Limerick board extends C.I.A. Salvage license pending January hearing
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[6:43] Lick. She lived down Lake Arrowhead. She had beavers coming up and taking down trees on her property. SRCTV made her replace them. Or not SRC, Saka River Corridor made her replace those trees. That was an act of nature.
[7:01] Mhm.
[7:07] Good evening. Welcome to the Limmerick Slutton's meeting.
[7:13] We are
[7:16] holding a public hearing tonight for CIA salvage renewal of the recycler license. [7:25] at this point in time,
[7:31] I'm going to ask Stan to come up and tell us what's his findings are.
[7:46] Stan Hacker, code enforcement. before we get started with the public hearing, I'd like to do the the conflict of interest resolution. So, what that is if there's anybody that's on the board that's a voting member, which you all are at this point, that have any conflicts, whether it's personal interest or if you've been contacted
[8:10] outside of a public meeting by anyone regarding the public hearing or the status of this meeting. If anybody has, just disclose it. And then what you'll do is say I can continue to either be unbiased and make a good decision or you feel that you need to recuse.
[8:31] But so has there been any communications outside of a public meeting regarding 366 Sokus Avenue and this recycler's license?
[8:46] As far as I'm concerned,
[8:47] right? Do any of you feel that you're personally unable to make an unbiased opinion?
[8:56] No.
[8:56] Okay. So, as a board you feel comfortable. So,
[9:04] that being said, and the reason why we do this because if there was and there was ever a question of it, then that could be a avenue of overturning whatever decision the board makes. Right.
[9:20] What I want to do now is I want to summarize what the information that you have in front of you, Sean. I sent you emails of all of this stuff today as well. So, what you have in front of you is a a notice of decision. You have the summary of the public hearing and the recyclers license that's unsigned
[9:42] in case what your decision is today. D's report from the November 4th sitewalk. My summary which supports DP's summary but a little bit more on the local level. the
[10:00] plot plan dated 112 2026
[10:05] which should be your map number one. Still waters plan for the hazardous waste contingency. That's part of the sweat plan that he has. And what that map does, which is should be number two, that labels all of the hazardous materials or liquid fluid stoages and areas of stoages and the amount of
[10:29] the maximum amount of storage that those containers can hold. then you have a site plan which is dating back to 2009. This was pre before the swept plan and the retention ponds were required. So it gives you a little bit of a history from 2009 to current
[10:56] reviewing the conditions. And there you have the notice of decision. And in this part of tonight's meeting, which is starts on page three of the notice of decision, you will see the conditions of approval. That is what you're going to be basically looking at tonight
[11:16] and forming your decision after you've talked and heard from Sha Gerard and others of the public if you so choose.
[11:26] again, I just said that you need to hear from the applicant and any other testimony that's regarding this subject tonight, you do have the right to put time limits on any rebuttals.
[11:42] Once the board has heard from the applicant and testimonies from anybody else, the board will need to make a decision. Whether it's a decision that you're going to extend the temporary recyclers license, you're going to issue a recycler license for the conditions, you're going to outright issue a recycler's license,
[12:06] or you feel it's necessary to deny it. And I'll explain this in a second for the denial, then you need to reference. And when we do the final decision, whatever it may be, I will reference where it references either an ordinance or a previous conditional use of approval or a stipulation of the temporary approval that was given in June.
[12:32] Right? If you do [12:39] if you decide to deny, the applicant has a right to an appeal. Our zoning ordinance and statute doesn't allow for the zoning board of appeals to partake in this because it is a select board's decision. So, the appeal can be several different ways.
[12:59] applicant can ask for reconsideration in a new public hearing. Okay. at that point certain information can be reintroduced but only by the applicant if it will change or give validity to the applicant or change the mind of the board. The other option is
[13:20] it would have to go to a judicial review which is superior court. So those are the only avenues of recourse there. But when you make your decisions whatever it may be I will ask each and every one of you to do it solely independently.
[13:41] You need to be satisfied as I have told you before whenever you is a permit or a conditional use or a license by statute under your review authority. You're saying that they're in compliance. Now, compliance with conditions
[14:01] are okay, but if you issue it without conditions and they're not compliant, you are speaking on behalf of the whole town and accepting the liability of any issues that may occur. Whether they do or not is another subject. But if you're saying that they're completely in compliance,
[14:21] you are agreeing that there is no issues at hand that potentially could bite the town. Right? So that being said, I am going to turn it over to the board. And again, you can reference page three, which is the conditions of approval. Those are the things.
[14:41] The main criteria was the plot plan which there is a revised one I received tonight. It is not wholly completed but he has made some revisions again to try and accommodate some of the requirements of that. If you have questions, you can ask Sean again and Sean should be able to speak after
[15:05] anyone else, but again with a time constraint, but and I'm here to answer any other questions you have as well. Okay. Anything else before you get started?
[15:25] I think a lot of this is a little ridiculous. again, Sean Gerard, CIA salvage. I was asked to give you a site map. That's what I gave you. Later this afternoon, I was told I have to have measurements from here to there. Stan actually did a good job on getting some of the stuff that Oak had. So, it shows the 100 year 100year footprint.
[15:46] It shows what my tank farms are, where my concrete pads are situated. the 100 year the 100 foot from the flood is here. this heavy black mat. But this is supposed to be a simple
[16:02] when I gave this when this piece of paper here from Oak was done in April of 2008, it didn't give accurate measurements on this end of the yard. And that's what I thought we were having this site map done. I didn't realize we were going into a site map that's, you know, designed for nuclear waste sites and all of that.
[16:24] I disagree with Stan's facts of saying that if something happens at my facility that this board or this town is responsible because you're not. They first person they come after is me and they come after my assets. So it's not anybody's job here as we know there's other sites in town. They haven't gone after anybody there. They go after the owner of the property.
[16:47] I just received Stan's paperwork for the select board. It would have been nice to have that a little earlier. I had a chat with Stan about last week's meeting when he said that, you know, the site map wasn't completed. I asked what he wanted. I didn't get any answers for that until just recently today pretty much.
[17:10] So, we scribbled some stuff in on one of the site maps that Stan has. If there's something you want, you got to come out and spit it out. We can't come into the board and say, "Well, I don't really have everything I want." And then when Shawn goes in, Shawn can't get the answers he wants because Stan doesn't know what everybody wants.
[17:27] Excuse me, Sean. Which late information did you get from Stan?
[17:32] I didn't get the notice of decision what we're going to be going through until just now when this young lady get handed it to me. I don't rec I don't
[17:42] I mean I got there's a whole array of stuff here that we're going through that you asked me for a simple site plan at the conditional use.
[17:50] Okay.
[17:51] You asked me for a site plan. This is going into I see storage on here for the facility. The public testimony raising concerns about tire storage screening visibility. I do all of this with the plan with the planning board. I don't usually do it with the select board. select board. I come in, I give them my recyclers license for the last 35 years. You've signed off on it and away I go.
[18:12] Now all of a sudden I got to have special site maps. I got to get measurement sites. Nobody else in town. You got gas stations in town. Do they have to go through this and take and say, "Okay, Sean, you're 26 feet from here. You know, you're 900 ft from here. You're 400 feet from here." I understand some of it can be useful, but this is a little ridiculous.
[18:34] I spent tens of thousands of dollars on these three different sheets you got here. This one shows all the all the contours, all of that. and today I was told that we want we want measurements. Well, these here, these are all the scale. They should be able to be measured. This one here was just done by Mikeon.
[18:56] That's got all the buildings on it. The next one shows you where the gas and everything is stored, all of that stuff. And this one, this one's all done to scale. How much I mean what are we industrial facility here that you know we're trying to and then the notice of decision you know going through that we're going to the findings of facts.
[19:17] I got this here just 10 minutes ago. I haven't had a chance to sit down and answer it. You know the conditions of appeal of the conditions of approval. I say I was asked to give you a simple site plan. That was what I was asked. That's what I gave you. I didn't realize we were going into depth this far.
[19:37] And I don't know where the where either the Stan and I get along with Stan, don't get me wrong. Some days he's an some days he's not, but I don't know where he's fishing to get all of this. And I mean, there's stuff in here that, you know, is ridiculous.
[19:53] required site plan contents, minimum at a property, boundaries, operation areas, vehicle storage, dismantle and shearing, prep, tire storage, barriers. We're going to go through all of this. I go through all of this with the planning board. This isn't this board's job. I don't believe you guys can take whatever job you want. I'm here for a recycler license. That's all. I'm not here to redo my whole conditional use permit.
[20:15] I'm going to do that with the retires down the street in 6 months. But I don't think I'm here to re redo my whole conditional use permit with this board
[20:26] based on what you just said. Did you just get that information this afternoon?
[20:32] The planning board don't ask for this stuff or they haven't as of today.
[20:36] Wait a minute. [20:41] would you
[20:44] prefer to have some time to look this over? Well, I just don't understand where we're going. I'm here for a simple recycling license that allows me to sell parts, not go through a whole a whole deal of everything in the stands got in this book.
[21:00] All we can do is look at those conditions of approval whether they've been met.
[21:04] What was your condition? What when you granted me an extension, you asked me to get what?
[21:11] Do we have those? Did we have those minutes,
[21:13] Dan? These are from that last hearing, correct? And what does it say?
[21:19] Well, it said that it was the date of approval that we signed it on June 23rd, 2026.
[21:25] You wanted a site map
[21:26] and required site map.
[21:28] There's a whole bunch. You didn't get a copy of this.
[21:30] He did get a copy of it.
[21:32] Well, they evident. I mean, it's all right here in black and white. Everything we wanted.
[21:37] He actually had the signed copy. Okay.
[21:43] believe I had that.
[21:47] You should have it. It was handed plus.
[21:53] What? Can we go through that and see what it says?
[21:59] I mean, it's it's exactly what you're looking at now is the same as
[22:02] same thing as this.
[22:03] That was from June 23rd.
[22:05] All right.
[22:05] This is what was requested of you.
[22:07] So, if we deny the permit today, I have to go to court. I have to go to Superior Court.
[22:14] Fortunately,
[22:19] I don't believe that. I don't believe it's right. I think what we're trying to maybe get too I've never done this in 35 years that I've been here, guys.
[22:35] So, we got a new code enforcement officer. We're going to change everything. I'm here for a simple recycling license. It allows me to sell used autobots.
[22:42] It has nothing to do with the code enforcement officer.
[22:45] I understand. Obviously, it does because you signed this. You signed this
[22:51] on June 23rd. You got the copy of it. We all voted on it and you signed it and there was all the conditions in there
[22:58] and there was it was given to you. It had to be done in 90 days. And
[23:04] if you didn't trouble getting a survey to come in and do what he had to do. Well, it says right on here that everything has to be marked.
[23:15] So, answer Sean's concern is you did get a you did get a copy of the notice of decision that was signed after the board sign.
[23:24] Okay.
[23:25] Via email and delivery, but also with the recycler license is stuffed that the board covered on June 23rd. Those are the criteria you've already been through though Sean. So that was added to the findings of fact and the conclusion and the conditions of approval. All right. The biggest thing that was missing at the time was a puff plan which is defined under state statute.
