← Back to MaineScanner

Auburn Planning Board approves hospital and dance center projects, rejects zoning change

2026-11-10 · 2h 6m · Source: City of Auburn, Maine, Planning Board Meeting, November 10, 2026 (City of Auburn / Great Falls TV (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Chair: enough collection of people here to approve the minutes. Let's look at the draft minutes of October 13th. Any questions or comments on those? Not take a motion. Move for approval. Second. Seconded. All in favor of that approval? That's unanimous. We also have in our packet minutes of the comprehensive plan committee and planning board public hearing. Are these minutes that we need to vote upon? Or it was a. That's really a comprehensive plan committee meeting. I'm not. Planning board meeting. [0:45] Speaker B (unidentified): There was a quorum of the planning board there. So that's, it was a quorum with the planning board there. So best practices to also. [0:52] Chair: reported all right have people had a chance to review those minutes and if so could I have a motion to approve seconded then moved and seconded any discussion all in favor again that's unanimous thank you very much item number three oh before I move on with it with the agreement of the board if it's all right I'll ask if there are any members of the audience who are here on a matter that's not on the agenda in other words here for a public comment usually wait till the end of the meeting and we'll take it up again at the end of the meeting but if anybody is here to comment on something not on our agenda and wants to do it now have the opportunity to go home and see the Celtics and Sixers you can do that anybody no takers okay all right next item three item three older continued business public hearing site plan amendment special exception 220 Danville Corner Road. Application submitted by Platts Associates on behalf of Recovery Connections of Maine to change the use of the property at 220 Danville Corner Road from education to hospital. The property is located in the General Business District and will be reviewed under chapter 60, article 16, division two, site plan review, and division three, special exception. [2:38] Travis Netto: yeah hello my name is Travis Netto I'm with Platts Associates Architects here to talk about the hospital we're talking about here the project's been in there a few times so I'll kind of skip through a few of the details just scribe an existing building the site improvements include a sewer line insulation to eliminate the need for a septic system reliance on the property that work's been done today I drove by on the way here and looks like they're out of the street at least and up by the Building we're also going to have an enclosure on the dumpster screening for that and some curving along the parking area and the building's existing building two stories it's got elevator access, sprinkler system, fire alarm, everything's good, work in order. Proposals to have 28 bed hospital here with facilities for care professionals. There's gonna be a shift of four during the day time hours, generally, and then a program here. Excuse me. I guess that's really kind of all we've got going on. There's not a lot of new construction that's the existing buildings in good shape we're pulling out a few closets to make the bedrooms a little more accommodating and adding a couple walls to help separate some of the units and some of the staff spaces oh the recent items that we came forward with was we worked with the city staff and some of the district managers for the sewer and making sure we get a good sewer connection in there we hustled that together buttoned up in good shape right now. We also furnished some more information on the water system it's a existing water service there is there was a note of a well if anybody has any questions. [5:02] Chair: Any questions from board members there had been a question at the last meeting about the impact on property values that had been raised by a neighbor who was there did you provide any additional information on that I don't have any specific information on that topic. [5:17] Travis Netto: On property values? Mm-hmm. For the adjacent neighbors? Yes. I don't have any specific information on property values. [5:29] Chair: For the development. So you don't have anything to address the standard about whether you're going to have an adverse impact on property values? [5:37] Travis Netto: Well as I guess as a use allowed use within an existing building we're not creating any conditions that are adverse to property lines any adjacencies the building is well set back from property lines the use is a very low traffic use so I'd argue that also helps with the sense of developments impact on the neighboring properties the space is a very sort of it's almost three acres it's a pretty broad nice pastoral scene I don't see it negatively at all. [6:34] Chair: How many parking spaces do you need for this use? [6:38] Travis Netto: Well, there's over 33 spaces there currently. We don't anticipate that degree of parking demand, but there are some recreation opportunities that a hardscape is good for. So we're anticipating leaving the parking area as it stands today. It's certainly generous for the anticipated need for the staff and the tenants, but it would allow for comfortable access for visitors and. [7:14] Chair: Do you anticipate visitors? [7:16] Travis Netto: I guess I can ask the guys if that happens on occasion, I would guess. Yes, so family visitations and that sort of thing would be. [7:36] Chair: Any other questions for the applicants? Representative? You, I'll open it up for public hearing unless there's an objection from any board member, any member of the public like to speak on this topic. Being none, will close the public hearing. Board members have any questions for the staff [8:02] Board Member: or yes, Kathy, thank you. I believe, and correct me if I'm wrong, were there some questions about discrepancies between the bid, the number of beds in the unit it as compared to what the plan actually called for at our last meeting? I think that might have [8:21] Travis Netto: been a meeting ahead of that, but we did address that there was a discrepancy in the number of called out, so we had to go back out to the water district abilities [8:48] Chair: staff at all, no, what's the correct bed count? So I mean to follow up on that, yeah [8:58] Travis Netto: we had originally on a couple of the documents had 25 beds counted and that was on part of the letters back to us from the districts that we made sure to correct the correct the record and have them respond with the correct account. Oh, it's 28. Sorry, what is the count? 28. [9:24] Chair: All right, well, as in recent past practice, there is a suggested motion here unless someone has as we want to propose something different, we have in our packet a suggested motion on this application. So I would ask the board member to make a motion or have a discussion before we make a motion. [9:47] Board Member: Bob? Maybe just a question attached. We have the findings of the fact. Is that something we should vote on first? [9:59] Speaker B (unidentified): No. No,, your findings fact is your record of your decision-making. So vote on their findings in fact after making. Thank you, I [10:16] Board Member: Will make a motion that we approve with conditions the application for 220 Danville corner Road, PID 122-0 6, submitted by Plots Associates, located in the general business district, pursuant to chapter 60, Article 16, division 2 site plan and division 3 special exception, with the following conditions of approval: one, prior to construction applicants shall provide the approved site plan to the Auburn sewer and water district in the City of Auburn Permitting staff and receive all applicable permits to No development activity shall commence until any bonding or inspection fees are paid are provided to the City of Auburn as determined by the Auburn engineering department [11:01] Chair: There a second. And moved and seconded. Is there any further discussion on this particular motion? Not being any discussion, all in favor of the motion, please raise your hands. Passes unanimously with all members present voting affirmative. Now, while we do have findings of fact and conclusions of law, which, unless you've had a chance to review and have a question about anything, thing. Suggest that we can either vote to approve the proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law, which is probably the more prudent thing for us to do. I don't think that we have to read every one of them. [11:47] Speaker B (unidentified): No, just the fact that you have reviewed it. [11:54] Chair: Everybody had an opportunity to review the findings of fact that were in our packet. It looks like this might draft the time being. If it's acceptable in its present form, I'll take a motion to that effect. If it raises questions for anybody we can entertain those. What would typically happen is that I would be presented with a clean version of this to sign shortly after the hearing, so you know where it goes from here. I [12:29] Board Member: Move to approve the findings of law and decisions for the application for 220 Danville corner road. Second. The
New Business
[12:46] Chair: Movement seconded. Any discussion about these findings of fact, conclusions of law that have been presented to us? All those in favor then of the motion passes unanimously. Thank you very much. Thanks for coming in a second. Thank you board. Thank you. Our next item under new business is a public hearing site plan special exception 16 Western Avenue, application submitted by the Dance Center LA LLC for a new 44 by 72 foot one-story annex building. The property is located in the traditional neighborhood t4 to be district and the application will be reviewed under chapter 60 article 16 division 2 site plan review and division three special exception there are representative of the applicant here does the staff want to introduce this to us before the [14:00] Planning Staff: applicant does I can introduce briefly introduce the project but I defer to the applicant for specifics but I can walk through a bit of the review process and use classification so as noted in the agenda this is for roughly a 3,000 square foot annex building on the same property as the existing dance center off 16 western ave it's in the traditional neighborhood district which is in the form-based code also sorry i'm sam pikus i'm the planning coordinator as you know just wanted to introduce myself for people here that don't know so our job as planners is to classify the use and as you know uses are classified into permitted uses and special exceptions special exception uses go to the planning board for site plan review so this use we classified as artist studios performing arts center it is a another dance center building that use is listed as a special exception which is why it's here before you today and in accordance with section 60 1278 site plan review is required for all permitted use all uses permitted by special exception staff has deemed the application complete which is why it's here before you today and why we've started our substantial review we have been in touch with department heads and there are no concerns at this time and staff has noted all information in the memo and draft findings of fact and you don't have any concerns at this time as well and we defer to the applicant for to discuss project