← Back to MaineScanner

Auburn Council postpones Webster's license denial, adopts heating aid

2026-11-16 · 1h 54m · Source: City of Auburn, Maine, City Council Meeting, November 16, 2026 (City of Auburn / Great Falls TV (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:38] Jeff Harman: the november 16th 2026 auburn city council meeting will be called to order please join us in the pledge of allegiance to [0:48] Kelly Butler: the flag of the united states thank [1:05] Jeff Harman: you if we could have the counselors introduce themselves starting good [1:10] Brennan Geary: evening belinda gary counselor at large [1:15] Rachel Randall: good evening rachel randall ward one good evening tim cowan ward two good evening matthew duvall [1:23] Tim Cowan: ward three good evening jeff harman mayor good evening kelly butler ward four good evening [1:29] Adam Platt: leroy walker one five good evening adam platt city councilor at large good evening brennan [1:35] Owen Robinson: edwards student representative good evening owen robinson student representative bill kroll city
Consent Agenda
[1:41] Jeff Harman: manager thank you there's no consent agenda this evening the first item of business is approval of the minutes of the regular city council meeting of november 2nd 2026 is there a motion to approve are there any errors or correction is there a second the move by council walker seconded by councillor platts vote will be by show of hands all those in favor seven having voted the affirmative and none of the negatives the motion is adopted under communications presentations and recognitions we have one item this evening the annual assessing statistics presentation and reevaluation update karen scam and the city assessor will be our presenter and maybe it's mr st peter who's our presenter karen's [2:36] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager or Staff): actually here she's checking on our presentation just to see if it was queued up and i don't see that it was yeah so i so what yeah i guess it is on the pdf so we'll do it that way back up okay I'll get it I promise I'll get it here it is I found it I found it okay there's all kinds of slides and I you know I'm gonna get it here eventually okay so counselors mr. mayor thank you for indulging us we have our annual commitment data that we that we like to provide every year it's it's very important and it's important to understand the numbers behind it so let's start with commitment 2026 there are three dates that are pretty important the first is the assessment date the second is commitment date which is the day that we all breathe the site we all sigh in relief because we're done but April 1st is basically the date when property value is set so we have to get our values in order in order to commit by july 13th so it's a short period of time so those are two important related dates and then if we didn't get everything right then the taxpayers can call us out because the abatement date is january 14th which is six months after the commitment date this year we certified at 73 percent there are some disadvantages to having a certified ratio below 100 one is things like exemptions are less in this year was 18,000 to 250 as compared to $25,000 the benefit to the taxpayer is approximately four hundred forty seven dollars in tax dollars our mill rate this year was twenty four point five next up are the valuation totals. These are all in your council packet. We have $2.4 billion in taxable value. Of that, in real estate, $497,000 is exempt. We have 9,508 parcels, and you can go down you can go down through all the different breakdowns of value but our taxable value is 2.4 billion dollars we also will assess personal property not everyone's aware of that and included in that is solar assets which we treat as personal property Betty exemption is value that is reported to businesses that is exempt they have to put in an application it's notable that it's more value than what we have in taxable value so they're getting relief on that bitty exempt property and that is reimbursed to us by the state at a rate of around fifty five percent the taxable value the property owner could also get relief on that as well through a refund program called better so a lot of this value is reported by the businesses, but it is eligible for one type of relief or another. So just going down through kind of a comparison year to year of our taxable versus exempt values, I kind of want to start with the conclusion here is that this year our net valuation increased by $64 million, which is kind of remarkable if you consider that we had to ratio a number of classes of properties, including energy production facilities in all of our personal property. So even though we had to ratio, new valuation and adjustments netted an additional 64 million in property value. And we have top ten taxpayers, and this list hasn't changed much. There has been a few additions, a few movements on the list. but this generally we count the top taxpayers by the combination of their taxable real estate and their taxable personal property and that's how we develop this ranking if you look at the share we have a pie chart of all the different of the top ten taxpayers but if you compare it to the rest of the city they account for ten point two percent of the values which is a big deal which is which is a lot of valuation that they are you know if you have 9500 parcels these you know are probably somewhere around you know 50 parcels that are worth 10% of the total value in the city of Auburn and if we look at our tax base and this is this is according to valuation our residential property, which are generally deemed to be single family to up to four units, is 56% of our value. And that's been increasing as far as the ratio of value over the past decade or so. And then you have the commercial, industrial, and the multi-families, utilities, personal property, vacant land, those are all kind of a compositional of our valuation. And, from there, I'm going to hand this over to Connor. Connor is actually kind of the architect of the report this year, so we thought it'd be important that he had a word to say about it, so go for it. All right. [8:44] Unidentified speaker (likely Staff/Presentation): So, as Joe was just talking about that tax-based mix, you can see up here we're looking at two subsections of that mix, and we're just looking at residential across the top and commercial and industrial across the bottom. And what we can see is 10 years ago, the residential only made up about 48% of the entire valuation of the city. Commercial and industrial was 37% of the entire value. Over time, these two have kind of split. Residential now takes up or is now responsible for 57% of the total valuation, with commercial only representing 34% of the total value of the city. as these split that shift that tax burden shifts towards the residential property owners those are the one through four units here we have a breakdown of all of the real estate exemptions in the city 16.8 percent of that total real estate valuation is exempt the biggest exemption we have is city owned property schools city hall things like that but coming in second is the homestead exemption which you get partially reimbursed for by the state this year that reimbursement should be about 1.4 million dollars the personal property we have over the past seven years just to see how that has changed and hasn't changed really the top number there in the green is taxable and the blue is very exempt and despite having a ratio those values down to 73 percent of the reported value this year they stay steady you see across seven years they've stayed pretty setting which tells us that the asset values are increasing and if after this revaluation we're able to declare a 100% ratio those values are very likely going to increase beyond what we see here. This is our valuation based trend so over the past seven years that valuation base is taxable valuation of real estate and personal property plus the state reimbursements that we get for the homestead exemptions and the betting exemptions it increases slightly every year we've seen it increase thanks to development in the city and investment in building the city as well as the market adjustment that we've been making along the way to try to expand our valuation we saw that pie chart of all of the real estate exemptions and i think it's important to look at total value but i also think it's important to look at tax dollars and how those dollars relate a little bit more directly to the budgets that you guys look at and the dollars in our pockets three two years ago 2024 we due to exemptions took 16.9 million dollars on the tax roll that's exempt property real estate and personal property and this year that dropped down to increased to just under 18 million of tax dollars not on the tax roll in the same vein we can look at tax dollars lost due to ratioing so 2024 we declared a 93 ratio and that meant about 612 000 were not taxable due to ratioing personal property and those bits of real estate and now with a 73 ratio that's two million eight hundred thirty seven thousand dollars that is less than what we would have gotten if we were declaring at a 100 percent ratio and again with that revaluation we're hoping to get back up to 100 of market value and see that line go up to zero dollars lost and getting that full value thank you thanks great job are there any questions on the booklet at all [13:02] Adam Platt: I just had one question about some of the trends percentage of commercial property value are there any are there any metrics that you're seeing that are unique to Auburn any ways that we're standing out relative to other communities in the data that we've just seen or are we have fairly typical [13:23] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager or Staff): community I think we're fairly typical I mean what we're seeing across state is residential property that 's increasing that being said the jury's not out on commercial property because in the last couple years we've seen a number of sales that indicate an increasing commercial market we really won't know until we have the final numbers on the reval but we're seeing trends where commercial property needs to be adjusted some of it may be adjusted down but we are seeing some sales that indicate real growth and we're kind of excited to see that because commercial sales you don't see a lot of but we've had sales that we can kind of hang our hat on and that's a good thing other [14:11] Jeff Harman: questions from the council just to follow up on that so the graph that showed the trend line for the difference in valuation is the percentage of residential and commercial right to follow up on council classes point should we assume that part of that is because there have been more residential sales and there were market rate adjustments on the residential side during a period of time when there were fewer or no adjustments in some of the [14:47] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager or Staff): other classifications I think that's an excellent hypothesis and I think it's it's I think it's supported again we won't know until we actually do the commercial valuation I do think when we when we have our commercial numbers it's going to catch up that's my hope that's my that's my hope but if you look