← Back to MaineScanner

Phippsburg Planning Board Approves Two Dock Applications and Discusses Zoning

2026-11-10 · 1h 22m · Source: Planning Board (Town of Phippsburg (Town Hall Streams))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Garage door people to reset the wheels on the awnings, yeah, especially on that one on the left so we can get it over the thing. Now that we've got a brand new setup, we want to keep it as dry. [0:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, as far as we can, that'd be really nice. Yeah, it'll be good to get those fully [0:16] Speaker A (unidentified): back on and get the canvas fixed on the other one. So I'm gonna have to look at how the budget is going to look after the pavement, and we just got the invoice for the for the refit, which was like 15 000, which was right around what they said it was going to be, which is good considering they had two grain trucks and two days put into it at least, and they stopped by this morning. So yeah, hoping to get things really up to snuff over there. [0:44] Speaker C (unidentified): And where we pay for weight of our trash and debris being hauled off, it's really nice to have it covered because any moisture will be repelled, rather than us paying for the water where you hauled the whey. [0:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Oh yeah, left to wait. [1:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, anything else? [1:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that's what I've got for department and committee reports. [1:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, moving on to correspondence, seeing none, courses, meetings and seminars, seeing none, back at you Evan for administrator and select board comments and announcements. [1:16] Speaker A (unidentified): The home energy assistance program applications are open at the Midcoast Maine Community Action, that's on Wing Farm in Bath, that's otherwise known as LIHEAP. You can do it over the phone, on the internet, or make an appointment to go in person. Really important that people get it, get out there as soon as possible, that they can get an appointment or do it online, that plan on applying. Absentee voting currently ongoing, you may request your ballot over the phone or in person. The deadline to get it online is passed, and you can get those until next Thursday, October 29th, at 5 p.m. Election Day is Tuesday, November the 3rd, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. At the Town Hall, 1042 Main Road. So sample ballots are available on the town website, maine.gov, and are posted at the Town Hall. We got the trick-or-trunk which will be at the Town Hall parking lot, October 31st, Halloween night, 530 to 7. You can sign up to participate in the trunk or treat if you give a call to Amy Burden at 751-6742 or Kathy Thomas 522-3105. Seems like there'll be quite a few people out that evening. Hopefully it's good weather. Let's see, we had a couple of theirs. Let me just pull that up. There will be a candidate forum at the Albert F. Taubman Public Library on October the 24th. All three candidates for the legislature are scheduled to attend and that is, I believe, at 11 a.m. I'll double check that but I believe that's at 11 a.m. And then Popham Beach erosion discussion headed by Peter Slovensky from the Main Geological Survey will also be at the Albert F. Toddman Public Library on November the 4th at 7 p.m. So plenty of good events going on at the library. I believe that's what I have on my announcements, Gary. [3:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Got anything? No, just a reminder that we'll have Youth Day, two days, coming up on Friday and Saturday. It'll be Friday and Saturday this week. Yeah, this week. And then next week is going to be opening day for our residents, so make sure that we're wearing an orange. Please be careful. We're not walking our animals or taking a stroll through the woods. [3:53] Speaker E (unidentified): Please be careful also. And we do have some albino deer running around the town of Pittsburgh. [4:01] Speaker F (unidentified): My son's got them both on his game camera. Another [4:09] Speaker B (unidentified): thing is make sure we're having our chimneys cleaned before we start that fire for the season. It's getting cooler out. Everybody's going to want to stay warm. Just don't want to have that fire. [4:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Good evening it is 532. Welcome to the monthly meeting of the planning board. We have one member who has not showed up yet he can he can protect when he comes. The first thing we will do is consider the minutes of August 25th public hearing and October 13th regular meeting you [5:20] Speaker H (unidentified): said you wanted to post on [5:21] Speaker I (unidentified): our postpone the August. I am sorry, I would like to make a motion to table the [5:26] Speaker G (unidentified): minutes from the August meeting because I did not have time to read them today. I'll be having those too. Yeah. We should just have an August meeting. Yeah. Well, that's why. [5:41] Speaker J (unidentified): Okay. And there are a lot to read. That was a lot of work, I'm sure, at all. Yeah. [5:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Are we agreed to hold the August meeting minutes until next time? Yeah. Agreed. Sir? Yes. Okay. What about October? [5:58] Speaker H (unidentified): Huh? Do you need a second and a vote? Or are you... I don't know. [6:01] Speaker I (unidentified): I made a motion. Okay. That's true. It can all be in one. [6:09] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay. New to me. Okie dokie. [6:13] Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, we can go back. [6:15] Speaker J (unidentified): Either way, whatever you say. It's fine with me. You're the boss. [6:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Take back your motion and we can... I will take back my motion. We agreed on the regular meeting of October 13th. [6:37] Speaker J (unidentified): As far as you know. Well, I wasn't here, so... [6:40] Speaker E (unidentified): I was there briefly, yes. [6:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. All right. Somebody make a motion to hold back on August and approve October. [6:48] Speaker E (unidentified): I'll make a motion to hold back on August and approve October. [6:54] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll second that. Okay. All in favor? Okay. And the first applicant tonight is Herbert Gaten, 36 Caring Place Road, Tax Map 27, Lot 86-AB. This is an addition of a 45-foot ramp and 10-by-20-foot float to the existing pier that he has in the village district of the Shoreland Zone in West Point. And we all have our paperwork, but Herbie, if you could explain a little bit more how come or... [7:39] Speaker L (unidentified): Well, the way it is now, we don't have enough water at low tide to get the boats in there. So if we can extend out with a flow, which makes probably more sense than trying to get the dock extended, would help us a lot because we could get in at any time and we [8:01] Speaker G (unidentified): use it a lot. How close to, is there a channel there? How close are you to it? [8:08] Speaker L (unidentified): There's no channel. No channel through there? Our existing haul-off