← Back to MaineScanner

Gorham Planning Board Postpones Quarry Expansion, Approves Self-Storage Waivers

2026-11-02 · Source: Planning Board Meeting - November 2nd, 2026 (Town of Gorham (GGETV ChampDS archive))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:18] Speaker A (unidentified): ladies and gentlemen it is Monday evening November 2nd 2026 this is a regular meeting of the Gorham Planning Board would you please join me in pledging allegiance to the flag thank you ladies and gentlemen please silence your cell phones thank you looking to planning to someone call the roll who [0:52] Speaker B (unidentified): wants to thank you mr. Hager here mr. Benson here mr. Frank here. Ms. Nichols? Mr. Walsh? Here. Mr. Delaney? Here. [1:09] Speaker A (unidentified): In your packet, we have approval of the minutes of the September 28th, 2026 meeting and the October 5th, 2026 planning board meeting. Ms. Nichols is not here, so I would ask if anyone else has had a chance to review the minutes. Any errors, omissions? [1:33] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Frank? I have read and reviewed them, and I have no corrections or additions thank you mr. Frank I [1:44] Speaker D (unidentified): have comment [1:49] Speaker A (unidentified): and we might need legal maybe to help chime in on this so on page 404 at one point mr. Delaney was anticipating because of a job situation an employment situation that he was going to have to vacate his position in fact that is correct as of this moment on these minutes but luckily mr delaney is sitting with us that job situation has clarified itself we should leave this as it's written and state on perhaps other minutes that he is not resigning [2:27] Speaker E (unidentified): thank you for the question i agree i think the minutes are meant to be a contemporaneous account of what happened at that meeting so if the situation's changed from [2:37] Speaker A (unidentified): there the record can reflect that certainly okay thank you so mr frank i agree that was my only comment anyone else please is there a motion please so move the frank thank you is there a second any other questions or edits all those in favor thank you that is for the minutes of [3:03] Speaker B (unidentified): September 28th please abstention please you have one member that didn't vote I [3:16] Speaker F (unidentified): have to abstain I wasn't at the meeting I apologize all [3:22] Speaker A (unidentified): the favor were for one abstaining correct is that okay thank you yes thank you apologize I want to be 411 and we also have a planning board minutes of October 5th please again miss Nichols is not here has anyone had a chance to review them comment yes [3:47] Speaker C (unidentified): I reviewed and I have no comment no comments or corrections thank you mr. [3:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Frank is there a second please second day Paul thank you mr. Walsh all those in favor anyone opposed any objections anything else how's that [Speaker D (unidentified): already thank] you reports chairman's report because we have been having extra meetings each time we seem to I seem to not being saying thank you enough to the staff on my right for a council with us to bend Ike upstairs he sits up there and to my left for your time and effort in this planning but we have a lot of challenges and I appreciate your time and effort to do this so if we don't get it in at the end I'm telling you now that I appreciate your time and effort very much that's all I have committee reports ordinance review the [5:00] Speaker F (unidentified): THE ORDINANCE COMMITTEE JUST COMPLETED A MEETING DISCUSSING A PROPOSAL FROM THE TOWN COUNCIL WHICH REVIEWS SOME LANGUAGE REGARDING DATA CENTERS, AND THAT DISCUSSION WILL BE CONTINUED [5:15] Speaker A (unidentified): TO ANOTHER MEETING. THANK YOU, MR. WALSH. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION COMMITTEE. [5:25] Speaker C (unidentified): WE HAVE NOT MET. [5:26] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU, MR. FRANK. MOVING ALONG, ADMINISTRATIVE SITE PLAN REVIEW. [5:30] Speaker G (unidentified): yes mr. chair there were several items on October 19th the minor site plan review committee approved the presumptive regional land trust request for a 1440 square foot parking lot for the deer woods preserve as well as a two thousand seven or twenty square foot educational wrestling facility they'll be at 11 Burnham Road on November 4th the committee will hear requests from JOSH PROKEY AT TWO INDUSTRIAL PARKWAY FOR 640 SQUARE FOOT ACCESSORY BUILDING FOR SNOW EQUIPMENT STORAGE AND THEN ON NOVEMBER 18TH YOU'LL HEAR A REQUEST FROM EMMA JOHNSON FROM ROUGH LIFE RETREAT LLC FOR A DOG TENNEL AT 252 OSPY TRAIL [6:18] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU MR. YERKOFF ANYTHING ELSE FROM STAFF NOTHING ELSE OKAY THANK YOU moving along item number one item one please there's a public hearing relapid site plan review brickyard quarry expansion a request for review of a proposal to expand quarry operations and a 6.3 acre area adjacent to an existing permitted quarry zone industrial map 34 lot 14 the applicant Shaw Brothers Construction Incorporated is represented by Owens McCullough PE with some bagel techniques what to staff mr. Eklund is any chances of signing [7:01] Speaker G (unidentified): sheet thank you thank you yes introduce the item mr. chair so this item was before the board for a sketch plan review on October 5th 2026 in addition, the board went on a site walk on October 26th at the site. The applicants have submitted additional materials for review that's now before you. And it should also be noted that this item was subject to a rezoning that is now being appealed. We do have the town attorney with us to answer questions about the appeal of the rezoning that was approved by the council. So the expansion area is located in an area that was previously the urban residential zone, and that was changed to industrial. So the applicant has submitted the materials for the request for rezoning under the industrial zone. So as far as that request is concerned, staff and peer review have gone through and noted that there are several items that are outstanding. So looking for additional information as far as an update of the noise review, several changes needed to stormwater designs, air quality impacts, PECS review of changes to blasting. Hydrogeological study update is needed. An updated erosion sedimentation control plan and decommissioning reclamation plan. In addition, we'll note that the applicant does need to obtain an amendment to their DEP site law permit. Some other items of note, the ordinance calls for a 200-foot buffer to adjacent properties from quarry activities unless that's waived by the board. It can be waived to a 100-foot buffer, and that is what the applicant has proposed, and that's what exists at the existing quarry. However, for the expansion, the board should discuss and review whether an additional waiver is needed for a buffer to the expansion area. And then one thing planning staff would also recommend is that the lot be merged, and that's something the applicant has stated that they're open to do. And another item that we request clarification on would be whether additional lighting will be provided and also look for the applicant to address any additional peer review, engineer, noise comments, and staff comments that were raised and they're contained in this memo this is a public hearings happy to take additional questions after public hearing and board discussion and presentation from the applicant Thank [10:13] Speaker A (unidentified): You Mr. Yakalov good [10:16] Speaker D (unidentified): evening Mr. McCullough yes good evening Mr. Chairman [10:20] Speaker H (unidentified): members of the board my name is Owens McCullough I'm a civil engineer with Sebago Technics here with me tonight is Lee Pratt from Shaw Brothers Construction instruction, Kevin and Peter from Maine Drilling and Blasting, in case there are questions that might be germane to that, and also Gabe McGinn from St. Germain and Associates. So we were here before you in early October at a sketch plan review. Some additional submittal and items were provided to the planning board. at that time I took a fair amount of time to go through the project and the expansion I 'm gonna go back just a little bit if my screen will show up okay so what the applicant is requesting is this sort of dark brown is an expansion to the north to their existing quarry and I think the planning board was on a site walk here on what the 26th I think it was is that is that right I wasn't able to attend and Lee Pratt had showed the planning board around so the expansion area is that cleared area that you saw out there and I think Lee pointed that out to everybody so it's this area right here this other darker area here in gray is the current expansion area and if kind of I don't I don't know if it's better up on your screens to see this, but that's the open quarry area that exists today. Then there's a materials storage area up here. The processing area is down here on the other side. These are all existing activities that were previously permitted and approved. One item I would note was I did see that the Conservation Commission had a question about anything down along the Portland Water District easement, which is, hopefully you can see this, which is down here, completely on the other side. We're not going anywhere near that. We're completely on the other side of the project, so that remains completely untouched by this project. Shaw Brothers acquired the land to the north, which runs all the way up to Queen Street. Street. This expansion goes basically a very short distance into that property. It's still about another 700 feet or so to the Queen Street land. There's a stream that crosses the property to the north. We're following the edge of our excavation limits of our work to the 75-foot setback from that location. Since the original submittal actually it was just completed so I know the board will want a chance to take a look at it but Scott Bodwell the noise consultant did update a noise study I actually uploaded it today because I didn't receive it till today so it is on your website on it Scott went around did some physical measurements around the site for the current operation you'll see the results in it was sound levels he noted that it was within the ordinance requirements which I think is 60 decibels so it's all in that report for you to take a look at also simultaneously with that, St. Germain and Associates, Gabe McGinn is here tonight. We actually did upload a letter from Gabe, which went in with our submittal, that spoke to excavation no closer than five feet to the groundwater, and they felt that, based on their assessment, that would not have an adverse impact to go to that depth. we're going to be filing a variance request with the DEP to go below the groundwater which is the same process Shaw Brothers went through for the original quarry expansion and again this is for that six acres to the north that we're looking to do and st. Germain is in the process of going updating their study to address that small area to the north a couple of other notable items so this expansion, it was in the review letter or the staff comments. There's no lighting proposed associated with this. It's daytime hours. So there's no lighting affiliated with it. The expansion is pretty small, but it provides some additional capacity to the quarry. They're not changing operations. They're not increasing vehicle trips coming in and out. it just simply builds capacity to their existing operations so none of that changes on the site the you folks were out there and saw the material stockpiling the crushing the asphalt plant that's out there none of that changes we did submit an updated stormwater report we saw the review comments that came in on Friday so we'll certainly respond to those we're looking to expand the wet pond that is in the north portion of the site right up in this area here that expansion will be done to accommodate the change in surficial hydraulics that happen with the expansion of the quarry again as I noted we're going to be filing our variance request to the main DEP again, part of what hinges on that is the work that St. Germain is undertaking, but that will be submitted also. I want to make sure I touched on everything. One item that we did put in the application, and there's a note on the plan, previously the applicant had sought and obtained a waiver to the property line set back along the Westerly property line. And for this little expansion to the north, we're literally looking to extend that waiver request for this small area to the north. And what that waiver request does is it asks for it to allow for a 100-foot buffer. We keep a 100-foot buffer. And then removal of overburden, which will occur from the 100-foot buffer to the 150 feet from the property lines without any blasting. and then blasting would occur from the 150 foot property line inward however the maximum slope from 150 to 200 foot would be a three to one slope in that area and that's the exact same provision that this board had waived in the past and again it's a very small piece of it but it is along this side of the northerly property line which is what we're looking to do mr chairman do you would you like me to go back i know i there's a history of the approvals and everything already submitted i'm not sure we want to go back through that this literally is just for the that brown area that about six acre expansion in the front it was there was an approval in 2023 or 2024 that allowed them to clear into that area expand the pit right up to the property line since they now own that property we'd like to go to the limits of the clearing and that's that's it for the for the request [18:23] Speaker A (unidentified): i'm happy it is a public hearing i think we'll we might circle back to you but that's fine thank you thank you for the presentation right now [18:31] Speaker H (unidentified): So, Lee, anything to add before I sit down? Okay. We're good? [18:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Don't go away. I won't. I'll stay right here. Ladies and gentlemen, this is a public hearing. If there was anyone who would like to speak in favor of this, please approach the podium. State your name and address for the record. [18:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Mr. Chair, would you like us to set a timer? What's that? Timer. Oh, in favor. Good question. I'm sorry. [19:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Looking to my left. What's your pleasure? Two or three minutes? three minutes okay how many have 11 but by 9 but that would be 39 27 minutes but someone else speaking he's first on list yeah so again it's anyone in favor of [Speaker D (unidentified): this you] know when rising the gay portion is there anyone that wants to be neutral about this please approach the podium state your name and address for [Speaker D (unidentified): the record again] I see no one rising last but not least ladies and gentlemen if there is anyone that is against this and I have your name I will call you if your name is on the list if your name is not on the list please come up and let's get your name on the list so and random order here it. Pembership aside, please excuse me. Andre James something. Andre James Hungerford. I'm [20:28] Speaker I (unidentified): an attorney. You didn't pass Pembership very well, did you? I do see a score. That's why [20:33] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm a lawyer. I went to parochial school. I had. Right. Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank [20:39] Speaker I (unidentified): you. You're an attorney? I am. For John? John Wise, who's right here. He lives at [address] in Gorham, Maine. You begin. Three minutes. Okay, just a quick point of clarification. I'm looking through the packet for today, and this is a question for the attorney. I see that it says that an ADB has been filed. This is on page two, that the town council enacted a change September 1st. The rezoning took effect October 1st, but is subject to an ADB appeal. Can you comment on that, or is that wrong? [21:15] Speaker E (unidentified): what they say if you're referring to the lawsuit that you've been considering and we've been discussing then yes it's a declaratory judgment and not okay yes so i did file a declaratory [21:27] Speaker I (unidentified): judgment action today i'm not sure it should be in the system anyway so i'm here for john wise and i want to thank everybody here on the planning board for doing this because you have an important role to play. You have to decide what's going to be implemented in Gorham, Maine. And you're going to hear from Sebago Technics. I've worked with them. They're great. I've also worked with St. Germain. They're also great. But they're obviously paid to give one side, okay, of, and they're going to give you all the positives on this project. I noticed that you have a map it's on page three now I have actually this is an image I'm sorry it's not a map it's really an image of the site okay and I actually have an aerial taken after one of these explosions from this current quarry site and I think Benny at the town attorney I gave him a copy I don't know if you want to like can hand this to you pass it down thank you but that's what if you look at that photo that's actually what happens so what you have here is a static photo and so john wise lives right next to this so when these blasts occur he can feel it 's like shaking okay and that dust goes everywhere you know i just had some work done in my office some sheetrock dust right and they contained it was in a room and everything and you know what it got everywhere wait i don't know it gets through the cracks it goes everywhere so when this when this when they're quarrying like this and it goes up this stuff is carried by the wind all over so i like the planning board to consider that when they vote on this because the people that are here i'm not sure i don't think any of them I'm guessing none of them live next to the quarry and there are a couple of thousand people who live within a two-mile area so you have to take that in consideration right that this is going to affect a lot of people because you're expanding this out and so I think there am I up on time is that Okay. Well, anyway, thank you. Thank you for considering like wrap up. I won't go ahead. Yeah. So I'm sorry. So I just want you to take you, know, you're, you're doing a very important thing here and ask some hard questions because the people that live next to it will tell you, and you're going to hear some people talking about this today. They experienced it. The other people hired guns. They're all going to make money on it. So that's my point. So consider your source. Thank you very much. [24:21] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you Emily Hamlin please can you that's why I can see the time yes thank [24:39] Speaker J (unidentified): you hello everybody my name is Emily Hamlin my family's land directly abuts the proposed quarry area let's see for my family this the impacts of this decision will not end when this meeting does we live next to whatever you approve so that's why I attended the sidewalk and reviewed the application carefully and in doing so I'm concerned that this proposal is moving forward towards approval while significant questions remain unanswered and studies unsubmitted residents have been raising their concerns for years about blasting dust noise odors and impacts on their home and quality of life these concerns deserve serious consideration before this operation is expanded again the Town Council has initiated an independent review of Quorum's quarry ordinances. If the Town believes these regulations warrant another look, why approve an expansion now? What's the urgency? More importantly, the Town's own review materials show that significant technical issues remain unresolved, including noise, groundwater, stormwater, blasting, air quality, erosion control, and reclamation. The noise peer reviewer recommends an entirely new study. The engineering review states that a required traffic study was not provided. The application also relates on a hydrogeological study from 2009. That's when I graduated high school. That's a long time ago. Sound measurements date to 2015. Also fairly long time ago. These are not minor details to resolve after approval. They are evidence the board needs to determine whether the standards have actually been met. The ordinance is clear, the burden is on the applicant to demonstrate compliance. It is not the board's responsibility to help the applicant get to yes. I left the site walk concerned about the objectivity of this process. Regardless of intent, the interactions I observed combined with these unresolved issues created the appearance that approval may already be the expected outcome. Approval should not be the starting assumption. I'M ASKING YOU TO DENY THIS APPLICATION AS SUBMITTED OR AT AN ABSOLUTE MINIMUM POSTPONE APPROVAL UNTIL THE ORDINANCE REVIEW IS COMPLETE AND THE OUTSTANDING TECHNICAL ISSUES ARE FULLY RESOLVED. IF THE APPLICANT HAS NOT YET DEMONSTRATED COMPLIANCE, THE BOARD SHOULD NOT APPROVE FIRST AND FIND THE EVIDENCE LATER. NEW SPEAKER THANK YOU. [27:11] Speaker A (unidentified): HANNAH HAMLIN, PLEASE. NEW [27:23] Speaker J (unidentified): SPEAKER HANNAH HAMLIN, 26 HAMLIN DRIVE. So I came up here to talk to you guys about all the technical issues that Emily, Damon, and Sebago Technics just highlighted in this application. It's missing maybe like 50% of the information needed to assess whether this is a valid application that you should be approving. To approve it today, without all of that information that the man from Sebago Technics just stood up here and said needs to be completed, you would be approving something you have no idea what you're approving, that would be very irresponsible. So I'm here to ask you to not approve it at this time. We all know it's going to continue to be percolating for a while. So I ask that you don't approve it today. Wait on all of these studies that have been mentioned that are incomplete, that quantify the impact on people's wells, dust, noise impact, a stormwater runoff, which is bad for the environment, and a whole bunch of other things that still have not been addressed traffic studies we're looking at an Amazon warehouse maybe more traffic we don't know it hasn't been studied we cannot rely on the man who just stood up here and told us it won't change anything studies are why we do this you guys when you approve the zoning change a couple of months ago now you sent a letter to the town council asking that they ensured that regulations were being adhered to that's wonderful as far as I know and as far as you know, they have not done anything because they are still waiting for that independent third-party review to look at those ordinances. Not only that, but if you guys are asking them to adhere to ordinances, it would be hypocritical to approve an application that cannot be proven to adhere to the ordinances. Pretty much everything else I said has already been hit on. So yeah, I just wanna ask you guys not to approve this, to take the time to actually understand what you're approving and to consider the impacts of all of these studies on other people's homes thank you thank you please [29:32] Speaker A (unidentified): bear with me Paula I apologize I'm sorry that's you please and then And David would be following you, I guess. [29:43] Speaker K (unidentified): But he doesn't know about it. [29:44] Speaker B (unidentified): So I didn't realize that we were selling it. But I can speak. [29:49] Speaker J (unidentified): So I signed. [29:51] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay, my name is Paula Wehmeyer, and I live at Gateway Commons, Timber Ridge Road. I honestly thought I was signing a sign-up sheet to say that we were against the court. [30:01] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Hold on. Are you here in favor of or against? [30:05] Speaker K (unidentified): Against. Against is written right next to my name, right? Yes,. That's correct. Yeah,, yeah. Yeah, okay. so i signed up i thought it was a sign up to say against the quarry i didn't realize i'd be speaking you don't but anyways if i'm here i can just say i do live on timber ridge gateway commons and i do say i would like the board to consider because the blasting noise is our concern i mean what are we a couple miles away and the blasting the whole house just shakes so I would like to bring up that point. Okay? You can scratch David, I'm sure. [30:47] Speaker A (unidentified): David, do you want me to scratch you off? Are you happily married? I don't want to. Thank you, thank you, thank you, Paula, and thank you, David. Might have to get an ice cream tonight. Lisa, is it Bent or Brent, please? Lisa? Well, thank you, thank you, thank you for your honesty. [Speaker I (unidentified): Moving] along, Brianna Meschi. [31:27] Speaker D (unidentified): I apologize. [31:35] Speaker L (unidentified): Hello. In August, this board approved the zoning change with a letter to the town council asking that the council ensure that regulations on quarry operations are fully enforced. You also talked about the benefits of doing an unannounced sidewalk. Has this happened? Since that meeting, I have filed two complaints with of the town and Shaw brothers for their two blasts in September due to the dust clouds that have traveled over to my house so I'm on Queen Street kind of further down by Lily Lane I've taken videos of these I sent these to the town the only response I've gotten after asking what's going to be done to enforce these is just thank you I'll file your complaint that's it no call back from the Shaw brothers nothing from the town about how this will be enforced is my understanding the measure should be taken so this is contained it clearly wasn't I'm worried about what's in that dust that is heading toward the houses my kids go to Narragansett school what's headed towards there you know the blaster during school time recess all of that we don't have the updated quarry review or third party to kind of review do studies about you know those monitoring those kind of things, so I have no idea. Should I be worried about this? Should I not? I have no idea. The last blast and site walk that you all went to, well you went to a site walk, but the blasts the very next day were carefully orchestrated and scheduled in advance. I'm not saying that Shaw Brothers doesn't do good work, but that was a scheduled walkthrough that was carefully scheduled. The other two blasts before were the ones that really created that issues with dust. There's a big difference between you know the unannounced sidewalk and then one that's carefully scheduled. Local residents are seeing property devaluation and damage to their house and potential damage to their health. I talked to someone this weekend over on Lily Lane who has who does have significant worry about their foundation having damage done to it as a result of the blasting from this quarry site. If you approve this expansion it will be even closer to residential areas just because saying it's only six more acres I mean the blast it's there's going to be more impact how much do local residents have to endure so the Shaw brothers can make millions more I ask all of all of you what is the rush for this decision to be made I urge you to carefully consider all of our perspectives before making a decision tonight please do your due diligence to make sure that regulations are truly enforced and not just at scheduled times thank you for your time thank you [34:15] Speaker A (unidentified): charlie hamlin please hi [34:26] Speaker M (unidentified): charlie hamblin 26 hamblin drive from guarum i am on the town council but i'm speaking for myself not for the town council so some of you have been around for three and a half years where this has been going on where we've been asking the town to do something to enforce their ordinances in place review the ordinances to make them better to not approve any extension or expansion of the quarry until something happens. And really, the only movement is made by you guys sending, hey, town council, you need to enforce these rules, because really the town council does nothing. The town council is an elected body that is politically driven by whoever's in their office that day or whoever's threatening them one way or another. other can't rely on that because it's all politics and as you know politics is pretty ugly nowadays but the Planning Board you guys are appointed you're not political you should be looking at the facts and making a real decision based on what the facts if you look over the pictures my family's holding up there we got all kinds of evidence there's dust everywhere there's asphalt false smell from Little Falls School to Libby Avenue to Sweets and Eats