← Back to MaineScanner

Mount Desert Select Board Discusses Recording Advisory Committee Meetings

2026-11-09 · 59m · Source: Selectboard special meeting November 9, 2026 (Town of Mount Desert (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:02] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, I'd like to call this meeting to order. Please hold your comments until I open the agenda items for public comment. When addressing the board state, your full name, both in person and on zoom. It is suggested that you enter your full name as your ID on zoom. 1st, item select report reports. [0:26] Speaker B (unidentified): She's going to do it next time. Oh, yeah. Sorry.
New Business
[0:31] Speaker A (unidentified): I think she's shaking her head new business a discussion of policy regarding recording and broadcasting public meetings I'll kick this off a little bit just sort of give the background to [0:44] Speaker C (unidentified): this for everyone this is a topic that was brought up in terms of really making the request for us to expand the recording and broadcasting of meetings and I think this is an excellent topic for maybe about as good a topic as a town can have for a public discussion because it really is you know just how far do we want to go on here the things that I really want to sort of talk us through a little bit though everyone be clear this is not a legal From a legal standpoint, we're absolutely fine on this particular front. State law dictates that we need to have, you know, records of public proceedings for decision-making bodies. And so that would be planning boards, select boards, harbor committees. For advisory committees, that becomes an optional thing. also simply doing a video recording can actually take the place of the minutes if need be the town of course always strives to do a little further than this we of course have a mix of these decision making and advisory committees reaching from select board down to probably one of the smallest of the bunch the quarterly investment committee meeting with a whole bunch of meetings in between. Some of these meetings are staffed, some of them are not. And sort of right in the middle of all this, and I think this is why this makes such a fascinating topic, is the Warrant Committee, because it is an advisory committee, but it's the largest and pretty arguably the most important committee that is a non-decision-making committee. And so it's really, where do we go from there? And I think this is a great opportunity for people to speak up, to talk through it, and to go from there. This is listed as new business. There is no action item associated with it, simply because there isn't really that clear sense of which direction we'd be going anyways. So certainly out of this discussion could be an action item for a subsequent meeting, but there's nothing specifically being requested. From there, I think that's as much backdrop as I can give and let this, let you take it over from there. All right. [3:09] Speaker B (unidentified): So maybe you could walk us through what the current status is of which meetings are being recorded and put up on YouTube and which are not too. Yeah. [3:22] Speaker C (unidentified): So planning board, harbor committee, select board always recorded, always broadcast, and that ties to the decision making authority and ties to the fact that we've always got a staff person assigned to them. After that I'll skip past one committee now and go on to the other ones and then come back, finish with warrant, other committees. It's as best as we can and I think that's a really important component to it, where we try to record them, we try to get them broadcast, but quite frankly it doesn't always work. And a great example I would give is from two or three weeks ago with the comprehensive plan, where they did get it up there, but they didn't actually have any remote participation, so nobody noticed that the owl was muted. So they recorded a meeting with no sound. Yeah. I think it's a planned meeting, but nobody noticed it. And we kind of need to accept that at the end of the day, we're a small town, that kind of thing can happen. When it comes to the investment committee, it's me and Nancy Parsons just trying to get the owl to work correctly in the first place. And so you know while we sort of are a mix of that, it can get really difficult. I think this is a really important part, it's really difficult to be trying to run a meeting and operate the technology of the meeting at the same time, because yeah, more often than not it all works fine, but quite frankly the, they just act up, the owls hate me personally for some reason and just never seem to work the way I want them to. But sometimes that can be happening. Sometimes the internet can be acting up. And so sometimes it just doesn't work. And I think that's the piece where we need to remember we are a small town. Unless we really want to go down the path of staffing all of them and having really an AV person for all these meetings. And that'll be the primary expense, is that cost of just having an extra staff person on hand to manage those. And again, it all, if it all works great, it's fine, but it just rarely, there's always something. Now in between, again, is the warrant committee. The warrant committee allows remote participation but does not record or broadcast their meetings. So that's the current state of that particular. They [5:49] Speaker D (unidentified): have a minute taker, yes, and they post those minutes. Yeah, it's not behind on [5:57] Speaker C (unidentified): that this last spring, but yes, we caught up on that, and those are now posted. Yep, and our minutes taken [6:03] Speaker B (unidentified): at all the other advisory committee meetings as best as possible, yes, and they're posted. [6:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Not always, no. Again, sometimes when it's the investment committee with three people attending and no staff members, it can be a little tough to keep it. That's my, like, smallest of the small committees that I would go towards, but for the advisory committees, it's really as best as possible, but yes, warrant always gets the minutes there. We had an issue this with the website where they'd been put on the server, but not post, and we fixed that pretty quickly. Yeah. [6:36] Speaker E (unidentified): We've also had a few select board meetings that some pretty awful people have logged in. Yes. And that's embarrassing