Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Public Comment
[0:03] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Good evening. Welcome to the October 27 ZBA meeting. Meeting will come to order. I'm going to take a roll call of board members present. Kevin. Present. Chris. Present. John. Present. Isara Vervillan present. Peter. Present. Okay. Okay, Kevin, we will have you voting tonight given that Joe is absent, if that works for you. Okay, so we've got a lot on our agenda tonight. We're going to start with approval of the September 22nd, 2026 meeting minutes. Do any of the board members have any comments on the meeting minutes? Nope. Do I hear a motion to approve the minutes? Motion to approve. Second. All right. All those in favor? Aye. Passes unanimously. We have a big agenda tonight with one, two, three, four, five proposals, some of which I think will be generating a lot of comment. So I'd like to know how many people in the room are intending on speaking tonight. Seven, eight, nine. and those of you on zoom could you raise your hand if you intend on speaking tonight given that we have so many commenters I as the board chair I'm going to ask board members if they feel comfortable that we impose a comment time limit of three minutes per commenter absolutely okay so just to let you know three minutes for each comment any comments that you make should be addressed to the board not we're not engaging public comments are not intended to engage in a back and forth between applicant and the commenter all right i know some of you have gone through this with us before so, but just want to make the reminder. So with respect to each agenda item, we'll first hear from the applicant. The board will then ask the applicant questions about the application. We'll then have the public comment period first with those in the room. And then finally, those on Zoom. And after that, we'll shut down the public comment period and there will be board deliberation and decision. Please make sure you speak directly into the microphone as the meeting is being recorded as well as shown on local cable, and make sure you state your name and address. I want to remind applicants that the burden is on you to demonstrate compliance with each of the applicable criteria. With that introduction over, we will move to item 2, 34 Old Mill Road, Robert Althea McGeer request for conditional use approval to expand an existing structure.
[3:34] Speaker B (unidentified): And just to clarify, the three minutes is not applicable to the applicant themselves.
[3:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Hi, Bob McGeer, 34 Old Mill Road. I was here in the July meeting and we got unanimous approval from the board to do what I thought was the entire project that we have in mind this is our aging in place thing I'm trying to kind of speed things up this is speeding sped up for me. The day I found out that the elevator enclosure was not included in the prior board approval, thanks to Justin, always a bright light in my life, was just coincidentally, it was when I picked up the building permit and I saw the exclusion on the building permit, which was news to me and so i apologize for a somewhat limited packet that was all the time we had to put together and i'm just going to ask for a little discretion if i might you've got the engineering stuff in front of you got all the numbers and you got an engineering perspective on my little 3d home architect program at home i made up something that I find at least much easier to work with and if it's okay I'm gonna hand these out to the board members hold
[5:16] Speaker A (unidentified): on a second how does the board feel about it submittal of new information I
[5:24] Speaker D (unidentified): have no issues okay good just
[5:52] Speaker A (unidentified): a quick question to those in the room is there anyone in the room who's intending on speaking commenting on this particular application otherwise I would give that person the opportunity oh are [Speaker D (unidentified): you] saying that someone on zoom wants to no i'm saying i misspoke and i apologize okay all right thank you go ahead okay thank you so the idea of those
[6:29] Speaker C (unidentified): handouts is that i think they're more familiar to the to the common man at least to me the first page is kind of what the house looks like from Old Mill Road, the head-on view. And that would be sort of kind of to scale. And unlike the engineering things, you know, I don't have things measured out to sixteenths of an inch, whatever. The first page and the second page are just to try to give you a sense of what this thing is going to look like. And the third page is going to hit upon where I'm going to ask you to bless something that is different from what the engineering diagrams are. The reason for that is because those of you who remember the July meeting will know that we started off with removal of bedrock to the tune of something like 150 tons of bedrock were removed by a company that came in from out of state. And something that we knew had always been somewhat of an issue was how close they could come to the existing foundation of the house, which is a 1972 foundation, in the corner where the house exists, without jeopardizing the foundation or going to just outrageously expensive solutions. And when all was said and done, the bedrock has been removed to depth to about within three feet of those two foundations in that inside corner. So the bottom line is you just can't stick an elevator in the corner as the engineers show it. The engineers, for simplicity, show that the bedrock would be removed right smack up to the existing foundations, and it can't be done. It just can't be done safely. The engineers didn't like it when they put that in the diagrams. The rock drilling company refused to do it. So what we're stuck with is an offset of three to four feet from the old foundations. And because elevators tend to go just straight up and down, that three to four foot offset obviously applies to not only the basement level, but also the first floor level of the garage. And that's all there is to the elevator. It does not go to the second floor of the house, doesn't go to the attic, doesn't go to the ridgeline. It's a two-level elevator. So what I'm asking for permission is to build that elevator within the footprint that's shown on the last page. And I think that the square that I've outlined is something like nine feet on a side. the elevator itself is the smallest residential elevator that will accommodate a wheelchair it requires a space of something on the order of five to six feet square so with an offset of three feet I figured a square footprint area of about nine feet from that corner would still allow us to build the elevator it will still be attached to the house on both walls it's not a standalone structure out in the yard somewhere by itself and other than that if you will request that differs from the information that Justin put in the packet I think that summarizes pretty much where we're at and what we're asking for permission to do all
