← Back to MaineScanner

Scarborough Long Range Planning Committee Reviews Future Land Use Map and Growth Areas

2026-11-13 · 1h 25m · Source: Long Range Planning, Nov. 13, 2026, Scarborough, ME (Town of Scarborough (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, indeed, welcome you to the Long Range Plan Committee meeting on February of February. And roll call. Portia Hirschman, here. Jean Marie, I'm here. Ed Hodgson, here. Robin Saunders, here. [0:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Here. So that will be our forum if we need to vote on anything. And then we had Rick Mikey, here. Corey Fellow, here. And Michelle, here. We're missing here. And Rebecca. All right, review of meeting minutes. [0:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Any changes, corrections? I have a question. Sure. About when I was looking at them, one of the things we've talked about pretty extensively a lot of time was looking at working with the MTA and Socco about sort of aligning goals and looking at, you know, maybe another exit that would kind of help with that type of thing. And my question just was, what's the next step in that? [1:14] Speaker B (unidentified): Like, how do we, I thought it was a great idea, it's a conversation. I will mention to Tom. Okay, it needs to come really from Tom. Okay. Well, we had a meeting with NTA, I had to miss it though actually, to talk about some issues last week before last, but there's some ongoing conversations, so it'd be something maybe to bring up at council goals, like additional conversations. [1:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, right, thank you. Well, and perhaps even Transportation Committee, because we're having meetings with DOT and so on to discuss what's happening, right, with traffic and that. [1:52] Speaker D (unidentified): would certainly be a possibility as well it does it does help that it comes from an elected official though too I mean not just Tom if it is coming from an elected official it does help raise the bar so I think talking with Tom is the first step but knowing that it's coming from an alerted official helps okay great we can do that any [2:19] Speaker A (unidentified): other comments? Someone [2:25] Speaker E (unidentified): moved to, oh, sorry, yes, I'll move to accept the minutes as presented. I'll second it. Excellent, thank you. Do we have any [2:34] Speaker A (unidentified): the public on board? I don't see. I'm saying it's true. I'm on it now. She on [2:48] Speaker B (unidentified): but I joined it from the town calendar. Yeah, I had to join twice. Have her go back to [3:07] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't think it's still 100%. [3:09] Speaker E (unidentified): Mine came back this morning. I was happy and sad. I was happy and sad at the same time because I have colleagues that are like, nope, mine's still up. [3:18] Speaker F (unidentified): I just got to tell you [3:22] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah, everything came back. [3:23] Speaker B (unidentified): Make sure [3:25] Speaker F (unidentified): give us one second being funny. [3:29] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't use Microsoft at all. Oh, that's how I clicked it. So we're waiting on a member of the [3:37] Speaker B (unidentified): public for a public comment. Yeah, I just want to make sure I've got the render up. Oh, [3:49] Speaker A (unidentified): are [4:01] Speaker E (unidentified): you on Microsoft? Did yours come back in? [4:04] Speaker B (unidentified): You just had to click it twice. It was weird. The redirect. [4:10] Speaker A (unidentified): So we don't have anybody. [4:12] Speaker F (unidentified): All right, [4:17] Speaker B (unidentified): So it's working. Maybe I'll push it in. We just had, it's like redirected us so. So and then like it like it's like we're going to do you use a discussion at it. [4:31] Speaker C (unidentified): Do what? I don't have any. [4:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, she got in. Hey, Denise, you got in. Did you have any comments? We're about to move on from general public comment to muted. Yes, she is muted. All right, Denise, I'm going to say you don't have any comments. She said she's she's muted. I think she just wanted to watch. [4:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, all right, so shall we move to discussion and action items so. [5:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, this one is review and discuss potential select recommendations to town council concerning the true land use map and designating growth areas. So what you have in front of you is a draft future land use map to review basically and some markers. We took the input from last time. I will say yes, I was trying to go through it. We said no to areas then we added it back in and said no. So I kind of made some executive decisions on the draft knowing that we have this. It's easier to look at it I think. In a little context to see it this way, let me share my screen so those at home to zero or yeah. [5:50] Speaker A (unidentified): It's very helpful to have one big yes I said it looks like a risk board. [5:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Something makes some sense to me. You said you were in a risk club. I was the co-chair of the risk club in his goal. So you're highly flavor. What's that? You're a high risk person no we. [6:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Played the board game now. Oh, I was going to say what's that first one you came in. [6:26] Speaker B (unidentified): We're going to be looking at this map in detail in small groups so it's probably not going to be terribly too much excitement to watch on the video. But really I just wanted you all to take a look at it. I've given you markers so the proposed areas are painted into the designated growth area and this is the area that would be slated for the additional density from the new legislation and then low to medium density area. It's sort of the catch-all for everything else. The industrial area is called. Out just to acknowledge where it's at and then conservation and open space area. So the conservation open space area includes all lands that are in easements and conservation, state, federal, local, Sparrow Land Trust. It does not include all of the, we played around with some different versions. It doesn't include all of the stream protection because that is based on a line from a resource that can change. So it looked better. There was, it was more green, but it wasn't maybe necessarily as accurate, so we weren't sure about that one. But we really wanted to make sure first and foremost the designated growth areas is where you all think they should be, and if we should add some areas. And we took Dunstan out. There was some conversation last time about leaving Dunstan in, putting Dunstan, taking Dunstan out, putting some areas South of Old Blue Point in, but it wasn't really clear if there was consensus on that. So I just wanted to give you all this opportunity to take a look at it and add to [8:12] Speaker A (unidentified): or take away. I'm sorry, go ahead. I was going to say, and I'm assuming you don't have farmland [8:18] Speaker B (unidentified): trusts in there it is because i see one that's not mark that's why i'm here and that's why yes if there's anything that you know of that's missing scene. Please follow the green mark. Do you have a green one? No. Okay. I don't have any markers. Okay. Oh, you didn't. You took that. I ran out of, this is the random question. [8:47] Speaker C (unidentified): This is a question. When I look at this and I look at growth, so I'm looking at Oak Hill. Huh. And my question isn't, where should that be at growth here or not? It's, does that pinkish there and down at Money, does it identify just an area and what exists here now, or is it including like what's, because I'm looking at Oakland going, you know how much is really [9:10] Speaker B (unidentified): available there from a it's opportunity it's kind of a combination of existing zoning existing stuff and some opportunity so there's some land behind hanniford like at oakland you know the farm the farm so that is included okay and that would be a good conversation there's some land down at dunstan this bob harrisburg's property right in here i don't know if you guys can see that it's not included you know that is the zoning is the interesting thing about this exercise is the zoning's already here, we're not changing something. Yeah, so you can maybe not be a designated growth area on this map, but you still have the best zoning in town. Yeah, so we're not making any changes, we're just really using this as a very high level, so it's the goal is to have it more simple. Yeah, but okay, yeah, looking for anything missing or extra or pieces you want to add in, you know, like we don't have the municipal campus is not in the growth area because it doesn't need to be, but if it's cleaner to make Large swaths, that's fine too. This is just a really based on our conversations and what we're dealing with, what you all think. And if you want me to open up like Google Earth or anything so we can make it different, or GIS, we can do that too. So if it's helpful to look at aerials, like we started out using the zoning as a base, but then just for instance, we did some clarification on our own. Like this parcel right here, the zone glide light industrial, but it stayed manufactured homes, so we took it out of the industrial area. So we did some things like that we know don't make sense. This area over here along Muzzy, we took this part. There's one parcel that's owned, I think it's a bigger