Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): You don't have the thumbs up and yes, and I will call this.
Public Comment
[0:09] Speaker B (unidentified): When is that a special meeting on the commission order? All 3 commissioners in here, I'll open it up to public comment. Just in case, but I don't see any public here. So nobody so we'll move on to the action items and the action item at the moment. It is an active approved county administrative job description. Yeah. Okay. I guess we'll do that. Do I have a motion? So moved.
[0:50] Speaker A (unidentified): And a second? No, sorry. Second.
[0:54] Speaker B (unidentified): Seconded. Any discussion? We have with us an expert. Yeah, who's been looking over this job description to help us. Would you like to narrate the changes that you're recommending?
[1:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Sure. Yes. sorry.
[1:15] Speaker D (unidentified): That actually hasn't been an interview.
[1:17] Speaker B (unidentified): So, Betsy, please introduce yourself to the television audience.
[1:23] Speaker C (unidentified): Audience. Okay, sure. My name is Betsy Olson from H, located and found with me. Happy to be here with you folks tonight. And yes, a large part of the job description had been, you know, more, you know, drafted. And so I reviewed it and most of it looked really a lot of it looked after, but I also compared it with your just to make sure we covered everything. thing the only few things that we just need to you know the effective date was a tbd i would say october 2026 we'll put that date in there one of the questions that i had i'm a little bit nitpicky when it comes to things so bear with me but on the one two three four bullet down where it talks about selectmen they you know a lot of towns have sort of changed it to select persons instead of select men, if you would like that changed, we can certainly make that change.
[2:24] Speaker E (unidentified): We had made that mention in our last meeting that was appropriate. Okay, great.
[2:34] Speaker C (unidentified): I am sure if you might be able to help me out with this, I don't know. Oh, okay. I think I just crossed off. under sort of the last bullet, knowledge of compliance with state statutes that relate to common government that really falls under sort of the, you know, knowledge, ability, et cetera. So that was moved. And then the last edit, I think you refer to your department managers, not department heads. So I just changed that, right? Pardon me, okay. Okay, and then I typically, like, I don't have all of the other job descriptions. Usually it's. Helpful to have them all similarly uniform. I do think it's important to have a job description, have the employees sign it. So I put a signature line. Down there, I removed the, you know, Knox counties and equal opportunity employer because that really belongs in the ad. We already talked about a disability accommodation in the job description anyway. And so I removed that and just put, you know, have an employee signature line. So those are really the, main changes that I made or edits. Any
[3:59] Speaker E (unidentified): offense to me? Yeah.
[4:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, any discussion
[4:05] Speaker D (unidentified): any, input from, as he said, I think we made a lot of the refinements ahead of time and this was just the once over by her, which kudos to us is not a lot of ready to there. So, but I agree that there are, you know, everything that's there makes sense.
[4:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Great and if that's the case, then I will call the motion all those in favor. We have adopted the new job description. Thank you. Then it leads us into the discussion, which is the rest of it, which is behind the process of the county administrator.
[4:47] Speaker D (unidentified): So, that includes the, advertisements, you know, there's no requirement for you folks to do an actual action item on that. Just basically consensus that HR saying that we should do these things for the advertisement. And she had a couple of things there that I felt were more appropriate for her to ask you guys to have answered some of the data. We will have to provide her. I think it is accurate. We're just going to know the chunk is. So I'll let you take that away. That's it.
[5:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, so we're on the path right now. Yep. No, I just, you know, just put a different paragraph at the beginning that sort of describes Knox county. And I took that from your website, the 1st paragraph. So, if you wanted to add anything to that to sort of make it more desirable. I mean, I think that says a lot right there for a desirable place to come. And then just the Knox County operating budget, this is. This is not as far as I know, just need those numbers and then. And then, you know, employees annually and employees more than a 100 employees. I assume that's still real. Yes, okay. And then I just typically hyperlink. So it says, 3rd, it says. You know, I just said, please refer to the Knox county charter and the full job description, because when you're putting sort of 30 people. People, not necessarily, rather than look it up, they could just click it on and go there if they want to. And then I believe you had already. Discussed the salary range, so in case folks, we would want to do this anyway, July 20, this year state law that says that has been passed out. salary range posted. And so, you know, I always like them posted to discuss this at all. But, you know, I did do some sort of, I do work with a lot of municipalities, a couple other counties and, you know, cities, et cetera. And so I felt that this is a really reasonable salary range for somebody in such a position as this. I think you folks already talked about that piece. And then I'll just, you know, usually I just have the resumes come directly to me. what I typically do is, and maybe this kind of goes through part of the process, but, I'll clean up that because I also noticed that you have. Some sort of an applicant system online where the person goes online and actually fills out the actual application. We've had that reviewed because it hadn't been reviewed since I think 2022. 22. peter marchese looked at it and agreed that the language in there was appropriate some of the things you know older applications have asked questions that weren't allowed to ask anymore so yours is compliant all set and it's the same you know information only it looks different on your you know employment screen if you will so i'm just gonna make sure that aligns with and points to where people are to apply but as far as sending the packets they would come to me i didn't put a physical address and i think i think it's a sort of you know everybody's does email now so certainly they can just send it to me and then what i would do is i usually actually create a shared room, shared drive. So whoever's on the selection committee, I like everybody to send a confidentiality so that none of it, you know, this information gets out. And if we keep it in a shared confidential shared drive checking, help people walk through that a little bit, then you'll have access to, you know, when I get them in, they'll automatically go as they come in. And I'll also keep an excel spreadsheet that kind of gives a you know an overview of the applicant information so you can kind of see a snapshot of it but you'll also have the ability to see them that happens as they come
[9:42] Speaker A (unidentified): in you know in real time sounds good did
[9:50] Speaker C (unidentified): you want me to go through the rest of the process or
[10:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, actually one question. So you said you are going to sort of clean up that last paragraph so that the lines application versus emailing. Okay. Just making sure that was confusing.