[10:38] Speaker A (unidentified): right questions from the board my first
[10:42] Speaker D (unidentified): question is there anywhere on your application where it states how tall
[10:50] Speaker C (unidentified): this structure is the engineering diagram excuse me the engineering
[10:55] Speaker D (unidentified): diagram should state how tall it is okay where is can you point that out or does anybody see it because i do not age nine i'm trying to see yeah i 'm fully prepared to say
[11:10] Speaker C (unidentified): it's a two-floor elevator you know i understand your concern i just i don't have a number for you i believe it is on the engineering plans and it reflects one level in the basement that is yet to be completed and one level that is equivalent in height to the first floor of our house so
[11:36] Speaker D (unidentified): it but the top of the structure looks like it goes well above the peak of the existing roof which is fine i just don't know how high the existing roof no what am i looking at is that
[11:48] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah so i thought it was such a good diagram maybe my diagram didn't help
[11:53] Speaker E (unidentified): so it's going above the garage
[11:56] Speaker A (unidentified): wait a minute wait a minute it's very hard to do a recording so we probably need to have one person speaking at a time okay why don't you point to the diagram on where the elevator is shown mr gear laser
[12:25] Speaker F (unidentified): pointer yeah
[12:39] Speaker C (unidentified): The problem with this is it's in isolation because it doesn't show the house. The easiest way for me to explain it is...
[12:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you speak into the microphone?
[12:49] Speaker G (unidentified): I need to get the mic.
[12:50] Speaker C (unidentified): The easiest way for me to understand roof lines on that thing is that if you took our house and got rid of the second floor and assumed a flat ceiling and some sort of modest gable roof kind of a thing, that's about what the height absolute height will be at the top of the elevator it's a fairly slow low pitch excuse me and it's pitched across right back the now we don't know how many feet instead of four or five feet it might be seven or eight feet back but it's a it's a shallow pitch back into the corner of the house and the jog in the house that have been there forever I don't know if
[13:37] Speaker H (unidentified): that helps. Is the need for the added height due to the mechanics of the elevator?
[13:43] Speaker C (unidentified): The elevator actually only needs to be 8 feet high. Floor to ceiling level is something like 8 feet. There's no mechanical room, there's no whatever,. It's just you have to build a sloped roof on top of that.
[14:04] Speaker H (unidentified): you were saying the elevator only goes from the basement to the first floor
[14:08] Speaker C (unidentified): correct it looks like this structure goes higher than that the roof the roof does absolutely but
[14:17] Speaker H (unidentified): what is above the elevator that the roof is covering
[14:21] Speaker C (unidentified): nothing the elevator enclosure does nothing except enclose the elevator
[14:28] Speaker H (unidentified): So I just want to look, why so high?
[14:33] Speaker C (unidentified): I may have drawn it wrong. You know, it's going to be like a 4'12 pitch roof. It doesn't have to be anything exotic. But 4'12 pitch over six feet, so you'd have another two feet. So you'd be up 10 feet instead of eight feet for a flat ceiling. On that order. And that's why I say, if Justin had given me more time to put this all together, I could have done a better job, but, you know.
[14:59] Speaker H (unidentified): Well, I have you. The dash line is overhang, I'm assuming, on your home. The dash line that goes around the elevator perimeter, is that roof overhang? How should I interpret that?
[15:12] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm not sure. I am not by any means an expert with that software. There is an overhang which will match the overhang of the roof of the main house. house it'll be clabbers you know trim everything is going to be aesthetically done so that it matches the existing house as much as possible we don't want to put in a real steep roof for the reason that it would call more attention to itself and it would be higher and it would be more of an aesthetic thing and that's exactly what we're not looking for especially with the fact that we have this offset in the basement because of the existing bedrock. We're really trying to minimize that roof level.
[16:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Justin, did you want to say something?
[16:04] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I think something to keep in mind, and I'm going to be unorthodox in a minute and pass my laptop around to hopefully better demonstrate this. What we are not seeing, this is demonstrated as the plane of the elevator work to be done. behind the elevator there is a roof structure and a structure not shown back in this area here so my understanding from what i'm seeing in the drawing is there is a another roof ridge height here that extends further up that is not depicted in this if you go up a page and look
[16:38] Speaker B (unidentified): at the actual picture it shows you exactly where it's going to be on the picture page eight of yeah
[16:43] Speaker H (unidentified): i can this is it's better than the packet or better viewed but it's the same photo okay the
[16:49] Speaker D (unidentified): shed yeah the roof it's okay anybody else want to see that no i just i figured it out here it's that's what was confusing me you know if you rotate it actually makes it okay any other
[17:05] Speaker A (unidentified): questions from board members if i don't know if this will clarify or not if i can interrupt you
[17:11] Speaker C (unidentified): for just a second the house is a two-story house with a full attic with i believe 812 pitch so it's substantially higher than where the roof for the elevator enclosure will end up right thank you
[17:29] Speaker A (unidentified): so as i understand with the new information the elevator footprint is nine feet by five-eighths and five-eighths inches by nine feet.