[23:51] So what the board is doing when it renews your recycling license or any other license that comes up, there's one that's due every five years, one is due annually. The board has to verify that you're in compliance. So whether it's the plan board's conditional use which if you remember in 2025 the board said
[24:14] because of poor communication with the planning board they didn't have sufficient [cough] information. All right. So now they do have the information. They will be divided it once you go through another review which is separate in the planner board but they have to ensure when they renew your recycling license by statute that you're in compliance or they've set regulations
[24:39] to ensure that you'll be in compliance. All right. So, it's
[24:44] I know you haven't had anybody bring this up, but if the town fails, and it isn't that they don't go after you, but if you got hit by a Mac truck, the town is the one that is liable for holding the bag. Okay? In the town,
[25:02] we have several sites in town stand, nobody's holding the bag for them. But unfortunately, Sean, when accountability can't be held accountable, the town holds the back. All right. And they've learned that from past history where they've inherited other things regardless of whom when it was done, the town learned that it is liable for the other contamination
[25:25] and any results of cleanup. So, this is why the town needs to do its due diligence.
[25:32] It doesn't mean that they can't work with you and make accommodations or conditions, but you got to be held consistently and the board needs to ensure that's all
[25:43] consistent. This town hasn't been consistent in 35 years, Sam.
[25:47] But I can't answer to the passion. I am certified and trained and my responsibility to the board of this town is to do my job and that is what I'm doing. And I try to communicate that with you. And as you brought up today, I was willing to say and I have for week that I miscommunicated on the plane
[26:10] and I was going to tell the board that was my fault. But then because of all the questions raised today and your visit today, I revisited the notice of decision. And in that notice of decision, it clearly defines what is required. So this is why again I've been very insistent on I want to talk to you.
[26:32] I want to work with you. I want to get this result. Okay? I don't want you to come to these meetings with no answers at all. I help both sides.
[26:43] Okay?
[26:44] And the goal is not to shut you down. The goal is to make you as compliant as possible.
[26:53] It's just a shock that I'm coming in and we're going through all of this not you know notice of decision findings of facts and everything else down through
[27:03] my question is I mean and it's pretty basic one because it was agreed to has the concrete pad been replaced or repaired
[27:14] no D has allowed us there is concrete pad there has allowed us to go to June because we couldn't get any so qualified contractors to put the bad down.
[27:27] You couldn't get that done in 90 days.
[27:29] Well, in 60 because we heard this in
[27:32] you have to test March as well.
[27:34] You have to take and make sure that you got everything anything removed that doesn't need shouldn't be there that would [clears throat] be contaminated if there was contamination.
[27:43] Then you have to they have to come in they sniff test it and they do that and that's like three-week process. Phil Rock was scheduled to do it, but with everybody being sick and co and all of that, we couldn't get him to come in. So, D has given us an extension to the end of June.
[27:59] But this has been a six month with us and it's yes, I'm going to get it done. Yes, I'm going to get it done. Yes, I'm going to get it done.
[28:06] Now, we're looking at another
[28:07] but if you can't find a contractor that's qualified to do it, I can't just I can go down there tomorrow and pour concrete for you.
[28:15] The fact of the matter is it was supposed to be done, Sean. We can't control your contractors.
[28:23] You're the one that's in the driver's seat on that one.
[28:25] Then just deny it. We'll go to court.
[28:27] No, we're not looking for that. Okay.
[28:30] I think that's where
[28:31] But I'll tell you another issue I see and I saw just a minute stamp put this plan down. It's not accurate.
[28:40] What's not accurate?
[28:41] Your polls. [clears throat] It's just
[28:43] Well, if you look at this one, Howard, this I didn't know you needed that till 3:00 today when standing. But you look at this one. This one's accurate right down to the pinpoint. This one here is accurate of everything that might be on there. And then this one here fills in where the ponds are and everything else. That's all been done by Oak.
[29:03] But why isn't it on this master plan?
[29:05] Because we didn't know we had to do it.
[29:07] I asked Stan that last week and Stan says,
[29:10] "I got news for you. It says required site plan. This is on the conditions of the approval.
[29:17] Yeah. Well, obviously I didn't read all of that very well because I didn't
[29:20] Unfortunately, if you don't have it, we can't approve it.
[29:26] You have it right here on this Howard. You have it on this map here, which is part of the site plan. You have it on this one.
[29:32] This is your master plan right here. That master plan is going to go to in two days
[29:39] because obviously we have to send it back to Mike and have all of this stuff put on it.
[29:45] Why?
[29:45] We have to have all of this what Stan gave you.
[29:47] Why wasn't it put on when he did this?
[29:49] Because we didn't know we had to have it. We said we were having a boundary, a site plan. I didn't know you wanted a full I misunderstood.
[30:02] So someone what I what I think and the board has offered this they asked you if you need more time.
[30:08] So within reason and again the board can give you an amount of time and decide that but it would be preferable if you would say to the board I need a little more time because I didn't thoroughly read the notice of decision or again there was other things going on and Sean does have a very
[30:29] active business with mult businesses on that property. So, I'm not making justification, but if you need more time for an answer, it would be better to ask the board for that time. So, I guess Dan would like me to ask the board if I could get more time to incorporate everything on there and every measurement
[30:51] topos and everything that you have on the other three pages into one piece.
[30:57] And now that I know that what you're looking for is it's these three pages of material, I go through and make sure.
[31:06] I'm reluctant on that one for one reason, one reason only. And I'll read it. Under conditions of approval, it says required site plan contents. The site plan shall identify at a minimum the property boundaries, operational areas, vehicle storage, processing, dismantling,
[31:26] sharing and preparations areas, tire storage areas, hazardous fluid storage areas, used car sales areas, storm water and retention features, screening, fencing barriers and gates. waterways, highway and public ways, residential areas, and known public and private water supplies or wells to the extent reasonably available.
[31:57] This plan does not show that.
[32:00] I agree it does not show all of it.
[32:02] Then how do you expect us to make a ruling on that? How do you expect us
[32:06] right here? We have it all right here in these other two maps.
[32:09] Okay, but if we look at the old maps, this one says you have three pads.
[32:15] Yeah, that's not correct.
[32:16] Exactly. That's kind of the point. We need
[32:20] board be kind enough to give me a month to talk with Mike and try to get this straightened out and get all of this on one map.
[32:28] Are we willing to extend it 30 days and schedule a new public hearing? Well,
[32:36] but I mean it still doesn't I mean there's still other conditions that haven't been met which
[32:42] one of the conditions that haven't been met.
[32:44] You got to
[32:45] I'm sorry.
[32:47] You received them. They're right here in writing shop.
[32:49] I met every one of them conditions.
[32:52] I mean the concrete pad hasn't been done which is which is a major one.
[32:55] Spring no matter what we do.
[32:59] I mean at what point do we just say me just take it down? Just take it what, man?
[33:05] Just take the concrete pad out because if it's if there's cracks, if there's things that could be leaking in, there's
[33:15] nothing leaking in. There's been a pad there. I am one of the only two people in the state of Maine that put a pad underneath the processing area. And it doesn't mean that
[33:24] it's still a requirement. And it and it's been a requirement for the last 6 months is my concern. And now we're looking at even if we go with what D says and it's another 6 months by the time June gets here. Well, you can't get it done beforehand because it's too cold. So now you're going to try to schedule. So we're looking at another 6 months.
[33:43] So now we're a year and a half out. And if it doesn't get done then
[33:49] doing everything we can, man. We've done everything. We've got the stuff for Rang Road done. We've got the stuff for this done.
[33:56] You can't talk about Rang Road. I understand, you know, getting surveyors and storm water engineers and everybody on board is not everybody's sitting home waiting for Sean Gerard or CIA salvage having tea and crumpets and saying, "Okay, let me put let me help you do this, Mr. Gerard. You want a concrete pad down there tomorrow? I'll pour concrete tomorrow."
[34:16] John, before you just go and throw a concrete pad, explain to them there was another issue as well as it's not all the town's fault. This has been requested. This has been at the select boards meeting in 2023 and it was also mentioned in the 2021
[34:36] plan board. Okay. But the biggest problem lately is everybody's schedules busy because of lack of communication which is not the town hall still with prior engagements as well as Mike alone. Okay. So if they cannot meet the time constraints that are required
[34:58] then we need to be upfront and open and then preferably you set the realistic dates because if the board's due and we meet that date this is where [clears throat] this stuff is going to start biting. So
[35:13] I'd have to make a phone call to Mike and find out what Mike's schedule is. I'm putting this all on one map. And the other piece is with Still Water. So which is the pad they need.
[35:24] Still Water has agreed to the June deadline on chopping up whatever's left after the pad they want cut out. And there is a pad there. There's three/4 of a pad there now. So not all processing has to be on a pad. You know, we have aluminum piles, we have tire piles, and not everything has to be on a pad.
[35:43] Why not?
[35:45] Because it doesn't have to be. The town's dumpster is not on a pad. power.
[35:49] The town's metal is not on a dump.
[35:52] And again, the
[35:53] processing is where we do where we cut up the cars. Once we process it, we make piles of material, different material. You don't have everything on a concrete pad.
[36:01] Transfer station is a separate thing. [clears throat] And it is okay where the transfer station is because they actually had to dig to prove there was x amount of
[36:11] I'm just using it as an example, Sam.
[36:14] It's a separate issue. Yours has been a concrete pad for the metals.
[36:19] I have not had to have a concrete pad for all the metals.
[36:23] We have an aluminum that's not on the concrete pad. We have number one that's not on a concrete pad. It's the processing pad. It's a pad to process material. You bring the cars over there, you rip up a pad. So if there's anything that happens, it stays on that pad. And again, you're going to read your D agreement and the town's agreement.
[36:44] And the reason why the transfer station doesn't have to have a pad underneath the transfer station has a pad
[36:51] is because she has sufficient amount of gravel. All right? But yours has always required or it was proposed which is the same as making a requirement. If you say you're going to do something, you need to do it or you need to go back to the boards before the deadlines and make a change in plans.
[37:12] And that has not been done. Again, it's not all your fault. It's a lot of lack of communications and followup.
[37:20] We went from three pads down to one pad and we got approval for it.
[37:25] Again, there is reference in 2008 and 2009 for three pads. I showed you that. All right. The D referencing theirs says three pads, but the boards are only asking for one to be replaced.
[37:42] Yeah.
[37:43] Because of the damages done to that pad. All right.
[37:46] So, you need Still Water's input and you need microloans.
[37:52] Back when we said we wanted three pads, we said we'd have one for light iron, one for number one, and one for ion aluminum. But when a customer comes in, they don't have they don't separate their material. They dump it in one pile and they're done.
[38:15] Stan, I read in these all these notices we got u of there was I believe four different ways that we can deal with this for voting. Right. And I don't see it on here. That's why I don't know which I don't know which sheet is on what information's on which she seat here.
[38:37] What do you mean? There's four different ways to deal with it.
[38:40] No, as far as how we vote, how we what we can state that you can do.
[38:46] It's in the one that I used for myself for my notes. So, it should have been your very first
[38:51] site walk summary.
[38:52] Yes. Public hearing for CIA salvage renewal.
