Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Public commenter (Jackie Smallwood): Sources on deck for the same one percent of Bangor's population, the other 99 percent expected to cover it all with our tax dollars. When these grand ideas run out of money, the next grant falls short, or simply fails, slow down Bangor. No more rash decisions. We need a long five term, five year at least long-term plan, well thought out before any more money is wasted. Thank you. Thank
[0:25] Susan Hawes: you. Who's
Consent Agenda
Unfinished Business
[0:37] Susan Hawes: that, Furrow, resident of Bangor. I have a request that an item get moved from the consent agenda to unfinished business. It's item number 26-246. Oh wait, no, sorry, 26-247, 26-247, if that could get moved to unfinished business. Point of order, she said unfinished business. Yes, that would
[1:05] Speaker D (unidentified): have to be a request made by a counselor. Yeah, I'll make the request for Mrs. Furrow. Thank you
[1:14] Susan Hawes: to unfinished business. You want yes and
New Business
[1:22] Speaker D (unidentified): let the notes, but it goes to new business, new business.
[1:27] Joseph Leonard: Okay and
[1:30] Susan Hawes: that was presented by Councilor Mallar. Yes, poor Mrs. Pearl. Okay, thank you. Thanks. Welcome. Is that the one you, anybody else, person
[2:00] Carolyn Fish: who's registered to give online public comment? Is not
[2:03] Susan Hawes: online. It's not online. Okay, seeing no others, I guess we, no one else is approaching, so we will close the public comment period at 7:22. Consent agenda, please. Minutes of Bangor
[2:24] Lisa Goodwin: City Council regular meeting of July 27, 2026, Government Operations Committee meetings of January 5th, 2026, February 2nd, 2026, and February 18th, 2026, and Business and Economic Development Committee meetings of June 1st, 2026, June 15th, 2026, and July 6, 2026. 26-246, order authorizing the sale of property located at 10 Hersey Avenue to Hershey Rental LLC in the amount of fifteen $15,000. 26-248, order authorizing the city manager to execute a construction contract with Sergeant Corporation for the Pajajuat sewer I-95 crossing project. 26-249, order authorizing the city manager to execute a sole source contract with Coastal Traffic Inc. for Myovision cameras for Bangor traffic signal upgrades. 26-250, order authorizing the city manager to execute a collective bargaining agreement. Agreement between the City of Bangor and Bangor Federation of Public Employees Local 6071 representing the fleet services and ground support equipment employees.
[3:32] Susan Hawes: Thank you. Is there a motion?
[3:35] Joseph Leonard: I make a motion on the consent agenda. Second.
[3:39] Susan Hawes: The consent agenda has been moved and seconded. If there is no further requests or discussions, it will have passage referrals.
[3:52] Lisa Goodwin: To committee and first reading. 26-251, order authorizing issuance of four million four hundred and fifty five thousand dollars of the city's general obligation bonds to finance upgrades and improvements to the Kmart pump station and other sewer separation CSO infrastructure improvements and a tax levy therefore. First reading and referral to finance committee on August 17th, 2026. 26-252, order authorizing a loan in the amount of six million five hundred and seventy five thousand from the Maine Municipal Bond Bank State revolving fund to finance replacement of the Perry Road pump station and other sewer separation CSO infrastructure improvements and a tax levy therefore. First reading and referral to finance Committee on August 17, 2026. 26-253, resolve accepting and appropriating up to $300,000 from Maine Housing with $126,000 match from Bangor Opioid Settlement unspent funds to support Project HOPE. First reading and referral to Government Operations Committee meeting on August 17, 2026.
[5:01] Joseph Leonard: Move these items be referred.
[5:05] Susan Hawes: Is there a second? Second. Second. Okay. The items have been moved and seconded. These will be referred to committee without rejections.
[5:18] Lisa Goodwin: Unfinished business. Public hearing 26-242, order authorizing the execution of a credit enhancement agreement with Bangor Housing Development Corporation for a portion of the property addressed at 205 Corporate Drive. Councilor Leonard. Thank you, Madam Clerk. This
[5:34] Joseph Leonard: order authorizes the execution of a credit enhancement agreement with Bangor Housing Development Corporation for a portion of the property addressed at 205 Corporate Drive. The Bangor Housing Development Corporation has an option to purchase from the City of Bangor the noted property for the purpose of constructing 30 units of supportive housing. This district will capture the added value to the property for investment back into the property as the City may choose. This credit enhancement agreement proposed to return 75% of the real estate taxes paid on the subject property contained in the proposed TIF district for a period of 30 years. Under the requirements of the city policy, this credit enhancement agreement meets the general principles to encourage new affordable housing investment. It also in it is also in keeping with the 2022 comprehensive plan for affordable housing in support of housing creation as well as the council's priorities for the housing development. Madam chair, I make a motion to open the public
[6:32] Susan Hawes: Hearing second it is removed and seconded to open the public hearing. Public hearing is open, Mike.
[6:45] Public commenter (Mike Furrow): furrow resident of Bangor homeowner I do not stand to gain anything financially from speaking tonight I want to talk about the 30 efficiency apartments Yellen Pines that I'm totally against make no mistake about it there's no confusion about any of the public comments who have voiced disapproval for this project yellow pines the claim is a path forward to get homeless in the department not to resolve drug addiction and mental illness they want to take 30 of the hardest to house individuals i.e criminals with hundreds of convictions and long-term homeless, to be housed first, basically individuals who have no hope of recovery. Bangor Housing Authority, a non-profit, profits from the homeless industrial complex. It was stated that these 30 efficiency apartments are not furnished. That fundraising or possible city funds to raise money to furnish these approximately $400,000 apartments. They want Pebble Street out of Portland to assist with the housing of 30 worst offenders first. What could possibly go wrong with this? Citizens of Bangor, your taxes are paying for this. What if these individuals don't want to be housed that they're being offered? Then there's a moot point. Apparently, no one has thought through this, or they just don't care. Pebble State will have two or three staffers there all day long, that is a 24 hour day, three shifts, which is approximately 20 full-time staffers. What is their payroll? I say Dorothy Dicks is the answer. Again, let's talk about the damage that has been done by the homeless in Bangor. Porta potties, 175. Soap dispensers ripped off the wall, seven. Towel dispensers ripped off the wall, five. Steel doors destroyed, I don't know how that happened. A cost of over $200,000. The Ramada Inn, destruction of approximately $2 million. Trash cleanup on the property where they want to put the construction, approximately $20,000, not to mention all the other trash pickups due to the homeless of another estimated $20,000 to $40,000 elsewhere in the Bangor area. And some of these have not even been cleaned up yet, so the cost is still growing. It was stated the expectations that almost none of these individuals will return to work or be viable citizens. This project, as stated, will instill dignity to those individuals in the Yellen Pine project. What about the compassion for the taxpayers? The claim is those individuals will not be visible to any public anymore. What does that mean? You're not going to let them out? Is this the best practice? Are you kidding me? Who is believing this other than the nonprofits that benefit from this type of ludicrous action? The statements that we all made from reference homeless individuals with the most criminal records and drug addictions with 100s of arrests are a substantial cost to Bangor. What about the $11 million on the 30 efficiency apartments that's going to be spent? Who is believing this rhetoric? An example was provided with an individual with 300 police interactions a year. This is in Portland. He was moved to an existing home for good projects that went down to six calls. No specific length of time.