[10:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes. And I just want to, so usually what happens is once we get the ad and the job description All done, whoever posts on your website, they'll go there and in the link, the hyperlinks will already be in there as well. So, when the ad goes out, they can just type your link right to your website and again, get all the information and make the application.
[10:38] Speaker D (unidentified): So, I think, yeah, we just kind of go through the process, get some guidance from them on who they want and who the committee. I'm still waiting on those return guesses or knows that we can work on the conditional. But I think going through the whole process with them also for them to kind of give you a feel for what they're looking for in a candidate. I know you've got a lot of in front of you, but each person is a slightly different. So, I think it'd be good for you to hear from them, too. So I think, yeah, and work through the process of how you see you going.
[11:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Sure, great. Okay, so I'm just kind of looking at my. So, you know, creating the advertising, I typically like to. You know, post in a municipal association and that. Most all of their affiliates, like, their city council, city managers, et cetera. I also usually post in the New Hampshire and Massachusetts municipal associations as well. Which is a national municipality organization so that way it's nationwide. Obviously, your website, I do use indeed, but I set some parameters to make sure that we're just getting. Getting, you know, hopefully candidates that meet the criteria. Sometimes we will get, you know. resumes that just aren't applicable, but,. You know, I would, I would on my Excel spreadsheet, you'd see that, you know, you don't, you wouldn't even have to look at them if you, know, sort of vet those for you folks. And the length of the posting, I think it's important, you know, we don't want to lose a good candidate. So it's sort of, you know, open until filled so that as it wants to come in, we can screen them and, you know, get them in front of you sooner than it might take in a different. and then again, sort of what we'll do, or, you know, is receiving it's very important to me and I'm sure to you folks too that when we receive an applicant that I respond to them and say, thank you for your application and we'll be in touch and I like to follow up with them just to not leave anybody hanging. and so that will happen by me, and then, you know, you know, I think at this point, by screening the interview, says screening interview date. I'm sorry. right it's a so it's it's my understanding and maybe we can go through this that if we do an initial sort of pre-screen you know that can be done on zoom by selection committee you know i'll provide all of the appropriate questions you'll have an opportunity to add any questions that you'd like to see asked so that we have a consistent interview rubric if you well each candidate will be in the pre-screen as well as if you'd like me to provide those interview questions about in-person interviews and then you know at the point where you know we're ready to sort of interview you know candidates that i'll be I would like to facilitate that and be there in person to make sure that, you know, we kind of stay on track and also provide sort of what not to ask for candidates. I do that for everybody just because I just never know and we want to make sure that we're legally compliant with them. And then once a decision is made, before we're able to do a background check on anyone, we can certainly do reference checks, but before we do an actual background check, a conditional offer of employment has to be provided to the candidate. So that would be essentially, it's not a contract. It would be essentially an initial. You know, you know, conditional based upon the background and any other sort of testing that we, feel is appropriate. And then at that point. I mean, it's good. We'll work on, you know, and provide you with a sort of a sample contract for you to look at. And we can talk about sort of the negotiation piece and how you want that handled. I will say that particularly with managers, you know, town managers, city managers, county, whatever, they don't, they follow the employee handbook or personnel handbook, you know, for most things. But as far as benefits, it's common for, you know, what's important to somebody, you know, we would negotiate that. So, in other words, if somebody, you know, if you didn't have a specific benefit that was listed for all the employees, the folks that are in these positions do have a separate contract where other people don't. And so they're able to, and you're able to negotiate, you know, if there's, you know. Something that they're looking for, like, you know, I don't know, a car allowance or something like that. That would be common to sort of. Through the candidate and see what they're they're looking for and see what you're willing to do. And that would all be something that I, wouldn't do without. Obviously, your guidance and your input and. And if, you know, if you prefer to negotiate it without, you know, that's fine too. I just usually take direction from, you know, you folks, and then you can start with the negotiation process and be sort of immediate. mediator between that two
[17:07] Speaker E (unidentified): questions number one and I think you spell it out but will everyone that applies get a contact from you saying that we're done we're finished though because I know too many times people just leave people hanging never applying I think it's incredibly rude so yeah I'm so glad you
[17:32] Speaker C (unidentified): said that because that's one of my huge pet peeves and it is i think it is in here absolutely i'd like to follow it too to make sure like i'll put it on i think it's time to just give like a little bit of an update because we just don't like we're and then we've made a decision everything's
[17:51] Speaker E (unidentified): finalized then i would send out a phone you know that's that's important to me thank you for that and the same question that i guess i learned that we're not allowed to do background checks until we have a final person we're not allowed to do like the last three candidates or something right
[18:13] Speaker C (unidentified): so and i mean as far as the background check that is correct so you can do reference checks you know and those types of things with usually what happens with references is they'll provide us with references, you know, and usually it's somebody that, you know, whoever they are going to give them a good reference. Right. And so usually we don't, we won't make a reference to, like, their current employer without their authorization because we want to keep this as hard as we can. But, yes, full blown to be made it with a condition law.
