← Back to MaineScanner

Yarmouth Operations Committee Reviews TIF Program and Public Art Installation

2026-11-12 · 1h 57m · Source: Operations Committee - Meeting November 12, 2026 (Town of Yarmouth (YMTV TelVue))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:02] Speaker A (unidentified): This conference will now be recorded. So this is our November [0:07] Speaker B (unidentified): operation. It's our November operation. This is October at the time. [0:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, sorry. Excuse me there. [0:13] Speaker B (unidentified): All right, so we'll call the meeting to order. We have everyone here except Megan Casey, who is a few minutes late [0:19] Speaker D (unidentified): because of parent-teacher conferences she's participating in. [0:23] Speaker B (unidentified): And here she comes. And Heather Abbott and Councilor Zoe Wolf are both online. Our first item is a presentation from Development Advisory Board. We have Deb Watkins-Penn and Ted O'Meara here. Please come up, join us. So I'm liaison to that board and we've discussed having a little more frequent contact between the Council and the EDAB last year, and this is the beginning of that process. So welcome. It's all yours. I don't know, I guess you have something to share. [1:02] Speaker E (unidentified): So I'm the Vice Chair of the Economic Development Advisory Board, and Ted is the Vice Chair. And just as an aside, we're really glad to be here tonight. We, as a practice, except for maybe last year, we made several presentations. We would come regularly to the council and kind of do a primer of what we're going to do tonight. And then as there are special initiatives, we might come and go through that, like the LDC. We'll come back on the market study. study. And we always come in and present our recommendations, which we'll talk a little bit about that. Oh, let's see. No, I know. I don't know. Okay. But I mean, the presentations. [1:50] Speaker F (unidentified): I think this is the only way we can get it so that everyone in the room can see it as well as Heather and Zoe. [1:58] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. You sure? Because we just did it the other way. They could see [2:01] Speaker G (unidentified): it on. Didn't they see it? Yeah, I think maybe if we, oh, they may not be able to see the room though. [2:09] Speaker H (unidentified): We were able to open the whole thing up. [2:16] Speaker I (unidentified): I can, for what it's worth, I can see the presentation and the room right now. [2:21] Speaker B (unidentified): We're trying to, yeah, with the presentation small on our screen, so we're trying to. [2:29] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay. Okay. You guys can see the presentation still? Yes, and can still see you as well. [2:34] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, you can see us as well. That's even better. All right. Great. Great. We're still learning, really. [2:38] Speaker E (unidentified): That was how it was at EDEP. I always make sure that works. Okay. Well, Ted and I are going to do a tag team on this with you, and then if you have any questions, feel free to, and we welcome, there's some new members that don't know as much about the work that we do, so we thought this was great opportunity, and thank you David for inviting us. One more time, if that comes out, go away, huh? [3:39] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, quickly, let's see. Why don't, what if I email it to you? Yeah, try to me. Oh, sorry. We'll make them people wait. [3:48] Speaker E (unidentified): Here, oh, it could be that the problem with you, we can talk through it. Do you, do you all have your copies? [4:04] Speaker J (unidentified): Does anyone have it locally? [4:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, we did, it goes to a blank. It's going to page two. [4:13] Speaker E (unidentified): It's because of that Outlook. [4:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Is anyone having it locally on their laptop? [4:20] Speaker K (unidentified): I might have it. Be able to convert it to Google. I have Google, so we can try it. [4:25] Speaker F (unidentified): We got a backup USB port. [4:29] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't know. It's saying it's not okay. [4:32] Speaker L (unidentified): We can talk it through, [4:34] Speaker E (unidentified): Because I have a copy on my iPad 10 and I can just download it. [4:51] Speaker B (unidentified): So it's kind of sitting in the area. Okay. [4:56] Speaker E (unidentified): Sorry. We'll talk a little bit about that, but tonight we're here to give an overview of the tip. [5:01] Speaker K (unidentified): The tip program. [5:09] Speaker J (unidentified): Heather and Zoe, can you still see it? [5:24] Speaker E (unidentified): We always vote against this room for. [5:26] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, yeah, I just want to check. Zoe, Heather, are you there? [5:34] Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, I'm so sorry. I was giving you a double thumbs up because I can see my... [5:39] Speaker E (unidentified): She says double thumbs up. They've got it. Okay. Thank you. [5:44] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, so now, hopefully no more surprises. Okay, there we go. Okay, yay. [5:49] Speaker M (unidentified): Okay, this is going to be redundant for some of you veterans. Hopefully it will be constructive for some of the new members. Just an overview in 2015 or 16. When that was created, the 1st, economic development director was hired. There's a lot of work that went on before those decisions were made. One of the 1st things we did was create a 3 distant TIF districts, which you can see here for 1 or through 1 South and downtown. town before that the only tiff district i believe that existed in yarmouth was one that was created especially for the war which had a kind of enhancement agreement to it and only two percent a maximum of two percent of the acreage in town in any one district and five percent So, there's certain eligibility expenses and projects that can be paid for within those districts. And every year we have recommended a budget to the town council. [6:53] Speaker E (unidentified): One of the things, so I think it's really interesting just back here, Ted, the downtown district can draw upon the money that's generated by the other districts. And if you recall, TIFs were put together, they were also like a commitment to revitalizing urban downtowns. And so that's part of what the theory was behind all that. But you'll see that this, you can't then take the downtown and put it in Route 1 itself, [7:26] Speaker N (unidentified): Right? The question is, where is the 2 and 5? [7:29] Speaker E (unidentified): Those are legislate, those are administrative, they're state regulations and you have to get approved by the state and they monitor it to make sure we're following the ranks. [7:41] Speaker D (unidentified): Or the town is following the right. Yeah, that's the next slide. The DBCD had to have to approve. [7:47] Speaker M (unidentified): The districts we created, they were amended in 2020 to allow downtown revenue for grant programs for local businesses. Amended again in 2023 to allow revenue for affordable housing, including housing services for the homeless. In 2025 there were some boundary amendments, just some tinkering moving some acreage around, in a development program amendments. And that allowed for loan programs in both grants and loan programs. So it's been tinkered with a little bit in terms of what we can do within the districts and also the boundaries themselves. And somewhere along the way, maybe you remember this, fairly soon after we created the TIF districts, there was a major revaluation. [8:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Be more substantive than 2016 was the year we did. So we were able to capture a lot of that. [8:58] Speaker M (unidentified): And I think, as most of, you know, that these are the benefits if you do not have TIF districts. Every time there's a major increase in valuation. That basically there'd be revenue coming in, but it would basically be offset by the money that you lose. In school subsidies and other things from the state. So having the TIF districts allows us to capture at least half of that. And use it for other things.
New Business
[9:28] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, I understand. So outside of the, it's a non tip. Approximately half of every new tax dollar generated in the state. So new, what do you mean by new tax dollars? Does that mean, if, the re, eval, the difference between what the evaluation was before and the new right? Okay. Or, new or new business, new homes, anything that's that's incremental. But half of the tax from the previous evaluation, whatever it was, would not go to state, it's just a new, is that what you're saying? Did that's why, yes, or if you shelter new income, you know, shelters outside, that's why I'm asking you about it outside of the TIF. So for houses and the bill is not in the TIF, doesn't half of all of their tax dollars, those all go to the, okay, yeah. [10:25] Speaker E (unidentified): Those all go under the formula. Okay, so that's not quite, that should probably be rephrased. Yeah. [10:30] Speaker N (unidentified): We should say half of every tax dollar outside of it, outside of, that's a better statement, basically goes to state aid. Yeah, and if you're in a TIF district, what happens, it goes, it stays in the. [10:43] Speaker I (unidentified): The tip stays locally. All the increase. [10:50] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. So you had a baseline when you started it, and so then every increase. So it is in the tip distance. But probably that should be reworked. That's a good catch because EDAP didn't catch that one. That's because we know [11:08] Speaker A (unidentified): it, yeah, okay, so [11:15] Speaker E (unidentified): it allows you to keep additional money to use for enhancements to the community. That was the, that was the reason that these were created, and it takes some pressure off. Yeah. [11:30] Speaker P (unidentified): Okay, ready. Yeah. [11:36] Speaker M (unidentified): This is the famous buckets that we came up with. We created this for ourselves to try and understand what we're doing. The first bucket is organizational, administrative, and we really don't have any say over this. That's determined by the town manager and staff of the council. But they're any non-capital items that are related to economic development from administrative costs relating to special projects. We'll see a further breakout of this. This has increased fairly steadily over the years. In fact, some fairly large increases in recent years. But that is really, that is beyond EDF's purview to have anything to do with that. The only thing I would point out that I think just to consider for the future is that percentage doesn't necessarily foot to, you can't trace it back. You can't say, well, the town manager is spending 20% more time on economic development this year, so we're increasing that by 20%. It's been fairly arbitrary, and that's something you may just want to keep an eye on in the future. The other thing is these tip districts are going to expire at some point, 20 years down the road. So, if you keep taking more and more for administration, one of these days, there's going to be a day of reckoning, and there's going to be a huge hole that's going to be filled. So, just some things to think about. The other bucket. [13:07] Speaker O (unidentified): A couple of the things that fall into that first bucket, I know that the Economic Development Director said. [13:12] Speaker E (unidentified): We're going to go through that. We'll show you that itemized. We knew that you would ask that. This is to give you the sort of the principles, and then we'll go back through that. Megan, thank you. Yes, that we're explaining that a little bit later. It's, it's [13:25] Speaker M (unidentified): bucket two and three that we really must concentrate on, and bucket two, the community hands, but those are investments that enhance the overall quality, the overall quality of life in town. There are projects that make Yarmouth a more livable, more attractive place that, I mean, the economic development impact, you could make a case that it's making the town more attractive for people to come here and live here, things like bicycle and pedestrian improvements, that's able to have connectivity, you know, aesthetics. Bucket three is multiplier. When we recommended to council that we put money in a certain program, we were doing it with the idea that money plus X will come back to the community, that it will have a multiplier effect. I think, I don't know if we get into it all, but like the Venture Forward program, We got some good information from them about, you know, what our $40,000, I think, had a multiplier of 300 or something. So that's how we look at those. So it's basically bucket two and three where we spend most of our time. [14:41] Speaker E (unidentified): And those capital ones where we offset provide the local match on things, and we'll show you some examples. So, that leverages the opportunity for the town to draw down federal and state dollars with the local match. So, the town doesn't have to do that out of the normal. I mean, this is all town money. I mean, I don't need to say that it is. Okay. [15:06] Speaker M (unidentified): Guided by certain principles, these weren't thrust upon us. I have to say, in 10 years, I don't think there's ever been a case where we haven't come to a decision or