specifics but that's all from us the [15:58] Chair: additional square footage that is going to be devoted to this use doesn't require any additional parking on site [16:07] Speaker B (unidentified): it does not because it's a it's a non-residential that's something unique to the one base code. No, it is not. [16:22] Dan Moreno: Good evening. I'm Dan Moreno, Platt's Associates. I'm an architect. And with me, the owner of, oh, I got to talk into the mic. Okay. So basically what you're seeing here is the large building on the right. Obviously it states the existing building, the existing parking that is there. And to the left is the annex building. Building, and it's right now it's just a large long area, and we're planning to put a building, single-story wood frame building or studio space with bathrooms and corridor. It will have separate utilities from the street. The sanitary is off the back, shared by the existing building. As we're in agreement with the recommendations of staff on their comments regarding closing the driveway, the extra driveway entrance on the listing side. Did you say you're in discussions with staff about, we're in agreement, we discussed it, and that's one of the things that is noted in the application, so yeah, I pretty simple project as far as I, leave it open to questions. Any [18:05] Chair: board members have questions? Jim, good evening. [18:09] Board Member: My primary concern on this project is traffic, and as I look through the packet I see the police department also commented that they had some questions, wanting to be sure that parental pickup drop-off, employee transiting, dancers that drive themselves don't affect the safe travel of vehicles, emergency vehicles, coupled with the fact that's the major route into the new high school. I see, oh, there's a lot written here, but it's not necessarily as clear as I'd like it to be. I'd like you to talk a little bit about the new traffic pattern, the closing of the driveway, and what we could anticipate if this was approved, what impact it would have on traffic. First there [19:02] Dan Moreno: there would be no increase in traffic, it's just basically a separation of classes between the [19:08] Board Member: building. I did see that 10 to 15 and the more advanced dancers I guess would be using the new annex building, but it's an additional building, and common sense would lead you to believe that down the road who might increase capacity of the Dance Center itself, which would also increase traffic to it. I just need a little bit of surety that what we're looking at for numbers is [19:39] Ian Pullen: accurate. Maybe the owner. Hi there, Ian Pullen, and I'll just clarify that I am not the owner, my wife is, I'm here as her representative, she's over there teaching currently right now, but as Dan had mentioned and as it relates to traffic, this building proposed is really for creating a larger space for the professional company dancers to be able to move a larger space, so it's who are currently here now, so the goal is for them to be able to move over there in space in terms of how it will change Traffic in the future, the goal is to not increase the capacity or traffic to the site. It's really just a matter of practice. Our larger dancers over right now, when we perform at EL, it's a 40 by 30 stage, and so this allows the company practice that same size. That's why we're having this building. In terms of the pickup drop off and safe passage, there's multiple things that we're doing as a business to make sure the planning of the pickup and drop off is maybe improved, especially once this building is done. So as we plan for the future, as a, as in next season per se, the planning of timing of classes may be staggered a little bit more so that it's a little bit more efficient, not as jumbled at the time. So that's the goal, and again, this will not increase traffic down to the dance center. We have an ability to create some more, you know, opportunities for easier drop off maybe in the lower section, enter the other side, ability to make sure that, yeah, that was I guess [21:42] Board Member: to clarify, I was looking for egress patterns, you know, drop off pick up, which can be clumsy sometimes over there. Correct me if I'm wrong, does your current space share with a driving school as well, Roy's [22:02] Ian Pullen: Driving Academy does lease space? They're there a couple times a month on various days in the basement. They rent the one classroom on the basement floor, and so typically say Mondays or Tuesdays and Thursdays they do a lot of online classes. Since Kovat a lot of the classes went online, so they're not there as much, but there can be some congestion at times with Roy's, but again, it's just about planning the timing. And to your knowledge, the driving school [22:34] Board Member: would stay in its current location? This application is to annex Dance Center and Dan Center only [22:40] Speaker B (unidentified): correct? Yes, Roy's would stay right there. Yeah, to add additional information, the applicant has provided this information and more to the police who actually requested it, and they responded that they're, they're, they're in agreeance with the information that the applicant is given, so they have no further concerns. And in personally, we personally checked with the police and fire just to make sure that there was no actual concerns, and they assured me no, DeCarlo, we're fine. We're fine. We're fine. DeCarlo? [23:21] Board Member: Yes. Yeah. If I could just kind of follow along Tim's line of questioning, I'm familiar with this area. I mean, I live in the neighborhood off of Court Street. I do laps around coming through Western Ave to hit back onto Court Street through the high school and so on, the circle. I'm concerned about the pickup and drop-off person. I've seen a lot of cars park where they're not supposed to park, particularly on the sidewalk on a public way, forcing pedestrians to either walk onto the walk onto Western Ave or to, you know, go in between the cars and stuff, which both options are not safe. So I'm concerned about that. I'm wondering what you told the police department, what the applicant has told the police department to satisfy their query, but that's something I'm still holding on to, because I know in the evening time when everybody's parked on one side, nobody's actually in the lower lot, nobody's parking where they're supposed to be parking, and they're all coming up in the driveway parallel to Western Avenue, which is the easiest way to enter and the easiest way to exit, you know. And so, and also is a sidewalk for the public, so that's really my concern. I wonder what you can do to address that. [24:44] Ian Pullen: Sure, it's below. So with that, with the proposed curb cut ending that one section, what I will say is it will create a better traffic flow so that there's not an additional sort of people entering and exiting that upper lot. I will force people down. I will say I'm there most evenings and personally, sort of, I want to, don't want to call myself parking attendant, but do my best to make sure that when people are parking, you know, they're utilizing the spaces that we have, and that, you know, sometimes you can't control how people park, and do your best to by seeing it, you know, an issue. I try to go correct it. So is [25:33] Chair: there any signage along the street? There's no parking on the street. I [25:38] Ian Pullen: believe parking on the street is allowed on Western Avenue, so [25:47] Board Member: could you show us where the curb cuts are? I can't really see on the map. [25:52] Dan Moreno: There's, sorry, so the, that's the two-way. We're closing off the one to the right, so that will alleviate some of that drop-off pull-off on the side. They will end up parking in that space, and then on the other side is a, and typically what will happen is they drop off either the top or at the bottom. Again, it depends on the child. The parent might walk in, drop off, and go around the building. What [26:38] Board Member: about the right? So he's where the mouse, the cursor is, right? Yeah, to the right, just a little bit to the right, the front of the building. Those are parking. You're [26:50] Dan Moreno: talking about those four spaces, talking about right there. [26:52] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, those are parking, and you can see that there's actually a sidewalk in front of there, so it's not that they can't get out of the site right there. They have to go through one of the curb cuts, and in addition to that, as the applicant has stated previously, is that it's an operational, what's going on, but they have the capacity for the parking. And so that's one of the ones that, okay, we have to work together. Maybe there's additional signage in the right of way that working with the city, if you're seeing congestion on the street, but that's something that we're always gonna have to work with lively businesses in the city to make sure that they're parking the areas that they're supposed to do since there's actual capacity there to park. [27:45] Chair: I'm unclear now, I guess. Immediately in front of the building, there are parking spaces? Are those four spaces that you need those? Do you have the numbers from some sort of a manual that tells us how many parking spaces the dance studio needs, and are the four necessary? [28:13] Dan Moreno: But the data that we used was based on the existing use of the space, and that's how we estimated it. We lost one parking space. Again, that's because of patterns. Some people drop off, some people park and walk their child in, so that's why it gets used. I don't know if the scenario is that they're there the whole time, they drop off, and they do [28:47] Chair: get used. So, with all of these spaces that exist, other than the four, that's not enough? You need these four? I know they may be more convenient than the other spaces. My question is, do you need them? We do need them. Why don't you just add four spaces somewhere around that new building you're putting up? [29:12] Dan Moreno: We don't have room anywhere else. [29:16] Chair: That entire parcel to the left is where you're putting the new building? Yes. You don't have room for four spaces over there? on [29:28] Dan Moreno: the front. I don't know on the front. Anyway, I think along the front is what's problematic. Right. The front's got a small little pond in it. The rear is open space. Adding four spaces also means adding a drive aisle. So it's, it's, it's a bigger impact. they're [29:50] Speaker B (unidentified): also required to have a certain amount of open space because it is within the form-based code district and that's the area that you're seeing at the rear of the building do we know how many spaces are needed for a dance studio so we do not require any amount of spaces for non residential uses and so it we're we're now the decision was to be made to let the businesses decide how many parking spaces that they that they 're going to need with the thought of that they're only going to create the amount of parking spaces that they need and not access parking can [30:35] Board Member: I interject for a moment. Yeah, with the elimination of the right-hand curb cut, that by default is going to eliminate the current loop that Belial and I are referring to where people park on the curb, and they'll be forced in a circular pattern around the building. Correct? [30:52] Dan Moreno: I think, [30:56] Ian Pullen: again, the focus