Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:02] Brendan (Chair): Okay, I'd like to call this meeting to order of the York Planning Board for October 22nd, 2026. First of all, on the agenda, we have maybe we have a couple more agendas up there if anybody needs one. And first of all, the quorum, we do have a quorum tonight. I'll introduce the members. From my left is Crystal Tenney. I'm Wayne Boardman, Board Chair. Next to me is David Woods, who is a vice chair, and we also have Steve Friedman. So field changes, none? All right. Public forum. Okay. Public forum is the part of the meeting where anybody is welcome to ask questions or make comments regarding any topic that's not on tonight's agenda so tonight's agenda what we do have is york river landscaping final site plan we have 62 brave boat harbor road and open space conservation subdivision concept conceptual review and the third one is 1680 us U.S. Route 1, a sketch plan. So if you have any comment or questions that does not pertain to those three, which we are likely to have public hearings on certainly the second one and the rest is up to the board. Okay, is there anybody who wishes to speak at the public forum? okay seeing none I will close the public forum and we'll go right on to our first item on the agenda is York River landscaping and Brendan oh I forgot to introduce Brendan Somerville our town planner and our recording secretary working from YouTube is a very patient patience Horton and yes, so Brendan, would you please set this up for us?
[2:19] Drew Olahowski: Thank you, Mr. Chair. First item up is York River Landscaping. This item was previously approved in May of 2026 and reopened by the Board on the 24th of September for a waiver request for the Route 1 landscaping performance standards in 6310. The Board requested that the applicant return with revised materials to get closer to the 75-point goal, and the applicant has provided two plans for the Board's review, one with 70 points and one with 77 points respectively at this time staff believes that there is ample information for the board to determine whether a waiver is needed for the landscaping requirements and a representative of the applicant is here to discuss the differences between the plan okay and please introduce yourself
[3:01] Brendan (Chair): spell your last name for the recording secretary please thank you
[3:04] Joe Coronati: Drew Olahowski with Haley Ward and that's OLEHOWSKI so thank you Brendan for the introduction as mentioned we did provide two plans one with 70 points which is just short of the 75 required and one with 77 which is just over the requirement as you'll see there's very little changes between the two plans the only difference is those seven points which is resulted from seven shrubs which are included on one plan which aren't on the other and speaking with our landscape architect both designs are feasible and practical she does believe that the 70 point option is a bit more attractive just because there's a bit less plantings crammed into that one small landscaped area out front so we believe that either option is feasible so I did want to allow the board to make that decision on if you would want to go with the one that meets the standard or the one that might look a more a bit more aesthetically pleasing so again both plans very similar but I just want to provide options for the board to choose from and is it just that one plant so it's seven additional yep the mound black chokeberry which is a 18 inch high shrub so I think even with the addition of those it's not gonna really help with screening much more because it is a low-lying shrub but again it's it was there to meet that ordinance standard so we did what we had to do and again just for general
[4:36] Brendan (Chair): information the point system could you quickly brendan just describe what we're what we're
[4:43] Drew Olahowski: talking about when we talk about the point system right so article 6 310 in the zoning ordinance prescribes landscaping standards for route one for route one zones depending on per x number of linear feet that you have a frontage or on your side or rear you're required to have a certain number of plant unit or plant points as i call them to satisfy the requirement existing plants are given as a buffering as a buffering yes existing plants are given preference so mature existing trees are we encouraged we encourage developers to retain those and where they cannot not retain them we encourage new plantings in this case there is a significant amount of foliage that would be retained by the applicant the only area that was of some concern was the front buffer yard which in this case when the board previously met was 20 points behind that equates to either one mature tree or two newly planted trees and there's some other ways of getting there too between flowering shrubs and just small shrubberies themselves
[5:56] Brendan (Chair): between
[6:06] Andrew Schlunz: the plans the 77 and the 70 so I feel as though I forget which plan a and plan B but looking at the plan the one proposed with the 77 seven points looks a bit congested so if we were to look at the plan and then view that against aesthetics if you will i think i'm swaying more towards the 70 points because i know it was a difficult and i had to get pretty creative so i do appreciate that 's
[6:59] Joe Coronati: kind of where my thought process is at the moment the plan that was proposed the last time you were here do you remember how many points that have had off it was 50. so we added one sweet gum tree which was 10 points and then i believe it was five or so of the korean lilacs which was another 10 points to get up to that 70. and again our landscape architect is confident that either option would ultimately work it's again just the 70 would probably look a bit nicer the
[7:35] Brendan (Chair): other plants i can't exactly tell how the other plants are going to be arranged what i have on my screen with the existing plants and that line going to be spread out or simply a open space left from the plants that you would be taking out of the other plan
[8:01] Joe Coronati: i'm not sure i'm following that question are you talking about in that front island we're proposing the new sweet gum trees yes based on what i'm seeing it's a void where those wouldn't be so they're under the shade of one of the trees yeah and then it's connecting the two the shrubbery line right in here this void okay those was it five plants yeah there's seven okay right there so i think really the only people that are going to see it are the
[8:42] Brendan (Chair): two cars that park in that spot yes yeah and you do appreciate the sweet gum tree that is a native and it's well known as a good street tree so we appreciate using native whenever possible Okay. Well, what's the Board wish to do? We could discuss this more, we could ask for additional information, or we could offer a motion. motion.
[9:22] Joe Coronati: I was thinking the waivers that they had requested, are they, one of them would be applicable because they're not meeting the exact count, correct? Right, so I believe
[9:35] Drew Olahowski: the waiver is just for 6310 as a whole, which is all of the landscaping requirements.
[9:55] Andrew Schlunz: So what would, in this instance, what would the waiver? So the waiver would be for meeting
[10:03] Drew Olahowski: that 75 points requirement so if the board wanted to elect to go with a 70 point plan then you would need right but
[10:14] Joe Coronati: it would be a more focused waiver on that one requirement as opposed to the broader landscape waiver
[10:23] Drew Olahowski: in a way six three ten is just all of the landscaping the buffer yards requirements the plant unit ordinance is kind of spread throughout that so it include six three ten one two three four and five okay i think one important issue is that
[10:43] Brendan (Chair): with that ordinance if any trees or bushes die with a certain amount of time they have to
[10:51] Drew Olahowski: be replaced that is correct five years five years five or two yes depending on the size
[11:01] Brendan (Chair): that is correct so the important thing is if there was some failure of those in anywhere on the law that they would be replaced being a landscape company I'm sure they could think of something wouldn't be a good look first landscape company to have dying trees anyway
[11:28] Joe Coronati: way with one section 6 3 10.3 dot 2 an existing site covered with natural vegetation shall retain such vegetation sites that do not have existing vegetation that is equal to or greater than 75 plant units per 100 linear feet of plot line or fraction thereof shall provide a minimum plant of 75 units per 100 lineal feet of lot line. My preference would just be if we're going to wave it, just do that section specifically. I'm not sure if you have a different perspective, Brendan. I'm not sure if that's what they're using where it already has existing vegetation, how they came up with the 75.
[12:23] Drew Olahowski: No, the 75 is just based off of the frontage itself. itself okay playing units required per 100 feet they have a little over 100 feet of frontage so 75 points is required for this zone okay that would be six three ten dot three good
[12:56] Brendan (Chair): as part of the as part of the motion could we include information on exactly what we are either the particular plants or the description of what's being done along with the waiver of the particular section?
[13:27] Joe Coronati: Yeah, my thought to that would be to waive 6.3.10.3 to reduce the front planting count to 70.
[13:39] Andrew Schlunz: That should work. Specifically. Yeah, I don't think we need to get into details of shrubs and trees.
[13:44] Joe Coronati: That should do it. Or the plant units is the... Then... Points. On your plan sets, are there any... Sorry, did I cut you off?
[14:01] Andrew Schlunz: Go ahead. No, I was saying 70 points.
[14:04] Joe Coronati: Yeah, points are... The ordinance says plant units, so I...
[14:14] Drew Olahowski: I use points as a term of art in this case just because it's a little bit easier to say than plant units.
[14:24] Joe Coronati: So this isn't an amendment, this was a reopening of a previously approved or continuation of. That is correct. So the final, we would have to grant a waiver.
[14:36] Drew Olahowski: Granting a waiver followed by final approval.
[14:41] Brendan (Chair): Sure. Go ahead if you like.
[14:44] Joe Coronati: I move to waive 6.3.10.3 to reduce the plant units to 70 per the 70-point provided plan set, C-5A.
[15:02] Brendan (Chair): Second. Okay, it's been moved by David, seconded by Crystal. Any other discussion? Okay, we'll call for a vote. Crystal? Yes. David? yes steve yes chair votes yes 4-0 and then final approval do we have i got this i
[15:30] Joe Coronati: moved to grant final approval for york river landscaping map 59 lot 19 for
[15:41] Brendan (Chair): final review second okay moved by david seconded by crystal any other discussion Okay, call for vote. Crystal? Yes. David? Yes. Steve? Yes. Chair votes yes. Board zero. We're all set. Thank you. Thank you for sticking with it. Yeah, appreciate that. Tell your landscaper she did great. Okay, next up, 62 Bray and Boat Harbor Road, Open Space Conservation Subdivision Conceptual Review, Mappinlot 87-12A. thank you mr chair so this is a probably get closer to the microphones okay thank you we should do better but these microphones don't pick up very far away so this is a conceptual
[16:40] Drew Olahowski: phase for a proposed 22-unit open space conservation subdivision on 66 acres at 62 Braveboat Harbor. The current proposal includes placing 44 acres of the land or 60% into dedicated open space with the York Land Trust holding 35 acres and the homeowners association holding the remaining six. The staff reports have highlighted some concerns about the current proposal particularly with respect to the separate easement or ownership of the open space, the relationship between the significant vernal pools and the development itself and the lot boundaries or orientation within the conceptual plan okay
[17:21] Brendan (Chair): would you before we get started would you kind of summarize [Joe Coronati: to] get it on the yes the whole thing the tripod and everything then
[17:53] Joe Coronati: yes it would be I'll be helpful
[18:00] Drew Olahowski: So before
[18:08] Brendan (Chair): we get started This is an open space conservation subdivision. Therefore. There's certain Steps that were required by the ordinance to take the first step is the conceptual review and what's Describe What's the purpose of the conceptual review and why is it first?
[18:28] Drew Olahowski: so the conceptual phase of the review is to design the open space itself it's a little bit different from your traditional subdivision pattern where you design the built environment first within the landscape environment or the natural environment in this case you design the open space first to protect your highly vulnerable or valuable natural resources and then you then you design the actual built environment this is phase one where we do a yield plan which is a conceptual how many theoretical lots could this site hold and then that goes into the design portion where after the open space has been decided and what kind of conservation theme has been decided then you start looking at what the orientation and lot counts are with the reduced allowed reduced lot size that the ordinance allows so after were an application to get approval then the following this phase, they would go to preliminary and then final approval. So it's a three-phase process.
[19:32] Brendan (Chair): Yes, so in other words, tonight we're just talking about a conceptual review. We don't even wanna see an actual plan of the subdivision. We're strictly looking at the land and its resources and what's the most valuable part of the land to devote to protected conservation status and then later on in further steps if this gets approved later steps only then will we look at exactly how many how many units can fit on the on the property as far as you know all the other details and constrictions on the property and again, the yield plan can be confusing to some people not familiar with it because, well, you deal with it every day. So I'll give it to you again to describe what the yield plan is right up front.
[20:34] Drew Olahowski: So with this type of subdivision development, you are allowed to reduce the minimum lot size to as low as 20,000 square feet, which is just under half an acre. The yield plan looks at it looks at a piece of property to say how much could this support without that reduction? So with this particular zone you're looking at a two to three acre minimum for each lot So each lot shown on the yield plan would be two to three acres as it would be maximum saying this is what we can Do without conserving any land And that's what the yield plan is after that you strip it down to you condense it from there
[21:11] Brendan (Chair): And so the yield we're looking for is how many dwellings could actually be put on it. Then we've got to worry about how it could be done and where it could be done. Yes. Okay. I hope I set that up correctly for you and for everybody else to understand. So would you first introduce yourselves and spell your last name for the recording secretary?
[21:40] Joe Coronati: Yes, certainly. Joe Coronati with Jones & Beach Engineers. Oh, yes. Here we go. Joe Coronati with Jones & Beach Engineers. Spell your last name, please. It's, last name is C-O-R-O-N-A-T-I. I'll give you a card if it's easier.
[22:03] Jenna Green: Jenna Green with Rutland Investments, G-R-E-E-N.
