← Back to MaineScanner

Phippsburg Zoning Board Addresses Standing and Standards for Historic Dock Appeal

2026-11-12 · 3h 15m · Source: Board of Appeals (Town of Phippsburg (Town Hall Streams))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[7:25] Speaker A (unidentified): 30 which is the scheduled start time it's november 12 2027 few housekeeping items to take care of before we pick up the needles on the docket we do have four members here which is a quorum so i think we have the whole number of members we need in order to make a decision to hold a hearing. We do have minutes from the last public hearing, which was April 27th, 2026. There were two appeals that were heard that day. Momkern and Duncan, did everybody read the minutes? I know that you weren't there, so you're probably not going to be voting around the minutes this time, but did you guys, did Roland and Proctor, did you guys read the minutes? Yep. Do you have any comments or questions before we take up a vote? no I'm good I don't want to make a motion to accept those minutes so we do have two public hearings today they are interrelated the first is the historic George, 1774 in LLC, and then represented by Kristen, and then we have Joshua Bate, [8:49] Speaker B (unidentified): who was represented by attorney, [8:51] Speaker A (unidentified): what's your last name again? [Speaker C (unidentified): Ambly. Ambly, okay.] I know that there are a couple preliminary items that the parties wanted to talk about, including but not limited to the standard review and standing, I believe. You guys have a standing issue. were you going to challenge standing correct okay and also that i do have a couple of documents that were just handed to me that one of them was dated november 9 2026 and then there's a department order from the dep it doesn't have a date do you know when this was issued yeah and i apologize we [9:27] Speaker D (unidentified): just received those stuff yeah and with the other 30th have you got either have you seen these [9:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you want an opportunity? Do you think it's material to your argument? [9:39] Speaker E (unidentified): The ones to DEP approval, which I've seen. What's the other document? [9:42] Speaker F (unidentified): The other one's the Army Corps approval. Army Corps of Engineers. [9:45] Speaker G (unidentified): I have no objection to that. [9:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, you're okay with that. I'm in the record. So let's start with the standing issue. Do you guys want to be heard on whether to what extent the two appellants have standing? [9:58] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, I guess I'll take this one. We challenge the fact that they've filed under businesses, they haven't shown that they've been agreed. They've filed under what? They've filed under the names of businesses and they haven't shown that they've been agreed. [10:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you contest that they are abutters? [10:18] Speaker H (unidentified): I would contest that the 1774N isn't an abutter, but it's also, I'm not sure if she's representing the, it's owned by a trust. I'm not sure if she represents the trust or if she represents Sarah Dugan. So I think there's a, there may be a standing issue there on who she actually represents, Kristen. And as far as Josh Bate, I think he owns the building, but I don't think the business that he's filed the appeal in is. [10:48] Speaker D (unidentified): We can't find Bate Trading reflected in any of the deeds for the property. [10:52] Speaker I (unidentified): File it both as Mr. Bates and the entity, Big Trading, being left in was a typo. It should have just been under my name, but I think the appeal was under both your names anyways, right? [11:02] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I think they both have standing, but can I, can we just get clarity? Are they, are you challenging Joshua the individual standing or just the businesses? Right, yeah, I think he does. [11:13] Speaker H (unidentified): Own the property, right, so I don't think he's been agreed, and I think that's a requirement. So I know. Well, [11:24] Speaker D (unidentified): According to what we looked into, you have to show something more tangible than just being in a motor. [11:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Your argument is that they don't have, the entity doesn't have standing, right, and they're conceding that. We don't need to be a part of this appeal, right? Mr. Bateman of itself is sufficient. Sure, okay, so we can, we'll, we'll grant the denial of standing as to the entity, but not Mr. Bate. Now what's your argument with respect to Kristen's clients? Well, I'm not sure that Kristen [11:58] Speaker E (unidentified): hasn't said who she represents. The appeal does. I represent 1774 and LLC, which is a business that's [12:06] Speaker D (unidentified): directly harmed by the doc, but similar situation, we couldn't find them named in a deed related to [12:13] Speaker H (unidentified): of a property. When she said something interesting, that they're aggrieved, I don't believe anybody's [12:18] Speaker A (unidentified): probably, that's, that's the part of the issue, right? We're going to hear how they believe they [12:23] Speaker B (unidentified): are aggrieved, right? I mean, it's hard to make a determination on whether they're aggrieved [12:26] Speaker J (unidentified): what they have to say about it. No, I appreciate that clarification. Well, we're not going to [12:34] Speaker A (unidentified): bounce this on standing grounds right now, right? You can say whatever you want about standing as you, and I'm happy to give you more time if you don't. Okay, we're going to hear the parents. [12:47] Speaker K (unidentified): I just would refer the board to the shoreline zoning ordinance section 18c defines a group party to include a butter. So what's that? [13:00] Speaker G (unidentified): I think what is it, Shane, is that right, it's trying to point out is that under the code, you actually don't need to be aggrieved to have standing before the Board of Appeals under the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance. It's sufficient to just be in a mutter. Although, of course, if we go to court, then a grieve does come back in, so we'll probably take the opportunity to put some evidence in the record as to particularize some trade, if that's appropriate. [13:26] Speaker A (unidentified): So, yeah, that's fine. They have their, they preserve their vernal rights. I hear your argument. We know what the ordinance says. We can, we're not, we're not going to dismiss it on standing ground right now. And that's how that brings us to the second housekeeping issue, which is the standard of review. [13:43] Speaker K (unidentified): Sorry, just before we get to that, just for the record, can we, oh, I pointed to a test but I meant to take a vote. Yeah, I think taking a vote on whether there's standing might be helpful here. [13:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Does anybody want to make a motion? Okay, so what I believe the conversation fleshed out is that there's no objection to denying standing as to the entity that Mr. Bates, Mr. Bate, included in his application. What's the name of that entity? Bate Trading. Bate Trading. Does anybody want to make a motion to deny standing as to Bate Trading? They're conceding that they don't have, that it's not a necessary part of the, you do? [14:35] Speaker G (unidentified): Do no, I don't, okay, yeah, sure, I don't know that a motion on that is necessary if we're voluntarily [14:41] Speaker C (unidentified): withdrawing. Okay, so just for the record, you're just gonna, yeah, well, we'll be trading the entity [14:49] Speaker G (unidentified): as an appellant and retain Joshua individual as our, okay, does anybody want to, is [14:58] Speaker A (unidentified): everybody in favor of, for purposes of this hearing, finding that Mr. Bait has standing before the [15:07] Speaker L (unidentified): Board of Appeals? Can anyone make that motion? I'll make that motion. Anybody want to second it? [15:12] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm sorry, I'll have to ever say. All right, same motion as to Christian's client, which is 177, the Historic 1774 Inc LLC. Anybody want to make a motion to determine that they have standing for purposes of this hearing only? Anybody [15:38] Speaker M (unidentified): want to second? Sarah is the [15:43] Speaker E (unidentified): there's the principle of the LLC, the LLC operates the, then so [15:50] Speaker A (unidentified): we got, we got a motion. Anybody want to second that motion? I'll second it. All right, okay, so for purposes of this hearing, Mr. Bade has standing for purposes of this hearing. The Historic 717 1774 again has standing. Now moving to the standard of review, does anybody want to be heard on that particular issue? [16:15] Speaker G (unidentified): Sure. As we raised in our appeal letter, I think the correct standard of review is de novo. I say that because down below, the planning board was not required to have a public hearing and in fact did not have a public hearing. There were many opportunities for members of the public to comment because that's how they chose to run the meetings, But they never legally noticed it as a public hearing and we're not saying that's defective. That's correct They did it correctly. They were not required to have a public hearing and they did not Same with mail the butter notices. I mean many of others found out but there was no formal about our notice process Nor was there required to be one under the code in that circumstance when an application type is not Required to have had a public hearing and not required to have had a butter notices [17:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Kristen, do you have a... [17:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I would tend to agree with that. If you look back at the proceedings, it sort of had the trappings of there having been a hearing and notice, but there was no requirement for it, nor attention to make sure that anyone with an interest in the project was heard. [17:25] Speaker A (unidentified): You have counsel, so I can hear counsel. You want to tell me? Sure. August meeting. Yeah, we'll get to that. I got it. Do you guys, do the applicants have an opinion on the standard review? [17:39] Speaker D (unidentified): I think as we captured in our response letter is whether you call it a public meeting or a public hearing, it captured all of the same elements regardless of what term you put on it. There was notice provided to the public. They were provided an opportunity to comment. We know that opportunity was provided because both the appellants were there for numerous meetings. and so they have an opportunity to voice their opinion. [18:03] Speaker A (unidentified): So are you suggesting that it's not the NOVA review? Correct. Then you just provided two documents that are on the record before the planning board. What are we supposed to do about these documents? [18:17] Speaker D (unidentified): You can ignore them for tonight. [18:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you actually send notices to the abutters? No. No. [18:26] Speaker H (unidentified): And from what we understand, we were not required to. [18:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, which is, I think, the point that they made, which, because you didn't send [18:33] Speaker H (unidentified): the notices that it's- And we are familiar with the, we've looked at the Board of Appeals rules, and we understand that could be an issue that needs to be decided by the Board of Appeals. Right. [18:44] Speaker D (unidentified): And so just from my understanding now is because there have been a number of numerous DOC applications that have gone through the planning board and approved, are those now all need to be re-reviewed because there was no public hearing associated with it? [19:01] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I think you didn't need to have a public hearing. It just matter whether or not you had a public hearing that affects what we can accept into evidence. [19:09] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, and I apologize, I'm having trouble hearing it. [19:13] Speaker A (unidentified): You didn't have to have a public hearing, but the fact that you didn't have a public hearing means that we have the ability to accept additional evidence into the record at this point in time. That's all that means. If we don't have to go back and start anew, it just means that to the extent you have additional evidence that you want us to entertain in connection with this appeal, we can listen to it. Same with us as well. [19:34] Speaker G (unidentified): I'd just like to note for the record in case this becomes an issue at a later date and what Joshua was reminding me of is that at the August 11th hearing the Planning Board did explicitly note that this is not a public hearing and there is no public hearing for this application. Again, that's not a defect, that's just how these applications are processed. [19:51] Speaker E (unidentified): And just to draw a contrast, when a public hearing is required under the Shoreline Zoning Ordinance, it has to be posted into public places, published in a newspaper, which with the case law being what it is in the law court, it's extremely important that anyone with an interest in an application have an opportunity to come and participate before it gets down the road in an appeal stage where you're based on the record so airing on the side caution with the de novo seems appropriate. [20:21] Speaker K (unidentified): Here Kevin would it be helpful for me to read to the board the provision of the ordinance that [20:26] Speaker C (unidentified): addresses standard of review sure so actually if I could just interrupt I mean if it's the [20:32] Speaker D (unidentified): board's determination that it should be a de novo review I mean we're willing to accept that okay just in the essence of saving time sure I think probably for the record you can just read them. [20:42] Speaker K (unidentified): I'll read the de novo provision, and then you can vote if you see appropriate. So Board of Appeals Ordinance Section 4A4D states that when hearing an appeal of a decision made by the planning board or the code enforcement officer that did not require a butter notification or a public hearing, the board shall act in a de novo capacity. The Board of Appeals shall here decide the matter afresh, undertaking its own independent analysis of the evidence in the law, making findings of fact, and reach its own decision. Right. [21:14] Speaker A (unidentified): So it says shall, so, and there's no letter notice, so I don't think we even have discretion, right? I think it's shall means shall, and so we're going to put it to a vote, but I'm not sure we have discretion anyways but anybody want to make a motion in favor of applying to know what we do in the context of this hearing yeah so for those housekeeping issues taking care of I think the former jurors person make Can I [21:57] Speaker E (unidentified): just raise one, I think Kate will go first, on each of these issues and I'll probably follow up behind. As a sort of a preparatory thing, having just decided that it's a de novo review, one thing that I think seems extremely important is a site walk. Is what? A site walk. Okay. The planning board did two site walks and had a lot of visual information, and there's a lot of visuals in play in these arguments about the impact on the area and on the abutting buildings, and so I think it would be really helpful for the board to see that itself. Not saying that this proceeding shouldn't happen tonight, maybe we get all the evidence and then send the information on the record and then go take a look before a final decision is made. So that's just one ask I wanted to make. [22:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I know that there was an issue with the last site walk about who was able to attend the site walk. Is that going to be an issue here as well? [23:04] Speaker J (unidentified): It'll be an ongoing issue, that is correct. [23:08] Speaker A (unidentified): And there's still a existing no trespass order in effect? [23:12] Speaker D (unidentified): And there's also an existing criminal trespass that's in effect. [23:16] Speaker G (unidentified): If I could, when it's appropriate. Go ahead. [23:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Could we do a sidewalk without Mr. Bate available as long as counsel's there? I [23:30] Speaker I (unidentified): don't see why I should be excluded, but that's the only way it's going to happen. [23:36] Speaker G (unidentified): It's groundless. So I just want to clarify for the record, as far as we're aware, there are no criminal proceedings related to trespass. I mean, that's not true. [23:45] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, I wouldn't object to you saying that, because obviously you aren't informed. [23:49] Speaker D (unidentified): He was cited by Ranger Birch of the Forestry Service. [23:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, I think we're getting outside the scope of the. I think what I hear is we're asking for a site walk. I think it's a valid request. I have no idea what it looks like over there. I was trying hard to piece together what we're arguing about. So it would be good for us to see it in person. I don't know if you guys have a difference of opinion, but I think it makes sense. I think we're here today, so we can flesh out the legal arguments, and then we can schedule a site walk, and in the interest of comedy and moving this along, not raising additional issues, if Mr. Bate is fine with deferring to his counsel [24:31] Speaker B (unidentified): at the site walk, I think that would be. [24:33] Speaker I (unidentified): I'd rather see, sorry. [24:35] Speaker G (unidentified): Can I ask that we provisionally move forward with this plan, and then I have a chance to speak confidentially with my client on whether we'll pretty much... [24:43] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, I don't know what the law is. I mean, there's no trespass order. [24:46] Speaker K (unidentified): All we could do is for this board to decide whether the trespass order would prevent that. I think that's outside of the scope of what this board is asked to do. [24:55] Speaker H (unidentified): I think it's important to note he didn't show up at the second sidewalk. [24:58] Speaker J (unidentified): He didn't come. Okay. Well, okay. [25:02] Speaker A (unidentified): There is a provisional plan in place to have a sidewalk that's a date certain that's not tonight. We're going to hear evidence. And what she'll talk to her client about whether it's imperative that Mr. Bate be there as well. And if it is, then we'll have to figure out how we're going to deal with it. And I guess you're going to take through the, you can go first, I guess. [25:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Great. Before I proceed, I have another sort of housekeeping or framing question, which is in the code under de novo review, it says, It says, your job is to look at this application afresh, essentially putting yourself in the same seat as the planning board was. And the question in front of the planning board was, does this application meet the relevant land use standards under the shoreland and land use ordinance? In