Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:24] Chair: all right welcome everybody to the town of waterborough planning board meeting for october 21st 2026. angela can we start with both office
[1:33] Public commenter: all right next on the agenda is public hearing so we will start with the public hearing for
[1:48] Chair: for Old Alfred Road, Tulsa and Realty LLC site plan review, Nick Tully. So now I will open the public hearing before we start. First, we'll have the applicant and or the representative come to the podium and speak. As a reminder, planning board members and town staff may ask only clarifying questions during this part of the agenda. We'll do the application. The applicant will give their presentation and then if people would like to speak, I'll have you raise your hand. I'll call you up to the podium, state your name your address and we're gonna limit speakers to five minutes
[2:20] Speaker C (unidentified): tonight just because of the crowd so it's just we will start with you so my
[2:26] Nick Tully: name is Nick Tully Nelson Realty I purchased the land you 33 old Alfred Road back in July and have the idea and looking for the approval to construct build two 100 by 60 commercial garage buildings that we have them on the plan over there the goal is to construct one of the two buildings now where I will occupy half of the building for my personal storage and whatever and then have the other two available for rent to any potential people who would use it for storage space if that was to get filled up i then would like to have approval to build the second building using it for the same purpose rent and of course if the rent was not enough to fill the building i would then want to be able to allow it to be open for our contractor rent, contractor bays to professional trades contractors, maybe I had mentioned electricians, plumbers, HVAC, painters, items like that. I'm not looking to have tenants of trucking or excavation or landscaping where you would have lots of loud trucks and beat bank and equipment and trailers and junk everywhere. I'm not going to have that. Just a few contractors that may have a few vans placed for them to have materials, run a business out of rather than their home in the area if it was a need where people are now working out of their home, out of their home garages that have the ability to come to an actual commercial location to run their business and have the materials and park their work trucks and have their staff meet and get their daily agendas and go off and do their work. do their jobs wherever they are. That is mainly my idea.
[4:31] Chair: And I think there's a copy of the plans over there as well, right? If anybody has any questions. Okay, so that's your overview. Correct. Okay. so if any, anybody would like to speak, if you could raise your hand and come up to the podium.
[4:51] Angela Bean: And just thank you board. My name is Angela Bean. I live at [address] and I also own the property at 34 Osby Hill Road as well and I'm gonna read mine just because I know other people want to speak and I just want to hit my points so as an abutter to the proposed house and realty development of old Alfred Road I'm here tonight in opposition to the proposed site plan last week I submitted a formal letter and with photographic evidence to the board and to the main Department of Environmental Protection the DEP because of the severity of the potential environmental impacts, I have also escalated this matter to the governor's office and handed the board a copy of that letter as well. I'm here tonight to formally request that this board postpone any vote on the proposed site plan until we receive feedback from the governor's office and or formal evaluation from the DEP. The four critical reasons why this site plan should not be approved in its current form tonight are as follows. First, the contradiction between the developer site plan and the surveyor site plan. While the applicant site plan mislabels the water feature that crosses both our property lines and is labeled a minor pond, the signed and stamped professional survey explicitly identifies this area as wetland. That's in your packets, probably, I don't know if you've seen it, okay. Because of this contradiction, the board must table the approval until the DEP steps in to perform an official wetland delineation report furthermore the applicant has already leveled the land right up to the edge of the normal high water mark of our shared pond encroaching into the protected wetland buffer before the proper evaluation can take place so that was one second is inconsistencies in the development classification the applicant calls this development storage garages under a warehouse classification however the sheer size and scope for these two 60 by 100 foot buildings standing 26 feet high with a total of eight bathrooms eight 12 foot high commercial doors and the capacity to accommodate up to 48 workers is entirely inconsistent with a standard storage garage facility the site plan clearly details that the intent of the applicant is to be able to rent out these bays to contractors painters hvac technicians plumbers and electricians making this a commercial industrial complex and contractor yard miscategorized as storage garages which are held to a less strict oversight so i asked the board to explain or reconcile the mismatch between the storage garage label and the heavy duty infrastructure as i believe the physical capacity the electrical plans bathroom counts and wastewater design flow do not align with the stated zoning use. Third, zoning infringement. The footprint of the second commercial building crosses into an agricultural residential zone, creating another unauthorized land use conflict. I asked the board to identify the zoning district, its applicable permitted uses, and any required approvals before moving forward. it. And fourth, finally, there's no stormwater site plan submitted anywhere that I see. And there's going to be 12,000 square feet of roof area combined with 19 parking spaces creating nearly half an acre of unabsorbent footprint in the low-lying wet area. So like an inch of rain is going to produce like 7,500 gallons of water off those roofs, not including the 19 parking spaces so that's a lot of water pouring into the low-lying wood area the gravel is going to quickly compact under commercial not prevent severe flooding to the surrounding low-lying properties so I request the board require a formal stamped field delineation and a civil engineer storm water design so basically that's it in conclusion because these four critical concerns must be addressed I respectfully request that the board table any voting on approval at this time It is crucial that we secure the final DEP report and conduct a public sidewalk with the planning board before making any final decision. That's it. Thank you.
[9:19] Chair: Sir, come up to the podium, please.
[9:29] Julie Earl: My name is Julie Earl. I live at [address]. I am also an abutter. You might know it. It's a gray ranch with a big red barn across from the back of the elementary school. I concur with everything Angela just said it was a great research and all you did I thank you for [Angela Bean: that my] biggest problem with this is that Steve you haven't used the most recent site plan the most recent agreed upon land separation that we had in the one you used was revised on August 8th of 2022, signed on August 11th of 2022. And it was recorded around that time too. So the site plan that you submitted for Mr. Tully, just one big error is this list, my frontage is 136.9, forgive me, I'm getting blind in my old age, and the actual figure is 165.12. So if that boundary is messed up, then there was a site plan that my brother Bill Earl submitted that he wanted, but that is not the final draft of that.
[11:19] Chair: I believe I used the boundary that was set up for the division.
[11:25] Julie Earl: Well, it says here you used my surveyor, Middle Branch, Brad Lodge there. You referenced his December 16th, 2021, and that is not the most recent one. want. So how do I know? How did any of us know that any of the
[11:47] Planning Board Member: other boundaries are correct? Julie, for public comment, we
[11:50] Julie Earl: just addressed the Oh, sure. Sorry. So I'm not confident that even the setbacks are correct. So anyway, there's that. And I appreciate one of the board members, I'm not sure whom i'm sorry referenced the junkyard that property that mr telly bought was on a junk yard and when we were when i was a young person maybe early 80s my father would go round and round with the dep on that and they kept wanting him to clean it up and wanting him to clean it up and it really went on for like 20 years so before the DEP came down on folks you know cars would leak antifreeze back there oil you name it we all the all of our family pets were buried back there people would bury cans of paint and all sorts of stuff back there so we I personally cannot drink the water at my home i have to bring water in gallons to cook and then i have a water cooler for drinking and i know that my cousin angela her mother was my dad's sister and they live at [address] they cannot drink their water without a filtration system and my plumber tells me that many folks in Waterboro cannot drink their water because it's such a high iron content and also my father had bladder cancer and my brother Jim has cancer all throughout his torso so badly they don't know where it started so there's another woman on the hospital road that has brain cancer so I think it's something that we need to think about. And the whole eight bathrooms thing, man, I don't know anybody on Old Alfred Road that has eight bathrooms. That's a lot of stress on the water system. And I know the garage only has one. I only have one. Some people I'm sure have two, Okay, but eight bathrooms, that's a lot of stress on. I did bring copies of the final from August, 2022 for everyone so you could see it. So those copies of my deed which my brother, James Earl and my other brother, Bill Earl, both signed. Is
[14:51] Chair: there anybody else that would like to address the board?
