Eliot Planning Board Reviews Minutes and Discusses Lot Line Adjustment Request
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[2:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Recording in progress there.
[3:00] Speaker B (unidentified): She is okay hello.
[3:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Everyone I don't hear you guys.
[3:30] Speaker D (unidentified): Christina can Karina I'm sorry can you hear us wow that's loud I heard that okay there we go okay so the microphones are on.
[3:43] Chair: Pretty much well they're not quite adjusted right but Don are you comfortable to start you have a quorum and I'm yes okay so for the record I have 6 0 4 p.m this is the November 10 2026 meeting of the Elliott Planning Board we have a quorum tonight with three members present in-house and one member remote on Zoom at this point in time if you please join me in a Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag United States of America into the Republic for which it stands one nation under God.
[4:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Indivisible with liberty and justice for all put.
[4:46] Chair: That aside okay I.
[4:56] Speaker F (unidentified): Am looking for where.
[5:01] Chair: To go I had notes on it yeah okay we'll just go with those to start with for this eve. [Speaker G (unidentified): That's.] A different setup okay so to start up for the evening I see there's somebody here present we typically offer a 10 minute input session for any item that's not on the agenda this evening if you have something you wish to discuss with the board that's not on the agenda please come forward hi that little microphone in front of you has a button on the front of it that says push see your microphone right on the table you see there's a button that says push on the top of it if you push that and now. That microphone is on so oh now you put it off.
[6:07] Speaker B (unidentified): I would give them the overview and see and see if you can get some direction from them okay.
[6:12] Public commenter: My name is Shane Hutchings back in March of this year I bought a parcel of land on River Road for content it was a subdivision by Alan Gerson you guys had approved that subdivision it was [address] HR engineer and approved it on 529 it was approved by the planning board on June 2024. As you may recall each law is over 3.6 acres which is well in excess of the two acre minimum required the area proposed adjustments provided sorry I skipped ahead so now there's three lots 688 696 and 704. I'm building a house on one of them on 688 the other two lots we have a module home that's gone on one of the lots the other lot has a foundation we're waiting for that module to be delivered when I set up this project laid out the land I had a friend come with his engineering equipment and we laid out the properties and we put all the foundations like 21 to 22 feet away from each other. Thought it was going to be fine, thought it was going to be great. Fast forward about seven months, and I'm trying to get a bank loan, so they sent an engineering company out to take a peek at the property, and my roof line is nine inches over the 20-foot setback. The other house, the middle house, that lot line is six inches over the 20 foot step back. So I met with HR engineering, asked them what we could possibly do. They recommended doing a lot line adjustment for the properties. Do the lot line adjustment up for me. I think you guys have a copy of that in front of you there. It's basically two of the lots are losing 200, one lot's losing 206 square feet, the other's losing 315, and one lot's gaining 500. Literally we're talking about, we're talking about inches, right? Because one's nine inches over and one's three inches over. So I'm here tonight to, I was not able to get on the agenda. I've been kind of working on this with Don for the last couple weeks. Trying to get my loan closed. Unfortunately I'm in a place now where I might have to stop the project and I have construction people lined up for the next two or three months. I'm just trying to ascertain the quickest way to have you folks look at this online adjustment. The properties, none of them sold. We're all in agreeance that this is the easiest, is one thing for us all to do is just take a couple inches off each and get approved, that then we go back and have HR engineering finish the plan and That's kind of where I'm at. Okay.
[9:31] Chair: I believe Don told me you were on the agenda for the December 1st meeting. Is that correct?
[9:37] Speaker B (unidentified): Mr. Chairman, what I had discussed was possibly depending on the board's comfort level and you and I were still talking about noticing requirements, so I had mentioned that date to him, but there is no official agenda at this time. It's the pleasure of the board, so
[9:56] Chair: I remember this project very well because I believe our board did. Yes, if there's going to be lot line adjustments, I'll tell you what I do remember about the project. It was a closely clustered septic and water layout out given the shape of the place. I mean, everything was shoved to one side, so
[10:24] Public commenter: And that did play a, that did play a factor in, you know, where we laid things out. So two of the lots have the septics in the front of the house, and one lot has a septic in the back of the house. And we did, you know, we had to make these decisions based on where the well was going to go, where the septum is going to go, based on whether, whatever the setbacks in the engineering plan. So what really has happened to us, there's wetlands in the front and wetlands in the back. The building envelope is just off the wetlands in the front, so we pushed, we wanted to get away from the wetlands, obviously. We pushed the thing back a little further than we should have. And if you look at all three lots, there's a point on all three lots where they kind of narrow down, you know, they come in straight and then they kind of narrow down. And then they go back out. And unfortunately, that's where we had to put the house based on the level and based on the topic. Each step tickets 20 by 60 Mike promo has done those. 1 of the septics is already installed, happens to be the 1 of my house. We're trying to do all the things right. Unfortunately, I, made a mistake. Okay, I'm trying to ascertain the quickest way to.
