Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Welcome to the Town of Yarmouth Planning Board for October 28th, 2026. We'll have a roll call. Denise Cameron. Present. Ian Cromartie. Present. Jerry King is absent currently. George Ruscala. Present. Matt Schumacher is absent. Kelly Williams. Present. And I'm also here. so our first order of business is to approve the minutes from our october 14th meeting i did
[0:40] Speaker B (unidentified): see one typo in there david klein is c-l-i-n-e not k-l-e-i-n very good so just thought i'd
[0:51] Speaker C (unidentified): show that yep c-l-i-n-e yep very good i'll make those corrections I wouldn't have known.
[1:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Did you pick up on something, too?
[1:04] Speaker C (unidentified): No, I said I'll make those corrections.
[1:06] Speaker B (unidentified): I thought Janet had something.
[1:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, there was a missing word, but it still made sense. So I'm not going to.
[1:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Gotcha. Yeah. But other than that, with that change, I'd make a motion to approve. Okay. Do I have a second? Second. Okay.
[1:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Denise Cameron? Approved. Ian Cromartie? Approved. Jerry King is not here. George Riscala? Approve. Matt Schumacher is also not here. Kelly Williams? Approve. And I also approve. So, Erin, do you have some news or communications for us? Yep.
[1:44] Speaker C (unidentified): Excuse me. Wanted to mention the November meeting will be on November 18th. That is the third Wednesday. day it was shifted due to different holiday schedules including veterans day which would be the typical date that the board would meet on we have several items for that agenda last meeting the board saw 86 pleasant street they are coming back that homeowner is coming back for some additional changes that they are planning to the house so you'll see another similar face. If folks aren't aware, Rosemont is moving across the corner to 108 Main Street, and they're planning some parking lot improvements. So that triggers site plan, and you'll see them at that meeting as well. And then finally, the proposed community solar facility, off of Sligo Road at the CMP poll yard, will be presenting their preliminary site plan for the planning board to review. So that is the first application that takes advantage of those zoning amendments that were adopted last year. So some interesting items that will be coming up. up. I also wanted to let the board know that it is unlikely that the High Winds Homeowners Association will be back at that meeting as well. So we'll deal with tabling that again. So at that meeting. Other than that, we will then meet in December and then it'll be the new year.
Unfinished Business
[3:41] Speaker A (unidentified): I had forgotten about the high winds. Great. Well, we have only one item, no items of old business and one new business. It's an action item, major site plan and shoreland zoning permit for road improvements and site infrastructure. STRUCTURE, 123 EVEN KEEL ROAD, MAP 35, LOT 9, AND MAP 9, LOT 16, SEA MEADOW MARINE FOUNDATION APPLICANT. THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A MAJOR SITE PLAN REVIEW AND A SURE LAND PERMIT REVIEW FOR PROPOSED ROADWAY AND UTILITY IMPROVEMENTS AT 123 EVEN KEEL ROAD, MAP 9, LOT 16, AND MAP 35, LOT nine for Sea Meadows Marine Foundation on the Cousins River, which is in the Shoreland Overlay District. The proposed project includes a conduit for future underground power, a temporary mobile bathroom trailer, and connections to the public water line with a new eight-inch water main to service the site and other properties on the road, and a two-inch sewer force main discharged from a new pump station. Each new service to the property will tie into the existing utilities near the intersection with Even Keel Road and U.S. Route 1. The total earthwork for the project is estimated to be approximately 4,083 cubic yards of excavation, grading, and fill for utility trenching, shoulder work, and grading, which trigger the major site plan public comment will be received and a vote may be taken so with the applicant like to make a presentation to us the representative for the applicant right yeah that's right my name is Jenna Barry
[5:47] Speaker D (unidentified): so I'm here with CVM whar I just have a really brief presentation it sounds like you have the summary a pretty nailed-down of the project itself but to those may be unfamiliar and those online that aren't familiar the sea meadow property is located at the end of even keel road which is a private road off of route one the entire road and that portion of the property is within the shoreland zone you can see in blue there these adjacent properties and the sea meadow property are all within and that working, that waterfront commercial district three. So Even Kiel Road has a shared 30-foot right-of-way. As requested by the fire chief, we were asked to widen portions of the road for safety and for access. Even Kiel Road is currently between 14 to 22 feet wide in different areas. We were asked to widen that to 16 feet of total gravel and have two foot shoulders on either side, which equals that 20 feet. And that additional gravel is a pretty minimal amount because it will be dispersed in several small sections. That's about less than 200 square feet of impervious area of additional gravel. ALL OF THE UTILITIES THAT WILL SERVE SEA MEADOW, EVEN KILL ROAD AND THAT PROPERTY WILL BE WITHIN EXISTING GRAVEL AREAS. SEA MEADOW CURRENTLY