Scarborough Council tables sauna proposal, advances data center ban
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:59] Mhm.
[3:54] Mhm.
[10:11] Good evening and welcome to the Town Council workshop on the Climate Action Plan. Today is Wednesday, October 21st, 2026. without further ado, I will hand it over to staff and our guest presenter.
[10:25] Thank you. good evening. I'm Jamie the Town Sustainability Manager and as Councillor Fellows mentioned, we are here this evening to go over the Town's draft Climate Action Plan that we've been working on for the past 12 months or so. our one of our member of our consulting team from Kimley-Horn Associates is here to kind of walk through the process
[10:48] that we undertook, talk about the goals, actions, and strategies that came out of the process, and be happy to answer your questions afterwards. So, I will hand it off
[11:01] Thank you, Jamie. good evening and you're welcome.
[11:12] What I bring in most I would say is a really great opportunity to get to speak with Council. and to just note from the beginning, this is a really fun process and this is really you have a lot of dedicated staff and really engaged community members. so, I thought just about that here in a moment.
[11:34] just throw out that I had some interactive pieces planned in the slides. I think I'll go low-tech with that here. I'm having some problems with the clickers, but I think that's okay. We'll have a little short discussion. You're all navigators.
[11:52] so with that, I'll dive right in. My name is Justin please note that. I'm Mike Steiner. I'm the director of climate analysis at Kimley-Horn and Associates. So I'm in the action planning space for over 15 years. Emissions accounting, a lot of the technical work that
[12:13] I've done a lot of different parts of our process.
[12:20] But why are we all here? What is the core motivations for a climate plan? It really is about vulnerabilities and the climate impacts that we see from the changing climate conditions like rising temperatures. That's leading to things like weather that we've experienced on a day-to-day basis.
[12:41] Extreme heat. That leads to problems that people right exposure to vector-borne diseases. Higher energy bills particularly in the summer. sea level rise. That's not something that you all need explaining to what the what the risks are there. But also stronger storms. More heat.
[13:01] Driving more evaporation, stronger storms, bitter rain. Those things are happening now. and we have direct evidence of that here on Scarborough. The storm of 2024 and the ongoing drought situation that we're looking at the stats earlier just to kind of double-check to see what the what the status was and saw that this is the longest period that it's probably in this kind of the situation since 2000.
[13:31] This is the smart bank of the river. So, it's the longest extended extent of the drought we've all seen. and these are the things that we think are going to just continue to science going to get frequent, more severe. You all recognize that. Obviously, you can something to act on this and have a combination and I figure out what we're striving for.
[13:54] What are we going to do about these changes in the future?
[14:00] So, this is the failed interactive part of it. Which is magically just blowing up a whole bunch of responses that you all got. That you're all contributing to. but one of the things that I wanted to just get a sense from you all. what do you love most about Sparkle? Sparkle shining.
[14:21] So, these choices.
[14:28] Go around and do a show of hands. Yeah, right.
[14:32] [laughter]
[14:33] Beaches and trails.
[14:34] Yeah.
[14:35] First off, what question?
[14:36] Yeah.
[14:37] [clears throat]
[14:37] Yes, obviously you all love a lot of things.
[14:40] Yes.
[14:40] Community for a lot of different a beautiful place. And we both have just been a lot of fun to see some of the natural areas of the most of it.
[14:57] Maybe this one will get some more diversity of answers. But what do you see as the biggest challenge protecting what you love about Sparkle? Affordabilities, development pressure. Severe weather events. Extreme seasonal patterns. Challenge maintaining my quality of service.
[15:15] Yeah, all of the above.
[15:16] Sure.
[15:16] A [clears throat] A is my number one.
[15:18] When you talk about protecting it, and it's extreme storms and weather is certainly part of that more we have more control over other ways to protect town the town and the attributes that we love but we don't have any control over that one.
[15:33] And there's a there's an affordability component to pretty much all of that.
[15:37] Yeah.
[15:39] Recently been grappling with as you may know a road where culvert failed and trying to figure out best approach to that and how and when to replace it and within the context of all of our other infrastructure that is at risk.
[15:56] That particular thing like hits all of these boxes.
[15:59] Right.
[16:00] Yeah.
[16:02] Yeah, the unpredictability.
[16:14] So, in your opinion and maybe this that is a good leading question that how well prepared do you think the
[16:24] Not prepared at all.
[16:26] Between A and B. Yeah. A working towards that.
[16:29] Yeah.
[16:30] See, somewhat prepared in that we're doing this. Starting the process, I think.
[16:36] Yeah, I think high levels of awareness is a good first step in putting a plan in place.
[16:50] Okay. So, knowing a little bit about what we were trying to do with this plan and the things that we want to address, what of these describes your vision for a sustainable skirt?
[17:03] Could be one of these, could be something else.
[17:11] I'll say D, thriving natural resources.
[17:15] F and not for me.
[17:22] Extreme weather
[17:24] Extreme weather is something else.
[17:29] That's probably partially because we did the vulnerability assessment and so we have a lot of information that tells us you know, where we could have a 100-year storm, which is not very uncommon nowadays to happen and you know, going back to the culvert, like I think since we've had that conversation, it's like whatever we decide, if we have one of those storms, that investment would be wasted if we went with the cheaper culvert.
[18:02] Okay. Well, thanks for indulging that. I think that's the last Yes. great. So, you know, and those sentiments are definitely things that we commonly hear in all the communities that we works with. And yeah, it's just good to know that you all are supporting us. challenges
[18:24] what they're doing this. So, as we started this planning process, one of the things that we tried to do in this working with Jamie and some of the other staff to establish some of these things early is the guiding principles that we tried to infuse in all the conversations that we had. so, of course the sustainable stewardship
[18:44] the maintenance that we have to do in addition to preparing for the changes that we know are coming, but we also have to reduce our contributions to downstream part parcel of all of and possibly actually put in
[18:59] Oh. I don't mean they're corrupt. Can that be turned up a little bit? I think people are having trouble hearing.
[19:05] Bring it a little closer, too, if that's all.
[19:07] Yeah, that I think they'd be I kind of checked out. People are like, "I And I really hear." Thanks, Michelle.
[19:11] You're welcome.
[19:13] And we want to hear every word.
[19:15] [laughter]
[19:17] So, reducing greenhouse gases and you know, the other things that we all do as a society to fight to climate change. Whatever we can do to keep this down, that's important. Bold and transparent governance. This was something that we saw time and time again throughout just the way that you all which actually is really refreshing
[19:38] to see, having a hearing like this to go through this is really nice to see. Yeah. Let's keep people engaged, which is important. And also implicit participation, making sure that we're giving everybody an opportunity to weigh in on these things,
[19:58] contribute their knowledge. We had lots of opportunities to do that, as you'll see here in a moment.
[20:06] So, those are the guiding principles. One of the sort of foundational thing that we do in the beginning of these processes is the greenhouse gas inventories. So, this is kind of the accounting that we do of all the sources all the sources of greenhouse gases from the community. It's a good way to establish some data points, figure out what's being tracked
[20:27] already and highlight some of the things that maybe need better data sources going forward, but it gives you this starting baseline that you can start to measure progress against. The relative share. I'm not going to go into a ton of the numbers. Of course, if you've got questions, we'll go into that again, but you know, the share of buildings versus transportation versus waste pretty typical of how it looks for us.
[20:53] There wasn't anything that was like, oh, that's really odd. odd in some way. This is this is typical and no big surprise. Buildings and transportation are the biggest sources. Using fossil fuels, using energy is pretty universal.
[21:09] quick rundown on
[21:11] Yes. Is this for town facilities or town-wide?
[21:14] Sorry, great question. That is town-wide.
[21:17] Okay.
[21:17] So, that's the whole community. we did do a subset of just municipal operations. similar, right? It's the buildings and the fleet. the town operations accounts for about 2% of the entire community. So,
[21:32] I respect
[21:32] It's relatively small. and that's also pretty much the same every community almost that I've worked at. So, it's always 2 to 3%. So, no big surprises.
[21:43] Okay. How does our total number compare to other similar municipalities? Are we high, low, in the middle?
[21:50] that's always a difficult question because well, what's what's a similar community? but, you know, I think on a per capita basis, it's
[21:58] Mhm.
[21:59] emblematic of suburban communities.
[22:02] The meter
[22:03] [22:04] the urban area
[22:05] Mhm.
[22:07] Certainly.
[22:08] Okay.
[22:10] I mean, I'll just say one thing and some of the data sources So, for example, the miles traveled on transportation, you know, that came from GPCOG. so, that just kind of gave me an opportunity to look around at other GPCOG communities and you know, I'd say you're relatively high in that in terms of like vehicle miles traveled per capita.
[22:35] but, I don't think that's a surprise either.
[22:38] Does that include people who travel through Scarborough or is it just within Scarborough?
[22:43] It does include
[22:46] pass-through.
[22:47] It doesn't include
[22:48] like traveling to Scarborough. Maybe not just pass through, but it's it's I believe it's our residents and then people who are driving like from another area to either come to work here or something like that. Is there an impact with like number of streetlights for example? Thinking like in Oak Hill people are sitting there and cars are running versus being in you know West Carver where it's really just you know open
[23:14] road and then occasional stop sign.
[23:18] I would say it's not a huge contributor or maybe more importantly the scale of it at which we do these versus sort of like what's the total number of miles driven. Okay. Having a number doesn't really pick up necessarily that of like how much time are people sitting in traffic. I mean it certainly contributes if you're just sitting there.
[23:39] But yeah, I think I think it's actually a relatively small impact.
[23:46] a couple of things that I want to highlight here on sort of where some of this data comes from when we do this. So the utility information electricity natural gas that's all metered, right? They can just give us that information. So that's relatively easy but things like fuel oil those are things that we have to estimate. Look at how many people are using that as a fuel
[24:07] and then sort of what's the typical household use to sort of add in what those things contribute to. I already covered transportation and the other kind of big piece that I think is worth noting is that like a lot of municipalities you have pretty good information on residential waste. It's
[24:27] franchise that out you manage the collection of it but commercial waste like or anybody who's not served by the municipal program, that's also has to be somewhat estimated like okay, what do we think those folks are adding in. you know, that's also very typical so it's not a big surprise but something to think about
[24:47] as you engage businesses about maybe how they how much they are discussing these kinds of things. It could be a source of data to improve those estimates. to be clear.
[24:56] And all of the data was from 2024, so a couple years old at this point, but it was the most recent data that we had available to us when we started the process.
[25:04] Always the case. We're always working 2 years on data that's 2 years old and thinking about the future 20 30 years ahead, so a little tricky there.
[25:17] the next thing that we do in the analysis side is we look at well, what does it take to get to zero or very close to zero emissions? So, this is just kind of the chart that comes along with this. I'll highlight a few of the numbers when we get into to the actions, but it does make for a nice pretty chart. And one of the things that we do when we go through this process is we try to look at what is happening at the state level.
[25:41] a lot of times when we 're looking to do these things and knowing that we need to build partnerships to accomplish it, knowing what the state wants to accomplish statewide and think what is Scarborough's sort of fair share if you got, you know, a relative percent of the efficiency main money or, you know, your fair share of the statewide targets for electric vehicles.
[26:06] And so, we try to combine that with the information that we had on the existing emissions and draw these pathways out. a couple things I'll highlight. It doesn't get totally to zero, at least we didn't, you know, it gets kind of squishy when we are thinking about what 2050 is, but you know, we try to get it as close as possible and the remaining emissions that you see there are from
[26:29] commercial vehicles, which there aren't really a there's not a major initiative at the state level that's sort of doing that. Although, those vehicles are changing, too. and I know that there's, you know, maybe some large employers that are going to have a lot of trucks around and maybe some of those are going to be like electric. I don't know but, yeah, there's not really part of that in the moment.
[26:57] So, beyond analysis, we did a lot of community engagement. We had a number of polls. Hopefully, some of you took the polls and participated in these and pretty good response rates. You know, everybody is clamoring to take more surveys, but it's great to see that the ones that do. And largely the feedback that we got from these were was positive.
[27:20] So, there was a lot of appreciation that the town was taking this on and I think just good acknowledgement that the town doing this is reflective of the community's desire to see it happen as well. Yeah, that was reflected across the board.
[27:40] There was always some skeptical responses or people who were just not interested in doing the stuff, which is, you know, perfectly fine and they don't have to.
[27:52] We also had a climate advisory group. So, we had three different meetings of these. Actually, I see a lot of or a few familiar faces for people that participated in these and these were really good. Just an opportunity to get whole swath of community feedback on what's practical for Spring Ridge to do. You know, we
[28:12] didn't start off by throwing out some very ambitious things and then we sort of whittled some of these things down, but also opportunities that maybe we as the consultants weren't thinking of will rise to it rise to the fore based on something that we learned about the community project based on the fact that the kind of work that they're doing. Make sure that 's incorporated in the plan.
[28:34] And also just really fun to have those kinds of interactions and hear from your constituents. And there's a lot of really engaged and smart people here. I think they're there. In one of the meetings there was two former NASA scientists who had never met each other. I thought we got a lot of smart people.
[28:56] community events we did or more on the town side but was initiative was present at multiple events throughout the community and summer concert in the park series junk in the trunk clothing swap days which is really great to engage the people who are already sort of have a conservation mindset and making sure that they're aware of the separate small.
[29:24] I just want to give a shout out to Scarborough Public Library who was an amazing partner in a lot of these events. Definitely gave us an opportunity to bring people in for events that they were already doing and we had an opportunity to talk to them about the separate. Fantastic.
[29:44] Okay. So in the in the preparation of this and this is actually something that we do that is largely driven by those I mean the
[29:59] Sorry. Meeting me.
[30:01] Advisory group.
[30:01] Advisory group meetings. I would like us advisory. right. How do we form these conversations in a way that you know the right people are all together that get into a group and have these discussions. So but not surprisingly thematic areas do the group things. Clean energy and efficient buildings smart land use and transportation
[30:24] sustainable operations and waste management thriving natural resources thriving natural and coastal resources and resilient and healthy community for so giving good way to get the people who are working on these things every day and get their take what's going to be the best
[30:44] the best ways to move these issues forward. you know, different ways that we can do that.
[30:50] So, are these topics that this is what came out of all of your surveying and everything or are these the type of hot topics you're going to see in every climate action plan or is this kind of tailored to what you're seeing in Scarborough at least?
[31:02] This is This is definitely one that is Well, we designed it to support our advisory group as we're going to come together and who we were tapping to get that They're very similar to what you would see in any climate action plan. They're basically I would say the one that changes is sometimes waste depends up with natural resources and sometimes it's with operations.
[31:26] That's mostly has to do with who is Where does that responsibility fall within the town government? How we want to get this to work. but
[31:37] These are the overarching kind of topic areas, but then all of the kind of goals, strategies, and actions that fall below them are very much tailored to Scarborough.
[31:47] Thank you.
[31:56] I'll go with that. So, yeah. The goal, strategies, and actions. So, this was what we got and what came from all those conversations that we had in the advisory groups. Also looking at what peer communities are doing, KLA's experience in doing this in a number of others places on the kinds of things that we can be doing.
[32:20] so, you'll see there everything is organized under a goal. Goals have strategies and then one to four strat individual actions under each one of those strategies. to the far right, you will see some different metrics on tracking progress. So, this was you know, there's
[32:42] a lot of things that we do put in these plans to be comprehensive, make sure that we're sort of hitting all the things, but we try to also give you some very clear benchmarks on some of the things that really need to happen if you're expecting to see the numbers on that chart go down the way that they're modeled to go down. again, the targets that are set there for 2030, 2040, 2050,
[33:06] they are largely derived from the main won't wait plan. And again, sort of thinking about what it would be if Scarborough was on that same pathway that the state wants to achieve, what does that look like? So, almost heated with high-efficiency heat pumps, trying to get to 1,200 of those by 2030.
[33:28] and the numbers do ramp up rather aggressively after that. but we are hoping that the resources that state will make available to see that happen statewide, but you all are in a better position to see these things.
[33:45] I don't want to read all of these out individually, that would take a long time. but you know, I can at least go through the goals here. So, goal number one, Scarborough is primarily powered by renewable energy. So, there's there's two pieces of that. It's both what we can generate here within the town and making sure that the barriers to putting in more renewable capacity within the community,
[34:11] that you know, there's nothing that is necessarily holding that back. but also there are actions there to support, you know, how we can affect it through advocacy or you know, other mechanisms to help drive renewable energy generation and our renewable energy generation state-wide,
[34:32] and regional.
[34:35] goal number two, Scarborough buildings are energy efficient and minimize greenhouse gas emissions. You know, again, a lot of the actions here are really geared towards education, making sure that people there are barriers to people accessing the programs that exist. and really trying to set people up to get access to
[34:56] the incentives that are already there. There is a couple actions there particular to municipal facilities. but are really again not so much geared towards requiring that you're going to do a certain thing, but making sure that there's processes in place that you can consider the full range of impacts, particularly as it comes to environment, as you make those investments in solar systems.
[35:30] I'll move on to smart land use and transportation. So, goal number one, Scarborough residents regularly choose access transportation and transit options for local trips. again, the actions here are about making sure that those options exist to the extent possible. the community is
[35:50] moving towards the kind of form that would support those things more so than just a car and a drive style. so, yeah, again, making sure that the options exist primarily. And similarly with electric vehicles, not requiring anyone to sort of change, but making sure that if people do want to make that change, that
[36:15] the infrastructure exists to support it. So, finding making sure that there's ways to ensure that the charging infrastructure goes in where it needs to charging is not unduly expensive when people do want to put it in eventually. Probably long-term time horizons, those are the things that we need to be thinking
[36:40] that basically covered goal number two. goal number three, Scarborough continues to develop strategically with climate hazards in mind. So, thinking about land use and not just the transportation parts of the building, making sure that as developments come in as Scarborough continues to evolve, that we're taking everything that came out of the vulnerability assessment, you know, and then
[37:08] using that to guide decisions.
[37:15] Sustainable operations and waste management. goal number one, Scarborough integrates sustainability data and principles throughout operations and regular communicates progress with the community. So, this was really, you know, again, a lot about just thinking about how the town makes decisions and creating the kind of structures for incorporating these impacts into that decision-making process.
[37:41] The decisions could ultimately go where they go, but at least making sure that you have some tools in place to think about that and in the way of going forward. and then goal number two, Scarborough solid waste is reduced and managed responsibly. And I think that was certainly a goal number one.
[38:03] So, all there. So, a couple of things, there's a lot of initiatives that And I want to support that and we want to make sure that Scarborough is doing that. Participate and that is I think it's I don't know what the contribution is as much as possible, but also making sure that we're positioned to take advantage of some of the things that may come from the extended
[38:27] producer responsibility funding sources to deal with the waste that should be reduced.
[38:36] and lastly there are some strategies there for municipal operations just in terms of thinking about ways that you can do procurement differently in terms of the kinds of things that you buy, the amount of throughput that it takes to run these profound data days.
[38:56] there's always something more
[39:00] It's really just kind of a precarious place in terms of how those decisions are
[39:10] Driving natural and coastal resources. Goal number one Scarborough conserves sustainably manages natural resources. Yeah. I guess I'll just throw out that there's just far fewer actions here in this section because you all are doing already so much. it's really encouraging to see but there's there's definitely thing more things that can be done.
[39:34] Yeah, we looked at the tree canopy and identify there's some additional actions that could be taken there. Maintaining achieving that tree USA status and maintaining that 's a great thing. Great. granting applications always love to see those kinds of things and that shows that
[39:55] another way that towns can be active in managing those resources and enhancing those resources. That will be that's what I'll do some here. but then just you know, some additional things to make sure that the natural areas are healthy. That we're not burdening them with as much additional herbicides, pesticides,
[40:19] and that they're in a healthier position to withstand the extra impacts that they're
[40:31] Lastly, resilient and healthy community. goal number one, Scarborough residents prepared and protected from climate impacts. Again, a lot of education. making sure that all the town channels are firing on this and make sure that people have access to the information that they need to protect their loved ones and their property.