[11:39] Chair: SO THE ASK THAT YOU WILL HAVE FOR US IS TO ALLOW A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT TO ACCOMMODATE THE REQUIRED SETBACKS, WHICH IN SUBURBAN YOU SHOULD BE WHAT, 20 FEET ON THE SIDELINES. SO THE THING WE, AGAIN, THE THING WE WOULD LOOK AT IS TO SEE HOW THAT, WHAT THAT DOES IN TERMS of impact, in terms of the, you know, if you have space and you're, you're giving space in between the two physical structures, because those are fixed, those are not, physical structures are not moving. So we would need to verify the proper setback is available for the fixed structures, and then as i mentioned to you earlier, we would also want to get into what does that do in terms of the wells and the septic fields, because i do recall that there was one time a plan to put a septic field under their neighbor's driveway, and it was, i'm sorry, so right now all the wells are
[12:45] Speaker A (unidentified): actually in, are they, is that the little blue stamp? Yes, so all the wells actually, and it does not
[12:53] Public commenter: for this, the last 688, it does not show the well on that one. The well is in the back of the house, in the back left-hand corner of the house. So all the wells are in, all the septics are already laid out
[13:10] Speaker D (unidentified): are all okay, but we don't, the septics aren't marked on this. We don't know, are they, are they on the front, the
[13:19] Public commenter: 688 and 696, the septics are in the front, yeah, and then 704, the septic is in the back, right? I can, I can get these fixed. The septic, all the septic tanks are already in the ground and on the field. Okay. I did have Mike come out, and Mike and I walked it, and I'm clearly not the expert, so he looked at everything that we had going on, and he seemed to think that the simplest thing was a lot line adjustments.
[14:00] Chair: You have given the planner a full-scale drawing, like a C-size drawing?
[14:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Mr. Chairman, he brought some information with him this evening, and I had indicated that you would discuss this tonight and determine if you could put it on a future agenda. I don't believe he's anticipating a decision. I haven't reviewed the full-size plan, and he, I believe, has brought copies for you.
[14:24] Chair: I'm just looking to make sure we have the full-size plan that is legible so that we can look at the detail.
[14:31] Speaker B (unidentified): One is being submitted this evening. Okay.
[14:35] Chair: Okay, so I sense the appeal for urgency on this, and I think what we can do, and I'll defer to my board colleagues as well, is to take in the information that you have supplied this evening. The town planner will receive the full-size copy so that the architect's ruler can go on to it so we can verify all the dimensions on the plan, and then from that the planner usually makes recommendations to the planning board in terms of her observations of the plan set, what's, you know, perhaps something that needs to be addressed or other things that, you know, meet current standards and ordinance, and clearly the three big things are the setbacks, the location of the well, and location of the septic. Those are the things we're going to look at, and so next meeting is the 17th, which is, we have, I think, a pretty full agenda on that already, don't we, and therefore that's why we had discussed, when I say we, the planner and I had discussed today, next available, and I appreciate it, I understand
[16:02] Public commenter: this is, this is my problem that I'm dealing with, and I'm just in a bad spot, yeah, and that's why
[16:08] Chair: well, that's, but we're helping you by compressing the schedule because this is, I appreciate that, 's a quick turn, and so I think the more information we have up front and if it's the plans are clear and it all makes sense, it's going to make the whole process go more smoothly and quickly, because obviously we don't want to have any needs to come back and visit again later to get more information, so any thoughts from my colleagues
[16:45] Speaker D (unidentified): Are we going to have a picture that shows what's been adjusted?
[16:52] Public commenter: That is the adjusted lot line. It's so low.
[16:58] Speaker D (unidentified): That it doesn't even show up on something this small?
[17:01] Chair: Yes, ma'am. Is that what you're saying? That's why we wanted to look at it. That's why we wanted a big one. Okay.
[17:06] Public commenter: I got it. It is literally, you know, to the scale.
[17:10] Speaker D (unidentified): It's invisible because of the scale of this, essentially. Okay.
[17:13] Public commenter: It is.001 is what it is when you read it as.001.
[17:20] Speaker G (unidentified): I see. So what day are we looking for?
[17:28] Chair: The planner and I discussed having this on the December 1st meeting, which there's one meeting in between, which is the 17th, because we moved that because of the holiday. And we're already booked on the 17th.
[17:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. So the first would be fine.
[17:47] Chair: December 1st.
[17:49] Speaker B (unidentified): What I would like to suggest is that the applicant have the final plan and that you would be in a position to sign the plan that evening so he can record it. It actually has to be physically signed for the registry to take it. So an amended approved plan that evening is possible.
[18:04] Chair: You have to rescind the prior plan in order to replace it with the new one. Registry deeds. But that's the easy part. Smart. He's interested in the approval, but we're interested in also doing our due diligence
[18:17] Public commenter: to make sure. I've made a mistake and that's why I'm here. No worries. My object is not to make a second mistake. That's why I hired Atarn. They did the original plan. He's the second person who's come out. The bank who sent somebody out to do it, they were, they said we were like four feet over, so they weren't even close. So it's like, that's why I went back to AHR because they're, they've been there for a while. Okay,.
[18:48] Chair: So I believe the planner will receive your information. We will share that. We will review it prior to our December 1st meeting. If we have any questions or thoughts or comments that require your attention, we'll come back to you promptly. Otherwise, plan on December 1st as the meeting in which we really do the full review and if everything is to order and there's nothing else to find, we can vote on it that evening and get you sorted.
[19:33] Public commenter: And I'll go sit down with ATAR and I'll update the plans to show exactly what the septics are to show exactly what I know it's a lot more clear on this big one than it is
[19:44] Chair: Right so you understand the three those three fundamentals water septic and setback show those clearly and I think you're sorted thank you so much thank you thank you Mr. Chairman just to
[20:00] Speaker B (unidentified): Clarify then I'm going to put this on the December 1st agenda and hopefully it's going to be actionable and I'll give you a memo to the extent. Yeah okay it sounds like that should be. Yeah that's
[20:12] Chair: the desire. Yes thank you. So for some thank you for some reason I do not have my top sheet with all my notes on it. Okay I apologize for that and it's probably going to pop up somewhere. Okay so that was a 10 minute public input portion of our meeting. No other go right down to the minutes are on here. We have two sets of minutes and an NOD. Do you want to do the easy ones first? Let's do the minutes. I think the NOD is going to be a little more involved so we have a October 6th and then October 20. So starting with October 6th 2026 I'm on the front page one. Are there any comments on this one? All right I'm going to make one comment that is just for you guys to note. This is for our later discussion on the NOD. Line 38, there was an existing metal pier in place. I just want you to remember that when we go to talk about the NOD, there's what's existing is a metal pier. With regard to a possible edit, I'm going to pass on. Okay, so nothing else on page one for me. Anybody else? Line 45. Karini, did you say 145?
