Gorham School Department Presents Safety Plan for Narragansett Elementary Gas Issues
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening, everybody. My name is Heather Perry. I'm the superintendent of schools here in the Gorham School Department. I wanted to welcome you here tonight. Hopefully you were welcomed nicely out in the entrance by Principal Epler as well. And hopefully you were able to get a handout for tonight as well. I want to make sure you get that handout because we have a TV up here to project. Some of the things we're going to talk about are at a little bit smaller pictures. So having that there in front of you will hopefully be easier to follow. And also I want you to note the QR code that's on the front that'll get you to the digital version of this live presentation as well, so you can grab that at any time that you might want that. Okay, so again, welcome. I've already introduced myself. I'm going to introduce in just a moment some of our guests here, but before I get there I do want to make sure to just also let you know that we have a couple of school committee members here in the audience. So Nicole Michelle is there, anybody else in the school committee here? No, okay. So call Michelle and our school committee members, too, so you can also chat with them if you'd like. But let me go ahead and just get right down to things. The purpose of tonight is really to first inform all of you about what's been happening thus far, give you whatever information that we have. So we're going to offload some information onto you. Hopefully we'll keep it relatively simple and easy to understand. And then the real purpose of tonight, though, is for you all, if you have questions that aren't answered by the information that we share momentarily, that we want you to ask those questions. And my goal is that everybody leaves here tonight with a clear understanding of what's been happening, sort of why, at least what we know of why, to this point, and then what we're going to do about it, and then that you have any of your concerns or questions answered as you leave here tonight, okay? So if that's not the case, I don't want you to leave. Okay, well, I don't want to be here all night either, but I do want to stay, and if you have questions, please answer them. So we have a great group of people here tonight. It's not just going to be me in the microphone, although I will do my share of talking. We've got some really good individuals here in the audience, and I call them our Unified Response Team. These are folks that work closely with the schools. They are community partners. They are business partners. They are friends of the Gorham School Department and Narragansett, it specifically, and so I want to introduce these folks to you. First of all, from the school department, I want you to know Norm Justice. Norm, if you would stand to just sort of say hi to everybody. Thank you. He's our facilities director in the community of Gorman has been how many years? More, it's quite beautiful. You don't want to date yourself. Okay, I've been here 12 years, and he was here before me. How's that? All right, so that's quite a few years. I think, I think you know Erin Epler. Erin, I'm gonna wave your hand. She's the principal at Narragansett Elementary School. Then a special guest here tonight, too, from our home fire department. We have Chief Ficken, Chief, right there. And we also have Assistant Fire Chief Phil Callen. Phil, thank you. All right, and then from our utility and engineering sort of partnerships, we have Eric Steele and Michael Sano from J&J. There we go, thank you. And then we also have Joseph Renda and folks from UTIL. Thank you. All right, excellent. And so these are our partners, folks that we work with very closely to make sure that our schools remain safe places for our students and for our community. They're going to talk to you a little bit tonight. Some of them will talk more, and then we'll go forward. But let me talk about the agenda for tonight then. The agenda for tonight. First, I want to talk a little bit about the timeline of events. There have been, as you all know, several issues, and I want to talk to you about what those issues have been, and sort of the timeline of when they have occurred. So we're going to talk about those. Then we're going to talk a little bit about the science of natural gas, whatever its properties, sort of those kinds of things. And then we're going to talk a little bit about the plan that we have moving forward. There's the introduction, so I've got to keep up with this. All right. And the plan that we have moving forward, and then the ending part is open dialogue. However, I want you to know that as we're going, if you have a question about, like, a term that's used or what something means, I don't want you to wait until the end to ask that question. So if there's something as we're talking that you want to have an answer to, just raise your hand, okay, and we'll keep going. But then we'll have definitely a designated time at the end for open conversation, okay? All right, so that's kind of the agenda for the evening. All right, Norm, I'm going to invite you up here. You're going to help me out with this. All right, are you ready? Okay. And I'm going to go through this, and I might pass the microphone over to you. We only have one microphone, so this is going to be fun. We're going to demonstrate how to share things and have models for students. Okay. So, all right. There have been several issues. We categorize them in two sort of different places. One was what we call sort of an isolated incident. That was back in 2021. And we call it an isolated incident because it really doesn't have much of a relation to some of the other things that are happening right now. And there certainly was many years in between those two things that occurred. I don't know, Norm, did you want to talk a little bit about what that, what actually happened on November 4th of 2021?
[5:23] Speaker B (unidentified): So within the facility we have gas-fired boilers, and this happened to be a gas-fired domestic hot water heater, and it's associated as part of the new modular construction. It provides domestic hot water for that area, and what happened is we actually have in both the boiler room and this particular room a detection system, a gas detection system. It became code, I think, in 21 to add gas detection to any room that has an appliance that uses natural gas appropriate. So what happened was that detector detected gas, my department came as they normally do and their meters couldn't detect anything. And shortly thereafter, Unitel was in Chief Fickert's office and they said, look, let's go check it out and see if we can find anything. At the same time, we had Johnson and Jordan on site doing an evaluation to determine what the problem was. They weren't detecting any of the gas, but the units detected a faint amount of gas. And so what we determined is essentially we were going to replace that burner unit, the regulator associated with it, and add ventilation to that particular room. So it wasn't a quick answer, but we actually also suspected it might be the gas detector itself, checked with the supplier, and they said they really failed. So we definitely were detecting some sort of gas. It was ever so minute, but again, we just did all the bells and whistles and replaced the regulator, the burner assembly, and added ventilation to that.
