← Back to MaineScanner

Mount Desert Comprehensive Plan Committee Discusses Housing, Short-Term Rentals, and New State Laws

2026-11-05 · 1h 16m · Source: Comprehensive Plan Committee meeting November 5, 2026 (Town of Mount Desert (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[12:06] Speaker A (unidentified): some of the new state law changes so we're starting to see everything sort of come together here which is why i think we need to have sort of all the various parts talking through as we get to this because i think this you know like we i think we said a week ago this is where the rubber is starting to hit the road here a little bit with this one so that's just my piece if there's anything you wanted to comment on further david or don't i mean i missed the meeting [12:34] Speaker B (unidentified): i watched it on zoom and it's just i'm thrilled that it's bubbling up from committees and at the select board level i just want to keep it a priority something i'm hearing about from votes and i know everyone went through this a couple years ago i wasn't i was a town meeting but i wasn't involved in it in detail, but it just seems like a really important time to bring these efforts together. The comp plan is obviously broad brush, as it should be. The LUSO is very detailed, and we seem to be facing a situation where we're talking about it because there's these state mandated changes that we don't want to just usher in and have them inadvertently become a boon for short-term rentals so how the timing lines up i don't know but i want to learn and i want to carry the ball as much as i can at the select board level and talking to people so i you know gail you can talk better than i can about well my one committee doesn't get ahead of the other committee right and my sense is quite [13:45] Speaker C (unidentified): quite frankly, in November, my sense is that we had a, I had a brief discussion with Katrina after that last meeting, and Katrina said, well, to tell you the truth, I wasn't really locked in on what was going on, and I'm like, I was locked in on what was going on, and I still would flunk a quiz about what was going on, because it just is so hard to lock in on and say, oh yeah, we're gonna have to do that and that and that, and be able to recite it. I don't have it, even after all the times I've heard it. it. We do have to do that stuff. I know there's some desire to revisit the larger issue of short-term rentals. I don't see that happening this year. I see, I mean, it's just way too overwhelming and I think that a lot of groundwork needs to be laid before anyone should consider going to that extent again. However, we have to do what we have to do for the state law unless they're beginning to tell us there may be further delays, which I always look forward to from the state and we have we and that is an inflection point in terms of our policies about those things about that greater density that's going to be we're going to be required to allow what if anything do we want to put for guard rails on that and that i think is a good news i can tell is probably a good way to focus people's attention on that subject without maybe threatening people who already have short-term rentals. I mean, a lot of locals and stuff like that. It's like, okay, this was law was passed and we're being required to do this. And you may not like that greater density that's being proposed in your neighborhood, but the purpose of it was to increase availability of housing. So how do we keep it, as other towns are concerned about, how do we keep from just turning it into some developer coming in and putting up a four apartments on a lot and renting them all out short-term all the time. So I think that's where we're at. I don't see us floating on a whole comprehensive short-term rental this year. I don't see how that would be possible with everything else. It's not. Timing-wise, it's not. No, it's not. I mean, it's just like, does that jive with your sense of how the world spins? [16:01] Speaker A (unidentified): spins I mean to put a true ordinance out for the spring we'd need to kind of stop the presses to get there pretty fast yes and we're already doing that for the comp plan and we actually [16:13] Speaker C (unidentified): we're sort of doing it for all these changes we have to do to the ordinance which are going to be [16:19] Speaker D (unidentified): have the potential in some areas to be very significant yeah and I think that's where [16:25] Speaker A (unidentified): was sort of going with it a little bit too like this right here is in many ways how do you put this like the warning shot across the bow of okay we're gonna do this heads up everyone here it comes which is why i think also when we talk about this coming up i mean we'll have a lot of other stuff in there and this came up last night in sustainability where there was There's a number of things from A Climate to Thrive that there's going to be in the comprehensive plan, but I think this is going to drown out that just as we start talking through this. [17:05] Speaker C (unidentified): It's the issue that drowns everything out. The issue has drowned everything out in the last conference. I mean, the issue of affordability and availability. [17:14] Speaker A (unidentified): But in terms of how these pieces all are going to fit together in the timing, I mean, I'm still trying to puzzle that together myself as well. [17:23] Speaker E (unidentified): So yeah. [17:25] Speaker D (unidentified): Can I offer some observations? So I think just in the context of the comprehensive plan, housing is a comprehensive topic. And the bigger thing is that the comp plan and the data recognizes that there's more housing that is available to year round community members is what's the desired goal. There's multiple ways to get there. There's, you know, you build more, you keep more stock that's already here, used year round, you do infill development or convert things. There's like a bunch of different, there's ways to do that. And so the comp plan deals with those things comprehensively as a set of strategies, theoretically,, and where the action, where the implementation plan and the comprehensive plan comes in is to say more specifically than you've done in the past, that this is the highest priority that the town has. And we've taken the time to put something on paper to say we will start to address those things in a certain timeframe. And that by doing that is basically kind of putting the town on notice and then by virtue of the policymakers the select board we're going to we're going to get behind this and so what it says is we're going to create this we're going to recreate the economic development group and call it the housing and economic development committee and their first order of business is to create a housing action plan which will include all of some elements of all of these things and we're not going to deal with what exactly that is but just provide kind of the outline for them to do it. So within a year and a half, basically, here's our, you know, the Mount Desert Housing Action Plan, which hopefully we'll have actual actions that people can follow through with. So that's like, that's where partially where the comp plan comes in, what it what it does is actually says, the town is going to dedicate the resources and time that is necessary to do those things. Where the I think this where the new state laws and the you know the discussion around short-term rentals comes in it's like we are already going to have to we have to go through that policy conversation because we have to adopt those changes and that what that does i think is provides an