the Zone Board of Appeals ordinance, under de novo review, it says that talents bear the burden, which we feel that we've met by submitting lots of documents and lots of records. But there's sort of an inherent tension there between what is our burden to show? If the question that you're trying to replicate, the experience you're trying to replicate, is does this application meet the land use standards, are we in the position of having to prove a negative to prove that it doesn't? Is there some obligation on the part of the applicant to run through the standards and show that they meet them? [26:26] Speaker A (unidentified): I think for purposes of preserving the record and allowing us to write a meaningful opinion, we're going to run through the standards. All standards? Yeah. Okay, great. Okay. You're going to have your opportunity to say why the standards apply or they don't apply. And then Kristin can supplement if she wants. [26:42] Speaker B (unidentified): And they're going to have a reason to say why the standards apply or they don't apply. Okay. [26:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, in that situation, should they begin by running through or should the appellants [26:50] Speaker B (unidentified): begin? I think the appellants, it's your appeal, right? [26:53] Speaker G (unidentified): That's fine with us. Okay. So, in this type of application, this is a peer or doc application, there's a special section of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance that applies to these types of peers or docs. Obviously all of those standards apply. Those are in section 15D of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance and then also section 17D are general criteria for any permitted project within the shoreland zone. I believe some of the applicant materials and occasionally planning board also reference the land use ordinance section 12D. Those are identical standards to section 17D in the shoreland zone, so I don't know that it matters which one we cite to. [Speaker N (unidentified): But I, we] are going to focus on the ones we raise in our appeal because these we feel are the sticking points, although again we do think it is the zoning board's obligation to review all standards in the context of this appeal. So, beginning with the issue of suitable soils. Under the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance, Section 15D2, access from the shore shall be developed on soils appropriate for such use and constructed so as to control over them. This was a big issue for us below and it's an issue now and that is that the nature of the soils in a salt marsh, they're soft and that feature is driving a lot of the design of this dock. I mean this is a massive dock. It is much larger than anything in the neighborhood, it's much larger than I've ever seen personally for residential use and part of the reasons for that is the nature of the shoreline in this area it's a salt marsh there's a lot of area to cross to get from the upland area to the water so the soils are affecting the characteristics of the stock in two ways both in its width because as applicants acknowledge they had to redesign the dock to the piers be spaced 60 inches apart, five feet apart, topped by seven foot timber vents. Yes, the decking material itself is only 36 inches or three and a half feet wide, but the actual support material underneath it is much, larger. And the reason for that is that the zones of influence, which I assume means when you stick something into the mud, you sort of compromise the structural integrity to a certain extent. They needed to be spread out, and that's because salt marshes are not an ideal environment for building this type of structure in. For that reason as well, the applicant has had to use helical piles to support these pier posts. Helical piles are a pretty cool technology. I've used them myself in building projects. But they are made of steel, galvanized steel, that doesn't perform particularly well in a marine environment. They're not very long-lived compared to other materials. We have concerns about if these last only 15 years, what is the overall impacts over the lifespan of this structure compared to a wooden structure pinned to granite. I think it's important to remember when you're considering the suitability of these soils that denial is an option. I think what applicant is going to say, I don't want to put words in their mouth so we'll listen to what they actually say, but is that they've done the best job they could in designing this to be as sensitive as possible to this particular parcel. We disagree with that, but even if that were true, you have to bear in mind that simply denial is an option because not every parcel is suitable to have a pier and have shoreline access. It's not a guaranteed right under the zoning code, and some places just aren't appropriate for it. So because of this very, wide salt marsh, you now have a really large pier consisting of, I believe it's a 14 foot access ramp to begin with, five 40 foot long segments, additional two 40 foot long segments, and then a large float at the end, and it's just really, big. [31:11] Speaker O (unidentified): Additionally... But it's no longer than it has to be to get out to the, where they [31:14] Speaker G (unidentified): can dock a boat, right? It's no, yes, it is no longer than it has to be to get to the water, If you consider that a purpose, if you consider that a purpose that they're guaranteed to have, then I would agree that this is no longer than it has to be to get out to the water. I think our point is that you are not guaranteed water access from your property. There are plenty of other places in town to access the water from, including, at one point, my client had offered to use his property to have them access the water. I think that the issue of this helical pile and the replacement perspective is going to be... [31:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Where do 15 years come from? [31:56] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm going to kick it to Joshua in one minute. He has a document on that, and he's going to speak to that. But, yeah, it's just not... I think it's not a good project, and it's not in a good environment for these soils. [32:09] Speaker C (unidentified): Joshua, do you want to talk about it? [32:11] Speaker D (unidentified): And I'm sorry to interrupt. What was your question? [32:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, she said, you know, what happens when these pylons or whatever they are need to be replaced in 15 years. [32:20] Speaker B (unidentified): I was just wondering where the 15-year number came from. Okay. Yeah. [32:25] Speaker I (unidentified): I just did a basic bit of research on how long does galvanized steel last in a marine environment. And it's pretty much all galvanizers. The websites that come up, this one's typical. And it says in a coastal marine environment it's about 15 years. The issue becoming, in researching these helical piles, they can become damaged like if they hit a log when you're screwing them in. They're not as tough as you think they are. And these marshes are full of logs from years going by, obviously. The anchors will never be removed from the resource. At a minimum, the helix's welds will fail. If you've seen things in the corrosive environment, galvanizing goes first, then the welds go. The galvanized steel is going to degrade faster than the other structural components proposed. Everything above ground will last longer than these galvanized steel anchors. When they degrade, they release zinc, lead, and chromium into the marsh. The steel corrodes. It oxidizes. And oxides get into the soil. And iron can alter the soil chemistry in the marsh. From two to 10 years, major corrosion seems to proliferate from my research. I'm not an expert, but I just Googled and used some things. Something of note is that these are buried in a salt marsh. No sacrificial anodes have been proposed to mitigate this corrosion as well. So sacrificial anodes, like zinc, something that's going to corrode faster than the anchor. [34:31] Speaker K (unidentified): Do you want me to give this to Rachel to put in the record, this document that was shared? [34:38] Speaker D (unidentified): It's just general information on galvanized steel. It's not entirely applicable to helical anchors. I'm not sure it's relevant. I'm not sure how probative it is. [34:47] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm also, since we're speaking record housekeeping, I have some additional documents that I'd love to submit before we go any further. These were on our list that we submitted when we submitted all our other documents, noted as reserved just because we didn't have access to them. I think they're pretty uncontroversial. They're just minutes from the planning board meeting on the 8th and the 11th. Not even sure they're necessary at this point, but for completeness, these are prior minutes from the planning board, yeah, on September 8th and August 11th, downloaded from the town of Safe. Do you guys [35:27] Speaker A (unidentified): have an objection to that? They're publicly available, so no objection. And then the other [35:32] Speaker G (unidentified): batch would be these are color versions of the photos that you found at AR 334, 335, and these might be helpful to refer to [36:02] Speaker H (unidentified): so the for purposes of expediting we would object to these they 've obviously they've [36:11] Speaker A (unidentified): got in that, this is, we're not there yet, we're talking, okay, good, we're at the planning board minutes, and I understand that both party or all parties are agreeable to the two planning board minutes that were referenced coming into the record, and that will stipulate to the entry [36:27] Speaker C (unidentified): of those documents. Sure, broadly, if there's planning board evidence that folks want to [36:34] Speaker K (unidentified): sure, it might, anything that was before the record, if you have it and it makes sense, obviously it's up to you and the parties, but well, I guess we'll take it, might make it more efficient [36:47] Speaker A (unidentified): right, oh sorry, so they have an objection to these, can I see these, I think there's going to [36:56] Speaker H (unidentified): to be a sidewalk, these are, you can see for yourself if you are inclined to do a sidewalk, the second picture, it looks like a child has designed that, I'm not sure it's not the right materials, it's not representative of all our daughters [37:10] Speaker A (unidentified): it's a flying the AR-34 where you're taking exception to the correct, the rendering of the dock would look like that. [37:20] Speaker O (unidentified): Have you seen those pictures? [37:21] Speaker G (unidentified): These were in front of the planning board, and the applicant's welcome to make those arguments substantively, but... [37:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Are these all of them? These are all the same area? [37:32] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, those are just seven copies. [37:34] Speaker D (unidentified): And if you look at 336, I mean, that's a picture from the water, and it's not even in the area that the pier and dock system would be. [37:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Again, these were in front of the planning board and the zoning board. [37:56] Speaker J (unidentified): So they're already part of it. [37:58] Speaker G (unidentified): It's just a color version of we already submitted these documents. [38:06] Speaker K (unidentified): evidence can be, should be newly submitted in part of the record, so if there is an objection. [38:13] Speaker E (unidentified): So the attorney handily submitted the entire record with her appeal. So I think that came in a fresh that way. [38:25] Speaker G (unidentified): This is just the color printout. [38:28] Speaker O (unidentified): Okay. Thank you. [38:32] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to... Do we have any comments from the members? To me, I think we could omit it, subject to their objections to the probative value of this [38:43] Speaker O (unidentified): rendering. I mean... That's fair. [38:45] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think, it may not be probative, but I think it's relevant. [38:49] Speaker D (unidentified): I think coupled with the you know, the proposed site walk. Yeah. [38:55] Speaker P (unidentified): I have something to share. We're [38:57] Speaker E (unidentified): getting involved in like a record by record is it admissible and objection kind of thing. I think that's far beyond what an administrative board does. Throw it all in and you guys think it's [39:08] Speaker C (unidentified): relevant, you care about it, if you don't, you don't. Do we need to make a motion to put these into [39:16] Speaker K (unidentified): the record? I mean, I don't think there needs to be a motion for anything. I think there could be a motion to just agree that the planning board record is included in the record, but I think that for the record that would be helpful to do explicitly. Somebody want [39:32] Speaker C (unidentified): to make a motion? It's your motion or their motion, but I think having it on [39:44] Speaker A (unidentified): the right, all the records that were for the planning board are included in the record before us. Does anybody want a second? Question? All in favor? All right. So anything that was submitted to the planning board is part of the record before us. [40:03] Speaker Q (unidentified): We don't need to move it. [40:08] Speaker A (unidentified): So you were, I think we got, we were stuck on the second point under 15 D2. Rebecca, 15 D2, do you have other, are you done with that particular argument? [40:20] Speaker G (unidentified): On that particular one, I think I'm ready to move on unless Joshua has anything else you want to add? No. Okay, great. I'll let Christine take the reins here on D5. Yes. I'm sorry, D2. If you had anything to add on this one. [40:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Oh no, sorry, I don't. I did not. [40:38] Speaker P (unidentified): Okay, great. [40:41] Speaker G (unidentified): So next we wanted to talk about the pier's consistency with the character of the surrounding area. I'm going to do just a little bit of framing and then kick it over to my client, Josh, on this issue. So the character of this area is on the Kennebec, on the western shore of the Kennebec. It's dominated by the marsh environment. I just visited it for the first time. It's very beautiful. All of the docks nearby are pinned to granite and they are all much shorter than the dock in question here. It's also a very important, we'll talk more about this under the historical criteria. [41:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Why is it imperative or important that it's pinned to granite? What's the benefit of that? [41:26] Speaker G (unidentified): It's a different construction style. So the soft marsh soils are driving the choice of helical piles, which we have concerns about from an environmental perspective and from a lifespan perspective. And it's also, because you have granite pushing up against the river, it enables your dock to be much shorter because the water interacts right with a nice firm hedge that you can build on, versus needing to build this 290 foot or 200, however you want to measure the pier part of this thing, but 245 to 290 foot pier to even access the portion where the water hits. So, Josh, if you could talk a little bit more about... [42:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Does the site or site have the ability to put a document that's pending right now? [42:09] Speaker G (unidentified): I don't believe so. Okay. Yeah. I believe it's their whole. [42:13] Speaker A (unidentified): So it's either this or nothing. Right. And I think that- [42:16] Speaker D (unidentified): If I could just clarify, there is no existing ledge. Right. [42:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. Right. So there's a difference in. [42:23] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes. The luck of the draw that we have all marsh. [42:26] Speaker G (unidentified): Exactly. And we don't dispute that. But I think that this is like the core tension of how we how we think this should be viewed differently. I believe in the applicant's eyes it's like they are thinking well we don't have granite we don't have favorable conditions to do a nice short pier and in their mind that means therefore we build a really long really big one whereas in our mind it means maybe you don't get up here that is an acceptable outcome and you are not guaranteed one because not all soils are suitable for this type of feature. In terms of the impact on the area, it's going to have a profound impact on the historical context for the 74 Inn. Obviously it's Christian's issue but it's also my client's issue because he looks at that vista every day and the town's comprehensive plan really acknowledges that the historic value of these structures isn't just, you know, did a famous architect design it? Is this a fantastic example of federalist trim? No, It's about the overall cultural and historic context, and the rural context, and the aesthetic value of the area that this is considered. [43:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Didn't the state historic society or whatever, didn't they weigh in on this and they said it's not a problem? [43:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, they did. We'll talk more about that in the historic section, but they're looking at different criteria than we in this comprehensive plan would consider. So, Josh, you want to tell us more about the character of the area and how this fits into it, or doesn't? Sure. [43:53] Speaker I (unidentified): I've got pictures of 31 docks on the Kennebec, which you guys can take a look at. There are in the Planning Board's record. I'm saving the last picture because it's got my notes on it. That's in Atkins Bay. 31 docks on the Kennebec. Four have aluminum access ramps. The longest is 40 feet. By access ramp I mean stationary, not the dock ramp. 19% have no access ramp. Of the ones that have permanent access ramps, they are entirely wood and they're entirely attached to granite, which is identified as suitable soil. There's not any other dock on the Kennebec that has a permanent aluminum access ramp. They, so it's not in keeping with any other dock profile in the area in Pittsburgh on the Kennebec. [45:03] Speaker G (unidentified): Let's hold off on the historic section for the site, but maybe you could tell us a little. I think in their response letter they had said that you run a commercial boat yard. Can you tell a little bit more about what your operation is? [45:14] Speaker I (unidentified): I have a business permit for renting boats and moorings. I don't want to rent moorings, but I do rent boats to a couple of locals to give them access to their moorings on the river. I certainly don't have a boat yard. What else did they call it? A boat yard and a... Boat launch facility. Well, you know, there's a natural boat ramp on my property. I'm the only one that uses it occasionally. Somebody asks, and they're able to use it. But there's far better facilities than the natural boat ramp on my property. So it's not a commercial boat ramp by any means, and it's not a boat yard. That's not legal in the resource, I'm sorry, the stricter zone, whatever it's called. [45:56] Speaker G (unidentified): And the boat you rent is? It's a dinghy. It's a dinghy. [46:00] Speaker I (unidentified): It's access to land, access to the dock, access to the water, and access to the water. [46:05] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I just wanted to make that clear. [46:07] Speaker G (unidentified): And I know this isn't particularly, this is relevant to all criteria that we'll be raising, but maybe you could talk now a little bit about how you use your property and what you see and how this will impact you. [46:21] Speaker I (unidentified): Sure, I mean, yeah, how you agree, [46:24] Speaker A (unidentified): I know you're in a barter, how you agree. Sure. [46:26] Speaker I (unidentified): Should I go on the sidelines? [46:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Actually, yeah, go ahead, why don't you. [46:31] Speaker I (unidentified): I've given you some, I've made up some prints of the sight lines, the view sheds, however you want to call it. [46:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Are they all for the planning board? No, this is new. Did you guys have some of these? [46:48] Speaker D (unidentified): No. We'd like to have a copy, please. [46:50] Speaker K (unidentified): Once they get down this way, I'll bring them over and we can make sure. I have one for them. Oh, even better. Of the docks, too. The docks? [47:00] Speaker I (unidentified): The docs, this is my only copy of all of them. They're all different. They're already in the record. [47:06] Speaker K (unidentified): Those ones just don't have the mark. They just don't have the ARs in them. [47:10] Speaker G (unidentified): Ironically, the base stamps. Because Microsoft crashed and I couldn't... In terms of this document that Josh was sending out, I just want to make two notes. We prepared it in response to the applicant's response letter which we received on Tuesday, I believe. And then I think to Kristen's point, I understand the board's desire to make more clear about what the record is, but this was noticed as a public hearing. And so if a member of the public came off the street and said, I want to talk about this, and here's a picture I found on Google Maps, typically a board would say, alright, you know, let it in. [47:45] Speaker I (unidentified): So the top page is the view shed, the line that, the straight line across the marsh is the proposed, yeah, it's roughly where the proposed pier is and float. Okay. And if you're... [48:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Could you like hold it so we can... [48:02] Speaker I (unidentified): Sure, sorry. I'm going to hold it so it's kind of like... Yeah,, yeah. Okay. [48:05] Speaker G (unidentified): And actually, Josh, do you, is the camera somewhere? [48:08] Speaker I (unidentified): The camera's over there. It doesn't catch mine. [48:10] Speaker G (unidentified): All right. Well, there's one line that doesn't form a triangle with anything else. Right. [48:14] Speaker I (unidentified): Right, so this line that doesn't form a triangle is the proposed dock. These are the two view sheds from the 1774 Inn. And this is the view shed from my home on Cranberry Point Road. And the pictures of the church were taken from my home that are already in the record. [48:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So this is your house right here? Correct. [48:37] Speaker B (unidentified): So this one is automatic, but this one right here is? Correct. Correct. [48:42] Speaker I (unidentified): And the second image is the Devon's view shed. They said in their response to our appeal letter that they had seven docks in their view. They've got one dock in their view, and that's Sarah's. It's 1774. They can't see my dock from their house. It's behind ledge. They'd have to walk out on the marsh to see another dock. The third shows, I don't know, almost three miles down to the only dock they could possibly see from their house, which is over in Georgetown. So I don't know where they get seven docks from their house, but they can definitely see one. So that is the site line. [49:29] Speaker G (unidentified): And actually, since we're talking brief, could you tell us a little bit about how your business uses the property and how you use the property that actually abuts for your business, [49:39] Speaker P (unidentified): your shed and so forth? [49:43] Speaker I (unidentified): I've got a personal office right out at the waterfront. I spend most of my days there, especially in the summer. And from there, I can see the entire project. And it's a pretty peaceful spot. lot. I know a lot of you have been out there. Going back 20 years, everybody at Penn was out there. [50:04] Speaker G (unidentified): And that's the little shed you can see [50:06] Speaker I (unidentified): right on the waterfront. Correct. It's a little 18 by 20 shed. And I see across this marsh to the church. The church is lit up 24-7. And that view is my view from my home. And I wake up in the morning and I look across that marsh at the church so it's for my living room my bedroom and my kitchen and [50:31] Speaker C (unidentified): last thing are you do you live here seasonally full-time i live here full-time my daughter [50:36] Speaker I (unidentified): is a student across the street and i just voted here last week so these are not [50:44] Speaker C (unidentified): the record before the plan for it yeah so we're gonna have to move them in i think that's fine [50:49] Speaker K (unidentified): i think you can consider them if you want to move them in and just to say that you're putting [50:54] Speaker C (unidentified): it in the record i think that's well i mean if you guys have an objection to it you can voice [50:59] Speaker A (unidentified): it we're probably going to put on the record but we want to present honestly we haven't [51:02] Speaker D (unidentified): had sufficient time to review them we may have an objection later we'll put it in the record subject [51:09] Speaker A (unidentified): you had a chance to review them right okay so we're going to have can we if there's going to [51:21] Speaker K (unidentified): be a sidewalk yeah we're going to have to have another one of these so there will be an [51:25] Speaker C (unidentified): opportunity if there's a big concern we're going to come back maybe we put it in the record [51:41] Speaker M (unidentified): so you're saying that you won't be able to see the church if they put this dark in no not at all [51:46] Speaker I (unidentified): well that's what you'd reference it's going to be glaring bright aluminum 240 foot structure right across the marsh [51:54] Speaker G (unidentified): one other note on character of the area I believe in applicants response letter filed Tuesday they noted other docks in the Pittsburgh area which based on their description I think refers to a dock in Ararajic I think our perspective is when reviewing character of the area you have to look only to pittsburgh and more specifically to an [52:20] Speaker C (unidentified): area smaller than the entire they can clarify that one okay all [52:27] Speaker G (unidentified): right did you have anything [52:29] Speaker A (unidentified): you looked at yeah you're like oh yes well you're we're still in you know for an hour and we're [52:35] Speaker P (unidentified): Still on the first point, but this second point, character the area first, okay, around the second [52:41] Speaker E (unidentified): point okay but yeah I'll start with establishing my clients standing as well so the business is called the historic 1774 in and I just wanted to read you know the welcome blurb from their website which is 1774 in calm it says tucked away in the rural seaside village of Pittsburgh meaning you'll find a historic waterfront estate steeped in natural beauty and authentic main charm barn. Our elegant 18th century manor house and rustic event barn are surrounded by native plant landscaping and breathtaking water views. You might catch glimpses of seals lounging on the islands, eagles swooping from tall pines, stunning sunrises and starry skies." And that's exactly why the inn has standing here. It is specifically called out as a protected historic structure in the town's comprehensive plan say it's pretty rare that a comprehensive plan actually means specific buildings rather than the character of the area in general and yours does and it calls out this specific building and this specific area as being particularly important to this town I will provide some pictures that show you know the end I don't think that you can really get the sense of it until you do get down there in person and I think when we do the site walk it would be great if Sarah, by the way Sarah is very sick tonight and she wish she could be here, so hopefully, you know, she'll be able to talk at a future proceeding, but hopefully you can get onto her property as well and see what this is going to look like and sort of visualize from the backyard of the inn, which, you know, they used for weddings and gatherings, but the reason why it is a popular venue is because of how peaceful and beautiful it is and how authentic this area is. It is one of the rare places, I think, where you can still look around and not see the new building. It is one of the few places where you can look around and get a beautiful picturesque water view from every direction, and I think that's to go to Kate's point. When I train planning boards, one of the first things I always say is planning boards tend to forget that their job is not to find a path to approval for every project. There is always a reason to deny because the Approval standards are a yes or a no, and in this case it was really disheartening. I know this is a de novo proceeding, but it was really disheartening to hear a member of the planning board say, well, they got waterfront property, I mean, they got a right to it. If that's the standard, we might as well throw the whole ordinance out. I feel like this was a jump the shark moment almost, where at this point, if this particular peer is going to be approved in this particular location based on that precedent I can't even imagine what project would be denied, and it's the, it's the confluence of this size, this material, in this location that make the project just particularly objectionable and one that needs to be denied. So a couple of points, just based on the language of the ordinance, and I'm talking about section 15 d5 here, the facility needs to be no larger in dimension than necessary to carry on the activity. Okay, so what's the activity? The activity is not a dock or pier. That's a structure. The activity is getting onto and off of a boat or launching a boat. That activity can be conducted elsewhere in a way that is a lot less impactful on the environment and on the neighborhood. So each of these abutters, 1774 and Mr. Bate, offered the use of their docks to the Davins. The DEP, when you put in for approval of this project, does an alternatives analysis. Part of its review process is to say, okay, we're going to balance the impacts on the community, on the environment, with this analysis of what, how much is it needed. And one thing that we revealed in looking at the DEP process and the materials that were submitted is that they didn't call out the fiddler's reach landing, which is just a couple of minutes away, as being one of those alternatives. So there's a really nice sophisticated boat launch, there are marinas, and there are both abutters that could let the Davins have access to a boat without all of this damage to the historic and sort of scenic character of the neighborhood. And then, the other part of that standard is, it consistent with the surrounding character and uses of the area? Mr. Bates has given you loads of pictures of docks and piers, and I will grant you that it's a different scenario in some of those properties, if not all of those properties, because they have ledge to work with, and this property does not. But again, that doesn't mean every property gets its. And there are many properties in this town in particular that don't have ledge, and what they typically don't have, not every property gets one, not every property needs one, and if you've jumped the shark into allowing this kind of a structure on every property that doesn't have ledge, you will see them proliferate. I love South Carolina, I love Georgia, but if you go down there you see these monstrosities all along every single river, and that will be what it looks like here. So it is no small task to kind of stand up and say, look, we've got to say no somewhere and to be the bad guy. But I think that is what the ordinance requires here. [59:14] Speaker A (unidentified): But the use is consistent. [59:17] Speaker E (unidentified): The use of using a boat, sure, but the use of, but, you know, so is the use of having a home. That doesn't mean you get to build one that's physically tall. [59:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, it says then, it says the surrounding character and the use of the area, so I think we have to at least factor in what the ordinance says. You have to have both. You have to have both. Right. [59:45] Speaker E (unidentified): The character is scenic and it's historic, and at the very least, some material that is not modern. So to that point, I want to just give you a transcript. I know the record itself is sort of admitted, but I wanted to give you a transcript from the president of the Squirrel Point Lighthouse Association. She spoke at the planning board and I thought she had really interesting perspective to offer about the about the material. Do you have a sense on how we [1:00:27] Speaker A (unidentified): weigh the to the character versus the area are they just there's a character [1:00:33] Speaker P (unidentified): versus the area you know you see you see a character Trump to use I think you [1:00:37] Speaker E (unidentified): need to have both and if you don't have one consistency with the character here I think if the character is so impacted that it doesn't matter if the use is one that people undertake. Also I think you can't decouple the use from the structure here. Like the use is launching a boat via a pier on private property and if that's the use but you look around it's just not consistent with how other people build and use their peers. [1:01:11] Speaker L (unidentified): But that's by necessity, right? [1:01:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Necessity can't be the driver, you know. [1:01:16] Speaker G (unidentified): So could I ask, are you referring to the language and be consistent with the surrounding character and uses of the area? Okay, I read that as it needs to satisfy both. [1:01:26] Speaker O (unidentified): Right, I'm just trying to say, [1:01:28] Speaker B (unidentified): do you have arguments about why the character [1:01:31] Speaker A (unidentified): is inconsistent but the use is very consistent and I'm just trying to weigh those, [1:01:37] Speaker G (unidentified): But I don't think they get weight. I think it is consistent with uses of the area. It is not consistent with the character of the area though. It is required so there's no sliding scale. [1:01:47] Speaker Q (unidentified): Could I ask a question about Fiddler's Reach? You said you introduced that as a viable alternative. How far away is Fiddler's Reach and if they're keeping a boat at their property would they be able to keep the boat at Fiddler's Reach as well? [1:02:06] Speaker D (unidentified): Fiddler's Reach is approximately 4.5 miles from my driveway to the launch. And by state rule, you're not allowed to tie off overnight. This [1:02:34] Speaker E (unidentified): was Elizabeth Payne in her transcript that I passed out. And what she was referring to is the fact that the trail out of the score point has a bridge that's 115 feet long. It's made out of the same material and she noted that this pier is going to be twice the length. I'd say it's actually going to be significantly more than [1:02:56] Speaker A (unidentified): twice but it's what that's presupposed is it's like it's 247 or whatever it is [1:03:03] Speaker G (unidentified): the whole system is maybe get clarity from the appears 245 yeah [1:03:11] Speaker L (unidentified): it'll be an access ramp on the land and the woods up to the pier and then there will be a ramp down to the down to the docks. It's twice the size I classify it from the very [1:03:23] Speaker E (unidentified): start of the ramp all the way out to the tip of the pier at which point it's 290 feet anyway. Proposed pier is going to be twice that length and she says that she happens to live across the river from the bridge and she's always thinking that she's sorry to the neighbors because when she looks out across the river, it catches the sunlight. The thing looks like it's encrusted with diamonds. And she says from Squirrel Point we're going to have that same glistening view of 240 feet of sparkle over what is now pristine marsh. Maintaining the royal character and preserving the historic character, particularly in the center village, has been a stated goal of the townspeople [1:04:05] Speaker P (unidentified): for over 20 years so I think she is president of the Squirrel Point and [1:04:17] Speaker E (unidentified): she was also there to read a letter from the Clipsburg Historical Society which is in the record. Look at this comment so there was also and she was reading at the At the start of her comments, a letter from the Phippsburg Historical Society expressing extreme concern with the project too. So you have, and we can touch on this in the historic piece, but it all goes to character. You have it called out in the comprehensive plan that Phippsburg Center is of extreme historic reverence. You've got the Squirrel Point folks. That's a historic structure that's protected. You've got the Historical Society, and you've got my client, the owner of our operator of the business at 1774. All of these, you know, historic uses that are called out as being super consequential in this area, they've all come out against this project. That's got to mean something. They're not doing it to be NIMBYs. They're doing it because they have resources to protect. But there's a bunch of other entities [1:05:33] Speaker B (unidentified): that review the project that have come in favor of it. [1:05:35] Speaker A (unidentified): The Harbormaster, DEP is part of it. [1:05:38] Speaker E (unidentified): Harbormaster, the DEP do not review character. [1:05:42] Speaker O (unidentified): But they have signed off on the project, right? [1:05:45] Speaker E (unidentified): They don't review character and they don't apply this town's comprehensive plan. For DEP looking at this thing, they do not care whether Phippsburg or consider Spitzberg Center in this area as being... [1:05:57] Speaker B (unidentified): The Historical Society weighed in on it, right, too. [1:06:01] Speaker E (unidentified): The Historical Society weighed against it, yeah. Are you talking about the Maine Historic Preservation Commission? Yeah. Let's talk about that when we get to historic, because I've got a whole sub-argument on that. [1:06:11] Speaker O (unidentified): But they were not supposed to project, right? [1:06:16] Speaker E (unidentified): Don't get me started on their review. We'll get into it. [1:06:19] Speaker B (unidentified): But just for that's correct. [1:06:20] Speaker A (unidentified): So if we're going from baseline, they were not... [1:06:22] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, they found no impacts to the top