Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Unfinished Business
[10:17] Chair: I think we'll get started. All right, so welcome to the November 16, 2026 meeting of the Standish Zoning Board of Appeals. This meeting will now come to order. This is a public proceeding and unless the board specifically votes to go into executive session, you have the right to hear everything that is being said and to look at all the exhibits that are being offered. Please notify the chairperson, myself, if you are unable to see or hear some type of accommodation. accommodation. The board does work from a prepared agenda and will be considering tonight's items in the following order. Under old business, we have none. Under new business, we have an application for a non-dimensional variance shoreland zoning. The applicant is Stacy Anderson and Suzanne LaCroix. Map 33, lot 102, address is 97 Smooth Ledge Road. Applicant is seeking to build a 24 by 24 garage. It's located in the rural Shoreland Overlay District. Correct? Yes. Perfect. All right. For this non-dimensional variance, the applicant will be asked to proceed first and then be available to answer questions from the board. After the applicant has spoken, all other interested parties may make their presentations and then be questioned by the board. After all interested parties have spoken, each side will be given an opportunity for a brief rebuttal. Once the public comment session is closed, the board will deliberate and decide the matter. Since this meeting is being recorded, It can be often difficult to hear what's being said when multiple people speak, so please come up to the podium if you have comments or addressing the board and speak directly into the microphone and be respectful of others when they're speaking. We ask that, as a reminder, that the burden of the applicant is on you, and you have to demonstrate compliance with the provisions of the applicant's ordinance ordinances. And under this particular situation, you must demonstrate the proposal seeking a variance meets each of the defined four undue hardship criteria. For variance application governed by the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance, the Board acts by vote of the majority of the members of the Board present and voting. We have a full house tonight. We have five members. It's a compliment of our board. So you need at least three out of the five members present tonight to vote in the affirmative of each of the four criteria separately for your variance to be approved. approved. Okay, it's not as a whole request for a variance. It's each of the criteria has to go. We go vote on each of the criteria. You have to pass each of them. A tie vote should it apply on any of the four criteria is insufficient to grant a variance. It's essentially a no vote. Following a decision on the application or appeal, the board will prepare a written decision indicating its findings of fact and conclusions of law that will be made available to the applicant within seven days of the board's vote. If your application or appeal is granted, you must obtain a building permit from the code enforcement officer, JP. If anyone wishes to appeal the board's decision, you must do so to superior court within 45 days. Any questions with what I have just read? Not for me. Good. Great. Before we begin with the applicant's opening remarks, does any board member, you can come up on the podium now, does any board member have a potential conflict of interest or potential bias as it relates to these individuals with their variance request tonight that needs to be discussed?
[13:59] Board Member: No. I know the applicants. I know I don't have a bias. I don't think it would affect my decision, but I know Suzanne, we both volunteered with the sheriff's office, and Stacey, I know she used to play hockey at a rink I managed.
[14:22] Chair: Okay. So it's not a personal relationship, more of an acquaintance, right? Okay. And not a business or professional relationship whatsoever. Correct. Okay. Unless I receive a motion from the board that would suggest this is a conflict. I think it's a non issue. Okay, great. All right. So we'll ask the applicant to come forth and sort of give us a an overview of why you're here tonight and what you're asking for and why you believe a variance should be granted on your behalf for a 24 by 24 foot garage. Okay so I'm Stacey Anderson
[15:00] Suzanne LaCroix: Suzanne LaCroix and I live at [address]. We've been permanent residents there since 2017, seasonal since 2004, and it was my grandparents' property prior to my taking ownership of it. We began this garage excursion, if you will, probably a couple of years ago, trying to determine where we could fit a garage on our property. In February, In February, we were given a building permit to put a 24 by 24 foot garage on our upper, we actually have two structures on our property. And we were going to put it on the hill where our upper property is. It required that we redesign our septic system. In the process of doing the work with the excavator, he was able to determine that where the garage location was going to be. the pitch for us to get into that garage because our driveway slopes down the pitch was going to be too high for us to get a car in without scraping so we're here looking to move the location of the garage across the street from our seasonal camp that we have that's where we've got 32 feet of land the variances wouldn't be met with the 24-foot structure going in there. And we're here for that variance purpose. We have with us Kip Jordan, who is the abutting property owner. He owns both sides of that land. He and his wife, Linda, have given us variance approval, if you will, which we've had notarized and submitted with our paperwork. the, difficulty for us, it is really driving down that driveway, getting the location where we were approved. As I said, we could not easily get into that garage the way it was going to be structured. we're looking at currently storing, obviously our vehicles in there, just trying to retain our property value. you. Things that we have stored in our crawl space basement have become a challenge. Just putting them in there and smacking my head several times on the rafters trying to get things in and out. So we're hoping that with the garage, we can now put things there instead of forcing us to crawl into that four foot space and put things in there. We've tried to figure out other locations to do this on our property. It's really the only location that we can situate it. If you see the structures that I've provided in the pictures, there's really no other spot for it to go.
