Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:34] Chair of the Planning Board: Good day, or good evening, I should say. Welcome to the November 9th meeting of the Town of Wyndham Planning Board, which will be called to order. This is a public proceeding. Please advise the chair if you are unable to see or hear something. Please know that the planning board members will disclose any potential conflicts of interest of which they are aware of at the start of the applicable agenda item. The land use ordinance, the comprehensive plan, and the planning board rules are available for viewing on the town's website and the town office. The ground rules for public hearing applications are as follows. There will be the applicants presentation, then there are staff comments, after that will be public comments. Public comments, please state your name and address for the record, and all questions must be asked through the chair. We will then move on to board discussion. Before I continue, I would just a little bit of housekeeping here. We have, there are folks from the public who, and you do have the right to send your comments in by email. If you do that, this is for anybody out there, please make sure that you sign them, you put your name and what town you live in. It makes it very difficult for the planning department or anybody else to respond to you if we don't know who you are. The other thing is I would like to ask that you please refrain from clapping or cheering. It becomes very disruptive for whoever, either whoever's up here speaking or if we're deliberating. And the other thing is, if you have to talk to your neighbor, please take it outside of this room. That's another thing that's also very, distracting. These are requests, and I just hope you'll understand where I'm coming from. All righty. So saying that, could I please have a roll call?
[2:26] Planning Board Member: Leo Gerrier. Here. Here. Melissa Young. Present. Mark Schiavone. Here. Everett Crickin. Present. Emily Legere. Present. Rick Yost. Present. No absent tonight. You have quorum and staff present is Natalie Thompson, town planner, and Steve Puglio, planning director.
[2:47] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. I do believe that the minutes, we do not have them, you said, right? I guess so. So I guess so I would ask for a motion to postpone the minutes until the next meeting. Are we having one?
[3:00] Planning Board Member: I move to postpone the approval of the minutes of the October 26, 2026 Planning Board meeting to a certain date of the November 23, 2026 Planning Board meeting.
[3:08] Chair of the Planning Board: Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Any comments? Seeing none. All in favor? Okay, it is unanimous. Moving on to continuing business. News in accordance with the rules of the planning board, no public comment shall be allowed during the continuing business portion of the meeting except as requested by the board. Please send written comments by mail or email to planning board at windermain.us, and please sign them. So first on our agenda is PB 26-079, 25-27 Eventide subdivision, major subdivision final plan review, view 100 River Road, Row Even LLC. The application is to develop a 17 lot conservation subdivision on 27.92 acres with a new road built to public standards. Lots will be served by private subsurface wastewater disposal systems, on-site wells, and underground utilities. Subject property is identified as tax map one, lots eight dash one, eight dash two, and nine, zone farm in the PRESUMPSKIT RIVER WATERSHED. And here for the applicant is, I think those are always on
[4:24] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): yeah, they were red, so I think, are they still red? We're green now, so I think we're good. So good evening, Dustin Roma with DM Roma Consulting Engineers, on behalf of Roeven LLC, L.C., presenting this project tonight. So we were very recently here a couple weeks ago, and when we had left that meeting, there was a number of things that were kind of follow-up items that we were asked to do. So rather than go through kind of the project as a whole, hopefully it's fresh in everyone's mind, I'm just going to kind of run through the bulleted items that we that we've addressed since that last meeting. So you have, we submitted some revised plans dated 1029, so 1029, there's a just three subdivision plan sheets which kind of address a few of the items. Lot number 17, the board had directed us to shrink the lot size down to close to 30,000 square feet, which added some additional open space and provided connectivity between what was previously shown as open space areas three and four. In making that connection, we've gone through and just changed the notes so that we basically have only three open space areas now because they're connected. So we've made that update on the plans, and I think Natalie identified one spot where we missed it, so we've got to just clean that last piece up. So that added 0.11 acres to the open space area, consistent with what the board asked us to do when they Voted on the waiver so that, so the total area is thirteen point nine eight acres. Now the, we've also revised the building envelope on lot 8 to provide some separation between the wetland area and the building envelope, so it's not right up against it. So we did that on the subdivision plan, and we did look at that lot and just, you know, make sure we put a house on there and make sure we've got space for driveway and a building and a turnaround area and all that, so we're very confident and comfortable with, that layout on that lot. The one question, a comment that came in from a neighbor was just on the lot to the north. We were not showing their existing well on the plans. It was located as part of the hydrogeologic study, but we were not showing it on the site and subdivision plans, and he just had some concerns. I think it's 15 feet off the property line, so we just wanted to make sure it was very clear on the plans so that the siting of any wells and septics would certainly account for that. So we did add that location to this plan as well, and then that well is also kind of the subject of a additional comment from the hydrogeologist. We were asked to do two water samples, which we did, two existing wells on properties that are to the east along River Road, 100 and 100 A River Road, so we did collect those water samples, provided the results of those to Natalie for the records. So that's included now. And I believe that was kind of a completion requirement that we talked about last time that we needed to do. We worked closely with the town and Haley Ward just to provide basically kind of a final updated review memo from them. I think at the last meeting we kind of explained to the board kind of the process that we've been in working with them, but we felt it was important, given the amount of concerns and raised by both neighbors and discussed here at the board meetings, that we come to this meeting tonight with, you know, a kind of a clear sign off from the town's consulting engineer that they've, that they've hired in order to review the work that we've done, so there's a letter dated November 5th from Haley Ward which just bullets out five comments. The first four are essentially just confirming that there were an agreement with the information we provided, there in agreeance with that information, and then number five has to do with the one well on Mr. Fortier's property that I talked about a minute ago. That was the one area where we felt there was some additional safeguards that should be put in place just to ensure we wouldn't have issues with water quantity. And the reviewing engineer for the town felt that as long as we provide as much separation as possible, locating wells on lots 1, 2, and 3, as far south as would be permitted by those well exclusion zone areas. They felt that was sufficient to provide safeguards for that one well that potentially could have drawdown issues if wells were built too close to that one existing well. So they felt that was sufficient as long as we kept some separation and did them as far south as we can on lots one, two, and three. So there's a condition of approval that the town staff has prepared which addresses that, so that can be something that's enforced through code enforcement in the event that those lots are sold and then the people building on them would know the expectations for those lots. In addition to that, on the water quality side, we've agreed that wells will be drilled by the lot owners on each lot and water quality tests will be provided to the code enforcement office before a building permit is issued on that lot. So what that does is, you know, provide some assurance that, you know, before a structure is built and foundations are in the ground and all that, the well siding on each individual lot will have, will produce the adequate yield, and the water quality will be at least documented so that if there is any treatment that needs to be done or desired, that, you know, that will be identified prior to any home being built on any lot. So we felt that was kind of an additional safeguard that normally wouldn't be required of a lot. They could, you know, put that well in at any time, and we just felt that was something and that was a reasonable thing to implement for this project to ensure that we'd get good quantity and quality in each of these wells before homes are built. So as far as the groundwater component, that was kind of our focus, was to kind of rely on the work that was done by our geologists and then all of the review work that was done by the town's consulting geologist and to really just bring a project to you that doesn't have any outstanding questions on it. So I think we are there now. We just had those last couple of things to do that we weren't prepared for at the last meeting. So this couple of weeks was able to give us the time to get those items completed. Other than that, I know there were some additional letters that came in. I don't know if there's anything specific that you want me to address in any of those, and I think I'll, at this point, I can turn it over to Natalie to fill in any of the blanks if I've missed any. So thank you. Okay.
[12:55] Planning Board Member: So that's all stuff we went through last meeting, just the review history, what the proposed conditions are. So since then, the applicants brought in some revised plans, the groundwater. We got some guidance from the town attorney and got back our review. I went through, I'm sure you saw in your packets, and actually went through each of the submission requirements for hydrology and identified where the applicant had submitted those materials. So the town engineer did look at the comments that came from Haley Ward, and essentially the only, I don't know if concerns the right word, but he was in support of putting a condition of approval that will be the board's decision if they want to do that. But a condition of approval that would essentially require the testing before a building permit for quality. And then another recommendation from staff would be to put a condition for water conservation in drought conditions into the HOA documentation. And then lastly, this does not need to be a condition of approval, but the board could make it a condition of approval if they wish. But essentially that they will put a essentially a well zone on their final map subdivision plan before signing it that would be within the setbacks but as far away from as far south as it would be. You could make that a condition or you could not and just know that it's not going to come back to you and for signing until it's been done.
[14:57] Chair of the Planning Board: Can I ask a quick clarifying question? You made the statement that the well testing would be prior to building. He made the statement it would be prior to an occupancy. Building permits. Just the building permit.
[15:10] Planning Board Member: Okay. Yes. The Haley Ward comments said certificate of occupancy, but staff felt that was too late. We wanted it to be prior to building permits. You can continue. That was all I had. I just wanted to go over these additional conditions that we have recommended, but we have not added. It will be up to the board if they would like to add them or not.
[15:35] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. We'll open it up to the board.
[15:39] Planning Board Member: We should do a completion. Oh. At your last meeting, you deemed it incomplete. That's right. I Move the major subdivision final plan application for Project 25-27, Eventide Subdivision, is found complete in regard to the submission requirements based on the application checklist, but the Planning Board retains the right to request more information where review criteria are not fully addressed.
[16:09] Chair of the Planning Board: Any second? Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Are there any more questions or comments at this point in time? Seeing none, all in favor? Opposed? Emily, do you raise your hand? It's a yes or a no.
[16:33] Planning Board Member: You need to decline and tell us why. Where is it not complete? I am still not convinced that the groundwater quantity has been fulfilled. I think the quality has been addressed, but the quantity itself, I don't think we've quite. But that's a completion. This is a completion motion. Isn't that why we did not find it complete last time? There was missing information that the consultant mentioned that made it incomplete. Yeah, that was Haley Woods. Got it. So, the question is, it complete now? Even if it is complete now, you still can request more information. Very good, then. Sorry. Thank you for the clarification. I will vote with yes. Okay. Okay. It's unanimous, Natalie. Understandable.
[17:37] Chair of the Planning Board: I know. It does get confusing. Okay. So we know the waiver was approved. One was withdrawn.
[17:52] Planning Board Member: Just would you like me to go back to maps? Yes. Please. Let me know what type of map you want, but yes.
[18:02] Chair of the Planning Board: No, we're good. You want to go first, Leo? Sure.
[18:06] Planning Board Member: So – and again, it is like confusing, so help me out if I'm confused. So what I saw on the Haley Ward letter was, if I was understanding it right, was a question about the – it was a 10 percent – yes, thank you, impervious area, and that they weren't convinced that satisfied. And then it sounded like on the lawyer's letter that they weren't convinced that was satisfying the underwater ground quantity and that it kind of directed to that there would need to be a piece of evidence that would prove out that there was quantity and then us not being water experts underground. Ground I don't know what that looks like, but it did sound like full circle that hasn't been
[18:59] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): Met, tell me about that. How so? The way that I understood that response was that the just doing a blanket, you know, less than 10 impervious coverage is not sufficient by itself to meet the entire water quantity standard, which we agree. Like that's, there's a number of things in here where you need to demonstrate some level of evidence that there is available water quantity in this general area, and not only speak about recharge, because the that 10 percent is something that's actually in the ordinance. And that deals with recharging the groundwater, okay, on your specific site. So the evidence that exists to show the availability of groundwater quantity is the last page that's in our groundwater availability study, which is the presence of all of the wells in the area, which shows yields on kind of a broad base surrounding the property. So if we were in an area that was highly undeveloped and there were no existing wells and we were just going on surficial geology maps and trying to do a lot of estimates limits, then it might be prudent in that case to install test wells on the property to generate some data to see what are we looking at for existing yields on the property. Where you have, if you're in an area that has existing homes around it, existing development, and there are existing wells that have been registered with the state database for well yields, and there's enough of that information, then you get a very good broad cross-section of data that's there taken over kind of a long period of time, because those wells were all installed in different time frames. So that was the data that was presented in the report as evidence that there is sufficient groundwater. And that's, you know, with the amount of data that was presented, the peer review engineer that was looking at all this stuff also felt that was sufficient, and that's why they didn't request any additional information beyond what we gave them. I guess the follow-up that
[21:24] Planning Board Member: you probably expect is that, like what we talked about last meeting, that the ordinance has that shall not, so that like, you know, we basically, you can't put in or we can't put in a subdivision and it can't negatively impact those other wells. And I guess the concern that I'm hearing that I can kind of understand from the flip is that, like, just the existence of those wells doesn't necessarily prove that there's enough water to pull from without, you know, being certain that we're not going to affect those wells. And again, not being a scientist there, I'm like, okay, so I can kind of understand that where, you know, you've got people pulling wells. Wells, where's the threshold where it's one more well or 50 more wells that breaks the system? And maybe you could speak to that because I hear what you're saying. It totally makes sense that you have those wells there. They're registered. You can do some desktop data. But what testing specifically says that this many wells won't break the system and this many wells will break the system.
[22:32] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): So one of the things that's really important to consider when you're looking at wells that are installed for a subdivision like this, there's a few things going on. Number one, these wells get distributed over these 17 lots. So it's distributed out over, you know, that whole area, you know, half the property essentially. The other very important thing to consider is geologists who study this generally consider a single family home to be in equilibrium when it comes to groundwater withdrawal and recharge because we've got septic systems and we've got wells. So pretty much all the water that gets taken out of a well, you know, it runs through the plumbing of the house, goes through the showers, goes through the dishwasher, and then and it ends up back in the septic system where it gets deposited back into the ground. And it's not like recharge from runoff where you might actually have, if you've got clay soil, a lot of that water might be leaving the property if it rains. With septic systems, the only place for that water to go is into the ground. So what you have is this kind of, you know, recharging ecosystem on each lot. So every lot has a well and every lot has a septic system. Them so whether that individual user if they pull out the full, you know, three to four hundred gallons per day that we design these septic systems for a three to four bedroom house, if they're pulling all that water out, it still all goes back into the ground. And if you have a smaller user, same thing, it's just not as much water is coming out, but there's less recharge as well because it's a it's a smaller user. So if you consider each one of these lots to kind of be their own individual property That functions in equilibrium, that's essentially what's going on. So if you were to model that scientifically and have some flow rate, you know, you'd have q coming out, q going back in, flow rates, and very little because you don't have a lot of, you know, evapotransportation and all that stuff. You don't have a lot of water that gets, you know, soaked up into plants and things unless you're doing excessive amounts of irrigation or something like that, but that's, you know, most of the water is going to be consumed and put right
[24:58] Planning Board Member: back on the ground. Natalie, I guess question for you as far as the town is concerned, have you guys weighed in as that being evidence and being sufficient? Yes, we've had obviously the peer review look at it and they're, they find that what has been presented is sufficient for both quantity and quality, and the town engineer has also looked at it and has no issues or has no concerns in that capacity either, and a lot of it does have to do with that sort of circular recharge that Dustin's talking about. I think that's about it. I did have one comment though, Dustin. I was hesitating to say it, but I'm gonna say it anyway. The doing the water samples, I appreciate that you went and got the two water samples. I would have loved one of those water samples to come from the well that was in question. You know what I mean? Like I know when we met at last meeting, it was – we agreed, OK, we're going to go do two water samples. And there was a lot of conversation about being great neighbors in there. And I was like, well, I believe the person selling the property has two properties here. I'm wondering where those water samples are going to come from. And it's not that – like you fit the need there. But if we're going to be great neighbors, the one that's kind of concerned about as well, that's the closest, I would have loved to have heard, I tried, he told me to take a hike, you know, or something like that, you know. And I know that's more common than question, but that's so you understand where I'm coming from.
[26:43] Chair of the Planning Board: All right. That's all I got. Are you all siphonolio? Yes. That's enough of me. That's okay. If you have more, I'll go back. Melissa? I
[26:54] Planning Board Member: mean, I think the whole basis of concern around this subdivision has been driven down to the point of water, right? I think we've checked all of the other boxes with respect to the concerns. The open space has been acknowledged and waiver approved. improved but i'm still falling on the fact that like if we're waiting until somebody is ready to buy a lot and build a house to find out if they're going to have enough water or if they're going to impact other people's wells i mean i guess if that's the risk that the developer wants to take on maybe not being able to sell a lot because it's going to you know impact somebody else as well i don't i just don't know the level of comfort that quality or the quantity has been met and i mean i'm not trying to disagree with the town but it seems like we're putting it more in the hands of like wait and see what happens and maybe that's outside of our purview kind of your question what happens yeah like no i mean like really and really that's on the developer i guess at that point but I don't know so in my tenure on the planning board we've you know okay dozens of subdivisions and dozens of hydrological survey waivers based on evidence that we were given a stuff like this what do you think is driving see this is especially for you what do you think is driving the interest in this one more so than we've seen in the past we've got it okay I should have said
[28:48] Chair of the Planning Board: this at the very beginning but we've got a basically because Natalie is taking is no she's taking over the planning so we have to I think address our questions to Natalie and if she if she chooses to she can just pass them on to
[29:02] Planning Board Member: Steve okay I'll give it a go and then Steve can fill in any blanks if I have them but I'd say that the biggest driving factor right now is that we are They're hearing from people that because of the drought conditions going on currently that wells are not getting the same flow rate or they're drying up, and specifically kind of in this neighborhood. So more butters have come forward, and they're concerned about their wells. I think in general that is the issue is the drought conditions that we're in. And, you know, one of the things that historically we haven't seen in southern Maine is these drought conditions. That said, you know, based on our ordinance, we've, from the staff's point of view, have done as much due diligence as we possibly can to get this information to the planning board in a format. and with the credibility of our peer engineer and supplemental information being provided, I think we've addressed what the board needs to make a determination on. Now, relative to having wells drilled prior to building permit You've given us enough, Mike, you've given us enough information to determine, but are you saying determine whether we should go forward or not, or whether we should require a hydrological survey? Well, we've already done hydrological survey. We've already done a bunch of analysis there. So the only other place that our ordinance kind of speaks to is going beyond that, asking for more relevant information. Therefore, we've included what has been recommended by our consultant to put into this approval to test the wells for quality and quantity. So we actually would have a baseline of what the subdivision would require for water supply. Line. Until we start to build that baseline to understand what's in the ground, it's very difficult for anybody, the board, staff, consultants, to make that estimation that there is sufficient groundwater or not. Our ordinance does speak about not causing adverse impacts to other properties, existing wells, and I think with all the information that has been provided to the planning board, the planning board can make that determination and could go a little bit further by conditioning the approval that would require additional information, such as, you know, having drought conditions restrictions on water use as part of their HOA, similar to how public water systems work. If there's a drought condition and they put a stop irrigation on, then you need to do that. How we eventually get around to that, enforcing that on the town's level by having a condition of approval to that effect, if we find that they're not doing what's supposed to be done, then the town can enforce that particular condition, as well as enforce conditions such as making sure that wells are drilled prior to issuance of building permits to get quantity and quality from each one of those wells and establish where those wells are going to be placed on the property. So, you know, from that point to go beyond that right now, the ordinance, you know, doesn't talk about monitoring on other people's properties for well water conditions, but it does talk about this project providing enough capacity. I hope that was... thank you.