DOES NOT HAVE ACCESS TO WATER OR SEWER ON THEIR PROPERTY SO THE INTENT IS TO INSTALL BOTH WATER AND SEWER ALONG EVEN KILL ROAD SO THAT SEA MEADOW has access for temporary bathrooms for the near future. Electrical will be installed as needed for the pump station and for the bathroom trailer. So as you know, public utilities are off of Route 1, which will be tied in from an even-kill road. The water that will be installed in even-kill road will be a public 8-inch water main. The water district will have a 20-foot wide easement over that water main, so they will have ownership and a right to maintain and install that water main. main. I've been told that with that main being installed along the entire route of Even Keel Road, the services to both the adjacent homes will be installed by the Yarmouth Water District and connected to so that shared public water main will be serviced also to those homes as well as Sea Meadow. The fire chief requested a fire hydrant near the even keel road or end of even keel road at the Sea Meadow property. I've recently within the last week discussed with the fire chief a relocation of that hydrant across the other side of even keel road and I will be showing that on a map in just a couple minutes here but both the fire chief and the Yarmouth Water District were in approval of that small shift in the hydrant. The Sea Meadow property is going to need a new two-inch sewer force main to service their new private pump station on their property. So that will be a new force main line going down Evenkill Road. That pump station will be on their property, on private property. And like I mentioned, they will be tying up a temporary bathroom trailer up to the new utilities so they can have bathrooms for the near future until the plans for permanent constructed bathrooms will be installed. So other than the addition of utilities and the temporary bathroom trailer, there's no changes to the Sea Meadows site. The bathroom trailer will be located within an existing gravel area just like the utilities through throughout the road and along the driveway of the sea meadow site we have applied for a main dep permit by rule which was already approved earlier this month and we are aware that a sewer connection permit will be needed to tie into the public sewer out at route one oops sorry skipped ahead here so to speak about construction a little bit we're aware that construction may start in early 2027 pending funds and the acquisition of a contractor available to get started we're on we're in the understand it's that the lay down of the utilities and the equipment needed for construction will be at the beginning of even KILL ROAD AND ON SEA MEADOW PROPERTY. SO EVEN KILL ROAD WILL BE MAINTAINED DURING CONSTRUCTION, SO THEY WILL HAVE ACCESS THROUGHOUT CONSTRUCTION. IT WILL BE OPENED THROUGHOUT AND A LANE WILL BE KEPT AND MAINTAINED. THE CONTRACTOR WILL BE MADE AWARE THAT 'S A NONNEGOTIABLE FOR ACCESS TO BE PROTECTED throughout construction. They will be made aware of the existing sewer and water underground that's already an even keel road and those utilities will be identified with test pits and if needed identified in other ways so that it is very well known where those utilities are so they can be protected throughout construction. If they are encountered I know that the contractor will be well-versed in keeping them safe and in operation while the trenches are being excavated and backfilled. If there is a damage to any of utilities it would be on the contractor and on Sea Meadow to replace and repair immediately. And as far as the Yarmouth Water District is concerned they will be installing the water services off of the public main down at the end of even keel road the existing water services will be kept active until the connections are made and the public main is turned on to be switched over all of this and as well as traffic control and access during construction will be addressed in a formal construction management plan that will be submitted prior to pre-construction meeting and will be reviewed with the town engineer it was asked that the construction management plan is a condition of approval so the applicant is aware of that and in agreeance to that at this point if you're unfamiliar with the plans this is a view of the existing conditions plan it shows all three of the properties at the end of even keel road and here in point road it also shows the existing buffers that are on sea meadows property this is the site overview plan here that shows the entire length of even keel road it also shows on the new hydrant location that's been reviewed with the fire chief at this point The intention was to have it on the opposite side of the road where the water main will be, which will be on the left side, instead of having it on the right side at the fork of Huron Point Road. We have plan and profile sheets that show the connection off of Route 1 and the planned routing for the new utilities along Evenkill Road. and some details at the fork of Huron Point Road and even Kill Road. This is another view of that adjusted hydrant across the road where the water main will be installed on the left side. And like I mentioned before, Yarmouth Water District will have an easement owning the entire stretch of the public main, which will go onto the Sea Meadow property up until the blow off and service connection THAT SEA MEADOW WILL HAVE ON THEIR PROPERTY. THEIR PUMP STATION IS ALSO SHOWN AT THE END OF THIS DRAWING HERE, C203, AND AN APPROXIMATE LOCATION OF THAT TEMPORARY BATHROOM TRAILER AND ITS HOOKUPS. THAT IS EVERYTHING I HAVE TO SHARE.
