Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening and welcome to our town council meeting. We're going to go ahead and get started here. And Julie, if you would go ahead and do our roll call for the meeting, please. Councilor Diaz? Here. Councilor Tracy? Here. Councilor Mahoney? Here. Councilor Sharp? Here. Councilor Morton? Here. Councilor Hawk? Here. Councilor Vance? Here. That's everyone. Thank you very much for that, Julie. And before we start with item number one, Councilor Diaz is going to offer a couple quick comments regarding the Falmouth Superfans.
[0:35] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you, Bryce. Just wanted to provide some background on this. It's an initiative that we've been working on for a few months. The goal is to get more members of the town to be involved in the event and the town. So the focus right now is the schools. So for people who don't have kids in the school system but still want to participate in the events at the schools, whether it's a play or a sporting event, they are welcome and they are officially called super fans, but it's not limited to schooling events. It's just that right now that's the focus. It's initiative sponsored by our friends at Falmouth community events slash friends of Falmouth. It's the town council has been really polite in allowing that to go through and it's sponsoring it in its own way, but all the efforts are coming from that young non-profit. So very excited about this, a new thing, and lent thank you for letting me say a few
[1:35] Speaker A (unidentified): words about it. Thank you, Counselor Diaz. So with that, we will go ahead and we're going to jump right into item number one on the agenda, on the agenda, which is a Falmouth Memorial Library and Harbor Waterfront Committee update. The council has requested that the town boards and committees take turns providing oral updates at council meetings each month on board or committee's directions, including progress on work plan assignments, as well as a synopsis of the board committee's role in municipal government. The Falmouth Memorial Library and the Harbor Waterfront Committee will provide updates at this meeting. A written version of the library and harbor waterfront updates has also been attached with the agenda for this meeting this evening. So with that, we'll go ahead and start with the Falmouth Memorial Library.
[2:32] Speaker C (unidentified): Can you hear me okay? Sure can. Thanks for having us tonight. We've had a really great year at the library, so I always look forward to being able to talk to you all about some of our successes and big things that we have going on. One major item, we joined hundreds of other libraries nationwide in ceasing to collect overdue fines this year in July. This has been a long time coming. It's something I've talked about with the board for many years, and some libraries managed to do that during COVID, just kind of made that transition. But a lot of research has found that it disproportionately disadvantages kids. Kids can't get back to the library to return their books, and if their parents forget, and then their parents use their cards. There's a lot of kids with blocked cards, so being able to get rid of fines, it's also just really hard for educators. We see a lot of homeschool parents and teachers that take out 30, 40 books at a time, really easy to misplace a book and get a lot of fines. So we often forgive fines anyway, but this is just a way to just make that statement that just bring the book back, we don't care how long it takes you. There's a lot of library shame involved with that, which is very weird to us in libraries because we're always bringing our books back late, too, and we don't want that, so we really just want the books back. So we still have fees for missing items, but not for fines, and that was a big deal. We were one of two libraries around here that still charged fines, so we're really excited about that. The other big item I wanted to talk about just a little bit is that we are in the midst of a strategic planning process, and had a survey that went out to the community. We post on social media in the library, send it out to our newsletter, and I believe the town also sent it out into their newsletter. Thank you very much. And we had over 500 responses, which is really great, and I've gone through, pouring through all of the comments and all of the responses to the types of things that people want us to do, and I hope to have all of that completed soon. And we've got a committee on the, of board members and staff, so we're pulling all of that data together now, hopefully to have something written and then made public early next year. And I really want to make all of the responses public because it was really, interesting. The top three items when asked what the library should add when we're successful in fundraising and have the funds to do so were to buy more print books, add additional evening hours, and invest in more e-books and e-audiobooks. So I find that really interesting because it's all really traditional library stuff. And that print books is still in the lead. People just want more books. I think a lot of folks think everything's online. We don't need libraries. Everything's online. And that's just not the case. And we have a lot of book readers here in Falmouth. So that was really interesting. Another item that was really interesting for us, and we did intentionally ask because we know the difficulty cult of fundraising is asking if they knew that the library is a private nonprofit that relies on fundraising for a significant portion of its operating budget. And only 31% of the responders knew that. And I think that's huge. And it's always been a challenge. It's been a challenge in other libraries, nonprofits that I've worked in. Nonprofit public libraries are a main thing. And so it's not as common in a lot of other states nearby, and so people don't always assume that it's not fully funded by taxpayer dollars even though we are excellently funded, thank you all very much, but fundraising is a huge part of what we do. So being able to get that message out that we should be another organization that people think about with their donations is a big deal for us. I had some quotes that I definitely cherry picked out in my report so they were all really nice, but I also had some really excellent, I wouldn't call them criticisms, but a lot of really great ideas for things that we can do to improve the library and just even make tweaks to our services so that we can better serve the people of Falmouth. So it's a really, it's a great survey and lots of wonderful results, and I'd like to make that public as soon as possible so everybody can see what we've been, I'm working on. We also had a, I hope some of you were able to come out to, we had a very big exhibit when I was here last fall. We were just starting in, so I mentioned it, but it went for three months, and it was the Great State of Illustration in Maine, a partnership with the Illustration Institute. Probably like one of the biggest things that we've tried to do at the library, and it was very successful. One of the reasons we like them as a partner is they do a lot of wraparound programming with the exhibit itself. So they had ties to lots of different artists that came in and were able to, they did a draw, if they did some kids programming, they did some adult programming, some panels, and our overall traffic increased last year by 33 percent. And that's not just the exhibit, that's the programming, that's the energy. We also just had a really strong fundraising year, and a lot of that is like, hey, look what they're doing, and money follows money in some respects when it comes to that. So then people want to give us money for more programming. So we also got a $5,000 grant. We had asked people for money for the exhibit. It's like, hey, you know, I don't want to fund that, but since you're asking for money, how about I fund summer reading? And so we've been able to do some really creative things. So we don't think we have the capacity to do an exhibit of that scale every year, but it is something we want to try to do every two or three years so that we can bring big, exciting, fun things to the people of Falmouth. I found that one of the things in the survey I found super interesting is the top thing people wanted with programming was lectures by experts in their field, and then author talks after that. So all the book clubs, all the regular stuff, all the things that we do, we got a lot of smart people in Falmouth that really want to keep informed, and things like the Camden conference that we're partnering with upcoming, those are super popular programs. So we're looking forward to doing a lot more of that. The other thing that we've, we have a new programming person, and she's been doing a lot of what we would call in the library passive programming, where we're just giving a, like an opportunity for people to be part of a community, so there was like a poetry tree, and we partnered with community programs to do this community connection tree. And I had put this in the handout. And it's really just an opportunity to share people's feelings, thoughts on a variety of topics. So, you know, like during poetry month or if there's a particular celebratory week or something like that, it's really brought a lot of interesting engagement. I think in Valentine's Day we had little hearts that we placed around the library. People could talk about what they loved about their library. But we've also, like, tried to do that with the community as well, not just with the library, since we do get so many people that come through our doors. And I think the last thing I would like to highlight tonight is our Ugly Sweater and Merry Mile Race, which is an incredible partnership with the town and our flagship fundraising event. We had a 23% increase in registrations last year, and we are kind of, like, right on target with that. I promise it will be well run. I promise. Yeah. My puns are always intended. Like I said, it is our flagship fundraising event. It's due to strong corporate sponsorship, community participation, support from Falmouth staff, town staff that are there. It's, you know, there's not a lot of easy ways to go out and ask people for money, but our businesses in town want to support the library, and so this is one event that we can just slap logos everywhere and give everybody the best recognition and show that they're a partner in our community, and it's been really impactful for our ability to do fundraising, not just for the event but long term. So registration is open. I hope all of the super fans will come and enjoying this community event. So anyway. Thank you. Great, thank you, Jenna. Appreciate that.
[11:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Does anyone on the council have any questions or anything for Jenna while she's here?
[11:18] Speaker D (unidentified): yes counselor sharp thank you i know and forgive me for not knowing exactly but the kind of contribution revenues the donations we have a we have a person that does that at the library that's a relatively new position i think is that right it's like three years yeah gwen is our development director and it sounds like that's kind of evolving in positive ways i'd be curious sort of what you've learned you touched on it a little bit like are there things we've learned about ways to kind of get people a, aware that the library runs on at least largely on donations, and sort of to provide the circumstances in which people are looking to donate. I'm just curious if we feel like we're getting better at that, and because it is such an incredible resource, like, it seems a reasonable thing that people would want to, you know. Yeah, I
[12:06] Speaker C (unidentified): Mean we're definitely an easy sell because we're we're like involved in so many things in the community and such a core space for children and families. I think the word you used there was awareness is the biggest thing. I mean honestly before we hired a development director and the town and town council were really supportive of that kind of multi-year process of getting up to speed doing that and what it costs to do that, which we're grateful for. Honestly, we weren't asking a lot of people. We asked the same people. So if you had given to the library before we asked you for money, but we weren't asking new people. And after COVID, after the renovation, we had an enormous number of new cardholders who were from other states, from other places who did not know the way things are set up. So we are asking a lot more people. And that alone made a huge difference even in the first year. Gwen's awesome. She can ask you for money, and you won't even know she's done it. She is really, like, having somebody that is their job, their dedication, their focus is a really big deal. I mean, we were trying to do that with a great board of 12 volunteers who were actually stuffing envelope, doing the whole thing, being able to spend that time instead making connections with potential donors so you know even during this process for the strategic planning you know we did some one-on-one meetings and focus groups and just that process of connecting with people and having a conversation calling them up and saying hey you know can we talk to you that is a soft sell towards asking for a donation if it were me I would never actually ask for the donation because I'm a librarian and I don't do that but we have a having a development director that knows how to do that and knows how to explain why it's critical for our success and having that focus and I was shocked we have to we have to submit numbers to the state of Maine every year when we submit our charitable license application and the amount that we've submitted in the past has been I think the first time that I had Records of it was like 150 because that was our goal four years ago I think it was and I don't even know if I should admit this right before budget season but it was it included the Illustration Institute so all the grants we got the restricted gifts we got as a result of that we have a donations line that is like donations that we get that we might not expect every year and then we also got one donation from a foundation that sometimes gives us get twice in the same fiscal year so it's a Little inflated but it was over three $300,000. I don't think, I didn't even think that we would get that high that quickly. So again, a lot of that was restricted money that was for the illustration exhibit and not directly to operations. But we've just never fundraised at this level before. And if you talk to Gwen, she's like, oh yeah, she's just getting started. Because now she'd like to talk to you about your estate planning. And she'd like to talk to you about DAFs. And she'd like to talk to you about this did you know about that she just really she's really good at it and so we're and she lives in the community is a member of the community has kids in the school system so she's she's it's it's she loves it and we love having her so we love having the position and not all libraries do so we're grateful for that great
[15:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have any yes Counselor Tracy thanks Jenna great
[15:40] Speaker E (unidentified): Conversation, as always. You know, it's always fascinating to see how many authors and illustrators we have here in the in the state of Maine. I mean, obviously, the Illustrations Institute with was amazing, you know, the draw off of, you know, Chris Van Dusen, who couldn't be any better and Scott Nash and others, I mean, and some that live right here in Falmouth. So and, you know, before that, when we had Monica Wood and, you know, she was such a wonderful speaker and did a lot of her work at the library. So I appreciate and I think, you know, to your point and to Gwen's point, having access to or being able to access and use these amazing people in our community and in our state to be able to further fundraise. You know, I know we talk about that soft ask and Gwen is really good at it. And I appreciate, you know, I think having staff to be able to host these kind of events and to be able to ask these people to, you know, come and host builds on the library. But it's sort of one of those catch 22. You need you need to have the personalities and the staff to be able to do it. And I think, you know, it's been going gangbusters since Gwen's been around and, you know, you guys work well together and I appreciate all the things. And I'm sure we will continue with it. I love, I mean, it's fun to be in there and the programming is so deep. You know, it's fun to see the fly tying group. It's this bunch of big burly men with big bags of boxes of stuff and they go and talk fly fishing and tie flies. Eyes and it's fascinating to see this group come through and then you know all the littles coming through for story time it's you know it's a great I appreciate the breadth of programming that the library is putting forward and continuing to grow and tapping into the outstanding talent we have here in Maine on authors and illustrators. So thank you know it's funny
[17:46] Speaker C (unidentified): I thought I knew how to do library programming and then we hired someone new last fall and some of the programs, I'm like, what is that? Like, it's not something I would have thought of or planned. I think she had a fife and drum company come in for the 250th. And we had everybody out on the lawn, kids running around. It was really great. She had a classical guitarist come in two weekends ago, maxed out the parking lot. There was over 70 people there. It was like on a Saturday afternoon, like in the fall. I was like, what? So the variety has been huge. Speaking of author talks, I should have promoted. We've got Susan Conley coming next week, and she's the author of Landslide. She is super charming and I think is going to be a really, great talk. And that's one of the talks that we're doing where we also paired it with, like, a reception for donors beforehand, but then a program that's open to the public afterwards. So if you like author talks, please come to that. That's going to be fantastic. But, yeah, the variety of programming right now cannot be beat. It's not due to me, but our staff is fantastic. So I'm really appreciative of all of our great staff.
