Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[12:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Good evening and welcome to Limerick Planning Board meeting for October 21st, 2026. If you could stand for the flag salute. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. We have some minutes from October 7th. Is there a motion on those? motion to approve those minutes okay it's motion to approve and is there a second i'll second that okay and any discussion on those all in favor okay for walk-ins i guess we have stan do you want to do the update for first yeah is that what you let's let me go through so let's do Let's do Sean under update and yeah, let's hang on and let me do Stonewall Meadows first and then I'll get back to you. So do you want to take the podium for just a minute? Do you mind taking the podium? Going to the podium? Okay. So for the most, looks like for the most part, everything's there that we had asked for. A couple of things that we picked up was lot one has 161 and 110 feet. It doesn't really show any reason why that would be broken up into those two footages on the left-hand side, on the roadside.
[15:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Yep, I do see that.
[15:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Is the 161 supposed to be the one on the right side? and just got misplaced? I wouldn't
[15:30] Speaker A (unidentified): think so because the other one's 354, so I'm thinking this is 341, 354, sorry. So those numbers should be combined. And then I'm wondering if you could explain to me what's going on with that turnaround. It looks really confusing. It looks to me like the road goes around the turnaround. It looks to me like the... so the
[16:15] Speaker B (unidentified): minimum turnaround so l2 and l3 are 50 so the minimum depth and width of a turnaround is 50 by 50 he drew in just kind of a small road so it looks funny because the roads are supposed to be wider i don't know what the minimum for the actual base is does that make sense
[16:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, it looks to me like it's way over on the side towards,, towards the, towards
[16:51] Speaker B (unidentified): the ditch there. So. I don't know if we're looking at the same thing. I don't know.
[16:57] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm looking at, I'm looking at this thing here.
[17:01] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes. So this is the existing road. Okay. That's the existing road? Yes. Yes, this is the 50 by 50 is the, according to your ordinance, is the minimum allotted space for a turnaround. This is just, he just did a small skinny row. This is supposed to, I think, just be wider, but he's just showing that if you take out the requirement, then it shows I can still meet the minimums for everything else.
[17:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Okay. So this here is not really anything. It's just there's nothing been installed. Okay, so this is gonna be this is gonna actually turn around going so if you pretend
[17:40] Speaker B (unidentified): That's not there. Okay. All right
[17:42] Speaker A (unidentified): I was trying to figure that out Okay
[17:49] Speaker B (unidentified): For he forgot to turn around the first time they sit in the stand and he's like it's missing the turn around Okay, by the time I got it back and he hasn't responded X. I'm like, can you make it wider? Yeah, obviously it's gonna be done too. So
[18:03] Speaker A (unidentified): So the hearts will use the existing road. Correct, yes.
[18:12] Speaker B (unidentified): So the turnaround's only meant for emergency vehicles. Yeah. So then you're not allowed to park there or anything.
[18:18] Speaker A (unidentified): So it's not gonna be in the middle of the road there. It's gonna be way over to the right. So I wanna make it that if that ever was continued road, a road continued through, that turnaround was in the way. So it looks like that was a plan, but this yes,
[18:38] Speaker B (unidentified): It was showing it coming off the existing road whatever the road needs to become it would just still Come off the existing road because it shows the 50-foot right-of-way that I've reserved for the road And then in addition to that this the 50 by 50 goes beyond the 50-foot wide right-of-way So there's plenty of room to meet the dimensions of the turnaround. Okay, doesn't need a third side. Does it need a top? now does it need a top measurement for the top measurement is more than it's more than the 50 feet minimum because it's going back yeah i just didn't know if that needed to be delineated on the
[19:18] Speaker D (unidentified): map on the survey so
[19:23] Speaker B (unidentified): you want to show the line coming back of the 50 feet to make it a perfect
[19:26] Speaker A (unidentified): square or 50 feet that make more sense i'm just asking you just kind of show the just show the right away show the sorry yes it doesn't look like that weird yes because what ash is actually saying is so that would have to be the entire entirety of that turnaround would be to that boundary line yeah and so otherwise so by this map otherwise, so it would be better to take care of that. So, let's see, our next meeting, November. We can't have a meeting on November 4th. We'll
[20:19] Speaker E (unidentified): have a meeting that week. So they said because the planning board was meeting the 7th, the 3rd is voting and the 4th would be the planning board and the select board voted to not have a meeting that week.
[20:44] Speaker A (unidentified): And things will be cleaned up for that meeting.
[20:48] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm actually not around the first week of November, so perfect. It's a moot point, I guess.
[20:54] Speaker A (unidentified): How about 18th of November?
[20:59] Speaker B (unidentified): Unfortunately, if that's what it has to be, it goes on that far. Can I have a proxy that someone's there for me, or is that not?
[21:06] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, if you have your surveyor there or somebody that knows the plan.
[21:10] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, my brother is my partner. Yeah. So, I mean.
[21:14] Speaker E (unidentified): The 18th would be the next one? Yeah.
[21:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Or the next one would be sometime in December. So, you, can decide what you want to do.
[21:24] Speaker B (unidentified): I guess my question would be in a hypothetical situation, if it moves to approval, how far from that point before it gets approved?
[21:32] Speaker A (unidentified): It's hard to know. I mean, we could have that hearing and we could deliberate and it could be done that night. Oh, it could happen that quick. We could find some things that... Still need to be done. Still need to be done. But in a hypothetical situation, it's relatively soon after that. Relatively soon. Probably the first meeting in December would be...
[21:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Alright, that's fine then. We can just do the 18th to maintain the consistency of
[21:56] Speaker A (unidentified): maybe the... You want to do the 18th and then deliberate on the third, the first meeting in December? Yep. Why don't we do that? We'll do the public, do the site walk on the 18th and then on, we'll deliberate on December 2nd. We'll do, so we'll go through everything on the 2nd. We'll do the public hearing and the, or is.
[22:25] Speaker D (unidentified): Why don't we just do the public hearing on the same day as the 18th?
[22:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, the public hearing and the site walk on the same day. Yeah. But you can't be here.
[22:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Oh, the 18th you can be here, right? Right?
[22:36] Speaker C (unidentified): He said his brother could. Yeah. No, definitely here the 18th.
[22:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh. It was the 4th that I wasn't here. Okay.
[22:41] Speaker A (unidentified): So you can be here for the 18th? Yes. Okay. All right. So we'll do it on the 18th, and then we'll go from there, and we'll do a site walk and public hearing on the 18th. Do you guys... The time for the site walk? What's that? The time for the site walk?... What do you guys want to do? I'm...
[22:59] Speaker D (unidentified): Clocks, go back to the beginning of November.
[23:01] Speaker C (unidentified): I've got to check my schedule regardless, so you guys decide. But...
[23:05] Speaker A (unidentified): But I'm... I live in town, so I can do most any time. I'll probably forget, but I'll be in town.
[23:15] Speaker D (unidentified): Probably going to have to be like a 4 o'clock, right?
[23:18] Speaker C (unidentified): It's going to be dark by 5, yeah.
[23:20] Speaker D (unidentified): You can change the clocks on November 1st to 4th. Yeah, the 1st.
[23:31] Speaker A (unidentified): So sometime around 3.30, 4 o'clock. That's fine with me.
[23:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Sunset's at 4.26 that day.
[23:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. You guys tell me the time. I don't think it should take that long. Okay. 3.30 on the 18th and then public hearing will be at 7. What's the address for that? Is there an address for that now?
[24:15] Speaker B (unidentified): So it's 329 Parsonsfield Road is the current road that's there now that you see on the survey. GREG BRUDNICKI Okay.
