Old Orchard Beach ZBA Denies Staircase Variance, Approves Home Rebuild
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. Public hearing of the Orchard Beach Zoning Board of Appeals this 26th day of October 2026 is called to order at 6.30 p.m. Rick, would you call the roll? Here. Here. This is a public hearing, and unless the board specifically votes to go into executive session, you have the right to hear everything that is being said and to look at all the exhibits that are offered if you decide to do so. the board will work from a prepared and advertised agenda the meeting will adjourn at 11 p.m or as soon as the current issue at that time is resolved i want to stress that at each incident the burden of proof is upon the applicant and the board's task is to judge the marriage of each appeal appeals from the adverse version and the superior court within 45 days of this board's decision We'll stand for the Pledge of Allegiance to the prior. Okay, the appeals will proceed as follows. We will hear the testimony of the appellant with questions from the board members through the chair. We will hear anyone speaking for the appellant. Be sure to state your name and address for the records. We will hear anyone speaking against the appellant. Again, be sure to state your name and address. Any written documentation from the board would then be read into the records the chair will review the full justifications of variance and review administrative appeals would each member of the board having an opportunity to comment on them the chair will close the public portion of the appeal and ask the motion to approve or deny the variance miscellaneous appeal or administrative appeal the roll call will then be called if approval is given you must record it in a registry of deeds within 90 days or your decision is null and void. Okay. Item one. Miscellaneous appeal non-conforming means of egress, applicant's signal reduction, and a rear setback from the required 20 to a proposed zero. Appeal with a law of construction of a landing and stairs to remain. Scott and Denise, please.
[2:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Hello. I have, I guess I'm appealing to put a staircase in behind my house. In fact, I've already built a staircase. It is on elephant feet with four by four posts. It's pressure treated because the right of way between my house and my neighbor's house is not big enough to get granite back there. I was told if it's It's a free standing unit, you have a better chance of getting it approved. The only reason it's there is for egress, in case of a fire, to get out of the house. All I have is one door, the front door. Although I've got plenty of windows that are all egress windows, to be honest.
[4:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Can you show us something? Is this where you're having the steps? Can I approach?
[4:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Hello, I, [Speaker A (unidentified): right now, coming] in here is this? Yeah, that's where I was.
[4:30] Speaker C (unidentified): Alright, so this is the deck that you're doing, or this is the whole deck here?
[4:35] Speaker B (unidentified): This is the house. Okay, that's the house. I have front stairs here, and this is my dining room, and this is my neighbor's fence.
[4:51] Speaker C (unidentified): So you're just asking for the variance?
[4:54] Speaker B (unidentified): No, I'm asking for a variance for these stairs. Those
[5:06] Speaker D (unidentified): stairs are already there? Yeah. What size are they?
[5:11] Speaker E (unidentified): What's the size
[5:12] Speaker B (unidentified): of the existing landing? The size of the landing? 30 inches as I walk out the door. 30 inches to the fence. Well, less. It's about 32 inches to the fence. I left a little bit of space. With this way, I think it's 36. six with three descending stairs. I've got photos if you want to see them. That'd be great. I think this
[6:58] Speaker D (unidentified): was a new construction, right? You just built this recently? I'm sorry? This is a recent construction, right? You just built this?
[7:05] Speaker B (unidentified): I didn't build it. I hired someone to build it.
[7:07] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, what was there at the final inspection? [Speaker B (unidentified): Their final what?] When they inspected the structure, when you finished the construction, your contractor finished the construction, was this there? Was this landing built or was it still happening?
[7:21] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, when my contractor finished the, no, there was nothing there. There was, to get a temporary C of O, I had to have a blockade blocking the back door, which I had a piece of a van tech a sheet of a van tech blocking the bed screwed to the structure the house so I could open the back door but I couldn't go out and I went to town code off office and talked to mr. Haskell about options which I had really none other than what you see there and he didn't
[8:01] Speaker A (unidentified): say yay or nay I just you know I just gave it a shot no but I submitted
[8:17] Speaker B (unidentified): drawings to the town about what I was going to do I thought it was part of the house i was still working on the building permit i thought maybe i'm ignorant about this but i thought i was still working on building the house finishing the house is that what was going on and
[8:46] Speaker A (unidentified): why you had that thought process
[8:51] Speaker C (unidentified): so my understanding then is that you're building this house which is part of this as you're building this the reasoning that we're hearing right now and you're building these steps now because you need the ingress door.