and concerning. If we don't have, I mean, you do as good a job as you can, Kyle, but even then, people put the right last name or the, you know, and then you let these people in and it, sorry. [7:06] Speaker C (unidentified): Now, to be clear, we actually researched that one a little bit. I don't remember exactly what the statute is, but because of the pretty obvious harm of us leaving that moment in on the recording, we do edit out those moments. So the Zoom bombing is not a sterility. [7:23] Speaker E (unidentified): Oh, but still from the public in these meetings. [7:26] Speaker C (unidentified): And I forget what it is, but there's something to the effect of, like, it would cause harm to leave it in, and Zoom bombing is a pretty obvious example of that. Yes. So, yeah. But you have to... Yes. But that being said, it still needs to be edited out. Of course, in the moment, it's, well, none of us will ever forget the first time we had one, right? So yeah, the Zoom bombing is a concern, but I think Kyle has done a really good job in enforcing everyone having their name on there. I think we had one where you were trying to zoom in and come in as a guest and you were like, why isn't Kyle letting me in? [8:01] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it said something like iPhone. Yeah, I'd really love to hear. I know. [8:09] Speaker E (unidentified): There's a couple few members of the warrant committee. I mean, you guys kind of are at the [8:13] Speaker F (unidentified): I'd love to hear your thoughts. Hold our thoughts until we're done discussing. [8:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, I also have a statement from here. [8:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I mean, my personal opinion is that anything we can do to inform the public about what the issues are is a positive for me, especially after some things that happened around this last election that suggests that people will come in and they'll vote on things they have no idea what they're voting on. I'm not saying that these kinds of things, I mean, you know, you can bring a horse to water, you can't make it drink, but we got to do our best to do that. [8:59] Speaker C (unidentified): Kathy, I just wanted to throw in one little thing to answer. Can you stand and say your names? I'm just trying to make sure it gets recorded. You want me to go up there? No, we're good. Identify yourself. [9:09] Speaker G (unidentified): Kathy Miller, live in Stonefield. And I'm on several town committees. And at one of those committees, we were talking about a particular topic that related to town things. And I got a call later. I know the town got a call and then they sent them over to me. It was a private business that is scraping information off the internet about different things. And they thought, oh, you're interested in that? We have some service that we'd like to provide to you for a cost that relates to what it is you're talking about. So I just want to throw that out there that, goes on for better or worse. I didn't say it's bad company or anything, but there are technology businesses out there, AI is just scraping everything. And so whatever goes on in here is out in the pub, so. [9:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I mean, I get, constantly get emails from vendors that suggest I have some sort of control over things. For just those things and it just, it's just, it goes with the territory. Yeah, I [10:16] Speaker D (unidentified): would like, John, I would typically always lean toward transparency, communication, accessibility. I'm mindful that although they're not voting residents of the town, we have a big summer community that pays a lot of taxes and is not here. So having them able to understand what's going on week to week, just in the name of open lines of communication, I support that. But I do want to hear from people who serve on these committees to understand if making a change would affect the quality of the discussion, the quality of the decisions. Your participation, I mean, I'm, I'm all ears on that. I think the town does a, does a good job. Could we do more? Sounds like we could, and in general I would be supportive of that, because I think a lot of our towns suffer from not enough knowledge, participation, access. I mean, a lot of it's up there, and I don't know how many people are looking at it, but if we can be more transparent and accessible in general, I support that, but I'd like to hear [Speaker F (unidentified): more and] and cost, of course, staff time, whatever it takes to do this, it's an issue. Is it, is it more expensive to record more meetings? Is it less expensive? Do we need less minute takers? I mean, understanding the pros and cons, from what does it mean for the staff, I'm, I'm very attuned to that. I don't want to impose something that's not reasonable on a staff that's already, you know, got a lot of hats on and doing a lot of different jobs. [12:05] Speaker E (unidentified): And I would, I feel like as best we can does cover a lot, like you said. I mean, we do the best we can with the technology we have, but like, I mean, sometimes you, it just doesn't work. We do the best we can, and I feel like that's, you know, if you're really interested in what's going on in the meeting, they're all public, right? Even the Warren committee meetings are open to the public, and I don't know that we would get a lot more people. I mean, look, like this is a, should be a really good con, you know, conversation, and we've got Heidi who does our minutes and Julia who's [12:48] Speaker C (unidentified): works for the Islander. I would respond to that. One thing that we have been seeing is it's the rebroadcast, it gets a lot more. Okay, that's interesting information, definitely. It's on a regular, it's on a pretty constant upswing. Okay, like slowly but surely more and more people watch the rebroadcast. That's, that's a key thing there. Okay, yeah, my personal experience on the [13:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Luzo advisory committee, I was out of town, I wasn't able to Zoom, I watched it a few days later, it was very helpful. I got up to speed on, yeah, a 90-minute meeting that I missed [13:22] Speaker F (unidentified): as a committee member, so from a selfish point of view, yeah, no, I do it for [13:28] Speaker E (unidentified): several as well, so I think, thank you for that. I have a statement from Gail [13:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Marshall