[10:01] Susan Hawes: Who's that Furrow resident of Bangor? My opinions are my own and not that of any committee that I am on. So I'm finishing what Mike Furrow wrote. An example was provided with an individual 300. Okay, he was moved into an existing home for good project that went down to six calls. No specific specified length of time. Was that a week, a month, a state? I don't know. A statement was made reference to the homeless. One thing that happens is they are kicked out within three to three months or six months. Because they cannot follow the rules. So what has changed? If there are no rules, no one will be evicted. Is that what the truth is? The Pebble Street made in a statement that this housing is permanent. The success rate was eighty-eight percent. Out of the eighty-five homeless over three years stayed in housing, twelve percent go back to homeless. If that, if what she stated is correct, there is a 0% success rate to return these individuals back to the community. She also stated that there was a high level of mental illness. There we go, Dorothea Dix is the answer. Why work if everything is given to you and giving taxpayer funded drug use with no rules to follow? The goal is for homeless person to maintain living in the 400,000 apartments permanently. Taxpayer funding, permanent housing. Housing. Preble Street has been around for 25 years. The homeless crisis is increasing in Portland and spreading to Bangor. No reported success because it does not exist. Nonprofits are growing and demanding more tax dollars. If Preble Street is the best practices, why have we not seen a decrease in homelessness? Here we go with the vouchers for Bangor Housing Authority, which means we pay almost 100% of them living in an approximately $400,000 dollar apartment they are buying the land extremely cheap almost free four acres for approximately a hundred thousand dollars this is prime land by the airport if developed properly could be worth ten times that amount this is a non-profit they will not generate any money just use taxpayers money so what happened to the old pine tree in that Teresa's place that was renovated and who knows what that cost the taxpayers it opened a year ago how many people are living there this is a low barrier housing 41 small apartments which will provide stable housing if no one's talking about Teresa's place then it's probably a failure what about Dorothea Dix what can which can house approximately 1,800 patients let's put that money in Dorothea Dix which is equipped to handle individuals they want 75% of their taxes back so they can borrow more money taxpayers money It was stated that there's a lot of PFAS. I was not aware the soil study was done. When and by whom? We are not growing food there. It is a building construction with poured concrete. This is a bad idea, just like the porta potties, probably for good reason because of the repair costs. Good question if they'll be honest about their repair, if they could be honest about the repair costs. Thank you. Thank you, Hillary
[13:18] Public commenter (Simmons): Simmons, resident, Bangor. I am asking you not to approve the proposed 75, 30-year tax increment financing and credit enhancement agreement for Yell and Puns tonight, Pines tonight. I want to be clear, this is not about opposing affordable housing or helping people experiencing homelessness. This is about fiscal responsibility and whether Bangor should make a 30-year financial commitment without first providing taxpayers with a complete financial picture. The memorandum before in the workshop tells us that the applicant originally requested 100 percent of the tax increments, and the staff is recommending 75 percent for 30 years. Those numbers should be clearly presented before this council makes a commitment lasting three decades. I also took the time to look at Logan Place in Portland because it is specifically stated in the information provided to the Council. Logan Place does not appear, it does appear to have been successful, but the studies reported significant reductions in shelter use, police contacts, jail stays, ambulance uses in emergency health care after people are placed into permanent supportive housing, but there is an extremely important part of the comparison that was left out. According to the City of Portland's own housing information, Logan's Place received 435,000 in federal home funding and zero dollars in TIF assistance. That's zero. So if Logan Place is being represented as an example of why Bangor should support Yellen Pines, then someone should explain why the success of Logan Place demonstrates that Bangor needs to return 75% of the tax increments for 30 years. In fact, Logan's Place may demonstrate just the opposite. Successful supportive housing does not automatically require a 30 year TIF agreement. So Bangor should also be asking, who guarantees these services at Yellen Pines? Who pays for them? Are those services guaranteed for the entire 30 years Bangor would be providing this financial benefit? it and what happens if the state or federal funding disappears if bangor tax payers are being asked to make a 30-year commitment based partially on the success of another housing first project then we should make sure the conditions that made that project successful actually exist here i'm not asking the council to reject yellow pines i'm asking you to table this agreement until the public receives a complete financial analysis showing the annual cost the estimated 30-year value the complete finance financing package and the remaining funding gaps and exactly why 75 percent for 30 years is necessary. Supporting housing and protecting Bangor taxpayers is not mutually exclusive. 30 years is a long time. Thank you I'm
[16:34] Public commenter (Emily Ellis): Emily Ellis, a Bangor resident. I'm a realtor and I'm an advocate for housing. I would like to address the plan for Yellen Pines project. It consists of 30 units of housing for the homeless. Here's what we know. The Department of Housing and Urban Development, HUD, has recently determined that until the population secures services, it doesn't work to simply provide housing. From a numbers perspective in Bangor, Maine, in the last six months, 175 residential homes have sold. The average sale price was just shy of $318,000, but the median sales price was $289,000. That means 87 homes sold for less than $289,000 and 87 sold above. These are working people, professionals, retirees, but half of that buying population paid less than $289,000 for their entire home. Those homes averaged $1,665 for square footage, or $195 per square foot. Yellen Pines was designed for the homeless by an architect. An architect typically takes 10 to 15% of the cost of a project. There are requirements for this project that are, in my opinion, overkill. My husband will speak to those. This project equates to three hundred seventy three thousand dollars for 400 square feet. That's nine hundred thirty two dollars per square foot, or seven hundred thirty seven dollars more per square foot than the average Bangor buyer paid. The facts are we already know what's going to happen based on the recent removal of the metal public toilets and encampments. It seems clear that offering housing isn't the answer to our current dilemma, nor is throwing money at it without any real accountability or actual services. It seems dead wrong from my perspective that the bank or taxpayers are on the hook for something that costs more than most of us would ever pay for our own housing, after picking up the slack for the money the state mandates but doesn't reimburse the city. And to add insult to injury, we're actually trying to fast track away for this project to get out of paying taxes knowing full well the demand of the municipal services. There is a difference between affordable housing and subsidize housing. Unless and until we are compassionate enough to care that the people we have been enabling need some tough loving, we won't move the needle. Pun intended. I
