Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[11:55] Speaker A (unidentified): good evening like to call the meeting to order the york select board here at the york public library on monday october 26 2026. we could all please rise for the pledge of allegiance so our first item on the agenda there are agendas available up in the front of the meeting room everybody in the back hear me okay so leslie can you adjust the volume for inside the meeting room they can't hear in the rear okay we're taking care of that so we have a joint meeting with the ellis park directors if you guys if you folks would just like to come to the table up in front these are the twice a year meetings that we have with the directors of ellis park is codified an agreement that the town side geez i think that was probably what 10 nine ten years ago maybe that's where the park and the fall meeting will give an update on their park operations and future operations and all the great things they're doing out down there and items are thinking of going forward thinking and then the spring meeting is just sort of the reverse of that so thank you for being here and i guess i turn it over to you
[13:24] Speaker B (unidentified): mr president to give you a report thank you board for having us here tonight hopefully you've had a few minutes to read the packet that we gave you but i'd like to read something for the public at home we had a couple of first-time visitors this summer the new volleyball court we installed last year may have been the new airbnb for a pair of piping blowers when dave moulton started cleaning that area this spring he discovered the pair in their nest dave called us and we installed a yellow tape to try to keep people out of the area but not to draw attention to the pair once the chicks hatch We contacted State Audubon and they asked us to install the more secure fencing to keep the people and the predators out. We did as they asked and monitored them daily along with the Audubon volunteers. This was the first time ever reported nesting not on a beach. We watched them through their visit here until the four of them headed south for the winter. maybe they will come back next spring if they do we'll be ready for them right it was quite a quite an endurance because they were there about six weeks and but everybody was good the autobahn society came down at least three days a week and monitored i went down every morning tried to monitor them so but it all worked out well and they were quite happy they had people from Arno to Rhode Island come down to visit the only time that the pleb is have been known to not nest on a beach so the beach takes the takes the cake for that we have a lot of first in town we have a lot of first yeah so that was it and again hopefully you had a few minutes to read the go through the packet and anybody with any questions please feel free we
[15:34] Speaker C (unidentified): talked about the agreement at this point or just the information meeting with the directors i am curious you spent about 66 000 on engineering for the is it the paving project is that 's coming along when and you hope to break that into two years did i see we're gonna try
[15:59] Speaker B (unidentified): to break it into two pieces spring of 27 and fall of 27. it's been quite a quite a job to deal with the dep that is in a dune area so we had to abide by some rules that didn't make any sense to us but that's what they wanted us to do so is it actually in two different areas yes we're in
[16:26] Speaker A (unidentified): can you just turn your mic on with the green so we know they can pick you up just push the video
[16:30] Speaker D (unidentified): thank you so actually in two different zones for dunes very confusing so half the
[16:37] Speaker B (unidentified): parking lot doesn't go by the same rules as the other half so it makes it difficult to make the whole thing look the same so but we have finally got approval on that and we have now put in for the planning board to go over it to we're asking for a variance on the lighting height of the poles to in order to light that parking lot properly we need to go to a 19-foot pole and I believe the planning board is 14 foot so we'll be seeing them hopefully soon and try to work something out on that and then we should be ready for next spring to get started dep i mean the department of public works is going to start the drainage project they're doing all the drainage work we're going to upgrade the size of the pipes going there and going to the to the penstock so that whatever water we get, we can get rid of a lot quicker than we can now. The pipes are half corroded away, and the seaweed gets caught in them and all of that, so this should help to eliminate that water as soon as it comes in.
[17:57] Speaker D (unidentified): I think they put pipes that are smooth in,
[17:59] Speaker B (unidentified): so the swimming pool. Yeah, they're gonna be a smooth interior, so there'll be nothing that can get caught in there, so that'll be a huge improvement. we're going from 18 inch to 24 inch so we all know when the waters up here the
[18:14] Speaker D (unidentified): oceans up here gravity still isn't going to win out no matter how big that pipe
[18:20] Speaker C (unidentified): is and how much cash do you have on hand a little over two million okay good and then my other question is you have a project scheduled for fiscal year 2930 water station and shower at the south end of the boardwalk have you discussed with the Water District at this point? It mentions that you're going to require permitting
[18:44] Speaker B (unidentified): and coordination. We had one at that end of the beach, but it was connected to the irrigation system. So they told us that we couldn't use that water supply. So we're thinking of putting a new water supply in from Ocean Ave Extension to be able to feed that. But we still have to get it cleared
[19:05] Speaker C (unidentified): with the dep and so forth so yeah but you're in discussions with the water district to
[19:11] Speaker B (unidentified): coordinate we haven't even discussed it with the water district yet oh okay not yet that was right yeah and like i said the five-year plan a lot of that is working around the new paving that we're going to be doing the new fiber that's going to go in the new cameras security cameras that are going in that's all kind of a work it as we go along project so that's why it spanned out over five years so we've got no
[19:44] Speaker D (unidentified): electrical service going to the gazebo to right yep no I want to thank you guys
[19:50] Speaker E (unidentified): for this you know just a project moving forward and having it in the open so everyone knows what to expect and that this is coming and it's not someone saying, oh my God, this sidewalk is being ripped up, what are you guys doing? So I think having this and being a five-year plan, people can expect changes. Even though at the end of five years, you never know. But thank you for this and I like that the bathrooms are in there, they're all gonna be overhauled and new toilet seats and all of that. i'm like germaphobic when it comes to stuff like that in the public so thank you guys very much and you know and i taken you know what you take from the long sands beach and what's going on there to make the town itself when you enter it at the beach area look coordinated and well
[20:43] Speaker F (unidentified): out done so thank you yeah so just so people are aware you gave us a profit loss for this last year through June 2026 and you had total income of nine hundred and fourteen thousand which is the meters and the fines you had expenses of 535 000 so you had a good year you net income was 378 000 and again that speaks to i think what mr boston said about the two million dollars or whatever you have and then maybe you just because that money is used for the capital that you capital items that you guys have identified do you would you go through there i just like people to hear it i mean there's a lot of projects here and as we as we know everything costs a lot of money so maybe it'd be helpful just for people to hear all the i think maybe marla mentioned a couple but just so people hear all the stuff you're planning on doing to upgrade or maintain fiscal year 26 27 finishing
[21:59] Speaker B (unidentified): the engineering permitting and bid out the renovation of the parking lot to a water contract Correct, $50,000. 2627, installation of high-speed fiber for video surveillance system and operational control turned over to the town to manage and maintain system for the directors. Yearly operational costs will be borne by the PAC, 15,000. 2627, engineering permitting for installation of new handicap ramps from the boardwalk onto the beach. Currently, there is only one ramp near the bath house. The directors feel it's not adequate to accommodate our guests as we have many decades old. Ideally, either two or three would provide better access across the entire beach. Permitting and cost may dictate phasing project over a number of years if found permissible 25,000 for the engineering phase only 26 27 undertake replacing underground conduit and wiring between the gazebo pavilion in the basketball courts to the playground to discontinue the power from the bathhouse and separate into two electronic electrical panels at the gazebo 50,000 2728 installation of new poles wiring and security cameras to cover south third of the boardwalk between the pavilion and ocean have extension and along the border of the pack toward intersection of ocean ad and ocean ab extension 75,000 undertake packing lot renovation plan including new parking lot design pavement lighting and cameras project will also include new lighting and security camera infrastructure to cover the entire new parking lot cost and considerations will impact on events and businesses in the beach may dictate whether entire project can be completed in one year or need to be phased in over two years 1.5 million dollars installation of new light poles to match parking lot lights from playground to ocean have extension 90,000 installation of water station and shower at the south end of the boardwalk this will require permitting and a new source of water from the york water district currently the only piping for the water in that area is from lawn sprinklers and that cannot be used for the consumption or for public use this would require entire new line from the bath house or the separate source from main street on ocean ave extension 20 000 29 to 30 investigation and engineering of potential changes replacement Placement of the current boardwalk having seen the success of Long Beach Seawall the directors would like to consider options to protect the boardwalk and pack from major coastal storms in the future Understanding there are environmental concerns and permitting requirements To achieve to make these changes before any cost or timeline can be considered $40,000 the engineering and feasibility 29.30, renovation of the gazebo to include trim and structural needs if found in project as it progresses, 40,000. Expansion of security cameras to cover border of park along Ocean Ave and Ocean Ave extension to cover sidewalks and grass areas, 55,000. and 30 to 31 installation of a generator to power all pack facilities including parking lot lights
[26:09] Speaker F (unidentified): and cameras during power outages 40 000. thank you for doing that i know that was a lot to read but i think it's helpful for people to hear you know the level of investment that you all are making in the park to continue to maintain at a high level so thank you know rob
[26:28] Speaker G (unidentified): it's
[26:29] Speaker D (unidentified): It should be common knowledge, but it may not be. But all the money that's taken in the park has to be spent in the park, period. So those meters are providing all those things that Dave's talking about. And we have to use that money for that. Okay.
[26:48] Speaker H (unidentified): Marianne? Yeah, I just had a few questions, and thank you for this. Yes. The fact that you're relying on RDPW for the drainage system, they have to do that first so that you can do yours next. I know I can see around town there, they look like they're pretty busy. Have you had recent discussions for a firm timeline with Tim?
[27:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, I was talking with Tim, DiPerio, and he was talking maybe the 18th of this past, this month. He says, as long as the novel project continues to move forward and they get to a point where they can split some of the crew up and come down. But he said, you know, that's not going to freeze down in the park. It's all beach sand. So they can pretty well dig there all winter long. Right. so they're not really too concerned about it. I figured I would give them until the 1st of November and I'd give them a call to try to get an update on what they're looking at for a start date.
[27:54] Speaker H (unidentified): Right, and then my other question had to do with your security cameras and it looks like you're progressing quite a bit with that situation. And I know last year we talked about out who would be overseeing you know whether dispatch would be reviewing the footage or who was on first and what's on second have you had any discussions regarding that as to who actually was going to manage that or is that something future with the town manager that you'll be doing
[28:29] Speaker B (unidentified): we spoke at our last meeting in reference to the town taking over that part of it so that they would manage it. We'll still take care of any of the costs that it costs from them to do that, or any repairs. But they have the people that are qualified to do that, kind of search, and we're gonna try to leave it that way.
[28:55] Speaker H (unidentified): Great, thank you. Anyone else?
[28:59] Speaker A (unidentified): So I'd like to just thank the directors again for a, it's a thorough report. And I think it's one of the most thorough reports we've received from your board since we've had this agreement with Ellis Park, so I appreciate that. You can see you've taken a lot of work, a lot of forward thinking going into the capital projects that many members talked about and you read out loud for the audience, I appreciate that. You know, the coordination that has been enhanced with York PD, because I know there was talk a year or two ago about a different system that would conflict with the systems that dispatch has and be able to compatibility real time and it was granular video as opposed to pretty solid stuff that they can help maybe solve some matters that are happening down there. And you capture that operational, how the operational control and the costs would be borne by the park, but the eyes looking at the screens and the police presence, what happened from our local, our police department, so.
[29:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, if the camera goes out, we're not watching the screens, PD. I mean dispatch will be watching the screens. They just got to tell us that they're out and what it's gonna cost to try to get them back out.
[30:07] Speaker A (unidentified): So I appreciate all those changes. I appreciate the report from the superintendent. I don't think we've ever had a written report from the superintendent before. There have been verbal reports when your superintendent was here, so that's good to see, because it just memorializes what you've accomplished down in the park or what you see as challenges forever. I mean, it would get captured in somewhat minutes of our meeting, electronic tape, but it's not in a paper document.
[30:29] Speaker D (unidentified): So that's that's good to see too. I'm glad you mentioned that because Cory could not be doing a better job super conscientious
[30:38] Speaker A (unidentified): so short of Citizens coming to our board meeting to talk about geez I'd like to see X or Y at the park or I have concerns about you know something at Ellis short stance Park So how would the public communicate with the trust with the directors? I'm sorry
[30:53] Speaker B (unidentified): they would they would normally get a hold of the rec department and then the rec department contacts cory and then cory contacts the board and then we address it however we feel we have to address it okay they could call cory they couldn't get a hold of cory directly but usually
[31:10] Speaker A (unidentified): it goes through the rec department i do see the not often that i go on you know social media but oftentimes just during the summer i've seen posts from your superintendent that a ban's been canceled because of you know weather situation it won't be safe so you're kind of closing the you know the bandstand or delaying x or y so i guess there's probably that platform too possibly maybe if they can instant message the director or something but for the superintendent so it's a good system right now yeah it's a great system any other members have any follow-up questions or wrap-up statements thank you for all this we do have an action item toward the rear of our
[31:49] Speaker B (unidentified): presentation let me just mention one thing we do plan on being back here in December with the engineering board to go over the pack and lot renovations so that the public and you folks can have a list of what we're going to be doing in
[32:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Texas attached behind the action form is the amended in red font, the changes to the agreement that, and Peter can probably speak more deeply to those, but they were negotiated with you or your designee and then directors, or the director's designees to read upon these changes. So it's the board's pleasure.
[32:34] Speaker H (unidentified): So we're gonna be voting on this agreement right now. I just have a couple little tweaks that I noticed in it, if you don't mind. Okay, on, above Article 6, so it's probably the fourth page. letter i 'm just wondering whether we need that first statement still in there the board of directors agree to begin replacing the current parking kiosk with mobile commencing the 2023 season like that's already started so i just thought we could delete that line we had we had
[33:16] Speaker B (unidentified): 10 kiosks originally and we were being billed for repairs and cleaning of those and they said if we only did in whatever number we do that's what the number will be that we'll be charging you for and as time has progressed we're now down to five in the pack i'm not sure if we're going to go down any more any less than that or if we're going to stay at five the first the first
[33:42] Speaker I (unidentified): sentence is kind of irrelevant though that's what i thought it was irrelevant because it was in the
[33:47] Speaker H (unidentified): first agreement about the 2023 year and you've already beginning the replacement yeah now it's and then on the article 7 under short sands beach the hours about the lifeguard coverage i think they are now nine to five and this agreement says eight to five so i just think there should be some consistency because i think we may have a parks director in the audience
[34:20] Speaker I (unidentified): for those at home that didn't catch that the parks and rec director said 9 30 to 4 30 from the back of the room that didn't get on the microphone thank you so right in between
[34:32] Speaker C (unidentified): and that's it did it well yeah i have a couple as well in article five at the top of the page sort of two-thirds of the way into article 5 it cites the dates for parking kiosks installed and operational as being excuse me April 15 through October 31st and I wonder if we should add a clause or such other dates as are adopted by the town for the other parking zones in town such that if we were to make any changes to the dates for other zones in town that we wouldn't have to amend this contract that it would because i think your intent is to follow what we do here and we may leave them the same but just yeah just that and then suggestive language yeah you see the section where i'm talking or such other dates as are adopted by the town for other parking zones in town clear i
[35:43] Speaker B (unidentified): know i've been talking with brian trafton and he thinks there may be some more ordinances that are going to go into effect next year for the parking so we'll have to keep that in mind as we upgrade our ordinances also and then to be the
[36:02] Speaker C (unidentified): same as the rest of the town so right that 's the intention and then the following page at the end of article 9 in the red that talks about shall each submit the claim to their respective insurance carriers for review and termination of coverage I wonder if determination is supposed to be coordination determination of determination okay autocorrect we certainly none of us want termination of coverage do we and then lastly there's a following the where we all sign there's a table with responsible party and party assuming cost seems like we should change wherever it says trustees to directors the appropriate well it's
[36:59] Speaker H (unidentified): been three years that's all i have any others any other board members on that on that same page the last line of lifeguards is i don't think it's spelled correctly just oh yeah guard fix that fix
[37:12] Speaker J (unidentified): that so
[37:20] Speaker A (unidentified): we have a series of amendments i know all the members were following along but doing my chairmanship duties here so the first one was if we have agreement they're not numbered there was one h that marla mentioned or such dates is adopted by the town and then under i removing the first sentence beginning with the word the and then board of directors and then ending with 2023 season and the next page under article nine third well next to the last line of that section where it says termination should be determination and then the after the signatory page the sort of operational task and responsible parties and party swimming costs changing trustees to directors and lifeguard correct spelling i'm not sure what sort of
[38:11] Speaker C (unidentified): spelling we have article seven the lifeguard hours in the lifeguard hours right and i'm even
[38:16] Speaker H (unidentified): wondering with that do we want a time certain or give the flexibility to the parks and recreation director to set those if you know unless everybody thinks it will be 9 30 to 4 30
[38:32] Speaker I (unidentified): for the next three years you can just thumbs up thumbs down thumbs up you have plans to change lifeguard hours within the next three years or it might happen thumbs down no change and it's never going to happen in the next three years thumbs up it may happen all right do you want to you can get
[38:51] Speaker A (unidentified): it up if you want and as you arrive at the microphone just identify yourself please for the record thank you good
[39:01] Speaker J (unidentified): evening pete murray parks and recreation director so there is
[39:05] Speaker I (unidentified): nothing set in stone by any means but i know that the lifeguard captain has discussed
[39:09] Speaker K (unidentified): wanting to potentially go up to a 10 hour day so that's not anything agreed upon but that's
[39:16] Speaker A (unidentified): something that's been expressed as something that she thinks would be a positive thing for the town
[39:21] Speaker I (unidentified): that's all at this point right thank you so if it's on the table for discussion it should probably be noted a similar language or such other hours as established by the Parks and Recreation Department right with the understanding that would likely be an extension not a contraction of hours on your part
[39:39] Speaker A (unidentified): so you're comfortable that so those all be the amendments are there any additionals? So motion to approve is amended.
