← Back to MaineScanner

Mount Desert Harbor Committee Tables Ordinance Changes and Approves Pier Utility Plan

2026-11-10 · 31m · Source: Harbor committee November 10, 2026 (Town of Mount Desert (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, session the Harvard Committee meeting is called the order November 10th 26. Our first item on the agenda is to go into executive session pursuant to one Mrs number 405 parentheses six parentheses e consultation with legal counsel regarding interpretation of town ordinances, so we will go into executive session. This is Chairman. [0:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, should we not approve the minutes in the last meeting? Nope, after you need a motion to go. [0:42] Speaker A (unidentified): On executive session to be in a motion and then about, so move, second, all in favor raise. [0:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Your hand, opposed, carried. Okay, Julia, I'm going to pause, we're going and we'll be back and I'll, I'll start it back up again. [0:59] Speaker C (unidentified): It. [1:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Should be live, I don't, we want to proceed forward with this, we want to take a minute, select meeting, table the minutes, table the minutes to the next meeting as. [1:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Soon as we get everybody, secretary of the year, so Story's not either, he's right there, oh there you. [1:33] Speaker C (unidentified): What's that, it's which seats the shot up like a wallflower, yeah no you're not a flower, you know pills give you a discount, no. [1:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Covenants on it, yeah there are like I have something but they're easy, there's not files. [2:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, we're good, we. [2:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Have a motion to table the minutes to the next meeting, take motion to table the minutes to the next meeting, seconded, any discussions, all point of order. [2:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Motions to table, there's no discussion, thank you, we need some clarification as stated. [2:44] Speaker A (unidentified): All in favor raise your hand. Opposed? Carried. All right, folks. Do we want to carry on, or do we? Yes. All right. Next item on the agenda was to approve the minutes of October 15th. [Speaker C (unidentified): The table, yeah.] Audience changes for 2027. [3:18] Speaker B (unidentified): We asked you all at the last meeting to bring your ideas for our ordinance changes for this go around, and here's your opportunity. [3:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Maybe we should bring some next meeting. [3:38] Speaker D (unidentified): Patrick, I would like a brief detailed explanation of a timeline. Can you give us that timeline so that we know how much time we have rather than saying if we come to the next meeting? [3:52] Speaker B (unidentified): We've got until our meeting in February to have something all ready to throw at Patrick for his review, to get to town clerk by the end of late in February, okay, so we have our up to our February meeting, we have December, January, and we need to approve whatever we have come up with at our February meeting, okay, and I said a few things that's being discussed. [4:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Tonight that no dinghies can be used for qualification for moorings only corporations the operations marine related not locs that don't have relations of the water usage and closing west of Northeast Harbor making an enclosed Harbor and east of Northeast Harbor making an enclosed Harbor these are just things I wrote down for thoughts for ordinance changes we're going to be more specific than that well we can hash it out I mean I'm not making a motion I'm just saying these are my thoughts that I brought to the table regarding ordinance [4:59] Speaker F (unidentified): changes and here's the discussion when you say danny you mean a rowboat or a boat with it [5:04] Speaker E (unidentified): unregistered like you just have a puff and dick like John said anyone could and I said made a comment and like I don't think you should have a puff and dinghy and then I think I got that solved [5:13] Speaker D (unidentified): if we just say that 100 series morning start at 15 feet right because the dinghy goes to 14 feet so all we have to say is 100 series starts from 15 feet to 19 feet and then 200s from 20 to [5:30] Speaker B (unidentified): 29. Is that our definition of a dinghy is 14. What do you do with the 12-foot bullseye or I don't [5:36] Speaker E (unidentified): know if there's that's the only verse for only I'm not sure this is just these are just topics that I want to bring up for discussion yeah you can say like it's not fair someone just has it or the person people that apply they just have a dinghy to get a mooring somewhere yeah I don't [5:53] Speaker B (unidentified): necessarily think that's yes because right now I would accept a canoe or kayak correct I would not accept a paddle board but you know a new world kayak so I'm sorry if people are holding moorings [6:06] Speaker E (unidentified): with that I think they're eliminating people that have a bow knee usage so that's one of the [6:11] Speaker A (unidentified): topic we brought up a huge issue tonight about riparian rights especially in undesignated harbors and I have a lot of problem with having to own 100 feet of land gives you the gives those people the only rights to have a morning and 99 of the people that have moorings don't have chauffeuring property so I don't think we're addressing that properly [6:39] Speaker B (unidentified): In my opinion, that's what our designated harbors are for. That serves the people that don't own shore frontage, right, because it's open and free to anyone to