parcel, but we split it because there's a lot of wetlands on this part, so we just kept the frontage. So there were some decisions made. Pain Road corridor, we took these pieces out of the growth area. Most of this land is Warren Woods and Scarborough Land Trust land, a lot of wetlands. So yeah, Autumn, yes. Why keep if you [11:33] Speaker A (unidentified): keep going where you were just surfing around on an unsung trimmer there across the turnpike, like why is that not conservation, reminding what's in there and what's going on? Oh yeah, of course, well duh, it's pressed for my house, why wouldn't I know that? Okay [12:04] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, all right, so you guys like the assignment I guess. What would be helpful to have, I don't know [12:15] Speaker A (unidentified): what the source was, but the other day something popped up and it said number one growth town in the name is Scarborough, right? And then it was Saco, and then it was, you know, I thought [12:26] Speaker F (unidentified): better for a name, Warren. So right in the heart, oh my gosh, it's called suburbia [12:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, because of the metropolitan. So is our intention to tighten our designated growth areas or to open them up? I mean [12:54] Speaker B (unidentified): from the residents and Council and the direction and conversations is to tighten it up okay I just wanted to be clear this version is a tighter version than our current yeah okay right okay I just wanted to be clear yeah and the real reason you know we talked about a little bit last time like our current map is fine it doesn't necessarily mean anything it's a future land use that but the way the new legislation will apply it does now mean something so this map is now parcel based which is not The norm for a future land use map, this is not good planning. I'm just going to put it out there right, this is a dual zoning map situation that is not really. So it's in response to this, future land use maps are supposed to be very fluid and give you some flexibility and you know, you kind of, you might, the way our map now, there's a little village area in North Scar in North Carolina that's fine, but in response to LD 2173 now it says something different right, so we have to, we have to do this okay I just want everyone in the state to know that I don't like, yeah I've said it multiple times, I appreciate you. Yeah so I'm gonna share, would it, how would you all like to proceed and there's enough maps for a way to kind of work by themselves or together, what would be the easiest way for you kind of look at it, do you want to look at an area together, we can go on aerials or [14:31] Speaker E (unidentified): tell me what's the easiest way for you to collect data. Yeah I think, yeah what is easy to color on [14:36] Speaker B (unidentified): the maps, okay yeah I say that, yeah just tell us what to do, yeah familiar you know. Yeah there's an area that you know, I mean west of Scarborough, west of the turnpike is pretty straightforward, yeah I don't think based on any of our conversations we didn't want to put any of [14:55] Speaker A (unidentified): that in a growth area, question, and this has to do with my neighbor because now the Running Hill development or mixed use zone, so that's going to go away under this, yes okay [15:17] Speaker B (unidentified): zoning doesn't go away Jamie, it's just the designated growth area [15:21] Speaker A (unidentified): in right, but how will that affect the zone, the zoning, because that's the only, it won't have any [15:30] Speaker B (unidentified): effect so the only time this would affect zoning is if you're in the pink you get to do the five thousand square foot minimum lot size of four units that's what that's this is it's only for the residential okay in response to 2173 which supersedes the zoning right so we have we 're doing this and then my hopes is to give this to our recommendations to council january yeah and then to move along this process and then we're writing the next we'll start talking about space involved in a lot changes and stuff for you all [16:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, that it, thank you, that is, yeah, oh Robin hey, I see your hand, sorry, thank you, I'm just [16:14] Speaker D (unidentified): Just going to bring up the comment that I always bring up, which is, I know we have no plans to put public utilities on the west side of the Turnpike, but what are we doing on the east side of the Turnpike to mitigate the impacts to the runoff to the marsh? You know, so what I'm saying is, towns like Gorham are on the west side of the Turnpike and towns like Saco and Buxton and others. And they're dealing with densification on the west side of the Turnpike. And they're putting in public sewer and water out there and having to make way for development. The town of Scarborough seems to feel like if we don't put public sewer and water out there, then we can just leave it as is and have larger lots and just continue to focus and concentrate our development on the east side of the turnpike, which puts a heavier burden on the runoff that goes to the marsh. And considering the fact that we didn't get ahead of that when we developed the 500 acres at the downs, we're going to start seeing impacts at the marsh if we haven't already. So what are we doing, I know we're tightening up our growth here, our growth areas, but I'll just continue to say it that as Because, you know, our designated growth areas are generally near environmentally sensitive areas, like wetlands, which are, you know, baby marsh areas. So, you know what I'm trying to say, Autumn? [18:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, we hear you. Thank you, Robin. Robin, we have the low-impact development standards that we have to have in place, so that will help. [18:26] Speaker D (unidentified): I know, but we've been hearing that for several years now, and nothing's happened. And we've had incredible development over the last few years, i.e. the Downs and other places, that you can't go after sins of the past with low-impact development. [18:49] Speaker B (unidentified): I don't have a good answer for you, Robin. I wasn't here when the CEA or the Downs zoning was put in place. [19:00] Speaker D (unidentified): I know you weren't, and I was, I was saying it then too, though, Autumn. Yeah, I just think that I [19:07] Speaker G (unidentified): don't know that, like, legally we can't just say you can't build, you can't, you can't have growth, and so for better or worse, this is sort of the, this has been the philosophy, the planning philosophy that the town has followed, and that's in the comp plan, to have this, these designated, the designated growth areas. So we either have that with enhanced stormwater treatment. So the downs, before the downs, before it was developed as it's being now, had no stormwater treatment. Really? And so there's sort of trade offs between when you're talking about Robin and having sprawl and we can't we can't just say there can't be development. So I hear what you're saying, and I do think that the town is doing what it can within the within the framework of what's feasible to try and try and manage this. But it's just it's a it is it's a trade-off for sure. I just challenge the political I just [20:14] Speaker D (unidentified): challenge you all who are politically I think you all have been you know given if you all are hearing that you know we need to tighten up on the growth areas and we need to tighten up on certain things you're hearing from the voters that the political will is there and so we've got to look eye to eye yeah [20:42] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean I guess I would I hear everybody but I guess I'd say one I agree with Robin in the sense that it's been the number one issue that's come out of every survey for the last I don't know a dozen years so I think we're all pretty aware that people aren't happy with what's happened and they don't want it to continue the way it has. At the last meeting one of the things we discussed was you know do we want a group sitting here in 10 years wondering why they why we are what we are and wondering what we were doing sitting here today so we're saying we weren't here when it happened. I don't want a group sitting here 10 years saying well we weren't here when it happened like they made really bad decisions. So I think it's between what the town has said they wanted which is slow growth you know let's get a handle on it let's kind of let infrastructure and other things catch up with where we are with Corey's point of we can't just build a wall around Scarborough so I think it's how do we pragmatically follow the law but also do anything within our power which is what I think Autumn's been doing a great job of trying to help us migrate there and to hold everybody accountable and it's you know I know the downs but it's just every developer I mean I walk the Eastern Trail almost every day I look at Eastern Village and now there's a where you live in front of there's now a house basically on the trail almost you know so and there's more development going in and I'm not picking on Him, but I walk by there and go like, how did this happen? And you know, so I think it's, and that's right on the march. I mean, talk about environmental, you know, and the stormwater pond. Exactly. So I look at that and say, you know, is that already a done deal, or is there some way for us to, you know, change that and change, you know, growth, whatever we can, we have power or influence over, so there isn't, you know, seven more houses sitting on