Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Today is the desk all day. Now I'm finding myself sitting at the desk all day.
[1:27] Chair: Okay. Welcome everybody to Planning Board for November 12th, 2026.
[1:34] Speaker C (unidentified): Is it your birthday?
[1:35] Chair: It is. I didn't bring cupcakes for you. I'm sorry. [Mary Alice Appoint: Happy birthday.] I know. What a present. [Speaker A (unidentified): Happy birthday.] Everybody's going to be really well behaved. We like it. Could you call the roll, please? Sure thing. Bob Doyle. Here. Dutch Dunkelberger. Here. Earl Dean Wells. Here. Justin Gonsalves. Here. Ethan Bensley. Here. Russell White. Here. And Leah Kaufman is not able to attend the meeting tonight, just so you all know. While we miss her, that was the email I got before it stopped working and now the Pledge of Allegiance any amendments to the agenda board
[2:40] Speaker F (unidentified): what's that I'd like to make item one the whole purpose of the meeting oh okay well we'll go with
[2:49] Chair: that and I'm gonna read the public comment boilerplate that's on our agenda even though it probably doesn't apply to much tonight. Public may attend the meeting in person or remotely via Zoom. Public comments are welcome during this meeting, however comments and opinions related to projects currently being reviewed by the Planning Board, which will be heard only during a scheduled public hearing when all interested parties have the opportunity to participate. The ordinances and such that we're considering are not considered a project, by the way. Any commentaries pertaining to projects before the board or containing abusive or profane language may be terminated by the board chair. Those providing comments, please state clearly your name and address and record it in writing at the podium so everybody who is gonna speak tonight gets to go to the podium, write down your name and address, tell us who you are. I don't think we're gonna have any maps up, so you, I'm not gonna tell you need to use the pointer. Public may also submit written comments via email, US mail, or hand delivery to Town Hall. Email comments should be sent to M Zakian at can remain org, and those received by noon on the day of the meeting will become part of the public record. It may be read in whole or in summary by the Planning Board or town staff. And let me just say that the Town Hall had a glitch due to, not Town Hall's fault, but Microsoft Outlook, that was a widespread outage that affected a lot of people all over the Country apparently, and so a lot of the some of the emailed comments may not have made it into the planning board packet for tonight. None of them did. None of them did. So what we're going to do about that, we will discuss that once we're done taking the comments of the folks who have come here to speak. We do have will have three kinds of comments. We have the written comments which we may or may not deal with tonight, and if not we will continue the hearing to deal with those only. We also have Zoom speakers, and I don't, Jason, what do we have on Zoom for attendees? So far, it looks like we have four or three folks attending by Zoom. We don't know yet if they all want to speak. Sure. And we have the folks in the room. And at this point, what I'm going to do is go right to item one, which is the residential neighborhood business park zoning amendments. And our purpose here is to hold a public hearing to hear what people have to say about the housing committee proposal and the other proposals that have come forward as a result of that. Planning board scheduled the public hearing to receive testimony on zoning text and map amendments to Kittery's business park zone proposed by the housing committee and revised by the land issues committee. A November 12th public hearing was advertised in the weekly Sentinel posted a town hall as required by law owners of properties located on Martin Road Dennett Road and other nearby areas were notified of this public hearing by mailed postcard. And having said that before I open the floor to comments Jason is going to give us an introduction to the sort of checkered history of what's happened up until today. All right. Thanks, Russell. I was planning to speak from the podium, and Board Member Bob Doyle has agreed to work the controls while our pointer doesn't seem to be working. So give us a second to play a little musical chairs here. And board members, if you don't mind, I'm going to face the audience. I did mention this to Mr. White in our prep meeting, but I'm sorry you are stuck looking at my backside. So first of all, who am I and what did I have to do with this thing? I'm Jason Garnham. I'm the town of Kittery's Director of Planning and Development. My role in this has really been two things. One, I am the town staff lead on the housing committee, the land issues committee, and I also support a variety of other boards and committees in the town, including the planning board, with the help of the town planner. So my role was to essentially serve as project manager and try to keep track of the consensus positions and the ideas, both good and bad, that have come up along the way. My other role in this has been to advocate for and champion the goals that the town council has expressed for this project, both through their published annual goal lists and through the remarks I've heard from counselors over time. And those goals we'll talk about a little bit more, but they mainly relate to promoting and supporting affordable housing in the community while making sure we protect the critical resources on the property. Next slide please, Bob, thank you. Now I am going to make a comment here just on my presentation, two things. One, those of you who know me know I'm a little bit artistically challenged. And the other thing is I recently attended a planning conference where I went to a session that was about good PowerPoint presentation design. And what I learned is to keep your content really minimal on a slide and move through them very quickly. But lacking the clicker, this is going to get a little funky, because many of my slides only have one or two items on them. So that's why that happened. And, you know, anyway, I'll say no more on that. I am going to try to be brief. That's not always my specialty. But I will do my best to focus just on things that I think might be important to you. So why are we here? You know, why are we working on this again? First of all, it's it's a town council and town manager priority and it has been since at least 2023. Next slide, please, Bob. Why is it a priority? Well, first of all, the business park zoning uses are outdated. The business park zone was created in the 90s, to the best of my knowledge, to support industrial development, office parks, warehouses, manufacturing facilities. I think people at the time had some reason to believe that the type of growth that was planned at Pease International Trade Port might happen at this location in Kittery. We're all standing here today because that didn't happen, and what we know today is that there isn't really a market for those uses in Kittery today. Next slide, please, Bob. Why else are we here? There's a real interest in utilizing existing utilities in Kittery to support growth. With this site in particular, many of you have been here in Kittery much longer than I have, and you may know that the town and the sewer ratepayers bonded to install sewer utilities to this part of town. Now, some of that project was necessary to protect the environment and public health, but one of the express purposes of those multi-million dollars in debt that the town took on for the project were for the purpose of supporting growth in this in this zone. And of course, it makes sense to capitalize on those investments and prioritize development in areas that are served by utilities, rather than areas that aren't. Next slide, please, Bob. Which ties into the next bullet on my slide. Import improving the fiscal sustainability of the town does mean, you know, supporting development and creation of new value in areas that can support it, and of course we have we have a great need for affordable housing in the community, so that has been front and center as a project goal, but that's not all. Next slide, please, Bob. Along the way, this project has been going under my sort of involvement for a little over three years. And within that time, we've had several state laws enacted that you'll hear a little bit more about later. They have partly led to a meandering pathway and are one of the reasons why it's taken so long to draft these amendments. And then, of course, you know, I wouldn't be doing my job if I didn't say that from the very beginning, you know, one of the highest priorities for the town and for you all and for the planning board and myself is to protect natural resources. We know there are critical streams, vernal pools, wetlands, high water table. We know we know a lot about the conditions on the site, and you know we want to make sure that those are preserved as much as possible. Next slide, please, Bob. Short story on how we got here. This started, again, this phase of it started back in 2023, really, when this was made a priority by the town council, and the work on the project was essentially assigned to the Kittery housing committee. So those of you who don't know, Kittery has a housing committee created by councils, established in town ordinance, who is charged with, you know, promoting and coming up with ideas for projects to support affordable housing development in Kittery. Next slide, please, Bob. Housing committee has not Been working on this from thin air though. We started with a lot of background information, some of which I think was collected as part of a desire to do this project. We have a Route 236 and Dennett Road hydrologic study. We completed a real estate market study, and of course we had a variety of plans, including a recent property survey prepared by a qualified professional, in our files for the project. So it's a little unusual to go into a zoning amendment work with as much information as we had. Frankly, we know a lot about this zone and the properties that are in it, and we've been looking at and using that information the whole time. Next place, next slide please, Bob. So a big part of how we got here is, some of you may have participated in, others may have just been watching from afar, some of you have maybe never heard of it before, during one of our public meetings talking about some preliminary ideas for this zoning amendment. We heard from the public a number of things, but a resounding desire to find out what will it look like if we try to do these things. What would a project look like if we come up with zoning that is designed to kind of accommodate both affordable housing and environmental protection. So in the interest of trying to do something, to be clear the town is not going to develop the property, so we're not going to draw up plans for a project, but to try to give some shape to that, we commissioned the Workforce Housing Coalition of the Greater Seacoast. This is, this is the Charette process is something that they specialize in, and so we commissioned them to come facilitate that with us in 2024. So that was a sort of pivotal event in this project because it set kind of a vision of what we understood to be feasible and, with some exceptions, viable for achieving those, that combination of goals. So Housing Committee started going down one path. I won't get into it because it's not what we're looking at today. When the main legislature enacted new requirements for municipalities related to zoning laws, some of the details in those zoning laws completely changed the direction that the committee was going, and so it basically crumpled it up and started over, and this was about a year and a half ago, and that ultimately led to updated amendments that were largely completed around this time last year and had the finishing touches put on them in Spring of this year, which next slide please Bob, then put the housing committee's version out into the world for other committees and board members and interested persons to get involved with and wrestle with and the amendments, as you see them in the packet for this meeting, really were still changing as of, you know, about a week ago. You know, the committees continue to discuss information as we receive it and as consensus is achieved on specific points of interest. Next slide, please, Bob. I did want to highlight as part of that, there is really one main issue remaining. I would be remiss if I didn't mention it to the board and to represent, or many of the committee members are here in the audience. And that really relates to open space and developable upland areas. I included a couple of potentially helpful graphics here. One is a drawing from the Charette that I pulled out because it kind of shows in stark contrast some of the sensitive areas in blue with these dotted lines around it. What it highlights is that, to some extent, the non-sensitive areas are fragmented and kind of spread apart. Heart. And that what that means is it makes the site fairly difficult to develop because it requires a lot of roads and sewer line extensions and things like that in order to get into these pockets of developable area. And but then, you know, so from an affordable housing standpoint, you know, it's it, 's somewhat important to maintain some flexibility in and how those limited developable areas can be utilized and access. But then what we also have is information that you know, this, image here is taken from that hydrologic study I mentioned, we also understand that some of those developable upland areas are also home of some of the most important soils on the site for infiltrating stormwater. And so we have folks in some committee members who are really concerned that dedicating requiring a lot of open space in these upland areas might prevent the developer from being able to afford to provide affordable units. And then we have some folks who are skeptical of that argument and are advocating for protection of more of those upland areas in recognition that they provide a lot of value for storm water. Next slide please Bob. So what are we talking about here? We've got a zoning amendment package. I can't remember the exact number of pages. I feel like that's something I should know. The first thing that they focus on is housing and supportive affordable housing. Like I said, the business park zone was not created for housing, and the zoning amendments that are proposed put housing first and foremost. Every type of housing that you can think of except Hong Kong-style skyscrapers is allowed in the current draft zoning. Next slide, please, Bob. What else is proposed? Protection of natural resources. Above and beyond what we're doing today in other zones in town, next slide please, Bob. How are we doing that? Well, not only are the existing sort of wedding cake of state and local resource protections in effect for any future project on this, on this site, but in the draft zoning amendments that are in the packet for the Planning Board, there are new buffer restrictions that limit development in those areas around sensitive areas, new buffer restrictions that aren't required today, and perhaps most importantly, because they would apply to the entire site, there are new stormwater requirements, and those are requirements that we thought we're going to be required to be adopted by the state some time ago, but that hasn't happened yet. So we're, we're taking proactive measures early on. Next slide please, Bob. So what else is in here? The committee's knew all along that many aspects of these amendments and prospective development that would come later would be of great concern to Kittery residents as a whole, and specifically to folks who live in that neighborhood. So the early on the, there was a real concern to make sure that these amendments include requirements for minimizing impact, impacts on existing residents. Next slide, please, Bob. How are we doing that? There is an RS zone boundary buffer requirement. And there is a visual screen requirement for development near existing residences. There is also, though these admittedly are limited, there are building design requirements, because we all understand that large buildings are not popular. Many people don't like the way they look. And so the housing committee put a lot of time, probably four or five meetings, into, you know, devising ways to address what we understand to be some of the worst impacts of large buildings, but to try to do it in a way that it wouldn't add a lot of costs to a project and thereby, you know, potentially, you know, jeopardize provision of affordable housing. Next slide, please, Bob. So the other thing, of course, we set out to do is comply with Maine law. You know, that I said before, Maine legislature enacted for arguably five laws that are going to impact Kittery zoning town-wide, and we set out to make sure that this new zoning amendment would comply with that, so we don't have to go back and redo it in six months. Next slide, please, Bob. An aside on affordable housing, I didn't get to upload the packets, but some of the written comments I received expressed some questions about, you know, what does that mean? It sounds, it's an arbitrary term that, you know, you know, we're using just to, make an excuse for something some of us don't want. Next slide, please, Bob. So affordable housing is not an arbitrary thing. It is defined and specified in both state law in a way and in town code. So what does it mean? Affordable units are affordable to households earning 80% up to 80% of the area median income, and what it means in terms of rents or sale price is that the monthly rent plus cost of essential utilities cannot, is not supposed to exceed more than 30 percent of that household income. Based in town code, there are deed restrictions required for developer, development that contains affordable units, and we do annual compliance checks of what so far are just the few units, the few affordable units that we have in the town today. And just to be clear as well, 10% of all new residential units in large projects are required to be affordable by town code. Next slide, please, Bob. So what does that mean? We have affordable unit requirements, just summarize those. We also have very high construction costs. Some of that is caused by, you know, global supply issues, interest rates, fuel prices, high, you know, high labor costs in the area. What is, what is, what are these two things combined mean for a future project. Next slide, please, Bob. So I want to, this is a slide where I'm going straight for the jugular here. I believe that many of you are here because, or at least partly because, you don't like large buildings, apartment buildings. You don't think they should go in this zone. Some of you believe they shouldn't go anywhere in town. And so why? Are the committees and town staff preparing zoning that enables large buildings to be, to be constructed? So when you, when you combine those affordable housing unit requirements, which are a cost imposed on a property owner, and those high construction costs, and the site that is fairly challenging to develop, we perceive, we don't know what the exact numbers are or what the exact configurations of a development plan need to be, but we understand that the most cost-effective way to build housing is in relatively tall, relatively dense buildings. What I have been told from many people in the construction industry is that four-story buildings are the most cost-effective construction type on a per-unit basis. So, a couple other items too, given our site constraints, and again this is something that the committee's wrestle with to this day, we know that the developer needs some design flexibility. Traditional zoning tools like large setbacks and big frontage requirements, things that push buildings really far apart, we know that those result in higher utility and road costs and result potentially in more pavement and stormwater runoff. Those things also add to costs and make it harder for a developer to afford to provide affordable units. And then last, I already mentioned just limiting costly design requirements. I mean, we all, we all have our aesthetic preferences. Many of those were discussed at length in some of these meetings. And, you know, there's, there isn't, you know, unanimous agreement on what things should and should not be included in these draft zoning amendments. But by and large, you know, the, we've tried to steer away from, you know, aesthetic standards that may prove to be too costly to build a project. Next slide, please, Bob. So what is not, what are we not focused on today? First one, I'll say, actually meant to bring the press release that the town manager put out last week, but there was some interesting timing on, a Seacoast Online article last week, given that we've been in water conservation measures since July. But anyway, we know that we have water supply issues. We know that the water district is limiting new connections to their utilities right now. We are not going to solve that problem or really meaningfully address it in this zoning amendment. You know, that is something that the water district is actively studying, and we hope to learn sometime next year where our real limits are and what options we have in terms of finding or creating new supply or not in the future. What also is not the focus of this, I've heard many smart people say very reasonable things about where they think we should be focusing new development, and that's great. We are going to talk about that a lot in the comprehensive plan project that I'm also managing, but that is not the purpose of this meeting or the zoning amendments that are before you. I just want to throw that out there, and then again, I already said this, there is no development currently proposed. Every parcel in the business park is owned by a private property owner. The town is not proposing any development, and there are no designs that we are, we are putting forward for review or comment. So I, you know, I know there was a proposal some years ago for a certain number of units. We are not talking about that today. And then last, I also know that, well, all over Kittery people are concerned about traffic and what our master planning is for mitigating for traffic, improving flow and safety. Just as we're not looking at a specific project design today, we're not going to solve traffic or safety issues on Martin Road or Route 236 through this zoning amendment. That we have transportation planning process, I'd be happy to talk with you, any of you, about that outside of this meeting, but that's not what We're doing today left. Next slide, please, Bob. Oh, I thought maybe there was more for that one. So this is my last slide, next step. So we're here, big planning board hearing today, but I want you all into this is not the end. This is really just the beginning of the end, right? So planning board will hold their meeting tonight. Parts of it may be continued to future meetings. Planning board will need some time to decide what they want to do with all this, but then ultimately zoning amendments are reviewed and either adopted or amended or not adopted by the town council, your elected representatives. So someday, maybe soon, we don't have the dates determined, there will be another public hearing on these amendments with the town council unless they choose not to take it up at all, right, which I hope that doesn't happen after all the work we put into it. I'm looking at the counselors in the back of the room, so anyway, I just wanted to present this information for those of you who are concerned. Nothing final is happening today. Nothing final is going to happen in the next couple weeks. There are going to be more opportunities to study what's being proposed, what gets changed based on your input, and what finally goes before the legislative decision makers of your community. I believe that's it for me, and we're really here for you tonight, so I'll stop talking. Thank you, Jason.