made a recommendation that hasn't been done by consensus. In fact, it's a group that very readily, I mean, after a lot of debate, but we all seem to end up in the same place. Our personal approach, and a lot of towns disagree with that, and the Council may disagree with it, but we have not supported credit enhancement agreements. I think that's where TIFFs get a bad name in a lot of communities because you give away a lot of money to a business and a lot of times they don't actually do what they say they're going to do or they go bust. And so we have, it's been our principle not to do that. It's not to say we would never recommend it, but we really haven't seen one yet that we thought that we are. There was a project in an earlier version of the Railroad Square project where the developers, and it's not the current developers, came and were looking for some assistance. And even though it never happened, where we were prepared to go was to recommend, I think, $300,000 or $400,000 in infrastructure improvements, things that would have enhanced their project, but also would have had lasting benefit to the community. So it wasn't just like handing a check to the developer to help them. So that's sort of how we approach those things. We have not supported using TIF funds for debt servicing, and we have emphasized public-private partnerships as a successful element of what we're trying to do. [16:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay, so before we move into what are the things that inform that thinking and then give you the examples of what has been funded this past year, I want to, I always say this since the beginning of setting up the TIP, the council turned to EDAB and asked us to be the stewards and the advisors on it. We helped create them, we put them together, we come back and we don't always, the council sometimes says there's another priority, but that's kind of, I mean, Megan and David have gone through that. Those are the conversations that we have. I always like to think of us as kind of the loyal opposition. When you're elected official, it's always good to have some trade-off conversations. I know you look to your staff, the staff to do that, but we see that role as advisors as doing that. And we've taken that role very seriously. So sometimes, I mean, last year, I think there were some interesting dialogues that happened. But that's the beauty of having an advisory group that you all are open to continue those dialogues. And that's why it's important for us to have these ongoing meetings, which have usually been the practice. I think last year was an exception. [17:57] Speaker B (unidentified): I think we've probably gone along with 90 to 95% of the recommendations. I mean, it's the outliers that we have the conversations about. [18:05] Speaker E (unidentified): And you all have other roles to play. [18:07] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, we, I mean, we've always been duly aware that we are advisory, it doesn't mean we feel like it's supposed to be a rubber stamp, but we are advisory and we haven't been shy about speaking our mind when we feel strongly. It's been good advice. Yeah, and there have been times when the council has referred something to us, comes directly to the council and said, would you take a look at this and make a recommendation? We've always been happy about that. [18:54] Speaker E (unidentified): We did have staff doing that, and the last director was supposed to was working on that. I don't know if that ever got done, because I couldn't agree with you more. I really would love to see it. [19:12] Speaker N (unidentified): We're going to tell you some of that. Thank you, Jennifer. Some of it might be here. I wonder if there's an opportunity to go, yeah, I'll level up on it. Yeah, and just one other thing. [19:22] Speaker M (unidentified): We've always been acutely these are still taxpayer dollars. The program allows you to shelter some of those, but at the end of the day, it's still, you know, with taxpayer dollars. [19:33] Speaker E (unidentified): When this group was founded, [19:35] Speaker O (unidentified): there was a lot of discussion [19:37] Speaker E (unidentified): because apparently there had been some previous iterations of it and they never lasted. In fact, we're founders of this group. And when we started it, we were very aware that we wanted it to be not just one-offs, but that it was grounded in analysis. So, we did commission the market analysis in 2016, and that was very helpful, and that became a foundation for us to look at what are the things that we need to do in the community. Obviously, some of you have already started reading the market analysis. We gave you the final draft yesterday, but the world has changed, and we were very eager to get that study commissioned. Last year we tried to get it going a little sooner because there was a lot that we needed to understand as we make decisions and make recommendations to you all. You've got a great comp plan that gives you some of that. So we did, we did Commission a new market study so that becomes a good foundation for what are the trends, what are the economic and socio-democratic trends that are shaping our community, so that we can be thinking about it and make informed decisions. That we'll talk to you a little bit about. David wanted us to make sure that we gave you a copy of it, so that's why we sent it to you yesterday, and it's we're not going to get into much detail today because we are doing a we are we have a really large stakeholder engagement, but we 'll be going back to those folks and the Advisory groups that we were involved with to just present to them the findings and get some feedback and hopefully they'll use it too, right? So again, it's a roadmap. We had seven themes and you can see the areas that we that it's touching upon and there's like 60 recommendations with implications. So there's big things, what are the big trends, and then there's areas. And this was our consultant and was based on some information of what also was teeing up some work that's being done and then we also Look to them to share experiences working in other communities so you so that's sort of what we've done. Again, I told you that we're going to go for a public comment period and we'll come back to the council for the end of the year to report back to you on the more details. So tiff accomplishments, there's so many, but these are just some that you see that you may not even realize that were funded. I mean, there's waterfront access and infrastructure, there's a gin pole that's going in the spring That's a big worked on that will make it easier for the working waterfront to be effective down on the down on the boat yard. Thank you. Yes, there are bike racks around town. The sidewalk connections have been really important. Again, there's the edap dollars paid for the recent recently done my bike and head planning. There's all the connections happen a big thing and we had two starts of this because earlier in the town they had tried to do a branding effort and it was really it was a challenge It was we retooled that and I mean I think you must smile driving around town and see the way body I mean Ted shared that we also spin off subgroups to do the work because we meet once a month, but we have some hardworking group of people here and there was a group doing that. And then of course, that would be an area that we fund on the administrative costs to keep getting the materials out there because that's no longer a startup. The Cousins River and Village Bridge replacements, I mean, that's the matching dollars. [23:53] Speaker B (unidentified): We ended up basically paying 15 cents on the dollar for those projects because 30% match, half of it coming from the TIF fund, half of those dollars would have gone away. So if you think about it, we get like a $3 million project for $450,000. [24:07] Speaker E (unidentified): And think about the bridge up here. I mean, some of us were around when all that work was being done. Those enhancements with the pedestrian and the underpass, that was all funded with that. I mean, that's just, it kind of makes me smile when you think about that, you see the kids under there. [24:25] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, we got to the point where there was no money left in the budget to do the walkway [24:32] Speaker K (unidentified): down to group one. That's right. [24:34] Speaker M (unidentified): And we recommended TIF funds be used for that. That's right. [24:40] Speaker E (unidentified): I think it was like one of those typical infrastructure projects that go over a bus. Okay. And the Royal River Park, which you all know is being upgraded. I'm sorry. I just, I knew it was there. So I'm ready to go on to the next. You all know that, well, during COVID, we tried to get a grant loan program out and people were real nervous about submitting. So we retooled that and got feedback. And last year we started this YLEAP program, which is a grant. And three of the projects that were done are right here, year, 317, the accessibility. They had, because it's used so much, they had to change some of their access, so we're able to do that. Endowed at Sea Meadows, there's some improvements at the facility. And then at Peachy's, yeah, Peachy's, that whole facade was done. And we have applications in now, and we have a team of the group reviewing those, so you'll be hearing more about those okay [25:48] Speaker O (unidentified): that's right that's right thank you for adding [26:05] Speaker E (unidentified): that yeah it was it was a game changer yeah so then you all know because last year there was a debate about whether or not you want to continue venture forward we had come to you all with a partnership with the Roux Institute about also again we were hearing that the community the businesses wanted some more technical assistance and a member of our committee is also at group so we have been brainstorming with him on some ideas and we came up with this program and it was great I think we did a presentation last year at the councilman meeting and there was a real cross-section in that first cohort and they were like eight or ten groups and they're all small business they're not all small businesses i mean s brooks was in there to help get help on succession planning but there's it was very diverse but they've all collectively worked together and develop partnerships so it's been really fun to watch and it created a network for them and we also had mentors from the community that have allowed us to tap into some other talent [27:18] Speaker M (unidentified): Here, which is really good, you know, there are other programs sometimes that certain categories of business qualify for, but they sort of meet regionally, and this was really unique in that everybody was already invested in Yarmouth. And you know, even Esther Books, which is obviously well-established, learned something from the startups, and the startups learned from more established business. So the whole thing had a really great feel to it, and really I think heightened the sense of community among all these [27:47] Speaker E (unidentified): businesses, and just with a little more than half of the companies with the [27:51] Speaker N (unidentified): financials, this is something like three hundred, three hundred, three hundred [27:56] Speaker E (unidentified): twenty-five thousand. Yeah, I was just going to say three fifty in additional revenue. So I mean, that's really a great thing, because remember, Megan, I remember our conversation about this. It was how do we, how do we generate some commercial revenue? Because the small businesses spend a tough period. Right. So this is. Yeah, that's right. And so we're, we're going to be kicking up another one in twenty seven. [28:23] Speaker B (unidentified): So anyway, that's been replicated all over the state now. [28:26] Speaker N (unidentified): Yes. Everybody's, everyone's copying, which is really great. [28:30] Speaker E (unidentified): Right. It's really, I mean, we took the risk, we helped do it, and it was, we gave, what, $40,000, and look at what we generated. [28:37] Speaker M (unidentified): And Chris said the other day, there are a couple of banks getting involved now, helping underwrite stuff. And even within Roo itself, which is still a relatively new major investment in Yarmouth, he said that this program has really gotten a lot of notice within the Roo Northeastern community. [28:55] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, he got a promotion, so I guess it did well. I'm sorry. [28:59] Speaker Q (unidentified): No,, it's good. Can I ask a quick question? Yes, please. So, we went, we invested $40,000 and the data comes back that we've generated $325,000. At least that. Additional commercial revenue. Yes. The taxes on that stay within the TIF district, right? Or does that go into the general fund? [29:22] Speaker R (unidentified): Right. So it's the real estate value. It's a real estate value. So, but they generated [29:29] Speaker Q (unidentified): $325,000 extra commercial revenue. So the taxes collected go to the federal income and [29:39] Speaker R (unidentified): state income tax type thing. Yeah. Okay. Because they're businesses. Okay. So the idea then [29:44] Speaker Q (unidentified): Then is when the TIF district expired in 2046. We're hoping that these investments that we've sheltered away from the general fund, when the district expires in 2046, the land value will be such that the improvements that we made with the sheltered money, that the assessed test value of that real estate would then now contribute to the