[39:00] I get a copy of that.
[39:04] Oh, I know.
[39:19] So, it's starts at A, B, C, and D. The board may ask for additional information.
[39:49] The other thing is I turned the paperwork in the stand as soon as we got it from Mike was on And he didn't say, "Oh, no, Sean. This is not acceptable. This isn't even close." Because he didn't know what he wanted either.
[40:04] He may have known what he wanted, but he certainly didn't say anything.
[40:07] I've worked with a lot of engineers, a lot of surveyors, and if you go have them go in and say, "You document everything that's in that piece of property, it's got to be there." Whether it's a pond, whether it's a tire,
[40:21] I thought we were getting a simple boundary survey. show where the boundaries were because we couldn't tell how far we were on the boundary from the pond where we owned and we didn't own. Mike didn't understand either that when I gave him the paperwork that you wanted every nook cranny topo mapund
[40:37] sheet.
[40:38] You say I did, but I don't have I don't believe
[40:42] I'm saying did you if you received this did you give him that sheet?
[40:46] I did not give it to Mike. No.
[40:48] Okay. And I don't believe I got a Howard one.
[40:59] You wouldn't have had it typed up that night that we were here to disc and we talked about everything. You gave me an extension in June. You wouldn't have had that sheet then, would you?
[41:08] Or would you had that sheet that night?
[41:12] They you didn't have it the following week because the board we had to sign.
[41:17] Yes. But that doesn't mean I got it. I mean, I get 10,000 emails and 5,000 scam mails. So, I mean, it doesn't say that, you know.
[41:24] No, you get this one.
[41:27] Anyway, and when it came to miscommunication on Stan didn't know what he wanted. Okay.
[41:33] Well, you didn't tell me that when I gave you the map, you didn't say, "Shan, this is nowhere near closed. This is this is not what I want."
[41:40] Exactly. And I'm not going to make any excuses, Sean. Right. There are a lot of details that go on and on and on and I don't remember exactly but that is why we started to put everything in writing very detailed including verbatim what the law and the statute requires and that is the notice of decision.
[42:03] I can get all of that on there. I just need time to go bring it back to Mike and have all of that put on there. And then the only thing we'll have to discuss is the pad because obviously we're coming into the winter. We want to do it right. We don't want to take in I can go dig you out a pad and I can put concrete down there tomorrow. But it's not going to be right.
[42:24] It has the dirt has to be tested. If there's any dirt that's there that's a problem. We take it out. If there's no dirt that's been tested as the dirt
[42:32] How far do they test it? How far they tested it? We when we did the detention bomb, we went down 24 ft.
[42:45] They found no contamination. That yard's been there since 1969 and they found no contamination down 24 ft out. And Stan has that they did grid testing and everything.
[42:59] I mean, my concern is this has been going on, you know, since the 2023, March 2023 renewal
[43:07] agreeing to replace the concrete pad within two years. We're now three years, three and a half years out. Still not done,
[43:18] soon to be four years.
[43:20] Yeah. Yeah, according to the state,
[43:26] the concrete pad was something we agreed to do above and beyond. The state didn't require us to put in a pad,
[43:33] but it was agreed to do,
[43:34] but when
[43:38] I can I remember from that hearing because I know I specifically asked you or told you, make sure that's in by November.
[43:49] I go put it in. You want it in today?
[43:51] Well, why isn't it in now?
[43:52] Because you can't get somebody to test the goddamn dirt. Howard, there's no sense of taking putting the pad in unless you get somebody to test the dirt to make sure that it's clean. If you can't do the whole thing in the right steps, there's no sense of doing it.
[44:05] You've got an existing pad in there right now, right?
[44:08] Yes.
[44:08] And that has to be replaced.
[44:10] Part of it does. Yes. Half of it does.
[44:11] Okay. So, if that was that hadn't been tested before you put it in, right?
[44:16] Yes. But then you process cards on it. you break up stuff, you get a leak, you want to make sure that when you take and you redo it, you're putting everything right and you're doing it correct.
[44:28] You don't want to just cap over the dirty landfill. If that's what I mean, if I throw that out there, you got to make sure that the test people come in and test to make sure that when you put the new concrete in, there's nothing there on the ground and you're not capping it off.
[44:41] It would seem to me that it's the whole thing would not have to be totally tested. is just where you've got cracks or whatever the situation is. Something that would
[44:53] only the engineers can deal this with you is making sure
[44:56] they come in with they come in with baggies and sniff test. They take a piece of dirt, they put it in there, they weave it in there, zip for so many seconds, they bring over a meter, they test it. If there's nothing there, then you don't have to dig there no more. If there is something there above a certain decimal, then you have to redig it.
[45:12] This is what I'm saying. If you've got a pad already poured there and let's say you've got a crack and it's opened up, you can take that area out, test it. You wouldn't have to test it before if the other one was already pre-ested before you poured the concrete.
[45:29] Doesn't work that way. You have to They tested they test the whole area.
[45:37] The fact of the matter is, Sean, you haven't done it.
[45:40] I understand. I understand that, you know,
[45:45] it's hard to get the people into test. I get it. But it's been three and a half years. Sean,
[45:53] I understand that.
[45:54] You haven't No, nobody's had a had any availability for CIA limit in three and a half years.
[46:03] Well, it's I don't know.
[46:06] Well, we've [clears throat] called when we call, nobody has availability. I can't even get rid of waste oil because everybody's so busy. Nobody has time to do it. We called 10 people the DP sent us and we can't even get rid of oil and gasoline.
[46:21] You know, this the world is right now. And I hate to tell you that, but getting people to come out and do that is you know, they're a niche. There are certain people and they're doing these big jobs and it's just hard to get everybody. I would think if you hired these people to do all these testing, whether it be group five or if it's been over on range road, you have a rapport with them.
[46:46] Yes, we've used we've used oak engineers before.
[46:50] And I would hope because of that rapport that they would be able to come right down and say if you
[46:54] But they're still short-handed, Howard.
[46:56] It's not that I don't want to do the pad. I just want to I want to do it right.
[46:59] But Sean, it doesn't take 90 days. [cough]
[47:03] Sure it does. take three.
[47:04] It takes longer than that.
[47:05] No,
[47:06] these guys are out years. Howard,
[47:08] you're lucky. I'm lucky that I know the surveyor. That's why I do have that map in front of us. Phil Rock was is fit me in because we've done millions of dollars and thousands of dollars with him. But Phil Rock is he's a year out. He's not even taking any new clients because they can't find the help.
[47:26] Well, I can understand that. But
[47:29] I just
[47:30] I mean, if they're scheduling years out, when are you scheduled to have it done? We got right now we got confirmation that we can get people to work with us by June of 27
[47:45] which is only 6 months away.
[48:00] When did you contact them for them to give you that June date? How long ago did you
[48:06] Eight month eight nine months ago we've been after everybody trying to get everybody. We've told we
[48:10] that was that was eight or nine months ago. What about two years ago?
[48:15] Was that accredited?
[48:16] Well, yes. Well, Phil Rock was doing all of that back then and he doesn't he doesn't have the manpower to do it now. the company we had.
[48:25] But when you found out that accredited lab didn't have the manpower, did you make any effort?
[48:30] Yes, we did. Yes, we did. Yes, we did.
[48:34] We made effort to talk to people and nobody would touch us.
[48:37] Phil Rock used to do it. He doesn't do it anymore.
[48:40] Oak Engineers, which is on this paper here, they don't do it anymore. They do just heavy environmental places and that's it. They don't have time to do all of it anymore. Oak engineers. You figure they did this plan for us back in 2008. They don't have time for us anymore.
[49:02] There's no money in coming here and sniffing a little bit of dirt and telling you yes or no. Dig deeper or don't dig deeper.
[49:09] Oh, there's all kinds of money.
[49:11] I'm sure there is. I'm sure there is plenty of money out there for that.
[49:14] It's roughly $3 to $5,000 for them to come do the sniff test. But you got to have somebody that's qualified. I can't buy the machine. I can't do my own sniff test because they don't have
[49:25] not accredited.
[49:30] I mean, is it is it outside of the realm of possibility to do a 30-day extension to have a completed site plan done per the requirements and confirmation from a company that it is date set to have that concrete pad replaced?
[49:52] And [clears throat]
[49:53] what are you asking again?
[49:54] You can't pull the cont
[49:56] Well, no. I'm saying confirmation from the company that it's scheduled. It's going to happen. Here's when it's going to happen.
[50:03] Yeah, but that's in the springtime. That's after all the spring rain and all the snow melt and everything else.
[50:08] Yep. You're right.
[50:10] That's right. And we've had 20 years of water testing. We have never had our water tests are right where they are every month.
[50:26] As far as I know you're dealing with just a minute ago, I'll recognize you when I come here. U
[50:39] my big concern, Sean, and I've done this in many towns, is I don't like that plan.
[50:45] I can update that plan, and I apologize for that. I'm sorry.
[50:48] We're going to get that done in 30 days.
[50:51] I can I can go out right now if you give me five minutes. I go out and ask Mike how soon it would take to update it to everything you guys want.
[51:02] I know he's busy as well and he squeezed me in to get that.
[51:09] We may have got that in an email, but I don't see every email that comes through and I apologize for that. That's my fault. But this is a copy.
[51:18] Yeah.
[51:18] Of the approval, the 90 days extension.
[51:22] So you got it. And there's conditions on that approval. There are 15 conditions.
[51:30] I don't remember seeing it now. I really don't.
[51:34] Stan, it was hand delivered to.
[51:36] Okay. [snorts]
[51:40] You said this was hand delivered to me. Am
[51:47] I signed that I received it?
[51:50] No, I didn't ask for your sign your signature to receive it. Sean, I didn't think we had to get that.
[51:56] Yeah.
[51:57] Right.
[51:57] So, I mean I may have received it. I may not. I'm not calling Stan or you guys a liar.
[52:02] I'm just saying I don't remember seeing this notice of decision and it's the first time I've seen it today in months.
[52:09] When is the last time you did water testing? We didn't do last quarter because there's no water in the brook. There's D was at this facility. Do you have D's paperwork? Yep.
[52:19] There was no water running. If there's no water, you can't get no water. You can't get a water sample and give you a dirt sample.
[52:24] So, when was the last time you did water testing?
[52:26] It was June or
[52:28] first two quarters.
[52:29] Okay.
[52:30] June.
[52:31] You do it in a quarter and then they may give it to you and may give you your results 30 days later.
[52:37] Okay.
[52:40] So you said you did do monthly testing where
[52:44] we have Phil Rock comes out every quarter. We t we don't test the water every month.
[52:50] Every quarter we do it.
[52:51] Okay. So quarterly
[52:52] we do a quarterly water test. Yes.
[52:55] Okay.
[52:56] This is quarterly test done that they do the samples on. In the last 15 years, 20 years, every sample has been the same. We have not had any spikes or anything that the D is worried about.
[53:11] So, was he all up to date on his on the water tests?
[53:16] No, there was no water test done in the third quarter. We're now in the fourth quarter. the again the earlier communications you got from me was saying that we understand due to weather conditions that the water sample was unable to be taken.