I asked her she's so I can just speak on her behalf if we'd like sure to the select board. I am sorry I can't join you concurrent school board meeting. Please accept these observations in lieu of my attendance. I am fully in favor of transparency in all public serving activities. That is not debatable. I believe in following open meeting legal requirements. I believe we currently do. The larger question is how best citizens can and should interact with the business of their government. In this case, the government is our little town it is not the federal government for which we need to rely on c-span. I don't doubt the convenience for the observer of sitting at home and watching your town work for you on your computer screen but it is a convenience equivalent to a tv dinner versus a home coach meal. Well you simply cannot fully and fairly understand what is going on through your computer screen. In some situations, virtual appearances such as applications before the planning board on which I also serve can be a reasonable, although arguably less efficacious, accommodation. And but it usually adds a layer of complication due to the work of the board, often including technical glitches, delays, unregulated mute buttons, et cetera. As a side note, my mother was the king of the unregulated in other cases members of boards and committees can sometimes only make a meeting by zoom that we should accommodate and appreciate their willingness to serve but very often in my experience those members are less able to contribute to ongoing discussions because of the virtual interface. On the few occasions I've tuned in it's more of an observer than a participant given the serious abuses because of the two-way participation in so many towns in cities in Maine including ours very little online two-way communication can be allowed if we afford it at all. We have to afford it to all not book and choose because of the message so here it's been the intrusion of pornography. Bangor just silenced virtual commentary once again for all the online participants ranting with ugly racist and violent screeds. In our very small town, we rely on people who volunteer to become informed about how we get things done for one another and at times take on personal responsibility to help our town succeed. There is no virtual substitute to being president. As citizens, we owe one another more than just dialing in. We should welcome and encourage participants and observers to our work. Northeast Harbor is not far away from any of us in this town. The meeting rooms are always warm and welcoming. We should encourage those who wish to observe the work being done on our behalf to join us in person. We should not feel pressured to increase the use of a flawed participatory interface. We are currently complying with the best practices as required by Maine's robust open meeting laws, we should continue to do so. Thank you for considering my perspective, Gail Marshall, Chair Luzzo, committee members, school board, planning board, comprehensive plan committee, and assessment review committee. I [17:02] Speaker B (unidentified): would like to echo what David said. I would like to hear from all of you, but my inclination is that as much as possible, our meetings should be recorded. and available on youtube the warrant committee i think is especially important and i think it should be recorded and available to people because i think people need to be informed and need to be able to be informed as much as we can i don't like zoom i was sorry during covet when it became all the rage and now we've got it all the time but it's a fact of life now and people are used to it and we've got to make it available I think it's trickier on some of those very small committees I think we do the best we can and hope for the best, but the warrant committee is such a key part of the decision-making in this town. It's a big deal, and I think it's important that everyone, including summer residents, should be able to follow along. The [18:17] Speaker H (unidentified): comments from anyone ready yeah sure i'm jerry miller i have no problem at all with recording the warrant committee's deliberations never have we have we have had secretaries i'd like to get minutes and not just have them come up from having been transcribed off a microphone later earlier but i think it's all to the good the best news i heard was the people who checked in afterwards there's a lot of us trying to hear that myself included don't really want to go out at six o'clock every night i Got things to do, and if people are seeing it that way, they're at least seen, and it may make them more informed. They may not be the most entertaining YouTube. [19:04] Speaker F (unidentified): It's just positive. It's my opinion here. You're always entertaining. Well, that may be true, but I'm [19:11] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm not a YouTuber, I'm... [19:15] Speaker I (unidentified): Bill Lichtenstein. You have to stand up. I have to stand. Bill Lichtenstein, I'm the chair of the Water Committee, chair of the Sustainability Committee, and also the chair of the Investment Committee. I want to remind everyone, pre-Zoom, we always attended in person. I was the secretary 15 plus years ago when I started out when Bill Firm was the chair. And Bill said you didn't have to write down everything perfectly. You just wanted to get the idea in the room of what if you were asked, you know, what was the discussions. We are an advisory committee. We also are the scrutinizers of all of the five of you and your decisions. And that's where I sort of have my own personal concerns. And I think it's, you know, I've let my feelings be known that I don't want to inhibit any member of the Warren Committee to not speak up and speak their mind. And most of all, to go against some things that have gone on, things that are making the town that maybe not everyone would agree with. And all we've ever asked, well, it's time to vote as the Warren Committee. If you were against something, it was your job to stand up a town meeting and say why you were, you know, if it was 14 to 1 or if it was a close contentious vote on something that we didn't agree with, what you need to do to stand up and own your thoughts. We often have a roundtable discussion at the end of our meetings. I think that's really, I really hear very good comments. I think people are very participatory in it to analyze it the next