general fund much more than it used to be. [30:18] Speaker M (unidentified): That's a part of it. And I think the other thing about a program like venture for. Not only increases the revenue for those businesses, but it makes them more viable. We're creating jobs too. I mean, jobs. I get that. I mean, a lot of these businesses, you know, you know. I think they would all say they are in a much stronger position to be a sustainable business than they were before. [30:46] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean Joe's Cup of Joe's has already changed her business model and it's really positioned. I mean she's actually setting up a new business within her coffee business and Maggie Bae's set up a whole other business and getting business from downtown. [31:02] Speaker Q (unidentified): Town right but this is again general taxpayer money yes right and so we are helping our local businesses stay in town. We are creating jobs. We are creating a more pleasant area to stay well. [31:23] Speaker G (unidentified): That's good yeah I think I think it's well I think it's really important. [31:29] Speaker E (unidentified): That we help the small businesses because this is not a town that's ever going to be a big corporate headquarters or a big box. And so you want to be have a friendly one of the things we've heard is that we're not we there's a mixed message about how friendly we are. And so those kinds of things to be sensitive to what other added value that we could be bringing. And so that's why we went with the why leave and the venture forward as opportunities to demonstrate those commitments to help those. Businesses be even more viable. [32:05] Speaker K (unidentified): Thank you. You're welcome. [32:07] Speaker M (unidentified): And I think given all the other demands and constraints, it's probably unlikely that a council, this council or any council, would commit $40,000 to $50,000 to a program like that. But because we have these TIF dollars that are outside of that, it does allow you to make these kinds of investments, which I think have a big impact on the community. [32:28] Speaker N (unidentified): I know that would work quite well when the EIR is there, but there's probably an enormous conflict of interest in Chris working that room and half the dollars going to fund a program in the office. How closely would that be? That was, well, he doesn't vote. He doesn't, [32:45] Speaker E (unidentified): He recuses when we vote at the EDAP. Okay. And then I think my follow-up question would be, [32:52] Speaker N (unidentified): Would have done that right because you go under the concept it's an interesting model for them to go in there so I think for this time around we need to look more closely at those types of things because the mission of my sense of what we are doing here is building a place where businesses can be here which is different from building high growth startup businesses is what I write a little bit different nature and what we are anchoring as a community building yes so out of the 60 recommendations From our goal right what we get to do as a council say what is the north star direction for our town so that whatever our milestone is two or three or five years down the road we're radically focused on the most important things for this town at this time and I'm not sure it's high growth businesses well that we haven't spent time on those that's [33:45] Speaker E (unidentified): Right that's right because that's you're used to the Silicon Valley model where that's where you do it but that would be I actually don't want that from right now no and that's not what [33:52] Speaker N (unidentified): That's not these aren't those businesses and that's your question when I think about where we're headed and I want to hear about the budget how have you guys thought about things like I'm starting to worry about the things for life but I can't believe I'm saying out loud like that with that building on the corner across from Hanniford PhD that is now important and I'm starting to see more of this and I'm worried for our town in terms of the development of group one and what it looks like now Boarded up buildings actually how have you guys prioritized the things worth doing versus the things that come to you naturally out of ecosystem [34:26] Speaker E (unidentified): That's the question well that's a very interesting question because that's coming up in the market study and looking at how we infill everyone which is your point yes and so that is being that is starting to be addressed now remember the market study just we're just reviewing it right but that would be in that would be the work program that EDAB would do and be in consultation with you all but that has been one of the areas with the extra parcels and what should we be doing about [34:59] Speaker N (unidentified): Infilling opportunities. So I'm just trying to pretend our charge is to help direct and prioritize the recommendations that will come to be that for this budget year, which could run the gamut from what we do about the board of the buildings to an opportunity at group and there [35:14] Speaker E (unidentified): may be. And by the way, on the conflict, we have two people that have potential conflicts on media, and I've always made sure that they refuse themselves, okay? And we went to Chris and came up with that idea because we went to Rue and met a bunch of people and saw that as an opportunity. So it's bringing those resources. So we've been very careful about them not voting, okay? Because I come from a public life, you can't do that. Yeah, okay. And we are very careful, I mean, and Christine and I've had this conversation too. I mean, I don't want to shut down [35:52] Speaker B (unidentified): the conversation, but I know we're running out of time, being sensitive to the other. Yeah, I know I [35:56] Speaker E (unidentified): know, I know. Sorry, everyone loves this stuff. No, it's good. You know, you all can call us at the time. So this is, this is the budget that was approved last year, and this shows you have, let's just look at the, look at it as sort of big picture. This shows how the money is generated and how it's across the districts, okay? And then you see the total, that was the fiscal year 27 budget for the tip budget, and the projected revenue was just over that. So let's just go back to the list now. So, and we funded remember Ted was talking about the buckets, their special projects and there's capital projects. So these are the things that are funded. So you start to see the kinds of things, you know, you see arts, the farmers market, the brand, you know, you see the things that has been funded. And some of those have been carried over years, and some of them are one offs. [36:57] Speaker M (unidentified): And some have been directed by the council. [36:59] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, some have been directed, yeah. And then this is the capital projects that are in this year's budget. [37:08] Speaker N (unidentified): And these are capital projects that have to happen in the district or anywhere in town? Depends. [37:14] Speaker B (unidentified): It can, like, the pump station serves the whole town. It happens to be in the village district, but if it wasn't, it would probably still be eligible. [37:25] Speaker E (unidentified): And then the working waterfront, you're going to hear more about that. Did they pass the, did they pass the, approve the contract yet? [37:34] Speaker H (unidentified): Yes, we have signed the contract with them. [37:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Because one of the things we, have been very concerned about making sure that we fully understand the needs of the waterfront. The agriculture is just an incredible opportunity for this community. community. So we commissioned a waterfront master plan. And Christine is the project manager on that it was funded by TIF dollars. And that again, that was leveraging a local TIF dollars for local match. And okay, so that's, that's an overview. Oh, and this is this is just the process where requests come to us, we screen them for you. We screen them for the community they come from staff and the committees and local organizations and then we recommend a budget to the council because you all approve okay this would be these are just the kinds of things that are rolling for consideration Mike you had a question Christine can go back to slides [38:33] Speaker Q (unidentified): will put that one thank you the first the pump station a wastewater water sand people 500,000 dollars that's just going to debt service right David [38:45] Speaker C (unidentified): do you want to come in that was the that was the plan however the recommendation [38:52] Speaker B (unidentified): from EDA was that if you spent more on soft costs like engineering studies and things like that and it could be with the timing of the way the projects rolling out Amanda being like that right and because we haven't bonded it yet so it 's kind of fungible I mean it's gonna you know the bonds gonna [39:11] Speaker E (unidentified): be about the same either way that was a disagreement and that's what you saw the guiding principles we do not support use of it for bonding and that was when the council and we gave them ideas like the soft cost of design to delay the bond and do that it turns out that our recommendation is going to come to pass has probably with the town managers. But I mean, there's a lot that could be funded easily with the tip dollars. [39:44] Speaker B (unidentified): It's not something we've done traditionally. [39:47] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah. And I mean, people respected what we said, but there was some pressure, I guess. [39:53] Speaker Q (unidentified): I just want to make sure that it's not actually CIP at least, but that's good. [39:59] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. It was in the wastewater. Okay. That's fine. I think that's it. That is. [40:08] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah. Maybe what we discard. [40:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. I think you think you've usually presented. We usually do. We usually do. [40:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. I'm telling you now. [40:25] Speaker B (unidentified): And we have, and we've, we've reinstituted it. some of those in the past they've shown us and they said we don't recommend this and we said well we're going to do it anyway so yeah the affordable housing yeah 150 000 i think well [40:41] Speaker E (unidentified): we weren't opposed to it 's just that we wanted the market study done so we better inform and there's stuff in the market study that now you know why i wanted the market study done [40:51] Speaker B (unidentified): A lot of times the disagreement is just around time. [40:55] Speaker E (unidentified): What I know is that federal and state dollars will have to be deducted back in the summer. Yes, I think so with the market. [41:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you. It's so nice to meet you. Sure. Okay, everyone. Thank you. [41:18] Speaker K (unidentified): And if I don't see you before Thanksgiving, happy Thanksgiving. [41:30] Speaker C (unidentified): Now we'll move right along to item two. Are we all set here with presentations and stuff? Are you working on that? [41:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. We're going to move to item two, but we're working on some technical issues at the moment. [41:47] Speaker C (unidentified): All right, I'm free. I'm sorry, I'm free. We are with Arts Client's presentation, so come on up, join us, yeah. [42:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Audra, I don't know if you're attempting to show anything that we sent to you, but we do have some heart-warming pictures. [42:28] Speaker F (unidentified): So folks joining us remotely, we're going to cut out for just a second and then rejoin. So we need to take up and pause. [42:38] Speaker H (unidentified): If we drop you, please rejoin, I think, too, right, just in case, I think they're, oh, [42:46] Speaker F (unidentified): hey, oh, look at that, didn't even have to, never mind, yeah, well, we're going to try [42:53] Speaker J (unidentified): to get it, we're good, we're good to go, will they be able to see your presentation? [42:59] Speaker H (unidentified): They, if it's, if it's held up, okay, they're not going to be sharing a PowerPoint with [43:06] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't. Okay. That's fine. Got it. [43:10] Speaker M (unidentified): Okay. Okay. All right. Yeah, that's cool. [43:13] Speaker B (unidentified): And I think, I mean, they have the, they have the photos, right? I mean, sent out to send a whole packet right? Okay. So they, should have them. Okay. Zoe, Heather, can you hear us? I'm clear. Jump right in with you if you have any questions as we go through this. [43:30] Speaker L (unidentified): Thank you. Please take it away. So, [43:42] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm like, I'm the president of the board of arts, which is the public art, and the public art community has been very active in many years. Recently you're not familiar with example of where you can find public art environment and that's part of our mission to we are very grateful we to the NEEDAB grant, so that was a good presentation from Deb. So we're very, thank you very much for inviting us to come talk to you about the penstock control device, which is an awful. I've got public art committee members here who are going to help explain what that is and why it's along the pathway right now, the