← Back to MaineScanner

Scarborough Council Votes on Zoning Changes and Reviews Town Updates

2026-11-04 · 3h 33m · Source: Town Council Meeting 11-04-2026 (Town of Scarborough (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[2:02] Mhm. [4:05] Mhm. [11:03] good evening and welcome to the November 4th, 2026 meeting of the Scarborough Town Council. Would you please rise if able for the pledge of allegiance? [11:13] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [11:27] [clears throat] [11:28] Jody, could you please call the roll? [11:30] Councilor Dority. [11:30] Here. [11:31] Councilor Cain. [11:32] Here. [11:32] Councilor Shoe. [11:33] Here. [11:33] Councilor Donovan. [11:34] Here. [11:35] Councilor Anderson. [11:35] Here. [11:36] Councilor Hayes. [11:36] Here. [11:37] Chairman Fellows. [11:37] Here. [11:38] All present. [11:39] Thank you. That takes us to general public comments. This, as always, is for items that are not on our agenda this evening. If you'd like to come forward, just please state your name, address, and keep your comments to 3 minutes or less. [12:01] Denise Hamilton, 2 Rod Road. I'd [clears throat] like to take a moment to congratulate everyone who was elected yesterday to the Town Council, School Board, Sanitary District, and our state offices. Running for public office takes a lot of time, dedication, and a willingness to serve. I wish each of them success in their new or continuing roles, and hope we can all work together respectfully, [12:25] keeping the best interest of all of our taxpayers at the forefront. I'd like to thank the town for recently skim coating a portion of Holmes Road. Well, I think we all recognize this isn't a permanent solution. Hopefully, it'll get us through the winter until the more substantial improvements can be made. With hundreds of thousands of vehicles traveling this road, including significant heavy traffic [12:49] heavy truck traffic, a long-term solution is certainly needed. Also, I ask that the transition from new to old be evaluated as it's not smooth and creates undue noise. The neighbors in that area, as well as the center line, has not been rolled smoothly, and it's causing a ka-thump [13:10] when people transition. And second, regarding the I think it was on the town manager's report, the IF&W beach management agreement update. I have a couple questions and observations. Will the tentative agreement be made available for public review, or will the public have to wait until it's presented to the full council? [13:32] After reviewing the reports the town has posted online, there appears to be a significant number of documented violations. However, without a mechanism to total number of people entering the beaches with dogs, it's difficult to determine what percentage of beach users are actually violating the rules. Is it safe to say that out of the few hundred violations, there were zero fines or citations given? [13:58] I believe one of the biggest challenges is ensuring we have adequate enforcement personnel on the ground who have the authority to issue summonses when violations occur. Without consistent meaningful enforcement, I'm not sure that changing the agreement or adding more restrictions will necessarily solve the problem. Thank you. [14:18] Thank you. [14:25] Hi, I'm Nancy Glover and I live in South Portland. Good evening and thank you for allowing me to speak. I often protest at the ICE facility at 40 Manson Libby Road in Scarborough. Southern Maine has suffered enough under ICE's harsh policies. Many people think ICE has gone away, but this is anything but the truth. ICE apprehended 480 [14:47] Maine residents between January and July. Only one of these individuals was a violent criminal. On July 13th, Johan Sebastian Duran Guerrero was murdered by ICE agent David Breault. This heinous event has prompted no changes in ICE procedures and no justice for Johan. [15:07] Taxpayers are spending billions of dollars supporting this corrupt cruel system. Preferably ICE should be abolished and replaced with a system that respects the constitutional rights of all people. In the short term, I would like to encourage you to adopt an ordinance like the immigration enforcement restrictions adopted by South Portland on October 27th. [15:30] It is essential to include a mechanism for reporting violations such as the one South Portland has implemented. And I say this because the Scarborough Police Department appears to be actively cooperating with agents at the ICE facility in Scarborough. There have been several incidents in recent days. On Friday, October 30th, [15:50] an undercover ICE agent called the Scarborough PD on a single female who was observing him from an appropriate distance. There was an impressive response. Four Scarborough police cruisers showed up at the scene. The observer was not violating any laws, so no charges were filed. On Sunday, November 1st, I was pulled over by Officer Andrew Flynn of the Scarborough PD, who gave me a ticket because one of my license plate lights was out. [16:18] He could have given me a warning, but he chose to give me a $152 ticket to ensure compliance. I'm 77 years old. I'm glad to report that Officer Flynn is doing his best to keep Scarborough safe from old ladies with cell phones and broken license plates lights. On Monday, November 2nd, Officer Flynn was again hard at work protecting the interests of the federal government. [16:43] He charged a protester and documentary filmmaker at the ice facility with criminal trespassing. The protester was handed printing handing printed information to immigrants at the facility for check-in as our group does daily. Officer Flynn felt obliged to follow the dictates of the ice officer on duty and issue a summons rather than a warning. [17:04] The trial date is set for December 16th. There's a definite pattern to the behavior of the Scarborough PD who ticketed me but declines to ticket ice vehicles with missing license plates on the front and obscured license plates on the back as well as a very heavy tint obscuring anyone inside. Please, get ice out of Scarborough or at least call off city employees who are harassing peaceful protesters. [17:29] You on the city council have the power to change this. [17:33] Thank you. I'll note as a as a procedural matter that we do have an action item on second reading for of an ordinance related to local law enforcement and municipal employees and ice enforcement. So, if there are any other comments related to that, I'd ask that you please wait until we get to that action item. Does anyone else have any general public comment about items that are not on our agenda this evening? [17:58] I think I see one online. Go ahead. [18:04] Hello, my name is Matthew Keith at 8 Pleasant Avenue. And I just wanted to echo Denise in congratulating all of our local candidates who won. And I just wanted to take a moment to publicly shout out two amazing candidates who did not win. [18:25] who I think are just exemplary public servants in Scarborough. so to Shannon who, you know, took the path of an independent running in a year that was a very clear blue wave. I just want to shout her out for all her hard work, all her service and I 'm so grateful that she's in our community and I'm so impressed with the campaign that she ran. [18:54] and then I just want to shout out, Councillor Chen. I honestly this morning when I looked, I could not believe that he had not won the re-election. I literally like I'm mostly jokingly, but I was considering not voting for him because I was like, he's going to be a shoe-in. [19:14] So, my vote, you know, could go to somebody else that so yeah, I just I am so thankful for your service, Councillor Chen. Like I've been so impressed watching the work you've done, really putting in so much effort to everything you do. and I do support voters and the will of the voters, but on this one I think we got it real wrong and I hope that you consider [19:40] running again in the future cuz we are better with you on the council. Thank you. [19:47] Thank you. Is there anyone else for general public comment before we move on? [19:55] All right, seeing none, we'll close general public comment. Thank you. That takes us to item number five, the minutes of the October 2020 the of October 21st, 2026 Town Council meeting. do we have a motion? [20:09] So moved. [20:09] Second. [20:10] Any discussion? All in favor? That's unanimous, thank you. item number six, the adjustments to the agenda, there were none. Item number seven, items to be signed, treasurer's warrants. I signed those prior to the meeting and that takes us to item eight, the town manager's report. [20:29] Thank you, Mr. Chair. I understand in my absence at last meeting Liam Gallagher did a much better and quicker job than I'm able to do. Please bear with me but in all seriousness I was not here for the last meeting thanks to the council's support. I was attending the International City Managers Association [20:50] annual conference in California. Very good experience, great to reconnect with colleagues but also get you know, good much needed professional training. So I appreciate your support in that endeavor. So I'll do my best to move through this briskly. With respect to Scotty Hill Road, this is a standing matter. Just today we did learn that unfortunately we did not receive the grant. [21:14] we certainly had not been led on and we were aware that there was very stiff competition. I suspect there are limited resources for a lot of applications. So with that kind of final piece of information, I think the matter is ready to come back to this council for final decision and direction. So I'll work with council leadership to sort out whether this comes back as soon as your next meeting and maybe a bit unfair to three brand new councilors hearing this for the first very first time. [21:42] So we'll work through that but at this point I just wanted to make the public aware that we're ready to kind of bring this back and appreciate that we should do some additional work just kind of providing the background for the new councilors and to remind the public. So we'll get that scheduled. As was mentioned from the podium from a resident, we did have a successful meeting with Inland Fisheries and Wildlife last week and I'm pleased to advise that we I'll call it a tentative agreement. [22:11] We left that meeting I believe with a understanding that that we can add additional language, that the town actually proposed in our beach management agreement. This will this is short of us changing our ordinances, which is something that was asked of us. I'll call this kind of a prove-it period. [22:32] essentially it it commits the town to zero tolerance for the additional time from May 1st to May 15th. and we're actively working at the staff level understanding what our existing staff resources are to meet that standard. Other topics we talked about, we recognized [22:53] kind of record-keeping gaps on our side. We've just started this 2 years ago and I think are getting better and we expect to have a standardized system so we can have better comparable data year-over-year. that's something the department understandably was interested in seeing as well. they also made a very specific point that with changes on in beach areas and habitat, [23:17] Pine Point in particular in their view has changed notably from 14 years ago when we identified the restricted areas that were limited really to the jetty, just that portion close to the jetty. So, I don't expect there'll be any changes in this next round, but they were quite clear that we should revisit that and I think that's something that we'll have to certainly listen to. [23:39] the current restricted areas were based on data where the birds are and I think it's pretty hard to refute that sort of argument. So, that's a conversation I expect we'll continue to have as we gather and know more data. And lastly, they made us aware that they are internally considering imposing some restrictions on land they own at Higgins Beach. [24:00] It's about a 2.8 acre parcel. It's essentially the part of the beach closest to the river, if you can appreciate that. and this is land that IF&W owns themselves and certainly has the right and ability to impose restrictions as they wish. what comes with that will be some enforcement responsibilities presumably and I think that's a piece that they're trying to sort through and understand for themselves. [24:23] So, that may or may not happen. in any event it won't involve the town. That's a decision they can make on their own. hopefully they'll make us aware so we can make our residents aware. School projects, quick update. The design development phase is coming to a close. they're still on schedule to do bidding first quarter of next year. [24:45] That's a really the schedule that they laid out originally, and so they're right on schedule. we're having ongoing discussions at the staff level with the architects and engineers regarding site mitigation for traffic and some other related issues. We're having productive discussions there, and hopefully we can see some results. [25:07] And lastly, Norman and I have begun the process to understand what our next bond issue will look like. This project will be kicking off from a construction point of view sometime early summer is the timeline. So, we'll need resources to be able to pay those contractors. to do so, we'll have to work with the architects who will advise us really what the cash flow [25:30] needs of the project are. We don't want to borrow any more than we need, but we're actively moving forward in that direction. Portland West is still a conversation that continues with the with DOT. more specifically, the town's transportation committee has really taken this task on head headlong, which is great. [25:52] I think they're a bunch of thoughtful folks that are interested and engaged. and to that end, we're holding hosting a meeting with DOT representatives and folks from Gorham. really looking at the impact on our two towns. Many of the solutions affect really only us, certainly the traveling public, but so we're anxious to kind of dig a little deeper, and I'm pleased the transportation committee and our town staff is really actively engaged. [26:20] the election update, we'll get into that in a bit. I just want to make a couple of observations. We had just over 14,000 folks vote in this election. interestingly, over the last handful I would say as much as 5 years, we have kind of emerged a trend of having early votes and day-of votes about the same, equal amounts, kind of half and half. [26:45] in fact, it's not uncommon to have the absentee votes actually be a little ahead. And we would expect I expected that tradition to to happen again. This cycle, we did have 800 8,844 absentee ballots cast, which represented 63% of the overall ballots cast. So, something was different, not as many people showed up on election day as we've seen in the past, and that might be a trend that's been replicated and has been seen across the country. [27:14] I have been Today's been a blur. I haven't had a chance to put that in perspective, but that I thought that was noteworthy. for us, the town radio project did pass by about 700 votes. And for those interested, Old Orchard had a similar question on. Theirs passed by a very sizable margin, probably two to one. And so, now we'll be working actively trying to secure the congressionally [27:38] congressional designated spending, which is so key to us moving forward. Paving update, we were able to pick up a couple of additional projects right outside town hall. You may have noticed when you came in, Municipal Drive was done just down to the parking lot. a stretch of Gorham Road that was really in rough shape. And then a piece of Holmes Road. Again, these are kind of fixes to get us in the immediate future as was suggested, but really essential. [28:04] We intend to do restriping on those sections this week, you know, pending availability of our contractor. The weather looks good. And then remaining roads will be picked up in the spring. mobile saunas is a matter that was on your last council agenda. The matter was tabled to long range. I just wanted the council and the public to be aware that long range really has already its dance card full. [28:26] they are actively engaged in all the different matters related to compliance with some of the state law changes. And we really need to have them focus on that. So, they really can't take up any of this kind of outside work until probably next summer, July or so. So, you know, it's possible once the council reconvenes, its committees the ordinance committee could pick this up if that's something we want to advance earlier. [28:53] and I'm pleased to work once committees are sorted through. just remember next week we have a new counselor welcome reception. We have three new counselors coming in, so we'll do something I'm not sure if 5:30 or 6:00 6:00 and that will be something for the community and certainly the candidates and their and their families to come and just be welcomed into to the town council. [29:19] I just want to mention a little human interest story. this council may recall the Boston Post Cane was handed out to a recipient about a year ago, Geraldine Hodgkins. we did receive a note from her daughter and Liam's I think getting a picture, but she turned 100 last week. And so, she's doing very well and her daughter wanted me to share that with the council with the public, so I'm pleased to do that. [29:46] bear with me. I've got a few more things that came since I published this. we did receive notice earlier this week that the Small Business Administration is providing dis- disaster assistance for the drought that we're now experiencing. This is to benefit small businesses and private nonprofits. I'm coordinating things with SEDC to make sure that our folks are aware of what resources are available. [30:12] [30:15] this council's heard from members of the public regarding some conversations at the Shellfish Commission regarding interest in exploring a conservation closure of all of our flats. to that end, the Shellfish Commission did meet and has scheduled a public hearing for November 10th, that's next Tuesday. [30:36] and I will be there just making sure that you know that all the legal needs are met if you will and everything is functioning properly. But that's an essential part and a required part of this process. after public comment the commission would take the matter up formally and take a vote in that regard. [30:57] And they have final say. The way this works with our system we have a shellfish conservation ordinance that empowers our commission to make these decisions. I should say it is subject to Department of Marine Resources approval. But these questions don't come before the council I guess is the point I want to make. [31:18] And lastly I just want to welcome new councilors you know Shawn Jessica and Aisha just remarkable to have seven candidates. I don't think I've seen that in my tenure here. I think it's testament to the interest and involvement our residents have. usually when this happens people in my line of work we get scared that there's something wrong. [31:41] I'm not aware there's any one thing wrong. Maybe there's a lot of little things but there's all sorts of motivations it seems and I think it's just tremendous and a great testament to our community. And thank you Bill and Larry for your service. It's been a pleasure. [31:55] Thank you. [31:56] Mr. President. [31:59] It's time for you what to say. [32:00] Jonathan. [32:01] Jo- oh I beg your pardon. [32:05] [laughter] [32:06] So sorry. [32:08] I think I think we're all [32:10] for like a big speech at the end right now. [32:12] [laughter] [32:13] That was just a rhetorical example. [32:16] I think we're all kind of running on fumes from last night. [32:20] Yeah thanks. Yeah any questions or comments please? [32:23] I don't think anybody slept much last night so forgive us. Tom have you had any updates on metro and just the added service and just like for election day do we get a lot of takers on like free rides to polls? [32:38] I don't. I certainly can and that's something I think they can provide very accurate information on. I'm also interested in just general ridership. I see it all around town very often. It seems staged and ready to respond to the next call. I [clears throat] will say I received notice from them on two occasions since they started service in which they're just advising that they've expanded their service area based on demand and that's just a really good sign that they're being [33:04] responsive. But I'm interested in getting some metrics so I will work on that and I'll report out. [33:09] Good. Thank you. [33:10] Yes. [33:11] Anyone else? Scott? [33:13] Yeah. I guess the thing I'll touch on is the clam committee. it doesn't seem right or fair and I don't know how it was set up that way that the committee can make this decision without a vote of the clam diggers themselves. I think that they, you know, clam diggers should make this decision whether they want to shut down or not. [33:37] If it's a state mandated thing, that's one thing but and I think the clam diggers that talking to them, they're torn between the two. There's some that but I really think that maybe this should be something looked at to change the way the ruling is and the ordinances to [33:58] not have it that just a committee. I think we've given them the committee's too much power. I, you know, I've been saying that right along and I think that we ought to That's one of my goals for this next year is give the power back to the people and I've been saying it right along about having a referendum on some of these big issues when things come up. [34:22] You know, the committee's making the decision and then the council just going along with whatever the committee