is there now, and there's another haul-off north of ours. So, you have haul-offs there anyway? [8:26] Speaker G (unidentified): This would be considered under the town's shoreland zoning ordinance. Several sections, primarily table of land uses that deals with piers, docks, and so forth. Usually on a dock application there's not much that goes with it. In a position like this is a commercial fishing dock and it is already in existence and the planning board would be involved on any changes and what he wants to do is not any construction to the dock itself. There are any questions from Mr. Leighton from anybody so there [9:23] Speaker J (unidentified): are no other approvals required. What, there's no DP or any of that stuff is required for something like this? He should be all right just distraught [9:34] Speaker G (unidentified): no objection it isn't approval no objection very much longer [9:51] Speaker L (unidentified):... approximately will figure because of the angle... [10:00] Speaker E (unidentified): basket 30 feet. Sounds good. Have you talked to Seahorse? [10:07] Speaker L (unidentified): I have, yes. Talk to Scott. He's good. You don't care. It's tight in there. It's a little tight in there. Yeah, it is. But it will help him too. I'm sure it will get used a lot if it happens. Yeah, I'm sure it will. Any [10:28] Speaker E (unidentified): questions? I worry about radians and all that kind of stuff. What? The radians. I mean it's like does the effect other people's probably oh as it for Chuck [10:43] Speaker M (unidentified): projects out into the water are we straight up yes well be a little bit of [10:50] Speaker L (unidentified): an angle so to be sure that we're not in the pyramids he was not rather going straight we're gonna try to handle so don't hopefully be right in the middle of where the dock is now. [11:04] Speaker E (unidentified): Pull me off. That's 30 feet. Yeah, I get what you're saying. [11:08] Speaker G (unidentified): Does that angle go toward the wharf? Does your angle go toward the wharf? Of Phillips Wharf? [11:17] Speaker L (unidentified): No, it goes the other way. That will clear his haul off if they keep using that haul off. [11:25] Speaker G (unidentified): Any other questions? Do we have a motion? Motion to approve the application as submitted I'll [11:44] Speaker E (unidentified): second the motion but should we go through [11:46] Speaker M (unidentified): findings to the findings of that oh yes the chair usually forgets to do the [11:54] Speaker G (unidentified): findings so this is the man who reminds me all right so let's go down through the findings this is approved will maintain safe and helpful conditions [Speaker M (unidentified): will not] result in water pollution erosion or sedimentation of surface waters would adequately provide for the disposal of all wastewater will not have an adverse impact on spawning grounds fish aquatic life bird or other wildlife habitat. Well, it doesn't really say anything about that unless it's wildlife habitat. Besides, he'd never tell you how much he caught. We'll conserve shore cover and visual as well as actual points of access to inland and coastal waters. Will protect archaeological and historic resources as designated in the Town's Comprehensive Plan. [13:23] Speaker E (unidentified): How old is that pier that's there? [13:30] Speaker L (unidentified): The one there now, maybe twenty. [13:33] Speaker E (unidentified): But how long has there been one there? [13:39] Speaker L (unidentified): At least a hundred years, probably more. [13:41] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, you know [13:55] Speaker G (unidentified): not adversely affect existing commercial fishing or maritime activities Will avoid problems associated with floodplain development and use And is in conformance with section 17 of the land use standards To the vote we did vote but we voted prematurely am I correct? [14:39] Speaker H (unidentified): We have a motion and a second. [14:41] Speaker J (unidentified): We just had a motion. We haven't voted though. [14:44] Speaker G (unidentified): All in favor of the motion. It is passed. [14:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Do you have a check for me? Excuse me? Do you have a check for me? Yes I do. It's 100. Town of Pittsburgh and then planning in the memo. [15:25] Speaker G (unidentified): John didn't sign it. John. [15:31] Speaker E (unidentified): I haven't signed it yet. [15:38] Speaker N (unidentified): Sorry, John, I took your spot. Oh, no. As [15:43] Speaker E (unidentified): long as you leave Mark's spot, that's all right. [15:46] Speaker G (unidentified): You can have his spot. You want how many on that application? Four? I don't see that. Two, three, four? Four? Yes, ma'am. You got it. [16:38] Speaker H (unidentified): Correct. No. Right. And where did you go? He's writing his check. Oh, okay. [17:28] Speaker K (unidentified): When you're finished, let us know in 20 days that your work is complete. [17:39] Speaker G (unidentified): It doesn't matter when you do it. [17:43] Speaker L (unidentified): It's probably the torch spring, I think. Winter or spring. [17:49] Speaker G (unidentified): It's just one of those things. Okay. [17:52] Speaker L (unidentified): Thank you all. Good luck. Now [18:12] Speaker G (unidentified): We have Stephen and Wendy Hope, 395 Sebastopol Road. You're here tax path 30 lot one represented by David Matero of David Matero Architecture bath this is an addition to an existing house in the resource protection district of the shoreland zone and I gathered by the application that you are gathering information not looking for a permit [18:46] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah well so we didn't want to spend money on design I should say Mr Holt didn't want to spend money in design until we knew we could do a project so it's not a very large addition we're looking at a porch and mudroom and dormers on the second floor but it we're placing it beyond the 250 foot setback away from the lake on the bed on the sort of front side of the house at the front door and before we did any design work we want to make sure that this is going to be acceptable to you know if this is if this location is going to be okay then after this we could just deal with a code office but there were a lot of restrictions here shoreland zone we just want to make sure that we're doing the right thing without coming here with a full design and find out, I don't know, there's a red flag somewhere. So we're noting the house, the addition will not be higher than the existing house, it won't be close. And everything is going to be beyond the 250. So I'm not presenting a design, just a red blob of like, if it could go here, will it be okay? [20:00] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, so the 250 setback, this is from the lake itself. Correct. Okay. Yeah. And as far as, if it hadn't been for that, there wouldn't have been a question at all [20:16] Speaker J (unidentified): about footage. I just don't believe. Yeah, but this past 250 is just residential, right? [20:21] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, what I'm finding, if you read the deed, it's actually a 250 deed restriction. It sort of doesn't have anything to do with our zoning. On it right so