[53:33] Mhm.
[53:34] But please provide the town as soon as weather is allowed there. There are stipulations with the water sample. It's got to be done within two hours of the rainfall event ending. and it would be ideal considering we've been through a drought to get the next water sample.
[53:54] We have everything there to take the sample, but if there's no water on the D even put it in their report, there was no water running out of the pipe.
[54:00] But it has rained since June. we've got quite a bit of rain.
[54:05] That pond is 8 and 1/2 ft deep. That pond has to fill up. The water has to flow out the overflow and go out into that. And
[54:14] but you don't have to have that flowing out to get a water test at the bottom of it.
[54:18] Yes, I do. I also test the brook.
[54:22] We test the brook upstream, downstream
[54:26] where the where the cover the water comes has to come out of a cent. We test right there. We test downstream 25 ft. We test upstream 25 ft. We go up there a quarter of a mile. And we test the outfall up there a quarter of a mile or whatever the measurement is. We test upstream and downstream from there as well. So the brook has to have sufficient run and the water has to run out of the pond.
[54:50] We don't go in the pond itself and test the water.
[54:54] I would think that's where you'd want to be testing it.
[54:57] I'm not the engineer, Howard.
[54:59] Well, I'm not either. I'm just
[55:00] We tested the outfall pipe
[55:03] and I believe if we look at one of these maps, it would show it.
[55:09] Dan, what were you going to say? You don't want to test out of the retention ponds or in that vicinity. There's a absorbing sock that is to prevent any contaminations from going any further than the ponds.
[55:23] It's tested right here.
[55:24] So the testing is done at the outs beyond the ponds
[55:29] and prior to the property.
[55:32] If there's any contamination found then the retention ponds are not doing their job. Would it require 8 feet of rain?
[55:41] I'm sorry.
[55:42] Would it require 8 feet of rain to
[55:44] Well, again, we had an abnormal dry drought.
[55:48] So, it's going to take an abnormal rain event to saturate the ground enough
[55:54] to
[55:55] Okay, so this is this is not necessarily by choice.
[55:58] and in one case, there was a significant rainstorm I think the beginning of August. the problem was they didn't have any testing jaws to take samples with and apparently from my understanding is there was none available but we need to plan ahead.
[56:18] That's been communicated.
[56:19] We are planning ahead and if there's no water coming out I can't take it whether I have a water s I have a bucket or I don't.
[56:24] So you have test kits available.
[56:26] We have buckets available. They're in the office. Yeah.
[56:29] Okay.
[56:29] And we've been told that they're good for up to 18 months.
[56:33] Buckets. [snorts] They're not buckets. There's there's four coolers and they have bottles and they're all labeled. They got certain chemicals in them that last so long
[56:41] and you have to fill it to this depth and then you got upstream and downstream benchmark. You got benchmark for the other one and then upstream and downstream. If there's no water, we can't test it. And if you look at the results of the last 18, 20 years that we've done testing, water's always the same.
[57:01] You may get a little higher in the spring mail, but that's about all you get. And trust me, if the plan aboard, if there was any contaminants, they would already be on me. Sean, who's the company that you guar that said that they would do this in June?
[57:20] Chris Buart Jr., as you know, Chris was out for back surgery. He's going to do the concrete. Phil Rock is going to set up for the testing in the the soil
[57:37] with everybody being sick and all of that. Phil Rock was also out supposed to be out today for his quarterly visit and he didn't show up today because he was sick.
[57:58] I just I'm bothered by the fact that you run a business.
[58:03] I'm sorry.
[58:04] I'm bothered by the fact that you run a business.
[58:06] Yeah.
[58:07] You was before us on the 23rd and you wasn't concerned enough about our concerns to inquire. Did I Did I ever get the requirements that the board asked? Did you didn't
[58:23] I don't I didn't believe there was any when I came here my honest and I can swear to God on the Bible. I was asked for a sight plan to show my boundaries. That's all I was asked. And then I turned around and then I said to Stan, I says Stan I says if you want all of this I can pencil it in. I said, "But I was not anywhere
[58:45] thought that I had to have all of this on the map on this site map. I don't believe I received the paperwork that you said. The these are your terms and conditions, Sean, and this is what you have to have because I obviously went and spent the money and went to the to forward to have Mike Won do the map. If I had to do more, I would have asked Mike to do more."
[59:07] So, I don't believe I received that paper. Sam might have handed it to me or handed it to the office or emailed it, but I don't believe I have it. And I had I did not sign for it. I know that.
[59:21] And I today is the first day I've seen the 16 conditions and all of that in this paperwork.
[59:29] So you never you said you never get our approval?
[59:33] I do not know. Did it go through your
[59:36] truth or I have no reason to lie to you.
[59:39] No, but did it go through your attorney?
[59:42] I don't know. I don't believe it went through my attorney because I didn't bring this part of the If I went through my attorney, he'd be sitting here tonight. I did not bring this to my attorney's attention.
[59:51] When we do a conditional, there's conditions attached.
[59:55] The only condition I believe there was that I had to have a site map showing the boundaries because Stan wanted to know where the property in lines ended. And that's what we hired Mike to do. I did not hire Mike to do any of the other stuff in this map.
[1:00:11] But on your site plan, on any site,
[1:00:16] it
[1:00:18] doesn't show measurements. It doesn't show spillways. It doesn't show all of that.
[1:00:22] It's the scale, which is your ma measurement. However, there are other places you put you have to put
[1:00:28] figures in there.
[1:00:29] That is the scale. And we thought we were doing a site map,
[1:00:32] but I don't see anything here where the tire stuff is. [1:00:40] yeah, map shows
[1:00:41] pawns. Ponds aren't made with a pen, Sean.
[1:00:44] I understand that, but I didn't write this stuff today, but Stan, but there's the tire pile right there.
[1:00:52] And that's surveyed by Mike. And then we wrote this other stuff in because Stan said he wanted it and was we were going to pencil it in.
[1:01:11] We were under the assumption we were doing a boundary survey so that you guys knew how far we owned behind the other houses. That's what I was under the assumption of. I apologize if I'm wrong and I don't believe I ever received this paperwork that states what I had to have on that. I did not receive that and I don't believe you have one with my signature.
[1:01:35] Well,, we 've already ascertained that we did not make you sign to receive a copy. It was emailed to you. It was handd delivered to you. Whether you read it or not is not at qu it's not a question. I mean, it's we sat here and discussed and I'm going to go back to the concrete pad because that was a major one.
[1:01:58] It was. It was.
[1:02:00] And it was Yep. I can have it done by this day.
[1:02:04] I can have a site map. Yes. And I have a site map.
[1:02:07] Not a sight. Sight. Not a site map.
[1:02:10] The pad.
[1:02:11] Oh, the pad. I agree that you wanted the pad done. I remember hearing about the pad.
[1:02:16] But you keep saying the only thing you want that we wanted was this boundary plan. No,
[1:02:20] that's what I you wanted the pad down and you wanted the boundary survey
[1:02:24] which I gave you the boundary survey there and now the boundary survey is not good enough
[1:02:32] because it doesn't contain all the information that was asked
[1:02:37] the three pieces of paper you have here Howard I agree with you that it doesn't show all that but it does not show everything on one piece of paper
[1:02:45] I mean this the screening and maintenance applicant shall maintain screening fencing concrete, block barriers, vegetation, gates, and related features so that required screening maintains effective and acceptable to the town.
[1:02:57] Has that has the
[1:03:00] has the screening or fence been put in?
[1:03:07] It has. Okay.
[1:03:10] All your boundaries. The only thing you don't have, ma'am, is this concrete pad.
[1:03:14] Okay. and an updated site map listing everything under the sun.
[1:03:25] But you must recall the discussion that we had about that concrete bed. I mean that was
[1:03:30] Yes. But if I can get somebody to come out and do it, right?
[1:03:33] Time out. when you made effort to get someone to sample,
[1:03:40] I really think that you should have reached out to us prior to that to
[1:03:48] the concrete patch was never something the town required from me. It was D. D and I made the deal on the concrete pad. We just told the board what we were doing and we said we would get it done. But it was never something back in the day that this board required me to put in. It was something I agreed with DB
[1:04:07] and in negotiations I've had in the past, I've always been with DB on the not been with this board or the planning board.
[1:04:15] But it was part of the March 2023 agreement, which I can't go back 20 years. I can't go back 30 years, but I can go back three and a half years. And it was in there. We're now three and a half years later. It is part of the part of the conditions
[1:04:36] has been part of the conditions for three and a half years.
[1:04:41] And
[1:04:44] I mean it's hard when you just get No, I haven't been able to get anybody sorry, you know, maybe by this day. Well, maybe by this day has come and gone several times with 90day hearings.
[1:04:56] You haven't got besides concrete path. [cough]
[1:05:02] Water testing we know wasn't that isn't an issue just because of weather. Can't control weather. site plan, concrete pad. Those are the two main ones
[1:05:20] that I could see on there at least that I mean the D report was pretty good.
[1:05:25] You have 60 days. I can go to Mike and create one master plan with the topos on it, the spillways, the swearways, everything you see on all three of these maps on the one print. And I would have to ask for an extension on concrete pad. Just definitely can't do that. Can't do a halfass job and not do it.
[1:05:48] D has also stipulated and given Shawn no longer than June 30th of 2027.
[1:05:58] So they have actually come down and stood around and said that needs to be replaced no later than the end of June.
[1:06:09] Completely replaced or just the half of it?
[1:06:12] The pad will be completely replaced.
[1:06:15] Only half of it has to be replaced. broken half has to be replaced.
[1:06:19] Then they're going to have to clarify that because the interpretation since 2019 has been the whole pad.
[1:06:27] You don't have to replace the whole pad. Half the pad is still there today.
[1:06:32] You just said we had to replace that you had to replace the whole pad.
[1:06:35] Yeah.
[1:06:36] Lori asked you if you could do half of it and you said no. They got to do the whole thing.
[1:06:40] No, I'm doing half. You said that Ruck is the one that's going to do the work and I might be missing.
[1:06:48] No,. I'm sure that I know Bruotss will do it. They'll do the concrete work. They'll do an awesome job. But you said that Ruck was going to do the testing, but a little while ago I thought you said Ruck went out of business because he can't find any help.
[1:06:59] No, Phil Rock is still Phil Rock was supposed to be here today to do a cycle. He comes every quarter to do a [snorts] cycle. So, I'm borrowing my hearing aids and tomorrow. Bill Rock was supposed to be here today. He is still in business. They do it every day. They do bigger projects. Three times big pass. The sawmill that burned up north.
[1:07:20] That was one of his sites.
[1:07:24] And what's his company, Sean?
[1:07:30] Still water.
[1:07:34] Again, I as far as half the pad and whole I always have to be the entire I would have to get clarity and clarification on whether it's half the pad or whole pad. In my experience, again, if you do half the pad, it's got to be married together and I'm not quite so sure if the existing pad is stable enough to be drilled in spite.
[1:08:00] I don't know those answers. I'm not an engineer. that wouldn't qualify under fil.