the eastern trail next year. [22:39] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, and so I think for you it's kind of, I see it in the middle and I need to be dismissive of Robin's concerns. I just, I do think it's important. I think that's going to be one of our challenges this coming year as a town and as a council is coming to really come to grips with the on the ground realities of 2173 and how we're limited. And for better or worse, we can only, we can only address what is ahead of us. We think, to Robin's point, we can't go back and fix the sins of the past. Yes, but just saying we have to follow [23:10] Speaker D (unidentified): the law isn't, isn't, isn't addressing it, Corey. We can be more stringent than the state and the federal law if we want to, and what I'm saying is that the people of Scarborough are saying we want to be environmentally conscious and sustainable in our growth patterns. So I'm asking that we all put that in the forefront of our mind and asking what this is gonna look like in a hundred years from now and 200 years from now, if we continue on at this rate. [23:45] Speaker C (unidentified): So, I mean, Cora, I look at it a little bit like what we, you know, with sort of the loud voices across a bunch of town around the ICE facility. And it's a federal thing, but I think as a council we've kind of done whatever we can do to move the needle to say this is what we stand for, this is what we want our town, and we've kind of taken it to the edge. And I look at growth sort of the same way, like let's take it to the edge without sort of stepping in something that we don't have any control over, right, and what can we do before July 1st to sort of meet the goal that I think most of the town has stated, because we only have really six months to [24:26] Speaker B (unidentified): Be to get ready and have that in place right before July 1st, right? The parallel exercise is the low impact development standards because, Robin, finally we have to do them because all the appeals are over, and so that's all due by July 1st as well. So that's a exercise we did our first public meeting last month, and so we have some enhanced, we have the standards that we have to do for DEP, and then we have a set of enhancements that we want to do just for the reasons that Robin's talking about, so That'll start going to ordinance committee as soon as those committees are all ready. So we have, I don't know if I mentioned it, but I have asked Tom if I could do a workshop on January 6 to lay out all of the ordinances and the plans for all the things that have to come through before July, okay, just to give you all a good idea schedule of everything. Things is low impact development, and then all of these changes are going to be happening simultaneously, and then there's always some cleanup that Aaron and I want to do, I think [25:26] Speaker C (unidentified): before our goal setting, probably. We have three new people that, you know, are quick learners but need to get on a lot of this stuff, so that would be good to have before we have a goal setting [25:39] Speaker D (unidentified): And my only point in this is just like we had a Main Won't Wait plan, let's have a Scarborough a Won't Wait plan. Let's, let's stop waiting for everybody else and let's just do low impact development. Let's just do it. We've been talking about it for years, and even if it gets appealed, let's just do it and tell me what needs to happen, how I can support it, you know, or how whatever we can do. Let's just do it and stop talking about it, I guess, is what I'm saying. Thank you [26:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Robin, this is G Marie. When you say low impact development, can you tell me a little more about what you're talking about without going, you know, short and brief. [26:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, it's just a technique for developing that minimizes the impacts to the land, both the runoff and the vegetation and the clearance so that you maximize infiltration. You minimize, you know, sort of how you're going to impact the land, and there's just a number of techniques. Aaron, what's what's happening, I [26:49] Speaker B (unidentified): was telling her that we've been working on this for four years and yeah, so let's just do it. Yeah, we hear you, we would love to get just get it done. Yeah, it's gonna happen this, so it's spring drama. Well, let me, and I want to expand on that just a [27:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Little more so I can understand better, and I get that as both, you know, in all my different rules in life right now, but that doesn't stop development per se. It just tells developers you gotta follow certain rules if you're going to develop, and let's just, yeah, and [27:25] Speaker D (unidentified): And it's just being consistent. All you have to do if you're going to change the rules, just tell people what the, what the rules are that need to be changed, and then just be consistent about them, and just consistently enforce them, consistently talk about them, consistently apply them, and consistently implement them. And you know what, developers relish predictability, and they will keep coming, they will keep coming back to Scarborough just like they are today. Okay, they keep coming to Scarborough for a reason. We jack up the impact fees, we jack up whatever, guess what, they're not going anywhere, guys. So I'm just asking the political folks in the room to really have the political will to support staff with this, and I'm going to put on [28:15] Speaker A (unidentified): my realtor hat just for one second so pretend I'm not an elected official now I'm putting on my realtor hat and one of the things that especially on my side of Starborough is that people want the right to develop their properties they want the right to be able to sell them for a lot of people it's their retirement or it's their future so you know we've got to keep that in mind also and then you talk about gorham in particular because i represent gorham on the county i know that gorham's going through the same angst we are right now with their developing, and if you notice, and standards, because I represent standards too, that what's, what's happening, and what happens at least in Maine, it seems to me, is that you'll have these development centers sort of in the center of the town, of the municipality, and then they do these concentric circles going out. The further out they get, the more rural they get, and then the next one over it does the same thing. And so anyway, I'm just laying that out as the development patterns seem to be in this area, and I'm all for making sure we preserve what we can preserve. It'd be great if we could say, yeah, there's a town we don't want, so we don't want water on the west side of the turnpike, but I don't know if you can do that legally, but anyway, I'm just throwing this out there, but thank you Robin for bringing up [30:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Those factors, yeah. I mean, I guess my final thought on this is, well, I'm hurrying more, so I should say final, an additional thought is, you know, we were elected to support what people are asking for, and I think we've seen that in the recent election. It's like, you know, people, I think, are voting with what matters to them, and I personally ran to slow growth. I'm not against growth. I want strategic, thoughtful growth, and I think that's what most of the town wants, so that's the lens I kind of look at, and I'm not against developers, but they're not my customer, and they're not my, you know, that's not my focus. So I think it's what do we do to preserve, enhance, and continue a life, you know, style or a, you know, in trails and, you know, the rivers, and maintain all the reasons that we all moved here and things that were important to us. So that, I feel like, is what I'm trying to represent, because that's what people told me when I decided to run, you know, that this is what we need to be doing, and so I think it's using that is a filter and then i think you're right people are going to keep coming here they do keep coming there and so let's not be a cheap date you know it's like let's let's be who we are you know it's sort of like here's here's our expectations here's the filters follow the rules and then [31:32] Speaker A (unidentified): and, you know, we welcome you, and I'm going to, I'm going to counter that some degree. Not a cheap thing anyway, that's an interesting term, but then you also have to balance affordability, because Scarborough is, people can't afford to live here, and when I say people, I mean younger people, our kids work for, of course me, this workforce housing here, yeah, we can't afford workforce housing. So you got to have that balance of having the so-called rules and whatever with, but then are you preventing [32:06] Speaker C (unidentified): the development of by having these sort of, I agree, I mean, I totally support affordable housing. I think we need to define what that is, because people are like, oh, it's only 900,000, it's affordable in Scarborough. I'm like, that is not affordable housing. You need a 200,000 down payment, but it's like, we've let all this development in, and I would say the houses over on Chamberlain, on the, on the railroad tracks, going for 850, oh yeah, I'm like, so that is not affordable housing, and we let, you know, another 12 houses fall out there and I think we need to be surgical about what kind of housing do we want and if we want people to be able to afford here so that it's we have a middle class which I think most of us want right