[39:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Chair, I move to approve the agreement between the Board of Directors for Ellis-Short Sands Park and the York Select Board for the operations of Ellis-Short Sands Park as amended from the period July 1st, 2026 through June 30, 2029.
Consent Agenda
[40:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have a second? Second. Motion by Marla, seconded by Robert. Any additional discussion on the motion? Hearing none, I'll call the vote. Robert? Yes. Marilyn? Yes. Marla? Yes. Marianne? Yes. Chair votes yes. motion carries 5-0 thank you very much thank you okay so now we're down to item a consent agenda we have a business license renewals renewal by Anderson in meeting minutes from our October 5th 2026 meeting the
[40:33] Speaker E (unidentified): consent agenda and also and also for the minutes of October 12th. Do we have a second?
[40:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Motion by Marilyn, second by Robert. Discussion?
[40:48] Speaker C (unidentified): I think in a number of places that Anderson is misspelled. It's not S-O-N, it's -E-N. So in the consent agenda cover page and then in the request for action. And I say that because E-N is the Danish way of spelling it, so that caught my eye. and These things matter, right?
[41:23] Speaker H (unidentified): Also on that application The number of sellers or workers went from I think three to four, but there's actually only two listed That the other numbers one and two are crossed out So I think we should just change the number of workers to two the workers to two And then with our minutes, I'm not 100% sure on the citizen's form, the sixth person to speak, we have listed Richard Rattigan, but at the end of the evening, it was a Richard Ratta who spoke, and I think it's the same person, so I think it's Richard Ratta instead of Rattigan in the first.
[42:07] Speaker I (unidentified): You are correct. It's not Rattigan. Okay.
[42:10] Speaker A (unidentified): So those corrections are good? Yes. Robert? further amendments as amended call the vote robert yes marilyn yes triple chest motion carries five zero chair's report i'm sure all the items i would talk about peter will talk about but one that we can certainly both talk about never discuss it too much november 3rd is voting day so if you haven't obtained your absentee ballot time's running out to do that but voting day november 3rd the york high school it's usually it's in the auditorium there's signs directing you where to go once you enter the campus and voting is from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. again on November 3rd so hope everybody gets out exercises their right to vote with that we'll go to the manager's
[42:56] Speaker I (unidentified): report I would just add in terms of elections Mr. Chair so as you stated the election is next Tuesday November 3rd our midterm election gubernatorial and statewide offices election absentee ballots are available until Thursday 1029 so that's this up this upcoming Thursday in a couple days at 4 p.m. must be pulled at the town clerk's office before that time absent any emergency circumstances or extenuating circumstances that would qualify for a shorter term under state law absentee ballots must be returned this seems intuitive but it maybe is not by November 3rd at 8 p.m., so we cut off receipt of absentee ballots at the close of voting, just in case anybody is curious. Other states, some of them have extended provisions for mail or things like that, so that means if you're mailing it, has to be in the town clerk's possession by 8 p.m., meaning it has to get there in that day's mail and Tuesday's mail. The clerk has asked if you are returning ballots on Tuesday and you are able to bring them to the high school that cuts down on their shuttling back and forth at the end of the day excessively we do accept they will be accepted at the drop box if you're not able to make it to the high school we have to accept them at the town hall drop box there is an election employee who checks that at 8 p.m. to make sure we've emptied everything out in front of the town hall the clerk's office will not be accepting ballots at the clerk's office on Tuesday because all the clerk staff will be at the polls on Tuesday okay so you can return them a town hall in the drop box but the clerk if you're able and it's not too much of a big deal to either drive to the town hall or the polling place on Tuesday please take them to the high school if you're able as of today we have issued four thousand three hundred and seventy six absentee ballots this is pretty consistent with actually the total amounts in the past two or three midterm elections that have been issued so we still have a couple days to go that number will be higher it'll likely be it'll likely be a significant a pretty significant number by the time they're done we've returned 2,926 ballots so that means there's a pretty significant number outstanding so just a reminder for those of you that have your ballots outstanding they've got to come back by next tuesday all right i'll move along we probably have some people here who are interested in the next two items there will be citizens forum i think a few more than a few people are planning to speak and also we've got an agenda item for one of them but i was asked to provide updates on the curbside waste transition in the village revitalization project so we've over the past three weeks we've had two weeks of distribution of curbside waste barrels. It has gone, I would say, mostly well. There have been hiccups. I think we were told there would be hiccups. It is not a large number, but I know we've heard from a lot of people about mistakes, missed deliveries, essentially comparing lists of every qualifying house and property in town to what's actually delivered. We haven't had an overwhelming amount of phone calls on the subject only about five to six hundred to town offices which is not a lot considering we have over 10,000 service locations but that gives you an idea of kind of how smooth it went most of those were simple questions but a chunk of them were missed deliveries so we really do apologize and appreciate everybody that's been calling we've had a few significant issues that have popped up that we're still working on or at least trying to resolve and we know that not everybody has got their barrel so if you're still outstanding at this point please keep calling us we do have about a two-day lag due to the number of call volume we have about five staff returning calls that are trained on at least all most of the information that we're supposed to have so i do want to thank the public works department chris cartier and tim diperio over in public works who have been non-stop on the phone and with public with walk-ins also our clerk's office downstairs and catherine is not here tonight and diana in my office who've done a bulk of returning phone calls we know that people are leaving messages on the public works machine that are getting returned by town hall employees but that's to try to keep up with the volumes so i would say mostly well but with a few hiccups and i'll report back in two weeks as to whether we've been able to resolve those hiccups that'll tell me whether we're successful or not i'm not willing to declare victory complete victory at this moment because we do have a few outstanding issues the village revitalization project unless you've been under a rock for the past month is underway and i think everyone most in the room know what's going on but this is just for anyone who's watching from home or who watches this at a later date so the village project as you know is right out that door the back door of the library i'm pointing at the intersection of long sands road and york street it is a significant pedestrian safety economic development project that the town has been in the works for over 12 years 13 years the total project cost estimated to be around five million dollars four million dollars i'm using huge round numbers in construction costs and about a million dollars in design costs so a pretty significant undertaking that the town is underway so what you're seeing out there right now in the ground and why there are delays on york street and coming back through long sands road into the village this is the this is the significant part where they are in the roadway there's a lot of times when they're going to be in the roadway but we are doing drainage replacements so before you do upgrades to roadway sidewalk and things like that obviously the 50 plus year old drainage components that are buried under the ground cross pipes drainage pipes catch basins those are the giant concrete tubs that you see out there on the side of the road there's a significant stretch from the far end of the project to the town hall kind of old jail area there's a significant drainage area out here in the triangle what's now the triangle area and there's a little bit further up york street so the goal and why that has to happen is so we don't dig up a major road project five years from now when a cross pipe collapses or catch basin collapses and we understand that is just that's probably the most disturbing because you're going across traffic with cross pipes we're in the roadway as the project goes on there'll be other parts that aren't quite as disruptive and there'll be parts where they're working on the sidewalk where it may not be single lane traffic at all it may not be disruptive so the current schedule is weather dependent until the end of december and if the ground is not frozen and they're able to continue the contractor may continue to work beyond that drainage will move oh and one thing i wanted to mention you'll start to see impacts to parking areas you've seen some impacts to parking already so those that park in the village want to emphasize that there is public parking in the library lot here in the short term the library has signed the 30 approximately 30 spaces out of 100 that are in front of the library that's supposed to be designated for library parking during the day but the long side of the library down here that faces the village essentially in the far front lower lot is designated public parking so we know it's inconvenient that people are going to be disrupted from their street side parking while the project's underway way the end part of the end component of the parking component of the project restores all that restores not in the same location but all of the parking that is taken from one location is restored in number in slightly different locations including along long sands road including along york street including in front of the town hall where there's not currently parking on york street by old york historical society by the museum and up towards where the end of the project is I'll say in front of the realty building all right the next phase is pretty significant I've kind of been asked to update provide an update which I think will be the background to some of the conversation will probably happen tonight we have another agenda item for part of pertaining to part of the project specifically the monument rest movement and tree removal that is proposed as part of the project and I think that's why we have at least some people in the room here what i hear overwhelmingly for questions when i talk to people is why is this necessary i just want to start at the top of the project the roadway is being why is the tree removal necessary the roadway is being realigned long sands road will go through the middle in the design of where the monument and the tree are right now so it's not it's not something that was just chosen at a whim there's a lot of design work that went into that in a lot of discussion the ultimate goal is the creation of a town square which is immediately adjacent kind of to where the triangle is now so it moves the triangle which is not really a sufficient assembly area creates an assembly area adjacent to that and makes a t intersection out of what's a y intersection now i've also i'm also frequently asked how was this decided and I'm one of those people that had to do that research myself because I wasn't here 15 to 10 years ago when this was all discussed ad nauseum in the community. But in approximately 2013 to 2015, the York Village Committee was formed, and this was, I'll say, citizen-driven to some extent, resident-driven and business owner-driven by folks in the downtown area of the village to essentially change the village for the better. it was a long discussed process that committee the bulk of their work I know the discussion started well before 2013 but the bulk of that work happened between 2013 and 2015 and that was the design work that was the public meetings the discussion there was a very intensive public process that happened that committee looked at multiple designs so what you have now we'll call it the triangle or the wide design they looked at several designs including modified Y designs, including bigger Y designs with triangular kind of lanes, including a rotary, and including a T intersection. And I've got, there are, interestingly enough, we saved all the design drawings. I've got one here that I'll just point to just for brief purposes. This shows, this is what the current, the current design kind of evolved out of, and this is the. sure you want to be this is the village square concept of what you see now with the monument being relocated the final design is a lot is conceptually the same but the actual Plaza area is significantly different like I said the public participation process in this kind of attached to this right here is an email from 2013 there was a public design charrette where 252 people attended which was a pretty significant number bigger than the york beach greenway district public engagement process probably one of the bigger processes the town ran where they voted on so there are a couple of these design processes but this concept ended up getting 83 percent of the public design charrette vote now that is not a representative to grab that marianne not a representative town-wide vote but it is kind of what the committee used to steer the direction that they were developing this project a lot so that chosen design resulted in the creation of the york village master plan eventually which is this document from 2015 and i know i don't have to hold it up to you but just so the public can see so it's a lot of cross sections of roadways what the roadway design should look like but shows the current configuration the t configuration and that it was going in that direction so there's a couple illustrations throughout this document that show essentially the configuration in the current proposed so why am i doing this i'm just trying to show that there is a that there was some public consideration here a lot so that this master plan was incorporated into the comprehensive plan by vote of the town so it was adopted and incorporated in the comprehensive plan which is our master plan for the priorities of the town so it was incorporated in a standalone vote as a separate part of the comprehensive plan in November 2015 2016 the town funded the matching funds for construction which we are spending right now which was $400,000 that's the 10% match to the total construction cost in 2017 there's a design board that i have here which i won't make marianne hold up okay you can hold it up which shows this is virtually identical to the current set of plans which are the rolled plans of the contractors working off of about eight years ago nine years ago showing the circular kind of town plaza which is what is currently under process of being constructed or will be shortly this had a little bit of change to the parking I think the board I'm told the board wasn't happy with the parking space were being eliminated so parking was added up along Sands Road and right here also in front of the Town Hall area and the crosswalks alignment were changed just a little bit at the very center into kind of like a triangular pattern but other than that the sidewalk the roadway alignment all of that has not changed since 2017. So for nine years, this line set is nearly identical to the current layout of the building.
[56:59] Speaker A (unidentified): And there's also added parking in front of the old Baring Yard. Thank you, yes.
[57:03] Speaker I (unidentified): There currently is no parking. Correct, yep. So, and okay, and then. And the fire station. Correct. I'm almost done. Because I know people want to discuss this item. So, and then we have a 2018 rendering, which I can show people afterwards if anyone's interested showing an almost identical layout configuration and this I'm told was and this is kind of a little art seed up version of the current design and this what I'm told was in Maine Homes magazine as an example of a great design that was going to go into place somewhere in Maine so this 2018, I believe, is the date on it. Yeah. So what is shown on this plan, what's not shown is the island, the monument, the tree. What is shown are significant street trees, and I'll touch on that really quickly, and then I'll shut up. All right. Oh, and then 2020, the updated comp plan. The town's newest comp plan also incorporated the village plan as a priority into a section of the comp plan that was approved by the voters. So as everyone or most in the room are probably aware, and most in town are probably aware, there's been some controversy that's arisen with the removal of the trees that's been publicized. So that's scheduled currently for beginning of November time period. That will be when the monument moves, when the plaza is created. It's that phase of the project. So I've been asked by people, what are some alternatives? What is the town considering? What's the town going to do about this? a few things that we've talked about almost immediately when kind of hearing these concerns were is it possible to move the tree it is a physical possibility it's something that can be done i'm told it's expensive i think the numbers i've seen were in the 30 to 50 000 range i'm told it's probably closer to 50 000 plus by people who know the problem with that is not necessarily of the dollars although that's a pretty significant amount of money for the town it's also the timing and that takes a significant amount of time i think some people in the audience would know better than i do about how long that takes to prep a tree for movement but it's not something that can be done in a month even when we looked at it a few weeks ago it's not something that we could just pull the trigger on and even if money was no object and hire someone to do within a month or within two months that it takes a pretty significant period of time to make that had happened. Okay, could the roadway be redesigned? That is something also that we talked about almost immediately with the supervising engineer on the project from SLR, our engineer, myself, we looked at it. The consensus was that, so I want to stress this is a state and federal project that where the design is approved by the state government, right? So Maine DOT approves every phase of design. So the preliminary design, the final design. If there is a change in alignment of the roadway, which I don't want to say it's impossible because it certainly is possible. Given time and money, anything is possible if we have the right amount of time to work with and the right amount of money to work with. But this puts us 18 to 24 months where we were 18 and 24 months ago in the design phase. I think everybody knows what that means in terms of slowing down the project. So if we had two years to work with and we weren't in the middle of the construction contract right now Could we redesign that roadway to move it 10 20 30 feet out and make the tea make it tea differently Even if we're maintaining the tea it is certainly a possibility I don't want to say it would be impossible, but given the constraints of timing and they were currently under a contract That's not super realistic right now in my opinion and then And, you know, what are the costs if we do delay, you know, there's the contract that we are under with the construction company is a three-party, you know, there's three parties involved here. There's 80% federal funding, 10% state funding, and 10% local funding. So any change to that contract is not just the town's choice to make. and there 's pretty significant consequences if we stand in the way of moving forward something that's 80% funded 90% funded by entities other than the town meaning I don't want to envision what that might look like in terms of settlements and lawsuits and things like that but we wouldn't be getting 90% of costs reimbursed by the federal and state government if we were to make a significant change to the project so why is that a pressure that means it's not easy to delay and move the project timeline out just things to kind of keep in mind and then as i talked about a little bit street tree planting is part of the there's been a lot of talk about that it will remove a street tree that's absolutely true it's not a great outcome ever to remove a street tree if you can avoid it but i do want to you know to what little consolation it is to people there are in those renderings there are some depictions of what are kind of six smaller street trees but there are tree wells to plant and as part of the renderings of the project three to four mature street trees there are places to put them the town is committed to planting street trees as part of this project it's just not in the construction contract that is the hardscaping part of the contract so it's always been looked at as you know the immediately following the construction season to put street trees in there as part of the project as shown in the rendering so we're looking at that moving forward and i know there's a lot of people here that want to talk or maybe some people here that want to talk about this tonight and i know we have some write-ins that we'll be reading tonight that speak on the issue so that's kind that's the background where we're at i know a few board members asked me just to explain the basics of where we came from so the public understands that are there any questions on that information right now one question a contractor
[1:03:11] Speaker E (unidentified): contractor who is part of this if we change the plans on them can we be liable for lawsuits for changing what we are asking them to do or you would have to go back to the drawing board for a new rendition and for how much it will cost and recast and budgeting of the project?