[22:05] Speaker C (unidentified): It says on line 45. It just says, Mr. Shiner said that there is now three sets of numbers. But after and the proposed number, and doesn't want to lose sight of what there is now and what's to ask for it, do we want to say, like, and he doesn't want to? I'm not sure if that's a formatting thing, or it just struck me a little weird.
[22:28] Chair: Yeah. I made a notation of that too, but I didn't think it was, I didn't bring it up.
[22:33] Speaker I (unidentified): Do you want me to put it in?
[22:37] Chair: Yeah, because it's actually, and doesn't want to lose sight. Right. And he doesn't want to lose sight. Right. Okay. Thanks, Karina.
[22:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Just reminding you guys I'm here.
[22:53] Chair: I'm helping. Yes, you are. You are helpful indeed. Page two. 2.
[23:01] Speaker D (unidentified): I actually have a request. Yes. So on line 50, I know this is what I said. I know I said and plus and plus and plus. I get that. However, it adds great confusion to the written. So if we could just strike the and plus and plus and plus, and I think the sentence is fine.
[23:27] Chair: Yes. Yeah, that's a style. All right, anything else on page two? Okay, page three.
[23:40] Speaker G (unidentified): I just have a question about all of the red. Are these proposed changes to the sections that were put in red? [Chair: Those are strikethroughs.] Yes, but then there's some, on the required, there's a different.
[23:56] Chair: Like line 118, it's red and there's no strikethrough on that.
[24:01] Speaker G (unidentified): So that's a change, and all the rest are to be eliminated. Is that why they're in red?
[24:07] Speaker B (unidentified): They're proposed amendments, proposed edits. I'm sorry? That was staff's proposed edits.
[24:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, I just want to make sure that's the reason why they're in red.
[24:17] Chair: So if that's the case, I'll look at line 118. There's a period missing after that first red.
[24:24] Speaker J (unidentified): Comment. Yeah, okay, there's a period, so
[24:33] Speaker F (unidentified): if you go to the next line. Okay, pardon me, but section 33
[24:39] Speaker I (unidentified): 101, that's a direct quote. I don't know what happened with the beginning of the beginning
[24:47] Speaker J (unidentified): quote, but that's a direct quote from me. I don't disagree with
[24:51] Chair: the verb, the verbiage. I just say that there should be a period at the end of that before you start the next sentence.
[24:59] Speaker I (unidentified): But shall is... I don't understand why that's changed.
[25:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Was that a staff edit? Can I make a suggestion? You can merely reference that the board discussed 3301 and you don't have to actually put the text in there because the minutes aren't verbatim so you
[25:27] Speaker J (unidentified): could make general reference. Okay, so how would you like me to do this? What do you want me to write? You
[25:39] Speaker B (unidentified): could say the board discussed section 33-101 regarding sketch plan review process, something as simple as that. The
[25:57] Speaker I (unidentified): board discussed section 33-101 as part of the review process
[26:03] Speaker B (unidentified): regarding sketch plan review or sketch plan review process. It just has to be a general reference to the topic that was discussed.
[26:29] Chair: Okay. You said Ellen? Okay. Was there anything else on page 3? Over to the back page, 4. I have nothing. Anybody?
[26:40] Speaker C (unidentified): I just would say that line 141 to 142, it just seems needlessly wordy if we're trying to do a summary. So, like, Mr. Scherner would like the consensus from the planning board to do that and just strike all the do that if it is something we would like to pursue.
[27:05] Chair: Yeah. All right, line 140.
[27:07] Speaker D (unidentified): On the very last page, the very last thing. So what does she want me to do? She is suggesting that in line 141, which the line reads, and would like the consensus from the PB to do that, period. Strike the rest of the paragraph. Is that correct, Karina?
[27:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, just not necessarily the paragraph, but the rest of the sentence, yeah.
[27:36] Speaker D (unidentified): The rest of the sentence. Okay, so you want to keep the PB as an agreement.
[27:40] Speaker C (unidentified): If that is something you would like to pursue after that. Gotcha.
[27:46] Speaker J (unidentified): I just had a question about page 3.
[27:50] Chair: We're back on page 3, Ellen? Okay so okay
[28:03] Speaker I (unidentified): So understand that I have always quoted so I'm having to resume in my brain
[28:19] Chair: Well, I think I think the ask is instead of quoting the ordinance is just to quote the section and say we're referencing that you're it applies to that section, okay.
[28:34] Speaker I (unidentified): So in the 107 chapter 33 three is a whole there's like four different reds and they're all struck out so does that all keep going all
[28:51] Speaker J (unidentified): right so let's look at this that's why because that's half the quote that I had I was just as
[29:02] Speaker I (unidentified): a reference especially as someone 10 years or 20 years from now they know what the change was. That's my reasoning for putting that.