[15:28] Speaker A (unidentified): SO I WILL ASK THE PLANNING BOARD IF THEY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE PROJECT.
[15:38] Speaker E (unidentified): I have a couple of questions can you tell me a little bit about the existing utilities that are on the road right now I think you mentioned water and sewer are those private or public and if how they have already been located because I could see them on the plans and I think you mentioned a little bit about how you're planning to confirm locations during construction but can you just walk me through those really quick, just so I make sure I have a good understanding of them?
[16:06] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, absolutely. So there is overhead power along the entire stretch of the road. There is underground sewer force main, which currently serves the next door residents, and as well as an underground water service, which I believe is considered public right now. The water would be considered public, and the sewer is technically considered private. Okay, thank you.
[16:32] Speaker C (unidentified): i'll also just mention for the board's benefit that eric ganyan who's the superintendent of the water district has joined us and he is available for any clarifying questions that anyone might have throughout the public hearing can
[16:49] Speaker B (unidentified): we get clarification is the underground water
[16:52] Speaker C (unidentified): public or private the existing right the existing i'm not sure eric might be able to share but i believe it's public eric unmuted himself so he might be able to answer that
[17:04] Speaker F (unidentified): quickly for you go ahead eric right so that existing service line is private it is only public up to the service valve at the approximate right-of-way of route one so it's a very long private service line that only serves 11 heron point thank you thank you yeah
[17:27] Speaker A (unidentified): does the other residents have a well or something for water yes okay and septic or are they you don't know about the sewer aspect no oh okay not yet well
[17:49] Speaker B (unidentified): jenna what was the purpose of moving the hydrant just curious from the right side over to the left yeah because
[17:57] Speaker D (unidentified): currently the right side has only sewer and the water is planned on the left side Oh, so instead of the water going in or over or under over the crossing they would be on the left side
[18:09] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, yeah, thank you. Yeah. Yes.
[18:22] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't have any other questions here And do we have any public that would like to ask questions? George, by the way, do you have anything? Thank you. No,, okay. Thank you Okay, well hang on I we haven't opened for public comment yet no that was for the board sorry okay well we will open for public comment now please introduce yourself and your address thank you hi
[19:05] Speaker G (unidentified): my name is Alexa a striker and I am property owner one of them at 11 Heron Point I'm gonna budding and the abutting property with water and sewer lines for the record we have been very much in support of even keel doing this project I just have concerns about some of the inconsistencies in the paperwork that was available to be previewed and I did send an email today to Aaron to put those questions and concerns in writing because I apologize I didn't get it in earlier but I was notified via mail which did not come to my mailing address so and there's only so much I can do when I don't have enough time to respond and get through this pile of paperwork but one of the things that we noted and the paperwork that was available to be previewed from the link is that it does state that the existing water service is to be abandoned and that was in this paperwork and then alts where throughout the paperwork it states that the new water line will service even keel road we are not even keel road we are here in point so i really think that's important to clarify if our water is being terminated our private line then and we are being asked to join the public line it shouldn't cost us anything because we already have paid for our water line when we purchased it was there and that we need to make sure that it is not eliminated and it is able to be accessed you know and we are able to be connected the location of the water line you know in a 20 foot right of way it sounds great except for what if we're outside that 20 foot right away so i don't understand where that is going to be the other thing is that we also have a sewer line that is private and it does connect to the public sewer at route one so I am just concerned about disturbances and damage so I just wanted to make sure that there are some safeguards I know in the past we have met with the engineers and group down at even keel we talked about doing a shared pumping station I don't know what happened to that because communication kind of dropped off from them in the last six months so if you have any insights that would be great it just seems silly to run to sewer lines where we're trying to avoid sewer and water overlapping my other concern had been about the placement of the fire hydrant because that triangle area does flood and I am glad to see that it is moved to the far side so that's new and that addresses that concern so thank you know and just obviously the there's going to be a lot of disturbance and to the road we live there we travel it multiple times I understand that you want to keep it open it's a narrow road it's going to be challenging so we will need definitely to I would really like to see this construction management plan that would be really helpful and also it also mentions utilities underground my question to you is we already have utilities above ground so in terms of power am I misinterpreting that are you planning on putting utilities underground is that more digging or damage to the road I'm not clear on that I would really like to have a better understanding overall we want to be supportive we just want to make sure that our services ie we have to have water we have to have sewer we have to have power and internet we are reliant on that and if we can have assurances that we will not suffer financial hardship or disturbances that you know our problem for us you know it's going to take many months and I would like to be able to live in my home i
[23:47] Speaker A (unidentified): did have one question for you actually is there some sort of written road maintenance type agree oops road maintenance agreement there's a very
[23:59] Speaker G (unidentified): old road maintenance agreement okay it's from before the property has been developed the way it is. It's not how the road maintenance agreement is being done now. It's more of a handshake and you take care of this and I'll pay for it this time and you pay for it that time.