[19:49] Public commenter (Mike): Guess I'd be the husband. I'm Mike, I live in Bangor. My father had a saying, eat it's all over but the crying. I hope this isn't the case with this project. I did, I got 84 pages, site plan, architect, building materials, groundwork, electrical, plumbing, heating, landscaping. Maximum amount of money I could come up with was 6.5 to 1 million dollars. And that's sticking a million dollars straight in my pocket. I did some more research on other projects. Not quite as nice as this. There aren't too many projects like this that have solid surface, countertops, tile, electric fireplace, you know, in the entrance area. Moncton, New Brunswick, 2023, believe it or not. They did 30 units for homeless people. The cost was 320,000. That was 2023. They did 30 more recently, 3.5 million dollars. Atlanta, Georgia, 40 units, four million dollars. I said, well, Atlanta, the weather's totally different than state of Maine, obviously. That's why I checked on Canada projects, Canadian projects. Fredericton did 30 units for $3 million. St. John, 40 units for 3.5. My point is 11.2 million plus asking for more. I am aware of the environmental study that was done. I have no idea why you would do that on a project like this. There is no private water, it's all public water and sewer. To me that part was probably a waste of money anyway. Like my father's saying went, I hope this isn't all over but the crying, because I appeared to be doing a little bit of crying myself. Thank
[22:13] Susan Hawes: you. Good
[22:23] Public commenter (Jennifer Lowler): evening. My name is Jennifer Lowler and I work as the hub coordinator in homeless services and I'm based here in Bangor. I'm here tonight to express my support for the TIF for the Bangor Housing Authority's Home for Good project. In my past role, I worked about 20 years of experience in the field, in most recent years with people experiencing homelessness, including outreach. In my current role, I work with providers around housing resources and coordination, as well as with data that helps us understand what we are seeing within the homeless response system. One of the things that stands out in the data is just how long some people are experiencing homelessness. For individuals experiencing chronic homelessness who were housed in the month of June, the average time they were homeless was 1,819 days. That's almost five years of homelessness. I think that number is important when we talk about what Bangor is experiencing, particularly with unsheltered homelessness. Teams on the ground are doing great work, engaging people, building trust, connecting them to services and housing. But ultimately there must be housing to move people into, especially housing that meets their needs. When someone gets housed after years experiencing homelessness, it's a huge accomplishment. But for some, the challenges don't end there. We see individuals move into housing and then sometimes return to homelessness because they don't have the ongoing support they need to be successful. Having an apartment doesn't automatically resolve the barriers someone faced before they were housed. When someone loses their housing, it affects more than that individual. For the individual, it means experiencing homelessness again and having to start over, often with additional barriers added on like evictions. It also affects Bangor's broader response to homelessness. When people have the tools to remain housed, it allows shelters, outreach teams, and other providers to focus their limited resources on those who are still experiencing homelessness. Our homeless response system is already so stretched thin. That's why supportive housing is so important. It recognizes that for some people, housing alone isn't enough. Home for Good pairs permanent housing with ongoing support that can give someone the foundation to build from. It gives people the opportunity to work on their challenges, build stability without having to worry if they have a safe place to sleep at night. For Bangor, these 30 units give us the opportunity to move people from unsheltered and sheltered homelessness into permanent housing with support already built in. That's important not only to the people who will have the housing that meets their needs, but for the City of Bangor as we continue to try to find effective and lasting ways to address unsheltered homelessness. And that's why I support the TIF for Home for Good, and I hope the Council will as well. Thank you.
[25:21] Public commenter (Jackie Smallwood): My name is Jackie Smallwood. I'm a resident and I'm asking you to not vote to move forward with this TIF and tax credit package tonight. I listened carefully to the presentation that Mike gave at last week's subcommittee meeting and I learned two very important things. First, there is no waiting list for these units. This is a high security coordinated entry, permanent housing development for the chronically homeless, not transitional housing. housing. Units go to the most hardened, most challenged individuals needing 24-7 service. Few will ever leave. Some will end up in assisted living, some may die there, and many carry permanent mental illness from years of hard drug use. Second, ongoing services at Yellen Pines are funded by state DHHS through Maine's Housing First Fund, financed by the state's real estate transfer tax under Title 22, Section 20-A, not federal HUD money. At this stage, sidestepping HUD's attempt to roll back housing first, which has been deemed a disaster. While some may view this project's funding as shrewd, it is hardly risk free. The success of this model depends on Maine's housing first law staying exactly as it is. It hasn't stayed still. The legislature already changed this funds financing formula once in 2025 and can change it again or rewrite the program itself. Maine has an open governor's race this year. This program reflects this current administration's priorities and those priorities may not survive a change in leadership. Here is the risk to Bangor. If this council gives up 75% of this property's tax revenue for 30 years, that commitment does not reopen if the state's funding underneath it shrinks or disappears. The city's obligation is locked in for three decades. The states is not supporting this credit enhancement agreement or TIF district does not mean we are turning our back on this crisis. The safety and cost overrun possibilities are very real risks. Slowing down to study a model that hands permanent housing with no exit plan to our most medically and psychiatrically complex residents is being smart. These individuals absolutely need help. Real medical and psychiatric treatment or a brand new apartment with wraparound services needed for to even function. I respectfully ask that each council member takes time and studies this proposal seriously. Ask more questions. Revisit this after the November election. Bangor has to stop making rash decisions because the implication of that this proposal could have on Bangor for the next 30 years are very real. Thank you. Thank you.
