← Back to MaineScanner

Yarmouth Operations Committee Reviews Waste Fees and Sewer Equity Proposals

2026-10-22 · 1h 53m · Source: Operations Committee - Meeting October 22, 2026 (Town of Yarmouth (YMTV TelVue))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:02] Speaker A (unidentified): This conference will now be recorded on October 22nd, and first order is called to order. That's what I'm doing. It looks like we're all here, except Zoe. [0:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Councilor Wolf may be late, and Councilor Abbott is on the line. First other item, two, is update on Ecomain from Public Works Director David Manson. [0:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Come on around. Come on, Joellen. I'm sorry. [0:32] Speaker D (unidentified): hold on i just made my friend stop mike [0:41] Speaker E (unidentified): you want this red one i'll use this one [0:52] Speaker F (unidentified): so i thought it would be good to have dave was giving me some updates on eco main he sits on the board as yarmouth's representative and as he was kind of going through the updates i thought well this is going to have a budgetary impact so it's pretty important that you know he comes and speaks to all of you and there are also some pretty significant policy changes going on there and in terms of how waste is handled so i think that 's also something important to [1:22] Speaker G (unidentified): talk about with all of you so we just had our annual meeting a couple weeks ago and just wanted to give you guys a little bit of an update as to what's going on there first thing the rates of course are going up currently we're paying 110.75 cents per ton and we're paying the same price for recycling as we are at sw that's something that's new in the past couple of years they've just kind of brought those two up so that they're matching traditionally recycling has always been cheaper in order to get people to recycle they feel like you've got to the point now where everybody is going to recycle regardless and it's actually the more expensive you know option when it comes to how you manage waste recycling is typically more expensive just because there's so much labor intensive and the markets have kind of crashed as to you know newspaper used to be a huge thing that they can pick up now nobody's buying what was the amount per ton again i'm sorry 110.75 per ton for fy27 we voted the other day we're going know what to 116.50 per ton for the next fiscal year okay can i ask you what was the recycling rate before this they were both the same they were last year's yes yep so they've they've been the same for a couple of years and part of the reasoning behind that and i don't know if you guys know about the epr the extended producer responsibilities enacted i think in 2021. That still hasn't come to fruition yet. The state's having a really hard time finding somebody to manage that program. They put it out to RFP. They actually didn't get any responses. Extended producer responsibility. I think the easiest way to describe it is anybody who puts packaging into the state of Maine is paying in. It's almost like a deposit on your on your cans your bottles of cans so it's it's along the same lines as that so we're we're collecting this money from say amazon sends a ton of boxes so it's for packaging that you receive and the thought process is we'll collect this money and then it'll go back out to all the municipalities for reimbursement of handling the recycling unfortunately we don't anybody to run the program so the gains part of the reason they were bringing the price of the recycling up was so that we would realize more money in the long term when we get their reimbursement so if you're getting reimbursed at a lower rate you're going to get less if you pay them more you want to get it so that's that's why they brought it up so that they were remaining each other so that's what we have going on right now one of the other things i'm not sure if you guys are aware it's about 37 million dollars they have spent here recently and completely redoing the recycling plant it's a it's a brand new building it's adjacent to the property now they've purchased it and they're looking like probably march april is when it will go online they've purchased all the equipment they've got the building probably 90 done they've already started receiving all the equipment putting it in place the former facility it's still running now it's a little over 20 years old and it's costing a lot of money so where is it 's right next to it 's do you know where ecomain is right down near of the airport when you're driving on 95 heading towards the airport on the right hand side just before you get to the exit you'll see a huge smokestack that's eco me so that's where the recycling and the msw is burnt there so that's where they have their trash standard it's all right there and then the landfills over kind of in the corner of south portland and west spread is where the landfill is. So that's pretty much it. Pretty much what I have. [5:46] Speaker B (unidentified): What's some of the financial implications for the town though? I mean if we are there is there a capital thing that we're gonna have to pay into for that 37 million [5:56] Speaker G (unidentified): dollar expansion? That's all part of it. It's all part of the whole program. It's in on the prices that we have currently with EPR if that gets going you know if we ever get that off the ground of running you we will see our recycling rates go up but that will be you know as we start getting the reimbursements so there'll be one of those that first year will be a tough year where we're having to pay for it and then it was designed so that like in October you start getting the [6:27] Speaker A (unidentified): reimbursement we'll see when they finally get the program for that program is eco main collecting [6:37] Speaker G (unidentified): any fees from the companies that are free the state is it's yes it's not an eco main thing it's statewide so it's not just eco you know right i think there's 29 communities that own EcoMate together, but it's statewide. [6:57] Speaker E (unidentified): So that's roughly 16% fee increase per ton, right? And how many tons? I don't remember that. [7:08] Speaker G (unidentified): It's pretty big. We went through a lot. [7:11] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, so obviously a certain amount goes into the blue bags, the things that are general disposal and then everything else is recycling right so to cover the extra 16% increase in fees then when we're talking about budgetary concerns we're going to have to think about increasing the price of the bags right above and beyond because do we have a rough idea give when someone comes in with trash or maybe just based on our numbers in a given week how much how much tonnage is general and how much tonnage is recycled. Again I don't have [7:52] Speaker G (unidentified): I wish I had brought all the numbers in and as we go through the budget process you'll be I'll have all that for you. Okay are recycling rates 35 40 percent? It's roughly 35 statewide you know the goal when they started this all in the 70s was they were trying to get to 50 you know you got a big uptick at the beginning and i kind of leveled out now it's up to about 35 i think we do a little bit better than the average part of that is that's what happens at eco main is that 50 but then when you think about all the other things that we recycle at our transfer station you take that 35 and you can pump that you can get up to 50 pretty quick that extra 15 Right. And well, waste oil and all, you know, when you take in all the tonnage that we do at our facility, and then we recycle to other places, you know, you've got your propane tanks and all these other things that we recycle. So, it all adds up. [8:54] Speaker B (unidentified): I've been through EcoMain a few times, but I don't know how much the rest of the council has. Is there a chance we could get a tour? [9:01] Speaker G (unidentified): Absolutely. If you guys all wanted to get together or even individually, I could bring each one of you down. down. My predecessor is actually the Director of Recycling down there now, so whenever I go down for our meetings. Eric, that big building that they're building right now, that's kind of his baby. He does the outreach to all the communities. [9:24] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it would be worth it, something for us to talk about. [9:28] Speaker G (unidentified): For sure. They would love that. And if you guys wanted, we could also set up to have you know some members of eco main come here and do a presentation as well that would [9:37] Speaker H (unidentified): you know be a lot more in-depth than what i'm telling you i'm just on the extended producer responsibility does that include paint recycling no that's just packaging [9:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, but the EPR is just what we're getting reimbursed for a percentage of the packaging. So it's going to be a ballpark where we guess how much packaging goes into our recycling and then how much it costs electricity, how much manpower, you know, when we first do this, it's going to be it's going to be a big lift to get that first reimbursed. [10:22] Speaker I (unidentified): I think I heard it right. I heard $110.75 to $116. It's more of like a 5% response. [10:30] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes. $110 to $116. I'm sorry. Yes. So it's $6.00 and $5.00 and $0.25. [10:37] Speaker E (unidentified): I thought it was $100.75. It's $110. Sorry, that's our current rate. [10:43] Speaker B (unidentified): Good news. Better news. It's still going to be $117, but it's better news. Anything, I mean, that probably might wrap it up, but is there anything else from public work? [10:59] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, there is one more thing for recycling or for the transfer station. I'd like to hand this out and have you guys look at it. It has been since 2024 since we did any of our fee scheduling to increase fees. fees so if you look at this you'll see on the front what we're charging now and then on the back we kind of broke it down and to what it currently costs us to actually get rid of these products okay so there's some things that we're paying for now that actually you know we're charging a certain rate and it actually costs us more to get rid of it than what we're charging Yes, because it's theoretically everything should be from a homeowner. It goes to the transfer station. So it's not, you know, we don't have any big industry that goes over there. [11:59] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't think your people know what these are because I brought in air conditioners and they charged me $40 each. Here it says $15. I thought it was pretty high, $40. [12:20] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, what we have here is what we're, you know, it says 10 dollars. [12:24] Speaker H (unidentified): That's 15 for. Yep. So, [12:31] Speaker G (unidentified): the ones that are in red are the ones that we're looking to change. [12:37] Speaker B (unidentified): So, this kind of gets back to another topic. We probably need to address the council last year. We. We put in some automatic fee increases and. And it's up to us what we do with that. We could just leave it alone, but I'm hearing that it's somewhat problematic. We might want to, we might want to reconsider that how we do it. Not that we shouldn't increase fees, but I think the automatic 1 that we thought was a good idea might not be the best way to go about it. [13:07] Speaker G (unidentified): And I know for the transportation, none of that's automatic. This is something that I'm presenting to you guys. [13:13] Speaker H (unidentified): I would suggest this be posted at the transfer station because, as I said, I think I was [Speaker J (unidentified): grossly overcharged. Okay.] And I had to rely on milling it. [13:25] Speaker I (unidentified): That is true. You walk in there and it's kind of ballparking. And that's... [13:30] Speaker G (unidentified): We're not going to be able to fix the ballpark part of it because we don't have a scale. [13:35] Speaker B (unidentified): For volume stuff. For individual volume stuff. [13:37] Speaker G (unidentified): So when somebody comes in with bulky waste and they're like, oh, that's a large item, I can't get rid of that part of it because we don't have a scale so there would be they're [13:48] Speaker E (unidentified): expensive and then what's the cost like it [13:54] Speaker G (unidentified): would have to do the analysis but it would it would take a long time to pay for it so ballparking is the best we can do with what we have versus spending you know a couple hundred thousand dollars so you know if we're undercharging a little bit it would take a long time to pay for that oh [14:15] Speaker B (unidentified): yes go ahead i'm