[24:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Is this cover regrading it after winter and plowing and that sort of thing?
[24:29] Speaker G (unidentified): The formal road maintenance agreement that's outdated and definitely needs to be redone, it is just a percentage. Okay. Thank you. And your question earlier, our neighbor has a private well and a private septic. Okay. Great.
[24:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other public comments?
[24:57] Speaker C (unidentified): Eric, go ahead.
[25:03] Speaker F (unidentified): Thank you. Thank you for allowing me to address some of these. thanks for Aaron to sending me these notes with the concerns because they're definitely valid and definitely would like to just clear some of these things up so I did send a letter of ability to serve that was included with the town's information so that 's there but these issues were not addressed specifically so just going to go through some of the questions in that email who will own the water main? And if it's only for sea meadows and no, it will be a district owned main. It will be installed at the developer's expense. So Yarmouth rate payers are not paying for extensions. They never do. The developer pays for the extension. We take ownership after it's approved and maintained and fully tested. So we will take ownership of the water mains, all the service lines up into the shutoff valve but I think that was one of the questions is what if you're within that point but right away well it doesn't matter where the line ends we would connect to the existing service at Heron Point with a service valve and we would own that service line up to the valve so the private portion gets very you know cut down if you will it shortens up quite a bit. So we would own that, we would maintain it. So if it ever has any issues, it leaks, water quality, it's on us to repair and to get service back all the way up until, like Jenna mentioned, that blow off close to that bathroom trailer. So the other thing, there would be no cost to 11 Heron Point, and that is a service solely for 11 Heron. There would be no cost to them. Like she mentioned, they've already paid for service. This is actually a better way to serve that property. You don't have a, geez, a 1,500-foot service line going through property. That's just not the right way to build the system. So now that there's a public water main going in front of their property, we will pay the cost to tie into the existing service line when we cross it. that line would be active the water main would be fully tested chlorinated pressure tested and once it's fully in service we would make that transition from the existing long private line to connecting to the public portion of the system on the new main and that connection would be an interruption but we would schedule that in advance and if things are done right by a good contractor should only be like an hour or less of interruption let's find out properly so that's that's what that means by determining this in line that existing line would then just go away and it would be honestly shut off at route one the same would be for the empty lot that's the first lot on your right that's the other service line that has an existing service And we have to serve that properly. So we would be paying for that portion of the water line going to that abandoned or property that has no longer a home on it. And again, those costs would be incurred by the district, not by Sea Meadows. And hopefully we can work it out with their contractor to pay for that portion of the service line and the connection. action. Let's see. I think that locating the private lines, I think that was one of the big things in that email. And I think Jenna did address some of those is they're going to do their best to test it. We have location equipment. If the line is made out of metallic material, we don't mind helping out. We do that a fair amount of time on private. We don't like to make it a regular event, spending five or six hours doing things. But in this case, we would have our location equipment on us and we can actually usually trace some of those items if it is copper and i think it might be but who knows what they did back then we don't unfortunately didn't keep track of private systems back then what the materials were being used i think you already addressed the hybrid relocation that was great i'm glad the fire department was okay with us moving into the other side and it avoids us having slip joints and crossing other utilities like Jenna said, it's just a better way to build the system. But we are open if that still is not a great location on site. We can field locate. We, you know, if we're moving at 10 or 15 feet in one direction, that does not bother us. We put it in the best spot that a plow truck won't hit it. And, you know, it's not making a blind spot for turning and that sort of thing. I think that covered most of the issues. and I'm more than happy if you want to reach out to me if there's any other questions that I can take care of off this meeting, but just since these were submitted to you that I definitely wanted to answer them in public as well, but there are more detailed questions or any other follow-ups, I'm here to answer any of those.
[30:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Eric. So are there any other further public comments? Okay. We'll close public comment. And are there any other questions from the board?
[30:40] Speaker E (unidentified): I have a couple follow-up questions, if it's all right. Sure. No, sure. With that kind of new information. Well, first of all, I want to thank R. Butter for the really just detailed and clear comments. This participation in this process is what makes everything work a little better. And I know that those comments do not come without a level of effort. And I just wanted to take a moment to say I appreciated them. I think they were valid. And I also appreciate that the applicant was able to speak to them so quickly. And I think that has to do with just providing good comments and being able to address them. So this is the way the process should work. And it's kind of nice to see. So the one question I didn't ask earlier, though, was the power. And I think that was a good question that came up. And I was hoping the applicant could address the overhead lines. Are those public? Are they private? Do they need to be relocated? And just speak a little bit towards those existing overhead lines.