at if you go back to like the top ten taxpayers being such a large portion of you know just ten percent of the value for a handful of properties if you will even making subtle adjustments to commercial properties is going to have a favorable impact in theory if you look at last year versus this year on the [15:35] Unidentified speaker (likely Staff/Presentation): commercial as percentage it does go up this year we did make adjustments to commercial properties and you can see that directly reflected there from 25 to 26 yeah other [15:47] Speaker K (unidentified): question I think just a quick follow-up to that excuse me that's that's very reassuring to hear that were that you're seeing some data that may suggest that gap may close but when I look at 2016 that was a whole lot closer do you do you think it will get there'll be some your what I'm hearing you say is that you're thinking the data is suggesting there will be some adjustment yeah is the thought that it would get as close as that far back or is it going to be somewhere in [16:26] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager or Staff): between again hypothesis I don't know I think that's that's plausible you know when we talk about commercial property commercial industrial you have a wide variety I mean you know from retail to office space to you know hospitality to all those things are all affected at different rates what it's going to be in the aggregate i can't tell you for sure i do know though that i mean if you compare residential property values you know from that time to now i mean obviously it's escalated quite a bit so i do i think it's going to be as close i do not do i think it'll be closer i do [17:08] Speaker K (unidentified): thank you it's good to hear that we think it's going to be closer yeah [17:17] Unidentified speaker (likely Staff/Presentation): I just wanted to give you a brief update of where our revaluation is and what's been going on with that. So the first round of residential inspections are complete. They were finished in September, and so the next step to the revaluation after the first go-around is to contact all of the tax property owners who did not get an interior inspection send them all letters and give them the opportunity to pick a convenient time for an interior inspection so on September 29th the first round of callback letters went out to one group they're doing it incrementally obviously because we have a lot of letters out during the first round of cold calls it was not as high a percentage as I would like to see for interior inspections but that's probably due to they were done between business hours a lot of people were home during those hours some people maybe were not prepared to have someone come into the house we did gather a lot of information at the door but even those people that did give information at the door are going to receive these letters because it may like i said be more convenient now so those have gone out now at the same time that someone one of the data collectors is working on taking appointments and going out to do callbacks the commercial inspections have started so we have two staff members from krt appraisal in the field they are going business to business same way that the residential was done and they are doing the commercial inspections i'm happy to report that they are very positive about the response from the businesses they have started in the southern section of the city so they're out by the airport they're out mostly in that area and they said that so far they have had a 30 percent entry rate and they are doing full inspections for those businesses that don't have proprietary areas that you can't go into but they said that the property owners of our business owners have been very willing to have them come in and do an inspection so that's very encouraging so they are out there as well now these callback letters that went out I don't know if any of you have been contacted we have had a tremendous number one they want to verify that this is legit that's the word they use are these letters legit they really come from you why are they coming back again we have posted a copy of the letter on the website and on some other area in the news on the website and also on the website but yes we explained to them that it certainly is, and this is what's happening. We explained the process. KRT has given them, they've mailed out the letters and given them a two-week window to call and schedule an appointment, which isn't a lot of time, but again, they're going back to a lot of properties. So after one round, they have to send out another batch and another batch. so what we have been doing and what KRT has been because staff is more than willing to schedule an appointment that's convenient we have done so and we've done quite a few callback appointments we've had very good response from the letters as far as getting interior inspections that too is encouraging. So we've been working on that. Connor's been updating the map on the website on the Reval Hub, so any appointments that are done, they're being colored in as being inspected. So that's all up to date. And what else can I tell you? Data entry from the inspections and the notes from the data collectors has been ongoing. We have been, And all staff, Ozzie is here as well, all staff has been reviewing the data that's being loaded, checking for accuracy, checking for anomalies, making sure if a value went up, we have a reason for that because we need to be able to explain it to someone when they call and say, you know, I saw my valuation and it went up. I thought the reval wasn't complete yet. That's true. It was most likely due to a change in the property itself that we had not seen before. Those are being done right away. We've explained that already. So it's not due to the end result of the reval when the cost schedules are being updated. It's due to the fact that, oh, we missed a half bath or, oh, they've updated the entire property since we've been there, or maybe they removed their basement finish and the value actually went down. We're seeing all sorts of adjustments that are being made, so we are constantly monitoring whatever adjustments are going in that are being loaded. We are on target to receive our values for review by the end of May to mid-June. I checked the contract everything's on target so they will deliver the preliminary we call them preliminary values to us mid-may mid-may early June we'll review them they'll review them then the process will be informal hearings they will have property owners will have an opportunity to schedule an informal hearing with the KRT staff. They'll go over all the data. If there is something that is questionable, then they will inspect again, make sure it's correct, or take the information from the taxpayer. If there's been a mistake made at that point, it will be corrected. And then, after the informal hearings, the project is slated to be completed by August 2027. And then, of course, as we've already discussed, we will be reviewing all the staff, assessing staff will be reviewing all of those values, and we're going to take our time doing that, obviously. There'll still be time for taxpayers to call and say, hmm, this doesn't still look right to me. We're more than willing to go back out and do another inspection as long as it takes to get the data correct and accurate. So we will take all that time, 2027, and review all those values, do any more appointments that we need to do, and then they will be implemented for the 2028 tax year. So everything's on schedule. Everything's looking up, really. I'm very encouraged by these letters and by the appointments that we've made for interior inspections and the commercial inspection so all good news questions okay [25:03] Jeff Harman: thank you questions from the council for [25:07] Tim Cowan: individuals who are finding errors when they're receiving their letters can you speak just a little bit more to the time frame of having that resolved sure let me see well [25:22] Unidentified speaker (likely Staff/Presentation): it actually it's it's almost a year they will have time because they'll get their valuation notices they'll only have a small window to schedule with KRT appraisal and I don't have the contract in front of me but I believe that's a two or three week period where they can call and go over their valuation with KRT however again if they're not satisfied with their result those values are not going to be put into effect until the following year so we are more than willing to go back out do another other inspection of go over it with them and hopefully resolve any issues so if someone has [26:03] Tim Cowan: followed those steps and they're reaching out can they reasonably expect that the team will work with them step by step as opposed to waiting for a period of time and then addressing it absolutely okay thank you other [26:17] Jeff Harman: questions from the council thank you very much for the update we appreciate thank you we'll move on to the first open session of the evening if there's members of the public that would like to address the council relative to items that are not on tonight's agenda please approach the podium and provide your name and address good [26:44] Mary Moore: evening mayor harmer harman members of the city council and anyone who's present tonight either at home or listening my name is mary moore and i am a landowner and taxpayer in the ag zone while i continue to look at the big picture of language impact consequences future of auburn i am concerned about finalizing the language of the comprehensive plan without further review i appreciate the opportunity to speak directly to you tonight before the final readings I first want to highlight a few specific omissions in the plan that I discovered before I focus on something that is significantly more troubling while our current ordinance allows single-family homes accessory to farming recreation and natural resource uses like forestry, the draft comp plan omits these non-farming uses from policy two, objective three, and from policy three's goals and objectives. Leaving out these accepted uses restricts the existing residential and land management rights of non-farming land owners. Given the likelihood of similar gaps elsewhere in the draft, I urge the council to review the Ag Zone language again so these omissions are addressed. While those omissions are important to review, what follows carries far greater consequences. Since 1964, Auburn has tied a family's right to live in the Ag Zone to active land use rather than the physical character of the land, forest, open fields, and habitat. Even after the council removed the strict farm income requirements in 2023, the insertion of the word accessory in the ordinance left that exact same catch-22 intact. Now the draft plan's language allows only housing that supports active land uses, locking that same restriction in place under city ordinance section 6145 a plan permits one family detached dwelling provided that the dwelling is accessory farming or agricultural operations recreational uses for natural the home has no independent legal right this its occupancy is tied not to the physical character of the land, but to an unceasing, forever human activity. Reducing a home to an accessory tied to continuous use also creates a massive roadblock