[17:43] Speaker C (unidentified): That was as close as I could do it.
[17:46] Speaker A (unidentified): And as I understand, is that within where the garage was or where you've excavated?
[17:55] Speaker C (unidentified): It is within the area that was excavated. The existing garage is a detached garage. That's right. right so this sets more kind of in the middle of our of our lot okay i'm just trying to make sure
[18:10] Speaker A (unidentified): that yeah justin and you can help me out here that there's no change to any of the other setbacks
[18:19] Speaker I (unidentified): no i believe this one falls squarely right in the center of the law okay
[18:24] Speaker A (unidentified): are there any other questions from board members okay then i think thank you we're going to open it up to public comment is there anyone in the room that would like to provide comments on this particular application is there anyone on zoom who would like to provide comments on this particular application no okay we're going to close the public comment period and move to board discussion and deliberation anyone like to make any comments so
[19:11] Speaker D (unidentified): I have no issues with this
[19:12] Speaker A (unidentified): application all right would anyone like to make a motion yeah I can make a
[19:20] Speaker B (unidentified): motion to request to approve the request for conditional use under section 19 dash 86 to expand an existing structure at 34 Old Mill Road
[19:29] Speaker A (unidentified): second all right we'll move to vote Kevin vote to approve Chris vote to approve John go to approve Sarah Burville I vote to approve Peter I vote to approve all right well good luck with your application good luck with your project thank you very much all right move out of this i've lost i've lost the tab or something maybe i'll just do all right we're moving to item three 30 pleasant hill road hey
[20:43] Speaker J (unidentified): my name is matt piercehall i'm the owner of premier builders and i'm here representing peter and maura fitch at 30 Pleasant Hill Road basically what this is there was a we're doing an addition you'll see in your packet I probably have the blueprints in there we're doing addition and there was a freestanding garage that was non-conforming and we made a mistake I misunderstood Justin when I went in and talked with him and we went and tore the garage down not knowing we needed to come in for approvals on this basically the garage was built in 1991 and it was set about where it shows on there I what I've done is as soon as I knew we had to come in and get approvals I went and got surveyed from bh2m and had them survey the property and pin where the old garage was and where the new one's going to be what we basically want to do is put the garage we had to pull the garage down because we're putting an addition on the house that is conforming that roof has to land on the garage and the old garage was on a slab we needed to put a four foot frost wall underneath it what we've done though is to make it sit right where it was that left rear corner of the garage we had to shorten the garage up from 24 feet to 22 feet I've got pictures in here that show the existing garage and where it's at and I've got surveys here from BH2M which I'd like to pass out to you guys which show the original and where it's going to be now I mean it's going to go right back the basic problem was the left-hand rear corner and the rear of the building was not within setbacks they were off by about a foot one foot four on the left hand side and about three and a half feet four feet on the rear of the garage so I've got surveys here's that depict where they were and where we're going to put the thing right back where the old garage was and so we're asking for approvals to rebuild that garage back where it wasn't the only issue is we're We're making it two feet shorter than the 24 feet that it was before due to the fact that it's got to make room for the mudroom on the right-hand side by the bulkhead there that we're adding.
[23:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Again, is there anyone in the room that's going to comment on this application? No. Do you want to hand us the information?