[40:56] [40:58] Goal number two, Scarborough's infrastructure is climate ready and flood resilient. And the Yeah. example of the culvert is very on point for each one of these things. So, making sure that the sea level rise projections are part of how you make those decisions going forward where you're investing in that infrastructure dollars.
[41:22] and maybe particularly this action two, we'll be developing a vulnerability response framework to guide decision-making and protecting those municipal assets that's really exactly on point for hopefully putting you on a a better position to make those decisions.
[41:44] Yep.
[41:44] Just one question on that. This has been brought up a couple times about the culverts. there's three 4-ft culverts Scarborough Road they were put in I'm guessing probably 50 years ago or more. They last that long and now you have plastic.
[42:05] And if it is an issue with flooding, coastal flooding and stuff, I assume it'll get jammed up the other side of it. I think the more problem is the rain run off. If we have a big rain storm, it you know to get out and then it will flood across the roads. So, I think it's mostly letting it out. [42:25] and there's plenty of room in five culverts. You could put five culverts in few They have plastic now and they're really durable rugged and I assume those will last over 100 years. I'm assuming this, but I mean I have to say in plastic to galvanize is big difference. So, I think
[42:47] talking over, you know, 1.4 million dollars for a culvert there and the cement and cement isn't forever either. I don't know if the cement is less than plastic, maybe. I don't know either, but I'm just, you know, I'm just saying if we go from, you know, if we can do it for, say, 600,000 instead of 1.4 million,
[43:10] just a rough figures, it makes sense to me to put in five culverts, you know, instead of the cement.
[43:20] That's all I'm saying. It's just common sense stuff and think about what we do. And you do have to think about the impacts of the, you know, the environment and global warming or pain and more storms cuz it's obviously happening. We're seeing it happen. So, you know, it's really make that point cuz that is something we have to bring up. This road is closed for over here and it's like
[43:44] wait for grants from the state so they can put in a 1.4 million dollar culvert.
[43:51] Doesn't make sense. I mean, we ought to just take care of ourselves and the state ought to take care of itself and not get money from the federal government. I don't think that we should be taxed to the federal government so much and then they'll trickle it back to us. Why don't we just keep it to ourselves, you know? Manage our own neighborhoods.
[44:12] Thank you.
[44:15] You know you're with that point. I don't know the particulars of the what's proposed there, but yeah, I was looking at the things here and studies are looking at the long term.
[44:29] That capacity is there or not. There are some of the storm events that are going to be I mean 2050 years with all the impacts whatever materials.
[44:40] All right. All right.
[44:46] Okay.
[44:50] Decent segue there to a little bit on implementation costs. You know, we didn't assess the costs of these things specifically. There's not a lot of sort of hard changes here. A lot of it is stuff that we know the town can work into its existing processes fairly well, but
[45:11] again, a lot of the a lot of the actions are geared towards education, a lot of them are geared towards positioning for more grant funding. It may maybe slow incoming, but you know, those things are cyclical in nature and if you've got shovel-ready projects by the time is right that could be a good place to be.
[45:31] [45:33] I have a quick question. So, what would be nice would be and then maybe it's when we get to implementation like which of these are actually eligible for grants just to know like what's out there cuz I would assume a lot of these things are. It's just a matter of which ones aren't to make sure that we can figure out what's the priority to kind of go after these grants.
[45:52] Yeah, exactly. There are a lot of the actions outlined are eligible for funding through the state through the state resiliency partnership. we've benefited from some of those grants. One of those grants helped fund the development of this plan. So, so it is going to be, I mean, there annual opportunities.
[46:15] It's not a ton of money, but it's great to offset some of the cost of this. and so it is going to be prioritizing and deciding which kind of rises to the surface first that we're going to, you know, apply for our first grant to begin implementation.
[46:30] I have one more thing to as far as you keep saying that we got to switch over to electric. But electric is made from oil or coal or, you know, fuels to make electricity unless you have hydro. And hydro I've always said for years is the way to go. But you have the Hoover Dam that supplies electricity to four three or four states,
[46:52] you know. the state of Maine, you know, they tried many years ago. I think it was early '80s, late '70s, something like that. Do you know I think it was some big A dam or something like that. It was a project they were talking about. It was going to flood a lot acres. It was a private mouse. Doesn't want that. But really electric is the way to go. You can do electric heat, electric cars, you can do electric everything now if you have the supply for it.
[47:16] And the state of Maine has the natural resources to do that. As a matter of fact, the town of Scarborough has a huge resource right here just for our town. If we wanted to take it on ourselves, you have between Ferry Rock and the jetty at Pine Point. That tide comes in and out every single day. If you had hydro generators there, turbines,
[47:38] and you wouldn't have to dam off the whole river or whatever, just one on each side. And the wind comes from every direction there, too, if you wanted to have windmills there. I think the town of Scarborough could supply our whole town and then some. I think it'd better be a lot more than our town. with just that one spot there. And that'd be a chance to take out. That would be significant.
[47:59] That'd be real. That would be something changing, you know. Cuz we have a problem with small dams in the state. The fish ways and stuff with the small dam, they don't make enough power to be worth it. I mean, a small dam, but when you go to something like the Hoover Dam, when you get to that size, it's exponentially much more power and it's so much worth it then.
[48:20] But you do have to sacrifice, you know, they had a big they had a big canyon there that they dammed off and it didn't really matter, but here maybe we'd be damming off a lot of forest, you know. So, these are the issues we have and we really should I say we should go for that rather than nuclear or, you know, what are you going to do with the nuclear waste, you know?
[48:43] And oil is a finite resource. Natural gas is saying everybody switch to natural gas, but this is that's going to run out, too. You get that in Canada, but Canada has switched to a lot of hydro. They've done a lot of hydro.
[48:57] I think that's the way to go. It's it's it's renewable. It's, you know, it's the only way to go, I figure. and it's something the town of Skowhegan can do right now, do a project and Skowhegan get the grant. That would be something to You know, I usually say grants are waste money, but that would not be, [laughter] you know. That would be a I'd vote for that.
[49:17] Grant. I can
[49:20] Yeah. Now, there's a there's there's definitely a lot of energy there. and there's there's a lot of good opportunity there. I think some of the conversations that we had with Central Maine Power
[49:34] what they're trying to do to procure very large renewable energy sources and Brass Hill wind on Flagstaff Lake that's that's proposed and that is part of the math for all this and finally again I can't just look by everything. It's not fair.
[49:55] Well, it doesn't get you anywhere as far, so yeah, you know.
[50:01] Now, just a little moment on that too, I'm kidding about my grandmother who lived there. My sister's in the house now, and her electric bill is $28 a month. they had the Cat Mouse Reservoir dammed off, and they had their own power supply. The town's gotten bigger, and they do have to get from CMP too, cuz it doesn't It used to cover it all. It used to be really cheap.
[50:21] My grandmother was like 10 5 or 10 dollars a month for electric many years ago. and everybody was covered on it, but now, you know, so it's even at that size, it did it does work, and it's still working today. Thank you.
[50:37] Anyone else?
[50:38] I'm sure.
[50:39] Yeah, just a couple things. One, something that really stuck out to me and that kind of [50:44] [clears throat]
[50:44] is another, I think, piece of data for our affordability housing conversations is when the 90% of our workforce comes from outside the community. That number was staggering to me. So, just something for us to think about. The other thing, when you take a look at Maine, and who are we benchmarking ourselves against in the country?
[51:07] Like, who's doing this really well? And then, how is our you know, state government taking a look at that, and then how does that sort of cascade down to either, you know, funding or mandates or requirements or a sort of decision-making when you take a look at, you know, what Scarborough does.
[51:29] yeah, see. I mean, in terms of the comparisons, you know, I think one of the things that we've worked a lot in Caileys. Based in Massachusetts, we've worked with a lot of Massachusetts communities, and obviously, the state there has supported a lot for a very long time.
[51:49] So, there's a I don't know, a level that those communities are working at. That East Hampton may very well be on its pathway to catching
[52:04] Yes, and I think it's similar with other communities in doing for other states and so I you know I mean Connecticut communities are I don't know, we were working with Groton Connecticut earlier this year.
[52:17] Groton? Okay.
[52:19] very similar challenges, very similar levels of support from the state. The state's going ramping things up in a lot in a lot of ways. but also states working together. So, there's actually a really interesting thing that actually did survive from the Inflation Reduction Act, there's a
[52:41] a New England state consortium that is working on reducing the upstream barriers to water heating electrification. So, it's providing the training resources for the workforce that needs to put it in, the contractors that
[52:58] Okay.
[52:58] installing the stuff, putting in the incentives on the supply side so that a homeowner doesn't need to have to think about it. The whole package just gets cheaper.
[53:11] Yeah.
[53:12] So, those kinds of things are happening that will hopefully help accelerate them. Help communities and make sure that
[53:20] So, do you think our legislature is doing enough? And if you don't you can broadly answer, but I'm just thinking as far as you know, when we take a look at like what are they focused on the right things? Do you are they strategically going in the right direction?
[53:36] [53:39] nothing is too fast. Nothing is fast enough. That's That's kind of the way that I look at that question. But I would say this I'm not super steeped in everything that's happening at the at the state level, but I will say that there are some very interesting things that
[54:00] the state legislature has done that I think are unique for Maine, the extended producer responsibility law. I don't know of any other state in the country that has something similar already on the books. I think some are working on it. But that is I think very forward thinking and
[54:20] I think it is indicative of taking a systemic approach to thinking about what really is the source of that problem in terms of where does all this solid waste come from, right? Why does that get dumped on the public sector to have to deal with it? So, yeah, I think those kinds of things are great ones.
[54:39] Thank you.
[54:42] So, just to weigh in, I mean, Scott makes a really good point. I mean, this thing emphasizes that use electricity wherever you can. Water
[54:57] changes in the ocean. These are the things I've got a house that has every direction except north has a set of panels on it. And I believe in that. And I think that's that's what we need to be successful
[55:19] in ridding ourselves of oil and gas.
[55:25] Because there's a few other ways, but this is the most obvious. And hopefully technology will pull us along. Because I think that's really a necessary element is that technology exists and the cost exists to justify moving
[55:46] the whole society in that direction.
[55:48] Yeah, I just to respond to that, I think the homeowners who have the ability and the situation where they can install their own solar panels on their roofs or on their property, that's amazing. and we need as much of that as possible. And then for others who either they don't have a large south-facing roof or they, you know, are on a wooded lot or they don't have the financial means to make that investment
[56:16] all up front. Going electric is a good way to make large-scale change without even realizing it because as our grid becomes more renewable, as more renewable projects come online and all our the sources that are providing us providing CMP energy, that's going to transition automatically over time.
[56:37] So, you know, making sure that we are using electric appliances and high-efficiency appliances and, you know, if we are able to use electric lawn care equipment and things like that, that's how we will start to see change over time without, you know, just by going through our day-to-day lives.
[56:58] But I just piggyback on that, I can say from my own work in multi-family housing, there really has been a big move toward electrification. Some of that has been elective by owners and managers but through some combination of economic incentives and kind of, you know, moral imperative, if you will. but there also are things that the public sector do through permitting and funding incentives to push and pull in that direction as well and that's where you start to get some real scale
[57:28] beyond the sort of individual homeowners, although way think it's, you know, whatever can be done within reason to incentivize that as well is good.
[57:38] We recently needed to buy a new car. We bought a Chevy Equinox. Now we get 55 miles to the gallon.
[57:44] Yeah.
[57:45] first time we've ever owned an EV vehicle and it's terrific.
[57:53] John?
[57:53] Yeah. So I think this is great. I think it's a great work. I'm glad that the community came together to put it together. My question is what are the next steps and how does this go from words on a paper to real action and priorities and focus and delivering the results that are in here.
[58:11] Yeah. So the next step is to build out what are called blueprints or essentially kind of more formalized the the actions, the steps that need to be taken to achieve the actions that are laid out in the plan. KLA has helped us get a start by identifying five in the plan. They're on the screen now. Some are deal with town operations, others deal with providing
[58:36] support and guidance throughout the community. we have reached out to GPCOG about getting an AmeriCorps fellow, resiliency fellow, which is essentially a professional who has graduated and is looking for more experience in their fields. they don't like to be called interns and I can't blame them.
[58:59] but essentially someone who will come in and help us begin work on implementing this plan because I am your only sustainability staff person. So So any help that I can get is going to be great. So we have our sustainability committee, we have our conservation commission, they're all going to take roles in this. There's a role for the transportation committee especially as it relates to some of our transit work and then just identifying
[59:26] opportunities to work with other community partners and partnering with GPCOG on a resilience and fellow for a 12-month period of time. That's an annual process, so hoping that it will be really successful and we'll be able to then be a host site for a number of years.
[59:44] We need to look to Jamie to tell us give us guidance as we develop budgets so that we provide the resources to be able to fulfill our commitments to the community.
[1:00:00] [1:00:03] I probably should wrap up in the next couple minutes so we can get ready to transition to our next meeting. I can see and hear all the excited little league
[1:00:09] [laughter]
[1:00:11] but definitely appreciate all the work that went into this from staff and Salt Pond community as was noted. And also thank you for bearing with us on the scheduling of this. Thank you for finally being able to have this conversation. Better late than never. In some ways as we're heading really into the heating season
[1:00:35] particularly appropriate to be thinking about these things.
[1:00:37] Can I make one more note before you wrap up that this draft plan is available online at sustainingscarborough.org
[1:00:44] and we are accepting public comment through the website. It'll be open for another week or so and then we'll be passing on feedback to KLA to make some revisions. It has been available for public comment since early September, so it's been a nice long comment period and I've definitely gotten some feedback from the community largely saying thank you for doing this.
[1:01:05] This is great. Definitely some constructive suggestions as well that we're we'll work to implement and learn but really appreciate everybody taking the time to look through the plan and reach out with their comments and suggestions.
[1:01:17] Great. Well, we'll look forward to seeing this special to come back to the council. At least some of us I don't know if I'll still be here.
[1:01:24] Yeah. Thank you very much.
[1:01:25] Thank you.
[1:01:26] Thank you. Thank you. And I'll just make a final plug. Also, Sustainable Scarborough is going to be a long-term resource for keeping track. So, there's an example of a sort of action tracker that we have there. And we are looking to make that work. [1:01:44] to integrate more of our plans into this site so that you'll have a better understanding of how all of the plans that we've done over the past 5 or so years kind of connect and integrate. And so, you can better understand them.
[1:01:58] Great.
[1:01:58] Thank you.
[1:01:59] For everyone, I just want to give a shout-out to Jamie and Mike and all their work up front. But, I was on this advisory group and there was a tremendous amount of participation from senior staff as well in town went to all these meetings. They, for the most part, kind of got assigned as champions of these five focus groups and focus areas.
[1:02:22] So, working forward, they're also making a commitment to making sure they're incorporating all these strategies into the general operation of the town as well.
[1:02:31] They did a great job.
[1:02:33] Can I say two things quickly? You don't have to respond, but have we thought about partnering with businesses at all or like benchmarking with businesses? Cuz I you know, worked at Hanover for a long time and they were sort of a leader on this even like 25 years ago. And they're in our backyard, so that's one thing to think about. They do a lot of, you know, good partnering and support.
[1:02:55] and the second thing is when we take a look at going into our favorite topic, budgeting next year, [clears throat] how do we integrate this and then have a good sense of like, you know, what should we be looking at from a financial perspective as we head into next year?
[1:03:11] I need champion. What do you identify as private work? Including if you need more FD.
[1:03:19] [laughter]
[1:03:26] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you.
[1:03:31] We'll reconvene in seven for a regular meeting.
[1:07:09] Mhm.
[1:10:59] Good evening
[1:11:02] and welcome to the October 21st, 2026 meeting of the Scarborough Town Council. Would you please rise if you're able for the Pledge of Allegiance.
[1:11:14] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[1:11:30] Would you please call the roll?
[1:11:31] Councilor Cloutier
[1:11:32] Here.
[1:11:33] Councilor Cain
[1:11:34] Here.
[1:11:34] Councilor Shinay
[1:11:35] Here.
[1:11:35] Councilor Donavan
[1:11:36] Here. Here.
[1:11:38] Councilor Hayes
[1:11:39] Here.
[1:11:39] Chairman Fellows
[1:11:40] Here.
[1:11:41] All present.
[1:11:41] Thank you. And we're I just a quick note on a housekeeping note. Obviously we're in a different location than we usually are. We're not in Town Council Chamber. We understand the acoustics are a little bit challenging in here and we have a full big room, so we're going to do our best to try to project. Please, you know, flag us down if you're having trouble hearing us at any point.
[1:12:03] At this point, given the fact that we have a room full of special guests, we have a couple of special proclamations that we would like to do. I would like to move the two resolutions, the resolution and the proclamation, items 10.1 and items 10.2 up so that we do those prior to general public comment.
[1:12:26] I would entertain a motion to that effect.
[1:12:28] So moved.
[1:12:28] Second.
[1:12:30] Any discussion? All in favor. Thank you. So having done that, we will now move on to item number 10.1 resolution 26-003
[1:12:43] recognizing the 11U boys All-Star Little League baseball team. Councilor Anderson
[1:12:49] Yes, so the town has had a strong relationship with Scarborough Little League for many years and every time the boys have gone to states, we've tried to recognize them, especially when they win. So, I think for the six years I've been on the council, this is the third time we've had the opportunity to recognize Scarborough Little League and their achievements.
[1:13:09] And I think just even given this past year how we partnered with them to put the lights up, and really allowed the boys to play even more baseball, I think was great that the community was able to support them that way and I think that was great to see that in doing so, we're getting state champions again. And so, I just I love to recognize these kids.
[1:13:29] my son is a big baseball player and he has gone through Scarborough Little League and it was just such a great program and it's great at preparing these boys for many things in life to come, learning teamwork, learning good sportsmanship. And so, I just think it's important that we recognize these great programs in our community.
[1:13:49] [clears throat]
[1:13:49] Thanks, Shawn. before we go ahead and read the proclamation and do that vote, I welcome anyone who would like to come up and speak on behalf of the team.
[1:14:08] Thank you. This is working. Sounds good. All right. so my name is Matt McManus, resident, obviously, of the town. was the head coach of the 11-year-old team. also a board member for the Scarborough Little League for the last three years, I believe so.
[1:14:29] I do want to thank you all for inviting us. The kids are still excited from an epic summer and a great ride. I also want to take the opportunity to thank you all, for supporting our lights project. You know, you know, there's a lot that goes into doing something like that throughout the town.
[1:14:49] What a blast these kids had not only getting more opportunity to be on the field, but playing under the lights with their friends throughout the summer just created some real positive memories. I do want to thank you know the town support where this group we actually hosted our district tournament
[1:15:11] and the amount of volunteers that came out to assist and make sure these games were played and played well and played fair with good sportsmanship etc. A lot of lot of people. I also want to recognize the parents. We had 45 events over the summer, practices, scrimmages, games in Scarborough, Biddeford and all the way down to Beverly, Mass and what a fantastic
[1:15:37] parent group. We never had one issue. They were always willing to help. So it was it took it took a whole community really and you know the kids know how we feel about them, myself and Ryan and Brandon and the other coaches. They were just tremendous kids. They represented this town in the best way.
[1:15:57] I'll always I'll always remember them and I hope they do as well. So thank you.
[1:16:03] Thank you.
[1:16:11] So I'm going to read the proclamation and when I say your name, if you one of the boys can come up and line up here so that way we can do a picture and the chairs can give you guys a pen from the town. So be it resolved by the council of the town of Scarborough, Maine and town council assembled that whereas Little League Baseball is a program of service to the youth of our community dedicated to teaching sportsmanship
[1:16:34] and the competitive will to win as well as furthering physical fitness and well-being throughout our through helpful community activity to provide valuable training for the participants and entertainment for the spectators. And whereas the town of Scarborough has one of the largest Little League programs in the state of Maine and competes [clears throat] in District 6, which includes some of the best Little League baseball and softball teams in the state of Maine.
[1:16:56] And whereas the 2026 Scarborough 11U boys all-star baseball team excelled with tremendous community support and the assistance of many dedicated parents and volunteers. The team demonstrated great commitment, a positive attitude, and a strong sense of teamwork on their championship run. And whereas the Scarborough 11U boys all-star baseball team went undefeated in the District 6 tournament to secure the District 6 championship.