[1:08:10] Even if you put in a concrete pad, it's going to crack. I don't care if you put it in your driveway, it cracks. You put it in your garage, it cracks. You put your foundation in, it cracks. So, you get cracks in the foundation. You get cracks in the concrete.
[1:08:25] You get you get a line cracks if you get it all reinforced properly. What you do with this is you take your saw, cut the pad, you pin the pads together, but as long as there's no contamination or anything there, you pin the [clears throat] pad together and you use what concrete is there. You don't want to say you're taking up a whole concrete pad that's 80 by 200 or whatever the measurement is.
[1:08:49] But you don't want to have a gap in there either.
[1:08:51] No. and you will
[1:08:54] you don't want to have a gap between
[1:08:57] the two halves.
[1:08:59] So, they've got to get it
[1:09:01] and that's going to be a question for engineering to determine again Sean's experience with concrete and mine goes back to the paper mills and if the concrete cracked or even chipped they had to replace it. So if it's done correctly, my experience with concrete doesn't crack
[1:09:24] unless there's a reason the ground wasn't accurate and it settled, the reb wasn't in or wasn't usually a cause for a crack or the thickness of the concrete wasn't appropriate
[1:09:41] or if the mix was wrong in the mix. Now they got fiberglass to go with it. The ones I built in Massachusetts
[1:09:59] just say six feet.
[1:10:01] It was six feet. These were the ones I got were German machines. This machine cost over $40 million. So if it cracked that machine wouldn't make corugated boxes very well because the machine would
[1:10:17] kind of money to talk to me. [laughter]
[1:10:21] But that's again if it's poured right and designed right you shouldn't have the issues with cracking. Cracking is usually stress of some sort.
[1:10:30] Right. And I would have to agree because there are industrial sites all over Maine, all over America that operate with cranes as heavy as 50 ton that operate day in and day out. [1:10:47] we I my experience at the port naval shipyard port hole cranes ran for over 30 years on sections of pier that never cracked. I mean that to say concrete is going to crack it. It depends on how it's poured, how it's sat, and there's a lot of variances there. So that's to me it's not a viable
[1:11:08] long it's engineered properly. You won't have a problem.
[1:11:11] You're going to run excavators and stuff on it. It should be more than 10 in thick, right? Yeah.
[1:11:20] Well,
[1:11:29] we have three things. I don't believe I received your letter of recommendation or your condition, terms and conditions. I don't believe I received that for today. One, I can't get a pad in until June of this coming year, which is six months away. And my site map boundary survey which I was
[1:11:50] under the assumption the boundary survey I can't get completed till I go see Mike to bring it up to what you want within 60 days I come back to you with a sight and a half 100% done showing every boundary every building every spot of everything he has everything there he just has to overlay them and get them done
[1:12:10] concrete pad I would ask for an extension till June
[1:12:15] and Would
[1:12:19] you be able to
[1:12:22] provide information
[1:12:27] or whatever it is
[1:12:28] and a date certain and a date certain on when they
[1:12:31] I'm not sure if I can get that or not because we have to remove all of that for them to examine the pad
[1:12:37] and then go from there.
[1:12:41] Would you at least ask if he could provide anything If they can't when he would be able to provide any details you're going to be able
[1:13:03] to
[1:13:05] do that
[1:13:06] I mean and if we can assume okay that it's going to be the full thing okay when can they guarantee they'll have done. That's
[1:13:19] he has committed to
[1:13:24] that
[1:13:27] if July 1st comes around that is a violation and we will recently the boards both boards when there
[1:13:42] these properties both have to be there time frame for appeal and the right to a cure. If that time frame goes unanswered or unmititigated, then the boards have a due process that they must by statute or should by statute have another public hearing for disciplinary action if necessary
[1:14:08] or remediation of the issue which would include revoking a
[1:14:18] You've held your hand up for a long time. A long time here. Got something to add.
[1:14:37] I've I've had comments that because I wasn't recognized until now. I am going to probably be talking about things that should have been talked about when you're relevant in the moment. But the water testing Stan did tell him in August with the rainstorm coming to be prepared and to do it.
[1:15:02] He didn't have the kits. Boy, something that I had to do every quarter, I would think that you would have a kit available. Just saying.
[1:15:14] the processing pad.
[1:15:19] I'm going to go back to a legal document from the DP dated 2014, solid waste license. This is specific to CIA.
[1:15:33] section 17, process design information. Subsection B, processing operations. Sub section two, material processing. Last paragraph reads, "Metal will only be stored on paved pads or inside buildings."
[1:15:56] Sub three, material storage. Ferris scrap metal is stored in outdoor piles on concrete paths along the west side of the facility waste handling area. Vehicles are generally processed within 24 hours of delivery. If more vehicles
[1:16:17] are received than can be processed in this time, they may be temporarily stored in the stripping area. I don't see stripping area anywhere on that particular site map until they are processed and crushed. If the stripping area becomes full, no additional vehicles are accepted until adequate space in the area is cleared.
[1:16:43] Non-ferris metals may be stored in the main building in the non-ferris processing and storage area or outside on concrete pads until shipped to destination facilities. This is 2014 D license specific to CIA.
[1:17:10] The pad size for the shearing area, processing area. I've heard so many different names for that particular area. I don't want to say I know what you folks all feel that is, but it's that big pile that has lots of metal and I see tires and lots of other things in it. [1:17:30] you have received and I want to remind you of an email from the D. It was an exchange between myself and Eric Hamlin that went on for several back and forths. And on the email that was dated October 6th, 2026,
[1:17:49] this stated the pad size to be 75 by 110 ft in the amendment order that corresponded with and was driven by our 2021 agreement enforcement action, I'm sorry, an administrative consent decree with monetary penalty. So, in 2021,
[1:18:11] the size of the pad approved was 75 feet by 110 feet. Go back to your pictures and images that you have of that area and see how big it is. Remember that you have a report if you had time to read it that came from Derek Diccastro
[1:18:31] on November 4th when he and Stan did an inspection that said he could not find the pad when he walked around that pile.
[1:18:44] He said it's the end of his email said
[1:18:48] that this board does not
[1:18:54] this is a public hearing not a [1:18:59] if they want to turn me off they can turn me off. the last part or of that email said it is important that metal processing occur on that pad. No one can see the pad. No one knows exactly how big that pad is. It's not referenced in anything. Mr. Lolon didn't reference that area at all on his plan.
[1:19:22] and I will go back and say that I appreciate that u somehow Mr. Gerard stated he didn't find or feel he got this material, but he was at the same meeting I was on June 23rd.
[1:19:43] And sometimes you have to go back and listen to things again. But when I listened in quickness, I wrote down that the site plan that you folks mentioned required operations areas, storage area definition, tires, fluids, distance from waterways, residential areas, private wells, and highways. And that was just me trying to keep up with writing down what I heard.
[1:20:08] Mr. Gerard had that ability. It seems like people are being hired and not given the task that they should be given on step one. So things are repeating for you folks over and over again.
[1:20:24] The pad was to be completed for many years, but no one had a consent decree from the D. The town had the expectation from planning board meetings because I've been attending meetings for seven years. So, I know that people think that I'm just being a nuisance, but all I'm doing is saying follow the law.
[1:20:46] And for seven years, well, four or five of the seven years, I've heard about this path that was going to be completed. At least when I converse with Stan recently, he said that Still Water never heard about having to do this concrete pad thing and the soil underneath
[1:21:08] until just recently. And I can't say exactly what day just recently was because I didn't do that. And it's I'm an anecdote to tell you what Stan said to me, but in early October is when that decision by the D extending him till next June came. So it must have been shortly before that theoretically they heard as you had said it's been three and a half years at least that you've seen in paperwork where
[1:21:37] an organization could have been contacted and everything could have been done easily. Water is tested, but you want to know what the town's only required testing or the D actually and the town is supporting it and surface water. There's no deep water testing. Anything that's below that pad is not going to be in that surface water that's coming out of the detention pond.
[1:22:02] It's going to be in subsurface well testing if it was ever done. So there is contamination probable, highly likely I think Eric Hamlin has said in that area of the soils. We just keep extending the amount of time that it gets to leech down.
[1:22:24] I know you folks had to listen and deal with and are still dealing with that TCE issue. We're smarter now. We know a few more things, but we still are going to have surprises in life. This shouldn't be a surprise. This should be simple, black and white. Should have been fixed.
[1:22:44] Defiance isn't a good excuse.
[1:22:55] We dug down
[1:22:56] and I will say that Mr. Gerard answered when Mr. Burnham asked him last time round about the size of the sharing area. So I'm going to call that processing pad, etc., etc. And Mr. Garrett answered 120 by 140 ft. It's pretty big.
[1:23:17] So again, he doesn't know the size of this pad that he's supposed to be limiting his time, his operations to. And if he's going to exceed it, then he needs to be doing something about it. I don't know why D doesn't, but I'm just telling you what's in black and white, what's been permitted, and
[1:23:38] expect that
[1:23:42] it is the right thing to do to follow the law, follow the ordinances we have.
[1:23:50] I'm going to bring up something that I was a little disturbed by and it's select no Connors had said at the end of last meeting at 2 hours and 7 minutes
[1:24:03] we hammer at on CIA salvage since I moved to town in 2022. That's the only real planning board meeting where it takes 15 minute meetings to get something accomplished. I think it's ridiculous. It's a business in town that employs a lot of people, brings in tax revenue.
[1:24:28] And sadly, you agreed with that statement.
[1:24:33] I want to read to you how the state sees
[1:24:39] junkyards and graveyards. This is state statue.
[1:24:44] [1:24:47] it's under title 30A municipalities and counties part two municipalities chapter 183 economic regulations subchapter 1. So the state looks at a junkyard and on graveyard and has very specific laws and rules just like you have an ordinance saying he has to come back every two years for renewal of his license or conditional use permits.
[1:25:13] So, it says that junkyards and so-called auto graveyards have been steadily expanding and frequently encroach upon highways. These junkyards and graveyards have been a nuisance and a menace to safe travel on public ways, often distracting the attention of drivers of motor vehicles because it appears cars are parked on the highway and that an accident has occurred.
[1:25:37] It is declared that such junkyards and automobile graveyards are a nuisance and are properly subject to regulation and control.
[1:25:48] It is recognized that recycling of automobiles is a business enterprise that when conducted in accordance with certain standards differs from the enterprise of an automobile graveyard in that adoption of uniform state sta standards for this type of business enterprise would assist in development and regulation of that business.
[1:26:10] Junkyards, automobile graveyards, and automobile recycling businesses pose potential risks to the environment, particularly to groundwater and surface water quality if gasoline, oil or other fluids are not managed and disposed of properly.
[1:26:31] Proper location and operation of these facilities are critical to ensure protection of groundwater and surface water quality. other natural resources and the health and welfare of Maine citizens. These facilities may create nuisance conditions potentially affecting abuing land owners and others if not located and operated properly.
[1:26:57] For those reasons, it is declared that the facilities are appropriately subject to certain environmental and operational standards into appropriate municipal and state regulations. Now, I didn't want to really cite two of you for any kind of agreement with [1:27:17] this process having looked like it wasn't proper, but I know you wear many hats and it's hard to know everything and I've been doing this for seven years. So, I've particularly read a lot of the stuff in regards to this stuff and that's why I wanted to read what I just read. I want to educate you so that you can make those good decisions.
