← Back to MaineScanner

Auburn council reviews draft comprehensive plan, debates AG zone housing rules

2026-11-09 · 1h 0m · Source: City of Auburn, Maine, City Council Special Workshop, November 9, 2026 (City of Auburn / Great Falls TV (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:12] Council Chair: November 9th, 2026, Auburn City Council Special Workshop will be called to order. The single item on the agenda tonight, that's a review of the draft 2026 comprehensive plan. Provide a bit of summary for the council and for those that may be watching from home. How we got to this point in the process, what's in the packet, and what's for the count. Evening, so council will recall that almost two years ago a Comprehensive plan committee was formed for the purpose of reviewing the comprehensive plan and updating it from the 2010 version. We had a 20, the last full version was in 2010, and we had some chapter changes in 2021. The state statute envisions your comprehensive plan being reviewed on about a 10-year cycle, so the comp plan committee. THE COMMITTEE WORKED FOR ABOUT 18 MONTHS ON THE COMP PLAN, THERE WERE NUMEROUS PUBLIC INPUT SESSIONS, AND THIS FALL THE COMP PLAN COMMITTEE ADOPTED A DRAFT COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. THAT PLAN WAS POSTED PURSUANT TO STATE STATUTE FOR A 30-DAY PERIOD, AND THE COMP PLAN COMMITTEE and the planning board held a joint public hearing during that time period. The planning board was reviewing the comprehensive plan that had been a draft that had been adopted by the comp plan committee, and they made a number of recommendations to the City Council. SUBSEQUENT TO THAT, LAST WEEK, THE COMP PLAN COMMITTEE RECONVENED, THEY REVIEWED THE COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC HEARING AND THE RECOMMENDATIONS THAT THE PLANNING BOARD WAS MAKING TO THE COUNCIL, AND THEY MADE, BASED ON THAT, SOME ADJUSTMENTS TO THE DRAFT COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. So what's in your packet tonight is three pieces of information. So the comp plan committee's red line comprehensive plan begins on page two. That is the draft comp plan that they earlier adopted and any changes that they are recommending to the council along with some non-substantive grammatical changes and punctuation changes that the staff has made to that document. In addition to that, starting on page 497 of the packet, the planning board recommendations, and starting on page 510 is the summary of the comments from the public hearing. You'll see that there are direct comments from the public hearing, and then there are some documents that were submitted. During the public hearing process, staff had a portal open to allow written comments to be submitted so they are in the packet it with the comments from the public hearing when people testify. So the way that will proceed is that we the document we're going to work off is starting on page two, which is the red line comprehensive plan. We're in we're in a workshop format, so counselors have questions or thoughts about the plan either from their review of the original document, from the comments that were received through public hearing, or the planning board recommendations. We can raise those in the context of the red line comp plan version. Based on the outcome of the workshop, the draft comp plan will be before the council on December 7th for first reading. So with that, we'll open it up to the council and see if there's any questions or thoughts that members of the council have about a comprehensive plan. Counselor in are you [6:13] Councilor Walker: surprised? So what I'd like to bring forward is something that council of Walker and I have been working on together. It's regarding the existing undersized lots that are in the AG zone. We understand the restrictions for the AG zone. We understand that there's protecting the agricultural and natural resources and the rural character. That's all very important, and we don't want to weaken those protections. However, there are legally established parcels within the district that are smaller than the 10 acre minimum, and under our existing ordinance, owners of those undersized lots can get can seek approval for a single-family home, but they're required to demonstrate legitimate farming or agricultural or recreational or natural resource use. Council Walker and I both believe that requirement places an unnecessary burden on people who simply want to build a home on land they already own. Not everyone wants to farm or establish any other quality qualifying use, nor do they have maybe the time or the funds to do so on. What we're proposing possibly is to have a conversation about a limited exception that would allow one single family dwelling on a qualifying lot that was legally established that is now considered under undersized without the additional requirements of agricultural use. We're not asking to open up the ag district to any broader development. The properties would remain in the ag district. No additional subdivisions would be permitted under this, and all existing septic access setback watershed environmental protections would still apply I got some preliminary and information from Phil that identified about six hundred and thirty