hill. [1:06:24] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, I don't know if you can say whatever you want about it. [1:06:26] Speaker G (unidentified): Under the criteria they're supposed to review. USDA standards. [1:06:30] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, I think, Kevin, this may just be for me, but I think it actually would be helpful to figure out how we're going through this. Like, are they each addressing this, like, when Kate starts, if there's a point that Kristen is also making, are they just going to do it in tandem through and then have the applicant respond at the end? [1:06:53] Speaker Q (unidentified): And is that how you want to approach it? I would prefer that they're going to follow the same ground, right? [1:06:56] Speaker A (unidentified): So we don't need to be redundant, right? Okay. It sounds like they're tag-teaming it, and she's taking some pieces, and you're taking some pieces, and you're trying not to cover the same arguments. [1:07:05] Speaker J (unidentified): But if I'm wrong about that, let us know. [1:07:08] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, we each have our own clients, but we touch on a lot of the same issues. And so when I've raised issues that Mr. Bate has raised, I'm generally going second except for on this historic piece because that's really my client's issue. [1:07:24] Speaker A (unidentified): But do you have an answer to Shae's question about how we're going to do this more efficiently [1:07:30] Speaker E (unidentified): I think that is our general plan. Kate's raising an issue. I'm going to present, I'm going to backfill, and I think Kate has the right to kind of jump back in if anything else she wants. I expect that if this goes any further in appeal, we're all going to be in it together, and it's not going to matter so much whose argument was whose. I [1:07:55] Speaker K (unidentified): just wanted to make sure everyone was on the same page. [1:08:00] Speaker E (unidentified): So I guess I will go ahead though and also submit this is a letter that I submitted to the Maine Historic Preservation Commission, but I'm giving it to you now on this particular piece of the ordinance because it's got some nice color photos which are not in your record from planning board And just so you understand, like the first green photo you'll see in there, I did create this, but I created this using measuring tools with both GPS and then cross-reference with Google Maps, and I've located it as close as I can to where the plans show it in the area, and I wanted you to get a sense of what that looks like on the face of here. And the important thing here is I'm not sure you're in my [1:09:19] Speaker C (unidentified): right, yeah, you're here, you're on the other one. [1:09:29] Speaker I (unidentified): has to be sure. [Speaker C (unidentified): my personal] office is out here. I call it a shepherd, and my main office is here in these trees at the end of their field. Actually that's, you can see my office in the trees there, and my home's down on Cranberry Point Road behind those trees in this picture. [1:10:09] Speaker E (unidentified): But when you're considering the character, just kind of envision the various properties that are looking out on this. And it's not just the view from the shore out, it's also the view from the water in. And part of the thing that makes the Pittsburgh Center so special is it's a shipbuilding location. And the access to and sort of integration with the water is extremely important to the way everything looks there, to how bucolic it is. And when you essentially draw a line through half the bay, that really does change the way it looks. And people may start to unsee it after 5, 10, 20 years, but that doesn't make it better. All it means is that you get complacent, and you're going to get complacent to all the other ones that crop up like it, too. Before you know it, the whole shoreline, and I'm trying not to be hyperbolic here, but these things do change over time. and precedent is really important, and you got to draw the line somewhere, so I'll stop there. [1:11:31] Speaker P (unidentified): give us a heads up, all right, and we can do this issue by issue. I don't know if [1:11:37] Speaker E (unidentified): you care you know pinging back and forth yeah if you want to have them catch up [1:11:42] Speaker C (unidentified): to I think we're free so I'll and I'm character well it's up to you I mean it [1:11:49] Speaker A (unidentified): may be to your benefit to win now because well their comments are fresh so not just that there were a lot yeah so if you so they covered point two and [1:12:01] Speaker C (unidentified): point five right so far that's right 15 b2 and 15 do you have the list of the [1:12:07] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't have the list, but I can speak to. I have the review tonight. Okay. [1:12:15] Speaker D (unidentified): Just a couple of quick points, because I think the discussion started off with the helical anchor system. The what? The helical anchor system. I think what was presented to you was just information on general galvanized steel. However, I do have a couple of articles here that if you're interested in, I can give those to you. but they're they're widely used in marine applications they're actually also for their structural integrity they're used as bridge support systems for railroad crossings across rivers they're specifically designed for their ability to grab and adhere within soils particularly like in a marsh or that it's actually now a preference of DEP for these types of constructions like [1:13:02] Speaker A (unidentified): like we're doing for residential and commercial assembly both commercial applications but DEPs preferences for both residential and commercial now both [1:13:13] Speaker D (unidentified): yes and the it's rated for a 50-year lifespan the nice feature of the helical anchor is there's less equipment involvement to drive the anchor in that as noted in our response it requires less machinery so less impact to the marsh itself if there is an issue where there is breakage or deterioration with the anchor they are retrievable whereas you know with a traditional wood pylon system you know that the soil or the marsh itself is creating a friction or an adhesion and oftentimes it's very difficult to get the broken pylon back out in this it's much like when you extract a screw that has a broken head you know you have a system work and latch on to the existing pole and screw the auger back out and then reposition it there was also reference made to the widening now in the original application they were set at 36 inch on center which that is the minimum requirement however in speaking with the builders that do these types of applications and it's not the fault the engineer that Designed it, but they quickly noted is that's the minimum. However, if you're able to space them further apart, and they recommended 50 inches, that it adds even greater structural stability. I do kind of find it interesting that, you know, we talk about the scenics and the aesthetics and the history. The history of this area is seafaring. It's being on the water. It's there's tons of commercial water industries and things of that nature. As you know, as they know, there are docks and piers up and down. As I noted in the response, when we stand at the location where our pier is going to be, I can see seven. And this is that this is that winter time when the floats have already been removed from the water. So I'm sure in summertime, when floats are back out, there's probably going to be more that are visible. The element related to the bridge across the for Squirrel Point, I'm directly across from that. It's in the view from my house. I have not seen glare from that at all. The materials of construction for this system is consistent with the materials and construction of all the other existing piers and docks in the area. While they note that yes, and we've even noted in our response, while in this specific area there may not be a pier that is of our length. It's not uncommon for the Pittsburgh area. You only have to go a little bit upriver on the Orosik side and there's a 180 foot long pier there that crosses a marsh. It's up in the Fischer's Eddy area. If you go down around Sabasco, has a number of piers that range anywhere from 150 to over 200 feet. So it's not uncommon. Common, it just may not be common for this particular area at the moment. And then also just to note, related back to history, is that you know the Macabre house that was owned by two famous shipbuilders, and part of the reason they positioned the house the way they did was they wanted to keep an eye on their own shipbuilding activities and peers in the area. A person only asked to open a copy of One Man, what's the name of the book, One Man's, it's about Papa Beach area, and there's photographs, it's Replete with photographs showing large masted schooners that used to sit off in front of the church area in Squirrel Point. So this is not outside of any current usage or historical aspect. And then it's related to the scenic and aesthetic aspects. You'll note in both the original DEP approval letter and in their subsequent approval of the amendment, they actually applied their matrix system because there isn't the town standard for what is impact scenic or aesthetic views. They applied their matrix system to this particular situation and found that there was no impact. I [1:17:29] Speaker H (unidentified): think it's important to the town. This town identifies as a maritime community, and when you look at the comprehensive plan, that's the current comprehensive plan, their first goal is to maintain the rule character of Phippsburg. If you come by our home on a Saturday, if you drive by there tomorrow, there are, it's become a huge commercial sprawling waiting venue. There are massive tents that are put up. There's noise all the time, and if you come by on a Saturday we can't even think. It's so loud that inside our house it booms. I think it's so interesting that the Inn would make this point that they're maintaining the rule of character. Please, this Saturday, they just put up tents. Drive by, take a look, see what it's like. If you look at the website for the Inn, the first picture you see is a dog. They have a picture of their dog as they lead in, first picture on the website. That's how important docs are to people. We just want [1:18:36] Speaker D (unidentified): and just to, sorry to interrupt, but important to note there that picture is of their doc. It's the Dunnigan's dock on their primary residence which abuts the inn. That dock and that gangway is in full view of all of their activities for any of the events because of the way they set up the pavilion tents. So sorry, go ahead. Well, I think that it's important to know in the comprehensive [1:19:00] Speaker H (unidentified): plan too there's 27 vistas that are specifically noted as important to Fitzburg. This isn't one of them. This is a private view that basically three properties can see. The Squirrel Point can see it from across the way too, but if you go into Squirrel Point's website, the first thing you see there is they have a picture looking towards the Fitzburg shoreline that has of 100 years ago that shows docks and piers. There's nothing more Phippsburg than access to the water, and the comprehensive plan talks about that. On page 188 of the comprehensive plan, the goal, one of the goals of the Phippsburg plan, is to access to all maritime related, marine related activities, and they even suggest that property, private property owners who allow access over their property should be given some sort of an incentive. That's one of the things that they had talked about. We're not trying to do something different or do something that's not in the character of the town. There's nothing more Phippsburg than being able to walk down and get into a boat and drive around on the river or go out on the ocean. It's a very Phippsburg thing. It's the rural area is not going to be disrupted by this quiet, silent dock sitting out on the marsh. It is disrupted. Well, we look out every window, we can see the dock over at Squirrel Point. It's funny, when they put that dock in and sent out a thing, we sent money, you know. We think it's important that they have access to get over to the lighthouse. I think that's a really important thing. We didn't have any problem with it. We look at it every day. We probably have the best view of it of anybody. And we've never had an issue with it. [1:20:54] Speaker J (unidentified): The glare from their bridge. We don't see any glare. [1:20:57] Speaker D (unidentified): But to go back is, you know, with the Dunnigan's own gangway, aluminum gangway, that goes from down to their dock system, I don't see any glare. So, again, I think the tree line helps to obscure a lot of that. you know, and it's also, you know, it's, it would be dependent upon the positioning of the sun, but as in speaking with the builders, they said because of the salt air nature where we live that you get a natural oxygen oxidization, say that three times fast, that's going to occur in three to five years, and they indicated it happens with all aluminum structures out here. Well, Mr. [1:21:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Mr. Bate has used this. So you're saying to the extent there's a flare over time, the flare will dissipate? [1:21:41] Speaker H (unidentified): If there was any. It dissipates very quickly in about a year. But Mr. Bate has used the same material in his gangway. So, I mean, it's a very common material and very easily used. [1:21:56] Speaker D (unidentified): And just to note is, you know, regardless of whether we call it a commercial waterfront, a commercial boatyard, or whatever, However, there are times where there are boats and trailers stored up in that area. He has an 80-foot-long dock, which was put in, I think, 2021 was when he received planning board approval. I didn't hear the inn objecting to that. That's in full view of the inn all the time, to the point that if you go to their website again and you look at some of their photos that they have displayed, you can tell that the photos are blurred in the background, so that feature doesn't come out. So, I mean, to say that we're going to be out of character with what's already existing in the area, I'm having trouble understanding that. [1:22:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Aside from the necessity of the length of the pier, do you have anything else you want to say about why the pier is not out of character? [1:22:55] Speaker H (unidentified): We would like to put in a shorter pier if we could. We would just like to get to the water. DEP has dictated the height, the length, and where it has to go. We're not trying to put in the biggest structure we possibly can. We're just trying to get to the water so we can use it the same way our neighbors use it. [1:23:17] Speaker D (unidentified): It's important to note is the aspect of the 1 to 1.5 elevation ratio, that was not our decision. That is DEP, and that is just because of, to minimize impacts to the marsh. [1:23:32] Speaker A (unidentified): What do you say about their argument that, well, you bought the land as is, where it is, and maybe you're not entitled to adopt? [1:23:41] Speaker D (unidentified): But case in point there, when we bought the land, we specifically had conversations with the code enforcement officer at that time and with DEP about are there any prohibitions with eventually putting a pier and a dock on the property and we were told no but and actually we were told by codes enforcement is it's actually a matter of time and money because you've got a you've got a significant width to the march so that 's what you're going [1:24:08] Speaker H (unidentified): to be facing we do have those emails from Lee Rennie and we can bring those to the next meeting but Lee had before we bought the property we had inquired about that and we had talked to him, we had talked to DEP. When did you buy the property? 2020. But we were, you know, that was one of the things that we talked to him about, you know, in his capacity for the town is would this be a problem and we'll certainly, I know exactly what the rules are. Was the, like, the design of the care substantially mapped out at that point? No. Oh, no,, no. [1:24:44] Speaker D (unidentified): But, and then also there was an element brought up about that offers have been made for us to use the existing facilities. But what I failed to mention is Mr. Bait has issued notice of trespass against us. And so if I would, on multiple occasions, yeah, multiple occasions, and so if I was to walk onto his property I run the risk of being arrested. So I'm not too eager to launch my boat at his facility. And then similarly is what about the offer from Kristen's client. Well it would be the same. And again, sorry, this is where I'm going is what Mr. Bate hasn't brought up is that he's also brought this question to DEP and DEP had responded to him is that it unless it's deeded access it can't be factored as, I forgot the term they used, viable or plausible viability or whatever, because it can always be taken away wait at a moment's notice we've [1:25:44] Speaker A (unidentified): now gotten the army. Oh okay. So can you, can you, how far away is Kristin's client's property from yours and how would you, would you be able to get there by, how long would it take you to get there? Do you say it's four miles to the but there's reach about, how about Kristin's client's property? Well I'd have to go out the end of my driveway and go down [1:26:06] Speaker D (unidentified): across the end and then go down her road and then cross her property to get down. And I think that there would be some sort of objection if I decided that I wanted to go use their dock on a Saturday afternoon when they're trying to have wedding photos up there or a Friday night or a Thursday. Yeah I know we've been dominating. Yeah sorry it's sort of a tag team approach. Yes good evening [1:26:34] Speaker L (unidentified): My name is Mike Morse from Archipelago in Portland,. I'm here on behalf of the Davins, who are not the applicants any longer. They are actually the permittees for this pier. I mention that because I think it's an important point and probably because I'm a little anal retentive with details at times. But they are the permittees. They've been permitted for the pier by the planning board, which is why we're here tonight. They've been permitted by the DEP and by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. They've obtained all the permits. [1:27:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Those are the three permits that they need? Yes. [1:27:08] Speaker L (unidentified): The only three? Correct. And those are part of the record? [1:27:11] Speaker M (unidentified): They're part of the record. Yes, I believe.
Referrals