[28:12] Public commenter (Adam Baker): Adam Baker, proud Bangor resident, and any words that I say are my own and do not reflect any committee I'm a part of. I support this house, this housing initiative. I, it, I just lose my mind when we keep talking about housing and that it was, that it's been a priority for the council since this year, and that we keep stepping over each other and fumbling. Oh, here's housing when it's here and we don't do something, and we've been doing nothing the past few years when it's been the past few councils. So thank you counselor leonard for addressing that we either give them housing or we just continue to do nothing and i failed to recognize that we don't do anything that we can't do anything. And I give my full support to this. Nobody can get their life back on track if they don't have a roof over their head. They need support with mental health and drug addiction and whatever services they need. And I highly encourage you to support this. So
[29:25] Susan Hawes: Thank you. Thank you.
[29:35] Public commenter (Justin Russell): Evening. My name is Justin Russell. I'm a citizen of Bangor. i just want to raise one point someone mentioned that dorothea dicks had a capacity of 1800 beds i'm not sure where that figure comes from the recent figures i have found from the state of maine says there are 67 operational beds there and if you look at the budget there was a 2011 report said that dorothea dicks's budget was 28.4 million so if you look at 67 beds there that works out to 443 000 per bed per year and that's every year a recurring cost not a one-time cost and in 2026 it looks like the state budget is at least 26.5 million for that, which works out to 396,000 per bed. So any action costs money. I just want to keep that in mind, that even if we go a different direction, it's still going to cost taxpayers money. So thank you. Thank you.
[30:34] Carolyn Fish: Councillor Haas, we have one person online who wants to comment on this. Okay, Mr. Saunders, you're
[30:42] Public commenter (Chris Saunders): unmuted. Thank you very much. Can you hear me? Yes, go ahead, Mr. Saunders. Thank you. My name is Chris Saunders, and I'm the Vice President of Operations at Preble Street, and I am not a resident of Bangor. Thank you for considering Bangor Housing Authority's request for a TIF to support Yellen Pines, a home for good project. This project is designed to provide an immediate housing solution for 30 people experiencing chronic homelessness in Bangor, 30 people who have been homeless time and again, and have complex needs and disabilities that make maintaining housing difficult. This model has been proven to be the most effective long term solution to resolving chronic homelessness and keeping people housed and off the streets. Preble Street has successfully operated three similar projects in Portland, the oldest of which opened over 20 years ago. Our community knows that projects like this one not only help someone find a home, they provide them with 24-7 support they need to stay in that home and not return to homelessness, moving people from chronic homelessness to stable permanent housing benefits both the individual and the Bangor community. We certainly understand that the Council must take into account the fiscal impact of a TIF to support this project. Housing combined with the supportive services that keep people housed and help them connect with healthcare, substance use, and mental health treatment, education, employment, and more, saves taxpayer dollars by reducing emergency costs. To account properly for the community benefits of Home for Good programs, combining housing and supportive services, I want to share with you the impact of Logan Place opening in Portland 20 years ago, similarly housing 30 of its most chronically homeless residents. In the first year of operation, the system of care spent $23,328 less on its residents than it did the prior year. Translating that to present day, that's a savings of over $40,000. With stable housing and social work support, there was an 88% decrease in jail nights from Logan Place residents in its first year of operations. Emergency services also witnessed a significant drop in demand, with ambulance and emergency calls for these individuals dropping by 66% and police contacts dropping by 80%. And most importantly,, each apartment represents a permanent home for a resident who often has spent years or even decades without this basic human need. The state-funded Home for Good program is providing Bangor with a key opportunity to dramatically reduce homelessness in this community. A TIF would provide critical additional funding to ensure this project will be successful, and I think it's important to say that we're not asking for any other direct support from the City of Bangor. Therefore, approving this TIF is a highly cost-effective way for the City to invest in a program that will have a lasting impact in reducing costs and moving people off the streets and out of encampments. We know how high a priority this has been for this council and Bangor residents, and so we hope you will support this project. Thank you thank
[33:26] Susan Hawes: you Madam
[33:31] Joseph Leonard: chair. Seeing no one else approach, I would move to oh wait
[33:38] Public commenter (Mike Myatt): please come forward Mike my at Bangor housing. First of all just want to thank all of you for all the time that you put into this questions. We've done multiple workshops and you've all I know have put a lot of time into it, asked a lot of hard questions, and hopefully we've answered at least many of your questions. One thing I just wanted to say is regardless if Yellen Pines goes forward tonight or not, we're still going to have a homelessness issue and problem here in Bangor, and I think what Yellen Pines provides is not the end-all solution. You've tasked that with the homeless advisory council to give you long-term solutions, but Yellen Pines will make an impact today or when it opens. We're not asking for capital dollars, we are asking for very precious taxpayer dollars, but we feel that investment from the city and Yellen Pines will come back in savings for the municipality. That's police calls, that's that's first responder interactions, that's unpaid medical bills, that's time in jail, that's all those things that add up, and I think what we did find with the Logan Place study, albeit those numbers were 20 years ago, that worked. We're not doing the HUD failed housing first model, this is Home for Good because it does have the wraparound services. Those services yes are provided by the state, and I think as Miss Smallwood said, legislatures can change, governors can change, all those things can change, but what we do know is that the legislature and republican and democratic governors have supported Logan Place for the last 20 years, so that will work, it can work, and now I think it's up to council to make the hard decision. If we don't get the TIF, our project cannot move forward. So I urge you to really think about it and I hope that you'll support our project.
[35:42] Joseph Leonard: Last call. Seeing no one approach, Madam Chair, I would move to close the public comment. Second.
[35:52] Susan Hawes: Okay, it's been moved and seconded to close the public hearing. Seeing no further discussion, public hearing is closed.
[36:00] Public commenter (Mike): Madam
[36:05] Daniel Carson: Chair, I wish to move to amend by substitution this Order 26-242, the final paragraph of which currently reads, begins, The City Manager or her designee is hereby authorized to execute a credit enhancement agreement. Agreement my motion is to amend this first line to state the city manager or her designee is hereby authorized to execute and place conditions upon a credit enhancement agreement I would second that
[36:44] Susan Hawes: It's been moved and seconded to amend order 26242 by substitution that was just read by Councillor Carson any discussion okay seeing no discussion we'll do a roll
[37:09] Lisa Goodwin: Call vote and rather do the substitution Councillor Beck no Councillor Carson yes Councillor Deane yes Councillor Faloon yes Councillor Fish yes Councillor Leonard Yes. Councilor Mallar? Yes. Councilor Walker? Yes. Councilor Haas? Yes. Eight yes, one no.
