← Back to MaineScanner

Berwick Planning Board Approves Energetics Manufacturing Conditional Use

2026-10-29 · 1h 15m · Source: Planning Board Meeting • October 29, 2026 (Berwick BCTV22 (YouTube))
Speaker identification was not available for this meeting (plain auto-generated captions only) -- this transcript is not broken out by speaker. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Good evening, everybody. Welcome to the town of Berwick Planning Board meeting. This is a special extra meeting on Thursday, October 29th. If we could all please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:15] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:30] [clears throat] [0:32] All right, and I will introduce my board members. To my left, I have Jeff Brooks. You will be a voting member tonight, Mr. Brooks. I have George Classen, vice chair. Rick Raines, to my right, I have Nile Shore, Daniel Hook, Terry Wilson, our code enforcement officer is here, and James Bellissimo. I think he's still just the town planner is also here. [0:54] It's the formal title, just the planner. [0:55] Just the town planner. moving on to the approval of minutes for October 15th. I do have one thing that I think should be added. it is mentioned in here when I recused myself, but there was a point when I did resume the chair, and I think that should be added in there. So, [1:16] Okay. [1:16] does anybody else have any other amendments? [1:20] Yes. the piece where we talked, you know, we were talking about the third party review of Lexi Must Go was talking about the third party review. That was requested. and it kind of makes it sound the way the minutes are now that the board requested it, and the board did not request it. [1:42] So, [1:43] Which one was that under? Sorry. [1:45] you [1:51] Cuz we had Megan's Meadow, which was which was approved, and then we had Northland Drive. [1:57] Well, I can read it to you if you like. [1:59] Yeah. [2:00] The board recommended that no building permits be issued after the first six lots until our owners association documents are provided. A third party review has been requested. [2:08] Oh, okay. [2:09] And then it says James Felissimo revised pedestrian circulation. So, you know, that makes it sound like the board requested this and the board did not request this third party review. So, you know, I would say we should replace it with Staff reported that a third party review had been requested by staff on October 9th, 2026. [2:33] no board motion or vote authorized the review. [2:37] Perfect. Does that sound accurate? I was not on that board for that. [2:42] Yeah, I mean it could be another discussion for information items about what we want to do procedurally, but [2:47] Okay. [2:47] we should talk about that. [2:49] In reflection of this like or just in general? [2:53] I just in terms of procedure. [2:57] I agree. [2:58] Procedure for third party reviews? Okay. [3:00] I want that on the agenda for a future meeting so we can discuss that. [3:04] Okay, we can discuss it today. [3:06] Excellent. [3:07] Yeah. so we'll so we'll have that amendment. Also, so I'm looking for a motion to approve as amended. [3:17] I will make that a motion. [3:19] All right. [3:19] Second. [3:20] All right, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? No, all in favor of approval as amended. [3:26] Perfect. [3:27] I'm going to abstain. [3:28] You're abstaining, okay. Daniel abstain. [3:36] All right, move it a lot of people are joining, but these are all [3:41] I [3:41] Jensen Hughes people. [3:42] they're all I can't actually see but this is they're there if you have questions that [3:47] Perfect. [3:48] that I can verify. [3:48] Okay, I'm just wondering if any of them are here for public comment, that's all. We're going to open up public comment. I doubt they are. Usually we would get like a heads up. James would know if somebody was on Zoom for public comment. so we'll just skip this first public comment actually because there's nobody here and these are all engineers. [4:09] We have no public hearings tonight and we're going to move on to unfinished business. So, unfinished business for the conditional use at 500 [clears throat] Portland Street, Energetics Manufacturing R&D. This is in the industrial zone at the RCI zone. Oh, R&D industrial RCI zone. map R72 lot 17, [4:30] General Biological Corporation DBA AT Process Technologies. [4:36] Come on up. [4:40] So, just start off you know, thank you so much for all the time and thought put into this so far and special thank you for the extra meeting. I really appreciate it. I have a little spiel, but it is in the packet and there's no one here. So, would you like me to run through that? [4:56] I So, I read it and I thought it was so good. I mean, I don't think you need to read it in its entirety. Did everybody have a chance to read ATP's basically letter to the planning board? [5:08] I have not. [5:09] Okay, perfect. Why don't you give us a an outline of it cuz I thought it was [5:13] first introduce yourself to the public, please? Thank you. [5:15] David Zazeski, CTO and co-founder of ATP/General Biological. yeah, sure. So, high-level things Yeah, and yeah, thank you so much. the big the big the big points that I just wanted to, you know, bring up front is it's a very highly regulated space. there are many, agencies and departments that oversee us and who we have engaged with at a high level, but can't really get into much more detail with until we have confidence that we can occupy the site. [5:44] I have attached a sort of summary of like all of those agencies that regulate us, what parts they oversee, what enforcement authority they have, what ongoing compliance tasks they add, and at what stage they kick in in the packet. second part was that you know, I just wanted to highlight that the this is an R&D an R&D site to start. [6:05] You know, it's manufacturing equipment manufacturing, but it early on it will be equipment prototyping and development. And so, this means two things. One, it means that a lot of the details are not yet firm. which, you know, is not so great from a planning board perspective, but two, it means that a lot of the details are not firm so that they can be changed to accommodate the requirements of the zone and the requests of the community. [6:29] [6:30] [clears throat] [6:30] and then the last thing was that since we started this process a few months ago, we've had a lot of really encouraging success both in the lab and in the government. And we have several contracts agreements ready to execute with different offices within the Department of War for which we need a site. and one of the items that under the means we're under DCMA [6:52] regulatory framework basically from day one, it means we need that full earth covered magazine. which means that we need to get some concrete in the ground soon. So, this is why I appreciate the special meeting. And once we, you know, come to the set of conditions that we all agree on, Terry will be hearing from me shortly. [7:12] And yeah, just hit high-level points from like th- things that I felt I didn't do a good job of addressing last time. On noise, you know, I didn't have a clear answer there. I laid out basically to comply with the standard of the zone, assuming that the source of noise is on the test pad and the closest area of the lot line is about 640 ft, the equipment would need to be louder than 131 decibels, which is basically jackhammer or close range ambulance siren, which I can promise it will be much quieter than that. [7:42] although we are in an industrial zone, we do have we acknowledge we have residential neighbors. and you know, although that standard doesn't apply in this case, it's useful guidance. So, the from the test pad to the the nearest residential abutting lot is about 710 ft, which would mean that if direct line of sight, that equipment would need to be emitting about 117 decibels to register 60 decibels at that lot line. [8:07] which is a according to Google about as loud as a live rock concert. but between us, the pad, and that abutting line, there is a 19-ft earthen berm, two buildings, and a stand of trees. So, actually it would have to be substantially louder than that. And, you know, as we're only operating in the day, so that nighttime noise standard doesn't apply. On the environmental impact, attached some notes that Neil had prepared, basically outlining the correspondence that was had with IF&W back in 2020, [8:36] where they basically said that they did not have any concerns with regards to essential habitats or protected species within the envelope of development which we're staying in. highlighted some basically statistics around hazmat transportation. not with the goal of saying that this is not dangerous, but with the goal of saying that with the appropriate controls, hazardous materials can be handled safely, routinely, and are every day. [9:01] Can I just interrupt? Was this packet fully full packet made available to the public? [9:06] Okay. [9:07] Cuz I thought it was it was eye-opening the research that you put into it. talking about cuz one of the a letter that we got was about the transportation of hazardous materials. And when you really broke down like how much hazardous materials are transported in the United States every year, how much you know, how many incidents