← Back to MaineScanner

Sanford Planning Board Approves Sand Pond Shores Campground with Conditions

2026-11-04 · 3h 2m · Source: Planning Board Meeting (City of Sanford (Town Hall Streams))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Unfinished Business
[1:27] Speaker A (unidentified): your comments, please state your name and address for the record. With that, we will now proceed with tonight's agenda. Hearings in business. Old business file, R15, TAC1, TAC, Sand Pond, Shores, LLC, TAC, Siddle Road, R15, TAC1. Jamie, would you orient us? [1:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, this is the campground that has been before you guys now for quite some time. Jamie, could you hold on a second? [1:57] Speaker A (unidentified): just a reminder you do have to recuse yourself thank you since the last meeting the applicant [2:05] Speaker B (unidentified): had worked with our public works engineers to finalize the details on the sand pond road slash country club 2 intersection realignment that was the last details that the planning board had requested for final review those plans have been received and reviewed by the city the engineers. I think it's ready for you guys' discussion and final public hearing. [2:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Awesome. Does the applicant have anything to add? [2:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Good evening to the board. Steve Bushey with LJB Inc. I've introduced the project and gone through a number of things here for a number of meetings. I do have a slide deck very briefly just to show you the road improvement piece that we talked about, and I think there was a board question about some turning movements and so forth, so I'd like to show that to you and to also go through these other slides so that you're aware that we have them and if during any deliberations or questions you'd like to be able to reference that we can do so and also with me online tonight is taylor stevenson a fly catcher llc the person responsible as i had explained before behind the landscape buffering plan and so i asked him to be in attendance here knowing that there could very well be some questions and comments and thoughts about that and it would be better served to have him directly speak to those things he could not attend in person but he is online so hopefully if we get to that so here's the overall property 113 acres you can see hopefully on your screens and members of the public here sure yeah if they can see him on the big screens it'll be just a minute Ben is behind me so worries if you'd like I'll wait for a [3:52] Speaker A (unidentified): moment yep yes please there [3:57] Speaker C (unidentified): we go so Country Club to Road here more or less to the east and north Sand Pond Road in our intersection I'm going to highlight here more specifically here in a moment and then the campsite entering in off of a 50 foot wide width area of the property that comes in off of that intersection into the property and then the layout of a single new access road and campsites left and right to all of that you folks had seen that during a site walk and I think we've had a pretty good going over of all of the background here but I want to give you a sense here's the entirety of the property on a plan and where the positioning of the proposed campground is located here's a blow-up enlargement of just the campsite areas I think important to know Basically, those three zones of frontage along Sand Pond, the southerly area, as we've referenced, no campsites are otherwise there. We do have three campsites up in a central area and then a couple more up in a northerly area, but the predominant placement of campsites here off of this new road and the design of which all been done in accordance with city standards as well as for allowances for your emergency services folks and so forth here again here's that entrance area and a greeting area for the campsite here is the buffering plan so if we have a moment or in need of talking about that we have it here we can talk about that more flycatcher prepared this I presented at the last meeting overall a number of different zones where specific numbers and counts and locations all of these green dots as you can see them represent a plant that was GP GPS located to fit within all other existing vegetation and Taylor can speak to that if need be here later on so here's a plan that represents the driveway area again as well as the intersection of Sand Pond and Country club two roads and the predominant change that we discussed at the last meeting was taking this intersection and making it basically a four-way with through traffic happening here on country club and going on to sand pond ultimately how some road naming may occur renaming may occur city's input that's likely to happen. City engineer comments reflected, in fact, some of our proposed signage currently on the plan. Ultimately, when signs get placed, we'll reflect actual names, but for the moment on our plans, future road names as to be determined by the city. The important pieces here, though, are basically taking the intersection of Country Club 2 into this intersection and making it a stop control and I'm going to show you in a moment one additional change that has happened since the last meeting as it relates to some city staff and water district input because the water district has a larger vehicle that once a month or so makes the movement northbound from Country Club 2 Road going up to Route 4 and we wanted they wanted to have a little bit broader radius than what we currently have and i'll show that to you in a moment secondly the board had asked about the driveway the residential driveway here located on the north side of the entrance we're going to have a stop control there are two existing driveways that come out of this location today serving the property to the north and property to the south here is just another plan that the city engineer had requested showing more details about grading and drainage and that sort of thing And here is the turning movement piece that was specifically asked here by the board and the city engineers have reviewed. So we have the driveway coming out of the property to the north. And, in fact, that driveway today, there's a dash line that represents the edges of the gravel. There will be a subtle little change right where my cursor is located, if you can see that,, to allow the vehicles exiting that driveway, for example, to be able to pull up square to the stop bar, and that way keeping that vehicle out of a potential incoming movement of a vehicle coming off of the road. And similarly, we show the same sort of movement coming from the driveway on the south side. I made reference here just a moment ago about the larger truck, which we understand the district says what we call a WB 50, -foot long, semi-trailer. Once in a while, I'm not sure what they deliver, but it comes up from Country Club 2 Road and wants to make this corner. And so we flattened out that radius just ever so slightly so that truck didn't have to go all the way over to the opposing lane. Again, making a movement that a few times a month and knowing, as I had said previously at the last meeting, traffic volumes on Country Club 2 Road and Sand Pond Road, less than 1,000 vehicles a day, so not much traffic per se. But we did, there's plenty of room to do this, so flattening out that radius seemed to make sense, and as I understand it, the Water District is happy now with that. then here was just a survey of that intersection this goes back a little ways as to plan board comments and staff and city engineer comments about right-of-way making sure we understood what was going on with the right-of-way and I think I pointed out to you at the last meeting we had this survey done by Owen Haskell and also found that the city had been transferred some additional right-of-way area here, which all helps with the redesign here of this intersection. So we're quite happy with how that has all now come to be and happy with the plan in that regard. And here was just a summary. I'm not sure I need to go through this at all, but I had presented this to you at the last meeting, and I think the overall aspect of it is it's been a little bit of a journey, but a good one in that I think a lot of good things have happened out of the exchange of reviews and submissions and so forth. Certainly staff has had a lot of good input and I think that comes from not only Planning Board review and input but community members as well. We hope that we've addressed all the various things that go into making a development like this work successfully for this piece of property. So on that basis I think I can conclude my presentation unless you have any immediate questions, and I know you're probably anxious to get into public hearing. Thank you. [11:06] Speaker A (unidentified): With that, is there a motion from the board to reopen the public hearing? [11:13] Speaker D (unidentified): I move to reopen public hearing. Second. All in favor? [11:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Six-zero. All right. With that said, public hearing will be five minutes per speaker. There is a clock. please be conscious of your time. Is there anyone who would like to speak in favor of this proposal either here or on Zoom? [11:40] Speaker B (unidentified): I have five emails in favor to read after anybody in person. Thank you Jamie. [11:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anyone in opposition who would like to speak either here or on Zoom? [11:55] Speaker D (unidentified): I have five in favor. Okay so you want to [12:02] Speaker B (unidentified): I am going to start by saying I have been batting a cold for a little bit. If I lose my voice, I am going to hand everything to Kyle and have him finish reading. [12:10] Speaker E (unidentified): I would love to do that. [12:14] Speaker B (unidentified): Hello, Sanford Planning Board. Please read this at the next Planning Board meeting in support of the campground. My name is Mark Patterson, one of the owners of Patco Construction here in Sanford. We built nearly all of the homes along Country Club 2 Road that abut the proposed campground, we also built most of the homes that abut the Hootopia campground. I lived in Sanford and Springvale for over 60 years. I graduated from Sanford High School and the University of Maine. I have spent countless hours volunteering in the community and continue to do so. I spent years working on various Chamber of Commerce projects to bring additional businesses and tax income to the community. Our company, Patco Construction, still operates in Sanford. As one of the largest taxpayers in the Sanford community,, we pay in excess of a quarter of a million dollars in real estate taxes to the City of Sanford each year. Projects such as the one proposed will bring new additional tax dollars to the community and business sales and services from the campground patrons with relatively few additional costs to the City of Sanford. The seasonal residents will not increase school expenses, which is one of the largest costs of local government. The concept of taxpayer residents complaining about their tax rate yet opposing commercial growth in their community is incredulous. For decades, I worked with the Siddle family members to carve off subdivisions from the 100 plus acres that make up R15-1 and other parcels along Sand Pond Road. Our company never told any of the families we built homes for that the remaining 100 acres would be used commercially or for future development. I'm sorry, remaining 100 acres wouldn't be used commercially or for future development. In fact, the Siddle family was clear to me that they wanted use of the land to stay flexible, and that included commercial uses like campgrounds. If the current landowner wanted to put residential homes on the land, the abutters might be opposing a 50-plus lot subdivision, with each home having potentially two accessory dwelling units. That would be a total of 150 or more families living around the pond year-round. The setback on houses could potentially be only 15 feet from the property line, and that would not be much of a buffer. My guess is that some of the builders here tonight would be against a development like that as well. Maybe they're against anything built on this land that doesn't belong to them. As real estate developers, we deal with opposition often. Nimbism, not in my backyard, is an unfortunate challenge for growth in all of Maine communities. The people opposing this proposed campground need to carefully consider the alternative uses of this land. A cramped ground will be an asset to the City of Sanford, noise pollution, site pollution, air pollution, increased crime, dangerous intersections, etc. are all just fabricated excuses to stop something that is going to bring excitement and joy to the Sanford community. I'm hoping the Planning Board looks past this nimbyism and sees the value this business could bring to Sanford. Thank you for your time and consideration. Warm Regards, Mark Pattison. Good evening, members of the Planning Board and fellow Sanford residents. My name is Margaret. My name is Margaret. I'm 25 years old, and Sand Pond has been my home my entire life. My parents and I are among the few families who have lived here year-round, experiencing its beauty through every season. I understand that some of their neighbors closest to the proposed campground have concerns about what this development might bring. during. Change can be uncomfortable, and I recognize that people want to protect the tranquility and character of the place they vacation and find peace. However, I ask that you consider another perspective. As a child, I spent my summers swimming, playing outside and enjoying campfires with family and friends. There was laughter, noise and occasionally campfire smoke blown in my face. I never considered these things pollution. They were part of being outdoors, spending time with people I loved and creating memories I cherish to this day. Some of my fondest childhood memories are playing with my neighbors' children and grandchildren. From my parents' deck, we could see the campground across the pond. We watched families doing exactly what we were doing, swimming during the day and gathering around campfires at night, and enjoying their summers together. Those sights and sounds never made me love Sand Pond area any less. They were part of what made it special. Even this past summer, hearing families laughing, children playing, and neighbors enjoying the waterfront reminded me of why I chose to stay in Sanford. I want to live in a community where families can enjoy the outdoors and children can make the same wonderful memories I did. I believe protecting Sand Pond and allowing people to enjoy it can go hand in hand. Responsible development, environmental protection, and appropriate safeguards are important, as are the concerns of our neighbors. But we must also consider the opportunities this project presents for the greater Sanford community. community. My family and I are working to develop a high-end, glamping resort that will allow visitors to experience Maine outdoors while bringing additional visitors and economic activity to Sanford. This project is about more than a campground. It is about creating a place where families reconnect, children experience nature, and visitors discover everything our community has to offer. Members of the Planning Board, I ask that you consider not only what some fear they might lose, but also what our community stands to gain. We have an opportunity to welcome families, support local businesses, and contribute to Sanford's future while sharing the beauty of Sand Pond responsibly. I believe Sanford deserves that opportunity. Our city has tremendous untapped potential, and projects like this can help strengthen its reputation, attract visitors, and create new economic opportunities. We can show people that Sanford is a place worth visiting, investing in, and being proud of. I hope you will consider not only what this project means for Sand Pond, but what it could mean for the future of Sanford. Thank you for your time and consideration. Please read this at the next Planning Board meeting for the Sand Pond Shores Campground on R15-1. Good evening, Sanford Planning Board and residents around Sand Pond. Thank you for letting me share a few words tonight. For over 20 years, I have enjoyed summers on Sand Pond, so much so that one summer I took a job at Hootopia Campground across the pond from my parents' house in order to spend more time in Sanford. I learned firsthand how different areas of campground operate in order to create positive experiences. The memories of Hutopia vacationers will probably last a lifetime for those who visited Sanford that summer. Prior to Hutopia, the land was being used by Sand Pond Campground. My sister and I would sleep outside in a tent and listen to the karaoke coming from the guests across the lake. Margaret and I laughed at some of the singers as we lied there in our sleeping bags. We couldn't sleep due to the excitement of staying up as late as we wanted. Today, I can appreciate anyone who can stand up in front of a crowd and sing, I'd be scared to death. I remember listening as a small child to Shirley and Pat Siddle when they visited our home. At one time, their father, Cecil, owned all the property on Siddle Road. Shirley and Pat also told stories about the campground and the locals who would camp across the water. water. Over time, more and more shoreland was developed and private homes started to surround the