[7:18] Speaker A (unidentified): So basically, out of an abundance of caution, we really did a lot of work on that particular one. And one thing that was clear on that day in November was that there was a very quick response. Norm talked about the fire chief was right there, J&J was there, UNITIL was there as well. And then we come to what we're calling the cluster, and that could be referenced in that way in multiple different ways. Right, say that the cluster in this case, we're talking about as in terms of a cluster of things happening relatively quick succession to one another. And so and in what could be what could be determined as a related event. So we've got four different things that have that stem from last year, last fall, right about this time last fall. And then we had a second event in December last year, which is a little bigger, and then we had the two most recent ones this fall, both on the 18th and November 4th. And we're going to talk a lot about safety here in a minute so that you understand the level of safety, the level of risk that we're talking about here. But again, I want to get you through what has happened and what we know about what has happened first, and then we'll talk about that. Okay, so would you do you want to run through each of
[8:25] Speaker C (unidentified): them and all of them, or what do you want to do, you your name, either way.
[8:30] Speaker B (unidentified): All right, what's wrong, okay, well, we'll try to be a little quicker. The first incident, I don't have a fifth, was a failure of a regulator. We'll talk about regulators a little a little later, their purpose, but then within the gas crane assembly and the regulator failed, so it was emitting gas to the atmosphere and it was detected. And once we determined it was a faulty regulator, JJ was on site and replaced it, that particular regulator. We found a wood chip in there, which was a little concerning. December 8 through the 10th was a prolonged incident. That's when we evacuated all the kiddos to St. Ann's, and we were several days trying to go through and determine what the cause of the gas odor was. Again, UNITEL and J&J were here, fine apartments, all of them are always present. We were several days trying to determine and find a source of the odor. I think on the very last day, we found that the actual meter was chattering at Unitell's main gas station. The meter was chattering and emitting gas at the meter, which was undersized at the time. Their techs have actually recognized that when we start troubleshooting looking at a loan, but it demonstrated it was a couple days into the process, so that was immediately replaced. Again, just recently in October, on a weekend, we actually had parents on the football field report a gas owner. Again, by department units held respondent in that case. We actually had another regulator that was immediately, I guess, the atmosphere, it was very obviously, they picked that up very quickly, and again, J&J once. You to tell the data helps us identify, it's all changed as a polymer case, and that was quickly replaced again. So those were two incidences where we know we have known we've had regulated failures, and so we're looking into that further. We'll talk about that later. And the last issue most recently was this last week, Erin detected an odor within the building, immediately evacuated by a pilot and responded. They were unable to detect any levels of gas. Unitel also responded, and with their sophisticated equipment, they could not detect any levels of gas. Because of the wind, everyone noticed the odors, it led us to believe one of our make-up air units, that is gas-fired, that provides fresh air and heated air to the west wing here. We lean towards it being something in that unit, and as we began to implement additional procedures, we suspected it may have misfired that particular morning. We haven't been able to verify that. We have the company that installed the equipment back today to further investigate it, and we're leaning, they have one other, the recommendation that came out from that message all.
[12:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, so there's sort of the technical stuff and a reminder basically what has happened to this to date regarding gas here at Narragansett elementary school, and I hope that one of the things that you can see through this timeline is a number one, that there has been identification, a very quick identification of a gas smell, a very quick reaction of a gas smell by all the parties involved, and a focus on maintaining safety of students and staff at all times. And if that means we've had to cancel school or delay school or those kinds of things, that's what we're gonna do, and we'll continue to do that sort of thing in order to ensure the safety of our students and our staff. Now, and just again in a moment, I'm gonna talk a little bit more about the safety risk that's involved here, and what I hope that you walk out of here understanding in a moment, and we're gonna have Kenny and Phil talk a little bit about this, is just the level of risk that we're at, because you need to understand that when you smell the gas, it's a very, small level of risk at that point in time. There's a lot that has to happen to get to the big level of risk, and we'll talk about that in a minute. But I hope you also understand that you can see some patterns in this. We see a couple of issues with regulators, gas regulators, and we're laser-focused on figuring out what those things are at this point in time. And then you see a couple of other issues that are not quite as directly related to the regulators. So let me talk a little bit more about the regulators themselves. So this is a wonderful diagram of a regulator. Now, I want you to know that I did not draw this. I will admit that this was AI generated, but I did verify that it is an accurate depiction of a regulator. So I did my homework on that, just modeling for students and others how to use AI. But this is basically what a regulator looks like and sort of how it operates. And I want people to understand that when we smell the gas outside of the building or in some cases when we smell it inside of the building, it's actually the safety features themselves kicking in. So it's, it's, it's actually kind of a good, not a good thing, because we don't want to smell gas at all, but if we had to smell gas, it's a good thing that we're smelling it in the way that we are, because this is what the safety features are for. And so these regulators, know how many regulators do we have across in Narragansett? Over 40. There are over 40 regulators in this one school. Norm, how many do we have in the rest of the district?
[14:58] Speaker D (unidentified): Six or eight. Five to
[15:00] Speaker A (unidentified): six, yeah. There's like five to six in the rest of the district. I want people to understand that one of the reasons why Narragansett is unique in this is because of the structure of the modular spaces that we've constructed over here in the expansions. And that's because each of those modular spaces basis has its own individual heating system that's associated with it, unlike our other schools, which were constructed as schools all at once, and they have a singular heating system, if that makes sense. I'm oversimplifying things here, but I want you to understand that's why Narragansett is unique and different, and why we might not see any of these things happening in some of our other schools. Although we have had issues in the past with regulators, I remember even in my time here, we had an issue at the high school, and I think that I think that was probably about it. Maybe there was one at Village.
[15:46] Speaker B (unidentified): At the middle school.
[15:48] Speaker A (unidentified): At the middle school. That was it.
[15:49] Speaker B (unidentified): Often kitchen related, but with gas.
