← Back to MaineScanner

Eliot Budget Committee Reviews Investment Portfolio and Discusses Future Budgeting

2026-11-05 · 1h 3m · Source: Budget Committee Meeting (Town of Eliot (Town Hall Streams))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Hi, Kathleen. Good evening. Can you hear me? [0:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, she can't because, okay. Okay. Mr. Chair, everyone should turn on their microphones. And use them is the latest. Okay. See, can you hear me better? Yes. Yeah. In stereo. So that seems to be something that is helping with the hearing. [0:34] Speaker C (unidentified): problem. Excellent. High five. All right, let's start. This is the Elliott Budget Committee meeting. Today is Thursday, November the 5th, 2026. We're doing it today because next Wednesday, our normal meeting time is Veterans Day, and that's a day off for the country. So let's get started. I passed out a revised agenda. We have a, we've got four members here: Dan, Shannon, myself, and Brad. Jim is tied up in a business engagement meeting. Heather is ill, and Diane, I believe, is also under the weather. So we do have a quorum. Any conflicts of interest? No, good. Let's quickly review our minutes from last meeting, the October 14th meeting. I had one update I wanted to make, and it was on line 43, where it says the unassigned fund balance reached approximately $4.6 million, and the projected balance before the proposed carryovers was $5,488,962. [2:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, thank you. Okay. [2:12] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. It's a different number. I mean, we have a number that included the carryovers, but I think for the purpose of this sentence, let's just say before, because that will be the audited number once the audit is done. [Speaker D (unidentified): Any] other changes or updates? I [2:38] Speaker E (unidentified): would motion we accept the minutes as corrected, as amended. [2:43] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, Brad? Aye. Shannon? Yes. Dan? Aye. [Speaker C (unidentified): Gene? Yes.] Passes four to zero. [2:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you, everyone. Okay. Let's get into the main event here. We're very fortunate to have our guest speaker, Brian Jamrose, who is with Bartholomew & Company. You are our investment advisor to the town. And this was going to be one of my questions, and maybe I'll ask it right off the top to frame what you're going to present, which is the town has approximately 13 million dollars in reserves in total. If you add all the numbers, what portion of that do we turn over to you to manage for us? Go right ahead. And there's an on-off switch with that microphone as well. I think it's on. Okay. [3:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Good evening. And if I could, for some logistics. Kathleen, in the background, if you could upload your, for the people, I think there's one person that's at home, right? Correct? Still at home? [4:07] Speaker C (unidentified): He hasn't dialed in yet. [4:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, but we'll get it prepared anyways. Anyways, Kathleen, if you could put up the updated 930 report as well while I answer these questions, that would be great. Okay, so good evening. My name is Brian Jamros, and Kathleen Sikanovich is with me. [4:25] Speaker C (unidentified): Hi, Kathleen. Thank you for joining us. [4:29] Speaker A (unidentified): She would have been up here in person live, but she had some home things to deal with unexpectedly. I get it, yes. So we appreciate her being here. So first of all, to answer your question through the chair, Jean, as of 9.30, which is when we did the report through, was a little over 7 million, 7,022,857.41. And I'll give you the numbers through 10.30. Let me just log in. Sorry. Password protected here. I have. 10.31, Kathleen. Yeah. [5:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Through 10.31, it's actually on your screen right now. It's a little bit higher. 7.18 million great [5:16] Speaker D (unidentified): and [5:21] Speaker A (unidentified): We've been working with the town gosh now let's see since goes back a little way since December of 2022. Very good and this portfolio so we'll is there [5:39] Speaker C (unidentified): any other questions you had before we begin no go right ahead okay I have a couple but I think I don't think you're gonna answer in the course of your presentation. [5:46] Speaker A (unidentified): So just a little over 7 million. And I'm gonna hand out a copy for you here as well. But if you could go. Excuse me. The stereo is great, isn't it? Put on some music. The building is beautiful, by the way. I haven't been up here in a bit, so thank you for inviting us back. The handouts I gave you are, all the numbers are 100% accurate. We're going through kind of a transition right now, and so the reporting is going to look differently next time. The transition is 18 months ago, LPL purchased Commonwealth Financial Network. Bartholomew and Company did not get purchased. We're still independent. We're an independent investment firm, but our behind-the-scenes backroom office got purchased. That happened 18 months ago, and it's actually being executed November 13th. Next week, next Friday. Yeah, it's November, Friday the 13th, but don't worry about that. The funny thing is they made the announcement on April 1st. Even better. But anyways, somebody has a good sense of humor. So with that said, the handouts that you have now are through 930. Kathleen has 1031 numbers. Which would be your preference that you want us to review, the 1031 or 930? I didn't have the handout available electronically, you know, a week ago when you want this sent over to you, because today is the first day we have this available. So I can show you the 1031 numbers or keep it to the 930. [7:26] Speaker C (unidentified): I think this is fine. Okay. You know, this is big picture stuff, unless there's some craziness in the last 30 days. [7:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, it's been a positive mark in the last 30 days. The last two days have been crazy, but that's besides the point. So we can, Kathleen has it on the screen for those that are viewing from home, 730 as well. That goes along with your report. The only difference is the benchmarks are slightly different here on your report and paper. The benchmarks that Kathleen have are accurate. Okay. I apologize for that. We'll