sorry i'm not i was i mean [14:18] Speaker E (unidentified): there are some places where it's posted in the bulletin board it's posted on the bulletin board and it's posted at that table that's actually inside the thing but i don't think it's necessarily in an area where if you're bringing it in directly and then you're going to head down [14:34] Speaker G (unidentified): and not that we couldn't do a big board right up for i actually i There is. I don't know if it's up to date. It's this, it's this one here. Is it okay? Yeah. Because it's got that date on it, April 1st, as of that date. [14:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, it's, it's at the GARPA. All right. [14:53] Speaker E (unidentified): But the question, we voted in the automatic increase as a CPU plus 1 or something like that, right? Right was CPI plus 1 was that did that chapter include these fees? I thought it included everything except the sewer fee. [15:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Right again, it's, it's. [15:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I thought you can you quickly tell us why it's problematic? Well, it's it's too long. No, I mean, I think it says a couple of things. Some of the fees. [15:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Some of the some of the programs have. Regulations regarding how much you can raise a fee in a year. So, you know, we've got to be careful that we don't violate that. The other thing is, you know, people understand a $15 fee, but, you know, a $16 fee seems kind of weird, you know, or an $18 and it's, you know, every year you got to change it. So the suggestion that was made to me by Nat when he was doing it, because he looked at it, he says, this is really going to be a headache for staff and citizens, they're going to be very confused by this so his recommendation and we don't have to take it but he said why don't you just require that this is zoe i'm sorry i'll just look right through and see if she texted me that suggestion was making a requirement that the town manager come to us every year with the recommended schedule fee increases just based on like the costs are going up we should do that and just put it on the town manager to bring it to us but to not let it [16:30] Speaker C (unidentified): go 10 years between you know just making an annual event having it annually before the budget yeah [16:35] Speaker F (unidentified): everyone can you know use the fees to plan revenues for budgeting so i think we might want [16:41] Speaker B (unidentified): to we might want to rewrite what we did last year because i think it's just it's you know the first time it popped up was with the clam licensing fees because it looked like our increase was actually going to violate the state regulation there's like and the harbor and i'm sorry the and most people don't know about the changes so shellfish commission's like what we have an automatic fee increase we didn't know about this so it's you know good it was well intentioned but i think execution wise it's kind of a massive we should probably correct it before [17:16] Speaker K (unidentified): like five percent before we start the budget before the staff start their budget we'll give them a better idea of their revenue so they can budget with it so that isn't really [17:26] Speaker B (unidentified): over in november a good time to do it yeah we should probably revisit this very soon and just i mean i mean if that's what the council wants to do i think it's a good idea but i [17:35] Speaker I (unidentified): you know i'm just recommending it i'd like to try the market try the market rate figure out like why is anything free like scrap metal we can sell it right we it's a revenue source for us [17:47] Speaker G (unidentified): so i have no problem like metal there's no problem with that at all But like the shingles, we're charging $100 and it costs us $170. [17:56] Speaker B (unidentified): We used to be way up. We used to charge like $20. [17:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. We shouldn't be subsidizing that. And that's when you're asking about contractors. That's when a contractor is going to be like, hey, it only costs $100 here. I'm going to go there. Whereas if we're going rate what we're getting charged, they might get it cheaper down the road. They might go down the road and that doesn't bother us. Anything that's free or no charge is probably because we're making a little money on the backside. [18:31] Speaker B (unidentified): Great. Well, we'll need to revisit these and probably all of our other fees, but we've got to figure [18:37] Speaker E (unidentified): out. Your punch card is going to be in bigger denominations. We can do that. [18:48] Speaker B (unidentified): I buy those 55s like they're candy. [18:53] Speaker G (unidentified): The smoke detectors, that used to be one of those things where it wasn't a big deal. Now we're actually getting charged for one. [19:01] Speaker E (unidentified): Why don't someone just do that in general trash? [19:05] Speaker G (unidentified): it's not, it goes against us when it gets down to eco main, you know, they don't charge us if like one or two of those make it through, but it's one of the big stuff makes it through when they, if you've got a bunch of TVs in your trash, then you're gonna, they're gonna start digging you on those things. [19:23] Speaker B (unidentified): Just a second. Councillor Wolff, can you hear us? You can? Or no? [19:31] Speaker L (unidentified): Yep. Oh, see, yes, I can hear you. I'm so sorry. I've been having tons of technical difficulties. I would have been 10 minutes earlier. I apologize. Please, everyone who I called, disregard my phone call. [19:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, yeah, I was just saying, I did just because we were meeting and I didn't pick up. So, sorry for ignoring you. [19:49] Speaker E (unidentified): And David, when you say they ping us, do they? [19:53] Speaker G (unidentified): Anything goes against our 16? 16 no that will always be the rate okay and we're really good i mean anything that goes in there 's a guy watching so we that doesn't typically happen i mean if somebody puts something small in a bag it's probably going to make it right through there they're not going to see it [20:10] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah that's right okay thank you are we having any problems with people not using the blue bags at curbside pickup anymore is that pretty much gone away [20:24] Speaker G (unidentified): They bark at me as soon as they hear about it. [20:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Then I send out a letter. [20:30] Speaker G (unidentified): I've been here for just over a year now and I think I've had to send out two letters. [20:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Great. That's good news. It was a learning curve at the beginning. That's great. Fantastic. Thank you. [20:41] Speaker K (unidentified): Does anyone have complaints about the bags? [20:45] Speaker A (unidentified): The quality of them? I mentioned it to Scott a while ago. [20:50] Speaker K (unidentified): well, of course, and I don't know who is in charge of that. The labels to them. So they were in the [20:57] Speaker G (unidentified): I got a complaint from our former town manager, actually. Mr. Tucker emailed me, I think that they got by the way, now that I'm a resident. So I sent that off to their QA. They're looking into it right now. Thank you. [21:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Anything else we should, we have a big agenda, but it's good to see you, David. We haven't seen much of you, so please don't be a stranger. [21:26] Speaker J (unidentified): Absolutely. Thank you. [21:28] Speaker G (unidentified): And actually, if you want to, you can hand this around here. This is, that's from our meeting. do what's going on at eco main and awards step one so very [21:42] Speaker B (unidentified): good okay so we'll move on to item number three sewer fee structure this is jen monty's specialty so that's a monty take it away [21:56] Speaker I (unidentified): i wonder if you can forward them the email i just Zoe and Heather, I was going to forward you the email, which is just a copy of this, kind of like you guys already got it. Okay, I'm going to focus, to frame it up for those of you who have not seen this, I think the most useful thing is to take a moment to read the five key points there, and then perhaps we can take a look at the graph together. We'll give two or three minutes for that. [22:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Can I ask you a quick question? So, when you look at the, usage, was that still based on the estimated you said we have the best we have best we have. Yeah. So we didn't get any additional data. So, okay. All [23:28] Speaker I (unidentified): right, so, graph 1 real quickly. And if you go to the 1st page here, the blue line, what this shows, this is a classic problem when we have decisions in data. right is that with low users in the bin and to overpay on a per unit basis compared to people that are high users you know copying and tracking to just look at it you can see it's a soft food pattern right where look at for a person in the low sewer bin is being charged compared to the per unit compared to the previous ones right it goes up down and up and down you could but then [24:05] Speaker K (unidentified): and people are paying the same prices because they have less. [24:07] Speaker I (unidentified): Right, we don't have house by house data, but we have it in 400 cubic foot blocks. It gives a rough cut at it. So here's the example of the low tier. It's on the big screen here. You look by how much water usage is associated here, right? At the person who is only in the 400 tier right off the left is paying per 100 cubic feet, 30 bucks. But if you're at 2,800 all the way to the right, you're paying $4 in change per 100 cubic feet because you're a higher user in a tier that's designated as low. Because we don't have continuous data, you can see us make a choice to bucket it. This is the implication of how the buckets are set up today. So what you have is low users subsidizing higher users within every tier. If you go to the next one, Audra, this is standard tier accounts, right? So the ones at the low end of standard are paying 13 and change and then the ones at the far end are paying four dollars and change per hundred cubic feet wait looks about this end looks like 13 and that end looks like that 's just the number of users that so if you're at 32 two hundreds the low end of 13 bucks per unit and then it's four on the other end so it becomes the next one they're all the same story but what you had when you end up having is like here high users in high tier three bucks low users designated high tier five bucks and change. So this is why it feels like the low users are subsidizing the high user with any given tier because they are. So if you look at the graph at the back of the first page, you've got the top and then you just have a chart there. And I labeled the chart moved from lighter to heavier homes, right? So row two, low, there's over $12,000 being transferred from low to high users in the low tier. Standard tier, there's over $100,000 that moves over to high users from low, and the same thing happened. So just demonstrating what I think we heard from some residents that they felt like this might be, turns out it's the case. So the way I propose to fix it, I'm open to every discussion, right? [26:34] Speaker K (unidentified): You only look at the residential rate, [26:35] Speaker J (unidentified): you didn't look at the highest rate, which was industrial. [26:38] Speaker I (unidentified): Industrial is a separate issue that we'll talk about. This is just a handouts. All right, so to the fix, I mean, what are you trying to do? If you look at this, I'm trying to smooth out a stepwise function and make it a straight line and there's a way to get at that by looking at a fixed charge plus the same charge for every 400 cubic foot block to see where people would be so that's what 's kind of contained in the fix here [27:12] Speaker J (unidentified): Did you, from this chart, from page three, I guess, taking the numbers of what the bill for the income revenue would be if you did this versus what's today, is it more? [27:28] Speaker I (unidentified): So I think if you look at the next page, you'll see this is labeled, how it even about the disparities. So this would be page four at the top. You see what's happening today right in low standard and high tiers we'd be smoothing that out so that the burden of moving for each tier is not as high and once you go to the next chart you have it here it's up here so if you look up here who sends the flow and who pays currently low if you look at revenue divided by volume low is paying more than they should standard is playing more than they should high is getting a free pass