← Back to MaineScanner

Sanford Planning Board tables campground application, approves 12-unit apartment project

2026-10-21 · 1h 55m · Source: Planning Board Meeting (City of Sanford (Town Hall Streams))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Unfinished Business
[0:00] Chair: All right. Before we begin, this is a reminder that this is also a remote meeting and teleconference using Zoom pursuant to 1 MRSA Section 403, TAC-A. Welcome to the Sanford Planning Board's 10-21-2026 meeting. The meeting will now come to order. This is a public proceeding, and unless the board specifically votes to go into executive session, you have the right to hear everything that is being said and to look at all of the exhibits that are offered. offered. Please notify the chair if you are unable to hear or see something. Please know that if any planning board members have potential conflicts of interest of which they are aware, they will disclose the conflict prior to the board initiating a hearing or action on an application. All persons speaking will be asked to state your name and address and then proceed. At the sole discretion of the chair, public testimony may be limited to five minutes per speaker. For each item, the applicant will be asked to describe the project. Thereafter, of the chair will ask opponents of the project to speak, followed by opponents and then those who are neither for nor against but who may want to ask a question or make a general comment. Everyone who wants will have the opportunity to speak to the board through the chair. Any questions must go to and through the chair who will then decide at which point to either ask staff or the applicant to respond. The chair may wait until after testimony has concluded to seek answers to any questions that are raised by the public or board members. Please note that rudeness, uncivil behavior, clapping, cheering, booing, etc. will not be tolerated and if these behaviors occur, the chair at his sole discretion may terminate the hearing and reschedule it for another date. In addition, the chair at his sole discretion will limit repetitious comments, though it is entirely appropriate for an individual to indicate that he or she agrees with a previous speaker. Prior to closing the public hearing, the Chair will ask if there are any new comments, then the applicant will be allowed to make a single rebuttal in response to the testimony which was provided. Once the public hearing portion of the meeting is closed, the Chair will accept no additional public comment. However, a member of the Board at the Chair's discretion may ask the applicant or a member of the public to respond to a question. This will not reopen public comment. planning board decisions are based solely on whether an applicant has provided sufficient evidence to meet the requirements of local state and federal law in this regard public testimony is most effective when it considers the impact of a project in light of sanford subdivision site plan shoreland or zoning ordinances and other relevant regulations after the board discusses the merits of each project it will vote on written findings of fact since the findings may substantially affect any appeals right and also as a matter of courtesy the board asks that those attending the meeting not leave until the board has adopted the findings for the project you were interested in after the Planning Board makes its final decision any recommendations by the board must be made at the next regularly scheduled meeting if anyone wishes to appeal the board's final decision he or she must do so within 30 days the city's ordinance and comprehensive plan are available for viewing in the city's website and in the Planning and Development Department's office at 919 Main Street. Remember, this is a public proceeding and you have a right to hear and see what is happening and we welcome public participation. All right, we're gonna start with old business file, R-15, TEC-1, TEC-Sanpon, Shores, LLC, Siddle Road. Before we begin, Todd,, you were not present at the August 19th meeting. Have you watched the video and reviewed all the material? Yes, I did. Awesome. Thank you. Jamie, would you reorient us on this project? Yeah. [3:41] Jamie (Staff): This is a proposed campground down off of Sand Pond Road and Citadel Road in Sanford. It's been before you guys before. Last time it was here, it was tabled. So the applicant could provide updated buffering plans as well as clarify the roadway intersection where the private access drive meets Sand Pond Road. Since that meeting, they have given us several rendition of revised plans. We do have plans that now include a buffering plan that is more specific than the original one they had proposed. proposed. There is also a completely redesigned intersection proposal that changes the whole intersection almost entirely. And then Matt Hill, public works director, city engineer, has had a couple back and forth with the applicants, engineers this week as well. So there's been a few minor edits to that original redesigned intersection as well. So, updated topics would be buffering and access into and to the site. [5:00] Chair: Thank you, Jamie. Is the applicant here to speak? [5:05] Steve Bushey: Yes, sir. Good evening to the board. Steve Bushey with LJB Inc. Joining me here tonight is Randy Dutton, our traffic engineer in our office. If the discussion goes there, I do have a short slideshow here to show you, go over a couple of the plans that Jamie has referenced. So if that could be brought up on the screen, that would be great. So here is the overall plan. You've seen multiple times now showing the 41 campsites with access condition here just at the Sand Pond Road, Country Club 2 Road intersection. A new driveway, if you recall, during our site walk back earlier in the summer, we entered into the project site from that location. and then walked through generally along the alignment of this proposed access road, campsites left and right of that all the way to the far west end. And then we came back down Siddle Road and so forth. This plan here was one in a series of drawings relative to the buffering pieces here along Siddle Road. And what I'm going to show you next is basically the buffering plan that we had prepared by our consultant, Flycatcher LLC, Natural Resource Consultants, done a fair amount of work, I believe, here in the community and assisted with buffering plans. In fact, that's one of their service lines, I guess I'd call it, as to assisting land developers in buffering and that sort of thing. So hopefully we've achieved a lot with that all right so here is the buffering plan that we provided to you folks back in early September as a result of that August planning board meeting that we had at that time I think the request from the board was more information and specificity as it related to landscaping and the buffering locations so we approached flycatcher LLC and their team to come out and view the site area. I think we had given you information previously from them, but it wasn't quite specific enough. And so now they've gone out with survey equipment, GPS equipment, and specifically cited, as you can see on this plan, hopefully well enough, kind of beginning over in the far westerly end, and I'll work my way through. But you have a number of zones here, which they've labeled zones A, A1, A2, B through F, and within each of those they've specified a total plant count and by GPS located where those plants should be planted while accounting for existing vegetation that is there. So if we begin over here on the entry side, they show within zone A1 a collection of plants on both sides of the entrance road. So they have 84 there, and they're specifying 2 to 3 inch tall scrub oaks planted at 10 foot on center, and 5 to 6 foot tall maple and birch plantings as well. Continue on to the site, and you can see the leader lines here. So down in the corner, they're calling that Zone A as an example, and I won't go through all of these, But Zone A had 20 to 27 new plants, offset rows, the scrub oak, maple, and birch, and so forth. They provided a number of notes and planting pieces with some specifics about making sure that new plantings will be flagged. So we'll know in the future, and as would perhaps somebody from the city, if it's code enforcement or otherwise, in going out there, Okay, what are the plants, how are they doing and surviving and so forth, so we think we can have a good monitoring of all of those. On this particular caption here, I've just summarized 218 to 225 new plantings throughout the areas that are within that 50-foot buffer along the perimeters here, as well as activity areas and areas that we felt needed additional buffering. We think this sort of plan, given its specificity and with the numbers, the surveying location and so forth, is as tight and robust as can be. According to Flycatcher, this is a plan that, by and large, from their perspective, exceeds what has been previously provided for similar type buffering plans on other projects. So we encourage them to be as robust and healthy here, knowing that it was an important issue for the planning board, neighbors, and the community overall. So that's what we've provided for you, and we hope that now has gotten us to maybe a higher level and helps you folks get confidence in what we're providing for buffering. So the next drawing here is a previous plan of this intersection area, which I said again, comes off that intersection of Country Club 2 and Sand Pond Road. This is the older plan, which we had some back and forths. And at the time of the August meeting, I think you'll recall the city engineer had some comments that were provided that day that certainly lent themselves to you folks to have some concern that all right hey we need to go back to the table a little bit address those concerns and look at the design and so forth as you can tell here that the keys were how we were lining up Sand Pond Road to intersect with Country Club 2 Road. Now I'm going to show you the revised design which we feel now, yes, is a fairly significant change, but addresses a number of different things and does put this intersection more into a customary, safer condition. The reason that we looked at this, and Randy was instrumental in much of this, a number of things are in play here. We have two right-of-ways. We have the Sand Pond right-of-way, which is a so-called four-rod right-of-way, 66-foot wide. And Country Club 2 is similarly the same condition, so big, wide right-of-ways relative to kind of rural setting roads, which is good. And I'm going to show you something in a survey that we had also collected here in the last two months to define this right-of-way a little bit better. I'll show that to you here in a moment. But most importantly, what's driving the design here is traffic volume. So the traffic volume, at least presented in the DOT's, main DOT's website, and what they have for mapping basically all roads and streets throughout the state, and you can select those and find out what they have for example of daily traffic volumes. Country Club 2 Road, as it turns out, from basically this location going south, has a what they call a annual average annual daily traffic volume of 222 vehicles that's pretty low volume Country Club to just to the north I think was nine hundred and fifty and we show this here on the plans further south on Sand Pond it is 850 so the primary traffic flow really is from Country Club 2 road onto Sand Pond Road. That's where most of the traffic here is proceeding north and south, which more or less probably makes sense given that Country Club 2 road just goes down a little bit further and then runs back into Route 4. So that made us begin to consider, well, why are we looking at Country Club 2 being like the through road? Because that doesn't have the majority of the traffic. The majority of the traffic wants to go north and south here so the idea of reconfiguring this even though you can see this is kind of a wire angled acute angled intersection the idea of bringing country club to road at least northbound approach to a stop controlled situation and letting country club to and sand pawn with its continuity of traffic and the bulk of the traffic just continue as a regular road and then our driveway being on the west side here, would also be a stop-controlled intersection. So as you can imagine and see here visually, now you're looking more at just a traditional four-way with two stops on the minor approaches to the roadway. The radiuses here then