[18:55] Speaker D (unidentified): I know the hesitation. So I've done it a lot in my profession because we have a lot of things they have to do. You know, you have to go through a polygraph psych, literally an extensive background, and we do conditional offers. And to Betsy's point, that is not an offer of employment. That is a, if you pass everything we ask you to pass, then we will work on a offer of employment. So it's not actually limited to just one person, but you want to narrow the field specifically. So you already ought to give everybody conditional offer, but it's not actually limited to one. You could find two good candidates and say, okay, now to get to who's the best of the
[19:38] Speaker C (unidentified): You made your 2 conditional offers not am I wrong on that Betsy? No,. And I may have misstated that, but, like, you just want to make sure you have clear language in there that they understand that. They're not the only. Oh, yeah, that's not the only candidate, right? So that they know that, like, there is a possibility that even though you go through all of the background that you may not get the decision. That was my opinion. Okay. Great. Thank you.
[20:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, that conditional to a, background check is in this scenario is more likely to be on 1 person because the whole point of what we're doing is this rolling as soon as we get somebody good. We're not going to wait till we have somebody who's almost as good 2 weeks or 3 weeks later. do so that we can do two conditional offerings so it is really in effect we're going to be working
[20:41] Speaker D (unidentified): on one person at a time and finding a good person you're just pausing the process because that person may not work out and then you go to the next person that's good or maybe not as good but
[20:52] Speaker B (unidentified): good enough today we're not stopping the process just because we have somebody who's close to good You know, based on a conditional in the background, and we find that. Oh, well, maybe not.
[21:05] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, okay something we learned. Yeah. And I think it's pretty and again, like, the shirt said to, you know, for you to kind of share with me what you're looking for. I, do. You know, there's a lot of competition out there and, you know, in these types of roles. But, you know, it's, it's just as important to sort of, you know, sell the wonderful place of Knox County right to, you know, so it sort of goes both ways. But I, you know, it is, it's, it's important to, I think, sort of in this atmosphere in terms of, you know, competition or whatever to move things along. Right it doesn't mean we're going to rush into making a decision, but it means that will, you know, a lot of times if the process is too long that people are disinterested or whatever. So, you know, we, would be moving it along. And again, if you folks are all agreeable to, once you determine who the selection committee is, you know, that we also have the ability to look at the shared drive. Then it's, you know, it's not me emailing, you know, and having it, you know, accidentally forwarded to somebody. Do you know what I mean? So, it keeps it a little bit, well, a lot more confidential.
[22:26] Speaker D (unidentified): So, one suggestion I would like to make on the selection committee piece, because it makes it more for us, for Betsy to know who we're moving along. Depending on how many we have, I'm suggesting that we look at, we have a majority saying, yes, this person should move to the next step. 2 or 3 people could say, you know, say, we have 8 people on the selection committee 2 people say, yes, 6 people say, no, should we really have that city to continue that person? so I think we should draw a line there a little bit too. We should have a majority consensus in the first. So, I think we did, I didn't think of that until after regarding why this is happening. So we work through some of those problems. I think that would be a good thing to add to that. It's a bit off my count of people we've talked about. I think it's 9 or 10 that we have, but all may not participate. So.
[23:21] Speaker B (unidentified): Great. Yeah, I mean, certainly the committee is to have a majority as opposed to 1 person on the committee decide. Yeah, I think that's. You know, the ideal, and I think it's going to be less likely in a rolling process like this. The ideal would be to have an almost unanimous vote. You know, when you go through all of the candidates and you look at it, so this we all agree, this is the best candidate. In this case, there's going to be a few people who say this person is pretty good, but I wouldn't be surprised if there's somebody better out there. And so it may be harder to come up with a unanimous grouping when you do it like this. That's not to say it isn't the right product. I'm just saying that. Yeah.