and the wells don't matter i didn't think the wells because that's a different issue so this is where we are that's where we are today can you look at the next one i think it's useful and then come to the next one this is industrial as a separate issue so i put it up here but i think it may be more useful we'll look at. Look at number three. Can we just look at the one in front of us under point number three? What would be fair share? If you look at it today, right? Residential today, the first row, it sends 72% of flow. They're paying 79%. So they have a practical resident, 100 cubic foot rate. Industrial today has much lower, much lower. And then and for them both to be a fair share, we have a discreet cost for them. And then if we look at how Yarmouth compares to other towns, Yarmouth's 2.4 cents per cubic foot is the lowest industrial rate of the 14 towns within 20 miles that host their rate. It's 25% of the neighboring median. To make it right, we'd have to be about $4.50, four cents, four and a half cents. And Yarmouth would still be by far the lowest industrial rate on sewer. So we have really under-indexed on industrial accounts compared to residential, and we have a residential problem within each bucket. [29:52] Speaker E (unidentified): So a couple of assumptions, right, I asked about the first one, we're measuring flow, a flow that we are, we are, it's a best guess, imperfect, and then the other assumption is we're using flow of water coming in, whereas the charge is on wastewater, right? And so let's say I'm an industrial user and I'm pumping out gallons of water because I'm washing the boat, okay? The amounts that it costs perhaps to treat that water that may have some soap in it is different than let's say, as to brooks water and plants or fecal matter from a large family [30:41] Speaker I (unidentified): we aren't even accounting for what it costs to treat it right so that's the thing [30:47] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah we're further behind so but just there's a difference right it's not just based on volume there's actually a cost difference associated with the treatment that we haven't even touched [30:57] Speaker I (unidentified): we're not even capturing that no my question is in the residential part well actually probably both [31:02] Speaker K (unidentified): but the residential mostly we do we know like it's broken i mean do we know that we actually would increase revenue by doing this i mean do we know that there are more houses there are many [31:16] Speaker I (unidentified): houses at the upper level we are really just shifting revenue so that the total remains the same we are just shifting who pays to account yeah i know i get that but we're kind of [31:28] Speaker K (unidentified): assuming that if they'll say a low block now whatever you want about it that i don't if there's no there are some numbers so like you know here okay that's that's people with [31:39] Speaker I (unidentified): low flow they're paying a higher percentage people maybe a larger home or more people we don't know how many houses are in india the best we have are these 400 cubic foot [31:53] Speaker K (unidentified): a flow block right so and size of house which i saw somewhere that scrub footage is not necessarily [32:01] Speaker I (unidentified): at all indicative of flow it might be not necessarily somewhat there's another proxy [32:06] Speaker K (unidentified): there but there could be a small house that has six people living in it and there could be a large [32:09] Speaker I (unidentified): house because there's a lot of large houses right so it's totally independent of that so what we know i made an estimate if you look at right above where number three is who pays more I'm estimating 1,192 homes will pay less, and about 1,230 are going to pay more. Most of the standard low-user half will pay less. All 155 high-tier homes pay more, because their bills now rise with use. And heavier-use, low-tier homes are going to pay more, again, because they've been benefiting from being at the end of each sawtooth pattern over time. So what we're going to do here is redistributing based on usage and we're going to have industrial paying its fair share. And I think I just want to also frame who is industrial in this town, so I looked into who the high users are. You have things like a couple of nursing homes, a couple of rehabs, those tend to be tons of laundry. It tends to need to, we're not accounted for treating. and they're not non-profit they're for-profit real estate trusts they're not non-profit nursing homes so i think we do have a duty to our constituents to solve this in two ways i mean i think it's a discreet thing we could deliver on i'm also super mindful donna i used your data but i know i may not have done it correctly someone else may have a different point of view but it was lovely it was so well organized it was pretty easy to understand so revenue neutral shifts yeah revenue neutral [33:51] Speaker E (unidentified): smoothing out the curve i mean like you said the points above number three gives a breakdown of it's almost a 50 right in terms of 50 will pay more 50 of the residential payless but it looks like based on your industrial proposal, we're also probably shifting 75,000 from the residential part to the industrial side of things, right? So that's how we smooth out the residential. We have the industrial side pay its fair share and smooth it But the industrial side is still a deal compared to other towns. [34:34] Speaker I (unidentified): If we want to index for treatment, which is a fair thing to do, and that if you look at the other towns that I surveyed, they already do that. So what are we doing? Do we want to not account for heaviness of the water, heaviness, right? [34:51] Speaker J (unidentified): I don't know. Who's the correct person to talk to? [34:56] Speaker K (unidentified): Would it be Steve who would run with them, or would it be, okay. Okay, so has this, why did we go with the old style, maybe old for not to be our old style of building [35:08] Speaker A (unidentified): with the four levels? [35:10] Speaker B (unidentified): So I was here when it started and so I can try to answer, but it really, it feeds into the other thing we need to think about is if we go with this policy, it's gonna drive a different way of doing things with the data and we might, it's not something that don's going to be able to just go do you know but that's why we set up the tiers originally it was just simplification billing process from anything else so we had the only ones we had to the only ones we had to keep track of you know individual usage with the [35:47] Speaker A (unidentified): really high industrial ones which was a small service was a 1.2 so following up on that though [35:53] Speaker K (unidentified): so does that mean that we would need and perhaps other staff parts or privatized or something but [35:59] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, can I ask you a question? So before we get into, you know, the fix and the details about how we pull off the fix, I guess, you know, just to go back to sort of like what you're trying to achieve from a policy perspective, is it the equity and proportionality that's most important to everyone? Or are there other things like bringing us more in line with what wastewater treatment is doing regionally or even in the state? Are we looking at alignment with system costs and making sure that we're covering O&M as well as capital and debt and all of that? I guess what's most important in all of this and what do you all want to achieve? because if we know you know everything that you're trying to do it helps you kind of figure out where you want to go and then we can go back and tell you okay well if you want to make this change this is what it's what the implication is and then you can decide again is it is it gonna be worth that yeah and then it'd be better if he told you we you know kind of at the point where yeah we're you know we've we've talked amongst ourselves and it's really all about figuring out you know what's most important to all of you and [37:21] Speaker K (unidentified): what you're trying to achieve I don't know where we are with I don't know how we compare this type of graph on a residential side with our neighboring towns unless you have that right i'm sorry i'll be better next time no i bet you i bet you can find it [37:50] Speaker F (unidentified): something from gp [37:51] Speaker I (unidentified): so anyway i would like to see both an increase if it makes sense and i [38:08] Speaker K (unidentified): would like to know and make it more equitable that's just my i'm just saying my own point of view we have to talk about as a council but i definitely would love to hear the input from like i would this sounds great but i want to hear i have no idea how this might impact other things well i [38:24] Speaker B (unidentified): mean i'd be interested to hear what all of you think in terms of what is it you want to achieve because that'll help us decide how we frame it going forward i would just say though that i don't like to see policy be constrained by capacity of the staff if you know if we think of policy as the right thing to do that we need to consider what we do with staffing or privatizing or changing when we do things but i hate to work in reverse going well the only thing we can do is this so let's do this i'm not saying you're doing that i'm just saying [38:55] Speaker A (unidentified): if that was what we're saying no i'm just no i'm just i'm just saying let's let's be open-minded [39:00] Speaker B (unidentified): when we talk about we're trying to achieve and not worry about how we would implement That would be my recommendation. [39:07] Speaker K (unidentified): You brought up the fact that Dawn could do it. Oh, I know that. I know that. [39:10] Speaker B (unidentified): But what I'm saying is, it is a consideration, but I think we should do, as Audra's suggesting, what's our goal before we get bogged down into those other details. [39:23] Speaker I (unidentified): My North Star, I mean, taking this project on, it's a great example where use of modern, pretty basic data analysis is going to drive a change that impacts residents tangible and we can get our hands around so equity is super important to me and industry paying the appropriate share is important to me I guess like I don't understand why we are so behind on the industrial rate I also think there is such there's almost no margin for innovation in the municipal government for really good reasons this is an opportunity a little bit of breathing them on a topic where we're looking to do different things so it makes sense to me that we would consider all parts of this and I'd be interested in seeing the analysis which is what I think I got a thought that's the first or second base here what is the impact of treatment hey you know appropriate rates for appropriate treatments what does that buy in terms of a flex fund I use that term judiciously flex fund twenty thousand dollars that allows us to like but then innovate in another space. It's about two cents. [40:32] Speaker H (unidentified): Any other thoughts? Yeah, Mike. Well- Oh, I'm sorry, go ahead. [40:36] Speaker L (unidentified): We should also see if Zoe or- [40:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh,, yeah, I can't see the screen. [40:40] Speaker F (unidentified): I see first. Oh, sorry, I'll take. [40:43] Speaker B (unidentified): Janice, then Mike, then whoever's online. [40:45] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, well, I think this discussion was driven by our constituents who are concerned about the equity and that's what we should be responding to. It's not a lot of money for most people, but it irks some. And I think we have to respond to that. But I also think this might be an opportunity to respond to another concern, which is that we fail to set aside money for replacement of big infrastructure. [41:24] Speaker J (unidentified): but that includes the sewage treatment. [41:30] Speaker H (unidentified): So if we have a modest increase in fees, given that we're so below the norm in industrial, but also in residential, we're 66% of the same neighboring median, we can use, we can set aside that increase for a fund to for capital improvements of the waste water system which i think is another burning issue for the public so either for your team what i would [42:11] Speaker I (unidentified): be interested to see is what is the yield on an industrial rate that is more appropriate and what we want to do with that is you know we have about ten thousand dollars and then [42:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, so, I mean, I'm referring to that packet that he gave us back in August. So, I think equity, making sure that everybody pays for fair share. I think that's a very good goal, but it's revenue neutral at this point. Right? Right? Nat left us a love note