then we can't let people just keep coming in and building two million dollar houses so I think it's sort of like how do we achieve that and Corey can be very helpful I think in helping us with that 's true because I think that you're right Jean Marie it's not no but it's maybe not replicating what we've been [33:15] Speaker E (unidentified): doing right we're having some flexibility because if we keep doing what we've been doing we're going to be having these same conversations 10 and 20 years from now saying what were they thinking they knew they saw them they saw the problem if they let it continue and it continues to [33:32] Speaker C (unidentified): that day definitely show them sanity right correct yes so that's what I thought that was good and so [33:39] Speaker A (unidentified): in terms of the designated growth areas just looking at how we incent them workforce force housing or some kind of great means to incent developers to and sometimes it's partnering [33:53] Speaker C (unidentified): with employers you know employers I look at what's happened up in Jackson Labs and what's happened up at Saddleback Mountain with the mountain you know so it isn't just tax our tax our taxpayers money it's also employers saying we need to have nurses and doctors and housing and you know I'm a scientist, so we [34:16] Speaker A (unidentified): don't worry about surgeons and doctors. [34:20] Speaker E (unidentified): I was at an event last month. [34:24] Speaker C (unidentified): That's how much that they had last week in [34:27] Speaker E (unidentified): in York County for the Tourism Association. We got on to a couple of different topics, and one of them was ready seafood, which is just on the other side of the thing. They could not find people to work, so they had to get them their housing. So they not only have the housing so their employees can work. and I'm not saying that 's but it is something that is could be incentivized right if there's if [34:50] Speaker A (unidentified): there's a need for that right well I think of the mill towns in Maine because like the Rumfords and the Jays and the Millinocket Westbrook even when the mills came in the mill owners built housing for their people that's right and part of it is we our impact fees the offsets are not high enough right because the commitment developers have to build some kind of affordable housing oh well you know I'll just pay the fee and walk away and that's not nearly I know that [35:25] Speaker E (unidentified): Those who never could have seen that in Portland they've already said like oh it's not enough to actually counteract what they are trying to accomplish so somehow we need to have a balance. [35:36] Speaker A (unidentified): it's supposed to be days and tips i get i get news for you yeah well how and indeed you get what you're right really after i know and helping the public understand that 's what it's about because without education you're going to have pushback your phone yeah [35:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah should we should we get started well but I think conversations but our first step is we have to redo this map and then some practical real world gotta do it so I'd like for you all to take a look at the map and add anything and then like I said if it's helpful for me to pull up the aerial and we can talk about certain areas we can definitely do that I know it's everybody's brain works a little bit different so you tell me what would be the most helpful I think the pink areas that we have. Now it's up on you know pain road favelas the north side of hygas we did take out the other side of hygas where salt pump and all them yeah better is we oak hill main health's in there they get in so do you all want to talk about thunston and see if there's anything are you comfortable leaving thunston out of the designated growth area all the zoning remains all of them all that's still in place because we ultimately this group has to make a recommendation to council this map I come. [37:24] Speaker E (unidentified): Back to I think the same conversation I had last month which is I can't support putting dunstan into this kind of designated growth area with without knowing what could right now as it stands it shouldn't have that if we know that in you know so much time things will change infrastructure wise sure then go back and revisit it at that point but I think it's like a caveat to say yeah it's not until we get x y and z in infrastructure improvement so that we don't contribute to the bottleneck that's. Already there that's where I am yeah like if we have to know what can be done you know and I know that's a much bigger conversation for other committees and everything else but I think it can't have that designation until those things are addressed yeah. [38:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. Well, that's why that was my first question, which is, you know, how do we sort of advance that conversation? Yeah. And I think when Portia opened up saying we take a look at the growth, like, you know, we're one saw those two. It also explains why that whole corridor is just nightmarish. Well, I can't. All the compounding effect of all the southern traffic that's coming back and getting back and forth to Portland as well. [38:46] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, absolutely. Because if you give someone the option to say, from start from SACO to say, do you take the turnpike or do you take route 1? They're probably going to opt for route 1 based on where they're at. If they're closer to route 1. [38:59] Speaker D (unidentified): I can say, though, that if we designate it as a growth area, it will impact heavily the discussion that the turnpike how the turnpike receives the conversation from Tom and the elected officials. Officials if we do say that it is a designated growth area but [39:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Could we say we would designate it as a growth area, you know, like we've got to do a chicken and egg thing here, that's our 15 years, exactly, and that's why I'm saying, like, we can't, I don't want to have us stuck for 15 years making it exponentially worse for the hope that, you know, the correct, because you've got to go back to the to their board and get their board's approval and, you know, that it's, you know. [39:44] Speaker B (unidentified): I think we can some after we look at the map, I don't know if we'll get to it today, but next month we have to wrap this up. So we'll start looking at the descriptions for the areas and. To Robin's point, some of that we might be able to capture in the description and this low to medium density area. It's sort of this catch all. But maybe we could put some caveats and then this is stuff some of these areas especially along major arterials or there's potential to move them in the designated growth area once infrastructure so that might be a good thing though if that could be yeah if that could be [40:22] Speaker E (unidentified): Listed I think that would be perfect just so that it is providing that plan for the 10 and 20 years when none of us are at this table and people say well what were they thinking no they were thinking 10 20 30 years down the road to help guide them as well because it's not just a vacuum [40:37] Speaker A (unidentified): We're working in right well you start looking at the right-of-way requirements in order to put an exchange for rabbits the tighter that growth becomes almost like anyone be able to get right [40:51] Speaker B (unidentified): away to even build exactly it takes a play into that same vein of thinking we can even acknowledge some of those areas, like, maybe the North Scarborough village in the text as well. Like, we acknowledge that these areas are unique and there's potential, but until utilities are in place with that. Yeah, I think that's kind of. We, can also, yeah, not to add it in the growth there. I'm talking about the test. Yeah. So, like, you're not now like, oh, yeah. Well, I wonder if we do, like, how we wonder, like, then you would say, like, oh, very lucky about the future. future and these are the sites and if it's yeah it's not possible so it's like not now right not now and we're not going to go parcel based with it right but maybe we right just have one conversation like 10 years but macy we were just talking about we could probably even in the descriptors grab a piece of the map and talk about them uniquely and so we don't lose what we've already acknowledged that but we since we're stuck with this we could do a little bit of both so i [42:01] Speaker C (unidentified): think that i do yeah you know too i think it's with 2173 coming online i think it's also a good time to be having this conversation and pausing some and then you know like three years looking at what has the impact of that been and what's been the impact on infrastructure and schools and [42:19] Speaker B (unidentified): the environment and the roads and everything else so yeah because the first was the ld 2003 like the impacts really weren't really impactful for us but they didn't really give that one time to do anything right we already allowed adus yeah right so yeah our growth is actually slowed a little bit our residential permits have gone down right a lot of that has to do with the economy i was just going to land you know inflation all those things there's always you know for sure but yeah it's definitely good and we do track everything so we have a baseline always so we can see yeah good see if they're direct impacts like we've had two and a half density bonuses on the table for a few years now building 2003 so if you had affordable