[29:13] Speaker B (unidentified): I have a suggestion and it's based on the summary, the AI summary from the new camera system that we have. We haven't instituted this yet, but Ellen and I talked about this earlier and I've been talking with Kim and Mike about it. So what the summary was from that section was under other business discussion of a butter notices, Don Emerson and reviewed draft ordinance edits relating to public hearing and abutter notice procedures. She proposed striking the word generally from Chapter 33-129 concerning public hearings and discussed changing Chapter 33-132 required notice by USPS first class mail rather than certified mail. The board discussed whether the word generally carried legal significance and noted concerns about the reliability and timing of mail delivery while also observing that mailed notice is only one part of the overall notice process. No action was taken pending additional review. So regarding the sketch plan, so it just, that's how it summarizes. Yeah. And then regarding- Can I have a copy of that? You absolutely can. Regarding the sketch, it just says that language was presented that would make a pre-application or sketch plan optional rather than mandatory in every case. She explained that some projects are small and do not require a separate sketch plan meeting, While early pre-application discussion remains valuable to identify issues before applicants incur full engineering design costs, board members express support for a flexible approach that continues to encourage early consultation while avoiding unnecessary process for minor projects. And I can just give this to, if you feel comfortable that's a good summary, I could just give this to Ellen. Ellen.
[31:00] Speaker I (unidentified): It's your set of minutes, so ultimately you're the boss. I'll just have to start rethinking the way I do things.
[31:09] Chair: So I think the long-term desire is brevity. I understand that. And the essence of this particular paragraph, not that it's particularly long-winded as it sits, it's pretty brief. Sentiment of the board? I mean, I would have no problem incorporating the edits we've already discussed with those strikethroughs, with the added period at the end of the first sentence. That's fine. Do you agree? That's fine. Karina, do you agree? It's fine with me. Okay. Okay, can we do that for this copy? As we've discussed and as struck through and with the period, appreciate
[32:09] Speaker J (unidentified): that. Yeah, I don't have a problem with that.
[32:12] Speaker I (unidentified): I just have to make sure, well, yeah, it's my legal brain kicking in.
[32:17] Chair: Okay, all right. And then we had those final edits that Karina caught on four that would like consensus from the PB to do that period and everything downstream of that is stricken, right? I already did that. Okay, so that completes the October 6, 2026
[32:43] Speaker D (unidentified): edits. Mr. Chair, I make a motion to accept the minutes of October 6, 2026 as amended. Second.
[32:52] Chair: First and second. Second. And a triple. Okay. Karina.
[33:05] Speaker I (unidentified): Karina. Yes. Carmella. Yes. You can, you weren't here, I mean, you can just, yes.
[33:26] Chair: YES. you as a note ellen see your microphone is the closest to that loud speaker in the ceiling and that's what's causing that so a suggestion take it and turn the microphone so it's perhaps more this way and we'll see if it works we'll try it again sometime in the future all right next up on the agenda october 20 26 minutes any comments on the first page none heard any comments on the second page [Speaker A (unidentified): And] then her next comma, a third page. None heard. Fourth page. Fifth page. Sixth page. Yes. Wait a second. Was it the sixth page?
[34:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Sixth page. 273 line? Yes. That's the line I have, too. The
[34:44] Chair: line starts, you, we, off. Oops. You are off. Or you are. You are off. And that's all I had on page six. Okay, page seven.
[35:09] Speaker D (unidentified): Line 298. At the very end of that sentence, you can just include that, not included. That's what? You can just include that rather than included. Oh, yeah.
[35:28] Chair: Okay. Gotcha. Okay, that's page seven. Anything on page eight? Yes. Yes.
[35:41] Speaker D (unidentified): On page 351, I understand the aim to be abbreviated, but I would change not want to not appropriate. So density potentially too high, not appropriate as growth zone. Or another word, not want, just seemed a bit strange to me.
[36:07] Chair: Well, it's not, it
[36:12] Speaker F (unidentified): is not targeted as a growth, that's a better word, that's a better, that's it,
[36:17] Speaker D (unidentified): just needed a better verb, that's all. Not targeted as a growth zone, as a growth zone. Yeah. Okay, thank.
[36:25] Chair: You all right? That's page eight, page nine. None from me, I have nothing there. Okay.
[36:39] Speaker D (unidentified): Mr. Chair, I move that we accept the October 20, 2026 minutes as amended.
[36:55] Chair: First and the second from Carmela.
[37:02] Speaker C (unidentified): All right, Karina? Yes. Carmela? Yes.
[37:07] Speaker I (unidentified): Suzanne? Yes. Paul? Yes. So did you like the way I did the bulleting?
[37:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Concise. Yes. The bulleting is great. Very easy to read.
[37:25] Chair: All right, so let's buckle up for this one.
[37:30] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes. I will not be commenting on this notice of decision, as I was not here and I did not participate in it. Yeah, you can review yourself. Okay.
[37:42] Chair: But as a speaker of the English language with grammatical, anything you see that's grammatical,
[37:50] Speaker F (unidentified): I can do that. Please do anything that is the concept. I can't correct all right so next up is
[37:58] Chair: the planning board notice a decision for PB 26 7 and that I
[38:21] Speaker I (unidentified): actually have to talk to Mike about this because I have a permanent. Okay so
[38:37] Chair: that was started that's yeah the street. The street address is 44 Starboard Cove. You have that up? Okay. Page one, I'm going to make a comment. The TF Moran is requiring a space between TF and Moran. And that also happens further down in the paragraph submitted for September 15th. Other places it's fine. So it may be a search and your place so I made lots of notes on this particular NOD because I didn't like descriptive language that starts in the opening paragraph. In the reason I didn't like the opening language is because we're making a representation about what was there and a replacement and what's happening is that what was there was a metal pier that stood on pads and it was a removable pier system as opposed to what's being installed which is a permanent wooden pier system and they are distinctly different. So it is not a replacement of a fixed timber pier, it is a replacement of a seasonal metal pier system.