campground. I wish the new neighbors had left their shorefront vegetated as Pat and Shirley's father had and my parents did. Today, the Department of Environmental Protection doesn't allow this behavior. As a supporter of the proposed campground, I don't think it is right for the neighbors to keep drumming up excuses on why the campground should be stopped. Whether it's complaints about air pollution from campfires, air pollution from generators, fears of increased litter, noise from campers having a good time, threats over right title and interest, or dangerous intersections. These campground opposers are simply trying to stop something from going in their backyard. If anything, my parents' behavior of leaving buffers in place exemplifies responsible cohabitation with wildlife on the waterfront. Dear Planning Board, please don't be afraid of the neighbors and approve this campground. Thank you for your time. Best regards, Margaret Pattison. Hello, Sanford Planning Board. Please read this at the next Planning Board meeting in support of the campground. Good evening, Sanford Planning Board. My name is Thomas, and I live near the end of Citter Road on Sand Pond in Sanford. This time of year, many of the property owners around the pond have already left for the season. Some return to Kennebunk, Wells, and York, while others head back to their homes out of state. Unlike many seasonal residents, my wife and I live here year-round, and we enjoy everything the area has to offer. I'm an outdoorsman, and I believe a campground is a great fit for a community like Sanford. It encourages people to get outside, enjoy nature, and experience the recreational opportunities our area has to offer. It can also bring additional visitors and businesses to our city. Living on Sand Pond year-round gives me a different perspective on the activities that take place around the pond. We experience everything from generators and outdoor lighting to occasional late-night noise and summer fireworks. These are simply some of the things that come with living in a recreational area. I understand that some residents have concerns about the proposed campground, and I respect everyone that has a right to express their opinions. However, I also think it's important to recognize that a professionally managed campground has the ability to establish rules, address guest concerns, and maintain expectations for those using the property. For example, if there were an issue with a campground guest, there would be a manager or someone responsible who could be contacted to address it. I believe that level of oversight can be a positive thing for the surrounding community. I also think we should consider the recreational value of Sand Pond and the surrounding area. Every summer, residents and visitors enjoy the pond in many different ways. We should continue looking for opportunities to allow people to enjoy these natural resources by respecting and protecting them. Sand Pond is an important part of Sanford and I believe we should look at this proposal with an open mind. A campground can provide outdoor recreation, support local businesses, and bring something positive to our community. As someone who lives here year-round and enjoys the outdoors, I believe the proposed campground could be a great addition to Sanford and a good neighbor to the surrounding properties. Thank you for the time and for considering my support of this project, Thomas. Members of the Planning Board, my name is Bob. Having lived in Sanford for many years, I have always appreciated the value of our land and the importance of making good decisions about how it is used. I believe a thoughtfully designed campground is one of the better uses for this property. Compared to a largescale solar farm or housing development, a campground allows much of the land to remain open and natural. It preserves trees, wildlife, and the sounds of nature while introducing a reasonable amount of human activity. I also believe there is something special about giving families the opportunities to enjoy the outdoors as it was intended. Children playing outside, families gathering around campfires, and people enjoying the water and trails are part of what makes Maine special. I understand that change can bring concerns, but I believe this proposal strikes a good balance between responsible land use, economic opportunity, and preserving the natural character of the property. I also believe this project will bring meaningful revenue to the City of Sanford, while introducing a high quality, thoughtfully developed destination that can attract visitors, support local businesses, and help strengthen the City's reputation as a place for investment, recreation, and tourism. I respectively encourage the planning board to support this project and allow future generations to enjoy this beautiful piece of land. Sincerely, Bob. Thank [24:17] Speaker A (unidentified): you, Jamie. With that, is there anyone here or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this project? Please state your name and address. [24:33] Speaker B (unidentified): The name is Paul Fritchie, 43 Sandpond Road, since 1988. These are my comments and the comments on behalf of the Sandpond Association. Hopefully you have received and read a seven-page written document, which we submitted earlier in the week. I'll try to summarize that within the five minutes. First, on the issue of the entranceway. As you know by the ordinance, it's supposed to be safe and convenient. There's been now five or six drafts. I believe that Engineer Hill has said it's safe. However, there are still substantial concerns among the neighbors. They don't really understand the plan, it has been changed so many times, and they are absolutely convinced that it is nowhere close to being convenient. So the request is to have the planning board come back along with the neighbors and take another look at this, because they have real serious concerns about that. The next issue I wanted to talk about was buffering. As you know, the ordinance was a carefully crafted compromise at the City Council level between setbacks and buffering. Many of us wanted a much larger setback, but the City Council decided 75 feet. But they said there would be a 50-foot vegetated buffering that was a minimum of 8 feet high and 50 feet in depth. depth. This contrasts with several of the other ordinances dealing with setbacks or buffering. There is one about outdoor storage of machinery and equipment that requires it to be screened, without defining what that means, from view of any public street. There is another one that deals with service and storage areas. That is to be screened and there is to be buffering when there is a transition from one zone to the other. My point is that only when you get to the buffering for campgrounds is there anything specific. And it's very, clear it has to be 50 feet in width, at least 8 feet high. And we don't think that the flycatcher proposal approaches it from that direction. I realize that some of you may say that 's too much, that's too expensive. You could make do with less, but that is not what the City Ordinance said. You really have to, as you have said to all of us, follow what the City Ordinances say. We don't think it measures up. We are also going to have a number of individual members who are going to speak about the buffering near their particular properties. One of them who may not be here is the Mumney family. family, they have the area that you saw across Siddle Road, but they also have one on the side facing the north parcel. I don't think that's been addressed. Then we're also going to have a member who's going to talk about water quality. He's affiliated with the Lake Stewards. He's been certified as a water quality tester. He's going to have some, we hope, will be a persuasive and also brief presentation that will convince you that a little more water quality testing is appropriate. We also have a couple of minor points before my final one. One deals with financial and technical capacity. As at least one of the members has stated, the Board must find a financial capacity. My understanding is this proposal has four phases. The letter from Norway Savings, which is conclusory, says that there is enough financing for Phase 1. You don't even know if that is true because you don't know how much Phase 1 is going to cost. It says nothing about Phases 2, 3 and 4. So if you were to approve it, you only have enough information to approve it for the first of the four parts of this proposal. Lastly, to wrap up my five minutes, in addition to what we have already said, if you look at several of the ordinances that have more [Speaker F (unidentified): broader] policies, the Shoreland Zone says you are to maintain a safe and helpful condition and conserve natural beauty. The General Zoning says you are to promote health, safety and general welfare, conserve and stabilize the value of property, encourage the most appropriate use of land. The rural residential zone says you promote high quality rural residential environment while maintaining the rural character of these areas. Campgrounds are perfectly fine, but not in this location in the middle of a business. [29:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So thank you very much, and we'll set it. Thank you. Thank you. All right, is there anyone else who would like to speak in opposition to the project good [29:52] Speaker G (unidentified): evening my name is Steve Weiner and I live at [address] to Road I've been there for 20 years and I'm going to show you four videos of four homes that are not included in the buffer plan but they should be the existing vegetation that is there now does not provide a visual or noise barrier that is required by the code the homes right now are exposed to the campsites that are going to be developed next to them and the developer does not plan to add vegetation buffer but it is needed so if you could play the four videos you will see for yourself that the vegetation is lacking right now Ben could you pull up [30:44] Speaker B (unidentified): my screen please and [30:48] Speaker G (unidentified): settle road i'm going to walk quickly to their property line and this is property line is marked by this white fence and i'm going to show you how there is you can see into the woods there you can see if you look very carefully the white fence which you can just barely make it out in the distance there that is 188 or about 180 feet and you can see wide open there's virtually no buffer here for well into the woods and that's where campsite 39 is planned i'm going to walk the walk the border here and as i do you're going to see there is no buffer as you look down through here there's no natural buffer that is required by code you can see well into the woods all there are is tree trunks but no natural vegetation along here at all this does not meet code this is sandy point road and i'm going to show you first of all this is the property line marked by the white fence and i'm going to show you a view into the forest here and as you can see there's a clear view into it easily into 75 feet into the forest and beyond In fact, you can see, you can make out the Raz's house, which is 180 feet across the forest. So there is no natural vegetation at all that forms a buffer between this property line and campsite 40, which is proposed by the developer. developer and the developer has not planned any new buffer in this area, none whatsoever. So lack of vegetation, no planned buffer at all in this area. I think this is a deficiency that needs to be addressed. This is Joe Hardy's place on the pond. There you can see his white fence marks his property line and I'm going to show you a view into the woods where you can see there's very little natural vegetation and we can see clearly into the woods there is no natural vegetation which serves as a visual or sound barrier. Right now there is no plan to put any here by the developer. If you look carefully you can see a little bluish color that is the next house that's approximately i think that's 200 feet so clearly where the camp site 20 is 20 feet excuse me 75 feet into the woods that is clearly visible so we need some more plantings in here to form a barrier for this property i'll walk this way there's a nice pine here which does provide a nice barrier but then after we get through here again there's a wide open this is 49 Sittle Road and I'm going to do a quick walk through here so you can see the lack of existing vegetation that exists here similar to other areas that I've shown there you can see we have some nice tree trunks, but that's about all we have at this property, similar to the other three that I've shown you. No existing vegetation to serve as a sound or visual barrier for this property. It needs something here, nothing. Our [45:18] Speaker H (unidentified): camp is not built for year-round occupancy. We are at our camp for the summer and enjoy the outdoors. We have owned on Sand Pond for over 10 years and want to keep the property in our family for many years to come. Our heirs have expressed a concern with the lack of buffering and how that might negatively influence their decision to build a new home on the property next to a campground. I have expressed concerns over buffering along our property line from the pond and all along the fence line across Siddle Road and out towards Sanpon Road. This area was not part of the applicant-directed site visit. The applicant proposes campground amenities 50 feet from our property line. Will there be quiet hours for the campground amenities in this area? Will there be increased lighting in this area for the amenities? Flycatch's report does not adequately address a 58-foot-high buffering plan to cover the added noise, lighting, and security in this area. I'm still very concerned about the safety of the proposed entrance. The consultant's comments, quote-unquote, helps reduce vehicle trespass onto opposing lane when making the movement. I'm not a lawyer, but that doesn't seem to meet the requirements of the ordinance. I'm also not a traffic engineer, but in watching the applicant's animated video, there were a few turns that trespassed into oncoming traffic. The consultant at the last meeting indicated that would be okay since there wasn't a lot of traffic. Not sure if that is a reason for approving an unsafe entrance. Supposedly, this proposed campground will bring substantial revenue to the Sanford. Has anyone looked at the revenue stream for the local small businesses to see if there was a positive impact from Hatopia guests over the last several years that they operated? Or do they spend the money at the oceanfront? Thank you very much for your time and consideration with this proposal. Eileen Moroney and Barbara Purvis, we live at [address], we have property at 83 Citadel Road. [47:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Is there anyone else in the room or on Zoom who'd like to speak in opposition to the project? Please come up to the mic. Thank you [48:10] Speaker C (unidentified): for the opportunity to speak. My name is Guy Chabot. I live at number nine Sand Pond Road in Sanford, Maine. I've been a resident of Maine for over 33 years. I'm a decorated combat veteran. I'm a lieutenant colonel retired. I've deployed all over the world. I feel that's important to tell you because I'm just going to keep this on a personal level. A lot of the comments that were read at the beginning are frankly disparaging. You know, we're not demons, the people who are opposing this campground. And, you know, I hear the Pattersons talk about, you know, NIMBYism. It's all over their YouTube videos as well. Some type of disparaging comment that we're somehow abnormal that we don't want a campground in our backyard I don't and we don't that's just basically it and if it is approved it should meet the ordinances that have been set up by the by the town and you know I'm certain I can't really speak for you but I'm I'm certain that if you were in my situation, you probably wouldn't like having a campground in your backyard either. Earlier, somebody mentioned something about, oh, well, you wouldn't want a solar farm back there. Well, we all know that there is a deed restriction for a solar farm back there anyway. So that's a false flag. And even to bring that up, again, is just tainting the conversation. I think it's charming that the Patterson girls got to grow up and, you know, play footsie in their sleeping bags and listen to the campers and all that, and that's all great and fine, but it has nothing to do with the fact that we're talking about squeezing a business that is literally squeezed into the middle of a residential neighborhood. And again, yes, I know we don't own that land back there. That's the Pattersons' land. I mean, they can do really whatever they want with that within their rights. I recognize that. And somebody said in a threatening way, well, you wouldn't want 50 houses back there. Well, you know what? 50 houses would actually be better, to be honest with you, because you'd have more stability. Pattersons would probably make a whole hell of a lot more money turning that land over. Again, I just don't appreciate the characterization that the people that are opposing the campground are somehow evil or bad or, you know, any other type of characterization. I've also heard several times, oh, well, you know, change is good. Don't be afraid of change. I mean, come on. We're all adults here. I mean, we all know that things change. Nothing stays the same. Look at the town of Sanford. It's not the same as it was 20 years ago in a positive way. It's actually a