[1:03:31] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah I mean I don't want to I'm not a lawyer I don't want to pretend to be one or figure out what the outcome of that would be I don't think it would automatically be a lawsuit but dollars involved the so the way this contract is set up is there is a deadline for the project from the state and federal government and it's November of next year and the contractor has the flexibility the way that the project was competitively bid the contractor has the flexibility to organize the schedule in the way that best fits the contractors work this is a moving that triangle is a key component of the project it can't the realignment of the road the setting of the curb the building of the sidewalks other than the drainage everything follows the realignment of long sands road so there's not there's not a way for us to tell them in what order to do the project we could make requests but we are legally obligated they are doing the work they have to finish the work by this date and we have to give them 10 of the money and 90 of somebody else's money if they complete the work by that date that's the best way to think of the legal obligations under the contract could things be changed could they be negotiated always but i would predict it would get messy very quickly is anyone who's tried to change a five million dollar house construction project for a major you know or business construction project on a major project which i think that would be considered a pretty major project by a contractor standard yeah you get into you get into legal penalties pretty quickly so just like the contractor has penalties if they don't meet the finish the time the end of the timeline if we weren't to hold up our end of the bargain where we would tell them to stop or we were not to make payment or something like that there's going to be consequences for the town so there are penalties if the contractor doesn't finish by november in terms of dollars
[1:05:28] Speaker H (unidentified): per day liquidated damages I think it was good information to have at this point in time for our community so thank you for the history thank you Peter so
[1:05:44] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm on the on the radar any additions reports so we're done the awards are to two the first is the mount agamemticus lodge roof repair hello
[1:06:14] Speaker L (unidentified): i'm robin kerr parks national resource manager hello so tonight we have a couple bids one is the replacement for the mount agamemticus lodge roof it was an item that was approved by voters in may for forty thousand dollars we've received a couple of bids one was for from jjs universal construction company out of dudley mass for 55 600 another one was from sky high roofing at 38 950. let's see we've reviewed them both they seem good both of them offer premium roofing materials which is what is required at the summit of Mount a sky high came in lower we're recommending them
[1:07:15] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah thank you for this Robin I noticed that the JJS Universal has a 20-year warranty and sky high roofing has a 10-year warranty are those sort of the only real differences that you see and is 10 years within sort of industry standard
[1:07:35] Speaker L (unidentified): as far as you know? I think they actually said that they would be 25, but I think just, they didn't put it in the proposal. They said 10 in the proposal, but when we talked to them, they thought that roofing material would be 25. I wonder if they just know it's Mount A, but the roofing material that they were proposing is a heavier weight, and he said he was gonna caulk it all down he's been the one who's actually replaced the roofing portions when we've had pieces blow off in the past so he's very familiar with up there that's probably why he said 10 good thanks
[1:08:18] Speaker M (unidentified): yes
[1:08:20] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, so in the sky-high roofing bid, there's a note at the top and it says, please reach out to Mitchell to further discuss the possible insulation of the roof system, which we deem very necessary and not quoted here. So did you follow up with that?
[1:08:42] Speaker L (unidentified): We did not. I know when we looked at doing cost estimates for the roof last year we were talking about insulation it just would what they were proposing I believe was going to change the character of the inside of the lodge I don't believe oh okay yeah I think they were talking about bringing it down more and so you wouldn't have that exposed ceiling
[1:09:14] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah
[1:09:20] Speaker F (unidentified): I guess it would have been, well, okay.
[1:09:25] Speaker L (unidentified): No, thank you. I can look into it more and see for clarification. Anyone else?
[1:09:33] Speaker C (unidentified): We ready for a motion? Mr. Chair, I move to award the Mount Agamemnon Lodge Roof Replacement Project bid to Sky High Roofing in the amount of $38,950.
[1:09:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Motion by Marla, second by Marilyn. Any additional discussion on the motion? Wait, no,, call the vote. Robert? Yes. Marilyn? Yes. Marla? Yes. Marianne yes general chess motion carries 5-0 award d2 is Mount Agamemticus replacing a pickup truck Robin Corrigan yeah me again thank you
[1:10:06] Speaker L (unidentified): so this one is for yep the 2011 Dodge Ram pickup that is used at Mount Agamemticus that also was approved last year for $39,000 we received two bids One was from One Nation Distribution out of Pennsylvania for a 2026 Ford Ranger XL 4x4 SuperCrew cab for $45,494 less, a $6,000 trade-in totaling $39,494. and the other one was from Arundel Ford for a very similar truck but a 2027 that one was for $39,989 less a $3,000 trade totaling $36,989 so once again they're very similar I think from what I could tell in the bids there wasn't any extra that came with the 2026 it's It's still a standard, basic model, so I don't know why they came in so high other than maybe the transportation fee from Pennsylvania. So we're recommending the 2027 at the lower value of $36,989.
[1:11:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Any questions for Robin?
[1:11:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Chair, I move to award the Mount Angomenicus Truck Replacement Bid to arundel ford in the amount of 36 989 for a 2027 ford ranger 4x4 crew cab xl the second
[1:11:52] Speaker A (unidentified): was my marla second by maryland any additional discussion every now and then i'll call the vote robert yes maryland yes marla yes triple chest motion carries 5-0 thank you would untie to me reports are two the first is the assessor's annual report we have our assessor Luke Vigu.
[1:12:14] Speaker J (unidentified): Good evening, I'm Luke Vigu, your tax assessor. Thank you for the opportunity to come and do my annual report. I'll try to keep it both brief and interesting for you. You have about a three-page handout in your packet there that summarizes what I'm going to say. I'm not going to go through that line by line. Basically, we're in a good place. I think both in the eyes of the taxpayer and the state of Maine who has statutory requirements for us. I feel like we're in a good place right now and I'll go through and kind of explain where I'm coming from on that but as you know the tax rate came down 13 cents this year. That is because we do our annual revaluation. Because of our annual adjustments to stay at market value and because of growth we added 420 million in value about 5% it's important to know the distinction between those two things so when we add value because of a market adjustment so about 340 million of that increase was from the market adjustments that is not something that provides tax relief to the taxpayers it provides equity to the taxpayers so what's that doing is recognizing people who are being over taxed and some that are being under taxed based on what the market has done and redistributing the tax burden on them but the growth the 780 million that we've added that does provide actual tax relief that's new money coming into the town that lowers what everybody else would otherwise have to pay and so there's a chart there in the middle of that first page that shows the last four years and I remember back in 2024 being concerned because we didn't add a lot of value that year and I was like this could be bad but I had no reason to be concerned as you see it's the 2025 kind of offset it and then we're right back to an average of about 80 million which is just a little bit less than one percent so I feel pretty confident that I can say we have about one percent of new growth every year which is good to know as we're doing our budget planning and looking at the numbers at the end of the year. In order to do those market adjustments, I do a two-year sales study. We had 639 sales this year. That's up about 50 from last year. I think that's a good thing. After doing the market adjustments, I show our numbers at 94% of market value. The state just sent in their report to me and it shows us at 93% which is which is great two years ago we were at 89% according to the state last year we were at 91 so we're we're in better standing we're right where we want to be we also have a quality rating of 10 so the statutory requirements are to have your assessment ratio above 70 and a quality of below 10 that's your just dispersion from the average so it has to be below 20 so above 70 below 20 so we're at 93 and at 10 if we ever fall out in either of those measurements they withhold homestead exemption reimbursement which is getting pretty close to half a million dollars a year so that's that's why we do our market adjustments we want to stay in good standing and to stay equitable in order to do these market adjustments about 38 of our 75 residential neighborhoods went up that's about half so about half of them went up a couple came down almost all of our commercial neighborhoods went up there's a couple of tables at the end i'll show you i'm just you can kind of get an eye to see which ones those were that's about average i think for what we've been doing for the last few years i do want to point out down on the bottom of the first page it says we had an increase of nine parcels this year that seems low to only have nine new parcels created it is a little deceiving because that's the total number we do have lot consolidations as well from parcels like when maybe the land trust acquires some parcels, they get merged into one. So that's a negative on the parcel count. But some of the reason that we only have nine is because like a couple of subdivisions lately are not doing land divisions. They're doing condos. So Woodstone, for instance, it's 106 or 109 condo units. They didn't do lot splits. Harbor Woods down at 103 just did the same thing. So it's seven houses going up. No new lots because they're actually condo units. So that's a little deceiving but a little low What is alarming is on the top of page two the average selling price for a single-family home Excluding anything waterfront is now nine hundred and sixty thousand If you just go to realtor comm and just scroll and look at it, you'll you'll know so that was up that's up about 60 70 thousand from last year waterfront is up to about 3.2 million that's a an increase of almost half a million from last year interestingly vacant land sales told the average sale price of vacant land sales came down from last year it is not a measurement that I trust very much because there are so few of them so last year they could have been just an outlier that pulled the average up but it is interesting but the average land sale now is about 360 and even rurally we're seeing the a two acre house lot being over 300 000. what didn't make it into this report that i wish i had put in is the commercial sales so over the last two years we've had 12 commercial sales with a median sale price of one three but a mean of just under 2 million there were two really high-end sales one was the surf club and one was the lighthouse in that pulled up the average but it gives you an idea the median of 1.3 and that is why we did we did in a small amount tick up the commercial values this year I've heard from one commercial property owner, so that's good news. Projects, we continue to scan the old commitment books that were really never properly done. We do one at a time because it's too overwhelming for the poor people over at Alpha Graphics because the books are literally a foot thick, 11 by 17 pin feed books that aren't staying together and it's our only hard copy for years from the 80s and into the 90s now they take it apart page by page scan it and put it onto a thumb drive for me and then print me a good bound book so we're doing three a year because it's it's a budget that we can manage and with a few more years we'll be caught up on those and thankfully Alex Martin the assistant assessor has been out in the field the state requires assessors to do a review of every property every four years. They allow that review to be in-house. That's not ideal. I'd like to actually put eyes on properties more often than we are because currently we only see your house if you obtain a building permit or then we'd have to notice something going by for us to trigger or us to look at it. so we're doing basically drive-bys where he'll take the assessment card look at the house make sure the style looks right the condition looks right that there aren't additions that aren't supposed to be there and moves on so you may see him he was in the field today usually midday he's in the nissan leaf most of the time it's always available for some reason i don't know the code office doesn't seem to like it so we get to use it so those are projects that we're working on bottom of that second page there's a table there this is really just more interesting than anything but you can track what the actual net to be raised by property taxes has done over the last 15 or more years that's the number that goes on the municipal valuation return that takes the school budget the municipal budget the county tax and then subtracts out of that all of the things that are other sources of revenue. Revenue sharing, parking, reimbursements from the state, excise tax, and the only time we really, I get to see those numbers in one place is when we put together all of that data and calculate the tax rate. So you end up with a net to be raised by property tax that this past year was only an increase of 2.84, and bear in mind that doesn't account for the almost 1% of growth. so when you figure out you have 1% of growth we realistically only had a budget increase of about 1.9 percent last year effectively the next page are a couple of graphs that show just how the tax rate has come down as the taxable valuation has gone up the reason they don't match perfectly is because there is an increase in spending every year so the rate isn't coming down as fast as that value is going up but they do mirror themselves pretty well you can see the covet uptick on the taxable valuation and it does look like it's starting to kind of taper off a little bit up there and then on the last page i was referencing earlier the neighborhood adjustments both residential and commercial i know it's hard to read the actual factors that are in there but i put it here so that you could have a visual of on the left side those are all of our residential neighborhoods there are about 73 of them and you can see over the past four years the ones I've made adjustments to obviously a green is up a red is down there are two that actually haven't changed but you can see each year it's roughly half maybe one year maybe it was more like two-thirds were adjusted but that just gives you a good visual of the work that I do to do these market adjustments and then on the commercial side you can see last year almost all of those came up to a smaller degree to date i have received four and this isn't in your packet i've received four official abatement requests that number's down from years past one i immediately granted they really didn't have to go through the abatement process if they had called or come in i would have just agreed with them the other three i did deny and i they could be appealed to the Board of Assessment Review. That board is understaffed by one, but you will be shortly interviewing someone to fill that position so that we'll make sure that board is up and running and ready to go. But just because I've only had four abatement applications doesn't mean I haven't done abatements. I've actually done 38 abatements, and then when someone comes in or points out that I've made a mistake, we missed some homestead exemptions that were supposed to have been granted, There were some businesses that closed that we didn't know, so we sent them a tax bill. So we've actually done 38 abatements for a total of $24,000, but we've done four supplements, which is sent the tax bill that we should have sent for $20,000. So really, they almost even out. those the supplements were properties that were redeemed there were two properties that were redeemed and they needed to then pay the 2027 tax bill once they redeemed them I have some good news but I want to take questions before I talk about the good news does anyone have questions just a quick question
[1:24:51] Speaker E (unidentified): with the amount of money that it's been required to buy property in New York what's that doing to the population base young versus old do we keep track of
[1:25:03] Speaker J (unidentified): that I do not keep track of that I have a feeling that I have children becoming adults that are looking there they it's not even a thought that they're gonna be able to afford to live here and my parents moved in with me
[1:25:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other questions? Do you have a set of questions?
[1:25:38] Speaker E (unidentified): I reckon my case. Martin?
[1:25:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Luke, I just wanted to thank you. This is very comprehensive, but yet also very easy to understand and informative, and really appreciate your work in sharing it with us in this format.
[1:25:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I agree with Marla. And, you know, I mean, I love numbers, so this is great, you know, just to see all. It is a little depressing, though. I mean, I know it's positive in terms of tax revenue, but it's it's it's depressing to think that, you know, the average selling price of a single family home is a million bucks. I mean, it's just crazy,.
[1:26:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Not even in the water.
[1:26:20] Speaker F (unidentified): Not in the water, no.
[1:26:23] Speaker J (unidentified): Well, that leads well into the good news. Yeah. So ever since I've been an assessor, I have been disappointed and disgusted at how little the veterans exemption has been. and there's finally been a change to the veterans exemption it's taking immediately so for the April 1st 2027 assessment which is in six months the homestead the veterans exemption is now going to be available to any veteran who ever served during any war period so the currently you have to be 62 or older and have served active duty during a federally recognized war period. That is completely going away. So now any veteran, regardless of age or when they had active duty, is going to qualify. For those at that entry level, the number is staying the same. Actually, under 62, it's a $5,000 exemption. Above 62, it's a $6,000 exemption. That's what it currently is. But they're adding a new layer to it based on the level of disability that the veteran may have. So any veteran, regardless of age, who is 60% disabled is going to qualify for a $10,000 exemption. 70% disabled, a $20,000 exemption. 80%, a $30,000 exemption. 90%, a $40,000 exemption. and anyone that's 100% disabled gets a $50,000 exemption and this is in addition to the homestead which is the $25,000 so there are going to be some we're going to be going from either just the homestead at 25 or the homestead of the veterans at 31 all the way up to a $75,000 exemption. Assessors everywhere are scrambling because there are some components to this like we have to track age now to know when you tick from below 62 to 62. None of us have documentation that show level of disability. Veterans are going to have to find their VA letter that states their amount of disability and get it to us. Right now any veteran that's 62 or older that does not have 60% or more disability does not have to do anything, this forms the same, they do not have to reapply. But any veteran under 62 is going to have to apply and anyone with a disability has to reapply. We're going to do everything we can possibly do before tax bills go out to reach out. Of course the best level of communication we have is when we send the tax bill and we put that flyer in there for everybody to see we don't want to wait until they miss a year we got a listing of everyone with a veteran plate in just in York from the tax collectors but it's a list of names so we're going to try to use AI to connect that list of names to property owners so we can do a letter and we are gonna we obviously know every veteran is 62 or older they're going to get a letter from us saying if you have any amount of disability here's your form you need to reapply get it to us so i'm excited about that i hope our veterans feel a little bit more respected from what's actually a maybe a beneficial exemption compared to what it has been the one thing that we need to bear in mind is it's now it's tied to the homestead exemption. It's going to be one form. A veteran does have to qualify for the homestead before they get the veterans. Currently someone can actually be a renter but own land and they're a resident because they rent but they can get their veteran's exemption on the land. That is going away because it has to be at your homestead. So that also means there's a one-year waiting period for people when they come to town. We currently have four veterans that moved to town last year that got the veterans exemption in year one but the homestead can't kick in until that year has passed so now veterans are gonna have to wait that whole year before they get anything there's emergency legislation to fix that hopefully in time for this upcoming year the state also overlooked that we have some properties that have two veterans and this new law does not recognize that there's emergency legislation in place in case two owners are veterans to allow them both to benefit from that exemption the one thing we need to be aware of is because you know the state is required to reimburse towns for lost revenue we're gonna we're losing taxable value because of this the state only reimburses 76% of that so you know this is gonna be a little bit of a cost to the rest of the taxpayers anytime you have an exemption or an expanded exemption what's happening is the tax burden is being removed from those who qualify to those that don't so 24% of the money that our veterans are going to be saving is being distributed to the rest of the taxpayers that's how exemptions work I don't think that's going to be a large amount of money but it's something we'll have to keep track of and we'll we'll make our lives easier with the reimbursement because right now veterans either get 50 reimbursement or 76 percent reimbursement depending on where they were in the military so that's going away it's all going to be reimbursed at 76. it's going to make my life easier but i'm excited so we'll we're going to be working on getting these mailers together and together and sent out and that's that so any questions
[1:32:24] Speaker H (unidentified): for our successor this one is the form the gd214 still one that they would submit to you
[1:32:33] Speaker J (unidentified): that is one of the two forms we're now going to need that one gives us whether or not they had active duty you know we don't care about age anymore that's going to show if and when they served act you still have to have had at least a day of active duty so we will need that but if there's any level of disability we need the VA letter that states the percentage and apparently it's in 10% increments 60 70 80 90 or 100 so
[1:33:02] Speaker A (unidentified): one asset that's probably that's available to you so we have a committee on veterans affairs in time they have a fairly extensive list of email list of all the veterans in town. So that started probably three, four, five years ago when Barry Waddell was the chair, built up that list and they've been maintaining that and expanding it through VFW, American Legion, contacts, other events in town. So it's pretty comprehensive. So you can talk to the manager, look on the website, get their
[1:33:31] Speaker J (unidentified): chair. Right now the state doesn't even have guidance documents or an application, but they're saying hopefully by January 1st. So I would either share that document with them or ask them for their email list be watching
[1:33:47] Speaker A (unidentified): but yeah but just certainly reach out to them they do have a really extensive
[1:33:50] Speaker J (unidentified): list but for now we don't know anything we're dealing with the trash stuff right now so come in after January I will say we because we are getting a lot of calls as well the list for the trash pickup originated from the assessing data and so anywhere there is a mistake in the assessing data caused an issue for instance today someone on Woodbridge Road who has a home occupation in their home was cat I had categorized as a commercial property so they weren't on the list so this has given us an opportunity to find the issues that we have any data get him cleaned up they're gonna get their trash cans so it's but it has been, we're doing our best.