all work more conveniently compared to what we were showing before, particularly for the RV, long RV with a trailer behind it type vehicle assembly. These radiuses, and we've had a couple back and forths with Matt, and I'm going to show you the turning templates on these. But as you can imagine, these work far easier and smoother because they're basically nearly 90-degree type angles for the movement of larger vehicles and so forth. So that's all a good situation here. We had provided an earlier version and then with the city engineers input and a review, we extended the improvement zone. So try to explain here, Country Club 2 pavement surface has this kind of, it's on a curve. We're going to take out some of that pavement. It's kind of similar to what we were talking about way back when originally, but we were doing it on the other side of the road for removing some pavement, grassing it up, and then repaving. What you can see here in the shaded area would be reconstructed street section to basically the city street standards, i.e. pull out the existing pavement and the gravel, put in brand new gravel and brand new pavement within all of this area, put in the signage, stop bars, stop signs, that sort of thing. The city engineer had made reference to, you know, change of traffic pattern ahead type signs and so forth. So we've got that all now positioned on the site and within the road system here more conveniently. So we think that this is a considerably better improvement than where we were at previously, and we're happy that we've now discovered that. Another critical piece to our ability to do this intersection, And I'm going to show it a little bit more here in a moment, but I'll just trace out. In this corner of Sand Pond Road, the east side of Sand Pond Road, west side of Country Club 2 Road, there's a little wedge of land area that actually has now been transferred to the City of Sanford. That was a transferred area that went back to a subdivision here on the east side of Sandpon Road mid 90s or so when that subdivision was created that subdivision plan basically took that wedge and apparently as part of that approval process don't know specifically but you know almost 30 years ago the city must have said hey we want that for maybe some future improvement of sorts and so there's actually it's been deeded over to the city and city owns it So that, as you can see here, really opened up a huge amount of intersection area that's all within the right-of-way, so allows us the flexibility and ability to do the improvement to the road. The city engineer had talked about and asked for various plans and information. We see a bunch of spot grades. How is this all going to be constructed and built? I think we've satisfied his interest and concerns as to constructible plans to be able to hand to a contractor to build the intersection. Then we provided some turning movements here. This was just for a regular RV going in and out. This was an older plan. We had previously shown you the areas inside of the campsite, but also now the area here at the modified intersection. And further, this brings it to show you, as you can see here, a long RV with a long boat trailer. This is a 65-foot-long assembly, which is the longest that you're allowed on the road. As you can see, that works very smoothly and nicely now, getting in and out of the intersection. We did show going southbound, not likely there will be much traffic going southbound on Sandpond Road. the likelihood would be more to go to the north or maybe use Country Club Road to go to the south. Here is the survey right-of-way plan that we obtained just to firm up those conditions and know for certain what we had for right-of-way and the limits and so forth. So Owen Haskell, surveying out of Falmouth, did this for us, and we were able to incorporate this then all into our plans. You can see here where they had located the existing edge of pavement and road conditions. And again, here's the subdivision that was done a number of years ago to the east side or south side of Sand Pond Road and then that wedge of land that we provided. Pretty certain I had provided that just for the records of the Code Enforcement Office and Planning Department that, yeah, this was done in 95, 96, whenever it was, and the city controls that piece. So I've covered the landscaping piece, the road intersection improvements. I think those were the primary topics that we had before you folks back in August that you expressed concerns about. I'll wrap this up to a certain extent. We've been a number of times before you folks. We've had many good back and forths with staff and the engineer trying to be as proactive. We appreciate all of the comments. It only makes a project better when we get comments from staff and the board and incorporate those in the plans. And we think we've done a good job of that to date now. So to summarize, you know, this campground is a permitted use within the zone and within the shoreland zone. We've offered and provided you all the information that shows compliance with those standards. We're providing relatively modest campground here with 41 sites with the parking. This campsite area is like 6% of the overall of 113 acres of a piece of property, so it's really not a lot. We've given you all the information relative to the setbacks, clearing, impervious areas and site sizes and satisfying the zoning. We have great utilities, albeit with some on-site septic systems, but soils are great here. We're gonna have water, private water service to provide that, ample power and so forth. Emergency service access, we've gone through that fairly well and completely with the fire department and feel comfortable with that and I think this new intersection design only makes that even better relative to that location and the campsite specifically. Buffering, again, we hired a professional to help us out on that. They provided great input. They provided professional surveying and plant selection and understanding of what we have for species and so forth so very happy with that and as i said we think that this is as consistent of a buffer plan as you've previously approved in the community so the off-site improvements we think are now good hopefully you folks have had an opportunity to look at it if not we'll talk about it more and happy to do that as i said i've got randy dutton here who's a traffic engineer and he can maybe talk through some of those specifics if you have questions to that effect. The DEP permit, as you're aware, has been issued for a stormwater permit. We've given you other pieces of information about operations and management of the campground and how they're looking to go about doing that. You have your regulations about campsites. It's an operation and a business that's not a year-round. it's it's a seasonal business under your code of ordinances and operations so I think there's something to that in the sense of its overall impact financial capacity right title and interest we provided all of those I mean we don't think there's any issues with any of those aspects despite perhaps there being some pieces from neighbors or the San Juan Association and otherwise, but the information we've provided we feel has been pretty complete relative to ownership and our ability to do what the applicants here are proposing for the piece of property. We've finally been, I think, responsive to staff and the planning board. We made this application post-moratorium back in November 2025, and we're kind of hoping that tonight you folks can really give a hard consideration to an approval action and or help us be really specific as to if there is anything outstanding that we would have to nail down. We really want to have a good handle on what that could be so that we could get to a point of closure here. I know that I'm asking that, but, you know, it's my obligation to a certain extent. I'm the engineer trying to help out an applicant get through this process, and it's been a good process, I think, in my view, as I said earlier. Anytime that we can take good constructive feedback, which we've had a fair amount here, and turn it into something better, I'm all for that as an engineer. So I think we've tried to do that. So thank you. [24:09] Chair: Jamie, is there any staff comments? [24:14] Jamie (Staff): Public Works Engineering Department has had some back and forth with the applicant over the last couple of days. The last email I had received, there were still pending issues with the city engineer. I did speak with both mats this afternoon, and it is my impression that there still is some pending comments that they would like to either make and or have with the applicant. I'm not sure if they've had time to even communicate with those with them today. These plans were received yesterday and unfortunately we don't have time just to drop everything and review things as they come in. So I'm not sure if they've even had time to review the last set of comments. They are here tonight. Out in the same breath, I will say that I and nor Alex have had a chance to review these plans from when they came in last week either. so my personal opinion is I'm not prepared to approve this tonight because I haven't had a chance to review the documents and I'll make just a generic statement there have been a lot of changes done to the project so I personally feel the board might want to consider reopening a public hearing to give the butters a chance to discuss all of these updated amendments prior to [25:35] Chair: you guys making decisions thank you jamie matt do you want mind or either matt [25:50] Matt Provincial: i'll i'll go first so matt provincial you want to follow i think mr bushy had a good presentation there i think that we did have back and forth about a revised intersection design that i think on our part did solve a lot of the outstanding issues that were initially proposed but I do need to respect Director Cole's process and make sure that those changes are reviewed by other interested parties and department heads within the city so of course I defer to Mr. Cole. Thank you. Other Matt? [26:36] City Engineer: Yeah,, I agree with that. I think we're really, because we had an email correspondence with Mr. Bushy and everything this week. We haven't fully looked at the latest submission. I think that was yesterday, right? So we haven't made any comments on that, but even the ones prior to that were relatively minor. but again so yeah I think there is a bit more of a review on our part but I wouldn't expect I wouldn't expect substantial changes from what's being proposed from the entrance standpoint at this point all right thank you, Matt. [27:28] Chair: It's my opinion. I don't want to make a final approval on this until we have the go-ahead saying that this intersection is safe and is not going to cause an adverse impact to traffic. My personal opinion is we hold a public hearing advertised for the next meeting. [27:55] Board Member: Yeah, I would want to hear the opinions, everybody's opinions, before reopening public. [28:00] Chair: I don't think it's fair to just open it up right now. I agree. There's some people that may not have, you know, the last two meetings we haven't reopened the public hearing. And so I'd really like it advertised. At the same time, we still have the buffer and I believe also was conditions that were put on Hotopia. I'd really like to get through those discussions tonight as well. So that way we don't have a back and forth. like we if we were to table this right now we finally have the public hearing next meeting we then go through the other items and we could end up kicking this down the road a couple more meetings with terms coming up at the end of December I'd really like to push to get a decision made on this does anyone have any does that sound good to everyone it [29:00] Board Member: does sound good I just have one minor we're talking about the buffering from my notes from the walkthrough and what was just displayed again today I think there's some concern so I wonder I know that you brought in the traffic expert and wonder if a third party landscape company would also be here if we're going to open this [29:21] Chair: up again to talk about buffering yep so the order I was hoping to go into was first just us briefly discuss the new proposed road entrance, and then any concerns with that. Then we can go into the buffering, discuss our potential concerns. And then through that, the applicant will have time to prepare discussions for the next meeting, and then we also have