better place, more businesses and whatnot, and change is good, but not to the detriment of the people who live in that area. You know, there's been no outreach whatsoever from Patterson, not that it was going to change anything, but no outreach whatsoever. or hey, you know, let's kind of talk as a group, or can we make this better, or nothing like that whatsoever. In fact, the very first meeting that took place here three and a half years ago with Mr. Bushy, you know, we got letters, hey, there's something going on here. The Pattersons weren't even here for that. They've never really faced any of us in person. So again, I just want to talk to you guys on a personal level. We're not demons. We don't want a campground in the backyard. yard. That's true. If it does, there's 30, at least 30, ordinances here that aren't being met. And I'll just close in the last 40 seconds about the buffer. In our own section 280.2-2, The definition of a buffer area is to screen the adjoining properties from noise, dust, visibility, and glare. And you saw the videos. You can look at my own backyard. You can look at Holly's backyard. There is no 50-foot, 8-foot-high vegetated buffer that needs to go in prior to any consideration for the campground. Thank you for your time. [53:05] Speaker A (unidentified): is there anyone else here or on zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this project [53:20] Speaker I (unidentified): good evening my name is holly bennett and i am neighbors with guy and both guy and i are year-round residents that moved into that area over almost 30 years ago i also don't appreciate how we are being portrayed as nimbies or part-timers or people who don't contribute to our community. Guy and I are the gatekeepers to that park and when I purchased my home from Mark Patterson he and I had a conversation about where to put our house so that it would be least impacted by the potential road that would be built there because of the development that would happen behind my house. Therefore, we purposefully moved our house as far to the other side that zoning would allow so that we would be away from that intersection. So I don't, I detest the conversation that Mark Patterson said that we would, we didn't, we were, there could be development that would be worse than what we had expected. We expected it. We want it to be safe and we want it to be buffered I was told and it is in my deed that I'm not allowed to have a business I can't put a trailer I can't put up a sign I can't clear cut my land but another person can come in a rural residential zone and put a community pool, a barn, and a store only because it's called a campground? If it wasn't called a campground, you could put none of those things there. I don't understand how that works, and I don't feel it's appropriate in our neighborhood. I also agree with Guy that there could be houses there of neighbors who my children, three of them, who grew up here also and camped and snuggled and lived in a hammock in my backyard, would not mind being friends with. I do oppose campers, mobile homes, trailers going back and forth on my little road where I have to take a left out of my driveway in an area that you've already determined is not safe. I would love to know how I'm going to get my large vehicles out of my driveway at that intersection safely by pulling a left. Who's plowing that road if it's not even a winter campground? These are issues that I have as a community member of over 30 years that raised my children here. They're not addressed in Steve Bush's plan. They have redrawn that intersection section multiple times. It is still not safe. There is no buffer outside of my house. I can see straight through to Guy's house. Not that I mind. I like Guy. But there is no buffer. Mark and Mike cut it down. I'm a Gen Xer. I love change. It's my generation. I have three world traveling children. Believe me, I got change. I'm an educator. I know change. What is happening in our neighborhood is not appropriate change. If you noticed, the letters that you read in were only from Mike's family members. The entire neighborhood around him does not approve of what's happening. We don't disapprove of change. We don't disapprove of development. element. We want our community to be stronger. We want it done according to what the zoning ordinances allow. [57:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this project? [57:42] Speaker F (unidentified): Before you start the clock, I've got a couple housekeeping things, please. One, I want to know if the board members have received the letter that I submitted. [57:52] Speaker A (unidentified): My have that in your packet? They are in the packet. Yes. [57:58] Speaker F (unidentified): You have that. And secondly, I submitted some photos, and I don't, I asked the gentleman up back, and he said you would have provided me access to those here before we get underway. Can I know how to get access to them? I believe [58:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Jamie's working on it right now. [58:18] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm sorry, what was your name? Joe Hardy. Joe Hardy, yep. [58:23] Speaker F (unidentified): They were submitted as a as a cluster to Michaela and she was going to get them available to me Ben [58:35] Speaker B (unidentified): can you pull up my screen please yeah [58:41] Speaker F (unidentified): you have them here we're gonna go and how can I could control by pushing something here no I'm controlling oh you'll do it okay that's fine just tell me what to do thank you my name again is Joe Hardy I live in Wells and I have property at 31 Sidall Road I'm going to address my remarks solely regarding the buffer. I won't repeat all the things that have been said so far. But I want to first begin by saying the Sandpond Shores and Flycatcher have proposed a totally inadequate plan. And you might ask, well, does Mr. Hardy think he has a better idea or qualified to promote a better plan? That's a fair question and I'll answer it this way. As a soil chemist, I probably know things that they do not know about sandpond soils. And as a consulting team that has undoubtedly biologists on it, they probably know some things that I don't know. But there's one thing that I am pretty certain about. I will bet that not a single member of the flycatcher team has the practical experience of managing a 200-acre forest for a 50-year period. I do. And there are a lot of things that I know about trees and how they grow that I'll share in a few minutes with you. My approach is to use evergreen trees, especially pine trees, white pine trees. They provide a much thicker screen than deciduous trees, and specifically thickly planted white pines and not pitch pine or red pines. They prefer the sandy soils around Sand Pond, and I know that as a practical matter because when I was a child I helped my father plant a number of white pines, and today they are large, mature pines that are massive, wonderful trees. So it's a suitable place for white pines. I want to show you some of the photos here because they address the question of sunshine. Sunlight is imperative for full thick growth of pines and other evergreens. They provide, well let me start with this one first of all. These are some pines that are growing in my backyard. They're thin, they're scraggly because they are growing under a canopy of hardwoods. But whether they're under a canopy of hardwoods or softwoods, they will not grow into anything that resembles a screen. And if you look at the flycatcher proposal, the placement of all those trees are under a canopy of existing trees. They will not produce an adequate screen, especially with the limited numbers that have been offered. If you could go to the next one, Jamie. Here's some pines that have grown up near my house along the road they have some fullness of texture of act as a screen and this is with natural growth natural seating with limited sunshine go ahead here's another one that is even better it's not full sunshine and this is a natural growth the next one please I think that's not the next one. Did you skip one or not? All right, that's the one I wanted to go to next. Here's some pine trees along Route 4 between North Borough and Sanford. Extremely thick growth, full sunshine. This is natural seeding. Now, that would be ideal at Sand Pond along the Sidall Road and other boundaries, but it's not possible because of the existing trees. You can't get that, and if you could, you would need to maintain it, because when you don't maintain it, gets thinner at the bottom. That's, we go to the next one Jamie. Well, let's further ahead. You've got one that we skipped over. Yeah, that one. And we missed it again. Try again, please. Down. Keep going. No, this, yeah,, that one right there. What happens is in the natural succession of most species, there's a thinning out at the near ground level. That can be avoided if there's a maintenance program. If you can top these trees off, that's basically you're cutting the terminal bud and keeping them to about seven or eight or nine feet in growth. If you don't do that, they will thin out automatically. Now I wanna go to the next one. Oh, not that one, the one that we skipped over. There we go, there we go. That was an opening down the road from my house. It was, it came back as old fields do, it's called old field succession. It came back thickly in pine trees and was a screen for the house that you can see in the background for a while. And then it was allowed to grow. This is 45 years later. There's absolutely no buffer. I used up a little by time and explanation can I continue with these please wrap [1:04:00] Speaker A (unidentified): it up pardon me please wrap it up yes I will no I mean like can I go to the last [1:04:07] Speaker F (unidentified): picture please sorry we I took some time to get things clarified I ought you want [1:04:13] Speaker A (unidentified): to give me 30 seconds you did not start the clock until you stated your name so we see the final I have an example if we allow you more than five minutes we have to allow everyone more than five minutes. I'm the last person here. It does not matter because then we have to let everyone else go again. We cannot let people speak. I show the [1:04:33] Speaker F (unidentified): last picture as a screen. It could be used as a model. Could you please sit down? And you're not allowing me to show it. You're not giving me the respect that I do for an extra 20 seconds to show that picture that would be instructive to you guys to learn something about forced succession session, and what is an adequate buffer, and what is not. I have that experience, and you are denying me the opportunity. [1:05:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anyone else in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this project? Is there anyone? Was there anyone on Zoom? Nope. Is it? Yeah. Is that Neil? Yeah, this is [1:05:25] Speaker J (unidentified): Neil from 57 Sidall Road. We have an issue with the buffer as well. I'd like to see that last slide, please from the gentleman who is just there in my five minutes. Could you show that for me please? I'd like to see what an adequate screen looks like because we have an issue that behind our camp has been clear-cut so there is no adequate buffer but I'd love to see. There we go. Thank you. Yeah [Speaker K (unidentified): that looks] looks like something that you can't see through. So appreciate you. That's all I have. All right. [1:06:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Is there anyone else either in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to the project? Is there anyone in the room or on Zoom who would like to ask a general question or make a comment? I believe Clifford. I'll ask one more time. Is there anyone on Zoom? There we go. All right, Clifford. [1:06:46] Speaker K (unidentified): Good. Thanks. So my name is Cliff Batkirk, and I live at [address] since about 2004. I'm a member of the Sandpon Association, and I will just say that I agree with all statements given here by the association. So my comments this evening are related to expanding the current water quality testing program beyond what is currently conducted by Hotopia. So in 2019, we were concerned about the impact on a small 30-acre pond when Hotopia sought approval to replace the old sandpond campground, which was a mix of RVs and mobile homes, stuff like that. Apparently as a condition of the planning board approval, Atobia established an annual water quality testing program to ensure their clients and all the residents of Sand Pond can enjoy the benefits of a healthy Sand Pond. Now we're on the doorstep of another large campground proposed by Sand Pond. I'm gonna share a graphic here so you probably won't see me for a while, just so you can kind of follow along. My wife and I are the new Lake Stewards of Maine Volunteer Lake Water Quality Monitors. We perform one test only for water clarity, twice a month for five months over the season. Our test results are sent to LSM at the end of the season. From what LSM says, they have over 40 years of data on Sand Pond. So there probably were people doing this before I was. Our testing is separate from the annual water quality testing done for Hotopia by a third party. They do a very comprehensive set of tests. These two campgrounds are very different in at least two aspects, which is why expanding water quality testing by San Juan Shores should be required at the north end of the pond. So let me talk about vehicles. Hotopia does not allow vehicles at any campsite or on any of the roads or paths within the individual campsite areas. They provide a parking area that's in a non-invasive location away from the pond and the campsites. Sand Pond Shores, because it's an RV park, will by default, each campsite will have at least one vehicle. Some of them will be motorized, some of them are towed campers, and they're going to be located on impermeable paths. Water access. Autopia water access for guests is distributed along the length of their shoreline, including a general beach swimming area for all campers. You can see that on the left where it says campground. This helps to disperse the effects of any potential contaminants that might be carried by swimmers across the broad length of the shoreline. In Sand Pond Shores configuration, there's a signal designated area at the northeast end of the pond for all swimmers to use. This crowds all their guests into a small, shallow area of the lake, which could potentially concentrate contaminants that might be carried by swimmers. San Pond is a 30-acre pond, has a glacially slow washout rate, which means that only 0.3 water exchanges per year occur. So contaminants could sit on the lake bottom for a long time before being flushed out naturally. So in an effort to try to compare these two campsites, the impacts of the two recreational facilities, I contacted the people that I know at Lake Sewards of Maine, which is certified by the DEP as an authoritative water quality testing lake health management program. And this is what they recommend. Continue with the annual baseline testing with a focus on sampling, especially near the primary swimming areas. This would be for San Juan Shores or Hotopia. This is already in place for Hotopia. You can see the three sites at the bottom, Station 1, 2, and 3. Those are the Hotopia test sites. And the one on the left is next to their swimming area. What I'm asking for is two more additional sites to be added for sandpond shores at 4 and 5. This one here would be a control site, and this would be a targeted measurement site. annual testing provides an effective check of watershed and stormwater management systems to ensure that petroleum-based products cleaning fluids that come from pads and roads are not reaching the pond in addition they recommend E. coli sampling should be added and prioritized anywhere there is a high concentration of people swimming as in the case of San Juan onshore or swim area at the northeast end of the pond. [1:11:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Time. Really? Yep. Okay. Sorry. [1:12:03] Speaker K (unidentified): Is it okay if I submit the rest of my comments in a document to Michaela to have them put into the packet? [1:12:14] Speaker L (unidentified): This packet's closed. Yeah. Oh, okay. Fine. [1:12:22] Speaker K (unidentified): Essentially, I was going to ask you to make this a condition of approval that they do water quality testing. Thank you. Thank you. Is there [1:12:33] Speaker A (unidentified): anyone else in the room or on Zoom who would like to ask a question or make a general comment? With that, I declare the public. Good evening. [1:12:52] Speaker M (unidentified): My name is Ann Babkirk. You just met my husband. husband. We live at [address] in a year-round house for the past 22 years. I'm a member of the Sand Pond Association. Our house is the third waterfront lot from Hatopia at the south end of the pond. In the first two seasons of Hatopia's operation, we experienced problems with their campers trespassing on and damaging privately owned floats that were nowhere near the swimming area. We don't own a float, but we had people fishing off our dock. It wasn't until complaints were lodged that Hotopia responded and installed two floats for the sole use of their campers. The configuration of the proposed campground at San Ponchures is very unorthodox. Where most campgrounds may have a budding private property around the perimeter, such as Zootopia. In this proposal, as you know, there are several properties captive between the campsites and the shores