send that copy over to you. Actually, we already sent that copy over to you through Gene. He can distribute that accordingly. So this is in your handout. So let's go through this if we could. And let me just pull it up because I can't really see that far away. Okay, so the first, the first screen here you have, actually let me just pull it up. So come on, let's see. Okay, page two, you'll see this, the sand chart. Kathleen always comments for those that are colorblind, this isn't the best chart, so I apologize if you were in that case. But this basically shows you that you have a 30-70 portfolio. It's pretty much been like that for most of the time, you know, in the early stages it was we were understanding the cash flows and squaring up the books. I know the town manager and the treasurer's office was trying to scrub the books because it wasn't as organized as it is today. So they cleaned that up, and so we had, we added more equity as we came along. So now it's a 30-70 portfolio. Next screen, Kathleen. Sorry, that feedback. Okay, so this next screen here. Yeah, okay, thank you. All right, Brian. No, that's okay, that's okay. It's funny, my glasses, it's hard to see that, but I'm gonna kind of look at my Computer here, so total contributions to this account on the top left of page three. You're going to see the town has contributed 5.8 million towards this account, okay. This is since inception, the account opened on 12/8 of 22, and if you can see here, you have had zero withdrawals out of this account, and the ending balance as of 10/31, 1031, is 7,000,180, oh, actually, excuse me, I'm on 1031, ah, shoot. Do me a favor, Kathleen, if you could take over, because I have to pull that up, go through that screen for me, okay? That's the 7114 number. I have the 1031 pulled up, I apologize, give me a minute, so here we go, I have it, okay, let me just get to there. These new progressives are great, but I still can't see over there. I love being 50, right, 53, but don't tell anybody my age, I know we're on TV, okay, here we go. So total contributions through 930, which is means the town has put in this amount of money, you haven't taken any withdrawals, you just pretty much set it and forget it and invested it quite frankly, and the total gain after fees with an ending balance of 7 million 22 857 41, the total gain after fees was 1.2 million, that's an annualized return of 5.17. This is very conservatively invested, 30 70 portfolio, you know, remember we've been in a well since 22, really the rates started taking off at the end of 22 and they've been decreasing, so you know, you long term this is actually right where you want it, 's actually a little higher long-term expected rate of return, but you have a 30-70 portfolio which is great, very conservative The brown line below the right side, I'm sorry, the right side there. We'll show you the fiscal year review. It's only three months into it, 7-1 through 9-30. Markets were a little turbulent with the war, interest rates going up. So the time-weighted return is a negative 128, primarily due to the bond market. Federal Reserve raised the rates during that time, and so some of your prices on the bonds when lost a little value, but you hold those, you hold those inside the mutual fund until maturity and it goes [12:15] Speaker C (unidentified): back up, so we're good, so with a 70-30 portfolio mix we're exposed to this [12:22] Speaker A (unidentified): increase in interest rates, so yeah, 30, so and yeah, so 30% is in equity, right, and 70% is in the fixed income. So the nice thing is you're exposed in which way, Gene, if you could define what you're thinking about when you say exposed. [12:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I say exposed to the extent that, you know, big picture, theoretically interest rates are independent of what your stock market's going to do, whereas we're in a different 70% of it are in the, you know, fixed income side. Sure. And those are to me more readily impacted when you've got a bond market that's fluctuating like [13:01] Speaker A (unidentified): This has been. Yeah, Kathleen, why don't you answer the bond market? I know you love bonds so much. [13:07] Speaker F (unidentified): I know that's because no one seems to care about bonds, so I actually, I think the question's great. Yeah, so you know, to Brian's point, when you're looking at this negative return, it is pretty much entirely, on the bond side. So you are exposed. What I will say, just for a little more maybe detail is, the bonds you have in here as a basket, their, duration. So they're essentially, they're kind of their average life is a little under four years. So I mentioned that because, you know, you have some really short-term bonds, you have some longer-term bonds, but on average they're maturing in about, you know, a little under four years. So exactly, so I would say you are exposed in the short term when these things happen, they can be volatile, but in the longer term the good news is, you know, we're able to or the, you know, portfolios are able to reinvest in higher rates. Will they stay high? Who knows? The last Fed meeting they kept rates steady. We'll See what they continue to do, but to kind of over answer the question, definitely exposed kind of to the negative. What I will say is October through October this number is positive, if that's, you know, any good news, things kind of took a turn in October again with keeping rates steady, so that negative is actually a positive through October. So in the short run, yes, some volatility on the interest rate side. But long run, you know, it should actually be fairly good when you are so invested in bonds. [14:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I think you answered my question, which really is you're buying and holding these bonds. Bonds. So the impact of day-to-day changes in the interest rates are moot because you're saying you're going to keep these bonds until they mature, is what I'm hearing. Absolutely correct. And then we're going to reinvest it at the higher rates. Yes. So the risk impact is minimal because you're conservatively managing and holding these bonds. Absolutely. And we have a very good [15:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Relationship with your treasurer and your town manager to communicate with us cash needs ahead of time. That's the biggest thing with the 342 municipal clients that we deal with. We make sure we ingrain in them to communicate your