[1:27:46] I think I appreciate you listening. Have a good night.
[1:27:50] Thank you.
[1:27:57] As you know and Stan can vouch for we get rid of all our gas, oil, antifreeze, everything we have in our cars. We do it environmentally safe. They all go everything goes to proper facilities. We recycle our gas. We recycle our oil. We use a waste oil furnaces. you know, if you don't have a junkyard or salvage yard or auto part store, where you going to buy a used part or where you going to get rid of the stuff that comes into town?
[1:28:26] You know, we may not be a piece of property. You know, Fan has me in his love book, but it's a necessity that has to have you have to have a place to get rid of the material. We process over 5,000 cars a year. We did all our all our storm water testing.
[1:28:46] We've done every all the storm water testing the D has told us we missed one test, which was my mess up. Every other test has been either no water. I think we've only missed three tests for no water. One of them was my fault. I didn't get it done in that quarter and obviously if I miss that day I can't go back. That was years ago. We try to stay on top of it. Make sure that everybody's done.
[1:29:06] We're doing what we're doing. you know, we're not the there isn't everybody that comes out to say, "Hey, I approve of what Mr. Gerard is doing, but we have Mr. Fan, which disapproves. I would like 60 days to redo the permit, redo the site map because I didn't get all of this.
[1:29:29] I honestly do not believe I had this. If I had this, I would have given it to Mike and said, "Mike, this is what I need." Whether he could have got it done still be get my ass chewed or not, I don't know. I would like an extension on the pad to work with D and to work with Still Water. Two years ago, we tried to buy a tester,
[1:29:52] the sniff tester. We couldn't buy We can buy it, but we can't I can't use it because I'm not certified. Still Water Lost one of his guys, the guy that he matter of fact, I think there's a little dent up there in the wall up there. He moved to New Hampshire because Aaron upset him so much. He was a veteran.
[1:30:12] He's he still is a veteran. He works in New Hampshire. He lost half his crew. Went over to Vermont. He was supposed to be the one to do the sniff test. We've tested our dirt where the ponds are. When we dug all the ponds, that whole area was tested. That was where the old global salvage started back in 1969 with Jim Gary. We dug down 26 feet. They found and they tested everything in grids.
[1:30:34] Somewhere in my paperwork stand must have it in his paperwork. They found no contamination in the 26 feet of dirt that they put in. Mr. Fram would like me to spend another $20,000 on test wells and then I don't know where that would go. I mean, we have one of the any you I could show you pictures. I can bring up my phone right now and show you pictures of the yards.
[1:30:54] It don't matter because they're not in town. But we are one of the cleanest in the state. We do everything we're supposed to do. We take care of our materials. We get rid of the gas the way that we're supposed to. Gas cost me5 $6 a gallon to dispose of. I could just turn on the faucet and dump it in Maril's well, but I don't and I haven't dumped it anywhere else in town.
[1:31:17] If there's something that we need to get rid of, we pay to get rid of it. Do I always like it? No. But we do it. We do what we're supposed to do with it and we get rid of it. We get we dispose of everything the environmentally way. If I die today, somebody's going to step forward and somebody's going to be in my footprint. So, I don't think that, you know, somebody's somebody's going to be here to run that yard for the next 50 years or 100 years or whatever it is until,
[1:31:42] you know, a salvage out is no longer needed. I apologize to the board for not having this piece of paper, knowing what we wanted on this site map. I thought it was just a boundary survey again and that's what I got.
[1:31:57] Sean, I got a question for you. I'm just looking on this oak engineering plan. And it says proposed transfer station slab. Is that the same slab that you're talking about? Let me look at it.
[1:32:11] That's the CD.
[1:32:13] Okay.
[1:32:13] Originally, we proposed three slabs with D. Is that transfer station pad? This one here, the big one is there.
[1:32:26] Okay.
[1:32:28] That pad is there. We have approval from D to use it temporarily for scrap when we change out the other pad or we change cut the other pad into pieces to use what we can or we can't.
[1:32:42] But that's what's existing that's got to come out.
[1:32:46] That big pad is already there, Howard.
[1:32:48] And that's not the one that needs to be replaced. That's the one that needs replaced is
[1:32:53] is I'll show it to you. piece of
[1:32:56] this one right here.
[1:32:59] Vehicle prep area.
[1:33:01] No, that 's right behind the main building. This pad does not need to be replaced. You are going to this site. There's three of them here. These two are not available. This one is the one that's going to be replaced.
[1:33:15] All right. Which one is the one that D could not see when they did this when they did the walk? the one
[1:33:23] they did not see this.
[1:33:25] Okay.
[1:33:25] Because there's there's metal stacked all over it.
[1:33:28] Okay.
[1:33:29] Metal piles 20 ft high. So they did not get on the path.
[1:33:50] Stan, what is the C CU P in capital letters?
[1:33:55] The CDD or
[1:33:56] No, it's a CU cup.
[1:33:58] Oh, conditional use permit.
[1:34:02] Okay, sorry about that.
[1:34:06] In the future, I think we can get rid of the acronyms.
[1:34:14] [clears throat] I don't know.
[1:34:26] Based on everything that's been said here tonight,
[1:34:29] I'm sorry.
[1:34:30] Based on everything that's been said here tonight,
[1:34:33] I also have a question, Howard. It says here that this is something that I just received as well. it says here on this hearing for CIA 7 was recycled on March 20th, 2023 that I had not completed the fence along the scale. Well, Stan did say to me that he went back in that there is not there's not supposed to be a fence next to the scale.
[1:35:02] Right. Well, Stan, I actually asked about that and Stan said that is the way it's done. It's complete. It's not in violation. That one
[1:35:09] that was
[1:35:10] that one is good.
[1:35:11] It has not haven't been anything. This board has asked,
[1:35:14] right?
[1:35:14] We have not completed.
[1:35:15] Right. He confirmed that one's fine.
[1:35:17] Well, I know. But in this one, it does it's I'm just reading it says it's not complete.
[1:35:22] Right.
[1:35:23] If you listened earlier, that was the discussion and the things that was asked on June 23rd.
[1:35:29] Okay. And
[1:35:31] I had asked that he had I'm not even sure what the day was. It was like 30 days and then or two months and then John had brought up and they extended it. But my original motion that I made was that it went from the gate all the way across the scale area
[1:35:51] to cover all cover everything. But I didn't get a chance to go back and look through those minutes. said he found it in the minutes. Is that correct, Stan?
[1:36:01] And that was [snorts] discussed at your renewal with the select board in 20123.
[1:36:08] and it went back and forth and one of the board members had mentioned that because of the poor communications and lack of communication with the planning board, they really were left in a awkward position on knowing what needed to be done and what didn't need to be done. I don't agree with that.
[1:36:28] If I was required to put it in, I would have had to put it in.
[1:36:31] Well, we thought from day one that you need you need to be on this side of that scale and any of you were welcome to come down anytime you want. You need to be on this side of the scale to see the car that's coming down that road there to make that corner and safely pull in because I mean everybody's doing 50 60 miles an hour. If it was required me to put that in where the scale is, I would have done it.
[1:36:52] I would have had to do it. Well, you did object at the time, Sean, but the original conversation started with trees. All right. Because some of the trees that are existing because of the salt and stuff from the road have started to show was you would be able to if you're going slow enough, you could see up into your
[1:37:13] junkyard. Okay.
[1:37:15] So, you did object to it because of visual issues. you want if so it was decided at the time and I'd have to go back to the minutes but my memory recalls that from the scales north so from the end of the scale
[1:37:31] correct
[1:37:32] north and what you did because tried planting trees and it was not working as they decided to is you put up the rock granite stones or whatever they are which is between 6 and 7 ft which also gives it between 15 and 18, possibly even 20 ft from the road height.
[1:37:54] Correct.
[1:37:56] So that did satisfy that condition.
[1:38:00] Okay.
[1:38:08] Anyone else have any comments?
[1:38:18] I like to apply to concrete. U I'm not an expert, but I did in my 20s work eight years doing foundations and a lot of it was commercial. And if only half of the pad needs to be replaced, I know Lori had mentioned that the two pieces buted together. Normally what they do is they do a vertical cut, then they do a horizontal cut,
[1:38:43] then they epoxy at least one or multiple rubber keyways to seal the two slabs together. That's how they did it down here in the middle of the hill with the new water tank. They those got multiple rubber keyways between the footing, the wall, and the floor to keep the water inside of the tank.
[1:39:06] So
[1:39:08] hopefully
[1:39:09] so it can be done.
[1:39:10] But what you're saying it's an engineered system.
[1:39:13] Correct.
[1:39:14] Yes. And that's where Okay. And I know Junior Bruock very well. He would make all of that happen. But it has to be done correctly so any contaminants doesn't run between the two slabs.
[1:39:28] Right.
[1:39:29] Yep.
[1:39:29] Does that help, Sean?
[1:39:30] Yeah.
[1:39:55] I don't know about the
[1:39:59] the rest of the board. I'll put my two cents in here.
[1:40:05] Based on everything we're seeing
[1:40:09] and things not being done,
[1:40:13] I would recommend that we deny the recycler license and have him reapply
[1:40:21] and put everything on plans the way they're supposed to be
[1:40:26] instead of giving all these extensions. Sean,
[1:40:30] are you talking suspension until we have that?
[1:40:36] I mean, then he wouldn't necessarily have to reapply. Correct, Stan?
[1:40:46] I mean, I if we did that, I would also want something from the engineer for the concrete pad to say, "Yes, this is when it's going to be done." No if ends or buts because
[1:40:55] something in stone.
[1:40:56] Yes. something in writing from whoever is going to do it because when you hear it so many times that it's going to be done, it's going to be done. It's going to be done. I'm at the end of the it's going to be done. It's got to be done.
[1:41:12] If we deny my recycler license or close my door, I need the recycler license to sell parts and do that. If you give me an extension on it, I can work on the extension. And I can work on getting somebody Phil Rock and him to talk about the concrete pen. But if you if you deny the recyclers license and you shut it off today,
[1:41:33] can you get it in 30 days?
[1:41:36] I'm sorry.
[1:41:37] He asked for
[1:41:40] I don't you know I don't know if I can get Phil Rock to commit with everything he's got going in the holidays and everything on the concrete pad. I can have the I can talk to Mike. I can call Mike if you want to give me five minutes to talk with Mike and see if we can get everything on for the recyclers license on this piece of paper because as I said I didn't get that other piece of paper. I certainly wouldn't bringing you in a halfass print and then tell you that you know here's everything you wanted
[1:42:06] and give it to Stan and say here's everything you wanted and then try to pencil in whatever else.
[1:42:10] That's my concern Sean is everything should be on paper. It should be on paper, but everything you want is on these all three of these papers.
[1:42:21] So you're not being denied that it's not on the paper.
[1:42:24] They're all different and not one is accurate. So you can't
[1:42:29] out with out with what's not accurate.
[1:42:31] That information you have, Sean, all of this should be incorporated in that.
[1:42:36] I agree. Now that I know that 's what you want.