parcels under the ten acres that doesn't mean that there'd be six hundred and thirty potential homes that could be built it just means that landowners would still have to demonstrate that parcel so buildability buildable that it's buildable to other aspects like we mentioned before we recognize that the residential restrictions in this district go back many years, and we're not necessarily trying to restore building rights that were taken away. It's about looking at whether our current requirements of the 10 acre minimum makes sense in this particular existing property. Currently we believe that we can recognize the interests of these land owners while continue to protect the agricultural and natural resources in the district. With a comprehensive plan before us, we think it's an appropriate time to have this conversation. Councilor Walker and I are not asking for an ordinance change tonight, or asking whether there's enough general support amongst the council to explore this limited exception and to have staff and legal work through what would be needed to make it possible. I did, I asked for a little bit of guidance on which, how to do this, and I believe that this is where we landed, was to bring it up here. So we'd like to hear whether any of our fellow counselors are open to exploring this exception. We're not asking anybody to commit to anything tonight. Only if there's enough interest to have staff and legal look at what's possible. [9:48] Council Chair: I'm going to go ahead and ask for a motion to approve it. Comments from the council? Add [9:54] Councilor Randall: more to it if I possibly could. So I think we, under, some people may not understand exactly what is out there for the protection zone. Under one acre, there's 106 six lots that are under the one acre. Under the five acres there are about 150 lots, and under the 10 acres is about 113. My number comes up roughly 350 plus lots that protection out there, of course, is so that we can't be building, you know, many homes or a lot of homes all at one time. In the last few years that have been very few homes built, permits given to build homes I should say. Before that, going back, and I've been around for quite a while living in that AG zone, before that there was many times there was 50 homes built in a 10-year period or so, but that is really dropped off in the last few years because of the Restrictions that we have in the AG resource protection district, but I think one of the things that I look at is we are really, when it comes to municipal taxes in the city of Auburn, we holding back from the taxpayers of this city some was around three hundred and twenty-seven thousand dollars on an annual tax revenue that this city could be collected if we only allowed 100 lots to be built at the tax rate that we're taxing people today and what the cost would be to build the home most homes Average pretty close to the 300 000 mark. Personally I would think that the ag zone would be a good area to think about some tiny homes maybe at that point they'd be only valued at 150 000 which would of course take away from that number but I really believe we have restricted this zone to the point where we're not allowing people to have electricity where electricity may be needed. I can't quite understand that happening but if you want to build a shed that's bigger than 10 by 10 you must come To this city and if you're in the AG zone they may tell you can't because you're not farming and I'm sure that's what's going to happen if you wanted to build a small workshop being a person that works with wood and stuff you would be told no you can't do that either. The ag zone has really become something that we have pretty well locked it up so that most people have no rights to the ag zone whatsoever and then at the last minute I was talking with somebody about our ag zone that's in place Right now deep into our ag zone so that this doesn't get forgotten if you own land in the ag zone that's more than 10 acres and you've been farming and all the ones there under the new rule that I think we passed the last time we went through all of this protection on these districts it says if you don't farm any longer or if by some chance I believe the wording is really unclear to me at this point but I'd like someone as this council to look back at it says that if we can't farm our farmland Any longer that the city actually has the privilege to ask us to leave our farmland or to give it up or to sell it and I'm not I'm trying not to say it in a bad way but I believe the city can force you to actually do this under the new rules that are that were accepted a few years back so I'd like the mayor the city manager and whoever to see if that actually words it that way or am I incorrect and if I am I'm sorry I brought it up this way but I think it states very clearly that if we can't Farm it any longer that we could be asked to leave our land. That would hurt us in a lot of ways, especially if you're in, we'll say, late 50s, early 60s. You want to go to the bank and say you'd like to borrow $100,000 to do whatever and whatever. With that in there, and if I'm correct, no bank is going to lend you any money knowing that you're up in that age and you're asking to borrow that kind