Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:01] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm calling to order the monthly meeting of the Town of York Historic District Commission. It is 7 o'clock on Tuesday, November 2nd. Whoops, November 3rd, like I said. Tuesday, November 3rd. Welcome to the monthly meeting of the York Historic District Commission. Those present, those watching at home, We are appointed by the Board of Selectmen to maintain the character of historic districts and landmarked buildings according to Article 12 of the town's zoning ordinances. Our job is to review applications for certificates of appropriateness, determining whether or not proposed changes to any structures designated in the ordinance are consistent with its guidelines. These guidelines are based on the Secretary of the Interior standards for the treatment of historic structures my name is scott stevens i chair the commission i'm joined by kari laprey john covino and donald rose we have a quorum because this is the whole commission at the moment patience horton is our recording secretary watching remotely i see that we have one person in the audience and i believe you have signed in right thank you very much first item on the agenda is public comment i will open a public hearing for anybody to express opinions views or whatever to us about anything not on the agenda not seeing anyone wanting to do so i will close the public hearing and we will begin our due process and i am a little bit behind here i need to get online to see our agenda because i didn't get a do you have a drink oh my word thank you all right i'll note that the agenda had some unfortunate errors on it which i hope didn't mislead people it says that our meeting is on september 1st at 5 30. then in the next paragraph it says it's on November 3rd at 7 p.m. so we will begin our due process the first item on the agenda is an application by Robert Burns of three stage neck Road map 57 lot 1-a proposal for new window inserts the project requires review since the parcel is in the historic district first I will ask if anybody has a conflict of interest on this application no chair says no conflicts of interest then I will ask if we have a complete application can we accept it as a complete application for consideration. Gus, this? Yes, we should discuss this.
[3:39] Speaker B (unidentified): We couldn't open the Acrobat file, and I tried various ways, but Don did.
[3:49] Speaker C (unidentified): The portfolio file is hard to open. You have to be an Adobe Acrobat to open any other software. PDF software doesn't seem to wanna work.
[3:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I had the same problem. them so one of us has been able to see the photographs are you sir are you here on that application by any chance I don't see anyone here I think we have to I don't think we can accept it as complete because three of us could not get at the application unfortunately this is a problem with the new platform and just for the record what it when I clicked on the file that or the folder that had the photographs it was a PDF and the program wanted me to download Adobe Acrobat which I already have and sent me in this doom loop of trying to open it being told I already had it so I couldn't open it so I couldn't open the file. I did try to get a consultation with IT at town hall, but that didn't happen yet. So I apologize to the applicant and we will get to this as soon as possible. So being unable to accept this, I guess we need a motion.
[5:17] Speaker B (unidentified): I move that we do not accept the application as complete as presented due to the computer issues we don't know yeah we don't know we can't tell
[5:32] Speaker A (unidentified): do we have a second to the motion i'll second is there any further discussion well i would i wish
[5:40] Speaker B (unidentified): we knew what it looked like i wonder should we i mean if one of us opened it should we look at it and tell them if there's something more we want to know i mean i think the biggest thing is that we need to know about the condition of the windows yeah we need to know what
[5:54] Speaker A (unidentified): the original windows are what their condition is details about details yes
[6:00] Speaker C (unidentified): photographs seem to show you what the windows are but in terms of their condition it's they're not up close they're all from a distance okay so and
[6:10] Speaker A (unidentified): and this is one where we might need a site visit so yeah we just don't have enough I'll get on this and speak to code speak to IT I mean we would
[6:26] Speaker B (unidentified): need to show that the windows couldn't be repaired right we need to see
[6:30] Speaker A (unidentified): evidence of what they are first of all details of what they are what their condition is be convinced they can't be repaired that might require a site visit it so I will ask that we vote on this motion aye chair votes aye so the next item on our agenda is a application by Matthew ban now 52 Freeman Street map 23 lot 44 proposal for demolition of a building older than 75 years pursuant to article 12.17 the project requires review under sec under section 12.17 i said seven before i'm sorry article 12.7 one 12.17 of the york zoning ordinance as the structure is not located in a historic district so i'll just remind us and the folks at home that under this provision of the ordinance our first job is to determine whether this structure has historic or architectural significance and in that if we feel it does it has sufficient historical or architectural significance we can seek an alternative to demolition with the owner has to be mutually acceptable and we can delay it up to 60 days to seek that alternative so does anybody have a conflict of interest on this application I do not no conflicts of interest can we accept the application as complete I need
[9:02] Speaker B (unidentified): a motion We should go back to having a checklist maybe of things. Perhaps. I move that it's complete for consideration.