[37:36] Susan Hawes: Okay, eight yes, one no. Order 26242, the amendment, the proposed amendment has passage.
[37:56] Joseph Leonard: I would move passage of the amended order 26-242 second okay it's been moved and seconded
[38:06] Susan Hawes: To pass the amended order we could do a roll call vote is there do you want to discuss
[38:17] Wayne Mallar: Yes I'd like some discussion I don't think I'll ever the questions that we've asked either earlier tonight in the previous meeting here or in past meetings have been answered yet and I feel uncomfortable voting other than in the negative for this at this point in time okay
[38:39] Carolyn Fish: Council Fish I cannot vote for this tonight either I think we have a lot of questions And as I've expressed earlier, to me the elephant in the room is that it's not true that we have not worked and provided a great deal of housing, at least in my last two or three years. We've worked with great partners with Bangor Housing that are part of this project and Maine State Housing. And there's been a lot of recent housing that has opened up in Bangor. And with the city we've had the Granville the Grandview project in Moulton Place and a number of a lot of units in the last year or two not to mention what our developers some of who are here in the audience have provided to me I am tired of passing and voting yes on taxpayers backs for projects like this when we do not have a system of filtering who are our Bangor residents that need to help our unhoused people that are living on the street and it's not living they need help in they every day Suffer, it's an inhumane way to live, and yet we have not been able to figure out how to identify just who are these people that are our responsibility. People come up and say, well, once they're their responsibility. We do not have endless monies to take care of everybody else's. So now we want 30 units, which I am all for, wraparound services to provide 24-7 care with, I feel, providers that have a good track record, and I would love to partner with them, but not at the cost of over 30 years, which what I feel for 75 percent TIF tax back equates to millions of dollars. Millions of dollars that are not to the benefit of our Bangor citizens and to 30 individuals of which no one can guarantee are going to be our Bangor citizens. So until we figure out how to stop the influx of 40 or 50 or 60 new people arriving every month, what would this project for 30 or project for 100 do when we cannot figure out how to create boundaries and consequences. So I am not in favor of this because I don't know what those two numbers are. I want to know what that tax rate is. What happens if this property and then there is Phase 2 or Phase 3? So now that $20 million over 30 years, does that become $40 million, $60 million that our taxpayers don't have the benefit of? And then what happens with the land if they sell it? I want to see the state of Maine. I want to see our local communities. I want to see our other service providers like Maine Housing and Bangor Housing that have come here today come to the table and help us come up with more information. I want to know the financial data. I want to know what the future circumstances and the ripple effect on the city are going to be. So I'm not voting yes on any more of these projects until we get a handle on bringing the other partners to the table to take on some of the responsibility other than our taxpayers. So I'm not for it.
[42:14] Susan Faloon: Councilor Sloan. I see this as an investment in our community. I keep hearing, and I said this earlier during our workshop, if anyone was here I apologize for repeating it, but it this is not just an investment in 30 people, this is an investment in our entire community, and it's going to take a multi-pronged approach, and this has proven successful in other communities, and other communities had made the investment through these TIF agreements as well as contributing funds, and we're not even being asked to contribute funds outside this TIF agreement, so I think That it will be a benefit to everyone in Bangor, and it will get 30 of the hardest to house people off the streets. And whether or not they are originally from Bangor, we don't know that. We've heard repeatedly that we don't know that. But this isn't going to prevent people, are still going to come to Bangor regardless. That is a problem that we do need to address, but they're still going to come either way, and we have to start somewhere. And I think this is a really good place to start and a really good investment in our community. So I am in favor of it. I
[43:33] Michael Beck: think this is another case of, well, you got a problem with homelessness, we got to solve it, but not like that. Got a problem with needles and drugs, got to solve it, but not like that. You need a problem with criminals and all that coming to our community, gotta solve it, but not like that. We got to do something that the cost of an action costs way more. And I think that I've heard enough about the savings to the city. We're not having to invest any additional money into this. This is a tiff. So, yeah, it would be nice to have that seventy five percent taxes. But who's going to pay it? Because if we say no to this, that probably sits dormant. It's been sitting dormant for how long? I mean, there's no projects waiting in the wings of dying for that land with something that's going to move the city forward. So I'm absolutely in favor of this, and it's time we move it forward. So count me as a yes. A
[44:32] Susan Hawes: question
[44:38] Daniel Carson: related to the motion that we had just passed to amend by substitution, there were a number of issues that various counselors had raised that precipitated me wanting to do that. And I just am wondering if we would have the opportunity after conditions were applied to that agreement to review what those were and to make sure that the things that we had requested were in there.
[45:13] Speaker D (unidentified): The motion to amend by substitution authorized the city manager to place conditions on the credit enhancement agreement. It didn't specify those conditions. So I would suggest having a meeting with the city manager to discuss the conditions. But this, if this were passed, it would again, it would authorize the conditions that the city manager can place into the agreement, but it doesn't specify what those conditions are. I didn't specify in my motion because there were
[45:59] Daniel Carson: too many for me to remember. Your
[46:09] Susan Hawes: pleasure. Okay. [Public commenter (Mike): I] think we're ready to order 26242 as a men as amended with substitution. We're ready for a vote. Councillor Beck.
[46:37] Lisa Goodwin: Yes, Councillor Carson. Yes, Councillor Deane. Yes, Councillor Faloon. Yes, Council of Fish? No. Councillor Leonard? Yes. Councillor Maler? No. Councillor Walker? Yes. Councillor Haas? No. Six yes, three no.
[47:04] Susan Hawes: Order 26242, six yes, two no. The order does have passage as amended by substitution. Yeah. Yeah. Six yes, three no. Yeah. What did I say, two no? I can't read my own writing. Okay. Okay, next item.
[47:26] Lisa Goodwin: Public hearing 26-243 order authorizing the creation of a tax increment financing district for affordable housing for a portion of property addressed at 205 Corporate Drive with Bangor Housing Development Corporation, Council of Falloon.