[1:27:14] Speaker D (unidentified): So we just gave you copies tonight of the two recent referrals. [1:27:19] Speaker H (unidentified): And we'd ask that those be moved into the record. [1:27:23] Speaker K (unidentified): That was a hop of that. [1:27:27] Speaker C (unidentified): You guys have copies, right? [1:27:29] Speaker G (unidentified): I don't, but it's okay. It's in my email, which I will someday. [1:27:34] Speaker D (unidentified): They have the DEP approval because, for whatever reason, I don't know why, they sent the approval letter to them and copied Mike. [1:27:42] Speaker L (unidentified): Go ahead. I'd just like to make a few comments to respond to some of the comments made by the appellants this evening. One, regarding the suitability of the soils, there are a couple things. Things Rick has already mentioned that the galvanization 15-year shelf life or existence on the marshes is yes, if you buy the wrong materials, galvanization can be done several different ways to make it more heavy-duty or for light duty use, and much like stainless steel, some stainless steel would last in a salt marsh for five years, some will last for much longer, same thing with galvanization. The proposal here is not to install the cheapest lowest grade galvanized steel helical anchors in the salt marsh helical anchors are used very routinely and they have now for a number of years and this is very routine there's a comment about the soils are so poor quality that 's what's driving the design as though that's some type of problem. If you're familiar with any type of development, whether it's for your residential home on upland areas, a building in downtown Portland, a home on the sand dune on Popham Beach, you're going to find the design is predicated on the quality of the soils or the types of the soils. So is the soil suitable? Absolutely. You change the design. And the sand dunes up and down C Street here in Phippsburg, further down on Popham Beach and all the rest, you're going to see structural engineers designing those because of the challenges of building sand. So this is routine, it's nothing special, and the soils are not so poor that you cannot not develop a simple pier project, which this is. The spacing I think Rick indicated that this was a recommendation from the manufacturer that actually the manufacturer specifications for minimum with the 50 [1:30:02] Speaker K (unidentified): inches. I think that's an argument they haven't gotten to yet, okay? Am I incorrect on that? I think that's part of a different argument if they haven't addressed. It has to do with soil suitability. [1:30:13] Speaker L (unidentified): So it's just the manufacturer's specifications require that they meet a minimum separation in order to provide the structural integrity in these types of soils. So the design is nothing special. It can support the project very, simply. Point. There's a comment about, you know, when we're starting to discuss the consistency of the character of the area, we've heard a number of comments maybe over-exaggerating the character of Pittsburgh Center and this and that, ignoring some of the historical context of the area with, as my clients have pointed out, the shipbuilding history, the waterfront activity, and all that existed right around the corner on Parker Head Road. There was a large marine facility there. Then there are still some remains of that, but this is, this is a cultural and historic type of use. Before talking about the visual impact of structures extending over the water or over the marsh, we don't have to look very far, and in terms of the length of this structure of 245 foot long pier. We don't have to look very far, in fact, from the applicant's, or the permittee's, client's property. You look, you go down to the shorefront, you look to the left, which is Mr. Bates' property, and his total structure to get from the mainland out over the, a much wider area on the marsh, and out to the water side of his own wharf and pier facility is approximately 445 feet. I've got aerial photos of that. It's kind of an obnoxious-looking elevated roadway that crosses, again, the most significant part of the marsh. [1:32:14] Speaker H (unidentified): But you can see in this picture right here. [1:32:17] Speaker L (unidentified): And I only have these two copies that I share with the board. You can share it with the... [1:32:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Have you guys seen these? No. Have [1:32:31] Speaker L (unidentified): you guys seen these? This is not part of the original application. It's just something I might have looked at today and I thought was significant. [1:32:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Is it Google Maps? It looks like Google Earth. [1:32:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, Google Earth, yes. [1:32:44] Speaker L (unidentified): So, you know, that total structure length to provide that water access, granted it's in broken pieces with a little bit of upland out there, a little island, is roughly 445 feet. We're talking something substantially shorter than that. Josh provided, Mr. Bate provided photographs, a series of photographs to the board this evening showing numerous piers. I think he indicated there are 31 piers in Phippsburg, or on the Kennebec River. And he commented specifically that they're all wooden and there are no aluminum access ramps. And if you look at the photos, you don't have to look more than the first few. I think I scanned the first eight pages or so, seven or eight pages, and every one of those had an aluminum ramp, or at least some aluminum component to the ramp. This is no different in construction. If somebody's building a new pier, much like the 1774 Inn, and Mr. Bate himself, or I should say the owner of the 1774 Inn, they're using aluminum components such as aluminum ramps down the shoreline. So this is no different. Yes, we considered, we contemplated possible options to, as we were going through the planning board process, to consider dulling the brightness of new aluminum, and the ways to do that would be damaging to the aluminum. It would prematurely start a corrosion process that's inappropriate to take years and years off of the life of the expected lifespan of the material. We considered painting, but painting over a salt marsh is not an option environmentally with overspray or paint drips of toxic chemicals into the marsh. That was not an option. Last, I want to comment on something that was mentioned, brought into the equation. I think Kristen had brought this in about this alternative analysis that the E.P. considers. There are other boat launches around. There is Fiddler's Reach up the street, four and a half miles up the road. You can't tie up to that dock overnight. Night. In fact, the length of time you can tie up is extremely limited because it is a public use facility. There are other private boat launches. There are other smaller town-owned boat launches in the town of Phippsburg. However, they're not suitable for a lot of larger style watercraft. And it's a kind of a crapshoot, if I may, whether you're going to be able to access it because of tied because of other people using it. So a lot of those are used by commercial fishermen. They may be pulling their traps or pulling gear or something of the sort. So they're, they're largely inaccessible. My clients already commented on the possible, the viability of using the launch or the docket, Mr. Bates property that he seemed to so kindly offer, it's not an option for these trespass issues and otherwise, and at the end it's also not the other property. It's just not possible because of all that. Yeah, oh, you can use it provided that we don't have an event going on, which is five or six days a week. This is not about DPS alternatives analysis, although it's an interesting discussion. This is not about, there is nothing in the town's ordinance or under the planning board review or the board of appeals review tonight that suggests that we conduct any alternatives analysis. We had to do that for the DEP process, however, it's not a requirement here, although I think you would reach the same conclusion that the DEP did, which is there are no reasonable alternatives than to construct the project where it's proposed to be constructed. So I will leave that's all I'll have for right now. I do have one [1:37:07] Speaker M (unidentified): question. I didn't understand when you said the helical anchors, the high grade galvanized, which you said, 15 year or 50 year? 50. 50 year. Yeah, sorry about [1:37:21] Speaker H (unidentified): that yeah okay it sounds similar we would just ask that we've just gotten the dp approval and we would just ask that you go through and you actually read that and all of the things all of the findings of fact that they make about that this doesn't and the first finding of fact is the proposed activity will not unreasonably interfere with the existing scenic aesthetic recreational navigational uses of the area. It goes through a number of different criteria that all affect the criteria that you're looking at. The next one is the proposed activity will not cause unreasonable erosion of soil or sediment. This is DEP, the primary agency in this state on these types of opinions and issues and protecting the people in the state of Maine and the environment. The next one, just a, sorry to interrupt, but Mike [1:38:24] Speaker D (unidentified): could probably elaborate better, but that was related to my comment about for the scenery and the aesthetics. DB actually has a standard, they have a matrix system that they, that they use, and as part of that evaluation they deem that there is [1:38:39] Speaker H (unidentified): no unreasonable impact, and he goes through a number of other things that deal with the soil. [1:38:44] Speaker D (unidentified): I won't read them, which is consistent with the findings of the planning board, but it also they [1:38:48] Speaker H (unidentified): Also looked at another a number of other factors like wildlife habitat, freshwater plant wetland, threatening or endangered plant habitats, and other uses, and it goes very thoroughly through this. The planning board also went very thoroughly through this. They spent months on this. They came out twice, they asked a lot of questions, some of those hearings went for hours, and they, you know, they really went through every aspect of all of this in great detail. They let anybody who wanted talk. And some of the people weren't very polite and they weren't very nice, but they still let them talk. And I think that you have to consider that this issue has been vetted, these arguments are not new, and all of these things have already been addressed up to this point. Just if I may, just expound on that. [1:39:43] Speaker L (unidentified): Just a hair. The DP has a very similar standard under the Natural Resources Protection Act. The standard has to do with the visual or scenic impact to resources. Without any rule to make that more objective is 100% a subjective rule or standard. Well, what does that mean? It may mean one thing to you. It may mean something different to Rachel. It may mean something different to anybody else. It may mean something different to me. The DEP moved forward because of that. They recognized the problem, and they went through a formal public rulemaking process and developed the rule. It's not just a standard that Rick alluded to, it's this chapter 315 scenic and aesthetic impact standards where you have this whole matrix and you have to fill out a form data sheet identifying all this. The town ordinance has a similar provision that we can read, it I think it's already been read, where you consider the character of the area and whether they'll be any visual impact, and the town ordinance does not contain any guiding standards. You can't rely on a comp plan. The comp plan guides the writers of the ordinance and how to develop the ordinance. It guides the town voters what they would like to have in the ordinance. The comprehensive plan is not the law of the land. The ordinance is the law of the land. And without any way to flesh out exactly what this visual or scenic impact standard means, then it is back to this issue of it being 100% subjective. And we're all going to have opinions on that. And obviously the opposing abutters will have a very strong opinion, but that's only their opinion. Anyway, I'll leave it at that. [1:41:49] Speaker D (unidentified): And just to quickly add, is you also received tonight a copy of appellant's complaint letter to the Main Historical Preservation Commission. But just to note, is the Main Historical Preservation Commission, their approval, it notes in there that they reviewed the complaint and that [1:42:07] Speaker H (unidentified): this is their response to that review. They also, the N has also filed complaints with DP. They've, I mean, all of these agencies have considered their viewpoints in issuing these rulings. [1:42:23] Speaker J (unidentified): All right, we're gonna take a quick break. I have to go to the bathroom. Oh! [1:42:51] Speaker K (unidentified): Oh yeah, you don't care. I don't think you care. [1:42:57] Speaker F (unidentified): Chris, do you mind just knocking the mic? This? Yeah. [1:45:59] Speaker G (unidentified): It's getting set. We were just thinking, if we have to have another meeting. We're gonna, yeah. Yeah, [1:46:07] Speaker A (unidentified): we're not going to make any determinations until after the cycle. [1:46:12] Speaker E (unidentified): So what I'm thinking is like the visual arguments, which is what we've just completed, and then the historic. [1:46:19] Speaker P (unidentified): And then we come back and do all the wildlife. [1:46:26] Speaker E (unidentified): So you have somebody from the public who wants to talk to a portion of the lead? I do. I would happily. [1:46:32] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay. Where's Jay? We're just going to have a quick chat about the cycle. [1:46:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Shea, there's somebody that's from the public. [1:46:41] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay. Hi. We should wait until... Oh, the mic's back on. Great. [1:46:45] Speaker A (unidentified): She's fine. There's no problem with her talking or anything? [1:46:48] Speaker G (unidentified): The mic is on. [1:46:49] Speaker K (unidentified): Oh, yeah. I just wanted to make sure it was on if we're back on the record. [Speaker A (unidentified): Chris, the appellants.] I think that's up to you how you want to approach this. If you want to get through everyone's legal arguments first and then have public comment. [1:47:05] Speaker A (unidentified): We're less concerned about getting through. We have a hard time, I think we said nine o'clock [1:47:09] Speaker D (unidentified): is going to be the calendar note at 8:30, but yeah, I don't go to January as long as there's [1:47:14] Speaker K (unidentified): no object, I mean Kate's back now, but as long as there's no objections to doing that from parties before other stuff, then I think you're welcome to do that, but I would just, anybody have [1:47:25] Speaker A (unidentified): an objection to her saying her piece? Well, she can introduce herself, but it's to know, so [1:47:33] Speaker K (unidentified): anybody from the public? Yeah, I would just motion she decides a public comment. Okay, somebody want [1:47:38] Speaker A (unidentified): to make a motion to hear any public comments on [1:47:44] Speaker L (unidentified): there? One point of clarification, is this the public hearing, is this where all the public comment will be heard, or from the general public, or will that be reopened at a later time? We can reopen at a later time, right? I think she just [1:48:01] Speaker A (unidentified): She's been sitting patiently, and she has something to say. [1:48:04] Speaker I (unidentified): Sounds good. A little forward, now. [1:48:06] Speaker N (unidentified): Hi, my name is Erica Webb Kramer. I am the vice president of the Historical Society here. I am a member of the Store Preservation Commission. I just want to mention that the commission also is going to write a letter opposing the pier. Unfortunately, our chair passed away very unexpectedly. She was sick during the time that this has all been going on. That is in our minutes. I have a master's in historic preservation. I wrote my thesis on rural character. I live in Phippsburg in a historic home. No offense to anybody here, but no one here is really qualified to make a determination on the rural character in Phippsburg unless, in fact, and I also work for the main State Historic Preservation Office, they have a master's in historic preservation, or they actually have sufficient background in that work. And I would just like to say that yes, it does drastically and will affect the rural character that the 2006 comp plan called that out, that site called out many view sheds in Pittsburgh that were important, that one in particular has more important. There's a draft comprehensive plan that was started. I was actually part of that. I worked on it. The same rural view sheds were called out. The same significance was given to that area. And we also had a survey that went up to the general public, and the number one thing that came up in that survey was rural character. That's all I wanted to say. I appreciate you letting me speak and have a good night. [1:49:47] Speaker M (unidentified): Can I ask a question? [1:49:48] Speaker J (unidentified): Can I ask her a question? Yes. [1:49:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Unless she's left. No. Okay. I was just curious because earlier in the year there was planning board meetings related to the 1774 Inn conversion [1:50:02] Speaker J (unidentified): of what I consider historic property [1:50:06] Speaker D (unidentified): of the CB residence to allow for parking and to become a bed and breakfast, but I did not hear any objections at all from the Historical Society. [1:50:17] Speaker N (unidentified): Are you talking about changing the 1774 head? [1:50:20] Speaker D (unidentified): No, the property adjacent to it, 42 Parker Head. [1:50:23] Speaker E (unidentified): So it's parking on grass? [1:50:24] Speaker N (unidentified): This is a temporary parking area? [1:50:27] Speaker J (unidentified): This is not a structural change. [1:50:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Originally the application called for gravel. [1:50:31] Speaker A (unidentified): This is kind of beside the point. [1:50:33] Speaker D (unidentified): But what I'm just noting is it just seems interesting that this particular project, you know, got their involvement, but other aspects of the village area and its conversion to commercial use doesn't seem to raise to the mark. [1:50:53] Speaker J (unidentified): I'm just going to post the changes that are up here. [1:50:56] Speaker A (unidentified): We need to move on to the factors that are at issue here. Thank you for your contribution and we understand your issue. [1:51:04] Speaker O (unidentified): I just don't think it's particularly relevant and we're running out of time so [1:51:08] Speaker B (unidentified): we can just move on to the other factors. So are we [1:51:12] Speaker E (unidentified): on rebuttal though for that point, the character point? [1:51:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Would you guys? Mike and Mr. Morris and the client on the other side, I think they're done on that character piece, right? [1:51:28] Speaker P (unidentified): Right? Yes. Right. You guys have a little bit of a rebuttal. Yeah, sure. So, forgive me. [1:51:34] Speaker G (unidentified): Would you mind? I actually had a couple truly factual clarifying questions for Mike, and it seems like it might be a good opportunity to ask. That's fine. Mike, I just had some questions. I've heard, I think in the DAVIN's most recent response letter, they said the tiers would be 50 inches, but in one of your letters, it said 60. I know it's like 50 to 60 is the range, but I just wanted to know what it would be. Another question I had was in the DEP application materials from round one you mentioned the decking would be through flow, but now it seems like it's solid wood. And then the another question would be when you're assessing alternatives for the galvanized, excuse me, the aluminum material you mentioned, like, you know, buffing it or painting it, did you consider wood, and if so, why not go with wood? And then you mentioned, or maybe it was Rick mentioned, a 50-year lifespan on the helical piles. Do you have actual specs for the piles? Yeah, there's two articles here that I can give to them, but like, I mean, can we get more information on the specific brand and, you know, [1:52:34] Speaker D (unidentified): call outs? I mean, that'll be because of the issue with sourcing materials at the moment because of the tariffs. I mean, they'll, I'll have to find out from the builder where they're going to source from. I mean, since we're in, do you think you could run that down before the continued [1:52:51] Speaker L (unidentified): of your hearing? We don't have a builder for the pier yet because of this lengthy process. Could you get something like or equal if you get identify one and, you know, that your name is [1:53:06] Speaker D (unidentified): bracket? And then, yeah, the current builder that we're in discussion with, I'll ask if they, he can get some sort of information related to the helical anchors. Sure. Yeah, we can do that. [1:53:20] Speaker L (unidentified): It may not be the exact product, but something. Did you have, did you, did you [1:53:27] Speaker A (unidentified): have comments to our other three questions? I do just don't [1:53:35] Speaker L (unidentified): Forget to provide this, just making a note. The 50 inch to 60 inch spacing we're proposing, 60 inches. 