Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Council President: Okay. All right. It is 6 p.m. and I call this monthly City Council meeting to order. Agenda item number two, the Pledge of Allegiance. I move to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Agenda item number three, Rules of Order. The Council has adopted Robert's Rules of Order and we will proceed through this meeting accordingly. Agenda item number four, adoption of the Ellsworth City Council minutes from the following meeting, October 19th, 2026, regular meeting. So move. Second. Any discussion? All those in favor? Unanimous. Great. Agenda item number five, presentation of awards. We have one gentleman this evening. this is in recognition to Eric McLaughlin in recognition of 20 years of service in the highway department your devotion to duty and loyalty to this community have contributed to the improvement of the city of Ellsworth presented this 16th day of November 2026 and he is not here this evening so [City Manager: All right,] agenda item number six, city manager's report.
[1:37] City Manager: Thank you, Tabitha. I think the biggest thing for notice, I just talked to the clerks and confirmed with legal counsel. I know folks are eagerly awaiting a new council to be seated. It has been noted previously to the press and on our website that we received a recall request, or sorry, a recount request for the city council election. the we were waiting for a bit for the state ballots to return to us the state had taken them from City Hall which is their right to have them for their potential recounts and they've now returned them we were waiting on that to do the recount because the first step of a recount process is actually to unseal those boxes sort through them make sure there's no municipal ballots mixed in with the state ballots so now that we have those back in our possession our city clerks have reached out to the requester of the recount and notified them that we are hoping to have the recount on Monday November 23rd and November 24th reserved as a second day for counting as needed doors will open in this council chambers at 8 a.m. for public inspection of the setup which is our typical process for this and the recount will officially commence at 9 a.m. The website, EllsworthMaine.gov, if you click on the elections tab, it has a lot of great resources and information on how the city conducts recounts. Our clerks are the best in the business at this. We just did one perfectly, I might say. Last fall, we have, it's not just a credit to our clerks and election teams here in City Hall, but also to all the volunteers who put in an incredible amount of work on Election Day, just for this eventuality so that their work of making sure we hold free and fair elections and that the counts can be done by hand if need be are there, are ready to go. So hopefully on Monday, November 23rd, 8 a.m., we will begin the recount. I don't have a time per se for an organizational meeting once the clerks conduct the recount, count potential challenges or not challenges to see if there's a material change in the outcome. But that will be, and it'll just be for the two closest candidates, Tiffany Dilda Gaspar and Robert Grant Sr. For that day, of course, they will review the ballots if there's anything, so it could affect another candidate's vote total. But two of the candidates are well outside the range of being potentially part of an order change in the results so I think that's the most pressing item also want to note just a big shout out to Ray Williams one of our most frequent flyer citizens here that's at every Finance Committee meeting almost oftentimes is there with our clerk's office another is noting to make sure things are properly posted and elsewise you know I know Ray he's a former city councilor as well he's always asking the right questions always you know making sure that the city is on top of its game and even the most minute of details and I was just thinking last week on how lucky we are to have folks like him that are continuing to you know keep Ellsworth city government accountable and really appreciated his input, especially as of lately. And then I think that is it for me tonight. I'll send it over to you all so we can get to the agenda and get forward. Great. Okay. I have a question for the city manager.
[5:20] Council Member: Could you explain to the people of Ellsworth about your recent raise and how you got
[5:28] City Manager: audit without council approval you know if you'd like to have an executive session to discuss employment issues you're welcome to we can go into that but you know as was noted in that meeting i really want myself to play by the same rules that the entire staff plays by we're gonna be talking about executive session for example last year you wanted to give me an $150,000 as my salary and I told the council at that time I thought that was too much you put up a no and it got very strange in here I thought that would be well over 10% for a raise for the city manager I said that would not be fair to my staff who are nowhere near that level we implemented a performance review process that was pretty rigorous that's based on a variety of categories and the staff have now been in that for two separate times and you're scored on I believe seven categories. You set SMART goals, and then you receive a review, typically by one manager, maybe two. In this case, it was an HR committee, and that aligns to a score. We have a certain pot of money for merit pay in the system. I, just like any other staff member who's non-union in the merit pay system, so when all the reviews are finalized, the score that was given to me by council and the HR committee will be blended with the rest of the staff and distribute it appropriately it actually is probably putting the city manager at a disadvantage because they're now not a separate side negotiation with the council they have to play by the same rules everybody else but that's not just important to me personally it's important to the institution I think that the city manager has the same rigorous review process as any staff member but in the future if we can keep personnel conversations to executive session per the Charter thank you and the answer to
[7:21] Council President: my question I think we're gonna keep that to executive session Steve and we
[7:27] Speaker D (unidentified): do have one tonight so we can bring it up then what's wrong with telling the
[7:31] City Manager: citizens of how much I should note also might there's no such thing as how much my raise was right now as I noted Steve I received a score just like all the staff who will also receive a score based on their performance reviews, and then there's a set amount of funding set aside for non-union based on merit, based on the point structure. If my point structure, the score given by the council, is between a 70 to 75, the managers who all scored between 70 and 75 could receive a 2% raise or a 4% raise or a 6% raise. or lower than that they could receive a different block of raises it's just how any other organization treats that piece there's nothing special for the city manager in the in the category and so the answer is right now Steve we don't know because not the rest of the staff has not finalized their reviews and that's the process it's laid out it's actually in a memo provided by the HR director to yourself too might want to read that but that's why thank you all
[8:36] Council President: all right moving on to agenda number seven item number seven the committee reports we have a recreation Commission request to appoint two new
[8:48] Council Member: members do you have any information or just that I've met them at meetings and
[8:58] Council President: I am impressed by them all right it's a request to appoint Zachary at Lanning as a member of the commission with a term expiring 6-30-2027 and Richard Johnson and Danielle I feel like it's is it two members or three members here it is three members okay and Richard Johnson and Danielle Yovanovitch thank you as members with a term expiring 6-30-2028 I believe they submitted interest through to Roddy has that right and yeah any additional information that we have on them do you have anything
[9:49] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: no just to give a little background Roddy Arlenbach parks rec and facilities director just to give some background we had two vacancies moving into July 1st for Eric Marichal who had turned out and then in September Rec Commission member Bill Nelson tendered his resignation so Zack Lanning would be taking on a one year term to fill out the rest of mr. Nelson's term ending 630 2027 and then the two new members that we were lacking with just open vacancies would be Richard Johnson and Danielle Jovanovic with terms expiring in 2028 and all three of them submitted letters of interest through the online platform on reach and those were circulated to the rec commission members in marina i believe back in july or august and it's just been the process of getting recognition together to make a recommendation and now it's in front of you okay thank you do
[10:53] Council President: we need a motion to i'll make the
[10:56] Council Member: motion. Okay. I move to approve Robert Johnson and Richard, Johnson and Danielle, Janovic. Janovic. Janovic. To two-year terms on the Ellsworth Rec Commission and appoint Zach landing to the remainder of the vacant term expiring in June 2027 as recommended by the Ellsworth Rec Commission. Do you have a second? Second. Any discussion? All right. All those in favor?
[11:43] Council President: Unanimous. Wonderful. Any other committee reports?
[11:49] Council Member: I have some. Okay. So, sorry. Okay, so I have, so the REC Commission will be meeting tomorrow at 8.30 a.m. as Thanksgiving is coming up and we want to make sure members can attend. And with my last REC update, I highlighted so many Halloween events, but I'm just going to highlight one event, which is the Ellsworth Parade of Lights, which is December 5th, with the tree lighting immediately after that. An update on the Harbor Commission. The theme for the parade is gingerbread dreams and candy cane wishes. For Harbor Commission, I will point out that there is one more farmers market left just in time for your last-minute Thanksgiving needs. That will let you enjoy local food, enjoy local food with your family. And aside from that, is it. When, what time does the parade start? Oh, I want to say 4? 5.
[13:15] Council President: five p.m. looking forward to it all right any other committee reports okay I have a report from the solid waste committee so on November 4th the solid waste committee met about we're looking at moving our trash and recycling program from Eagle Point which is where we currently bring our trash to the Municipal Waste Hub. Members of the Solid Waste Committee have toured both facilities, and they have favored the hub. The Municipal Waste Hub is a no-sort facility, so that would mean if we decided to go in this direction, residents could keep putting their trash and recycling, or they could put their trash and recycling in the same bag, and the hub does the separating. We currently are... We still have some open questions about costs and the capacity of the hub and also they're looking at doing a food scrap energy system that isn't quite built yet but that would mean additional amount of our waste would be separated into organics there and so we are hoping I just really wanted to bring this in front of everyone because we are hoping to bring this as a formal recommendation to the council in December so I just wanted to let you all know so you if you have any questions you can ask me or anyone in the committee and before that meeting okay agenda item number eight citizen comments so and this part we welcome citizens to provide comments to the council that are related to the city's business we kindly ask that if people would like to speak about any items that are scheduled for a public hearing to wait until those items come up in the agenda. Otherwise, we ask for people to approach the DS and state their names for the record and that you keep your comments two, three minutes or less. So if there's anyone interested in coming to speak. [City Manager: Open public comment.] Open public comment. Do I have to do that?
[15:31] Council Member: Good evening, Councilors. John Linehan, 157 Shore Road in Ellsworth. I want to do a couple things tonight that I think is related to the city's business. First of all, I want to thank people for voting for me and allowing me the privilege of being on the school board. I've had an excellent inauguration period for the first two or three days. I was disappointed that I couldn't be at the first meeting, but I understand with the recount going on what was happening on that. But Paul Mycosian has spent several, I won't say several, but three or four hours with me giving me an introduction, showing me how things operate. He's given me a manual from the state of Maine, so I've been really engrossed in doing all that stuff. I also am concerned about the finances, And so, I've got a copy of the school budget and as I promised, I'm going through it line by line. I started a few days ago like that. And I think the city obviously always has an interest in the finances of school as well. I think I was very excited, I'm sorry about the recount, but I'm very excited that we had a lot of people running for the office today. And whether Tiffany gets elected or Robbie Grant gets elected, I think we've elected one more conservative financial person for the council. and I encourage people to that take a look because November 2027 is right on the road and I would encourage people to get involved I hope the person that does not make it on the on the recount would run again next year because we need conservative fiscal people here on the council so we're headed in the right direction thank you very much and have a good evening all
[17:05] Council President: right seeing none I'm going to close the citizen comments okay moving on to agenda item number nine counselor comments same rules for counselors three minutes and sticking to city business so many counselors that have any comments I'm
[17:30] Council Member: happy to begin in many ways this last year has been a little bit of a baptism by fire but I've learned so much and my core remains the same I remain a compulsive note taker this is my fourth notebook a year and I'm only a year in and these hold everything from Harbor Commission notes to rec library trustee meetings and all of this is another part of Who I am where I am a constant researcher where I always try to look up information to make up the best decision I can in the moment with the information I have. There was an exchange between my brother and I where he also summed up another part of me where I am the person who is most immune to peer pressure that he knows and that I always do things in my own volition, and that core already remains, even if there's times I need to slow down and to make sure I'm saying natural or national, but a few things have changed. I've gotten more confident, and that is in part because of the information and experience I have gained. The budget cycle was enlightening, seeing how all these cogs are connected. Skills have been polished. I'm a lot more comfortable speaking, even though right now my heart is in my throat, but I am so excited for this opportunity. And this year, many of my goals are the same as they were before, which is to cooperate with other counselors to find solutions when we have tough choices ahead, particularly with the infrastructure backlog and rising prices. So I look forward to many thoughtful discussions with the incoming council. MS. Great.
[19:49] Council President: Seeing none, we'll move to agenda item number 10, public hearing and action on the application for renewal for the following licenses, Jeff Kelly Locks, DBA 86 this, 125 Main Street for renewal of a city class B license, Vicular Liquor and Amusement, and renewal of a state restaurant class three and four malt liquor and wine license Ellsworth Suites 147 Foxport Road for renewal of a city lodging license NEH 15 LLC doing business as Comfort Inn 130 High Street for renewal of a city lodging license Tysana 321 High Street for renewal of a class a city class C license avicular and liquor and renewal of a state license class three and four malt liquor and wine license and dice arts service doing business as dice arts Ellsworth car wash 271 high street for renewal of a city class C license vicular and liquor and a state off-premise beer and wine license this is noticed as a public hearing so I'll open this to the public if anyone would like to come up and provide any comment on any applicants they can do so please state your name, come to the DS, and you have a three-minute time limit. And seeing no one, we'll close it. All right. And how would the council like to proceed here?
[21:33] Council Member: Yes. I move to approve business license renewals as presented. All right. Do we have a second? Second.
[21:42] Council President: Excellent. Any discussion? Okay. And it does say that all of their licenses have been paid, inspection is done, and license signed off by all the required departments. So all those in favor? All right, unanimous. Okay, Agenda Item Number 11, Council Order Number 112600, Discussion and Potential Action on the Request of the Police Chief to Reallocate Funds from the Police Forfeiture Account to the Police Training Budget and Acceptance of Forfeiture Monies.
[22:18] Troy Gutierrez, Chief of Police: Good evening. Chief of Police, Troy Gutierrez. So it's kind of like a tiered thing here. So we've had this forfeiture money actually in our account and we've just found research and there needs to be a council approval just to finalize this money. So four of the memos address that money ones for five hundred and sixty six dollars ones for two thousand seven hundred eighty six dollars and twenty nine cents one is for seven thousand two hundred and eight dollars and one is for eight thousand four hundred ninety five dollars these were all funds that were seized in drug trafficking cases by our police department. We have those funds. We just need the sign off from the council.
[23:11] Council President: What are the funds going to?