and to every ice cream place around here it's just this quarry is a disaster for the residential areas of Gorham there's no reason to move this thing for now the application was not very good it was incomplete inconclusive and I tell you 've already been sued on the declarative judgment if you move forward with this without getting a better application more lawsuits so if you really want to spend taxpayer money to fight things because you have crappy job go for it but this isn't ending here and please pay attention and see and this can go on even if this goes on six months from today it's okay because they have plenty of rock to dig forever the reason Shaw Brothers wants to move this for the election or whatever reason it makes no sense because they don't really need to and last comment the variance of 200 feet you to down to 150 I own all that land behind it nobody's asked me anything about a variance or getting any closer to my land that's 148 acres been in my family since 1850s 1860 something like that if you come after my land this is gonna get uglier than it is [37:05] Speaker D (unidentified): now thank you thank you [37:12] Speaker A (unidentified): hey folks please Doug is it Calderbank I apologize if I miss pronounced it hey [37:29] Speaker N (unidentified): doing Doug Calderbank 21 timber ridge road yeah I'm in gateway Commons gateway Collins is 76 houses there's a lot of them that are not here because they've been discouraged because of the whole Amazon and what's it gone for with Amazon and voting, and that's a mess as it is. But I wanted to share satellite photos of 2007 where Shaw Brothers just did the expansion of the office, then the 2010 expansion, and then the 2026, where it's at today and how big Gateway Commons has been here the whole time. and we're dealing with excessive noise the dust there's no there's nothing in place to stop them from 5 6 in the morning with a dump truck banging I'm not sure if you ever heard that banging three times two three times within a dumping it's loud and that berm is in variance is not big enough the berm that's currently there probably needs to be twice as high to really be to stop the noise the rock crusher constantly I'm not sure if there's some water being poured on it or something that's going to reduce the noise but it's excessive and I just deny this application is [39:01] Speaker A (unidentified): that it okay thank you thank you I didn't realize you had finished ladies and gentlemen is there anyone else that would like to speak against this project please approach the podium state your name and address for the record this is a public hearing only once going twice I see no one rising ladies and gentlemen I will close the public hearing thank you looking to my left that's that for the record please thank you mr. mr. chair I [39:44] Speaker O (unidentified): have a question for staff please what's the specifics on the need for a new [39:48] Speaker G (unidentified): traffic study in a proposal like this so there are new studies that are specifically called for in the ordinance where either a new quarry is being reviewed or expansion of an existing quarry beyond five acres, which this one is. The two studies specifically called for are traffic impacts analysis and a hydrogeological. However, there are additional criteria and site plan that need to be addressed as well, And that's where some of the other items that were discussed today included noise, the lighting question. [40:27] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, I just wanted to specifically on, and I appreciate your clarification, but so there is a specific requirement that's triggered because of the size of the expansion. Yes. Okay, thanks. [40:40] Speaker F (unidentified): Mr. Chairman. Yes, please, Mr. Chairman. I should disclose that I did watch the video that had been posted online of the drone footage of the blast that occurred last week. [40:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Thank you. I found it quite helpful. Anyone else? Would you like Mr. McCullough to come up, or do we have any other questions for him? [41:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, I guess, sorry, I do. I have a question for staff. Mr. McCullough stated that he had just uploaded a new noise study today, because I had that at number one on here, that the noise study was incomplete or needed to be updated. so that has been submitted and will we receive that and when will we receive that [41:32] Speaker G (unidentified): we haven't reviewed it yet because it was just received however any new materials would be reviewed and then would be provided for the board and the public [41:42] Speaker F (unidentified): right so I mean that right there says we're not going to be able to approve anything at least I'm not going to be able to approve anything until we get that information I look forward to receiving that and being able to review it just because that did seem like it was a big item on the peer review and I don't I can't imagine the applicant be surprised to hear that as far as this the other issue that was brought up is the waiver do we have a waiver request before us we [42:19] Speaker G (unidentified): have not received a waiver request at this time that is something that would we would need to review all [42:26] Speaker F (unidentified): All right. So we don't have it. That's fine. Can I ask a follow up? [42:30] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, I'd love to get Owens. Can I ask the applicant or the Owens just on the on the waiver? What's the impact if the waiver? And I guess we don't have a waiver request in front of us formally tonight. But what's the impact if the waiver is not approved and you continue with a 200 foot buffer? [42:56] Speaker H (unidentified): well what that means is then that we push the limit of the quarry 200 feet from the property [43:04] Speaker O (unidentified): line yeah so a hundred foot you're talking about a hundred foot difference across the six and a half acre expansion six acre expansion so it doesn't seem like a huge a huge amount of impact [43:18] Speaker H (unidentified): the waiver so when i said there's still a hundred feet of i just want to make sure everybody understands. There's still 100 foot of undisturbed, and then from 100 to 150, it's simply removing the overburden. It's in it because the ledge isn't always just right at the surface. They have to remove the overburden to get down to the ledge. And then they did want to have the ability to blast from 150 to 200 feet, which gets them down to where they're within the primary quarry area that they work. Same thing that they did on the prior permits. It makes it more efficient, more effective in how they move forward with the project. [44:13] Speaker F (unidentified): Mr. Walsh? Well, I guess I'm just a little curious. I hear from Mr. Hamblin that he owns the land. Was there a waiver approved in the past for the other area? Yes. that where there's a hundred foot buffer exists today is do I assume there was a waiver in the past that was approved remember [44:38] Speaker O (unidentified): that I don't remember the time [44:39] Speaker F (unidentified): I did that but there was yeah and did the you know I'm just looking at miss Hamlet did they have any input into that at that time or any please thank [45:00] Speaker M (unidentified): you for the question at that time my father owned the property but if you go about the line there's no berm if you look at the original planning board approvals they're supposed to be burns they're supposed to be attempts made to block the noise the dust and activity onto your property and no there's nothing like that whatsoever today okay thank you [45:25] Speaker G (unidentified): miss mr. oak we could include a history of waivers granted on this project that would be of use to the board in a future submission. That would be great. That would be great. [45:38] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to push this thing along. It looks like we have some things that are not buttoned up here. [45:43] Speaker F (unidentified): I do have a question. Please, Mr. Walsh, yes. Did you say you have somebody from the blasting company here? [45:53] Speaker H (unidentified): With your permission, yes, we do. [45:56] Speaker F (unidentified): I have a question about after watching the blast. Actually, it was a question I had for Mr. Pratt while we were out on the sidewalk. and then I was this is what's really got my curiosity watching the video and I'm taking this from a background in pulp and paper of having to manage large piles of wood chips and bark and having to control dust where my mill site abutted a much larger dense residential area so I know very well what neighbors complaining about dust is all about because I got the phone calls but you know my biggest solution was fogging with water and I asked this question during the during the walk and I just thought you know could you can you fog the area with fire hoses from our cart this is what I used to do with my chip piles, and just leave it there fogging. Because when the wind was blowing, we had to fog. That was part of our requirements, and to keep the dust out of the residences. And after watching the video, especially, I was thinking, I still don't understand why you could not set up fire hoses and fog along the perimeter of the blast area to capture some of that dust. I'm kind of curious, since you have the experts here, could you comment on that? [47:27] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm going to think at this point I'll let the folks from Maine Drilling and Blasting. [47:36] Speaker P (unidentified): Good evening. My name is Pete Bennett. I've got Kevin Bowers with me. We supervise drilling and blasting in the quarry application, five-state area in New England, so Arista County all the way down to southern Connecticut. I've never seen that practice be put into place before. our concern with introducing water to the blast site is you know shaw brothers in main drilling and blasting have invested in some technology with within the boreholes it's actually electronic detonators so the old the old school method used to be non-l it used to be cap infuse that type of stuff a little unstable pretty inaccurate typically higher vibration response this new technology there's every detonator's got a computer chip and it they are susceptible to water so the concern with spraying down a blast area you know directly on the shot is introducing that you know that hydrologic you know variant into the into the detonator it could typically it could technically shut the shot down and then you've got we've You've got a serious safety issue for the people working in the quarry. I mean, so the perimeter misting, I think, is what you referred to. I haven't, I've never seen that in place before. Our main concern is just not watering that area because of introducing that hydrological variant there. Okay. Okay. [49:11] Speaker F (unidentified): So have you ever seen any other dust control methods that are not being utilized in this site that could help the situation? [49:23] Speaker P (unidentified): We, you know, there's been methods in place to, you know, typically in a quarry setting, we're displacing mass amounts of rock. So you're actually, you're designing it not to be confined. You're designing it to roll out to make the quarry floor. So I think, you know, we could get creative with Lee and the team and try to water the floor down. The issue is, you know, I know there was a lady that spoke about September. You know, we would have to heavily water that floor. And I, you know, I think it's at least an option to try to control the dust as best we can on the actual floor area. But outside of that, I'm not sure what other methods we would be able to use. [50:01] Speaker F (unidentified): One of the things we didn't discuss during the site walk, and I meant to ask the question, is what conditions are required for a blast? I mean, it's obviously watching that drone video that there was no wind because that dust rose up and didn't seem to carry far. [50:17] Speaker P (unidentified): Well, and that's typically the result is that, you know, that dust and actually the, you know, sometimes there's gases involved in that detonation. You don't necessarily see it in the blast, but that gas pressure rises in the atmosphere. That's kind of by design. It dissipates up into the atmosphere, and that's typically what you see in a well-controlled quarry blast. [50:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. I guess in your – well, it talks about a manual, it has. I mean, are there certain wind conditions that have to be satisfied when you have a blast? No. Wind conditions as it's subjected to? [50:57] Speaker P (unidentified): Not by regulation, no, not to my knowledge. [51:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Would that be an improvement if there was, I mean, in other words, can you blast when there's a good stiff wind? [51:10] Speaker P (unidentified): Yeah, we certainly can and we certainly do. You know, I think wind direction plays, you know, plays a part in air overpressure. That's, you know, not necessarily the vibration, but you're moving mass air. You're putting mass rock into an area that was air and now you're moving it. it but i you know it's it's difficult to plan around that around oh i'm sure you know so when we you know when we show up typically at shaw brothers and we're and we're loading holes at 7 a.m we're at that point we're we're committed so you know i think it's something we can pay attention to lee but i'm not sure that's that's something that we can hang our [51:47] Speaker F (unidentified): hat on saying when direction is so i bet that comes down to is really just a cost control because, I mean, obviously it costs you a lot to set up on site. I have appreciation for that. Sure. But I just didn't know. Maybe I made an assumption that there were certain environmental or weather conditions that had to be satisfied before you could have a blast. [52:09] Speaker P (unidentified): There's not. I mean, we shoot and, you know, we're in New England, and, you know, typically we shoot in a vast variety of conditions, sometimes pouring rain, sometimes it's just. That rain would be great. It would. It would, but rain can introduce some other issues. Rain can introduce some other issues as well. You know, low ceiling, barometric pressure, that can influence the air pressure in a shot. Keeps it low, yeah. Keeps it