[18:02] Speaker D (unidentified): The grounds are all trees around. You've got to come up. If you want to say
[18:07] Chair: something, you're free to say something, but you have to come up and introduce yourself
[18:10] Suzanne LaCroix: all from speaking to Mark. Yeah, we've got a shed where the shed that we have now, which was previously approved, is the location that we're proposing to put the garage. So we had been granted a variance when we put the shed in for the distance to the water. We will not be any closer to the water with this garage structure and where it's located. It's the edges that also aren't going to meet the variance. So, we're hoping that we can get this location situated and approved by you folks. I don't know if there's more that I should be discussing or any questions.
[18:52] Chair: If you feel you've provided a good summary based on your application, we can start with questions.
[18:59] Suzanne LaCroix: Anything you wanted to add?
[19:01] Chair: Anyone else wants to come up and add something to your testimony?
[19:05] Speaker D (unidentified): it's up to you
[19:08] Board Member: the location again is i'm sorry just for the record you are suzanne lacroix just so there's no confusion where you'll probably see where the picture is but the shed that's there is surrounded by trees and his the jordan property that owns that is, you know, it's wild. Okay. So there's no one around us. There's, we're not disturbing anybody. We've gotten the okay from them to do that variance, which is minimal. Three feet. We'll have four feet on each side. Four feet on each side. And like I said, there's other than that, it's just trees and there's no other people that would be involved in this whole structure and i was just going to say we again because of storage we have none in our house right now because the only thing we have is our basement which is a three foot thing and we stacy is the one that goes down because i can't i can't get down there anymore and as i get older i can do less and less so it's important to try to have a better location to get access to our belongings in the basement that we put in and you know the cars and everything else to keep them clean from the snow and make sure that they don't they don't basically rot away from not from not us taking care of it but i've seen her with a lot of little bumps on her head and she's and it's not pretty when she goes down there and she's not saying a few words that we don't want to hear so that's i guess the only thing i had left to say all right that's it questions any questions
[20:53] Chair: sense? I'm sure there'll be a few. So I'll open it up to the board for specific questions at this time to the applicants like
[21:05] Board Member: to start. I have a question. JP in your cover letter second. That doesn't make sense to me. The officer received a building permit back on January 13.
[21:26] Building Official: That for a right at the location that the shed is now right so that should be application from building
[21:34] Board Member: permit application right here that's what you receive yeah i'm sorry it reads like that it's
[21:39] Building Official: just a typo technical application where it is not in there yes you're correct all right okay thank
[21:45] Board Member: you for
[21:48] Chair: the questions so i'll start while folks are kind of thinking one of the on that first criteria you've read the four criteria right your comp you understand the four criteria that you have to meet?
[22:02] Suzanne LaCroix: I will say the first one was a little ambiguous to me. I wasn't sure what you were looking for there with the reasonable return.
[22:11] Chair: Right. So that specifically speaks to if you were granted this variance for the purpose of your structure, would that essentially allow you or enable you to sell your property or get a return on that property because of the structure. So when it states that the land in question cannot yield a reasonable return on lessee variance. Granted, it's really speaking to what do you do with the land now? What do you have on the land now versus what you're asking to put on the land in terms of whether you could, by doing so, you'd actually get a reasonable return value for it. Okay. And so that was one of my questions for you tonight on that first standard is, you know, or first criteria is why do you feel that your property won't, isn't in a place now that would result in a reasonable return should you sell it if you don't have this garage?