[18:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Do we have any other questions or comments? Jenna, thank you so much for your time this evening. Certainly appreciate it. So with that, we're going to go ahead and shift to our next update, which is from our Harbor and Waterfront Committee.
[19:13] Speaker F (unidentified): Good evening. John Kilbride, Police Chief. I'm standing in tonight for Marty Bruno, the Chair, who couldn't be here this evening, so I'll give you an update on the report. The town landing continues as a well-managed multi-use waterfront resource. It is one of town's most visible and valuable assets. It is used by boaters, fishermen, beachgoers, paddle sport enthusiasts, swimmers, visitors throughout the year. The harbor staff and committee offer ongoing attention to maintain safe operations. The committee continues to be fully staffed with a dedicated group of volunteers, a mix of residents, and representatives from private clubs. Town Landing is a treasure, it certainly is. Continued collaboration between the Harbor Master, the Harbor Committee, the Council, help ensure that this valuable public resource remains sustainable, welcoming, and well cared for year after year. Air, we truly do appreciate the council's support and in maintaining this valuable resource. Some of the highlights at the harbor this past year: moorings approved moorings 1136 compared to 1152 this time last year. Weightless residents 104 compared to 98 same time last year, non-resident zero. Dinghy permits, a total of 64 dinghy permits were issued, 53 out of 57 to residents and 11 out of 13 to non-residents for the second consecutive year. All available permits were not sold. So we have that on Saturdays here in April. If you were listening, I would probably, you don't have to be here at three in the morning, probably get here at seven and you still should be pretty fine. Kayak permits, all 12 available kayak permits were sold and utilized this year. I think we had close to 60, 70 applicants on that. Remains popular both in use and excitement when we pull that out. Parking violations, total of 263 parking violations were issued compared to 182 during the same period last year. This represents a record of tickets used. We're not trying to break records with tickets, we're just trying to move people in and out of that small parking lot that shouldn't be there and push them up to plenty of parking at the top of the hill. Float installations and removal, we've already moved the recreational floats on October 9th. We keep the commercials in for a little longer for the working component of the waterfront. That's scheduled to be hauled November 23rd, plus or minus a day there depending on the weather. Grants, right now we Have a grant through MDEP continues to support the pump out operations at town landing with a 9D10 match. The plan is to replace the pump out in the spring of 2027, so we're in talks right now for a new pump out, which is about 21,000. We would be on the hook for about 10 of that, so DEP is a big supporter of maintaining pump out operations down there to make sure that, you know, these folks don't go out and dump it into the ocean, right? We have a temporary fix on the North Shore erosion issue damage. we've applied for various grants and working with memer and fema to see if we can bring that area back to its original state that is you know been in the works for two to three years and fema has come back around saying we may be interested in putting more money into that so we're working with amanda and the deputy fire chief who's our regional femur expert and see if we can secure some funding to bring that back to its original state float repairs a part of a grant has been made in the spring This coming spring through the submerged lands grant, replacing the hardware on the floats for half the flows for about twenty thousand dollars. We're able to get a grant for that for most of that. Some of that we're on the hook for, but these folks are about, we got these in 2018 after the big blow that if some of you recall took out our float system and our gangways, so that's needing some maintenance, so we're in good shape with some healthy grants and that's a great environment. Mooring fees we did. Let the hybrid committee know and they've tasked us to do a comparison study, will be done review the harbor committee at the April meeting of next year to see what regionally is out there and see if we're in line or we stay the same or does it need to be increased, and if that's the case something will be coming to you folks sometime next year for a rollout of 2028. If that's the case that would be three years, which is what we want to keep track of, so that's all we got. Any questions for the harbor update?
[24:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you very much, Chief Kilbride. Does anyone have any comments or questions here from the council? Yes, Councilor Morton.
[24:18] Speaker G (unidentified): Thank you, Chief. More of a comment. I'm just happy to see that the available kayak permits, the 12 that all were utilized, because I think the first year or last year that wasn't necessarily the case, that they were all handed out and provided to the community, but there were a few open slots that people actually weren't utilizing them. So I'm just happy to see that those who received the permits were actually using them as intended.
[24:40] Speaker F (unidentified): So that's good to see. They're a wonderful group of folks. We've had a couple that just said, hey, well, I'm excited to get it, but I'm not using it to the degree I'd like to surrender it. I mean, how great is that, right? So they're just a wonderful group to work with.
[24:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other questions? Maybe I've got a quick question for you, Chief Kilbride. You mentioned that the parking tickets went up from 263 to 182, which is a pretty significant increase. Was that a reflection of more people violating parking, or maybe we're just taking a little bit more aggressive approach to parking?
[25:15] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, but a couple of young ladies down there that were go-getters. [Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, fair enough.] We hope to get them back next year. Are we getting them back next year? I think we are. Okay. One of them wants to be a police officer, so we hope that we can grab her down the road. But great staff. They're wonderful young ladies. Great.
Public Comment
[25:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other last comments, questions for Chief Kilbride-Waller? Okay. Well, thank you. We look forward to having you again. All right. So with that, we'll go ahead and close out item number one on the agenda. Move on to item number two. This is an ordinance to adopt amendments for the General Assistance Ordinance, Amendacies A through H, to amend maximum levels of income and expenses for the General Assistance Program, Chapter 6, Article 6, Section 6.68, Appendices A through H of the Falmouth Town Ordinance. General assistance maximums are outlined, as I just stated earlier, and they outline overall maximums, food maximums, housing maximums, utilities, heating, fuel, personal care, and household supplies, and funeral maximums, respectively. Effectively, these levels are established as a matter of state law based on certain federal values that are made effective on the first day of October each year and therefore must be adopted by the town council annually. A public comment period has not been included with this item on the on the agenda, so I'd like to bring this back to the council if there are any comments questions regarding the ordinance to adopt these amendments. And not seeing any comments then would ask for a motion for Ordinance 42-2027. Councilor Tracy, do I have a second? Councilor Morton? All of those in favor of Ordinance 42-2027. And that is unanimous. And that closes out item number two on the agenda. Moving on to item number three, which is a public hearing and the ordinance to the temporary sign ordinance amendment. Town Council has heard concerns regarding temporary signs around town. These concerns land in one of three categories, environmental safety and aesthetic due to the increase in comments from residents in the town council added amending temporary sign ordinance to their 2026-2027 work plan. The ordinance committee presents the following amendments to the town council one is to no longer exempt the town from provisions of the ordinance number two allows public works to remove signs in violation of the ordinance. Three, imposes a fine of $25 per sign upon pickup of the signs from Public Works. Number four, signs are no longer allowed to be placed in the medians or roundabouts. And five, increases the distance between signs with similar messaging from 30 feet to 50 feet. The goal of these changes are to reduce the amount of signs around town and to ensure that signs are not left on the side of the road to deteriorate. A public comment period has been included with this item, so we'd like to extend an invitation to anyone who's attending here in person who would like to speak. And not seeing anyone, we'd then like to extend that invitation to anyone who's attending remotely, if you would raise your hand. And not seeing any hands raised, so the action then for this evening is just to schedule the ordinance for November 23rd, which will be our next council meeting. So that's really where we're at on that. Does anyone on the council have any questions or comments at this time? All right. Oh, yes, Councilman
[28:57] Speaker G (unidentified): Just for those who worked on this, I was just curious if there was discussion with Public Works on actually administering and enforcing this new law. I do know that we had previously heard that 's just an added burden of having to make sure that they're kind of looking at signs, picking them up, and now storing them for up to seven days, and just making sure that they're managing that. Was that kind of part of this conversation as part of the solution?
[29:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, Councillor Diaz, yes it was, and they recognized that it is an administrative burden to enforce this ordinance as it was even before any amendment. The way that they would describe it is they can go on a Friday, spent all day picking up signs, and then by the next week it will be tons of signs yet up again, so it was. Because the ordinance itself, in some indirect way, makes that a little bit easier in that they no longer have to go to each sign to identify whether they comply with all of the requirements in order to lift them up. They can now say that sign is on the median, so it's not allowed to be there, and so they can remove it. And they also have the, if they're busy as they may be, there's no obligation to do it, but they so they still have the option to make a judgment call and say we're just stretched, then we can't do it this week or this month, but now they also have the authority to do so, which they were also concerned that in the past it was not clear that they had the authority. So we're hoping that this will work, and if there's any tinkering that needs to be done as a result of the first season, then we'll go back and get their feedback on how it went and make it a little bit better. Great.
[30:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Counselor Diaz. Maybe other comments, questions? Yes, Counselor Tracy, I
[30:49] Speaker E (unidentified): know how we get this information to people that are running for public office, because that's a little more obvious to give them the directions. How do we, how do we push this message to, because I think, you know, to the public works conversation, those people are going to clean your heat pump or, you know, blow your leaves or, you know, do other things. How do we, and they don't have, I mean, they barely have a name and a phone number on them, so how do we get this information out to others? Was there any conversation on that? So
[31:24] Speaker B (unidentified): i guess in theory we could advertise it in our website but i can also say that my experience the way that i learned about it was because my signs went away. And so I put them up in the median, and they were removed the next day or two. And I thought, gosh, dirty politics. But then I thought, no, it's probably at Public Works, and that's where they had them. And that's where I learned that 's the places where I can put them, where I can't put them. And they have their—you know, in that particular case, they didn't charge me anything. I think they were just relieved to see them gone, but they also have that, they can, they have that judgment call in there too, where if they don't see the need to charge someone is the first offense or whatnot, but you're right, most of these vendors do not put contact information under signs, so we hope and expect that they'll be able to connect the dots the same way that I did and walk into the Public Works Department and ask for further signs. Great.
[32:30] Speaker H (unidentified): Yes. Counselor Vance. Yeah. I'll just add that, I mean, we did discuss, you know, chamber of commerce, you know, outreach, but there was not a sense that there was going to be a lot of, you know, overlap between, you know, those sort of, markets and,, you know, uptake on that, but, you know, happy to,, to chat about that more if it, if it turns out this doesn't have the effect, you know, that we're hoping for. So.