low, and sometimes it's a good result, and sometimes the surrounding neighbors may say, I felt that one more than typical because it will actually hold that pressure rather than dissipating in the air, hold it down, and so it's, you know, there's a balance there. [52:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. Well, thank you for answering my questions. Absolutely. [52:54] Speaker Q (unidentified): don't please sorry just real quick to touch on Pete's one sorry just one time Lee Bradshaw brothers so to touch on what Pete was saying we do communicate with main drilling and blasting so if we know it's gonna be a low ceiling the day of the shoot like the day before we'll communicate with them and usually will hold off if it's gonna be a low ceiling because we don't want that air blast to come down I think and be troublesome you know and to your point, yes, we would love it if as soon as we touched that shot off, the rain just let loose and killed everything. It's just, unfortunately, the timing's there. And once the shots are loaded, it becomes a safety issue. You can't leave the powder in the ground at that point once it's in there. So once it's loaded, it has to happen that day, typically. [53:44] Speaker P (unidentified): And I may have misunderstood the question. I thought you were asking if there was, like, a regulatory piece to that, you know, depending on wind condition or speed or anything like that, which there isn't, to my knowledge. I mean, I've been doing this for almost 27 years now, but from the regulatory side, there isn't. I will say, you know, Shaw Brothers, we work with probably over 100 different customers throughout New England. And depending on the area, like to Lee's point, you know, if we know it's going to be just a wash of a day, we won't go out and even introduce that hazard into that day. That wouldn't be good. [54:20] Speaker F (unidentified): If you say you work with a lot of different customers throughout New England, how many of those quarries tend to be are close proximity to residential areas? [54:30] Speaker P (unidentified): so like most of our business down in massachusetts connecticut rhode island we're you know we're much closer and on the scale of very you know the scale of actual quantities you know those are million and a half ton annual quarries a lot of those so [54:50] Speaker A (unidentified): yes sir no it was the project manager at main water and it was you were across the street from the original plant 200 feet the main will remain you blasted all of the all of the granite yeah and that and just far as distance I'm talking [55:06] Speaker P (unidentified): about distance sure yeah and in there in some poor applications we are shooting well within 300 feet but it's a you know at that point it's a question of blast design right so we were regulated by Maine DEP there's also federal regulations through the US Bureau of Mines the 8507 standard that was created back in the 70s which kind of governs all of you know the quarry blasting application so you know if obviously if we're shooting 200 feet off a home the design is much different than if you if you have 2,000 feet for example so it's based on site factors that's how we that's how we design our [55:44] Speaker C (unidentified): blast okay frank please thank you the photographs that the hamlin family showed after the blast with the opaque of that how much of that was really just gas that you can't really hold in your hand versus how much is really stone dust that you can grab a hold of? [56:13] Speaker P (unidentified): So the initial, like the initial, it looks like the gentleman brought a photo like right post blast. You know, the majority of that material would be that gas being released up into the environment. Okay. So, you know, but it's hard to say a percentage of gas versus, you know, actual aggregate material. I wouldn't be able to give you that. [56:36] Speaker C (unidentified): no I'm not looking for a precise percentage just a question of rate ratio type most of it is not really stone dust yeah I would say yeah [56:48] Speaker P (unidentified): broadly yes it does [56:57] Speaker F (unidentified): it brings me that do we have data on the silica dust the silica component of that dust and the particulate size, do we have anything? I'd be curious to see it because, I mean, there's, you know, in my background, you know, the silica dust or something had to be regulated because of exposure to the lungs. And I'm thinking much more inside of closed, like in confined spaces, Jim, you know what I'm talking about, tanks. But I'm thinking here as I'm listening to all that and going, is this something we should be looking at? As you look at that, and Russell, it's a good question, you look at that cloud and go, okay. But obviously there's got to be some particular matter in it, and what is the component of that? What is the makeup of that particular matter? [58:03] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, my only thought is that 's probably typical of every blast that takes place in every quarry. Okay, yeah. [58:11] Speaker F (unidentified): Everywhere. Right. Right, but if, you're absolutely right, but then there should be some data on it. But what is the exposure risk? [58:26] Speaker A (unidentified): The gentleman in main drilling and blasting, please, if you don't mind. So the majority of the folks here probably have heard of OSHA, and my prior experience is dealing with MSHA, the U.S. Mining and Safety Health Administration. Yes. so are there any guidelines I don't know I don't I'm not aware of any I'm looking to my right to my left about dust mitigation etc there are most of its [58:52] Speaker P (unidentified): ties specifically to so like the folks operating right in the environment you know mostly for us it's our drill operators because they are there they're drilling a hole that's you know it is creating that material obviously things have come a long way since the old air track days but So there's a water confinement system within all of our drill rigs now. You know, I would say on the quarry side, 95 plus percent of those folks are in an enclosed cab, whereas back in the day you were drilling right beside the hammer. But there was always testing, and our drill operators get it multiple times per year across five states on silica exposure. And these are the guys right on top of the holes that they're drilling. and obviously we have to be below a certain threshold I can't name that off the top of my head my apologies but you know that's that's where we see it the most so the people directly exposed to the drilling operation I'm only trying [59:49] Speaker A (unidentified): to insinuate that there's more than just OSHA involved in this M shot and the [59:54] Speaker P (unidentified): Bureau of lanes of mining right yeah main DEP as well you know as some oversight into that as well yeah thank you yeah it's awesome I'm just saying [1:00:03] Speaker F (unidentified): And I'm sure your people are using appropriate PPE for that exposure. I'm going to say now, what exists when you have a cloud of dust and it gets off-site? And what is the component of it? And what is the exposure level? It might be way below any exposure level. I don't know. But a lot of good questions have been raised here, so it got me curious. [1:00:27] Speaker P (unidentified): To that point there, so, you know, MSHA, they won't accept, you know, something that's got an engineered function to it. So you're talking like a respirator or something like that. When our drill operators are on a time-weighted average on their exposure, they don't have any of that material on because that's not really realistically what they're doing. So they're not putting respirators on. It's a time-weighted average on our exposure with non-engineered controls. Really? Yeah. But it speaks to kind of the technology of, you know, the drilling and blasting industry right now and how far it's come. Interesting. Yep. [1:01:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Mr. Walsh? Members? We have a couple of motions here, maybe. All of you would like to speak? [1:01:23] Speaker H (unidentified): Sure. To Mr. Benson's question earlier about the waiver, my customer just informed me that they he's been thinking looking at that they would work they would remove the waiver from the we won't request a waiver we'll proceed without it 's pretty small section it'd be preferable but they can live with it so we will remove the waiver from THE REQUEST. MR. CHAIRMAN, IF I CAN, THIS MIGHT HELP THE BOARD A LITTLE BIT. WE KNOW THIS IS GOING TO TAKE A LITTLE BIT OF A PROCESS, SO AS FAR AS TONIGHT GOES, WE KNOW YOU WOULD LIKE SOME TIME TO LOOK AT THE recent sound study information, which is fine, some hydrogeology work is in process. We're assuming you would like to see that. But we wanted to get back in front of this board, bring in the main drilling and blasting folks. We have the hydrogeologist here if you had questions tonight, or as more information, we'll bring him back. but we wanted to roll this out in a manner that gave you some time to consider these things as we go forward so as far as tonight goes I don't know that we're particularly looking for a decision from the board tonight but to continue the conversation thank you try to expedite this thing we have some [1:03:04] Speaker A (unidentified): information that we want and we need no fault of yours mr. chair please Colonel [1:03:13] Speaker O (unidentified): I'd like to make a motion to postpone site plan amendment and a special exception approval. Move to postpone further review of Shaw Brothers Construction request for major site plan amendment and special exception approval for expansion of existing quarry pending responses to remaining issues. [1:03:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Dave Walsh, second. Do we have any revisions to the plans? I don't believe we do. I don't. Okay. Except in this document we had a 200-foot, and they want to remove it. [1:03:41] Speaker O (unidentified): and both letter okay letter zero i understood that it hadn't been formally [1:03:46] Speaker G (unidentified): applied for yet so correct we had flagged that as a requirement in the ordinance and i believe they 're going to meet the requirement without requesting the waiver but we actually showed it [1:04:00] Speaker H (unidentified): on the site plan but i'll remove that note for the expansion okay that was letter oh thank you [1:04:05] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you thank you thank you for okay colonel there's a motion there was a second, Dave Walsh. Mr. Walsh, is there any other discussion? Any other communication? [1:04:14] Speaker O (unidentified): Just the other discussion for the staff. It would be very helpful to know what the DEP or other monitoring of the quarry is and what the schedule is, how often that happens, and how the town or others are informed when that does happen. That would be very helpful as we go forward. [1:04:34] Speaker F (unidentified): And I would be interested in knowing are there any requirements on fugitive dust and is there any data on the makeup of the particulate matter in that dust and what would be the hazards to it and any limits? Probably quite small, but just now curious. but more so about fugitive dust and then anyway it really kind of struck me I was kind of curious and surprised that there are no requirements weather restrictions on a blast where you could result in and have fugitive dust we [1:05:22] Speaker G (unidentified): all set on the right yes we captured all those requests and we'll be sure to bring that [1:05:27] Speaker A (unidentified): information back I respectfully ask that you just read them back however you written them just so we can agree I but I have was that the board is looking for [1:05:38] Speaker G (unidentified): additional information on DP monitoring and scheduling for that fugitive dust data on fugitive dust makeup of the dust and then question regarding weather restrictions on blasting and whether perhaps additional restrictions could be put in place or have been put in place elsewhere is that the nature of your [1:05:59] Speaker A (unidentified): question okay you got it that satisfy you thank you so we got a motion in a second translated some things over there all those in favor is anyone opposed thank you mr mccullough [1:06:12] Speaker G (unidentified): thank you for your time thank you very much ladies [1:06:31] Speaker A (unidentified): and gentlemen we're going to take a five minute recess please evening ladies and gentlemen we had just taken a short break this is a planning board meeting, November 2nd, 2026. It is about 8.10 p.m. Moving along, item two, please. Item two, public hearing, site plan review, Ossipee Trail self-storage facility. A request for review of a proposal to construct a 44,350-square-foot self-storage facility and associated infrastructure on a 4.29-acre parcel on Ossipee Trail, zone roadside commercial RC, C map 76 lot 11 the applicant Kevin Bosworth is represented by Jason Haskell PE with DM Roma consulting engineers I look to planning to introduce this [1:11:03] Speaker G (unidentified): please yes mr. chair so this application this is the first time the site plan reviews come before the board it was before the board for sketch plan review back in May of 2026 who identified several items during the review that we'd be looking for from the applicants and suggest the board discuss one is a photometric plan also make the board aware that they're still their Department of Environmental Protection stormwater permit reviews pending Army Corps Engineers Wetland Permit pending. There's several staff and peer review comments to be addressed as well. One of those to highlight is parking. So the applicants aren't proposing specific striped parking areas. However, in previous reviews of self-storage areas, the board has allowed for temporary parking and drive aisles for loading and unloading, and that could meet the parking needs for the site. There's also a matter of building materials in the zoning ordinance. Three material types are required. the applicants provided to however discussion with staff it looks like they could modify that plan by adding shutters to create a third material so that's something the board should review to see if that make a finding that meets the ordinance requirement press one of the larger at items and staff peer review comments has to do with the driveway spacing so we'll know that this is in an area subject