opportunity to have the like the short-term rental conversation maybe more constructively and thoughtfully than you know coming back with another ordinance right away like if i were my recommendation would be like, let's take the time while we're doing these policy changes to really ask the question, you know, we're being either forced or the states made it so that we're going to change our density rules. You know, how should that housing be used? How should we think about that and start to think about the pros and cons of all that and then develop that maybe into another policy that comes down the line, like next year? So, I think it's a real opportunity to actually engage with the conversation and not rush it. [20:46] Speaker C (unidentified): These ordinance changes are like the guardrails for having that discussion. [20:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, they're not just the guardrails. I mean, we have to do it, but I think it's the- [20:53] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, it doesn't make it a broad, short-term rentals, it's these kind of short-term rentals. Correct. You're right. [20:59] Speaker D (unidentified): And I also think it's the reason to move beyond the shell shock from the last conversation. conversation. Like you have to have that conversation. It's the opportunity to have the conversation rather than just say it's too, it's that was too emotional last time. We're not going to deal with it. Like now you kind of have to. [21:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. Can I ask a question on a slightly different topic? We're going to create, we're going to constitute the housing and generally and economic development underpinning, as I've said before, all of these housing availability and affordability questions is the structural inequities and challenges in our community system I don't know how we think about the economic development committee grappling with that issue as part of that because I don't think you can have a reasonably successful housing development program unless you're talking about the larger forces that have got us into this mess to begin with and i think wherever there are opportunities you know constructive opportunities to raise those issues whether it's talking with the state about what their policies might be i think that has some issues some proposals and ideas that come out of the next state government or wherever yeah [22:23] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I'm curious how other people on the committee feel about that, and my sense would be that if we're just really focusing in on what we're trying to do in the comprehensive plan is provide guidance for the things at a really high level that group is going to sort of wrestle with. if that's something that needs to be added even just as a placeholder we could certainly do that in the comp plan and then i would say i mean not to pump the issue too hard but you know that's an issue that they could really wrestle with and i would say you know to i think those are questions that i mean you know you guys have heard me say this a bunch of times like is that what's the higher question and then at what level or what point does it need to get addressed and how is it most effectively addressed like there's a it's a continuum i agree with that it's just that if [23:20] Speaker C (unidentified): we it's like the it's like the elephant in the living room and if we don't if the committee of the people working on that don't have whatever their framework happens to be for it doesn't have to be mine but if they don't kind of understand those levers and pressures and realities then And I think it's potentially going to hamper their ability to come up with proposals and ideas that are actionable. Why? Because we can talk all we want about building a few houses here and a few houses there, but we can only do so much within just staying within the confines of our little town. town. And if we don't see it within the larger context, I mean, it's not just our town's problem, it's every town's problem. It's all over the place. It's a very similar issue. And so where the Libra is not only here, but in other levels of political organization,, which we are, aren't we missing on potential opportunities by not participating or not being aware of what might be going on in other places that we might want to say at the state level, we might want to say to our representatives, we like this proposal, we'd like to support that proposal, this would help. Because this will further our desire to be able to afford to build this or help people be able to afford to actually do this. That's all. I'm not saying you make it your primary mission when you get up in the morning, but to me it's obvious that 's a big part of what do you think we can accomplish without putting it in the understanding it within the broader context of the forces that have created the situation we're in now? [25:17] Speaker A (unidentified): sure at the local level we're only going to be able to do what little bits we can do within the town that's the limitation we're going to face that doesn't mean that the group shouldn't still do everything they can at that end what i would not want to see housing and economic development turn into is an advocacy group first and an implementation group second i guess is what my concern there was listening to that because at that point in time, there is some real work to be done here around ordinances around some of the TIF district talks around a lot of these things. There are things that this group can sink its teeth into. And that's all I'm saying is I'd prefer that they sink their teeth into those things. Yes, there's bigger picture forces at play. But it's sort of like you said, asking housing and economic development to tackle wealth inequality in the country as a whole. [26:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Not necessarily tackle it but if we don't understand if people working on it aren't understanding how we get you know trying to understand how also how we got to this place. How can you work your way try to work your way out of it as effectively as possible. That's all okay i'm not however i honestly do think i mean there may be an issue about that according to campaign rhetoric there may be an issue about different tax levels for second homes in this state who is it in this community working on these issues who should look into this and consider whether or not it could have a positive or negative impact on how we actually implement and get more opportunities to actually build housing and provide housing and to help people maintain the year-round residences that they have I think that one [27:17] Speaker F (unidentified): aspect of what that committee should do is make sure that they are well-versed what the state is proposing correct yeah implement it and make best use of it yes yeah [27:29] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm not looking for us to become frontline advocates but we have to be we have to understand what the drivers are and try to figure out how best to work to make those work to our advantage to accomplish what we're trying to do which is have more people live here who aren't like bajillionaires [27:54] Speaker E (unidentified): i just think that you're what I hear is your adversity to having people with funds live in this community be it year round or summer and what we need to do is embrace everybody because everybody brings something to the table some people bring money some people bring labor some people bring talent and we need to embrace that and if we don't embrace it we're going to continue