apply. [6:49] Speaker G (unidentified): But it's also state law, and I would, in a lot of those circumstances, the stricter rule overrides a lesser rule. [7:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Typically, but I think what I'm hearing is that, you know, one, I think all these ideas are great, and, you know, this is what this is for, right? Like, let's get these ideas, here's what we've seen this past year, and start getting a list. And okay, and what, how do we want to then, what's the, maybe the next meeting in January or December, you guys come back with specific language proposals to, hey, I want to see this is where it would change in the ordinance, I want to see that. To your question and to Rick's point, yeah, there's, if your ordinance is silent on an issue, you're going to defer to the state's statute, yeah. But here, what I think what I'm hearing is, do we need to designate more areas for moorings, or do we need to come up with a pro, you know, like, again, like, okay, we want, if the, if the goal is let's provide more access to moorings to more people outside of our current designated harbors, close harbors, great, what does that look like? And you guys need to come up with a proposal as far as is that we need to designate more harbors, you know, create more closed harbors that have more capacity for moorings, is that something? And then you just, because that could be simple, right? Again, I'm no mariner, so I'm not gonna, you know, you guys know the water better than I do, but maybe there's just, hey, we need more moorings, maybe these areas is in the, in the town's waters could, you know, hold more moorings, let's designate them, let's figure out how many moorings could go in there, create a way of for you know, what are the requirements to qualify to apply for a mooring, and if that's something you guys want to do, you can do that, or you, or maybe there's something else, I don't know, but that's, you know, coming, having this conversation now and then you come back in December, maybe someone's thought of a really good idea or a different idea, and you guys can discuss and debate what that looks like, so by the time we get to February we have a proposal on that potentially. [9:07] Speaker F (unidentified): Are you entitled to more than one morning if you have a hundred feet, or just one? Just one. [9:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think our statue says you can have two more people, and some sound they have a mooring at their house and they have a mooring in some harbor. No, what I'm [9:26] Speaker F (unidentified): just talking about, if you want 100 feet of shoreline, are you entitled to the only thing [9:29] Speaker B (unidentified): you want to put 10 moorings there, or just guaranteed the one, and then if you want more, if there's space available, it's at my discretion to give you one, I said, then we get into this. [9:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Undesignated harbors again, you know. And yeah, that's what's not, oh yeah, outside of the harbors. [9:47] Speaker H (unidentified): One thing that occurs to me, if we allow or undesignate more moorings, we don't even have room at the harbor for the skiffs that people have in the harbor. I mean, you've got to start taking that. And Clifton Dock, I imagine, is pretty full. And, you know, there's more than just saying you can have a mooring. I think you have to take into consideration how they're going to access that. But I'm sorry, you know, where are they going to keep their skiff? [10:22] Speaker B (unidentified): They would launch it at the ramp, and these are all things again, you could say okay, you can, you know, potentially qualify for mooring in these other waters if you satisfy these requirements, and you guys, you guys come up with the requirements that you feel, what we need to come up with makes sense, then yeah, then you can amend the ordinance to do that. And, you know, like, yeah, and it makes sense, access, obviously, safe navigation, you know, these, you know, what proof that you own a vessel, right? So people don't just like speculate of, oh, I want to get a boat one day, I'm going to get a mooring, right? Like these requirements that you would have. And then, okay, like, all right, we think people can qualify for all these things. where are we going to put these moorings how many are we going to allow you know do you apply the same kind of tiered analysis where it's residents and then fishermen and then or you know like that you know what 's the order of preference for people to get these new moorings that you're [11:18] Speaker C (unidentified): creating space for? How [11:23] Speaker A (unidentified): it's i think we should right now how we probably correct your other show well i think considering the time and what we've concentrated on tonight i think we should hold off on our recommendations till the next meeting well i disagree i would like to well i 'm we came here to discuss this tonight discuss what ordinance changes like that's what's on the agenda can we finish that topic well we've spent an hour and a [11:59] Speaker G (unidentified): half discussing previous issue. Did you have something that you had brought to raise up, or just more discussion about that different? Yeah, so he just brought a few things that he was asked to bring, I guess. How's [12:17] Speaker F (unidentified): everyone's field? I'd say throw them out there and we can think about [12:27] Speaker D (unidentified): I know John does this, I don't know how informally, but I think if he does it informally, we should make it formal, which is that he often allows when a spouse dies, that the mooring gets [12:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Transferred to the living spouse, right? That's correct, as long as the boat ownership is going to stay with the wife and she's going to continue to use