[23:19] Suzanne LaCroix: garage? Honestly, I don't think there'll be much. We've seen this property go from its lakefront. So, I mean, the garage, any garage on any property is probably going to improve
[23:31] Chair: the return of the property. It may improve it, but that's not the first standard.
[23:39] Suzanne LaCroix: That's why I'd say I'm confused with, if we're putting a garage, anybody puts a garage on a property, I would expect that's going to increase the return that they're going to get if they sell
[23:48] Chair: their increased return but the question i had isn't it's not designed for sort of maximizing a return of value it's designed to so your development of the property would allow you the opportunity that should you sell it or you wanted to you know get an investment return on it this addition would make it valuable versus a zero net gain invaluable right i would expect that it
[24:16] Suzanne LaCroix: it is going to increase our return on the property to put a garage there, but the purpose is not for us to get an increase in the return. The purpose is for us to be able to protect
[24:25] Chair: our assets. Right. And an increase in return is different than a reasonable return. You stated you have two dwellings already on the property. Yes. Right. So the property has
[24:36] Suzanne LaCroix: been developed with units. It's lakefront. Yeah. When we took over the property, there were two units on it already sure and we've turned a seasonal camp into our your own living
[24:53] Chair: now so what i'm trying to get at is if you were to forget about the garage if you were to sell that property tomorrow one would argue you'd probably get a reasonable return for that property i would expect that yes as lakefront so adding the property would might increase the value but it wouldn't affect the reasonable return you get currently without it that's the issue okay. It's criteria one. Gotcha. I just wanted to clear off. Yep. Questions from the board?
[25:20] Board Member: How did you land on the 24 by 24?
[25:24] Suzanne LaCroix: From a size perspective, we wanted to have room for two cars and the things that we have in the shed now. Snow blowers, the extra chairs and things that we use in the summertime, we want to be able to store those up in the garage. So we're looking for enough space to do that and safely be able to get in and out of the cars. And it's two cars? That's what we're looking for, a two-car garage, yeah.
[25:49] Board Member: But your opening was that you don't want to store things under the camp anymore. I assume you don't, or out of your home, the structure. And I assume you don't currently store your cars under the structure. Is that correct?
[26:01] Suzanne LaCroix: That's correct. We don't store the cars under the structure.
[26:04] Board Member: But that was your opening, was that you want to do this because you don't want to store things under the... structure anymore. But you're now saying that you actually want to park cars in a garage.
[26:13] Suzanne LaCroix: We want to park cars and store our seasonal equipment things in that garage.
[26:20] Board Member: I'm a little confused. You did get a permit for a garage to be located between the two existing structures, that's correct?
[26:29] Suzanne LaCroix: Yeah, it was up next to our camp.
[26:31] Board Member: But it was between the two structures?
[26:34] Speaker D (unidentified): pretty much yes that was yeah I'm not sure if it was I'm just a little bit
[26:40] Board Member: unclear I know there's a lot going on here I'm coming in late but I'm just trying to figure out exactly what is it was approved yeah if you look at if you look at the exhibit a 2017 dwelling I've got the existing the other existing dwelling right I believe that it was kind of the garage that was approved was
[27:03] Speaker D (unidentified): around between the C and the D. Yeah. Stacey Anderson. We, right, we, exactly. And then you said it could not be built there because? Because that garage, the driveway slope coming down. Okay. is a steep, very steep pitch. Okay. At one end of that garage. And there's no way to go down lower? Is that not a possibility? No, because the property actually runs downhill. Okay. so, there's a picture actually of where the
[27:33] Suzanne LaCroix: excavator was going to put the lines and that is photo one. With the 24 by 24, we were required to put in frost walls and the way this property was designed, we had to put frost walls in.