to DOT review for driveway permits, and the spacing is less than required in the ordinance. We've identified that if the waiver is requested, there's actually two ordinance sections that point to that spacing. So if that's being entertained by the board, there's two separate motions here for each separate ordinance section. On that, the applicant's requesting to reduce the spacing from 350 feet to 169.3 feet. Another waiver staff has identified would be from the requirement for public water and sewer. I believe no water or sewer is proposed to be in use on the site. That's something the board should, however, discuss because it is one of the site plan review requirements. And with that, I'll turn it back over to you, Mr. Chair. [1:14:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Mr. Yakalov. Good evening. [1:14:07] Speaker R (unidentified): Good evening. Jason Haskell with DM Roma Consulting Engineers here on behalf of Kevin Bosworth. so we're looking at seven individual self storage buildings the total square footage would be forty four thousand three hundred and fifty square feet of cold storage so not heated we are proposing no water and sewer because there's not going to be any plans for any manned space that would require a bathroom or anything that nature so that's kind of the reason why we're not proposing that and none of the buildings as they're designed right now requires sprinkler systems so we wouldn't require the water connection for that reason we are looking at going underground from the existing utility pole that's out there to provide power and communications to the facility the front The front building was turned 90 degrees so that it was run parallel to Ossipee Trail. It wouldn't have any of the overhead doors that obviously we're trying to avoid having to have all those doors facing the public way. where originally we were proposing something along this line with a stone facade along the bottom with vertical siding with some faux windows with a black vinyl trim around it and then a metal roof above them. During the staff meeting, we did talk a little bit further about that and it sounds like we need one more material so what we'd be looking at is doing something more like combine combining these two into one window in the middle with shutters on either side like a wooden shutter so that it has the New England feel that I know that the town really kind of goes towards and it would break it up for just as much as these windows will the so obviously when we follow up our submission with any of the review comments that we'll address will also include a new rendering of what that's actually going to look like I've been working with a landscape architect on a the design as its requirement for the by the ordinance a lot of the areas that we've tried to focus on are the thinner areas of the existing tree line trying to also double up a little bit more on the in areas that are existing houses off the property and anywhere is where off the property it is a thinner area so that's kind of the game plan with that. The stormwater for the project is going to be covered with two gravel wetlands. So it'll look like a wetland, just so it'll have a little bit more stormwater functionality to it, along with another detention pond to provide some additional stormwater detention Tension and slowing down the water before it leaves the site did submit the stormwater permit to the DEP since we're over an acre of new impervious area. It sounds like, based off of the letter that we got of the acceptance of the permit for processing, the date that they listed was December 28th. So, right around that time is when we'd be looking at getting that approval. Obviously, we'll be working our way through that with the DEP and then also with the Army Corps of Engineers permit since we do have some wetland impact associated with the construction of the site. So after we made the submission, after talking with the applicant, he was looking at some information on what the primary interest in this area is and looking at the way this the second half if you will of the site is showing three individual buildings with doors all the way around with driveways all the way around was to do something more like this apparently there's a big need for some of these deeper units going from a 15 foot unit which deep unit which was kind of what was being proposed before going to more like a 40 foot so they'd be a deeper they would be probably 15 foot by 40 feet deep so that if the renters if you will have an RV that they want a parking they are something a little bit larger than the typical units will allow so what this does is it reduces the number of buildings it actually will increase it'll decrease the number of total units but it will increase the square footage of storage from forty four thousand three fifty to forty seven thousand five fifty what this will do is it avoids the need for driveways to go out and around, avoiding any headlights or anything like that would be shining towards any of the residential to the north. And what it will also do is avoid any lights needed to be on the backside of it because it wouldn't need to light anything up. So it would be just looking out at the driveway here. year that actually will reduce the amount of impervious surface on the site just because of removing those driveways obviously if we can talk about that tonight we can and then we've also got some conversations we got to have with the town staff as we move forward with any design change there the one item that we originally had in mind was the waiver request for the spacing it's actually my understanding that this area is within the urban compact so that this town has jurisdiction over the driveways so we avoid having to go that direction with the DOT but at the same time we do have the standard that we need to look at which is the distance between driveways there's the existing driveway to the north of the site it's about two parking spaces more or less coming right off the road so what we'd be looking at is going from 350 feet to 169 feet based off of the speed limit of 50 miles an hour out there. Some of the sight features that will help safety out here is the sight distance is extensive in both directions. It's dead straight through there. Everything's cut back within the right-of-way, so there shouldn't be any sight distance. You can see, as people are leaving the driveway, you can see the driveway further up the road. there's also going to be very few very little traffic coming out of this it's not a huge generator of traffic that there shouldn't be a lot of potential impacts between the two driveways and then it's also we've also made it the furthest point away on the property away from that driveway so we've been trying to accommodate what we can but obviously based off of the restrictions of the shape of the property and it's making things very difficult to go any other direction there so I guess tonight I'm hoping to discuss some of the designs if you have any questions about that discuss the waiver and then without seeing what the comments are from staff and the third party engineer whether or not approval would be appropriate at this time but obviously I'll let you guys make that decision so yeah here to [1:23:22] Speaker A (unidentified): answer any questions thank you thank you I want to look to staff for example I don't see the strong in the package am [1:23:31] Speaker G (unidentified): I wrong this I believe this is something that the applicant is considering and they haven't submitted it for review if the applicant wants to change the site design, we would encourage them to resubmit that for review. I hesitate to even [1:23:48] Speaker A (unidentified): discuss this. It's the pleasure of the board. We're looking at something that isn't in this package. There may be other attributes in this. Yes, please, Colonel. [1:24:00] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, personally, I recognize the change, but there are things about the application I think that should be discussed, and we've got a public hearing, and people may be here to speak about it. so they should be allowed to see we've asked them here whether we approve it or [1:24:15] Speaker A (unidentified): not it's different I appreciate that I didn't know if we were gonna continue so I'm happy to continue thank you thank you yes ladies and gentlemen this is a public hearing so if there was anyone like to speak in favor of this project would you please approach the podium and state your name and address for the [Speaker D (unidentified): record I] see no one rising ladies and gentlemen if there was anyone that would like to speak against this project would you please approach the podium state your name and address for the record anyone I see no one I see no one rising ladies and gentlemen if there was anyone that is neutral that wishes to speak about this project neither for nor against please approach the podium and state your name and address for the record again I see no one rising and I will close the public hearing thank you currently you mr. Walsh good I was just [1:25:26] Speaker O (unidentified): gonna say personally and it's reflected in some written statements that we've received but the board knows that we've considered other projects in this areas but a lot of time discussing traffic and sight lines and driveway distances and I personally am gonna have a hard time overcoming and voting in favor of a waiver for the driveway on this stretch of road because of all the work we've done with other with other sites other projects where this has been a big consideration, and I'm just going to have a hard time overcoming that. So I just wanted to state that. I know we're not voting on that necessarily, or maybe we are going to vote on it tonight, but I would like to hear from others if they have opinions on this, but that's my holdup with this right at this point. [1:26:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Colonel. Can I just, I'm going to go right to you, Mr. Frank. Are you referring on page three? Those waivers? Yeah. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Mr. Frank, please. [1:26:27] Speaker C (unidentified): the colonel has eloquently pretty much summed up by what i was going to say so i will second his [1:26:36] Speaker A (unidentified): comments thank you mr frank mr walsh third i'll third his comments mr delaney you're still awake over there absolutely so we are not going to discuss these waivers consensus all righty so let's continue on then please mr. [1:26:57] Speaker G (unidentified): chair just wanted to flag something for the board's attention if you didn't receive any comment here seeming although there were two written comments that were submitted I just [1:27:07] Speaker F (unidentified): want to make sure the board members and I'll say I'm guessing my friend here was referring to those comments because I read through those comments and they did raised to refresh my memory we spent a lot of time talking about access with another site that's nearby and you know this area is getting built up we ought to be consistent yeah and you know if we're saying this to in Chuck you're you're our man when it comes to access management any words of wisdom yeah just [1:27:45] Speaker S (unidentified): Just to be clear, if the board has read those comments that came in today, the standard that was applied there was specific to a property that had frontage on two different lots. So just to make clear that the application of that standard was it's prescriptive that the entrance has to come off the street of lower classification. [1:28:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Right,. And then there was one business in the corner. Correct. Yeah, and that doesn't... Yes, please. [1:28:19] Speaker B (unidentified): While you may not like to talk about the waivers, you should actually act upon them because the applicant has requested them. Okay. And so you should take them up and make a vote on each one. [1:28:34] Speaker O (unidentified): But then somebody has to nominate to approve the waiver, and if you don't have anybody in favor of doing that, then who's going to make the nomination and second it? [1:28:43] Speaker B (unidentified): usually what happens is you make a motion to approve the waiver or grant the waiver and then everyone votes in the negative yeah that's that's normal [1:29:01] Speaker A (unidentified): procedure yeah we would say either in favor or against mr. chair right if you [1:29:06] Speaker R (unidentified): don't mind really with the driveway location understand that you don't want multiple commercial developments along this stretch but this is a very low traffic generator the peak trips during a.m. or p.m. peak hour is eight and I feel like that's high based off of what we've seen in reality but obviously we 've got to continue with the Transportation Board's numbers. But trying to do our best to make it as compliant as we can. Just the shape of the lot is just making this very difficult for us to make that separation. and just if you have any other ideas we can definitely you know take a look at that but obviously we want to make sure that we can get something out here for [1:30:17] Speaker F (unidentified): mr. Bosworth okay just this question on that line could you just clarify what is the status of the lot is this is this are these lot lines fixed and have they has this lot been as I understand from reading some of the documentation this is being divided off another existing parcel and has that occurred already because that are the lot lines as we see them they fixed and [1:30:45] Speaker R (unidentified): legal so yes it's a purchase and sale right now so none of the lines have been finalized but obviously what we have the purchase and sale for is kind of what we have shown tonight. We did discuss this with the family of the current owner, and they have very little interest in giving any more road frontage than they have to. So it would be kind of a stretch to try to get something like that. But, yes, correct, it is purchased and sale right now. so they are it's not it hasn't been conveyed as its own property at this [1:31:32] Speaker F (unidentified): point okay thank you mr. [1:31:36] Speaker D (unidentified): Frank regarding [1:31:39] Speaker C (unidentified): alternative entrances shall we say the as the letter we have from Patriot Holdings suggests that you should buy more property and build the entrance off of dingley spring just what