[9:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have a second?
[9:15] Speaker B (unidentified): I can second that. We have a second. Is there discussion? I
[9:26] Speaker A (unidentified): don't think so. Discussion? Then I'll ask you to vote. Aye. Aye. Aye. Chair votes aye. so we will accept the application for consideration we have I believe someone here do you care to address us to add perhaps any information to what you presented in the application well first please identify yourself yeah I'm Matt
[9:55] Speaker D (unidentified): Banno I'm designed a new house for my clients Pat and Connie Scanlon on this property so the extent of the submission was the photo packet and to the point of getting things up online it was tough because it would only take one file so we just had to make a multi-page file to get you all the pictures because once we had one it would only accept one document i think that's just a glitch that probably gets worked up please yeah please give
[10:23] Speaker A (unidentified): feedback to code yeah and i think that's that was the problem with our other applicant and that they put it in a format that some for some reason yeah and it was demanding
[10:35] Speaker D (unidentified): software other software so i'm a lover of old houses this is a nice vernacular little cottage but you know kind of a carpenter-esque basic cottage i again i love older homes it just doesn't fit what the owners have owned it for a number of years and it's just quaint but doesn't fit nearly what they needed to do so they're planning to demolish it and I know this isn't a it's under article 1217 this isn't a design review but I think what we're putting forward will be an asset to the neighborhood and I mean, I can answer any technical questions if you have them, or you wanna talk about the pictures. Well,
[11:30] Speaker A (unidentified): I will start, not hearing any of my colleagues. The pictures depict a structure that's pretty sound. That is, it's not, it doesn't need to be, doesn't need drastic repairs, major repairs.
[11:47] Speaker D (unidentified): I would say structurally it has a number of issues,, and that, you know, as is most houses, dangerous stairs, low ceilings, as far as the historical fabric inside, a lot of it has been sort of removed over the years. I know that the owner's level buildings, but I think they're planning to keep four interior doors and reuse them as well as the original front door.
[12:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Please speak into the mic so our recording secretary can hear you. Yeah, I noticed the stairs. Sometimes when these come before us, there are code issues. They want to fix a house up, but to do the project, they have to bring it up to code, and that represents problems. I wondered if that were an issue.
[12:34] Speaker D (unidentified): I mean, this would be an issue in the sense that, you know, there would be such a renovation, you know, the value of the house, it would be a major kind of gut renovation. you'd have to bring the stairs would not meet anywhere near current codes you know settlement we're also proposing to make it less non-conforming so that's of benefit to the town it just doesn't suit the needs of what these owners want to do they've rented it to date and they have a lot of great memories in the house but they want to make it more of a full-time home and their daughters from california is moving back to be in the second unit and it just does not in any way spatially or you know conducive to their daughter living there with her family and her children and they want to move the story of the property forward but keep it the design again i know is enough issue here but we very much are you know using vernacular cottage design that i think
[13:42] Speaker A (unidentified): will fit in that's encouraging if it if it will be compatible with the neighborhood sure anybody else care to ask questions or comment the lead into
[13:57] Speaker C (unidentified): the mic please foundation basement you don't have anything that shows us what
[14:02] Speaker D (unidentified): that looks like it's a very small crawl space there's there's you know dry rye rot and moisture issues and kind of what you would expect from an old cottage that has a lot of mileage on it is it a set up for a year-round occupancy right now or is it seasonal it's year-round yeah I don't know this extent of insulation we didn't even explore that probably maybe it wasn't built as year-round possibly yeah I mean it's a I don't know the date it's clearly either late 19th early 20th century yeah that's I think the Assessor's guess and I haven't found anything that said it I just know that
[14:48] Speaker A (unidentified): it's older than 75 years a generic year put into the database there was apparently a huge building boom in York in 1900 yeah I don't disagree if we're We're throwing a dart. I'd say 1900. Yeah, I was going to say early 20th century.