[24:04] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and you want to know what we're looking for, I think I do. And just 1 quick comment that might be helpful for you too, is in some cases that I'm happy to do it here as well. when we sort of, you know, after we interview somebody, right? And then, you know, we sort of. Then debrief a little bit and oftentimes I'll put up on a whiteboard sort of like, you know, you know, I don't like to say pros and cons, but sort of like, you know, in category. So that it helps the whole committee kind of see also where everybody came up, you know, came out in terms of, you know, their own assessment. And then the group assessment that might.
[24:54] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, we'd like to. Yes, so you're slightly looking for this. There's a certain base of knowledge. We're looking for looking for somebody who has some certain skills, administrative skills. Ideally, they have some background administration, but the number one thing they're looking for is somebody I like. I know that sounds silly, but this is somebody we're going to be working with and just because somebody has been sitting in an office their whole life and has absolutely no social skills isn't the person I don't think that we want here. I think that social skill is going to be an incredibly important part of working with the county and the employees we have.
[25:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Yep, well, also, and to help you with that, too, is a lot of the questions that will, I'll provide to you, know, sort of her approval is, you know, there's a lot of questions about, you know, essentially about the position, but there are a lot of sort of HR questions, behavioral questions, how would you respond to the, you know, that kind of brings out that personality a little bit more too. So, no, I agree. That's a, that's a great.
[26:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Blowing off of that to some extent is how is a person working within their community? You know, are they a member if they move into a community to become a member of that community? Or do they see themselves as separate because they're only going to be there for 5 years.
[26:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, just taking notes. Yep.
[26:33] Speaker F (unidentified): For me, it would be, like, hard and soft leadership skills and examples of those. and you know I think you can get that definitely out of the interview process but I think another important piece is going to be the references and getting a sense through those references of whether or not someone has those skills and also you know supervising do they have a fair amount of experience supervising because I think that is going to be critically important
[27:15] Speaker E (unidentified): And unfortunately, I can't give you a list. There are too many permutations that would work in this situation. I'm, I think I'm going to have to just, I agree with everything that and Morgan have said, but I can't add to it. I, think I need to meet the people. Sure, because there's, there's too many variations. Can
[27:48] Speaker G (unidentified): I clarify something? Are the candidates that are potentials going to get an initial Zoom interview with Betsy? Or is it going to go straight to interviews with a live interview?
[28:07] Speaker D (unidentified): So that's what we were, I think part of what we were looking for. So what I've written Now, just thinking of that is, I think, because I think the challenge sometimes is, especially if we have out of state people to your point. So, this is my suggestion is Betsy does the intake. All those come to the selection committee that's decided. The majority says, yes, Betsy do a screening, goes back to selection to then do the commissioning.
[28:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so he is doing this thinking that's what she said that makes it easier to have her do it again. Nice feedback. Yeah. Versus trying to have an all of us. Yeah, definitely. Especially since it's a large group of both, and it's also a consistent repeatable with the same issues.
[28:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, so this can be seen twice once on intake. Yeah. 2nd, time after screening to then make a decision. Do they come before you either live in a person or through a zoom like this? Because California applies well, the opportunity if they're good candidates.
[29:18] Speaker B (unidentified): So, sounds like what you're saying is the committee never interviews anybody.
[29:24] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. I don't think that was really the intent for them. It was more to screen them. Do they have the qualities that we feel you are making the decision to, so to her, to the point where you guys just said, you can have them in person that with guided help of making sure that the person you are looking for to then move to that conditional off, because then we can dig deeper into some of those things that we couldn't before, but you're going to have, when you get to, hear them hear from them before we move into that next piece because that could be more interviews as part of that conditional offer we can make that part of that process but are we going to
[29:59] Speaker F (unidentified): get a document that just spells this out all the steps yeah so we have that initially but we can
[30:06] Speaker C (unidentified): go to more detail i think yeah i can i can detail this and also just to let you know like, when I do free screenings or screenings with individuals, I take very thorough notes. And so those will also be provided. So that people will have that information as well. Great.
[30:24] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, and I'm sorry if I, looked at my email, but I didn't see that document. So that's really all points.