[33:13] Chair of the Planning Board: Yes, sir. Okay, I can always, we can always come back. Do you have anything else at?
[33:21] Planning Board Member: At this point, I would comment that the fact that we're going to have the developer test for quality, in my opinion, should be part of our ordinance anyway. As a guy in real estate, I've sold lots of new houses over my career. Used to be you could get a reverse system for $5,000 or $6,000. Now you're in the teens to get a water driving system. That's a big burden to a homeowner that goes, oh, my water was tested. So your flow rate was tested, but there's There's no quality test on that, and it's not required by us, and I think it probably should be.
[33:58] Chair of the Planning Board: Before I leave that, though, do you want to make a recommendation to Steve that they look at that ordinance? We have it on one of our workshops coming up. Okay, I'll sit.
[34:10] Planning Board Member: Emily? I would like to just bring up the trails again. And I see that you updated the map with the change to one of the lots to make so the open space was connected. I like that. But I would like to see the trails on the final plan. Because right now it still shows the same trails that are going through the southern lots. And we had discussed previously that there would be a cohesive trail system.
[34:44] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): So what we did is we added notes in a few different areas just saying that, you know, any trails that run through, like, numbered lots in the subdivision wouldn't, you know, be discontinued, basically. Those trails wouldn't be in effect anymore. More I think the question was at the is how do you get to the trail system which was we added that pond access road that's being built at off the end of the road to get down to the pond and that basically ties right in with the trail system that's there and then we identified like the note says their existing trails just kind of highlighting those areas within the open space and like I said on the subdivision plans themselves so we tried to label the trails more that are in the open space and I And label the trails that run through the lots as saying that they're going to be discontinued this particular property just a little bit challenging because there's so many trails and they're not just skidder roads from an old tree harvester I mean these are nice trails that you know people ride dirt bikes down and stuff like that so and there's a network that kind of goes all through the property so it was a little more challenging than most just because there I believe it's an ordinance Requirement that we show where the existing trails are, so we can't just not show the trails that aren't going to be there when the project's done. We have to show where they are when they start, and then we did our best to go through and just label up the trails that are going away, and then label up the trails that are going to
[36:19] Planning Board Member: stay. I don't think this cuts it. Go ahead. Do they, is that a, an ordinance that they show the ex, the existing trails? It is required on the existing conditions plan, but it is not a requirement to be on the final plan.
[36:39] Chair of the Planning Board: Sorry to add on to yours. I think more in line with her request was the fact that a lot of those trails are going through what are going to be people's private property. So if basically someone could go to code after these are done and said, I have a map here, and it shows a trail. It goes right through, whatever, Lot 7 or whatever, and the citizen is saying, no way, you're not walking through my property. So I think that is more in line with not having the trails on there as designated trails.
[37:14] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): Yeah, that's a very simple thing to do as long as everyone's fine with us. So the plan won't show trails that exist there today. If we're saying that they're going to go away, we would just eliminate. I think that's what you asked last time. If that's what you'd like, yeah. Yeah, I didn't think we could do that.
[37:28] Planning Board Member: So, yeah, right, the final plan should just show the final ones, because once this leaves, we're never going to see it again. Right. And we just have to trust that what was drawn on there was built. And right now it seems like it's kind of in limbo when it comes to the trails. May I say something, Chair? I think that's absolutely a perfect request from the Planning Board to eliminate the trails that are shown on the private properties parcels. They can show all the trails, whether they're going to keep them or not, in the open space, as the applicant has indicated that they're dirt bike trails. They're well-hewn trails. They're not going to go away. We're not going to ask the developer to revegetate those. They're just going to remain, whether they're connected together or not. But I agree that the subdivision plan should eliminate any trails crossing through the proposed parcels.
[38:36] Chair of the Planning Board: Does that answer the – you said, Emily, with that piece? With that piece, yes.
[38:42] Planning Board Member: And I think we've covered everything else. So on the water quality test, did you, in fact, reach out to Fortier about the well testing?
[39:01] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): To get a well test on theirs? I didn't request a test from his, but we're happy to do that. If the board wants a test, we can offer.
[39:11] Planning Board Member: Yeah, we'll be good to do it.
[39:13] Chair of the Planning Board: Let people know which well you're talking about. The one to the north.
[39:21] Planning Board Member: And then on the trails, because we were just talking about that, so how are you going to deal with the fact that there are trails that essentially start on the existing property that is being split off, you know, those two lots at the bottom essentially right there at the Tevenian southern piece, go all the way through the private lots and then connect with what is presumably a public part of, well not public but a common part of the trail, again, like there's some, not that it's really a concern, I think, for us as the board, but probably something to look at on how to signpost that. Okay. Because I don't think it's going to be very obvious otherwise where the common trail ends in particular. Because it looks like, and correct me if I'm wrong, that there will only be one access point to the trail system, which is at the end of the road.
[40:22] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): There's nothing else. Right. It's basically where the open space starts at the end of the road. Right. Yeah. The rest of the open space pieces are primarily for conservation. So, yeah.
[40:32] Planning Board Member: Yeah. And there are some trails that run in there, but they're like mini trails, right? So, you know, but you're not taking them out either, right? Nope.
[40:41] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): So, they'll be there and, yeah, you can still access them from Eventide Drive once that's built. I mean, if you wanted to walk through there, you could.
[40:49] Planning Board Member: What is the status of the other law that is noted as going to be donated to the
[40:58] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): prosom squad river land trust yep so we've got some email documentation that we've basically expressed our interest to donate that to prlt they have a process that they've outlined back to us in an email that basically just says they have a land committee that'll outline that they'll make a recommendation as to you know whether they want to accept this as a donated piece all indications so far that they're excited about you know any type of riverfront property that's of this size if it was a smaller size, maybe they wouldn't be so interested, but they've expressed interest in owning this lot on the river as well as the open space that, you know, which is now open space lot three, the larger piece. They've expressed interest in. And it's not that they don't need both of them or they won't take one. They said they're definitely interested in the waterfront piece, but they're also interested in the other if it were to be offered up. So we're going to wait for them to come back to us and say that their land committee has voted that they want to go into the final process. And then we'll go through that, whatever it is.
[42:09] Planning Board Member: Do you have a backup plan in case that doesn't happen?
[42:11] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): The backup plan is essentially the condition of approval as it's worded on the package here, which is a conservation easement over the property or a declaration of covenants that would restrict any development on that piece. And that would be reviewed by the town attorney, and I think it's a requirement that it be recorded before the project plan is recorded. So that ensures that it will get done. done and
[42:40] Planning Board Member: then on the water quantity testing so help me understand how this works so you got 17 lots do you put in all the wells at once and test them at once
[42:52] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): no that wasn't what was proposed so basically you know it's each lot would have a well drilled as you know before the building permit is issued so that just to demonstrate that it's you know it's it's going to work in that location it's i can i didn't want this to look like a like you said like kind of a wait and see approach because that's clearly not our intent here i think if there was some evidence based on the data that it might be difficult to get water here then i think you know being more prudent to you know drill all these wells up front and make sure that there we're going to have water would make more sense but in this case given the, average amount of water across the 35 wells, I think that were studied through there was 11 and a half gallons per minute, which is very much on the high side. I believe the state minimum is 0.5. So we're 20 times the, on an average basis. another thing that's highlighted in the report that's important to note is that the, you know, the direction of groundwater flow, in this case, goes towards the river. So Presumscott River is the ultimate destination for the groundwater flow in this area. So when you think about the potential area of influence, if we were to do, you know, have a drawdown in this area, there's really nothing between us and the river. It's all open space. So this cluster of wells that we're going to be installing that we're at the bottom of the recharge area, so even though we're still in equilibrium pulling water out, putting it back in, so that's one level of assurance. Then you look at where are we located in the greater recharge area, and we're essentially at the bottom of the hill right before it daylights into the river, so we're getting the recharge from other areas down into to this. So the potential for us to influence somebody else because of the location of this lot, that's just another safeguard. And all that's in the report that was done by the geologist. It's not just the layman terms of trying to just put this.
[45:17] Planning Board Member: So if we were to request a kind of like a well zone, for lack of a better way of putting it, would that just kind of like follow the
[45:25] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): exclusion zone in a certain strip width? Correct. So basically what we have is a 250-foot swath or so right down the middle of the lot where that's where the septic systems go in the front yard. So that's the recharge area for any water that comes out of the ground, and then the wells kind of just go in that backyard. What that does is it helps to distribute these wells again over these lots so that we're not going to have a bunch of wells clustered in one area that could potentially have localized effects. This distributes the wells across all the properties fairly well.
[46:02] Chair of the Planning Board: Thank you. On that same vein, on lots one, two, and three, the wells as far south as possible,
[46:09] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): does that put it right up front near the road? No, it just puts it like near the well exclusion area boundary. So if that condition were not in there, somebody could put a well all the way back on the rear property line which might only be you know 25 feet away from the well that's in that's we have concerns about, so I looked at that area and I mean if you draw you know 120 foot circle around it, I mean there's no reason for any wells to be located within that radius of that existing well that's there, so you can see the proximity. Yeah, it's just off the screen to the north where the well is. There it is, so You can see we have quite a bit of separation there, and I think what the geologist that was reviewing this on behalf of the town recommended was that, you know, we don't want those, the wells for those three lots to be placed near the property line like similar to what was done on that lot. They don't want it to just be a mirror image on this side, so south is down when looking at that, so it's essentially putting the wells near that well exclusion zone, and we could do something to the effect of if There's a distance off that we wanted to set that way, it's measurable based on this plan. We could say, you know, within 15 feet of that well exclusion boundary. We don't want to go too close because that's then we're getting close to the septic systems that are on our lot, and again the groundwater flow kind of goes down towards the river, so I think if we were to maybe say within 15 feet of that line that would be appropriate.
[47:42] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. So, all right. So, far, if I'm keeping track, we have three conditions. Oh, question first. Has the HOA been reviewed by our legal department yet?
[47:56] Planning Board Member: The attorney has it. We've not received comments back. Okay. Which is pretty common for this stage.
[48:03] Chair of the Planning Board: We don't typically have them back. I know. I just wanted to make sure where it was in the cycle of things, so the conditions are is basically this, the information is going to be in the HOA, and that's going to be a condition that it is in the HOA as far as the wells, the well locations, and then there will be test wells prior to the bill, so it'll be those three right conditions added, yes, to what we
[48:27] Planning Board Member: presently have, yes, to what you have on your memo. Okay, chair, those wells prior to the issuance of building permits, aren't test wells. They're wells, but we're testing quantity and quality. Oh, gotcha.
[48:45] Chair of the Planning Board: Sorry. I wrote myself a note. I took a test out. Okay. What was my next one? Okay. Now, there was a comment. Can you bring that plan up again at the end of the road about the road possibly being extended at a later date, could you explain how that would happen, or is that okay to ask now? Sure.
[49:15] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): What we did is, yeah, I mean, we put, it's kind of a disclaimer note that we put on there. It doesn't obligate the planning board to do anything, but what it does is it gives the planning board a tool if the adjacent lot were to be, if somebody were to come forward with a plan in the future, this gives the planning board a tool to be able to, you know, potentially have a road connection with this road if it was appropriate. Without this note, we just have this gore of open space that we can't cross without amending another plan. So that was the goal, was to just, and I think we have a more substantial note on the actual subdivision plan. I think that was an abbreviated note, and we've got a more substantial one on the subdivision plan, which just kind of lays out in the event somebody wanted to utilize that as a road connection it permits it to be done with Planning Board approval in context with the
[50:11] Chair of the Planning Board: review of a whole nother project okay and that'll that this development would be included if one was to be put behind there the number of houses would be included right they'd be added to what if one came in we only go to a certain
[50:27] Planning Board Member: number and you need to two means of egress access egress that was all I had
[50:47] Chair of the Planning Board: have you thought of anything else we I don't want to leave anybody out if
[50:49] Planning Board Member: they've got more I want to bring up can we go back to the neighbors well because i'm just rereading the note the letter that he wrote and his concern isn't about wells being near his well his concern is about a septic being near his well so i just want to make sure that we have that you know there'll be that hundred foot setback for the septic yeah
[51:15] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): we were very cognizant of that so the all of the septics are basically going to be up near the road so in order for so you can see where all the test pits are located so these will be you know front yard septic systems so that you know the septics can't go you know really anywhere beyond where those test pits are because the wells will all be in the backyard okay great thank you
[51:40] Planning Board Member: you all set rick you got anything else i think i don't know if this it may be prudent at this TIME TO DO A LITTLE FURTHER INVESTIGATION ABOUT ADDING A DROUGHT CONDITION RESTRICTIONS TO THE HOA BASED ON NEIGHBORS' CONCERNS.
[52:00] Chair of the Planning Board: I THINK WHEN ONE OF YOU MENTIONED THAT EARLIER, YOU HAD THE WORDS. I THINK IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN YOU, STEVE. OH, IT WAS YOU, NATALIE. OKAY. YES.
[52:08] Planning Board Member: SO I WROTE DOWN THE THREE CONDITIONS. THEY ACTUALLY WERE ALSO IN YOUR PACKET IN THE HYDROLOGY CHECKLIST PACKET. the wording changed just a tiny bit since then but essentially it's the condition so the first would be the condition that in the hoa documentation there would be a drought condition for water conservation second that they would be doing the water quantity and quality testing and then the third one that was the one i said if you wanted to put as a condition or you can just he 's the applicant will have to show it on the final plan before signing where the well zones will be on lots one two and three as suggested by the Haley Ward comments. Could you just create another well exclusion zone that essentially like, well, yeah, I think that was my proposal is that if
[53:05] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): we, if we said that the wells on lots one, two, or three can be located no more than 15 feet away from that well exclusion line, that way you basically have a 15 foot band across each of those lots that the wells have to be placed in, so horizontally they can go anywhere, but is that
[53:21] Planning Board Member: easier as a condition in text, or is it easier to just draw a line on the plan and essentially create a northern well exclusion zone in between and have the well sit in between the two exclusion
[53:31] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): zones? We can do it that way. Yeah, my thinking was just saying that if a well is located no more than 15 feet away from the well exclusion zone boundary, and it just, that way because I don't know if it's going to be on the right or the left, it'll be depending on how they site the house. I can do it either way. If you think it's more clear to say it has to be located in this hatched in area, if you think that's more clear, I'm happy to do that. It's probably easier. Okay, if everybody
[53:58] Planning Board Member: agrees. Yeah, that's fine. You all said Emily? Yeah, it seems the same, just two different ways to get there. I forgot about gravity. You forgot about crap again. So we're, no, I honest request to understand this. So you're talking about each of the lots being in their independent equilibriums as standalones, but you also stated that all water likes to run to the river. If the wells are in the back of the properties, and particularly those on the north side, and the leach fields are at the front yards, excuse my language, but hoop's going to run downhill, how are you in equilibrium on that lot if your leach field is heading out toward the river? Just talk me, talk me through that, because it doesn't make sense.
[55:02] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): Yep, no, I can appreciate that, and it's not a situation where it's like the water is being replaced in the exact same location as, you know, because it's coming out of the ground several, you know, in some instances, several hundred feet down, and then it's going back into the ground 20 feet down. But when you look at the things that would prevent a recharge condition from actually recharging the aquifer, it's things like evaporation, it's things like runoff, and the situation, because everything is distributed over the lot, it may not be, so like if you're pulling water out of a well on one lot and you've got the septic system that's contributing, you know, putting the water back in, you know, if you just broaden out a little bit, you know, because so the lot next to you that might be the septic system that's actually, you know, potentially kind of recharging your ground, you know, shallower, and when you look at it across all of the lots, they're all having the water come up out of the ground and recharge. I think it helps to look to think of it as compared to a project where we might have a single water source and then a single septic system. We've had several of those projects in town where you're usually on public water, so usually pulling the water that way, but you might have one large septic system in a corner that's treating 100 units in one location, so in that case you've got this, you know, this one spot, like if you were to assume there's a well on that project, you might have one extraction point, one point where the water is going back in the ground. And I wouldn't automatically just make the statement in that case that you have this equilibrium because you've got more things going on. You've got a single draw point location. You've got a single point where it goes back in the ground. But on a project like this, 17 lots over 15 acres or so of land, in the general case, looking at all those lots together and everything is water in, water back in the ground, you're basically recharging that aquifer over that, over that area. Yeah, I just, if you look at the
[57:04] Planning Board Member: Go move down a little bit down the road, or no, physically down, other way is down, north, there you go. So the, it's fine, lots one through three, right, which we're concerned about, out with our neighbors. Well, regardless, so they are not benefiting from any recharge from the balance of the properties, right? The location of where those wells are going to be, or the leach fields in the, their neighboring lots, aren't going to add value to their wealth. So I think that's where, when it comes to this adverse effects of, you know, are they pulling something that could take from an upstream neighbor, is still a valid concern, and I just don't know that 's been adequately addressed to meet the standards. I mean, yes, natural groundwater river flush, but who's to say that we're not going to be drawing down the other landowners? Well, I just don't know that the evidence has been presented, is my concern. I mean, I don't disagree, except that I don't know what more evidence we would ask for. I'll just say, if you look at the elevations, I think then the wells are at a lower spot than the septic. And I don't think it's quite like it all flows toward the river, not being any sort of expert, but there's a water table, right? And so it's not quite as, I think you've made it kind of very black and white, but it's not a black and white situation. Because it has to do with like the type of soil, and you know, is it sandy versus, no, I understand that, but what he's trying to sell an uninformed board on is this simple insights, and I'm calling him out on it. Like, it's either simple or it's not, you know, like, either it's a, you 're on an island and you're replenishing yourself over and over again, or you're not, like, it's the, it's the, It's the conflicting information that's being fed on this that has me concerned that everything is going to be okay and there won't be adverse effects and they won't get to the 17th property to be built and all of a sudden their water quantity is subpar.