saying that the wastewater funding will be in the red by $336,000 by FY 30. Right? So that's in the red. That's not necessarily probably accounting for everything that they have to do anyways. So somehow we got to make up $336,000 within the next three fiscal years. Right. And, you know, that's if we're thinking that we're going to raise that money through applying some sort of heaviness on top of just flow rate. And we're going to, I think that's, I think, I mean, I haven't done the math. I think that would be a hard lift for people to, for us to make up $336,000 just based on this in the next three years. [43:56] Speaker B (unidentified): We need a 10 or 15% increase overall. [43:58] Speaker I (unidentified): I actually think that the industrial side of this might cover it completely. We're talking about a market rate for industrial plus legitimate water treatment burden. We'll have to see where it lands. It's a hypothesis. [44:14] Speaker E (unidentified): You may, but I would say that it's hard enough to get businesses to open up in Yarmouth, especially big businesses, right? Right. And I worry about that because I don't, I don't think we're going to grow ourselves out of our affordability crisis without the help of and we're being more inviting for large businesses to come to town. [44:43] Speaker I (unidentified): This is a false herring community development. It always has that. Well, I don't know. Is it trying to attract big businesses? It's not going to happen here. here and let's start with who is already here. Yeah. Right? So. And go from there because if you grow, like having started two businesses in Yarmouth and being super mindful of the challenge [45:06] Speaker D (unidentified): of even working in Maine, [45:08] Speaker I (unidentified): I think that we should focus on who is here, not who we hope to potentially attract. [45:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Not all 88 industrial users are for profit. [45:17] Speaker I (unidentified): Right, we should look at it, but that there's a big it's not even distribution there are a few high end and those are there i looked at them they're rehabs and nursing homes yeah that are real estate investment trust number i'll tell you that they make one to two percent margin they do on being a nursing home they make seven to nine percent on being a real estate investor and those companies [45:37] Speaker E (unidentified): will just shift the burden on the people who are taking care before we get too deep [45:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Before you're too deep in this, I mean, we do have Zoe that has a question, so Councilor Wolfe. [45:57] Speaker E (unidentified): We can't hear you Zoe, sorry. [46:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Looks like your mic is on, but we can't hear you. Yeah. Can we have this one? Well, it was working before though, so I'm not sure if that's true. [46:12] Speaker L (unidentified): Last try, can you hear me now? Yeah, we can hear you, yes. No headphone, I guess. Yes. I think I, well, I, first, I just want to say the quiet thing that I feel like should just be said out loud. Fees, and one of the reasons that we've had such trouble adjusting fees are, you know, inherently a regressive way of raising revenue. And so the conversation around equity is a hard one to have because I think equity implies that there's some sort of structure that pays attention to who can afford to pay what and unfortunately this can't do that and that's sort of the nature of fees and so it's one of the things that I find hard about having these types of conversations is there are going to be people in all of the tranches of this that are impacted differently by it whether it be industrial or low user there are going to be some people who will find this money in their couch cushion and there are going to be some people for whom this is going to be the choice between and whether or not they get groceries that month, right? So I just think it's important to understand that. I don't know that equity is the word, actually, that I would use here. I would use market rate. We want people to be paying market rate. We don't want people to be subsidizing sub-market rates for other people. And I think what we should be thinking about is how we get folks to market rate And also how we use this as an opportunity to sort of level set with the surrounding communities and use that money to start to, I mean, this isn't going to potentially, I mean, it could, we haven't seen the numbers yet, but I don't expect this to make up that $300,000 deficit, but we've got to have some way that we start chipping away at it because it's not going anywhere by itself. So, you know, I'm very grateful to you, Jen, for looking at this data and I'm in favor of doing whatever we can to outsource this so we can actually make it happen. And that's another piece of the pie here for me is that if Dawn isn't going to be doing the work, presumably we're going to be outsourcing it. and i'd like to know what that is going to cost because obviously we need to be able to offset the cost of whatever it takes to outsource this to somebody else to do it so those are my 12 cents [48:36] Speaker B (unidentified): thank you councilwoman so just from the process standpoint we do have other topics on the agenda this is a great start can we leave it here and pick it up again or how do we want to move forward? [48:52] Speaker K (unidentified): I would like to, but it's fine to leave it now, but going forward, what does going forward look like? One thing that would be important to me is a report from the staff about impacts that we might not have seen or whatever. That would be important. And also, you know, I don't want to totally dismiss Mike's idea about the impact on industry. Our industry is very small and we have an entire committee E-Dev devoted to increasing it, and it's difficult. And it will, it does, if it were to grow in any sort of substantial way, it could help with the property tax issue for the residents. [49:37] Speaker I (unidentified): One thing I would just say, having looked at all 88 industrial users, is that most of them are in the industry. So we should be cautious, just that there's not, there's no big industry here. The ones that are, I just told you who they are. [49:47] Speaker B (unidentified): You could probably rename the tier and just be a very high user or something like that. [49:51] Speaker K (unidentified): Well, there are some, there's Hennifer, there's Don, there's Hennifer, there's Estabrook. [49:55] Speaker I (unidentified): When you look at high users, you look at all the users, they're not equal. Right. [50:02] Speaker D (unidentified): You can have a residential meter that is feeding the house and an apartment if it's a duplex or an in-law apartment. And a lot of the high industrial users or the industrial users, are a meter for multiple units, so they're not, you can't usually compare that to the others because if you look at Blueberry Cove, I believe one meter feeds four condos. If you look at TAMO, it can be ten units that are off of one meter, so they get to the high or they get to the industrial. And they are using more, but if they were individualized, they'd all be down in residential. [50:38] Speaker I (unidentified): That's interesting. I can clearly understand industrial better. [50:42] Speaker D (unidentified): but they also have the option of doing that right they think they could i mean obviously it's more than just meters it's coming right it's you know yeah mike no i also say thank you for [50:53] Speaker E (unidentified): that's awesome it was it was cool to read and yeah i think it's a good start can i can i ask [51:01] Speaker F (unidentified): one last clarifying this is a goal getting to a point where you're generating enough money from wastewater fees that it covers both operating costs as well as capital costs. [51:18] Speaker I (unidentified): I think we should see where at market pricing we land with the ability to meet some of these other needs outside of the day-to-day function. I'm okay with leaving this right now, but we need a work back date when we want it to be operational. It should not take us six months we have to show more ability to act yeah and for us it's just kind of understanding what [51:44] Speaker F (unidentified): it is you want us to look at because we can you know we can do all that analysis you know it's just kind of until we know what it what exactly it is that you're trying to achieve we don't want to be wasting effort i guess at the same time cip and budgets yes right i would never be able to [52:02] Speaker K (unidentified): telling you i don't think exactly what we're going to do until steve weighs in so i know [52:16] Speaker E (unidentified): dave we got like lots of other stuff but oh and i just wanted a big picture view from audra if you took the amount of money we budgeted this year we looked at how much we actually spent versus how much we budgeted and we've put out I mean I guess it would be better for us to know like how much burn do we really want to place on the taxpayer for budget year this year like so for example our reserves at seven percent right ideally we get to 14, 15, 16. I mean, that was what Nat had wanted. I don't know. We've never been there. We've never been there, right? I'm trying to think big picture. If that is ideal and we come up with a five year, 10 year plan, whatever, pick your day. And we have all these holes that we need to plug in a CIP. Maybe we can get a rough idea of if we divide it over five years and we divide it over 10 years in order to fill the holes and to get our reserves to where we want it to be we can get a rough idea of what that overall what you know budget is going to be per year right and i think that i think the biggest elephant in the room is how that pie is divided and right now the municipal side is a little bit small because the school side is a little bit big right and i think we have the ability to grow the town side a little bit to meet all these things that we need to do municipal wise but who's going to articulate that because we're going to have to take a little pie away from the school side which traditionally we have not done, but gosh, the school's been going up 7 to 8. Percent per year over the last 8 years, right? So, do we have the ability? Do we have the willpower? To sort of grow that municipal slice a little bit. To try to make up for our deficits. And not squeeze the schools to have nothing's in the school. So we've got to keep on running. How do we, how do we achieve that from a bigger point of view, and it would help us then decide, well, how much do we need to increase in order to the fees in order to make ends meet? [55:11] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, so we'll, I mean, now, that we kind of know what it is that you're looking for, we can go back and, you know, do the analysis to figure out how could we cover that over time. there's there's also policy decisions all of you can make like as it is now with wastewater fees 67 percent of fees collected you know go back into capital reserves maybe for a little while you want to do 100 percent so that's that i expect coming back yes so that's yeah those are all the sorts of things knowing what you're, what you're looking to do that we can, you know, kind of give you different options around. But, you know, there's always going to be the other side of that is, you've got the 35% of revenue that went into the general fund that you now have to make up for in that budget. So there's always a, there's always a push pull. Yeah. [56:10] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. We don't charge ourselves. [56:20] Speaker I (unidentified): All exempt. My expectation is to be handed on an option space, right? As like a board of a company, executive company, that's what I would expect. That's what I'm hoping for. And then to come back with the smartest questions we can come up with based on our limited non-domain expectations. I wanted to ask Dawn, I did send this in advance just to make sure that in your mind and that was like, yeah, she missed, she somehow missed in how she used the data. I presume she would have written back or told them. [56:46] Speaker D (unidentified): I don't know, yeah, no. [56:47] Speaker L (unidentified): All right, good analysis. [56:49] Speaker D (unidentified): I did want to mention though, when we were talking about, when you were talking about, you know, when you were talking about boats washing and stuff like that, we do use the winter reeds. So we're hoping not to bring in some of the stuff. So what you're looking at is probably the real dirty stuff [57:06] Speaker I (unidentified): that doesn't need to be treated. Yeah, perfect. [57:09] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you very much. [57:16] Speaker B (unidentified): All right, let's move on to the next couple of topics. Stay and. Pilot, I'll introduce