[31:42] Speaker D (unidentified): that's right yeah i had the same question actually here sure yeah as far as we know the overhead lines are private sea meadow may need underground power to service their pump station and future utility connections at their site so that was the intention of providing CONDUIT UNDER EVEN KEEL ROAD. FROM A COST PERSPECTIVE, WE MAY BE ASKED TO REMOVE THE CONDUIT FROM THE PLANS ALTOGETHER SO THERE MAY NO LONGER BE ANY UNDERGROUND POWER AT ALL OR THERE MAY JUST BE ONE LINE PROPOSED AND THAT WOULD REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF DISTURBANCE IN THE ROAD AS WELL. DOES THAT ANSWER YOUR QUESTION? I GUESS I HAD A RELATED
[32:32] Speaker A (unidentified): QUESTION. IF THEY DO REQUIRE MORE POWER in the future is it a zoning requirement that it'd be underground like it is in many
[32:43] Speaker C (unidentified): many areas in town sure so if the if that installation triggers site plan review which is excavation of a hundred cubic yards or more and then that would trigger site plan review would either be a minor site plan or a major site plan the threshold for major is a thousand cubic yards which is a lot of cubic yards that at that point yes there would be that would trigger the requirement for underground utilities and but the simple installation of electric, you know, a power with CMP, that doesn't require a town permitting unless there's a shutoff, which might trigger an electrical permit, things like that. But, you know, that would be something that would need to be coordinated with CMP. So the only way it would get triggered for underground is whether or not the proposed installation triggers site
[33:53] Speaker E (unidentified): plan review thank you denise did you have other questions hey i have one other question so the i noticed on the drawings that existing sewer private sewer will be maintained can you just share if something were to happen during construction inadvertently gets damaged etc although i appreciate that it will probably be protected can you just explain like who would pay for any damage to that private line in the case it was disturbed during construction yeah
[34:25] Speaker D (unidentified): so in that case it would be on the contractor who's handling the construction which would be paid for by sea meadow do
[34:35] Speaker E (unidentified): you see any issues at all with being able to install what you're installing while also maintaining the existing sewer with the information you know on location
[34:43] Speaker D (unidentified): right now yeah with the understanding that we're a little bit flexible with where the pipe can be placed as long as we're maintaining the 10 foot separation that we need between the new water and the new sewer. We can jog around if we do find that there might be a conflict, like when we do investigate with test bits, we'll be able to lay out a better plan and understanding moving forward.
[35:14] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you, appreciate that.
[35:16] Speaker C (unidentified): If I might add to that, I did share the comments that were received today with the town engineer, and he suggested that if the planning board has concerns about making sure that it's abundantly clear where the other utilities are in the road, that the planning board could consider adding a condition to have, it's not DigSafe, which does public stuff, but there are vendors out there that will mark utilities in private situations like this. And he said, if the planning board has concerns about it, could be appropriate to include a condition to have one of those vendors I, you know, Eric is very generous about offering his equipment location, his location equipment stuff. But if, just for peace of mind, if that's something that the planning board finds is important, the town engineer didn't have a concern with adding something like that in.
[36:26] Speaker F (unidentified): So how long do you anticipate the construction process to be?