to have these little pods of twirling in their own little places and it's not going to work we have to we have to embrace the people that have funds because they're going to help us do something else and we have to embrace the people that have talent because they're going to create some i mean just we have to be open. I think you need to be a little bit more open minded about having some people with money in our community. [28:52] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, it's a given that we have people with money in our community. And I know full well that if the people with the kind of money are in our community already, really were encouraged and motivated to they could actually finance a tremendous amount of what we need to do to have you around. I don't have to think that's good public policy but that's the end of there at this point in time so i totally get that it's not like i'm talking about being personally alienating to individuals who are already here but there's a reason we're in the mess we're in and it's not there's reasons we're in the mess room [29:36] Speaker E (unidentified): anybody [29:41] Speaker D (unidentified): else and [29:46] Speaker G (unidentified): what i got from that was we need very educated people on that committee people that are critical thinkers that are going to reason if we pull this lever what happens at the other end because as soon as you today well we could tax a second home well what if a corporation owns that home and the owner rents it from their own corporation like there's like you just have to play out these war games and like how are people going to subvert whatever we're trying to do you know so you have to go into it with that you know okay we tack corporations and now anybody with a business that's a corporation you know okay now we need three tiers of taxes yeah so I just want [30:26] Speaker D (unidentified): smart people working on that sure I would also urge everybody to think about the bigger picture which is we need more homes for year-round people and there's a bunch of tools to do that and try not to get overly bogged down and trying to work through an action plan that like deals with every single scenario that's like trying to write an ordinance today for something that we cannot possibly fathom you know a year and a half from now like they're living things so but you get lost in the weeds and you're not gonna you know do some you know do something meaningful you can easily spend 18 months just trying to figure out all the different ways this is going to play out but it's a i mean it's a good point to consider keeping in mind as it goes down like if you do this what happens to this kind of thing and that committee should really be seeking [31:21] Speaker G (unidentified): developers maybe not in this area but people that do commercial development people that have those second homes how do you arrange your corporate structure you know because that's [31:34] Speaker D (unidentified): things that we don't think about but they do certainly strategies and education to be to be had as part of that group you know i think the point for the comprehensive plan and the reason why alex i think was not triggered but by what triggered your thinking last time was that we're actually in this plan taking a much more proactive and forceful to some degree recommendation than has been happened in the past and by that i mean here's what you're going to do in three months and here's what you're going to do in 18 months and we're committing to putting the resources and time aside for that we're committing to put together a committee that [32:20] Speaker F (unidentified): will solely focus on that which i think is we really haven't had that kind of focus or [32:26] Speaker B (unidentified): commitment yeah so i'm i'm not a member of the committee i'm sitting here just like remember, what I hear Gail saying I think is two things. One is sort of fundamental societal drivers that we should think about. May or may not go in the plan, probably not go in the plan, but to be smart about leveraging other levels of this activity is a given, I think. I mean, I think we have to do that. It's leverage, it's policy. We have a governor coming in who's, this is a huge part of what she wants to do. So I absolutely hope that this committee will really have its finger on the pulse of what's going on at different levels so our town can leverage and thrive and tap in. [33:25] Speaker D (unidentified): yep where i added that was on the second page i just was going to add some language under the maybe a bullet even to something like that yeah how can you so this is what comes into the action plan so while we're trying to do right now and there's really two places that this can happen one is in the action plan you want to set up an action item that's basically making sure that you have the kinds of conversations that gail's talking about and you're also tuned into capitalizing on whatever sort of federal and state and other initiatives are happening i think sort of like what you were saying kathy and then underneath that there's the actions to begin immediately and i think last time we did take this out because i wasn't quite sure how i deleted the part about i wasn't even talking about last time but because i was trying to figure out how to write something like that like just be aware of and in tune with all the things that are happening now so you can you know make the most of them essentially is what we're i think we're getting at but i can add something isn't it but that's like you're now committing to doing that even while the action plan is being developed some [34:39] Speaker F (unidentified): people might read this and think wait a minute is the town going to start building housing maybe and it's good and it's going to be some kind of investment at some level in some way and when it gets time to public feedback and that public meetings i think we're going to have questions about that sure i'm wondering if you should have a suggestion box put in your questions put it so people can be anonymous about here try this Yeah. Yeah. I feel comfortable speaking out loud about. Yep. Some ideas. So I'd love to try to [35:16] Speaker D (unidentified): understand in a way that's constructive is how to present this in a way that's saying this is a this so this action plan is the first step that we all talked about as a way to make meaningful progress on this issue of housing which we all think is the most important thing that we can do and it really flows through the existing comp plan and the new one that we're writing and so in the action plan if somebody asks is the town going to be in this conversation for where we are now if somebody asks the question is the town going to be building housing i would ask i guess my question would be well let's talk about the pros and cons of that and how do we address that in a comprehensive plan that we're just recommending that people address that like i don't want to i would love to have that conversation but i also don't want to i want to kick the can down the road a little bit too just because we'll never this is not the place to address that like to me the action plan would be the place to address that yeah [36:19] Speaker C (unidentified): the second in the action plan the sort of the meat of it for me is the evaluation of the housing tools namely this plan the recommendation will pursue and it has that it's on the second i'm trying hard to wrap my head around what that's going to look and sound like and i mean do you perceive particular individuals or entities or organizations who are going to be able to deeply understand