[15:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Okay. So, anyway, what I want you to see is in here, this diagram is depicting, like, it's got a little piece of, you mentioned a wood chip a moment ago, but it's got a little particle that's right there. It's that arrow is pointing to that particle. And what generally is happening when the regulator expels gas into the atmosphere, is that's a safety feature. When it has a particle that's inside of that, rather than have it get into the system where it can cause more significant issues, it actually will just shut the regulator down. The regulator then will just expel the gas into the atmosphere outside of the building. Okay? Did I do that okay? Do you want to add anything? You did it awesome. I didn't put that.
[16:37] Speaker B (unidentified): I've been learning. With this one, folks will tell you it won't meet code because it doesn't have a sniffer release on it.
[16:46] Speaker A (unidentified): So my AI-generated image does not meet code, but ours do meet code because it has a sniffer on the exterior. Thank you, Norm. All right, so that's one thing. I also want you to understand that, okay, so we just talked about the fact that these regulators might be spelling gas into the outside. Then how is it that we're spelling gas inside of the building? Well that's relatively easy to understand as well, and that has to do with the fact that our air systems our heating systems and air systems in the school are constantly exchanging air with the outside of the building. So our air is done we're constantly exchanging air, and so if there's gas outside the building there's might be some it's picked up by an air handler kind of what's being shown here, and what could then be smelled inside. You want to add
[17:35] Speaker B (unidentified): Anything more? Well, I was going to say this may be what we experienced last week, because the, as I mentioned, a DMA cup game unit that supplies the end of this west wing is located out in this corner of the building here where all the gas supply comes in. But this unit itself out there has its own burner on it, so we're leaning towards thinking that it was either malfunction of that particular makeup air unit or exhaust from that unit itself that was brought in through the ventilation system.
[18:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you Norm. So that kind of helps to get out a little bit of how you smell gas inside the building when the majority of the issues that we've been experiencing are actually happening outside the building. Alright, so this next piece is very important, so I'm going to take some time on this one, and this is where we ask Kenny and Phil to come on up or talk a little bit if you would about the science of understanding what happened and basically the safety risk that we're talking about here. Simple, thank you all very much for being here tonight.
[18:47] Speaker E (unidentified): The way that I try to explain this so that I can understand it easily is understanding a level of concern versus a level of risk, okay? Who's a parent that has a child that goes to this school? So the only other time that I've responded multiple times to a building with an order of gas, a concern for gas, is actually my daughter's daycare, okay? So I can empathize with you responding there in my role as the assistant fire chief and managing those incidents repeatedly. Why is this happening, right? But it's important that we understand the level of concern. How much gas do you expect to be in your child's school? Zero. So when there's any, are you concerned? Agreed. Me too, right? But when we smell gas, we have a level of concern. Very rarely, when we smell gas, do we have a level of risk. So mercaptan, so natural gas is an odorless and colorless substance. And so that we can detect it, is required that this odorant, mercaptan is added to it. So anytime gas is moving, whether it's over the road, in a pipeline, anything like that, there's mercaptan added to it, which is measured in parts per billion. So risk with gas is when it goes boom. For it to go boom, there has to be a certain level of gas within the environment. And we call the minimum level of that the lower explosive limit. So when I get to the lower explosive limit, I can't possibly go boom. Everything before that is concern. So, the example that I used in explaining this last week is, if I want to color this entire TV screen red to get to LEL, to get to boom, I can smell that percaptan, the odorant, and my concern begins probably at about one single period there at the end of the threshold. It's an engineered level of safety that is incredibly risk-averse, okay? So, as the fire department, you've heard earlier in this presentation when we responded here, we have not been able to detect gas. Because as the fire department, we care about life safety, okay? So we respond here and we look for LEL, because when I detect LEL, I know I have a life safety problem. At no point during our response here have we ever detected any level of LEL. We talked about an event in November of 2021 when a combustible gas detector activated. That happens at, in this particular instance, about 2.5% of the way to LEL. My meter activates at 10% of the LEL. So when my guys are in here metering, they have a built-in 10 to 1 safety valve. So if their meter activates, the fire department meter activates, that volume of gas has to expand about 10 times for us to get to risk. Okay? So odorant, mercaptan, the smell, very, minute in the environment, and you can smell it. Potentially, and thankfully so far in our instances here, a long way from risk.
[22:13] Speaker A (unidentified): You want to tell them? Did you guys want to add anything? Did he cover it pretty well? He did training with them. Nice. That's when you know the training is working, when they can just do that again. Alright, good. You know, this is a great place to pause right now. Do people have questions about what we've talked about thus far? Yes, what do you have a question? Take them one at a time. All right, what is the lifespan of a regulator? Do we know that at all? And I can tell you what right now, the regulators should not be failing at the rate that they're failing. Does that answer your question? If you're trying to get out, should they be feeling? We think that there's, there might be something there, but we're not sure. We're still researching that because the typical Regulator doesn't because these are relatively new modules. Yes, they were installed in different phases, so they're not all in the same batch. So that might be something there to think about, but they're all relatively new because they've been installed as part of the module expansion. It's a wonderful question. No, there's no warranty I'm not that I'm aware of. No. Yeah, well then we'll do one more question I think. I'm gonna walk because I don't want to make sure somebody we are doing safety checks. Every day. Yes. Who's doing them? That's actually a combination Mrs. Epler has developed a fine nose, yeah, so she's one, but also our friends at J&J are doing them daily. What's that? And our facilities people are doing them daily. And I just want to be clear that J&J does not have to do them, they are stepping up as credible partners to help us with this. Yep, one more question, all right. Yes, yep.
[24:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Hold on, Jay, hold on, I want to get the microphone on this one.
[24:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Twice a year we do complete HVAC maintenance on every building in the district.
[24:39] Speaker B (unidentified): We are also going to be extra diligent on this and we sent a contract over so once a month we'll go through the entire exposed gas system in this building.