Royal River Path. It was a relic that we salvaged from the dam removal project. We think that artifact is a really interesting and very worthy of being saved piece of industrial equipment. It's the only thing left in the dam removal, and as you know, the dam removal was done very quickly. Specifically, we are here to explain our process and why it got located a little bit before we were able to get a good meeting with the town council. So we'll explain how that happened, of course if you agree with us that it's an interesting and worthy piece of equipment to salvage, historical value to salvage from damage. It's the only thing left. And I think just making sure that everybody knows what we're talking about. I'm going to pass it on to Bill and Kenny. [45:49] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, I think I ran by it the other day and I was like, what the hell is it? [45:52] Speaker A (unidentified): But you know, I'm hoping people have had a chance because the talk was so great. And since it's been a lot of people going by it, I'm sure they wonder what it is. And we're hoping some scientists can go up there and explain. [46:08] Speaker S (unidentified): That was kind of a before and after. [46:10] Speaker A (unidentified): So Bill McKinney is a member of our public art community and he's going to tell you what the control device is. Thank you, [46:22] Speaker S (unidentified): Anne. And my name is Phil McKinney. I'm a landscape architect, and I'm a member of the Yarmouth Public Art Committee. This background here are a few pictures of the penstock control device as it was before the removal of the dam in its original operating position, and where it sits now on the opposite side of the river. The penstock was a nine foot diameter pipe that carried water from behind the Bridge Street Dam to the Sparhawk Mill. Penstock pipe was fabricated from old rail cars on a train the ends of the cylinder cylinders cylindrical tanks were cut off and the remaining tubes are welded together forming a pipe in order to control the flow of water into the penstock a gate valve was installed at the intake of the pipe a massive 10 foot square plate was raised and lowered by the penstock control device operated manually by a hand crank. We believe the device was installed in the 1870s as part of the dam construction, and it's more than 150 years old. Moving forward in 2026, as part of the dam demolition project, the contractor diligently removed everything, including the penstock pipe, and the only remaining piece was the control device. Device. They moved it to the south side of the river and took the initiative to collect two granite blocks to serve as supports for the device. These granite blocks were also [48:11] Speaker D (unidentified): part of the dam structure. [48:13] Speaker S (unidentified): Lincoln did all of this work at no cost, and we greatly appreciate their efforts. We feel fortunate that Yarmouth was able to salvage the only remaining piece of the dam. It's a visual reminder of the role the river has played throughout much of the town's history. We think it's a relic of DeArmas history that is worth preserving. And I'd be glad to answer any questions about the Pemstock control device; otherwise, I'll [48:41] Speaker L (unidentified): turn it over to Jamie. Questions? Yes, [48:52] Speaker B (unidentified): go ahead. Oh, we can't hear you, 're muted. [48:56] Speaker I (unidentified): Can you hear me now? We sure can. Awesome. I'm just curious, I've been down there to look at it. How movable [49:07] Speaker R (unidentified): mobile in its current form? It's, it's no longer operational or movable. It's, it's [49:18] Speaker S (unidentified): just frozen in place at this point, so all those parts are stationary. Okay. And [49:24] Speaker I (unidentified): And had it, when it was like originally there, maybe like a month ago, was it mobile and it has since been immobilized? [49:31] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, that's a good question. [49:32] Speaker S (unidentified): I don't think so. When I was over there initially, taking a look at it at the beginning, it was in that same condition without, and I tried to move it and I couldn't. Okay. I mean, I assume over time it froze up. [49:50] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay, thank you for the clarification. [50:00] Speaker P (unidentified): Hello, I'm Jean Rapone. I've been a member of Plymouth Public Art for over six years now. I'm currently co-chair of the committee along with Linda Horstman, who unfortunately can't be with us tonight. As we outlined in our letter to all of you, the Public Art Committee became involved in the Penstock project this summer when we learned about the possibility of preserving an artifact from the Bridge Street Dam. We were excited about the potential of using the salvaged material, the penstock control device, for a public art piece, but we quickly refocused our efforts on actually preserving the artifact as a piece of Yarmouth's history. We felt some pressure to work quickly as we could secure the penstock control device so that the contractor could continue to stay on his schedule. Our intention was never to bypass the typical review and approval steps. It was simply an effort to save something of historic value to the community. The penstock actually turned into art without any of us realizing it. No one needed to make art from the scraps of metal. The piece of art was already there right in front of us. Thanks to the generosity of the contractor it was moved at no cost and installed to the current location along the pathway overlooking the river. We hope that you will approve our rescue of the penstock control device and its placement where we chose to put it along the path. With proper signage our community can walk the park leave the history of the former dam while overlooking the flowing river of the Sparhawk Mill, and the Sparhawk Mill, another incredible piece of Yarmouth's history. So, I don't know if you have any questions about how that piece landed there? [51:56] Speaker K (unidentified): Not exactly, but I'm walking along the trail along the river. There's several circular formations of formations made out of bricks from one of the factories that used to be located there. I don't think there's any explanatory sign there, but it's my understanding it was from the factory that used to do cardboard boxes or something. [52:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Ruins of them. Yeah. It used to have signs. It probably came down during the project. There's new signs going up. Yeah. [52:32] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, well, it's not near the bridge. It's, it's, it's the cistern. Anyway, I just bring that up because that too is, you know, a big part of our history. Absolutely. That place generated enormous amounts of toxins. And it's a miracle that we can have this beautiful part there now. So I just would encourage you as part of your work to make part of your art. Thank you. Nice. First of all, by the [53:06] Speaker N (unidentified): side is you guys going to create that signage as a part of the arts? Well, we're going to work [53:10] Speaker P (unidentified): with Katie Worthing over at the historic center and help us with the wording and also [53:16] Speaker A (unidentified): also care. Okay, so they match the other side. The child has a program of doing new interpret sciences. Yeah, we're hoping that we can bring this into the right. And that was my second question [53:28] Speaker O (unidentified): so have you talked to Karen McNeil? I mean, and she's yes with all of this where it is and all [53:35] Speaker P (unidentified): that in terms of well she actually told us to come here. Okay. The building did present [53:41] Speaker E (unidentified): For most everything to do with the park, we just say care. Yeah, well, we really, it's not going [53:47] Speaker G (unidentified): to be a problem for any like maintenance, or you know, I think that's the discussion we need to have [53:54] Speaker B (unidentified): because I mean we need to have someone tell us, right? I guess what I'm saying is not unlike another gift, public gift that is in the public space. We need to, you know, talk about all those aspects. Is it the right thing? Is it in the right place? Is there a plan for maintenance? Is there issues with safety? All of that are things we need to discuss anytime we have a public gift given to us that wasn't in a plan anywhere. It just sort of showed up on our doorstep. And I'm glad you saved it and I understand the time pressure you're under. I probably would have done the exact same things, like yeah, don't throw it away, right? You know, it just kept moving, but you know where does it end up there long term, who knows, but that's what we need to discuss and we need staff input to tell us and committee input, you know, parks and lands care and all that. It shouldn't [54:51] Speaker A (unidentified): just like plop in front of us, you know, so just in terms of placement, it's on the far side of the [54:57] Speaker K (unidentified): river where it's not right. Yeah, yes it does, right out of like as you reach Bridge Street, it's it's [55:05] Speaker P (unidentified): right where you used to be able to kind of go towards the dam and see the dam right there. Right before you get to Bridge Street is the location, and when you stand there and with the device now you see the flowing river where the dam used to be [55:28] Speaker B (unidentified): and Sparhawk Mill. I think we should consider the temporary location. It may end up being permanent, but I think staff should review it and get back to us. [55:40] Speaker N (unidentified): Do you have anything from staff that you can share with us right now? [55:46] Speaker F (unidentified): Not anything from staff. Parks and Lands sent out the list of points that they wanted you to consider. [56:02] Speaker B (unidentified): I have a chance to read the answer. [56:05] Speaker N (unidentified): Do you guys know the general specs on it? How much does it weigh? What do we need to move? How do we get moved? It's like a dropper. [56:11] Speaker S (unidentified): It's heavy. It's very heavy. So they tried to put it on one backhoe and they couldn't. It was too heavy and it couldn't be moved. So they had to use a bigger background and they laid out all those wood planks and moved it across. They did mention it was really heavy and anticipated. [56:36] Speaker N (unidentified): So kept dry movement is not without expense and you're thinking about it differently. [56:42] Speaker S (unidentified): And they did bolt the unit. They did a great job. They bolted it down when it's stale boats in and they drilled into the ground to support. Yeah, so it's secure. [56:55] Speaker N (unidentified): And it's that little bit of land, it's like town-owned land. I know exactly where it is. I presume it is, just making sure, not like, by the way, it's somebody's [57:05] Speaker A (unidentified): land, it's yours. All right, it's yours. So we will get to you in a second, Mike. [57:14] Speaker Q (unidentified): Sorry, I just wanted to ask and clarify with Audra, when you sent out the meeting minutes with the agenda and the information you all provided on the timeline, there was another piece of paper that was signed off by Dave Madsen, it was a bill. [57:33] Speaker K (unidentified): Oh, that's something different. [57:35] Speaker Q (unidentified): So that's for something else on the agenda, that's not included with this, right? [57:38] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. Just wanted to make sure. [57:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Zoe, you had a question? [57:44] Speaker I (unidentified): And you're muted. I always raise my hand instead of unmuting myself. It's just a fun little thing I do. Yeah, so, as liaison to the Parks and Lands Committee, I've spoken with a couple members directly. I wasn't able to be at the meeting this month, but it does, you know, the concerns that they presented, I think we should follow up on them, especially where liability is concerned. I think that was like the most significant concern from the members that I spoke to were just concerns about what if the piece were to move? Could it hurt somebody? Are we sure that it's in place the way we want it to be? I personally, like not speaking in that role, have walked by it and like it. I think if we're going to put signage by it, my hope would be that signage would be fundraised for. You know, I think as we're talking about accepting public gifts, one of the kind of conditions it seems that everyone is interested in the tight budget moment is, you know, are they, is the town having to pay for some component of it or not? And my hope with something like this would be or not there's standard signage in a bunch of places in Royal River Park and so there's a format that was like approved and implemented as part of the Royal River Park upgrades or there was signage that was already there before that they just left in the same places because the place didn't move the pathways did so I think I could not be a bigger fan of public art I love what you guys do I'm deeply appreciative I understand the sort of sequela of Events that led to how it got to where it was, and as a liaison to parks and lands, I just, I want folks, other council members in the room to understand that the conversation within that committee was there was a lot of concern about just making sure that the questions that they had were followed up on. And you know, I think unrelated to this project, it really does turn us back to a larger conversation we've been