[1:42:39] And that's what an updated PL plan is. And that is specified in the statute when any there's any other changes an updated plot plan needs.
[1:42:49] Why did I pay somebody to do a boundary survey stand
[1:42:52] if you wanted a site map?
[1:42:54] But you again you needed the boundary survey to begin with because that's your base.
[1:43:00] Well, we've been telling me I need a boundary survey and that's what I paid Mike to do.
[1:43:03] And I admitted that is my own fault. Okay. But again, it is all in writing and that is why we put it in writing and you get a complete version of the findings of fact and the conclusion.
[1:43:18] I now have the findings of facts. I believe that I can work with Mike for Mike to get all three overlays of all everything in here
[1:43:25] onto a complete site map showing you every building every building is on that map. It just doesn't show you where the detention ponds on it are and it doesn't name them. But I have I have what you're looking for now to say this is this is this. If you can give me 60 days of continuence on the recycling license, I will come back
[1:43:48] and I will check with Stan to see if we can get it done quicker. [laughter] We'll have it all drawn out on that site map. So you have all three versions on one map with everything there. Then the only thing we have to deal with is the
[1:44:01] And I do I do know the surveyor are straight out. We have one that the planning board's going to have to deny the application because they have dragged it out over 3 months and they still don't have any idea when they're going to complete the rest of it. I have heard from Mike Lon because I'm waiting for one other thing with the property where the firebond is.
[1:44:25] He is still behind, but he's working on it. So, in Still Water, between his vacations and prior obligations, [laughter] he's behind. And now he's probably got the cold and flu that every single one of us have already had. So, 60 days, I think, is reasonable. And if you don't have the things, and I'm not going to tell the board how to vote, but then at that point, you may put in a stipulation that if you do not have those items within 60 days, that
[1:44:55] it would most likely result in a denial.
[1:44:59] Okay.
[1:45:00] And how long would it take for him to reapply?
[1:45:03] Reapply again is between 60 and 90 days.
[1:45:11] I take make phone. So, we let him we let him go back to and it's got nothing to do with anything. Sean, I don't want to put you out of business. I don't want people to lose their jobs, not work.
[1:45:21] But,
[1:45:24] he needs to do it. He's had three and a half, four years to do it. He's had, you know, he had this piece of paper. He knew what it was. It's not our fault that he didn't read it. He had all the conditions. And then we'll give him another 30, 40 days, 60 days, and then
[1:45:46] and he's out there calling Mike Long. But and I agree with you, the lack of information. It isn't because of lack of information. All right? And this is why the town has taken the approach of the full disclosure
[1:46:02] of law exactly the way it would be written if we were presenting it to a judge in court. All right. So the information is there. The problem has been it's always been delayed,, delayed. Nobody's ever asked for definitive time frames and specific
[1:46:22] deadlines or criterias. The boards are now doing that.
[1:46:28] It isn't Sean's fault. Again, it is because you didn't have the advising people that you have now working for you to show you the direction of where we need to go. So, it does put you in a really bad position, but you're getting the time frames and the criterias met.
[1:46:48] I wouldn't go another six months. I would not go another two years. But again, it's because of bad habits. You've heard me say this have been ongoing and ongoing and ongoing and it's time to break the bad habits.
[1:47:02] So, let me ask you this. Is it possible to do a we will have this information no later than 60 days. If we don't have it, 's automatically suspended.
[1:47:16] Well, it's not suspended. You still have to
[1:47:20] you
[1:47:20] I have another hearing.
[1:47:22] When you vote, you can vote. You need to have this in 60 days. Okay. You can say that the potential outcome will be you're revoking it, but you have to have a public hearing in order to do that.
[1:47:35] That 's what I was asking is if we have to go through another public hearing.
[1:47:38] You got it. Thank you, Mike. But again, I think it's reasonable, but I there's been a lot of lack of communication here and there and a lack of information to the boards as well as Sean and the proper way to do things.
[1:47:56] So, you can have
[1:48:00] what' you find out?
[1:48:02] Mike says we get it done within 60 days. So, can we just push forward? He says he does not he did not have a list of everything that you're asking, you know, the 16 conditions and all of that. He did not have any of that. He said he was going to call tomorrow morning, speak with me, speak with Stan. He says some of the stuff from Oak needs to be overlaid and changed.
[1:48:25] He get down there and survey the ponds where they are and put all the ponds on there so we can bring it right up to date. He said, "But I've been asking him for [1:48:34] every bit of information you've got right there,
[1:48:38] it's got to be on there."
[1:48:39] And I agree. And we didn't know we had to have that.
[1:48:43] I don't know where the miscommunication come from. I am deaf. I'll agree to that. But I did not get that. the 15 pieces that you have here. I did not get
[1:48:55] the emails.
[1:49:01] I didn't hear you on that. June 29th, 2026 at 8:47 a.m. It got emailed to you from the board.
[1:49:11] It got mailed to me personally as CIA salvage or to Shan Gerard
[1:49:18] like I said.
[1:49:21] Yeah. So I don't get every email. Diane, the office administrator, goes through the emails and I apologize for that. That's nobody's fault but my own. But I thought I had to have a boundary survey. So, I don't want to hear a I didn't get it anymore because at some point, you know, if your office staff is getting it
[1:49:43] and not giving it to you, are still getting it.
[1:49:47] You're just not
[1:49:49] getting
[1:49:49] it's not on the town because when you say, "Well, I didn't get any excuses for anybody. I'm here and you know what my feelings are and you know what I did and what I didn't do."
[1:49:58] Right. But Sean, when you keep saying, "Well, I never got this." That puts it on the count that we never provided.
[1:50:03] That's important. Then you guys should you guys have to have her do it and they should sign it. Just maybe my email was down that month. Who knows?
[1:50:12] You can't guarantee that you know something that's holding up my livelihood and 26 other guys livelihoods came through an email and you can assume that it got read.
[1:50:20] But Stan also handd delivered it. So,
[1:50:24] and if you at some point you have to take accountability for
[1:50:28] someone should have said to me Sean this isn't within a row of roses that this is what they want.
[1:50:35] But at some point you have to
[1:50:38] I'm can take be accountable for my mistakes
[1:50:42] but the board should be accountable that if I didn't get an email I didn't get an email.
[1:50:46] But Stan handd delivered it. So that negates even the email. We I still don't know when staying hand delivered it.
[1:50:55] But also that night that we went over these, you talked to us, Sean, about not getting an extension. You'd have to you'd have to close on temporary basis. That would to me as a business owner, if I was looking at closing my doors, I'd be very concerned.
[1:51:15] I am very concerned that you wanted a site man. And if I hadn't heard from the select board within 10 or 14 days of what my requirements were.
[1:51:26] If you look at the violations that Stan wrote me up for. Okay. Let's let's dig let's dig a little deeper. Let's find the Stan gave me. I don't know if I got it.
[1:51:39] All of the notice of decision, findings of fact, and conclusion of law is based on the minutes that was transcribed of that meeting. So, you were present when all of this was discussed as well. Regardless, again, who's to blame, whether you received it, whether you noticed it, Sean, I've already said you've got a revolving business over there,
[1:52:04] and I have repeated
[1:52:05] I take responsibility 100%. We just got to figure out where we're going to go to fix it.
[1:52:09] One of the things I've repeated to you since June, if not even longer, is I want to focus on Route Five so that you don't have to deal with this over and over, but you have answers that you can supply and we can get through this without this back and forth. All right?
[1:52:28] And I understand that s there is no blame. Okay? So,
[1:52:32] I'm not blaming anybody. I'm just saying I did not get thatif that
[1:52:37] again maybe you didn't. All right. It's irrelevant at this point. You're asking for 60 days. It is up to the select board to now make a decision if they don't have any other questions. I wouldn't go with defending this anymore. We already realize there's a glitch somewhere. So, we'll just own it. And
[1:52:56] I would ask the board to please give me 60 days on the recycling license. I spoke with Mike the surveyor. He will get you everything on that print is the day I have it just like the day I had it today or the la the other day I gave it to Stan immediately and if there's something on there that's not there that we don't have we'd be happy to get it.
[1:53:19] So, can we get a standing comm commitment, a written commitment from a from a lab that they're going to come out and sample prior to June 30th for that
[1:53:30] within that 60 days?
[1:53:31] Within that 60 days,
[1:53:32] it wouldn't even go 60. That'd make it like 40 45 days. 45 days
[1:53:37] before the end of the year.
[1:53:38] Well, make it 60 days that I got to come back here.
[1:53:42] You know what I mean? Put it down that I got to work with Mike. I asked Mike if he could get it done within the 30 to 60 day period. He said yes. We'll set a date that I can come back here and we start over. What if we do it that all of the information documentation needs to be to Stan no later than December 31st
[1:54:05] and then December well December 29th. And then this way we can set the new hearing on the next hearing on December 29th.
[1:54:17] That only gives me 30 days. Correct.
[1:54:20] 45
[1:54:22] 45.
[1:54:26] What we're talking about, Sean, you don't have to go out and do surveying and anything else can help you.
[1:54:30] No, he has to overlay all of that. But what you guys understand is he has to also get part of it from Oak Engineering, which I no longer do business with. And he also has to get part of it from Still Water Environmental.
[1:54:44] This is all done on a computer.
[1:54:46] I understand that.
[1:54:47] And that's what Mike says. He says he can get it done.
[1:54:50] All right. So
[1:54:52] So we plan on being back here in 60 days.
[1:54:55] No, you just said the gentleman said he could get it done and we're saying 45 days. You're saying the guy can get it done. Why do we need an extra 50?
[1:55:05] As soon as it's done, I'll give it to St. Just like I did that. Imagine in a few days if he called and they could email it over to him, he would have it in a day or two. Anything and then all he'd have to do is put it
[1:55:15] or even four weeks because they are busy. So, you know, but I think because
[1:55:24] the majority of it is done. It just has to be put together.
[1:55:31] It's not like it's starting from scratch. It's not a start from scratch plot plan. It's not All the conditions have to be met.
[1:55:41] Yep. Yep.
[1:55:43] Those 15 conditions on the back here,
[1:55:45] but the but the concrete pad, we need something in writing saying that it's
[1:55:53] guaranteed that it's going to be done at a certain time.
[1:55:56] Yeah. The sampling, right?
[1:55:57] Yeah.
[1:55:58] Yeah. So that we can Yeah. Well, the sampling and the contractor,
[1:56:03] right, for the concrete pad, we can't have sampling, you know, in writing, but a lab is going to come out and sample on June 1.
[1:56:13] But I neglected to talk to Mr. Broulard, and he's not going to be able to pencil me in until October 31st. I mean, we need writing stating things are going to fall into place. This is going to be set up by the deadlines.
[1:56:32] We do have in writing where Sean has committed to have the pad done. However, the engineer has designed it or the requirements of it by June 30th of 2026.
[1:56:44] But I want it from the engineer. I want it from
[1:56:47] the engineer needs to get us the design standards and experience specifications.