[1:34:37] Speaker I (unidentified): Do you want to say we, there are surprisingly few while we have Luke here. There are minor issues that you have in your data. So for example, street numbers, you know, being off or having two sets of street numbers, or maybe that property classified wrong. But when we drilled down into probably 19 out of 20 of the, we didn't get trash cans and they said were a commercial property or something like that, they're all explainable. I was actually surprised that most of there weren't more surprises in your data set. So thank you for the accuracy here. Your clerical data set is a shambles, but the core of it is really, good.
[1:35:20] Speaker J (unidentified): We also found someone's location that I had incorrect. They had it correct on the house. I had it in the system wrong, which means it was in the E911 system wrong. So if they had called me down on one, yeah, they no one would have known why they were so we got it We found it. We got it fixed
[1:35:36] Speaker H (unidentified): silver lining of it all
[1:35:38] Speaker E (unidentified): Thank you. You're welcome
[1:35:42] Speaker A (unidentified): So now we're down to reports the second item is ambulance update. I know we have our I Think all the ambulance people one just walked in When you're in the back of the room great
[1:36:10] Speaker N (unidentified): Eric Becky board president for York Ambulance Association We are back to provide an update prior to the vote next week. I will start with a board change update for you and an introduction and then kind of hand it off for some updates from them. So we have Matt McTighe, who has joined our board, and he has taken over as our board treasurer at this point and has been working with a small team from our board and our crew with wendy in the town so i'd like to hand it to him to kind of introduce himself and provide some updates in terms of what
[1:36:50] Speaker O (unidentified): they've been working on great thanks eric i know some of you nice to meet those of you that i haven't had a chance to meet with yet so my name is matt mctye for the last 15 years i've served as the treasurer of the york village fire department i was i joined the fire department as a firefighter in 2010 and have served in as treasurer since 2011 in that time I've helped you know create 501c3 status and a fundraising apparatus for the department and then use that model to help other fire departments in Maine follow suit to create their own independent corporations to help supplement town funding that is often stretched and you know as we see lots of competing interests and certainly understandable that departments you need all the help that they can get and you know try to supplement their revenue with private funding i've known josh in that capacity for you know as long as i've been a part of the fire department and so in the wake of some of the issues that the ambulance has been going through which you all have been talking with them about and well documented and obviously you're going to be voted on next tuesday josh asked me if i would consider helping out and i was more than happy to do that and joined about three weeks ago officially and now taken over as treasurer since then and even before that because I know you know in the since the meeting I guess it was probably two of your meetings ago and I think that there was a more robust discussion of the ambulance which is around the time that I was approached to join there's been a lot of great work going on and I just want to give a shout out in particular to Wendy who since I got involved in this two or three weeks ago has just been a phenomenal partner in helping us really try to sort through some of the questions that the town understandably has had and make sure that we can make progress and really try to use this as a marker to create a going forward, not try to relitigate the past. We certainly acknowledge there was miscommunication, there were decisions that I think when we look back now, definitely would not have made. And there were things that weren't clearly communicated to you all or to the town that we're still kind of trying to deal with, you know, the small business loan being, you know, the prime example, but we are taking steps to address all of those things and really want to turn over a new leaf in terms of just the ongoing communication, really having a clear ongoing chain of command, a real clear back and forth, getting you all the information you need on a regular basis in the form that you want so that we can have, you know, complete transparency up to and including and i think i joined i was i came to the meeting two weeks ago where it was discussed the idea of having two members from the town whether it's the select board or one of the committees join our board which we would absolutely welcome with open arms and you just tell us today and who you want to do but we 've we have already discussed that at one of our york ambulance association board meetings i'll try to just do this briefly but to say as part of the voting guide that went out to York voters, there was sort of a one-page attachment that outlined nine things that the town asked the ambulance to do sort of as a condition of the funding request that voters are gonna be going, voting on next Tuesday, and in some cases are already voting on with early voting. I'm pleased to say I think we have now accomplished or at least made progress on all nine of those things. I'm happy to review them if you would like I do have the attachment here but that would be helpful so York ambulance agrees to immediately notify the town of any sorry any material financial developments including but now I'm limited to and there's a long list of various things that could be that's obviously an ongoing thing that's not that wasn't just that was really I think more of a because of things that happened in the past let's make sure it doesn't happen again needless to say that is a firm commitment that i make and i know all of the members of the york ambulance association board will continue to adhere to going forward york ambulance association agrees to provide monthly financial reports bank statements and run activity to the town's finance director by the 15th of the following month it goes on i'm just going to do this briefly we're now doing that we've sent over everything for the last three months to wendy we've had some really good back and forth she's had good questions some of this quite frankly and i'm i'm really trying to get up to speed myself because i just having just joined some of this is information that we you know wasn't readily available and i think that in some cases is why you know we got into some of the situation that we were in we've now you know made changes to our board structure and now with me taking over i should also mention we've also voted as a board to create a new officer level position on the board of auditor that does not meet the request that was in here which i'll speak to of having an independent audit which we've never done before which we are going to begin taking bids to try to find somebody and welcome and we've said this to wendy welcome any recommendations that you all or anybody else from other agencies here in the town have used before we would love to meet with them to do that independent audit we've never we don't have one that we can share because there just has never been one done but we did also create a an actual board position of auditors so that on an ongoing basis, we can be doing that even without having to go out of the, take the added step of paying for an independent auditor. York Ambulance Association agrees to make two ex-officio board seats available to the town. As I said, we look forward to that. So you just tell us how you wanna do that. Technically, we didn't have a status of ex-officio board in our, you're either a board member or you're not. So that is something that we can make a change in our bylaws to create a new category of ex-officio member and would just have to spell out what that means but frankly I have said this to all the members of the ambulance Association board we are we would be open to just having it be a full board member not even having any sort of special designation that would potentially have you know fewer you know voting rights or anything else but suffice to say we look forward to that and would really welcome it from a transparency standpoint York Ambulance Association agrees to consult with the town before issuing debt or encumbering assets that's another ongoing commitment that we can make york ambulance association agrees to develop a plan to resolve the small business loan default by october 1st i did not become treasurer until i think october 13th or so but we have since then submitted something to wendy that i think was shared with most of you i'm happy to discuss it about a pro one proposed plan that depending on the outcome of next tuesday's vote we believe would solve that problem or at least get us out from under the sort of crippling period of collections that is now just kind of hanging over the ambulance we can come back to that one because I think that's probably one of the biggest ones that you all may have questions about your game you'll associate agrees to develop a plan to resolve the previously disclosed ambulance purchase that sort of wraps in it 's all part of the same sort of proposed solution which again I can go into your game with Association agrees to file their 2025 IRS forms by November 30th. I am working on that now, and I do that for the fire department every year, and we'll certainly do that well before November 30th, and then we'll do it without having to ask for any extension in future years. Agrees to provide a copy of their most recent independent audit. As I mentioned, we've never done one, but we are committed to doing one, and again, would love recommendations from anybody that has worked with credible auditors in the past. and then last but not least the town and york agree that the conditions contained herein will become effective on november 4th which that's you know we're already sort of adhering to them but i just want to reiterate again and then i'm happy to take questions and or and we could turn it over to either josh or crystal if you have any specifics but you know since i got involved in this i would say that the communication with wendy in particular has really i think just been stellar i mean you know just all i have to really compare it to in the town of york is just with the fire department that's never been bad that's always actually been quite good but this has been exceptional wendy is just really extremely responsive when we send her things she is very thorough she asks great questions you can tell she's read everything she's really been thoughtful about everything the questions that she sends back to us and i think and i want to give a particular shout out to crystal from our department does a fantastic job of pulling together answers very quickly and then you know the few times we've had something where it's like i still don't get it or you know i have more follow-up questions we schedule a time to you know get on the phone or you know set up a meeting and come in so you know i think things are going much better i feel very good about the you know the path forward presuming hoping knock on wood that the vote goes through next week so that we can frankly survive the current financial challenges and make sure that we are in a position to get ourselves out from under the sort of, you know, the cloud or whatever metaphor you want to pick, so that we could start the year fresh, we could start the year, you know, with a real plan to go forward, finish off the contract that we have currently with the town that takes us through the first half of the year, and then hopefully, you know, continue to work on a, you know, an ongoing partnership. Anything I feel like I left out, or should we ask any questions?
[1:46:20] Speaker F (unidentified): I mean, I think we need more information on the SB loan. You mentioned that you're going to talk about it more fully. So what, because we had, as you went through it, a resolution we wanted by October 1st. So obviously we blew through that date. But what are your plans now to- Well, so the reason for the big, the biggest
[1:46:40] Speaker O (unidentified): reason for the delay, just to reiterate, I think most of you know this, Wendy certainly knows this, and for the audience or for the sake of anybody listening, the reason we didn't have it was because we had a basically a we were in a status of dispute about whether or not the loan was should have been sent to collections it was it was sent to a collections agent there was a question about the timing because there were payments that were made that we believed and we reached out to the treasury department we you know we reached out to the small business administration we reached out through senator collins office we reached out to anybody that we thought could be helpful in getting clarity about the fact that we had made payments we had you know made a payment right up in this sort of limbo period between when a letter was received from the small business from the sba and before it was officially you know sent to collections and there was some dispute about whether or not you know it should have ever been sent to collections in the first place the long story short version is that we now believe that it has been sent to collections and there's virtually nothing that we can do about it whether we could fight all day and say well you know but we did make this payment and we have proof of the payments and that's not what's in dispute it's just a question of when the treasury you know hit the button to send it to collections and then the collections agency at that point you know the treasury is like it's out of our hands we can't do anything and even said you know even senator collins office we've been working with trying to just get clarity get answers just you know can you get the right person on the phone because when we spend four hours on hold We were you know kind of just left with more questions and answers payments were missed Well, I don't even know I can't answer that offhand, but I can you know confirm it But it was quite I think there was at least you know tour there was at least a two-month period where there was no payments made And there was and you know at that point. What's that? Yeah, no Yeah, I mean you guys obviously have been working on this lawyer that I have there. They know the answer. Yeah, okay?
[1:48:37] Speaker F (unidentified): it's not thank you so i mean so i mean it shouldn't come as a surprise it's not the collection because it was nine months well and make payments right but we had received
[1:48:47] Speaker O (unidentified): communications from the sba that you know based on the dates of what at least from what i've seen just trying to get caught up on all this stuff at least we're all it's you know i believe that frankly mistakes were made and i you know i even though i wasn't part of it at the
[1:49:04] Speaker F (unidentified): time i think it was absolutely you know so you now believe that not that it's in collection you're not going to be able to get it out of collection correct so you're going to have to find so what are your solutions for remedying that because right now because it's in collection
[1:49:19] Speaker O (unidentified): you're not receiving payments medicare payments so they're they're withholding medicare payments without which the ambulance cannot function right on a month-to-month basis the town's contract the 12 000 issues you know ish per month what we make from calls what we make from our private fundraising what we make from any other revenue services would not cover expenses to have payroll to have an ambulance respond when somebody calls 9-1-1 to you know be able to actually fulfill our obligations to the people of the town if we are having medicare withheld and we have now and we've sent this to wendy know that you know we are now having medicare withheld as of you know two weeks ago when we received our reimbursement statement from our Medicare broker there was withholding payment of I think close to $20,000 that you know basically created a gap that made our balance sheet untenable and frankly it would it's it we're entering a slower period where call volumes are only gonna go down so it's not like the high you know we make the majority of our calls are in the high peak summer months you know winter is usually you know kind of more hand-to-mouth in terms of at least the numbers that i've been you know seeing and getting caught up on so it is in collections so the plan is or at least the proposed plan is to make a motion as in my in my position separately as the treasurer of the york village fire department corporation i can't speak for the beach but we plan to talk to them about possibly partnering with us on this, that the York Village Fire Department Corporation would use our private funds that are raised completely independently from any taxpayer dollars whatsoever that are invested and have been grown over the last 15 years that I've been treasurer to now be close to a little more than half a million dollars, most of which is invested in very conservative, this isn't my money, I'm not chasing stocks trying to go after the latest anthropic ipo or you know by nvidia we are you know we have a conservative portfolio for the majority of our investments we would use a portion of that to just pay off the loan both the small business loan and the ambulance that would get the ambulance out of collections because that they're requiring that payment be made we will be in collections until every dollar is paid there's no payment plan they are not offering they're like a loan shark they do not come in and say well why don't we work something out that's fair you know we'll do a nice low interest rate you know twenty five hundred dollars a month that's like until you pay every dollar we will be in collections so how much money is that it's about a hundred and fifty thousand for the 157 000 is when you subtract so i think the original loan was about 180 we made about thirty thousand dollars worth of payments but the minute it went into collections which we could now verify it did a penalty of a little north of 25 000 was added so we're effectively back where we started we are we now 157 000 towards the small business loan separately
[1:52:26] Speaker C (unidentified): the ambulance the outstanding i'm sorry that would be 175 and then are you netting out the 20
[1:52:33] Speaker O (unidentified): thousand that's been sorry where are you getting the 175 180 minus 30 yeah plus 25. it's 157 746 now i may be getting my numbers about what the original loan amount was i can get you more information but i don't have it in front of me it was i know i didn't know if your 157 reflected the twenty thousand and i may have stated the 180 they do you know the loan amount the original loan
[1:52:57] Speaker P (unidentified): amount so the original loan amount was for 150 000. we suffered 40 000 in penalties when it went to collections that brought it up to 190. currently with our medicare being garnished and such that amount the medicare garnishments plus what we have paid in that amount is now
[1:53:15] Speaker O (unidentified): down to a total of 157 000. and that is not counting the 25 000 so for the ambulance so we would i would propose and again this is not a motion that we have made yet to the we would wait until after the vote you know because if the tax if the townspeople don't vote in favor of the funding you know we have bigger problems but this would get us out of collections we would work out a fair and reasonable rate based on probably the five or ten year bond yield you know at the time of execution of any loan agreement i happen to do this line of work in my day job so you know i would write the donation agreement and have it all you know legally verified but we would work out it would basically be an investment what we'd be making back on the interest over the next 10 years or whatever the duration is that we ultimately determine we think makes sense to get the monthly payment to from the ambulance down to something that they can manage that we would space that out as long as it needed to probably not any longer than 10 years but somewhere between five and ten should do it and i believe we could get that monthly payment down to somewhere between two and three thousand $1,000 depending on whether it's a five or ten year loan with an interest rate below five percent Again, that's not a handout. That's not you know, we're not just that's not a gift That's not a lot You know that would be a loan just like the investments that we make Through you know the conservative portfolio that we invest the majority of our corporation assets And I should just for background for those who don't know the reason we have you know A corporation that raises private money the town obviously funds the majority of our you know our expenses for the fire department the roof over our head making sure that there's firefighters to answer the call 24 7 most of the trucks that aren't federally funded but there's a lot of other expenses that come up training materials training sending people to specialized training a lot of the water rescue expenses a lot of the additional equipment that we buy to outfit our trucks with you know more cutting edge up-to-date things that we see and learn about that are that are life-saving equipment as well as helping to support firefighters and their families when they fall on hard times so this would you know it would obviously be you know come out of that but we are doing very well with our private funds and the investments that we've made and I believe that this would be a prudent way of helping to get the ambulance essentially out of hock so that they can live to fight another day that we would be able to start the year fresh that we would be able to
[1:55:38] Speaker F (unidentified): continue to work so have you had conversations with the officers of the York Village Fire
[1:55:43] Speaker O (unidentified): Corporation I've talked to most of them we haven't we haven't brought it up at a monthly meeting yet we would wait it just so happens that our next monthly meeting is next thursday so we would know the outcome of the vote if the vote goes the way we hope it will i plan to bring that up but
[1:55:57] Speaker F (unidentified): i've already discussed it so if they vote no what's the plan well what's plan b it would
[1:56:05] Speaker O (unidentified): we would have to turn to you know private investor private donations or look for other people to helpfully hope you know to try to buy off the loan but i've already gotten i've already i've already received soft commitments from the majority of the firefighters to support the resolution and I wouldn't bring it up if I didn't think that it would pass and
[1:56:27] Speaker F (unidentified): so then what so when do you run out of money when does the
[1:56:32] Speaker O (unidentified): ambulance run out of money yeah I can answer one way but do you all have any
[1:56:45] Speaker Q (unidentified): so once we get out of that problem where they're you know taking our money every month in the Medicare. We'll have a better idea on how much we should be receiving, you know, looking at our past finances, which I've been working with Wendy on to do the projections for the future. But, you know, we've done up to 350,000 with that projection in mind.