there are like over the last 10 years, there was like it was a very small it was like a handful in 10 years out of millions of pounds of [9:38] energetics transported. [9:40] [laughter] [9:42] So, I'm glad that the public has an opportunity to see that because it was educational for me, so I'm sure it would be educational for them. [9:49] Yeah. No, it's it's it's always a I mean, I personally really like DOT transport regs and hazmat stuff, but it's just always eye-opening to see how common hazmat is everywhere, even though it's usually not labeled with the actual chemical name. You know, if you're walking down an aisle in Home Depot, and spotting, "Wow, there's a lot of stuff in here." and how much is routinely moved around especially under limited quantity exemptions which are those diamonds with the white stripe in the middle the black on it. [10:15] So, you might even like if you get an Amazon package with that and there's hazardous materials in there. [10:19] Yeah. [10:20] But, What else did I have? Oh, there's a there's an attachment in here about the physical security plan. the most important section of that is up front where the standards are listed. I then wrote a memo of like this is our current plan as of this moment. It is possible that a DCMA examiner will say change X, Y, and Z but the standards that apply will not change. [10:41] and a lot of those in the PDF version of this are viewable they're public. I included a the quotes we have for insurance that we intend to bind once we take occupancy of the site. which I acknowledge the quotes are expired but we you know, it's put this together a while ago so we're in the process of renewing those. [11:03] Want to call out that those were created with the insurance broker through detailed review of our you know, intended process the chemicals we intend to have on site their quantities. and that the both policies are through what's called a surplus lines insurer which is an insurer that specializes in weird stuff. Un- unusual risk. [11:24] and the pollution policy specifically kicks in in three different situations. One is paying for clean up injury or property damage and legal defense in the case of a release on the property or if it migrates off into the soil, ground water, or neighboring land. it covers it both if a neighbor, an agency, or any third party makes a claim against us. [11:49] It also kicks in even if there is no claim if we discover our own contamination which a lot of policies don't and that creates weird incentives. it covers releases for the company's materials in transit if a spill occurs. Usually that's the liability of the carrier but if it can be shown that we improperly packed something or did not declare something in the right way it kicks in there. [12:11] And then it also covers pollution that arises from our waste even after it's been sent to a offsite facility. Because under RCRA EPA rules, the generator has responsibility from cradle to grave is what the statute actually says. And then way in the back there is the engagement that we have with Green Site Services for spill response [12:33] and whom we're also working with for the spill response plan stormwater monitoring and groundwater monitoring programs. Those are not complete yet, so they're not in here. But we've engaged with them with that. And they were selected because they have a service center in Dover. and we wanted to find basically the closest possible responders. [12:54] And the external hazard analysis from Jensen Hughes is finalized cuz I know that was asked about last time and it's in there. And also joining us on the call are our is our team from Jensen Hughes who are have been our advisers and partners and assisted us with basically every aspect of this project. collectively they've bring decades of experience with explosives, hazardous material safety, and emergency response planning. [13:18] And I just want to make sure that any and all questions get answered as fully as anybody wants basically. So, to the extent that I can answer, they certainly are able to. So, I don't know if if the Jensen Hughes team wants to introduce themselves [13:37] They're all on mute and off camera. Oh, there they are. [13:40] [laughter] [13:41] Hey. [13:42] Feel like I'm at work. [13:43] Hi. [13:44] Hi. I am Hi. We're We're all coming on. [13:49] There you are. [13:52] If you want to see our faces, we can totally stay this way. I just wanted to step in and say hello. First of all, thank you guys for the opportunity for letting us join you tonight. We appreciate it. this has been probably the most professional town hall I've ever attended, so kudos to you. [14:05] Oh, wow. [14:05] yeah. [laughter] Strong work, Barwick. My name is Preston Dewey. I'm a certified explosive safety officer and system safety engineer. come from about a decade or so of experience with the Department of Defense. Before that, I was a paramedic. so, yeah, very community-driven person by default, not just an engineer. [14:27] actually care about the safety of these operations and assuring their safety. So, I'll step off and let my colleagues introduce themselves. Elaine? [14:36] Thank you. I'm also the co-co-lead for the CBRNE group at Jensen Hughes, the chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, and explosive safety. I too did about 20 years as a paramedic and firefighter and a hazmat specialist. So, also used to serving the community. [14:57] I was also the operations lead for a very large army program that safely destroyed chemical weapons stockpile in Kentucky. And of course, I mean, we the whole team here we kind of share a lot of experience with DOD. So, I'm going to go ahead and let Matt Orwig be the one to speak. [15:21] Hello, everyone. Matt Harper, Jensen Hughes, over 30 years as a technology generalist specializing in integrated security platforms for military design-build projects. Thank you for having me. Leonard? [15:35] bringing up the rear of this introductory sequence. I'm Leonard Deering. I'm a certified emergency manager with more than 40 years in the fire service. highest [clears throat] rank held was a deputy fire chief over training and operations. served in fire departments as small as eight and as big as 1,500. [15:56] And my specialty is emergency planning. And I'll be doing the emergency plans for the site that meet all state, applicable local, and even Department of Energy requirements for safe operation of the plant. All the emergency planning that will pass through me first, then on to the specialists you see here with the background in CBRN and energetics. [16:17] Thank you for having us tonight. [16:19] Thank you. [16:20] Thanks. [16:21] Very nice. I'm sure you guys had a chance to review that the Jensen and Hughes study, which was awesome. Also full of chock-full of information that was very helpful. [16:35] Are you guys looking for me to do something? [16:37] [laughter] [16:38] so were there things in your notes? I was looking at the South Berwick cuz South Berwick sent that memo at the end of September, it looked like. I was looking at their [16:49] You want me to read it? [16:50] The South Berwick one? Yeah. It's right here. Oh, yeah. I read it. were have we sent over any more information to them or are they just relying on us to kind of take care of their concerns here? I just [17:06] From the South Berwick Water District? [17:08] Yeah, I just didn't know if they got the this updated packet. [17:12] I think they probably follow along. [17:15] I think so. I So I had one of the South Berwick town council members reach out and meet with me just to answer questions and whatever. And they she said that they fully supported our decision and thought that we were handling it fine. Just [17:33] They had some proposed conditions. I think a lot of them, if not I don't know if every single one verbatim was made it to the conditions, but I think a lot of it has made it into the proposed conditions. [17:45] Okay. I thought so, too. there were there was I forget what it was that I had made a note of it of what didn't make it to the conditions, but was there a reason that we didn't put that in conditions or [17:58] I guess I'd have to look at what that note was cuz I don't recall it off the top of my head. [18:05] They're they wanted to limit the quantity of RDX stored. [18:09] Yeah, and that's in the condition. [18:10] That's in there. contaminant of testing operations require all areas where RDX is manufactured, handled, or tested to utilize impervious surfaces and secondary containment. I think you have that, right? It sound It sounded like the chemical storage and the test pad both have [18:27] That's That's correct. [18:29] The skid also has a built-in spill tray, so technically it's tertiary containment on the pad, but [18:35] all solid and liquid waste associated with RDX production or testing activities be properly characterized, stored, removed from site by licensed contractors at regular intervals. I think that's maybe not necessarily a condition, but part of the plan. [18:52] Yeah. [18:52] Emergency response planning. we have a full professional team on that. was it stormwater monitoring that didn't get in there? Development and maintenance of a stormwater monitoring program including sampling protocols, reporting requirements [19:07] That is That is That is a condition [19:10] It is