[23:15] Troy Gutierrez, Chief of Police: So forfeiture money is very, it's put in an account, very specific for what you can use it for. It just can't be spent, so we keep it for when something comes up equipment-wise that we might need or, in this case, some of it that we're gonna ask you to transfer over is for the payment of a new officer that we hired so the last part of this is we hired Ashley Winslow from Lincoln PD she had five years of service and you'll see on that memo there's an attached Academy scale for payback to the sponsor agency at this agency was the Lincoln Police Department, and she falls under the – she was hired in 2021. So we owed Lincoln Police Department $8,607 for her, and we took that money out of our training account to pay for that. So this request, the second part of this request, is to transfer $8,607 from our forfeiture account back into our training account.
[24:27] Council President: Any questions for Troy?
[24:36] Troy Gutierrez, Chief of Police: I'll just say on the forfeiture, I can leave those with you. I just need, there's four forms on there that at some point that you would have to sign off on so we can finalize that. but the transfer is just a I think it's just an approval by the council
[24:57] Council President: okay and I see there's a motion for each of these transfers this is somewhat
[25:07] City Manager: routine we do this every year I apologize for the administrative part of
[25:11] Council President: this but no job so Ebony is second though the packet that came out today has all of them I think the first packet didn't have all of those so does everyone have the motions in front of them new [Council Member: ones I'll] take a motion not
[25:39] Sarah Dellen, Deputy City Manager: all at once I'll take the next motion
[25:48] Council President: it's are we doing one motion we're doing we have to do all of the motions yeah so we're starting with the 15 yeah I believe hope to approve the transfer
[26:01] Council Member: from police department forfeiture account 40-30-10138 account to police training account 10-200-51020 to cover the cost of hiring Officer Winslow.
[26:21] Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director: Second. Any discussion?
[26:25] Council President: All those in favor? Anonymous? All right. Move
[26:33] Council Member: to approve request to transfer the defendants in the case of State of Maine versus Asa J. Polk, pursuant to 15 MRS a section 5 8 2 3 section 3 and section 5 8 2 6 paragraph 8 of the revised means revised statutes to the city of Ellsworth and while the finance director to deposit these monies into the police forfeiture account 4-0-3-0-1-0-3-8 upon receipt of the funds.
[27:26] Council President: Second. Discussion? All those in favor? Unanimous. We've
[27:41] Council Member: got two more to go. Yep. I think I found the next one. I move to approve the request of the transfer of the defendants in REM, in the case of the State of Maine versus, it's not August. Austin. Austin. Thank you. Austin Craig Hamilton, pursuant to 15 MRSA section 5824, parentheses 3, and sections 5826, parentheses 8, of the main revised statues to the city of Ellsworth and to accept the finance director and allow the finance director to deposit these monies into police forfeiture reserve account 40, 30, 1,038 upon receipt of the funds. Second.
[29:07] Council President: Discussion? All those in favor? Unanimous?
[29:11] Council Member: Great. Go to approve the request of the transfer of defendants in REM in case of State of Maine versus Jeffrey S. Card, pursuant to 15 MRSA, Section 5824, Section 3, and Section 58—paragraph 3, excuse me— and Section 5826, Paragraph 8, in the main revised statute in the City of Ellsworth and to allow the finance director to deposit the monies into the police forfeiture account 40-30-1038 upon receipt of funds.
[29:52] Council President: Second. Discussion? All those in favor? Unanimous. I think. One more. One more. Don't move.
[30:08] Council Member: Move to approve the request transfer of the defendants in Ram in the case of State of Maine versus Timothy James Stanley pursuant to 15 MSR MRSA section 5824 paragraph 3 and section 5826 paragraph 8 of the revised state statutes of this to the City of Ellsworth to allow the Finance Director to deposit these monies into the Police Forfeiture Reserve Account fund receipt of the funds.
[30:56] Council President: Second. Discussion? All those in favor? Anonymous. Thank you. Sorry to put you through that.
[31:04] Council Member: No,. Don't worry about it. You brought some money in. thank you thank you yeah
[31:15] Council President: no problem thank you okay moving on to agenda item number 12 council order number 112 601 public hearing and action on amendments to the city of ellsworth code of ordinances chapter 34 personnel ordinance carrie hi good evening carrie taylor hr manager
[31:35] City Manager: So tonight we have some proposed amendments to Chapter 34, which is our personnel ordinance. These are primarily housekeeping changes intended to clarify some of the existing language and make sure the ordinance accurately reflects how we currently administer employee benefits and personnel policies. So the first changes proposed relate to the paid leave. So currently, the paid leave tables list benefits both in hours and days. Since our employees work different schedules, having both listed can create some confusion and is not really applicable. We are proposing to remove the references to days and express paid leave benefits strictly in hours, which is also listed in the ordinance. It has the hours listed and then the days is in parentheses. so we are proposing to remove just the days section and this is currently how and historically how we have always administered and tracked leave is in hours so to just I just want to emphasize that we are not changing the amount of paid leave hours that employees receive the hours and craft cafeteria credits associated with each benefit level will remain exactly the same so that's the first piece do you want me to continue on or allow for questions before I move forward so the second proposed change is to remove there is a section under the health insurance and we're posing to remove the family plan 50% option that's currently listed under level two of the health insurance benefits this is an option that currently no employees are using or enrolled in the language in the ordinance is somewhat confusing so really we're just proposing to remove it to simplify the ordinance because it doesn't currently affect any benefits it's not going to impact any employees current coverage and it would change future insurance options available but this option would make health insurance significantly more expensive than what employees currently pay so based with the cafeteria point system it's just kind of ambiguous the way the language is in there with nobody utilizing it we just thought it might be easier to just remove it any
[34:08] Council President: questions on the health insurance part for Terry great
[34:13] City Manager: and then the final proposed change is just to relating to the tobacco and nicotine products so the ordinance already prohibits tobacco use inside city buildings and vehicles this change would be to clarify the language to specifically include products such as electronic cigarettes vaping devices nicotine pouches and smokeless tobacco the existing provisions for designated out store outdoor smoking areas would remain unchanged. So really just wanted to add some clarifying language to make sure that all tobacco products are encompassed in that. Any
[34:54] Council President: questions there for the tobacco products? Okay, I think this is, there's no questions here. This matter is a public hearing. So I will open this up to the public if they would like to speak on this matter. Again, state your name in three minutes. nobody okay I will close it how would the council like to proceed I
[35:32] Council Member: make the motion move that the City Council approve the proposed amendments to chapter 34 personnel ordinance as presented second
[35:43] Council President: second great any more discussion nothing all right all in favor opposed okay
[35:53] Speaker D (unidentified): that's good them MS. Thank you, Carrie. Okay.
[36:00] Council President: Moving on to Agenda Item Number 13, Council Order Number 112602, Public Hearing and Action on the Request to Reallocate and Repurpose Excess Bond Proceeds to a Roof Replacement and Repair Project for the Parks and Recreation Storage Facility at Pump Station Point.
[36:18] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Rodney. MR. Good evening. Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director. Yep, so pretty much, long story short, we began moving some overflow equipment into the Pump Station Point facility back in the spring, early, spring, late winter, based on the need for additional space at Highway Department and the items that we had stored inside there we did not want to expose to the elements on a long-term basis. so we move some items in there primarily mowing equipment snow removal equipment some hand tools and then as we began moving equipment in there we noticed that sections of the suspended ceiling were coming down due to water penetration and infiltration from the roof we had a couple of projects happening around the city doing some roof repairs one at the police department one at the harbor park and we had a vendor on site on several occasions over the summer and we just asked if they would go and just do an unofficial kind of assessment on where we stood with the integrity of that roof they basically gave us a an informal bid there was nothing presented in paper it was just kind of a verbal like yeah this is what's going on with your roof and basically the way they presented it there was daylight visible from the attic space where sections of the asphalt shingle roof system were completely gone there were holes in the existing roof deck areas of the fascia and soffit were missing there were just all kinds of opportunity for weather penetration into the perimeter so at that point we moved forward with an rfp just to kind of get an understanding of what we'd be looking at for a cost we really didn't have any money set aside to rehab pump station point as going into the budget process for fy27 it wasn't really clear to us how that space may or may not be used so once the road i apologize i don't know the exact title but like the local road improvement bond. Once that came through and the prices came in, we identified a difference in what we requested and what the price came in at. So there was an opportunity there to maybe reallocate some of that bond to repairing the roof and then moving forward with soliciting bids for mold remediation in the ceiling in the underside of the roof deck and then replacing interior ceiling sheathing after insulation. We have not moved forward with the other two phases because it does not make sense to go out to bid a project if we're not going to start by replacing the roof so that's pretty much where we are right now great
[39:11] Council President: any questions yes Roddy correct me if I'm wrong this is
[39:15] Council Member: this is on the city's historic list is it not it is not it is not it is not as
[39:22] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: far as I know that is not on the National Historic Registry no not the national on the cities I did not research the cities I apologize I'm
[39:31] Council Member: rate for the national I believe it is on the city's register I'll get with you on this I'll just need a application for a COA okay if it is yep I believe it is okay I [Council President: don't] have any questions but I have a comment if you'd like to hear I bet you don't, but I'm going to say it anyway. I sat in this seat, I want to say, maybe four years ago and listened to the city engineer tell us how unsafe this building was and had to move the water company out and had to pay $4,500 a month on a three-year contract to go to Main Coast Mall. Now I guess they're not there anymore. I don't even know where they are, but there was a big hoorah about how unsafe this building was, and bricks were falling out of it, and they couldn't have personnel there, and couldn't do this and couldn't do that, and signed up for a great big lease. And now I'm hearing that we want to steal money out of the road bond and mix up monies again and put it in somewhere where it doesn't belong and put money into a building that was unsafe for a previous city crew but now this city crew can be in it I'm very confused about this and this happened in the time I've been here
[41:07] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: what's up do me a piece of this yeah I wasn't here four years ago so I can't speak to the decisions that were made then I
[41:14] City Manager: apologize nor was I you know I well I was maybe do a quick fact check I don't believe it was the city engineer the city has it ever had a city engineer That's not true.
[41:25] Council Member: MR. It's the public works director. We had a city engineer and she stood up and said.
[41:28] City Manager: MR. It was the public works director who has an engineering degree. MR. Oh. MR. And they later posted for a city engineer for the city, which was never filled, to my knowledge. To your point, I wasn't here either, but what I've been told is the water department that left in a hurry, a lot of it was due through mold remediation, potential leaks in the ceiling, et cetera. Right now it's being used as a storage facility, correct me if I'm wrong. MR.
[41:52] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Yeah, we don't have any break room or staff areas where they go in and mingle and whatever. It's literally where our equipment is stored. They go in, get what they need, and come out.
[42:02] City Manager: I was told that the previous office arrangement for the water department, I believe, was they were there full time. They were sitting there. They were in basically their office environment when they weren't working on the pipes. So it wasn't good for that type of use. It's been used as storage for some time, not just for this, but for the windows that were in the city hall building now in the basement. Those were stored there for a period of time as well. And the water department, yes, they moved to I think the old Payless Shoes store. I agreed that was not an excellent arrangement that went on far too long and that the capital asset should have been improved and mitigated and potentially the cost of that lease could have brought us back into that building. Thanks to our new water superintendent who worked with Lightning Speed as a new great business wanted to move into that private sector space and offer us the opportunity at less cost and in record time they moved to some temporary trailer arrangements at the water treatment plants now being and we've had meetings on this I believe in workshops and Eric has presented on that move multiple times the need for that but then also that we're going to be designing the new spot a treatment plant system to have some on-site capabilities for offices permanently at the new water treatment plant, although we will at some point in time as part of our capital improvement project planning potentially looking for some satellite office space for the water department. Obviously, a good bulk of our lines are here in downtown Ellsworth, whereas the treatment plant itself is out at Branch Lake, so we need a little bit of a dual structure in the future. So more to come on that. I think tonight is really, to Roddy's point, is the current condition of the building, its storage, its potential danger for roof collapse and the loss of that asset. I think actually in the future we need a much larger discussion about Pump House Point on potential sale, potential if we're going to use it as a city asset we should, but at the very least we need to protect the capital asset to the extent possible as it is now, and that is why Roddy is coming forward with this. Anyone
[44:06] Council Member: else? I just have a question. Steve, I'm not being, I mean, I'm not, this is genuine. you want i just are you is your concern that it wasn't done then or that it shouldn't be done like this now my concern is this first you're stealing money out of the road account now anyone that lives in this town knows that the money needs to go into the roads not some building that's unsafe that's number one number two is i sat here in this seat and learned about how unsafe this building was fine they moved out of the building now we want to take money out of a road account and rebuild a building that's my concern is two parts one you're stealing money out of the road account and you've got potholes in this town that it can be a hot tub and now you're going to take money out of that and you're going to put it into a building that three years ago, you wasn't supposed to walk in it. I don't get it. I just do not understand putting this, taking that kind of money out of the roads and putting it into a building that was already deemed unsafe and unusable by this city. I just do not comprehend either of those products. Sell the place, put it on the tax rolls, use it for a park, but stop I'll put money in that damn building. Councillor Smith. So three things. So it sounds like we're just trying to get the roof in such a state where it's not going to cave in. Correct. And if it were to cave in, that would greatly impact any resale value, correct? Yeah. So that would be more money that the city may not get and that this is just trying to keep up some capital investment. That sounds like it got overlooked. looked that is unfortunate but we're in the mess we're in now so let's this is an opportunity to actually address something that was missed and it sounds like we can't just give this money back because this we've already bonded the
[46:24] City Manager: money correct no I would say I would note on the bonding piece there is a level to Councilor Howland's point of an opportunity cost here this could be spent on more roads it's roughly in this amount we already have I'd want to bring up Sarah for that conversation we already did the year one on the capital improvement plan roads funding and now year two now there's a lot more to go here one of the great aspects of having somebody of Sarah and Roddy's capital caliber doing capital improvement planning is just these types of pieces cans been kicked down the road for many years and now they're being addressed and being brought forward for council to prioritize so we put aside, I think, 1.2 million, Sarah, correct me if I'm wrong, for a potential year one bonding on the roads. This cycle, we did 2 million the year before in roads. You're probably looking at 20, 22 roads in Ellsworth. I know that is not. There are very significant potholes all over the city, and we have a very methodical method in which we're addressing them. The bids for roads this year came substantially under where we thought they were going to be. That's why we did the first two rounds of roads. There's also, I know Sarah is an expert, and Amanda and Mike and Brian, our whole highway team on, you know, we can't do the entirety of the $20 million of the capital infrastructure plan backlog, year one backlog in one fell swoop. So that's, I think, the last council meeting we approved an additional round of road funding as part of this package. and really as Roddy was analyzing this building felt that this was a critical need and that with the surplus funds we could not do any more roads we could wait until the spring to do it for next year's capital improvement planning project for roads we're going to likely need to do a magnitude larger than the remaining on this bond for the next flight of road bonding in the city so you don't necessarily have to draw down on that bond for this purpose but this would authorize the city to take, I believe, 80,000 of the 300 and some thousand remaining on the bonds that came under from the roads aspect of the bond to move forward with.