of money, and you can be asked to leave your land if you was to fall sick and couldn't farm any longer so again I'm asking that the people above me that know what 's really going on with these rules and regulations is that stated in that way and if it isn't please clarify it so that I can say that I'm sorry I brought it up but as far as protecting the egg zone and you know the protection, so it's too strong, the rules are too strong. We need to come up with some special exemption or something so people can build on land that's under the 10 acres, and when you start getting down to the five, four, three, two, one, there is no way that you can farm that small amount of land, and you should at least be able to build a house on it. And we all know there is no dead-end roads in Auburn that we don't have a bus at least go to the end of it or the fire department or the police department or the 911 emergency. They all travel these roads and they've been doing it for years. There's no reason to say that you can't build a house. Further [16:05] Council Chair: comments by the council. [16:10] Councilor Carson: calum appreciate the comments councillor walker i just want to clarify so i'm making i want to ensure that i'm understanding your comments correctly it sounds like you're asking for something beyond what council randall was proposing in addition to us thinking about that is that correct yes [16:35] Councilor Randall: I guess yes, and I'm a hundred percent with Rachel, Councillor Rachel. Other [16:44] Council Chair: comments from the council so make a few comments here first to address the question posed by council Walker about occupancy permits So, in 2023, when the last substantive change was made to the AGRP ordinance, there was a lengthy discussion by the council at that time regarding the issuance of building permits in the AGRP zone if someone was engaged in a bona fide activity is listed in the ordinance and then as soon as they built their house stop the council at that time the Planning Board Actually, and the council at that time came up with this construct that's in the ordinance today that says that, in a fact, these occupancy permits for the land and the use are conditional upon that continued use, and the occupancy permit can be removed if the person doesn't continue in the bonified activity. At the time, the advocates for the AGRP zone pointed out repeatedly that was problematic, that some changes to that should be made, and the council decided not to make any changes and proceeded. I think everybody recognizes the situation that they want to prohibit somebody as a subterfuge from claiming they're going to engage in a bona fide activity, building the residence that's accessory to the bona fide activity, and then stop doing it, but there are going to be circumstances say by age or disability that seem like reasonable reasons why the person would no longer engage in the activity having recognized that for some time now a proposed ordinance to modify the AGRP zone to take Into account age and disability for these circumstances and I would point out these are only new construction. Everyone that lived in the AGRP zone prior to the 2023 passage of the ordinance, this doesn't apply to right so this certainly is not an emergency at this time because the few new constructions that have been we haven't reached that issue so staff has reviewed a proposal related to this it's sitting at legal as all the counselors know what's it legal is kind of a rolling list depending on what's the biggest priority at the moment but in the not-too-distant future there will be a item an order An ordinance change in front of the council to deal with the issue related to new construction that council Walker has pointed out before I make other comments about council Randall's proposal any other comments or thoughts from the council so [20:53] Staff Member: Counselor Walker asked about electrical services so it can only be approved for a lawful use or accessory use a structure on the property so if the electrical service may support a principal agricultural natural use natural resource use or a principal lawful principal recreational use then it will be permitted but it must meet that the same language that's currently then ordinance as it pertains to for a bona fide farm or record further [21:34] Council Chair: Questions on that, so just as a bit of background, so I think it's important that everybody understands that the House or the Comp Plan Committee got to the point where we are today with what's in the Comp Plan relative to the low growth zone and those areas in the low growth zone that have more restrictive characteristics, sticks related to housing. So the first thing that happened was the recognition that there needs to be a differentiation in what used to be the AGRP zone from things related to drinking water protection, which is the boundaries of which in the plan before you is the watershed and the rest of the AGRP zone. I think everyone on the Comp Plan Committee recognized that the current policy that's in the ordinance was a compromise that came about after a number of years and lots of discussion, and the outcome of that compromise was a removal of the income standard that had been in place since 