day, but it still makes me a little uncomfortable. I think I don't want to hold people back from being able to speak your mind. I don't abide by whatever you all decide in the end as a group. But that's my own personal feeling. I think I've had very good note takers. I like to call meeting summaries when we're like an advisory committee, because you can't really write down every little minute. We don't have a Heidi sitting there writing down how everything was discussed and what was your vote, who's seconded it. But Laura Hufler did an amazing job, her minutes were impeccable. Yeah, but then she had to return to Norway to escape it. I know, that's my personal feeling, that I just, you know, we've asked every year as a group. Once soon became in place, is this something we want to do? It was an informal vote, and most people said that you wanted to be recorded, because we're available in person, we're available on Zoom, and that's basically where, you know, digital content, you know, it's, it's, it's a complicated thing, and I don't, I think I want people to speak there. Well, I don't want to lose that in the warrant committee, that people aren't speaking their body. We're not up here like you all making decisions that are the final decision, we're discussing the decisions before they're being made, right [22:20] Speaker J (unidentified): You're there, heard Robot Creek member of the warrant committee. Personally, I could go either way on this. I suppose being a member of work for several years, it has come up, and the majority of the group says we don't want to be recorded. I'm not sure why that is. I also have a concern about all the townspeople, the town employees that come to our meetings, they have to be there amenable to be recorded too. I don't know if that influences them, I don't know if being recorded would influence more Committee members, I can't speak for the rest of them. For me, I don't think it would matter, but my concern is I don't really see what the value added is. I mean, we're all for openness, it's an open meeting, the public can come in, we're not making any decisions, it's a discussion session, you can tune into Zoom, you can TiVo it, or record it at home if you want, or whatever your technology of choice is, and we publish minutes. So I'm not sure what the value added is. It may cost more in time and effort, but if that's what you want to do, okay with that. But that's I guess my only question, is there really value added for a non-decision committee [23:40] Speaker I (unidentified): Committee to be recorded next. Well I just wanted, Jerry and I just had a quick discussion, we'll make sure regardless whatever is decided we will vote on it, we'll bring it to the whole water committee on our first organizational meeting, report back from our meeting summary, do we want to have our meets recorded or not, and we'll see what the group says, that would [24:10] Speaker K (unidentified): Opinion, because I'm not a co-chairman. Thank you. May I first react to Gail's letter? So on September 29th we were here in this room and Gail made a very passionate speech about the school consolidation. I thought it was brilliant, one of the best things I've ever heard. Was during a Warren Committee meeting, during that meeting she castigated the RPC for essentially doing everything in private, okay? Some of you were there and remember her saying that. It was not a process that was opened up. And I totally agree with her. The school is actually driving me more crazy than any other public body. So Gail and her committee, last Tuesday, in their wisdom, decided to have their monthly school committee meeting on election day at 4 p.m., okay, while everybody else is running to try to get their ballots in. Now, so on the one hand, she's saying, I think this technology is flawed. I think that's the word she used. But I'm gonna schedule a meeting on one of the days where we can ensure there's gonna be absolutely nobody who comes to our meeting. And at that meeting last Tuesday, the school committee began the process of tackling the budget, the school budget for next year. And it was only because Julia Rush, who's online tonight from the Islander, only because she was at the meeting were we able to read some report of that meeting. I cannot go back and look at any recording or any representation of what they said, okay? And that's a fact. I did the same thing that you have. I've done spot research search, and virtually every meeting that Mount Desert has, virtually every meeting you have, you have a bigger audience online after the meeting, all right? Now, some of those meeting, some of those attending were attending live, which is the only way they can attend the Warren Committee. But if you go back and do your own spot check on your own meetings, you will find that there were a lot more people viewing it than attending, okay? That's a fact. In fact, when Alex was the day he was appointed a manager about a year ago, I went back, I think was a September meeting, I don't remember, but there were hardly in the in the video showing the meeting was hardly anybody in the room, like most of your meetings, but there were 41 viewer views, okay? 41 views for a meeting. Now maybe some of them were live. I would bet that most of those views came afterward. So there is what lawyers call pregnant facing evidence that you have a larger audience attending on Zoom than you do live, okay? I get calls all the time. And the other thing that you have to remember is Julia tonight is going to write a story for the Islander, which is going to be read by more people that are attending tonight's meeting. I do the same thing, and Carrie does the same thing. Now, I can bet you right now that Carrie, who's not online right now, I mean, I've never met anybody like Carrie, okay? I can bet you that tomorrow she's going to watch this meeting and she's going to decide whether to write about it. Now, Julia and I and Carrie, we have thousands, of viewers. That's why we have the press. That's why the press has preferred seats where they used to, okay, on Air Force One and in the White House. That's why the AP always had the first seat because we represent what people want to follow government activities through our representation, through our reporting. And I get calls from people all the time, Lincoln, you got to go back and look at the meeting of the harbor committee in southwest harbor was such a such state okay you got to go back and look at