[1:17:19] Including a walk-off victory in an elimination game and a thrilling come-from-behind victory in the District championship final. And whereas the Scarborough 11U boys all-star baseball team advanced to the 11U state championship in Biddeford, Maine, competing against the other District champions in the state. The boys displayed their depth and teamwork as all 12 players contributed to the team's success.
[1:17:41] The team went four and zero four to zero outscoring their opponents 54 to 11 on their way to being named 11U boys all-star state champions. And whereas the Scarborough 11U boys all-star baseball team earned their spot in a regional Little League tournament in Beverly, Massachusetts. The boys beat New Hampshire and Vermont and fell to the eventual tournament champions, Massachusetts, in exciting one-run extra inning game.
[1:18:05] While the boys narrowly missed advancing to the regional final four, they represented Scarborough and the state of Maine tremendously demonstrating great effort, respect, and sportsmanship throughout the tournament. Now therefore, be it resolved by the Scarborough Town Council and Town Council assembled, the following members of the 11U boys all-star baseball team and their coaches are hereby recognized
[1:18:25] for the great honor they have brought to their team, their families, and the town of Scarborough. So first is Benny Capone.
[1:18:39] Yeah. Connelly
[1:18:46] Wyatt Harmon
[1:18:52] Blake Harmon
[1:18:58] Aidan McManus
[1:19:05] Donte Memms
[1:19:11] Owen O'Donnell
[1:19:16] Owen Paul
[1:19:21] Honor Pettit
[1:19:25] Everett Pettit
[1:19:30] Susan Miller
[1:19:35] Duke Medina
[1:19:38] And manager Matt McManus and assistant Brian Cutrone and Brandon Wine.
[1:19:52] Let's do the picture, everybody.
[1:20:01] Make sure they're in the First not last. Yeah, let's go.
[1:20:07] [laughter]
[1:20:19] [clears throat]
[1:20:22] [laughter]
[1:20:34] Thank you.
[1:20:35] You also have
[1:20:52] Thanks, guys.
[1:21:03] Thank you.
[1:21:13] Thank you very much.
[1:21:28] It must be a place where Rogers was made.
[1:21:38] All right.
[1:21:41] Moving on to our other proclamation, item number 10.2, proclamation 26-006,
[1:21:49] declaring the month of October as
[1:21:51] Yeah.
[1:21:51] Oh.
[1:21:52] I need to speak. Sorry.
[1:21:54] Do we
[1:21:54] We actually did.
[1:21:55] Vote on it.
[1:21:58] [laughter]
[1:22:00] I guess we better make it official.
[1:22:02] Yeah.
[1:22:03] So, I move to put it on the floor.
[1:22:05] Second.
[1:22:07] Any discussion? All in favor, say aye.
[1:22:09] Thank you.
[1:22:10] [laughter]
[1:22:11] Oh, it's legal.
[1:22:15] All right.
[1:22:17] Now, moving on to our next item, number 10.2, proclamation 26-006,
[1:22:25] declaring the month of October, as dysautonomia awareness month. I'd like to introduce Colleen Ammon, who I believe is here, to say a few words about this.
[1:22:38] [clears throat]
[1:22:39] my name is Colleen Ammon, and my daughter, Molly, has autoimmune dysautonomia. Dysautonomia is an umbrella term used to describe various conditions that cause a malfunction of the autonomic nervous system. The autonomic nervous system controls most of the essential functions of the body that we do not consciously think about, such as heart rate, blood pressure, digestion,
[1:23:02] dilation and constriction of the pupils of the eye, and temperature control. I'm also the chair of the Dysautonomia International Maine support group. I became involved with Dysautonomia International as a result of our journey, which began 13 years ago. When Molly was in eighth grade, she came down with a mono-like virus.
[1:23:24] The virus lingered, symptoms changed, and symptoms worsened. We saw multiple doctors, and after 2 and 1/2 years, Molly received the diagnosis of POTS, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome. Some of you may have heard of POTS as a result of COVID. POTS is a condition in which a person's heart rate increases by over 30 beats per minute when they move from lying or sitting to standing
[1:23:52] because of abnormal blood flow. POTS can cause dizziness, blacking out, and passing out. Researchers compare the disability seen in POTS to the disability seen in congestive heart failure or COPD. Currently, there's no cure. Over the past 13 years, Molly has continued to manage the good days and bad days that come with this condition.
[1:24:17] She has seen or consulted with multiple specialists in Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Texas, and Wisconsin. Dysautonomia International, first started in 2012, is a 501c3 nonprofit that seeks to improve the lives of over 70 million individuals around the world living with disorders of the autonomic nervous system.
[1:24:44] They offer patient and physician education resources, community outreach, legislative advocacy, and patient support for all autonomic disorders. They've raised over $4 million for research and support. I'm here tonight because October is Dysautonomia Awareness Month.
[1:25:06] It took us 2 and 1/2 years to get a diagnosis for Ali, and we were considered lucky. It takes an average of 4 years for a patient to be diagnosed with POTS, largely because of lack of awareness. Interestingly, though, POTS is actually more common than multiple sclerosis. Maine does not currently have an autonomic disorder specialist
[1:25:27] or testing lab. There's only six specialists and seven testing labs in all of New England. I am requesting a proclamation from the town of Scarborough to recognize October as Dysautonomia Awareness Month. My hope is that by raising awareness, the journey for current and not yet diagnosed patients might not be as long and difficult as ours has been.
[1:25:52] My hope is that we will receive more funding to do more research, so we will one day find a cure. Speaking of fundraising, on Sunday, October 25th, El Rodeo, here in Scarborough, will be hosting a fundraiser from 4 to 9. 10% of all eat-in and takeout orders will go to Dysautonomia International.
[1:26:13] I'd really like to thank you, Corey, for sponsoring the proclamation, but I'd like to thank you all for your time and consideration. Thank you.
[1:26:22] Thank you. Thank you, Molly.
[1:26:29] [1:26:30] Corey, is it okay if Molly speaks?
[1:26:32] Of course. Please. Thank you.
[1:26:42] Hi guys. My name is Molly Emmen, I'm a community member here in Scarborough. Mom,
[1:26:47] That was my fault.
[1:26:48] So, I'm her daughter. so, I want to share with you why this proclamation is important to me. Why it's important that I raise awareness for dysautonomia. So, if you go if you guys were to look at me, you would think I was a normal, healthy person, but for the past 13 years I've been living with
[1:27:02] Not normal.
[1:27:04] [laughter]
[1:27:05] I'm sorry. For the past 13 years I've been living with a condition called dysautonomia, which is an invisible illness. I got sick at the age of 13 with a virus that never resolved. I became bedridden my entire eighth grade year of school. I had constant headaches and fatigue and was being bounced around from doctor to doctor.
[1:27:25] It took over 2 years for me to come close to a diagnosis. I was finally diagnosed with POTS, which my mom just explained was postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome. So, this leads to me feeling dizzy and blocking out upon standing. Following this diagnosis of POTS, I was able to then see a neurologist who diagnosed me with autoimmune dysautonomia and small fiber neuropathy.
[1:27:46] Due to all these conditions, I deal with daily symptoms including fatigue, GI issues, nausea, vomiting, headaches, migraines, chronic pain, as well as temperature sensitivity. For almost all of high school and college, I spent days I spent multiple days going into the hospital monthly and I was there for two or three nights receiving a treatment called IVIG.
[1:28:08] This helped regulate my immune system and helped me stabilize so I can fight this condition. as my dad said, I'm not normal. But if you were to look at me, you would not know that over the past 2 years I've spent over 150 nights in the hospital. I've survived months for months on a feeding tube. I fought life-threatening infections and went through surgeries.
[1:28:30] And we've consulted with numerous specialists in both Maine and out of state. So for me, it's important that I raise awareness for dysautonomia because it took me over 2 years to just be diagnosed with this condition. There's not a lot of research or information about this disease, and there's still not a standard treatment plan for dysautonomia. So if my story can just help one person get diagnosed sooner, it's worth sharing because I know how hard
[1:28:54] it is to deal with this condition, and I don't want anyone else to feel as alone as I felt at times. So thank you for listening to this story. and I appreciate your time and support. Thank you.
[1:29:18] All right. With that, we do have a proclamation, which I will read now. proclamation 26-006, a proclamation for dysautonomia awareness for the month of October. Whereas dysautonomia is a group of medical conditions that result in a malfunction of the au- autonomic nervous system, which is responsible for the automatic bodily functions such as respiration,
[1:29:44] heart rate, blood pressure, digestion, temperature control, and more. And whereas dysautonomia impacts over 70 million people around the world and includes conditions such as diabetic autonomic neuropathy, neurogenic orthostatic hypotension, and postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome. And whereas dysau- dysautonomia impacts people of any age, gender, race, or background, including many individuals living in Scarborough.
[1:30:12] And whereas some forms of dysautonomia can be very disabling, and this disability can result in social isolation, stress on the families of those impacted, and financial hardship. And whereas some forms of dysautonomia can result in death, causing tremendous pain and suffering for those impacted and their loved ones. And whereas increased awareness about dysautonomia will help patients get diagnosed and treated earlier, save lives, and foster support for individuals and families coping with dysautonomia in our community.
[1:30:42] And whereas Dysautonomia International, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that advocates on behalf of patients living with dysautonomia, encourages communities to celebrate Dysautonomia Awareness Month each October around the world. And whereas we seek to recognize the contributions of the professional medical community, patients, and family members who are working to educate our citizenry about dysautonomia in Maine.
[1:31:08] Now, therefore be it resolved that the Scarborough Town Council does hereby proclaim the month of October as Dysautonomia Awareness Month. Signed and dated this 21st day of October, 2026, on behalf of the Scarborough Town Council and the Town Manager of Scarborough, Maine.
[1:31:27] Yeah, a motion?
[1:31:28] So moved.
[1:31:29] Second.
[1:31:30] Any discussion?
[1:31:31] [clears throat]
[1:31:32] Yeah, just sometimes there's a time for applause in a council meeting.
[1:31:39] Yes.
[1:31:40] Yeah.
[1:31:41] I agree. We saw that tonight.
[1:31:43] Absolutely. Thank you.
[1:31:46] I'd like to thank Colleen and Molly for sharing their story and their journey on this. and for helping to educate all of us and great everything that you're doing. We certainly wish you all the best going forward.
[1:32:04] All in favor of confirmation? That's unanimous. Thank you.
[1:32:24] Do you have a signed version here?
[1:32:30] Thanks again.
[1:32:31] Thank you.
[1:32:31] Well done.
[1:32:32] Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:32:40] Now, shifting gears. moving on to item number four. This will be a general public comment. this is for items that are not on our agenda this evening. just ask that everyone follow the regular protocol, 3 minutes or less. please state your name and address. [clears throat] we don't have a light system in here, so our assistant town manager will be our timekeeper.
[1:33:02] [laughter] He's going to give you a sign. He'll give you a look if you're if you're running over. with that, I will open it up to general public comment.
[1:33:16] April Hill, 8 Laurel Avenue. Can you hear me?
[1:33:18] Yes.
[1:33:20] I read the report from Community Services regarding dog violations on the beach for the 2016 season. It represents, quote, interactions through the lines of park rangers, animal control officer, and reserve officer, end According to the report summary, it states, quote, in relation to the animal control ordinance, there were 181 related communications, including 24 off-leash on beach warnings, 18 off-leash in the lot warnings, 14 in restricted areas, 71 off-leash after hours warnings,
[1:33:50] and 54 miscellaneous explanations of dog ordinance violations. In separate documentation for plover monitors, their data summary noted 325 violations. There is likely overlap by sea. While the police note that the plover numbers are good this year, there were still reports of dogs harassing them and reports of dog waste raising concerns of beach sanitation and water quality.
[1:34:12] A cormorant had to be euthanized due to what appeared to be a dog bite. And maybe not surprisingly, we have a new source of violators on our beach. People riding e-bikes. 32 violations reported. This is not just an issue of plovers and dog owners. These violators, many of whom are not locals, impact well-behaved dogs and their respectful owners, the elderly, disabled, children, people afraid of dogs, and other wildlife.
[1:34:37] I have seen separate reports of unleashed dogs attacking leashed dogs and people stating they no longer go to the beach with their dogs because of this. I want to be clear that I am not speaking now to make a case for any ordinance change. I am, however, speaking to two concerns I feel very strongly about. First is the need for a policy of transparency from the town in reference to public data that informs decisions affecting all of us.
[1:35:01] The public has the right to have easy access to an annual report that will shape our public safety ordinances, policies, and budget. Every year will present new numbers and challenges and hopefully some wins. Scarborough taxpayers by having supported these reports, it's not privileged information. Second, it seems to me that the town may need to invest in more enforcement regardless of whether or not there are ordinance changes.
[1:35:24] Plover monitors do not have the authority to enforce our ordinances, nor should they be placed in that position. We do not We do not have an ACO working after hours and on weekends. The way to get buy-in from taxpayers is to share the facts. Finally, I'd like to publicly dispel the myth that secret data was shared with the state last year. What was submitted to the state was public data that our sustainability coordinator had already submitted to them, as she does annually as required by our agreement with them.
[1:35:52] This is a community problem and we need to figure out how to work together to solve it. Selective transparency is not how democracy works or how trust is earned. It's definitely not how problems are solved. I'm formally requesting that the town post the report summary to its dedicated public page annually starting this year. Thank you.
[1:36:11] Thank you.
[1:36:20] Denise Hamilton, 2 Red Road. I'm shorter so my phone looks better. Tonight, I want to raise a concern about how Scarborough determines whether proposed land use is permitted, particularly when that use isn't specifically identified in our land use ordinance. At Monday night's planning board meeting, the planning director explained that determining whether a proposed use falls under classification
[1:36:45] such as high technology facility is currently administrative decision potentially involving legal counsel. I want to be very clear. I am not questioning the planning director's knowledge, ability, or judgment. My concern is with the process itself. High technology facility is a broad subjective classification
[1:37:05] that can encompass entirely new types of development never contemplated when our ordinance was written. But just because something might fit within a broad definition doesn't necessarily mean that it's an appropriate use for that zoning district or that it was ever intended to be permitted. Our land use ordinance is prohibitory in nature, meaning uses not expressly permitted are generally prohibited, and the town council has a legislative responsibility
[1:37:35] for establishing permitted land uses. There's an important difference between interpreting an existing ordinance and effectively determining that entirely new type of land use is permitted. I believe that when a proposed use isn't specifically identified and requires a subjective interpretation under a broad classification,
[1:37:55] there should be a formal public review process involving the ordinance committee and town council. That process should determine whether the proposed use was intended to be permitted or whether an ordinance amendment is necessary to allow it. Rather than finding ourselves adopting a moratoriums or amended ordinances to specifically exclude a use, the question should first be whether that use was ever intended to be permitted.
[1:38:21] If a use isn't expressly permitted, our prohibitory ordinance provides the starting point. If the town wishes to allow a new or undefined use, that should be considered through a transparent public process. We've seen the complications that can arise when a land use are addressed through administrative policies rather than clear ordinances as we experienced with short-term rentals.
[1:38:45] While a formal public review process may seem like additional work up front, it could prevent considerably more work, costly legal disputes, and potential litigation down the road. More importantly, decisions affecting neighborhoods, natural resources, and surrounding properties deserve that level of public oversight. This isn't about taking authority away from town staff.
[1:39:07] It's about ensuring that decisions establishing what land uses are permitted go through the appropriate public process. With three councilors being elected November 3rd and sworn in November 18th, I ask the newly seated council to prioritize reviewing this process and establishing appropriate safeguards for public oversight.
[1:39:28] Thank you.
[1:39:29] Thank you.
[1:39:33] Anyone else in the room for a general public comment?
[1:39:39] Do you have someone online?
[1:39:43] Sophie, you should be able to speak.
[1:39:45] Hello. I am here remotely. I apologize. I am here to share some brief comments with everyone, and I hope you can hear me. my name is Sophie Warren. I'm I have the privilege Oh. can you hear me? I'm so sorry.
[1:40:03] Yes, we can hear you very well.
[1:40:06] Great. Okay, thank you so much. I apologize. I've got the privilege of representing part of Scarborough in the main legislature. I wanted to buzz in tonight remotely during public comment because I wanted to share a concern that I've heard from a resident that I represent that we all represent about a reported installation of a Flock camera by the Market Basket in Scarborough.
[1:40:32] And I can't confirm whether that report is true or not, but it does raise a broader issue that I didn't realize had come to Scarborough, and certainly it might come to Scarborough. And so I wanted to ask the council if they could take some time to consider action on Flock in an effort to protect the privacy of the people that we serve.
[1:40:57] I do appreciate the importance of providing public safety with effective tools to investigate crimes, keep our community safe. I have serious concerns, however, with the use of Flock surveillance cameras and similar styles and mechanisms of technology of collecting and storing this information about movements of ordinary residents.
[1:41:19] what's different about these these cameras, they don't simply capture a photograph of a vehicle involved in a crime. They can create a searchable record of where people travel, where they when they travel, potentially reveal patterns about their daily lives. there's just quite significant questions and incidents across the country in relation to the privacy, particularly of vulnerable populations and the use of the technology and database that this can facilitate.
[1:41:51] Culver residents should not have to surrender their reasonable expectation of privacy simply because this technology makes widespread surveillance possible. particularly thinking about tonight and the great work that you all have considered and are doing the potential for information collected locally to be accessed or shared with outside law enforcement agencies, including federal immigration authorities, or used for purposes our community never intended.
[1:42:18] Even well-intended surveillance programs can create opportunities for misuse, particularly when oversight and accountability fail to keep pace with technology. so just moving forward, I would urge the council to require a transparent public discussion, clear evidence of the technology's effectiveness, and perhaps a consideration of whether we want to continue
[1:42:41] to have these be a possible use for the purposes of public safety considering the just enormous privacy concerns they bring forward. that's certainly something that I would be happy to be to speak on further if you all do find it's something you want to bring as part of a formal more formal discussion, but it certainly was very concerning to hear, and I appreciate all the work you're doing in so many realms, but wanted to throw something
[1:43:11] something more at you and thank you all for the great work that you all do. And that's all for me. I'm going to try to get off here now. Thank you.
[1:43:20] Thank you.
[1:43:24] Anyone else?
[1:43:27] One last call for anyone in the room for general public comment. All right, thank you. that brings us to the minutes of the September 30th, 2026 Town Council meeting. Do we have a motion?
[1:43:40] So moved.
[1:43:41] Second.
[1:43:41] Any discussion? All in favor?
[1:43:46] One abstention.
[1:43:47] One abstention. Thank you, Scott. Councilor D'Arcy abstained. moving on, item number six, adjustments to the agenda. We did move the resolutions up earlier. item number seven, items to be signed, treasurer's warrants. I signed those prior to the meeting. pass those along. That takes us to item number eight, the assistant town manager's report.
[1:44:11] [clears throat]
[1:44:11] Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll do my best to do my Tom Holland impression. So, I guess just I guess I would like to just start with the last public comment. we're certainly not aware of any Flock cameras installed in town. It's certainly not an activity of our police department. that technology was
[1:44:33] brought forward for consideration a long time ago, and we chose not to advance that. That was even prior to some of the more recent public controversy. so, to the degree a camera does exist, it's it's not a town initiative. and I would I would just generally have some questions about
[1:44:54] what sort of systems that camera could access, cuz we're talking about board vehicle information. So, certainly happy to look into it and speak with Representative Warren, but that's not an initiative of the town.
[1:45:08] Liam, when she was saying that with Marco Basket, I believe I read in the news or heard that there was situation maybe in Westborough with that, and that it's since been disabled, but I don't know if, you know, if wants to do that on their own, do they have to go through a process
[1:45:29] to have that approved or to get permitting or I don't I don't think I understand like what the precursor would be to then actually installing something.