[1:57:07] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, but we did it looking at it on a monthly basis. So I think, you know, Wendy presented to this board how much she thought it would be per month. and November is gonna you're not gonna have enough money yeah
[1:57:26] Speaker Q (unidentified): I mean everything is really dependent on this boat and the SBA loan that's killing us and yeah I don't really have an answer for you
[1:57:34] Speaker C (unidentified): right now yeah I know but November is like next week yeah thank you really appreciate the updates still a lot of uncertainty I'm looking at an email that you sent out Matt last yeah last Tuesday evening about the situation to Wendy that was shared among some of us and it mentioned in addition to the Medicare reimbursements being withheld it mentions a couple places garnishing of wages so we've
[1:58:12] Speaker O (unidentified): clarified that can you explain that yeah no it is just the medicare withholding i was mistaken i'm i'm new to this literally like that was my i wrote that email you know 10 days into the job but we've since clarified that with wendy but it sounds like the clarification didn't make it to
[1:58:27] Speaker C (unidentified): you guys okay and you discussed the possibility of the york village fire corporation making a loan to the ambulance association to repay the sba loan and as of tuesday night when you sent this out had you had discussions with the village fire corporation president or vice president of
[1:58:47] Speaker O (unidentified): those officers yes you had okay but not taken a vote i mean we still haven't taken a vote it was the request in the document you know was for a plan this is a plan it's you know it's the it's the best plan i've had time to come up with so far i mean and frankly it's the only plan that i think would get us out of the emergency situation that we're in because even if the vote passes on Tuesday, and again, I'm optimistic. I know that everybody I speak to understands the value of the ambulance to this community and what would happen if they weren't able to endure in the short term. But we would need to come back to you all with the approval from the voters to get an immediate fusion to get us through November and then figure out what the month that we would need from a month-to-month basis going forward.
[1:59:36] Speaker C (unidentified): We certainly are hopeful as well. i have a few more questions as you think about the structure of this potential loan from the village corporation to the ambulance association would it be secured or unsecured secure it would be secured so it would replace the all asset lien that the sba holds so that the village fire corporation would now have a lien on all the ambulance association's assets what other conditions
[2:00:01] Speaker O (unidentified): conditions are you contemplating so are we contemplating yeah for the fire department loan yes just you know fulfillment of it you know pending that if the bet you know if there was a bank you know if the ambulance did ever go into bankruptcy that we would you know have ownership of their the assets that they own privately that we would have to sell to pay off you know to make whole any loan amount that's still outstanding at the time that such a thing you know god forbid happened all right so basically similar to the sba structure well similar except for the most important difference being that the sba is you know requiring it right away and has control because you're in default but
[2:00:47] Speaker C (unidentified): if you were to be in default under the new loan well the new lender could exercise those
[2:00:52] Speaker O (unidentified): rights as well so yeah it's a replacement just different well sorry we would be the village fire department would be the new lender correct yeah we're not you know gonna go after the york
[2:01:02] Speaker C (unidentified): ambulance association's medicare reimbursement with regards to the ambulance purchase obligation i thought i saw communication somewhere else and forgive me i'm not sure where and i know you had a full page ad in the sentinel i'm not sure if it was there or somewhere else that there was a suggestion that perhaps a private donor would pay off the 25 000 to we did
[2:01:24] Speaker O (unidentified): did have somebody come forward with that proposal but frankly we asked them to hold off on that because we don't until we would you know we have bigger problems you know the vote the small business loan take precedence over buying and paying off a new ambulance it would be a shame to lose you know if we ended up having to pay the penalty if we pay the 25 000 what we would be losing out on aside from the obvious 25 000 is the commitment that we have from bulldog the out the ambulance provider the outfitter that we had worked with on that at the at the rate and the terms that they had agreed to at the time the cost of an ambulance has gone up probably about 25 to 30 percent
[2:02:07] Speaker C (unidentified): speaking of the penalty part the 25,000 so that offer you're not pursuing at this point that you're you're sort of your plan we didn't want
[2:02:16] Speaker O (unidentified): to ask a donor to pay off something if we didn't think that there was going to be you know that there was a chance even a infinitesimal one and you know god forbid not likely one that there would you know wouldn't be an ambulance association to run that ambulance okay my next question is in wendy's review of the most
[2:02:33] Speaker C (unidentified): recent financial information that you provided her i understand that there was a large health insurance payment made recently had your health insurance payments fallen behind crystal you want
[2:02:44] Speaker Q (unidentified): to take this one the one from the month before went through on the first and so when i had sent out the other one that month sometimes i had some issues with getting my check signed so was that
[2:02:56] Speaker C (unidentified): two months worth then yeah it came out in the same month this has to do with the former treasurer
[2:03:03] Speaker O (unidentified): and that's one of the reasons why we made the changes to the board understood how much cash
[2:03:10] Speaker C (unidentified): do you currently have on hand do you ever around 40 000 not 40 and your next payroll is not for another yeah we just had it yeah okay so have you prepared an updated cash flow forecast once again trying to zero in on you know when does the money when does the money run out have you prepared an updated cash flow forecast maybe with some assumptions yeah we did a you
[2:03:44] Speaker O (unidentified): know i don't know if this is but we have our november and december projections that we
[2:03:50] Speaker C (unidentified): started putting together have you provided us with those or provided wendy with those updated
[2:03:56] Speaker O (unidentified): projections we haven't had a fine we haven't had a final review of our finance committee yet but the plan was to send it this week we have a finance committee meeting on wednesday to just review all the you know this was one of the things in one of our meetings with wendy in addition to the five the nine things that were listed in that voter guide which we tried to prioritize getting answers for those things there were also some other questions that she asked us to prepare some additional documents, including the cash flow projections, what an ask would be under different, like so assuming that the vote passes on Tuesday, what would the ask be on Wednesday for the month of November, or if we were gonna try to do something for a larger month, November, December, to get us through the end of the year, the calendar year, what the different projection needs would be, and that includes a cash flow analysis and projected spending for November and December.
[2:04:48] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah to me that would be very important yeah and we hope as soon as we as soon as the finance committee reviews it we will and i would say personally that i think one of the intentions of the way the conditions were established was that we would not be advancing large amounts to carry you through multiple months because there is still risk involved in the situation but that smaller advances would be considered based on a cash flow forecast. I think that was sort of mutually our expectation and so that cash flow forecast, super important. That's all I have, thank you. What's
[2:05:31] Speaker Q (unidentified): another thing I just wanna bring up too that a new thing that we have added is to do that finance committee so we have a second meeting during the month that a smaller group of people get together and talk about the financial stuff like the forecast just so you guys know that is something we added to it that's to help oh and I'm sorry one more thing
[2:05:51] Speaker C (unidentified): so you met you said that you manage all of the York Village fire corporations private investment accounts and do you do that as an investment advisor for a fee no I just do it for free okay but you're are you like a licensed
[2:06:07] Speaker O (unidentified): investment advisor I am I have many people that work for me in my personal capacity or in my professional capacity managing large estates who do it provide it as a service you know for free okay just thinking about potential conflicts sure they would they would not be involved in this they helped me manage the investment funds of the York fire department private corporation they wouldn't have any you know the bankers at UBS and Morgan Stanley wouldn't have anything to do with this loan for
[2:06:44] Speaker E (unidentified): the ambulance Association okay thank you just a quick question for who is garnishing the Medicare payments the
[2:06:56] Speaker P (unidentified): federal government the US Treasury so taking them because the federal loans so they're taking any federal money that we could potentially receive so you have federal loans
[2:07:08] Speaker E (unidentified): right now is that a small business loan small business administration is a federal u.s department of treasury federal loan oh thanks for clarifying that because i was about to say that you can't really garnish medicare payments unless you're a federal government unfortunately
[2:07:25] Speaker F (unidentified): robert and marianne so just two more questions so i just want to be clear you don't have any expectation that you're going to be coming back to the town to ask them for money to pay off the sba loan no the town yes no so there's there's there's no expect the only
[2:07:44] Speaker O (unidentified): thing that we would the only thing that we will do or you know we would do assuming that the fire depor you know the vote passes next tuesday and the you know the corporation the fire corporation you know votes to use our private funds to support this is that we would build into our monthly until our annual budget you know when we submit to you all in the next couple of weeks because this is one of the other things that wendy asked us to get as soon as possible a projected budget for next year that there would be built into that a line item along with all of the other utility bills and other expenses that we have whatever a monthly
[2:08:18] Speaker F (unidentified): payment would be that would be part of the budget to my second question which is so you've answered that you're not coming back to us for that money if plan a doesn't work with the york village fire you won't be coming back and asking us you'll find another method to do it or else you won't do it right so if there is a loan payment if this goes forward and there's a loan payment my expectation would be the payment amount would be very similar to what the sba payment was well that well because that was the that was the you know we came up and look at the budget that we came up with the 350 000 it had that sba loan in there and that may require you to do interest-only payments for those first seven months i don't know but i my expectation it would be that amount not a much higher amount i guess yeah i mean the hope is
[2:09:11] Speaker O (unidentified): it would i don't remember maybe you guys knew what that monthly payment was i mean we didn't
[2:09:16] Speaker C (unidentified): I remember six or seven hundred bucks and it was a 30-year loan so the payment was quite low right
[2:09:25] Speaker O (unidentified): yeah this wouldn't this would end up I mean this would almost certainly need to be more than that because I don't think that we at the fire department would be able to get approval for a 30-year loan I think we would probably end up doing something but you could do interest only for seven months yeah the ambulance certainly and it's based on the payments good yeah
[2:09:42] Speaker H (unidentified): I just want to thank you for stepping forward I know I've seen you over the years and you perform my wedding there you go and I know you know you stepped into a big mess and I really appreciate you trying to fix the situation I consider the Amherst association really almost part of the town you are not a town department but you've been the place that we've been going to calling after 9-1-1 for many years so i 'm looking forward i'm encouraged that you have the knowledge and expertise to help the folks that you're sitting with at the table and then helping the town too so i know it's i know some of my peers here are numbers people so they asked all those hard questions and you answered them but i think better days are ahead for everybody so thank you i hope so i believe they are thank you so i
[2:10:57] Speaker A (unidentified): just have a couple of questions my colleagues and answer most of them i just want to maybe get some clarification on a couple so there been any other changes in the trustees of the evidence association other than the treasurer no not to this point is there any other so no one's been added to the just we wanted to wait until we knew who
[2:11:16] Speaker O (unidentified): you all were adding because at this point what we're trying to do what we really would like to do is try to fill like a you know like an NFL team drafting for need you know if you okay we really need a new linebacker we need a new quarterback like what you know we're going to the draft we you know we have it in our bylaws i think we still have space for i think up to up to 12 so another four that we could not counting the two from the town and rather than just you know throwing it out and saying oh this person's really smart or they're nice or my neighbor asked if they could be a part of it really trying to figure out so like for example like if somebody had auditing experience i would love to talk to them about possibly joining our board because that's a position that we've agreed to create and I would love to have somebody, if somebody had, you know, a more accounting experience, a retired accountant, and I'm saying this to anybody that's listening on the speakers or in the audience, you know, we really would welcome people that have real specific expertise that could be of value to essentially a small business like ours. You know, a small business that happens to be a public benefit corporation that provides literal vital life-saving services to the people of York. And so if you, know, or if people want to do some good and have some experience specifically in accounting or auditing or sort of financial management we would
[2:12:28] Speaker A (unidentified): love to talk to you in the other is there been any additional discussion with the southern what main health with regard to your building facility on
[2:12:39] Speaker N (unidentified): their property is any of that changed we do have sort of what we think would be the final go-forward offer but there were sort of holding off until the vote as well so that we can give a yes we're gonna move forward with the $1,500 a month you know proposed that's the number is it 's yeah that was the original proposed number and that's the number that would go forward it would stay right at that 1,500 okay and then the other is just following up so I want
[2:13:05] Speaker A (unidentified): to make sure I heard you correctly so the email that you sent out on this is the mat Thursday was that's probably last Wednesday yeah that's
[2:13:15] Speaker O (unidentified): Wednesday right or the night of our board so next yeah Tuesday night yeah I'm just trying to get this
[2:13:19] Speaker A (unidentified): yep Tuesday the 20th at about eight o'clock so you said that you did discuss the loan with
[2:13:27] Speaker O (unidentified): leadership of the York Village Fire Corporation I so I spoke to some of the fire the leaders from the board of the fire department about that initially we first spoke about this when we talked about it in the ambulance just about the just about doing the ambulance offset the a $25,000 ambulance loan, buying that. So essentially paying that part off. That opened up a conversation with the board, or at least a few of the officers from the board, about what we as a fire department were willing to do to try to help our brothers on the ambulance to continue to provide the services that they provide to the town. And basically the concept of this sort of approach of us paying off some of their debts is what was discussed.
[2:14:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you mention the loan amount that's in the email on that Tuesday? So there was no number attached to that? No. Okay. So what's the process that has to happen for the York Village Fire Corporation members to authorize this sort of action?
[2:14:25] Speaker O (unidentified): So how does that happen? Is it a public meeting? Is it a private meeting? It's a private meeting of our corporation. So every firefighter in good standing, as well as some of our past firefighters who are still voted on, we purge our rolls. i think quarterly but it's about 60 active and former firefighters most of whom work the smart truck that are still active voting members of the york village fire department corporation which again is a separate and independent entity they vote on everything when we when we are we gonna have a barbecue are we gonna send three junior explorers to a training are we gonna buy new jaws of life tools are we you know we have these votes every you know every month we review our finances we you know we discuss you know any major you know anything any activities that we're planning for the corporation i give the treasurer's report anybody on the floor can make a motion any vote any member can make a motion you know to propose something that they want to buy if they want to get a new utv to help you know wilderness firefighting or if they want to buy new t-shirts to sell at our annual field day they can make a motion for an expenditure so i would be the one making this motion and would articulate the reasons for doing it but again would you know i see this as somebody who watches our investments come and go and yes the last 18 months things have been on a tear and you know really ripping and so the rate of return even on our conservative portfolio has been above normal i don't expect that to live forever and so i think that this is frankly just as good of an investment from our corporation I wouldn't do it if I really thought that this was risky I think that you know the thinking of this is a loan that you know every month when they make their payments I will reinvest that back into our investment accounts and until then we will be accruing interest on it that I think ultimately over the span of the light of the term of the loan will yield more or less the same as what would have come out to pay it so did you
[2:16:27] Speaker A (unidentified): ever discuss this idea like months ago before we arrived at this position that
[2:16:31] Speaker O (unidentified): we're in with the ambulance was that ever talked about i didn't know about the situation that the ambulance was in at the time okay so
[2:16:39] Speaker C (unidentified): it would be one non-profit lending to another yeah well yeah
[2:16:51] Speaker P (unidentified): anyone else any questions for us i just got some more information for you joshua allen york ambulance chief of operations just to put it into perspective for the amount of work we do in town just some call numbers for you so through the end of september this year so the first three quarters york ambulance has responded to 1 311 calls for service in the sound in the last quarter july august and september those are our busiest months we've responded to 497 calls to service. Of those, that's averaging out to 166 calls a month. Of those calls, it remains consistent that about a third of them are non-billable calls. Those are your false alarm medical alarms, your public assist calls, fire standbys. So again, we're not getting paid for every call that we roll out the door on in light of these recent discussions as a board we have started developing some more policies to help alleviate that a little bit we are establishing policies to be able to begin billing for motor vehicle accidents if we come to your motor vehicle accident and you're not injured but we provide an assessment take vital signs that's something auto insurance companies pay for we have worked with our billing company to develop these procedures so that we can begin billing for that was not something that was made clear to us in the past our public assistance calls we are working on policies to begin billing individuals who utilize our services in excess additionally any facilities in town that have medical staff on site that are utilizing our services to come do the jobs they should be doing, picking up people off the floor, helping them to the bathroom, et cetera. We're working on policies to begin building those facilities for those services. So we're working on generating new revenue streams in addition to our traditional insurance billing. Also internally, on our operations side and accounting side, we've already purchased programs and put into place accounting software so that we don't run into these problems again in the future it's gonna be real time you know online QuickBooks type of thing where accounts are regularly updated seen in real time so that we're not blindsided by these financial shortfalls in the future thank
[2:19:46] Speaker H (unidentified): you thank you thank you here I'm
[2:20:00] Speaker A (unidentified): item F on our agenda citizens form and the citizen form is open to any member of the audience for comments on any town matter all comments should be respectful in tone it should be directed to the chair comments should be brief and to the point traditionally three minutes please and members of the public shall refrain from making personal charges or disparaging remarks or form verbal attacks upon the character or motives of members of town boards committees or commissions or town staff or other citizens of york questions that require extended answers or cannot be readily answered at our meeting this evening will be referred to the town manager for follow-up the board will also receive input received by the select boards page on the town website which there are several the manager will cover those and anyone who wishes to submit written requests for future agenda items could do so on the form that's available at this meeting or may obtain said form through the town manager's office so how many people in the audience are here for citizens forum show of hands please so we have about six so we probably have about 10 in reality, just by the way it works. So I guess we'll start on this side, so the front, and I'll just work to the back of the room, and I apologize for parking. Yes, sir. So could you go to the podium, please?