it, I do allow the transfer from in that process, like your discretion, but we but [13:05] Speaker H (unidentified): It's not okay, but what's your other suggest? We don't need to argue about it. [13:09] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. Okay. Sure. I was, oh, thank you. I was considering that I noticed that the fish buying vehicles, like they've moved off the pier, but now they sit parked in the yellow striped areas, which is illegal parking, and they keep their engine running all the time. Which I don't know, I know there's a statue and menu that says you can't keep your eye your car running for a truck running for more than 15 minutes except for certain exclusions, and I don't know if they fall in that exclusive or not. [13:49] Speaker F (unidentified): They don't leave the truck running, so you hear the reefer coming on and off, oh. [13:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Is that what it is you do, and I believe in our traffic [13:56] Speaker E (unidentified): ordinance is that the vehicle is loading or unloading or it is attended in those, I believe it's a lab. I'm not sure, but that is the last interpretation. [14:06] Speaker D (unidentified): It just seems to me like they could be off site while they're waiting for their next call rather than sitting right there. [14:13] Speaker E (unidentified): That's all. That has my attention. [14:16] Speaker C (unidentified): OK, great. [14:20] Speaker D (unidentified): I, personally experienced two problems related to Blair Colby's operation this year. One was, as John knows, someone came up to me and accused me of being that person and wanting a piece of my hide because I'm making wakes in the harbor because my boat looks like his. And then the second one was I was eating dinner at 7 o'clock at night after the harbor closes at 4, so it was after hours, and he just came steaming in here as fast as he wanted. So I mean you can see it on the videos, I'm sure, you know, I didn't really keep track of the date and time, but it's clearly still a problem, and we've asked him to dial it down or remove his ability to do his operation. Who is who [15:13] Speaker B (unidentified): is this, but holy, do I say his name right, dad, like water taxes? Yes, I know I've [15:19] Speaker D (unidentified): seen him do that too, so I just want to know, like, you know, how can we address this so that it really is resolved in some ways, because both those things, you know, [15:30] Speaker F (unidentified): are impactful to the harbor, I would say. Yeah, I would say if you see it as a member of the harbor committee to speak John about it, right, you know what, then John's job. Okay, all right, but [15:45] Speaker D (unidentified): we do have the when do we meet to talk about whether or not we want to re-up someone's every [15:52] Speaker B (unidentified): Every three years so we can review if there's an issue, we can review, you know, somebody or cause not to overly defend, but I think one of the problems that he throws [16:08] Speaker H (unidentified): away is it is really about heavy, it's really what now, heavy in his engine, in his size, and the smallness of the boat, it's, I'm sorry, the Harvard masters are seeing videos of him for always feeding in the harbor, I'm not, I said I've not done a lot of times, so he's thrown away and [16:30] Speaker D (unidentified): He's, he's, so the next one I had was that the commercial operators need to, we never had this actually in our ordinance, but you know it kind of fell into this situation, but I think commercial operators need to show, we need to write in there like what we're expecting them to be in business, right, because we don't want a commercial operator sitting on one of those five valuable permits that they get just to sit on it because they might want to do it one day [17:06] Speaker B (unidentified): In the future rather than actually running a business that could, you're saying like a use it or lose it type, yeah, exactly, use it or lose it, thank you, yeah, and that could also go over to commercial operators also, okay, yeah, we have had this discussion last year and I think we had planned on doing something in this go-around, okay, so I bring it up, it was on or before September [17:33] Speaker E (unidentified): 3rd every third year after an operating contract, is executed, yeah, maybe we [17:40] Speaker G (unidentified): Should change that to be a little more, John just said that if there's an issue, oh, we can be reviewed [17:45] Speaker D (unidentified): Sooner, okay, cool, and then what was the last thing I had, oh, I don't know what's going on, but and maybe this is just, you know, a thing with John again, but I've been trying to get public access to the waiting list for a couple of years, and I know that originally like it was taken offline, line because you were trying to figure out the, what is it called, the residents versus [18:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Non-residents and how to work with them, so it's been a couple of years, basically there's a problem with online morning that when it's visible people have the ability to do stuff that would benefit them and we had to remove the viewing to stop that and they haven't come up with a fix for it yet [18:32] Speaker D (unidentified): okay so i 'm not i'm not trying to say anything i'm just saying that there's a state law that says like the morning list has to be public the waitlist has to be public so and anyone can come [18:45] Speaker B (unidentified): In and it's public, okay, all right, I get 10 calls a week, people call and say hey, where am I [18:53] Speaker D (unidentified): On the way. Yeah, okay, great, because you know sometimes I ask people how you're doing on the waiting list and I can't tell them where they are. Sure, those [19:03] Speaker E (unidentified): are my ideas. Yeah, just make it suggest. [19:07] Speaker