← Back to MaineScanner

Advisory Committee on Homelessness Reviews Prevention Services and Strategic Planning

2026-11-09 · 1h 47m · Source: Advisory Committee on Homelessness 11.9.26 (City of Bangor YouTube)
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Jason, can you hear us? Jason, you're on mute. Could you come off mute and let us know if you hear us? [1:51] Speaker B (unidentified): Hello, I can hear you, but I can't see you. [1:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Yeah, we're having a little bit of a problem with our camera this evening. Oh, okay. We're having a little bit of a problem with our camera, but we're going to start the meeting. But I have moved you to be a panelist so that you can participate in the meeting. I don't think there's anything in their packet that we actually sent it over. I think I sent it just to you, so I'm sorry. So I can give the background. So the acre committee has a website off of the city website that has a blog and with some updates. The acre committee, the committee members themselves are the ones who do the writing for the blog, the ones who maintain it, they take ownership of it. So that is a model that could be used. I know that there's a lot of work that already needs to be happening in the next nine months or so. And also, I think one of the things, Jen, the only audio that is working is your mic. That's weird. Oh, so you're mic might not even be working. I'm sorry for the technical difficulties this evening, but I think one of the things that when Alton and I spoke that with the work that you are all doing right now, this might be a blog to consider in the future after having a strategic plan done and providing updates and things of that nature. So it was just an example and I leave it all in your hands to [5:24] Speaker C (unidentified): decide your [6:12] Speaker D (unidentified): thoughts. You're smiling. Is [Speaker E (unidentified): that good? Well,] i think that i mean i 'm gonna have to go through the bucket we can still find some way to weave in some you know communications even if the blog is not as important as i mean i agree with that i do but you know i do to often, as I do, worry about the temperature of the issue with the public. And it feels like if we were to just ruminate on the strategic plan for 12 months, that temperature will only continue to grow. And I do think that is something that the committee can help with. Maybe it's not squarely our domain, but I don't think it isn't our domain either. And yeah, that's pretty much how I feel. [7:20] Speaker F (unidentified): Is Jay able to speak? Do we know? Jay, do you have any thoughts as well? I want to make sure everyone gets a chance to voice their thoughts. [7:31] Speaker B (unidentified): I think that a blog would be a good idea in the long run. I'm not sure how useful it'll be right now, but as we become, as we have a strategic plan, as we have something to publish I think it will become something that will become useful. I think we'll have to look at the voice and the tone that we use will become important. [7:56] Speaker F (unidentified): Just sounds like we're all in agreement that this is maybe not a priority right now, but certainly something that we want to consider in the future to help get information out there. [8:08] Speaker G (unidentified): Jen, can you repeat what committee is using that so that we can look at it? Sure, it's the [8:14] Speaker A (unidentified): acre committee. Thank you. Is that an acronym, the advisory committee on racial inequity? I'll have to look at the rest. Thank you. It's right next to us when you go on city agenda. What I can do is I can actually send, Alton, if I send you the link and send it out [8:39] Speaker F (unidentified): to everyone, you can take it. I actually already have the link, so I can just send it. I will get that out to everybody. Awesome. All right. Moving on to item number three, our three-month report, which we had a discussion on last week. And Teal took some time to draft a version that was shared within our packets. So I actually like to pass it over to Teal to talk through the three [9:04] Speaker D (unidentified): month report that they created. Thank you. Hopefully, so yeah, I took a stab at working on the report. I remember thinking while hearing about this report, you know, sort of gramming for a science project, and I was thinking of the different things that we worked on and if how would I try and sort of pin down some of these more astral things that we've talked about, the connections that we've made, the different, you know, interpersonal connections that we've made as a committee, and, you know, do that in a in a way that, you know, conveys the idea that we have done serious work here, and that is what I did. So, you know, some of this language is a little boilerplate. I think it needs to be demystified a little, but, you know, for the most part it focuses on, you can call them buckets, but different categories that I thought would be of use to anyone who wants to create our homework as a committee. So I focused on the data that we've looked at, the feedback that we've looked at, the connections that we've made. As a committee and externally, I looked at the subcommittees that we made. Though I wasn't sure if I had fully captured the subcommittees that we've made, I looked at our progress towards our meant to deliver a strategic plan. And I also looked at, like, I wanted to be inclusive of all of the plans, the people who had come before us. I put forth, you know, just so that people know we haven't ignored those plans. We have looked at them very thoughtfully. We've reviewed the information that they presented. And so I'm trying to make sure that those are encoded here as well. And then also finally, you know, a message on what our actual strategy is, you know, that we've created this sort of, I described it as recursive, you know, this way to look at things item by item and use that to inform our strategic report. So hopefully you can see that there is a description for each major category that describes our work, and also underneath, if there are relevant bullet points that, which, you know, support the description, they're there. If not, they're not there. Awesome. [11:49] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, thank you, Teal, for taking the time to put this together. So I would open this up to the rest of the committee. What are everyone's thoughts? Any feedback that we have? Thank [12:05] Speaker D (unidentified): you. I want to say that Jim helped as well. Thank you. [12:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Thoughts other than great job, you did a great job, but any feedback that we have, that alterations or [12:22] Speaker D (unidentified): recommended additions? It might be useful to look at the word from the committee, because I recalled that while we were discussing the report that, I can't remember, it was multiple people who said that it would be nice if, while we're giving the report, we're also receiving, like, this might be another convenient injunction to receive feedback, and that's really what I said here in this word from the committee. But I also felt, you know, I mean, this is good word from the committee, so if anyone has any other words and is a member of the committee now, I think this would [12:53] Speaker E (unidentified): be a good place to goodbye seeing [12:59] Speaker F (unidentified): nothing in the room. Jay, do you have any thoughts or feedback regarding the three-month plan document? This [13:08] Speaker B (unidentified): is a great start I 've read it twice I'd like to read it again the word from the committee at the end I think we need to expand that a little bit to you I think there's a little reluctant to [13:29] Speaker D (unidentified): expand it without speaking to everyone, because, yeah, go ahead. I think that's, I [13:39] Speaker B (unidentified): I just think there's more to be said at the end. Do [13:44] Speaker F (unidentified): You have any specific examples? I think what I mean, like what I'd like to see, is us be able to get this to a point where after this meeting we can put the final touches on this and vote next meeting to send this to council. So do you have any specific things that you'd like to see expounded upon in that section? Hearing no [14:16] Speaker B (unidentified): response. Working on it. Hold on. [14:20] Speaker F (unidentified): No, you're good. I want to make sure. [14:24] Speaker D (unidentified): And I'm also reachable by email if anything comes up, you know. [14:29] Speaker H (unidentified): Quick, a lot is thinking. Should we put something, one or two things that's concrete in there? [14:39] Speaker D (unidentified): Do you think that needs its own category and areas of focus or do you think that can be added soon? [14:45] Speaker H (unidentified): I think we added it just like because I think I mean there's a lot of general themes in this which is great but I don't know and again I know it's pretty much but would things be like even like the warming kind of thing I mean it's something that's concrete within the same in the three months this is well I thought that was kind of [15:13] Speaker F (unidentified): captured in some of the bullets that Teal had put on there but to your point like does it need to be in its own set like here are the things that we did that what you're envisioning I mean when you [15:22] Speaker H (unidentified): see that for example I see the warming shelter so it can be full it says we consulted on Yellen [15:26] Speaker D (unidentified): Hines project Hope Face Center and warming shelter I'm wondering if it would be more visible if we were to get each one of these it's on bullet point I mean we've got a lot of space here I mean this [15:40] Speaker H (unidentified): fourth page if you know SQL in space I mean we could say consult on you know and then put online or what happened it's just something to say that we haven't yeah that's a yeah that's a great idea [15:51] Speaker D (unidentified): but I think I would need some help with the language on that if anyone has any suggestions [15:56] Speaker E (unidentified): you know so [16:00] Speaker F (unidentified): you're you're thinking just so that we're like expounding upon the bullet yeah there's [16:05] Speaker D (unidentified): one just a run thing yeah what I'm understanding is like warming shelter as it's as a bullet and then a blurb about what we did to consult. [16:13] Speaker H (unidentified): And yeah, I'm fine with that too. It's like, as long as you can just say, hey, this is the concrete step we took. And that will just show, you know, because this in a way can sell, okay, well, what does that mean, consult? Again, we don't have to do it for everything, [16:31] Speaker D (unidentified): just a few things. No, I'm in favor of that too, because it does increase the visibility of the work product. I think another area where that could be done is a little bit of the data section, because you know it says that we were to give the Robin memo and the date of the memo, but we reviewed a whole ton of stuff within that, becat stuff, state stuff, you know. And I think that if we could break that up a bit, people would. But it's hard for, I would say, the city councilors, if they're not following every meeting, and the public, if they're not following every meeting, to look at that line item and say, we reviewed the Robin memo and know what that actually means. [17:20] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, same thing with the plan. When you talk about the plans, Carolyn Fish plan, it's like if you put one line on that. So because I presume the reader, which is the city council, they're not looking for you to say hey this is the roadmap to do exactly this is just kidding right this is what we've done and [17:37] Speaker I (unidentified): they may ask what the point is. Sorry, what did you have, something? Well, I