[24:30] Speaker E (unidentified): November. GREG BRUDNICKI No.
[24:42] Speaker A (unidentified): GREG BRUDNICKI And you'll be all right to have the lots all laid out and all that pinned out before, of course, for this November 18th date.
[24:54] Speaker B (unidentified): GREG BRUDNICKI yeah. I could have, I can.
[24:55] Speaker A (unidentified): GREG BRUDNICKI They don't need to be pinned out, but they just need to be flagged out so we know about where the lots are going to be.
[25:02] Speaker B (unidentified): General idea or you need actual, you need the surveyor to stake it?
[25:07] Speaker A (unidentified): We usually have the surveyor stake it, don't we? Yeah. If that can't,. I just gotta confirm with them. If there's a reason, if there's a reason why we can't do that, we'll, we'll do the, first week in December for some reason. So. Yep. When do you, have to know by Friday to put that in the Shopping Guide? I think so. Yeah. We'll
[25:37] Speaker E (unidentified): probably do it on the 4th, but we'll do it on the 6th.
[25:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So you have, you have a few, so by the beginning of November, if you.
[25:48] Speaker E (unidentified): The 6th I'll have to have the information signed somewhere.
[25:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. So if you can't, for some reason you can't make it by, get it all done by the 18th, we'll move it to the next first meeting in december yeah i'll find out this week from the
[26:04] Speaker B (unidentified): survey company okay just to confirm they can put the all right you is now just the just the lock
[26:10] Speaker A (unidentified): corners just the lock corners yes and the turnaround and the turnaround in the turnaround Yeah. Okay. So, I'll make a motion that we, accept this, we'll call it a sketch plan right now, and then, schedule a site walk for November 18th at 3.30 p.m. and public hearing for 7 o'clock p.m.
[26:51] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll second that. Can we revisit the road situation?
[26:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Can we revisit the road? Yes. How about if we take a look first and then we talk about what we're thinking at that point. I'm really pretty stuck on it. So I don't know what the rest of the board feels. I think there's going to be three dwellings using that property, using that road. So I think that's a reasonable compromise. That's my feeling. The rest of the board can think about it on their own and take a look at it and decide what you guys want to do.
[27:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Could I have five minutes just to present some material to you and you guys can take it and think about it for the next meeting so that. Sure. So the reason being is just that I was completely caught off guard with it. That's why I was so unprepared. when i first reviewed this plan with stan back in 2024 the understanding we had was that is a road and that i qualified for the road frontage on that road which i also have the email for as well and the back of the reason is part of the conversations we had regarding it as well so the first part is specific to the road itself so the lot directly behind me which is the heart residence which is lot 13 on the tax map and i brought copies of it So you'll notice on the tax map that there shows 130 feet of frontage on that back lot. And the reason why that's important is because when we were here last time, you had mentioned that you recalled seeing the house in the back being built at one point, and you were wondering how they got a building permit without road frontage because they would have to have a road. So to your point, you can't create a road when there's no road. for road frontage the 130 feet has to be connected to a road back to an existing road so the right-of-way extending from 160 was extended on lot 11 to create 130 feet of road frontage for that which would mean that the rest of the road would have to also be accepted as a town road by the town when they gave the permit out for what that lot 11 which was built i don't know late 80s and on the fact when i went online today it didn't say when it was built i don't know if you know when that
[29:55] Speaker A (unidentified): was built 130 feet that 130 feet doesn't even meet the minimum lot i don't know what it was back in 1980 so that all that's showing is there's a right-of-way there it's a it's that's a hunt and where it is it doesn't refer to really the road how it got there i don't know In
[30:16] Speaker E (unidentified): 1900 or 1902, Vera Sabler bought the properties off the Noah Hill. That was the Noah Hill farm. So the house was there long before that. Vera Sabler also sold the freight box for her individuals. So she retained the lot that the Hots are staying in now. But it was there long before, and you're going to remember our ordinance didn't start until the 1960s and they actually didn't have an approved ordinance until 1987.
[30:58] Speaker B (unidentified): There's also a deed from 1928 for the specific lot and even then it references the 130 feet of frontage of old lane road. So that section that you see there was even deeded in 1928 as an existing road not a driveway So it's it's referenced on here and it gives the dimensions from the actual deed and from the map which I highlighted
[31:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. I guess my feeling is that there needs to be, there's gonna be three people using that road. You're the developer and I think that you should pay at minimum, 150 feet, 125 feet. Now, by rights, I think you should pave 175 feet onto the other lot because your lot that you have shown here in your map, the lot number four, doesn't actually go down to the road which we talked about earlier so by that not going all the way down to the road you can't use that 50 feet wide so you technically don't have any frontage on this on a road so we're giving you it we would be giving you a private road status for part of it for that one house. So that my personal feeling is there's going to be three dwellings using that road. And I think that's a good start if three people are going to be using that and it's a.
[33:11] Speaker B (unidentified): So my last question then would be in the subdivision ordinance, there's a classification specific to a private right-of-way. That's gravel on section eleven point three point two. Mm-hmm so what's prohibiting me from doing a private right-of-way frontage enforcing me into a minor road pavement I got I read the ordinance. So I think specific to the I think
[33:46] Speaker A (unidentified): When you come before this board, you're subject to the conditions that we impose. Yes, we have to go by the ordinance, but we also have the authority to exceed and to make things better for the residents. So I'm not going to bend on this one. So you can convince the rest of the board, but I'm not going to bend i'm that's i'm i'm very i'm very adamant that this is the way it needs to be done and so you're welcome to try to convince the rest of the board but convincing
[34:30] Speaker D (unidentified): me is not going to happen yep i have a question for stan is old lane at all considered a road today does the town recognize old lane as an existing road it has never been it's
[34:46] Speaker E (unidentified): just been a private driveway because it only services one now where the statute and 9-1-1 regulations came into play anything over 200 feet no longer qualifies to be a driveway and then the
[35:02] Speaker D (unidentified): address for the hearts is not old lane road it's parson field it's just it was referred to by vera same as the old lane so but their official address is not old lane no okay her address is
[35:19] Speaker B (unidentified): it technically does service two houses two house lots though because the back lot the knights also are deeded but the key is dwellings because it's not dwelling there right so once again
[35:32] Speaker E (unidentified): there's only one dwelling and it was originally like noah hills and then it was saying there are sailors and now it's the hots. The key is, one, the driveway definition under 911 cannot exceed 200 feet. The other thing that distinguishes it beyond the 200 feet, a private way, and I had to do some research in common terminologies with other towns and municipalities, a private way can serve as two dwellings, but there's another trigger, just like subdivisions, once you hit three it does convert into a public service road because it affects more homes than not but so what garen is proposing is the two dwellings will still be on the dirt private way but the one first lot is going to be on a minor road which should be paved according to the
[36:35] Speaker A (unidentified): standards so it's it's a little bit of a compromise that's how i feel i feel that 's a compromise we're allowing the second the fourth lot there to be not on a on a paved bar i still want to make sure there's 50 feet wide there and someday if that ever becomes an actual road so that other people can add on to it or the other people that have Access to that have that same Because
[37:10] Speaker E (unidentified): you had DOT gave you three entrance permits, but because you don't have enough frontage on Possensdale Road, traffic restraints, the plan board can ask you a conditional that you come out on O-Line, so then you would have to have 175 feet there, so that's where
[37:37] Speaker B (unidentified): so based on that i'm only missing two feet on one lot that's generating this is what you're telling me because i have 175 on two of the lots and i have 173.07 but even if you had even
[37:50] Speaker A (unidentified): if you had 175 feet on all those we still can tell you that we think it would be best FOR EGRESS TO THESE LOTS TO COME OFF THAT OLD LANE. SO WE HAVE THAT JURISDICTION TO DO THAT.
