← Back to MaineScanner

Wilton Select Board reviews draft bylaws, clarifies conflict of interest and executive session rules

2026-11-10 · 1h 28m · Source: Wilton Select Board Workshop - November 10th, 2026 (Wilton Select Board (Mt. Blue TV YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:03] Speaker A (unidentified): We're interfering with recreation. It is right now, isn't it? [0:09] Chair: Oh, this is recreation. Ah, yes. [0:12] Speaker C (unidentified): You need to be retired. [0:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Yesterday morning we were here for three and a half hours and I'm like, [0:17] Speaker D (unidentified): you haven't seen much of my white truck, have you? [0:19] Chair: I haven't seen it at all, I don't think. Just that one day, Sunday. [0:23] Speaker A (unidentified): The one day that I was looking around, yeah, I haven't been able to get out there. I have a feeling I'm going to have to buy half a cow the week that it's growing. I actually, I did get out yesterday, and I had a bobcat walk up the wall I was sitting next to. Within 15 feet, I'm like, I've got to say something. [0:48] Speaker E (unidentified): I said, hi, kitty cat. [0:50] Speaker D (unidentified): And it stopped. And it looked at me. [0:53] Speaker A (unidentified): And I said, shoot. You [0:58] Chair: can rise for the pledge of allegiance, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you and welcome to the Select Board Workshop of November 10th. The lead was standing back out on page 12. That's what I had. [1:52] Speaker C (unidentified): Did you just send that? [1:53] Speaker F (unidentified): I just shared it, yes. [2:17] Chair: Executive session, you want to lead it off so [2:38] Speaker E (unidentified): we [2:54] Speaker A (unidentified): left off with the executive session. This is how the board enters the executive session, what's permitted under executive session, an example of what an executive session motion is, what you do an executive session, discuss things in the executive session. Any action is taken by a vote in public session after the board reconvenes. I don't know if there's any comment on that section specifically. [3:43] Speaker E (unidentified): The last sentence in the first paragraph, the chair determines consistent with the statute who other than the members attend. It's a little awkward. You got a correction? I say the chair consistent with statute determines who may attend in addition to members or something along those lines. Works for me. Sure. So the [4:28] Speaker F (unidentified): chair gets to sit in what statute determines who [4:39] Speaker E (unidentified): can attend in addition to the members. I don't know if they should or can attend. The statute would require. Right.
Public Comment
[5:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Onward. Yep. Public comment is the next section. Basically, it goes over state law that requires the opportunity for public comment. We've, as a matter of many years, have allowed the public to speak even before this became state law. Each regular meeting includes a public comment period beginning by email to the board's jurisdiction. For the board votes on any item of business, the chair asks whether any member of the public wishes to comment on it. I put down each speaker is limited to three minutes per comment period. Speaks once on each matter. No comment to exceeds 30 minutes unless the chair would consent the board extends the time that period. Speakers state their name, whether will the resident taxpayer dress the board to the chair and speak the matters from the board's jurisdiction. The board listens and they ask clarify a question but that's not debate our act during the public comment a matter meeting action is referred to town manager placed on a future agenda context ends will apply every member we've got some viewpoint Jimmy the client to recognize of an interrupt and direct to include speaker who exceeds the limit and just goes on to say it's disruptive including threats personal views feel to yield the floor complaints about an individual employee that seeks personnel action I submitted writing to the town manager that's not part of a public comment the person please stop to me after a warning may be removed from the chair on the chairs order going up to public comment one thing I do want to state here is that during public comment this is not I feel this does not include any board member from speaking as a member of the public. However I do feel that if a board member wants to speak as a member of the public they do so from we've already discussed before from the table here so I don't want to infringe on anybody's first amendment rights what I'm saying but just saying that this is if a board member wishes to speak this is the place that they would do it from understood [8:06] Speaker E (unidentified): When [8:15] Chair: you're in session you stay at the [8:19] Speaker A (unidentified): table it's the loss of public com right that's no because we address the other part up above just doesn't I don't want to negate anybody's first amendment right of being able to speak during public comment. Agenda and workshops. I want to read this verbatim. It's just the proposed language for agenda and workshops. Packets posted to the town office. Chamisca workshops receive information to refine future agenda items. There's special meetings that are posted. The public is, as always, allowed to attend. No formal votes take in at a workshop. Straw polling the guide staff is permitted. Questions, comments, public hearings, updated language. Chair opens the public hearing. Any questions on public hearing? Voting updating the conflict of interest definition of conflict of interest. Abstentions should be limited to conflict of interest out of disqualifications. Mr. Chair, I believe you have a question. May I? Comment. [10:52] Speaker G (unidentified): So the new sentence that's being added under voting says, a board member with a direct or indirect pecuniary interest shall publicly disclose. And I would like to ask a question about how the language being added here affects or interacts with similar topic that was mentioned on page nine. So I don't remember the section number on page 9, but on page 9, the phrase appears, a member who has recused from a matter because of a personal or financial interest. What I want to ask about is, it the intent, by adding this sentence here under the section voting, to narrow the definition of what qualifies as a conflict of interest under these bylaws to exclude the non-financial elements, meaning that after this revision is accepted, the only conflicts that shall be a violation of these bylaws are the financial conflicts. That's [11:59] Chair: a great question. Not necessarily, not the way I would see it, but my statute talks about the financial conflict with regards to conflict of interest. [12:21] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't see either, but I am open. This is just a draft. [12:25] Speaker D (unidentified): This is for the entire select board, [12:27] Speaker A (unidentified): so therefore any proposed language is always welcome there. We're just, this is just a starting point. Nathan? [12:34] Speaker G (unidentified): So my interpretation is that under the current version that has been in place for years, broader definitions of conflict of interest, such as personal ones, would have been a violation of these bylaws and thus compelled abstention even though that personal interest wasn't a violation of statute and I'll tell this the story that was from last year to illustrate what I mean last year there was an open seat on the school board one of my immediate family members was one of the names mentioned in the discussion for potential appointment my interpretation of the existing document is that if I had been on the board at the time, this language would have compelled me to abstain due to the personal conflict. But if the