[22:10] Joe Coronati: We've been before you in the past with the phase one of this development this is jenna is the owner of green and company they're working on currently constructing the homes that were approved in phase one of the harbor woods development which is just adjacent to this property separated by an old trolley line property that runs between them but so tonight is the first hearing of i guess what would call phase two of harbor woods and we submitted a set of plans to start this process the first set of plans or the first plan i guess that to be discussed is as brendan mentioned as the open space layout on the property so the second page in your plan set and i have a couple of copies if anybody needs anything up here but the second page this overview existing with open space plan shows you the area the property that's been proposed as open space on the entire looking at the entire parcel this also looks at the parcel to the west which would be phase one And we're showing the area that's already in conservation to the east, which is the Rachel Carson easement property, to show you how all these properties align and to give you the big picture, I guess, of what the open space area that we're proposing would look like. We go on to the next page in the set. And if it's helpful, I can stand up there and flip pages. Sure. You can actually bring that microphone with you and I am a lot and I'm not too loud or loud enough, I guess Would that be easier to use then he's
[24:28] Brendan (Chair): gonna be on the other side
[24:45] Joe Coronati: So as the plan set goes on the next page is a more detailed version of the of the existing conditions. This plan shows you in more detail the topography, the wetlands, the vernal pools, which ones have larger setbacks because of the status being significant and which ones do not. This is basically our existing site resource map, which is the requirement in your conservation subdivision. How we proceed is to provide you with the areas on the site that have environmental sensitivities. This provides you with an idea of where the wetlands are, the setbacks, which wetlands have setbacks. this particular property is it's got a little bit of everything going on it's it's a large property it's completely vacant of buildings it's on brave boat Harbor Road there is an access kind of a trail type access old logging road the previous owners did a lot of selective cutting over the years. And so there are some access roads throughout the property, but the entire property is basically wooded. There's different slopes we've highlighted on the plan. The areas that are hatched are the steep slope sections. So when we looked at the areas to basically preserve, put into open space or put into deed restriction so they wouldn't be developed we targeted the areas that have obviously the wetlands steep slopes leading to the wetlands the vernal pools and then as you go further into the property you get a lot of the same as you go back deeper into the lot a couple vernal pools the main the most significant vernal pools are in the rear of the property which is why that was one of the reasons that was targeted as the as the priority area to create open space and then at the very end of the property we actually have frontage on a title estuary so that was so clearly it started our open space layout really started from the rear of the property and started to look as to what came forward and as you can tell the tidal estuary being in the rear then these significant vernal pools as we come up slope that was the I guess the highest resource area on the lot which coincides with basically coincides exactly with what we were targeting for open space looking once again back at the back at the entire parcel this is the title side of the estuary you can see the wetlands in blue these are those vernal pools hopefully you guys can see this but you see on your own plans there and these four vernal pools are the ones that are targeted for the open space and the title and we understand we have additional ones at the entrance but you just sometimes you have to get by the we have to look at the most important and the most sensitive ones first and we realize the ones that are right up by the road are not as I guess significant as the ones that are in the back that connect directly to the title areas and the other open space areas this does provide you with as you can tell it's a little faded on this plan but the basically a start of a corridor across these properties this to put in perspective this the area on phase two open space is just over 40 acres phase one i think was about 12 acres and then i don't know exact size of the rachel carson and but that's much larger and then continues on so it's a it's a good I guess continuation of the open space and connectivity and that was our goal I don't know if you want me to go any further I know you have to look at the again I think tonight the goal is to approve the open space layout and then we can start to discuss the next aspects of the plan the yield plan and then hopefully the conservation layout and our goal would be to obviously move towards you know getting this is I guess a conceptual hearing and so not quite a sketch plan different slightly different process but we'd like to obviously from here we have to move on to preliminary design we'd like to tackle that as much as quick errors as much as we can tonight I guess
[30:29] Brendan (Chair): first of all any questions from the board we will have a hearing on this I'm not sure we've got whether we should stop and have a hearing on this part of it or wait until the yield plan is discussed or and we could have a second phase of the public hearing too there's no reason why we can't do that my
[30:59] Joe Coronati: thought would be to start off with a public hearing now where it's okay start a new application before we okay yes please do we probably need to accept the application for conception that's right what are the
[31:13] Brendan (Chair): considerations for acceptance brendan completeness i mean for completeness
[31:25] Joe Coronati: Chris did point out a few items yes he did yes
[31:39] Brendan (Chair): would you exist elucidate on the single existing site resource resources map you were discussing in your review Brendan I'm so Chris
[31:54] Drew Olahowski: pointed out that only two existing conditions plans had been submitted the ordinance anticipates that a plan identifies the significant ratchets of resources and also the proposed limits of the open space so he's in his own words that there is there's no single plan for the board to consider i believe you wanted to see the or what the ordinance is specifically calling for is kind of what this sheet is really where it's showing all of the existing conditions and the possible layout of the open space although on this sheet i don't believe that the second open space is shown One of the HOA would be proposed to own.
[32:35] Joe Coronati: Yeah, that's correct. Yeah, it is shown actually and It's not shaded the same color as the rest of it, but the HOA area is actually that there's a line that runs right through the site. So that is the that is shown be highlighted differently so that The proposal is that the rear of the property that's shaded in green would be owned by York Land Trust. Then the area that's owned by the Homeowners Association, we didn't shade that portion, but it's a different ownership, and that's something we wanted to discuss as well with you tonight. night
[33:28] Brendan (Chair): so it's the dark black dashed lines indicates the what you're proposing for
[33:35] Joe Coronati: a separate yes yeah we when we in discussions with york land trust they were not inclined to take ownership of that portion just because of its shape the topo of the land and the proximity to the proposed lots which i know we're not supposed to discuss but the there are proposed lots along that section and they wanted to obviously it's much easier for them and to worry about a kind of a to maintain and have to monitor one track of land when it starts to get long and sort of in people's backyards it's a little more challenging so they have and i've heard that from many conservation groups on properties as well so it's so we have two themes or two ownerships of the open spaces what we're proposing a large track that would be deeded to york land trust and then the smaller portion that would be retained by the
[34:39] Andrew Schlunz: hoa and monitored by them so what would their recommendation be to move forward with a possible public hearing in lieu of actual not having an actual plan for us to approve
[34:56] Brendan (Chair): well the as Brendan said the conceptual part the requirements for the conceptual part have to be complete before we could open a public hearing unless there's waverable aspects to that I don't know that's the process is to have to be able to make an informed discussion and this is this last issue of course is a big part of it we generally don't approve non-contiguous pieces of conserved land because it reduces the value of the conserved land so this would this would be something completely different and we generally don't we'll get into this later but it's not generally the process for having homeless association take responsibility for that either but we can deal with that later IF WE HAVE ENOUGH TO DISCUSS THE PLAN IN GENERAL OR SOME OF THE CHALLENGES OF WHERE THE OPEN SPACE IS AND IS NOT. WAS CHRIS SAYING, I WASN'T QUITE UNDERSTANDING, HE JUST WANTED THE WHOLE THING ON ONE MAP rather than having a split up like they do in the second part in order to provide more detail obviously it's a big parcel and getting anything like that on one page is difficult can I ask the applicant what kind of details did you think was essential you know to see more clearly in order to break that into two
[37:05] Joe Coronati: maps we well i guess we always have we typically always have an overview plan when we have a large parcel which this is the one map that i guess i would disagree with the statement that we're not providing it on one map because i think it's right there it's all on one map then we have additional maps to give you more detail which i think is additional information that maybe you don't want but I thought we feel it's easier to read the more dialed in plans once we zoom in on the scale so if it's helpful or if it's I believe it if we covered it both ways we have it all on one page and then we have more detailed plans as well and you can break it up however you really want us to but I think we have all that info you know two things I was kind of looking for so significant habitat corridors or rare and endangered habitats there's not really mention of that if they exist or don't exist if they don't exist they don't need to be on the map but we would need to see something that agrees with that and then the other item we normally have a table with the net and gross calculations for the land areas i didn't know if that was included somewhere that i missed what type of like a table stating you know total 66 acres this much conservation this much developable i mean i believe all that information is in the set the we have the total open space provided it's on different plans we have the number of acres being conserved the net developable area calculation is that the one that yeah that's what i was looking for that table so net developable area calculations on sheet y2 that provides the area of the wetlands the steep slopes the unusable area the developable area then the calculation for the number of lots allowed that based on that calculation we'd be allowed 27 lots this was more for the 60% reserved portion I just it's just we just need something to prove that you're meeting the requirements for open space conservation outside of the growth area which is at the 60% level I
[39:45] Brendan (Chair): think it was mentioned by the yeah so that's that's
[39:56] Joe Coronati: page c4 which is sheet 11 of 14 that has our open space developable open space calculations I think this is maybe what Chris was referencing just some kind of being scattered through this yeah so page c4 which is kind of a zoomed in plan of the cluster slash i guess open space conservation subdivision note three talks about the open space required the 60 the size and then the amount that we're providing with a breakdown of the wetlands in that open space as well thank you and
[41:07] Brendan (Chair): what part was in the part the green to the left and what part was in the HOA part that you're proposing
[41:20] Joe Coronati: yes the so the part that would be deeded to the York land trust is 35 acres and then the part that would be retained by the homeowners association is six point two four acres there's actually a third section it's a small part behind the lots that separate the lots from the existing homes to the east of us there's a small open space area of 1.75 acres as well so those three of those are what add up to our total being 60 percent well
[42:06] Jenna Green: so it's a total of 42.99 acres so it's 64.6 percent of the total 66.61 acres of the property so if we're looking at the land just the land
[42:19] Brendan (Chair): that you're proposing and the land trust is looking at what percentage of the total
[42:27] Joe Coronati: property is that the land trust is going to be tentatively
[42:34] Brendan (Chair): in charge of yes 35 acres because there's questions about the others being part of that so we might as well know right up front what part is proposed to go to an organization like the land trust
[42:54] Joe Coronati: so 52 percent of the land 52.5 percent of the land goes to the land trust okay so
[43:07] Jenna Green: and then the remaining open space land that the hoa would own would have the same deed restrictions as the land that the land trust would own in our conversations with the land trust you know because of that land you know we wanted to preserve the land in the front there's a there's a significant wetland in that 6.24 acre portion so it made sense for that to be part of the open space but it's not a portion of the land the land trust wanted so you know in our discussions with them sort of the agreement was they would take the back portion of the property that 35 acres which has the shoreland and you know some of the other sensitive areas and they were in support of the hoa holding the ownership of the remaining open space land but having the same deed restrictions that the york land trust land would have yeah but in the fine
[43:56] Brendan (Chair): print they did say if approved by the planning board if approved by the planning board yes
[44:05] Joe Coronati: My thought on that is for evaluating for completeness, whether the information is accurate and in compliance with the ordinance or not, that's the part of the completeness portion that can be discussed after. So it's more focusing on the items that are either missing or just need clarification, I guess. Okay. so one of the one of those just going back to the habitat endangered habitat items i wanted
[44:35] Andrew Schlunz: to circle back to that also if there's any information
[44:39] Joe Coronati: on that you guys have yeah we actually have some i brought some packets with me and i didn't resubmit all this documentation but when we did when we did phase one of the development we did submit wildlife habitat assessments that cover the entire property we had to do a in looking you know working with inland fisheries and wildlife we had to do a bat study we have a copy of the bat study that covers the whole property those were all submitted as part of the first phase of the development i didn't think to resubmit those to the board with phase two but they do cover both parcels and i have that information and with me tonight i can hand it to you i don't know if you want to look at it but it's all stuff that's been previously submitted and is in the file at the town i 'd
[45:32] Brendan (Chair): recommend going forward that you forget about phase one it's there's no phase one there's just this right now so that would that would make things easier and if there's duplication then
[45:43] Joe Coronati: that's that's okay too but we do have a lot of a lot of analysis excuse me on the wildlife life the wetlands the connectivity the vernal pools we have vernal pool study
[46:00] Andrew Schlunz: it's been completed did your analysis flag any endangered species or areas of high cost concern or just cause for concern in general especially with the
[46:15] Joe Coronati: vernal pools there was yeah there's a there's been yes there was definitely review of those areas, all the different animals that were seen in the, from the inland fisheries and wildlife, and then a discussion between the wetland scientists. We have Chris Copey working on us, or working with us on this development, doing all the wetland delineation, the soils and the wildlife. And previous to that, we had Golden Environmental Services doing a lot of the work as well. so we have We have all that documentation and we can submit that and did that include?
[46:59] Andrew Schlunz: Like trees and etc not just the actual wildlife
[47:06] Joe Coronati: Good question the
[47:09] Brendan (Chair): Endangers species of plants Yeah, so
[47:17] Jim Gilroy: we
[47:21] Joe Coronati: have a letter from the state of Maine that looked at we had they wanted us to look at bat species there was turtles they looked at significant wildlife habitat fisheries because we and because we're on the title i don't know if there was a anything specific to the woodlands themselves that were brought up are you familiar with previous applications where that would be plotted on a
[47:54] Brendan (Chair): site plans or is it more of a site note it's usually a beginning with habitat
[48:01] Drew Olahowski: submission is that in there somewhere I don't believe I saw it in this
[48:07] Brendan (Chair): application yeah but the beginning with habitat which is a state program you know we'll map out general areas where there's rare species of various kinds or endangered or valuable but they don't zoom in great detail because they don't want, in some cases, someone to know exactly where these ancient species are, but that's where you would get a wildlife biologist to do a more detailed look at it.
[48:39] Joe Coronati: Yeah, we have, I mean, we can submit, this is a 70-page wildlife habitat assessment done by GovEnvironmental in 2020, 20 and they honestly go through all of the items that you're talking about we don't have any way to really you know show those areas because they don't as you said they don't exist necessarily in one specific location it's but there are maps there's pictures of the vernal pools photographs of the vernal pools with the egg masses where they exist on this property we're talking about not just the previous development yeah this is specific this large documents specific only to this property i mean well both properties phase one and two which technically in 2020 they were actually considered one parcel but we have test pits vernal pools conservation lands all that information and it's all and as i said unfortunately i didn't resubmit
[49:46] Brendan (Chair): it sounds like the kind of information we would need is that correct brendan that would be
[49:53] Drew Olahowski: my interpretation as well particularly whenever establishing conservation theme well and i want
[49:58] Andrew Schlunz: to bring up that main significant vernal pool rules were amended as of may 17 2026 so we should we should revisit that. Excuse me.
[50:09] Brendan (Chair): Okay, yeah, good idea. I have an idea for the board to consider. This, so there's at least question about whether this is complete for review. I would like to bring in some, so I see representatives of the Conservation Commission are here and their specific role is to work with the planning board before we you know call it complete or before we have a public hearing i would suggest maybe having one of one of them come up and give their impressions on this part of it i mean there's other details that may be further down the road but on the part of about the value of the of the conserved land or the proposed conserved land details like that so would somebody be willing to come up
[51:10] Joe Coronati: is that all right yes i have a another thought if the applicant was willing to we could possibly accept this as a sketch that doesn't allow the it doesn't time stamp the application as accepted but it allows us to open a public forum and then have a little more substantial discussion on items ask questions you can ask us questions we've kind of dabbled in that now but it's been for the purpose of understanding if the application is complete or not but it will give you hopefully more insight as to what we're expecting beyond completion and also let you hear
[51:48] Brendan (Chair): concerns from the public so that would make sense because again we have we're questioning whether or the peer reviewer is questioning whether there was enough to be complete. The applicant says it's there, but it's not in a form that we can accept at this point because it's not all in one place in writing. So we've done that before many times. It's just created as a sketch plan.
[52:17] Andrew Schlunz: I think that's a great spot to move forward. Okay.
[52:22] Brendan (Chair): Okay. Okay, then would you like to open a public hearing? If so, I would suggest going with the Conservation Commission first, or we could go with the Conservation Commission first and then open a public hearing.
[52:37] Andrew Schlunz: I think we need to accept it first.