comes up with as in thinking that 's from the This is the committee that's part of the people in the town but it's a small very small percentage of people. So I think that it should really come [34:43] from the people. And this is a situation, too, that could be on that referendum thing. You could say, you know, and they could ask the Kennebunk people in town, you know, what do you think? Do you want? And then the people can vote on it. And I think that's the main thing we got to do is put the power back in the people's hands and have these issues go. [35:06] And then we don't have this, you know, all of a sudden people are all coming out. And it's like everything you think everything's fine, and all of a sudden the people are coming out, "What the heck are you doing?" Cuz nobody listens. Like I said, they don't listen to the committee meetings and stuff. They just take all of a sudden hear what's going on in town, and then there's a big uproar. So, I think if we make it very clear, and it'll be talked about until November when the, you know, November election comes. [35:29] And I think that's an important issue. It's all connected. But and it connects a lot of I think it have For me, it would solve almost all the issues in town. But yeah, thank you. Thanks, Scott. Anyone else? Bill? [35:49] Tom mentioned the IFW meeting the regarding plover protection and that they plan to take further protective action or they may. Looks like they will. I thought it would be helpful for people I live at Higgins Beach. In fact, I live down by the river. So, their land [36:10] backs up to my land. and I've appreciated the support of IFW and this town in trying to protect piping plovers. It's an endangered species, and it deserves the protection. It gets tremendous attention and interest on Higgins Beach. [36:31] People come all the time just so they can see them, see the chicks go. And I so, I wanted to just weigh in and say, "I think that would be great if IFW imposes greater restraints on that portion that they own, which is as you get to the river beyond the last house, they start to have a property ownership [36:58] and it goes all the way back towards Harmon's Island where I live in the marshy area that's covered and it's that's the major area where plover nesting takes place. So, it would have an important positive effect in promoting [37:18] the protection of the piping plovers. [37:22] Thanks. Just like Councillor Donovan reminds me a question was posed at the podium that I can speak to with respect to the beach management agreement, no prior agreement has come forward for council action. It's all been done at the staff level. That was my intent with this as well. This is a document that does a number of things, but essentially allows us to rake the rake the beach and but provides all sorts of protections to the satisfaction of the [37:52] state and federal government. Having said that, I'm pleased to share the document and the language that we're proposing and make that publicly available. There's no concern there. So, I just wanted that's my anticipated route forward unless I hear otherwise from council. [38:13] Anyone else? Right. Thanks, Tom. Moving on to item number nine, standing and special committee reports and liaison reports. Scott, would you like to kick off anything? [38:27] Next Tuesday. [38:28] All right. All right. No, thanks. Okay. [38:31] No, they didn't meet, so thanks. [38:32] Yeah. Karen. [38:36] I just want to mention that the Conservation Commission and then what's coming before the Ordinance Committee, whoever's on the Ordinance Committee, and is the low impact development standards that are coming down from the state. I just kind of wanted continue to mention that cuz that's something that the town's been working on for about a year now. And so we're on that kind of timeline of having meetings [38:56] and workshops. So we had the first workshop last month. And so we're going to be starting to work on that or the town's going to be starting to work on that with this ordinance committee in January and February. So while it is standards coming down from the state, we are looking at different places where we could maybe be more restrictive or put more protection in place for some of our urban and impaired streams and the marshes and things like that. [39:21] So I just ask everyone to pay attention. It's going to be a lot of information. It's going to be a lot to take. Well, there's not a lot we have control over it, but there's going to be a lot of interest. [39:30] Yes. Thanks. Bill? [39:33] nothing. No committee meetings. [39:35] John? [39:35] Yep. The transportation committee met and they looked at traffic calming improvements around the Payne Road area. I would just hope that the council will remember that when we approved in the budget to have 300k in traffic calming improvements that it also contemplated some Scott Hill Road improvements. And I know neighbors who live there are worried that 's getting lost in some of the conversations. [39:58] So for those that are going to stick around, just ask that as those traffic calming projects come forward that we don't forget about Scott Hill Road. I'm sure what you will need to deliberate about the the culvert might impact that as well. So again, just want to make sure what that we think about those residents on Scott Hill. I highly recommend what Tom had suggested earlier about having a sitting councilor or a new councilor attend the next transportation committee. [40:27] Which will probably be before there's assignments because they are going to be with the Portland West group with main DOT. That was a very big issue project a couple years ago. I suspect even as they make decisions trying to do it right, it will also still be a very big issue for our community. [40:47] And so I just highly encourage the council to stay very close to that, and hopefully consider having a workshop at some point with main DOT. I think one of the mistakes we made in the past was we didn't meet with them enough. We like met with them, and then a year passed, and then we met with them again, and just because I think the impact is going to be so big depending on whatever route they go with that just keep a close pulse on that. [41:12] there's also conversation about hopefully having a joint school and transportation committee meeting to really talk about offsite traffic improvements. one of the concerns by the transportation committee was there's a real opportunity to make some improvements, some of which are already needed and have been needed for a while, [41:33] and while that may not be the scope of the project, or they make some of those improvements may fall outside the scope, the town should really look into that and figure out what are other things we may want to do to help make sure that those improvements are happening. the SEDCO celebration was a couple weeks ago. Myself, Larry, and Corey were there. [41:55] It was great. Karen did a phenomenal job as she usually does highlighting some key stats about the community, and so I just wanted to share a couple. So, jobs have increased 16.9% in Scarborough between 2020 and 2025. Unemployment is at a wonderful low of 2.5%. [42:15] I'm going to share this next one. It's not super popular, but it's important. for TIFs, we've generated 629.6 million in new value that's been shielded from the state and county for tax calculations. We brought in 7.35 million in revenues. 2.05 million of that has been paid out in CEAs, [42:36] but the shelter benefit that Karen reviewed with us in finance showed that this year the shelter benefit was 2.25 million, which is actually more than the CEA payments for the first time since we've had the TIFs in place. And that's just really important because as the TIF area continues to grow, as the Downs especially in their next phase opens up all of those new projects, [43:02] that shelter benefit is going to continue to grow exponentially. And that's really going to help with affordability within our community. And so while I know TIFs and CEAs have a negative connotation in our community, CEAs, yes, those are tax breaks to developers. But you can have TIFs without CEAs. They can be mutually exclusive if you want them to be. [43:24] And so as we continue to grow because we will by state law, making sure that the council really thinks about TIFs as a strategic tool to help with affordability, not necessarily for tax breaks, but to really make sure that we're using the tools that we have available to us to help with affordability, I think is important. So I would encourage the next council to really [43:46] spend some time and the new councilors really to kind of get more knowledgeable in what TIFs are and aren't and try to avoid the hyperbole that's around them as it relates to development because they really can be great tools for affordability. that's it. [44:03] Thanks, Shell. [44:04] yeah, thanks, John. Can do you just have a sense on the timeline for Portland West? [44:09] I don't know what the timeline is in terms of when they're planning to make actual decisions, but I would suspect, given the work that they've done up to this point, within the next year I would assume they're going to make a final recommendation. So they have five options. The transportation committee is going to review and ask a lot of really good questions. I've previewed them and that group, as Tom said, is very much on their toes. [44:33] and so I just think it would be really great for councilors to really dive in and understand. [44:38] Good. Great, thank you. couple of things. One, long-range planning meets next week on the 13th. the communication committee met on the 22nd and just a couple things the councilors completed their last round of conversations with councilors. those went well. There was a lot of focus on the radio project in those meetings. [45:02] There's been a suggestion and kind of a request by groups in town. Hillcrest, for example, would like us to do one at Hillcrest because they have a larger audience there and that would be convenient for them. Somebody in Eastern Village mentioned to me they have a they have a group and association. So, I think that one of the things I'm going to look at going into next year is having some that are broad-based, but also trying to like go to natural populations of people that want to engage, [45:32] which I think is great. another suggestion, which I think is a good one, is at those meetings maybe the first part targeting a topic. So, it could be the budget, it could be the radio tower, it could be you know, traffic, anything that feels like a hot topic that we want to get more input on. And so, part of it might be focused on a topic and then the other half of the session might just be open Q&A and dialogue. [45:58] too. And the last piece on that is we have a group of about 15 people that have attended some meetings to be communication ambassadors and one of the things we'd like to do before January is just to kind of plot all those people on sort of a map of Scarborough and make sure that regionally that we have representation like across the town. [46:21] I know like, for example, North Scarborough when we went out to do some meetings there said really no one had gone out there to that to before that and so they sort of felt like they were isolated or really weren't being heard. I know the other side of the turnpike has had some of those concerns. So, I really just want to make sure that, you know, every regional part of the town has a voice at the table and feels like they're getting, you know, the right level of engagement. [46:46] So. [46:48] Thanks. So, as evidenced by some of the updates this evening, we're obviously in kind of a transitional period with the council and we'll have three new members joining us in 2 weeks and shortly after that we'll be working to figure out who will be on what committees and we'll get those constituted and get everyone up and running so that we can continue to do to do all the work that we have to do. [47:10] So, look forward to that. I also wanted to just mention as John talked about few of us attended the SEDCO event last week which was great and I appreciate that John took that picture of the of Karen slide about the all those facts and figures which was a lot of good stuff. They're also [47:31] were awards given as they do every year to local businesses in different categories including historic preservation which was given to the Cindy Taylor's project across the street just across Route 1 which now in some ways looks like a new building but really captures a lot of the spirit and Cindy talked about some of the history and how it used to be a dance hall [47:52] and so that was kind of that was kind of interesting. Ken's Seafood got an award and they noted that next year will be their centennial as they as they put it. So that's something else to look forward to. The Black Point Surf Shop got an award as well. So it was it was good to just sort of be reminded that you know that we do have some great local businesses and entrepreneurs in our community that also serve our community so appreciated that opportunity. [48:21] So moving on we'll head to the next section of the agenda item number 10 resolutions and proclamations none at this time. That takes us to public hearings. Item number 11.1 order number 26-94 [48:38] 7:00 p.m. public hearing and action on the new request for a food handlers license from Todd McKay doing business as nothing bundt cakes located at 550 Gallery Boulevard and from Thang Swan Tong doing business as Hosanna Sushi located at 70 Market Street and I apologize if I mispronounced anything. [48:58] Yes, thank you on behalf of the town clerk's office, I present this these orders of the Nothing Bundt Cake is a muffin week. So, it requires a approval for the council. The other is Hosanna Sushi is a new Describo and I believe they're within Market Basket, which requires since they're a separate entity, they require a license. [49:19] the applications have been vetted and the clerk's office requests approval. [49:25] Thank you. do we have a motion? [49:28] It's a public comment. [49:29] Sorry. Oh, sorry. Now, I'm going to play the sleep deprived card all night. before we move to council action, is there any public comment on this item? [49:42] All right, seeing none. Do we have a motion? [49:44] So moved. [49:44] Second. [49:45] Any council discussion? Call the vote. All in favor? Sorry. Oh. [49:49] Yeah, you're being [49:50] Sedco had Nothing Bundt Cakes there. They're so delicious. The lemon raspberry one is my favorite. So, thank you, Karen, and thank you to them for donating those cuz those are just amazing. [50:01] Yeah, that was good product placement. Excellent. Yeah. All right, any other comments, questions? All right, now I'll call the vote. All in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you. Good luck. [50:17] Item number 11.2, order number 26-95, [50:21] 7:00 p.m. public hearing and action on the new request for a massage therapist license from Heidi Hokal working at Helios Corporation located at 20 Black Point Road. [50:31] Thank you. Again, this I'm presenting this on behalf of the town clerk's office. This is a new application which requires a public hearing and approval by the town council. The application's been vetted and the town clerk's office is asking for approval. [50:45] Thank you. do we have any public comment on this item? All right, seeing none. Do we have a motion? [50:52] So moved. [50:52] Second. [50:53] Okay. Any discussion? [50:57] All right, all in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you. And good luck. [51:06] Moving on to old business, item number 12.1, order number 26-73, second reading of the proposed amendments to chapter 405 zoning ordinance section 6 definitions to add and amend definitions pertaining to timber harvesting and updating commercial zoning districts to increase streetscape buffer minimum requirements to 20 ft for all streets. [51:29] Autumn [51:30] Thank you. Good evening. My name is Autumn Speer. I'm the director of planning and codes. And before I talk about this, I just wanted to say thank you so much for to counselor Cain, counselor Donovan, and especially counselor Anderson. I've I've spent the most time with you and I got to be part of the tiger team, so it was fun. I just wanted to tell you all you've been really a pleasure to work with and staff really appreciates your professionalism, your consideration, your kindness. [51:55] so we will miss you. Now I'm going to talk to you a little bit about tree definitions. So 26-073 works in conjunction with the next item. These are the amendments to the zoning ordinance chapter 405. And so essentially we're changing all of these different zoning categories to include a 20-ft streetscape buffer for all other streets. [52:21] Most of those in your packet, there's a summary table and you can see that for the majority of our arterials and primary roadways, we already have 25 to 35-ft streetscape setbacks in place, but this change would apply to all other streets. this particular item really only pertains to that and I can keep this one separate from the second item if you'd prefer or I can I can discuss it in conjunction. [52:49] It's really up to you all. [52:52] I'd be fine with you taking on the second one now as well if that works for you. It's all sort of connected. [52:59] The second part is chapter 405B. It's our site plan review ordinance. And this one has quite a bit more to it. We are adding some process descriptors and some clarification on how we process for code enforcement cases, how we address minor administrative and major site plan reviews. [53:22] The real meat of it comes in the landscaping changes. And so, we worked with the Conservation Commission, our ordinance committee. this has really been most of the year. It's hard to believe we're already in November. but essentially, we have put a proposal together that increases the number of trees in the streetscape buffer [53:45] from 1 to 30 to 1 to 15. That's the proposed change there. We've also established recommended and establishing tree preservation. And so, in that, we have defined significant trees. Those are trees that are 20 diameter at breast height wide. And we've also identified what a heritage tree would be. [54:06] Those are much more significant trees. And what you would have to do on a site if you remove those. So, there's some mitigation requirements, some replanting. And then later in your in the agenda on the evening is also an option for a fee in lieu. So, if you're unable to replant on site for those trees that you might have to remove, there is a fee in lieu proposed as well. [54:32] So, essentially, when I look at it, I think of number six, 12, and 13 are sort of the three areas that are really substantial for the landscape changes. In your packet, there are also some text amendments that staff has put together. We had our landscape architect peer review look over these. [54:52] And so, in that third attachment, there are some things that are highlighted in yellow, and those are some recommendations that they provided. Just for clarity, it also addresses diseased trees and how those would not have to be mitigated for. And I 'm happy to answer any specific questions you might have about that item. [55:15] Great. Thank you. we'll open this one up for public comment if anyone would like to speak on this. [55:25] April Hill, Maple Avenue. I support the tree harvesting ordinance coming before you as written without amendments. This ordinance has gone through conservation ordinance committee twice, has been in front of the planning board, and now the council for a third time, second reading. You, the council, volunteers, and the public have weighed in. Staff has put a great deal of time and work into it. [55:47] Now you get to vote to pass it, but do we need this ordinance? Yes. I came before you in the summer speaking to the illegal clear-cutting by a developer on Route 1. This developer cut into the protected stream buffer and cleared trees over significant vernal pool. Fines are in process, however, you can't bring those mature trees back and significant vernal pool back, either. [56:08] This ordinance will work to prevent that in the future. On Muzzy Road, there was an illegal clear-cutting and no fines were ever assessed by the town. This ordinance will help prevent that kind of clear-cutting from happening again. Let's talk about Eight Corners, which has been used as an example in these chambers and around town repeatedly of what Scarborough does not want to have happened again. [56:29] I have yet to speak to someone who wasn't shocked and horrified by how it looks. Yet that massive clear-cutting without any tree buffer was and is permitted under our current ordinance. The ordinance in front of you tonight will change that. It requires buffers between the development and the road. No one wants or needs to see a business or apartment complex to know that it's there. That's what signage is for. [56:50] One of the published council goals for 2026 is, quote, "Explore strategies to limit tree cutting for new commercial developments," end quote. The council credited this ordinance in front of you in the council goal status update 2026 as an indicator of having met that goal. Here is the moment of truth. You have the opportunity to make this goal a reality. [57:11] I trust that the council will pass this ordinance and without amendments that will whittle away or weaken the protections desperately needed in town. Thank you. [57:20] Thank you. [57:23] Chrissy Maurer, 20 Meeting House Road and I'm a sit on the Conservation Commission. So, I'm here to speak in favor of this this ordinance. I really think it's important to keep those 20-ft buffer for commercial properties. I think there are ways if there are concerns that this is sort of a blanket that there