12:40] so I don't want to take testimony from you about what the statute says I don't think it applies to your situation I No. [3:12:53] Well, that's why heals. [3:12:56] okay. Can I go just a little bit? I think [3:13:01] if you're talking about the statute [3:13:06] that doesn't apply to these facts. [3:13:14] even if you give up on [3:13:19] show that the state cut down trees before they even admitted that they existed. [3:13:29] Well, we can listen to that. This is Dr. helps [3:13:38] and establishes remedy and cost for [3:13:46] so I'm showing this because that's the remedy for okay we talked to say don't think that statute [3:13:58] would help your presentation is a description of what happened. What [3:14:11] do you sir is tell us about tell us about your loss [3:14:20] just so we know because you're applying this just the fact that we don't [3:14:26] understand [3:14:28] that's okay thank [3:14:38] Well, okay. He said that. [3:14:48] Yeah. [3:15:12] You must [3:15:22] not [3:15:42] Okay. [3:15:55] Can we see that first? [3:15:59] Where is it? Number 41. There we go. Thank you. Yeah. [3:16:13] So this was started people said okay [3:16:24] engineer this time. I was also the [3:16:29] greatest [3:16:32] captain. [3:16:36] So [3:16:43] city. so when this stuff started happening I was aware they there was a process [3:17:00] so [3:17:03] page 41 if you look up in the top right hand corner that page right below that [3:17:12] is that little square that's my front And if you look at right below the little green bar and if you look at it wiz if you look at the properties on the show where the trees are but on my own trees. [3:17:38] Okay. so figure out what he did. So it blew it. If you look at page 42 [3:17:50] and [3:17:53] it says, "Oh yeah, just like so at this [3:18:02] point trees exist." Well, their respects are disagree with that. We have photographs that show how dense the vegetation of the road was. [3:18:17] That there were two mature trees. [3:18:24] They acknowledged there were two hardwood trees. [3:18:29] Two trees, two hardwood trees and 18 cedar trees. two because [3:18:40] we [3:18:42] keep saying let's get to that. So, [3:18:49] so we said [3:18:53] those trees [3:18:59] at this point [3:19:08] still [3:19:13] number of trees on the or that [3:19:19] state says [3:19:23] I'm going to jump to [3:19:28] page 44 [3:19:36] bottom 3375 [3:19:41] and it shows the left hand side of the property. rebel and it shows no trees. The scale is actually trying to find [3:19:56] this. [3:20:15] So just keep those [3:20:19] statements [3:20:33] probably [3:20:41] 27. [3:20:43] far as I'm concerned only two trees [3:20:51] only [3:20:54] tree [3:20:56] says tree [3:21:02] they did acknowledge a patch [3:21:07] which I think was their chosen [3:21:13] Was [3:21:15] that [3:21:23] 18 of those [3:21:29] page 56 on page 50 [3:21:37] statement requesting that meeting him page 57 Seven. Hold up. [3:22:00] Page 50. We're jumping all the way to 51. [3:22:07] Page 52. [3:22:10] this is me writing down [3:22:20] the day of the [3:22:31] nobody should be treated like that [3:22:35] again. You've got a year anger. [3:22:41] We don't know whether or not Mr. O'Brien agrees with your recollection of conversation. This is your version of a conversation to take place and what's the relevant of it? well they 're suggesting that I was maybe rude for taking him off. He to me first thing on that is that he was notified that rental property and he did not do before and after evaluation [3:23:11] property. Okay. I understand that you made that point [3:23:20] because that's really the key people talking to each other. [3:23:27] As soon as you rent the property, then several [3:23:44] trees. [3:23:50] That's what their appraisers said during his testimony. [3:23:54] Do you have any evidence against tree? I do. [3:24:02] Brian say [3:24:05] everything. [3:24:08] Okay. That's not [3:24:18] sound privacy. [3:24:23] So tenants when they look at my table they stay there [3:24:41] you've got to stop the person with [3:24:44] okay we don't know where he's driven and you don't know he's driven so it doesn't help your case [3:24:50] to throw stones at the opposing witnesses just as so try to keep it to the fact [3:25:03] you think the difference in [3:25:07] life. [3:25:16] So let me ask you this question. [3:25:19] Yes. [3:25:34] What's that? 24 I believe. So has you have you had any problem getting tenants because you didn't have any trees? [3:25:43] Yeah. I had people playing the