50 was specked out as the minimum by the by the manufacturers of these products, and as again as a minimum, so we're going with 60 inches, just a instead of always going with a bare minimum. The throat through flow decking was proposed with the wider. So a little history for the Board of Appeals: in the initial application to the Planning Board this year, we proposed a pier deck surface width that was five feet in width. There was an ADA need within their family with a couple family members, and the width that was originally permitted by the planning board at the other location on the property was too narrow to be able to get folks down in wheelchairs or other similar mobility devices. So we proposed something wider. Things changed with that family, those family members, and so we went back to the planning board with a revised application that reduced it to the width that was proposed with the original application because it was wider, and because of the desire of the then applicant to not create a shading problem for the salt marsh below, they proposed a through-flow decking, a very heavily perforated decking material for the pier to help more sunlight to go through. And it was going to be elevated higher as well. When they scaled the project back and the deck was going to be narrower, there didn't seem to be any apparent need for it. DEP said, they're the watchdogs for the vegetation and all the rest for shading, said it just isn't necessary, so we went back to the less expensive decking material. Alternatives, why not wood? There's wood will decay much quicker than an aluminum system, and there's no point, and there's also a cost issue with aluminum, I mean a cost issue with using wood. Plus you'd have to have substantially a substantially greater number of pier events to support the shorter distance, the span you can get with wood versus aluminum. So it would have been, there would have been a higher direct impact of the coastal wetland. As part of our DEP alternatives analysis to avoid and minimize coastal wetland impacts, we would have been forced to consider something different, which we're proposing in the first place, the aluminum pier system, the [1:56:31] Speaker M (unidentified): one and a half to one ratio for the pier, is that width to height, or it's, it needs to be [1:56:41] Speaker C (unidentified): elevated one and a half times the width, so correct, the shading surface. Yep, yes. [1:57:01] Speaker G (unidentified): Please, all right. [1:57:05] Speaker E (unidentified): Do laptop photos. I apologize, I apologize, but since they brought up the pier that's on the 1774 and property and on their website, that's it. And for a point of... [1:57:25] Speaker Q (unidentified): How is that going to be on the record? [1:57:27] Speaker E (unidentified): I can submit for the next meeting. I'll submit paper copies of this. The squirrel point bridge that the commenter referenced, that's what that looks like. So double that in length. And then compare that to the dock you just saw, which is typical of the docks you can see in this area. It's really just a huge and striking difference, and you know, through the planning board process I actually thought that there was a technical requirement that was requiring this big aluminum structure, and it's really striking to hear that actually there is no technical requirement, that was a choice that appears to have been mostly cost-based. If this structure would, it would blend a lot better with the sort of more natural [1:58:19] Speaker M (unidentified): and historic character. He just explained why they couldn't go. No, he didn't. He [1:58:24] Speaker E (unidentified): speculated that DEP would have put them in an aluminum dock, but they did not see that. They never started with the wood structure. If everything was the [1:58:33] Speaker A (unidentified): saying, except for this wood instead of aluminum, would we be here? No. No, I don't think so. [1:58:42] Speaker E (unidentified): This seems to me like it's a cost-based preference, and aluminum does not break away in pieces in a huge catastrophic storm. It breaks away in one, well, however many sections this is. But they're going to come down and crash into other people's docks, piers, property, and shorefronts in much bigger chunks. Because the heel of blankers are not necessarily the standard here. The offer to use the 1774 dock was not conditional. It would have been an easement that would have been a permanent right. Just wasn't an offer that was taken up and never put the paper, and in terms of the alternative of the use, I mean, if the use, the character, those two arguments have to be made. The use of using a boat and being able to tie it up, that can happen with a mooring. In terms of an alternative, that only requires having a dinghy at the shore. So is that, is that not an option? That's what seems to be what most people who live on marsh do. And then the DEP, I think at the planning board level mistakes were made in simply just deferring to the DEP and deferring to Maine Historic Preservation Commission. If we're going to defer to the state agency, why do you guys even exist? Your job is to look at the comprehensive plan and the standards that have been put in place for your ordinances and to simply say, oh well, DEP looked at it and said it was fine. They're looking at different standards. And particularly unfair in this case, I'll tell you what happened. The original project was put forward a couple of years ago. My client knew that they're peripherally sort of knew that there was a project that they were planning, looked it up, saw where they were they're planning it, and kind of made the judgment call that she wasn't going to get involved. When IFNw came back with their comments that said, well, we don't like it, 's got too much environmental impact, we'd like to see it move down there, no one told 1774 in that was happening. So DEP, through their permit, shoved this pier all the way down to the very edge of the property line, and my client had no way of knowing that was going to happen and how impacted it would be. So she did not provide any comments to DEP, and I think that if we had been involved raising these issues, that process would have gone a lot differently. When the DP looked at just this last iteration of the project, they don't reinvent the whole approval, they just look at the element of the project that has changed, and this was just a slight, you know, change the width of those anchors. They don't go back and reevaluate the whole project. So we didn't, with this application, have a chance to go and say, hey, this thing is right next to the property line of this historic property, look at all the ways that's going to impact the character and the views from the area. As though the DEP would have said those issues were already decided and you guys weren't here at the table. So to, in this case in particular, just kind of input what DEP decided into this process and say it looks good because they found it good is unfair to the ordinance and unfair to 1774. [2:02:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Sure, yeah, just quick rebuttals on this DEP issue. Again, as Christa mentioned, they're looking at a different standard. There it's a big difference. The key difference is that when you do a NERFA permit for a DP doc, you're looking to make sure that they've done the, that they've avoided impacts the greatest extent possible, which in turn is defined as choosing the least impractical impactful practicable alternative, and practicable is defined as like within the realm of you get to do what you want. Within the realm of budget and other technical constraints, so they actually are looking through the lens of, okay, these people probably get to do this? Have they done their homework in mitigating it? That's not the lens that the Town of Pittsburgh ordinance and comprehensive plan calls for you to apply. There's not this presumption that you get what you want, you just have to do your homework in mitigating it. So please don't look to the EP as decisive in how you apply the ordinances in this process. The role of the comp plan has come up. I actually think Mr. Davin stated it correctly when he said the comp plan does not apply directly to this project, that is true, but a lot of the standards the board is being asked to apply are Moshi-subjected standards, like character of the area, this sort of thing, and when you are trying to figure out what that means, reference to the comp plan is essential. I already asked for my clarifying questions for Mike. The character of the area, I think the, [2:04:08] Speaker K (unidentified): I'm sorry, is it Davin or Dilan? Davin. [2:04:10] Speaker G (unidentified): The Dabbins reference the history of shipbuilding in Pittsburgh. That may well be true, but it's not shipbuilding in marshes. And the comprehensive plan gives marshes a special role. It talks about their value, scenic value, as undisturbed areas, buffering the uplands and wetlands. I think that context is important in evaluating how the comprehensive plan fits into this. I think Kristen hit glare really well, except Josh wanted to mention that in your rendering, that the dad instead objected to showing a rendering of the aluminum pier in place, that was actually photoshopped from an image of the Squirrel Point aluminum pier. [2:04:52] Speaker I (unidentified): Well, not that high tech. It was cut out and taped on that picture of the, that's a picture of the point, of the pier going to the Squirrel Point, going across the Skrill Point Marsh that I put in my rendering, and it's very glaring. [2:05:09] Speaker G (unidentified): That's not like a glare filter from Instagram, that's an actual photo. [2:05:13] Speaker I (unidentified): It's just a picture I took sitting in my office of the ramp across the river, and I pasted it on the other thing that was the same distance away. [2:05:20] Speaker G (unidentified): Lastly on soils, Mr. Morris made some comments about how in development we see what the soils are and we engineer to them. Completely agree with that. It is absolutely possible through the miracles of engineering to design a pier that would be structurally sound on any soil type, but that's just not the issue that the ordinance is calling for. It's not saying is the design suitable for the soils, it's are the soils suitable for this type of use. Different standard and the question is, a salt marsh appropriate for a dock? Again, you don't have to have one. The code does not guarantee you one. And so it might be that your soils on your site are just not the type of soils where this is appropriate. [2:06:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there a salt marsh in front of your property? Pardon? Is there a salt marsh in front of your property? [2:06:07] Speaker I (unidentified): Most of my property is salt marsh. [2:06:08] Speaker O (unidentified): But you have a dock, right? [2:06:10] Speaker I (unidentified): I have a dock that was put in the 60s as well as that road that was put in the 60s. [2:06:14] Speaker G (unidentified): And your dock is pinned to? [Speaker I (unidentified): Nothing but ledge.] So the road, which I think Mr. Morse referred to as a 400 foot structure, or maybe that was Mr. Davin. Just to clarify, it is a road. It has been there for decades. It's not really a new decision to build a new aluminum structure, so maybe you would consider that a structure. I personally wouldn't. Back to the issue of soils, I just want to pull up the language one more time for reference here, because it says, access from shore shall be developed on soils appropriate for such use so again it's not calling for how well can you engineer this design to the soils it's saying is this an appropriate place for this type of thing to begin and that's all I have in rebuttal if we're ready [2:07:06] Speaker Q (unidentified): I'll move on to the next question on the alternative are you asking us to consider the perpetual easement that would let them have access to that dock any time of the day or night? [2:07:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm saying that it was offered and in the realm of other options it exists. It's obviously something that would have to be negotiated. But lots of people use, you know, easements to get viable docks. [2:07:44] Speaker D (unidentified): Are we allowed to comment? [2:07:48] Speaker L (unidentified): Okay, I'll go quickly and then I can comment. A couple things I just want to mention. There are comments about, made that the planning board are suggesting that the planning board relied very, heavily on the DEP and made a stark preservation commission. I'm not here to speak on behalf of the planning board, but as the representing the Davins, as in the applicant form, before the planning board, that is probably the furthest thing from the truth. The DEP was not consulted by the planning board, to my knowledge. Through this process, there was general discussion about the DEP permitting process, where things at. But ultimately, you may note that the planning board issued its approval for the project before the DEP ever or the Army Corps of Engineers ever issued their permits so yes I think that's a mischaracterization of the Planning Board's reliance on the DEP and with respect to the Maine Historic Preservation Commission the town's ordinance includes a requirement that for this type of project that the Maine Historic Preservation Commission be notified and the Planning Board would consider comments from the Maine Historic Preservation Commission so the Why would the planning board do that? Why would the ordinance do that? Because the Maine Historic Preservation Commission is the state's foremost leading group of experts on historic preservation and historic issues. The ordinance required it. That is why their comments were included as part of the process. and then the other issue that I want to make a make mention of is again we're related to the soils I'm going to reread the first part of that provision in the ordinance and it says access from shore shall be developed on soils appropriate for such use and constructed so as to control erosion what's the purpose so it controls erosion okay that's very important but I'm going to even take a step back further and I'm going to read the first three words of that again. Access from shore. It doesn't say anything about what happens in the resource. What happens when you're in the water? The highest annual tide line, or astronomical tide line, is almost up to the embankment at the shore. So, the only thing we really have at the shore where this standard is really relevant is just this aluminum ramp that will be providing access, 14-foot aluminum ramp, as I recall, providing access to the pier structure. We demonstrated to the planning board that the pier structure will be supported sufficiently as well, but that is not on the shore. So that's not just semantics, that is what the ordinance says, access from shore. There's there's not an issue with the salt marsh soils on the shore. [2:10:58] Speaker D (unidentified): That's all I'll say, and just a quick couple of clarifications. It was said that the pier is now up against the property line. That is partially correct. Our property is made of two parcels, parcel one and parcel two. Originally IFNW and DEP wanted the pier moved all the way against the abutting property line in parcel 2. I had indicated to both at that time that there are setback requirements required by the town, and so we both agreed that the pier would be located near the property line for parcel 1. So we're a good 52 to 55 feet off of the abutting property line. Also it's not been mentioned, and you'll see in a number of the photos, there's an existing forested area in that part of the shoreline, and so from the end's perspective a vast majority of the pier is going to be obscured by the tree line there, particularly in summer when all the trees are leafed out. We had submitted information from the planning board and photos showing that at the point at which you can start to see the building for the end, you're approximately 180 feet out already in the marsh. Couple other quick points, the deeded access was never offered to us. It was just an open comment. Well, you think you at any time you want to use our dock you can, and it was just left at that. The in the aspect about the road is, the original road has existed for decades. However last year, Mr Bait made a significant improvement on the road, which raised that, it used to be at almost that marsh level and was prone to flooding, which I can understand why he would want to improve it, but that improvement is significantly raised, and you'll see it at the sidewalk. It's [2:12:59] Speaker H (unidentified): important to note, too, we're here asking for permission. I don't believe Mr. Bate did, but we're here asking for your permission and waiting for your approvals, and I think that 's something that should at least be said. [2:13:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Are you on to the next point? [2:13:16] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, and you did. Is that next to the road? [2:13:20] Speaker I (unidentified): The road has been there since the 60s. [2:13:23] Speaker A (unidentified): I think we're good on the road. I just didn't make the call. Okay. [2:13:27] Speaker G (unidentified): Next issue we've raised is the issue of water pollution. I think we've addressed that through discussing the concerns about the bill for piles, so I'm going to move on from that issue onto the issue of wildlife. If you look at our materials,. The area of the salt marsh is a very high value habitat. I mean, salt marshes are important wetlands. Wetlands serve an essential ecological function for a number of species. There is a, like the thing I