[59:43] Chair of the Planning Board: That becomes an issue for the builder.
[59:45] Planning Board Member: No, I understand. But like, you know, to say that we feel like everything has been covered and that there's been, you know, transparency and the thing with the, let me get two water samples instead of three and pick the two that belong to the, you know, landowner, like that, there's been a lack of transparency that I have concerns if all of the needs have been met. And without us being subject matter experts and there still being concerns and statements from our third party stating that conditions haven't been met, but they're leaning to our decision, it's a tough spot to feel good about.
[1:00:30] Chair of the Planning Board: I don't think there is an answer that is going to 100% satisfy everybody's concerns here. I'm going to give you just a small example. I live right next to the lake. My well is probably 15 feet away from the lake. We had to drill down, I think, like 400 feet to hit water. My neighbor has water bubbling out of the top of their well. I think it's very difficult to be able to go to an area that is that big. I'm not trying to campaign for you. This is just something I am aware of. But when you get an area that big, you don't know how the water is flowing underneath. It should flow to the water. It doesn't always. I can tell you that from where my well is. The person who's not even near the water has got more water than I have, so I don't see the water coming by my house. So I think to say things without being underground really looking at it, you could go 10 feet away from one spot and all of a sudden it's different, because Maine has a lot of ledge, it has a lot of stuff under the ground. And I'm not, I just know from the experience of what we went through, it's very difficult to find a spot that's like perfect. This is like if we put this here on every spot it'll be perfect. So I guess what I'm trying to say is I don't think what you're looking for, the solution, is possible. I mean, for an answer, I just don't think there is one thing that says if we do 10,000 things, we'd have to have to drill something every three feet, you know. We might have some kind of an idea, but that would be insurmountable.
[1:02:26] Planning Board Member: No, it's a statement more of a level of discomfort that, you know, this has been thoughtfully, you know, presented. If I can ask a question about that. With what we have from Haley Ward and from the town engineer, and if we assume that we put in place the condition of approval that the wells on lots one, two, and three need to be within, and probably also four, need to be within, let's say, 15 feet of the exclusion zone line boundary, is that satisfactory to the town engineer and the planning staff?
[1:03:09] Chair of the Planning Board: Yes. And the drilling of the wells prior to the build. Right,. Yeah.
[1:03:13] Planning Board Member: He did say the conditions of approval, so yes, that would be satisfactory to the planning staff and to the town engineer and to everyone who has looked at this project from a staff side. Okay. Because I think we're going to keep kind of like circling around the fact that none of us are experts in drinking water science. Isn't that why we turned to the experts and asked their advice? And we did, right? And we did.
[1:03:40] Chair of the Planning Board: I think. But okay, one, let, I just have one last thing. Are there any other open items that we should be aware of, not on this project? Okay, so does anybody else have anything else? I know we've been very concentrated on water one way or the other and surrounding water, but I didn't know if there was anything else.
[1:04:05] Planning Board Member: But you know that anybody else, I thought, I think, I mean, when the public come to us and say we have concerns about this, I think we're supposed to deep dive into it. Well, we are.
[1:04:14] Chair of the Planning Board: I just wanted, I didn't want something to get overlooked because we're so concentrated on the water and the wells and everything, which we should have been. Okay, are we ready? Although I do have a question.
[1:04:27] Planning Board Member: Oh, there was a request for the third sample.
[1:04:29] Chair of the Planning Board: Yeah, I know. That was my question. They are going to, and he agreed to it, test Mr. Forty's well.
[1:04:39] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): How does that... Well, yeah, we'll offer.
[1:04:41] Chair of the Planning Board: Well, they're going to ask him if he would allow it. How does that affect this now?
[1:04:49] Planning Board Member: I don't believe that it can affect this. I might be incorrect, but they've already met the testing requirement for the site, and that would seem, I mean, Steve, you can. [Chair of the Planning Board: Go ahead.] Yeah, so we had a public comment from Mr. Whalen, who owns Balmoral Root Farm, who I think is concerned about the Highland Cliff Estates project. Yes. And in there he makes a comment that, you know, the way the board resolves 129.11, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, will not stay here. It will become the working standard for every conservation subdivision that follows, blah,, blah. I just want to confirm with you that whatever decision we make today has no binding effect on any future decisions we make on other projects. It will have no binding effect, and you are about to look at some standards that would change the hydrology stuff. And once that goes into effect, it would also change a lot of this anyway. But you, as a planning board, never set precedent. We're not a court. I just wanted to confirm that because we did get that as a public comment.
[1:05:58] Chair of the Planning Board: So that's that's the ordinance that's last on our agenda. Yes. All right. Okay. Yep. Okay. So
[1:06:22] Planning Board Member: did you add those conditions of approval? Yeah, I determined that you guys said you wanted them. So I'm going to put them on. Okay. All right. I move the major subdivision final plan application for Project 25-27, Eventide Subdivision Development, identified on tax map 1, lots 8, portion 8-1, 8-2, zone farm in the Presumptscott River watershed, is to be approved with conditions with the following findings of fact, conclusions, and conditions of approval.
[1:06:59] Chair of the Planning Board: I need a second. A second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. And before we vote, I do want to make the statement that if anybody sitting on the board is not comfortable voting for this, feel free to not. You're not tied to voting for.
[1:07:13] Planning Board Member: Sorry, they have to vote either up or down. I said for. Okay. Up or down, and if you're down, please provide ordinance.
[1:07:21] Chair of the Planning Board: You do have to vote. Okay. Okay. All those in favor?
[1:07:29] Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers): Okay. It is unanimous. Very good. I appreciate your time on this. I sincerely do.
New Business
[1:07:36] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay, new business. In accordance with the rules of the Planning Board, no public comment shall be allowed during the new business portion of the meeting except as requested by the Board. Please send written comments by mail or email to the Planning Board at WyndhamMaine.us. PB 26-080, 26-18.2, Aldi Grocery Store, Major Site Plan, Sketch Plan Review, 786 Roosevelt Trail, and 30 Landing Road, Aldi, Inc. The application is to construct an approximately 19,432-square-foot grocery store with 98 parking spaces and associated stormwater and utility improvements within the Wyndham Commons Shopping Center. The existing bank on Lot 5 is proposed to be demolished. Subject property is identified as Tax Map 70, Lot 5, and Tax Map 18A, Lots 48A and 48A-1. Zone Commercial C1 in the Little Sebago Lake Pleasant River Watershed. And here for the applicant is?
[1:08:51] Andrew Kerman (LJB Civil Engineers): My name is Andrew Kerman. I'm with LJB, the civil engineers working on the project.
[1:08:57] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): I'm Rich Derbis. I'm the Director of Development for ALDI.
[1:09:01] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay, great.
[1:09:02] Planning Board Member: I mean, Madam Chair, I want to make a correction on that description. It was inadvertently noted that the demolition of the building on Lot 5 is not the bank. The bank is not going away. It's the former Mangione's sub shop. Yes, okay. It's been vacant for quite some time. Can you correct that? Yes.
[1:09:26] Chair of the Planning Board: You can pull that closer to you if you want. They have a long cord.
[1:09:31] Town Finance Director: All right, go ahead. Good evening.
[1:09:36] Andrew Kerman (LJB Civil Engineers): just a little background on the project we're located at 786 roosevelt trail in front of walmart and just south of mcdonald's we're in the commercial district c1 ws north wyndham properties and its subsidiaries own the three lots that are involved in the project so moving from south to north we have map 70 lot 5 which has that vacant building and septic field that we'll be removing and a portion of map 18 a lot 48 a which is a portion of the Walmart parcel those two parcels will be conveyed to Aldi for a combined total area of 1.8 acres. And then there will also be some modifications to Map 18A Lot 48A-1, which is the McDonald's lot. So the total building area, when taking into account the canopy, is over 20,000 square feet. So the architectural design will be need to meet the commercial district design standards. So there will be future submissions with building elevations and things of that nature. One of the major changes that came with the initial meetings with town staff was to add a main entrance right along the frontage of Roosevelt Trail, as required by the ordinances. As we make the necessary architectural revisions to meet the commercial district design standards, the building footprint might fluctuate slightly, but we're confident that we can still make these changes work with the site. As far as entrances go, the existing driveway on Lot 5 is going to be modified on the south side of the building to allow for delivery vehicles to access the site and the loading area over there. The McDonald's entrance on Route 302, that write in will be upgraded to allow for write outs onto Route 302 as well as provide access to the all the lot. There will, there may be some additional revisions to that entrance just to account for the North Windham moves projects. And then also under a separate project, the owner of the overall parcel is WS Development. They are proposing modifications to Landing Road and that's under review with the town staff, and that would greatly benefit the proposed development and existing McDonald's, as it would allow vehicles to access the site from that access drive on the west side of the parcel. And so as part of all this, we're going to be coordinating with the fire department and town staff to make sure that all the entrances are designed in accordance with the fire department's needs and all the design requirements that go along with that. Currently we're showing 98 Parking spaces to serve the proposed development. We are doing an additional analysis for the overall shopping center to make sure that the proposed modifications don't have any negative impacts on the existing development. So that'll come with the final submission. As far as utilities go, we do have public water and sewer and electricity available adjacent to the site. So our final package will include the necessary correspondence from the utility providers relative to their ability to serve the proposed development. As far as stormwater goes, we will be providing detention and treatment in accordance with the local and chapter 500 requirements. There is an existing approved stormwater management system associated with the overall shopping center, but we are planning to treat this site as an individual standalone site. So essentially we'll be meeting the chapter 500 requirements on top of the existing stormwater that's already in place. With the limited space, our approach is probably going to be to utilize subsurface chambers for detention and treatment. We do have an area designated underneath the parking lot shown on the plans that we think could be feasible for our stormwater management system. And obviously our final package will include a detailed analysis of the stormwater. As far as permitting goes, we do trip the threshold for a traffic movement permit with the DOT. So, we will be keeping the town involved in that as that process gets going. And then, as previously mentioned, we will need a site law amendment from the main DEP. It is our understanding that you guys just got your delegated review authority for site law. So, we hope that can be included as part of the major site plan review process. Process, we'll be coordinating with the town staff as needed to make sure that everything goes smoothly there. And I just wanted to say the town staff has been incredibly helpful getting this project to this point. It was a great staff memo that you guys put together, and we took a look at that, and we don't have any major concerns with our ability to meet those requirements and address all your comments. So with that, I'll open it up to any questions you have for us.
[1:16:06] Town Council Member: This is
[1:16:20] Planning Board Member: the only big comment I have. I do believe the applicant just went through things very well, but their original submission to staff for the sketch plan did include elevations, and because they were missing some of the commercial design standards and we had meetings. So if you saw the memo that I wrote back to them, which noted some of those deficiencies, when they resubmitted, they decided not to include an elevation because they're not required at the sketch plan, but also they were not going to be like that once they resubmitted. So if you saw the notes on that, 's why. But just wanted to make sure you understood why those comments were in the staff review stuff and not given to you. Front entrance and pedestrian access. We had a separate meeting with just a couple members of staff and the oldies group to discuss this. Specifically because the design standards in the C1 require there to be an access point off of Route 302, so in order to meet that, we have added, they, the applicant has added in this vestibule essentially that would be a covered entrance that goes around the building to who meet the actual entrance, which staff felt met the intent of the ordinance, even if it's not, like, directly the words for words. And then those were my big comments. And because this is a sketch review, this is just more guidelines towards the applicant than motions and what not tonight.
[1:18:21] Chair of the Planning Board: Can you put the plan back up, please?
[1:18:23] Planning Board Member: Madam Chair, can I just make a couple of corrective statements relative to the applicant's proposal? One, we do not have delegated authority at this time. I didn't think so. Okay. But we do have what's called capacity site, and I'll explain it a little bit more in my presentation, which does provide Wyndham with the authority to look at site law applications up to 10 acres in size. In growth zones, which as we have discussed with DEP, they would actually allow our team, our stormwater team, to review the amended site location of development as referred by SLOTA. So we might be partnering with DEP or we might be taking it on ourselves. We can just, I'll discuss that with my presentation, but I just wanted to correct that in the, in the record. The other correction I want to make sure that the planning board understands relative to the pedestrian connection to 302 as sort of the district standards as it's termed, based on their presence of putting an entrance along 302 that would allow pedestrians to access from 302 into a portion of the building that would actually reach the actual functioning part of the front entrance of the building further down the parking lot. We felt that, as Natalie indicated, that the intent of the ordinance was being met by that effort. effort. So with that, I just wanted to add those two items for your concern. Thank you.
[1:20:23] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. Rick, you want to go first?
[1:20:28] Planning Board Member: I like the project. I think it looks good. I think it's well plotted out. I appreciate the effort you guys have put into it so far.
[1:20:35] Chair of the Planning Board: Emily, do you have anything? Yeah. Can
[1:20:38] Planning Board Member: you explain the access with the roads again? Because that's confusing me a bit. So there's I don't know if Natalie, if you could like... Do you have your pointer? Yeah, can you point or zoom in or something?
[1:20:52] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): So going from west to east is...
[1:20:55] Chair of the Planning Board: We can't tell west to east. Say left to right or something. Left to right, okay.
[1:21:00] Planning Board Member: Your left, your right, that's where it gets confusing. So can you point? Can you use a pointer? I'm trying, just seeing if I think I can do a pointer if I do it this way.
[1:21:09] Chair of the Planning Board: There we go. There we go.
[1:21:12] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): I can't see it.
[1:21:14] Planning Board Member: the next slide sorry but i think i can okay where
[1:21:24] Chair of the Planning Board: emily where are you at are you on all of it to the
[1:21:27] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): to the left side of the building yep so there's so that particular entry exit is today it's an existing right turn in right so we're going to alter that so that they can continue to right turn in and they can hook right around into the drive-thru as they do today right or they can continue straight and get into the left there's a turn at the i don't know about 10 spaces up i think there's a left into the aldi that's going you'll be removing like seven spots that were mcdonald's parking right now so those if you look at the dotted line that goes between the aldi in the mcdonald's it's diagonal can you enlarge that those are actually the least the least lines but i can't your hand pointer's fine that's fine so if you look at the that diagonal line that dotted line is actually the delineation of the lease premises from the mcdonald's and from what will be the aldi right so the those parking spaces are actually on mcdonald's property and they have access to those. And the whole center is actually non-exclusive parking, so anybody can really park anywhere.
[1:23:05] Planning Board Member: Yeah, I'm just saying, like, those seven that are existing, because we all know the area, will be gone. Yes. And that will be then the entrance to the Aldi parking lot. Yes. One entrance. Yes. And you'll be able to exit that way as well and then take a right onto 302 going south.
[1:23:24] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Yeah, and actually one thing that, for the McDonald's benefit, of it. When we looked at this, if you come in from Landing Road and come from the Walmart from the top of that, you can just leave it still. I know. From the top of that, coming in, you can come in and then take a right into Aldi, or you can continue straight onto 302, or you can come in and now there's a turning lane for McDonald's so that, you know, when you think about the drive through, right, that's like significant backup at peak times. So that won't impede any of the traffic flow going from the all the onto 302 or the you know Walmart area onto 302 so those are two entrances and then you have sorry there are two entrances on the Walmart side there's there's different curb cuts so there's one going from the McDonald's side there's one that is like enters into the main parking field there's a second one just beyond that and then And then there's a third one. For trucks? Primarily for trucks. Okay.
[1:24:24] Planning Board Member: And then there's an access for trucks on the 302 side as well?
[1:24:29] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Yeah, they can come right in that road to the left of the Aldi, pull up and back into the truck dock. Okay. And I believe there's three curb cuts there today on those two properties combined. Correct me if I'm wrong, but so we're going to reduce it down to two. So it'd be less access in and out on 302
[1:24:58] Planning Board Member: Where will shopping carts where do you imagine those
[1:25:02] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): shopping carts are up by the door there's they're on the up against the if you see the two double doors opened they'd be to the left of that there's no cart return there's a cart corral
[1:25:14] Planning Board Member: but no cart return within the parking lot no so no you get your quarter back you haven't gone I've been to Aldi before. I've been to Aldi. Well, you've got to get your quarter back.
[1:25:25] Chair of the Planning Board: You've got to bring it back when you've got it.
[1:25:27] Planning Board Member: No, you've got to get the fake one. You can 3D print those now. Sorry. Okay, so there's no –
[1:25:34] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): As long as you bring your fake quarter back with the carriage, we'll be fine.
[1:25:37] Planning Board Member: Okay, but there's no places within the parking lot to place a cart. My only thought is if you're going to have like a vestibule from 302 all the way to the entrance it would be nice to be able to access that maybe I don't know if there'd be
[1:25:57] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): other accesses well you it would be covered from 302 to the main entry but you'd have access through
[1:26:03] Planning Board Member: the yeah I'm just thinking like winter time trying to get in there and there's like this It's a nice covered place, but I have to walk all the way around. That was just my thought. You're saying it's not glassed in, so it'll actually be open?
[1:26:19] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): It'll be glassed in when you enter. It'll be closed, and then you can exit through to the sidewalk.