that I'd like to just present to the board is that this building is not proposed to increase, you know, traffic counts to the Dance Center. And with that curb cut being sealed and operationally, when this is just, we can improve the drop-off procedure to create that more circular pattern to alleviate congestion off the street. It's kind of the way that I'm thank [31:33] Board Member: you well A couple questions. How many employees are generally at the Dance Center? I [31:45] Dan Moreno: I believe it's three or four, depending [31:48] Board Member: where do they park in the lot, any specific area? We don't have any designated employee parking. I guess I'm somewhat concerned with the pattern you're trying to develop, go around the building, but you've got four spots right out in front, so if somebody pulls in there they're there just for the short-term of drop-off. I'm assuming they have to back out to get up back onto the street, back out into a travel lane, in your circular pattern around the [32:31] Dan Moreno: building. If they're coming in from the entry side, they would pull in and it no [32:36] Board Member: different than if they're, but you also have an arrow that's a two-way coming into the, as I look at the diagram, to the right of the building. So somebody pulls in there, takes a left into a parking spot, then they've got to back out into the exiting showed arrow exiting from that side of the building. [33:02] Dan Moreno: Correct, but that's typical of any parking space when you're backing out. [33:07] Board Member: you're backing out into two-way traffic and so I guess I go back to the question of how many employees it wouldn't it be wiser to have those spots dedicated to the employees who are going to be there for the evening and not have anybody backing into a travel lane yeah we [33:26] Ian Pullen: You make a good point. I mean, I think effectively, Mr. Hayes, that it, that does actually happen. The employees get there typically first, and so they're usually taking those spots typically. So, we could look into that. [33:42] Board Member: I would hope maybe it'd be a dedication of those areas just for employees. [33:49] Chair: Notting an agreement, would you accept that if it was a condition of your approval? [33:56] Dan Moreno: It's not that we're not in agreement with it, 's just we hadn't thought of it because sometimes we have grandparents that want to drop off their child. We were looking at it as no change because it's working. [34:08] Board Member: So I guess I've heard it really isn't working properly currently. [34:23] Speaker B (unidentified): So for clarification, because you all act as a board, so this is when I kind of step in and ask, it would that be a requirement of the board to dedicate those spaces for employee parking? And just from a planners point of view, I know you haven't asked, but I'm here to provide it anyway, that the parking space is right in the rear. So I definitely hear what you're saying. I also have just visited Hannaford this evening when congestion was at its worst, when you're trying to get out and in, and those have travel lanes, and you are always backing up into a travel lane and having to wait and then can go forward. That's typical of any busier parking lot for that time at short as it is because of the blocked driveway, the curb cut. Think about there's, there's always other options than just those four employees can use the ones farther away from building, which is more typical of employee parking. Right now I do believe that the applicant, they allow their employees to park where they will. I still do hear your concern, but in a, in a parking lot it, there is already, because of the low speeds, there's already a consideration that people will be pulling out and getting into parking spots on throughout the time. I have remarked though that the applicant is not opposed to having that condition on their site, but I did want to add just a little bit more context to pulling out and going in when it, when it's in reference to a parking lot. [36:14] Board Member: Admittedly I didn't read every single word, it's a pretty thick packet. Are there signs planned for entrance and exit only to direct drivers, and if not, would you be open to that being a condition of entrance only and exit only on your two curb cuts if [36:37] Dan Moreno: I may, we can accommodate that because we're, we are adhering to this traffic if [36:43] Board Member: we ask that to be a condition, I [36:56] Chair: Have an entirely different topic, and this is more directed to you as the professional, and it's a plug for bank or savings bank. I've been kind of a stickler about financial capacity, and most of the letters we get aren't worth the paper they're written on, but this is so short and so elegant that you need to keep it in your file and tell every client to go to the bank and get something that simply says this: the dance center has the financial capacity to complete its upcoming construction project. On Western Avenue, I'm goosebumps. It's compared to what we get, that statement is unequivocal, and I'm assuming that your financial situation. [37:41] Ian Pullen: I'm not sure how the stock market's doing today, but no, I'm just kidding. [37:48] Chair: Fair enough. But again, that's perfect. Any other questions for the applicant? All right, then we'll open this to a public hearing, unless there's an objection from the board. Public hearing is open. Are there any individuals who would like to address the board on this particular application? Education. Yes, sir. [38:16] Dan Brown: Hi, my name is Dan Brown. My wife and I are 23 Cleveland LLC. We are the abutters that you see on this map. I have mixed feelings by stepping forward here to oppose this, and I'll tell you why, because I've met Ian. He's a good guy. He's a good neighbor. I think a dance center is a nice thing for the community, and it's a good use of an old vacant school that used to be there. However, the parking is a real problem out on the street where I own right next door. My wife and I have been there for the last year renovating this rundown house, so I'm there a lot, and Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday evenings from four to seven I have three cars each side of my driveway every night, and what's tough about that is there's a crest of a hill right in the middle of. Ian's property, which makes visibility poor. Okay, the thing I don't understand about parking on Western Avenue, if you enter the other end of Western Avenue from Minot Avenue, there are signs all the way by the church, all the way by the access to the high school, and about two-thirds the way up the street say no parking November 15th to April 15th on that side of the street, and I guess if those part no parking signs continued right by my property and right by his property, I'd be a happy neighbor, but. The fact of the matter is there's 10 to 15 cars on the street on the crest of that hill three nights a week, which makes it hazardous for visibility for my people in my building to see to pull out or pull into their into their homes. And since that's a narrow street, I feel like when I'm driving it when it's lined with cars, I have two options. I play roulette with is my mirror gonna scrape somebody's mirror or am I across the yellow line. I think it's hazardous. There's a crust of a hill there and I think you know the owner said that well maybe they could stagger start times. That hasn't happened in the last year, so I think it's going to take more than that. What I'm saying is currently it's not okay in my opinion as a neighbor and as a taxpayer, and I wish you would take that into regard. Thank you. Good [40:49] Ann Oscom: evening ladies and gentlemen. My name is Ann Oscom. I live at [address] and I've lived there for 10 years now. I am semi-retired. I live alone. My family is grown and so in the hours of five six, seven o'clock. I don't have a lot to do. And I'll tell you that I really have enjoyed having the Dance Center as a neighbor because they bring a lot of life with them. There are children. There are families. There are people who have their dogs on the leash. There's a lot of coming and going. But the reason that I felt compelled to come here to speak to you tonight is because I watch what happens there every night and there are safety concerns. And I would be here even if there was not a new addition happening. The situation the traffic situation the parking situation is a safety problem now. There's a couple of things that I want to point out about this drawing and one is that the elevation of the property on the front of the street is much higher than the back part of the property so people are coming out of that exit they're shooting up the hill and over and into the street before they're able to stop and see. Now the biggest problem is parking. It is not uncommon for there to be bumper-to-bumper cars parked from Court Street all the way to Summit Street. They don't block the driveways, but they use those driveways to turn people who are traveling northbound, I'll say towards Minot Avenue northbound, people who are coming in to utilize the center that are going northbound. They have to pull into private driveways to turn around and park on the on the side of the road. Another problem there, I am, another problem is that our lovely beautifully newly paved Western Avenue and the incline coming from Court Street has always been a speeding problem because people go up that hill from a stop and they have to put the pedal to the metal and they come roaring up over that hill. My driveway is blind for people who are racing up Western Avenue when the cars are parked going northbound on the even side of the street. There is no room for traffic in that northbound Lane. They must cross the yellow line. The parking lots are full. The majority of people are parking their cars, having their children climb out of cars into the oncoming traffic, and they're either carrying or they're ushering small people into the building. So there's a lot of people there and I would say that 75% of them are much smaller than I am. They are adorable. So we have traffic speeding up the street. We have people going towards Court Street or driving down the middle of the road because there is no room for them to pass. The parked cars. There's people exiting into the street. The four spots in front of the building usually have six cars in them. I think that's perhaps where the teachers are parking, because early in the afternoon, the traffic and the parking is not so much of a problem. But those spaces are taken, and people park over the sidewalk in front of the building. So there's usually six cars there, not four. And then as they're parking along the side, closer to Court Street, they have to, because that's a turning lane. There is no room to park. They pull up onto the sidewalk. So I wrote a letter to the Planning Board I think in the beginning of October. Did any of you see that? I submitted comments to your online comment submission. It was at the beginning of October where I talked about most of these things. Excuse me [46:21] Chair: ma'am, I don't believe that we have that. So if you would summarize it for us, well [46:25] Ann Oscom: Well, I have done that pretty much here. So the only thing that's different between the 1st of October and now is that it's dark. There's not adequate street light on that stretch. There's a street light down on Court Street, and then about three or four houses beyond me. So it's dark. We have weather. We also have giant garbage cans lining the road now as well. This is also usually happening right around rush hour, between 4.30 and 6.30, and I understand the programs and commend their schedule adjusting to attempt to mitigate the number of cars that are accessing the building, either leaving or arriving, by staggering class times. That are coming in at the same time. It's a lot of cars. My concern now, if we're talking about a brand-new building, in a situation where the traffic and the parking is already unmanageable, is that the traffic is already unmanageable. The proposal for this building is a larger space which will hold the entire company or a larger portion of the company all at one time. So my question is, if we aren't adding patrons to the already large group, now the whole idea of staggering class times is for naught. You're going to have a large area that holds more people that's going to be more cars that are waiting or parking so yeah I don't see in and I'm not there all the time I don't see a lot of drop-off pickup there's mostly people who are coming parking taking their children into the building there are a lot of people who wait in their cars as well and people taking their children into the building and then children coming out of the building which is the biggest concern that I have is that again 75% of the people who are walking around in the middle of this giant parking conundrum are very small people and I just seems to me like a terrible accident just waiting to happen. Thank you very much. Thank you. Good [49:32] Paul Arthur: evening. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. My name is Paul Arthur and I live at [address], so just opposite the Dance Center. I want to reiterate I also feel that the Dance Center is a fabulous thing to have. I think it serves the community well in many ways. It's important for children and families. I'm a real supporter of that activity and at the same time I share all these concerns about parking and congestion on Western Avenue. We're quite aware of it as we come and go of cars jockeying for position and it just feels a little bit like walking on eggshells going by there rolling into our driveway when there's activity. I'm not here to say that it shouldn't happen, but I do feel that particularly in a residential area, there has to be great effort put into making the parking and the comings and goings as safe as they can possibly be. It doesn't feel that way now, and even if the intention is not for there to be increased building, it's hard to believe that down the road that there might not be pressure that would lead to that, even if that's not hoped for. So, that's all I have to say. Thank you [50:53] Ian Pullen: for hearing me out. Mr Arthur. [50:57] Chair: Where did you say your home is located? [51:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Just could you state the address? [51:12] Dan Brown: Yeah. Oh, thank you. Anyone [51:21] Chair: else care to address the board? My [51:32] Lily Tower: name is Lily Tower. I own 19 Western Ave, which is directly across from the Dance Center. I just wanted to say I do love the Dance Center. I think it's a great thing that we have, but I do have these same concerns. I have a duplex, so one of the spots, I mean, it is hard juggling all the cars around, and we have a spot right outside of, right in front of our house, and getting into to that spot it's really hard with that crest not being able to see people are speeding and coming out of the parking lot so I just I do have some of the same concerns. Thank you. Thank you [52:19] Chair: Any other comment? Hello [52:25] Wendy Brown: I'm Wendy Brown. My husband spoke for us. We're 23 Cleveland LLC. I just want to speak. I grew up in this neighborhood. I've lived in this neighborhood my whole life, grew up on Summit Street, and we actually live on [street], so I walk a lot in the neighborhood, and just like the board members spoke to, it's a challenge walking Western Avenue on the sidewalk in front of the Dance Center when there's class sessions happening. You're you are you're navigating trying to stay on the sidewalk, but there's cars there. 's it's a challenge, and you know when it's dark like this I have my reflector things on and I'm you know trying to be real cautious, but I feel like I see them better than they're seeing me and don't really feel safe walking that way. And I think that we have to consider that high school brings more traffic, and you know when we're working at our building we see kids all the time walking, not so much at night, but I think there's just going to be more and more activities at the high school, and you're going to have more kids on foot traffic, and it is that there is a sidewalk on the other side of the road, but that's not the you know the side that gets the use. It's you know the side that is the Dance Center and the high school, so and just the concern with you know trying to get out of our property again. I have a low vehicle and you can't see with the crest of that hill, and you've got cars parked both sides of our driveway, dangerous getting out of there. Thanks [54:19] Chair: Thank you. Close the public hearing. There's an objection board. Okay, the public hearing is closed. Comments or any questions that arise from the board based on comments that we've heard? [54:31] Board Member: Yeah, obviously there's a lot of concerns with parking. And do you feel that you have insufficient parking, or is there sufficient parking and people are choosing not to use it for in lieu of the convenience of parking on the street? I [54:50] Ian Pullen: think I would say that we have sufficient parking. I'd say it's a combination of the lack of using spaces and directing folks during the drop-off procedure. I will say that the staggering of classes hasn't particularly happened yet. The parking lot can be congested at those coming going times. We realize that are looking to make that correction for next season. Does [55:30] Chair: your facility parking area or would it accommodate the users of your facility without having to park on the street? I [55:44] Ian Pullen: think it would because [55:47] Chair: I am troubled by what I'm hearing about the existing traffic and parking situation on the street, and I'd like to know if there's anything that about your application that would help alleviate that situation, that you're not going to be increasing the amount of users. That's what you've testified to, right? That's correct. So you're telling what I'm hearing then is that this situation that's being described for street parking is not going to be exacerbated by this use? [56:37] Dan Moreno: If I may, what we assume is that the situation that's I think what we're really talking about habits which clearly there's a discussion some people are using residents for a second tentative case of duplex. I can't speak to what's going on Western app, but what we established was working from our parking and [57:10] Chair: what I'm understanding is the parking lot is essentially underutilized. [57:16] Ian Pullen: It's an asset that's not being it can be at times people think it's inconvenient to park at the lower section, and so in the past we obviously communicate with our families and give them new procedures and happy to put up signage and create a better flow. One way that could alleviate the congestion is by requiring a drop-off at the bottom of the lot at the entrance in the back of the building, which would create traffic going in and further down, therefore creating a better safer drop-off procedure. Is what we talked about you [58:03] Board Member: You just segued right into what I was going to ask you, is if your facility has an entrance at the back of the building, and if so, would you, is it suitable for that to be your primary entrance and exit, whereas what is now used is defunct, is that possible with your building, it's [58:32] Ian Pullen: Certainly it would alleviate the drop-off side of things to be used to go down the lower section and enter from that which is not being used, all right, and [58:48] Board Member: My second question was, does this proposal add additional parking spaces to your property, and [58:54] Dan Moreno: If so, how many? It does not add additional parking spaces, we actually lost one, [59:03] Board Member: So all right, that answers my question, well I guess I was interested in one comment, it seems like there's no parking, I kind of gathered from the high school entrance down to towards Minot Avenue, yes [59:49] Wendy Brown: From Summit Street to Minot Avenue on this side, the Dance Center side of Western Avenue, there is no winter parking, I guess what they're, they're using it for, but there's no signs from Summit Street, the courts, so technically there can be on-street parking all year even with snow banking and such, so I had one thing, but ideally if there could be no parking on the street along there, that as an abutter, that would make me more [1:00:26] Chair: Support of this, so this board does not have the authority to regulate parking on the street, have you discussed this with anyone at the city? I have not, hold on, if you, if you wouldn't mind, is I just would like to get a sense of some historical use, so please do come to the podium and tell me, yes, in [1:00:57] Ann Oscom: The past I've worked with my Ward 2 city councilor and had them come mostly to talk about the speeding traffic coming up the hill and my blind driveway, which is 21 in [Board Member: This] Situation, but it has, that's an existing problem that I tried to address, they came and they put one of those your speed is exceeding 25 miles an hour, it doesn't, doesn't really change anyone's behavior, so I had talked with, brought my city counselor up there to talk about the traffic, talk about the high school and that sort of thing, and parking as well, can I assume that, yeah, we talked about the dancer and, you know, I mean, I think really y'all need to come and have a look, what [1:02:01] Chair: I'm struggling with is that the applicant is saying that they're not, that this proposal in front of us is not going to [1:02:08] Ann Oscom: Increase the traffic or the parking situation, I would say an increase is not, is at this point there's a problem. I hear you and Mike. My, the question I would put out is if the mitigation of the traffic problem is being addressed by staggering class times, then having a large building enough to hold the entire company is not going to include staggered times. That means everybody's going to be there at one time. That's my question about that. But I think the larger question for you folks is the idea that there is adequate parking at this time. I would say no. I'm guessing my neighbors would agree with [1:03:02] Chair: me on that. I'm, I'm convinced that there's not adequate parking from what I'm hearing. But let me just read for you the standard that we have to follow: a special exception sought, meaning disapproval will neither create nor aggravate a traffic hazard. So if it's a bad situation, it's a bad situation. And if this application is not going to make it worse, then arguably they meet this standard. [Speaker B (unidentified): I understand.] The problem, I think, is for the city, not this planning board, but for the city to address or to convince you that it's not a problem. But I don't think if the applicant is true to his word that this is not going to increase the number of users and the number of people parking on the