cash flow needs at any market, quite frankly, especially in a market like 22 when interest rates went from 0% to near 5%. But in any market, we just train them. That's the number one thing we tell our treasurers and finance teams, if you will communicate with us cash needs as soon as you know, because there's things that are on the short term, even though Kathleen said the short duration, I mean the duration of the overall basket or the portfolio was four, we have something shorter and something's longer [16:09] Speaker C (unidentified): so we can manage that accordingly, right? But you mentioned cash flow, we're going to have Mike and Kristen in at our next meeting and I was going to ask her that question specifically [16:21] Speaker A (unidentified): about her cash flow. Yeah, they communicate with us ahead of time when they do know about it. Right now there's room for that even if they don't know their cat, like if it's an emergency or something comes up, you know, we can always plan for that as well. This is still a 30 70 portfolio and you know, we're not very, you know, we're not overly concerned about cash flow needs, but there's, there's margin for that in the portfolio. Yeah, makes sense. It does. Any other questions before we move on? No, I'm good. Okay, excellent. Just interrupt along the way, we don't mind. Not interrupt, interject, it's not an interruption. Okay,. So the next, let's see, where are we? So you're on the screen, right? Okay, that's good, we can go to the screen. So your portfolio, these numbers are page four of seven. Your portfolio year to date, as you can see, the top line there is 2.02. The one year number is a 12 trailing month number and the three year average is based on a data point through 930, so it's the last three months from 930 backwards and the average return on that is 6.44. Now, Kathleen, can you go over, oh yeah, so they still just put, we still just have benchmarks of the, these aren't necessarily benchmarks per se, but they're just points. Can you talk through the benchmarks on that for us, please? [17:49] Speaker F (unidentified): like the reference points more so yeah it's just some comparison there's actually more on the next page that okay go to the next page then yeah just because you do have the stock market in here which you do have 30 percent ah perfect thank you yeah so i think this is if you can see my screen, hopefully. Yeah, so this portfolio's return is obviously that first column, and then you have very plain vanilla one- to three-year bonds. I will say your portfolio is a little longer, like I said, more like four years on average, but we have that in here as a comparison. And we also have, if you skip a couple lines, one to five year. So that's a comparison to in terms of that bond portion. But jumping back to consumer price index, inflation, obviously. So that's really the, you know, one of the number one things we try to think about, obviously, is keeping the purchasing power of these funds. And as we all know, inflation has been very high. But since inception, you know, CPI on average has been about 3%. This portfolio has been up about 5.17. So good in that regard. And then that next one over, that's the Bloomberg one to three month treasury bills. That's kind of our money market proxy or cash or, you know, a bank account, which has been pretty high these past few years. And so if this had been, you know, really sitting in a bank account since then, it would have made 4.65%. So you've outperformed that. What I will say historically, right, cash or a bank is the rate is much lower than 4.65%. We've just been in this unique environment where obviously rates have been higher since 2022 here. And then you have the Dow Jones. So kind of how this is invested, you know, all domestic stocks, but again just giving you those, obviously it's funny we say or I always say that double digit returns aren't normal, but that's kind of all we've had in the past few years, and even if this went further back you would see double digit returns. And so this year in 2026 has been a little more normal. You know, the Dow is up about 7%. After today, I'm not sure. Today was sort of a bloodbath. But, you know, that's day to day. These are long term funds. But that's giving you an idea of what the stock market is. And then the last one isn't relevant for you, but this is international stock performance. [20:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Now, if we could, while we're here on this page. Thanks, Kathleen. The portfolio return you can see here, a very moderate portfolio, 30-70. I try to say to those that don't know, it's like driving in a car. A car goes from zero to 100, how fast do you want to go? Right now you're going 30 miles an hour. These are longer-term funds, although there was a lot of discussion and settlement of the funds as we took these funds over back in 22. The books, like I said, weren't as clean as they are today, so there was some reorganization. So that's why we bumped up the equity exposure back, what was that, two years ago, Kathleen, [21:19] Speaker F (unidentified): or is that now three can you check so we did it we did it over time so I think when we initially talked our goal was to kind of get to 30 in equity but we it took we took it kind of slowly because we didn't want to make a market timing risk so it took all that to say it took a couple of years just to get it there that was what we kind of agreed on with the treasurer [21:48] Speaker A (unidentified): And what was the timeline? When was it finally up the 30-70 portfolio, Kathleen? What time point was that? If you could check that while I go over the rest, that would be great, if you can. [21:58] Speaker F (unidentified): I'll have to stop sharing my screen. Oh, then don't worry. Don't worry about it. We'll do that in a bit. [22:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so your portfolio return right here, just looking at your portfolio from a calendar year perspective. I know you're on fiscal year, but I'm just showing you this number. So if you're in the private world, you'll tend to look at these numbers. so you can see the last several years you know this year because of the bond market's down 202 don't get overly concerned about that because of the bond pricing is what we already talked about but in 25 you saw a 7.89 percent return the 24 5.22 and in 23 5.76 if i would have had a guess i think it was closer to the end of 24 is when we switched over to this is