[24:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Good question. Yes, Kenny.
[24:55] Speaker F (unidentified): We've had gas installed and grown for better than 20 years. Every house that has a regulator could have one or two regulators in there. Falcon Crest up on Ford Hill Road that 200 plus over 55. We have not had a regular failure. The only place we've had them is right here in Arragansett on the roof. So that's why we're leaning towards a public defective or a bad batch. But other than that, 20 years and we've never had this problem other than Tilton.
[25:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you Kenny. This is highly unusual and we are looking at that more deeply but right now we haven't been able to certainly identify that just yet. Yeah yes all right any other questions for now I'm going to keep going and then we'll pass more. Yeah so I'm going to go ahead and jump in the next slide because that's what we're going to talk about next is the prevention pieces. So let me do that and then if you still have a question after that then please ask it again okay. All right, so I'm going to keep going. All right, so here's some anticipated prevention and clear next steps for the schools. So here's what we're talking about, and folks can jump in and help if I'm missing anything. But first of all, we are looking to install six new detectors in key areas in this building alone. Now, we already have some because we're actually above code. Well, we're with code, right, in terms of already having some with the equipment that we have. But we're going to add six more in key areas at the Narragansett School for that purpose to try to be more proactive and identifying. Okay, so that's one thing, and I hope what you'll see as we talk about these things is that it's not, it's not like a single answer here, folks. What we're trying to do is a bunch of little things and then maybe a couple bigger things. All right, so this is one of the smaller little things we're layering things on top. The next piece that we're working on is we're instituting what I would call strict daily operational check-ins with our partners, Johnson and Jordan. Now, I want to be clear that this is not a, like they're not going through and fully testing every single component, but they are walking through, and they're looking at and smelling and using their detectors to assist us every day to ensure that the building is open, is safe to open. So that's happening, so that's the daily check-in, okay? Then on top of that, once again, we are, with our partners, Johnson and Jordan, we are also instituting monthly pipe evaluations. That's what Eric was just talking about a moment ago, that we're instituting a full check of the system itself every month. And that, again, we have over 40 regulators. How many feet of, you said it? There's almost 2,000 feet. Feet of this kind of piping on the roof of these modular expansions. And so that's not a small task that they're doing once a month, but thank you for doing that. That's a great preventative measure as well. So we're doing those things preventatively. [Speaker C (unidentified): Then we're looking] at two larger options, or two bigger options. Well, and I would say the third one if we need to get there. But the first one that we're looking at is because we've noted a couple of different times that there might have been some particles associated with the regulators, as I showed you on that diagram a moment ago, that maybe there's some particles getting into these regulators that are causing the regulators to fail and kind of vent into the outside. One of the things that we are thinking of trying to do, but we don't know if we can do it yet, so we're engineering, we're sort of asking this question, could we perhaps place some filters in the pipes just before the regulators so that if there are particles, it would catch the particles before it got into the regulators? Now, the question we have, and we don't know the answer to yet, is whether that can be done and still safely operate the system because the system operates on a certain level of pressure. And if we don't have that pressure, then we might not be able to operate the system. So that's something that we're looking at and we're investigating right now whether that's possible. So that's one big ticket item. Am I doing okay so far? Okay, good. Another big-ticket item is that we're looking, and Kenny and Eric both mentioned this, we're looking into the batch of regulators more distinctly. Is it a bad batch? If it is a bad batch, then perhaps we have a mechanism of being able to replace those regulators. And if we do find it's a bad batch, we're probably going to proactively figure out how to do that anyway, whether the company originally will pay for it or not. We're going to have to find that out. But we're looking at that as a potential here but whether or not it is actually the whole batch of regulators that might be an issue here so we're kind of going through and investigating that as we go the other thing so these are kind of the
[30:01] Speaker D (unidentified): mechanical things that we're doing oh yes sir yes we placed the order down so
[30:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Electricians will be here on Wednesday, and as soon as the devices arrive,
[30:18] Speaker A (unidentified): so thank you. We hope within a week, maybe a week and a half or two weeks. Very close.
[30:24] Speaker G (unidentified): Thank you for that question. Yes. I was going to ask the same question on both options. What would the timeline be on looking at replacing all the regulators?
[30:32] Speaker A (unidentified): That's a little longer time frame. That's a longer period, because number one, we have to go through an investigation process to say this and this happened so it's got to be like a causal kind of thing and we're not sure that we have that just yet so that's going to take us a little bit longer to figure out we also know that when we built the modular expansions we did so in three distinct phases we don't know the same batch is in all three of those phases and it or if there's parts of them that are the same batch and so we're Trying to, we're trying to chase down serial numbers, which is not as easy as it sounds right now, but that's what we're doing right now. It's going to take a little bit longer probably to do that. Does that answer your question? Yeah, thank you. Any other questions on those preventative pieces? Because I have one more thing I want to talk about, and then I want to make sure to open it up to the conversation. Okay, all right. The last piece I wanted to make sure that was clear about was also, you know, we're trying to anticipate and actively plan response protocols for this potential. We understand the concern, the impact of canceling school late minute. I think it was like 7-15 or something crazy the other morning when I called. Thank goodness you guys all checked your phones and you were able to get that message, and we were able to call school off. That was great, but I can't anticipate that level of communication is going to occur every time. So what we're trying to do is trying to figure out, can we expedite the notifications and the systems? And can we develop contingencies that don't require us to always immediately try to cancel school or get kids home? So we're working on that kind of contingency. When I say those kind of contingencies, what I'm talking about are things like, could we, if we knew something was happening, could we go over to St. Ann's and then maybe bring kids to another school, perhaps? What's up? That's one of those, what is that called, a stink bug? Those are good. He's just trying to find a warm place. He's just trying to find a warm place. I'm good with them. If it were a spider, you'd have had me freaking out, just so you know. Thank you, ma'am. But we're trying to think about what those contingencies could be, perhaps getting students on a bus and taking them to another school and continuing education, and then perhaps getting them back here if we can determine that the school is safe kind of thing, rather than just immediately your problem kind of thing. So we're trying to figure those things out. We're working on those right now, and then again, you know, those added layers of detection so that things can be more quickly assessed and mitigated. And it stems even as far back as last year after that December is incident. We actually added several valves to really help to kind of isolate parts of the system that were not there before. That helps us to more quickly respond to the concerns as we see them so those are some of the big things that we're kind of talking about I know that in this presentation or conversation I haven't had I haven't been able to say okay this is the issue I get that 's frustrating please know that I'm frustrated with that as well but we know we're kind of honing in on a particular issue and we're trying to address multiple phases of this as we go and also, I hope that one of the major themes that you see come out of this conversation here tonight is that we have some really incredible partners that are working with us to try to figure this out, and that we are taking the safety of our students very, seriously. So, and staff, don't forget my staff there, also my staff as well. That's pretty much all I had for the detail stuff, but I still want to exhaust your questions.