street, which I guess, as I've heard you say, you couldn't increase the number of people parking on the street because all the spaces on the street are taken right now. And in fact some of those overflow into the sidewalk because the street itself is not wide enough for parking on both sides of the street, two-way traffic, is that right? I'm seeing a lot of nodding of heads. Thank [1:04:27] Board Member: you. So to follow on that line of topic and the concerns voiced during the public comment section with the neighbors, if it would appease the board and the applicant, I would be interested, and I don't know if staff can comment on this, if this is something allowable in the ordinance or our procedure, but I know the city has a new patch, a new parking and traffic safety committee. I know a lot of the concerns that were brought up by the neighbors relating to signage, no parking signage, you know, I can Talk the fact that this abuts a school zone and the need for more additional and cautious pedestrian foot traffic, as was mentioned by some of the neighbors of this property, and I don't think we should, you know, negate this project because of these concerns. I think this is part of a broader conversation in the neighborhood, right? And so one potential thought would be to, as a condition of approval, to take this project and make a recommendation to the parking and traffic safety committee to find a solution as it relates to on street parking on this, on this section of Western Ave. Now I don't know if that's something allowable [1:05:49] Chair: for staff, but that's just a thought. Well, I think it's certainly allowable if we as a board think that we've heard testimony that suggests that there is an existing safety problem in this city, and it's been starkly brought to our attention, that we could ask staff to direct that concern to someone, to the appropriate board or body or official, and report back to us [1:06:14] Speaker B (unidentified): on the topic generally. I don't know, I don't know why we can't do that. And so I think the law was actually bringing up to have a condition of approval of this project for taking this topic to the safety committee. I didn't, I didn't understand that to be the case. Yeah, but that [1:06:36] Chair: would be sort of a condition that really isn't a burden on the applicant, correct? I prefer that it be, I think it would be better if it was simply something separate and aside from an approval or denial or conditional approval of this application, that we asked that effort be undertaken. Tim, you [1:06:54] Board Member: got your finger on the buzzer? I do. From what I've heard from neighbors and what I've witnessed myself, the primary issue is pick up and drop off. My thought is, if we make it a condition where the rear of the building become the primary drop-off pickup point? I think we would circumvent 95% of this issue, and I'm open to discussion on that. Then drivers are forced to utilize the parking lot, forced to go around the circular pattern, and be off of Western Ave, because no one will be going in or out of that entrance other than employees. I think we're in kind of a, I just would be supportive of that being a condition for approval, for sure. [1:08:01] Chair: I'd like the applicant to weigh in on this, because if we make this a condition, and I think that you've suggested you could go along with it or that it is feasible, but it's going to require, I don't know if there are doors there presently, if you've got to make entrances that don't presently exist and it's going to require follow-up by staff to see that the condition is being met if we were to create a condition that says that there will be pick up and drop off at the rear of the building. Tell us if that's something that can truly work. [1:08:37] Ian Pullen: Yep, I think I can let Dan speak to the existing facility for a second, but before Dan speaks I'll say that I think that you know I, we're obviously all about wanting to keep the neighborhood safe and keep our children safe and keep the staff safe and keep everybody safe as well, certainly don't want to get around that, so I think the pickup and drop-off procedure that especially the drop-off down below would be an easy thing to accomplish through communication to families, signage, and we would have. To replace that door on the rear side to be a little bit more friendly than it is right now or a little more appealing, but other than that it would be more than feasible. [1:09:25] Board Member: And I think it's important to clarify that the condition I'm speaking of isn't that it's your pickup drop-off door, that it becomes your primary door, because if it's pickup drop-off only people may be tempted to circumvent that, I. [1:09:45] Ian Pullen: Think that's fine, it obviously it's gonna go against people's natural inclinations, but I think that's fine. [1:09:56] Dan Moreno: There is a door there and it is required as a means of egress, but. [1:10:04] Chair: It can be used for ingress too, sorry, but it can be used for ingress too, right, again, but we. [1:10:10] Dan Moreno: Can manage that or we can manage that, this is for egress, that's the case, but I'm just saying, I'm just saying we can't eliminate the door, so I don't think we want, yeah, the front door would. [1:10:25] Board Member: Still have to stay for emergency egress and it could be perhaps the employee door, but my train of thought is that your rear door become the primary entrance for all of your customers, students, what have you. Not just pick up, drop off. That's where everything happens. Because that will get everything off of Western Ave. [1:10:47] Chair: So that then leads me to a question. Is there adequate lighting at present to make that facility the primary entrance? [1:10:55] Ian Pullen: Yes. And if we had to include an extra light, but I think we're fine. The light, it might need a new bulb on that not on that staircase adjacent to it on the rear of the building that provides light right now but then it there's a current light that's there that can be utilized so we don't need additional [1:11:18] Chair: lighting or additional submissions on lighting if what the applicant is saying they can use existing lighting. Okay, anything staff would like to add before we move to probably to a vote here shortly? [1:11:48] Planning Staff: So I think just sort of to reiterate hearing the concerns of the butters and also some other concerns from the board, obviously we're staff and we don't, we don't live here. We review the projects for compliance with the ordinance and receive department head comments based on traffic and safety. So the parking lot is all existing, they're just changing out one space to an ADA accommodating space. So the question is really if the new building is going to further exacerbate these parking and traffic issues and we as staff reached out to department heads on this fire department and police department the police department comments I believe are included in your in your packet for tonight and we heard no additional concerns so our stance on this is that it 's not going to impact traffic but obviously the board is it this is the board's decision you guys all live here so you know this area we did have a few advisory comments regarding the parking in the form-based code we have no specific landscape standards, but we would like to see some screening or softening of that parking area, especially regard in regards to the four parallel spaces out here. They are parallel and not perpendicular, so it's a slightly lower risk from rolling out into the main row, but we believe softening that view would benefit that neighborhood. And then my last note is if the board votes with that condition as suggested with changing the drop-off zone, I think we as staff would need to see what documentation the applicant will need to provide to satisfy that condition prior to receipt of permits or construction, if it's a note on the plan or if it's signage, just to specify that. Thank you. I'd [1:14:04] Board Member: like sorry i'd like to i appreciate staff's input in regard to the landscaping and softening in this specific scenario given the inclines and grades on the property I think doing anything to even further degrade lines of sight and visibility would be against the goodness of safety in this scenario all [1:14:42] Chair: Right, we have, as we did with the last application, you have a suggested motion and discussing potential or possible condition of approval. So will we make a motion? Someone ought to have in mind what they want to say about this condition of approval, which I think could be summarized as the rear of the building would be used as a primary access and exit of the building, and there will be adequate signage to, I have a motion to approve the application for 16 Western Ave PID 239-226 to assure that, or words to that effect can be much more than that. Yes, Tim. [1:15:22] Board Member: I got something written up, ready to go. We're ready to entertain a motion. [1:15:26] Chair: We're going to entertain a motion. [1:15:29] Board Member: I move to approve with condition the application for 16 Western Ave PID 239-226 submitted by Platts Associates on behalf of the Dance Center LA LLC located in the traditional neighborhood, T 4 2 B district pursuant to chapter 60 article 16 division 2 site plan in division 3 special exception with the following conditions of approval. Number 1, prior to building permits, the applicant submits the stormwater connection agreement to the city engineer. Number 2, prior to building permits, the applicant releases the performance bond to the city. Number 3, entrance and exit points with clear signage to drivers for parking area be installed. Number four, the rear entrance of the building become the primary entry and exit point of the dance center. Is [1:16:30] Chair: there a second to that motion? Oh, a second. And is the purpose of the final condition And in addition, to encourage, we hope, greater use of the parking area, which might reduce on street parking. [1:16:46] Board Member: Yes, chair. And to also increase the safety, which is currently an issue. [1:16:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, just as a point of clarification. When we're talking about the rear entrance, we're talking about the main building and not the new annex. Correct. [1:17:04] Chair: existing structure yes sir does the does the plan show that where the entrance to the new structure is i can't see it yes it's right there okay so there's and [1:17:22] Dan Moreno: there's an egress door in the back where you can see that sidewalk okay for the rear of the new annex building thank you [1:17:35] Board Member: I do have a question. So if we approve this, we're not, we're not exactly approving this plan. Would we need to see an amended plan? [1:17:50] Chair: I think that with our motion, we've made it clear that the ultimate development will have to have signage, and that we can, we can, we can designate staff to take care of that without this coming back to us. If you want, as Sam said, if you want to be a note on the plan, or if you want to plan revision. [1:18:11] Speaker B (unidentified): I guess I'll look to staff. It's a good question, but I so one in the expectation for any condition is that there will be a note on the plan stating the condition on number two. When we're talking about signage for e ingress and egress, that they are located abutting their the road. [1:18:35] Board Member: Pursuant to the diagram