for future Ag Zone landowners trying to obtain a mortgage to establish a homestead. Conventional banking institutions are far less likely to finance a structure that can legally be stripped of its occupancy rights. When a dwelling is not permanent but instead traditional, the city has a legal right to terminate occupancy if the ongoing land use requirements can no longer be met. Then there is the human toll if the family with an approved agriculture or natural resource plan in place faces life cycle change. If an established AgZone resident suffers an illness or injury or simply grows too old to continue the activity required by their plan, the enforcement clause is triggered. When an owner can no longer maintain the primary operation, the dwelling loses its legal right to be occupied. And I quote, in no case shall any residence constructed under the provisions of this section continue to be occupied as a residence if the lot upon which the residence is constructed fails to meet the requirement. While the ordinance carefully avoids using the word eviction, stripping away the legal right to occupy an existing home is, in effect, a municipal eviction. Even if the city chooses to grant an exception, the resident has no legal recourse. Any exemption is granted solely at the pleasure of the city. Does Auburn wish to build a 10-year roadmap that perpetuates severe financing complexities today and effectively evicts elderly or ailing residents tomorrow just because life happens? Every AgZone resident who owned a home when the 1964 ordinance was enacted was safely grandfathered and protected. The city already grants them residential security. How, going forward, are you going to respond to those AgZone residents who were not grandfathered? Under Maine's Growth Management Act, the intent of rural zoning is land preservation, not continuous activity. State law defines rural areas by their need for protection from unrestricted development, preserving open space, forests, and wildlife habitats, and never requires continuous active use as a condition for living in a home. The 60-year sphere of suburban sprawl that has shaped every plan and ordinance since 1964 can be managed and controlled using the exact tools that have always been and remain in place. These include strict lot size minimums, open space standards, and subdivision vetting. Relying on these physical standards instead of active use protects our rural character without putting AgZone families' housing security at risk. Looking at the bigger picture for Auburn, I believe there is a simple, constructive way to adjust this in the draft plan. In the future land use section under Policy 2, the language could shift from tying homes to active land uses to instead allowing single-family dwellings and I quote that are compatible with preserving the physical rural condition such as open space forested acreage and working landscapes without conditioning residential occupancy on continuous active operations that single shift gift gives the city full authority to protect rural character as well as address sprawl to a variety of standards already mentioned, while giving working AgZone families permanent, not conditional, housing security. Before the December 7th reading, I urge the Council to take the necessary time to examine this 10-year roadmap and apply regulatory common sense. Because this plan will guide Auburn's zoning ordinance for the next decade, pausing now to review it with fresh eyes is critical before moving to final adoption. Please ensure that the final plan explicitly protects the non-grandfathered homes in the Ag Zone as a foundational anchor, rather than treating our families as tenants at will on their own land. [34:55] Jeff Harman: If there's any other member of the public who would like to address the council, please approach the podium and provide your name and address. [35:12] John Cleveland: Good evening. For the record, my name is John Cleveland. I reside at [address] in Auburn. I wanted to take just a few moments tonight to reflect on the November 3rd midterm elections in Auburn. i had the opportunity to observe all of the voting places several times during that day i really want to be here because i want to compliment our city clerk emily carrington and the members of her election team the city staff who helped with the preparations for the election the citizens who worked at the polls and everyone who took the time to vote that day or during the election this was really a record brain record-breaking election you may not know it but maine had the highest voter turnout in the nation at 65.78 percent so we once again were leading in auburn 10 571 eligible voters voted that was 67 percent of our registered voters who came out. Approximately 5,000 of those were able to vote by early or absentee ballots because of the very well coordinated and planned and implemented early voting process that Emily oversaw. This was actually a higher voter turnout than in the midterms in 2022, and it came very close, but not quite, to the turnout for the presidential election in 2024 so this was a very enthusiastic voter turnout and was well prepared for here in the city all citizens who were eligible to vote had the opportunity to vote in Auburn and there were no disruptions or intimidations or interference with voting at all at any of our voting places throughout the election and also, to the best of my knowledge, no one who was ineligible to vote voted in Auburn as well. I say this because this was a free and fair election, and it is critically important to understand that voting is the most important freedom of all the freedoms that we have in this country. country. It makes all of our other freedoms possible to happen. Well-run elections that people can trust are essential to the preservation of democracy, and that freedom happens in every municipality locally. It is under the Constitution that they're guided through the local municipality and we do a fantastic job here in auburn so i want to thank emily and her team for a fantastic job in this critical democracy process that we have thank you
Unfinished Business
[38:32] Jeff Harman: thank you for your comments if there's any other member of the public who'd like to address the council please approach the podium and provide your name and ad not seeing any the open sessions CLOSED. WE'LL MOVE ON TO UNFINISHED BUSINESS. THE FIRST ITEM IS ORDER 7709082026. BUSINESS LICENSE APPEAL HEARING FOR WEBSTER'S TRADING COMPANY AT 150 MINUTE AVENUE. THE REMINDER TO THE COUNCIL, THE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC, THIS IS AN ITEM THAT WAS PREVIOUSLY POSTPONED ON SEPTEMBER 8 AND ON OCTOBER 5. I WOULD DRAW THE COUNCIL'S ATTENTION TO THE MEMO IN THE packet from code enforcement director chris bowden mr bowden will provide us an update before we proceed you'll [39:27] Speaker N (unidentified): have to forgive me i'm not quite sure exactly where it is i'm i didn't see this and you know due to the outlook or the microsoft outage last week i wasn't sure it made it in chris i think it's page 41 of the packet all right so yeah i want to touch base on this memo that i wrote On Thursday the 12th, so I've been monitoring the property since the last council meeting just to see how work has been coming along. I've had really no communication with the property owner. He hasn't called for any inspection, so I can't confirm any level of repairs to the interior of the building. That being said, the exterior of the building still has violations. The level of completion isn't quite where we had expected it to be. based on the owners remarks the last council meeting right now violations of the ordinance still exist there were some changes today so the last notable work that I saw occur happened around the week of October 23rd nothing had occurred since up to my site visit on Thursday today it looked like there was some exterior work completed but again this work really wasn't enough to remove any of the violations that are at the property with that being said because the violations are at the property unfortunately staff does have to recommend denial of the license at this time however unless i am mistaken chapter 14 of the ordinance it doesn't prohibit reapplying once the corrections have been made are [41:30] Jeff Harman: there any questions to mr bowden regarding his report i'm not seeing any the motion that's on the table from the september 8th meeting was to adopt the order that's in the packet titled order 7709082026 6th it would seem based on this report that the appropriate course of action would be an amendment to the order that's on the floor to deny the business license is there a motion do [42:12] Sean Copeland: i get to say anything out of this i haven't seen this until right now [42:18] Jeff Harman: first of all we'll get the motion on the floor and then you're the property owner or the [42:24] Adam Platt: business owner the business owner i'll move to make the amendment to move this onto the floor i amend that we deny the business application i don't have the number of the order on the table but i make the motion to deny to open it up to discussion so the [42:43] Jeff Harman: motion is to amend the main motion amending order 7709082026 to deny the business license is there a second and by councillor gary if you could state your name and address [43:00] Sean Copeland: for the record sir sean copeland 150 minot avenue okay i this is the first time i've seen this right now there's a lot of work being done there they're almost done they've got 12 sheets to put up and they're done with the building and they're going to clean up the brick i don't know what you're seeing but i see it i'm there every day first of all second of all the rental business it does not say rental in the initial thing this has been here for 21 years this isn't new this isn't like a back room casino that you found and suddenly you know we can't have that this has been here for two decades out in plain sight you can't just shut that down and you reworded it doesn't now you've added the rental and lease for some reason that suddenly started showing up in all the emails the initial one says sales no outside sales of et cetera et cetera so the wording has changed to fit your needs this is just you know this is going to close my business down i take this very seriously i haven't done anything wrong i have a good business this. It's been in the community for two decades. It helps the people. I think there's more to this than just, you know, this isn't, has nothing to do with rentals. It has nothing to do with the building's condition, which I personally don't like the condition of the building, but they're working on it. And probably the other half is going to go away in the spring. But back to the matter is, I think this really has to do with the March 2024 when you guys were approved purchase of the building and then backed out because suddenly you didn't realize I was a tenant and you didn't want to deal with a tenant. And a year later, now there's a violation on the building. And you're coming up with this stuff. It's just going to put me out of business. And, you know, I'm going to have to do what I have to do at that point. That's not where I want to go. I'm trying to work with the city and stay in business. [45:15] Jeff Harman: I have a question. [45:20] Adam Platt: so I understand