[1:26:23] Planning Board Member: I was just thinking, like, so where that hatched place where, yeah, right where your cursor is, like if there was a, will there be another entrance, or would you just have to walk around over to the sidewalk to get in? I'm just thinking if you're parked in this bottom corner and it's snowy. Emily, there's going to be no wall on the overhang, canopy overhang. After you get out of the vestibule, you'll walk to the front of the entrance towards Walmart. So that whole area will be covered. Oh, covered. But won't be walled. I thought you just said glassed in. The only part.
[1:26:58] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): The front part will be.
[1:26:59] Chair of the Planning Board: The thick wall, the black thick one. Oh, okay.
[1:27:03] Planning Board Member: I can't imagine what that will look like, so it will be nice to see what the elevation looks like. I'm waiting on them. Okay. Okay, that's it, thank you, Leo. Yeah, I mean, it's it's it's it's good, it's not a lot to look at now because I think we're all interested in the elevations. I know for myself when I first looked at it, some primary concerns I had were that we were going to meet all of the architectural design standards. I know from like your note with like the sides like going down 302 there. Like, I understand that, and I guess it would be important to me and I'm sure others that the front of that building that's on 302, especially whereas it only needs a 10 to 20 foot setback from the road, looks within character of, you know, the rest of the town, you know, and looks like the front of a building, you know, of a main building. I was very concerned when I looked it up. I'm like, well, so we've got the front in view, the side where you have the vestibule. When I'm driving down 302, I'm going to be seeing that whole side. There doesn't appear to be much screening, and the loading barrier is partly in view. So you've got this challenge where you have three to four sides of the building that have a lot of view to them. So I guess, you know, it would be important to me and others that it matches and really holds to every standard we have as far as the building material, the amount of windows, all of the things, the roof slopes, all that. And I'm sure that you're working on those, but without seeing those, it's hard to look at. And then, you know, my other concern that doesn't probably fall into this is, of course, like the lighting portion of it, where I'm sure there are different feelings out there of, you know, we want to make sure that parking lots are well lit for safety and this and that. that i come from the concern of any way that we can illuminate eliminate light pollution and not light up north windham as though it's daylight at all hours is favorable right so i know we have standards for that and i'm kind of jumping ahead of that now but yeah i 'd be interested to see those you know and looking towards a building that ages well within this area and doesn't 30 years from now look like a pizza hut you know and you're like well why that doesn't quite fit in you know what i'm talking about yeah that 's what i got, Alissa. So I would just, I'm not going to assume, I'm going to ask the question from the traffic study evaluations: is that whole McDonald's into all the kerfuffle evaluated from a, there will be this mini accident standpoint, because I'm sorry, but people don't drive well at peak hours or non peak hours at times. I'm, I'm very concerned about that whole, like where you can go straight through or you could cross over or, you know, it's, this will require a traffic movement permit, but does that just the in and out, or will it also include those traffic flows? They will look at every intersection, every entrance, and the project as a whole. It will not just be trips in and trips out. Okay, because that I just see nightmare written all over that. I don't know if you sat in that McDonald's park and go check out Starbucks at, you know, seven in the morning, and that's exactly what that'll be. It's a hot mess. During our development review team meeting, public safety also was interested in seeing some more of the traffic information that would come out of this. Okay, good. Everett? So the curb cut on the, let's call it the left side of the building, that is for trucks, right? For deliveries? Yes. Is there a way to eliminate that and have all trucks come from the Walmart side?
[1:31:20] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Not really, because the dock is on the – at least I don't think so. Because the docks, you've got to pull in and back into the dock. If it came from the Walmart side, you'd have to like – yeah, there's no way.
[1:31:41] Planning Board Member: Are you going to put up signs there that basically say no entry?
[1:31:44] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): I think, I think, and I think that was discussed at the staff meeting. I think we said we try to sign it appropriately, but in the DOT would probably weigh
[1:31:57] Andrew Kerman (LJB Civil Engineers): In on that as well, signage especially along Route 302.
[1:32:01] Planning Board Member: Then could you zoom in on the vestibule, please, so there's a little door that opens outward from the from the building itself? That is an emergency exit. Okay. So the ordinance says that you need a primary entrance on 302. Well, on the front facade. And it says that a primary entrance must provide ingress and egress. Does this provide ingress?
[1:32:34] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): You can go in it and you can leave it. So I can go...
[1:32:38] Planning Board Member: Is that what you're asking? No. So the vestibule. Yes. Suppose I enter through that door, kind of like the 302 side door. Yes. The one at the bottom.
[1:32:51] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Where do I go next? Straight through to the other side, to the sidewalk. Okay.
[1:33:00] Planning Board Member: So I don't really have any building ingress because I'm going in, then I'm going back out, then I've got to go all the way around.
[1:33:12] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): If you're a pedestrian walking from the street, you'd enter through the vestibule, exit the vestibule on the sidewalk side, which is covered, up and through up to the main entrance.
[1:33:28] Planning Board Member: I'm not a fan of this part of the ordinance, but I don't think it meets the ordinance, just my opinion, because it doesn't provide ingress.
[1:33:38] Chair of the Planning Board: Us Natalie, is this similar to when we've taken the porches and swung around to the front of the building, even the door, even though the door is on the other side, to have that main entrance being on
[1:33:48] Planning Board Member: the main street, except this is section 400. We'll have to let Steven turn that. I wasn't here for any of those projects. Yeah, I would say that 's, you know, this is a struggle that we had along with Chipotle and Starbucks, although that went through a staff review and not the planning board. So I think the intent of the ordinance is to provide at least a primary entrance located on the building's front facade. So I've got a question then about that. No, the question is sort of a technical question. We would, you know, have our attorney weigh on or their attorney can provide a statement regarding whether or not this particular setup is providing ingress and egress, but is it to the interior of the building is what you're asking, right? That's part of it, yes. Your interior of the building. Yes,. So, I mean, I'm going to say that, you know, all these as the applicant should provide a comment from their attorney relative to the language on this to see whether or not what this district standard requires an entrance into the physical building itself or is this vestibule enough to say that it's in and out. Let me ask a different question because you bring up a good point about Chipotle and Starbucks. I cannot get into Chipotle and Starbucks from the 302 site at all. That's great. So how did that get approved? I wasn't here at the time, so I can't answer that question. But this was in the ordinance, right? But I can't answer that question. I don't know. Is it possible that the front facade of the building doesn't have to be street-facing? I mean, they could have multiple front-facing facades. It doesn't necessarily have to be primarily located on 302. It could be other primary entrances. The Bangor Savings Building. That's the same situation. Because they have visibility on all three of the sides, and they're that close to the street. When I saw it, I was like, and it's actually probably a similar-sized building. To your point, I think what they did, I was just looking at their street view. I think what we're asking is do we have to technically call the front of the building the part that faces 302, right? Right, because the Starbucks and Chipotle front facades are away from – Because, frankly, the idea of, like, bolting a vestibule onto a building, which will make it look ugly no matter how you do it, But just to satisfy, you know, this, where we're not really able to enter the building, seems like a waste of effort to me. I think that there's, you know, the intent of the vestibule is to mirror, you know, similar Aldi's marketing with the tower above the vestibule to say that here is where you can get into the building. Also, this is part of the design, part of the standard design. Or did you put this in to meet the ordinance?
[1:37:34] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): This has been put in after we met with staff. We figured this would be put so we could meet.
[1:37:41] Planning Board Member: Can we get clarification on entrance? My suggestion is that you request the applicant to provide a legal analysis of these terms so that our attorney can review it. As much as we want to interpret, we can't interpret everything as well as an attorney can. And, you know, my suggestion is that the board request that information from the applicant, and that's perfectly in your purview to do that. I'm not trying to— Very specifically, I would ask, if I were you, I might ask your attorney to basically say if there is anything in the ordinance that says that the front has to face the road. And if the front doesn't have to face the road, you don't need the vestibule because then you can just have your entrance on the front facade. Everett, though, are we going to be looking at the back of a warehouse building? So that is where the commercial design standards come in. You have to have frustration. Which, also, it would have been nice to see elevations because Mr. Puglio, correct me if I'm wrong, or actually Ms. Thompson, we can waive the commercial design standard. This is true. That is true. So you can come to us with a design that doesn't necessarily – like if you find that you're partially meeting it. And the building doesn't look ugly and we're not looking at a blank wall from the road and things like that, then there are certain things. Because, you know, and this may be just my view, I would rather we have an attractive-looking building than try to, like, force design standards in there and make it look like an abomination. No, but can we ask that they make every attempt such that we don't have to waive? Because that's the one thing I think we get beat up the most on. Oh, absolutely. So, like, we want it to look good. That's the reason that the design standards are in there. If there is something, you know, that you have strong concerns on, please bring them to us.
[1:39:45] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): And just, I guess, maybe for me to back up for you guys, too, because this isn't our first pass at this, right? So we've been kind of working together a little bit back and forth. We first brought the plan that was not on the road. And then we said, well, it needs to be on the road, design standards. We did that. And then they said, you're not meeting any of the, well, not any, but a lot of the design standards. So then we went back, changed that, and met a lot of the, actually all the design standards, I believe, except the entry on the door. So then we came back to this, and we, you know, this is what we came up with to try to meet the standards.
[1:40:26] Planning Board Member: Well, and here's the thing. If you can make it look good, that's one thing. Right. But if it just starts looking weird, and we can't waive the standard because it's a district standard, not a commercial design standard. It's in Section 400, so it's not waivable, at least not this one. But just look into it because we've had some other cases, I think, with building designs where we had to force a certain design element, and it just ended up looking weird.
[1:40:54] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): So, just so I'm clear, so what you're saying is if there's language that says the front of the building doesn't have to face 302, then the entrance doesn't have to be there.
[1:41:06] Planning Board Member: So, we're asking you to investigate with your attorney to interpret that and bring it to the town's attorney. Got it. Okay. I mean, specifically Section 120, 410, F3, and 4. And those are the design district standards in the C1 district.
[1:41:27] Chair of the Planning Board: Can you scroll that down just to put it down just a little?
[1:41:30] Planning Board Member: I would also suggest that if you covered the walkway, that covered walkway, if you were to enclose that, you would then meet the standard.
[1:41:38] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Yeah, so, I mean, the only challenge with that is if you park there.
[1:41:43] Chair of the Planning Board: Yeah, you need a place to get in. It's kind of like, why have it if you can't get into it?
[1:41:52] Planning Board Member: I mean, there's probably six ways to. Just make it look good.
[1:41:56] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Yeah, you know, just to address some of the concerns, too. So, you know, when we did come up against one of the iterations, I don't know, I must have did like seven different iterations of this. And, you know, we are going to put a facade on the front. Even if there isn't a door, we're going to make it look like the front of a building. And we even talked with staff. They recommended, you know, some graphics on the front, that sort of thing, with glass. So we have every intention of making a nice building. We always do. You also, for now?
[1:42:27] Chair of the Planning Board: I'm also. Okay. I have a big concern with all the driveways. Can you bring it over to the McDonald's one? I didn't realize you were going to have an exit there for some reason. I saw you were changing the entrance into McDonald's, I guess you're going to widen it and then it's going to go up and then you're going to have the entrance into your, but I didn't realize there was going to be an exit that came down beside it. Now is that going to meet the distance between driveways for MDOT? MDOT says you can't have two driveways within, I don't know in the commercial district if it still applies. You can't have a, how far away
[1:43:14] Planning Board Member: is one driveway from the other? I think this would be considered one curb cut because it's in it's
[1:43:19] Chair of the Planning Board: one in and one out. Yes, but it doesn't have an island. I thought it was all the only with a with
[1:43:25] Planning Board Member: a slash. This is an island. Okay.
[1:43:29] Chair of the Planning Board: And so does the arrows, what are the arrows for? Yeah, the arrows
[1:43:34] Planning Board Member: are what are throwing me because so if you leave all these and you want to go to McDonald's or if you're coming from the Walmart area.
[1:43:43] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): So the arrows is so that the Walmart drive-thru doesn't back up and create issues so that people, traffic can flow by. If the Walmart, McDonald's drive-thru backs up, that doesn't create a traffic issue for everybody else. Right. So it's trying to separate that. Now,
[1:44:07] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay, so you have the arrows come this way. So that means that if people come in from 302 into McDonald's, they get right past the island, they can just swing in there. Yes. Left. I thought that's what that crosshatch up near the top.
[1:44:23] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): Crosshatch is a don't block the box.
[1:44:28] Planning Board Member: Oh, that's a Boston thing. So you've got to translate that for me. Right. Like I'm from Boston.
[1:44:35] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): I know. Sorry, I'm from Boston.
[1:44:39] Chair of the Planning Board: So the exit, which is 10 feet wide, oh, my God.
[1:44:46] Andrew Kerman (LJB Civil Engineers): We're going to be taking a –
[1:44:47] Chair of the Planning Board: This is going to – I mean, traffic, with all of these things coming in and out of 302, we're closer and closer to the lights. And the backup of traffic on that road is – I'm assuming you're going to tell me that MDOT is going to look at all that stuff. Yeah. But I guess if, okay, if you can come in from Landing Road.
[1:45:19] Planning Board Member: But not only MDOT, we'll be working with the applicant in MDOT. So, you know, like the fire chief and the police chief and everybody that's involved with the scoping meetings will be working on this when they go through the traffic movement permit process, which they have to have in hand before they come back here. Okay. So, you know, this is all based on working through the North Wyndham Moves design team, which we've presented this to them. We've presented some modifications at Landing Road to the North Wyndham's design team, which is under MDOT, not up and down. And we're trying to coordinate all the sidewalk and drive and access ways and island improvements so that it's all coordinated and it's all going to integrate into one contiguous project that is going to work. So, you know, this is the applicant's proposal right now. Now. We expect, you know, like the exit, right exit lane needs to be widened from what they're showing there because our fire chiefs said that our trucks are not going to be able to get down there. There's some considerations that we have to do with WS development because WS owns the property that McDonald's sits on, and they own this property and the adjacent property and the Walmart property, and the access way that's available through Walmart that goes all the way to Shaw's, all the way out to 135, is, you know, designed so that there is this sort of back alley road that will be able to connect all of those properties together. And then with North Windham Moves Middle Connector, there's another option to get back onto 302. So it's going to be radically change from what we're seeing today when all this is done well i do know i can
[1:47:26] Chair of the Planning Board: tell you from experience multiple experiences that when it's very busy at mcdonald's that drive through those cars are back over into that lane that you're pulling into and you can't get out of that parking spot and oh yeah and people can't i know you can't get out of the parking spot but they back they back up i know they've got like two lanes now but they back all the way up there Which is there, no, up to where they're going in to go to your store. Oh, okay.
[1:47:58] Planning Board Member: I don't disagree with you, Marge. I mean, those are things that we're going to have to take a look at. It could affect, you know, the TMP, the traffic movement permit, for a lot of things. So, you know, that's a whole other review that's going to take place where we have our traffic engineer review their traffic engineer, and we're going to have North Windham Moves involved, and we're going to have DOT involved. What we see today is their proposal. It may be altered. It may be different than what you're seeing right now. Remember, this is a sketch plan. This is just to kind of bring you up to speed. You know, some of these design criteria that we're talking about here at this time, if you want to make suggestions for them to look into it to consider it
[1:48:50] Chair of the Planning Board: I would like a traffic study done inside of that I would like a traffic study done inside traffic circulation I guess traffic circulation study and I don't know who does that
[1:49:01] Planning Board Member: well a traffic engineer will I mean you know all of that we can take into consideration again to respond to what you want them to provide to you for information so again i'm just trying to emphasize that what you want you ask them and they either can handle it or they are they're going to say no this is not going to work for us at all
[1:49:25] Chair of the Planning Board: Because I, because I'm, I'm really concerned. I don't know if I'm more concerned with the congestion, 302, of the congestion in there, because it gets very, I mean, there is nothing going on over there right now, and it gets congested in that area as it is. I don't have an issue with the truck as long as there's a sign there that says delivery trucks only. No, you know, that's fine. But I know what's going to happen. People are going to leave McDonald's. The people that didn't go to Aldi's are going to leave there, cut through, and come right out onto 302. So I hope a lot of that, which is not your issue, so I hope that is also taken into consideration of what can happen there. The problem I have with traffic studies is they don't do enough of them, and they do it whenever. You know what I mean? It's kind of like they do it once or twice, and that's it. So it's different in the summer than it is in the winter here. It's different during times people are getting out of work than it is at, like, 9 in the morning. So I know we have no control over that. That's just a comment.
[1:50:42] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): I mean, when we did our initial traffic study, it was done during the summer to get that peak activity.
[1:50:48] Chair of the Planning Board: Well, we didn't see the traffic study, so I don't know about that. But I think it's fine. I mean, with it being there, I just am concerned about the traffic. I really am. I think it's great because that's been just an empty parking lot that just, well, not the front one, the buildings are gone, but where Wal-Mart's was, it just collected extra stuff. You know, people parked their campers or whatever the heck there and left them there and so forth. So that's good. And if you can get the fenestration in the main entrance figured out so that it's – because actually it's not a gigantic store, but it's a good-sized store. So to have the entrance up in that one corner so everybody that's down here is really far away, and they're going to walk all the way back up there with their cart. And I don't know if you can move the entrance so it's more centered.
[1:51:46] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): So the entrance, the main entrance as it is today, is central to more of the parking than anywhere else you could put it, but
[1:51:57] Chair of the Planning Board: Well, not necessarily, because you have more parking down here than you do up there, but that's okay, I get it. I think if you guys know this job isn't, if you look at it from a distant standpoint, then yeah, but anyway, I guess my biggest concern is that the traffic. I don't have a problem with the building. I will be interested in landscaping. The thing being is we've had some people put some stuff in, and then they don't keep it up. We do like landscaping because it makes everything look better naturally, especially when it's just a big brick building or whatever your building is. So we'll be interested in that naturally. And the thing I would ask, and Natalie, tell me if it's inappropriate, is that when they come back for the preliminary, if they have anything conceptual,
[1:52:50] Planning Board Member: this is a site plan, so they'll only come back for final.
[1:52:53] Chair of the Planning Board: Oh, they'll only come back. That's right. Okay.
[1:52:58] Planning Board Member: Okay. I had one more thought. Go ahead. What's your plan for snow removal?