[47:41] Susan Faloon: Thank you, Madam Clerk. Clerk. This order authorizes the city manager or designee to file the creation of a tax increment financing district for affordable housing for a portion of a property addressed at 205 Corporate Drive with Bangor Housing Development Corporation. The Bangor Housing Development Corporation has an option to purchase from the city of Bangor the noted property for the purchase of constructing 30 units of supportive housing. This district will capture the added value to the property for investment back into the property as the city may choose under the requirements of the city policy. This district meets the general principles to encourage new affordable housing investment. It is also in keeping with the 2022 comprehensive plan for affordable housing in support of housing creation as well as the council's priorities for housing development. Madam Chair, I move that we open the public hearing for order number 26-243. Second.
[48:42] Susan Hawes: It has been moved and seconded to open the public hearing for order 26243. Public hearing is open. My name's Suzette Furrow. I'm a resident of Bangor. The opinions I express are my own and not those of any committee I am part of. I would just like to know this whole TIF district that we're trying to establish here. I know Hope House is up in this area too and nobody talks about this, but Council Leonard, you should be pretty passionate about this. I know that the Hope House allows pedophiles to be housed there. I stand against pedophilia like you do. Now are any of these, nobody has said, I've listened. To the committee meetings, is Yellen Pines going to allow pedophiles? Does Theresa Place allow pedophiles? Are we creating a district of lawlessness and abuse of children? That's what I would like to know. But no one has discussed that. We've discussed just like people with serious criminal records, what type of criminal records. And as Councillor Fish said, I'm tired of hearing in these committee meetings, well, we don't know where they come from. It's really hard to know. I believe if you got the detectives involved, it would take them five minutes to find out. I mean, we live in a surveillance state now. I don't know how that could possibly be that we don't know, can't account for anybody. So I don't agree with that. And I would like to know if they are allowing pedophiles and if this is a whole going to be a whole area you know Bob Carlson the fake reverend was part of the establishment of the Hope House and his goal was to expand that so I have concerns about that thank you thank you Hillary
[50:34] Public commenter (Simmons): Simmons resident Bangor I just would like to know how many people on the council pay taxes in the city of Bangor how many of you are actually paying taxes here in the city okay how many so yes people need help people need assistance but you also have to give people the ability to achieve you have to have them want to want something if we took a survey on the homeless community you're going to probably get 80 percent of the homeless community want to be homeless because they don't want to follow the law. We have rules. If you don't want to follow the law or the rules, that's why they're homeless. Is at Yellen's Pines going to be drug-free? Is it going to be a free injectable place? Are we going to be handing out needles hand over hand are we encouraging the homeless the drug addiction all of that are we really solving the problem or are you putting a band-aid on it for half of the council up there to sit and feel good about yourselves or are you looking for advancements on all of your nonprofits that you have affiliations with that's the question we need to start thinking what is the best for all the citizens of the city of Bangor what about the elderly population you're going to be taxing them out of their houses they're not going to be able to afford housing so do you have homeless housing for the elderly do you have the ability to house them let's sit and think about it thank you
[52:34] Public commenter (Mike Furrow): Mike Burrow, resident of Bangor. Here's the question I have. So the TIF right now is only for downtown. So now we're creating another new area that we want the TIF to apply. Is that going to apply to the Hope House? We know you want to apply to Yellen Pines. But what about Teresa's place? So we already have places up there. I mean, I can just see this thing just expanding like crazy. We only have 31,000 people in Bangor. I mean, how much money do you want to throw at these things? And the other thing, the other unanswered question is, you know, we talked about Portland. How much destruction is being caused by those structures they have? They house the worst of the homeless, the criminal records, the homeless spend the longest. I mean, how much destruction? I never heard once mentioned how much money they had to re-renovate places. That, I think, is very important. That's something we should look into, the destruction of these places. Although we build them, they're very nice, almost 400,000, there's going to be destruction. I mentioned the porta-potties. I mentioned the trash. I mentioned Ramada Inn. It's obvious. I mean, it's blatantly obvious. So that's something we've got to consider. How much money is this going to cost us? Well, I'm telling you right now I spoke against supportive bodies. This is going to be the same thing. They're going to be destroyed. And what if somebody burns them down, burns the whole thing down, then everybody's out. We're out all that money. We're going to rebuild it. There's a lot of problems that need to be thought through. Thank you very much. Thank you. I
[54:19] Public commenter (Mike Myatt): Mike Myatt again, Bangor Housing. We would not be housing pedophiles at Yellen Pines, Madam
[54:34] Susan Faloon: Chair. I move that we close the public hearing for order
[54:37] Susan Hawes: number 26-243. Second. It's been moved and seconded. Close public hearing for order 26-243. It does
[54:47] Susan Faloon: it is closed. Madam Chair, I move passage of order number 26-243. Second. Order
[54:59] Susan Hawes: 26243 has been moved and seconded for passage we will have a roll call vote council it back oh wait first yep go ahead
[55:13] Wayne Mallar: Bangor Housing has mentioned the fact that there'll be no pedophiles in this facility, but I think it's would be inappropriate for me not to ask the question, and I know the answer. This is a low barrier shelter, so we will have active drug and alcohol being used there. Is that correct? I believe it is a low barrier shelter. So then that's what you told us at the last meeting. Can you go to the microphone, please?