in there. Okay. And then require the use and maintenance of appropriate track-out prevention measures including personnel and equipment decontamination practices where warranted to minimize the potential migration of RDX containing materials [19:26] That was the That was the one cuz from my understanding they were not I don't think there'd be RDX being tracked out, right? That would be [19:34] Yeah, so I mean on the on the pad itself the stormwater the SWP, the stormwater pollution prevention plan. Basically, the way that would work is that whenever it rains the pad's going to fill up with rain. There'll have to actually be testing and logging of the water that's in there before any discharge. if there's ever enough RDX on the ground that people can track it out on their boots, we I mean that's bad. [19:56] That's like you have to We're going to have that cleaned up by a spill responder there. So [20:01] Okay. [20:03] It's something that we can institute, but I mean I don't I if that's like basically washed down in there, we can do that. and then that water would be covered under the SWP as well, but [20:17] Yeah, I think [20:18] It's kind of a It's like a sort of a If this was considered manufacturing that was permanently installed, we would be required by state law to have that pollution prevention plan in there anyway. It's a little bit of a gray area because the stuff is not ever permanently there. It's coming out and then being removed. It's not a problem to do. We have one in Louisiana. It's pretty standard practice. [20:38] So, that's fine. Fine with us. [20:40] Well, if I mean, if it's not a big deal, we can put it in and that would completely satisfy a South Berwick Water District, which we have much respect for and we're within like 500 ft of them, right? [20:52] We're talking about the [20:55] personnel and equipment decontamination. [20:57] So, they're they're going to wash down, do a wash out or wash down. [21:01] yeah, it says [21:03] as necessary. [21:04] require the use and maintenance of appropriate track out prevention measures, including personnel and equipment decontamination practices where warranted to minimize the potential migration of RDX containing materials from production and testing areas. [21:18] And what are you proposing to do? [21:20] I don't have a concrete plan there because I'm trying to think of like what whether that would actually make it not worse, but just generate more water that would have to be discharged. If like that was a condition that was applied, what I would do just standing here right now is everything would get washed down before leaving the pad and then the pad is not, you know, free discharging. You have to manually discharge that. [21:42] That water would get tested prior to discharge. [21:44] Right. [21:44] The only reason I'm hesitant there is because I think wash down water is treated separately from storm water under most permitting. I 'll have to think about that, but it can continue. [21:52] Doesn't he have any [21:53] It's as far as water, it seems like they're more [21:57] Yeah. Yeah. [22:01] I You're opposed to Civil Consultants of New England. I think it sounds like South Berwick is more concerned with individual and individual like vehicles like tracking RDX materials, which I don't think is really applicable or appropriate to this one since it's not something that's being manufactured. If it was an RDX manufacturing facility, I could see something like that being applicable. [22:25] For this one since it's really the manufacturing of those components and not the RDX itself, I don't think it's significant enough or, you know, prevalent enough on site or in the facilities that it would it would make sense to have those inside any of the areas. Like David was saying, the test pad would be the only place for it and that's that's kind of already all encompassed with testing and everything. [22:50] So [22:51] Okay. That's yeah, kind of what I was thinking. And then I mean, is it really [22:58] Yeah, is it necessary? [22:59] Well, that's what I'm thinking too, is it necessary? And is it something that the water department themselves would be concerned with also? Or is it just a general concern? It's not like, you know, [23:11] Do we make it a tangential condition if RDX is found in sufficient quantities in the water beneath the test pad? [23:21] I don't think we're testing water beneath the test pad, though. [23:24] Well, I mean, this is like the storm water that gets contained. [23:26] Oh, yeah,, yeah. [23:27] Yeah, cuz that would imply some failure of control elsewhere. [23:30] Yeah, that if sufficient quantity of RDX is found in the storm water that [23:35] Right, then it's getting out, yeah. [23:37] And then the sufficient quantity is a measurable quantity of any kind, just a trace. [23:41] In that case, a like this hazmat response wash down response would be required to be [23:48] That makes sense. That makes sense. Are you writing that down? Are you writing something else [23:53] Is there a wash down instruction entrance to prevent track out? I'm not [23:57] I would think it would be washed down before you leave, but I'm just [24:00] That would take care of the track out as well. [24:03] Yeah. [24:03] Okay. [24:04] Yeah. Cuz it would just wash down the container. [24:07] plan? [24:08] we can put [24:09] I was going to say something I did want to jump in here. [24:11] Yeah, no, please do. Please do. [24:13] Awesome. what one of the things so we address that two ways actually with the with the site safety plan the and as well as the emergency plan. So both of those kind of approach that potential like concern, [clears throat] I guess, in two ways. part of that is the operational rigor that we attach to the site safety plan by virtue of the fact that these are things that we have to do to keep that safe. [24:36] And the other part is the emergency plan. The way that we address that is it's required to have clean work procedures. So, in other words, housekeeping is required as they work. and that's a normal lab procedure as well, like clean bench, clean work. But that is required of the energetics. That's a step that General Biologicals is taking anyway. The second way that we address that [24:58] is through personal protective equipment. So, typically within these operations, personal protective equipment is worn and it's disposed of properly as opposed to tracking out. So, you wouldn't have people working, in other words, with these particular materials that they can get on their person or on their shoes or on their clothing or something. Those we have those isolation barriers within those working zones to keep that keep the stuff at the facility, keep the PPE people separated from those particular risks, but we also keep it within the confines of the process. [25:29] Thank you. That's super. [25:32] Well, that answers our question. I don't think we need an extra condition for that. [25:37] Scrape that. [25:37] Do you guys agree? [25:38] It's a simpler answer. Just take the PPE off before you leave the pad. Is [25:41] Yeah, that makes so much sense. Yeah. [25:44] Thanks for inviting them. [25:45] Yeah, yes. [25:46] Well, listen, that's why we have, you know, that's why we have these technical people that make sure that we're in compliance. Elaine, do you have something to say or are you just [25:54] Well, what I was going to say to you is vehicles within the site plan, we also put that vehicles couldn't be within a certain amount of feet of the area. So, the chance of them getting on any vehicles, no personal vehicles should ever be in that area. So, DDSD is something that requires standoff basically distances. [26:16] So, vehicles at that point shouldn't be close enough to track anything. [26:20] Awesome. [26:21] Right. [26:23] So, I read the Jensen Hughes report and there was a list of key recommendations at the end that I imagine you're going to follow. [26:33] Yes. [26:33] I can go over them. I don't know if you want me to go over them, but I they're in the report. They're very straightforward, easy [26:41] easy to understand and laid out there for us. [26:46] Does anybody So, you want to talk about the third-party review [26:52] Yeah, I can just make a note that I reached we've reached out to I think it was four third-party reviewers, and we eventually got a fifth contact who said that there really isn't much to review. [27:05] Mhm. [27:06] that the explosive report is prescriptive in nature. They said it was a good job, and the money would be best spent during the permitting process. [27:18] Yep. and I think so. I mean, there's so much oversight with this through many different agencies that are much more technically aware of these regulations than the Berwick Main Planning Board is, and I think it's okay to rely on these wonderful people who have expertise in energetics and whatnot [27:42] in this instance. [27:43] it routine that you would share any communications from the ABC agencies with Terry? [27:52] Some of them, yeah. Some of them probably Others probably not, but which one I like [27:58] State police [27:58] State for sure, yeah. Yeah,. Oh, and emergency planning of course has to be done with the local responders as well. yeah,. And that's that's that's in here as well, of course. Yeah, those would be worked out with local police and fire before any operation