i wrote now i have i [1:32:03] Speaker R (unidentified): actually haven't seen any of those letters i just got that we all just got this tonight [1:32:08] Speaker C (unidentified): so as an alternative i'm wondering if you have given any thought to the possibility of providing your access off of amber way which is a lot closer to this piece of property [1:32:23] Speaker R (unidentified): than Dingley spring is so amber way is a residential I don't know for sure but it appears to be a private road but I don't know that okay I didn't research that [1:32:39] Speaker G (unidentified): element of it staff let's see here Chuck is looking that up yeah it's a [1:32:48] Speaker S (unidentified): private way okay it is a private way [1:32:53] Speaker R (unidentified): thank you now if I made one [1:32:55] Speaker G (unidentified): clarification to on the roads for the board we were looking at the urban compact question it turns out that the state's map is actually incorrect so that it's defined in statute and kind of engineer here has looked at the statute and it specifically it references where the urban compact exists and it in the language of it, does describe this area, but the map doesn't show it. So that's the source of the conflicting information on that. So apologies for that. We go with the statute over the map. [1:33:33] Speaker O (unidentified): So the bottom line is that the standard applies? [1:33:36] Speaker G (unidentified): It's within the urban compact. Correct. Okay. [1:33:39] Speaker F (unidentified): So just Chuck and Damon, Carol, what have we done in similar situations? have we had similar situations where you have a lot that access, it wouldn't meet the access management requirement is the only option a waiver have we denied other businesses have we struggled elsewhere with this issue because it seems to me if we deny it then I'm trying to think what the heck happens I [1:34:18] Speaker B (unidentified): can't think of another property that's been reviewed that's been in this situation in terms of the access management rule yeah [1:34:31] Speaker F (unidentified): because if you look at this parcel of land and up as I understand it if the if another slice was taken out of it and created a similar lot next to it 'll be in the same situation we're not It would [1:34:51] Speaker O (unidentified): be further away, maybe. I don't know which direction you're going, but they have a waiver in both directions. [1:34:57] Speaker F (unidentified): Right, but if you were to cut another similar rectangular slice back off of Osprey Trail, that's a long, narrow lot with narrow frontage, but deep, you'd run into the same situation. [1:35:13] Speaker R (unidentified): So, actually, it just dawned on me after I was looking at the aerial. right in through here i don't know if you can see my cursor now they said right in through here is part of the wetland complex that continues down this direction and this lot a lot of it is wet so for us to do that obviously in most cases there's ways around it to do wetland fill but at the same time we try not to do that as much as we can I'm [1:35:57] Speaker F (unidentified): stumped that's that I'm stumped so are we going to bring the recommendation was to bring the waivers up and vote yay or nay on to [1:36:19] Speaker D (unidentified): have a legal record yes what one [1:36:23] Speaker O (unidentified): thing we're gonna table this anyway then can't we just table the whole thing everybody given guidance and said that we're told the applicant where we're at and [1:36:39] Speaker R (unidentified): if it's I mean if we do our part with talking with the landowner and there's some conversation documentation back and forth if that would be sufficient at least to provide you with a little bit more information to back it up we can definitely do that what's one of these please and just for I have a [1:36:58] Speaker G (unidentified): public record mr. chair just one suggestion the perhaps there are other strategies for improving safety for the intersection I just looked at the town engineer to see if he has any thoughts on that before just to help the board [1:37:14] Speaker S (unidentified): just some thoughts from an engineering perspective the access management standard does have language in it that relaxed can relax the standards but it's certainly up to the board I think what should be considered is the entrance uses that are adjacent to this parcel, the daily traffic, I would suggest that the applicant provide additional information on crash statistics on Ossipee Trail, segment and intersection crash statistics, those types of things, so that the board, if they do eventually make a decision on this, have much more information to go on from the entrance perspective. Because while these are parameters that we've set within our access management standards, there's certainly this corridor, certainly the existing entrances don't all adhere to the standard spacing. [1:38:16] Speaker O (unidentified): Right, but I would say that's part of the problem. [1:38:18] Speaker S (unidentified): It certainly can be, correct. [1:38:19] Speaker O (unidentified): And why there's been so much building out in that area. [1:38:24] Speaker S (unidentified): I did look up some crash data today with some of those comments that came in. So I don't have them memorized verbatim, but I think they certainly can paint a better picture for staff to be able to make that decision. A little more, rather, to make that decision. [1:38:45] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. To summarize, we're going to vote on these waivers, so it will be part of the record? [1:38:51] Speaker F (unidentified): Sure, that would help. It sounds like we're going to table, but would that make it more helpful to have it? [1:38:59] Speaker R (unidentified): Yeah, with the additional information, we can definitely help if we could table it. I mean, we could definitely bring that additional information for the next meeting. Yep, let's do it. [1:39:09] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, Mr. Walsh. All right, so, yes, on page three, we have two motions. motions so move to grant a waiver to Kevin Bosworth from requirements in 300 dash 2.3 7.1 C intersection slash entrance spacing from 350 to 169 point 3 feet for the proposed self storage development at map 76 lot 11 is [1:39:39] Speaker A (unidentified): there a second please mr. Frank second thank you mr. Frank everyone understand what we're we're trying to do here I'm just trying to clean this document up all those in [Speaker D (unidentified): favor all those] opposed okay I'll go with it all right wonderful all right [1:40:01] Speaker F (unidentified): mr. chairman yes please move to grant a waiver to Kevin Bosworth from requirements in subsection 300 1.5 a b 5d intersection slash entrance spacing from 400 feet to 169.3 feet for the proposed self-storage development at map 69 lot 11 thank you mr. Walsh through a second right thank you mr. [1:40:26] Speaker R (unidentified): Frank I apologize for interrupting but it is this the final decision on the waivers yes so if we don't get the waivers so we got to figure out what to [1:40:37] Speaker F (unidentified): do with the project he is second before you have a discussion yes all right you [1:40:42] Speaker O (unidentified): secondary. Yeah, so that's why I don't understand why we're voting on these, because I thought we had just decided that we were going to table it and wait for additional information. I mean, I guess they can always resubmit the waiver, right? And we just vote on it again. [1:40:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, that's the way I understand it. [1:40:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Once you vote on the waiver and let it set, it's voted on. So you've denied the first one. [1:41:09] Speaker G (unidentified): Although somebody who... [1:41:11] Speaker O (unidentified): reconsider votes and there's all kinds of stuff. [1:41:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Only if it's at the next meeting. Yes. Reconsideration can only come back at the next meeting. Correct. I don't think they'll be ready at the next meeting. [1:41:24] Speaker F (unidentified): Why would we want that? I guess I thought, Carol, you were asking us to put on the record that we're denying, but if the only recourse to that is reconsideration, then why are we putting [1:41:36] Speaker B (unidentified): ourselves in that box? If you deny, if you do not grant the waivers and you vote to not pass them essentially then they would have to redesign their project somehow so [1:41:53] Speaker F (unidentified): if they came back with compelling evidence that they showed us crash data or something to support the fact that we would have a we would support the waivers we couldn't do it that's what [1:42:05] Speaker B (unidentified): you're saying you can only reconsider it at the following meeting and then mr. [1:42:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Mr. Chairman, I withdraw my motion, and I would ask for reconsideration on the first one. [1:42:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there a second on the reconsideration, please? Mr. Frank. Thank you, Mr. Frank. Everyone understand? A motion can only be reconsidered at this meeting or the following meeting. Yeah, right at the beginning. So we're absolving this, and it's going to stay just the way it is. Yes. [1:42:35] Speaker F (unidentified): What do you have to do for reconsideration? I've never done that. [1:42:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Mr. – are you looking to pass the waiver or to table it? [1:42:42] Speaker A (unidentified): To table all the – Yeah, table it all. I'm not speaking. [1:42:44] Speaker F (unidentified): I think we, knowing now what Carol just told us, I want to get away from the waivers, leave them be, and table everything. [1:42:53] Speaker B (unidentified): Leave them outstanding and table the entire review. Correct. [1:42:58] Speaker A (unidentified): That's your consideration? Yes. Okay, so let's finish up this reconsideration. There was a motion by Mr. Walsh, a second by Mr. Frank. All those in favor? This is a reconsideration. All right. Thanks, Pete. Okay, so Mr. [1:43:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Chairman, just to clarify, that reconsidered the first motion, and I had withdrawn the second motion before we voted. [1:43:22] Speaker A (unidentified): We haven't had a second on the second. [1:43:24] Speaker G (unidentified): And just for the benefit of the note-taker here and for the minutes, so the reconsideration was to table the waiver, consideration of the waiver. Right. [1:43:35] Speaker B (unidentified): No, we voted to reconsider the waiver and table it. [1:43:42] Speaker A (unidentified): until the next meeting they come back yeah yes the entire document we had a motion and a second i want to make sure that was clear thank you are you okay yes we did have a motion and a second on [1:43:53] Speaker F (unidentified): the second item it was withdrawn i withdrew the motion before you voted okay before [1:44:01] Speaker A (unidentified): we voted okay we're good with that then yes understand mr chair please i move request for [1:44:09] Speaker O (unidentified): site plan approval for seven building 44 350 square foot self-storage facility with parking driveways and associated infrastructure located on that 76 lot 11 in the roadside commercial district pending receipt of additional information thank you colonel is there a second please second [1:44:24] Speaker A (unidentified): dave walsh mr walsh thank you everyone understand what's going on are you are you following all of this we want to we want this cleaned up apparently i was off by one vote i'm looking i'm looking over to my right we're gonna work with this work with the applicant to [1:44:41] Speaker G (unidentified): provide information as requested by the board yes sure hopefully [1:44:46] Speaker O (unidentified): putting that up yeah I would also say that for me personally I still have a concern about the waiver whether I like at this point I wouldn't vote for it so I would need to be such some compelling reason not to so if there are other options on the table or redesign for the project I like that would be appreciated from my perspective because that'll be a high hurdle for me to overcome okay all right there was a motion in a second to pay it to table [1:45:14] Speaker A (unidentified): any other discussion a big nose all those in favor thank you thank you look forward to seeing you soon thank you for your time moving along gentlemen item three a discussion site and final subdivision plan review South Ridge condominium Association a proposal to construct a 21 unit multi-family development and associated infrastructure on a 4.33 acre parcel on south street zone urban residential map 104 lot 14. the applicant anthony fernandez is represented by silas canavan pe with canadian civil consultants i look to staff to please introduce this mr chair [1:46:11] Speaker B (unidentified): THIS DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN IN FRONT OF YOU SEVERAL TIMES SINCE MAY 2026. PRELIMINARY APPROVAL WAS GRANTED BY YOU ON SEPTEMBER 14TH THIS YEAR. THEY ARE PROPOSING FINAL SUBDIVISION AND SITE PLAN APPROVAL FOR THIS EVENING. The, let's see, the reviews include Wright-Pierce's October review, and they have no further comments, including the street lighting that had a question to it. So that's been resolved. The channel for review confirms that the HOA documents are acceptable. and then the only resolution that needs to be figured out is parking space size waiver and [1:47:18] Speaker D (unidentified): with that I turn it to you mr. chair thank you very much thank you [1:47:25] Speaker Q (unidentified): good evening mr. Caribbean thank you silence canavan civil consultants the civil engineer for the project here representing Anthony Fernandez the applicant so thank you Carol for the rundown basically the plan is essentially the same as we saw last time most of the resubmissions have really just been administrative in nature we did submit the additional financial capacity and updated homeowners association documents that were requested the only changes to the actual site plan were that we moved we moved the cluster mailbox out of the right-of-way and we added some signage in the back of the law in the trail area just to indicate where the end of the development property is and the abutting neighbors property around them just