that recording and because they're trying to tip me off on something that happened that was so important to the town. I have to give southwest harbor a lot of credit. Every town on this island that I cover has a different pathology. Southwest harbor seven years ago had a very a very different pathology than it does today. Southwest Harbor went and elected, completely turned around the representation of their select board. They just kicked out a member of the planning board who had so many conflicts. He's the largest landowner in town. He owns the landfill and he's on the planning board. Southwest Harbor just turned that around. Southwest Harbor has a sustainability committee that just is now ahead of every other town except for Ball Harbor on vacation rentals. They elected two women under 40 to be on the select board. Southwest Harbor in February passed a policy that said we want every board and every committee Sustainability Harbor Committee to be recorded, to have remote participation, and to make it available to everyone. That's half of my work. People calling me and saying, you've got to go see this recording. And, you know, Phil, you and I heard you say that before, for how you wanna create a comfortable environment so that members of your committee can speak freely. What does that mean? They can't speak freely and have their representation and opinions be seen by more voters than the three who come to your meeting at the time? The meeting on September 29th, which I attended, was an incredible Warren Committee meeting. And I have to give the Warren Committee a lot of credit. The minutes from the Warren Committee is unbelievable. I don't know who does it, but somebody who does the minutes for the Warren Committee, I've never seen minutes that good. Here's the problem. It's six months old. The last minute I checked today from the Warren Committee was in March. Now, I know the Warren Committee doesn't meet regularly, okay, but still, there's still about four meetings that they haven't put up, and so where does that leave me? That when I want to see what happened, right, and with all due respect to Gail, this technology I think is actually opened up representation. It's opened up information. And it's all about information. That's how democracy flows. And the more information out there, we're going to see better results. Now, I'm going to meet with Jessica Stewart, and I'm going to pound the schools. Schools, they are, they are the least transparent body on the island. 40 of our tax dollars go to the schools, and when they start a conversation about it, they do it in the dark, and they do it on election day at 4 p.m. And Gail had, Gail had a hand in scheduling that meeting, and there's no way anyone can go back except for the minutes, which they will file months later, on exactly what happened. Thank you, Julia. I mean, she, I think she's, she did us a great service on Tuesday by coming to that meeting, so I And the Warren Committee may be an advisory committee, but man, every year it's got their recommendation right there on the ballot. And there are important meet, there are important boards, obviously planning board. The viewership on planning board is out of sight, okay, that's the number one. The, select board, the harbor committee. I'm just saying, you know, just not just for transparency, but for better government, that the Warren Committee ought to feel like they can talk about anything in front of us and not in front of five people. Enough said. I [34:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Agree, I mean, the Warrant Committee is supposed to represent a cross-section of the town, and I'm puzzled that anyone would feel uncomfortable comfortable sharing their opinions with the people they're representing, so I think we should do it. I think we should see how it goes go. [34:39] Speaker C (unidentified): ahead just one minor thing that I think just to mention I do think that if we're going to do that we should assign somebody to staff and do the recording I think asking Warren committee members who are not town employees and or Phil who's trying [34:57] Speaker H (unidentified): trying to run. We're talented for that matter. What's that? [35:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Actually, Phil's better than I am. [35:03] Speaker I (unidentified): It was really hard during Zoom to run the meeting, run the Zoom, watching Kyle every time in here. I just want to be really clear to everyone. I am open. I want to do what the group wants to do. Just to be clear, I don't want to speak for the 22 members of the board committee and say, oh, Phil says we should record our meetings. I still want to make sure that I've got to bring that to a vote to the Warren Committee. I think that's fair to the committee. I am open to it. I don't want everyone to think I'm negative, I'm open to anything. I do have a problem a little bit on parts of it, but I think I get through it. [35:46] Speaker K (unidentified): One really important thing, the decision that was made in Southwest Harbor in February, board, their new policy, was made by the select board. And nobody, and I'm glad you corrected my email, that this is an appointed board. The Warren Committee is an appointed board. And so I'd rather have an elected board, which is you, 're the ultimate authority, to make policy and not have 22 members who feel uncomfortable say, I don't want to be recorded. [36:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Martha. Yeah, I don't think, Phil, I don't think it's up to the members of the Warrant Committee. I'd like, we invited them here to hear their point of view, your point of view, but I don't think it's up to them to decide policy. [36:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Along those lines, our current remote participation policy is geared far more towards really COVID era. And so it's really about simply allowing Zoom to simply exist, because I think we all have to remember, like, prior to 2020, remote participation and meetings was what, you know? And then suddenly we had to move a decade into the future. [37:09] Speaker B (unidentified): And it's evolved over time. [37:11] Speaker C (unidentified): And so for that to occur, we would have to create a more up-to-date remote participation policy addressing these areas. And that's part of why tonight was sort of silent, to go down that path of a remote participation policy geared towards 2026 rather than 2020, 2021, which