B (unidentified): So I think these are all great ideas and I, but I would, I don't know if they're being written down, [19:12] Speaker E (unidentified): but I shorthand, I was going to say if everyone could email their ideas in to John or the chair so we could systematically go down through them and then vote or discuss, it would be very helpful. [19:25] Speaker B (unidentified): So that was going to be my advice. But I think thinking about your schedule, right? You've got to make sure, one thing, that when you email, you can't have a conversation about the merits of anything because then it becomes a meeting. So I think what I would advise is individually email John or the chair or whoever they want to handle it. And then at your December meeting, right, you come and say, here's everything that people have proposed, let's talk these through. And then at your January meeting come and maybe you started to hash out language changes and I don't know how you divide that work as a committee and then so but so then you have that pile John can provide it to me and then at your February meeting you've had my review [20:10] Speaker C (unidentified): and then you guys can vote on advancing these changes to the select board that was just [20:17] Speaker F (unidentified): license legally can John like give you know we send him what we want legally could John [20:24] Speaker B (unidentified): email us in two weeks and say oh yeah here's what's been provided and then you just don't say hey nobody's saying this or that then you show up in December everyone has the same list you've got time to think about it and you're prepared to start you could even come and say hey I've drafted some proposed language I think that so how we've done most of our last ordinance [20:46] Speaker E (unidentified): changes how he's done most of the drafts email back and forth and Mate and we've and yeah Chris [20:51] Speaker D (unidentified): and I have hashed out most of the language so the most ones that you've approved and you've [20:55] Speaker B (unidentified): reread and the last couple yeah and that's fine as long as it's kind of like you have to change years of change because then I review and then the final product is presented at a public meeting yes so that's absolutely fine but if anyone else wants to help Chris I mean I'm more than half I'm open to anyone being willing to help us we need a motion to say people are just [21:20] Speaker E (unidentified): writing down people please bring or email to John was that good or the chair note in the minutes [21:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Well I kind of think we understand what we're talking about here. We don't need a motion for [21:30] Speaker E (unidentified): everything we discussed, but so if everyone's in agreement we'll email the chair or John [21:35] Speaker B (unidentified): on sure ordinance. Oh you've saved just to email both so they're both aware of it, and then whoever ends up kind of cutting the list [21:53] Speaker A (unidentified): press just on your suggestion everything east of north northeast. How are you saying, like northeast having a sea level? Well yes, what are on the east side yes and [22:05] Speaker E (unidentified): one thing I don't, I have a good comprehension, I'm not on the waters of this part. What's in that area and we have never seen a map charted area of what more is registered over there and something what's registered and corrugated to Google Earth to see what's happening over there. That area Barwoods has been neglected. We lost a member who was very adamant and kept us in check at Bartwoods and we don't have representation over there. I've seen a chart on that so and I'm on the waiting list for that So but I mean beyond that our waters where privates coves have been a minute so a lot of the problem is people have, people with more money have a house on the cove and they monopolize it with morgues and they have more boats and I think we've been really trying as a committee to open it up for everyone and not let a small group monopolize certain areas. I think we've been good and I think that we're continuing to try to strive to that so that's one area I we don't I haven't I don't know I don't have eyes on, my eyes on this area. We have areas that are over expanded, oversaturated with moorings and by saying that what my idea was that to get it on to the weight west we backed John a specific criteria for that and what, who comes first the others so [23:26] Speaker A (unidentified): west of northeast that was a big area right I [23:29] Speaker E (unidentified): mean we get a lot of post lights yeah and it's pretty saturated so at least but I'm also suggesting east so it shuts down any over monopolization what he was trying to do with denying the two moorings so it doesn't cascade effect so to speak so that we all mount cert it could, it could be what I'm saying is I don't have, I understand this area, I don't have a understanding of Bartlett's. I don't, I haven't been over there enough and I'll spend enough time I guess I should Google Earth it to see what's current, you know what's plotted there. I mean that should be incorporated too [24:03] Speaker B (unidentified): I'd love comment from someone that's frequent that area so I do have specific points from point to point to point to point for the entire coast of the town of Mount Desert is designated in online morning so all of these out of the harbor moorings are in one of them areas. I will bring that information at the next meeting and explain and show you guys on a map where these points are and there are areas where yes there could be a bunch of moorings put in but some of those areas don't have any access so that's but I think that should fall into our criteria I think that should go to [24:44] Speaker E (unidentified): John he's a set criteria you know as he does in the higher