[30:32] Speaker D (unidentified): both points one page there's the previous one this would be one for tonight's previous one last friday's meeting whatever the meeting left me we had one pager that we spent but again it was that was just that here's what we're looking at just a big picture of the one pager to your point and some of this just needed some detail worked out i'll tell you more details because that was also the intent is to get you some of those questions you know my list of questions which ones do you want her you can see that so yeah
[31:11] Speaker C (unidentified): and i'll just clean this stuff you know based on what we've talked about tonight i'll tweak it and then spell it out a little bit more in terms of like you know with me pre-screening then i will upload those notes you know to the shared drive etc so i'll go through a little bit more detail and send it
[31:27] Speaker A (unidentified): off to you folks but
[31:30] Speaker D (unidentified): that's where i'm used to this concept for very strong consultant
[31:39] Speaker A (unidentified): work that's a lot on that great that sounds great looking
[31:49] Speaker B (unidentified): for an administrator and so when that brings up this committee in general
[31:57] Speaker D (unidentified): you're looking at potentially nine people in this committee i think it was nine or ten names of names you kind of out there for us to look into have you been in touch with these people only a couple of them just i don't have a lot of time so i should have answers by the beginning
[32:12] Speaker A (unidentified): of the week at nine three o'clock correct we see that it's additional there
[32:19] Speaker D (unidentified): abouts i mean yeah give or take you can always add more if you had other names of people i mean i don't think we need
[32:26] Speaker F (unidentified): to now i know sound like too many already i'm pretty sure a few will say me yeah
[32:37] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah doing people this committee isn't interviewing anybody that makes the nine you know better in that sense that there's more responses there's more eyes looking over these applications won't even get to the point where we're authorizing Betsy to go and do an interview. Yeah, no,
[33:06] Speaker G (unidentified): I think they summed up. I think leadership is a big piece and. Managing others a lot of people can. Do all the administrative tasks, but they avoid the people component of that are so I think that's extremely important. one multi-task multi-projects all those things play in and
[33:35] Speaker F (unidentified): i'll add one more being a team player i think that's such an important you know this is a really tight-knit staff and when everyone is working well together obviously everything works better so to the degree that they can be you know like we've been so lucky to have kathy and pat and amber like willingness to share leadership across your three departments and work together in these times where we you know have not had the county administrator and etc and so someone who can step into this role and, you know, in particular, see not just departments that they have to oversee, but see peers who they want to work with. You know, I, think that 's really important.
[34:35] Speaker C (unidentified): you just made me think of 1 question that I, didn't ask. Is there anything in your charter that says they have to live within a certain radius of.
[34:45] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah,, in the county, but we have many exceptions to that.
[34:52] Speaker D (unidentified): Which you can reach you in the contract.
[34:56] Speaker B (unidentified): I think I think Peter, especially because it's completely real. Yeah, but there is the ideal is for somebody to live in the county. Which is a pretty large geographic area. Yeah, well, I mean, just gone through in the not so distant future. This is. Hiring process and interview process and reading applications. there was basically nobody who had all of the skills that we're looking for. it's not like, oh, there's the perfect candidate. It was a matter of making sure that we had all of the skills that we were looking for. figuring out who had most of the skills that we were looking for because it's going to be hard to find somebody even if they're a town administrator who has dealt with the same kind of all the departments we have they may have absolutely no experience in corrections or and I mean so the team player part is very important that they have to be able to rely on and trust their department head. So we want somebody who's got that kind of rapport with the departments that they're going to hear them. And so therefore, it's more leadership. But what I found was there were people, and I've said this over and over again, there were people who had certain skills that they brought to the job. They may have been the head of a fairly large HR department in a county, or a very large finance department in a county, and did some of the other stuff. So the question is, and that's why I have a problem with the rolling thing, is unless there's a really perfect candidate, we're going to be looking at somebody who's close, and figuring out how close is close enough.
[36:44] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I think that you will find though, and I totally understand where you're coming from, But they're personal, as we all know, there is no perfect candidate, right? It's going to be, it's going to be important for the committee to really, you know, invest time in, you know, listening to what they have to say to some of these answers and, figuring out, you know, oh, gosh, in our situation, maybe they're not real strong in finance to the point where we want them. but we have we know we have a strong finance director so but they have all of these other attributes so it's going to be you know that 's going to be part of the process to really you know hone in on their skill because it's going to be very personalized for knox county right dependent upon who you have in the leadership some organizations have very green So, you would break, so you really have to sort of tailor it and, you know, I, 've done it both ways to be honest, and I haven't really run into, you know, that I can think of a major problem with doing it that way. Just because, you know, we'll, you know, I, think that. Anyone who's looking for this position and wants this position, they're going to apply pretty quickly. one
[38:15] Speaker F (unidentified): other thing that comes to mind and this is not something that i think we want to publicize but you know as we get farther down the road with candidates who might be coming from out of state we do have a little apartment at the airport that has been used for a variety of things and in the when we brought on our communications director she moved from out of state and we it was available at the time and so she was able to move in there for a short term while she looked for a house so it might just be a good thing to know that we have that i don't know about its availability right now but that's just something that we can offer potentially that's great thank
[39:00] Speaker C (unidentified): you yeah just
[39:05] Speaker D (unidentified): add one thing that i feel is important for the position that it sometimes is overlooked or hard to quantify but the ability to delegate right some folks cling to the new job and cling to everything that's part of the new job and sometimes have a hesitation to delegate and to the point there is a good team here that can do a lot so I think it's important when we screen these folks that we're looking for that ability to so yes
[39:41] Speaker B (unidentified): we're not looking for somebody to step into the county and clean it up you know fix all the things that are wrong there have been times that you know people have that approach oh I'd be with and make everything right I don't think we're at that point I think we've got good departments of good department heads and good employees and we want to support them not say oh wait a second now where I come from we do it this way, you've got to go right. You know, so we're looking for somebody that you're saying is not just delegating. It's trusting.