new language did seek to narrow the scope so that it only restricts voting in the case of financial interests, then any similar situation that occurs this year would allow me to vote for an immediate family member. So using that case as an example, with the revisions that are proposed right now, I hope that the bylaws intention is that would still restrict me from voting for immediate family member even though that vote would not be a violation of statute. [13:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, the intention of my putting this in here is to make it clear what a director indirect pecuniary interest was, so feel free to make a recommendation for language that way there it just opens it back up again. I'm happy to have the [14:07] Speaker G (unidentified): language as proposed as long as we understand that it's not a narrowing of the scope compared to previous versions. It [14:16] Speaker A (unidentified): works for me if somebody wants to add language, please do so. Are [14:27] Speaker C (unidentified): we concerned that a future board member may interpret it differently? [14:39] Speaker G (unidentified): It is my concern based on what is written now that the revised version says that the scope of conflict of interest under the bylaws is narrowed to be referred only to the pecuniary interest that aligns wholly with statute. It doesn't mean I'm correct, it's just that the way I read it, that was my reading when I first saw this proposed [14:59] Speaker A (unidentified): provision. I will make it for, I won't make a proposed revision since nobody else wants to make a proposed revision, so where it says a board member with a direct, an example would be a board member with a direct or indirect, just take out the turn here. No, that is one example of a, at the beginning it says a board member may participate or any vote on any matter in which the member, no, board member may participate or vote on any matter in which a member has a conflict of interest, so it starts out with that paragraph, right? I was proposing that community interest in interest be added here. Let's just make this an example and that way there it doesn't appear as those narrowed in any anyway. Does that? Okay. So we'll make that an example. [16:07] Chair: How are you reading it most? Yeah, [16:11] Speaker A (unidentified): can you just explain to me what you're going to change on? Sure. Where it's accurate to by majority vote of the remaining members, period. An example is, comma. And then we would just revise the sentence to make it grammatically correct. [16:35] Chair: Sure. Okay. And I would say that this section is just about voting because back on page 9, it's already about the other, right? And [16:57] Speaker A (unidentified): then we slide down to abstentions. [17:01] Speaker G (unidentified): Nathan? So on the abstentions one, it says abstentions are limited to conflict of interest and other disqualifications, and then a member who is not disqualified and declined to vote is recorded as abstaining. It sounds like, what's the point of limiting abstentions if someone can just decline and abstain under any circumstances there? It's like, I could just decline every time and be recorded as abstaining without a reason, which defeats the purpose of requiring a reason to abstain for a sentence. [17:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Great point. What would you like to propose? that [17:45] Speaker G (unidentified): people can have the removal of the first sentence [17:55] Speaker E (unidentified): so someone can get on the board and just keep abstaining then what's the value of the membership to that because you voted in to make decisions so if you just keep abstaining then you're not doing your job well [18:21] Speaker C (unidentified): I remember back when I first joined the board I had a conflict of interest because he was buying their property and I remember asking what's the proper process for abstaining and all that and I was some other situation where it's more of a gray area and Tom Saviello reminded me that I'm not allowed to abstain once I have a damn good reason and I'm wondering where that comes from because if that's already written down somewhere and something we're already hearing do that we don't need to spell it out here. And I don't know where that comes from, because anyway, I trust in Tom. Does anyone have a limit? Could just be a Robbins Rules thing, too, isn't it? Well, I think those are the reasons why we're talking. [19:06] Chair: Are we okay to move on while you're looking up? [19:10] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm okay with that. I'm okay with the government. Yeah, but I'm not going to hold this up. [19:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Because I think that, you know, that's the extensions is, I think, what Nancy's talking about is that abstentions are for cause. Right. [19:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Like you didn't attend the meeting so you don't understand the information. Something like that could be a cause. It may not be [19:34] Speaker D (unidentified): but it could be or you know. You abstain because meeting minutes. Yeah, you weren't there. [19:42] Speaker A (unidentified): So maybe it's a better way to have reward that. I see votes are shown by hand, roll CALL, MANSION FOR COORDINATED MEMBERS. ANY VOTE TAKING WHILE A MEMBER PARTICIPATES REMOTELY. ANY VOTE THAT IS NOT UNANIMOUS. VOTE MAY BE RECONSIDERED ONLY IN THE MOTION OF THE MEMBER WHO VOTED ON THE PREVAILING SIDE AT THE SAME OR NEXT REGULAR MEETING. ANY MEMBER MAY APPEAL THE RULING OF THE CHAIR. SECOND OF THE CHAIR PUTS THE QUESTION, SHALL THE RULING OF THE CHAIR BE SUSTAINED? That way there, if someone wants to challenge the ruling, it's okay. [20:38] Chair: With that, yep, should. [20:43] Speaker E (unidentified): That have its own paragraph just so you can pull it out of here and. [20:56] Speaker A (unidentified): I am, I only need some draft documents. [20:59] Speaker D (unidentified): this is a board workshop not a tip workshop it's a lot of it 's a lot no i just want so [21:06] Speaker E (unidentified): If you were going, if you were going to look at how you overturn a motion, right, which is what that was, reconsider emotions, right, okay, would you look under abstentions, which is the first word of that paragraph, two different topics, right, yeah, it's two different topics, it should be. [21:25] Speaker F (unidentified): Two different paragraphs, I agree, okay, so would you start the paragraph at votes are by show of hands or roll call and minutes report each member's vote, did you start it there, that sounds reasonable, still talking about abstentions, yeah, votes are by showing hands or roll call works. [21:45] Speaker E (unidentified): For me, yes, that's fine, yeah. Sorry, I actually. [22:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Think that it was just a misplacement. I think that the voting, I think my intention was to put it down the decisions and records, you. [22:30] Speaker E (unidentified): Could do that, it. [22:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Doesn't matter either way. I've been just looking at it now. It's been a while since under the head, yeah, that's. [22:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Where it should have gone, not about the heading, I know, yeah, but this heading is under voting. But it's under voting. It's currently under voting. Yeah. We'll leave it voting. [22:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Let's see. Minutes. We added about town park. Are the designated steps. The town management keeps the minutes. Anything the board like discuss under minutes and recording minutes? [23:34] Speaker E (unidentified): Answer. It says every motion and vote by member is provided above. And maybe I'm missing something, but I don't think Aaron puts down our names next to who voted against. We don't do a roll call vote. And it sounds