Historic Preservation Board reviews 57 St. Lawrence Street condo proposal

The Portland Historic Preservation Board held a workshop to review a proposed four-story, seven-unit condominium at 57 St. Lawrence Street in the Munjoy Hill Historic District. Board members raised concerns about the side entrance, the ratio of glass to solid materials on the side elevation, and the treatment of the fourth floor. No vote was taken, and the applicant was encouraged to revise the design based on the board's feedback.

Key points

• The board reviewed a proposal for a four-story, seven-unit condominium on a corner lot at 57 St. Lawrence Street.
• Members expressed concern that the side entrance on the north elevation is not sufficiently prominent or welcoming compared to neighborhood standards.
• Discussion focused on the high percentage of glass on the St. Lawrence Place elevation, with members suggesting it deviates from the typical solid-to-void ratio of the district.
• Board members questioned the differentiation of the fourth floor, noting that the change in materials and window size may break the vertical continuity seen in local triple-deckers.
• Public commenters debated the zoning implications of the building's length and the necessity of infill housing in the neighborhood.
• The applicant explained that the side entrance was chosen to preserve view corridors and efficient circulation, though they acknowledged the challenge of announcing the entry.

Next steps

• The applicant will revise the design to address feedback on the entrance, fourth-floor treatment, and side elevation materials.
• The applicant will provide additional renderings showing potential rooftop equipment and sight lines.
• The applicant will proceed with site plan review to address zoning questions regarding building length.

Read the full transcript