[1:45:37] Yeah, it's a good question. I mean certainly private businesses have the ability to put their own surveillance cameras and security systems in place. I think the technology around flock cameras and other technology is just as the representative cited is a different proposition. Yeah. So again, I can't I can't speak to what that is, but I can certainly reassure
[1:46:00] the audience and public that this is [clears throat] not a Scarborough Police Department doing that. Thank you. so just to go down my punch list data centers on your agenda this evening. There's a number of two items specifically pertaining to data centers. One is the proposed addition of a definition which you entertain a second reading on our public hearing this evening second reading on November 4th.
[1:46:26] There's also on your agenda an action item that contemplates the process to revoke the moratorium as the definition is no longer potentially required. Otherwise the moratorium is slated and November 20th. So your work should you choose to move forward with that will be concluded by that deadline.
[1:46:48] IF&W update and I know there's a comment from the podium about dogs on beaches. I do have a brief update to this. So we did reach out to IF&W to have an in-person meeting. That meeting's actually scheduled for October 30th. My understanding is that some counselors will attend that in addition to staff
[1:47:09] to advance a review of the beach management ordinance. So that will be happening and that process will start October 30th. My understanding from the manager is that will be an agreement that gets brought back for some council feedback and public participation and visibility. So, stay tuned on that. Portland West, this is again the successor agreement to the MTA project that was it was not advanced.
[1:47:35] And there was well attended meeting back in September. There are some alternative approaches that are being advertised. There's some additional information on our website about that project. Election update. Absentee or person absentee voting has been very popular this year. so far they the town clerk's office as of 5:00 p.m.
[1:47:56] this evening has issued over 6,000 ballots. that's almost a third of our registered voters. 4,700 over 4,700 have been returned to date. And so that's still with a number of weeks left. And less than less than 2 weeks, but left with absentee. also just want to make mention that in -person absentee voting is available this Saturday, October 24th from 8:00 to noon at town hall.
[1:48:22] So, there is a Saturday date for people to vote in person absentee.
[1:48:29] Paving update. Pine Point neighborhoods were done last week. Old Neck neighborhood is was contemplated [clears throat] for this week. I'm not sure if they were able to start or not. we're still looking for an estimate on a stretch of Holmes Road. So, I do know that 's still in the plan for this year before they shut down due to the seasonal nature.
[1:48:50] Metro update. There was a ribbon cutting on October 2nd. You know a number of people attended and it was very well received. service is up and running. We'll look to provide periodic updates to the council on ridership and other participation. we'll note that it's it's free to ride on election day. It's also free to ride through the month of October.
[1:49:10] Can you hear me? Can you speak up?
[1:49:12] Okay. I'll do my best.
[1:49:13] so, get out and try that service if you can. low impact development ordinance, this is work that will be done by staff and brought through the ordinance committee in early 2027. these are main DEP standards or they set the standards to requirement of our municipal permit.
[1:49:35] so, work will need to be done on this. This is not an optional initiative. There may be some enhancements that staff brings forward for some consideration, but that will go through the public process of the Town Council ordinance committee. just to bring some awareness, pesticide application to Wiley Field on November 23rd. this is going to be a pesticide application.
[1:49:55] They did seek a waiver through the Conservation Commission, and people will need to stay off field the field for 48 hours. so, just bringing some awareness to that. Upcoming Town Council events, so bittersweet ones. November 4th will be the send-off for Councilors Donovan and Anderson. and November 18th will be a welcome reception for our newly elected councilors.
[1:50:17] and then again, some good community events. the fire department had a public safety open house on the 15th. It by my account, it was really pretty well attended and a great success. I know we had the fire marshal's office down here doing a demonstration burn for sprinkler rooms versus non-sprinkler rooms, as well as just a good open house for some of our staff and equipment.
[1:50:40] Project Grace had a food drive on Saturday. Stephanie Cox is the executive director, so it was an overwhelming success. Over 50 people donated food and donations to their to their drive, and she wanted to make it a point to thank the VIPs, Rotary, library staff. there is another opportunity to donate on November 7th, their annual fixings food drive, where they look for traditional Thanksgiving sides to be donated, and that will be November
[1:51:10] 7th from 10:00 to noon at the Enclave on 18 Black Walnut Road.
[1:51:16] Few more things, bear with me. National Drug Take Back Day, October 24th here at the Public Safety Building from 10:00 to 2:00. So, any accrued or unused prescriptions can be returned here to be destroyed safely. And just two more things. the fifth annual Junior Firefighter Muster will be October 25th.
[1:51:40] This is again a tremendous community event that's put on by our fire staff to bring some of our junior firefighters in the community and surrounding communities that to participate in the competition. it's been a phenomenal feeder program for us. We've hired a number of former participants in our full-time fire department and you know, Darren Granada and the rest of the command staff really do a phenomenal job hosting.
[1:52:03] So, that's another great community event. Scotto Hill Road was not on my report, but just to provide an update we did hear that the MIAF grant decision we should have in hand by October 30th. So, that will be the information I think necessary for the council to [clears throat] forge a path forward on that.
[1:52:22] Yeah, that's good.
[1:52:23] and then last thing on October 26th as I think most people know, we have a radio project as a referendum item. there will be an information session here at Public Safety at 6:00 p.m. that is unique to that. I know that we have had some staff
[1:52:40] Mhm.
[1:52:40] go through the conversations with councilors events provide some additional information. there's one more event. I guess I'll plug them sure someone else will as well. This Saturday at 10:00 a.m. 10:30 a.m. here at Public Safety and we will have some Public Safety staff to present and be available for questions on that project. So, that's my efficient work group.
[1:53:02] Thanks, Steve.
[1:53:02] Appreciate it.
[1:53:03] Any questions?
[1:53:05] [laughter]
[1:53:07] I'm sorry, I didn't hear you.
[1:53:11] Then prompt to respond to the fact that some handwritten additions I get to see it every other week.
[1:53:17] Yeah,. We can encourage Tom to do Liam Gallagher in the
[1:53:21] [laughter]
[1:53:25] This one when I try to stump Liam with any follow-up questions or comments.
[1:53:28] [laughter]
[1:53:29] I have a couple of questions. So, you had emailed us with a public comment about the materials on the data for 2026 in the beaches. Is that all the material that was provided the council also provided IF&W?
[1:53:41] I don't know the answer to that question.
[1:53:43] I would imagine that would be
[1:53:44] I imagine it will be if it hasn't already.
[1:53:47] And then, I just wanted to comment. I was going to talk about the low impact development workshop at committee updates, but since you brought it up, I just wanted to say I attended it cuz I'm liaison to the Conservation Commission that's come through. So, I think the workshop it was the first workshop that we've done for it. It went really well, got a lot of good feedback and support for it. I just, you know, I kind of want to put this out there. We've been working on this for a long time. And so, I appreciate staff.
[1:54:09] I Autumn, Angela, and Jamie did a really good job presenting it, I think. And so, we're going to be seeing a lot of this stuff coming through
[1:54:18] And then, I also attended the fire department public safety open house, which was a great. There was a really great attendance, and then they had the fire marshal who did this huge demonstration. So, I just wanted to give another shout-out cuz there was so much staff there, so many questions were answered, random questions, about the communication thing, all of that. So, I just wanted to say thank you for that as well.
[1:54:41] What else? All right. Good. Thanks again. That takes us to item number nine, which is standing and special committee reports and liaison reports. Kick it off with you, Scott. All right.
[1:54:56] finance did not meet this month. the schools, I just want to remind everybody there's the first forum for the school building project on November 17th. I believe we're still confirming the location partly because of a lot of this which are going to be here. Chair, board chair, Mr. Misner told me that it is going to be located here.
[1:55:17] and that'll be the first opportunity kind of give an update on the whole construction project, where we are as far as design development, budgeting, whole number of things. That's a great opportunity for the public to catch up on that. If you attended any of the forums on the actual building committee prior to the referendum, it'll be a similar format to that with the representatives from the design group, Harriman Architects,
[1:55:47] and school staff leadership as well. I want to thank Chamber of Commerce and SEDCO for running two different nights of candidate forums this year. with the number of candidates running, I think it was really helpful to get that information out and be able to compare and contrast people's answers. and so they ran a great event for that.
[1:56:09] It was really worthwhile. And that's all I got. Thanks.
[1:56:14] Thank you. Okay.
[1:56:15] Thanks. so the planning board met this Monday and they reviewed some of the stuff that's before us this evening, including the sign ordinance and the data center ordinance and the moratorium. Or the [clears throat] just the that we're not allowing it. and then also I just wanted to mention because they had a lot of public comment. I 'm not a Higgins Beach girl, I'm down at Pine Point there, but I guess the Breakers
[1:56:37] is under new ownership and they have they're doing somewhat of a transition from opening their restaurant to the public. And so they got a substantial amount of public support that evening. And so I think it'll be interesting to see kind of how that little neighborhood plays out. That was a big thing with the for the planning board this week. and then the, you know, we have the conservation commission who's always working on something, and they're working on a community stewardship guide, which would basically be for the residents to kind of just guide them and explain to them how it's good to be a sustainable member
[1:57:07] of your community. That's all I got.
[1:57:09] Thank you. Bill?
[1:57:11] No, none of my committees met.
[1:57:13] John?
[1:57:14] transportation meets on Monday. They're going to be reviewing traffic calming conceptual plan reviews for Payne Road at Two Rod Road intersection, Two Rod Road from Payne Road to Scottow Hill Road and Scottow Hill Road at Two Rod Road intersection. So I expect to see Denise there, for sure.
[1:57:31] [laughter]
[1:57:31] But I'm I'm sure a lot of residents are interested in that. again, I think as we've gone through a lot of the conversations with councilors, one of the themes I think that keeps emerging is traffic safety
[1:57:42] Yes.
[1:57:43] and traffic calming, and so I know that's a huge priority for our community. we used to talk more and more about congestion
[1:57:51] Yeah.
[1:57:51] when I was first on the council, and I feel like the conversation has started to shift more towards safety, more so than congestion, and so I just think as the council moves forward, it'll be important to keep that top of mind and hopefully really make updating the traffic calming policy a priority for next year, because I think that's going to help with all the traffic safety issues that are coming our way.
[1:58:14] SEDCO, the annual 41st annual celebration of business is this Tuesday, which I think all of us will hopefully be at. I forgot to RSVP, but I will be there.
[1:58:26] I'll see you [laughter] there in the audience.
[1:58:27] and so that starts at 5:30. So that's that's always such a fun event to be at. Karen does such a phenomenal job talking about all the great metrics and impacts that the business community has had to Scarborough, and so it's just one of my favorite things to attend. So if you haven't been, I would highly encourage you to go on Tuesday, the 27th.
[1:58:49] I'll pass it to Michelle to talk about communications.
[1:58:52] Yeah, thank you, John. a couple things I it was mentioned our last conversations with counselors for this quarter is public safety building here on Saturday from 10:30 to 12. There's a lot going on at the town hall and public safety building on Saturday. we've had four sessions this quarter and it's just kind of the topics that have been sort of consistent across
[1:59:15] the radio tower and I appreciate staff showing up with those and being able to answer a lot of questions and specifics. traffic and road safety and it's not even just there. I mean, everywhere I bumped into some people at the beach yesterday who said, "We love the new Eastern Trail. what are you going to do about e-bikes because I almost got killed." and it's just I think that safety piece is becoming more and more profound.
[1:59:41] another topic is sidewalks and more walkability in town. e-bikes and then one suggestion we got, which I think is a really good one, is having a lead topic for each counselor with conversation session and maybe spending some time on that so people come ready to focus on one topic and then at the end maybe having some open time to kind of have an open forum.
[2:00:05] So, that's then thanks to everybody who's come and we will keep those going. the second committee was just long-range planning committee which Corey and I participated in and once again, it's when I looked at the Karen's I mean, send me some notes today. I said, "Remind me what we talked about 2 weeks ago." And one of the biggest things was traffic versus congestion versus safety.
[2:00:30] And taking a look at different traffic flows in town and looking at Dunstan and saying, "It's not that there's necessarily more cars flowing through there than there were, but it's just a level of congestion." And also conversation, which thought was really powerful was having some conversations with Saco and the Maine Turnpike Association to say, "A lot of people get off the turnpike
[2:00:56] and they're using it as a pass-through. So, is there a way to have a new exit off there that kind of bypasses a lot of Route 1 that helps with the safety issue and actually helps with the congestion issue with the 30% of people flowing through to Scarborough with that really don't live in Scarborough." So, if I If you guys can jump in, but I think the overall thing was just looking at traffic, safety,
[2:01:21] congestion, and how do we strategically go about it moving forward and plan for what's coming next as opposed to getting into a challenging situation and then saying, "Now, what do we do?" So, it was a good conversation.
[2:01:38] Thank you. I was sorry to miss that last that last long-range planning committee but, but to hear that some more good conversations are ongoing. I Since the last meeting, there was a participated in a remote meeting of the Maine Municipal Association Legislative Policy Committee.
[2:02:00] they've arrived at the five or six items that they plan to focus on with the new with the new legislature. And as I reported previously, they It's kind of a common thread around, common themes around revenue sharing with the state to try to try to, improve things at the municipal level for things like school funding,
[2:02:23] Yeah.
[2:02:23] potentially, reduce the reliance on property taxes, which there's been discussion separately about a regional option sales tax, which, MMA is not planning on sponsoring per se, but there seems to be a lot of support there. And then generally, themes around home rule and kind of hitting the pause button on state mandates on housing and things like that. So, a little bit of that is redundant from what I said last time, but those of those have been approved and will at the broad committee level and are now will now go to the
[2:02:54] executive committee for formal adoption heading into the new year and then at that point the staff at MMA will really dig in and start working with the legislature.
[2:03:04] I have a question.
[2:03:05] quick question, when you said less mandates on housing, how does that complement or sort of con- conflict with LD 2173?
[2:03:15] I think the way it's the way it's been discussed is recognized that LD 2173 is yet to really be rolled out and fully implemented and so let communities digest that.
[2:03:27] Yeah.
[2:03:28] and let's see how that works and see what kinks might need to be worked out and not have something else coming right down the pike before communities have had a chance to kind of adapt and I think we're we're we have some unique challenges here, but we're fortunate in that we have a pretty robust planning staff and a lot of more capacity than a lot of communities have to even handle kind of the administrative aspects of it.
[2:03:52] al- although even in Scarborough, that's going to take some time and then obviously that the actual policy changes and what that means for how we manage growth remains to be seen in some ways.
[2:04:04] Thank you.
[2:04:04] Thank you. beyond that I John mentioned the event the civic event on Tuesday. forward to attending that and I did attend the ribbon cutting on October 2nd for Metro. It's a great day. Got to take a ride over to park and ride. and it was it was an exciting day and I've been glad to kind of see the buses on the road and I look forward to seeing what the intake on that is going forward.
[2:04:31] Or just one thing I meant to bring up earlier, but I the Calavale, are they going down there now? I think I heard that
[2:04:41] They are, yes. Yes, Tom had reported that during our last meeting a few weeks ago that I think it was that day that they had sort of
[2:04:49] Right. Right, that's good to
[2:04:50] time that they were going to do that, so.
[2:04:52] I think they actually all came to town hall voted early. Is that correct? They went to lunch? The whole like seven of them.
[2:05:00] I think there's a photo of all of them up on the website about that, so. Yeah, very happy to see that. Well, but thanks for asking.
[2:05:10] What's the time of the school meeting there?
[2:05:16] Sorry. I didn't have a chance, so wouldn't give it.
[2:05:23] You can follow up offline on the
[2:05:26] Any loose ends?
[2:05:27] Yeah.
[2:05:28] All right. Thanks, everyone.
[2:05:30] Thank you.
[2:05:31] All right. So, that takes us to public hearings, and I will note that the next few items are public hearings only. We won't have any council deliberation or action. We'll have the opportunity for public comment. And then we do have a couple of public hearings, the last two that are that will be followed by council action. [2:05:52] So, kicking things off, item 11.1 order number 26-073, 7:00 p.m. public hearing on the proposed amendments to chapter 405 zoning ordinance section six definitions to add and amend definitions pertaining to timber harvesting and updating commercial zoning districts
[2:06:12] to increase streetscape buffer minimum requirements to 20 ft for all streets.
[2:06:18] Thank you, Mr. Chair. Autumn Spear, the planning director for the town. You all considered this at first reading on September 2nd, so it has been quite some time. There's been a break in the meetings. We did take this to planning board at their last meeting in September as well and they have included some brief comments for your consideration as you move this forward.
[2:06:40] This item is in conjunction with the next item. This first part is amending the zoning districts to increase the streetscape buffer width essentially for all of the roads outside of the primary arterials in town. And it's also including a couple of definitions related to timber. I'm happy to answer any questions.
[2:07:00] All right. Thank you. With that I'll I'm going to use the gavel for this. Why not? I'm going to open the public hearing on this.
[2:07:10] Any takers? All right, I'll close I'll open the hearing to the council.
[2:07:14] [laughter]
[2:07:16] It's probably not sustainable getting all this stuff.
[2:07:20] [laughter]
[2:07:21] So again I would anticipate that this and the other the next item which is sort of going to be held in an item that see this on our agenda for second reading or at that meeting I'll open this up to Moving on to 11.2 order number 26-074
[2:07:38] 7:00 p.m. public hearing on a proposed amendment to chapter 405B site plan review ordinance section two applicability section three application and review procedures and section four performance and design standards section B landscape and screening standards.
[2:07:56] Thank you again and as I mentioned this one does work with the previous order. This one really addresses the site plan standards and this one I would say has more to it. There are some administrative requests that we're asking for to clear up and some consistency on how we process applications but there are also tree preservation requirements.
[2:08:17] We increased proposing to increase the tree buffer requirements. We have taken out the residential applicability that did not at your first reading that was a topic that you all requested that be removed, so that did not get even taken to planning board for consideration. but this one if there any questions that you have, I'm happy to answer those.
[2:08:39] It does have quite a bit more consequence, I would say.
[2:08:43] Okay. Thank you. now I'll open the public hearing on this item. What's Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing.
[2:08:53] And we will forward seeing that going forward.
[2:08:57] Well, we got any public comments
[2:08:59] No comments.
[2:09:00] No, it's just a public hearing for that.
[2:09:02] Just for that.
[2:09:03] Yeah.
[2:09:03] Yeah, we'll have opportunity for further deliberation once back in our agenda and for second reading.
[2:09:10] item number 11.3
[2:09:14] Order number Order number 26-080 7:00 p.m. public hearing and second reading on the proposed changes to chapter 405 Town of Scarborough Zoning Ordinance section 12J temporary signs.
[2:09:30] So this is an item that's gone through ordinance. It's also gone through a first reading. in brief, essentially requires that or allows for the town's municipal sign ordinance temporary sign ordinance to comply with the state statute. we found an inconsistency in that. as well as incorporates restrictions on where those can be placed.
[2:09:53] we are also staff is also asking for a friendly amendment to allow I think that the ordinance as considered previously would be enforced by the code enforcement officer. We're just asking that to be the code enforcement officer or designate. some of these sign ordinances, especially when they're off cycle, are enforced by our volunteers of the police service or other staff. So, I'm looking to change any substantive of but I think that help with the enforcement component to it.
[2:10:17] And that amendment is in your packet.
[2:10:21] Thank you.
[2:10:23] we'll open the public hearing for this item.
[2:10:28] Seeing none, we'll close the public hearing. Do we have a motion?
[2:10:32] can I can I say something? I just want to ask how many how reasonable is it to enforce the sign ordinance? And how many how much time is it taking town resources to deal with it? I'm just curious.
[2:10:51] Thank you. Good question. I'm going to look to Brian, more the expert in this field.
[2:10:55] I believe the clerk has the VITs going out twice a week.
[2:11:00] Okay.
[2:11:01] And I believe they go like in the morning. They take me up to areas that are
[2:11:09] corners and then the this is Okay.
[2:11:13] So is it reasonable like you feel like it's a reasonable utilization of resources and it's not Okay. Okay.
[2:11:21] It is.
[2:11:22] Okay. Thanks, Jody.
[2:11:23] And we are doing second reading on this one, [clears throat] so once we have a motion and a second we can discuss it further if anybody would like to. Do we have a motion?
[2:11:32] So moved.
[2:11:33] Second.
[2:11:34] Any further discussion?
[2:11:38] All right.