[52:38] Joe Coronati: Yes, we'll have that one then. Yep. Is everyone okay with that?
[52:41] Brendan (Chair): Someone makes a motion. Okay, a motion to accept as a sketch plan.
[52:49] Joe Coronati: My thought was to check with the applicant, see if that was okay.
[52:52] Brendan (Chair): Yes, it's our mental. That's right, you have to be okay with that. Yeah, we agree.
[52:56] Joe Coronati: So then I will move to open a except for a sketch plan for 62 Harbour Road, tax map 87, lot 12A.
[53:07] Brendan (Chair): Second. OK, moved by David, second by Crystal. Any discussion? Call for vote. Crystal? Yes. David? Yes. Steve? Yes. Chair votes yes, 4-0. OK, then. Then.
[53:24] Andrew Schlunz: I would recommend having someone from the conservation come and speak before we open the public hearing, because there might be some shared concerns.
[53:38] Brendan (Chair): Then there might be some information that would answer the public's questions before we do. So is that all right to be moved that way? Yes. yes okay then if someone from the conservation commission would like to come up to the podium and again it's this is not just an ad hoc thing it's part of the cons of the of the zoning ordinance to involve the conservation commission in various points in a application of this magnitude especially so if you would please introduce yourself
[54:23] Stephanie Byrne: Yes, I'm Stephanie Byrne. Byrne is spelled B-Y-R-N-E. I've been on and supporting the Conservation Commission for several years and I'm here to help them and the Planning Board in any way I can in terms of open space reviews. So my first question is, there were several things to comment on here. Do I have to limit it
[54:48] Brendan (Chair): it to something specific here it seems like if we could focus on the first part the conceptual review part of it you know it's going to overlap somewhat but that's that's where we are now we can't go forward in terms of where we put individual lots for instance until we get the conceptual plan approved okay so
[55:20] Stephanie Byrne: So I will try to do that, but it seems at this point, there are lots of comments about the yield plan. Should those be held for a second public hearing if one occurs tonight?
[55:32] Joe Coronati: I think it might be useful for the applicant to hear, and if it meanders in.
[55:38] Brendan (Chair): We're in the sketch plan anyway, so we could get to that at a later point.
[55:44] Joe Coronati: I don't think we need to be as rigid with 7.6 it's during sketch, it's really, if you have questions, even in the final portion of your application, now's a great time to ask that, I think.
[55:58] Stephanie Byrne: Okay. So I'll make all the comments at a risk of being repetitive and going too far. So I'm here, so I'm speaking to emphasize information that was included in a letter that was formally submitted by the York Conservation Commission and the first thing is the extreme conservation value of this property which is located within the brave boat harbor garish island focus area of statewide ecological significance and the Rachel Carson National Wildlife Refuge conservation land state it contains extensive freshwater wetlands multiple vernal pools for its forested uplands and important wildlife habitat. The state of Maine records for this focused area includes blanding turtles, spotted turtles, New England cottontails, and several rare woodland plants. This fact warrants that a current parcel-specific review should be obtained from the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife and Maine Natural Area Programs and that a qualified wildlife biologist to evaluate the entire property for rare species habitat, significant natural communities, and wildlife connectivity. Any identified resources should inform the development configuration, clearing limits, and permanent conservation boundaries. These resources form an interconnected ecological system whose long-term protection depends on preserving the surrounding forest habitat, wildlife corridors, and connections to existing protecting lands there are concerns with the limits of the current open space design as well as protection of natural resources across the property has already been stated this lot is approximately 66 acres and the land to be held by the land trust is 35 acres and we commend the York Land Trust to step up and take on the ownership and there's a significant investment to protect this 35 acres. However, the 35 acres only represents 52.6% of the total and I don't have what the net developable portions are. And I understand that there's an opportunity to have, and i will call it common space for the hoa to not be built on but in order for space to be open space by the ordinance if it is owned by an hoa it then needs a third party conservation organization to have a conservation easement and then to provide the monitoring that's involved the enforcement that's involved the state registry that is involved so if in approving i don't think this is approvable at this point because it would only be 52.6 percent if it were to change and if it was up to the 60 level and there still was something separate for the hoa it would be very important then that there were deeds and covenants so that it was put into permanent protection by those, but then that would also involve there to be annual monitoring as well as registration with the state. And then I would like to comment further about how important this land is in terms of any further submissions of plans, because the objective here is to ensure that the most ecological important land receives effective permanent protection so given that objection there should be consideration told now in terms of what we would need in future submission of development plans and there should be substantial evaluation of the development configuration to avoid sensitive resources reduced forest fragmentation we should be maintaining wildlife corridors and to minimize disturbances from roads driveways and residential activity now the protection of wetlands and significant vernal pool habitat within the development remains a major concern as noted the rules change in May we now have a new hundred foot protection area that regulates critical terrestrial habitat and that's also protected within the 250 feet of the significant vernal pool and as an aside side, I currently do not know or understand if the area within this 100 foot zone around Fernal Pools, is that included in net developable land or not, because I would think it would not because it's clear now that it should not be included as net developable. Now in terms of submission of future plans, the plan should have a consolidated natural resources constraint and development implementation plan that identifies the wetlands in applicable town and state setbacks, significant vernal pools, the 100 foot protection zone, and where are the critical terrestrial habitats shown along with the proposed roads, driveways, septic systems, clearing and grading, existing and anticipated disturbances with regulated habitat, and all importantly,, the forested connections among open space, wetlands, vernal pools, and enjoining conservation lands. I can't emphasize enough how much it is to not have things fragmented, and I understand perfectly why the land trust needs their land as a whole to not be fragmented, because it's the only way they can protect it, and they are fiduciaries of that protection. That's why to increase that area and to take into account what's already been admitted or significant vernal pools up to one side and down the other and should be reconfigured so they're unfragmented to what the York Land Trust owns. So it could be one unfragmented area would be the best decision to have it. And I would also point out that the cumulative disturbance is particularly concerning where there are multiple residential laws affecting the same vernal pools Because only up to 25% of the, from the 100 to the 250 feet, I believe, would be allowed to be disturbed. Because in addition just where the relative houses are, you need to avoid the sensitive areas of associated clearing for driveways, septic systems, and residential activity. It can collectively fragment critical habitat. I mean the plan should provide a cumulative habitat disturbance analysis from a qualified wildlife biologist and to identify other opportunities to improve the habitat protection as well. Now in terms of comments on the yield plan, there are at least four principle concerns and one is again that cumulative vernal pool impacts of what that road would be going throughout out that whole property and how that would accumulate and it just seems it would disturb a lot more than 25 of the vernal pools then there are where the septic system is going to be located and the wells you know looking what i saw on the map there were test pits in the well radiuses They were test pits on lot lines between them. They were up in levels of high ledges. And for the thing there, they would be leach fields there in a septic system next to the house. Some of it just wasn't making sense. To the western end of the property, there's significant steep slopes, and it's questionable whether any of those lots on that end for a reasonableness point of view for a yield plan would actually be reasonable. And it's difficult from the map seen in the yield plan to understand with the combined restraints of not only where things are located, but access to be able to configure it together to see how it all works with the wetlands, the setbacks, the vernal pool, the habitats, the slopes, the septic suitability, the well separation and where the driveways would be accessed that information which is critical to make your decisions can't be seen on the yield plan without that kind of information and all importantly that whole yield plan by ordinance needs to be certified by a professional certification from a soil scientist so that what the yield plan shows in terms of the location of all of these features including the wall and septic that they would certify that those soils will support such a yield plan as an aside just recently i learned there's some site subdivision requirement that when a development has one point of access for a road that the number of units is limited to less than 15. i'm no expert on this i just learned of it recently but that should be something that should also be evaluated when looking not only at the yield plan but i'm sure you would know more than me about this at a development in general and so finally i just wanted to speak to the level of review that is warranted by this land the extraordinary conservation value of this property calls for a review with the utmost scrutiny of protection for this ecological area of significance Such a review is also in alignment with the comprehensive plan strategy 2.8 that states ensure all planning board decisions will strive to optimize conservation of natural resources while enabling development that has minimal environmental impacts and aligned with all town goals. and as a member of the Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee I can report that a lot of thought was put into that strategy and it is an important strategy and probably the most important that is supporting the community's number one priority which is to protect natural resources and keep in mind that the one key measure of the success of this subdivision will review will be how effectively the final design preserves the property's ecological integrity and connections to the surrounding conservation landscapes. Adjust.
[1:07:22] Joe Coronati: Can we discuss a couple, or do we get a chance to respond to questions on it? [Brendan (Chair): Yeah,, sure.] So I believe a lot of this information has been submitted. We did submit, and as I said, you have information from Inland Fisheries and Wildlife. I know it's on the property from the first phase. We did submit, we do show all the vernal pools, all the significant vernal pools with their setbacks, the 100-foot, the 250. 50, and we do have a qualified soil scientist and wildlife person in Chris Copey working on this project. He can certainly present to you more information. I believe we protected all the areas of the property that are most sensitive we have we have a lot of concerned or not a lot of concerns a lot of considerations when looking at this property when you drive out there you drive up you get to the intersection of route 103 and brave boat Harbor Road they come to a kind of a unique intersection where you kind of go straight and you're you end up on brave boat harbor road you climb a hill you take a kind of a slight bend to the right all the access of that to this property along the right is limited by the slope of the land the driveway location is basically already installed it's out there today you can you know you can walk it you can park there and walk into the site because it's the best access to the property all the access to the west is too steep of a slope not only on the land but on the brave boat harbor road itself it's also too close to route 103 intersection we wouldn't want to move our entrance to this development really any closer down the hill we really can't anyways because of the slope but it also would push us closer to the intersection of a an existing intersection. So it limits our location as to where we come into the property. The location where it has been historically used for access by the loggers and the property owner, the Paynes for many years is where we're showing the access. It also happens to be where there's a vernal pool to the east of us. There's basically a vernal pool right adjacent to Brave Boat Harbor Road, adjacent to an abutting property. and unfortunately right where we have our entrance and where the best access is to the lot. So our location of our access is really dictated by the slope of the property and the existing layout of the road network. So we're kind of limited as to how we get into the property. We tried our best to keep away from those two vernal pools. we'll obviously have to do the calculations that are suggested or not just suggested they're required you know by the town in the state that we provide you documentation and we have to provide that proof to you before you'd obviously ever approve those parcels so we would do that as part of this here tonight we're just really looking at the open space layout and as well as We hoped anyways the yield plan, but the critical habitats on the property, you know, you submit this documentation to the state, they give you a list of species that exist in the vicinity of your property. There's no, I can't just show you a spot and say there's a Blanding's turtle here, there's a bat species was discovered here. It's a it's more of they look at the area in general, and is there potential habitat for those species? So I don't have a way to show you, I guess, a plan that says this is the potential critical habitat location specifically only here on the plan. We looked at it from the perspective that the most critical habitat is clearly the tidal marsh in the rear, and then all the adjoining wetlands that feed to those that provide wildlife access to the tidal marsh. And those are the four vernal pools that we're protecting in the open space layout. layout. The vernal pools that are immediately adjacent to a high-traveled road are just less significant than the ones that are adjacent to the tidal marsh. That's really where we focused our preservation of the parcel on. I think York Land Trust would obviously agree that's the part that they would prefer to have as well. Overall, still providing 60% of the land and basically deed restricted undeveloped never to be developed is i feel it's not only your requirement but it's also a pretty good percentage of the land when you're looking at overall developments the need for housing preservation of 60 of any parcel is i think a pretty decent outlook on how best to develop a piece of land keep the development to the most minimal you can and still provide a reasonable layout for houses septics wells none of our septic systems and wells overlap i don't know why that was mentioned but we have we show on the yield plan and the conservation plan the septic areas and the well areas none of them are overlapping each other the we have room to fit septics and wells on each lot. We show them on both the open space layout and the deal plan. We provided test pits as well. We don't have test pits in every single location yet because we're at the preliminary stage, but Chris Copey, soil scientist, did a battery of test pits all around the property which were submitted as well so i'm hopeful that we're we'd like to continue this on and obviously there's more detail that you need from us and our consultants which would all be part of the process moving forward the preliminary design and we'd hope to i guess move forward as through the conceptual as if we did submit all the items you need
[1:14:24] Brendan (Chair): and show on the plans one question for you included in the conserved land that strip of land between your properties your property and the adjacent properties
[1:14:44] Joe Coronati: how wide is that 's a good question it's say it's 50 feet wide
[1:14:54] Brendan (Chair): i in my experience it's unprecedented that we include that as part of the conserved land it's it's part of a buffer but a buffer doesn't count as a conserved land in my opinion because it's you know anytime you stretch out a strip like that you strip off a lot of the value of it But so I can't think, Brendan, am I on track with this, that this is not something that is considered?
[1:15:31] Drew Olahowski: Yes, you would be correct.
[1:15:34] Jenna Green: I don't think we, I mean, we don't need to include that in the calculation because we're at 64.6%, 42.99 acres. I think that's 1.75 acres. So that doesn't need to be included in the calculation. It is going to be undeveloped land. but we're I guess we're in excess of it so you can skip that anyway okay and
[1:16:01] Brendan (Chair): there's still question about the so-called HOA open space and whether that's a good way to preserve that land obviously talk more about that hear more comment i'm sure about that but yeah okay any other thoughts before we move to it
[1:16:33] Andrew Schlunz: can i ask a really quick question sure the previous report that you had done in regards to endangered species etc what is that dated we have a we have a couple of them we have one dated
[1:16:51] Joe Coronati: dated June 11th, 2020, then we have another report from the Fisheries and Wildlife from 2025.
[1:17:01] Brendan (Chair): That big thick one that you showed us?
[1:17:04] Joe Coronati: No, we got that as well. That's 2020, and I can submit all this stuff. We have letters from.