of Sand Pond. They are bordered by campground property on three sides and the pond on the fourth. My concern is that campers will feel free to cut through private property, even if posted, especially since the campsites in the early phases will be quite a distance from the proposed dock site in hopes of heading off confrontations if the board chooses to approve the proposal I think it is reasonable to require that a campground welcome letter or registration document of some sort include a notification that all the residences along sand pond along Siddle Road are private property and the campers are to refrain from trespassing on these properties including floats and docks or otherwise invading the privacy of these neighbors. Thank you for your attention and consideration of this request. [1:14:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Is there anyone in the room or on Zoom who would like to ask a question or make a general comment? With that I declare the public hearing closed. is there any staff comments no [1:15:16] Speaker N (unidentified): new comments no all right is [1:15:27] Speaker A (unidentified): there any discussion on the road entrance Matt apologize no [1:15:40] Speaker N (unidentified): the two remaining items that we were waiting on last time was the turning movements coming out of the driveway and then the notes associated with the road naming and those have been taken care of on the on the latest revisions all the turning movements have been shown as mr bushey showed and then the notes were revised to leave it kind of open [1:16:07] Speaker A (unidentified): ended with the road naming thank you matt all right i'll open up to the board previously we've had issues with entrance and buffering and then so does this board have any other concerns [1:16:29] Speaker J (unidentified): Will say it was interesting from one of the residents who said who will Manage the snow clearance for their properties. I didn't even think of that till today Till was brought up, so how will that get resolved? [1:16:44] Speaker A (unidentified): And I didn't catch that time road maintenance or they at least the entrance maintenance who is responsible [1:16:53] Speaker B (unidentified): That would depend on how the easements are written I don't know that answer. I don't know how their easements are written. [1:17:01] Speaker J (unidentified): So it's, all right, and that's fair. I just think, I don't know how it gets to the level of address, but it is a fair concern that we didn't discuss. [1:17:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Who's maintaining it now? [1:17:14] Speaker A (unidentified): That was my question. I don't know. [1:17:20] Speaker J (unidentified): Right, so it's not used. Is that fair? No, go ahead. If it's not used and then we're creating something, then we have to create. [1:17:28] Speaker A (unidentified): It is being used as a shared driveway that currently exits there. So the two shared driveways have to plow their respective driveways. This doesn't change except now there's a third road going further. I mean, the entrances still have to be plowed out. Got it. [1:17:46] Speaker J (unidentified): And then since it's a town road? Correct. So then they would have to at least come in and make sure it's plowed to their private driveway? [1:17:57] Speaker A (unidentified): No,, no. Sorry, the Sand Pond Road. or whatever it will be named, is the public road. This is a private access. Any concerns with the entrance on the board? [1:18:22] Speaker E (unidentified): The main question has been safety, and I've heard the residents talk about they're worried about the safety. Matt, do you have any worries about the safety of this new project, the road, the modifications to the road? [1:18:43] Speaker N (unidentified): I think it would be probably more appropriate for Mr. Bushy and his design. I could certainly chime in. [1:18:53] Speaker E (unidentified): We're really looking for your opinion of either you or probably Matt Hill. [1:18:59] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, so in terms of safety when it comes to intersections or any entrance, sight distance certainly comes into play, which has been provided on the plans. And it's adequate for the speed limit and the conditions. The other thing that comes into play is when it comes to an intersection, this design, I would say, is an improvement in terms of the way that the intersection is as it exists this today, the skew angle, so how the angle that the roads come together is not 90. That's the ideal situation with an intersection, just because you've got the best sight distance and viewing angles, basically. So this design would improve on that condition. So based on that, the skew angle change and the available sight distance, those check some major boxes when it comes to safety. [1:20:19] Speaker D (unidentified): That answers my question. Sure. So just to add to that, Matt Hilde also provided us a memo on November 2nd stating that and he provided many memos beforehand weighing out all these concerns. concerns. This addresses all the remaining concerns regarding the intersection design and the turning templates demonstrate adequate access for the expected design vehicles and proposed signage. He goes on to talk about that. So, I'm satisfied with that valuation from the cities. [1:20:52] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I just wanted to hear it. Yeah. [1:20:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I think for me, before, you know, hearing that it's better, that's all well and good but we have to actually it has to be safe you know like we need a determination that it is in fact safe it can't just be better because better can still not be safe so then I think that's what we were looking for determination all right buffering yep [1:21:26] Speaker O (unidentified): Lenny I wonder if we could just ask the applicant or person representing the applicant just to speak with respect to of the four properties that we saw pictures of. Maybe if I could just, it's hard for me to visualize what it looks like. I don't know if anybody wants to chime in on that. Is the buffer inadequate for the properties that we saw? I just need to hear another opinion on that. [1:21:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Who would you like, Mr. Bushy, Flycatcher? [1:21:56] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, I guess if Mr. Bushy could speak, I don't know if Mr. Bushy wants to speak to that or if there's somebody from Flycatcher on here that wants to speak to that. [1:22:04] Speaker A (unidentified): So if you would like to respond. [1:22:11] Speaker C (unidentified): For the record, Steve Bushey again, LJP. So the imagery that we saw, I couldn't tell necessarily the day. I would expect that it was probably taken in the last week or so, given color and all that sort of thing. I do recall as we had our site walk that we had looked at, I believe, all of those various areas. And at the time of the site walk, which I think was in July or so, had the benefit of, you know, summertime type coverage. With all of our discussions that we've had, none of those areas were pointed out as being specifically a concern relative to the buffering pieces. So I'll go on the side of when we observed all of those areas and looked at them, the board, and your final judgment, so to speak, of the buffer pieces, to a certain extent, felt comfortable with that. Now, we had retained Flycatcher to come in based on what we did here as to the areas that were more concerning. And along Siddle Road, certainly, there was a number of spots there. Our plan has over 200 new plantings being installed there. Now, the question as to whether what type of plant, I will fall on Flycatcher's recommendations and professional judgment. As I said earlier, I do have the Flycatcher representative here if you're interested in talking about those specifics. I appreciate that folks have lots of history and understanding and background in those sorts of things. all I can offer as the engineer on this side and not necessarily the landscaping person, we retain somebody to make good calls on that, certainly to address, I think, the comments that we heard from you folks. So we felt we brought a really solid plan back to you with Flycatcher spending a number of hours out there with GPS equipment, locating existing trees, locating the spots where new vegetation should be planted to really improve the buffers, and that's what we've presented to you. So with respect to those four specific sites, none of those seemed to jump out when we had our site walk, and so I can't really speak to anything more to those. They're all areas that have plenty of separation via the setback from the adjoining properties,, let alone having the 50-foot buffer. It seemed that the buffers were more of a concern where we had Siddle Road, because Siddle Road takes up some of that 75-foot setback, and so we wanted to assure that what was left within the 50 feet was strong, and that is what we provided to you. Hopefully that addresses some, and like I said, if you want to talk to Taylor, we can do that. [1:25:07] Speaker L (unidentified): Plant scrub pine from—remove scrub pine from his property and plant them in this area? [1:25:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Could we do—is that a— I'm sorry. [1:25:19] Speaker D (unidentified): What's he— Scrub oak. Scrub oak. Scrub oak. [1:25:22] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah. So if those fail— [1:25:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Have to replant them. [1:25:26] Speaker L (unidentified): They'll have to replant them. [1:25:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Yep. For the first two years. [1:25:33] Speaker L (unidentified): And maintain them for the first— Yep. [1:25:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, so this comes back to, for me, Joe and I actually have a lot in common in our opinions on this, and I have been saying all along that this property is very difficult to buffer because there are so many mature trees and there is no appetite to allow for the tall trees to be cut because everyone keeps going back to this 8-foot tall. Everything must be 8-foot tall, and that is not a buffer. It is supposed to be a mixture. The eight-foot tall, when we had this discussion, was to prevent grass from being determined as a vegetation. We put a number in there, because grass is a vegetation. So the buffer has to at least be eight feet tall. Not everything has to be eight feet tall. all. So I have, I struggle with this because when we went there, I expected that the landowner had cut and cleared everything. I kind of wish he had, you know, five years ago because we wouldn't even be having this discussion on the buffer, but he hasn't. It's natural and we're literally asking him to go above and beyond what is already there naturally without being able to cut the buffer down that exists currently I don't know how we get around that I [1:26:59] Speaker J (unidentified): will say with your concern though it doesn't allow for a screen buffer it doesn't allow for it [1:27:06] Speaker A (unidentified): so what do you do even if we get it perfect today and this is so again this is where I agree with kind of Joe there's not really a mechanism for a maintenance agreement you know to go in maintain it over time the trees get bigger the underneath gets thinner and 20 years from now there's zero buffer and that is with every project every buffer requirement for every type of development so we don't have that and unfortunately we don't have that so even if we get it perfect today there's still going to be the issue of 20 years from now the maintenance for the scrub pine is only going to be for the first two years. [1:27:55] Speaker J (unidentified): Can I ask you a question on that? Scrub oak, sorry, scrub oak. Yeah, with the buffer? So does it really say we want a buffer, a buffer is only to be there for a certain period of time? No. You would assume then there, if you had a wood screen and the screen broke and you're responsible for a wood screen and it broke, would you have to replace it? So my point is, should it be maintained for forever because you're dealing with a buffer, a screening of vegetation, 50 foot by 8 foot. This doesn't sound like there was a time limit to it, and after that, it's irregardless. So I know you can, I hear your concerns, and I understand them. [1:28:40] Speaker B (unidentified): So I can answer that. Anything shown on the proof site plan does have to be maintained. But as one of the abutters mentioned, trees grow tall, and sometimes when they grow tall, they shed their lower branches. So maintained could potentially mean that those lower branches end up and those trees are still being maintained. So the definition of buffer is a hard one for you guys to discuss. Yes. As Jace mentioned, it mentions eight feet. In Chapter 280, it was brought up by one of the abutters that the definition says that it should be screened from visible screening. So this one is a tough one for you guys. I just want to remind you that the ordinance gives options with vegetation. It gives options with fences. It gives options with berms. It gives options with lots of things to create what you guys agree is an adequate buffer. So I'm not saying what they are proposing is or is not adequate. That's you guys' decision. But I just wanted to remind you that if you guys think that it's hard to get low undergrowth to grow because of the upper story, then potentially we do it with some other method like a fence. Fences haven't been discussed. I don't know if that's something you guys would consider. I just wanted to remind you guys of the options. [1:30:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone want to comment on fences? [1:30:28] Speaker O (unidentified): I mean, I guess the goal is screening so you can't see. And obviously, based on this discussion, you're not going to get a natural buffer that's going to attain. You're not going to get that with a natural buffer. Even if it exists today, like you say, it's not going to exist in 20 years just because of the height of that canopy. canopy. The only way you're going to get that is with a man-made structure like a fence. I don't know. [1:30:52] Speaker A (unidentified): And then my only concern with a fence is that it's not in keeping with the rural character. [1:31:03] Speaker J (unidentified): No. True. It's just that the images speak a thousand words. [1:31:09] Speaker A (unidentified): So, I struggle with these images because they are taken in the fall. The foliage has dropped. I do agree. The campground is closed. Correct. Right. Correct. Which kind of goes back to like current conditions. I do agree pines would be the absolute best, but the only evergreen that will grow in shade in the area would be hemlock and is very slow and it is very picky. [1:31:49] Speaker O (unidentified): So what's the objective? Natural or man-made? I guess that's what are you looking for well [1:31:58] Speaker A (unidentified): when we went for the sidewalk i had two concerned area two or three areas of concern and all were addressed to me to the best you know that i'm ever going to be able to visualize it because of the plantings you know that i've shown the first year or so they're probably not going to be exactly what you know i'd want because they're going to have to reroute and grow. [1:32:30] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I'm feeling the same way as you, Jace. I think we have the same areas. Flycatcher did go back and pose a considerable amount of plantings in those areas. I personally would be opposed to the fencing only because it is a we ask for a vegetated buffer. Well, a fence is not vegetation. vegetation so I believe that the I was satisfied with the I [1:33:07] Speaker A (unidentified): mean I will throw this out there but it'll be on the site plan he will not be able to put a fence up without coming to us any neighbor that so chooses can still put a fence up [Speaker N (unidentified): mm-hmm but] for the purpose of the ordinance I believe that the buffer that is there is adequate we have never required someone to plant so many trees with a natural I keep hearing not this isn't natural this is natural everything I saw in those pictures was natural it just wasn't you know the big bushy pine trees on route 4 and so we've made people plant but everything was cut down and we've replanted and we didn't say the project must stop because those trees don't create this picture-perfect buffer but they will in a few years so is there still specific concerns with the buffering? I mean, you're [1:34:31] Speaker O (unidentified): not going to get 100% buffering, I don't think, no matter what you do. [1:34:35] Speaker E (unidentified): I think that's impossible. I don't think there'd ever be 100%. [Speaker D (unidentified): It's not natural.] Yeah, it wouldn't be a natural buffer if it was a hedge line that you couldn't see anything through. And I don't think anybody wants that. I can't speak for them, the folks that live in the area. But we're asking for a natural vegetative buffer, and a hedgerow with no sight line is not a natural vegetative buffer. That's my opinion. [1:35:15] Speaker A (unidentified): My hope is that as the clearings for the pads are done, that stimulates some sunshine and some growth because of the sunshine that it could allow in. All right, so. Are there concerns with buffering still? I just... Nope. Okay. So we had some other issues. I know right title and interest was mentioned a couple times. This is not the appropriate place to