the public hearing. Does that make sense? Since I just want to make sure that we don't get to a point where we're constantly each week pushing back, but having to ask for something else. So with that, what is the board's opinion of the new road entrance? [30:14] Board Member: So it's definitely a lot better than it was. I think that getting the city engineer's impressions on all of these different turns and making sure that we're not creating some other adverse condition because of this. But other than that, I mean, the general overlay or the general outlay of this, I'm mostly satisfied with. It's just obviously I want engineering's opinion on that. Yeah, I definitely would like to hear the experts before I say anything or give any opinion. [30:52] Chair: Yep. I will have just, yeah, let everyone else go first. [30:57] Board Member: Anyone else have a concern? [31:04] Chair: Nope. All right. The only concern I saw was the turning template showed a turn from the southern driveway but not from the northern driveway. and judging from the drawings, I can't see how a car would be able to turn out of the driveway and come to a stop without blocking the entranceway. So I don't know if the applicant can speak to that. Right. [31:34] Steve Bushey: If I could ask, my hearing's not so great. Could you repeat the movement that you were talking about? [31:40] Chair: So right here on the right-hand drawing, you can see a passenger vehicle exiting the southern driveway, but the northern driveway is much closer to the intersection and I'm questioning how a car can turn and make it to the stop sign without blocking the intersection. Got it. So coming out of the residential driveway. Yeah. Got it. All right. We can do that. That's my only concern. I see that being a little unsafe. Okay. Anyone else? All right. Buffering was really what I wanted to get to because I don't want to keep having things what do people think of the new buffering plan the [32:27] Board Member: applicant said he was going to move some of the trees on the property yes it will be you know how many probably nearly all of [32:39] Steve Bushey: these plants here of the 218 to 225 flycatcher has basically walked the entirety of the property to basically find out is there this much plant material on the property and there certainly is and more they were had a pretty amazed actually on the availability of plant material there was a certain degree of excitement because in their world of doing plantings and so forth having stock basically that comes from the site is of always ideal because it's already been established that's a good setting and a good soil condition and if you're just moving them from one location on the property to another location I'll note that the and I think we talked about this maybe at least with a few of the folks when we were on the site walk the applicant here does have a tree spade that too was fairly exciting to the folks at flycatcher who are committed to helping the owner in that experience of doing plantings and transplantings which they've already started doing some of their own but the applicant owner here acquired a tree spade which oh okay that's you know step one in the process of all right being able to effectively re take out plants and then transplant them on the property so that's where all the stock is expected to be coming from thank you [34:10] Board Member: you. Jack, does that answer your question? Yeah. All right. Saves me a lot of money. Well, except for the spade. Yeah. [34:21] Chair: What is the rest of the board's opinion on the new buffering plan? [34:31] Board Member: So in my notes, I have by sites four and the septic area. Now the septic area is supposed to be during, it's a grassed area that could be for recreation, right? I do see that you have a lot of, what appears to be a lot of plantings on the roadside, but what I was looking at is, or noticing in my notes, when you turn to the, well, when you face it, turning to the right by going up to site four, site three, that was still very light, too. I don't know if there's a private house on the other side of that fence, but I just know that was very light, and I'm not sure why, if it's based on my notes, it's been a while since I've been to the site, where there are no plantings, turning right, yeah, where your cursor is from, in that, not that high up, but in that area. That was light. The other place that was very light, where I saw, was from site 11 to 17, and I can't tell if you have as many plants there. That was extremely light. The other areas you seem to fill in, those two are the concerns that I saw, and I'm not [35:43] Steve Bushey: sure I'm not sure if I'm reading it right we did walk this area here on the kind of south end with flycatcher knowing that we'd had some discussions about that and we did some measurements and they felt no we're in good shape on that side we certainly if we had felt yeah it needed it there and with fly catchers review of it we would have planted more there so they ended up But having an emphasis, and I think that area somewhat stood out during the site walk because as we were coming down Sittle Road, you could tell that, all right, this was a bare area that needed some help. So you can see right here, Zone A, 20 to 27, three offset rows of plants and so forth. So, you know, trying to put in a fairly good density with some rows of the plantings and so forth to improve that. Same thing goes as we go further up here along Siddle Road in various spots. [36:46] Board Member: But I do see that first very dense, three rows, and I do see further up where you have a density. If you bring the cursor up to the left past the curve, keep going, up right in that area, that looks fairly dense. Mike, what I observed is down to the right, where you keep your cursor going down past that opening keep going down from that point probably there it just seemed very light there and I would have liked to see more density I can't tell what this really is going to represent in real life because it's just these are just dots it's just a concern that I don't see the same emphasis in that area and maybe this like this company can show that in a more better detail so I mean I think I have to disagree because plans yeah we did the site walk on the top right hand side or left hand side of this that was one of our major areas concerned a lot of a lot of trees plantings have been added to that schedule yeah moving down to the corner where the sites 22 through 20 are that was the other piece I didn't make any note of any moat note of a lightness in the buffering on that bottom corner by septic one septic one how about from 17 to 17 to 11 any note there I thought there was parts where it was pretty light but again this is months ago but this of my nose nothing anybody else that was on there so I didn't have any [38:31] Chair: issue in this, can you go back to the other plan, Jamie? I've got controls. Oh, you have the controls? Thank you. Sorry. My notes were where the plantings, the previous plantings had stopped on this one was where I was surprised, the note I had made was I was surprised that they had proposed planting in this area because I thought It was already pretty well. Is it already pretty well established, but that bottom Little section where the planting stopped to the property line. Yeah, was very open That's where what I had noticed [39:10] Board Member: but they've had Considerable plantings in that to that section. Yeah,, you're talking to this area here. Yes, correct All [39:27] Chair: right, so any other comments from the board on the buffering [39:37] Board Member: I would just say it's hard to visualize. So I'm just having trouble trying to visualize what it looks like. That's all. [39:47] Steve Bushey: I guess if I could, Mr. Chairman, reiterate a couple of points of what Flycatcher has put within the plan as well for the monitoring aspects of it. Going to the specificity here of survey locating with GPS equipment, but, you know, pretty good accuracy to that, these locations are on the plan so that the owner is going to be planting them in a good specific spot under the guidance of Flycatcher as well as using digital files because we now have this all in our CAD files which they're going to be using to locate all those things. Then I think some of the notes here talk about well yeah and those plants will have flags on them so that over a period of time they can be monitored to make sure as I said earlier that, yep, they're surviving, they're growing, they're thriving, and we're doing what we need to do there. There are some other notes here. Some of the input that Flycatcher had, and regrettably I asked at least one of their folks to be here tonight. They couldn't make it. It does sound, if we do go to a public hearing, that I'll try to see if I can get them here because that might get us over another hurdle as well. But the point I was going to make is their interest in some selective thinning, actually, because you've got to get some daylight into the ground floor here to allow some of this stuff to thrive a little bit better because some of the taller conifers there are kind of shielding out sunlight, and it's just not getting enough. So they commented on that, and there might be some selective branch trimming or whatever. anything that gets some more sunlight down into the ground is going to be useful to try to get some of this deciduous growth to really capture it because this stuff as you saw out there in certain areas can get really thick pretty quickly and in within a height range as well at five to eight feet which is great to stop the visibility and so forth so that was another element [41:52] Chair: of their input awesome thank you i will say i do appreciate the specificity it is very difficult when we have a plan proposed and to for the staff to be able to determine if a plant should have been there or should not have been was removed had died you know what was what needs to be kept for the two years. So I'm very thankful for the specific planting locations. I do think for me this does touch on all the areas I had commented on. I still am of the belief because it's pretty the buffer is pretty much untouched in the wooded areas it is going to be tough to get a very thick buffer. The taller our trees will shade out the understory and it will become more park like and it will continue to be that way but there's nothing I mean that's nothing yeah so I [42:59] Board Member: would just add that I was satisfied with the with the planning schedule in this and I have made note of the specificity as well being really important and Mike I did have a question for code enforcement on this because that was One of the concerns was, that specificity enough to give us the ability to, it sounds like it, but to keep this and make this an enforceable standard or enforceable objective? [43:27] Jamie (Staff): I think there is enough specificity there where code enforcement can go out and inspect after the installation and verify if it meets or does not meet the requirements, yes. [43:37] Board Member: Okay, thank you. And so the last thing is, and we talked about the thinning and the problem with the overgrowth extensively in previous meetings. So, yeah, so I think that makes sense. Yeah, all the areas I was concerned with were addressed. Will the plantings be done on phases? [44:07] Steve Bushey: You asked the question, would they be done by phase or? [44:10] Board Member: Yes. Would they be done all at once or in phases? [44:14] Steve Bushey: I'm pretty certain the owner is willing to go out and do all the plantings here at once. Okay. Because that way, the sooner that they get transplanted, the better they're going to be as the future phases come into play. [44:29] Jamie (Staff): I will say I had a conversation with him, and he alluded that if and when they receive approval, that would be one of his first steps so that they would have time to potentially take and start to grow, especially for the later phases. So I can confirm that he told me that would be his intention, would be to do this almost as the first step. [44:52] Board Member: Would that be a condition? [44:54] Jamie (Staff): If you guys would like, yes. [44:57] Chair: Everyone else? Yeah. I believe the consensus is yes. [45:18] Board Member: Can I just ask a question on that? How do we make a condition that they, the order by which they actually execute the project? If we give them the go-ahead with a permit? [45:31] Chair: The permit's going to fall. [45:34] Board Member: The permit is going