[9:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, yeah. It was the final thing to finish to get to C of O. I thought I needed front steps. I needed a rear egress, but maybe I don't need that. Maybe we can just block off the back.
[9:22] Speaker C (unidentified): But he did have a, he did have his building permit for the house and everything else he's been doing, right? Okay.
[9:36] Speaker A (unidentified): So anybody speaking for the apparel line? Is there anybody speaking against the appeal? Come up and state your name.
[9:56] Speaker F (unidentified): My name is Richard Priestley.
[9:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I can hardly hear you.
[10:00] Speaker F (unidentified): My name is Richard Priestley. I live at, I have a cottage at 54 Saco Ave. I'm an immediate abutter to this. Before I go any further, I'd like to say I have no ill will towards squandering his life. I had the pleasure of having his two daughters live next to me for a number of years. years, which I believe have been fantastic people. Okay, very polite, very respectful. I have nothing but good things to say about K.E. and Jess. They were fantastic neighbors. But that being said, since this whole job has started, I have had nothing but headaches. Right up until today, and yesterday, and last week. Scott, I was never notified of anything on this property. I was never notified about the house being built. Never notified about the house being 35 feet in the air. I was never notified about anything. I was notified after the old house collapsed,, because they tried putting a second floor on the house. No engineers were involved, nothing. They just put a second floor up. And one day, boom, it came down. So the city of Old Orchard asked them and told them, you had to have the desk down and put in pillars, concrete pillars in the ground. Turned around, just locked in. Put the pillars in. The pillars not on his property. The pillars are not on his property. Not. The pillars, because Scott called me and told me, hey, my contractor made a little mistake and we're off by four or five inches with the pillars. And the pillars are in the easement between my house and his house. But the week before this, Scott called me and said, I think we have a problem. I Your garage is on my property, and it is. I came down to City of Old Orchard and I asked, we looked. In between time, I had a fence going from where I thought, and everyone thought the property was because the fence was already free up, it was already there, and it went to my garage. I look and the fence is gone, the
[12:37] Speaker C (unidentified): fence is gone. You said the fence is gone?
[12:39] Speaker F (unidentified): Gone, this is before he built the house. Your fence is gone. My fence, okay, which was there, and it went to my garage. I asked, oh, he goes, oh, my bad. That was it. You're a real estate agent, right? Are you a real estate agent? Okay. No,, no, it does because, okay, if he's a real estate agent, which he is, one person if he's a real estate agent which he is he has never licensed if he has a license that means he has had to go to school or learn the laws and so on one of the laws i don't know but one of the laws i would think would learn about property lines what you can do what you can't do okay on property lines take it down someone's fence i don't think it's legal i'm I'm not sure. I'm not a real estate agent. I'm just somebody who owns a piece of property. That was the beginning. The beginning of the nightmare. Then they put the Taj Mahal in. You come around the corner from the police station, coming down the hill, the first thing you see is this house. When he put this three-floor house up, he stole every inch of my privacy in my backyard. He has plenty of windows. I can't do anything in my backyard without him seeing it. I have no privacy. You have privacy. Everyone has privacy in their backyard. I don't. Okay. He's, I can go, this night is not long enough. Okay. I have a couple of pictures here. Probably about 50 or 60. Okay. Here's one picture if you'd like to see it. Okay. He hired a surveyor to survey the property. That's how we know there's an easement between his garage, my garage and his house. These are his surveyor's markings, and it shows a property line. Okay. This orange thing right here is the easement. There's a 17-inch easement for the property line, 17 inches this way, 17 inches this way. Okay. That's my corner of my garage. As you can see, it's at least an inch, maybe two inches. Mm-hmm. Yeah. The total
[16:13] Speaker D (unidentified): state, which is the property line.
[16:17] Speaker F (unidentified): This orange state. And that one right there, too. That is his side of the easement.