started at the site. [28:15] I do have a question for James. So, if there's a major change, let's say they, you know, go forth, and there's it's R&D to begin with, right? Until you find exactly what to do with your skins or how to manufacture or what it what it entails. If there's a major change, then they would come back to the board. [28:34] Yeah, just about any change to the site plan. [28:36] Okay. [28:36] You know, if [28:37] So, if the a location of something changes, if the size of something changes, that would all flag. [28:42] Any of the chemical locker, test pad, [28:47] magazine, new buildings, obviously. [28:51] Okay. Your scope, obviously. [28:52] Yeah. [28:54] Yeah, we have to file the chemical inventory with the fire department, too. So, if there's a something that raises a red flag for us, we're happy to address that also, but [29:04] Would you notify either James or Terry if you do choose to take that option after 10 years on your lease to extend it? [29:15] Sure. Yeah. [29:16] [laughter] [29:17] Are you going to remember that in 10 years? [29:18] Yeah, yes. Yes, well, I've got to I've got to read back reflect the reflect the meetings. [29:23] [laughter] [29:25] That's another story for another day. [29:27] I have a very intelligent engineer made a note that the chemical storage container should be on a level concrete base. Is that your plan? [29:36] Yes, there 's a patch shown there. [29:38] Perfect. [29:41] I I don't know if it's a question so much as maybe a clarification. I know that your company and this project has a lot of technical details about it that the average citizen in Berwick may not either know or follow along with. Certainly I struggle, too, with all of the expert information that you guys need to have to produce your product. [30:07] [30:08] but I 'd like to ask if this is a an accurate synopsis of what we're looking at here. on this property by your company, you are not making bombs. On this property by your company, you are making machines that mix chemicals that create a a substance that's used elsewhere [30:33] for a of different reasons, including explosives. But you're not making bombs on your site, period. [30:41] Correct. I mean, I'd say most of the places that get it's get it's getting used is in explosives, but yes, otherwise that's a reasonable. [30:48] Because I know it would be easy for people to hear about this project and hear the word explosives and immediately think the entire you know, York County is going to blow up. which is obviously an exaggeration, but people take things to extreme. And I know that we are paying attention [31:11] to the technical and safety and permitting and ordinances to make sure that you satisfy what we what we want. I just wanted to kind of simplify it in case anybody else had a notion that you're something different than what you really are. that was more of the statement. [31:32] I guess one question I had and correct me if I'm wrong, your original plan was for a 1,000 lb maximum of RDX on site. And you have said, I think, repeatedly, you know, we're going to test our thing and it makes whatever, 10 lb, 20 lb, and we're going to sell that and we're going to ship it out. [31:54] I guess my question would be, why 1,000 lb max? [32:02] it's a number that allows us to stockpile a number of different I mean, it is sort of as you can tell kind of a nice round number. it seemed like a reasonable distance that kept some a reasonable quantity that kept some of the site outside of the inhabited building distance for site planning purposes. but there wasn't a lot of rigorous analysis that went into that number. [32:23] Well, it's a condition on here, so [32:25] That's fine. As a As a ceiling, it's a comfortable ceiling. That's fine. Yeah,, yeah. [32:28] Did you tell me at one point Can I [32:30] Yeah, go ahead. [32:31] Did you tell me or maybe I heard it in some of the conversations that 1,000 lb was like the smallest number that actually had data behind it for studies. [32:42] No, I don't know. That's not to my I mean actually we have we have folks on the call who can comment here. A lot of IQD sighting, but [32:51] Sure, I'll jump in. there 's two ways to do this. Kind of the prescriptive normal way is to address that in pounds of what we call net explosive weight. we've studied the effects of all the way down to the gram scale, all the way up to 30 40,000 kilotons, right? Of the way that those things behave over time. [33:13] There's about 70 years of studies that go behind the analysis that we're doing. and what David Steve has done is taken the extra step of not only analyzing at that particular like ceiling, but analyzing at all the way down to the gram scale. So, we're able to provide an idea of the effects of that, the distances that are needed to keep everybody safe from that, and by everybody I mean everybody including the ducks, the trees, the frogs, the people, all of it. [33:38] so, there's a lot of repeatable study, a lot of history, and then of course we're able to take that additional step to do actual quantitative analysis and see, okay, what ceiling works for their operation? What do they realistically need? and what can we realistically store that's very safe that has a margin of safety. So, he's built in with that 1,000 lb limit about 32 times the normal margin of safety [34:03] over the normal margin of safety to keep everything comfortable and safe and resilient with that. In fact, the magazine that's out there is actually rated for I think it was 52,000 lb of stored energetic high energetic material. So, it they're very over-engineered for what he's actually got out there. [34:24] Wow. [34:24] Excellent. [34:25] Yeah. [34:25] Yeah, I mean one driving factor is that eventually we aim to demonstrate continuous production. And if you say, okay, let's say it's, you know, making 10 lb an hour and we're moving that off of the pad, you know, how long would you want to run it? Would you want to run it more than you know, one or a few different batches to demonstrate? that's not for just FAT testing for the skids. That would be for demonstrating a capability. [34:46] for a research and development contract. [34:50] And your studies of blast zone and noise and you know, the PSI of the of the blast or whatever at different distances all was figured on if a thousand pounds exploded. [35:09] Correct. [35:09] Yeah, it's always on the worst case scenario. [35:13] Okay. [35:15] So, there was also an economic impact and community integration statement and I thought that was awesome, too, because you can ask James and Terry directly. Like we don't get a lot of huge businesses coming into Berwick that are creating a lot of high-paying jobs. I mean, how often does that how often do we see an application in front of the board that's bringing in real revenue to the town. [35:43] Very rare. [35:44] Very rare. I agree. so you're looking at eventually at full operational capacity the facility will create 18 to 24 full-time permanent positions. highly skilled technical, operational, and engineering positions with target average wage wages between 110, 120,000 [36:06] annually. and there's a note that says this compensation significantly outpaces the regional median keeping highly skilled talent and robust disposable income within York County. And I thought that was a good thing to add cuz it's something [36:23] And we did talk about you guys having lunch at Maggie's. [36:26] Oh, of course. Of course. And sauce boss, also. [36:28] And yes, absolutely. [36:29] But [36:30] Is that a Can we make that a condition? [36:31] That's not actually a condition, but I don't think you need to make that a condition. It's more of a recommendation. [36:38] [36:39] Does anybody have any questions? Have you guys had a chance to go over the findings of facts and conditions? [36:44] I think everything looks pretty straightforward. [36:47] I just have one question. [36:48] Yeah. [36:49] assuming [clears throat] things move along as they have been, when would you begin operations? [36:56] basically as soon as we get through all these conditions. by operations here I'm I'm, you know, saying we have chemicals on site, we're doing stuff with them. So, for that to come into place, we need to get that storm water protection plan written, we need to have the building permits for the both pads and the magazine. I need to actually get the chemical storage lockers installed, get the storage permits from ATF, where we kind of started that process, but then, you know, paused it because we just like basically [37:26] say, "Hey, we're thinking of doing this thing. Do you have any major objections?" and the state but basically as soon as we're hoping to get it up and running by the end of the year, but [37:37] End of [37:38] This year, 2026. Yeah. [37:40] 2026. [37:41] Yeah. [37:41] So, when would you be hiring these 18 to 24 engineers? [37:45] We're going to hire a number of them right now. So, you know, folks to actually run this site. definitely looking for safety people, definitely looking for I mean, security is that's not really engineers, but we do need that to start. test engineers, QA QC people. [38:03] We have actually we did just hire a an automation and controls engineer who's technically commuting to Waltham, but is from closer to this neck of the woods, and once the site is up and running