as long as he's behind the 250 according to what as far as I know though it's it is actually kind of quirky on the map because there's a green section there it's it's treated the pond itself is treated as 125 which I know I built there at 125. But it is kind of odd if you follow the shoreline there's a little green blob that's in front of their property but I but I don't know if that means anything and it still says if you will read the book it's a 125 resource protection 120 then the next 125 is residential so technically according to us he could build over 125 feet right when we talk [21:14] Speaker D (unidentified): To severe, he was saying something like there's some sort of a beaver dam there at one point that raised the lake, and I don't know if that's true or not there. [21:23] Speaker E (unidentified): There was a beaver dam there for years, down that end. It wasn't active for all that time, but it's on the wrong end of the lake to raise the lake. The dam is at the other end. [21:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, that's what Sarah was saying. I didn't quite understand it. [21:38] Speaker E (unidentified): No, so that wouldn't have impacted that at all. But, yeah, so I mean... [21:46] Speaker J (unidentified): So it's conforming, right? Right. Right. [21:50] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah. Right. It's conforming. Not a non-conforming law. [21:54] Speaker J (unidentified): So it's only the deed restriction that you've got to worry about because we're Yeah. [21:59] Speaker D (unidentified): But there are other, I mean, there's been, yeah, there's just a lot of restrictions here, and we have a new code officer in town. I wanted to make sure that, you know, this is all in the up and up and that's why we came here. [22:15] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. I texted Steve briefly saying that I thought it wasn't an issue because I figured it was But it's the deed that is what's the, but as far as, you know, the shoreline zoning is 250 anyway. As long as you're outside of that, you're outside of shoreline zone. Right. [22:36] Speaker O (unidentified): Right. And the deed shouldn't be a problem. Hmm? No. No, it shouldn't be. [22:41] Speaker E (unidentified): Heights are no issue. No. Yeah. Even at 125 it wouldn't have been an issue. [22:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. Not from a town standpoint. Yeah. [22:47] Speaker H (unidentified): I mean, for reference, so David and Sophie Swain, they were the ones that had been emailing over the last month or so, and the board made a recommendation that they come in and present to you. Okay. Yeah. [23:03] Speaker G (unidentified): My only thought on that is if it hadn't been for the old 250-foot rule, we'll call it. I know some of the quirks of, like you've been saying, along the way in ownership, find a mistake, correct it if best you can, but I don't think any of those things that happened in the past, I think we've got plenty of written material about that. [23:38] Speaker J (unidentified): I'm confused by this. This says that the existing gravel road, the septic system, and the existing house are located within 250 feet of Wahtaa Lake and may remain in place and be used and maintained, but it seems, this deed seems to indicate that the house is indeed within this deed-restricted 250. Is that the case? [24:02] Speaker D (unidentified): And that's why that there's a that's why that's indeed a release of that restriction is deeded so I think my guess is the house yeah prior to trying to be underlying it whoever is the original. [24:16] Speaker O (unidentified): Loan Janice Wright built that. She apparently built the corner of the within the 250 at the point. Then she went and got a delift on that post build, yeah, which is entered in the county's. [24:31] Speaker J (unidentified): You know, yes, so that's that's really we don't have any, we can't do it. No, I know, but it's just [24:38] Speaker D (unidentified): one of those other layers that you just want to make sure we're all comfortable with it, yeah. [24:42] Speaker E (unidentified): Because I was like, I did it over here a little bit. I when I built Bill Carney's house they made me be 250 from the house from the water at that point too, but it was because the pond was [24:53] Speaker O (unidentified): Sebastian's drinking water. Right. When was that? 20 how long ago was that? [24:59] Speaker E (unidentified): God, I don't remember. 25, 30 years ago. It was a while ago. And that could have been part of it, but that was removed. [25:14] Speaker O (unidentified): That's when it was built. 05 is our house. [25:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Is it? I don't see anything. If your deeds are clear, it shouldn't mean anything to us. Right. Okay. [25:37] Speaker B (unidentified): Will we come in at the next meeting with an application? [25:39] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, do we need, I mean, do they need to, yeah, is this not just a building permit? [25:46] Speaker J (unidentified): I think make sure you're here protected from this deed restriction, yeah. [25:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, right, but I'd love, I think I'd appreciate a motion by the planning board that as far as they're concerned this is acceptable. Now we deal with the [26:01] Speaker M (unidentified): code office to the board of the project. I'll make a motion that 's [26:08] Speaker E (unidentified): acceptable. Not [26:11] Speaker I (unidentified): yet. What is the motion or just he wants us to go on record that we [26:32] Speaker J (unidentified): we don't have any issues with the development of this pursuant to setbacks and other restrictions within the ordinance and just try to give himself some comfort because if we have a new CEO and seems belt suspenders to me, but [26:47] Speaker M (unidentified): I don't think it hurts us in that. Okay, I don't plan on to just clarify, yeah, we [26:59] Speaker G (unidentified): have a motion in a second, yeah, all in table now. I'm going to give me a minute because usually I will write up things in advance when I know the section [27:14] Speaker J (unidentified): anything. Well, if you want a piece of paper, I think your bonus is just what [27:20] Speaker G (unidentified): is being rendered. I think you don't need a piece of paper by saying that. Okay. [27:30] Speaker D (unidentified): Run my TV, you're on TV. [27:33] Speaker O (unidentified): You do need to check though. [27:37] Speaker I (unidentified): And you mean no, you have your blessing. [27:41] Speaker D (unidentified): Alright, well thank you for your time. [27:44] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, I like those. [27:47] Speaker O (unidentified): Better be safe than sorry, right? [Speaker E (unidentified): Oh, 100%.] Thanks for the time. [27:52] Speaker E (unidentified): I didn't notice. [28:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Next is Eric Kramer, Lot 12, Kennebec Shores Road, Tax Map 9, Lot 3-1, one, represented by Diane Ford, agent. This is construction of a residential dock system consisting of a four by 12 pier, three by 40 ramp, and a 12 by 16 float in the resource protection district of the Shoreland Grove. And so we will turn it over, I'm assuming. Yeah, okay. [28:49] Speaker