← Back to MaineScanner

Kennebunkport Growth Planning Committee Reviews State-Mandated Zoning Changes

2026-11-10 · 1h 46m · Source: Kennebunkport Growth Planning Committee (Town of Kennebunkport (Town Hall Streams))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening everybody and welcome to the Kennebunkport Growth Planning Committee meeting. Today is November 10th. I'm going to call the meeting to order. I would ask the committee tonight, because we are missing the chair and vice chair, if you would please nominate a chair, a temporary chair for this meeting. [0:39] Speaker B (unidentified): I nominate Liz Johnson. [0:42] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm happy to second. And all in favor of Liz? Liz, are you in favor of Liz? All right, Liz, I'm turning the meeting over to you. Okay. [0:57] Speaker C (unidentified): We'll do quick intros. Growth Planning Committee meeting on the date. What's the date? The 11th? [1:05] Speaker B (unidentified): 10th? The chair is here. The chair is here. [1:12] Speaker C (unidentified): Saved by the bell. [1:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, we have to restart the meeting now. Now we have to repeal the temporary chair. [1:21] Speaker C (unidentified): I repeal the temporary chair assignment. [1:27] Speaker D (unidentified): All right, so what is today? [1:29] Speaker C (unidentified): I know, that was my problem. November 10th. [1:31] Speaker D (unidentified): November 10th, thank you. Day before Veterans Day. Good evening, all. Sorry for being late. And we'll start off as introduction of members and guests. Go to my left. [1:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Ann Marie Martin. Dan Saunders. Tom Smith. [1:49] Speaker E (unidentified): Tom Vandershav. Liz Johnson. [1:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Mary Beth Gilbert, Select Board [1:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Rep. Ben Averill, [1:56] Speaker G (unidentified): Support Staff. Nadia Crockett-Current, Support Staff. [2:01] Speaker D (unidentified): Hello, sir. Thanks for joining. So, our agenda, I believe they have the minutes to be reviewed from the last meeting. I honestly didn't have an opportunity to reveal anyone. I haven't had a chance, so we'll pass. Recording in progress. Then the next thing would be LD 2173 and continue our discussion. So I'm actually [2:34] Speaker G (unidentified): kicking us off tonight. Okay, perspective, we're gonna talk about the dimensional standards table. I'm so I'm gonna pull that up on the screen quickly. You also should all have a copy in front of you. Dan, I guess you probably don't have a copy. We [2:57] Speaker A (unidentified): just like to thank the team for the font size and size. We were trying to [3:06] Speaker G (unidentified): make it easy. So I pulled it up here. You can follow along on your paper if desired. So this is the culmination of some of our discussions about the lot density requirements, and I was unfortunately not here at the last meeting, but I believe that Ben discussed with you the potential changes to or our suggested changes to lot width and lot coverage to accommodate the new lot size requirements. So you see those changes reflected here in your density table. If we'll just review the village residential zone section for now, just to kind of give an overview of how I've laid the table out and what this proposed new layout looks like. So I've added four sections both for minimum lot area and minimum net residential area per dwelling unit. This is to reflect the four different required standards in the growth zone with utilities, growth zone without utilities, non-growth zone with utilities, and non-growth zone without utilities. So you can see down the table in each of those four columns, if the zone doesn't have any area in the non-growth zone or in the growth zone, I've simply blued out that section and written non-applicable, just, you know, because it makes it easier to follow along the table if you know that something simply does not apply to the zone. And I've done the same thing with the minimum net residential area per dwelling unit. As for the actual numbers, you'll see in the village residential zone we'll start with then we can kind of go down the table, but you'll see reflected there the minimum lot area in the growth zone with public water and sewer has been changed to 5,000 square feet for single-family to family and three to four dwelling units. The multiplex is kind of a policy decision that the committee has the opportunity to make decisions about. I've put 10,000 square feet in there for now, but again, that is an area that there's some flexibility. And then without public water and sewer in the growth zone, the required minimum is 20,000 square feet per dwelling unit because that's the state minimum for a septic system. Moving over to minimum lot width, so my proposal and that, and if I've been and I discussed this and kind of agree that this is a good starting place to talk about for a minimum lot width is 70 feet. It's 30 feet narrower than our existing 100 foot minimum lot width. 70 feet would allow for a perfectly square lot, weaning a perfectly square 5,000 square foot lot, which to my mind is nice. It's kind of the ideal shape for a lot, and it's in keeping with the existing character in a lot of the densely populated areas in town already. There are a lot of lots between 50 and 100 feet wide, so 70 is kind of splitting the difference there and giving us a good place to create lots that are in keeping with the general look of those growth areas in town. For the multiplex I have brought it from 150 down to 100, so allowing for a little bit of a longer minimum lot width for those more than four unit lots, because they will naturally be bigger anyway than the 5,000 square foot lot for the single to four dwelling unit developments for the net residential area. [6:46] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, sorry, lot coverage positive for a second, sure. And so for those numbers, the 70 for single family, two family, and three to four units, if the committee remembers from when you had your last meeting, which seems like it was kind of a long time ago, but it was, we had an extra week in between. We had just started to discuss what possible, what some of these dimensional standards that we have as policy choices could be, and as Nadia mentioned, when we've been talking about it in office, we were really trying to find something that would allow for lots to use the new reduction in the land use requirement. So with the reduction from 40,000 square feet to 5,000 square feet of required minimum lot area, we were hoping that the minimum lot width would also have some form of a reduction to allow for a buildable lot. So it's not even mentioned, 70 seemed like a good number for staff, but I would definitely recommend that if the committee has thoughts on either other numbers or doing something different with the minimum lot width, I think that would be something that we would want to discuss as well. No. [8:13] Speaker D (unidentified): I think this, I mean, I think the 70s [8:15] Speaker A (unidentified): reasonable number. So the, can we think about the three to four dwelling units on the 70? So I get the, get the square for the one unit, and now if we do this 70 for the three to four dwellings, this again can be three to four separate structures [8:42] Speaker G (unidentified): theoretically. Excuse me, theoretically it could be, right? Reality, the person, whoever was doing that construction, would have to make pretty small units to have four completely separate dwelling units. I think what's more likely is that you would see what looks like one sort of large-ish house that happened to have four units inside, but if a developer was able to make it work to fit four very small units separate, like with separate foundations, onto the lot, then you know that would be their prerogative to make that work. Could [9:21] Speaker C (unidentified): we remember discussing this last time, but I don't remember how it concluded. Can we put in a requirement that has to be the case that [9:37] Speaker A (unidentified): was it, was that a question going to the state in terms of is, should [9:42] Speaker F (unidentified): will there have to be separation between the individual single-family homes, like [9:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Like, can we, as a town, require with this whole thing that they're within one unit, they're within one roof? [10:01] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm still waiting on clarification from that from the state. And I suspect they are waiting for their rulemaking period to be complete before they answer questions like that, which may be why I haven't heard back. [10:17] Speaker A (unidentified): But I can poke them again. When do you think the rulemaking period at the state [10:22] Speaker F (unidentified): level is? I would suspect it would be at some point in December. They closed their rule in mid January or mid September, so I would suspect it would be somewhere between December and early January. Why does that matter? I mean, if we're [10:42] Speaker C (unidentified): allowing for four units on a lot size, why does the state care? We're still, we're still making available for places to live. I suspect it doesn't, but [10:58] Speaker F (unidentified): all when I have clarity from the main office of Community Affairs I'll definitely share that and I think it's worth mentioning now while we're kind of starting to think about whether these numbers make sense that when we left this off last during your last meeting I was referencing that in order to meet the state requirements the number for the single family dwelling to family dwelling and three and four dwelling unit provisions needs to be the same so if we're using 70 feet for the lot width, that 70, and that's reflected in this chart, would be the same for a single-family home, for a duplex, or for three or four units. And then we can do something different as a policy choice for something that is four units or more. [11:53] Speaker A (unidentified): But we can't, and that applies to the setbacks too, right? So minimum lot width and setbacks all have to be the same? That's correct. Okay. But the multiplex is where it changes? Yes. [12:07] Speaker F (unidentified): The multiplex would be up to us both to choose dimensional standards and then, when we get to it, to decide what does more than four units actually mean, what performance standards are we putting on four units or more within town. [12:25] Speaker B (unidentified): May I ask about the multiplex? Is that always going to be defined as one building, one roof? [12:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Multiplex, it currently is defined as one building in one roof, and either later tonight or at your