was going to suggest that [17:44] Speaker C (unidentified): if you wanted to potentially refer to the domains in the memo, that might give you that level of explanation for your report. If it's a little bit more descriptive, the domains is of the green, the domains in the memo that we talked about, like what was the scope of the issue and then what's [18:07] Speaker E (unidentified): been done and [18:11] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it's important to keep in mind too, this is an update. Yeah, this is not meant to be an all-encompassing thing. If council has additional questions on exactly what something may mean, they can certainly reach out, and I would, I would challenge us to not go beyond four pages. I mean, somebody goes, you know, what's that? Yeah, so I mean, so we've got a little room down there at the bottom of page four, which to Jay's point, I mean, if we want to expound on the word from the committee, but I do like the idea of adding a couple of more concrete examples as you said, Dr. Tony. Like, would you suggest maybe emailing Teal, like [18:55] Speaker J (unidentified): so to help you like add to this, like, oh yeah, totally, yeah, like Jason, if you have things, you know, feel like for that ending, and then if any of us do help Teal guide, like, that's perfect, so [19:10] Speaker F (unidentified): do we as a committee think that we can commit to getting Teal any feedback by the end of this week? That way, Teal, you have time to work on it and get it to Jen and I before the next meeting so that we have time to review and get it in the packets. Perfect. Does the end of this week work for everybody? Mm-hmm. Perfect. And that works for you, Teal? That gives you enough time to... Awesome. All right. Thank you, Teal. Yes, thank you. Any other questions or comments regarding the three-month report before we move on to the next agenda item? [19:41] Speaker D (unidentified): I was just going to say, too, that maybe we're trying to keep in mind your tuition fees. But in terms of like the externality piece and like the plans that we reviewed, maybe rather than like say what those plans compose here, we can say in the word from the committee, those plans are available on that idea. [20:16] Speaker F (unidentified): We can represent it back so that they can go back. [20:19] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I don't think it's, I mean, there's so much stuff in there that you can't summarize, but even if it's just something that we're doing. [20:26] Speaker F (unidentified): Absolutely. I mean, and keeping in mind that we have three new counselors that will be in contact for the first time, so, presumably. All right. So moving on to the next item, emails and community communication. So I saw we did have a couple of emails in the packet, or one email packet. Any questions or thoughts or discussion needed from said email? [20:55] Speaker J (unidentified): I mean, I think in general, a lot of emails are very similar in the response people have and, you know, a lot of references to different spaces, utilizing spaces in town and, you know, the people what they're gonna do, you know. And we have a lot of references, a lot of people have emailed me with references of what resources, which is helpful. Like, if there's something we didn't know that our healthcare needs and where to go, I think that's great and been able to utilize that. You know, I do wanna find them like, oh, you know, I just learned this or that, you know. So I think that's, but I know there's a lot and I feel like I feel like people are spotting like they want an answer why the ethics isn't empty, you know, those sort of things, which is really hard for us to, we can't fix and get those, so in general I don't really think it's very concerning, concerns which we share. [21:59] Speaker H (unidentified): I think that's a struggle, I'm not reading somebody's email because they, I mean, they're and it's beyond the scope of this committee has for anything, so and I don't know how to, I mean, others it's the fact that we can say in this meeting that these emails were recognized and initiated sending, we can't be providing a direct response because we just don't have. [22:24] Speaker J (unidentified): An answer, but we, you know, we are acknowledging that we already know we do see them, and there's some very things in there that we all fear, that things that are concerned on a lot of stuff, so. And then there's some very detailed ones which are great, and I think in the future we, you know, you guys or, as you know, some of them that have really taken the time to section off stuff, we can as we progress and maybe meet some of those things, point out that like that's a goal, you know, we did like we heard. You know, and we did this, you know, the warming centers were a big thing I think now we're here, right? So the together place was a big thing, you know? So it's like, we are voicing these that are in the emails and I think we've met some of them. [23:11] Speaker H (unidentified): But you know, one theme actually just made me think is that rather than a specific location, but the theme is some folks are asking, can we optimize a new space period? And whether it's Dorothy Diggs, whether it's, you know, some old section of the town, whatever it is. So that's something for the city council team here to take an inventory of a new space and what are the opportunities to use any of them and they can go from there what they would need to do, whether it's up in state or whatever it is. [23:41] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that's it. Oh, sorry. Hi, I just want to comment on the Dorothea Dix. So City Manager Carollynn Lear and I did meet with the Dorothea Dix representatives, the superintendent and others involved and they walked us through a map of the property and there isn't any space that's really usable at this time and some of the space if I remember this correctly that's potentially usable meaning it's empty means it also means there's significant amount of money that needs to be put into any spaces to be renovated but at the time that we had the conversation there was no available [24:17] Speaker I (unidentified): space on the Dorothea Dix campus yes the state design oh whatever they the [24:24] Speaker H (unidentified): the law they wrote until these days I mean I totally get all that but I think the general theme is people need to know that they don't understand it but they also just the ongoing efforts look at okay well we can't do it now let's look at another time there's no like [24:41] Speaker J (unidentified): what are they used for what is it used for like you know a lot of people that i get are just the whole building definitely there's one wing so you know they don't understand what is going on i don't think that 's part some of it needs they need to understand [24:56] Speaker D (unidentified): I was gonna say both of your points, like from what I'm getting, not just from the emails but from, you know, like the community, like a lot of times, you know, I met Chipotle and someone pulled me aside, like I saw you on the zoom. But you know a lot of the ideas that I hear are very visionary, you know, like I drove past this building, why can't it be used and converted into beds. And I guess, as sympathetic as we are to those feelings, everybody who's seen this very human issue wants it to be resolved and wants it to be resolved quickly. The committee is not singularly empowered to do that. And our priority is the strategic plan. And if we did, as we were strategizing, come to the conclusion that it would be helpful for the city to audit spaces and accommodate new, you know, ideas, and we could put that into our report. But, you know, we can't tell the city right now to spend money that is beyond our jurisdiction. Jurisdiction to renovate a property that somebody drove by, and you know I think that it's very thoughtful and helpful that people are keeping it in mind, and it certainly does hurt for people to keep it in mind. But all of these different like zoning and policy things that come up when comes to reclaiming a building are, you know, one, the actual city council's jurisdiction, if anybody's, and you know, yeah, I guess, no, you know, yeah, very much Amy and Brittany, either of you have any [26:58] Speaker G (unidentified): On the emails, no, I mean, I'm, yeah, I've been, it's it's really nice to see that the public is committed to continuing to move things along. There it's great to hear from constituents, I, there were there were a handful of emails that were like, they were kind of surprising, and that I was, and so it's been great, but I think [27:31] Speaker K (unidentified): That's that's where there could be opportunity for just like public education maybe from at the city council level, even if it was understanding like the nuances of reclaiming an abandoned building or understanding the cost that might go into renovating something as significant as Dorothea Dix. I don't have an answer for the best way to do that. But I just think of, you know, during like the public health crisis, like where the CDC for instance, can like help address common misconceptions. And I don't know if there is an opportunity for that, but that seems like there's potential there. [28:12] Speaker H (unidentified): The other thing too is I don't see it in this month's emails, but it was a couple months ago when a lot of them just complained that they found totally public order stuff. I think if we can screen this and basically have, like for example, like that month we could have Dave and the police give an update, okay, how accurate is this? Because it sounds like this is the whole city on fire, but it's really just a small issue in the scheme of things. So I think if we can timely educate that. Now question, when people post these emails, is it only for us or can the public see these emails? Or do they see it because of the agenda? [28:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, they come directly to the committee's inbox, and then when they're put in the packet, they become public. [28:57] Speaker D (unidentified): I believe that when it was first posted on social media it was exclaimed that [29:02] Speaker H (unidentified): your emails will be sent no so that means actually that's more like stuff where it's potentially you know charged. I think that's where we can say okay let's get someone in here for the next meeting to talk address this can kind of like you know educate and provide [29:19] Speaker I (unidentified): data to what is happening what isn't happening. I think we can use I mean like right we have [29:27] Speaker G (unidentified): there's a certain scope of work that we can do and it's important when we're being informed of how it how the community feels and i don't know that we necessarily need to get bogged down with some of those things because it is people's opinions it's yeah ideas that we can't we can't chase all [29:45] Speaker D (unidentified): the leads on so i think the aims thing that i'm very passionate about and i think would be a good idea is for like for things that are more objective like the zoning issues like it would probably in my mind be helpful like i was trying to say last meeting like we did see that cities, communities, governmental official bodies have done advocacy to work on stigma and that they are able to educate you know from the position of their office or from whatever and release videos and when you see other cities do it literally all the time and say we appreciate the well-being of support of people coming in and saying you know Dorothea Dix the mall wherever but unfortunately due to zoning issues or whatever the objective part of that piece is, they can get out in front and say, the costs because of X, Y, and Z outweigh the benefits. I think that we could do that with some of these ideas, not to say that they're bad ideas, but I think