[40:20] Speaker C (unidentified): No, that's huge. And you don't, you definitely don't want something, unless it was a directive from you folks that you said, you know, you definitely don't want somebody to come in and do that. It's very important for the person to not even make any changes for the first several months until they really get the lay of the land and understand people's strengths and offer maybe, you know, additional opportunities for staff rather than negative. Yeah, absolutely. It's important. I don't think so. So, I mean, I think I'm good, you know, I guess as soon as, you know, I get, you know, finish up the advertisement, you know, we'll start posting that, you know, as soon as possible. And I'll just need to, I forgot who is there somebody in charge of posting on your website?
[41:27] Speaker A (unidentified): You can reach out to me, Betsy.
[41:30] Speaker C (unidentified): I can't see who's the examiner. Oh, okay. Yeah. And then I'll set up a shared, if everybody's still in agreement, I'll set up a shared drive, at least with, you know, you three commissioners until we get, we understand who's going to be in the committee. But at least I'll get that set up, but if you. Students are need help with that. It's it's pretty Joe. A flick, you know, 1
[42:05] Speaker D (unidentified): thing that just to be conscious of, because we are only mission of 3, just make sure they don't have the ability to directly communicate.
[42:16] Speaker F (unidentified): We can't have communication.
[42:23] Speaker C (unidentified): So, yeah, I don't think you. You make it, I won't make the shared drive editable. It'll just be something that you can view and that way there's no information. Thank you. No, I think it's I know this is a. sometimes it's a process, but I,. You know, I think it's a, it's also very positive, right? It's everybody kind of the same thing. I think hearing sort of the same theme, and I think most employees, particularly the public servants in municipal government, they need to do a good job, and so help them accomplish and not be sort of a disciplinarian person that's all they're looking for. So I think it's an exciting time to move forward with your company. Hopefully, we'll get the rate right fit. Yeah, I think it's important that, you know, we,, we don't rush it, but we also, if we recognize that we have a candidate that we move with it.
[43:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, that would be a real.
[43:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Let's get them to be pulled in there.
[43:57] Speaker F (unidentified): I'll also add that just what you were saying about being positive about this, I feel like we really are coming at this from a position of strength. I think we have just things are in really good shape for us, and we have great internal leadership. And so I think whoever we bring on, they're just coming into a really good situation. So, I also am feeling optimistic about it. Go ahead.
[44:28] Speaker D (unidentified): The only question that did come up was a legal review. So, nothing will be finalized without a legal review, just so you're all in. Betsy will be good, just like with a lot of us already going through some of the personnel stuff. You know, Betsy just helps to ensure that all the T's are crossed and I's are dotted, but Peter and his team do just that final glance.
[44:50] Speaker B (unidentified): As we get to that point, legal will be doing that final review and I think we've pointed this out before we've learned something with the last few contracts we've had with administrators as well as other department heads that we can have a new contract with that really to protect the county have to be in there. You know, and it may be a severance clause, whatever it's going to be and that. from an employee's standpoint they may not want that but it may be part of what we have to do to protect ourselves absolutely
[45:28] Speaker C (unidentified): and i think most people even in the contracts that i've done with like town managers they all know that 's part of the that's part of the deal right
[45:38] Speaker B (unidentified): well my deal is we're going to hire somebody they're going to be here five years ten years whatever it is and do a great job but there is always that possibility that it doesn't work But there is something we're able to look that we're not, we're certainly not invaluable and we may have really, you know, well, we screwed up. And it has to be a way for both us to get it's almost always a way for the employee to get out. But by the same token, it has to be something for the county to get out. Not that it's not a process, but, you know, and it's part of the things we have to establish in a time.
[46:18] Speaker D (unidentified): and talking with Betsy, that's the disadvantage we have as a county. We had a very 10 year county administrator. and we have not had this experience. Betsy has found a lot of the time she's been working with, they go through a lot more unfortunately. so it is not uncommon. Common for those things to be in those contracts and for the serious ones that are worth hiring. They already know that going into it, you know, like you said, we learned some lessons because we haven't had the experience. Now we do and much better place. I think so.
[46:57] Speaker C (unidentified): And I think the last thing that I'd like to say, that's sort of unrelated to the search, but in the last several months that I've been working with different folks in the cop county. everybody that I have dealt with has been great committed very professional and it's been you know I think it's it's it's going to be a real privilege for the next county administrator to
[47:23] Speaker F (unidentified): come in here I totally agree and I'm glad to hear that for you because I know you have worked with a lot of folks so it's not just me having a like knox county battles
[47:37] Speaker E (unidentified): it's been very awesome i think we can make some one state
[47:44] Speaker G (unidentified): anything else i do have just a bunch of questions not for betsy related bubbles
[47:52] Speaker F (unidentified): Should we let that? Yeah, thank you.
