← Back to MaineScanner

Windham Planning Board Postpones Highland Cliff Estates Subdivision Review

2026-10-26 · Source: Planning Board (Town of Windham (Granicus/Legistar))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. Welcome to the October 26th meeting of the Town of Wyndham Planning Board, which will be called to order. This is a public proceeding. Please advise the chair if you are unable to see or hear something. Please know that the planning board members will disclose any potential conflicts of interest of which they are aware of at the start of the applicable agenda item. them. The land use ordinance, the comprehensive plan, and planning board rules are available for viewing on the town's website and the town office. The ground rules for public hearing applications are as follows. The applicant will do their presentation. We will then have staff comments. After that, there will be public comments. When you come to the podium, please state your name and address for the record, and all questions must be asked through the chair. After that, we will have board discussion okay so can i have a roll call please natalie yes leo gerrier here melissa young president march davoni here everett cricken present you can put emily down as present emily over here emily this way emily you're present [1:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Absent tonight is Rick Yost, and staff president is town planner Natalie Thompson and planning director Steve Puglio. And we do have quorum, and I'll just update the board that Kathleen Brown has officially resigned. Okay, thank you.
Public Comment
[1:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, before I start, I just wanted to say to the public or anybody that might be sitting out there, We have two openings on the planning board, one for a sitting member and one for an alternate. I know a lot of people have a lot to say about what we do up here, whether they like it or not. And this is your opportunity to be part of the process if you're interested. So next on our agenda is PB 26-077, approval of the minutes of the meeting of September 28, 2026, if I could have a motion. So moved. both. Second. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Are there any comments on the meeting? Seeing none, all those in favor? Okay, it is unanimous. Okay, public hearing and continuing business. After the planning board chair opens the public comment period, members of the public may present evidence or statements relevant to the project under consideration. The planning board reserves the right to limit testimony to a specific Please send written comments by mail or e-mail to planningboard at windhammaine.us. All righty, so first on our agenda is PB 26-075, 26-10, Highland Cliff Estates Subdivision. Major Subdivision Preliminary Plan Review, 180 Highland Cliff Road, Highland Cliff Estates, LLC. The application is for a 27-lot residential subdivision on a 45.98-acre parcel in the farm zone, utilizing the conservation subdivision standards, the 23.93 acres of proposed open space. The existing farmhouse and barn have been separated from the parcel. Phase 1 consists of 12 lots and approximately 2,750 linear feet. Whoa, we did it different. of new road proposed as a public street. Phase 2 consists of 15 lots on the Phase 1 road, held as part of Lot 12, is 12.33 acres, and reserved for future development. Subject property is identified as Tax Map 3, Lot 49A, Zone Farm, in the Presumpskit River Watershed. And here for the applicant is... [3:59] Speaker C (unidentified): Dustin Roma with DM Roma Consulting Engineers. years here tonight on behalf of Highland Cliff Estates LLC. Can you pull that closer? Yeah. Yeah. So thank you for having us here tonight to present the preliminary plan for the Highland Cliff Estates subdivision. You may recall, and as you kind of read into the introduction there, this project proposed as a 27-lot subdivision intended to potentially be approved and built out in two phases. At this preliminary plan stage we thought it was it was best to move forward with a complete picture of what we intend to build on this site as opposed to coming in with a smaller first phase and then adding on to it later on. So as it's presented in the plan set all of the road and plan and profile sheets and stormwater management design and all the components for the details are for the project as a whole any phasing for the project will be much more detailed in the final plan when we submit that so it'll be very clear as far as the what will be built out as that first phase and what would be a complete or i guess the second phase would be subject to coming back to planning board for additional approvals so the length of the road is about 2,800 feet we've got two hammerhead turnarounds along the way as well as a cul-de-sac turnaround at the end we've taken into account the wetland areas on the site as we've laid out these lots we've got a stream and some wetland areas to the rear of the site which i think we at least saw the limits of those wetland areas when we conducted the site walk so nothing has changed on this layout for the road alignment that we looked at in the field when we did do that site walk we had made some changes from the sketch plan that we've discussed previously which was to move a couple of those lots that we had previously proposed out in the field and move those internal to the site Going through, you know, over the last couple of weeks, we've started to receive the review comments for stormwater, hydrogeologic, as well as staff review for engineering and planning associated comments. So we have compiled responses to all those comments in kind of a single document. And once we work through our meeting here tonight, we're just prepared to resubmit all of that information to planning so that they can have kind of one complete revised set, which addresses all of those different levels of comments that we received to date. I did want to just run through a few of those here tonight just to give some additional information. As far as completeness information goes, we did receive a letter from the Maine Historic Preservation Commission that they've conducted their review of the site and found no historic properties that would be affected by the proposed development. Another thing that was discussed previously is we had done some consultation with the Maine Natural Areas Program under the MDI-FNW department. And in that review, there was mention of a small world begonias study that wasn't part of their original consultation specifically. specifically so we did hire the state botanist to conduct a site investigation on the property they have provided us with a letter indicating that there were no documented occurrences of that species and they felt that the it was likely not suitable habitat for that species to exist so we have that letter as well and we've shared that with planning but we'll include that in our response packet that comes back in we working through the stormwater comments were very basic so I won't go into those tonight in detail it was basically taking information that we've already have and putting it in different places on the plans so nothing really to go over from a technical aspect there the town engineer had reviewed the plans there were a couple of discrepancies between some tables on the detail sheets for elevations associated with structures in the ponds so we've rectified those just a couple of attempts of elevation here and there so we've gone through and reviewed the plans and cleaned up those items we do have one waiver request tonight on the placement of street trees within that first section that runs through the field. So the justification for that waiver request is really just around aesthetics. In this situation where we have an existing open field, we felt it would likely look pretty unnatural to just have double rows of trees that just run through an existing field area that maintains fields on both sides. Certainly the street tree requirement in and around all the residential dwellings and the lots certainly makes sense but in this case trying to you know where one of the main objectives of the you know this conservation layout is to preserve areas that are field areas with that aesthetic we just felt it was appropriate to not be planting trees down through that field area and we did there was a comment from the town engineer, that he felt that was appropriate to not be planting trees in that field area, and he was supportive of that. We did receive some public comment, which I expect we'll hear more of tonight, in regards to the hydrogeologic assessment and just some questions there. So, I mean, this is certainly something that's a little bit new as far as the town's review and our analysis for subdivisions looking at the groundwater components and drainage for wells. So, we've worked with planning staff. We've gone through and spent quite a bit of time reading those ordinances, worked closely with our geologist that prepared those studies. And,, you know, I think to the extent there are questions tonight, we'll do our best to kind of answer those. But in summary, I think from a water quantity standpoint, the test pits that we've dug all through here, I mean, when you dig into the ground three feet, you encounter groundwater. It's abundant through here. There's nothing especially unique about this property in regards to bedrock aquifers or anything that's different than the surrounding areas. Certainly other subdivisions in this part of town have been built, and wells have been installed, and it seems to be a good track record of success as far as being able to support that level of development. and we did have our geologists take a look at this specific lot and all that underlying information and, you know, all that information was contained in their recommendations. So I think to the extent that there are specific questions, again, we'll do our best to answer them here tonight, but we did feel that our analysis was complete and we're not anticipating any issues for groundwater quantity for the project. In regards to groundwater quality, there are some standards in the ordinance which deal with, you know, ensuring that there's adequate water of suitable quality for these homes. homes, and trying to analyze well quality over a site that's 50 acres, there's going to be likely some variations from lot to lot. That's been my experience with other developments is that as individual wells are installed on lots within a subdivision, you'll have some lots that require water treatment systems to be installed in order to meet the safe drinking water standards that the state requires for new home construction. And then other lots won't need them. So it's kind of hit or miss as you go throughout these developments. However, there are those requirements in place that any new home that's built on these lots will be required to have a water test done as part of the construction permit. Any concentrations of pollutants that are above or near that state minimum standards would have to be mitigated with a water treatment system and that's you know those are very readily available there's companies that provide those regularly it's not a specific hardship for this particular development so we're not anticipating any issues there i think yeah with this being a public hearing tonight maybe it's most appropriate TO HEAR ANY COMMENTS AT THE BOARD OR PUBLIC MAY HAVE AT THIS TIME AND AS I SAID WE'LL ANSWER THEM AS BEST WE CAN. THANKS, JUSTIN. NATALIE. [14:17] Speaker B (unidentified): OKAY. SO JUSTIN WENT THROUGH MOST OF THIS. I DO HAVE A COMMENT ON THE PUBLIC HEARING. hearing so typically with the preliminary we will have a public hearing as the ordinance states unfortunately notices went out incorrectly they were mailed but we didn't word it as there would be an opportunity for public comment tonight and we've spoken to some residents so they know that they will have an opportunity to speak tonight but we can't count this as our public hearing because it was not properly noticed we've spoken with the applicant and they're okay coming back at our next meeting for public hearing that we will publicly notice properly and that's where you'll also get to see some of those additional materials that have come in today or weren't in your packets materials and i kind of just wrote down on this slide that you can take public comment tonight but it will just be public comment not a public hearing written comments that were received are in your packets but all those will be in your packet again next week next sorry next meeting not next week and then we'll make sure that the public hearing notices are put out properly this time open space oh so i kind of made a note on this just because this is the first project we've had come through where the open space is using the new criteria for the conservation subdivision so as you probably recall the sketch plan they were well the project was asking for a waiver I think on open space but with the new calculations they were able to come in with the appropriate with the amount that the ordinance asked for and I kind of just documented down how some of that works with the you know right away and whatnot that wasn't calculated in the previous calculations this is just saying like they're proposing it in two phases and the only waiver is the street trees and this is on the groundwater which i believe most of the comments we'll probably hear tonight are focused based on what's coming so far on the hydrology so this is our first project where we've had the hydrological study come back and i think we'll want to talk as a board kind of how we want to interpret the responses that are coming from the applicant in response to the responses from hayley ward who were was our third party review this time around and I think that is all I have for this one for right now okay [17:13] Speaker D (unidentified): I want [17:22] Speaker A (unidentified): there is a [17:24] Speaker E (unidentified): correction I think I think the correction I think based on the fact that we did not get the advertisement the way we're supposed to do it because of staff issues and other things i think it would be helpful the board had a little deliberation about that and came up with a motion to accept public comments now and to go through that process and then we could take any kind of questions that you have regarding that and then postpone the public hearing until the november 9th meeting if i think that should be done up front and then we can then go on with the business. Sure. I [18:09] Speaker F (unidentified): move to open up the meeting for public comment tonight. Public hearing. Second. [18:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, conversation. Does anybody have an issue with basically having public comment tonight and then having a public hearing at our next meeting? It seems the logical thing to consider, considering a multitude of people have come out to make public comment, and I don't think it would be right to not hear what they have to say. Agreed. So, all those in agreement? Okay, so we will have public comment. Before I open that, though, I wanted to make, when I read this, originally it said it was public, but I think it's been changed [18:59] Speaker B (unidentified): to private that was another thing sorry i forgot i misread something and i put down private it's going to stay private and they're going to build it to public standard with hopes that the town [19:12] Speaker A (unidentified): council will adopt it as a public road okay so they're not going to keep it as not keeping it [19:16] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah that actually i did write a note on that and here are my apologies that i was going to [19:22] Speaker A (unidentified): fix it in the okay i just want to make i just want to make sure there is a big difference between a private road that you billed to public standards that's going to be given, hopefully, to the town council to approve versus a private road that stays a private road. I just wanted to get that straightened out before we went any further. Okay. [19:44] Speaker G (unidentified): So,... Excuse me, Chair. [19:47] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you want your completeness memo or public hearing first? [19:54] Speaker E (unidentified): Did you – I'll put in the condition regarding the planning board taking comments and holding reserve, you know, so basically the position that we can take public comment, but the planning board reserves more information if they feel that's necessary. I think we need to have that motion, notwithstanding the fact that this is an official public hearing, but we still need to go through the condition that the planning board may hold reservation for more information, that it's not complete, but the planning board will listen and will ask for more information or even have a completeness determination. determination. If it's not complete, I mean, it's really because of... You mean when we get to that part? When we get to that part? Certainly. Which we're not there yet. Before we actually take public comment, if we're going into public comment right now, at this point, we kind of need to do the [20:59] Speaker A (unidentified): completion motion. Well, do the... Bring the... Okay. [21:03] Speaker F (unidentified): Completeness first. I move the major subdivision application for Project 26-10, Highland Cliff Estates Subdivision, is found complete in regard to the submission requirements based on the application checklist, but the Planning Board retains the right to request more information where review criteria are not fully addressed. [21:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Could I have a second? Second. Okay. Any comments, questions? Seeing none, all those in favor? Okay. It is approved. Before we get into public comment, I would like to let everybody know that there is a three-minute limit. There are a lot of people here. I am not going to tell you what you can and cannot say, but I would like to request that if someone has gotten up prior to you and you just want to get up and say, I agree with everything that they've just stated, blah,, blah, without actually repeating exactly what has been said prior to, it would be appreciated. I'm not saying you have to do that. I'm just saying I want to make sure that everybody here has a chance to say what they want to say. So saying that, we will open it to public comment. If you come to the podium and state your name and address, who wants to be first? [22:33] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you, Board. My name is Ben Whalen. I live at [address], the property that abuts this development proposal. My family and partners, we operate Bumroot Organic Farm, a certified organic farm that abuts this project along our northern boundary. Our farmland is permanently protected through a Maine Farmland Trust conservation easement. I had four concerns. Dustin addressed one, the small world begonia, and more or less I have some issues about this process and kind of where we are at this point. My main concern is around water and the wells and the hydrological study that has come out. I'm not a hydrologist. I'm not a professional at reading these sort of reports. reports, but from what I can tell from the report that was presented, it's GIS data about area wells and all the recommendations have to do with residential usage. We are a commercial farm that is irrigating during drought seasons, like 20 hours a day. We're washing vegetables, we're filling flower buckets, and everything about the report with wells has to do with average residential usage. there's nothing in there about being right next to a commercial farm additionally the last line in the in the report mentions only addresses likely adequate for up gradient wells it has nothing to do with down gradient or cross gradient we are pretty much parallel with where this division subdivision would be and it's all bedrock it's all rock and as Dustin mentioned you can dig a hole anywhere on our farm and find water we have two historical hand dug wells that have water sometimes and sometimes they don't. But what we're talking about is drilling for wells and it's, I don't know enough about it. It feels pretty mysterious, but I am concerned about my livelihood, the impact of 27 homes, this conservation subdivision, it, condenses things. It makes things tighter. It's 27 homes right on top of each other, right next to our working farm. And that's a major concern that I have. additionally, you know, storm, I've got 43 seconds stormwater runoff, at steady point three, it's a 16% increase during common storms. That doesn't mention 10 year storms, which are now happening every year. And that, stormwater it's, it's not getting diluted. This isn't a subdivision that's sitting somewhere in the woods. It's flowing right into the Lincoln weeks. Brooke, that is a tributary of the inkhorn Brooke. The way that flows is a direct connection where nitrates, phosphorus are all running through there. Through our farm, admittedly, that portion of our farm we're not super active on. I'm not worried about the land. I'm worried about the waterways. This is a farm zone. The board should be weighing the real impacts this proposal has on working commercial farms right next door. The conservation sub-design protects the resources in exchange for smaller lots and developers, lots of developers against. against the planning board is the steward of that bargain. I'm just asking that you hold this project to the town standards and really think about this as a project in the farm zone. Thank you. [25:58] Speaker D (unidentified): Next. Jeff Hadabaugh, Seafox Farm on Albion Road. And I've got 257, so I got to be quick. Now, I'm one of a handful of commercial working farms where that's how we feed our families in town. When we take agricultural land and we start making it available to developers, there is no way farmers can compete. This guy right here, he can make millions. If I pay that price for land, I'll go under. Ben will go under. When we develop ag zones into houses, we may as well just change the zoning. And then we can call this open space. it is it is open space but from an agricultural perspective a bunch of yards is very different from pasture now all the deer that live there when they build this they're going to end up in our fruit orchards now we're taking deer out of season with special permissions where do the predators go they follow the deer now my livestock i need guardian dogs when we and you know it says open space and i know the development board loves to talk about preserving the rural characteristics of this town but ain't nobody going to look at that and say oh what a beautiful field it's it's a house farm and if we're gonna let house farms be counted as farms then it's more nails in our coffin because we can't compete price-wise on land with these guys and when best highest use of our land becomes housing development then well what do we get taxed on best highest use so now my best highest use is not my sheep it's not my apple orchard it's i mean what are these 500 000 each i don't know but there's no way no matter how good we are at farming we have any chance of competing at those prices thank you for your time thank you come [28:01] Speaker I (unidentified): on hi i'm liz weiskop i live at [address] directly across from this property I'm going to talk fast. If