[32:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Thank you, Counselor advance. Any other last questions or comments on this? Again, that this is a scheduled ordinance that we will look at our next council meeting on the 23rd of this month. And with that, we'll go and close out item number three on the agenda, moving right along to item number four. This is a discussion for the Greater Portland Transit District, the Metro Bus, which was proposed to the fiscal year 2027 budget in accordance with the state statute 30-a mrs 3516. The procedure for preparation and adoption of the annual metro bus budget requires board adopt adoption of a preliminary budget and municipal assessment formula before October 31st and submittal to each member municipality by November 1st. The municipal office officers, i.e. the town council, have 30 days to review the budget and formula and may accept the submittal either by formal action or non-action or notify the district of a refusal to accept the submittal. If the district receives notice within 30 days the municipal officers refusal to accept the formula the district is then required to petition the main public utilities commission in December to establish the formula. A public comment period has not been included with this item so with that we'd like to open up our discussion and thank you so much for being here offering a presentation here on the Greater Metro Portland Metro so with
[34:26] Speaker I (unidentified): that hi Glenn Fenton executive director for Metro it's great to be back here in Falmouth and I have a few slides for you today. First a nice update on how things have been going at Metro over the last year, and then I'll run through our proposed 2027 fiscal year budget. First, again, just probably a review for most of you at this point, Metro formed in 1966. Falmouth joined as a formal member community in 2009. We currently serve eight communities in the greater Portland region with 14 bus routes and two microtransit zones. We have a little more than 50 buses and about 140 employees. Here in Falmouth we serve Falmouth with two primary fixed routes the route 7 which serves the route 1 corridor which operates just right now in the in the core of the route 1 area not into the neighborhoods as it did. We replace that with microtransit we'll talk about that in a second and then on the route 100 side we have the 9b B service, which serves the Hannaford Plaza there, and then connects back into Portland. The microtransit service, which was launched two years ago, MetroConnect, serves most of Falmouth now. We've been steadily expanding that zone as the service has progressed. We've been able to do that and still have relatively short wait times on the service. That service is a small van, hopefully you've seen it at this point, running around town that's largely aimed at local trips. It's also aimed at solving what we call the first mile, last mile dilemma that keeps a lot of people from using public transit, which helps them get from areas that might not be walkable out to bus stops so that they can connect into our full fixed route service. And so they pay the fare on there and they get a free transfer and are able to use any other Metro bus that they connect to. We've been busy over the last 12 months. A few different things. Most recently, we launched new service to Scarborough. We launched a new bus route to Scarborough, and we also launched our second microtransit zone. So basically taking the model that we've tried here in Falmouth with the small vans and launched the same idea in Scarborough, another town that works well for that service because some of the areas are a bit sprawling and don't necessarily have pedestrian infrastructure. So this service has been, again, we're just about a month into it, so we're still learning how successful it'll be, but it seems like it's ripe for more transit. We also launched Tap to Pay earlier this summer. That feature allowed folks to use their credit cards or a mobile wallet to pay on the bus. We think that 's going to be a really great way to get new riders on the bus. People who don't necessarily understand fare payment can get on and just pay like they would at a regular store. door. And then lastly, we had a fare increase that was approved by our board and took effect on August 1st. And I'll talk about that in a second here. The fare increase, our lease fare prior to the fare increase was $2 per person for a full fare. It went to $2.25 for the increased amount. The reduced fare, so that's for folks with disabilities, seniors, veterans, that went from $1 to $1.10. Our monthly fare cap, that's the most amount of money that anyone could pay in a given month for their fare, went from $60 to $65, again, for the full fare riders. And then for our reduced fare riders, those eligible, we didn't increase the fare cap for them. So most out-of-pocket for someone who's eligible for reduced fare remained at $30. Ridership for 20 thus far in 2026 has been largely what I would describe as flat. We are up actually in the in the most recent months. We had in January we took quite a dip in ridership. There was a lot of folks not using transit. You may recall there was a an insurgence of ice enforcement during that time period, and we saw a significant downtick in ridership during the weeks following that. But since then, we have rebounded back to above average in the months following. Not greatly above average, but the average for the year now, I think we're right about even. We might be down 1,000 or two rides, but not too much. As I mentioned, the Tap to Ride program that we launched in July is off to a good start. Again, it's still early, but we're seeing growth in that sector. As it's now taking up as much as 4% of our riders are paying by credit card or using a mobile wallet on the bus. Again, we think that's encouraging. Some of those riders are definitely shifting from other payment methods, but there's also some growth in that group of new riders we think could be tourists, but we are still hoping to see more growth in this area in particular. To speak to Falmouth's ridership performance over the last 12 months, or I should say this is a 10 month comparison from January of 25 or the first 10 months of the year. I'll just say for the last four years we've had great success here in Falmouth. You can see that when we compare back to 2023 which was before any of the service changes were made, our ridership was in that 17, 18,000 riders per or for the 10 month period. Now ridership topping 35,000 riders in Falmouth, so it's really encouraging. Similarly, the Line 7, after the overhaul of the route and the frequency improvement, we've seen ridership on that route in particular for the full length of the route jump over 300% in that time period. Microtransit service here in Falmouth, so we had a really strong summer with the MetroConnect in Falmouth. You can see ridership was up. Some of our highest levels, over 450 rides a month, which is very encouraging. We're now getting into the fall where ridership seems to be a little bit lower, but overall a good trend on MetroConnect. This map just gives you an idea of where a lot of those trips are generating from or going to. You can see, of course, a lot of them focused along the Route 1 corridor where you might expect to see them. As far as productivity of the route, we're still seeing productivity be a little bit below where we'd like it to be, trailing between one and 1.2 riders per hour. We'd really like to see that number closer to two riders per hour or more. We'll be wanting to look more closely at this and come back to the council with some recommended benchmarks if we want to continue the service because we really want to see productivity in that area. We will be doing more campaigns in Falmouth to promote the Service targeting businesses as well as the high school to make sure that there's awareness about the program. But we do want to see the productivity improve, so we'll we'll be coming back. I think Nathan, I talked about setting a future meeting where I could get into deeper the actual goals and what some of the industry standards are for success with connect with a micro transit network. With that, I'll jump into our operating budget for next year. So again, as a reminder, Metro operates on a calendar year budget. So as was laid out, our board has adopted their preliminary budget, and those assessment letters went to all the member communities at the end of October. And we're now in the review period where each municipality has an opportunity to review the budget, and should they have a protest, test, let Metro know so that a PUC process could be taken to address that. Once that period runs out on November 30th, the budget is set. Metro's final budget will be done on March 1st. That budget is all inclusive. Any changes made in that budget will not affect assessments to the community. So the amount that is in the assessment letter is essentially locked at this point. Once that final budget's approved, warrants will be sent to the communities with payment in July or August of next year. So Metro's budget for 2027, on the expense side, $23.5 million. That's about a 14% increase in expenses. As I mentioned, we have basically two new services launching in Scarborough. We also had the City of South Portland approve additional service in their community. So I'll walk you through the budget, but please keep in mind that a lot of these services are, a lot of the increases are directly related to the additional services in these other communities that don't directly impact Falmouth's assessment. All of the service in Scarborough is fully funded through an agreement with the main Turnpike Authority as well as Maine DOT and in the town. On the wage side, so wages and benefits make up about 75% of Metro's budget. So on the wage side, we're looking at about a 13% increase versus the previous year. Part of that is tied to a COLA for our union employees, as well as our non-union employees. Our collective bargaining agreement will be expiring at the end of June. So we'll be going back to the bargaining table, and we're hoping to be able to maintain a reasonable increase there, although there'll be a lot of pressure as we, as we begin to bargain in today's environment, in the,, in addition to the COLA increase. The increase in staffing is driving a large part of this, and again, that staffing is largely related to the service expansions that are programmed in Scarborough. On the benefits side, we're seeing, I think our rate now with Maine Health Trust was a 9% increase just on the health trust side. And then the additional increase is related again to growth in staffing. So 14% increase in health insurance. And then the other benefits are going up as well, the HRA, workers' comp. Those are really driven more by wages. For non-personnel expenses, fuel is, both of our fuels are really significant increases this coming budget. Metro is coming off of a very fortuitous diesel contract. We had a contract that's just ending or just ended in October that was $2.37 a gallon for diesel. I think we all know you can't really find diesel for $2.37 anymore. We budgeted $4 a gallon for next year. Even that, I think we were pretty aggressive with, but we're hoping that as we get into the end of the year here, we can get a downturn and lock in at a rate that's at least $4 or possibly lower. Similarly, our natural gas price, we saw about a 65% increase on our natural gas fuel. We operate 10 buses that are natural gas powered. So that also had a significant increase in our budget, about $180,000. And then gas, greases and fluids, all those things that are also, so derivatives of oil, we saw significant increases as well. And then parts largely as an inflationary increase of about 6%. So, again, on our non-personnel expenses, I think our other lines were relatively on par with what we've seen previously. We were able to reduce our capital reserves slightly, as well as some of our miscellaneous expenses. Is, but utilities, of course, up, as well as supplies and equipment. So on the revenue side of things, again, revenue up 11%, almost mostly based on funding for additional service, new service. So that's not a straight increase from federal formula funding. Our actual increase in federal formula funding is closer to 2%, which is typical for what we see in increases in federal formula funding. So that funding, of course, comes to the pax region and then is divided up among all the transit providers. So really not a lot of growth in that area. The what the amounts that you see, that additional 11 percent, is largely one-time funding that we receive as a offset to help for launching new services like the service in scarborough on the municipal assessments. I'll get into this that in just a second. Passenger fares, 8.4%. Again, that's tied to the fare increase that we had earlier this year. So we did see some growth there, although the net increase there is really only about $275,000. And then on state funding, it was essentially flat, no increases in state funding. So that, of course, makes it hard to keep up with rising expenses. And then on miscellaneous revenue, which is largely the on-bus advertising, We also saw a decrease related to our renewed contract with our advertiser. So on the municipal portion of the assessment, so overall for all communities, about 18% increase in municipal assessments. As a percentage of Metro's budget, that's about 32% of our budget on municipal assessment. You can see that 's creeping up over 30%. Over the last three or four years, we've been able to hold it right to that 30% mark. But really in this year, without any other revenue sources to backfill the rising expense, to cover the rising expenses, we're seeing more increase in municipal assessment than in previous years. So on the actual assessment for Falmouth, it's about $420,000 and about a 30% increase. As you hopefully remember from last year when I was here, ARPA funding for Falmouth services was phasing out last year. So in this year, I should say 2026, there was a partial credit of some ARPA funding in there, and also our board of directors voted to assign about $300,000 in carry forward funding to help offset some of that ARPA increase on the communities that have ARPA service, and that's not all of the communities. Falmouth had the largest amount of ARPA service improvements out of any of the Metro communities. So historically...
[49:55] Speaker J (unidentified): So that was for the microtransit?
[49:57] Speaker I (unidentified): And the improved frequency on Line 7. So both of those were ARPA-funded service improvements. Historically, the increase in assessment has been many times below 5%, and actually in 2025, the assessment for Falmouth and several metro communities went down. But again, these most recent two years here of high increases are related to the ARPA service improvements phasing out and the one-time funding that has been associated with them going away as well. well. So just for reference, last in Metro's 2026 budget, there was about $140,000 in one-time funding or ARPA funding that was directly supporting service. So that's not carrying forward into 2027. As I said, it's one-time funding. So this increase of the net increase for Falmouth is about 98,000 in the assessment. So what's happening is as that funding is no longer included as the one time the overall funding Metro receives, so that state and federal, Falmouth is drawing more of that because of the fact that you have more service in the formula. And then the last thing I just wanted to mention was the amount of the total assessment that would be eligible for TIF funding and that's about two hundred and five thousand dollars that's about one hundred and thirty three thousand dollar increase from last year and again that's directly related to the fact that this is new service which makes it TIF funding eligible last year a large part of it was being funded through ARPA funding this going into 27 it won't be funded so that makes that funding eligible for you to use your TIF I'm in the actual amount for the general fund went down because of the amount of the proportion of the service that is again not being funded as part of arpa funding sorry if i went through that a little bit quickly i'm happy to go back to these slides glenn thank you so much i really appreciate
[52:20] Speaker A (unidentified): that i would like to bring us back to the council if anyone has any questions or thoughts comments
[52:24] Speaker J (unidentified): yes counselor mahoney just on that last slide and this might be you glenn or it might be you Nathan so the total assessment is four hundred and twenty thousand but of that four hundred twenty two hundred and five can be covered by TIF that's correct
[52:45] Speaker K (unidentified): When we created the village center TIF district, the intent was to pay for this increase when the opera money ran out. So this is happening according to schedule. As a matter of fact, Glenn found more TIF-eligible money than I had anticipated, so the TIF will be covering all of it, provided the council approves the budget in that way. And then the operating fund actually is going to see a slight decrease because we're relying on more on the TIF than I thought we were going to be eligible for.
[53:18] Speaker J (unidentified): are okay so just rough math about 215 000 will be on the we'll hit the operating budget and 205 is tiff yeah thank you anyone
[53:34] Speaker A (unidentified): else have any comments or questions yes counselor sharp
[53:38] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you for being here. Thinking about slide, well, I guess 23, 24, I'm just trying to kind of understand the puts and takes in here with the ARPA money going away, which obviously kind of causes the assessment to bounce all over the place. I just wonder, we don't have to do this now, but it would be helpful to see kind of what the, and I'm looking now at, I think it's 24, the annual assessment change, kind of what that would look like if you could strip out the impact of the sort of temporary funding. Because clearly there's sort of an underlying increase in the cost of service and the fact that we have more service in Falmouth, but it does feel like this one-time funding is kind of distorting this in a way that makes it hard for us to kind of talk to residents about what's going on underneath.