that perhaps there's some disagreement with the wording used to describe the budget operation. My question is, has the has the applicant attempted to apply with the planning board for that? I did [45:36] Sean Copeland: proper use. I did. I talked to Decarlo and. There was nothing that could be done at that level. By hammering down the or myself starts with you for that however again i don't think any of it really matters it's been there for 21 years this isn't new this is out in the open it serves the community and has been it's well known i don't know what else to say about it i don't to me this the common sense of it i'm just a farm boy i look at everything in common sense and i'm not seeing any common sense I'm not a lawyer, but I don't feel that I need to be a lawyer. I don't feel that I should have to hire a lawyer to tell you the same damn thing in different terminology, because it's common sense to me. This has been here an awful long time. [46:34] Jeff Harman: All right, Council Platt. To follow up on your point, there is a memo in the packet. at this question was posed to legal counsel and to summarize my understanding is that at the time that this business was authorized the rental leasing sales activity was not authorized in the site plan and the current zoning does not allow that activity so even if the applicant that the applicant was to apply to the planning board. Legal is opined that the planning board would have no authority to usage. [47:23] Adam Platt: But there would be a path through a zoning board of appeals, correct? If such a let me rephrase that. Would there be a pathway through the zoning board of appeals if the applicant was looking for some sort of variance? [47:38] Jeff Harman: No, the issue, my understanding of this, the issue here would be related to a determination, a site plan review by the planning board, so if an application was made to the planning board, the appeal process is an ADB to Superior Court, not to the Board of Appeals. board of appeals in Arbor and only hears appeals from direct action on land use from the staff okay other questions councillor Randolph can I ask [48:17] Speaker P (unidentified): the business owner through you when 21 years ago was there a rental where are you renting cars then no cars it's they're moving trucks so there's no licenses need for that for 21 years it's been doing that and now we can't so when did that change [48:36] Jeff Harman: thank you well my understanding from the information on the packet it was never authorized to begin with [48:47] Speaker K (unidentified): other point j sorry mr mayor just from the letter just page 48 it starts at page 48 summarizing that 2003 review and meeting of the Auburn Planning Board and item J there shall not be any outside storage or sale of cars or storage of storage boxes and or containers I think is what that's what I was connecting to the issue that's the first of the second sentence outside sword or sale of any motorized or non-motorized vehicles and trailers including but not limited to snowmobiles campers motorcycles boats trailers all-terrain vehicles are limited to designated areas to be shown on the revised plan and i think the issue is i understood it from what i was reading is that there was never a confirmed revised plan do [49:49] Speaker P (unidentified): you point to where it says rental on there i [49:55] Jeff Harman: i think i think councillor cowan's point here is in this site plan review at item j it's not necessarily the rental action storage of vehicles outside the building that was called out in the original site plan as not being allowable other questions IS THE COUNCIL READY FOR THE QUESTION? [50:29] Sean Copeland: I HAVE MORE TO SAY. GO AHEAD, SIR. OKAY. SO THESE ARE RENTALS AND NOT SALES. THEY COME AND GO. THEY'RE NOT STORED THERE. THEY COME AND GO. IN AND OUT. I DON'T OWN THEM, FIRST OF ALL. SECOND OF ALL, AS SHE WAS SAYING, THIS HAS BEEN HERE FOR 21 YEARS, AND YOU'RE SAYING NOW IT'S A PROBLEM. WELL, HOW HAS THIS NOT BEEN A PROBLEM FOR 21 YEARS AND suddenly, it's a problem. How is that? And there's a car dealership on the very same block as me, another one right across the street, and another one just on the other side. So even the sales thing doesn't really hold any water. We're all in the same zone. I have the zone right here. How is that? Even though this is not sales. But to me, it comes down to just the fact that this should be grandfathered in, if anything. it's but you have permitted it for all these years it was out in the open you can't like say I missed it I didn't know that you had rental trucks and now you're just trying to close me down is the way I look at I'm taking it very personal I think you're just trying to get something that you want and doing it in a well an underhanded way and I hate to say that but I really feel that's what's going on it just everything's right here it's 50 cent folder holds enough for me to you know i think legally have a case here but i don't want to go that route i just want to go to work and not worry about this anymore i'm tired and i have a good business that helps people on both ends of it [52:14] Jeff Harman: does that conclude your yes okay thank you any further questions or comments from the [52:20] Speaker K (unidentified): council cowell mr bowdoin was there can you remind us of a schedule that was set you know set aside the storage of the vehicles they are stored on your property whether they're coming and going they're still there they're parked they're left there for a while i see that as storage so we could debate that but regardless there's other issues that you had concerns about including not hearing from the business owner about the progress being made on the interior was there a set schedule that you were hoping to have heard by this time [52:53] Speaker N (unidentified): my understand my understanding from the property owner is that the work would have been completed by now at the initial council meeting he assured me that the work was going to start it was going to be completed it would be a quick job and then a follow-up question if i may it I went there on Thursday, sir. [53:14] Sean Copeland: Yeah, and the work's been going on. I mean, you cannot not see the work going on. It is going on. I don't understand why I haven't seen this yet. Why am I here? That's the second time you've had me sitting here going, oh, shit, where'd that come from? You are something else. [53:32] Jeff Harman: So if I could remind the council on the September 8th meeting the issue of a schedule. So at the September 8th meeting, the action was postponed until the next meeting to give the property owner, and I think everyone's sympathetic to the issue of the individual leasing part of the property for his business, but the issue here is that the ordinances is don't permit the ongoing business activity in buildings that do not meet code so in september this was postponed until october and in october the work had not been completed but there was more of a detailed plan and some work had begun i think the understanding was at the time that this work should be completed before this came before the council again in November so you know we have mr. Bowden's report I don't think there's any question that some work has been done there in the past and from time to time maybe work is ongoing but I think it's clear at this point that the building does not has not been repaired to the extent that the inspection can take place to determine if it meets code and it's still in a non-compliant status [55:06] Speaker K (unidentified): if that helps council account with the schedule it does thank you i think my final point is i appreciate you're trying to work with the city but as i read the communication here is that there hasn't been enough communication so if i'm to vote to continue the owner of the building [55:25] Sean Copeland: I can see all the work being done. I spoke to them three hours before I came here. They're almost done. I don't know. All I can do is ask them how the progress is, and I see what I see. But when is it done? I don't know. That's out of my hands. However, we all know that there's no threat to life and limb. And it's all about how it looks. The bricks are taken care of. the bricks that were going to fall down are down they can't fall down and hurt anybody so now they're putting siding up and they're almost done i don't know what to tell you i'm sorry [56:07] Speaker P (unidentified): i'd like to propose moving it postponing action for maybe 14 more days to see if they're that close to being done maybe we can get it complete and be able to give him his license okay can i [56:21] Adam Platt: make a comment relative that I not opposed to that my I guess what I'm kind of I don't say I'm tired of it 's our job to be up here and make these decisions but it seems like it just keeps getting kicked back to us to have to make this emotional decision of if we're gonna be the good guy or the bad guy and I'm it's it's this is an objective decision it's black or white I don't I don't think it should be an emotional one my question is could we are we allowed to grant a business license with conditions can we grant a license that says if this building is not to code by January 1st the business licenses rescinded because what I would love to do is leave this between the tenant and the landlord I feel like that is the reasonable way to deal with this issue I don't know the landlord I don't know the tenant I am I am empathetic to the predicament that the tenant is in i also understand we have a duty to enforce the objective rules of this body and of this city i feel like that move would buy them more time and then it's on them they can decide if they will be in communication the tenant can decide if he wants to hold his landlord's feet to the fire that's my thought yeah so i would defer [57:37] Jeff Harman: to the clerk but i would bring your attention to the original order 7709082026 and the way that this first came before the council in september was that the license activity has to cease until the repairs were made and that was item number one the building must be repaired in accordance with the notice of violation issued in march 24 2025 and item two is the owner must remove all truck rentals from the property or obtain an amendment approval from the planning board of course we've since received opinion from legal counsel that absent an actual change in the zoning ordinance that lies in that zoning district that the approval for the rental trucks couldn't take place so I think the council has two potential courses of action one the amendment that's on the floor to deny the business license if the council believes that given the amount of time that's gone by and the building not being up to code they would deny the business license then the majority if the majority votes yes then the that will be denied if the if the majority does not vote to deny the license i think the second course of action would be go back to something similar to the original ordinance excuse me the original order we would amend that because either way the truck rental vehicles have to be removed that they're without the council changing the district regulation that's not allowable and we could go back to that 's indeterminate the license activity at this site has to stop until the buildings are paid if they're