workforce course how we can get two and a half to density so it's the densities you know the only project that we have that have has come in and tried to use that was the marsh view affordable housing project but no one else has taken advantage of that are they taking advantage of it in other [43:32] Speaker E (unidentified): areas no one okay so it's so it's not just you know this is actually kind of reminds me an [43:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Interesting point that was made when we had early last year, we had a kind of a workshop with other town officials and representatives from Greater Portland. They included Cape Elizabeth's town manager. We were talking about eight at the time, 1829, and his point was that, you know, and not, and it wasn't to take away any of the concerns about local control and the ability to manage growth, but just sort of to, what Autumn was just describing, that there's a tendency, an understandable, like, human tendency to just kind of to jump to the worst case scenario, like, well, this is going to be allowed, so we're, there's just going to be a mad gold rush of people coming in, and they're going to build up, they're going to build out every available piece of dirt in town. And again, it's not to minimize the concerns, but the realities of markets and everything else dictate that they're, you know, they're going to be constraints, and it's not all going to happen at once. So it's just again, it doesn't, it doesn't detract from the need to think about this carefully. The other point I was going to make, or observation I was going to make, is I feel like Dunstan's a good example. It gets a little bit to what Robin was saying before about how, by definition, the areas that we that are the designated growth zones are in parts of town that are already at least adjacent to play areas that are already pretty well built out, and we have congestion, and that's kind of a planning challenge when you're thinking, it's hard to kind of hard to divorce your thinking from what you observe already. So like Dunstan, so you know what we were talking about earlier, it's hard to think about that being, it doesn't be a growth zone, there's already such congestion there. But if you were just looking at it and you didn't know anything about the area, you were just looking at the map, you would say, oh yeah, obviously. Basically, that should be a designated road zone, because there are major arteries there and there's infrastructure. So I do agree with the approach that I was kind of suggesting, kind of at least retaining some of that destructive content, so that it's recognized that those areas have certain qualities and potential. [45:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Natural. Well, it speaks to Robin's comment about continuity too, of saying we've got a process, we've thought it through, and here's our process, so that there is a continuity in terms of how we're approaching designating these high growth areas, not just willy-nilly because it's got a lot of little tiny squares on it. Okay, it's on that high growth night. Yeah, I [46:18] Speaker B (unidentified): circled some areas, the areas where we're talking, like my thoughts on what a little snippet on that. So I have Broad Turn and Holmes Road, and that's why I was thinking, just to Aaron's point, like just a visual and a super loose circle, like this is an area to revisit in the future, Holmes Road and Beach Ridge, north of the Scarborough County Road and Sopho Street, running hill and Dunstan, Spur Wing and Black Point Road is one I always think is a really interesting little village, just a tiny little thing, but I think that's, and then Pleasant Hill area, those are the ones I circle, just as these are areas of, they're a bit different or potential, so they'll, they might be open to revisiting, and maybe we can put some language in that these sorts of things really have to be in place for something to get moved into the dozen. Maybe these criteria should be evaluated. It doesn't, we don't have to define it exactly, but these are the things that are important if Gorham gets water and sewer up here and you know, or something happens over here. Yeah, it's potentially, we should put those back in. Yeah, or maybe not, it's just areas that are of special interest. So maybe this low to medium density can have like this, an additional category, as long as we're again [47:51] Speaker A (unidentified): consistent in how we approach making those determined emotions yes so that we say okay here 's the process that we follow it doesn't mean every right area has to be the same but we have a consistent process i don't know like what would that well for instance impact on [48:10] Speaker B (unidentified): marsh, impact on, I mean, look like all the bullets, right? Yeah, you know, maybe Gene Marino [48:18] Speaker C (unidentified): is the answer to this. I looked, I worked here, I went 33 years, and you know, the growth that came in that time, you know, certainly impacted the schools, and then when I take a look at, you know, when I've been out meeting and greeting and meeting people at council or conversations around town, I've been surprised in the last five years how many people have moved to town to retire. Oh, and the school numbers really haven't gone up, they've gone down, right, even for when my son graduated in 2019. So when you Take a look at infrastructure. I used to think about like the impact on schools being the number one, and now I look at it and go, no, it's really more all these other things. So you know, I just, have you seen that like, oh honey, yeah, I'm selling all cash. [49:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Retirees who want to live near Portland, who have the money because they sold big joints right in Massachusetts, or they got more money than going from Texas. That's not what, you know, it's like, but I mean, it is what it is. But here's the other thing, I'm 71, yeah, in 10 years I'll be 81, and I was born in 1955, which is the peak of the boomer, right before 95. But we're all going to be dying whether we want to admit to it or not. And so the next challenge, and this is what it's been talked about, real estate. And realtor, you know, whatever, is then what happens, because then you're going to have another big shift, yeah, with all these houses that we've been living in, right, that are then going to become available, right. But we aren't having the kids to replace us, so that's going to be your next challenge, you know, 15 years, just so you know. So I just, I bring. [50:06] Speaker C (unidentified): That up just to say it also impacts like what we're building, but also when you look at the infrastructure impacts, I think the conversation, I think 22 of people have kids in school, and those numbers are diminishing. I guess families have got smaller, so when you talk about infrastructure on our footnotes on here, you know, is it more roads and bridges and trails, and you. [50:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Know, I put for bullets, so let's add to it. I put environmental concerns, water, sewer, schools, road infrastructure, amenities, distance to services, yeah, and I mean, we keep adding to that, yeah. But those are not, as you know, you have to, but these are all the criteria to be evaluated. I'm waiting on a future day or whatever. It doesn't say we're just picking and choosing. Right. There's something lacking in these things. Maybe just one or maybe two of them in all these little red circles. [50:58] Speaker E (unidentified): I think that's a really good way of providing a flexible roadmap for the next time that this gets. Because we don't know what it's going to look like. I mean, 10 years ago, I'm sure none of us thought that Scarborough would look the way it does now. Now, and 10 years from now, it's going to look, could look vastly different than what even we're. [51:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Planning for right now. Who knows? I mean, I just remember being a kid, my friend moving from South, I grew up in South Portland, so I grew up with so-called urban density. For me, I mean, my best friend moved to Scarborough when we were so sad for her. Yeah, she was moving out the middle of nowhere. I was in the hills in the middle of nowhere, so there you go. I mean, even that was [51:39] Speaker C (unidentified): 60 years ago. Even in 93. I remember my friends at Hannaford that lived in Fountainville were like, you're building in Scarborough? Like, why do you need to found this? I'm like, I don't want to live near country clubs. Yeah. Like, I want to live near farmers. [51:54] Speaker D (unidentified): I think it's just as important for us to describe what we don't want to have happen, though, as we want to have happen you know because like I've said when I moved to Scarborough from northern Maine you know I just assumed Scarborough was going to turn into Saugus and Danvers you know by 2026 honest to god I did you know because you know I thought that 's what you know the way things were going you know being from northern and central Maine I just figured that's what it was going to look like So that's why I got, you know, involved. So I think it's just as important for us to remember what we don't want to have happen. As many unknowns as there are, I think it's important for us to remember what we can control. We [52:56] Speaker G (unidentified): won't have data centers, by the way. Did that one get examples? That's an example of something that would not have been on anyone's radar. That's right. Yeah, did that one, that was on the planning board [53:17] Speaker D (unidentified): that did that one advance or is that one still in the planning process? No, it didn't advance. No, it [53:24] Speaker G (unidentified): there was actually a court ruling yesterday. Yeah, really? Yeah, good [53:31] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean frankly, if we could prevent water and sewer from coming over to my side of Starboard [53:40] Speaker B (unidentified): I'd be fine with that, seriously. And then that's a terrible thing, right? And to Robin's point, always water and sewers, and environmentally speaking, and for people and for services, everyone should have access to water and sewer. Just gonna put that out there. That's what's unfortunate about the predicament we find ourselves in for density concerns. [54:00] Speaker A (unidentified): But when you bring water and sewer, then you get to build it. [54:03] Speaker D (unidentified): I know, I know, I get it. [54:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Then you don't have your 40,000 square foot minimum required by the state of the. [54:12] Speaker D (unidentified): It's a double-edged sword now, I know. [54:14] Speaker B (unidentified): So you kind of have to have all the other things in place that we do not honestly have in place. We don't have a requirement. In Texas, all of this would have already been developed out, but every one of these little pods would have had their own pool and amenity center and all that, I mean. And so it's Austin, but at least there are services and little pockets of, yeah, grocery stores, completely different. But we don't have any of that, not that, and that's good, but we don't know yet what we want that to look. [54:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Right, this were to develop. I have another thought, and maybe Corey can help me with this a little bit, but I don't know what the list is called of all the infrastructure, like Scott Old Hill's on there, it's like number 41, and you know the barn, yeah. So when you take a look at that and then you sort of layer that on top of this, is that another piece that we should be looking at? So we know that like the top 10 high risk items on there are, you know, also in something that we have looked at, listed in the growth area, you know. Should we be looking to fix those things before we allow, you know, the traffic to increase by 20, and I'm just making these numbers up, but I thought about that because until another, you know, catastrophe happens, and if it's in an area where we're just encouraging growth and then we realize all the infrastructure is crumbling and really can't support that impact, that doesn't seem like a good decision on our part. And I think [55:55] Speaker G (unidentified): that's definitely a good way to wrap up. [56:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Because it's not just the infrastructure, it's also who's going to be underwater. Oh yeah, exactly. [56:10] Speaker C (unidentified): And when it is full moon and high tide, oh yeah, like I literally can't get out of my house, right? I can't get out of mine, right? I become an island, so you know, it's so, and I'm not, it's not about me, but I'm just thinking when I look up the, you know, Pine Point Road, there were times when that happened, an old Blue Point, and well [56:28] Speaker A (unidentified): there's gonna be Pine Island down there. I know, I know, we're gonna invest in a kayak and a motorboat [56:34] Speaker C (unidentified): but I think it is something we need to really think about when we look at this is, you know, where is that high risk, and then solve the problem before we contribute to it, which is another [56:47] Speaker A (unidentified): piece of the Dunstan thing, because if we have to raise one across the marsh, yeah, that then I don't know if it's done, that's right, that's right, not viable to explore [57:01] Speaker C (unidentified): so I guess with that information, Autumn, what is that duty? I don't even begin to understand what [57:07] Speaker B (unidentified): That does to the map, but I think it just adds maybe some, just some circles. Yeah, and we'll just put some more descriptors in this low to medium density area, and I don't even think we'll go as far, I don't want to think about it. Like, I want to call them something, but we'll just acknowledge that there are other areas in town, and then the descriptor language will be updated. They did, so it kind of sounds like we will if we brought this map back with that, and then the descriptor language to you all in December, would you be, yeah, there's my team, would we be able to vote it forward to move to Council in January the ordinance going to pay for discussion? I mean, that kind of, that's what I'm looking for. [58:02] Speaker D (unidentified): See, I totally trust all the work that you do on them. [58:09] Speaker F (unidentified): What would it look like if we put the wetlands to [58:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, we wouldn't be able to put all the way wetlands. Wetlands, we would only have the National inventory, and I think it would imply some misinformation because it would not pick up all the individual wetlands that are required to get picked up with the wetland delineations, so I wouldn't want to, I wouldn't put it on there for that reason, because when what happens, we have a layer, and then we can turn on the National, and I can see big wetlands, but when you come in and develop this parcel, you probably have a little wetland here [58:53] Speaker F (unidentified): and I wouldn't see that. Yeah, right, yeah, I was mainly looking at where the, where the big ones that have been identifier, I mean, there's been a lot, but they also, they also change. Yeah, that's true, but it's changed. Why? Because of environmental impacts. Sure, a whole lot, a whole slew of [59:14] Speaker B (unidentified): but they change in a way that we don't have control, they're unpredictable, right, exactly, so to have it on a printed map, yeah, I just wanted to see what it would, you know, even GIS, yeah, but I don't know if it belongs on, that's kind of the same, we started with this idea of doing resource protection on this map, and then once we looked at it, we didn't like it because it was [59:38] Speaker F (unidentified): complicated knowing that. Yeah, I thought it did, but everything else is good, I think that will help us if we were, you know, what is the definitions of low to medium density, that's, that's the, these areas are saying, I think some wetland impacts could lend itself, I mean, yeah, you have a little bit of wetlands where you have a lot of implants, right, and that can certainly help [1:00:02] Speaker A (unidentified): another way that we did not anticipate, and the difference between salt water and fresh water [1:00:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Because then you're impacting Wells. Yep, just to give you guys a crazy idea, in other places that I've worked at, so people would say this broad term, this is just an example, brought to her own Holmes Road intersection, say somebody developer was really interested in doing something here, but our zoning is all RF rural farming, and so what they would do is consult a comp plan, the land use plan, and so if the land use plan has this circle, then the developer it would be on them to say oh I'd really like to have the zoning changed here. In Maine we call that a spot zone. That's not actually a spot zone even if it's in compliance with your latest plan. So then the developer would be on them to take all of our evaluation criteria that we've laid out, make their case to council to actually amend the future land use plan to actually let them apply for a reason. So there's like a process, that's how it should work. We don't do a lot of rezoning here, which I'm not grabbing, I think that's great, it makes my life easier. Yeah, but in this sort of scenario in 10 years that might be a really inappropriate thing, or this intersection, something's like I really want to do something here and it would be great, we all kind of think it would be great, maybe there's, and so that would be the process they would take, these evaluation criteria, the weapons, the water, all the things, make their case, and then we could actually amend this map and they can amend zoning to comply. So that I like where we're going, I think that those there you can make, then you have real criteria, so I like that and all those things. So I think what we'll do is tweak this a little bit more to these circles that I've talked about. Do they generally make sense that what everybody kind of walk around and see if there are any other on this one. If you add any missing things, any green or any areas that you think should be seen, just put them on your maps and then we'll collect them all and then next time for December we'll give you our final draft map and the language and then hopefully we can move it along. long. And then we can start talking about lot sizes. Yeah. So who? Don't worry about it. [1:02:51] Speaker C (unidentified): That's going to be our topic for 2027 or next year. [1:02:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, 2027. In January, we'll start talking about space and bulk and lot sizes. Oh, yeah. Because we have to change our minimum lot size, and then with that, we need to address frontage. We also need to really address private way standards and backlogs and how all that. We need to make area nice lives a little easier. And people that have property. We have some real world examples. If you have 40 acres, I believe you should be able to have two houses on it. But our rules are really cumbersome. And that is a