like that's requiring a roll call vote. [23:54] Chair: Well, not necessarily a roll call vote, but a recorded. [23:57] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, like, yes, he voted against, and everybody else voted for. It just says four to one. [24:02] Chair: And years ago, it used to be you would see a motion and a second. It would just be the initials, but. [24:10] Speaker F (unidentified): There's names on the minutes now, I believe, for the motion, yes, but not who voted, you know, in how they voted, and how they voted, it's not there, which the way I read talk about voting against, right, or abstaining, haven't we had that conversation, we talked about minutes when we were talking about reorganizing the minutes, and so not that the board. [24:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Has to do it this way, but the way I do it from my own notes is, obviously, at the top of the page it shows the members present, so you know the pool of people from which votes are being done. Then the vote would say vote was three to two, and then comma, name one, name two against. So that way you would have the two people, have the people voting up, voting opposed to something listed out, and you could deduce who was in favor based on comparing to the member list. That's, that's what I found the most concise way that contained all the information and was easy to write, because votes opposed are rare. Right. [25:21] Speaker F (unidentified): But we weren't able to find anything in statute that required, or Robert's rule, that required that way of record. [25:28] Speaker G (unidentified): That was just my own notes that I found best work for me. Yeah. Because [25:35] Speaker E (unidentified): that right now, it's not. It's not. It's not there. [25:38] Speaker D (unidentified): It's not there right now, but that's what's being proposed here. [25:41] Chair: Well, it would make it cleaner if you jump back a paragraph when you want to reconsider, then you know who voted in affirmative on emotion, right? [25:54] Speaker E (unidentified): that makes sense I have no problem with it I just wanted me just give clarity it is different than what we're doing now so that we just need to make sure that [26:01] Speaker A (unidentified): yes, it is different. A lot of this is different than what you know. Well, that's [26:05] Speaker E (unidentified): true, but this is, you know, every week, every other week. Well, it does [26:09] Chair: does remove the question, did I vote for that or not? [26:13] Speaker E (unidentified): I just asked me, what else do we need? There you go. [26:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Yep, I think we're good. I'm sorry. Sign documents outside of meeting. So when the board has voted in public session to approve a warrant, contract or other document, and the rightful flexor members may sign individually at the top, so without another meeting, signing as ministerial. And no deliberation or action occurs. Nancy, you gave a question, I just thought I cut my... No,, sorry. Committees and liaisons, though no member of the board serves the voting member of the Board of Appeals or anybody where decisions are reviewed by or appealed to the board. Liaisons and committees appointed by the board at the first regular meeting at the annual town meeting at least on attends reports the board unless the board provides otherwise. Does Art vote on the committee to speak for the board? Committee actions are recommendations and are placed for the board. Has motions? Second. [27:52] Speaker E (unidentified): So when I took my training, it said you also couldn't be on the Board of Education. You couldn't be a member of the Board of Education, which I We don't necessarily vote on that if that was what they said at the training [28:09] Speaker H (unidentified): You're talking with the school board school board. Sure. Yeah [28:16] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay, so should we add that to That falls under statute. So I don't think it does have to be okay. That's fine. Yeah, but I would think the Board of Appeals [28:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, those it's saying is the you can't be a county commissioner just like what we could be a long list of interest be lots of a lot of things and you could not. Statements, correspondence, information requests, statements issued in the name of the board, approved and advanced by the board. Chair may sign routine correspondence carrying a decision already made. Maybe we want to put something, let's see here. Correspondence to the board's tribute to all members by town manager, next regular meeting, public record times received and use it town email accounts for board business and members request for their information that Tom as your chair finds me credit staff time may be placed on the agenda for board decision if I was reinforced by chair to the Williams 20 border 72 appeals in your article 5 remember who violates the bylaws Freedom of Information Act interest The interest may be heard, be censured by a majority over the full board in public. Do you want me to stop right now, Nate, or continue? Mason? [30:03] Speaker G (unidentified): So the word censure is mentioned four times in this document, and they're in three different places. We're on page 14 here, which is Article 6, where it's mainly defined. find. And so I would like to compare the language here to the language that's used in the two previous instances, one of which is on page 12 and the other one on page 8, and offer clarification, if not for myself, then at least for people who are reading it in the future. So page 12, which we just went over, talks about executive sessions, and it says in that case, the content of an executive session, quote, disclosure is grounds for censure under Article 6. My understanding is that since the article that we just read says that any violation of the bylaws is grounds for censure, it's redundant to specify for executive sessions that disclosure is grounds for censure under Article 6. That reference on page 12 could be removed without changing the meaning of anything. Is that understanding fair for everyone? [31:09] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I think that makes sense to me. [31:10] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, so the prior occurrence of this reference is on page 8, and in this case, I will read it from two different sentences. The first one says, talked about, vote to censure the member after the member has had an opportunity to be heard. Again, in the subject matter being discussed on page 8, since any violation of the bylaws is an opportunity for a censure, specifying that violation of what's on page 8 would be not an opportunity for a censure doesn't add any substance to the document, and that first sentence, which includes a vote to censure the member after the member has had an opportunity to be hurt, could be removed and not change the meaning of the document at all. I agree. So that leaves us with the second sentence on page A, which is, censure is a formal expression of disapproval entered into the minutes. It does not affect the member's right to attend and participate. With the previous sentence having been removed, that second sentence doesn't seem to fit too well on page 8 anymore. It would fit best on page 14 under article 6, where censure is introduced and defined. Thus the scope of censure would apply to the entire document being introduced in article 6. So I'd suggest just move this, the sentence I just read, censure is a formal expression of disapproval, from page eight under article six, but it's under conduct and decorum of members, and a violation of conduct under decorum of members is grounds for censure under article six, so putting it under article six connects the dots in the logical sequence. Conduct and decorum of members is in the bylaws, a violation of bylaws to the grounds of censure under