that would let people know that they're listened to and that it would help them sort of steer their passions away from doing duplicate work, right? Everybody is, I mean, but plenty of people have suggested Dorothea Dix. And I think that someone who is so passionate about it, that they're trying to get involved would be able to steer their focus to something else, or maybe even steer it further based, maybe they see the video and they think, well, that's wrong and I know why it's wrong, but either way, the video empowers them more than it does. does and it decreases that temperature outside of vitriol and you know confusion so it takes [31:41] Speaker H (unidentified): means a big few big properties going to be like everyone go to for anything so [31:47] Speaker D (unidentified): I would be I would love to see education you know from the city counselors or from some of the staff who are you know trained in some of these matters so [32:01] Speaker F (unidentified): in our three-month report can we add recommendations to counsel like I mean I think you bring up a great point and we've talked about it right and we've talked about this almost ad nauseum it's so important I wonder if there's value in including that in a three-month report hey one of the things that is universally agreed upon within the committee is that more education needs to be done from additional channels on what are the obstacles to these things [32:32] Speaker E (unidentified): instead of just being dead. [32:36] Speaker A (unidentified): So the beauty of not having a template for a report means you can do whatever you'd like with your. So yes, you have creative privilege to do whatever you think is meaningful because the primary audience of this report will first be city council and then the public. So however you wanna use the report. [32:56] Speaker F (unidentified): So how do we feel about that? i'm making that recommendation in the report that gets submitted to council [33:05] Speaker D (unidentified): to tony's part as well it makes the report more substantive as well you know if we include that because it does seem to have universal agreement [33:17] Speaker F (unidentified): jay you haven't had a chance to chime in sir on the email piece or this added language to the [33:23] Speaker B (unidentified): The report. Any thoughts, sir? I like the added language to the report. This has been a bit of a something that's floated for years, and it's always been something that we've gotten a no from, but it doesn't seem to be something that the that it keeps coming back. And if we can come if we can come at it with a with a cleaner message, here's the why that would be a good reason as it as it relates to emails. I don't see anything this time around to respond to. I would like to say to those that are listening, please continue to email, please do include solutions in your emails as much as possible. I do like a good email with a solution and a suggestion in it, and look forward to hearing from you. Thank [34:14] Speaker E (unidentified): you, Jack. All [34:15] Speaker F (unidentified): right, any other items related to emails and community communication? I just want to echo [34:22] Speaker D (unidentified): which I said, and that we thank the community and also the fact that it has helped us and it has, you know, shown us the level of civic engagement that, you know, we need to get through these meetings and do our work in the community, and it's awesome. So please keep emailing us, please [34:42] Speaker F (unidentified): we're ready. Excellent. With that, we will move to the next agenda item, the primary agenda item for the day, strategic planning, specifically in the prevention bucket. The plan had been for Bruce to share a kind of city prevention services. Unfortunately, Bruce is unable to join us. However, Jen gets to step in and fill those shoes for the evening. Cherry, thank you.
Referrals
[35:06] Speaker A (unidentified): I want to say I will not be able to give this justice the same way that Bruce can, but I will try my best. With the focus on prevention, the ask was for us to go back and tell you sort of what Citi does around prevention. So Bruce had put together this document, and I'll just, I won't read through everything, but just sort of highlight the programs. So one of them is the Housing Navigation and Stabilization Program. This is a program that's about to finish up its second year at the end of this calendar year. It was originally supported by Maine housing dollars for two years. And what that funding allowed us to do is to hire one full-time person and then to have funds to help a person stabilize their housing. So our person who came into that position when the program launched was Bruce. And the goal of the program was twofold. One was to prevent evictions and the other one was to help people who had just been newly housed to prevent that early eviction. So it's very much on that prevention bucket. City Council decided as part of my budget of my department, I included that position as a city position going forward and that was approved by City Council. So this program receives referrals from a number of places. We get referrals from landlords because Bruce has built an extensive web of relationships with landlords throughout the city. You'll get referrals from landlords that say, I've got somebody here that's at risk of eviction, maybe could use some help. We get referrals from community-based organizations, from clients themselves, from general assistants or some of our other programs. And then now Tricia Sear, who's in that position, is linked with them along with Bruce to sort of really talk through what their situation is. Is it back rent pay that they just need to have a conversation with the landlord to figure out good payments going forward? Is it an uncleanly situation? You just need some help getting going and write a checklist. So they really try and sort of come together and troubleshoot. Often what we found is the person needs connection to case management, or the person isn't in the right housing situation. They need to find something more affordable, or they need to go into assisted living, or there needs to be a better option for them than what they're in right now. So a lot of it is helping to communicate with the landlord and then finding what the best fit is. Sometimes housing can't be saved. And so what Bruce and Tricia do is help to find a landing place for that person whether it's at a shelter or with a family member or somewhere else so that is around pre-eviction yes so that's that program so yes yeah so that's that's what a good bit of a conversation is so a landlord will say I've done everything that I know how to do. I'm going to have to evict this person. And then it brings in another person to kind of be a neutral party to kind of come together and potentially find solutions. Sometimes that works beautifully and everyone's happy and no eviction happens. Sometimes it just doesn't work out, but they do everything possible. The goal is to get that person into case management if they're open to it. And sometimes when they're connected, when the program's connected to a client, sometimes the client has a case manager, but doesn't know how to work with a case manager. So we're really trying to put all those pieces together. [38:50] Speaker H (unidentified): Now, one thing that we did too, is to highlight the success this committee does when they gave up prevent homelessness, because I think people, this is like the quiet victories that no one knows about. Yes. [39:04] Speaker B (unidentified): I have questions. Huh? Oh, I have a question when you're ready. I thought you were done. I'm sorry. No, go ahead. Yeah. So that's basically one. Go ahead Jen. You talked about that person in service, those people, but I want to talk a little bit more about who those people are in this service particularly called housing navigation that the city offers. Are those individuals just that, are they individuals, unaccompanied individuals, are they family members, are they youths, are they veterans? What does the, what does the population actually look like that you're serving? Predominantly, who are they? All of the above. [39:43] Speaker A (unidentified): So we are working with people who are on their own. We are working with families with young children. We're working with veterans. We're working with people who experience a disability. We're working with anyone that we receive a referral from. [40:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you predominantly have a, is there more of one than the other that you find that you're working with individuals? [40:08] Speaker A (unidentified): You know, I don't have that data in front of me right now. I can provide a data report. I think some of it was maybe in Robin's sort of aggregate number. I don't have disaggregated numbers this evening. [40:21] Speaker F (unidentified): Any other questions regarding Housing Navigation Stabilization? [40:25] Speaker A (unidentified): The one thing that I will add about this program is that the funding from Maine Housing will come to an end in December, while the position will continue, the money that came with that funding to help with back rent or back utilities or to help get someone into clean, all that other sort of discretionary funds is going away. That funding will not continue. So we're gonna do the best to leverage the resources in the community, but that part of the program will go away. [40:54] Speaker H (unidentified): State funding, city funding? [40:55] Speaker A (unidentified): That funding was from Main Housing, state funding. [40:58] Speaker D (unidentified): So can we get a like report on like the sort of like actual fixed things that we're using that discretionary funding on that be going away? Because I think that would be helpful for us. I mean, in order to determine, I guess what I'm saying is in order to determine the burden that the unhoused are going to experience, if this program goes away, we would really need to have a good idea of what is going away, I guess is what I'm trying to say. Like the big, the. [41:31] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think we're just trying to do, how much was the funding? [41:35] Speaker A (unidentified): So the funding in total was two, I believe it was 200. 