[38:33] Speaker B (unidentified): So my final pitch then to the other members, because I know you're upset on that. So I build homes for low-income people. I mean, I can give you guys letters from people. I just did one the last year. one living in a trailer with his handicapped daughter was going to live on the streets because nobody could build a home I was able to do it at a point that I could make money and for the company where we could make money and get him in a house I built a home last year for one works I have that vanity they couldn't help our backyard I do you cover but we were able to do it I have the email from Stan my impression from the email which you can see as well was that I wouldn't have to do this so I expected a certain cost attributed with doing the development the house I've started on lot 4 which you guys are welcome to walk through when we go do the walkthrough I'm building a multi-generational home so if you look in I know that we have a realtor in the room too so she can back me up and look up the comps but an 1800 square foot house in all of york and county and cumberland county for a new build anything above 1800 square feet 590 000 is the cheapest house the lowest cost house for something that size based on what i've put in for numbers and what i'm trending i'm building an 850 square foot house that has an accessory dwelling unit in it as well so that means i've got i got three bedroom two bath a one-bedroom, one-bath, a one-car garage, and I'm going to be under $500,000. There's nothing around that's even close to this. Those people that have parents that are aging out of place and can't afford $10,000 a month and lose their multi-generational income, they can get into a home like this, have rental income coming in to help them afford it as well, and keep the family together. If you've got kids that are getting older but they can't find someplace locally,, this appeals to them, the additional cost is going to raise the price of everything as well. I know it sounds like it's just a small thing, I get it, but at the same time, there's gravel roads that can be just as wide through, and I don't have to pass that cost to construction, and then I just keep pushing the price up is what I'm trying to avoid, so that's why I'm passionate about it. And I've got the email. know how i understood in what i was facing i understand i come here and things get changed so i get it i've got to respect that but i just wanted to share my thoughts and why i was so
[41:25] Speaker D (unidentified): passionate about it at the last meeting as well generally what's the cost of 125 feet of paving
[41:38] Speaker A (unidentified): 25 000 maybe what's that i don't know today what's just curious what the cost was going to be probably for 125 feet of to do the entire road thank you so it's one of reference so when they're really not talking that much money so i don't know where that price comes
[42:17] Speaker B (unidentified): from i don't get that pricing it cost me to pay the driveway fifteen thousand dollars for a small driveway so i don't know if that's because you're in the town you get a different price point but
[42:27] Speaker A (unidentified): that's not what i would pay for a driveway that was the top that was the top coat but i mean we're talking 175 max on that lot so how wide though too was it 20 24 feet is that what we
[42:47] Speaker C (unidentified): in some ways the discussion you had about multi units or accessory dwellings and multi-generational and that i think kind of supports what aaron's saying a little bit with that, not only is it three lots that are using that, it's three lots potentially that have multiple families living in them. So the volume of traffic on that road is probably potentially down the road might be more than if it was just three lots. Now, granted, it's really only two lots that are affected by that, but I guess that's part of that to something to think about in terms of the volume of traffic that, you know, people that are gonna use that piece. I think that's what your concern is.
[43:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. I think some of these costs are going to have to be borne by the developers. We're asking a developer to come in and pave an entire road from the beginning where it hits Route 11 all the way up past their property. And I think that's probably above and beyond, but they wanna be able to develop their property. And so the previous boards have required them to make upgrades and make paving. Now, you're fortunate that in the old days, is any other people could not work on the town road well this isn't town road at that at this point but there was they like pro keys that they had to hire the town road commissioner or to do that road and that was very expensive. So I think like I say, this is a good compromise. I think giving you the opportunity to create that back lot, to use, to pave a certain part of it and then to use a part of it as a private road, I think that's a good compromise. And I, so let's look at it and then we'll decide. So, okay.
[45:18] Speaker D (unidentified): I would like to see how the back lot uses that road, just to have a visual. So I think that will help. Okay.
[45:30] Speaker A (unidentified): So with that, I think we're good for tonight. We're planning on the, we'll plan on the 18th. And then unless you come back and tell us there's something wrong, something.
[45:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I'll know by the end of this week, if i can get that okay that staked out in time for the 18th so now send that email to stan okay
Unfinished Business
New Business
[45:50] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you so while sean's here stan can you do an update i don't know if you want to do both because there's there's you're listed under old business and new business and i guess we're i'm I'm not sure if the appeals, Board of Appeals, I'm assuming it pertains to this as well, so.
[46:31] Speaker D (unidentified): They're having a termination hearing on the 6th.
[46:35] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes. So Jay's auto is good with what the board would like to do for a sidewalk. Okay. As long as he has a date and a time. Okay. So. All right. the you just dealt with stonewall meadows 41 rangy road i have sent you the email where there's been correspondence from stillwater i also did confirm that with the planning board and told you that in my conversation with eric hamlin with dep that stillwater also confirmed with him that he did have the information so and stillwater does have a backlog because according to his communications, he was on vacation and a backlog of work. Black Bear Burgers, in my opinion, and again, it's gonna be ultimately up to the planning board. I would prefer that they didn't go any further with the planning board until they can make sure that they can afford bringing the subsurface system them up to snuff fine they're very persistent on trying to do and under the counter or inside interceptor so it's they really need to do and I checked with as I told you last week with the site engineer and it is reasonable for them and it's already been made a call motivated to attach to the current subsurface system there so again other than the cost of dinging up and connecting to the tank and to the house for the separate sewer line to the grease and the sink that they're going to operate that's going to add quite a cost and I'm sorry how old is the existing thing it's a brand new system that's it's a year and a half maybe two years old it's the house just before you cross the bridge going into waterborough on the right hand side so the house is very new again my opinion is because they're really don't understand that they cannot have an inside
[49:00] Speaker A (unidentified): interceptor it has to be an external so stan are they still planning on using that as a dwelling
[49:08] Speaker E (unidentified): they are they live upstairs and i'm assuming they're going to make the downstairs stairs which is a finished area as well as a garage into some sort of takeout so this is the
[49:22] Speaker A (unidentified): place on the river there yes yeah so does is that all like meets fire code no they will have to do
[49:29] Speaker E (unidentified): some upgrades with fire codes right because the double layer of sheetrock and all that
[49:34] Speaker A (unidentified): stuff from the ceilings and because if they've got a business down below and a apartment above
[49:40] Speaker E (unidentified): And at that point, because we haven't, the town has not adopted NFPA, we have to bring in with the fire chief, the fire marshal's office to do a walkthrough because depending on what they're using to fry or cook with may depend on whether or not they're going to have to put in a powder extinguisher system or a sprinkler system of some sort. But that will be up to the fire marshal's office at that point. so there's going to be a little more for them to do depending on what scope of work they want to do and then they have a d.o.t entrance permit they have d.o.t has revised van did revise the entrance to accommodate a heavier traffic load all right good and then crane road with linda corbin BEEN, I HAVE STILL NOT HEARD FROM JOE STANLEY. HE HAD CONCERNS ABOUT SOME OF THE EXTENSIVE WORK TO DO. I SAID, WELL, SHE'S DIVIDING THE PROPERTY. SHE'S NOT DEVELOPING IT. I SAID, YOU'VE DONE THIS BEFORE FOR THE TOWN. SO YOU KNOW WHAT THE PLANNING BOARD IS LOOKING FOR IF IT IS AND CAN BE CONSIDERED AS A WAIVER ITEM, ASK FOR A WAIVER. BUT OTHER THAN THAT, she's got to have the subdivision plans that we require with the information that's that's what I have there oh there was the solar farm and we're going back and forth with that the letter we have with the performance bond does specify a termination date but it also says they will annually renewal we're supposed to get a new copy we have not got a new copy that proves that it was renewed so they are in violation there i hope to hear back from them this week if we don't then i am going to ask again the plaintiff board to have a public hearing to consider how to move forward i appreciate
[51:48] Speaker A (unidentified): getting those emails a violation and it scares me i look at it i'm like what's that
[51:55] Speaker E (unidentified): if we don't hold them accountable just like anywhere else it's going to stem into other problems so
[52:05] Speaker A (unidentified): you're also under new business and you have an update on the board of appeals you have new businesses violations for cia the board of appeals the select board has
[52:19] Speaker E (unidentified): has authorized the hiring of Freddie Flaherty, which is Gray Lewis, to represent the appeals board. That firm did ask me for all the documentations. They were forwarded it. I do know he was supposed to talk to Sean's attorney, and from my understanding as of today, that's probably true that he has. But there's been some confusion of whether it's been the town attorney or Gray. I FROM MY CONVERSATIONS WITH SHAWN EARLIER, YEAH, I'M PRETTY SURE IT IS GRAY AND NOT BENT. SO. AND
[53:03] Speaker A (unidentified): THEN YOU'RE UNDER NEW VIOLATIONS. THAT'S AT SACOCAS TRAIL 366, IS THAT CORRECT? SAYS NEW VIOLATION CIA AS UNDER NEW BUSINESS. SO THAT'S ON OUR AGENDA.