Article 6, so identifying and defining the scope of censure will be best placed in Article 6. [33:19] Speaker E (unidentified): So again, I would say, if I was going to look it up, where would I look for it? Would I look it under enforcement and conflict, or would I look it under it for, the quorum and whatever that, the conduct of the quorum? [33:41] Speaker G (unidentified): If you were going to look what up? [33:43] Speaker E (unidentified): I wanted to know about centering a member of the board, fair question. Where would I normally go to look it up? When I look it under quran doc and the quorum, well usually you're going to send to someone because of their conduct or perform, or when I look under the other title which I am gotta go all the way back to, which is the, what was the title? Enforcement in conflict with laws. Nathan. [34:15] Speaker G (unidentified): So one part of the answer to your question is, where would I look it up? Well, I'd Control left starts the word in the document, first of all. And secondly, you said usually. [34:25] Chair: Control left doesn't work online. [34:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, it doesn't work online either. [34:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Usually, you said usually people get censored for their decorum. But in this case, of our bylaws, that's not the case, that every single word of the bylaws is equally eligible for censure response. So just looking up in one section wouldn't make sense for something that has been written to apply to the entire document equally. [34:53] Chair: Did I answer your question? [34:55] Speaker E (unidentified): Not exactly, but I'll do Control-F, I guess. [35:02] Speaker C (unidentified): Read it so you find it. [35:03] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, you're going to have to teach it to me, all right? [35:05] Speaker H (unidentified): We can do that. [35:06] Speaker C (unidentified): We have classes, we have a workshop on technical savviness. [35:10] Chair: I was going to ask if you changed your calendar. Stop. [35:14] Speaker D (unidentified): What Nate is proposing makes sense to me. [35:19] Speaker A (unidentified): I, it doesn't matter either way, but. [35:23] Speaker C (unidentified): I think both things can be true. It can be fine on that subject and you all can learn how to search document. We can do both. I do feel like we're spending an awful lot of time on this and I'm curious, in the history of our town, I don't know how many we had to censor anybody. [35:37] Chair: In my 10 years, it hasn't happened. [35:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Nathan seems to have an answer. [35:42] Speaker G (unidentified): There's been no provision for it. Up until these revisions are accepted, so it couldn't have happened. [35:50] Speaker C (unidentified): Because it hasn't been talked about, it means it couldn't have happened? [35:54] Speaker G (unidentified): There was no opportunity to do it. Okay. [35:57] Speaker A (unidentified): I have to say, when I first became a select board member, I can think of times when, in prior select boards, if I had known there was such a thing as a censure, I probably would have asked the chair to censure. [36:12] Speaker C (unidentified): I wasn't here yet, so that wasn't me. No,. [36:14] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm saying this is going back a dozen years or so. [36:19] Speaker G (unidentified): There wasn't such a thing at the level at the time. Correct. [36:23] Speaker E (unidentified): Now there will be. But it's in Robert's order, so you could have pulled that. [36:27] Speaker D (unidentified): I was a new select board member. [36:29] Speaker E (unidentified): It's okay. No, I'm just saying. You're saying it was never here. Okay. [36:33] Speaker G (unidentified): If you put it that way, and I agree with you. [36:38] Speaker C (unidentified): It's still taking an awful lot of time and it's probably not going to get used anyway. [36:44] Speaker F (unidentified): So are we all set? What's our decision? What is the decision? So Nathan recommended to move it from page 8. [36:54] Chair: I thought Nathan just... Did I misunderstand you? You said you were all set? [36:59] Speaker G (unidentified): My suggestion is to move the sentence of formal expression of disapproval from page 8 to page 14. To page 14? Under Article 6. [37:10] Speaker C (unidentified): I think he was all set in understanding that CEDRIC could have come from a parent document of some kind. I [37:29] Speaker F (unidentified): can tell [37:44] Speaker A (unidentified): at the end here that conflict with laws, I would actually propose that any conflict very consistently between these bylaws and any applicable probably put something like state or federal law shall be resolved in favor of the state or federal law, something of that nature, just going off memory [38:04] Chair: and I'm old, but I think we that's on the like on page one, maybe it is page with yes, so it can, I think it leads out of that, but without looking at it just seems like we put that disclaimer on the front end. You can have it on the back end too. No, let's just take it out. I'm not thinking like [38:22] Speaker A (unidentified): I thought I'd change that, but change [38:26] Speaker E (unidentified): the whole thing. What's that, you're gonna remove the whole thing? Well, if it's already at the beginning, that's fine. Let's just try to make sure it's [38:33] Speaker C (unidentified): that you could, you could try to control that and see if you find it or [38:38] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm gonna scroll with my [38:40] Chair: finger until I, you got this. Yeah, it's, it's the first red paragraph on page one that talks about under its authority regulate proceedings provision of state of federal [39:03] Speaker H (unidentified): law questions procedures, so I think it's there. Yeah, let's try get out, so I got out the entire, yes, just scrolling, it's a lot of emotion which of course will [39:19] Speaker C (unidentified): require every number of everything after that. I should write the end, so it's [39:23] Speaker D (unidentified): probably fun. Yeah, it's really difficult reading from red line after a while. Yeah, [39:28] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm seeing a red not because I'm mad, it [39:36] Chair: worse if you recall blind waivers [39:51] Speaker A (unidentified): and amendments at that point there. I'll let each of you read, seems [Chair: reasonable those] So my suggestion, I'm sure there's other Selectwood members that may have suggestions. I [40:37] Speaker C (unidentified): mean, you're very thorough. I don't like it. [40:41] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I don't think this one is my best work. I'm excited. Orientation of Selectwood members. Fathers, W-4, FOIA requirements, I-9s, helpful to know, before your first meeting, but not required, these bylaws, decorum, public comment, executive session, voting. [41:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Do I have to read the bylaws? Do I need to read the bylaws? Well, I'll give you. A little redundant. [41:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, I don't even know whether or not we should say, you know, especially article four and article five, but I would hope that they'd come prepared. [42:08] Chair: Yeah. Well, the goal should be is that, one, if you're going to review them every three years, which is good, but when someone new is elected to the board, there should be a packet given to them along with this schedule so they can sign up for the Freedom of Information Act training. Oh yeah. [42:33] Speaker H (unidentified): But this is the [Speaker F (unidentified): chair responsible for] guiding them. I think the chair would work with the town manager. Well, I will [42:51] Speaker F (unidentified): will say that I think that the process can be sure, but I mean, if we had a [42:58] Chair: packet, yeah, that you give to a newly elected member, and then if you're reelected, you have to go for the foyer training every three years anyways. That's requirement of the law. My [43:13] Speaker A (unidentified): point was, you know, the first to put down these bylaws, but it just seemed like it was too short, so I put especially, and then I'm treating it like, I don't know if you want to say especially anything. No, just read the bylaws. These bylaws is what I'm saying, is that it seems so short, I added in something that is probably longer than it needs to be. So should we just strike out especially because we should really ask them [43:37] Speaker D (unidentified): just to read the bylaws, period. [43:39] Speaker A (unidentified): So let's strike out anything after these bylaws. We'll strike out the rest of the sentence. [44:02] Chair: Soothing anyways. I was thinking the same thing. [44:05] Speaker F (unidentified): It's not a good year for you. Hey. [44:15] Chair: You probably do more than I do. [44:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Sign up and attend MMA training for newly elected officials and introduction to the incident command system, national incident management system, as time allows. Familiarize yourself to the municipal government. [44:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Tiny, detail on that one. The second to last line on the page, it says, Wilson made our org. Yes, oh [44:48] Chair: you could browse. I'm not doing much good, just look [44:55] Speaker C (unidentified): at you there. Does it still be direct? Yeah, that's good. Make sure you have [45:01] Speaker D (unidentified): corrected though, range [45:07] Speaker A (unidentified): tour. So the town manager is at each department, town facility. Yeah, that's time allows. That's [45:20] Speaker C (unidentified): up dot org shows up twice. Do you do a [45:23] Speaker H (unidentified): little left? Yeah, I'm living in it. There we go. Where else is it though? Well, [45:32] Speaker C (unidentified): there's pull this forward to count other websites, page seven, as time allows. I think we just looked at it. Oh, is this showing up twice? No, it's not. So, 7 and 16. It looks like it's the same thing. That's weird. [45:52] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, because this was striking. Oh, right. [45:56] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah,. Okay, sorry. It's showing me that, yeah. That's fine. Not bad. Understood. See, I didn't even use Control-F right. I did it wrong. You are better than I am at this. Not, no. [46:13] Chair: You're good at everybody else's. [46:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Executive Session references, example motions. [46:37] Speaker C (unidentified): David Arriba-Meyer. Thank you, sir. [46:39] Speaker G (unidentified): So I made a reference last meeting to half the reason why we're here at this one. Executive Session references, there has been conflicts as well, and so I've been waiting to talk about this one for a long time. Under 405A, it lists possible reasons to go into Executive Session. And as you know, if you read 6a, it talks about if there's a person who has made complaints or allegations, then the person making the complaint or allegation has to be, has the right to be present in the session, and if it's an investigation, then the person being investigated has the right to request that the investigation be made public. So I know I've talked about this for a year now. But this is one of the reasons why it's important to follow the practice of making a precise motion for the session rather than just saying 4056A personnel, because you have to clarify whether it's for investigation, allegation, complaints, or whether it's not for those things, because different standards of session applies to this. And this, the statute does say a motion to go to executive session must state the precise nature of the business, and if it just says four or five six A person's analysis, fails to meet the statutory standard for precise business. And I know we've had these conversations many times. I'm hoping that today will be a finally day to have it all resolved, and I will say the training that I just [48:17] Chair: went to an MMA talking about executive sessions, they clearly said you do not need to break it down to the minute detail of what an executive session is. If it falls under, you know, 4056A personnel, that is fine, and that was from Maine Municipal. Nathan, how will anyone know what the complaint [48:42] Speaker G (unidentified): or allegations were the subject of the business, and whether the complainers should be invited? [48:47] Chair: Well, that will be the chair and the town manager working together, setting up the agenda, that those procedures will be followed. [49:01] Speaker E (unidentified): Nancy? It says there only a public discussion can damage a person's reception. If you had put my name or you said that investigation of a complaint, and then I'm the only one sitting in the chairs, in the chairs, and you know that I've been allowed to go, presumed to go, you know, presumed to go, that could violate my rights as a personnel. [49:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Mason? So the very last one is 841, and I'm asking whether this executive session reference list implies that a sufficient motion to go into executive session could cite only 36 MRS 841. So it is possible for executive sessions to reference multiple pieces of statute, not just one. Sorry, my question is, do these bylaws say that is appropriate to go into executive session if the sole citation is title 36 section 841, so [50:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Is the question, is the question means if I want my taxes debated, I don't get the privacy. Is it going to have my name on there? [50:27] Speaker F (unidentified): No, it's just, I'm sorry if I may. How it's worded. Should the motion say pursuant to 841 and 405, whatever it's, is that what you're saying? So should the motion actually refer to, because it actually, you can use either or. Is what we've gotten from legal, is the opinion that we've gotten from MFA legal, is that it can either, it can fall under either. Depending on what the situation is, obviously, but it could fall under either [50:57] Speaker G (unidentified): or both or this did come up at a previous meeting and I want to talk about it in a proper setting before one of our executive sessions. Cindy gave me this packet and it explained to me what this, the creator of this packet thought that motion should be, and I've stapled to the front of it just the two sections in question, and what this document says is that the motion has to cite 405 6f, it can't be absent 405 6f, and I don't know when the proper setting to talk about this is, so I hope today's the proper setting, but if you read 4056, discussions of information contained in records made when accessed by the general public to those records is prohibited by statute. The reference to something being prohibited by statute in the case of a poverty abatement obviously is referring to 841, but 841 is not in itself the entirety of section 4056F. So my reading of this line is that 4056F requires the matter be discussed in executive session, but it doesn't authorize the motion. The word requirement is not a synonym for the word authorization. And it's not worth talking to the lawyers about this because it's not important enough to spend the money on it, but if someone reads it differently or is willing to talk about it with me, because 4056F includes a reference to something being prohibited by statute, but it's not. If [53:21] Chair: it's strictly a tax abatement, is that what you're saying? [53:25] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm saying that the 841 says that you can't talk about the tax abatement outside executive session, but that is not, from a reasoning standpoint, the same