N (unidentified): I'm Diane Ford. I've given you all of the paperwork, I'm sorry, but I didn't keep a whole copy for myself. But this is a new development with Kennebec Shore South. It's a brand new development, and I went out there in November of last year, I think, and I started this process with DEP and Army Corps and all that last December. And it's progressed to this, so it's a brand new subdivision, so there's really no addresses out there other than number 12 and north and south. So this will be a, I think, I believe the second approved application for that area. This one is, I don't even know where it is on the map. I don't know Hipsburg that well. But this project is on the southern part of this development, one of the very southern locations. So it's not really interfering with a lot of the inlet part of the Newark in this development is more on the southern part, and like I said, brand new, and they want, they'll be there year-round. They were from out of state, they came here year-round residency, and so they would like to have something to, they have a brand new nice area where they want to float in the dark. I'm sorry for the photographs that I had to make. My color printer died on me, so I had to go to get photographs at Walgreens. I'm sorry for that, but I think they came out okay. [30:49] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm going to compliment you on the photographs. [30:51] Speaker N (unidentified): Oh, thank you. I'm glad they worked out. You know why? Why? [30:56] Speaker G (unidentified): Because you have got here six photographs on one piece of paper. [31:01] Speaker N (unidentified): Yes. So that saves a lot of file space. It does. It does, because it was very difficult to try to get them printed at Walgreens, but I had to do the best I could. [31:17] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm going to ask you to come here and sign this as well. Oh, and then sign something? Yeah. Oh, I'm so sorry. That's okay. Okay, I thought I had. Tomorrow's the, okay, not for the benefit of anybody watching. [31:49] Speaker N (unidentified): This is, this contractor Tanner Wheeler is a young man out of Woolwich. He and his father and his brothers all work in this business, and he's all over the place. See, I have an application with him in Scarborough. I did one in Cushing, I'm doing one in Woolwich, and this one. So he's, he's does beautiful work, and I think it won't be a eyesore, you know, won't be one of those big clunky things, will be well done, you know. And like I said, it's one of the first ones on the property and the whole subdivision, so I think it's a subdivision, I'm not really sure it is, right, so I like working with Tanner, and he does very [32:44] Speaker G (unidentified): very nice work. This is considered under the shoreline zoning ordinance, several sections all dealing with the water of course, and it's a functionally water dependent use, so to speak, because it is a dock, and I won't bother to read all the different sections, no point. We need a photographic record again, so if this is approved and it's all done, anybody on any application has 20 days to get a picture to the planning board after it's finished. [33:30] Speaker N (unidentified): Right. I do that for my PPP also. Okay. All right. [33:36] Speaker G (unidentified): And this is a recreational seasonal dock? Correct. Okay. And the ramp and float will be stored off-site? Off-site. On-site, but not on the dock? From the docks on the off-season. Let's see. I don't think there are any other questions about that. We have the Harbormaster's letter of non-objection. Is this, though? This is not his usual form. All he did was sign it. [34:18] Speaker N (unidentified): Well, he's at that Scarborough training class today, and I didn't get it from him to him from him until today, and I think he's like [34:31] Speaker I (unidentified): took a photograph of what I sent to him. I'll get the hard copy from Peter or [34:37] Speaker H (unidentified): you're asking it to be more descriptive in the future. Well, all he did was sign [34:40] Speaker G (unidentified): it, and what did he go, he didn't say, he didn't say he didn't object, he didn't [34:46] Speaker N (unidentified): say it's in a printed pot. I have an email from them today with his approval. [34:56] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, it doesn't to me, it doesn't state that on this piece of paper. Okay, I did also, well, it does say, we can Eric Kramer and then the name and address has requested permission to build erect construct the following, he describes it on his or her property located at, he did not write that in, using apparently the address of the home, but this is not his usual form by a long shot. We are, will accept it because of the circumstance, but this is not his regular, what's the [Speaker N (unidentified): regular? No, I] would appreciate a statement from him saying yes, he's [35:43] Speaker K (unidentified): non-objection, writes it on there. Yeah, I mean, that's the form that I thought from [35:50] Speaker G (unidentified): This office, no, he hasn't said yay or nay, or he doesn't care. I mean, it's just he signed it. Well, he doesn't say yay or nay anyway. He says he has, it's no objection. Okay, he doesn't tell you how to build or when to build or anything. It's just in his realm, being harbormaster, he has no objection to this, where this dock is going to go. And [36:30] Speaker J (unidentified): The DEP approval appears complete, although the flood hazard doesn't seem to be. The permit doesn't seem to be executed, but I guess that's our approval, which just says you have to get all the approvals sent away. Right. The DDP seems cool. [36:55] Speaker G (unidentified): And only a year, I think, I've read all the time. The [37:01] Speaker N (unidentified): DDP takes an honor course now, but DDP is so short-staffed. Unbelievable. Yes. [37:09] Speaker G (unidentified): Unbelievable. That's why I say a year, because if you started working on it a year ago, it would make up like a record right now. I think that helps. We try to tell people to don't come here for us, get your other permits have taken a little longer. [37:44] Speaker N (unidentified): I won't come before the planning board without my fee being on the. [37:48] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, it takes so long to get those. [37:50] Speaker N (unidentified): It does me no good. Right,. [37:52] Speaker G (unidentified): And I think their approvals are for a longer duration of time. [37:56] Speaker N (unidentified): But you know, I thought you had a few- [37:57] Speaker J (unidentified): It makes us ask a zillion questions. [37:58] Speaker N (unidentified): Right, but you have to understand too, is that the Army Corps has not sent out very many approvals. They send out emails saying they have no objection any more because they're working on bigger things like dams and infrastructure and all that. So they don't care about some warps sometimes. So when I get an approval, I get excited about it because it's rare. But the DEP always sends out those approvals. But I wanted to attach them both. Yeah, it's good, it helps a lot, and I didn't have any response from the DMR or I didn't get any response from them, and I did from the Indian tribe, they