[14:59] Laura Litalia: Hi, I'm Laura Litalia. I live at [address]. I'm here representing the owner of the property who couldn't be here tonight, Amy Gates. Her land up plots, the very edge of the proposed site. We're agricultural and we're concerned about runoff drainage. The water features, as it were, on the property are not posted correctly on the maps. We do have a stream that runs along the whole edge of the property line and includes touching where they'll be developing. I'd like to see a DP study, have the board propose something for drainage for runoff, snow load on the roof that size, where the water is going to go because the lower half of our property floods every year because of the surrounding wetlands. This is going to affect the entire property because that stream runs along the full edge and we have a hundred acres where wildlife for recreational property at this point in time we don't farm back there but the wildlife wanders through people hunt etc and so forth I just want to make sure that's not gonna affect our water table we all have wells we all have septics my well water my well is only 25 feet deep. What is that runoff is going to do to our water table and what level of contaminant could it put into it long term? I've got no problem with the renting for storage. That's an awesome idea. It's great, but you're also crossing into an agricultural zone on the proposed plan. Obviously the village, that's permissible, but when you start crossing into the agricultural, which is what touches our land, you're inviting a host of problems that are going to like drift into the property and I'd like to see somebody look at research at the DEP study those environmental problems there's a vernal pool on the corner of the property that will be affected by runoff that's a snowed it on our on the maps in the corner of the property so that's our intake on it we'd like to have that taken care of all right thank [Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you, ma'am.] What was your name again? Is there
[17:25] Chair: anybody else that would like to address the board? Okay. Hearing that there's nobody Angela, did we receive any comments?
[17:42] Public commenter: Nope. Nate. He lives. This is good morning. I'm writing ahead of the public hearing scheduled for the Tulsa project, located 53 C. old alpha room. I received a letter from Mr. Tolson on Monday, October 19th, regarding the public hearing, but it included no further information. I have since watched the recording of the previous meeting where this matter was discussed. I am writing in opposition to this project for the following reasons. 1, zoning, this law is split between village and agricultural districts. Approximately one and a half of the proposed buildings appear to be located in the Agricultural District. Please see the attached PDF with the zoning overlay. The magenta line highlights the location of the zoning divide. Per section 3.03 of the Waterboro Zoning Ordinance states, quote, on lots larger than two acres, the applicable district regulations shall be followed in the portion of the lot located in that district. I do not believe to commercial use building should be placed. So, at this point, he's attached a link that links back to the town of water zoning ordinance number 2, unclear use the properties intended use is vague and open to interpretation. The application states project quote project goal is to construct to 100 by 60 buildings. Each building should have four bays 25 feet by 60. Of one building, owner to use two of the four bays for storage, rent other two bays to friends and family. If other two bays are full, build second building to accommodate additional rental space. Most likely offer bays to professional trades businesses for a place of work and quarters to warehouse materials for their offsite job sites. Also, part company vehicles, it's needed and this is not a clearly defined plan. The site plan shows 19 parking spaces and the septic system is designed for 48 people per day. Would there be a limit on the number of vehicles businesses operating on site or equipment stored there? This is a significant amount of traffic into the space. Number three, safety and security. If this is not Mr. Tolson's first full time residents who will monitor the site's security and ensure the parking area and the outdoor storage are kept safe for operating hours. If this is a self storage facility in a place for contractors to meet before work, who will determine the operating hours? Could 48 people be arriving at 4 a.m. every day? Will the site look like a parking lot full of vehicles seven days a week? Number five, stormwater and sanitation. Where is the stormwater management plan for the proposed parking lot? How will runoff, chemical spills, or equipment washing be handled? And where will that water go? Given the lot's existing slope, runoff will flow into my backyard. I have no objection to a barn for the owner's personal use and personal he has bolded, but I do not believe two commercial buildings with eight garage bays and multiple contractors belong at this location. Thank you. meet LaRochelle. Is that the, that was the only one. Angela Bean had submitted as she said it before but she spoke so I do not need to read the link. Alright, I will give
Unfinished Business
[21:36] Chair: everybody the opportunity one more time if there's any more public comment. If not I will close the public hearing. So we'll move on in the agenda. Next is old business. So I guess we'll jump right back in and go to Old Alfred Road, Tulsa and Realty LLC site plan review. Just a reminder to the crowd here tonight that now this portion is the board's ability to address the applicant, the public should keep their cannot address comments at this point. So this is our time to ask questions. And then so Mr. Tully, I don't know who wants to speak at this round. But yeah, Yep, if you could get it back up to the, I don't know that we need to go through the overview again. Maybe Michaela, we can start with your memo. I guess. Yeah, sure.
[22:30] Julie Earl: So, I guess I will talk about the.
[22:34] Planning Board Member: use first since that would probably have been a few different comments. So from my perspective, this is an allowed use that fits into a few different use categories which I think can perhaps contribute to the confusion. In the village zone, both warehousing and contractor businesses are primary uses. The storage and selling of local farm forest or orchard products is a conditional use in that zone. In the A&R zone contractor businesses and the storage and selling of local farm forest or orchard products are both primary uses so as I look at the application and look at those zones both those zones allow for the storage of business material related to those in particular contracting businesses and if you wanted to rent to you know local farm forest or orchard related businesses both of those things would be allowed additionally in all of our zones accessory uses to primary uses are allowed which generally includes garages and it is really only before the planning board for site plan review because it is a non-residential use so all non-residential uses in our zone must go before the planning board another thing i will brought up i brought up in my memo that has been brought up as concerns is about the wetland or finer pond that is partly located on the property is about 940 square feet and so neither shoreland zoning nor the natural resource protection act standards applied to the wetland it is exempt from both of those. So, it's exempt from DEP or NRPA permitting or from shoreland zoning because it's just too small. So, if that pond was wholly on the applicant's property, they could completely fill it in with no permitting required. There are absolutely no standards related to that I know that there's a berm on the property based on a survey photo I was shown but I do think showing on the site plan the control measures used during construction would be helpful showing any silt fences or other measures that help prevent runoff would be a helpful thing to show on the plan set. Since last time the applicant adjusted the buffer was a fence buffer on the one side and after talking to that abutter they changed it to a vegetated buffer so that's now shown on the site plan. Any questions about those assessments so far? so the buffer that you just mentioned is that on the current map that we have it's on the one marked b3 and it's also uploaded on the town public hearing site now as soon as i was sent in it's also available over there if anyone wants to look at it and that was where the proposed privacy defense was going it's now vegetation study and i will point out too just based on a concern i heard about there already being a condition of approval on the plan about any equipment or materials being contained within the building and that the property would never turn into a junkyard or have materials stored in places that weren't approved by the planning board It was just a note that concern was addressed by you all previously.
[27:03] Chair: Right,. Where we would put that as a condition, right? Yeah. Did
[27:13] Planning Board Member: I ask other questions? Yes. Go ahead. So the clearing of the property up to this point, were there cars and everything on that property before you started or was that all cleared? No, it was all cleared.
[27:32] Nick Tully: Okay. It was minor pieces and items that we moved while we were moving around some of the piles that were existing. Some items were there.
[27:47] Planning Board Member: And who was responsible for moving all that material prior to, and are there any, because it was a junkyard or storage of old vehicles, was there any, is there any requirement to do like a site test or whatever yeah he chose to do one oh you did choose anyone else yeah it's in the file yeah extensive there was everything came back
[28:19] Nick Tully: late we went down in a ground water samples for any contaminants any I heard someone mentioned any phrases or oils we did several test pits back in June new before I purchased it from Bill and yes, everything came back clean.
[28:35] Planning Board Member: Okay, good. Yep. Thank you for reminding me. Yeah. It's the last attachment and the one called packet in your folder. It's also called packet. And is there a current concern regarding the use of the incorrect site plan in regards the description see around the frontage and proper representation of the abutters I heard a concern about incorrect frontage on an abutting property not on this property so I think the question was if there was one error on that site were there others and shouldn't they use the current just to
[29:22] Speaker C (unidentified): make sure that's
[29:25] Chair: what I heard and I think you're saying it is the current one correct was that yes I took them it's a long story sure I modified my overall boundary to what the court decision was for the division of land including the frontage along old alfred road with some minor changes but the division itself was pretty much this i mean that's i use that division and
[30:32] Planning Board Member: in your staff reviews has anybody done a site from council kind of site no we did not have a site walk so one of my recommendations was to determine whether you feel like a sitewalk is needed I'm confused that we're in a drought and we have a stream so I'm not doubting you but I'm sounds like there's active water so just wondering if anybody has seen this no any
[31:29] Speaker C (unidentified): other questions from the board I'm just
[31:32] Planning Board Member: going to point something out so one of the one of the comments was towards the septic system and for 48 people the septic system isn't designed for people it is but it is so in this instance it's designed for 48 people it's 12 gallons per day so usually a house is designed for per bedroom you get 90 gallons per bedroom this system is designed for 576 gallons it's it's equivalent to a six and a half bedroom house is what the system is these bathrooms aren't used they're not going to be used as much as a as a residential structure would be used they're going to be you know it's going to be a very low impact septic system to say the least yeah it's an occasional use you know morning and afternoon so no shower no laundry right you get yeah you have you have more of a septic when you deal with a restaurant or anything like that so i've reviewed these plans these plans are designed by licensed site evaluators and the one that did this is a very they're very trustworthy so and as well as it has to be designed as a first time system so it meets all the criteria from wetlands wells everything like that so that shouldn't be a concern i mean ever it's a concern for anybody else but i'm just letting you know from my office
[32:59] Speaker C (unidentified): it's hard and i'm assuming the bathroom is just toilet and sink yes yeah just in the morning
[33:06] Nick Tully: you got to go you have a place to go sure and the reason why it's for our building is they're going to be four separate units basically so i wasn't planning on having a shared bathroom you know just everyone has their own space basically if they're in their rental unit right yeah and
[33:30] Chair: and that's all it would be correct like you're not expecting somebody to use it as rental and their business right like I don't know oh I guess I'll use the example of what you wanted to do that I think it was generators correct yes I install generators yes okay so you have the generators there would you be doing assembly there where you would be there for hours right here you're just picking something up to bring it to another location, right? So the expectation wouldn't be that there'd be 10 people working there for eight hours a day or anything like that.