was trying to find is a letter in the record from Inland Fisheries and Wildlife outlining all the species that are present and outlining their concerns with what they call the proliferation of decks of piers in salt marshes. I think the Dabbins have pointed out that ultimately IFW did say okay fine we're fine with it but again the reason they said that is that the standard in the context of a DEP NERPA permit is has the applicant done enough homework to demonstrate that they've mitigated this as much as practicable. We don't have that word in our ordinance practicable it doesn't our ordinance doesn't so much care about budget [Speaker P (unidentified): and technical feasibility.] The standard that you're looking at is, will this have adverse impacts on wildlife? And it will. Salt marshes are dominated by grasses. Grasses are sun-hungry species. They need the sun. Shading is a big impact, and it's something, it is the reason that these types of structures are scrutinized so closely. The commentary from IFW when it was asking the now permittee, as Mr. Morse points out, to mitigate was, well, can you move this farther south to an area that has more cattails and is slightly less, you know, if going from a high-value habitat to a medium-value habitat? And because that's where their property line ends, they have done their homework from DEP's perspective to mitigate it to the extent practicable. But here, in the zoning context, where we're not so much worried about practicable, we can still continue to look at the fact that the bottom of their property is still the middle of the salt marsh. And building a really long aluminum pier in the middle of the salt marsh, which creates a dead zone in this important habitat, is going to have profound adverse impacts on songbirds in particular. There are, IFW did identify potential for habitat for endangered species, although it did say that it doesn't think any habitat exists. There's potential for that habitat. Habitat. A number of other sensitive species are there. And this is just a very, large structure and a really important environment for them. Josh, do you want to add anything on wildlife? [2:16:41] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah. The voters already put a couple hundred feet of fence on our property line that blocks the natural wildlife corridor on land and now this proposal is going to block the marsh. This is a picture of my wife texted me in October. I'm sorry, in September. It's going to be, I can't tell if that buck is on my road or on the marsh, but it's going to be a hard pass for wildlife to get from south to north. This is the aforementioned road, yes, existing road I raised it up above the 2024 storms and other issue I particular thinking about is with black ducks in the marsh. This year they nest in the cattails, they come down the water end to feed, and then they go back to the cattails. This is going to interrupt their activity and I will note that when I did do the road improvement last year. It went from 24 inches of culvert to three 24-inch culverts. So while I'm raising the road, getting it so it's not flooding and being washed into the marsh, properly rip-wrapped with three times the drainage it had, was an ecological improvement. The town has put a four-foot box culvert on Cranberry Point. So this section of marsh now is well fed and it's much healthier than it had been in the past. [2:18:23] Speaker G (unidentified): Alright, I apologize. I found the document I was looking for. It's at AR983. That's our department. Published scientific literature has demonstrated that coastal marsh vegetation as measured by stem density and biomass is produced under and near piers. And this comment goes down from here really explaining the impact of peers on this type of ecosystem. I encourage the board to read this document in its entirety beginning at AR91. And then I think it's really important to bear in mind that to the extent you're allowed to look at DEP's analysis and its ultimate conclusion, approving the peer, part of what made DEP approve the peer was that they required a couple thousand, over $5,000 as a fee-in-lieu to help mitigate the impacts. So the way a fee-in-lieu works is the EP looks at all the impacts and says, you don't have no impacts, you have X amount of impacts, you can either redesign your project to reduce them or you can pay a fee-in-lieu of doing that to help mitigate them. The town of Phippsburg does not have a fee-in-lieu program, so you can't ask them to pay you $5,000 to mitigate the environmental impacts you deny the permit if they're going to be too many environmental impacts and that's that's our argument on wildlife and the next one is historic resources so if you could respond to the [2:19:46] Speaker H (unidentified): wildlife what's up oh we could we respond to the wildlife argument the [2:19:54] Speaker E (unidentified): transcript that I've provided also references that this is a seal nursery [2:20:06] Speaker H (unidentified): I'd like to just refer to page 3 of the DEP approval that we just received. On number D, it says the proposed activity will not unreasonably harm any significant wildlife habitat, freshwater, wetland, plant habitat, threatened or endangered plant habitat, aquatic or adjacent upland habitat, travel corridor, freshwater, equestrian, estuarine, or main marine fisheries or other aquatic life prior to the start of construction, a payment will have to be made. But they have found consistently they've been out to our property numerous times. [2:20:51] Speaker D (unidentified): And specifically, DEP has been on my property four times. IF&W has been out there twice. DMR has been out there twice. They've spent time out in the marsh. And, you know, as appellants have noted is while they did indicate some species in the area, that most of the species that are noted is that there is a potential. It's not meant that they viewed them. You know, particularly when you look at the Army Corps approval, it notices that there is a potential for loggerhead turtle habitat. Now, I've never known one to come up in this cold of water, but I guess there is a potential. Just a couple other elements to point is, you know, it keeps being referred to as a saltwater marsh. That's partially correct. As IF&W noted in their visit, the presence of the cattail is showing that the marsh is in transition. And that's because cattail, they prefer a freshwater environment versus a saltwater environment. And that's part of their reasoning for asking us to move the location, is that it was a less suitable habitat for anything that wanted to use the marsh, potentially. Also, as they noted, there's no impact of travel corridors, so as Appellant noted, the picture of the deer, which actually is on his property, due to the height elevation for the pier, it shouldn't impede anything being able to walk underneath. I mean, Mike, can you give more specifics to that, if needed? Can I [2:22:34] Speaker Q (unidentified): ask a quick clarifying question? Sure. You talked about changing the decking because you made it a little bit smaller or less wide. How does that play with the three-quarter inch spacing versus the quarter inch spacing? [2:22:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, honestly, I'm somewhat confused that there's such fixation on this. So again, remember IF&W and DEP and DMR, they're looking at shading impacts from the decking material. and so that's why they had they had proposed a quarter and I mean a three-quarter inch spacing however it was at the second site walk for IF&W and DMR it was noted to them but at that time we were being represented by Tim Forrester he explained to them that you know listen a three-quarter inch gap that could present a safety problem because you get fingers toes tripping hazard thing of that nature and as we indicated in our response letter that's we said we were going to stay with the quarter inch gapping they said that was fine it would just be entered in as part of the in lieu fee assessment and again might correct me if I'm wrong but my understanding is it's a new requirement it's only been around for a few years now and that you know we were just part of a lucky project that we were one of the first to be assessed this fee and it's going to be an ongoing fee for all projects thank you the [2:24:12] Speaker G (unidentified): fee in lieu is not a standard fee it's assessed it's customized to the impacts of the project the reason we are fixated on the deck spacing is that ifw in its analysis of impacts recommended bigger spacing to reduce the shading beneath which is the primary driver of ecological impact from the pier. The permittee chose not to do that and to pay the fee in lieu instead because that decision increased the fee in lieu. Again, the town doesn't have a fee in lieu mechanism, so it can't use money to help buffer out that decision in the same way that DEP can. So that is part of the analysis that needs to happen here on how these impacts work. Regarding page three that the permittee quoted, it's absolutely true that DEP found that this project would not have unreasonable impacts. You have to bear in mind that chapter 310, which this is issued under, defines unreasonable impacts as impacts that come from projects that aren't designed to avoid impacts to the greatest practicable extent. So in that context It's finding that you have avoided impact to the greatest practicable extent, taking into account budget and technological constraints. So that's not the standard that we're applying here. Pittsburgh doesn't care about budget. I think our next issue is... [2:25:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, should we respond to those couple of comments before you jump to... [2:25:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I think we're going to not come to the next issue anyway, so we'll give you the... for a couple of minutes, and then we'll let everybody go home and go to bed. [2:25:59] Speaker L (unidentified): I'll just start by, I guess, sharing the reality of DEPs in Lufi. And it's simply this. DEP in the past, I'm going to say two years, two and a half years, felt their authority allowed them to charge an in-Lufi for any indirect impacts to a coastal salt marsh system. They've charged and in lieu the same fee in lieu for compensation for freshwater wetland impacts for many, years. What's triggered this more recently is their interpretation that their standards allow them to charge a fee for indirect impacts as well as the direct impacts. The threshold is 500 square feet, which, by the time you add up all the square footage of the pier, for indirect impacts you're going to exceed that. It's just the same for a shoreline stabilization project that impacts coastal mudflat with riprap, so large rock or boulders down in the salt marsh. If you exceed 500 square feet, you're in the door for in-lieu feed compensation. The compensation for this had absolutely nothing to do with the quarter inch versus three-quarter inch gap, and that's what's being characterized by the appellant as being the trigger for this fee. Oh, if you're not going to do the three-quarter inch gap, then you're going to be charged this fee. That's not the case at all. They were going to be charged this in lieu compensation fee regardless of the gap in the boards. [2:27:42] Speaker D (unidentified): do you have anything more to say not on that but just you know the issue it's been brought up a couple times now the constraints of the budget and just to clarify is this is the most costly approach to me for developing a peer and a doc system if i went pressure treated it would traditional pylons it would be less costly like by hundreds of thousands of dollars and the only reason we're moving in this direction is we're trying to coordinate with DEP's recommendations to have the least amount of impact to [2:28:20] Speaker L (unidentified): the environment. And then my last comment related to the wildlife impacts or perceived wildlife impacts, and so there's been a lot of emphasis put on the DEP permit, and that is because the DEP is one of the, that's the state's leading environmental agency, so there's purpose for that, but I don't want to leave this conversation without pointing out that the Planning Board also under its own ordinance made a, their own independent determination that this project will not create an unreasonable impact on fisheries, wildlife, and all the rest, and I feel they made up an absolutely correct decision. So okay, we'll leave, I think we'll [2:29:06] Speaker H (unidentified): call it a night there. Can we ask when you would be wanting to come out to do a site visit? What's that? Do you have an idea of when you would want to come out to do the site? Saturday would be good. You could get the full effect of the end sweating, and it's, we know this [2:29:22] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, it doesn't need to be noticed, but we should be able to check our calendars, like, how much notice has to be given. [2:29:31] Speaker K (unidentified): Rachel will help. [2:29:32] Speaker F (unidentified): It can be listed [2:29:37] Speaker A (unidentified): in the paper. Can we do, like, the site walk and then half a second here at the same time? [2:29:42] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, we could, but I can get it to the newspaper on Tuesday, which means it will be published on the 20th, which means you guys are looking at the first week of December. It [2:29:57] Speaker G (unidentified): is now a good time to discuss the mechanics of that with respect to my client's attendance? Do you have a, yeah, we're going to preserve an object if he's excluded from the sidewalk. Well, we would be looking to counsel for the zoning board's opinion on whether the permittee can exclude him from the sidewalk. [2:30:15] Speaker K (unidentified): Our position is that, if you're directing it at me, is that it's not a question that's appropriately before this board to interpret any trespass order that is in place. And that would be something that needs to be dealt with separately. Obviously your objection is preserving your record, but we're not going to say who can and cannot come to a sidewalk. It's a public sidewalk. It's noticed to the public. Like your client can make his own decisions, this body doesn't enforce or not enforce a trespass order. [2:30:52] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I think the way I would frame it is, I don't think we're asking for interpretation of the trespass order. [2:30:59] Speaker K (unidentified): The way I would look at it is, [2:31:01] Speaker G (unidentified): you know, I think in the permittees response letter, they kind of framed it as a takings issue. You know, we have a right to exclude anyone we want from our property. But if you're looking at it through that lens, like Nolan Dolan says that sometimes you have to give up your property rights in order to get your permit because that's the give-and-take of the permit process permitted is a privilege not a right you're not guaranteed one they have the power to permit him on their property I mean that's very clear they could just say trespass notice remote come on in that's they have that power so as a condition of them getting this approval they should be required to grant that [2:31:41] Speaker O (unidentified): permission because mr. Bates gonna do why does he want to be there I mean [2:31:46] Speaker C (unidentified): because it's an open public meeting can you have a technology why does he want [2:31:51] Speaker O (unidentified): to be there what is his purpose of going there to observe he has the right to [2:31:55] Speaker E (unidentified): hear what everybody says we representing planning boards all the time I have applicants that say you know oh it's dangerous here I shouldn't have to let any random member of the public on my property that's you don't get to pick can choose if you want a permit it's a public process and you have that little [2:32:13] Speaker K (unidentified): mini public meeting this board isn't saying that he gets to go or not gets to go I think would be right but the board would agree that it's open to the public [2:32:35] Speaker E (unidentified): the general public, right? [2:32:38] Speaker K (unidentified): Correct. I mean, I think. [2:32:40] Speaker E (unidentified): Because they can trespass anyone, right? They could say. It's just a notice. They could say Sarah Dunnigan and anybody else in the near boat is also trespassed. [2:32:50] Speaker K (unidentified): I guess, what is the specific question? Are you asking? And I want to be careful to like, I'm not making this decision, right? I'm saying that our legal opinion to the board would be that it is not up to the board to determine whether anything outside of this context, text, prohibit someone from coming to a public meeting. [2:33:11] Speaker G (unidentified): Why don't you brief it? Yes, that sounds great. I'm happy to do that. [2:33:15] Speaker E (unidentified): But for the record, I do think it would be helpful for anybody watching to understand it is open to the public, right? [2:33:21] Speaker A (unidentified): I want to know the interaction between the trespass. [2:33:24] Speaker D (unidentified): Can I just comment that it's been very clear from what we've read that a site block, whether it's the Planning Board or the Board of Appeals, has been defined differently by the state of Maine. It doesn't reach the same element of a public meeting or a public hearing which I would agree if I was Excluding mr. Bait from this meeting or any other town meeting. Yes, he would have a Reason there. However, the site walk is just an informative Evaluation by the board and it's at the discretion of the board if they want to entertain the public on the walk [2:34:05] Speaker A (unidentified): If we decide to entertain the sidewalk, [2:34:09] Speaker O (unidentified): then don't we have to make it open to the public? Yeah. [2:34:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I think maybe it's true that there's no actual deliberation happening, but it's still subject to the Open Public Meetings Act, which says that when any three... I would argue differently. [2:34:22] Speaker D (unidentified): I would suggest you read Duffy. [2:34:24] Speaker G (unidentified): All right, well, it sounds like briefing might make sense, but that might kick out the timeline, then I don't... [2:34:29] Speaker H (unidentified): Do you need a sidewalk? Are you all not familiar with this... they're requesting a sidewalk one of the reasons that we keep seeing is to delay things to cost us more money we have to pay an expert to come and I think that Kristen has been very good about bringing up one issue at each thing so that it has to come another month and it has to go another perpetual do you all really need to come and see this marsh do you not know what it looks like is it really going to be that helpful to go to all this trouble the [2:35:06] Speaker E (unidentified): board's standard like if this goes to court the court is going to be looking at whether your decision was arbitrary and when you start making judgments on the visual impact of things without having seen it and relying on no offense to mr bate but you know some lines that somebody drew on a piece of paper when you could have seen it with your own eyes [2:35:28] Speaker D (unidentified): Looking at the entire record and there were already two sidewalks completed by the planning board. Nothing has changed about the march. The location hasn't changed. The only thing