approved that, but that's, I didn't get any, so unless there's an issue they won't send me anything. I've learned that one too, so. So, less is more. [39:06] Speaker J (unidentified): Learned that stuff recently. [39:07] Speaker G (unidentified): Right, yeah, less is more if they even look at it. [39:12] Speaker N (unidentified): I don't know, I've made it, I don't know, I don't work with it, I won't, I don't know. [39:20] Speaker J (unidentified): Actually, I mean, the application is more together than we've seen in a long time. [39:26] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, for us. [39:28] Speaker N (unidentified): I used to be the code and I used to work for the coats and tanning and board of appeals in Knoxville. [39:33] Speaker J (unidentified): Okay. I know what you want. [39:37] Speaker N (unidentified): I did what her job is. Only three offices, so. And then I tried to retire. [39:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Good luck. Here I am. Any other comments or questions? No. [39:56] Speaker E (unidentified): I'd kind of like to see where it is this way, but yeah, like where is it in relationship to the other properties, like is it five feet from the neighboring property, where is where does it actually take off from land, is it centered on their property? [40:26] Speaker N (unidentified): Oh, yeah, it's centered on the property, yeah. [40:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Like Herbie's, you can't be on the property line and then go at an angle in front of the [40:41] Speaker N (unidentified): other people's house. No, this is way too much land. [40:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Without seeing that, you don't know that. [40:46] Speaker N (unidentified): It's way too much land on these properties that have a lot of property. [40:50] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, there's one in West Point where he owns five acres of land and he's in front of the other property. [40:55] Speaker N (unidentified): This is Kennebec Shores. Right. Wherever that is. And this is his property, right, all right, three one, so it's there's a hundred and seventy six feet here, all right, so this is going to be plenty, isn't this, I mean their house is right [41:22] Speaker E (unidentified): in the middle, I know, but where is the dock attaching to linen, well I don't have that because [41:28] Speaker N (unidentified): it's all in photographs, I can I can send that to you if you want to see the [41:44] Speaker M (unidentified): distance between butters, oh we just have to make sure you're not going across in [41:50] Speaker E (unidentified): front of another brother, we don't have a drug, we don't have anything proving where it's going. [41:56] Speaker N (unidentified): We would not do that, but if you want, I would. Who would? Yeah. [42:04] Speaker E (unidentified): Usually there's a survey map with it drawn in, where it goes from an overhead view of it. Right. [42:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Do you know offhand how many feet from side to side? Not offhand. Roughly? [42:19] Speaker N (unidentified): Not offhand. But I will get that to you. I'll get you an onyx map with footage between the two up-butters. I did that. I don't think that's what I was about to do. I [43:03] Speaker J (unidentified): think John's right. If we could do our diligence correctly, we would really kind of see where it is on that. Yeah, you would think that there would be, the DEP obviously has a survey or a map or something in. Yeah, I think so. It's got to be something. I mean, their application is very extensive and must have what you're looking for in there somewhere. [43:35] Speaker G (unidentified): That's, I can't see that so I don't know what that says, but it does point right to the middle of the property. [43:45] Speaker N (unidentified): I'll send you something. I'll send, well, I don't know, the code office. [43:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you send it to me? I don't know. Let me go check real quick. [44:11] Speaker G (unidentified): Compensation of the subdivision map. I can't be most of it. Are we in agreement of the statements that have been made on erosion control and... [44:44] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, that's all covered in the... [44:46] Speaker E (unidentified): You sent an email to us. Is that about this one? So [44:58] Speaker J (unidentified): The, you know, they're in set of page, whatever that is, hard to tell, oh, 2 of 11. There's erosion, soil erosion, and it documents the, they claim there won't be any. [45:36] Speaker N (unidentified): Right. Yeah. I think I attached an erosion control page anyway. Yeah. Other than the DDP. Yeah. But they write it up their way. And [45:57] Speaker G (unidentified): they talk about the trees. They have mentioned that, which is good. The winding path. [46:39] Speaker J (unidentified): Unless we can get a survey with John that we need to table it until we see one. [46:50] Speaker E (unidentified): It doesn't have to be a survey. [46:52] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, whatever. You don't have to spend 20 grand for a survey, but some way that we can feel confident that it's not. It's not encroaching on neighbor's land. [47:02] Speaker N (unidentified): Well, that's why I submit the onyx. I can have the property outlined with the onyx, and then I can measure to and from the south and the north, whatever. If that will do, I don't think that's a problem. [47:19] Speaker E (unidentified): I think that's all I care about. I just legally, I mean, I trust you. But just to say, oh, I want to build a dock, you could build it right on the property line, [47:28] Speaker M (unidentified): which that is not something. Does it have to be tabled or can it be pending the [47:40] Speaker N (unidentified): submission of that? Because I noticed you didn't have a December meeting plan, right? So I'd rather not wait till January. I'm just gonna spit ball this. If [47:56] Speaker G (unidentified): she were to approximate something she's already given us where it's going to be and then verify that with her, I will be happy to verify it like that. I'm not [48:09] Speaker M (unidentified): perfectly fine with all this. I just wanted, right, we know, me too. I just want to prove that this is not going to be. So if, yeah, I can, you begin, she can, we get [48:19] Speaker J (unidentified): sister representation, just sketch it on a map. Here's the two borders, it's gonna [48:23] Speaker G (unidentified): be in the middle, and then we've got a, we've got a, oh, we got a picture of the property. Yeah, just like draw an arrow or something. Yeah, and then and then support it with another piece of paper. [48:45] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, that'd be fine, like as long as you know it's not encroaching, it's really right over the eagle. [48:57] Speaker J (unidentified): It's right over the eagle. It's right over the eagle. I think it might be prudent to just have you take a pen and go... I can do that, yeah. And then we can verify. And then we have something to verify. Yeah, anything. [49:14] Speaker G (unidentified): I would be very happy with that. [49:40] Speaker N (unidentified): I know it's right over the eagle. Sorry, it