meeting next week we'll dive into what a multiplex is and what we would possibly want it to be. We [12:50] Speaker A (unidentified): are not, we do have it currently in our [12:55] Speaker F (unidentified): definition, in our, in our ordinances, as a defined use in most zones. It is on this table, it's reflected anywhere that it previously existed, where it's in red is [13:14] Speaker A (unidentified): where it's new. Correct. Okay. So for example, Cape Arundel, there was no [13:19] Speaker F (unidentified): Multiplex there, so it's red, correct? And that would be because we were previously using multiplex as three or more units, and we now need to make it be four or more. And so for some of the, some of those zones, in order to make sure that we have the three or four unit provision, we have a new multiplex definition, but we were already allowing that type of multiplex in those zoning districts. So that has not been proposed in any new zoning districts. [13:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, because I think in the last meeting, Paul had made the comment about when we have more than one unit on a parcel that we would normally want larger side setbacks, just because there's more than one occupant, more traffic into that lot, more noise, so that would be like a general. But what we're saying is that we can't have that, right? [14:24] Speaker F (unidentified): One, two, three, and four have to be the same. Have to be the same. Okay. Multiplex. [14:29] Speaker D (unidentified): I suspect we can put some setback between units. Yes. We can identify that separately from setback on the lot, right? [14:38] Speaker F (unidentified): We can, yeah. Yeah. [14:41] Speaker D (unidentified): Or we can hold it the same. You need 15 feet between, actually it'd be 30 feet, that would make it more difficult to build individual ones, not that's not the purpose, but you want to have access to all four sides, right, from a safety purposes, be able to get [14:59] Speaker A (unidentified): out of the building, and they get firemen around it, you want to prevent, and then likewise you want to prevent when issues arise in one dwelling, you want to be able to prevent and capture that, so for example, if the fire, god forbid, if a fire house [15:18] Speaker D (unidentified): that's generally the worst case scenario in our town, right, so if you have a fire in one unit, you got to be able to get water on the other one to keep it from also catching on, right, plus get into that building, right, all righty, so where would we end up putting that data, where would that be, because we don't really have a column for spaces between. Sorry. [15:41] Speaker F (unidentified): That's all right. I'm trying not to cough on the microphone. If we were adding that provision, my recommendation would be that we amend how we currently think about our duplexes. We don't really have a multiple principal buildings on lot provision in our ordinance, but we could add that, and I think it would make sense to capture where this committee's thoughts have gone, but also just the possible changes from moving forward with these ordinance amendments and [16:18] Speaker D (unidentified): the only thought I had on multiplexes and I know we have more to work to do on that but greater than four is fine but what if it's 70 I mean that doesn't make sense but it's an outrageous number right I mean it doesn't fit on 100,000 square feet and the size of the septic Is that $20,000 based on the number, $20,000 per residential unit, or is it $20,000? Yes. Right, so even the three-to-four dwelling units, wouldn't you need $80,000? Wouldn't we need $80,000? [16:49] Speaker G (unidentified): I think I'd put $60,000 on here as the minimum for three-to-four because technically three units could be $60,000. But that would be dictated through the code office as well that someone would have to have that. Right, so you need $20,000 per unit. [17:04] Speaker D (unidentified): So maybe we do, we write it that way then, 20,000 per unit versus for the growth [17:14] Speaker G (unidentified): zone without public water and sewer. I think that we can certainly amend the minimum lot area. It is captured, I think, in the net residential area requirements, okay, at 20,000 per unit for all of those zones, okay. But we can, I can rewrite the minimum lot area as well to make that clearer. Can we put a cap on [17:43] Speaker F (unidentified): the units within a multiplex? You, we can. Right now our multiplex has a ceiling of eight units per building. It's [18:02] Speaker G (unidentified): not 70. And if you look at the, and if you look at the multiplex line, excuse me, the multiplex row for minimum net residential area, you can see that we've put in 1250 for the first four units per unit and then 5,000 square feet per unit for more than four. Again, that's another policy decision of the board. There is some flexibility given in LD 2173 for anything over four units. There's not really a required minimum. So 5,000 is kind of just something that we threw in there, but it's another policy discussion for the committee to have how many square feet of net residential area you want to see on that list for each unit over four units. One to four units, our hands are tied at 1,250 square feet of net residential area per unit, but five to eight units, you can have that be 5,000 square feet per unit or 10,000 square feet per unit. That one's a little bit more flexible. So I think this is [19:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Where you by default are now creating your buffer zone, right? So even though it's going to be a multiplex within one building, you're you're creating that by looking at this what Nadia just read through us, that by default once you get over that four units you're now requiring more lot space, which is in essence creates a buffer zone for you between the neighbors. If I'm thinking about, am I thinking about that right? Mm-hmm. So that would be good to. We've [19:54] Speaker G (unidentified): also added some amendment to the maximum lot coverage for most of the zones for anything that has that changed in that residential area requirement. The thought here being the same as the changed minimum lot with, if we have a 5,000 square foot lot where the maximum allowed coverage is 20% it doesn't actually allow for that development to happen. So our proposal is 35%. It still is less than half of the lot developed, and what the December was not pulled out of thin air. I did a little bit of looking on our GIS maps at existing neighborhoods in town that have lots that are roughly 5,000 square feet and many of which have more than one dwelling unit existing on the lot, and oftentimes we see about 35% lot coverage. So there are areas of town that you can drive through that have this existing lot coverage that have similar lot widths and they don't look, they look, you know, like Kennebunkport. They kind of look like what you see just all the time around you. So 35% we don't think would be too much of a change but would be enough to actually allow those units to go in on a 5,000-square-foot lot. [21:09] Speaker A (unidentified): And that's house-only. That's not solid surface. That's correct. [21:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Driveways. Outside of the shoreland zone, that's only structures. Structures. So sheds would also count towards that lot coverage limit. Decks, anything like that. [21:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Not driveways? Not driveways. [21:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Or sidewalks or walkways. Correct. [21:32] Speaker E (unidentified): I guess if you looked at it that way, Nadia, did you also look at how many were actually, what proportion of homes were actually close to 35%? Do you have any, is that, I just don't know what numbers we're talking about, but it seems like increasing it to 35% for all homes. There could be a lot of [21:52] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I think that and it's something that I think we've kind of discussed over the past several months, is that likely we will see a little bit of a change in what, Kennebunkport looks like in some areas because of this LD2173 change. So I don't think that it's reasonable to say that 35% will keep every lot looking exactly the same as it does now. [22:15] Speaker E (unidentified): That wasn't why I was bringing it up. I'm just trying to understand, like, how much is the ramifications. [22:20] Speaker G (unidentified): I think that it depends on the area that you're in. So in the Cape Rundle zone, it's a little bit more suburban. The lots are not as densely populated. So a 35% lot coverage and decreased minimum lot width, you probably would notice a change. It would be a noticeable difference if every lot suddenly changed to those specifications in the village residential area. Less of a change, less of a noticeable difference, same with the Cape Porpoise zones. So it depends on what part of town you're in, but in the kind of downtown core, it would be quite similar to what is existing already. I don't have an exact number of lots off the top of my head, but a decent number. [23:02] Speaker E (unidentified): They're not conforming, so they're already bigger than the 20%. [23:04] Speaker F (unidentified): I purposely didn't bring my literature that I've been bringing with me most of the time that we've been going through these dimensional standards table, but I do have books in the office that talk about the best ways to create lot coverage requirements and other requirements and zoning codes, and the general consensus was for this size of the lot, for a five to ten thousand square foot lot, that the lot coverage should be right around thirty five, thirty to thirty five percent lot coverage, which again, as where we were going the last time the committee met, was trying to make it so that this dimensional standards table would allow someone to still have a lot that they could construct and build on in the future, and to not retain some of the numbers that are there and restrict development of any kind within various districts across town, do [24:04] Speaker E (unidentified): I have it right that when you look at in conjunction with the setbacks, we're kind of putting things in the middle, in a 30, 35 by 40. Yep, it would be quite, they would have to [24:15] Speaker G (unidentified): to be quite centered on the lot to meet both the setbacks and with the new lot size to meet those setbacks. If you picture a 70 by 70 lot, you have about 40 feet to work with from the sides and 35 feet to work with between the front and back, so it is a, you know, a tight square in the middle, basically. Got it. So if [24:40] Speaker E (unidentified): If someone wanted to put multiple units in, it's likely to go up three floors. [24:45] Speaker G (unidentified): We do have the height limits. We