1960 and a somewhat relaxation of the requirements in the AGRP zone, although they are still more restrictive than in other zones. We should be clear that since 1960 the primary purpose of this zone HASN'T BEEN RELATED TO THE PROMOTION OF AGRICULTURE OR RECREATIONAL USES. IT'S PRIMARILY BEEN AN ANTI-SPRAWL MEASURE AND THE CURRENT ORDINANCE STILL READS IN PART PRIMARILY BECAUSE THESE AREAS ARE SO REMOTE FROM EXISTING CENTERS OF DEVELOPMENT THAT ANY ADDED UNCONTROLLED GROWTH COULD RESULT IN AN ECONOMIC BURDEN ON THE CITY AND ITS INHABITANTS. In 2023, when there was lots of discussion about this and the Council changed the policy in the AGRP zone, the Sustainability and Natural Resources Board brought in sites to about 100 studies relative to the impact of development in rural areas outside of the city core. The staff at that time, looking at the proposed development, their estimation was that for every dollar of new property tax we brought in, it would cost $1.85 in services. So, this is still, I think, fair to say, from the Comprehensive Plan Committee's perspective, an anti-sprawl ordinance. The whole basis of the Future Land Use Map is to work from the core out. I think that in the course of this, that was a primary driver from the Comprehensive Plan committee. And even though what's currently in the AGRP zone has been lightly diminished because other areas have that were previously AGRP are now in the growth zone, or they're in the moderate grown zone, they, the decision that the comp plan committee came to was to continue this as anti sprawl. This has also been looked at by the Ag and Natural Products Resource Board working group and the conservation working group, which did not recommend the change to this. It's been looked at by the Planning Board that did not recommend the change to this, and again by the comp plan committee. So I understand the concern that there are some people that are not satisfied with the restrictions have been in place for the last 65 plus years and we like to build on these lots. There's lots of people, when you engage in zoning, they don't necessarily agree with zoning decisions throughout the city relative to individual parcels that they own. The purpose of the zoning isn't to respond to each individual person, it's map out the future land use for the greatest benefit of the community. So I, so I think that the current construct in the comp plan that's before us is well thought out. It certainly takes into account the issues related to sprawl. It doesn't diminish the 39 current uses that are allowed in the AG zone, and it seems like that is a prudent policy to continue with. And the last thing I would say that is that as a matter of equity, if the council were to say that certain individuals can build on their half-acre law, one of the gentlemen that came before the Comp Plan Committee a couple times has a half acre lot, and he wants to build on the half acre lot. As a matter of equity, how do you say to that person, yes, you can build, and say to other people, you can't build on half acre lot, because there's nothing at all to prevent someone from subdividing land that they own and selling off pieces of land. So if we set a policy that says if you own a piece of land that you can build a residential structure on it, 's not going to be one or two or three or ten, it's going to be hundreds and hundreds, and we'll have a very serious problem with burdening taxpayers throughout the city with substantially increased property taxes to subsidize the developers that want to develop those laws. And any other comments on this issue from the council Randall [29:02] Councilor Walker: So I bring it up as a conversation to have and for and to ask staff and legal to see how it would work, not to actually change the ordinance. If they came back to us and said this would work if we wrote it very specifically, very narrowly, that say over one acre up to the 10 acres, okay, if you have an undersized lot and you can meet all the other criteria, you can build one, you can build one family unit. I feel I believe it is unnecessarily restrictive for the landowners. They can't sell their land to someone because who wants to buy a piece of land that they can't build on, and they can't retire and go to a smaller home on their smaller lot because they want us an easier life, because now they have to stay in their big house on their big land and do all the stuff that they didn't want to do because we're not allowing them their property owner rights to build on their property. [30:03] Council Chair: Well, relative to the retirement issue, it's a misnomer to believe that you can somehow limit construction on current lots, or if we make a change to one structure. The state law prohibits that. There's nothing to stop someone who owns a lot today from building an ADU, either attached or unattached, in the lag zone. The state law prohibits you from stopping someone from building an ADU. So if there's people—one of the issues that we heard during the public comments was, well, what if somebody has a farm, they've been farming, they get older, their family wants to take over the farm but they want to fill the house to live on the property, they can do that today. There's no prohibition on