are that we can incorporate if you make any amendments, you know, some way to request a waiver in case there are [57:54] hardships on the specific commercial property that can be justified. But, I think in general this is very workable. It's also complements of what is going to be forthcoming low impact development requirements anyway. So, it's going to help us keep heritage trees. I don't think it's going to create a screen that's you know, basically [58:14] you know, where you can't see property. But, it it's going to be important for managing stormwater runoff and maintaining our, you know, our significant tree cover. Thank you. [58:27] Thank you. [58:40] Nina McKee, 309 Black Point Road. I just quickly want to say that I am so glad that there is this focus on trees. there is a development on Traymore and Highland Avenue that I actually took pictures that I was going to bring to this council. The that the developer took down a whole [59:04] whole street of trees. It was a whole It was horrible. And then piled up huge soil or something. It was It was just horrific. And, and I'm so glad that this ordinance will stop that because, it really was upsetting to see. [59:26] And trees are so precious. maybe someone should tell Trump that he shouldn't cut down any more trees. Yeah. Thank you. [59:35] Thank you. [59:41] Anyone else in the room for public comment on this? I think we have someone online. Yep. Go ahead. [59:49] Hello again, Matthew Keith, 8 Pleasant Ave here. I don't know how I'm supposed to follow up Nina and say anything any better than she just did. but I would like to echo the strong support for this this All right, I forget if it's a ordinance, a amendment, whatever it is. For this for this proposal. [1:00:11] because, you know, really as we've seen in many of these different developments where it was kind of just like a oops or we didn't we didn't think it through or the ordinance wasn't in place. I think getting out ahead of this especially before citywide changes to [1:00:32] the requirements or the lack of requirements that we can do at the town Sorry, I'm stuttering and my stutter sometimes is a block so I can't get some of the words out. But, yeah, I just also I just want to echo strong support for this and then normally I am a big proponent of following the protocols. [1:00:53] so I'm sorry in advance on this but I forgot earlier on to shout out John Anderson. So I just want to take a moment to say that Counselor Anderson and previous Counselor Sider were honestly the biggest inspiration for me when I first got involved to stay involved. and they both are one of the main reasons why I've continued to be as involved as I have. [1:01:15] So, I just want to appreciate you publicly, Councillor Anderson, and thank you for being an amazing counselor, an amazing person, and for helping to inspire me to stay involved. [1:01:29] Thank you. anyone else with public comment on this item? Or really these two items. They're sort of connected. seeing none, welcome a motion on 2673. [1:01:44] So moved. [1:01:45] Second. [1:01:46] Any council discussion? Questions? Here. [1:01:51] I'll start. this has been a long process. I think as some of the speakers have said and as our town planner director, Autumn, has also indicated. to kind of touch on John Surface, you know, this was sort of why I ran was because I was on planning board when the eight corners development went in and was like, why are we cutting all these trees? [1:02:13] And it was just, well, it's allowed. It's allowed. It's allowed. I was like, well, I want to change that. It's not that easy. And so, four years later, this here we are. And so, I think we've worked really hard this past year kind of crafting this because it is it is unique but unique but not. South Portland does it. So, people are doing this but every town is unique within itself. [1:02:35] And so, I think we took a lot of time with this ordinance to try to really feel like what is best for Scarborough. You know, throughout my service, I think we've consistently received complaints about tree cutting and I can you know, we heard a couple examples tonight and while you people were speaking, I thought of a couple other ones that I've heard throughout the years. And you know, I always think of with the pine tree state. And so, you know, I just I kind of want to remember that. [1:02:56] You know, I think Scarborough is special when we think about the marsh and all of the streams and the rivers and all the resources that we have. And I think that's what makes Scarborough special. And so, I really feel like this is a step in the right direction specifically kind of in you know, response to resident complaints and kind of preserving what we have here. You know, we you know, we're trying to slow growth as much as you can but you can't you can only control it so much, but this is another mechanism of saying, "Okay, you know, we have growth in Scarborough, but at least we can keep a line of trees there to kind of keep it that [1:03:26] way." And so, I know you know, I think there are some concerns and some ideas that have been brought up, but I do feel like we've had ample time throughout this process to kind of go through it, and it is pretty in-depth, and there's a lot of details and things like that. So, I appreciate again the ordinance committee Bill and John working on this, and the conservation commission that just spends endless hours and on this, and [1:03:49] that's it. Thank you. [1:03:51] Thank you. [1:03:54] Bert? [1:03:55] Yeah. so, I am interested, just in case you might think I'm just going to go quietly into the night. I do have some amendments to propose to this, but very, in my opinion, very minor, and they come from the aspect of that through this whole process, which I completely agree with. [1:04:16] I love the intent and the goals, but I don't think there was much consideration for the impact on property owners and business owners. And so, I've got well, kind of three and a half amendments, and certainly willing to hear the rest of the discussion here before I introduce them, but [1:04:36] I just want to let you know that we're going to move forward those. [1:04:40] Thank you. John? [1:04:42] Yeah, I don't I don't think any of those amendments are for this particular item, right? So, [1:04:46] Right, they're all combined. I think Yeah, we ended up Autumn kind of presented them together, but yeah, sorry. That's That would be the next kind of companion item. [1:04:56] Bert? [1:04:56] Yeah. [1:04:57] For this one in particular, which is really the 20-ft buffer, you know, the reason why I supported it in ordinance was because I do feel like when you look at our buffers today, in the most cases, it's higher or close to 20 ft as it is. so, adding an extra 10 ft in a few places is not very big, and frankly may not preserve very many trees in the process. [1:05:22] And so but where it does do it, where it does matter, I think it's worth it. I think Karen raised some great points about and some of the speakers about the low impact development fee our low impact development that we're trying to do in town. And because we are a coastal community and we have the marsh, the more green we have around, the more I believe that it protects [1:05:44] our beautiful natural resources. And so this to me is a little thing. It's not a big thing. And while I appreciate that for some property owners it could have impact. 10 ft in addition to what they already have to do to me doesn't feel like that much of an ask. And so I'm comfortable with this, seeing how it goes, and of course [1:06:04] anytime we change anything, it's never perfect and we're going to learn and for the next council, you know, you guys can hear what the impact is live cuz it will have impact. People won't really know about it until they feel it. And so then you guys can figure out whether it should change to something else. But I'm comfortable with it moving forward as is. [1:06:24] This one. [1:06:25] Good. Thanks. [1:06:27] Yeah. [1:06:28] Anyone else? Scott? [clears throat] [1:06:30] Yeah, I'm opposed to it because couple of facts. the eight corners project, I thought it was kind of odd that the building was close, but maybe it is the setbacks. It just seems cuz it's so big, it seems like it's closer to the road. when you do a development like that, you have to clear cut. I mean, you're building a building, so you have to cut everything. [1:06:53] And I think they left a huge amount of trees out back. And it only makes sense, like I've said before, for that development, any other development, when you do a clear cut like that, the trees at the edges tend to blow over. They 've been supported by the other trees. And now you get a strong wind, they're going to blow over. So you're going to build a brand new structure and you're going to have a tree fall into it. [1:07:16] It doesn't just doesn't make sense. same with the buffer in the front. if you're going to clear cut an area, you're going to leave those trees in the front, pretty much it's almost a guarantee that you're going to have a tree fall into that brand new structure, and it just doesn't make sense to do that. I like trees, but you know, again, if you have one threatening, you know, and then you have to determine what is a threat and how is the tree growing and is it going to split off? [1:07:45] And you don't know, obviously, you know, we have power outages all the time. If they knew which tree was going to split off, they'd cut it down and take care of it, but you can't cuz you don't know what Mother Nature's going to do. so, I think it's the individual landowners' choice should be, in other words, power back to the people, and this should be maybe a referendum you know, item and ask people, but a lot of people wouldn't know what to do, what is you know, what would make sense. [1:08:16] it sounds good to have the trees. but I just it just doesn't For that reason, it doesn't make sense. So, and we have an ordinance now. We already have a tree ordinance now that has buffers and stuff. so, you know, I don't know how you cannot clear out if you do want a housing development, you have to. [1:08:41] I mean, you would have to clear out. They take the stumps out, they take the soil off, they you know, they do the process that they do. You have to how it has to be done. I don't know how you could do it any different. And it's state law that you have to allow development. So, I just think that we just keep, you know, beating a dead horse. [1:09:03] Thank you. [1:09:04] Thank you. Anyone else on this item? yeah, I first of all, I really do appreciate all the work that's gone into this and the process to date, and I thought we had a good conversation at first reading back in I guess it was September. and I appreciate that you know, we're no longer including residential property owners here. [1:09:26] I think there was some legitimate concern about that maybe being a little bit overreach and kind of practically difficult to enforce given the constraints of our staff. and you know, I definitely understand the concerns. We've We've I feel like the A Corners project is it's kind of a poster child in some ways for a lot of people when it comes to how our town has grown and the development pattern and the and curb appeal in some cases. [1:09:55] And as Autumn has described well in the past, you know, that and others have alluded to that you know, that was not a violation. That was That was a result of what the what was a very intentional policy of the town at the time and kind of planning philosophy of the town which was that you know, we wanted in certain areas to have buildings closer to the street, try to foster an environment that's you know, maybe a little bit more quote unquote village-like. [1:10:22] and in practice it hasn't quite played out the way that it might you know, we some might have hoped and I think for better or worse sometimes it with zoning and planning in general it can be a little bit trial and error and the pendulum kind of swings back and forth and it can take a while for things to sort of mature and for us to see the full impact of things as things are built out and landscaping [1:10:47] grows in and matures. you know, I do have some reservations about this notion of you know, every building, every business should be hidden from view. I think if we're going to take that approach, then maybe we should revisit our commercial design standards that we hold developers and owners to because we presumably care about what buildings look like. [1:11:08] And I think there is a legitimate interest in businesses having some visibility from the street. that said, I think this particular item is I think it's I think it's fine. and as John said, I think it's worth worth a try so to speak and it'll be interesting to see what the sort of what the response is once it's been implemented and people come into contact with it. [1:11:36] and we'll we'll see how it goes. Those are my thoughts, Michelle. [1:11:43] Thanks, Corey. I just Autumn, this made me think of our last long-range planning committee meeting, and one of the things that I kind of brought up at the end is we were discussing zoning and should, you know, areas be a growth area or not a growth area, and you know, what are we trying to do. And it got me thinking about cuz we're all sort of like, how do we get here? [1:12:05] Like, how did Eight Corners happen? You know, how do we end up with a swimming pool near in the road? and you know, there were groups of people before us in those meetings that well-intended came up with these, you know, ordinances or, you know, rules or buffers or whatever it whatever it is. [1:12:26] And what I said to the group is, you know, I don't want people sitting in that meeting 10 years from now and saying like, what were they thinking? And you know, you can't figure it all out, but I think in some ways we've seen enough in town, we've seen growth, and we've looked at projects and said, you know, this is something that we're proud of, and this is something that feels very [1:12:48] you know, environmentally friendly, and it feels like we're preserving what we care about in town, and we're still, you know, encouraging commercial business or the type of housing that we want. So, when I'm listening to this conversation, I really trust Autumn, and I really, you know, trust the people that have been on the committees, and the more I think about it, and certainly with what Karen said tonight is [1:13:13] I feel like they've thought this through far more and far more in depth and far more strategically than certainly I have and probably others on sitting up here may have, and I trust them, and I think that we've all had some pretty in-depth conversations about what we're trying to become [1:13:33] and you know trying to I guess improve and get better at. So, when I take a look at this, I support it. [1:13:41] Thank you. Anyone else? Blair? [1:13:44] Yeah, sorry for the mix-up before. I just want to be clear. I do support this move forward. I understand the intense and the trying to prevent maybe some of the bad outcomes that have happened in the past. so, I just wanted to be clear that it for this I'm definitely in favor of. [1:14:02] Thanks. [1:14:05] if there are no other comments, I'll call the vote on this item on 2673. All in favor? Opposed? Okay, that passes 6 to 1. Thank you. And now just for the record order number 2674. This is item 12.2, order number 26-74. [1:14:26] Second reading on the proposed amendments to chapter 405B, site plan review ordinance, section two, applicability, section three, application and review procedures, and section four, performance and design standard standards, section B, landscape and screening standards. Sorry. so, we've already had this one introduced. [1:14:49] we did [clears throat] get some public comment that touched on this as well. I will give the opportunity again if there was any confusion about that. [1:14:58] If anyone would like to speak on this particular item. [1:15:01] so, seeing none, would welcome a motion on 2674. [1:15:07] So moved. [1:15:08] Second. [1:15:10] All right. Any discussion on this item? [1:15:13] I think now's your time, Larry. [1:15:16] It may come as a surprise, but so to be clear, this is the more of the performance standards and design standards. So, really what I'm looking to do, like I said earlier, is tweak this a little bit to have some consideration around the impacts on property owners and businesses having to do with development and visibility from the street. [1:15:37] So, it's a series of three amendments plus one that is accepting the edits that are already covered in the draft that you have. so, Corey, I don't know if you'd like to entertain these one at a time or have further discussion from anybody before we start entertaining amendments. [1:16:00] I'd say go ahead. [1:16:01] Okay. Yeah. okay, so amendment one is a motion to move approval to amend the main motion to accept staff recommendations as noted by the yellow highlights to chapter 405V in attachment three. So, those Adam referred earlier to they had consulted with [1:16:23] arborist or landscape architect and there were suggested changes from that. So, these this is just a catchall to approve all those updates that the landscape architect suggested. [1:16:38] Second. All right. Any discussion on that amendment? [1:16:45] All right. I guess I will call the vote on that. That's it. There's no discussion. All in favor? [1:16:52] That's unanimous. Thank you. Returning to the main motion or your next amendment? [1:16:58] Sure. Amendment number two is a motion a motion to move approval to amend the main motion to section four, definitions colon significant tree definition to read bolded significant tree, a non-invasive tree species with a minimum DBH [1:17:19] of 24 in or 36 in cumulative DBH for a multi-stem tree. so [1:17:30] Second. I need a second. [1:17:32] so, the with this is that right now it's significant trees particularly definition in the performance and design standards. the intent would be to avoid to have an developer or this could be an existing business that's expanding [1:17:52] that has needs to take down some trees in order to accommodate their development. and it's increasing the DBH which is something breast circumference diameter at breast height which it was pointed out that I'm going to have Norm do all of these for us. [1:18:15] [laughter] [1:18:16] so it's increasing it's 24 in. So in effect you would not be allowed to remove trees with a diameter over 24 in. The original spec was 20 in. And this is just to if you can think about particularly a wooded lot say and somebody's coming in to place a building there or they're they're going to develop that their property in some way. [1:18:44] it allows them to save what it requires them to save trees above 24 in. but allows them to remove the other trees they might need you to site a building. and so this kind of concerned me from the standpoint that property owners would have bought or have owned [1:19:06] their existing property either for development or for sale. later, you know, they've invested in this property and by requiring many more trees to be that you can't cut them down, you'd really restrict how they could use their own property. And and the way I look at that is that then for whatever they're planning to do with that property, it would devalue that property. [1:19:32] and so and it could have a significant effect. And so it just allows a little more leeway for them to cut some trees to keep the existing value of their property. [1:19:48] I think that's enough. I We can discuss it more, but I just I just have concern that it feels a little bit like zoning through tree restriction. If you take somebody who has an existing property and you all of a sudden limit what they can do with that property, that's how what we accomplish with zoning laws. [1:20:08] And typically in a significant zoning change, the those property owners would be notified in those wherever those zoning changes occur. They would be notified and they would be advised of the impact on their property. They would on their own figure out that is a devaluation because it restricts what they could do. So that's kind of where my concern with that came. [1:20:32] Thanks. Any discussion on that? Michelle? [1:20:36] Yeah, that was a good explanation, Larry, cuz when I was reading all this yesterday, I was literally trying to get my head around how big the tree is and like what you know, it's it's complicated. But I guess I'd ask Autumn, you know, how often would you has this occurred or would you see this occurring where our businesses, as Larry points out, well, you know, trying to expand or trying to have an addition and is this something that we face a lot? [1:21:02] I'm just thinking like is this like one once every 3 years or are there businesses just constantly being challenged with us? [1:21:11] we don't have this in place now, but I would say that excuse me, most of the businesses that we have that are adding additions or expanding, they don't have trees to remove to do that. This would really probably affect those areas that there's not development on right now. so I'm I'm not sure I'm answering the question. [1:21:33] We don't We don't have tree preservation requirements. So I don't have a tree survey requirement. It's hard to say. A 20-in diameter breast height is So it's 20 in this way and then 24 as 2 ft. It's a significantly large tree. Walking around campus, there's not a very many if maybe less than five that I would say are at the 20 in. [1:21:54] So it's a it's a significant tree. but I don't I can't answer how we are how that's affecting us now. [1:22:03] Well, I'm just trying to get a sense of the scope and the impact. So we don't want to dissuade businesses from being successful and being able to grow, but we also, I think, need to have boundaries