having about gifts and what is our process for accepting them and what does that look like. Like, we can go all the way back to the Latch String Park of it all and say that was also a big pro, there was a big process around that. And so I think probably we as a council need to get clear on what process looks like so that folks don't feel like they're being unduly targeted for one gift and then somebody else is making a gift and nobody's looking at it or talking about it. So I just, from a process point of view, but I have walked down there and again stepping back into my personal perspective, I think it looks really cool and I'm not sad that it's there. I just think we should be tightening up on process that [1:00:45] Speaker P (unidentified): makes anybody feel any better. We also have a process on accepting gifts because you know we have to have that process as well. Two quick [1:01:04] Speaker N (unidentified): Yes, we have to get tighter. [1:01:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Two quick questions. What's the ownership situation? Do you own it? Who owns this? And how is that documented? [1:01:15] Speaker S (unidentified): Sure. So it went from the town originally to the contractor. By contract, they owned everything over there to take care of it. And then Michael Wilber, who owns the house on the other side of the river, right there on the retaining wall, didn't want to see it be salvaged. He wanted it kept in town. So he asked for it just to try to help make that happen. So the contractor gave it to him, and then we went to Michael. Michael was just concerned that it'd be done in a way that it was respectful of the history and he didn't want to just give it to us without that. So he didn't give it to us until the end, till the placement. And then he said, yeah, I think it looks great. So. [1:02:03] Speaker B (unidentified): So, I think, even though this has all been verbal concept, it's because at some point we have it. Maybe I assume at some point. I mean, if we accept the gift that the town will then. We own it, right, although if there's no paper trail, maybe we still own it. I mean, I know I went to Lincoln for sure, you know, on paper, I mean, that was the contract, so we're going to need something, maybe from Lincoln, the documents that, right, would go to the town. My other question is, so is your official name now Public Arts and not here with Arts Alliance? I've heard you say [1:02:38] Speaker P (unidentified): public, we are under the umbrella, so Yarmouth Arts Alliance is the big umbrella, okay, we are under Yarmouth Arts Alliance, but we are Yarmouth, we, our focus, so Yarmouth Arts Alliance is the big all arts that are happening in town, okay, our focus is [1:02:55] Speaker D (unidentified): just public art in Yarmouth. I see, but I didn't think you used YAA as the, when [1:03:00] Speaker B (unidentified): you said, oh, you did, yeah, okay, my mistake then, because I thought you said one [1:03:04] Speaker A (unidentified): thing, I thought you said another, I'm like, what is YAA? I tried to explain it, I'm the president of the board of the alliance [1:03:13] Speaker B (unidentified): is the public. I misunderstood you then when you introduced, I'm sorry, and just so you know [1:03:17] Speaker P (unidentified): we didn't even let them know that this was happening, we moved so quickly, we, you know, we didn't, so Ann is presenting here as the, as the umbrella, but we didn't even let them know, we [1:03:30] Speaker L (unidentified): just kept moving, I mean, we'll stop and we will look at it, something will happen. I just want to [1:03:37] Speaker N (unidentified): say Les was in the record, I worry about things you might not know, like is it full of lead that kids going to lick, is it somehow radioactive, we don't know, like we have to have a strength assessment for the risk, yeah, it's tricky, but there is lots of that's other, there's lots of public [1:03:55] Speaker J (unidentified): art and, oh yeah, and public structures like, no, but I think just make a point, you know, there's [1:04:02] Speaker B (unidentified): there's things we have to consider when these things happen, you know, you can't, we can't just [1:04:07] Speaker P (unidentified): play rubber stamp, go on, that's great, thanks, yeah, unfortunately we've had to deal with some vandalism that we never thought we were ever going to have to deal with, oh yeah, not with that piece, but we've had smashed, we wanted all of our plaques to be slate or not all of them, but we wanted to use slate here and there, we can't use slate, it was, they were smashed to pieces, so there we have to, I know that you all have to consider everything as we do now too, we have to consider everything when we're choosing a piece of art, not just how is it going to work in the in the town, but is it going to be safe, is it going to fall over, our kids going to climb on it and fall off of it, so there's all that fun stuff, presuming that the other one starts out next [1:04:56] Speaker N (unidentified): Year, I know it's still fundraising. Are there other artifacts there that we can get ahead of? What do you anticipate on the second? [1:05:02] Speaker L (unidentified): Oh, on the other day. Oh, on the other day. [1:05:05] Speaker N (unidentified): There's probably some cool enough that aren't there. You know, we planned for those. [1:05:09] Speaker P (unidentified): That would be nice if it could be pre-planned so we'd have time to come to you to ask. Because, you know, if there's some really cool metals, there are metal artists out there that would, you know, come take that and commission art from it, so. [1:05:24] Speaker K (unidentified): Well, the scrap came from the dump. Yeah. [1:05:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, we don't have that list. So what would the next steps be for us to help you respond? [1:05:44] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I think, well, I think what's going to happen is staff, it's going to be in the hands of town staff at this point, and they'll contact you if they need to, and then eventually end up on one of our agendas and we'll do our regular process. [1:05:57] Speaker N (unidentified): So I'll talk about it at a workshop and maybe another ops meeting and caution or anything. What we have is, it looks fun. Right? Right by the river. I want to go for it. Do we need in the immediate term to have that somehow important. [1:06:12] Speaker F (unidentified): In person so I want to speak to our insurance carrier and make sure that it's listed as a item that's insured under the town's general liability policy makes sense and then you know all the other sort of you know logistics of the site it's on looking into some of those you know I think with public art in general I've gotten some feedback from Yarmouth Community Services that you know they're they're kind of struggling with the maintenance expectations around the public art itself so I think That's something you know like a more general conversation that we need to have about how we plan for how they're maintained going forward [1:07:04] Speaker P (unidentified): That's the thing that we're also considering when we're choosing a location and what it is. [1:07:10] Speaker A (unidentified): One good thing about this is it's been sitting out in the open for 150 years. Right. We don't expect that it would need maintenance. Some of the other questions about paint, it definitely doesn't move. [1:07:23] Speaker D (unidentified): It's solid. [1:07:25] Speaker F (unidentified): I think their concern is not necessarily maintaining the pieces of art themselves, but the request to landscape around them and you know weed whack and stuff like that this is more of those oh yeah it's more of their they're having a hard time [1:07:40] Speaker E (unidentified): Keeping up with what we have already. Yeah, thank [1:07:48] Speaker K (unidentified): You. Thank you very much. [1:07:52] Speaker B (unidentified): All right, moving along to item number four, review and advancement of the draft, November 19, Town Council voting meeting agenda. So basically next week, anybody have questions on anything we'll be voting on next week, roll call, minutes, reports, that's by standard, liquor licenses, standard, over-limit permit. Yeah, go ahead. [1:08:19] Speaker O (unidentified): So, Megan, my question is on for approval of affordable housing reserve to pay for town office parking lot expansion. I just don't agree. I think I remember talking about this before and I'm also not going to be there next Thursday. So, I would love to know what this is about. [1:08:40] Speaker F (unidentified): So, and this is something that's handed over to me. So I think, I don't know if Nat spoke with all of you about this. But right before he left, he mentioned that, you know, because we're losing some space in the very back parking lot, public works did some work to expand the parking lot to the side of the building. And so the idea was to pay for that, expansion of parking back there, that we'd ask the council if that could come out of the affordable housing reserve. [1:09:10] Speaker R (unidentified): So that was the, that was the seventh, that roughly $7,000. Yeah. [1:09:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, okay. I think the original estimate was 10, so I guess it came in a little under budget. I do remember talking about that a long time ago. I think it was in an email before he left. I read it. Yeah. And they just completed it and got the, yeah. [1:09:30] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, okay, my response back, we never really circled this one, shouldn't the developer pay for it, and the response I think was like, well, that wasn't originally part of the deal, we didn't originally know that you would need it, so I'm not in favor of that. I mean, develop, they're going to generate a lot of positive return on their work, we love the work that they're doing, why should we, it's an inconvenience to the town, did they, did it turn out that they [1:10:01] Speaker O (unidentified): needed to take more spaces from the current lot than they had originally said, no, so this has always been part of the plan, I think, I remember, that's what I mean by a long time, we just, I think [1:10:10] Speaker B (unidentified): I've been hearing this a long time, yeah, they didn't do anything different, it's just the town under Nat was like, we're not going to party, we shouldn't create something, well, I mean, I think we all realized that, we just didn't, we everyone's had a concern about the parking, it's just a question of how bad will it be and is there anything we should do about it, and I thought [1:10:32] Speaker K (unidentified): we should do something about it, when do we have a long full of parking, I mean, yeah, many people come [1:10:40] Speaker F (unidentified): It's mostly just Thursdays in the, you know, kind of summer time when the partners. [1:10:48] Speaker N (unidentified): Oh, I think it's the talk on Homer in the store. [1:10:50] Speaker K (unidentified): But it's Brickyard Hollow that's using up all our spaces, why don't they pay for it? [1:10:56] Speaker N (unidentified): It seems like a weird use, it seems like the easy thing to do is say, oh, just use reserve funds. But I want us to have like a little more discipline on approaching these projects, it's basically a commercial project, where we made a decision that we needed more, does that need to come before the council, or was that a staff level decision? So, what I'm trying to decide, like, if the guys already been cast and it was made at the staff level and. What are we going to do? It doesn't feel like a lot of money, but the lack of attention to detail is continuing to screw us across several areas. I don't know what to do about each of these as they come up. [1:11:34] Speaker Q (unidentified): Right is the I agree with you, but is I mean it's the works, but done right? And so you know, I guess the question is, for we take the money out of now that it's been spent. So it looks like it was signed off by public works right? Yeah, it's not coming out of the public works, but we're, we're trying to. [1:12:02] Speaker R (unidentified): Use up the money from the affordable housing wizard. I believe that if. [1:12:08] Speaker F (unidentified): If the council doesn't want it to come out of the affordable housing reserve, it would just be absorbed into their operating budget. That's why Dave sign up. Yep. [1:12:19] Speaker Q (unidentified): Yeah, so the money's already been paid out of the public works operating. [1:12:26] Speaker B (unidentified): It just wasn't something they expected. Correct. And they did their budgets of like, hey, could we get reimbursed. [1:12:31] Speaker F (unidentified): From some thought, and also just to be, there was some,. Ancillary benefits to them doing that project. It was a good skill building project for the crews. So other reasons to do it. [1:12:46] Speaker O (unidentified): But so I'm, I just, I'm always reluctant to take money out of the affordable housing reserve because I have myself into that. So, and I, this is my memory and it's just my memory, but I have been involved with overseeing and hearing about this for a number of years, a couple of years now. Now, when it was first designed, I do remember them saying, we're going to need some more spaces, possibly. And then somebody said, well, we could put them on the side. It wasn't that, because this is during his retirement, his first retirement. But I don't remember a time when that was solidified as the plan. It was mentioned a couple of years ago. [1:13:30] Speaker B (unidentified): It was never in