[34:02] Nick Tully: I mean, I was just thinking, am I, am I going to speak right now? Oh yeah. I was just thinking local contractors here in Guatemala that may take use of this, an opportunity. That's all for, growing, you know, trades are growing everywhere. So again, I mean, I started out of my house in my garage, my garage full of work stuff, my yard full of work stuff. and i was able to get into my facility in seabrook new hampshire and do the same thing down there and it's worked out very well and it's clean it's neat i actually have pictures if you want to see just let you know it's not going to be a junkyard or whatever and up here you know being on the lake we have boats that i'd like to store there rather than take them to other places and other friends on the lakes same purpose that was the ideal goal trailers and you know whatever we need so just a space an overflow space for us and then if anybody wanted their own space to rent you know this is the opportunity help me with the cost of the construction and taxes and
[35:08] Speaker C (unidentified): all that stuff too that will be due every year every year so how does this com how do these
[35:14] Chair: buildings compare in size to what was put on logan circle very similar same size same size okay
[35:23] Speaker C (unidentified): we did that right yep
[35:30] Chair: very similar where he did the first garage and then added the second garage so
[35:35] Speaker C (unidentified): that's a smaller lot i think i don't recall a lot of size advocate may have been you know I
[35:45] Planning Board Member: wasn't done. I have two questions. Security issues on the property. Is that, Michaela, something that pertains just to the individual owns the property or does it go beyond that? What are the requirements from a legal perspective there? Yeah, so there's a standard in the site plan ordinance kind of about just not negatively affecting neighboring properties so it's, it's fairly vague, but generally not having lighting that shines directly to things like that not causing security concerns, you know, wanted ones. ones. And if it did, it would be up to the owner to rectify it and with the owner personally using some of the space there. He is, I would assume personally motivated to keep it safe and secure every site.
[36:44] Nick Tully: I will have surveillance cameras if that helps your concern.
[36:50] Planning Board Member: And I think the other thing that was about the operating force is going to be there at three o'clock, four o'clock, five o'clock, I mean, 10 o'clock at night,
[36:57] Nick Tully: I can clarify, you know, appropriate time, you know, with anyone that we have in there said that these are the rules for our place, you know, 7 a.m., you know, 6 p.m., Monday through Friday, you know, and if some people say, oh, no, I operate at 3 a.m., that they're not fit for that location. Yeah, you can't operate here.
[37:23] Planning Board Member: I know you don't put the equipment together, but do you test it? Like start a generator?
[37:29] Nick Tully: No,. So I know you asked me the question. I don't know if I answered it, but how we operate is we get generators shipped to us from the manufacturer and then we store them. I mean, I, in Seabrook, I do about 60 stored units. I've been getting busy up in this area doing generators again, meeting people, knowing people from the local area, local towns. and I have been reached out by my manufacturer to start taking this area on for potential seals for generators so they come to me we warehouse them and then coming in the morning we take one and take the equipment we need the wire the gas pipe load up our truck a van and then we leave and go install it and then we come back drop off the van get my personal vehicles and go home okay I was
[38:19] Planning Board Member: just isn't that as an example in case you tested it and had to run it real quick no would there be any kind of guidelines in regards to you can't have loud noises it before 8 a.m. in the morning or whatever you don't have a
[38:35] Nick Tully: noise but you I could make it just to be practical and consider part of the
[38:42] Planning Board Member: rental agreement whatever you have don't yeah low on the horns at 6 a.m. I
[38:49] Chair: understand absolutely and I think I think I read and maybe one of the communications that was submitted and the generator expert but I thought there was something about something about batteries and their concern with
[39:03] Speaker C (unidentified): batteries in the storage did see that too so we don't know you know there's
[39:07] Nick Tully: no any large battery systems if that's what the concern was but you know we do use 12 volt car batteries for these generators to stock those engines but we typically only stock 12 or so at a time so and then there was another concern with that as well but it's it's a this is the business i do yeah it's very quiet and that's why i had said professional trades meaning electricians plumbers they operate the same way they come in load up their truck go to their remote daily job do it and come back it's just a place for them to keep their tools and equipment and materials and meet and congregate and go over the daily tasks of it come back it's not going to be open for the general public to come in and look at things it's you know when I had said private meaning like you know not open to the public just only who is renting here should be
[40:04] Planning Board Member: in here that's how i want it to be yeah but i think we talked about there'd be no like signage
[40:10] Nick Tully: inviting people in like no yeah i mean i want to keep it that's why i like that lot it's behind the old bandies it's kind of hidden i was trying to put the buildings over in that corner i do have plans of doing you know some landscape shrubbery and all that around everywhere and try to bring some trees back in because it's pretty leveled right now but yeah make it look
[40:34] Speaker C (unidentified): good you know keep it clean questions
[40:44] Planning Board Member: are you good well we have the middle school right there
[40:48] Public commenter: and i know that speeding's always been an issue and we had we just have a sign up basically no flashing lights do we know what the threshold is for like maine d.o.t to come in and like put more signage or something that's a little bit more bland than what's there the
[41:07] Planning Board Member: last I talked to them about speeds on that road they said their process is to do and basically a speed study and the speed study indicates that 80% 80th percentile speed is faster than what's there that they would raise the speeds even if the concern is to lower the speed so I said okay like, protection with school, so I don't think they generally go lower.
[41:41] Public commenter: Yeah. Like, they don't even, I don't even know that on that road that they have, like, a blinking sign. I think it's just a sign that says, oh, like, 2 and 3 years close to 50 miles an hour.
[41:53] Planning Board Member: I guess I don't I don't know. I can look into that.
[41:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Sure. What's your concern?
[42:00] Public commenter: My just concern is it's a busy road as it is, and it's supposed to be a 15-minute number, so I don't know what the actual business is into that area.
[42:13] Chair: That may trigger a little bit more.
[42:15] Planning Board Member: I know they wouldn't trigger a traffic movement format through the DOT, so my guess would be that it wouldn't trigger anything else. It would more be a something, it would be separate from the business, more like an initiative, you know, rather than anything to do with this planning application yet. That would be my assumption.
[42:50] Speaker C (unidentified): So, Mikayla, my concern, one of my concerns or clarifications I guess I just want to be clear about is there's obviously some concerns from the group about runoff and stormwater
[43:04] Chair: and all that stuff.
[43:06] Speaker C (unidentified): From what I heard you say earlier, both the AR and the village zones allow this project, correct? So, I mean, he meets those standards. He did do test pits of test spots where the water came back positive or not positive, but good. And you're saying, I thought you said that the DEP, this doesn't meet the criteria to get DMP involved.
[43:37] Planning Board Member: So I reached out to DEP. I sent them the packet as well as one of the lengthy complaints that we had with photos and their concerns I'm pretty much got a response back. We're the size of the wetland of the of the So there's there's a larger wetland behind the property that this doesn't even affect the size of the wetland that is Shown on this Our GIS shows is 950 square foot but he literally came back and said, does it meet the requirements? If the, let me pull the email. Give me a second.
[44:11] Speaker C (unidentified): I saw the picture. I think there's some pictures in there with the packet.