[15:06] Speaker D (unidentified): You can see a lot of the windows are very low to the floor. It has the funky, cool cottage charm. I was saying earlier to the secretary, we grew up renting a cottage just behind this for like 10 years in the 70s and 80s, my family. So I know it and love it. it from my standpoint we're trying to respect the property in town of york i'm invested in it but this property i've been through a lot of old houses i love old houses it's just sadly i think it's it's just not going to work for these owners on any way shape or form for what they how they want to live for the years to come
[15:54] Speaker A (unidentified): other comments or questions i do have a letter so submitted testimony it's to harry norton and to my mind it deals more with planning or code issues than with historic district issues but i'm going to read it because it was submitted to me for this meeting to the york historic district commission i'm writing to express my concern regarding the proposed demolition of the historic home at 52 freeman street i received the public notice of hearing on friday 10 31. i own the abutting property 6 belmont avenue along the rear of the 52 freeman lot i live in massachusetts and wish to provide written comment based on inability to attend the 11-3 meeting in person. I'm disappointed by the prospect of losing a historic property that contributes to the character and architectural fabric of Freeman Street. At the same time, I recognize and respect the property owner's rights. As long as the building plan for the proposed project is in harmony and not incongruous with the historical and architectural values of the neighborhood, I have no standing to object on these grounds. My greater concern is what may follow the demolition. The existing home is located on a non-conforming grandfathered lot, and I believe it is important the demolition of the existing structure and effect... I'm sorry. Let me try this again. The existing home is located on a non-conforming grandfathered lot, and I believe it is important the demolition of the existing structure not effectively extend or expand non conforming conditions for future development the rear of the existing property 6 sits right on the property line but the roof line for that section is only about 7 feet high as this part of the home sits only 12 feet from the side of my home any construction higher than the existing elevation at the rear of the house will loom over the cottage at the back of my property furthermore if a multi-unit property is to be constructed it should comply with usage requirements inclusive of the finished garage at the rear of the 52 Freeman lot the current single-family house is used with a finished garage acting as an accessory dwelling were two units to be constructed in the new home the accessory dwelling would potentially leave three rentable units on a small lot with limited outdoor space, which is likely to have a negative impact on surrounding neighbors and the neighborhood. If demolition is approved, I respectfully ask the Commission and other applicable town boards and officials to ensure that any future construction complies with current setback and dimensional requirements to the fullest extent required by applicable ordinances and regulations. rather than assuming that the location or footprint of the existing historic structure establishes an entitlement for a replacement structure protecting historic properties is important but so too is ensuring that redevelopment is consistent with the standards that apply today and respects neighboring properties and the established character of the district thank you for considering these concerns as you review the proposal for 52 freeman street sincerely garrett mckinnon as i noted mr mckinnon's biggest concerns are factors that don't fall within our purview or the or the ordinance the 12.17 but i thought since he addressed it to us it should go into the record is there a shall we discuss the potential historical or architectural significance sure
[20:18] Speaker B (unidentified): since that's our main job here well as we always do in these cases we know that this is not in an established historic district I we should perhaps also acknowledge that this section of Freeman Street does have a number of houses that are still intact on it so you know there is a potential for a district but it doesn't hasn't obviously this would be a contributing building in a district if there was a district but individually it doesn't appear to have enough integrity you know to be individually as a summer
[21:05] Speaker A (unidentified): our cottage comments from either of our colleagues i would tend to echo what kari said it's sorry i
[21:15] Speaker C (unidentified): would i would tend to echo what kari said it just doesn't have anything that's particularly outstanding and it's been a kind of a hodgepodge of additions over the years i
[21:29] Speaker A (unidentified): would agree then i will entertain a motion oh
[21:35] Speaker B (unidentified): i just want to ask one more oh yeah no i just said Well, it's sort of a public hearing question, though, because I was going to ask him. Absolutely. I just was wondering whether you would consider putting a little zigzag sawtooth molding into your design.
[21:48] Speaker D (unidentified): We have on the rake. That's an active discussion.
[21:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Because it's kind of distinctive.
[21:55] Speaker D (unidentified): I would be in favor of that, yeah. I think that's... I mean, that's... I know you have access to the plans. We do have some artistic renderings, you know, for basically... what we're trying to do, so.
[22:13] Speaker A (unidentified): In this case, we have no authority over that, but.
[22:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Just as a fellow building lover. Yeah,. Old building lover.
[22:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I'm glad you're making that effort.
[22:27] Speaker D (unidentified): But I love the little craft, very simple, carpenter-esque, just that little sawtooth on that double one-by rake and eave box, Dave, yeah.