the stay 1, I guess, just kind of like, you generally the sewers. I've kind of been the stay guy. So what we have now, the program is several years old. We've revised it a couple times, wants to increase the size of the benefits now, the maximum benefits somewhere around $2,400. And last year, we lowered the eligibility age down to 65. So this year, I mean, it's, I guess it's up to us, you know, it's always up to us if we want to do something different with it or leave it just the way it is. is a couple of things, or one of the things I've heard Van Dien about is just eliminating the age requirement entirely. So that's one thing we could do. If we lower it, we can only lower it to 62, or we can just eliminate it. And then the other thing we can do is grow the size of the program, or shrink. I mean, you can change the size of the program, I guess put it that way. So we can change eligibility, we can change the size. I'm sure there's other things, but I don't know there any other things that people wanted or want us to talk about or is that really the scope of [58:36] Speaker I (unidentified): what we're discussing help people based on how well sized we are today as i recall there was [58:42] Speaker B (unidentified): money left over last yeah so what we do is we budget a given amount and then if we had more claims than that let's say we budget 300 000 and if you paid everybody it would be 400 000 Everybody gets 75%. We prorate it. So we never run out of money. There are years when we budget, say, $300,000, and we only spend $250,000, and then that other $50,000 rolls forward. So the next year, we go, well, if we want to put $300,000, if we want to have $300,000 in the program, we only have to put $250,000. But again, it's a year-to-year decision how much we want to fund the program. [59:24] Speaker I (unidentified): Remind me, it's all our money, or it's part state, and then all of that? All of our money. Okay, yeah. Yeah, I already missed the question. What was the question? Is it all town money or is it for state portion? No, it's all town money. Yeah. [59:36] Speaker K (unidentified): What about this current year? How is it being used? I mean, how much is it? [59:43] Speaker F (unidentified): Where is it uptake? I think Don said that all but about 10,000, you know, give or take. [59:51] Speaker B (unidentified): So it's being well used. Yeah, we've usually been pretty close, you know, because we. because we see what happened last year and things don't change a lot in a year so we go oh last year or we might see it grow maybe it grew 20,000 last year so okay it might grow another 20,000 this [1:00:06] Speaker K (unidentified): year we've been pretty close this would have been the year this year's ending would have been the year when the re-evaluation reimbursements were really hit well the reval though doesn't [1:00:17] Speaker B (unidentified): really change anything too much because again it's it's all based on your ami and things like [1:00:25] Speaker K (unidentified): I know, but well, I mean, but maybe more people would apply. Okay. Because everyone's taxes went up to 30%. Right. They may have more people, but it doesn't sound like that many more did. So, okay. [1:00:38] Speaker I (unidentified): So, sorry, it did hit this year or it did not and we're about to see it. It's coming here. [1:00:43] Speaker H (unidentified): Oh, re-evaluation hit last year. I'm sorry. Oh, yeah. But not in time for the stay program. [1:00:49] Speaker K (unidentified): No, but in time for people's taxes. Pardon? It hit people's taxes. So if they were going to make requests for the stay, if they were going to make requests of the stay program, they would have made them this current year, right? Is that right? [1:01:01] Speaker H (unidentified): Right. But they haven't, that's not due to labor. [1:01:06] Speaker I (unidentified): I paid a lot more last year. So therefore, people were paying on requesting stay on last year's bill. Right. That all was aligned in time. [1:01:15] Speaker K (unidentified): This year's bill, you're right, it hasn't been. [1:01:17] Speaker B (unidentified): But they still, I mean, it really, it really doesn't impact it much because they, let's say you qualified for $2,400 reimbursement before your house was revalued, you're probably going to qualify for it again. [1:01:31] Speaker K (unidentified): But there might be more people who are qualifying. [1:01:33] Speaker B (unidentified): I know, but what I'm saying is I don't think we need to worry too much about when the reveal kicked in terms of what people got for reimbursements. [1:01:44] Speaker K (unidentified): I wasn't, I was wondering if you were going to find out there's been a run on it and wanted it and we didn't have enough to pay them like that. [1:01:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Gotcha. Mike, you have a question. [1:01:54] Speaker E (unidentified): When, since, when this program was, instituted, was there a discussion about evaluating people's ability to pay or doing some sort of asset cutoff? [1:02:07] Speaker B (unidentified): well there 's it is definitely an ability the state law requires it to be a financial need dependent program so it's based on you know you've got your income it's based on what percentage of your income taxes are so it's it's because on the on the [1:02:26] Speaker E (unidentified): when i went to look at that on the town website there it doesn't give that discrimination it's just as if you're over the age of 62, I think. [1:02:35] Speaker H (unidentified): No, you have to hand in your- [1:02:37] Speaker B (unidentified): It's means testing. It's means testing. Yeah, absolutely. [1:02:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Kind of like the general system. Yeah. [1:02:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Zoe, you have a question? Call me, you're muted. [1:02:53] Speaker L (unidentified): Can't help it, can't stop, won't stop. I think, another layer, Mike, on your question is, To answer your question a little bit more, I think the benefit of the approach that we use in STAY is that other programs, the state program that has, I forget what it is, but the reimbursement at the state level, there's a 60% AMI cutoff, right, Audra? Do you know what I'm talking about? Yes. And ours, I think, is ours 90, David? it's either 80 or 90 but the benefit of that is that we it really addresses what is often referred to in this kind of program as the missing middle right so it's we're not only focused on super low income folks we're also focused on you know working class folks who are you know close to ami not quite hitting ami and sort of integrating what we now understand the data that we now understand about what a livable wage looks like, especially in Cumberland County, is not really reflected in our AMI at this point. So I think that 's the means testing that we do actually hits the people that we want to make sure that we're getting, which is a benefit of this program. And one of the reasons, Councilor Ornstein and I worked on this a lot last year with David, and one of the challenges is administrating a program like this. And there were some conversation about tying it to state, to state means testing. But the issue with that is then we lose a huge tranche of people who are kind of clinging on by the skin of their teeth and not eligible for any other kinds of assistance. So the state program is pretty cool in that regard is that it, that it does include working class folks over 65 at this point and that does bring a good point [1:05:03] Speaker B (unidentified): though one that i neglected to mention earlier so i'd said something about well we could talk about age we could talk about the size of the program we could also talk about eligibility and how we structure that too i'm not suggesting we do i think i like the way it is now but we did look at that last year so yeah and certainly there's other things we can do with that people have ideas but i guess i was kind of coming into this with you know kind of like what jed did with sewer you know kind of giving us a baseline proposal this is what we could do my what i would throw out there is what i would you know if i was if we had this in front of us at a workshop or we're considering a resolution i would probably suggest that we get rid of the age limit that was that was my idea of what i would like to see us do and the size of the program, it's really tricky to know who's going to apply for it, how it's going to change things. And I'd love to be data driven, but this is a really tough data. These are tough data to get, especially since you don't know who's actually going to take advantage of the program. So you almost have to run it for a year to see. That's one way to do it. And it would be really good data because it's the best data we'd ever get, is how will people actually use our program? But we probably should think about if we were to expand the number of people that are gonna go into it, do we want to increase the size of it? So I think they kind of go hand in hand, but that's where I was coming from. I have no idea if that's got any traction with the rest of the council. Lots of hands up. I saw yours first. [1:06:41] Speaker I (unidentified): I have a question. We're under no obligation to a discrete amount if somebody applies, right? You apply and we use good judgment about how those funds are distributed, right? So it's not like, in other words, I 100% agree with dropping an AIDS limit because my hypothesis is there's a working poor layer in there. I think what Zoe was saying, basically people who are busting it to keep up, so that we can more transparently see that just in the application for whether we fund them all differently but we objectively would i mean if [1:07:17] Speaker C (unidentified): someone qualifies we'd pay out right but everyone gets a little bit less yes we are seeing the data [1:07:24] Speaker I (unidentified): because an age cut off is a is a yeah well we've always had it i mean and it was a [1:07:31] Speaker B (unidentified): struggle to bring it down even from 67 to 65 there's there are a lot of people and i'm not one of them but there are a lot of people think this should be for seniors and actually at the [1:07:43] Speaker A (unidentified): end higher end i'm not there i'm not there not either but another thing that's out that's part [1:07:50] Speaker K (unidentified): of it thanks phil is that someone has to live in town for 10 years yes do we have other requirements like the amount of time residency so that is that first of all makes it so we have a Kind of gives you a lower limit of age. It's not going to go much below 32 or so. Yeah, no, we could definitely change. We could definitely change the other aspects of the eligibility. Yeah, but I was saying, so,. Which to me is always, I've always that's sort of always wrinkled me. I understand that I've never been in a place. other besides Maine that values how long you've been there as much as Maine does so I get that but it also seems it's we're not going to hit the very working poor because they can't have owned a house here for 10 years yeah that's hard we could I don't know I don't know if that matters but we're not gonna I mean [1:08:51] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, just to explain why that's in there is because when we created the program, that's what the council wanted. [1:08:58] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I understand. I'm not surprised. [1:09:00] Speaker B (unidentified): No, but I mean, the thinking was, well, we don't want someone to just move here, buy something that's too expensive for them to pay taxes on, and expect to get a reimbursement the first year. It should be somebody who's been here a few years. I can understand that argument, but maybe 10 is too long. I mean, I don't think anyone would really do that, but I think 10 is probably – I've always thought 10 was too long. but again the political reality that was the only way to get it passed was that the only way to get past was 67. so things have changed since then mike what's the crossover of applicants for ga [1:09:31] Speaker E (unidentified): and also apply for state or are they allowed to double to do both absolutely you can double dip [1:09:40] Speaker B (unidentified): in program they're not there's nothing exclusionary about this nothing says oh if you're If you are doing this, you can't get it. It's for renters also. It's very difficult to qualify as a renter. Even though we've tried to make it better, I think we get two or three renters a year out of the 110 or so that get it. So it's a very small percentage. [1:10:15] Speaker E (unidentified): So it's bigger than, I mean, the general one, two, three, four qualifications. There are actually more. [1:10:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, it's probably the application itself that gives you the, you know, you've got to fill in the income stuff. I believe, though, I'm