[27:55] Speaker D (unidentified): So at the point, he was looking to lay out the garage. Which exhibit or which photo,
[28:02] Suzanne LaCroix: Sorry, photo one photo one. He actually had a pink strip at the top of that pole. I circled it. So because the of the slope of the land, the top of the wall would have been at that point, the frost wall coming in. So it was quite a steep angle to get into the garage. And you can see how the driveway slopes, it makes it a little monkey trying to come in. We don't own where those two trees are. That's not our property. So for us to come in on the other side, wasn't feasible. Okay, we could only come in from that driveway side. And
[28:53] Board Member: I'm just gonna ask because I don't know how wide a garage could be. Could they put on the back of the property where the shed is right now?
[29:02] Suzanne LaCroix: It's listed as 32 feet. We have 32 feet so 12 foot wide garage. Okay.
[29:15] Chair: So just piggybacking on what Steve said, I just want, for the record, I want to understand, are you suggesting that once the code enforcement officer granted you a permit to build a garage on the property, the original site, are you saying that it is your investigation or through your contractor, there's no way a garage can be built there?
[29:41] Suzanne LaCroix: we don't have enough space between where the cabin is now we considered shortening it and maybe doing a 20-foot garage instead of a 24-foot and it's still i mean he came up with alternatives that were just not workable with the cement so stepping the inside the garage we'd have one lower piece than a higher piece just to try to do things like that and he was not confident that any of that would work and be solid enough for us to continuously maintain that garage.
[30:20] Board Member: And I'm just going to mention, we did have to get involved with the septic in that area too. Now, I don't know if that was anything that we might want to say why, another reason why we put our different loads in that area too.
[30:34] Suzanne LaCroix: Well, we actually redid the septic because we were looking to put the garage in and we were in the midst of digging, and we said, finish the septic. People already got the lawn dug up. So we've got a more efficient septic in there, yay.
[30:48] Chair: So knowing that you had to modify the septic to accommodate a garage, did you consult with someone first to say, hey, if we do this, we can put a garage here?
[30:59] Suzanne LaCroix: Yeah, so that's a whole other part of our fun that we've had with this garage. We worked with Dennis Harmon to design the garage and septic locations, help us help us with all that and figuring that out we got our permit in February and Dennis decided to move to Florida in March so we had a new excavator that we had to work with and that's where some of the challenges been with understanding what the design had been planned and then actually getting in there and starting to look at the leveling eyeballing. And, you know, eyeballing, Dennis eyeballed a parallel line, straight line, whatever you want to call it, where the driveway cement would be going into the garage. And in reality, when you look at the height of the high end of that land to where the end of the garage would be and the doors would be, there was just too much of a pitch there getting onto the driveway. way.
[32:00] Chair: JP, I'm going to get technical on use because I'm not an engineer, but based on the applicant's description of the frost wall and the pitch, something's not making sense to me here.
[32:12] Building Official: I'm not sure about the pitch because I don't know. I haven't been out there to see exactly where the pitch is, but they are correct. Anything over 600 square feet is required to be frost protected. That can be done with four foot frost walls and or slated slab. They do shallow foundations, but you just have to insulate around the haunches of the foundation. I don't know if that would make a difference or not because it's still, I mean, a four foot frost wall doesn't need to be up above the ground. It can be down below, but without going out there, I mean, we approved what they asked for. We didn't go out and look at that, so if they are correct, it does need to be frost
[32:55] Chair: protected. factor. So did you consider going down for the four foot to meet the four feet for us? Yes, absolutely. Yeah. Again, it's
[33:04] Suzanne LaCroix: you need the level floor. And from the high point to where that stake is, that's got the circle on it, we're looking at least 18 inches of increase trying to get in. Okay, but I
[33:20] Chair: guess what's not making sense to me is that an excavator could grade down that incline to sink the wall down and then remedy sort of the pitch going up you wouldn't have the wall as high above ground but it would go down below further did you have that
[33:37] Suzanne LaCroix: looked at we had every conversation we could have about alternatives to keep it in this space because we've been trying to get approval for this for a couple years but you did get approval we did get the approval to put it in this spot that you see in the picture I guess the reality of having somebody come in and look at it and put the lines in, and yes, I understand, an excavator can dig down in. If we're digging down in, then we're getting even a deeper pitch in that driveway because right now it kind of slopes down. And if we're going to say we have to get that to the level where it's even, we're going to be dropping land inside. So we're really going to be driving down and then driving back up again.
[34:22] Chair: Right, but land can be modified on the sides, too, to accommodate that.