I don't get it done, I'm going to ask somebody in the audience that doesn't plan to speak to come up and read the rest of it for me so I don't lose what I want to say. First of all, thank you for hearing from us. This is the first time we've had a public chance to speak. My main concern is the effect of the 20 new seven houses on the neighboring wells. I don't doubt that the new homes can get a water supply. I'm concerned about some of the drought. And with the chair's permission, I wanted to ask the hydrologist some questions. He's not here, so I'll tell you the questions I'm going to ask, and maybe they can come back with them for me at another time. The 92 well outputs in the report were probably based on the time that they were drilled. I would assume that. Is that correct? Okay. And my house is 30 years old. Nate's house is 20. All the others are a lot older than mine, or most of them are. So that may make a difference now on how the water is. And does this report take into account the things that have happened since these wells have been drilled? Do they have the information, which includes the number of these wells that went dry, ran low, or had to be replaced by new wells? That would be information I think would be important. important. When was the data for the estimated annual influx to the recharge area done? Is that a new study or an old study? I'd like to know an answer to that because an annual influx doesn't adequately show what a summer drought period might be any more than we would need any air conditioning in our houses in the summertime here if we base things on our average annual daily high temperature of Portland is 56. So you mentioned, and they mentioned in the thing, that they were going to regularly monitor well yields and groundwater levels in both the project and neighboring wells. Has a specific plan been submitted to the planning board for this? And in my opinion, it's too late once a project is built to find out if any harm has been done. It's like closing the barn door after the horse is gone. And if they say there's plenty of water in the recharge area, Why are wells in our area going dry? Why are they being real drilled? Why are they going low? And was there any data in your report that shows the usage of the water at the bumble root farm? Your report said that it will unlikely cause an impact on neighborhood wells I want to read what our ordinance requires any water table down draws beyond the subdivision boundaries due to groundwater withdrawals by the proposed subdivision shall not adversely impact groundwater supply availability to existing wells and cause structural damage. The ordinance doesn't use the word unlikely. It says shall not. It is the developer's responsibility to do whatever is necessary to ensure that it will not have an adverse impact on existing wells. This has not been done. It would give greater assurance and more proof to have three test wells done and have a simultaneously pumping for 72 hours straight. This will simulate a drought condition. Neighboring wells should be measured before and after the pumping, and if the wells are lowered, it should be measured to see how long it takes to recharge. I am requesting the planning board to require this. I know this will be an expense to the developer, But they will be making a profit on this subdivision, as they should. If this is not done and wells are affected, the burden and cost to remedy this will fall solely on the homeowners. The ordinance was written to protect our neighboring wells. I think both the developers and the neighbors would be happy and overwhelmed to learn of a positive report if this was done. And one thing more regarding Bamba Root Farm. There should be no financial burden or extra work required by the owners of Bumble Root Farm to accommodate any impacts of this subdivision into their farmlands. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Liz. Next. [32:27] Speaker G (unidentified): Hi, I'm Don Seip. We live across the road from the development of 185 Highland Cliff. I just want to point out a few things that are consonant with the concerns about the water and the tests that was done. Really, there was no hydrology test done here. It was basically armchair hydrology. You can look most of the information up on Google, and Google searches are good, and I looked up some of it. But they really aren't a test of anything. The years used to get the average rainfall were 91 to 20. So there's six years missing, which have been mostly drought from the water that they measured over that period. That's a significant amount of changed circumstance, I think, that would require retesting. Some of that information may be available. It's not public yet, but it should be looked at. As opposed to the idea of drilling some test wells, obviously, if they're going to develop anything at all, they're going to have to drill some wells. So I don't see that as being any added expense if there is anything that's ever developed on this site There should be test wells drilled and they should be tested and they should be tested at a maximum flow of 6.8 gallons per minute according to their own hydrology report, which is what the maximum that the units will use when they're when they're running so If that's a fair test of the hydrology report then it should be done. It's from their own numbers I do have a concern that there is not, well, there's an assumption that the aquifer is not locally differentiated in any way. So you've got 92 houses spread over a mile, and we're going to have, what, 30 spread over an eighth of a mile. I think the local impact of that is more significant than what the study assumes with the spread out area. I just think there's probably local effects that need to be taken into account. So that would be my recommendation is drill the wells, run them at that level, test all the adjacent wells, and also get some data on how much Bumble Root actually uses and how to test it fairly when we're in a drought and they're using as opposed to the local wells we've got. Next. [34:58] Speaker J (unidentified): Good evening. My name is Andrea Elder Bruns. I reside at [address]. I would like to mention I was the real estate agent who represented the seller when they purchased the property where this subdivision is proposed. And I mention that simply because it's important to me to state in this public forum that this is by no means a personal attack on the applicant. In fact, Garrett was a great person to work with through the context of that transaction. It's also not a wholesale objection to growth, which is inevitable. nor an objection to home builders making an honest wage by building homes. Clearly, there's great concern around this. I'm not going to say everything I had in mind to say about water because I think you're hearing that refrain. The ordinance is very clear as to shall not versus we're going to put our hope in something that's unlikely to happen. We need to follow the ordinance. We're asking you to require that. THAT. AND DATA CAPTURED BEFOREHAND IS VERY IMPORTANT. IT'S LIKE SAYING I'M GOING TO TRY TO PROVE I TOOK NOTHING FROM THE COOKIE JAR, BUT WE DIDN'T KNOW HOW MANY COOKIES WERE IN IT TO BEGIN WITH. SO WE NEED THAT PRELIMINARY DATA. ADDITIONALLY, THE PROXIMITY TO BUMBLE ROOT FARM IS OF CRITICAL IMPORTANCE HERE. THEY NEED, NEEDLESS TO SAY, A SUBSTANTIAL UNINTERRUPTED SUPPLY OF WATER TO PROVIDE FOOD FOR OUR COMMUNITY. AND THIS BRINGS ME TO MY NEXT concern, which is around zoning. Zoning reflects the town's intentions around land use and development. Wyndham has, I believe, 10 primary zoning districts, all of which reflect the character and vision for that part of town. We're here talking about the future of the farm zone, the farm zone of all the zones. Of all of them, this is one where the interests of those farming should take priority it should go without saying in my opinion and yet here we are contemplating 27 wells and 27 septic systems right adjacent to this farming operation right on the heels of a front page article in the Wyndham Eagle talking about the capacity of the new system in North Wyndham to save us from the many pollutants being dumped into the aquifer and watershed by septic systems. And the streams that are in question here, as Mr. Whalen mentioned, the Incorn and Lincoln Weeks Brooks, are already listed as impaired by the state. So this, to me, doesn't make sense. Finally, neighbors shouldn't have to come asking for ordinances to be followed. We should come with the full faith that 's what's going to happen. We don't get a second chance. We don't get a mulligan, so to speak. If we later learn that greater wisdom should have prevailed, we get one chance. And I'm asking that you take this deeply into consideration as you make your decisions tonight. You're here. Next. [38:21] Speaker K (unidentified): Sharon Taylor. I live at [address], which is right on the corner of Highland Cliff. one thing that hasn't been mentioned in you know interest of bumble root farm these developments tend to use massive amounts of pesticides fertilizers because they love their nice green lawns that is going to deeply affect our wells I have a very shallow well. It's 30 feet deep. Ben and Jeff have their livelihoods. They're organic. What is going to happen when all of these fertilizers and pesticides are being dumped into the water supply? We've already had issues where we've all been tested for PFAS. Fortunately, we're clear. what are pesticides going to do it's going to destroy their farms traffic study has not been addressed that's already a problem it has not been addressed this evening and i'm under the understanding that traffic studies were waived for what reason you [39:50] Speaker A (unidentified): can answer that one natalie excuse me no traffic studies were waived they haven't been addressed [39:55] Speaker B (unidentified): There were traffic studies in the report, in the preliminary packet that was submitted for tonight's meeting. [40:01] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay. I have not received one. It's online. It's online? [40:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Okay. I will check into that. Keep going. Keep going. Can I [40:22] Speaker L (unidentified): get up here without falling down? [40:23] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm sure you can. [40:28] Speaker L (unidentified): I'm John Kruger, and I'm from the Highland, excuse me, the Highland Cliff. the Canada Hill end of Island Cliff Road is I just got a few comments and people have covered this very thoroughly. I don't have that sort of coverage but my concern is a lack of public water and public sewer and this is the second year of a drought and we've been hearing reports of dry wells in Maine for the last couple years. And I have a neighbor, immediate neighbor, and I'm bringing her drinking water because her well is not doing well. And she's hoping to have a new one drilled, but she hasn't had drinking water for months. I have another close neighbor who I think a year or two ago had a well drilled, and he had to go down 700 feet. And again, with Bumble Root, there's market farm right next door and that has a very can have a very serious impact with a lower water table or particularly also the potential contamination from leach fields. It could be deadly. And just finally, my mother came from Kansas and where a lower water table out there meant that those windmill water pumps just would not pump because there wasn't any water there. And much of the Great Plains, which is our agricultural bedbasket, the water there was from an Ice Age aquifer. And most of that has been depleted. There's a place in western Nebraska where there is still some, but it's a problem. So, you know, drought with reduced rainfall means a lower aquifer, and a lower aquifer is deadly for people with wells. [42:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Just walk around it or something. Anyone else? [42:49] Speaker M (unidentified): Hello. Cade Williams, 18 Mason's Way. I'm here really in support of Bumble Root. I think it's a, you know, just a prized possession for all Wyndham residents. I'll have more to say next week after I review a lot of materials online. But I work in risk management. That's my day job. I think based off of kind of what I heard earlier, it sounds like you feel like a lot of boxes have been checked with this development already. But you are obviously holding for further review. view we faced some similar situations in my day job where like a development would come in next to a golf course that we owned and they we would force them to indemnify us against any eric golf balls because they wanted to put the houses right up against the golf course you have the opportunity to do that here you have livelihoods on the line you have and you know it's an llc So, you know, they're hiding behind limited liability. But you think about it, in reality, you want to put their money where their mouth is. And one way to do that is by forcing them to actually guarantee indemnification for the neighboring landowners. If wells become a problem, if chemicals become a problem, and the developer will try to walk away from it. But then it's on the, if there's an HOA, whether it's formed or not, it's going to be on those that live within that community. Who wants to buy in a community that has that kind of exposure? maybe they check all your boxes, but there's still a lot of questions out there. And I think there's ways to force them to really reconsider whether they want to develop right next to such an important possession. Anyone else? [44:43] Speaker N (unidentified): Hi, I'm Debbie Kelly. I live up in Mineral Spring, 17 Wintergreen Circle. So I don't live anywhere near the farm, but we've been going every week during growing season for years, first to the market and then as members of the CSA. And it's one of my favorite places in Wyndham, and I know it means a lot to hundreds of people in the community who do the same thing we do. I'm glad someone mentioned pesticides because that was on my list. I think the water issues have been very well covered by a lot of very well-informed people, but the pesticides from this neighborhood could be a real disaster for an organic farm that means so much to us. So I'd really appreciate your consideration for all of these things that have been brought up. [45:36] Speaker J (unidentified): Hi, I'm Gwen Schroeder. [45:38] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm at 238 Highland Cliff Road, and really I can't say anything more than they've already mentioned. I'm in complete agreement with the statements of Liz Weiskopf and Ben Whalen, [45:49] Speaker O (unidentified): and I'm really in support here for Bumble Root. [45:52] Speaker C (unidentified): And I also have a written statement, if I can hand that to someone. [45:56] Speaker A (unidentified): That's right here. Okay. Is there anyone else? See, I know if I wait long enough, somebody will come. Yeah. [46:13] Speaker P (unidentified): my name is kimberly snow i live at [address] and i'm on the opposite side of the bumble root farm i agree with everything everyone has said i'm very concerned about the water table we have installed a roa system because there is salt in our water and i'm very concerned with the impact of 27 wells, it blows my mind. The farmland is a huge issue. This is farmland. This is why we bought our home and this property 20 years ago. Never imagined 27 homes would be built on this property next to Bumble Root Farm. It just blows my mind. And I'm concerned with the pesticides and everything else everyone has discussed tonight. So I'm in total support of what these folks have already spoken. And I hope this is not put through. [47:29] Speaker Q (unidentified): Anyone else? My name is Jean Chiron. I live at [address]. Obviously, I agree with all the water. We all want water. I heard a geologic study, but was there an environmental study done on the top of the land, like the brooks and the wet spots, and was that completed? [48:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Natalie, you can answer. [48:07] Speaker B (unidentified): so as part of our ordinance requirements they are required to map out all the wetlands and the brooks and everything and there is a certain setback from each of those that they are required to adhere to as well as the natural area resource program at the state so that is the one that identified the begonias that were then surveyed on site to found not to be there and all those have come back so all the ordinance requirements along the like natural resources on the site have been submitted to the submitted to the planning board and are in the [48:48] Speaker Q (unidentified): packet my other concern is i the animals that live out there 's lots of deer that live out there and porcupines and raccoons where are they gonna go there's no place to go there's no place left on that land for them to be. And that's what I had to say. [49:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else like to speak? Going once? Twice? Okay, I am closing public comment. If anybody else has anything they would like to say or want us to know, please feel free. You can still send, even if you already sent one, you can send another email if you've thought of additional things you'd like us to know here. here. And, of course, you'll be notified about the next meeting that we have a public hearing. Go ahead, Natalie. Which will be November 9th at 6 p.m. So if you want to jot that down, hopefully, and hopefully that does not move. So, okay, can we go back, Natalie, to, so before we go to the waiver requests, I'd like to give Mr. Romer a chance, if he wants to now, any of the things that he heard tonight that he can answer now. I know there's a lot of stuff that you can't answer tonight and will probably be answered the next time. But if there's anything that you can answer now, I'll give you that opportunity now. [50:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I guess what I'd like to make sure we iterate to everybody that's here tonight and people that are listening at home and have concerns about this project that, you know, we have every intention of being, you know, the best neighbors that we can be for this project. I know, you know, there's some people that are upset about the development. One of the things that's difficult for us to do is when the overall consensus of the group is just that they don't like the development as a whole. There's not a lot for us to do with that information. if there's specific things the letter that i think i sent in today from bumble root farm had a few things that were specific that we can look to implement that stuff that we can work on there was some mention tonight about you know testing wells and some things like that those are some things that again we can address but just the kind of the blanket comments as a whole that you know we don't get to use the groundwater and we don't like the size of the development it's it's a difficult situation so I guess I'll just ask people if there's specific things you'd like us to address that information can be passed on to Natalie and we'll do our best to address those as we move forward into our final plans yeah [52:11] Speaker A (unidentified): okay natalie you want to bring them up again please the wave is now can you natalie for the benefit of the public can you explain the first one yes so the applicant had requested a [52:41] Speaker B (unidentified): high intensity soil survey a waiver on the high intensity soil survey and the planner and director did approve that but based on the fact that most of the information was already in the packet so they felt that the additional survey was it would have been redundant to make them go through that survey when all the information that would have been captured was basically already there. [53:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you have any more to add to that Steve? In support of [53:13] Speaker E (unidentified): they needed to provide a hydrological analysis assessment which that's what they had to work on so typically when you have either or it doesn't make sense to have both of them so the waiver for the high intensity soil survey with the fact that we got a hydrological assessment that's the reason why for that we're postponing [53:44] Speaker F (unidentified): the meeting we're postponing the review so we postponed the waiver as well we can we can i if i can i'd like to ask a question because I'll make a motion to postpone the approval of the waiver for Section 129.11.E.1.B. until the November 9th meeting. [54:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Can I have a second? Second. All those in favor? Okay. That is approved. I'm sorry. Go ahead. [54:17] Speaker F (unidentified): No, I don't know if all members of the public who are here tonight are also going to be at the November 9th or 23rd meeting, BUT MAYBE A BIT OF AN UNUSUAL REQUEST, BUT I WOULDN'T KNOW HOW TO VOTE ON THE STREET TREE WAIVER BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW WHAT LOOKS BETTER. SO I'D LIKE TO TAKE A STRAW POLL AND SEE WHICH MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO SEE STREET TREES GOING UP TO THE DEVELOPMENT VERSUS THOSE WHO [54:43] Speaker I (unidentified): DON'T. I CAN'T HEAR YOU. CAN YOU SPEAK UP JUST A LITTLE BIT? [54:47] Speaker F (unidentified): MAYBE I NEED TO SPEAK UP A LITTLE BIT MORE? IS THIS HELPFUL? OKAY. i'd like to take a straw poll if that is allowed are we allowed to do that you can okay [54:58] Speaker A (unidentified): great so by so basically except you have to remember you have i do want to remind you that it's a board decision i understand i understand this is just gathering so rather than taking a poll people know that waiver is coming so if they are going to send something to us prior to the next public meeting, that is the time for them to do it or to bring it up because we're putting the waivers off. We're not going to discuss them tonight anyway. [55:26] Speaker F (unidentified): So if you have feedback on the street tree waiver, so specifically whether you want to see street trees going up to the development or don't want to see street trees going up to development, please submit that as a comment to the planning director. We'll do it that way. [55:45] Speaker B (unidentified): You can email planningboard at windhammaine.us, or my email is nethompson. Yeah, okay. Planningboard at windhammaine.us is the best email for public comments. [56:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Now, before we do the next one, Natalie, I think we might want to have some discussion from the board before we – we're going to have to have the discussion anyway. [56:24] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe there's a motion to postpone this decision to the November 9th. [56:32] Speaker A (unidentified): That was the public comment. Who at the bottom one? Oh, you didn't read that. I did not. No, he just read the public comment. He just went for the waiver. [56:43] Speaker E (unidentified): So I do feel that Everett was correct that, you know, we shouldn't really be deliberating right now unless it's sort of, you know, not really terribly binding. I think what the planning board could be asking is for the applicant to provide more information in those areas that you have concerns with as well as the public. I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, MANAGE THIS AS A PUBLIC HEARING BECAUSE