to be you can go ahead, right? Pre-construction being all that's going to happen, how do we enforce when they start planting and in which order [45:44] Jamie (Staff): they do something? Dr. Well, I think it would be worded such that all revegetation will be done before the completion of phase one. So, not that it's the first, they can't put a silt fence up until the revegetation is done, but before phase one has received occupancy, all the revegetation has been completed. Dr. Okay, that's good. [46:06] Board Member: Not that people are going to try to do this. I'm just thinking, you know, we don't normally dictate orders of operation. [46:16] Jamie (Staff): I would agree. That's why I think if we say in phase one, that I think achieves the goal that Jack was talking about as well as making it so that we're not trying to dictate exactly what order they wake up in the morning. [46:30] Chair: Yep. Any other concerns? I know Todd has expressed some. Anyone else? All right. In the packet tonight, and if we can pull it up on the screen, if you don't mind, is Hotopio's, the conditions that were put on Hotopio. [46:53] Jamie (Staff): Michaela, did you put that in today's packet? It'll take me just one minute to pull it up. So, Lenny had asked previously if we could discuss some of the conditions applied to Hootopia. In your packet and on the screen is the actual confirmation of decision from Hootopia Sanford's approval. In the paper version you have, I highlighted the sections of the approval that related [48:13] Chair: Related to conditions? Yep. I'm just curving them off. They were 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 10. [48:21] Jamie (Staff): That would be correct. All right. [48:26] Chair: All right. So we'll start with number three, which is work with the planning director to define parameters and then undertake baseline water testing of sandpond prior to the start of construction, then at the beginning and end of the season for the first two years of operation, and annually thereafter, with water quality reports provided to the planning department. [48:52] Jamie (Staff): So I'll say my comment on that is I don't personally see the benefit of having two different water tests done at the same time every year. So I wouldn't be in favor of making another company spend money for the same thing that we're already getting from somebody else. So I don't know if this campground owner would like to go in with Utopia and one year Utopia you pay for it one year these guys pay for it but i wouldn't be in favor of making two companies [49:19] Chair: do the same thing for no reason i guess first i want to understand how important this is to the board for that they feel that you know there is some threat to the water quality from this proposal that requires water testing and for what purpose it serves hold on tom yep to the comment about not having to, I agree, but if Utopia were to go out of business, there is no, if we find water testing is important, there would be no second requirement. So with that. [49:55] Board Member: So I have a question. It says, work with the planning department to define the parameters. Did we ever define the parameters of this test? [50:04] Jamie (Staff): So we defined what we wanted them to test for. As far as the values, we do not have a defined value if, say, phosphorous hits this level, what we do. We defined what we wanted them to test for, but we didn't put limits to what sets off a red flag. I think I mentioned this in a previous discussion, but essentially what we do with these water tests is we have a baseline, and then we have every year been able to check today's values against the baseline, and if for whatever reason one of those values starts to rise and or drop continuously, then we know that something is going on with Sand Pond. It might or might not have anything to do with the campground, but then we would have to work with DEP to try to determine what in fact might be causing the change over the course of time. I would say realistically speaking it would be more highly likely that it didn't come from the campground like say with septic systems the campground have brand new state-of-the-art septic systems installed far away from the water whereas all across America camps on water sometimes have septic systems that are old sometimes they're just holding tanks there's lots of things happening on old camps across America. So I guess I just want on record that even if Hootopia's water test comes back that something's happening with the pond, that doesn't mean it's coming from Hootopia. It means something happening in the pond. We would look at Hootopia and all of the abutters around it to try to determine what might be causing that sudden change. Comments from the board? [51:51] Board Member: Doesn't the State of Maine have certain levels for what, if something increases, something needs to be looked at? [52:05] Jamie (Staff): So, there are like published, like say the oxygen level of the water and the temperature of the water. So there are some published, like it should be in this range, but I'm not aware of any, again, a body of water is surrounded by more than one property almost always. so I'm not aware of any parameters where if let's say the phosphorus came up a little bit higher in Sand Pond where that would then set off a big red alarm that the military comes down and figures out what's going on type of thing it would be again if we if we notice that the temperature is consistently rising or the phosphorus is consistently rising or the alkalinity is completely consistently dropping, that we then try to determine what is causing all that to happen before it becomes a problem where all our aquatic life and stuff. [53:07] Board Member: I think they can rate the health of your lake, depending on what the water test comes back with. [53:14] Jamie (Staff): The water test tells you the condition and health of your lake, that is correct? Yeah. their [53:21] Board Member: property on Bosch Lake, which is New Hampshire and Maine, and there are some issues with water quality testing. You know, I think there's a rate some lakes on the health, you know, which is really good. I believe the state of [53:44] Jamie (Staff): Maine does an annual test on every body of water in the state. I know the state of Maine does their own separate water test on Sand Pond. I'm pretty sure they do it on every body of water in the state, but don't quote me on that. But one of the monitoring stations on Sand Pond that Utopia uses is the same one as the State of Maine. That's how I know that. [54:10] Board Member: My thoughts, is it in the name of fairness that one does it, one doesn't do it? Should they both do it? It is stupid that they both do it at the same time. Could they work together? Sure. That's the first second What we do with the information what doesn't seem like a lot to actually do anything with it is also like why are we doing this? Okay, it's that and then the third is If the quality of the water does deteriorate over time do we stop phase two stop phase three? I mean does what and then these are just I? Know this came up first. Yep. Those are my thoughts. I don't know where to go with it other than [54:50] Chair: then yeah because thing is if it comes back higher it doesn't stop utopia from operating or this campground from operating there would be an investigation i would assume so yeah again [55:02] Jamie (Staff): i'll repeat what i said earlier if something starts to change with the water main dep would step in and try to determine what is causing that change just because something changes doesn't mean it's utopia doesn't mean it's sandpond shores it could be a camp that has a septic system that failed it could be a camp that used high nitrate fertilizer on their lawn and got a heavy rainstorm and all that nitrogen went into the pond and changed the number so again it's not an automatic assumption it's caused by one of the two campgrounds if these numbers rapidly change an investigation is done to try to determine what caused that to happen and fix it so it doesn't happen again so [55:43] Chair: So I was on the board when Autopia came up, and I do remember there was concerns with the septic system, which may or may not have been failing. I only say that because it was extremely old, and they had the campground cleared all the way down to the waterline. So both of those introduced very high risks to the pond. this campground is majority of it is located outside the shoreland zone the septic systems are located out of the shoreland zone and there's no clearing straight to the lake so i'm not as personally i'm concerned with changes to the water quality and if there are changes to the water quality i would anticipate it not be from this campground i'll [56:37] Board Member: just make a comment i don't remember 2019 all that well This was back in 2019, so I can't remember every word that was said during the meeting. I think a lot of these conditions were adopted as a means of granting approval to the application. So, I think at this point, it's just a matter of fairness, as it was said. I mean, you could split hairs over water quality if you want, but I think a lot of these are just a matter of fairness. If you're asking one person to do something and telling somebody else they don't have to do it, and they both share the same lake. So, I think that's the question that pops up for me. [57:06] Chair: Yeah. Even if we were to require it, I would not want to require both of them to do it, that we get one water test, not two, because two that we do nothing with but put in a drawer makes way less sense. [57:23] Board Member: So assuming this does continue, and maybe it won't, but if it does, how would you determine who's going to share the responsibility for that? I think like somebody said, what if one of those entities goes out of business, then does that become a responsibility of whoever's left? It just brings up a lot of legal questions, that's all. [57:45] Jamie (Staff): Correct, yes. All of that would have to be put into language if this would be a condition that the planning board decides to impose. All right. [57:59] Board Member: Tom? Yes, I don't agree with having a condition out of fairness. If the condition is we do it. We did it before. We made a decision to require something. It hasn't necessarily borne the fruit that we thought it might have because we were concerned about water quality. We're concerned about the impact. Doing it to another entity because if this was a campground or a development of camps or houses, would we do it for every single house that was being developed in this area based on that rationale we would and I don't know that I agree with that so doing something out of fairness it seems there has no utility if the state of Maine is doing water testing why are we requiring campgrounds to do the same testing I was actually just trying to look that up as well unless it's unless [58:56] Jamie (Staff): we're low so I wasn't part of the planning board back in 2019 but I always try to determine why something happened. So one of the findings of fact for shoreland zone is will not have an adverse impact on spawning ground, fish, aquatic life, bird or other wildlife habitat. So ponds, lakes are wildlife habitat. Let's say a failed system, let's say too much fertilizer, let's say a lot of different options. I don't want to talk about all of them. I think that was probably the finding the fact that discussed and brought forward the water testing and as Chairman Jase brought up, Hootopia in its existence state had campsites four feet from the water, literally. Those were moved back to about 20 feet or so from the water. Hootopia, when it was previously Sandpond campground had septic systems on that little peninsula down by the water. Those were relocated back, but we still have septic tanks fairly close to the water. So Hutopia is a different animal. It's 160 sites instead of 40. It's very hard to compare two campgrounds to the same because they're different animals. I 100% understand what Lenny is trying to say that if we have one campground I have to do X, the other campground I have to do X, but just like two cars are different, these two campgrounds are completely different animals, just for the record. But I think those are some of the reasons with that fight in effect as to why this condition was imposed on Hootopia. [1:00:41] Chair: There was a lot of concern with the septic systems on that project and I think that's why you see two different conditions here relating