[53:22] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, you got the violations, a copy of the violations for 366.
[53:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. And Rangy Road. I'm sorry? And Rangy Road, too?
[53:33] Speaker E (unidentified): And the Rangy Road, which is the subsurface system, the wastebath. The stormwater. The stormwater.
[53:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Which you addressed earlier that it feels like that's progressing.
[53:42] Speaker E (unidentified): And now you've got communications since then that Stillwater has received it in writing. SHAUN HAS ALSO STARTED COMMUNICATING IN WRITING VIA ROUTE 5 TO GET THAT RESOLVED BEFORE THE 29. BUT THE BIG KEY THAT I HAVE EXPLAINED TO SHAUN WITH ANYTHING AT THIS POINT, WE REALLY NEED THINGS IN WRITING SO THAT THE BOARD CAN DECIDE. IT ISN'T THAT THEY'RE NOT WILLING TO WORK WITH YOU, BUT IT NEEDS TO BE SOMETHING MORE SOLID TO MAKE A DECISION norm because they can't keep continuing to allow it to go without being completed
[54:23] Speaker A (unidentified): it gets difficult when the board when the planning board is asked to make exceptions or make changes so we're basically would have to open our meeting change the findings and then and basically we really should open our meeting, have a hearing to change the findings. The only other option is for you to enter into a consent agreement in order for him to get these things resolved, whether it be at Rangy or on Sokokish Trail, I think.
[55:11] Speaker E (unidentified): even with a consent agreement it would have to be with the agreement from the plaintiff board as well because it still will affect the findings of fact in the
[55:23] Speaker A (unidentified): conclusion of law that was defective okay so that get that gets complicated so it does and I don't like the thought of the thought of opening the findings to alter them.
[55:43] Speaker E (unidentified): And I wouldn't recommend that. But again, if they're making progress and they can prove it in writing and they have a commitment date, that's one thing, but again.
[55:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Can we reopen it when we're even in the middle of an appeal anyway?
[55:59] Speaker E (unidentified): If you change any of your findings or conditions of approval, you have to reopen it and have a new public hearing.
[56:06] Speaker A (unidentified): And then it gives a new date and a new possibility of an appeal and so I'm not in favor of that but the rest of the board can think about that but.
[56:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Either way it reopens it.
[56:24] Speaker E (unidentified): And what I am to do if they're in violations I can enter into a consent agreement and it depends on which avenue i choose to take and i would consult with again either board but there is a court ordered consent agreement which is filed with the court it's not an order it's filed with the court and then there is the consent agreement that's with just the town so one versus the other is if we have a consent agreement and the terms not met within the conditions of the consent agreement then i have to go to court the other one the court has already approved it's signed if it's not met then the town can do whatever actions so that those are the two options that i have so just
[57:18] Speaker A (unidentified): trying to think how this works so if you inform the board that there was a violation. And we held a hearing for that. At that point, we wouldn't have to change the findings, but we could come out of that with an agreement to...
[57:51] Speaker E (unidentified): You could, and that would be the same as a consent agreement.
[57:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I would wanna make sure that we...
[57:57] Speaker E (unidentified): That agreement, now that you brought it up, But that agreement after it is signed by both parties, that would be filed at the Registry of Deeds and would be just as binding as a court order because those are conditions put aside in addition. If he's in violation, my job is to notify either board or both boards and in this case, just this board with 41 Range E Road because the select board is not involved with that what you're supposed to do or what one of the options are is the planning board in this case if it isn't done within the date specified which in this case I believe it was 30 days then you couldn't have the option of calling a public hearing to take action disciplinary action up to and including revoking which is also meaning you have the option to revoke the conditional use as it is but you can also make conditions specific to dealing with the issue if there is an agreement and it becomes binding then it has to be filed at the registry deeds can i speak sean
[59:17] Speaker F (unidentified): gerad cia salvage the notice of violations you guys have in front of you are due to two things one the engineer not being able to get to us because obviously we had, I think it was a 60 day window before we thought we could get it done then. Stillwater is backed up on all the stuff they have, the state and federal and all of that. So Stillwater has the plan they're putting together now. We still have to bring that to you to get it approved because you guys wanted to look at it. So the violation that we have is not on our doing. We've done everything, we filled in the hole, We got it. We are great. It's green. We've had the surveyor come in. He's done his end The problem what happened is getting the engineer to do his point That's on rain gene room. That's what we have for violations here. Other than that. There's no violations Yeah, that range you wrote that range. You go down to 366 and Stan wanted me to have a Boundary survey done. Well, if you look at the town map what it shows the outlines in the book out there Mike with on has gone through that and that's also the violation that we have down there is it's not consistent it's not the boundary that he is on the map here in town is not the boundary that we have in town we have what Mike with on Mike is working on that now and we should have that within the next 10 days and then that will eliminate the that will eliminate the violation of that we have reached out to DEP to get an extension because still water has to come down and help us do the new pad and we've asked for an extension until june on that so the concrete we if we have to pour we have to pour if we have to wait till june of next year when we can get still water and have everybody lined up for spring then that's what we're doing standards also has given us a notice of violation for no storm water pull from the pond well if the pond don't run i can't piss in the pond and give you water i can call the fire department and get you know have them dump 20 000 gallons in the pond but if the water's not running out of the pond i can't give you a water sample but i have a violation for that as well i don't believe
[1:01:30] Speaker A (unidentified): that's what i heard was the was the issue i heard the issue was you didn't have the bottles
[1:01:36] Speaker F (unidentified): they didn't have bottles when i called one time so you it's not that we have bottles so there's no water in the goddamn pond that's what that's what the issue is i'm here right now and i and i send stan pictures i can pull up pictures on my phone so there's no water running in the pond to get a sample so you've missed you've missed two of your quarterly
[1:01:56] Speaker A (unidentified): samples no i did not yes you did you missed it you missed your june quarterly sale oh you're sorry you're january you're january to march you missed and then you just missed the next
[1:02:06] Speaker F (unidentified): one so you've missed two i've done two samples i don't know what the date is stan you must
[1:02:10] Speaker A (unidentified): know what the day is april 19th that was that was the only one that we've gotten this year
[1:02:17] Speaker F (unidentified): so no there's been two no there's been one there's been two there's been i've had two
[1:02:23] Speaker A (unidentified): tests i'll bring it down you guys can have it tomorrow the only one i know of was an april 19th
[1:02:27] Speaker F (unidentified): test let's see i can have diane send it to you right now because there's been two samples this year i have no reason to stand here in front of the public in my view so the third sample i cannot get because there's no water in the pond stan can tell you i got no bottles but that's i got i called for bottles one week they didn't have them the next week i go get the bottles been sitting in my office for a month i can't get water out of the pond you want to take a dirt sample i'll give you a dirt sample stan what was the result of the test that we got this
[1:03:01] Speaker E (unidentified): year what we're doing the test didn't show anything significantly different than the previous time
[1:03:09] Speaker A (unidentified): which were fine as well which were well there 's no difference test to test but they're not fine is that correct right now i wouldn't know changes i would result in that
[1:03:24] Speaker E (unidentified): that would be a little concerning. Brian Higgins looks at them, and he used to tell me there's anything, but they've been very consistent in the past.