a plan. This was unplanned. This was something that... [1:13:34] Speaker J (unidentified): Although it was no, that's what I see. We knew. Well, I mean, we knew we were losing. We knew we were losing a bunch of spaces. Nat decided. [1:13:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Hey, you know, we ought to recover some, put some on the side. Well, Scott had said that too. Right. But, I mean, it's, it's part of daily operations, you know, it's like, okay, we need to react to something. We do it. It's in their budget, you know, they pay out of their budget and normally. doesn't come back to us because it just comes out of their operating budget. In this case it was just like hey could we recover the monies. If there's no appetite for that we say no. [1:14:11] Speaker N (unidentified): Does it need a vote in a public meeting? [1:14:13] Speaker F (unidentified): I mean you know if there's consensus here that it's something you don't even want to come to a voting [1:14:20] Speaker L (unidentified): meeting then we'll see. We moved it to the voting meeting at the last stop. Oh, right. He said we go so we can go to down and we can look forward and we can. [1:14:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, yeah, it's not everything comes before us passes, you know. Good not trying to shortcut the discussion, but it may have other questions that would help you. Help inform your vote. [1:14:48] Speaker Q (unidentified): Do we have any fluff anywhere else? [1:14:50] Speaker F (unidentified): I think that there's funding you know they wouldn't have approved it if they [1:14:54] Speaker R (unidentified): didn't have yeah have room in his budget for it yeah okay appointments [1:15:01] Speaker B (unidentified): so we will we be getting any appointments or whether as a committee [1:15:06] Speaker I (unidentified): Matt I don't know what's going on no we and in fact just saying this to Mike and Heather we should plan on 630 next month before the ops meeting so that'll be December what 11th or something 10th December 8th 9th 10th yeah December 10th standing meeting that we had on the yeah it was it removed it had been before we had initially had it before workshop but then I think the decision was that because it's hard to make the meeting public in the log cabin before a larger meeting goes public because people are kind of sifting in and yada that we had moved it in front of the ops meeting and for whatever reason that's not when we met this month so I think we should plan to meet on December 10th before the ops meeting at 6.30 because we're going to have a large slate of applicants coming through because it's the end of the year. And I would just request that folks make the reminder when they're at committee meetings in the next few weeks that people whose terms are expiring and who would like to serve another term in 2027 need to resubmit an application because that is the way to get reappointed. So right now we have one applicant, but we don't have the larger slate that I would anticipate that we'll have for the voting meeting in December. [1:16:49] Speaker B (unidentified): So can you just make sure please, that even though no member of the public has ever attended an Appointments Committee, just make sure that we have it noticed. [1:17:01] Speaker I (unidentified): It's always noticed. Noticed we in fact we've canceled them for lack of posting like if it's not if it's not noticed in time we don't do it. Perfect thank you. Yeah so we do have [1:17:14] Speaker Q (unidentified): that one applicant one candidate that is in reserve until we have an opening [1:17:21] Speaker R (unidentified): pop-up from the comprehensive. Yeah that's actually not the only applicant [1:17:30] Speaker I (unidentified): that we have in reserve, so to speak. [1:17:32] Speaker Q (unidentified): We have another one too. [1:17:34] Speaker B (unidentified): You'll get a bunch in the next month, yeah. [1:17:36] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah. That question is who am I, 'm gonna tell my committees if, they might not even know if they're up. So like, oh, is my term expiring? Like, does everybody need to tell them? [1:17:48] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I'll ask Lisa to share out the most updated version of the boards and committees spreadsheet that she keeps. It has everyone's name on it and the year that their term is ending. [1:18:00] Speaker N (unidentified): And if they want to be on, they have to send a letter to who and by when? [1:18:04] Speaker I (unidentified): It's not a letter. They go on the town website under the boards and committees page, and there is a quick fill form that they send in. And the sooner the better, because otherwise, if somebody else applies before they do and there's an opening, they may not get their spot back. Back. You just asked an important question. Oh, they're just remembering that we, in tightening up the council rules, we have been stringent about the two terms. [1:18:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Sorry, cut out. We can't hear you. [1:18:44] Speaker L (unidentified): We can't hear you. We can't hear you. [1:18:47] Speaker R (unidentified): You're muted. Oh my God. [1:18:50] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay, now you're back. It's like the people at Apple think they're geniuses but they're not okay freaking ipad pods airpods anyways the a reminder that we are pretty strict on the two-term limit so folks can serve two full terms if they serve a partial term prior to their first term they're still eligible for two terms subsequent to that but if they have served two full terms they need to take a year off and then they're welcome to reapply the following year just like on council all right [1:19:30] Speaker J (unidentified): any anything oh [1:19:33] Speaker Q (unidentified): sorry my question from before was what was I never saw any paperwork on the MD [1:19:41] Speaker R (unidentified): OT over limit permit how much are they going over by they don't know at [1:19:46] Speaker F (unidentified): this stage how much it's really just a permit that covers them for during the construction period if they need you know i don't even know if they'll need to go over any local roads i think [1:20:00] Speaker E (unidentified): that's just to cover them in case they do thank you can [1:20:07] Speaker B (unidentified): we move to item five this is scheduling a future work and discussions so cmp presentation on transmission line upgrades is there anything, [1:20:17] Speaker C (unidentified): is there anything scheduled right now or not? [1:20:24] Speaker Q (unidentified): Well, I was going to say, so Jen and I were both at the climate action board committee meeting earlier this week and remember at the workshop, I mentioned that. one of the things that were thrown out at us was that substation needed to be upgraded in order to have the power from the solar panels to be transmitted into the grid and if yarmouth did not support if the greater transmission plan did not go through then we have to we as in the project manager would have to come up with the funding to replace the equipment in the current substation in order to make it work and that was news to mr earths who was running this so he said that was the first time he's ever heard of that concern and so it's, you know, and I think it's important to get that meeting and really get an idea of how much, how little, because now next week we're going to have a planning board meeting over, you know, a major, you know, I mean, to approve this project, right, to a certain extent. And it doesn't make sense if we don't understand if the solar farm is actually going to be able to interconnect with that we need to get some idea if the project is actually even going to [1:22:01] Speaker O (unidentified): be feasible right following up on that yeah it's shocking that david usually oh yeah well yeah makes me wonder if the person working at the at the station told you the correct information [1:22:16] Speaker R (unidentified): because david might know it better well so david told me that the [1:22:22] Speaker Q (unidentified): the selected group er dp edpr was working on this interconnection with cmp and i again that's why i don't know what's what right or wrong that was just what was presented yeah so i think it's important i mean that whoever presented to me knew that i was a councilman that i wasn't there as a you know i was there as a private citizen of interest but they knew i was a council person so i just want to make sure we know exactly what we're getting [1:23:00] Speaker R (unidentified): ourselves into before we prove something another question about that so when you write cmp [1:23:07] Speaker O (unidentified): presentation on transmission line upgrade is that just referring to the station that mike was talking about no there's the whole entire system from through town [1:23:17] Speaker F (unidentified): being upgraded station to it would be huge yeah so I guess that's kind of what I wanted to get your input on do you would you like CMP because I know they've come in and they've done a community presentation on the project twice so given that really the most significant impact for us is on the transmission station and the solar array it would probably make more sense just to have them come in and focus on that and with the solar developer so that you can all hear firsthand yes so is everybody able to come to that yes absolutely is a presentation [1:24:10] Speaker L (unidentified): though necessary could we just have our i think it's more of just a meeting unless yeah but i'm [1:24:16] Speaker K (unidentified): thinking before the planning board meaning which is next thursday right so [1:24:25] Speaker B (unidentified): i was trying to say is a presentation necessary at all though can we just have our you know can we reach out through our attorney and ask cmp to go on record as to what the real story is i mean i mean i don't want to sit in a meeting and have them tell us something that we don't have any way to you know if it's just bluster or not it might yeah so and i'd like to make sure that cmp did reach [1:24:55] Speaker Q (unidentified): reach out to the butters, right? So they told me they did. They knocked on doors, left flyers. And so I want to make sure that whatever information is relayed to us is relayed to those butters. You know, more opt-in, give them all the information. They say, Audra, thanks. We don't need it anymore. Stop. Then they volunteer to opt out of that info. It's a very small piece. It's just literally the greater transmission line, the one that you hear about in the news, it only affects Yarmouth at the very, end, just down the street. [Speaker C (unidentified): And Cumberland.] Yeah, they're organized, so it'd be interesting to see if that project actually goes through. [1:25:45] Speaker B (unidentified): So what do we want to do? [1:25:50] Speaker K (unidentified): I would suggest that you... [1:25:54] Speaker Q (unidentified): Right, we get that information for us to be recommended. Yes. And the E. R. E. D. R. P. R. Yeah. And say. You know, project goes through, I think we're in the clear project doesn't greater transmission line doesn't go through. We need something from saying they are going to pay for the upgrade equipment necessary. necessary and how much is that right so cmt has to tell us how much is the upgrade cost going to be [1:26:26] Speaker N (unidentified): And that's going to be still willing to do the engagement. Yeah, they might just be like, no solar. [1:26:32] Speaker K (unidentified): No way. Yeah, can't help it. What do they care about solar? It's nothing they're invested. [1:26:40] Speaker B (unidentified): All right, anything more on that? The next one kind of gets to what Counselor or Monty brought up last week, and we had that presentation from Breeze. Is what other things should we hear about? And so Honors made this list. Does it look good to everybody? The water [1:27:02] Speaker N (unidentified): district, we had our coffee with the counselor and Zoe and I were there, and Gift, our kind of water trustee, you know, relationship was there, and we talked about this and he gave me some context on how we got to where we are, but he also agreed it would be really good to have a session like that. I talked about briefly about the kind of sewer fee opportunity stuff. He was not yet aware of that, so strongly in favor of this, not just for hydrant rental discussion, but really understanding that what's going on there, what are the opportunities there, and they are a separate [1:27:34] Speaker R (unidentified): organization from us, right? They're not, we are not in any way, maybe some numbers, right, to [1:27:41] Speaker Q (unidentified): to see exactly how much we are putting in. [1:27:49] Speaker N (unidentified): I'll just- We are not in charge of them, but they do charge us. Yeah, I know. We are not. [1:27:57] Speaker F (unidentified): The biggest expense to us in our budget are the hydrant rental fees. [1:28:02] Speaker N (unidentified): So we get a bunch of Public Utility Commission issues with that I was not aware of until the coffee with the counselor, so. And we'll learn something. It's very different. [1:28:13] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, and I was on a meeting with the administrator for Cumberland County, and he said he'd be more than happy to come and present Cumberland County's budget for 27 and answer any questions that you had about it. So that'll be an easy one to schedule as well. [1:28:41] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it would be interesting to see the breakdown