all on page five too just so you know in case you're not there that's kind of one is my best guess if memory serves me correctly That's when we did it. I think it's eight of this presentation, the presentation. Yeah, sorry about that. Yeah, make sure that you guys have that corrected version. Actually, I already sent it to Gene and it is on the screen. If you take a look at the screen, that is correct. We'll have new reporting next time and it will not happen, promise. Okay, let's go to the, let's see the holdings if you will. These are all the holdings on, let's, let me give you the page. It's on your sheet, so back to your sheet. Let's see. That would have been on page nine, so if you go to page eight, let me go back to that page eight with the numbers I was just going over from a calendar year perspective. Page eight on your handout, out that's where you can look on your portfolio under portfolio return. You can see that first year was a negative number because rates were going up so high so quick. We inherited a lot of bonds at the time and we shifted and we took that over time and we re-transitioned the portfolio. The next couple of into 23, but you can see there the 5.76 in 23, 5.22 and 24, and 25 was the 789, and then this year is low at the 202, but it's only through 930. That number is a little under what is it, under five percent now, four point, if you can give me the number through 1031 Kathleen, that'd be great. Yeah, or us the number that page, it's 4.3, so 4.3. So you can see it shifts quite a bit on that, and primarily because of the bonds on there as well. Any questions on that? I don't want to go too quick. No? Okay. The next page, nine, you're going to see all the holdings. Kathleen, you want to talk a little bit about the portfolio structure on here? It's practice? [25:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Monday? No. Monday night practice? Or is it a fire? That's the fire department over there. [25:07] Speaker G (unidentified): It is practice because there were a lot of guys there before. [25:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, it's not the building fire alarm. Fire station. Fire station. [25:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Fire station fire. Reminds me of a kid when we used to have the fire alarm go off and it was always Monday night fire drills. [25:22] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes. This is not drill. Do you have the horn or do you have a siren? [25:26] Speaker A (unidentified): I think it's a siren. We had a horn. [25:27] Speaker B (unidentified): We do the drills on Monday. Yeah. So this is. This is a real fire. [25:32] Speaker G (unidentified): But they were out in the parking lot doing something. So that was my question. [25:38] Speaker A (unidentified): We just need a medic Kathleen. It's super loud in here. Yeah, no problem. I assume you can't hear yourself. [25:44] Speaker E (unidentified): yourself. I'm sort of used to it by now. [25:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you guys hear or do you want to wait? Wait a minute. I'm not a rush. It does remind me of fire drills. I was a volunteer firefighter at 18 years old. I thought it was super cool because you could do a, you could get a red, a red light for your car up until I went to my first real accident that includes a death. So this isn't for me. It was not cool anymore. So I like, I gave that up. It wasn't an, I don't even like blood. So I pass out when I see blood on my hands. [26:22] Speaker B (unidentified): You can hear it all over town. You can hear it in my house. [26:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I can hear it. And [26:32] Speaker C (unidentified): if the wind is right, you can hear it. [26:35] Speaker E (unidentified): I can hear it in my house. I'm three miles away. [26:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, remember, this was before pagers and phones and alerts. This is what they did. [26:44] Speaker E (unidentified): First time I heard that, though, when I moved here, it almost came out of my skin. [27:05] Speaker A (unidentified): How many times does it go off? 12. It must have been 12, right? I think it depends too, doesn't it? Well, everybody knows now. Oh, yeah. That's right. Okay. So, Kathleen, if you could please go over some of the holdings and just, you know, some of the reports as well. That would be great. This is page 9 of 10 on your handout. [27:29] Speaker F (unidentified): So, one of the things that we, I guess, maybe should have mentioned in the beginning is we follow an investment policy. So, all of the, and, well, of course, we follow the law. Maybe the law and then the investment policy, right? So there are, you know, limited investment options that we can use as per those, the law and the investment policy. So what you'll see are very efficient, you know, on the domestic equity side, very efficient ETFs, so very inexpensive, following the market at a high level. And then on the bond side, similarly, you know. So ETFs, again, very simple in nature. What I will say is the investment team is in here managing the total amounts of everything. So if you follow the market at all, you probably know that AI and technology companies have really, led the market. And so your second one down there that iShares S&P 500 growth, that's really where all of the AI and technology funds kind of live. And so the investment team, when those are doing really, well, they'll sell some and rebalance the portfolio. So we're always in here, you know, making adjustments from that perspective. But again, just kind of going back to the investment policy, that's really what we're following. And then of course the main loss as well. So pretty, it stays very stable because again, we like to think of this as obviously a very long-term fund. So we don't make, you know, tactical decisions based on elections or geopolitical things. This is very much a long-term viewed portfolio. [29:30] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU, KATHLEEN. SO THIS IS THE BUDGET COMMITTEE. THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT UP. THE IPS IS DESIGNED, YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY LOOKING AT YOUR STATE LAWS AND THEN DESIGNED THROUGH YOUR TREASURER AND THE FINANCE TEAM INCLUDING YOUR TOWN MANAGER. AND THAT'S HINTED TO US AND WE FOLLOW THAT TO A T. WE CAN FOLLOW WITHIN THE MARGINS OR THE MINS AND THE MAXES WITHIN THE TARGETS. THERE'S A TARGET AND THEN THERE'S A MINIMUM