will be working at that location. [38:13] Cool. [38:14] [38:15] David, can you just for [clears throat] the sake of simplicity again, explain your security plan for the site? [38:24] Sure. so, basically what I was told is that we are employing a point security model and not a zone security model. And what that means is we're securing very tightly the sensitive areas within the site, so that includes the magazine, which is quite sub-sub-sub-substantial [38:44] barrier. I mean, the door is thick 6-in thick. and the chemical storage lockers in the buildings as well. the site itself has a high security fence, which we the one that's been listed here that I'm I'm getting some quotes on right now is this welded wire mesh. it is anti-climb and much harder to cut. So, it basically has really small openings. [39:07] so, you can't get your fingers in. You also can't get bolt cutters on it. And that because of that, you don't need razor wire on the top. [39:12] Mhm. [39:12] And so, I can get that powder-coated in a neutral color. and then within the site, there's lighting on the buildings. there's some area lighting in like around the front of the magazine. That'll probably motion activated. and then camera coverage of the magazine, test pad, exterior of the buildings. we will have likely two security personnel there in the day. [39:36] at night, we're still sort of like deciding what the best path is there, but the plan is to have that being remotely monitored by the same company that the cameras for our lab in Waltham as well. [39:47] Okay, great. along that vein, [39:52] [clears throat] [39:52] do you have any type of security plan for your own employees to make sure that, you know, things are staying on site that should stay on site? [40:01] Yeah, everybody So, everybody's background checked before joining. the keys for sensitive areas are very tightly controlled. and so, it's not like everybody can just like walk in. The buildings themselves has a combination I mean, this isn't This is addressing the last question really, but it's a combination of like key card and pin pad access. So, if you find someone's badge on the ground, you can't just waltz in. [40:22] You need a second authorization. [40:23] second authorization. Yeah. And then the keys to the magazines themselves are usually kept in a safe, that the basically the site director has access to. [40:32] Great. [40:33] Can I add something? Just Can I add something? [40:37] Yeah, go ahead. [40:38] Just re-emphasize lighting. Just to make sure it's downward facing, the correct color temperature, 3,000 K, no stadium lights out there. [40:47] I asked several times, yeah. Make sure that like I can get these lighting this light that complies with the appropriate standard. [40:55] Most of them are really are really out of compliance because of [40:57] Do not look at the other buildings on there. [41:00] Kind Farms? Kind Farms? [41:01] You can look at Kind Farms. [41:03] Kind Farms. [41:04] Ideal Shred, the Show and Building, the Revolution Motor Works, those are good examples. [41:09] If I missed anything for folks on the Zoom, please jump in, but [41:13] Yes, please show your faces. [41:16] [snorts] [41:16] go ahead. Oh, no, I was go ahead. [41:20] I was simply going to just make a note that I think the biggest concerns, I'm not I don't want to speak for the public, but what I was hearing from them, the biggest concerns is understanding what you're doing and safety and security. And it sounds like those are very thoroughly addressed. I understand the [41:42] creating of an emergency plan takes into worst-case scenarios, but hopefully thinking outside the box, a plane crash into your site or a fire not related to explosion, but a fire or any number of different scenarios. There needs to be an emergency plan for as many [42:05] general possibilities as possible. [42:08] Oh, trust me, they will make you have that. [42:10] I mean, those things were actually all noted in that Jensen Hughes report. [42:16] Marissa? [42:19] I feel like when you're facing [42:21] your faces. [42:22] face po- Oh, okay, no,, no, it's fine. I figure when I see a face, that usually means you want to talk. I understand how this corporate thing works now. [42:29] No, [laughter] no,, it's fine. No,, I was really just going to say our emergency plan does I think you guys have a copy of the external hazards analysis, the initial one. What we took a look at including all the plane crashes and floods and trains and cars and all the things that we kind of look at and factor in. Yeah. both natural and unnatural. but our emergency plan moving forward and I'll I'll let comment more on that. [42:53] Also anticipates those kind of I don't want to say like day-to-day possibilities, but things that are probably more probable than an explosion, which has extremely low probability, but I know really scary potential to talk about. And with that said, also the site explosive safety plan on the on the matter of security requires really specific things to happen in order for this operation to be within compliance to that plan. [43:20] And part of those things are dictated like a two-person rule, for example, where you can never have more where you can never have just one person dealing with the energetic material or the precursor materials for the energetics. So, you don't have anybody unattended within the magazine or the test pad area. [43:36] In addition to those other layers that David's already discussed. So, those things are part of the operational rigor, but they're also part of the requirements of the site plan, and that's a that's a plan that kind of moves forward through those permitting agencies and authority agencies as part of that approval process. So, that's something that naturally falls within the operational rigor as well. [43:58] Yes. Go ahead. [43:58] I have a question. So, you have some explosive material that's manufactured while you test the machine. That goes into the magazine. That's immediately entered into That's what you have in stock. So, if something was to disappear, you'd probably figure that out pretty fast, wouldn't you? [44:15] Oh, absolutely. Yeah,, yeah. No, we're we're required to log anytime anything goes in or out. We would are required to conduct an inventory. Well, we're not We're not required to We do conduct an inventory every week. there is also a periodic inventory requirement as well. And if I'm speaking to ATF like jurisdiction, but if they show up and your inventory is off, that's a big problem. [44:38] And if any material is discovered to be missing, you have to notify federal, state, and then local authorities immediately. [44:46] Yeah, part of the site plan covers loss, theft, and prevention, so that assumes both internal and external threats to the particular materials including their constituent chemicals. So, all of that is not only watched, anticipated or planned for within the security plan and I'll leave that to Matt, but that's also an element of daily reporting and regular inventory and stuff that's going to be required as well for external contracts. [45:14] Thank you. [45:17] And again, just for [45:20] just for simplicity's sake, and I just want to reiterate it so people really understand it. Your RDX product is an explosive material, but it will not explode without a secondary or primary rather explosion to ignite it. Is that correct? [45:38] Generally, yes. It is considered a secondary explosive and in actual use cases, you do need a detonator of some sort. It's not impossible that like, you know, in weird circumsta- arc flash, stuff like that, you know, but yes. [45:57] Yeah, well, bullets are designed only to be fired in one way, but sometimes they go off if you drop them or so, of course, there's ways that things can happen. [46:06] Well, the in the bullet's case, you have, you know, your propellant and then you have the actual primer. The primer's the touchy part. Yeah, so the RDX would be the propellant in that case. So, it's the much more [46:15] wanted to clarify that, you know, people aren't thinking that this is an unstable explosive material that if not, you know, carried from one place to another correctly is going to accidentally blow up. That's not the case. [46:27] Correct. [46:30] I'm going to comment on that, too, if you guys don't mind. RDX And there's about, you know, 60-70 years or so of research that kind of go behind the way RDX behaves just as a compound, just as a chemical. RDX tends to be one of those energetic materials that is extremely non-sensitive to external stimuli. [46:50] And what I mean to that is that it typically isn't static sensitive, it typically isn't sensitive to it can actually endure quite a bit of thermal influence. In other words, a fire would have to be an extremely hot fire, for example, to get this material to do anything. That's why it needs inspiration, if you will, in the way that it's put into weapons. [47:11] It has to have something act upon it fairly violently in order for RDX to react or what we call decompose, which is just a fancy word of saying explode. [47:24] The additional thing, and you'd asked the question about bombs earlier, and obviously no bombs here. We're not assessing it for bombs. They aren't making bombs. That's not what they're doing. Another thing about RDX, and this really goes for any base compound