on all of these, like we got one in the breeze. I thought that was a good presentation. Yeah. [1:28:48] Speaker Q (unidentified): So, and Dave just actually highlighted, so, you know, my understanding was that, you know, Essentially that 60% increase up to, you know, that's the fee that we are obliged to discuss whether we're not, we're going to pay that. We're not to get out of that freeze contract is horrendous. Yeah, right. Because it seems like, in order to get out of the service, get out of sort of beholden to their budget. budget, we actually have to pay one-sixth of the debt that program has incurred over the life of its thing. So I would just say, you know, as we move forward, especially when, you know, the email about GPCOG and regionalization, as we move towards looking at projects like this, we don't get ourselves into a situation where it actually costs an arm and a leg to get out of and we'll be holding to a entity where you know we have very little control over the price increase. Right, I mean, gosh, we have to go to PUC, we gotta go through all of this to get quote unquote reassess. I mean, if you look at just that one slide, that one number using their formula, even though they try to soften it, the biggest users are in Portland, right, the most users in Portland. So I feel like we're sort of subsidizing Portland writers for that service, right, they're going to Portland, right, but the Portland used. Yeah, there are more people in Portland who use the breeze in Portland than Yarmouth using the breeze to get into. [1:30:44] Speaker O (unidentified): I don't think that's right. I don't think because the breeze doesn't stop in Portland. It picks up with one, it's two stops within about a two o'clock. [1:30:52] Speaker Q (unidentified): If you look at that slide that says. And then they come here. Yeah. If you look at that slide that says Portland and how many rides that. [1:31:01] Speaker O (unidentified): But they wouldn't go, where would they go? [1:31:02] Speaker J (unidentified): They would be going from the library to the, so when you get on, when you get on in Yarmouth [1:31:08] Speaker B (unidentified): that counts as a Yarmouth ride. Yeah, when you return to Yarmouth from Portland, that counts as [1:31:15] Speaker J (unidentified): a Portland, but the Portlanders are writing from Portland to one of them. What I'm saying is so [1:31:20] Speaker B (unidentified): there's always going to be a lot more important because that's where people are going, but I'm [1:31:25] Speaker O (unidentified): trying to explain to Mike that doesn't mean that those people are riding around Portland that we're subsidizing. They are coming here and they may very well be Yarmouth residents coming here from Portland. It's not there. The whole metro itself has a whole entire. Sure. Okay. [1:31:40] Speaker J (unidentified): But the breeze is not part of that. It's just for. Okay. I mean you make a good point and it's [1:31:46] Speaker B (unidentified): difficult to get out of and you can understand why they would do it that way too. You can't have people dropping in and out buying buses that everyone quits on. Right, but then we're [1:31:54] Speaker Q (unidentified): we're beholden to the service fees and costs. So you'll see what the question is. [1:32:01] Speaker K (unidentified): But no, the place is really intended to help the Outline community. [1:32:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Sure, not Portland. [1:32:08] Speaker O (unidentified): Right, and it doesn't. It doesn't help Portland because it stops in two places and both of those are places the Metro also stops. If you wanted to go from the library to up by the parking. [1:32:18] Speaker R (unidentified): Yeah, I'll wait until I see. [1:32:26] Speaker B (unidentified): So, back to this, though, is this people happy with this list? Or are there other things you'd like to see on that list? [1:32:36] Speaker N (unidentified): What might be useful is just to reference this to the previous budget and see if there is a bucket that is a kind of an affiliated thing. Just that we understand the pregame before the budget. Just there may be others that aren't here that we wouldn't even know to look for. Gotcha. Yeah, I went [1:32:57] Speaker B (unidentified): over the list with her the other day. I added the assessor that wasn't on there. I think [1:33:04] Speaker I (unidentified): everything else was Dave. David. Oh yeah, go ahead. I just, I don't know if this is like entirely pertinent, but I think some understanding of Wyman might be helpful for folks, sort of like where we're at with Wyman, what emerging concerns there are, how the town is positioning itself. I think when I'm out talking to folks, I mean, I know I'm on the island a lot, but even off island, Wyman comes up often, and I think it would be helpful to have had a primer on that as a group. Yeah. Mike? [1:33:38] Speaker Q (unidentified): Did we ever get any feedback from... remember when that we had gotten our assessment and we're going to look at that again to see if we [1:33:52] Speaker R (unidentified): can get more money? It's not that we ever get any feedback from them, so the, there's an appraiser [1:34:00] Speaker F (unidentified): working on that and they're waiting for the end of the calendar year to get a full year of financials to help them do that analysis, so that's kind of a hold up at this point. Thank [1:34:20] Speaker K (unidentified): you. I forgot about that. There's a lot of talk in the market analysis about Wyman as a location for a working waterfront. Now that's just the strip, you know, at the very end. And so, if we have discussions with them, I know they don't really want to sell their. Enterprise, but maybe X, maybe an easement for the. More French. All [1:35:02] Speaker B (unidentified): right, Council policy initiatives. Is this new stuff? Yeah, anything that you have. [1:35:13] Speaker Q (unidentified): I think the first one dovetails nicely. I'd like to schedule some time to make sure that we do follow through if we're going to follow through, but we follow through on creating a policy for gifts and other things. Just tonight, we see it's a recurring thing. The other thing is, I did meet with town counselors from North Yarmouth and Cumberland and trying to see if they can consolidate their fire and rescue to lower costs. But to also increase the serviceability of the 2 counties, not their goal is not to fire anyone because it's hard enough for them to keep the staff that they, have their goal is to try to make sure that we all have enough personnel to do what we need to do. Plus the equipment. So, of notes, the two counties have agreed to come up with a memorandum of understanding. There's a list of questions in that memorandum's authority to give to their individual town managers to answer some questions with data. And so, as I see that MOU, I'll be bringing it back to you all to see if that's anything we want to consider or sign up for, because you know, our next big bond issue potentially is a new ladder truck. And, you know, do we really need three ladder trucks within the 15 miles and is there a way? And so the idea of their formulation is they would have an expert come in and sort of figure out using the existing facilities how we would partition the staffing and the equipment. But this is all in the talking stages right and in order to answer some of those questions and to model this out I haven't included any of us I was just listening in they're coming up with a letter a memo with a list of questions so hopefully in the near future I'll bring that up to you all you guys can see if you want to participate it's not that we're saying yes we're going to get involved but just to participate [1:38:03] Speaker O (unidentified): Is this an or is this an initiative started by one of the other towns or both of them? [1:38:08] Speaker Q (unidentified): No they were already doing it and they were they were already doing it Cumberland not Cumberland and North Yarmouth [1:38:17] Speaker O (unidentified): Two counties two towns okay so they were already talking and they and then we just okay yeah well [1:38:25] Speaker Q (unidentified): They asked me if I was interested with Yarmouth was interested as I didn't know but I asked council earlier if I can go to these meetings just to find out more. So I did. [1:38:34] Speaker O (unidentified): I was going to ask if it was something like started by GDCOT or something and they were just doing that. [1:38:39] Speaker Q (unidentified): Yeah, I think they wanted to just keep it a little bit smaller and a little bit more manageable because the three of us towns are in close proximity to each other. [1:38:52] Speaker B (unidentified): It started up like three years ago. Bob Vail was probably there from Cumberland, I assume. Yeah. So Bob was the one that kind of brought us together first time. He really just wanted to talk about fire departments and the rest of us wanted to talk about regionalization. And then that grew into this GPCOG thing. And I think Bob was like, I still want to talk about my thing and kind of broke off this little subgroup to get back to his thing, which is, I don't blame him. He was getting lost and everything else. But there wasn't much interest from the other towns in what Bob wanted to do. You know, Falmouth was like, we don't have any interest in doing that. Freeport was like, we don't have any interest in doing that. And we didn't show much interest in it at the time. So I think he probably felt like he needed to get rebooted. [1:39:34] Speaker Q (unidentified): So, yeah, so just a clarification. Communication Dispatch Contract account of Falmouth. We're paying Falmouth right now to be our dispatch and communications for fire rescue or just for public service for all of it. [1:39:49] Speaker F (unidentified): All of our communications for public safety, so police fire and rescue. [Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so, okay.] So, you know, I guess there's been talk about switching to Cumberland County for this service and, you know, I think we're at a time where we might get a lower price from the county than from Falmouth. However, there needs to be some major upgrades to the police departments. There's, there's different technical upgrades, like, their, system that sort of integrates with a database that gives them information. You know, when they pull people over and stop them, that's different from Cumberland county to our police department. And so that would need to change. And there's a few other, I think, hardware issues. So, you know, the annual ongoing cost to Cumberland county might be lower, but there are some things that we need to do. [1:40:45] Speaker B (unidentified): There's some capital investment in order to do that. So sounds like medical systems. When we, when we were developing this list on Tuesday, Tuesdays, we, it started to kind of blow up because we started putting in all these regionalization things. And I think we kind of settle on that might be a separate, we should probably have a separate list of all the regionalization things we're doing and talk about those. But to do this first because this will impact the budget and the other one can be maybe it maybe just follows up but I didn't want to get too I didn't want to make this list too long and have stuff that you know it's just a thought but the dispatch even though it's regionalization it's also a fairly sizable bill and I thought it made sense to keep it in here. [1:41:32] Speaker O (unidentified): I generally briefly talked about this but sometimes I worry that I love working with GBCOG and they do great things but regionalization that can happen among us a few smaller towns here sometimes might get you know GBCOG is a lot of bigger towns than us and they get a lot more those towns get a lot more attention from GBCOG which makes sense but I wonder if there's some if either through them or by ourselves there could be some sort of a small group to talk. [1:41:59] Speaker E (unidentified): About regionalization from Falmouth, Cumberland, Dartmouth, North Yarmouth and Freeport. [1:42:07] Speaker B (unidentified): That's with those five towns and the fire department or no it started as fire departments with those five towns though okay and then it got more general regionalization with those five towns but then it got picked up by gpcog and now it's kind of big but I think there's a lot those towns we already not and it's not always all fine we already do a lot of stuff with like yeah animal control, general assistance, and yadda. So it would be good to meet about that so that we're all on the same page. [1:42:41] Speaker O (unidentified): Having a group with both the town and the school, representations from all of those towns together, just those towns, and not taken over by GBCOG and including anybody else, we might find things that we can, both the schools and the town can collaborate on. [1:42:57] Speaker B (unidentified): We did it. We were meeting like quarterly. I honestly didn't see it getting going. I kind of lost it, but it could just be me. I know Karen was really into it. I sat through those meetings. I'm like, we're not getting anywhere. I didn't feel like much was happening. [1:43:26] Speaker N (unidentified): The process piece is important. I would encourage us to get away from the word gifts, because gifts and strategic asks and public art that is suddenly bolted to the ground. I think the language is important. Who do you imagine in the town that would lead on that type of policy development? I'm just interested to know who might work with us. [1:43:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, I