haven't proposed any changes to the maximum building height. There is a provision in the law that allows for affordable housing developments to go 14 feet over the height limits, but for any other housing, we haven't proposed any changes to that height. So basically you're still getting maximum three ish stories out of those buildings. [25:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you, I know this is a state mandate, but I'm just having a really hard time swallowing this concept when we worked for years on our comp plan and regarding, you know, stormwater runoff and keeping things green and not over maxing the structures we have, ie schools, roads, storm drains, so I just want to make sure that because you can get overwhelmed looking at all these numbers and I'm not a super number person, but I just want to make sure that we are doing, and if anyone doesn't agree with me let me know, that we are doing the minimum of what we have to do to follow the state law so that we're in, we are in compliance, but it is the absolute minimum down to the square foot. [26:31] Speaker F (unidentified): We are meeting the state requirements on this dimensional use chart and we are making some amendments, but those amendments are strictly so that a lot within town with that reduced lot size still has the ability to have a way to construct new structures on the lot. So if we retain specifically the frontage, the plot width requirement or the coverage requirement, both of those would mean that if a division occurred for the five, for a lot up to 5,000 square feet, that there would be awkward shaped lot for the minimum width provision in which a lot would need to have a hundred foot of width or a hundred foot of road frontage but still be very small, and so by modifying these numbers a little bit will allow for better build out if there are lots that are divided or to Nadia, to where Nadia was going, a more conforming figuration of lots in many of the zoning districts, either here in village residential or in Goose Rocks or other locations in town that are more dense already, so [27:59] Speaker A (unidentified): we didn't get an answer back from the state or anyone about if we, if we could just put density growth to affordable housing, workforce housing? [28:09] Speaker F (unidentified): I have not, although I do suspect the answer is that as Nadia kind of alluded to, the affordable housing density bonus is its own thing and we would not be able to restrict these provisions, the 5,000 square foot reduction, to affordable housing. [28:29] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think what we talked about before to answer Liz's part of her question and what you talked about, Ben, is that to follow the state mandate we would have to go down to the 5,000 square foot lot, the left side of this chart. But the state didn't mandate us to change any of our setbacks. They actually said we could keep our setbacks. So you could create a scenario like Ben was alluding to, that you say, okay, fine, we're going to update it, we're going to go into 5,000 square. But our setbacks on our minimum lot width stays this way, and so therefore it basically becomes a moot point because they can't build. [29:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, why can't we do that? [29:13] Speaker A (unidentified): You can. This is your committee. You were almost chair tonight. [29:19] Speaker D (unidentified): You gave it up. [29:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Why can't we do that? [29:23] Speaker D (unidentified): I was just doing some basic math. and so if we've got a 70 by 71 foot lot that's 5,000 square feet you know plus or minus a couple of feet and if we have our setbacks so fronts 20 rears 15 that takes away 35 feet from the 71 so it leaves you 36 and if you have the 15 on the side that takes 30 away it leaves you a 40 so now you're dealing with a footprint if you filled all that in with just a house that's fourteen hundred and forty square feet right and that would be during to do lot coverage you could take into account the setbacks or do you have to extract that setbacks are [30:11] Speaker G (unidentified): excluded, included, excluded, you can count the whole lot of the law, right? So that [30:15] Speaker D (unidentified): would be so that 1440 you know divided by 5,000 that gives you a 29% you couldn't build any more on that without stepping onto the setbacks correct so [30:32] Speaker A (unidentified): you couldn't even do 35% coverage on that. So what is that, what is the, how does [30:37] Speaker G (unidentified): somebody get a variance on setbacks? So any variance for dimensional standards goes through the Zoning Board of Appeals. Nope, an existing non-conforming structure can go through planning board process to make amendments to the footprint or anything like that within the setback. But for a new structure to be constructed within the setbacks, they would need zoning board of appeals approval for an official variance, and there are a couple different paths to get a variance, but they're generally very Challenging, you usually have to prove some kind of hardship or that you can't get any reasonable return from the lot without having a variance for those dimensional standards. But there also are some other regulations, like you can't have that hardship because of any action that you or a previous lot owner have taken. So if you split off an unbuildable lot, that's not a good enough reason to get a variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals. It's quite a challenging process. It's very tough to prove hardship enough to get a variance from those dimensional standards. [31:52] Speaker C (unidentified): So if the only piece of this that's being mandated by the state is the minimum lot area, we can't we as a town, if we come, if we comply to that, why then can't we as a town say all right, we'll do that part and then we'll adjust the rest of it to be our affordable housing, well we'll adjust the rest of this and allow for more homes and units. I like that. But they all have to be affordable housing. This is our town. This is our rule. We follow the state rule. [32:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Why not? Can you expand on that? Would you be proposing retaining the existing dimensional standards provisions for single family, two family, three and four as they stand? [33:08] Speaker C (unidentified): As they stand today? Yeah. [33:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Before the amendment, yes, yeah, okay. And then you would get this red version, I think what I'm hearing Liz say, then you would get this red version if these were indeed affordable housing. [33:23] Speaker C (unidentified): Right, so that's the indefinitely affordable, none of this 30-year stuff, we'll talk about whether [33:33] Speaker F (unidentified): we could actually decide that indefinitely was in a deed, but 30 years doesn't make a difference at all, and we'll get, when we do the affordable housing density bonus, we'll talk about what the state asks us to do, and then we could certainly talk about do we want to ask for qualifiers that are higher than that in terms of whether we're asking for different deep language, but for the question you asked, for the dimensional standards chart, I think yes, if that was this, the committee in the select board's recommendation, the town could certainly retain the dimensional standards chart as it exists and then have a separate use classification of affordable housing. The challenge would be we would need to create that full new use as an affordable housing, whatever that meant, and make sure that it was just filled out within this chart and then matched the provisions of the affordable housing density bonus. Okay. Our recommendation would still be wherever the numbers lie, that the numbers for lot width coverage and setbacks would allow for structures to be more easily constructed across town. Because our concern isn't necessarily that everyone's going to do it but that it would be when eventually someone divides a lot and creates a new 10,000 or 5,000 square foot lot that we have the ability to actually let them construct something on that lot if [Speaker C (unidentified): it's affordable I] think we can do that as a separate use classification but I think Nadia's recommendation is still modified the lot with the lot coverage and possibly the setback requirements, but the committee can choose to not move forward with staff recommendations. [35:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Why would we want to allow that if it's just going to be an uber-wealthy wanting to get even more uber-wealthy? [35:59] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think what you heard Ben say is that the committee, you guys can have that discussion and decide and bring that forward to the select board. But Ben and Nadia as the planning crew are taking just like they did for the parking on the select board said no we're not changing our you guys approve the parking during this and the select board said nope we get safety first in our town we're not doing we're not following the state's mandate you know so we so you guys can say okay Ben and Nadia I get it you're trying to make this so it works and but our what we want to bring forward is it works on we only make the setback changes for affordable. The committee can decide that. You're not gonna get Ben and Nadia to agree to bring that forward to you. That's what you guys gotta decide. [36:50] Speaker G (unidentified): We bring our best policy recommendation and it's- [36:53] Speaker A (unidentified): To make it a buildable thing. Right. And then you guys can come in and say, yeah, that's great, but state mandates only for the first section of this. And then if somebody wants to do that because that goes back to the question I raised which was can we just the intent of this from the very beginning was affordable housing then it just became small lot sizes well for global housing workforce housing however [37:24] Speaker D (unidentified): However that gets defined, I mean their definition was a little bit different than HUD's, which was more expansive. I think there, I mean, some of these numbers I think still have to change though, right? Because we can't have different setbacks where the different dwelling, you know, right, those all have to be the same. That's correct, one through four should be the same. So the first three rows on here all have to have the same dimensional requirements. I made a comparison to that [37:55] Speaker H (unidentified): that point between row one and row four, and the numbers across one and four, rows one and row four, they're all the same. My concern would be some developer comes in, wants to maximize his or her return on investment, buys the dirt, wants to put up buildings, well, guess what? They want