and a maximum when we follow these ranges that they provide but as far as the budget meaning you know what could we be helpful for providing you something from a financial perspective for us that we haven't talked about that would be helpful for you or are there any questions that you have [30:14] Speaker G (unidentified): for any of us i do so when you're talking about minimum and maximums can you elaborate on that [30:20] Speaker A (unidentified): sure i don't have the investment policy statement but i can bring it up but there is for example we may have we have equity exposure domestic equity that may be a target at what is it Kathleen target if you could pull that up for or just tell us there [30:36] Speaker F (unidentified): is a little bit different so okay remember it's all domestic okay all [30:41] Speaker A (unidentified): domestic okay thank you can you pull up the IPS the targets and I'll just [30:45] Speaker G (unidentified): explain that yes that'd be great question so you're saying it's all domestic yes because sort of a requirement for a municipality or not necessarily but for kathleen [31:02] Speaker A (unidentified): i'm going to let kathleen know because she dug into the state law and the ips on this particular case i was not involved with that i'm going to like kathleen that's more of the investment team [31:11] Speaker F (unidentified): so i can i can reach out to them too and see but let me pull up the investment policy [31:21] Speaker A (unidentified): A SLIGHT DELAY WITH THE ZOOM, THAT'S ALL. [31:33] Speaker G (unidentified): THAT'S TOO BIG. OR SMALL. [31:44] Speaker F (unidentified): CAN YOU SEE THAT OKAY? YES. OKAY. ALMOST. I CAN'T. YOU CAN? I CAN. WOW. I DON'T KNOW WHY IT'S LIKE 10 PAGES OPEN AT ONCE. [31:55] Speaker C (unidentified): OKAY. THERE WE GO. WHAT ARE WE LOOKING AT? [31:57] Speaker A (unidentified): WHAT'S THE INVESTMENT POLICY STATEMENT? [31:59] Speaker C (unidentified): THAT COMES OUT OF THE TOWN. TO YOU. Okay. [32:04] Speaker A (unidentified): But to answer the mins and max, there's usually a set guideline. Let's just say domestic equity. I'm going to make up numbers. 30%. Okay. We can, the target is 30%, but just keeping it super high level. Target is 30% of domestic equity, but we can go up to 35% because of the market movements. Or we can go as low as 25. depending on how the markets are moving. Yeah, so we and we have that alone, you know, a little unique based on not unique customized to your account and unique to Elliot. [32:44] Speaker D (unidentified): Very good. [32:47] Speaker C (unidentified): So those are the parameters you work within. Correct those. I'm sorry, I didn't mean to. [32:54] Speaker G (unidentified): Cut you off. Yeah, and do you have a copy of that? I mean, I know there must be a copy and there must. It must be, yeah. Would it be in the town ward? [33:02] Speaker C (unidentified): I've not seen that. [33:03] Speaker A (unidentified): No, this wouldn't be through the town ward. This would be internal. [33:07] Speaker C (unidentified): I'll ask Mike for a copy of it. [33:10] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, okay. [33:11] Speaker C (unidentified): It may have been in one of the select board meeting minutes. [33:17] Speaker E (unidentified): I think it would be good for us to have a... [33:18] Speaker C (unidentified): But I think, yeah, that's a wonderful document. I've not seen the complete document. [33:26] Speaker A (unidentified): And that's not abnormal to have a budget committee not have access to that. Not necessarily not to have access, but to not just be provided for. Well, I think. You can ask for it, but that's. [33:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Sort of trying to, you can say it. [33:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Those policies have evolved to concur with everything else our treasurer and town manager were doing to, you know, right size these accounts. Sure. So I think it's just, it's a final copy that we never saw. Absolutely. Because a lot of the items I just looked at were things that had been in discussion. [34:00] Speaker A (unidentified): So do you help? Help me understand, because I don't, you know, do you help with the, like in the state of Massachusetts, where we, the Board of Selectmen, oversee the final draft of the investment policy statement. How does that work with you folks? We're advisory. [34:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Advisory, okay. One of our members who isn't here right now, he's from Massachusetts, Jim Ladder, and he characterized that we are like a finance committee that's elected. [34:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, so I'm on my own finance committee, and that's exactly, I'm advisory only. Yeah. Ironically, Kathleen's husband is the town manager. Oh, interesting. And there's no conflict of interest, I promise. [34:39] Speaker C (unidentified): But the difference could be with what we do is that we exist to advise the legislative body, which are the voters. [34:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I do the same thing on the finance committee. Yeah. [34:53] Speaker E (unidentified): We're just advisors. I just think this information is good for us in general. Oh, of course it is. Yeah, just ask Mike. [34:58] Speaker C (unidentified): He'll give you a copy. I think we never got a final copy because I remember seeing pieces of that in development. [35:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, ask Mike and he'll give that to you, I'm sure. [35:06] Speaker C (unidentified): Now, one question I did have, though, was in the context of how those returns, your returns, show up for the town. I know I went back and looked at our budget for the year. We're in right now. They listed under revenues $420,000 as the estimated returns. Because they call it Interest income, I think is the line item. And I guess I need to ask the town manager how they get to that number as a function of the performance you guys are turning in. But I guess, where do those returns come from, based on the portfolio you've set up? [35:58] Speaker A (unidentified): So it depends, because initially when you spoke, you were talking about, what was it, 13? How much million did the total town have? [Speaker C (unidentified): About 13 million.] 