[1:03:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. So anyway, I think we're kind of getting in the weeds here. This isn't our job to figure out the violations.
[1:03:50] Speaker F (unidentified): If there's no water today to take a water sample, how do you expect me to take a water sample? But last year we had a drought. I couldn't take it for like six months. Now all of a sudden I'm getting a violation because I don't take a water sample.
[1:04:03] Speaker A (unidentified): We've had some pretty significant rains.
[1:04:06] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm surprised. Ask Dan if he wanted to come down and see the pond. I didn't get a response for that.
[1:04:17] Speaker A (unidentified): So it's not up to us to police that.
[1:04:20] Speaker F (unidentified): I understand it's not up to you to police it, but if there's no water, you can't get a sample.
[1:04:26] Speaker A (unidentified): So Stan has issued you a violation for not doing it. I think that it's not a-
[1:04:34] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm here with the planning board and they said that we've missed two stormwater permits and water tests. How many water tests have we done this year?
[1:04:44] Speaker D (unidentified): I have a result here for June 24th.
[1:04:47] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm going to put you on speakerphone.
[1:04:48] Speaker D (unidentified): Here's my- July 2nd.
[1:04:50] Speaker F (unidentified): Here's my girl in the office. Diane, I'm here. is the plane aboard how many water tests have we done so far this year two we got the we got the bottles there for the third one yes and there's no water in the pond thank you well i can tell you there's two and i told everybody this too you have one from june
[1:05:17] Speaker D (unidentified): sample date june 24th extract date july 2nd dep has it
[1:05:24] Speaker E (unidentified): They're not supposed to hear from me.
[1:05:27] Speaker F (unidentified): I understand that, Stan, but if we send it to you and you don't get it, that's, how do I know that?
[1:05:33] Speaker C (unidentified): So Stan, you sent one in July that was for June. You sent one to us in July that was for June. And you said there's an April one as well? So April was the end of Q1 and the June one was Q2? There was one in June.
[1:05:45] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah. It was the last one and I knew it was April. So I stand corrected, it's not true. Yeah. So. I got that.
[1:05:59] Speaker C (unidentified): I can read the date a
[1:06:05] Speaker E (unidentified): couple
[1:06:11] Speaker F (unidentified): weeks back you know but there's no water to do I
[1:06:14] Speaker A (unidentified): can't do any water I'm not trying to get this quarter so April 19th is as a mist
[1:06:21] Speaker F (unidentified): April, May, and June, July, August, September.
[1:06:24] Speaker A (unidentified): So April 19th is a missed test. It's not a missed test. Yes, it is. Listen. Excuse me just a minute.
[1:06:32] Speaker F (unidentified): No, you listen to me. If I put the test in the time frame, and then they take 60 days to get the results, it's not a missed test, Aaron.
[1:06:40] Speaker A (unidentified): The quarter starts June.
[1:06:41] Speaker F (unidentified): You know what? You guys go fuck yourselves. I can sit here and argue with you about shit that's stupid because you're an asshole. Okay.
[1:06:50] Speaker A (unidentified): So a quarterly test is January 1st until March 31st, March, April 1st to June 30th. And so, I don't know, it's not up to us to police this. it's up to you to deal with that, report to us and...
[1:07:21] Speaker E (unidentified): Again, that isn't up to you. That's why I send you the notice to allow you that this is what's going on with the properties. So, okay. When I asked him, I did talk to him. I talked to him quite often. So when I said the last one that I got that I could recall was April, they said they did do another one i said then send it to me that way i can verify it but i never got another email so i probably didn't get one in june and i just didn't remember when i spoke to him the
[1:07:54] Speaker A (unidentified): last time so it wasn't even if it was april and june that's still two in the same quarter so that doesn't count it's only that's only one quarters testing once in july and the test was taken in june 24th and it was so if you did an april test and a june test there's that's still in the same quarter it's not in so technically it's it's a missed test he missed the first quarter yeah yes
[1:08:20] Speaker E (unidentified): and so in the plot plan to be clear what he was talking about the survey it's not a survey it's it's called the plot plan and it is going to combine few of the lots that are on our tax map because the plot plan is his entire site where things are located and what the activity is on versus the sweat plan will show you the stormwater runoff and from what areas there is buried tanks and how the water is supposed to run off the property so we did not have a plot plan that doesn't concern the plan a board at this point that is the select board right now and their temporary issue of a recycle license that needs to be done by the 29th tax maps aren't used as reliable sources of plot lines anyway well he's got several lots that he uses that have never been combined so but he uses the lots for his business so the plot plan has to include the entire site and where he added the tires and some other things we needed a new plot plan which we never had what we had was the sweat plan and that is not sufficient yep and that was probably by mistake so what does that mean he dropped one yeah got it one it was lot one a and lot two okay so when i didn't know if he meant like he sold one or he just like wasn't including it okay but and i apologize for that i didn't mean you guys get yelled at but it's it's right the bottom line is accountability well
[1:10:21] Speaker A (unidentified): it's very hard to work with somebody and give them extensions if we can't have a civil conversation without swearing and hollering at people.
[1:10:30] Speaker E (unidentified): And my answer to him was, you have a right to ask. That's up to the board, but I have already approached them and they said no. So.
[1:10:40] Speaker D (unidentified): So question for you, just as this process works. So violations issued. So the violation was issued for not having the first quarter water sample. This says corrective action within 30 days of receipt of this notice, you must complete the required water testing. testing. So he complied to the violation of not being in by having a water test within the 30 days. So that water test does technically satisfy the violation of not having one the first quarter, correct? Yes. So then the one in June, at the end of June, satisfies the second quarter.
[1:11:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Correct. And then he's correct.
[1:11:20] Speaker D (unidentified): And now we don't have one for the third quarter, but he can still get us one within 30 days.
[1:11:25] Speaker E (unidentified): So one of the perfect opportunities, and this is talking with DEP, and I talk to different people at DEP, is if we have a heavy storm event, especially after a drought, it really would be very important or a very good time to take a water sample, even though it's not within that quarterly realm. Because if you have the drought and now you're getting the saturating rain, that will show that the stormwater is working properly and it will also if it isn't functioning the contaminants will be getting beyond that and that's why at the waterfalls if we have those samples it will show there's a problem okay so again that is me pushing for the consistency and i did for another reason i was there and i think it was because still water was there and i was trying to explain what we were looking for precisely especially with rangy road and route 5 we still need a new plot plan for rangy road too because the storm water has not been installed yet so once that is done he has to do another plot plan to give us what is going on with
[1:12:40] Speaker D (unidentified): that property when we were there for the site visit i guess a year and a half ago now maybe two years ago there was talk of possibly there being an issue with one of the ponds
[1:12:51] Speaker E (unidentified): did that ever get addressed well and that's been discussed too so there's been a lot of things talked back and forth but we have nothing in writing which brian havens mentioned there's a stormwater plan which is a pamphlet that describes the property the purpose of it and gives all the information, then you have the actual layout and design, which also shows you the way it's gonna flow. Whether or not there needs to be a retention area or not needed to be determined because of the elevations. So, and then at one point, it was said that he was only elevating it this high, but in reality, it's like this high. So it changed, Mike Lalonde did get the elevations done and I know he's been over there working this week at Route 5 to do the plot plan, but.