WE DIDN'T ADVERTISE IT CORRECTLY. SO IF YOU WANT TO LEAVE THEM WITH SOME MORE INFORMATION THAT YOU NEED, THEN I THINK NOW IS THE TIME AND THEN WE POSTPONE THE HEARING DELIBERATIONS UNTIL THE NEXT MEETING. YES. [57:30] Speaker A (unidentified): BECAUSE THE THING IS, IF THERE If there are things that the board feel that it's important for them to hear now from the applicant, I'd like them to be able to address that versus prolonging this so it goes further and further out. I mean, if there are things that we're aware of that we would like to ask now that it's not going to affect the final, could affect the final, it should be asked. I agree. [58:00] Speaker E (unidentified): I agree. I just, you know, any kind of deliberations about issues should be held off until we have an official public hearing that we have noticed that meets the statute. Right. Okay. So, I mean, you certainly can ask the applicant in anything that you want to have more information or even want to talk about a little bit of the details here. Absolutely. But like I said, just the formulation of a decision on a certain area. [58:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, we're not going to make a decision. I just want to make sure that if there's anything that needs clarification, that we get it. That's all I'm looking for right now from the board. If there's things that they feel that they need clarification on, that they can ask it now. There's no decisions, nothing like that. Absolutely. Okay. Do you have anything, Emily? Okay. Leo? [58:54] Speaker R (unidentified): One thing I was going to ask was about the trees as well. Well, it seems like, you know, in the scheme of all the water issues or questions, it doesn't seem giant. But one of the clarifications I wanted was when we talk about, you know, kind of view from the street, when we did the sidewalk, you had talked about keeping all those remaining trees at the top of the hill that would kind of mask the buildings from the street view. Is that still in play? [59:24] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah so basically going up the hill you know the entire roadway leading through the field area and then approaching up the hill would just be road without homes so the first homes are going to be all the way at the top of the hill you know cresting and going back down so yeah we [59:44] Speaker R (unidentified): made sure that there wasn't anything and you had like kind of a screen of trees there that you had said we're going to remain other than like the roadway through. [59:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, there'll be – within the open space, there is an area of wooded area before you get to those first two lots. Yeah. Okay. [1:00:03] Speaker R (unidentified): Yeah. And then during that site walk, we talked about the cul-de-sac at the end of it because originally like we were looking at Hammerhead and then we switched to a cul-de-sac. And you had mentioned during that there might be a waiver request in there to be able to size that cul-de-sac. But I didn't see that there is one now, so I'm thinking that it's sized appropriately. There was a conversation about trying to get it so that you could get the turning radius for buses and fire trucks and all of those things. [1:00:36] Speaker C (unidentified): So my understanding, like the Appendix B dimensional standards in the ordinance, which are all minimum standards, So we have minimum centerline radius, minimum road radius. So what we've done is we've increased those at the request of the town in the event that they do take it over and maintain it. They've had issues plowing cul-de-sacs here in town that have been built to the minimum standards. So we took it upon ourselves to just make it bigger. [1:01:09] Speaker R (unidentified): And then, let's see. I mean, I guess my comment is that I'm interested to see and try to understand all the reports and hydro studies that you have more information coming on. You know, looking at, I don't want to misspeak this, but Mr. Whalen's notes that you got as well, and his comment about the farm. And I don't want to misspeak, but the farm was being scaled as residential versus its actual commercial use. So I'll go back and take a look at that, but I thought that was interesting. So I'm hoping that I'm going to dig in a little bit more on that and you're going to have more information. [1:02:02] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that you're right. Am I correct? Yeah. And what he said when he was up speaking, yes, that he felt it was all looked at as residential and none of it was reviewed as farm. And I'd have to go back and read that whole thing. It takes too long at the moment, so we're not doing it tonight. But just so you're aware, so we need clarification on that. [1:02:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and I guess for us, too, I mean, again, you know, trying to be good neighbors and understanding what's being asked of us. What hasn't been clear to me is are we being asked to show that the water that we're going to pull outside or out of the ground, taking into account recharge, is not going to negatively impact the excessive amount of water that comes out of the ground now from Bumble Root? Is that what we're being asked to do? What I haven't heard is, like, from the neighbors, I mean, I don't know what people's issues are. Like, if they've experienced drawdowns, like, are their wells producing less water? And if that's the case, I mean, is that because bumble root's there and they're pulling all the water out of the ground? [1:03:17] Speaker F (unidentified): I don't know. Could you clarify something? You said the – everyone, please, quiet down. Quiet down, please, everyone. [1:03:24] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm just asking questions. I don't – I mean, it's a complicated situation. [1:03:28] Speaker F (unidentified): You mentioned an excessive amount of water being drawn down by Bumblewood Farm. [1:03:32] Speaker C (unidentified): What do you mean by that? Well, I'm asking the question. What I've heard— You didn't ask a question. You made a statement. [1:03:37] Speaker F (unidentified): What do you mean by the excessive amount of water being drawn down by Bumblewood Farm? [1:03:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Because the testimony we've heard today is that during drought conditions, there's, you know, 20 hours of pulling water out, irrigation, and I don't know what quantity of water that—like, I don't know how that relates to a 27-lot subdivision. I'm not sure. Is it more? Is it less? Is it—like, I don't know. What [1:04:01] Speaker F (unidentified): kind of information would you need from the farm to be able to fold it into your model? [1:04:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, where it's actually being pulled out of the ground, I don't know what mechanism that they have to monitor it. And I think in the documents that have been provided to us, I don't think it's been quantified, and it seems that they don't know how much water is coming out of the ground currently. So I don't know how to compare it. But [1:04:30] Speaker H (unidentified): Steve, no. Hold on one second. Sorry. Steve, [1:04:37] Speaker A (unidentified): okay, you, that survey that was done, that hydrological you said is similar to, anyway, the first one you approved there, the hydrological and the groundwater stuff, who approves that? Who approves that? Who makes up, who determines? [1:05:03] Speaker E (unidentified): This decision will, in effect, approve the hydrological analysis that's being provided by the applicant. Now, there are some questions regarding the hydrological analysis that were also brought up by our third-party reviewer. So there are some unanswered questions that need to go back to our third party for them to do a further review. and any kind of data that could come from existing farm use or anything along those lines will help out our third-party reviewer to ask the appropriate questions or make a determination on whether or not their hydrological analysis is sufficient to show that they will not, they shall not cause any adverse impacts based on our ordinance. Okay. Okay. So, you know, there are some things that because of when those ordinances were developed that are going to be upgraded as we go forward. We will be talking about that at the next meeting based on some concerns that DEP has regarding improvements in our ordinance to get you the information. that seems to be the gap right now that we have between what was done under our ordinance and what our reviewer is asking for. So we can ask for those things, and we need to get a response back from the applicant to get back to our third-party reviewer for them to assess whether or not they've addressed their concerns as well as the concerns of the public. [1:06:46] Speaker A (unidentified): So that is still an open item then? [1:06:48] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe it is. I believe it needs to be tightened up, and I think anything that we can get for data that will help that to be tightened up, then we need to have it put in front of those experts that are going to review it and give us the feedback that's necessary for you to feel comfortable to decide whether or not there's going to be any adverse impacts or not. [1:07:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Now, I don't know. This is not my field, naturally. But I'm sure we know that there is a database for residential. Is there a database somewhere for farms? I mean, there must be one. [1:07:29] Speaker E (unidentified): No. Nothing? I mean, we don't maintain. I don't mean us. Okay. [1:07:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Out there somewhere, is there a formula of some sort? I guess that's what I'm saying. How is that third party, how are they going to do the review if they don't know what they're comparing it against? And I don't think the farm has a record of how much water I've drawn out of the ground over the course of a year or six months or whatever. I'm not sure. So do we know how? [1:08:03] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. They may have some kind of information. We'd have to put it into Mr. Whalen's hands to provide some additional information that will help our consultant figure this out. I mean, that really is what it comes down to. Okay. You know, as much as they've hired the proper accredited people, we've hired the correspondence accredited people. THERE WERE SOME GAPS THAT WERE PRESENTED IN THEIR REVIEW. WE'D LIKE TO TRY TO FILL THOSE GAPS AND IF WE CAN ADD MORE TO THAT CONTEXT BY BRINGING IT UP TO 26 OR 25 OR WHENEVER THE DATES THAT WE CAN FIGURE OUT, YOU KNOW, WHAT IS IT EXACTLY WE'RE LOOKING AT. WE NEED TO HAVE SOME CONTEMPORARY INFORMATION THAT NEEDS TO BE PROVIDED BY THE APPLICANT AND ANY OTHER PERSON THAT CAN PROVIDE INFORMATION. If they have well information that they can provide, we certainly would like to put it into the mix so that we can protect everybody's well system. There's certainly plenty of criteria in our ordinance that talks about ambient levels of contamination and limits on those increases on contamination. and it's those are standards that are in our ordinance today that you know we want to be able to get to as well so you know I think we want to protect the groundwater we want to protect the runoff that ends up on bumble root farm as it recharges their groundwater or is it a shared groundwater issue that we got to be concerned about but we also need to try to figure out what kind of ambient stuff is out there that we need to evaluate relative to the quality of the water that's in the ground and what's going to be running off the surface as mr. Roma indicated in the stormwater review they're treating the runoff up to a 97 percent quality which exceeds the DEP s requirement UNDER CHAPTER 500 FOR TREATMENT OF THE RUNOFF. AND THERE ALSO ARE TECHNIQUES AND, YOU KNOW, ENGINEERED SYSTEMS FOR THE SEPTIC FIELDS THAT WILL HELP ALSO REMOVE SOME OF THOSE CONTAMINATIONS WITHIN THE SEPTIC SYSTEM AND THE GROUNDWATER SYSTEM. THOSE TWO INTERFACES, THINGS THAT WE SHOULD BE CONCERNED ABOUT MAYBE SHOULD BE restrictions on fertilization and pesticides because those are obviously going to be runoff issues and that's something that would be included in the homeowners documentation that the homeowners association would maintain those restrictions or minimal restrictions or whatever the case may be but we need to ask the hydrological engineers what their consideration should be relative to the pesticide [1:11:12] Speaker A (unidentified): fertilizer issue. Okay. Do we think, not we, there's no we here, do you think that there's a possibility we might have some of those answers back by the next public hearing? [1:11:28] Speaker E (unidentified): I would hope so, but I, you know. You need information from other people. We need to gather whomever, you know, can get on their internet you know any board.com Windham us you know send us any kind of information if you have recent information regarding your wells that you've done some kind of study or you had somebody check it out or anything along those lines we'd appreciate you know any kind of information there we can then pull it together with the assess the response that mr. Roma had and get that over to our third party and start to do that evaluation I don't know if mr. Whalen has any kind of data on the amount of water that he uses or any kind of rates and how long you know get an estimation of what possible water consumption that you need to provide water to your crops that would be helpful in figuring this out, you know, whether or not we need to help you filtrate the groundwater. I mean, it's not unusual. We've seen some interesting techniques where people are concerned about, you know, water consumption, that they're putting in large, you know, wet ponds that are They're charging up and then taking that water and going through a filter and then applying it to the crops and cleaning up any kind of, you know, contaminants that might be in that wet pond. There's options out there, and I think, you know, from the town's point of view, we want to help out any farmer that needs to understand, you know, what's coming from the ground and how to protect the water that comes out of the ground into the fields. Okay. But, I mean, we can talk later. [1:13:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, you can talk later. [1:13:29] Speaker E (unidentified): I certainly want to bring up any kind of solution that could even actually improve your situation from what it is right now. But as everybody understands, you know, we're in a drought. We're hopefully going to get out of this drought soon. But, you know, these things cycle through and, you know. Okay. [1:13:50] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that answers a lot of questions. Leo, were you done? I'm sorry. [1:13:55] Speaker O (unidentified): okay I just I just had one thing and I was it was really disappointing I think Dustin to hear your response to the ordinance says you shall not do harm to your neighbors and you were saying that you're just trying to be a good neighbor but then tried to turn it on the farm about them taking all the water there they're there they're established and you're requesting this subdivision being BUILT. AND IT JUST I WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT I'M DISAPPOINTED IN HOW YOU REACTED TO THAT. [1:14:40] Speaker F (unidentified): ON A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT TOPIC, A QUESTION CAME UP ABOUT AND I CAN'T TELL WHICH ONE IT IS, IT'S THE ONE ALL THE WAY ON THE RIGHT. THAT OVERLAPS PRETTY HEAVILY WITH THE WETLAND. 20. [1:14:53] Speaker A (unidentified): I MADE A NOTE. 20. [1:14:56] Speaker F (unidentified): I RECALL DURING THE SIDEWALK THAT AREA THERE WAS VERY clear evidence that was, in fact, wet at times, right? And it looks like the building envelope currently has drawn, goes into the wetlands, but you'll pull that, you would pull that back, right? [1:15:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, we've got the tree clearing limits clearly outside the wetlands, but the building window extends into there, so we would bring that back. [1:15:25] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah. And so a question came up essentially to basically say, and I think it was from one of the public comments that basically said, that, you know, you shouldn't have a lot that completely overlaps with, you know, or that at least partially overlaps. So just for the sake of argument, if we were to ask you to move that lot or remove that lot, what would you do? [1:15:51] Speaker C (unidentified): So we looked at anywhere that we would move that lot would, I mean, We really only have the areas that we're putting in the stormwater management features. And if you recall, when we did the site walk, that was the area that was very kind of difficult to walk across. That was like the lowest, wettest area until you got to this rear spot. So certainly trying to move it to that location would, I don't think, would be an improvement. movement. In this case, what we felt was because that cul-de-sac is being built up in grade based on the profile, the homes on like lots 20 and 21 are going to be built up as well. So they'll have some daylight basements and some small backyards. So it's not going to require, you know, fill area or anything in those backyards. So it just having that be the one lot where we did have some wetland areas in the back you know we've got zero wetland impact for this entire project and we're not anticipating to impact any wetlands on lot 20 either so we're we're not filling any wetlands to build this project out at all so we felt that those could be appropriately protected similar to you know the forested buffer areas that are adjacent into perimeter boundary lines and things like that with some proper monumentation out there to protect those areas. And certainly, because they are wet, it's not an area that people would customarily just build into. [1:17:29] Speaker F (unidentified): And if I recall correctly, part of why you reconfigured the lots this way is because the first plan you came to us with actually had houses in the open field, right? [1:17:39] Speaker C (unidentified): They did, yeah. So we had to move lots back in order to accommodate. So there was really two things. It was the incorporation of the cul-de-sac, as well as moving those lots out of the field area so that they wouldn't be in view. So all of that kind of moved the development further back into the site. And, yeah, so this is the resulting layout, which we do feel has a good balance. Again, not impacting any wetlands. [1:18:07] Speaker F (unidentified): Roughly how far does the tree line extend out from, let's call it the left side, the west side of the plan? Because it looks like you've drawn tree limits next to the road, but not back up to the lot lines. How thick is the buffer there between the open field on lot number one and the open field on lot number seven? [1:18:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so, yeah, it's not shown on this plan, but it's basically down at the bottom of that steep hill. So where it says open space area two in that dark green area, so basically right where it says the number two, that's more or less the tree line. [1:18:55] Speaker F (unidentified): So there's going to be quite a bit of buffer there. [1:18:59] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, there's some large pines that kind of go up that hill. We're [1:19:07] Speaker F (unidentified): set for now. I'm set until the next meeting is. Next meeting. [1:19:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. All right, we're going to let it go until next meeting. [1:19:19] Speaker F (unidentified): I move to postpone the preliminary plan review of No. 26-10, Highland Cliff Estates Subdivision, to the November 9th Planning Board meeting, at which properly noticed public hearing will be held. [1:19:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Natalie, was there a reason you had November 9th, November 23rd on here? Is that in case we couldn't make the 9th? [1:19:45] Speaker B (unidentified): I was giving, I was, you could have chosen either. Those are your next two upcoming meetings. Okay. There was, I, okay. I was going to give you an option, but I mean, I think we've all agreed on the 9th. [1:19:57] Speaker F (unidentified): That's okay. Is November 9th enough time? [1:20:00] Speaker E (unidentified): I would suggest you ask the applicant. [1:20:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Is November 9th enough time? [1:20:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. I mean, we were talking today. I mean, we basically addressed the comments that we've received so far. We just wanted to get through this meeting tonight just in case some things came up so we could have a more complete package that we could submit tomorrow. [1:20:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, but we have to have some answers on that hydrological from that third party too. [1:20:26] Speaker C (unidentified): No, understood. And we'll, to the extent we can get some contact information, we'll gather as much data as we can and we'll see if we can, you know, build a model that, you know, we can demonstrate. Well, I'll tell you what. [1:20:40] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll schedule it for the 9th, and if worse comes to worse, we can always move it to the 23rd. I think it's more important that we have – maybe you should rephrase this to either date. I think it's more important that we have the answers for everybody, including the public and including us. I don't want to continue these meetings like on and on and on. on. I really want to come at some point to a resolution, and we can't do that until we have all the information that's needed. Absolutely, Chair. I think [1:21:12] Speaker E (unidentified): that's important. I think because we are advertising appropriately, if we're not complete with the review on the 9th, we'll postpone it to the 23rd. Okay. All right. That's fine. You know, you'll have the draft agenda. It will probably be on the draft agenda, but if we don't have it nailed down by the 2nd of November, which is a week ahead of your meeting, we might have it scheduled for the [1:21:42] Speaker A (unidentified): 23rd. Is that when it goes in the paper? Because that's probably what most people see. It's the paper. [1:21:46] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, what I don't want to do is advertise for a public hearing, and they're not ready, and we have to postpone it again. Again, we want to make sure that we have a public hearing with all the data that we've asked for tonight. And we've given a pretty good list. And I know we have it well documented, so we'll be looking for those things. And we also have to work with a third party. Yeah. So, you know, I don't control their schedule, so sometimes we get them to help us and sometimes they're bogged. [1:22:18] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. And it would be helpful if the— Are the third party notes online? [1:22:21] Speaker M (unidentified): The third party, is that online? line, the report? [1:22:25] Speaker B (unidentified): It is, and it's under its own tab that says [1:22:31] Speaker F (unidentified): the hydrological review. Actually, hold on. One request on that. So for the third