to those septic systems. [1:00:51] Board Member: Yeah, we did a site walk. Yeah, we did. Yes. [1:00:58] Chair: All right. We'll do a straw poll on each of these after we have a discussion on each. And then property will be used for seasonal camping. No large-scale events shall be allowed. That's kind of like two conditions all [1:01:17] Board Member: one Jamie [1:01:21] Jamie (Staff): so our ordinance nor does this approval define large-scale event so that would be the interpretation of the code officer that was investigating a noise complaint our large-scale event complaint our ordinance does not define that I will say that our campground ordinance does say that you can't have you around camping in Sanford, our campground season is defined in ordinance, so the property will be used for seasonal camping. That's already taken care of in ordinance, but as far as the no large-scale events, that would be the interpretation of the code officer that is investigating the complaint. I will make note that on Sand Pond Shores campground proposed documents, they already state that only campers will be allowed on any event on that campground site. And I have had it on record that any events that might take place is limited to septic capacity. And I've made note that they have no excess septic capacity. So not only do we have a note that says it will only be campers, they don't have septic system capacity to have people there other than campers. So, that plan, as currently proposed, have some limitations already placed on it for similar nature. [1:02:52] Chair: And if they were to increase septic capacity, say to allow hardscale events, it would come back before us? [1:03:01] Jamie (Staff): If Sand Pond Shores was to increase their septic capacity, that would be an amendment to their approved plan. That would come back before you. you. Okay. Does [1:03:11] Chair: anyone have a discussion [1:03:14] Board Member: on that? Based on what Jamie said and how the [1:03:18] Chair: limitations are created. Yeah. The seasonal camping, you know, if I imagine for seasonal camping, you'd have to make modifications to the plans if the city determined that they want to allow it. [1:03:33] Jamie (Staff): Correct. To my knowledge, we don't have a campground in Sanford that is plumbed correctly to have year-round camping all [1:03:41] Steve Bushey: right mr. chairman just for a moment Jamie really said what I wanted to say as to the clarity of which we provided in our application as to the uses that were going to happen in the areas like over the septic systems it was referenced earlier where things could happen for the guests at the campsite I think we've been pretty clear on that side of things So that condition that's related to Hotopia, I wanted to emphasize that I would not like to have that condition necessarily because we've been very clear as to what was going to happen on the site, on the campsite. But Jamie kind of articulated that, so I'll let you go with that. I appreciate that. [1:04:25] Chair: yeah my if we would have if we were to use this i would be concerned with the large the definition of large just if we want if we if we are concerned about it i think we have to be specific number six is the only pets that will be allowed shall be dogs and they shall be leased [1:04:52] Board Member: I think some I know I think some people travel with cats but and I don't know how you would know [Chair: or] enforce it I think that animals should be that at least the discussion about how animals are leashed or at least they're within sight or whatever it is important but yep I believe [1:05:13] Chair: state law now states that dogs shall be leashed unless they are you know if they're off the property of the owner has however I do think there's an exception for if they are can be recalled by voice hmm so that'd be my only concern hmm no they [1:05:32] Board Member: need to be leashed yeah I agree only to this voice control because yeah they see a chipmunk or a squirrel, they're gonzo. Mm-hmm. Leased or penned? Oh. [1:05:47] Steve Bushey: Steve? Yeah, dogs only. We can't control if a guest wants to have a cat or some other sort of pet. As long as they're under state law, local ordinance provisions relative to control, we would abide by that. But we definitely don't want to have anything that would say, well you can't bring your cats into the campsite that 's a kind of a non -starter so we would hope i'm not sure what went to this condition kind of feels a little unique per se maybe there was a dog issue sometime or another there but i know the owners here don't want to have that sort of control under leash control absolutely no problems with that but if it's a cat or something else, you've got to be able to allow. [1:06:33] Board Member: Alarm was considered a pound. I'm sorry. Alarm was considered a pound. [1:06:39] Chair: Could be, but I'd love to see someone try to bring it camping. Okay, so we'll go back to this one for the straw poll. Campground activities and facilities shall close by 9 p.m. I do want to state that under the ordinances, most of the noisy events would have to be concluded by 10 except on Sunday, which is 9. Jamie, is that correct? [1:07:07] Jamie (Staff): So the daytime hours of the noise ordinance reads the hours between 7 a.m. and 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Sunday. day. So five nights a week, daytime hours stop at nine citywide. Two nights a week, they go to [1:07:30] Chair: 10 citywide. So I stand corrected. And this is to basically modify Saturdays and Sundays to 9 p.m. [1:07:40] Jamie (Staff): So if you would be to impose this condition, that would mean that on the two nights, Friday and Saturday night, that the city ordinance would allow slightly louder noise until 10. [1:08:02] Board Member: They would don't think we need to change it. I think it should be, we should just follow the city ordinance because all the abutting properties get to live by that, whereas this one would have to, well, two now, potentially. Clarifying question. [1:08:17] Chair: The police enforced the 10 p.m. The Sanford Police [1:08:22] Jamie (Staff): Department is who is in charge of enforcement of the noise ordinance, correct? But the code [1:08:28] Chair: enforcement officer would be in charge of enforcing the 9 p.m. if the planning [1:08:33] Jamie (Staff): board imposed a different daytime hour limit the police would not enforce that one that would be a code enforcement action keep [1:08:43] Board Member: it to the local [1:08:49] Chair: any comments okay so we'll go back through with a straw poll on all these after provide appropriate signage in addition of language to campsite rules to direct campers to stay out of sensitive areas. I was on the board for this project. There is a, the land trust does own land. It is a cedar swamp and they wanted to keep campers out of the abutting property. [1:09:24] Board Member: Well, the company that owns Utopia is Canadian or French? I believe Canadian. So they may want dual language and signage. [1:09:37] Chair: I do believe the condition was to satisfy the concerns of abutters over campers sprawling out into the woods that is not owned by the campground because none of the woods really was owned by the campground. There [1:09:56] Board Member: are properties here too in Camp Pond that they need to stay away from. Correct. [1:10:06] Chair: I will say the only other thing is I would rather have it the sign be specified on the plan versus having it say provide appropriate signage would be my only concern so if we feel that a sign is needed I want the board to say [1:10:24] Board Member: it shouldn't be a condition here it should be if we want if we need signage on the somewhere then we should be saying this is where the signage should be not leaving it up to planning because that's what happens this is why we've changed a lot of our process to stop doing a lot of conditions with so that we as a planning board get to make this decision on what goes on the plan what are the requirements so if there is a need to put signage up i have no problem with that but i want to make sure that we are we are documenting where it needs to go and it's not just a arbitrary sensitive area well that's that's what this says this doesn't say where the signs are they could have put a hundred signs that they could have put none up right for this because there's nothing to hold them to it yes it doesn't actually specify well like plantings this would require Alex or [1:11:18] Chair: someone in code to determine what is a proof I have to specify what is appropriate first and then also what is sensitive which is I'll make a generic [1:11:28] Jamie (Staff): comment on San Pon Shores site there is a protected cedar swamp towards the route 4 side so on who topia there was a fairly large wetland and stuff that was protected if the planning board so choose and I don't remember if there's already signs there. [1:11:50] Steve Bushey: On the Cedar area you're talking about? Correct. No not specifically but we do have a signage plan that was part of our package kind of somewhat predicated on that Hotopia so we put that in our package so we do have a certain amount of signage that I think addresses well where are the signs and what are they supposed to be well we have a signage plan management buffers that's a DEP piece so those signs are going to be like every 75 or 100 feet along those areas so those are you know addressing the sensitive areas that cedar swamp area is kind of out in the back I don't think we have anything specific to that other than the fact that it's well removed from the camp campsite but I wanted to add appreciate that you allow me to talk that we do have a signage plan to address campsite rules and where the people are supposed to go and direction and that sort of thing we try to be as specific as we could be and you have a plan that all right here are all the signs and that's in our package so thank you thank you so I would say if me [1:12:54] Jamie (Staff): as code enforcement Jamie read a condition that states this and it talks about appropriate signage out of sensitive areas on San Juan Shores site I would feel that might be talking about the protected cedar swamp that is supposed to have limited, very limited activity in. So if you guys so choose, I agree with Tom's analogy that if you guys feel signs should be there, they should be shown on the plan. I agree with that. I'm not saying they need to be there, but in Hootopia's case, they were talking about wetlands. If you wanted to discuss it on Sand Pond Shore's case, I think it would be for the protected cedar swamp on the route 4 side and that is thousands of feet from the proposed campsites but there are proposed walk-in trails through that 90 extra acres that go closer to that swamp so if you guys so choose I think to mimic this condition it would be some signs near the cedar swamp and informant campers that you're not supposed to do much walking through that area discussion. [1:14:10] Board Member: I think a sign just for the swamp area might be appropriate if that was shown on the plans just to denote the sensitive area so people aren't walking through it. [1:14:24] Chair: I am going to so when we do this drop hole we'll just drop hole I believe on the discussion about the sensitive areas because all of the signs should be covered by the plan. [1:14:39] Board Member: Is private area sensitive so signs along the private properties? [1:14:49] Chair: The private property owners can post their property. Got it. There is a fence around this entire property. So I'd hope people stop at a fence. Yeah. Okay, hold on. All right, and then the final one is 10, and that was the applicant shall pump out the small septic systems every two years at the end of the season. So not the main septic system, the two that were close to the body of water. [1:15:26] Jamie (Staff): So, yeah, I did some research on this one, too. So, Hotopia has four large septic systems that do a majority of the sites. Some of the more remote sites further back into the woods, they did small septic systems that do two to four camp sites each. So, this doesn't say that all septic systems have to be pumped every two years. It's more talking about the smaller ones that might be more problematic. So just, and on Sand Pond Shores, they are not proposing any septic systems that would fall under that small category. These are all large systems, each doing large groups of campsites. [1:16:08] Board Member: So this is not really applicable? No. Correct. [1:16:11] Chair: There was a lot of