[47:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Thank you. You will be in. Yeah, so
[48:08] Speaker G (unidentified): we have a budget range that's been decided that would be in the post set. From a budget perspective, do you want to budget the high end? Do you want to budget the middle? And 2nd, piece is that, like, you were referencing if someone comes in, they need lodging. That's an expense to admin because the admin has to pay to get focused. You have the FAA rules. Yeah. So do we want to look at that? What did you pay for communications? What that happened? Do we want to budget that? Where do we want to go?
[48:42] Speaker E (unidentified): I wasn't done with Jessica.
[48:46] Speaker G (unidentified): How was it done with Jessica, the input charges communications for the logic, just like they do when they have anyone else staying there, we have to treat the same. Okay. So, it is, it is a benefit, no resource, but there is an expense along with that. I don't care that. Okay.
[49:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, and then the only expenses with hiring somebody. When we sign the contract with somebody who's coming from Connecticut, they may want us to pay movie.
[49:18] Speaker A (unidentified): In addition, so we haven't done that for any of.
[49:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Right, I'm just getting it. I think we should include all of that in the budget so that we know what the cost of hiring a new person on. And whatever you think. Those costs could be, or are likely to be, you don't think that they're paying, you know, moving costs are great. But if you think that we're going to pay for somebody potentially to rent the room, the airport, I think that's more likely.
[49:53] Speaker G (unidentified): Because let's say someone else somewhere else in May. I think that's more likely. I think.
[50:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Maybe a little bit whatever you believe they are, if you think and that we should certainly, because we don't have a lot of reserves and we don't have a lot of undesignated funds, we have to make sure that's in the budget. We can't just say, oh, well, if it isn't there, we can make it up. We're in a position on our budget, trying to build that up again. and by automatically doing what we're you know not putting it in there we're saying oh we have that money and it'll make it harder next year to build up that reserve so i think we should be honest about what it's going to cost in
[50:41] Speaker D (unidentified): my experience what i've seen some do also is they budget top tier but then those are negotiables in that contract you could have had So, contract, so, budget wise, it's still the number, but there's taken the. Right. so.
[51:02] Speaker G (unidentified): And I, think as a commission, I guess I'm asking, do you want to go as a budget with the highest salary? And obviously we'll go with the highest health because that's. Common if we're budgeting the highest salary. salary do you also want to budget the potential for having to cover lodging or to pat's point that if you're at the high end we're into we're not supplementing that for you
[51:33] Speaker F (unidentified): i think yes on the lodging just because that's that's kind of a nice well it may be a necessity honestly that we have that available for someone just because of how challenging housing is and can be I do think the high end of the salary but my understanding is with the height of the salary that you're talking about was you can get to that level if you are not also taking advantage of our health benefits and some of those other benefits right so oh I didn't know so I think there's a trade-off there so that at the high salary level, we're not also doing the... Where to do it?
[52:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Where did that come from? Okay. It was just the discussion we had with the universities. When I brought that at the last meeting, that's one of the things we discussed is, some of these folks are gonna potentially be retirees that say, hey, here's a great opportunity to move to mid-coast Maine, right? I wanted to do it, but I don't have a job, I just have my retirement, get a chance to have my retirement and a salary.
[52:44] Speaker E (unidentified): He's potentially that way, but not.
[52:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, that's what we have.
[52:51] Speaker F (unidentified): They're in terms of, you know, so
[52:55] Speaker G (unidentified): we're fortunately, we have someone and we're paying them the salary at the top of 178 at that point. We're not offering them health insurance.
[53:04] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, I think it's a, it's a negotiation, so it may come in at the highest level. of the original salary range, and they'd say, oh, well, I don't need health insurance, then that kicks in that additional range that goes to the top. And that was my understanding from you guys.
[53:28] Speaker D (unidentified): So this range she's putting in the advertisement is everything that exists. but there was an original range of a lower end what is expected of what the market in this area is showing and then there was the top end of here's all these special scenarios that we might need to be prepared so that's where that comes okay so but to her point you have to advertise that because the way the law is written you can't not say it if that makes sense
[54:02] Speaker B (unidentified): So, you know what I mean? Like, you've got to still say that this is what you're saying is basically is that we put the upper end of the salary range in there as a number of potential salary. We don't add any of the other stuff in there potentially we need, you know, by the exit there was just.
[54:28] Speaker D (unidentified): That's how we get it. She just wants to know her budget. What are we putting in the name?
[54:38] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, a family plan and insurance and the difference goes into salary. Yeah, then not.
[54:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Not budget any other expenses relating to this. Okay, I just want to make sure, because this is going to be obviously a, change to what was already presented. And then the other thing I was thinking, I was talking is Betsy was talking about drafting a new contract and. I thought the last contract, there was a lot of time and legal time spent on that. so i don't know whether it needs to be enlisted of betsy then doing the same thing that we've
[55:20] Speaker B (unidentified): already done from this last one in her case she has a boilerplate pattern that she uses and pretty much now peter has a boilerplate that he uses it's going to be a matter of combining those two i think in her case she's going to be helping to negotiate with the person So, that's going to change the contract more than what she has to write to put in there.