that. In fact, the city can't prohibit that because it'd be a violation of state law, council. [31:11] Councilor Carson: Council, the other thing that you know we work many hours and identify two hard, you know, high density growth zones, one's in the southern part of the city, which potentially the thought being that over time there could be more growth around that area. So I think I think looking out past 10 years, you know, that we did expand the growth zones in, you know, we do taking converting some mag zone parcels acreage into other land use categories because it made sense where we are going to try to expand those. Things out, we were trying to be very careful, and we did get a lot of feedback from residents who provided feedback that they really didn't want these pockets of what seemed to me like spot zoning if we did this, potentially, of houses all over the outside of the growth zones, because it does, you know, we're trying to coordinate resources. I'm I am concerned, you know, the studies are there. You start putting those houses out there, 's a potential we're putting more money for every dollar we gain Towards resources. If things are built too far outside of the zone, does that mean we have to think about additional fire resources and in areas that we don't have them existing right now? So I think there's there's just a lot more to it, and a lot of that is was already evaluated, reviewed, researched, considered, debated, voted on by the comp plan. My [33:02] Councilor Walker: Question now is, what's the point of having this workshop if we're going to bring things up and they're just going to get pushed down saying that these decisions have already been made? Why bother to talk about it? Well, [33:16] Council Chair: You, I think that this is like every other workshop, right? Councils can raise issues. You and council Walker have raised an issue. There's a discussion being had about this. The question is that it's before the council, is the consensus of the council to modify the plan. We would not necessarily need the exact language tonight, but as I understand what you and councillor Walker are suggesting is that on these smaller lot that residential construction be allowed without any need for it to be accessory To a bona fide activity, and I think what I think what councillor Cowan is pointing out is that a number of bodies in this process have spent many hours discussing this. They did not come to that conclusion. Happy to have the discussion. If the consensus of the council is to change that, 's the change that will be made in the draft for first reading. If it isn't, then counselors certainly have an opportunity at first reading to move for an amendment. Council dual, yeah, I 'm not going to repeat what the Comp plan [34:43] Councilor: Committee did. We did a lot of work. One thing though is I don't understand what the proposal is here vis-a-vis changing the language in the comp plan. Right, now this sounds like ordinance to me rather than a suggested change to the comp plan, so I don't even know what sort of discussion we would actually have. [35:07] Councilor Walker: The discussion that we're asking to have is to have staff and legal see if this is even something that would work and then present to us what it would look like if we did decide to go down the avenue of an ordinance change. So it's not, it's not committing to an ordinance change and it's not committing to even being open to an ordinance change. It's just being open to seeing what staff could do. Is there something we could do that could accommodate these landowners? [35:39] Councilor Randall: Council walk, thank you. I'm not quite understanding when you say the ADU, anyone could build an ADU. Does that mean if we own one, say yourself or myself here in the city, but we have a piece of land that's in the AG zone somewhere, we could build an ADU that way? No, it's by parcel, so it would have to be, you got a house on that piece of property now, you can add. Correct. Could I ask the manager to explain the electricity one more time to me, what it is as we can or can't, or why we can't get electricity? [36:22] Staff Member: Sure. So the current, when we had staff look into this based on the questions that were related to the 499 Henley Corner Road on whether or not an individual could gain a electrical permit, or I think this individual was looking to stay on the property. It was not an approved or a lawful use access on that property. So the electrical permit would have been, and I apologize, I'm not sure if it actually was submitted or not, I don't believe it was, but it was at least advised that if the permit had been submitted that it would have been denied because it's not an approved lawful use or a lawful accessory structure for electrical services on that parcel. And this would be the same throughout. If it's not meeting the qualified lawful use on that parcel, then electrical permit would not. All right, thank you for [37:46] Councilor Randall: that. But I'd like to just ask this question. If I, if I choose that I want to go to that lot a hundred times a year and if I choose that I wanted to spend the money to drill a well, why wouldn't I be given the okay to have power brought in so I could at least