which he's done an amazing job and his assistant has validated changed the waiting list done an amazing job looking at where people fall into that after ordinance changes, I think we need to apply that to the other areas. [25:02] Speaker H (unidentified): I need to open out and create them all. Okay. I thought that was Bar Harbor. I thought you gave that to Bar Harbor. I remember. Start giving up. Are we tabling the. [25:18] Speaker B (unidentified): off the operators fees or we moving forward with that your discretion but one thing here I do need [25:26] Speaker A (unidentified): to run over with your from Darlin Gorsky but yeah you go ahead John because I do you want a table that other I do because I want our meetings to be efficient and I think we've run over the [25:38] Speaker H (unidentified): efficiency we haven't but with those we have time to set the fees in December yeah oh yeah okay oh yeah I know there was a deadline at some point so all we were talking [25:48] Speaker E (unidentified): about was discussed was a dollar for passengers 500 for cargo fees yeah but I'm just saying [25:54] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah no we talked like we had until February for the final preparation but for fees all we [26:01] Speaker B (unidentified): need to do is make a yeah to the select board and I write a memo and they approve it or and when does it have to be by I'm afraid it can be any time of the year there's no set time on us changing a fee for something we generally only change fees just after that season has ended so there's time for me to implement it and let people know before the new season comes but you know we have we have time on that nobody's really going to have any passenger fees other than maybe a water taxi or the ferry But the ferry runs year-round, so really May is when we need to have it wrapped up. If we're going to change those fees, so you guys are going to table those until our next meeting. Yeah, okay. So the one piece, Dartland Gorski, there was multiples, but I was able to answer, and they were number of slips and stuff like that. This is directly from them. We also wanted to follow up on an update from item 3.3, design team follow-up, identify cost implications for integration of the utility trench within the pier, where we were going to, instead of hanging the equipment underneath like we do now, we were going to integrate it into the pier. Response, we've received a very preliminary estimate from a precast manufacturer indicating that the trench could add approximately a quarter of a million dollars in material cost alone. This estimate does not include the additional construction cost and is intended only to provide a general idea of that potential anticipated cost. Their question is, do you want to continue with the trench or do you want to not? So that's just the, just the box of the transit, the concrete, and just the construction, so that could be, yeah, three, four, five hundred thousand dollars. I think they look nice hanging. But if we raise it, I think that is nice hanging. That is correct, going up. You're also pulling the stuff up and the stuff hangs lower. The stuff could be tighter to the bottom of the pier. [28:17] Speaker A (unidentified): i like it exposed underneath the pier personally because i think there's access to repairs and upgrades and i will say something about the costs we're trying to design and build something for 75 years none of us are going to be around 75 years from now they're going to say geez how do they build that so cheap and i don't think money should be an issue right now i think good design should be the issue when i when i asked them [28:52] Speaker G (unidentified): would it be more expensive by hanging things, they said because it is more exposed to the elements, it may incur costs being exposed as well. Our equipment that hangs under the pier is already [29:07] Speaker B (unidentified): waterproof. It's already underwater every day, twice a day, so it's already designed to be underwater water, so that's not a factor in my opinion. What is it? I don't know. I think you want to show this. I would say you need a motion if you guys want to go one way or another, so I can relay to Dartwood. [29:28] Speaker A (unidentified): And Gorsky, which way to keep moving? We're making the motion. I would like to make a motion to have the utilities hang underneath the work. I'll be second that moved and seconded to have the utilities hang under the wall. Any other discussion? I have a question. Did they say which one was going [29:46] Speaker G (unidentified): to be more expensive, to bury it or to maintain it over a period of time, the trench? So we know that's going to be up to 500,000. What would be the question as a result? There's a lot of other costs [30:00] Speaker B (unidentified): and going with the trench, everything would have to be dug up and be rerouted to come up over the top of the pier, where if we stay with what we go now, it would come up underneath the pier, go up and attach to the bottom of the pier and continue as it does now, just three feet higher. [30:16] Speaker H (unidentified): And those lines aren't being replaced? The existing lines are being used? [30:21] Speaker G (unidentified): They are. I remember that came up also. Okay. [30:24] Speaker B (unidentified): And we have money in our CIP lines to replace those lines when needed. They have an incredibly long lifespan on them. They're built for undersea submarine table usage and that's [30:38] Speaker C (unidentified): what they are ready [30:42] Speaker A (unidentified): for a vote. Okay, we're voting on the motion to have the utilities under the pier. All in favor raise your hand. Opposed? It's carried. Make a motion to be adjourned. Seconded. Any discussion? All in favor, raise your hand. Opposed? Carried. Thank you very much for everybody. Thank you all.