[34:28] Suzanne LaCroix: What? You can come up here.
[34:33] Board Member: The other piece is that we're dealing with a septic system, so they can only do so much. In fact, at one point, with the rocks, because on smooth ledge, we have boulders everywhere. So this was another thing. We started to dig and try to do what he thought he could do to make a foundation and get us prepared for that. bottom line he couldn't because he had this huge stone and they just couldn't they weren't going to dig up this whole thing not knowing how much or how large the stone was so that's it's another challenge that was put into the to the rank of building this and getting this place done so you know we're just going with the nature and he's he was very good about telling us and felt that, you know, he in true,, for his, in his business that he would not feel right in doing something like this for us because he knew it was going to be problems down the road. Not only that, but all the runoff of water that would go down into our house. Cause that's where we live at the bottom of the hill. So, you know, there was so many different little things and that just didn't, wasn't, it wasn't falling into place. And he said, I honestly in good conscience cannot do this so he told us and which was great i'm glad he did i wish he was here
[35:46] Speaker D (unidentified): tonight he could explain all that but you know he's he's not jp was this the only site on this
[35:53] Chair: parcel that would accommodate a 24 by 24 garage we
[35:59] Building Official: do not design projects we approve projects well i can pretty much say that there was not a lot of land to put this garage on we have the new calculations for impervious as such that pretty much is really the only site other than across the street there
[36:20] Chair: again this is this is predicated on their request for a 24 by 24 versus a smaller correct okay I think I've that's answered my question well
[36:33] Building Official: the question we have done their homework to see where it could go. We'll give them that.
[36:38] Chair: Sure. I respect that.
[36:41] Suzanne LaCroix: I did some photos as well. I don't know if you want, I only made one copy. Just other locations on the street that we live on where we've got less than four feet between buildings. And what we're looking to do, as Suzanne said, there's nothing else in that area. We're not going to be close to anything other than the property lines, which Kip and his wife have said, it's okay. You know, you're going to be within the 10 foot mark. I don't know if you want to look at these or not, but.
[37:14] Board Member: Do you know when those buildings were placed there? I mean, that makes a difference. They weren't done in the last. This was done in the last three to five years. And it's four feet from the property line? It's
[37:24] Suzanne LaCroix: less than four feet from the property line. This was a rebuild, which is probably three feet from the property line this is probably two feet from the property line that's an old one granted kip's neighbor has a hangover which there's no foundation under it but they gave them the okay to put that add-on and that was okay this shed it's probably got two feet from the neighbor's property line these are older so i won't show you those this shed was just put in this past year less than three feet from the property line actually less than one foot on one end of it
[38:06] Board Member: is the property line so how is that happening jp are they without seeing the photos and knowing
[38:13] Building Official: the addresses if some of those are new houses ma'am are those some of those are new houses as well the they're mostly rebuilds yeah so rebuilds you if you're in violation of a setback if say you're at four feet from the property line and we're at shoreline zoning and land use ordinances you're allowed to maintain that four feet so new construction as in brand new brand new shed brand new house would not be approved if the house the houses are probably gone to the planning board to get approval because of the fact that if you're if you're variety in violation part of the ordinances went into effect. You can maintain your current nonconformity setback, if that makes any sense. Yeah.
[39:05] Chair: So just for my clarity, it is possible that a garage could be built on this property in a different location on a smaller scale.
[39:19] Building Official: Yes, as long as they meet their side setbacks.
[39:21] Chair: Right, exactly. And where the shed is currently, they have at least enough of a structure size to play with it of a 12 by 12.
[39:32] Board Member: Or 12 by 24.