[44:16] Planning Board Member: Yeah, so if the wetland qualifies for alteration exemption, it can be filled in entirely. And that's a forested wetland, things like that. If it's on your own personal property, right same thing not big enough to make any kind of impact so and where he's not proposing all pervious surfaces so impervious surfaces pavement and stuff like that doesn't trigger stormwater and the size of the thing right obviously we would want to work with him to minimize any stormwater runoff to the adjacent properties but it's not triggering anything through the state
[44:56] Speaker C (unidentified): that's kind of what i thought i just wanted to confirm all that okay good thank you neither
[45:06] Planning Board Member: Michaela, you are in your, I don't know if we could, can we talk about your memo?
[45:11] Julie Earl: Yeah, I read through it.
[45:12] Chair: That's what we're doing, we're going through it. We're almost done with it.
[45:15] Planning Board Member: So you have, aside from that, accepting all of that discussion that just transpired, you have suggested to require sedimentation and soil erosion control measures to be added to the plan. add were they not added in the last in this last version is that what you're saying correct they're not on the plan they're not on the plan yeah that is I'm not it's it's basically an extra thing the board could require of the applicant to show that the standard is met I don't extra thing or is it best practice I would say best practice but not entirely not completely required so that's why I did not say that. I did not stop. So what would that look like on this plan. A drawing of a silt fence showing where the silt fence would be located during construction and if they do a soil berm which I believe exists now. Yeah, illustrating where the soil berm is on the property. Talking about, you know, what, revegetation might look like in affected areas that would then help with the tree line. Yeah.
[46:50] Chair: Which hasn't been done, correct? We wouldn't want would we are you asking for something different than what's been added to the plan for the
[46:57] Planning Board Member: the vegetation shown as the vegetative buffer for screening purposes so that's more about like leaf cover yeah versus showing like ground vegetation oh I got you okay so if we put that in as a condition we would need just need to see that updated on that all right if we're talking about update on the plan just because I didn't mention it to Michaela I'd like to see where snow storage would go just to ensure that it is adequate and it's distanced from the property lines just so when it does melt and thaw that we have a good idea where that's gonna be so
[47:57] Chair: we think if we're good right now I think the first thing that we need to discuss is whether we want to do a site sidewalk, because that was mentioned.
[48:09] Speaker C (unidentified): What is everybody's feeling about sidewalks?
[48:17] Planning Board Member: I would like to.
[48:26] Chair: How about we start with a motion? So how about we get a motion to hold the sidewalk. Looks like we're proposing November 4th, which I don't know.
[48:38] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, that's the Wednesday. Okay.
[48:40] Planning Board Member: Yeah, we're next meeting it at five. So before the start of what the sun goes down, which is now won't be well, that's after the time change. Yeah. That's not going to be early enough.
[49:03] Speaker C (unidentified): You want a motion? I'll make a motion.
[49:06] Chair: Well, we need either a motion. I need a motion first to hold a sidewalk and see how that vets out. And then I'll need another motion to not do one if we decide not to do one. So you want to do a sidewalk. If you're making the motion, then don't make the motion, because
[49:22] Speaker C (unidentified): that means you're voting for it. Don't do it.
[49:26] Chair: Mark, I think you want to.
[49:27] Planning Board Member: I'm probably the only one. I'll make a motion to hold a sidewalk for this on November 4th whatever time i can actually say things and people are available thank you second so
[49:47] Speaker C (unidentified): can i get a motion to not hold the site book for the application i'll get a motion i'll make a motion to not do a site mark for this old alfred road project and i'll second that motion not told all those in favor to a post as well Oh one folks correct and one I want to see the string all right I'm just deadly curious about this is recommendation to postpone
[50:26] Chair: based on adding of the snow removal sedimentation and soil erosion control measures so I could get a motion to postpone a vote on final approval of this application until a future meeting following the updated submittal of the
[50:42] Planning Board Member: plans I get this help you can just say I'm so moved yeah because I just said the motion so yeah wow i'm so rude i moved to postpone the vote on the final proof of this application based on the two conditions that need to be added for the erosion soil erosion control measures and the snow storage i'll talk about those in favor all right so if we can just
[51:17] Chair: make those adjustments to the plan then we'll reconvene go over the changes okay
[51:22] Planning Board Member: awesome thank you very much thank you and just to clarify since people in here will probably be interested whether or not it will be on the November 4th agenda will depend on when they can submit it ahead of time so just pay attention to the website the agenda and you'll see if it's listed or not for if it's not the 4th, then it would be potentially the 3rd Wednesday, November, but that is the day before Thanksgiving. So we may have to discuss that. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you.
[51:59] Chair: Okay, next under old business is who Hill road 1, not subdivision preliminary review. Steve ever representation representative.
[52:11] Speaker C (unidentified): good evening how are you everybody hello how are you today pretty swell how you doing good
[52:35] Chair: so at the end of the last meeting you required another test pit which has been done the logs have been submitted and a hundred foot radius has been placed around that for no well, installation, and other than that, it's pretty much the same. Any questions from here? I think that was really the ending thing.
[53:17] Speaker C (unidentified): We vetted, I think, the rest of it. Yeah. All set. Yeah. I'm
[53:33] Chair: good. So as a reminder, under. So we did have some condition about the 25% lot
[53:52] Speaker C (unidentified): coverage as a result. So I just want to mention that.
[53:56] Chair: So I guess if there's no questions, if I can have a motion to approve the preliminary subdivision plan for Hooping Hill Road with the condition about the lot coverage as discussed. dust so
[54:10] Speaker C (unidentified): that's just basically like you can only use so much of the land you'd have to leave it like you know woods or whatever yeah 20 which is 25 you could basically come here out yeah oh you could cover with the house or clear no you can clear all of it 's impervious like buildings oh okay i highly doubt they're going to be yeah exactly it's not a good size lot 25% sounds like a lot but it really isn't yeah no I mean it's two acres so
[54:56] Planning Board Member: yeah as we talked about it's a basically a preventative safeguard so that way if you had if you sold it and the person wanted yes impervious service over the whole thing they couldn't I'm good I'm good I moved to approve preliminary subdivision plan road with the condition around the lot coverage as discussed.
[55:35] Speaker C (unidentified): All right,
[55:38] Chair: so then we, on the next meeting, we'll do the findings of facts.
[55:43] Planning Board Member: Well, final approval, final approval is 1st, but since we didn't have any additional changes other than just adding the condition words on to the site plan or the subdivision plan excuse me you would likely be able to do findings of fact at
[56:02] Speaker C (unidentified): the next week so that's it that's it so next week another one more one more one more yeah sure so it'd be simple hopefully right yeah i don't know it seems like a lot more fun anyway all right we could come to any other beach
New Business
[56:22] Chair: like i'm part of the team now and there's an opening that's right All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. So we're all set. All set for tonight. Thank you. All right. Next on the agenda, new business, 87 things, middle road, Verda, cell tower, site, plan, review, Matthew Bowen, representative.
[56:55] Staff/Representative: So I understand the revised plans have not made it here physically, so we're going to try to project the plans here on the screen and discuss them. So I apologize about that inconvenience, although you might have the digital copies
[57:15] Nick Tully: in front of you anyway. We're going to stick them up there in a second.
[57:20] Planning Board Member: Maybe you could talk through it, and then I'll work on getting those up there.
[57:24] Staff/Representative: So the proposal is simple. It's a 120-foot monopole cell tower that's being proposed in a forest agricultural zoning lot where there's already a single-family residence. In order to access that back lot, there is an easement through the front lot off of the Things Road, and the cell tower will be within a fenced compound, and there's already Verizon as the cellular company as the applicant.
[58:02] Planning Board Member: We'll have one on the phone call for you next time. Which plan would you like me to be on?
[58:12] Staff/Representative: Well, your memo has concerns on the fire department turnaround, so I think that would be, but really wherever the board has questions, I'm happy to answer.
[58:28] Planning Board Member: I would describe the project a bit, just since it's the first time the board is hearing this.