[32:28] Speaker F (unidentified): You've got a sign-in sheet there, don't you?
[32:36] Chair: I have a sign-in sheet here, multiple pens, microphone and we're about to open the public comment section, which you're all here for. Could I get a show of hands about how many folks are here to speak? I'm looking around 15. You
[33:13] Speaker G (unidentified): want to just mention that if you sent an email, you have the opportunity to speak as
[33:18] Chair: well. If you'd rather have your email, sure, that's co-chair has a good idea, that essentially if you did submit an email and we have told you that the emails didn't all make it into the packet, so we may not consider them. If you want to speak on the subject of your email and you weren't planning to speak, you can also speak. So I'm trying to estimate about how long, let's say 20 speakers at, we're gonna do a time limit, and the point, the point of the time limit is really to make sure everyone gets a Chance to speak, and that the board has sort of a competent way to take in the information tonight. So we're going to do a three minute limit on each speaker, and we're going to have a nice impersonal timer up on the board that you will be able to see, so you'll know when your time's up. And Jason, did you query the folks on Zoom if any of them are here to speak or just to watch? Okay. Looks like we got six attendees in Zoom. If you intend to speak in tonight's hearing, the chair has asked if you would raise your hands. I see one. You can change your mind later, but we're just trying to get a feel for how long tonight's meeting is going to be. So far I'm see, I saw two hands, Russell. Okay, so we'll just estimate a total of about 20. There may be a couple of town committee members here. I know there's at least one who is not planning to stay for the whole meeting, and I'm gonna give him a little deference and have him speak towards the beginning of the session, or ask him to, I should say. So we're asking three minutes per speaker. We'll use a timer up on the screen. If questions come up that need brief clarification from up here, either a board member or staff may do so if it's necessary, and there's no, we don't know if that's going to happen or not, but that's a possibility. We're going to ask that there be no repeat speakers. The point being, we want everyone to have a chance to say their piece at least once, and then if there are repeat speakers that want to come up, we'll leave that up to the board to determine if that's going to be allowed. This is a public hearing to get community input. It's not a debate night, and we're really asking you to express your views, no matter how strong they are, in a respectful manner. We do have, obviously Jason has indicated this is going to end up at Council, so this isn't your last chance to say things about this, and the Planning board is not planning to deliberate on this proposal tonight or make any final decisions. We will continue the matter to work on this at another meeting, preferably the next meeting, and that also may be a time when we take all of the written comments that have been submitted and make sure that they are either read into the record or summarized for the record, because that's an important aspect. Right, at this point we will open a public hearing, and whoever would like to go first, please do. Hi.
[37:35] Lois Marshall: For those who don't know me, my name is Lois Marshall and I'm on the conservation commission. I'm speaking for myself tonight though. I live at [address] in Kittery. What I want to do is to remind everybody of something that Jason already reminded you of, and that is that the term affordability means a lot of different things to a lot of different people. There are people who have eight hundred dollars, nine hundred dollars a month in income. Affordability is going to mean something very different to them as opposed to somebody who is a successful business owner who has lived here in Kittery all their lives and have a beautiful home all paid for. You know, that's affordability for them is a lot higher. Then there's the in-between people, the people that work in the outlets, the people that work in the businesses, people who have fixed incomes of Social Security. It's not much money and it's getting to be less every day. I'm just asking that everybody keep that in mind when they're thinking about this, that we have people all of those categories here in Kittery and some of them need more housing. They don't have a place to stay. Some are literally living in their cars, which is not a good place in the winter. And that's basically all I had to say in the matter. Thank you very much. I'm
[40:15] Brad Hurst: Brad Hurst. I live at [address] and I come tonight as a member of the diversity equity and inclusion ad hoc committee of the town of Kittery. On behalf of the town of Kittery diversity equity and inclusion ad hoc committee, we are writing again to voice our strong and continued support for the efforts of the housing committee, planning board, and Kittery land issues committee to address the critical needs for affordable housing in Kittery. This statement reiterates our earlier communications to you this past May. We understand that the housing committee has, at the direction of the town council, most recently been working on a draft ordinance to replace the existing business park zone with zoning more attuned to the needs for additional housing and in particular to support provision for a substantial number of affordable units. It is clear that sufficient affordable housing is in short supply. Given our charge as a committee, we are concerned that this shortage particularly affects our most Vulnerable populations, we believe that an increase in affordable housing opportunities would serve all residents of Kittery. As a committee, we unequivocally support zoning changes that expand affordable housing in order to foster the vital and fundamental need for a thriving and inclusive community. Everybody.
[42:12] Emily Flinkstrom: Good evening, my name is Emily Flinkstrom and I am vice chair of the Kittery housing committee. I'm also that representative, a representative of the committee to the Kittery land issues committee. I'm also co-executive director of Mainspring and a resident here in town. I'm given all of the hats that I wear, I've been intimately involved in long and thoughtful journey that this proposal has been on. I want to emphasize that in the end this is the product of extensive public input, committee collaboration and compromise. It doesn't give everyone everything they wanted but it reflects a serious effort to balance those priorities. I support the proposal before you tonight and I want to start with why this work matters. At Mainspring I see the consequences of our housing shortage every day. Families struggling to remain housed, working people who cannot afford rent, long-time residents being priced out of our community and a growing number of people living in their cars. We may have different preferences about the types of homes we choose for ourselves but our community needs a range of housing options that includes apartments for young adults starting out, smaller homes for older residents looking to downsize and housing for teachers and other workers who want to live in the community they serve. Through our comprehensive planning process a number of years ago Kittery identified this area for growth. It's close to major transportation corridors, employment centers and existing infrastructure. It's not a perfect site but when we ask why here we also need to ask where else. We can't meaningfully commit to addressing our housing shortage without identifying places where housing can actually be built and I want to emphasize something about affordable housing specifically. This zoning was developed with an eye toward making affordable housing financially feasible, not simply allowing it on paper. Affordable housing is extraordinarily difficult to build. Construction And infrastructure costs are high, while the rents and sale prices are restricted. On the other side, every additional requirement has potential cost and restrictions that reduce the number of homes that can be built, can make an already challenging project financially impossible. That's why the details of this zoning matter. We need meaningful protections, but we also need enough flexibility for affordable housing to actually get built. The environmental concerns about this property are legitimate. The town's hydrologic study identified low impact development practices as a way to mitigate potential water quality impacts, and the expanded LID standards in this proposal reflect an effort to address those concerns. The water districts recent announcement raises a separate concern about water supply that must be addressed before development can proceed, but that immediate challenge shouldn't by itself determine our long-term land-use vision. We're not approving a development tonight, we're establishing a framework for future housing, including affordable housing, subject to applicable protections and review. Development has impacts and we have a responsibility to minimize them, but not building housing has consequences too, and we have an equal responsibility to address those. I believe this proposal reflects a concerted effort to take both responsibilities seriously, and I support moving it forward. Thank you. My
[45:47] Anthony Volk: name is, excuse me, my name is Anthony Volk. I live at [address] 2 Old Dennett Road on adjacent property to the proposed site. I'm against this proposal. I've lived in Kittery for over 13 years. My wife and I moved here because of the quiet small town atmosphere, in a community that seemed like it looked after its own. It was a place where I thought I would live until I die. I. Today, I'm not so sure. In many ways, the town of Kittery seems to prioritize the wants of outsiders over the desires of its own taxpayers. Repeatedly, the people of Kittery have opposed developments in this area, and I believe this is the fifth time the town officials have shown they're not concerned with what the residents want. Here we go again. I watched as the town forced the sewer on Martin Road. I watched as it connected to the giant new apartment complex. I now have to see every time I look out my window. It seems Kittery is run by developers and outsiders and not its own people. This proposal is far too intrusive and goes above and beyond state regulations. It destroys even more of the nature and wildlife that makes Kittery what it is. The construction itself will change the landscape and create new environmental concerns for the surrounding areas. And all this for what? How will another giant complex improve the lives of its residents? How does this make our small town community better? While I won't begrudge private landowners from developing, this area should be zoned for residential suburban use and should not allow another giant complex. Smaller buildings that blend into the community and not large ones that stick out. This still benefits the landowners but won't affect the surrounding community nearly as much. The town of Kittery has responsibility and obligation to its taxpayers and not developers. The only people who benefit from another giant developmental proposal are people that don't live here or are benefiting to make it happen. Please stop selling out the town of Kittery and destroying our community. Please zone the area for residential suburban construction separately. The affordable housing thing like this is crazy to me. Like as a taxpayer, Maine's a super expensive state, one of the highest tax burdens in the country. No one here is proposing to subsidize my cost of living because I don't make enough money. The idea of importing people that can't afford to live here, like it doesn't benefit the town, it doesn't benefit taxpayers, it doesn't benefit me at all. And I feel like the town should be more concerned with the people that live here and make it work and pay to be here and not people that don't. That's all, thank you. [Chair: Thank you, I've] got to go back to work. Have a good night. Who
[48:30] Chair: wants to go next?
[48:38] Andrew Parker: Andrew Parker, seven Martin Road. Kind of new to this, so you don't forget, would you sign in for me please?
[48:44] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, thank you all.
[48:56] Andrew Parker: Right, I've only lived here four years, live in seven Martin Road. I have thoughts about large complexes as we all see through Newington, Portsmouth, and some of them seems like they're getting, they're not filling up quite a way, so I don't know. I don't see that as the future, and I don't see that as the way to low-cost housing for me, low-cost housing. There are other ways besides rent control, regulation, all that stuff. Honestly, if you want low-cost housing, make this zoning residential suburban and honestly, you can put some trailer parks in there. That is a lot cheaper to develop, low cost for people, and they have a non-aminity and their own dwelling, modular homes, smaller items, essentially dwellings, and it will keep the footprint. And I want to say the, I don't have the space, and you won't have the eyesores that people are talking about. I just think smaller developments a little bit at a time way better than and the landowners of Kittery getting a little bit buyback versus large complexes going for broke, that we can just do incremental small sections at a time. Well, I don't know, that's my thought for now. Thank you. Hello.