[48:42] Council Member: I don't want to take anything from the roads because it's not just putting the pavement, it's doing the drainage and all of that. and the city and in the past before us all of us got on the council I don't you know I mean not gonna point fingers it happened okay but they deemed it wasn't that okay I don't want I don't want to kill it but I just soon table it to like
[49:23] Council President: I just have a few questions for you, Roddy, pending if this was approved, when are you looking to do this work? MR.
[49:33] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Our hopes would be to get it done before the new year, but that would be contingent on the weather cooperating. We'd need a day, and a half where it's 40 degrees, which is…
[49:43] Council President: MS. Which it's giving you right now. MR.
[49:44] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Which it's giving us right now, absolutely. Absolutely. It also would depend on notifying the contractor and working with their schedule, but they have told us that they would be able to prioritize it if we were to move forward.
[49:54] Council President: Okay. Another question I have is, did you put this bid out for just asphalt, or did you do metal roofing as well?
[50:04] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: I put the bid out for asphalt just to try to keep the price point down. the bid that we did receive comes with a 30-year warranty for mold as well as for workmanship so it would the life expectancy of the roof would outlive the term of the bond which I was mindful of but going with a metal roof you pushed it from 40,000 to 90,000 dollars and then after the mold
[50:37] Council President: and if you were to do the roof and then look at the mold remediation that needs to be done there's a ton of extra work on top of that right like the brickwork
[50:46] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: and yeah I've no basically what we're looking at right now is to stabilize the building so it can continue to be used in the capacity that we are now not a storage as to we're not entertaining the idea of like moving a whole crew in there and setting up shop or anything like that it's literally where their tools are stored where they can go and grab them and come out are there any pieces of machinery in there yes yeah the all of our mowing fleet is in there our sidewalk plow machine the vent rack is in there all the attachments for that the water department has their met at meter testing facility still in there as well as a whole bunch of other resources and materials that they use on the
[51:23] Council President: regular do those places have another home if this groups roof collapses
[51:29] Council Member: outside so our city employees regularly engaged in any lengthy use of this
[51:39] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: building with mold in it my crew goes in and comes out they go in they get what they need for the day they pull it out that's that's the I can't speak to the water department's meter testing facility that's that's in that room we pay for electricity and heat in the building because it has to be maintained above freezing for the meter testing facility so I'm one more
[52:02] Council Member: question I know this is I'm I'm guessing that you addressed this is there any other way to pay for this besides as Steve says put it stealing from the
[52:13] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: roads I don't know of a reserve account that would cover the cost of this that is appropriate to this type of use it would be going out and pursuing another bond that we could roll into something with a lot larger perspective I guess but yeah in the short term no I don't have any other options for financing
[52:34] Council Member: this project and you don't think the big blue top from Home Depot slung over the
[52:38] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: top was no I mean like it's not just water penetration the roof decking is compromised you can see in some of the photos i provided where there's daylight coming through the roof structure so if you get a snow load or ice dams on there the weight of whatever's on the roof most likely would come through it's not just water penetration at this point
[53:01] Council Member: now this is a bigger issue than we're talking about here i don't know about this meter testing facility that I'd like to learn more about because I would assume a meter testing ability requires human occupancy to this building but I would like to hear about that but there's a bigger issue here you're you're indebting the city of Ellsworth for roads and you're spending it elsewhere and you're not unique to this organization I have seen so many things reallocated where we have a bond to pay for roads and the next thing you know it's paying for other things it's not good accounting your debt needs to align with your expense for your capital improvement or your asset you shouldn't be having a debt on roads and then slipping that money out and putting it over here and over there and ten years from today people sitting at this table aren't gonna have a clue about what the hell the previous council has done that's not good paperwork folks good paperwork makes good friends and you should not be reallocating monies just for pet projects. I'm sorry. I don't like that idea, not just this one, but others. And secondly, this specific project, you know, I saw the city of Ellsworth deem a home that had a fire in it on Fairground Road that it was unsafe and they tore it down and built the homeowner or the landowner. And here we have a building that's unsafe and we don't want to tear it down and repurpose anything. We want to throw money out of it, out of the road account. I'm sorry, I just don't get that philosophy when I saw it on Fairground Road the city spent money tearing this building down that was unsafe and now you want to put money into this building that has already been deemed unsafe and you can see through it everywhere I'll never understand is there what is the value of the equipment that's currently stored there or do you not know is it more than 80,000 so we could lose $80,000 worth of equipment if this caves in or we need to store it outside I know this is not an easy decision but we're already trying to maintain what we have and this again I don't like having to take it from an existing bond, but this may be a bullet we have to bite because we can't lose equipment, particularly when, in many ways, our fleet is already a little taxed.
[56:20] City Manager: For what it's worth, I'm somewhat amenable to Councillor Shea's point on the table for a slightly different reason, and I know staff may not be pumped to view for this. We've got a new procurement system. We've only got one bid in here. Some notes in the metal piece, some I know you posted it to all the right places, Roddy, but I'd love to maybe do a little more manual outreach, reopen the bid, try to get a few more to get some competitive price quotes. We had a good email today from a citizen on just some notes, but I also weigh that against the immediacy of it, right, which is, to those points, we get a big storm, something this will seem like a very bad decision to table. At the same time, December storms aren't too likely. I can look a little bit more into the financing piece. As already noted, this is part of our capital improvement planning process. When Sarah and the city council and myself, when we did the multiple workshops, when we prioritized all the items, if we knew the exact price point of all the roads that were being proposed and we knew that this one was going to be a big one, last spring we would have made it maybe a different decision. but you can administratively it becomes easiest to reallocate within the existing bond capacity if not we could look into new bonds which would take more paperwork more you know applying and funds you might have to do a ban a bond anticipation note before bond because we've missed the bond cycle that'll create interest over a certain period of time so but I can get you more options on a table as well if that would be preferable that's I the
[58:01] Council Member: building The building was deemed unsafe, it's got mold in it. The roof's bad. I could see that without going inside. I've been there, okay? That's just years and years of neglect on city-owned property, okay? And I would like to introduce a motion to table it until December or January by the latest. it the mother patents i'm i'm not a big fan of taking bets against mother nature but if the roof is as bad as what it shows in the pictures it's going to be more than what and we got a new proposed procurement policy and it's not even listed on the capital original capital improvement so my motion would be i'd like to introduce the motion to table it to december no later than january
[59:12] Council President: is there a question there i'd like to continue discussion
[59:15] Council Member: before the motion oh that's okay i was just going to say something quickly i'm not opposed to tabling it as long as we would guarantee that would be on the december one because that's how i don't like rolling the dice, but I don't mind tabling it so we can get it.
[59:33] Council President: When you table it, has to go on the following meeting's agenda, correct? Yeah, so it would be December, which I think gives enough time.
[59:41] Speaker O (unidentified): But, Councilor Howland?
[59:43] Council Member: My question is about the storage part. I don't know about the meter part, but the storage part. Where were these assets stored prior to them going to that?
[59:54] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Most of them we did not own. the Ventrac was purchased last fall with all of its attachments. Prior to that those pieces of equipment that Ventrac replaced were stored outside at
[1:00:04] Council Member: the highway department. Okay and the equipment that's in there, lawn mowers and Ventrac and all of that, aren't those equipment, aren't those made to work outdoors yes okay certainly storing them inside would be wonderful but at what cost is the question and isn't there another if you're worried about this thing collapsing there isn't there a better solution to get these things out of this building if you're so concerned about this building collapsing on the assets couldn't there be an alternative to the storage of that those
[1:00:52] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: assets somewhere I could explore one yes I just don't know where it would go it
[1:00:58] City Manager: would be a cost to make a point of order but to but I don't know if that was a motion to table or not would it was a motion to table but there was no second
[1:01:06] Council Member: there's no second to it and I asked to continue the conversation so
[1:01:14] Council President: we do have motion on the table I don't
[1:01:23] Council Member: like rolling the dice but I will second it just so that we can actually get some more information in because we can't miss this equipment but we're all in the dice okay no discussion all those in favor
[1:01:40] Council President: All those opposed to tabling? All right. That means we... Oh, my God. Motion. Motion denied. So it didn't pass. We need four... Tonight, we need four votes to make sure the motion passes. So this is still...
[1:01:58] City Manager: There can be still discussion on the Adam proposal, but it seems like there's no... So we can move on to... Okay. So we can just... Unless there's a motion to pass or to move forward with this, but it doesn't seem like that's the answer. Is there any other proposed motion?
[1:02:15] Council Member: Well, I do have a comment, and that's the fact that, I mean, I've been on a year, and this is really the first discussion I've heard of this building, really. I haven't heard anything else about it. If, in fact, it is in that dire straits, I don't know whether it's on the city's register of historic places. If it is, you have to ask the Historic Preservation Commission to tear it down or do anything to it. But let's just leave that alone for now. If it is past the point of all reconstruction or, you know, conservation or whatever, why are we going to put a roof on it? That's, I just need more information.
[1:03:03] City Manager: Yep, I totally agree.
[1:03:04] Council President: Is this something that we can bring up at the December workshop?
[1:03:08] City Manager: Yep, we can definitely discuss it at the workshop. I would definitely plan on it and it's one of the reasons we brought it forward tonight is to have some conversations, as its condition is to where it's at. So let's keep that conversation up. We'll put it at the very top priority of the work plan for 27 for discussions. A couple other items, I think, are top of the list as well.
[1:03:27] Council Member: I'd like to hear more about the meter testing piece of this.
[1:03:31] City Manager: The meter testing, I believe, is just the housing of – they swapped out, like, the old meters for new digital meters. So I believe it's actually just holding – it's not an actual testing facility. It's just a storage area for a lot of our meter testers, but maybe we'll get more information on that in the early December meeting as well. So, I didn't do the public hearing.
[1:04:03] Council President: I did not do the public hearing. You are correct. I did not do the public hearing, but we didn't, we actually haven't had anything passed anyway.
[1:04:11] Council Member: Well, it's listed as a public hearing.
[1:04:13] Council President: It is listed as a public hearing, so I am going to open up this public hearing to this matter. I am so sorry. thank you for pointing that out yes state your name and three minutes it's
[1:04:24] Council Member: okay it happens first time Tiffany Gaspar Ellsworth so in conjunction with a little bit of what Steve said to you're robbing Peter to pay Paul which has been a big issue within the city for not just the last few years but the last ten years there's got to be a stopping point to that this building for easily I would say over five years has looked like this the roof is not anyone that's driven by that on a regular basis has seen that so a couple of things the bid process again metal roofing not metal roofing asphalt the selling point on that 30 year warranty if you look at the packet and look at the proposal it's you have to buy into that 's not just given to us you have to pay extra for that 30 year workmanship guarantee and the shingles for that you're upgrading to this architectural shingle that instead of mold it says is actually algae and if you reference the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association, ARMA for short, algae is primarily a cosmetic issue and does not directly destroy or wrought shingles so doing that getting the upgraded shingle and then this 30 year warranty with it that's workmanship warranty that you don't know if this custom company is even going to be in business in 30 years is kind of wish-washy to me it's a little bit gimmicky it's a way to upsell the product but in addition you know there are storage containers you can purchase for significantly less. There is a counselor sitting on there that sells them. Stephen will not sell one to the city. Okay, well, there's other vendors. There are other vendors who do sell those type of containers that can store and house those things. And I believe the school uses some out behind the water tower. So those are options for storage to protect the assets that we're worried about. And I think this is a good opportunity to research grants. We talk so much about grants in historical buildings and everything else, this would be an opportunity if you want to save this building to incorporate a grant into saving that so it doesn't cost the taxpayers using money allocated for specifically roads, and that was just two months ago. I think asking for that when we definitely have things that could be worked on with roads or money that is set aside for that or can be used towards another project to benefit that city in that department where it's very much needed is it's just unacceptable at this point and you know if it's unsafe to be on and you can't roll some tar paper out to make it through the winter to keep it dry then I mean again you need to look at I'm ingredients with you tabling this because it needs to be looked in more and the cost and realization of those costs in the future and if you're gonna sell it a new roof maybe it'll help it but realistically it seems like there's a lot more work that's going to be needed to be done including if you look at the bids and proposals the mold remediation was rough price at 17. that by chance will probably not just be 17. i used to work for a mold remediation company so chances are it would be more and then again just looking at storage we have a city garage you can maybe add something onto that an adjacent building a metal building to store something that's like a lean-to type situation these are items that can get what you can purchase covers for them you know I mean it off Amazon so we can figure out different ways but I don't think spending 40 grand on a roof on this building is probably the best option right now thank you anyone else
[1:08:20] Council President: no okay I'm gonna close public comment thank you citizens for keeping me in line okay is there another motion on or are we gonna rock with that one [Speaker D (unidentified): and discuss] this more at the workshop which I'm in favor of I think we have a lot to dive into here on this building and what we want to do with this piece of property. I think there are some alternative storage options for us for the winter. But yeah, I think there's a lot that we could discuss on this building.