use my well? [38:10] Council Chair: But if I might give a couple examples, I don't know about the well, I think that's going to get a little tricky because the question is what's the well servicing. But if I could give a couple examples, in the AG zone today, if you have a vacant parcel and you put a cell tower or some type of a communications tower on it, which is an allowable use, and you come to the city and you ask for permission for the power connection, they'll authorize CMP to connect it. If you're in the AG zone and you're growing vegetables and you build a barn, you can get permission to have power go to your barn. Right, so the way this came up before was an individual had a lot who was illegally living on the lot, using a generator for his power, and tried to get CMP to connect power to his trailer, his mobile home, and CMP could not do that because the city would not provide permission for CMP because what was happening on that lot was not a permitted use in that zone. So there's nothing that generally prohibits electrical service being provided to lot in the AGRP zone. As the managers pointed out, the electrical service has to be supporting something that's an actual permitted use in that zone. I'm not, does that help, Council Walker, further comments or questions? [40:09] Councilor Walker: councilor ann i guess just before we move on i mean do i'd hate to have a good conversation and then just walk away and have it never come back is there enough support to see if this is even worth exploring i guess before we move on i'd like to know if we have enough of that support [40:26] Council Chair: Sure, so let me, perhaps I can help frame this out. If counselors go to page 46 of your document, as was pointed out, this, we're not really having a zoning discussion, right, because the comp plan doesn't set district zoning regulations. What we're really talking about is the land use characteristics and what is in the draft comp plan today in the AGRP, we don't call it AGRP, that's a density. This is in the low density area for agricultural, forest, recreation, and open space, the land use characteristic and The land use says typical uses include agricultural activities and associated businesses, or sea and resource management, and passive and active outdoor recreation. Residential uses are allowed but are accessory to bona fide farming, agricultural operations, recreational uses, or natural resource uses, and that language aligns with the change it was made in 2023 as a compromise to removing the income standard. And so I think the counselor Randall's point, this is where the change would be, and I think what's being suggested is that this sentence about residential uses would be modified to allow residential uses that are not accessory to a bona fide use with some either on all lots, or I think it's on all lots, because I don't think what you're suggesting is, I'll just make an illustrative example, you can do it on five acres or less but not between five and ten, or even on a ten acre lot, or if I have a 200 acre lot, I'm assuming what you're proposing is I can still build a structure on. Okay, so I think this is, that's the question before the council, which is what's the council's thought on modifying the land use characteristics for this agricultural, forestry, recreation, and open space area to allow a residential construction that's not accessory to a bona fide use in that area, and as we've done before, we can take a straw poll here by show of hand and council random. So I don't know as [43:17] Councilor Walker: though we would be raising our hands to change this language today. What we're asking is to have legal and staff work through it to see if it is something that we want to do, is it worthwhile, what are the options, what is actually possible, what could we help, what could we do to help these individuals. Yes, so I [43:37] Council Chair: don't, I don't think that's the question at the moment. The question before the council is really a broad policy question: do you want to allow this? If the answer from the council is that the majority of the council says yes, we think that the land use characteristics could be changed, then staff will go off and come back based on that with some type of proposal, as has happened all through the comp plan process, to what the comp plan language would need to be modified to effectuate that change. So I think that's the question, is as a matter of policy that the counselors think it should be changed to allow residential construction that's not accessory to a bona fide use. That's the question, and if people are in favor of that and it's the majority of the council, then and we'll have staff work on that. If it isn't, we won't. Councilor Geary. [44:46] Councilor Randall: What about a small bunkhouse with a storage shed so that if you do some farming, you have places for the people that do the picking and the planting and the whatnot, [45:02] Councilor: and then they'll have a place to store their tools and whatever crops. Is that allowed? [45:09] Council Chair: That's currently allowed. So in the ordinance today, there is an exception that allows housing to be built for agricultural workers on the land where the activity is taking place. People