[16:22] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, and this is your side. Right.
[16:24] Speaker F (unidentified): My side, as you can see, is about two inches from the garage.
[16:28] Speaker A (unidentified): I can see this block is over the easement.
[16:31] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, you haven't seen nothing yet. You're going ahead of schedule. Okay? I can show you. Right here, it looks like, see that little corner right there? That's his house. Okay. Okay? As you can see, it looks right here about two or three inches into the easement. It's actually a signature. So he likes that. He asks for forgiveness. It's not bad for him. Five feet on the front. Grandfathers. Boston. Okay. And so on. Beautiful driveway, isn't it? Okay. Beautiful driveway. See the palace? Yeah. It's an easement.
[22:06] Speaker A (unidentified): let me ask you is your property surveyed yeah or is it only the easement
[23:32] Speaker F (unidentified): After doing all of that, you'd think my headaches stopped there. They just started. I came up here about a month and a half ago, two months ago, drove up, and I went to go park in my driveway. Couldn't. Scott was having friends over. Everybody parked in front of my driveway. Couldn't get my own driveway. Okay. Didn't say nothing. I just parked on the side street. Next day, you know, do something. Yeah, I'll do something. Nothing was done. I have pictures in here just last week I came home go in my driveway I can't get there I was parking in my driveway I wanted to get out to get out and get some stuff at the grocery store I couldn't leave because the truck is blocking me in want some pictures I got pictures okay no problem okay you think it stops there though I went down to get a curb cut from it to make my driveway, I don't know, I had a 12-foot entrance, to make it bigger because what they do now, as I've explained it, is when my driveway is here, they start their cars parked right there on the edge of my driveway. So now I have to make a curb like this, back up, and go in straight. I can't just pull in like anywhere else. All the stuff I've done to be a nice neighbor, it's just I'm getting more and more harassed. You would think I showed you your driveways on my property, he might turn around and say, hey, he can stop at all. All he has to do is tell his friends and everyone, don't park in front of his driveway. Park down the street. Don't do this, don't do that. No. Because that means God doesn't do something. I can go on and on. I mean, I got pictures of the back deck that he's talking about, with the easement, stakes and all this other stuff. My neighbor, okay, I don't know if I should say this, it's up to yourself, just tell me when you want. Single mother, works in Old Orchard, has a beautiful daughter. Money's tight for all of us. She pays, I don't know, what, three, four hundred dollars? Three twenty-five. Three twenty-five to a fence company to come out and fix her fence so her dogs can't get out. Scott put up his back deck, his back little thing he's trying to get permission for. He didn't just put it there, he pushed her fence, and I have pictures of it, pushed her fence, popped the fence out. Now she has to pay another three or four hundred dollars to fix the thing she just paid a month ago to fix. If you go by Scott's boundaries, the stakes I just showed you, if you go by those, that yellow stake, which is the property corner, her fence is six inches beyond that. So this back porch is six inches beyond the stake for the property.
[27:17] Speaker C (unidentified): me i'm trying to understand the deck that's being that's built right now is there anyone's issue that's on anyone else's property except for scott's property [Speaker F (unidentified): just hers that's] what we're talking about right now and that's her fence right there okay but the steps and that deck is still on his property right now this is the property line right here yeah so that's that's the case what he's asking As we can see, property line, his steps, line, his line, so he's within his property. This is what we have to go off of? Right,
[29:57] Speaker A (unidentified): the stakes are here. It's not the property line. The stakes are there. Okay, so he is on the other person's property. I don't know why the black line is further. See where the pin is? Look, the black line is further. Those are the pins. Well, why is the pin there?
[30:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, probably off the property line.
[31:02] Speaker D (unidentified): I would encourage you to keep a conversation about just the application alone. If you have issues with the fence or them removing your fence, you've got to follow a legal process for that.