[58:32] Staff/Representative: Yeah, so like I said, 120-foot cell tower. It's a monopole. so monopole means it's a singular pole where with at the top with the arms that connect to the rf transmitters as opposed to the style of cell tower where you may see like multiple triangular shaped where it has cross wires and bars so it's going to be a single pole whole structure at 120 feet with the different transmitters at the top, and then they can go additional tenants below. The primary and first tenant is Verizon, hoping to fill the gaps in coverage in that area. The spot is particular, and this is common with a lot of cell tower development because whether or not there has to be a full NEPA study or abbreviated NEPA study because of the federal regulations over the wireless license in this particular you know as in many parts in rural Maine there 's some forested wetlands and the crossing of an initial stream which required a full NEPA study. In that, we have very, carefully placed it in about the only spot that we can without doing another full NEPA study and without potentially causing any sort of environmental impact. So it's a thousand foot road that goes into the back lot in the compound and it's carefully placed along the way. And then the compound itself, both with the topography and the location is set to avoid any sort of environmental impact. And what questions do you have that I could answer? I know you guys probably don't get a lot of cell towers. Let's start with generic. So what questions do you have about cell tower development
[1:01:01] Chair: that I can answer? So the first picture that you showed of the actual tower, are those the ones that sometimes they make look like trees?
[1:01:08] Applicant/Representative: This one will not look like a tree.
[1:01:12] Staff/Representative: Yes, we call those monopines. They're a type of monopole structure, but this is going to be a traditional monopole, where it'll be not attempting to be anything it's not.
[1:01:25] Planning Board Member: Incidents of fires on monocled towers over the last 12 months in New England. i'm sorry the incidence of the incidence of fires of monocle towers or transmission in new england
[1:01:39] Staff/Representative: for over the last 12 to 24 months i can definitely get that answer i can tell you
[1:01:46] Planning Board Member: every week does it happen every six months you know does it happen what burns metal aren't they
[1:01:54] Staff/Representative: well i mean you have electrical components so you're always going to have and particularly when you have storms there is going to be some risk but i would say it would be a very minimized risk that whenever you have electrical you know exposed to the elements there's always that natural risk but that being said it would be within the 50 by 50 compound tomorrow away from any residential so and to the extent that there is any fires the road would be able to allow for fire access back there from an emergency and safety response perspective the more likely although once again still very minimal risk is if we have maintenance crews doing periodic inspections to check on you know make sure everything's safe it can happen that there could be someone who slips falls and the more likely fire and safety issue would be a rescue from a climber but in terms of electrical fire risk more than your utility poles or utility lines okay
[1:03:09] Planning Board Member: let's see some data on that okay so do the fires the electrical fires then cause forest fires
[1:03:21] Staff/Representative: well i think any fire would cause any fire but once again this is i've not heard of any particular instance where the cell tower has been a cause of a fire it's not to say that it can't happen or that it hasn't happened but realistically you know when you're dealing with the equipment and the grounding, the types of galvanization and bonding involved, it does seem to be more theoretical and rare than likely, but still happy to try to get some additional information.
[1:03:59] Chair: How many other types of these self-towers do we have in the town of Waterboro today?
[1:04:08] Planning Board Member: Do we have others? Do,.
[1:04:14] Chair: So, and it's, and it's a similar scenario, somebody's residents, this is how it's typically done. Sorry.
[1:04:26] Public commenter: Mouth is the 1 up on the mountain. Yep. But the other 2 remaining are similar to this, they have at least a spot on somebody's property. And we've, to my knowledge, there's, we can, I can check with Mike.
[1:04:41] Speaker C (unidentified): frazier there's been no issues no issues i think is lyman actually isn't it 's at the end is that waterborne deering ridge that one might be lyman i think that's lyman that's the end
[1:04:55] Public commenter: we've got one off old alfred road and one up off jackson ridge and are they as remote as what this over is yeah well old alfred road is not known as remote the chapel bridge road
[1:05:09] Planning Board Member: has to back along which road is 120 125 feet 120 feet i'm not familiar with towers are they
[1:05:23] Applicant/Representative: is there a fence around it so nobody so it will be a fence compound and really if we could
[1:05:29] Staff/Representative: go back maybe to the first or second page so this is a great example either of these will do you can see how far back it is set from things road and so really you're gonna have trees all the way at 120 feet you know really the top is going to crest over the trees a little bit obviously you need you know to be higher than the trees for the propagation purposes but in terms of just driving down the road I mean if you're driving down that main road you're not going to be able to look back and see the tower because of your i wasn't worried about seeing the towers
[1:06:09] Applicant/Representative: people loitering going there well so if you can't see the tower you're not going to know
[1:06:14] Staff/Representative: the tower is necessarily there but it will be within a fence compound because you're dealing with safety and security of the equipment i
[1:06:26] Speaker C (unidentified): want the road going into it is that going to have a gate keep people from going in there and dumping do you know it shares a private driveway Yeah, you would need the fire access there too. Yeah, I know that. I know you. Yeah, but I didn't know if it needed to have a gate.
[1:06:41] Staff/Representative: There's not currently an attempt to have a gate anywhere along the access road.
[1:06:50] Planning Board Member: How close is the residence?
[1:06:53] Public commenter: Oh, I mean,
[1:06:57] Staff/Representative: hundreds of feet. I mean, the access road itself is a thousand feet. feet. It's 147 feet to the nearest property line. And then even from there, it's going to be much, more feet before you even get to a residence. So you can see right there is the compound. So from the compound to this boundary is 147 feet. And so the nearest road, there's a house here I believe that's a house too I mean so you're looking at 400 feet approximately
[1:07:41] Planning Board Member: so that you say you have a potential client Verizon is and today can be a tower five different companies yes or no I mean they can be used for anyone there can be multiple tenants
[1:07:55] Staff/Representative: And it's ideally every carrier wants to be the top. That's gonna be the best real estate on the tower.
[1:08:07] Chair: I will tell you it's desperately needed in that town. I lived on Route 5 in North Waterloo and actually couldn't even work remotely during COVID from my house because the reception was so bad
[1:08:19] Speaker C (unidentified): and the internet was so bad.
[1:08:20] Staff/Representative: Sure. And, you know, that's a common complaint that, you know, here all across Maine. Oh, look at that. Pretty fancy. I appreciate that. All across Maine. Look, I live in Brunswick. I commute to Portland and there's this spot on 295 that I say, okay, hon, hold on. Not here. And it always comes down to zoning. You know, we have these holes and we try to fill the holes, and but we run against you know you have a zoning that only allows it in certain places and you have the need but then you have the wetlands and all of these things and yeah so just you know trying to fill the holes comes with just
[1:09:02] Chair: regulatory I think it's it's very interesting because I think everybody's assumes that every emergency call is going to 9-1-1 yeah but not every emergency call goes tonight sure there's other emergencies and if you don't have cell reception and now houses are even built without phone jacks in them that's what you're relying on and it makes it tough when you can't pick your phone up and call somebody yeah it's
[1:09:27] Planning Board Member: frustrating who's responsible for plowing isn't the person who owns the property but the people
[1:09:34] Applicant/Representative: that rent the space the for from that long road going into that tower i believe that's
[1:09:44] Staff/Representative: going to be the responsibility of sqf as the tenant to ensure because yes because they're also going to have maintenance needs you know even when things are perfectly going fine you still need to inspect the tower to make sure that nothing's becoming loose you're not having any corrosion issues you know those kinds of things so it i'm not going to say it's an every day every week or every month kind of thing but you will have workers accessing that lot and then And of course, if there is a storm and cell tower goes down, you wanna have that lot available, that back compound available so that you can get the crews in there to get the signal back and propagating.
[1:10:24] Planning Board Member: And the easements are already in place. So is the road partially there?
[1:10:29] Staff/Representative: There's a... So you have...
[1:10:33] Planning Board Member: Let's see, there's a little tiny dot on the backside of it.
[1:10:37] Staff/Representative: Tiny dot. Oh, the shine on the... So, right now, you've got an initial driveway and then the road does not exist. So, I would be intended to be constructed from the edge of this driveway in between the house and the garage going forward.