[1:09:13] Council Member: Procedural question. So can we move on because we haven't had a motion or do we need to do something formal to... We can move on.
[1:09:20] Speaker D (unidentified): We can move on. All right,
[1:09:23] Council President: thank you, Roddy. All right, moving on, we are at agenda item number 14, council order number 112603, discussion and potential action regarding adoption of the updated City of Ellsworth procurement policy and accompanying procurement guidelines and operations manual. MR. Great.
[1:09:47] City Manager: Well, thank you all. I know for those who watch our city council meetings quite a bit, procurement policies,, new systems to manage procurement for the city of Ellsworth has been a major focus of mine and our teams over the last year. I know upon arrival we were very much in a paper-based system if following the procurement policy at all, to be quite frank. Tracking was limited and consistent evaluation practices varied wildly from project to project and talked to one department head about a project they were moving forward with and early in my tenure and said well like have you gone to the procurement policy they said i've never heard we have a procurement policy so it really had kind of fallen by the wayside for a while it had existed to my knowledge it wasn't council approved it was just kind of in the general policy area in the city Manager, the administration could change as needed. We really did two things over the last year, but six months has been the project implementation team worked on a new digital platform system through OpenGov to make sure that our procurements are much more transparent, available, accessible, much more rigorously followed in our policies and procedures and train through all department heads. I think we've done, I don't know, probably 25, 30 meetings on this now, including four or five all department head meetings to go through every piece of this process. Some of our team members are expert in this category, and you've already seen some of the product of their work on a variety of procurements. I think the OpenGov teams were surprised by just how quick we started using the system. And I think when you're going from a paper-based system, you are so excited to use a system that's actually a lot more robust and helpful. We've already seen significant cost savings, a lot more bids today notwithstanding. But even today, when a citizen has a question about things, we were able to send packets quite immediately. city councils have readout access to all of our bids and we're receiving a lot more competition we have over 400 active vendors registered in the system planning and approval thresholds are extremely detailed we now have a longitudinal data set on every single bid that's gone into the system over the last six months and that will continue to build to provide better and better our data not just externally on bidders and when things need to be rebid when a bid might expire but contracting as well I've noticed that a lot of the bids or the policies that move forward the city didn't have a contracting phase of those procurements now that's a requirement of the system you literally can't get out of it or go to the next stage until you've gone through our contracting which is done through our legal I noticed a lot of our contracts seem to be delivered by the vendor themselves and the city was sort of signing on their dotted lines and now ours are our terms and conditions our system so it's better records and oversight better contracts and accountability better competitive competition and evaluation and excellent audit trails and even smaller things like you know I know that Sarah Devlin has is the number one staff member in open gov followed shortly by Amanda ray how many hours they spend in the procurement system they've also helped train our teams I'm sliding in at number six I think right now, some of our others, so it gives you actually some metadata too on just how many people are in the system, what departments are using the bids and the contracts the most, and exactly how to do an evaluation committee. It's been extraordinarily helpful thus far. We are now in the full implementation stage, but as part of that as well, an enormous thanks. I cannot thank enough to our project manager, Leah, from the finance department on this. She has done just an incredible job. Our department heads gave her a standing ovation at the last training for all the work that she did to implement the system. And then every step of the way, as we were learning from the procurements that were going online, we were modifying what you're seeing now with both the procurement policy per our legal council's guidance that we'd like to have official city council to not just an informal rule of the 15,000 or more but a City Council adopted that if it's 15,000 or more it has to come before the council and having some of those general principles on conflicts of interest being a general policy and a notation on a much larger procurement manual that guides city staff now and into the future so I 'm really proud of this project proud of the team that's brought it forward I think it's gonna pay dividends especially in the future even now you can see some pie charts for distributions of procurements two three four years from now it's going to be an incredibly useful tool for the city to know exactly where these sometimes significant funds are being spent the number one expense the city has is in labor but this is number two is in procurement so we need a lot better system and now we have one to guide this moving forward so the motion is to should the council decide to move forward is to adopt the new procurement policy and its accompanying framework and then you'll be continuing to refine it and as refinements move forward brought before council and hopefully in the future the city's procurement policies will never get out of whack again. Any
[1:15:38] Council President: questions or comments to Charlie? Is there a motion?
[1:15:50] Council Member: I'll make the motion. I move that the City Council adopt the City of Ellsworth Procurement Policy dated November 12, 2026, Subceding the Procurement Policy dated January 18, 2024, effective upon adoption and acknowledging the accompanying Procurement Administration Manual as the implementation framework subject to city manager subject to the city manager's direction and approval with the finance department serving as its administrative head. Second.
[1:16:44] Council President: Discussion? All those in favor? Opposed? Motion passes. Okay moving on to agenda item number 15 council order number 112604 update and presentation from the water superintendent on the water treatment plant replacements good
[1:18:19] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: evening okay great good evening I am Eric Nystrom the new superintendent for the water department I've been with the city since April but I was contracted since January through April with the main row water so it hasn't been quite a year yet and I'm excited to be here a lot of challenges but some really great people to work with both at the water department public works in the city in general I've been incredibly impressed and humbled by everything that I've seen and trying to live up to the level of folks that are here. So I was asked to put together a little presentation to kind of give the council an update on where we are with the new water treatment facility. And Wooden and Kernan came also, as in case there's any technical questions that I can't answer. And so we'll just begin. So if I hit this right, there we go. Firstly, I'd like to start the presentation with why the City of Ellsworth is pursuing a new potable water facility, and that will take us back to learn about the current treatment facility. So we'll do background, new treatment facility proposal, and projected schedule. The background. So the current treatment facility was built in 1991 and came online, or 1990 and came online in 1991. It utilizes coagulation, clarification, filtration, and disinfection, and its maximum daily output is about 800,000 gallons a day. As everyone probably knows, its location is on Branch Lake, serves as a source of water for the current treatment facility as well as the proposed treatment facility. The new facility will be built on the same property. A little addition here, the current Clearwater Way water treatment plant has been serving Ellsworth residents since 1990. While it has reliably provided safe drinking water, the facility's infrastructure is aging, no longer meets modern standards for efficiency and resilience. In 2010, an ultraviolet light system which augments the disinfection process was installed to help mitigate disinfection byproduct levels. Our increasing business and population growth in Ellsworth increases the draw on the water infrastructure and capacity levels of the current water treatment plant are nearing total daily limits. The decision to build a new treatment plant reflects the city's commitment to sustainable, high-quality water supply. It will feature advanced technology to improve water quality, reduce maintenance, and support Ellsworth's continued growth. Some facts about Branch Lake, if anyone's interested. The surface area is approximately almost 3,000 acres with a mean depth of 39 feet and maximum depth of 124 feet. The supporting watershed is around 31 square miles. Safe yield has been identified to be about 23 million gallons a day. The watershed is largely undeveloped, and there is moderate shoreline development. element. Potable water usage demand will eventually surpass the current potable water treatment facilities capabilities. The demand for potable water is growing. During the summer months, the current potable water treatment facility operates close to its upper limits. As the city grows, the current potable water treatment facility will not be able to treat enough water to meet its expanding needs. We are just barely meeting potable water demand during the summer months. New housing and businesses will drive potable water demand beyond the current treatment facility's maximum capacity. So if we look here, this is a proposal for the new water treatment facility that Wooding and Kernan graciously provided me with today. The structure itself will be about 14,000 square feet. You can see here this is where our treatment trains will be, and we're also proposing to have an admin section put on the building as well. The majority of the building will house the treatment trains consisting of the raw water inlet side where coagulant will be added prior to static mixers. Then the water will proceed through flocculator chambers and then on up to the flow plate settlers for clarification. This is where the bulk of the material is removed from the process water. water. From the upflow plate settlers, the water continues to the rapid sand filters. After the final filtering is complete, finishing chemicals are added consisting of sodium hypochlorite, hypofluorosilic acid, and sodium hydroxide. The water then travels to two clear wells that can operate in series, parallel, or single configuration. An additional tank will act as reserve for backwash water. From the clear wells, lift pumps will push fully treated water to the distribution system. The remaining structure will house offices, the lab, bathroom, and mechanics room, maintenance room. There will be a separate structure built closer to the lake that will house the raw water pumps. This is kind of a better bird's eye view. This is the current treatment facility here. This is the proposal for the new site. and then you don't really see it but there will be a smaller facility somewhere in this area that will act will store the house the raw water pumps to pull the water in and push it up to the treatment facility parking babe to receive chemicals and goods will be there then you can see these three sand filters that will be right next to it or drying beds is a more correct term new potable water treatment facility parameters. Our raw water pump house will contain three variable speed vertical turbine pumps configured as two duty and one standby. The raw water pump house will supply lake water to the treatment facility. The treatment facility is currently proposed to be 14,000 square feet, will house three treatment trains, two on duty and one standby. The clear wells and backwash tanks will be subterranean. Two variable speed turbine pumps will pump treated water to the distribution system and a third pump will be present in standby mode. The facility is rated to produce 1.635 million gallons a day, which is over twice the capacity of the current plant. And again, I'd like to say during the summer months, and I witnessed this myself last summer, we have days that are pretty much at the top of the current treatment plant. So even if you invest it into the old plant, you're not getting more capacity out of it. So we're, especially during the summer, we're at the top of what that plant can do. Okay, so, and it will house, the facility will also house a new laboratory and our admin rooms and mechanical rooms. Three sand drying beds will be constructed next to the treatment facility to allow the removal of sedable solids generated by the treatment process each bed will have a 5 foot storage depth and hold 2 219 thousand gallons of water the beds will be operated on a rotating basis for residuals receipt settling drying and solids removal supernate and under drain filter will be collected in a 6 foot diameter recycling pump station and returned to the head works for treatment facility. There is room for a fourth bed if it's deemed necessary in the future. What's really nice about this configuration is that we'll have no water from our treatment process that needs to enter the environment. It will all be self-contained within the treatment process. This is the schedule of where we are. So the 30% design basis report has been completed. The 60% design is due on January 13th, 27, 90% design is due in March 17th, 2027. The bid set is for 3-31-27, so March 31st. Bid opening will be April 30th, 2027. Construction starts 6-1-27 and construction hopefully ends 10-31-28. That's Halloween. And any questions? Yes. I've
[1:28:00] Council Member: heard a lot about the treatment of the water. What about the natural resource of Brant Lake? Yes, sir. Does that have the capacity? Yes.
[1:28:15] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: As I stated earlier, there was a study done when they were actually proposing the current treatment plant that you can pull 23 million gallons a day from that from the bot from Branch Lake safely right now we're at 800,000 during the summer and this plant design is 1.6 million so far under the 23 million gallons that was determined to be a safe withdrawal rate when was that I don't have the numbers also assuming because I was for the new treatment facility or that
[1:28:53] Council Member: the current treatment facility I should say and is it safe to assume that hasn't changed I'm just concerned when we talk about capacity about depleting the animal that's feeding the plant which would be the lake and if we I'm I'm not stating anything other than I'd be very interested to hear that as the city grows that we're not building a plan and then we run out of the raw material which is water or affect the lake in some way shape or form if we're We're dealing on 80s analysis, I wonder, it's just a question I have, certainly today it's not a problem, but what about 20 years from today? That's a concern.
[1:29:53] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: Well as far as I know, I haven't seen a new study done that could be proposed to our engineers to see if that's necessary or not. I don't really have a specific answer to that question.
[1:30:08] Council Member: It sounds like you're more than safe, it's just, I just.
[1:30:12] City Manager: Morgan, do you have anything, if I remember, would have been current on that? I know you've been probably with the project longer than anybody.
[1:30:17] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): Yeah, I mean, the only thing I would add there is that I think the biggest threat, if that's the word you want to use, to the water supply is actually the condition of the dam that keeps the water in Branch Lake. So that's really, and we've taken a good look at that because that is an asset of concern for the city. So we've looked at a variety of scenarios and designed our pumps and things to be able to accommodate sort of worst-case scenario. But I will say that the biggest change and the biggest driver would be the condition of that dam and if anything catastrophic ever happened to that dam. Good.
[1:30:52] Council Member: Which wasn't probably considered in the analysis done in the 80s.
[1:30:57] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): I haven't reviewed that analysis in detail, so.
[1:30:59] City Manager: There's been a separate working group established on that. I know they've met a couple times this year. we've been reformed on the branch lake dam piece with alongside the branch lake association but definitely and i know simmons pond i believe is also secured at some point in time in the city as a backup water supply at some point but maybe we can get a little more detail on that in the next presentation on this what counselor halloran mentioned on capacity analysis when the last one was done that we think it's sufficient obviously we're right on the limit as we are now even if we were to not grow much more at all and with new hotels and dozens of new housing units going up even just recently getting permits pulled you know one of my favorite things as city manager when new councils arrive is to give them a tour of city facilities and I love taking you all to the water wastewater treatment plant which had a similar reconstruction a new facility built to meet modern standards it's excellent the water treatment plant is one of those ones where you go to you and you see the 30-year age and it definitely needs to be replaced in order to meet modern needs. I would also note, though, that this is the treatment plant itself in capacity and modernization. It's going to be much better for the city, but we still have a lot of the pipes issues. It does not replace the pipes by replacing the plant. We have a lot of places where previous system designs had it dead-ending instead of actually looping. obviously when you design a water system 130 odd years ago and then you go through a period of time where them the plants is built and then people remain in the old plant building that goes under disrepair we're in a bit of a rebuilding stage but big thanks to Eric Morgan we're in current and really the whole team we also have a separate process project through open gov to digitize all of our water lines and systems and put together automatic work plans and other pieces just like the way the wastewater treatment plan is run now so this is one piece of a very large puzzle that Eric's been working incredibly hard coming in new to get us on a track to best in class in our water department thank you so thank you so much Eric and the whole water department team they've been doing a heck of a job
[1:33:12] Council Member: this may this may be a stupid question i don't know do we know that the aquifer that supports branch lake the geology is sound we know that aquifer is
[1:33:24] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: in good shape i believe it is honestly the real person asked that question too would be john whedon if you were willing to come in but you know the watershed is 31 square miles so from my understanding that it's actually in really good shape it's a lot of area a lot of bodies of water contribute to branch lake when i worry about the ellsworth water system So that is really the lowest of my concerns is the capacity of Branch Lake to meet the demand that we experience.