[50:50] Jennifer Bassett: My name is Jennifer Bassett, I live at [address], been there for about 18 years, and I am, I agree with what most people have just said. I recognize the importance and the value of affordable housing. The person two speakers ago said something about importing people here, I don't think that's the issue. I know there are folks here that you know need housing. I also strongly feel the importance of protecting wetlands, keeping reasonable setbacks, which I know has been discussed and is in the preview of the council, and most people are for that. They don't have anything new or original to add, just putting in my feelings. I hope there's a balance to have both affordable housing and to protect the environment. I do like the idea what the previous gentleman before me mentioned about smaller housing, smaller footprint. I realize the woman over at Footprint said that, I think it was you, said that the most economical way for affordable housing is four stories. I think it was someone else that said that. Yes. I'm not an engineer. I don't know these things. I don't know. Four story seems kind of high, but how high are the buildings that are already there on Dennett Road? I don't know, they're not the prettiest buildings. I just, I wonder if there's an in-between. Like I said, I'm not an engineer. I am for affordable housing, but also very concerned about over development and protection of wetlands. Thank you, thank you, thank you so.
[52:54] Speaker G (unidentified): Members of the board, I'm just going to preface this is my wife.
[52:58] Speaker N (unidentified): Hi, I was going to preface it too. Her comments are our own, they are definitely my own. Welcome, I bet you.
[53:05] Chair: You've been here before, or is this your first time here? I.
[53:08] Speaker N (unidentified): Think I was here once, but maybe pre-Ethan.
[53:12] Chair: You don't watch them on TV when you're home, right? Sometimes.
[53:16] Speaker N (unidentified): I don't know, it's kind of boring. Anyways, I submitted this as a letter, but I guess they're not going to be read tonight, so saving you the effort of reading it to each other at your next meeting. I'll read it aloud tonight. Hello Kittery town staff and planning board, including my husband Ethan. For clarity, the views expressed here are definitely my own. As a Kittery resident, I wanted to quickly share my thoughts on the proposed zoning changes for the business park. My preference would be to see the. Property zoned residential suburban, in line with its surroundings. I also hope any amendments will be as restrictive as possible when it comes to density, building height, setbacks, and lot coverage, while preserving plenty of green space. And why I request this is because I live just half a mile from Seacoast Residence, and I have experienced over the past couple years firsthand some of the very negative impacts of larger developments that they have had on our surrounding neighborhoods, particularly. When it comes to traffic, infrastructure, and absolutely the natural environment. Those realities have made me much more aware of how development decisions can affect the town and the people who live here. And as a side note, in an attempt to be an informed citizen, I tried to scan the residential neighborhood zoning amendments document published online. I respectfully asked for clarification on line 158, which seems to allow developers to satisfy up to 25 percent of their affordable housing obligation. By transferring land to a nonprofit. So my question, which Jason answered via email today, was why is the town creating a special exemption that allows certain nonprofit organizations to receive land as part of a private developments approval. In my opinion, Kittery does a great job providing substantial support to nonprofit housing initiatives, and I don't think our zoning ordinances should be written to create additional opportunities for land transfers. Thank you for your time and consideration and I just Jason answered my question so I wanted to share based on the town's limited experience this appears to be the biggest bang for buck thank you
[55:23] Chair: Thank you we'll
[55:34] Dean Bensley: Keep in the family. I'm Dean Bensley, Ethan's father, and I've been there for about going on 40 years now. I did submit an email which I understand isn't going to be read. I did not come with that email to read it, so I'll give you some general comments, just a couple, briefly. In general, I understand anything like this is compromise and different perspectives. My perspective is I would like the town to continue in a fashion, you know, in the fashion that I saw the last 40 years. Some of the recent development does not follow what I would consider Kittery's, you know, perspectives, and it doesn't fit in. The development we've seen recently does not fit in with what I like in this town. I'm not against affordable housing by any means, but it's all priorities again, right, how much do you get for what. So in general I'm against what Jason pointed out as I think what we're looking at is large dense buildings. You've seen some of that and I don't like it. I hope that the Planning Board moving forward with this thing considers maintaining the town flavor, and I know that's subjective too, but not going towards tall dense buildings, maintaining natural resources, and that would be my general comments.
[57:43] Matt Brock: Good evening. I'm Matt Brock. I am chair of the Kittery Housing Committee. I'm here to speak in favor of the housing committee's proposal and ask that you recommend it to town council for approval. I have heard several things I agree with. This is about compromise and I understand that, you know, these are sensitive issues to people, but I want to also make clear the housing committee did not on its own just decide to make a proposal for affordable housing in this zone. And Jason made some reference to it, but I want to say the comprehensive plan, which was approved by the voters of this town, was approved by the Town Council and state of Maine designated this area as a designated growth area with an emphasis on housing and particularly affordable housing. So we were tasked with implementing what the voters said they wanted in this zone. First point I'd like to make, we spent probably close to two years developing this proposal and we also recognized an environmental protection was important, it's important the housing committee as well. So for example, wetlands protections, setbacks, the housing committee did not disturb any of that. What you have is what you will go forward in the housing committee proposal, low impact development standards. Kittery's expert, this is not the housing expert, Kittery's own expert said implementation of those standards would provide adequate protection to the watershed including Spruce Creek, which is a stressed water body. Again we were concerned with that, we included those standards and we elaborated on those standards at the request of the Kittery Land Trust in our most recent proposal. We included additional language on that and in terms of open space, currently as I understand it, there is 25 percent in this zone for open space and our proposal maintains that. Open space is important in every part of this town. You have 25 percent now and we maintain that. Our concern with the comprehensive or the ConCom proposal was they want more open space than is currently provided for and I think there's two problems with that. First, that's inconsistent with comp plan said or the comprehensive plan said the direction of this should be, we should be going in more housing and they want more open space so we feel like we compromised on maintaining status quo. The other thing is using the ConCom's own cost estimates, we very roughly, and we don't have a development proposal in front of us, but very roughly would add millions of dollars to the cost of a project out there and adding millions of dollars to an affordable housing proposal or development seems completely inconsistent again with what the voters approved. So given that, we feel like we've tried to and think have adequately addressed the Important environmental issues raised, and given that, we would ask that the planning board recommend approval. Thank you. Thank you, Matt. Hi.
[1:01:41] Mary Alice Appoint: Everyone, I already timed this and it said it was two minutes, but I went really fast when I did that, so I'll go a little slower. Good evening, I'm Mary Alice Appoint and I'm the chair of the Kittery Conservation Commission, and I'm speaking on the commission's behalf tonight. I know the planning board has received a memo from us, and you've also received quite a lot of facts, but I want to leave you tonight with just one number, and that's 17. the draft before you right now says that as matt just mentioned 25 of the 68 acre parcel must be open space that's 17 acres we agree that 's a number our concern is what's allowed to be counted on those 17 acres as written those 17 acres like Matt just mentioned could be made up of unbuildable land wetlands and setbacks that already can't be built on we disagree that 's the open space that's the vision of what the citizens of Kittery want right now the areas that can't be built on are vital They should be protected by law. They are counted, they are protected by law, but counting them as open space is duplicitous. That's not open space. Protected lands can't be counted twice. They can't be both protected lands and open space. So we're asking for one change, that the 17 acres are comprised of real forested upland set aside permanently, probably around Gary Creek, in addition, in addition to the wetlands, not instead of them. This isn't our opinion alone. The town's own Spruce Creek watershed. Management plan says this watershed is already stressed. The draft itself names wooded buffers as the best stormwater protection that there is. A forest around Gary Creek doesn't, does that work for free. Everyone in this room knows how meaningful Fort Foster, are Fort Foster is, the Kittery Town Forest, Rogers Park. These green spaces mean a lot to this town, and it makes up the character that this town is known for. There's some of the places that we love the most, and someone in your role in the past. Had to decide to keep those. The dent, this Dennett Road neighborhood deserves the same real trees, real woods that are set aside on purpose. The conservation commission has decided to support creating affordable housing in this area, but only if it's coupled with real protections and land protections and dedicated land. Thank you. Don't.
[1:04:51] Chair: Start the timer yet, please. I just want to not take a break, but I do. I think after this speaker I want to see if there's anybody on Zoom that would like to speak and work them in also, because they are here in a sense. I am
[1:05:14] Sharon Clark: Sharon Clark and I live at [address]. I am in support of the conserved, oh sorry, I'm in support of the Conservation Commission's proposal asking for additional preserved forested open space around Jerry Creek. They are asking for open space requirements of 25 percent of the land. I honestly feel they're not asking enough. This area of Dennett Road has been the subject of great contention over the past several years between those who want to develop all of the property and those who want the land preserved. It is clear that the majority of the residents of Kittery are very concerned with over development of the town and the fact that precious wildlife habitat is being destroyed at an alarming rate. People don't want every single inch of Kittery to be developed. Why can't we have a balance? We don't need to destroy every inch of land so that people can move here from other states. Kittery is a beautiful small town and we the people would like it to remain that way. The residents have made it clear several times they do not want a large development in that area of Dennett Road. New zoning has been proposed but once again the people's voices aren't being heard. Those who have written the new zoning claim to be supportive of the people's wishes for more conservation but the new zoning proposal does not reflect that. I understand the owners want to make money on developing their land but are they willing to compromise? Millions of dollars can still be made by developing half of that parcel and donating or selling at a reduced price the rest of the land to perhaps the Kittery Land Trust or the town for conservation. This is a true compromise in which all sides win. How about thinking outside the box when it comes to zoning and development, creating space for existing wildlife. Humans and wildlife can and must coexist. Compromising on zoning and development requirements would make it much easier for developers to get the green light and support from the residents. I realize that LD 1829 makes it very difficult to create zoning that is environmentally friendly, but I would ask that all the town officials and also the landowner and developers meet together and have a serious discussion on how to try strike a true compromise and set aside land for conservation and also allow reasonable development for the town of Kittery. I am asking that a newly proposed zoning be rejected and sent back for revision. Town officials need to take the residents wishes for true conservation seriously. Yeah, thank you Sherry. Any takers on Zoom?
[1:08:06] Chair: All right Russell, we've got two hands up. Lisa Lena hands and has been up for quite a while. So Lisa, I'm going to say allow to talk. Are you there? Lisa, you're on mute, I think. Lisa's either having technical difficulties or... If she can get off mute, maybe she could go next. Is there anybody else? Any other Zoom attendees wish to speak at this time? Please raise your hand. Not seeing any. Russell, now Karen Burbank, I am going to allow you to speak please.
[1:09:13] Speaker R (unidentified): Please go ahead. Hi, I'll be pretty brief because I wasn't prepared to speak anyway, but I totally agree with Sharon Clark, the previous speaker, that we do need to have a meeting with everyone involved. Just briefly, my land abuts, my land abuts the Dennett Road land, it's on my D98 Dennett Road land, and also abut the previous developer and back of me who filled his wetlands with all of the dirt and debris and asphalt from the sewer project, and as a direct result of that I was flooded with three devastating floods in my home so i am very i really do think it's important for kiddery to have some affordable housing i don't know if that's the place to put it or all of it maybe some of it but i do want it to be very carefully thought out how that land is going to be developed i'm done thank you anyone
[1:10:45] Matt Brock: else in Zoom? Not
[1:10:49] Chair: seeing any hands. Russell, is Elisa still trying or no? Lisa dropped off the I think there's probably an email that an email that will be submitted for her that we'll read at the next meeting. So yeah, so we do have a hand up, Elizabeth Lascelles. What's that? We do have a Hand up. Okay, who is that? Elizabeth Lascelles. Okay, go ahead Elizabeth. This is actually James Brown and my wife Elizabeth Cells. Hi James, we're having trouble hearing you. Is it possible to get closer to your microphone? Any better? A little bit, thank you. Sorry about that. I sent
[1:11:35] Speaker A (unidentified): an email but I guess it's not going through, so I guess I'll just keep it short if the mic's
[1:11:39] Speaker G (unidentified): not working here at 10 Nordia Lane with my wife Elizabeth the Cells and we're
[1:11:48] Speaker A (unidentified): just definitely against this. I'll try to get the email in or get on the next meeting, thank you.
[1:11:53] Chair: Thank you. Okay. Anyone else in Zoom? Seeing none. Yeah, if more hands come pop up we can go back to Zoom at some point. Anybody else here for, I actually got an email come
[1:12:18] Speaker S (unidentified): She said she's got the screen message that she gets when she tries to click.
[1:12:23] Chair: Can I show it to one of you? So it's not working for her somehow?
[1:12:27] Speaker S (unidentified): Correct. Yeah. Would you like to see this? [Chair: See what the...] She said what she's seeing on the screen when she tries to click.