[31:16] Speaker F (unidentified): you give if he gets permission for this deck back deck then that puts a pinpoint he gets occupancy permit and this whole thing is stopped okay and now we have to hire attorneys and now it turns legal if we just have him all he has to do is say listen whatever we can do let's work it out let's work it out like gentlemen no problem i'm all game for that 's why i haven't taken
[31:40] Speaker D (unidentified): the chop saw to his driveway but this board is only overseeing this application and the contents of this application not nothing about parking nothing about the driveway even if we approve or deny the application those things will still need to be addressed this is what i'm saying okay
[31:53] Speaker F (unidentified): that driveway okay i've asked him six months ago four to six months ago nicely and nothing's ever been said talked about he never came over and said hey rick what are we going to do about this
[32:04] Speaker C (unidentified): i have a suggestion here yeah when we do this we're going to look at what's in front of us right now and i understand exactly what you're saying and maybe what you and scott should do is have a talk about your concerns of those other things sure okay and i think that's a great place to start i can see and i can see you're willing to do that i'm pretty well as scott's willing to listen to you as well and you guys can sit down and look at that but as of right now i'm going to just we look at what's here and we're going to rule on this little thing and i do you understand all your concerns you have?
[32:42] Speaker F (unidentified): I'd be more than happy to sell Scott and his wife. As gentlemen, we have to live next to each other. We have to live, and it's easier to live with each other knowing that we can talk things out and get things taken care of, than it is to turn around and I'll up one you, I'll up one you, I'm gonna hire an attorney, I'll hire two attorneys, I'll hire four. No, I don't want that. I'm moving up here to relax and be tired. This is the last thing I wanna do is take one of my village i mean i had nothing but nothing but great neighbors putting a house up there you want your house retired yeah excuse me i mean it's time to move on now so we're going to close this portion well okay like i said that's the feeling but i would i would just really i
[33:42] Speaker C (unidentified): would really like to you can speak you need to come up to the pull him and state your name and your address gentlemen
[33:54] Speaker G (unidentified): lady i'm elizabeth michaud 58 sacco ave i have bought their property congratulations over your marriage this weekend i don't have any problem with you guys i don't care what you do your set of stairs in the back property that wasn't approved to begin with the original set of plans that you put forth to the town and was approved with a certain set i have a problem with the fact that the set of stairs that they shoved in is touching my fence the way that it is i had just knocked on your door two weeks prior to this set of stairs being put in there and asked for permission to enter your property because i was hiring leo menard to go in and reinforce the two posts so that the fence was secure they have a dog i have a dog he has a dog i wanted to make sure that my fence was secure Sure. No problem. Sure. Leo and his guys didn't have to go on their property. He reinforced it from my side without entering their property. Paid him 300 some odd dollars to do that. Two weeks later, they shoved this set of stairs in there, disrupting the fence post that we had just reinforced. I thought it was awful rude. I mean, I bought this house in 2022, as he said. single mom I was dang proud never did I think I have to look at property lines the fence was there I've spoken to since the previous owner that I bought the place from and asked them about the fence and they said when they bought the fence that fence was there they had replaced the fence but they kept it in the same exact spot so this fence has been there for decades whether that piece of paper says that it's on my property their property I don't have I did not hire my own surveyor to do that, so I can't provide you with anything like that. I just think the whole thing is really strange that a person goes to the town and gets a set of prints approved to build a certain footprint, building structure, and then after the fact, they go ahead and change it on their own will without getting permission, thereby putting in an egress in the back that wasn't there originally, thereby needing a set of stairs. I just think some people get to do whatever they want and repercussions are null and so good for them. I don't really know what I'm asking for. I just think that it's wild and I figured I'd come up and say hello.
[36:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anybody else speaking against the appellate? Okay. I got a few questions myself here today. It shows here on the pictures that he showed us, and you're claiming zero on the side, which is right against the fence. So I'm skeptical as to your plans here, because you get no dimensions on your plan how far you are from the fence to begin with. I don't see anything here from there to the fence. Says here, rear yard four feet, proposed zero. and the picture he showed us, you're right against the fence. Now it looks like a brand new fence, so it's in your paperwork. The picture he showed me, your deck in the back is right against the fence, okay? And yours shows here, your rear yard four feet and you're proposing zero. But you don't have any markings here and you don't show four feet from the rear here or anything, you just show throw a little set of stairs there.
[38:07] Speaker C (unidentified): So I would. You can see, yeah, come to the podium. Come up to the podium and we gotta get it on record.