and recommend and how will this committee develop in a pretty short order the type of intensive expertise that's going to be able to sift through and figure out so what will might work best and what won't work yeah my other [37:08] Speaker D (unidentified): thing that this plan does is acknowledge the fact that you're going to have a committee that's assigned to do this work but that the committee might not be the committee might need outside assistance to understand both the tools that they have at their disposal and how they might work. So it's not just that the committee has to spend time talking about it and doing research on their own. There are experts all over the place that understand the tools and how those tools might be applied. And so I think what I would envision is first, here's a list of tools that we should be talking about and then have a conversation about which tools seem to make sense for the town of mount desert and then how would those tools work in the town of mount desert and then even more specifically like okay how are we going to use this tool by what time and how we let's get specific about it but the action plan could even be something as simple as like you know you it's more about we're not going to have the time here in this process to really deep dive into to any of these things so at the end of the day the action plan could be very simple like if you had to pick four things that you had to do for housing in the next three years what would those four things be and one of them could be we need to set aside some funding every year to do a housing development i don't know i'm just making stuff up but like that's the part of the point of the action plan and it kind of gets it's it keeps getting revisited it's not going to be the end of it. But if you don't, I think that where we came out on this conversation is if we don't actually just say we're going to do something, then it's all these policies that are almost exactly the same as they were in 2009 are going to be the same, you know, 20 years from now. So we actually have to do something. I don't think, so I guess I'm rambling all over the place to answer your question, which is, I believe that what will end up happening is that you'll have to set aside some resources to have somebody help the committee understand what those tools are and how they work. And it could be multiple different people that are going to do that. [39:19] Speaker C (unidentified): And I think it gets back to Vincent's point. We're going to need people who are talented. [39:26] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. Or easy to say, like, you know, you guys are starting work on TIFFs. And that's a tool. And you've got an expert via Alex's connections to help you develop the TIFF. and what is that tiff for and then you have a board of selectmen who is working on trying to figure out like here's our here's the policy framework around that tiff and how it's going to help us achieve these goals but that could be happening here and it could be you know once you do an evaluation of here's the town available town land the committee might say well great we have these resources available to us let's partner with island housing trust who actually does more, you know, like you've already, they've already done, you know, those are just continuations of things that you've already done, or you could be something even more innovative than we've already talked about. Maybe it's just like our role is to help pay for infrastructure improvements and support development in the ways that we can easily pull levers on, at least for the short term, because they're, those are the easier things for us to manage but it's more than just talking about it that it's actually like doing it [40:38] Speaker A (unidentified): yes that's what I'm trying to get at and to come back something Kathy said earlier the question about you know is the town of Mount dessert getting into building housing I think there's two ways to answer that one is simply the committee will evaluate whether or not that's the best way to go about it but along those lines i think you just hit on something where the this town and most towns will always have the most expertise and probably the best ability to produce the most bang for the buck is the underlying infrastructure roads water sewer that's what towns do already that's where they tend to know this stuff so sticking to that end of it that would always be the way to go. And that's not insignificant investment by any stretch of the imagination. So that's always gonna be where the town can go best. Yeah. [41:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Kathy, have you ever learned or communicated with the folks at Jackson Lab who built the apartments for employees? Is there anything noteworthy there that's... [41:45] Speaker F (unidentified): That they have a very long waiting list as soon as they built them, that there were people more interested in smaller of the apartments like the one and two bedrooms are much more of interest than the three bedrooms they split one day two buildings one with pets one with no pets right yeah process yeah very long process and they did not want to be the landlords so [42:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Correct, they form that out. Yeah, those are all things to know about. [42:19] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, first cut for me working with any committee would be like, what are the tools that the municipality has already existing that are not overly, they're not stretching the boundaries of things that towns actually do and are supposed to do. you? That's like the real that's like the easy, easiest first cut, it's regulatory policy. It's infrastructure development, it's whatever there's a there's, there's a handful of things, there's only really only a handful of things. And then there's like, what are the new things that are coming down the line that would allow you to do even more? And is that advocating for, you know, local option taxes, so you actually have more flexibility to do things that are probably back to your core things are there you have land that you can give is it a tax-acquired property that you could use for something that's a that's a where i don't know if there's ever ain't going to be any tax-acquired property amount but like these are other times that you have to deal with that i was in i was in danforth the other day i think they have like 10 tax-acquired properties and it's like holy smokes so yeah it's like just identifying those tools and levers first is a good start and the policy choices are there's some policies conversations like the one we just had about short-term rentals that like it that's a that's a big tool and a not insignificant conversation so [43:52] Speaker A (unidentified): when we do the meeting this will be probably where the front and center handouts correct [Speaker D (unidentified): yep okay yep] this is our last chance to really let's get after it yeah right [44:04] Speaker D (unidentified): Yep. Okay. Yeah. You don't like it. What's that? If you don't like it, now's your chance. That's where I was going. Yep. [44:11] Speaker F (unidentified): If this is gonna be hand out, are we gonna make it available in advance? Sure. People. Yeah. On the website and we can leave people to that first because this is a lot to take up. Yep. [44:21] Speaker D (unidentified): Mm hmm. Happy to put it up. I'm gonna sit and read it. Nobody. Yep. I'm gonna put a big old draft watermark on the back of it though too. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Yeah. Mm hmm. Well, I read it and sent you some comments. I actually saw another short-term rental thing on the same bullet that Gail was talking about, but I think that's the one we decided to keep. [44:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, it's a little bit more embedded. Yeah, catch up David on that one. One of the real struggles we had here was the first version of this said the word short-term rental a lot more than this version did and we sort of we were a little gun shy yeah poison pill yes and so it's this real interesting question of just how much do we or don't we talk about this and this so that's why you see us going back and forth on it a little bit it's yeah elephant the room versus poison pill and where do we land on all this kind of hits also the last bullet [45:27] Speaker D (unidentified): it under the outline for the action not the second to last goal that's under the action for the outline for the action plan where i say monitoring a monitoring program with annual progress report i might just suggest we take out the last part using data definitions i think just having a monitoring plan is probably enough i just noticed that i forgot yeah i mean what is [45:54] Speaker A (unidentified): the state of maine's municipal housing data collection i don't actually yeah there's some [45:58] Speaker D (unidentified): some of that, but it's too complicated and it's not worth putting in. Keep it simple and then the committee and in developing the plan can come up with the actual thing. [46:11] Speaker E (unidentified): Under the actions to begin immediately, would the assessor be able to help with completing the baseline inventory of year-round and seasonal homes? He doesn't know which ones are which. [46:24] Speaker D (unidentified): So I think last time we had this conversation and we decided it was just going to be a I was using his management authority to help people on staff help if it makes sense and not really assign assessor slash CEO to any of that. [46:43] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm actually not sure how we're going to get that information. [46:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, that's part of where we were going with it. And this was a request from the select board Monday. Yes, Monday. It's been a long week for us to make another stab at combining that data. The best path to do it is there are a lot of software companies out there that essentially, to be honest, scrub the internet to get at this information. And that tends to be the best method to get at it. It's not exact. There's also going the poll route, but that relies on people to respond to it, which is where the data scrubbing is probably the better way to go. It's not that hard to get at this stuff, to be quite honest. It's all out there. Perhaps people doing short-term rentals that aren't using the internet in any way would be missed, but all five of those people aren't really a hard. You can't really do it that way. So that would be the best method to do it. But yeah, in terms of the assessing database, base. It's what kind of a structure is it? Is it heated or not could be used to be an indicator, but that's still not going to determine whether or not it's rented or not. And so if you think about it for both from Kim and Kyle's perspective, they're thinking about the structures themselves. [48:12] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes. Well, not thinking about was it a seasonal rental? Was it a short term rental? And I was just thinking of, does it [48:19] Speaker A (unidentified): have heat or not you know yes that part yes sorry i misunderstood that yes we do have [48:24] Speaker C (unidentified): the data about vague quote-unquote vacant properties i mean we've discussed in the state in the town we've discussed the percentages of properties that are deemed vacant which means [48:37] Speaker A (unidentified): they're not used all year and that data came from the same idea or so where we hired a software company to go out there and scrub the internet for that yeah so that's where that first version came from we'd be doing something similar again. And that in fact is what I really don't like which [48:51] Speaker C (unidentified): is what's happening that time is that number keeps going up it's not the people. [48:57] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah I think there's a few sources. The community itself is even several years ago it was over [49:06] Speaker D (unidentified): 63%. Yeah I think there's a few sources you can pull together to come up with like a good pretty good guess for what you need. Again back to my other point with don't get in you don't have to get super deep into the weeds on data you just need a good clear picture there's always another data point you could try to get but it's not going to change the result of your conclusion [49:26] Speaker C (unidentified): and the reality is in terms of what people are willing to do about it is going to depend on [49:30] Speaker D (unidentified): whether or not the data jives with what their sense is and also data doesn't always keep up with [49:36] Speaker G (unidentified): you know current times so what i'm hearing is this first bullet point compile a housing baseline inventory is a guess at housing inventory it's not precise but we're going to update it each [49:51] Speaker D (unidentified): year sure guessing I think if you set up the model you could have a key with that it's like [49:56] Speaker G (unidentified): what's the alternative I don't know actually digging and actually doing a really investigative survey and then keeping up to date but it just seems like you're like well about 64 is seasonally used and next year it's about 64 because our plus and minus is five percent on our [50:18] Speaker D (unidentified): guesses i would even i would take it to a slightly different level which is what's going to be important is to over time use it as a visual tool as well not just a percentage tool and that if you correlate it with like on a gas map and you just use two different colors and say here the dark colors are seasonal and the light colors are not you can go all through the town and just be like and you can see and like it just gives you a visual representation of like oh okay this is here's a change over time or this is what we're looking at today and you know how did that affect you think about his neighborhoods you have to have knowledge of how individual properties being used i guess what i'm saying is i think there's enough data points out there that you could come up with a pretty reasonable sense of how that is even if the committee like in selfless harbor and we've even done this for like northeast harbor you just know you know it's a pretty good guess of who's who's around right good enough for the tool yeah the other thing is before you know where we just bought a bunch of data on short-term rentals for hancock Cocke County. And we haven't had a chance to add it into the GIS yet, but won't be so we'll share that before you like go out and try to get more but that might be really simple. Yeah. [51:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Because if that gets us fine enough, [51:41] Speaker D (unidentified): it's for that probably our rental conversation, it will be [51:44] Speaker E (unidentified): helpful. Yeah,. Different topic, but same topic. How is the survey that Southwest Harvest doing being received? And how is it going forward? I haven't. Have you done it? I haven't [51:57] Speaker D (unidentified): received the survey yet. So, I don't know. Nobody surveyed me. So, how is it being received? but I think the town is using whatever the cousin group is doing is a good tool