[54:32] Speaker I (unidentified): Sorry if I don't have that, but I believe that on the, I think it's about 4% is what our net increase would be without all of the other things that are going on.
[54:47] Speaker D (unidentified): So if that, I mean, I don't know, again, we don't have to do it now, but if that's information that you can share back with us, because I think that story is helpful. Absolutely. Because, again, we did have that. I mean, we were, I guess, I'm sure glad to get the money, but taking it away hurts, right? And then, may I follow up? Yes, go ahead. On the micro, transit, you talked about benchmarks and just sort of how we think about, hey, is this actually, is this working or not? It sounds like you'll come back and talk to us about that, but I think it is, I'd be curious, how do you feel so far? Presumably kind
[55:22] Speaker I (unidentified): of tepid on how it's, how it's gone. I think, yeah, we'd like to see it closer to two riders an hour. I think that, but you know, this council will, have, when I come back, you'll, You'll have to have a value discussion, right? It can't all be numbers about the actual folks who are using it. And I think that we have some really devoted people who are relying on it in the town. So I don't want to take anything away from that. But from a strictly numbers perspective, we'd really like to see it above two riders per hour. And not to get too far down the road on this, but if we're not there, it doesn't mean that the service necessarily needs to go away. It might just need to be right-sized to really focus on the parts of the day that are most productive so that you're getting the most bang for your buck, so to speak.
[56:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, Councilor Morton.
[56:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Great. Thank you, Glenn, for being here this evening. And similar to Councilor Sharpe, I was curious about the MetroConnect. So I think in concept I'm very excited about it, and I think it has a lot of opportunity. But I do continue to see it around town, but I do continue to see it either empty deer occasionally with one rider and I think just kind of seeing how things are laid out here is helpful and so I do think it is important that at some point we have that value discussion and I would love to and maybe it isn't here but to see a further breakdown of you know the use of route seven versus the micro connect especially knowing that's kind of how the town is assessed by how much service we're getting, how much of that is in Route 7, which seems to be, I think, bringing people in to work in Falmouth and also getting people into Portland. And so I see a lot of opportunity there. But I think looking at the microtransit and how it is truly being used and by the town would be important. And just to hear kind of the strategy of getting it to two or beyond would be helpful so that we can appropriately assess the value. Again, I'm very proud and happy that we've tried to test it here, but I'm starting to question just the fiscal value that we're receiving in return from it. And then the one other question I had, I was curious if Route 7 is going to at all connect in with the Roo Institute once that is fully developed.
[57:51] Speaker I (unidentified): That's a really good question. And actually, we're meeting with Rue tomorrow. To be determined, I guess, if there's interest here in Falmouth or not, we'd be interested to hear that. When we get to that point, and that's early 28 type of service changes when I think they're opening, and we're planning on that. So we'll be doing public involvement and getting input from our riders. And so if we hear from folks in Falmouth that they either do or don't want it, we'll take that into consideration. It had originally been intended to be served by an extension of our Route 5. Initial look at that looks like it might be more efficient to serve it with the 7. It might be a way for us to improve frequency on the 7. And I think when we talked about service improvements in Falmouth originally, we wanted to be at 30 minutes, and we're not quite there. So it could be a way for us to get there. And what could be, again, just speaking very hypothetically, you know, if things maybe didn't merit continuation or as much service on the microtransit side, you could invest that on better frequency on the 7. I can tell you right now that when you compare the two, you're going to see the 7 is way more efficient for what you're spending for the service, even though it costs about 40% more to operate a fixed-route bus versus a van, it's still way more efficient. But that's also the nature of transit, and density and fixed-route transit works better in the denser core areas, which is exactly where you have it.
[59:32] Speaker G (unidentified): Great. Thank you. You. May I have one more question? Just for clarity, because I have heard from a couple individuals who are interested in the micro connect that initially, I think when it was launched, it would pick you up based on where your location was in door to door delivery. And it sounds like that's not necessarily the case. I know one individual was telling me that they were interested. They went to essentially schedule it and they were going to have to walk eight to ten minutes to catch the micro connect and so at that point they thought well I'll just walk so I was just curious what the expectation should be for our residents no it
[1:00:08] Speaker I (unidentified): Shouldn't be that long a walk. It's, it isn't door to door, but it's, you know, it should be at the end of your street or the nearest intersection or corner. It's not an eight to ten minute walk, it should be very quick. So if that, if you hear that again, please refer them to us and we can add these, the locations, the pickup locations we call virtual bus stops, we can add those on the fly, especially if someone's interested. Okay, we'll put, you know, we'll put it very close to their house. We've, we've done that with a bunch of folks
[1:00:34] Speaker G (unidentified): already. Okay, perfect, thank you very much, I appreciate it.
[1:00:38] Speaker H (unidentified): great any other yes counselor Vance thank you very much I just wanted to say thank you for getting to tap as someone who does not like using the UMO derigo app but rides 9b occasionally and I'm pleased to say you're now more advanced than Redmond in Washington where I travel frequently and I still have to use an app to go on their light rail and buses which seems insane to me the increases from the service rollouts you noted for Scarborough and things like that you mentioned that those were all going to be essentially paid for by, you know, sir assessments. Are those assessments one time at some, you know, three years in the future? Do those become part of the general operating budget that's diffused across all the communities? Right, so we have, we have
[1:01:23] Speaker I (unidentified): five years of pilot funding from the main turnpike authority for the service in scarborough we have about two and a half three years for main dot and then we have another two or three years of what was essentially discretionary federal funding so all of those are funding it through the pilot phase our plan is to ask the scarborough the town to join as a member community in 2029 In 28, we'll ask them to join as a member community in 2029. At that point, they'll be assessed just in the same way that all the communities are assessed. So this is how much service you have, how big a piece of the pie is it, how many people are riding in your town, and then the remainder is yours. So at that point, they'll be just another member community. I don't see it having really an impact on the other member communities. If anything, they may draw a little more federal funding because they won't have as much startup funding, but they'll be paying a much larger assessment than their introductory assessment that they're paying now.
[1:02:31] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, thank you. So basically marginal impact to other communities. Okay, that's really helpful. I'm not going to do one more. Yeah, I think kind of echoing I think the comment that Councilor Sharp made, it can be difficult for someone who's new to these budget figures to try to draw like-to-like, you know, given the changes with the Scarborough funding and things like that. So if there's some way to normalize those to the community you're presenting to in some way that would be really helpful, you know, going forward. And similarly around, you know, if for instance like staff increases for Scarborough rollout, you know, are in absolute dollars, if there's some way to normalize those to like average salary or something like that, it gives us a better sense of where like the cost allocations are going. Yeah, absolutely. I can get that information. Thank you very much.
[1:03:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank You councillor Vance any other last comments or questions maybe one last question for you glenn and again echoing what's already been said thank you for being here this evening offering this presentation in terms of the metro bus itself obviously it's part of for here it's route seven which is part of the larger regional effort but then the actual connect buses those only operate within the town of falmouth is that correct they do
[1:03:43] Speaker I (unidentified): not regionalize to anything beyond this municipality, only in the zone. Okay, just
[1:03:49] Speaker A (unidentified): wanted that one quick clarifying question. Okay, any other last questions? Okay, with that, thank you so much for being here. I really appreciate the time and attention to this. There is no anticipated action this evening from the council on this item, so not having anything
[1:04:07] Speaker H (unidentified): else we're going to go ahead and oh yes counselor vance this is my naivete but like what is the future like structure of the council response is it all or none is it like a partial approval how does it work kind of from a governance
[1:04:24] Speaker K (unidentified): perspective? So this is a typical how you normally budget things. So they're telling you what they're going to assess you that you're man mandated to pay. If you want to oppose that, you would have to take formal action in this month. No action is also okay, and that would mean approval. We have never taken any action, either approval or denial. In the history of Metro, I don't believe any community has ever opposed to it. I don't think the PUC has ever had a case on this.
[1:05:00] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I've been with Metro for 13 years, and in my 13 years, no one's ever opposed. And it was interesting because I was at Yarmouth Council last week, and they asked, well, what happens if we opposed, what happens with the PUC? And I said, I don't know, it's never, I guess we call the PUC and say, hey, someone opposed. I don't really know what that, in the statute, that's what it says, as was read at the beginning of my segment, that they, there's a PUC process, but we don't really know what it looks like. All right, well, I don't, we don't want to find out.
[1:05:33] Speaker H (unidentified): Either, I don't, yeah, I don't know, it's just for novelty. We should, thank you. Great.
[1:05:40] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, thank you very much, and with that we will go ahead and close out then item number four, moving on to item number five on the agenda. This is an order in order to authorize the town manager to enter into a multi-party real estate agreement relating to the proposed relocation of the Underwood Pump Station. As a part of the West Wastewater Treatment Department's capital plan, the Underwood Pump Station is scheduled for replacement. The Underwood Pump Station was originally installed in 1970 and is located at the bottom of Glen Road. The Department's Climate Resilience Plan noted that the Underwood Pump Station is located within the floodplain as well as subject to climate hazards such as sea level rise and storm surges. There, the pump station will be relocated to adjacent land currently owned by the Seaview Homeowners Association. During the course of the last year, the Wastewater Department has been meeting with residents impacted by the proposed project, including the Seaview Homeowners Association and other neighbors. Attached to this item on the agenda represents a negotiated multi-party agreement that summarizes the various real estate transactions that will be needed to complete this project. A public comment has been included with this item, but we also have time for some, maybe even before we start that, opportunity for presentations, a chance to talk. We have both Dan Marks from the Wastewater Department, and also we have Bob Klein, who's representing the Seaview Homeowners Association as well. So maybe we'll go ahead and start. If Dan, if you would like to step forward and offer some kind of overview and any
[1:07:29] Speaker I (unidentified): Insights you might have. Great, yeah, Dan Marks, Wastewater Superintendent. Thank you, counselors. Good evening. Yeah, you summed it up well. Just to provide a little bit more context, the Underwood pump station upgrade is part of our capital plan, currently under design. We have upgrades to four pump stations, including Underwood, and construction of a new pump station on Route 1, and I don't know exactly, around 10,000 feet of pipe that's going to be going in the ground over the next two years. So it's part of a much larger project. The Underwood neighborhood itself, this pump station will be the most impactful to the residents, and so we've been spending more time there in terms of understanding what it's going to look like, how it's going to affect the neighborhood. The other pump stations, we tend to be out of sight, out of mind. In the wastewater world, that's how people like us. So this one, we've spent a little more time there because it will impact the residents. We're in the neighborhood, we're part of the neighborhood, we want to be good residents or good neighbors. So what we've been doing over the last year, having neighborhoods, starting with neighborhood meetings going back more than a year, say, hey, we're coming, we have to do this thing. A lot of conversations have been had. This agreement that's in front of you represents, I think, our best effort to say this is the path that we want to go, this is how we want to be good neighbors, describing all of that with a little bit of legal veneer on all of it to make sure that we have the right title and interest that we need to go and get the funding that we need to do the project. So that's the, that's the crux of it, I guess. But yeah, I think this, you know, it's, I think it's, it's, it's an approach that's, I guess, different than another option to the town would be an eminent domain taking for an infrastructure project like that. It's a possibility to go that route. We've decided that we want to try to work with the neighborhood and see how, see where our commonalities can align, and if we can have this be a win-win. So that's been our approach, and I'll mention, I'll, I'm happy to take any questions. There's, there's quite a bit here. There's a lot of sort of moving pieces that need to happen in a sequential timeline for this project to go forward. As you can imagine with wastewater infrastructure, we need to keep the pumps on all the time, so we need to build the new thing before we can do away with the old thing. And so, you know, the timing of the real estate transactions and when we have right to do what we need to do is all sort of laid out in here. I'll also mention we have Lisa Witt from Drummond & Woodson, who's the real estate attorney who's been helping us. She's online and available if you have legal questions that go over my head.
[1:10:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Thank you, Dan. I appreciate providing that oversight. And we'd just like to extend an invitation to Lisa, since you are here. Is there anything in addition, just from a legal perspective, you'd like to add to Dan Mark's comments this evening? I think you're muted at the moment. Oh, here we go.