[1:11:00] Planning Board Member: And Jason, we would require them to build the road in accordance with our road. yeah so we that was one of the things that our fire marshals as required as well as jason champion yeah and yeah then yes so they want it done according to nfpa so the fire truck can get in there in turn in case anything happens emergency services can get in there turn around and all this other good stuff so there will be also be a knox box included so that the fire department can get into there if they need to do any kind of emergency shut down yeah so i will
[1:11:36] Staff/Representative: note that our request is for a 12 foot wide as opposed to the 20 foot but we do propose doing a couple bulge outs so that the vehicles could pass by each other the reason for not trying to do the whole thing at 20 is because of those environmental concerns and the topography but when i met with the staff there was the concern about making sure that an exiting emergency vehicle can still pass a incoming emergency vehicle particularly if you're dealing with one of the climbers who needs to exit for in an ambulance so 12 feet with a few couple bulges that go out to 20 feet to accommodate those passerbys but not the entire road at 20 feet so here 's the kind of the concern with the fire that's noted in the memo from town staff now originally we had it at 44 feet but we learned that your guys's biggest truck is only approximately 41 feet so we were able to revise and revise some of the area for the y turn we might be able to push it out a little bit further but where the truck partially overhangs here because this would be the compound that would be leveled and stuff you can see that the tires remain still on the leveled part and so you know the fire truck still should be able to make the hammerhead turn around with that despite seeing the truck kind of protruding a little bit beyond that leveled ground because that part would be not where the axles and the wheels would
[1:13:23] Planning Board Member: be i think the concern that mike had brought up during the staff meeting and that i still have here looking at this is that this is the idealized computer model of a person operating the fire truck and that back wheel on the top is on the exact edge of the surface area so if a human operator is not meeting and doing the exact angles they're not gonna they're not gonna stay. The other thing is I'm
[1:13:56] Chair: assuming that our fire truck may be a little smaller right now. Right, that's what I was going to say. It sounds like our future. Wouldn't we plan that there's a chance that we would have a more
[1:14:07] Planning Board Member: standardized truck? We did well we did ask Mike about that and he said not in the next like 15 years could he imagine having a truck yeah so the other aspect is the captain sully landing on the Hudson aspect this is under ideal conditions drawn by a computer with no pressure on a driver what happens when the damn thing's burning up and everyone's rallying to get in or out having six inches to move a truck may not be enough the overhang also might be tricky if the wind and the winter if the snow is a great season i'll watch the movie again
[1:14:54] Speaker C (unidentified): that's a good point though right if we move snow when it's backed up yeah snow too yeah good point oh
[1:15:05] Planning Board Member: mate snow i know nothing about these towers is there any environmental issues with
[1:15:09] Public commenter: So a lot of times we have like 1,500-foot setbacks from cell towers in place, including Bar Harbor, but it's actually a recommendation for cell phone towers. So I guess we don't have necessarily any setbacks for these.
[1:15:33] Planning Board Member: No, our ordinance just says where feasible, move it back to keep the initial ratio of the setback to the height. So the zone's height limitation is 35 feet, setback of 100. So maintaining that ratio as much as possible where feasible.
[1:15:54] Public commenter: So it's based on like a building perspective, not necessarily an EPA type or environment.
[1:16:00] Staff/Representative: that's true if I think I understand your question you're asking about setbacks
[1:16:05] Public commenter: from one cell tower to another it looks like cell phone towers to homes and
[1:16:12] Staff/Representative: schools oh okay well it's showing I'm not surprised that Bar Harbor is
[1:16:20] Public commenter: requiring a let's just want to main sorry I'm just curious I'm not sure that
[1:16:27] Staff/Representative: bar harbors would pass federal preemption because 1500 feet from any home or school is extreme quarter mile yeah i will tell you in my experience typically we see a one-to-one setback plus a certain number of feet maybe 20 feet or 50 feet from property lines or housing structures the idea being there is that if there is any sort of in the very extreme and rare situation that a cell tower does collapse due to high winds and weather conditions that there would be no fall risk on any abutting property or residential structures so that's the typical setback that I see with cell towers, the setback from schools, that's a more rare, you know, we all use cell phones. Obviously, you know, our school children are not going to be standing up next to these, you know, high power RF antennas right at the, you know, by the time the signal reaches any of our cell phones, it's already at a, you know, the normal ratio, which, you know, the FCC and other entities have, you know, long regulated and determined safe.
[1:18:09] Planning Board Member: So environmentally, because I like, I don't, I don't know anything about towers. Are there any, is there any harm? Is it generating anything off of it that would cause harm to animals, people?
[1:18:25] Staff/Representative: well so once again when you're dealing with RF propagation at like at the very near base there can be you know safety precautions so like the individuals who are working on the towers are going to take safety precautions to not be in the direct line but the fence would be enough to keep people of course even at our base yeah and that's once again you know the standards that have been long determined and regulated by the federal government. I'm learning.
[1:19:01] Public commenter: There are preliminary studies and studies that are ongoing. And so Maine actually has the highest childhood cancer rate per capita in the nation. So it's just something that I think should be put in a thought.
[1:19:16] Staff/Representative: Yeah, I mean, even assuming those preliminary studies, you know have any merit and definitely not conceding that issue at all we're we're talking about a single tower very remote in the part of town that has no cellular signal but once again you know that kind of the signal and safety combination is regulated by the federal government and so all of the carriers who are operating have to comply as a part of their license, and ensuring that their equipment is properly tuned to those safety metrics. But I hear your concern. To the extent there is any concern, it would not be applicable with this particular site.
[1:20:16] Planning Board Member: All right, I have an odd question. Of course. I have helicopters go by on my property all the time in planes low because I'm sure they're looking for crops is there any type of issue with these towers do they need to have any type of alerts on them or blinking lights or whatever it is for anything that's flying around I
[1:20:42] Staff/Representative: have no idea FFA FAA does not require any sort of blinking light stop requirement does not become implicated until 250 feet there still may be faa
[1:20:56] Speaker C (unidentified): registration just for an awareness to there's one in the area yes 120 feet there's something going on wrong okay let's have a look up just get pretty low yeah 120 beats not very far honestly well i wouldn't want to be on top of it i don't know that So
[1:21:24] Staff/Representative: I think there's further discussion changes in regards to the turnaround. Right? I'm hearing in the turnaround. Yes. Yeah. Yeah, that does seem to be the singular point of concern from staff and the memo, we will, we'll review and, you know, revise to the greatest extent possible without implicating a full NEPA. redoing the NEPA, and we'll see what we're able to adjust and propose as part of that adjustment.
[1:22:01] Planning Board Member: I don't know if this is commercially sensitive, but what's the proposed service area in terms of
[1:22:08] Speaker C (unidentified): households or mileage?
[1:22:12] Staff/Representative: How big does it serve? Sure. Yeah. Happy to submit the propagation, the proposed propagation as a additional somebody else like
[1:22:27] Planning Board Member: me who has property near there will I now get a cell signal because I certainly don't now McKinley mentioned something about streams and wetlands yeah I just found the plan to be a little visually difficult to read in terms of what kind of stream it is which matters for what the setback requirements are in our ordinances and then just visually it looks like the setbacks for the wetlands are far enough but they're not numerically specified so i just adding those setbacks from the wetlands would be helpful to the impervious surface.
[1:23:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Any other questions for tonight?
[1:23:31] Staff/Representative: So I know staff has provided the recommendation on whether or not you are wanting to do a site walkthrough.
[1:23:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, that was my next question.
[1:23:44] Staff/Representative: I will say if you're proposing it for the fourth at five, I'm coming back from Bangor that day I do believe I will be able to leave Bangor by three and make the meeting if we're doing the meeting at six but a site plan walk through at five or even earlier would not be available for it'd be a pretty significant trudge out
[1:24:08] Speaker C (unidentified): out there anyway okay so then it's all forested that whole section is that not yeah all right so then can I so let's let's address that can I get a
[1:24:42] Chair: based on the conversation can I get a motion to not hold a site walk for this
[1:24:48] Speaker C (unidentified): application make a motion to not hold the site war for this application second
[1:24:54] Chair: in that all those in favor which
[1:25:06] Public commenter: is the Wednesday before Thanksgiving thank you
[1:25:24] Planning Board Member: You got it wrong. You got it wrong. She got it wrong. The 16th is, the 23rd is the latest.
[1:25:28] Chair: You're thinking of comprehensive plan. 26th.
[1:25:32] Planning Board Member: That's, that's a little late.
[1:25:35] Speaker C (unidentified): 26th is Thanksgiving, so.
[1:25:37] Chair: No, it's the 18th. Yeah, it's the 18th.
[1:25:39] Staff/Representative: So if we were gonna make changes that would need, if we set for the 4th, we would need to make those changes and have it submitted by the 28th. And considering the delays we had with the physical copies on this one I do think it might just be more prudent to request the 18th.
[1:25:59] Planning Board Member: For the public hearing. It gives you more time for the noticing anyways. Yeah. What's the half-life of a tower? When do you replace them?