100. I'm sorry, I was not prepared to provide the numbers and the budget this evening. So I can get those I can get that for you. Yep. I'm totally Oh, yeah, I will get the budget and the breakdown and who we serve. Sounds like a place that so the position will still be filled because that position was approved up in the city budget. The funds are something that I would have to put back into my budget in this coming budget season. [42:06] Speaker K (unidentified): In so you moved a bunch of sex I'm guessing it's a significant number the number the amount of money [42:14] Speaker A (unidentified): that was used in the discretionary funding yes I'm guessing I believe about half of the funding [42:24] Speaker B (unidentified): might have been discretionary funding yeah if you're using the money from the discretionary funding then we have access to be able to track data in a new or different way on this [42:34] Speaker A (unidentified): on this information yeah we have the detailed data because we have to provide that to main housing for our financial reporting i can provide that amount for you thank you did you have if i did it 's gone just to give you a little bit of a sort of put in the back of your mind is anything that comes with a price tag that would be something that would be included in the in the upcoming budget year, which kind of kicks off around February, March, departments start to put their budgets together. So this might be, these conversations are probably good timing. [43:12] Speaker K (unidentified): This falls under public health budget? This is my budget, yes. [43:17] Speaker E (unidentified): I was going to say, so you, the funding [43:24] Speaker D (unidentified): That we had to initially hire that 100-year-old this professional who would all come from that was for this who is initially coming from main housing and then got moved into your budget. Yes, so the city has assumed that burden. Yes, and you know another question I think I articulated, I'm not sure, like I'm, you said some of the things that discretionary funding does, but like, you know, I guess that's something I would love to see typed up or put, you know, put forward in a more concrete way. It's just Like what are we losing from that money, what was that money saving, what was that money doing to strengthen our response, that way if we do as a committee decide that it is something that was a load-bearing area of response that we'll, we'll be empowered to advocate for it in our strategic plan. So that's where I'm coming from. Does that, yeah, it's cool, and to be clear the funding ends December [44:32] Speaker K (unidentified): of 26, not December of 27. Can I ask just one more just general budget question, which is [Speaker E (unidentified): is, well,] nevermind. That's a question for Mara. It's not a Russian person. [44:54] Speaker A (unidentified): So Bruce was the first person hired in this position. Bruce then moved to the next position, the Homeless Response Coordinator, and Tricia Sear moved into the Housing Navigation and Stabilization position. So the Homeless Response Coordinator was previously known as the Homeless Response Manager. When Jenna Jones, who was in that position, left that position, we reclassified it to a coordinator to balance a little bit more on the ground activities. And so that's what Bruce is right now. That position was originally funded by ARPA funds. Those ARPA funds come to an end also in December of 2026. However,, that position was also included in my budget last year that was approved. So that position has ongoing financial support at this time. [45:47] Speaker D (unidentified): And how much did we get for this position? [45:53] Speaker A (unidentified): We don't have that number. So it's to cover benefit, you know, salary and benefits, just the salary and just the personnel position, no other funds to go with it. [46:03] Speaker D (unidentified): So those are the only ARPA funds we took for that? [46:06] Speaker A (unidentified): That was for that position, it was just for the staff. Bruce's role is multi-faceted. Bruce straddles the world between being on the ground and providing direct service to individuals and trying to support some systems level work. The way that he works in prevention specifically is really in support of Trisha. He's doing a lot of landlord relationship building, key is helping to identify people to refer to the stabilization. We are actually internally at our department coming up with a new way of doing intake so that when anyone is referred to our department, they meet with Bruce, Tricia, and our outreach person to understand what their story is and then gets triaged to the right person. And Bruce is really helping to coordinate that triage so that somebody who is at risk of losing their housing, then three of them would have that conversation together and then it gets sent to predominantly Trisha to work on so Bruce is doing a lot of more of the he's balancing working with individuals and then also trying to work at the system level one of the things that he is looking to work particularly towards around prevention is understanding how we can be informed of evictions before it gets to the court or while it's in process whether it's working with Pine Tree Legal or some other entities he's trying to understand how there's a way to understand and get the data around evictions [47:43] Speaker H (unidentified): In general this is for my own education how long does that picture process take like from the moment I decide to say you know I can't work with so anymore I need to initiate [47:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Shape of eviction will happen? It varies because the reason for eviction can vary. So eviction can happen because someone hasn't paid their rent, and that one's a little bit quicker. And then it can be evictions because of behavioral or other issues, and that can sometimes take a little bit longer. And then when you go to eviction court, a judge could decide that the landlord didn't keep good records of why the eviction should happen and the eviction doesn't happen. So, it varies. [48:27] Speaker H (unidentified): Once I decide to evict someone, then I go to eviction court to request a petition that person be evicted. Is that what it is? [48:34] Speaker A (unidentified): And it's like the reasons. You can describe that process better. [48:37] Speaker J (unidentified): It's a very lengthy process. It's definitely not a quick process. [48:41] Speaker K (unidentified): It gets laid out in one of those resources, I thought, really well. Yes. But you could probably summarize it. No. [48:48] Speaker J (unidentified): I mean, yeah. I could go on and on. I mean every scenario is very different, but they I feel like between the mediators, you know, Pine Tree Legal, we get there is a lot of conversation. I mean, I think, you know, versus what I do versus a private landlord, a little different, right? But as far as, you know, for me going in there, I mean, when once we've gotten there, we're at that point, right? But we try to still mediate, we try to still keep them housed. We've contacted all these resources. There's, you know, I think that the judges nowadays really understand the fact that there's nowhere for people to go, so you'll find a lot more agreements, or, you know, so we'll come to an agreement. So if we have somebody, let's say that hasn't paid, owes us tons of money, we've tried everything, we're plans, we'll get there, and then a judge will say I'll try to come up with another plan, and then within that plan they say okay, you can't be late within the next 12 months, this is agreement, if you are it will be served, you know, and then you've got 48 hours to 10 that bit served and you're out, you know, but this is like, you know, this still takes a year, you know, it's a long process. If it, you know, if it's cleanliness, I mean, there's a lot of things you have to do prior to you have the proof, of course, you get to court, is just talk, you're not, you know, you've wasted your time, you know, so. [50:13] Speaker H (unidentified): So basically, from the moment this starts to the moment this ends, whatever that reason is and whatever process is, I could stop and reverse the whole process. [50:22] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, you can stop it. You can, you know, I can. [50:26] Speaker H (unidentified): Even if it goes to court, you can still reverse it. [50:29] Speaker A (unidentified): And it's also very expensive for a landlord. I very agree. So legal fees, as well as getting somebody in, like it's landlords we have found have tried to work really hard, most of them, to be able to keep somebody there because it's actually [50:41] Speaker J (unidentified): really expensive for that. I mean, none of us really want to get there. It just comes to a point where it's unsafe and financially, you know, strangling us, and then, you know, not having the support in, you know, the homeless sector, you know, the homeless, we're focused in there too. But we have a lot of house people struggling and we work very hard to keep people housed. But I will tell you some of the encampment looks look like our inside of our units right now. Like it's, and then you know they leave, or when we do get to that point, we're talking eighteen thousand dollars to turn a unit, and it's so, it's it's just bad, it's a [51:19] Speaker H (unidentified): discouragement for someone to be a landlord to say I have a place I could actually rent out but no hearing this I don't do it is and in the fact that [51:28] Speaker J (unidentified): you know to get someone in say they're denied or you know and then I'll do a hearing with them to get them in and have them show me what they're doing and then they get in and like I said those services drop and we're right back to square one and so then my it's bothersome when I have to do that I see that and then I have to evict again and I know that now that person's back out on the streets and is going to have another bad landlord reference you know and so the likelihood that anyone is going to take them right off is very slim so it is huge that the prevention part like I think it's I think that [52:04] Speaker K (unidentified): that process is also really helpful for the general public to understand why some of our folks that visually appear chronically homeless, it's not for lack of effort. There has probably been a lot that goes into them either struggling to maintain housing or their rental record because of issues in the past make it very hard for them to be housed again. [52:25] Speaker J (unidentified): I, within a year, housed 10. And I re-overturned hearings and hearings and hearings to get them housed I have one left you know so nine of them are back you know that to me is very sad and it necessarily you know it's also the education when you know some have been on those streets for a very long time they don't know how to maintain inside the unit and I as a landlord you know I would love to go in and say okay you index this I'll index that you know but that's kind of what they need they need to handle care to learn how to do it so yeah we can go on for days on that but the process is very and they can't you know but judges I do find are you know willing to work out those deals and a lot of attorneys are and the you know the goal is to [53:15] Speaker F (unidentified): try to all work together to keep people happy and the housing navigation and stabilization piece so they can help with those life skills lessons did I understand that correctly [53:27] Speaker A (unidentified): or can help sort of in an episodic way meaning that they could you know say hey let's get a checklist on your refrigerator of everything that you need to do this week can help in those provide those type of resources I think [53:45] Speaker H (unidentified): We see this in all places to psych hospitals. We have patient degrees, hey, go do your life skills, and they come looking at you. What does that mean? I mean, some of them are like, we had to run these cooking groups to figure out what to do to get ingredients to cook a simple meal. We just don't know how to navigate that. So I think, you know, it's great, but I think they actually need more of it. Sorry. But for six months, it won't get you. [54:13] Speaker A (unidentified): And I would say that speaks more to case management and intensive case management. [54:18] Speaker G (unidentified): And support of housing. Yeah. Yes. Hey, Jen. [54:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, Jay. Has the city been engaging with the eviction prevention program? And how has that been working? Are you familiar with it? [54:35] Speaker A (unidentified): I am familiar. Bruce could probably provide you more details on that. Okay. [54:42] Speaker B (unidentified): I wonder if that's not an outcome that we might want to mention directly, is that the city might want to support the continuation of the eviction prevention program in as a part of this work [55:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Just two other quick buckets. A general assistance is another resource that we offer. People don't often see that as prevention of homelessness, but it is. People need to meet certain criteria. The most basic criteria is that you don't have an income. People will call, this is general assistance is something that every municipality has to have. They have the same manual that they need to follow, although we do hear about nuances in different communities. And this is really, you