[1:34:04] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): Yeah, and I can add a little bit more detail to that. The other thing that the city has done that's been incredibly beneficial is acquiring land around in the watershed. So they own a very large percentage of the water that's in that watershed, and as a result are able to protect it. and so I work in a lot of places and the water quality in Branch Lake is one of the best that I see which is partly natural but part of it is because of those protection efforts that the city and landowners have done the only
[1:34:37] Council Member: my only question would be is it given the fact that actually our area is among the highest rated for drought right now in maine that certainly affects the ability of the watershed to feed in to branch lake which led to my question about the aquifer because it is spring fed correct branch
[1:35:05] City Manager: lake i don't think it's a natural glacier lake it's natural so we've got many streams and brooks that feed into it yeah it's one of the most premiered
[1:35:15] Council Member: You've got Rocky Pond, it's a little Rocky Pond that's up in a higher elevation. Okay, so it's not bed-by-bed.
[1:35:23] City Manager: It's not like green, which is that the dam is a component of it, but the dam would change obviously if the dam wasn't there, but it would still be a pretty substantially sized very deep water glacial lake.
[1:35:36] Speaker D (unidentified): It's surrounded by hills on that north side, too, so there's...
[1:35:39] Council Member: And like I said, there's streams that feed down from Dedham. There's ponds up in there. Yeah. So, you know.
[1:35:52] City Manager: Also, we'll get a little bit more into the geology, the environmental, the capacity. I think those are really important questions, not just for now, but for the future. We obviously have some new council to be as well. This was originally intended as it's such a big project for the city that we wanted to give the council a good update. date, but maybe we can come back at a later date with some more answers to some of these questions and keep this conversation going.
[1:36:15] Council President: Eric, I want to ask, so the current facility that we have, what was the lifespan of that? Should we have, are we kind of late to the game? Should we have done this earlier?
[1:36:26] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: You know, you look at the infrastructure across the United States, and I worked with the U.S. military for a long time. A lot of it's in disrepair. I mean, a lot of it just needs to be updated. They went online in 91, here we are in 26, that's not a bad run for a facility. It did its duty, it's tired and it's at capacity. It's simply time to retire it and send it out with honors and let's go on to the next
[1:36:56] Council President: generation. So roughly 35 years is the lifespan of a water treatment facility?
[1:37:01] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: I would surmise that this next facility probably will have a much longer life cycle.
[1:37:07] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): I was going to say, the existing plant, you don't want to say was built cheaply, but it wasn't built in a way that would make it last the 50 years that the current plant will be designed for. Oh, wonderful. So just things from material of construction, you know, it's not a masonry building, ventilation was off light switches, so if somebody turned it off in a room with, you know, fluoride in it just eats away at the electrical equipment so there's a lot of materials of construction and design elements that went into that last plant that contributed to its what we would say is less than a desirable lifespan
[1:37:44] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: it's difficult to work on any component in there because they didn't really engineer that so to get into the filters or to work on other components you're We're not in the safest place where a new facility will be built up to safety standards that will allow for repair and maintenance to be a much safer and easier and quicker transaction than these older plants. And Ellsworth is not the only city with an older plant. I mean, that's across the nation. We are very deficient in our infrastructure as a country. And so, you know, Ellsworth is nothing special as far as that's concerned.
[1:38:25] Council Member: are there backup is there backup electrical plan generators for the new facility yes for how long how long does it run without power we lose well so
[1:38:36] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): typically for a plant like this we would design it with storage for 48 hours of runtime obviously fuel can be delivered and that can extend but 48 hours is the typical fuel storage for this type of facility just in case the zombie apocalypse no it's it's a good point and for systems like this which is considered critical infrastructure, that is a really important consideration. Not just backup power, but all of the processes as we look at them are redundant. So you could have one pump go down and you're still able to meet your maximum demand. You could have one tank go down and you can still meet your maximum demand.
[1:39:10] Council President: The ice storm in 98 had two weeks of no power out there
[1:39:14] Speaker D (unidentified): in North Ellsworth, so it's, yeah.
[1:39:16] City Manager: Yeah, we're contingency planning for a lot of this as well. Obviously, the computer systems are also quite old here. I know when Sarah came in, really focusing on capital improvements, she and Amanda and Mike and the team really fast-tracked to think it was a new backup pump as well, because if you have one pump go down, that could be it. So there's a backup pump there as well, and then there's Lagoon's situation as well that need to be upgraded. So these things are very... I'd say we just made it to the end. It's still, you know, as you mentioned, Eric, it's done an excellent duty, and we'll tie it with honors. We're going to get the system, but none too soon. All
[1:39:55] Council President: right. Any other questions or comments for Eric? No? Okay. All right. Thank you so much for that presentation. Okay. And that puts us on to agenda item number 16.
[1:40:08] Council Member: Is this a public comment?
[1:40:09] Council President: No. That was just the presentation. Yes. Highlighting that. so council order number one two six oh five public hearing and action authorizing a one million sixty three thousand three hundred dollar loan from the main municipal bond bank drinking water srf program dhhs dws rf number 2026-08 and issuance of the city's bonds and bans, therefore, to finance a portion of the costs of the new water treatment plant project.
[1:40:45] Chris Nemeth, Chief Financial Officer: Hello, Chris. Hello, hi. Hi all, so I'm Chris Nemeth, the Chief Financial Officer. Yeah, it's a little unnerving, like every time I stand up here it's like a million dollars, but the water stuff and the infrastructure projects, as you saw, not cheap at the end of the day. The good news is, by way of context, this $1,063,300 is the third, I was thinking of a kind of tranche of debt connected to the last council meeting where you approved $6 million and $6 million. So this project for a water treatment plant was estimated at just north of $13 million. The bad news is that we could only apply for each tranche of debt up to $6 million, so we had to break it into three. The first two were very time urgent, so by the time I even showed up on site, we were behind and we were running out of time, so those were crisis. We have a little bit of time in terms of this third piece, but not a lot. So that's why we broke them apart into the three. weren't trying to make it difficult on purpose. By way of context, though, I would say that of all the different types of financing that we look at and deal with, this program, this DWSRF, which is the drinking water bond program, or the CWSRF, I don't even know what the C is. Is it? So it's wastewater, but they call it clean water? Yeah, very intuitive. Love that. I thought it was crummy water or something. So DWF-CWF, they're kind of joint programs between the main Department of Health and Human Services and the main bond bank. I would tell you it's probably the most favorable programs that we deal with. And there's a bunch of reasons for that. One is that I think you know in like the general obligation bonds where we're trying to finance, for instance, we had this discussion about roads or other types of infrastructure we have to choose kind of a band or a bond and if we take the band route there's some advantage to that but it actually is two separate closings then when we have to then close on the subsequent bond program this program actually combines them together so it gives you the best of both so when you are approving for me to go and actually get the process going for this million sixty three dollars because of this band bond combination what you're actually proving is that is the maximum that would be the maximum that we would take under this program when we do the front-end band on that we're only spending what we need and if we can keep those costs down and then I have to convert that to a bond I'm only gonna to bond the amount that we used. So that's an unbelievable kind of advantage there. And like I said, it's only one closing. The other thing is, apart from the – and we talked about this in the general obligation bonds, but the interest in the terms that we get are better than market. So if we had to go shop this kind of money at a bank, not only would we pay more from an interest, the cost of money would be higher, but we couldn't get these kinds of terms. Maybe they would give us ten years and then our payment would be two and a half times on a monthly basis what it would be under this program. But the other piece is that we routinely get forgiveness of the principal. So for this $13 million water treatment plant project, we're getting between the six to the six in this just north of $1 million, we're getting $4.5 million of that forgiven. That's 35%. And so the remaining principal will be roughly $8.5 million, 65%. And then we pay below market interest on that remaining amount. So of all the different types of debt instruments that we're looking at in terms of financing,, if I had to, again, work with private banks or local banks, even if they're friends of the town, or heaven forbid I had to finance this out of taxpayer dollars, this by far is the most favorable program I think that the states got going. So I would just offer that up. Does that make sense? Morgan, did you have anything else to add to this? No, I don't have. Just also
[1:45:53] City Manager: note, yeah, obviously we've been talking a lot about this for, I don't know, this was started before I was city manager so we about this water treatment plant upgrade we also for those that were here with us we recently did a rate case study and a rate case analysis to start prepping for this debt for the water treatment plant previously some of these projects were done and there was a big balloon increase once the debt service hit so we were trying to stagger that a little bit that includes the city's the amount we're paying for water this year is actually significantly more than last year that's one of the reasons the tax increase this year is the water rates the city's paying in preparation for this debt service the city is the largest purchaser of water in the city of Ellsworth so we've we've been planning ahead so that we can somewhat soften the debt service blow to the water rate users when the debt service does come on these projects
[1:46:53] Council President: chris i have a question for you this overall project costs 24 million dollars correct that's no that's not correct okay so i was just pulling
[1:47:07] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): this up i think that number must have come from like adding the principal forgiveness and the loan amounts when they're the principal forgiveness is a part of the loan so i actually have a breakdown down, but the total project cost is just about $17.5 million, and so where the sources of that are the $6 million plus the $6 million plus this $1,063,000, the city has also received a $1 million NBRC grant, a $2 million CDS grant, which is the congressionally directed spending and then we'll talk on the next agenda item about a 1.5 million dollar SRF loan that's separate from this that would be used as the required match for those two grants so both of those have a match component so that will factor in there and so all of those together arrive at that 17 563 okay so we're
[1:48:13] Council President: financing them $14 million because we have to match that grant. Correct, yeah. Okay. Does anyone else have any questions or discussion for them
[1:48:32] Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director: on this? No? Okay.
[1:48:36] Council President: There is, this is a public hearing so I will open this up to the public if anyone would like to speak on this. No? All right seeing none I'll close the public hearing all right how would the council like to proceed i'll make the motion i move to
[1:49:02] Council Member: adopt the council order authorizing one million sixty three thousand three hundred dollar loan from the main municipal bond bank drinking water srf program dhhs dws rf number 2026-08 and issuance of the city's bonds and bands therefore to finance a portion of the cost of the new water treatment plant project second
[1:49:29] Council President: second any further discussion okay all those in favor opposed all right motion passes great thank you Chris I think you are staying up for agenda item number 17 council order number one two six zero six public hearing and action authorizing a one million five hundred dollar loan from the main municipal bond bank drinking water srf program dhhs dwsrf number 2026-09 an issuance of the city's bonds and bans therefore to finance a portion of the costs of lagoon and intake improvements at the new water treatment plan
[1:50:15] Chris Nemeth, Chief Financial Officer: sure so i may ask morgan to comment on this one in terms of the specifics of each of the pieces of this debt but the project my understanding the total project for this lagoon's intake is 4.5 million dollars morgan just kind of rolled through but we got two grants a two million dollar grant and a one million dollar grant and the conditions of that was we needed to match come up with our own match of 50% of that so 1.5 million dollars and by the way again part of this DWSRF program even for the matched piece of it we're getting three hundred thousand dollars of that forgiven and so we'll see if we spend then the room you know the main remaining 1.2 or how the whole project comes in but again we're only gonna pay interest based on what we actually use kind of at the end of day so when I add up that you know 4.5 and if 3.3 of it is forgiven and we were left with a remaining principle at the end of the day of 1.2 million dollars so now we've got a project in which 75% is forgiven or you can think of it as almost a grant, and we're actually able to finance this project really only paying 25%, and again, at preferred terms, better than the market. Do you have anything else on that?
[1:52:02] Unidentified Official (likely City Manager or Engineer): Yeah, I can just give a little bit of clarity, too, as to why they're two separate ones. So I also just want to clarify, the $4.5 million is included in that $17 million number. So we view this as one project, the treatment plant and all the associated infrastructure. There are two main reasons why we're breaking them apart. And so the first one is that federal match component, or the grant match component. So because NBRC and CDS funds are both federal funds, you can't match them with federal funds the DWS RF program has some funds that are federal and some that are not so when we tell them that this one and a half million needs to be non federal they can make that happen so it meets the requirements the second one is last year the let me backtrack a minute while the terms of these programs are very favorable there are certain requirements you need to meet because they're federal money and one of those for a long time was called AIS which was American iron and steel any iron and steel on your project needed to be made and founded in America last year that requirement became more stringent so it's now referred to as BABA which is build America by America and it extends those requirements to everything so electrical equipment plastic pipe anything and that comes with a very high cost. And so the drinking water program who oversees the SRF program, because the city had started this project so long ago, allowed us to be grandfathered in to AIS instead of BABA. And so the primary reason that we're separating these contracts is that when we put out the water treatment plant contract, which is the building and all of the equipment and the electrical stuff that would be most impacted by those BABA inflations we won't have to apply that and we'll use the funds the NBRC and CDS funds that do have BABA for the lagoon construction and the earthwork and the things that we can get as iron pipe that's already like readily available so those are the main reasons why these are split out into two different loans and why we talk about them as two separate projects is primarily to save the city money in the long run
[1:54:26] Council President: any questions or discussion from council no okay this is also a public hearing so I'm going to open the public hearing up interested seeing no one I will close the public hearing move to
[1:54:53] Council Member: adopt the council order authorizing a loan of up to 1 million 500 thousand dollars from the main municipal bond bank drinking Water State Revolving Fund Program, DHHS-DWSRF Project 2026-09, and the issuance of the city's bonds and bond anticipation notes, therefore, to finance a portion of the cost of the lagoons and intake construction project. Okay. Second.