[1:17:13] Andrew Schlunz: Well, I'm just wondering if the thick one or whatever was submitted six years ago what that timing threshold is on our end if it should be repeated given the time difference
[1:17:30] Drew Olahowski: a timeline difference i should say i've in my experience i've seen typically like five years be the be kind of a good threshold for needing new information as if whether or not that's called out specifically in the ordinances i would have to do a deep dive and find that out for you i don't
[1:17:47] Andrew Schlunz: think a deep dive is necessary okay if
[1:17:55] Brendan (Chair): that was to be the case any other
[1:18:00] Joe Coronati: questions or comments I have more questions but I think at the public comment portion going and we'll have even more questions possible okay make a
[1:18:14] Brendan (Chair): a motion to open a public hearing on
[1:18:23] Joe Coronati: the agenda there we go move to open the public hearing for 62 brave boat harbor map 87 lot 12a second for the sketch plan of course a sketch
[1:18:40] Brendan (Chair): plan publicly okay then moved by david seconded by steve any questions call for votes crystal Yes. David? Yes. Steve? Yes. Chair votes yes for zero. Okay. So this will be a public hearing. We'll ask you to please, there's a good crowd here and this is not the end of it. There will be other public hearings along the way. This is just for the conceptual review and it's just for the sketch plan. if we were to then decide at a later point to take into consideration new information submitted by the applicant and reopen the conceptual review which we would have to do there'd be a chance to comment then if that was accepted by the board then the next step well include includes the yield plan but then there's a preliminary review again it's a chance for the public to comment and if the applicant made it through the preliminary phase then there would be and it was approved then there would still be the final review and the final review would involve public hearing as well so you don't have to get all your ideas out but i would just ask an interest of time if you would like to speak to try to keep it as much as you can to three minutes okay so is there anyone who would like to speak right now yes [Rebecca Harrington: and] as usual please come to the podium give your name and spell your last name for the recording secretary i have some comments on the now
[1:20:27] Bill Goodwin: if you don't want to hear it at this session you'll find i don't need to speak probably
[1:20:34] Brendan (Chair): you're ahead of the you're ahead of the things on the plot plan yes the one that you're pointing to right now yes is way premature if you have other thoughts we'd be glad to hear them so again the plot plan is really kind of the last part of it after we accept all
[1:21:02] Bill Goodwin: this other information but go ahead okay my name is bill goodwin i'm on winsome farm lane in new york and these are just my personal comments i'm not representing any group or stuff but i looked at this plot plan just i'm going to ask for a few changes when it comes to this i mean you know that the entrance way is where it currently sits is in this restricted zone here number second point lots one two and three most well a good portion of them are in the restricted zone around the burner pools, the other, almost all the rest of the lots are in the habitat zone. So I'd like to just take lot two for an example. It's 36,000 square feet. And I'm just using very general numbers here. So it looks like about half of this is in the restricted zone, so you're now down to 18,000 feet you can work with. Of that part that's in the habitat zone, you can use 25% of that, so you're down to 4,500 feet. One thing I would note here is that this road coming in here is also in this habitat zone, and you have to account for that some place. so I'm gonna suggest that half of this is think of about the midpoint of the road and that point to the west I sorry to the east of the midpoint would affect lot number two and that part to the west affects a lot a lot so if I estimate, this may be overestimating, say, okay, you've got 200 feet along the road. If the road is 50 feet wide, that area, that means 25 feet would be facing lot number two. So take 25 by 200 and you get like 5,000 square feet. if it's if this pot right here touching the road is less maybe it's if it's a hundred square feet it's going to be able like half that number but if you so if you add the restricted zone here the pot that comes on the roadway to this lot you get an increase in potentials of it that's in the habitat zone and so if you take 25% of that you get 5700 square feet of which so if you take out of that potential stuff you could do if you take out the 5 000 feet square feet that's already used up by the roadway you're left with like a 700 foot square feet of development that may be too restrictive but just mentally think about how small that piece would be you know you could put a shed on it not much more if you know if you want a house lot you're thinking you're going to have a driveway you got the well in the front or the septic in the back or something you have some clearing up here to the street so you get that view of the street and looks good so it's very tight
[1:25:06] Brendan (Chair): i don't mean to cut you off but those are good comments i think okay it would it would be one of
[1:25:13] Bill Goodwin: the first things that would be looked at by our i'll zip through some of the just other comments So you have a zone down here at the borderline on the east side, and that is listed here as HOA thing. It may be conservation land, but such a narrow strip like that.
[1:25:41] Brendan (Chair): Yeah, we did talk about the narrow strip. sense that's that's that's not that won't be counted as conservation land that's a buffer
[1:25:50] Bill Goodwin: okay another thought is you for these flag lots you've got these driveway corridors here if you shifted these corridors over to one spot the same put them between lot seven and lot eight and you shift these other lots over so i'm not changing the size of these lots here four five six and seven but you just shift shifting them over and you combine them all together you can you can have a little corridor you know wooded corridor that connects this wetland here to that wetland up there so you have these lots in here in the wetland 250-foot boundary. So you've got to take that into consideration. Okay.
[1:26:54] Brendan (Chair): I'm going to stop you now because we've got more people that might want to talk. And, again, this is way down the road, and there will be plenty of time to take a look. But that'll look completely different if we get that far all right. I thank you for your time Hi
[1:27:20] Rebecca Harrington: Rebecca Harrington h e r ing to n my comments are my own I just have three questions First off Chris copy is he a wildlife biologist or a soil scientist because
[1:27:32] Brendan (Chair): Would you address your questions to this chair, and we'll ask them all later, perhaps.
[1:27:39] Rebecca Harrington: Chris Coppe, I heard him named as both the wildlife biologist and the soil scientist. Seems to probably not be both. I know Maine gives a general details about the possible endangered species on the lot. lot. I think a qualified wildlife biologist could give a lot more accurate picture of the property. In terms of the HOA space, I have never known an HOA to be well qualified to manage a conservation easement. A lot of other skills for managing the property and collective community, wildlife conservation, and land conservation is not typically one of them. If that is the case, then it seems totally unreasonable to approve an open-space plan that does not meet the open-space ordinance requirement of 60%. and lastly if you can't have an entrance to the property without significantly disrupting significant vernal pools and ecological areas then maybe the property is not meant to be developed
[1:29:06] Stephanie Byrne: George
[1:29:18] Unidentified speaker: Hutchins H U T C H INS local resident here looking at this I'm going to talk in the for the natural resources protection questions piggyback on what you said about the entrance on the vernal pools. Nobody's mentioned here the canopy. There's also a requirement for the canopy of the trees to be covering over these vernal pools of 75 percent. I haven't heard anything mentioned about that. It's not, and the fact that the engineer himself mentioned that we're protecting the back vernal pools, but the beginning vernal pools, that's not as important. I don't know who gets to decide which vernal pool is important and which is not, but because it's in a different location doesn't mean it has any less importance than the other ones having witnessed the construction of phase one of their building and the amount of impact they've had to land i seriously question them constructing anything in the neighborhood of a vernal pool the hammering and the things that went on and there's their houses that they're building now has been pretty drastic and pretty I mean hammering from all hours a day but I mean for around a vernal pool around that construction I don't know how you're gonna construct that area and still avoid that without having impact and what the oversight is as well is once that begins who has the oversight to see that we're staying within those bounds because we didn't see that on what's going on across the street straight across the street from my son on watching on a daily basis and it was pretty very impactful from there and i can't imagine being trying to work that around wetlands and vernal poles and once again somebody else mentioned the plant soils hadn't heard anything about that what study has been done on the plant soils and i mean it's impactful that air is gorgeous been around for a long time We used a brave boat Harbor area a lot of relatives down there It's a gorgeous area Harvesting trees is completely different use than a subdivision of homes when he tries to mention that was a hope that was a way They use for trees. That's great. That's a completely different use than having a Subdivision of 20 homes that are using that versus harvesting the land. So those just points to ponder. Thank you. Thank you
[1:31:49] Brendan (Chair): i do appreciate your enthusiasm but i would just ask to avoid the applause right now just so we keep on moving somebody else had their name yes sir hi
[1:32:06] Jim Gilroy: i'm jim gilroy i live on i live on brave boat harbor road i'm at one edge of the diagram there the concern that I haven't heard mentioned yet but that's one that a number of people who live on [street] have is that the is about the aquifer on the side of Brave Boat Harbor Road that this development is being planned for the I know of at least three houses that had difficulty finding water initially one of those was about 30 years ago. The other two houses that I'm aware of have had their wells go dry within the last year or so and have had to have re-drilling done or fracking done, one person had both. so I think it's important that whatever gets developed that we be as sure as we can that the aquifer can support that I don't know how well you can tell that ahead of time I hope there's a way that you all know one of
[1:33:53] Unidentified speaker: my big concerns is reiterating what Jim said there are more than three homes that I know of that have had issues with wells up in our area and I'm just concerned about the number of homes that are planned or proposed to go in the town water doesn't go as far as we are I'm across I share a driveway with the Gilroy's and so we'd be really stuck if we were not able to get water and very difficult as jim said that some of the homes have had to do several drillings one of the neighbors down the street just had to do an 800 foot well and they don't get a whole lot of water out of that at this point that just happened so that's one of my big concerns the other is the tied in with the environmental piece i'm just thinking of 22 or whatever septic systems on the property and the light pollution and things like that are going to interfere with this being a natural habitat area looking at salt on the road salt and driveways pesticide use or fertilizer use by the homes thinking of heavy rains because we've had a lot more of those in more recent times and how that could impact the wildlife as these wetlands get contaminated by some of these runoffs and I just think any wetland is valuable any habitat that preserves a lot of nature is a problem if we do anything to contaminate that space or interfere with it based on sound or light or other issues that might you know not be compatible thank you my
[1:35:57] Joe Edwards: name is Joe Edwards I live on Sam Raines path Edwards EDW ARDS and my thoughts are my own first I just want to thank you know you the Planning Board for kind of you know allowing us to participate in this process I want to thank all my you know neighbors here who have raised exceptional points and I really applaud the prior speaker I fully agree with everything she said and I just want to emphasize some of the points that you guys raised earlier which is this aspect of kind of completeness and i and i hope that the applicants kind of view this less as a you know abiding by you know the legalese and in the process for its own sake and really view it truly as a sign of respect to the community and into the land because i hope that's how they're treating it there were a lot of you know aspects of outdated documents things that were just you know maybe we could squeeze them through because maybe they kind of you know fit the template that i hope they reconsider and take much more seriously and to invest the extra time effort and consideration and making this an application the board can properly consider so thank you thank you very much anybody
[1:37:01] Brendan (Chair): else nate
[1:37:08] Joe Coronati: lozier l-o-s-i-e-r i live at [address] i also have an issue with the well problems our well went bad in the late 80s we had to get drilled I live right across the street from the entrance ours had to be redrilled down around 600 feet and then all the other wells that have gone bad over the last few years that's a concern another concern is safety and traffic flow the corner down at the bottom with 103 and brave boat it's an extreme corner it also has a dip that goes down the site looking down 103 there's some blind spots there's a blind spot turning up onto it i feel like that corner would have to be reconfigured with the expanded traffic going up that hill plus the way it is now people don't really like to take that hill because of the danger so all the traffic is diverted down to the other entrance everything flows one way yeah i guess those are my concerns thank you thank you the
[1:38:36] Brendan (Chair): others yes if it's not too long you can you can come up and we have received your letter by the way i'm
[1:38:57] Cynthia Hosmer: pretty sure all right can you hear me from here can you hear me can you hear me yes if you get
[1:39:05] Brendan (Chair): maybe you can move that microphone just a little all right i'm happy to do that yes and your name
[1:39:12] Cynthia Hosmer: and oh excuse me cynthia hosmer h-o-s-m-e-r i write as a concerned neighbor to question the plans of the quote cluster development of off brave boat harbor road i have often walked the trails in the woods in that area and know that many there are many vernal pools and small ponds some spill down to a small stream where there used to be a sawmill and that stream flows into Brave Boat Harbor. My concern is about the potential pollution of the harbor, which has been a favorite clamming and fishing resource for York residents for many years. All of the wooded areas are eventually draining into that harbor, and the impact of multiple houses, septic tanks, fertilizer drainage, etc., will be devastating to the incubation of our sea creatures. The harbor is the resource for aquatic life that we must be a vigilant protector of. Please be very careful of the trespass of any vehicles within the margins of the wetlands, which the construction vehicle drivers do not either know or honor. And I will be attending tonight's meeting. Thank you. Anyone
[1:40:38] Brendan (Chair): else? and i will say as i often do we always welcome written comments too that can be directed to the town planner by email or mail and that can be found on the website and we did receive email this time october 19th from katie edwards pam stoppy october 20th allison and aaron ramsey also co-signed by several others on the 21st and mrs hosmer on the 22nd so although we don't read those aloud we all do read them and consider them and appreciate any feedback we get from you okay if there is no one else that's had second thoughts i'll close public hearing without objection without objection so moved and let's move on what next we
[1:41:51] Joe Coronati: can loop back to some i have a few questions one i think we shared was the open space not being contiguous with the hoa open space if that is allowed for our zoning regulations to have kind of a pocket of open space and not being held by, I guess, a regulatory easement holding.
[1:42:21] Drew Olahowski: So I would need to look into whether or not they can actually be separate. However, the ordinance is pretty clear. While the HOA can own the land itself, it would require a conservation easement to be put on top of it. So they wouldn't be able, the HOA would not be the monitoring agency. They would own it, but a third party would need to manage the conservation aspects of it.
[1:42:46] Jenna Green: Okay. So does the conservation commission ever take open space like this as a conservation easement or no?
[1:42:52] Joe Coronati: We're getting no head shakes in the back. I don't believe so.