so that people when they're walking the trails will not wander on to the to the neighbors property we did receive our main DP stormwater permit for the project and we did receive our Army Corps jurisdictional letter for the project which indicated they were not taking jurisdiction of this wetland so we do not need a permit from the Army Corps we also don't need a permit from the DEP for the wetlands because we're under the four thousand three hundred square foot threshold for that so one thing that did come up with staff is that we did that we do actually have to ask for a waiver for the parking lot parking space size the ordinance actually defines a parking space as 200 square feet they don't give dimensions to that but they call it they give it an area this whole time we've been proposing nine by eighteen nine foot wide by eighteen foot parking spaces which is the industry standard these days so we're hoping that the board will consider that reasonable for this residential project which we certainly in our opinion we believe that it is so that's the rundown of the changes, and I'll open it up to questions. [1:49:49] Speaker F (unidentified): Just one question I have for Chuck. I don't keep track of parking space sizes. Is this request typical? [1:50:02] Speaker S (unidentified): Yes. We've actually seen it in other projects as well, and it is an item that the town staff have talked about updating in the land use code. Nine foot by 18 foot is standard Park Next All Bay size. [1:50:30] Speaker F (unidentified): You've done a lot of work on this, and it's really looking good. No doubt. Is there anything else we need to discuss? There's a waiver. Oh, I guess we have to do the waiver. [1:50:46] Speaker O (unidentified): Mr. Chair, I move to grant a waiver from the parking space to mention a requirement contained in Chapter 300, Part 4.9d to allow an alternate parking design with parking spaces measuring 9 feet by 18 feet or 162 square feet rather than the required 10 feet by 20 feet or 200 square feet, which will provide for safe and convenient circulation of vehicles throughout the lot. [1:51:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Colonel. Is there a second? [1:51:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Frank will second. Thank you, Mr. Frank. [1:51:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Pretty clear, I think. Pretty clearly understood. understood all those in favor anyone opposed thank you mr. Delaney four to one okay moving along anyone [1:51:34] Speaker F (unidentified): else mr. Walsh are we ready for motion on the project [1:51:39] Speaker A (unidentified): looking around the other comments questions suggestions ideas means it's [1:51:47] Speaker F (unidentified): gone through a lot of a lot of discussion well [1:51:52] Speaker A (unidentified): this what I like about this application is the lack of yellow yes yeah I noticed the same thing well done that's a compliment if you misconstrued it's a compliment appreciate it yeah some other meetings yellow is the bane of our existence [1:52:08] Speaker F (unidentified): first thing you look for and you know I missed the September meeting and when I think we can get preliminary but I like the changes that you have made then Public [1:52:29] Speaker A (unidentified): comment? No. No, sir, it's not a public hearing. Look to my left. Only one person. It won't hurt, I guess. Please come up to the podium and state your name and address on the record. [1:52:46] Speaker R (unidentified): James Walker, 8th Concord Court, Gorham. [1:52:50] Speaker G (unidentified): All I want is, can I get a copy of this? This layout? Is it public information? Of course it is. Yes, it's online. [1:53:01] Speaker B (unidentified): in the planning board web page that's all i needed it's connected to the agenda [1:53:22] Speaker A (unidentified): sorry you had to wait so long okay so mr walker's happy anyone else please look [1:53:36] Speaker O (unidentified): it looks like we have two motions mr chair i move to grant final subdivision approval for southbridge subdivision located on map 104 lot 14 in the urban residential zoning district based on findings of fact and conditions of approval as written by the town planner thank you colonel is there a second please [1:53:54] Speaker A (unidentified): second dave wall thank you thank you mr walsh any other discussion on this it's pretty cut and dry i think we passed one waiver all those in favor anyone opposed one down one to go [1:54:06] Speaker O (unidentified): Mr. Chair, I move to grant Anthony Fernandez's request for site plan approval for Southbridge site plan located on Map 104, Lot 14 in the Urban Residential Zoning District based on findings of fact and conditions of approval as written by the Town Planner. Thank you, Colonel. Is there a second? [1:54:21] Speaker F (unidentified): Second, Dave Walsh. Thank you, Mr. Walsh. Any [1:54:25] Speaker A (unidentified): other discussion on this item? All those in favor? Anyone opposed? [1:54:32] Speaker F (unidentified): Good luck with the project. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. [1:54:34] Speaker C (unidentified): A quick comment. Very nicely done on the sidewalk oh thank you very informative it was a quite a [1:54:42] Speaker A (unidentified): interesting hike thank you everybody and there were no bugs that was good no ticks that I know okay keep going okay ladies and gentlemen ladies and gentlemen this is item for item 4 in our agenda a discussion pre-application site plan review district plaza mixed-use development a request for review of a proposal to construct an approximately 6,000 square foot commercial building with parking and associated infrastructure on a 1.16 acre parcel on County Road zone South Gorham commercial corridor map for lot 9 the applicant Jovic Holdings LLC is represented by Andy moral PE with bh2m Did I say that correctly? Jovich? Jovich. I don't mean to disrespect you. Jovich. Jovich. I apologize. Look to my right, please. [1:55:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, Mr. Chair. This is the initial pre-application sketch plan phase, so the staff recommendations aren't binding, and they're just, you know, getting your comments. Initial comments and feedback. The habitat, there's possible wetland and natural resource habitat toward the furthest part of the original parcel. And the reason I'm saying that is because there's a proposal to split off a lot toward the front of the main parcel. And so the habitat and wetland would not be on the lot that is proposed to be split off. But as it stands right now, it's on that lot, so we need to mention it. The possible apartments on the second floor would trigger sprinklers, and so there's a debate with the applicant whether to actually have this as a mixed-use property, which would include commercial, professional, and residential components, but they're still debating that because of the cost of sprinklers. So that's to be determined, but it's part of the discussion with them. them you don't need any decision this evening they just need feedback and comments and with that I turn it over to you mr. chair thank you miss Ironman good [1:57:31] Speaker A (unidentified): evening mr. Morrow I'm trying to look at the site but do you have this on cat by any chance other than this beautiful rendering I'm trying to try to locate this I can see South Street I'm trying to see what other street it's in between there is no other street on the site plan there is any chance you can pull that up but you know I have that 's further away in your location map you show where the site is but I was wondering what is the name of the street thank you I'm sorry Oh Deering Road okay thank you thank you [1:58:31] Speaker G (unidentified): yep Deering Road good [1:58:50] Speaker A (unidentified): evening mr. moral thank you good evening sorry [1:58:57] Speaker T (unidentified): I'm just trying to get technology to work here good evening thank you the applicants are here as well 1.16 acre parcel roughly at 99 County Road zone the South Gorham commercial corridor the applicants kind of in the information gathering stage trying to decide whether they want to move forward with this project so we're here tonight to just kind of present this project to you guys get as much input from you as we can the applicant will then kind of decide whether they want to whether this makes sense to move forward so we thought the best way to start that conversation was to come here and have a conversation with you guys so here we are what the applicants looking to do is a high-end mixed-use building known as district Plaza we've currently proposed a 6,000 of the square foot building two floors the first floor would have a 3,500 square foot gym on one end that's if you're looking at the front rendering that's what's on shown on the right hand side of the of the rendering you're looking at 270 to 750 square foot office spaces in the interior on the first floor those are kind of where you see all the windows in the in the center of the building and then one 1,000 square foot unit on the other end of the building second floor we have proposed commercial space over the two end units and over the two interior units where you see those bank of windows if you will those were originally intended to be residential apartments we did have meeting with staff last week had a pretty detailed conversation about different options for this building I think the applicant is contemplating removing those residential units and making them all commercial units but that's still to be to be determined but I think that's kind of where they're leaning at this point so we'd be we'd be happy to hear any discussion from the board on that the other building is a 625 foot square foot detached building for a cafe or a food distribution drilled well subsurface wastewater will serve both of these buildings we have shown they pull up our site plan here we have shown 47 parking spaces on our building in our parking lot the ordinance would require 32 parking spaces not knowing the use this is kind of where we started I think as we work through the process we'll kind of fine-tune that parking wait on one item we definitely talked with the fire chief when we met last week was he liked the ability to loop the parking lot to make his fire truck easier to get in and out of we tried to if you look down where the entrance comes out on the county road there's an existing entrance there we tried to match that as best we can just because the site distance is better on that side of the site so we're trying to propose this entrance in the safest location possible certainly when we do the survey work as part of this we'll measure the site distance and when we come forward to you guys we'll have all that information one other item we discussed was potentially phasing this project the applicant may potentially kind of phase this building their priorities would be kind of the two end units on the first floor would we really get those up and running as kind of the first part of the project so this project in this building and project may be phased in some way as we come forward we had a very productive meeting with staff last week we talked about phasing sprinklers sight distances fire truck turnarounds screening requirements 5% parking requirements in the parking lot septic systems we also talked about a master sign plan which the applicant has reached out to spectrum sign plans to work with them to kind of do a master site sign plan approval concurrently with this approval sketch plan is in my opinion the most important step of a project we're here tonight to just try to introduce this to you guys we welcome any comment any direction you can give us is greatly appreciated that will help the applicant as they decide how best to move forward with that so mr. chairman with that I'll throw it back to you and happy to answer any questions you may have thank you very [2:03:48] Speaker A (unidentified): much mr. moral can you leave up the rendering happy to thank you appreciate [Speaker D (unidentified): it that] was the board I'll chime in I'm not I want to go home at some point I'm gonna chime in this rendering yes I don't know whose idea it is I'll give [2:04:15] Speaker T (unidentified): you the credit I'm not sure what it was not me this credit I don't deserve it [2:04:19] Speaker A (unidentified): this is an excellent representation of what we would like to see my career is in this as you know and so I can visualize it the big picture but seeing this for a non-technical audience I think is a great step forward now, if we can do this, it'll be even better. And I'm sorry, I stole your thunder, Mr. Walsh. [2:04:39] Speaker F (unidentified): No, I have to agree. It's great to see some of this. I mean, you said earlier, come for a high-end building. I mean, it looks really nice. I guess if you can now go back to the site plan. Sure. I'm just a little troubled by the layout. I know you have an awkward lot here. The food building. Yes. It just seems like, okay, that could drive volume, and it's kind of an awkward area. I have to park him back and walk. Oh, I don't know. You've lost my interest. Yeah. Unless it's really good food. I don't know. It just seems like over there, wouldn't it seem like that might be better in one of the other slots and have your office over on the other side? You asked my opinion. [2:05:31] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah, no, this is what we're here for tonight is to get your opinion. So we welcome any opinions. [2:05:36] Speaker F (unidentified): And then the other question is, okay, food, I mean, obviously you put it there. There's no real way to do drive-thru. So, you know, in that location, if that was even a thought. [2:05:51] Speaker U (unidentified): It could be a very small drive-up coffee window type thing. [2:05:56] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, but not in that location. Yeah. [2:05:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Please, Mr. Frank. [2:06:01] Speaker T (unidentified): i was waiting for andy to write his essay over there go for it i can listen and write at the [2:06:08] Speaker C (unidentified): same time yeah with respect to the food building i was originally thinking that okay the apart the second floor apartments which i just learned are maybe not going to be part of the deal that they were going to be the attendee or attendees the ones who are going to patronize the place and moving the food building in the way