doesn't, there's that, and there's my signature in the framework, not the scale. I kind of call it over eagle. Sorry. Okay, perfect. Yeah, that works for me, and I will, I will submit [50:12] Speaker G (unidentified): something. Yeah, perfect. Yeah, perfect. Thank you. Thank you. And then official for the record, be [50:18] Speaker J (unidentified): Great, okay, then you can just email it to me, Diane. Yeah, and just we just need to as a condition and verify that the measurements will show that it's in the middle of the water. [50:30] Speaker N (unidentified): What are the setbacks to the abutters? Just 25 feet? [50:41] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm actually not even sure. Essentially, there's lines sticking out into the water that you're not supposed to cross. So technically, they could be pretty close to the property line. If you're 30 feet from the property line, you're fine. It's basically you just can't be on it. This is pretty cut and dry because the lines are all straight, it's when you have properties that look like this coming into the shoreline. [51:02] Speaker N (unidentified): That's to my advantage is that they're all... [51:04] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, this is all straight, you're not going to have an issue. [51:09] Speaker J (unidentified): But irrespective of whether it's a setback, it's just prudent to have a document that shows where it's going to come from. [51:15] Speaker E (unidentified): So if you can approximate on that onyx, where it goes, but there is no issue about the [51:28] Speaker N (unidentified): I don't think there's even anybody on the southern side. It's a huge piece of land, and I don't think there's even at all, so I don't know, you know. [51:47] Speaker G (unidentified): Someday there will be. [51:49] Speaker E (unidentified): I don't know. Is that the part, Mark would know, is that the end that the guy bought all of it? Oh, maybe. So that no one could develop? [51:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, it could be. [52:00] Speaker N (unidentified): Oh, I don't know. All I know is I sent out a butter notice. [52:10] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, so we go over some findings? Absolutely. Sure. Okay, if it is approved, will it maintain safe and helpful conditions? I agree. Will not result in water pollution, erosion, or sedimentation. Will adequately provide for the disposal of all wastewater. Will not have an adverse impact on spawning grounds, fish, aquatic life, bird, or other wildlife habitat. Will conserve shore cover and visual as well as actual points of access to inland and coastal waters. Will protect archaeological and historic resources as designated in the Town's Comprehensive Plan. [Speaker M (unidentified): Will not] adversely affect existing commercial fishing or maritime activities. These agree we'll avoid problems associated with floodplain development and use is in conformance with provisions of section 15 land use standards. [54:22] Speaker J (unidentified): Right, I'm old then I think of my dad. Can we have a vote? Can we have a motion? Well, we're copying at the moment, probably. I'll bet make a motion that we accept the proposal as presented. [54:39] Speaker M (unidentified): Just have the condition she's in her, yeah, I think with the condition that, oh, with the condition that [54:45] Speaker J (unidentified): that the location of the dock is verified in a subsequent submission. Yeah. [54:53] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll second that. Oh, okay. There's [56:08] Speaker N (unidentified): so many new things that everybody wants. The DEP, the Army Corps, blah,, it's been in the towns. There's so many new, I remember doing these just three, four years ago, and it was like, it's amazing what has changed. The DEP has changed in the last few years. Yeah. It really has. Yeah. [56:31] Speaker J (unidentified): The DEP has changed. [56:33] Speaker N (unidentified): It's extensive. It's an arduous... I don't know what... Sometimes I wonder what... Why I'm continuing... [56:43] Speaker J (unidentified): It's interesting. It's a historical perspective. Yeah. [56:46] Speaker N (unidentified): It's very hard. When I was in the code office and accepting these in the code office, it was a third of the code. And you could get it approved without the PPP approval. And it was, you know, a building. I don't know about Pittsburgh, but I did a lot in Park State. I didn't change too much about requirements [57:16] Speaker G (unidentified): since I've been on the board. I've been here five years. What's that? [57:31] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. Wow. Oh, we're doing good. Yeah. [57:41] Speaker N (unidentified): Well, this last one, I don't have for approval, so it will be postponed. Oh, thank you. No. I would like to table this because the harbormaster indicated he did not get a site visit. He would like a site visit because this particular one is a rebuild, complete rebuild, because it just needs it. That's true, and because they want to move it like three feet, four feet away from their butter for more stability, and she, you know, hasn't seen it, so I don't, I think I will have to table it at least. I don't know, you don't do December meetings though, right, because of December? [58:50] Speaker G (unidentified): I get it. [58:52] Speaker J (unidentified): And this one's just... [58:54] Speaker N (unidentified): It's exactly the same submission from me, but it's a complete rebuild. [59:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Again, it's there now. Is it exactly like the original? [59:10] Speaker N (unidentified): It will be. The only difference is the crib. The crib has to be completely replaced, and the rocks that are in the crib were there originally and have to be removed. The DEP and Army Corps do not want the rocks dispersed in the water. So they have to be removed, so that's like, I don't know. And we got the approval, I think it's in there, it's in the DEA approval that the rocks are going to be removed and put someplace on land instead of in the water. [1:00:01] Speaker M (unidentified): What's the new dock? Is there not a crib? [1:00:03] Speaker N (unidentified): It's not a crib. Cribs are frowned upon in Maine lately. So we try to do the pylons more so than any cribs because of the amount of space it takes up and fish, you know, fishing and whatever. So we try to stay away from those. But the old ones that are being replaced, most of them are cribs and the rocks that are in there are the problem a lot of times. They're the problem. And they don't want them just put back in the water because of the green crabs. And again, that's what this issue is forming. But the harbormaster wants to see it mainly because it's being moved away from the abutter, but it's the exact same size. And it's better for the abutter because as far as I think, I think it was too close. I don't know, it's been there a long time and way before my time, so, and I don't even know if there was a permit for it. I mean, that's how old it is, so, you know, I don't know. But so there's some issues and I just, I guess you just have to wait for the harbor master to approve, go down and visit, and maybe with the code officer because I usually go to all of the site visits