[36:33] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah we estimate it between four to six weeks okay thank you and i noticed you said early 2027 and are you doing that because it's easier to do this type of construction possibly in
[36:45] Speaker D (unidentified): during winter when the when it's not muddy and yeah so if conditions are right and you know weather is allowable you know in freezing conditions could be a good case for this but if it does push into you know late winter when there may be mud it would probably be delayed until a drier season like in the summer until the frost comes out right i
[37:17] Speaker B (unidentified): just i have one question for alexis if that's okay sure yeah alexis with the responses that you've received throughout the meeting is every have do you have anything outstanding that you have concerns about it was
[37:42] Speaker G (unidentified): definitely helpful to hear Eric talk about the water line so thank you for that because that obviously was a big concern and I guess and a lot of this has been the sewer and having them the sewer line has to be ten feet apart from the water line and having two sewer lines that I'm not an engineer so that is something i don't fully understand but i'm sure it can be explained to me by the pros and that's helpful so thank you okay sure thank you all right so
[38:24] Speaker D (unidentified): jenna would you like to respond about the distance separation yeah i can do my best so that new water being a public main, it was requested that there is 10 feet separation. That's a requirement by Yarmouth Water District. Yeah. So since we're designing a new sewer, since both of them are private, I mean, I think we can only control like what's going in new with the separation. So I'm not really sure how to comment on separation between existing. So if Eric wants to chair that would be great but where the existing is i don't know if he's still on he is
[39:13] Speaker A (unidentified): yep here he's back yeah
[39:17] Speaker F (unidentified): i can comment a little bit to that you know we require 10 feet of separation and it's honestly just for public safety you don't want clean water with the same trench as the septic or sewer it's just not good public health and if one breaks and somebody puts it in the same trench and you excavate it, you end up excavating both lines and you have a potential there for contamination and making people sick. So there is a requirement for a 10-foot separation between sewer and it doesn't matter to us whether it's new or not. And I know it's not understood exactly where the existing sewer is, but we would require a 10-foot separation between the existing as well. I mean, they'd have it shown on the plan. the plans that we've reviewed, we're okay with, you know, there is some leeway in that separation. You know, we were not going to move into the woods to gain another foot or two. So we are a little reasonable with that. They definitely cannot be in the same trench because a native trench does help keep things apart from each other. If something does happen, but that's the reason it's really a public health issue. You don't put sewer in the same trench as water. And that's just, you know, private or public, it's just good practice. And it's in our terms and conditions, and the Maine PUC backs us up. So, yeah, it will be probably difficult to maintain the separation with something you don't know where it exists. But hopefully we understand that to the best of our abilities of where those, the private sewer, existing private sewer is in place.
[40:56] Speaker B (unidentified): I do like think thank you for that Eric I do like the town engineers you know as a condition of approval if the board wants to move forward that to get a vendor to locate the private utilities I think that's important one of them has a
[41:16] Speaker C (unidentified): very clever name called dig smart instead of safe okay great
[41:23] Speaker A (unidentified): oh did i closed public you can open it if you want okay i will reopen public comment
[41:36] Speaker H (unidentified): thank you for being here and thank you for reopening it for a proposal this extensive
[41:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Wait, excuse me. Could you state your name and your address?
[41:47] Speaker H (unidentified): Yes. My name is Michael Mastronardi. I live at [address], and I've been a Yarmouth resident and a businessman for 40 years. and I have a bunch of questions but I guess I want to begin by asking Stephen Mehar and I'm sorry I didn't call your name JD. I'm Jen. Yeah and I assume the question's directed to her unless Chad is listening in as well but the question is did you talk to the owner of the road about this proposal. That's a simple question. Could you answer it or is that not appropriate?
[42:45] Speaker E (unidentified): I think we present the questions to the applicant, but you can provide the comments. Yeah, we will have her
[42:56] Speaker H (unidentified): respond but not now do you have other comments well has the planning board had a site visit no but we've reviewed the plans excellent i'm impressed with the plan there's a lot of details, some of which are kind of surprising. The proposal for having residences as if it's going to be a lodging facility as well as marine related activities. But those are relatively minor with the application itself. It's a very detailed proposal, incredibly extensive from my limited experience and it just seems to me that we might need more time to digest all that is in the proposal but I 'm wondering what the owner of the road thinks about this proposal and whether or not anyone from CV my hair or sea Meadows Marine Foundation LLC has shared with the owner of the road this plan. Okay. Seems like a good place to begin a discussion of the plan. Okay.
[44:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Closed public comment? I'm not sure how to share.
[44:56] Speaker E (unidentified): this isn't really our purview is it well i think what's in our purview is right title and interest and so maybe so as part of the application any applicant needs to submit something called right title and interest that would indicate their authority and ownership to do the work within the property that is shown so that has been submitted staff has acknowledged it in the planning board report to us but maybe just a brief like if you're able to just give us a brief overview of what the right title and interest is for the property in the work that you're proposing so that's all right i'd love to ask that question to the applicant jenna thanks
[45:45] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah i can do my best to answer that so the road is inside of a shared right-of-way so i know that Sea Meadow has the right title of interest, like she's saying, to maintain and install utilities in that shared right-of-way. I don't know exactly if Sea Meadow has communicated directly with the owner at that lot at the beginning of Route 1 that technically owns most of that road. But with it being a shared right-of-way to multiple properties, I know that there is adequate ownership allowed to do these proposed utilities and improvements. Thank you. Thank you.
[46:29] Speaker E (unidentified): And Erin, was there anything that you noticed on the right title and interest documentation that had any questions from staff?