tenants may complain that the church was [3:25:54] okay. Have you ever been unable to rent a unit because of the street noise? [3:26:04] I think they can stay in 36 years. [3:26:09] So, okay. So to my way of thinking, you tell me where I know, the fact that your trees disappeared five to eight years ago has had no impact on your ability to rent to tense. Okay. Problem that you run into when you start looking at the [3:26:31] city code of ordinances requires limited certain five parking spaces for five tenants. And it also can [3:26:44] limit the number of occupants to the building. What do you feel if you wandering off of a path? Sir, I asked you if you had trouble renting a unit, did you have a prospective tening [3:27:00] unit? [3:27:01] Okay. And I honestly don't think you have much of an argument. These trees affected the ring. [3:27:12] The trees [3:27:15] had [3:27:17] you paid the wedding. It was paid not a replacement value or not [3:27:26] value not a comparative value. We can look at the property from the street. I was a [3:27:36] a [3:27:41] company love to you the tree. [3:27:46] So we're here to consider the value of those trees. I don't disagree what you just said. So let's go to the next page if you want to say again. [3:28:30] 53. [3:28:40] Mr. Viller [3:28:56] We typically do not use the income approach of partial savings because we are not taking the whole property of the district. We typically appraise to go to vacant land and then reimburse for any improvements on the related paper. [3:29:15] That's not what the state has said today. Not taking land by the building. Okay. Now, [clears throat] what I believe the state is taking is that yellow strip that even though the purple strip has no physical proof. [3:29:37] the let me let me say one thing. Remember, I used to be the city and I had no problem at all with the city doing the verbal area for construction purposes. Again, you have to have space for your equipment. That's so the verbal area is not even consideration [3:30:00] and the bad is really [3:30:07] consideration. They are listing the [3:30:13] yellow area as a highway easement. Highway easement [3:30:19] is for telephone. How [3:30:23] well I think he [3:30:29] taking God's command [3:30:42] [snorts] [3:30:51] can't put company [3:30:55] agent on your land says that you can't use it for anything that interferes with their use of it. So they have totally [3:31:04] have essentially open [3:31:18] you don't like the legal decisions that this commission makes. You have the right to appeal. [3:31:23] Yes. [3:31:24] And if you do appeal, I recommend you hire a lawyer to help you. [3:31:32] 73 on social security. [3:31:37] I respect that, sir. [3:31:42] Mr. [3:31:45] Onage 55. [3:31:49] Yes. [3:32:08] just reading this letter quickly. It looks like he raises this, you know, the interest versus Eastman interest and they Mr. Sanderson worked work for the DOT in 2021. [3:32:25] was trying to explain that to you. And what he said was one of the reasons you took any was so that the size that you bought would not change which could affect your ability to add more. [3:32:43] I expect more [3:32:46] the city on the backy [3:32:53] city. [3:32:56] So that had nothing to do with the taking. Yes, it does. Because this is my only chance to stop that [3:33:08] even [3:33:26] people [3:33:29] to get it on. [3:33:47] Noble [3:33:50] to do. I don't remember. [3:33:58] Well, I've seen no evidence that you parking spaces because of Were you parking car tires in this triple van before they took it? [3:34:07] Yes. [3:34:08] You were parking the lab where there were cedar trees there before they took it. Cedar trees were 14 ft from [3:34:17] Okay. But you could have been parking cars amidst a bunch of cedar trees. [3:34:22] The gap space beside my driveway extended all the way to the street an additional 14 ft past where it does that. [3:34:34] Your property line has not changed. problem when I came but I could use that space to be where my property line I'm sorry Mr. I don't know how [3:34:48] we lost [3:34:51] because I used to pour trees on a circle vegetated with cedar trees. You couldn't have cuts there. I mean those two things don't make sense. Cedar trees did not go all [3:35:08] sufficiently between seed trees and [3:35:23] And obviously [3:35:44] Okay. [3:35:52] What's the next page you want us to look at? Thank you. [3:36:10] 51 state. [3:36:18] Still no indicative of [3:36:46] Page 63 page 63 I'm sorry. [3:36:58] So [3:37:01] I have asked for [3:37:05] several times. It was supposed to be available 9 months after project was completable. Project was completed July of 2025. Okay. Let me just cut you off here. Even if the state wrongfully withheld the appraisal, [3:37:26] which I'm not yet convinced it did, that has no effect on the market value of the land it took from you. You have issues like the state didn't follow state law regarding providing appraisals. You're not going to get that issue solved here. [3:37:42] That's true. [3:37:42] You don't have that authority. How can understand talk about that [3:37:49] because it's not relevant to our job. as relevant for me as caring what [3:37:58] that [3:38:11] so like a stuff that's just not relevant to us. [3:38:18] And I know that's hard for people to understand. No, I do understand. [3:38:22] Okay. We have a very narrow set of facts to be considered. [3:38:27] As a city engineer, I understand. I absolutely appreciate the fact that have to expand utilities. I will be the first person to tell you all that I'm saying. There is a process anytime that anything spot that the city [3:38:47] state county town is using that process. [3:38:56] Well, I agree with you. It's important any governor doesn't follow. [3:39:02] Again, that's not what we're going to hear. He said if you complain against the state of violating some state regulation or state law which you can't do you've got to pursue it in the civil courts. This board can address it. This understand this board is one of the steps [3:39:25] that the system ask you to take. [3:39:31] Okay. Page 67 has a picture of the trees standing trees. [3:39:39] Page 68. [3:39:40] Hold on. Let me ask a question about 67. [3:39:45] Who took this picture? [3:39:46] I did. [3:39:47] Where were you standing? [3:39:48] I was standing adjacent to my [3:39:52] Were you What were you looking toward? [3:39:54] I was looking east. [3:39:58] Were you looking for water? The store was behind these trees. [3:40:04] Okay. So, these were the trees that were there before the tag. [3:40:08] Yes. [3:40:09] Now, that's relevant. Okay. Thank you. [3:40:15] This is great. The best thing you brought today. [3:40:20] Okay. Age 68. [3:40:25] 68. [3:40:27] Yeah. [3:40:32] We [3:40:35] were standing on the side of I guess tell me why you want to look at this because the state came in. And I told you before the state build a dow [3:40:48] this and when they built the ditch not only it used to be a ditch right here that's right in the middle of used to be a ditch on trees and still water the state that ditch in and oddly they filled it in with sand [3:41:10] and they filled it in all the way to the property with no reason there's no logical reason to do that was observed the vehicles [3:41:23] they all the way to the end [3:41:34] if you look at this picture right [laughter] you see two okay you see a tree and some [3:41:48] is that icing. [3:41:51] Yeah. Okay. so when the state did this, they filled right close to the problem and they said that they treat [3:42:11] those trees belong to the state. Okay. [3:42:17] that came. They did manage to kill three trees, two Zas and one [3:42:29] [laughter] 69. You see the two tree lane and you see the two stumps and there's that picture. And now same [3:42:48] [clears throat] include its [3:42:54] But that's really [3:43:01] interesting [3:43:05] stay. [3:43:22] condition. [3:43:26] If you trees [3:43:30] histori And if you grow this tree, these two trees at the state [3:43:41] show you where they [3:43:49] exact [3:43:54] [laughter] [3:44:01] of course [3:44:05] year. [3:44:21] Okay. [3:44:26] is your tree age. [3:44:31] So 712 [3:44:42] Yes. [3:45:03] 18 mature cedar trees, two mature trees. [3:45:17] It's unfair when you say the state doesn't [3:45:27] understand the determination of how much money they take in taking your land. [3:45:36] We back at the beginning of the state showed this. It didn't need to be didn't even show trees on the cross session. There's 17 trees in I understand that we talked about it. Generally speaking, those plans are not toident. [3:46:05] [clears throat] [3:46:11] Okay. So, trees 1 through 17 a particular. Yes, I'm sorry. [3:46:27] a good decision. [3:46:49] 89 [3:47:03] is helpful. Thank you. this shows the trees [3:47:08] after their obviously removed the right shape on left hand side [3:47:18] and you see a string [3:47:31] and they end the easement that was taken by This is DOT. [3:47:37] They are. [3:47:38] They are. [3:47:39] Okay. Thank you. [3:47:43] Page 