[1:53:08] Andrew Kerman (LJB Civil Engineers): There is some space in the, I guess it's southwest on the plan. And it's the top left. There is some space up there for some snow storage. And I believe that we would also be able to work something out with WS relative to snow storage in the existing Walmart parking lot, if necessary.
[1:53:34] Planning Board Member: The problem is, they normally store snow right where you're building that building. Correct.
[1:53:38] Chair of the Planning Board: Right. Because nobody parks there.
[1:53:42] Planning Board Member: The cross hatches, I mean, I don't know if you've driven by Walgreens, but nobody cares about the cross hatches. They block the box all the time, so I would not lay into that as an opportunity to control traffic, just my two cents on that. Heck, it's half painted over, I think, right now from paving work, so, and then you are tying, you would be tying into our new septic, yes, system. Correct. Yeah, there's a gravity line in the, in the access drive. Where would your sign
[1:54:19] Chair of the Planning Board: be going, other than the building? Is it just on the building? Are you planning on putting a sign
[1:54:24] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): at one of the entrances? Probably have a sign at the entrance, probably on the island, I'm guessing. Quite honestly, we haven't.
[1:54:29] Chair of the Planning Board: This island on 302.
[1:54:31] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): That hasn't, we haven't kind of definitively identified that, but we're definitely going to have building signage and a pylon sign.
[1:54:41] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. Now, there was some conversation, and we didn't really talk about it because later on there's sidewalks, and I think that was the whole idea of if the sidewalks are there and the door, you know, you'd have that vestibule. You could walk up from the sidewalk. Is that dictated anywhere that you have to have entrance if there's a sidewalk there? I know the sidewalk is going to come after the fact.
[1:55:08] Planning Board Member: Well, again, that pedestrian access, and I would like their attorney to provide some information regarding that. The sidewalks are going to, will probably have to assess an impact fee and collect that money and provide it to DOT as they're, when they finish 302, the MOVES project, and they put the sidewalk back in, that money will be there for them to use at that time. [Chair of the Planning Board: Okay. All right.] Because there's nothing out there right now. Okay.
[1:55:38] Chair of the Planning Board: Now, I know what you said, but what was in what I read earlier, and I guess this has changed about the stormwater because you were going to use what was there, air and then you then you talked about an in lieu fee which I don't think we have but you've changed that I think from what you said as to how you're handling storm water it'll still go to the
[1:55:59] Andrew Kerman (LJB Civil Engineers): pond next to Walmart but before it gets there we're going to essentially treat it and over treat it and make sure that we're not increasing flows to the existing catch basins and storm drain lines on top of making sure that it doesn't adversely impact the existing pond.
[1:56:21] Chair of the Planning Board: So we'll see a report on that? Will there be something? Because I've seen that when it's full.
[1:56:28] Planning Board Member: Yeah, our consulting engineer will be, either one will be issuing a stormwater permit for this particular project or will do an amended site law permit. FOR THE ENTIRE WS DEVELOPMENT AREA. SO, I MEAN, THAT'S SOMETHING TO COME. OKAY. GREAT.
[1:56:52] Chair of the Planning Board: DOES ANYBODY ELSE HAVE ANYTHING ELSE BEFORE? I DO. GO AHEAD.
[1:56:56] Planning Board Member: YEAH, ONE QUESTION. SO, CONCEPTUALLY, HOW DO YOU DEAL WITH THE DEFENESTRATION REQUIREMENT ON THE 302 SIDE OF THE BUILDING? BECAUSE WHAT PART OF THE STORE IS THAT GOING TO BE? IS THAT GOING TO BE LIKE THE WAREHOUSE PART?
[1:57:11] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): So that would be part of this mostly back room. So, you know, we haven't been working on that right now. But, you know, just looking at this, we'd have basically a tower on one of the corners. And then we'd have glass with graphics like on the front. So it's not just like a big brick building. That's it. And I guess one more thing, too. You guys talked about stormwater and water and septic. Sanitary. Nobody asked about gas. We're not going to have gas here. It's going to be an all-electric building. So, just in case that comes up. I
[1:57:58] Chair of the Planning Board: think that's it for now, Natalie.
[1:58:07] Planning Board Member: There's no motions on The only thing I, if you guys would just want to determine if you'd like to have a sidewalk.
[1:58:18] Chair of the Planning Board: I would like to, personally, I'd like to see some. The thing is, if we have a site walk now, and we don't know if what we're going to end up seeing once the final is what that looks like now. It's very difficult to have a site walk. I don't know how we do this, but I think it's –
[1:58:38] Planning Board Member: Yeah, because the biggest part is, like, traffic flow, and if that's not finalized – Well, yeah. You could have your site walk after they submit their final plan.
[1:58:49] Chair of the Planning Board: That would be good. Yeah, find that window in there. I think would help. It would be very difficult now because you couldn't really show us anything. It's kind of like, well, we showed you the buildings here and we showed you these are the driveways and then it comes before us and then I don't want us sitting here saying, okay, what we looked at is not what we're looking at now so we should go out and look at it again. That's all. I'm just trying to save you from that. But that would be fine. We can do that. Okay.
[1:59:24] Planning Board Member: I think we are good. Okay.
[1:59:28] Chair of the Planning Board: We'll be at the same thing, right? Public hearing will be the next meeting because there's only one more. At the final, usually. All right. All righty. Moving on. Next is PB 26-081, 26-24, Land Use Ordinance Text Amendment, Chapter 120, Articles 8 and 9, Site Law Delegated Review Authority, Town of Wyndham. Staff proposes amendments to Site Plan Review Subsection 120-811 and 120-812 and Subdivision Review Subsection 120-910 and 120-911 to satisfy main DEP requirements for Site Law Delegated Review Authority. The revisions address soils, groundwater, blasting, noise, natural resources, wildlife and fisheries, scenic character, and odor control, enabling the town to review qualifying site law applications. I know this is yours. I have to ask you a question before we start on this, though, Steve. We were having that conversation when they were here for the sketch plan on us being able to do that. How is that going to happen, seeing as they're in front of us now and that has not been approved, the change?
[2:00:54] Planning Board Member: Well, let me explain. Okay, thank you. I'll go through my presentation and I will answer that question for you. Well, thank you for taking the time to review this. So this is a focused effort remaining on a few of what I call miscellaneous ordinance amendments relative to our ordinance that would put us in line with DEP as ordinance equivalent to the DEP site location permitting process. So we've been on this track for quite some time. As you all know, we've made a number of amendments. And what we're looking at here is to strengthen our site plan or our subdivision standards. And this group here is involving soils, groundwater, natural resources, noise, a little minor change with our blasting. I'll explain that. Scenic characteristics and odor. And this will keep Wyndham's existing review structure in place as well. So we're not going to be changing our review structure to look like DEP statute, but we've built it and integrated it into our existing ordinance structure. So that it fits within how we do business here and how the planning board reviews applications and it stays within the same process that we're in now. I'm going to briefly explain the changes here. We're now working with the town attorney to make sure the language is legal. We've spent some time with DEP's director of the land bureau and his permitting director, Jessica Damon and Rob Wood, to work through these things. So the last meeting that we had with DEP, and as you are all aware, that we are exempt under Chapter 500. So unfortunately the gentleman didn't understand that. But we're exempt under Chapter 500 to issue our own stormwater permits. And that's basically up to three acres of impervious on a five-acre or more-sized parcel. So that's what we're doing now. We've done a number of stormwater permits with the planning board's approval through some site plans, A-plus auto, a couple of small subdivisions, Monty Way, things of that nature, and the Eventide subdivision was a stormwater permit. And as you know, the Highland Clift, they want to break up in two phases so they can do the stormwater and then maybe a site law subsequent to that. So as of our last meeting with DEP, we've been issued also what's called capacity site, which basically means that the town, without any direction with DEP, can review site permits, which would be 10 acres of impervious conditions for a commercial building in the commercial growth area. So for instance, all these is a commercial building, it's in a commercial growth area, the total site does have more than 10 acres, but because we've qualified, DEP would work with our, with us, Wyndham, and our contractors to do an amended site location of development permit or a SLOTA. And then this effort is to get the final designation of a delegated review authority for site permits, which would mean any place in town that has, and I will read you sort of the thresholds, any place in town where DEP review applies to projects where it occupies land or water more than 20 acres, a structure or total ground area of more than three acres, building, parking lots, roads, paved areas, stripped, graded, and not revegetated, and is a subdivision of five or more lots offered for sale within a five-year period with an aggregated area of more than 20 acres. So the delegated review range the town could permit locally under subsection 489A that subdivisions with more than 20 acres but less than 100 and structures of more than 3 acres but less than 10 projects above can stay within the DEP limits. So those projects scope we would now be designated as a review authority. And to do that, what we have to do is we have to elevate our ordinances to as stringent or more stringent than DEP's standards under three chapters, Chapter 373, 375, and 376. So that's what we're asking, a land use recommendation from this board to the town council so that we can finish these amendments. And I'm going to kind of go through them. They look like a lot of amendments, but as you are aware, because you implement the ordinance, our statements show up in different areas and they have to be covered across the board. But in general, they are those sort of five to eight items that we need to tighten up. And beyond that, the town hasn't really kept pace with the changes of the environmental ordinances that we're kind of talking about here, which are scenic character, wildlife, and things of that nature that the DEP has changed over time. As a matter of fact, other delegated communities haven't brought up their ordinance to this level. And through our work with DEP, they've recognized that. So the last time they've issued a delegated review authority for site permit was in 2015, so it's been quite a few years. As a matter of fact, the people that are managing that bureau weren't even employed the last time they issued a delegated review authority permit. So this is new for them and it's new for us, but we've helped them figure out a process that going forward more communities will be able to come on board if they meet our application effort that we've made through. So, the amendment package that we're looking at here updates the site plan under Article 8, subdivision review under Article 9, align soil, groundwater, natural resources, noise, blasting, scenic character, and odor standards. Clarifies evidence findings and mitigation and conditions available during local review. And, again, it's designed to address – these ordinances are designed to address the October 19th recommendation and closely remaining site law equivalency gaps. So we want to close those gaps, and that's what we feel that we're doing right now. Again, we're working with our attorney to do those things. So under Article 8, we have some smaller sort of applications, submission corrections. Our ordinance was – we kind of missed it in places. It says five applications, and again, I've gone through and corrected all of that because we only take three paper copies and electronic filings. We also added in the submission requirements under 9-11 soil limitation reports with mitigations, estimated groundwater withdrawals, potential contamination inventory, background water quality, spill prevention plans were applicable. applicable, so we're strengthening the issues that we feel that the Board is a little bit deficient right now and having kind of concerns with trying to have enough evidence to make it go through the review and approval process. Under 128.12 and resource findings, so threatened species, agency recommendations, again, groundwater quality and quantity, anti-degradation zones, excuse me, degradation zones of contribution, which I think Everett was talking a little bit about, where are the zones? Now they will have to show the zones based on what's required underneath this amendment to align our hydrological assessment with the state's hydrological assessment. So there's a little more beef that we're adding to our ordinance that would allow the planning board to request and require these things that right now is sort of asking them to do because it's not there in ordinance. You know, like I said, zones of contribution and cumulative withdrawals and having professional and technical evidence provided. Going on further, on 8-12, we're beefing up our noise ordinance so that there is no excess of 80 decibels at the property line cap. Cap, and that there is a 5 DBA adjustment for tonal and repetitive sounds. So they have to apply that not only to our standard limitations, but there's a cap on what can be produced at the property boundaries, even though we have that stated in our ordinance table. They wanted us to include that property cap limit, which is part of theirs, but also this is 5 dBA adjustment for tonal and repetitive sounds. That's coming right straight out of the recommendations from DEP. And then for other impacts, for instance, 812U, which is our blasting ordinance, the DEP was concerned with a term we had in there, can prove or can demonstrate safe blasting criteria. They wanted that changed to will, so that's part of this amendment. We've added scenic characters, which is going to be V, and then odor control when you're talking about commercial developments under W. So that explicitly aligns with DEP's requirements for those additional sections V and W, that's scenic characters. So what we hope, what I'm trying to get the board to take away is a clear completeness review and stronger findings for approval, before approval. And then along with the subdivision review amendments, similarly with the completion requirement under 910, we're talking about three copies again having soil limitations and full build out ground use reports provided as part of the submittal potential contaminants and spill planning which is not in our ordinance now which would require them to provide us a SWPPP type program and how they would prevent any kind of spills during construction or subsequent, you know, illicit discharge from the actual subdivision that's being put in place. So we could have some requirements as part of their homeowners association that, you know, illicit discharge will not be, you know, allowed. And then if it is a project that requires state-delegated review, there would be no waivers to the state compliance standards. So if it's a site law delegated review project, their site law application is going to rule the day. There will be no waivers below the standards and thresholds of these amendments as written. If it's not a site law project, even though these ordinances are there, the planning board could choose to implement them or to waive them depending on each unique situation in dealing with the applicant. Going on, natural resource areas, wildlife fisheries, natural buffers, mitigation, and other agency recommendations, which we do as sort of a courtesy, but now we're codifying it. So if there is the small world Pagodia as identified as a threatened species from the IFNW or MNAP program, and the recommendation is to do an area that's protected by a buffer of this size, then, you know, that's the recommendation we're going to be looking the applicant to make when they deal with the threatened and endangered species criteria. So it gives us a little bit more oomph to make sure that, you know, the threatened species category is being cared for. Groundwater, excuse me, groundwater drinking standards across the affected area. So it's not just the property boundary. It can go beyond the property boundary. Country. So, again, we're going to have to have reports. We're going to have to understand how that comes into play when we go forward, when these ordinances come into play, if they're adopted. No further degradation, which we do have, but the language is stronger now. Well water, natural resources, contribution zones, and cumulative withdrawals have to be understood and reported on under groundwater, and that's 9-11-H, so it's very specific. There's a lot of work that we put into 9-11-H to kind of beef that up for us. And then finally P and Q, other impacts. So again, the mandatory blasting compliance from can to will takes, it takes place in 9-11-P. 9-11-Q is a new ordinance for, it's not an odor standard, but it's not the odor standard for non. It's only for the odor standards. It's only for odor standards for non-residential subdivisions, so commercial subdivisions. So residential subdivisions don't have to comply with the odor standard. But if we have a commercial subdivision, then that odor standard would apply. And, again, what we're trying to do is reduce the gaps between the review pathways and align eight and nine so that they run parallel and affect each type of proposal equally. How do amendments improve the workflow? So, you know, this is one of the big things that we have to deal with is workflow and not, you know, going back to the applicant late stage for information. We want to get all the information up front. We don't want to go back and forth and have these things drawn out for long periods of time. They're either going to meet the standard or they're going to withdraw their application because it's too heavy for them to meet the standard. But the intent is to, you know, have a pre-application with the applicant to understand the risks and needs study, needed study to identify early, you know, we want the amendment to spell out what the applicant needs to submit, soil limitation reports, estimated groundwater use, potential contaminations of inventory, potential contaminant inventory, with background, water quality, spill prevention, planning in unusual natural areas. And the staff will be able to tell the applicants at the first meeting that studies will be needed, that we'll avoid surprises later, and keep the applicant on budget and costs for the technical work up front. Completeness, again, we want to be able to align our completeness for applications. Again, dealing with the areas that were concerned with this amendment, but primarily groundwater and natural resources, noise, blasting, scenic characteristics, et cetera. The technical review, so the Board will be able to rely on reports, agency inputs and peer review, and the amendments will make clear that the Board may consider professional technical evidence, and agency recommendations. For example, threatened species and wildlife and fisheries, as I mentioned before, and outside peer review to give us the evidence that they're complying with the ordinance. And then the findings or notice of decision evidence will be directly tied to the approval criteria, board's written findings on groundwater quality, and quantity, any degradation, zones of contributions, cumulative withdrawals, natural resources, and other impacts, we'll point back to specific evidence and to the criterion of 812 and 911. And then finally, we'll be able to monitor. Monitor we can have conditions monitoring different impacts mitigations to safeguard targets so again this will all be tied back to the ordinance standards and will allow the planning board to put in conditions of approval which the town will then have to enforce as part of this approval so you know we feel that this will be a much better administrative record through the process with conditions and directly address and identify the impacts and it will take away any concerns that people may Have relative to personal opinions it will be based in evidence and reports peer review so the benefits of the town and the applicant in the public so the town will integrate great their site law review means as one local process instead of being separate state permit track so we'll have it all in-house the town will be looking at all of these issues there will be a clear equivalency between DEP's record and the planning board's record a consistency with article 8 and 9 expressed the authority That the planning board would have for evidence and conditions of approval that would be required. And local peer review from reviewers that know Wyndham, that understand the lakes and wetlands and groundwater and safeguards. For the applicant, it requires them to identify things earlier in the process. Fewer later duplicate requests, more predictive review for them, electronic filings, fewer paper sets, things like that are helpful. Reviewers are already familiar with Wyndham Soil and Water, so we're not dealing with an agency that might be in Augusta or even in a different place in the state that would be reviewing these site law applications that would affect the town site specific not generic studies will be requested so we'll be looking at things very specifically and beyond that the oops sorry about that the findings are tied to evidence for the public stronger groundwater and resource protections transparent agency Input, you know, better mitigation and enforcement records. Those are important for us to implement these decisions. Independent local experts checking natural resources impacts will be very much leaned on when we go through this process. So we'll have more input from our third party that is very familiar with development here in Wyndham, and then reflect that in findings and conditions of approval. So, again, overall benefit is more complete local decision-making, less regulatory ambiguity, and more based on evidence. And how the ordinance update will benefit reviewers in approval. So clearer decision standards. So every report will be linked to specific rules that they must meet. The board can see the evidence backed by the decision. Local consultants check reports against rules for the Wyndham sites. So, you know, that and better technical record so the board can ask experts for reports in outside review, which we do anyway but now it is formalized and it's built into the ordinance so the applicant can read that and it's clear to them that the board has this authority. Input from state and other agencies will be shown more openly. More precise conditions, and that's really kind of key. We'll be able to understand what things need to be measured and monitored and reported back and continue to provide those other safeguards. And stronger, more defensible actions. Written findings easy to explain to the applicant and the public. Clearer records mean fairer, consistent enforcement and fewer reopened issues. So, and again, our local experts will help protect our resources. The bottom line is a clear, documented path for evidence for findings, conditions, and the final decision. We had two public comments. Basically, these are the common themes of the public comments. Drinking water, existing wells, protection of natural resources, soil, stormwater, groundwater, wildlife habitat, farmland, town characteristic. We feel that these ordinances are going to strengthen all of those areas, enforceable standards, clear noise and blasting odor limits, clear requirements for development, consistent enforcement during and after the construction, and then providing meaningful review for approval for you, the planning board, and decisions are based in evidence. And finally, you know, an open process. This process is an open process. We want the, you know, residents to comment on proposed language. If you do have any comments, we are asking suggestions to be provided to Planning Board at windham.us, windham main.us, before November 16th so that our attorneys can review any kind of modifications before we come back for a public hearing on November 23rd, where you will then look at making a recommendation on the Delegated Review Authority site law, miscellaneous and land use ordinance amendments in Chapter 120. And with that, I can answer some questions. It's not a public hearing, but I certainly am happy to discuss anything that the Polanyi Board has on their mind. I have one major question. My primary question is, so I understand why we're doing all of these things. Were any of these changes put in here at your discretion, or did these all come from review of DEP standards for us in order to get certified? All of these proposed amendments are directly related to the request that I provided to you in the packet from DEP. Thank you. And like I said, they did an exhaustive review. We did an exhaustive review. I provided several hundreds of pages of documentation to DEP, and they spent and many months reviewing every bit and pieces of what we provided.