[23:51] Speaker J (unidentified): So the first page is basically showing the original house, the original garage. when Andy told me when he did this was he basically used a topographical thing we had a pin set right where we had taken the old garage out but he did a basically a topographical so he's kind of guessing where the garage was but if you turn to the second page what we're showing and these numbers are kind of hard to read but I wrote him in here for us the left rear corner is about 19 foot 19.7 inches from the setback i mean 19 feet seven inches from the from the sideline so it's about five inches six inches in from the setback which is i mean you don't want to make the garage any narrower because it's already 20 feet and we'll barely get a car in there now as it is with the mudroom that's in there and then you'll see on the backside that's a 36 foot 5 inches that right rear corner of the garage is 36 5 inches from the rear setback which is basically where it was before so basically what we're asking for is approvals to put it back where it was anything
[25:20] Speaker A (unidentified): else okay board members do have questions i have
[25:30] Speaker H (unidentified): a question reading the first page where it has the apparent location of the previous garage the lower left corner of the garage is clearly within the dash right and then on the next page on the next page thank you the proposed building is clearly outside of that area so they're not exactly in the same spot well like i said pete the
[25:59] Speaker J (unidentified): did this. I can't remember what he exactly told me, but he didn't have anything to go by except a topographical view of the property. And I can tell you that garage was a little farther out, but we're still at 36.5. I mean, all that stuff that I sent you guys is us. We found the four points of the corners, ran strings. You'll see measurements that we took but I wanted to make sure they were exactly correct for you guys when we came and did this so those numbers are what the numbers are and being that they're inside of the ten-foot contingent that you guys generally are a no-go by we're asking for you guys to let us go the way it is thank you any
[26:56] Speaker A (unidentified): other questions I have none Kevin Chris John all right I don't have any more questions so we will now is there anybody in the room that would like to speak on this application is there anyone on zoom who would like to speak on this application public comment period is now closed board discussion does anybody have any comments did you want to say something Justin I just want
[27:42] Speaker I (unidentified): to make clear for the record that and correct me if I'm wrong Matt on this It sounds like page one states the assumed based on aerial imaging. It sounds like the actual location of the garage was back from that aerial imaging assumption. And you are holding to the line of the previous structure. Exactly. Okay. I just wanted to clarify. Makes sense.
[28:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Even though the visual representation doesn't reflect that.
[28:14] Speaker I (unidentified): i wanted to yes clarify that at the very least i will make some notes on anything that comes in to
[28:20] Speaker H (unidentified): further validate that so page one was essentially a google earth or similar right where page two was actually field notes excellent that's i hope i understood it correctly that's correct okay
[28:35] Speaker A (unidentified): so i guess that goes to my question you have a rear setback of 35 5, 7, but page 2 shows 36, 7, rear setback.
[28:52] Speaker K (unidentified): Fair point.
[28:54] Speaker J (unidentified): Page 2 is 36, 5.
[28:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Excuse me, 36, 5. So I just want to make sure it's clear for the building permit where he's allowed to build to.
[29:02] Speaker I (unidentified): The better data, I'm assuming, is on page 2 of this rather than the previously submitted setback. No, thank you for the clarification.
[29:09] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Any other, any board discussion? All right. Would anyone like to make a motion?
[29:24] Speaker B (unidentified): My only question would be, is it worth setting a restriction on how close they can build towards the rear setback? Because ultimately, we're approving something outside of the building envelope. So, or would you say as presented? Typically, it's as presented. You could
[29:42] Speaker I (unidentified): certainly limited to the figure on the page if that's the comfort level unfortunately we're we're taking some yeah after the fact yeah so but you know otherwise that if you don't add it that's what my default would be as presented okay board
[30:03] Speaker A (unidentified): member like to make a motion i'll make a
[30:04] Speaker B (unidentified): motion to approve the request for conditional use under section 19-84 to tear down and rebuild a garage 30 Pleasant Hill Road as presented second that okay we'll start
[30:18] Speaker A (unidentified): with you Peter to approve I Sarah vote to approve John vote to approve Chris vote to approve Kevin go to proof okay good luck with your project thank you [Speaker J (unidentified): guys appreciate the] next agenda item non nine Providence Avenue tear down and rebuild of an existing garage and expansion of the garage to create an ad hello
[30:50] Speaker G (unidentified): my name is Joe Atwood I'm the property owner like you said what you're holding is an application to tear down an existing garage and expand it by the width by four feet to the interior of the lot and build an ad you on the second story it's part of a larger project which includes doing dormers on the primary, on the house. We made a bit of a mistake. I'll put most of the blame on my architect. But essentially, we didn't know that we had to apply to the Board of Zoning Appeals for the home and doing the dormers, that expansion. So we only submitted an application for the garage. And what I'm asking today is that you consider both as a part of this application because the dormers are by far the priority here we're looking to get those done first and we're fighting winner so I have some updated drawings that show both the adu and the dormer project together that I can pass out and then I have some details confirming our exact setbacks
[32:06] Speaker A (unidentified): for both structures Wow three applications in a row with submittal of new information hold on a sec is there anybody in the room who is intending on commenting on this particular application yes okay so we will need to share the new information with the gentleman in the rear as well anybody on zoom he
[32:43] Speaker I (unidentified): can have mine for now if you want yeah okay all