back it'd be kind of invisible no that probably wouldn't work well either Oh one other thing please mr. Franklin I would welcome a site walk [2:06:53] Speaker O (unidentified): okay I saw the nose sidewalks required I don't know if you plan to do it in lieu of for off-site sidewalks so that 's just a something I'm interested in I [2:07:11] Speaker T (unidentified): know I appreciate you bringing that up I think that's definitely something we were hoping we could discuss this evening I think our intention would be to do an internal sidewalk as part of the site I mean obviously County Road there's there's not a whole lot of sidewalks out there on County Road I think the applicant would be in favor of the in lieu fee for the off-site sidewalk but we'd certainly like to hear your thoughts on that yeah I mean [2:07:37] Speaker O (unidentified): we've been consistent on the in lieu fee but I think the general plan for the area you know is hopefully to build it out and to have it you know as a commercial zone so yeah which would you'd want to have sidewalks at some point absolutely in the area so tied to that then and I don't know I should know this but the you mentioned septic so I don't know how far away sewer and water is but if we're building this out as a as an industrial commercial zone it would make sense to have sewer and water in the area we're not that far away from the intersection of 114 and 22 there's already some commercial projects there so I'm just if you if you know please enlighten X I don't [2:08:20] Speaker T (unidentified): remember I don't I don't know exactly how far the water is away I can tell you of the sewer is a significant distance away from this I want to say [Speaker U (unidentified): public water] is up in the Scarborough side of County Road I believe closest [2:08:40] Speaker G (unidentified): public water may be on South Street even [2:08:42] Speaker S (unidentified): I believe the closest we're currently doing a study in South Gorham and I will say without getting into too many particulars water and sewer in this location would be prohibitively expensive without a lot of major infrastructure projects to happen. The nearest sewer would be either South Street or when the Gorham Fairways project gets constructed down McClellan Road. Those would be the closest areas. Water, I do believe, is South Street would be the closest. [2:09:11] Speaker O (unidentified): All of them pretty far away, even with the correct thing to do. Very, far away. [2:09:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay. We could check with Laura Nobles and see if she has downed water at her house. It's right next door. [2:09:29] Speaker O (unidentified): And then on the setbacks, and forgive me for not knowing the requirements, but, like, I see the dumpster, like, you know, outside of the setback, there are some of the parking lot overlaps, et cetera. Is the setback only for permanent structures, or is it supposed to be for all site design? [2:09:50] Speaker B (unidentified): It's for all of the buildings. the parking lots and trash receptacle items can be in the site right up [2:10:02] Speaker O (unidentified): against the property line there's no there's no requirement at all for that 's a true statement so my shed on my personal property has to have a setback but from a house next door but the dumpster does not duly noted it's a yes [2:10:19] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, but there are screening requirements in place. That is true. So it could be there but screened appropriately. And that's something we've – I think we flagged this for the applicants, that they'd have to meet the parking lot and zoning screening. [2:10:36] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, it looks like there's plenty of space to be able to put a dumpster somewhere. So it's not a big concern. I just saw it. [2:10:42] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah, I think relocating that dumpster makes a lot of sense. [2:10:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Code enforcement is going to call on you tomorrow. [2:10:50] Speaker F (unidentified): Coming back, just thinking back, I know you originally mentioned residential and then not residential. And just looking at what you have laid out here, it would seem to be awkward to have a couple apartments up above this thing. Yeah. Yeah. Not that it couldn't be done. I mean, it really speaks commercial. [2:11:17] Speaker T (unidentified): commercial yeah and I think that's the way the applicant is leaning is to potentially remove those that residential component and go with a commercial second floor but that's still to be determined and you one thing when [2:11:32] Speaker F (unidentified): looking at the map well the property line map on the in the packet yeah it shows a much larger lot that's kind of an odd-shaped thing. Yes. How does this fit into that? [2:11:49] Speaker T (unidentified): So if you're looking at that larger lot, this is to the left of the other lot that was cut out of that. So kind of that left little flag leg that's cut out of that lot. [2:12:01] Speaker F (unidentified): So has this been cut out? Is it part of that whole lot, or has it been broken off? [2:12:06] Speaker T (unidentified): it is currently part of that lot and the owner of that lot is looking to sell this lot as well as the remaining piece of the land so the applicants are considering purchasing this lot which would be one point one point one six acres is the total all right so [2:12:25] Speaker F (unidentified): it's just really what we're looking at correct i mean it's a little bit bigger than what i've [2:12:29] Speaker T (unidentified): shown here on the screen but i mean i can zoom out a little bit you can see that's the whole lot right there okay all right so the other portion of the lot is up is up here yeah and [2:12:39] Speaker F (unidentified): would you ever consider would you consider another building in the back we 've had discussions [2:12:46] Speaker T (unidentified): with the applicant about potentially doing something else in the back what that would be at this point i don't know we talked about some potentially you know out some kind of outdoor facility a basketball court something like that but what we tried to reserve that area that's why you've seen I've kind of pushed my stormwater facility to the very back of the site because it's the lowest spot but also trying to kind of reserve that area back there for potentially something else okay so yeah there certainly could be something else back [2:13:18] Speaker D (unidentified): there all right snow yeah thanks [2:13:28] Speaker A (unidentified): anyone else yep one more yes please mr. [2:13:32] Speaker U (unidentified): Delaney I really like the 24-foot access drive okay good I don't like the size of the spaces being 9 by 18 okay they're not I mean I mean becoming known as you know, the parking lot guy, I guess. But 9 by 18 is not big enough for a pickup truck. Yep. For a small truck, sure. Yeah. [2:13:58] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah, an F-150, maybe not. Yeah. Yeah. [2:14:00] Speaker U (unidentified): Mine is, you know, again, people are sick of hearing me talking about my trucks, but a 20-foot truck is pretty normal. If anybody was at the grand opening for the farm stand this weekend, that parking lot was absolutely full of vehicles, and there were trucks just parked at least two feet from the designated parking spaces because they just couldn't fit in there. And it was a giant nightmare to just navigate around that parking lot. [2:14:31] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah. Would you support kind of a combination of the two? I was just going to ask that. Some 9 by 18, some 10 by 20? [2:14:38] Speaker U (unidentified): A lot of trucks have to park, and it's acceptable to park like in the back of the parking lot because the spaces are sometimes bigger, or we take up two spots. So in the back of the lot, if they're 10 by 20, perfect. [2:14:58] Speaker T (unidentified): No, that's great feedback. Anyone else? [2:15:04] Speaker C (unidentified): Please, Mr. Frank. In view of Ms. Nichols, I'm going to ask you, are you planning on any charging stations? [2:15:15] Speaker T (unidentified): Have you guys considered any charging stations? No. We have not. [2:15:22] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to look to the right. Is that coming up as developments are being created? [2:15:30] Speaker B (unidentified): that we haven't discussed it you know to put on-site plans so yeah [2:15:40] Speaker A (unidentified): and I'm not trying to pressure anyone I'm just I'm just curious in a talking point it the town is putting in all over the place I just didn't but they probably got some grant money so I don't know yeah grant money you sure [2:15:53] Speaker G (unidentified): gentlemen anything else just one question for the board there was a discussion of a site walk is that something you'd like us to try to schedule now I look to the app on the perennial site walk suggested with the applicant like us to try to schedule that now with winter coming in I believe you under you have some purchase deadline coming up would you like to do [2:16:14] Speaker T (unidentified): the site walk before that or after that here I'll give you my input I think a site walk the earlier in the process I think the better I think the sooner you guys can see it the sooner we can get input from you guys about what your thoughts are I think in this case we're going to want to look at the entrance location and where we think that entrance should be best located I think that would be a really critical step as early in the process I think that could be helpful to the applicant at this point when they're trying to kind of figure out whether it makes sense to move forward with this project I think that would be helpful something [2:16:50] Speaker A (unidentified): something during the daylight [2:16:51] Speaker G (unidentified): yeah which shrinking it may need to be in the morning if that's okay with the board fine please coffee and donuts okay we'll send out how about we send out some a doodle in late November or possibly early December to see what works we do [2:17:12] Speaker A (unidentified): need time to advertise it okay what's what's if you started tomorrow one if you advertise tomorrow about two weeks about that's probably the tightest we could go yeah don't know earlier than maybe the week of the 23rd Thanksgiving week yeah would that be okay he's a second yeah would that be okay with the [2:17:32] Speaker G (unidentified): board early Thanksgiving week maybe Monday Tuesday yeah we'll send out a poll that okay coffee and doughnuts how about turkey if I had if I had the [2:17:47] Speaker T (unidentified): corner of the buildings in the corner of the parking lot staked out is that is that really what you guys would like to kind of see when we're out there? Sure. Is there anything else that you'd like to see while? Yeah, [2:17:59] Speaker A (unidentified): I was only proposing the sooner the better. I mean, for everyone concerned. Well, winners. Back to the parking lot, John. [2:18:06] Speaker F (unidentified): Flag would be fine. Okay. [2:18:09] Speaker G (unidentified): We'll send out a duel with some dates in that range. Okay. Yep. Great. [2:18:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Anything else for Andy? Mr. Morrow, rather. We'll see you in a couple of weeks. gentlemen the last thing on our agenda for this evening is the 2027 planning board meeting schedule we try to get this thing published early and so the whole world knows when we're getting together it also includes optional dates which are less optional and lately but we need them just in case with the planning do you want to kick this off or is this self-explanatory I guess the only thing [2:19:02] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm gonna ask is just really personal because I tend not to be in town in the summer is if we can just minimize those second meetings in the month in the summer in July and August if those could be avoided hey just make my life well [2:19:17] Speaker A (unidentified): I have to travel I mean yeah we just need a majority yeah and then you have a short of me. We can meet at your place someplace, wherever that is. [2:19:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Always welcome. We've worked the schedule around holidays and for everybody. [2:19:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, we included major religious holidays. We attempted it, made every effort to scan against that. [2:19:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Sure,. So we have to, we want to vote on this. [2:19:53] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, if the board would like to vote to approve it, I think that would Do we need more time? [2:19:57] Speaker A (unidentified): you're good to vote on it i mean yeah let's go becomes no way anyone do we need to vote typically we have on the other groups i've served on any emotion yes please i think mr delaney said [2:20:13] Speaker U (unidentified): so right mr delaney make a motion to adopt the 2027 planning board meeting schedule second dave [2:20:19] Speaker A (unidentified): walsh thank you mr walsh is there any other discussion and you know perhaps maybe in the middle of the calendar we have to change a date but right now this is going to be this is going to be what's published for the for the community anyone opposed thank you very much is there any other business to come before us one just real [2:20:43] Speaker F (unidentified): quick when you when we're talking about self storage tonight we come up with this a couple times parking standards for self storage we always have to just you know go around obviously you don't need it in the next revision of something should that just be written in that you know because we're getting more and more of these things coming up just save yourself the trouble if you just write it in that you don't have to have the parking standard for self-storage [2:21:17] Speaker A (unidentified): wonderful alrighty anything else to come before us thank you to everybody before we adjourn, is there a motion, please? Move to adjourn. Thank you, Mr. Walsh. Just a second, please. Sure. Mr. Frank, thank you. You're on a roll. I appreciate it. Any other discussion? Any reason why we can't? All those in favor? Anyone opposed? Thanks to everybody for your participation and your hard work and your patience with me.