[2:26:59] Chair of the Planning Board: So these are actually, a lot of this is basically from you up to, well, from your department up to DEP for them to compare them to what they have to what you're looking for. I assume some of this is not necessarily just everything that came from them. I mean, it's got to be a lot of the stuff that is needed for you guys to do your job.
[2:27:24] Planning Board Member: No,, it's really, it's really the other way around. We made application, we provided DP with everything we thought that was as stringent or more stringent than their regulations or statutes. And they came back and said, no, not so much. You know, we have these areas that we're concerned about. We want to see, your ordinance refer to recommendations from agencies. We want to see you put in threatened species because that wasn't there. We want to see some of these things that need to talk about scenic character in more measurable terms and not sort of gray terms that we had in our ordinance. So all of the red line information that I provided you is to address their response to our application. And I believe that with the work that we've done right now, sitting in the attorney's hands to look at the legal language to make sure it's consistent, I think we've addressed and strengthened our ordinance to be very in line with the state site law statutes. So it was almost like sitting in front of us. Yeah. I wouldn't go that far. I would say they're a lot easier, a lot easier. Go ahead. Yeah, a couple small questions. So I was looking at the noise ordinance. And you have something in there about tonal and short-duration repetitive sounds. And then you say we add 5 decibels to the observed sound level. So at the property boundary, the general rule is no louder than 80 decibels, right? That's a cap. Right,. Okay, so for short- For short durations, you can't exceed 80 decibels. 85 decibels. Well, it depends if it's tonal or repetitive. Right,. So if it's tonal or repetitive, it's 85. Right. So I think the word observe should say something like allowed, because observe is what you measure. So you would add five to the – anyway, it's just a wording thing. Sure. Otherwise, there's – otherwise, people say – otherwise, it becomes 75. Anyway, so I think, yeah, that would be helpful. The second thing is the item around scenic character and scenic resources. I look through the rest of the ordinance, and we don't actually define in our definitions, Section 3, I think it is, what a scenic resource is. It's talked about somewhere in 900. It says something like, you know, scenic resources, comma, for example, these and these things. It would be helpful if we have a definition of what is a scenic resource. Because the current ordinance says, you know, something like including, you know, something in agricultural fields. So to me, this seems kind of like almost like a circuit breaker. You can say, oh, well, it's a field. It's a scenic resource. You can't build anything there. So it almost seems like we're making things more vague than more precise in a way, but maybe I'm reading it wrong, because this applies to the site as a whole, right? So just something to look at, something if there – if there is something a bit prescriptive about what is, what is or isn't a scenic resource, I think that would be helpful, because especially scenic character, that to me seems like one of these things that everybody thinks they know what it is and has an opinion on what it is. Well, I agree with you. I mean, I think that I did struggle quite a bit on trying to, you know, take their comment and make it something that would be as stringent as DEPs. I think I probably, like I said, I think your comment relative to definitions is good. I think that also probably we should probably talk about odor control as well in definitions in Article 3. So I'll come up with a definition for that. I will talk to our attorney about how we can make scenic character more prescriptive and less subjective based on the language I got here and see if we can tighten that up a little bit. Because if I recall correctly, like many moons ago, I think you said something like that because of the state, we have had to get rid of character-based codes, right? Because they were too, something like that, right? So character-based codes kind of fall into a different thing, and I know scenic character and character-based. So character-based codes typically are codes that are applied sort of in a district standard type. So, in other words, a character-based code would be block standards that were very specific, like you've got 1,600 feet this way, 1,600 feet this way, and this is the characteristic of the block. Got it. So I misinterpreted that. So a scenic character is exactly what you said is, you know, is there a field there and that scenic character, nothing can be built in the field. And you all did, I think, an exceptional job by identifying those two properties in Highland Cliff, the States, and getting them out and keeping that scenic character the way it's supposed to be. So, I mean, this gives it a little bit more teeth. I want to define it a little bit more clearly so that it's not as ambiguous as my proposed language. Yeah, maybe at least the scenic resources, that would be helpful, I think, even if it's only examples.
[2:33:58] Chair of the Planning Board: I mean, if somebody has a farm and they sell it to a builder, then it's kind of like, well, nobody's going to farm it. But so then, you know, we're looking at it, and it's kind of like, okay, it was a farm. Now we're going to put a bunch of houses on it. So what do we use as a standard?
[2:34:17] Planning Board Member: Well, I mean, is that true? I understand that, but I also hope that this body understands conservation subdivision. You know, you can leave farm or agricultural use in the open space, and it would be and could be and maybe should be maintained as a farm one way or another, whether it's just hay in the field or having cattle graze or goats or sheep.
[2:34:46] Chair of the Planning Board: Most people who sell their farms, it's because there's no one in the family who's going to carry it on or they couldn't find someone to buy it and continue it as a farm.
[2:34:56] Planning Board Member: I understand that, but I think there's a segment of farmers in this town that maybe would take an opportunity to use some open space that's in a subdivision and continue to keep it in agricultural use because they might not be able to expand their farm, you know, because just what they said at the last hearing, it costs millions of dollars to have land in this town, so wouldn't it be great to just have an easement to farm on your adjacent subdivision that's keeping a certain amount of land in agricultural use for zero money? I want to make sure we're focused on is there another action that we need to take on this tonight there is no other action other than having a discussion that you want me to look at a little extra detail I got some information from Everett does anybody else have anything I do have one more the groundwater contaminants it talks about fertilizer almost every residential subdivision uses fertilizer some way somehow, so just let's make sure that is not too restrictive, although I wouldn't mind it.
[2:36:19] Chair of the Planning Board: Rick, did you have a question while he's looking at it?
[2:36:21] Planning Board Member: I caution people on some of this prescription stuff, just that it's much like art, right?
[2:36:27] Chair of the Planning Board: It's all on the eye of the beholder. Same thing with odor.
[2:36:31] Planning Board Member: You know what I mean? I think any perceptible odor could be considered. You know, if you've got a nut allergy, I might love this. You know, roasted peanuts may make my day, but if I've got a nut allergy, it ruins my day, right? So, I mean, we have to be pretty careful with some of this prescriptive stuff.
[2:36:45] Chair of the Planning Board: Yeah, because look at the conversation we're having. We can't even agree, and that's just us.
[2:36:59] Planning Board Member: Or at least some guidance. I mean, I think whether the term is definition or if it's guidance, that gives us something.
[2:37:08] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay, are we good? We're good. Okay. Natalie, other business, do you have anything there?
[2:37:16] Planning Board Member: Just for the sake of time, I'd just like to see a quick hand of any of you who have not taken the MMA, Maine Municipal Association Planning Board training. So that is something that very soon we will be required to do once a year.
[2:37:38] Chair of the Planning Board: We're going to do it here, right? We usually do it here.
[2:37:43] Planning Board Member: What she's talking about is the MMA planning module.
[2:37:48] Chair of the Planning Board: The one that's coming up. In fact, it just came out in my email today, I think.
[2:37:51] Planning Board Member: But, I mean, we do an annual FOIA training with our attorney. That wouldn't be the same thing. Yeah, that's what I'm saying is, can we ask you to do that?
[2:38:00] Chair of the Planning Board: Yeah, can we do that also here? I think we don't. We used to do it on school boards.
[2:38:06] Planning Board Member: I'll have to look at how that would work because the training is very specific under 1829. Is that the one where, like, they offered it in Augusta or by Zoom? So they had, like, a Zoom meeting. That's what I sat in on. There's one coming up shortly. Yeah.
[2:38:23] Chair of the Planning Board: This week? I forget when it is.
[2:38:25] Planning Board Member: Yeah, that serves that. I mean, MOCA, the Municipal Office of Community Affairs, which used to be the state planning office, is coming up with a training that's specifically related to 1829.
[2:38:43] Chair of the Planning Board: The problem is, I noticed, though, when we got it, said for new or fairly new board members. So I'm trying to think how it relates to what you just said, that it becomes mandatory. If you've been here for, like, 20 years, you're still going to have it every year. If it sounds like it's like a same thing, you know, I mean if it's for new people. It's kind of like okay. Let me bring you all up to snuff. It can be state law. So
[2:39:07] Planning Board Member: It sounds like if we can just get more information and if it if there is an online offering or what the offering options are We can definitely look into that. Again, state law. So even if it is the same thing every year, nothing we can do about it. True. I move to adjourn. Second.
[2:39:25] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay, a motion is second. All those in the we're adjourning, by the way, in case you didn't hear. Okay, we are adjourned. Thank you.
[2:40:46] Planning Board Member: Yeah, no, it's all And it was sad, they're not going to have any friends, because you're not going to be in the bedroom with them. And that's what happens with my kids and my peers, and I feel very bad. I'm going to probably call a friend. Yeah, and that's what they say, like, meetings, you know, they have a good time in it.
[2:43:47] Town Council Member: Have a good night. You too. Have a good meeting. The
[2:46:42] Town Finance Director: Checks will be cut, after the checks are cut, the town council has to sign off before any checks leave power. Another big part of our job is grants. Departments love grants, unlike me, and they apply for them and get them approved. Once they get to finance, it's important that we read through the documents, make sure we understand what can be purchased, what the reimbursement process is, make sure we get the money back. We have two types of budgets. We have our CIP, our capital equipment budget. This covers a 10-year process. We present 10 years of the department's requests or needs and once that is in print, the manager's office will go through it and choose what's necessary for the operating budget, which is how the tax rate is calculated. The general operating budget starts in December. Departments again do their part. They input the text and the numbers to their budget requests. requests. Those numbers then are reviewed by finance. Finance also handles all the revenues of the town, makes sure we have historical documentation on it, and records that in the budget docs. The manager and assistant manager then meet with the department head, review view the documents and make changes as required to get the budget to what the taxpayers can afford. If you're going to do large projects and you're going to buy vehicles and that kind of thing, you've got to have bond documents. One of the big things we work on takes almost two months is preparing all the data for our financial advisor and this is a lot of financial data, statistical data, and historical data. Put it all together so that he can sell our bonds, get us a good interest rate, keep our bond rating up and then we get to do the projects and pay the bills. And the last thing is the audits. First of all, they're done once a year. And once the books are closed, right now we're using a gentleman who was from an auditing firm. He comes in July. He reviews all our books. He has access to everything we do. He reviews it, creates financial reports. I also do the same thing. We meet, we review, and then he submits his reports to the CPA, Peter Hall, who comes Comments in September, complete the audit. Sends it to council for review, meets with the council, and shares the results.
[2:51:17] Chair of the Planning Board: Hello Windom, welcome to the town council meeting, dated October 13th, 2026. Mr. Clerk, if I could have a roll call, please.
[2:51:28] Town Council Member: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Councilor Cook. Present. Councilor Terry. Here. Councilor Aneto. Present. Here. Councilor Morrison. Here. Councilor Reiner. Councilor Fortier. Here. Councilor Jones. Five councillors present.
[2:51:41] Town Council Chair: Great, thank you very much. If you could all please stand for our Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, minutes to be approved. Approved. CD 26-157 to approve the minutes of the September 22nd, 2026 Town Council meeting. So moved. Second. All in favor?
[2:52:24] Town Council Member: Passes. Thank you, Anthony.
[2:52:28] Town Council Chair: Public participation. Is there anyone here, by chance, who would like to speak on an item that is not on tonight's agenda? Well, we do.
[2:52:38] Gary Plummer (Public Commenter): Do. Good evening, Mr. Chair, honorable members of the Wyndham Town Council, and others at the horseshoe. I am Gary Plummer. I'm here to talk a little bit about Wyndham Neighbors Helping Neighbors this evening. Before I do that, I would like to mention a couple of other issues that I happen to be involved in, and one is the flower planting at the Rotary. I want to thank the Council for the support you've given us over the years. We have added flowers for next year. It appears that the bed flower beds will still be there. Next year will mark the 40th year that the Wyndham Rotary Garden Club has planted flowers. Thank you for your continued support. I also, as some of you know, I'm a bit involved with Babs Covered Bridge. And I thank the council and particularly the manager, Bob Burns, for the support he's given over the years on behalf of the Wyndham Historical Society and myself. Very much appreciate the support that we've received. Covered Bridge is over the river. It should be over the river, and as long as I have anything to say, it'll stay there. Wyndham Neighbors Helping Neighbors, a 501c3 nonprofit, was founded in October of 2007. It is made up of Wyndham volunteers who have come together to provide one-time emergency assistance to those Wyndham residents who require immediate heating fuel. In the spring of 2007, late one afternoon, Bill Diamond, Mac Bryan, and I were sitting in the Criminal Justice Committee room in Augusta. Bill was chair of the committee. I was on the committee. Mac frequently came over to visit, and we frequently met to discuss issues, in common, Wyndham and so on. We talked about calls from constituents regarding needing help with, and then it was, high cost of heating fuel. After several discussions and recruiting a few other people, we formed Wyndham Neighbors Helping Neighbors and started helping people with fuel assistance in October of 2007. Seven, earlier this year, Tom and Deb Matthews notified us that they would be leaving the board. Both held leadership positions in the board. The current board members are Bob Hunt-Murray, Linda Morrill, Judy Vance, Sandra Tyler, Sheila Corey, and myself. I'm quite sure most of you recognize those names. Names. Tom and Deb are here tonight, and I don't have to tell you what go-getters they are and how much we've appreciated the work they've done on the board. And Linda Morrow, you know, is great to have on your team. It's a great board. I've enjoyed very much working with the board. We sat down with Deb and Tom to map out the future of Wyndham Neighbors Helping Neighbors. We felt we could not let this dream of Bill Diamond cease to exist. We talked about several scenarios. We decided we will continue to raise money to help those in need of fuel assistance. The difference is, people will now call the town of Windom, and I believe it's 892-1906, the social services, when they're in need of fuel. We have made a donation to the town to be used for fuel assistance. Assistance, we plan to do this every year. We have met with town officials and hope to continue this relationship for many, years. I wanted to be sure, I'd heard rumors that people said, Wyndham Neighbors Helping Neighbors no longer exists. We're here, we're well, if you want to send a donation, Post Office Box 1956, Wyndham, Maine.
[2:56:49] Town Council Chair: Thank you, Gary Plummer. Appreciate it. No, it's a very good cause. So thank you for coming tonight and educating us all good
[2:57:00] Town Council Member: luck a tank full of oil cost over about nine hundred bucks right now double it I just got a
[2:57:09] Town Council Chair: delivery I did 2858 yeah so anyway anyone here would like to speak on an item that is not on tonight's agenda it doesn't look that like that is the case so we will close public participation counselor comments I'll make one comment last week it was last Wednesday we had a ribbon cutting for the new sewer system that we have now in place and cutting the ribbon was Senator Susan Collins we had the Portland water district was well represented and several others there was four or five folks from The council that were in attendance, including former town manager Barry Tibbetts, so it was a very well attended ribbon-cutting and something that we can all be very proud of. Is this will help us move forward into the future. I'll
[2:58:19] Town Council Member: make one comment on that. Sure, the sewer system is not costing anybody anything on taxes. It's all being paid for by TIF. I think that was a wonderful financial move. Totally 40 49 million dollars. No
[2:58:47] Town Council Chair: thank you for that's a nice little tidbit to add, so thank you for saying that. Anyone else? Okay, let's move on to see if i can keep my act together here. 26-186 to receive public comment and act on a medical marijuana caregiver retail store renewal license application submitted by mac manufacturing llc doing business as maine's alternative caring in accordance with chapter 128 of the code of the town of Wyndham. Open public comment. Seeing none, closed public comment. So moved. Second. Thank you. Pretty straightforward. All in compliance. Yes, everything is in order. Fantastic. Comments from council. Seeing none, put it to a vote. All in favor. It passes. Okay. Unfinished business and general orders. 26-184 to adopt a 180-day extension to the ordinance establishing a moratorium on the development of car washes in the town of Wyndham, extending the existing ordinance expiring from October 22nd, 2026 to April 20th, 2027. So moved. Second. You tonight we have town manager Burns is on vacation and filling in we have Amanda Lassard our assistant town manager. Amanda, do you have some background on this for us
[3:00:31] Town Attorney / Legal Counsel: yes so the council adopted the moratorium on development of car washes on August 19th but it was retroactive to April 28th 2026 which is why it expires on October 22nd as 180-day moratorium. This 180-day extension is the maximum allowed under the state law. We likely will not need that full amount of time. So when an ordinance is adopted by the council it will likely be amendments both to the land use ordinance and the sewer ordinance. We the council be asked to repeal the moratorium ordinance. The council's ordinance committee has begun discussions but we do need more time so that's the need for the extension of the
[3:01:19] Town Council Chair: moratorium. Great, thank you very much. Appreciate the background. Any discussion from council? Seeing none, put it to a vote. It passes. Next item 26 dash 185 to ratify changes to the e code 360 to incorporate land use ordinance amendments adopted by council order 12-052 on April 24th 2012 related to site plan review waivers. So moved. Second. Thank you
[3:01:59] Town Attorney / Legal Counsel: Amanda, you have additional background on this. Yes, so earlier this summer, in doing some research on the town's adoption and amendment of our commercial district design standards, we discovered that there were amendments adopted in 2012, in 2012, that weren't fully incorporated into the land use ordinance at that time. So they have been left out of our site plan review standards for the this entire time. When we went through the process of codifying our land use ordinance into the e code that's online it was also left out where it has been so long and we've gone through this process where the council had to adopt the codification into the e-code. We did consult with our town's attorney who gave the opinion that was in your packet that the ordinance as adopted in 2020 in 2012 had not been further amended or revised and you know I did the research that there were no changes so they are incorporated into the eco that you see online now. They're still in full effect and he recommended though that the council vote to ratify those changes as they're reflected in the e-code. So the planning board has been advised of this and so have applicants when it becomes necessary for their review but everything that you'd see in the code online does reflect our understanding of the ordinance that the council adopted in 2012. Great.