determine right title and interest. That would be in a court of law. There was financial and technical capacity. Jamie, could you speak to that? Specifically how it relates to the letter only related to Phase 1. [1:36:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes. The applicant provided a letter from their bank saying that they had the funds to build phase one. I guess I just want to make the comment of if the applicant decided to stop at phase one, they could. There is nothing saying they have to build all four phases. That is why a project is phased. So we only require the verification of funds for the first phase. And if that is as far as they go, that is as far as they go. If they want to go to phase two, we get verification for phase two at that time, and so forth and so on. That number is based upon the number that is received for the performance guarantee. Performance guarantee covers all site improvements not related to building construction as in structures. So that performance guarantee monetary value is what is the basis of the financial capacity for phase one. [1:37:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Jamie. everyone good with that all right there was concerns about a septic in the buffer Steve would you able to answer to that honestly [1:37:33] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm not quite sure where that location was off of Siddle Road between the road in our access piece we have a collection system that septic tank in underground sewer would just be that. I'd have to look at my plan judging from what I saw on the screen. I thought we were okay there. [1:37:57] Speaker D (unidentified): So I don't think we care if there's a septic in the buffer. It would be a concern if there'd be a septic in the setback. That's not what we're talking about here. It's a vegetated buffer to provide screening. If there's a septic system there, does it matter? Does it? You can't [1:38:16] Speaker A (unidentified): really have vegetation on top of a septic it wouldn't be very good practice to have it would take very specific vegetation what's up no but it [1:38:33] Speaker J (unidentified): goes right back to a buffering right doesn't give the 50 foot mm-hmm 30 you know 42 feet whatever can you find it on the plant Jamie you I'm trying to find [1:38:46] Speaker B (unidentified): that slide thank you I believe that was one of the slides that was added that wasn't present to us I could pull up the actual plan yes please that's what I [1:39:27] Speaker A (unidentified): care most about Steve [1:40:11] Speaker B (unidentified): do you remember is this the septic that would be closest to [1:40:14] Speaker C (unidentified): the entrance I think so yeah there's one area I [1:40:26] Speaker B (unidentified): believe we're referencing this leach field right here would [1:40:33] Speaker A (unidentified): you whoever brought the comment up could you just specify which septic? [1:40:41] Speaker C (unidentified): If it would please the board, if there happened to be a septic tank and manhole that was on the very edge of the buffer, the 50 feet, we're certainly able to move that out of that 50 feet in any planting areas if that happened to be the case. Don't [1:41:01] Speaker A (unidentified): remember seeing one because my concern is even with what was presented, if we can't see it on this plan, which is what we are approving. [1:41:20] Speaker C (unidentified): You'll have to go to a utility plan, Jamie. Yeah, it's out of the three series. So it could be the one next to site five? This one right here. Right. Okay. Do you see the 75 foot line? [1:42:13] Speaker L (unidentified): It's not in the buffer. [1:42:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Without taking a measurement. [1:42:27] Speaker A (unidentified): So that is not septic, that's the, what am I looking at right there next to site five? [1:42:33] Speaker B (unidentified): So this right here would be the septic tank that is, I believe in question, within the buffer. So the red lines are lines and the two square boxes is a septic tank and a pump chamber. Right. And they [1:42:52] Speaker A (unidentified): are outside, they are in the 75 foot buffer. It appears as though the septic [1:42:58] Speaker B (unidentified): tank would be within that buffer. And [1:43:02] Speaker J (unidentified): they have to be cleared so they can be clean periodically, correct? Those tanks? Subject tanks need to be cleared of vegetation [1:43:09] Speaker B (unidentified): at all times, you can't have tree growth around subject tanks or fields. Correct. [1:43:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Can you correct that? Yeah, certainly. I mean, I've been looking at them and thinking that they're within or between 50 feet to 75 feet, so we still have a 50 foot buffer, but they're in the zone, they're in the setback zone of 75 feet outside of the buffer, but within the a setback. As an underground system, if the provision was that there was not to be any septic systems or septic infrastructure within the 75 feet, we can move that out very easily. [1:43:47] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not that there's a specific rule that you can't. It just doesn't really go with the idea of a buffer. Is the dotted line I'm seeing or the hash line... [1:43:59] Speaker D (unidentified): But is it impacting the buffer? Sorry. [1:44:00] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I'm just trying to figure out where 50 feet is now. The hash line, is that the shoreland zone or was that the 50 foot? [1:44:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, no, that's not the shoreland zone. We're outside of the shoreland zone in that area. [1:44:26] Speaker B (unidentified): There is no legend on this plan sheet, so I'm not sure what that line represents. [1:44:36] Speaker C (unidentified): As you can see from that collection system, which is the red line, it goes underneath the various pad areas for each RV to be able to connect to the sewer. so moving that basically closer approximate to site five would be very [1:44:54] Speaker A (unidentified): easily handled and I'm only concerned with it if it does take up the 50 foot of sure necessary vegetation I [1:45:07] Speaker J (unidentified): agree make sense yeah well [1:45:13] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm I'm good as long as it is within 50 feet is that something we can put a condition on we [1:45:20] Speaker B (unidentified): We could write a condition that the septic collection system in between Sites 5 and 6 is located a minimum of 50 feet from the property line. [1:45:33] Speaker A (unidentified): We have the 75 feet, but then we have the 50-foot vegetated buffer. [1:45:37] Speaker B (unidentified): So you want it outside the 75 foot? [1:45:40] Speaker A (unidentified): We just don't want it taking up. [1:45:43] Speaker D (unidentified): We don't want it impacting the buffer, which is why I said 50 feet. [1:45:48] Speaker J (unidentified): It should be outside the 50-foot buffer. [1:45:51] Speaker B (unidentified): Minimum of 50 feet from the property line would make it outside the 50-foot buffer. Again, word it however you want. That's why I worded it that way. Yeah. You could word it outside of the buffer to make it clearer, maybe. [1:46:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Locate it in such a way that the adequate buffering distance is met. Okay. The discussion of campfires was brought up. Any concerns with campfires? My thing is the fire department, I shouldn't say the fire department, but the Forestry Service regulates when you can and can't burn, how you need to burn. It's a campground. I'm really not concerned. [1:47:08] Speaker D (unidentified): The vast majority of residences in the city of Sanford have them. I have a fire pit in my backyard. Yep. [1:47:19] Speaker A (unidentified): And then water testing. The other two points of water testing. [1:47:43] Speaker J (unidentified): Any discussion? You mean measure for E. coli and measure for petroleum? Or is that an adding those as a test? [1:47:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Also, we went over this last time where we had Autopia do water testing, and I really do believe I believe it was because of their septic system and the fact that it had these small collection tanks. But the issue is we require them to do testing, but there is absolutely no standard for what happens with that test. It could be as bad as ever, and it doesn't stop Hotopia from operating. It doesn't trigger Hotopia to do additional testing or to do any other investigative work. It just provides a baseline. line. [1:48:28] Speaker L (unidentified): Doesn't the state test all these lakes? Correct. No. And I think lake stewards are a bunch of volunteers that go out and do this on their own. Of course, they have to pay [1:48:40] Speaker B (unidentified): for somebody to test the water sample. Yeah. The state does test water bodies. It's not every year, and it's very specific items. So I mentioned that last one that state does testing. I didn't clarify all of the details. The state does testing, but it does not include all of the items that Hootopia currently tests for. [1:49:11] Speaker A (unidentified): And so we had discussed that it would be silly to have both do testing, especially when the results go to the planning office and they get filed in a drawer. However, the proposal was to test in different spots because the swimming area was in a different location of the lake. I will still, I do not fear the campgrounds impact on the water as much as I fear the residents impact on the water and residential sewerage systems that are already installed. I really, with most of this campground operating outside side of the shoreline zone versus, like, Hotopia goes, it's all cleared straight down to the shore with the small tanks next to the, right in the shoreline. [1:50:23] Speaker B (unidentified): One of you guys is. And I just want to make a clarifying statement. You are accurate that the ordinance does not have any provisions as to what we do with the test and results. results. But I do want it said that if we got test results back from any body of water within Sanford and Springvale, we would then try to identify why it is happening. I wouldn't immediately just go to the campground. I would go to all of the properties surrounding the water body to try to determine what is going on. So we wouldn't do absolutely nothing with the information. The ordinance does not have provisions as to what we would do. But what we would do is we would try to figure out what actually was transpiring and get it corrected. [1:51:09] Speaker J (unidentified): That's what we talked about the last time in that we said if there was an issue, then all people on that pond would be notified or action would be taken. So I think the concern is there's not enough testing and so therefore not enough action, but it does sound like there already is procedures in place that if there were high test results that are being done, there would be action taken. [1:51:36] Speaker B (unidentified): That is correct. [1:51:41] Speaker A (unidentified): For me, the water testing for Utopia directly correlated to me being able to say that the safety, you know, basically the quality of water would not be hurt or made worse. And it was very specific to the exact type of development that they already had existing and so forth with this we're talking about a swimming area and not septic systems and not cleared waterfront I'm I just don't have the same concern for the quality of water like I would not I would not fail or vote no on the standards when it comes to adverse impact to the water quality without the water testing especially [1:52:33] Speaker D (unidentified): where two entities are already doing water testing no on this small pond right [Speaker P (unidentified): I'm in the] same position you are is [1:52:56] Speaker A (unidentified): there anything else you guys have for concerns comments [1:53:01] Speaker J (unidentified): I just heard one other thing yep which is someone brought up why Siddle Road was not shown on the plan in a particular place. I'd like to just make sure that is fact or is not fact. [1:53:15] Speaker B (unidentified): It's, so the road is shown on the ALTA survey. That is the document that we require to show property boundaries, all of that type stuff. That is shown on the ALTA survey. survey. On some of the site plans, it doesn't appear as it's there anymore. We're not deciding if Center Road exists or not. We're approving or not approving a campground. The altar survey is the document that is required by municipalities to determine property lines, to determine right title interest and all of that. The property owner has given us deeds that says as the property he owns and all of the land that he is proposing the campground activities on is shown in his right to tell and interest documents as he has the right to do so. There is some legal discussions going on outside of this hearing between the abutters on who has access to what. That is not our purview. That is a court of law's purview. you. But they provided the right title of interest documents required for you guys to hear this case. [1:54:30] Speaker A (unidentified): And this is all at the risk of the applicant if it is found otherwise. Okay. Any other? Do we have findings of fact? [1:54:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. 280-16-7A, utilization of the site, is recommended that it is met because the proposed site plan reasonably uses the site. [1:55:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. [1:55:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All in favor? 6-0, 1 abstention. Sorry, did you not raise your hand? I did not. All right, can we redo the vote? All those in favor? All right, all those opposed? All right, 5-1, abstention. [1:55:32] Speaker B (unidentified): 280-167Q, technical and financial capacity, is recommended that it is met because the applicant has demonstrated adequate technical and financial capacity. [1:55:42] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. Any discussion? No. [1:55:46] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. All those in favor? 6-0, 1 abstention. [1:55:55] Speaker B (unidentified): 280-167D, Internal Vehicular Circulation, and 7E, Pedestrian Circulation, is recommended that it is met because the development would not create hazards to vehicular or pedestrian [1:56:07] Speaker E (unidentified): traffic. Motion to approve. Second. [1:56:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All those in favor? 6-0, 1 abstention. [1:56:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Group 2. 280. 16-7F, stormwater management. 7-G, erosion control. 7-H, water supply. 7-I, sewers disposal. 7-J, utilities. 7-K, natural features. 7-L, groundwater protection. protection, 7M, exterior lighting, 7N, solid waste disposal, 7P, shoreland relationship, and 7S, airport encroachment, and 270, 15D, 2A, will maintain safe and healthful conditions, B, will not result in water pollution, erosion, or sediment to surface waters, C, will adequately provide for the disposal of all wastewater. And D, will not have an adverse impact on spawning ground, fish, aquatic life, bird or other wildlife habitat. E, will conserve shore cover and visual as well as actual points of access to inland and coastal waters. H, will avoid problems associated with floodplain development and use. And I, is in conformance with the provisions of Chapter 270-13, Land Use Standards. It is recommended that it is met because the applicant has provided adequate provisions to meet these standards. Motion to approve. Second. Any discussion? [1:57:44] Speaker A (unidentified): All those in favor? Okay, 6-0. One abstention. [1:57:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Group 3, 280.16.7.B, access to the site, and 7.C, access into the site, is recommended that the standard is met with the condition that the Sand Pond Road slash Country Club No. 2 intersection is reconstructed as shown on the entrance area plan. [1:58:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. [1:58:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All those in favor? [1:58:19] Speaker B (unidentified): 6 0 1 abstention group for 270 15 d 2 f will protect archaeological and historic resources as designated in the comprehensive plan and G will not adversely affect existing commercial fishing activity is recommended that it is not applicable because the applicant is not proposing any applicable [1:58:44] Speaker A (unidentified): couple development motion to approve second any discussion all in favor 6-0 [1:58:53] Speaker B (unidentified): one abstention route 5 to 80-16 7o landscaping and our buffering is recommended that it is met with the condition that the applicant install the plantings following the proposed plant and plan motion to approve second any [1:59:11] Speaker A (unidentified): discussion all those in favor for all those opposed to or to one abstention you [1:59:31] Speaker B (unidentified): have a motion for us the planning board accepts the information in the June 2nd 2026 summer report and the November 4 2026 site plan review committee recommendation to the planning board grant the requested waivers with the exception of 280.16.6G.2.C.8, and find that major site plan and shoreland zoning request approval application number R15-1 to build a campground with associated site improvements has satisfied the requirements of Chapter 280.16.7 of the Zoning Ordinance and Chapter 270.15.D.2 of the Shoreland Ordinance subject to the following conditions. [Speaker E (unidentified): By] February 4th, 2027, unless other arrangements are made with the Planning Department, provide three complete bound and folded plan sets, one digital copy, five rolled copies of Sheet C.3.0, five rolled copies of Sheet C.3.1 of revised plans that correspond to issues raised in review, which are part of the following conditions of approval. approval. One, update the utility plan to show septic collection system between sites five and six to be located outside the required buffer area. Two, ensure that all plan sheets submitted as part of this application are included in the final plan set. The index on the cover sheet shall accurately identify every included plan sheet by its corresponding sheet number and title. And then standard conditions of approval, No. 2, performance guarantee, No. 5, outside agency approval, No. 6, inspection fiasco, No. 7, pre-construction meeting, No. 8, landscape and performance guarantee, and No. 9, alteration of plans. [2:01:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I'll move that we approve the motion as read. Second. [2:01:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All those in favor? All those opposed? 