party, sorry, if you're talking, can you please stop talking? [1:22:43] Speaker A (unidentified): It's okay. It's just disruptive for us. [1:22:47] Speaker F (unidentified): For the third party, if they could render an opinion on whether given kind of like the unusual USUAL NONRESIDENTIAL CONSUMPTION PATTERN WHETHER MODELING IS ACTUALLY SUFFICIENT OR WHETHER ADDITIONAL KIND OF LIKE LIVE TESTING OR SOMETHING ELSE NEEDS TO TAKE PLACE THAT WOULD BE SUPERHELPFUL. OKAY. [1:23:04] Speaker A (unidentified): WHATEVER RECOMMENDATION. WHATEVER THEY RECOMMEND. [1:23:07] Speaker E (unidentified): IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE DRAWDOWN TEST. [1:23:10] Speaker F (unidentified): HOWEVER THAT WORKS. I'M NOT A HYDROLOGIST. [1:23:14] Speaker E (unidentified): OKAY. SET? WE'LL MAKE SURE THAT'S IN THE REVIEW. [1:23:16] Speaker F (unidentified): ALL LOSING FAIR? WE NEED A SECOND, I THINK. [1:23:19] Speaker A (unidentified): I thought we all were second. I'll second again. She seconded it. Okay. Okay, all those in favor? Okay, it is postponed until hopefully November 9th. All righty. Okay, I'm going to take a five-minute break here, just in case people want to leave. I don't want you to have to tiptoe out. So we'll take a five-minute break. We are back. All righty, so moving on with continuing business. Excuse me. In accordance with the rules of the planning board, no public comment shall be allowed during the continuing business portion of the meeting except as requested by the board. Please send written comments by mail or email to planningboard at windermaine.us. Just for the public's benefit, this was advertised accidentally. I saw it on Facebook as a public meeting. We have already had the public meeting for this previously. So PB 26-076, 25-27, Eventide Subdivision, Major Subdivision, Final Plan Review, 100 River Road, row even LLC. The application is to develop a 17 lot conservation subdivision on 27.92 acres with a new road built to public standards. Lots will be 30,000 square feet with 13.87 acres proposed as open space. Lots will be served by private subsurface wastewater disposal systems, on-site wells, and an underground utilities. Subject property is identified as tax map one, lots eight, 8-1, 8-2, and 9, Zong Farm in the Presumpskit River Watershed. And here for the applicant is? [1:31:44] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, good evening. Dustin Roma with DM Roma Consulting Engineers. I'm representing Roweven LLC as the agent for the project. And we're here tonight to discuss final approval of this subdivision. We've had a second site walk for the project. I think was the last time we had met to discuss this proposal during that site walk we the road alignment had not changed from the previous version but in some time had passed and some planning board members felt it appropriate to put their eyes on the site so we could look at a few things notably one of the things we wanted to take a look at was the building envelope associated with lot number eight there's an area of wetlands that kind of runs down the back side of that property and we had the lot corners staked out in the field as well as a test pit location and there was some concern at the preliminary plan stage where we did have a building envelope shown extending into that wetland area which could be construed by somebody as having the ability to impact some of those wetlands for lot development so we wanted to make that clear on the subdivision plan that the building envelope ended at the wetlands and we did include kind of a special note on the subdivision plan that will be recorded SB1 which just points to the edge of those wetlands and just says no land disturbance into the wetland area just for extra emphasis to understand that wetland boundary is indeed a boundary of the building envelope. So the board also expressed some concern that the overall subdivision plan was difficult to kind of read and interpret some of the information on the plan. So we did break the subdivision plan up into three separate plans at a much bigger scale. So hopefully you were able to more clearly see the lot windows on each of those lots and have a better understanding of available space for development on those lots. There were some comments in regards to the well exclusion zone boundaries and a couple of minor modifications that were requested by the hydrogeologist. We did make those changes to the plans, primarily associated with a setback distance from the roadway itself. So we've made those adjustments to further modify the well exclusion areas on the lots. And then, let's see, the other two primary items, well, I guess it's really combined into one primary item, is the open space waiver that the board did not act on at the preliminary plan stage but still needs to be discussed and approved as part of this application. The open space amount for this project is deficient based on the ordinances that were in place at the time that preliminary approval was granted. so based on that information the waiver is still required and what we've done is we've been working with the town on our proposal for the preservation of that additional five plus acres that's the waterfront piece in between the Mountain Division Trail, and the river. At our last meeting where preliminary approval was granted, there were still some questions about what would be the best mechanism going forward for preservation of that land, ultimate ownership, public access. There were a few things that we needed to address. And the board wanted to get the town attorney to weigh in and make sure that what the board was going to be potentially voting on is something that works within the confines of the ordinance and is also consistent with what the objectives of the conservation subdivision are intended to achieve. So we did work closely with the town. We had a few different options that we had presented. And the one that seemed to make the most sense for everybody was involving the Presumptscott regional land trust so they expressed interest in owning that parcel the lot nine and they have a process that they need to go through where they have a lands committee that's going to review this proposal to dedicate or basically deed this land over to them and then And as part of that, you know, they will propose a deed restriction covenant that will be placed on that property. And what we've told them is that it's, you know, it needs to restrict development of it so that it's basically conservation, preservation land that can be used for passive recreation and that there needs to be a public access component. And both of those things are consistent with their mission and what they intend to utilize this parcel for. They also expressed some interest in potentially owning one of the open space lots, the larger one in the back. We're investigating the pros and cons of that, and we're not entirely sure. So it's not necessary that they own that open space piece, open space lot four, but it is something that they have interest in. And if there's a mechanism to do that, I know that's one of the options in the land use ordinance as far as conveyance of that open space is that it could go to an entity like that. So we'll certainly investigate that when the time comes as the property is developed. If there's an opportunity that it seems to make sense for both parties, then maybe that's a good long-term solution for the ownership of that parcel as well. But we are committing to offering that lot number nine to the land trust for them to own. So with that additional five acres, we more than make up for the lack of open space that we would otherwise need to provide to meet the ordinance requirement under the old ordinances that are still in effect for this project. project. If we were to apply the new ordinances that are now in effect today for every project going forward, the deficiency is around 10,000 square feet. So we are still just below where we would need to be to just meet that ordinance outright. We're within 10,000 square feet. Potentially, we could do a tiny bit of moving around lot lines and stuff to try to make that number work but we think the better solution is to give the 5.7 acres to the land trust and have that be basically public lands that they would be the stewards of before you go any further [1:39:11] Speaker E (unidentified): our town attorney statement was that the waiver request and the approval of the waiver request is not determined on the 5.7 acres being conveyed to either the town or PLTR. It's a separate lot in and of itself. The applicant, out of the generosity of his heart, felt that this is a good piece of land to protect, given the proximity to the Presumptscott River. PRTL has been working with Wyndham and Gorham to identify opportunities like this to acquire the riparian area along Presumpt-Scott River to protect the water quality, and they feel that this is a good opportunity. That said, the exchange is not determined on your determination on whether or not you feel that the waiver is a valid waiver. Mr. Roma is correct the amendments to the conservation subdivision did go through and there are in fact they're in effect today which basically would take out that road right away as not a determining factor on the amount of open space. And based on the numbers that we're talking about, it would meet that standard, but for the fact that he has to count that road right away, that's why we're below the 50%. That is the minimum that is not waivable going forward. so in your determination whether or not you know there is some more conservation land out of the open space that can be dedicated which would be a different component because it's in the contiguous land area of the subdivision that's a different story and it doesn't play into the waiver request in and of itself so i just wanted to emphasize that particular lot but in no way is part of your decision for the waiver on the open space because we're under the previous rules. And you'll have to find merit that you believe that this is a good option because it does allow for public access as part of that lot that goes through the subdivision. That is already a benefit that property has relative to the subdivision. In other words, there is pedestrian access through the open space of the contiguous area to this parcel that's adjacent to the Presumpt-Scott River. [1:42:13] Speaker A (unidentified): So the waiver does not include Lot 9, right? So we're taking it on basically what is presented to us, and it doesn't matter what they do with Lot 9. That is correct. What they have is what they have. So in order to meet this, they would have to give up house lots or house lot. [1:42:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, as Mr. Romer indicated, that they could manipulate and come up with another 10,000 square feet of open space if that's what you want him to do. [1:42:53] Speaker O (unidentified): I thought he said he was 10,000 square feet short of the new standard. Right. Yeah, he's like two acres short of the standard he's under, right? [1:43:02] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, he still needs a waiver regardless. [1:43:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, he would need a waiver. [1:43:07] Speaker R (unidentified): Which standard are we working with? [1:43:09] Speaker E (unidentified): You're working with the old standard. The old standard. Which basically says the planning board can waive the open space requirement. [1:43:17] Speaker A (unidentified): But it still uses the same calculation, though, right? [1:43:21] Speaker E (unidentified): It uses the inclusion of the road right-of-way as it has to be made up in the open space. [1:43:28] Speaker F (unidentified): Can the applicant decide to use the new standard? [1:43:32] Speaker E (unidentified): No, unless we take them backwards to preliminary. Right now, this is the final request, the final review, and this is, you know. [1:43:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, well, before we get into this, though, we've skipped ahead here. Did you finish? No, he didn't. [1:43:56] Speaker E (unidentified): But I just wanted to make sure that you understood from our attorney that 's what you're likely to consider. [1:44:05] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, so certainly we can come back and visit the open space discussion. That's certainly one of the critical pieces. [1:44:09] Speaker A (unidentified): We will because the wave is there. [1:44:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Yep, and we can get into that discussion more. And then other than that, we've just been working with staff a little bit just on these last couple of questions on the on the hydrogeology and you know one of them is just again in regards to testing and treating of water for the new lots being created you know in our statement and to in the response here it for any of these lots again that have you know water quality that's pulled out of a well that doesn't meet the safe drinking water standards we would install a water treatment system that's a requirement of the state and as far as the recharge requirements one of the options in listed in the ordinance to demonstrate compliance with making sure that groundwater recharge is achieved post-development is to limit the impervious area to 10 percent or less and we're around eight points eight point something percent for this development so we do meet that requirement as far as the groundwater recharge standards but again that's something that we just would like to talk to the board about to see if there's any issues on this whole this whole issue of groundwater and modeling and quality is something that's a little new as far – I mean, the ordinance has been around for a long time, but I think this is something that the board is just dealing with now in a different capacity based on comments that have been received and everything. So we're working closely with our geologists, the peer-reviewed geologists, just to make sure that we're addressing those questions adequately, and we believe that we have. the last piece of that is related to, the physically drawing the nitrate plumes on the lots. There was one question about, there was some lots internally that the, geologists use their professional judgment after conducting site specific, nitrate plume analyses on several lots that they identified as potentially having groundwater gradients that are traveling towards a property line. And then they go through the analysis in those conditions where they take soil samples and they sieve them out and they do a pretty extensive model, which predicts the length of the nitrate plumes heading towards property lines. But then they use their professional judgment on certain lots that are not having those groundwater, you know, gradients heading towards property lines. And it's not necessary per se to do individual lot nitrate plumes on those. So that was, I think, the last third comment that was in that geology's comments that we addressed. Other than that, I think, I believe we've submitted the remaining pieces for the final plan submission. Interested to continue the discussion about the open space and certainly address any other questions that you might have. [1:48:16] Speaker B (unidentified): So the groundwater, we kind of just made a note on everything that the peer review said. But I kind of went through the biggest comments they had left and tried to summarize them a little bit. So you guys can go through them if you want to. [1:48:42] Speaker O (unidentified): THE PREVIOUS SLIDE, IT SAID IT WAS INCOMPLETE, THAT WAS THE PREVIOUS REVIEW. IT'S NOT LIKE INCOMPLETE IS [1:48:49] Speaker B (unidentified): PROBABLY NOT THE RIGHT WORD THERE. THE WAY I WROTE THIS WAS THAT YOU AS A BOARD WOULD GET TO DETERMINE IF YOU WANT MORE INFORMATION ON IT VERSUS, YOU KNOW, STAFF SAYING IT WAS COMPLETE. [1:49:04] Speaker A (unidentified): NO, SHE'S SAYING RIGHT THERE, YOU'RE SAYING DATA ON EXISTING GROUNDWATER QUALITY HAS NOT BEEN PROVIDED. [1:49:10] Speaker B (unidentified): that was what [1:49:16] Speaker O (unidentified): written back as the peer review and has there been a response on that is my [1:49:19] Speaker C (unidentified): question so what they did so again this is this is something new that so what haley ward did is they basically just regurgitated the ordinance back there's nothing specific that says you know groundwater quality data like what to provide it just says that you know there needs to be some them plan for groundwater quality. So what they did is they just restated that section of the ordinance that just says groundwater quality information wasn't provided because we didn't provide any data, but there wasn't any data to provide. Like we don't have wells on this property currently. We certainly can't go around testing other people's wells. And I don't, I honestly don't know what this ordinance is intended to accomplish other than if we have a plan for how we address groundwater quality like when dep does their site location permits we don't go out and test groundwater on adjacent properties i mean we basically have a plan for how we're going to make sure that the lots that we're creating will have access to safe potable drinking water and that we're meeting that requirement by providing water treatment systems in the event that they're are required. And I don't know what level of analysis beyond that we would do. [1:50:40] Speaker Q (unidentified): Mr. Puglio, [1:50:43] Speaker A (unidentified): the ordinances are in your ballgame there. So why do we have an ordinance that doesn't really give some kind of basis of what's required? [1:50:54] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I will be frank that the ordinances are a little outdated relative to the same criteria that we would see with a site location application to DEP the intent of what we're trying to do with the modifications to the amendments to qualify as the delegated review authority for site location you will be seeing some more or less miscellaneous ordinance amendments that will address these issues concerning groundwater, quantity, quality, protection, and things of that nature that's going to ramp up our ordinance as it is written today to meet DEP's standards. That said, I can't explain whether or not our ordinances are rigorous enough to get you the information as described by our hydrological reviewer until we ramp it and we quantify it based on the DEP standards. So we're sort of there, but not really there. That's what deps told us and as dustin's explained this is really the first time we've had to assess this in such a specific detail all right so that said there are just some things that haley ward Board was asking the applicant to respond more specifically to the ordinance performance standards that we haven't had an opportunity to get Haley to respond to what the applicant has already responded on their comments. [1:53:01] Speaker A (unidentified): So the ordinance is pending review and updates. [1:53:05] Speaker F (unidentified): The ordinance seems pretty prescriptive here, right? [1:53:09] Speaker E (unidentified): It is pretty prescriptive. [1:53:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Either from test wells in the subdivision or from existing wells on neighboring properties. Do you have a test well on the? [1:53:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, there's no existing wells on the property. [1:53:22] Speaker F (unidentified): Do you have neighboring wells that you have access to? [1:53:25] Speaker E (unidentified): And that's the rub. That's why we ask for volunteer information or people that would want to participate to help out that particular criteria, which is not something that we can make an assumption that our applicant can go on to the people's property and do those tests. [1:53:42] Speaker O (unidentified): Didn't you say a test well, though? I mean, has a test well been done? Have you performed a test well? [1:53:48] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't know that anybody's ever done that on a subdivision. [1:53:51] Speaker O (unidentified): So has this project performed a test well? Okay. So how do we know that we're meeting DEP standards? [1:53:58] Speaker C (unidentified): They wouldn't require that. [1:53:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, if we can't go onto the neighbor's property and test their wells, why would the applicant not put a test well in? Just asking the question because it looks like it's— [1:54:10] Speaker C (unidentified): I guess what would you do with the data? [1:54:12] Speaker A (unidentified): I have no idea. I'm not the person that reads these. I only get the end results. [1:54:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, I guess I have no issue providing data that we're going to use. [1:54:26] Speaker A (unidentified): We're just trying to tie together the ordinance versus what we're seeing. you know what you're providing and what she's asking for yeah i mean the company that we hired [1:54:38] Speaker C (unidentified): to perform the analysis is you know they're based out of you know livermore falls they do a lot of rural development large subdivisions up around the ski resorts they're very used to providing the level of analysis that would be required for a site location permit and that's specifically what we asked them to do we said please you know prepare a analysis for nitrates and groundwater that would be suitable for a DEP site location permit application, and that's what they produced. And the peer review engineer was doing their job in that they just said, this is what your ordinance says, and this information wasn't provided. He didn't say that he needed it to make a decision one way or the other. It was just a statement. [1:55:24] Speaker P (unidentified): Emily? I was going to ask, have you asked the neighbors if you could test their well? Was there any effort to try to test neighbor's wells no i mean we didn't yeah we didn't attempt to make to test their water quality and then i think the concern at least i have is you know i don't think windham represents all of maine being that i think it's like five of eight of our watersheds are at risk of impact from development because of our watersheds some of them are quite small, and because we have a lot of development going on, I don't think we're just a representation of the rest of Maine. No, certainly not. So that would be my concern. [1:56:17] Speaker A (unidentified): So where are we? Natalie, can you go back to the? Well, so there's more. I know. There's a lot more in there. Yes, I wanted to see. [1:56:26] Speaker O (unidentified): Well, I'm still reading through these bullet points. So partially answered, open to the off-site drawdown on existing wildland response sites to 10% in previous limit. Sorry, I got hung up on the first few. I want to make sure we... [1:56:48] Speaker A (unidentified): How does the... It would be nice if we could see side by side. How does the groundwater peer review line up with the previous slide? I just... That was... Oh, I'm talking... Yeah. [1:57:04] Speaker B (unidentified): That's just the data. Okay. Yeah, that was an overview. We don't have to... Dot,, dot. Yep, gotcha. I [1:57:23] Speaker A (unidentified): don't know. This has not come up in the past. [1:57:32] Speaker P (unidentified): i would like to see if you can access neighbor's wells and test those and get some more data i think that would