[1:13:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Stan, the concrete processing pad, could you just explain, I know Sean gave us an explanation when he was here, but what's the current status there? Because the expectation is that has to be widened and increased in size, correct?
[1:14:04] Speaker E (unidentified): Right, so when I share the pictures that I receive of the aerial views you can see the process area and that is extending closer and closer to the pad is actually back along that tree line area the pad is significantly damaged there has been no Eric Cameron indicated and one of his emails there was a soil test on there 's never been a soil test there. But it's been an ongoing, since I've been here, that pad needed to be replaced and there was some discussion of two other pads being put in for the metals.
[1:14:46] Speaker D (unidentified): Is there something special about a process pad other than just poured concrete? Is that a stupid question? It's no. Why is it such a hard thing to get done?
[1:14:57] Speaker A (unidentified): the removal of the unders the soil underneath yeah is probably going to be the most expensive and has to have a person oversee it sean indicated with his explanation just like at the transfer
[1:15:13] Speaker E (unidentified): station you'll see at the transfer station there is some sort of retaining area around it that prevents the runoff from going into the pervious areas so the prep pad is similarly designed and it's not sloped out so that it runs off the patch on indicated that
[1:15:31] Speaker C (unidentified): he there's coming communication with still water I think in relationship to that too that they were waiting for some engine he's waiting for some engineering elements for to get that completed is that was that because it's part of your
[1:15:43] Speaker E (unidentified): stormwater runoff so it is involved with this whole process so a backup with
[1:15:48] Speaker C (unidentified): still water is somewhat viable in the context of this is why this isn't done yet i know we've been working on this pad for two years it feels like or at least a discussion about
[1:15:58] Speaker E (unidentified): it you know on the town side this is where i go into defenses this is something i've been here since 2021 okay so none of this is new this has all been required it's all been written yeah i just making sure it's been in every conditional use so the communication area is era is not with the town it is with the applicant and whoever he decides to contract with and the town has worked with him because again the economy is up and down and it you're you're sympathetic and empathy with the process of it the metal prices go down does things build up but if the communication MEDICATION ERROR IS NOT WITH THE TOWN AND THE APPLICANT. IT IS ON THE OTHER FLOOR. UNDERSTOOD.
[1:16:50] Speaker A (unidentified): SO, STAN, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I ‑‑ YOU HAD SOME CORRESPONDENTS, I BELIEVE IT WAS WITH ERIC, ABOUT TEST WELLS. AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HE SAID WAS, WELL, THERE MIGHT BE SOME LEGACY CONTAMINANTS THERE. there. Well, if that's the case, shouldn't we be knowing about that? And shouldn't we have a baseline? You put me in a tough spot. All right.
[1:17:23] Speaker E (unidentified): It's already known that the grounds there are contaminated. All right. The difference between monitoring wells and the testing of OUTFALLS IS THE OUTFALLS ARE DESIGNED TO TEST THE WATER RUNNING ACROSS THE TOP OF THE GROUND OF THE SURFACE WATER THE MONITORING WELLS TEST THE WATERS IN THE GROUND GOING BELOW TO THE GRANITE OR THE LEDGE OR THE BEDROCK SO IF IT SHOWS CONTAMINATION LIKE IT DOES AT THE LANDFILL AND AREAS OF THE BUSINESS PARK and Central Avenue it means it's already saturated and the problem is beyond
[1:18:10] Speaker A (unidentified): preventing it is now there so that doesn't make sense to me that you [Speaker B (unidentified): wouldn't be extremely] careful to make it work not to make it worse well and so if we if we think that 's the case i didn't really like that answer i'm gonna i'm not
[1:18:34] Speaker E (unidentified): gonna lie i didn't really like that at all because basically what they're saying is why open up pandora's box or a barrel of monkeys well the town does have the authority in its review to say we want monitoring wells here and here it needs to be tested by annually depending on what you find the test will increase or decrease but again if it's there you need to know what is the extent level of the contamination if it's there you can't deal with something if you don't know so it was basically the answer say we know it's there but we don't want to open up pandora's
[1:19:24] Speaker A (unidentified): box wouldn't we want to know like how far how far has it moved how far is it traveling right if it's if it's indeed contaminated wouldn't we want to know that it is it has it has moved 500 feet five miles yep or it maybe it hasn't but maybe that's right maybe not at all but then they turn
[1:19:48] Speaker E (unidentified): around and say who do we blame it isn't the point of who do we blame but you have no point of start so you've got no reference point to move forward if you know this is the level there it could have been the one previous owner prior to cia salvage but at least now you've got a point from here on out that if it gets worse, then you know where it's resulting from and we can prevent it or slow it down or remediate it, is a better word. So, it's just, and the purpose isn't to point blame, the purpose is to prevent an issue or something going unknown until we actually have what we have already.
[1:20:33] Speaker A (unidentified): My big worry is that things that we don't know today are problematic. In 5, 10, 20 years, whatever, 50 years, we're going to find out that they were extremely hazardous and we're going to have a situation like what's happening on Central Ave. and I think that we need to be thinking about that. Especially if
[1:21:04] Speaker E (unidentified): certain checks and balances aren't being followed consistently. So that's where things can get by and be unseen or unknown.
[1:21:16] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm gonna give Merrill a minute. Do we have a stopwatch? I'm giving him a minute.
[1:21:30] Speaker G (unidentified): Impossible, because you opened it up with a bigger can of worms. I know. That pad, just to remind you, in two of your prior conditional use permits, you had a commitment that was going to be done and replaced before. And Select Board has also had that statement made to them and was part of their understanding of what was to occur you were included in email chain with Eric Hamlin I hope you read them to know that processing area is supposed to be 75 feet by 110 feet you take a look at the pictures and see what you see the replacement is because the pad is all broken up maybe there's an I'm a pad there we don't know there was no testing done under that pad of any soil, so we don't know what is there. So we believe it's heavily contaminated, and I think DEP believes it too, but they're not gonna put that into handwriting. So the only one who's going to is someone who says, let's get it tested and define it. I really wasn't here to talk about Sokokas Trail, but there's there's that water sampling supposed to be quarterly for the town the state says only three times a year but doesn't matter what the state says your paperwork says quarterly also Stan is being either Stan has told me things that aren't true or he didn't want to totally be honest Sean was told before the big storm that we had, this is a great opportunity to collect the water sample. So it's not like he didn't have opportunity and heads up that this would be a great idea. It always seems like poor little him. If I knew I was gonna do four tests a year, I'd have water bottles always sitting in my office. To say that they're suddenly not available, I doubt that the water testing facilities are lacking water bottles for almost a year and luckily they finally came in and because they're not making any money if they have a year without having water bottles. Rangy Road, I'm sorry, I didn't get this notice of violation for Rangy Road. So I hate to do this, but I'd like to ask, what was the violation letter? When was it issued for the 41 Rangy Road?
[1:24:02] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. Issued October 15th.