[1:55:22] Council President: Further discussion? All right. Seeing none, all those in favor? Opposed? All right. Motion passes. All right. Thank you very much. Okay. Agenda item number 18, council order number 112607, discussion and potential action on the appointment of Caitlin Miller as the city clerk for the city of Ellsworth. Charlie.
[1:55:48] City Manager: Thank you very much. Just a little background here. This is part of an operational realignment in the city to have more structure and clarity of roles and purpose. The last few years, we've been doing sort of a hybrid system where the tax collector has also been the clerk and the executive assistant to the city manager has also been doing an incredible amount of clerk's duties and we've sort of all been making due. This is sort of the final piece of transitioning to a more traditional clerk structure with a dedicated clerk overseeing that aspect of things. The previous council, it was two council meetings ago, but I think it was the previous one, we reallocated funds from the city manager's budget to the clerk's office in part for this purpose, so that the clerk's office could be staffed appropriately, and we don't anticipate backfilling the executive assistant role to the city manager and upon a hiring committee was formed and an internal candidates selection process was gone through and we're happy to note that amongst some great applicants who applied that Caitlin Miller currently the deputy city clerk was chosen by the hiring committee to be the next clerk for the city of Ellsworth so we're asking for the council, should they so choose, to ratify the selection of the hiring committee and the city manager. In the appointment of Caitlin, she's an incredible leader in our organization over the past three years, has done many things that the community has depended upon, both small and large, really took the lead on our election cycle. This election cycle she actually handled herself, obviously with support from our entire team, but really took the lead for the first time to make sure everything went smooth. She's taken the lead on multiple recount now procedures and has done an excellent job there. She has incredible statutory detail, records, deadlines, customer service. The clerk's office in general, not just the clerks, but the tax collectors and our utilities coordinator, have also made a big push to do a lot of cross-training so that our customers, when they arrive, no matter what type of business they're doing we have obviously expertise in certain areas but with the cross training that anybody can help we're available and it's been a big change for the city I think positive for our customers and I think Caitlin one of the other things she really brought was a vision for the future and this is a great team and how do we keep building upon that how do we keep cross training customer service statutory and deadline line and minutiae excellence at their core. And I love this team. I think they get some of the highest marks. You know, I get a lot of emails as city manager. The ratios on this is going great to, hey, this needs to be improved are not always awesome. But the clerk's office, you know, whenever I see something about the clerks, it's always, oh my gosh, I had a really complicated thing that I was running into. They treated me so well. They gave me all the information I need. It's such a top-notch group for probably the unit that interacts with the most amount of customers in the city and the citizens here out of any so they do an incredible job and I know Caitlin and the team are gonna keep doing an incredible job moving forward any
[1:59:20] Council President: questions comments for Charlie there is a suggestion motion
[1:59:31] Council Member: anyone's interested I can give you a break Carol there's less numbers on this one I moved to ratify the selection of the hiring committee and the city managers appointment of Kaitlyn Miller as city clerk in accordance with section 6.03 of the city charter and applicable personnel policies effective immediately second
[2:00:08] Council President: discussion all those in favor unanimous wonderful okay council order number 19 sorry agenda item number 19 council order number one two six zero eight discussion and potential action on the request of the IT systems administrator to purchase network switch upgrades grades.
[2:00:37] City Manager: Is Jason going to join us? Jason, I believe, is not able to attend tonight. Nate? Nate, I don't know if he's going to be out there. Maybe Sarah can take this over.
[2:00:46] Sarah Dellen, Deputy City Manager: I can handle it as well. I mean, you're really getting the D team on this one. Sorry. Sarah Dellen, Deputy City Manager. Yeah, Jason is not here tonight. He's out with an illness. So this, I'm going to do my best to describe the core network switches. So this is a critical piece of our city's infrastructure as we saw last week when things go down like Microsoft it makes it really hard for us to do our work so these core switches were installed in 2018 they provide connectivity between city facilities and servers and it allows for redundancy without actually redundancy with systems So, it was approved, funding was approved through the bond package. This was listed, I think, as one of the top two priorities in the capital improvement plan that staff identified and scored. So this is, though, being requested to be a sole source purchase. It was not put out to bid. Jason and the team decided to go with a sole source due to the warranty and service provided through this company that is not matched or met with any other company and the ability to maintain those warranties and the connectivity would be more seamless with this company in installing the new switches. So it is a sole source. It was not put out to bid and that's why due to the warranty and vendor support that's offered through the duration of the project and it's not to exceed amount of $50,000 for these switches for this product any
[2:02:34] Council President: questions just want
[2:02:41] Council Member: to go on record that I am NOT a sole source fan however these two guys in that department run the entire city and they do a lot of work for other departments that they do not receive the credit for and if Jason Ingalls says this is what he needs and he was bypassed by an additional employee in the last budget cycle again I reiterate I do not like sole source but if Jason Ingalls and the IT department says that this is the best value for the city of Ellsworth again they do a lot of work that nobody sees I'm in on anything that department says The
[2:03:41] Council President: other discussion? I agree with Steve's remarks there. All right, there is...
[2:03:51] Council Member: Move to authorize the sole source purchase of core network switching infrastructure directly from somebody. How do you pronounce that word? Ubiquity. Ubiquity. Okay. In an amount not to exceed $50,000 with funding from the FY27 general obligation bond designated for core network switch infrastructure upgrade.
[2:04:24] Council President: Second. Wonderful. Any further discussion?
[2:04:27] Council Member: I would like to make one note that it appears that this general obligation bond fits the mold of infrastructure and we're not jumping out of turn and taking money from something else. This fits right in, I believe. And again, I would like to support that department that does so much work. Great.
[2:04:53] Council President: Okay. All those in favor? Unanimous. Wonderful. wonderful. Our city will keep operating another day. All right. Agenda item number 20, Council Order Number 112609, Appointment Recommendations from the Community Development Director on behalf of the TIF Committee to fill the remaining three seats. Ms. Hi, Twyla.
[2:05:17] Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director: Ms. Hello. Good evening, everyone. Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director. Director, I am here tonight on behalf of the existing TIF Committee to provide the Council with a summary of the submissions of interest that we received from Ellsworth citizens from October 17 to November, I'm sorry, 27 to November 10 to fill the three remaining votes on the Committee. I'll also inform you on the scoring criteria and the results of those submissions And then the recommendations to the council from the TIF committee for three Ellsworth citizens to be appointed to the remaining seats. The three voting seats to be filled are Ellsworth at large, or a resident of Ellsworth at large, someone from the Ellsworth downtown community. So that could have been a business owner, a resident, or a tenant in the downtown, and an Ellsworth business member. and then of note there is a non voting youth seat that we didn't receive anything for as of yet but we're going to just keep taking rolling admission or submissions for that and it will remain open until filled so tonight is the three voting seats that we're looking at the committee received four letters of interest actually they all came through an online submission because we created a form to make it easier all our Ellsworth citizens and those four were received from timothy carter john stein karen otto and amy bowles and i know there are two amy bowles this is the amy bowles employed by first national bank and the brief intros i know it's a little late here but just to give you a background they were asked to provide a description of their background relevant experience or community involvement so the real short version from each one from timothy carter i am a retired professional from the pulp and paper industry 40 plus years I worked on both sides of the table major equipment supplier and pulp mill operations I worked with major construction firms in both of the above roles the work involved writing specifications contracts developing cost estimates supervising both people and projects doing postmortems I am now retired and very interested in helping the city of Ellsworth grow in a steady and cost-effective manner from John Stein he is the owner and founder of fog town Brewing Company established 2017 he says, since our founding, I've driven Fogtown's mission toward community engagement and collaboration with other local businesses, nonprofits, and conservation projects. I joined Heart of Ellsworth shortly after and served as vice president on their board for a couple of years. Later, I served as Ellsworth City Councilor for one term, sitting on the Recreation Committee, Solid Waste Committee, HR Committee, Communications Subcommittee, Forum to Homelessness Workshop slash Coalition to better understand the needs of outside organs and social services funding requests during budget season. I also sat on the Historic Preservation Committee and the Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee. And then there's more in there, Frenchman Bay, Conservancy Fundraising, lots of committees and organizations locally. And then from Amy Bowles, as a lifelong resident of this area, I'm passionate about our business community thriving. As a former business owner in Ellsworth, spouse of a current business owner, president of the Ellsworth Area Chamber of Commerce, and a current employee of First National Bank, my roots are very connected with our region. I also served on the Business Attraction Plan Committee several years ago and believe that work would complement this committee. Karen Otto, as an Ellsworth resident and civic leader, my background bridges hands-on downtown revitalization with more than 25 years of professional experience in strategic operations, organizational governance, and community-driven economic development. I have worked closely with the Heart of Ellsworth since 2020, serving on the Board of Directors since 2022 and as Board VP for one year and Board President for the last two years. During this time, I co-led the 2022 Makerspace Feasibility Study to assess local market demand, physical infrastructure needs, and community economic impact, which support broader organizational strategic planning. planning. A central priority of my board leadership has been ensuring that downtown initiatives directly align with the broader citywide goals outlined in Ellsworth's municipal planning documents. She also chaired the Main Street Application Committee and much more. So we got some great letters of interest from these folks. And then two, Timothy Carter and Karen Otto expressed interest in the at-large residency. One was eligible for both the downtown or business seat that was john stein and then one was eligible for the business seat amy bowles so as we scored them and if you want to see
[2:09:59] Council Member: this was our little tweet
[2:10:04] Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director: it doesn't have the title and for those folks listening or watching online it was residency and local stake or stakeholder relevant expertise, civic understanding, time and commitment, conflict of interest review, and that would bring us to a total score, possible score of 100 points. So when these were scored, all the applicants scored above the 70 percent needed to be recommended to the council. Again, there were two competing submissions for the at-large seat, and Timothy scored the highest for that one. So, the committee's recommendation to the council, based on the scoring, is to appoint Timothy Carter to the resident large seat, appoint John Stein to the downtown seat, appoint Amy Bowles to the business seat. And that would complete our seven-member committee and allow the TIF committee to begin working on TIF objectives, like tracking FY27 TIF expenses, evaluating our FY28 TIF considerations, and then to process any TIF or CEA applications from developers that come through. That was a lot.
[2:11:26] City Manager: Just a small note, I mean, huge thanks to Twyla for redesigning all the new TIF districts in record time to take advantage of some of the two-year lookbacks and all the growth here to make sure we don't lose some of the revenue sharing from the increase in growth that we're seeing, and then also doing, not just doing those new TIF districts, but putting in place the accountability mechanisms that institutionally I think will be much better for our TIF districts moving forward. And I'd also note that there is still the council appointee on the TIF district that would need to be made, but that would be appointed by the chair once the new council is seated. So there's still that component that needs to move forward. That's not changing here. That's just a separate piece of the process. any
[2:12:18] Council President: questions or comments for Twyla I have a question if I may is there a
[2:12:28] Council Member: there's four applicants of interest is there any reason why we couldn't accept all four instead of just three council
[2:12:43] Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director: could move to make it a nine member committee instead of seven and then we could I
[2:12:53] Council Member: just hate to see people interested and get cut from the process because
[2:13:02] City Manager: we found just size was chosen ahead of time you know that could have been up more people I even stepped down from being on this committee myself just because you know it's a committee gets too large it can be harder to make a decision especially I think this is an odd numbering committee intentionally as well so that you don't have these split decisions so that's in many ways why that the number amount was chosen and I also felt like the city manager not being a part of this piece is important to that this as well independence from the city manager's position I may be at odds with what I think should move forward with TIF or should not move forward with TIF but it's good to have a little bit more back and forth kind of in the similar way to the budgets done at a department head level then the city manager recommendation then the council final recommendation so I think the size is pretty good and we have other committees that we are thinking of forming as well relative to the budget and audit committee to have more citizen engagement in that part of the work as well and I think Twyla obviously if you believe this person could be a great candidate for that maybe that could be a place we can always use people willing to volunteer and in other areas of government to
[2:14:14] Council Member: make a motion move to move to appoint Ellsworth community members recommended by the TIF committee to the corresponding TIF committee seats I'll second and the non-voting youth position is still available and I do encourage individuals who are interested to seriously apply. This is a wonderful opportunity to learn so much about how the city works and it is it is as the youngest member on the council I can tell you that civic service is worth it and that this is a wonderful opportunity that people should pursue.
[2:15:01] Council President: On the youth note did you reach out to the schools directly or did you just kind of put it out there without kind of honing in on our youth so maybe we could try to get the other Amy Bowles to
[2:15:18] Twyla Fisher, Community Development Director: to send it out or you know try to push it from that and we will that's this great question and i think i you know we put it out there and several city staff contacted folks that we knew were had connections or very connected in the community to reach out as they saw fit to whomever they saw fit and aside from that we kind of left it up to the community to push this forward although our communications director did put it online pushed it out through social media and all that but i think we can do that make a more concerted effort in the future to try to fill that seat i also know it might be kind of hard i don't think i don't we barely know what tiff is we're still learning i think i can look sitting there like what's tiff and why am i going to sit on that committee but we can do a lot to promote it and to put the word out there 's been
[2:16:03] Council President: desire here on this council to yeah for years to get the kids involved more strong could be a first action of the new TIF committee great okay any more discussion all right all those in favor unanimous wonderful thank you okay let's see council order I'm sorry agenda item number 21 council order number one two six one zero discussion and potential action on the request of the parks and recreations and facilities director for authorization to execute a five-year contract extension to A. Atherton for the harvesting of alewives.