to probably put as many houses on that lot as they can, so the requirements. Apartments are all exactly the same, but if you allow people to put up to four dwellings on one unit, you're really tightly crammed. I wouldn't want to be a neighbor to that unit, as opposed to having one house that's maybe 30, 40 feet away. You have several houses with that eyesight of your home. I think that it's natural for the developer to want to maximize the profit, but at the expense of the appearance of the town and the convenience of the neighbors who are already [38:50] Speaker G (unidentified): there and that's, that's where you have some policy flexibility for anything over four units. One to four units though, there is where that state mandated number is coming in. So while, you know, I hear your point that it would be a potentially busy building to have four units in that, you know, single family house space, that 5,000 square foot lot for those four first four units is the mandate that we're working with, so anything over four units we have some flexibility to decide where we want to go with that and technically speaking the setbacks could be changed for all of that, those number of units, but to, so what Ben was saying earlier, if we increase the setbacks to a certain extent it creates functionally unbuildable lots at 5,000 square feet, so we're kind of, what you're seeing kind of is us trying to balance those state requirements with the concerns that we have heard from the committee about providing too much opportunity for development on those small lots. Your point is well taken that it could potentially create busy areas by having so many units on a small space. [40:03] Speaker H (unidentified): I think it'll happen. I think I wouldn't want to be a neighbor in that area and have somebody come in and build a four unit lot that is probably as big as a person who lives there. His or her lot is already 5,000 feet, square feet, and somebody else comes in and plops four houses down, crammed on top of each other in that same space. I wouldn't be a very happy neighbor if I were that person already living there, not at all. [40:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Could I ask a couple of questions on that? With what you're raising, Tom, the argument that I seem to hear with regards to affordable housing, and I'm still trying to get ahead around what the definition of affordable housing is, but one of the things that they seem to be saying is that the more units that are available, prices are going to come down. This is economic thinking from years and years and years ago, which doesn't seem to apply today, but I think that's the argument, that if we have more, the prices will naturally come down. I don't see that happening in a town such as Kennebunkport or Miami or Martha's Vineyard. So I think it doesn't apply here, but that's the argument that they're going to make. So the long-term thinking is how does this town protect itself from five years down the road, ten years down the road, someone coming in and saying, we're going to build more units, and they're basically for affordable housing. It's going to, because the prices will be lower since there's more units that are out there. So I feel that what you've come up with is an attempt to try to steer off issues five to ten years down the road. And, you know, correct me if I'm not saying this, you know, properly. And then the other thing that I have a concern about is if you're going to have a multiplex, I would love to see building standards that required sound, you know, buildings with sound barriers between the units so that people can live in it and have their music or have whatever noise that they want which doesn't interfere with the next-door neighbors because there's going to be calls on that, there's going to be a greater police involvement and there's, you know, additional cost. So I'd, I'd love to see some protection to the units that they can be just something that allows people to live next to each other comfortably and not interfere with each other and bring in town resources to keep things going. [42:42] Speaker F (unidentified): I am going to say something that I do not have enough knowledge on, but we can get clarification for your meeting next week. But any units that are three units or above, any building that is three units or above, is commercial building code versus residential building code. So there would be some provisions related to fire safety in which wall structures would be thicker or there'd be other materials as the units are constructed, and we can ask our code officers to give us a little bit more guidance with that. [43:17] Speaker G (unidentified): unless you know offhand thank you that's three units and above three units and [43:23] Speaker D (unidentified): above would be commercial three units or three stores three units three dwelling units three dwelling units I got you in one structure correct so [43:37] Speaker E (unidentified): I make sure I understand if we went down the road of having two different categories of affordable and not affordable I understand the lot width is something that can be different between the two are the setbacks different between could [43:51] Speaker G (unidentified): they be different as well both the lot width and the setbacks there's no state mandated difference for affordable housing but technically speaking yes the committee could decide to have a separate less strict standard for affordable housing for both the lot width and the setback so if you could set you know 15 foot side setbacks for market rate developments and 10 foot side setbacks for affordable developments or we could just leave [44:25] Speaker E (unidentified): everything the way it is for anything that's not right 15 feet is the [44:30] Speaker G (unidentified): existing side setbacks couldn't that be seen as a motivation for affordable [44:36] Speaker B (unidentified): housing then to my concern is there's an interest that says we want to build and we want to benefit from that building and then there's someone over here who says we're so excited because that'll mean we have affordable housing and I don't see that necessarily happening I think I think to your point [44:55] Speaker A (unidentified): earlier and Marie we live in a little microcosm so we're a tourist community we're coastal and we're small if we were part of a couple of the towns that surrounded us then I think you could make that argument that you know you are going to get some pockets but right along the coast I think our port town will remain exactly how we've been saying in terms of the market rates when you look at market rates of how the market has dropped over decades the past couple decades kenny bunk port if you do The study on that, we don't, we fluctuate, we may stagnate, but we certainly do not go down. And so I think that is, I think an inherent fear or concern that I think this committee has talked about before. And you know, I understand the state may saying, okay, you know, supply demand, you know, let's just flood with houses, and you know, that would be more supply, so the demand will be where it is, and prices will drop. Great. We all know that curve. But in our microcosm, I think we're all having a tough time. So from my perspective on the select board, if we are truly doing this to allow workforce housing, I would like to, wherever we can, to Liz's point, wherever we can, where the state hasn't mandated, where we can come in through the side door, literally, and say, okay, we'll give you this and make it so, but we want it workforce housing right, because that isn't a goal, yeah, right, that has been the discussion, been our goal. If not, I think we all are understanding what this is going to be, and again you know, the village parcel at some point, you know, the town is not a developer, but at some point there'll be some decision made at some point, and that is what we're defining here also is the future of that parcel. So do you want a highly dense high ticket price, you know, units in there, or do you want more of a moderate, you know, highly priced built the way that we build them today, and then pockets of affordable, because they somebody's going to get that density bonus, you know, they're going to have to be bringing in utilities into that spot, so they're gonna look for density, so maybe they do a hybrid, and that's what we want to try to push people towards. Otherwise, I think we're given, to Liz's point and to your points, I think we're given, we are not going to get, and that's what we talked to rep care about, we are not going to get the intent. So I think, but that I think you guys should discuss about where you all lie, because you all represent the residents here, and we need to understand where your thoughts are, and you know, are you lining up with Liz, and are you, well, I agree with Liz's [47:59] Speaker B (unidentified): perspective I think that 's a great incentive to achieve the goal but it also recognizes that the reality of this of the layout of this town so I support with what Liz had suggested. I think it's a fantastic chart you developed for us, Nadia, and I think it is really important to keep it going forward as every year seems to change now. Just be prepared for [48:29] Speaker G (unidentified): differences. Okay, so I think [48:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Let's talk about that just a little bit though. I think the reality though is that there's not too many numbers up here that we can really change. Right, we, unless we want to change what our single-family setbacks are and make them bigger, which I wouldn't encourage, but we have to set all those to be 20 by 15 by 15 like I said, or set them all to be 30 by 20 by 20 or 50 by whatever, right, the minimum with one, we don't, we could leave it at a hundred. What that could do is turn that 36 by 40 home into a 20 by 65 home, which doesn't look like anything in Kennebunk Ward, that's actually 15, right, I mean I've been in those places in California I rented then they could be very nice and built very well and be very pleasant place to live, but it doesn't look like the port, right, it's just a long structure and they're right next to each other maybe six feet a fart, right, so that could happen and those still could be two million dollar homes that are sold and now it doesn't even look like what our town looks like versus a versus a 36 by 40. Are we [49:49] Speaker C (unidentified): also stating within this I guess, no, that's only in the historic district, yeah, right, so yeah, exactly [49:56] Speaker D (unidentified): So like I'm saying, you know, if we left it at 100, right, if you went bigger than that it's going to be even thinner, so I think we got to be careful with that as well because someone could still divide that up and build the what we don't want and not affordable housing