[1:24:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, was there a notice of violation letter? It wasn't last week, so it must have happened in the last few days
[1:24:12] Speaker E (unidentified): so the notice of violation that we've been talking about is he has not completed a plan to present to the planning board within the 60 days he has not installed or completed the storm water runoff within the 90 days so now he has 30 days to come forth with a plan and then we'll have to take it from there last time I
[1:24:47] Speaker G (unidentified): was at this planning board meeting and Stan was there and you were there I presented other factual information about violations that existed and I'm unsure why we are not putting those violations into a letter in the same way with the same enforcement because it seems like we're diluting why we do this process why you waste your time or probably feel like you waste your time up there and why I on the community side and many of my neighbors and other people in town think that we're sitting in a situation where no one's doing anything and watching that house and then houses is a problem and I don't I'm just I'm disgusted truthfully that I was black and white last time and this Notice of Violation letter contains one thing. I appreciate I have a copy of it. If that's all that's in it, because that's what I asked before I did it, because I haven't had an opportunity to see it. But to me, there's-
[1:25:47] Speaker E (unidentified): And I'm gonna answer that for you, Mel, because I've told you this many times. I can share those aerial views, but I cannot use those legally, and unless I see it, I cannot violate it. I do not spend every day on Sean's properties or anybody else's property I'm not going to harass somebody or babysit somebody but again I spend a lot a lot of time trying to work with Sean and we have made a lot of progress regardless of whether I issue violations or not but I cannot issue a violation unless I see it with my own eyes or I take a picture of it with my own self so aerial views under the law are not eligible for court unless it is a residual of something else or we have some statute that allows us but i cannot use them but it does help us everybody that gets them including dep likes to see them sean likes them because it gives you an overview of what's going on but unless you see it face to face i can't issue a violation
[1:27:00] Speaker C (unidentified): stan is it fair to say though that the storm water plan and the plot plan that you're talking about and the stuff that we have in these violations right now is a priority in the context of
[1:27:10] Speaker E (unidentified): violations that exist there those are the top priorities because one is supposed to prevent been any further contamination if there is correct so that's why and again defense is more of an issue of privacy and screening but the priority for me is the stormwater runoff okay the fence is
[1:27:33] Speaker A (unidentified): not a is not a violation at this point because we gave him a certain amount until july of next year
[1:27:40] Speaker E (unidentified): but and that's one of the things Sean came here to repeat what I asked the board last week Sean and his attorney wanted to drop the appeal with two conditions that Aaron recuses from anything to do with CIA forever and to that to drop the fence out of the conditional use so the response was and AARON IS CORRECT, IN ORDER TO DO THAT, YOU WOULD HAVE TO HAVE ANOTHER PUBLIC HEARING AND DO THE PROCESS OVER AGAIN TO MAKE A REDECISION, WHICH IS A RECONSIDERATION. THE OTHER THING IS THERE IS NO LEGAL GUARANTEE TO PREVENT SOMEBODY FROM RECUSING FROM THE BOARD. THAT IS A MORAL AND A STATUTE REGULATION THAT YOU GUYS NEED TO DO EVERY TIME AN APPLICATION comes before you before you start it you do your vetting for conflict and you did do that so other than that it is a moral obligation you look at it you make the decisions and then the board as a whole makes a decision so we can't do that legally and he was told no but i also told him it doesn't hurt to come in here and ask the board directly so thank you can i read can i read about
[1:29:04] Speaker C (unidentified): your concern express concern yeah so i expressed i wasn't dismissing it i was just i said i wasn't
[1:29:10] Speaker G (unidentified): dismissing it just well it does sound like when you say so this is our priority the priority is the whole permit if you're in a butter and i know you don't live next to it or down near it or drive buy it or have your property influenced by its value so i'm going to say to you that the whole permit is relevant and it is just as important that item one and item ten and everything in between are followed so i really i actually am i'm disappointed to have had you say this is a priority they're all doing the process of priorities including don't put any more film there he filled it in he changed it after you folks did things if stan didn't want to drive by after I told them about those facts that's that's sad to me they are visible to them are visible from the road as you drive by and I'm just shocked that you haven't had a chance to go by Ray G Road the remainder are on the outside don't require permission from the owner to go on to the property to look as the CEO to say the fire lanes are not supposed to be obstructed and I cannot, he could say, I can't tell you that it's been longer, even though I have aerial images, I understand. However, he could have been over there twice in two days. It was 24 hours to clear a fire lane. The extra materials in the back, I just, I don't know why you do what you do, but it's for the sake, I thought, of the community. And I don't expect you to enforce it, but I don't know what to do when the CEO does not. And I believe Stan spends many hours a week doing CIA material. And I talk to Stan regularly, and I enjoy the time.
[1:30:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I appreciate your thoughts. I appreciate your thoughts. But what do we do? But we have all tried to work with Sean. Sean and Stan is trying to walk the tightrope here and trying to work with Sean and work with the board and we're just all trying to do the best we can. So I'm sure there's more to be done. I'm sure there'll be more violations to come, but let's take one step at a time. We have a pretty major violation right now. Whether or not the Stillwater company could do the work or not, he agreed to that time frame and he didn't do it. So how do we move forward we'll have to figure that out i guess so your comments are not unheard we hear them but one thing one step at a time there's nobody that's more frustrated about this than probably me but i
[1:32:42] Speaker E (unidentified): need to do but again i try to prioritize but before you guys move forward with the meeting i know the next meeting which is what the force yes i would like to have some time and it won't be two hours but i'd like to at least spend an hour starting to review some of the ordinances and particular things where we have some glitches one of them is the definition of what a private road is okay so the other is that's being concerned is they brought up water extraction that isn't a concern we already have it but the moratorium on data centers we can I'll draft that but I want the planning board to be part of that before the select board and then the growth ordinance and I'm drafting now the impact fees so if you guys got any and girls have any input please send
[1:33:45] Speaker C (unidentified): them to me on the agenda you'd mentioned or had written the 2003 growth ordinance MORATORY? DID WE DISCUSS THAT? I KNOW THERE WAS A COPY OF IT IN HERE, TOO.
[1:33:57] Speaker E (unidentified): I SENT YOU ONE THAT I STARTED, I ACTUALLY STARTED IN 2024 DRAFTING. AND IT TOOK A LITTLE BIT OUT OF WHAT THE GOAL WAS WHEN THE TOWN HAD IT IN 2008 AND IT EXPIRED BECAUSE NOBODY RENEWED IT. THIS ONE DOES NOT EXPIRE UNLESS IT'S REPEALED BY THE LEGISLATIVE BODY. THERE ARE CERTAIN STATUTORIAL REQUIREMENTS IN THE GROWTH ordinance which are added into the one that i labeled 2025 and it will be changed to 2026 or 2027 when it gets done that needed to be in there even in 2008 and it wasn't so this just tightens it up and explains it there were some differences in the requirements back then i believe you only have to have one affordable housing now per so many you have to have four So there's a whole calculation process which has to be part of the ordinance. But the $500 fee is for the process because there is a lot that goes in before, again, code enforcement can issue a permit at that point until everything is verified.