[39:33] Building Official: I don't know where the rear of the shed is currently to the bog, which is still considered the high water. So they can maintain that 70 feet and they can come up as close to 20 feet to the road. right
[39:52] Chair: so there's there's that there's an option there it's just not a 24 by 24 garage
[39:58] Speaker D (unidentified): right we consider that as well okay or two 12 by 12 garage i mean yeah you can go double deep we have enough length we could go double deep absolutely i will just share that i was on the
[40:10] Board Member: board of appeals in freeport we had 50 foot spaghetti lots and the creativity of some people to come up with ways to park cars was virtually amazing and the slopes that i yeah not heated i'm not a proponent of heated driveways by any stretch however yeah any
[40:35] Chair: other questions from the board at this time any other comments you'd like to make the only thing whether it means
[40:46] Board Member: anything or not but that property in front of the shed is right now where the garage would be that area in front between there to the street is also like a parking that right now we use it as a parking area and it's you know enough to spread from two to three car width versus you know there's plenty of room but that's it's also the turnaround area for the town plow right
[41:10] Suzanne LaCroix: okay so for us to go double deep makes it a challenge for the plow people is this a town road or is this a right-of-way where town plows? It's I think it's considered a right-of-way we have a we have a local unofficial association for the road maintenance okay so and the town does plow it but we had to do some work to bring it up to code.
[41:35] Building Official: Do you have a winter maintenance agreement for the town? Yes. Yeah so it's a town plowed road it's a private road with winter maintenance agreement for them to do the plow.
[41:45] Board Member: So you have to maintain the turnaround for yes. And we've had to in our role, we had to do quite a bit of work to make sure that was using the plow.
[41:54] Building Official: And you just renewed that this year?
[41:57] Suzanne LaCroix: Yeah, we just got the paving done probably two weeks ago.
[42:00] Building Official: I'm at the winter maintenance agreement with the town. Oh yeah, yes. So it is a private road to winter maintenance with the town.
[42:08] Board Member: And just for my implication, where is the turnaround around if you could just show me on
[42:18] Speaker D (unidentified): photo what if you photo two can you show me right
[42:23] Board Member: here on this oh sure this was the approved location correct yeah so the so the turnaround
[42:31] Suzanne LaCroix: for the town plow okay the town will they'll come down plow into this spot up here and then
[42:36] Board Member: back in and drive up so you could do things here except the chambers are in the way okay
[42:41] Suzanne LaCroix: We've already taken care of the chambers because we were prepping to put the garage here. So we've moved the septic, taken out half the chambers.
[42:55] Chair: You said there's two dwellings on the property currently? Yes. And either one, both have crawl spaces?
[43:03] Suzanne LaCroix: No. The one that we live in year-round has a crawl space. The other one has a basement that's finished.
[43:12] Chair: Okay. And who is that? do you rent that out we rented seasonally okay so you do a potential
[43:20] Suzanne LaCroix: storage there we have yeah we could if I mean if we rent it out we have rented out in the winter to college students I've been doing that for a while but it's a it's a finished space so yeah we surely don't want to put our lawn mowers
[43:36] Board Member: and our snow machines yeah what about machines but when comes snow blowers in the basement, because it's really a finished area in the camp.
[43:47] Chair: Would a 12 by 12 shed take care of, like, the snowblower and some of the other seasonal?
[43:54] Board Member: Oh, we also need it for our cars, too. You know, we want to use that because, you know, we have to, every time we have a snowstorm, and part of it is my issue because I, with my back now, I can't go out and take snow off and brush all this snow off the cars and all that. So we would like to have that garage as well to put our cars in and take care of them and not have to, you know, worry about it every time there's snow, you know, snow thing going on. So I think we've pretty much maximized everything that we presently have available to us, but it's not comfortable to do, that's all. So, you know, having the garage would be a lot easier for us, you know, because I'm not getting any younger in either shade. I don't believe anyone in the room is. No, I'm pretty sure.
[44:47] Chair: Any other questions? Anything else from the public? Then I'm going to close the public. I'll take a motion to close the public session. All in favor?
[45:05] Board Member: We want the board to discuss before we go to vote.