that's changed is you're unlikely to see any wildlife out there. [2:35:41] Speaker G (unidentified): But we have a factual dispute about whether you can see the dock site from, this is a dispute you have raised about whether... [2:35:49] Speaker D (unidentified): It's entered in the record. We provided photographs. You've provided photographs that show the same tree line. [2:35:56] Speaker K (unidentified): We talked about this sidewalk in the context of arguments that they've made tonight, so I would just block that for the board is something that I mean I think it was discussed at the beginning of the meeting without objection and then arguments were made with the understanding that would be a site walk at this point probably makes sense to take off vote on whether you need a site walk but I would just note that you may need to revisit some stuff at a future meeting if you don't have a site walk. Based on the way site walk was incorporated into the arguments from all parties tonight I was under the [2:36:30] Speaker G (unidentified): impression the board had already decided I think [2:36:36] Speaker M (unidentified): a sidewalk would be helpful to visualize I mean I've seen marshes before but we're talking about a particular spot on the marsh I mean we're all [2:36:45] Speaker C (unidentified): adults we ought to be able to figure out how to do a sidewalk right do you want to do a motion [2:36:51] Speaker K (unidentified): and a vote on whether the sidewalk is needed though I think you decided to do it earlier but there wasn't a formal vote I think at this point it might make sense to have a formal vote on it [2:37:06] Speaker D (unidentified): And what is your objection to Mr. Bade being there we've had years of animosity with Mr. Bade part of the reason you know he noted the fence that we put up part of it was to keep him away from certain aspects of my property so again this is a situation where I 'm sorry for the protection and safety and the emotional aspects of our family I will have law [2:37:32] Speaker K (unidentified): enforcement present and I think the vote is on whether to have a site walk not [2:37:38] Speaker C (unidentified): about who can attend right do we need to have a public site walk or can we just do a board site walk [2:37:46] Speaker A (unidentified): No I think if we do a site walk it's for a council but I'm pretty sure if we do a [2:37:51] Speaker D (unidentified): site walk then it has to be and as I commented to the planning board and it's on the video and in their record the public is welcome Mr. Bait is not okay well we can I think [2:38:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Shay's point is well taken, that we were operating under the assumption that a sidewalk is inevitable, right? So we should probably, if we haven't voted already, then we can, for belt and suspenders, we can take another vote right now, and then you know it'll be open to the public, and you know Mr. Devine's call, Devon's call, law enforcement, then that's not that we can control. That's not our problem. I agree. Well, so. We're not going to prohibit them from dialing the phone and calling the sheriff. [2:38:38] Speaker G (unidentified): We're not going to do that. I'm not asking you to do that. My question is, I have framed the issue differently. I can re-explain our position if that would be helpful. It sounds like it wouldn't. Someone suggested briefing. I just want to know how, like, do I preserve the objection in this meeting? Are we doing briefing after this meeting? Maybe we hold the vote on whether it's happening and then we talk about the mechanics. [2:39:01] Speaker A (unidentified): The mechanics are, it's open to the public. They're going to say, they're going to call the cops and they're going to remove him. That's what's going to happen. [2:39:08] Speaker G (unidentified): Is there, is it happening? Is the sidewalk happening? [2:39:12] Speaker O (unidentified): It's happening. We're going to vote on it right now. [2:39:13] Speaker G (unidentified): So maybe we'll do that and then we'll discuss this after. [2:39:17] Speaker K (unidentified): I think that makes sense. [2:39:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody want to make a motion for a sidewalk? Make a motion. We have a sidewalk. Anybody want to second it? In favor? Passes. Okay. We're going to have a second motion. [2:39:30] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. So our perspective is that the Board completely agreed that it is not the Board's role to give us legal advice on how criminal or civil trespass can be done. However, the board does have the power as a condition of this process to refire the Devons, excuse me, Davin's, to grant permission for the public. We're not going to exercise that discretion. All right, then I'll note my objection to that decision. [2:39:55] Speaker H (unidentified): We [2:39:59] Speaker F (unidentified): want to pull out our calendars for potential site walk dates for the first week of December. [2:40:06] Speaker Q (unidentified): If we look for that, I'll get from the 15th of December till the 5th of January. [2:40:12] Speaker B (unidentified): We're going to do it the first week of December. [2:40:14] Speaker F (unidentified): The first week of December and sunset at 4 o'clock. [2:40:18] Speaker L (unidentified): It's going to be dark. [2:40:20] Speaker F (unidentified): Sunset's at 4 o'clock. [2:40:22] Speaker E (unidentified): Oh, jeez. I'm sorry. [2:40:25] Speaker P (unidentified): No, it reads sunset's at 4 o'clock. So we'll have to do it [2:40:28] Speaker C (unidentified): likely by [2:40:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Before. We need to be parking by 4 at the latest. And the Tuesday and Thursday of that week, the town hall conference space is, if [2:41:26] Speaker E (unidentified): I notice it, on [2:41:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Tuesday, it'll be there Friday, 7, 8, 9, that's 10 days. November 30th, Proctor? [Speaker Q (unidentified): I believe so.] 4 p.m. Roland, aye. [2:41:43] Speaker Q (unidentified): No, it'll be before 4. [2:41:47] Speaker M (unidentified): 3 p.m.? [2:41:49] Speaker F (unidentified): Or three, I mean, the planning board side blocks that you might take more time, but they, I think they were about a half an hour each. At [2:42:05] Speaker D (unidentified): least you folks get the benefit of, there'll be no bugs this time. The planning board had an endurance for you, isn't it? Maybe three o'clock. [2:42:12] Speaker L (unidentified): And would the regular meetings follow that? Yeah. [2:42:15] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. A continuation of the hearing, right? Of this hearing? [2:42:20] Speaker M (unidentified): Yes. Great. Perfect. So when do we, what time? What? Three. [2:42:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Was it three? Does that, does three work okay for you, doctor? [2:42:26] Speaker E (unidentified): What time are we going to do for the actual hearing? [2:42:31] Speaker F (unidentified): We can say immediately following, but likely through the afternoon. If you don't want to attend the type off. [2:42:36] Speaker E (unidentified): That's what I just wanted to add. If I wasn't attending the type off, I wouldn't show up. [2:42:43] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, if you're first off. [2:42:48] Speaker D (unidentified): Just a logistics comment. We don't have a lot of parking available, so I'd like to leave it to the board that they get first preference and ask anybody else that's coming in attendance to libraries available and you know other alternatives, but I'm sure we could find somebody that can help us with directing parking. Can [2:43:16] Speaker L (unidentified): I ask a procedural question as we move forward with the planning board process that was kind of dragged on and on, dragged on and on, because the anybody speaking in opposition, the public neighbors, could come up with any new argument at any point during the process, and that's what happened on at least several occasions. And so, well, applicant, how are you going to respond to this? Well, we're going to need to review this and get back to you, and it resulted in numerous meetings. So we had a point where we feel like we've We've hashed and rehashed these specific topics we've covered tonight. I won't go over them all to a point where I'm going to ask the board if they'd be willing to say, all right, we're done with those, so that we're not going to keep having folks offer new info. Part of the problem with the planning board was folks would drum up a bunch of angry folks in town to come out in droves, and not in droves, but you know, a number of them, and presenting their new concerns, and they weren't there for the first two meetings. And so it's just, it's it's a very inefficient way to have that process conducted, and I'm hoping for relief from that from the board of [2:44:39] Speaker A (unidentified): appeals. Well, I mean, if somebody shows up and they want to talk, do we have discretion, not only the discretion to tell them they can't talk? Very, I think it's called [2:44:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Democracy prior to public comment closing. Note, yeah, I think what Mike's just pointing out is [2:44:54] Speaker D (unidentified): even the arguments tonight, they're redundant. I hope that we're not going to go back and start [2:44:59] Speaker C (unidentified): with point two and five again. I think we're past that now, so questions make them up when the board [2:45:04] Speaker K (unidentified): discusses it though, right, and after the sidewalk, but I [2:45:13] Speaker A (unidentified): don't know if I can answer that question [2:45:14] Speaker C (unidentified): right now. Good night. I think she did. Yeah, I think that, you know, it's in, they're tabling it and [2:45:21] Speaker A (unidentified): continuing it, they can't. All right, so we, so just whatever we need to get out of here sooner around later, so we voted on the sidewalk. What is the other thing we have to vote on, just to table [2:45:32] Speaker C (unidentified): and continue it? Okay, anybody want to make that motion? Anybody want to second it? All right, so [2:45:38] Speaker A (unidentified): So, we're going to have the site walk on the 30th at 3 p.m. [2:45:57] Speaker J (unidentified): The site walk and then hearing at public hearing. [2:46:01] Speaker F (unidentified): And then hearing immediately followed by 4 p.m. [2:46:04] Speaker K (unidentified): As a reminder, in the intervening time, please don't discuss it, the app, it's the appellant's, with anyone. [2:46:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Adjourned at 9-14. The [2:48:07] Speaker R (unidentified): more important that could be taken care of right now. You can't cut out of me now, baby. Now when you've got me feeling so, warm all over, I'm good for you. I know I'm good for what you want. Keep [2:48:53] Speaker S (unidentified): your g-string on. I only came in here to change my clothes. Now I'd like to see the rest of the show [2:49:09] Speaker R (unidentified): that the queen but the mayor don't out of here choose company who's to tell me to blow [2:49:31] Speaker S (unidentified): too. Remember it's going to be made around here tonight, honey, eat your heart out. Yeah, look [2:49:47] Speaker R (unidentified): what you've done. Let me see you later, I'll make everything up to you. Yeah, you [2:50:17] Speaker S (unidentified): think you had. He would have you on his back. [2:50:23] Speaker R (unidentified): That's me. What's a guy like that want with leftovers? [2:52:42] Speaker S (unidentified): Like being like this? Revenge? He alive has given me a power he didn't count on. That you can feel. Hideous as our deformities. And it will wreak our revenge. And [2:54:26] Speaker N (unidentified): you will enforce it. The thing out here. In [2:56:54] Speaker T (unidentified): some miscalculation and often lose themselves in transplants of broken limbs and amputated arms. But with this serum. He has used you. His arms not just one substance it is would never take it would never stay in place that blood's antibodies would attack it as they attack any invading matter void tissues voids that provide the antibodies for the blood that detect foreign transplanted matter makes me feel the three element of the universe. How can you speak of power he's pumped into me under a body this person's here with a girl before she disappears. Do you think you'll get one Here's a new taste treat, the corn dog, I dipped in a thick golden southern style corn batter that seals in all their freshness. Yes. [3:05:47] Speaker R (unidentified): We'll have to finish the game. [3:05:48] Speaker S (unidentified): Tomorrow afternoon. Tomorrow I'm going to Mary's party. Tomorrow. Aren't you a party? [3:05:53] Speaker R (unidentified): Why, I didn't even know. I don't like parties. I never have any fun at parties. [3:05:58] Speaker S (unidentified): I was kind of hoping you'd go. Parties are more fun when all your friends are there. Cindy! Well, I'd better go. I'll see you. Here's your ball. Mother, [3:06:23] Speaker R (unidentified): why do you suppose Mary didn't invite me to her party? Are you sure you didn't get an invitation? Maybe they thought I wouldn't want to go to a party. They probably thought I wouldn't know how to act. Hey, now, your name's Cindy, not Cinderella. You will get an invitation to the party. There's just been some mix-up. Wait and see. Oh, it's not important anyhow. Good night, Mother. Good night, Cindy. Cindy. Cindy, not Cinderella. You go to the party. You go to the party. Wake up, Cindy. What? Who's there? I don't see anybody. Of course you didn't. I'm not just anybody. I'm your fairy godmother. Sure. You don't believe me? Well, that's up to you. I just thought you might want to go to that party. Oh, I do, I do. We've got some work to do. We've gonna get you ready. Oh, but I wasn't invited to the party. They probably thought I'd rather play basketball or go fishing or... Well, you've been invited, all right. I've seen to that. And I'm going with you. But you mustn't tell anyone. Not even Dennis? Well, maybe we'd better tell Dennis. I have a feeling he's going to need my help, too. But hurry up or you'll be late. But the party isn't until this afternoon. It is this afternoon. Now hurry up, out of bed. Oh, what a mess. Oh, well, that's why I have the magic wand. Ready? Oh, but this isn't my very best dress. Oh, now look. You're not going to the party to show off your clothes, but you should be clean and neat when you go to the party. We'd better hurry now. We don't want to be late. Ready? Here we go to Mary's. Here we are. Oh, I hope everyone is already here. I'd hate to be the first one. I don't blame you. No one likes to sit and wait for a party to start. And a party can't really get going until everyone arrives. So whenever you go to a party, Cindy, always be on time. And when the clock says it's time to go home, be sure to leave on time. That's important. Well, my clothes turn like Cinderella. Oh, no. But you can spoil the fun of a party if you try to make it last too long, so that everyone gets tired and bored. Come on, Janet. Oh, look, here comes some of the others now. We're all getting here at the same time. Where'd you go? Hi, Cindy. Who are you talking to? Oh, no, I was just thinking out loud, I guess. Hi, Janet. Hi,, Cindy and Dennis. Cindy and Bill, so glad you could come. We're going to live in your room. Cindy. [3:09:32] Speaker S (unidentified): Well, hi, Dennis. I thought you weren't coming to the party. [3:09:36] Speaker R (unidentified): I wasn't, but you'll see her, then you'll understand. [3:09:39] Speaker S (unidentified): See her? See who? See me. [3:09:48] Speaker R (unidentified): What? She's going to help us enjoy the party. You are? Certainly. See, they're setting up for a game of musical chairs. [3:09:56] Speaker S (unidentified): Ah, but I don't like to... [3:09:59] Speaker R (unidentified): There. That's the way to have fun at a party. Join in the games. A party calls for teamwork. Why, nobody will have any fun unless everyone joins in. So join in wholeheartedly in any game suggested, and you'll all have a lot more fun. Everybody get up. Remember now, don't be too noisy or rough. And don't break things. Gee, thanks. Yeah, and you lost your chair too. You're out of the game. That's what you get for bumping into things. [3:10:47] Speaker S (unidentified): Oh, she's only kidding. [3:10:49] Speaker R (unidentified): I know, but don't tease and make fun of others, not even your very best friend. They might not understand. Why, if they thought you were serious, their feelings would be hurt, and then neither of you would have any fun, now would you? All right, Grand Godmother, -oh, the music's starting. [3:11:08] Speaker S (unidentified): What do I do? [3:11:10] Speaker R (unidentified): Why, just what you have been doing. Obey the rules of the game and be a good loser. here. I know. Stand up. Come on, Cindy. Come on. Come on, Cindy. It's a tie. Hey, that [3:11:33] Speaker S (unidentified): was fun. Actually, you won. Sure she did. But here, Cindy, you show him what I whispered [3:11:39] Speaker R (unidentified): in your ear. Just as I sat down in the chair, she said, be a good winner. And she was. See how much fun it is when you join in the games in the right ways? I just hope I can remember [3:11:52] Speaker S (unidentified): the right ways you've shown us that's easy just remember your manners be [3:11:57] Speaker R (unidentified): polite and above all be considerate of others so have fun together here I am wait a minute don't write anything I bet I know what you're gonna tell us remember our table manners when eating oh now you spoiled my phone I wanted to ride it for you. Now you won't think I've been any help to you. Oh, you've been a big help, Fairy Godmother. I've enjoyed the party. So go ahead and ride it for us if you want to. [3:13:00] Speaker S (unidentified): Sure, we want you to ride it for us. You do? May I? [3:13:06] Speaker R (unidentified): Remember your table manners. You didn't really need my help. You knew it already. I guess you don't need me anymore. I may as well be going. Oh, no. Oh, yes. Yes. You can't see or hear fairies unless you need them. And you don't need me anymore. But you will remember to leave on time, won't you? And you'll remember to thank the hostess. And whenever we go to any more parties, we'll remember to be clean and neat and to be on time. [3:13:38] Speaker S (unidentified): And we'll be considerate of others, too. We'll join in the games. [3:13:41] Speaker R (unidentified): And to obey the rules. [3:13:43] Speaker S (unidentified): And make fun for everybody, not fun of anybody. Or be too noisy or too rough. [3:13:48] Speaker R (unidentified): And we'll remember our table manners when eating. You'll always have fun then. Because parties are fun when everyone is considerate of others. Goodbye now. Go. Don't go. Don't go. Don't go. Don't go. Cindy. Don't go. Wake up, Cindy. Oh, Mother, I just dreamed that... Cindy, here's Mary's sister, Nancy. She just came by to tell you that she was supposed to deliver your invitation to Mary's party three days ago. But she forgot. Wasn't it nice of her to come by so early this morning to tell you about it? Oh, yes. Oh, thank you. Thank you so much. Ma sometimes feels she's in a zoo. [3:14:41] Speaker S (unidentified): The show will start in minutes, too. [3:15:01] Speaker T (unidentified): Assorted drinks, your favorite beverages. Oh, boy.