[1:35:10] Speaker D (unidentified): For the growth ordinance, is that going to be based on zone or are those zones already decided? I'm sorry? for growth ordinance permits is that going to be based on how many we do per zone and
[1:35:21] Speaker E (unidentified): those zones already decided right okay and then it's an overall average based on 10 years
[1:35:28] Speaker D (unidentified): and then for the last moratorium we had which was just really subdivisions right yeah for lots did we have any people that came through that would have affected them that we had to turn away or was that just kind of in place and didn't really come into effect
[1:35:48] Speaker E (unidentified): if they have an application prior to the ordinance being enacted yeah then they're grandfathered so it wouldn't apply so from the time it is enacted by the legislative body this would apply and it restricts how many people how many dwelling permits that a subdivision can get
[1:36:07] Speaker D (unidentified): at no but the last one that we just had and yeah and it did anyone come in that would have affected or was it just kind of there and people were like oh i'll just and i'm glad you
[1:36:17] Speaker E (unidentified): asked that because there was an article in the townsman from 2008 that addressed us the developers get really smart and do little things so they bought one plot of land and the partner put half of it in his name and the other half in one partner's name and they both created subdivisions and you laugh but we actually had a situation where somebody approached me recently to do that and they said would that be legal and i said no that's circumventing the law as it stands so we can't do that and there is a law that protects us if we find out and that was a 80 acre lot and the planning board also in some of this when we're reviewing and i hope i remember some of this stuff but subdivisions if it's a large subdivision the planning board can require it to be done in stages or phases so that's been done in the past too
[1:37:29] Speaker D (unidentified): so what point do we do an analysis to see when the amount of houses over the last five years needs a new look at different infrastructure for the town like adding a stoplight or requiring more infrastructure more fire department bigger schools
[1:37:48] Speaker E (unidentified): 40 to 45 a year so and last year we had even more because it was just a big boom and everything was being competitively bid so something would go on the market and then it just kept going and going and going the growth really impacts your infrastructures your utilities if it impacts areas where your water and your sewer districts are you can have an overgrowth where the demand is so high that you outgrow it too fast you have a brand new fire department if you add 142 dwellings in four years you've just increased something that was planned and three years ago to be developed for X amount of population and with a 10-year growth or a 20-year growth and you're just about halfway there already in four years.
[1:38:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Joanne's a perfect example of that, the transfer station has taken on so much more
[1:38:48] Speaker D (unidentified): that we're- Is that 80% already or something, right?
[1:38:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Your budget is very close to being- Yeah, we won't make it. So just-
[1:38:58] Speaker E (unidentified): So it's $25,000. Yeah. and those are one of the areas where impact fees will help because it's going to be
[1:39:16] Speaker D (unidentified): an adverse effect we have to we have to specify an area that the impact fees will go towards right and do we decide that or is that something you propose and we vote and agree on a select board
[1:39:27] Speaker E (unidentified): what i'm trying to do is get some legal advice more from the court side is if we can have an impact fee that goes into one account and then as we develop the areas that are and we can justify it like roads or the transfer station or the water and sewer district then we can by legislative vote justify the expense and pull it from that account versus limiting it to 50 percent roads 25 five percent this because there's a catch to doing that and that you have 12 months to use it for that and then you have to return the money with interest so working around it there is and that's pooling the money similar to what lake arrowhead does do you think it's reasonable to
[1:40:21] Speaker D (unidentified): increase the minimum lot size as a way to limit building versus limit amount of houses being built
[1:40:28] Speaker E (unidentified): in a year so and as long as their town isn't making a profit on it which again you wouldn't
[1:40:34] Speaker A (unidentified): be i mean i'm not i'm not a huge fan of that because i think it swells up more land by doing that i think i actually think it would be better to make them smaller and make the lot sizes smaller and make development developments have more open space cluster development and increasing
[1:40:54] Speaker E (unidentified): We don't have a cost of development ordinance, right? One of the statutes that's currently in, you cannot make or create non-conforming lots. So if you increase your buildable lot size, you're creating a lot of non-conforming lots. So there's a lot of lots that are 1.43 acres or 1.45, so if you increased it like a lot of other towns they're three acres or five acres you'll be creating a statutorily violation but aren't they grandfathered at some level or this they would be grandfathered but the statute says you cannot create a non-conforming law so the purpose of the town and the planning board is to try and make the lots conforming so if aaron buys two non-conforming lots and they're budding the law says they have to be combined okay so it makes it less non-conforming yeah so that's the goal but you don't want to create anymore because now you're you're creating a conflict
[1:41:58] Speaker A (unidentified): with statutory laws so i with that growth ordinance are there any exceptions to that yes
[1:42:08] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, there is. Low income housing or elderly housing for people over 55, there's an exception. There's a few others there too. Does that have to be an entire neighborhood of 55 plus housing to be considered? Yes, we do, but there's kids standing at the school bus.
[1:42:25] Speaker A (unidentified): I was just, personally, I was just thinking like at some point, probably my children are going to want to build houses and every time we do something more to increase the cost it's harder for them to build up build a house and we've kept this property and so that and there is an exception for immediate siblings
[1:42:50] Speaker E (unidentified): or immediate family the need for an in-law dwelling because again those are helping people
[1:42:57] Speaker C (unidentified): live you mean dividing properties like that there's an exception for you know immediate family when you're subdividing property? I mean, yeah.
[1:43:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. It doesn't have to count towards the amount you would subdivide within five years, correct?
[1:43:10] Speaker E (unidentified): You want to try to help it make them more affordable, but you also want to slow down the in-growth or the population coming in a little bit because the overgrowth is going to be very taxing.
[1:43:24] Speaker A (unidentified): So we haven't really been asked, actually Shelly Burbank sent us a message about our email about the data center stuff but no we weren't really asked to do anything with that are you gonna present that to us is that what you're thinking or I'm trying to draft this stuff and get it to the plan of board
[1:43:54] Speaker E (unidentified): for you guys's opinion first and girls I shouldn't say guys to the plan of board
[1:43:58] Speaker A (unidentified): members together i don't see them coming to limerick anytime soon i think it's going to be with the with the high iron water i think it's going to be very costly to use the
[1:44:11] Speaker E (unidentified): water so and we're running into some very stringent time frames to get some of this stuff done so i'm pushing a little bit more a couple people from the comprehensive plan committee have resigned and there was some information that was misleading as to the cost so i'd rather just push forward and start getting this stuff out and i'm going to use the planning board as my sounding board and minds and stuff sounds good well that's a good question because under the statute that's currently in place you cannot deny a tiny home so every single one of them have a potential to have a tiny home on their property there's lots yes well unless the subdivision has a criteria in the condition of approval that no other dwellings can be placed on it or the lot can't be divided or it has to have a restriction and that's why it's important that it's on the plan because that's the registry of deeds and that will hold that does give you
[1:45:39] Speaker A (unidentified): the authority to yeah [Speaker D (unidentified): so] there's a lot to do this week this meeting well and i don't want to get it
[1:46:01] Speaker E (unidentified): overwhelming but i would like to if you guys are available to start discussing some of this stuff we'll plan on that and if we keep waiting then it's going to become two hours to four hours long and i 'd rather just try to keep it to an hour long or something and get some direction from you and then I'll do the paperwork and Joanne's volunteered to
[1:46:25] Speaker A (unidentified): help so we'll just do our regular quick meeting and then we'll have a
[1:46:31] Speaker D (unidentified): workshop for the remainder we can start this conversation through email as a group right those thoughts to discuss at the meeting I think so I think when
[1:46:50] Speaker A (unidentified): when we're only working on, we can't have a meeting by email, but we can.
[1:47:03] Speaker D (unidentified): If I want to be like, I think we should propose a growth ordinance.
[1:47:06] Speaker E (unidentified): Discussions and thought process can be communicated via email. What you cannot do is discuss a decision or a potential decision. Discuss things openly, your ideas, all right. You can say i feel this way that's fine you're not leading and you're not making a decision or asking for a decision so just stay away from the decision process and we'll do that all in the open thank
[1:47:33] Speaker A (unidentified): you so with that our next meeting is november 4th is there a motion to adjourn i'll make a