[2:16:49] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Roddy. Good evening again. Roddy Erlenbach, parks, rec, and facilities director. Yeah, so as the memo indicates, back in 2017, the city entered a contract with Richard Welch to harvest alewives pursuant to Title 12 MRSA Section 6131. that contract offered a five-year extension if notice was given prior to six months of the expiration of the existing contract. Mr. Atherton came to the Harbor Commission meeting in August and expressed his interest. We did not have quorum at our September or our October meetings so we held a special meeting last week to get a recommendation from the Harbor Commission which they put forward a recommendation to grant the five-year contract extension under the same terms as the existing contract from 2017. So that's where we are this evening. Great. Any
[2:17:49] Council President: questions or comments from Ronnie? Yes,
[2:17:57] Council Member: Governor. Could you speak a little bit to, this just isn't a cost to the city, this process brings in some funds to the city. Could you speak to that a little bit?
[2:18:10] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Yeah, so this year in the budget process, we indicated a possible revenue of $40,000 to the city, and that is basically the contract outlines that Mr. Atherton will go actually do the physical harvesting of the alewives, do all of our reporting to the Department of Marine Resources, which leaves us with no responsibility really than to authorize or to express our interest annually that we want to exercise our right to harvest alewives we then work with the folks at Brookfield to make sure that mr. Atherton has access to the fishway there he does all the harvesting he does all the reporting he makes sure everything is done to the letter of the law and we basically split the proceeds with him the $40,000 possible revenue was based off of averages over the past several seasons this year we fell well short of that it was just a terrible year for the fishery I think we netted like six grand I don't from the from what I'm seeing going back year over year over year that's the worst it's been in decades and that's just a product of the fishery but you look at last year I believe it was I'll let mr. Atherton to speak to that because that those numbers came in before I took my position here with the city but it was it was a lot closer to that 40,000 than the six so but yeah it's a significant revenue source yeah
[2:19:37] Council Member: I just wanted that to be on the record that you know after a dismal year this contractor has come forward and willing to keep going and do it yeah and I didn't know that number but it's it's not just an expense to the city it's it's a it's a contract with a citizen and that contract is feeding leading money to the city.
[2:20:05] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: I don't know if he wants me to mention it or not, but he is in the audience this evening if you have any questions for Mr. Atherton.
[2:20:10] Council Member: It's kind of a unique situation. It isn't very often we get to vote on a contract where the proceeds are really helping two people, the city and the contractor. I don't know of too many of these situations that is such a win-win. I don't know how enthusiastic the alewives are. Yeah you can eat them. They're awful bony. Alright,
[2:20:43] Council President: any questions? There is a motion here.
[2:20:46] Council Member: I'm happy to make the motion. Great. I move to offer Alan Allerton a five year extension of the existing Alewives harvesting contract originally executed in 2017 and subsequently amended by Council Order No. 092110 in September 2021 pursuant to title 12 MRS a 61 31 subject to the finalization of extension terms and execution of an agreement acceptable to the city second any
[2:21:43] Council President: further discussion all those in favor unanimous wonderful congrats okay agenda item number 23 22 sorry council order number one two six one discussion and potential action on the request to authorize the donation for the necessary temporary work area easements for the u.s army corps of engineers inner harbor dredging project and wave compensation and its associated
[2:22:13] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: appraisal costs I was really excited to see this on the agenda yes so this is more discussion about the upcoming Inner Harbor dredging project the work on this has been going on since before I got here that sounds like a recurring theme tonight I do have in the audience this evening Miranda Cashman from US Army Corps of Engineers New England district who is going to answer any questions you may have and do the formal presentation the very high level overview we're looking to perform the inner harbor dredge in the 2028 dredge season at this time army corps is working on getting their budget together so they can put this project out to a bid and they need to reflect all of their costs and expenses one of those typically is the temporary work area easement where they would look at the property where they're going to be doing the work, have a third party come in and do a property appraisal to figure out what fair compensation for that property is in the event we wanted to be compensated for allowing them to use that area to stage equipment and resources while they're performing the work. the actual I think the big piece of information here there is zero cost to the city currently to have the Army Corps of Engineers come in and do the dredge it is not going to cost us anything for to have them come in and do the work so essentially waiving the appraisal waiving the easement and the associated appraisals isn't so much a cost savings as much as it is to accelerate their ability to move the project forward so without further ado I will let Miranda come up in speaking I
[2:24:06] Speaker O (unidentified): heard that I could also plug in is that Is that something that someone could help me with?
[2:24:13] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: Do I do it?
[2:24:15] Speaker O (unidentified): Oh, I log into the Teams? I apologize.
[2:24:17] City Manager: Okay. All right. Well, give me.
[2:24:26] Council Member: The wizard shows up. Don't go down. I was awake.
[2:24:36] City Manager: Ah, there we go.
[2:24:39] Council Member: We're just going to cheat here. You see the salad didn't put you to sleep, huh?
[2:24:42] Eric Nystrom, Water Department Superintendent: No, that's why I had the salad.
[2:24:45] City Manager: Make sure this shows up. Perfect.
[2:24:47] Speaker O (unidentified): Wonderful. Well, thank you so much. I really appreciate it. Hi, everyone. My name is Miranda Cashman. I'm a project manager at the Army Corps of Engineers, New England District. I'm here with my associate, Andrew.
[2:24:59] Council Member: I'm Andrew Fino, Morality Specialist at the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers,
[2:25:02] Troy Gutierrez, Chief of Police: and I've been working with Miranda on this project.
[2:25:04] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, so he can help answer any of the real estate questions. questions. I did anticipate to have some folks online as well who might be able to answer other specialty types of questions about the environmental side or the engineering side. I don't know how many people we actually do have online. I apologize. We do have the flu sweeping through our office right now, so we have several people who are out sick. But as Roddy kind of teed up, I'm here to talk more generally about the project and kind of what real estate we're anticipating to kind of want to use to execute the dredging so i have about maybe like 15 minutes of material and then i'm happy to answer any questions that you have this is my email roddy also has my email if you have any follow-ups or need any more additional information or anything that we can't answer tonight and also huge thank you to roddy for facilitating our visit here today so andrew introduced himself we also have like at the team is comprised of engineers of environmental specialists of real estate specialists program managers etc so without further ado I wanted to kind of start with the project background here the Union River was authorized quite a long time ago in the 1800s and it is considered a federal navigation project so if I say FNP that's what I'm referring to is the federal navigation project here it is outlined in red on the slide so it's It starts at the anchorage where the Ellsworth Marina Park is, goes down, breaks for a distance through the narrows, and then has this swing out into Union River Bay. This project is maintained, or this federal navigation project is maintained by the federal government. That is our responsibility, and that is our authorization to maintain it, to provide safe navigation in this river. the authorized depth is six feet below mean low or low water that's usually the metric we use so that is what we are authorized to maintain it to anything deeper we cannot do without kind of a congressional action so this River was last maintained in the early 2000s at that time the Army Corps removed about 70,000 cubic yards of material that was all placed at an open water disposal site in Union River Bay called Tupper's ledge this is where set at the open water disposal site is really where we can place kind of material that is deemed clean enough to not impact the environment so at that time during like you know the environmental standards did allow for the material to be placed there and since then we are kind of looking at it no longer qualifies to be placed at Tupper's ledge so it is what we call unsuitable and that does not mean it's hazardous it does not mean like it's you know anything hot it just means that it would kind of pose an environmental impact that you know therefore is not kind of deemed suitable to place open water unconfined so our most recent effort started actually about ten years ago where we went back up to do sampling and testing we had heard there was kind of extreme shoaling that needed to be removed at you know and this made that this river needed to be dredged again. As I'm sure you're aware and have experienced, kind of the federal funding process went through its process. And so we received funds in fiscal year 2022. And then it's been kind of a slow roll based on just kind of an influx of work at the Army Corps. So we're looking to dredge again in this river and kind of restore safe navigation. So, like I said, during that 2016-2019 original effort where we were starting to scope what the need was, we were actually planning on constructing a confined aquatic disposal cell. And really what this is, I'm not going to spend too much time because that's no longer the kind of working plan, is to really dig kind of a big hole in the river, place the unsuitable material in it, and then cap it with clean material. And so it kind of becomes just like a little box. It doesn't have like impacts to the environment and it kind of confines the material that is no longer the plan The reason here is several folds. So the original plan was Looking at kind of removing all of the shoal material in the channel, which was about again 70,000 cubic yards We were actually able to reduce that amount of material that needed to be removed because most of the shoaling was happening in this lower reach oh okay perfect okay we can do that it was in that lower reach kind of in the Union River Bay area so that was really where we were seeing the most unsafe navigation this was shoal to like one foot mean low or low water but boats were automatically just avoiding it because they knew the river so what we did was we changed the channel limits we're allowed to do that if our congressional authorization doesn't specify exact coordinates of kind of the bounds of the FNP. And so we coordinated with Coast Guard. We coordinated with Roddy as the harbormaster at the time. And we coordinated with NOAA to make sure their charts were updated. And we realigned the channel to a more central path that avoided some of the most extreme shoaling. The reason why this was really important, one, it reduces the amount of material. to all the material in this lower bay is kind of wood fibers it is wood pulp material this is comes from the kind of the history of the area being a big logging area and a lot of kind of scrap wood being thrown into the river kind of before there were other ways or methods to dispose of it unfortunately that wood pulp material would have completely blown the budget if I'm just kind of to talk frankly that is considered kind of an environmental remediation type project where we would have had to remove the wood pulp and kind of transport it somewhere else to either be burned off or, you know, we wouldn't have been able to dispose of it in the open water. And the second you're trucking 70,000 cubic yards of material off-site, it becomes wildly expensive. So that would have likely been a cost share with the city. And by avoiding that need to remove that wood pulp material, we are able to federally, this is considered a federal action to maintain since there is no new construction and it is not kind of an environmental remediation kind of project that kind of is out of scope of the original charge, which is for us to maintain navigation. So I know I went down a little bit of a tangent, but I do think it's important to just note kind of in the future if this needed dredging for other reasons, it might be a little bit more expensive for the town or for the city and for the Army Corps and for, you know, for the federal government. So our pathway forward, one, avoided this shoaling. So we rerouted kind of the federal channel limits through the center. There is some material here. It's right now about four to five feet below mean low or low water. And again, just because of the nature of this material, We are not able to remove it with our appropriations at this time. It is something that, of course, we can discuss as kind of a future action if and when this does need kind of more scrutiny on providing navigation through this area. So our plan right now is only to dredge the anchorage. That is the other main part of the channel, actually the only part that is shoaled in above that six-foot mean low or low water authorization depth. and so you can see on this figure anything in red is above that and would be removed through this sewage dredging action it's reduced significantly in terms of amount of material it is now around six thousand cubic yards of material that would be removed from just the anchorage and so the plan here is to dredge it to dewater it and then to dispose of it upland and now the reason in here is that we do believe that this is a cheaper pathway to truck upland 6,000 cubic yards of material as opposed to constructing something new. If we were to construct something new to confine this material, that would be a cost share with the city. So we're able to do this on the federal dime. We have enough appropriations to do so, and we can kind of move forward and get it done. All right. Going through kind of those steps of the process first the dredging part this is a more updated figure kind of showing in the light gray the areas that would need to be removed of course you have the parking lot and the park and we can talk about the areas that we are looking to use you know in a few slides but this material would be mechanically dredged so you can think like excavator coming in scooping up the material and then I'll get to the dewatering on the next slide and the way our dredging season works as I'm sure most of you already know it's you know we have our dredge window in the winter so all of this work would be happening between November 1st and April 15th so there's very or hopefully very little impact to recreational use of this area and you know hopefully we'll be in and out pretty fast based on the fact that it's only 6,000 cubic yards. After we scoop it out of the anchorage, we have to dewater it because we are looking to bring this upland. And so dewatering is kind of an open question right now. The reason here is because the Army Corps doesn't prescribe means and methods in their contracts. This allows for more competitive bids. It allows for contractors to come up with solutions that we are not aware of. they might have methods at their disposal they might have equipment that they already own you know that they don't need to rent that makes them a more competitive bid for us so we cannot like prescribe how they will dewater we can give them controls and environmental standards and you know kind of goals to meet in our contract but we are not going to tell them how they will dewater it but some of the potential options that we've heard from contractors by putting this project in front of them is, one, I think the first bullet here is probably the most likely, which is dewatering either on a flat deck barge, which is the top pictures, or on that town landing parking lot area. This would be controlled. There would be things put down. I'm not an engineer nor a construction expert, but the equivalent of a construction level tarp would be placed down on the parking lot to contain sediments things like hay bales and silt socks would be employed to make sure that you're not running material all over the place and kind of it having like run off back into the river that would have adverse effects and this type of the types of controls that we would put in place would also be in coordination with maine dep when we go for our water quality certification so it would all be kind of vetted through the state and also kind of our environmental specialists the second method that's potential but I don't think is likely is geo tubes where you have material pumped into these kind of you know big liners that allow the water to drain out and can contain the sediment and then the last which I think is the least likely is mechanical methods so centrifuges belt presses things that like literally squeeze the water out of out of sediments here next after everything is dewatered to a certain standard we would be disposing of this material so like I said we are looking at trucking this upland for placement and disposal this is like I said not as a cost to the city because we're not constructing something new and it is kind of on par equivalent to two cost of other types of methods for disposal so what this would look like is just dump trucks coming through this area the material will be loaded onto them and they would go to dispose of it again, we're not going to prescribe where it is disposed, but it will be approved by Army Corps. It has to be a state-permitted facility. It can't just be someone's backyard. Those are the types of things we'll be looking for. We think that they'll probably dispose at Juniper Ridge Landfill. That landfill does accept this type of material. We actually got a preliminary approval of the material based on its chemistry when we went out and sampled in May of 2026. And that is the closest place that is state approved, that checks all the boxes, right? That the material would be accepted, is state permitted, and accepts this type of material. I do also want to stress that I know you probably can't see the spec language here, but we do put in our specifications things that the contractor has to restore the site to an equivalent of its original condition. condition. So they would be asked if there