be if neighbors said yes the simplest way to get the data to ensure that we're not having a impact on the water i think we have one neighbor how do you [1:57:53] Speaker A (unidentified): test the neighbors well is it just getting water out of the faucet yeah you'd take the water out [1:57:59] Speaker C (unidentified): out of the faucet and you send it off to a lab. [1:58:00] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think anybody would object to that unless their effector would actually probably be kind of good. It's a freebie for them. It's kind of like, here, you can test my water. [1:58:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, you know, I think... But then it's going to the planet. I mean, it's out in public record and everything. [1:58:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I don't know. Steve, you had something? Yeah, you know, [1:58:25] Speaker E (unidentified): it... You know, testing the water coming out of their faucet is not i don't think is really because some people have filters and whatever so you know the board you know as mr crickin indicated could require a test well in the subdivision or you know existing wells on the neighboring properties i think you know that Section D underneath, you know, the hydrological assessment under, you know, 910, C3D is really the planning board may require that of the applicant. if we're not satisfied with trying to get wells within 1,000 feet and test those existing wells, and that's the alternative. But again, I think what Dustin is saying is correct. I think a lot of the things that Haley responded back to them is, how come you didn't provide this data, how come you didn't provide that data underneath our ordinance section which when this amendment comes to you guys soon we'll be looking at sort of the DEP's criteria not our criteria so this [2:00:01] Speaker O (unidentified): will be modified but we're living under our criteria right now and so for us to ask for what meets our criteria whether we want to stick it in a SHOE BOX OR NOT IT'S STILL MEETING THE ORDINANCES SO [2:00:14] Speaker A (unidentified): IT'S EITHER OR IT'S A [2:00:18] Speaker F (unidentified): TEST PIT OR IT'S THAT'S WELL OUR NEIGHBOR WILL SURVEYS YEAH WHICH WAS BE [2:00:24] Speaker E (unidentified): VERY TIME-CONSUMING AND PROBABLY WOULDN'T HAPPEN THE APPLICANT COULD PROVIDE THIS DATA VERY QUICKLY RELATIVELY RELATIVE TO SEEKING OUT budding well information within a thousand feet but again i believe that's you know the way i read the ordinance it said the planning board may that's that's on section two of that of the hydrological assessment submittal so [2:01:06] Speaker B (unidentified): steve are you saying that if they're okay with the developer or just doing the testing and treatment of each new well as they're built, they don't have to require any additional studies because it's May and not shall? [2:01:31] Speaker E (unidentified): I believe it's in the Plainy Board, based on that language, the Plainy Board's court. They can decide either way. They can not require it. They could do test pits and provide that to our hydrological assessment, or they can – and when we look at Section 911H, which is groundwater quality and groundwater quantity – I'm trying to see if there's anything that requires a – [2:02:12] Speaker A (unidentified): so the only ones open a two and two and six and three is partially and i steve okay let's just take it one at a time is two is their response adequate because that was their response but natalie just went through it [2:02:46] Speaker E (unidentified): That would meet the – so underneath the groundwater quality under 911H1F, the planning board – whenever the planning board determines the potential of some lots in the proposed subdivision they have a difficulty obtaining a well adequately to adequately adequate quality and quantity for portable water the developer shall require drill well and verify the water supply before the lot sold so we're back to drilling a lot so that goes back to and that's what natalie is stating that you know as properties go forward a drilled well would have to provide us the data that shows that it meets both the quality and quantity requirements under 9-11-H. [2:03:49] Speaker A (unidentified): And that would be in conditions of approval? [2:03:51] Speaker E (unidentified): That could be in a condition of approval, certainly. [2:03:54] Speaker C (unidentified): I do think the way that 's worded, the first sentence basically says you first have to determine whether you feel that it's likely that water quality would be an issue, and then it requires a study. Just the way that you read it, sounds like if the planning board determines that water quality may be difficult to achieve. It's weather. We've designed a project in another town where we had neighbors come out and express concerns that there was illegal dumping that had happened on that property over the years. So there was evidence that there might be an issue with groundwater. And we got DEP involved in their uncontrolled sites program, and we did wells and tested it, and everything came back fine. But that's a circumstance where I think, again, you know, there could be a reason that there is suspect that groundwater quality might be an issue but in this case where we're in a very rural circumstance lack of that you know those allegations it's it's just a typical site i don't see a reason why there would be concentrations of any contaminants that would be out of the realm of just putting in a typical residential water treatment system would take care of [2:05:08] Speaker E (unidentified): And then that goes back to, you know, limiting the amount of impervious conditions of the overall site to less than 10%. [2:05:17] Speaker F (unidentified): That one only applies to runoff, not the drawdown. That's true. So, Mr. Puglio, the way that you are— [2:05:27] Speaker E (unidentified): That's the quality issue. [2:05:28] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, the way that you read the quality part, so 12910C3C3D, so the first one, on item number two, I don't see that we have any leeway there other than to grant a waiver. Because it says if we go to three, the major subheader three, it says the following items shall be submitted as part of this preliminary plan unless there is a waiver. Then C is hydrogeologic assessment. And three, if an assessment is submitted, the assessment shall contain at least the following information and then d is data on the existing groundwater quality either from test wells or from existing wells so i don't see as of any we have no leeway there as far as i can tell we can't just there's no may there 's shell i only see shells so that would be a waiver you're correct and i know we haven't looked at this deeply before even though it may have applied to previous project but once it is brought to our attention we can't obviously cannot ignore what the ordinance says but the option exists for them to approach a [2:06:54] Speaker O (unidentified): neighbor and request testing that would avoid them from having to tap a well and avoid us from issuing a waiver that doesn't feel necessary so [2:07:07] Speaker C (unidentified): our options are to so approach a neighbor to get a well sample and if they refuse we have to drill a well on site to collect a sample. [2:07:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I'll come for a waiver. Yeah. [2:07:18] Speaker C (unidentified): At any depth or... [2:07:21] Speaker E (unidentified): I... Depth of ground water table. The depth is the ground water table. I represent your point throughout the subdivision. That's the shell containing the following information. That's [2:07:38] Speaker C (unidentified): what it says. That's the three options. And option three is to request a waiver from drilling a well, and it sounds like the board doesn't want to grant that waiver. [2:07:49] Speaker F (unidentified): WELL, IT'S A SUBMISSION WAIVER SO THE PLANNING STAFF CAN GRANT THAT AS WELL, RIGHT, TECHNICALLY? [2:07:57] Speaker E (unidentified): I WOULD IMAGINE. [2:07:59] Speaker N (unidentified): TECHNICALLY. TECHNICALLY. TECHNICALLY THEY CAN. [2:08:02] Speaker E (unidentified): BUT I THINK AT THIS POINT, IF I DIDN'T GRANT THE WAIVER FOR THE HYDROLOGICAL ASSESSMENT, THEN IT SHALL INCLUDE IT. [2:08:13] Speaker F (unidentified): THAT'S FAIR. SO IT'S EITHER ALL OR NOTHING? Right. [2:08:17] Speaker E (unidentified): You're either in or out. I'm not going to parse it. That makes sense. You can parse it if you want. It's a board. Clearly we can, yeah. Yes, we can. [2:08:29] Speaker F (unidentified): So those are the options, Mr. Roma. [2:08:34] Speaker C (unidentified): And we can't request a waiver tonight unless – well, you said you can't grant it anyway because it's a submission. [2:08:38] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, not a partial. That's true. I think the planning board can reach if they want to. [2:08:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Does it become a performance standard once the submission requirement is met and now there's a component of the submission requirement that's not included? Does it become a performance standard at that point that the board waives? [2:08:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, it actually very specifically says unless the applicant submits and is granted by the planning board a written waiver request as part of the sketch plan application review, by the way, the board may determine additional criteria, blah,, blah,, blah. So that's very specifically what it says. You can go back to sketch plan and adopt a new open space requirement calculation. [2:09:21] Speaker C (unidentified): okay so we just submit a water test that says anything and we check the box at least for the [2:09:28] Speaker F (unidentified): submission yes that [2:09:31] Speaker E (unidentified): would that would make the submission complete right it would i mean they need to provide the data right whether the data i don't whatever the data says including [2:09:45] Speaker F (unidentified): some interpretation please because we're not water well yeah usually special usually there [2:09:50] Speaker C (unidentified): There's a threshold where it becomes, you know, an issue. Yeah, like dangerous. Yeah, exactly. And then you're, you know. [2:09:58] Speaker F (unidentified): I think we've all, hopefully we've all seen water tests before. [2:10:05] Speaker C (unidentified): And this is just the standard state one for drinking water. [2:10:08] Speaker F (unidentified): It does not specify what kind of water quality test it needs to be, Mr. Roma. [2:10:14] Speaker A (unidentified): So what about the runoff now? Nitrate is just six. [2:10:19] Speaker E (unidentified): Six. Well, the nitrate assessment is part of the drinking water standard. So that's, you know, that is being addressed either through the system. [2:10:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Not that I want to be too picky, but we still haven't done completion. You took over from my – [2:10:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, that's all right. We're assessing completion. Because this was part of it. That's why we haven't gone any further. [2:10:43] Speaker B (unidentified): Deliberating a lot. We're still on that. I just wanted to point that out. No, we're still on that. We didn't forget. [2:10:47] Speaker A (unidentified): get it's just we're still trying to resolve this so we can go back and decide whether it's complete or not because it basically said according to haley wood it wasn't so by the way is that a is that a company or is that a person it's a company oh because i said her because haley would be a girl's name and dawned on me afterwards i think that's a company but anyway i think there are [2:11:14] Speaker F (unidentified): also men and daily but that's beside the point we don't even get distracted by that I guess item number three that's okay yeah so we're good on that mr. point down to six number six that's the runoff no that is the drawdown on existing wells which is a separate item this is the one that says which we're discussing in the prior application as well any water table drawdowns beyond the subdivision boundaries due to groundwater withdrawals by the proposed subdivision shall not adversely impact groundwater supply availability to existing wells nor cause structural damage for example settlement [2:12:12] Speaker O (unidentified): so is that gathering data from the neighboring well how does that work mr roma yeah i mean [2:12:19] Speaker C (unidentified): what we took of that because so groundwater withdrawal you know we looked at that as you know a combination of again we have recharge and withdrawal so i guess if you would assume no recharge and only withdrawal if there was a well that was nearby i guess you would impact you know analyze the impact of wells on that well somehow i guess i'm not really sure i mean we've gone over this with our geologists trying to anticipate it's like is there a way to answer this question without structurally going out and doing so in order to put enough infrastructure in the ground to adequately to answer these questions with lots and lots of data there's a lot involved they couldn't really even give me a scope because it's so site specific they would be doing you know they'd probably go out and do individual small diameter wells first to kind of analyze groundwater gradients over a large area so that they could then determine the slopes of the groundwater gradient so then they can decide where to put the bigger wells and where to do the drawdowns and build that whole three-dimensional model and i think we have we have complete conservation land on one side of us and then we do have a neighbor on the other side. There is a second neighbor, but they're way out near River Road where we only have stormwater ponds. [2:13:56] Speaker A (unidentified): So you have one well adjoining where you are close to it. [2:14:04] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, there's a couple of wells closer to River Road on those lots that were created you know divided from this bigger piece several months ago where the two existing homes are so now we've got basically in three different directions it's it's very complicated it's i mean you know if we were nestle trying to you know pull water out for a bottling plant or something it might make sense but yeah [2:14:38] Speaker E (unidentified): and that's and that's exactly what DEP is concerned about. If there was a manufacturing facility that's using groundwater, then there's a, they have a much more detailed quality quantity requirement under Chapter 375, Subsection D, 7D that talks about what happens to the water, remaining water quantity-wise when you have a manufacturing facility that's drawing the water down. [2:15:17] Speaker O (unidentified): I'm just concerned if we don't have data, if we don't have a baseline data for these existing wells, then we have nothing to prove whether we've harmed them or not, right? And the fact that they exist means that they shall see no adverse impacts. impacts. So, I mean, I'm feeling, you know, like deja vu all over again, but the question still stands. Like, how do we know that we won't be impacting without information? So, how many [2:15:46] Speaker C (unidentified): neighboring properties were you saying? Three. We have one to the side of us, and then we have two [2:15:51] Speaker F (unidentified): out near River Road. And so, it does look like we got a public comment about this specific. Yeah, it is, it is. And it mentions the continued diligence that shows the groundwater removal would not impact the existing farm and homeowners' well supply. Is there a farm nearby, like very nearby? [2:16:22] Speaker C (unidentified): Maybe across the street. Because everything to the south of us is basically conservation easement land for the Parsons-Smith House. [2:16:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Well, this is close. This is a neighbor because we're at 100. This one is 12. Yeah, not far. [2:16:47] Speaker H (unidentified): And I [2:16:50] Speaker C (unidentified): could see a situation if this was like a condominium development or a trailer park or something like that, where we had a common well supply for 40 houses that was pulling off a one well, and it was a public drinking water system. And, you know, I think certain circumstances, because this ordinance doesn't qualify, you know, it just basically says for every project, [2:17:08] Speaker A (unidentified): you know you shall demonstrate this well i guess at as a minimum the least we could do is you say this three is basically what we did for the last one it approached those basically get something in writing from those three people as to okay my well is fine you know it's usually i don't know 400 feet down blah i've never had a problem my well or my well is close to being, you know, something from the three people that would give us some kind of an idea of what are they seeing as an impact to the drought that we presently have. And it's better than no information. [2:17:56] Speaker F (unidentified): This one seems exceedingly difficult to get information on absent. [2:18:00] Speaker A (unidentified): It is because it's— [2:18:02] Speaker F (unidentified): Another opinion on how one might measure this beyond going through really, like, extensive real-life testing. [2:18:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Mr. Puglia? I would agree with that, Mr. Crick. Looking at sort of the comments from DEP regarding this particular issue, which is 9-11-H, quantity, quality, the only thing that they want us to do that our ordinance doesn't really talk about, we can modify some of it. But what they are suggesting is an additional language that talks about the quantity that would be used by the subdivision and any, you know, sewage disposal system that is involved as an aggregate of more than 2,000 gallons per day. So across the board, you have X number of houses that amounts to $2,000 per day. They want to know what the quantity of groundwater would be used by the subdivision. [2:19:10] Speaker A (unidentified): And that can be supplied, right? I mean, we've seen it in other buildings. [2:19:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, we have documented what the wastewater is. Because basically your water consumption and wastewater demand are just basically connected. [2:19:26] Speaker E (unidentified): but also it does talk about you know nitrate levels at the property boundary and by and large what dep looks at is actually quite our ordinance goes a little further when it talks about adjacent wells and not having impact to them but dp is their site law pulls back a little on that It's at the property boundary that the wells, the groundwater impact is not adverse. So, you know, I've got to go through that in a little bit more detail and look at some of the actual statutes that the DEP has. But for our concern right now, the ordinance is what the ordinance says, that it shall not cause adverse impact. and if the planning board feels it's incumbent to the applicant to reach out to the abutting properties that could be affected that's your will and that's what you want to see before you make your final decision because that's important for you to have that information for you to make the final decision if it's something that we can condition that could also be something that could be subsequent to some kind of trigger, building permit issuance, that type of thing? [2:20:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I think being a good neighbor, it's not a bad idea to do that. Basically, it's kind of like a heads up to folks who have those wells who would not think about what is this going to do to my well? I mean, some people just never give that a thought. [2:21:09] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, you know, relative to the conditions that were at the last hearing, you know, there isn't, quote, unquote, a commercial farm that's directly adjacent to the property like Bumble Root. [2:21:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, I understand that. But I think this is a gentleman's farm. [2:21:28] Speaker C (unidentified): What if we made it a condition of approval? Again, we're skipping the conditions of approval just for discussion. discussion what if we made it a condition that we provide at least two you know water that way that there will be data that's the town has on file we'll provide you know a water sample from at least two separate well sources whether it be two out of the three neighbors wells or if we drill something on site like we'll accomplish it however we need to do it we'll have a plan that shows where the water was sampled from when it was taken and we'll test the water and that'll be something that'll just be submitted because I think what we've decided is that the information needs to be submitted and it needs to be part of the record but it's not necessarily something that the board would use to make a decision so maybe we make it a condition of approval that we sample two that way it's not just one single location it'll be at least two wells [2:22:21] Speaker A (unidentified): and then well if you do that then it becomes a monitoring thing then because what does it look [2:22:28] Speaker C (unidentified): like after you put those i didn't read it that way i think it just i think the requirement is that we submit the data i think the requirement is that we submit the data and that we have a plan for addressing and mitigating water quality issues on our lots if it becomes an issue and that way if a neighbor does have a complaint later on now we have a baseline condition of pre-development [2:22:51] Speaker S (unidentified): of water testing well quality yes but quantity no right that's the quality we haven't gotten [2:23:05] Speaker E (unidentified): THE BOARD CAN ASK FOR QUANTITY DATA TO GET AN IDEA OF WHAT KIND OF FLOW WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. HOW MANY GALLONS PER MINUTE FROM THEIR FAUCET OR FROM THEIR SYSTEM, YOU KNOW, YOU CAN DO BOTH OF THOSE THINGS, QUALITY AND QUANTITY. [2:23:19] Speaker F (unidentified): But if we, okay, so assume for a second we make this a condition of approval, and then what? The data gets submitted, and then what happens? [2:23:32] Speaker A (unidentified): If somebody has a problem with their well, then they're going to complain, and then what? Then it becomes, then they have to fix it. Do that? Yeah. [2:23:40] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, it would be part of your approval, and if they weren't able to meet that condition of approval without having an adverse impact, [2:23:47] Speaker F (unidentified): because that's what it says right which it won't find out until all the properties are built and everybody starts drawing water out of the ground that the neighboring well goes down by like a couple hundred feet so then the [2:23:58] Speaker E (unidentified): developers gonna have to address that they have to drill them into well yeah I believe so if you make it if the terminology that shall not cause adverse impact and it 's pretty clear will not cause structural damage settling seems [2:24:16] Speaker F (unidentified): seems complicated. Well, I mean, it does, but I don't know how we're going to establish an [2:24:24] Speaker E (unidentified): ambient water level without having some kind of outside, you know, information