13, I didn't want to misspeak. And we managed a little over seven. So I don't know the breakup of that. So I would check with Mike, and then we can tell you that. I can tell you what, you know, I mean, I can tell you what we actually, do we have it in? Yeah. [36:23] Speaker F (unidentified): So on this, Brian, we do, it does have estimated annual income and it's saying that our estimated annual income is about $233,000. So I'm thinking with that math that Gene was just saying, it might be the total, right, of the $13 million, like that math, I guess, sort of makes it $100,000. [36:45] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes indeed that number is the result or the return on that total. Okay, so you're answering my question for what you guys manage you estimate you've got that portion of it which is about half [37:00] Speaker A (unidentified): of it. Oh yeah. Now Kathleen, that doesn't include what does that include the dividend and interest income correct and that's we're just talking about income. Yeah just income right no growth. No realized gains. Right. Right. We can't we can't give you that number until next year. Correct. Correct. I give you last year's number, but I can't give you next. The future year is coming. So it was last year's. Kathleen, can you from a fiscal year perspective, can I give it to you? Guess what we can do, Kathleen. Can you look at the fiscal year account report? That should give it to us, right? Yes, okay, she's looking that up. And so the performance reporting, which, you know, we're getting ready to get all new performance reporting, which I'm actually looking forward to it because those are the things that we'd like to see on here, which we are, our current provider has not been able to give us. Yes, sir. [38:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Dan, I have a question, Brian, on, working on page nine again. Sure, could you walk us through, just pick a fund on the equity end and just walk us through those numbers and what they mean? And I was also looking for a rate of return at for this year or last year or just over [38:28] Speaker A (unidentified): a five-year period or something like that, a rate of return from a percentage standpoint. Yeah, for [38:34] Speaker D (unidentified): one of the, like this on the top one, yeah, and I'm looking across at those numbers and I, they're [38:41] Speaker A (unidentified): a little bit confusing to me. I'm not sure. I can walk you through that, Kathleen. Do you have [38:47] Speaker F (unidentified): that number by chance? Or yes, so the income, total income or earnings for the past fiscal year was $204,000. And then, so that includes realized gains and losses, obviously. So that's what it would have been. In terms of unrealized gains for the last fiscal year, it was $300,000. [39:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. So we didn't realize the gain, even though there was growth. Yeah. So on the new reporting, we'll have to look for this, but so 204,000 was realized gains and income total, right? But there's another 300 and what, Kathleen, 305 unrealized gains on there. So that is part of in the balance, right, that we haven't rebalanced and taken an advantage, but if we liquidate the entire account, you would have those gains. Yeah, so let me go through this. So let's just start with the top line if we could. So the, it will go right to left if that's okay with everybody. So the top line which is Pro Shares S&P 500 Dividend Fund. The estimated annual income, which is the dividend, is $18,721.16, okay? The original, the next column over, which does not include any growth, the next one over is the principle, $725,114.04 is what was originally put in, invested. Invested. So essentially that was like the cost basis. I want to be accurate on that, Kathleen, because the cost basis, does it get, how does that get readjusted? Can you talk through that please for me? I want to be exact for Dan. The 725 is that the cost basis under principle? There's another [40:52] Speaker F (unidentified): Calculation. Yeah, that's the initial amount, and then any reinvested dividends, that's what's getting you that tax cost. Yeah, obviously it's not 100 tax costs. Thank you. Yeah, so it's the 725 plus [41:08] Speaker A (unidentified): the 18. No, it doesn't matter. No, this report does not give that. Okay, never mind, that's all right. But this is helpful, this is good stuff for when we build that next report. We're going with an Orion reporting system, which will be more robust than this. We have it in bits and pieces. So the estimated tax cost basis, which you're not a, you don't need to worry about that, but that would be the, actually that would be more in line, that would be your principal plus your realized gains, right, Kathleen, your realized gains on that. Nobody's asked me this in a while, so I want to make sure I'm exact. That would be that, and that would be your 767. So that's your cost, your updated cost basis, per se. Right, Kathleen, right there? Yes. Yeah. So 767, 825. The percentage of asset is just a percentage of asset overall for the whole portfolio. The value is the value as of 930 only. It's a snapshot in time. The price only for that date, which is 930, it's the price per share for that particular date, and then you have the quantity of how many you have, and then the symbol. If you wanted to Google that, would tell you more information of the symbol for the, position that you hold. Okay, did that answer that, Dan, a little bit? [42:40] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, that's very helpful, and additionally I was just looking at the comparison. Some of these are doing much better than the other ones. But for example, the growth ETF on the S&P 500 is pretty significantly low. [43:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Kathleen, can you talk about the detail of the principle? Because when we sell portions and we rebalance, what happens to that in the principle? What does that look like? Right, if we rebalance the portion? It's not true. So say that question again, Dan, if you could. Okay. [43:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I was just looking at the next line down, which is the S&P 500 growth ETF, and I just, I just noted that the estimated annual income was significantly low as compared to the rest. Oh, especially. Yeah, and I'm looking now at the calculated cost basis is 375 and principal is 369. That's it, hasn't made it, hasn't done very well, as it appears to me. Oh, that's, oh, I'm sorry. [43:50] Speaker A (unidentified): I misunderstood the question. I'm glad I re-asked it. Okay, but look at the value. Yeah, but look at how much the value is. So this one is designed for growth, not income, right? So take a look at the growth or the value. So your cost basis with the reinvested dividends was 375,361, but the value as of 9/30 is 662,906. So we're giving up the income to get the growth, and I'm okay with that. And that's your 300 and whatever Kathleen said. Sorry, a little foggy tonight. 