[34:20] Speaker H (unidentified): So, have at it, what do you have?
[34:24] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes sir, so it sounds like we don't really know what the issue is, we're narrowing it on it but no, we don't have a single answer. So at what point do we kind of say how many occurrences or cancellations
[34:38] Speaker I (unidentified): does it take before we sort of say we need to look at sending these kids to school where there's not? Is there a threshold of sort of saying, like, this is clearly a repeated kind of equipment failure, and we need to, you know, get these kids to school somewhere else?
[35:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, that's a hard one, because when you have the conversation, if you recall this line about safety, like, in all these circumstances, we know that our children were not unsafe. We were able to smell, and at that level, there's still a lot of things happening before it gets to the risk kind of piece. But with that understanding, we also know there's a large level of concern. I think Phil was great about differentiating between those two things. There's a lot that would have to go into that, and I'm not sure, what we're trying to think of is what is in the overall best educational interest of the students, and having them just attend a school that could be in a gymnasium with not great noise control and just really not good facilities for that level of a number of students is probably not in the best interest. So we're trying to avoid that to be honest video, we're trying to figure out other smaller steps that we can take to mitigate the Risk, as I mentioned a moment ago, could we do it on a one-case basis and then if we've identified the area then bring the students back as quickly as possible because we know that we can identify these things relatively quickly but I don't think there is a single threshold sir I mean if you're asking me for a number I don't think I have it I think what I'm what we try to do is take these circumstances at a time and then see what the cumulative effect is and try to make that decision based on where things are with students and what the impact to students might be at that time I don't that doesn't give you a great answer and I'm sorry but that's the best one I can give you thank you similarly though is there a threshold for
[36:36] Speaker G (unidentified): where you just say, it's time to replace all the regulators,
[36:39] Speaker J (unidentified): and then, like, the end? Yeah, so...
[36:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Like, serial numbers and figure out
[36:42] Speaker H (unidentified): if I have an insurance claim afterwards?
[36:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, and that reminds me, I was going to tell, there was another kind of big box that I didn't have on the slide, but it is also something we're looking at, which is, what would it take if we needed to replace the whole system? And what does that look like? And we are doing, we're looking at that right now. We have some engineers that are looking at that, what it would cost us, what it would take to do that, what would the time frame be? Anything like that is going to be a longer-term kind of thing, because it's not something you can pull off immediately but what about the right like just
[37:08] Speaker G (unidentified): replacing the regulator I know they're not cheap I understand that yeah we don't have a price
[37:13] Speaker A (unidentified): necessarily on what it would take to replace 40 plus regulators I don't know JJ what are you [Speaker D (unidentified): thinking we] could get one see they're willing to give us a price yeah we could get an estimate of what that would take and see we're just not 100 sure that's exactly where it is yet that's but we haven't done that yet, okay, but that's a good question. Other questions? Yes, ma'am.
[37:40] Speaker J (unidentified): When you say long-term, does that mean, like, summer, or, like, one of the breaks, or we have to go somewhere for a certain amount of time? Like, just what is that, what does long-term
[37:53] Speaker A (unidentified): tend to mean? Yeah, so, well, long-term could be a lot of different things, but what I guess I would say at this point in time is that, you know, if these issues continue, then we're going to first try to figure out if there's mitigating, like the smaller steps that we can take to still have students maybe go somewhere for a little bit, fix the issue, and come back. That way, the first step, if that doesn't work out and we still keep seeing these things repeated, then we're probably going to have to look at what would it take to, you know, do the regulators? And that is not something that probably is likely to be able to be done while students are in session. Like, that's not something we could do, all students are in school. I'm, I'm not even sure if something of that magnitude could be done during, like, a break. So it might be a summer kind of thing, and then we have to sort of limp until we get to the summer. Also, depending on costs, it might require a special referendum for the costs. It's not like we have hundreds of thousands of dollars sitting around that we could do something with. So that might also play into the timeline. Does that?