[40:28] Speaker I (unidentified): This is a replacement pier replacing something else.
[40:38] Chair: It is a replacement pier of a seasonal metal pier with a permanent wooden pier.
[40:47] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay, so replacement of a
[40:55] Speaker D (unidentified): metal pier?
[40:57] Chair: It's a seasonal metal pier. It seems like a
[41:16] Speaker I (unidentified): title residential fixed number.
[41:26] Chair: I don't know what the title is about.
[41:29] Speaker I (unidentified): It's title. That's what it was named in the documents. I mean, I can remove that.
[41:35] Speaker J (unidentified): I
[41:42] Chair: don't know what the description would be. So
[41:49] Speaker I (unidentified): it's a replacement of a seasonal mill pier with a residential fixed timber pier.
[41:56] Chair: That's what it is, yes. I think the engineering firm adds the word title because their work could happen in an area that has a title influence. Influence, but that has no ordinance or statutory descriptions about that at all.
[42:21] Speaker I (unidentified): So it's, I don't need to put that in any of them, even if they mention it.
[42:30] Chair: The only time we talk about tidal is we talk about it, for example, like the high average tide lines. So we know how high the tide comes. It's not in the ordinance or in terms of a requirement. It's just like location finder.
[42:49] Speaker J (unidentified): that's what I had on page one anybody
[43:00] Chair: else with anything on page one all right page two I am looking at item number S that refers to sheet C -02-RIPRAP. It looks like you use M-dashes on all other locations, but the RIPRAP has a hyphen right next to it. It's a formatting error. It's item number S, which is at the top of the page. You see you started a list of items on the prior page, submitted for September 15th. It carries over to the next page. It is item S. Yes. And it says sheet C-02. [Speaker D (unidentified): Referent B-2.] You use M-dashes and all the others, but you use a hyphen. [Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, I'm sorry.] Did you grab that one?
[44:27] Speaker D (unidentified): Just copy it from the line above. Okay,
[44:46] Chair: that works. Can I take it down the page in the findings of facts section? Yes. ITEM NUMBER FIVE, I HIGHLIGHTED REPLACEMENT BECAUSE IT LOOKS LIKE REPLACEMENT IS IMPLYING IT'S A REPLACEMENT FIXED TIMBER PIER.
[45:17] Speaker I (unidentified): NEW SPEAKER OKAY, A REPLACEMENT OF SEASONAL METAL PIER WITH A RESIDENTIAL. NEW SPEAKER YEP. NEW SPEAKER SO PUT THE LETTER A IN. so
[45:29] Chair: i just want to make sure that we describe it so that it's it's not a replacement fixed timber pier it is we it is replacing the metal here with a permanent timber pier like we discussed on first page president
[45:54] Speaker I (unidentified): well okay so let me go back to what i
[45:59] Speaker D (unidentified): then you have to change the verb
[46:00] Speaker A (unidentified): construct to something else because you can't because then it is you
[46:10] Speaker J (unidentified): can use
[46:17] Speaker I (unidentified): residential if you want we have
[46:29] Chair: two types of peers commercial and residential And in this case, it's residential. Yes. Okay, so. All I'm saying is that replacement title, resident fixed timber pier, to construct a replacement, what existed was the metal pier. So the replacement is the timber pier.
[46:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Can I make a, never mind.
[47:02] Chair: I think, yeah, I think I'm going to let go on that one.
[47:05] Speaker I (unidentified): I think I'm driving you guys crazy. I'm sorry.
[47:08] Chair: I'LL ALSO NOTE ON THE NEXT LINE, THE FIRST CARROT. [Speaker I (unidentified): EXISTING TITLE ACCESS.] EXISTING TITLE ACCESS STRUCTURE IS A 4 BY 44 METAL, SPELL METAL.
[47:26] Speaker J (unidentified): M-E-T-A-L.
[47:28] Speaker D (unidentified): SO THERE'S AN R AT THE BEGINNING OF IT. NO. IT LOOKS LIKE R METAL.
[47:33] Speaker I (unidentified): YEAH, I THINK YOU'RE PROBABLY RIGHT. IT IS.
[47:38] Speaker D (unidentified): Can I make a just to be easier? I think if back up to the number five, the applicant proposes to construct a residential fixed timber pier. I think if you just take out the word title, that's adequate because the very first thing that is there is the existing, which will be completely removed, so it's covered. So does that make sense, Ellen? So for number five where it says the applicant proposes to construct, strike out the word replacement and strike out the word title, and everything else is fine. You don't have to add any language there. Residential fixed timber pier.
[48:26] Speaker I (unidentified): That is. I'm going to take out the metal pier.
[48:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, because you have covered that in the first sub-bullet as being what is there already, and it will be removed. So those two.
[48:41] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay. Yeah, I usually carry that all the way through, but that's okay. I don't have to do that for replacement tailors. Okay, I get it. So we can just ignore the seasonal note, period, right?
[48:58] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. And then I think it is a simpler sentence.
[49:04] Speaker B (unidentified): I like that. Thank you.