if I can. Well, I've just gotten over two years of dealing with cancer so I've missed a few site visits but I'm back, you know, doing it, so I am, I would be there too. The [1:01:56] Speaker G (unidentified): benefit of anybody watching, you listening, this would have been item six on the agenda. Irena Rosenblum, 26 Samuel's Landing Road, tax map 36, lot 14, and this would have been, as explained here, a construction of another dart would be a replacement. So we will automatically put it on the next meeting which at this point [1:02:30] Speaker N (unidentified): is January and just prior to the meeting there was an email from the butter [1:02:56] Speaker H (unidentified): that's something we're not in support of the application so check your email if [1:03:00] Speaker I (unidentified): you want to look at. Oh, I didn't get that. Would you like me to? Yes, I would. [1:03:06] Speaker N (unidentified): I didn't, I didn't know that. So but no, that's it. Okay, if you want to table it, that'd be great. [1:03:17] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, motion to table. Somebody, I'll make a motion to the table. [1:03:26] Speaker N (unidentified): Thank you very much for your time. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, and [1:03:41] Speaker G (unidentified): all the business [1:03:45] Speaker J (unidentified): I'd like to report to the board that I talked to the consultant zoning consultant but Rachel was quick to describe the company that you max for the makeup yeah I spoke to him on the phone and we went through the discussion of resource protection because the question was how we read Georgetown's ordinance that doesn't include restriction on cutting and his answer was well they then they haven't been updated by the DEP because the DEP would never approve that 's what he said and he said that the historically what's happened is a lot of the trimming that's been done has been done under the guise of timber harvesting and that's how that's in fact jared was talking about that before the 40 that's timber harvesting which is people have used and then gone back to residential he said they don't they frown on that now too and he said that the first 70 in an rp zone the first 75 feet you can't do anything to and the next whatever it is you can use their very limited trees down and that sort of thing so that the his guidance was to really know to get the to get the RP zone to that I talked about the definition of RP and that a lot of the land that's on RP isn't doesn't meet the definition he said we need to fix that but he said that you could put it in another zone if you wanted to be protected but that's a whole nother thing and then I discussed the residential one residential two residential three and he thought that was a very good idea as a way to sort of codify the setbacks so it's he seemed to think we were on the right track and I kept asking questions about how you know there seems to be all kinds of different rules and it was applied and it wasn't applied and he said yeah that's been an issue but they seem to coalesce behind this now but I don't know if he's a but he seemed to have worked for a lot of different of the municipalities around here so that's so I think it might be worth talking specifically about what we read in Georgetown and asked him directly but the response I got from the consultant didn't give me one [1:06:43] Speaker E (unidentified): so not opposed to talking to Jeff again anyway but you know to clarify to straighten out what we got but I think we're back on the track of having to I don't know if we hired in Judy yeah we were waiting for the talking first so yeah we I don't [1:07:03] Speaker G (unidentified): know where we are with that I know she's waiting to hear back from us sure I do know we probably need to run that by the select board financially they are waiting to hear from us right so but i [1:07:25] Speaker J (unidentified): Don't know, did we get a response from the clerk, wherever your caller for to make sure that, you know, we were all surprised that our balance was three thousand. Have we had any response on that? Yes, and I was wasn't going to want to do it. Okay, I have printed off copies for everybody. Okay, cool, so which is something that was on my mind. Yeah. [1:07:50] Speaker G (unidentified): Oh, okay, no, it's handled, and we have detailed copies of all extended shows for the last two [1:07:59] Speaker J (unidentified): years. Okay, thank you. [1:08:09] Speaker G (unidentified): Announcements. We at this point do not have a regular meeting planned for December. Never know when something real radical pops up, but at this point there will be no regular meeting in December. And the board will hold officer elections in January. [1:08:38] Speaker J (unidentified): No, and so we're sort of on hold until we get Judy going, and then we can get another, we'll refine more with the 500 feet and all the things that we're asking, and then maybe we have a document that we're a little more comfortable with, right, and the select board doesn't meet [1:08:55] Speaker G (unidentified): tomorrow, so next week should we go and talk to them about it if we are going to let Judy loose, which I think we thought we should, unless the select board says no. I agree, we'll just ask to be put on the next agenda. Sure, great. [1:09:20] Speaker L (unidentified): Make [1:09:24] Speaker J (unidentified): sure you email me so I ping and remember to come, because so maybe I can help explain what, you know, I've been at the job too. I don't like stepping up now. Lori's been doing it all night. Well, yeah. But I've been trying to, I know more about our piece on that than I ever wanted to, but it's, the truth is it's been very, they've applied it this way, then they applied it that way, and it's, there's been no consistency. No. Oh, and I also found that 1,000 thing, whatever it is, a guideline, because when you look at the ordinance it's very clear in the ordinance that's [1:10:10] Speaker G (unidentified): what they, that's what I told, like Jeff keeps referring to the chapter 1000. [1:10:14] Speaker J (unidentified): Right, but when I asked the guy about, I said, well, it doesn't mention in 1000. He said, well, that's just a, that's a guideline, you have to look back at the ordinance. And I did, and the ordinances as like pretty straightforward, sort of just like ours, yes, so I didn't check it word for word, but there's 75 feet and all the other [1:10:37] Speaker G (unidentified): crap is in there. Okay, so I don't know, Lori. Yeah, because he just, Jeff, she says look at chapter 1000. [1:10:43] Speaker J (unidentified): So that I look at chapter 1000. And you're right, it's the guy said it's not in there, right? And I said well, and he said well I have to look at the ordinance. So I looked at the ordinance and it was did there all right. So what ordinance though, the actual our resource protection ordinance on the state level there is one yeah, or what if they call it the law or whatever that one is. [1:11:05] Speaker G (unidentified): Well it should be very similar because most of our wording is directly from the EB right. [1:11:13] Speaker J (unidentified): I went through that one thousand thing too, there's no mention of cutting, no not a thing yeah. So, confusion reigns as usual when