[38:53] Speaker K (unidentified): Yes, sir. I have two questions. First one is, there a point at which the state would require you to make up the days that are missed? Ah, that's a very good question. It's not like they work like snow days or second part of the year. To your problem about the budget, all of the early warning, the checking, is that, is that sort of tossing the going gets the budget, knowing how hard it is to get
[39:18] Speaker A (unidentified): school? Okay, so let me take those two questions one at a time, all right? So first of all, the make up of the days. So state statute would require that if two thirds of the district's population were out at any given time, then I would need to make up the time. So one school at a time does not require it. However, let me be clear that I understand the educational impact of having a school not have school. And if there is a need for us to consider making that up, then we probably will have to consider that. How could that be done? Well, there's a lot of different ways that can be done. Some of it might be done. Well, you could have, I did this as a kid. I would not suggest it, but you can make up Saturdays. You can also, you can also take what would be full days and for a week, you can add an hour to each day, and a week of additional hours is a single day. So there are ways that we can make up that time. Now I will say if we need to, but right now we don't need to, and it's just been a day, and so I'm going to play that by ear, but that might be something we have to talk about if this keeps going on. And then just generally speaking, traditionally, I want you to know that my belief is strongly in the area of snow days, because as a kid I love snow days, and so we do snow days here in Durham. We do five snow days, and then after the fifth snow day, then we'll go to the remote learning modules. So I really love snow days, and I want kids to love them too, so we still do that. Now the second piece of your question was around monetary impacts of what we're talking about right here. I can tell you that the detectors, the additional detectors, that's stuff that we can probably handle within our existing budget without any trouble at all. And I can tell you for a short period of time, our friends at J&J will likely continue to do the daily check-in with a relative small cost associated with it. If it extends beyond that, then there's going to be larger costs that are involved, and we're going to have to either try to plan contingencies within this fiscal year, or we're going to have to start looking at what the alternatives might be for larger pieces. Does that answer your question? We have really great partners, but they're, I mean, they're doing the best that they can, but at some point, if this keeps up, then we have to have money exchanging hands. Yep. Yes? Their point of the state. Norm, are you aware of any, you know, you know, I'm aware of a school in the northern part of the state that actually, like, fire, ruined the entire school. Like, the next day, they couldn't go to school, and the state never stepped in until the following, I think it was two or three years from there, they actually built a new school, but it was a while. That they had to deal with that locally, so I mean, could it happen? Yes, but I wouldn't, I wouldn't count on it.
[42:03] Speaker L (unidentified): Other questions? Yes, ma'am. So what I hear you say, summer is looking probably if there is a regular situation, so we're gonna have to basically figure things out, have to figure this out for the rest of the year. That's a lot of staff. Yes, I know they're great staff, by the way, they're an awesome staff. Yep, and I just, I so I just want to clarify that we're probably, because I work in schools for a living, and most of the work is done in the summer, so I just want to make that clear, yes, so that everybody has that expectation.
[42:42] Speaker A (unidentified): If we have to go in that direction, then we'll have a lot of implications, yes, in that area. And I will also tell you that we have incredible staff. They're awesome. They do what it takes for kids. I think anybody can say that, and they do it without blinking. But we want to try to be cognizant to not take advantage of that for our staff as well, and try to balance that out. But we have incredible staff that are likely willing to do just about anything for our kids, so we'll work with that. Does the risk
[43:10] Speaker G (unidentified): increase at all with winter coming? You know, we've been trying to identify if there's anything like
[43:18] Speaker A (unidentified): that might be associated with this, with temperature differential or pressure differential or different things, and we don't have a clear, based on those five instances we talked about, there doesn't seem to be a clear pattern there, because we've had situations where something has occurred in the warmer weather, and then of course we had that December one that was cold. I remember being out here in the parking lot, that was freezing. So I don't know if we've got a pattern of that yet, but that's something we'll keep an eye on as we continue. Hopefully we won't have any more of these, you know, let's knock on wood, cross our fingers, whatever we can do, and we're not gonna have to continue to deal with this. But in the worst case scenario, I'm always a big believer in Murphy's law, that if it can go wrong, it will go wrong. And so let's prepare ourselves for what the worst case is, which is we're gonna have to limp through some more of this stuff as we go. Yes, ma'am. Yeah, so we've actually mitigated some of that, Mrs. Epler, did you want to talk at all about that? Look at this, our principal is awesome. She can come up and talk a little bit more about the mitigation of some of those concerns, because that's a very real concern. Hey.
[44:38] Speaker H (unidentified): Everybody, so because we've been having to manage some of these situations with children in the building, we've already done some things to try to prevent some of the things. They seem little and not perfect, but for example, a couple of these instances where we left the school, it's been warm weather and we've been lucky a couple times. That has not been the case at all. And so for example, back in December it was so cold it was inside recess, and not to rub it in, but what really happened was kids didn't have their coats and then we were outside, but we were able to get across the street to St. Anne's within 20 minutes. So we were able to clear this entire building, account for every single child, and then get across to a warm space within 20 minutes. None of us felt good about that, so what we've done since then, and once again, we try our very best to solve problems, is we work with our teachers to put coats on the backs of chairs. Normally, when children show up, they hang their coat on the little coat rack, but anytime there's an evacuation, we're trained, we don't stop to put our coats on. So we are working, so our kids are putting their coats on their chairs, so if there's a fire alarm they just grab their coat and they have it. So it seems something little, but that's definitely something that we're working on to make sure that kids are warm. I will say again though to the staff, the teachers and the ed techs that work in this building, they truly have your children's best interests at heart. The last time it happened, we had children huddling around teachers inside their coats, kids that didn't have coats, we had teachers telling kids to put your hands inside your t-shirt so that we can get across the street, and then we were, and we also have our amazing nurse in our building too. So in a situation like that, right away, is there anyone that's hurt, is there anyone that needs medical care, and when that happened in December we didn't have anybody need that type of care. So another thing that we've done too is we've moved where we evacuate to. We've learned that we need to be further away from the building just for safety. Going back to the level of concern versus risk, the level of concern is higher than the level of risk that we've been communicated with, but we know we all line up further away from the building. We also line up where there's faster evacuation routes to St. Anne's Church. So those are some of the small things that we've been doing to make sure that we do have to evacuate quickly, that we're not outside for very long, and that we have a faster direct route that doesn't interfere with the fire response or the police response when we when these things happen in the past and hopefully never happen again.