concern with these septic systems being so close. Okay, so we'll start up, just going to do a raise of hands. so first I'm going to ask is anyone who here would like them to test the water as in condition three raise of hands yes okay property will be used for seasonal camping no large-scale events okay I'm gonna break that into two just because I feel like that's two separate conditions so do we need to have a condition that property will be used for seasonal camping. Okay. No large-scale events shall be allowed. Do we need a condition to specify that? Is everyone satisfied with the language that's in the plan currently? Okay. The only pets that shall be allowed will be dogs. I'll vote on that first. no and the other one is dogs and they shall be leashed do we need a condition [1:17:28] Board Member: that pets the city ordinance says the dog should be on a leash right on top yeah on public property okay but people have like backpacks to carry cats in it still too yeah do [1:17:52] Chair: we believe that they need to be a condition that says dogs shall be leashed. I'm fine with that one. Yeah. All right. You guys all fine with that? Anyone for it? [1:18:04] Board Member: Pugs should be leashed. Or pets. Just say pets should be leashed. That way we don't get into [1:18:08] Chair: this. Well, it's not. So we do want, okay. So yes in favor of having animals shall be leashed. Raise of hands. Yes. Okay. Okay. Jamie, you got that? All right. Campground activities and facility shall close by 9 p.m. This is Friday and Saturday. Alex? Sorry. Thank you, Alex. All right. So, again, this applies for Friday and Saturday. Does anyone in favor of requiring this condition? No, I think the explanation we received, I think, covers it all. You guys all in agreement? Okay. So, no to that one. Provide appropriate signage and additional Okay. This one was, do we want to require signage along the sensitive area, the Cedar Swamp? It would be kind of helpful to see, can we just look at the diagram and rough area of where the campground is and where the site would be? And Steve, please correct us if we're wrong. [1:19:27] Steve Bushey: I have to ask Jamie to pull up that plan. I don't have it on my slide deck that shows that area. Hopefully, I'm sure he can find it. [1:19:43] Jamie (Staff): I'm going to have to go into an older plan set to get the big plan. [1:19:46] Chair: All right, thank you. Give me just a minute. Yeah, we'll just do 10 first. The applicant shall pump out the small septic systems every two years at the end of the season. Does anyone agree that we need to require this? That doesn't apply. No. So we're good? Okay. No. [1:20:09] Board Member: Now we're just waiting on Jamie. While Jamie's pulling up those plans, I think it's not a condition. It gets added to the plan. Not a condition. [1:20:17] Chair: Right. All right. So we're still going to do a straw poll on it if we think it's required, Because I don't want the applicant to have to go back and revise the drawings again if we don't if we don't need to [1:20:30] Board Member: Well, if he's putting in trails couldn't there be a sign at the beginning of the trail to yeah [1:20:36] Chair: We didn't exactly cover the trails in the proposal, right? so [1:20:44] Board Member: It's in there the route for side of the property has a Jamie it's in binder one for LOR number six sand pond campground PDF in today's I think I got it on a different one but okay then I'm ready so [1:21:13] Jamie (Staff): this is the overall survey for the site this end is sand pond proposed campsites here the cedar swamp is essentially right up here like where it says detail oh and detail are that is essentially where the protected cedar swamp is located I believe we have a trail plan in here 's another good one you can see where it says vernal pool that vernal pool is in that protected cedar swamp again vernal pools we have to stay away from and here's the trail map so all of these dotted lines which for instance these trails right here pretty much go right up to the edge of that cedar swamp so if we were looking for signage warning people of sensitive areas i would suggest around that protected street of swamp if you guys felt necessary yep all [1:22:29] Chair: right does anyone feel that is necessary show up hands yes i mean on a plan to add signs to the plan yeah okay i'm looking i'm i'm with it either way right but here's the thing it's just saying signs [1:22:48] Board Member: they need to be specifically put like jamie said up on that right i think it would be shown on the [1:22:57] Jamie (Staff): site plan a note that says signs that state protected swamp stay out or however they decide to word it a note would be out of the plan says i note that states this will be placed every x amount of feet around protected swamp or something like that [1:23:17] Chair: everyone good with [1:23:18] Board Member: that yep okay I'm satisfied with the review of this answered all the questions I had I think it generated the necessary discussion to resolve those [1:23:27] Chair: issues so yeah so applicant does that make sense or [1:23:35] Steve Bushey: do you have everything that we've discussed I think so the cedar swamp piece I've got that the signage and is there any of those others necessarily that [Chair: just the leash] right for pets yeah [1:23:52] Jamie (Staff): which I think we had talked about leashes on pets before and I know Mr. I believe Mr. Pattison had agreed to that I don't remember if there's already a note on the plan I think you're right as code officer I'd love notes on the plan as official ways to say what planning board and their applicant has agreed to because then it's it's it's very easy down the road for anybody to look at and be able to determine conditions and pose so as code officer Jamie I would prefer to see it added as a note on the on the site plan rather than a condition of approval but I'm okay with condition of approval as well if you guys want that it's just as code officer I'd love to see notes on [1:24:37] Chair: plans yep I still do believe that a owner off of their own property still has to have control of their animal for a law so there's also the owner aspect [1:24:48] Board Member: of the animal being liable so just to go to what Jamie just said though I'm okay with it not being a condition that's listed in here if it's in the point if [1:24:57] Chair: it's on the plan I'm everyone content yes it has the same legal weight [1:25:04] Jamie (Staff): unenforceability so I think it has more legal weight on the plan because this document could be misplaced the plan never gets misplaced so I think it's less likely to be missed in the future if it's on the plan when future court officers future property owners have questions they go to the plan mm-hmm great [1:25:26] Chair: that everything I think so covered a lot yep it felt like so in the big The big thing for the next meeting, we really want confirmation from Public Works, especially in regards to the conditions, that there won't be adverse impact on traffic and so forth. Not that this is just an improvement, because we really have to make sure that this isn't unsafe. [1:25:53] Jamie (Staff): Correct. We need to make sure that the findings of fact that say access to the site and access into the site is met. Correct. Correct. So Public Works Engineering Department will continue to work with the applicant and their engineering staff to try to get a plan that could be finally reviewed at the planning board meeting with the public hearing so that everybody sees what is being proposed and is discussed at the same time. [1:26:20] Chair: Matt, we good with that? We don't want to just leave it up to you as a condition and say, yeah, at the satisfaction of the engineer that it's safe. We want to actually make the determination based on input. [1:26:29] Board Member: And then just to clarify or emphasize, the turning template for that other driveway. Yep. Right. Yep. [1:26:36] Steve Bushey: And may I ask one question somewhat related for Jamie's, Matt Hill's comments about the addressing and street nameage and so forth. To the best of my understanding, that's landing locally with, I guess, either code enforcement and or emergency services and so forth. To the best of my understanding. It's not a state issue or DOT issue. It all falls locally on street names and so forth. And that was a comment that Matt had made, and I think he basically said, working with code enforcement over the course of time to figure out what that street naming piece was. And I'm just asking, hoping that won't be a holdup per se moving forward relative to the board's deliberations. [1:27:21] Jamie (Staff): So my comments on that is I am the E911 officer for the city of Sanford. I am the one that ultimately determines street names and street numbers with Alex's assistance. I will say that for the public's sake, if this intersection is created as designed, there will be a new street address taking place on both Country Club Road No. 2 and what is currently shown as Sand Pond Road. Because we had a thruway on Country Club No. 2 and a dead end on both, not dead end, but stops on both end of Sand Pond. This proposed road change is going to change that layout so if this goes through as designed everybody that lives on [street] and Country Club number two is either going to get just a new address and or a new street name and a new address. So every house on those streets will be affected by this change if this gets approved as and installed as designed. My comments to the plan set that we're discussing currently in the plan set, it showed some signs that were wayfinding signs that says, Country Club 2 this way. I would suggest we eliminate the Country Club 2 portion of that and just put a future road name this way sign so that more than likely we're not gonna come to a conclusion on street name per se before planning board approval. The planning board, no offense, fence really doesn't have a say in the street names. If they wanted to give input, I welcome input, but just the public that's here, the public that's listening, and the public that's informed from the people that's here. Typically speaking, when we rename a street, I and Alex try to involve the people that live on that street, so we send out a letter. We ask for people to give us potential suggested names to make them feel like they have some ownership in the change. The City of Sanford recognizes that a street and or address change is cumbersome for all the owners to notify all their creditors and all of that. So we try to make them feel like they have a part of it. And just for the record, Country Club 2 is a sound alike to Country Club 3 and Country Club 1, and Country Club. So code enforcement in the city of Sanford has already started an endeavor to eliminate all of the dual-name streets. And believe it or not, we have over 100 of them that need to be changed. Because we had, at one point, Sanford was a town, Springvale was a town, so we had the same-name streets in Springvale and Sanford. Now we're one town with a village of Springvale. So we have already started the undertaking of renaming streets. So this would have happened to half of the residents even if this development didn't happen. So just for the record, we would have fixed this even if it wasn't part of this project. [1:30:34] Chair: Matt Hill, are you good? I saw you had your hand up. Yep. [1:30:38] Matt Provincial: Jamie beat me to it. That's what I was going to say. Awesome. [1:30:43] Chair: And thank you for clarifying that. [1:30:45] City Engineer: I got one more thing on the on the access so as it's shown now as it's designed the entrance is very wide and that's to accommodate the turning movements so that will require a waiver for the maximum width so just want to you guys to be aware that you'll need to approve a waiver so if you have any thoughts on that now would be a good time because it would change that design significantly sorry I'll put it over here [1:31:18] Chair: Thank You Matt yep with that is there any discussion on the board with the waiver if the waiver was all that was needed to determine that the intersection is safe or that the entrance is safe will there be anyone opposed to a waiver? I have no issue with a waiver. [1:31:40] Board Member: No. I'd be fine with a waiver as long as it's safe. Agreed. [1:31:47] Chair: Awesome. With that, do we have a motion? [1:31:55] Board Member: I motion that we table this until the investigation is complete and we can reopen the public hearing as soon as we have enough information to do so.