energetic materials that you might think of, if you don't confine them, in other words, if you don't put them inside of a smaller container, or if you don't keep them as they boil or something like that inside of something, there's relatively little to no opportunity for them to actually detonate because there's just not enough there [47:53] to each. Just if that makes sense. You know, you put wood on a fire, it kind of actually works the same way with energetic materials. And with this within this operation, there aren't points of confinement of this particular material, either. And it's not being exposed to high heat or anything crazy like that. it's also really stable at low temperatures. [48:14] Thank you. [48:15] Thank you. [48:16] Mhm. [48:17] Any other questions or comments from the board? [48:20] I have one security question. [48:21] Sure. [48:22] I'm just curious. You mentioned that you would have two live security guards on site during the day. Is that right? [48:28] That's correct. [48:28] But it's not in the evening. Is that correct? [48:31] That's right. And the intention there is visitor check-in and escort delivery drivers, checking them if any operations are happening at the test pad end of the pad to be able to make sure that nobody's wandering over there. And there are two because, you know, two is one and one is none. So. You got to Some of you got to go to Maggy's sometimes, so. [48:54] Buddy system. [48:55] That's right. [48:57] All right. I guess I mean, should I take the temperature of the board to see if there I mean, I don't hear any questions from my board that are unanswered that we need to that haven't been answered that we need to go get more expert evaluation on. so I'm comfortable making a decision and voting on this, but I want to make sure that everybody else is. [49:21] I am comfortable. [49:22] What are we voting on? [49:23] the approval of the Well, the conditions, the findings of [49:27] fact and approval. [49:29] All right. What about the third-party review that we voted on? Are we going to resend that? [49:32] Yes. [49:34] So we have to vote on that first. [49:35] Yes. [49:35] Yep. [49:36] Okay. [49:38] Are you [49:39] I'm good. [49:39] good? Jeff, yeah? Daniel, good? You're okay with that? [49:43] I'm good, yeah. [49:43] Okay. So the first order of business is to resend the requirement for a third-party review because we could not get a third-party review. but it has been thoroughly reviewed. So, I will make a motion to resend. [49:58] Second. [49:58] All right. A motion and a second. All in favor? All right. [50:14] And then I'm looking for a motion to approve the findings of fact. Everything we don't have any amendments to the findings that [50:23] Nope. So moved. [50:25] All right. I have a motion. I'm looking for a second. [50:27] Second. [50:28] All right. I have a motion and a second. All in favor? All right. [50:33] I would recommend reading through the conditions. [50:35] I was going to, yeah. [50:36] Sorry. [50:36] As verbose as they are. I don't have to We don't have to vote on each one, do we? [50:41] No, unless there's an objection or a proposed [50:45] conclusions of law too, just findings. [50:47] Just findings. [50:48] We need to do conclusions. [50:50] We need to do conclusions? [50:51] Well, we need to vote on the conclusions of law. [50:54] That kind of is a part of the findings. It is the [50:59] there were no waivers granted, so that's good. so I'm going to read through the conditions and then we'll vote to we'll we'll vote and if there's any amendments that need to happen, it'll be during that during that motion. Does that sound good? so the conditions are as follows. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall fund an independent fire protection engineer selected by the town to review the final explosives safety analysis, [51:28] construction drawings, and chemical inventory, and to perform on-site inspections as deemed necessary by the reviewer during construction and prior to operation. Condition two. Prior to operation, the applicant shall submit a groundwater monitor monitoring plan establishing test wells, baseline sampling, and periodic third-party analytical testing. [51:54] The plan shall be reviewed by the town's third-party reviewer at the applicant's expense, and no operations shall begin until the plan is approved. Sampling shall occur quarterly for the first year of operation and at least twice a year thereafter. Sampling results shall be retained and provided to the code enforcement officer upon request. [52:17] Third condition. This approval is limited to the operation as presented with explosive storage not to exceed 1,000 lbs net explosive [clears throat] weight and test pad synthesis enclosure operations not to exceed 10 lbs net explosive weight per event. No intentional detonation, [52:38] destructive testing, or open burning of explosive material shall occur on site. Any increase in quantity or expansion beyond the previously disturbed footprint shall require amended site plan review. Condition four. One rapid entry Knox Box system shall be purchased and installed. [53:02] Condition five. The storage magazine and test pad barricade shall be constructed in accordance with applicable federal and state explosives safety requirements and are subject to inspection as applicable and approved by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives [53:23] and the main office of state fire marshal. The applicant shall provide the code enforcement officer with confirmation of that inspection and approval prior to operation. Condition six, prior to operation the applicant shall file with the code enforcement officer and the Berwick fire department the final chemical inventory and quantities, [53:46] a written spill response plan addressing detection, containment, clean up, light ends disposal and notification and documentation of hazardous waste disposal arrangements. Condition seven, prior to bringing any chemical on site the chemical storage lockers shall be installed on an impervious concrete pad designed and certified by a licensed professional engineer. [54:15] The sealed liquid tight sump integral to each locker shall serve as the primary spill containment. Stamped drawings and copies of inspection reports shall be provided to the code enforcement officer. [54:29] [clears throat] [54:30] Condition eight, prior to operation the applicant shall confirm with the fire chief the on site fire water supply pump access and emergency response provisions. [54:43] Condition nine, the test pad shall be constructed with an impervious surface and perimeter containment as proposed so that wash down water, spills and residuals are contained rather than discharged to the ground. Condition 10, general liability and pollution liability insurance [music] shall be bound before operations begin and maintained for the life of the use. [55:09] A certificate of insurance shall be provided to the code enforcement officer upon request within five business days. Final condition. Prior to operation, the applicant shall execute a Hazmat emergency response retainer agreement and provide a copy of the site specific Hazmat emergency response program to the code enforcement officer [55:35] and the Berwick Fire Department. The retainer shall be maintained for the life of the use and annual compliance inspection reports shall be retained and provided to the code enforcement officer upon request within five business days. I'm looking for a motion to re- to approve the conditions as written. [55:56] So moved. [55:57] All right, I have a motion. Do I have a second? [56:00] Second. [56:01] All right, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion or amendments that anybody have? [56:05] I have some grammatical corrections. [56:07] Please. [56:09] in condition one the comma following chemical inventory [56:15] Mhm. [56:16] is inappropriate in that sentence. [56:18] Strike the comma. Yep. [56:22] And then in condition six the and between license disposal and notification [56:30] is [56:32] on line three. [56:34] Oh,, yeah,. Yeah, I thought it was repetitive also as I was reading it. [56:39] And causes lack of clarity. [56:43] Thank you. [56:43] And then I just have a comment which is [56:46] [clears throat] [56:47] there's a lot of conditions here and it sounds like there's a lot for Terry to follow up on and before they start cutting the ribbon on production. and that's something that you are absolutely qualified and prepared to do, correct? [57:05] I It is part of my job, so yes, absolutely. [57:08] Great. Awesome. [57:11] That's what I just wanted to We are Terry is one person, so part of the conditions and part of the procedure here, we are leaning upon the federal agencies. That's why there are conditions where Terry is permitting these test pads, but she's not going to be responsible for knowing the ins and outs of the test pad or the magazines. [57:35] That's why we are going to require the federal agencies of agencies that are in charge of overseeing it to provide us with a certification. And that's also the importance of having the the engineer third-party review as well as some SLR third-party reviews as well. [57:56] Third-party reviews and inspections? [57:58] Yeah,, yeah,. [58:00] Excellent. [58:01] Can I ask you a question? Do you understand all 11 conditions? [58:06] Yes. I