almost finished and the buildings were paid tomorrow or a week from now then the applicant come in to the city clerk and if code enforcement says the building has passed code the clerk will issue the building license at that time I don't think the council should consider taking some type of a formal action to allow license activity to take place in violation of ordinance any thoughts on the council from for that council sadly i agree and i [1:00:25] Speaker K (unidentified): appreciate that the situation you're in i did not realize the owner is the one that's holding this stuff up but i think there's precedent well there's also the budget issue which to me is a [1:00:36] Sean Copeland: bigger issue than the building the budget issue is a real serious issue the budget rental budget rental is a serious issue I don't believe you can take that away after all these years it's it's it was blatant there it is it's blatant and all of a sudden it's a problem where I can't have it 's not grandfathered I can't do that business there but there's a new car dealership there's another car dealership you know all this I'm not even a dealership and as far as I'm gonna slip for a second here you just stated that the work was supposed to stop on September 9th for that no that was not the case I don't remember who it was that asked I think it was you that asked it can he continue to do his business until and the answer was yes I remember that clearly so just so you know though I didn't need to see just to clarify [1:01:36] Jeff Harman: that is correct and I think that would still be the answer if there was a general postponement but if the council is going to enact the order then I think it's a different construct and the license activity would need to cease pending the completion of code violence why [1:02:03] Speaker P (unidentified): can't we take up something like what adam has had suggested because [1:02:08] Adam Platt: we'd sound like we'd be in breach of our own ordinance if we allowed licensed activity which you know i don't know what the repercussions of that are but i would imagine they're it's not the precedent we're looking to set to answer the mayor's original question i listen i'm i'm again to me it's a black or white i mean the building is not in code the business is not i mean i haven't been on this council for 20 years so i can only see what i've seen over the last two or three then the business is not in code sorry is not in compliance that said i would i would vote against the denial and try to find a path forward that keeps us in compliance with our own ordinances even if that is not allowing license activity until the building is brought into code but i don't know if that answer is your question mr mayor but that's what i would be inclined that i would be inclined to follow that pathway it's not perfect for the applicant but i think it's it's i think it's [1:03:12] Sean Copeland: the best we can do without breaking our own laws can i ask does that mean like stop business as of now is that what that how i understand that well we haven't quite got time no i'm just saying if that was the case if that was what is that what you're saying there will when [1:03:31] Jeff Harman: we get to that point we'll fully explain what this would be but we're not in [1:03:35] Sean Copeland: layman's terms so like the layman's turn I appreciate we're not quite to that [1:03:39] Jeff Harman: point are there any more thoughts or questions from the council [1:03:43] Speaker K (unidentified): count yeah just to follow up on counselors Platt's comments I agree I think we would be doing the city a disservice if we tried to vote in on this particular order in some way that was to try to find an exemption I don't I'm not seeing a path out of that and they welcome clarification on that but to me it's where we're that the order as presented we're either voting to deny I the license or we're voting against the order the amended amendment of the order to allow it to go and then we're in violation of our ordinance I think there's also much more complex issues at least as I'm seeing it with only a few years of experience here is the issue of the rentals the truck rentals it is not allowed in the zone that it's in right now as I understand it and so I think that 's a whole nother step in terms of if I'm thinking of this correctly if we were to make some kind of exception I think that's a separate motion separate step that would need to be prepared maybe I'm [1:04:59] Jeff Harman: incorrect on that but yeah to clarify I think as I understand a memo from legal the district regulation the district zoning regulations and that district do not allow that activity and in order for that to be authorized the council would need to modify we need to do a text amendment we need to modify the underlying district regulation so the councilor collins point it would be a separate action and it would be an action that like other district zoning regulations that the council could transmit a request to the planning board to review and recommend such an action but as we sit here tonight the council has no direct path to take an action to modify the district regulation other questions or comments yes we'll just i have a question please so the item that's before the council now is a motion to amend, which is to deny the business license. So if your intent is to deny the business license, you'll be voting yes. If your intent is not to deny the business license, you'll be voting no. If the nays prevail, the business license will be denied and we'll have completed the action on this item. them if the nays prevail we will then consider further motion and alignment some of the discussion that council plat started so is the council ready for the question vote be by show of hands all those in favor opposed seven having voted in the affirmative and none in the negative the motion fails excuse me did I say it opposite? Okay, well, thank you. None having voted in the affirmative and seven in the negative, the motion fails. Okay, so the question then is how does the council want to proceed? We can proceed in a similar fashion to the order that was before our September 8th meeting and that was postponed into October and tonight, the building would need to be removed. The license activity would have to cease until the business license is issued. The business license would be issued when the building came up to code and the rental truck would need to be removed. So thoughts on that? [1:07:54] Adam Platt: I mean, barring some, and I'll just speak it in plain language barring some legal advice or some admission that the city has granted grandfathered businesses like this in the past I don't think we have but if that's been a common practice of ours we could consider it for this gentleman but I don't believe it is and I don't believe I've ever seen anything suggesting that it is and so not having that information I would support the current order as it's as it's presented I'd be curious if that's a conversation we can have if there's precedent behind grandfathering and businesses that have been operating out of zoning ordinance for decades but again if that doesn't exist I 'm not willing to make that exception for the first time ever today well I understand actually we would not be making that exception today it would be a different action but i'd be open to that conversation i think i know the answer so yeah i defer to the manager of the clerk if there's [1:09:01] Jeff Harman: past history of this but the reading of the memo from legal would suggest that the activity was never authorized and the planning board has no authority to authorize it at this time and I'm not aware of whether the city has in some way either administratively or through the council allowed license activity to take place when there were licensed violations that were not remedied I [1:09:39] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager): would just start with there was action that was taken probably in 2017 where the city council chose to take their own authority to give somebody an exemption to a current order. And a legal came back, it had to do with hunting. Legal came back and said, Council, you do not have that legal authority to take that action. You have other means. that action was not allowable option for the council and so I would advise the council taking that type of action and I think just for history for the council to you know there's so many different moving pieces with this property you have the license that was approved in 2003 was a different business owner than who's sitting in front of it and then you have a property owner that is as a building that's not in compliance with what needs to take place regarding the code issues for that facility which is separate from the person so you do have multiple layers with this situation and that makes this more challenging but ultimately i think as was just shared by the current is that for his business from what i'm hearing is that operation of that budget rental operation within the organization is critical to his business there's there is no path as the council sitting here to go ahead and grant a license when that's not in compliance and so that's that's your challenge as a council and then you also have the separate issue which is regarding the building not meeting the code issue at this time it doesn't prevent you from doing exactly what you did in the previous meeting there a lot you can you can move that and ultimately though you're gonna be back at this position so you're going to be back in this position where you're going to make a decision regarding this license as it pertains to even if the building comes into compliance you're still going to have the issue as it pertains to the budget rental culture [1:12:20] Jeff Harman: where [1:12:21] Speaker P (unidentified): i'm running into an issue of understanding what's going on here is that this gentleman's been able to run this business with the budget rental whether it was in compliance or not he has been able to and i'm wondering why now it's an issue is it because he came up where the building is not compliant and so it came up and now everything is being thrown into the bucket or has this been an issue long term because it doesn't sound to me like it was an issue before [1:12:48] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager): this we'd have to get that information for you i'm i'm not friendly so i'm not sure but i think that if the council so chooses you could provide an additional 30 days to get the information that you're looking for based on what we're hearing today allows for the continuation of that building repairs and we can provide you some more just [1:13:18] Jeff Harman: to be clear that is an option but if 30 days from now we come back and that history is provided the City Council has no authority to do anything about that right the district regulations of the district regulations and it's it's admit the business owner may have some avenue to object to that action but the council will have no authority any more what 30 days from now than it does tonight to tell someone they can violate a district zoning regulation and have an unauthorized use on that I would [1:14:09] Speaker P (unidentified): be happy to sit here and do this again in 30 days if it meant that I got proof that we didn't know he was