New Business
[1:32:07] Chair: Second. Second. All in favor? All right. Next item, new business file 2026, TAC 27, TAC FS, NASSAN Phase 3, Barth Way. This item has been tabled at the site plan. So moving on to new business file 2026, TAC 34, TAC FS, Yes. Edward Benway, 29 Winter Street. Jamie, can you? [1:32:53] Jamie (Staff): Thank you, Alex. Alex just reminded me that Lawrence wasn't at the sidewalk, so he actually has to recuse himself on the Sanpon Shores votes. [1:33:03] Chair: All right. So can we have a new motion? [1:33:06] Board Member: Oh, I have to say it again. I motion that we table this until we can figure out everything that's going on and then reopen our public hearing. Second. All in favor? [1:33:24] Chair: All right. One abstention. All good. All right. So now we're on to new business file 2026, TAC 34, TAC FS, Edward Benway, 29 Winter Street. That's K2844. Jamie, can you orient us on this? Yes. [1:33:45] Jamie (Staff): Yes, this is a 12-apartment residential internal subdivision on an existing building formerly used as the funeral home. Brick building right down by the Mouser River on Winter Street. This has gone before the site plan committee twice. It went two weeks ago, and it went again yesterday. yesterday. The applicant has now provided site and subdivision plans that substantially meet the ordinance requirements. There is still one small pending condition from the water districts. They wanted specific language on the detailed plans that currently it says that a backflow preventer will be installed. They wanted it to be more specific to say an RPZ backflow preventer will be installed. So the applicant, with the help of their consultants, have addressed all staff concerns with the exception of that. [1:34:48] Chair: Awesome. Is the applicant here to present? Yes. [1:34:56] Joanne Cavanaugh: My name is Joanne Cavanaugh from J.C. Cavanaugh Architecture. I'm located, my office is at 21 Braden Street in Springvale, and I've been working with the client on the development of this plan. and we actually I did send the that final note was added to the site plan details which I sent to Michaela I know I didn't have time to review it but so as far as I know we've satisfied all the requirements if you want to go into more detail nation if you feel it's necessary okay all right we're just we're renovating the existing building to provide 12 apartments, and to accomplish that, we're adding a second and third story to the garage, which is in the back of the building. The existing parking lot on the water side accommodates the 19 required spaces, and we're also having a dumpster enclosure on that side. One issue with the site review committee was the ability to have a garbage truck to back onto the property but with the conversation with a local hauler we'll have a smaller truck and we'll have individual bins for each unit and it's that he said that was feasible for us to him to get a truck in the existing driveway on the other side of the building with a curb cut will be removed and the sidewalk will be replaced your original condition without the curb cut and the only like it'll be all grass and there'll be one sidewalk because one of the units will be accessed on that side we've had with the comfort of the construction on Cottage Street on Winter Street there that has new water connection and the sewer has been well it hasn't been upgraded but the existing manhole, that the sewer system, we have a pump system that goes to it. It has been upgraded. So we're just looking forward to going ahead. [1:37:05] Chair: Awesome. Thank you. So what we'll do is we're going to open the public hearing, and then the board will deliberate. If we have any questions, we'll call you back up. Okay. Awesome. With that, I declare the public hearing open. Is there anyone here or on Zoom who would like to speak in opposition to the project? Is there anyone here or on Zoom who would like to speak in favor of the project? Is there anyone here or on Zoom who would like to ask a clarifying question or make a general comment? I declare the public hearing closed All right board discussion. Oh, I guess there's no staff concern. So there's probably no staff comments [1:37:47] Jamie (Staff): No in between the first and second site plan review committee meetings, the applicant addressed everybody else's concerns. [1:37:56] Chair: All right, now to board discussion. [1:37:59] Board Member: Site plan meeting was seven minutes and our assistant engineer had nothing to say. Challenge accepted. I just have one quick comment. I think the design review looked at this too. Were there any changes since that plan was approved? Nothing? No. [1:38:23] Jamie (Staff): All the changes were really parking lot and driveway related. They had to move a few things around just to make turn-in stuff work. Okay. [1:38:35] Chair: I think at preliminary, it was mainly about backing up on the main street. [1:38:40] Board Member: Yeah, they blocked off one of the entrances, right? Yeah. [1:38:45] Jamie (Staff): Yeah, one of the existing driveway entrances that used to go to a garage door that has been blocked off. There's a walkway now to the Winter Street and some vegetation and a little, I guess what I'll call, courtyard up close to the building. [1:39:03] Board Member: Now, where will they park the hearse? [1:39:10] Chair: Any concerns from the board? Do we have any findings of fact? We do [1:39:23] Jamie (Staff): 275 dash 39 Conformance with other regulations is recommended that it is met because the proposed subdivision meets all minimum dimensional requirements performance standards and all other applicable land use regulations outlined in chapter 275 and chapter 280 [1:39:40] Board Member: motion to approve [1:39:41] Chair: second all in favor [1:39:47] Jamie (Staff): 280-16-7A, Utilization of the Site, is recommended that the standard is met because the proposed site plan reasonably uses the site. [1:39:57] Chair: Motion to approve. Second. All in favor? [1:40:03] Jamie (Staff): Group 1, 275-35, Traffic Conditions, and 280-16-7B, Access to the Site, 7C, Access into the Site, 7D, Internal Vehicular Circulation, and 7E, Pedestrian Circulation, is recommended that it is met because the development will not create hazards to vehicular or pedestrian traffic. [1:40:28] Chair: Motion to approve. Second. All in favor? [1:40:34] Jamie (Staff): Group 2, 275-31, Pollution, 32, Sufficient Water, 33, Impact on Existent Water Supply, 34, Soil Erosion, 36, Sewerage Disposal, 37, Solid Waste, 38, Impact on Aesthetics, Open Space, Historic Areas, Wildlife Habitat, and Shoreline Access, 41, Impact on Water quality and shoreline, 42 impact on groundwater quality or quantity, 43 floodplain management, 44 identification of freshwater wetlands, 45 stormwater management, 46 recreation and open space areas, 47 phosphorus impacts on great ponds, and 48 spaghetti lots, and then 280-16-7F stormwater management, 7G erosion control, 7H, water supply, 7I, sewage disposal, 7J, utilities, 7K, natural features, 7L, groundwater protection, 7M, exterior lighting, 7N, solid waste disposal, 7O, landscaping, 7P, shoreland relationship, and 7R, buffering. M280-15D, 2A, will maintain safe and healthful conditions. B, will not result in water pollution, erosion, or sediment to surface waters. C, will adequately provide for the disposal of all wastewater. water. D, will not have an adverse impact on spawn and ground, fish, aquatic life, bird or other wildlife habitat. E, will conserve shore cover and visual as well as actual points of access to inland and coastal waters. H, will avoid problems associated with floodplain development and use. And I, is in conformance with the provisions of Chapter 270-13 land use standards. It is recommended that these all meet because the applicant has provided adequate provisions to meet the standards. [1:42:47] Chair: Motion to approve. Second. All in favor? [1:42:53] Jamie (Staff): Group 3, 275-40, Financial and Technical Capacity, and 280-16-7Q, Technical and Financial Capacity, is recommended that it is met because the applicant has demonstrated adequate technical and financial capacity. [1:43:12] Chair: Motion to approve. Second. All in favor? [1:43:17] Jamie (Staff): And Group 4. 280-16-7S, Airport Encroachment. 