[55:58] Public commenter (Mike Myatt): Mike Myatt again, Bangor Housing. We're not building a shelter. Yeah, if someone's using, they'll be using in there. That could happen. We're not building a shelter. It's permanent
[56:08] Wayne Mallar: permanent supportive housing but you allow drugs and alcohol to be consumed on the premises is
[56:14] Public commenter (Mike Myatt): that correct if someone's using in their unit they could be doing that but the whole point of having the wraparound services is that Preble Street will be there to encourage folks to not
[56:25] Wayne Mallar: do that to encourage but not to prevent so I have issues I will be voting against the tiff thank you
[56:34] Carolyn Fish: thank you i would like to comment oh you oh yes go ahead yeah madam chair you may thank you i understand the tiff districts and how they benefit and we have one downtown and i think earlier economic director actually explained we have a couple of other districts and typically there's a benefit to an area in multiple businesses where that money comes to benefit the downtown area for various projects that can benefit multiple businesses in a broader area. I understand the reason for this TIF. They need this to make it affordable for them to provide these 30 units for these unhoused individuals. But when I look at a special TIF for a very designated area for a very specific purpose for this development, and I see the millions of dollars over 30 years, I feel that it's, in my mind, representation without taxation. And for the taxpayers that are not going to have the benefit of that 20, 30, 40 million dollars over 40 years that's taxation without representation so to me i'm trying to balance out the one or less than one percent of our population that's benefiting from a tax equation and they'll say well it costs so many dollars for these individuals to be out on the street for all the services that we're giving them but when you do the math over 30 years my math says it's 500 hundred to a million dollars per person and I'm just not comfortable with giving up the future tax benefit for the city taxpayers as a whole for 30 individuals and I will not be voting for this no
[58:42] Susan Hawes: further comments you made the motion to close everything so now we're just going to vote did yeah
[59:04] Lisa Goodwin: councillor beck yes councillor carson yes council dean yes council falloon yes council fish no council leonard yes council maller no council walker yes council haas no six yes three no six
[59:27] Susan Hawes: yes three no for the order 26243 it does have passage
[59:35] Lisa Goodwin: our next order is 26247 correct 26-247 order appointing nominees to various boards and
[59:45] Susan Deane: Committees, Councilor Deane. Thank you, Madam Clerk. This order will appoint nominees to the Board of Assessment Review, Board of Ethics, and the Advisory Committee on Housing. Vacancies were advertised and applicants were interviewed by the Personnel Committee on August 4th, 2026. The committee developed recommendations for full council consideration as noted in this order. I move
[1:00:10] Susan Hawes: passage of Council Order 26-247. Second. 26-247 has been moved and seconded. We will have our, is there any discussion further? Oh yes, go Suzette Furrow, resident of Bangor. My opinions are my own and not those of any commit, committee I'm on. I just want to comment about a couple people that are on the Advisory Committee on Housing. Michael Myatt, who spoke a couple times, I mean he hasn't said, but I know he said before in another committee meeting he's a resident of Herman. I don't really understand why we put people on these committees that don't even and live in Bangor, and he actually benefits from the homeless industrial complex. He's an empire builder. And also Janet Jonas, she sits on the Planning Board for the city, she's also on the board of Dignity First. I just think more attention should be given when we have people on these committees and their conflicts and their potential financial gain. I just wish that more consideration would be taken and more people in the community who maybe don't benefit financially from these things would apply for these committees. Thank you so order, we're ready for about, yeah, 26-247 has been moved and seconded and we will do our roll call vote.
[1:01:54] Lisa Goodwin: councillor beck yes council carson no council dean yes council falloon yes council fish no Councilor Leonard? Yes. Councilor Malheur? No. Councilor Walker? Yes. Councilor Haas? No. Five yes, four no.
[1:02:15] Susan Hawes: Five yes, four no. Order 262475, yes, four no. It does have passage. Next we have new business again, 26254. I believe we have someone to speak on this order, maybe after the, yeah, okay, all right, but there is still someone
[1:02:44] Lisa Goodwin: here correct yes okay 26-254 order authorizing the official naming of the baseball field at mansfield stadium in honor of ronald j saint pierre councillor walker thank you madam clerk
[1:02:59] Angela Walker: This order would authorize the official naming of the baseball field at Mansfield Stadium, his honor of Ronald Ron St. Pierre and his significant contribution to Bangor through countless volunteer hours and dedication. Mansfield Stadium opened in 1992 and the city and Bangor Westside Little League had an agreement for its management. Ron, together with David Mansfield, voluntarily managed the operation of Mansfield Stadium for more than 30 years. Until the end of the agreement in 2023, Ron's dedication and passion for the facility ensured that athletes from all regions of the state, country, and world had the best possible experience at Mansfield Stadium. Ron also dedicated countless volunteer hours coaching generations of youth in Bangor in local leagues, as well as teams in local, state, regional, and national tournaments. Through this unwavering commitment, he is a great example of the value and spirit of volunteer service. Madam Chair, I move passage of 26-254. Second.
[1:04:24] Susan Hawes: Order 26254 has been moved and seconded. And we do have a person approaching.
[1:04:34] Public commenter (Mike): Thank you, Tracy Ouellette, Parks and Recreation Director. Thank you for the opportunity to share with you a couple of additional comments tonight about the order you have in front of you, and thank you for considering and voting on the order tonight. I am joined by some of the Mansfield crew, I'll call it the senior management team, Mike Brooker, Adam Troy, and Seth are here with us tonight, as well as shared with you. There are two individuals that have really shepherded the gift that has been Mansfield Stadium since the tremendous gift from Stephen and Tabitha King. Those two individuals, certainly David Mansfield and the gentleman we're talking about tonight, Ron St. Pierre. As the summary that Council Walker shared with you, it really describes Ron's dedication, and the impact that he has had on youth here in the community and worldwide. The presence of these four here this evening also demonstrates the loyalty and dedication that Ron's employees and staff have had for the stadium over the years. It's quite an alumni. It's quite an alumni. I. Were it not for the attention to detail, the impact and pride that Ron has had for over 30 years at Mansfield Stadium, it truly would not be the tremendous asset that it is. As I mentioned, he has certainly shepherded this gift tremendously by permanently placing his name on that field. It will ensure that we can share his dedication and share the impact that he has had on youth here in the community, either through coaching or in his teaching at Bangor High School, so that for generations going forward, we can talk about the two gentlemen, David Mansfield and, through tonight's order, Ron St. Pierre. Thank you for the order tonight.
[1:06:45] Susan Hawes: Any other comments? It's been moved and seconded.
[1:06:51] Lisa Goodwin: we'll do our roll call please counselor beck yes counselor carson yes counselor dean yes that's the balloon yes that's what fish yes that's the leonard yes that's the mallor yes that's the walker yes that's the haas yes nine yes zero no order
[1:07:13] Susan Hawes: Two six two five four 4, 9, yes, sir, or no, it does have passage.
[1:07:20] Lisa Goodwin: Next order. 26-255, order authorizing the city manager's appointment of Eric Pelletier as fire chief.
[1:07:28] Joseph Leonard: Councilor Leonard. Thank you, Madam Clerk. This order will authorize the city manager's appointment of Eric Pelletier as fire chief and the execution of an employment agreement. Mr. Pelletier joined the Bangor Fire Department as a lieutenant in 2015, was promoted to captain in 2018, and has served as the city's deputy fire chief for eight years. Prior to joining the Bangor Fire Department, Mr. Pelletier was both a captain and assistant chief in Herman. In addition to over 26 years of fire service experience, Mr. Pelletier serves as a member of the board of directors for the Penobscot County Fire Chiefs Association and vice chair for the emergency vehicle management section for the International Association of Fire Chiefs. Mr. Pelletier has an associate's degree in fire science and a bachelor of science in fire science administration. Mr. Pelletier's extensive education, experience, and leadership experience makes him an excellent choice to serve as the city's next fire chief. Ma'am Chair, I would move order 26-255. Second.