know, every day we get calls from people, I lost my job or I've encountered a medical issue or many other reasons why they don't have an income. And general assistance helps with things such as paying for rent, paying for medications, paying for groceries, is paying for other needs so that somebody can stay housed until they get to either getting SSI or a job or sort of getting back on their feet. So general assistance, I would consider a prevention program. And then the last one that I'll mention right now is the rental assistance program. That's our permanent supportive housing and also falls under another bucket. But the reason why we put it here under prevention is because many of the people who are living in permanent supportive housing. If they are at risk for eviction, they'll often call the person who runs that program in our office and we try and troubleshoot to be able to keep that person housed. And again, that's oftentimes conversations with landlords, conversations with the clients so that people don't get evicted. And then I would say, you know, there's much bigger things to prevention you know housing affordability livable income that are bigger systems issues but in terms of the prevention bucket with our small and mighty team those are the things that we work on i don't know if bcat or mckinney vinto wants or part. [57:05] Speaker C (unidentified): Money that we give you for the Welcome Home Fund and the memberships. [57:16] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, your assistance. [57:20] Speaker I (unidentified): Dave, could you put your... Oh, sure. [57:23] Speaker L (unidentified): Just to chime in a little bit on BCAT, they work closely with Bruce and with outreach as well. But one of the things that they're able to offer is if somebody is in a situation where they're trying to get to a place where they have a support system, but they're just unable to get there you know we are a service center so sometimes somebody's here because of the hospital and that's not uncommon so bcat's able to provide some assistance to help somebody get back to where they can receive a more foundational support system so but they do work closely with Bruce he's a great asset for all of us [58:01] Speaker D (unidentified): So, my question is how do we audit these programs, because a lot of these programs are very noble and do a lot of good work, but I've applied for some of these programs and I've helped other people apply for some of these programs and, you know, I've been in the same room with case managers that are applying for some of these programs and many of them are extremely obfuscated and even though, like, you know, GA, for example, follows a very clear rule book but the interpretation of the rules seems to vary greatly depending on the worker that you talk to their understanding of the rules and even their mood that day so i've been with some people who they're extremely lenient towards and you know they're immediately thrilled and then i've been with people who no matter what you say no matter what you do they cannot not be convinced, you know, and so I think that like, we were talking earlier, we again, one of the things that we seem to talk about is like, resource maps and truly figuring out what our resources are, you know, how I mean, I guess my question is, how can we increase the efficacy of some of the resources that we're pointing people towards? You know, it was pointed out to me that like keel for instance is still on some of our resource brokering documents. We're sending a lot of people to facilities that no longer exist, and we're sending other people, I mean you must know as a landlord what these fights can be like, and we're sending other people to resources that do exist but for you know many reasons some of which are troublesome are not all that they could be. And you know I think that worries me in particular because that's often the end where I am sitting right, like I'm sitting next to someone how they're probably using my cell phone calling a GA and you know we're scratching out the ledger on a piece of paper trying to get it right. And you know I worry about the efficacy of these programs and you know how can we figure out what the turnaround is on, you know, we send someone that direction, we work with their case manager, and I mean, you hear it, that they never heard back, or that their application was never approved, or, you know, I think that it, there's risks that it would be harmful if we were to craft a prevention strategy of purely strategies that, you know, we don't really know how successful they can be and obviously you know maybe it's harmful not to include them but I think that it would be it bears a conversation or some way for us to figure out how we can [1:00:49] Speaker H (unidentified): take stock. That's something that we need to say though because I imagine any program City they're supposed to be an audit system so it's not like we need to repeat what they're supposed to be [1:01:00] Speaker G (unidentified): doing anyway right. And so we when we think about what the scope of this group is I'm like the strategic plan is that like this, our like collective is not meant to be doing things like auditing city, you know, services. We could, if we felt like there was some sort of ground where we needed to say that we suggested that someone audit city services in a different way, we could certainly suggest that, but we can't get bogged down in the idea that we need to be like, that we need to be auditing those things. And I can appreciate your personal experience, Teal, and the experience of, like, things that people are reporting to us, and we need to be sure that, like, we're not putting more barriers in the way of, you know, the finite amount of resources we already, you know, have from being able to be operational. Not that 's not a reason why we wouldn't suggest that those things don't need to be audited, but there are some processes in place that are already, you know, Herculean that they need to meet. And so I think that there is a bit of trust that we need to have in some of those systems. [1:02:20] Speaker K (unidentified): I think when we're looking at kind of what we currently have for prevention services, low hanging fruit in my opinion is looking at what Jen was saying that she can provide us which is like kind of the data that's already been getting gathered around the Bruce's role and Christian's role, the homelessness response coordinator and the housing navigation and stabilization and understanding what funding has been going into that from main housing and arpa and what funding is going to be gone so that way if we're looking around strategic plans and recommendations from this group around prevention services we could we could make a little more concrete recommendations around what services we would like to see continue recognizing that is going to impact the public health department's budget, whether we're requesting, we're arguing or supporting a higher budget request than in years past because of the work that's being done. This is very anecdotal. However, I can, having done street medicine for almost six years and having these roles relatively new in comparison, I can say regularly I have someone at least that I can reach out to on the healthcare side of things when patients are expressing concern for losing their housing and I know how that's going to impact their health and really how difficult it is to rehouse someone after an eviction and how that deteriorates their health immensely and I have been called to intervene being to try to help prevent an eviction. And these two roles are vital, in my opinion, to prevention. And understanding the loss of those potential wraparound funds or whatever, what do you guys call them? Discretionary funds, wraparound funds, whatever you want to call them, I can imagine would really hinder the ability of these two roles to be able to provide rapid intervention to prevent eviction. So I think that, to me, I think is hugely important in understanding our recommendations. [1:04:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. And when we think about what it is that we can logically recommend, you know, and not what, yeah, not the things that we can physically do, but what we can get information around. Around, yeah, how that output of that recommendation is. That feels important. Not so much us, yeah, like, you know, auditing the way that 's happening. I can imagine it. I mean, in this field for a long time, any program that has any level of client assistance, discretionary funds that have some success, we are like going to see a total sort of decimation of like how successful those programs are going to be without the ability to offer, you know, a landlord something to keep someone from. Losing their housing so it's like the person and the people are important but the client assistant funds are often the most important part of those programs and I'd be curious not [1:05:40] Speaker K (unidentified): not even just the loss or potential loss of funding that's associated with the role so like not the role itself but the discretionary funds that go along with that I'd be curious if anyone Jen or anyone on City Council knows of a program or funding that is going to be changing that pertains to prevention in addition to you know what Bruce laid out for us and not saying that means we can change anything but I think it would be good for us to be aware of any potential changes in funding that are going to be coming up in 2027. [1:06:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Well I can tell you one potential funding is the loss of permanent supportive housing resources. [1:06:22] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, that's so important for us to just like have in writing as we're developing a strategic plan around prevention. [1:06:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, and I think that adds like a different, you know, added layer of complication when we think about the things that we truly want to recommend is that like, can we be taken seriously if what we recommend is that everyone just funds everything, right? And so there is some level of auditing that we'll need to do that's like, you know, when we think about Jen, I don't know if you know off the top of your head, when we consider permanent part of housing in the Bangor area, how many households that impacts. When we think about those cuts, which like the city doesn't have, you know, that is money coming from the federal government that the city and the state are like trying to figure out how we manage that. But if we say we have to have enough funds to save how many people's housing, about 26 to 30. About how many, 26 to 30 households, so like 30, yeah, around 30 households that depend on a subsidy that now are just not going to exist. And that's not, you know, when we consider what's happening across the state, that's a small percentage of what we're considering on the larger scale. [Speaker E (unidentified): That's] people who are currently in housing who are not going to have the ability to pay their [Speaker E (unidentified): rent and] have nowhere else to go. No, and so that's in addition to, you know, all the folks that we're talking about who are currently already experiencing homelessness or on the fringes of [1:07:59] Speaker J (unidentified): homelessness. Yeah, we have the question of what we do and the cuts to food stamps, yeah, is making [1:08:07] Speaker K (unidentified): a drastic impact on rent because people need to, and the loss of health insurance that is potentially going to be coming in 2027 as well, right. Again, people are now having to choose between rent, food, and health care, and each household is going to navigate that differently. So it does impact the work that we're doing significantly. I think there's a lot of moving [1:08:33] Speaker H (unidentified): parts