thing. [1:03:32] Speaker A (unidentified): I feel like we should have to do this. That's all set Jean Marie because of me this is my own experience all anyway Scarborough has way more stringent septic rules than anywhere else in the state and it has to do with the night mid 1970s lawsuit to do with the clam flats basically I mean I'm really playing this stuff but it impacts attacks people who aren't anywhere near the clam flats yeah nor is the water going in anyway it's just something to look at do we need to keep it that stringent part of me says yes but let's have an option for people who may be able to make the argument that they should you know that they can follow the state yeah and I and I bring that up purely selfishly until recently because I have eight acres of land yeah and we subdivided one lot and part of it was because I could perk fine for state standards for septic but not by Starborough standards that being said we have found that it does perk for two so if you drive by my house you're going to see some stakes in there because that's part of my retirement so I bring that up and I'd be the first one to tell you yeah but that you know so it's just something to look at I mean I think it makes perfect sense from an environmental point of view I think it did help a lot before the sewers went in yeah on this side of Scarborough that was part of why the sewer district came into being yeah was because you couldn't do anything yeah but just something [1:05:28] Speaker C (unidentified): to keep in mind well I think it's a good point and I don't know how pervasive this is but I know when we were doing some of our initial conversation with counselors meetings and we I mean, one of the ones I did out at North Scarborough Fire, maybe that might have been where Corey's at, but there was a gentleman who came and, you know, brought up that point. He owns, I don't know, 20, 30 acres somewhere in town and has a couple of children that are in the community. [1:05:56] Speaker A (unidentified): And he wants to leave land to them. [1:05:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Or to have them do it now and just, you know. Yeah. So, you know, sort of multi-generational living, but not under the same roof, but under the same cloth, right? Right. And I think there are probably a number of situations like that. And it's like, I want to support those people. Right. Right. [1:06:17] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, that's even I'm sorry. No. And I just was going to say, I mean, that gets to kind of, you know, lowercase a affordability. Yeah. Yeah. Talk about just kind of a more diversified housing stock and creating opportunities for people to even, you know, you know Councilor Doherty who is you know pretty conservative overall he's spoken publicly many times about his property about trying to make it a little bit easier within recent yeah to do things like tiny houses right exactly more kind of starter homes because that's a that's something that's generally not available in town now right I 've had conversations with people like just Recently at the polls and elsewhere these are people who don't necessarily come to the town that come to our meetings during the week, or we don't, they're not necessarily emailing us, but there are a lot of these kind of anecdotal stories about people's kids who can't, who are now out of college and they can't find a place on a stake, but they can't come back. And it ties into the generational thing that Jean Marie was talking about. That's something where this is getting beyond the scope of the immediate topic, but it is something we have to really- [1:07:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Partner rentals are beyond, I mean, just ridiculous. [1:07:35] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I think, Corey, I've had the same scenario, but flip-flopped is people our age wanting to move into a smaller cottage or something on the property and having their kids in the bigger house with their brains. So it's sort of the same thing. And I've had people say to me, I'd love to downsize, but I can't afford to downsize unless I could get my kids to do the reverse. Right. I think that's the trend that's going to hit in the next decade so yes that's another point [1:08:06] Speaker B (unidentified): as us boomers are making our way in reverse yeah exactly i think the american dream of homeownership is probably not the american dream for like my 14th oh i know it's not oh it's not i almost think that 's okay that's okay we should probably to you know start planning on how to divide your house up into four different units. Exactly. I couldn't have my daughter have my house [1:08:33] Speaker A (unidentified): And you live in an ADU because, well, I can now because I finally get real soils testing done, but it costs money to do that too. And you know, a preliminary thing could have shown if I weren't under the Scarborough whatever, I would have been fine. Yeah, but I had to pay all this extra money. [1:08:54] Speaker G (unidentified): You know, blah, that's part of what 1829 2173 is intended to do. Yeah, that's that was kind of the that was the good intent behind it, right. So part of the challenge, right, for this group and for the town and municipalities in general is to try to try to manage that and share that in a way that still allows for some. Yeah, so I think it's [1:09:20] Speaker C (unidentified): like encourage the good and sort of yes try to mitigate what we don't want, like the downs is [1:09:26] Speaker B (unidentified): supposed to be a really good example of you're supposed to be able to have multi-generation. Yeah, you have home ownership, you have condos, you have senior, you have the minute of memory, right, basic services and things like that. And it's unfortunate that it has like this sometimes negative connotation because that is kind of that's where my child is going to want to live somewhere like. Yeah, she actually wants to live in New York because she's crazy. She you know that little idea having something that you're not having to rely on a vehicle, being able to you know have that neighborhood sort of feel. Yeah, so it's it was it's like what the state did, they did this it did this weird mandate of giving us production building lots. Yeah, that's bad. Yeah, that's a bad thing, but they didn't with the idea that they were going to create these unique. So it's really I guess up to the cities and towns to kind of understand. Yeah, that is they want that to work out, so it's not all it's not all bad. No, but it is definitely tough, and it's also change is hard for people, and the idea of having you know densification and things like that happening in areas for the greater good, it's hard for people to swallow. Like Dunstan, you know, really should be this very vibrant engaging sort of beautiful walkable. Oh yeah, there should be this really nice, you should know you're there and you get there, it should really feel special. So there's tons of potential, but change is hard. Yeah, and so some of that change would be you know traffic patterns. Yeah, and yeah, I mean you [1:11:23] Speaker C (unidentified): know there's absolutely walkability, and I think people feel unsafe walking there because of [1:11:29] Speaker A (unidentified): But we're one of those kind of problems. Dangerous. [1:11:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, we. Well, that's your one-on-one talk. [1:11:37] Speaker A (unidentified): One-on-fourteen that I look on as a super-high right now. [1:11:40] Speaker B (unidentified): We talked a lot about traffic calming, and I always find it's funny because I feel like we're trying to solve the problem of the speeder, and we're never going to solve that problem, right? Like, sometimes places become walkable because people are walking. Yeah. And sometimes people have to... You have to make change to get change. Like... Yeah. I'm putting your body out there in front of a moving car right yeah there's something else [1:12:05] Speaker G (unidentified): There are I'm going to say I think it's somewhat similar to transit with the bus and spend like you know you have to there's a little bit of like learning curve yeah it seemed like a weird way to put it but like kind of fake until you make it like you know exactly people have to see people doing it yeah and then kind of that might take a little while to remove the needle to where the except the buses and other nice that people think of as a viable a viable alternative I mean you obviously have To create the physical space and so that it's except some baseline of safety the [1:12:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Big issue with you know the thing that we were proposed that dot was proposing over the Marsh was why don't they just use the Eastern Trail why are they trying to use one is for cars. Who said we'd want to use? Oh, a lot of complaints about the D. O. T. [1:12:55] Speaker G (unidentified): That was particularly close to one lane. Right. But it was. Yeah. But the pushback [1:13:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Was significant saying, we'll just use Eastern Trail. Why are you trying to leave a car? Why are you walking? Pedestrian or bike? I'm 71 years old and I can't walk very well. I mean, that's not me personally, but you know what I'm saying? Yeah. I think part [1:13:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Part of the two at the time courses they were still looking for you know part of a million dollars to complete the Eastern Trail that wasn't budgeted and the Eastern Trail is awesome so like we finally have this done and we haven't even finished