[1:42:56] Drew Olahowski: if yes then it would go to a town vote as they are a town entity yeah the we can
[1:43:09] Joe Coronati: you know looking at the layout of the subdivision it would be very simple to connect physically connect the hoa open space to the york land trust open space behind those couple of lots on the west side of the parcel on lots 11, 12, and 13. The ownership of it, we would ask, I guess, that we'd be allowed to have the HOA control a small portion of the open space, and then York Land Trust preserve and maintain the, i guess the more large chunk bulk of the open space i would say that would be something
[1:43:54] Brendan (Chair): to perhaps negotiate with the land trust and see if they're interested we've we've already discussed it yeah i know but you're talking about adding more land no not no we're just
[1:44:10] Joe Coronati: talking about we're just making a strip yeah we would add a strip to connect the two physically Oh, I see. So they're not disconnected. That would resolve one of the concerns. The second concern being that the York Land Trust has said that they do not have interest. We've reached out to a couple other agencies, and they're in the same ballpark. So they just do not want, I guess, the strip of land, so to speak. They are agreeable that where we're ending the development is in line with the other conservation parcels on either side of us, so that makes sense, but the strip of land to the west, the six-point-something acres, they didn't want to control. but the and i've understand i believe it's been done in the past in town where the hoas are allowed to and it's actually somewhat typical i guess that a lot of hoas not anymore right
[1:45:12] Brendan (Chair): at one time and that's one reason why it's not done now there are i know one large subdivision that has a bunch of land around the edge and it was such a nightmare to monitor that I don't think you'd find any you know trust land trust that we want to take responsibility for that again but it despite the fact that factually you it's not as valuable as a continuous piece of land so the question is how much of a connection you would have to have between that land that you want to hold with the homeowners and the land that the land trust is i would look for expert guidance on that we're not in a position to say whether that would be sufficient or not i would think you would have to have some real backings to show that does make the land valuable enough for somebody to take it on as a conservation easement because again you know we're quite specific in our regulations that the homeowners Association cannot own it and maintain the easement at the same time I think
[1:46:43] Joe Coronati: the cleanest thing would be to expand the current your plan trust portion up to the 60 and then just if you wanted to keep that other sensitive area in hoa well i think just
[1:46:57] Jenna Green: just thinking about that you know so if the york land trust land was expanded to 60 you know the purpose of making that portion of the land part of the open space was also because of some of the features on it but you know if we're adding upland into the york land trust land then you know that land would become part of some of these lots and that does have a wetland and some of the vernal pool setbacks in it so even though it is maybe how the ordinance reads it's kind of not accomplishing i feel like what the goal is which would be to preserve some of these more important features in the open space but if we can't find somebody to hold it on the
[1:47:36] Brendan (Chair): On the issue of 60%, we would leave it up to you, I believe, to find the best use or the best way to do 60%. You may be on the right track in looking at it as let's expand the existing part rather than try to piecemeal it. but again I can't say at this time that 's the only solution you would have but the 60% is pretty hard and fast as far as we're concerned that in that area it has to be a minimum of 60% conserved and you know which comes with all the all the requirements we've been discussing another comment that got
[1:48:25] Joe Coronati: brought up is the net calculation if the vernal pool offers were included in those calculations are they supposed to be in or supposed to be out I know the slopes and all those items clearly spelled out but there's no is wetland areas are subtracted out of your net area calculations but not offers to two vernal pools as far as the way the ordinance is written, as far as I'm aware of. So we do have open space calculations on sheet C4 that talk about net developable areas within the open space. And it's just really wetland areas, steep slopes are what gets subtracted out. and
[1:49:27] Brendan (Chair): i've got a question for brendan again the yield plan in order to be in order to say that this many lots could go on the land don't you have to subtract out it still has to be developable land right so that would still fall
[1:49:49] Drew Olahowski: into the suitable land calculations in this case it refers kind of back to the site sub regs and how if you know if it's something supposed to be reasonably developable then it would work within the site sub regs so yield plan should follow the same guidelines as that and so if the yield
[1:50:09] Brendan (Chair): plan included a lot that you know had more wetland or unbuildable land unbuildable land then it's not an adequate yield plan correct and what is it is it two acres or one acre in this
[1:50:27] Drew Olahowski: area within this zone give me one moment i thought it was two but i believe it's two as well but it bounces around between two and three whenever you get outside of the growth area but i believe it is two
[1:50:44] Brendan (Chair): yes it is two yeah so each one of the lots in a yield plan again which is just saying how many dwellings you can get there, each one of those lots would have to be, have an adequate amount of developable land to add up to two acres, correct? Or we're just saying that it, if it included wetland, it would still have to be two acres total and enough buildable land for a lot which is it so do we count that yeah we
[1:51:32] Joe Coronati: have a we have a plan sheet y3 and the plan said it's page 7 of 14 it has a whole net area calculation for each lot with all those i believe what you're looking for all included along with the length and width calculations okay
[1:51:57] Brendan (Chair): up in a table on the top right corner so total use usable acreage for each one of them is at least two acres and what you're subtracting from that is wetland steep slopes how about restricted areas like set you know the 75 foot
[1:52:26] Joe Coronati: I don't believe those are requirement to be subtracted out of your net usable area those would be a requirement to be calculated you know when we cited a building on it right. And I think it'd be more appropriate for the open space layout is where you'd want the detailed calculation of, you know, the quarter, you know, 25% of the area around the vernal pools and that type of thing is normally how that's handled. I believe all the lots meet the yield, you know, all your yield plans meet the lots meet your requirement for net usable area.
[1:53:15] Drew Olahowski: So one element of the yield plan submission guidelines, number seven, I'd like to just remind the board that they, the board may request other details needed to assess that a yield plan is deemed reasonably achievable. So if there's any element that a board that the board believes would prevent this from being reasonably achievable Ask that be shown on the plan as well
[1:53:40] Brendan (Chair): And in the past we've had a situation where there was there was a river that bisected it and The planning board ruled that they Could not count the land on the other side of the river because you'd have to build a bridge over it to get to it But, okay, I think I understand what you're saying is that those are the calculations that have to be, and I presume that peer reviewers will take a look at that at some point in the process, make sure it does add up.
[1:54:17] Joe Coronati: I think one of the comments from the public was it With the Percentage 25% in the vernal pool area if there was enough actual buildable area with the setbacks to achieve a Developed final product on that parcel on those first three lots on them. Yeah that and then some of like lot nine seems like all of it, except for the part that's in the 50 foot buffer yard is included in the 250 foot buffer. I don't know if I'm conveying that.
[1:54:59] Brendan (Chair): Is this Y2 you're talking about?
[1:55:02] Joe Coronati: I am on Y1. I'm on Y3. We're talking about the same lot. Yeah, you're assuming more.
[1:55:09] Brendan (Chair): So you're saying the entire lot is within.
[1:55:12] Joe Coronati: in yeah where there's so many vernal pools can you achieve a driveway and a dwelling as per our standards which 190 square feet to constitute a dwelling so that part's okay but driveway the setback all that if you're needing the 25 and i'm not sure if that is in the entire vernal pool area it's not necessarily you know lot nine can only be 25 impactful or can you only impact that significant or vernal pool in general up to 25%. Right, so it's 25% of the area of the 250-foot setback. So if you look at the size of that on those parcels, the 250-foot radius around the vernal pool encompasses, let's say, all of lot nine. So if that's three acres without looking. And we would only be developing, we would never be developing 25% of a three acre lot with a house and a driveway, you know, we'd be developing much smaller amount, and we could provide that, calculation.
[1:56:31] Drew Olahowski: The revised state rules on vernal pools, that 25% is on a per lot basis, so it's 25% of the vernal pool buffer on a lot would be able to be disturbed.
[1:56:43] Joe Coronati: So if a lot's completely in a vernal pool buffer, then 25% can only be developed. Right. Right, so that was what we looked at as well. I know you are looking at a large parcel on a couple of plans, so the scale might be exaggerated a little bit, but you can see that lots 8, 9, 10, part of 11 are in that vernal pool setback, but that also constitutes about eight acres of land with three homes on it and a portion of the road. So, overall, it's really a small amount of impact in that area, and it's the same as the open space subdivision layout. Even though the front has the vernal pool on it, I did some scaling, and we can roughly impact almost 70,000 square feet of land in that front, and it only covers two and a half lots and a portion of the road so like that and that's all stuff we would have to lay out for you anyways when we get to that point yeah thanks for that
[1:57:56] Brendan (Chair): good a hypothetical for your Brandon if you had let's say the center of let's say you had four lots come together at one point and it was the center of a vernal pool if each one could develop 25% of it of the vernal pool setback the 250 foot bar does that mean that each one could take 25% of their 25% and
[1:58:33] Drew Olahowski: counted hypothetically yes to the greatest extent practical applicants must maintain 75% of the critical terrestrial habitat present on their property so no matter what 75% of whatever that buffer is has to be
[1:58:50] Brendan (Chair): preserved in its current state what about it already about half of it is already on an old, a previously approved house many years ago. I'd say half of it was. Again, you can take a quarter of what's on your property, even though half of it's already.
[1:59:13] Drew Olahowski: I would need to double check with the town attorney to be sure, but my understanding is that yes, that would be the case.
[1:59:22] Brendan (Chair): It's kind of a shortcoming of the regulations, it seems to me that if you only have half left that you can still you can still develop a quarter of the of the setback but anyway and we can look into that later if necessary but it seems like a weakness in the regulations, but again, that's why the most important land is the land that's large and contiguous rather than piecemeal. And I would agree with the applicant that the less valuable land, and rural pools are those that are already half in the road that obviously it doesn't have much value. But on the other hand, we need to look at other situations perhaps where it is more valuable than this should be considered when making a final decision. Okay. Other thoughts?
[2:00:45] Joe Coronati: I was just going to go back just to make sure the applicant understood what was missing from the packet for completeness review. Do you need any more instructions on what we were looking for? I believe so because I'm not, yes, I'm not sure at all in addition to what we've submitted. My main point was the habitat corridor Can be either explained or on the plan if there was Corridor if there weren't any corridors and a note on the plane stating so Was there other parts of the completeness review? That was the main one that kind of stumped me and We would have had to grant the waiver for that other packet which package the 70 page package i don't think we had enough time to really review oh right
[2:01:59] Brendan (Chair): right into this slot right yeah that's that's definitely something that
[2:02:07] Joe Coronati: should be resubmitted and there's a question about refreshing it where it's six years old i'm not sure if we have anything in our book that requires that but we can request it
[2:02:25] Brendan (Chair): Yeah, I think it's reasonable if you can get the same scientists back to do it or the same group to do it, I guess it would be ideal, but I would think if they, with the study that went into it they could probably you know do a walkthrough and at least see whether there's been any significant changes or incursions in that very least and they may be other issues going on that would or new regulations that would have to or big or best practices may be a little bit different i think
[2:03:22] Joe Coronati: one item additional it's a nitpicky but just having all the items for the conceptual design review he on that sheet on the resource sheet yes which items are all under 7.6.1b it goes item one wetlands shoreland areas significant habitat corridors rare and endangered habitat frozen buildings within 100 feet it goes on further you do have a fair amount of them but just i've just double checked that yeah it'd be nice it's nice to have the calculations kind of all organized versus having to hop from section to section if you have room on it i think chris called that out we could do that he had in his completeness review confirmation of a suitable holder for the future open space yeah that's that's definitely
[2:04:49] Brendan (Chair): going to have to be something you find a solution to I don't know I don't know how but pretty much something that we can't waver from if it's going to be counted as conservation space that wasn't a completeness thing but that's
[2:05:08] Joe Coronati: just like a right just to be aware of yeah we're stuck at that 60. understood yeah so it's there's never been a situation in the recent past where the hoa has been able to be the holder of
[2:05:23] Brendan (Chair): their own in the end no it's not it's it's prohibited right now anyway and for good reason and you know a good point that was brought up is light pollution because you know all the more reason to be really careful about even the set the setback the 250 foot setback is excessive light and a lot of homeowners these days like to put you know spotlights out everywhere running all night and that does have a significant effect on things like vernal pools because of migration during the springtime not related to this however is the issue of dry of the wells in the area is there anything brendan that we can do to at least question that?
[2:06:35] Drew Olahowski: I would need to check in on that, but if the board feels like there could be negative impact to where adequate water could not be supplied to this property or be a detriment to others, then that's something that the board can at least look into seeing if that is something that a scientist could possibly figure out, a soil scientist or some kind of water scientist of sorts would be able to determine whether or not that aquifer could sustain
[2:07:02] Brendan (Chair): that level of population i think that 's a good idea to try to find i think it's absolutely
[2:07:07] Andrew Schlunz: worth investigating considering the testimony that was provided for those who were present
[2:07:13] Brendan (Chair): already live right nearby yeah you know it's it's it would it would be an impact for sure
[2:07:22] Joe Coronati: or if that was the case broadly in that area well you should also consider the
[2:07:38] Andrew Schlunz: other side of that as well with how far down they're drilling having to drill and what that impact does to the ground layers underneath and what that any the issues that could cause in the future now going forward i've i've never lived with
[2:08:00] Brendan (Chair): with a well like property so i'm not experienced in that but i have it's very expensive and it is not fun and the issue is you could go as i understand it you could go 50 feet in one direction and hit water and the other direction have to go 800 feet before you hit water up so whether that can be determined or not I think it's certainly worth having Brendan take a look and see what options there are for protecting wells and neighboring areas because obviously you don't want to have a bunch of houses in there without with water problems either even a few okay anything else we need to cover here not
[2:09:01] Joe Coronati: at this point there's another comment we have concerns about the roadway design and the impact that this would have on the already tight corner i have a note of traffic
[2:09:16] Brendan (Chair): study question mark that's probably future yeah brendan i would assume that town engineer would be brought in on this because of the size of the of the or the size of the development
[2:09:32] Drew Olahowski: number of houses depending on possibly so all of that would be addressed though at least at least during the preliminary application phase, 6-3, I think 6-3-14 and 6-3-17 call out different levels in which traffic impact analyses and possible offsite improvements could be required.
[2:09:54] Andrew Schlunz: There was a comment in regards to the current driveway is in a spot that was not approved. Do we know, well, can we confirm that?
[2:10:04] Joe Coronati: that? Well, it was an old logging road. Is that right? Right. It's been there for many years. It's not a driveway. There's no house out there or anything. It's just a borderline trail. I don't know what it looks like at the moment, but last time we were out there was when we dug test pits and it was, you know, like literally a trail out to the end of the woods that we used for an
[2:10:30] Brendan (Chair): excavator okay thank you at some point we certainly would want to do site walk too good idea and the appropriate time would we win well not the calendar time i've said before what part of the process i think we'd have
[2:10:52] Joe Coronati: to accept the application first at least into the conceptual section yeah right now we can't have a site well no what yeah under sketch we'd have to accept it in some capacity i would think
[2:11:11] Brendan (Chair): so and there's nothing said we can saying we can't have more than one sidewalk so that's true So, yeah, let's keep that in mind if we get to the point where the conceptual plan is accepted, at least.
[2:11:33] Andrew Schlunz: Yeah, I think you can make a recommendation.