[22:48] Speaker B (unidentified): I will make a motion, if you wish.
[22:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Please make it into the microphone.
[22:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Oh, I move that the commission at its public meeting on November 3rd, 2026, determined pursuant to section 12, 17.2 of the zoning ordinance of the town of York, that the house located at 52 Freeman Street, which is before the commission by application of Matthew Banno for its demolition, and which is not included in the historic district but is 75 years old, lacks historical or architectural significance sufficient for the commission to pursue alternatives to demolition.
[23:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Do I have a second to the motion?
[23:35] Speaker C (unidentified): I will second that motion.
[23:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Mr. Rose seconds. Is there further discussion? If not, I'll ask that you vote. Mr. Covino? Aye. Aye. Aye. Chair votes aye. thank you very much thank you for getting some minutes out I have to say I didn't get a chance to read oh I know I just but yeah so let's let's postpone
[24:11] Speaker B (unidentified): those to the next meeting think that's okay I do and we need to talk to the town hall about how we're supposed to be doing it because I was under the impression that we were going to get them from the town but maybe we're supposed to give them to the town and then get them thanks a lot thank you know what I mean so we just need a little more yes we need to we need to
[24:38] Speaker A (unidentified): straighten it out okay
[24:42] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah as long as you didn't feel that we needed to get them on the record I don't think there was really anything specific in them that needed to be it's
[24:54] Speaker A (unidentified): one of the topics i'll take up as soon as i can speak to them okay
[24:58] Speaker B (unidentified): and then what is the process for getting them onto the website once they're approved is the next step because we don't have very many minutes like attached to our meeting files and that might
[25:12] Speaker D (unidentified): be our fault but i'm not sure i thought there was one meeting in there in the last few that we never
[25:20] Speaker A (unidentified): approval minutes right I think they're I'm not sure but we had some catch-up to do that yeah for sure I'm going to try a little bit different procedure next time from they came from a training session I was going through my overstuffed files and discarding and keeping and I have a fair amount of training material from the years, for those listening at home, we're supposed to attend annual training put on by the Maine Historic Preservation Commission. And one was a variation of the format for a meeting that I thought might be an improvement. So I'll share it with you in advance if you'd like to see it, but I hope you'll bear with me while I experiment a little with a different format. Just it's not hugely different. and this is kind of a legal format, but it just builds in some back and forth with applicants and potentially with people providing testimony.
[26:31] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay, not just the strict.
[26:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah,, you've said I had your piece, now we deliberate, yeah, so. Okay. And I think we've seen some need for that. Yes. I also want to remind members that we told, at our last special meeting, we told the applicants we would give them some written feedback, somewhat similar to a finding of fact. I wanna thank Kari for contributing some notes. I'm going to do that. Again, if you'd like to see those before I submit them, I'm happy to do it there. Since they're coming from the Commission in general, I can share them with you. Sure. Okay.
[27:14] Speaker C (unidentified): You probably don't need to send them to me
[27:19] Speaker A (unidentified): because i'm right oh that's right and we talked about providing some thoughts to the planning board on the kingsbury house the development around that just want to remind everybody that will probably be coming before the planning board again this month so we need to compose that again i may lean on you carrie and we can draft something and send it around
[28:03] Speaker B (unidentified): okay should we attend should someone attend the meeting or you think just send them yeah i'll
[28:09] Speaker A (unidentified): i will i think i mean certainly one of us should be there to present our findings aloud not simply hand them a letter and it might be good for another person to be there in support or whatever but we'll we'll work that out i seem to remember the 22nd as being a potential meeting date i'll find out and let you know does anybody have was that was con
[28:37] Speaker B (unidentified): those were comments on proposed on the proposed design of the yeah not them
[28:45] Speaker A (unidentified): that's a demolition of that no that will have to come before us right we can't
[28:50] Speaker B (unidentified): we can't
Unfinished Business
New Business
[28:55] Speaker A (unidentified): presuppose that no we're not presuming any decision about that is there any new business old business and I will entertain a motion to adjourn I move we adjourn at
[29:24] Speaker C (unidentified): on this day Tuesday November 3rd
[29:27] Speaker A (unidentified): do I have a second for that motion [Speaker C (unidentified): second] Is there any discussion? Then I'll ask you to vote.