[45:08] Chair: I'm closing the public session. Okay, yes. I apologize. All in favor? Close the public session? All right. All right. So let's take a few minutes and discuss what we've heard as it applies to the four criteria and see if the board has any points of interest or pieces that they want to discuss among ourselves. any
[45:34] Board Member: comments? I'm an engineer but I've seen many other things and apparently the first person you had doing the work had an idea of how to do it and I think based on that there is a way to do it and there are other options in the property rather than granting a variance to put a large garage all the way across the street. It would be nicer to have it really close wouldn't it? It would be nice to have yeah and i think that there are yeah so we're talking we're talking i'm sorry that's fine because
[46:11] Chair: you know unless we want to have them come back up okay no thank you very much for that i just
[46:16] Board Member: as a reminder yeah okay so i believe that there are other options i on the property as the property currently exists on the property even with the existing driveway it will not be interfering with the plow turnaround which will impact the rest of the neighbors on the road yeah i would agree
[46:34] Chair: i mean that's the problem i'm having this i'm sort of like a bit of a hung jury on that piece but i don't i mean other than testimony from the applicants i didn't see any hard evidence to say yup what was approved is not is not feasible at all nobody can do it or modulate it or do it in
[46:50] Board Member: such a way to make it work or on a smaller scale if i had an engineering survey put in front of me this you know a study that said it cannot be done here's why stand by pe but that's a quite an expense to ask you need to do however that was certainly wavy right yeah that's one of the bigger
[47:09] Chair: sticking points i have on that piece and that there is testimony that there is alternatives for storage space not necessarily garage but storage space and that they could it looks like they could pursue a smaller version of a garage, just not a 24 by 24 size garage. That's another option that's available.
[47:30] Board Member: Or even two garages, one across the street. I mean, there are other
[47:33] Chair: options. Be creative, I suppose. Yeah. A lot of money when you're on fixed income. And I think the biggest issue is, in terms of the criteria other than that one we just talked about was the fact that the first standard is where i'm concerned that i don't they've got two dwellings they just testify they rent out one of the dwellings so they've got supplemental income i mean there's value in the law let's talk about income levels yeah so i 'm concerned they're not gonna the standard the first one's not gonna be met because they can clearly get a reasonable return without the garage versus having to they have to have the garage to get
[48:15] Speaker D (unidentified): a reasonable return on their property yeah i don't see how you don't you have late property that's not that doesn't yield a reasonable return even if it's just to make him buy his property
[48:23] Chair: that's the concern i have right and again i understand what they've asked for and i understand the need and whatnot but these are you know variance requests the town has very strict variances and they have to meet these four criteria and i think it's a struggle from my perspective. Any other deliberation or discussion?
[48:45] Board Member: One more question. The turnaround for the fire department, can that be relocated somewhere else? Oh, it's not, it's not involved. That's what I asked about, because we've gone through it down on Road 19. And it's an owner's process potentially. But a separate issue from this. It's up, it's up near the, it's up above where the new garage with a proposed garage slash shed. So I guess I'm not
[49:19] Chair: it's a separate issue. We're not going to address that. But I understand what they're what they're asking about. But that's not pertinent to request the applicant at hand, or the application request for a variance at hand. All right, anything else before we take a vote?
[49:35] Board Member: Well, the shoreland zone also prohibits this as well.
[49:42] Chair: What? The garage? No. No? No. They can certainly build a structure. Right. It just has to be within the setback requirements, the size of the structure, given the lots, how the lot conforms. The new size would not fit or it would fit? Well, that's the dilemma I think Steve and I, at least, are having with this, is that we just don't know. It was approved. We have testimony that at least one contractor said probably wouldn't be able to do it because of the grade here, but I don't have enough evidence to say that it can't be done by somebody else the size they want. But if they could have it, they've had approval. They already had a permit issue for the specific size they're asking for right the proposed garage was right
[50:37] Board Member: Right approved garage is right in here. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah right in there and they're asking for the garage over here. Yes, okay
[50:44] Building Official: Yeah, JP mr. Chairman if I can maybe help a little bit sure the Shed currently is 70 feet from the high-water mark. They can't go any closer than 70 feet from the high-water mark okay so if they can if they can meet the front setback of 20 feet so got the 24 feet then they can't go into closer than 70 feet okay they're already allowed
[51:10] Board Member: that right now so there's 70 feet here that's why they in the garage the garage go all the way 20 feet to the right-of-way
[51:20] Building Official: The current location of the approved meets all setbacks. They do have the 200 and something square feet of impervious they have to get rid of to help offset the garage, but it can be done.
[51:42] Board Member: Yep. Thank you. Anything else? All right.
[51:48] Chair: I'm going to call the votes, the vote for each of the criteria. So I'm going to make a motion that land in question.