brought to us. [2:24:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Because that was going to be my other question. So suppose we ask for it to be submitted before we approve. Then clearly the data has to do something to our approval, right? It either has to lead us to a decision that yes you can build as is or no you have to limit to i don't know 15 13 12 lots or no you can't build at all but i mean that's that's literally the only thing we can do with the data right when you think about drawing water out of the ground because either you're drawing too much and people's wells go down or you're okay and it gets replenished how would we use that data like what kind of opinion would we need to say that no oh, this, you know, based on our testing, you can do 15 lots, not 17 lots. [2:25:15] Speaker E (unidentified): I don't think that would be a decision we wouldn't [2:25:18] Speaker O (unidentified): because we don't have the technical expertise. That would be where we get our insights from third party. [2:25:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Does that exist? [2:25:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, what happens, okay, let's take it away from this a minute. Okay, blasting, right? Now, you don't know, you do the test and everything, you don't know until you blast if it's going to affect. Okay, we did some tests, whatever, it shouldn't affect anybody. All of a sudden, the next property over has a crack in their foundation. They're responsible to take care of that. So this becomes a similar thing. The minute, okay, we say, okay, that's fine. You gave us those. We know what those samples look like from those wells. And the minute that two years from now or a year from now, you know, they come forward and they say, hey, my well went dry. [2:26:04] Speaker F (unidentified): Hello, voila. Guess what? Somebody's going to say, it was a drought. [2:26:08] Speaker C (unidentified): It was a drought. I mean, this is how I see it. [2:26:11] Speaker F (unidentified): It sounds like a total hassle, a legal hassle. [2:26:13] Speaker A (unidentified): But you can put it in as a condition. [2:26:16] Speaker C (unidentified): Because the way I see it is this is just a piece of evidence. If somebody chose to pursue it, if something were to happen and somebody were to, you know, say that it was the subdivision's fault, it would create a piece of evidence to start from that it was at least tested in the beginning. And, yeah, I mean, the lack of, I mean. [2:26:35] Speaker R (unidentified): I understand whatever it's saying, and, like, we don't want to put people in that position. I, you know, but I do, to your point, Dustin, like, it does give a baseline, and it, per our earlier conversation, kind of behooves. If I was the neighbor, I'd be like, yes, please come test. Yeah. You know, because I want to have that now documented. This is where my well's at, you know. Well, it's the thing. [2:26:58] Speaker A (unidentified): You're protecting, you're actually protecting the neighbor when you do that. [2:27:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and some people refuse pre-blast surveys and stuff for the same. and it's it's for their own protection and they you know they may or may not want it yeah [2:27:09] Speaker O (unidentified): and i would say if you went if you went to all of them in good faith and all of them shut you down that's a different story yeah the concern the board has today is none of that has been even attempted and it's it's frustrating that we are doing everything we can to follow the ordinances so if i mean let's start with good faith and see what happens [2:27:30] Speaker E (unidentified): in my opinion are you are you suggesting that the condition of approval or that information is done prior to your decision or we need prior we need it prior because if he gets no data back then we i'm just i'm just checking to make sure that i mean i'm fairly [2:27:50] Speaker C (unidentified): confident i can get at least two that's why that's why i said that so i'm comfortable moving if the Board is. And again, if we don't deliver the two samples, then we haven't satisfied our requirement and we're not, we don't have approval. [2:28:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, Emily? [2:28:09] Speaker F (unidentified): So, submit the data before we approve or submit because we add a condition of approval? [2:28:19] Speaker A (unidentified): No, submit before we approve. Okay, I just want to [2:28:21] Speaker F (unidentified): be clear about that. No,. Because I think Mr. Roma is asking to add it as a condition of approval So we can approve the entire plan tonight. [2:28:28] Speaker A (unidentified): No, he said he thinks he could get it pretty quick. [2:28:29] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and the only reason I'm asking that is because it doesn't sound from the discussion tonight that the board is going to use the information to base their decision. So it seems like something that we can just include in the file as a condition. [2:28:42] Speaker P (unidentified): That's my question. For clarity, we're not just talking a water test, right? Because my concern is more quantity, not quality, right? right? So it's not just asking for... It would be both. They would similarly determine what their flow is from that particular... [2:29:02] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, we would submit a report that has water quality data and something to quantify either water levels or some drawdowns or something that we'll work with our geologists and the peer reviewer will look at it. But we'll submit some data for at least two wells that are on adjacent properties that will go in the file to create that baseline as a condition. [2:29:22] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Natalie, can you go back now and continue? I'm sorry. [2:29:33] Speaker E (unidentified): You woke her up. She was falling asleep. No. [2:29:41] Speaker B (unidentified): I was fully paying attention. [2:29:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Of course you were, Natalie. I'm in jest. [2:29:48] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I don't have anything additional. That was my last slide for you guys. [2:29:52] Speaker A (unidentified): So, yeah, and we would probably add, whenever we get to the end, another condition of approval that we discussed earlier, but that would be after. Condition of approval. Just to make sure it's in there. When we had the last discussion, we have that database, and if something happens later on, that would be responsible for it. [2:30:13] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm sorry. I'm hearing two different things. I'm hearing some members of the planning board saying we need it before we make the final decision. I'm hearing you say we can add it as a condition of approval. No,, no,. [2:30:22] Speaker A (unidentified): No, still, it's both, because we still need it as a condition of approval that, by the way, if somebody reports two years from now that there is an issue, they are responsible to fix it. [2:30:35] Speaker F (unidentified): Can we put that in a condition of approval? Not those words. [2:30:40] Speaker E (unidentified): Those are not the words. I think so, right? When the Plenty Board makes their determination, right, and the applicant doesn't meet all of the determination requirements, then we will issue a notice of violation. They're in violation of what your conditions of approval are or any other performance standard. So that's where you have the leverage. It's not if you don't do it within two years or if something happens in two years, it's not that. If it happens ever, because it would be in violation of your decision, because the terminology is shall not cause adverse impact to the abutting wells, shall not. So you want that data up front to see what it is, and the condition of approval says that these wells that have been tested, the data has been provided to the planning department and the reviewing engineer, and if we get a call from the abutter that they have a problem with their well, then the condition of approval is what rules the day. We're going to have to have whomever is now the responsible party. It could be the developer. It could be the homeowners association. It could be the actual homeowner. in and of itself, do some kind of mitigation for the abutting wells because they violated that condition of approval. Okay. [2:32:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I just want to make sure it's covered because I do understand that the minute we approve a project, we have no say over anything that happens. That's why I want to make sure everything is documented. [2:32:26] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I mean, yes and no. I mean, it's up to us to make sure that your decision is implemented according to the decision by the board. I mean, we work that all the time and you know, oh I understand that piece of it, but it just doesn't always [2:32:43] Speaker A (unidentified): In the past it has not always relayed to after the project [2:32:52] Speaker F (unidentified): We're also still under the you know, is the application complete So given that this was not submitted as part of the application [2:33:03] Speaker T (unidentified): I have some questions as the applicant, as the owner of Roweven. [2:33:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Could you say who you are? [2:33:11] Speaker T (unidentified): Sorry, Ron Goddard. I'm the managing member of Roweven LLC and the developer. So I understand everybody's concern about the wells, and it certainly makes certain sense to do these things. what happens if another applicant a year or two years down the road comes in with another parcel and you know there's a lot of developable land that's in that area and you know there's another 15 or 17 lot subdivision how does that come back on to me you know i mean these are questions that nobody has brought up what happens if we have a five-year drought i mean that's an act of god not an act of the developer or the subdivision or anyone in the subdivision so how do those things get mitigated is there any language that you guys have drafted i haven't seen any that sort of addresses these things how does that come back on to me or the homeowners association you know if you know those things arise and that would be something that i would you know [2:34:28] Speaker O (unidentified): We're not making anything up, though, today. Like, everything is in the current ordinances. [2:34:33] Speaker F (unidentified): But it's at the time of the application, right? So I think the questions you ask are really good questions for the planning department who can choose to send it off to the town attorney or whoever. Basically, post-approval enforcement and what cannot or yes or no be in a condition of approval and those kinds of things. And acts of nature. Because the way I read this, essentially,, the way I read this is the information needs to be submitted at the time of submission so that we can make a determination reasonably whether at the time that we are approving it, we are expecting there to be impact on the quality or quantity. [2:35:14] Speaker T (unidentified): And I thought that's what the hydrology reports were supposedly done. You know, the board asked for them. We provided them. I thought that was actually answering those questions, but it sounds like the hydrology reports didn't answer any questions. [2:35:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, because of Haley, whoever that company is, they're the ones that brought the questions up. Basically, it was their response that prompted our questions. [2:35:40] Speaker O (unidentified): But they found gaps that were not responding to the ordinance. So, no, your hydrology study didn't really answer the question. [2:35:46] Speaker A (unidentified): You know, it's nothing we went through because we, believe me, I don't think there's one of us up here that knows much about hydrology. [2:35:53] Speaker T (unidentified): Quality from quantity. No, I'm sure. It's a very technical – who knows how – [2:35:58] Speaker A (unidentified): We have a third party, so what we have is the questions that come up from the third party. [2:36:03] Speaker F (unidentified): And at the end of the day, the ordinance says what it says. Again, once something is brought to our attention, we can't just ignore it. We can't just say, well, now it doesn't – because it didn't matter in the past, it doesn't matter now. You know what I mean? Right. Right. Yeah. So I think that also then raises the question, essentially, about whether the application is complete or not. It isn't. There was, in fact, a report submitted that didn't have all the information as requested by the ordinance. [2:36:30] Speaker E (unidentified): You're correct. I'm not going to disagree with you, Eric. So that's the motion. [2:36:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Because we need that. Okay. [2:36:41] Speaker P (unidentified): Wait, can I ask a question first? Yep. if it is not complete what 's the next step it comes back again just like in two weeks that's [2:36:50] Speaker A (unidentified): what happens okay i'll whenever they hopefully the answers is the public allowed to speak at [2:36:56] Speaker K (unidentified): this hearing no thank you i [2:37:00] Speaker F (unidentified): move the major subdivision final plan application for project 25-27 eventide subdivision is found complete in regard to the submission no i'll vote for completeness and then we can vote it down why you don't have to it says off [2:37:14] Speaker A (unidentified): off. You're going to do the other one. The second one. I mean, where did that come from? I moved the major subdivision [2:37:21] Speaker F (unidentified): final. I moved the major subdivision final plan application for project 25 dash 27. Eventide subdivision is found incomplete in regard to the submission requirements and the application is tabled until the items identified by staff are fully submitted. Sorry, my bad. Postponed. I will read it again. I moved the major subdivision final plan an application for Project 25-27. Eventide subdivision is found incomplete in regard to the submission requirements and the application is postponed until the items identified by staff are submitted. Thank you. [2:37:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Okay. Any other comments? [2:38:02] Speaker S (unidentified): Can I comment on that? Yes, you can. [2:38:05] Speaker C (unidentified): My understanding is that the requirement was to submit the report, so that's the completion piece the incomplete piece is what you were talking about before which i had thought we were talking about a condition of approval to submit the data no [2:38:25] Speaker O (unidentified): we said we wanted to see that the data existed that's before we could call things complete and then we move on [2:38:32] Speaker K (unidentified): yeah i [2:38:34] Speaker A (unidentified): think it got confused because then we were also talking about what would go in the conditions [2:38:38] Speaker F (unidentified): of approval versus so it's kind of like a yeah basically the ordinance says you need to submit a hydrological report and part of that report shall be the following information which is not in that report therefore the report is incomplete is that a fair assessment correct yes so we [2:39:02] Speaker A (unidentified): just need those two well tests so however you're going to do it and we'll be all set we're going to have to vote on the [2:39:15] Speaker B (unidentified): open space waiver i mean yes you certainly you certainly [2:39:19] Speaker E (unidentified): probably should what dispense of the open space yeah well can we do that [2:39:29] Speaker F (unidentified): after we find it incomplete or do we need to do it before we find it [2:39:32] Speaker B (unidentified): incomplete well that was a preliminary requirement so you can do it now cuz your preliminary was complete except that you didn't make a determination on [2:39:41] Speaker A (unidentified): the open space we brought it back again right yeah we can do the waiver after we After we do this motion here. [2:39:49] Speaker E (unidentified): We'll definitely do the motion. Okay. Okay. All those in favor? [2:39:54] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. It is unanimous. Before we do this waiver, I have to ask a question. On a lot, is it eight? Can you bring that one up again, the one that has all the wetland on it? That one down there. How much of that 30,000 square feet is buildable? [2:40:23] Speaker C (unidentified): When you look at buildable land, it's really all the way to the road because you've got the driveway will extend all the way to the road. You've got the septic system that can go. So you see where the test pit is? It's inside of that front yard setback. So you have a structure building window,, and then you have the developable land beyond that, which basically goes all the way up to the road. So what I thought was the best method, which we kind of did in the field, you know, we looked at what is, you know, we mapped out where those side property lines were, and we all kind of stood out there and looked. I showed the board where the house would go, where the exterior wall would go, where the back wall would go, and just to show that it, You know, there's ample room on that lot. It's not going to be a big backyard. It's not going to be a lot that somebody wants, you know, a big swimming pool in the back or something. They won't choose that lot. But somebody that wants a little privacy from their neighbors, you know, because there is some wooded area on that lot that surrounds the wetland. So there's some benefits to that lot that maybe some of the other lots wouldn't have. [2:41:30] Speaker A (unidentified): I guess my – [2:41:32] Speaker O (unidentified): I'm interested in – I know. Sorry. All right, what is the answer to her question? Like how much of that is actually buildable of that 30,000? [2:41:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Do we know? Well, when you say buildable, you're talking about – Because you can't build on the – That's not wetland. [2:41:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. How's that? How much of it is not wetland? Because it doesn't say how much is. [2:41:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, it's probably in the 15,000 to 17,000 square foot range, which in the FR zone, the lots are 20,000 square feet. And you easily have at least 15,000 of buildable land on that lot. [2:42:02] Speaker A (unidentified): lot you give the shape of it though it's oh well the house might be a little different and it would [2:42:09] Speaker C (unidentified): cut back the tree line right i think you talked about that yeah so that tree line that's shown there 's basically some birches that are kind of right along the edge of the wetland that we would keep but there's kind of some scrubby stuff in front of it that we talked about taking back so that tree line that's on the plans there kind of represents the limit of vegetation so some of that would be just that shrub stuff and then there'd be a row of those bart's trees that kind of continue along the wetlands that are there now so this is going to have a homeowners yep yeah we submit a documentation for that all right [2:42:42] Speaker A (unidentified): in that documentation for that lot eight can there be something in the homeowners thing that basically tells them they cannot touch that wetland area because once they own it 's [2:42:55] Speaker C (unidentified): It's right on the subdivision plan that will be recorded. [2:42:57] Speaker A (unidentified): It's there, but once the people move in, that goes away. They don't see that anymore. [2:43:03] Speaker R (unidentified): You know what I mean? They don't see that. It's gone. It's kind of like now. It does, yeah. Whatever they want. I remember it was like you could put like a 25-foot house there. I can't remember what I was watching. [2:43:13] Speaker S (unidentified): Yeah. There wasn't much reason to touch that. No. No. [2:43:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, and I think, I mean, that information on the subdivision plan, I would think that would be the most prominent location that somebody would look, if they're purchasing Lot 8, if the code enforcement officer is issuing a permit on Lot 8, it's really the – it's a big prominent note right on that. [2:43:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I would just like some assurance that nothing can be built on it. [2:43:37] Speaker E (unidentified): We'll check the HOA documents. Yeah, can you just check that for me? [2:43:40] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm sorry. I know I got off the track a little bit here. Okay, we can go back to the – [2:43:45] Speaker P (unidentified): Before we – kind of related to open space, can we talk about the trails, the existing trails? [2:43:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Are those all staying? Yeah, I mean, other than the ones that are basically where the roads are going. [2:43:59] Speaker P (unidentified): What about the ones that are going directly through lots? I've lost the one that it was. [2:44:10] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, I guess what we could say is, yeah, I mean, for sure the ones that are in the dark green areas. Like 16. In the open space. [2:44:15] Speaker P (unidentified): Right through the middle. Like for 16, is that going to stay? No. Are they easements or are they just current trails? [2:44:23] Speaker T (unidentified): It's actually not a trail. [2:44:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you bring that closer to you? I'm not going to. Sorry. [2:44:30] Speaker T (unidentified): It's actually a dirt bike track for the land owner who owns the land originally. He built sort of a dirt bike track back there for his kids to ride his dirt bikes and four-wheelers. So it's not really a trail, so to speak. [2:44:47] Speaker P (unidentified): So then the trails that are staying are only the ones in dark green? or maybe those need to be redrawn so that we know which ones will be trails yeah it's really [2:44:59] Speaker C (unidentified): anything that's in the dark green so any trail that's in the open space area and the reason that we you know part of the reason that we did the orientation of the road the way that we did and we kind of looked at this on the sidewalk is so that the way that the road ends it basically ends at an existing substantial trail so that it's a very easy logical connection to just go straight off the end of the road you're not going to be crossing over you know a bunch of stormwater stuff and then from there it goes all the way back to the mountain division trail and it kind of [2:45:30] Speaker O (unidentified): crisscrosses there's loops and that's not the way right now it's showing cutting through lot 17 like in the top half right you've got dark green on one side dark green on the other and you've got a trail cutting right through lot 17 and i think that's emily's question is like we're not preserve it is that a trail is that a dirt bike path because you're just both of you told me two different things right so are we maintaining trails are we getting rid of dirt bike trucks [2:45:54] Speaker C (unidentified): we are maintaining trails that are located within the depicted open