paying for it now we're like trying [1:13:33] Speaker A (unidentified): To do this well except the Eastern Trail is a very different oh yeah I know I have then when you're you know if you're trying to get down to work well to work yeah or you know down to the Dunston area to go on the vine or something, I mean, you're a significant distance from Eastern Trail. And like you get in a car, if I was facing that, I'd get in a car to go down there rather than taking my bike because I'm taking my life in my hands. So yeah, I mean, you're still dealing with the poor. I can't, and I live on the second star road. I take my life in my hands to walk from my house to the new road yeah so I can walk in the neighborhood back there I don't again this is just this whole side star what is it one of the issues that we're looking at is do we need to widen the shoulders on all these highways there's no place to [1:14:31] Speaker C (unidentified): widen it 114 but for example or I live up one exact and I used to jog on there all the time when I first moved there 30 years ago I am tear I literally crawl down that road now it's because people like with baby carriages or walking their dogs are literally taking their life there is no shoulder action there is one and there's nowhere to go because right you go from there to wetlands or into the Mars so you just can't yeah so that's part of the issue is the [1:14:58] Speaker A (unidentified): constraints are real but I think all of that has to be taken into consideration in terms of the enemy absolutely yeah if you if you can't provide some of that then you have to look at what the other inputs are which is going to be traffic because if you aren't you aren't able to walk it or bike it or use a transit you're going to get in a car and most cars in Scarborough have one person I'm horrible yeah because my job too yeah I drive that's part of my job I had a drive to be in and there's always gonna they're always going to be those folks but they're gonna be folks in your time by the retirement community they'll get in a car to drive someplace because well because they can't bike so they can't bike and they can't walk right so they're going to drive a car well if they can't walk I would be seriously considering whether they ought to be behind the wheel but that's well you know what I'm no but I'm just saying their partner may be able to drive you know but they better drive the person who can't walk anyway that being said it's yeah it's it's interesting because and I'm just gonna put this out here because I will do it all the time in my elected job which is oh we need to build you know the bike trails and this and that and I like and I think of my constituents who live in Baldwin and Standage and Sub-Ago who come into Portland and they are not going to park their car to get into something to drive on a bike on a bike trail or take a bus or whatever. So what are we going to do about that? I mean, I'm really upset that the connector got shot down. Now, it hasn't gone away, I'll tell you that right now. Yeah, I know. It's coming back. This is 3,000 building permits in Gorham right now, and there's 800 in Standish. [1:17:03] Speaker F (unidentified): So well, what's going to really be interesting is how we regulate e-bikes. And oh, jeez, that's, I mean, that's, well, that's okay. [1:17:18] Speaker A (unidentified): So you can share off the breaks. I know we're gonna go. I got it. [1:17:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, okay. So next time we're gonna bring you this and we're gonna, I'm gonna put it on the floor for you guys to make a recommendation. Yeah, that's a lot of excellent. Thank you. So let's move on to committee and staff updates. Instance, so we have, I'll start, council last week approved the data center, yeah, ban, and then we also made some updates to our site plan ordinance and tree clearing rules. So now we had a 20 foot minimum streetscape requirement, and then a little bit, we went from one tree for 30 feet to one tree per 20 feet, and we are preserving 24 inch, yeah, trees, so really big trees, I want [1:18:06] Speaker C (unidentified): Your preference, I'm like, I need a visual, and you're like, well, that would be this [1:18:10] Speaker B (unidentified): And there were no trees on this municipal campus that will be preserved [1:18:22] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, so based on our, did you measure the term breast type? [1:18:29] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, okay, good. There's some good changes in there. I don't think there's gonna be a lot of trees preserved, and fully honest with that 24 inch. But there will be some preservation of existing streetscape, yeah, oh good, that sounds good, and planning board, I'll, we have a really short agenda for Sunday, we're going through the advisory opinions for the schools, and so we're doing all the blue points, yeah, and we've got a [1:19:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Conservation subject on Spur Pink, we still have more conservation, yeah, I hope so, because that's [1:19:13] Speaker A (unidentified): What I want to do with Miles, well, in terms of transportation, our next meeting will be a meeting with DOT, we're supposed to have it this past month, but it's been moved to again talk about the West Scarborough study, and we're reviewing our questions of the study, because we had some concerns, for instance, is the purpose for safety or congestion or both, well, but that, a lot of these weren't addressed in the study itself, and roundabouts, could we start with one lane rather than two lanes in terms of Addressing some of this stuff, but again, pushing back on some of the study that says, okay, we're talking about a whole lot of money. Yeah, that's the only saving grace. Is there a way to back out of some of this and go for very targeted places where we're experiencing a lot of congestion that addresses particularly safety issues? Issues and so like in front of my house we've got, yeah, we've got a meeting with the OT for our [1:20:22] Speaker F (unidentified): next transfer to talk about that. Yeah, bottlenecking on Payne Road where the water is, can't get another lane in there. Oh yeah, he's a killer. Yeah, something's got to be done with that crossing. [1:20:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, there's no money. What you're saying, there's no money. DOT has absolutely no money, which I'm like for some things that they've been talking about, which reminds me, because Ed asked me where did you go? No, we just painted. Anyway, I've noticed there's some lines painted on, well, painted, or I don't know if they're counts or whatever. It's on Gorham Road and Payne Road and it's [1:21:07] Speaker B (unidentified): DOT or Elastangelo. I think they are doing some sort of counts. Yeah, I think they are. [1:21:14] Speaker A (unidentified): And up on County Road they are. They just showed up like, this morning I'm driving, and I'm going what the hell is this now. They're probably part of this study, I'm sure it is. It's been asking is there a volume, regular volume, or is it just timed congestion? They need to remove all the studies from 30 freaking god damn years ago, hasn't changed. I know I'm on camera, and actually from 30 years ago, 20 years, the volumes have gone down. Yes or no? The congestion, the congestion has gone up because it's very time sensitive. Exactly, yeah. Rather than talking about exactly what times they want to have the volumes have gone down, which may speak to the transition to more retirees, because they aren't on the road quite as much, but they are a very particular time. So well, no, this is, these are commute terms that I can't get out of my where I live. Yeah, it's the traditional, I call traditional community, but I'm saying you've got a lot of retirees rather than families, so you've got your volumes that are down. That doesn't mean that, oh yeah, I see what you're saying. Yeah, yep, except we got a lot of young people who live west, that's where they're living, and they're coming in. So there you go, that's transportation. Anything else? [1:22:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Well council, we've got three new members who can get sworn in on Wednesday night. It's a good group, and then as alluded to, we're already having conversations about many liaison assignments, and our goal is to be able to get those finalized and approved by the council in early December so that they can meet in those groups, can meet in December, and these conversations that are fortuitous and timely given that we're going to be kind of ramping all that up and doing goal setting in January. What [1:23:22] Speaker C (unidentified): he said, that's what I'm [1:23:26] Speaker G (unidentified): like, that's what's going on, and we and of course we do have one of the new counselors is North [1:23:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Scarborough, so I know, thank God. Yeah, actually she's from Worcester. There's a difference into that. Would you people start getting less of the turnpike? Okay, that's better. Yes, correct, yes. [1:23:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Because I've moved to adjourn. I think that's a great thing. It's 9:30 exactly. I can't see that. All right, and we'll be, see you guys on December 11th, one, so happy Thanksgiving. Thank you. Yes, thank you. Thank you. Did you, did you get accomplished [1:24:11] Speaker D (unidentified): what you needed to from us today, Autumn? Oh yeah, okay, thanks. Yes, we're good. Give me your math. [1:24:20] Speaker F (unidentified): I didn't make any, I just put it down, my alliance.