[1:10:27] Speaker L (unidentified): Here we go. Good evening,
[1:10:34] Speaker M (unidentified): everyone. I am Lisa Witt with Drummond Woodson, the town's legal counsel on this project. I don't think there's anything in particular that needs to be added other than, from my perspective, what Dan was referencing as far as all the moving pieces is primarily easements given to the town and fee acquisition composition of the new pump station parcel and then conveyance of the existing pump station parcel. But I'm happy to answer any questions about the specifics of any of it. It's a little complicated.
[1:11:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Since we have Lisa on right at the moment, does anyone have any particular legal questions like to ask her while she's here? All right. Lisa, thank you so much for making the time this evening and offering some additional insight thank you Dan I appreciate it and we may circle back with you here in a moment but we also have Bob Klein here who's representing the Seaview homeowners Association so Bob if you like to have an interest and go to the podium and offering some insight as well Bob
[1:11:50] Speaker L (unidentified): Klein Seaside Way here as the treasurer of the Seaview homeowners association I want to commend Dan in the town for the approach they've taken. I advocated early on, and Dan did as well, that a collaborative approach would probably produce the best outcome. I mean, nothing's going to be perfect from every perspective, and you shouldn't expect that here. But with Lisa's support and backstopping from Nathan, I think we've presented what is a reasonable approach. There's more things to be done. The provision and the framework that you see allows for that. There's certainly this is a very preliminary stage of engineering and layout. I feel good about the level of communication we've established. And keep in mind the Seaview Homeowners Association is the only property that's being taken or needs to be apprehended. All the other situations involving homeowners are really connectivity issues where previously there was a gravity And now it's going to be an individual single pump station, private pump station. So those adjustments have been made. They're all in the package. And the groundwork has been laid. So again, as everyone else has said, I'll be glad to respond to any questions if there are concerns that any counselor has, I would like to very much be heard before you make a change in terms of what we work to present. MR.
[1:13:17] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. All right, so with that, I would like to bring it back to the council. There is action anticipated this evening, and before that, I'd like to see if anyone has, since we have Dan, we've got Lisa, and we've got Bob here this evening, does anyone have any additional comments, questions, as we kind of work toward a decision here this evening?
[1:13:43] Speaker J (unidentified): Yes, Councilor Mahoney. So it's a comment, really, that as you stated when you laid this out, this action is being taken as a result of climate hazards such as sea level rise and storm surges. And I would just note that the state is embarking on a year-long study of costs associated with climate hazards such as sea level rise and storm surges and extreme weather events on the impact on state and municipal infrastructure. And this is a perfect example of that type of cost that's gonna be incurred across our town and across the state as a whole. Ultimately, the goal is to establish a fund created through assessments on fossil fuel companies who are at the heart of causing climate change to fund those as opposed to Falmouth taxpayers who will be funding this work as opposed to taxpayers across the state. So I just wanted to note that. I know there was a presentation made earlier in the year about that and I hope that moves forward because this is not a cost that should be borne solely by the taxpayers of Maine.
[1:15:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Thank you for that, Councilor Mahoney. Does anyone else have any comments or questions at this time? Maybe a very specific and technical question, probably for you, Dan. I was just curious, you mentioned that there's a temporary construction easement. Do you have a sense of how long that would be going on for?
[1:15:32] Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, I don't want to go on record saying that. that. I can give you my best guess. I mean, I would say three to four months, but six would be the conservative. The sequence of operations is an important part of a final design, as Bob mentioned. We're sort of trying to find a happy medium between having enough information to make a meaningful agreement, but allowing the design to proceed at the same time. We don't have all the details and all the answers, but we will be putting in to the construction and bidding specifications, you know, the important pieces of sequencing to the neighborhood and the residents. You know, there are a lot of residents down there. We're going to need to maintain access for emergency vehicles, turn around during the construction. It's a tight neighborhood. It's going to be complicated to keep a lane of traffic open while we're digging up these roads. These are also private roads, as Lisa mentioned and Bob mentioned, too. The easements across some of these private ways to install new public sewer. So there's going to be a lot of coordination and sequencing that needs to be considered. We try to leave a lot of that means and methods to a contractor while putting up the guardrail saying, this is what we need to see, and you go about and do that. I'm saying all that to say that it will affect the timeline. It's not just like dig 1,000 feet of pipe as quickly as you possibly can. It's going to be how do you work around the neighbors and work around the homes and don't just tear it up as much as you know they're going
[1:17:01] Speaker A (unidentified): to be moving slower yep fair enough appreciate it and thank you counselor mahoney for offering kind of the larger perspective of these issues because they are part of a much larger framework than even just specific this project alone but i also just going back to the project really like to thank everyone for really a collaborative process that's gone on between the town and the neighborhood bringing this to bear. So thank you everyone for that and your diligence in this. With that, I'd like to just ask you any last comments or questions from the council before we move forward? Okay, then not seeing any last comments, would then like to ask for a motion for order 43-2027. Okay, Councilor Vance, do I have a second? Second. Councilor Sharp. So all of those in favor of order 43-2027? And that is unanimous. And that will also close out item number five on the agenda this evening. We're now going to move on to item number six. This is a discussion about traffic enforcement with special attention to speeding. Traffic enforcement, especially speeding, is a frequent concern raised by Falmouth residents. Police Chief John Kilbride will describe his experience with these concerns and the police department's intention to traffic enforcement. Chief Kilbride will offer a brief presentation, including the attached PowerPoint presentation, which is up on the screen, and we'll jump right in. Thank you very much, Chief Kilbride, for offering this evening.
[1:18:37] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, good evening, John Kilbride, police chief. Thanks for having me. When Nathan asked me about this, I've been 18, 19 years in a leadership role, and I've never been asked to talk about traffic enforcement, and it is a complex item that we do out here, and I'm very excited to be here and talk about it. So we're just going to dig right into the slides, and I'll just kind of walk through if I'm working this right. Do I press the arrow? Oh, let's try that one. Okay. So before we get right into the traffic, let's talk about what we're working with. the overall staffing for the Falmouth Police Department is 22 budgeted personnel out of that three serve in the command capacity myself the deputy chief who's here this evening and the lieutenant we have two assigned to the schools ten months of the year when they're not in the schools they're back in patrol operations we have harbor officers to assigned to the harbor six or seven months out of the year these are all sworn police officers we have two assigned to the detective bureau one traffic officer, animal control. We do not have that is tasked out to an officer that first typing takes on those special skill sets, can do follow-up on animal control, so we can hit the state guidelines, state mandates on animal control. We all handle animal control. If I leave here tonight and there's a loose dog, I'm gonna take care of the dog and take it to a shelter, but that officer follows up when he has to. We currently have two open positions. So with that, we have in the patrol division at any given time to handle calls to service and traffic enforcement, 10 to 12 officers, 24-7. Work volume for the police department, we're projected to probably land around 15,400 calls for service. Out of that, probably 6,000 of those calls for service are self-initiated calls, property checks, follow-up investigations. So about 9,000 or 10,000 of those actually are face-to-face with the public answering their complaint. And so just to give you an idea on that, crash investigations, we investigate between usually averages about 280 to 310 crashes a year in the community and arrest and criminal charges around 260. And that's usually averages about the same there. So those are that's a pretty good workload. The arrest and criminal charges are very time-consuming. Type of calls that we handle, pretty self-explanatory right there. Domestic disturbance, mental health, unhoused management, crimes in progress, retail crime. We have a big two retail districts. Property checks keep the peace. Well-being checks has really spiked up in senior crimes. Thus, our two detectives is a huge target, not only for Falmouth, but for Maine. Traffic enforcement is what we call secondary enforcement. So when you're not doing all those other things, we ask you, we require the officers to go out and start working traffic enforcement. And the primary focus on traffic enforcement is to reduce the number of crashes, fatalities on our roadways, to get the impaired drivers off, to get those that are not licensed to drive, those that are suspended to drive, those that are driving aggressively, to get them off the roadway. Today, we're trending about 4,300 traffic stops in Falmouth. With our current staffing in 2025, we were about that right about now, 2024. We're probably going to land around close to 5,000. I've seen it as low as 3,000 and as high as 5,300, 5,500 traffic stops. And, again, it's all depending on staffing. I've been in the leadership capacity, or chief anyways, for eight or nine years, and I think I've been full staff for six months. So everything is dependent on that. We cover 84 miles of roadway in Falmouth, major connector roads, Roots, Route 1, Route 88, Middle Road, Turnpike, Spur, Interstate, Gray Road, and Blackstrap Road. Major interchanges through Falmouth. If you're going to travel through Maine, you're coming through Falmouth. We have thousands and thousands of cars a day interacting in our community, in our roadways. We have a lot of connector roads, side roads that we'll talk about. So we're dealing with an absorbent amount of traffic and volume. And, you know, the buildup and growth not only inside the community and on the outside of our community is impactful, right? If you're having big housing development in Wyndham and Cumberland and anything west or north, they got to play through Falmouth. They want to get to the interstate, the Turnpike system, and a lot of our resources down in the Route 1 corridor. Are. Our traffic division is one officer assigned. I'm very proud of what we do in this particular component than what we've done in years past. We really haven't done anything in years past. The officer and the department, we have four speed measure boards. You've seen them out in the community. We started these boards back in 2011 with one. We've continued with three more. We have one covert speed volume classification measuring units. It's about the size of a loaf for bread. We were getting complaints from the public of saying, yeah, Chief, we really appreciate putting the speed board out there. But when people see it, they slow down. And that's the design from it, right? 90% of the public just needs a reminder that they're speeding with these electronic signs. I've caught myself doing it too, right? Oh, wow, okay, I'm going to slow down. The other 10% are just going to go until they get a ticket, several tickets, and they're going to continue to go but so we went out and get this covert box I convinced the manager it was you know three or four thousand at the time we were paying for traffic studies anywhere between three and five thousand for a company come out and give us traffic studies on volume classification of vehicles trucks motorcycles cars we can do that now internally for nothing the manager can send me an email Saying hey can we get some traffic numbers over on ledger we drive, Layton Road. We put the box up for a week. We attach it to our telephone pole. You don't even know it. And we can capture real-time data for that road and classification. We'll show you what that looks like. Our traffic officer, what they do is they work with the complainant. We don't get a lot of complaints, but we do get complaints. We get multiple complaints from generally the same person or depending on which particular areas, but we assign that up to a traffic officer. If we get an email, we get a complaint, they're gonna knock on your door, they're gonna get the data for you in front of your house, they're gonna show you the data, they're gonna share you this, should the data with you, they're gonna focus on any enforcement on what that data has identified, the data identifies. We'll show you a little later in here in a couple of slides, what the speeds are, what the 85 percentile speeds are, when they're speeding the most. And then we can dedicate traffic enforcement during that time. It's the best use of time management that we have. And so we really, I take great pride in working with the members of the community that, yeah, you can send me an email that they're speeding. Yes, you can call me, but we're going to follow up with you and you're probably going to have someone knocking on your door and sharing the data with you, because it's important to differentiate between volume and speed, right? You know, we'll get complaints to doing a hundred miles an hour, okay? That's, they get emotionally charged up and I get that, but that's generally not the case and we're driven by data. I am driven by data. I'll cut through the emotion. I'll listen to your emotion, but I'm driven by data. What's, does the data say? So this box is, has been very helpful for us. The speed signs, more visual cue, it does collect the data. We pay fifty seven hundred dollars a year out of the operating budget to get all this data from the speed signs in this box, so we're going to use it and we'll show you what that looks like. The other component that we have is grant enforcement details through the Bureau of Highway Safety. Bureau of Highway Safety will offer funding for seatbelt enforcement, speed enforcement, OUI enforcement. We have to match it with the cruiser, the gas. But we haven't posted these details in at least five or six years because we don't have the staffing to support it. We're trying to fill overtime shifts in our core assignment, which is what we saw in the first or second slide. So one of the big struggles we're having is that when we're down two people right now and we're battling staff shortages, the traffic officer position gets collapsed. That's the first position that gets collapsed in patrol. That officer now is not just doing traffic. They're answering calls. They're working late shift. shift. They can't do this task right here. When they can do it, we're real successful at it in