probably remember in the past, we used to have transient workers that would come in to pick apples. If you had somebody picking apples and you have an orchard and you come to the city today and you want to do what Councillor Geary just described to provide housing for the agricultural workers, that is already allowed in the ordinance. Other questions? Councillor Duvall. [45:56] Councilor: So I just want to say, from a policy standpoint, I don't support separating, I don't support I don't think we should allow residential uses full stop in the ag zone because then it's no longer the ag zone. It's a completely different thing. [46:21] Council Chair: I agree. [46:23] Councilor Carson: That's where my hesitation comes in. Councilor Randall, I apologize if I made you feel like I cut you off. I have hesitation in what you're proposing. I'm concerned because I think I heard you say that when I first read what you have here as a proposal to be explored you're implying it would be for those small parcels but then when you were asked if someone should be allowed on a 200 acre lot to be able to put a house you said yes is that correct they were already allowed to put one [46:51] Councilor Walker: on a 200 acre house aren't they on a 200 acre lot only if it's accessory to the uses in the ordinance [46:58] Council Chair: right just to be clear so we all have the same information today for new construction The residential construction has to be accessory to a bona fide use, immaterial of what the size is. So if someone has a 200-acre lot and they engage one of the bona fide, there's 39, I think, on the list, 39 or 40 authorized uses. if they are engaged in that and the residential structure is it is accessory to that bona fide use then they could build it but it's all the same they just can't build a residential structure on the lot even if it's 200 acres unless [47:52] Councilor Walker: it's accessory to bona fide so even so 10 acres or more there's they can't can't build a home in the ag zone without these restrictions, even with the 10 acres? Correct. [48:10] Council Chair: Okay. And just for clarification, that's where you get into the sprawl issues, because in 2023, I wasn't on the council, but I was sitting in the audience, and there were many discussions about this, and there were developers that came forward, and people are on the last council remember they came to the council after the 2023 adoption again developers came in and what they wanted to do was subdivide their property into ten acre lot and just have houses and that is part of what's going to lead to the sprawler if there's no other comments. And let's just by show of hands, so we get a sense of where people are, and it's not a binding vote, but so we understand what we're doing with this policy issue in the comp plan. Counselors that are in favor of allowing new residential construction on parcels in the Ag Zone that are not accessory to a bona fide use, who's in favor of that? Yes. Come on yeah and those that are not in favor okay and counselor plats is not here he had plans way before we decided to set this meeting to be out of town just so the council knows he shared that he is at this point not in favor as well of allowing that residential construction although he said that he would watch the meeting and read the materials before this comes back up on the seventh are there other are there other thoughts or questions that the council has about the draft comp plan that's before us nothing else last chance the staff the planning director and our long-range planner are here if people have any questions about what's in there as well you don't have to be suggesting some change but this is an opportunity to ask any questions that people might have about the content of the plan or of the public comments or the planning board recommendations before we get to reading council Duvall you've heard enough from me so I don't I don't have any further comments thank you no other questions or comments council Walker [51:18] Councilor Randall: Yeah I guess my last one would be I'm really not sure that when you're saying that the cost of somebody building out of the city limits I'll put it that way would cost us more money in the long run than what we would benefit from it. I would like somebody to dig up that and show us I can't believe at their costs to build new homes today and the taxes that we would pay on the property as well as the home that is going to cost us more money to have that operation working then than what we would Actually take in the long run, and you know, you might be able to prove that with only building one or two houses, we'll say, on the furthest house away the Thicket Road. But if we built 10 houses on the Thicket Road, there is no way that it would cost us more money for a police car, a fire truck, an ambulance, a bus, whatever else, to run down that road. I just, I don't believe you can show us that this is going to cost more money than what you would take in. So I appreciate the [52:37] Council Chair: comments. Staff will take a note. The SNRB provided the sites to these. I don't know the exact numbers, around 100 studies the last time this came up. I'm sure that we can go back on the record and find those and provide