270-15D2F, will protect archaeological and historic resources as designated in the Comprehensive Plan. plan, and G, will not adversely affect existing commercial fishing activity, is recommended that it's not applicable because the applicant is not proposing any applicable development. [1:43:45] Chair: Motion to approve. Second. All in favor? Do we have a suggested motion? [1:43:54] Jamie (Staff): We do have a suggested motion. The Planning Board accepts the information in the October 20, 2026 summer report and in the October 2021-2026 Site Plan Review Committee recommendation to the Planning Board, grant the requested waivers, and find that final major subdivision, major site plan, and shoreland development approval application number 2026-34-FS to construct 12 residential units with associated site improvements has satisfied the requirements of Chapter 275, article 10 of the subdivision ordinance and chapter 280 16 7 of the zoning ordinance and chapter 270-15 d2 of the shoreland ordinance subject to the following conditions by january 21st 2027 unless other inputs are made with the planning department provide three complete bound and folded plan sets one digital copy five rolled copies of sheet l1 proposed site plan and seven rolled copies of Sheet SD-1, Subdivision Plan. I've revised plans that adequately respond to issues raised in review, which are part of the following conditions of approval. One, address all concerns raised in the Sanford Water District's memo dated October 14, 2026, more specifically on Sheet L-2, Construction Details, adding note that backflow prevention device shall be an RPZ-style device approved by the Sanford Water District. And then standard conditions of approval,. Number two, performance guarantee. Number three, AutoCAD submission. Number four, signed recorded plat. Number five, outside agency approval. Number six, inspection for yes grow. Number seven, pre-construction meeting. Number eight, landscape and performance guarantee. And number nine, alteration of plans. [1:45:52] Chair: I'll move that we approve the motion as read. Second. Any discussion? All in favor? Congratulations. Enjoy. All right. Moving on to other business. Before the planning director's report, I just want to discuss the proposed opening statement. I'm not sure if everyone got a chance to read it. It's substantially shortened. It is in your packet. If you haven't seen it, does anyone have any concerns with it? [1:46:24] Board Member: it. I like it. [1:46:27] Chair: Send to the printer. Jamie, when can we start using it? [1:46:33] Jamie (Staff): So Michaela and Alex took my notes that I brought before you last time, kind of made it into an actual draft. We've talked a lot over the last several years about trying to shorten that opening statement because it's cumbersome and unnecessary. I believe this draft accomplishes everything that we legally need to say. I think it accomplishes informing the public of things that they might need to know. So I think if you guys so agree, probably do make a motion to accept it as the new opening statement. I don't think we have to, but just straw poll it like you did before or something. Chair Greg Musil. [1:47:13] Board Member: I really just get a motion. Chair Greg Musil. I'd like to make a motion that we approve the new greeting as drafted. [1:47:21] Chair: Second. second. Any discussion? All in favor? 7-0. Perfect. I do appreciate that we now, like some of the things in there when it starts talking about minutes to discuss, the bylaws specifically state that it can be reduced to three, but then you're supposed to be giving a number in the opening statement, and I don't want to state five when you can actually reduce it to three. There was some, I didn't like it. So I like that we refer to the bylaws because those are in fact to what we follow. [1:47:53] Board Member: So, just the question on the legal requirement for us to read this, do we have to have a legal read on this before we start using it? [1:48:02] Jamie (Staff): We do not. If you would like me to get one, I can. [1:48:05] Board Member: I'm good with reading it. I think this satisfies everything that the past one did. It just does it more succinctly. [1:48:11] Jamie (Staff): I've done legal research on this. There are very few statutory requirements on what has to be said. So this covers all of the very few that have to be said as well as I think covers, as I've said many times now, the previous one essentially was your bylaws worded slightly differently. So this informs people of the bylaws. We now have them in every packet. We actually printed some coffees and we're going to have them at the entrance so if any of the people in the audience would like to read them, we're going to have them available at every meeting for review. [1:48:45] Chair: Good because it's gonna be a lot more beneficial to the public to be able to read the bylaws rather than hear me mumble through them. So Yeah, I'm happy with this. Mm-hmm. Awesome. And Then directors report. I'm gonna say if you guys haven't noticed yet. I have a cold [1:49:07] Jamie (Staff): I did pretty good to keep my voice through that whole thing. So you're gonna get lucky I'm not gonna talk much more, but I do want to say that Jace, Kyle, and Todd, your terms are up this December. Larissa Ricketts, Executive Assistant to the City Manager, will be sending out notices that your terms have expired as well as with an application, if you so wish, to rerun. I just wanted you aware that if you guys do choose to be volunteer members again, that will have to be... Larissa's stuff to you will dictate the timelines, lines, but if you so choose to run again, please make sure you follow Larissa's instructions. Awesome. Thank you. [1:49:52] Board Member: Communications. Harbor Freight Tools has opened. I've been waiting for that. I've been waiting forever for Harbor Freight Tools, and you keep telling us it was coming, and it finally showed up, so I was like a kid in a candy store the other day, so I like that. How much did you spend? Ten dollars. [1:50:18] Chair: The only thing I have to add is I figure I'll just say it now. I will not be running. I mean, I'm not running. I will not be putting my name in for another term. I do not expect during the next term that I will continue to be a Sanford resident. I cannot guarantee. So I would like to let someone else put their name in who does plan to stay for the entire term. Those kids. Any other communications? [1:50:51] Jamie (Staff): I just remembered. So last meeting, I brought up that we typically have a holiday get-together. We discussed it a little bit. We discussed location a little bit. In review of upcoming applications and priority items coming before you, I'm actually going to say I don't think we should give up one of our planning board meetings as scheduled for a holiday party. And I guess the choice is yours. Do we want to try to find another night that everybody's available? Or do we just want to bring in cookies and tea on one of our nights and stay 10 minutes after and kind of celebrate that way? Margaritas? I'm sorry? [1:51:41] Board Member: I'd be for that. I would vote in favor. [1:51:45] Chair: I don't think we need to make a motion for it. Yeah, because we haven't adjusted the schedule. So I say we keep it as a planning board meeting. And if we so choose to have a holiday party, it will have to be on a non-planning board day. [1:51:59] Jamie (Staff): Do you guys want to discuss a date? Or for now, we'll just kind of drop it and decide it closer to the holiday season. Okay. I'm fine with that. Awesome. [1:52:09] Board Member: All right. Do we have a... Should we talk to the restaurant to see what's a good date for them? [1:52:16] Jamie (Staff): So I have not yet. That's what sparked this. We got together yesterday, Alex, Michaela, and myself, to try to figure out the schedule of all the applications coming forward, which is really hard to do because SitePlan is doing a better job of making sure applications are good before they come to you, so it's hard to guess which ones are going to make it through when. So we looked at the applications yesterday, trying to decide which meeting would be the best one to try to skip, and we couldn't come up with a good one that I didn't think would be impactful to businesses. and as much as I love spending the holiday night with you guys my priority is businesses so I think you just want to spend an extra night with us sure [1:52:59] Board Member: absolutely well this last application was good because I mean they came before site plan what twice yep in the second time everything I mean a minute It was seven minutes we were there, which was a record. [1:53:20] Jamie (Staff): No, again, I've said it almost every meeting now. I think our group effort in trying to make it so we got clean plans getting approved by you. We got mostly clean plans coming out of site plan. We have no more of those subjective conditions that staff is trying to determine what is a large gathering, What is a small septic system? What is, what is, what is? So, no, I thank you very much. I thank the Site Plan Review Committee very much. You are making my staff's easier job on the code enforcement side in trying to enforce these approvals without all of the pages of conditions that sometimes we didn't even know what they meant. [1:54:02] Board Member: And for Matt to say no comments. [1:54:08] Chair: I do want to reiterate, that's why, like the last project, why it goes so quickly. It has gone through multiple levels of review by the time it gets to us before things were left as conditions subject to the approval of. Really now it comes down to whether there's waiver requirements for most projects. [1:54:26] Jamie (Staff): Waiver requirements, like the buffering standards, those aren't black and white. Those kind of have to be determined by you. So there's still lots of things that the planning board is the key role in, but the site plan is now doing a more thorough job of making all of the technical stuff that are black and white addressed prior to arriving here. [1:54:49] Chair: Any other discussion? Or we have a motion. Motion to adjourn. Second. All in favor?