managing that piece. But staffing, as you well know, is challenging in law enforcement across the board in all sectors, and it remains challenging for law enforcement. So if we can get our staffing up and get the traffic officer dedicated to what they can do, these are the things that they do, and they're very successful at it. And we can get back into the grants which support that. I should tell you that none of the fun, this is all 100 funded by the taxpayers of Falmouth, radar units, gas, fuel, everything for traffic enforcement is funded by the taxpayers. All the revenue from tickets go back to the state. There's there's no motivational factor except the piece that we're trying to cut fatalities. We're trying to make the road safe for all the users, that is our shared motivation in what we do. I've got some stats here. This is eCitation came on board, geez, about five years ago. And it was just that. It's an electronic ticket that the officers have in their cars with their laptops that they can print from a printer. It saves a lot of the handwriting piece of it. It's faster and streamlined. And so we just came on board. A lot of the agencies were on board well before we were. The state came down. The legislators came down with mandated demographics on predeterminations for stops, pre and post. And the reporting mechanism for a traffic stop was just insane. saying. So e-tickets is able to do all that electronically, GPS the stops, things along those lines. Officers have to enter in a lot of data into the e-tickets. And I was just hesitant on coming online sooner than later because I didn't want to pay for it. It costs a lot of money and I felt the state should pay for it if they wanted us to have it. The deputy chief was able to find us $8,000 through the Bureau of Highway Safety for the printers. And we were able to get online a year and a half ago. So this is data pulled from last week from e-tickets on giving you kind of a comparison regionally and locally. And I ask you not to be judgmental of other agencies. There's just a lot of stuff going on. Every agency is different. The city of Portland is different than Falmouth is different than Yarmouth. We're all different. We're all having, we're all dressing different things in our community. And so but this gives you a snapshot that as of last week when this data was pulled, we're number two in Cumberland County and stops, 4,315 out of that, 952 citations and 584 of it was speed. So speed is obviously the number issue in Falmouth and probably looking at that across Cumberland County. That tells me that we're active. We're doing pretty good. Our traffic officer is active right now. He stops a lot of cars. And I do not want, as chief, ticky-tack violations in how we enforce it. I take great, I've been here for almost 30 years, and I take great pride that we are fair in our traffic stops. I say that if I start seeing officers writing speeding tickets for five over the speed limit, that's not where I like to go with that. I take issuing tickets serious. They're expensive. They can be detrimental to people's well-being, and it's a grocery bill. It's rent. So I ask my officers, I don't dictate to them that you're going to go out and have a quota, but you're going to go out and do your job. You're going to go out and stop cars. You're going to let the people see the blue lights. You're going to look for impaired drivers. And if it's warranted for a citation, then you give a citation. And so we periodically review that and how they do business. But that's my policy is that we're not out there ticky-tacking. We do get complaints. And we want a safe community. Go out and do your job. So I'm pretty pleased where we stand. We're number two in Cumberland County with 10 or 12 officers out there enforcing the traffic violations. Portland obviously much bigger, 158 staff, but I ask you not to compare us to other agencies because it's just different. It just is on how we do things. Portland's addressing their high incitations right now. They're addressing their own issues as we all know. We can see you're playing out. They go out and do Enforcement details with probably several officers and everyone gets a ticket, right? Their issues are different than our issues. I know that because I see it all the time because I live in there. So I just ask you to do that, but I am pleased where we land in what we have with what we're working with on and what the officers are doing out there. These, this was Nathan asked me to put some comps together on this is a snapshot probably various speed surveys that we've taken from that stat tracker or that sign board. The data is there, we can get real-time data if we want. I can, it's on Layton Road right now. We've had a complaint from a citizen that is a wonderful complaint, very detail-oriented, on some crashes up there. She's asked for crash data. She's asked for us to look at Layton Road like we look at Johnson Road or Route 88. She's asked for a speed study, and we're able to answer all those needs within an hour. We're able to get the box up there. We're able to get back to her in a week's worth of data. And then we're able to address it with directed enforcement based on what's being identified for the times and dates of the speed. In this particular classification, we looked at some of the complaint roads, Johnson Road, Depot Road, Ledgewood Drive, Brook Road. We look at, obviously, your posted speed, the average speed that the box is reporting back. We usually run it at week intervals for one week. week, the daily volume, the 50 percentile, and the 85 percentile on the speeds going down that road. And then the report will, I mean, that's a summary report that, you know, we put together on Excel. But our report can identify times and dates and, you know, when's the best time to have a car up there. Is it Sunday afternoon or is it Saturday morning or things along those lines? So that gives you a snapshot on those particular roads. But it's, you know, it's like every road, right? It's Blackstrap, it's Gray Road. We're, you know, we get, you know, on one side, we're getting, hey, you're not, can you do more traffic? And we actually have at least one or two folks calling saying we're stopping too much cars, stopping too many cars that, you know, every time I leave my house on Blackstrip Road, you have a car pulled over. You guys are entrapping us. You're setting events up at the school so you can entrap people going to the school. So I was real. I was actually I was kind of pleased to get that. I've never got someone complaining that we stopped too many cars. So it took me 30 years to get to that point, but we got there. So that kind of gives you a snapshot of those particular roads that are constant. Lunt Road is a heavy volume cut-through road. Johnson Road is. These are not big surprise to the people in this room. Ledgewood Depot. repo. Falmouth is managing a lot of volume and a lot of traffic. And you can just look at the layout. It feeds Portland, feeds Cumberland, is feeding a lot of these outlying areas where it's just constantly building up. I can't control the volume, but I think we've got a good plan in how we address speed, especially when we're running in all cylinders. So this is a snapshot of the traffic analysis report. The one to the left is what we get from that stat tracker box, the little bread box that's attached to a telephone pole. It's on Layton Road right now. This gives us volumes, days, percentile speeds, percentage of violators on, you know, what's a good day to run traffic up there. If our traffic officer sees Saturdays and Sundays, he'll change his schedule to work Saturdays and Sundays and address traffic up there. What you will find is volume, heavy volume dictates slower speeds because all it takes is one person to do 30 in a 30 or 35 in a 30 and everyone else is doing the same. What you see the big speeds are is weekends when it opens up, the roads open up, the evenings open up, the lights open up. And then you get your class counts down below there, small class, motorcycles, medium cars, large class trucks. So we get a lot of volume complaints, truck complaints. You know, a lot of that's kicked in after COVID or during COVID when everything was being delivered home and still is now, right? So UPS trucks and FedEx trucks and things along those lines. So, you know, what we do is we, these are the reports that we get. These are the reports that the residents will get. They're looking at the same information we're looking at, right? We're operating from the same sheet. You know, we can't make everyone whole. You could give me 10 more traffic officers and we're still going to have speed complaints. That's just how it is, right? So we can't make everyone whole on that. But the vehicle class is interesting. We generally, I've been doing this for a while, and you can tell why I'm standing in front of you. I get into this traffic because it's such a big component of what we do that, you know, an average for a road is 2, 5, 3 percent trucks. When you start seeing 4 percent trucks and 5 percent trucks, that's heavy. That's a lot of trucks. And I agree with him. That's a lot of trucks. But there's very little we can do with a lot of trucks. You know, if the trucks are speeding, we can. If there are loads uncovered, we can. But it is frustrating for a lot of people. I thought I had, I wanted to go back to this slide. I missed this on the traffic stops and the dates. The OUI arrest in 2025 and the operating complaints, that has been a really big time suck for us in managing impaired drivers. We talked about this earlier in the finance meeting about the average OUI is taxing our officers three to five hours and managing that. And when I started, it was between 10 at night and 2 in the morning when the OUIs were moving around. It's all day long. It's all day long that they're moving around. And so we can get bogged down and lose staff real fast when it comes to OUIs. Fifty-seven OUIs last year was absolutely amazing. And a lot of that is one officer who's our traffic officer right now. He was really dedicated in getting OUIs off the road. I am, too. We started the regional ride program enforcement, and now it's gone nationwide. And we started that about a year and a half, two years ago in getting regional police officers from various communities who are very good at impaired driving detection, protection, drug experts, phlebotomists, advanced training. And we would go out and saturate areas, including Falmouth, to make these roads safe. And so with legalization of cannabis and poly drug use, which is the combination of drugs and alcohol, it is extremely challenging for us and time consuming in managing these OUIs. So I say that in pleading with people to please take an Uber and don't drink and drive. But I wish I could say that the roads are getting safer. I just think it's challenging to say that with the impaired drivers. We're looking at the operating complaints, 385 to date. That's one or two a day. We get people calling on their phone saying, this person's all over the road. And the officer has to make a determination, how bad are they all over the road? And do I respond, "License Irene," or I just work my way there? So, you know, we're chasing. The public's calling in. But they are incredibly time-consuming for our staff and for everyone across the state. So we hear you. We hear the traffic issues and the traffic complaints. And we're doing what we have. And I'm sure other departments are doing what they have too. So in summary, traffic enforcement, I feel, as your chief, is good. I'm satisfied. I'm happy with the numbers we have. We continue to make it a priority. I think we've got a good follow-through program in identifying our challenge roads, which are many, and getting resources there to address it. Staffing continues to be a challenge. It's always going to continue to be a challenge, but we'll work through that and do the best we can. We're regionally high for an agency this size. I think that's pretty self-explanatory. Our citations are fair and balanced. I'm proud of that. If I get complaints, I handle complaints. The deputy chief handles complaints. Everything is on video. Every interaction is on video. I've got my camera, sorry, over there, but I've got my camera here. So if we get complaints that, you know, the officer is unfair, we're going to look at that and we're going to evaluate that. I do not like ticky-tack violations. I want them to do their job. I want them to be fair and balanced. But I'm not one of these chiefs out there, if they're doing three over the speed limit, they need a ticket. Traffic volume continues to increase with local and regional growth on the fringes of the community, which I talked about. We're addressing emerging challenges with street takeovers and faster vehicles. That, I don't want to jinx myself, has been a calm summer with street takeovers. Those are cars that race into an intersection, spin around in parking lots and cause havoc. We had a couple episodes out here. We jumped on it immediately. I think it was a year and a half ago, about a year and a half ago, We were able to identify the drivers and five of we had like, let's just say 30, 40 cars out here. Five of them were from Falmouth. And we knocked on the doors and spoke with their parents. And it stopped. Right. You know, it stopped. And then we held regional meetings in southern Maine and in York on collaborating, sharing information. and being aggressive when we're dealing with the street takeovers it has it's been a quiet summer and i think a lot of that is because we've taken on law enforcement regionally to stop this if you've never seen one you've probably seen videos of it 's pretty horrifying faster vehicles we're dealing with evs i drive one and it's fast and it can get away from you vehicles are quieter they're faster they're comfortable they don't you don't hear the noise like you did years ago so you can tend to get up to speed, go beyond the speed, and not really mean it. Increased impaired driving, we've talked about that. We have a aging population, the oldest in the country. With that comes cognitive behavior diminishing and getting behind the wheel. We're dealing with a lot of seniors with operating issues, and, you know, we take that serious. To me, that's an impaired driver when you're all over the road driving down the road. But, again, that's time-consuming there. And new drivers, we're dealing with a lot of drivers that don't have licenses that are driving, something that I, you know, when I started out here, that wasn't a thing. You had suspended licenses, but you had formal training. So we're dealing with that, which creates hazards. We're dealing, no big secret, with a larger user group than in the past. We have more pedestrian using our roadways, cyclists, and EV technology. We've seen the emerging piece of EV technology, so we have a lot of people moving around on our roadways, pedestrian, cyclists, and EV, bbv bicyclists are vulnerable to a vehicle, and so we take that serious. And you know, we continue with the enforcement because we know, you know, Portland's struggling with that, with a lot of pedestrian crashers and things along those lines. And you know, then we get down to traffic calming measures and cost and locations and how do we measure that. And I think there's been a lot of discussion with the council and the town manager on is, you know, is this something that the town wants to take on and do. And I've seen it in the city where I live in, it's a lot of visual confusion when you, when you see these things, and towns are addressing this across the state. And my only thing would be, when we start looking at this, I would go slowly. That would be my recommendation, see what others are doing, and be prepared to what you do the one road you got to do to a lot. That has been my experience in talking with the public is I want what they have, so, and I get it, I get it right. So I just leave it at that, you know, because I think that's going to be something that's going to continue because we're seeing it in other communities. So with that. It was in 45 minutes, but with that, 's an overview of what we're doing and how we're doing it. And I look forward to your questions.