too because it won't look like what we have and the reality is, I mean, I can't imagine much of this property down here that the developer is going to take it and turn it into affordable housing, it's just the property itself costs so much darn money. Well good, they're going to half a million, so the only way they're going to be able to do that and justify it as if they can turn it into luxury [50:38] Speaker G (unidentified): apartments to be used for others. Unfortunately I think it is, so to Dan's point there are already some really great affordable housing density bonuses that are mandated by the state and we haven't seen a boom in affordable housing in Kennebunkport as a result of those density bonuses 2003, you know, they [51:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Didn't to Anne Marie's point this is a great chart because it's going to keep coming until they hit that thing of when does it start to happen so if developers don't pick up on this you know and they don't get what they want then it'll be whatever's next right because that's first we had the comp plan we had to define the growth area right then and then we had ld 2003 that told us you know what we can do into this and now this ties back into that so i think if there are any areas that allow the Town i guess my advice to the committee would be if there are ways that we can incentivize the workforce affordable housing for the bonuses I think that would be a good approach I understand what Dan is saying so maybe you want to make it so that you still can build but then you get a bigger you can you can actually achieve you can actually achieve something more if you go affordable because then the town is benefiting the town is benefiting we're getting in you know you know kids that are Starting off you know seniors that are downsizing just plain workforce you know you know just more affordable units so [52:46] Speaker F (unidentified): We can i think the committee should keep looking at this table if you would like to continue to go through some of the proposed changes but if you it sounds like there's a preference for staff to bring back to your meeting next week additions to this chart which would have affordable housing and or a workforce housing use classification is that [53:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Correct well i don't know Dan i think you gotta sort of like hear from your committee because yeah [53:24] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean realistically the numbers we can affect are the minimum setbacks but that'd be changing them for all and does that need to be for all in all districts that are on in the growth area they would have to be similar right we couldn't have it 30 and 1 and 20 and another correct to be similar for [53:49] Speaker G (unidentified): Everything that's in the growth area and for some of the districts we don't have to allow more than two dwelling units anyway I believe so those ones wouldn't have to necessarily see changes but for the zones that we've really highlighted they'll have to be pretty uniform so [54:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Cape Corpus so [Speaker D (unidentified): We] Always think of the growth area as like I think one we're visualizing that it is the port but you know there's a significant thing in Cape Porpoise and yeah it's big it's a big area [54:39] Speaker H (unidentified): Cape [54:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Rondo, yeah, it's not just, oh, it's the growth area, I would say that the, you know, there as a proportion of zones there are more in the growth area than any of the other growth zones, but the growth zone itself is less than a third of the land area in Kenny Bunk Port, so it just happens to be that the zones in the growth area are small zones, the farm and forest zone and the free enterprise zone are huge and make up most of the rural and transitional zones, so I, as Mary Beth pointed out, there's a lot of zones in the growth area, but I think it's, it's good to remember that the growth area is not actually taking up most of the town, it just happens to be that those zones are small and all fit inside the, you know, relatively smaller growth area, and [55:39] Speaker F (unidentified): we had printed out maps of the growth area for the committee in the past, we could certainly bring up the map if that were helpful, but as we had talked about I think last time or maybe the, maybe two meetings ago, while there are lots of districts that are within the growth area or lots of districts that are required to have amendments because they also have public water and public sewer. There are many portions of town, primarily in, well, pretty much all along the coast, but primarily in the Goose Rocks area, the Cape Porpoise zones, and parts of the village districts that are within flood zones or other provisions in which we will have a qualifier in our ordinance that effectively negates this density. So the table you have in front of you will always be the same because it's for the district, but there may be 50% of lots in some of those districts that cannot actually meet those requirements and would have to have a different, would need to just not have that reduction. [56:59] Speaker A (unidentified): You know what this reminds me of? Remember, you guys won't remember this, but the encyclopedias, when you used to go to the transparency pages and you could build, like you would add on, like you'd have the skeleton of the frog and then you'd lay on its circulatory thing and then its organs. It's sort of like that. I remember that. Do you remember? Yeah. Okay. [57:26] Speaker D (unidentified): So we can write that in a way that we don't reference any correct civic flight flood maps, right, so as life goes on and in ten years from now we've got a flood map that impacts more properties than we do, that it's a living, it would update, say that property is no longer in or out, right, that's correct, there are specific [57:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Provisions under state, under the state statute, and it would effectively mean that on a parcel by parcel basis that these reductions would not apply. Okay, it should make [58:01] Speaker D (unidentified): sense because we shouldn't be building in flood zones if we gonna avoid it, and that's consistent with our comp plan, correct? At least one of the things that's consistent. I mean, I like the idea having something different for a workforce housing, but to make people think about it at least that it's a benefit, but I'm just worried about they'll look at some developer will look at and say that's fine and I think it's but I'll be happy building a narrow and long home and sell it for a million and a half and have you know multiple of them on a wall. [58:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Does that math even work? Like literally could they? It may reduce the total [58:52] Speaker E (unidentified): number they can get, it's but that's setting up a 15 deep by 70 why it's one room deep, that's what the [59:16] Speaker D (unidentified): market is at the moment, that's the people who are paying the money for new homes have the money to pay for new homes. Unfortunately, the young kids can't even get the mortgage to get the down payment because they're paying off their student loans. [59:35] Speaker G (unidentified): We can also discuss some kind of middle ground. The regular market rate housing could have a minimum lot width of 85 feet, whereas the affordable bonus could still be 70. And it doesn't have to be 100 feet for market rate and then something smaller for affordable. It can be kind of a middle ground for both to avoid having long, skinny houses more so while still allowing for a greater, or I guess a smaller lot width for affordable developments. [1:00:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Would that be within the same area, the same subdivision, that you could have a variety of sizes of lots and it would be so much more interesting for people to live with? [1:00:31] Speaker G (unidentified): That's a good question. We've yet to have any mixed development in Kennebunkport, but theoretically speaking, probably. [1:00:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think if you're going to do something like that, so if you go back to the common of, so go into the village parcel, in order for somebody to go in there with, you know, to drag in those utilities, that's expensive. So they're going to look for density. So if you can do some mixed where you give them more density capability, if they hit that affordable because I think the way it is right now 2003 LD 2003 was a percent, it didn't really give you it's two and a half times the [1:01:24] Speaker G (unidentified): density in areas with public water and sewer, right, but [1:01:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Nobody's been able to, nobody around here has been able to, well, most people haven't. That's correct, we [1:01:41] Speaker F (unidentified): We have not had any, no development has used the affordable housing density bonus here in Kennebunkport. [1:01:54] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think that's the problem that we've been struggling. So maybe is this an option for you guys to have, take Nadia and Ben up on maybe their proposal that I thought they were heading at was to try to find a, see if there's a thing that makes it so you don't get the long, skinny houses. Yeah, but then also that you don't, you know, give everything away unless they say we're gonna, you don't give them like a hundred percent of all of the density unless they come in with the affordable stuff. Yes, right, we can certainly come in [1:02:39] Speaker G (unidentified): with a couple different variations. Next week is a bit of a tight turnaround, but we, so we might not be able to get things out to you guys in the next meeting. But if you just, we can take one segment. Yeah. Yeah, we can definitely come with that prepared and I can also bring a few examples of existing developed areas in town to kind of show what those different lot widths and different lot coverages look like in existing lots in town already. That might be helpful to visualize more what we're pitching. Sounds [1:03:17] Speaker D (unidentified): good. I just did a couple of quick math ones and I don't, like a cape is normally 37, 38, 40 feet by 32 or something. It doesn't get much narrower than 32 feet, so you're still looking then at a sort of a lot that's 80 by 62, so 80 being that frontage to sort of even get that cape. It's not really much different than 70. So in my mind, that would trigger, yeah, okay, I'll do it that way to get the workforce housing, right? It'd be nice to have a developer on our, you know, that's no longer developing, but give us the ideas. [1:04:05] Speaker A (unidentified): He was