and be really clear on our expectations about you know, what we're trying to preserve and what we're trying [1:22:24] to be. So I'm trying to get my head around, you know, how do those two things either complement each other or sort of oppose each other. [1:22:34] so maybe I can help a little bit. So when I said earlier there's number six, 12, and 13. So there's three different things or two different things really at play. Number six really deals with that front street facade. So we have established now in the item before that the minimum is going to be 20 ft. and so if you are a site, the way it's written now, if you are a site with existing trees, you would maintain that existing buffer. [1:23:01] You could remove the diseased or dying trees, but and you could clean it up a bit, but you have to maintain that existing buffer. If you don't have that buffer, you're going to have to plant one. And as proposed, it's one per 15 ft new trees. So that's the first part. But then when you get ready and you get ready to build the building on the other part, that's when that tree survey would come into play and we would find out how many trees there are, you know, in that 20 in [1:23:30] diameter breast height calculation. So if you have three or four of those, if you're in a heavily wooded site, you're going to certainly have some of those trees. And if you The idea is that if there is a stand of trees that a grove of really good large trees, you are going to think about how you site your building and put a little bit more thought. [1:23:51] The land that we have in Scarborough, a lot of the land that has significant trees is also inundated with wetlands. So, there's already some problems on the land. much of the vacant land that we have now that is for sale is for sale for a reason and still vacant for a reason because it does have these problems. but the way the ordinance is written, so if you have four or five of those larger trees, you have the you have the you can still remove them. [1:24:15] So, we are not prohibiting you from removing them, but you have to mitigate for them. And so, it's a rate of two and a half trees and those two and a half trees can also count towards your required trees that are already in the ordinance. So, you have to do trees in your parking island, you have to do trees in your entryway, and some foundation planning. [1:24:35] So, they can all work towards that. and then if very worst case scenario, you absolutely do not have the ability to put those additional trees on site, you can ask the plan planning board to allow you to use this fee in lieu option. So, there are some ways to address it. [1:24:56] but as I mentioned, we just don't have it in place, so it's really hard to tell what the outcome would be. [1:25:02] Great. That was impressive. Thank you. [1:25:05] I think so. [1:25:05] Thanks. John? So, when I when I'm trying to like look at what other communities do, it seems like some progressive communities would go to 12 in instead of 20 in. And so, I'm just going to apply the Goldilocks principle to this and say 12 in is too small, 24 is maybe too big, and 20 feels just right. [1:25:25] And so, I'm I'm likely not going to support this particular amendment because I don't think it significantly changes things and 20 feels okay to me, and so I'm fine just keeping it as is. [1:25:41] Okay. Thank you. Karen? [1:25:45] Yeah, I think I'll just say I don't know that much about trees, but I will say that when it comes to this type of detailed work. But, I would say there were multiple meetings about the diameter of trees. And so, I really feel like at that time, that is the time that we need to really be having these discussions, you know, we have these goals, so we know that we're doing them. [1:26:06] We know that we're working on them. I 've said from the beginning, this is a pretty in-depth type of ordinance with a lot of details, and a lot of different things that we had conversations around. And so, I think when we get to the second read and we get to the final point, I feel like there's a lot of people who are in this process who are now sitting here going, I want to have that chance to be able to speak in support [1:26:26] further beyond what Karen's saying right now why we introduced these diameters. And so, I think that's I feel like we should stick with what we did. I think with any ordinance, you know, we're nothing's perfect. I think it would be great to kind of see how this gets implemented. You know, I good or bad, I really don't know how many commercial lots are left in Scarborough with lots of trees. [1:26:50] and I think as our town the planning director just described, like we're not trying to prevent people from developing their properties. We're just trying to have to work with them to do it in a more mindful manner. and so, I again, I appreciate Autumn kind of coming up and clarifying again that like, you know, we're not saying you can't build because you have this great heritage tree in the middle of your lot. We're just saying like, you can't just cut it down. [1:27:11] Now, you kind of have to be thoughtful about it and think about what you're going to do because you are going to be cutting it down. Thank you. [1:27:18] Thank you. Blair? [1:27:21] Thanks. Just to be clear, we're not talking about the heritage trees at all. Those are over 60 in. [1:27:25] Right. [1:27:25] no, I just didn't want to because it's a it's difference, but I think I think why I'm poking into this is from what I ascertained. And just to be clear, at first reading, I did have some of these objections and moved it along. but I didn't see [1:27:46] a contact, outreach, consideration for the business community in this whole process. so, that's why I was poking into this, and I think what I was envisioning and Autumn described it a little bit, but if you've got a property that already is severely constricted by wetlands, which I agree with those setbacks, [1:28:06] and you have a opportunity to place your building, and there's three of these trees, three say, I guess 20-in trees that are keeping you from doing that, I would want the owner to be able to make that change with the property already being restricted. [1:28:27] so, I'm saying for the 24-in trees, which I don't think there's that many of, either, that we would they would not be able to do it. so, I again, it's kind of coming at it from the property owner's point of view, and trying to recognize that we've done many, great ordinances and setback requirements and all, and so I don't think this difference [1:28:54] actually will come into effect all that often, but when it does, I would like that business to be able to have that opportunity to do it. And just to be clear, the it for this size tree, the in lieu of fee is $5,000 a tree. So, that also, depending on how many they had to take, could be a significant financial burden to the property owner, as well. [1:29:18] so, that's where I land. [1:29:22] Thank you, Karen. [1:29:22] I just want to make a point that I do believe the business community is aware, and Autumn's shaking her head. I just like generally, the Conservation Commission has been super busy. They're the developers, the they are they are in tune, they are watching our meetings. We have Karen Martin from SEDCO, who is somewhat of our liaison, who at least would be saying there's work going on in the council that would be impacting your business. [1:29:44] And so, I think that's also why it's important that we put these out there, because I mean, that's the point where it's going, "Okay, you know, last January, the council's talking about trees, and Karen doesn't want to cut any more trees." And so, I think like I do I just I want to clarify that cuz I do feel like they are aware they are aware that it's happening. sometimes they're strategic, and we get emails right at the end, even though they've known all along that it's happening. [1:30:06] So, I just want to make sure that people are aware that it happened. [1:30:14] Okay. [1:30:16] again, with the committee meetings, I mean, you can go and voice whatever you want, but they're going to do what they want to do, you know? You can go there and say, but you know, why people aren't going to waste their breath? It's like they're going to do this, and I had a guy that's passed away now that after this town hall was built, he says, "We voted against it, and they built it anyway, so I'm never voting again." You know, he just got discouraged with the whole town. [1:30:43] He never voted again. He just was done. And I said, "Jeez, you can't do that. Don't do that." But that's his reaction to it. And it's just you know, micromanaging everybody's lives, you know? It's just how many ordinances are we going to have? I mean, Jesus, you got to go through hoops. And everybody wonders why everything costs so much. [1:31:04] Well, the businesses are going to have to pay. No, you are, because businesses are just going to pass it along to the consumer. And why does everything cost so much? This. This is why everything costs so much. Every time we turn around, there's a new council that wants to fix things for us. Or, you know, somebody comes from another state and says, "You know, we've been here 350 years, but let's see if we can fix it and make it better." You know, you don't know what you're doing. [1:31:28] And no, I we've got enough ordinances and enough fees and enough all of this stuff restricting people and homeowners, and you know, in this last election, I you know, why people didn't turn out to make a statement on that, I don't know. I don't understand it. you know, when [1:31:50] they voted me in cuz I wanted to cut taxes, but they voted for to spend all kinds of money on other referendums on the same ballot. So, hard to figure people out. [1:32:01] [laughter] [1:32:04] You know, it's I it just I'm I that's that's the one of the main reasons that is main reason that I ran because I you know, I wasn't here to fix things. I'm here to stop things from trying to be fixed that don't need to be fixed, you know, and that's an economic thing. It's an economic issue. And if people would see that, I mean, I can see it as you know, it's like they're in front of your face, but these people like I don't see it. [1:32:29] You know, anyways. [clears throat] Bye. [1:32:32] Thank you. I don't think you'd be able to fit all that on a bumper sticker, Scott, but that's I do appreciate the sentiment and in all seriousness, you know, I do I really can sort of see both sides of this. and this is, you know, to Larry's point, that make no mistake, in my opinion, this is a significant [1:32:55] a significant new regulation {slash} restriction. And I think, as alluded to earlier, the impacts and the reaction to those impacts might be somewhat delayed based on the nature of these parcels. I think, you know, I generally support do support the ordinance. [1:33:16] I support the spirit of it. I also support I agree with the spirit of the of the amendments that Larry's bringing forward. I'm really torn on this particular one, because we're talking about, you know, somewhat arbitrary cutoff numbers, dimensions. and it's, you know, we were sort of joking about it earlier, but most of us in our daily lives don't think a lot about tree diameter, [1:33:39] and things like that, and how that relates to human scale, and so forth. I do think I do think it's you know, the point about cost impact and affordability is relevant, particularly if we're thinking about parcels that could be could potentially be developed for housing. and as has been mentioned, low-hanging fruit is pretty much gone around town. [1:34:04] So, the parcels that are left tend to be kind of infill sites and/or they're surrounded by wetlands and they end up being sort of conservation subdivision parcels. So, you're already severely limited in terms of how you can site buildings and how much buildable land there really is and still abide by all the setbacks. and I so, I think we [1:34:25] however we vote, I just think we should be open-eyed about that. cuz things will [clears throat] will get passed along. I guess at the end of the day, I you know, I guess I'm in favor of this of this amendment given that it is at least a little bit of a nod to trying to change the threshold a little bit while still kind of pursuing this the spirit of this and the goal of this, but trying to mitigate the potential impact and potential affordability effects. [1:34:55] So, that's that's where I am on that. I certainly [clears throat] understand why folks would feel differently. [1:35:02] Any more discussion on this amendment? I'll call the vote then. All in favor? [1:35:08] I count four. And all opposed? [1:35:14] Three. So, four to three. Thank you. [1:35:18] Larry, would you like to [1:35:20] Sure. [1:35:20] keep us going? [1:35:21] very similar for this amendment I've been your document amendment three. a motion to move an approval to amend the main motion as amended to section six, buffer yard streetscape to read section six, buffer yard streetscape. [1:35:44] Everybody hear that okay? I mean the first part I don't have to redo then. to increase the streetscape. so, section A is increase the tree spacing to 20 ft, currently at 15. Restore the statement which was in the original version that's [1:36:04] letter I, the buffer strip shall be maintained as a naturally vegetated area with native and non-invasive vegetation where it is adjacent to water bodies, wetlands, or other areas with significant natural resource values unless an alternative treatment is approved by the planning board as part of site plan review. [1:36:26] And C is to remove the requirement for understory planting and preservation in all other cases. So the intent of this that the first intent is right the proposed under the changes here the is to increase [1:36:47] Right now the spacing [snorts] between trees that are required is 30 ft currently. The version that you had before the amendment is to increase [snorts] the tree sorry to have a site the space between trees at 15 ft. Originally 30 ft now this is changing it to 15 ft and my amendment is increasing that to 20 ft. [1:37:12] So this is tree spacing in the buffer yard out in front of buildings for new development or where the buffer yard is triggered by redevelopment and that again just speaks up this more is about developed properties for the most part where somebody's got their business there with a signage and a building and right now the requirement would be or the original requirement would be 30 ft and that reduces that to 20 ft. [1:37:42] So kind of to John's point earlier this is just a compromise on the spec with the ability for that property owner business owner to have better visibility of their building and their that what they're trying to attract whether it's a service business or a retail business, to [1:38:06] have more visibility across particularly like somebody driving down the road can see what they're selling and offering and or even an office building. so, that's one part of it is just compromising instead of going to 30 ft between the trees going to 20 ft between the trees. and then that statement that's to be restored [1:38:29] is combined with C and that that had been taken out and I'm proposing to put that back. that whole the buffer strip should be maintained. and that's in conjunction with removing the requirement of the understory planting and the preservation in all other cases. [1:38:50] So, the catch-all change with the buffer is keeping those restrictions wherever it's adjacent to water bodies, wetlands, natural resource because that requires a specific type of vegetation and the amount of it that's specifically beneficial to the wetlands. [1:39:10] the start part C is to remove that understory requirement, which is kind of the lower plantings under the trees, for other cases, so if it's not in the wetlands. And if that doesn't make any sense, we're going to refer to Autumn. [1:39:27] But do we Do we have a second? We need a second. [1:39:29] All right. All right. Further discussion? Done? [1:39:33] I'm going to support this one for the same reason, the Goldilocks rule. No. I do think that the conversation at the very end had I had more time to think about it, I might have supported that first amendment because I do think to Scott and Corey's point about affordability, like the more we do, the more strict we are, [1:39:53] the more expensive it's going to be and that's just going to be passed on to the end users ultimately and so again, this feels reasonable. it doesn't you know, going from 30 to 15 to bring it back to 20 still feels like it's it's a good approach. And so, for that reason, I'm going to support this amendment. [1:40:15] Thank you. Go on. [1:40:18] Sure. we did receive one email in opposition to this or with some suggestions. It was from the representative of the Downs. This appears to be some of very similar to some of the complaints or the concerns that the Downs brought. you know, I'm just going to say again that there was multiple times and I 'm honestly disappointed that counselors would vote and support a goal and then not kind of join the process, [1:40:45] follow along knowing it's something you have an interest in and then kind of coming at the final read to make changes to these chances to this. I There is substantial reason why this was in there. And so, like this last minute removal, I understand we want to find compromise. I'm not sure who we're compromising with right now, to be honest. [1:41:06] There's been I had no one's coming to me saying I can't run my business, I can't sell it. If there's someone complaining, like I have not heard from them. So, like while I appreciate the idea of compromise, it is frustrating that we voted on a goal, had staff spend some ample time. Staff, this is the professional recommendation. [1:41:27] There are reasons behind this and we're just kind of going, "Well, I don't like it." I am not a professional. I cannot support removal of language that was drafted by professionals who work in this field every day. They clearly have thought this very through and they feel that they can sit in their job and talk to a landowner and not feel like we're ruining their property. [1:41:49] I think that's the conversation we would have been having at the beginning of the goal session. so, you know, I just my biggest concern is these are very in-depth issues. This is the second read. This is the council goal. I will All I will say is that I hope that the next council with our goals that we are more involved and that we're not making changes like this at the end and that we bring along everyone that helped us up the process. [1:42:13] Thank you. Anyone else? [1:42:17] Did you do you [1:42:20] One sentence for you guys? [1:42:21] Mhm. [1:42:22] I just want I think you all mentioned it in the amendment before. This does not apply to single-family subdivision development. This is just commercial development. I think I just wanted to clear that up for affordable [1:42:35] the conversation. [1:42:36] But Autumn, just a quick follow-up question on that. Would a would say like a mid-rise or even garden style multi-family that would be classified as commercial? [1:42:45] Yes. That would fall under the site plan. I just wanted to be clear. [1:42:48] Yep. Thank you. [1:42:51] I One quick question on my part. so, housing development? [1:42:59] single-family subdivision, this would not apply. [1:43:03] It wouldn't apply? [1:43:03] Right. So, only you know, apartments like the Muzzy Road site or development on Route 1, Dunstan, that sort of thing would apply. [1:43:13] Thank you. [1:43:17] Yeah. John, you had something else? [1:43:18] Yeah, I know. I would just say, you know, [1:43:22] this is the way the process is supposed to work where if we didn't be open-minded at second reading to make changes, then what's the point of having the process that we have? And so, it's not to slight the process or the people that are involved in the process. It's what you've elected this body to do. [1:43:43] And the goal is still the goal. How we get there sometimes is different. how we how we try and finalize it can be different in different perspectives and I think that is what governance is. That is what democracy is. And so, I don't mind and I never have minded any counselor bringing any changes at second reading. [1:44:04] It's never a slight to the committees. It's never a slight to anybody. It really is about good democracy and good governance and we don't always get it right. We can sometimes get it wrong. In my opinion, this goal is achieved. Not achieving the goal would be doing nothing, which is also an option that you know, I'm assuming Scott, you're going to vote no on this all together. [1:44:24] and you know, that's that's that's not a bad thing that you do that either. I think that's okay. Your voice is important. And frankly, there might be more of us who like I personally feel like this is the right thing to do. It's a good thing to do. Is it a little bit of a government overreach? I'm I'm leaning that way, but it feels like the right thing to do. So, I'm going to support it overall. [1:44:45] but I just I hope when the new council sits that you guys are open, you listen to each other, you don't come with your decision already made. I was I was given credit earlier today for being somebody who changes their mind and I think that's okay. It's okay to change your mind. It's okay to take in new information, new perspectives, new ideas [1:45:05] and do it to the very end. And so, again, I just I just hope that that spirit continues. That spirit of collaboration, of listening, and being good neighbors. [1:45:18] Thanks, John. [1:45:21] Yeah, I support this as well and like John, I feel strongly that there's a reason why we have a first and second reading. There's a reason why that why this comes in front of the council in the first place