[1:12:37] Chair: Yeah, that's not my expertise. We trust you. I believe you. We're not trying to keep her out and we will have her email read out loud at
[1:12:49] Speaker S (unidentified): the next meeting. While I'm here I'll do mine. Jeff Clifford, 27 Miller Road, Cary Point. I'm a member of the CLIC committee and also the open space tiering committee. I've also worked on five workforce housing projects as a, on the project team as civil engineer, so I've been intimately involved with this for a long time. I want to acknowledge all the work done by CLIC, by town staff, planning board, and the public. I also want to acknowledge how difficult it is for the public to try to follow this information that gets presented and I do it all the time and it's still hard, so I just want to let people know that it is not easy, so thank you for trying. As a CLIC member, I was invited, I was involved with many of the meetings except the last one, which has some pretty important stuff going on and new information. And also one other thing that I did, it's not all about me, but I prepared the stormwater management plan that, or portion of the RN that got accepted last Thursday by the housing committee. So I was pleased and thankful to them for putting it in there because there's some pretty important information about this very special watershed. See some Prioritization of Stormwater management practices. I'm gonna skip ahead so I don't lose my time about one thing. I said some questions for the planning board. What is the status of legal review and it has there been any done and if not, when will that occur? Did the town receive a $15,000 grant for legal costs to help with ordinance preparation? I thought it might have. Okay, Jason's shaking his head no. And will the playing board tonight be discussing the latest rounds of amendments and information that you received? If not, would there be more workshops? shops. I'm going to go back to my original piece. I submitted two letters today to the planning board. And I'm not going to try to go through those all because I don't have the time. But first one was about open space and the need to coordinate with section 16.10 of the conservation subdivision ordinance, which outlines what open space is supposed to be when you're in a residential zone. And none of that coordination was done as part of the click work so I see that as a gap that needs to be addressed and in that gap it talks in that part of the ordinance that talks about the land that should go into the upland basically and that's where it's defined it isn't defined yet because this ordinance didn't this is new but that's supposed to be coordinated with that section. Also the second bullet, second email I wrote was about the Maximum Impervious Service and I think Jason did a great job of bringing some more information into the discussion about impervious service. It got put into the ordinance but after it went through the housing committee they made some changes to it that I don't necessarily agree with. But also, there's a big gap. It all talks about what's on the individual lots. But there's also land that's going to be potentially right away that's going to have a roadway in it that's going to be impervious. There could be open space that would have impervious for ball fields or whatever, too. So there's some pieces that need to be put together. We aren't there yet. And we're really looking forward to the planning board discussion about these things. things, and if the CLIC has to weigh in on some of these issues again, and I think they might, I certainly look forward to doing that.
[1:17:02] Chair: Jeff, your time is up. Thanks, Jeff. Just before the next speaker, Jason, do you want to address whether there has been any legal review at this point? As far as I understand, there has not. No. No, that wasn't necessarily part of, intended to be part of this product. I need a final product to review first anyway. Yeah, and then as far as the grant funding goes that we do, we were awarded, the town was awarded a grant for updating the town-wide zoning to comply with the main laws. The time spent on this business park zone has not, has not been deemed by myself to be part of that project. So we're gonna be tracking time and an effort for the grant program in our next zoning project, which we've already started working on. Sorry, chair, if I may. Sure. Before we move
[1:18:10] Speaker G (unidentified): on it, so is there going to be a legal review of this proposal? I wasn't
[1:18:15] Chair: intending for there to be one, but if you or the council raised issues that would warrant legal review, that's, we have a town attorney. Thanks. And I, just have two cents to say about housing. At the last meeting, which was last week, did accept many of the recommendations of the click committee and put them into the housing proposal. So housing committee is not completely stuck on its own work. They are receptive to outside, you know, other committees and listening, and you know, that's just, that's my housing committee hat, that's just, I wanted to say that. And so we do have a slightly different proposal than we've had at any time before. It's in my opinion better. Okay, I'm done. Go ahead. My name
[1:19:15] Speaker S (unidentified): is Ramon Legere. I live on [address]. I'll make it short. It sounds like we want a town, not a city. Good
[1:19:54] Tom Emerson: evening. My name is Tom Emerson. I live over on [street]. I'm a member of the housing committee, I'm also a member of click, and I also do affordable housing advocacy both locally, regionally, and at the state level. It's important to understand that all affordable housing is subsidized. It's either subsidized by the market rate units that go into a project or by federal programs, state programs, philanthropy, private programs. There's no such thing as housing that simply happens to be affordable when they build it. So understanding how financing works is essential. Suburban residential zoning does not allow buildings of more than four units by right, but almost all financing programs, especially at the federal level fund, do not fund less than five units. So if you switch to four units, it's going to make it really hard for anyone to fund those kinds of projects. Allowing a non-profit housing provider with much greater access to affordable housing funding can create more deeply affordable housing. Than 80%, 80% is the standard. The most nonprofits that are providing housing work at a much more deep level. We've heard the concerns of differential maintenance that were brought up at the last year, last meeting, and we've tried to address those online 166 in the most recent proposal, just basically saying all the buildings have to be maintained to the same level. So in terms of funding, allowing someone else with greater access to federal funding than your standard developer allows us to do better. Generally, as the housing advocate, separating out affordable housing from market rate housing isn't, it's a no-no. This is a specific instance where we can do better this way than we can just do it in a normal way.
[1:22:10] Chair: Thank you. Anybody else? It's a race to the podium.
[1:22:44] Helen Betts: Hi, I'm Helen Betts. I live at [address]. The current apartment's back up to my house on the other side of Dennett Road. I have two things. First,, the relocation of wildlife has been a really big hit since those apartments have been there. I currently have, I would say, a herd of five deer mostly residing in my backyard. When I first moved to Kittery 40 years ago, I never saw a deer in my yard because there were a lot of woods behind us, and now the deer are there constantly. So I worry about the relocation of the wildlife that are currently trying to live across the street. And secondly, how do you, my question is, affordable housing. How many people in Kittery who currently are having trouble being housed, affording their rent, are they living in the apartments that back up to our house currently? Will they be able to move into any new development if this goes forward? How do you know who gets those affordable units, quote unquote affordable? I worry about that. I mean, there are unhoused people in Kittery, people who are struggling, but are they moving into those apartments? I don't know if anybody tracks that, but if it's important to help the people in Kittery afford their housing, there should be some way of doing that, and not, you know, some young people from Massachusetts who work down there and just want a cheaper place to live. Not against that for them, but it would be nice to take care of the citizens of Kittery first. Thanks. My
[1:24:57] Romi Charlesworth: Name is Romi Charlesworth and I have some disparate questions to ask and a couple of remarks. I think first I wanted to mention that in reviewing the survey questions on the latest is comprehensive plan, it was overwhelmingly that people wanted to keep the small town feel and actuality of this town, and I think that adding high density high buildings housing runs contrary to really what people want. And if we think about, there's been a lot talked about affordable housing, but what our standard is, that for affordable housing, as it is legally defined, what we have to get is we have a hundred the ratio is a hundred market rate houses compared to ten affordable houses, and when you look at the overall rent or sales of that actually raises the market rate mean for the town, and that in turn raises the affordable rate of the town, so you're really not getting much for affordable housing in this kind of a situation I don't know I know that as Tom said it needs to be subset that affordable housing needs to be subsidized in some way the way that's being suggested by this zone change i don't know why we're calling it an amendment is that we're not subsidizing housing in a way that we could by federal subsidy and that's i think that 's really what it what we need and we haven't done that at all because we're doing this trade-off where we're getting very expensive housing it's more expensive than New York City right now and we're getting a lot of it, so it really changes our numbers too, and I think that according to our latest survey this is not what people want, as was said so eloquently. We are not looking to urbanize, I mean I don't think most citizens want to urbanize. What we love about this town is wildlife, access to nature, clean water, abundant and water, and access to you know being able to be cohabiting with many creatures and plants, and having dark skies that we can see stars at night, and this is just exactly the direction that this project isn't going in, so I think that we should be able to come up with ways in which we can introduce affordable housing that's truly affordable without having to increase the dense overall density and market rate. Also wrote me
[1:28:46] Chair: Your time is up. Okay, thanks. For me, thank you. Who's next, the
[1:29:01] Speaker G (unidentified): enforcer down there? Yeah, doing a good work, accountability and standards. Well,
[1:29:08] Chair: I suggest that we take a short five-minute break, and we'll come back, and the board will discuss how we're going to manage the rest of our wager. Okay, we're back in session, and I just want to poll everyone who's here. Is there anyone who hasn't spoken that would like to speak? I hear a silence. I think what we'll do is not close the public comment quite yet. We'll leave it open but we're gonna let the board discuss how to proceed at this point. Russell, we do have Lisa back in zoom. If she can get on, we would like to hear from her. Okay, Lisa, can you hear me now?
[1:35:49] Lisa Linehan: We can hear you now. All right, Microsoft is not the only one having technical
[1:35:54] Chair: Nicole, difficulties. Lise, you are coming in a little quiet here. Is there any chance you can get closer to your microphone?
[1:36:01] Lisa Linehan: Is that better? A little bit. Okay. So I sent something in that was not able to be included tonight, so I'm just going to read it. Dear members of the planning board, my name is Lisa Linehan. I live at [address], a short distance from the Dennett Road parcel. I'm writing as a Kittery resident and neighbor who has significant concerns about the proposed zoning change and its potential impact on a community. I recognize that Kittery is facing a housing crisis and the state legislation is requiring towns to accommodate additional housing opportunities and greater density. I support thoughtful growth and understand that our town has responsibility to address housing needs. However, I believe we also have a responsibility to carefully consider where growth occurs and what long-term impacts will be on our existing neighborhoods, infrastructure, and natural resources. First off, our infrastructure is already under strain. Kiddery has been under a water ban for months due to drought condition conditions and insufficient water supplies for customers. I personally experienced brown water in my home following main breaks in our aging municipal system. These real challenges we are facing. Before designating additional land for potential hundreds of units, we need to seriously consider whether our existing water supply and infrastructure can support that level of growth. Secondly, traffic and neighborhood safety concerns are another issue. I walk Martin Road every morning. Last week when the Route 95 on-ramp was closed, many commuters took Martin Road as an alternative route. I was alarmed by the volume of vehicles and the speed at which people were traveling. It's dangerous for our pedestrians, children standing at bus stops, and residents. While the traffic diversion this month was temporary, the potential impacts of a permanent increase in traffic are not. Martin Road is an important connector to 236, the transfer station, Shapley Middle School, and other destinations. What would hundreds of additional housing units mean for a road that already serves so much local traffic? How would pedestrian safety be protected? Thirdly, we need to consider whether this is the right place for growth. This parcel that is undeveloped contains important wetlands and it's surrounded by established residential suburban neighborhoods. It's also an area known for flooding. These characteristics can considerable weight in determining whether this is an appropriate location for increased density. Kittery has other opportunities for growth and redevelopment. Route 1, for example, has existing commercial properties and shopping outlets that are underutilized and already have access to public water and sewer. Why are we placing greater emphasis on revitalizing and redeveloping this area? if approved this proposal would create the only zone of its kind in kiddery i believe there is good reason to maintain consistency with the surrounding residential suburban zoning doing so would provide greater protection for the partial parcels natural resources help preserve the character of the surrounding neighborhoods and recognize the importance of wetlands and flood prone areas much of the discussion in this proposal seems focused on the financial feasibility of development and cost to developer why understand those are important considerations they cannot be the only ones we must all could also consider long-term costs and consequences for the town and its residents water supply roads school public safety storm water management wetlands and the overall quality of life in our neighborhoods the question should not be simply whether this parcel can be developed but whether rezoning it is the best for the long-term interest in kiddery i love this town and want to see it grow and thrive, but thoughtful growth requires wreck to us to recognize that not every undeveloped parcel is necessarily the right place for a long large-scale development. We have the opportunity to make a decision that balancing housing needs with responsible land use, infrastructure capacity, environmental protection, and the character of our existing neighborhoods. I respectfully ask the Planning Board to consider these broader impacts and recommend residential suburban zoning designation nation for this parcel consistent with the surrounding neighborhoods. Thank you thank
[1:41:17] Chair: You very much Jason. Anybody else on Zoom? We'll for the moment suspend the spoken public comment section here and decide, try to decide procedurally how do we want to handle the rest of this. Thoughts of the board?
[1:41:46] Speaker F (unidentified): I think you've kind of set the agenda by keeping the public comment open for the email portion that we haven't received, so I think that can be addressed next meeting but keep it at the emails that haven't either been read or we haven't seen yet.
[1:42:10] Chair: Just to be clear, I encourage this approach. People did send comments as they were instructed in the public notices. Those instructions included a certain time limit, and I just want to make sure we, the planning board, is to review comments that were submitted by a certain time today or do you want to keep the record open up to your next review of those written comments? I think if we're keeping the public hearing open we're keeping the public hearing open as to the email comments. I think as to spoken comments I don't know if we need to keep that open. I think this was duly noted and the Zoom was working, people were here, and the only reason we're not dealing with the email, we would have sufficient time, let's say we had 20 emailed comments, we could summarize or read all of those in the next hour approximately and be completely done, but with
[1:43:27] Speaker F (unidentified): that portion of the intake and I think I think we ought to, it ought to be for any emails that we that met the timeline, no new emails, so I'll just put this out
[1:43:40] Speaker G (unidentified): here. Since it's not super late, I did print 13 emails that I received or at least the ones that I was cc'd on that were received prior to the 12 p.m. time today. I know that might not cover everything but I'm happy to read the ones that were received if we want to hear some of them tonight and I didn't get any emails. Yeah, I think it was Russell and myself and then town
[1:44:11] Chair: staff. The only reason I'm not comfortable with that is that like all the information to go through the same door and be handled by the staff and distribute it out to us, then we know there's sort of a uniformity of information and I actually read quite a few of them as they came in today. I didn't print them all, kudos to you. And just so people know, I did read every email I received. I responded to most of them, so if you sent me an email, you either did hear back from me or you will whenever Outlook starts working again. But what I did not do was download them for the packet because I was planning to do that all at once, basically after lunch today, right about when Outlook stopped working.
[1:45:06] Speaker G (unidentified): So could I propose this then, if we don't want to read these, can we commit to reading the emails hopefully in another meeting in totality, in totality? I think that we probably owe folks at least that if they're gonna get kicked to another meeting and not just a brief summary of their emails.