space but the portions of trails that run through deeded lots will not be maintained as trails so the trail actually starts on c8 [2:46:08] Speaker A (unidentified): that open space there right and not on the other side of the street at all it's going to start [2:46:12] Speaker S (unidentified): out there and go up okay yeah if you could and that's it and that's a substantial i mean [2:46:17] Speaker C (unidentified): that's what we walked down when we did the last site walk it's the widest we walked right through there and it kind of makes a turn and goes up a steep hill and continues on down so it's i mean you can almost drive a truck down there it's a pretty substantial okay yeah i'd just like to see [2:46:30] Speaker P (unidentified): that accurately drawn and then connected to the road so that it's clear that from the road you would be able to – technically, right now, you can't access that trail without a really big leap. [2:46:44] Speaker F (unidentified): And you are required to put that on the plan per the ordinance, the trail system? [2:46:50] Speaker C (unidentified): So you're just talking about the little connection from the end of the road to where – [2:46:53] Speaker F (unidentified): Whatever the trail system is. [2:46:54] Speaker P (unidentified): Right, and then remove the ones that are not going to be existing anymore. [2:46:57] Speaker C (unidentified): So delete the existing trails that are – [2:47:00] Speaker P (unidentified): Only show what the planned trails are. Those are just dirt bikes. [2:47:03] Speaker A (unidentified): If it's not a trail, we don't want to see it. [2:47:05] Speaker P (unidentified): just because it is a requirement to have trails in the open space absolutely yeah and this is i [2:47:11] Speaker C (unidentified): mean of all the subdivisions we've done this one has the most trails okay we'll go back to the [2:47:17] Speaker A (unidentified): you all said emily yes the [2:47:23] Speaker B (unidentified): other one sorry want [2:47:35] Speaker F (unidentified): me to make the motion and then we can discuss yep great please i move to approve the waiver request of section 129 11 k6b minimum open space requirement to reduce the required open space from 16.21 to 13.34 acres my [2:47:56] Speaker A (unidentified): second okay we have a motion second and a discussion on the open space requirement going back to let's see can we see the pictures again please yeah the plans pitches can [2:48:34] Speaker P (unidentified): i ask a question about open space lot 17 is i don't know 5 000 square feet larger than the other ones is there a reason that you decided not to connect the open space in the north side of the land just [2:48:52] Speaker C (unidentified): along the property boundary there yeah i don't know i can't think of a reason that reason for that if that would be part of the open space [2:49:12] Speaker P (unidentified): so I'm trying to be sensitive to the fact that there is a new ordinance that would allow you to be with you'd be within like 10,000 square feet of that [2:49:21] Speaker C (unidentified): new ordinance that's where we are now currently I think we're within 10,000 square feet of meeting that current ordinance I [2:49:33] Speaker R (unidentified): had a question on how close we actually were during preliminary ever brought up that on river road that section open space area one that the requirement as I read it afterwards requires it to be at least 50 feet wide to be counted I think it has [2:49:54] Speaker P (unidentified): to be 50 I looked at this as well in detail 50 feet and 10,000 so if it's less than 10,000 square foot and has a minimum distance of 50,000 or less so if it's an and right it would have to you would have to have both but because this one is [2:50:14] Speaker E (unidentified): what 32 000 square feet it's sufficient size wise so it doesn't have to meet the 50 foot requirement the 50 feet is measured along the new road not river road so you're looking at 43.7 and some odd feet along River Road, but the length of that C1 arc is, what, 300 feet, 400 feet? So where the open space hits the road, it's got to be at least 50 feet and 10,000 square feet in size. So when you look at that, the road itself, the new road, even-tied road, that whole piece is the frontage. So that's, it exceeds 50 feet. So that's what's considered the width. Right, that's 50 feet, more than 50 feet in width, and then it has more than 10,000 square feet of area. [2:51:08] Speaker R (unidentified): All right, and then part two of my question would be, I understood the open space was supposed to be contiguous, and that one doesn't appear to be. [2:51:17] Speaker P (unidentified): 75% of it has to be. [Speaker E (unidentified): 75%, that's correct.] I looked at these same things. [2:51:22] Speaker E (unidentified): okay so I mean I think I think no matter what I think they're there except for that kind of included area that's got the wetlands and if they were able to wrap around a 5,000 extra feet that might be on lot 7 that's adjacent to the property boundary then that would connect those two and they would have all the open space requirements met under the new ordinance no under the [2:51:51] Speaker O (unidentified): previously. I thought we were like two acres short. [2:51:54] Speaker E (unidentified): No, I'm not talking about the waiver request. The reduction is underneath your authority, but the standards of what Emily's saying is that the open space, 75% of the open space has to be connected. And if we have extra lot area on lot 17, it doesn't necessarily have to be considered part of that lot then we can connect that open space behind that parcel at the boundary at the boundary also reducing the amount of open space reduction that's required by approximately 5 000 more feet getting you closer to where we would be in today's ordinance because there's a significant for getting right-of-way for the 2,700-foot road. What's the length? 1,700 feet? So the right-of-way is approximately 20,000 square feet. [2:53:00] Speaker C (unidentified): Right, and we're basically, you know, setting all the houses back from River Road, so they're further back than any other house. As you're driving down River Road, all the existing homes are there, and then these new homes are going to be behind them. [2:53:17] Speaker E (unidentified): So, I mean, I think the reduction – what would be the reduction, Natalie, on that if we added back that area, approximately 5,000 square feet, that is included in Lot 17? I'm making math. I can do math. Where's the waiver request information? [2:53:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, you need to – they're short 2.34 acres. [2:53:57] Speaker B (unidentified): It would be like 0.2 acres, right? 0.3 max. It's [2:54:05] Speaker A (unidentified): going to give them contiguous, but it's not going to give what they need. [2:54:09] Speaker F (unidentified): No,, no. They are short 2.34 acres per the old rules. Under the new rule, you need 50%. So they're short three-tenths of a percent if you were to apply the new calculation. [2:54:26] Speaker O (unidentified): If they were to take it back and then come forward. I mean, that is their choice. [2:54:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Or if they decide to adjust the plan to comply with the new rules and we grant the waiver on that basis, which would, I think, align with how the town council at least would hopefully look at it in terms of it not being waivable anymore. [2:54:48] Speaker C (unidentified): more if we were to reduce slot 17 to exactly 30 000 square feet or just above and try to take that 5700 square feet and put it into open space it would basically be a 18 foot wide strip from one side to the other which what we just talked about wouldn't count towards open space anyway [2:55:07] Speaker F (unidentified): technically if it's connected it would technically because the i was going to make a correction But the ordinance says in its smallest dimension, no less than 50 feet in its smallest dimension. [2:55:22] Speaker C (unidentified): So if you have a student that's 13. And 10,000 square feet. So in order to make it. I understand. So I'd have to do like basically a 50-foot wide little rectangle. Yes. And not a connecting bar, which is what we want to do to make it comply. And I don't think, yeah, I mean, we can do that if that's what you want. [2:55:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Take a little chunk out of it. Can you meet the new requirements? [2:55:44] Speaker C (unidentified): that is the question i don't believe so we i mean that's that's probably what we would have proposed because all of these lots are within 50 square feet 70 square feet of the minimum that lot 17 really i think was the only one that had some additional land area we could get really crazy with the lot frontages and just try and have all the lines crooked and stuff and to try and make it but [2:56:10] Speaker E (unidentified): just to say that the right away itself the right away he's showing the right away that would extend the road to the adjacent property if that ever happened in the future is showing 103 feet am I got that wrong from the pen to the pen from the pen at the end of the right away to the end of the property is 103 feet That's correct. [2:56:40] Speaker F (unidentified): And that has to be counted as not open space because of this future right-of-way? [2:56:44] Speaker E (unidentified): The right-of-way would be in the open space but would have to be made up on the adjacent property if it's lost. Right. That's the way we deal with it. But that whole length of that right-of-way, the length of the frontage of that potential open space exceeds 50 feet. So, you know, it's not disconnected. It's connecting the open space, and it meets the minimum access way of 50 feet. I don't see where – if they provided that connection. I mean, from the wetland, you're just seeing all the way through there. Make that green. Then there's going to be at least 50 feet along the right-of-way itself, which would meet the standard, even though the right-of-way isn't built out. But that's what the standard says. It's got to be along the right-of-way itself It has to be a minimum 50 feet in 10,000 square feet if it's if it's fragmented This would be a connection. So whatever the size would be if it's 5,000 extra feet. It's 5,000 extra feet, but it does Meet the 50 feet that's required and it would connect those two open space areas [2:57:56] Speaker F (unidentified): It could not because then you drop your lot size below the below the limit [2:58:01] Speaker E (unidentified): you can keep that lot size within 30,000 square feet [2:58:06] Speaker O (unidentified): we could take a razor blade to this map all night long the question is they came in under the previous standard where they're showing that they're over 2 acres short and so the question is not like what can they do to meet today's standard because today's standard they would then need so like my question was and it had been brought back in you know the preliminary plan was how do you meet the standard and you know I think the response was you know we build condos and so like that's I haven't seen an effort made to meet the standard as it sets for this project and my question is what would you do to meet the standard without requiring a waiver how many houses would we eliminate I mean at the end of the day it was a choice to buy this land with this amount of wetland and you know all of these that like those are all choices and then that's why I challenge when you come and say you know we're allowed to build this many houses we need a waiver for the for the green space well that's that should never be a given and it feels like that's because the [2:59:22] Speaker A (unidentified): requirement for the green spaces there already right in the ordinance exactly before the plan is drawn but [2:59:34] Speaker F (unidentified): that is also why we had talked about the arrangement with lot nine old lot nine not new lot nine no that's why they [2:59:42] Speaker O (unidentified): discussed that arrangement no the lawyers discussed as a group but we did [2:59:46] Speaker A (unidentified): but we wanted legals opinion on it which well what I see yeah I yeah I was a [2:59:51] Speaker F (unidentified): little surprised that we didn't didn't see more about maybe like a decision by the town council or something like that, or the town manager? [2:59:59] Speaker E (unidentified): The bottom line is that if it was included and then given back, then there would be a bigger requirement for public space. No, I understand. So this is sort of the idea of the generosity of the developer to give up this space and not include it as part of the subdivision. Now, again, that's not— [3:00:22] Speaker O (unidentified): That would have just meant we had to give a larger waiver. I mean, that's what I'm trying to ask is how do we get to not have, you know. You're right. [3:00:27] Speaker E (unidentified): So, I mean, the net result is that, you know, there's more open space that this developer is providing than what we would normally see in a conservation subdivision because of that option of having the second parcel given, not connected to your decision of the reduction in open space. Now, I mean, I'm not saying that you should, but I'm just saying that is part of the approval. [3:00:56] Speaker F (unidentified): Could you clarify one thing? When you say not connected to the decision, do you mean we cannot take that into account? That's what he means. Yes. Okay. [3:01:06] Speaker C (unidentified): I guess that's the part that I don't understand because I'm just reading from, you know, Attorney Ben McCall's response here. And, you know, basically he just says, I'll just read it, you know, because the basic premise of a conservation subdivision is to protect more land from development than would otherwise be developed and in part to protect natural habitats, I think there is plenty of justification for the planning board slightly reducing the required open space on site in return for another larger area being permanently conserved. I do not think the nullify or that tradeoff would nullify the intent or purpose of the conservation subdivision form itself. So I think that's what I took out of the attorney's memo is that he basically gave all of the authority back to the board, as it should be, to make your own decision on the waiver request. But that they felt it was keeping with the context of the conservation subdivision if, you know, the PRLT was going to, you know, receive this land in conservation as something that we are offering up as a justification to grant the waiver. with the understanding that it's not a requirement that we're not meeting the standard by putting this five acre piece into conservation we're providing a rationale for the board to feel that it's meeting the objectives of the conservation subdivision by granting the waiver and [3:02:36] Speaker O (unidentified): actually Bill Reiner was kind enough to quote me in that last meeting and I said ideally we'd have them coming in meeting open space standards but leaning into conflict I feel like we should be prioritizing open space over houses. Yep. [3:02:56] Speaker E (unidentified): I would have to adjust my comments that, you know, the attorney is saying that you can do that in the context of providing more open space with this approval and not having it as a condition of approval. [3:03:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, but, you know, we're saying, or somebody's saying, well, we are not saying, that basically, all right, so we're going to give that over to the presumptive land trust and they're going to make conditions that everybody can use it, whatever. Well, the land trust can change their mind at any time and close that property and it would not be open to the people who live across the tracks, so to speak, because it's not really public land, but they make the rules that what happens there. [3:03:45] Speaker E (unidentified): If they get the lot as conveyed as it currently stands, there is access on that property through this property, 9-1. So the access is not going to be dissolved unless the owner of the property removes that condition. PLTR is not going to adjust their – they're not going to take away that right to the public to access that land. because it's already part of that parcel right now. That's access and traveling across the lot 9-1 is part of the deed of 9. So unless somebody that owns it takes that away, that will be perpetuity with the development. PRTL is fully in support of the public using that land and would maintain it as part of their program. That's why we want to get it, the PRTL. If the town takes it, then we're going to be responsible for maintaining that, and we do not want to. [3:04:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you back off just so we can see a bigger picture? [3:05:00] Speaker B (unidentified): Like this? Not that big. [3:05:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I meant to go back to the development. How far is that last house out to the trail? And there is no trail that goes out there, by the way. [3:05:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, we would have them dedicate a trail specifically that would access that. [3:05:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, we don't have – where is – [3:05:24] Speaker O (unidentified): It's down here. [3:05:25] Speaker E (unidentified): It's a blanket easement of access. [3:05:31] Speaker A (unidentified): So there would have to be another trail at the end of that road somewhere there that went out to that. There's a trail there. Yeah, it's on the plan. There's a couple of trails. Are they really trails, though? Is that a dirt bike again? [3:05:45] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, we walked down quite a bit. It's pretty open. [3:05:47] Speaker A (unidentified): They're pretty wide. Yeah, but we didn't go to the trail. We didn't go to that mountain. [3:05:52] Speaker F (unidentified): We didn't walk that far. We did not walk that far, but we walked pretty far down. I think we went to that fork in the road that is up there at the top right. [3:06:01] Speaker A (unidentified): That's not the dirt bike one, right? This one? [3:06:03] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, up on the boat there. [3:06:05] Speaker F (unidentified): I think we stopped about there and then turned around because it was still a long way down. [3:06:08] Speaker R (unidentified): Steve, can you inform me on process for this? So let's say that this is something that we wanted to do. The way I was reading that letter was that, you know, he said this is kind of the avenue that the board could do. You know, you have the ability to waive this, so you can do that, but it can't be a portion of kind of the agreement. So right now, the property isn't already donated. And we, it doesn't sound like we can make it a condition that property get donated. So we have to like, so I guess from my end, what happens when we say, when I say like, oh yeah, you know, we should grant the open space waiver and that gets recorded. and then some period of time from now that deal with the land trust doesn't go through for whatever reason, is there any recourse to that? Because it's not a part of this agreement. [3:07:15] Speaker F (unidentified): The attorney did mention the following. If this is the direction that everyone wants to go, then I would suggest that the waiver be granted on the face of the plan and that as a condition of approval, the developer be required to record a declaration of restrictive covenant over map 1, lot 9 to be reviewed and approved by us in parentheses that permanently prohibits any development of the property. And then it says conservation easement will be another possibility, but finding a holder could be difficult, blah,, blah, all sorts of things. So it does say that we can add a condition of approval that prohibits development of that lot. [3:07:59] Speaker R (unidentified): Is that lot developable? [3:08:03] Speaker E (unidentified): There could be some upland on there, yeah. I mean, it's not out of the question. It's not an easy thing to develop. I mean, there's floodplain, there's upland, there's potential for a lot. But, again, I think, you know, the whole intent is not to develop it. [3:08:21] Speaker R (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, but just besides intent. You know, like are we trying to protect something from development that couldn't be developed? Not necessarily. [3:08:28] Speaker E (unidentified): I mean, we can develop with proper review authority resource protection land. The code office can issue a building permit for a single-family house in the floodplain if it meets certain criteria. So, you know, and that could be considered what we would call a nonconforming lot of record, which means it doesn't have road frontage. And theoretically, it could be developed, yes. [3:08:53] Speaker C (unidentified): And I will say back in 2016 or 17, I submitted a plan that had planning board review on Lazy Acres Lane, which is a similar lot to this, but just further up. And we had fully engineered a road that went down and crossed the tracks. We received a license from the main DOT to build a road over the tracks, and then we had development on the other side. And that project went through the planning board review process to meet the standards. So, not saying we would do that here, but to your point of, is it possible? I mean, we had a project. That was on Lazy Acres Lane. When was it? Probably 2017, 2016, around that time frame. [3:09:32] Speaker A (unidentified): A different kind of planning board then. [3:09:34] Speaker C (unidentified): That's what I'm saying. I don't know that we would do the same plan now, but I'm just saying. [3:09:37] Speaker A (unidentified): The ordinance, I'm sure, have changed. [3:09:39] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, well, we didn't have a conservation subdivision. Yeah, right. So, everything's changed. Okay. Yeah. [3:09:54] Speaker A (unidentified): I am torn. Only because, the reason I say, I get, all right, in the past, recent past, recent past, we've done similar things. We have done it on, behind Bob's Seafood, because now they have the path that goes down to, well, everybody goes down to Dawn of Ethelip and Puck from all over the place. We've done it with the- [3:10:25] Speaker F (unidentified): That didn't require a waiver, though. [3:10:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Up behind, no, I meant using the open, no. No, but they used that as open space because it was a trail. [3:10:34] Speaker F (unidentified): Because proximity to a public park. [3:10:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you know, it's a similar thing. We've allowed people to use, it was recreation areas. [3:10:43] Speaker O (unidentified): It wasn't open space. But this is their own area. [3:10:46] Speaker A (unidentified): But this is not going to be their own area now. Is it? No, they're going to give it away. It's not theirs anymore once they sign it off to the thing. If it's theirs, then we've got a problem because now it has to be counted and with the rest of the acreage. [3:11:02] Speaker C (unidentified): I think the way it's worded in here I think is a good solution because we have full control to put a conservation easement over on it and we have made commitments to offer it