340 plus, what was it, Kathleen, unrealized gain? If I don't write it down, I can't see it. So I'm going to write it down, 305. Okay, unrealized. [44:30] Speaker D (unidentified): At some point, do you take profits when it gains at a certain level? [44:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Sure. Our team rebalances the portfolio from time to time, depending on at least once a year at a minimum. But Kathleen was on that team. So Kathleen will tell you more when the rebalancing happens and when we take profit on that. [44:50] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, so like Brian said, buy investment policy once a year. But I would say it's been more often than that, just given what's going on in the market. But that's a great example of the fund that's done the best in the near term. Really, all of your domestic equity has done really, well. So they're always in there. We want you as a total, you can see the bold line, the percent of assets, we want that to stay around 30%. So when that starts to, you know, get way off, whether it's in this case, higher than 30%, they'll go in and sell some because what we don't want is for that to grow too high, right? Right. And then let's say we have a day like today where all of the technology companies drop. We don't want you to be overexposed. So they are in there. Yeah, absolutely. To your point, you know, making those trades. [45:45] Speaker C (unidentified): And that's the discipline we pay you for, because I can't do that to my own. But you can do it to the town's money. Less emotional. There's no emotion. Right now, I would think I'm sorry. [46:00] Speaker G (unidentified): Go ahead. I was just thinking I would expect it to be pretty automated at this point. Yeah, it's a certain level that you ding, you're gonna sell this and it almost happens automatically. [46:11] Speaker A (unidentified): At this point, yeah, we still have a lot of, we have automation and we also have a lot of, we still have hands-on. I mean, Kathleen can talk about that on the inside, but it's, yeah, do you want to talk about that, Kathleen? It's both. Yes, yeah, I mean, we're getting, we have a young woman who is in our office who is doing an incredible job with updating reports, utilizing and leveraging, you know, technology, and it's been incredible, pulling in, utilizing AI, and pulling in all this database system to get fresh data all the time, so it's, it's incredible in that regard. You know, we're not, we have to make sure it's 100 accurate before we can present anything to you, so it's not like, hey, we're just putting this on AI and doing it. I don't want any of the public to misunderstand that anything we do has to be in data that might be helpful. It's a tool. Yeah, it's a tool, absolutely. Very sophisticated system allows them to do a lot more research quicker than they've ever had to do before, so, and we just, we just hired a young man out of college with a degree, also helping us with a degree in computer science, and helping us build up and ramp that up as well, more of our technology. Good, so it's great, we're looking forward to all these changes. So any other questions that you guys, or I say guys [47:42] Speaker E (unidentified): generically, but seems to be reflecting what's happening just on my own stuff, so yeah. [47:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, and just remember, you know, we can always, if the goals change of the town through your finance committee, you mean finance department, the treasurer and the finance team, if the goals ever change, we're independent, we, you know, we can change this portfolio to whatever the goals are to and from. We're an independent advisor, we don't make, you know, we don't have any proprietary investments in here. We get paid a management fee and we work for the town. And if the town's goals change or they want to take, you know, now that you're all cleaned up and you want to move forward and take some advance and try to grow this portfolio more, we can do that, or we can keep it as it is, or lower the portfolio, whatever makes most sense for the finance team in the town, of course. [48:35] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I think when you started basically it was a pile of paper, so where the town has come in the three or four years you've been involved and Mike and Kristen, it's light years better than it [48:50] Speaker A (unidentified): was. Yeah, I'd like to take the credit, but it's Mike and Kristen, not us. Yeah, well, it's a team, but [48:56] Speaker C (unidentified): What I'm saying is I recognize personally how far we've come to get to this. Sure, so for any lack of sophistication or whatever. Well, that's not because we've been doing it for 30 years and we've been sleeping on the job. No, this is all new iterations. And we're learning and we're getting better at it. And even the town of Elliott is going through a new ERP implementation that's gonna make us even better with the data we have. And so I see a very positive future. In terms of working with you guys and the returns and you know what Elliot can benefit from because like I say I looked at that number of what we expect in the budget to gain from investment returns 420k that's real money and that's a lot of money that'll offset what may have resulted in tax increases having prepared so people should be aware of how valuable your services are to us and to the town because it's really growing what we've already got and everyone's benefiting from that growth. Well we've appreciated and we enjoyed working with [50:13] Speaker A (unidentified): your team your entire team and it's good to come up here and see the new building as well and you guys done a phenomenal job at and maximize your resources here it's incredible. So thank [50:23] Speaker C (unidentified): you well we appreciate your time and certainly if there's I guess if there's any other questions we have we've got your email address let us know. Good to see you all. Great to [50:36] Speaker A (unidentified): see you. Happy Thanksgiving. I can't believe I'm saying that but it's three