running a budget rental I mean for some reason he was allowed to run the budget rental and now all of a sudden he cannot and I would like to wait for that before voting to take his license away so the question i would raise [1:14:27] Jeff Harman: council randall is 30 days from now i think i 'm in the same position the manager is i don't have the information in front of me but there have been discussions in the past about the budget rental truck so let's say best case scenario for the owner of the building the report 30 days from now is no one ever noticed, no one ever did anything. The council still have no authority to take any action other than to tell the person that they cannot have an unauthorized use, something that violates the district regulation. In order, according to the memo from legal, the only path forward to allow that budget would be that the district regulation that applies to that parcel and many other parcels in the city would have to go through the regular zoning process to have a text amendment made which is not something that's going to happen [1:15:41] Adam Platt: within 30 days. Council Platt. Thank you. I would also support another 30-day punt. I hate to say this feels incredibly sloppy on our part. I don't like it But I would do it for different reasons than councilor Randall and I just want to state those I would do it because it gives this gentleman 30 days to figure this out if we are back here in 30 days Regardless of what evidence what information it doesn't change anything. We can't authorize budget car rental on that parcel and so I Am open to punting at 30 days it gives you 30 days to figure this out but in 30 days there's no discussion there's nothing to discuss I mean I think what I've learned is that unfortunately our hands are tied this is a this is a one of our judiciary actions where we have to make a decision based on the laws not based on our emotional feelings so I would support another 30-day postponement but again to state it in plain language, it's to give this gentleman 30 days to figure out what to do with the budget part of his business, relocate it, whatever it may be. Perhaps you do have a legal path forward that we don't know about. I don't know that, but it's one step better than pulling his license tonight. It gives him a fighting chance, but I agree with you, Mr. Mayor, we're back here in 30 days. There's nothing to talk about. Either the building's decode and budget's off the building or it's not and if it's not there's no license so that's that's where i would [1:17:14] Brennan Geary: stand other questions council gary thank you mr mayor could he go through the planning board for a change of the ordinances to allow the business there i mean go there present the case and then they can come back and decide whether it's allowable or not so there's any under the [1:17:37] Jeff Harman: ordinances there's three methods by which a text amendment to a district zoning regulation could be made one is a 25 person petition that's the avenue for this business owner they could come into planning they could get the petition they would have to get 25 registered voters to sign the petition and that would bring the matter in front of the planning board the other two methods is the Planning Board of their own volition could take up a district zoning regulation change or the City Council could through a referral to committee action could refer to the Planning Board a suggested change to the district regulation for the Planning Board review and recommendation all three of these methods would end up back at the City Council for action after the Planning Board has reviewed the proposed change it's whether it's consistent with the comprehensive plan or not and whether the Planning Board would recommend for that district regulation the change of you thank [1:18:54] Rachel Randall: you Council DeWolf. Yeah, I just, I wanna comment. I appreciate the situation you find yourself in. I find myself agreeing with Councilor Platts and his proposed solution here is one that I would accept. [1:19:09] Speaker K (unidentified): Council Cowell. I too, and I'm sorry you're in this predicament. I just wanna add one other layer into this is that the 30 days does give the owner of the building it needs to be in compliance you know that's the other piece that i just want to state here out loud that it's it gives you time to think about how are there other options for the budget rental and where we might need to go because changing that i think is going to be well beyond 30 days so you know it gives you some time to plan but it also means that the owner of that building needs to get it in compliance or i cannot vote to permit you your license I do support your proposed approach, thank you, Councilor Platts. [1:20:01] Jeff Harman: Councilor Angel, did you have something further? Any other questions from the council? Councilor Platts, would you like to? I believe the motion would be to postpone to the December 21st regular meeting. [1:20:17] Adam Platt: Is that an amendment or just a motion? [1:20:18] Jeff Harman: It would be a motion to postpone. [1:20:20] Adam Platt: so I would make a motion to postpone this for 30 days whatever that date may [1:20:25] Jeff Harman: be that's my motion yeah just so just to clarify the motion is to postpone this item until the December 21st regular City Council yeah and I and this might [1:20:37] Adam Platt: be out of place but I would just add I mean it I hate to say this but now it's on it's on you I don't know what the agreement is with your landlord but I'd [1:20:44] Sean Copeland: I'd read those lease document I'm confident the building is gonna be done Great. I've seen the progress and I did talk to him today. Great. The budget thing is kind of a
New Business
[1:20:54] Jeff Harman: Wait, we have motion. Is there a second? The vote will be by show of hands all those in favor Pose seven having voted affirmative and none in the negative this item is postponed until the December 21st regular City Council thank you we'll move on to new business the next item is ordinance 1911162026 amending chapter 60 zoning of the city's code of zoning regarding waivers and vacancies this will be for first reading your call from some prior discussion at workshop and from the packet This is an item brought before the council by the planning director. Mr. Brown is here. He can answer any questions that you might have on this. This change is being made on the recommendation of planning and legal to conform with some recent Maine Supreme Court rulings to ensure that the city zoning language regarding waivers and variances conforms to the rules. is there a motion so moved is there a second [1:22:13] Speaker K (unidentified): i think i heard you at the same time [1:22:16] Jeff Harman: yeah so moved by council platt seconded by council cowan if there's any member of the public who'd like to address the council on this item please approach the podium and provide your name and address not seeing any public comment will be closed discussion by the council platt yes [1:22:35] Adam Platt: thank you i had a question for mr brown i did some research on this and i kind of wanted to understand what state ruling this came from so i read a little bit about i assume this is andrews versus kittery is that the ruling that's kind of influencing some of this language so one thing i wanted to bring up was in the proposed language here it's it's very binary waivers that are allowable by planning board and certain things that are not one thing i found in the andrews versus kittery ruling that we don't address here and we might not need to but it references the ability for planning boards to grant waivers based on zoning specific subdivisions whereas those are allowable planning board can make waivers for subdivisions that are zone specific but our language here doesn't seem to allow for that unless subdivision language in auburn is not zone specific does that make sense our this language would I believe would not allow planning boards to grant waivers based on subdivision rules and so I was just curious if this is if what we're proposing is a bit tighter than what the state has the state's courts have ruled I'd be curious just what your [1:23:57] Carla Brown: thoughts are on that absolutely thank you for having me my name is to Carla brown your planning director and so in the case that you're referring to they bring that subdivision can be within your ordinance or separate in regulations and what the ruling basically says is that in this case it was a subdivision and subdivision isn't zone specific in its provision zoning is and so we'll talk about setbacks and you can talk about lot coverage and things like that and those are stone specific regulations and in this instance the case was about in any subdivision in any zone you have standards here and because they're not zone specific that board could give waivers now in our ordinance here we give a more blanket ability to waive things that are not zone specific and so it would cover our subdivision regulations as long as is a certain provision isn't zone specific. So to get directly to your account, it is taken into that into the account and that's something that we spoke directly with our legal representation with. [1:25:09] Adam Platt: So is it safe to say that our language is no more or less restrictive than the state's intention? Correct, yes. That's really what I wanted to make sure of. Absolutely. [1:25:19] Jeff Harman: Other questions from the council? Council, ready for the question? Vote will be by roll call. The clerk will call the roll. [1:25:27] Speaker P (unidentified): Councillor Duvall. Yes [1:25:30] Kelly Butler: Councillor Butler. Yes [1:25:32] Brennan Geary: Councillor Walker. Yes. Councillor Platts. Yes. Councillor Geary. Yes. Councillor Randall. Yes. Councillor Cowan. Yes [1:25:39] Jeff Harman: Seven having voted in the affirmative and none of the negatives the motion is adopted at first reading The next item is a public hearing for the consolidated annual performance report turn your attention in the packet to the this is the annual cdbg home consolidated annual performance evaluation report for the program year 2025. staff is here if counselors have any particular questions on the report but the main purpose of the item is to provide an opportunity for public hearing regarding the report before it's final so there any questions from account miss Longley is here hi [1:26:34] Speaker P (unidentified): so there's about what three point two million dollars in home funding being reported is that correct that sounds about right I don't have the numbers right in front of me how much is already committed to projects and are their deadlines with the remaining funds I do not know if those numbers with me [1:26:54] Jeff Harman: today I might point out why mr. Holmes is coming to the table remind the council that the CDBG program is focused solely on Auburn the home program is a consolidated program where Auburn is the administrator of the home program for [1:27:14] Kelly Butler: both lewiston and auburn mr home as far as committed the council has not committed any funds there's a budget that's approved that allows for about a million dollars currently in auburn potentially for the home program for the home for good program that has been worked on for the last year and a half that