5-1, abstention. all right Jamie at this point can we safely say that we will not be getting to the ordinance section at the end of this I know there's a ton of people that [2:01:50] Speaker B (unidentified): are listening to discuss this the planning board bylaws said that you are not supposed to start any new cases after 9 p.m. unless affirmative vote of [2:02:03] Speaker A (unidentified): all members so we still have two more projects to get through and I know there's a lot of people patiently waiting for that topic. I don't see how we're gonna get through two topics before 9 maybe not even before 10. [2:02:22] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm willing to stay. I don't know about everybody else but if it's important and there's people that have been waiting all night they deserve their moment. [2:02:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay so that's what I just want to make sure are will we be going past you know Is everyone just a straw poll? What are people's opinions? [2:02:43] Speaker L (unidentified): Well, it depends. I mean, if we're going to be here till midnight, I didn't bring my sleeping bag with me. Yeah. [2:02:52] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, just for the sake of saying it, we received lots of emailed in things requested to be read, and there's half the audience full of people. So I would suspect a lengthy public hearing. [2:03:10] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah. Do you want to just do a public hearing and then pick up this discussion, carry it over to another meeting we [2:03:18] Speaker L (unidentified): have I think we just should do the next two applications okay and see where we are because I think the ordinances are going to take a lot of time especially if he's going to read everything into the yeah [2:03:36] Speaker D (unidentified): and I'll be both of those next projects are also public hearings yes okay so
New Business
[2:03:42] Speaker A (unidentified): So we'll just keep moving along. All right, moving on. New business file 2025, TAC 38, TAC AP, Mercy Chapel, 1861 Main Street. Jamie, can you orient us on this? [2:03:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, this project has come before the site planning committee a few times. It's been revised over the last year by the applicant. It went through site plan a couple weeks ago as well as yesterday. At this point in time, the applicant has remedied all of the concerns coming out of site plan. I'm going to say most of the concerns coming out of site plan. There's a few minor ones still at site plan, but the plan at this point was transferred to you guys from site plan yesterday with minor details left to iron out. [2:04:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Yep. Awesome. So the applicant here to present the project. I [2:04:45] Speaker Q (unidentified): think Jamie's bringing up a rendering, but good evening. Thank you for having us tonight. Thank you, Jamie. My name is Kaylee Gallickson. I'm a civil engineer with Sebago Technics, and I'm here tonight on behalf of Mercy Chapel Church to present the Mercy Chapel Expansion Project, which includes a 7,900 square feet building expansion between the two existing buildings that stand there today, as well as expanded parking to provide 155 total stalls. Additional pedestrian walkways, landscaping, and stormwater are all a part of the project. Based on the expansion resulting in just over an acre of new impervious area and estimated traffic generation being over a hundred trips in a peak hour. The project has been reviewed by Maine DEP and Maine DOT. We have received our Maine DEP permit. We are working on a few tweaks with DOT which included providing a 10-foot sidewalk easement along the frontage of our parcel. But other than that we've had good communication with Maine DOT. Tonight we're looking for the board's approval of the site. If you have any comments or questions, myself and Pastor Jonah Hadley are here to answer questions. Thank you very much. [2:06:34] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, at this point, I will open it up for the public hearing. Is there anyone in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in favor of this project? Is there anyone in the room either here in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this project. Is there anyone on Zoom who wants to ask a question or make a general comment here or on Zoom? All right. I declare the public hearing closed. All right. [2:07:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Staff comments. Yeah, I'll just make you guys aware of what was pending coming out of site plan yesterday. Coming out of the City Engineer's memo, this project is requiring a main DOT traffic movement permit because of the peak traffic essentially on Sunday only, but because they trip that 100 peak hour trips, they have to do a traffic movement permit. Part of that process with the DOT is going to be potentially the requirement to do a rough design of a sidewalk across the front of the property, as well as a rough cost estimate for the DOT so that's going to be a potential condition of approval. Matt requested or clarified that they have to do a highway excavation permit prior to scheduling the pre-construction meeting for the work within Main Street Route 109. And then coming out of code enforcement there was the applicant had put a parking calculation block on the site plan. We requested just a little bit more detail in that to show the handicapped accessible parking spots all required and provided, as well as a note that says that they'll only do one use on the property at a time. The reason for that is they have enough parking for the church functions. They have enough parking for the use of the function hall separately, but when they add those, if both buildings were full at the same time, they wouldn't have enough parking. Churches don't run both things at the same time, so they're willing to put a note on it that only one use will be at a time in the facility. They have some emergency egress doors coming out of the screen south and one out of screen east. They are not proposing sidewalks out of those doors, which is okay. NAPA does just require that those points of egress be maintained year-round to an area of refuge, which is going to be in the parking lot. So the applicant did put a note on the plan that they would maintain it from snow. I requested that they add to that note that it will also be maintained slip-free, meaning without ice. It is going to be a little bit of a challenge where it is lawn because typically you use salt to prevent ice buildup and if you put salt, it will kill the lawn, so they are going to just have to do a good job of keeping it shoveled, but just requested a little additional note pertaining to that. And then this lot is part of a subdivision that occurred decades ago. Part of that subdivision showed that the next lot down, lot two, when that lot gets built out, that the entrance that currently exists on this property today to be removed, and it showed essentially an access across the frontage of this over to lot two should utilize that shared intersection. section. On the other end of the project, it showed a similar thing. Lot 2 has never been constructed. In the end, somebody is going to have to request to modify that subdivision for potentially keeping this access that the property owner's request is that they are allowed to keep this access point as shown without having to tie into Lot 2 in the future. The lots on the other end, originally on the subdivision plan, the shared access was not shown where the street light was installed. So they're going to have to do an amendment on the other end to show the shared access where the street light is. Long story short, the subdivision plan said that they are allowed to keep this access point until the entrance on lot two is constructed. So they are quote unquote legal today. We can approve this plan as presented. But a condition of the approval is that the subdivision plan be amended at some point because the sidewalk that might or might not ever get built is going to have to be shown on that subdivision plan as well as determining the best way to provide the access management to an arterial to Route 109, the highway. which the original subdivision essentially had two access points shared for the six lots. And at some point, the City of Sanford is working with these owners to try to help navigate because the original developer no longer owns the lots. They're privately owned. And the City of Sanford would like to try to get an easement from the lights at Walmart Lowe's back to the airport, both for a water main and for potential access in the future. So we are working with the property owners to try to help them navigate the subdivision amendment process to try to make it work best for everybody involved. But there is a condition that says the subdivision plan will have to be revised at some point. Jamie, could you just point out [2:12:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Which one is lot 2, north or south of this? [2:12:51] Speaker B (unidentified): So lot 2 would be the next lot down. It's not shown on this. It would be the next lot due south. Currently owned by the City of Sanford. Irrelevant. And then we just ask that all the plan sheets provided are accurately depicted on the plan cover sheet table. One of them is just mislabeled, so we asked them just to clarify that. And the fire department did talk a little bit about the required fire lane, and currently the dumpster is shown within that fire lane, so they're going to relocate the dumpster either screen south or screen west outside of that fire lane. Those were all the comments coming out of site plan and would be potential conditions of approval. [2:13:50] Speaker A (unidentified): all right thank you Jimmy all right any discussion no sidewalks out of our purview dot no the whole subject site plan change you know but i hope it does change because i don't really see how you can get the access would be difficult with the current configuration or the previous configuration I should say but I don't have any issues so I [Speaker J (unidentified): agree all] right and we have these findings so 280 [2:14:42] Speaker B (unidentified): -16 7a utilization of the site is recommended that it is met because the proposed site plan reasonably uses the site motion to approve second any discussion all in favor? 7-0. Group 1, 280.16.7b, access to the site. C, access into the site. D, internal vehicular circulation. And E, pedestrian circulation. It is recommended that it is met because the development will not create hazards to vehicular or pedestrian traffic. Motion to approve. [2:15:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Any discussion? All in favor? 7-0. Group 2, 280.16.7b, access to the site. [2:15:24] Speaker B (unidentified): 7F, stormwater management, G, erosion control, H, water supply, I, sewers disposal, J, utilities, K, natural features, L, groundwater protection, M, exterior lighting, N, solid waste disposal, O, landscaping, P, shoreland relationship, Q, technical and financial capacity, R, buffering, and S, airport encroachment is recommended that it is met because the applicant has provided adequate provisions to meet these standards. [2:15:55] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. Any discussion? All in favor? [2:16:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Ready for the suggested motion? Yes. The planning board accepts the information in the November 3, 2026, summer Report and the November 4, 2026 Site Plan Review Committee Recommendation to the Planning Board grant the requested waivers and find that Major Site Plan Amendment Approval Application 2025-38-AP to construct a new building with associated site improvements has satisfied the requirements of Chapter 280-16-7 of the Zone and Ordinance subject to the following conditions. By February 4, 2027, unless other amendments are made with the Planning Department, provide three complete, bound, and folded plan sets, one digital copy, and five rolled copies of Sheet C-101. I have revised plans on adequately respond to issues raised in the review, which are part of the following conditions of approval. 1. Address all concerns raised in the Assistant City Engineer's Memo dated November 2, 2026. 6. More specifically, provide draft sidewalk easement language for review. Prior to scheduling of the pre-construction meeting, coordinate pavement disturbance on Main Street through the highway excavation permit process with the Sanford Department of Public Works, and provide the City with the main DOT and main DEP permits and any associated plan amendments that are required. 2. Address all concerns raised by the Code Enforcement Officer. More specifically, the parkulation calculations shown on the comment response letter should be shown on the site plan along with the required provided number of ADA parking spots. If parking calculations are based on a singular use occurring at once, then a note should also be added to the site plan documentedness. It doesn't appear that physical pathways are being proposed from secondary means of egresses along the backside of the building. Please add to the existing note on the site plan confirming that egress paths will meet all requirements of NFPA 101, flat, dry, stable and slip resistant. The survey references the revised subdivision plan of SFM Airpark Route 109, Sanford, Maine, recorded in Plan Book 194, page 49. However, elements shown on the reference subdivision plan appear to conflict with the proposed site plan. Further discussion and clarification are needed to determine how these inconsistencies should be remedied. Three, address all concerns raised in the Sanford Fire Department's memo dated November More specifically, revise the site plan to demonstrate that a minimum unobstructed width of 20 feet is maintained where necessary to accommodate fire apparatus deployment around the building. The dumpster appears to be in the fire lane. And then four, ensure all plan sheets provided with the application are included in the final plan set and update the sheet list table on the plan cover sheet to include all plan sheets included in the submittal. Mercy Chapel Church photometrics plan, truck movement plan, and overall site plan exhibit were the ones missing. And then standard conditions for approval, number two performance guarantee, number five, outside agency approval. Number six, inspection free escrow. Number seven, pre-construction meeting. And number nine, alteration of plans. [2:19:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I'll move that we approve the motion as read. Second. [2:19:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All in favor? Good luck. All right. New business file 2026, TAC-27, TAC-FS, NASON Phase 3, Barthway. Jamie, are you oriented on this? [2:19:51] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, this is the property that's come before you guys several times now, formerly the Nassau Dormitory Complex in Springvale. They originally came in for Phase 1 to convert all the existing dorms into residential uses, apartments. They then came in and got approval for Phase 2 for a multi-unit apartment building. in. This is now phase three, which is townhouse style condominiums on the new access road. This has gone to site plan a few times, came out of site plan review committee yesterday. I think with a few just minor technicalities and one slightly, I will say it, Summer Street,, which was the entrance road, has a portion that was accepted by the City and a section that remained as what we call a paper street, an unimproved section of road shown on a subdivision plan. They are going to end up having to ask the municipality to vacate a portion of that Summer Street, so a condition of approval is that they work through that process through the City Council. That portion of Summer Street does not directly affect this approval thank [2:21:13] Speaker A (unidentified): you Jamie applicant here to present good evening [2:21:17] Speaker R (unidentified): I'm Oscar Wilkerson from Green Mars real estate based in Portland thank you guys for staying up with us here and thank you Jamie for helping us work through this application this is the third development we proposed on the Nassau College campus the first one has gone great the second one will kick off after we can resolve the Summer Street