and a lot of it was like I think research from individual members of the community knowing like who lives where I [52:14] Speaker C (unidentified): could be wrong. It isn't Tremont. Didn't think they were. huh. They did an online survey recently. Like [52:20] Speaker D (unidentified): like they've they wanted to do a survey yeah engage people's opinions on the topic yes how the properties are being used right selfless did an actual well that's useful inventories like that was yeah one or two committee members like really engaged with that and that's as a result of the of the necessary watching yeah again my sense is because i've experienced this a number of times we already know anecdotally what's happening we're just trying to find some additional support to like put a pic paint that picture a little bit more specifically but it's a policy you get it don't don't ignore the policy question in favor of just doing the research like the research is going to tell you the same answer you already [53:10] Speaker C (unidentified): know yeah except that if you actually get to the point where you're like, applying for something or, you know, I think you can make my statistics work already. [53:23] Speaker D (unidentified): Hey, don't have to have the policy discussion. It's a toughie like. [53:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think we're ever going to have a hard time proving that we have a lot more people in the summer than the winter. [53:37] Speaker G (unidentified): I just don't want to screw up this committee that at the top of this page, plan should not repeat the work of, you know, don't get bogged down in the data. And then it says at the bottom, go get some data. Yes, concerned that work. [53:51] Speaker D (unidentified): 1 of them could happen now 1 of them will be doing that tomorrow. Yes. My point was for that, but yeah, the other 1 is just. Again, back to my big push, which is like, you've got a lot of reports have already been done to tell you what's up with housing. Now you have to figure out actually how to get the housing. That's the hardest part. So I highlighted on page two, just so we can talk through this a little bit, I highlighted the select board, town manager, LUSO committee planning board at the end, because I thought we might want to talk about who's supposed to be doing that. I know how much Gail loves it when we assign LUSO committee. Yeah. [54:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. And I think, and I will say the same thing here. The LUSO committee has never been, and we had that discussion with the select board a year or two ago, that the JavaScript for the LUSO committee is not to be a generator of policy or is to do the try to do the work of creating the changes that other decision making bodies are proposing like this if the select board wants there to be a policy you know it's about this or the planning board recognizes they can answer something about that or however it gets to us that we do it that we don't sit around on our own and say now what can we create in order to solve a housing problem you act on decisions that others are making yeah because we're not we're not a decision-making body we're an advisory committee we don't have any and so and it's frankly we don't i don't get to get the committee together that often and we don't have a lot of bandwidth in order to keep up with of big sweeping changes and I don't see us developing strategies for building [55:57] Speaker D (unidentified): housing. I was going to recommend the Housing and Economic Development Committee but I then I got this is what I was doing on some edits and then I was like well wait a minute are we there isn't one yet and so should we be recommending that they do it if these are things that are supposed to be happening now but I think by the time the comp plan gets adopted there really are the appropriate group to get started on that or is that too much for them if they're [56:24] Speaker A (unidentified): trying to develop an action plan well I was going to have a different route which is the you're talking about the housing and economic development doing all this work so why would they be forwarding it on to themselves yeah that's true you're creating a circular route there it's almost like you can skip them because they're already doing right they're already the driver of all this yeah so [56:49] Speaker D (unidentified): i think yeah the point of the things that could begin immediately were was to facilitate more you know stuff that could be happening while you're establishing the group and they're working on the action plan i was somewhat contrary to what i just [57:08] Speaker C (unidentified): said but not really i don't have any problem with the housing and development committee coming up of a bunch of ideas that are going to require ordinance changes and then coming and then bringing in on coming to the loser committee and saying what can we do you know we facilitate that with land use ordinances well you know if you need land use ordinance changes to do this can you guys help us with that i that would be appropriate but likewise the planning board because the losers actually exist because the planning board couldn't keep up with the work the planning board is supposed to be doing this is all like fly a piece of planning board work that doesn't get done by the planning board except by those of us who are also in the planning board [57:55] Speaker D (unidentified): it all makes sense gail yes do you think that bullet we could just delete and move it [57:59] Speaker A (unidentified): up to the action plan yes [58:04] Speaker G (unidentified): great [58:10] Speaker D (unidentified): settled the next one inventory town-owned land suitable for housing noting size zoning access and utilities that to me is a pretty easy gis exercise that kyle could do but i just kept you i kept town manager on there as an assigned tab to somebody [58:29] Speaker A (unidentified): else okay with fluence it's the next one where i keep struggling yeah just because geography is working hard against us on this one sure you're not going to come up with a pond in sumsville that works for water supply getting jordan pond water all the way to otter creek is going to be tough but there needs to be a part of this plan that studies it and whatever [59:07] Speaker C (unidentified): depth you need to study it and want to say well that's a problem we're going to have i mean it needs to be a piece of what of a puzzle even if it's just rolling things out yeah it's not like it's not it's not a bullet point that says do the following digging to do the following connections. I mean it's like what could we do? [59:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Just I don't want to give people false hope. That's all. Yeah that's my concern there. Yes. [59:37] Speaker D (unidentified): is there a better way to phrase the type of study that we're you know of starting the evaluations that [59:43] Speaker A (unidentified): we're talking about? What begin studying the possibility. Yes [59:47] Speaker F (unidentified): exactly. Yes. [1:00:00] Speaker D (unidentified): Opportunities and constraints for. that works too. Yeah. [1:00:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. You want to say when you when you talk with us through and probably just gilding a little bit where they would support year-round housing you want to add something that ends supportive economic activity or something like that because it isn't like we talked about creek and we talked about the sunsville north sunsville [1:00:37] Speaker D (unidentified): everybody okay with that yeah that's fine i [1:00:41] Speaker