[38:15] Speaker B (unidentified): The picture I took of the set of stairs, you can see on the left side, the fence side, there's about two inches from the treads to the fence, which continues right up to the deck. I'm
[38:31] Speaker C (unidentified): seeing that it's written on the fence. Yeah. right here you're right against you're right against that fence all right so that's you can
[38:50] Speaker A (unidentified): stand back yeah and i'm a skeptic about people building things without permits i mean they could
[38:57] Speaker C (unidentified): have been you need to come up to the and they set your name and address yeah i'm jim ashley i'm
[39:05] Speaker H (unidentified): on 2b street up here off adelaide i'm a friend of elizabeth's i've been over there i was just curious i'm a property owner as well is there a ordinance or a rule for is there a buffer like from your property line to your neighbor's property you know what i mean i mean you can build right to the edge that doesn't seem right well if it's a mean of egress if it's a necessity mean of egress they can't go right to the property line okay and i just didn't know if that was an issue here that was part of the you know because that one when she first showed me i said this is crazy you know why would you how can you build right next to someone's fence i mean it's just you know even the place where the house is i don't know what the rules are but it just seems very close to a adjacent property but yeah that was that i just wanted to check that 's non
[40:15] Speaker A (unidentified): -conforming means of egress the request to stay away a ramp in the minimum structure dimensionally as required by a ton of orchard beach building code the stairway egress from the back of the house was designed to be the least evasive to the space and to all surrounding properties it is completely freestanding structure supported by temporary concrete footage and i also disagree it would due to physical features a lot and the location of structures on the lot it would not be practical to construct a proposed stairway a ramp and conformance with applicable space and bulk requirements it will be impractical if not impossible to build the stairs with granite the structure is the most minimally invasive structure i could build as a means of regress from the house backside i agree sam i disagree and i also disagree and i have a motion
[41:17] Speaker C (unidentified): i'd like to set a motion for denial for item one tax map 206 block 11 block 2 zone 6 b2
[41:27] Speaker D (unidentified): I'LL SECOND THE MOTION.
[41:31] Speaker F (unidentified): WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO DENY VARIANCE APPLICATION. I AGREE.
[41:51] Speaker A (unidentified): ITEM TWO, YOUR APPEAL HAS BEEN DENIED. I'M SORRY? YOUR APPEAL HAS BEEN DENIED.
[42:10] Speaker F (unidentified): SO THE STAIRS AND JUST THE BARRIER AGAINST THE DOORS? THEY'LL HAVE TO COME OUT, YEAH. YES. YES.
[42:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Miscellaneous appeal, applicant seeking reduction of front setback and quiet 15 to a proposed 11 and a half appeal would allow the construction of a single family home after structure demolished, Glenn A. Fairchild.
[42:54] Speaker E (unidentified): Hello, I'm Glenn Fairchild, I own 216 East Grand Avenue and we demolished a cottage July 11th of 25 that was on the property. And we're looking to rebuild in the same dimensions. And we're asking for a variance because it's only presently 10 feet off of East Grant. We went through various drawings with Owen Haskell and speaking with Mike Foster and Rick over the last 18 months or so 17 months we did several designs to try and get it as far as high elevated as we could and as far from the hat line and also the wetlands as we could so you'll see the various drawings with the final drawing be in our proposed final position for the new home
[44:48] Speaker D (unidentified): yeah we went through
[44:57] Speaker E (unidentified): various alternatives and in five and Mike suggested that I put this in there that we were thinking all right if we eliminate the need for a variance at all and get go 15 feet off of these grand where would that put the position relative to the wetlands the Hat Park and everything else that it was determined it's just pushing too close to the wetlands to come 15 feet off of
[45:25] Speaker D (unidentified): these grand the front
[45:57] Speaker E (unidentified): of the new house would be actually in flood zone X it
[46:03] Speaker C (unidentified): would be out of the flood zone entirely the front of the house is going to little river road or
[46:07] Speaker E (unidentified): east grand it's on east grand the front of the house yeah and my property goes all the way over to little river road so it's on the corner so
[46:25] Speaker C (unidentified): the which one are you proposing with
[46:29] Speaker E (unidentified): exhibit which exhibit is exhibit six final proposed okay so exhibit five is essentially Exhibit 5 was something we previously discussed and had drawn up just to see an alternative but it really didn't accomplish the environmental goals.