[33:05] Speaker G (unidentified): right so you'll need to take us through this packet if i can borrow one of your packets my last one good okay sorry so the plan set on the original application did show the primary structure and it showed the primary structure the house with the double dormers those are not there it's so this new plan set shows everything both the both the adu the expansion of the garage the expansion of that footprint and the addition of the adu on the second story and the full plan set for the double dormer so dormering out both sides of the roof so
[34:35] Speaker A (unidentified): anything else you want to add
[34:39] Speaker G (unidentified): i mean i'll defer to a lot of justin's comments where he feels that it's you know within the confines of 1977 1984 and sorry i won't read through all of his comments i'm sure you read them before but you know we're the setbacks on both the back and the sides are over 10 feet I think they're both 14 the setbacks on the front are I think 22 or something like that we're not obstructing anyone's view by doing the dormers we don't have water views you know there's quite a few structures in my neighborhood that have dormers just like this with similar setback issues the real issue here is that we didn't weren't aware that we had to submit a separate application and this project is a much bigger priority than what you're looking at for just the ADU so yeah I would ask that you know they'd be considered in tandem and I'd even be willing to just forget the ADU and just consider the dormers at this point all
[35:57] Speaker A (unidentified): right just we're taking a look at your new one yeah I know it's a lot of
[36:00] Speaker G (unidentified): information thank you board
[36:18] Speaker A (unidentified): members do you have questions I have a question for
[36:20] Speaker D (unidentified): the board and being completely sympathetic with the stresses that come with this sort of project is this recording of a meeting adequate enough to supply documentation since none of this is actually on the application can
[36:41] Speaker G (unidentified): i add something real quick we submitted a separate application for the dormers weeks ago and we only found out once the you know deadline had passed for this meeting that we needed to be in this meeting for the dormers so that application that permit has been submitted just not to the
[36:59] Speaker B (unidentified): Board of Zoning Appeals I think Chris's point is more that the information was not submitted publicly to allow potential the butters to comment about the additional information that's been presented tonight have we figured out
[37:11] Speaker H (unidentified): fulfilled our legal obligations yeah to even consider it all my neighbors are
[37:18] Speaker I (unidentified): where i have that with them but i think that question gets dicey the bigger the information submitted the night of the meeting is and i think that from a from a technical legal perspective this is a request for a modification of an existing we have seen applications submitted to the board that were simply under the wrong thing like variance versus conditional use that, there's a hard line at that. This is a version of a conditional use that has additional pieces. Frankly, when people come in for applications and they have two parts that might meet multiple pieces of the ordinance, I don't ask them to fill out multiple conditional use applications. So to answer your question, the risk that this application runs if you choose to accept and review new information, is the potential for repeal goes higher. Can you not approve it? I don't think there's anything hard and fast rule that you can't review this information and work with it. But, again, that potential risk goes up.
[38:25] Speaker E (unidentified): And if I'm not mistaken, the new information is actually shown in the application that's of record. It's just not shown as new. It's shown as existing, right? Yes.
[38:33] Speaker I (unidentified): If someone were to argue the point, there is no comment to it. there is no lines for setbacks it is not demonstrated but you're absolutely right it is shown in the elevation yeah shown
[38:51] Speaker A (unidentified): in the elevation but not in the actual
[38:52] Speaker I (unidentified): plans correct it is it is the rendering only I believe okay but I think to
[38:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Kevin's point to the extent that there was public notice of this project there
[39:04] Speaker I (unidentified): was some notice for sure and I think that again that's that's just a are potential higher risk of appeal. Right. Okay. Thank you. Are there any other questions
[39:16] Speaker A (unidentified): from board members? I have a question with respect to the proposed height. It appears to me that the proposed height of the ADU is going to be 11 feet. 11 feet 11.
[39:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Is that On the highest end, that seems correct, yes. And we did that salt box design to conform with the expansion standards.
[39:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you know, does it show what the height is with the dormers?
[39:57] Speaker G (unidentified): The height of the roof is not, I mean, the roof line is changing, but the peak of the roof is not.
[40:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Will also be 11-11. The main house? Yes, with the dormers.
[40:10] Speaker G (unidentified): no that's much that's higher than okay yeah as far as I know I mean yeah [Speaker C (unidentified): I'm] trying to figure out the height the height of the prime of the home is not changing the peak of the roof is staying exactly the same okay great thank you yeah all
[40:35] Speaker A (unidentified): right any other questions from the board all right is there it we will We'll move to public hearing. Is there anyone in the room that would like to comment on this application?
[41:06] Speaker L (unidentified): My name is Ronald Fabio.
[41:07] Speaker K (unidentified): I live at [address]. I support this project. End of story.
[41:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else in the room? Is there anyone on Zoom? We'll close the public hearing. Board discussion. I'm assuming everyone has no concerns.
[41:40] Speaker D (unidentified): I have no concerns. As long as it has been deemed acceptable that this satisfies everything that's necessary for public notice.
[41:53] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, as Justin pointed out, there is a bit of a risk of appeal where information was submitted late or past the deadline and potential lack of public notice. But that's sort of something that we have to weigh versus, you know, what we've seen for public comment on this proposal and the extent of the changes. But, yeah, it's a slippery slope.