91. [3:47:47] You got to remember at this point in time save a lot of knowledge that these trees were lying on my dogs. [3:47:58] Contractor trees. So I posted that sign contractor be my son. So I'm concerned they're not paid for yet. They're not acknowledged. [3:48:11] contractor called the [3:48:16] representative on site touchscreen [3:48:39] [laughter] difference. Okay. [3:48:42] What they describe as a head is you're describing as trees. [3:48:49] I understand that. But let's not get hung up on the state only acknowled [3:48:58] their report on damages described the hedge. I think these are horribly I mean when I think of a head I think of something that 8 ft tall dense bushes I think I think the head they were referring to was the proposal [3:49:22] I think that's the [3:49:25] I think I don't think [3:49:29] Yeah, [3:49:31] that's what I hear. It's a ste. Okay, let's [3:49:37] Okay, so do me a favor. You've told us multiple state, [3:49:45] so you don't need to repeat and I heard you loud and clear. [3:49:52] So [3:49:55] posted sign contractor shows up to take the stock solid shows up and says yes Mr. Grant here is the gives my acknowledgement on that page 92 [3:50:08] this is the letter I got yes Mr. was this many trees and no problem. Okay. And as soon as he gave me that piece of paper, I let the contractor get some. [3:50:21] Okay. Well, let me just back up a little bit. [3:50:33] You think there were more than 17 trees on your property? Originally there was [3:50:41] okay. [3:50:44] So somewhere between 17 and 23 [3:50:52] you see very credible sir. I noticed that you signed something. [3:50:58] Yes sir. [3:50:59] Are you a naval or postcard officer? [3:51:01] Army reserve. [3:51:02] What's that? [3:51:03] Marine reserve. [3:51:04] Oh. Oh, cool. Thanks. Big service. [3:51:08] You keep going now. I got that [3:51:10] annually. [3:51:12] [3:51:15] okay. So, 93 [3:51:19] falling down. 94 getting [3:51:26] 84. This is the right side. When the state filled in the ditch, they also filled in neighbors. So it didn't rain. And if you look at page 94, whenever it rain, it flooded all the way back. [3:51:49] Was that on your land? [3:51:52] And since we're looking at page 94, there's no there's no [3:52:04] Yes. [3:52:11] Testimon [3:52:17] to address drainage issues. usually address what was in the Bible. [3:52:42] But it was also looking back. [3:52:56] This shows this shows that [3:53:02] page [3:53:05] 75 [3:53:12] looking at your house or your neighbor's See the big on the left hand side [3:53:25] I show you what we're going to do. This is me standing almost from the edge of the street. [3:53:34] And this happens every [3:53:41] day. [3:53:46] Okay. Again, that doesn't that's nothing that we can address. [3:53:54] Yeah. Again, [3:53:58] we're not here. I believe what you're thinking and if anything, [3:54:06] you should be concerned. We can't address that. I understand it. [3:54:17] The reason was because that killed first. [3:54:24] That's why they the state intentionally build a ditch [3:54:32] intending no reason [3:54:37] to do it the new road with these the cut [3:54:51] Yes. [3:54:56] Why [3:55:01] so bad [3:55:09] you pretended to address this big issue [3:55:19] yourself? [3:55:24] the way to go. Okay. And it's been working. [3:55:31] Yeah. Okay. [3:55:34] Good job. Thank you. [3:55:39] Picture 97. [3:55:43] Water. The wire goes all the way up to [3:55:50] that big see a sun on the left hand side that pointed out [3:56:01] that's [3:56:06] taken. Yeah. No, this tree is all the way. This is 17. This is [3:56:16] 193 [3:56:18] down. [3:56:38] Page 98 is the state said that they the new construction they put in a ditch only on my name of the property and yeah and they modified my property and said oh well this is just a swag [3:57:01] is an apple rose and they actually ran a ditch all the way up my property all the way to that right [3:57:17] and then [3:57:34] yes beyond it is your neighbor's And this was this water intended to [3:57:43] the picture that [3:57:50] didn't even get [3:58:06] the same structure. [3:58:20] Just because it was clean show [3:58:32] dish with the previous dish shows up. Page 99. This is what my lawn This is what my driveway looks like every time. [3:58:46] Has that problem been corrected? [3:58:48] No sir. [3:58:57] This is what [3:59:02] Okay. [3:59:08] So there's [3:59:16] something which [3:59:26] This is this is [3:59:31] engineer site [3:59:35] shows. [3:59:39] Okay. [clears throat] [laughter] [3:59:48] So it wasn't [3:59:56] all [3:59:59] this [4:00:04] one time. This is the value of your race. [4:00:14] And the driving is dangerous. [4:00:21] It's absolutely [4:00:35] dangerous. [4:00:38] Unless you crazy. Okay. Picture 102 [4:00:45] showing [4:00:49] north to the McDonald sign [4:00:55] show [4:01:03] brought this to the detention of the state at least three times. also brought to the attention of the fellow. [4:01:10] Excuse me. [4:01:11] Yes. [4:01:12] Th this picture is interesting. I don't know why it's but I do know this had nothing to do with my it does because Thank you. It does because this was envisioned probably the [4:01:33] construction of a new road and anybody gets hurt from wend [4:01:43] this road is not constructed properly for drainage especially if they've been made things so it's not constructed see y [4:01:53] this is some wet pavement with a little of the public. I don't want you to show this picture as evidence that you have a danger of struggling. [4:02:04] It's a wet rolling ve. [4:02:22] Okay. Thank you. [4:02:37] page 107. We know most time not relevant but exceed college [4:02:45] completely but way across. Notice that the cars that do continue across there water [4:02:57] page 108 [4:03:06] blame in front of my [4:03:09] nose [4:03:13] people [4:03:17] studies subtracts is not [4:03:24] where's the five. [4:03:30] Yeah. [4:03:42] See a picture back a little bit ago from page 109. This is a One right around the corner. Tony, [4:03:51] I see one behind. Not sure where it is. House. [4:04:22] 2003. [4:04:27] Okay. This c this document fall same category as the last document shows. This is a report from world. Unless there's someone here from the farmer testify about the content of this report, we really can't consider [4:04:48] it's here. [4:04:59] We're waiting on time [4:05:06] to tell us. [4:05:12] What else have you got to show us? [4:05:19] We can't put this in a full time used to be the city. [4:05:25] Excuse me. [4:05:26] We used to be the city. [4:05:28] You said that. [4:05:29] Okay. Thank you. and I'm telling you that the lane in front of my property is develop and if they hadn't put up an additional lane in front of my property then I wouldn't have had to take I wouldn't be here and [4:05:48] they submitted does not show this second [4:05:55] that's not relevant Let's keep [4:06:01] it accurate. [4:06:22] He's doing that together. [4:06:27] I don't like I don't think we witness [4:06:38] the witness will be here showing the cross. [4:06:43] What's the Rose going to testify about? He is he is going to testify. [4:06:54] This is a different person. [4:07:01] Yeah. At this point, you've got someone coming. It's 3:18. If you can have someone here by 30th grade, do you want to offer us an additional boost? Let me ask you this. Do you have any other witnesses besides yourself? The lady next to you going to testify? [4:07:19] No. about testifying. [4:07:24] The only thing the only [4:07:29] iss [4:07:36] Just [4:07:45] like [4:07:53] you file the court [4:08:03] sits over Here they have lots of cardies. We sit over here. This is the size of a 20 year old. [4:08:12] But this is intended as some [4:08:21] people do with us. 110 [4:08:29] 110. well tree trespass plane. Not only did the Not only did the state build a ditch that killed three of the trees and the state cut down the other 17 trees without farm [4:08:50] knowledge they stated [4:08:54] designated [4:08:58] trees [4:09:01] more you can [4:09:16] The bottom still shows [4:09:24] the neighbor [4:09:27] trees. They went state killed three trees [4:09:34] and [4:09:36] then it [4:09:46] page 112 showing [4:09:53] steady hand [4:09:56] occupancy [4:09:59] 5.3 [4:10:02] and evidence damages 1600 month and a total of 274,000 [4:10:13] tenants there the whole time [4:10:15] now if I lose occupancy 53 I'm going to lose occupancy 5.3 because of this taking [4:10:40] We [clears throat] can't help you being [4:10:55] you got a higher to present evidence regarding what the safety buffers are going to do. He was looking for $275,000. [4:11:10] But you have no professional opinion [4:11:15] that this painting [4:11:20] affected your property that [4:11:26] the damage that can happen doesn't have to happen before this problem. If it happened after [4:11:41] I have no recourse. Well, [4:11:46] I'll say it for the last time. [4:11:48] This has nothing to do with liability for three years to find out if the states the state paid you the proper amount of money. That's only issue being decided. This