C (unidentified): mean i would go i'm sad but just as well supportive [1:00:44] Speaker D (unidentified): economic okay all right so we all i mean just to get through this section we all we're good with this, right? This is a good, I mean, I think it'd be really interesting to engage with people that come to this meeting with this strategy in mind, and to also try to keep them at the larger question for the implementation is how should we take our highest goals and move them into action. And so we stopped talking about the goal and actually try to do something about it open [1:01:29] Speaker F (unidentified): to all ideas well this is a heavy lift for people to read and absorb and respond to sure and i think anything we can do to get it out in advance and give people a chance to do that before the meeting because then you're going to have a higher quality [1:01:47] Speaker A (unidentified): conversations with yep well you can talk to our harder story yep I wonder it's [1:02:01] Speaker D (unidentified): around it's about it that'd be pretty interesting to talk to him about the sexual all right well let's dig into the priorities for other topic areas [Speaker A (unidentified): one] One thing to highlight is what I tried to do was take, some of the short-term strategies and just sort of pick a couple and may or may not be the ones. And then one thing I thought was really interesting is that there are no short-term economic development goals or strategies. Of course, I'm housing. I know, but I mean, so I would say yes. And isn't, so. [1:02:45] Speaker C (unidentified): I guess I just leave it out Oh, because it's going to, or do you have to have a bullet point? [1:02:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, no, we don't have to. I just think it's really interesting. Like, isn't there an economic development? And maybe it flows through some other topic areas, like if we pick something about the marine economy or whatever,. I guess I'm just sort of thinking it's really interesting. Housing is a driver for a lot of things, but there's still economic development that has to happen. [1:03:11] Speaker C (unidentified): but why are we creating a housing economic development committee if we're not expecting that to be a component of the what that committee does so one of the things that you might want to include in the hot in the plan that they're developing is discuss or make recommendations about economic development proposals that would enhance the likelihood of success of year-round I'm not wording it well, but shouldn't that be a piece? Otherwise, why is economic development [1:03:48] Speaker F (unidentified): plans that would work cohesively with the larger year-round population? [1:03:55] Speaker C (unidentified): In Philadelphia, they have to have a job, a year-round job, right? They have to be able to make money. Year-round. [1:04:02] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah. around yeah i say you want businesses that the local population is going to that they want they need and they will support right it benefits the community life so [1:04:18] Speaker B (unidentified): can i ask a question sure about economic development alex raised a few weeks ago this tiff concept we had a public hearing on it i have like housing in mind when i think about tiff but tips are also used for economic development, right? [1:04:38] Speaker A (unidentified): So- Yeah, they're actually primarily that. Primarily, yeah,. We're just planning to use them a lot less as that as the primary driver. [1:04:44] Speaker B (unidentified): So we've got that conversation kind of charging ahead. And again, how is it tied to this? And does this mention that? I mean, are we gonna have conversations about economic development when we have the TIFF conversations? [1:05:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I think if we wanna just put a sentence in there, explore TIF districts as a means to spur economic development, boom, you've got a sentence in there along those lines. I do think that housing remains the primary driver for so much of this that the economic development sort of one follows the other. Housing creates the economic development. It is also why I've been thinking in terms of the housing and economic development being one committee because the people who there's so much overlap in the types of the discussion the type of things being discussed that it there's there's going to be so many similarities there that the two are inexorably tied to each other but in terms of just having a line in there because I don't I do think that everything after pages one and to is just not going to be as hot topic. So we don't need to spend too much time on something that nobody else is going to pay as much attention to either. [1:06:10] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, we've had discussions in this community, I think, about, I mean, Vincent, you've talked about some of this stuff, like mixed use communities. And people have talked about Otter Creek and if you had small scale, the ability to encourage small scale businesses mixed with housing development, otherwise we become simply, we just perpetuate the bedroom community kind of thing, which we're not going to bend the curve on that heavily, but we should look for opportunities to do that. [1:06:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Also entirely possible that we're going to get to the library and all anyone's going to want to talk about is the marina we're going to be like wait what [1:06:59] Speaker D (unidentified): i would i would say themselves what i would encourage is that housing yes is an element of housing is a thread that goes through all of the many different topic areas that we're going to talk about but it is not in and of itself an economic development conversation it is a part of that conversation you have to have houses for people who live here but there are people who live here who aren't going to work here so you have to have an economic development strategy for the things that you want to do in your community to foster economic development so is it a how do we want to capitalize on the changes in the blue economy what do we want to do about technology changes in the workforce and how can we support that and foster that like there's a bunch of different things that could be talked about for economic development how do we as a community want to foster growth in the businesses that are already here and what are they and how can we support that where do we have locations in our community that are suitable for the kind of businesses that are here for them to grow or do we or do they have to go to other towns if you want to get bigger the things you can do you know trades people have them yeah or yeah what do we if we have to look to our villages and we can use otter creek as an example to say what we have like businesses who want to grow in some of those areas and what does that mean and there's our zoning actually supportive of that like there's a whole economic development conversation to have that is nothing to do with housing so what is all that I think yeah I think you just have your [1:08:32] Speaker F (unidentified): bullet points for economic development what's that you just have your bullet [1:08:36] Speaker D (unidentified): point economic development I just want to make sure I don't not making stuff up but I mean I know like housing dominates the conversation all the time and I don't I think it's I just want to push back a little bit and say don't forget economic development is still really important and you have to have that conversation too workforce training is an economic