showing the flow of traffic, correct? [1:18:41] Chair: So there will be no need for this board to see another plan if we were to approve this at this motion. That's pending. [1:18:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Correct, if they were major Design changes or specified design changes that you wouldn't envision at this time, Staff would recommend the submission of a new plan. To the existing building is not changing. That is also already. [1:19:16] Chair: Specified. One other point of clarification and for the applicant's benefit. The changes that we are or the condition that we're imposing while it runs with the construction of the new building. In other words, if he doesn't do anything, he doesn't have to do any of this stuff that we're talking about, correct? Yes, I want the neighborhood to understand that as well, that is tied to the development that we're approving tonight. Any more discussion? Not all in favor of the motion, and please, that's unanimous. Thank. [1:20:05] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you, neighbors. Appreciate it. The findings of fact? [1:20:11] Chair: Oh, very good. We have been given proposed findings of fact, and I would ask if you've had a chance to review them, if you find them acceptable, with the understanding that I believe the findings of fact will have to contain the additional condition that we've placed on it. That understanding is the other findings of fact acceptable to the board? Yes. [1:20:42] Board Member: Maureen, yes, yeah, I would like to make a motion that we adopt the findings of fact as presented for 16 Western Ave Dance Center annex building site plan special exception PID 239-226 with the additional conditions with. [1:21:08] Chair: The all in favor, that passes unanimously as well. Thank you. I'm afraid you may have to wait until our public comment period. Yes, thank you. Thank you for that. I. [1:21:29] Board Member: Just said like, okay, so I'll make a motion for the board to make a recommendation to the parking and traffic safety committee to review this parcel on Western Avenue and just treat by, you know, that's the word I'm looking for, to look at the traffic conditions related to pedestrian safety, bicycle safety, just vehicular traffic in general on Western Avenue and no parking signage and all the things that are related to that. I'll, I trust Councilor Butler to know what I'm talking about, so just to review. Any recommend, make recommendations for the city council to, for any proposed changes to go to council, so I know that was a lot, a lot of, a lot of words there. Honestly, I just want to make sure that the citizens that spoke today, the neighbors, are heard and that the appropriate city. [1:22:35] Chair: The city board addresses those concerns and is the focus of geographically, isn't it, from Court Street to find it out all the way to mine it out? Well, I mean, yeah, I mean Summit, yeah, Summit Street. [Board Member: Yeah, do.] I have support for that motion. I would second. Then moved and seconded. Is there any discussion? Okay, all in favor of asking the parking committee to look into this and will you see that. [1:23:08] Speaker B (unidentified): That message gets delivered somehow? Yes, I will. I'm on that committee, so I'll be helping you deliver that out. Thank you, thank you. Change. [1:23:53] Chair: Positions. Next item on our agenda is a public hearing, chapter 60 zoning, proposed zoning map amendment, Pownall Road, is a proposed amendment to the zoning map being presented to us by the city council as I understand it, and I gather that our city planner is the representative of the city in this matter. I'm. [1:24:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Actually your liaison to the city. This is a, this is, this comes from an order that was that's bought by the city council for you all to review and have a public hearing on the proposed zoning map amendment. This came up at a prior meeting of you all and we scheduled this public hearing for today, so today's purpose is the public hearing. Following the public hearing, you all are free to have a discussion and offer your recommendations to the city council. If you just hold on a second, I'm making sure. That this is, this will come up, you have to go to the drive. Okay, give me one second, it should be in the packet 1110. I want to, you all the least be able to have the map up on the screen while members of the public are speaking, so I'm guessing it's all the way at the end. There it is, very. [1:25:55] Chair: Good, did okay. So I understand this proposal to amend the zoning map by removing certain property that is located presently in the agricultural resource protection zone and to designate it rural residential. [Speaker B (unidentified): Correct. Why, but...] Why do, why does the council want to do this? So I can't... [1:26:22] Speaker B (unidentified): To speak on behalf of the council, however, I can't speak to if it's consistent with the comprehensive plan, that type of analysis. The current comprehensive plan in 2021, it actually states, and you have this actually in your packet, that as residences change along this road, there was the, there was the intent to extend this rural residential down this road, and it, I point that out in my analysis in your packet, and this is an example of, there are residences here on the road, and there's one that's already here that is the product of a, of a farm plan, but nonetheless there are residential properties along this road, which makes it consistent with the section in the current comprehensive plan that asks us to review these areas as more residences come along this road. We have a map or plan that shows the 1,200 feet [1:27:27] Chair: typically, and there are any residents in that 1,200 feet, or do I understand [1:27:33] Speaker B (unidentified): vacant land on either side of the road so that the 1,200 foot stretch actually is this the edge of this border here down to this border that's the 1,200 feet stretch and that means there are no there are no houses there presently there is so there's a home here this area is just about vacant this parcel but there is a home here and this area currently is zoned agricultural but there is a residence here and then this is an active farm here but those are residences within the current ag area here And here in the areas that were, is proposed to be amended to rural residential, how is it, there's a, the residence that you've both, I guess, that farm related, I am not sure. I do not think so, it is farm related. The house appears to have been there for a little while, but it is not farm related as far as I can tell. Yeah, it is our, it is an older residence. Again though, this, the original map and mapping and zoning mapping is, has come a long way. It did not used to be as exact as it is today, so you'll see Some discrepancies in your zoning areas. There's only districts all around the city, and this is an example of one of those that in one prior map this may have actually encompassed that area that the that the resonance is, but once you get once the technology improves the area starts to be more and more exact. It's one of the reasons actually why we request that people who are using our GIS system online not use it for their site plans because their discrepancy in when it comes to certain GIS just applications, and so for this map here and using this projection system is actually it's it's it's more exact than in the original Zone what would have illustrated without me getting too technical. That's that's the base explanation that I can tell you, but in just the gist of it is that this area in the 2021 and the prior comprehensive plan it did have in it that as this area does convert to more residential uses along this road that it be more considered more for a zoning change just on how it could be [1:30:32] Chair: developed. President, if it's agricultural I don't know plays out. Yeah, and so [1:30:41] Speaker B (unidentified): that's when I bring up this house that's actually more recent in scope. It is a accessory use to an active farm plan, but it does have a residence on it, and so because it is it does have a residence on it 's one of the things that okay if I had a shop that's closer to the road and a big farm in the back, the primary use of the lot would be farming, but that doesn't preclude from the area near the road to have the shop on it. You can't ignore that the shop is there near the road, and so in this instance there is a residence here. The main purpose of the lot is supposed to be farming, and the primary use is farming, but in the area where the road is what the area of concern and what the comprehensive plan today states about extending this line down is that if there are residences along this road then this area should be considered for extension of rural residential. You do not have to, but the thought of the comprehensive plan says that it should be considered for that extension. The [1:31:55] Chair: residential structure that's where your cursor is now that has a plan for farming if this [1:32:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Amendment takes effect and they don't need to do any farming in the area. No, they would not have to do any farming. What do you mean in the area? So as you know the way zoning works is that if the residence is squarely within the area that's been changed to rural residential then if residential uses are a permitted primary use then no they would not have to do any farming. Their current approval is attached to their farm plan and so any changes from what they have a sort of approval for would require them amending that approval to allow them to have that primary use there. But it being rural residential you they would be able to amend that to say that it is a as a primary use of the land. Yeah [1:32:57] Board Member: DeCarlo I in the packet talks about a property owner has commented on discrepancies. I'm just asking for a little more clarification in the genesis. Is this coming from that property owner or is this coming from council itself [1:33:09] Speaker B (unidentified): So the genesis is actually from a property owner themselves, as they went to speak to the comprehensive planning committee, and then that information was actually sent to the council, and the council initiated the order. The property owner is not the one with the house on it. It actually is the one that's vacant next door. [1:33:31] Board Member: Okay, and that leads me to my next question. If this was approved by us and by Council and all that stuff and it got changed That's going to change Property taxes on people that have no interest in this change. Is that correct? It may but it's not a guarantee [1:33:50] Speaker B (unidentified): property taxes and property valuations is based off of If people will purchase the land it's based off of going from a no-growth zone to rural [1:34:00] Board Member: residential is going to increase the property value am I not right with that [1:34:05] Speaker B (unidentified): so it may if people will actually try to purchase the land and so it will take somebody purchasing land nearby there to actually change valuations. It doesn't change automatically. It a sale must occur for valuations to change in assessing. Thank you well [1:34:27] Board Member: it appears that there's a one large parcel that it's going to be divided zoning wise so i guess first question is the actual address 1890 is a little square which is a very small square