will not preclude you pursuing any other issues you may have. And obviously you have a lot of other issues [4:12:09] that we just don't have jurisdiction over. Understand? Remember I want you to understand that this process is one of the steps that I'm supposed to take. [4:12:27] Well, you say that. What are you talking about? It doesn't stop you from filing a parallel lawsuit over these other issues. There's nothing I know says you've got to go get evaluation decided before you can sue for other damages. So, I really challenge that statement. This is a step process you need to follow. [4:12:49] It is one of the steps. [4:12:52] This is not a step. This is a [4:12:56] this is we're going to be finished with this issue for those hearing [4:13:03] right here. It still can be resolved at after this point and I can't come back to a bunch. [4:13:13] Okay. Thank you. I've heard that before. [4:13:18] All right. Anything else you want to tell us? that's all in the packet and last page is my certification that [4:13:29] still [4:13:41] really good [4:13:45] so that we could bring the pages with gray. That's not how [4:13:56] but I do want to put together. [4:14:15] So you have nothing else to offer. [4:14:20] Yes. [4:14:47] Well, he had it up on his computer. [4:14:50] I'll give it back to you. [4:14:57] I can't believe it. [4:15:09] It's 2037. [4:15:19] Excuse me. [4:15:22] Oh, [4:15:24] yeah. [4:15:28] The door is open. [4:15:32] Do you want to recall Captain Grant, Mr. Grant, David? [4:15:35] Only David is not going to launch. [4:15:37] All right. you said you never had a vacancy in [clears throat] 36 years [4:15:44] and you're really on here about 29. [4:15:48] No, the back minimally is almost [4:15:52] and you're not other than the trees, you're not really hear about the purple area. You hear about the yellow? [4:15:59] Yeah. You know, I know I was an engineer. [4:16:06] Can you show on exhibit one if you don't mind there before the project taking you used to have your tenants aring and turning around you know chill [4:16:40] so the driveway is still represented here over to above right here. the glass ceiling and the pine tree used to be great. Well, actually [4:16:59] now you know what [clears throat] I want the court to understand that [4:17:08] this is here in standard here suggested to me that they erased it. [4:17:18] They raised it. [4:17:20] Raised it because it shows up in that little one I showed you. [4:17:38] So all the way up to the highway [4:17:46] in the states existing right. [4:17:50] Thank you. That's all happens. [4:18:05] Also, [4:18:11] go ahead. [4:18:11] You said you saw the I think you said you saw the D building in the ditch and sand in 2007, [4:18:18] right? [4:18:22] Could it have been the town the city or the town that was doing that? You know, this property is in urban area [4:18:29] and that would be the point because it's in the maintenance work done. Remember I was a city. [4:18:42] So you're aware that the city does [4:18:44] if the city was going to do work was a city engineer, he would have discussed it with me, but the city would never have built in a ditch. [4:18:52] Okay. Do you know why the DOT chose to fill in a ditch to kill its own trees in 2007? [4:18:58] Yeah, I believe it was intentional to kill my trees. that why else were they filled all the way all the way to all the way to property? They even filled in and ground your trees. So this was 14 years before the taking. [4:19:15] This was 200 16 is what? Yep. [4:19:20] You said 2007. [4:19:22] No, 200 student number seven. Two 2007. [4:19:29] Okay. you said in your exhibits 71 through 89 you had you encountered trees and some slight [4:19:41] right [4:19:43] I mean that's my question [4:19:46] and do you have exhibit six in front of you [4:19:53] what number [4:19:57] six [4:20:07] It's [4:20:10] ahead. [4:20:13] Did you look that over and see how many total trees were just there? [4:20:26] 18 and then two, right? [4:20:32] I don't 18 to 48. Go ahead. [4:20:36] So the 48 ground number of trees is 18 to two 20 trees. [4:20:41] Okay. So let's make sure. This is the first time use I've seen [4:20:46] right. You're ambushing me with this KT. And the only way I found out is when I post that sign to build a contract to say I'm not self and I'm sorry. [4:21:03] So you don't say in 18, but I didn't know that back when you took the [4:21:11] but you the one person who could explain that to you and asked to leave your property and then you consistently told the DOT we