development thing you know there's a lot to that right so that's [1:09:00] Speaker C (unidentified): why it should maybe go up into the somewhere in the how if you're going to make it like I said if you're going to make it the housing economic development committee yeah I think [1:09:10] Speaker D (unidentified): the strand of that the reason why you know i think the rationale that i heard last time was we're gonna let's call it housing economic development committee because there's already a committee we don't want to like over committee and so we're just gonna we're gonna add another layer of responsibility to that group and then i think you're right we you know we could try to balance it out but i don't want to dilute the priority immediately housing right yes but then don't lose the part of the conversation. That's, you know, economic development. So that committee is going to be doing some pretty awesome stuff, actually. [1:09:44] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, they should be empowered, notice that they should be empowered to get to a point where they in that committee that their charge should include, well, look at ancillary economic development issues that can further the possibility of success. [1:09:59] Speaker A (unidentified): And that was the complaint of the committee when it was asking to go on hiatus, which did not have enough meat to sink its teeth in too so here we go they got some meat now be careful what you ask for [1:10:15] Speaker D (unidentified): due to you know yeah i can think of a bunch of different things that would be really cool for you guys to talk about as a town all right so alex i think what you were suggesting is let's not we don't need to worry too much about the priorities in each of these areas [1:10:34] Speaker A (unidentified): is nope we won't get there love it although transportation where you say lead to be confirmed it will get the parking committee up and going sooner or later we're going to call a parking committee right there's parking committee it is actually got its group together i just need to stop having crises every day are [1:10:55] Speaker E (unidentified): you going to include fire and ems in that [1:10:57] Speaker A (unidentified): as well yes public safety we'll just call it yeah public safety i mean police is primary on that but [1:11:05] Speaker E (unidentified): But yes, we decide we need to do something specific there. No, I just know I,, I live off the street right now. That's got contractors on both sides of the road. And if I were a fire truck, I'd have to be a very thin fire truck to get down the street right now. That's why I think of that. [1:11:26] Speaker C (unidentified): How did we decide to platform in this document? Historical, archaeological and cultural resources. So. [1:11:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Oh, I think that's a requirement of those. Yeah, I think, I mean, I would also couch that as a, it's not, it's, it's a cultural and economic development thing for the community. Like, you know, there's cultural resources, which bring people to the area who want to live here because of all the cultural amenities, but also it's like a huge. I'm not sure if this is the question you were asking me to answer, Gail, but I'm going for it anyway. It's also a really important economic development aspect of your community. And so I think that what we had talked about for this strategy was like just inventory it so you know what you have. And it's documented. Does it have to be a short term goal? [1:12:18] Speaker G (unidentified): I mean, I see it's state required, but we could take our time on this. None of that stuff is going anywhere. [1:12:28] Speaker D (unidentified): I think the reason it's a short-term goal is just what you were saying, so that it doesn't [1:12:32] Speaker E (unidentified): go anywhere. You need to preserve it. [1:12:34] Speaker D (unidentified): Or that you enhance it and use it to your advantage. [1:12:39] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. Like, do we have other economic development goals that are not short-term? I was trying to look up our list, but- [1:12:46] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I think we do. I'll have to go back and look them in. It would be worth us taking a look at it. [1:12:51] Speaker G (unidentified): Maybe there's something in there that- Yeah. [1:12:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, and these can be, you know, they're just priorities. I pointed it out only because I thought it was really interesting that 's was one of like, when we started this process, however many years ago, like the two or three things that we thought we were going to really spend more time on or economic development, housing and then. But those are really the top two. So, what that start was interesting that we hadn't identified a short term strategy. All right. Well, Kathy's point is well taken. Make some edits. Have it available for people to look at ahead of time. We're going to try to get that out, and at least it'll be linked. This will be linked on the page that people could pull it down. And I'd say I'll make these edits, and it should be available by the beginning of the week. [1:13:51] Speaker C (unidentified): Let me just say the one that we have in here about working with a townhoster, we build one or two at the head of the island. I'm going to consult an actuarial table and tell you how long, I think, personally you have to get that job done, please. Oh, yeah. [1:14:09] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I think your town manager has made it clear on a few occasions to say that 's a really high priority. [1:14:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes,. Even him messing up his car driving the road didn't get it going faster. So anything else I can do. He literally made him mess up his car, but he... Right, the DOT? Yeah, did you hear that story ever? Yes, he reported back, I broke my car driving the road as you forced me to drive at him. [1:14:44] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm not sure he's, unfortunately, probably not in that position. [1:14:48] Speaker A (unidentified): No, he's not high up enough to make a difference. [1:14:52] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. Can I ask, because I'm just trying to look at this now,, is there an easy access on the town website to get to the Comprehensive Plan Committee? Good question. Website? [1:15:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't know how front and center it is. I'll see how close it is, yeah. [1:15:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Because if we just want to send people to something, we should make that. [1:15:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Yep, we can make it one of the headers that takes it. Okay. [1:15:14] Speaker F (unidentified): What I just found was, here's the 2009 report, and here's the 2003 study that led to it. So I was like, hmm, what's that all about? [1:15:23] Speaker G (unidentified): the person who did the 2003 actually and then on the site that this takes me to there's not much there it says coming soon public outreach coming soon i'll look to see where they usually yeah i'm assuming coming soon coming soon coming soon okay is there any documents so [1:15:48] Speaker A (unidentified): we'll see each other in two weeks right yep okay make [1:15:53] Speaker E (unidentified): a motion to adjourn [1:15:55] Speaker F (unidentified): So moved I can say it was in favor. [1:15:59] Speaker C (unidentified): Hey, you [1:16:03] Speaker G (unidentified): can join another meeting and try and hop onto your other.