just in the room. [1:04:07] Speaker D (unidentified): What would they need to do workforce housing, right? What would they need to have to get the workforce housing? [1:04:16] Speaker G (unidentified): So we'll bring in some options next week, and we can review together and kind of have some different variations, and we can work from there. It's been fun thinking about and kind of, you know, doing town research on existing lots and everything. Thank you. [1:04:39] Speaker F (unidentified): You also have in front of you, and I'm happy to share my screen with this, so we have permitted, we've updated our permitted uses table so that would show similar to the dimensional standards chart that would show where all of the more, all of the new use provisions are within those zoning districts. Thank You and so in each of the zoning districts, this shows just those new change to the to the use table. We will probably amend this if we are amending the dimensional standards to have some sort of affordable housing use classification as its own use. We would amend this to make sure that is also a permitted use within those zoning districts. In the past, when we updated the ordinances to comply with all the 2003, the affordable housing density bonus was just a performance standard that was within the code, so it wasn't it's a standalone use, and so if we create the dimensional standards for it, we just need to make sure that we also call it a use and put it within this chart as well, and [Speaker E (unidentified): then] And depending on where the committee would like to go, you do have the very basic accessory dwelling unit provision up on some of your desks, and we only had a couple copies, but we could pull that up as well. But I'll leave that up to the committee to decide if you have more brain space tonight or if you'd like to have an easy night tonight. [1:07:11] Speaker B (unidentified): So this is proposed language? [1:07:15] Speaker F (unidentified): So it is. The existing language with one minor modification, 160 [Speaker B (unidentified): square feet.] Correct, that's the only change that is currently proposed, and I wanted to walk us through. So that change to 160 square feet would meet the state requirement. It actually wasn't a part of LD 2173, but it was amended when the state updated its building codes in 2025. That was reduced. The remainder of our accessory dwelling unit performance standards can stay the same, and I wanted you to just see them as they exist today. The one difference that we would be making as we move through this process would just be ensuring that accessory dwelling units, or we call them accessory apartments, are able to be added to single family homes, duplexes, so two family homes, or three or four units. So the only change that staff would do would be to update some of these provisions to ensure that an accessory dwelling unit or an accessory apartment could be placed on those types of structures. [1:09:02] Speaker A (unidentified): And these aren't allowed to be in the short-term rental, right? [1:09:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Correct. They are not able to be short-term rented. [1:09:10] Speaker D (unidentified): But that was still on one per lot, right? [1:09:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Correct. And unless we were to decide something different, it would still be one per lot. [1:09:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Not at 190 square feet. So [1:09:31] Speaker D (unidentified): if you built a three-story building, you couldn't have one section with an accessory apartment on the end of each floor? [1:09:40] Speaker A (unidentified): No, just one. The other ones would just be closets. Are [1:09:48] Speaker C (unidentified): These spaces supposed to be independent living? Like a bedroom, a bathroom, and a kitchenette in 160 square feet? Correct. [1:10:05] Speaker G (unidentified): tiny the layout can be kind of studio apartment dish so the bedroom doesn't necessarily have to be a separate full room it is tight though there's you can kind of you can look up a lot of towns or states have kind of stock adu plans that they allow people to just kind of pull that plan and they can say i'm going to build this exact adu and they show them in lots of different square footages it's kind of a neat exercise if you're interested in seeing how people use that space there are some that are as small as 160 square feet and they're tight but they're livable and [1:10:52] Speaker F (unidentified): so when you meet next week we'll also include provisions for affordable housing because it makes sense if we're talking about what it is as a use to talk about the performance standards around it and then we can also try to dive into multiplex and decide what that is and isn't as well, if that works for the committee. [1:11:14] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, that works. [1:11:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Can I ask a question about other business? Can you ask him? [1:11:24] Speaker D (unidentified): Let's see, we got any other discussions on this? [1:11:27] Speaker H (unidentified): I want to raise a question, an issue about, I guess I'll frame this as a dumb question, why? By why, I mean, who are the stakeholders? Who are the people we're trying to serve in this whole business? I can see a lot of different competing objectives. There are some people who don't want any progress in the town, keep it the way it is, no change and so forth. And people on the other extreme want to come in and turn the town inside out into a commercial enterprise. Obviously, the state has a lot of constraints on what we do and how we do it and so forth. And I'm kind of wondering, is there some way we can identify who are the so-called stakeholders, who we're trying to serve, and what their competing objectives are? Because if we pull on one string, we're pushing someplace else. And by helping to serve this group of people, maybe hurting other people over there. How do we kind of, I guess, rationalize this whole process in a coherent kind of way and make sure that we're going down the right path and doing what's best for the town, subject to the constraints of the state? I can see where, again, some people want to stop any development at all, keep things the way they are, and some people who have kids in the town, they want them to grow up and stay here and be able to afford a decent house. So how do we, I guess, integrate all those competing objectives and come up with a rational, coherent kind of strategy? [1:12:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think your question would say, to me, Tom, your question is almost like a green slate question. What? Like a green slate, like you're starting from scratch. Meaning that if we were gonna have that discussion, then we would talk about who our stakeholders are and what we're trying to achieve. For me that's been, we are not there. We're basically taking a state mandate and knowing that in our comp plan and what we were trying to achieve through that, you know, is, you know, with the housing trust and stuff, neighborhood trust, now some type of workforce affordable housing. So if that is what density is supposed to yield, I think the discussion that this committee had tonight and the direction that Ben and Nadia are going to come back with next week to try to see if there's a way to say, okay, you know, we're following the state regs and we know what we're going to get from that, which is people building out expensive homes because they can do more. And then if we could say, okay, we'll give you that and this within the state guidelines, but we, within the state guidelines, we don't have to give you all of it because we have our setbacks and stuff and we're going to give more of that to the people that will come in and either do a hybrid or they'll buy some plot of land and they can do some housing that's high end and then they can do some housing that's more dense, that's affordable, that is utopia I think for our town. But if this table could be set up to entice the developer to do that versus just a blanket slate that says, okay, density here it is and you choose, I don't think anybody that's a business person is going to just for the sake of goodness choose to do affordable. It's not, you know, they have people that they have to pay and everything. So but you're saying [1:14:53] Speaker H (unidentified): some of these constraints are elastic and we can work around them and how do we do that and who we hurting by maybe relaxing this constraint as opposed to [1:15:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Giving somebody else some other benefit. Yeah, the town said, the town gave us a rule book, right? So they said 5,000 square feet, and as Ben and Nadia have heard, this nice chart have outlined for us here's the boxes that all have to be the same. So your minimum lot side, your setbacks for these three categories all have to be the same. So Nadia came back with Ben and said, okay, roughly right, you do 70 feet of frontage, 35% area coverage, you're going to get a nice house. Okay, well, they're going to come back next week and say, well, if you do this, and then we can actually give them more,, you know, meaning we wouldn't give the farm away for the really end expenses. If you want more density per the setbacks or whatever they're going to look at, then that's when we give more of the density that the state is looking for. [1:16:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Are we the town and therefore can't we then maybe make some of these adjustments to the constraints that I see here if it's within the guidelines of the state? [1:16:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. Yes, and the thing that you heard at the beginning or at one point during this meeting, we could be as prickly as we want to be with the state right now because the state law came in and said, here's the things, here's your playbook, 5,000 square feet, we're not going to touch your setbacks, we're not going to touch these other things. These just all have to be the same. We can make it so it's impossible to build anything on 5,000 square feet. But what the committee which you guys basically said is, okay, let's make it so we don't get those straight narrow places, let's make it so it still seems like the port, and then Ben and Nadia if you can go off and work some magic to see if we can get more, we can we can sort of split, so I think we're just trying to come up with something where the incentive is really going to achieve or at least a head nod towards achieving what the state intended for density growth, which was supposed to be to bring affordability into the towns. So will it work? Who knows? 