didn't give you credit for trees. [4:21:21] We did. [4:21:22] Okay. [4:21:24] Because I only received this today. [4:21:28] Did you have did you get your own pages and dying? [4:21:48] The date on the top of page 94 is that May 1st, 2023? [4:21:52] It is. [4:21:53] That's before the construction actually begin. [4:21:56] That's correct. [4:21:58] Okay. So two years after the tape, a year and a half after the tape, but before any construction. [4:22:04] Oh, [4:22:09] I'm aware of what you said happened in 2007. But what I'm doing is on this particular [4:22:15] on May 1st, 2023, they hadn't started building anything. [4:22:45] Yes. [4:22:45] When do you understand the construction was the road construction portion of this project was needed? [4:22:54] I got it documented from 2000 July of 202. [4:23:01] Okay. So on January 1st 2025 the project was not done yet. The construction was not done yet. No, they was asking that question, you know, that [4:23:17] but as far as confirming to me [4:23:27] your son [4:23:32] was test [4:23:37] And I don't understand how you would have expected grass to create the state build the ditch. [4:23:48] Yeah. [4:23:54] When the state [4:23:58] was saying did try to benefit. [4:24:06] So on exhibit 98. [4:24:08] Yes sir. [4:24:10] I understood one of your complaints to be that they smoke the land down to the ala trees. That's the border between you and your neighbor that looks like a ditch or sway. [4:24:23] Is that one of your concerns? [4:24:26] Good great good question. I really do. So if you look at the gray states, those two little states that used to put three arm stakes that you put, that is the limit of the permanent easement on my property. It's only about 8 in away from the edge of the drive. [4:24:49] Right. [4:24:49] Okay. [4:24:51] Yeah. [4:24:51] Okay. So and then if you look at you see the center line [4:25:03] to engage [4:25:07] that's [4:25:09] from [4:25:12] 75 ft away but that's some five seven ft away the edge of the sidewalk. [4:25:20] Okay, if you say so. Oh, [4:25:22] well, I'm just guessing as an engineer that it's not six inches, it's four or five feet. [4:25:28] I think my question was simpler. Is are you complaining that you drained the water that way? [4:25:33] I'm complaining that you didn't even drain the water. [4:25:36] Okay. [4:25:37] And you establish and you established a ditch all the way across my property. When you say established a ditch, what really happened here is they graded the new elevation into match your land, right? [4:25:50] Doesn't does it's not draining seat piles on my [4:25:56] rain that falls on your land. Do you think the DOT has an obligation to that for you? It has an obligation to not [4:26:07] if you if you this is why you take temporary easements so that you can put the property back so you work in the way it's supposed to. [4:26:16] Yeah. [4:26:17] Okay. That's that's why you have temporary easy. You didn't do that. And so now you've established the ditch line to be [4:26:28] at least six feet away from the sidewalk. I can't I'm not going to be able to run. That's going to be wet. That's doesn't you've got a ditch. [4:26:37] But sir, you have water on your property. And if we hadn't done anything, it would all just pull there. What the DOT did as a courtesy in a good neighbor was graded so flow towards the swale and not just pull in your area post. If that was a good neighbor, then why did you [4:26:58] say and establish that the neighbor has addition from his problem and call and call the same thing straight line? [4:27:10] I have no idea what [4:27:13] I don't mean. [4:27:16] Would you turn to page 99? [4:27:22] Yes. Okay. Do you see the puddle that is here? [4:27:25] Yes, I do. [4:27:26] That's from where it was fixed by the board. [4:27:30] You made an effort to fix it. Still it still floods but not as bad as it did. [4:27:34] Okay. And all of the water that's cooling there is to the evening with the sidewalk or out into the street. Right. [4:27:42] That's correct. [4:27:43] So that's within the state's east. [4:27:45] Absolutely. Okay. [4:27:47] But I have a drive. [4:27:48] Then you have a drive. [4:27:54] That's all [4:28:03] that testimony. [4:28:13] Let's [4:28:21] take it's 3:39. Let's take a break till 3:50. That's 11 minutes. [4:28:32] I think [4:28:34] so. [4:28:38] And then [4:28:40] you know that [4:28:54] we're trying to do the best we can. [4:29:43] At [4:29:55] least [4:30:14] James. [4:30:39] Stop. [4:30:48] [laughter] [4:30:53] still saying that.