[2:11:40] Yes, Mr. Chairman.
[2:11:42] yes.
[2:11:43] I just have one thing. It was a state mandated it was something wrong with the with this We were doing something wrong the state said you can't do that.
[2:11:50] no, so we found that our ordinance was inconsistent with state statute. So ours allowed for and I have to mix them up. One allowed for six weeks every six months, the other one allowed for 12 weeks every 12 months. So we're making sure it's consistent with state statute.
[2:12:06] Right. That's all this is about.
[2:12:08] That's really all it is outside of some changes around where to place them and some environmental considerations. Yeah, which I think are de minimis in large part.
[2:12:15] Okay. Thank you.
[2:12:22] So, I would like to motion to amend the ordinance to include language under section J, temporary signs. Temporary signs that are not in compliance with the ordinance shall be removed by the code enforcement or their designee.
[2:12:37] Second.
[2:12:40] Any discussion on the proposed amendment?
[2:12:42] Yes.
[2:12:44] Yeah.
[2:12:44] The one thing is should the person be notified they could cut the sign. I've had people say, "Hey, my sign's been stolen." And then come to find out it was at town hall.
[2:12:55] [laughter]
[2:12:56] The clerk's office does notify the candidates of the signs being that we picked up.
[2:13:02] Right.
[2:13:02] And there are in some instances we don't have them. They could have been in
[2:13:07] Yeah.
[2:13:08] taken by
[2:13:09] Right. Right.
[2:13:10] What we pull, we notify the candidates and they come and pick them up.
[2:13:15] Okay. Great. Thank you.
[2:13:17] And I will note one of the requirements is that you put your You know, it's still going to be in there, but you have to put your so that they know who Address and phone number in there so I pick up the sign and give it a call.
[2:13:27] Right.
[2:13:28] Yeah.
[2:13:28] I think what happens is some What happens occasionally is that if you go get If it's on private property, the owner or property manager sometimes will just take them and never see them again.
[2:13:38] True. True. Now, well, another issue of that is what is private property? How far does the town own? And so, there's certain place like if somebody puts a sign out in front of my house, I can remove it or have it removed or
[2:13:52] The right of way is.
[2:13:52] The ordinance defines the right of way, the public right of way.
[2:13:56] Right. So, but there's an ordinance of having it too close to the road, too. Is that So, it has to be so far off?
[2:14:05] No, as long as it's in the right of way.
[2:14:08] Yeah.
[2:14:09] The right of way of the road.
[2:14:11] Which is usually Is it like 5 to 10 ft from the pavement?
[2:14:15] I think so.
[2:14:15] Roughly.
[2:14:20] 10 ft from the pavement that's usually where the right away is.
[2:14:23] Yeah.
[2:14:24] So, they have to keep it, you know. But, they're not supposed to have it right at the road. It has to be a setback.
[2:14:32] Public works can view it as a hazard.
[2:14:34] Yeah.
[2:14:35] Public works can view it as a
[2:14:36] Okay.
[2:14:40] But, then my neighbor put one out and she got tagged and then I noticed it was moved back like 2 or 3 ft and then I guess it was fine.
[2:14:48] Yeah.
[2:14:49] But, anyway, it's just it's confusing, but I guess we'll deal with it. Yeah.
[2:14:54] All right. So, we still have a second in proposed amendment on the table. Any further discussion on that amendment? All in favor? It's unanimous. And now we'll return to the main motion as amended. Any further discussion on that? I'll call that vote. All in favor? That's unanimous.
[2:15:15] Thank you.
[2:15:21] Order number Moving on to item number 11.4, order number 26-081,
[2:15:27] 7:00 p.m. public hearing on the proposed changes to chapter 405, Town of Scarborough Zoning Ordinance, section 6, definitions and add definitions pertaining to data centers.
[2:15:38] Thank you. This is the public hearing for the data centers. You all considered this on September 16th. We did hold a public hearing this past Monday with planning board. We heard from one member of the public at the public hearing. the planning board did not move any comments forward. This again is creating a definition for data centers and specifically excluding that from the fiber technology facility and research development and light industrial use categories.
[2:16:04] And it is essentially a ban on data centers in all three districts. I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have.
[2:16:12] Thank you. With that, I will open the public hearing on this item.
[2:16:22] Denise Hamilton, 2 Rod Road. I think everyone on this council knows where I stand when it comes to large-scale data centers, so I'm not going to repeat everything I've said at previous meetings, but there are a couple points I believe are important to reinforce. First, this is fundamentally a land use issue. Scarborough has very limited industrial areas, and I've spent considerable time looking at where a large-scale data center could potentially be located.
[2:16:48] One area includes light industrial district with the rural farming overlay where established residential neighborhoods are in close proximity. The other is our industrial district near the Scarborough Marsh, one of our most significant natural resources. In my opinion, neither location is appropriate for a large-scale stand-alone data center. Just because a property is zoned industrial does not mean every industrial use is appropriate for that location.
[2:17:13] We need to consider surrounding properties, infrastructure requirements, and potential long-term impacts.
[2:17:21] When there's a question about whether a proposed use was ever intended to be permitted, that determination should not rest solely on one person's interpretation of poorly worded ordinance. Clear definitions and established review process would provide by greater certainty for residents, developers, and town staff, while helping prevent similar situations in the future.
[2:17:42] Finally, this decision goes well beyond any one application or property. The ordinance you adopt will help establish what types of development are appropriate in Scarborough for years to come. Economic development is important, but it must be balanced with protecting our established neighborhoods, natural resources, and infrastructure. And prohibiting data centers as a primary use does not mean prohibiting technology.
[2:18:07] Businesses should continue to have the ability to maintain server rooms, telecommunication equipment, and similar infrastructure secondary to their permitted primary operations. I appreciate the time and effort the council, planning board, ordinance committee, sustainability committee, and town staff have devoted to this issue. Ultimately, this is about making thoughtful land use decisions today that we won't regret years from now.
[2:18:31] I support the proposed ordinance and encourage the council to adopt it. Thank you.
[2:18:36] Thank you. Anyone else? On data centers?
[2:18:42] We do have someone online.
[2:18:47] Hello everyone again. This is Sophie. Thank you so much. I'm Sophie Warren. I represent part of Scarborough in the main legislature. I'm here tonight. Again, I'm sorry I'm virtual, but I strongly support prohibiting large-scale data centers in Scarborough. I'm so grateful to everyone, including all of you and all staff that are might be listening
[2:19:08] for helping to get through the very thoughtful process and due consideration here on this proposal. I hear all the time from the folks that I represent about so many serious questions that our community is facing in relationship to the pace of development, the strain on our infrastructure,
[2:19:29] rising property taxes, the long-term affordability of living here, electric bills being among them. Large-scale data centers are really in so many ways a site of these questions and a multiplier of so many of those very serious concerns. Well, comparatively, they offer much less direct benefit to residents who would bear those consequences.
[2:19:55] These facilities can require enormous amounts of electricity, substantial water resources depending on their cooling systems, and expensive infrastructure upgrades all while generating relatively few permanent jobs compared to their physical footprint and resource demands. There are places where these may be a strong fit, but there's nowhere in Scarborough that I see where they would be a good fit.
[2:20:19] Moreover, we do not have protection in state regulation at this time to prevent unintended consequences that this could bear for our community and many other communities that might be similar similarly situated. Therefore, I strongly agree with the great analysis and work done by our town, by our staff
[2:20:41] bringing this forward and do believe that we should not be permitting large-scale data centers here. I really do believe in responsible economic development, but responsible development does mean recognizing that not every project belongs in every community. And Scarborough really does have limited land, some sensitive
[2:21:02] ecological infrastructure, finite infrastructure capacity, and an obligation to protect the quality of life of the people who already call our community home. I think we've got to make sure we're protecting and supporting and incentivizing investments that we know can with data we understand will strengthen our community rather than
[2:21:23] the only thing we really know being placing additional risk, burden, and costs on our resources. Once we permit large-scale development like this with significant long-term consequences, we just can't reverse those decisions easily. So, I urge the council to take this really strong proactive step and adopt this prohibition before Scarborough faces those types of pressures.
[2:21:48] And certainly until we have strong regulations and rules of the road out of Augusta. Thank you all so much for all your time, work, and consideration.
[2:21:57] Thank you. Back to public.
[2:22:00] All right, Steve [clears throat] Zamoreski, Teresa Massey Lane. At the first reading, the council many of the council members acknowledged the need to step beyond just a ban and look at towards regulating the use of electricity, water, and pollutants into our environment for all businesses, not just things that we call a data center.
[2:22:20] And how much water is too much water? How much energy is too much energy? Can we require businesses to generate their own non-fossil fuel energy? Those kind of questions and many more are important. I think I would ask the council and the state Sophie to take this up. And I think that should be the role of the state to help us determine
[2:22:45] what those numbers are. We have great resources here in town, but I think it's beyond all our pay grades to make those assumptions and those recommendations of specifically how much is too much water, and can we regulate for instance water usage that's in a on-premise well, for instance. We see Hollis, you know, the community's really having a trouble with that regarding people businesses obtaining water.
[2:23:12] so I would ask the council, and I know we're in the middle of transitioning with the end of the year, but please put this on your agenda for next year. State representatives, please put this on your agenda for next year, so we can move from calling something and banning that to really a good regulation
[2:23:33] on usage of water, electricity, noise, and other issues. Thank you.
[2:23:38] Thank you. Anyone else? Nora?
[2:23:44] Hi. Nina McKee, 309 Black Point Road. You know, it just occurs to me as I sit here how incredibly wonderful and receptive the town council is to the public who has come very, strongly against data centers. And as I recall, I think there was you passed a mandate
[2:24:06] or a moratorium for and I don't know how long that lasts, but I certainly hope it lasts in perpetuity. Is that the right word? Whatever. Because it we don't want the we don't want anything here. We don't want it in the whole state. So, but congratulations
[2:24:27] to you all for right getting right on it and doing in autumn and doing all the zoning changes that we can do to prevent them from coming. So, thank you.
[2:24:38] Thank you.
[2:24:42] Eric Nicholson, a Scarborough resident. one, thank you so much for the work you've all done on this issue. I just had a question pop in my head as I was sitting listening. The language refers to data centers. the zoning ordinance is about data centers, the moratorium is about data centers, but what I'm hearing in both town council members and the general public's comments is a lot of references to large data centers.
[2:25:09] And I just wanted to clarify for the benefit of everyone here whether this ordinance would allow some data centers that are smaller if this is truly a ban like I believe most of our residents want to see. Thank you.
[2:25:27] Thank you.
[2:25:31] Anyone else? I think we do have someone online.
[2:25:38] Hello, can you hear me?
[2:25:40] Yes.
[2:25:42] My name is Matthew Keith at 8 Pleasant Avenue. and I agree with what so many people speaking have said [2:25:55] in regards to Scarborough in particular and how Scarborough wouldn't be a good fit for a data center. I think the thing that I'll add on that I've been thinking a lot about recently is the sort of place that we're at and the development of AI and like the ethical implications and I think a lot about
[2:26:19] the ice facility and how, you know, if we could go back in time and not have it be in Scarborough, I think most of you up there would vote for that, but now there's a lot less we can do about it. And very similarly, you know, AI is beginning to take a lot of jobs, just solved one of the millennium math problems and then Open AI
[2:26:43] said afterwards they solved actually 700 plus of the unsolved really complex math problems and you know, it's just a there's a lot of positives with that, but it's also a bit of a canary in the coal mine with where we're headed and you know, a lot of job instability the leaders of these AI companies are debating the percentage chance that AI is an existential risk to humans and you know, whether that how much it's true or not, I think
[2:27:13] we have an opportunity and I appreciate I know that so many of you really support this and so thank you for that cuz we really have an opportunity to make sure that we're not as complicit. We're all complicit. We all use it whether we want to or not. but you know, there are things we can do and this is one of those moments where, you know, we can make a stand and decide what Scarborough wants to be about.
[2:27:36] And so, I appreciate you all acting on this opportunity. and special shout out to Nina, the real MVP.
[2:27:45] [laughter]
[2:27:46] Thank you.
[2:27:50] Hi, my name's Jamie McMahon. I'm a Scarborough resident. I have nothing new to add. I just want to add my desire to see you guys pass this and to thank you for all your work on this issue. I agree with everything that's been said.
[2:28:03] Thank you.
[2:28:09] My name's Kathleen Miller. Scarborough resident, chair of the Conservation Commission. I want to just echo what the first the last person who spoke online said like AI is not an inevitability. We allow it to take what role that it will
[2:28:30] have it, you know, in the future have. And just so, I feel like having an intervention like this in this moment is really crucial and allows us to make thoughtful steps that don't react to the moment that we're in, where everyone's pushing this idea that we need, we need, we need.
[2:28:51] Like, let's think about what we actually want. so, I appreciate the thoughtfulness that you all have brought to this process and the work that you're doing on behalf of all of us.
[2:29:04] Thank you.
[2:29:05] Thank you.
[2:29:08] Anyone else? Any other speakers?
[2:29:13] Thank you very much. Close the public hearing. just mention in terms of next steps, as a reminder, anticipate that this will be on our agenda on November 4th for second reading. We'll vote on that. and to answer one of the questions from the podium, if you look at the ordinance language, that it doesn't say anything about size.
[2:29:34] Just defines data center. So, I do understand that, you know, sometimes it's conflation with size with these things, but the ordinance doesn't speak to size. So. with that, we will close out that item and we will move on. item number 11.5, order number 26-085.
[2:29:54] 7:00 p.m. public hearing to establish a new ordinance entitled municipal policies regarding federal immigration enforcement. so we had first reading on this, a few weeks ago. and as discussed, this was this is a ordinance language that was, modeled after another main community,
[2:30:15] and I think in many ways reflects some best practices given what I think we're trying to solve for as a council and a town. on the law enforcement side, it really, aligns both with our police department's existing standard operating procedures, as well as the, recently enacted state law around that.
[2:30:38] And then on the more sort of municipal side, non-law enforcement municipal side, I think just sort of removes any ambiguity, and provides clear guidelines for, for cooperation or lack thereof with federal immigration activities. So, that's just sort of a quick reminder of what this is about.
[2:31:00] again, this is just a public hearing this evening and we anticipate voting on this, second reading should be a binding vote on November 4th. so with that, I would open the public hearing on this. If anyone would like to speak on this.
[2:31:24] Eric Nathanson again. again, Scarborough resident, live in the Pine Point area. in the recent weeks since the last time we had a, discussion about this at town council meeting, there's been multiple news reports about, continued, threats or discussion about ICE showing up at polling places, and ICE has also been involved in raiding, the homes of political opponents of the current administration.
[2:31:51] And I bring all that up because, I think it highlights how important it is to do everything we can to build the type of society we want to live in here locally using our state government power, our local government power. And so, I applaud the members of the town council for the work they are doing to try to build a safe and just society for all of us who live here in Scarborough.
[2:32:12] So, I support the ordinance wholeheartedly, and thank you all for the work you do.
[2:32:17] Thank you. Anyone else?
[2:32:26] Hello, I'm Jennifer Jordberg from Scarborough. I first want to thank you all for, bringing this ordinance up, and it looks like I'm hoping that it will pass, when you're ready to have a vote on it. I am a member of a group called the, Community Coalition for the Removal of ICE, and our mission statement, really, our goal is to have ICE removed from Scarborough, from Maine, and ultimately
[2:32:57] everywhere. And I mean, some people who might say they're on the other side would say that we want open borders, and we certainly don't. As a matter of fact, ICE is not responsible for securing our borders. Custom Customs and Border Patrol are. What we are against is the current weaponization
[2:33:18] of ICE against American citizens and our immigrant neighbors, as I've said in the past. So, the group that I am a member of the Community Coalition for the Removal of ICE, very much supports the passage of this ordinance. We are hopeful that, during any training to municipal employees,
[2:33:42] that they are made well aware of any repercussions that might, fall upon them should they fail to keep the ordinance in mind during their work day. And also, we would hope that you would make public in easy way, if there is an already a mechanism in place for someone to file a complaint, that, a way to file a complaint would be made public should the need arise.
[2:34:08] So,
[2:34:11] I think that's all I wanted to say tonight, but thank you all for the work that you're doing.
[2:34:16] Thank you.
[2:34:22] Hi everybody. I'm Abigail Henry. I live on [street]. I want to echo Jennifer's thanks for the work that you're doing on this particular topic. and I also want to share a quick story, that highlights how urgent this ordinance is, and to really make sure that we all are aware that ICE is a intimidation and human trafficking tactics continue unchecked in our community.
[2:34:44] Okay, so on October 11th, Oscar, an asylum seeker from Peru, walked his dog and then head to the drugstore. According to his family and local volunteer ICE verifiers, he was then stopped by ICE near Black Point Road and Eastern Road. When he didn't come home, his wife and his 14-year-old son feared the worst. They searched for him, and eventually he they found his abandoned car at the Amato's on Route 1, and they learned that he had been taken into custody and was being processed
[2:35:13] at the ICE facility at 40 Manson Libby Road. He was then taken to detention out of state. Oscar is diabetic and depends on insulin. During these past 10 torturous days of his detention, his family has worried whether he was receiving appropriate care and nutrition. His wife and his son have struggled to eat and sleep since he was taken.
[2:35:33] Their fear has spread well beyond one household. This ordinance would not have prevented Oscar's detention, but it would make clear that Scarborough's employees, facilities, information, and then our tax dollars are not there to facilitate federal civil immigration enforcement. So, we've not yet found a way to stop ICE from kidnapping our neighbors, but hopefully we will.
[2:35:57] but we can determine what our role what role our town government does play. Thank you.
[2:36:03] Thank you.
[2:36:07] Anyone else in the room?
[2:36:09] [clears throat]
[2:36:10] We have someone online?
[2:36:13] Thank you all so much. This is Sophie Warren. I represent part of my hometown here in Scarborough in the main legislature. I just want to begin by grounding us in the fact that ICE is right down the street from this building. and because they are right down the street, Scarborough has one of the highest records of residents being taken since the surge under this federal administration in Maine.
[2:36:40] [clears throat]
[2:36:40] That is stunning and horrifying. We don't want ICE anywhere in Maine, but when they are down the street, the threat is higher and the responsibility is ours. And it is a particular threat that we see clearly in the data to have a safe haven for them here within our community.
[2:37:00] This effort tries to do something about that, and I am so grateful for the step that we're taking here. I strongly support adopting a municipal policy prohibiting the voluntary use of town personnel, property, public safety official, facility, equipment, and other taxpayer resources to assist federal immigration enforcement.
[2:37:20] Scarborough's municipal government exists to serve and protect the people who live here, regardless of their immigration status. Our police officers, our firefighters, our public works employees, and our municipal staff should be focused on the responsibilities our community, you all, entrust them to, not to be diverted into carrying out federal civil immigration enforcement.
[2:37:44] When residents fear that interacting with local government could expose them or their families to immigration enforcement, they may be less willing, rightfully, to report other crimes, seek emergency assistance, or cooperate with local authorities. There are so many ways that makes our entire community less safe.
[2:38:06] We should be building trust always between residents and local government, not doing things that undermine it. And there is so much extreme fear in our town. There is so much there's so much fear. we are obligated to do everything that we can to keep our community safe.
[2:38:28] So, this proposal, it's not about preventing federal authorities from carrying out their lawful responsibilities, but it is about establishing clear boundaries. The use of Scarborough's resources are our own. Further, I believe this policy should expressly prohibit any voluntary assistance, including the use of town-owned land or facilities for immigration enforcement operations, while preserving compliance with valid judicial orders and other binding legal obligations.
[2:38:57] Local governments have limited resources, and our residents deserve confidence that those resources will be used to meet local needs only. More fundamentally, this is a statement about the kind of community we want Scarborough to be when our public safety is rooted in trust, where the things we see in the news and in the data about the members of our community who have been taken, that we are doing everything that we can, everything
[2:39:23] in our power to fight back against that, to keep our community safe, and to say something about what we stand for, the well-being and rights of all of our neighbors. And so I appreciate your time and consideration, and when it does come forward for the vote, I hope that you will support the effort.
[2:39:44] Thank you.