extension that showed up on our most recent survey as part of getting this. That is through the NASON, the second part of the process. It is not affecting where the development is for these, this section three. This section three is 13 townhomes and I open it up to you guys for questions. [2:22:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Awesome. We're going to have to open the public hearing first and then after that if the board has any questions we'll call you back up thank you with that i declare the public hearing open is there anyone who would like to speak in favor of this project either here or on zoom is there anyone who would like to speak in opposition to the project either here or on zoom is there anyone who would like to ask a question or make a general comment either here or on zoom all right declare the public hearing closed staff comments no just [2:22:41] Speaker B (unidentified): a reminder this came before you guys earlier this year for a preliminary approval at preliminary approval there were a few minor like storm water management and those types of issues to work through they have worked through all of those in between preliminary and final and again it came out of site plan yesterday with a fairly clean approval recommendation. [2:23:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there any concerns from the Board? [2:23:13] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah. I can just ask a clarifying question. This is just for my interest. There was something about affordability, some provision that was not triggered, I think. I don't know, can you elaborate on that? I'm just curious what that was. [2:23:27] Speaker B (unidentified): In the original application, they had mentioned affordable housing. Staff asked them what they meant by that and it was determined that they are not trying to meet the State requirements to fall under that category. Our ordinance has different provisions if you meet certain requirements, so we seek clarification as to whether they are trying to reach those provisions and they are not. Thank you, Jamie. [2:23:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other concerns or questions? All right. Do we have findings of fact? [2:24:07] Speaker B (unidentified): 275-39, conformance with other regulations, is recommended that it is met because the proposed subdivision meets all minimum dimensional requirements, performance standards, and all other applicable land use regulations outlined in Chapters 275 and Chapter 280. [2:24:25] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve? Second. [2:24:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All in favor? [2:24:32] Speaker B (unidentified): 280-16-7A, utilization of the site, is recommended that it is met because the proposed site plan reasonably uses the site. [2:24:42] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. Any discussion? All in favor? [2:24:50] Speaker B (unidentified): 280-16-7S, airport encroachment, is recommended that it is not applicable because the applicant is not proposing any applicable development. [2:25:00] Speaker E (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. [2:25:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All in favor? 7-0. [2:25:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Group 1, 275-35, Traffic Conditions, 280-16-7B, Access to the Site, C, Access into the Site, D, Internal Vehicular Circulation, and E, Pedestrian Circulation is recommended that it is met because the development will not create hazards to vehicular [2:25:28] Speaker A (unidentified): or pedestrian traffic motion to approve second any discussion all in favor seven zero group two [2:25:37] Speaker B (unidentified): 275-31 pollution 32 sufficient water 33 impact on existing water supply 34 soil erosion 36 sewage disposal 37 solid waste 38 impacts on aesthetics open spaces historic areas wildlife love habitat and shoreline access. 41, impact on water quality and shoreline. 42, impact on groundwater quality or quantity. 43, floodplain management. 44, identification of freshwater wetlands. 45, stormwater management. 46, recreation and open space areas. 47, phosphorus impacts on Great Ponds, and 48, Spaghetti Lots, and then 280-16, 7F, Stormwater Management, G, Erosion Control, H, Water Supply, I, Sewerage Disposal, J, Utilities, K, Natural Features, L, Groundwater Protection, M, Exterior Lighting, N, Solid Waste Disposal, O, Landscaping, P, Shoreland Relationship, and R, Buffering. and it is recommended that they are met because the applicant has provided adequate provisions to meet these standards. Motion to approve. Second. Any discussion? All in favor? Group 3, 275-40, Financial and Technical Capacity, and 280-16-7Q, Technical and Financial Capacity, is recommended that it is met because the applicant has demonstrated adequate technical and financial capacity. [2:27:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Motion to approve. Second. Any discussion? All in favor? 7-0. [2:27:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Ready for a suggested motion? Yes, please. The Planning Board accepts the information in the November 3, 2026 Summer Report and the November 4, 2026 Site Plan Review Committee Recommendation to the Planning Board. Grant the requested waivers with the exception of 280.16.6G.2.B.10 and find that the final subdivision and major site plan amendment approval application number 2026-27-FS to construct 13 residential units with associated set improvements has satisfied the requirements of Chapter 275, Article 10 of the subdivision ordinance and Chapter 280.16.7 of the zone and ordinance subject to the following conditions. By February 4th, 2027, unless other arrangements are made with the Planning Department, provide three complete, bound, and folded plan sets, one digital copy, five rolled copies of Sheet C-101, and seven rolled copies of Sheet S-101 of revised plans that correspond to issues raised in the review which are part of the following conditions of approval. 1. Address all concerns raised by the code enforcement officer. More specifically, provide draft homeowners agreement for condos and maintenance agreement for the entire site. And the existing conditions plan sheet EC2 shows the proposed build-in and associated parking area for Phase 2. These have not been constructed yet, therefore should not be shown on this plan. And then B, the ALTA survey depicts an unimproved portion of Summer Street crossing a portion of the parcel. Verify and document the legal status of this paper street. And then standard conditions of approval, number two, performance guarantee, number three, AutoCAD submission, number four, signed recorded plat, number five, outside agency approval, number six, inspection free escrow, number seven, pre-construction meeting, number eight, landscape and performance guarantee, and number nine, alteration of plans. [2:29:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I move that we approve the motion as read by Jamie. Second. Any discussion? All in favor? [2:29:35] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. I spoke really too soon, but at the same time, how many emails did you get to read into the record? So here's my issue. I don't like this being at the end of the night. At the same time, there's been a ton of people who have stayed with us. We have city staff here. but that so the last public hearing went for over an hour and there was five letters [2:30:07] Speaker L (unidentified): read into the record well some of these letters i read them all and they talk about both [2:30:14] Speaker B (unidentified): both of the orders it's one public hearing for both biosolids treatment facilities and the data center ordinances. One? It is one public hearing for both, correct. [2:30:26] Speaker L (unidentified): Oh, I thought they were separate. I [2:30:40] Speaker E (unidentified): don't even know if we can do that. [2:30:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Deputy Mayor Hurley is correct. By State statute, we do not have to read them. It has been historical practice that the Planning Board does read in all written correspondence, just so everybody feels heard. But she is correct. By State statute, we do not have to read them. We just have to enter them into the record opinions [2:31:26] Speaker A (unidentified): What's up? I know I'm Yeah, thank you. I Did miss misspeak? Okay, yeah, no I did misspeak I [2:31:48] Speaker E (unidentified): have no problem with staying late like I said so that people are heard, but I do understand that people have left Yeah, I don't want it. We're gonna tick somebody off no matter how we choose to do this we choose to stay late we're going to somebody's going to be mad at us we choose not to stay late [2:32:08] Speaker B (unidentified): there's others that have been waiting all night so i can i speak i can say that it's fair to say even if we do open it tonight which would take a positive motion from all of you to because it's past nine can we extend the public hearing yes i think we could extend it we could allow the people that are present to speak and then we would keep it open because it's then old business it's the first item on the agenda at the next meeting and then the people that have left would then have their opportunity to speak let's do [2:32:39] Speaker A (unidentified): it get it over I'm very content with it we'll get the public hearing open those who haven't spoken will speak at the next meeting we'll give the staff the ability to present the proposal? Sounds good. Do we have a motion? [2:32:56] Speaker E (unidentified): I'll make a motion that we extend past 9 o'clock. Second. All right. [2:33:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All in favor? All right. Is there a member of staff here to present the proposal? [2:33:12] Speaker B (unidentified): I will present it, and I'll be short and sweet tonight, and I'll get more elaborate next time. So essentially, the citizens of Sanford did a citizen's petition for two separate moratoriums, one on data centers and one on biosolid treatment facilities. The Sanford City Council then chose to enact those moratoriums early without making them go to the election that took place yesterday. For the last four or five months, led by City Manager Buck and Deputy Mayor Maura Herlihy, there was an industrial task force that has been working on drafting ordinances, two separate conditional use sections, one for biosolids treatment facilities and one for data centers. Those are in your packet. Those have been vetted through the industrial task force. Tom Morgan was the planning board rep on that task force so I'm sure he'll have some additional comments when it gets time to discuss I think I think that's a good introduction to get the public hearing started again I will be prepared to say more next time when we have more time to discuss thank [2:34:25] Speaker A (unidentified): you before I open it I still want to apologize for my comments that may have led to people leaving and again we will keep it open for the next meeting. I have a question. [2:34:41] Speaker E (unidentified): Can we read if we decide we want to read it in can we read the letters in at the next meeting? Yes. All right I'm happy then let's do it. Yep all right [2:34:56] Speaker A (unidentified): well that said I will open the public hearing is there anyone here in favor of the proposed ordinance, either here or on Zoom. [2:35:15] Speaker P (unidentified): Keith McBride, Executive Director of the Sanford Regional Economic Growth Council and member of the Industrial Standards Task Force. I think first it's appropriate to start off by thanking very much all the members of that group that got together. It brought together a wide array of folks who volunteered an awful lot of their time and effort and thought power to kind of slog through a lot of concerns, a lot of documentation, a lot of proposals. I'd especially like to acknowledge City Manager Steven Buck for leading that group in doing an incredible amount of background and prep work to lead those discussions and get us going in a productive direction. I'd also like to acknowledge residents and members of the Sanford Clean Air and Water Coalition who were participating in that and made valuable contributions, raised important questions that needed to be addressed. We as a group were able to review and address all the concerns raised in those moratoria that were passed to the satisfaction of all the members that participated in that task force and produced the conditional standards that are put in front of you today my role on that was to be there on behalf of the goal of economic development which overwhelmingly people agree is a good positive thing we want to promote that but I want to be clear what economic development wants when it comes to things like this economic development is not in favor of the removal of all regulations and saying yes to every project that is bad economic development that is a recipe for bad projects what we want are clear standards that are strictly and equitably enforced across all projects equality and easy to understand and i think we've accomplished that with these with these conditional uses we want it so that we as you know that as the growth council as economic development can help, whether they're applicants, developers, large businesses, small businesses, anything in between, evaluate their potential development opportunities here in Sanford and to make a good decision for their business. So whether they move forward or not, they know that a predictable and transparent process has been laid out in front of them, and I think when we do that, they can make the decision that, yes, I can make a project work here, or no, I can't, and they leave happy either way because if we're able to help them and make help them make that decision quickly before they have to invest a lot of soft costs and planning that's a good decision for them and ultimately that's what business-friendly means even if businesses leave here and say I couldn't get my project done in Sanford but they were very good to work with that's a win for this community so and I think we've done that I think we've done that with these standards so we'll continue to do that I you know this group was not there to evaluate whether a ban was appropriate that was never on the table and was not part of the moratorium and I'm not here to tell you that we are looking actively for any of the businesses especially the data center piece of this you know looking to start recruiting them all we want is these things on these standards on the books so if there is a proposal that comes forward we have something that we know is going to be enforced in an equitable and fair way and it's transparent parent, because the worst possible scenario is when projects like that come forward and are subject to just being a yes or no without care and caution for what types of rules are on the books, even if they follow them or are able to meet those standards. So it's important to have these standards in place. I think they lead to better projects in the end. And again, I think it's appropriate to acknowledge the contributions of everybody on that group. They did an awful lot of work in a relatively short period of time. So thank you for consideration of this. thank [2:38:54] Speaker A (unidentified): you is there anyone else in the room or on zoom who would like to speak in favor of this ordinance good [2:39:08] Speaker S (unidentified): evening andre brusso superintendent for the sanford sewage district i was also part of that task force and i felt it was important to put my input in so that we can protect what we treat at the Sanford Sewage District. We have to make sure that our rules and regulations are set so it coincides, but we're also protecting future development as well. So we have strict pre-treatment standards that were followed through this so that we can protect the mouse river but also have future development not only ai centers data centers excuse me or biosolids facilities so i thought it was a great feat for the city to come up with these standards so that we can have great projects as keith mentioned thank you [2:40:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Is there anyone else who would like to speak in favor of this ordinance, either here or on Zoom? [2:40:28] Speaker T (unidentified): Yes, good evening. My name is Stephen Buck, City Manager. Appreciate the opportunity to address the Planning Board concerning the proposed conditional use standards. I'm here this evening to recommend that the Planning Board favorably consider both proposed ordinances and their companion land use table amendments, subject only to those technical, or legal refinements that the Planning Board determines are necessary through its review and public hearing process. The moratoria concerning these two industrial uses arose from legitimate community concerns about the potential environmental, public health, infrastructure, and neighborhood impacts associated with these types of large-scale, first-of-its-kind development in our community. The fundamental purpose of the moratorium was to provide the City with the opportunity to examine those concerns, evaluate the adequacy of the existing municipal regulations, and determined what additional protections should be established before considering future development proposals such as these. City Council established the Industrial Development Task Force. Over five meetings, the Task Force examined both industries, reviewed existing municipal, state and federal regulatory requirements, researched regulatory approaches, used