is what that policy was very clearly, like many other municipalities, sort of scrambling to say, okay, how are we suddenly going to go remote here? And you can kind of see it in that policy, which was really what the goal of it was. [37:46] Speaker A (unidentified): I think for me the bottom line is that people need to be better informed. Too many people are showing up at the polls and voting on things that they don't understand and that has to stop. This is a way to do it. It may not work. I mean Gail's ideal, I applaud the ideals that she set forth in her letter, but they're ideals. You know, people aren't going to suddenly show up to meetings that they don't have time for they just won't there'll be no shows we can do anything we can to invite their participation whether it's through digital means or otherwise and great and [38:29] Speaker B (unidentified): to me that's very interesting that you've brought up that most people are watching the meetings afterwards i didn't realize that i thought they didn't come But if they're watching later, that makes it more convenient for them. [38:42] Speaker H (unidentified): That's good. Anybody binge watching? [38:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I didn't want to say this to Lincoln, but the 40 of those 41 was just me watching myself over and over again. [38:54] Speaker E (unidentified): with that family members yeah phil's i started on the warrant committee many years ago and it's a small town and sometimes it's hard to put your views out there because you don't want to be scrutinized you don't want to be you know criticized or whatever and just quoted it in the paper did in the paper perfect but just like the school and i 100 i work for the school but i wanted my view of the school reorganization to be as private as everybody else's some people you know you view you said what you believed and you that's not my personality so if alex or the someone had said that this select board must vote on the school reorganization committee in public i wouldn't have done it and so i appreciate what you're saying and you are right and i getting information out there and i think it's very interesting that i that people watch them i thought i was the only one that did that sometimes but i also understand volunteering on a committee and being able to say something or ask a question Or make a comment to get more information and not have it be public opinion that's [40:27] Speaker K (unidentified): not the country we live [40:28] Speaker F (unidentified): in that's my little world Lincoln but you are right and I'm still reveling [40:36] Speaker K (unidentified): over the results of last Tuesday this is the country I'm sorry but you know Donald Trump can have all his private meetings and kick out the press and do whatever he's doing and he got a big rebuke last week well I think it's important to clarify [40:57] Speaker D (unidentified): we're not holding private meetings they're made available for the public to come I'm in person or on zoom and the minutes are shared so I don't like that comparison and I appreciate all the warrant committee members who have spoken and said I'm open to this but really appreciate that and I guess to you know Craig what's the value add I think the hope is that the value add is more information shared to more people just by giving another option for somebody to watch the next day when they weren't able to be there i 've had that experience myself and i think others would too so that's the value add it's not that the current system is broken as lincoln thinks it is i don't think it is i think we're looking to add a margin of extra value well let me know the cost isn't too high agree and I put that in my opening statements that I want to understand what the cost is [41:59] Speaker K (unidentified): yeah let me give you the flip side of that okay I saw the one committee had once a year they have the so-called our representative from Hancock County come and talk and I remember when they had Paul Parity here and I watched that and every member of the warren committee asked these softball questions of Paul Parity and some of them were just uninformed and wrong and here we are we're the biggest funder of Hancock County We have a warrant committee that's asking that has asking questions that were either uninformed or softball questions. And we, you know, we don't we don't even we never demand anything from Hancock County. OK, here's an easy one. Hancock County does are not 911 calls. Okay. They do all our 911 calls. Mount Desert, Bar Harbor, the Park Service, Southwest Harbor, we all have our individual dispatchers. We all fund millions of dollars. I mean, even in Bar Harbor and Mount Desert, which we've consolidated police department, have different expenses for dispatch, and then the Sheriff's Department has it separate. You talk about technology. Jim Willis said years ago he paved the way for this island and Hancock County to consolidate dispatch and save millions of dollars. That's you know, is anyone on our warrant committee aware of the economics of Hancock County? [43:55] Speaker F (unidentified): are they asking tough questions are they really representing you should ask so I just I will tell [44:05] Speaker E (unidentified): you I probably spent 50 plus hours on the Hancock County budget advice I saw that yes and my eyes are this big Lincoln what just exactly what you're saying but even as a select board person I didn't know this until I started getting the fine print and the report and I mean the jail that's a topic for next week's meeting I can't [44:41] Speaker C (unidentified): even tell you why I'm a select board reporter on the budget advisor at Knox [44:45] Speaker K (unidentified): Yes, I mean, you're really putting some teeth into it for change. I'm really, I'm really happy about that. But you know what I hear more in this town than any other? I hear it from this town. Don't worry, Martha will pay for it. And I don't mean this, Martha. Okay. You've never heard that phrase in this town? Don't worry, Martha will pay for it. [45:05] Speaker E (unidentified): I've never heard of that phrase. [45:08] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm just clarifying that, you know, when I invited Paul Parenti to the party committee, we've never had anyone come from Hancock County to any more committee ever before. That started the ball rolling and we were all as uninformed as Paul was. Paul said, I had no idea, you