[47:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Erin, and I would be remiss if I didn't mention the wonderful partners that we also have at St. Ann's Church who allow us to use that facility as an evacuation site if we need to. They're great partners. Yes, just a question, what
[47:43] Speaker K (unidentified): what time are the walk-throughs happening in the morning? Like Ms. Epler, it sounds like you had that at 7.50, but generally, what time are those walk-throughs happening? Just so I can actually put a slide on my-
[47:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, that, you know, that's very good. So did you wanna talk about when the walk-throughs are happening by maintenance or J&J and Aaron? 6 a.m. About 6 a.m. for J&J folks, maintenance about the same time, because they're with them, yep. And then I think Ms. Epler does one a little bit later, right around seven o'clock, so it was actually kind of a double up. Yes ma'am? If
[48:16] Speaker M (unidentified): I understand correctly, there was some gas that was detected inside the school, is that correct? Yes, we believe it came in through an air handler, yes. So my question is, I really appreciated the image about the blue risk, and the immediate risk to life, which is obviously really important, but my question is, especially because my daughter is in the modular classroom, is there a long-term risk to repeated exposure to low-level of gas for children and for SAP?
[48:48] Speaker A (unidentified): That's a really great question. I've done a little bit of research on that. And the levels that we're seeing, I'm not aware of anything that is coming up in the research that I've done at the levels that we're seeing. Again, we're at those very minute levels at this point. So I'm not seeing anything that would be a risk in that way for repeated exposure.
[49:08] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, Joe, did you want to comment on that? Yeah, my technicians are in it literally every day, and our company doesn't that's not something that our company actually tracks is health exposure like that. Again, go back to the levels that you're You're talking about, the odor is being smelled at parts per billion, when that is so low. Our best CGI's, our best combustible gas indicators, are detecting one part per million, so you've got a 10,000 scale there. It's just so low. It's just so low. that yeah and we haven't looked into any health effects or i can't find it for us at that
[50:06] Speaker E (unidentified): at that rate so yeah one other consideration as far as the volume of gas that we're talking our leaders like this tells me right here is what i use if i have a good idea of where the leak or the source might be although that's right that's a snipper by the way I don't have, if anybody has a propane gas stove, and maybe the pilot light goes out, or the burner is on light but doesn't light, I'm going to get that with this. I've got nothing at any point in this school with this. Okay, so the volume of gas that takes, right, because that's still a pretty small amount if you leave the burner on at the end of this. I haven't got anything here.
[50:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Here and then there.
[51:14] Speaker J (unidentified): I will look again
[51:18] Speaker A (unidentified): I can't say that I found anything that said there isn't but I certainly didn't find anything that says there is and I did an extensive search on that but I'll look again to see if I find anything that says that at like what level parts per parts per yeah okay yeah
[51:40] Speaker C (unidentified): we are
[51:44] Speaker L (unidentified): let me get
[51:46] Speaker A (unidentified): that information I probably can get that through our public health at the state level it's all at least ask and we'll see what they have to say yeah OSHA that's more of an adult thing I think they're interested in children We'll give it a shot. We're going to definitely do some more work on that one. All right, and then you were next, and then I think Teresa was in the back. Yep.
[52:10] Speaker G (unidentified): So if there is a gas smell during one of the walk-throughs in the morning,
[52:16] Speaker J (unidentified): but the sniffer doesn't detect anything, so would the plan be to still conduct school?
[52:24] Speaker A (unidentified): We might, you know, anything that, if we smell gas, we're going to react to that, just so you know that's just an automatic because that's what we're trying to do and that's what we're going to do but it might be something where we allow kids to come in and we transport them over to like an alternative location while we figure out what's happening and then perhaps get them back into the building or keep them over there for the remainder of the day whatever those contingency plans like I was talking about that we're working on right now that's probably what we'll try to do if we if we feel like there's there's no anticipated time of figuring out what is causing this then we might you know release early or we might if we have no idea at all we might you know cancel but I'm going to try to mitigate that as much as possible while still keeping children safe Teresa right
[53:16] Speaker C (unidentified): We will always react. We do react. We will always react. Yes, yeah, this reaction or an alarm is a mental or a serious issue that's by staff and students. So I know you can't quantify how long that goes on, and we're talking about they're not being a health risk, but this is there's a there's something that happens. You're talking about anxiety and mental health
[53:45] Speaker A (unidentified): concerns. Absolutely, Teresa, and I want you to know number one that for students especially that we do have support for that if we need to. If your child is experiencing that kind of anxiety or you are, you know, we can maybe work with the with the students directly through our social workers and school and school counselors. For adults not so much at this point in time other than to know that we're doing everything possible and that we're reacting to keep everybody safe. I mean, that's going to be our job every single time is to do that. So it might require flexibility, adaptability, and willingness to change on a dime, but it is something that we will do to keep people safe, and all those actions are being done for that purpose.
[54:30] Speaker O (unidentified): Yes, sir. I may have missed this, but is this primarily the concern is the portable classrooms, right? Not necessarily the main building, but where are we finding these, where are these sniffers detecting these?
[54:41] Speaker A (unidentified): The regulators that are of issue are mostly in the portals. Mostly in the portals, okay.
[54:45] Speaker D (unidentified): On the roof specifically, yeah, yes.