[1:48:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Chief Kilbride. That was a very thorough overview. I really appreciate it. We would like to extend an invitation. Anyone on the council who would like to speak to this item at this time. Yeah. Oh, so who's a counselor. Okay, Chief, I just wanted to
[1:48:35] Speaker G (unidentified): thank you for being here this evening and for all of this information. As always, hearing from you and Deputy is just always very valuable and informative. So thank you for everything that you do for our town and for all of the data that we have to back statements up. So I appreciate it. Yeah, thank you for the opportunity. Thank you. Yes.
[1:48:55] Speaker E (unidentified): Counselor Tracy, thank you. And yeah, thank you too, Chief. It's great to have you and Deputy Chief with us. One quick question. You had said, you know, obviously speed enforcement because there's a lot of bicycles and pedestrians and, but what about the bicycles and scooters, all of the motorized ones who are sometimes riding on the sidewalk really pretty fast and, you know, I have a thing for no helmets as well and other crazy things that they do, but are there rules around that? You know, I know I think there was some issue with some students again, perhaps, that we're breaking some rules. But, you know, is there anything you guys can do when you see people riding motorized scooters on sidewalks and doing other things that they shouldn't be
[1:49:53] Speaker F (unidentified): doing? Yeah, no, great question. And that's an emerging challenge for a lot of agencies. We've done some educational components through social media with the public. We've done enforcement components in educating those kids. Those that have an EV bike with pedals are handled differently than an EV motor scooter. We've had, we tried to initiate at least two or three stops, and they've taken off on a chase component. Of course, we're not chasing. So, but we know who they are, and then we go back and manage it that way. So, we are, to answer your question, we are addressing it. We have seen, I've seen a curvature in that under the streets. The SROs are addressing it at the school level with the kids. I know I covered a football, I covered some type of game a while ago, and they're all over the place. And I get like, okay, wow, you know, here we go. So we are addressing it. And I think a lot of it's just an educational piece to the kids. A lot of them feel that, and their parents, that if it's for sale, we can use it and there are guidelines and rules with that so I'm pretty pleased with I'm hearing officers stopping them talking to them and of course the ones that are not stopping we're not chasing but we reach out to the at the officer reaches out to the SRO the next day and we try to identify them so we have video of everything so we go back in the video and we show it to the SRO and they're usually that's so and so we talked about they're a great resource on that great
[1:51:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other comments questions go counselor Diaz and then counselor Vance
[1:51:40] Speaker B (unidentified): I just had a question about the 85 percentile if it says say 35 miles per hour on 85 percentile. Does that mean that 85% of the vehicles were 34 and below, or? Yes. All right. Councilor Vance?
[1:52:07] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah. For the 50th, 85th, like, speed studies that are generated on the per location basis, do you have, like, benchmarks from the state DOT or comps with towns to say, you know, we're out of variants in a similar way to other towns? You know, if people are doing 47 and a 35 at 85th percentile, is that roughly commensurate?
[1:52:30] Speaker F (unidentified): I've never known the state to provide me data. I don't know if you have a place where that lives. They don't. I've never seen them come out and do studies. They rely on locals for that. MDOT is not really a partner when it comes to speed identification, speed management. management their rule of thumb to me is when we've looked at streets to hey can we lower the speed right their response is what does it feel like you can do right it's kind of that's that's how they operate it's that's tough to explain to someone on gray road that it 's 45 or it's 50 and they want a 35 but it's gray road right so mdot hasn't been really a resource for any data Any speed data, real speed data, is captured and managed by us. Interesting. Thank you.
[1:53:23] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I think we've used the fear that we've heard at times that if we actually have the state DOT look at a road, they may actually increase the speed limit, right, because they go to, well, what seems to be safe, you know, based on rates and things like, you know, accident rates not being high, despite having, you know, people traveling 42 in a 35 or something like that.
[1:53:43] Speaker F (unidentified): They did it on Leighton Road. They raised it five miles an hour. Yeah. So it's kind of like, okay, we don't want to bother them.
[1:53:51] Speaker H (unidentified): And then I appreciate the targeted time-day analysis you were talking about that seems very intelligent use. Is there similar correlation, though, you've observed with, for instance, like accidents and those time of days that have higher speeding? Intuitively, one would assume that, but I don't know if that's actually borne out in the data or anyone's taken a look at it.
[1:54:12] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, it doesn't. Accidents, that's a whole nother mechanism, that holds all the traffic data. The two are not combined. Wednesdays are our highest crash times. Sunny days are our highest crash weather. And, men are the demographic that get in more crashes than women. In. What I pay attention to that data, I mean, first of all, our big push would be traffic enforcement, right? Let's continue what we're doing, slow people down, be visible. And there's the other component of it, Counselor, which is high visibility reduces crime. So if you're intent on coming down to Route 1 and shoplifting from Walmart or Shaw's and you see blue lights on Route 1, that's a visual deterrence. That lets them know that there's a police officer there. That's not my statistic. That has been around forever, that high visibility with your law enforcement deters crime. And we know crime operates in a vehicle. It just does. It rarely walks. It sometimes does, but it rarely walks into your community. So, yeah, we don't, the speed, Indeed, what I pay attention mostly from that platform is the percentage of impaired drivers in the crashes. So we average about 2.5, 3% of the 300 crashes a year is alcohol-related. I start seeing that shoot up to 5% or 6%. We start making adjustments on enforcement levels and start looking at some OUI enforcement and things along those lines, dedicated OUI enforcement.
[1:55:58] Speaker D (unidentified): You bet. Great. Councilor Sharp, I wonder if we just kind of play through because I think we do obviously get, you know, complaints, let's say, from residents about speed. So I'll, you know, using myself, so I live on [street], I don't have a problem with the or right off of Woods Road, I have a problem with the speed. But if I called you and told you I did, you take this bread box, you stick it on a telephone pole on Woods Road, you collect the data for a week or however long, and then I could see. One circumstance might be you bring me the data, you show me this, and you say, hey, you know, it's it's not what you're saying and what we're seeing are two different things. There's there's not really a problem here. And I imagine that happens with some frequency. Is that fair to say so far? But then if there is, if you do find a problem, is the way to get people's behavior to change is that we do traffic stops on that road? Yes. Yeah, I mean, and so we'll identify the
[1:56:57] Speaker F (unidentified): road, the traffic officer may do, hey, give me some help. We may do some dedicated high visibility enforcement. High visibility enforcement's a really neat model when you come around a corner and you see three or four police cars dedicated through a particular road. That's a high visibility impact where that leaves an impression in you the next time you take that road. But that's exactly how it works. I don't know. You know, you look overseas, Sweden. You look at these foreign countries that use traffic cameras. They don't even do traffic enforcement. The camera just captures you, and you get a ticket in the mail. I don't know if America's got the appetite for that. I'm sensing they don't for traffic cameras on every street. But, you know, when you get there and you get all these complaints, it's not going to happen in my time, but that's how Europe is dealing with it is cameras, and you get a speeding ticket. And some places in the United States.
[1:57:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Sorry, but it does generally work. So if you find, hey, if I go there on Wednesday at X time, I'm going to be able to hand out a couple tickets. And then, in fact, we see that speeds reduce, and I assume for a period of time. And I guess people then eventually forget that you were doing it.
[1:58:08] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, high visibility, commuter time is a big thing. Like you say, Bavage Road, everyone coming from Wyndham heading to work. So you stop a car and you have another 45 past you. That's 45 that you've left an imprint in. And then you can use the message board that reminds 90 percent of the people to slow down because 90 percent of the people want to do the right thing. Ten percent of the people are just going to speed. And eventually tickets and high cost of insurance and going to jail will wear them down. But it's a combination of enforcement, knowing the problem, and knowing when the problem is, we're on it. And then using message boards, those message boards, speed boards get moved every two weeks. So what we've determined is you get desensitized to it after a while, and so we move it to another location. So when you turn the corner, it pops at you.
[1:59:09] Speaker J (unidentified): Councilor Mahoney. So first of all, based on personal experience, or actually I've been told, not personal experience, your officers do use discretion quite well. Well, and I think it's really appreciated for folks, so I would just make that comment. And the second thing is I think the bread box technology is great. I think in addition to kind of sharing it with the person who requested it, I think it would be a good thing to put an example. I don't know how often, I don't know how readily available the information is but it seems to me it wouldn't be a bad thing to put on a town website and give one example of here is the information for Falmouth Road on this date and if you're interested in other roads you can find it here where we collected data so people can see so it's not just you know people who have a specific complaint, but it just allows for that greater general knowledge about, you know, the town and the police department's not ignoring the issue. It's actually out there collecting the data. And sure, if you're standing on the side of Falmouth Road getting the newspaper in the morning, it feels like every car's going 70. But they're probably not. They might be going fast, but they're not 70. But I think that's a helpful thing for people to get some appreciation for the scope or lack thereof of the issue.
[2:00:58] Speaker F (unidentified): That's a good recommendation. And I think that's easily what we can do. If you ask my employees who my favorite employees are, they're going to say the sign boards. They go to work April 1st and they just stopped last weekend. We had to put them in right weather, sand, salt, position of the sun, their solar, their solar power. But they do a lot of great work moving around, and when the traffic officer is operational 100 and I'm not collapsing him for anything else, these are the things that we can do and I am a big proponent of keeping maximizing our equipment and keeping it out there. Like I said, these go out in April and they don't come back until November and that stat tracker goes year round so we try to capture the goal is to capture speed data on frequent roads at least twice a year and posting is a good idea and we'll we'll look into that. I certainly didn't want to load the department up. I was
[2:01:59] Speaker J (unidentified): I was thinking it could be with our communications team and putting it onto Falmouth Notes.
[2:02:03] Speaker F (unidentified): It's not a big lift in printing it and posting it. It really isn't. I look at this as something the traffic officer can do if we can get them going, you know what I mean, all the time, right?
[2:02:12] Speaker J (unidentified): But getting it into Falmouth Notes might be helpful just to kind of make people aware that it's there. Most people aren't scrolling through the PD website, Chief, probably for good reason.
[2:02:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Right. Any other? Yes, Councilor Diaz.
[2:02:30] Speaker B (unidentified): Just some questions. We've been talking about speeding. What's the definition of speeding in general?
[2:02:42] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, be operating over the posted speed limit. So the fines are broken out into increments of one mile over to four miles over, all the way up until it gets to criminal speed and which is 30 miles and over and then that's there's no longer a fine address to it and the fines are between 114 and 278 and then you get into criminal speed which is summons right you're you can take them to jail it's an
[2:03:14] Speaker B (unidentified): arrestable offense so in theory if you're going one mile over the speed limit, you can get a $114 ticket? In theory, but if you contest it, the judge is not going to hold that up, and he's going to look at you like you're crazy. And so, and it seems like, you know, from the documents that we've seen, the traffic analysis report, the violation threshold is marked at 10, so it seems like we've decided that 10 over the speed limit is actionable. Anything under may not be as action.
[2:03:47] Speaker H (unidentified): It can be.
[2:03:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Each officer has their threshold.
[2:03:54] Speaker B (unidentified): And when we talked about traffic calming measures, from experience, we know that, or you've said that speed boards work. Anything else that you think can make people slow down, even if it's for a week or two, for a short period of time?