just [58:08] comfortable that you'll be able to comply with them? [58:10] Many of them are were I mean, it's good to spell them out explicitly, but were things that we needed to do anyway. I just wanted to clarify just so we all are on the same page that operations in this case can be defined as when chemicals are on the site. [58:24] Just to Just does that work for you? [58:25] Are you referring to a specific [58:27] Just because everything says prior to operation, so I want to make sure that So for stuff like permitting, building the pads, running power to places, that's [58:34] yeah. Permitting and all that, the building part of would not be operations. [58:37] Okay. [58:37] So it would be Yeah. When chemicals are on site, makes sense. [58:41] All your infrastructure will be taken care of, and then you're just like, all right, bring in the stuff. [58:46] Good stuff. Yeah, that works. [58:47] Does that work for you, Terry? [58:49] Right. Yeah, we I mean, you're talking about the pads being poured, fencing being up, right? [58:54] Or even just like setting up, you know, benches and tools and that sort of thing in the buildings. That's Okay. [59:00] Is the fencing going to be one of the first things that go? [59:02] Fencing is going to going to be one of the first thing that gets ordered. Lead time on that is frustrating, but yes. [59:11] That's special fencing? [59:13] Special fence Special It's a lot of It's like a half a mile of it, too. So. [59:17] [laughter] [59:18] They'll be happy. [59:20] Okay, so I have a motion and a second. We have some amendments. anybody else have any questions or amendments? Nope. so all in favor of the accepting the conditions as amended. All right. So I have a So then I am looking for a motion to approve the conditional use. [59:39] I will make a motion to approve the conditional use. [59:44] I'll second. [59:45] All right. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion on this? All right. All in favor? All right. You're all set. [59:54] Okay. [59:55] Do you have plans for signature? [59:56] Oh, wow. Let's get right down to business, shall we? Just keep them away from the microphones cuz [1:00:05] The individual items will have to go back to the findings of fact. [1:00:08] Okay. [1:00:10] Can we remove that column? [1:00:13] From the findings of fact? [1:00:15] It doesn't refer to the condition or the first one. [1:00:17] Oh, this is just Got you. [1:00:21] Did I remember Did I read somewhere that there are code enforcement officer office hours? [1:00:26] Yes. [1:00:26] Yes. [1:00:27] She's like, "Don't talk about it." [1:00:28] That would be useful like just to plan out what sequence what you want to see for everything. [1:00:33] And what when are those? [1:00:34] [1:00:35] I believe it's posted on the town website. [1:00:36] Well, you can you can Yeah, they are on the town website. So my walk-in hours are from 8:00 to 11:00, but you can submit stuff to me outside of the office hours. [1:00:48] I just want to you know maybe sit down and whiteboard out everything. [1:00:53] Oh, I only sign one. And then I do the afternoon my first day, but yeah, that's [1:00:59] 8:00 to 11:00 every day? [1:01:01] I'm trying. [1:01:04] [laughter] [1:01:05] I heard you have some help though now. [1:01:07] Yes. Let's get us some She's going to be the enforcer of the walk-in hours. [1:01:12] Oh, good. [1:01:13] [laughter] [1:01:15] Hope she's not listening. Or watching. [1:01:19] I can't imagine anybody's watching this for fun. For funsies. [1:01:22] only need you one copy. [1:01:23] Okay. Okay, sounds good. [1:01:26] I think we can skip those guys this time. [1:01:29] [laughter] [1:01:30] Oh, yeah. Thank you. Thank you all. Oh. [1:01:34] Really appreciate calling in. [1:01:36] Yeah, thank you. [1:01:37] Jensen Hughes folks. That was very [clears throat] helpful and I'm glad we have it on record, too. That was [1:01:42] That's good. [1:01:44] [clears throat] [1:01:45] You're dismissed. [1:01:47] [laughter] [1:01:48] Thank you. [1:01:49] All right, thank you. [1:01:49] Bye, everybody. [1:01:50] Thank you. [1:01:51] Thank you, everyone. [1:01:51] Thanks. [1:01:52] And good luck. [1:01:53] Yeah. [1:02:02] There's like more of these. [1:02:07] My first one was pretty, but the rest of them are not going to be. [1:02:10] I hope maybe they [1:02:20] We'll just take a brief moment while the rest of the board signs the plans before we move on. [1:02:34] Last guy to sign dates it, right? [1:02:36] Yeah. [1:02:36] Yeah. [1:02:37] That's a rough one. [1:02:38] [laughter] [1:02:40] It's a rough way to do it, guys. [1:02:43] [laughter] [1:02:48] I will say, while we're taking this moment, that we do have an opening on the planning board. So, if this looks like something that you would be into, you don't mind a little [1:02:57] I got this. [1:02:57] public ridicule every once in a while, [1:03:03] we've got an opening. And it'll be for an alternate position, right, James? [1:03:08] That's correct. [1:03:08] Yeah. So, so it gives you a little bit of a buffer time to learn the ropes. [1:03:14] Don't listen. They'll throw you right in. [1:03:17] [laughter] [1:03:19] There'll be a couple weeks to apply, so [1:03:21] Yep, couple weeks to apply. It's an appointed position. You don't have to you don't have to gather signatures or run for anything, but there is a an attendance requirement. And that tends to be what gets people. We need we need people that can really commit to physically being here at the meetings and contributing. [1:03:42] All right. Thank you, guys. so, moving on, we have no new business. We have no public comment, but we're going to have some Who's Scott? [1:03:53] Is iPhone here? [1:03:56] It's not Scott. [1:03:58] It said Scott or one of those Scotts. [1:03:59] I don't know. It just says Scott's iPhone. [1:04:01] Scott, yes. [1:04:05] Oh, maybe. Maybe. so, we're going to move on to some informational items. One was the planning board opening, but I think we want to talk about third-party reviews. [1:04:15] Yeah. [1:04:16] talk about it. [1:04:16] So, from I guess where I stand on third-party reviews for subdivisions, as part of the ordinance, we take in review escrow. So, I thought procedurally, I'm trying to commission those to align specific timeline horizons. So, [1:04:37] if the board prefers to want to authorize that before I do that, then just that's just I'll just do that. [1:04:46] Okay. So, in other words, you were just saying it's it's something that they pay for regardless, so you're just automatically requesting that to save time for the applicant so that they're it could possibly take a couple weeks off of their application process. [1:05:01] Right. [1:05:01] Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you. [1:05:03] and generally, when I'm asking for a third-party review, I try to pin it to things that I'm not super comfortable with. So, if it's something I like I do a cursory overview, but I say, "Here are the things that I'm not super familiar with. Focus on those. And then obviously things I might miss in general. [1:05:24] Like what? Give us an example of something that you would [1:05:26] Storm I mean like in terms of storm water flows and calculations. I mean they're pretty sometimes straightforward, but if something's if something's missing or Like there was one where I was like one example I was reviewing a subdivision and I noticed there was extra flow going off the site and there's a certain number of the flow that's going off and then I do some research and it seemed like a significant number. [1:05:53] but if I'm going to bring that up to the board, I want to be sure. Like I don't I don't want to bring something up and then lead you guys down a different path. [1:06:02] Yeah. [1:06:03] so it's just good to have an engineer's perspective to say, "Yeah, that is a problem." Or [1:06:09] Yeah. [1:06:10] No. So that's just one example. There's like road construction. there's all kinds of examples of like [1:06:17] crossing wetlands or whatever. [1:06:20] Yeah. [1:06:22] Okay. Things outside our expertise. [1:06:24] But I don't know. You tell me. So we have sketch plan. We have no money collected at sketch plan. [1:06:30] Mhm. [1:06:30] We go on the site walk. They come back. They produce a preliminary plan. it's just one of those things procedurally I've waited a little longer to generally around the time they come to the board for preliminary plan. That's when it kind of triggers in my mind, "Okay, should be a third party review." Because in my mind [1:06:52] just like the last one for Northland, I'm thinking I want to have the I want us to have a third party review done by the public hearing. [1:06:58] Right. So that So that when the public comes with questions, we have the answers. [1:07:02] But instead of me making that call, if you prefer at preliminary plan procedurally, you can say, "We want to I Maybe I can say here are the things I'm not super familiar with. [1:07:12] [clears throat] [1:07:12] Does the board want to do a third party review on whatever?" And then you can say, "Yes, we want to cursory review on everything but focus on this and that." [1:07:22] it's also possible or likely even that not every project needs a third-party review. [1:07:28] In terms of a major, I would from This is specifically we're talking like subdivisions. [1:07:33] Major