2003, as Ben and Nadia said, the roots didn't go into the ground for that one. The ADUs haven't taken off in our town. There's a lot of things. I mean, ADUs can help if they're not short-term rentals. Those can be helpful for people that are looking for affordable rentals workforce. [1:17:50] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I think the economy right now could have had something to do with that. And if that changes two years from now, and the cost of things isn't so astronomical, that could change. People could have more spending money to build ad use and stuff [1:18:21] Speaker B (unidentified): like that. Yeah, well, [1:18:23] Speaker A (unidentified): we've had the ad you on our books for a long time before 2003. We just, for whatever reason, that flywheel doesn't get going. But your point is taken. Yep, so all this could, you know, hopefully, so Tom, that's the, I think, the committee, you know, your team, you guys have been working at this and trying to achieve the stakeholders, which is our residents, and trying to get some affordability here. [1:18:50] Speaker H (unidentified): My concern is as you give somebody something, you're probably taking that away from somebody else. So how do we, I guess, develop the optimum solution by raising everybody higher and higher in the, I guess, whatever criteria we use to establish success here? How do we give the maximum benefit to people without hurting other people below subject to the state's constraints? It seems like it's a very elastic kind of a problem. [1:19:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Who would it be hurting? I don't understand. [1:19:23] Speaker H (unidentified): Say, for instance, if you said you want to have a place that is really, dense in population, the neighbors next door may not like that. [1:19:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, no, we don't want that. Exactly. We don't want that. [1:19:34] Speaker H (unidentified): If you want to have, I guess, high-rise buildings and so forth, the neighbors may not like that as well. So you can go on and on with examples of benefiting some party and other people are going to basically lose something. I think we have to be aware of those compromises and those trade-offs, I guess, to get the best solution. I guess, personally speaking, I like to maintain the character of the town without basically spending an awful lot of money to achieve that. And therefore, you have to have some development come in and have people build houses and so forth to keep the tax base down, et cetera. And what about those people, again, who have families who want to raise their kids and keep them here in town? As prices rise, it's more and more difficult for those folks to do. [1:20:24] Speaker C (unidentified): I think that's why we're all sitting here. I think, I mean, when I joined this committee, however many years ago, we were in the middle of writing the, revising the comp plan, and there was a town, not survey, but for lack of a better word, survey, and some event down at the Nonantum where townspeople came and sort of spoke. They wrote things on sticky notes and table conferences, and I think there was actually a town survey, and the majority of the people said, keep our town green. Keep as much of it green as we can. Let's minimize development. Obviously, development, to a certain degree, has to happen. Otherwise, we'd still be in the Stone Age. That's what keeps a town alive, but I think our goal as a group is to control that development the best we can, the speed of it and the look of it, while respecting different regions of the town's desires and needs and impact on school systems and water systems and storm systems. And to try to maintain the look and feel of our town while it's developing. Thing so sort of trying to preempt, get things in place before somebody comes in and says, hey, I'm gonna do this, and we don't have an ordinance for it, and then this obviously is very specific to what the state is mandating that we do, so I think our goal with this is to say, okay, yes, state, we've done what you asked, but we're doing it in such a way that will minimize the impact of density, expensive density, high-end density, itself, and high-end density. So, I think we'd all be okay with the minimum density that this would allow, especially if it can go towards our workforce, our cops, our firemen, our teachers, our small shop owners, our little farm owners, whatever. [1:23:19] Speaker D (unidentified): Makes sense. Yeah. The comp plan, right? I mean, that's what we put together, and that's what decides, and that's our road map, and then the voters tell us whether we did a good job or not, you know, come every warrant, so fortunately they voted for the comp plan, so, and that was based on a lot of visioning sessions and surveys and questionnaires and all types of different outreach opportunities during and COVID and after COVID to get that written. And we wouldn't have put in what is being proposed, otherwise we would have done it as part of that. So now we have new rules to follow that impact our comp plan. The only saving grace I think out of any of this is that it actually makes our comp plan worth 12 years now versus 10. I think that was one positive change. change so we had until 20 actually until 2034 right before we have to put a new one in place any other discussion on this piece before we move the other so we can talk a little about a historical district well that yeah that's the other we got to wait for the other piece I don't [1:24:38] Speaker C (unidentified): hear anything else. Okay, I'll turn it over to you, Liz. That's my other is where do we stand with the historic district? I do not. Ann and I were talking just between ourselves and we don't want that this topic to just fade and we personally feel that there actually should be whatever we want to call it a design review committee that overlooks the historic district design that consists of people who live there. Maybe not everybody, maybe if there's seven people, maybe five of them live in the historic district. Maybe hopefully one's an architect, one's a designer, who knows? But I think if you had a chance to open that article that I forwarded from the New York Times about Saratoga Springs, they've done a good job of preserving their historic district and it's ended up being an attraction. So, not that we want to attract more people here, but let's keep that piece of an already very old town with beautiful historic homes as an attraction, because it already is. That's a lot of what people come here for, is just that look and feel. So where do we stand with that? What happened to us? [1:26:26] Speaker F (unidentified): I can give you all an update so I'm forgetting which date you last reviewed it but you last reviewed it at some point in September. It might have been your first September meeting but I don't fully remember but somewhere during the month of September it was last in this committee and has gone to the Board of Selectmen for their review a couple of times or I've at least let them know where you are in the process a couple of times earlier this fall. The last time the select board reviewed it was in the select board second September meeting which I think was the 24th of September when the select board last reviewed the ordinance as it stands. They asked for the planning board to be able to review the ordinance and to have some sort of discussion around the provisions of the ordinance. I may be putting some words in this left board's mouth but my understanding of that was mostly because the ordinance was directed towards the planning board that the planning board would be that body that would Be reviewing the ordinance so the intent was that they at least have the ability to see what was proposed and be able to understand how that review may take place. The planning board had a lot of things on their agenda in October. And the intent was to try to have a workshop after a meeting, and that just was not able to happen. And so they had a workshop last week after they had a smaller site walk meeting. And there was some relatively good discussion both in that meeting and then previously through written comments that were shared with the intent of having a workshop during one of their regular meetings in October all of those comments are condensed into a memo that is going to be before the select board on Thursday's meeting and much of the planning board's comments were related just to how they would actually review guidelines within the district. So it was either allowing them to feel more confident about making a defensible decision, whether that meant more clarity around the performance standards around what would actually be part of a findings of fact for them or provisions which this committee hadn't even really discussed which was the ability to have peer review or outside review from architect or a historic preservationist or other folks which I think if push came to shove we would have been able to find provisions in the land use Ordinance to allow them to do that but they were hoping to kind of button it up. And similar to the reviews that they do for non-historic things, that they were looking for standards that would make them feel much more confident if they had to make a determination. And so I think it was actually a very productive conversation. And the select board will hear parts of that on their meeting on Thursday as well. Two things. [1:29:55] Speaker C (unidentified): Is it, would it be feasible to pull up and show up there what we actually submitted to them because I don't recall and oh that is that neat what you said they were needing like architectural input or whatever in my mind would be a reason to have a design review committee yeah I think we have to go back [1:30:27] Speaker A (unidentified): To I think we got to let this play out because we the packet the plan the packet is out for the select board meeting and then so I was able to read Ben's summary from that so the select board is gonna have to talk Ben's gonna have to present the select boards going to talk about some of the points that they made without having that discussion what the other board members I would say when i read it they're looking for more specific and i'll listen to ben on thursday but when i just read the language and the memo it seems like they need more specificity versus you know the look and feel which then that's that gets us to a level and i know in other discussions that we've had with select board members you know there's that's going to we have to think through and talk through that because there's many the implications so you know I think we gotta let this play out this week if I [1:31:29] Speaker B (unidentified): could just add there's a so spending time having a look at Saratoga Springs and their work on design review which was interesting very familiar to the Kennebunkport scenario, but they had a great sentence in there as defining what a design