compared to the larger lots that surround it is that is it one parcel that is truly just a square. Yes square correct and so that small parcel [1:35:01] Speaker B (unidentified): i believe the owner owns both parcels but that small parcel is existing and so it would it [1:35:08] Board Member: would be on that small square i guess okay so the small square is within that in that little pond [1:35:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Area, the blue part of that. Yeah, the small square is not in the pond area, it's near, it's next to the road, so there has some distance between the pond area, right, but that, so you say [1:35:32] Board Member: that is part of a larger property across the street. I'm part of the larger property that surrounds it that does have the pond within it, so note that the [1:35:47] Speaker B (unidentified): 1890 parcel is a parcel on its own, it's a separate parcel that has its own like [1:35:53] Board Member: one acre. It looks very small, yes. Yeah, it's, it is a very small parcel, okay. And I guess it seems like we are then going to divide a major parcel that even is the back side of the pond, because I'm looking across the power road from the particular parcel that we're speaking 1890, that is a farm activity, quite a large structure and an old hen house, I believe. So we're using its property line to extend across straight and divide a property. [1:36:33] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, it's a, it's a logical strip down the road because it's about the offset from the road. But you want to somewhat line it up with some property lines. And so there's [1:36:55] Chair: so it's 900 feet wide, 450 feet on either side of the road, yes, correct, 1200 feet long, correct, and just a rough approximation, how many lots, how many existing lots are there in that 1200 foot [1:37:11] Speaker B (unidentified): strip? One, two, three, four, five, six. Well, these have area within the rural residential. So the amount of lots being added would be one, two, three, four. [1:37:26] Chair: And topography aside, because I don't know it, I don't know if it's developable land or not, but the proposal is to go from agricultural, which really wouldn't allow any residences there at all unless they're agriculture-related, to rural residential. Residential, so we're skipping over low country residential. It's 325 feet of frontage requirement and three and a half acres or three acres in size, and we're opting for, in this proposed change, just a one acre parcel. That's 250 feet on the road and 150 feet deep, but it has to be 175 feet deep to get to an acre. So in this area that you're showing, if it was zoned rural residential, somebody wanted to, and if the market were there, they could build a parallel road, parallel roads 175 feet back that and have probably 10 to 15 or 16 house lots, right? [1:38:38] Speaker B (unidentified): If the septic allowed it and there's certain caveats. [1:38:42] Chair: Sure, that's why I said conditions, but that's, we're not just talking one or two or three or four, it could be as many as, it could be a dozen or more blocks. [1:38:52] Speaker B (unidentified): So it really is gonna be based off of geography of the land, and if the owners want to do that, the predominant pattern of the area would suggest that this, it wouldn't, it would not be developed in this way. But if we're talking about a legal sense, as long as they meet the minimum requirements of size and acreage, they would be, they would have that right. And that's not uncontrolled growth, because they'd have to come [1:39:23] Chair: I'm here for their approvals and have to meet all the standards of the subdivision, right? That's not [1:39:28] Speaker B (unidentified): uncontrolled growth so they would be required to follow the procedures of subdivision if they if they qualify if that's a qualifying act they 're not required to go through subdivision if it's two or less right dwelling units or but if we get up to the number that I'm thinking you [1:39:51] Chair: could fit in there, which is easily a dozen or more, then yes, they need subdivision approval. [1:39:56] Speaker B (unidentified): They would, one thing I would point out, as currently frontage lot width requires them to have frontage one panel road, and so they would not be able to make their own private road currently and have that frontage also on panel road. The frontage is going to be required to be off of the public street. That's one of the things that we've looked at as part of our provisions, but today we're talking about the provisions of today. They have to have frontage on Pono Road. [1:40:27] Chair: Yeah, that's, that's kind of bizarre. You can't build a road that's probably better than Pono Road, but I'm just, on the one hand, I'm all in favor of this, as you know my position on the Ag Zone limitations. On the other hand, it just seems a little disingenuous for the Council of all entities, after last night's meeting of the Conference of Planning, hearing their views on the Ag Zone, to propose this. It's just counterintuitive. I don't follow the ball here. I don't understand why they would be proposing this. I know you're not here. [1:41:21] Speaker B (unidentified): I understand the question. It's a great question, but I am here as your liaison to walk you through the procedures that we're required to do tonight, just [1:41:38] Board Member: going back to the particular address, what is the size of that lot? I do not have an [1:41:46] Speaker B (unidentified): exact number. I can get you an exact number, but because if this is the entire area, we didn't, I don't have the specific information available right now. If you allow me and give me two minutes, I can bring up the GIS and it has the acreage. [1:42:03] Board Member: There I'd be interested because I think that's a good point. If you look with respect to what diagram we have, all the lots pretty much down except maybe for one that's up towards the junction of Hollow Road and I forgot what cross is there. But they're all, I'm assuming, Will Country residential. This parcel is very small compared to those. So I would be interested. And also, when did this lot be delineated? Is it been on the? [1:42:44] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't have that information, but I can give you the information on the size of the lot if you just give me one second. So the lot acreage is much smaller than an acre, it's 0.08 acres. Yeah, and so because it doesn't have access to water and sewer, there's no guarantee that you can put a house here because you're going to need septic and you need a well, and that has separation requirements from [1:43:29] Chair: well in septic only 5,000 square feet. It is not even, yeah, that's not even, that's not gonna, you can't put a septic on a lot that small. No, does [1:43:42] Speaker B (unidentified): this person own land around? Yes, it is the same owner of the larger lot. So you could see a situation where you can do a lot line adjustment and give enough area for the new lot or for the existing lot to be able to place a home on it. [1:44:11] Board Member: Okay. How does this compare to the new draft plan? Like this area? [1:44:20] Speaker B (unidentified): This area in the new draft plan does include this area. It includes the same exact boundary line. [1:44:34] Chair: That's just in the comprehensive plan's future land use map that you're referring to, right? Correct. In the proposed zoning map would still need to be amended. Correct. Which is what we're asked would recommend tonight. Correct. [1:44:51] Board Member: Not necessarily, Mr. Chair. We have option four, which we direct staff to follow a different path as instructed by Council. That's the way I'm leaning. [1:45:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Before then, we do have a public hearing. Yes. Today? [1:45:10] Chair: Yes. Well, that sounds like a good segue to a public hearing. Unless there's an objection, I'll open the public hearing now. Anybody wishing to speak on this matter, please approach the podium. [1:45:34] Steven Beale: Steven Beale. I usually offer the address of 575 Johnson Road because that's most relevant to watershed and forestry and agriculture matters that I frequently speak on. On. My actual residence is at 462 Auburn Pound Road in Durham, two miles south of this area, three miles south. I go back and forth beyond this parcel twice a day, virtually every day. I'd first like to correct, with all due respect, some factual statements. On the side of the easterly side of the road below the level of the present split zone where there is a house here above or northerly of the parcels at issue by the present presenter who has sought this zoning change there is a house here at the end of this present yellow strip zone. There are no other residential parcels south of there on that side of the road other than the farmhouse that is currently under development pursuant to a farm plan approved last year by the planning staff as the color was indicated on the other side on the road this is the large Honeywell Steve [1:47:01] Speaker B (unidentified): you need to use your [1:47:06] Steven Beale: your mic the mic was working excuse me and this is a 1950 era three-story chicken barn broiler barn that's presently used to house boarding facility for horses. This is a large residential activity for horses some sheep and occasionally some chickens. No residences from near south to the Durham-Pownall line other than this agricultural activity on this side of the road. My suggestion is that you postpone this entire matter to your January meeting because, as DeCarlo has indicated, this area to a distance of approximately 12 or 1300 feet further south is an area that is proposed to be converted from agriculture resource protection to that is a low growth area to a moderate growth area under the proposed new comprehensive plan. Under the present comprehensive plan the low density country or rural residential area and the moderate growth area both and the zoning south that would make the zoning inconsistent with the present comprehensive plan. As you are well aware the plan has been through many revisions and amendments. You've been before this board many times. It's now in a position to go to the City Council for its two votes on December 7 and December 21 for the final acceptance or rejection of the Comprehensive Plan. So if you were to defer action on this matter until your January meeting, then you would be talking about a zoning change that would be consistent with the new Comprehensive Plan, whereas taking action on a zoning change now would be inconsistent with the present Comprehensive Plan. plan. I think that's where the matter ought to be deferred for that reason. I want to address at this time the substantive reasons why these two parcels that the citizen complained were zoned differently unless you decline to continue the matter, which case I'd like to reserve one minute to address why these two allegedly like parcels are not alike. I [1:49:51] Chair: Think in our packet you have our planners' analysis of why this zone change would not be inconsistent with the existing comprehensive plan, and for reasons beyond me the city council had pressed us to act on this under the current comprehensive plan. While I recognize that the future comprehensive plan likely, if it is to pass soon, will change this area to a moderate growth, which could mean more residential, or it could mean low country residential, but we've