[1:45:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Else, yeah, I don't know exactly, so we'll read them all at another, the next
[1:45:39] Chair: meeting. I think we should make it item one at the next meeting, entirety, get it done, and then we can, if we have some time after that, we can start to structure our deliberations. There's a Zoom hand up, yes, and Elizabeth Edwards. Words, do you want to resume with public comments? I mean, anyone who's here now, we have not closed the actual speaking part of the public comment, so we invite Elizabeth to speak, sure, she wishes to, okay, whoever Elizabeth Edwards, yep, we can hear you. Sorry, Elizabeth, is it possible, can you possibly get closer to your microphone? It's coming in a little quiet. How's this, is this a little better? Oh, that's
[1:46:34] Speaker X (unidentified): great, thank you, better, okay. Just I live right off of Old Dunnett Road, I've lived here for 30 years, I was part of the charrette that we did a few years ago, I remember getting together and talking about what the development might look like on this parcel, and I remember we were supposed to get, you know, a big readout and get notified because we were, I never got anything, thing, that's just one thing aside, so I sort of put it on the back burner. I know that we're -looking at this and I don't have all the information, I've been listening tonight, I've been reading things online, I've spoken with some of the people in the audience here, even up the charette, but I do want to just voice my agreement with one of the letters that was written in by the conservation committee about the requiring at least 25 of the parcel to be held as reserved upland open space. In addition, it doesn't say what kind of open space, and I just think that's a very interesting idea, the idea that it would be contiguous and That whatever is already designated isn't the open space that's part of this proposal. I'd like to explore that more, and that's really all I had to say. And I just wanted to also say I know that there's this has been a lot of work by a lot of different people, and I would hope that the exasperation that I'm feeling from a lot of the people that have been working on this for years isn't a reason to just re-look at it with fresh eyes all again if we can in any way. And I'm also interested in the legality part of all of this, just from a purely you know analytical standpoint. But for me it's it's really the forestation and making sure that the wildlife has place to go. I mean it's not just you know it's not just deer, and I know what this one is saying, and we have lots of deer and turkeys and you know bugs and bees and everything, and it's it's why we love Kittery, it's just what makes Kittery amazing. So that's to me the most important part, that's all I
[1:48:39] Chair: wanted to say. Thanks. Thank you very much. Okay, back to board discussion handling the rest of this evening. It's the only item on our agenda except for
[1:49:02] Speaker G (unidentified): do you want to take a vote now? No
[1:49:08] Chair: not ready, but do you want to vote
[1:49:10] Speaker F (unidentified): We since a lot of us haven't seen the public input and I don't think about it
[1:49:15] Chair: You already agreed to not to close the public hearing, sorry, that was a joke Yeah, I think we're we're going, I'm suggesting that we close the public hearing as to spoken comment and continue the public hearing as to any emails that were submitted by the noon deadline today, and we will have those catalogued and in our packet for the next meeting. We'll make it you know the item business to deal with and read them and then close the public hearing as to that, and then we can proceed to delivery with the commitment
[1:49:57] Speaker G (unidentified): It meant that we're going to read those emails in entirety? No, I think we should
[1:50:04] Chair: read or summarize, and I guess what I should read the emails in the entirety
[1:50:10] Speaker F (unidentified): but for the meeting's sake I think a summary is more than adequate. We read the emails in the entirety and that I will commit to. Yes, there is just one
[1:50:27] Speaker C (unidentified): one more meeting this year for Thanksgiving and Christmas
[1:50:31] Chair: And that's another procedural discussion we can have. Do we want to try to schedule a second meeting in December? I thought we had talked about next week and this month we had mentioned it, but I don't know that I want to, but for notice purposes is that too quick? That's the 19th, so November
[1:51:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Do we what kind of business do we have other than this
[1:51:05] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't know it would be max but no way more than you Jason.
[1:51:07] Chair: I believe you do have three or four applications in the queue for your next meeting for December, yeah, at least one sketch plan, I think a shoreland plan you've already seen, I'm not sure what else, but my recollection is there were three or four lines on that part of the dry erase board that's in our hallway, don't quote me on that, well. there's probably some lack of eagerness to have an extra meeting in I'm willing to do it if the board decides that 's appropriate and it's
[1:51:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Able to be scheduled, I looked at the calendar and the 17th is, they have a meeting at 5 but not at 6, so this space may be open for which month, December.
[1:52:12] Chair: December 17th, yeah, so it'd be the two Thursdays in the middle of the.
[1:52:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Month and what do we plan to accomplish with that additional meeting, that's what.
[1:52:25] Chair: We're talking about right now, yeah, I make a recommendation, that's all the vote I do, it would seem to me if we can do it I think that would be a good idea to figure out a way to send this in some comprehensible way to the council, are we in a hurry for this, I'm not, well, I mean, I don't, if it's in January I'll be watching on Zoom or not, but I.
[1:52:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Think we had just talked at the last meeting about wanting to do our duty and deliver a product one way or another to the town council by the end of the year and.
[1:53:08] Speaker C (unidentified): I guess I, because right now it is just a, it's a business park, you know, so the zoning is.
[1:53:13] Chair: Wide open there, I feel like the housing committee has definitely made some serious accommodations to the work that's been done and willingly so, the housing committee would like this to succeed and they, you know, the last meeting they thumbs up on a whole bunch of amendments that Click proposed because a few they didn't, but you know, I mean, my approach might be to say, well, you take the 25% issue and give it to council, don't, don't make that determination, but I haven't seen any Click, you haven't. Seen the new.
[1:53:56] Speaker F (unidentified): Click input was on the latest version that you sent out, right, correct, okay, yep, that's what you've seen, yeah, that's what that's.
[1:54:09] Chair: That's what I'm talking about, not Click separate, but Click into the, yeah. to be clear and for the record I don't have the exact number in front of me I actually intended to get that number but I didn't have time the land issues committee has been reviewing the amendments for over a year and that's just the land issues committee the housing committee as you already heard me say has been working on it for over three years not every month during that time so there's been a there's a lot of deliberation and input in the amendments that you've got in front of you right now yeah I'd put forth that we
[1:54:55] Speaker G (unidentified): as the Planning Board haven't, to my knowledge, recommended or incorporated any amendments in there though. No, we have no, well
[1:55:08] Chair: if we, if we had an extra meeting to handle business and liberations or what, a possibility we could get through this, and there's a possibility we just be chasing our tails.
New Business
[1:55:23] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't know, Jason, for the next December meeting we have, my suggestion, since you're going to have new board members, you don't put any new business on it. And if you take the new business out of that.
[1:55:42] Chair: I don't know if we can do that, Dutch. When people submit applications, we've got to process them. I
[1:55:52] Speaker G (unidentified): understand that. Well, we could continue to review it.
[1:55:58] Speaker F (unidentified): Problem, yeah. That's just bad practice.
[1:56:01] Chair: Not ideal. You probably have to kind of set it all.
[1:56:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, but when you process it, doesn't mean you have to set it necessarily a planning board date to it either.
[1:56:10] Chair: No, we typically do.
[1:56:12] Speaker F (unidentified): You may do it. That doesn't mean you have to do it.
[1:56:16] Chair: In some cases, we do. There are timelines in code. Couldn't tell you what they are. We could look them up. Well, once they're on your agenda, you have a lot of leeway in what you can do with them. Absolutely. As you've heard me say, we are not the ones who are going to stonewall.
[1:56:37] Speaker F (unidentified): When you put it on at the end of the year with a new board, you just slow everything down when you do have a timeline that the planning board has to face.
[1:56:48] Chair: I think that's bad practice. It could be avoided. I mean, avoidable if possible. It should be avoided if possible. And, you know, I'm not the scheduler, and I don't know.
[1:57:03] Speaker F (unidentified): The only reason I bring this up at all is if we eliminate the new business, that might allow us the time to have the discussion
[1:57:09] Speaker G (unidentified): on this in the two meetings in December we
[1:57:14] Speaker F (unidentified): don't have two meetings in December, I think that's what we're talking about. Yeah, but we haven't decided on that, and we don't know who's available to do it. 's true. I have a suggestion. All ears.
[1:57:28] Chair: You could close the oral portion of the public hearing now and fire away. Way it's only eight o'clock but
[1:57:45] Speaker F (unidentified): we haven't read all of the input from that's true yeah but
[1:57:54] Chair: you do have time to discuss and express the thoughts or concerns that you have right now. I mean this is not the first time you all have looked at this or talked about it. 's just a suggestion I'd be more than happy to go home in the next five minutes and sure you know yeah it was something else if that's what you all want to do. Well I think we could we could take a little time to point out a list of questions and concerns that we might want to consider. I mean it would it would be a good idea to maybe get started on that put them on the record now and we don't have to stay till midnight maybe another half hour you know hour whatever. I'm gonna close the public comment portion of this public hearing and as discussed leave the written comment portion open for review and consideration at the next meeting do we want to do that via motion and roll call vote Russell just so we make sure there's board concurrence on this procedure might as well so does somebody want to make a motion to that effect
[1:59:21] Speaker A (unidentified): are we going to leave it open for written comment like through the end of today or till tomorrow morning because of challenges without look because there may have been a handful of people that sent emails this morning that didn't go through or come in by noon. I feel like this should be a grace
[1:59:36] Chair: personally yeah how long a grace period I'm not a technician here maybe 24 hours
[1:59:45] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm not sure time you decide yeah about till tomorrow okay call business tomorrow okay so if it's everybody hear that you want to send an email if it's
[1:59:59] Chair: It's date stamped by what time tomorrow? Noon.
[2:00:07] Speaker F (unidentified): Noon Friday. Brother Keith, since you got it, make a motion.
[2:00:11] Speaker G (unidentified): I make a motion as such to continue to accept written public comment until noon on Friday the 13th.
[2:00:20] Chair: Okay. And as part of that motion, also to close the spoken public comment portion. So moved. Seconded and now Jason gets to ask us Dutch Dunkelberger yes Earl Dean Wells yes Justin Gonsalves yes Ethan Bensley yes Bob Doyle yes Russell White yes yeah I think we should discuss in sort of a conceptual way what our concerns are if we make it the same as the adjacent zones, which is an oft expressed desire. The adjacent zone does not have the environmental standards that the new ordinance has. Are we talking about amending the adjacent zone so that it protects the wetlands and upland and all that set aside? We talk about brand new ordinance, if I may. Yes, I do want to mention the RS zone was put in place before sewer was brought to that area. The RS zone, if you look at the standards, it's really pretty rural in character and, you know, arguably doesn't really support the type of development that, you know, is fiscally responsible given that type of investment. So I would add that had sewer been in that location 40 or 50 years ago when it was made RS zone, it probably would have been made a different zone. So it's it's it's just my sort of thoughts and observations, but I do think that public sewer investment warrants some other approach. Doesn't have to be significantly other in terms of, you know, what your ideas may be, but I don't really believe that it's it's an appropriate area for RS zoning given that public investment. So then what would you make it? I'm my opinions, I'm apart beyond sharing that observation, I'm keeping records stating urban, at least I am championing the council goals. The reality is it is
[2:03:03] Speaker A (unidentified): rural. The only reason it's potentially urban is because we have a water and a sewer line under the road with sidewalks to nowhere. And council, what's that? Yeah, council
[2:03:15] Chair: made that years ago, 20 30 years ago, council made that determination that was going to be a prime industrial development area of town. It was access to the highway, it was, you know, undeveloped land parcels big enough for warehouses or transfer things or, you know, manufacturing, whatever. Never happened, right? It is also pretty for a reason to be protected. I don't think that was their worry back, but now it is.
[2:03:52] Speaker C (unidentified): Now it's it's weren't the worst, but the 90s weren't the worst environmentally. No,
[2:03:59] Chair: no, I'm not saying it was completely unknown, but over the years since then, we've heard over and over from abutters, Martin Road and others, about the water flow issues that affect
[2:04:19] Speaker A (unidentified): that neighborhood. Has the current comprehensive plan, and I apologize for not being involved in that, but is this still a targeted growth area?
[2:04:29] Speaker G (unidentified): So as your representative from the planning, I held a meeting in the last two months.
[2:04:37] Speaker C (unidentified): And that's when I gave it to you.
[2:04:39] Speaker G (unidentified): But it's my understanding that, yes, this is still listed as a growth area. For debate? Well, I mean, that's, at least in my opinion, the purpose of the comp plan committee is to discuss these. My personal opinion is that back when we did the last comp plan, the specified growth areas had a lot less bite, if you will. But now we have LD 1829 that says if they're designated as growth areas, then thou must allow. And I don't think there's been a conversation, at least on the comp plan, to talk about, hey, should this still be a growth area or not? We just haven't gotten down to that sort of granularity and reconsidered. It's just a growth area because it was a growth area on the last component we
[2:05:29] Chair: haven't drafted a land-use map yeah yet and just so folks in the audience know the reason we haven't had comprehensive plan committee meetings is we are actively interviewing consultants to help to finish the project so we were reviewing proposals in october and we're interviewing the three finalists this month and hopefully we'll make a selection before the next scheduled comprehensive plan committee meeting we may not have that meeting either but we'll at least be able to provide an update and show the committee the winning proposal. That's so. Anyway, I just wanted you to know the Comprehensive Plan Committee did not wander off and take a nap. We're just doing a slightly different piece of the project right now. Yeah.
[2:06:29] Speaker G (unidentified): I would also put forth that the comp plan process is extremely drawn out and takes a long time to develop the current plan, and I don't think that I can virtually guarantee that nothing coming out of the current comp plan committee will be ready in time for us to consider as part of this proposal and current
[2:06:51] Speaker A (unidentified): things goals change from the start of that current time period of that is it's a nice one time to be drafted by the time it comes out another year to
[2:07:03] Chair: develop ordinances or amend ordinances based on the comp plan the goals. Well, I don't know. This complaint isn't an ordinance. It's just direction of the town. It's guidance.
[2:07:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Sitting here right now, I mean, 75% of the people that spoke today were not in favor. We have three committees, subcommittees, that cannot agree on an amendment. And we're being asked to push this through to town council with our signature on it saying that we agree with it. And I don't know, like it just feels, well, at least for me right now, it's like, how do we push something through, say, yeah, this is the plan, but there's three subcommittees that spent tons of time, send our own opinion, drive them nuts.