[1:26:09] Applicant/Representative: Ten years? Fifty years? Is that what they just did on the mountain? Was that a replacement?
[1:26:15] Staff/Representative: It all depends on environmental conditions. One on top of the mountains going to have much more and greater maintenance needs than one, probably where this is gonna be very protected from trees and won't have that same amount of impact, you know.
[1:26:34] Planning Board Member: It'll last a long time, is what you're saying.
[1:26:37] Staff/Representative: Yeah, I mean, I think the lease is for 30 years and so they generally try to-
[1:26:41] Planning Board Member: I'll withdraw the question, I'm just curious.
[1:26:44] Speaker C (unidentified): They're constantly changing components though.
[1:26:46] Planning Board Member: Not constantly, but you'll get, we get building permits to change components in and out and update stuff every few you know a few years or something it's not an iron tower fire tower from 1944 anymore I don't know how they're doing it if they're doing phases you know they have they have one leased out I don't know if they keep on adding components as the lease goes as they rent them out
[1:27:10] Staff/Representative: how that works so the on the tower itself you'll have the different spaces that are leased and then typically with the subtenant which is Verizon AT&T they'll also lease out space on the ground in the compound that will be for their particular equipment and so those building permits that you get are typically changing out the equipment both on the ground and in the air so
[1:27:35] Planning Board Member: speaking of construction I mean speaking of helicopters and structure do you fly the damn thing in or you put pieces together on the ground and lift them up
[1:27:44] Staff/Representative: and bring in giant cranes it's gonna be brought in with a crane and so they'll do the road one of the conditions that's being requested of us is that we bond a couple of different roads because of the heavy equipment and the recent paving so those bonds will be presented to the board prior to the application we're work we're firming up those details with Public Works six o'clock November 18
[1:28:40] Chair: so next on the agenda is minutes of previous meetings, which we do not have next communication. So, Michaela added screen, local planning boards and boards of appeal workshop, which is in person workshop, Tuesday, October 27, 2026, community drive and Augusta registration 4 o'clock to 430 workshop 430 to 830 dinner served midway through the workshop.
[1:29:05] Public commenter: show so if any of you are interested in attending reach out to me so I can get your register and then
[1:29:14] Chair: Michaela is going to give a comprehensive plan
[1:29:18] Planning Board Member: so [Speaker C (unidentified): I'm] here to update you all on the conference plan progress since the July update although those three of you are on that committee as well. So you don't really have to be updated. But here we are. First, we're going to talk about the outreach we've done, then what the comp plan committee has been up to, and then our next steps. We have done a lot of outreach since July. At the end of July, we had our public open house. This was our kickoff event for the plan. We did create a virtual version of that open house as well. We've been meeting monthly with the Comprehensive Plan Committee. I updated the town council at yesterday's council meeting. So they got a very similar presentation to this one. We've been putting updates into the town monthly e-newsletter. I've been working with the schools, the elementary school, the middle school and the high school. And then I've also been doing an informational campaign called calling waterboro by the numbers and i'll get into some of these in a little more detail so the open house was on july 29th we had about 19 in-person attendees and then three virtual attendees generally they really liked the draft vision statement and the draft values that the committee had come up with they did a mapping exercise where they identified key places in town and they were excited about the process and wanted more open houses so it's just delayed my slide is moved on but that slide is not moved on do you have any ideas why that's happening
[1:31:46] Speaker C (unidentified): you might have to restart reconnect google cast get a little cast
[1:31:53] Planning Board Member: us. Hopefully I don't have to do that every slide, but if I only
[1:31:57] Chair: have to do it every couple. Okay.
[1:32:01] Planning Board Member: So you can see you know, the sticker voting exercise they did on the values and the math there. So yeah, it was successful, not a ton of attendees, but everyone who attended really appreciated opportunity. Okay. So the school outreach has been really fun. I'm working with fourth grade for the elementary school, seventh grade for the middle school, and then a particular class in high school called the History of Maine class that Jill helped connect me with. And the results are in for the seventh grade, and they're very adorable. So I'll give you a little sneak peek of some of their work. But my goal with the student outreach is kind of two parts. so one i'm trying to introduce them to civics and local government in general and waterborough in particular and then secondly trying to introduce them to planning and getting them thinking about waterborough's future and what they want for the community and one thing that the seventh graders did is come up with a dream town they had to come up with a name and a slogan and then needs wants features and a big idea for their town so I guess I'll recast they're really cute some of them are hilarious overall they're very thoughtful as well a lot of students mentioned yes a lot of students mentioned healthcare emergency services, sports centers, those were very popular. A lot of kids wanted a community garden in their dream town, library got a few mentions, shopping areas got a lot of mentions. Let's go to another one.
[1:33:59] Chair: What was the discussion around healthcare? I think that's interesting for a seventh grader to be concerned about that.
[1:34:04] Planning Board Member: So I did not go into the classrooms. Oh, so you don't know the- Yeah, so I came up with the kind of the plan in and the worksheets and then worked with the teachers to adapt it and then
[1:34:14] Chair: they worked with the students. Were you surprised to see something that I guess matured?
[1:34:22] Planning Board Member: Yes, I'll show you one example that's just purely for humor. Is this a history class? This was their interdisciplinary studies class so they do like sustainability and civics and a bunch of different things. So
[1:34:39] Chair: they're already talking about where the deficiencies are and things like that okay
[1:34:44] Speaker C (unidentified): that makes sense yeah the playground we definitely need a better playground that's a cool thing friendship park is over there they need this it's giving you your home screen do you want to switch scratch yes okay
[1:35:13] Planning Board Member: well i'll just turn my computer around to see this one just this one is really just for the title which is water burger a rare find a medium town a well-done life we want
[1:35:34] Speaker C (unidentified): them on the planning want them on my marketing team burger could become a
[1:35:42] Planning Board Member: change does the
[1:35:56] Chair: town do anything with Google Analytics as far as the Facebook
[1:36:00] Planning Board Member: page or websites things like that not that I know of I use the Facebook like professional page analytics. So they provide some- So you can see your engagement
[1:36:09] Chair: when you're posting this, how is it?