[47:00] Speaker C (unidentified): So you said it's the same footprint but you need this variance because of the...
[47:06] Speaker E (unidentified): It's not 15 feet from East Grant.
[47:19] Speaker C (unidentified): 15 from Little River Road.
[47:21] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, we're moving it over to be 15 feet from that side. Any
[47:47] Speaker A (unidentified): more questions from the board? okay we'll go through the criteria anybody speaking for the appellant anybody speaking against the appeal okay we'll go through the criteria you may sit down the existing buildings or structures on the lot for which the limited reduction are yard size limited expansion a lot coverage is requested we erected prior to date of adoption of this provision or the lot is a vacant a non-conforming lot of record the cottage that was removed on july 11 2025 was constructed approximately 100 years ago prior to coney current zoning provisions and the original use as a two-story cottage stan i agree ethan i agree and i also agree the requested reduction is reasonably necessary for the owner or occupant of the property to use and enjoy the property in essentially the same manner as other similar properties are utilized in the zoning district the reduction is necessary to allow the owner to rebuild a small single family home in the same dimensions as the original cottage 22 by 18 in a location which is further from the wetlands and highest astronomical tide mark that the removed cottage in a new home will have to flood zone reclassification as 7 17 24 from the aoe which is lesser risk of following the water and have a greater area in the flood zone ethan i agree stan i agree and i also agree due to the physical features of the law and the location of existing structures on the water would not be practical to construct the proposed expansion enlargement or new structure in conformance with the currently applicable yard size the lot coverage requirements if i rebuilt a new single family home 15 feet off west grand avenue it would bring the new home closer to the wetlands and hat mark and further out into the flood zone at the subject and the code enforcement director rick hassel and associate town planner michael fist faster we made four survey changes to mitigate the wetlands impact and minimize the setbacks from these points while not creating additional non-conformities see exhibit for the impacts and affection allows me not expansion of the principal building or structure on existing uses the name who will not be substantially different from a greater than the impacts and effects of a building or structure which component the I size requirement the new single-family home will not impact the neighborhood adversely or as it will conform with the outside requirements height of all the rvd zoning requirements and it will be located further on east grand avenue than your regional cottage and further from other wetlands and the hat lot ethan i agree i agree and i also agree and i have a motion a
[51:01] Speaker C (unidentified): motion to approve Tax map 201, block 2, block 3, zone RBD, item 2, for approval.
[51:13] Speaker D (unidentified): I second the motion. Great. Does it take a vote?
[51:24] Speaker A (unidentified): I agree. I agree. I agree. You should be able to pick that up sometime at the end of the week. Do I have a motion to adjourn?
[51:48] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm open to adjourn.
[51:50] Speaker C (unidentified): I second the motion.
[52:22] Speaker I (unidentified): Rain is nowhere to be found even though we could use it over here because of the statewide drought conditions. So your futurecast showing nothing but sunny skies throughout the day on Tuesday. If you want to head out and maybe do those fall festivities, pumpkin patches, whatever it is you have in mind, gorgeous weather to do so. We'll keep dry conditions and cool and comfortable temperatures. Overnight will be another cold night as we start off Wednesday morning. We could see maybe a few clouds moving through, especially for areas northward, but another dry day as high pressure keeps us dry and that extremely dry air mass. Really not able to squeeze out anything in terms of rain. Here's a look at the forecast highs over the next five days. We are on the cooler side with below average temperatures for Tuesday and Wednesday looking at highs only in the lower 50s as we head towards the end of the week will be watching our next cold front arrive on Friday and that's going to bring some slightly warmer temperatures ahead of that. So notice we are bouncing back up into the 60s for Thursday and Friday. That is above average for this time of year. Mid 60s for Thursday. a little bit higher on Friday. That cold front moves through and that will bring another batch of colder air so will drop back down into the mid 50s so a little bit of a roller coaster here with those temperatures. Rain staying.