[2:21:40] Speaker G (unidentified): So what would you, would I what? Could you read that to him, what's on this shirt?
[2:21:52] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, you can read what's on the shirt. He just, he's the manager. If you could go to the podium, please.
[2:21:57] Speaker G (unidentified): All right, well, okay, thank you.
[2:22:03] Speaker F (unidentified): No drinking out of it, Peter. I said that. Okay. All
[2:22:47] Speaker G (unidentified): right, James Ketsis, 280 York Street. Well, I'll read what's on the shirt first. On the front of the shirt, save the honey locust. It means more than just another tree. On the back of the shirt, honey locust symbolized protection, strength, endurance, beauty, tolerance and our village requiem for our Christmas tree it wasn't a storm that brought it down a tempest of such terrible force no it was the leaders of the town who felled the tree with only feigned remorse just another sacrifice to progress as the village is to be improved the old traffic pattern altered The soldier's statue moved. It's long needed to be done. Don't you all agree? But that was coldest comfort to all of us who love the tree. A few weeks ago, somebody who had learned of my personal mission to save the honey locust tree in the village center said to me, James, you're York's Lorax. Then last Friday afternoon, as I sat on the bench at the monument site, a book was handed to me. The Lorax by Dr. Seuss. The full meaning of what had been said earlier suddenly made full sense as I opened the book and came to the page with the lines of verse which read, I'm the Lorax who speaks for the trees. It seems a noble calling, but I'm at present only qualified to aspire to the title. I really would also like to be thought of as the Lorax who speaks for the environment, the town's historical heritage, and just about everything that residents here value and fear might be lost if no individual comes to the fence if york is an urgent need for a lorax i'm ready for the task and my first responsibility is to speak on the behalf of a doomed tree i'll do my best and apologize in advance for my failings with my newly acquired powers i can not only speak for the trees but i can also hear them as they speak as well the honey locust is my personal friend A friendship that was formed in the winter of 2018 and 2019 when I stood to protest the move of the archives. Afternoon and afternoon for 100 days, I stood there and only the tree stood with me and braved the elements. I'd returned to the very same place in April 2025 for yet another protest against the current regime in Washington. Once again, the tree was my partner, and I felt strong because of the strength it offered and the shielding protection from the summer sun or the drenching rain. For me personally, the tree is friendly and wise, and over the times it has been just the two of us out there, I have learned some remarkable aspects of a life spent right in the middle of town. I was here during the great fire in the winter of 1959, when buildings burned so close to where I was, and I could even feel the heat it was so that near. But I got through that, And the storms that were so strong, I feared at times I'd be uprooted, broke my branches, swept away my leaves. What about Christmas each year, with all the different colored lights woven around me? How the tree crew worked to get it done. The parade went by, so noisy, and with the large crowds, I really enjoyed that. How many vehicles have gone by in my years here? So many different styles of vehicles, and the rapid passages of the fire trucks and in the loud racket. I've seen lives come and go, heard conversations only feet away. Everything has happened here, just where I stand. Sadly, it's all about to end for my friend, the honey locust tree, a majestic tree that soars above the street, so striking in autumn foliage. To refer to the tree disparagingly as an invasive species, as I've indeed heard, was not only insulting to my friend, but to the tree's hundreds of friends, who care so deeply for its fate, that they have put their signatures to paper. Just as I now have this extraordinary ability to hear what the tree says, so can I also hear what the people say, who care deeply for the tree. And I sense their anger over a callous, entirely senseless act that reveals to us that the government of our town is lacking in compassion, sensitivity, and worst of all, concern for the environment, and that is why unscrupulous developers are allowed to rule here. My hope is that the legacy of the tree will be rigorous enforcement of environmental protections and that developers will cringe and sweat when the very word York is mentioned because their greed driven cynical manipulative practices will no longer be permitted and the town's full heritage will be protected. Only then can I honestly assume the title of Lorax. In death, if I have my way, the tree will be even more powerful than it was in life because it will be remembered not only for what it gave to this town but ultimately what it will give to this town so one more time with feeling it was not a storm that brought it down a tempest of such terrible force no it was the leaders of the town who fell the tree with only famed remorse just another sacrifice to progress the village is to be improved moved. The old traffic pattern altered. The soldier's statue moved. It's long needed to be done. Don't you all agree? But that was cold as comfort to all of us who love the tree. Now, I am hoping there will be a modification that will allow it to survive. Of course, that's what I hope for. But if it is killed, I will be out there, and I will gather every signature who holds that of persons who hold that act in contempt and I will not rest until there are hundreds and hundreds of names on that signature no matter how bad the weather is no matter how cold the weather is I will be out there to collect those signatures and they will be certified and they would be part of the public record of this town thank you
[2:29:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Next, on this side. Yes, sir.
[2:29:35] Speaker R (unidentified): Hi, I'm Ben Marong. I live at [address] 1. I don't recall 2013 when the Town Beautification Act was voted on. i believe that if i had seen that it was going to involve the moving of the soldier and the cutting down of the tree i would have raised an objection at that point at this point it may be too late to raise an objection but it is sad to see it have to go but i'd like to talk about the ambulance corps i have had occasion to have them visit me at home and i would like to know that there will be an ambulance for me if i need him again I was very impressed with their service I don't have a contact with him very often but living on route one I see him go by every day night day rain snow they're out there saving lives and I think it's worth I think it's worth 500 000 to be sure that they're able to we're able to maintain their service i'd hate to see them go down the tubes and we'd have to hire some for-profit corporation who would come in and we wouldn't know whether the service is going to be any good we wouldn't know what the cost of the town would be it just should be easier to get them through this situation main maintain monitoring of their situation going forward. And I'd say, let's put them in the budget for next year for a million dollars, like some of the other towns around here do with their ambulance corps, to make sure they're gonna be around to take care of me and you, thank you.
[2:32:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Someone else on this side, is there? sir
[2:32:29] Speaker S (unidentified): joe holm 376 shore road cape netic and thanks for the opportunity to talk about permit parking my wife and i went to get our permits again this year and we were shocked to find out it hadn't the price hadn't decreased it hadn't held steady it didn't go up by the rate of inflation or 10 it didn't double it didn't triple it quadrupled it went from 20 for a senior rate to eighty dollars to put that in perspective i know everyone's happy about gas prices imagine instead of 450 a gallon 18 a gallon it went up two reasons one is we although we are full-time taxpayers we are part-year residents so even though we don't use all the trash services the schools everything else we still pay the full rate you're welcome second is we found out for some reason a non full-time resident it doesn't matter if you're a senior I've never heard of that I suppose next the handicapped parking pass will be restricted so what becomes of quadrupling so here's our reaction in past years we bought three passes we never used more than one car at once and rarely used it honestly so we paid for three this year we bought none so instead of getting 240 out of but she got zero there are other implications to this places that we went to for dinner when we could just park stone's throw we probably went once a week this year zero shore road delhi zero it impacted businesses and i'm going to let them know that second and more profoundly you actually change the way we think about york we 've been coming here for 40 years we've been part year residents for 10. you change the way we think about york because you change the way you think about us and they just don't get it listen we all make mistakes oh and by the way like now it's coming up on giving tuesday so now i got to think well you know the fire department the ambulance the land trust maybe we don't matter as much as we thought we all make mistakes this was a mistake so we hope you'll reconsider it and just put in something reasonable thank you
[2:35:20] Speaker A (unidentified): on this side anyone else no more hands on this website yes sir
[2:35:37] Speaker M (unidentified): andrew king 12 avon ave i'm here to speak about the tree i've been a arborist a working arborist for 28 years i'm certified isa certified arborist i'm track or tree risk assessment qualified the one thing i would like to say is there should never be a healthy mature street tree cut down we all here remember the ice storm in 98 the ice storm of 08 the christmas 2 22 2022 where i was without power for up to a week the micro bursts and 10 and 14 all these took down trees along our roadways in our public spaces these cutting trees down for human reasons or for infrastructure reasons is abysmal infrastructure engineers like to build things growing things and building things are totally different and i think saving trees should be our priority along the lines of these storm incidents we have Asian longhorn beetle ravaging trees in town right now you've grown up with Dutch elm disease with spongy moth or it's called spongy moth now you know it as gypsy moth chestnut blight all these things have ruined our forests over time there are things coming along the lines that are gonna take out more trees so at the very least I know it's a done deal but in the future, consider saving trees as opposed to cutting them down. Anyone else this side?
[2:37:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Try to keep it to three minutes, please. Might be difficult. I'm going to try to keep it out. I'm going to try to.
[2:37:58] Speaker T (unidentified): My name's Mike Lee, 16 Dock Road. I've been an arborist for 54 years. Second generation, everybody in my family was an arborist. Now I have my children working as arborists. have a degree in agriculture and urban forestry and i've been licensed and certified for over 40 years i've been consulting for this town under community service never being paid never being asked to be paid and i've worked for the town the highway department i do the hazard tree evaluation every year for the school department free of charge and working for parks and rec so the tree one of my biggest problems was is that the public did not know that tree was being removed and we can see those drawings those are conceptual drawings what we never saw was an actual concept drawing of the square that shows the tree missing now we have lots of discussions about the memorial and so my question was why wasn't it ever disclosed by the committee that the tree was coming down so I researched the six years of the meetings there were 72 committee meeting went through every single one of them there was never a single mention of the tree being removed my question is why now obviously we're past the 11th hour we're past midnight so I've talked to a few of the committee members and no one recalls a discussion about the tree being removed so there was a negative aspect that the committee did not want the town to know and obviously that is a problem we had a committee member refer to the tree as being invasive we've heard this time and time again if the tree was termed to be invasive and it's not it's just not native and then again it never must have been discussed in the committee meetings the landscape architecture stew dawson who was a friend of mine certainly knows his plant material and that would have been relayed in the meetings and one of my other problems with this whole thing is there is no formal landscape plan for this plant this project there's not you have conceptual drawings, but you have no landscape plan. Mr. Joseph mentioned that we're going to replant mature trees. No, we're not. The best thing you're going to do is put a two-and-a-half-inch tree in a hole that's not a mature tree. And as I've stated before, we'll never see a mature tree downtown again. Just not going to happen. We don't have enough lifespan for that to happen. it so i've got to tell you every construction plan that this town has been on i have had to intervene post destruction so it was the middle school was the first one and they cut the roots of the beach trees and they're still suffering they have survived done amazing remedial tasks on trying to save those trees. The town hall, the contractor excavated the roots of the Crimson King in between the town hall and the church. And again, I am still working on that tree. The high school athletic field, this one's a great one. They protected the rock for the memorial for Hannah. And the tree was planted as a memorial. And the contractor cut the roots, parked their equipment on top of it, and put their cement mixer there, dumping calcium all over the roots. And I have spent the entire summer trying to keep that tree healthy. So that brings us to this right here, right now. I'll share these with you. you. Today, on my way through town, I observed that the contractor has excavated the roots of all the trees in front of the town hall. This is a major buttress root off the red maple tree. I honestly do not believe there's any remediation for this. The oak tree that's by the corner is probably a goner and the ash tree that is there in front of the town is probably a goner so you're probably going to lose the three trees that are directly in front of the town hall due to negligence now we're supposed to have an engineer that's supposed to be looking out over this job engineers are supposed to be educated on construction work and excavating the root system of a tree is counterproductive to anything that's going on So what does this have to do with the tree in the center of town? Not much. Because I'm pretty sure you've already decided that the tree has to go. We can't stop the contract. We can't redesign the intersection. We're not going to move the tree. I have a couple questions. The plan was 13 years in the making. It's been 10 years since the vote. There was flawed data using to determine if the intersection was a dangerous intersection. I looked that up. I researched that. I also called the York Police Department and got the most recent data for the last 10 years. There were 15 accidents in the center of town in 10 years. years none of them with bodily harm all of them were fender benders most of them were five of them were rear-ended two of them were side swiped one of them was a backup mr lee i've given you liberty we're in about we're getting to it we're getting really close here another part that really bothers me is when we talked about those conceptual drawings there were three options there was actually a fourth option and the fourth option was the no option but the committee decided that was not something they were going to present to the town they pushed the three options and the only option that removed the tree is the one that we have so we're short on funds so on may the 17th you as a board decided to transfer money from phase two of this project and the d.o.t said that They said they would give you the money and any money left over would be taken from that and put onto other DOT projects. In other words, it left the town of York. That is a change in the scope of the project. And this is what we get to the heart. MMA, Maine Mutual Association, says the board of selectmen cannot change or overturn the substance of a project that is legally voted for and approved by the town the other thing it says after the wording after the fact they cannot change the specific intent scope laid out and approved in the warrant article so that make that vote on may 17th is exactly what you did and i got stonewalled and bs'd by several town employees when i asked that the job the scope of the job has been changed there is no phase two there is no money for phase two there is no phase two anymore the town the voters voted on a complete project and you have cut the project in half so i don't know what your answer is to that but that's what i have to say thank you so we
[2:47:40] Speaker A (unidentified): try to be respectful no clapping please i mean this is a public meeting who else has raised their hand on this side no anyone on this side no one so you want to read the i
[2:47:59] Speaker I (unidentified): want to get some coffee donna bacon from york writes in dear select board would you be able to tell me where i could read or listen to your discussion on question four on the upcoming ballot i see that the preference of the board is no so i'd like to know the reasoning behind that before i vote thank you for your time donna bacon danielle demers from york writes and i'm writing to request revisit the vote on the town revitalization project the project was re approved by voters 10 years ago and with work now be just now beginning citizens deserve the opportunity to revisit the vote before this project moves forward in 10 years since the project was initially approved costs have risen significantly and business needs in town have changed the cox building home to several businesses will lose vital parking spots they rely on additionally the destruction of the 60 plus year old mature honey locust tree a familiar icon at the center of the village will be a huge loss for the town the town's history and charm is part of what makes york such a wonderful town to live in and to visit it cutting down a mature tree is a loss that cannot be rectified dear members of the york select board i am writing to respectfully ask the town to continue this is laurie putney wrote in dear members of the york select board it's an email but it was asked to be entered into the record so i'm writing to respectfully ask the town of york to consider an alternative traffic plan that could improve traffic flow and pedestrian safety in the york village while preserving the magnificent centuries-old tree and the monument that have long been part of our town's character and history i understand that traffic safety is important and that changes may be necessary to address the concerns at this intersection i fully support finding a safe and effective solution however i believe it is worth exploring whether there is another way to accomplish these goals without permanently removing such a significant part of york's heritage i would like to suggest the town consider a roundabout or rotary designed around the existing tree and monument is a possible alternative to the current plan i recognize that i am not a traffic engineer and do not have technical expertise or financial resources to develop engineered plans my suggestion is simply an idea that i hope the town will be willing to explore i believe a preliminary engineering feasibility study could determine whether a carefully designed roundabout might improve traffic circulation and safety while allowing the tree and monument to remain in place before an irreplaceable centuries-old tree is removed moved I respectfully request that the town arrange for a qualified traffic engineer to evaluate the feasibility of a roundabout that preserves the existing tree and monument this is a bullet list number two compare the potential safety traffic flow pedestrian access environmental and financial implications of this alternative with the current proposal number bullet three share the findings with the public allow residents an opportunity to understand and comment on alternatives before irreversible work proceeds mature tree of this age cannot simply be replaced even if a new tree were planted it would take generations to provide the same presence beauty and sense of history the monument and surrounding landscape are also part of what makes york village special i'm not asking the town to abandon its responsibility to improve safety i am asking that we make every reasonable effort to find a solution that accomplishes that goal while preserving the historic features that make our community unique sometimes an alternative worth exploring begins with nothing more than a question can we make this intersection safer without sacrificing something we can never get back i hope the select board will give this suggestion serious consideration and support an independent feasibility review before the current plan moves forward to the point where the tree and monument cannot be saved thank you for your time service to the community and consideration of this request respectfully concerned york resident joanne muck and hoop of york writes in hello around 2017 york citizens along with ylt saved the highland farm preserve from development we started to preserve the highland farm and with everyone's efforts it worked i love york and love living here we may not be perfect but we are pretty great especially when we come together a few weeks ago mike lee posted about the select board asking the select board to save the amazing tree in the village i don't know mike beyond what i've seen him do for our little town his posts have spoke a lot of dialogue both online and off i usually don't participate on social media pages but I did with this issue please let's save the tree and what it represents to so many of our neighbors there's no doubt that forward change can happen without killing such an iconic historic