was any damage to the parking lot or the boat ramp or anything to replace it in kind. So that is ironclad. Our construction overseers and PMs are watching for this and making sure that before any work is approved as complete, that the site has been restored to its original condition or better. yeah okay briefly want to touch on environmental coordination as well so as I don't think I actually stated this the material in the Anchorage is considered unsuitable for open water disposal that's why we're not going to Tupper's Ledge and that is why we have to kind of dispose of it you know in some in some capacity most of this unsuitableness is based on PAHs and metals in the material and that's just based on kind of runoff from the river and you know things that accumulate kind of in material nearby yeah like industrial centers and such but I've read like everything I said like I said in the Anchorage was approved for Juniper Ridge and we are in environmental coordination right now with federal agencies and Maine DEP for our water quality cert, our CZM consistency, and then all of our, just like our federal coordination that we do. So schedule, as Roddy said at the beginning, we are looking at the dredge window of November, starting November, 2028, and going through the winter to like April, 2029. The reason here is we, because of the strong kind of dredging season especially in Maine we want to make sure that we're timing our solicitation for times when we expect to get competitive bids on this and that we can have good competition and lower prices on a project like this and so while we will probably finish a lot of our engineering and our environmental coordination and you know all of the things that are our real estate sooner than that we want to make sure that we're going out for competitive bids. And that's really kind of the reason it's kind of getting pushed into that dredge season, just to make sure that we will be getting kind of competition. Right now, I know this is a lot of dates and a lot of words, but I kind of started here, which is like the contract solicitation and award, which would be happening in the spring before the winter dredge season in 2028. Everything that happens before that is really the environmental coordination, so our water quality cert and CZM concurrence, our public notice, everything that goes out with our environmental coordination, our plans and specs. So all of the drawings that you see, the engineering, the specifications for what the contractor has to do, what kind of standard they're going to be held to, and kind of what we expect from them. And then our real estate, which is kind of what we're here to talk about today. day, more specifically. So I do have other slides that have more about like the tasks of real estate and kind of how that will play out, but really our biggest items here at a very high level are the appraisal if it is needed, our title exam slash last owner search to prepare those offers to sell, and then negotiation with the landowner. So in this case, we're looking to use city property, so the landowner would be the city, and then closing and recording the temporary work area easements. So in terms of real estate, here's a zoom in. It's oriented a little bit differently from some of my other slides, but we have the river here on the right, and then the parking lot and then the road on the left is kind of the bound here. Right now we're showing kind of the maximum amount of space that we think we'll need. It is very possible. Well, it is possible that the boundaries of this might get tweaked, you know as we go through design But right now we are looking at using as much space as possible in this parking lot and the kind of one more landward The advantage to providing this area to contractors is it does allow them to do water on this area Like lately, you know store their equipment here. And if they are going to end up using it for dewatering, the more area we can provide them, the faster it dewaters, the faster we finish the project and get out of the way. So the gray boxes are temporary work area easements. So we are looking to actually, I think the packet that Roddy sent you, we've since talked about it as a team more, we'd be looking to acquire those temporary work area easements for 24 months or a two-year period that does not mean the work will take two years. The reason that we are acquiring the temporary work area easements for that duration is that if we go out to bid and no one bids, we will not have to come back and reopen all the real estate again with you, with, like, everyone and go through the entire process. We will be able to just go to the next dredge season and solicit again and hopefully, you know, correct. And again, this is all ifs and worst-case scenario, but that is why we would be looking for a two-year temporary work area easement over that. With that comes the road easement. We are looking to do this non-exclusive, a non-exclusive road easement so other people could access this area in emergencies or if the harbormaster needs to come through, maintenance, et cetera. The only thing that we're like kind of continuing to discuss is if there's any safety concerns with that because obviously we want to make sure everyone is safe in this area when the work is occurring. So the work, last thing I'll say about the work is that the work, there's a few windows that I just want to make sure are clear. So, the temporary work area easements, as I explained, we're looking for a two-year period just, again, for safety's sake, making sure that we have them and we don't need to come back and reopen all the real estate again if something were to go sideways. The second kind of window is that dredge window, which is November to April, and then there's the actual amount of work that needs to be done. We're really only expecting this to take one or two months. so by providing the contractor the full window from November to April that will allow more flexibility for when they're able to come in and you know do the work you know this is northern Maine you know and we're trying to do water sediments there is a possibility that they need to work around the season and around the freezing season so that's what those are the windows kind of at play and we would of course be coordinating closely with the city when a contract is awarded to make sure schedules are communicated and that you actually have a sense of when people will be in here and kind of performing the work and how it's going. All right, last slide, I promise. So the question that we've come here today to ask is about the possibility of the city to waive appraisal and donate the temporary work area easements needed for this project. You have the right to an appraisal, you have the right to fair compensation,, but the pathway that I just want to state is that right now we are looking at adding about six to nine months to the schedule if we go down the appraisal route, and that is just based on the amount of time it takes to get an appraiser on board to perform the appraisal and also to negotiate anything that happens at that offer to sell period with the city. If you do waive appraisal, the Army Corps would be asking for a signed waiver and intent to donate. I have shared that with Roddy and kind of a blank form of it for review of counsel if anyone has questions, we're happy to talk about it. And then the process would continue for real estate and the project. And then near the end of the project when we're actually looking to acquire and record the easements, Army Corps would provide, excuse me, provide that kind of offer to sell, but the value would be shown as zero since you had, you know, intended to donate and kind of waive the appraisal. If you don't waive the appraisal, we would start kind of, you know, as soon as possible to get an appraiser on board. it does add a little bit of cost to the project since I would be paying Andrew for his labor to coordinate that and paying the appraiser to do their actual work and like I said the appraisal like that whole process is probably a six to nine months window just based on our experience on other projects with appraisals of this size again the process would kind if you know we would we would start that process we would try to get our appraisal done you know kind of as soon as possible and then the same process would have occur as the waving where one usace would continue with the project and when it came time to do the offer to sell we would negotiate with the city with that kind of compensation that was determined so really the risk here is just schedule and a little bit of money in terms of keeping the project moving you know obviously i'm biased and would love to just kind of be able to move forward and continue without kind of schedule hiccups and delays but is there anything you'd like to add about the real estate process or their right to waive appraisal or anything okay so I know I threw a lot of information and I do have a tendency to talk fast so I will that is the end of my presentation and I'm happy to answer any questions yeah I'm sorry but I'm completely lost with this
[2:48:21] Council Member: real estate totally yeah aspect of this what I do you understand what real
[2:48:29] Speaker O (unidentified): estate yes so acquisition yeah it's that's no it's a it's not it's a great question so we're judging the river yeah and we want to be able to provide our contractor space on land to store equipment or dewater the material coming out of the river so to be able to do that we have to acquire the easement to use the land that we want to use we are proposing that we want to use these parking lot areas in gray and access the site via this road easement and so those are those are the easements we would be looking to not real estate you're
[2:49:05] Council Member: buying its easements you yes okay yes okay I have another question assuming that you go with this dewatering nor the contract it goes with this dewatering the first option that you talked about how temperature and weather dependent is that method
[2:49:20] Speaker O (unidentified): it is very temperature and weather dependent so the contract it would be up to the contractor to so yeah it is very weather dependent is the short answer and that is why the method of dewatering is a bit of in question and that's why i did present some other options that they might come to site with, if they own a centrifuge, if they own a belt press, maybe that's cheaper for them. And they can say, we can do this for cheaper than anyone else on the market using our own equipment. That equipment does take space, so again, that's another reason why we want to provide the space. If they do want to just let it free drain and kind of dry on a barge or on land, they would probably be looking to do this work either early in the season, so like November before the big freeze sets in or closer to the end of the window in like the March-April time frame.
[2:50:13] Council Member: Is it normally associated with odor?
[2:50:19] Speaker O (unidentified): No. Well, that's a good question. I might have to get back to you before I categorically say no odor and then people get mad at me.
[2:50:26] Council Member: People not too far from it about how all they can have with odor. Yeah. Yeah, so... And my other question is, there's people that use this park all winter. Myself, I walk my dog there all the time. So would you be, like, you would really have to close it, right? I mean, you can't have people wandering around dewatering, right?
[2:50:52] Speaker O (unidentified): If we do need to use this full area, it would be harder for people to access the site. I think it would be a question on how safe everything really is. But really, we're expecting either this area is going to be used for, like, contractor equipment, meaning they, like, plop something in that area so they can use it or store it, you know, when they're not working, or sediment. If it's sediment, I think there's less of a risk just because we'll have, like, hay bales and they'll, you know, there might be temporary fencing around the area. You know, obviously, our safety standards, you know, are put into our specs for what we consider, like, what would be safe. we are expecting the most activity to happen closer to the boat ramp to bring the material out of the water and then the trucks exiting the area some of it unfortunately would be like up to the contractor in terms of like exactly how they're going to go about this and so some of it i can't fully answer just based on that but i'll explain Blame it to him.
[2:51:57] Council President: Yeah. This might be a question for Roddy, too. I know we have at least one lobster fisherman that works out of this harbor. Does this – I don't know if he does the winter.
[2:52:10] Speaker D (unidentified): He doesn't go out during the winter.
[2:52:12] Council President: Do we have any fishermen that – what if we had a fisherman come in and wanted to fish?
[2:52:17] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: That would be a two-month window.
[2:52:19] Council President: That would be closed down.
[2:52:21] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: And I did reach out to Doug Beck, Maine Bureau of Parks and Lands. They administer the Land and Water Conservation Fund grant. The Harbor Park was acquired through Land and Water Conservation Fund, and I checked with him on the funding restrictions. LWCF allows for up to a six-month closure for maintenance and upkeep. so we are still well within our rights to close it to public access for up to
[2:52:53] City Manager: six months just to confirm right this is recommended by the Harbor Commission and
[2:53:02] Rodney Erlenbach, Parks and Rec Facilities Director: they've seen these plans last week at the special meeting we held that I referenced on the last agenda item Harbor Commission also put forward a recommendation to waive the rights to appraisal and donate the temporary work Carrie Eastman primarily because if you look at the slide that she had of where within the anchorage one of the heaviest areas of shoaling is the eastern extent of the float dock where that at low tide we have I think it's four vessels who are floating in two feet or less of water and just a huge thanks to the
[2:53:39] City Manager: Harbor Commission I think summer 2024 I went out with the Army Corps of engineers and some staff there and we had some pretty scary conversations about the state of things and potential million-dollar plus matches etc the it's not just this project you all been doing an excellent job of moving forward with in a way that can be beneficial to maintaining the harbor but also to the city's finances but also just even moving that channel right I mean that was something you could have said active Congress we're not going to consider it but was able to do that as this project has gone forward and mark our upper commission chair going out in the boats we have other experts in there this has been a ton of work to it's gonna be a big future upgrade for the city of
[2:54:22] Council Member: Ellsworth back in 22 I believe you mentioned that's when this chatter began I was at a finance meeting and the then city manager came forward and was explaining a little bit of this process and at that point there was a cap sell that it was going to and he had brought a presentation to that meeting that there was going to be at least an $800,000 cost to the city, 400,000 one year, 400,000 the next year. And again, that was in your previous plan. And that was a minimum cost. And to hear that all the city has to do is loan a piece of land and avoid this capping off some ledge somewhere, whatever it is. This is huge that the dredging can happen without local funding. This is absolutely wonderful. And to think that all we have to do is forfeit. Let's say we had to forfeit a season for this dredging. I mean, that's no different than other construction sites that have to forego a hotel renovation for a season or what have you. So things always have to get worse before they get better. And even if avoiding this process of appraisal and we suffer a season without that access, success think of what it's going to do in the next five seasons after i do have one other question you mentioned that the dredge material isn't suitable for open water disposal because of metals we bet we're we're a mill town that's probably from tanning or textiles what happens though when you disturb the bottom like that what happens and you're going to take some of it out but you're also going to disturb the bottom so what happens to the water quality as far as
[2:56:51] Speaker O (unidentified): dissolved and undissolved metals yeah so i 'm a little out of my depth so i will speak to what i understand and know but there has been a lot of research scientifically about what dredging does to marine environments and kind of exactly that question right is there risk to you know users, like people who, you know, swim in water like this? Is there, you know, impacts to benthic organisms and just kind of the state of the environment? Really the studies show that it's a very temporary impact. So a lot of the impact of dredging is like kind of the first 60 minutes after the dredging occurs having higher turbidity in the water, and then it kind of settles out. this is the kind of question though that is coordinated with Maine DEP since we do need to get our water quality cert from them before the project can move forward and that is the type of thing that we discuss with them so based on the chemistry you know based on the action that we're proposing you know do they recommend turbidity curtains or silts curtains to kind of localize the impacts or not right the good thing is that a lot of the material coming out of this area is sand so metals don't typically bind all that well to sand and then of course it settles out much faster the water column than something like silt or clay so most of the material being dredged here is sand but that's exactly the kind of things that we're coordinating with the state and all of you know like i said i can only speak to kind of what i understand but that there's the studies don't show kind of lasting impacts okay yeah good to know any
[2:58:33] Council President: other questions thank
[2:58:37] Speaker D (unidentified): you so much for that presentation that was really it was
[2:58:42] Council President: really enlightening and yeah we have been talking I know Charlie's mentioned this to me a few times and it was very scary when you first started talking to
[2:58:52] Speaker D (unidentified): me about this like yeah Mike Steve was saying they were big numbers and it's wonderful that you guys have found a way to make it affordable for everyone here
[2:59:05] Council President: so thank you I think there is a motion here if anyone wants to authorize the
[2:59:16] Council Member: donation of necessary temporary work area easements for the US Army Corps of Engineers Inner Harbor dredging project and wave compensation and associated appraisal costs subject to final easement terms and conditions acceptable
[2:59:33] Council President: to the city further discussion all right all in favor unanimous wonderful thank you so much thank you guys okay agenda item number 23 executive session to discuss personal matters in accordance with MRSA title 1 chapter 13 section 405 paragraph 6 a should we go to quick break yes absolutely MS. Quick break. MR. What's that?