[42:30] Speaker D (unidentified): I'll say judging from the lack of anybody against this particular I don't I think the risk is probably acceptable in my opinion however it might be a good exercise to go through what happens if it does go on appeal because it doesn't really it doesn't only affect the board it's going to affect the construction as well and possibly push that into unexpected delays yeah certainly if you
[43:01] Speaker I (unidentified): don't mind certainly potentially I think the mechanism if this application and it appears to meet the technical merits of the section reviewed under if someone were to say lack of notice and there was an appeal that was granted this item would effectively start over and come back to the board and you would review it with a fresh notice and you would look at probably the same information it is very much did the board have the right to make the decision and was the decision of merit and to the ordinance so it may restart and the application may come back i suspect you probably wouldn't come to a different result i'm
[43:49] Speaker H (unidentified): empathetic but i'm supportive and i probably shouldn't be or i shouldn't it should in fact you're in it should be more of a black and white technical but due to the time of the year and the in where you are in the production or the construction process it would be a significant delay to tighten this up although it's my preference to tighten it up like i said i'm empathetic to the project and where you are so personally i'm supportive of going forward even though it's not ideal i'm
[44:26] Speaker D (unidentified): in agreement i'm actually thinking what 's the best you know to protect the applicant hmm because that sounds good I don't know if it does get an appeal it's going to make it even worse than if we just
[44:47] Speaker B (unidentified): waited to I think a factual point is we're not here to protect the applicant we're here to evaluate the merits and requirements and to ensure meets the requirements all right
[45:05] Speaker A (unidentified): any other comment okay I'm wondering if we do we need two motions here one to accept the annuity sure if you wanted to be super safe I think so okay is there a motion does anyone like to make a motion to accept the new information I
[45:28] Speaker H (unidentified): make a motion to accept the new information is there a
[45:30] Speaker A (unidentified): second let's take a vote I'll start this time I see our verbal vote to approve accepting the new information John vote to approve Chris vote to approve Kevin approve Peter I vote to approve okay moving on does anyone want to make a motion with respect to approving the application so question on
[45:52] Speaker B (unidentified): that it would it be better to make two motions one for the teardown of the garage and one for the dormers and adu well the dormers because my concern is then that at least the one can proceed regardless of if the other one is appealed and if the other one's appealed it only applies to the dormers i
[46:14] Speaker I (unidentified): don't know i'm not an attorney i'm sorry i would love to jump in and give my opinion on that but i am not sure that voting on them separately gets past the fact that they are technically one application does one save the other if
[46:28] Speaker A (unidentified): it's appealed I don't know wouldn't hurt I would prefer to proceed as this is one project okay does anyone want to make a motion with respect to the
[46:44] Speaker D (unidentified): substance of the application I'll make a motion to approve the conditional use application under 1984 for the property located at 9 Providence Avenue structural tear down and rebuild as well as the additional information that was provided tonight let's
[47:09] Speaker A (unidentified): clarify that the motion to say tear down and rebuild of the garage action and installation of dormers as presented I was see if I
[47:21] Speaker D (unidentified): remember that I'd like to make a motion to approve the conditional use application under 1984 for the property located at 9 Providence Avenue the structural tear down and rebuild of the garage and ADU as well as the dormer the additional dormers second
[47:43] Speaker A (unidentified): okay largely correct okay we'll start with you Thank you, Kevin. Vote to approve. Chris. Vote to approve. John. Vote to approve. Aye, Sarah. Vote to approve. Peter. I vote to approve. Good luck with the project. Okay. We're going to move on to Item 5, 21 Underwood Road, Alexa Dayton, request for conditional use approval to expand a structure.
[48:24] Speaker M (unidentified): Great. Please proceed. Hi. Hi. Thank you so much for entertaining my request this evening. it's good to see you all. Alexa Dayton, the owner at 21 Underwood Road. As previously reviewed by this board, I am back to you for a third time. I would say I enjoyed it so much, but no, really, we ran into delays in proceeding with the project last year. Again, cost increases and other personal reasons. We really didn't get going with detail planning, again, until this August. And in going forward with detail planning with my builder, we, again, really studied deeply what we have before you today. And I'm so close to putting in a building permit application, I can taste it. And in doing so, one of the things, well, A, we ran out of time. so I was going to be before you anyway to make sure that we were still within the boundary of an approved BZA application but in working with the builder one of the things we recognized was there's one modification that we wanted to make to ensure we didn't go over what you had previously approved in terms of the allowable height so the packet before you is essentially the same packet of prior two rounds and on the application now I've noted that once we build the proposed structure which is 25 foot 10 inches from the beginning of the ground floor to the peak of the roof and we place it on the existing foundation which as you know sits on a hill and so we have different starting elevations on either side of the building and equally the starting elevation is actually not three, but a fourth step up and in once you get through the sunken living room. So as we really reevaluated very carefully our starting elevation, and then with the very detailed drawings that show the 25 foot 10 inches on top of that, we are really close to 29 foot 10 inches and so the proportions of what you see have not changed what we saw on our site visit and talked about has not changed it's just the drawing now reflects that amended starting elevation to ensure we don't actually go over what you allowed which was originally 28 feet So we're amended to 30 feet. That is still within the allowable 35-foot height from what I understand of the regulations. And we just want to make sure that the packet that we hope you'll approve tonight is as buttoned up and as tight as we possibly can. And hopefully that will allow us to get through building a permit application here in the next month and actually proceed with the project this winter into spring. and we'd like to get the project done before the sidewalk improvement project starts on Underwood Road next summer. So that is my pitch and review of the packet. I welcome questions, and again, thank you again for being here tonight and serving.