[2:11:37] Joe Coronati: Was the sketch plan accepted as complete? You could walk it based on that jurisdiction? I don't think we've ever done that. no i think the sketch plan doesn't start a time clock for you i think it needs to be officially in queue to schedule that yeah i believe so
[2:12:00] Brendan (Chair): okay anything else any questions from the applicant no
[2:12:11] Jenna Green: so do we need to request to be
[2:12:13] Brendan (Chair): continue to the next meeting here i would say we would we would not have to continue it because we haven't approved it yet but simply work with the staff and put the materials together and submit them and we'd get you on as soon as we could anything
[2:12:36] Drew Olahowski: else brendan that they need to no mr chair they can contact our office at any time we'll be happy to work with them and keep the flow of information coming and see about the
[2:12:48] Joe Coronati: next meeting date okay well the well the items you brought up be summarized or we just use the minutes to as basically the items we need to address this will need to get these to our goldfire metal and crystal yeah provide these documents some of them are in longmeadow planning review under his completeness portion you're
[2:13:18] Andrew Schlunz: referring to the peer review letter yeah yes yeah do they receive a copy of that yes it's available on the
[2:13:24] Joe Coronati: one i think right yeah so that was seven dot six dot one dot b dot one through three is what you call that and that involves the habitat corridor and the other items and the other item of
[2:13:39] Brendan (Chair): course was that other separate homeowner association right parcel of conserved land that has to be addressed satisfactorily for the ordinance, however you do it. Okay? All right. Okay, if it's still okay with the board, we'll take a five minute break and we'll ask folks if you go out, maybe go upstairs. stairs okay we're back up again and we will go on to our next application which is 1680 u.s route one we're in a sketch plan for map and lot 100-24 and brendan would you like to set this one up for us.
[2:22:13] Drew Olahowski: Yes, Mr. Chair. For 1680 US Route 1, this is a sketch plan review for a proposed redevelopment of 1680 Route 1 to what the applicant defines as a contractor flex space, leaseable spaces within a larger building for contractors and associated businesses. Proposed structure covers an area of 27,600 square feet with 20 individual units for rent. Staff have highlighted some concerns for the proposed land use, the design standards, landscaping standards, and traffic impact among others. Some items in the review though, the applicant has already responded to and addressed some of those concerns. However, that was prior, that goes within the window, the 17 day window. So they're here to discuss those with the board and see how the sketch plan can move forward potentially. Okay.
[2:23:09] Brendan (Chair): Then if you would introduce yourselves and spell your last names for Recording Secretary, please.
[2:23:15] Heath Davis: Sure. I'm Heath Davis, D-A-V-I-S.
[2:23:18] Joe Coronati: Andrew Schlunz, Outer Engineering, S-C-H-L-U-N-T-Z.
[2:23:24] Brendan (Chair): Okay. Then you want to give an overview of what you're planning?
[2:23:30] Heath Davis: Sure, yeah. So Heath Davis, developer for the proposed redevelopment of 1680 US Route 1. I LIVE HERE. I'M A RESIDENT IN CABE NETTIC WITH MY WIFE AND TWO DAUGHTERS. I HAVEN'T WORKED DIRECTLY WITH THE PLANNING BOARD YET BUT I HAVE DEVELOPED MULTIPLE PROPERTIES IN TOWN ON THE RESIDENTIAL SIDE. WHAT WE'RE ULTIMATELY PROPOSING HERE IS BRENDAN STATE 27,000 SQUARE FOOT PREENGINEERED METAL BUILDING FEATURING 20 SMALL FLEX INDUSTRIAL UNITS. I DID WANT TO QUICKLY THANK BRENDAN FOR HIS PRELIMINARY FEEDBACK WHICH WAS HELPFUL COMING INTO THIS MEETING JUST TO KIND OF GET TO THE POINT AND NOT WASTE TIME AND THEN ANDY will be able to speak to any specific technical questions that you guys might have about the site plan. For clarity regarding the target tenants and the land use, we are firmly specifying a multi-tenant light industrial warehousing and material assembly hub. We are not proposing a commercial retail contractor center or a retail service shop, which we understand is prohibited in this zone. Assuming this project is approved following development, I am planning to keep the building in my portfolio and manage the asset myself. It's right down the road from where I live it's worth noting that the demand is significantly outpacing supply for these types of spaces with a vacancy rate under three percent new york county there's a strong need for the specific use case right here in our community so we're happy to take any questions or give any further color on the project i'm
[2:24:52] Joe Coronati: going to make a motion to accept for a sketch second i was asking if I can yes I moved to accept 1680 u.s. route 1 or sketch map 100 lot
[2:25:11] Brendan (Chair): 24 for sketch review second okay moved by David and seconded by crystal Any other questions? Call for a vote. Crystal? Yes. David? Yes. Cheryl? Yes. Okay. Then what's your interest? Where should we start here? We
[2:25:42] Joe Coronati: can work off of Brendan's memo. Okay. If there's interest in holding a public hearing for this. Very quick. quick.
[2:26:04] Brendan (Chair): Yes, then. Can we have a motion to open a public hearing on this?
[2:26:10] Joe Coronati: Move to open a public hearing for 1680 US Route one map 100
[2:26:15] Brendan (Chair): lot 24. Second. Okay, moved and seconded. Call for votes. Crystal? Yes. David? Yes. Yes. Chair votes yes for zero. Then is there anybody who would like to speak to this? Yes. If you would just come up to the podium, state your name and spell your last name for the recording secretary. You go right behind the podiums, unless you need to come up front. But either way, you gotta get close to a microphone. Okay.
[2:26:50] John Shaw: John Shaw, S-H-A-W. I live right next door to the thing.
[2:26:56] Brendan (Chair): I'LL NEED A MICROPHONE WITH YOU. OKAY.
[2:27:00] John Shaw: SO ON MY CONCERN IS THE OWNER RAISED THE PROPERTY LEVEL ALL AROUND HERE, LIKE ABOUT BY FOUR FEET, WHICH IS THE BUFFER ZONE IS 20 FEET. IT HAS A LITTLE BIT OF TREES AND THAT'S THE ONLY TREES ON THAT THING. SO EVERYTHING'S UP IN THE AIR. SO MY PROPERTY IS JUST SEEING WHATEVER YOU'RE GOING TO BUILD and i don't want to stop you from building anything but i'd love to see some bushes up on the higher ground to block off as a now the screen compared to the buffer zone and the other concern was they said that this was all going to be paved and just where is that water going to go is it going to run down into the 20-foot buffer zone or is that going to be piped down into the retention pond okay because i didn't want all that water from the tar because right now it's no problem because dirt and everything goes in it but once you tie that
[2:28:01] Brendan (Chair): whole thing where's that water going to go that's my concern any other concerns we'll get to those
[2:28:08] John Shaw: not really because i don't want to stop people from building stuff so you know i just kind of want to protect my stuff okay all right thank you very much thank you thanks okay then is
[2:28:20] Brendan (Chair): there any other anybody else want to speak okay that would be no so without objection i'll close the public hearing and with no objections so ordered then would you like to start off with answering those questions yep there's already a stormwater pond there that
[2:28:48] Joe Coronati: will be utilized and any minor changes required by the main dep will be make sure
[2:28:56] Brendan (Chair): you speak up loud enough so that yeah and maybe get a little closer to the microphone yep yeah
[2:29:03] Joe Coronati: we will use that existing stormwater pond and any changes required by the main dep will be done as necessary so as far as stormwater it's all going into that basin that's already there so are there i believe so we will still we'll have to go through the main dep but yeah that would be my guess yep and then the other item was the buffer for or that side property possible concerns over, or not possible, concerns over the elevation changes between the property lines? Are there any plans to increase buffering or anything like that? Yep, we can as necessary.
[2:29:56] Heath Davis: Yeah, so from a code and guideline perspective specific to Route 1, we had already discussed some of that and obviously we can share that when that comes up. We hadn't talked about the back of the property at this point yet. Most certainly we'll consider it. I know the residents that you're talking about now kind of behind the property. Yeah, so as we present the actual building and site plan and so forth, when we get to that level of detail, we'll take that into consideration.
[2:30:24] John Shaw: Yeah, but before they had a pile of dirt and spray. Yes. And now it's very strong. Are you still ready to move it
[2:30:34] Rebecca Harrington: next? all the lights all the sounds all the smells and neighbors
[2:30:43] Brendan (Chair): let's yep oh and again if this goes forward you'll get another chance to review the updated plans too and comment again and you know i'm glad you spoke up because they've heard you so hopefully they'll come up with a solution that will work for everybody in general are you raising the whole area significantly from what it is right now no so it's that level up there right now yeah I have to go with these guys right now yeah there's some there's some great changes
[2:31:34] Heath Davis: towards the if you're looking at the map the right side of the property here but for the most part
[2:31:37] Brendan (Chair): yeah it's it's level and wait a minute I'm sorry I can't we can't have a back and forth here because the public hearing is over just for formality's sake here has well just one general question is the existing business no longer a landscaping business or is it taking just a corner of it or what's or is it going to be one of the one of the units in here so Tom is selling
[2:32:11] Heath Davis: the site we're under contract on the property and he has another property that he's moving his business and materials too good that helps explains that kind of like a conditional sketch see if the property will be purchased maybe correct yeah we're we're in you know exactly yes we're in the research phase currently that will dictate whether or not the deal comes to
[2:32:35] Joe Coronati: life going forward into more advanced meetings if that's what happens i'm not sure if right title of interest concerns are going to get brought up by just giving you a heads up so that's not a trip wire at the last minute whether the property owner conveys agreements to you that allows you to act on getting approvals for his land or whatnot just legal wise something to look
[2:33:07] Drew Olahowski: out for okay check with town staff on that typically a letter from the price letter a signed letter from the property owner providing permit or granting them permission to do this as you know conditional agreement of purchase that's not out of the ordinary for the town to accept
[2:33:26] Heath Davis: and for what it's worth has tom reached out to you brendan i yes he has okay so tom is tom is looking for this to come together as well so he can he can move on so he'll be in support yep
[2:33:39] Brendan (Chair): i don't quite understand the drawing it looks like it's this cross hatchet in the middle of the building but it doesn't look like 20 separate units can you explain that a little bit
[2:34:01] Heath Davis: sure so contiguous 27 000 square foot structure as we had mentioned in the middle and so as you will see here, I believe there is, yeah, 10, and then 10 this way as well. So 10 on each side.
[2:34:17] Brendan (Chair): And what about the parallel line at the bottom, you know, about a tenth of the way up there?
[2:34:28] Heath Davis: Parallel line at the bottom.
[2:34:30] Joe Coronati: Inside the building. I think those might be measurement arrows. Yes. That's what they are. For the 276 radiating out.
[2:34:43] Brendan (Chair): okay i see i see i didn't see the arrows at the end of it looked like you were subdividing that those on that side like another partition yeah like another partition okay
[2:34:58] Andrew Schlunz: okay and other questions that i did have a question in regards to traffic or traffic study I think it would be important to have one performed and then the other question was in regards to parking this is what's what's the parking variance difference between industrial and commercial sure so it's for the
[2:35:39] Heath Davis: the industrial use case it's 44 that we would need on this site for the commercial it would have been 72.4 because
[2:35:48] Brendan (Chair): you don't have customers coming on site correct yep
[2:35:55] Heath Davis: important delineation here when atar had sent over their first memo to the town for review that was unclear and so brendan's feedback was we're going to have a number of issues here if you're trying to go after commercial and we had to re-clarify that okay excellent and then i'm
[2:36:14] Andrew Schlunz: just thinking about the amount of coverage that would be paved and what that would do to the overall calculation of the law to the impervious yeah sure we have all that okay the
[2:36:30] Drew Olahowski: impervious as impervious service shown on the plan is 49.2 percent maximum allowable in route 1-6 is 50 percent yep that was a concern during my review was that the plan notes had indicated 30 slopes were utilized to indicate to calculate that we require anything greater than 20 percent i confirmed with brandon lanning one of their engineers at attar that this was just a typo on their end and they ran the calculations back and everything came back kosher oh cool and then in
[2:37:05] Andrew Schlunz: regards to any minutes of any what are they just talking about sounds light etc is there a plan to put like a fence or a buffer towards the back to sort of minimize that impact to neighbors so you said you didn't give a lot of thought to it but yeah no as it's as it's come
[2:37:29] Heath Davis: up just off the cuff yeah i mean we're gonna have to give you guys a pretty comprehensive layout of what we want to do for a buffer zone for the 100 foot setback to root one anyhow so that'll be presented to you at the same time sure we have had another application in the past that's
[2:37:45] Joe Coronati: designing space to be determined by whoever chooses to rent and i was briefly talking with code and I'm not sure code agrees with me but he did not agree with me for the uses that you're requesting if you just pre listed them and then as we're designing the site with you and approving what's presented or working with you through it we would design to those standards so if you wanted all of the industrial uses then you could almost request that to be allowed on the lot it was also brought to my attention that uses on route one i'll find the section for you 18.12 it allows code to issue the permits on that section if it's less than 2500 square feet and where each unit could technically have its own use per bay, then that would go through code anyways after it's approved or not. My concern when I saw the 20 potential uses was every time there was a tenant, they'd have to come back to us to get the use approved. And I was trying to prevent that from being a revolving door situation.
[2:39:13] Heath Davis: situation basically predetermine the use cases so that there's no we don't have to revisit this and so it's just this fits into the box or it doesn't yeah so it falls outside that
[2:39:23] Joe Coronati: yeah okay and then also addressing i guess what would happen if two units were combined or three units were combined if that was ever an option for a tenant to do would trigger a greater amount than that 2500 if there's three units we'll say okay so just adding a plan note that states if a use not previously listed is greater than 2500 square feet approval from the planning board as per use table would be required makes sense that's a good idea actually it's a little more involved for sketch but as you're it's easier to get that stuff in now than an afterthought if it really changes and then I'm sure you've seen which is why the building is not more than 30,000 square feet some of the conditions based on that you had mentioned 100 feet either undisturbed or planted vegetation screen I believe it's referenced as so that was just a comment I wanted to make sure you were aware of for future work for the board and land uses in general it's very strange that lighter commercial uses are not allowed in this zone like you can't have a carpenter shop carpentry shop but you can have a machine shop assembly and wood fabrication under industrial use But if you look in, I think it's section one, it goes down and lists what each zone of route one dash whatever view or vision was. So this was rural mixed use. And it pretty much says, this is summarizing, do what you want, just don't let it be seen from route one. It was my interpretation of it. so same I think designing in that character will help and then going forward once there's elevations if you find a building design you like another item I was kind of not concerned with but envisioning here's the elevation of the land just getting trees or vegetation to be higher than that building isn't going to fully screen it so just keeping in mind the architectural view shed I guess, that it would be seen from Route 1.