and why we don't just have a rubber stamp that just accepts everything verbatim every time. I think it's healthy and appropriate for us to use our own critical thinking skills and have discussion and deliberation and sometimes we might change each other's minds. [1:45:49] Sometimes we won't. I still see this assuming the [clears throat] main motion does pass when we get to that vote eventually. I would still view this as a as a win that you, Karen, and everyone involved should be really proud of. and is wholly consistent with the spirit of that goal. [1:46:09] So, that's where I am on this. Any further discussion? Call the vote on the amendment. All in favor? [1:46:20] All opposed? Okay. 5 to 1. Thank you. And fourth amendment? [1:46:29] Fourth amendment [1:46:29] And then this time let's just read it and then we'll we'll get a second and then if you want to elaborate, we'll do it we'll we'll do it that way. [1:46:39] I motion move also to amend the main motion that amends to section 20 waivers and landscape screening standards to add the following: A, the planning board may waive or decrease required streetscape buffer yard up to 10 [1:46:56] He's done. As like a rookie. the planning board may waive or decrease the required streetscape state buffer yard up to 10 ft for new development in an urban setting or for redeveloped properties. This one I think is our process more so in that this suggestion came from the planning board review. [1:47:19] and so it gives the planning board as they're doing site plan [1:47:24] Oh, sorry. Sorry. Let's get a second and then you can elaborate. Sorry. We'll have this down by the end. [1:47:29] [laughter] [1:47:30] Yeah. Do we have a second? [1:47:31] Second. [1:47:31] Thank you. All right. [1:47:33] Sorry. [1:47:33] Thanks. so the idea this would be there's so many unique properties in town that may not the building may already be there, may not physically have room for these for all the restrictions and requirements of this. So it just gives the planning board the ability to adjust that for site conditions that are [1:47:53] you know, all over town all the differences all over town. [1:47:58] But thanks. [1:48:00] Any council discussion on this? [1:48:04] There's a second. Sorry. [1:48:05] Yeah, there was a second. Yeah, go ahead. [1:48:06] I just again, I want to dive into the discussion that was behind this was I did feel like generally with the residents and the folks that were involved in the conversation, it was we wanted to be a little more tight with our rules. We wanted to maybe make it stronger for people and say, "You know what? We're not going to We're not going to let them be able to kind of take that discretion, and we're going to say that Scarborough's hard when it comes to this stance." And so, I just [1:48:32] I appreciate the amendment. I think I just want to reiterate the concerns that were coming from the residents regarding sometimes the discretion that the planning board has. They As you know, they do need discretion, though. and so, I think that was where this had originally come from. [1:48:47] Thank you. Anyone else? [1:48:50] I'll call the vote on this amendment. All in favor? Opposed? That's about Oh, sorry. You were opposed? [1:48:58] I'm opposed. [1:48:59] Opposed. [1:48:59] Opposed. [1:49:01] So, 5-2. Thank you. [1:49:06] All right. we'll now return to the main motion as amended. [1:49:12] Any further discussion on the main motion? [1:49:16] John. [1:49:16] Well, again, I just think this is excellent that we are actually doing something to really address the feedback that we've gotten. Karen, to your point, 4 years is a long time, and your persistence is one of the things that I admire about you the about you the most. The fact that it's taken this long to get here is a little bit you know, again, part of the frustration sometimes of being in government. [1:49:39] It's slow, and it's usually by design so that the right conversations and engagement can happen. I think this overall is good for our community. I think it's good for the environment. I think it's good for the future of Scarborough as we think of LD 2173 and what that's going to do. Like, what I worry about is 20 years from now when a developer, you know, brings water over to the other side of 95, and all of a sudden [1:50:05] land that is not technically developable becomes more developable, what it's going to do to all the trees on that side of 95. And so, to me, this is very thoughtful in terms of long-range planning to put something like this into place to avoid a situation like that down the road. And so I just think this is good and I'm I'm happy to support it on my last meeting out. [1:50:28] Thanks, John. Anyone else? No, I 'm I'm happy with this as well. I know there may be mixed feelings about some of the some of the amendments and compromises, but I think it I think it would will be good for the town and I think it's an important message as well for about what our values are. [1:50:48] So I will call the vote on the main motion as amended. All in favor? Opposed? 6 to 1. Thank you. [1:50:59] Moving on to item number 12.3, order number 26-81, [1:51:05] second reading on the proposed changes to chapter 405, Town of Scarborough's zoning ordinance, section 6, definitions and add definitions pertaining to data centers. Back to Autumn. [1:51:17] Thank you. this is the second reading. This is in an attempt to address the data center issue. We do have an emergency moratorium that was put into place. and ultimately what we are recommending and what you all approved at first reading is that we would create a definition for data center and we would exclude that use specifically from high technology facility [1:51:41] and the research, development, and light industrial use. So this is effectively a ban on data centers at this moment in time. if there ever becomes a place that this might be an appropriate use, I think our sustainability committee would be interested in reviewing that, but at this time this is what we are recommending. [1:52:00] Thank you. now I'll offer the opportunity for public comment on this item if anyone would like to speak. [1:52:08] Thanks. [1:52:10] I think you know the ground rules. [1:52:14] I do. [1:52:15] Denise Hamilton, 2 Rod Road, and hopefully I can get through this without choking. Over the past five and a half months, I've spoken numerous times about data centers, and I don't believe there's much more I can add that hasn't already been said. I do want to acknowledge the considerable time and effort that has gone into this process [1:52:36] by the ordinance committee, sustainability committee, town council, town staff, and members of the public who have participated along the way. I fully support prohibiting data centers as defined as a primary use throughout Scarborough, regardless of their size. However, after reviewing the proposed definition again, I have two areas I'd like clarified before tonight's discussion and vote. [1:53:01] Based on some questions that have been asked by me, been asked of me by taxpayers. First, the definition excludes server rooms, telecommunication closets, computer equipment rooms, or similar accessory spaces that are incidental to a principal use. Does this exclusion [1:53:22] require that the server room or computer equipment room be located within the building housing the principal business, or could a company construct a separate building on its property to house computer services and related equipment for its own operations? An example would be a container-based building used to house servers for primary use, or the fact that these may use chillers, generators, etc. [1:53:50] would exclude them. Second, the definition re- references large-scale internal operations. How is large-scale determined? Is there an established threshold or criteria, or would that determination be left to administrative interpretation? My concern is ensuring that the accessory use exception [1:54:11] doesn't inadvertently create a loophole allowing what would otherwise be considered a data center simply because it's associated with another permitted use. After five and a half months of work, I believe it's important that we eliminate as much ambiguity as possible now rather than leave these questions open to interpretation or potentially face challenges down the road. [1:54:34] I appreciate everyone's efforts and hope the council will provide these clarifications before adopting the ordinance. Thank you. [1:54:42] Thank you. [1:54:47] Thank you so much. I'm Sophie Warren, state representative for part of my hometown here of Scarborough. I wanted to second everything that Denise Hamilton shared. I really am so grateful to her comments and her diligence throughout this process and to everyone that's been part of our planning processes and ordinance review processes throughout this as well as all of you. [1:55:09] I hope that we'll be able to get those questions answered because the intent behind this, of course, is to make sure that we're not skirting around what we're trying to do here with this ordinance change. And certainly, I think it's consistent with what our hopefully our next legislature will do to make rules of the road that are truly fair and appropriate. [1:55:29] And I think this is a very prudent course and a very measured response. And I hope that we'll have a strong hopefully bipartisan non-partisan support here tonight. I know that's what I've heard from those that I serve here in Scarborough that just across the board we want to make sure we're not creating any unintended consequences in a very sensitive resource here with our Scarborough Marsh lot of land or beautiful [1:55:54] natural spaces where a development like this is just not an appropriate use perhaps regardless of what the state does. But I hope that those questions from Denise will be answered. And otherwise, I hope that this will have your support. And you've been a real leader and have really done your due diligence throughout the process. So I'm I'm really grateful for that. And that's all for me. [1:56:15] Thank you. Anyone else with public comment on this? I see someone online. [1:56:24] Go ahead. [1:56:25] [clears throat] [1:56:27] Matthew Keith, eight Pleasant Ave here again. I won't go on and on about it cuz I've spoken up at the past readings on this as well. But just say that I strongly support this and I'm really grateful to the council for making sure to move this through with haste [1:56:47] so that we can get it done and move on and remove the moratorium. Just let it be known that Scarborough is not a place for these. Thank you. [1:56:58] Thank you. Anyone else on this? All right, seeing no more. We have a motion. [1:57:06] So moved. [1:57:06] Second. [1:57:08] Council discussion? [1:57:11] Anything to add on this, John? [1:57:12] I'm just interested if Autumn can respond to some of the questions that we heard. [1:57:19] Sure. One of the questions was about could the does the would the exclusion allow the server rooms to be in a separate building? And typically what you would find like the town, we have a server room that's upstairs, but Maine Health actually has a separate small building on their campus that is their server room. [1:57:39] So it would be that would fall under the accessory space. So that would this definition would allow that to happen. The great thing about the way our ordinances and rules are written is that any new use that we would see and we have a process in place for changes of use and reviews for these things would have to go through [1:58:01] minimal is processed through the planning and codes and the public safety fire department office and the majority any new use with a new building has to go through the planning board. So there could be further scrutiny, you know, if there's a fine line in that use. But I feel confident in this definition. This is what GPCOG put out in their proposal. [1:58:22] I feel good about the exclusions. I think I we're set up for success. [1:58:30] Thanks. Yeah. [1:58:31] Did you have a follow-up? [1:58:32] Well, no. Just thank you for the clarity because I think that's that's important to be responsive to the questions we got. no, I think this is great. I'm glad we're doing this. I think it's the right thing to do. we need to allow for more state and federal regulation of this industry, I think, before we allow for it. [1:58:52] technology's changing so quickly. Who knows in the next 5 years it might be much more environmentally friendly. Hopefully, it will have to be in order to continue to do what's happening with AI. And so again, I think this is really important to do in Scarborough given our location and where we are near the marsh. but also [1:59:13] originally coming from northern Virginia, like I hear so many people in Loudoun County who are very upset about what's been happening in northern Virginia as a result of data centers there. And I would hate to see something like that happen in Scarborough even though we don't have a lot of places where they could technically go. I just I think it at this point it's just [1:59:36] in our best interest as a community to ban them for now and revisit it down the road if it ever makes sense. [1:59:44] Michelle? [1:59:44] Exactly. [1:59:45] I agree with everything John said. And a question I have for Autumn that Denise triggered is the situation in Eastport right now where they're trying to get permission to build a data center underwater. Would this the way we've worded this, does that include that? [2:00:06] Because that it's sort of a whole different animal. [2:00:09] It's still a data center, I think. [2:00:10] Right. Yes. [2:00:11] Okay. [2:00:12] At this point, we are not allowing data center uses in any form. [2:00:19] So, it wouldn't be a loophole. [2:00:20] No. [2:00:21] Okay. Perfect. [2:00:25] Thanks. Good [2:00:25] question. Anyone else? Blair? [2:00:29] Yeah, I think this is a great example of how we tackled this very quickly and thoughtfully by having a moratorium to start giving staff time to develop a enforceable moratorium. And so I definitely support it, but I really like the process that we used to do this and the speed with which we got it done. [2:00:51] Thank you. [2:00:53] Yeah, I agree with that. I think this was an example of us being I think as nimble as we could be, as nimble but also thorough as possible. drawing on our staff capacity and some outside expertise through GPCOG and others. and this really has been one of those, you know, rare issues where it's been you know, pretty much unanimity. [2:01:17] I spent time at the polls yesterday and multiple people asked me about it. and it really sort of cuts across and transcends party lines in my experience. And as has been discussed, there are a lot of a lot of reasons why I think this makes sense for Scarborough right now. Any further comment? [2:01:38] All in favor? [2:01:40] That's unanimous. Thanks. [2:01:47] All right. Moving on to 12.4, order number 26-85. [2:01:54] Second reading to establish a new ordinance titled municipal policies regarding federal immigration enforcement. we did have We did have first reading on this item at our previous meeting, well, a couple of meetings ago we had a public hearing about it as well. again, just to quickly recap, the intent here is to align [2:02:19] our police department's align our local law enforcement policy with existing Scarborough police standard operating procedures as well as state law and to further you know, remove any ambiguity around non-law enforcement municipal staff as it relates to potential cooperation [2:02:40] with ICE. So with that, I will open it up for any public comment on this item. Just ask that you direct your comments to the chair. Please state your name and address and keep your comments to 3 minutes or less if you'd like to speak. Thank you. [2:03:05] Hi, I'm Jennifer Jordberg. I am from Scarborough. I'll let Sophie go after me because that means I can just be short and sweet cuz I know she'll cover everything. But I'm a member of the community coalition to remove ICE. lots of us are here tonight as you can see. And we do support this ordinance and I think it's a really great first step. [2:03:30] I'm not really sure of the procedure procedures, protocol and such. But I anticipate that down the road we might have to either ask you to add on to this or to look at things differently. I guess this is where I'm coming from. tonight we heard from a woman by the name of Nancy. [2:03:51] I just met her tonight. I don't know her specifically, but she told us of situations where it appears the Scarborough Police Department is if not assisting ICE, certainly working with them in some way and then pulling her over for the same thing that they seem to ignore [2:04:12] in ICE vehicles. I guess to me that sounds like assisting ICE. So I know tonight we're here to talk about municipal employees. but I wonder if we can't enforce this through LD 1971 when the police officers are not supposed to be using their time assisting ICE in any way. [2:04:33] I don't know how we're going to enforce this ordinance, and I'm not saying therefore let's not pass it. I'm saying I think everyone will need to really look at that because it is an ordinance that will need to be enforced. And also, I think we'll have to be careful to ensure any complaint process either by fellow municipal employees or member of the public that suspects someone might be assisting ICE [2:04:59] that the complaint process is accessible, transparent, that we all would know how to register said complaint, if you will. as we all know, ICE is the weapon- weaponization of what really is a pseudo law enforcement agent agency. [2:05:21] And you know, their cruelty in acting outside of our constitutional norms seem to be their point. So, it's going to be important for all of us to really know Let's pass the ordinance, but ensure it can be enforced. Ensure that I Now I know where you know, we might have to come back here and ask someone at the Scarborough Police Department whether or not they're helping ICE, and then ensure our own other municipal employees don't have the opportunity to do that. [2:05:51] and if so, are disciplined for that reason. And also, to ensure that if we as the public have to issue a complaint against anyone, we know how to do it, and it's relatively easy. Thank you. [2:06:07] Thank you. [2:06:12] Thank you so much. I'm Sophie Warren, state representative for part of my hometown here in Scarborough. Thank you so much to Jennifer for really laying out and speaking on behalf. I know so many folks that are here and folks that couldn't be here about where we stand as a community and that we're going to do everything that we can do to keep members of our community safe regardless of their legal status. [2:06:33] I think one piece that Jennifer was touching on that may be a point of conversation but I think may be a little bit about the kinks that are worked out since the law at the state level has gone into effect and maybe more work that needs to happen at the state level around the level of discretion that local officials can have in enforcing certain laws that we have we have on the books but definitely what was shared at the beginning of this council meeting was very concerning [2:07:04] and raises important questions. I think this step is important to take at this time regardless of how we go from here in that enforcement mechanism. My chief concern again speaking to what Jennifer shared was around the use of interpreters and that may be a piece where understanding [2:07:28] when we're talking about federal immigration enforcement, are we talking about officers in different capacities and are we talking about federal officials that have one type of hat on as they maybe they work with federal immigration enforcement but are we ensuring that their translation services are not being used by our local law enforcement. [2:07:49] I think that's really important. I've talked with various members of our community who have experienced criminal actions but are not comfortable coming to the police our local police regardless of the laws that have recently changed and that is inherent concern with those that are not documented [2:08:10] or maybe are in a place of transition or in a precarious place because there are folks that have been doing everything right that still get caught up and still in some cases are deported. So making sure that everyone feels comfortable with our local law enforcement is one of the things we're trying to do here and any type of facilitation we have with our local municipal staff including that translation services I think is an important inquiry point but this ordinance as it's written is a really important first step [2:08:40] and I know there's other conversations, there's more work to be done, but this and I hope a strong vote in support with things ironed out that will send a really strong message. And then we go from there into making sure as we put it into effect that we're getting all the details right. And also that speaks to work that we need to do at the state level and conversations that are happening from changes that have been made including with that LD 1971 as Jennifer so aptly brought up. [2:09:09] But thank you all so much for this conversation, the work you've done, and I hope to see a strong supportive vote as this great first step. Thank you. [2:09:18] Thank you. [2:09:25] Hi, my name is Mary Daley and I live on [street] here in Scarborough. I'm going to attempt to read a transcript between a caller down at the from the facility to a counselor down here. I wasn't here when this I wasn't there when it happened. I regularly work with the folks down there now, but I wasn't in attendance when this phone call took place. [2:09:47] so the caller says, "Hello. I'm trying to reach someone that is on the city council for Scarborough in the zone that ICE facility is in." The council they and who they spoke to was Mr. Doughty. May I just say Scott instead of your [2:10:07] What's up? [2:10:09] In the transcript that they're referring to you as Scott, would that be fine? [2:10:13] You can just you can just direct your comments to the chair. [2:10:16] Okay, so the I'll just say the counselor responds to that. Let's see. Okay, then the individual who called was trying to reach somebody who was in the zone that the fight ICE facility is in. And the council that responded said, "I don't know whose zone that would be, [2:10:39] but I'm on the council." The caller said, "I just wanted to let you be aware that there's escalation at the facility. And there are there are individuals with guns there today. The counselor. I would reach out to the local PD. Do you think that any of the ICE agents are in danger? [2:10:59] The caller. No, I do not. I have reached out to the local PD before. And they take it with a grain of salt. The counselor. I mean they do [clears throat] have the right to bear arms. The guy in Minneapolis had a gun though and they took it from him and they still shot him. I hope that nobody gets hurt. The caller. [2:11:20] Is someone available from the counselor council to come see it? The counselor. You would have to reach out to local PD. Caller. What if there's an escalation today? Counselor. ICE agents are plenty prepared to handle any situation that arises at the facility. [2:11:40] Counselor. Gotcha. Absolutely. Conversation ended. That has left all of us who are opposed to the tyranny and the criminal activity of ICE afraid that nobody has our back. 99% of us are not armed. One individual is and is legally allowed to do so. [2:12:03] And that individual is armed but our protection. Because we have been threatened. We've all been threatened by ICE. [2:12:13] I no longer feel safe. I no longer feel safe in my own community and I've lived here for 30 years. I'm actually very disappointed reading this and knowing that 's how that went. I really kind of would like just a little more clarity of the conversation and what was meant by ICE agents are plenty prepared to handle the situation down there. [2:12:36] Sounds like a threat to me and it sounded like a threat to everybody there. [2:12:39] Thank you. Your time is up, [2:12:41] ma'am. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for letting me speak. [2:12:44] Thank you. [2:12:56] I'm Christopher Smith. I live in Scarborough. I want to thank the members of the council for this ordinance. It takes more integrity and courage to stand up to this particular federal administration, especially when a lawless and out of control branch is operating in one's own town. And its members have been told [2:13:17] incorrectly, but many times, that they are completely they have complete immunity. And they were told that by a pretty high-ranking member of the federal government. It's not true, but they believe that. But this ordinance is coming at a critical time. [2:13:37] It's so different than it would have been last night or night before last, it seems to me. Given the results of yesterday's election, there are a couple of ways things could play out, I think. It's possible that the federal administration will take the hint and decide to slow their activities down and just let it all go. [2:14:01] I don't think that's going to happen. The other possibility, I think it's more likely, they will decide to put the throttle right to the firewall and arrest and detain and deport as many people as they possibly can in the time they have left. Sowing fear and insecurity as widely as they can, including to us. [2:14:24] So, I'm afraid this ordinance is great. Thank you for doing it. I hope you pass it. But, I think it's going to get stress test tested pretty hard fairly soon. I was really upset by what I heard tonight, cuz I have been down there, but I haven't been down there recently, and I haven't seen things like the interactions I'm hearing about. I think they're getting farther out of control. [2:14:46] So, thank you for what you've done. [2:14:49] Thank you. [2:14:53] Anyone else in the room to comment on this? [2:14:59] We have someone online? Thanks. [2:15:03] Matthew Key from Scarborough here again. Just wanting to speak in support of this and like some speakers earlier have pointed out, I think it's increasingly becoming aware that there are more things we can do at the town level around [2:15:24] exactly [2:15:27] what is happening to protesters, what is happening to our immigrant population and the how the police are being involved, how response from counselors is being involved, like how we are going to show up as a town for these things and how we make sure that we can enforce that. [2:15:47] And this is a big step in the right direction and I applaud you all for pushing this forward. And I think my ask would be that we continue to ask what more we can do because I know there's limited power we have at the town level to remove the facility, but I do think as we dig into this more, it becomes more and more clear how much more we can do [2:16:09] at the local level because it is a facet of our community. And so what can we do to help mitigate the negative impact on our [2:16:21] our citizens in Scarborough and those who are [2:16:27] brought to the facility. Yeah, so thank you so much for considering this. I hope you pass it and to you and the incoming counselors next week, I ask you to continue to make this a priority in your agenda. Thank you so much. [2:16:44] Thank you. Anyone else for public comment on this? Right? you. As always, I your understanding of sort of our protocols on public comment. I know it can sometimes be a little frustrating or confusing, but we have them for a reason and we do appreciate hearing all the comments. [2:17:05] do we have a motion? [2:17:07] So moved. [2:17:07] Second. [2:17:08] All right. Council discussion and I do want to caution I want to try to try to focus on the item that's in front of us for second reading with this ordinance and try not to get too much into litigating details of some of the things that have been brought up. We certainly have some discussion on that, but I think we just need to be mindful of kind of staying on track and with the understanding that there can certainly be further discussion [2:17:35] going forward to make sure that people get the answers that they want. John? [2:17:41] Yeah. You know, I'm I'm very happy with this council and how swiftly we acted on this. I also do want to recognize Scott because I felt like it was his statement at a meeting that really led to us collectively to do something and so Scott, thank you for being the first one to say we got to do something. [2:18:02] What's happening is not right. And so I really just appreciate you and you having the courage to say that I think made all of us kind of then react appropriately. you know, again, like we were talking about with trees and I know this is not trees and I'm not trying to equate them because they're not exactly the same, but policy making is messy. we heard representative [2:18:24] Warren, I want to call her Senator Warren, Senator Elect Warren, you know, also say how you know, the state did some stuff and they have some loopholes that they need to close and so I highly encourage the council to continue to partner with our state reps to make sure we get it right. you know, it is hard when state law comes down to say we must restrict [2:18:49] and doesn't really give any other guidance to communities for how they're supposed to do that. what resources do they get to put things in place. but it is true what I think some of the community members said that you know, there are people there watching, which means there's going to be incidents. There needs to be ways to bring those forward to the town so that the town is aware. [2:19:11] I don't know in the ordinance if it talks specifically where to do that or if there's a policy that the police department created based on the law how they were going to comply with the law, but maybe that's something that needs to be looked into. That's why I'm looking at Liam. [2:19:27] Yeah, I'll just offer that. you know, the police department has had a long-stand well, a fairly long-standing SOG speaking to this issue. Obviously, with the passage of LD 1971, now it's a state law that sort of put some guardrails and restrictions on law enforcement's court collaboration, coordination with immigration enforcement. [2:19:48] So, I think if there's a concern with a violation of not only an SOG or SOP, but also now a state statute, there's a complaint process that can be followed whether it's going through the department complaint process or going to the AG's office if a civilian or resident thinks that they have been in violation of that. just quick background on the ordinance before you. [2:20:11] The spirit and intention behind this is to extend those same sort of guidelines and limitations and restrictions through 1971 to the balance of our municipal staff. So, it's it's really the spirit of it is to provide those same expectations for all the whole municipal workforce, not just law enforcement. [2:20:29] So, for a citizen though who observes something that they think is worthy of a complaint, is there course of action to report it to the AG's office? Is that for at least as it relates to LD 1971 for police, but if there were town staff observation, [2:20:47] So, the town manager has a role in this. I would encourage any resident again who has a concern. Obviously, the concern brought forward this evening was really a law enforcement employee who'd be subject to the state statute and I think it's a civilian employee then there's a protocol to inform the town manager of an ordinance violation [2:21:08] the way any resident could for any other policy violation or ordinance violation. [2:21:12] Okay. So that's I just wanted to make sure there was clarity on the process that people have. but again I do support this. I'm proud of that we acted swiftly. I agree that there's still work to do. I'm very optimistic with what just happened at the congressional level that hopefully there can be more conversations with our congressional delegation on what to do. [2:21:36] I know we reached out originally with a proclamation and unfortunately because of the election season and timing I think that kind of muted our voice but with things that have changed my hope is that the next council will continue to use that voice to advocate for the change that I think we ultimately want which is what at least what I want is for that facility to leave Scarborough and then have no facility like that in the state of Maine. [2:22:01] And so that is out of our this body's purview in terms of direct impact to that but I do think with the voices that we have and I see some head nodding in the back with a very loud voice that I know will be sitting up here on this topic. that you use that loud voice to continue to advocate for the right things to happen. [2:22:23] So thank you to the council. Thank you to the public for bringing this conversation forward. Public safety is paramount. We want to make sure all of our neighbors regardless of where they come from feel safe and are willing to you know live here comfortably calmly and without concern for harm and so I'm I'm really happy that we're putting this forward. [2:22:48] Thanks John. Anyone else? Scott? [2:22:52] Yeah, it was so I should elaborate on this that somebody spoke to. It was a bizarre phone call that I received and I was like stumped for a minute, but they said that there's there's a protestor down there that has a gun. I says, "Well, you need to call Scarborough PD." They says, "Well, you're a counselor, can't you come down just now?" I says, "No, I can't come down and do anything. [2:23:15] I ain't coming down there. if but I said is this person cuz they made it sound like they weren't a protestor. They were somebody worried about the protestors. This person that I was speaking to, whoever it was. Obviously, this is a bait thing to try and get me to say something, but and they said I said [2:23:36] are they brandishing the weapon or threatening with it?" They said, "No, they just have it." I says, "Oh, well, I says they have the right to bear arms. They can a protestor can have a gun if they want to." And I says, "Oh, okay. All right. Thank you." And I was like, "Okay." And that was the end of the conversation, but you know, to say that I was [2:23:59] I did say she did state cuz she had it verbatim pretty much, but she left out those things. They did say that I said are the ICE agents at risk because they said that the protestor had a gun and maybe they were going to and then and I says, "Are they at risk?" He says, "Well, I don't know." I says, "Well, I says I think they're well armed. [2:24:25] I think they can probably take care of themselves, but you still should call Scarborough PD if somebody's down there with a you know, and they're brandishing a weapon, but if they're not, then it's really not an issue." But anyway, that's just to clarify that cuz I that's that caught me off guard. and to that I've I've been [2:24:48] supportive of them completely. And when I drive down through there once in a while they go to public parks or whatever and they 're parked there all the time. And good for them. They're protesting and that's what it's about. You just sit there and they're out front here. Good. They're they're making a statement. You know, calmly and quietly and lawfully. [2:25:10] and I've been supportive of that and I think that's a good thing. That's that's how it should be. but with this tonight and because of that and I felt as though I was almost being baited into saying something but it didn't work. [2:25:30] And so I think tonight I'm going to vote against this cuz that's how it works. If you try and play dirty it doesn't work for you. So, [clears throat] I was going to be for this. I was in complete support of it until a few minutes ago. And maybe they did this to me because I'm a Republican [2:25:50] and I feel like I'm on the show The View and I'm the token Republican. [2:25:55] [laughter] [2:25:56] But you know I have my views and I have my political views and I have the right to them. And so I'm going to exercise them right now. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? John? [2:26:15] Yeah. Scott, I would I would just ask that you reconsider that only because I do think you genuinely support this and while I 'm not happy either about debating or the perceived debating I would hope that you support this purely because you think it's the right thing to do, which I again, you were the one that kind of said we need to do something and this is what we've done. [2:26:41] So in the spirit of like who you are as a person, which I think is genuinely a very good person with a big heart, I hope you will let what happened happen and go with your heart on this one like you do for a lot of things. [2:26:57] Thank you. Anyone else? [2:27:02] yeah, I 'm I'm proud that we're we're at this point and and that we've been able to take at least an incremental step and as was suggested there may be things that we need to [2:27:18] to explore beyond this and there may be tweaks. there may be some implementation issues to work through. I think we need to make sure that there's good public visibility around who to go to with a complaint or a question or concern. and there are going to be situations that are that you know, that are sort of gray areas and aren't aren't necessarily cut and dry. [2:27:43] you know, when someone gets a call out of the blue that there's someone that there might be a situation that needs to be de-escalated. there're going to be some judgment calls around how to respond to that and I think my sense anyway is that our that our police [2:28:04] generally want to respond when they hear that someone is in need. and so we just need to make sure that there are I think this is going to be an ongoing process and hopefully continued open line of communication with our public safety leadership around protocols and how they're handling some of those some of those gray area type issues. [2:28:26] and that everyone understands kind of where the line is and I think there could be some tricky situations where there's an impulse to respond and sort of where does where do you where does that where does that end and where does quote and quote cooperation begin. So, [2:28:47] I appreciate the discussion and did you want to add something, Don? [2:28:50] Yeah, just I like to underscore that point. I think some of what you heard from the podium, you know, respect irrespective of this ordinance or the state law, if there are calls for service, our officers are going to respond. In fact, they have to this location, at the request of folks at the ICE facility and at the request of protesters. [2:29:14] So, I just want to be very clear that 's that's their duty. They will respond. And I have the utmost trust in the training and education and disposition of our officers to make the judgment call, to use the discretion given the circumstances they find when they arrive. That does not, in my mind, constitute cooperation with ICE or anyone. [2:29:34] It's responding. It's doing their jobs. this is going to be tricky to navigate. but rest assured, we will respond when requested. [2:29:44] Thanks, Tom. Any further discussion? With that, I will call the vote. All in favor? Opposed? That passes 6 to 1. Thank you. And just to be clear, that is the final vote on this ordinance. Doesn't mean that it there can't be modifications going forward, but that is the final vote on that item. [2:30:06] Moving on. [2:30:08] Yes. [2:30:10] Just for the record, no applause. Thank you. [2:30:13] [laughter] [2:30:14] Should have said that earlier. [2:30:16] Thank you for coming. [2:30:16] Yeah. Thank you. Item number 12.5, this should be a quick one. Order number item 12.5 order number 26-90, second reading on the request to repeal the 180-day temporary moratorium entitled Town of Scarborough ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on data centers that was approved by the town council on June 3rd, 2026. [2:30:41] So, this is this is a housekeeping item at this point since we did approve the effective ban on data centers couple agenda items ago, so this makes this moot. [2:30:55] Do we have a motion? [2:30:57] So moved. [2:30:57] Second. [2:30:58] Any discussion? All in favor. That's unanimous. Thank you. [2:31:04] Moving on. [2:31:04] All right. [2:31:06] Break. [2:31:09] All right, I'm going to call a very brief break just to sort of let the room turn over a little bit if folks are heading out. And then we'll get back to it in about 3 minutes and get through the home stretch. Thank you. [2:35:17] Mhm. [2:37:20] Hey. [2:38:50] Welcome back. moving on to new business, item number 13.1, order number 26-96. [2:38:57] First reading and schedule of public hearing and second reading on the proposed amendments to chapter 311, schedule of fees to add applicable tree preservation in lieu of fees. Act on. [2:39:14] Thank you again. This is the item that would add the fees that were alluded to in the earlier item. So, as presented and recommended, we have two set of fees, one for significant and one for the heritage tree. And the significant tree would be $5,000 fee in lieu, and then the heritage tree would be the $25,000. [2:39:35] little bit about the rationale behind the amounts. so, we currently assess when someone has a tree that they're required to give us a performance guarantee on, we put that amount at $1,000. And so, the mitigation for your significant tree is two and a half trees, so that would give you $2,500. [2:39:56] Anytime you provide an opportunity for a fee in lieu, we typically want the fee in lieu to be, for lack of a better word, a bit more painful than actually doing the required change. So, it's proposed to be doubled. The heritage tree, that would require five trees, so that'd be $5,000. Using that same logic, you could put the heritage tree mitigation at $10,000, [2:40:21] but through the discussions, it really needed to be much more painful, I think, because the heritage trees are those really large 60-in diameter. So, that needed to be something that you really needed to design your site around. So, happy to answer any questions. [2:40:36] Thank you. do we have any public comment on this item? Seeing none, do we have a motion? [2:40:41] I move. [2:40:42] Second. [2:40:44] Council discussion? Larry? [2:40:47] I just want to point out this is a good example where I was originally concerned with the impact of these fees as well, but from the early amendments, I think we're giving the property owners some leeway and some flexibility on how they deal with these problems. And therefore, I have no objection to these fees any longer because I think we're giving them opportunities and avenues to solve and site their buildings where they need to. [2:41:14] So, I agree that there should be a disincentive to take the trees down if they don't have to. Thanks. Anyone else? [2:41:26] yeah, I'm I feel the same way I and I appreciate the rationale behind having them be sort of meaningful amounts and so it's not just a you know, not just an easy sort of pay your way out that it you know, forces a sort of a thoughtful approach there. So. [2:41:45] There's no further comment. I will call the vote. All in favor? Opposed? 6 to 1. It passes. Thank you. Item number 13.2 [2:41:58] Order number 26-97 first reading and schedule of public hearing and second reading to authorize the town manager to sign any related paperwork to transfer the following town owned properties to the Scarborough Land Trust. 