[46:36] Speaker C (unidentified): No, we found that it conveys the right of way in the easement for legal purposes, including access, egress, installation, maintenance,, repair, and replacement of all utilities, including phone, water, power, cable, gas, and sewer. And I believe that property is owned by an LLC, but I believe, Mr. Mastronardi, you do own that property. Is that correct? Yep.
[47:02] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you. Okay. I don't know.
[47:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Nothing we can do. Sorry. George? Yes. Yeah. Go ahead, George. I'm sorry.
[47:23] Speaker I (unidentified): I mean, considering all the information that was provided and the explanation that was done by the applicant, I mean, from a planning point of view, would it be, how should I say it, rather than having two sewer lines, would it be possible to have a joint line that would serve all the properties and possibly future, you know, enhancement or expansion. What I mean is, I don't know about the sewer for 11 and 19 Tadron Road, but the two inch proposed, would that be enough for the future in case there has been expansion and would rather having one sewer line than two sewer lines? Thank you.
[48:34] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm happy to kind of have commentary on that if you're okay with that. So, George, I agree it would be really great to see a combined line here, but my understanding is although we can acknowledge that would be a nice solution because this is private and private lines I don't believe it's within our jurisdiction to make it as a requirement it's not a public road and there's no public sewer so I would just for commentary say that if after this approval there was discussion and a solution came up that would allow for shared sewer lines, I would certainly be supportive of it in the future, but I don't think we're allowed to require it at this point in time. It's my read, but open to others if you understand it differently.
[49:25] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I agree, Denise, this is separately owned.
[49:31] Speaker E (unidentified): But if something works out in the future, I think we're open to it. Okay,
[49:41] Speaker A (unidentified): any other discussion? Shall we have a motion then? I
[49:50] Speaker C (unidentified): think there was discussion about adding a condition. Yes, we would like to add the condition of the
[49:55] Speaker A (unidentified): private vendor for locating utilities, existing utilities. So that would be a
[50:02] Speaker C (unidentified): fifth condition to the conditions of approval. The first one is the There were several plan review comments from Steve, our town engineer, that he required to have updated. The second one was prior to the pre-construction meeting, the applicant shall prepare a construction management plan that covers logistics of construction, parking, deliveries, and any staging necessary. I might suggest to the Planning Board that you might want to include, you know, like access, uninterrupted access too. Yeah. The third one is prior to the completion of the project, applicant shall provide to the town specifications on the sewer pump station, electric alarm notification system and the sewer pump station service agreement between the property owner and a third-party vendor. The fourth condition is installation of erosion and sedimentation controls and best management practices that need to be installed prior to disturbance of soils, vegetation, and must be maintained in good working condition. And the fifth one could be, YOU KNOW, IT COULD BE TAGGED WITH PRIOR TO THE PRECONSTRUCTION MEETING, THE APPLICANT SHALL COORDINATE WITH A THIRD PARTY VENDOR TO MARK OUT THE PRIVATE UTILITIES WITHIN THE RIGHT OF WAY.
[51:53] Speaker A (unidentified): SO IT WOULD ALL GO UNDER THE CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT CLAUSE?
[51:58] Speaker C (unidentified): NO, I WOULD ADD IT AS A FIFTH CONDITION. OKAY. okay but i'd recommend adding it as a fifth condition i think the other things we forgot
[52:06] Speaker A (unidentified): to mention is that there are three waivers that the town has recommended we agreed to one is the soil intensity what is it high intensity soil report one is a lighting THERE IS REALLY NO LIGHTING FOR THE PROJECT SO WE DON'T NEED TO DO A PHOTOMETRIC PLAN. AND THE THIRD ONE IS THE STORM WATER ANALYSIS THAT OUR TOWN ENGINEER FELT THERE WAS SO LITTLE change and what how the road is going to be re-engineered so to speak that it will not affect how it's draining today so anyway i think we have a separate motion on the waivers that's
[53:13] Speaker E (unidentified): it so are we ready would you like me to make the motion sure that'd be wonderful all right aaron you get to help me a little bit because i think i followed most of that but prompt me if necessary So let's start with the site plan review waiver for certain application requirements. Based on the application, plans, reports, and other information submitted by the applicant, information from the public hearing, information from the findings and recommendations contained in the Planning Board Report dated October 21, 2026, and by adopting the findings of fact and notice of decision dated October 28, 2026, regarding application for a major site plan and shoreland zoning permit, Sea Meadow Marine Foundation applicant, roadway and infrastructure improvements with Even Keel Road and at 123 Even Keel Road regarding compliance of the applicable regulations and standards of chapter 702 site plan review, the planning board herein finds and concludes that not requiring a traffic analysis, stormwater management plan, high intensity soil report is consistent with the intent OF THE SITE PLAN REVIEW ORDINANCE AND IS THEREFORE APPROVED, SO MOVED BY DENISE CAMERON.