[1:36:12] Planning Board Member: It's increased a lot since I started, but it really peaks and dips depending on a posting and when those things happen, yeah. But I mean, I started the planning account in January. It didn't exist and I have 640 followers. well so it's pretty good yeah and then we come out and vote so the big idea is to make burgers and then pour water on them yeah they're just an idea present. Somebody else is going to try this. Yeah. Yeah. Others, you know, motorsports, rentals, gas stations, water filtration districts. So they were very thoughtful. Some of the ideas was quite mature, in general. I think just very reflective of adult ideas, but with a little more humor thrown in. And it was it was there were also a lot of comments on needing things to do and things to bring people together. There were a lot of comments about community and coming together and having relationships with other people in town. So yeah, it was it was really nice. sort of the actual challenge of rural areas yeah yes so yeah I'm awaiting fourth grade and then with the high school I'm hoping to actually go into the classroom and looking towards like January for that for when they get to like that unit and in that class is it a process just to go into the classroom from like you don't have to get fingerprinted and stuff like that I think I do yeah I think I have to do it back probably but yeah I'm really excited that we're getting some youth input and besides the that fun presentation they talked about what they love about Waterboro and what they hope could change so I have a list of those ideas summary summarized and then the worksheet that I created are both worksheets they shifted into like a Google Form format because I guess the kids prefer doing it on their computer but I have all of those results as well so seeing yeah different ideas about like civics and Waterboro and they had to look up you know job opportunities and local government and things like that and talk about ones they might be interested in so yeah that's been that's been a really good process so far for youth engagement the other kind of engagement campaign I'm working on right now is the water borough by the numbers one I dropped off the packets over there so if you want to take one you can it's it's in two parts online I'm doing one at a time and it's an infographic of data that the comp plan committee is has been looking into essentially and just converting it into a simple infographic and then spreading the word to try and get awareness so people who end up engaging in the plan throughout it are you know coming from the same page when we start talking about goals and strategies and then those are also available in all the counters so when people come in and they're waiting for you know the computer system to do something or for the clerk to get them a form they have something to look at and they've been browsing through those and a bunch of people have asked to take copies home so that's exciting i've got it on this computer oh perfect you can go forward several slides next one and keep going okay so we've had five meetings so far with the comp plan committee our sixth meeting is next week there is room for more folks on the committee although not more planning board members still since last time we've solidified the vision statement and the values and we've dug into the data for this livability phase we're calling it next this is the vision statement that we have Waterboro is a thriving rural community where people from all walks of life find opportunities to connect, put down roots, and fully engage in community life. Local businesses and traditions strengthen our small but active village centers and bring people together. Responsible growth protects our beautiful natural resources, outdoor lifestyle, and small town character. That's the vision statement and it's meant to anchor the plan and be forward-thinking. And then these are the values they're actually the same as i think the draft i showed you all before with the exception of the last one which we added following feedback we got over the summer at different public engagements next okay so i'll just give a very brief amount of key data we've looked at so far because we've been here a while already but this is probably the main one anyways, this is our population changes over time. So we had very rapid growth in the 70s 80s 90s and early 2000s. And now we have very slow but steady growth. So 3% 2% rate. And that's what we expect to happen in the next eight or so years. So the predictions come from the main state economist office, they do predictions for I think, every municipality in Maine. And so, you know, could be totally inaccurate, but in all likelihood, it'll be something around this unless, you know, something drastic happens that changes where people are living and why. So do they plot this against, say, the state of Maine? So how do we compare? Yeah, so your county is growing. Wait, or your county. Something, what's the baseline? You know, where do we sit you know compared to so yeah a substantial number of Maine communities are declining population your county is growing and so is Cumberland County so those two are kind of growing the fastest and fairly significantly still I think your county was that like I remember correctly it's like 7%? Yeah, so we're growing a bit slower than York County, but that makes sense given the growth is usually concentrated in the coastal communities. [Speaker C (unidentified): So this] is some more key data. If you go to the next one, just how many people we have around 8,000 and about 3,000 households. Our median household income was about $84,000 and we have a very high school attainment and about one of five have bachelors for the adult population and then our median age is 42 which is indicative of an older community but not a retirement age community so we're distinctly not you know a Florida retirement home community and we are younger than York County as a whole or Maine as a whole but still aging and older yeah next slide please the okay that's enough which is fine so some of the major trends and implications that we've talked about as a committee I've already said out loud going through the data additional ones include that we're no longer a low-cost community although we still remain cheaper than much of York County We do have a large working-class and middle-income population, and if you look at households by different income brackets, most households fall under one of the low-income brackets. So what's low cost relative to real estate? What's that referring to? So... Approximately prices or cost of building a house. Mostly real estate and housing, yeah, but cost of living as a whole. Yeah. absence yeah so it's not really just water bro it's pretty much anywhere that's within an hour and a half of city part of that is because the housing market is extremely tight next slide please what that means right now we have one percent of homes are available for rental or for sale so that means that there's not a lot of movement in the housing market part of that is you know nationally housing production hasn't kept up with demand part of it is that in town we have very little housing diversity 90 percent of our housing stock is single-family homes and those are the most expensive type of housing so that's contributing however our renters in town do have the greatest affordability challenges so meaning they're the most likely to be paying a higher percentage of their income on housing no matter what their income bracket is and no matter whether they're renting an entire home or a unit they're just more likely to be paying more money compared to their income on housing and then kind of a large future implication that we've been talking about and the committee is that as our population ages we'll have new housing needs next steps keep going please Dave okay and your housing stock is aging too that's true as well yes and they're built in the 70s and 80s and it wasn't actually the golden era of building in North America so these aren't gonna last 200 years these are not 200 year houses that were put up you know yeah that's a really good point you know so you've got a confluence of two things happening things aren't being built you have aging housing stock and not a lot of it that's not moving people who are on the lower and middle income who are not going to be investing in aging housing stock so you can potentially see it getting worse yeah that's a good point i can tell you because i live in a 1979 building right that's not very well done which will probably in 20 years need to be raised not lifted raised any other data comments or questions before we go into next steps so hoping to launch a community-wide survey in november we'll be talking about that with the comp plan committee next week and then we'll be transitioning into goals and strategy development for this first phase of information and data. Yeah, so a lot going on with the comp plan committee. Thanks to these three for being on it and contributing. And I'll probably plan for another planning board update of the comp plan that's similar to this in another couple months, every couple months, just because they're quite long so you don't need to do one every issue every meeting but the information all the meeting summaries are available on the website so if those of you who aren't on the comp plan committee want to keep up you can i'm i'm one of the ones who's not you mentioned at the end of the last meeting i mentioned this my email to you sort of casually as we were all kind of walking out that looking at potential result or the comp plan allows for the possibility of resolving yes changing zones changing boundaries etc at this early stage do you anticipate that 's a possibility remote or not so remote at this stage I don't imagine anything drastic will come out of the comp plan but I imagine maybe recommendations to change what current zones allow or don't allow or slight boundary changes like maybe we look at build out and see that most of the village zone is built out and so maybe there's a need to expand village zoning to allow for that or maybe you know we do the natural resources data and see that our zoning isn't doing what it should to protect our most sensitive areas and so we want to you know look at how zoning can better support those areas I really can't say at this point but it's the early stages yeah it's very early but I've never seen a comp plan fully like get rid of existing zoning and do something that wasn't what I was suggesting I was just I was just curious where if anything was becoming evident at this sort of early stage or initial
[1:50:30] Chair: stages if I had to give a summary I feel like I feel like if I had to say right now what I would expect to happen is that I would expect there not to be any significant changes the people on the committee are very fond of the town and the way it is today but they understand the society is dictating other things but I think that there 's a lot of discussion about our outdoor resources the people are drawn to this town because of the zoning in some instances because there is ample and that you're separated from things like that so if I had to guess right now I would say I would agree with Michaela that it would be like little tiny things and not there's nobody on there that's like boy we gotta rip this down and we gotta start it i feel like everybody's pretty aligned in that way and but we're also just doing like i mean we spent most of the time doing the vision statement so yeah you know we're kind of kind of there but i would just say based on because there's a lot of discussion as things come up and it feels like everybody's pretty aligned and i don't feel like there's
[1:51:44] Planning Board Member: anybody who's really looking to know i think like the biggest concern with is that we have three different villages and do we centralize exactly yeah it's it's things like that 's kind of what i was thinking about when i and you know i'm kind of new here so but both physically and the planning board and you know you know i know the villages are kind of there's kind of three of them but then you look at it and go well actually there's there really isn't three of them you know it's it's like right around five and 202 and but even along 202 down toward the center of it is there's not a lot of development there that's why i was also asking about heat map where has where have things grown over the last five ten years you know yeah i hope i can produce that kind of map but you know even like tractor supply coming on board which is a really great it's a really great thing and it's a really great addition and you can see this area kind of becoming the village, more dense and, walkable. Like I see they're working on the sidewalk over to Hannaford's and I'm like, yep, these guys did that, which is really good. You know, it's, it's, it's that thoughtfulness about connectivity. So, yeah. So, don't worry, I'm not the radical who's going to get rid of it or change it. I'm just curious where, you guys were, so. I think if anything, I think the, what will be maybe most different are creative specific policy ideas that the committee comes up with I think that might be where we end up having some fun or creative or impactful changes but yeah we'll see oh there's so there's a lot of work left to do we're at the beginning but I also get a sense when I'm in some of the public meetings here and earlier before I was on the board, that people have come here for, they kind of have come here for a reason and they like it here. And they didn't come here, hey, let's change everything with that kind of mentality.
[1:53:50] Chair: And in reality, Steve bringing up that fact actually was, if anything, it was kind of good timing because a lot of the people that were here at that public hearing are on the comprehensive plan. it's almost the same room of people that have joined the committee so I think that triggered them to kind of open their eyes a little bit as to how things could change around them and that they had an opportunity to have a voice in it and they took that opportunity which is great so a lot of those people were here for that public hearing speaking out like well everybody spoke out against what was being proposed so I it was it was nice to see people who didn't just come out for their own personal interests that they are dedicating their time for the interest of
[1:54:34] Speaker C (unidentified): everybody and to protect that so that's kind of cool thank you sorry i wasn't trying to keep you
[1:54:39] Planning Board Member: up okay
[1:54:42] Chair: yeah okay next is miscellaneous the planning board as a reminder has one open seat i see you sat here the whole meeting all right so you're not our one all right so then i guess if there's nothing else can i have
[1:55:11] Speaker C (unidentified): a motion to adjourn i'll make a motion to adjourn i will second that all right