tree I appreciate your consideration Julie Edminster from York writes in dear select board I'm writing because the new trash bins don't just work for a town like ours they're heavy and awkward and a lot of us live on long dirt roads and driveways plenty of people are older and can't manage them easily for years we've put our cans in the truck and driven to the end of our road these new ones make that a lot harder every week our neighbor at 76 barely has any trash she used a small can she could handle on her own now she has this large bin she has to wheel out in the winter when there's ice something might work something that might work fine in newer subdivision down south isn't practical here in maine we also had bulk trash pickup for years could you bring that back even if it's once a month i hope you'll reconsider this and pull the new bins back they create real problems for lots of residents. Julie Edminster. Julie Edminster from York writes in, Dear Select Board, I'm writing a follow-up on my previous email regarding the new trash bins. Since then, I spoke with a staff member in the town manager's office who explained that beginning in November, residents will be able to exchange their larger bins for a smaller one. When I asked whether our household could have two smaller bins instead, I was told firmly that each residence is limited to one. I explained that a single small bin would not be enough for our family. The suggestion I received was to hitch larger trash and recycling bins to the back of our truck and tow them down the road i appreciate the staff for working with the new rules they've been given but i hope you'll agree this is not a practical solution towing bins down a driveway is awkward on a good day and in maine winter with snow ice and plow banks it is simply unworkable is also not an option for residents who don't own truck or for older residents and others with limited mobility the goal of the new program is a good one but a one-size-fits-all approach doesn't fit households of different sizes and circumstances respectfully ask the select board revisit the arrangement at a minimum allow households to purchase additional small trash bins and recycling bins when needed and offer monthly bulk pickup for items that overflow that don't fit in standard bins these changes would help the programs keep the benefits of the program intact while making it workable for families like ours i would welcome the chance to discuss this further happy to attend an upcoming meeting if that would be helpful thank you for your time and your service to our community sincerely julie edminster chuck robinson from cape netic writes in could someone please explain how this new trash removal contract was decided in my opinion the contract only benefits casella as things stand now this is unsustainable there's no way one barrel trash enough for families over four people and summer residents another example of higher taxes and fewer services also poor communication by the town most people weren't aware of this change until the implementation stage seems like by design chuck robinson holly dumont i'm not here to be negative or bash anyone's opinions i truly feel very strongly about not changing the village i grew up in this town and i was planning on living in this town for the rest of my life i have generations of family who have been born raised and still living in this town our town is changing and it's not for the good i am absolutely so disappointed the town would agree to move the tree and monument that has been there for generations i personally have never had an issue with a traffic pattern in the village i think the town should focus more on the section of route one near anthony's is where near where anthony is where there is repeated accidents happening this historical town should stay should stay a quaint oh a quaint sorry historical town and not turn into the city of boston is there a way we can have a revote on this the vote from years ago should be revisited is this possible most of my life this town has been close and family oriented we cared about the history of the town we cared about our family and generations of all the families that live here i feel like people are trying to change the town and there's no need for it i'm tired of everybody just coming in and trying to spend those are just my thoughts and also wondering if we can have a revoke a revote i think for change in the village years ago this town would never agree to move such an amazing generational tree and now you're just willing to move it just like that there's nothing wrong with the setup of the triangle and the village it's the people that are not paying attention the town is punishing a tree for stupidity of people not paying attention while driving paul palumbo of york writes in i'm writing as a york resident concerned about how maine's new statewide housing and zoning mandates will function in a town that does not regulate short-term rentals these state reforms were created to expand long-term housing options yet york currently has no registration licensing or tracking system for strs in the single family or multi-family homes as a result the town does not know how many strs exist where they operate or how they affect housing availability with the state now requiring towns to allow additional dwelling unit triplexes four plexes in increased density in zones that previously permitted only single family homes the absence of str oversight creates a real risk these new units could be diverted into str use instead of serving year-round residents if that happens the state's affordability reforms will not achieve their intended purpose in new york instead we may see more strs in residential neighborhoods fewer long-term rental options for workers families and seniors higher housing costs and reduced availability increased pressure on parking safety services and neighborhood stability given this i respectfully asked the board how does the town plan to ensure these new state mandate state mandated units actually contribute to the long-term housing and are not absorbed into unregulated str activity york needs a basic str framework so the town can understand where strs are operating set reasonable standards and protect the long-term housing supply these state reforms are meant to strengthen thank you for your attention and your service to the community nancy martin from york writes in to the select board and town manager i do hope you do not stop the village revitalization project this project is long overdue if the state had not delayed it for so long it most likely would be done by now the revitalization committee volunteers and professionals had spent countless hours working on this project to get it to what the town residents wanted and a majority voted for there is absolutely no reason to stop or delay the project the save the tree people have had years to figure out what they should do with the tree the project was there for anyone to see and read it was not hidden they could have done something years ago to wait to the last minute and say they did not know is disingenuous i believe i know i knew the tree and other plantings would be removed it's just common sense if the most important structure on the monument island the statue is being moved back for sight and safety issues did they not think that a tree that was next to it just as tall and wider than the statue would not be removed for the same safety reasons to try and stop or delay the project now when it has already started and to supersede a legal vote that was passed by a majority of town residents is outrageous i'm sure once the new monument area is ready the organization or people that took care of the old section will make the new section look just as nice or even better thank you for considering my opinion in martin york jordan cohen location not given rights to the members of the york select board and town leadership i'm writing to urge reconsideration of the planned removal of the beloved honey locust tree in york village while i support improving traffic safety and pedestrian accessibility cutting down this iconic tree will irreparably damage the historic character of our town center crucially the original york village revitalization plan was completed about 10 years ago just as building permits expire and require formal resubmittal to ensure they align with updated codes a decade-old municipal plan should not be executed blindly a plan conceived a decade ago cannot accurately affect our community's current needs environmental priorities and contemporary desires oh sorry it's two pages moving forward with irreversible actions based on outdated data is a disservice to york's future furthermore enforcing a decision from so long ago disenfranchises a significant portion of our current population in the last 10 years york has welcomed many new families who choose this town specifically for its historic charm these fairly new residents have heavily invested in our community yet they never had the opportunity to vote or have their voices heard on a project that permanently alters their new home a community as it stands today the honey locust tree standing proudly next to the soldiers monument is a vital visual and emotional anchor whether it is adorned with holiday lights or offering summer shade it signals that you have arrived in the heart of York removing it means most current residents will not see a tree of its stature here again I respectfully ask the select board to pause the schedule removal treat this decade-old master plan as a data document and explore creative design modifications that preserve our living heritage sincerely a concerned resident of york main mike lee i'll i'll read mike's quickly from york writes can the tree at the monument not be removed 10 years have passed and traffic flow has drastically changed because of the new beach access contract costs have dramatically increased the budget vote was very close and citizens are being asked to pay additional costs without any reconsideration the traffic pattern can be altered to accommodate the tree the center of town will greatly be greatly enhanced by keeping the tree it will take decades for a tree to grow to maturity, Long Sands Road can be redesigned and pushed towards the Old Bank of America to accommodate the tree remains. Over 200 people have responded in support of keeping the tree over the weekend, and probably there are a huge number of additional citizens supporting it to stay. What is the construction timeline for the project, and when is the tree scheduled for removal? Would a stay or stop order allow time to reconsider the revitalization plan and give time for a petition to be brought forward and a reconsideration vote to preserve the tree? [Speaker T (unidentified): Eric Goldberg from] From Cape Nettick writes, good evening. The comment concerns the removal of the honey locust tree from the center of the village in preparation for the revitalization project. My desire to pause the project should not be seen as diminishing the hard work and passion of those on the revitalization committee who believe the village traffic pattern needs to change. Whether I agree with the overall project is separate from my concern about removing a healthy tree that has meant so much to our community for more than 30 years. This tree has been a symbol of our town center and a major part of Christmas season and festival lights. We have watched it change with the seasons go grow sorry throughout its life to remove it without first exploring whether it can be saved or transplanted seems incredibly disrespectful to give us some time to explore alternatives i've submitted an application for the state of maine forest service for consideration is one of maine's big trees jan santer the project coordinator is hoping to measure tomorrow for the application whether it qualifies or not i hope the effort will encourage us to pause and consider whether this important community landmark can be preserved i would also respectfully request a new traffic study before the project begins it has been approximately 10 years since the last study and there have been significant changes in town including the new short sands road connection from route 1 to the beach i respectfully ask the select board to consider both preserving the tree and conducting an updated traffic study before moving forward thank you for considering my comments respectfully eric s goldberg david chase of york main writes in two members of the select board i am contacting you in reference TO TONIGHT'S SELECT BOARD MEETING AGENDA ITEM J1 CITIZEN PETITION SAVE THE TREE ORDINANCE THE PROPOSAL IS NEITHER FACTUALLY CORRECT NOR TIMELY IT IS ASSERTED BY THE PETITIONERS THAT REMOVAL OF THE HONEY LOCUS TREE ADJACENT TO YORK CIVIL WAR MEMORIAL REPRESENTS A FAILING OF COMMUNICATION AND COORDINATION FALSE REMOVING THE TREE IS PART A NECESSARY PART OF THE YORK VILLAGE MASTER PLAN APPROVED BY YORK VOTERS MORE THAN A DECADE AGO BEFORE GOING TO THE VOTERS THE PLAN was vetted extensively through stakeholder meetings and public design workshops held in 2014 and 2015. the site plans including removal of the honey locust were on view and open comment well before the vote they have remained on town on the town website it's only because of the state dot it's only because the state dot has dragged commencement of the project out for so long that the petitioners have forgotten the project results from a very public review process furthermore the petition before you is not timely because at long last the project is underway let it continue without delay. David Chase, Janine Vieten of York, writes in, as a single senior citizen, 65, lives on a private road. The new trash policy is going to be a real problem for me. I have at least one-eighth to one-quarter of a mile to get my trash to the main road, Chase's Pond Road. For 26 years I've lived here, I bag it, usually one bag, in my blue recycle bin and drive it to the road at 6.55 a.m. on trash day. No problem. It works. Now I have to get two giant bins to the main road. road they will not fit in my car i've had two discussions with the town manager and also filed an issue with public works casella reviewed my road and refused any leniency because there are low wires and drainage ditches on both sides of my street the solution offered was for me to purchase some sort of harness to drag my cans behind my car really for the record there are four homes on my private way three of which are seniors we don't generate that much trash why are they making this so difficult for us i really feel the contract needs to be revisited for those of us who fall out of the majority that the system will work okay for what about us what about those who can't handle the bins i live in york because it is a premier town in maine i love my home the town and living here but this new policy could break me i feel i've exhausted the regular channels and i appeal to the select board as the ultimate authority in this town please help respectfully submitted gene beaton arnold lane there's only 30 minutes that's not bad any do we have any new ones yeah
[3:05:39] Speaker A (unidentified): there were two that six 646 647 same person i think they will repeat it's like two or three paragraphs okay
[3:05:54] Speaker I (unidentified): oh joanne muck and hope again hello since i cannot attend the meeting on 1026 i wanted to share my thoughts please let this be something that brings us together let the citizens be heard there is this is an amazing opportunity to build a little faith in the impossible saving this tree would have a lasting impact in all the best ways this is exactly what we all need right now thank you i
[3:06:17] Speaker A (unidentified): think the second one's very similar to that one there's a few words that were different but the same it's
[3:06:23] Speaker I (unidentified): the same yeah i
Unfinished Business
[3:06:27] Speaker A (unidentified): read the longer one yep okay so we'll close citizens forum now it's 10 o'clock on my well not quite three minutes i'll call that so around item G public hearings are a non item H endorsements item I old business the first is Steadman woods conservation easement release of deed restrictions yeah
[3:06:51] Speaker F (unidentified): so I guess I would ask that we not vote on this evening I mean there are some issues regarding the de minimis commercial activities and so I would like to just have that be clear before we vote on it. So I would just like to table until our next meeting.
[3:07:20] Speaker H (unidentified): I agree. You know, at this late hour, I had some questions on it, too. And instead of rushing through something that we've been waiting for a long while, I feel bad some of the parties have sat here. but that's the public process I guess in a small community to be able to speak so agreed I would like to so table it so we'll move it to the first meeting
[3:07:47] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah I certainly am supportive of that because it sounds like there needs to be further discussions it's been a couple years there's been multiple iterations there have been multiple parties involved there's been there's been there's been lots of discussions among all the parties and this is the document that was agreed to but there obviously there are members here who have concerns so I appreciate and support that but I would also put forward the option if anyone is interested in considering it that we could approve this with a clause that any non-material amendments as agreed to between the land trust old york and the town be permitted as part of our approval in other words but i certainly understand if that's not something that folks want to entertain but I wanted to throw it out as an option because after a couple of years, here we are. And, but if we need more time and we need one more turn of the document, that's fine as well. I just wanted to throw out an option if there was an interest.
[3:09:03] Speaker A (unidentified): So I guess I'm not hearing one. It doesn't sound like it. So November 6th would be agenda item on our November 6th meeting, which would be our first meeting in November. So it's not the 6th or 9th. I wrote down the 9th and I said the 6th. Yeah.
[3:09:17] Speaker C (unidentified): nine so november 9th so what do you perceive the process to be is it you that has concerns are there i mean who's going to drive what's what do you what's going to happen over the next couple weeks and who's going to drive that in your estimation to this is
[3:09:37] Speaker F (unidentified): reaching out to another party to ask questions good so i think i think there is a process going forward, I just don't feel comfortable being more specific than that. Okay.
[3:09:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Okay, we good on that one? So November 9th, meeting on November 9th will be on that agenda item. Redemption 285 US Route 1, property redemption?
[3:10:09] Speaker I (unidentified): Yep. So this is a proposed property redemption for 285 US Route 1. the adjacent it's 291 and 285 years through one there is an adjacent piece of property that was already redeemed to the previous owner so the taxes have been paid there are costs related to a heating system replacement that happened when it was in the town's possession and the taxes have already been back taxes have already been paid so there is no there should be no subject interest to be paid unless until new taxes are accrued.
[3:10:59] Speaker H (unidentified): Do you want to read this? Yes, sir.
[3:11:01] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. I move to approve the property redemption of tax map 0059 lot 0018A located at 291 US Route 1 and tax map 0059 lot 0018 ROUTE 1 AS REQUESTED SUBJECT TO ALL CONDITIONS BEING MET AND ALL TAXES, FEES, INTEREST AND ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS PAID IN FULL BY NO LATER THAN DECEMBER 26, 2026 WITH CASH OR CERTIFIED
[3:11:36] Speaker A (unidentified): BANK CHECK. DO WE HAVE A SECOND? SECOND. SECONDED BY MARILYN. SECONDED BY MARILYN. ANY DISCUSSION ON THE MOTION? I HAVE A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS.
[3:11:46] Speaker H (unidentified): SO THIS ORIGINAL BANK CHECK Redemption from Catherine Lagasse to the board was dated February 5th for the for the typical taxes and fees when did we receive the check from the former owner way back then or just recently for these that I was paid in full it was in between okay and we did we not issue a quick claim deed back to the former owner already or is that still in our
[3:12:23] Speaker I (unidentified): hands we did not issue a quick claim deed to the previous owner okay thank
[3:12:29] Speaker A (unidentified): you yes motion carries 5-0 so when our bylaws operation operational bylaws after 10 o'clock we need to have majority vote to move forward. So we'll be good to go. I mean, I think we can maybe get through to 1030. Okay. So we'll go on to item J1, citizen's petition entitled save the tree ordinance.
[3:13:08] Speaker I (unidentified): Somebody asked me to make a copy of the charter section pertaining to citizen petitions. So that section 22 that's in the first page in front of you, it's double-sided but it's really a and b so the town received a petition last week hold on one second let's get in front of me on thursday certified by the town clerk to contain 124 certified signatures the child charter in front of you requires 100 signatures is for a question to go on the ballot the procedure by the select board is to set a public hearing get public input on it and then the Charter specifies to call a special general referendum after that point after that public hearing so it's not a question of if you put on the ballot or not you are required to move it forward to a ballot once we receive the petition the question is when and is there significant input at a public hearing?
[3:14:15] Speaker A (unidentified): So really, to set the public hearing, what's that date?
[3:14:21] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I have a point that I can recall this occurring during my tenure as the town clerk, that section A, the sentence reads, voters of the town may at any time propose the enactment of any lawful ordinance by filing with the town clerk, blah,, blah. And I can recall having historical knowledge that some petitions were not accepted by that current board because they weren't lawfully worded as to what an ordinance should be. And I question what was submitted to us, whether it's lawfully worded. You know, I have some other comments to the speakers here about the situation, but I'm specifically now talking about what the charter states we should do and if it's lawful or not.