between like, you know, changing administrations and previous budgets, and I don't want to touch on like, you know, heat and security for this [1:08:42] Speaker E (unidentified): one more [1:08:49] Speaker G (unidentified): thing. I'm sorry, I was going to say, when we're thinking about prevention, those things like this is, you know, prevention of, in the public health department, this is prevention as it, as we think about homelessness. But it's not even like the sort of prevention arm as we think about substance use disorder or, you know, any of the other things or, you know, Tony, like you're saying, like when we think about the things that, yeah, what is going into the prevention category for things that don't just like have the word homeless attached to it, but are the safety net services for how people are remaining housed. [1:09:24] Speaker K (unidentified): Anecdotally, from a substance use perspective, it is not uncommon for us to see people stabilize in their substance use disorder. They get a job, they get housing, they lose their insurance, they can't afford their medicine, they return to use, and they become unhoused again. This is a very common cycle that we see. So again, I mean, that's like the point of me bringing that up is, again, around the education that could be provided around homelessness and the cycle of homelessness and avoiding vilifying people with substance [1:09:54] Speaker D (unidentified): use disorder teal yeah you want to get into the supportive housing conversation but i also wanted to talk a little bit more about like the commentary that we'll be making in terms of prevention like i'm looking at this on paper we have the invention production program we have ga we have parental assistance programming you know all these different cities all of these different resources some of which are like official for the city some of which are in hands of our partners and if we are not going to be self-critical in the prevention language you know what would we say right like i do think that most case managers and other you know of those types of providers are aware that the bottleneck is happening somewhere with the official services right like the on paper record shows that we have a watertight defense right nothing should be happening we have all of these different layers of redundancy but the like what I see with my eyes record shows that you've got water flowing everywhere so you know I do feel like not that any one of us should be an auditor of these programs but we should have something in our hands where we can concretely start our stamp of approval on it and say like yeah we're we're in favor of the city's current strategy because you know some aspect of the strategy must be failing this is my understanding right like some aspect of our response is failing and maybe it is that we just can't generate more money maybe if we had four million more dollars it would be fine or maybe it's that the money that we're currently spending is not being spent on programs that are operating at 100 which is not to shame any program that isn't doing it how could you possibly do that in this current ecosystem but i just feel like i feel like the constituents would probably expect us to be doing some sort of that commentary voluntary before we would be going forward with the plan all right I mean that's why we're [1:12:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Brought together right. Could I add something? I just want to provide some context. In no way am I saying we do this so homelessness should be prevented, like I am in no way saying that. I'm saying here's a few things that we're putting our fingers in the dam that's leaking. Because for example, we are not addressing domestic violence here, a leading cause of homelessness. We are not addressing young people who are coming out of the foster care system. This is for the resources that we have been given. This is what we're able to do. And I'm more than happy to provide more data on the numbers and the budget, but I just want to provide the context like in no way do I think that this should be preventing. I will just add for the quality piece to back up, our general assistance does have an annual audit by the state, our rental, our permanent supportive housing program has an audit every year from HUD, the funder, as well as the main COC. And then our main housing grant doesn't have an audit, but we have to do regular financial and narrative reporting. Any of those reports, you're welcome to have. Not to say that they miss things, that could be better. I am absolutely open to accountability, but I just wanted to provide a little bit more context to the conversation. [1:13:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you, I appreciate that. And I didn't think that 's what you're saying. That's why I said right at the start, like it's a lot of these things are in the hands of our partners, right? Like literally, we have partners or fees, we have a lot of different community organizations that are tackling that piece of the puzzle. But I am not empowered to tell Shaw House anything or the Partners for Peace anything. But it does seem like that, you know, the committee wasn't empowered to look at that aspect of what our partners, what their responsibilities were, you know. I just have, I'm personally troubled, I guess, by the idea that we are sending people off in a direction and we start with 10 and we end with one and we're not asking ourselves how that transmuted like what happened in that till that's not the [1:14:41] Speaker G (unidentified): scope of the work that we're doing here because like that narrative is like doesn't even have i mean that's like coming from a partner right and so like lots of partners have lots of other narratives of things that go well or things that aren't going well but you know having bangor housing authority change the way that they're able to support people in housing isn't one of the recommendations that we're going to be able to have and i think i think i understand that what you're saying is you want to make sure that right we're seeing things sort of holistically like what's going well what's not going well and how do we make sure that if we're going to put our stamp of approval on something then it says that everything is going well i don't know that jen or anyone at the city thinks that everything's always going well all the time but when right like when you're trying to plug holes nothing's going to go well and i think when again your experience is your experience my experience might be my experience and someone else's is some you know someone else's but when we think about the task in front of us i can't imagine that when we are tasked with sort of auditing what's currently going on that we want to get bogged down by saying to a city that's asking us what you know what else could we be doing or what else should we be shifting or changing that much of that is going to be well you should take these dollars that are already too slim and reallocate to something else when even if what we're doing is helping eight people that like we're we're collectively not in agreement that like those eight people aren't worth that you know worth that certainly if these were programs that were flush with resources, so if this was a program that had $90 million and it felt like they weren't able to help those 10 people, that's one thing, but this is a program that's going from having a client assistance funds of $100,000, I don't know, just making it up, to having none. And then we were talking about whether or not we're auditing if this one person trying to prevent the hundreds of people in Bangor experiencing homelessness is doing enough. That, to me, doesn't feel like a good energy that the energy that I want to be putting into like how we're going to come up with recommendations for what could be happening differently. [1:17:24] Speaker D (unidentified): And I hear that again. I worry about our partners in the sense that I worry about them, but I'm not saying that I would try and change what they're doing. But I think that if we're used to now be sort of looking at the body of the city and we're trying to figure out how it's helping and harming others and for whatever reason we came to the conclusion that it was just smacking some random person, I feel fairly comfortable saying in the report maybe you shouldn't do that, right. Like if everyone is aware that there's bottleneck in the great services that you said are provisioning lots with a little right, they're doing great. But if we were aware that there was a bottleneck there, I just, I don't understand what the harm would be and being well-informed in that and then to articulate that in our model. [1:18:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Teal, could I ask a clarifying question about the way that you're using some words? Are you using the word audit limiting to a financial evaluation? Or are you thinking about an assessment and an evaluation, which is potentially a different type of conversation where you would evaluate what the actual problem is to define it? Whereas auditing does come from a financial world and it kind of gets into budgets and lines. I just wanted to clarify because I wasn't quite sure. I thought that you were in- [1:18:59] Speaker H (unidentified): I mean, it's a hospital where like, you know, you look at quality matrixes, you know, patient satisfaction. [1:19:05] Speaker C (unidentified): The five P's. Right. Patients, practice, professionals, right? [1:19:13] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, that's more what I meant. I didn't mean, I mean, surely there's financial components that does not fall squarely into our whatever. I do understand the scale is smaller and that we're not left with resources. But even if I had a lemonade stand and I couldn't attract any customers or I was attracting less customers than I wanted, I would be fairly happy to find out why. I wouldn't necessarily be afraid of that information. And if I was going to impanel a committee to tell me about my lemonade stand and maybe because of the scale, I'm not big lemonade, I don't have 90 million customers lost, but [Speaker E (unidentified): you know I'm] okay with finding out from the community I'm sort of why I'm losing [1:19:59] Speaker H (unidentified): customers that I couldn't have. Like I would like to propose that we just make the recommendation so I mean we want to make that the city continue to develop a quality measurement tool for these programs and just leave the city to kind of figure because again we just there's no way but [1:20:17] Speaker G (unidentified): But those things exist. I think that's the problem. [1:20:19] Speaker H (unidentified): I'll make it more, have fidelity to it, actually have fidelity to it. [1:20:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Can I just add, when we have these conversations, I think when we look at the format, what will be helpful is also understanding the resources that need to come with it. So for example, with evaluation, just to play this out, what it looks like in the real world is we could have client satisfaction surveys, or we can count the process measures, that we will need resources to do that work. So when you have the conversations about doing these things, I think that's great. I am all evaluation, but I think in the conversations, just a reminder that we also want to capture where more resources are needed. [1:21:03] Speaker H (unidentified): Have some way to measure this anyway right now, or you don't have that? [1:21:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Not necessarily, depends upon the program. [1:21:11] Speaker J (unidentified): But I just want to add, like, Teal, I really think it's important to recognize like you have where you're coming from and that's which is another reason why you're on, right? Like you have exercised these