[2:42:09] Heath Davis: Make it as aesthetically pleasing as possible and not just a plain metal building. Yeah, exactly. Understood. That would be nice. Yes.
[2:42:15] Brendan (Chair): That has to do with things like changes in the roof so that it isn't all one blank roof. Some variations in it or little dormers or cupolas or whatever to provide some variety and it doesn't again doesn't look like just a warehouse Brendan you said six three thirteen calls for all buildings not separated run by 50 feet or less to meet all the design standards with that ordinance yes in that category yes so I
[2:43:03] Drew Olahowski: in my review i highlighted that 6 3 13 is not triggered but 16 6 3 13 3 the call for all calls for all newly constructed buildings to show their best face forward if they utilize route one as their point of access which i believe this does fall into so it would just need to show its best face forward
[2:43:30] Brendan (Chair): and probably the back is going to look the same as the front I'm assuming unless you create some visual details that could have two best faces yes you could yes it doesn't matter if you make the back the same as the front but what they don't again the idea is not to have blank walls to have an entrance make it look like it's part of you know the area rather
[2:44:07] Drew Olahowski: than just you know as in a blank wall I will also say that with 63 it's unique in the zoning ordinance and that the board can wave elements of 63 so if hypothetically there was sufficient EFFICIENT SCREENING TO WHERE THIS WASN'T SEEN FROM ROUTE ONE AT ALL AND THE BOARD FELT COMFORTABLE THAT YOU COULD ELECT TO WAVE THAT BUT IT HAS TO BE PROVEN YEAH USUALLY BEST FACE FORWARD IS IN
[2:44:36] Brendan (Chair): REFERENCE TO A STORE OR FACILITY THAT HAS THEIR ENTRANCE ON THE SIDE AND A BLANK WALL IN THE FRONT WE TRY TO TRY TO GET SO THAT AT LEAST LOOKS LIKE THERE'S AN ENTRANCE ON THE ON THE ROADSIDE So it's more visually appealing in this case. You have a single entrance isn't what interest is facing fun Yes, we do but you have the parking primarily in the back
[2:45:05] Joe Coronati: That was actually one of the questions that I had So the rear facing side, there's a parking spot essentially for every unit right there for the frontage the piece facing route one there's a door it doesn't look like there's a sidewalk and you've got a 21 foot roadway that goes both directions right so i don't know if maybe having some kind of a sidewalk or some kind of a brick walkway just for protection of people coming in and out of each of the units because you're gonna have traffic going both way 21 feet is reasonable no question about it but if I'm coming if I'm a unit owner and I'm coming out and I'm looking one way and a cars coming the other way the result might not be pretty so creating some visual reference point that causes me to pause might not be a bad thing am i making sense okay and
[2:46:20] Brendan (Chair): obviously parking is not allowed in the front one but yeah I see I see a point even if it's just you know a painted sidewalk area with maybe some bollards or something two foot two and a half two feet wide some
[2:46:38] Joe Coronati: something that creates the person exiting to notice that there's a change
[2:46:45] Heath Davis: in scenery and i need to look so delineation between the walking area in front of the building
[2:46:50] Joe Coronati: yeah the internal roadway makes sense easy enough to do sure that's good with
[2:46:58] Andrew Schlunz: the traffic flow i just want to make a note of ensuring that any emergency vehicles are able to enter fully swing around the building if you have if it must but turning radius as well when I looking at the front of the building does that say 21 feet of a width between the corner of the building to the end of the road yep it's a tight squeeze yeah
[2:47:34] Joe Coronati: we were able to track that halfway around and had a 72 foot long tractor trailer through there so we can compare that to any fire truck that the town might the
[2:47:51] Heath Davis: building initially was 30 000 square feet and when we had them pin it out we stood at the front and we're like this there's just not enough room here right so we shaved off two of the front units made the swap bigger my i hadn't thought of emergency vehicles but my thought was i wanted a team to be able to pull in this comfortably WITHOUT GETTING TOO CLOSE TO THE BUILDING AND GO ALL THE WAY AROUND THE BUILDING AND BACK OUT. SO I'M HOPING THAT IF WE CAN FIT 18 WHEELERS THROUGH, THEN WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO FIT EMERGENCY VEHICLES AS WELL.
[2:48:17] Andrew Schlunz: WHAT IS YOUR PLAN FOR THE WINTERTIME, THOUGH?
[2:48:20] Heath Davis: AS FAR AS PLOWING?
[2:48:21] Andrew Schlunz: YEAH, PLOWING, YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO BE NARROW.
[2:48:25] Heath Davis: i mean we have a we have a pretty big amount of square unused square footage in the level area of the lot already on the side of the building that you know now that we don't have to have all those parking spaces over there 's going to be plenty of room for stone
[2:48:41] Andrew Schlunz: is that also where you're planning to put dumpsters i'll be honest i haven't got that far
[2:48:48] Heath Davis: that's correct it's a good question yeah fair question yeah no that was not initially where we thought that we were going to put dumpsters because there was parking but now i suspect that i'll have to put dumpsters on both sides of the building so all great considerations thank you
[2:49:07] Brendan (Chair): that's a tricky one because some users might not need dumpsters and others might go through them
[2:49:14] Joe Coronati: pretty quickly yeah it's a tricky one there are some services where you could have your own toter kept inside the building and then on their pickup days you just wheel it out by your door and it's a smaller like i don't want to name brands but not it's a small truck operation that a lot of people in wells use yeah just as an option or that a fenced-in area where everyone can store their little toters on the egress to and from one before you get to the building that roadway doesn't have at least i don't see a width is that also 21 feet i can check that yeah i'll add it to the drawing
[2:50:10] Heath Davis: the initial entrance yes width of road yes i thought i don't know that i don't know the answer to that but i know that brandon has it somewhere or brandon i'm sorry
[2:50:21] Drew Olahowski: I would actually I don't have that information either that's it's not indicated on the plan set
[2:50:28] Brendan (Chair): okay in a sketch plan it's a good opportunity to just make sure that's delineated on the on the plan talking
[2:50:38] Joe Coronati: about that you're talking about the road coming up I'm not sure if that road is set in stone and not fully a requirement but if there was more of a meandering path it might help with the screening yep portion I know now just by driving down if you look down you just see the block containers of their storage bins right now pretty much be this building if there was either like a little vegetated island behind that ABA parking spot on the corner or something that's kind of buffering that straight shot from route one or if the road curved or did something it might help with that screening okay it's hard when it's a straight shot down aesthetically when you look from the street if the first thing you see is the back end of cars it's not as attractive as among other ones understood
[2:51:53] Brendan (Chair): i am not one to push for more parking than the applicant wants But I can think of some electricians or other tradespeople who might have a bunch of vehicles. Would it just be up to them to find a different place to park them, or how would you handle that if you had you know numerous ones that had four or five vehicles each
[2:52:30] Stephanie Byrne: so
[2:52:33] Heath Davis: what we're going to do here ultimately is thread the needle between what the town requires for the zone and what we think would be preferred by our user our end user yeah there is going to be a fair amount of flat unused space again there's a couple considerations now we're talking about dumpsters we're talking about snow removal things of that nature my plan was to have defined areas where overflow vehicle parking could happen whether or not it was paved or not and again it's going to live in that corner that i was talking about so to your point there needs to be more as long as the town is okay based on the use case with what we pitch to you what we will bring in addition to that is what we're thinking for overflow if that's fair But there's going to have to be some type of a ceiling. I can't have everybody in there want to have five vehicles on, right? So that really comes down to my lease agreement and what we'll be allowed for.
[2:53:28] Brendan (Chair): That's a good point. And, again, I'm not encouraging you to put more asphalt up there by any means. If you do, at minimum, you can justify.
[2:53:39] Andrew Schlunz: Brian, is there a concern about the number of possible tractor-trailer trucks turning in and out of that entrance onto Route 1? in the in an increase of tractor trailer trucks that could be a point of concern that's that's
[2:53:55] Drew Olahowski: whenever we would get the town engineer involved in review it depending on the number of trips generated by the site it could end up requiring a traffic impact analysis to be impact analysis to be performed in which case the town engineer would have to review all of those findings verify them, and then make any kind of recommendations for if perhaps off-site improvements are needed on Route 1, either like a, let's say like a flashing hazard light, or do the sight lines work out to where, because I don't know the speed limit in this area, I believe it's in north of, is it 50 in this area, or in the 45?
[2:54:33] Andrew Schlunz: I think in that area, it just ticks to 35, and I think it's, no, is that still at 55? 55 well so it's in there's a range where it goes from 55 to 35 it also goes from four lanes to two so and it's like all within this area so that was why i brought up the concern for tractor trailer trucks in this area that's already kind of either becoming congested due to a significant decrease in speed limit as well as road capacity limit and then you have it on the other side so where the tractor trailer trucks would be turning in and out assuming they're coming from south north from the highway north they would be cutting it close with that turning radius in because you're kind of narrowing it down and or coming out so i think a traffic study would and should be conducted if we get to that point and i think part of that also depends
[2:55:35] Drew Olahowski: It depends on the design of the entryway, too. Just depending on what is the proposed width of the curb cut, would it be able to accept a tractor trailer moving in at what kind of speed? There are other elements, too, that we can look at on top of that. Okay.
[2:55:49] Brendan (Chair): I think the 35 you were talking about is Cape Neck Village, which is actually quite a ways back, and then it gets to Loggin Road, and I think it goes up again to 45, maybe.
[2:56:00] Andrew Schlunz: be no because isn't this address near yorksville kingdom no it's further up oh it's further up
[2:56:08] Heath Davis: it's right before the camp what's the campground yeah dixon's right before dixon's campground
[2:56:15] Andrew Schlunz: oh okay good well that makes me feel a little better
[2:56:19] Joe Coronati: one thing talking about the traffic assessment i think that's based on the use type right when it's calculated. So just be mindful of the uses you're requesting. I'm not sure how the board wants that to be calculated when there isn't just one use, it's a hybrid. This is where my engineering doesn't exist to make that recommendation. But if you had a use that you wanted just to have as an option, but it was the worst traffic count number for you, just I guess take that into consideration but I think having a range of those uses part of that calculation the hybrid of uses are going to be pre-approved we almost real life realisticness not worst case scenario if every use was the worst traffic sure points I guess and again I
[2:57:19] Brendan (Chair): I'd leave a lot of that up to the town engineer on determining that, but I mean, it's been used and it was approved not that long ago as a landscaping business, which they're, you know, big panel trucks pulling trailers and coming in and out twice a day regularly, I think it wouldn't be too far off. off but again that's that's a determination for the town engineer to determine whether a traffic study would be needed but again we're going to have to give them a count by the by the engineering
[2:58:00] Drew Olahowski: manual right it trip generation is required to is that the best standard that we follow so yeah
[2:58:08] Heath Davis: yeah so doesn't seem like a huge departure from current use though is what you're what you're
[2:58:14] Brendan (Chair): saying right it's a busy landscaping business if it was that it is conceivable you know maybe more traffic overall but maybe not more intensive yeah big traffic big vehicles did
[2:58:35] Joe Coronati: you have any questions for us that we haven't answered yet is
[2:58:42] Heath Davis: there anything else like this in town
[2:58:43] Brendan (Chair): that I'm unaware of there is up on Birch Hill white Birch Lane I believe it is at least it was it was approved 12 14 years ago okay but it was the same concept and smaller that's all it was fewer units maybe a half dozen
[2:59:14] Joe Coronati: and units i look at it more like a storage unit than a business it's more of like a central
[2:59:25] Brendan (Chair): reloading supply point than it is yeah but if somebody has a small machine shop they might you know it might be available a carpenter's cabinet shop i can think of a lot of uses and obviously that you've found that is there is demand for such things yeah i can see a lot
[2:59:46] Joe Coronati: of value in it lighting is probably going to be a hurdle just for not shedding them across
[2:59:53] Brendan (Chair): property lines yeah metric planes that kind of stuff yeah so yeah it will require photometric plan and keep into consideration you know dark sky compliant is required anyway Keep in consideration also on the front where you're elevated above the road or neighbors, you wanna be especially careful about light trespass. Sure.
[3:00:21] Heath Davis: Who does a photometric lighting plan study?
[3:00:24] Brendan (Chair): There's lots of them there. Oh, you can do it? Okay. That's pretty standard. You go to the manufacturer and they help you produce it, right?
[3:00:35] Joe Coronati: Yep, it's just another sheet we add on. Just another sheet.
[3:00:38] Brendan (Chair): And again, just consider, even if it's not absolutely required, the elevation makes, you need to be more sensitive that the light doesn't reach the neighbors. Okay. Okay. Makes sense. And Dean will probably require, and perhaps there already is, a light at the entrance. Do you happen to know if there is?
[3:01:06] Joe Coronati: Like a street light on Route 1 or anything?
[3:01:08] Brendan (Chair): Yeah, a street light. Yeah, he may require, he often does require, you know, a 15-foot light or something similar. Could be, could be. I think there is. Oh, yeah. Could be. Yeah, at the Elk's Lodge, yeah. I remember it as Elk's Clams, Fried Clams.
[3:01:46] Joe Coronati: okay Brendan did we leave anything out
[3:01:50] Heath Davis: I want at least another hour and a half of your time
[3:01:54] Unidentified speaker: at least oh goodness
[3:01:57] Drew Olahowski: that's all from pretty much all from my review seems traffic parking landscaping you know it's 100 foot setback 50 foot front buffer yard has to be has to be landscaped in accordance with 6 3 10 that would be all of my notes that I have in the moment
[3:02:18] Brendan (Chair): You can, you can speak afterwards if you'd like. And again, the, you know, there'll be engineered stormwater done on site so they put their reputation engineers put their reputation on the line when it talks to stormwater and they're pretty good at that. so again i'm just going to have to ask you can just grab me after okay there you go okay then if that's it do you have to make a motion for anything nope yep just project goes further and reapplies yep as soon as you forward to seeing you again i think it's a good idea and keep in mind it's always best to get all the required information into the planning office the first time so that we don't have to come back again. And that'll speed things up a lot.