[3:03:29] Town Council Chair: Excellent, pretty powerful any, thank you. Any comments from council?
[3:03:37] Rich Derbis (ALDI Director of Development): So these were adopted once, but just left out of the written ordinance? That's correct.
[3:03:43] Town Council Chair: Okay, thank you. Let's put it to a vote. All in favor? It passes. Next item, 26-187, to approve a new particular license application submitted by Hyde Park Main 2 LLC, doing business as Five Guys. So moved. Second.
[3:04:12] Town Council Member: All compliant, yes, their part as far as this is pretty easy with the town. They just have to apply for victualers as far as state licensing that's more sophisticated up with them but this is their
[3:04:23] Town Council Chair: only part here with Wyndham. Okay, comments from council, seeing none, let's put it to a vote. All in favor, it passes. Next item, 26 dash 1 8, to authorize the disbursement of two thousand four hundred ninety dollars from the substance prevention grant program fund to the Wyndham middle school to help fund student participation in the drones not drugs program that helps students improve their skills and stay involved in something meaningful to them and helps them make better choices as they progress Through school as recommended by the substance prevention grant committee. So moved. Thank you. So I sit on this committee. It was reviewed, it was unanimous in the funding, and so it is now requiring a council vote. Does
[3:05:23] Chair of the Planning Board: this funding come from the marijuana fund? Yes. All
[3:05:29] Town Council Chair: in favor, it passes. Next item 26-190 to award a bid for the purchase of a 2027 International HV 507 SF a 4x2 dump truck with Viking civs gear in the amount of $264,396 from Allegiance Trucks Capital Expenditure, PW-2026-002, which was approved as part of the physical year 27 bond. So moved. Second. I see we have our Director of Public Works here. Oh, there he is. I got on the gun.
[3:06:21] Public Works Director: The guy already on it.
[3:06:22] Town Council Chair: Okay, Mr. Moran, take it away.
[3:06:24] Public Works Director: Way, the floor is yours. Good evening, council. So we went out to bid a few weeks ago for a single axle dump truck with all the gear. Only got two bids back out of the four that we sent out. We didn't receive any others. The one bid as you can see in your packet was for the chassis only, no gear was involved in the bid, the business mistake in the way it was bid. So the Allegiance truck put in two bids, one with Viking gear and one with Allied gear. The cheapest is the 264-396 with the Viking gear of 131-896, I believe. Some history with the International here. So the last two trucks we've purchased, the single axle and wheeler, we've gone with the higher bids of the Western Star for the particular reason that we haven't seen the industry proven the s13 motor through international. The last fall Nate White up in Raymond received the first truck of that kind east of the Mississippi. He plowed with it all winter, had no issues. So it's a good thing with this because they are now the lowest and we feel comfortable we can purchase a truck like that and have any, have no issues. Fantastic, great.
[3:07:50] Town Council Chair: Thank you very much. Any questions for Mr. Moran? Seeing none, let's put to vote. All in favor, it passes. Thank you. Thank you very much, appreciate it. Moving right along to the Assistant Town Manager's report.
[3:08:16] Town Attorney / Legal Counsel: So we just wanted to acknowledge, and we've put some press out there on our website and social media pages around some delays we're experiencing in the Code Enforcement Office due to staffing shortages. We do have two Code Enforcement Officers on leave. So there is a bit of a delay in processing permitting, and we want to acknowledge that we are doing the best we can. There is a process to kind of hire per diems and temporary personnel to fill this gap while our permanent staff are on leave, and we do appreciate the public's patience and understanding as we kind of work through to accommodate all of those permit requests that are pending. On Saturday the 17th at 9 a.m. We'll be celebrating the Wyndham community forest, both in renaming of the East Wyndham conservation area and the Lowell preserve, and ribbon-cutting ceremony for the opening of the universal access trail, and weather permitting, I think I'm leading a little walk on the on the one mile trail up to the overlook at the top of the quarry, so if you can join us that would be great. What time is that? 9 a.m. 9 a.m. Location at it's at the Atherton Hill trailhead, which I believe is 189 Falmouth Road, it's the former East Windham conservation area, and then I was hoping Anthony maybe could give us a little update on absentee ballots being available and early voting kind of extended times. Sure, absolutely, so
[3:09:57] Town Council Member: absentee voting began on October 5th. It's open during our business hours right through October 29th. That'll be the last day, that's a Thursday, and will be open until 7 p.m. that day for absentee voting, and it's available to come in. You can request by mail, you can come vote in person, or you can come in to get ballots to take home for yourself or immediate family. Thank you. Well
[3:10:25] Town Council Chair: Anthony, I hope you feel better than you sound. Thank you for being here tonight. Thank you Amanda for your report. Next, committee reports, appointments committee. Okay, do you have an update? Yes
[3:10:48] Town Council Member: The appointments committee met right before this council meeting tonight and interviewed three individuals. We still have more interviews to conduct for the comprehensive plan steering committee, and we do have some vacancies as well. We have two vacancies on the natural resources advisory committee, one for the parks and rec advisory committee, one for the Planning Board and an alternate seat as well, and then three vacancies for the Wyndham Economic Development Corporation, as well as two vacancies and an alternate for the Zoning Board of Appeals. So we have quite a few vacancies for our various committees. If you are interested, anyone in the public, please go to our website and more information can be found there. Great. Thank you Finance Committee. Last finance meeting was canceled. Our next one is 1015, but that's been changed to November something. I forget the exact date on the November one. It just got changed today, the 10th. Thank you. Okay.
[3:12:00] Town Council Chair: Great, thank you very much.
[3:12:03] Town Council Member: Ordinance Committee. Last meeting we worked on the ordinance for the car wash, as Amanda stated. We will be continuing that, and our next meeting is 10-21.
[3:12:21] Town Council Chair: Parks and Rec Advisory Committee. That's, we're at Winham Economic Development Corp.
[3:12:32] Planning Board Member: We haven't met since our last meeting that we had at Eric's Church.
[3:12:40] Town Council Member: And we'll be meeting soon in the next couple weeks. Great.
[3:12:44] Town Council Chair: Natural Resources Advisory Committee.
[3:12:47] Town Council Member: We have not met since the last town council meeting. Okay.
[3:12:51] Town Council Chair: Greater Portland Council of Governments, we have not met. EcoMaine, that's?
[3:12:58] Town Council Member: EcoMaine is a meeting Thursday night at 4 o'clock that I'll be attending. Great.
[3:13:09] Town Council Chair: That is it for committees. No discussion items tonight, no agendas and scheduling. I will entertain a motion to adjourn. Motion to adjourn. Second. All in favor, it passes. Thank you for joining us, Wyndham, tonight. Have a good evening, stay dry, stay warm. Good evening, Wyndham, and welcome to the town council meeting Tuesday, October 27th, 2026. If we could please have a roll call, Mr. Clerk. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Councilor Cook? Present. Councilor Terry? Here. Councilor Netto?
[3:16:41] Town Council Member: Present. Councilor Morrison? Here. Councilor Reiner? Present. Councilor Fortier? Here. Councilor Jones? Here. Seven councillors present.
[3:16:48] Town Council Chair: If you could all stand for the present. Okay, first item, CD 26-161, to approve the minutes of the October 13th, 2026 Town Council meeting. So moved. Second. All in favor? Passes. Public participation, is there anyone here tonight who would like to speak on a topic that is not on tonight's agenda? If so, please come forward. It does not look that is the case here. So we'll move on. We will close public participation and go right straight to counselor comments. I happen to have a comment. It is bittersweet that we have our fellow town councillor who's here tonight, his last official council meeting, seven years. So I'm sure in some respects it seems like a flash in the pan, in other respects it was probably maybe perhaps a little long, but at times it got long. Yeah, I want to say first, I really enjoyed working with you. I always enjoyed your perspective on things. And that was very important to have the dialogue where we could have a back and forth, and it was always done in respectful way, and you really can't ask for anything more than that. So thank you for that. You represented your district well. So Brett was first elected in 2019. As I said, he's been on council for seven years. You've, he's served on the Natural Resources Advisory Committee. It's best known for his advocating for protecting our farms and open spaces. Also known for being an advocate for our environment and a big proponent of our sewer project, which has taken a tremendous amount of pollution out of our water tables and our aquifer, 25, 20 to 25 tons a year. As fire captain down in Old Orchard Beach, you have been a tremendous resource with our fire department here, making recommendations, tossing things back and forth, best practices. And so I think that your background with that really has helped our town tremendously, especially in all those areas. When I think of Brett Jones, I think of open space. I think of an outdoorsman who is passionate about the outdoors and preserving what we have for our woodlands for the next generation. And also you played a critical role in our East Community Park. Yes, something I'm most proud of, my
[3:20:19] Departing Town Council Member: time here is the ability for us to acquire that land and preserve it forever for future generations, and something I've been really proud of. If that was the only thing I did in seven
[3:20:29] Town Council Chair: years and I'd be happy. So right, yeah, no, it's quite a legacy. And so we have a plaque to present to you now. That's the good news. The bad news is it is still, we have a plaque in transit, so that means, Brett, we're gonna have to call you back one more time. Okay, we like to present you with a plaque and do it right in honor of your service of seven years and your contribution to this town.
[3:21:00] Departing Town Council Member: Thank you. Yeah, thank you. I just want to thank everyone for their support over the years. It's been a lot of work and it's been a lot of fun, but I really, and I really enjoyed my time here, and I look forward to watching you guys on Facebook Live when I'm at home enjoying myself, but always a phone call away. So great, thank you. I
[3:21:30] Town Council Chair: was counting on you to say something. Thanks, Brett. Yeah, that's all you got.
[3:21:43] Town Council Member: That okay. I'm gonna miss you because we've had a lot of long talks, a lot of conversations. We hold a lot of the same issues dear to us. We have a lot in common with public safety, yes, East Windham. I know that was a lot of work on you, and I know you have continued to try and bring in more land into that project. It's been a little bit difficult, but hopefully you'll still be able to guide some people our way with that. But now it's definitely gonna be missing your support, and you're going to be missed. On the council, yeah.
[3:22:13] Town Council Chair: Well, you can be very proud for the service that you gave this town. So thanks again. Anyone else? Just thank you for seven years of service. I know it's not always easy. No, but thank you. I appreciate it. Thank you for your
[3:22:29] Town Council Member: service. You've been a good mentor. So very much appreciated, and I would just echo that as well. So as a new counselor, you were incredibly welcoming and gave some really great advice, and we're going to miss you.
[3:22:44] Departing Town Council Member: Stay safe. Don't be a stranger. No, I'll be here if it's controversial. All right, good. We're counting on that. I'll stand at the podium and say, when I was on the council, this is how it went.
[3:22:56] Town Council Chair: Back in the good old days.
[3:22:58] Town Council Member: We've heard that before.
[3:23:01] Town Council Chair: Okay, moving on to unfinished business and general order 26-191 to approve an agreement with the town of Gorham for the provision of code enforcement services through December 31st, 2026, and authorize the town manager to take the necessary steps to execute the agreement. Open public comment. No, this is not, this is general business. All right, forget that part. You have a second. Okay, Mr. Manager, do you have some background for us on this? Yes.
[3:23:41] Code Enforcement Director: I do. So I know the council's aware, but we are extremely shorthanded in the code enforcement office. Our assistant code officer and our deputy code officer are both out on leave. That leaves two of the three full-time employees jobs unfulfilled. It's followed, the entire burden has, for at least outside inspection, has fallen on our code enforcement director, and it's just not tenable. He cannot keep up with the amount of permits that he has to handle and the inspections that need to be done. So we've taken several steps to try to mitigate the effects of this we brought in a an inspector To actually different inspectors electrical inspectors specifically that 's an a niche Aspect of the job, but that's a help I myself have interviewed a Part-time code enforcement officer, we believe he'll start the beginning of November but still that doesn't get us get our heads above water we're taking a number of complaints from business folks and citizens alike so this is the another effort to try to utilize our neighbors. I've you know already worked through it with the town of Gorham, and basically what this means, I have signed the agreement so that they can perform inspections, but with your ratification tonight this will allow them to actually perform code enforcement duties if so needed. I don't know that will be needed, but if so needed they could do that, and then the details are contained within. I also will be working with the city of Westbrook trying to get the same the same agreement with them. You know my some of my history is with public works, and public works I counted on this agreement, this type of agreement numerous times in my career where I use the city of Portland, Buxton, Standish, Windham, Westbrook, all of those entities helped us when the chips were down and we needed help, and we need some help. Unfortunately it would be potentially easier to hire a full-time employee, a full-time code enforcement officer, but we don't have that in the budget. We have I have some monies we can utilize for part-time, but both of these employees are almost certainly coming back to work with us, and so we can't we can't move on that. So that's what we have for an approach. I think it's a good half step, it's not going to get us still up to speed, but it's a good halfway there measure, and we're just going to keep working for other avenues, and we also have advertised for part-time and or contracted code enforcement duties. Haven't seen anything from that advertisement, but we're hoping that people will network and will there something soon, so we're trying to do everything we can to get basically 80
[3:26:41] Town Council Chair: hours a week back with inspections. Right, great, and so I'm assuming that all this work that's being done by folks that we contract with everything runs up through
[3:26:53] Code Enforcement Director: John Rue, that's correct. Yeah, John will still run his department and will handle all the coordination with his assistance. Yeah, his oversight. Yeah, well, I'm out of a job in a week, but her charter went away the year, so oh well. Yeah, that's too bad, but yeah, we could have used you. All right, thank you. Was anything more? No, I just hope that the council endorses this. Will, like I said, get us part of the way there. It will help. Great questions.
[3:27:25] Town Council Member: Comments from council. I'd like to thank the town manager along with the Gorman town manager setting this up. We're down to only one code officer and our backs against the wall. I asked the public to please have a little patience with us during this issue. We're working on it, trying to take care of it, but the, like the manager says, two people that are out are out with their salaries, and there's no other money in the budgets.
[3:28:04] Town Council Chair: Yeah, I know there's two folks in code assisting, and there's a lot going on there. So thank you to them, and thank you to John Rue for shouldering the burden for these last several weeks. I know it has been making for long days. Anyone
[3:28:27] Town Council Member: else? I guess the only thing I'm gonna ask is the numbers that we're paying. Yeah, comparable to what our
[3:28:34] Code Enforcement Director: salary would normally be? Yeah, if you look at the agreement the numbers are burdened, right? They include overhead, if you will, and so it includes, you know, that's like, how do I describe this? But basically it includes their health care costs. It includes, so it's a burdened rate. So when you take that out, that's about 70% of that number when you take that out.
[3:29:03] Town Council Member: So it isn't just salary that we're paying. That's correct, yeah. This is the total number covering their benefits that they would normally get as a full-time employee. That's correct. Can we keep it out of overtime? We can try. I can't.
[3:29:16] Code Enforcement Director: Honestly, although this agreement showcases it, I had this discussion afterwards. Overtime is actually very, it's not very much different. This agreement makes it read like it's time and a half on top of the burdened rate. They're not going to charge us that. They're only going to charge us the, it's time and a half on the unburdened rate plus the minimal amount of, that's carried on overtime. So, in other words, you cover most of the payroll burden overhead on the first 40 hours of your employee, and then there's a limited amount that hits the overtime. So, in the end, it'll be a very similar cost, very little difference.
[3:29:55] Town Council Member: And do we have a vehicle that they can use?
[3:29:57] Code Enforcement Director: We do, and they've also proposed using theirs, and I'm not certain why they're – I don't know if they're going to demand.
[3:30:04] Town Council Member: Theirs looks like it's $200 a day. That's right. It's $1,000 a week.
[3:30:07] Code Enforcement Director: They do not have to use theirs necessarily, so I'm going to encourage that they use ours.
[3:30:16] Chair of the Planning Board: Any other questions seeing none. Let's put to a vote all those in favor Thank you passes Okay, Tom manager report
[3:30:31] Code Enforcement Director: Very limited. I just like to say thank you to Councillor Jones. Haven't worked with you the full seven years, but we've had some fun meetings, and thank you for helping us get to the name The Wyndham Community Forest. I think that was a huge, that was a, that was a huge move ahead for a plot of land that didn't have a name. So now it's got a name and a purpose, always had the purpose, so yeah, we're excited. But thank you very much, thanks for your steady hand. I can think of a number of different issues that we noodled together, and I appreciate your support. So thank you very much.
[3:31:11] Chair of the Planning Board: Okay, moving on to committee reports. Excuse me, sorry.