you're dealing with the bureaucracy. [1:11:30] Speaker G (unidentified): That's right. Okay, anything else? [1:11:33] Speaker E (unidentified): Just that we're going to, when are we going to get back together again? I mean, are you going to go to the select board? The 18th. It should be the 18th. Then next week is Thanksgiving. [1:11:46] Speaker J (unidentified): Right. Maybe we should, if, I don't know if Judy's, it shouldn't take her too long to turn that, right? [1:11:52] Speaker G (unidentified): I think she said two to three weeks once she got going right so we could meet in [1:11:58] Speaker J (unidentified): December at some point and go through with that we could be timed with her the [1:12:03] Speaker M (unidentified): next meeting as soon as she does when we want unless there's other stuff we want [1:12:07] Speaker E (unidentified): to do and I was going to say I know we don't have a regular meeting I mean at this point would it would it be worth planning a workshop on the second Tuesday for us at this point which isn't that far considering can't do it next week and then it's Thanksgiving you know yeah at least have something on the books yeah at least have something on the books and if we need to meet if you meet with them and you want to do something before that you can call a text but that's smart job but let's plan on just having a work workshop in lieu of a meeting on the second Tuesday yeah because we can do it like our plan on the mapping but nothing else I can start working on some of the other stuff [1:12:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Right we're also talking verbiage so we need to make a decision on a mapping right [1:13:07] Speaker E (unidentified): That makes a lot of sense to me to figure out and get us organized on what [1:13:11] Speaker J (unidentified): we're doing right yeah right agreed that makes a lot of sense okay so workshop on our regular [1:13:20] Speaker G (unidentified): Tuesday and Tuesday yes [1:13:25] Speaker J (unidentified): 5 30 oh yeah any different time or might as well why reinvent the wheel so it's good yeah it's working let's not fix it yeah I don't want any earlier so Okay. Sounds good to me. I think that's a great idea. [1:13:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Gotcha. Okay. Are we through? [1:13:46] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah. Motion to adjourn. [1:13:49] Speaker E (unidentified): I'll make a motion to adjourn. I'll second. [1:13:51] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. All in favor? We are adjourned according to the times to 6.42. too [1:14:02] Speaker M (unidentified): program [1:17:00] Speaker L (unidentified): are sponsored by door tank distributor of quality commercial doors nationwide you [1:17:42] Speaker P (unidentified): know this film rod and daniel i think they could have done a better job with it you do yeah really okay it's not that spooky it hasn't frightened me in the least however i'm told by our director tom that richard keel this is his first role really yeah he was discovered by the director in a cowboy bar no bouncing in a cowboy bar i mean a bronco if one bounces on the cowboy bar you're [1:18:09] Speaker F (unidentified): on the bull right i don't know he was the bull and then another bull seven foot two that's [1:18:15] Speaker P (unidentified): tall that's that's a long drink of water as they say here in the states anyways let's talk about you guys so door tech i you know i still don't know quite what you do i mean i imagine if i had a broken door you could fix it because your texts right we could if it was a commercial right now [1:18:34] Speaker Q (unidentified): what we do is we do commercial doors frames and hardware we do architectural hardware the lever hardware we do panic bars closers biometric hardware so you do the big stuff though you [1:18:45] Speaker P (unidentified): wouldn't do anything like these doors you do like things for like the government right yes absolutely [1:18:50] Speaker Q (unidentified): Absolutely. We do things for hospitals, correctional facilities. Right. [1:18:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Large facilities, buildings, fire rated assemblies. [1:18:58] Speaker P (unidentified): So somebody doesn't call you and say, I would like one door, please. They call you and say, we need like 5,000 doors. [1:19:04] Speaker F (unidentified): Right. We need hundreds and hundreds of doors. [1:19:06] Speaker Q (unidentified): Hundreds of hundreds, yes. [1:19:07] Speaker P (unidentified): And then you have to come out and install as well. [1:19:09] Speaker Q (unidentified): But we also service the one door jobs. You do. Because service is our name. Ah. [1:19:14] Speaker P (unidentified): Service is the name underneath. [1:19:16] Speaker F (unidentified): We get the job done. Absolutely. [1:19:19] Speaker Q (unidentified): Absolutely. And we don't play around, no fooling around, no games. [1:19:22] Speaker P (unidentified): And you must be doing well if you can sponsor a travesty like our show. I mean, this must be good. [1:19:27] Speaker Q (unidentified): We look at it as a privilege to be here. [1:19:30] Speaker F (unidentified): It is a privilege. We have been blessed, yes. The privilege is entirely ours. We are very much entertained. [1:19:33] Speaker P (unidentified): So you guys have done some big things for big people like Apple. You opened some doors for Apple, right? Yeah, absolutely. And then some of the other, you told me about the other big company that you did. [1:19:45] Speaker Q (unidentified): We did a project for 8x8. [1:19:48] Speaker F (unidentified): and they make cubicles correct right eight by eight cubicles we did a project for uber [1:19:55] Speaker P (unidentified): Uber, you know they won't come out here. They'll come to Bodega Bay, but they just won't come here. Oh, I see. Now we've tried. It's apparently an issue with the road. It's a crazy drive. Well, it's it's not the road itself. It's like it's apparently haunted, the road, and people see things. And I told you that there's a lot of u-turn marks. That's what it was, right by our gates. There's u-turn. We actually got lost and had to come around twice. Well, that's good. Well, you know the place is well hidden. Well, for a reason. Yeah, no, it needs to be. I wanted privacy when I moved here. So you know, during the break we're going to go look at some doors here because I think I should replace all my doors with like nice commercial doors, right? Absolutely. Let's touchless openings. Touchless openings. I don't know if I like the sound of that. We've got too much of that going on with this one. All right. I'm giving a signal. We've got to get back to the movie, but when we come back, we're going to talk some more with Rod and Daniel, so you guys stay with us. You guys stay with us, and we'll see you soon. [1:21:16] Speaker J (unidentified): Roxy. Roxy. Roxy. I think my collarbone's broken. [1:21:36] Speaker O (unidentified): Here, let me help you. [1:21:38] Speaker C (unidentified): How did you get here? [1:21:40] Speaker M (unidentified): Well, we came looking for you and- [1:21:52] Speaker L (unidentified): She's mine. She's friendship [1:22:05] Speaker G (unidentified): going he [1:22:35] Speaker M (unidentified): likes your perfume now all you want