[51:55] Board Member: let me call the vote i'd just like to ask a question sure what we have done what i had done in a different town we've made our concerns known to the applicant and asked them if they would like to withdraw the application or have us rather than say no take what we discussed into account and come back potentially a new solution rather than have to resubmit the entire
[52:20] Chair: our application well you can certainly make a motion that if you feel that the board wants to entertain that but i don't think it's necessary okay it's not a standard operating procedure board given the facts and given the application i mean that would be an option that you could make a motion for if you feel that's okay warranted but it's not it's not standard
[52:43] Board Member: operating procedure i guess okay no every town's different and that's why i'm asking
[52:47] Chair: sure i'm a new board member yeah i think there are some circumstances where a board might be swayed to do that given things but it's not required okay are you making a motion steve no
[53:00] Board Member: it was just we were we had four or five applications per month and very frequently a minor modification to a design would allow it to come into the requirements of what the board members felt was appropriate and again i in this case i understand what you're saying
[53:15] Chair: yeah i completely appreciate that point i do think that the again that doesn't solve the point made earlier of a permit was granted for this and it's unknown whether that is really
[53:29] Board Member: a doable site i think that's the struggle i'm having with this so okay i understand thank you
[53:35] Chair: for sure absolutely all right anybody want to make a motion on that topic or anything else [Board Member: Council. Okay.] So we're going to take these criterias. The first one is criteria one is I'll make a motion that the land in question cannot yield a reasonable return unless a variance is granted. Second. Second. Any further discussion? All in favor? All opposed? Okay. So the need for a variance is due to the unique circumstances of the property and not to the general conditions in the name point. Second. Any further discussion? All in favor?
[54:31] Speaker D (unidentified): Opposed? I don't have enough information. Abstentions?
[54:36] Board Member: I'm going to abstain from that. Abstention?
[54:40] Chair: So that passes. Did you abstain or oppose? You opposed, Steve, right? I opposed because we
[54:47] Board Member: don't have enough information for that one okay correct or i do not have enough information okay
[54:52] Chair: that's fair enough all right criteria three i'll make a motion that the granting of a variance will not alter the essential character of the locality second any further discussion all in favor unanimous and last criteria i'll make a motion that the hardship is not the result of action taken by the applicant or a prior owner any further discussion all in favor opposed for opposed and I'm gonna abstain on this one because that's the one I don't I don't have enough information to say yay or nay on that based on what I've heard for testimony this evening okay so that concludes the vote unfortunately we can't grant you a variance for this evening but i do believe that maybe there are other options you can explore as a compromise that's up to you certainly go back to the town and work with jp and staff and see if there's some other type of arrangement that can be made can i just ask a question if you want to come to the board you may
[56:12] Board Member: On the variance issue, the owner of the property here and they signed the letters and everything, it didn't really bother them because, like I said, it's all trees and nothing's going to live there ever. Doesn't that in itself say that the variance has been met?
[56:32] Chair: No, because that's just an abutter. It's just an abutter basically saying that we're comfortable with you doing what you want to do, but the town supersedes the town's policies and its setback requirements and zoning rules supersede just the fact that a neighbor says, yeah, we're okay with you doing it.
[56:53] Board Member: Now, when Stacey showed you some of those photos of people that have recently done, put structures alongside without any, you know, without consideration of how close or how far they were from a member or a neighbor, because in the past, if you had property that was old, you have to help me with this, but in the past, could we have been, what am I wanting to say? grandfathered into some of this since we've owned this property so long?
[57:26] Chair: I think JP spoke to that earlier this evening. Every situation, every butter situation is different. So it depends on the existing dwellings and what was there before. But I think he already sort of spoke to that particularly as it related to we spent time in the shed, the shed piece of it. And there's some setback requirements in grandfathering of the shed 70 foot. Or garages. Right. But every,, I can't speak to your neighbors. Every situation is different. I can only speak to your particular property. [Board Member: Okay. All right.] Any other further business this evening? I'll make a motion. Awesome. Thank you. Second. Any further discussion? All in favor to adjourn the meeting? All right. November 16th, 2026 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting is now adjourned. Thank you.