resources, you've attempted, you've seen some of the challenges, you've assisted people directly, you know, to try to get that and maybe some doors are shut and makes you question it, right? But that's also what our public is doing because like they don't understand because we don't, you don't understand. Like you're like, it was okay for this one, it's not okay for this one so I think giving people that clarification and understanding you know rather down the street it's it's law or whatever we come to say okay this is the expectation even though it's on like GA's website right like if you go there but does people know to go there right I think that's the educational piece of which we've talked about when we when we get it or if it's in our plan like this is what needs to happen all these resources and how these work needs we need links we need these things too so people do understand and if you're unsatisfied with something like where to go where to turn so you can not say that audited but also looked into because that's a problem I think [1:22:24] Speaker D (unidentified): maybe I should have picked better verbiage there but I appreciate like [1:22:28] Speaker J (unidentified): You having that experience, like, and being able to share that experience with us, because I think it also helps all of us at this table that do the work to understand someone that tried to access resources. You know, maybe we can do better too at stepping in to help navigate that and help educate. Because if we know, right, we can help educate you or whoever heard that. Okay, it sounds like this, but did you contact X, Y, and Z because that incident happened? [1:22:55] Speaker G (unidentified): And maybe out of this is actually, I mean, I know Jen just sort of named this, but this is kind of low hanging fruit and something that like, and when we think about the amount of resources it takes is like right one of the things that we should constantly be getting is feedback from the people who are right receiving those services. And so if we don't have channels to make sure that we're receiving feedback for those who are directly impacted, like is it as big of a lift, you know, it's not a hundred thousand dollars to print signs that have a QR code that takes you to the satisfaction survey of those who access general assistance services, or like, you know, there are some like things that we could get at that don't. So [1:23:45] Speaker F (unidentified): speaking of recommendations, we're moving forward and it's getting a little bit later. I'd like to kind of pivot the conversation a little bit towards bullet C under item five, this brainstorm of objectives and activities [1:23:59] Speaker D (unidentified): for the prevention strategic priority. [1:24:02] Speaker F (unidentified): So we've had a great conversation here and thank you Jen for sharing all of that information about what is readily available or what is currently available at the city level on the prevention field. So I'd like to open it up for discussion on are there strategies and objectives that the committee thinks should be included in the strategic plan, keeping in mind that it is a living document, this may change. Like, let's let's start getting some things to be able to put into paper so that we can really start [1:24:34] Speaker D (unidentified): moving this forward. So my thought that I've been staying on for a while that I wanted to get back to this is supportive, right, like I think we all agree that supportive housing is a much more expansive and diverse conversation than the ones that most people typically have when they mean supportive housing, because we know from our experiences and from the data and from everything else that a lot of, there's a lot of turnaround after we provisioned people the services of them, you know, and They're failing out of those services or reentering the service cycle. And I think a lot of it, just from my domain, is coming from life skills, right? A lot of people who've experienced long-term substance use disorder have deprioritized the acquisition and maintenance of light skills in order to prioritize use. And when they get into housing, they're very good at prioritizing use, but they're not good at using appropriate cleaners on the appropriate material. They're not very good at managing waste accumulation. They're not very good at keeping linens and other, and walls, any permeable material that could be, they're not good at keeping that clean, using the appropriate detergents for that. And in addition to that, Like, I mean, that's, I mean, that's one of the things that I did at Together Places that I facilitated. I did like resume coaching, I did mock interviews, I had a lot of fun with that. A lot of people, due to chronic homelessness, may have never picked up the skill, may have traded the skill in order to favor street survival or, you know, substance use, and they've lost it. So financial planning is another big one. I would, I'm wondering if there's some way that we can represent that in our [1:26:38] Speaker F (unidentified): So I think that sounds like it's very encompassing. I think, what if I'm misunderstanding, but I think the kind of the bucket that we're talking about is supportive housing, right? I don't know that we want to get into all the things that make up supportive housing. So let me ask this question. I think we all agree supportive housing sounds like it's an important piece. Is that an objective that we then need to build a strategy to get to support a thousand, or is supportive housing the strategy itself to reach a separate objective? I feel like [1:27:19] Speaker D (unidentified): life skills can be pieced out a bit because, like, supportive housing or not, you're gonna need those, right? And if you're gonna have any chance of any of the buckets, pockets, you're going to need those, and those, like, so I guess maybe I'm confused now, which is happens frequently, as you're all aware, like, isn't that just kind of classic prevention, like [1:27:44] Speaker F (unidentified): life skills, like, can we just say, like, that's good? I don't disagree, but from a strategic plan or [1:27:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Standpoint we have to bucket this. Yeah, could I, could I add something to build off of that? So one of the things that I didn't mention because I didn't, thank you for reorienting me. I didn't think of it as a prevention bucket, but one of the things that Bruce has started to kind of lay the groundwork for is sort of like a housing readiness program. He started at Together Place having conversations with small groups of people to talk about, you know, financial planning. Our dream is to have like a simulation apartment where people can practice skills. So I think I just want to support that. I think that you're talking about two different things, but they're both related. I think there is room and opportunity in place even for the city to be doing this, like life skill development in conjunction with partners who already do it really well and permanent supportive housing that also offers that there. So I think I just want to, I didn't put it on my hat, prevention, had to think of it in terms of prevention, I was thinking in another bucket, so I just wanted to mention that there was some path in that work around what Bruce was doing [1:28:56] Speaker K (unidentified): separate from permanent supportive housing. So can I offer just like from a bucket perspective? I would recommend that we, I mean these two roles are going to continue and one of the sub-bullets or objectives around continuing these roles is curriculum development around life skills which is already in the works, so encouraging that to continue as well as I would also love to see a way for folks that are newly housed to be able to socialize or have like a support group amongst themselves. So in addition to the curriculum just a space for those folks to meet to gain new connection because the loneliness is a big piece that I see and then the other bucket being permanent supportive housing as its own strategy [1:29:51] Speaker B (unidentified): I guess now we've talked about, we've talked about families, we've talked about unaccompanied youth, veterans, we've talked about people with disabilities, people in domestic violence situations, people in foster care situations. How does prevention activities relate to people coming out of jails and institutions? That is a question that I have for the group. [1:30:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Can I just add, one of the things that I meant to mention is on your B bullet, what I try to do is also provide context of the conversation on what are some evidence-based programming and Jason, I don't know if this is a place, I can't remember if it's in all of these, but these resources might provide interventions, programs that have been proven to work in other places that could be applied to some of the populations that you have just mentioned. [1:30:53] Speaker K (unidentified): And I would say specific to the resource, the third resource, the enterprise community resource from pages 11 through 19 had like a really lovely kind of grid with all of the associated links to connect to that actual program, which I thought was really helpful. And you can pick up the themes there because I think when like Alton was saying this is a living document and into some kind of starting point for us. I think as we grow this document in the future, I think it is important for us to tease out all of the subpopulations that we're hoping to serve. So maybe one of the things that we can kind of, a place to start is some of the broader strokes. Who [1:31:54] Speaker J (unidentified): Went quiet? What's that? I don't think we answered your question. [1:31:57] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't think so either, but that's okay. Maybe not. I think the objective or right, well yeah, and I think what I'm trying to do is to help us so that for the next meeting we have a draft strategic plan prevention section and so my question to the groups like again I think we all agree that supportive housing is critical in prevention and it probably serves a role in several other of these different stages if you will so what are the strategies and or objectives that should be included in the strategic plan related to [1:32:37] Speaker D (unidentified): Supportive housing, I see, so is that what you're asking me is if I'm asking over, well okay, like skills, you're asking the whole group if they should be a bullet point under what I'm asking [1:32:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Is I think we all agree that they should be, but how do we articulate that in the format of a strategic plan, right, so what is, what is our recommendation, you know, I'm going to just kind [1:33:07] Speaker H (unidentified): Of impulsively say it and I don't know if I can. We need to wordsmith it. I mean, basically I think the committee would be advising utilization of supportive housing in his contingent plan to deal with prevention of maintaining housing and with key principles to look at life skills and cabal things that we identified and leave of that. And then I think this is a separate huge task to stop looking at programs which one do we want to use housing, you know, housing because you know. And I think that's Where subcommittees of city would look at school, but we as a group endorsing that supportive housing needs to be part of your plan and that's what we should do. [1:33:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, I'm sorry, I have to interject. We have a definite, we have a definite change in the way that things are going with funding and we're looking at transitioning transitional housing in the next three to five years. More and more permanent supported housing is looking at being cut. It is in, it's in, it's in the works. It's being, it's at court, it's going through