them. I would say as a general matter of tax policy, often residential structures at best break even. There's really typically only a net gain from residential structures if you're close enough to the core and the density is high enough to generate the taxes for the increased services. So I think we've heard that over and over again. We heard that from staff again this time when the comp plan committee discussed this, but we'll, we'll look up the studies that they use the last time this and the manager can circulate those to the council. Account I think it may [53:43] Councilor Carson: also be of use to take a look at the housing study, because you know, when they were looking at the housing needs, the current inventory of homes that we have in Auburn, we have a whole lot more of larger homes that are best used for families, and the need is for smaller homes, older retirees. And so that often could be more beneficial if they're in a more densely dense neighborhood or retirement community or apartments. So I think that would be also be helpful to be looking at as we're thinking about any language or changes we wanted to make in terms of ordinances and in relation to this comp plan, because you know, there was discussions that we had in the comp plan to talk, you know, talking about, well, there may be good policies and approaches vetted elsewhere that we could use to help elderly couples that are in the home, still in the home that they raised their family in, if they had other alternatives, and then we could fill the existing homes for families. We could end up being in a much better financial state from a, from a tax structure. So don't [55:20] Councilor: You do all while we're on the subject of taxes my recollection from a while back when I was on planning board is that this would it that sort of change to the language would actually drastically change the tax burden on the people who currently own land in those areas and a lot of THE FARMERS WERE REALLY CONCERNED THAT IT WOULD ACTUALLY JUST TAX THEM OUT OF THEIR PROPERTY SO IT ALMOST GUARANTEE SPRAWL I DON'T SO CHECKING ON THAT I THINK WOULD BE APPRECIATED BUT THAT 'S MY RECOLLECTION SO I APPRECIATE THAT OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS [56:04] Councilor Walker: FROM THE COUNCIL COUNCILOR RAMON I JUST WANT TO THANK ALL THE FELLOW COUNCILORS FOR LISTENING and having a discussion about what i brought up thank you mr [56:17] Council Chair: manager anything from staff [56:19] Staff Member: no like you said i think the staff was prepared to walk through some of the changes maybe you had already seen the discussions at the last comp plan meeting i appreciate the work that the planning board did to provide further feedback it only strengthens our comp plan I think complaint committee has done a great job of really digging into all of that determining which language could be brought in I think that we have received a very favorable report from the state regarding the first review of the plan staff will be making those modifications they were all non-substantive as far as referencing certain language that's required within a complex so the staff will go through it and make those make those adjustments as well this has been a huge lift for everybody I think we had great citizen involvement when I went back through and was looking at this report and some of the numbers were updated regarding citizen engagement and you're looking at over 2,000 citizens involved in this process, it really demonstrates, even though when we went for public comment, you look at those numbers, you're like, boy, there's only, I don't remember what the number was, it was very few. That's because I think people were deterred, so kudos to the team, we had different staff change out through this Lauren was consistent through the whole thing and so we appreciate her and we certainly appreciate the work from very done that was a great selection that the team had gone through and vetted several different proposals that had come before us but it was clear that Barry Dunn was the right partner and they provided us a great report that we will use I can tell you staff is already Gearing up, my executive teams already gearing up, looking at taking the plan, breaking out now. How does this align with our future budgets, our 10-year CIP plan, and start digging into that? We have meetings that are lined up already to hit the ground running on this, so we look forward to providing you regular updates on now the work. I think Lauren had stated it, now implementation starts, and so here we are. So great work. You'll see this again on December 7th for your first reading, and we appreciate [59:04] Council Chair: everyone's assistance on. I just one final comment, so what will be in front of the council on the 7th is in effect the document that's in the packet tonight. It'll look a little different because this is the word document. If anybody had looked at the comp plan committee's initial draft, looked really nice because it was in a publication format. Staff will work with Barry Dunn and move this into that publication type format, and that's what will be for the council on December 7. Anything else to come before the council? In that case, the council's adjourned.