[55:46] Speaker G (unidentified): So, and I'll give her what Peter has. Well, my concern is we're going to go to Peter. We're going to pay for Peter and we're paying 2 different costs.
[55:56] Speaker A (unidentified): From the same product, which well, yes and no.
[56:05] Speaker D (unidentified): That's what she's going to do is get that from him. What are the, just like, we've dealt with it in our other contract, which is one of the things that Peter says we must have what can she negotiate for? What might be.
[56:19] Speaker B (unidentified): to me in talking to peter about this the other day he basically said he doesn't force me spending a lot of time because it's already done he just wants to look over what she's already
[56:31] Speaker G (unidentified): done yeah i think we've spent all the time left yeah so that makes sense that we shouldn't have
[56:39] Speaker B (unidentified): to spend it this summer i also don't want to leave him in the discussion and i don't want to leave it entirely to him because you can think i think we're working with her to make this happen
[56:55] Speaker D (unidentified): she has a lot more experience at the important side of it great you know peter's great when we're meeting with corporate negotiations but betsy's because she's going to be working with this person the whole process feel them out and know where those devotionals are they're weak spots
[57:17] Speaker E (unidentified): That's what we will call them. Oh, they're negotiable. So call them negotiables. I just have to add. I'm a little uncomfortable with. Putting in on a salary and then with conditions in it that are not spelled out. Make 150, we'll give you medical, but if you make 178, you're not going to make medical. It's not what it's not what you're saying. Say, this is the top end. So.
[57:41] Speaker D (unidentified): out yeah it's all negotiable you can walk in and then with one year's service say i need the top salary to get it i'm just you may have that one person who has 20 years in county management who really wants to come here i need this because this is the cost of my life you may say yes
[58:06] Speaker G (unidentified): actually that the risk would be if you say yes on the high-end salary and then they say i also need I just want to make sure the budget is reflecting what you as a commission, you're envisioning so that we should have an idea of what that might cost.
[58:31] Speaker E (unidentified): You know, we can figure out what we're going to present the budget committee down the line, but I don't think we should leave you hanging and then come back to you and go, oh, by the way. way which has been done probably before and
[58:49] Speaker B (unidentified): as
[58:56] Speaker G (unidentified): you mentioned in the past unforeseen we could ebb and flow yeah we don't have the ebb and the flow so i just didn't want to
[59:04] Speaker D (unidentified): leave you hanging so i think what i'm hearing is both family and top tier and see what we
[59:13] Speaker E (unidentified): happen then is we decide what to present the budget community you know well if you're making
[59:20] Speaker G (unidentified): that decision that will be what's in the budget that is going to the budget committee next week
[59:26] Speaker E (unidentified): and the other thing that will happen is i'm hoping that the chances of that happening
[59:33] Speaker F (unidentified): are slim enough i mean there's no i don't think there's any scenario where we're going to be paying the top salary plus health insurance I mean that one amazing she's
[59:45] Speaker D (unidentified): not done drafting that a post yeah how to bring talk to your dad so we
[59:55] Speaker B (unidentified): also being optimistic that there will be a good person who's fine because what we've seen in other counties and other towns is they're still having a hard And so we may be at that lower end, basically saying this is a good person, but they need room to grow and they're not going to be at the top tier, you know, if that person was available, then we're willing to pay that.
[1:00:25] Speaker D (unidentified): So, I also say, if you want to apply your contract, and you get top tier at year 5, that's negotiable.
[1:00:33] Speaker B (unidentified): Right. And we know, basically, this experience is part of it, is in five years when we go to the top tier, everybody else will be paying $10,000 more for their top tier.
[1:00:47] Speaker D (unidentified): The sitting in negotiations happen.
[1:00:49] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, they're going to be up there someplace while we're still here. Yeah.
[1:00:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Part of our problem, in my opinion, is the calendar you're thinking of being six months behind the towns does set us back.
[1:01:06] Speaker B (unidentified): No, we're six months ahead of the towns. Yeah, okay.
[1:01:10] Speaker G (unidentified): I was thinking that myself, being able to do this. Okay. Sure.
[1:01:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. Shall we? We shall. Well, then, we'll obtain a motion to adjourn. So moved. Second. Seconded. our next meeting is a birthday meeting next thursday yeah thursday night with the budget committee so there's not necessarily no i'm trying to speak to november 5th
[1:01:38] Speaker D (unidentified): and we have no other meetings special meetings scheduled so the next regular meeting will be the following tuesday which is the
[1:01:53] Speaker F (unidentified): We don't have to set up cops in the building. We just move in.
[1:01:58] Speaker D (unidentified): We'll give you a little bit of a break. I think we caught up enough. I'm just going to take up a lot of our times.
[1:02:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Appreciate all the work you guys go
[1:02:09] Speaker B (unidentified): on for a book. All done with the paper?