[2:07:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and we are citizens, we can't go and to the public hearing, right, voice our support or town council, yeah, but we need something and he's there, needs to be a change, we can't let it stay a business park, someone somewhere will.
[2:08:10] Chair: want to take advantage of that I guess what I my view is not quite as dark as yours in terms of the committee's all disagreeing because I think housing took in the work of click understood quick work very hard and conservation was represented very effectively in the quick process so a lot of the conservation suggestions went through click and got put into the proposal by agreement of the housing committee last week yeah but we still heard click and conservation
[2:08:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Tonight that had opposed the opinion that was on that one issue on the, on the percentage issue.
[2:08:50] Chair: That was one that the house, housing couldn't find a unanimous or, you know, opinion on to put it in, largely because of our affordable housing mandate, you know, that if you take develop a land out of the calculation, you reduce the developers ability to subsidize units by building market rate units, I mean, that's how I understand it.
[2:09:21] Speaker F (unidentified): Anyway, yeah, so curious, Matt pointed out, Matt and I'm talking about, they compromised with the Conservation Committee and I don't know exactly what CLIC might have contributed to it. But my concern is in compromising, I think they've priced themselves out of any potential development. This has priced itself out of any potential affordable housing development. It's getting close.
[2:10:04] Chair: Well, I mean, I think, you know, that was our key trigger for each section that was agreed to was, would this be a deal killer? And the information that we had was no, it won't help, but it won't be a deal killer.
[2:10:22] Speaker Y (unidentified): May I say something? No. I'm going to. Okay, it just so happens that I moved to Kittery 30 years ago. And when I came here, I joined the Conservation Commission rather quickly because I knew somebody who was the chair, somebody I had worked with already, and was invited to join it based on the fact that I did understand a lot about wetlands. When this area, 30-so years ago, was signified as residential suburban, Kittery and the state of Maine had very little wetland preservation in any ordinances or statutes. They had very little understanding of it, and they really weren't interested in Russell. You should remember that I would come in and talk to you about wetlands and vernal pools and watersheds endlessly. I know I wasn't, I was annoying myself. It was, it was never ending, and people didn't believe you, they didn't want to do it. So I mean to say that this has been going on for 30 years or more. Well, you didn't have the right information in it, and to say that we should go along with this because this is what it was deemed to be zoned, well, it just doesn't add up now that we know how important this area is to the watershed, to the aquifers, to the whole workings of the entire area there, and all the flooding is due to wetlands having been improperly impacted. So, you know, I mean, you've got to stop. I don't think that's an accurate thing to be bringing up, that this has been there for over 30 years, because you didn't have the right information at that time.
[2:12:38] Chair: You mean that the zone has been in effect without anything happening for 30 years?
[2:12:43] Speaker Y (unidentified): No, that it was even made that, into that. I mean, I lived in New Hampshire for a while. That's why I know New Hampshire is very far ahead of Maine. Then I moved to Pennsylvania, and they were very far ahead of Maine. Then I came to Maine, and Maine was, I couldn't believe it.
[2:13:03] Chair: Wouldn't you say Kittery has, in that 30 years, enacted stricter wetlands protections than the state requires? Right,.
[2:13:12] Speaker Y (unidentified): Right. But had they had the information that was available, a lot of it was available at that time. They just weren't paying any attention to it or somebody didn't want it. I've never understood why Maine is so far behind.
[2:13:25] Chair: I don't think we have town management that was very interested in planning for many, years.
[2:13:32] Speaker Y (unidentified): I could agree with that.
[2:13:33] Chair: Until the past, like, 10, 12 years, we have had town manager who is very connected with the importance of planning and supports it and listens to it.
[2:13:46] Speaker Y (unidentified): But possibly it never would have been zoned the way it is. It would have been rural and had more protection, and the wetlands would have already had more protections, and then we could have stopped the wetland impacts, too.
[2:13:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I want to stand up for man. I mean, I built what I thought was my forever home 30 years ago in South Berwick, and we have vernal pools, we have wetlands, we have a beaver pond on that property, and we, I mean, there were strict guidelines where we could and could not build our home.
[2:14:14] Speaker Y (unidentified): Well, it wasn't hard and kiddery.
[2:14:16] Speaker C (unidentified): So, I mean, Maine is maybe not kiddery, but Maine is not backward.
[2:14:21] Speaker Y (unidentified): Completely. Completely. It's been very slow to move ahead.
[2:14:25] Chair: Well, sort of a town-by-town patchwork, in a way. Yes.
[2:14:29] Speaker Y (unidentified): And then for a while Kittery has been more restrictive than everybody else. We decided to be more restrictive, and now that's all turned around. To only seem to want to do as far as the state is things, but sure we can be more. Well, does the
[2:14:48] Chair: board think that it's desirable to enact something that would have adequate at wetland protections, particularly because in the greater density that's going to be allowed by state law could impact this zone in a negative way without those protections? That's that's sort of a rough understanding I have and
[2:15:11] Speaker G (unidentified): anyone please feel free to correct me. I have concerns with the enforceability, right? I think if I've learned anything on four years on the board it's that whenever there's a question of, you know, can we, the onus seems to default to the developer. And that's probably inherent, right? And I see a lot in this proposal that I think how would we as a board handle this? Specific examples are the building height setback and we've changed the verbiage like three times at this point from usable yard space to buildings to lot lines. Who do we think would be the winner of, you know, a debate if the developer wanted to meet their full 55 foot building height within 200 feet of usable yard space and the developer said no this meets the a requirement and the abutter said no you know that's you know my wooded yard space or that's my garden and it's up to the board to decide, right? And who has the backing and the legal muscle and the money to win that? And I don't think we want to get into that sort of circumstance with ambiguous language that seems littered in this proposal, right? Because when the language is ambiguous and it's not clear-cut and there's not clear-cut restrictions it's impossible for us as a board to effectively adjudicated, right? And so if I've learned anything from these four years it's that ordinance proposals, especially ones of this scope and this importance, be very clear-cut. And I don't want to pick out every example, but I think it sounds like Dutch has some concerns as well. I think that this reads more like a wish list that came from the developer or like-minded folks, and I think it would be very, difficult for us to enforce force what I take in as the public opinion on this, which is to restrict this as much as possible as able from state law and to basically enact the wishes of the people and keep this under control. And I just see this proposal as
[2:17:57] Chair: rife with well I guess I look at it from the side of a developer. I want an ordinance that's easy to interpret, not easy but I'm able to interpret it clearly so I know what I can do so I don't run into these problems when I come in front of a board. I say you know that's that is what I want, but there
[2:18:21] Speaker F (unidentified): are that's what we want. There's a lot of you have to plan to put electrical conduit in different parking spots and onto buildings so that at some future point they might want to hook up solar power or some kind of electrical appliance or plug-in cars. Now if I'm a developer and I'm running against a deadline or I'm running against a cash flow issue, guess what I'm gonna do. Copper wire costs a mint right now, yeah
[2:18:58] Speaker G (unidentified): so just to clarify I'm not saying we need to get specific with things like that. I'm talking setbacks and yard space, I understand that, but
[2:19:07] Speaker F (unidentified): that you know Dennett road setback the whole ordinance with regard to what it specifies in here and it has the potential to create I think a lot of different issues. For the past few meetings Justin has been saying that this is not the right place for affordable housing, and right now I have to agree with him that the affordable housing you know we had approved a hotel that was never built on route one, two hotels, so two hotels right across the street. I'm not even talking about the bypass, I'm talking about the north end. Put the Marriott up, yes, yeah, it was supposed to be the Marriott
[2:19:54] Chair: right, but it never got built, it never got built. Why couldn't that be, I was at the Homestead right
[2:20:00] Speaker F (unidentified): right, why couldn't that be a three or four story affordable housing center
[2:20:07] Chair: no, as I understand there is a limitation on water and sewer in that area right
[2:20:13] Speaker G (unidentified): now without bonding a upgraded lines. Feel free to send an email until Sue
[2:20:22] Chair: sewers as well, sewers the issue on route one, it's very finite. I don't, I don't I think a lot of people would just nod their heads to what you just said. Why in
[2:20:35] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, okay, but again, so do it, to put it bluntly, I say zone this thing is RS just because a previous council made a an error as far as where they put the sewer.
[2:20:49] Speaker A (unidentified): That's not our problem. Could you do take all this work and put it into another growth area zone in town to incentivize affordable housing in the area that but
[2:21:03] Speaker F (unidentified): But if you put it on Route 1, then you actually put it close to centers of working, shopping.
[2:21:10] Chair: I think maybe you guys didn't hear me. There's very limited sewer capacity on Route 1. I understand. Okay. Just want to make sure you heard that.
[2:21:17] Speaker F (unidentified): The town doesn't have a problem with bonding things because they bonded the fields. They bonded the community center. So they don't have a problem with bonding. And I know that some of the bonds that they have terminate this year or next year. So they've got plenty of room to bond it if they want to build that sewer.
[2:21:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Or if you pulled four developers together that wanted to build on Route 1, I'm sure they would chip in if there were some incentives.
[2:21:50] Speaker G (unidentified): Would you be willing to share, just expand a little bit on your thoughts on why you don't think affordability is an option in this proposal?
[2:21:59] Speaker F (unidentified): Or in this proposal, in this proposal primarily because all the additions with regard to adding
[2:22:09] Chair: electrical connections, let's say you took all that Christmas tree ornament stuff out and just back to basics, because you know we can do that, could work if you get back to the
[2:22:26] Speaker F (unidentified): basics what the housing committee had for basic when they presented it to us in the original form, that was workable. The negotiations that they have crafted to put into this, I don't think make this affordable from a development. I still have problems with making, and it's interesting in that making a special exception for not including affordable housing within or allowing affordable housing to be in a separate building
[2:23:05] Chair: and I think that's, I think it was explained to us once that it was a funding consideration as much as anything, not an attempt to segregate, but if we get rid of a lot
[2:23:21] Speaker F (unidentified): of the other fluff then maybe that could be also driven out. Somebody correct me
[2:23:28] Speaker G (unidentified): if I'm wrong, we in our ordinance for project to the size we are guaranteed 10% meeting the affordable criteria or a payment in lieu, right, no matter what.
[2:23:41] Chair: Any project larger than 20 units is required to provide affordable units.
[2:23:48] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, so in this case, given the scope of this, I think it's pretty much guaranteed.
[2:23:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Didn't we do a variance, though, for 110 units to eliminate two? I thought we did that on Route 1 within the last year. We did, yeah, 283.
[2:24:01] Chair: Maybe you eliminated some, but you didn't eliminate all. There was still a requirement to provide affordable units.
[2:24:06] Speaker A (unidentified): I think it went from 12 to 10.
[2:24:08] Chair: That may be, but they are still required.
[2:24:10] Speaker G (unidentified): So regardless, either units or payment in lieu, no matter what?
[2:24:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Is payment in lieu?
[2:24:17] Chair: $100,000, yeah. Payment in lieu by itself is not an option.
[2:24:22] Speaker G (unidentified): So we're guaranteed the 10%, right? Right, anywhere. Given the scope of this, I think we're going to have more than 20 units no matter what we do, right? So we're guaranteed 10%. I find it very difficult to believe that this land will not be developed if it doesn't work out in financially feasible four stories so we can afford to do the 10%. I think the reason that this land hasn't been developed residentially in the last 30 years is because perhaps the owner was waiting for the most profitable option, which is large-scale development like this. It doesn't matter if he does it residential, suburban, single-family, duplex, quadplex, 12-unit apartments, or high-density. he's going to they are going to provide 10 percent affordable regardless and so my opinion is that we're we're selling the farm you know and giving away the character of Kerry if you will with the four stories when the developer needs to provide 10 percent regardless whether he does it apartment buildings or less intensive development right and I don't believe for a second that if we zone this for residential use in some form it won't be developed right I don't I don't buy the finance argument on this will definitely get developed it just won't be affordable
[2:26:02] Chair: affordable well they're they have to provide affordable I do want to point out and I mean I haven't seen their actual books but the tide Mark the company that got your approval to build that 100 unit apartment development they were talking about on Route one they haven't started construction because they can't get financing for the project which in theory is probably an easier and let me that's what I was going to say you think getting water and sewer and road utilities to that development is hard no compared to this work so that this is a very limited sample size but based on what that developer is telling us there they want like tax credits and things because they claim that their margin of what they're showing the banks right now does not meet the thresholds for a loan.
[2:27:05] Speaker F (unidentified): That's what they're telling us. Which is why and at least in my opinion and adding all of these other requirements that were negotiated in has really just priced affordable
[2:27:16] Chair: housing. They spent millions and millions of dollars on that piece of land I'm sure they're not letting it sit idle or nothing right like I don't think that's what
[2:27:27] Speaker G (unidentified): they wanted to do with it maybe we shouldn't be dabbling in rent control as a municipality but
[2:27:32] Chair: that's a discussion another discussion yes that 's a discussion the housing committee also has from time to time yeah that's
[2:27:43] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean I'm hung up on that we can't build affordable housing in an ideal location currently and to think that this is going to get affordable housing in a more challenging site it's gonna have to be a certain
[2:28:01] Chair: scale to create the profit that would support putting in the infrastructure and subsidizing the required number of units or doing the payment in lieu so, say, 10 units or 20 units, that's, you know, $1 or $2 million payment.
[2:28:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Or getting a nonprofit in there that has access to state funds to be able to do that.