know, I'm not defending Paul. And then we got Sam DeMello, who knew even less. and then we had invited sam back on alex's first you know go with it all last year you know working for carmelin county couldn't believe some of the things that he saw here so that was that was a really good eye-opening thing for all of it and we do you know lincoln that is something you're correct and it is something that our town because it's based on valuation pays a lot of the hancock county and i really commend wendy and i really commend alex to really start looking at the numbers before because you know people used to say all we got was a jail in the airport the airport's a separate budget but yes a lot of our summer clients do like the airport [46:14] Speaker K (unidentified): anyhow long story short see there you go phil not a single dime i don't think phil was finished actually he brought up the airport yeah he's so wrong on that well no there is no money i [46:28] Speaker I (unidentified): Was explaining to us that yes, I don't work for the county blanket. That would be really clear that it's a federal budget, if I'm not mistaken, that pays for the airport and the vendors, and the vendors pay for them. All right, Jerry's got another question. My question is how we [46:44] Speaker H (unidentified): wandered from discussing the filming or not to this. That's a good question. I was making a point [46:51] Speaker K (unidentified): at one committee by opening it up, will become better representatives. They're going to learn. Nobody was disagreeing. They're going to learn as well by opening it up, opening up themselves to scrutiny and questions. They're going to learn, they're going to get better, right? I just want [47:12] Speaker J (unidentified): to clarify in case there's anyone out there who doesn't realize the word committee has absolutely zero oversight or influence or any interaction with the county. That meeting with our county commissioner was strictly informational for us as a total sideline to what the work [47:31] Speaker I (unidentified): committee does. Okay, thank you Craig. Good. Was I am, yeah, there's a lot involved, a lot [47:45] Speaker C (unidentified): anything else? Yeah, so let's come back to it. Direction from the select board as we move forward, what are your thoughts? Well [47:57] Speaker B (unidentified): I think, where would you like to, I think an updated policy would be great, and my vote would be to have, I think with the small committees it's going to be very tough to try and bring someone in for each of those tiny committees, but I think for the warrant committee we should record and put it up on YouTube. I did just get reminded of something [48:26] Speaker C (unidentified): in our town charter it does say that the warrant committee gets to decide their own rules and procedures, so that's a town charter. Interesting, thank you. Like I did, I did know that from, oh I didn't, sorry, I apologize, I didn't know that. So it would be an advisory function or it would be something that would have to get changed at the annual town. I see. I really think we can find a way in between those two though, with everyone, sorry. And you know it's, it's, I don't want [48:57] Speaker I (unidentified): to lose the small town being able to scrutinize the five of you or all the budgets that are put forward from all the department heads. At the same time I am willing to be open, but I want the group to say we want to do that. I am speaking tonight as a citizen, yes, I am the chairman of those three committees, but I also feel it's really, I want to empower my group or the group to make the choice and not be told what to do. Great [Speaker K (unidentified): thank] you. Well [49:35] Speaker D (unidentified): To continue the "where do we, you know, go with this," I would like to, I'm, I'm, where I would like to better understand the demands, the implications for staff, but I would like the board, perhaps at the next meeting, to take a vote and make a request that the Warren Committee take this under advisement, if they're the ones who set the rules, that we'd like to see this happen. [50:03] Speaker C (unidentified): And this was before my time, but I'm told the Warren Committee did used to have a staff member assigned to it. [50:08] Speaker I (unidentified): So when I first started out, we had, who wasn't Heidi, we had Jennifer was our point person. Person, so she would grind up all the minutes, she would help me, I didn't have to write the agenda, everything was done by the town and by staff. By the way, we're all volunteers, there's no excitement, we get 600 to do or set, we're up to 750 for an annual dinner, that's the only expense, or a 90-day commitment. By the way, I guess because we are still being recorded, I want to remind, I remind everyone that a friend of Mr. Milstein decided to storm out of the room because he didn't like what he heard. I didn't like that. But I have to, it's my chance, because I get picked on in his press for my views that I knew the rules about, because I've been doing this for a long time, and the story on that. Also, I want to remind everyone, when we're at the town meeting, Article 3 of the warrant. What does Article 3 of the warrant say? [51:11] Speaker F (unidentified): Allow people, allow non-voters, non-voters to speak. [51:16] Speaker I (unidentified): And so I'll make sure that the Warrant Committee will be voting on that with each meeting to make sure that people that are non-voters, you know, we have to say that as a group because we can have 25 people in the room and get ganged up on some night. Who knows? I want it open to everyone. There's some nice things that were being discussed tonight. There was no reason to storm out when we had the five of you in the hour. [51:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyway, I agree. I think Martha's correct. I think we need to have more of a conversation with the Warrant Committee. You need to go back, maybe. [51:59] Speaker C (unidentified): I said I didn't storm out, I don't increase the views, so it may be at some [52:10] Speaker I (unidentified): point. When is your next meeting, next meeting? I think is the 6th or the 7th of January, I have to pull out my calendar, I turned off my phone, give me a second. [52:19] Speaker A (unidentified): And probably need to have something before that. [52:24] Speaker I (unidentified): I'll give you the exact date. [52:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Probably