[54:29] Speaker A (unidentified): I HAVE A SECOND. I SECOND. OKAY. THANK YOU, KELLY. AND WE'LL HAVE A VOTE ON THAT. DENISE CAMERON? APPROVED. IAN CRIMARDI? APPROVED. JERRY KING IS ABSENT. GEORGE WISCALA? APPROVED. MATT SCHUMACHER IS ABSENT. KELLY WILLIAMS? APPROVED. I ALSO APPROVE.
[54:51] Speaker E (unidentified): I can keep moving with the motions if you'd like going with all right this is for site plan based on the application plans reports and other information submitted by the applicant information from the plan from the public hearing information and findings and recommendations contained in the planning board report dated October 21st 2026 and by adopting the findings needs of fact and notice of decision dated October 28th, 2026 regarding an application for major site plan and shoreland zoning permit. Sea Meadow Marine Foundation applicant roadway and infrastructure improvements with even keel road and at 123 even keel road regarding the compliance with and with the applicable regulations and standards of chapter 702 site plan. The planning board hereby finds and concludes that the major site plan meets the required standards and is therefore approved subject to the following conditions of approval. Such motion is moved by Denise Cameron.
[55:55] Speaker A (unidentified): So just curious, the way we've got this written, Erin, the conditions of approval are actually under the shoreland zoning permit. Do they relate to both?
[56:05] Speaker C (unidentified): They do relate to both. Okay. It's just the format of the report. Sure. So just a friendly reminder to add the fifth condition
[56:15] Speaker E (unidentified): as discussed. Yeah, subject to the following conditions and the conditions as discussed, which included private existing utility location services prior to the pre-construction meeting and a condition that traffic access shall be maintained to the abutting property WITH, YOU KNOW, MINIMAL TIMES OF DELAY.
[56:46] Speaker A (unidentified): THOSE WERE THE TWO, RIGHT?
[56:49] Speaker E (unidentified): OKAY. YEAH. IN ADDITION TO THOSE NOTED.
[56:52] Speaker A (unidentified): THOSE TWO NEED TO BE ADDED TO THE, RIGHT. SO WE'LL HAVE A VOTE ON THAT.
[56:57] Speaker E (unidentified): DENISE CAMERON? OH, I THINK WE NEED A SECOND FIRST. OH, SURE. OKAY. KELLY SECONDED.
[57:05] Speaker A (unidentified): DENISE CAMERON? APPROVED. IAN CURMARTI? APPROVED. JERRY KING IS NOT HERE. year. George Vizcala? Approved. Matt Schumacher is also absent. Kelly Williams? Approved. I also
[57:17] Speaker E (unidentified): approve. All right. We have one more to go. Shoreland zoning permit. Based on the application plans, reports, and other information submitted by the applicant, information from the public hearing, information from the findings and recommendations contained in the planning board report dated October 21st, 2026, and by adopting the findings of fact and notice of decision dated october 20 2026 regarding an application for a major site plan and shoreland zoning permit sea meadow marine foundation applicant roadway and infrastructure improvements with even keel road and at 123 even keel road regarding the compliance with the applicable regulations and standards of chapter 701 zoning article 4 r 11 a and b the planning board herein finds and concludes that the plan is in conformance with the required standards and is therefore approved subject to the following conditions of approval amended with the two additional conditions of approval previously discussed. [Speaker A (unidentified): Great, second.] Such motion is moved by Denise Cameron.
[58:20] Speaker A (unidentified): We need a first, second. I'll second. Denise Cameron. Approved. Ian Cromartie. Approved. Jerry King is absent. George Wascala. Approved. Matt Schumacher is absent, Kelly Williams and I also approve. Thank you for everybody participating in this. It sounds like there may be some work outside of our decision but we think it's a good plan and hope Sea Meadows can make it happen.
[58:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Thank you all. Thank you.
[58:57] Speaker F (unidentified): thank you thanks for coming and
[59:01] Speaker A (unidentified): i guess no other items of business oh okay so this is my
[59:06] Speaker I (unidentified): my last board meeting oh no yeah so i sent my resignation into aaron and she accepted
[59:15] Speaker A (unidentified): reluctantly i imagine well i don't think so i had much of a choice
[59:18] Speaker G (unidentified): but it's been a pleasure and an honor and i appreciate all you guys
[59:23] Speaker B (unidentified): what you do thank you we appreciate the service thank you thank you
[59:29] Speaker A (unidentified): can we adjourn we may adjourn now I think there are no other right thank you thank you everyone thank you