just looking at the website. OK, so we actually have a stay everything. I mean, it's many, pages long. So the website just gives people, you know, a snapshot. [1:10:48] Speaker E (unidentified): And how much did we fund this last year? I mean, I think, overall, it goes back to almost the same question that Audra asked us when we were considering the sewer, probably the same question that we're going to be dealing with the pilot, which is, you know, what's our goal, right, and I just don't have a sense of I mean I you know fill these gaps and get our reserve to whatever percentage we feel comfortable with within five ten years that would give us a rough idea of what we really need to do I mean I think that's the only way from a data driven point of view with some sort of planning that I would personally know how much should we be putting in to stay or how much we need to adjust the sewer fees by work what do we need to get out of pilot in order to make the numbers work I lack sort of the big overview right and I think that's I think we really need [1:12:08] Speaker I (unidentified): that question was how does your reserves affect your bond rating because I don't worry about saving more money because it seems like the external organizations that evaluate us really like us is that fair to say it well because of you know [1:12:30] Speaker F (unidentified): good financial management so things like you know sticking to our fund balance policy of having, I think it's like anywhere between 10 and 7% unassigned fund balance, so completely non-committed funds. And then we have really good at capitalization of our reserve funds. So all of those things help us with our high bond rating. [1:12:57] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. If you add in our CIP, we are at those target percentages. And the bond rating agencies look at that. It's just that a lot of towns don't have a CIP and it all has to be in reserve to make ends meet. So we kind of split it. We're at seven. We've never really been much higher than eight or nine. [1:13:22] Speaker L (unidentified): I just wanted to make sure people could still see me because I've lost [1:13:28] Speaker F (unidentified): lost video so i just okay we're i'm having we see you the same camera issue that a few people [1:13:34] Speaker A (unidentified): have been having so she can't she can't see us oh go ahead so i remember not saying that we [1:13:42] Speaker E (unidentified): were able to keep our favorable bond rating because we were able to or found grace in whoever was rating us to allow us to roll our money that's actually in reserve that we've held in reserve and count that in conjunction with our unrestricted reserve exactly right but like you said if we really stuck to it we would our bond you know if the raiders were not as generous and allowed us to allow that to happen we would actually not be as favorable in there. Does that make sense how I'm describing it? So there was something about that you have unrestricted funds, right? We have funds that are locked into the CIP. If they were just really looking at the unrestricted funds, we would not have as favorable of a bond rating as we do now. [1:14:50] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, so you're saying we didn't have all of those. [1:14:53] Speaker E (unidentified): Correct, but they allowed us, they took into account that we had money stashed in the CIP and allowed us to apply that money as, you know, towards cash on hand, essentially. And that's how we maintained our favorable. [1:15:16] Speaker K (unidentified): So, to me, I just love to know that, like, just simple data from this year. How many hasn't been used? So going forward, do we need to put more into the next year? Do we need to lower the rate? Because there's 100,000 that we didn't use and there might be younger people who could have used it and we didn't do that. I mean, that's, we don't know, we can know if they're younger. It's usually close though. So we're close. We're usually close. [1:15:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, so, you know, it hasn't changed much year to year. We get around 100 to 110 or so awardees. And they almost all get, they get close to the maximum benefit. Usually the people that apply, they really need it. They get almost the maximum benefit. And it pretty much works out. it would change obviously if we change age or something like that it's going to change we'll end up having to do something different or prorated or something but it does change my [1:16:18] Speaker I (unidentified): opinion to say there's no age limit but if you qualify based on these criteria you get it in other words we have to pre-specify the criteria versus looking at the natural history of the population overall now why is that it's our program it's not state mandated we could say we're going to take a look at it when it comes in without an age limit and actually understand our population because right now we've kind of used pretty standard kind of special groups that think it should be for them which is older and i've lived here forever we actually can't open the box safely to understand the distribution if we commit in advance to what the limits are going to be. That's not the way we should do it. We should understand our population and then look [1:17:09] Speaker C (unidentified): at what to do. Right, but that's a hard data set to get is what I'm saying. Is there a way to get [1:17:18] Speaker I (unidentified): any of it without we have a new visitor Sean yeah I told them I would love to [1:17:26] Speaker B (unidentified): know I mean I would love to know you know salary you know wage distribution through the town and then all of their tech show American community [1:17:38] Speaker I (unidentified): survey data that help us be smarter about say in what way the granular and I [1:17:45] Speaker F (unidentified): think I think it would give you a good starting point so you'd have a little more information than going into it completely blind but what David was saying before the best information you're going to get is running the program for a year and seeing you know who what the uptake on it then [1:18:11] Speaker I (unidentified): having artificial cutoffs based on the traditional metrics that again recycle innovation and how we understand who lives here and works here but by that by artificial mean like age 65 up to 10 years [1:18:23] Speaker C (unidentified): i mean it's i know but we have to have some criteria for the program you know just [1:18:28] Speaker F (unidentified): so i understand though it sounds like the overall goal is you just want to help the residents who need it most and you don't want there to be any sort of limit on age as to who that is it's it's more of a need you'd like it to be more based on need then like you said [1:18:44] Speaker L (unidentified): that thank you appreciate it thank you yeah I think I mean I'm I'm I'm in the same camp as Jen I just I would I don't know what the exact right amount to set that it is just that the number at for the year is, but this is, you know, in terms of budgeting for this, it's a, I don't wanna say it's easy, but it's simple, not easy. It's a pretty simple choice because we can't overspend. So we get to decide how much we wanna spend on this program and we get to see what utilization looks like. I do think that it's likely if we're changing limits that we should probably set aside a little bit more money for it because I worry about folks who maybe have come to rely on it suddenly finding themselves with half of what their refund use or reimbursement used to be and you know David I know you have you know part of the next part of the conversation that's gonna maybe tie in to pinch late how we might do that so I don't want to steal your thunder but just circling back to the equity conversation we were having earlier you know, this is, my, I'm, I'm in my fifth year of council. So I finished my fourth, I'm in my fifth. And every year we've sort of had these conversations about like, what are the actual mechanisms at our disposal to help people in town who actually need help specifically with property tax relief, which is the, pushback we get all the time. And, you know, folks there, are a There is a lot of affluence in this town, and there are a lot of people for whom property taxes are an irritation but not a life-changing thing. And there are people for whom they're really life-changing, and this is the one thing we can do to help those people. It's the one thing we've been able to figure out that might have a substantive difference. and so I'm really eager just to run the program and see who actually takes advantage of it because that would give us a really great idea about how to actually provide the relief that people have been asking for year-over-year [1:21:10] Speaker M (unidentified): that's okay you were just you're asking everyone didn't weigh in but I think run the program for a year to get data the data that we need then that's what we should do we're going to get great data that way and we can make a good decision going forward in the following years thank you yeah what i was going to say [1:21:29] Speaker K (unidentified): is that i think it'd be really getting that data will be really interesting because once you get below say 50. there's i know there's a window 50 to 65 it's a big window but you're i wonder how many people have lived here for 10 years own a home and are making 80% of AMI or lower. We may find that there's quite a lot of them, we may find that there's very few, especially the home ownership part. Many of them are probably renters and maybe the renter thing would work out better, I don't know. But I'd be curious to know if that's, it'd just be really good data to get, but I agree with Zoe, we're gonna have to put a little more money into this. I don't want people to depend on this. It's time to get to the next topic. [1:22:09] Speaker C (unidentified): i know yeah i see that 's good okay awesome mike did you have anything [1:22:14] Speaker H (unidentified): yeah i think it's good policy to change it to no age criteria because of it reflects the change in our economy you know people are losing jobs that are in the working age group at higher rate, I think, from what I read on paper. They're likely to be homeowners. For many years, we've piled on benefits to seniors without much thought as to whether or not they're really the ones in the most need. And I say that as a senior, a reasonable senior. [1:23:06] Speaker B (unidentified): And I say that to someone who's just about there. Although I think it was well-intentioned. [1:23:13] Speaker H (unidentified): But times have changed. Times have changed. And now the people in most need are those who are working two or three jobs and still can't afford their groceries. So, the other thing I want to mention is, and this may be a dead end, but you, had told us that, you know, we can, we can. We can do a state program only if we have an age limit above 62, or no age, and that had done just that. So I'm wondering whether we can find out. [1:23:58] Speaker B (unidentified): But I think there's, I think their criteria are a little bit different. I think, if I recall correctly, I think they are tying it to the state program, the state reimbursement program. [1:24:10] Speaker C (unidentified): So that has different criteria than ours does, but we could still, it still could be interesting. If it's a real spike, it's real interesting. If it's not much difference, that's also it. [1:24:21] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, the other thing is, I know Megan, you were saying about the 10 year thing. That's also up a negotiation, right? We could drop it to five. We could get rid of it. We could do all sorts of things. So, okay. We [1:24:46] Speaker M (unidentified): lost sound. Are [1:24:54] Speaker I (unidentified): you back [1:24:58] Speaker F (unidentified): now? I know I texted him and he was just here. Yeah. Yes. [1:25:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Sean's working on the system. That's why we may have dropped out or whatever. [1:25:07] Speaker H (unidentified): Because Sean arrived. Yeah. [1:25:12] Speaker E (unidentified): I'll say it this way because it applies to the pilot as well. You know, we need to look at both sides of the equation, right? In one part we're talking about how we're going to be more equitable in how we fund to provide assistance to people who need it and how do we distribute that money. The flip side of the equation is we also control how much we're spending right it's our spending that's driving the hardship and the feel like we need to make things more equitable so i would just say we gotta that's an equal bite at the apple right i mean that's quite honestly i think as we go and talk about the pilots out there but it [1:25:59] Speaker B (unidentified): in the plans for planning as well right yeah i understand the perspective i think when you