looking at around maybe 12 hours or so worth of staff time. It would just be my very back of the napkin. And that would really, I think in some ways, you could swap out the person doing the minutes for the recording because the recording would actually satisfy the function of the minutes anyways. But certainly, I don't think it would be advisable for it to be me because I'm presenting the budget and I'm pretty yeah so we would need to find somebody willing to do that which again we've had in the past for them anyways so it's I think that's what [53:01] Speaker I (unidentified): we'd be looking at there cool so we are meeting on the 5th of January will be our organizational meeting and then Alex will give the budget we'll do the Alex is over general we could have a meeting on the 12th and then we break for the Dr King and then we get going with all [53:19] Speaker H (unidentified): the others I don't you know Jerry I don't see that there'd be any problem with it the select board sending the warrant committee an opinion of what they would like to have us do that we can discuss that yeah you can arrange any setup for town participation or support board and have that be part of the suggestion when we discuss it okay [53:48] Speaker A (unidentified): so well you know as we've been saying we would like have meetings recorded and [Speaker H (unidentified): posted think] about that and get the temperature of the committee John can I [54:05] Speaker D (unidentified): ask you some our deliberations here bleed over into the school board in school committees do we have we have no say on that no okay unfortunately Jerry [54:25] Speaker H (unidentified): select board consent the Warren committee and Christie's of what you just said sure do that I'll do that [Speaker C (unidentified): way] it'll just give us a talking [55:02] Speaker D (unidentified): I think it's a fascinating conversation and hearing the range of views is very helpful. Hearing Gail's views, although she's not here, she is so involved in our town and if we make an overture or an action around in increasing options for remote participation or listening after the fact I also think we should redouble our efforts to get people here in person whatever that takes you know the meetings that we've had up at the neighborhood house about certain topics now that makes them not very easily zoomable but I do agree with her points about in-person participation is better I don't think it's either or but I'd hate to see any action we're taking make people less inclined to come right so I want I want to do both I guess is what I'm saying because I think the in-person is the [56:06] Speaker C (unidentified): best you know possible option yeah along those lines i think something for the select board to consider and it's an expense but it's it's probably a very worthy one offering child care and in our services for people who can attend and have that tends to drastically improve the ability of people to attend and this is something I think the school reorganization committee hit on this organization they hit on it and they quickly found that worked really well and a few other groups have really found that 's a great way to pretty drastically increase participation after hours what's that it does seem to do the trick there when we started and i'm going to make a push for us to get that back next year because i can see that would be great yes the school refused it [57:01] Speaker H (unidentified): after and decided they didn't want it, I [57:05] Speaker E (unidentified): can do community service for, yeah, meetings like that. [57:09] Speaker C (unidentified): 100, yeah, it definitely made a pretty big difference. I think it was one of our, I think another one of our informational meetings last winter, you could really see the difference. Yeah, I think it does also food, oh yeah, pizza and coffee. [57:27] Speaker A (unidentified): People have forgotten how to just meet face on and have a conversation. All right, so good, I will put something together so you can present it to the committee. [57:41] Speaker I (unidentified): I just hope the four of you understand that we're not close-minded, but I can't speak for my group here tonight, and I have to, I do have my own personal opinion, and I do really, I lead more towards the Gale side of things where it's really, you know, I think we've done a lot to make sure our meetings are open to the public and there's the Zoom. I think that the recording was always the next step. I'm not, I'm still open to it even though it's, it's still ruffles went from feathers a little bit. [58:15] Speaker H (unidentified): Once we got your thing, there's nothing to say that we can't send it to the committee, just an email, exactly, yeah, so absolutely an advance warning and then get some feedback. Yeah, we don't [58:28] Speaker I (unidentified): have to, we don't have to wait for the fifth, so if you decide to do something and you know that'd be great, first of the year we'll make sure it gets to everybody, and we're involved with all the budgets and all your recommendations too that come to us and little people read this and we're all, you know, as always, you know, please, you all feel like you're invited, you know, that we do have contentious issues in town and I think it's the great way to discuss them, and Phil, I want to [58:52] Speaker B (unidentified): apologize again, I did not, I did not know that was in the charter, that's okay. [58:57] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, so I should have that online. Yeah, there's a lot in the charter that we probably don't know about. I've read the charter, but it goes out of my head. [59:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, okay, so we're ready for the next item. Anybody else anything? Okay. Okay, informational Bar Harbor committee meeting minutes, September 8, 2026, or harder. I'm sorry. Committee meeting minutes, September 8, 2026. And thank you letters from Island Connections, Mount Desert Nursery School. [59:34] Speaker H (unidentified): Public comment, anybody? [59:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Anybody online? We had a lot of public comment already. Yes. [59:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, okay. Adjournment, I'll take the motion to adjourn. [59:46] Speaker E (unidentified): Wendy, I'll move approval at seven o'clock. [59:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. All in favor? Thank you, everyone.