subdivisions. [1:07:34] Okay. [1:07:34] Yeah. [1:07:35] Yeah. [1:07:35] But, do you foresee any [1:07:36] And some minors minor, too. [1:07:38] But, do you foresee any subdivisions that might come before the board that would not need that third party review? [1:07:43] I can't think of anything, but the [1:07:45] So, you're thinking that there are [1:07:46] The amount that we collect is proportional to the size of the subdivision. So, we collect on a per lot or per dwelling unit basis. [1:07:55] Okay. [1:07:56] So, [1:07:56] And what Yeah, George was [1:07:57] So, the amount you collect that price with the third-party review. [1:08:01] That's correct. [1:08:02] Okay. [1:08:02] We collect it at applica- But, I don't mind I don't I think procedurally it probably could still work that [1:08:11] I'll think about it I think we could work it into it that way your form your formally signing off on a third-party review and then it could be maybe even more pointed after your after the It would be at application completeness. [1:08:24] Mhm. [1:08:24] So, we just make it part of the part of the procedure. It'll [1:08:29] Yeah, see that's why I brought I've been bringing it up a while because there's actually no policy for Berwick on how the third-party reviews are handled. There's ordinances [1:08:38] Mhm. [1:08:38] that specifically says the board has to approve all third-party reviews. If the ordinance is also state that the cost for the third-party review has to be given to the applicant. Like, for you they have to agree, "Okay, I will pay this cost." You can't just say it might be a certain amount. So, I think if we can tighten this all up with a policy. [1:09:00] and it doesn't even have to be very complicated. [1:09:04] Yeah. [1:09:05] It's Yeah, so I mean if you if we identify It's just the only issue I have is delaying the application. If we're waiting if at application completeness you say, "Hey, listen, you know, we need whatever the stormwater survey, whatever for a third-party review." And then we go [1:09:25] and get a price for that to come back at the next meeting. We've already delayed them 2 weeks or maybe 4 weeks. That's all. So, it's just adding it's it's adding time to their application. [1:09:38] I understand. But, I mean [1:09:40] Well, we're trying to like [1:09:41] the other night when we had this discussion about the town ordinance and the planning board's policy that didn't align up, and then what was it said at the end? That the ordinance is law and that has to be abided by. So, are we going to just sweep this under the rug now for this? [1:09:55] Well, I think we do give I mean, we do give them a price at some point. It's just that when we're sitting here, we don't say it's tons of [1:10:01] No,, I'm not saying that. No,, I'm not I'm not trying to speak here. I'm just saying, why don't we just get a clear policy? We can all discuss it and say, you know, this is fair, this works this in the name of efficiency, we're going to allow this and this. I'm totally cool with that. I just think we need a policy. And then we can avoid all these other little snafus going down the road. [1:10:23] Is it aligned with the ordinance? [1:10:25] Exactly. And that's why it's going to We can't just do it in this meeting. We 'll have to It'll take several meetings, and then we can have the lawyers check it out and say, "Okay, good." And then we can make a motion and vote on it. [1:10:37] Yeah, that sounds good. [1:10:38] Yeah, cuz the ordinance isn't changing before next June. [1:10:42] Yeah, mhm. We wouldn't change an ordinance, just a policy within our procedures, right? Oh, James doesn't look at his face. [1:10:49] Oh, no, I have I have a completely unrelated thing to talk about. That's all. [1:10:53] Oh, okay. [1:10:53] No,, I wasn't talking about changing the ordinance. I was saying we have to comply with the [1:10:57] Just have a policy that we're not sweeping things under the rug. [1:11:00] No,, but I mean, if if we're actually sitting here and discussing that it's okay for the staff to order third-party reviews, and that is not that is totally against what the ordinance says, that's illegal. [1:11:12] Right. But, we would need to change the ordinance. [1:11:14] No,, we have to comply to the ordinance. [1:11:17] Right, yeah. [1:11:18] Are we complying with the ordinance? [1:11:20] Yes, yeah. [1:11:21] Cuz we're we can't change it before next June. [1:11:23] Right. [1:11:24] I wouldn't change that any or I wouldn't want to change that. [1:11:27] Yeah. Yeah, so we'll work on that. Do you want to come up with a [1:11:34] I already did. [1:11:35] You did? [1:11:36] Can you put it on the agenda for us, please? [1:11:38] Yeah. [1:11:38] On a future meeting. [1:11:39] Can you put it on the agenda? [1:11:40] Yeah. [1:11:40] Yeah. [1:11:41] Fantastic. [1:11:41] Can you send it out in an email so that we can review so that we can all [1:11:45] do it probably tomorrow, yeah. Got a busy day, but otherwise it'll be by Monday. Just ping me if I do forget, but I have it. [1:11:51] All right, cool. [1:11:54] What else do you have? [1:11:55] Oh. [1:11:58] For we have our ordinance project. Our Phil from Bernstein Shore has gone through the ordinance. I've gone through some of the comments and stuff to like there's probably 15 or 20 changes to comply with some of the new laws. There's some smaller decision points. So, at some point I'll bring that to the board that we can discuss. [1:12:19] We're ramping up already to ordinance amendment season. And we have to be done by January-ish to have the public hearing. [1:12:29] Which is crazy cuz we have such a heavy like we have a heavy schedule and ordinances are important. [1:12:35] So, I'll have to sneak that in at some point. [1:12:37] Yeah. [1:12:38] We'll have to grab a light meeting and make it a conference. [1:12:41] have a light meeting coming up? We have a heavy meeting and then we and then it's [laughter] like Thanksgiving and then it's Christmas and then it's January and then like [1:12:50] We're not going to want to put an extra meeting in December. That never works out. [1:12:53] What are you talking about? George does. [1:12:56] [laughter] [1:12:56] Well, remember by policy in December anyway, by policy we don't meet on the [1:13:03] Third week in December and the first week in January, right? [1:13:06] No, we meet in July. [1:13:07] We meet the first week of January. Oh, first week of July. [1:13:11] July 4th [clears throat] and [1:13:13] We can always add meetings. [1:13:15] We want to add this one. [1:13:16] It's exactly Things are going to slow down. [1:13:18] Certainly setting that precedent. [1:13:21] I did receive the preliminary plan for Hanson Road, so you'll see that coming. [1:13:27] Oh. [1:13:27] But other than that, I don't know. I can't think of any other projects that are like in the queue, so. [1:13:32] Okay. [1:13:35] Oh yeah, and I received I received the application for the gas station. [1:13:39] you. Yeah. [1:13:40] And they actually they reduced the building to 3,000 sq ft. [1:13:45] That was the best decision they could have made. [1:13:47] Wow. Where's that board? [1:13:49] that's Blackberry Hill Road at the end at a Route 4 on Blackberry Hill Road. Route 4 on Blackberry Hill. [1:13:54] Not far from where these guys are doing their When do you think that will be before? [1:13:58] the next meeting, you think? [1:14:01] November 5th. [1:14:02] excuse me, November. [1:14:05] Like Thursday? November is very busy. [1:14:07] November 9th November 19th, I'm sorry. [1:14:10] [laughter] [1:14:11] November 19th. [1:14:11] No one can miss a November meeting. You heard? [1:14:16] [laughter] [1:14:18] There's a lot of things happening in November. [1:14:20] Yeah. [1:14:20] Yeah, cuz the next meeting is two sisters and then there's Berg Woodlands for application completeness. [1:14:26] Oh okay, yeah. That's good. [1:14:27] That's the Megans. [1:14:28] Will there be the invoice for the third-party review for two sisters? [1:14:31] We did. It's So it's still ongoing, but the one invoice we received was for $5,000. [1:14:36] Okay. [1:14:36] So that's a lot less than [1:14:37] Yeah, about [1:14:38] the original scope. [1:14:39] This It's still It's still ongoing, so there will be, but I think the subsidence substantive review was a $5,000. So now there's a response to the response, now there's a response to the responses to the response. [1:14:50] Got it. [1:14:51] Oh. [1:14:51] Is that all contained together in [1:14:54] Yeah. [1:14:56] It's a good question. [1:14:57] I only so far I provided you have that's the res that's the applicant response to the third-party review. Everything else is provided in the digital packet. [1:15:10] Okay. [1:15:11] If you want more, let me know. I thought maybe the more material may end up being confusing because things are being referenced to the previous documents. Yeah. So let me know if you want if you want the other things printed out. [1:15:23] Are the all the two sisters things online for the [1:15:27] They're in the packet, yep. Everything is in the packet. [1:15:30] I'm thinking you're going to cut down on hunting time. [1:15:34] [laughter] [1:15:34] There's always Sunday, Jeff. Anybody have anything else, any other information? [1:15:40] No, ma'am. [1:15:41] All right. I move we adjourn. [1:15:43] Second. [1:15:43] All in favor? [1:15:45] Aye. [1:15:46] Aye.