will be coming as soon as that application is received by the developer and as far as how old the money is there's about a half a million dollars it comes in per year so therefore several years get saved up to be able to get to a project size amount [1:27:50] Jeff Harman: other questions from the council representative [1:27:57] Unidentified speaker (Student Representative): edward okay so i just have two questions just talking a little bit more about how this is helping students so to start how does the city evaluate the impact of housing and like move these funds to help with financial hardship on children and students in auburn and how are those needs reflected in the city's community development housing priorities [1:28:18] Kelly Butler: so every year we do a survey those postcards go out we some years we get three four five hundred back some years we get back a hundred all those things are put into the matrix when we look at student stuff it historically has not been really high obviously we're mailing these two households so probably the students aren't the ones filling those out so I would love to have any input from youth how we could get to people in the schools more effectively in the coming year because i think it'd be a great idea what we do though is if you look at the whole community development programming it's focused on mostly families with children we have put money into a lot of programming when it comes to like scholarships for day camp in the summer for younger kids things like that and our public health officer work does a lot of work with the program Almost we can event I can't even do Group and we tried to support that we've paid for kids to be in different schools because of what they move too often So we help with programs like that [1:29:36] Jeff Harman: further comments or questions [1:29:38] Speaker K (unidentified): I just a follow-up for representative Edwards the homelessness committee, the McKinney-Vento representative sits on that committee as a staff liaison and public is welcome, so you would be in school at the time of the meetings, but if you have any comments that you wanted to prepare as yourself or as a group of students and have Sasha or, you know, we can present that on your behalf and then maybe we even schedule special meetings to learn from that because the goal of that committee is to help coordinate advocate monitor the issues and then we can work with our staff on that so we'd love to have participation in some way so happy to talk with you about that further [1:30:28] Jeff Harman: comments by the questions by the council if not we'll open the public hearing if any member of the public would like to address the council regarding the consolidated annual performance report please approach the podium and provide your name and address Good [1:30:50] John Cleveland: evening, Mr. Mayor, and members of City Council. For the record, my name is John Cleveland. I'm still residing at [address] in Auburn. I took the opportunity to read the 33-page report from beginning to end. Frankly, it was a little bit difficult to read because it's written in bureaucratic language. But having said that, I managed to get through the end of it. i think it's important to note that there are actually some noteworthy process progress that's been made here which is not intuitively clear being made in the report so i dug it out for you one of them is that the auburn resource center has continued to be developed and put in and it's been used as a centralized location to provide services for a variety of nonprofit organizations that provide services to those in need, homeless individuals, and the like. That's a big step forward and should be noted clearly. Within that resource center is the drop-in center, which provides extensive services as the homeless individuals providing them meals and showers and survival gear and clothing and the like that's really a benefit to folks who are homeless as well and we should be noted that three years old years ago that didn't exist as a municipal source so that's a big step forward as well also it notes that it does coordinate with the urban housing authority and with the lewiston shelter and trying to provide additional resources and alternatives for housing or people get them into more stable housing and it also supports the pal center which really services a lot of lower income children in this community providing them with critical services as well not fully for all of the students but those are important things that have been accomplished going forward so I wanted to note them but I also like to make a suggestion my suggestion is there's really been there's really an opportunity here to be very clear to make a clear and concise statement of what the total need in this community is for those who are really suffering and low income it doesn't make that case well at all in this report nor does it suggest how much the unmet need is that is how much more do we need to do going forward in the future and over what period of time would nothing necessary make more progress as we've had in the past and what needs to be done to do that I think it's a missed opportunity it's unfortunate you know a lot of work and effort went into this report and I congratulate them for putting in the work but this is an opportunity to inform all of you as policymakers on what is the problem What is the extent of the problem? How are we meeting it? What more do we need to do? We missed that opportunity in this report and Equally important we need to keep the public informed if we don't provide information on what these needs are then when you have to go through difficult decisions in the budget, there's not a Platform or basis on which to say we're addressing these kinds of needs. This is what the reports indicated there are this is why we're making the decisions we are so overall congratulations on the report and I hope the next annual report might follow up on some of my suggestions thank [1:34:36] Jeff Harman: you for your comments if there's any other member of the public who'd like to address the council on this issue please approach the podium and provide your name and address not seeing any the public hearing is closed move on to the next item which is order nine three one six two zero two six adopting a heating assistance program the turn the council's attention to the packet and you were called from the workshop the item would appropriate sixty thousand five hundred dollars from the undesignated fund balance to fund the proposed heating assistance program and the community development team under mr. Holmes has provided the documentation with the qualification criteria for the program is there a motion I'll move by Councillor Geary is there a second seconded by Councillor Randall any member of the public would like to address the council on this item please approach the podium and provide your name and address not see any public comment will be closed discussion by the council [1:35:54] Brennan Geary: Council Gary? I'm supporting it wholeheartedly. [1:36:00] Jeff Harman: Council, ready for the question? Representative Edwards. [1:36:03] Unidentified speaker (Student Representative): Sorry, back again. As a student representative, I'd like to just take a moment to speak in support of the proposed heating assistance program and the impact it can have on students and families across Auburn. When we talk about the cost of heating a home, we tend to focus on the financial impact as adults and homeowners. I think it's just as important to bear in the mind and the impact that it has on children and students. A student's ability to succeed in school doesn't start and end in the classroom, it starts at home. Having a warm, safe, and stable place to sleep, to study, and to be with family is key to a student's physical health, their mental health, their attendance, and their ability to concentrate at school. When families are in positions where they're struggling to afford the basics, heating being the most obvious example, the stress doesn't just stay with the adults, The kids feel it too. It can lead to anxiety, it can be a distraction, it can be a source of uncertainty, and that can in turn make it very difficult for a child to concentrate at school, to get involved in things they should be getting involved in, and to just be a kid. No child should have to be in any doubt whatsoever as to whether their home will be warm when they get home from school, or whether their family will have to make the choice between heating the house and paying for other things. programs like this are predict yeah predicted on the notion that supporting our community means supporting the whole family it also recognizes that investment in families today is an investment in our students our schools and the future of Auburn I really do appreciate the City Council taking this program seriously and their commitment to looking after the residents of Auburn who may be in a bit and in need of a bit of extra assistance during the coldest months of the year thank you thank [1:37:44] Jeff Harman: you for your comment any other comments or questions by the council ready for the question vote will be by show of hands all those in favor seven having voted in the affirmative and none in the negative the motion is adopted [1:37:58] Brennan Geary: excuse me mr mayor yes i just got a text message that my ride is coming earlier than quarter [1:38:08] Jeff Harman: of quarter of nine i mean yeah quarter of nine yeah then let's take this out of all do you do you have anything to report okay great thank you sorry [1:38:25] Brennan Geary: the van that we're using on thanksgiving day to bring those that need to have a lift or i'm sorry i'm not good under tutu pressure in other words the city is through the rec department and age-friendly they're going to provide transportation that those that can't need it those that possibly are in a chair or needed help with walkers and those that cannot climb [1:38:52] Jeff Harman: onto a regular bus great thank you very much so we'll continue on with reports I won't repeat mr. Cleveland gave some excellent overview of the election I won't repeat that but i do want to thank the clerk they do a really great job if anyone ever goes behind the scenes this is an election like this is a massive amount of work and it takes many weeks to prepare and as i told the clerk the morning after the election i was at a election night event when he sent me Auburn results and I had two mayors from larger cities come up to me and wanted to know how our clerk did that because we announced the Auburn results and they called back and their clerk said well in a couple hours we'll have the information for you so they run a very efficient operation and we're really thankful for the great work and the clerk's office and all the volunteers do a few other items from this week free word G and baldachi there was a ribbon cutting there at 186 Main Street that people were called that's the new mixed-use facility with we had a opening earlier for the housing piece and we got a tour very nice facility on the comp plan the comp plan committee reconvened for their final meeting on november 5th and they provided their insight on the public comments and the planning board's recommendations the city council took those up on the 9th for the public the next comp plan action