review committee would be doing, and it's, a review process exists to review proposed changes to buildings within the districts. The goal of the process is to protect the architectural character of the historic district's buildings while allowing owners the flexibility to adapt the structures to changing needs. And I thought that was one of the best written sentences I'd seen for a design review committee. Because it's funny, we restored a 1773 farmhouse. And we tried to do it as if it was still 1773. So it's the sort of thing you do once in your life and you never do it again. But you have great sympathy for people who have an older home and they realize that there are more and more means to accomplish what would look like a 1773 farmhouse with modern materials or some flexibility. Because it would be unfair to say to somebody that chimney issue is going to cost you $75,000 and say, well, you are held to doing that because it's in the historic district. I mean, to me, that doesn't seem flexible. And so, however, saying to somebody who has a design, you know, let me take a step back. When we had people come expressing concern about what we were doing within the historic district and feelings, though, they didn't know anything about it. They didn't know any of this discussion had been going on, and they wanted to be further involved. I just saw such a committee, and even if it's under the planning board, such a committee would give people an opportunity to participate in a community that is interested in the historic design of Kennebunkport and promoting that through a committee such as, let's just say, if it is the planning board that would have such a committee aspect. That would mean that you've included people within their community, within their town, and you'll have somebody, I'm sure, there who would talk about, well, you know, there's different designs of roof slates. There's different, you know, the idea of a chimney, instead of it having all of the incredible architecture that can go into a beautiful chimney, there's a reality that 's really you don't want to put people in a position where they're paying $75,000 to do that. Well remember I mean that is [1:34:38] Speaker A (unidentified): I think Saratoga started at a different point too right so we actually don't stop people from demolishing the buildings so that's not so you have to always remember the playing field or the goal where we're starting from when we roll the dice and so to go to a you know even a Kenny Bunk type approach from where we are right now is would be a shell shock to people that some people that live in that so I think it's the question of how much can we do you know how much can we achieve without trying to achieve too much and then basically getting thrown back at us and achieving nothing so that's why we tried to do the look and feel and I was simplifying it in my head like to me I gotta wait for Ben to talk us through what he heard from the planning board and you know other than what was written the more context behind it but to me if you're sitting in the planning board and you see a house that's in front of you that has a New England type look and feel versus sheer glass front, I'm pretty sure you could say, yeah, that has the New England look and feel and the sheer glass front, no, not so much, you know. To me, I think at that level, you know, would be a good point to be able to stop, is the wrong word to be able to maintain you know the value and the look and feel of the court that we're trying to maintain so I understand what you and Liz are saying about the committee that's more to me of the how versus we're having trouble with the I mean look at how much how much we spent with Ben and Nadia and about just the language right and I think you know so that's why you're gonna at Thursday's Meeting we'll hear from the rest of the select board and stuff, but you guys did a great attempt, all that work to get something that would achieve a look and feel. The planning board gave us back some feedback. We've got to now let that play out, hear that word from the planning board, because why we went to the planning board is because they are the implementers, regardless if we came up with another committee at the end. And a type of group of residents that look through that lens will be those people. And so we needed to hear from them if they could implement or what their thoughts were. So it would be good for you guys to either come to Thursday's meeting or listen to Thursday's meeting to that section so you could hear more about what Ben and you could hear the select board conversation, because then you should be able to call in or stand up and also say, hey, I'm on the growth planning committee and this is what I think. So it's good. This is the conversation that has to keep going because then we'll eventually find the there. When and where is it? It's Thursday here. We're here. Great. It's like a four-day time. It starts at five for executive session, but then six would be a good time to show up. There's a lot of things on the agenda, so you can actually look at the agenda and then pick your, roughly, if it's midway through. I can't remember where it was on the agenda. [1:38:05] Speaker F (unidentified): It's around midway. The agendas are posted up on town website and actually with the select board, because their packets are usually much more dense than most boards or committees, you can actually click on the individual item and be able to get into it. So if you go into the packet part of agendas and meeting agendas in the minutes on the website and go to packets, if you are interested to see the memo that is created for that or for anything else on the board's agenda, that's the [1:38:38] Speaker D (unidentified): easiest way to do it. Did I forget, did we vote on what we were finally sending off for review? You did, thank you. I guess the only other piece I would put in there as I, from what I see anyways, from a priority standpoint, is this, because we need this by July [1:39:05] Speaker F (unidentified): right, July one. I'll, I'll give you everything, I'll give you all firm dates next week, but theoretically we would need to finalize things for the warrant ideally by the second December meeting and there may be some wiggle room for a early January meeting, but I'm going to confirm that with our town clerk when she's back. She's out of the office right now, kind [1:39:38] Speaker D (unidentified): of wiggle through until February ish beginning of March there's a little bit [1:39:42] Speaker A (unidentified): of soft wiggle room in March is when we hit legal reviews so you would have had a band through a board vote so we have less time than I was even thinking yes [1:39:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, you have less time. So we've got, like, three meetings to wrap this up. [1:39:59] Speaker F (unidentified): I'll come with a proposal, and I'll make sure to send that to you, Dan, first, but I'll share a proposed schedule for the next couple of weeks, next week. [1:40:08] Speaker D (unidentified): So really, I think we need to focus on getting these knocked off how we feel it's appropriate, right, because that has to be in place. Otherwise, we're not compliant. All right. Then the district can come after, right? [1:40:24] Speaker B (unidentified): that's not well that's an ongoing for me there's no deadline on that and then the first and then [1:40:29] Speaker F (unidentified): the first on the 15th as yeah and so that's a good reminder so even though it feels weird this was the off week so you do meet next week you meet in one week here in this building per usual and so that'll be november 17th at six would be your next meeting and I think we're still in other business I will send this out as an email to you all and I just confirmed this earlier well yesterday but earlier this week there is a consultant who's working with the main office of community affairs as that department for the state works on doing some rulemaking and some best practice provisions for the growth management law and comprehensive planning. There is a consultant who is working for that department who would like to speak to members of the growth planning committee specifically who were engaged with the comprehensive plan when we adopted it earlier this decade, but theoretically it's open to any GPC member. member. She will be here between 4 and she'll be leaving right before your meeting starts at 6 on Tuesday next week, which is the 17th. It is a one-on-one process. It is not part of your committee, the GPC's committee as a whole, but it would be members who were part of the comprehensive planning process or others if you want to talk with her to talk one-on-one and share really anything. So good and bad of how the comprehensive planning process worked and what you wished you would have known. And the intent is to take that and put it in a best practice report that would be shared with communities across the state. They identified us for a couple of reasons. But one of them was when we adopted the comp plan earlier in the decade. We had a very large visioning process, which was alluded to earlier in conversations, and we had a relatively deep process, even if it was elongated by the pandemic. And a lot of that was done kind of in a more cohesive and larger manner than other communities our size. So they're really looking to see what we, as a population size of less than 5,000, could have better done or had more knowledge of or had more support from the state of as comprehensive planning processes shift and change from the state. So again, it's a one-on-one meeting. It is not part of your GPC meeting as a whole, but I wanted to share that with the committee. [1:43:29] Speaker D (unidentified): So you mean one by one? She only wants to talk to one person at a time, or she's happy to speak [1:43:33] Speaker F (unidentified): with four of you at a time? Is just doing that. I believe she would speak with a couple of you at a time. Okay, but it will not be a growth planning committee meeting. So no, that's fine. Many of you are here in the same building. You are here as a individual capacity to talk about the comprehensive [1:43:48] Speaker A (unidentified): plan. Yeah, okay, there's no meeting. Yeah, that's fine. No offense, but could you, somebody mention that it shouldn't have been so long? Could somebody mention that we shouldn't have had the plan so long? Yeah, pages, page count should have been [1:44:14] Speaker F (unidentified): so where's that here? That'll be this right here in this building, right between four and six, is what she's gonna be. Perfect. Thank [1:44:24] Speaker B (unidentified): You, Nadia. Thank You. Been really nice work. All right, so we'll take a motion. So move their second. [1:44:33] Speaker D (unidentified): So I'm adjourned. All in favor. All right, thank you.