[3:15:23] Speaker A (unidentified): So I. Yeah, absolutely.
[3:15:28] Speaker I (unidentified): I did forward this last week, Thursday, to the town attorney, talked to her again today and asked her to provide a written opinion to the board. prior to your meeting at the latest of next week so she's working on that she said she took a brief look at it but doesn't have an opinion letter to us yet on review or anything like that so i asked i told her we're likely to have a public hearing on it so if she could provide that before your next meeting and she agreed that she could do that but realistically the tree could
[3:16:03] Speaker H (unidentified): could be removed before her legal opinion and the public hearing and the vote i mean we could be voting on something that's a moot point is that correct i want to be clear for everybody
[3:16:15] Speaker I (unidentified): this is something that was just so the petitioners i think are aware of the timing constraints i know it's not an exact date of when that's going to happen but it's in the range that 's likely or a possibility.
[3:16:29] Speaker H (unidentified): But at least she'll tell us whether this is lawful or not for us to even accept it. I mean, I think at this point in time, we need to put a pause on the acceptance based on her opinion.
[3:16:49] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe we have certain rules by which we need to put ordinance in place and those involve multiple steps timely manner in which or changes are being made oversight by our lawyers making sure the ordinance is as it should be and I think as a board that we should do our due diligence in making sure we are following all the steps that's needed and move forward in as timely a manner
[3:17:19] Speaker A (unidentified): as we possibly can so you see that involved having the lawyer look at kind of look at this before we take any action yeah
[3:17:27] Speaker C (unidentified): I agree first of all I'm not clear whether it's a petition for enactment of ordinances or whether it's a petition for ordinance reconsideration and overrule of action or inaction by the select board and I really look forward to our town attorneys interpretation about that and whether it's lawful and the Charter does not require us to take to schedule a public hearing within a certain time frame and think it's important that we clarify those issues given the way this is written before we
[3:18:00] Speaker I (unidentified): schedule a public hearing so that doesn't change anything in terms of getting a legal opinion by your next meeting having on the agenda for discussion of mary's opinion then would that
[3:18:11] Speaker A (unidentified): be the proposed course by the board i think i'm here for the board that they want to have our town council give advice and consent what is this legal is this a legal format either in state statute or town charter before this board takes action
[3:18:31] Speaker C (unidentified): including setting a public hearing right yeah so until we hear from just like we tabled the last an action recently yeah on seven woods we table this until we hear back from our town attorney and have an opportunity to evaluate her feedback is how i see it agreement
[3:18:52] Speaker F (unidentified): yeah i'm not opposed i guess we should i think it would be great if mary could weigh in by our next meeting so that we did have that information by then so we're not putting it off
[3:19:05] Speaker A (unidentified): you know too much into the future so if peter 's reached out to her she comes back next week has something you know leadership meets on wednesdays sets the agenda if it's all set up we'll communicate individually that we have this and then we'll have our public discussion as a board at possibly the november 9th meeting i'm just trying to set the yeah set the course here yeah
[3:19:27] Speaker C (unidentified): hopefully the request for action for the november 9 meeting can include
[3:19:32] Speaker A (unidentified): her input her legal review opinion we're
[3:19:39] Speaker F (unidentified): good on that one so can we can we have now have a little bit i know it's really late but i thought perhaps we were going to have some conversation about the feedback we received and yeah and i know you spoke to that yeah i'd like i'd like to
[3:19:55] Speaker H (unidentified): speak to the speakers and thank all for everybody who has chimed in over the past month six weeks I want everyone to know and I probably can speak for my board members but we care I do care I care about this community I care about your opinions I've been in public service my whole adult career I care but having said that, sometimes we're in a position that what some people might want, we can't provide. Progress is often sought, but change is resisted. I wasn't a fan of the original plan, I'll tell you that, but there was a vote. and we need to we live in a democracy where we need to uphold the voters and that's what I sitting here on this board have done and I know I ordered or I voted to have a contract signed and I feel like I do need to follow those contractual obligations I respect mr. Kensis and I respect mr. Lee I've worked professionally with mr. Kensis at Town Hall and mr. Lee came to my house for an emotional tree that I wanted saved so I so I get that and my red maple is still there so i won't belabor it 's late i am empathetic but i feel like i have a duty as a select person here to uphold the law yeah
[3:22:02] Speaker F (unidentified): so i agree with the sentiments of my colleague back in the day when this first all came up there was significant citizen input there was lots of meetings and hundreds of people who participated and the design was approved by voters and we now have a signed contract with a company and we just can't go back this is a state road and they sort of control a lot of what can be done but i get i guess i'm a little depressed I'm depressed to hear Mike Lee talk about these issues where we're doing construction and we're not respecting trees that are sort of in the way. That's just depressing to me. It's also depressing to me that when I drive down the road, as I did recently on York Street, and see a big tree being cut down, we owe it to the next generations to be planting trees now. we some trees have to be cut down some trees probably don't have to be cut down but are anyway i 'm sympathetic but we have and this board has tried for a while to get a tree warden we have it as a as a as a position in town it's not paid but a tree warden and we have a budget for planting trees but we don't we don't do it so for me the bigger issue here is what mike lee was talking about trying to do a better job around construction that we are respectful of the trees there and then also begin planting trees for the next generation the generation after in the public spaces we have now i know they aren't full grown and they won't be full grown in my lifetime but i have children and maybe grandchildren someday and i'd like them to be able to see the trees so we need to do a better job but it needs to go forward
[3:24:16] Speaker E (unidentified): thank you james i know how passionate you are about the tree and you know one of the reasons i moved to maine was because there were so many trees. It's coming from a city where, you know, a tree grows in Brooklyn is like a really great movie. And you're looking at a tree and you're like, yes. You know, so I understand. I love where I am because we're just surrounded by so much of nature and oxygenation and better air you breathe because of trees. Perhaps moving forward, one of the things we can consider is whether or not we can have a project for tree preservation and replacement for the town. You know, just something similar to what Robert suggest in having that in place so you cut down a tree because it needs to be removed, you plant a new tree somewhere. You know, so you're evening out the balance of nature and beautification at the same time. So I think for all of the discussions we have had which have been passionate and you know emotional you know trees are needed we all are aware of that you know they make up the air we breathe they give us what we need shade everything i'm i wish i had a big tree in my yard so i could put a swing on it because i think i would i love swings and i would just sit there and read and swing you know but i don't have that so but I think, you know, I think we're all very aware of love of nature, love of trees, especially in a place like Maine. So we hear you, know, and hopefully moving forward, there are other things we can do and other trees we can plant and multiple trees along the way that, you know, beautify the place and help us to live healthier lives.
New Business
[3:26:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else so I support the, my colleagues are not going to try to try to repeat what they said. I agree with them wholeheartedly that. I supported this project right from the conception going through it when I served on the planning board. And then when I had the ability to run for this. This office and was elected by the voters of York to be a select board member. It was a question was asked that when I was running as a candidate, what was your position on. on the village revitalization projects and concepts. So yeah, I've been a supporter of the project from the beginning. Important part that since I was elected to this board, we reinstituted a budget for the tree warden that Robert talked about to plant trees because there's not only town money, there's sometimes state money and there's definitely federal money to plant trees and we need to have a tree warden to help facilitate that. Reached out to arborists that are in our community, some may have spoken tonight they're not interested you know that they said but they always told me they'd find somebody well it's been you know over 11 years and i'm still waiting so it's important position there is funds it's you know certainly volunteer but people that care about trees in our community can certainly i'm sure the manager would appoint them as a as the town tree ward and there are funds for that and i've also sworn an oath to the state of maine into the u.s constitution to hold up you know governments of both the state and nationally and there are elections and the elections are the numbers that we have to go by and make i'm looking at the ballot card eight of nine from may 21 2016. there was a item on there about york village revitalization it was the 400 000 to be appropriated and the voters supported that ballot item so that's the guiding document we heard from a lot of people that like to see the tree preserved I've heard from a lot of people offline that want the project to move forward we're not going to come down here and stand at the podium they talk to me wherever I may be in the community and sometimes I might not even be in the community but they 're in the same place I'm located talking about the support of the project and seeing the beauty that it's going to bring to the to the village once it's complete i mean change is always hard i mean i have difficulty with change i admit that but usually when i pop out the other side of that change is probably in a better place heard from some people both write-ins to our portal and on the street that you know why are you changing the village it's like just the way it is there's you know like just a couple businesses that are there i think we can certainly do better because i also hear from the other side that it basically five o'clock 5 30 it rolls up there's nothing there you know there's businesses that try to survive after hours and hopefully this is going to help facilitate some of that so that was the concepts and the thoughts of the original creation of the york village revitalization the master plan that peter had hoping to sort of bring a more vibrant not only daytime activities but evening activities in our village and maybe getting people to live there and you're starting to see some of that happening with you know second floor developments that are happening in the village so I support the project I think it's gonna be you know wonderful once it's completed with that basically two pocket parks right in our center one in the area where the monuments can be real relocated to new plantings and then kind of adjacent to in front of what was formerly known as the bank of america building that's going to get bumped out and there'll be another larger green space there as well where people can gather and maybe we can plant a lot of trees when we find a tree warden if not there's groups in town that will plant trees such as the rotary planted a bunch of trees at the bog road facility here in our town i think that was what it did close to 10 or something you know some years ago remember i participated on that project so i guess i'll just end with that you know i support the project i look forward to its completion it's gonna be hard the next year and a half to get through it but you can already start to see some of the changes even with some of them they've just started what the lighting is going to look like then the travel path so anyway that's all from me on that so we go on to the next item a new business sale of parks and recreation equipment and i'm watching the time so we're going to try to give it the time it needs but who's setting that one up is that pete or you
[3:30:52] Speaker I (unidentified): stayed now you're talking
[3:30:56] Speaker A (unidentified): so is there a motion read the motion mr
[3:31:02] Speaker C (unidentified): chair i moved to place the following parks and recreation equipment up for sale a 2010 john deere z925 a 1999 john deere 2653a and a 2000 john deere 4600.
[3:31:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Seconded by Robert any discussion on the motion questions for parks and rec director Hearing done. I'll call the road Robert. Yes, Maryland. Yes, Marla. Yes, Marianne. Yes. Here will chess much carries 5-0. Thank you very much director
[3:31:32] Speaker I (unidentified): Murray told him if he stayed there would be no questions if he left there would have been five stayed
[3:31:38] Speaker A (unidentified): J3 main Department of Urban Partnership Initiative also known as UPI grant application for Long Beach Avenue sidewalk project Dean
[3:31:44] Speaker K (unidentified): Good evening Mr. Chair, members of the board, I'll try to be very quickly. So section 5 of the seawall, as it moves forward, we'll get participation from FEMA to help us pay for that. What they don't pay for is a sidewalk, any road work, curving. This is an opportunity for us to bring in some state funds to help us with that sidewalk project. If you look at the estimate, I estimated about $700,000 and that's just for the curving and the sidewalk. I believe we can be successful with somewhere between two hundred and three hundred fifty thousand dollars from in this UPI program Which is the same grant that we just got for the long sands project. So with that I recommend Applying for the UPI For the UPI grant for the sidewalk Project along Long Beach Avenue and that's section five of the seawall If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer any questions
[3:32:42] Speaker H (unidentified): before so Dean we're doing this project regardless of whether we get grant money or not correct that's correct so there won't be any delay in the project waiting on finding out whether we get grant money in other words I don't want this to be another village revitalization based on a dangling grant
[3:33:07] Speaker K (unidentified): two very different animals here okay no funds very difficult to manage this is all state funding no federal funds very quick so we will probably have at least the notice that we're going to get the grant before we even really start work on that section five of the seawall and if you remember we start at the bottom and work our way up so it's very likely we'll that will be all done before we even get to any sidewalk construction thank you because it's
[3:33:33] Speaker H (unidentified): going to look markedly different too from four feet to eight feet wide it is if you've seen the
[3:33:37] Speaker K (unidentified): sections that we've built it's it's a game changer out there safer thank you 're welcome
[3:33:43] Speaker A (unidentified): i guess
[3:33:45] Speaker C (unidentified): i'll build on what marianne alluded to and that is not wanting to add uncertainty or jeopardize anything and so i guess my question is have you coordinated with nicole pastana our emergency management director to be absolutely certain that by bringing in an additional or a separate source of funding, how that will be perceived by FEMA in the FEMA review process? [Speaker K (unidentified): I have not.] I would really, like to see that happen. I think that's an important box that we need to check.
[3:34:24] Speaker K (unidentified): It's pretty much two different projects. The seawall is separate from the road and sidewalk. FEMA does not participate in the sidewalk or road work. So we went through a second appeal on that and we lost. So we I know that I experienced that second repeal and tried to get them to help us with the sidewalk and Road So they're two different basically it ends up being two different projects Even though when you look at it and when we build it goes together because it has to it's it's contiguous It's built on each other So but as far as funding and who's going to participate in it female not participate in the sidewalk work And I've had that discussion with Nicole numerous times
[3:35:02] Speaker I (unidentified): I MEAN WE CAN CHECK THE BOX BUT DEAN'S CORRECT THEY WENT SO FAR AS I REMEMBER ON THE OTHER SECTIONS SEPARATING THE CEMENT BY PSI GRADE BECAUSE SIDEWALK CEMENT WASN'T THE SAME 4000 PSI VERSUS 5000 AND ASKED FOR THE BILLS FROM THE CONTRACTOR AND THEY DREW A VERY HARD LINE BUT I MEAN WE CAN WE'LL TALK WITH NICOLE TO MAKE SURE I'M
[3:35:24] Speaker C (unidentified): I'M I'M FINE WITH APPLYING FOR THE GRANT BUT BEFORE WE ACCEPT IT I JUST WANT TO MAKE ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN THAT IT WOULDN'T THROW ANY KIND OF A monkey wrench or into we can have the conversation tomorrow that process thank
[3:35:37] Speaker K (unidentified): you and I'll be back in front of you to accept the grant and by that time and
[3:35:40] Speaker C (unidentified): are there any conditions associated with the grant I'm sorry are there any conditions associated with the grant I see it's on a reimbursement basis yes but other than the matching funds are there any what conditions are the big
[3:35:52] Speaker K (unidentified): one is that it'd be done within three years after the agreement is signed with
[3:35:55] Speaker C (unidentified): the town to the state and that's doable under the schedule that you have for phase five yes sir yes ma'am i know i'm a little harsh tonight
[3:36:13] Speaker E (unidentified): yes dean thank you i just want to say it's nice to see application for grants you know that cuts down on how much we have to put up for the project so thank you guys for going the distance in making sure we investigate all avenues and hopefully it doesn't have anything to do with FEMA and it's all good and clear, so thank you. You're welcome. Anyone else?
[3:36:37] Speaker F (unidentified): We have a motion. Mr. Chairman, I move to authorize the engineering director to submit a main DOT CACS MPO Urban Partnership Initiative, UPI, project grant application for the sidewalk improvement on Long Beach Avenue in conjunction with the construction of phase five of the Long Sands Beach seawall from 65 Long Beach Avenue to 155 Long Beach Avenue so motions by Robert do we have a
[3:37:04] Speaker A (unidentified): second by Maryland any additional discussion yes. Chair Vilchius, motion carries 5-0. Thank you. Thank you. Item four is kind of a tough one. So Maryland's our select board representative on the library board, and Maryland is stepping away from that position, so we need to appoint, if there's interest, from a board member to be a member of the, our board represent, sitting on the library board.
[3:37:40] Speaker H (unidentified): I would say where my peers have done some heavy lifting with the ambulance and such-and-such and probably will continue I can volunteer for it if they'll have me I move to appoint Mary Ann Janowski as the select
[3:38:04] Speaker C (unidentified): board's representative to the York live Public Library Board of Trustees we have
[3:38:09] Speaker A (unidentified): a second looks like marla second by robert any discussion in the morning
[3:38:14] Speaker H (unidentified): i'd like to thank marilyn mclaughlin for her time very good very good yes
[3:38:23] Speaker E (unidentified): carolyn thank you very much of course it's one of my favorite boards to be on by the way
[3:38:27] Speaker I (unidentified): thank you should see the raise in your next stipend check mary number five board of
[3:38:32] Speaker A (unidentified): committees there are none though we did receive a communicate over the weekend that wade fox is resigning from the Veterans Affairs Committee. We'll have that on the, this will be six years. He came by and saw me this afternoon. So we'll have that moving forward. Future agenda items, I mean, does that one, I don't know if you have other, do we wanna talk about those?
[3:38:58] Speaker I (unidentified): I just don't have a list in front of me. If you wanna give me a couple minutes, I can.
[3:39:01] Speaker A (unidentified): So if members have future agenda items, they're already on the carry. Contact Peter, myself, and Marla, and we'll work them into the agenda. Agenda. Is there other business? Citizens Form Number 2. So at 1029, the motion is adjourned. So moved. Meeting adjourned.