elsewhere, identified gaps in the City's existing ordinances and developed specific conditional use standards to address those gaps. task force work was deliberate and comprehensive it considered technical information potential environmental impacts public concerns municipal regulatory authority and the practical responsibilities of the planning board when reviewing future applications so what the proposed conditional use standards accomplish the proposed ordinances represent a substantial improvement to the city's ability to evaluate the industrial use they establish specific requirements concerning environmental resources water, consumption, water, air, emissions, and applicable permits, noise, traffic, emergency preparedness, building scale, site compatibility, operational controls, and long-term financial and environmental responsibilities to a far greater extent than we've had in our ordinances elsewhere. Importantly, the proposed land use table amendments would restrict these uses to the industrial business district subject to conditional use approval only. The ordinance also established requirements for technical documentation, professional analysis and ongoing compliance. Adoption of these ordinances does not approve a data center or biosolids processing facility. It establishes the standards that an applicant must satisfy before the development can be approved. I recognize that noise ordinance is still a primary concern in here, but if you look at the conditional use standards as drafted, they recognize these concerns and incorporated requirements for professional acoustic assessment and engineered noise mitigation into the proposed standards. This is not differently than how the marijuana industry was treated as far as smell and odor. They have specific designs engineered design plans and standards that they have to meet in the absence of a specific odor control ordinance. So we should not allow the absence of a fully developed municipal low frequency noise standard to protect to prevent adoption of the of the substantial acoustical assessment that would provide for the engineering necessary for the Planning Board to make a concerted decision on this. I'll wrap it up by saying that the Industrial Development Standards Task Force was assigned an important responsibility to examine the potential impacts. Through the five meetings of substantial research and technical review was accomplished. They also accomplished a substantially stronger, more comprehensive, and more accountable framework. They provided the Planning Board with the clearer requirements, more substantial technical information and a stronger basis for making the defensible land use decisions as a balance i respectfully recommend that the planning board forward a favorable recommendation to the city council for adoption of both conditional use standards and the companion land use table amendments with only those targeted technical or legal refinements demonstrated through this public hearing process thank you thank you all right [2:44:24] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Is there anyone else in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in favor of this ordinance? Is there anyone in the room or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this ordinance change? Just please state your name for the record. [2:44:47] Speaker U (unidentified): Hi, my name is Jordan Matthews. I'd like to start by just noting that I don't think that this hearing should have started now. Whether inadvertently or inadvertently, you caused people to leave for public comment, and I think that the disparaging of public comment should be noted in all of this because there were a lot more people who were definitely here to talk about this. So I'm a member of the Sanford Clean Air and Water Coalition and as such I've spoken extensively to members of the community for months and I can tell you confidently that nobody wants either of these industries in our community and again as someone who actually drafted the data center moratorium these moratoriums are meant to protect Sanford in the community not meant to serve as a means to develop a soft permitting process that allows for these predatory proposals to harm our community. If they cannot be meaningfully regulated, and which, from reading the drafts, I do not feel that they are. There's not a lot of concrete requirements for testing or any kinds of numbers. I think that the sensible thing to do here is to consider a ban, and that is what I am urging the Planning Board to pass on to City Council, as well as for them to urge City Council to extend both moratoriums. Just a couple of other notes. Financially speaking, Neither of these proposals serve to, in an assured way, bring revenue or jobs into Sanford. We've seen that the data center bubble is popping and Aries Clean Technologies has millions of dollars in unsettled debt. I think it's incredibly unwise to allow these industries into Sanford because if they fail, we are left to clean up the mess as the community. The last thing I just want to touch on is water usage because the state of Maine has been in what is now a severe drought in most areas for over a year and people's wells are running dry so if we're going to be giving water away to industries that could ruin it and make it unusable for the foreseeable future I think we're making a grave mistake that could harm the community. Thank you. [2:46:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Is there anyone else in the room or on I'll start I'll start with in the room first in opposition to this just please state your name. [2:46:53] Speaker V (unidentified): My name is Nick Saratela I'm also a member of the Sanford Clean Air and Water Coalition. A bunch of us have worked really hard getting signatures for both issues. I gotta say I greatly resent the way this is being handled and the way both issues are being lumped together. These issues are of great concern to this community and in gathering those signatures the people who signed didn't want regulations tweaked. They wanted a ban. They don't want either one. Now, with regards to the sludge plant, I went to that meeting at the high school and I read about their history of Aries. Very sketchy outfit, fly-by-night, and all of their claims about getting rid of PFAS chemicals. They were debunked by several people who had a lot more scientific knowledge, and Ares couldn't counter with anything except to say, I disagree or I refute that. I haven't seen anything like scientific evidence or any kind of independent study verifying their claims, and honestly, it's an outrage to me that you guys didn't laugh them out of town. I mean, this is a fly-by-night con operation, very unstable. stable. It's ridiculous. Now, as far as the data center goes, I read through the information you had and the thing I kept seeing over and over was reasonable limits. Reasonable limits and within state regulations. There were no specifics at all about any of this. And this is a new thing. There's a lot of things we don't know about it as far as like low-frequency noise, the damage that it causes, the harm it can cause to people. We don't know what the effects of this are. The state doesn't know. The state doesn't have good regulations in place. Yeah, the people of Sanford want to ban, but at the very least you need another moratorium because there are too many unanswered questions about this and I don't know it seems to me like you guys have forgotten who you work for. You work for the people of Sanford and the people of Sanford [2:49:23] Speaker A (unidentified): do not want this. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else in the room who would like to speak [2:49:31] Speaker F (unidentified): in opposition to this? No that's fine. [2:49:41] Speaker W (unidentified): Hello my name is Alex Clary. I am both a member of the Industrial Standards Task Force that drafted this regulation and a member of Sanford Clean Air and Water Coalition. I just want to first take a moment to critique the process that has happened tonight. One, it's both, it's irresponsible to put these issues together. You should not have five minutes to discuss each issue. They are entirely separate issues and they deserve the merit of considering them as separate issues and you need to do better in the future. The time issue has already been stated, and I won't repeat it, but it is disappointing when you did have an opportunity to table. Now, moving on to the actual issues with the drafts, we can go through it piece by piece. If you go to draft number two, section G, biosolids, thermal processing facilities, subsection five, approved operating parameters, and feedstock acceptance. acceptance. We, so far, we're talking, when we talk about authorized feedstock categories in section one, during the process, we are basing that on Ares' criteria, but we are basing that criteria on something that is flexible from a company in the way that if you actually, if you do the math on how much feedstock they need based on their operating capacity that they're aiming for you would need all of Maine and that only gets you 50% all of Maine's municipal sludge that is regularly going to Aries and that gets you at 50% capacity that means you need an enormous amount of other suppliers and I raised this issue in the meeting where we did when we discussed this area that we need tighter regulation on where that feedstock is coming from because it is going to need a wide net of municipalities to remain profitable Moving forward we go into subsection 6, air emissions. We simply put, and DEP is in this too, are not set up to effectively manage PFAS air emissions. You will be seeing very shortly independent data that is going to prove that Ares only is doing partial decomposition with some PFAS through their thermal destruction method for getting rid of PFAS and in some cases partial decomposition leads to higher concentration of PFAS after it has gone through the filtering process. And that is something that we really do need to address if we're going to do thermal destruction and that is why thermal destruction is not the best way forward for dealing with PFAS and why we've remained opposed to this method. Then we continue on to eight, waste Wastewater, stormwater, and spill prevention. We need to better consider how we're going to manage the condensate. And the reality is that is going to have to come from DEP. Sanford Sewer District and their treatment plan is in accordance with state law set through DEP guidelines. We need better DEP guidelines to manage that condensate coming in that we are going to have to do treatment of. And we simply aren't there yet. Moving forward to monitoring, reporting, and independent verification oversight, I would like stronger language to require startup testing and regular and more regular cycle of testing of their water condensate coming out to make sure that the pollution load is within acceptable levels and in accordance with our city regulation. And I don't think we'll be able to do that without that regular testing moving on to data center conditional use standards draft 2h data centers we can go through to Sorry, it's a large piece We number six on-site and on-site emergency power generation seven and seven water slide consumption cooling systems We are not competent to regulate water and energy, yet we do not have effective state legislation to meet this. The state is going to be handling this issue shortly with a statewide moratorium, likely in January, and they are going to address this through their own data center advisory recommendations. Until we have that in hand, it is irresponsible of you to allow permitting to continue if the moratorium ends, because we have not yet met that issue. I appreciate all the work of the task force I think that there is a lot of really good regulation that has been added I really appreciate what we've done as a city to deal with the decommissioning and financial assurances process that's a big issue for Sanford and I really do think we more comprehensively addressed it but as our own same manager said we have not it's we haven't comprehensively answered the noise question but it's not just noise, energy, water, feedstock acceptance may sound confusing because these should be separate issues to begin with when we're discussing it and I've already run out of time because of that so please consider managing this differently in the future. Thank you. Thank you. [2:54:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anyone else in the room that would like to speak in opposition to this proposal? All right. [2:55:07] Speaker K (unidentified): Hello, my name is Robert Haas. I live in Sanford and I can't speak to anything technical but I can say that all the reading I have done about data centers I don't think there's anywhere in our country where people support them or people who live near them think it's a good thing that it's ruined their communities and I'm really surprised that Sanford would even consider letting them in and the sludge Center I don't know really much about but data centers are pretty frightening to me I think we should have both a moratorium and a ban thank you thank you is there [2:55:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anyone else in the room who would like to speak in opposition to the ordinance? All right. Anyone on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this ordinance? All right. I am going to apologize again. I did not mean to discourage people from being here. We normally do not have meetings go this late. Anyone want to speak in opposition? Yes. [2:56:25] Speaker X (unidentified): Hi there. My name is Dagan Fantamark. I live in Springvale, I own a house here, and I run my law practice out of my home. While I appreciate the effort that went into crafting this proposed amendment, I want to echo the concerns that others have raised that this amendment doesn't go nearly far enough and I believe this is futile because no data center and the sludge plant will ever meet the conditional use standards. The proposed amendment just doesn't cut it. It asks whether it asks sorry it merely asks major would-be polluters to describe their plans and then defers to main DEP, which doesn't have these standards developed. I was expecting to see particulate limits established for Sanford, specific benchmarks for monitoring. I was really hoping that the requirements were going to serve as a functional ban on hyperscale data centers. Speaking of bans, many neighboring towns have now implemented full data center bans, and the bans have been enacted unanimously in councils and by high margins via the electorate, such as in North Berwick, where 78% of the voters just enacted a ban. Why we are still considering such dangerous businesses is frankly very frustrating. Sanford, as you've heard, by and large, does not want this. The technology will be obsolete, the building's vacant, just like the international woolen factory, and at least one company is already questionably financially solvent and nothing about this amendment protects the health of residents and the environment. Moreover, this offers no protection for the depreciation of home values and the deterrence of future businesses and residents, something that Sanford should be addressing, not DEP. Also, I don't believe any hyperscale or large data center could ever comply with the general conditional use requirements, such as Section 280-13-5A, 3 through 7, unhelpful conditions because of smoke, dust, or other airborne contaminants, nuisances to neighboring properties because of blah,, blah, noise, et cetera, et cetera. I'm also really concerned that the proposed amendment is far more permissive than the Maine Data Center Advisory Council proposals that were released last year, where many of those proposals were that Maine DEP actually needed to develop the regulations, such as rigorous standards, a database, and transparency, those aren't in place yet. So for Sanford to defer to an agency that hasn't even established the regulations that were saying, oh, comply with main DEP's regulation that don't exist. [Speaker I (unidentified): That's really irresponsible.] And I completely agree that no permitting should go forward without that. I really hope that a ban can be put in place because this is just bad. I believe this is unethical for Sanford. And I don't think that any data center or sludge plant could ever comply with conditional use. So I'm urging the planning board to not submit this to city council and to put in real protections that act as a functional ban or simply just to ban this because data centers are supercharging climate collapse, enriching billionaires, draining groundwater, and making us sick. Neither a data center or a sludge plant are right for Sanford. Thank you. Thank you. [2:59:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anyone else on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to this proposed ordinance. All right. With this not closing the public hearing, we just need a motion to suspend the table. [3:00:15] Speaker B (unidentified): Motion to table with the public hearing left open. [3:00:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. No, someone needs to make a motion. [3:00:28] Speaker D (unidentified): I'll make a motion to table this for tonight and pick it up and leave the public hearing open. Second. [3:00:39] Speaker A (unidentified): any discussion i'm going to apologize again i really cannot stress how much i did not mean to do that and so i really hope people do turn out to speak at the next meeting yeah no all in favor seven zero