[49:06] Speaker A (unidentified): All right,
[49:11] Chair: so that's page two. Can we move on to page three? Anything on page three? All right, I will take you down to item 25, the third carrot. Riprap replacement will occur within a 4 by 70 area along the shore. We corrected that. It's actually a 12 by 80 section. Recall in the, we had the application discussion about how big is it? it? Right. You also say just as a footnote, you also say 12 by 80 up front in the opening paragraph. All right. So that's all that's heard on page three. Anything on page four under the decision paragraph, I'm going to ask for comments from my colleagues talking second sentence insist of a replacement title residential fixed timber pier does that read well for you so
[51:03] Speaker J (unidentified): we just get rid of the title okay and then we have a item down below that's
[51:17] Chair: in red yes yeah
[51:22] Speaker I (unidentified): the there's two and it's the same thing the one that's in the motion is for site plan review this is a shoreland zoning review and the permits expired differently
[51:40] Speaker A (unidentified): that's why i did that i talked with don about it okay this is to call attention to it yeah
[51:47] Speaker I (unidentified): and the only thing is that it's wrong in the motion and I just remove that or replace it with the right information the correct information is still
[52:01] Speaker B (unidentified): applicable because that's what's in the ordinance right and so we do with that summary memo and that doesn't obsolete the other requirement okay so was a
[52:13] Chair: Scrivener's error and then it was orated at the meeting. I'd say that's correct. All right, so let's correct it so that we match the statute, the shoreline permit expiration. Yep, okay. And so
[52:28] Speaker D (unidentified): is what is there for number seven, is that correct or not correct? Number seven is wrong. Okay, got it.
[52:34] Speaker I (unidentified): It's the one below where it says substantial start in one year when
[52:46] Chair: you say below, I'm I'm
[52:48] Speaker G (unidentified): looking at numbers. Okay, thank
[53:00] Speaker I (unidentified): you for clarifying. I think
[53:10] Chair: to the planners point, our motion can only accept what's allowed in the ordinance. We cannot make anything up on our own. Doesn't
[53:32] Speaker D (unidentified): mean we don't try. All
[53:35] Chair: right, so I bet that would complete listen. Oh, Devin is
[53:51] Speaker D (unidentified): there any reason why I did that under the appeal section, the word can is underlined, it's just emphasize to get people's attentions, it doesn't have to be part of my standard then, that's fine. I apparently never caught my attention before, that's all. Thank you. All right, all right, with that said, is there a [Chair: motion?] I move that the planning board approved the notice of decision for PB 26-07 shoreland zoning permit application replacement residential pier gangway and float and repair existing riprap in kind as amended.
[54:42] Chair: A second? Second from Karina. Ellen, would you call the roll? Karina? Yes. Suzanne? Yes. Karmela? I wasn't here. Oh, that's right. You were, yes. You were abstaining. Paul? Yes. It's a dangerous toy. All right. So those are the three items that we had. Other business, I think the planner has a couple of things you'd like to discuss with us.
[55:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, one of them you just received a little bit earlier was regarding the daycare. There was a question about LD 1428, and I had it wrong on the agendas, 1420. So what was left over from prior discussions you had around daycare was that the statute, the statutory change requires that any place that you have residential you allow daycare facilities. The state's trying to open up, remove barriers, and have more daycare available for families. So there's just a change which we need to strike out 16 in that table and just put SPR, site plan review, and that, I believe, meets the requirement.
[56:19] Speaker I (unidentified): So, change is to get rid of
[56:21] Speaker A (unidentified): 16 and put in SPR. That's the proposed change.
[56:27] Speaker I (unidentified): That's the table.
[56:31] Speaker B (unidentified): That's what I handed you earlier.
[56:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you have that there? But that's okay. Oh, yes, I do. Okay.
[56:49] Speaker B (unidentified): So you can, you don't have to do anything with this tonight. I wanted to give it to you. We have it on what I'd, the other thing that I'd like to hand out is a memo that went to the council. I'm sorry, the board of selection. So we had just, we've previously discussed the targeted items that you intend to put on the warrant for June, 2027. And we had come up with a draft, a targeted deadline matrix. The Board of Selectmen, the town manager had asked we provide a list for them. So this is the memo and the table that were the results of those discussions that went to the town manager, and they have this on their agenda, I believe, Thursday night. And so one of the items on this number two is a reference to child care and the change that needs to be made me which is just this one so I don't need you to do anything with it tonight but we do have it on our checklist and here is the language and we can discuss it more when you actually have some time to look at it further.
[58:18] Speaker F (unidentified): This will be the easiest one we've done. I can't believe it's this simple. I have
[58:28] Chair: suspicion because it's too simple.
[58:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I do. So I
[58:51] Speaker B (unidentified): actually, I guess I need to look at this and get back to you but this might be the piece that the tricky thing is that notes note eight regarding home-based businesses oh no we'll be taking out note 16 which is the route to 36 frontage standard so no it so I guess the question for a future discussion is the whole question of commercial uses on route 236 and the parameters around which the area of land can be used for the commercial uses that are allocated that was something that the chair had brought to my attention recently and that's not on our list for this year but it's something to keep in mind as we go through applications and have these discussions in general did that does
[59:46] Chair: that make sense for the benefit of the board the question was if it abuts 236 we have a whole series of footnotes that say, aloud,, aloud. The question is, you could abut Route 236 and also go a mile inland from there. And there's no descriptor in terms of abutting 236, how deep into the lot. And so, in other words, like on the lower end of 236 to go over to Goodwin Road, there are some farms or some properties that go a long way between 236 and Goodwin Road that could connect, in essence become a, what's in the rural zone become allowable commercial by virtue if it's a budding 236 on one side. And I don't think that's the intent. Really? I think the intent was to have businesses on 236, but almost big lots that are deep that go way back and connect out the backside, if you will. The characterization of a lot is very different. So the question was, do we want to address that by thinking about if you're on 236 should we put a number on it in terms of how deep you can go with these commercial activities? It doesn't have to be answered, it's just that's a little more descriptor of what it's about. Well,
[1:01:43] Speaker C (unidentified): businesses are allowed on Goodwin Road. I think that there's a certain level of like what to what degree are we talking about. I'm not, I'll have to look again to see what kind of things are allowed simply by virtue of being on 236, but if it's just the qualification of it being a business, there's there's already a lot of businesses here. Well,
[1:02:10] Chair: you got to be careful because what's allowed on 236 can be unrestricted quite large businesses because we recall we passed the ordinance UPGRADE FOR THE PHYSICAL STORE SIZE, WE INCREASED IT HOPING FOR A GROCERY STORE AND THERE WAS A 5,000 SQUARE FOOT NUMBER THAT WAS EXPANDED. NEW SPEAKER So does that mean that anything
[1:02:36] Speaker C (unidentified): ON 236 AUTOMATICALLY IS KIND OF IN THE COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT?