thing as having the authority to enter an executive session. [53:43] Speaker F (unidentified): Which is why the both of them would be required. [53:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Which is why the training that Cindy gave me showed me that you go pursue it to 405. And I realize that these convoluted deductive reasoning chains are not really great meeting fodder and most people don't want to do them, but sorry, this is just how my brain works. [54:04] Speaker E (unidentified): so for clarification if you don't put the 405 on it doesn't let people know that we can it lets people know that it's files that can't go out into public is what you're saying right is that what is that what it is so they can know it's a tax abatement but then it just backs it up and says we can't go out and discuss it or it can't be discussed and that's why people can't know the information so it's sort of a protection and lets the public know by having them both in there I'm asking does that allow for more protection for the individual who's asking for the abatement and unless the public know why we're not discussing it, okay. [54:52] Speaker A (unidentified): If I give it a shot, so I think I see where Nate's going in and I agree with this, here is that though both of them provide that cover, the actual motion itself is not proper to say title 36, even though it's covered under title 36 section 841. Maria said that either one is appropriate, one does not give the authority to make that type of a motion, and if it's already covered under F, then why are we even including it whatsoever? I think I [55:32] Chair: heard because of legal counsel recommendation, is that what you said? [55:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, so within the last few, I would say five months, we've had a larger conversation about that and just trying to understand entirely. I guess there's a lot of moving parts when it comes to that, and my understanding is that it's both, is that it would be required both. I really seem you would be required to enter in pursuant to title 36 and [56:02] Speaker A (unidentified): then title one, so one's not included in the other, you'd have to do both, that you would [56:09] Speaker F (unidentified): actually have to do both, is that what you're also understanding as well? I know I know that you're explaining it, I'm explaining, you're explaining it differently, but I think I do. [56:17] Speaker G (unidentified): That's the end point that I'm getting to. That's what it says here in the training. Yes. Okay. [56:21] Speaker E (unidentified): So then my question is, do we have to include 36 LRF 8401 in every one? Or is it just the ones that are in 405 6F? [56:33] Chair: No, so I'm sorry. That's about tax abatement. [56:36] Speaker F (unidentified): Do we have to include 841 in all of them? Yeah. No. Okay. No, 841 is separate to its own. [56:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah. Okay. Just trying to understand. [56:49] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it's when you have 841 is when you need to, when you're dealing with something relating to 841 is when you need to have the vote. Okay. [56:59] Chair: That's what I understood you said. [57:00] Speaker F (unidentified): But you can go in to 405, Title I, 405, 6F, all on its own. Right. You have the ability to go into it all on its own. [57:10] Speaker A (unidentified): So, maybe putting 36 under 4056F and where applicable as a child. Because the only time you're going to use 36 MRS is when it's used in conjunction with 4056F, correct? [57:34] Speaker F (unidentified): Is that what you're saying? Yes, 36A41-2E. [57:38] Chair: So, in parentheses under, just when applicable. [57:42] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah. Okay, that makes sense. I [57:47] Chair: wouldn't change the order. Sorry, it just doesn't flow. Okay. Got it. [57:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Like I said, it's not my document. Okay. [57:57] Speaker G (unidentified): So getting back to the first one, which I had time to think about it between the last minutes, is many pieces of these bylaws are more restricted than statute, meaning that things are rules that we are adding that statute does not require us to do. And in the case of my question about precision of executive session motions, I would like to make a case to the board why being more precise than statute requires is to our benefits and some meetings are recorded others are not executive sessions are not the camera brings accountability i can't speak about the content of prior executive session but i can say that my feeling right now is of concern that future eggs future executive sessions will devolve into social gossip hour where people are presented with things that they could not have prepared for and that this activity is particularly concerning in a space that lacks accountability. Not only is there no record, video, or written, but I can't even report on it later when something happened that seemed out of line. Hypothetically, if that's were to happen in the future, that's why I keep pushing the adoption of culture of being cognizant of precise motions and sticking to them. [59:18] Speaker E (unidentified): Nancy? Are you saying that you want the executive sessions recorded? No. [59:21] Speaker G (unidentified): more precise motions so that people understand what they're going into and i would say [59:32] Chair: The board gets clear information on what it's going into executive session for, which is who the executive session is for. It's not for the general public, so they know what's going on, this private business that needs to be conducted outside of general public information. That's just my take. Nathan. A minute ago [1:00:06] Speaker G (unidentified): I heard the board gets clear information on what we're going into executive session for. If we were able to have a transparent conversation about that statement, it would be a long one, and I disagree with that statement. [1:00:22] Chair: We don't get front-loaded with information on executive sessions because we're supposed to learn about the information in executive session. [1:00:36] Speaker C (unidentified): That's my interpretation. Thoughts? Bill? I tend to agree with that. I think I've been cut off guard in executive sessions twice total, and in both times. Everything I needed to know I was told in that executive session. Usually it was because of a town event happened that I wasn't aware of yet. But every other time I felt prepared, either town manager has briefed us ahead of time, or I just turned to the grapevine because it was a big public event, anything [1:01:10] Chair: else we started on time, it's five o'clock [1:01:14] Speaker E (unidentified): I was going to say that the information going back and forth through emails is a potential for a violation of privacy also, so not having all the information all the time, we get it in the session so [1:01:37] Chair: Just to wrap this up, you have, and I know you're short-handed and busy, do you have a timeline of when an edited version, without red lines, will be available for us? [1:01:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Meaning, could we have it by the time that we set out the agenda? No, not necessarily. [1:01:58] Chair: No, that's why I preface, we've got a holiday tomorrow. Speaking of which, the Lions Club is at 1 o'clock tomorrow, is doing a rededication of the World War II monument, open to the public. It there'll be light refreshments afterwards, tomorrow is veterans day [1:02:20] Speaker F (unidentified): I would, if you're looking at me, if you're looking to me for an answer within the next month, I would say in December, by the December meeting, so we'll try for the first meeting in [1:02:34] Speaker C (unidentified): December. Yes, it's reasonably, thank you, Phil. Are we considering this completed then? Because I have two more paragraphs that I wanted to circle