mean, you know, that's probably something that I would normally do. Great. Yeah. And I know Mike's done a bit of research and I think I've had a few other and, you know, I might get Christine to help me as well. [1:44:09] Speaker N (unidentified): So I'd love to be involved in that issue. Yeah. [1:44:12] Speaker O (unidentified): Like your research, was it looking at what other towns do for gifts? [1:44:15] Speaker Q (unidentified): Yeah, it was. I'm happy to send you an electronic format. It's a little unwieldy, I have to admit. But it makes sense why in larger towns you divide town to own property from everywhere else. [1:44:30] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah, we had I didn't think of three or in each case. They were kind of ad hoc I know a guy like that type of culture. Which I think is really poison from process that one feels like we're doing things with process. You know that in our council policy came back to was like we don't have a North Star Articulation as a town council about what we want to see like even eat up coming today, which is awesome I want to learn more from that of it. There are 60 recommendations like I come back to that meeting. We had a meeting we had, I don't think we were here yet, where GPCOG came in and put those pieces of paper around. And it was clear that we wanted the village to be the center of our economic development. So I already know that's where I want to push that. I don't want to see recommendations about some industrial land that's been trying to move for 20 years. Encourage us like North Star, what we expect of this council in the next three years to help like prioritize things. Every week I say to myself, we're too ad hoc, right? Right. We don't we haven't done that North Star policy planning. I don't know if that just means making a more digestible CIP so that we can have a reference that we're routinely using to tell the story of what we're doing and also to tell it to ourselves. Oh, does this one align back to us? So I'll take a crack at trying to do that. [1:45:49] Speaker F (unidentified): There are so many plans, but there's a lot of plans, so it's kind of figuring out within all of those. What's the most important thing, the story of the most important things that we continue to go back to. [1:46:02] Speaker N (unidentified): So, what's the elevator pitch of this council as we talk about this council. At here at the top, the 3 things that we're looking at. [1:46:11] Speaker Q (unidentified): I think that's what was that GP COG orientation was for, right? I think what she pulled out was the biggest, you know, action, plans from the comprehensive plan and made us go put the stickers on. And we were surprisingly aligned. And we were surprisingly... [1:46:33] Speaker A (unidentified): It wasn't wildly diffused. [1:46:34] Speaker Q (unidentified): Yeah, so, I mean, I think that's a, like you said, it was, I thought that was a good place to start in terms of coming up with, you know, some of our listed priorities that we shared in common and work on those. I've forgotten what those were because I don't think, I mean, I didn't take minutes, I didn't take. [1:46:56] Speaker B (unidentified): I get the report back from, I think I forwarded that to everybody. [1:47:01] Speaker N (unidentified): But perhaps that's the foundation of our anchor so that I can't keep referring to like oh well here's our sit 100 pages long and 30 percent of it is contextualizing values which is different so man I would love us to push towards more of a anything can do it Gettysburg Address vibe like the short means you thought about it yeah and that I mean that would [1:47:26] Speaker F (unidentified): be helpful for me too and also I think you know very helpful for all of you as liaisons with your committees and giving them direction on what your as a group what you're expecting from [Speaker A (unidentified): them I] know yeah well [1:47:47] Speaker B (unidentified): I think and I know Megan has said this before I think we were and maybe we're maybe in a different place now but the last two or three years that elevator speech was affordable housing climate change and taxes I mean it's that was those are the three things we're working on trying to try to control property tax rate trying to do something about climate change trying to do something about housing you know those are the big buckets but maybe we have a different three now and that's okay but we should talk about it yeah I mean the study was [1:48:19] Speaker O (unidentified): great I was pointing at the screen out of those people where the study was an hour ago was you I did read it and it's heavy on how it is it says basically Yarmouth can't grow economically if it doesn't grow its housing and so there's some of those two things and which if it grows economically it might I mean commercially it might lower property taxes on residents so those things are kind of tied together not they didn't mention climate action as much as they should have I think but we will we make we you know not really much at all that was weird but whatever we'll we'll still that will be up you know that's important to us it doesn't matter if they mention [1:49:00] Speaker N (unidentified): it and study it and our when we met us this council that cannot last right remember they were over here like some of the climate stuff just was a little bit lower and that's okay because we have a plan that's moving forward this might not be like and maybe that's why maybe we maybe a lot [1:49:16] Speaker O (unidentified): People of those of us there thought, okay, we have made that plan, right? It's going forward. We have many, we have stuff happening. We don't have to focus on it as much because we're doing it. I don't think that people were less eager to do it, just that we thought we were doing it better than [1:49:32] Speaker J (unidentified): housing, which has always been harder. I think one of the ones that came out big, and you, I believe [1:49:35] Speaker B (unidentified): you're the one that suggested it to getting up there in the first place, to put things that was around public engagement, and you know, maybe that, maybe that's one of our big three now. And it is extremely hard. Those of us have been a few years and have tried and tried and tried. But I also think, and I'm not saying, I'm not saying we're done. I'm not saying we couldn't do better, but we've come a long way. But it's still more to do. [1:50:08] Speaker Q (unidentified): I did not, I mean, I'll look, Dave, was it, did that final report come from you? [1:50:15] Speaker B (unidentified): I sent it, so the facilitator wrote the report and sent it to me and I distributed it to you, but if I didn't or if it's in my mailbox or something. [1:50:27] Speaker C (unidentified): I dropped the ball before there. [1:50:35] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, Linda Ray, right, Linda Ray, and she was a former counselor. She is funny. She, I was looking back at notes from like 10 years ago and she facilitated something with us and I completely [1:50:49] Speaker J (unidentified): forgot about. I have a question. [1:50:50] Speaker Q (unidentified): Is there anything you need from us? Like we've been giving you a lot, but is there anything you need? [1:51:01] Speaker F (unidentified): So, I, you know how I said in my transition plan I was going to come back within 90 days and kind of give you, know, the list of observations and recommendations that I have. Probably, you know, given this conversation, it might be helpful if I, if I came back a little bit sooner with some of that stuff. [Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.] And I mean, I'm sure there's, there's going to be more that I pick up, but I think that there are some significant enough things now that it would be helpful to have everybody's input on. [1:51:35] Speaker B (unidentified): You mentioned one room the other day, and I think there's going to be a lot of interest in one. Yeah. [1:51:40] Speaker O (unidentified): Or would that be a separate special meeting we have for this report? [1:51:44] Speaker F (unidentified): I think we could do it either way. [1:51:46] Speaker N (unidentified): Is it a public meeting or executive session? [1:51:49] Speaker F (unidentified): I think the majority of items, it's fine in public meeting. Like, you know, I'd say the biggest one is restructuring the budget. I'd really like to restructure the budget. So, you know, talking about that and what I'm. What I'm proposing to do, because, you know, we've got the budget coming up. So it's like, you know, it's a lot of work to restructure the budget and then put it together. So I want to speak with you all about that before we go ahead and jump right into it. [1:52:17] Speaker O (unidentified): I think this is a question tied to the market analysis, but also what's going on in town. Railroad Square, do we know if anything's happening with it? And the reason I'm asking is because the market analysis made the point that we could have a very vibrant down village area, except for the area that is currently Railroad Square and the area across the street from Railroad Square. So, and I thought, well, if it's floundering and we have an opportunity there as a tool to do something. [1:52:48] Speaker F (unidentified): So from what I understand, the developer's initial proposal just isn't penciling for them. So they have to go back and yeah. [1:52:59] Speaker O (unidentified): It doesn't work if you have no purchasers. Yeah,. So what are they going to do? [1:53:04] Speaker Q (unidentified): Their technical drawings look beautiful. [1:53:06] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, they were nice, but. [1:53:07] Speaker Q (unidentified): You don't think they're going, I mean, at the rate they're going, they're renting those things out now. [1:53:13] Speaker O (unidentified): Well, the apartment house that's built, that will hopefully rent out, but I'm talking about all the area behind it. The 99 units. So, I mean, if it doesn't work, what happens to the... [1:53:24] Speaker F (unidentified): So they're looking at redoing, you know, like the density. So instead of some apartment buildings, they're looking at townhouses instead. And I think they're trying to pencil out, you know, what they'll, you know, what they project they'll be able to get based on, you know, different density. [1:53:43] Speaker D (unidentified): Sort of thinking lower density. Yeah, less units. Well, yeah, I don't see how that. I mean, [1:53:50] Speaker R (unidentified): I think, I think more, expensive enough as it was. Well, I mean, [1:54:02] Speaker B (unidentified): They're, they're sitting on a several million dollar mortgage for just land that's not doing [1:54:08] Speaker J (unidentified): Anything. So I'm sure they'll want to come up with something. I just, I'm perplexed by the ground floor [1:54:14] Speaker D (unidentified): Level with the gravel. Oh, in the new building. Yeah. Oh yeah, that's. Well, I think it's so they can put [1:54:20] Speaker J (unidentified): In facilities. Okay, we have anything else? [1:54:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I don't know. I don't know. [1:54:32] Speaker O (unidentified): Town gym we were just talking about, but yeah, it's that whole space back there. I just thought, I mean, if they go bankrupt, if we can get it for less, but there might be something we can do with. [1:54:41] Speaker N (unidentified): That would make really make a centerpiece for town that is townland that we sold to them. [1:54:45] Speaker J (unidentified): No, it was not talented. It was probably held or sold to them, right, for Vickford. [1:54:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Is there something we probably ought to get, you know, like a, at least quarterly update maybe from Christine on stuff like that? Yeah, oh yeah, you know, we haven't really, I know you're, I mean, you're new and you're still getting going, but I think, you know, hearing from Christine on things like that and hearing from Erin on planning stuff on a regular basis is good, just as gets us. [1:55:17] Speaker R (unidentified): All yeah, all in tune to what's going on. Erin's going to have a big packet of ordinance. [1:55:24] Speaker F (unidentified): And it's affordable housing or state mandate. Yeah. Okay, so anything else? I don't know. It's bumped up on 9 o'clock. Can we adjourn? Oh, nothing else. But when, before everybody takes off, I need that you guys to sign this medical services transfer. [1:55:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, this is for yes. Is this the 1 that just says what we are doing? This isn't, you've already approved. Okay. We approve this. We just sign up. [1:56:02] Speaker K (unidentified): Be voting meetings next week. [1:56:05] Speaker J (unidentified): You're not, you're not sorry. You're not. I am. I am. You are. You are. [1:56:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Are we at the voting meeting next week? Heather? [1:56:20] Speaker M (unidentified): She might not be listening. Well, we'll have. [1:56:24] Speaker K (unidentified): Well, the reason I have 3 of us, plus for Zoe and Heather. One of them, I'm sure. Because I have guests, but I can do it. [1:56:38] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't know anything we voted on this, we just didn't sign the paper with you. [1:56:47] Speaker F (unidentified): Probably a lot of stuff. Yeah, that's not even the highest priority by far. [1:56:58] Speaker Q (unidentified): Thank you. I got it. No, worries. All right, we're done here. I think we're done. Thank you, everyone. Thanks, everybody.