to PRLT. It has to go through their land committee. They have to accept it and there's a process there. Based on all the correspondence we've received from their executive director, they're very enthusiastic about receiving this lot. Like I said, they even want the rest of the open space if we're willing to give it to them. They see any opportunity to preserve land along the Presumptscott River, especially waterfront land, as a great opportunity for their mission, and I think it's a good partnering situation here, as opposed to the alternative, which is going back to preliminary approval, resubmitting a plan, just getting it re-approved as preliminary so we can shave 10,000 square feet off lots and come in and not need the waiver. I just think this is a much better long-term plan for open space. [3:11:58] Speaker O (unidentified): If that road were not there, if that trail were not there, we would not be having this conversation? If what? If the trail did not run through that lot, would we even be, like, right now the trail divides that 9 and 9-1, right? [3:12:15] Speaker P (unidentified): In the DOT land. [3:12:17] Speaker O (unidentified): And so, like, if that weren't there, we would be saying find more open space, right? That's the issue that I'm taking with this, and I hope you can understand and appreciate that,, like, all in, it feels like a shell game. And even if at the end of the day, presumptive land trust gets a good piece of land, like the path to this has been not – has not felt good. [3:12:50] Speaker R (unidentified): I don't disagree, but I guess, Dustin, and I realize I'm just circling back on something that was said earlier. Can you modify your plan to meet the new standard? standard because if you're meeting to Everett's point you know if we're looking at like what the council would look at and we have a new standard out there that we basically waive to the new standard rather than bringing you all the way back to the beginning because that's something you can do and we say okay let's skip that step let's waive can you meet the minimum of the new standard by modifying this plan and then we do the same thing you were going to do with that, you know, the land on the presumpt's got, and then that's the reason, you know, part of the reasoning there that we're waiving it. Am I articulating that? [3:13:39] Speaker F (unidentified): Plus or minus a couple hundred square feet. [3:13:41] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, we wouldn't need the waiver at that point, so I guess why would we have to? [3:13:43] Speaker F (unidentified): No, you would because you're performing under the old standard, but the reason we would be waiving it is because you meet the new standard, which we've done for other developments. [3:13:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, but in that scenario, we could just apply under the new standard. [3:13:57] Speaker R (unidentified): Well, I guess you could reapply through the new standard. [3:13:59] Speaker C (unidentified): all the way back yeah i mean yeah it would be a preliminary re-approval under the current standard i don't think it'd be a burdensome process to do that but i think this is better i think it's better for the town of windham i think it's better for the land trust so he's saying he [3:14:14] Speaker O (unidentified): wouldn't do the land trust if he went back to preliminary and got okay no there wouldn't be a reason to do it right no exactly and that's that's been the heart of it is like well what's [3:14:24] Speaker A (unidentified): the difference what is the difference between what you would have for open space and what the trust has for open space. What's the difference? What can you do on your open space, and what can or can't you do on theirs? Are there any restrictions on that? Well, there are. [3:14:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. I mean, if we continue to own the open space, we could build kayak storage on there or something, or we could regulate who gets to use it. We could put signs up and prohibit the public from using it. It could be just for the residents of the neighborhood. There's different things we could do if it was just part of the subdivision. And I guess I apologize if we're coming across like we're trying to get away with something here. I honestly think this is, you know, shaving down lots to meet a standard, and I think this is a better solution. [3:15:14] Speaker A (unidentified): It's actually eliminating lots because I don't think you could shave them down enough to meet. [3:15:19] Speaker O (unidentified): No, they won't eliminate lots. That's the thing is they'll build condos instead. That's what they've already told us. so that's where like this thing of oh well if we don't if we want to meet this standard then yeah it's just to say like oh well if we don't have to meet the new [3:15:36] Speaker S (unidentified): standard then we don't have to give up this to presumption there is a net [3:15:49] Speaker E (unidentified): NET RESIDENTIAL DENSITY, YOU KNOW, THAT NO MATTER WHAT KIND OF SUBDIVISION YOU'RE DOING, THEY HAVE THAT DENSITY. THAT'S BASED ON OUR ORDINANCE. THE DENSITY SAYS 17 UNITS AND YOU ONLY WANT THEM TO PROVIDE 15 LOTS, THEN THERE ARE TWO LOTS THAT COULD BE A DUPLEX UNDER OUR ORDINANCE. THEREFORE, THEY HAVE THE NUMBER OF UNITS [3:16:12] Speaker O (unidentified): that they want no i know they're completely allowed to do that and but that like that is the if we can't have then we will it was the concern and now it's if we can't if we don't get this waiver then we don't need to give this land to presumpt scott that's like that is not [3:16:33] Speaker C (unidentified): feeling good i think it's fine yeah all i'm saying is we might still choose to do so it becomes this [3:16:39] Speaker A (unidentified): is they want to go back to the beginning go but the new standard and they can meet it and they [3:16:42] Speaker O (unidentified): don't would they still need a waiver no but i mean it's like it's this whole like we want to do this out of the best interest and all of that and good faith and then it's like oh we don't have to do that okay we don't you know then why would we do it i mean i think that 's [3:16:54] Speaker A (unidentified): building i wouldn't have to no but it's like never mind it's fine i know what you say the [3:16:59] Speaker R (unidentified): current plan doesn't meet the new standard correct no so what would it take for the [3:17:02] Speaker C (unidentified): the current plan to meet the new standard we could make the road longer and shave off some of the lots and have it be a balancing act in the open space so we would end up with less open space than we have now because we would just make the road longer to offset the numbers in that direction [3:17:21] Speaker P (unidentified): it's just the way that it works like i don't know what to do so i guess i'm i don't feel like i'm feeling the same way as the rest of this what i'm hearing from the rest of the board where I think when if they donate this or make it so that it's not buildable it is meeting the intent of the open space whether I mean this is a business right they're in it for the business part whether we like it or not our job is to you know figure out if it makes the intent and if it meets the requirements as far as all the requirements no currently it's not but the requirements have changed while they're in the process I don't see a reason to make them go back just to move it around so they do meet the requirements, right? We can't stop them from building. We just can make sure they meet the requirements. I think they're meeting the intent by donating this. I would be fine with adding this to a conditional approval. It would be a waiver. And a waiver. And a waiver. But I would like to see the open spaces connected, and I would like to see some cohesive trail plans. [3:18:26] Speaker C (unidentified): lands yep yeah we can i guess that 18 foot strip we can connect the two even though it won't count [3:18:31] Speaker P (unidentified): it'll be but we'll cover by the open space it's more than the 10 000 minimum so it's still it [3:18:37] Speaker A (unidentified): counts because it's an and in there the only difference the only difference now then is the fact that it that piece of property out there does not belong to the subdivision therefore the people who live in there and have the use for that open space do not have the use of the Presumpscot River, because I'm not, unless, wait a minute, wait,, let me finish my statement. Unless the trust allows them to launch canoes from there, etc. Well, I mean, [3:19:09] Speaker E (unidentified): we're not talking about that. If you're just saying that the subdivision residents, they have all the rights to access that land. To walk on it. To walk on it. Now, whether or not Presumpscot Scott Land Trust would allow you to put kayaks in, that's a whole different ballgame that we haven't talked to them about. [3:19:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, which is I'm just saying the difference between if you're giving somebody open space that borders, a lot of it borders a nice river, but, oh, by the way, you can't access that river. [3:19:40] Speaker P (unidentified): An HOA might not let you either. Who knows? They might not. [3:19:45] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not a guarantee. But that would be the HOA belongs to them, though. You see what I'm saying? An HOA is made up of the people who own in there. [3:19:51] Speaker P (unidentified): they make the rules i don't think it has to be either so well i don't know i mean right that's it's not a guarantee is what i'm saying yeah sounds like a private contract issue to me [3:20:05] Speaker E (unidentified): not a decision factor well yeah i mean you know i think i think what emily said was is very much where i think the planning board should be because it should be looking at the intent there is definitely a request because they're underneath the old rules and you know i think that's up to the planning board to consider that but to try to you know come up with solutions and ways of how pltr would manage the land through this decision i think is the wrong direction I think the planning board needs to consider what the intent is of the ordinance what we're trying to do here And if I remember correctly through some of the discussions we've had when we were looking at the amendment Melissa indicated that she would like to see more open space as part of what takes place now whether it's prescriptive or a offer from the developer We're getting more open space for the town that is being managed by an organization that manages a lot of open space in this town. PRTL manages a lot of open space in this town, and they are an organization that has put a priority on trying to obtain riverfront property on Presumpt Scott River and lock it up in open space. And here is an opportunity for us to do that in conjunction with the developer that's willing to give up that development right and give up that property to PRTL. I'm just saying that 's the intent of the ordinance, and it meets those intents, for lack of a better term, the intent of the ordinance and the different intentions of what the town would like to see, what PLTL would like to see, and what the developer is willing to give in goodwill. Okay. [3:22:15] Speaker A (unidentified): So I think that, well, we haven't approved anything yet, that I guess let me ask. I'm going to ask. That's not what I think. I'm going to ask if the members of the board feel like they are, because we're just discussing this to death now, I think, if they think they're ready to make a decision now or would they like to wait because we do have to come back and make a decision on this when we come back. You have time to mull it over in your head or not. I'll decide on it now. What would you prefer? Leo, I'll start with you. Now at the next meeting. Right. Melissa? [3:23:09] Speaker O (unidentified): Indifferent, but as to when we talk on it, because I don't know that anything's going to change between now and the next meeting anyway. [3:23:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Emily, I know you're all set, right? [3:23:25] Speaker F (unidentified): Everett? I think I'm all set. Well, I'd like to ask a question again. Suppose you reclaim the 5,000 square feet for that one law, right? you are less than 10,000 square feet off from the new standard. Is that correct? You're almost at 50%, essentially. [3:23:48] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, we're at 49.7 now. [3:23:50] Speaker F (unidentified): You're at like 49.85 at that point. Yeah. Right, we're like 5,000 square feet under. [3:23:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Give up the house a lot on eight. We'll have to all weddle in. [3:24:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Build a single duplex, yes, that would be easy. Yes, I have what I need to make a decision. [3:24:06] Speaker A (unidentified): okay so I think the board is at a point where we can vote on this so your [3:24:17] Speaker B (unidentified): current motion on the table is to approve the waiver with conditions with [3:24:23] Speaker E (unidentified): conditions the waiver well we're looking at just the waiver does come with conditions I don't well you can yes you can the condition to the attorneys requirements of providing access across you can put conditions on a waiver because [3:24:57] Speaker A (unidentified): who owns who owns the trail who owns the mountain division trail connecting the [3:25:04] Speaker E (unidentified): open spaces so I mean I think that if the waiver request would be the adjustment, and the amount of the reduction in the open space provided. So, in other words, we're looking at 49.85%. What is that in acreage? That's the number. So, it's from 16.21% – 16.21 acres to what? [3:25:36] Speaker R (unidentified): It's the wrong one. Are you saying we have to wait because we need an exact number? [3:25:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, you're in the wrong – [3:25:43] Speaker E (unidentified): for the amount that's supposed to be provided to a number that's less than that's what the waiver [3:25:50] Speaker C (unidentified): is and that's all the waiver has to be for so we're adding 5 000 square feet to the open space out of lot 17 which is going to add 0.11 acres of open space and we're currently proposing to dedicate 1387 so that'll be increased to 1398. [3:26:09] Speaker E (unidentified): 1398 open space. So that would be what the [3:26:14] Speaker F (unidentified): waiver is. Want me to amend the waiver? Because I thought the language was very prescriptive. [3:26:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Bring that waiver up again please. [3:26:30] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah so it's from 16.2 to 13 point what? [3:26:37] Speaker F (unidentified): So I move to amend the motion then to change 13.87. [3:26:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, sorry. You wanted that number still. [3:26:53] Speaker C (unidentified): No, 1398 is what it's going to. [3:26:55] Speaker P (unidentified): Yeah, that's what he just said. [3:26:56] Speaker A (unidentified): No, he needed the other one. Oh, I'm sorry. No,, no. [3:26:58] Speaker F (unidentified): Do you remember? No, because then this number was wrong to begin with. Because if we're only 0.11 acres off, 0.11 would make it 0.45, not 0.98. So I just want to make sure we don't create trouble here, right? If 1398 is not right, you would need to make it. [3:27:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, so I had this number wrong. My bad. [3:27:20] Speaker E (unidentified): So it's 13.98 would be the result by adding that 5,700 square feet by connecting the open space. Great. [3:27:34] Speaker F (unidentified): So I move to amend the motion for the waiver request. TO CHANGE 13.34 ACRES TO 13.98 ACRES. [3:27:43] Speaker P (unidentified): I SECOND THAT. OKAY. [3:27:45] Speaker F (unidentified): WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND. WE NEED TO VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT FIRST. YES. [3:27:52] Speaker A (unidentified): YES. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR OF THE AMENDMENT? OKAY. NOW, WE NEED TO TAKE A VOTE ON THE MOTION AS AMENDED. [3:28:06] Speaker F (unidentified): and any discussion still right so how do we deal with the condition of approval that is recommended by the attorney because that is not part of the waiver that isn't but that would [3:28:15] Speaker E (unidentified): be part of the condition of approval at the final decision so it will be on the record and we'll add [3:28:22] Speaker B (unidentified): it to your next packet when they come back ready [3:28:28] Speaker F (unidentified): are we all in agreement on that okay [3:28:34] Speaker A (unidentified): all those opposed okay it passes all righty you went through that one okay so we're done with the waivers yeah we're not going to do the final because we didn't approve the completion [3:29:03] Speaker C (unidentified): the completeness so the so the only thing we're coming back with is a water test on two wells [3:29:11] Speaker A (unidentified): and updated drawings showing the connection the trails yeah cohesive [3:29:17] Speaker P (unidentified): trails because since they go into the land right there we'll show a connection [3:29:22] Speaker C (unidentified): from the end of the road just going straight okay behind so it'd be [3:29:26] Speaker P (unidentified): something to walk around cuz right now it all like dead ends and people's land you know make it usable okay that'd be nice to see did we you know what I did [3:29:34] Speaker A (unidentified): not see in there I did not see a letter anything from the fire department did [3:29:41] Speaker C (unidentified): I Did I miss it? Well, we had a development review team a long time ago. [3:29:43] Speaker A (unidentified): I know they were okay with the hammerhead. Yeah, but I don't know if I was seeing anything from the fire department. [3:29:46] Speaker B (unidentified): I can make sure that there's something in there. I do know that they're all set with the plans as they are. So I remember they made a note about the hammerhead in the first one, and you switched it. So they've seen it there. But we'll get something. [3:30:01] Speaker E (unidentified): So, again, the fire response and that amendment preceded – went afterwards, after he started this development project. So that was way back in – Yeah, I know. Back in December last – in February last year when we had our development team review meeting and the fire chief had some comments. So going forward, we'll see those comments in the record. Okay, good. So they've retooled their review process as well. [3:30:41] Speaker A (unidentified): So is this going to remain a private way? [3:30:44] Speaker C (unidentified): It's designed to be accepted if the town wants it. [3:30:48] Speaker E (unidentified): Right, we'll have to bring it to the council. [3:30:50] Speaker A (unidentified): And we're all set from public works is all set, plowing, et cetera? Yeah. Well, we don't know yet. We're hashing some stuff, but this has gone on for so long, [3:30:58] Speaker E (unidentified): it's kind of like trying to say that we don't know because that those are you know that 's really the stuff that we pulled together for the council for the council to make the determinant 9-11 m6 okay but the public work [3:31:12] Speaker B (unidentified): stricter had no additional comments and no oppositions to it being built to town [3:31:16] Speaker A (unidentified): standards right okay good that's good then and have you contacted the RSU I can guarantee they're going to want a cluster stop on River Road. [3:31:30] Speaker E (unidentified): If it's a public way and it doesn't have a cul-de-sac, then they'll have a – [3:31:35] Speaker A (unidentified): No, they don't have to. It'll be a cluster stop. [3:31:37] Speaker E (unidentified): It could be a cluster. It will be a cluster stop, yes. But, I mean, Bill Hanson's already been part of that review. So, I mean, he's aware. Okay. Absolutely. [3:31:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Because if that's the case, especially on River Road, you know, if it's going to be a cluster stop on River Road, there really should be some something down there a pull off or something or i was going to say a shelter but you guys go crazy you go crazy whenever i say put a bus shelter down there [3:32:06] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah we do have some shoulder space our mailbox is located down there as well so we've got kind of that long stretch where we've got the stormwater ponds on the left side so as people are exiting they'll be able to park on that right hand side okay good because that's that's for some [3:32:21] Speaker A (unidentified): little kids that's that's kind of a long walk for some little yep just stay there okay all righty so when well we don't know when they'll be back right nope it will be when they're able to do their hydro well it's all you anyway so you have another one you have to yeah i mean our set up natalie [3:32:43] Speaker C (unidentified): goal would be to get on for the seventh and we'll get that dated to you and get that plan updated dated tomorrow 9th all right [3:32:52] Speaker A (unidentified): so we don't have anything else so see you when you return thank you all right thank you thank you okay other business very brief we're going to have a very brief discussion very brief discussion on sidewalks we will not be doing any more sidewalks prior to meetings because it's going to be pitch blackout and that's not going to work. So we will probably be sticking with our Saturday. Excuse me. I would say even doing it off Monday doesn't work because it gets dark so early and some of you aren't even out of work yet. So I think we're going to have to stick with the 7 o'clock Saturday mornings if people can make it. We're going to have to wait and see. It's going to be initially but depending on we're probably going to have to change it again at some point in time and then there will be what i've discovered is having sidewalks in after a snowstorm is like ridiculous because then we end up having another one later on because guess what we couldn't go see anything so it's going to be dependent weather dependent as to when we do the sidewalks and we might have to move the sidewalks to further down i know we like to do it early on and early on so we get to see what it looks like no I don't mean the time I meant early on and you know like after they do the sketch play it's nice to be up you know so we might have to like move it so we don't hold them up that much and do like maybe you know like do the preliminary and then say okay now we'll do the sidewalk so just to get through the winter you know hopefully that works out okay and again and it's 930 I doubt if anybody's watching but we have one opening and one alternate open it on the planning board i read a lot of things i hear a lot of things people have a lot to say well this is the place to be if you really want to be part of developing wind because it will develop like it like it or not if you want to be part of the process and helping it to develop appropriately please fill out an application. So with that I am adjourned. Somebody motion. Move to adjourn. Second. Okay. All those in favor? We are adjourned. Thank you for joining us.