back to at some point, but I know. Okay, just go up to page four, please. I've pasted the net, I don't know if they're gonna show up on your end or not. I believe they are. And these come from the concern that first happened back when we had Rhonda as a town manager, where each member of the board would go to Rhonda separately and just ask her questions, and she'd go, yeah, I'll look into that for you, I'll look at that for you, I'll take care of that for you. And none of us all realized that all of us were doing it, and she was being tasked by five different people and felt obligated to it to help all of us, and it was, it was draining on her, and it wasn't appropriate for us to be doing that to work. So I thought, especially, and that also that was the main catalyst, but I also noticed that some language in here is not in line with what we talked about, so recently is that, is that bothering the town manager for information should go to the trailer, and the bylaws says differently, so you have that, is that there, it's not, yeah, my net is green, but I'm out of the dark mode on, so [1:03:46] Speaker F (unidentified): it might be different, may require access to or partners, that's the one, so it's [1:03:53] Speaker C (unidentified): like what members may require access to recorded or historical information in order to conduct official town business, except when access is restricted by law, individual, sorry, by law, individual members may ask where existing records or information can be found. Any requests that would require the town manager or other town employees to research, retrieve, compile, summarize, or create materials should be presented to the Select Board for consideration as a whole. No individual member should establish a priority or deadline for such work unless authorized by the Select Board. That's the works for me, I don't know. Okay, I can't get a written version of it because I [1:04:42] Speaker H (unidentified): can't see the screen, so then the [1:04:57] Speaker C (unidentified): next paragraph that is an addition, so good to, after we, if we're settled on the first one. [1:05:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you scroll back up further? Yeah. Good, right here. [1:05:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, so we have two. [1:05:19] Speaker G (unidentified): So my first question about the deadline piece is that in most cases, the reason why any requests would be made would be in preparation for a meeting. That's the typical reason, and if the agenda is that we start Friday and the meeting is on Tuesday, day I don't know who's authorizing that the deadline is be worthless after the meeting, right. So to not be able to authorize a deadline being before the meeting, we defeat the purpose of oppressing information most of the time. My [1:05:53] Speaker C (unidentified): point is that no member of this board has the authority to give the town manager do this by a certain time because none of us are individually their boss. Collectively you guys explored where their boss, but not any, I'm not sorry, not any individual member. If [1:06:16] Speaker F (unidentified): there's a request that comes in and understanding that it's look, I want this information prior to and we want to end and give a reason, you know, that you're requesting the information prior to a select board meeting, the meeting that's in two days, and do my best to get that information to you, but yes, it's as time allows. But if you flag it and say hey Maria, this is the information I want, including the chair, as I would assume would be required, then we will do everything in our power to get the [1:06:47] Speaker C (unidentified): information out there, and I would think that if information is needed for the meeting, but that would go to the chair, the chair would say oh yeah, we probably shouldn't talk about that until we know XYZ. The chair can table it if they [1:06:57] Speaker E (unidentified): I don't think we have enough information. Right. Or anybody in the group can do. [1:07:02] Speaker A (unidentified): When I first read this, I didn't even consider that it would be specifically two days before a select way meeting. I was thinking of things that if I was asking for recorded historical information, for instance, if we were doing something for the foster bill and I wanted documents that had to, you know, from when we first did the site testing there. So I'm saying it's just not regulated to one lens of a particular select board member. I was reading it from my own lens thinking like, oh, that makes sense, and that I might request information because I would like to see what the development of a property is, and can you get that to me next week because I'm going to meet with Greater Franklin and then have something else, and that might be not, you know, in line with the priorities of what the town manager needs to do, so. Any sense? [1:07:59] Speaker G (unidentified): As I have another minute to read it, and I reread it, I could read it differently to say that the final sentence, the one I'm referring to, only refers to the sentence right before it, immediately prior, not to the first sentence. Then it would make more sense that no priority assigned to work that requires town employees to research, retrieve, compile, summarize, or create should have a deadline. [1:08:30] Speaker C (unidentified): I didn't follow that. That's my own disorganization. [1:08:33] Speaker G (unidentified): Right, so as I read it again and look at the last sentence which mentions the deadline. [1:08:39] Speaker C (unidentified): So the last sentence being no individual member? [1:08:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. That sentence, if it's intended to reference only the immediately preceding sentence, which talks about requests that require title employees to research, retrieve, compile, then having no deadline obviously makes sense. [1:09:02] Speaker E (unidentified): I think it goes for everything. I [1:09:08] Speaker C (unidentified): hold that it applies to everything. And the next paragraph goes on a little bit more time with that, I think. But none of us are authorized to tell Maria what to do and when to do it. We're just not. As much as I'd love to boss her around. It's not appropriate for me to do that. [1:09:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. So I think this is a very good conversation now that you brought it up and I wouldn't have thought of it before. So if I come to a meeting on Tuesday and say, well,, this was on the agenda, but we, as a board, haven't had a quorum since Friday. So there was no opportunity for me to ask for the information before Friday. So all I'm doing on Tuesday is coming to the board to request the information. So that we can talk about it in the following meeting. Because we, as a board, can't give direction between Friday and Tuesday. [1:10:05] Speaker C (unidentified): I would imagine, in that case, you'd come to the meeting and say, well I'd love to talk about this but I don't feel like I'm educated enough to do so. The board can then decide, well, everyone else feels like they are, they might want to proceed anyway, or they can say, yeah, you're right, we should probably stop and get some more information. They can choose to table it, but any one person doesn't get to boss around the town manager because they individually don't feel they have enough to come to the board. Talk to the board. The board decides [1:10:29] Chair: together if they have enough information. Well, that's for me, it's part of the board collectively talking at a meeting. Try [1:10:41] Speaker F (unidentified): To prepare the information to the board with the information that we have at the time that those agenda items and there are times where I follow up with people and say hey you have any other supporting documents that you can send and I'm sure the board knows more history and you guys have lived here very long