court right now. It's being cut at 30 percent. As much as I'd like to support that, I think we have to take a wait and see of an attitude Before we wholesale support, add our wholesale support to permanent supported house. I think it's one tool in a toolbox and I think it's gonna be a number of tools that we're gonna have in the future. [1:34:52] Speaker H (unidentified): I agree, Jay. I think the thing is, you're right. It's just not the thing that replace everything. And we can put a whole bunch of things in there. The problem is you and I don't have a crystal ball to see what's gonna happen in February. So we could come up with five great tools and all five tools get axed. All five tools. I have no idea because I don't know whether the state will pick up some of the slack. I just don't know. But I think, agree, we should leave it in there and then we can always pull it out if we know this doesn't exist then right I just I feel [1:35:23] Speaker C (unidentified): As though the committee would really benefit from reading the housing and Community Development strategy and taking the goals and the objectives out of that plan that pertain to because then what you have are two different documents. I am working off of this document and meeting these goals, but then if you create conflicting goals you've got staff going in two different directions. So pull the things that have been approved like as pathways and then decide whether we act those and start new but It would give you a good place to start and it would make those other plans that already exist strengthened by what you are going to create rather than conflicting it. Does that make sense? So you already have goals and objectives and numerical measures for those housing pieces already. So maybe that's a place you could start and then [1:36:22] Speaker A (unidentified): build on. I'm sorry, can you be more specific, Robin? What document is this? [1:36:27] Speaker C (unidentified): It's called the Housing and Community Development Strategy, and it was approved in July and it was also given in your packet in July and [1:36:40] Speaker A (unidentified): was it broken down to these [1:36:41] Speaker C (unidentified): buckets it was broken down by I mean it's a 300 page document it's very comprehensive but it specifically talks about the goals related to homelessness the goals related to supportive housing the goals related to housing production there's lots of different chapters in there that you could pull out this was the goal that we established is this relevant so that was sort of like where i started you all to say this is where i left off where are you going to lead me essentially in my department so you might think about that because it could conflict with the trajectory i'm on and i want of course correct if you feel that 's necessary [1:37:26] Speaker D (unidentified): So basically what you're saying is there is a current trajectory for prevention and [1:37:32] Speaker C (unidentified): for the supports for permanent supportive housing. And there are some other directives sort of related, but I think you're getting into something that's a little bit more meaty and direct. I think it would be helpful for me if you could tie those two together. So I know what's obsolete in your recommendation. If you're saying, let's move away from something here, it would be really helpful. Would it be helpful to you if I were to bring that information to the next meeting and present it in a different way? What might be helpful? [1:38:07] Speaker D (unidentified): It's in our July packet, which is archived, right? Yes. [1:38:11] Speaker C (unidentified): You could find that easily, but I'm not sure if you might need... We'll think about it. Okay. [1:38:25] Speaker D (unidentified): I was going to ask if anyone had any thoughts, if they wanted that information presented a different way, if they felt that- [1:38:32] Speaker F (unidentified): Seeing that I haven't reviewed that information since at least July, and a lot has changed and evolved since July, I think it may behoove us to take a look at that document and see how that may fit into the strategic plan and the conversations we're having currently. We don't want to send you guys in totally different directions and just mess everything up that's already in progress. So what does everyone think about kind of taking that approach? I mean it may slow down our process a little bit but it sounds like it would be who not only the committee but staff no I think I mean thanks for bringing that [1:39:22] Speaker H (unidentified): up because I think just kind of like why reinvent the wheel I mean and the only thing I ask can you [1:39:28] Speaker K (unidentified): resend that I know where I can find you if you go to the agenda center I'm pretty sure it was the July 28th meeting because that was our second meeting and then all the links are in it we do [1:39:41] Speaker C (unidentified): I do also on the community development section of Bangor's website, I do have a tab that's labeled, I think it just says plans, and it's got like every plan that we've written, including like the comprehensive plan, the housing strategy, the housing production plan, lots of those different plans. and you know anyone you know watching wherever looking it's on it's on the city's website on the community and economic development landing page there's a nav tab called plans and so I use that as sort of the repository for all of the different things that we produce and you might find [1:40:20] Speaker I (unidentified): lots of different helpful that's a consolidated plan for housing and community we talk about that [1:40:24] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah. Okay. Do you remember exactly what month this person named? I cheated. I'm not sure. [1:40:31] Speaker D (unidentified): It was July 28th. I was like, you're on the phone now. [1:40:37] Speaker J (unidentified): It was pretty impressive. No, I pulled it up. [1:40:43] Speaker D (unidentified): I had an eidetic memory. [1:40:47] Speaker F (unidentified): So, thoughts? Do we want to kind of pause, review this, bring it back for the next meeting? I mean again this is going to put us a little bit behind schedule is [1:41:04] Speaker K (unidentified): there a way that we can collectively determine what information we need to be ready to I don't want to argue but like maybe debate like what are the top two or top three are there two or three things that we really want to make sure the strategic plan incorporates and can you rank them or something along those lines because knowing it's a big document I just fear that we're going to have another meeting where we're kind of it can go so far and so why that I feel like it is there a way for us to Kind of consolidate things down, so just a thought, what if we [1:41:44] Speaker F (unidentified): look at two to three major components of prevention as we've discussed today, we very high level, right, supportive housing, just leave it at that, and then we go look through the plan and find all of the related pieces to supportive housing and kind of work from that and so on and so forth. Eviction prevention might be a separate piece. Can I just share the [1:42:11] Speaker A (unidentified): buckets that I heard tonight that you want in prevention? Those buckets include quality improvement including feedback in the current city programming, mapping of resources that the city may be using for referrals or referring to, doing education to the community about sort of those activities, curriculum development around life skill development, curriculum development around life skill growth, creating opportunities for socialization particularly those that are newly housed, and then sort of a bucket of permanent supportive housing. So I think one of the things that's always challenging about strategic planning by group is how do you take all these ideas and put it into a strategic plan. So we could do this a couple of different ways. We can take a pause, go to the document that Robin referenced, and then you can come back and completely do like a different format on how you want to do this plan. At the same time, what we could do is in the format that we've talked about, I can just dump some of this into that format and you can play around with what that feels like. And then, you know, maybe next meeting is a little bit of both because the last thing that I want you all to have to do is like sit here and say buy x, what's the right word we're going to use here, but I also want to make sure that we're supporting you to put you on a path of a strategic plan, and typically a strategic plan is more than just a list of recommendations. So I leave it to you all and what you want to do next, but I want to also make sure that we're capturing those, and if I missed any buckets please let me know here, but what I can at least do is dump this into that format and just so you can see what it looks like, take it or leave it, compare with the other plan and what you may want to take from it, and it could be just a way to start thinking through it. Yeah, I think it speeds things up a [1:44:29] Speaker F (unidentified): Little bit, so thank you for making that recommendation, Jen. I think it's great too, here. So does anyone have objections to having Jen kind of take these topics that we've discussed, putting them into the strategic plan, and then at our next meeting we can use that to kind of fine-tune the language and kind of move the pieces away. I really appreciate that. Is [1:44:51] Speaker K (unidentified): there any buckets that were like major themes that were missed or anybody feels that were missed? [1:45:04] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm sorry, one other piece was the concern about the loss, I wouldn't say the loss of, but it sounds to me that you want to add into these buckets is city resources for that eviction prevention stabilization. [1:45:19] Speaker D (unidentified): I think I heard you sort of mentioned education with the public on the resources we have. Out. I had in my own notes, like networking, trying to make sure that like, we have a good, like resource master list that has been distributed to people who are at risk, you know, that we can just sort of disseminate as widely as we can, with programs that are still extant. You know, that's the only thing that I can kind of think of is like, you know, because like you said before like some of the stuff the city doesn't directly like use and [1:46:00] Speaker A (unidentified): but I think you've made an important point to you that we may not have sort of jurisdiction over those resources but we have a responsibility to make sure that we're sharing up-to-date relevant information to expedite people being able to reach those resources so [1:46:22] Speaker F (unidentified): it sounds like we have a plan ish to get through anything else that we need from city staff for next week's [1:46:30] Speaker E (unidentified): meeting everyone can think of so [1:46:35] Speaker F (unidentified): we will come back with a we'll call it a draft of the prevention section of the strategic plan next I think I said next week right next meeting not next week because next week but it was next week I think I have a different board meeting here we will go through that document and start fine-tuning and work through that any other items that we need to cover that are not on the agenda or need to be discussed I [1:47:06] Speaker A (unidentified): guess the other update that I'll just quickly add is I've not been made aware of yet but you will have a counselor chair a counselor representative here those decisions around committees is just being made so probably at the next meeting there'll be somebody assigned to the committee [1:47:22] Speaker F (unidentified): Thank you thank you with that we will adjourn tonight's meeting of the advisory committee on homelessness thank you everybody So when I was sleeping,