[1:56:52] Yes. And what happens if we just let it slide and it got to June and then he didn't have it done and then the state said ah we'll give you another 6 months or we'll give you another year we'll give you this we'll give you that which has been going on since
[1:57:08] you guys shouldn't even be involved in the concrete that was something we had between us and
[1:57:13] but it became part of the agreement and therefore it's part of it. So, whatever is agreed on at this point, the board agrees whatever the dates are. When you make your decision, it is all recorded. I will transcribe it or download it as it is recorded and the findings of fact and conclusion of law and the conditions of approval will be written just as you see them there.
[1:57:38] If these deadlines are met, then he's gets a notice of violation
[1:57:45] and then he has 30 days to appeal. If it's an appealable violation and if it doesn't mitigate or rectify the violation, then the board has to by statute have another public hearing for any potential discipline action
[1:58:07] or up to revoked
[1:58:11] or licenses. So again, Sean doesn't want to go that far, but it's it isn't a matter of anymore. It was just again a lot of bad habits and the previous ways we did it and now we're learning to do it the right way that notice the decision conclusion findings of that with the conditions of approval
[1:58:35] of a binding thing that can uphold in court. So that's why we're doing it way down.
[1:58:46] So if he's not done, if he's not done by the end of December, 45 days,
[1:58:53] then that means he's done. Do we still we have to have a public hearing after that? We have to keep continue it going. If there's a chance you're going to revoke or deny the recycling license, the statute requires the board to have a part. The reason is because DMV and D
[1:59:14] and all parties of interest in Sean need to be notified and allowed or aware that there is a potential in what is going to be. I mean, I could I could live with I could live with extending it to December 31st, [laughter] [cough]
[1:59:35] provided we get the required information by that by that time. I mean, it's
[1:59:41] when will we have the next hearing? If you extend it to December 31st, when is the hearing going to be signed? The 1 of January or that's that's the question I have. I mean, I would like to if you're going to extend it, extend it to the next meeting, the first meeting in January.
[1:59:57] I know you want 45 days, but why don't we extend it so that it goes right to
[2:00:01] What's 45 days from right now?
[2:00:05] The 31st.
[2:00:06] The 31st.
[2:00:09] When? Yes. But on the 31st, it's going to expire. And then you're going to have a meeting in what 's the first meeting in January? I can get into
[2:00:19] January.
[2:00:19] What's the What is wrong with setting this up and saying we're going to have another hearing on the 31st of December and all this material has to be
[2:00:30] because that's a Thursday and the budget committee is going to be crunching.
[2:00:33] Jesus Christ, I'm not even thinking about all of these.
[2:00:37] Pardon me.
[2:00:38] So the [sighs]
[2:00:45] I don't go anywhere for New Year, but I
[2:00:50] Yeah. [2:00:55] so what if we did? What if we did the fourth?
[2:01:03] What are you going to be available?
[2:01:10] So, do we want to set a hearing for that date?
[2:01:14] It's a Monday.
[2:01:15] Yes.
[2:01:18] Does it have to be another public hearing or could it be just
[2:01:21] be another public hearing like we're having tonight
[2:01:25] and all of this material including what was asked for
[2:01:30] and this has to be here by that night. If not it's over.
[2:01:36] Okay.
[2:01:39] And that includes the engineering
[2:01:42] guaranteed that they're going to do it. The day
[2:01:45] I can't give you the engineering because we have to go back and they're still going to be working on that. There's no way
[2:01:50] confirmation from the engineer that they
[2:01:54] work on site, not the blueprint that they're going to be working on site,
[2:01:58] right? But we want confirmation that they will be able to complete it by the deadline of June. a letter from Still Water stating that they'll be working with us on site
[2:02:09] and that we can finish by
[2:02:12] June 30th of 27.
[2:02:14] We need that we're
[2:02:16] complete what
[2:02:17] I don't feel we need that because if we're setting a date this has to be done
[2:02:23] I could care what's
[2:02:24] he can't get the concrete pad in by December 31st.
[2:02:27] No, we need to we need to put it in there and it needs to be in writing and we need to make sure that he gets
[2:02:33] confirmation from the engineer. confirmation from the lab that the soil will be tested by June 31st.
[2:02:40] By June 30th.
[2:02:41] By June 30th, rather that these
[2:02:46] professional people on their letterhead will give you and us a commitment date
[2:02:55] for completion.
[2:02:59] What are we doing with these plans?
[2:03:01] That has to be done before the 31st.
[2:03:05] That has to be done by the 31st of December.
[2:03:08] But we're sitting June 4th
[2:03:11] for the for the
[2:03:12] Yeah. January 4th hearing.
[2:03:14] Yeah.
[2:03:14] To for Sean to present us the material
[2:03:17] site plan all has to be combined by June by January 4th.
[2:03:22] Right.
[2:03:22] Before January meeting.
[2:03:24] Yes.
[2:03:27] So can I just marrow?
[2:03:31] Okay. What time is the public hearing?
[2:03:34] Six o'clock.
[2:03:35] 6 o'clock. Okay.
[2:03:37] My request is that you get the material before that meeting on the 4th so you have time to review it and the entire packet of all this material has been distributed to all interested parties or available to all interested parties because tonight part of the problems are that
[2:03:57] you were looking at this last minute. It was only provided to the code enforcement officers today with the details of some locations of operations. But
[2:04:10] wasn't just today.
[2:04:11] No, the operations were put on there today. It but isn't it fair
[2:04:16] the 30 to have it to stand by the
[2:04:19] have your material at the end of December and gives you four, five, six days to look at it.
[2:04:25] Yeah. So have it stand no later than
[2:04:28] close of business on December 31st.
[2:04:31] That gives you the 45 days.
[2:04:33] Yeah.
[2:04:33] To get your material together for us to review it and then 5 days out from there we'll
[2:04:40] have that public hearing.
[2:04:42] Have that public hearing and work together.
[2:04:46] Agreed.
[2:04:47] Yes, Dan.
[2:04:48] Awesome.
[2:04:49] So clarify the motion.
[2:04:53] You're asking for the plan to be completed by December 31st along with a written commitment from Stillwater Engineering regarding that the PD will be completed along the testing of the soils by June 30th
[2:05:14] of 2027.
[2:05:17] make sure you guys close the public hearing so you can vote on that. that
[2:05:24] well [clears throat] environmental is already
[2:05:30] I mean D has already given the has given the extension they're not going to be able to do it in the winter in the middle of winter
[2:05:37] I realize that
[2:05:38] so they're going to have to get it scheduled but if we can get a commitment from the engineer that it will be done once that time comes It's not done
[2:05:53] game over they will work with us to do it
[2:05:57] on January 4th when you make your final decision. One of the conditions of approval should it be approved will be that the pad and the soil testing will be completed by
[2:06:14] it. The conditions of approval on January 4th if it's approved will be u that all of the pad and any testing of the soils will be completed by June 30th
[2:06:28] 2027. Yes.
[2:06:30] 2027. fully completed.
[2:06:32] Completed to commission is the best way to put it. So he can't use it until it's completed, but
[2:06:40] yes,
[2:06:46] I was thinking
[2:06:50] he can't
[2:06:56] as it is written on. he's going to be able to use the pad that he's got until that time. Is that what you're saying?
[2:07:04] Yes. Until that time. The other thing, the reason, another reason to consider June 30th is when Sean is in the process of replacing and testing this soil, the area is going to be restricted from his normal everyday business. So he needs to plan a little bit around that and be able to still operate
[2:07:27] at some minimal efficiency. So that gives the town a commitment date that's part of a conditional use which is in writing and it's binding and it will also allow Shawn to get with his people and communicate to make sure that he doesn't completely stall his business or create another issue with his business.
[2:07:52] So December 31st. Oh, sorry.
[2:07:54] In that time frame that you're talking on that pad, he's basically not going to be able to use once he takes that other one out. He's not going to be able to use that pad for a month.
[2:08:05] Not Well, it's under construction. It's not
[2:08:07] well and curing.
[2:08:09] Well, and that's going to be part of your engineer's report. What's the time frame to commission?
[2:08:15] But it has to be installed and completed by June 30.
[2:08:20] So if he plans on using it July 1st, then whatever the curing time is or the setting up time, it will have to be done prior to that. But June 30th is the deadline to commission, which means to be able to be used.
[2:08:40] Basically, anything I'll say after from Easter on
[2:08:46] is things are going to be moving.
[2:08:50] And that allows Sean and the engineers to plan accordingly. As long as they commit and they get it done by June 30th, however they do it, is their issue, not the town.
[2:09:03] Yep.
[2:09:05] Yep. So, plot plan with all of the required information no later than December 31st
[2:09:15] and then the testing and confirmation by the 31st by the engineers for the soil testing pad completion and pad actual pad completion to commission no later than June 30th. and hearing set for January 4th.
[2:09:46] All right. You want to close out the meeting and we can vote on that? Close out the hearing and then we can vote.
[2:09:54] Okay. All those in favor closing.
[2:10:03] So 804.
[2:10:08] I would make a motion that we
[2:10:15] grant an extension on the conditional use permit.
[2:10:23] Don't you guys do my recycling license?
[2:10:26] Oh, that's what I mean. Not the condition. Yes, the
[2:10:32] long day. on the recycling permit. until December 31st or should we do January 4th?
[2:10:43] January 4th. [music] until January 4th, 2027
[2:10:48] pending all of the items in the previous
[2:10:56] conditional use. the conditions we need to have the
[2:11:05] confirmation.
[2:11:07] No.
[2:11:09] Oh, it's a long night. You said conditional use.
[2:11:13] I did say conditional use. Somebody else has to do this because my brain is has turned to mush at this point.
[2:11:19] You want a completed?
[2:11:21] Yes.
[2:11:22] Yes. December 31st to allow time for the board to review
[2:11:26] along with all the conditions
[2:11:30] and along with all of the conditions that are existing as well as a written commitment from the engineers that the prep pad or the pad that's used for processing is completed to commissionable by June 30th of 2027.
[2:11:52] Yes. What Stan said
[2:11:59] to make that motion.
[2:12:04] So moved.
[2:12:07] Does that count?
[2:12:10] That's longwinded. Okay, hang on.
[2:12:13] Okay, I'll make it.
[2:12:14] Okay, thank you.
[2:12:19] Make a motion that all drawings, all conditions of approval as stated in the June 23rd, 2026
[2:12:33] approval,
[2:12:37] notice of decision and the and the notice of decision have to be met
[2:12:46] by
[2:12:49] December 31st.
[2:12:52] And we will hold a public hearing January 4th
[2:13:00] to determine
[2:13:03] whether or not there will be a renewal.
[2:13:08] Yeah.
[2:13:09] Oh, and the concrete. Well,
[2:13:11] I'd like to amend that to cover the engineers and labs written agreement to facilitate the concrete pad by June 30th.
[2:13:34] Second.
[2:13:36] Okay. All in favor?
[2:13:40] You all set?
[2:13:41] Yeah. You
[2:13:42] sure?
[2:13:43] I'll listen to the reporting.
[2:13:46] [laughter]
[2:13:50] Motion to adjourn.
[2:13:52] Second.
[2:13:53] All in favor?
[2:13:55] Good night.
[2:13:56] Have a good night. Stan, do you want to use your program to transcribe?