weeks. Thank you very [50:41] Speaker C (unidentified): much too for joining us and your work behind the scenes of course. Yeah thank you. We want a couple more things for people who are. Yeah I was going to ask did you bring a couple prominent male [50:54] Speaker A (unidentified): The ones up to or with better likely than what we just presented or what you just wanted. [51:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Those will be fine. That is correct. Yes. No, these are fine. [51:06] Speaker A (unidentified): These are fine. How many would you like? [51:09] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, I don't think we'll mail one to Diane. [51:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, there's three missing, and we should get one for Diane. [51:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, we should mail it to her. [51:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Maybe four. I have four. I have five. Yeah. [51:23] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll take five. I'll take them. Good to see you. Thank you. Nice to meet you, Dan. [51:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Have I met you before, too? [51:32] Speaker E (unidentified): Were you here a couple of years? [51:33] Speaker G (unidentified): A couple of years. Nice to see you. [51:37] Speaker A (unidentified): I know you. I've been here for 25 years. [51:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you for coming in. [51:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Stop by my office next time you're in the building. Wow. After Halloween. [52:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, there's no public comment, we have no public, anybody on the Zoom? Nope, okay. BC member input and correspondence. I had two things I just wanted to bring up briefly. One is for good or bad the beach road sidewalk proposition did not pass. Say like air we'll we'll see some time again I hope in some other way. Anyway, the second thing is that the November 12th Select Board meeting is going to include a presentation from the directors of MainSpring, Emily and Megan. The presentation, I believe they're going to do, I saw this past summer, and it blew me away as to the success those two women have created from nothing years ago. It's just incredible, the number of people they've served in this community. It's off the charts and what blew me away was not that they were so successful but so fast they were so successful that the numbers I saw 18 months of their existence like 10,000 encounters with clients incredible numbers so it's just a wonderful story and again the work they do is just first class. And I think a lot of people benefit from it. So anyway, I bring that up. It's next Thursday. Just if you have the ability to come or dial it up on Zoom, it'll be worth hearing because we do have a hand in influencing. [54:23] Speaker D (unidentified): When is this again? [54:24] Speaker C (unidentified): It's next Thursday at the select board meeting. So here at 530. Okay. Any other input from any of us? Okay. I'm going to bring this up. I don't want to spend a lot of time on it because I really don't wish Jim were here. But on the topic of us developing a long-term budget forecast, I had a chance to look at what Jim had sent us from the town of Beverly. And find it but what I wanted to share from it was the whole fiscal forecast and it was wonderful template for our purpose but I thought what was very valuable was just the table of contents because this was something that Jim was referring to when we were talking about where to start and the city of Beverly's report is actually very simple in the way it's laid out and I think it's a template that's something we could mimic basically the financial forecast in this report is simply revenues and expenses forecasted out five years. The meat in it are all the assumptions that get built into what those numbers are. And so when I went through what the town of Beverly did, it's almost as if the numbers are the highlight, but it's all those assumptions that go along with those numbers that really is the meat of the report, which made me really think that 's the work. It is figuring out or pie-in-the-sky-ing all the factors that would influence what our future expenses would look like. And that, you know, that's the challenge. That's the work. So I'm going to take an action item, and I didn't have a chance to do it before this meeting, but to lay some of these details out to the town manager and get some input from him as to how we should start with this, how we can begin to create this initial template, which, as I mentioned, I look at what the city of Beverly did. It's simply total estimated revenues, total estimated expenses, and they just trended out five years from the present as a place to start. But it's the assumptions that's the work. As I read this report, that's where all the detail is. Okay, well, if anybody has any thoughts on this, as you think of these things in your spare time, I would appreciate it. But I'll have the action item to go over this template this format for a budget forecast for our town and hopefully develop something between meetings with him and then the finance director. Any other thoughts? Okay, if there's nothing else, next meeting is December 9. Our next meeting is next is next month on Wednesday, December the 9th, where Mike and Kristen McNulty, our finance director, will basically kick off the budget for next year. It's that time of year again. Thanksgiving is three weeks away. [58:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Three weeks from today? [58:58] Speaker C (unidentified): I can smell the turkey on the barbecue. [Speaker E (unidentified): You okay?] Anything else? Thank you. We're [59:11] Speaker B (unidentified): good. Motion to adjourn. Thank you very much, everybody. [59:36] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm glad we could meet. We had a phone, my son just sent me a text that the Atlantic Grill is going to be permanently closing for people who over in Rye. Yeah, brothers seek a new tenant, so the restaurant, the Labrie family will permanently close the Atlantic Grill restaurant and bar. Oh no, brothers seek a new tenant. So every time I was, we were there, that's all, every time I go in there it's busy. Yeah, Atlanta Grill and Rye, it's always busy. Yeah, my neighbor is great, very Atlanta-esque, my neighbor down the street is a manager there, so yeah, it's too bad.