been advised Mr. Beale may be right, but we've been advised by Mr. Brown that this would be consistent with the current comprehensive plan. Anybody else from the public like to address this matter? Thank you very much. The public hearing will be closed. Back to our discussion and dialogue then. I [1:51:03] Board Member: would say with all due respect to the council, understanding how much they value our work in our opinions and giving them the deference do, I would like to know the rationale behind this recommendation. You know, to say that it's inconsistent with the surrounding uses is fine, but there has to be a reason behind this request, and to me it doesn't make sense until we have additional information. I also agree with Mr. Biel that it makes sense to review it after the adoption of the comprehensive plan knowing that it is going to change. It seems like it would make sense to defer it and discuss the entire area at once. I would agree with that, and I guess further I'd like to have an opportunity once we have the new comprehensive plan in effect, because I think this whole strip that's now rural residential may give us an opportunity to even look at that. Maybe it should not be rural residential, maybe should be the low country, thinking again under state guidelines. Now it's true to have a higher density, still got to rely upon septic, but still I'm wondering with the larger lots that are here, most of those are three acres or more, even above this area that's even now rural residential, so I would prefer to delay and consider this whole strip in more detail. Yes, Kathy, thank you. Have the owners of the large agricultural operation been consulted about [1:53:08] Speaker B (unidentified): the zoning change? Not as far as just the regular notifications, but they haven't individually been consulted. It's not been in our practice to talk directly with every person for every owner of the property for every zoning change outside of our normal notifications. [1:53:37] Board Member: And so if this zoning does change, would that property then be subject or allowed to have three houses on that as well? That lot be divided into three house lots. [1:53:56] Speaker B (unidentified): It possibly can, but it's really going to be based off of geography and how they're seeking to develop the land. it 's possible but it's it's with any zoning change it allows you to propose something but it doesn't mandate that you do that and [1:54:16] Board Member: just for a little bit of history on that lot that they're talking about, that little teeny square used to be a very large ice house and fur gathering shed, so it was a structure at one time, and that lot also was very wet because it was part of the ice gathering endeavor 120 years ago, so I'm not sure it would be suitable for a dwelling. I don't [1:54:51] Speaker B (unidentified): know. Yeah, and so those environmental concerns are always a part of it, and just because the zoning changes doesn't mean that you're gonna be able to develop to the maximum that the zone allows, just because of physical limitations of the actual land itself. One thing I do have to just bring up very honestly is that because the order has been sent down to all to review the request and hold a public hearing, you all as a board do not have the power to delay council action on the matter, and so you are consulted for the purposes of the proposed amendment, but the council can take action after this public hearing, and so I just wanted to be very honest with that. And so if they do choose to go forward, that is their choice as a as a public body, but I didn't wanted to give you guys any illusions that they would be stopped from doing so based on your actions tonight, so [1:56:03] Board Member: basically we're wasting our time. The council's gonna do what the council's gonna do, so I have no further comments. I did not say that, I [1:56:12] Speaker B (unidentified): can't speak for them, but I did not say that. What I'm saying is that they are they are looking for your feedback on this proposal, and they do value your [1:56:25] Board Member: your feedback. I'm in line with Maureen. This, I'm I'm comfortable directing staff to follow a different path as determined by counsel. What does that even mean? I [1:56:41] Chair: know it's written there, I see it, but I don't know what that means. It's a polite [1:56:45] Board Member: for us to wash our hands of it. I don't think that's actually directed towards us. I think that's an old memo to the city council. So I'm not sure what our appropriate action is here. My recommendation would be that we vote on whether or not we are in favor of this and let the council do what the council's gonna do. I liked your earlier, it was a little more emphatic that we have a comprehensive new comprehensive plan that's within a month [1:57:21] Chair: of being adapted and that it's that was a bigger message being sent we [1:57:31] Board Member: don't have the authority to delay council's order no I but just our to me the recommendation would be no we do not want to would not recommend change now that we should be reviewed as all ordinances will be we be reviewed under the new comprehensive plan which will be effective supposedly January 1st [1:58:04] Chair: hearing everything that has been said I am nonetheless I'm going to make a motion that we recommend approval of this zone change to the council I'm sorry I didn't hear you I'm going to make a motion that we recommend this zone change to the council and I'm not hearing a second okay I [1:58:33] Board Member: would move that we discourage or do not recommend this change at this time second any [1:58:47] Chair: discussion on this motion which would be to recommend that the council not enact this proposed zone change additional [1:58:56] Speaker B (unidentified): information would be helpful and to give to the council what would be helpful just additional information because this has been [1:59:05] Chair: the zoning since 1960 when the population of Auburn was the same as it is today and the effort has always been as I'm told to prevent sprawl and this change is not going to do nothing but exacerbate the possibility that sprawl will overtake this city that would be my rationale [1:59:24] Board Member: And I would add just the recognition that we have a new comprehensive plan that will probably be in effect as of January 1st, and all this area should be reconsidered based upon that new plan. [1:59:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you for the additional information. All [1:59:50] Chair: right. So there's a motion in front of us to recommend that the council not approve this proposed Any further discussion on that motion? All in favor? All opposed? Six to one. Chair is opposed. You're welcome. We had an earlier public comment session. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to address any matter that hasn't come before, isn't on our agenda tonight? I just would note that there's a meeting, I saw it on Facebook, of the Minot Avenue redevelopment. Yeah. Could you just, it's Thursday night. I just want the board to know about it. If anybody has an interest in attending, they might have, this is the second public meeting that's been held on what to do with Minot Avenue. [2:01:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, absolutely. I can get you information for that. It was going to be held at the elementary school. They have an alternate location, but it's a little late, and I don't want to give you incorrect information, so I can send that out to you all. So this portion of Mined Avenue, where Mined Avenue and Union Street, that big intersection, that area is marked for redevelopment. And so one of the things that we do is that we hold plans, some of what do people want to see in this area. And so working with our consultant Barry Dunn, who's also worked with the comprehensive plan, they come up with some ideas of some possibilities, and the city wants feedback on those possibilities. Does it meet your expectations? Is there additional changes you would like to see? And that's what's going on Thursday. On Thursday it's a public meeting, public process of discussing some of the some of the sketches that they've they've put together to get some initial feedback from you all. So that we welcome everyone one to come out. Actually Lauren will be there, I will not be there that night, but Lauren will be there from our staff and will be helpful in walking you all through the work that has been done previously and the work to come to redevelop that area. So you as a planning board, it's a great chance to really get into what are the challenges of this specific area, be it traffic, it's a it's a primary arterial right through the middle of our city, it cuts off in certain sections, and some ideas of how to mitigate some of those impacts, and also some ideas of what it could look like 10 years from now, 15 years from now. So that work starts now, and that will inform some traffic improvements. It also will inform maybe some of your decisions when we're were talking about new regulations or new zones. And so this is it's a great segue. Thank you for so much for bringing it up. It is on Thursday at I believe 6 p.m. I will be sending that information out to you all. I'll make sure to do it either tonight or even though you know we're closed tomorrow, maybe tomorrow morning, so you have some chance to get there and have some information. So thank you so much for bringing that up. Thank you. Yes, and we have a meeting on the 19th, we'll be talking about the provisions again to be consistent with LD 2173, which is the old 1829. You all have reviewed all of those regulations now and made comments, and we've made Corrections to those. Now it's the time to start talking and breaking them apart and getting through, getting through workshop to start talking about adoption. Staff's view of this is that it's, it's the package is huge. It took us multiple meetings just to get through the reading of it, and so we are proposing to break that apart somewhat for your consideration. Some sections are more, a more priority for us than others. The information that we brought for today is about the public roads, private roads situation and subdivision, and that's, that's been a topic for some time. As you know, I've been here since April. We have not seen one subdivision come before you, and so there is some work to be done to ensure that we are creating the housing that people need, and so that's, that's a little bit of something that we'll be talking about [2:04:39] Chair: on the 19th. Not to delay the adjournment of this meeting, but your understanding that under our current zoning ordinance you cannot build a road or a subject the [2:04:52] Speaker B (unidentified): road that you build would not be considered lot for lot with lot with refers to the area that's attached to a public road so we just need to change the definition of what would address that yes there are other changes such as there are changes that you guys you all have already reviewed and to make it consistent is to make sure that 's a possibility for instance in the subdivision section itself it also has a provision that has to do with when you are creating lots it has to have frontage on a public street. So there's certain tweaks that we need to do to our provisions to make sure that our intent, high you can develop on a private row actually is reflected in our provisions. On the 19th. Yes, on the 19th, the workshop