[2:28:22] Chair: Right, which makes a lot of sense. Yeah. I mean, that makes a ton of sense to me. Maybe I'm biased. But that's not guaranteed. So do we want to set a goal of trying to wordsmith or pick this apart or come up with? recommendation of council based on both word editing and cross this section out or do this or whatever and can we do that in the time that's allotted before the end of the year
[2:29:02] Speaker A (unidentified): not by the end of the year is I don't know there's a lot of really smart people that have been doing this for a long time a long time and that's kind of where I'm at we still don't have something that everybody's in agreement on you're never going to well they're
[2:29:17] Chair: not they're not all going to never going to I mean I think it's our job to try to meld the different stuff or make a recommendation to council that's that's what you're expected to do recommendation positive negative with changes you can you can promote as much policy advice as you would like as part of that but really your goal is to issue an opinion on the amendments and I think we could do that in the time required we may not we may not have to find perfectly wordsmith everything but we can we can say you know we like this part of it we think this is workable we don't think these parts are workable so
[2:30:10] Speaker Y (unidentified): Recommend with closer to the original density and everything out there, and I don't think that's, I can't go along with that because I think it's the wrong place. That's the stuff from state law, Earl Dean. I know, but I still think it's stable. I mean, how can they come down here and tell us we have to ruin one of our most sensitive pieces of property? Oh, it's
[2:30:32] Chair: town wide. It's state, this is statewide, but I don't think we have to implement it right. It
[2:30:37] Speaker A (unidentified): could be the developer will come in and say the town audience ordinance doesn't align with the
[2:30:40] Chair: If you don't want me to do it, I'm going to go to court. Right. If you don't have an ordinance.
[2:30:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Then we'll go to losing court, which is going to cost money, and then we won't be able to have affordable housing. I think
[2:30:56] Speaker F (unidentified): if the council was serious about affordable housing, the place to do it is particularly at the north end of Route 1 or to get the owners of the Kittery Outlet Malls on board to develop different areas of the malls to do that. What with that? Yeah, I know. That's probably the hardest thing about it.
[2:31:18] Speaker A (unidentified): But isn't there landowners there now? I mean, we talked to one a month or two ago that, I mean, they want to develop that land. That's true. They want to be incentivized somehow to develop that land.
[2:31:32] Chair: I mean, the Tide Mark.
[2:31:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Not them, but the other one that came up in the mixed-use zone.
[2:31:38] Chair: You know, I would just offer, I mean, again, you're all smart folks. You live in Kittery. You care a whole lot. Like, it's obvious, right? You've been having kind of this flavor of a policy discussion for, yeah, several months now as well. It's not been quite the endurance event that the committees have held. But, you know, you do have one counselor in the room who's listening, but I'm sure others are hearing your opinions too and I don't want to push you guys around but at the end of the day that's not really the question that's being asked of you right now. I don't want to discourage you from thinking about it and, you know, some of you may have the persuasive abilities to convince the council to change their goals but right now that's the key. I
[2:32:31] Speaker F (unidentified): mean you just put the hammer on the nail here. The council wants affordable housing. This does not meet the council's desire for affordable housing.
[2:32:45] Speaker C (unidentified): The issue north of 91, our north end of Rue 1, is, you know, sewer and water, sewer. How far, I mean, can we get into consortium with York? How far does this, so how close their sewer line? I mean, because we drink their water, it's already Kittery.
[2:33:06] Chair: Sewer Kittery sewer line it's already there the challenge with Route One.
[2:33:11] Speaker C (unidentified): You know I'm trying to say I mean can we combine utilities and services with the other town cuz we get our water from Belmarge that's our stuff yeah that's
[2:33:22] Chair: Not York I mean the challenge is that those transmission mains were built to serve malls and they were not necessarily sized to accommodate a lot of residential development we don't just like just as the water district doesn't know how much water they actually have yeah the sewer department doesn't know how much capacity the transmission mains on Route One actually have they just know that it's limited they were installed literally 50 years ago or even more and they are trying to identify Resources to put the flow meters in and do all the sort of data collection that they need to understand what the capacity is but it's not a lot you know what we're hearing from the sewer superintendent is yeah we can do a project here and a project there but eventually we're not going to be able to accommodate growth on Route One with our
[2:34:25] Speaker F (unidentified): Existing utilities so if the council wants to get serious about affordable housing, and we want to put it there.
[2:34:34] Chair: If they want to get serious about affordable housing on Route 1.
[2:34:38] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes. That bond, a sewer project. Yep.
[2:34:41] Chair: But I do agree with you, Ducks, that we need to try to wrestle this into shape that it does meet the council goals. And if we have misgivings about how our final product, send it to council, tell them what our misgivings are, and say, you know, We've got all these smart people that can't agree and you know some people want this some people want that I mean I had my misgivings about some of the bells and whistles that have been added because I think every time you Add a little thing even if it's just an empty pipe with a rope in it You've got to draw it. You've got to plan it. You got to locate it. You got to put it in, right? There's a whole process No wire, just a piece of nylon rope to pull the wire in the future.
[2:35:32] Speaker C (unidentified): And you've got to future-proof it. Right.
[2:35:35] Chair: And I think, and you don't even know, you really don't even know, is that the technology that people are going to use in ten years? Because everything keeps changing so fast. It's crazy. I
[2:35:52] Speaker G (unidentified): Was just saying, I'm concerned about the basics of this proposal, right? Height the things that we have under our purview and control when we're drafting this ordinance and I can just picture a fight because there's nothing, there's no, for example, there's no specified setback from Dennett Road, right? So I would assume that the 15 to 30 foot that's in there would apply, which is significantly less than the existing, except it's quite a bit of unbuildable land between, right? Yeah, and so you know, we get all these anecdotal things like, oh you know, it's, it's okay if you don't Restrict it at the ordinance level, just naturally it'll work out on the site because the wetlands, and I would put forth that we should absolutely restrict it at the ordinance level and as much clarity as we can on basic dimensional standards, not the extra stuff, but just the basics of our job on the planning board are to really think about the dimensional standards and the things that affect our job, and I think this proposal is lacking in those things and I think it'll open us up to a world of Hurt when we actually get a proposal with a project for this, so that's why I'm not sure whether we can adequately take the time with this proposal to go line by line and look at those important things and come up with
[2:37:23] Chair: A consensus in the current form that it's in. I do want to point out one small thing, Ethan, and I think it's one of the things that you're referring to, among the many other provisions in the main zoning laws, we are not allowed to have setbacks for multifamily buildings that are different than setbacks for detached single-family buildings, that's gonna be illegal or so, that's one of the reasons why some of those buffering provisions for existing residents are written the way they were, regardless, so Anyway, I just wanted to bring that up, you guys might not have known that. Yeah, but that's, that's a, that's a fact, but just
[2:38:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Discussing each of the critical dimensional standards in that sort of granularity I think is important, right? Why is it 15 to 30 feet, okay? Do we agree what are we permitted to change it to? That's the sort of level of discussion that I think the planning board should provide this proposal and I'm not sure we're able to, ready to do that. You've had them in front of you for
[2:38:27] Chair: Months. Yeah, so we have, that's, that's on you. Well, I'd also put forth that the
[2:38:33] Speaker G (unidentified): Proposals changed a number of times, not that much. For example, the this height setback from property lines slash usable yard space, that's a big hold up for me, and that's changed, and I still don't understand we fix it. There's a there's some new verbiage in the latest and the latest proposal. I think it would still be a nightmare for us if it was to come in front of us.
[2:39:20] Brad Hurst: Thanks for your if you're volunteering.
[2:39:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Personal issues and stuff that we don't get it done.
[2:39:36] Chair: I still think there's a pretty strong reason to try to bring this over the line. I'm not in a hurry in particular. I'll be off the board in another meeting or so, and I can watch from the sidelines. But I do think it's been going on for a few years and you know, I think we sort of have a duty to Get this to council and they don't like it. They're gonna have to do something about it. I
[2:40:11] Speaker G (unidentified): think it's gonna be tough, especially when we Get all the written comments in the next meeting, and I'm gonna guess that the majority of them just like we heard tonight night opposed to the proposal. I'm gonna have a tough time significantly going against public opinion if we were to make that choice right. I think what
[2:40:33] Speaker C (unidentified): doesn't go unanimous to town council, I mean you can know I understand your
[2:40:37] Speaker G (unidentified): descent and I certainly do, but I think the public came out tonight and I'm guessing via the email comments as well he's from the smattering that I saw yeah, and so I think that, like we talked about at a previous meeting, right, this is not an application or a proposal from a developer. This is an inter-hittery ordinance, right, and I think that public opinion should, at least in my opinion, public opinion should hold the majority of sway on this.
[2:41:13] Chair: On the other hand, people keep saying, I want to protect this, I want to protect the wetlands, I want to protect the wildlife, and if we do nothing, we are not, I mean, obviously if we do nothing, there's no development. As long as there's no development, okay, that's the status quo. At some point, this will get developed, and I think our responsibility is to try to put in place better engineering and better protections than currently exist. This and I think that's very responsive to the public comment, and I think saying I don't want any or I want I want this to be a wildlife park, well where's the philanthropist who's gonna buy this and create a wildlife park right there isn't
[2:41:54] Speaker G (unidentified): one. I don't think that was a that was no I'm understanding it a little bit I
[2:42:00] Chair: agree you don't hear from people in support you hear from people who are
[2:42:08] Speaker C (unidentified): opposed and i've been vocal i when you oppose something you get out and you're motivated and you come out you don't come out when you're in support so just because everybody who came in tonight might share my opinion i reposed we don't know who in town like people in the housing
[2:42:28] Chair: committee who know that we're opposed to any development are we opposed we want single family homes which will actually do more environmental damage if you build if you build 20 million dollar homes there and you all the infrastructure I don't know that is less damaging than a well-engineered community of more
[2:42:53] Speaker G (unidentified): units I think it's the cars they come with the units that's the primary very concerned and that
[2:43:02] Speaker F (unidentified): land just can be naturally restricted as we saw when there was when there was a project you know wetlands crossings you know and when it comes in front of the planning board that's that's that can be a killer
[2:43:14] Speaker G (unidentified): for any project very tough you're talking about the wetland impacts yeah
[2:43:18] Speaker F (unidentified): from the not or yeah for trying to get to some of the upland areas yeah and to
[2:43:25] Speaker C (unidentified): get to a small buildable area that's going to be very limiting on a structure on so many buildings but
[2:43:35] Speaker F (unidentified): you know i'm just looking at simple stuff i look at where you have buildings and we're going to limit the amount of grass that can be there but there's going to be a lot of families there so where do they play right do it in the parking lots i don't think so but no grass can't 20 grass i think was what it was and oh by the way you can't use public water to water it i'm sorry that just does not make sense to me only
[2:44:13] Chair: in the sense of people irrigate lawns with public water that could otherwise be conserved or used for you know necessary drinking and sanitary purposes but you're telling people they have to use gray
[2:44:28] Speaker C (unidentified): water or waters or water harvest right which rain barrels should be doing whatever but yeah
[2:44:35] Chair: I got my crystal ball at the dollar store. It's a piece of crap. Excellent. But I predict really soon you are going to see townwide irrigation limits or similar water conservation measures being proposed. I think it's a hell of a good idea. If our ponds are four or five or six feet down, there's not water in our lawns anymore.
[2:45:00] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm very confused by the messaging here, guys. Right.
[2:45:04] Chair: That's an aside, and I'm sorry.
[2:45:06] Speaker F (unidentified): So we're going to eliminate the splash pad at the community center then?
[2:45:10] Chair: No, because that's recycled. No, it's not. Yes, it is. I thought he said that was recycled.
[2:45:16] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm getting away in the weeds here.
[2:45:18] Chair: I don't know where that is. It's its own animal. It's auto-off.
[2:45:23] Speaker C (unidentified): It runs for about three minutes and turns off.
[2:45:27] Chair: He did a good job of selling that to us. Do
[2:45:33] Speaker A (unidentified): you know if we're going to see another draft of this, or is this it?
[2:45:36] Speaker C (unidentified): Up to you. I think this is, so we need a working group, or we need to, there's no more working groups.
[2:45:44] Speaker F (unidentified): So here's, so my concern is, you know, the housing committee spent months, click, I don't
[2:45:52] Chair: know how much time they spent. They spent about 14 months. Okay. More than months.
[2:45:57] Speaker F (unidentified): And then to put together in a matter of weeks this negotiated compromise timeline in itself is a little disturbing. Well, would it? I find some contradictory stuff in here.
[2:46:13] Chair: Would it be better to check in with council via a workshop or something focused on, we've got all this conflicting information. I mean, council knows this already, but maybe it would be good to get in a room and say, how do you want us to handle this? You know? I mean. It might help you, Dutch, to know. Forgive me for interrupting, Russell. No, good. What you saw was a changed version, you know, that came out very recently, but those changes were under discussion by the land issues committee going back to like May, so we were not amending the ordinance every single time. The land issues committee came to consensus around something that would change; that was just been a month-to-month ongoing conversation. That all the things that the land issues committee agreed to with through consensus got put into it all at once, so that's what you saw, and anyway, so that's, so it looks like it came out of nowhere, but really it was
[2:47:17] Speaker F (unidentified): building for six months. Right, but it's not just the land use committee inputs, it's the, it's the negotiation to put the conservation committee inputs into it, that's, and that's what the land
[2:47:27] Chair: issues committee was discussing. Yeah, I don't know, I was already probably speaking longer than I should have at the intro to the introduction, but a lot of these details in that project story, you know, didn't just didn't have time to cover, right, but that's, that's what was going on. The conservation commission's suggestions are what the land issues committee was reviewing over the last six months. The housing committee's suggestions they reviewed back in the spring frankly never really had Substantive comments on it with a couple of exceptions by someone who's in the room right now, but that the discussion of the Conservation Commission's suggestions are what really occupied a lot of the substantive discussion over the last six months, and I will say that although the Conservation Commission gives a nod to affordable, it's not their primary mission. The primary mission is to look at this undeveloped piece of land and say what's the ideal level of protection that we
[2:48:41] Speaker F (unidentified): should recommend. Yeah, but then you start to lose, okay, what is the goal? Well, the
[2:48:46] Chair: goal from the housing was to develop an ordinance that balanced the competing issues, meaning some environmental protection, setbacks, neighborhood buffers, you know, wetland protection, in allowing for an express interest of the town for
[2:49:11] Speaker C (unidentified): affordable housing, and you know, so it's it's the cells wasn't in a vacuum. I mean, it feels like it could have been, but it wasn't in a vacuum, you know. We're all trying to we're all kind of like meld conflicting concerns, and it's well, in a
[2:49:28] Chair: way it'd be easier if we had a project, you know, then we could say no. What was
[2:49:33] Speaker A (unidentified): it to justify the money spent by the town for putting the water and sewer in?