[51:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Questions from the board?
[51:49] Speaker B (unidentified): A couple things. Thanks.
[51:52] Speaker D (unidentified): Your explanation or your presentation, I don't think I can hear myself, your presentation mentions that there was a glitch, I think, in measuring. Is that what explains the difference between the original presentation, which was at 11 feet for the original building, and now it is measured at 14? Because it looks like it grew three feet.
[52:15] Speaker M (unidentified): Yeah, exactly. It's where it starts. And so we measured it originally standing inside to the pinnacle. And if you now take into account the elevation, the average grade, again, it's on a very substantive hill. That's where the difference is coming in.
[52:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Is the chimney not part of this measurement?
[52:37] Speaker M (unidentified): measurement the chimney is the dotted line chimney is a proposed chimney
[52:46] Speaker D (unidentified): extension wouldn't my height be based on that I'm
[52:53] Speaker I (unidentified): looking it up right now but I believe chimneys are one of the exemptions okay give me a moment other
[53:02] Speaker A (unidentified): questions from the board one of my questions would be when we reviewed the application in november of 2024 and we did do a sitewalk visit and we were inside the home of your up your butter above you yeah and we were able to make an assessment of you know what we thought the impact of view would be are you saying that with this revised elevation it would be the same impact in other words okay so it's not like it's a higher roof it's just you're
[53:45] Speaker M (unidentified): starting from a different point that's true there is no change to the impact to amy and lance's
[53:51] Speaker A (unidentified): lance meters property from this amendment okay thank you and have you been in touch with any of the abutters with respect to this application i live in the neighborhood now i have done
[54:08] Speaker M (unidentified): done my best to keep my neighbors informed and they continue to support it. I don't know that anyone is here to speak against it, but probably because I've been in touch with them along the
[54:18] Speaker A (unidentified): way. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions from the board? Okay. Okay. Thank you. We will open up the public comment period. Is there anyone in the room who would like to speak with respect to this application okay is there anyone on zoom no all right public comment period is closed discussion by the board well
[54:55] Speaker E (unidentified): i don't have the benefit of the 2024 sidewalk but i have no concerns
[55:02] Speaker A (unidentified): i also don't have any concerns i mean we're approving the same proposal that we've approved twice now and hopefully she'll be able to get to her project constructed anybody else Okay, would anyone like to make a motion?
[55:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Make a motion to approve the request for conditional use under section 19-77 to expand a structure at 21 Underwood Road.
[55:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. All right, any discussion on the motion? All right, we'll start with you, Chris. How do you vote? Vote to approve. Peter? I vote to approve. John? Vote to approve. Kevin? Approve. I approve as well, Sarah Verville. Good luck with your project. Hope it goes forward this time. [Speaker F (unidentified): so] before we move on to the next application i think it's gonna probably take a little bit longer than the ones we've just reviewed would the board like to take two or three minute break okay thank you we're going to take a break before getting started all right we're going to get started again next agenda item 241 a four-side road michael coin request for conditional use approval under section 19119 to construct a single family dwelling okay welcome back thank you
[1:03:04] Speaker K (unidentified): michael coin representing the applicant with archetype architects i think we all know the project so i'll give sort of a brief overview on you know the general scope of the project but mostly here to talk about updates since our last hearing and meeting here so again we're looking for single family residents on an existing legally established non-conforming lot it's a conditional use approval within the water view overlay district so we are here today for that purpose the design does meet all required setbacks lot coverage requirements and it respects the deeded buffer and view easement imposed on the lot so moving from the last board meeting there were a number of topics that were discussed and questions and concerns raised by the board so at that time we chose to regroup and obviously our last application was withdrawn so we've taken that time within the application packet this round it was page three it was sort of a cover letter that generally overviewed the updated elements within the application via design or further information that was submitted within this application so I'll look to sort of speak to those changes as just a general overview. So leaving the meeting last time, the biggest sort of concern and question was meeting and coordinating with the neighbors. Obviously, the view overlays are one of the bigger elements of or topics of discussion through this process. So that was sort of our first step and why we wanted to withdraw our application to give ourselves adequate time to try and set that meeting up. Throughout the process, in our last meetings, the abutters did make note and reach out that they were willing to engage in a conversation with us. So after our withdrawn application, we did reach out to try and set up that meeting. They did voice that they would like to see a materially different application presented to them that they felt met the zoning ordinances prior to meeting with us. so we took it upon ourselves to go through the previous objection letters and use that as kind of creating a template or milestones for us to look at a redesign on our own and then present that to them so kind of taking the first step to coordinate with them so we use and all of that documentation is supplied in the application that we submitted so we use those objection letters and the concerns raised by the butters to try to either implement design changes or inform more decisions, be it construction management narratives and plans, information on erosion, grading, drainage, those types of things. So we did end up supplying them with an