37 Woodspell Road, map U48 lot 24A 47 Elmwood Avenue, map R57 [2:42:21] lot 1B 0 Hampton Circle, map U14 lot 8 11 Ronda Drive, map U16 lot 30 12 Ronda Drive, map U16 lot 28 13 Ronda Drive, map U16 lot 29 0 Broadturn Road, map R9 [2:42:43] lot 4 0 Fingler Road, map R9 map 6B and Carpenter Court map R47 lot 5A. [2:42:56] Yes, I'll provide a couple of words of introduction. Yes, just about a year ago, just over a year ago, Scarborough Land Trust made this request for the properties you mentioned and one more and in fact if you'll indulge me for a moment, I will speak to the next matter as well because it's really in keeping with the same matter. [2:43:18] these are properties that had been identified through one means or another through the Land Trust. Most of them have theirs contiguous and existing ownership by the land trust for these properties and there are other motivating factors perhaps that have caused them to express interest. The town does have a real estate disposition policy [2:43:41] which I followed in large part. I've kind of done things in a bit reverse order. Among other things that policy requires me to these matters to be referred to the parks and conservation land board for their review and recommendation. But it also requires me to solicit input from various town staff and other town committees. The intent of which obviously is to make sure that there's full awareness and full a full appreciation for current and future municipal uses before any [2:44:11] property sold. Beyond that it also contemplates a more conventional kind of private sale through a competitive open process. This is a bit different just given how and from whom it comes. So I did solicit input essentially from the groups that I was required to seek input from. I didn't receive any meaningful substantive input. The matter was subsequently referred to the parks and conservation land board who [2:44:35] and I'll let the chairperson speak to their process but I was involved in that. It was very thorough. They reviewed each parcel and actually subjected it to their evaluation process. So perhaps it's appropriate to allow them to expand on that process. [2:44:52] Good evening Steve Zemansky chair of the parks and conservation land board. The board met on September 24th to evaluate the conservation [clears throat] value of the 10 parcels that we just identified that were requested to be transferred to the Scarborough Land Trust. This includes two conservation easements and eight ownership transfers. [2:45:16] Following site visits and our typical evaluation process the board determined all 10 parcels contain significant conservation value and voted unanimously in favor of transferring them to SLT. Doing so would preserve these lands in perpetuity and would enable the land trust to invest the time and an expense required to actively manage these properties to maximize their human and wildlife sustaining attributes. [2:45:44] And on and on in appropriate parcels to provide public access for passive recreation. Your packets have all the details as the town manager stated that we did an evaluation on those. given it's late, I won't go into all the detail, but in summary, I would say that all the parcels we recommend that we transfer all the parcels [2:46:08] so that the land trust can permanently preserve these lands to improve drinking river and ocean quality water quality, to provide habitat for many animals and species, and provide expanded access for passive recreation. For these reasons, the Parks and Conservation Land Board recommends the council approve the transfer of lands these lands as stipulated to the Scarborough Land Trust. [2:46:33] And I'll stay here if we have any questions. [2:46:37] Yeah, I just want to tag on one of the properties they requested that was evaluated and recommended by Parks and Recreation Land Board I have pulled out and is subject of a separate item your next item on your agenda. And that was done specifically because the Housing Alliance really on the eve of the Parks and Recreation Conservation Land Board as it turned out was prepared to make a recommendation [2:47:02] expressed interest in evaluating whether housing could be would be suitable and appropriate on one of the parcels. And this is the so-called Tibbetts Road parcel. Incidentally, that is the one parcel of the requested parcels that has in my view any development potentials given its size and its attributes. all other properties because of their size and attributes and location [2:47:26] really don't have any develop potential whatsoever for Dennis William or otherwise. So, I want to make sure you didn't have to complicate this by pulling that. I pulled that for you and we'll have a discussion around that on your next agenda item. [2:47:44] Thank you. Thank you. [2:47:47] we have any public comment on this item? [2:48:02] Andrew Mackie, I'm the executive director of the Scarborough Land Trust. Our office is there at 25 Plaza Drive, Scarborough. I just want to clarify, two of the parcels we're requesting to put a conservation easement on. That is not transfer of ownership. The town would still retain ownership of that. we would hold the conservation easement. [2:48:24] all the other parcels, are adjacent to existing properties that we have. and so that's, kind of our process of why we request the transfer, so that, those conserved properties can be larger and managed, [2:48:45] all as one, where we, work on things like making sure that the boundaries are posted, that, any public access is maintained and kept up in good working order, that we control invasive plants, and that we manage, for wildlife. [2:49:07] And all this falls under a comprehensive management plan that is done for each preserve or series of properties if they're connected. the conservation easement is a little [clears throat] different. We already have a conservation easement on a piece of town property, [2:49:27] and we're asking there's the town property is actually, bigger, both on both sides of the piece that has a conservation easement on it. And we so we're just asking to expand that protection to that entire town parcel. That was all open space land through the planning board process. [2:49:51] and I just wanted to clarify that. [2:49:55] Thank you. Any other public comment? Seeing none, do we have a motion? [2:50:01] So moved. [2:50:02] Second. [2:50:03] Council discussion? Questions? [2:50:05] Yeah. John? it is Do these count towards our 30 by 30 or they already counted in our 30 by 30? [2:50:12] I believe they're already counted at this point. [2:50:15] Can't double count. [2:50:18] Yeah. okay, that's good. I mean this all this all makes sense. I mean I think it you know to put to transition it over where it makes sense and to expand the conservation easements makes sense. So I'm excited about the Elmwood and the Woodsbell one cuz that's in my neighborhood. And so does that mean that the land trust will start taking ownership of maintaining [2:50:43] them if this passes or like what is like the trails and stuff that are there? [2:50:48] again, this is conservation easement. it would be subject to what's allowed in the conservation easement. I don't recall specifically those properties. I think there may be some existing trails on some of them. what their long-term plan for stewardship and access I can't speak to. [2:51:05] Okay. [2:51:08] I support this. [2:51:09] Great. [2:51:10] Thanks. You good? [2:51:12] Yeah. [2:51:13] Anyone else? Karen? [2:51:14] I just want to thank the Parks and Conservation Land Board cuz they spent a lot of time and effort. They did a little tour. They went around town and they really took the time to look at all these properties. And so now I appreciate them doing this and giving the feedback. And I appreciate the Scarborough Land Trust who continues to be our partner cuz you know even this even though this is in conservation, what they're doing is they're expanding these lands that our residents have access to cuz you know we're not using them. [2:51:38] They're not going to be usable and so they've actively come to us and said here's some land that you aren't using that we feel like we could make available and help conserve. So that's great. Thanks. [2:51:48] Thanks. Anyone else? [2:51:51] I just have a question. do we mark these like you know, are there maps on them? I'm thinking of different you know, properties that we own or you know, is there anything there that or is it just open space and open land and it's contiguous so there really isn't a [2:52:08] In most cases the town makes little or no effort to manage them including identification and I think that's one of the great benefits of this is that they bring a professional stewardship component and will actually you know, deal with invasive species and ideally gain public access when it's appropriate. [2:52:29] Thanks. [2:52:31] Yeah, I also appreciate the work of the PCLB and Scarborough Land Trust on this and I know I mean this is true of all these but I know that a lot of work went into this and it this has been eyed for quite some time and glad that we're able to bring this forward. So if there's no further comment, I'll call the vote on this. All in favor? [2:52:53] That's unanimous. Thank you. Tom already spoke to this a little bit but I'm number 13.3 order number 26-98. [2:53:04] It's first reading and schedule a public hearing and second reading to authorize the town manager to sign any related paperwork to transfer the following town owned property to the Scarborough Land Trust. To transfer ownership of the following town Okay, a little bit of redundancy there. Broadturn Road Tibbetts Farm Road Broadturn Road Tibbetts Farm map R6 lot one. [2:53:28] Yeah, just to expand the motion just read Mr. Chair was is as you'll know posture in the affirmative so it is positioned in consistent with the Parks and Recreation Land Boards' recommendation, you can certainly consider that in light of the the Housing Alliance expressing interest in spending some time with to do proper due diligence and understand whether housing could be supported on a portion. [2:53:54] And just be clear, this is about a 60-acre parcel, 70-acre, excuse me. you know, the discussion at least initially at the Housing Alliance was for a very small portion, 5 acres or something like that. so, just to disavow any concern that we're looking at a huge subdivision, that was not the initial discussion anyhow. [2:54:14] so, really in view of the fact that you've got a a committee whose responsibility is to consider housing and has expressed interest in knowing more and finding out more, I was kind of left with how do we deal with these somewhat conflicting requests? You know, one option would be to physically or not physically, but to carve off a portion of the property that they could look at and conserve the rest in immediately. [2:54:44] Another option, and I've prepared a motion, would be to table this for a period of time to allow that evaluation to happen and recommendations to come after due diligence. I prepared it to allow for 6 months. Frankly, with the holidays and needing to engage professionals and to do it correctly, I think you probably need that much time. [2:55:04] so, that's an option that you can consider. [2:55:09] All right. Thank you. Any public comment on this? [2:55:17] [clears throat] [2:55:18] Chrissy Maurer. Chrissy Maurer, 20 Meeting House Road. I'm on the Conservation Commission. I just wanted to express support for the you know, motion to transfer this property now rather than to delay it and give it 6 months. of reasons. [2:55:39] first, I think that there's is sort of an and this might be more optics than fact, but this is a former sludge site, and to place housing on it brings concerns regarding environmental justice. there's no city water, there's no sewer, it would require well water. So, you're going to have to and even if it does say you find there's no PFAS, and it's going to still require, you know, expensive filtration systems and water systems to develop this site. [2:56:09] and even if it's not optics, there might be actual you're going to require study actual potential exposure to things like PFAS. The second is location. I think the pro- This is property is a prime property for conservation. if you look at the open space plan, it's right near the Nonesuch River, and that is and is contiguous and close to other already conserved lands. [2:56:33] So, this you know, transferring it now means that you're going to have a much larger contiguous piece under conservation. it's going to you know, sort of be coherent with the open space plan, which is you want to preserve all those corridors around rivers, and that's where you want to build that connectivity throughout Scarborough. [2:56:55] and it's not connected to any desirable services. I mean, even if you were just to hive off 5 acres, this is at the end of a very long road, not near any public transport, not near any services. so, does it make sense to just invest money, our you know, our taxpayer money to study this thing when it just on the face of it is not really a terribly desirable site for affordable housing. [2:57:22] and then finally, cost. I understand that this site has to be developed in individual housing units, so this is not an opportunity for higher densities and lower cost per unit. So, that, you know, sort of is another issue to think about. I said it will require, you know, it well water, and well water on a former sludge site means expensive filtration and testing. [2:57:47] do we want to invest money to see if this is really where we want to build that, you know, have to invest those kinds of monies in that infrastructure. and then so just, you know, is it worth, you know, spending 6 months doing due diligence and money on what I think on the face of it you can already I think it realizes it's highest value is conservation. [2:58:09] Thank you. [2:58:10] Thank you. Anyone else? [2:58:15] All right, seeing none. Do we have a motion? [2:58:17] So moved. [2:58:18] Second. [2:58:20] Thank you. Yeah, I just I think I'll just jump in on this one. I first of all greatly appreciate that crossover member of these committees had this impulse and asked us, asked the committee and asked us to consider this. you know, in my in my experience being involved in affordable housing in particular [2:58:44] situations where towns can make municipally owned land available for development can be great opportunities. but in this case it just doesn't feel like the right kind of set of circumstances and fact pattern for some of the reasons that were just voiced at the at the podium. [2:59:05] And I would however, you know, if we do end up just accepting this for conservation tonight which is how this how this item is this motion is worded. I would strongly support a more sort of concerted intentional effort around sort of keeping [2:59:26] town owned land, buildable land on the radar to the extent that it might become available. I don't think there's [clears throat] a whole lot of it out there. but I think there should be a we want we should make sure there's a mechanism for the housing alliance to be in the loop on those types of opportunities as they as they may come up. [2:59:46] And again, I really do appreciate the effort to bring this forward and have us have us consider it and maybe there'll be a better a better site sometime in the future. Anyone else, Karen? [3:00:02] I agree with what Corey said. I won't belabor. I agree with basically everything Crissy said. I think one of the things when I was on council was like we need our committees talking to each other. With that being said, you know, I think the conservation commission was like, "Well,, we got an email from Randy." And I think they were like, "Why didn't we get to comment on this?" and I think you know, their comments that we've heard are why this just unfortunately wouldn't be a great situation. [3:00:25] And I think it was our town manager who ultimately was the one who recommended it for conservation. Not that it's wrong to explore stuff. But I think that was the right recommendation. [3:00:35] Thank you. Anyone else? Larry? [3:00:39] Yeah, I'm curious. My understanding would be if it was viable would be a project would need 6 to 10 acres out of 70. yeah, I obviously it'd depend on the size. But I'm curious. I get all the what ifs. and we should just move ahead and conserve it all. [3:01:02] But I wonder if the process had included the housing alliance earlier in this process and they had consideration if we would be thinking more and it would have come maybe more thoughtfully and more complete and we're kind of jumping in it at the end. But I think that [3:01:22] if it if there was a way with all the facts of due diligence it might be a very clear black and white decision of like it's not appropriate. and therefore we could transfer the whole piece. But if it is appropriate and the costs work out and there's say possibly even some interest from a developer [3:01:48] to also chime in on this that kind of why wouldn't we explore what the all the possibilities are. I don't see there's no urgency particularly this. It's vacant and undeveloped right now. So, if it was still that way in 6 months and we transferred it then, I don't think we've lost anything or any advantage to doing it tonight. [3:02:11] so, I think I'd be supportive of finding out the details. I think right now it's a little bit of speculation. Thanks. [3:02:21] Watch this. To get the details, wouldn't we be spending money on tests? I think that was the comment was like we should we be spending taxpayer money on testing a former sludge site when the recommendation from the town manager and from our disposition policy was to conserve it. And I think that's the question cuz I do think there is an impact. I think we have to spend money to figure it out. [3:02:42] Am I understanding this correctly? [3:02:44] Yeah, quite possibly. I think there are some low-cost things and there was discussion at the Housing Alliance. Resources would likely come not from tax dollars but from the initiative fund, housing initiative fund. It would it's a qualified use to explore housing. one thing that occurs to me is we do have a developer that we have identified and has expressed the conceptual interest. [3:03:10] I think it may be might make sense between now and second reading frankly to have them just give us an assessment that doesn't cost us anything and that's something. And I to be totally honest, I'm the one who manages and is responsible for this real estate disposition policy. One thing we ought to do next year is perhaps expand the folks that need to be notified and solicited earlier, including conservation and housing alliance and others perhaps. [3:03:39] but certainly I could have brought it to them. I'm the staff person for them. I guess I was personally discounting it because of many of the [3:03:50] Yeah. [3:03:50] impediments to development, many of which were explained at the podium, and that probably wasn't fair to it. But in my mind, I didn't think it was really viable without really doing the work. [3:04:04] Thanks. [3:04:07] Shell? [3:04:07] Yeah, I'm I'm more leery of I don't really want to set precedent for not doing like due diligence, and I don't know if this has come up in the past, like we had a situation in the past where we haven't really done due diligence, and then we've sort of, you know, gifted it to the land trust or to someone, cuz I just I think that can [3:04:29] kind of go down a slippery slope. So, I like that you, know, put the offer on the table of like, do we take 6 months and really take a look at it without incurring a lot of cost. I just think that the public might feel better knowing that we kind of did that extra check. [3:04:47] Sorry. [3:04:49] Sorry. Go ahead. [3:04:50] If people are entertaining the idea of prolonging this, I think my first request or one of my requests would be that this go to the conservation commission to get a real opinion from them regarding what Yeah. I don't I don't know enough about sludge sites. I take this very seriously. If I don't I don't want to spend a dollar on, you know, personally researching a site that sludge site, cuz I don't know enough about it. [3:05:13] so, I think I do think we did do our due diligence. We have our disposition policy. We are following our disposition policies, so I do feel like we are doing our due diligence, but I think if we're going to bring in one committee, it would be fair to get a committee's, cuz I mean, we Randy was the chair of the conservation commission for a very long time. She's very educated. They know they I mean, they have a lot of strong opinions and educated opinions about their concerns around it. [3:05:38] I would like to I would like to conserve this, but if other councilors are considering the other option, I guess my request would be to give the conservation commission a chance as well to look at it. [3:05:51] I have a question. Was it on the table that we could make a conservation easement for a portion of it and leave some of it not a conservation easement? [3:06:03] Certainly that 's available. That would require us to delineate, you know, which part of the parcel we wanted to [3:06:09] And we don't know we don't know on that parcel like where it's possible or not. [3:06:13] You know, from a practical, you know, infrastructure build perspective, there's a very obvious area that housing would go. You wouldn't build it up on the deep interior of the property because of the cost. And frankly, that's where the highest conservation is along the river. So, generally I think you could identify a piece of that property, 5 7 acres, whatever it ends up being. [3:06:36] But to do it right, if we're going to actually transfer it, we would need to survey meets and bounds and be able to identify what's being transferred and what's being held back. That's possible. We just didn't pursue that. [3:06:47] Mhm. And what kind of brought this up was the housing alliance thinking it could be for affordable housing, but it could also potentially be for