[1:02:43] Chair: No, well, for example, the minute the minute you get above Arc Road and go north on 236 you're in a rural zone there, and there are properties other than about 236 in the rural zone that go both directions, go towards the river and also go inland towards Goodwin Road, and they go deep. And you have the potential for somebody to say, hey, I abut 236, and therefore get the benefits of the lifting of restrictions because they abut 236 on one side. They could conceivably have just as big as an entrance on the Goodwin side as they do on the 236 side, which would bring a lot of 236-facing kind of activity over into a secondary road like Goodwin, or State Road for that matter.
[1:04:02] Speaker C (unidentified): I think in that case it's a valid concern, especially on the State Road side, because I don't think State Road anywhere near has that kind of character. And maybe we should put a cap on it to be like the standard depth of acreage that a normal commercial lot on the 36 is.
[1:04:25] Chair: So, you know, in summary, the question is, just because you're on 236 doesn't mean you have unlimited development rights all the way through the property that may go deep into the rural zone. And if we feel that makes sense, then that's something that we should think about. Is there some number to arrive upon that's a maximum depth that you can do that activity from 236. As part of that conversation
[1:05:05] Speaker D (unidentified): conversation. Could we also, is it possible to get a list of the footnotes that provide the exceptions so we know the kind of things we're talking about? So maybe start there and say like what is it that potentially could be allowed and then maybe work the conversation that way so that it doesn't necessarily have to be all or nothing. We could maybe look at like I'm, I don't know what I'm going to make it's a grocery store, we'll just pick grocery store, and maybe we want to look at on a, on a use by use basis and say these would be inappropriate if there were a property that would have access not on 236 but get the benefit of the abutting. Maybe look at it that way as opposed to like all of them or none of them. Yeah, I'm
[1:06:13] Speaker I (unidentified): sorry please do we have many properties that we know of that are like that up there are several
[1:06:23] Speaker F (unidentified): there's a couple that run all the way I'm almost up to York Pond. There are, there are, yep
[1:06:28] Chair: you know, as they exist today, you know, you wouldn't feel there's an issue if they change hands and it could be totally different next year. Yeah, this is, this is, this is anticipating that. You know, second to that, there's also discussion with the school district about taking the water and sewer at Arc Road and taking it to the middle school. If you take it to the middle school, I guess the question would be does that open up other opportunities for developers along 236 up that end to say hey look there's water and sewer now coming up the street, what can we do? Yeah
[1:07:29] Speaker D (unidentified): I think that, I think those, I think the water and sewer question gives a really good reason to reevaluate the footnotes about special consideration if you're in a butter but outside the commercial district. I'm
[1:07:50] Chair: sorry, Dawn, I kind of interrupted you. Know, no, this is very helpful for my
[1:07:55] Speaker B (unidentified): purposes. I'm just making notes. I'll make up a document, a table, and you know, I'll work something up for purposes of discussion. Yes, that would be great
[1:08:04] Speaker D (unidentified): Really good. So when we look at it back to this note that you sent to the town manager, so we think child care services is small, and then number four and number five are pretty small as well. Those are just sort of the language changes that are for our benefit. Is that correct? Okay, and so it's really one in three that are quite beefy.
[1:08:34] Chair: That's where the work is. Yeah.
[1:08:36] Speaker D (unidentified): I just want to keep making sure we stay
[1:08:41] Speaker B (unidentified): with that. And we are working with a consultant that you have worked with previously on number one, when you created the mixed-use district, so we have some familiarity.
[1:08:55] Chair: Do we have a schedule on when that starts?
[1:08:57] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm having a video meeting with them Friday morning. And I sent them this schedule that you have outlining your goals and when your meetings are. So I hope to see them there.
[1:09:11] Chair: After your meeting with them, then they kind of cross with ideas in terms of what a schedule would look like. I just want to make sure we have it backs into what the vote requirement is.
[1:09:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, exactly. So I sent them actually the table that went to the council that they can see these are your meeting dates and this is when you what self-imposed deadlines you have, and I know that they already had a draft of something Vanessa emailed and she had a draft in some ideas going, so I'll have more information after Friday. But they're they're well versed in the community, so I think that it's it would be a much heavier lift if they hadn't worked here before.
[1:09:56] Speaker J (unidentified): War. Good. Great.