go through the budget process i think you're going to see it would be it would be very difficult to do something that would be a 24 2400 benefit to somebody you know it would be that would you know that would be massive on the spending side so this is a targeted program for the people in But not to disagree with you. I mean, obviously, the spending side matters. [1:26:31] Speaker K (unidentified): I want to agree with you and say that I think that, like what Dave presented to us tonight, an increase, that is par for the course, and you will find that there is not anywhere near as much stuff that we can do without that it might appear to be before you plan for the budget process. It's a very hard thing to do. [1:26:55] Speaker I (unidentified): I have a question. I'd be interested in seeing it there. Is on the off chance that Pingree can pull off property tax relief right away, would stay go away and should we build it? Do we have to build? Is there any language in there about if there are changes to the funding mechanism, we drop, stay drops and that goes elsewhere? I think she has an outside shot. [1:27:18] Speaker B (unidentified): We don't have anything built into it now that says that. It's a standalone program. [1:27:22] Speaker I (unidentified): Right, but that says like that. Okay, so we would have if, you know, it maybe doesn't work, but it looks like things hold. Whoever it is, they're able to do something on property taxes. I would like to see STAY modified in real time. [1:27:35] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, so we're not making, you don't have the discretion to do that. [1:27:38] Speaker I (unidentified): This is why I view STAY as eminently discretionary. Yeah, that's what I find exciting because there are so few levers that we have to visualize anything, right? so let me try her 110 people apply 110 people got it right you can't apply if you're not eligible therefore if you apply you probably get it but we still maintain our discretion about the amount [1:27:58] Speaker F (unidentified): that goes out to each one okay all right and say you know say something miraculous happens next year we get all this property tax relief that's that's money that through the next budget process you can reallocate to other things or you know you can you can put it can go into surplus and then that can go towards more property tax relief by reducing another revenue source that reduces the overall budget. [1:28:23] Speaker K (unidentified): So you got a lot of options. [1:28:27] Speaker H (unidentified): Do we need anything from staff on this? [1:28:28] Speaker I (unidentified): It's more a policy decision than anything else, right? Like what we're saying is, I think what I'm hearing, I don't know if we're aligned, is drop the age, see what happens, and go from there. [1:28:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, kind of how we created it. [1:28:43] Speaker I (unidentified): When we did it, the top number, right? Are you aligned with dropping the age? [1:28:45] Speaker E (unidentified): No, I don't oppose dropping the age at all. I'm not even opposed to increasing the amount if you're going to drop the age. I'm just making sure you realize that 's a growth of the general fund that everybody has to pitch in to fit that. right so I'm we can drop the age we can we can put more money into it if we feel like we need to but that money needs to comes from the job somewhere yeah what [1:29:20] Speaker I (unidentified): is the 30,000 foot view because I don't want to play scrap here and there like for example what always comes to mind is my first meeting Scott was like oh the bomb came in better than we thought therefore this is like other money over So, I don't ever view it as 1 to 1 out of like this than that. It's like, how do we model the flow? And I don't know if there's a way to do that, but I would like to see more. [1:29:46] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, so coming out of this, Megan said, she'd like to see data, which is really easy for us to get on, you know, how the money's been spent in the past over the last few years. How much and how many applicants. [1:30:00] Speaker B (unidentified): And I think we were going to see if there was some data that we might give us some idea of what our sub-65 population looks like. Yes. If it's okay, I'd like to move on to the next one. So pilot, again, not that I'm the only one that's come up with this idea, but I've been kind of pushing it the last few years and never gotten anywhere. where again it's voluntary if we put a pilot program in place there's nothing we can do to enforce it people point out well you know portland did this or that well okay what portland did was they went to their assessor and said please take a very close look at properties owned by non-profits and really make sure that they qualify to be tax exempt and they found some stuff that wasn't but that didn't that's not their pilot program that's just getting things categorized as taxable instead of tax exempt so a pilot program is going to be would have to be voluntary my thought is for simplification is that you know we're not trying to go after every little tiny you know nonprofit in town that's you know that has a small office or something you know at least I'm not my thought is they're not really creating a huge tax burden on the town or a service burden on the town, but there are some large, maybe one or two large nonprofits that really are getting a lot of services and aren't paying into the tax system. So I was thinking we create a pilot program and we put some fairly high exemption, like your first 5 million exempt or something like that. And that would really just target at the very large non-profits and saying you know can you help you know pay your fair share if we want to use the sewer fee example now one of the things the reason i was tying this to stay is one of the thoughts i had is if we feel like expanding the user base of stay but we are reluctant to say well i'll throw more funding at it we could say the pilot the revenue from pilot will fund the state program. And that gets us away from Mike's concern about if we pro-stay, it's a burden on the taxpayers. What it does say is you large nonprofits that are benefiting from our town services, you can contribute to that and your monies will help people that are really in need. I think that's a nice meshing of the two goals. So, this is a thought we could, you know, we don't have to structure it that way. We could just have a pilot program and take it for general revenue or we could earmark. So, those are my thoughts and I don't know where the council will be if they want to do a pilot or if they want to market that way. But that was my starting point. [1:33:00] Speaker H (unidentified): That's I like it because it would make it would put a tremendous amount of shame if they don't contribute. [1:33:09] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, it raises money in about the right ballpark to, yeah, because it would probably raise if we got full participation, it would be in the 100, it would be 100, 200,000. [1:33:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Besides, it's probably nobody first parish church. [1:33:33] Speaker E (unidentified): 317, we're 5 universalist sacred heart parish. Those are your top 5 in terms of property, assessed values. [1:33:50] Speaker B (unidentified): I haven't thought of anything. I mean, we can, I don't know if any of those pass. I don't know what the numbers are. I know what NYA is. It's $22 million. [1:34:00] Speaker K (unidentified): You're talking about property value, not like... [1:34:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, first of all, it's voluntary. So we're not saying to churches, you have to pay us taxes, we're suggesting it. But if we if we don't want them to do that, we can raise the number. [1:34:23] Speaker D (unidentified): I have a question. [1:34:34] Speaker I (unidentified): My question is that I don't think why my question is, why haven't we been billing for services [1:34:40] Speaker B (unidentified): for years? Because we can't. [1:34:43] Speaker I (unidentified): But you said they, use town services, like, we do the sidewalk. [1:34:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, they pay for. Okay. I'm sorry for interrupting. Please. That's the part of it. [1:34:53] Speaker I (unidentified): What they use services, they certainly do your services. Have we been not billing or under billing? How does that use it? Can I tell you my theory as to why this. [1:35:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Kind of happened this way, your myth had a tax base that was more similar to like a mill town. because you had one taxpayer paying 50% of the bill so you know for a very long time no one even thought of fees for service in addition you know other sources of revenue because it was like half the property taxes are paid by one entity we don't everything else gets plowed into that and then that changed [1:35:36] Speaker B (unidentified): But I guess what I was trying to say, though, for example, before we had a sewer fee, they didn't have to pay anything. They do pay a sewer fee, right? I mean, because just like any other sewer user. But there is no plow the street fee for people. It's property taxes. [1:35:57] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm just thinking about, is the idea here that we want to get as much as possible or we want them to start to pay a kind of fair assessment for the burden on the town? [1:36:09] Speaker B (unidentified): That's kind of the direction I'm headed. So, for example, and Nat had some thoughts about this, he shared with me, he's like, yes, we plow the streets for them, like for everybody, and that comes out of property taxes, but they don't pay you, so they do it for free. and we take care of you know stormwater for them and you know like we do for bus however they're not sending kids to our schools so maybe it shouldn't be the full tax rate because 70% no but I mean but I mean even if they even if you kind of treat them like a like a regular taxpayer they do not burden our school system. So should they pay that piece of the port? [1:36:52] Speaker I (unidentified): These are tricky. These are hard. I still am happy to live here. So I guess my approach here is, of course, they should be paid. I think it's unconscionable that they haven't been for as long as they have been. So I've heard, you know, through the grapevine about how some of those conversations have gone, I want to strongly recommend we open those conversations. And I'm in favor of not linking it to stay because if the state does the right thing stays going to go away if we are effective in that policy and then we have a lit we start to gain a little bit of flexibility and breathing room and get away from like one-to-one slugging holes like there's holes in a dam i don't want to do that anymore understood i think i think that i [1:37:34] Speaker K (unidentified): am hesitant to add the churches to that yes i want to i want to just put that out there i don't know if we can go beyond i know mine wants 317 i don't mind nya but i mean obviously when we pay different the amount of fees that we're making that's a much smaller yeah but that so that and beyond it [1:37:50] Speaker A (unidentified): beyond the top five i'm willing to clearly exempt an amount and religious institutions i mean we [1:37:56] Speaker K (unidentified): start here anyway but and then i don't mind tying it today i think that might be a impetus for people to actually do it so i'm fine with that but that's so that's where i am but i would like [1:38:07] Speaker A (unidentified): to do it. I think it's great. Looking online, nobody there. Zoe! [1:38:15] Speaker L (unidentified): I don't disagree with Jen on the like linking it to stay being risky. I don't have a ton of hope that the state is going to make the changes that they need to make as quickly as we would hope that they would, but I've been wrong before but my sense is anything to get them to start paying because once they start paying it will be harder for them to stop and so if it's more if it will be more palatable to them to be talking about pilot because they can link it to housing affordability and that's what they can pitch to their board because that's who's going to approve it or not then link it and then five years from now when the state has suddenly decided that we can do differential property tax rates we can say you've been paying this amount of money it's already in your budget the calculation around affordability is changing but the sewer that remotely they pay for fees but the cost to plow the street is not and we want you to continue making those payments i just think anything to get them to start and framing it is really important [1:39:49] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah i think framing is important i 'll be honest with you i really I really