[2:04:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Short of altering the road, you know you can start putting in speed bumps and pylons and stop signs. Portland's a big thing of let's just throw a stop sign up on a straight road, and Portland does that everywhere. I don't know the studies behind it. You know, you could, you could throw stop signs up. You have to check with MDOT. I think they went against MDOT on that, but you'd have to have to look into that. I've seen that play out in the city of Portland, and then you get into complaints coming to our end on they didn't stop at the stop sign, they roll through the stop sign, right? It's just, you know, pick your poison. But those are some of the measures that I've seen in Portland living in there. Yeah, so I guess, and the other, the other component is we've had, we've put permanent signage out, electronic signs in areas where we've identified a higher percentile speed, the 85 percentile speed. Johnson Road got two of them. So this is an unbudgeted thing. These are $5,600. I think they're down now. We've got smaller ones, so they're probably around $4,000. It's an item we don't carry. It's something that I go and beg the manager for at the end of the year, saying hey, can we get one up on Brook Road inbound, data supports it, because I need data when I get calls from all over the other places like Andrews Ave that says hey, we want one down in Andrews Ave, or we want one over here. We put, we put the box out there, and it's data driven for that, and I just don't have a line item for stuff like that, you know. So I have them in my neighborhood in Portland, and they have knocked. It's a heavy-volume road. And I try to tell my neighbors that it's the volume that you have issues with. Speed is late at night. You know, at 10 o'clock at night, the kids get on it going to Westbrook. But they have helped. They have helped. It's just a question of how much you want to spend and what's the formula that we're going to use to put them in there. I'm not saying my formula is right. Right. I'm just, I had to make a decision. And that was let's see what the 85 percentile is. Let's be data driven on that. That's another traffic piece. We have one down here on Woodville Road. We measured the speed coming from Thalmothin and we measured the speed coming the other way. And the speed coming this way was much lower than coming the other way. So that warranted a sign before you hit the school zone. So that's why you don't see two, you should see one, because this is the time they turn the corner. They're not rare, they're, you know, they're just not getting up to speed as opposed. When you leave Woods Road and you take that left, you can get, you can get moving through there. And so those are the
[2:07:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Permanent speed boards, right? Yes, they are. And we have four of them in town, or we have two on
[2:07:27] Speaker F (unidentified): Johnson Road, the study ones that was put in by Public Works, is still on 88. I imagine they're, they're still there. And I have one over on Brook Road. Yeah, one over on Brook Road.
[2:07:41] Speaker B (unidentified): And the Woodville Road. And the what? And the one in Woodville Road. Woodville Road, yep. And how much do they cost?
[2:07:48] Speaker F (unidentified): They're about $4,000, $4,500 each.
[2:07:52] Speaker B (unidentified): And our take is that they work, or do you think that eventually people just forget that they're there?
[2:07:59] Speaker F (unidentified): I think they work. I think they work as that 90% reminder. If you're going to speed, you're going to speed. So, I mean, I ask all of you when you go down Lunt Road in the car in front of you, watch the car in front of you when that speed sign flashes 30 or 27. What do they do? Do they hit the brakes? What do you do? Most of the time they hit the brakes. It's that reminder. So you're looking at the same thing I am. So I just ask you to look at that, and I'll give you a good understanding on people's reaction to it. Thank you so much. Yeah, you bet.
[2:08:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Great. Maybe I just have one last question, and that is I've certainly heard from residents both when I was door knocking and also last spring, but also an email that in more recent years seems like at least people have told me that it feels like the traffic is getting faster than it has in the past. We looked at the data, which was pretty clear. Have you noticed any trend lines in the number of speeding traffic today as it was, say, compared to 10 years ago or some time in the past?
[2:09:13] Speaker F (unidentified): We didn't have all this data back then. Yep. You know, my fallback on that is volume. Yep. Volume has just increased tenfold. We can all shake our head on that. Yep. And volume sometimes gets confused for speed. Yep. It just does. us. Or you're walking, and a truck goes by you at 35 and a 30, and it feels like they're doing, or a dump truck, and it feels like they're doing 55. We've all felt that. We've worked on the interstate and been out there and had trucks go by us at 70 miles an hour, and you would have swore they're doing 120. So I think the volume, we have, we actually, I don't have data back then, but we have it now. But I actually think the volume piece over the last 10 years has increased immensely throughout the town.
[2:10:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Thank you. And again, I wanted to echo what's been said by other counselors. Thank you, Chief Kilbride. Thank you, Deputy Chief Pardue, and your entire staff for all this providing safety and security to us as a community. Greatly appreciate it.
[2:10:18] Speaker F (unidentified): And I encourage when you get emails, obviously they're coming our way anyways, but we look forward to doing the best we can in addressing them. So thank you.
[2:10:26] Speaker A (unidentified): most appreciated all right so with that we'll go ahead and close out item number six on the agenda we're now move on to item number seven and this is an order to approve a supplemental appropriation to authorize the town manager to execute a heating assistance program with found money fifty five thousand seven hundred thirty seven dollars was found in 2022 near the central fire station, and a trail running from the station to a parking lot for the Legion Fields. The police department followed state laws applicable to be found an unclaimed property. After proper notice and time, it went unclaimed. In accordance with state laws, the money must be for charitable purposes. The town of Falmouth has historically initiated a heat pumping, heat assistance program during times of economic uncertainty for people who can least afford basic necessities, Great Recession, COVID, et cetera. The programs were aligned with Federal Heating Assistance Program, known as the Low-Income Heating Assistance Program, LIHEAP. The town manager is recommending establishing a heating assistance program for the ensuing heat season due to the unusual cost of fuel. The town manager further recommends that such program again align with LIHEAP. The proposed eligibility will include any Falmouth resident who has completed LIHEAP application and is eligible for a LIHEAP assistance. Anyone that meets this threshold will be eligible for a $500 assistance. That's heating, fuel, electricity bill, rent if rent includes utilities, etc. After a period of time, the town manager authorized additional funding for another round of assistance. With any remaining funds, the town manager further requests that the town council approve a supplemental appropriation to fund the program in the amount of fifty five thousand seven hundred and thirty seven dollars. A public comment period has been included with this item, so with that I would like to extend an invitation to anyone who's attending here in person who would like to speak to this item and not seeing anyone to the podium would like to extend that invitation to anyone who's attending remotely and not seen any hands raised i'd like to bring this back to the council if anyone has any comments questions regarding this item counselor diaz should
[2:13:00] Speaker B (unidentified): be more detailed. You know, five fifty thousand dollars just in a bag. Where was this and how often does this happen, and how often does this happen?
[2:13:12] Speaker F (unidentified): yeah john kilbright police chief yes where was your question on the yeah so someone walking by the trail the connected you know behind legion field the little league field the parking lot back there 's a connector pathway to the fire station someone saw our safe i pointed it out to the fire department fire department says yeah just notify the police we went down recovered the safe went to public works opened the safe and there was the large amount of money in the safe so yeah unusual it was i don't want to get into details on how it was packed, but we sent a teletype out which goes to area police agencies. It was, there were some bans that were identified. We tracked the bans to a bank in New Hampshire, called them, saying, well, you were a victim of a robbery. No, we weren't. We sent teletypes out to other agencies with, you know, we've discovered a large sum of money. Of course, we're not giving the amount, right, you know, because it's everybody's at that point. And so we went through protocols, legal, six months, anyone claiming it, things along those lines, advertising it through the forecaster, along with other items that we have. It's not unusual for us to have discarded items, kayaks and bikes and things along those lines that we have to find a place to donate it. But we hung on longer than usual for the cash, just because we just didn't know if there was going to be a victim that was going to rear its head, a senior somewhere that didn't know until a child came home and discovered it or things along those lines. And there was details within that cache that if it was yours, you would be able to walk us through it to make us feel comfortable in surrendering it. So we surmised after hanging on to it for quite some time in our safe in an evidence room under camera. I was like to the manager, like, we got to get it out of here. We've had it for two or three years now. No one has made claim. No agency has come forward. We talked to legal. Goal, we did everything we needed to do to advertise it, and so, yeah, it gets, it gets turned over to the people, and, that's where you have it right now. So we can surmise that, you know, maybe a drug deal, maybe someone left it for drugs where its location was, you could access it through that parking lot, which you're not really going to be seen, there's no literally games going on, you could exchange it, grab the safe, and put something else down there again, this is just guessing. The money was dry, so it wasn't out there for any length of time. And so we're surmising that it was there for pickup and something else was going to get dropped off. But, yeah, we don't know. So it's a good way to end a meeting. Good news. Yes. Councilor Sharp. How did you open the safe? We peeled it at Public Works. So everything was documented. Trust me, everything was documented by video, but we brought it to Public Works where they cut it open, and then phones
[2:16:32] Speaker D (unidentified): were ringing off the hook. Must have been a great day for police. I mean, what, it wasn't it, what an adventure. Yeah, it was a different day, it was, it was, it was a
[2:16:43] Speaker F (unidentified): Different day, and then you know you got to get a counting machine, and you've got to get some stuff, and everything is just, you know, the deputy chief's all on it, and nothing gets by him. Everything's on video, every call, everything to document, and everything, so we're not used to handling large sums of money like that on the open, so
[2:17:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, let's see, Counselor Martin. Thank you. I have a quick question. I wanted to thank Nathan too for the idea to put these funds toward this good purpose, and is certainly going to be needed for this upcoming heating season. With that being said, if we do not go through the entire $55,000 in this season? Does it roll over to the next season? Like, is it designated for LIHEAP assistance moving forward? Or what's kind of the restrictions or intentions of it beyond
[2:17:35] Speaker K (unidentified): this season? My recommendation would be to go with one round at $500. And my goal is to get it out there and start it soon so that we can distribute the money in mid-January, according to our GA coordinator from the county. She's telling me that's what she sees as the highest need month. People are very cash poor after the holidays. It's the peak of the heating season. And then I'm estimating that we'll be somewhere between 30 and 50 people first round based on past experience. We could have more people that are eligible for LIHEAP now, so it may be more. So that's why I didn't... My initial thought was $1,000. The first round, and that would cover 55 people. I got thinking, well, what if all of a sudden there's 75 people in Falmouth that are eligible? So I want to go with a $500 first round and then immediately do a second round and get the money out the same heating season, especially with the price the way it is. I mean, $500 is going to buy you 100 gallons if you're lucky. Yep.
[2:18:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes, Councilor Tracy. Thank you. Just to be clear for everyone that might not know as much, you're paying a heating bill. You're not giving someone $500 and saying, please go pay your heating bill. You're paying Irving Oil or whoever, you know, the gas company or whatever, correct?
[2:18:59] Speaker K (unidentified): Yes, we're going to make sure that we are reimbursing for the fuel or paying direct for the fuel. The only difference is how I'm going to deal with if the utilities are included with the rent. So if they can show that they've kept up with the rent, I want to be able to do that. I saw that just recently in how other towns are handling it, and there are some situations where the utilities are included, so I don't want to leave those people out. Yeah, great.
[2:19:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other last comments or questions? Yeah, I would just kind of echo a little bit that an incredible find has turned into an enormous amount of serendipity, given the amount, the timing that we're in right now as we enter the winter and looking at how fuel costs are, this just seems like a lot of dots are being connected here. So thank you for your thoughtfulness in this as well, Nathan. So with that, I would like to ask any other, any last questions. If not, then I'd like to ask if there would be a motion for order 44-2027 counselor Vance and we have counselor Mahoney for a second all those in favor of order 44-2027. And that is unanimous. So that will close out item number seven. We now just move to adjourn. Actually. Oh yes, Councilor Mahoney.
[2:20:21] Speaker J (unidentified): I probably should have done this at the beginning. I just wanted to make two comments. First, I think we commented on it at our last meeting, but since we have the organizer of the community supper here, year. That was such an amazing success. I just wanted to recognize Nancy Lightbody for bringing back the community supper, which was really a fantastic event, and I hope continues to be an even more popular event going forward. So thank you very much. And the second comment, this is our first meeting since the election day, and I just wanted to give a shout out to the town staff and all the volunteers at the polling station. As we know from Nathan's notes at the end of last week, almost 85 of eligible voters in Falmouth voted last Tuesday, which doesn't matter what, who you voted for, that's an amazing number, and it's really great. And I, and so Ellen and Linda and all the people have been volunteering for years, and the rest of the clerk's staff really deserve credit for that. So I just wanted to make
[2:21:30] Speaker A (unidentified): those two points yes thank you for highlighting those two points councillor mahoney and yes
[2:21:35] Speaker H (unidentified): Councilman, yeah, I'll just echo that. Some friends of ours who are now constituents of Council Mahoney's on Summit Drive had to wait like an hour and 15 minutes to vote on election day, and I was like, wow, Falmouth is getting it done. So no such lines here, so thank you to everyone.
[2:21:50] Speaker A (unidentified): on the staff for that yes it takes a village and we've got a good village to say the least so thank you for finishing on those really nice remarks with that then now we will then move forward to adjourn does do I have a motion to adjourn council money do I have a second councillor Tracy all those in favor that is unanimous y'all have a good evening thank you