[1:10:05] Chair: I've got one other thing. The transition zone on between Beach and Bold Hill, between the two growth areas. We had some discussion about the characterization of that on the maps that we had seen that were produced by SMPDC, and we saw some of the folks from SMPDC at the Kittery event, of which they were very agreeable to edit any map that we have that needs editing and just to give them specific instructions so that then they know what to do. So I think we should do that so we have a updated version that shows the growth areas as the village zone and then the mix you sell with the proper boxing lines around it to show here's the growth. We should do that. I also look back through the comprehensive plan and the comprehensive plan is, it is not explicit, it is slightly ambiguous, but it does say implicitly that it is a zone that is between two growth zones, being the mixed use and the village zone. And then I also looked at the GIS map with the village transition, and it shows that as a suburban zone. We have never declared that any other way on our GIS mapping. So I'm of the opinion that our intent, although maybe taken, you know, with that growth area designation in the comp plan, it is really described as a light increase in density in that zone. Own. So I don't think we have a problem. I do think we have to, for sure, correct the map that SMPDC did. And for sure, we need to communicate it to the state that we found it ambiguous and
[1:12:57] Speaker C (unidentified): we wanted to clarify. I'd also like to chime in on this and just say anecdotally, I spoke to a resident on Bolt Hill Road who was also a little concerned and confused about the sizes of lots in that area, and they were looking to subdivide their two acre or like greater than two acre property, but they weren't able to due to the sizes of the lot requirements, and they were like, but there's a lot that's like only an acre just a few like not even a quarter mile down the road, and they were like, but that's been grandfathered in, and there's so many small lots in this area. So I think there is certainly a call for looking at that area closely and maybe giving its own zone.
[1:13:45] Chair: Yeah, I think to really deliver what we had envisioned, we're going to have to not only correct the maps. I think as Don has queued us up for working after we take care of the village, go back and take a look at the zone, which is a suburban zone currently, but we'll call it the mid-village
[1:14:15] Speaker C (unidentified): transect. Yeah, some sort of transitional term or like a transitional village.
[1:14:20] Chair: And that would be the place where we could say, hey, maybe you could take a little more density a little more of this and to be determined, so my original panic is
[1:14:33] Speaker F (unidentified): over, and I have a new understanding that you're gonna say I have a new panic. No,
[1:14:41] Chair: no new panics. That's all I had. I understand by looking at the select board agenda for Thursday there's a gentleman who's made application for the Planning Board, and I'm going to attend the select board meeting as they usually do, and otherwise I don't have any additional news. Dawn
[1:15:16] Speaker B (unidentified): is there anything from the planners office? No, nothing official this evening. I do want to hand some things out to you when we're done before you go.
[1:15:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Is there going to be a digital copy?
[1:15:29] Chair: Say again, Karina? Hi, Karina. Did you have something?
[1:15:39] Speaker C (unidentified): I was just asking if there was a digital version going to be available?
[1:15:43] Speaker B (unidentified): Or a digital version? There is. We could mail these for her or drop them off as well if she wants, or if she's
[1:15:51] Speaker C (unidentified): here, if you want hard copies. I could probably come by and just grab a copy on maybe Friday?
[1:16:00] Chair: Not on Friday because Town Hall is closed.
[1:16:02] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, that's right. On Friday? Oh, okay.
[1:16:04] Chair: And they're shut tomorrow for Veterans Day.
[1:16:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and then I'm not going to be able to go over on Thursday, so I'm just trying to think how I'm going to do it. I'll find a time to get over there.
[1:16:16] Chair: Okay. Yeah, don't forget to pay your property taxes.
[1:16:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, yeah, that's right.
[1:16:23] Chair: I was alerted today. Okay, if there's nothing else.
[1:16:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Motion to adjourn. Second.
[1:16:39] Speaker C (unidentified): All right, thank you, everybody. Thank
[1:16:51] Speaker D (unidentified): you for being patient with me. Let
[1:21:02] Speaker B (unidentified): me see if this turns it down. Actually, I shouldn't do that. I will mention to Kim that the microphones.
[1:21:16] Chair: When Ellen tried to speak, it took off. Yeah.
[1:21:20] Speaker I (unidentified): I know, and I had to jump to that. I know. Is it okay if I add Karolina? The
[1:21:43] Chair: planner and the chair, right?
[1:21:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Suzanne had that copy of the canvas, too,
[1:21:48] Speaker A (unidentified): because she has some electronic.
[1:21:54] Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, I don't know if you'd want them electronic. I will send them to you.
[1:21:58] Speaker A (unidentified): You could just, she could just send them
[1:22:02] Speaker B (unidentified): to the town hall and we'll distribute them. them. Pardon? You could just send them to staff and we'll distribute them if you want. Well, I have everybody's address. It's a click. Do you just want to add? Yep.
[1:22:16] Speaker I (unidentified): Christine asked me not to stop, partly because you didn't want them. I don't know what the other reason was. I don't remember. But I used to send them to everybody. And Corrine's never
[1:22:28] Speaker A (unidentified): here, so it might be easy. I will put you in the office.
[1:22:53] Speaker B (unidentified): this is part of the problem that i'm having right now is that i'm paper too and that we're the town's trying to go digital which is fabulous But I need the original file as well.
[1:23:08] Public commenter: No, you talk to us right now.
[1:23:12] Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, yeah. You have a very soft voice. I wasn't very soft on Thursday afternoon, I'll tell you what.
[1:23:27] Speaker B (unidentified): It's such a, like, you don't want to waste resources. But I, it's definitely planned, but I have to get my co-authors out and talk them all off, and yeah, that's what I do.
[1:23:37] Speaker G (unidentified): The only way I can comprehend what they're trying to do. And I go to them and I look up the ordinances and I go. Yeah, I know.
[1:23:45] Speaker I (unidentified): Unless you have, I'm tempted to get, well, I want to get another screen anyway. But when I worked for an attorney, she had to, because she was in state legislature, So she was up in Augusta, and I was not.
[1:24:03] Speaker A (unidentified): But one was for her, and one was for my work.
[1:24:07] Speaker I (unidentified): It works, but I don't like it.
[1:24:15] Speaker F (unidentified): OK, I've got a procedural question from the group. Like
[1:24:23] Chair: we did for 76 C, the road, I don't want.. He saw us, and he voted on it, and he gave it.