[2:49:37] Chair: That's just one piece of the puzzle, but it is a piece of the puzzle. It is a piece of the puzzle. The need for affordable housing is a very big piece of the puzzle if you talk to the town councillors and advocates on the housing
[2:49:53] Speaker A (unidentified): committee, but if there wasn't water and sewer there, we wouldn't be talking about
[2:49:56] Chair: we would not be talking about this today. Right, at all, right, because it wouldn't be it wouldn't be an appropriate site, right, and the developer would probably
[2:50:05] Speaker A (unidentified): prefer market rate detached family houses or market rate housing on that land, so
[2:50:15] Chair: are we trying to, you know, put a square peg in a round hole? I think that's
[2:50:21] Speaker F (unidentified): exactly what we're trying to do, and Jason just pointed out why. That's how I built my house, right, so try to justify that sewer system that's there. That's the only reason we're pushing this for the affordable housing location,
[2:50:42] Chair: but well, we're pushing affordable housing any and everywhere. I understand
[2:50:47] Speaker A (unidentified): that, but if we're really pushing it there by adding housing stock, it's the
[2:50:53] Chair: The only way it can be achieved.
[2:50:54] Speaker A (unidentified): It's housing stock. But that could be market rate. It could be affordable. It could be anything. It's just more housing stock. So I don't know. That's kind of – is this the right place for high-density multi-unit development?
[2:51:06] Chair: That does circle back to locations that are served by utilities. I hate to get into the trunk load of policy reports that we have in our folders, but the this part of Maine is short in supply by thousands of units of housing, and there are so few places that are served by utilities to support them, and we're talking about one of them. From a from a strictly housing policy standpoint, there isn't even a debate here are. We have we chased our tails Scales enough tonight. Shall we review the minutes and move along?
[2:52:03] Speaker G (unidentified): What are we doing about the meeting in December?
[2:52:10] Chair: I'm okay with having a second meeting in December, but I feel a tidal wave of enthusiasm.
[2:52:25] Speaker C (unidentified): I move for a meeting December 17th at 6. Here.
[2:52:34] Chair: Somebody want to second that for discussion? Discussion?
[2:52:38] Speaker G (unidentified): When's our, I'll second it for discussion. When is our regular scheduled meeting?
[2:52:47] Chair: Thursday before that, the 10th.
[2:52:50] Speaker Y (unidentified): But how many things are we gonna have on the agenda then that's going to take up the meeting, and we may not have enough time to even discuss it?
[2:53:00] Speaker C (unidentified): We have three on the whiteboard, Jason said.
[2:53:02] Chair: Well, if you schedule a separate meeting, then the separate meeting will just be focused on this. Is that my understanding correctly? So if you schedule a meeting on the 17th, it will be just to continue this conversation. You could you could always see what the agenda is like on the 10th, try to get through it then, and then you could cancel.
[2:53:27] Speaker A (unidentified): What's the other option? We read out the emails and the additional public comment, and then we could vote on recommending or not recommending this ordinance as is, or we sit there for another other meeting, wordsmith it, go back, and after we wordsmith it, then we said.
[2:53:43] Chair: Either of you there are don't recommend it. I don't think anyone will criticize the board if you take some time to make recommendations in terms of text or whatever, to the extent that you have the wherewithal to come up with them. Well if. We if we could meet the 17th, what we could do is handle our regular business this next meeting, put a placeholder on the agenda for this item as well, maybe handle it, maybe handle it then, maybe not, but and if the 17th is necessary, we keep it, if not so.
[2:54:28] Speaker F (unidentified): What are we going to do? I mean, before I vote on whether we're going to have a second meeting, I want to know what we're going to do with that second meeting. I think we should. Yeah, that's.
[2:54:37] Chair: I think we should get the major objections that you feel are barriers. You feel there are major things in here that are barriers to making it work as an affordable housing proposal. Ethan feels there are barriers to enforceability, which he either wants to understand why is it worded this way or make the wording clearer to satisfy your concerns. Those are the two things I see and I'd like to have if we're gonna recommend it
[2:55:12] Speaker C (unidentified): with changes I'd like to have like at least a list of our so to speak waivers what we would like to see change they're worded differently
[2:55:23] Speaker A (unidentified): but to your or Ethan's opinion like when we just not recommend it right because it's you can do that aligned with what you believe suitable for right and it
[2:55:34] Chair: just moves you can't do that right now like I'm just still like finish your
[2:55:37] Speaker A (unidentified): public you're gonna spend all this time these guys are very educated professionals hopefully educated in this industry and I don't know I mean I'm in the industry I'm still sitting here I'm like do we really have the professional right of all to wordsmith something and say yep now this is perfect let's go never gonna be it's not I just am like never gonna we're chasing our tail you
[2:56:03] Chair: Look at every zoning.
[2:56:04] Speaker A (unidentified): It's like either, as it is, they put something in front of us that I think is.
[2:56:09] Chair: They're all in probably as. They all prevent more good things than bad things. Correct.
[2:56:15] Speaker A (unidentified): So it's like, I don't know, I'm kind of like ready to.
[2:56:19] Chair: Well, you could send it forward with a written list of concerns and issues. Right. And say it's, you know.
[2:56:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Either we're against it for these reasons or we'll support it if these are changed.
[2:56:31] Chair: change but you know or to say we don't recommend this because of the following yeah well and we
[2:56:41] Speaker A (unidentified): or we do recommend this but we are concerned about it I could recommend it and some could
[2:56:45] Speaker F (unidentified): not recommend it right it doesn't have to be unanimous right so usually when that happens
[2:56:51] Speaker A (unidentified): it's like could you say I recommend it with these only if these aren't incorporated then I don't recommend it is individuals I mean I don't know if we're going to get a consensus of this
[2:57:05] Speaker C (unidentified): board sitting here by that's what the public hearing is for to an email
[2:57:10] Chair: I bone up on the rules around motions and how many you can make and so on because it's possible that like you know Ethan may make a motion to say I move to recommend adoption with these following changes and someone might second it but then in the end you might not agree on that and then somebody else could make another but I move to or we
[2:57:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Amend these Ethan's so I'll do a motion on the table. Speaking of motion, we do
[2:57:44] Chair: which one is it? I'd say to have an optional second meeting that's cancel tentative. Yeah, and then I should provide those written comments for the December 10th meeting, and we'll have it on the agenda. Yep, and have it advertised as such, so that if you can get through them we're done. It can be done, and you can decide to cancel the 17th, but meanwhile we will prepare for a meeting on the 17th. Is that, yeah, is that what we're discussing? Yeah, I haven't voted yet, but
[2:58:23] Speaker A (unidentified): I want to make sure. And then the plan for the 17th is to go line item by line item if we need to, if
[2:58:29] Chair: we need to, we need Christmas. Hopefully you've all done that before then. Oh yeah, see mine are all
[2:58:35] Speaker F (unidentified): in pain, just saying that's not a lot then. Oh, you haven't seen the other pages. Yeah, so why don't we
[2:58:46] Speaker G (unidentified): all plan to come at least partially to Dutch's level of preparation to the December 10th meeting with our each individually marked up copies of that with what we want to see. Yeah, let's try to
[2:58:58] Speaker A (unidentified): talk through it on the 10th, and which one are we marking up? Yeah, so the latest one that's marked
[2:59:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Marked 11-9, I think. All of them on today's agenda item. One in the packet. One in the packet. All right. That's good. Still a motion on the table. Yep.
[2:59:21] Chair: All right. I second it. Okay, it's seconded, and that's from... That was my motion. All right. If we know what we're voting for, are we ready to take a vote? That was my motion. What's that?
[2:59:32] Speaker C (unidentified): That was my motion. It was your motion. So I can't second it.
[2:59:35] Chair: This is already, I thought didn't you second it even for a discussion? Yes, it has been. There's a motion on the table has been scheduled a second December meeting on the 17th. All in favor, aye.
[2:59:49] Speaker F (unidentified): What are we voting on? I was talking, I ended up meeting, she was having another separate meeting.
[2:59:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I, we're having a subcommittee of a subcommittee. I'll bring cupcakes. Oh, okay.
[3:00:03] Chair: Here.
[3:00:05] Speaker C (unidentified): I just wanted something an official in case other people need to come in. Please
[3:00:15] Speaker Y (unidentified): are we going to do the minutes? Please, I absolutely adored October 8th, but I'm abstaining because I wasn't even here, so it was wonderful though, just such a real thing, made you feel like you were
[3:00:32] Speaker A (unidentified): there. I'll make a motion to approve the October 8th 2026 kid replanting board meeting minutes. It's in September 24th.
[3:00:40] Speaker F (unidentified): No,, no,, no,. Only one.
[3:00:43] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. October 8th, 2026. No,, no,. No?
[3:00:47] Speaker F (unidentified): No. There is a line 59 on October 8th. Oh, [Speaker Y (unidentified): the 1700, yeah.] Yeah, there was no recording of the vote on that. She had 1700 there. I think it's probably that
[3:01:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Left five then five zero. I
[3:01:20] Speaker G (unidentified): believe so. That's probably how she types it in. Yeah
[3:01:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Well now because we had seven people here, right? No,, you weren't so it would have been Leah wasn't here
[3:01:29] Speaker G (unidentified): That's six and Leah or not
[3:01:32] Speaker F (unidentified): No, Leah was here. We assume she's oh, yeah
[3:01:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Maybe we could ask to go and look back at the video and reclarify
[3:01:43] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it was six zero you can amend your motion so that was that was the only five zero I know I think it was six zero Leo was there she
[3:02:01] Speaker G (unidentified): should we just watch the video she can and
[3:02:06] Speaker F (unidentified): amend it appropriately then you got
[3:02:09] Chair: We've got to amend line 88, which says 7-0-0, even though we have six members. Yes.
[3:02:15] Speaker Y (unidentified): Oh, that's nice.
[3:02:19] Speaker C (unidentified): We'll have Max vote if he'll leave with us.
[3:02:24] Speaker G (unidentified): How about we fix those and we'll...
[3:02:26] Chair: Okay, so as amended, whoever made the motion.
[3:02:33] Speaker A (unidentified): So I'll make a motion to approve the October 8th Kid re-planning board meeting minutes with line 59, change to 600, and line 88, 600.
[3:02:48] Chair: Second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Okay. How about the next set?
[3:02:55] Speaker F (unidentified): I move to accept minutes of September 24th as written.
[3:02:59] Chair: Is Leah here? Second. Yes, she was. All in favor? right okay one more oh is there another set no but i will get in big trouble if we don't do this okay let's do it november 2027 regular meeting a year from now a year from now yeah would be on 11 I can't remember that's Veterans Day yes so your regular meeting would be on Veterans Day and whatever the bylaws you have say would put your alternate date on another holiday or some day that town hall isn't open. So you need to decide when to hold your November 2027
[3:04:10] Speaker G (unidentified): meeting. Is this something that could be tabled until the new board is seated? No. It could make that decision?
[3:04:16] Chair: No, because we have to make the calendar for next year. What's wrong with the 18th? Is
[3:04:23] Speaker F (unidentified): there somebody already in here?
[3:04:26] Chair: Could be. I don't know. That might have been the issue.
[3:04:30] Speaker C (unidentified): it might be the Conservation Commission will either be the fourth of the 18th
[3:04:36] Speaker F (unidentified): yeah it's interesting because my calendar already shows the Planning Board on the 18th but that's I think that's a recurring the fourth is a poor
[3:04:45] Chair: authority so you can't do it then fourth is Thanksgiving there was there was a reason the 18th wasn't gonna work unfortunately I don't I can't I can't access the email that tells me what the problem is how about the fourth let's propose the fourth
[3:05:01] Speaker A (unidentified): now that's poor authority poor authority i thought i had the 11th as a second yeah but the 11th is veterans day oh the 11th is veterans day sorry i thought you said the 17th and the 18th
[3:05:14] Chair: There is a reason. There was a reason. And let me see if I can access my emails because it's going to be hard to propose a date if we don't know when this place is available. What about the 10th,
[3:05:26] Speaker C (unidentified): the day before? Sure. No, I'm asking. Yeah, is that good? Wednesdays are the
[3:05:33] Chair: Wednesdays are almost guaranteed. No, there's no business. Let's do Wednesday special. We'll, we'll put Wednesday the 10th in the calendar and we'll make sure it's confirmed when you, because I believe you, I believe you will set your 2027 calendar in your next meeting, so that's why I was asked to
[3:05:51] Speaker A (unidentified): cover this today. So I make a motion to move the November Kidder replaying board meeting till 11 10. November 10, 27 at 6 p.m. Second. There we go. Well done. I make a motion to adjourn the November 12th Kittery playing board meeting.
[3:06:20] Chair: And I seconded it. All in favor? Aye.