will be on december 7th at first reading where the council will get the draft plan and from that came out of the workshop and the again the planning board documentation of their recommendation we had a great ribbon cutting at the new greenhouse at edward little high school counselor Cowan and I went it wasn't what I expected I thought this was going to be some like you know 12 by 8 greenhouse and this is a really great facility it's going to be a great opportunity for students at EL to get involved you know lots of kids have no opportunity to get involved in growing anything so we really look forward to that I want to thank the Lewiston-Auburn veterans council for hosting the veterans day event over just across the river in veterans park very well attended and it was a great opportunity to thank our veterans i appreciate that council walker attended with us to that event i attended an update State, hosted by Wynne Brown, who's the CEO of St. Mary's Hospital, updates on activity going on there, and was very encouraged by their ongoing plans to build out their behavioral health capability, especially in the area of mental health and substance abuse. I think the work they're doing there is going to be very beneficial going forward for the community. community. The second Minot Avenue revitalization workshop took place. We saw some draft plans put together by our planning office and Barry Dunn, who's the contractor, the consultant on that job, gathered feedback and they will be shortly posting some updated plans. Those plans will then be coordinated with the current Minot Avenue and Court Street transportation plans. And lastly, the Winter Farmers Market, the first session is this Thursday night at four o'clock to 7 p.m. at Edward Little High School. So you'd be a number of farmers, bakers, and all kinds of things available for you there with that counselor in thank [1:43:29] Speaker P (unidentified): you first I'd like to say thank you to Owen and Brennan for taking the time and the thought that you put into your comments tonight I think it's great to see you guys speak up in these more in these meetings and become it's like you're at the table with us you're you're standing up for people who don't have a vote but are going to live with the consequences or benefits with you know either positive or negative consequences of how we vote and I think it's great to see you guys taking part in this and secondly I just want to I want to congratulate the Auburn Public Library on receiving the 2026 health healthy Andrus Goggin partnership award the library of things and wellness programs help make health and recreational resources more accessible to our community and I think all of the library staff for all that they do and [1:44:22] Jeff Harman: that's all I have great Thank You councillor Cowell Thank You mr. mayor [1:44:26] Speaker K (unidentified): homelessness committee meets tomorrow 930 to 11 the primary discussion is germane to mr. Cleavon's comments and that is the annual point in time or pit count, as it's often referred to. We're planning further ahead. We're working with regional resources to ensure that we can do even better than we did last year, which was an improvement over previous years. But there's some gaps that we recognize. And so we'll keep you posted on that. But that certainly goes to the issues that we have in terms of the number of people who are out on the street and looking at the needs assessment the pit count will be happening in January but it's never too early to start planning Thank You [1:45:19] Rachel Randall: council dwell yeah the just one quick update the appointments committee met this afternoon we have a suite of expiring terms coming up most notably on the 9-1-1, Lewis and Auburn 9-1-1 Committee and on the Planning Board. So if you're interested, put in your application. More critically, in the vacancy department, we have vacancies on the Board of Assessment Review. That board at the moment, I believe, is not able to make quorum. So if you have any interest at all, I think there's a good opportunity there, particularly with assessment and revaluation coming on this board will probably see a fair amount of action and they need quorum in order to do so thank [1:46:12] Tim Cowan: you the parking and traffic safety committee meets this Wednesday at 3 o'clock here at City Hall and the Lewiston Auburn Lewiston Airport committee will be meeting also on Wednesday at 530 and the Lewiston auburn 9-1-1 committee will be meeting thursday at 8 a.m thank you council walker thank you [1:46:40] Speaker T (unidentified): i have three things one is the neighborhood watch meeting has been moved to november 19th because of thanksgiving so those of you that are listening november 19th will be at six o'clock at the church and on 6th Street. The second thing is the age-friendly is doing a Thanksgiving dinner on Thanksgiving Day. Right now we've got just about a hundred people signed up. The doors open at 10, we will serve at 12 o'clock and we will have all the fixings so please show up. The last thing is November 28th United New Auburn Association will do the new Auburn tree lighting at the anniversary park. This year we have got a few special things happening. Walton School, Sherwood Heights School chorus kids will be singing from 5 o'clock to the time that Santa will come to light the trees so you're all welcome to come and join with us we'll have hot chocolate and we'll have some other goodies that night so six o'clock the tree lighting five o'clock the chorus from the elementary schools in new auburn and i think that'll be a great night to kick off the holidays so please come on out with us and [1:48:08] Adam Platt: and welcome everybody thank you council platt thank you a couple announcements on wednesday the 18th is the next school committee meeting on the agenda is discussion on the budget calendar for next year's budget cycle for the school department it's always a good thing for us to kind of understand what's going on the school side any of the counselors can come to me if you've got specific thoughts or questions that you'd like me to ask I for one will be particularly interested in the school's budgetary plan for the AMS project as we know we've been talking about the bonds related to that there are obviously costs associated with this potential transition so that's something that I will be poking into and asking lots of questions about so if you guys have any other questions regarding that or anything please just let me know throughout the process but you can go to the agenda for this week and there's a calendar showing the budget calendar for the school so good for us to all internalize that schedule next i wanted to just make a comment representative edwards heating assistance comment i did bring that up specifically at the last school board meeting to let them know that was something we deliberated i will announce on wednesday in my comments that it's something that we passed I urged all administrators principals to know that this program exists because to Brennan's point there are lots of students out there who have needs when it comes to heating and this is a program obviously that they need to know about lastly tomorrow night at 6 p.m. the conservation working group will meet here in the breakout room and I only bring this up because there's a particularly interesting agenda item him tomorrow and we'll be sitting down with eric cousins to learn more about the allocation for the little field damn grant monies and how that progress is going it's it's been a long ongoing process but the conservation working group is particularly interested to learn about where those monies are going and to learn about additional ways that they can be supportive of the process that's all i've got thank you thank you representative edward okay bear with me [1:50:26] Unidentified speaker (Student Representative): It's our busiest time of year. Edward Little was proud to host the state field hockey championships for all classes, the eight-man football state championships, the Class C boys' soccer regional finals. Posting these events allowed us to showcase our beautiful facilities to the community while raising money for Edward Little Athletics and the overall school. This week, the Unified Eddies, a club designed to bring together students in special education and the wider school community, is hosting a gratitude wall. and as winter sports get underway we are excited to welcome our eddies back to Norway Savings Bank arena and the Edward little gymnasium for another season lastly we have 194 days until graduation thank [1:51:05] Jeff Harman: you representative Robinson so [1:51:08] Owen Robinson: Edward little also recently hosted its annual craft fair welcoming community members into our school and bringing everyone together for a day of creativity and local shopping as Thanksgiving approaches Edward little students are getting ready for a well-deserved break the break begins with a half day on tuesday and continues through the following sunday so pretty different than what we normally do and we hope everyone has a wonderful thanksgiving great thank [1:51:34] Speaker K (unidentified): you council colin you have something else thank you mr mayor not nearly as fun as the events happening at the high school it's really great to have you guys here i forgot to mention this thursday the lewis and auburn transit committee had to reschedule the point meeting it's this Thursday at noon and it will be here at the community room. [1:51:56] Unidentified speaker (likely City Manager): Mr. Manager. Thank you, Mayor. Just a couple items. First, related to Casella's app regarding our solid waste and recycling. Feedback that we had received was many did not want to download an additional app, and so we worked with Casella and our IT to embed this within our website that work is now complete so if you were to go to the city's website under automated collection you'll find the waste wizard that basically allows you to search I have this item how can I recycle what's the what could be done and how do I dispose of it so that information will be right there on the website as well as if you put your address in it will also provide you the calendar for collection and then there's an additional link for if you need help and information will get back to you so I know we had reported on that before trying to make that accessible to individuals who did not want to download the app and so that's now available last item I have is the Hilton holiday hangout is tomorrow at 4 p.m. to 7 p.m. the Hilton Garden in and in the city of Auburn bringing together about 35 local makers and vendors as we kick off the holiday season it's a great event there'll be live music there's food and refreshments to encourage people to come and support [1:53:32] Jeff Harman: local makers thank you thank you very much we'll move on to the second open session of the evening if there's any member of the public would like to address the council relative to items not on tonight's agenda please approach the podium and provide you name and address not seeing any the open sessions closed there's no executive session this evening is there a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second so walker seconded by councillor platts vote by show of hands all those in favor the council will be adjourned.