[3:03:24] Joe Coronati: Got it. And feel free to check in prior to actual submission if you have questions, just so things don't get brought up before a meeting and then not that 's bad, it's just the process, so.
[3:03:35] Brendan (Chair): Yeah, yep. Yep. Okay, thanks. Appreciate your time. Thanks so much. Thanks, guys.
[3:03:40] Joe Coronati: very popular you are now we
[3:03:59] Brendan (Chair): do have findings of fact three
[3:04:08] Joe Coronati: sets of minutes and two findings thank you where do
[3:04:20] Brendan (Chair): you want to start what do you want to start
[3:04:21] Joe Coronati: yeah we do have three new findings for holding anyone up yeah okay now because
[3:04:27] Andrew Schlunz: my meeting minutes are all
[3:04:35] Brendan (Chair): right then how about Mountain Road amendments draft THIS
[3:04:53] Joe Coronati: IS MORE OF THE FORMAT OF THE FINDINGS. I KNOW WE HAVE FINAL PLAN AS WHAT IT IS, CALLING OUT WHAT IT IS, BUT IF IT'S AN AMENDMENT, DO YOU THINK WE SHOULD ADD GOING FORWARD, LIKE, AMENDMENT, AMENDED FROM PREVIOUS PLAN AND KIND OF KEEP A LEDGER BACK FROM WHEN THE LAST APPROVAL WAS? I DON'T KNOW IF THAT'S HELPFUL. I'm not sure what I actually think it's a good idea because we've had a few of these come back come back and come back and come back and come back so being able to trace the lineage, I would think, is to our benefit that's a change the board would like to see then i am more than happy to include that it was more when it just said it is the final plan but it's also an amendment to a previously approved plan it doesn't say that anywhere else right it's it says up in the header like a plan amendment but then when it goes down you know list the materials submitted i guess it is final stage final plan i don't know just something that caught out my eye it's been fine for all these years so just improving the system a little there's a
[3:06:11] Drew Olahowski: change that y'all would like me to make i'm happy to do it i
[3:06:15] Joe Coronati: think for this one it's okay i'm gonna say do it going forward yeah that's fine with amendments at least sounds good to me okay this one was a pretty small yeah i think otherwise it looks good to me and
[3:06:33] Brendan (Chair): And that's the meeting I missed, so I'll take your word for it. So if there's nothing, would anyone like to motion to authorize the chair to sign the findings batch?
[3:06:56] Andrew Schlunz: Steve was here for this meeting, right? Yeah. So we can, because we vote.
[3:07:02] Joe Coronati: Yeah, so this happened recently.
[3:07:05] Drew Olahowski: Recently members that weren't present can still vote to authorize the chair as long as long as they have reviewed the previous meeting and feel they're substantially up to speed on the case.
[3:07:23] Andrew Schlunz: So if Steve, you and myself were present, we can vote unless Chairman Wayne reviewed the application and is able to vote as well.
[3:07:41] Brendan (Chair): Right. You know, something like this is simple enough that probably could do that, but I have yet to see the video because I couldn't see it. It doesn't exist, and I have yet to see approved minutes. So, Erin, on the side of safety, if we have a quorum that could go, then I'd say let's go that way.
[3:08:08] Andrew Schlunz: so then in the motion you
[3:08:13] Brendan (Chair): can authorize me to sign it because I'm I'm just your
[3:08:20] Joe Coronati: voice but I'm not I don't have to you're acting only in your capacity as chair right no I'm not and you're executing on an approval that was passed with a
[3:08:35] Andrew Schlunz: majority willing to make a motion I moved the chair to approve the findings of facts for application 9 Mountain Road plan amendment and condo conversion tax Pax Map 0097, Lot 0018.
[3:08:58] Brendan (Chair): Really close with the language. Urenes. The authorize the chair to sign the findings of Pax.
[3:09:09] Andrew Schlunz: And I authorize the chair to sign the findings of Pax. Second.
[3:09:17] Brendan (Chair): Second? Yep. Okay. Motion by Crystal, seconded by Steve. Let's call for votes. votes. Kristen? Yes. David? Yes. Steve? Yes. And I will abstain. So the motion passes 3-0 and one abstention. Thank you. And the next one is Pine Ledge. Also
[3:09:57] Joe Coronati: pretty small. It's just a removal of a plan note that restricted it to only being affordable housing right no revision same dates this didn't have any conditions right because it was just a striking of a note yes that's my reference again
[3:10:34] Brendan (Chair): pretty straightforward and again i wasn't there can
[3:10:41] Andrew Schlunz: i try it again go for it i authorized the chair to sign the findings of facts for Application, Pine Ledge Cluster Subdivision Amendment Tax Map 0099, Lots 0103, 0115, 0119, 0121, and 0122.
[3:11:09] Brendan (Chair): Second. Perfect. You second it? Okay. Moved by Crystal, seconded by David. Any discussion? No. Call for a vote. Crystal? Yes. David? Yes. Steve? yes again three zero with one stem okay and minutes i think
[3:11:34] Joe Coronati: we partially reviewed these and changes were made i'm remembering right there was something the last meeting we didn't have a question but we talked about them yeah with vacancies with absences we did not have a quorum but we kind of I've pointed a few things out. Yeah. I don't know if these have been updated since.
[3:11:54] Brendan (Chair): The September 10th one, I know I was there. [Joe Coronati: I was absent.] And you were out, okay.
[3:12:02] Joe Coronati: We were also running out of time that night. That's true. 1023 when we got to this point.
[3:12:07] Andrew Schlunz: Yeah, I was present. So my only two edits for these meeting minutes on September 10th, there's line number 40 And line number 45, they are the same, which is the correct spelling of my name, which is C-R-Y-S-T-A-L. In the meeting minutes, it is recorded as C-H-R-Y-S-T-A-L. [Bill Goodwin: Okay. okay to] be a little nitpicky if you want line number 55 to put pm after the time of 905 to be in conformity with the rest of the time stamped which line my number 55.
[3:13:08] Brendan (Chair): yeah it didn't go all night to the end of the morning [Joe Coronati: the next meeting] it only seemed like it [Jim Gilroy: any other] corrections move
[3:13:26] Joe Coronati: to approve the amendments for Thursday September 10th as amended second
[3:13:32] Brendan (Chair): moved by David, seconded by Crystal call for a vote, Crystal and Steve
[3:13:39] Joe Coronati: I abstain I was at that
[3:13:46] Brendan (Chair): one So, yes, I was there with that one. You were there. This one, I was thinking the other one. Yes. So, vote yes. So, it's 3-0 and one abstention. Yes. And again, in a pinch, if you would read all the materials and preferably watch the video, you could have voted.
[3:14:13] Joe Coronati: Okay. So, this is the – oh, sorry. I jumped ahead to the 24th. Okay.
[3:14:18] Brendan (Chair): Okay, so now the 24th, that's the one.
[3:14:24] Andrew Schlunz: So one gleaming edit, which I'm sure we all saw was line number two, updating the date to reflect September 24th, not September 10th.
[3:14:39] Brendan (Chair): And I did not call the meeting to order.
[3:14:47] Andrew Schlunz: Yes, that was gonna be my next one. line number seven mentions chair wayne boardman called the meeting to order at 7 p.m however on lines 9 through 10 notes that he was also absent correct yes vice chair called the
[3:15:03] Brendan (Chair): meeting to order right now so just change that to vice chair david woods yep and line number
[3:15:11] Andrew Schlunz: 9 again adding p.m. after 7 0 7 time stamp just to be consistent yes well [Brendan (Chair): it's] kind of a formatting mention that the bold bullets that are lettered they sort of indent with other motions and they don't stick out so i would it would be my preference if i was to be that nitpicky my name is not pete if you're listening i'm sorry to remove that indent yeah
[3:16:15] Brendan (Chair): yeah really the indent should only be for the bulleted items correct
[3:16:45] Joe Coronati: I move to approve the minutes for September 24th, 2026, as amended.
[3:16:52] Brendan (Chair): Second. Okay, moved by David, seconded by Crystal. Any questions? Call for vote. Crystal? Yes. David? Yes. Steve? Yes. Chair abstains. 3, 0, and 1 abstention. Again. Okay. October 8th.
[3:17:30] Andrew Schlunz: There is no mention of those members who were not present as the other meeting minutes call out. Myself and it appears that Gail were absent for this meeting. Yes. So it should be listed on at least line number 9 to include Crystal Tenney and, correct. We're absent. I was trying to, yeah, we're absent period. Okay. And then that's, I think that's all I had.
[3:18:37] Joe Coronati: Crystal, I'm disappointed on line 49. You didn't
[3:18:40] Andrew Schlunz: say 10 16 PM. I was looking at it as you said that. Yep.
[3:18:49] Brendan (Chair): So line 49, 10 16 at the PM.
[3:18:53] Andrew Schlunz: well in a previous meeting minutes adjourn the word adjourn and the time is on the same time yeah
[3:19:02] Brendan (Chair): i thought that was yeah formatting safe yep okay and so no other corrections
[3:19:23] Joe Coronati: i move to approve the meeting minutes for thursday october 8th 2026 as amended second
[3:19:32] Brendan (Chair): Second. All right. Moved by David, second by Steve. Call for vote. Crystal. Abstain. Go. All right. David. Yes. And Steve. Yes. And chair votes yes, three, zero, and one. Abstention. Skinner v. T.
[3:19:50] Joe Coronati: Consistent. What a small but efficient move. Right?
[3:19:57] Brendan (Chair): Okay. Any other news? I didn't look have you posted the future land use for Tuesday this next
[3:20:12] Drew Olahowski: Tuesday we're going to add that yes it should be on that should be on the list and should be posted okay that should be coming out sometime tomorrow afternoon
[3:20:20] Brendan (Chair): I think yeah we got a very significant package from Dylan on you know trying to summarize all that we've been looking at with regard to the changes for the coming ballot in 1829 and we at that point tried to kind of remove some of the controversial possibly controversial items that aren't directly required by the new legislation for something to consider when we have more time and we're as it is we're going to be presenting a huge package to the select board we'll try we tried to and dylan when he we drafted it to try to get it to four or five separate items on the ballot and combining the ones that logically made sense. And we're going to have to kind of make a final decision on that at the next first meeting in November.
[3:21:42] Joe Coronati: Is that our only public hearing time slot, or do we have one more?
[3:21:48] Drew Olahowski: There is, I think, one, the Planning Board's public hearing slot is in December, actually. The November meeting would be our final workshop to go through it.
[3:21:58] Brendan (Chair): The final workshop before the public hearing, yeah. Right. Yeah. No, the idea being we want to have it as complete as possible for the public hearing. Right.
[3:22:08] Joe Coronati: so we're going to try to polish it up the future land use ordinance subcommittee try to get it as clean and polished and finished as we can and then hopefully get that out really shortly after that last subcommittee meeting so everyone can digest it a little bit there's there's not a ton of new information but it's a whole new packet so it's going to
[3:22:34] Brendan (Chair): take a while to see what's changed it is and some of it is 1829 adjacent okay or
[3:22:46] Joe Coronati: what's the word i'm trying to think it's like in cause of yeah it's it's
[3:22:53] Brendan (Chair): without it collateral it could create other problems or create other uncertainties right
[3:22:58] Andrew Schlunz: yep the next scheduled meeting is I'm looking at the calendar is it November
[3:23:04] Joe Coronati: 3rd yes we changed are you saying the subcommittee meeting yeah oh
[3:23:11] Brendan (Chair): the subcommittee meeting is this coming Tuesday It would be a chance for you to pre-digest it.
[3:23:43] Andrew Schlunz: Yeah, that's what I was thinking.
[3:23:45] Brendan (Chair): It's really a big mouthful.
[3:23:47] Andrew Schlunz: Well, I was thinking pre-digest slash process so that showing up to the planning board a little more prepared versus looking at it
[3:23:57] Joe Coronati: for the first time and if there's public comment on it be nice to not have it placed right in front of you and try to understand it yourself while explaining it to someone yeah that's a talent that's a town hall right here town hall 8 30. i
[3:24:17] Andrew Schlunz: will be present all right okay
[3:24:23] Brendan (Chair): there's still other work to do with that with the zoning but again we're let's try to do just the basics right now because in general may is not a good time to be submitting a lot of zoning articles because you've already got the budget there and big enough yeah i tried to warn the some of the people at the capital planning committee meeting that yes this is going to be a really big they were talking about trying to get more explanation in the voter guide which is a good thing it's gonna be a novel more explanation you know have to do with some of the capital items that are being requested like you know what's a front-end loader maybe a picture or something but it's it's it's a lot and if there was some way of ensuring that everybody every voter read the voter guide it would be great but that doesn't happen either people show up and see our six lines on there what is this hopefully people will though and still they might not understand it because I DON'T UNDERSTAND IT SOMETIMES WHEN I'M IMMERSED IN IT. OKAY. ANY OTHER ITEMS?
[3:26:13] Andrew Schlunz: SO I SEE ON THE MEETING MINUTES THAT PLANNING BOARD SCHEDULING IS NOVEMBER 5TH, NOVEMBER 19TH, DECEMBER 10TH, AND THEN DECEMBER 17TH FOR MEETINGS, WORKSHOP, APPLICATION, WORKSHOP, APPLICATION.
[3:26:28] Brendan (Chair): YES, WE'RE WORKING AROUND THE HOLIDAYS. rather
[3:26:35] Joe Coronati: than working on the holidays
[3:26:36] Brendan (Chair): for some reason nobody was enthusiastic about Thanksgiving evening but
[3:26:46] Andrew Schlunz: with those date changes the location remains the same and time that is correct and
[3:26:53] Brendan (Chair): you booked the room for
[3:26:58] Drew Olahowski: yes Diana got on that right away
[3:27:00] Brendan (Chair): great okay then is that everything? Everything. Oh, good. We'll finish early. Early. [Joe Coronati: Three minutes early.] All right, we are adjourned. No overtime. There you go.