[2:39:46] Thank you.
[2:39:48] [clears throat]
[2:39:49] Mr. Chairman, I'm a resident of Scarborough. I am not part of all of that. I support everything she said. It's what she said, what they said. I'm only here cuz I made a mistake at the last meeting. I thought that you said that the second reading would be tonight. And it is it going to be November 4th? Is that right?
[2:40:08] Yes.
[2:40:09] Okay. But I told people it was going to be tonight, and I'm I misled them on that one. Not doing that again. Thank you.
[2:40:16] Thank you.
[2:40:17] I do support all your work. I appreciate what you're doing. Proud of Scarborough. Thank you.
[2:40:21] Thank you.
[2:40:25] We have another one online.
[2:40:30] Hello again, Matthew Keith here. Scarborough resident. I want to applaud you all for bringing this forward. and hope that you're able to pass this at the second reading, and I'd like to challenge you all and the future town councilors to continue to do anything and everything you can.
[2:40:52] I know that we have limited power at the local level, but I think by continuing to find every lever you have, and continuing to put pressure on the state government and just continuing these efforts means a lot to us as constituents and I think, you know, what Sophie was saying really hits home as far as a higher percentage of Scarborough residents
[2:41:18] suffering at the hands than elsewhere and you know, I know in past conversations I've heard some up on the council say things like, you know, well, you know, if it wasn't here, it would
[2:41:30] be somewhere else in Maine or somewhere else and that's probably true and at the same time
[2:41:35] we represent the constituents here and it being here means our constituents suffer even more and so I applaud you all for doing this and yeah, appreciate any and all future efforts to explore everything you have symbolic and otherwise to move this issue forward.
[2:41:56] Thank you.
[2:41:57] Thank you.
[2:42:01] Anyone else?
[2:42:04] All right, with that I'll close the public hearing. Thank you as always for your comments. And again, we will expect to have this on our agenda for second reading and final vote on November 4th. moving on to item number 11.6 order number 26-088 7 p.m. public hearing and action on the new request for a massage therapist license from Sherry L.
[2:42:28] Ross working at Oasis Wellness Center located at 433 US Route 1.
[2:42:36] so mostly performative I will note that the background check has been completed but it's a state issue not a local issue so the license will not be issued until it has a satisfactory background check. Just a note.
[2:42:51] Great. Thank you. That I'll open the public hearing on this item. Anyone would like to speak on this?
[2:42:59] Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing. And we have a motion.
[2:43:03] So moved.
[2:43:04] Second.
[2:43:05] Any discussion?
[2:43:08] I'll vote then. All in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you.
[2:43:14] Item number 11.7, order number 26.
[2:43:23] Is there another beta?
[2:43:25] You know, I think this is a
[2:43:25] 089.
[2:43:39] we'll go ahead and do this one. Item number 11.7, order number 26-289, 7:00 p.m. public hearing and action on the new request for a food handler's license from DeMoulas Supermarkets Inc. doing business as Market Basket located at 70 Market Street.
[2:43:59] so we have a new supermarket in the Downs and looking for the required food handler's license.
[2:44:08] I'll open the public hearing on this. Any Anyone want to speak about Market Basket? Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing and do we have a motion?
[2:44:18] So moved.
[2:44:19] Second.
[2:44:20] Any discussion?
[2:44:23] All in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you.
[2:44:43] Okay. Want to give our finance director the opportunity to speak on this report if you would like. Sorry for the oversight, Norm.
[2:44:56] I was waiting all night for this one.
[2:44:58] Oh goodness. Goodness. I'm Gil Da. let me first start with live on [street], and I will report to the town the assistant town manager that paving has not started on the
[2:45:10] Old Neck Road yet. So, that's a lot of work to be done.
[2:45:16] So, in your package is the first quarter of fiscal '27 for the executive summary, and this is going to be short and sweet where we're right on target with where we expect to be after 3 months. Expenses are approximately 25% of the appropriation. So, we're fourth of the way through the year, and we're we're slightly above, but
[2:45:41] some of our fellows had the had the best description of why is it some of our expenses are lumpy.
[2:45:48] [clears throat]
[2:45:49] County taxes we paid one shot, we're done. So, but those are normal recurring things. So, I'll just end it at that. We're right on track where we expect to be, and I'll take any questions you might have.
[2:46:08] Thanks, Norm. Okay. Do we have any questions? Council?
[2:46:12] No questions.
[2:46:13] Oh, I'll ask it. I always have to ask a question. So, when you take a look at where we are, you said it's not lumpy, or it is lumpy. do you anticipate any the economy, you know, is kind of in flux and struggling a little bit. Do you taking a look at all that seriously? Do you see any potential surprises coming down the road?
[2:46:36] I don't think I would call them surprises. I would anticipate that the Fed is talking about another rate increase, probably December. So, that's that's both good and bad for us. It's good because our investable cash will earn more. It's bad for us when we go to the bond market, it's going to cost us more.
[2:46:59] So, net we need net that, we're going to be in about the same position. It's just going to be bigger numbers on both sides of that equation. [2:47:11] Fuel?
[2:47:12] Fuel is is a big number. It's we're we're I think the manager reported last meeting we're currently out of contracts and we're paying spot prices. So, I would expect that every department's going to overspend on fuel and they're going to have to manage their budget other areas this year to offset that.
[2:47:34] everything's if you know inflation is at 3.7, everything's up. So, the department heads are going to have some challenges ahead of them this year to manage the budgets.
[2:47:50] Okay.
[2:47:52] That's the economic forecast.
[2:47:53] Thank you.
[2:47:54] Thank you.
[2:47:55] Thank you.
[2:47:56] Good use of your public comment time. Okay.
[2:47:59] [clears throat]
[2:48:01] at this point I'm going to suggest that we take a maybe a three or four minute break. and then we'll resume and we'll put the home stretch here. So, see you back here at
[2:48:16] 8:44.
[2:50:39] Mhm.
[2:54:38] All right. Welcome back.
[2:54:42] Moving on to our next session, old business. Item number 12.1. Order number 26-084.
[2:54:51] Second reading on the request to expend an amount not to exceed $380,000 from the land bond fund to assist the Scarborough Land Trust in purchasing 65 acres located at 8 Blueberry Lane, also known as Blueberry Preserve. Identified by the Scarborough tax assessor's map R3 lot 11, as recommended by the Parks and Conservation Land Board.
[2:55:14] And authorize the town manager to execute any and all documents as are necessary to protect the town's interests. if someone from the Parks and Conservation Land Board is here.
[2:55:24] Steven Zamansky 1903 Samoset Lane, in an official capacity as the chairman of the Parks and Conservation Land Board. I won't go through the whole background. You have that. We talked about that last time. But the board voted unanimously to approve the expenditure not to exceed $380,000
[2:55:46] to partner with the Scarborough Land Trust for this parcel because it's really a great opportunity as for to promote clean air, clean water, animal habitat, and public access for passive recreation. If you have any questions, I'm here as well as representatives from the Scarborough Land Trust.
[2:56:06] Thank you, Zamansky. open it up for public comment if there's anyone who'd like to speak on this.
[2:56:16] Seeing none, turn to the council. Do we have a motion?
[2:56:19] I'll move.
[2:56:20] Second.
[2:56:21] Any discussion?
[2:56:23] Yes.
[2:56:24] Yeah, I just want to thank the Parks and Conservation Land Board for all their work and our partner in the Scarborough Land Trust for our 30 by 30 goal. You know, I feel like we've been we've accelerated with our $60 million our $6 million bond. I'd like $60 million. and so I think it's just really exciting also the couple of last really big plots of land cuz you know, we keep feeling like there's not a lot left, but you guys are finding them.
[2:56:48] So good work.
[2:56:48] Yes.
[2:56:49] Thank you.
[2:56:50] Another step in the right direction.
[2:56:51] Yeah.
[2:56:52] Yeah.
[2:56:52] John?
[2:56:53] You know, I think this is great. I do just want to say one thing though. Karen and I have been asked to go to the middle school on Friday to talk a little bit about conservation things that are happening in town and I started to write a list of all the things that we've been doing and I couldn't help but think about how this list came together because of Karen and I don't think we would be doing all of these things including what we're doing tonight if it wasn't for
[2:57:18] Karen's support, leadership, and advocacy in this space. And so as much as I'm thankful for this particular thing, it just thinking big picture, I just want to thank Karen for her leadership in this space.
[2:57:33] Anyone else?
[2:57:37] Well, this is obviously another great success story and look forward to seeing it come together. appreciate the work of everyone behind it. so with that I would call a vote. All in favor?
[2:57:51] That's unanimous. Thank you.
[2:57:55] Moving on to new business, item number 13.1 order number 26-090, first reading on the request to repeal the 180-day temporary moratorium entitled Town of Scarborough ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on data centers. That was approved by the Town Council on June 3rd, 2026.
[2:58:17] Sure, just a brief introduction. So, this is this would be the first step in repealing the moratorium. Again, presuming that the council will support planning to incorporate the definition of data centers, this would no longer be required should this go forward. Sorry. This is So, this would be this is the first step in the process to repeal the moratorium
[2:58:38] that would no longer be necessary should the council move forward with the definition of data centers. Thank you.
[2:58:45] and it may seem somewhat out of sequence given that we're we're not yet voting we're not we've not yet had second reading on the ordinance the ordinance language itself. But the intent is to align things so that we don't have a we don't have sort of an awkward statutory situation where we have a moratorium that's still in effect while we have a new ordinance in effect.
[2:59:07] So, in the event that the if we do approve this at first reading tonight, in the event that the ordinance itself does not pass a second reading, we're only at first reading for this. So, that would not be
[2:59:22] Correct.
[2:59:23] out ahead of it.
[2:59:23] Yeah.
[2:59:24] That makes sense.
[2:59:26] All right. So, there'll be a second reading on this.
[2:59:29] Correct.
[2:59:30] Just before the other one or just after?
[2:59:34] Just after.
[2:59:35] Just after. That would be the way it'd be set up. Good question.
[2:59:40] All right. open it up for public comment if anyone would like to speak on this. Sort of a housekeeping thing. All right. Seeing none. Have a motion?
[2:59:52] So moved.
[2:59:53] Second.
[2:59:54] Any further discussion?
[2:59:57] All right. All in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you.
[3:00:04] Item number 13.2, order number 26-091.
[3:00:08] First reading and refer to the planning board the proposed amendments to chapter 405 zoning ordinance section 13A, zoning district use tables and conditions to add mobile sauna uses on town property in the residential two, residential four, and residential four A zoning districts. [3:00:27] Thank you. a bit of a different topic from our earlier discussion, but this is about mobile saunas. On August, you all approved the creation of a mobile sauna use and a mobile sauna registration ordinance that would allow those in different sections of town. staff has been asked to accommodate mobile saunas on our town-owned
[3:00:48] beach property, and those three zoning districts represent Ferry Beach, Hurd Park, and Higgins Beach respectively. And so, what we've put together before you is an additional use that's allowed in those three zoning districts with the condition that they would only be permitted on the condition specifically says only permitted on town-owned properties with town approval.
[3:01:13] So, it's how we're incorporating the use. the next item is also addressing the actual registration. So, they work hand in hand. But, I'm happy to answer any questions.
[3:01:24] Thank you. do we have any public comment on this item? One up.
[3:01:32] Hello. My name is Michelle. I'm in Yeah.
[3:01:36] Yes.
[3:01:37] My name is Michelle Gregory. I own Rose Sauna in Scarborough, just down the road, and I'm actually covered in soot because I've just come from Well, not covered, but you know, I have some marks because I've been leading some sessions just down the road at Black Point Surf Shop. And I was asked by our customers, who many of them are local Scarborough residents, to come and speak on behalf of their interest in having mobile saunas at the beach.
[3:02:04] I'm really excited about it because that's been working toward since we started. and yeah, it'd be really cool. yeah, and also if you have any questions about which one to use, I can answer those. So, thank you so much.
[3:02:19] Thank you. Anyone else?
[3:02:23] Oh, hi.
[3:02:24] Hi.
[3:02:25] this is
[3:02:27] Oh, thank you.
[3:02:29] Yvonne McKee, 309 Black Point. Just a question. I My understanding is that this would be saunas that would come along and be purchased at Ferry Beach and other places that are the that are town that are town-owned property. Is that what we're talking about? Well, I'm wondering about Okay, I just had a heart attack.
[3:02:51] So, what about if somebody sitting in the sauna has a heart attack? Are we covered for that?
[3:02:57] That's what I'm wondering.
[3:02:58] Is there a problem with insurance?
[3:03:01] That's
[3:03:01] I mean, if I go and sit there or you can't respond. But if I go there If I go and sit there and then suddenly have a heart attack and then my family says, "You know what? The town really is responsible." I mean, I'm just wondering if that's an issue. I'm just cuz I just had a heart
[3:03:18] We can certainly along with staff provide responses going forward. Yeah. Thank you.
[3:03:27] Anyone else?
[3:03:30] All right. Turn to the council. Have a motion.
[3:03:33] So moved.
[3:03:35] Second.
[3:03:36] Council discussion, questions? Michelle?
[3:03:39] so, this I did not set you up for this. but as she That's exactly my question or legal challenges. And if it's on town-owned land and it's, you know, I'm thinking somebody gets out of the sauna and slips and falls and hits her head. Somebody does a cold plunge and then goes back into the sauna and then has a, you know, health event, a heart attack.
[3:04:03] and even though I know that the owner of the sauna would be insured, it seems like Scarboro would be a bigger target to go after. And then my second question is, you are we in the business of renting out, you know, town land to do other businesses.
[3:04:23] So like if I had a dog that went swimming at the beach and it comes out and I'm going to Are we going to put a mobile, you know, dog washing business there? I mean I guess I'm just I have a lot of questions about this.
[3:04:43] What else?
[3:04:44] I mean questions, comment, where are we at in the procedure?
[3:04:48] Discussion.
[3:04:49] Discussion.
[3:04:49] We have a motion, so discussion.
[3:04:51] Yeah.
[3:04:51] Yeah.
[3:04:52] I'm going to try to stay [clears throat] focused cuz I know this is two parts. and so right now what we're proposing is to allow commercial saunas on town parking lots. Correct.
[3:05:08] Well, so the actual
[3:05:09] Any town property.
[3:05:10] It's any town property within these zoning districts.
[3:05:13] Okay.
[3:05:14] And so currently, if I want to run a residential and if I live in the residential zones, which is the zones that you're proposing to change tonight, that's all residents. So if I'm admit living in a residential zone and I'm like I want to run a commercial business, I have to go before the ZBA. And the ZBA will notify all the neighbors and tell them your neighbor, who you know, wants to run a business out of their property.
[3:05:41] And so, I struggle with the fact that we seem to be circumventing this process that our ordinance has put in place to protect the residents who live in those areas. and so I generally, well that being said, is this is the first time I've seen this. and there's not a lot of material online. So, I haven't really seen a legal opinion.
[3:06:02] So, Michelle sort of touches on some of the concerns that I have right now. And I don't know I don't know which under which agenda item we should be addressing those concerns, but I will try to again to stick to this one. How many mobile saunas do we currently have in Scarborough right now?
[3:06:17] We only have one that I'm aware of that has gone through this process.
[3:06:21] And we have not seen the impact of what having one mobile sauna in town has done for us. And what I also heard this evening was that, you know, the goal all along was to be at the beaches, but yet for somehow we had what came before us and what went through long-range planning and through ordinance committee was for private commercial properties to be operating mobile saunas.
[3:06:42] So, now this is to me a very substantial change because we're not we're not we're going into the residential zones. And we're saying, "We're now going to start operating commercial businesses in your residential zone, but we're going to circumvent the ZBA process because you're the council and you can do that. We have the power to do that." I'm saying I would appreciate more democratic procedure where going to long-range planning, having a discussion at ordinance.
[3:07:11] I have a lot of the same concerns. I work at a personal injury law firm, good or bad. We sue everybody. So, and that's and so I think honestly the questions that I have and I apologize, I've seen nothing. The questions I have tonight is who's responsible for snow removal on the town properties? Who's responsible?
[3:07:31] I think So, is this the Now I'm asking a question to staff.
[3:07:36] Great. We do our own snow removal. Each parking lots we do some limited maintenance on our
[3:07:40] Yeah. So, like right. So, that would make us liable because we are maintaining the property. And so, I think typically what I see is when you have a commercial property, you have a you hire a plow company and they have a very strict schedule, so they don't get sued. Because especially in Maine with slip and falls, I mean, these are the things that you're looking at.
[3:08:00] And so then I don't see anything about insurance. So I don't know if this mobile sauna is insured for outside of the property, and things like that. So we're inviting people in to town property, but yet it's unclear who the insurance is by. I want to apologize. I just this didn't go to ordinance. This just kind of came forward, so I do have a lot of concerns, cuz I was on the zoning board for a very long time.
[3:08:22] I take, you know, protecting residential rights very seriously, and so I do feel uncomfortable not even going through any board or committee kind of just saying, "Hey, guess what? You know, you might wake up tomorrow, and there might be a business in your residential zone." Not saying I'm against it. I just think that there should be more of a process behind this. and so then when we talk about town properties,
[3:08:46] are you talking about Higgins Beach parking lot? Okay. So that was actually bought by land bond funds. And so and it was bought by funds that we received from Trust for Public Land. And what was interesting is when the Breakers Inn came up this week at planning, they were saying that they're putting people over to Higgins Beach Park.
[3:09:06] And I'm starting to question if the fact that we used land bond funds and Trust for Public Land funds to buy the Higgins Beach parking lot, which that specifically restricts it to access to natural resources. And so I'm I'm I'm going, "Okay, we used taxpayer money and state nonprofit money to buy this lot so we could preserve
[3:09:32] access for residents to basically Higgins Beach. Cuz there's no other way to park and go. And so I think when I see town property,
[3:09:44] that's one of my concerns. Is we're not even talking about beach. That's one of them. And so, I think it's where are we going with that? And so, I think I'm asking the council to please try to think about this. if this was my residential zone, and I'm not saying I ultimately get it, I'm against this. I'm saying I really feel like we need to do more of a democratic process here. I do feel like this is a huge change to go from personal private corporation to having a property to now the town is doing it.
[3:10:11] I just want some more answers. considering my background, I really think it would be important for us and the taxpayers to know you know, even if we do it and some they have all the insurance under the world, we're still going to get sued and we're still going to have to pay to respond to those type of things. I really
[3:10:32] really think if we're going to start getting into the private commercial business of renting out to commercial properties, I feel like there's a lot more discussion that needs to be happening before we sort of open that door. One of the questions I had was, well, you know, I have a mobile I have a food, so when can I go? And how many are you going to allow there? And so, I think those are some of the questions that I have that I would like to hear from the residents about.
[3:10:56] I think that's a great idea. That would make me feel great. I'm a little like, do they feel great about this? And I don't I haven't heard from any of them. I haven't heard from the Butters. I don't know if anyone knows this is happening. Council didn't know this was happening until we started receiving emails from residents. and so, a lot of concerns about that. Want answers specifically.
[3:11:18] Do not want to get on the wrong terms with someone that we have good relationships with that give us funds for a lot of the land that we buy. I do have more questions, but I'll I'll I'm going to stop there. These are the type of things that we do kind of through committee work and ordinance and things like that. And so, I don't want to I know there's anticipation and excitement around it, but it is a new idea.
[3:11:42] I'd like to kind of see if mobile spots work in Scarborough. See if the residents in these neighborhoods are open to this cuz right now this kind of circumvents basically all the residents in those neighborhoods. Thank you.
[3:11:55] Thank you. Scott.
[3:11:57] Yeah. My concern is kind of as lines. I was just wanted to know from Autumn. In other words, it's just going to be those parking lots you talked about. It isn't streets. Town owned property is roads. They just can't park on the sidewalk. They would do it anyway. They would park on the street. The other thing is [clears throat] in the summertime parking lots full.
[3:12:17] Are they going to have a designated space that they're going to take up?
[3:12:20] This was proposed to be off season. So
[3:12:23] Okay. All right. So that takes care of that. Cuz that would be an issue I think if they're going to be taking up space from people when they get to the beach, I don't think we should. But if it is off season a lot of time. Although, you know, being at Ferry Beach especially, you know, during COVID, it says summer down some, but it's amazing how many how much how many people are at Ferry Beach parking lot in the evening and stuff.