[54:51] Speaker G (unidentified): Ma'am, what is the I appreciate that it's difficult to answer some of the concern with we don't know. Yes, what is the intention and plan to like keep us informed over the next like is this a monthly something we will be updated on or what would you like? I think there are outstanding items personally, and I'm sure you guys do as well, and I guess I would love answers somewhat frequently, okay, or I don't know what
[55:22] Speaker A (unidentified): the key would be. I mean, certainly if there's something, if we get the answers, like actually answers to some of the things that we still have questions on that I've mentioned tonight, I will share that information immediately. But is there like, I mean, I'm happy to do like a weekly update or you know just to kind of keep you informed of where things are out. Is that something that it would be beneficial? Happy to do that. Yeah, okay, happy to do that. Thank you. 're
[55:46] Speaker J (unidentified): Welcome. Yes, ma'am, this is a more logistical question. Has it been thought about doing a late start and then say, like, hey, we'll keep you updated, versus like calling it for the day when things like this happen? Once again, I know
[56:02] Speaker A (unidentified): there's so many logistics and not. Yeah, so that's that's part of what we're doing right now is with those contingency plans I talked about. We're trying to figure out is there a way that we could just bring kids in, hold them for a period of time, and then get them back over here safely, or depending on what time of day it occurs, could we get the students over there, hang on to them for the rest of the day rather than immediately calling. That's what we're trying to do. Yeah. Yes
[56:27] Speaker K (unidentified): sir, I might have misunderstood your answer to that question. Oh, I'm sorry, but what I understand the question to me is like when we have snow in the morning, we start two hours later. Yes, I think that's what you were asking. Yeah, right
[56:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. Oh, you mean calling that in advance as a delay? Yeah, a delay start. I'm sorry, I missed that.
[56:44] Speaker J (unidentified): I'm sorry for doing that.
[56:49] Speaker A (unidentified): It could be something that we consider, again, trying to, the problem is that we don't always know how long it's going to take. Unlike a storm, I can actually look at the radar, and I can say, not with 100% surety, but close, and say, oh, things are going to be improving as we go throughout the day, and I can make that determination. I'm not 100% sure of the timeline of this. We've been able to get it much shorter. I mean, three days in December last year. It took us to figure things out. We're way quicker at this now. But I'm still not sure that I can do it by then, and once you get those mechanisms moving for the buses, trust me. You cannot undo those, and so we have to. It might be something to be better of saying if we are aware of a smell in the morning, this is detected, then we're just going to start the day off in a different location and then go from there. That would probably be the better solution for kids and for communication with families. Other questions? Again, remember my rule, I wanted you to walk out of here tonight having felt like your hand, your questions were answered. Yes, sir, does having all of that piping
[57:58] Speaker N (unidentified): network exposed on the roof, is that accelerating aging of the equipment, like leading to some pretty common installation, if you look at any component?
[58:13] Speaker A (unidentified): So did everybody hear that? And your question was, do having the pipes on the roof accelerate maybe the, you know, the deterioration of the pipes? And the answer is, not any more so than it does at the high school, or at Village, or any other school. That's a pretty common installation, is on the roofs. Yep? Yes?
[58:32] Speaker J (unidentified): So if that's a common inspiration, if you determine for regulators that if you have to replace all of them, would it make more sense to see if the
[58:44] Speaker A (unidentified): board is regulated? Yeah, I mean that's absolutely a conversation around what, at that point in time what you're talking about is installing a new heating system. It would not be the same design as what we currently have and that would be a pretty large Budgetary item or a conversation that would likely require us to look at a special referendum or something larger than that For that kind of dollar figure. That's not a small thing. Yeah, but it's not impossible. It's just not a small thing, right?
[59:26] Speaker L (unidentified): notoriously across the state like they're not passed. If for whatever reason it's not a quorum, which would be crazy, but if they didn't pass it, then like when does it become a monetary issue versus a sustainability issue for staff and kids? Like where do we have that conversation?
[59:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Safety always comes first in any conversation. If we were in that position, then we would have to make some really difficult decisions and choices. I mean, I don't even know what the dollar figures we're talking about at this point so I can't wrap my head around that until we have that information now we are looking at that we're looking at what would that take what would that cost and then at that point I can develop contingencies about what that might look like I know it's gonna be a large dollar figure but is it so large that if the referendum like that would pass that we would have to I don't know close another school and look at something else or move the kids permanently to another school and look and how we would do that I mean those are that's the level of discussion that we're having at that point time which would be a very big conversation and very public so you'd be aware of it for sure yeah no and by the way I disagree to a weekly update so we're doing good yeah we should be fine with that I mean in terms of updating what we know what we don't know where the direction is that we're headed in yeah absolutely I Can't believe it's already close to the holidays, so I mean, where did that go, right? Yeah, snow's going to start flying. No, time does fly. Yes, snow days, I don't know, but yes, weekly, I've agreed to that. We'll set
[1:01:23] Speaker D (unidentified): something up weekly. Yes, I think you guys mentioned Johnson's going every six months. You
[1:01:27] Speaker O (unidentified): got to doing like a PM schedule without a light. Yeah, so is, are the regulators on that PM schedule? Yes, so hypothetically every six months one's probably coming up pretty soon. Is there any update, maybe we could get saying, hey, check all the regulators January 5th,
[1:01:44] Speaker D (unidentified): everything looks good. Yes, you know, I mean, yeah, just know that, you know, we
[1:01:49] Speaker A (unidentified): check all the regulators six months ago and they all look good then too, but yes.
[1:01:53] Speaker O (unidentified): Well, no, that's, I mean, yeah, but at least give us some peace of mind, you know what I mean, that for the next few months in the winter hopefully we don't have to
[1:02:01] Speaker A (unidentified): worry about it, you know. Yeah, again, I'm gonna keep you informed on a weekly basis until you guys tell me not to anymore, so you'll have to yell at me for sending too much information out. Anything [Speaker J (unidentified): else?] Did we meet our rule? Okay, if not, I'll stick around. I know some of our friends here will stick around if you need, if you want to address one-on-one. Happy to do that, but thank you for your time, thank you for your questions, and thank you for your commitment to the schools. Appreciate it. All right. Thank you, partners.