market rate housing, too. [3:06:57] It's not a good [3:06:58] what we're saying cuz I know in the conversation I had with Corey briefly, it was like this is not really a parcel where you would do affordable housing given it's not near density, it's not really affordable development wouldn't necessarily happen there is what I understand. [3:07:13] be. I think you know, as Corey mentioned, you know, the a gift of land or low-cost land can often be the substitute to make a different make it work. clearly this is single-family home construction because of zoning requirements. minimum lot size I believe is 20. [3:07:31] It would be 2 acres in RF, but it's a 20,000 sq ft minimum per subdivision to be fine. So, right. [3:07:42] So, theoretically it's possible. I think there's some major challenges from a cost perspective. [3:07:50] Is this for affordable housing? Cuz I we our residents have been very clear about growth. So, I am we're just saying. [3:07:58] It came from the Housing Alliance who focuses on affordable and workforce housing. [3:08:02] Yeah. I mean [3:08:07] Does this help us get closer to our 30 by 30 goal? [3:08:12] Yes. [3:08:14] [laughter] [3:08:14] It's already counted. It's already counted that. I suppose No, it wouldn't if you if you took a piece of it out. [3:08:21] Yeah. [3:08:21] So, just to just to reset things as we approach 10:00 here. I don't know if anybody's watching. we have a second motion on the table which would be to just accept this land. there has been the option discussed of tabling. there's also I guess as a subset of the of what's on the table right now we've approved it approved this at first reading. [3:08:46] We could ask for a have an expedited assessment which would not be full pledge due diligence but it would at least be some input. So, those are the options that are on the table right now. [3:09:00] And I think it's possible for us to get that this the person we have in mind out there before second reading and at least have a another set of eyes. [3:09:09] Okay. [3:09:10] We can control when second reading happens. [3:09:13] It's true. [3:09:14] That's right. There's nothing prescriptive about that. [3:09:17] first reading. [3:09:18] Yeah. [3:09:18] Mhm. [3:09:19] Right. [3:09:20] Yeah, but I think that we should define what we're going to do instead of just saying it's first reading we're going to go to the land trust but I vote for that. I 'm all for affordable housing and I think that yeah, so we have an opportunity to make affordable housing we should seize the opportunity. [3:09:39] We have a Put the second reading a little later. Yeah. So, the conservation could we have the conservation commission maybe look at it and at least issue their opinion so we could have and if there's any other committee maybe that we want to hear from. [3:09:52] And that's and that's definitely customary that staff use that time staff and committees use that time. [3:09:58] And I'm sorry for conservation they're looking at it from what perspective? For because the Parks and Conservation Land Board has done a full evaluation and I think made a infallible recommendation for conservation. I'm just not sure. [3:10:10] To understand the information that I'm getting in regards to sludge land and what that entails. And so okay, if you know, if right now maybe this isn't a problem, what hap- like would you see issues 20 years down the road? What happens when they try to do a little well? These are all things that I just don't know. So you're saying let's spend taxpayer money to sell the property, but I'm like I is I just have a lot more questions about I think the fact that we originally the render original recommendation was conservation. [3:10:39] And now we're exploring housing on a sludge former sludge site. And I think that's where I'm I don't know what that means, but it seems like people are concerned about that. So if the Conservation Commission isn't the correct person, if there's someone else who felt like they could educate us on Yeah. What that looks like, I feel like we do need to. [3:11:00] Yeah, there is there has been a DEP survey that 's a baseline of information, but I think a lot more work and understanding would need to be done. [3:11:08] Yes. [3:11:08] All right. Point of order. Since it's after 10:00, but we're already deliberating, do we need to amend the rules? [3:11:14] That's just start a new item. [3:11:16] Okay. [3:11:16] Right. [3:11:19] So for the next one we would have to do it. [3:11:21] Yes. [3:11:24] So an option would be to slightly delay and that could simply be your second meeting in December. I don't think it needs a long delay. [3:11:32] [3:11:33] second reading and that would allow folks to further consider this and bring back more information before you make your final decision. [3:11:41] And that would give the Parks and Conservation Land Board maybe the opportunity to speak further as to why they were recommending it for conservation or not keeping it. I guess. That would be maybe a little clarification as well. [3:11:55] Okay. [3:11:58] Can we ask the audience what they think? [3:12:02] I have noticed John increasingly referring to the council in the third person yeah tonight so [3:12:10] So yeah I'm glad everybody's here. so I think we're ready to vote on this feels to me like we're ready to vote for on this for first opposed passes 6 to 1. Thank you. And Nance to be clear what's the expectation of when it comes back to you in second reading? [3:12:31] Normal procedure would it would come back to you at your next meeting you could certainly tell us now and we'll schedule it at a later date if that's your pleasure. Especially given the fact that we have new three new counselors coming in. [3:12:46] So I'd defer coming back until you got new counselors with their legs underneath them more information about what the options are for the use of the property so you're looking at January? Yeah. [3:13:09] First meeting in January we'll we'll bring this item back. Thank you. [3:13:14] thank you. Now do we have a motion to suspend the rules? [3:13:20] Second. [3:13:22] All in favor? Thank you. So yes we will vote to certify the election. [3:13:30] I don't remember 13.4 order number 26-99 [3:13:36] act on the request from the town clerk to certify the results of the municipal general referendum elections and special school board election that were held on Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026. [3:13:49] Do you have anything on the have an intro on this Tody? [3:13:54] On behalf of the town clerk department I present the certification by the town council the election results for the municipal elections that were held on Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026 and forgive me if I mispronounce any names. Esha Agrawal, 5,366 votes. Lawrence King, 4,434 [3:14:14] votes. Samuel Koffman, 2,438 votes. Tom Flaherty, 7,050 votes. Janice Hamilton, 4,499 votes. Jessica Sargent, 6,617 votes. Russell Wayne Worth, eight 1,815 votes. Blanks, 9,799 [3:14:35] votes. For the Board of Education to fill a vacancy with a term to expire in 2028, Andrew Brault, 5,820. [3:14:45] Steven Samarosky, 4,754. [3:14:49] Blanks, 3,432. [3:14:52] For the Sanitary District, Matthew Garrett, 7,636. [3:14:57] Jason Greenleaf, 8,469 votes. Dennis Laferriere, 5,000 votes. Benjamin McDougall, 5,949 votes. Blanks, 14,964. [3:15:12] Question one, which was the Communications Project, the yes vote was 6,706. The no vote was 6,092. And the blanks were 12 1,208. [3:15:26] Thank you. any public comment? I think the public's already commented. do you have a motion? [3:15:34] So moved. [3:15:35] Second. [3:15:35] Any discussion? [3:15:38] Larry. [3:15:40] Really bad form to table this, right? [3:15:42] Yeah. [3:15:42] [laughter] [3:15:48] Let's have a long procedural discussion. [3:15:49] I second that. [3:15:51] Okay. [3:15:51] No, I just wanted to congratulate Tody and Kristin and the whole team for an outstanding election day. Went smoothly, heard great comments. And also just want to congratulate the Town of Scarborough for coming in at 73%. [3:16:07] at voting. I mean, I think that's just amazing. So, good job, Scarborough. [3:16:14] Thank you. [3:16:15] John. [3:16:15] Yeah, I just want to echo that. Like, watching Kristen and her team do the early voting and how that went seamlessly and then to run election day was it's just amazing. congratulations to the winners and also thank you to all of those who stepped up to run this year. Like, it was a lot of people. I think it's great that we have such an engaged group of individuals in our town who want to step up and serve. [3:16:39] And so, you know, looking forward to see what they accomplish in their term. [3:16:45] Thank you. Anyone else? Yeah, I'd also like to thank staff for everything they did to staff and volunteers everything they everything they did to make it run smoothly. One of the One of the fun things for me about spending time at the polls on election day is in addition to just the general atmosphere and people with their kids and [3:17:07] classes and Cub Scout troops coming through, kind of seeing democracy in action is just really seeing people seeing people out there and having a chance to chance to talk to them and it's just great energy. and good to see it all working smoothly. [3:17:27] So, and I again, I One of the things we talked about earlier was how John tends to say what you were going to say. And so, I echo all of that as well. with that, I will call the vote. All in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you. we have no non-action items and that takes us to council member comments. [3:17:51] Lauren. [3:17:54] So, for my last comments, and I know it's after 10, so I'll be brief, but I really want to thank truly everybody on the council, the town staff, which is fabulous. We're so lucky to have that team, leadership, and all for a truly rewarding experience. And then I'm going to read this cuz otherwise I don't know that I'll get through it, but while the outcome of the town council election was disappointing, [3:18:18] but everything else about my experience serving on the council has been very rewarding. First, congratulations to Isha, Jessica, and Shawn on their successful campaigns. They all worked very hard to earn those votes, and I wish them well bringing their unique talent talents and perspectives to the council. I say thank you to my family, old friends, and new friends that gave me support, advice, and guidance throughout my campaign and my service on the council. [3:18:47] your generosity and help is appreciated, and your friendship is invaluable. My wife Kathy made my venture into town politics possible. Without her help and patience, the experience would have been drastically different. this council has worked with collaboration and commitment to achieve positive outcomes for our town, and hopefully that productive style of governing can continue to the next council. [3:19:14] I've agreed and disagreed with everybody on this council at times with no lasting impacts to future productivity. My parting comment is that I have a new appreciation how fortunate we are to live in Scarborough. The town leadership and staff are outstanding. Our citizen committees, which we've referenced many times tonight, are dedicated and talented. [3:19:36] They all truly share the vision of excellence and improvement for our community. This is a special place to live. It's been a pleasure to participate in our local government. I want to thank you for that opportunity. [3:19:51] It says [3:19:59] John? [3:19:59] Yeah, I just want to say this past year and this past council definitely was one of my favorites to serve on, and a lot of it was Larry because of the things you just said about how well we collaborated, how well we discussed issues, how we worked through them, and how I think we ultimately got through some pretty tough things, especially tonight. [3:20:20] Tonight, we saved trees, we worked on conservation, we addressed ice. this is a lot of stuff that we do, and it's just amazing that we were able to do that tonight together. Scott, like I said earlier, you have one of the biggest hearts, I think, on this council. I think that's your superpower. And I always respect how you bring that thought and care to how you take on issues. [3:20:46] Larry, as I said earlier, you're extraordinary. maybe it's extraordinary Larry is what we should call it. and I really hope that you [3:20:57] Brain is always working. [3:20:58] I know. It's Well, I was like, "Wow, that's amazing." That just leads me I'm tired, but extraordinary You're extraordinary. but I hope to see you continue doing things in town, and I really hope you run again because I'll be rooting for you. I'll be waving signs for you. I'll do another owl video [3:21:18] if you need one. but you're just excellent. Karen, like I said, your persistence and focus on conservation is admirable. when we went to the eighth grade forum, like before I prepared, I was like trying to list everything we've done, and I'm like, "We've done so much since Karen's been here." And you have your fingerprint on all of that. [3:21:39] So, I'm so proud of you for doing all of that, and I'm proud that you're going to be here for 2 more years, hopefully doing more. Bill, as I said earlier, your wisdom is untouched based on your experience, and it's been such a pleasure to serve with you. Michelle, you are an amazing add to this council. [3:22:00] we're lucky to have you. You're care and focus on public engagement is something I hope to see continue to grow and see what you do to kind of continue to bring people along. Liam, you've been the best marijuana czar [3:22:19] any town has ever had, and I know the boys in the eighth grade class are looking forward to you as the e-bike czar and taking things on. I always appreciate your partnership, your humor, and how you keep this old guy over here spry and young. Jody, you've been [3:22:40] like you just make me feel comfortable. And when things have been tough sitting behind here having you sit there always brings me peace. And you just do that to people, and I saw a couple years ago they put the article in the Scarborough Living Magazine or something and they talked about how you're like the heartbeat [3:23:03] of this town, and you truly are, and it's been such a pleasure being with you for the past 6 years. Corey you're not the most handsome chair ever but you are definitely one of the best chairs that I've had the pleasure of working with and the way you approach issues and [3:23:24] how you analyze things I think is just really what this community needs, and you really do a great job. to dorky Uncle Tom it has been [3:23:38] it's it's it's been honestly a great pleasure working with you and your leadership. by far one of my highlights this year was renewing your contract cuz I think [3:23:51] Absolutely. [3:23:52] while we all come and go the consistent, strong, calm leadership that you provide to this community is one of the greatest blessings that we have. And so I'm just very thankful for you. [3:24:13] Phil. Well, this being my last meeting I want to first and foremost thank the town senior staff for making the town of Scarborough a better place. That really is just we all admire the preparedness. It just It blows me away how hard working, smart, [3:24:38] and conscientious your senior staff and I so enjoyed working with them. I've had the opportunity to see town management up close for over 50 years cuz that's what I did for a living for 40. and now the last 15 years I've been close to lucky to be close to Scarborough. [3:25:04] Very lucky and that was lucky to married Molly and she had a house at Higgins Beach and that brought me to Scarborough and retirement and the opportunity to serve a community that I've come to love. [3:25:25] the long my 40 years of practicing law was focused almost exclusively on municipal law and state regulatory law and so I had the opportunity week in week out year in year out to see the best that New Hampshire had in cities and towns, counties, [3:25:50] state government. and I will tell you we are blessed to have Tom as our town manager and the staff that he has brought around us is second to none. And I've seen it up close for a decades. So I town after town [3:26:12] town council work can be demanding at times if you want to do it right. you can kind of take a walk if you want, but if you want to do it right, you have to make a an effort. and what I want to do is thank Molly for the sacrifices [3:26:35] that a spouse makes when you have a person who's out busy doing meetings at 6:00, 7:00, 8:00, 9:00, and 10:20 in [laughter] the evening. So, thank you. [3:26:52] Thank you, counselor. [3:26:57] we did some toasting and roasting at the little reception we had beforehand, and I don't I don't I'm not going to repeat all that, but I do just want to express my appreciation to all three of you for your for your service and it's been great being colleagues with you. Bill, I 've I've been so fortunate over the years to have you bringing your professional [3:27:21] perspective your professional skill set to this work and your overall demeanor, and you've been you've been a champion for the people of Scarborough and the plumbers of Scarborough. [3:27:30] Yeah. [3:27:31] And I know that will both of those will continue, maybe in a slightly different ratio, though they're interrelated. and I'm sure we'll see you around, and John, you if you're you've been prolific and persistent and know, you know, it's no secret you make liberal use of chat GPT. [3:27:51] Yeah. [3:27:51] and I hopefully we won't have to approve a data center to support your continued production [3:28:00] [laughter] [3:28:01] but thank you thank you for everything, and Larry, it feels like feels like you've been on the council for much longer than a year, and a half, or whatever it is. and it's been real privilege working with you in leadership. you've done a lot of heavy lifting on things ranging from you know, the school project to the to the budget, the school municipal budget. [3:28:24] getting Tom's contract done, so many other things, helping us navigate the ice situation, which none of us could realistically anticipated when we took office. And so many other examples. I really appreciated all the conversations and the sense of humor and I feel like developed a friendship and certainly hope to continue that going forward and I do hope that you'll be coming back. [3:28:50] But in the meantime, we do have this plaque which was rush ordered unfortunately this morning. [3:28:56] Will you put my name on that thing? [3:28:58] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. [3:28:59] I do want to be clear that we didn't anticipate you losing the election. [3:29:04] show this was not Yes. [3:29:05] Exactly. Jody did her work her magic and got that made up today. [3:29:10] To Larry W. Cain in recognition and appreciation for your outstanding and dedicated service to the town of Scarborough as a member of the Scarborough Town Council. Thank you. [3:29:21] Thanks very much. [3:29:28] I do have to make one comment cuz John referred to it. The video he made in his owl suit, as I was analyzing kind of what went wrong, what could I have done differently. in that video, my campaign sign was next to him on the couch and I can't help but think that was a contributor to my loss. [3:29:53] All right. Anyone else? Michelle? [3:29:55] It's bedtime. Like long ago for most of us, especially after last night. I just want to echo what everybody said and I've had so many people in town ask me, so how has it been the first year? Is it, you know, and I said it's just been fabulous. Like it's been great. Corey, I think your leadership has been amazing. We literally, I was thinking about the calls we were getting during the beginning of some of the ice stuff and just a lot of curveballs that you had to handle sort of on the on the spot. [3:30:26] And I mean we all run thinking we're going to worry about the budget and about, you know, maybe traffic and you know, I think when you look at some of the things that we had to tackle this year, they were completely unpredictable. I think this group, to John's point, it's been fabulous. It's been collaborative. We've had lots of debates behind the scenes. We've had lots of discussions on the side, but I think that we presented a very respectful dialogue and a very professional approach to our work. [3:30:55] And I'm I'm really proud of that for all of us. And Larry, I cried last night when I realized you weren't going to be my partner on a bunch of things. you've just been fabulous. Like I you've absolutely been fantastic and I'm so sad to see you go. And I'll still be texting you saying, "What do you think about this?" But I also want to just welcome Shawn and Aisha and Jessica. [3:31:21] And they I know they're up to the challenge. They ran great campaigns. They worked hard. And I know they're ready to step in and do the hard work. So I welcome them. I feel like I'm graduating college and like the people I've lived with for like 4 years are just like moving to Europe or something. But I'm I'm just really proud of this group the last year. [3:31:43] And it's it's been an absolute pleasure. So. [3:31:47] Thanks. Anyone else? [3:31:51] Motion to adjourn. [3:31:53] Wait. Who's going to do the so moved when I'm gone? [3:31:57] I was going to say I'm going to have to break the habit of just automatically looking down to the left. [3:32:02] Don't worry. We'll figure that out. It'll be a new council. [3:32:05] Yeah. [3:32:05] Yeah. [3:32:06] Yeah. [3:32:07] We'll develop our own Yeah. Yeah. [3:32:09] Yeah. [3:32:10] So final installment of the minutes. We have Councillor Arneson motioning and Don seconding. [3:32:16] Yay. Yay. [3:32:18] Good show. All in favor. [3:32:20] Yeah. [3:32:20] Thank you. [3:32:22] Thank you. [3:32:22] Yeah. [3:32:22] Yeah. [3:33:37] Mhm.