[3:12:46] It doesn't fill up. In the summer it does. I think they should probably collect until 8:00 in the summer because everybody comes down in the evening to cool off. But then again, what do they do? So the other issue I guess is the liability. I mean, is there anything we can put in there to say we're not liable?
[3:13:07] But the other the other thing with that is they So we're we're allowing food trucks.
[3:13:12] Not at this time.
[3:13:14] Not in those parking lots? Okay. But other places in town we do. What places do we?
[3:13:19] I don't remember the exact zoning districts, but it's a lot of our commercial zoning districts. Our town is So you have to go through a site plan.
[3:13:28] Okay. Is it town owned property though? No town owned property.
[3:13:31] Unless it's a town sponsored event.
[3:13:33] All right. All right. Allow them. Okay. All right. So then So, we're really not liable. But, well, I mean, in any event
[3:13:41] I'm no expert in it, but I wouldn't say that it would probably be any greater than our standard liability for a park or public space. But, we can definitely check into it. There are certain There are some communities around us and neighboring New England states that have started to do this. So, we can definitely see if there's some lessons learned out there that can be really
[3:14:00] All right. Yeah. My point another point is we allow people to get out and walk the dogs. And if they get out of the car and slip on the ice the town plowed the parking lot, and they slip on the ice and fall and they get Can they can sue the town.
[3:14:15] Anybody can sue anybody.
[3:14:17] I mean, have we had a real issue with that though? Have we had a lawsuit or anything? So, I think the odds of that are slim. So, there's that side that it would be slim that it would that they would. But, like she says, lawyers they're going to go after everybody because it's a business, and it may make it a different situation that it's just a town.
[3:14:40] But, again, town is a good target to go after.
[3:14:44] I think to Counselor Shupe's point, it is really a fundamental discussion on whether or not you want to allow a commercial entity that's not specifically the town somehow through a relationship with community services to do this use. That's why it was separated in The first mobile sauna use was discussed as a commercial enterprise as a standard zoning district, and this would be brought back at a later time.
[3:15:08] Because we knew that it had different considerations around it.
[3:15:15] Just with regard to liability, we did consult our insurance carrier. They did make a recommendation to require the business entity to name the town as an additional insured, which essentially extends their coverage to protect the town, which is in an uncommon practice when looking at insurance certificates of coverage. So, that was their response to it. something we could certainly incorporate if it's not already into the licensing and zoning should you choose to move forward with this.
[3:15:40] So that's our insurance company basically is
[3:15:42] Our insurance company would make a recommendation that the insurance company of the private industry extend the town as an additional insurer. Essentially assuring the town by virtue of their coverage.
[3:15:52] Okay. would that make you happy again?
[3:15:58] I mean I don't know. I you know, if that's
[3:15:59] There's a lot of
[3:16:00] Is that all part of this that we're that we're voting on now? In other words, that will be part of this that we're voting on? That's how it will be written.
[3:16:09] I would prefer to see this in writing. I like Yeah. I just I'm a It would be great to have a little more information about it. cuz I don't we're currently not in the business of doing this. So I do feel like it is gosh.
[3:16:23] Who owns MZE's?
[3:16:25] the town owns the property.
[3:16:27] Well, they owns the business. The town owns the owns the structure. And so that's a lease agreement with a private
[3:16:35] Sorry. I just spoke to her about it that there's some kind So the town owns the structure?
[3:16:40] Owns the structure and then they lease the space to a private company, a private industry.
[3:16:44] Okay.
[3:16:46] So they'll be able to sue them and the town cuz we lease it to them?
[3:16:50] [laughter and clears throat]
[3:16:51] Karen, perhaps
[3:16:52] So and I think what I'm more focused about ice removal, putting sand down, things like that. Because there is some responsibility and if that falls on us, there is a strict responsibility when it comes to liability. And I think that those are those are just the questions I have that I think we should have before we move forward is a very clear mind about how this will work and like what type of insurance they have to have, where it'll be.
[3:17:16] Cuz right now we're under this I'm a little concerned that we're maybe cuz you're we suggested Higgins Beach, but I'm questioning that because of with lot lines. And I just got those the questions I think would be helpful to have answers to along with if the residents that voted for
[3:17:32] It sounds like some of the things you might want more information are more probably in items that would be in a contract rather than an ordinance. so I'm wondering if it might should come back to you all similar to the way you do food handlers licenses and you approve innkeepers and things like that.
[3:17:52] Maybe there might be some sort of additional approval in that manner. It's more oversight, but it's not necessarily an ordinance. I don't typically in the zoning ordinance you wouldn't typically have in this type of liability in this type of those specific details, but you could have it in a contractual agreement, maybe.
[3:18:14] You had your hand up before, didn't you?
[3:18:16] yeah. I mean
[3:18:18] [laughter]
[3:18:19] What do you want?
[3:18:20] Well, I mean like when I think of like what this is, I think it's really small. But when I think of what Karen said,
[3:18:27] Yeah.
[3:18:27] it's important that [clears throat] we do go through a public process to allow for these types of deliberations and discussions. This shouldn't necessarily be happening at this level, which is why we have the process we have. And so my gut is while I would likely like to see this in the future, I do think there needs to be discussions by our committees.
[3:18:48] It needs to come to ordinance. It needs to be fully deliberated. you know, for me for fairness, I'm thinking like I would like it to be a bigger conversation about what mobile businesses we want to allow on town on properties. I still feel like we haven't fully thought that through. Like we have mobile food trucks, we now have mobile saunas.
[3:19:09] What mobile businesses do we want to allow in Scarborough and where and like have a bigger conversation. I'd love to see to Nina's point some mobile emergency places throughout town that could help if there's an emergency or you know, we have a lot of dogs on the beach. Should there be a dog grooming thing there in the winter time? So, right.
[3:19:28] So, I just feel like it would be nice to maybe put this to long range, have that discussion more about what type of mobile uses and where, and then try and get through it. That may mean that this season may not work for the mobile saunas, but maybe next season they will.
[3:19:46] Yeah.
[3:19:46] and I think it's important to go through the public process, like Aaron said, to really beat these things, think through them. Unfortunately, that's slow for people, but that's why government exists is sometimes to be slow, to do due diligence. And so, I think it would be good to kind of I don't know if that means tabling this until that happens tonight, cuz again, I don't want to lose sight that we want to eventually move this forward,
[3:20:12] but I think there needs to be more public process.
[3:20:16] Yeah. What he says. And I think we shouldn't table it. And, you know, I feel like what I was going to say is it just feels like this emerged. And if are we setting precedent? So, then when I always thought of the dog, you know, washing grooming thing because of the dogs on the beach and stuff, but then it's sort of like we you know, move with this and then five other things come to us and then it's sort of the conversation we had in long range planning about the group that's sitting here in 10 years going to be saying, "What were
[3:20:46] they doing and why didn't they handle this?" And I feel like this could be a similar situation where, you know, we support something and all of a sudden it snowballs and we haven't gone through the process. And then it's like does it feel discriminatory because we said yes to this, but then we start to really question everything that comes, you know, up ahead of after that because we didn't anticipate it.
[3:21:11] Now all of a sudden we're like, "Oh my gosh, like now what do we do?" So, it just feels like we need to pause, which isn't necessarily a no, but it's sort of like I don't like being pushed up against a wall and saying, "Oh, just because, you know, winter's coming, we need to make a decision." And what So, I feel like we need to pause,
[3:21:32] go through the process, and then make a very deliberate decision that also impacts and it forms all the decisions that we make going forward when similar people bring a business idea to us. So, that's where I'm at.
[3:21:51] Learned.
[3:21:52] Hi. I'm over here on an island.
[3:21:55] [laughter]
[3:21:55] I was in favor of this. it came partly through conversations with Community Services who put together a contract for this use. it is and I don't I guess I don't like the slippery slope argument in that if something with dog grooming came up, we should consider that on its own merits.
[3:22:16] the I think some of the the liability issues have kind of been discussed and handled in that I don't I don't think the town's liability increases in those parking lots over what it is today. the vendors would have their own insurance policies.
[3:22:38] They would name the town to be covered under their insurance policy, and I don't mean that 's indemnity, but it 's an improvement. it's specifically slated for off-season, which I believe is October 1st to April 30th. So, I'm not worried about how many people are in the parking lots, that it's overcrowding,
[3:22:58] that it's disturbing other crowds on the beach. I would I would be okay with further defining the public space, you know, if that it could be restricted to the parking lots of these three beaches. I would be okay eliminating Higgins Beach for some of the reasons that Karen said,
[3:23:21] but also it's not really that great a candidate for what the sauna vendors want to do because the idea is to do, you know, jump in the ocean and if you had to walk a quarter mile to get to the ocean first, that's probably not a great place to do it anyways. So, there's some changes like that we could make, but I really came at it from a small business point of view.
[3:23:42] These people are trying to get up and running in Scarborough by the it is certainly more saleable or desirable for the clients to be able to have the cold swim opportunity and would help these businesses succeed because of that. so, the that's where I am.
[3:24:02] I would I would support it. I do think community services has a draft agreement for what the vendors would need to sign in all to be approved. Trying to think if there's other restrictions. They I think we could designate which part of the parking lot they use
[3:24:26] so that if public works is currently plowing and maintaining a particular I think they do less so in the winter time. They make them all accessible, but not necessarily like Hermark isn't necessarily every space. So, there could be some things around that to define it in a better way, but I really came at it from
[3:24:48] the idea that this was a seasonal use.
[3:24:52] [snorts]
[3:24:52] if we go through a longer process, I think they will lose this season and I was being supportive to think that if we think it's a reasonable use going forward that it was palatable to try to get them to where they gained this season's worth of business.
[3:25:17] I'm delighted to represent the residents of Scarborough. I'm curious what residents you've spoken to about this and if you spoke to like people in those areas cuz I think that's kind of like what residents have we touched on this subject.
[3:25:31] I've anecdotally I've spoken to a number of people who are very interested in doing this because it's it in meaning having the idea the sauna and the whole plunge. But I haven't certainly haven't done any surveying or getting opinion. I will say we're putting it into what is already a publicly parking lot that could have all kinds of
[3:25:52] public activity going on that people who live next to those parking lots or close to those parking lots already have that exposure.
[3:26:05] [laughter]
[3:26:06] Bill, did you want to chime in?
[3:26:07] No.
[3:26:11] [laughter]
[3:26:12] Yeah, I appreciate all what Larry said and again I felt like though that in that in what you just said there were a lot of like permutations of things that we could do and again I feel like to me that's a symbo- symbolic of the fact that it does merit some more public discussion and process that really needs to go back to our committees.
[3:26:33] The value of the committees is they really think through all of this stuff. I know if this went to long range they probably would think of every single permutation and issue that could happen and really make sure what we get is a solid recommendation.
[3:26:47] [clears throat]
[3:26:47] And so again I'm not against this conceptually. I think I just side more with Karen on this conversation that it would be better for more public process, more discussion, more deliberation, a better final product and then really then come to the council for a decision. so I just I even just this discussion to me feels like well, I think the intent was good.
[3:27:12] I mean, it makes a lot of sense on face value. Yes, we should do it. I don't have a problem with it personally. but being a steward for government process, I feel like it's important to go through process.
[3:27:25] Yeah.
[3:27:26] Yeah, and I think we need more consensus within the council. There's a There's a real division listening to this. and ideas as to how to do it and ideas how to how it's got problems were raised.
[3:27:47] And this is the first discussion I recall us having. And so this sort of discussion at the committee level would make some sense.
[3:28:00] Now, it's true it puts the thing off until a year from now. But I think we'd be more satisfied with the correctness of our action. This is six This is first reading. Second reading will be in November? Is that the plan? Right? Or is this the
[3:28:18] This is first reading and I haven't really chimed in yet. I Well, I mean, this is first reading and we do this all the time. We have first reading and
[3:28:30] then this changes by the second one. We have We have this discussion. The other first readings tonight, for some reason, we didn't have discussion. But
[3:28:38] I guess I'm I'm not I'm not I think I'm I'm not sensing support for first reading. Some I think to my mind to my mind, typically when you know, it's not It's not unusual for us to move something forward at first reading that has some loose ends or some things to be ironed out. But,
[3:28:59] this feels fundamentally different in that there doesn't seem there seem to be some threshold concerns about the proposal and about process. And I will say that I'm I'm more aligned I think more aligned with Larry in terms of the merits of the proposal and that and the impulse to accommodate
[3:29:20] a small business and seasonality of that knowing that we do not have the opportunity. I don't think ordinance is going to be again until early next year. so, that's not perfect and I do I do appreciate the concerns about process and transparency. I think it's good to err in that direction. But, I just one counselor, but I 'm
[3:29:45] I don't feel comfortable based on what I'm hearing from the bulk of the council about having a vote on first reading knowing that there are so many so many questions, so many open Can I say kind of threshold questions? And I would because I personally support pursuing this, I'd hate to have a negative vote at first reading.
[3:30:07] That really
[3:30:10] Can I ask the
[3:30:11] negative vote at first reading.
[3:30:12] What's the option between voting down at first reading versus tabling?
[3:30:17] I was just about to ask our parliamentarian experts
[3:30:21] Before we do that, before we do that, can I make a suggestion though of like I would be fine to say let's move this to first reading planning board and long range planning to review this, have the discussion, and then come back to council with a broader recommendation public process. Maybe it should go to ordinance too like I just feel like we
[3:30:44] I want to know how are we talking to the to the residents? Because we're we're changing residential zones in Scarborough at the beaches, specifically, mostly. And I just it's So, I even putting in another meeting, I'm going like I want
[3:31:01] for public comment at each and every one of these.
[3:31:03] and so I think I want to be able to find a place and a time where they feel like they can do that. And you know, I also just wanted to take this time to apologize to the residents who have come forward to me asking for ordinance changes. I have said that it's election time, we're not meeting, we're not doing stuff right now. And so, that's kind of like how we've been operating.
[3:31:23] And so, I think
[3:31:25] I think you're right.
[3:31:25] [3:31:28] I would recommend going back to long-range planning. I'm with John with the fact like I would like to have a bigger discussion of what do we want this to look like? Someone's comment to me was, "Well, you don't want to turn into Old Orchard Road with businesses all in the front, cuz these are residential zones." So, I do think it's worth going back to long-range planning, not adding a step to the process because we skipped the process.
[3:31:52] So, like I like the way the process goes cuz we start with the residents, and then it leads up to us, and it's kind of crafted with what the residents of Scarborough want. What I'm hearing now is we sort of created something, we're going to kick it back, be like, "Do you like it?" Where I 'm afraid long-range won't have a real substantial conversation if they're focused on mobile saunas, where I'm going well, maybe we want more than mobile saunas down there.
[3:32:15] And I don't think it's equitable to just be like, "Well, one business came and they want it right now, so we should do it right now." And but there are other businesses. And these are just so new to us. I'm just very uncomfortable with changing the process with what we've done today. [3:32:31] Okay. As a committee, that's what I thought. Nobody goes to the first contact of the people of the people here. Nobody goes to the committee meetings, nobody else. The people here from first reading, and then the word gets out. You've seen it many times. Then the word gets out, "Hey, you know what they're doing in town? They're doing this." So, when you do a first reading, then the word gets out and the rumors go.
[3:32:55] [clears throat] And but before that planning board everybody Nobody Everybody's oblivious to it. So, in a way it doesn't do anything. Larry has convinced me that I think and we say that they're going to have to have the assurance of I think he's convinced me and that's what this discussion's all about to try and convince people what we're doing.
[3:33:13] represent? The residents or small businesses?
[3:33:15] I could refer you to the emails that you've got.
[3:33:17] Were they all positive?
[3:33:19] Not to show you a butter, but you're asking for the community input and you have heard overwhelming community input supporting it.
[3:33:27] I honestly don't know where all the people were from. I know some of them were for Cape and I'm not saying I'm against it. I'm coming from the zoning board of appeals. I'm very concerned about the residents who actually live next to these properties and I want to find a way in our process to be able to get their opinion.
[3:33:42] going to lose nice to have a way.
[3:33:44] Well, I'm talking about Pine Point and Higgins Beach and all the apparently now it's open up to all town properties. I just feel like it's a bigger discussion. I just find it disappointing personally. I think I think we should
[3:33:55] Is it just these three parking lots?
[3:33:57] No. It's only permitted on town owned properties with town approval.
[3:34:02] Do you know here in this parking lot? In front of the town hall?
[3:34:05] No, that's not the appropriate zone for
[3:34:08] Okay. And [clears throat] there is the town I'm assuming staff or us would re would approve each one of these. So, if somebody came forward to put it on the school property, obviously those are in a residential zone, but they but you'd say no, you can't do that. We'd have that or staff would have that ability to not approve that.
[3:34:29] I'm Go ahead, Don.
[3:34:32] Well, I was just going to say it sounds to me like we're this is more of a fundamental conversation and we're trying to fix it with a zoning ordinance that I'm a little bit uncomfortable fixing. I The reason we have to address it in zoning is because it is on a town-owned property and it's a different entity. We can't just do it ourselves. If we had our own mobile sauna, we could do it without a zoning change, just full disclosure.
[3:34:55] if community services bought one, they could go into this. but it sounds like maybe this should I don't I don't want to step speak out of turn, but maybe it should go back to long-range and the spring summertime we're fully booked up on Portland's items right now to get through LD 2173 and things like that. We are fully scheduled out.
[3:35:15] You can ask Tom. I actually have a spreadsheet through July. And then in August we have availability, but maybe it's something we could look at further. And then to Councillor Ship's point, maybe on those locations, well, specifically if you were to move forward on it, we do a 500-ft abutter notification. We're not required to do that when we add or change things to the zoning districts, but I think if you would speak to the transparency of the process, maybe that could be something that could be looked at.
[3:35:43] So, for next season, I think we advise Just for the record.
[3:35:48] Yeah.
[3:35:49] Could you do that between now and second reading, though? Could you put that in there? You can't put that in there, though.
[3:35:55] I think you can't do all that.
[3:35:55] I think for everything you should have you should notify the abutters on everything. I think that you should have We should have done more of that with Sawyer Street, you know, down at the cable line. There were people who you know, they weren't even notified. It was going on for 2 years and they had no idea it was going to be closed. And so, there should have been no notification right off. So, we really got to get on that or applications.
[3:36:20] But Yeah. Yeah.
[3:36:21] All right.
[3:36:22] I like what you said.
[3:36:22] So, I think we're at a point where maybe just need a little bit of procedural guidance in terms of tabling.
[3:36:32] If you table it to table it to long-range planning or whatever committee you wanted and if you defeat it, still can go through the same process. You can still send it to ordinance or long range planning. It doesn't it just goes with the group. Defeating it but you're still moving it forward through the process whereas tabling it still can go to
[3:36:56] Do we need to withdraw the second it first reading motion that's on the table?
[3:37:02] If you
[3:37:03] Before tabling or does tabling just supersede that?
[3:37:06] It supersedes it.
[3:37:09] Okay.
[3:37:12] So I will motion to table
[3:37:16] See again
[3:37:17] There's I'm sorry. Happy to happy to talk after it. I motion to table and send it to long range planning for review.
[3:37:25] Second.
[3:37:26] Should we have a vote
[3:37:27] There's no there's no discussion on it on the table. Motion to table it so All in favor?
[3:37:36] Opposed? 5 to Thank you.
[3:37:48] Item number 13.3 order number 26-092 first reading and schedule public hearing to consider amendments to chapter 1015B mobile sonic ordinance addressing town owned property. [3:38:03] [clears throat]
[3:38:04] There's the accompanying amendment that would just do some minor changes to the registration. So the real significant change would be that town owned property would be the permitted mobile sonic location. And again, this could be looked at in conjunction with further
[3:38:22] review with the use itself.
[3:38:29] I'll go open this up for public comment. Yes, I this is a companion to we just discussed. We're not going to be able to have a back and forth dialogue, so but feel free to State your case. State your case and be fun loudly.