[1:08:32] Susan Hawes: order 26255 has been moved and seconded i don't see any discussion right at the moment there will
[1:08:41] Susan Faloon: be probably. Go ahead. Thank you. A lot of times when there are news articles related to city business, the comment section is not all that positive, but today that was not the case. I read the comments and they were overwhelmingly positive, and I have to agree with all of them that I couldn't be happier to support this order. So thank you. Any other comments
[1:09:10] Susan Hawes: on the order? If not, we're going to move to the roll call. Just really quickly, if you allow me,
[1:09:15] Joseph Leonard: chair my goodness it's you've been here since i 've been here as a council long before that and it's so interesting seeing how the department has evolved since my time on here from the days of chief higgins to recently with chief low and i just i've never felt more positive about the department in this current history right now, and I can't think of a better person to lead the department into the bright future that I really see for it. I am immensely proud to see you in this position. It's well-deserved, and I'm going to shut up, and let's pass this, all right?
[1:09:59] Susan Hawes: So I didn't have to tell you to shut up.
[1:10:07] Lisa Goodwin: Councilor Beck. Yes. Councilor Carson. Yes. Councilor Deane. Yes. Councilor Faloon. Yes.
[1:10:13] Carolyn Fish: Councilor Fish. Yes. Congratulations.
[1:10:17] Lisa Goodwin: Councilor Leonard. Yes. Councilor Mallar. Yes. Councilor
[1:10:20] Susan Hawes: Walker. Yes. Councilor Haas. Yes. Nine yes, zero no. Order 26255 has passage nine yes, zero no. Chief Pelletier, would you like to make any comments?
[1:11:06] Fire Chief (unidentified): I promise I'll keep this brief. Thank you, members of the council, city manager Lear, and to the men and women of our great department for allowing me to serve as your next fire chief. I am humbled and honored to accept this position and the responsibility that comes with it. I would not have this opportunity today if it wasn't for the hard work and dedication of those who served before me. Thank you, Chief Higgins, for believing in me, not once, but three times, as you gave me the opportunity to serve as Lieutenant, Captain, and as the department's first Deputy Chief. I want to thank Chief Lowe as well for helping lay the groundwork to increase our staffing and to improve our EMS capabilities. Thank you to the city staff and department heads for creating a positive work environment centered around teamwork. I want to say thank you to the many friends, colleagues, and mentors I've had the privilege to share this journey with. And most importantly, I want to thank every member of our department who gave their all every day to ensure we provide the best service possible to the citizens that we serve. I also want to thank my family for supporting me and understanding the commitment it takes to serve. I especially want to thank my wife for always being by my side and always willing to offer me advice on how to grow to be a better person, such as helping me learn that no matter how much I believe it to be true, I am not always right. Although we have been able to accomplish a lot over the years, there is still much to do. As the city continues to grow and evolve, so will our department. Safety for the public and our personnel will always be a top priority. We will work to build stronger relationships with our residents, community stakeholders, and local organizations to enhance fire prevention, education, and emergency preparedness. We will continue to invest in the professional development of our personnel, ensuring they have the tools and resources necessary to help them excel in their roles, and to ensure that we continue providing the highest level of service to those in need. I am excited to work with you in this new role to create an environment that fosters collaboration, innovation, growth, and professionalism. Thank you again for this tremendous opportunity.
[1:13:17] Susan Hawes: Congratulations. That brings us to the end of the agenda for tonight. It's nice to end on a happy note. Any closing comments from staff? And they're everywhere. Anybody? Nobody? Peanut gallery.
[1:13:57] Daniel Carson: Council Carson. Thank you, Madam Chair. I just want to thank everybody who came in, offered public comment, in particular at the two public hearings that were offered this evening. Just because something moves forward, I'm thinking about the credit enhancement agreement and the TIFF that just passed this evening, that just because they continue to be in motion does not mean that we have ignored all of the questions that came up tonight, and the conversation certainly will continue, especially around some of those important questions. So I wanted to say that, and I wanted to offer again a rousing congratulations to Chief Pelletier. Chancellor
[1:14:37] Michael Beck: Beck? You know, one of the quotes that comes up often in our old annual reports is the city is only as good as the people who see to its care, and this last item on the agenda was a great reminder of that. When you look at our new chief and the men, the women who serve under him, Bangor is absolutely well cared for.
[1:14:58] Susan Deane: Thank you, Councillor Deane. There is a continuous theme of hope and happiness with the appointment of Chief Pelletier. I wish you all the best. Congratulations. We are very proud of you, and good night, Bangor. I
[1:15:19] Joseph Leonard: remember one of the first times all the fire department troublemakers came in, and my goodness, it's such night and day. I mean, I know not everything is solved. I know we still have a lot of things that we have to work on and improve upon, but I really feel in this moment that our best days are really before us. And I see that on your faces. I see, instead of anger, I see something that's actually hopeful in a lot of ways. And I just want to say thank you so much for being here. Thank you for your service to the city. And good night, Bangor. Council Flew.
[1:16:05] Susan Faloon: Well, I don't know what else I can say other than congratulations. Congratulations. But everyone else has already said everything there is to say. Congratulations, Chief Pelletier. It's been a pleasure working with you and looking forward to working with you for many more years. Thank you to everyone who came out tonight and stuck with us for the entire meeting. And good night, Bangor.
[1:16:28] Angela Walker: I just want to say congratulations, Chief Pelletier. Oh, good night, Bangor.
[1:16:37] Wayne Mallar: I'd like to say congratulations to Chief Bellator and he gave me an opportunity to vote yes for a change. Good night, Bangor.
[1:16:47] Carolyn Fish: And I'm glad I finally got to sit next to you when you did vote yes. Congratulations, we're very pleased and look forward to working with you in the future.
[1:16:59] Susan Hawes: Good night, Bangor. Thank you all for coming, sticking with us. Congratulations, Chief. Anybody back there want to say anything? No? Okay, well then we