right well we've pulled stuff because people [1:11:00] Chair: Haven't given back up information reports an agenda right yes but also [1:11:06] Speaker F (unidentified): That information that you're asking prior to if there is this interim you know this time in between then we need to ensure that we're sharing that with all of the board and making sure that all the board has the information same information we try to check try to hand out as much information as we as we have it sometimes you guys have the right to table and make decisions [1:11:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Based off of what you have at that time Nathan I like this part of it all the weren't having the same information. Can we add that into Phil's edits to ensure that five people all have the same pool of information? If the town manager provides anything to one person, they provide it to all five of them. [1:11:48] Speaker D (unidentified): If I may, it's going along with what Dave was, a little different take but along the [1:11:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Same lines, is that if we ask something of the town manager and it goes through basically the chair so the chair can take a long list of things that should and shouldn't be on there and can modify the agenda one way or the other if there is enough information then that would be included in a packet of information that would goes up so that way there if somebody feels that there is something on the agenda and they want more information and ask the chair can get more information on this it's Relevant and there's either enough time to get it there's not enough time to get the chair can reflect and also decide that yes well we'll table it our feel that there isn't enough time to get that information and potentially could be tabled I don't I like the idea that everybody gets the same amount of information but I don't want to create a loop where anything that goes directly to the town manager for requests of information where we're just starting to flood the town manager with emails And I would say that [1:13:02] Chair: I have no reason to suspect when we get our agenda with all the backup information that we don't all get the same group email am I correct we all get the same email you send it send it to us and [1:13:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, I might give them a special Phil edition of the thing. I thought that was your favorite. [1:13:32] Chair: So, thoughts on Phil's amendment? [1:13:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Nathan? I want to add a provision for having everyone have the same information. That's my thought. Nancy? [1:13:46] Speaker E (unidentified): So, every time I email Maria with a question, you want her to respond to all of it? So sometimes it's like, Maria, do you know about this? So ThinkTown can do that. Do you really want that answer back? Or are you just saying what reflects on the agenda? [1:14:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Nathan? According to the provisions that Phil just offered, the question that you just asked would be a violation of the bylaws. [1:14:12] Speaker C (unidentified): Because you would have gone to the chair. Okay. [1:14:14] Speaker E (unidentified): I said it to Maria and David. And he does. I do, right? I'm now doing that. Yeah. But maybe it's, you know, I just think I don't necessarily want all my email, all those emails. Because I'm sure you all ask questions all the time. No. [1:14:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, everybody asks questions. Stop it. [1:14:41] Speaker C (unidentified): If you have exact wording you'd like to add, it would be good to propose it. But I personally am not concerned. [1:14:47] Chair: I don't think it's needed because we get a group email with all documents. [1:14:55] Speaker C (unidentified): I'd be more concerned if you think there's a conspiracy where the town manager is telling certain people one thing with other people something else please for the love of God bring it up because that's a huge thing we should deal with if that's happening if you don't think that's happening it's probably not an issue for the to go into bylaws I'm actually hearing it from way [1:15:11] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm hearing Nate say that if somebody's asking for something if I was asking I'm going to go back for Sivivahar testing of soil, and I thought that was relevant to prepare for something, whether it's a meeting or something down the road, it might be relevant to all members. So I'm not hearing any conspiracy, I'm just saying that I heard it a little differently. [1:15:40] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm not saying just the conspiracy thing. I hope it's a very,, what's the word I'm looking for, non-controversial issues as well. But that's the only reason I would think it would be so important we could put it in the bylaws. Again, if you have wording, please put out the wording, and we'll type something down. Do you have one more? I do. Are we all set with this? Does anyone want to change this to that? The maybe change that Nathan was talking about? Okay. This is pretty much an extension of that. But it occurs to me that we do an annual review with the town manager, and we see how they're doing and whatnot, and sometimes they get put in the crossfires in front of the whole world, and it's not fair to them, and it causes stress for them. And something I think sometimes is lost on us is that we are their supervisor, and we need to have a safe environment for them. So I added this. Supervision of the town manager shall be exercised by the select board as a whole, unless specific authorized by the select board individual members shall not direct, supervise, or assign work to the town manager or any other town employee, because this applies to them as well. The select board should foster a safe respectful and productive working environment in which the town manager is empowered to exercise professional judgment to carry out established priorities and succeed in the role. Any direction or performance related feedback should be timely specific actionable and provided by the select board as a whole. Select board members should seek to be constructive partners to the town to the town manager supporting the effective administration of town business while respecting the TIME AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE POSITION. [1:17:21] Speaker A (unidentified): IS THAT ALL IN VIEW THERE? THE ONLY THING THAT I MIGHT ADD TO THAT, IF WE'RE GOING TO KEEP THAT AND PROVIDE IT BY THE SELECT BOARD AS A WHOLE IN AN EXECUTIVE SESSION, BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE A PERSONNEL MATTER. [1:17:34] Speaker C (unidentified): OH, YEAH, FEEDBACK, YEAH. [1:17:36] Speaker A (unidentified): ANY DIRECTION TO OUR PERFORMANCE-RELATED FEEDBACK SHOULD BE TIMELY SPECIFIC, ACTUAL, AND PROVIDED BY THE SELECT BOARD AS A WHOLE IN AN EXECUTIVE SESSION. YOU KNOW, IF THERE'S FEEDBACK AND WE'RE GOING TO DO IT AT THE BOARD, YOU KNOW, THAT WOULD BE A PERSONNEL. [1:17:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Your show yes I press I think that would apply I'm sorry apply to employees well I've seen I super unfortunate word a board member in the past has taken issue with one of the town employees and took a trip on themselves ourselves to berate them on TV in front of the front everyone that was absolutely not appropriate and I wish we would stop doing that not [1:18:18] Chair: fair to them one person's talent manager not the select board select board has one employee [1:18:26] Speaker D (unidentified): and she does a really great job remember that town manager should be we all know a lot of good ones [1:18:34] Speaker C (unidentified): Anything else I think I think it's reasonable that's the last one I guys want to make sure everyone's okay with it [1:18:58] Chair: All right, we call the workshop over at 518.