[3:38:46] thank you so much for your consideration. This is definitely something that really affects my livelihood. There is so many other communities that are allowing beach fronts on us and as I serve the Scarborough community and serve mostly the Scarborough residents, those are the people who are caring for the Scarborough
[3:39:06] it is getting harder and harder as those other communities are allowing beach fronts on us for me to continue to operate. So, this is a service that I'm, you know, is mostly for Scarborough residents. That's the majority of my clientele that will maybe potentially, if you know, this trend of mobile sauna beach front properties continues
[3:39:32] in other areas that I won't be able to operate them in Scarborough serving the Scarborough community. and that you know, obviously pains me and is like vulnerable to share, but it is the truth that it has become a lot harder to sustain my business while other saunas are operating on beach front property and my
[3:39:54] Yeah, I'm sorry I'm already but like my desire is to serve the clientele that and customer base that love and care for which are Scarborough residents predominantly and that 's my that's my goal. Those are the those are the people that are wanting this to be Ferry Beach
[3:40:14] specifically. That is like the one that they're like this little neighborhood that I'm serving wants it at Ferry Beach I think that the way that the ordinance was written in my understanding was that it would allow for the town to remain in control of like our liability, which is like double what is the town's requiring that I could put you as like the top That's totally do that.
[3:40:40] I can put you on as additional insurance. and if there if you guys you're in control, if you want us to make sure that there's sand, we can you guys can tell us to do that, and we can do that. That is your like that is our agreement, and I'm so desiring to like work with you guys on how it can feel mutually beneficial, because these are spaces that are not being utilized
[3:41:06] during the off-season, and that's the seasons that we're trying to operate. They're not being utilized. That's That's the time that we want to be there. That's the time when nobody else is using that space. That's when I want to be there. So, yeah. For me, this seems like something that well, for me, super part like super pertinent.
[3:41:28] Like I need like it's really important to me. and I realize I'm not a server resident, and so, you know, but I'm just nearby, and I grew up here, and an immigrant. I like am a sole woman owner of like I'm an indigenous person. I have a lot against me, so it would mean a lot to me to have this work.
[3:41:53] Thank you.
[3:41:58] Nina McKee, 309 Black Point Road. Okay, Larry, I'm sorry, but I think this is nuts. I really do. I go to Ferry Beach so much off-season to see the sunsets, which are magnificent. There are a lot of people that go down there and actually even off-season.
[3:42:20] But, besides that, I don't know that it's the council's
[3:42:27] function to change ordinances for a business to prop up a particular business. I mean, if you do it for one, then you've got to do it for everybody. And to this to I mean, how many people How many people will actually be going down there and putting bathing suits on and going swimming?
[3:42:52] And how about children? I mean, the I just this seems like the whole thing is I mean, it's just we don't need it. I mean, sorry to Larry. I'm really sorry. But, maybe you could put one in your backyard.
[3:43:07] [laughter]
[3:43:10] But, I just had to say that because I just think the whole thing is it's not it's not right. I just hope that maybe you guys come to that conclusion. And I know you'll study it. That's good. But, to prop up one person's business, I don't think it's I'm sorry. But, I don't think it's it's something the council should be doing.
[3:43:33] Especially in the parking lots. What do you do? You have this sauna, and during the during the summer, my god, there's no parking. Sometimes it's right down Ferry Road. So, what do you do? Move the sauna in the summer? I mean, I just let's think it's not So, thank you.
[3:43:53] Thank you.
[3:43:58] Tunis Hamilton, 2 Rod Road. Process. What I said before, we're talking about people's land, you know, in residential. This needs to go through, in my opinion, the appropriate process. Even if it's not long-range planning, going before ordinance, fully vetting it, notifying the public,
[3:44:20] being transparent, jumping the first reading in front of town council. I don't think this is the right place right now. Thank you.
[3:44:30] Thank you.
[3:44:34] Yeah, someone online?
[3:44:40] Go ahead.
[3:44:40] Hi, yes. Can you hear me?
[3:44:42] Oh, yeah.
[3:44:43] Great. it's John Hardy's. I'm a resident of South Portland. I'm here with my wife as well, Kylie Hardy's. We're the owners of Village Sauna. it's not lost on me the complexity around this. So, I just appreciate the council having this discussion. I've appreciated the work Autumn, Nick, the Community Services Department has put into trying to figure out, you know, a way to create the structure that, you know, is good for
[3:45:11] residents and figure out a way to bring this amenity in the off season to the Scarborough parks. I certainly agree about the, you know, took sort of parking lots and park lands that make more sense in terms of Ferry Beach and Pine Point where the Higgins is a little bit more surrounded by residential and a little bit of a different situation, but the one thing I'll say is that there's a there's a precedent building throughout the country across our coasts of, you know, sort of public private partnerships in towns working with mobile
[3:45:41] saunas in particular to bring in off season amenity to their to their residents. It usually aligns with town's comprehensive plan to increase access to recreation at these spaces in off season months when these areas are less crowded and actually easier to recreate and go to as a resident, you know, that cherished time.
[3:46:03] the way to get a lot of public sentiment and that other towns have used in the past is pilot programs. One nice thing about mobile businesses and mobile saunas is you can create structures and contracts where there's a recourse where the town can say, "Okay, nope. Got to Got to move it. Got to get out of there." And over the course of maybe a month at a certain location, you could operate test and really solicit a lot of feedback
[3:46:29] from the community in that time and then go from that point on. It's one of the best ways to get data. So, just a thought there. we've had the opportunities operate at the ocean in both City of Portland and also South Portland. there is now a sauna in cooperation with Biddeford Parks and Recreation at Fortune's Rock Beach. And we talked a lot about community sentiment.
[3:46:50] That has been I would say extremely strong and positive.
[3:46:54] also wanted to put it on the floor.
[3:46:56] And that's I just wanted to speak up again. Appreciate the thought. Thanks again.
[3:47:03] Thank you. Anyone else on this? Thank you very much. We've been turned back to council. I don't want to have the same conversation that we just had. We just spent 20 minutes talking about it. It's almost 10:00. Yeah. I think we just need to be clear on the process here. if we want to consider another motion to table
[3:47:27] kind of paired with what we already voted on. [3:47:36] Oh, I put the motion on the floor for discussion. You know what I mean if you want us to do
[3:47:39] I moved to table.
[3:47:42] We got to put the motion to discuss. To make motion.
[3:47:47] I motion to put it on the floor.
[3:47:50] Second.
[3:47:51] I got it.
[3:47:52] Motion to table.
[3:47:54] Well, we have a motion to discuss.
[3:47:58] Right. That has to be discussed.
[3:48:01] I ask a good question cuz I thought it was an interesting provocation that the last speaker said about doing a pilot and like trialing a pilot. So, even if we're not making an ordinance around it, what authority does the town have if they wanted to do something like a pilot this season to test it out to see
[3:48:22] and learn, right? Because I think that might inform long-range planning as they go through the process. So, I just don't know
[3:48:29] Is the pilot on town property or they're just saying do a pilot for mobile saunas generally in the town?
[3:48:35] I don't know.
[3:48:35] And I think that's I think we're doing our pilot. We just passed it. We have one and we're going to see how it goes. That's why I And I think my question was like what other towns are actually allowing it at their town properties. I understand there are other places that are allowing it, but I think there's a And that's that's the stuff we need to explore.
[3:48:51] Yeah. And maybe that's for staff to look into and maybe come back to council. Like there's a way that the town has authority to do a pilot program to test it out to see what it's like to inform, you know, future zoning. Like I feel like that seems reasonable to say what's
[3:49:06] If we're willing to do it for others and I think that's also the consideration we need to make tonight is if we want to do this tonight, are we comfortable doing this for every other business that we that feels that they need it. Or And so, I think that's
[3:49:23] So, we're Is that a motion to table and refer to
[3:49:30] long-range
[3:49:30] a suggestion to staff. I thought it was an interesting provocation. Is there a pilot?
[3:49:35] I make a motion to do a pilot program with this person just at Ferry Beach for this winter. And give them one season and then we'll look at it again and go through planning for any other people who want to do it or may want to do it.
[3:49:51] I appreciate the spirit behind that, but I just
[3:49:53] a second? Do I have a second on that? Second.
[3:50:00] I could
[3:50:01] I think I have discussion.
[3:50:04] Now we're discussing that, right? So I would very quickly be interested to hear from Autumn of what the mechanics of doing the pilot program would be.
[3:50:11] At another time. I don't know if I'm fully prepared to answer that question, but my information from the attorney and the way our zoning and land use works that is if it's a if it's a use the town does, if it's a municipal use, we can do it anywhere. But if it's a private entity and we're leasing it, needs to be an allowed use and I would assume that would even be the case for a pilot.
[3:50:34] Okay. That would be my error.
[3:50:36] I'm not sure.
[3:50:41] I'm good if you if you want to vote on Scott's
[3:50:48] So having heard that explanation
[3:50:50] Call vote on Scott's and Scott's proposal. All in favor.
[3:50:57] Opposed.
[3:51:00] Six fails.
[3:51:05] All right, so where are we now?
[3:51:06] We're headed to
[3:51:07] I'm going to motion to table this and send it to land use planning. That's what I did last time, right?
[3:51:14] I'll second.
[3:51:15] Say it again.
[3:51:15] If all in favor.
[3:51:18] We need a discussion there, no?
[3:51:19] There's no discussion on a table on a table.
[3:51:23] Most one opposed.
[3:51:25] Okay.
[3:51:26] Thank you.
[3:51:27] Chase the one.
[3:51:29] [clears throat]
[3:51:31] That's where it belongs.
[3:51:34] So look forward to discussing that going forward and appreciate the discussion.
[3:51:39] Thank you, Kevin.
[3:51:40] Item number 13.4, order number 26-093, act on the request from the fire department to adopt a the municipal [clears throat] resolution emergency medical services transport plan. I do apologize that we didn't move this one up at the beginning of the meeting along with the other ones. At least you're on your home turf.
[3:51:59] [clears throat]
[3:51:59] Right at home.
[3:52:01] Rich Kindelan, your community's fire chief. I'm going to be very brief. I'm going to pass this on to Deputy Chief Walker, but I didn't want to throw him to the wolves without introducing him. The finance committee got to meet him this year when he started in April, on his second day. Yep. Yep. Second day he had to go to finance committee for the first time, so I just wanted to mention that I make I'm extremely honored to stand here and bring this resolution request up to you.
[3:52:21] after over 75 years of emergency medical service delivery in this community, spearheaded by Dr. Haigis back in 1951 for the first municipal emergency medical services in the state of Maine. this simply for me, this is feels really good. It codifies all the hard work that everybody that stood before us and the and ran in those ambulances and volunteers at night that really set the stage for us, and the state has finally recognized
[3:52:47] that emergency medical services is an essential services essential service that communities are supposed to provide. So, I'm just really proud of this community and to be able to stand here and do that. I'm going to turn it over to Deputy Walker.
[3:52:59] Thank you, Chief. Good evening, councilors. I will try to be brief. I will try and turn you over to home to your families. So, tonight I'm here to with a request for the adoption of municipal resolution of an EMS transport plan for the town of Scarborough. a little history on that. During the last legislative session, LD 245,
[3:53:19] which is entitled "An Act to Implement the Recommendations of the Blue Ribbon Commission to Study Emergency Medical Services in the State of Maine" was brought forth. One of the many subjects of this legislative document was recognizing that emergency medical services is an essential service to the citizens of Maine. With this chapter 154 of title 38 of the Maine State Statute was born.
[3:53:41] This statute requires each municipality within the state to adopt a plan of how transporting emergency medical services will be delivered within their municipality within is borders. As the chief just mentioned, Scarborough started ambulance service for the state in 1951. It was the first municipal ambulance service within our state.
[3:54:04] So, this shows that the town of Scarborough has made this plan decades ago. with the adoption of this resolution, it's going to make it official and follow along with this new state statute. with this that what I'm what I'm asking for tonight, there's no operational or fiscal changes as compared to how we operate now.
[3:54:26] Okay.
[3:54:27] And it's just putting us into compliance with the state statute. I appreciate your time, and I'm ready willing to answer any questions you might have.
[3:54:37] Thank you. I'll go ahead and read this resolution.
[3:54:44] Municipal resolution emergency medical services transport plan, town of Scarborough, Maine. Whereas 30-A MRS 3172 requires the municipal officers of each municipality to adopt a plan stipulating the method by which transporting emergency medical services will be delivered within the municipality. And whereas the town of Scarborough is committed to ensuring clear, expedient, and reliable emergency medical services and transport pathways
[3:55:10] for all residents and visitors in emergency situations. And now, therefore, be it resolved by the municipal officers of the town of Scarborough, Maine, the following emergency medical services transport plan is hereby adopted. One, primary provider. Transporting emergency medical services within the borders of the town of Scarborough, Maine, shall be primarily provided by the Scarborough Fire Department.
[3:55:33] Two, service model. Directly managed municipal service where the municipal munici- municipality directly funds, operates, and staffs its own municipal ambulance service as part of the Scarborough Fire Department. Three, public posting. This resolution shall be posted publicly at the town hall and on the town's website in the same manner as municipal ordinances.
[3:55:55] Four, amendments. This plan may be amended by the municipal officers as necessary. Any amended plan shall be submitted to Maine EMS within 30 days of adoption. Adopted this 21st day of October 2026 and signed and sealed on behalf of the Scarborough Town Council and the town manager of Scarborough, Maine. do we have any
[3:56:15] additional comment on this?
[3:56:19] We have a motion?
[3:56:20] So moved.
[3:56:20] Second.
[3:56:22] Any discussion? Yeah, Scott.
[3:56:24] I'm sure Dr. Haigis would be very proud that it's finally accepted officially what he started 75 years ago. Cuz I didn't know that fact, but I wouldn't have known all my life if I didn't know that. But that's I knew Dr. Haigis, knew of him. Yeah, so I think it's a great thing.
[3:56:42] Absolutely.
[3:56:43] Great.
[3:56:45] Anyone else? Well, this is great. We appreciate you sticking around and appreciate your efforts. all in favor? That's unanimous. Thank you.
[3:56:57] Yeah.
[3:57:05] All right. On action items, we have none. That takes us to council member comments. Michelle.
[3:57:13] Quickly, I just want to wish all the candidates running for office good luck because when we meet next time we will have had an election and have new people supporting our town and I know how hard it is to campaign and how tiring it is and I think the people running have been doing an amazing effort just being out there and I really appreciate that.
[3:57:35] And the second thing is I have three friends here visiting, college friends from few decades ago. One from California, one from Connecticut, one from Mass, and we got fresh lobsters from Council Jordy late yesterday and they all just said these are the best lobsters we've ever had in our life. They saw Scott, he actually delivered them to when I went to get I got personal service and
[3:58:00] I just appreciate the hard work that the people that work on the waterfront do and Scott's been my lobster connection for decades and my friends wanted me to thank you and said that it was just a fantastic meal last night.
[3:58:15] Thank you.
[3:58:18] John?
[3:58:18] I just want to thank Paula O'Brien for bringing cupcakes tonight for those boys. She did that and Bill and my cupcakes are in the serving room and I just want to say that out loud so I don't forget to get them when we leave tonight. So someone please remind me if
[3:58:34] I thought you wanted us to eat them.
[3:58:36] Yeah. Everybody can have one if they want. April didn't share hers when she left. So I will just say that out loud.
[3:58:46] I do I do want to you know speak to the row of owner and you know I apologize for what happened tonight but I do think ultimately what we did was the right decision in terms of you know really thinking more broadly about our entire community and making sure that you know I don't think any of us are intending to be a barrier for your success.
[3:59:07] I think it's really about us going through the right process as a town. Your clientele are clearly for this and we know that there's demand there. It just might be one more season until something like that happens at the beaches which I know might be an issue but I hope you also recognize how quickly this council went through a process to make it so that you could operate in town at all which I think was something that we reacted to very quickly for you and for your clientele and so
[3:59:37] I know this probably wasn't what you were expecting or wanted to have happen tonight, and you know, nobody wants to see you not succeed. I think we all do. It's just we have to go through the process. So, I apologize that tonight wasn't exactly what you were looking for.
[3:59:53] Yeah, that's all.
[3:59:54] Also.
[3:59:55] But on that note, the main reason I got on here was to cut the red tape and help the individuals, and that's why I voted the way I did because it's like I think it's a good thing. I think we're going to go through with this whole process. I think a year from now it's going to get approved. I 'll guarantee you it probably will.
[4:00:15] especially if we could have done tonight and done a pilot program to see, and it may become an issue where as if we let this person do it, then how many other people are going to want to come, and what other kinds of businesses will want to be running the parking lot. And I mean, you know, we can just like they have in the past, they just say no, that these aren't approved.
[4:00:35] That's it. I'm all one for saying if you if you do for one, then you got to do for all, you know? And I cuz that's not right either. If you let one person, you should let everybody, but I really do feel it for you. And so, sorry.
[4:00:53] All right. On an unrelated topic, I we did receive notice from Tom last week on an effort that South Portland made around comparing tax rates, and Scarborough, out of 12 communities, has the lowest mill rate, 12 surrounding communities has the lowest mill rate this
[4:01:17] year, this tax year right now. So, I thought that proved a lot of hard work on staff's time, Norm's time. and and that that it was again kind of reinforcing while it was a challenging process this past year, we really came out with a good result and great to see us compared against other communities that favorably.
[4:01:41] Thanks.
[4:01:44] Bill.
[4:01:45] I've been doing this a long time. You're nearing the end 8 years. and I've been the town councilor rep for the Scarborough school board on for numerous years. And I saw Shannon in the audience tonight and it may be
[4:02:06] be reminded that she's done a tremendous job as chair and I was up close and personal having the opportunity to see that as our excellent school system maintain those high standards. So, I wanted to recognize Shannon here tonight.
[4:02:29] Well said. I'll just quickly add a comment related to the sauna discussion and you know, I also don't feel great about how it all played out, but I think at the end of the day we'll we'll get to the to the right place for the for the town and hopefully for the for the business owner.
[4:02:49] I do, you know, I do think it's important for us to try to try to keep in mind and when we when we talk about our residents and businesses and the business community that it's not necessarily zero sum. I'm not suggesting that anyone feels that way, but I think sometimes when we get involved in certain conversations it can it can start to feel or sound that way and
[4:03:14] I think one of one of the reasons that we that we have a relatively low mill rate is that we have a we have a balanced tax base that includes a robust commercial component. and I don't think that's that should be the driver how we think about things, but I think it is important for us to be reasonably supportive of small business. And sometimes that does mean you know, having entertaining requests for relief or accommodation for certain things.
[4:03:44] I totally agree that needs to be done in a transparent fair way. And I'm confident that you know, that this council and the future council and staff and the committees will help facilitate and I hope that the applicant will bear with us and take that in that spirit. going to the going back to the proclamations beginning of the meeting, it's great to see the team in here.
[4:04:09] I was reminded my one of my sons was on the U10 state championship team 10 years ago. so it's great to see those kids and it's always fun to be able to do something like that. And thank you for helping to organize that, John. and then finally, I just want to thank everyone for helping us to run this show here, including staff and our AV support.
[4:04:31] definitely not easy and and looking forward to being back in our home turf next time. with that, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn. Unless anybody else has anything.
[4:04:45] Oh, one more quick thing. Not a Larry's thing. We're very fortunate and other towns don't have that we have oceanfront that we have. And the taxes that are paid, there's people down Prouts Neck that pay between 50 and 100,000 dollars a year in property taxes. I think these are the towns don't have anywhere as near that. So, that is why,
[4:05:07] you know, our tax base is so low. Not that Scarborough's really frugal about spending money cuz they're not. They spend it liberally. but we're fortunate to have that money down there. That's why we all that we have because of that income. so I still think we should be careful about spending.
[4:05:32] Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else?
[4:05:35] Nice job facilitating a challenging lengthier than meeting than I anticipated. Thank you, Corey.
[4:05:43] Thank you.
[4:05:44] Good job.
[4:05:45] Thanks for all your help.
[4:05:47] Motion to adjourn.
[4:05:49] Second.
[4:05:50] All in favor?
[4:05:51] Aye.