[3:31:14] Code Enforcement Director: I've forgotten two things. One, I wanted to talk to the council about, so November and December, we have Council meetings during the week of Thanksgiving. Yeah, the council meeting the week of Christmas. And I'm just pulling the audience here to see if we should think about canceling the meeting just before Christmas or not, if you were, and as long as we're all set would be the one the week of Thanksgiving, just seeing if the council is okay with keeping the schedule or would you like to cancel the any of them. All
[3:31:55] Town Council Chair: right so I'll go first I 'm aware what's on the docket and what's coming up so I think that if we do not have a council meeting on the week of Thanksgiving I don't think that's going to hurt us nor do I think it's going to hurt us on the week of Christmas so I 'm all for conducting business when business is needed when there's an opportunity to spend a little more time with family I think that's also merited anyone else you know I don't know what's coming up in the docket you guys said the docket but if we don't need to have a meeting on those two weeks super yeah we and if something comes up we can always make one meeting a little longer yeah and there's been special means call to have been yep I would agree as well okay I'm having knee surgery so I'm fine with it all right might be cursing ourselves because every time we do this
[3:33:10] Town Council Member: I know yeah cross your fingers I think it's okay to do it but we just have to keep in mind of no we're gonna be flexible yep it's not a no was there
[3:33:26] Code Enforcement Director: something else yes the second thing was amanda lessard had a couple things to share oh thank you
[3:33:33] Town Attorney / Legal Counsel: i just wanted to give you an update on the town's application to the department of environmental protection on our application to review site location of development act permits as you know we made a series of amendments to our land use ordinance in hopes of being granted that authority they have identified a few more amendments that need to be made but they have found that our ordinance is substantially in line so they have granted us delegated site capacity which means that site law app permits that would be applicable in our growth areas the town can review so for projects that are under certain size in our growth areas those applicants will not need to go to the department so I think that's a huge win we've seen most of our growth and growth areas and those are the projects we really want to keep moving so that's where we are right now the ordinance committee kind of reviewed the departments i'm cutting your glory and your ordinance committee update but we reviewed kind of the list of the dep comments and those will go directly to the planning board for those discrete amendments and they'll be back to the council in december so we expect we can hopefully receive that delegated authority for or town-wide by the end of the year, hopefully. So I think that looks good. And then also kind of addressing Parks and Rec Advisory Committee and Natural Resource Advisory Committee. Both of those committees together are charged with implementing our open space plan, and to that end, we have scheduled a community public meeting on November 5th to talk about conservation with the community. community. It addresses a goal in the open space plan to educate and incentivize private property owners to keep their land as undeveloped open space. So we'll talk about the goals of the open space plan and where we've prioritized wanting to keep that land as open space. The presumptive regional land trust will come to talk about what the process is. If people are interested in conserving their land permanently or with a conservation easement or selling their land, and that could include, you know, woodland or farmland, and we can talk about all of the other conservation organizations that may be appropriate. And then the town assessor will be there to talk about the land use programs that people can enroll in, which may also, will not be a permanent protection, does offer kind of reducing a tax burden, which is what happens also with conservation. Easements, so that meeting will be here in council chambers Thursday, November 5th at 6 p.m. to about 7:30 p.m. We will record it, that we will post it on the town's YouTube. We won't be broadcasting it live, I don't believe, but we will, we'll make it available to run on cable television afterwards as well. So we hope people can come, and it will be a resource for people to understand what they can do to take steps to keep their land as open space. Great, thank you. Anything
[3:36:39] Town Council Chair: else? Thanks, Amanda. Great, very good. You know, that's such a, that's such an important topic, and it's all about balancing our growth and balancing our open space, keeping Wyndham. 6 p.m. Okay, first up, appointments committee.
[3:37:05] Town Council Member: We met this evening right before the council meeting. We interviewed some more people for the comprehensive plan steering committee, which we've had a great turnout from the community, and I do just want to thank everybody who has volunteered. We do still have some vacancies in the following committees: the Natural Resources Advisory Committee, Parks and Rec Advisory Committee, the Planning Board, the Wyndham Economic Development Corporation, and the Zoning Board of Appeals. Great, thank you. And those
[3:37:35] Town Council Chair: positions are all posted on our website, correct? Yes, thank you. Finance committee, finance
[3:37:44] Town Council Member: committee last meeting was canceled, and Bob's trying to schedule the other one. It was set for November 10th at five. The ordinance committee, it's
[3:37:59] Code Enforcement Director: I wonder if the two counselors that are on it could answer if they're able to attend. Katie and Bill, can make that on the 10th? I will be in Savannah. Lucky you. That's right, we covered a straight. Are you able to make that, Bill? We could, sure. Okay, we'll change that to four o'clock on great.
[3:38:33] Town Council Member: Ordinance committee. The ordinance committee we met October 21st went over several different ordinances. Amanda expanded on one which is the state just wants us to use their terminology in our ordinances, so we got a rewrite several ordinances to put their terminology in our ordinance, and we looked at c2 zoning for the new connector. I do not remember when the next ordinance committee meeting is. Thank You Amanda when is it 18 Thank You Thank you, Amanda.
[3:39:26] Town Council Chair: Okay, great, thank you very much. Parks and Rec Advisory, Windham Economic Development. We
[3:39:39] Town Finance Director: have not met recently. Okay.
[3:39:51] Code Enforcement Director: That was absent.
[3:39:56] Town Council Chair: Natural Resources Advisory.
[3:40:01] Town Council Member: We have not met. But I would echo what Amanda said about the open house on November 5th at 6 PM.
[3:40:12] Town Council Chair: Greater Portland Council of Governments have not met. EcoMaine.
[3:40:19] Code Enforcement Director: Actually, my alternate was able to stand in for me. That was when I was on vacation. So, Councilor Netto has a detailed report.
[3:40:27] Town Council Member: Yes, I got a detailed report. It was unique to go to that meeting. I don't think people realize how up and down EcoMaine is. The cost of what they're getting for cardboard or what they're getting for glass, it goes up and down. I don't know how they put a budget together with so many dips in trying to forecast what they're doing. But they put a piece together, and there's going to be an increase coming. and they were they were shocked when I told them their increase coming next year is going to add five cents to our mill rate. they were they were shocked they in fact afterwards they asked me how'd you come up with that and I showed them all right there's gonna be a five cent increase you know eco me okay that
[3:41:53] Town Council Chair: That is, on that, is our final committee report.
[3:41:59] Town Council Member: Sorry to give you good news.
[3:42:02] Town Council Chair: Yeah, we're not ending on a high there. Yeah.
[3:42:08] Town Council Member: That's why I come up with that figure so quick when they gave me their figure.
[3:42:14] Town Council Chair: So we're moving on now to discussion items. CD 26-162, G.B. Cogg with the status of Route 302 Quarter Study. Welcome. Welcome. And I'm sorry, your name again, sir? Chris Chopp.
[3:42:30] Code Enforcement Director: Chris Chopp is the transportation director with the GPCOG. We work together in the organization called PAX. And I think I'd turn it to Amanda, she can talk about this particular project. She has been kind of spearheading this for the town of Windom with Chris. Maybe give a quick intro and then Chris is going to take it away.
[3:42:52] Town Attorney / Legal Counsel: I think if I had a sneak peek of Chris's slides, it's the first slide to talk about what the purpose of the study is. And I do serve on one of the PACs. Both Bob and I are on the PACs committees. But I think Chris teed it up to talk about what this plan is and how PACs does transportation planning. I think
[3:43:14] Code Enforcement Director: you have to give him a. As soon as he tells me to move it ahead, I'm ready. Y'all set? Maybe. See if I can make this happen. happen.
[3:43:30] Chris Shop (GB Cog): Mr. Chair and honorable members of the council. My name is Chris Shop. Thanks for having me this evening. And thank you for your service. Counselor Jones. Yeah. And, yeah, here tonight, we were a lot of different hats at GB cog. Transportation is one of those and transportation planning is one of, one of the big things we do and want to give you a little bit of background on this effort. Where we're at now, what data sources we're looking at, what we've heard from the public thus far, and where we're going. And just as a way of background, this corridor study that we're talking about this evening was selected as part of PAX's two-year planning budget. It's called the Unified Planning Work Program, and the request came from the town of Wyndham, and other communities said, yeah, that sounds like a good idea let's look at the entire corridor 20 miles from Raymond to Portland including Windham and Westbrook and take a fresh perspectives on it and so here we are today I got selected through that work and I'll move forward through it thanks Bob just the partners and our key steering committee members the four communities and main department of Transportation Amanda is our Wyndham point of contact on this effort. All right, so why do a corridor study? Certainly we know that transportation's not confined or limited to municipal boundaries. That Route 302, it carries local traffic, but it also carries longer distance regional traffic. So we're trying to think holistically about it, understand where people are coming from, where they're going to, their travel patterns, their pain points in their daily trips what concerns they have we want to understand safety looking back at prior crash data on the corridor but also looking forward based on roadway characteristics where there might be high-risk areas that have bubbled up in the past as issues or could bubble up in the future so we want to anticipate that and we want to Understand gaps in the network, missing connections. Someone's trip is only as good as the weakest link, so we really want to take a look at that and understand how long are the distances folks are traveling, and then ultimately the name of the game is prioritizing investments. Working with Main Duty in particular is really important at this phase because it demonstrates to them that our region has our act together, that we've looked at data, we've heard from the public, and that we've prioritized. Solutions that ultimately go into conceptual design. Go ahead, Bob. Thank you. That's the corridor. The north arrow is tilted slightly, so north is, you know, top left of your screen, but four communities, 20 miles. All right, go ahead, Bob. Here's just kind of the lay of the land and what we're doing. We're building on prior work. I'll mention North Window Moves in a moment, looking at prior plan studies, what's, what's being built out there today or being engineered, designed. We want to understand that, obviously. Before we move forward, and we just wrapped up our first phase of public engagement, so I can share a little bit about that, and then we're getting into solutions, right, recommending different projects to address the concerns we're hearing and what the data is showing, and then getting into prioritizing those projects. We expect to have about eight designs that will come out of this project. All right, just a little bit on 302 today. I'll move pretty quickly through these, mainly just to show you some of. The things we're looking at. These are all prior plans or studies or projects that are in design or construction. Certainly the big one in North Windham is the North Windham Moves project, and on the next slide, we'll just quickly touch on kind of the differences between this corridor study that I'm talking about this evening and what North Windom Moves is. The scope's different, right? North Windom Moves is a capital construction project, a very transformative one at that. The 302 corridor study is a planning study. So earlier in the process, before you get into engineering, design, and certainly way well before construction, in terms of geography, North Windham is Route 302 from White's Bridge Road to River Road, with some connector roads and shared use paths. Our geography and study area is that 20 miles, but we're generally not gonna be touching the area of North Windham Moves. It doesn't make sense for us to come in with new solutions on top of what's already been done in the coordination that's happened between the town and in main duty and bring that fraud project to fruition. How are they related though? I mean, certainly North Windham Moves provides a foundation that we can build upon. You know, I was listening to some of the minutes from your recent public meeting on North Windham Moves, and yeah, there's a lot of interest in the areas just, you know, on the periphery, so that's where I think we can pick up is where that North Windham Moves leaves off. You had to cut North Windham Moves off at some point right so now it makes sense to fill in the gaps knowing what we know and what we expect that project will do good slide shows existing transit service we've got metros route two in orange it's pretty frequent during weekdays every 30 minutes less so on weekends but as you can see it turns around in pride's corner in westbrook so obviously does not come out to windham in windham you've got the lakes region explorer it's a couple trips per day but no service on sundays so transit is one of the things where we're looking at and whether there's demand to support transit in the future. Access focus areas, just where disadvantaged populations live, and darker colors on this map represent higher concentrations of those communities. So it could be seniors, low-income individuals, folks from a different country, limited English proficiency, a lot of different data points here. What's out there for the bicycle network is another thing we're looking at, and pretty much across 302 it's really limited, whether it's Portland or Raymond or anything in between, there's not a lot in terms of paths or bike lanes, and so it's worth knowing and something we'll look at as well. Good, Bob, next one's the pedestrian network, sidewalks. It shows sidewalks on the corridor, and I'll just flag that. I believe this map is still showing proposed sidewalks in Wyndham that were recommended in the active transportation plan. So we'll scale that back to what's existing today. It also shows traffic signals. The only exception, the only dot missing on this map is the one, the new signal at Albion Road. So we're well aware of that. And it's important for us to kind of understand how the signals are working together and in concert with North Wind and Moose. Just a couple more. Just a couple points about vehicle traffic on the corridor. We are going to do a more in-depth kind of congestion hotspot analysis where there's backups, delays, but I have a couple slides just showing kind of how travel has changed on the corridor. It's interesting. In the Pax region, so that's 17 cities and towns, we've seen traffic go up about 10 percent from 2010 to 2024. We look at this corridor, it's not keeping pace with that. It's actually down a couple percentage points when you look at the, that annualized, which is average annual daily traffic or AADT, that's the kind of the red bar on this. It could show that it's declining. We drill in, it depends on the what part of the corridor. When we drill into Windom and North Windom, we're seeing kind of flat to maybe declining slightly in certain areas of Windom, which may not be intuitive, and what we're kind of reflecting what we're hearing from the public in terms of traffic volumes and growth. So we'll take a closer look at that, but that's you know based on main duty traffic counts, traffic counts that we've done as well. I think it's just a comment on that. We had
[3:52:21] Code Enforcement Director: the River Road rebuilt in that time frame there, which changed things tremendously. I'd be curious how the to check that. Right, you said portions of 302, so I'm thinking that maybe north of that intersection maybe we saw a little increase, and but my guess is River Road has become a much-used alternate route. Council 40 has probably witnessed that. Yeah, and you know what will be interesting is we have a bridge replacement coming up on River Road, which will basically render it dead end, and it will Throw that burden back on 302 at that time. It'll be interesting to watch that. Where's that reminding so down it is. It will be. It's south of Windham Center Road. I don't want to call it by the name everybody knows it as. Yeah, that one. Yeah, the Pleasant River Bridge. Yeah, I'll have to get back with you on that one, counselor, but it's coming right up. It'll be, it's, I believe, about a year away. Yeah, all
[3:53:34] Chris Shop (GB Cog): right. Yep. When we look at trip purpose, actually pretty small share our home to work trips on the corridor, about 23 percent. So this is using anonymized cell phone slash vehicle manufacturer data, like GPS systems built in. It's not perfect, but it's kind of the best we have for corridor level trip purpose. Say most people are, you know, home to other trips, or I shouldn't say most, about 45 of the trips are about that, running errands, dropping kids off at school, going to soccer practice, all that, all that stuff. That's the bulk of the, trips on the corridor. Yeah, using that same data, we can look at a number of different ways to understand where people are coming from or going to. This map shows where people are coming from when heading to North Windham in the morning, right, in the peak period morning, 7 to 9 a.m. North Wind, I mean, that hexagon with it x on the, on the map. So shows kind distribution to say, all right, are these local trips? Are they longer distance trips? The darker the colors, the higher concentration or percentage of originating trips. So you can see those dark crimson hexagons right around North Wyndham. Those adjacent ones are like 30% of the total travel. So a lot of local trips. But on the flip side, you go down the corridor or into Portland and you see like you are pulling traffic from Portland and parts of Westbrook, even South Portland, as part of a reverse commute trend. It's not major numbers, but it's, it's more than I would expect looking at the data. And then you're obviously pulling from, you know, areas north and northeast of you as well, Raymond, Gray. That's because there's only one way to get
[3:55:41] Town Council Member: in and one way to get out. And if
[3:55:45] Town Council Chair: you have a seasonal by chance, because that's the traffic in August is gonna be very different than the traffic in November
[3:55:56] Chris Shop (GB Cog): yeah I don't have a slide on seasonality today but I think we can use the same data to slice and dice and after that'd be great to see season yep is our feeling and what we're hearing from the public and what you all know to be true is yeah it's Raymond and Wyndham are probably seeing that bigger jump right in the summer traffic on 302 I don't think Portland sees it as much I mean
[3:56:22] Code Enforcement Director: I'm adding up all these percentages, I would get to 100%, or you better. Yeah, I would think so. Yeah, so just we're not, there's, there's other nodes outside of
[3:56:32] Departing Town Council Member: this map. Yeah, okay, very true. Additional truck comes across from turnpike and goes north from that point
[3:56:48] Town Council Member: Just, you know, that's a good point, because your GPS on your phone used to take you to exit 48 and people would come up through 302 straight. Now if anybody's going up above us, it takes you to the Gray exit and down 35, down 115
[3:57:16] Departing Town Council Member: And well, it they changed it
[3:57:24] Town Council Member: on your GPS, and that's what nailed it when they fix the turnpike to
[3:57:36] Code Enforcement Director: the data on the previous slide, Chris, it was that some type of a cell phone data? Do you know how they, how that the percentages were, how they collected that, how did they determine that
[3:57:46] Chris Shop (GB Cog): I think they what's coded by time of day and then anonymize kind of where a trip where it starts roughly and where it where it stops. Thank you. Yeah, I mean you can drill down and start seeing like if they're like by the trip purpose, like the data source will infer that someone's running an errand. If they're popping into a place for like an hour, they'll code it as a work trip if that person is regularly spending like eight hours there. This is average annual daily traffic on different segments of the corridor. So typical traffic volumes on an average day across the year. You could see darker colors on this map are indicating that the higher volumes and maybe no surprise North Windham is the highest volumes, if not the highest on the entire corridor. You can see a couple pockets in Portland that show up as red, but really that stretch through North Windham is carrying 20, 25, sometimes a little bit more depending on the segment, vehicles per day. And then the black bars indicate total travel lanes, number of travel lanes, so wider segments of road you could see a couple Intersections Portland, Westbrook, and then the North Windham area, and here we're looking at high need safety locations. This is where the most severe crashes have happened, so fatal and serious injury crashes over the last five years. Each community has little pockets. The dots represent intersections, the black bars there segments of roadway, and in Windham that the two areas that are showing up really the North Windham area and kind of the periphery even to River Road on the on the south and then Albion Road. It's possible that Albion Road was safety was addressed through the new traffic signal, so we can look at the before and after if you're
[3:59:53] Town Council Member: that if you're that little building on the corner you're not going to agree with it because if it's an accident after the