don't know, like, from your point of view, what they feel like, they contribute to the town already. Right? I don't think that they're this. Stand alone entity that benefits 100% without. giving, I,, I, get that they're not maybe giving in terms of taxes what we consider to be fair share. but i don't even know what in their minds they consider their contributing to the community so and how we value that right so i like to get a chance to hear from them to see exactly what they think they've been contributing and how do we if there is a value that we put on that I find it a slippery slope that if you're going to do a pilot for non-profits that we start picking and choosing non-profits in terms of artificially coming up with standards. And so, by all means, we can come up with different ways to carve it out, but we're just hard in North Yarmouth Academy. I don't want to tax churches. I mean, I looked it up the top one, two, three, four, five, six, seven. I mean, North Yarmouth Academy, I said the three churches, it's actually four churches, 317. And the next one, the last one down the line is Yarmouth Senior Housing. So, I mean, it's... Again, it's voluntary. Yeah, I understand. It's voluntary, but, you know, we all know where this is. Everybody will know who we're targeting and I. I feel uncomfortable. Doing that, I think, you know, what's good for the goose is good for the gander and I'm not, I don't want to put my finger. I don't want to put the scales. I mean, that's just you could ask. I don't know. I think this has been asked previously. [1:42:02] Speaker I (unidentified): casually in a way that was not strategic but i wasn't yeah but i don't know what [1:42:06] Speaker E (unidentified): they contribute to town i'm not sure how you know i'm not sure [1:42:09] Speaker I (unidentified): in july they contribute a lot is there is there a history of the discussions [1:42:17] Speaker F (unidentified): and how they went there 's no file but there are conversations that have been contained [1:42:26] Speaker I (unidentified): what where's the process and documentation that leaves us with no ability to see or understand. There's no institutional record, right? So if they balk, and they will, because they have in the past, and Waincley balked, and everybody balks, is there a mechanism for assessing fees on a footprint that large that pays no property taxes? [1:42:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Is that true? That's really- Well, the value's been assessed. [1:42:52] Speaker I (unidentified): No, I know. So we know what the value is. There's no mechanism to be recouped our costs for caring for it. [1:42:59] Speaker F (unidentified): The only thing is, and this is why, you know, places that have, service center communities in particular, shift a lot onto fee-for-service. [1:43:10] Speaker I (unidentified): Because these are the types of things I'm talking about. Yes. [1:43:13] Speaker F (unidentified): Because that's how they're able to recoup those costs. Because if you have a lot of not-for-profits, then you just don't get. There's no other way of doing it other than that. All right. [1:43:25] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay, so main campus, secondary campus, total acreage, total assessed value. If you apply the bill rate, if they pay taxes, it's 200,000. [1:43:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Right. I have no idea of what services they're providing. Again, how much we thought it was closer to three, but okay, because I was 22 million or 15. [1:43:45] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, this is who knows if we're looking at the right cards. [1:43:50] Speaker B (unidentified): It's in that range. [1:43:52] Speaker E (unidentified): So, it's in that it's in that range, right? It's 200,000 dollars. And again, grand scheme of things were collecting 66Million dollars from. Everybody in town, and so I think they should, I think I need some more information to see really what they're contributing in town, how we should value their contribution. [1:44:15] Speaker B (unidentified): That's the number, right? Whatever the number and that's why I said, that's why I was linking to the state because it's in the same scale. I'm like, you know what it's it just gives you an idea of the value. We have this really good program. Stay. [1:44:26] Speaker E (unidentified): The cost and why he's not paying for me linking that almost feels like we're trying to deal with them into doing it. And I think you're going to have a board that give it out about. Yeah. So I don't think it was anybody. Yeah. Yeah. So it's fine. It's fine. You don't have to link. No, but I get it. I'm trying to give it. I'm doing a perspective of what how, you know, because. [1:44:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Because 200,000 doesn't, you know, people are like, [1:44:51] Speaker A (unidentified): well, what do you spend that on? You know, it's just one thing. [1:44:53] Speaker K (unidentified): It seems unlikely that it would be with $200,000. Who knows? I think that, yeah. [1:45:03] Speaker B (unidentified): So again, just trying to move things along. What should we do? Should we start just talking to NYA? [1:45:10] Speaker H (unidentified): Is that what you're suggesting? Yeah, but with a strategic point of view [1:45:12] Speaker I (unidentified): and expertise that has been there, I don't know who that would be. [1:45:18] Speaker L (unidentified): I can just, Jen,, I can speak to that from conversations that I had with Scott and Karen last year. To my knowledge, and I don't know where the conversation you're being told about comes from, Scott never brought this up with them. Karen never talked about it with them. [1:45:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Nat did. Whenever I was talking, I was only referring to Nat. Oh, okay. Years ago. [1:45:51] Speaker L (unidentified): Okay. So it's been several years since it's been brought up, but that was not a thing that's happened in the last five years, I don't think. [1:46:04] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't even think it's happened in my tenure on the council. It's a long time ago. [1:46:08] Speaker H (unidentified): And frankly, NYA was in a bad place financially 10 years ago. They are not anymore. And they are thriving now. And yeah, so it's a different scene and they can afford it. [1:46:23] Speaker B (unidentified): So just process wise, I think we need to talk to them. [1:46:27] Speaker E (unidentified): I think at least I personally need to understand from their point of view what they're contributing to now. [1:46:35] Speaker H (unidentified): Just in terms of what they're doing. I mean, every business in town contributes something. You know, whether it's a bank or the bookstore, or, you know, they can all make a case for how they're not that they're good neighbors to the community. [1:46:55] Speaker E (unidentified): So, I don't really think that counts, but they can close their facilities for use for clown festival. [1:47:02] Speaker K (unidentified): They do contribute a lot of funds. [1:47:04] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, it's not possible. [1:47:05] Speaker I (unidentified): Or they can charge us a certain rate. Or they can charge. Yeah,. [1:47:09] Speaker E (unidentified): I just don't know. Again, I'm not disagreeing with you, Janet. I just don't know what, in their mind, they're giving back. [1:47:16] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, they can make that case. They can make that case. Yeah. But it shouldn't be embedded in our approach, is all I'm saying. [1:47:25] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, yeah. I just need the data to sort of, from their point of view, what from their minds, how [1:47:31] Speaker B (unidentified): How they're contributing to the account. And I know the way I've talked about in the past probably looks like I'm targeted anyway. I'm not. I am trying to look out for the taxpayer who is subsidizing and why a somewhat like we're talking about the people in the tears of the sewer system. they're subsidizing people at the other end this is a case where you know we provide value to them whether they provide value into town or not the town [1:48:00] Speaker A (unidentified): is definitely providing value to them and we should recoup some of that well I [1:48:08] Speaker B (unidentified): mean it would probably be some sort of would there would be some sort of ordinance or something that talks about you know what it is but it's again it's And I mean, we can go to any other town and see what they've done, you know, I'm sure it was voluntary. There was no way to enforce it. [1:48:26] Speaker F (unidentified): All right. I think maybe just very quickly, I think some relationship building with NYA is going to be the most important thing that can be done now because, you know, I obviously don't have a relationship with them. And it sounds like, you know, with the council could also help to, you know, reach out and form that because I think before we talk about money, if you're able to kind of have that common ground and understand where, like Mike said, what's your perspective on it, they, you know, having them understand ours, I think it's going to be really important. [1:49:04] Speaker I (unidentified): I think that the question for that is who is the right person, is that not, is everybody a nobody? Who should that relationship be? [1:49:12] Speaker K (unidentified): You might start with the, I don't know what, I don't know where they are or what they're [1:49:19] Speaker B (unidentified): up to. I would not count on them for anything. [1:49:20] Speaker K (unidentified): No, but they must be somebody they talk to every year, because every year the Vet Festival takes over the entire campus of NYA. So they can't just do that without talking to somebody. [1:49:31] Speaker A (unidentified): So, there's a relationship someone has a relationship there that could maybe start and introduce you. Yeah, I just say, I mean, it makes a lot of sense for a brand new town manager to develop a relationship with the headmaster or whoever it might be a way, just like she does with businesses. [1:49:46] Speaker I (unidentified): More than I did with, I think some expertise from, I don't think a county attorney knows the space necessarily, but somebody who can tell them to navigate that. I don't know what resources you have at your disposal in terms of expertise. [1:49:59] Speaker M (unidentified): Well, not right away though, I would just start with that, I think just, I could suggest [1:50:04] Speaker H (unidentified): a friend of mine who lives here, one of whose kids went to NYA, the other one went to the public school, that's what they wanted, and the kids, and he was on their whatever governing board is called. so he this was probably 15 years ago or more so it's somewhat dated but he knows the personalities he's a lawyer he's real smart i could ask him if he could join your team or something like that with your person back yeah and there probably are some of the [1:50:44] Speaker K (unidentified): same people did their next door neighbors when they had their son at nya this is steve [1:50:49] Speaker J (unidentified): grandchildren you know i'm going to be into the shannon so then when i'm hanging with the m.I.A. [1:50:54] Speaker B (unidentified): okay so we're running out of time is there anything else we want to talk about tonight I suspect not, but I want to throw it out there. We do have a few minutes. Anything else on anybody's mind? All right, so we are, we do have a week off on the 29th. We are not meeting next Thursday. And then the next time we see each other is on my birthday, November 5th, at the workshop. [1:51:43] Speaker K (unidentified): So we probably will need a vote on nomination studies. [1:51:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, it's also a good time of year. If you're no people that might want to serve on committees to remind them that. To send in an application, because we'll do a pile of appointments at the end of December. Yeah. So it's a great time for them to send in stuff. Okay, I guess we're adjourned. Thank you. Thank you. [1:52:12] Speaker A (unidentified): I think so. Yeah, [1:52:18] Speaker E (unidentified): he also sits on the board. Oh, thanks. [1:52:27] Speaker B (unidentified): Good discussion folks. It's hard takes time to do these things. [1:52:33] Speaker K (unidentified): I will tell you now that I will not be here for the voting day in November, sorry, in November. I also will not be here for, I'll be here on the 5th, but I won't be here on the 12th. [1:52:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, don't miss my birthday. [1:52:46] Speaker K (unidentified): I won't, but we have conferences on the 9th and the 12th this year. Our conferences are on Monday night and Thursday night. And then the following Thursday, I have a thing I have to do at school too, so sorry.