updated design. The building got scaled down. The building was decreased by 10 feet in length, so successfully pulling our end of edge of building back from that sort of water view overlay zone as an effort to really preserve that core view to the water from the abutters so with that meeting we were able to sit down and discuss where we were with our design it also gave us the opportunity to understand from them which views were important through their properties that allowed us the opportunity to take those photographs and do the overlay studies which is one thing that has been lacking through all of the applications even the ones prior to our involvement so with that we did ask them to give us some information or direction on which views were important from them so they did give us various views and those were the photographs we used for the overlay studies that were submitted in the application in this round would direct sort of direction from the actual butters so in addition to the redesign design and the overlay studies. We did want to just give a comparison on our good faith effort to try to reduce the volume of the house. We understood the, you know, we recognize that building anything in a unbuilt lot will have view impacts. We're not trying to deny that. We are just trying to present a design that we feel meets the ordinance and adheres to the requirements regarding views and as the ordinance states you know it's compatible with a general neighborhood regarding scale design and bulk of the proposed structure and it does not have significant adverse effect on water views so we feel that we're hitting those marks you know we are not beholden to no impact of views but we are trying to be respectful to the important views use by meeting with the abutters but also providing a design on this property that it makes sense you know it has to have some value to it the more we condense and consolidate that design the project just becomes infeasible and we end up getting to a point where we have an unbuildable lot so what we did was we took the initial design i believe it was 2004 24 that was submitted our intermediate design and the new design and we did a volumetric and size study in this application with that study you can see the overall scale and volume of the house today from the first submission was about 17% in reduction in volume and size and a 6% reduction from the intermediate design so we've continued to try to scale this down in an effort to preserve views and be respectful of the scale of this property to adjacent properties and as I mentioned before the intermediate design which we first submitted was within the bounds of the property setbacks and overlay zone we've now further pulled that building back ten feet from that view overlay easement that's on the property so effectively increasing that view corridor in addition to the design changes those overlay studies and supporting documents we've also provided a construction management plan which was talked about with the board we did provide that to the town who shared that with local fire department and emergency services that plan essentially outlines sort of a standard operating procedure for the duration of construction that can be enforced by the town and fire department and local emergency services it looks to sort of address the concerns we understand it's a small road it's in it aims to identify how materials are being handled whether they're on-site or deliveries how construction vehicles are being addressed parked brought into the site left the site and how that road is being preserved for the duration of construction temporarily as the structure would be built it also discusses measures to address emergency services if there is any street work happening that would impact old powerhouse road that would be coordinated with the town and emergency services and provisions would be made that could be addressed in the event of something happening so again it's a lengthy document these have all been submitted the goal is to try to create some type of standard that the contractor can be held to that everybody feels comfortable with in addition to that drainage and erosion was one of the questions that were brought up, so we've also provided that report. I think it's important that we continue to look back to what the ordinance requires of us. There's been a lot of concern with existing groundwater issues within this whole neighborhood. What we are tasked to do is provide sufficient evidence that our project, which again is a single-family home within a neighborhood of single-family homes does not have negative impact or create issues with flood, erosion, drainage, grading, that sort of thing. So the report discusses how standard construction elements address stormwater, roof water, runoff from driveways, how we are managing collecting all that stormwater, similar to that foundation, grading, drainage, all of those elements. and then there's you know standard procedures for construction to avoid erosion while construction is happening those are all permit elements they're all mandated and addressed and enforced through construction we would not deviate from anything the report also does go into elements that we can explore if we do come up with groundwater issues again the back of the site which we're not building on has been the main topic of concern so we have discussed with different civil engineers on different elements and technical infrastructure that could be incorporated into the plan but again at this point we don't have a full civil set document we don't have an approved project we don't have a permitted project we are beholden to provide information that outlines we do not have a negative impact to flood erosion grading those elements you know if approved and through the permit process full civil plans and all of those details would be accompanied with our construction drawings that would be reviewed and approved by the town and lastly the property value we've given a property value from a licensed assessor as well as a local broker and just their opinions, all of that documentation has been provided in the application submitted and they have gone and done comps on adjacent properties and the history of properties and new construction and have sort of deemed through their review that there are no significant adverse effects through us and our proposal taking into consideration like the view studies and the scale and compatibility and size of the home with the adjacent properties. With that, I think it sort of covers all of the new elements and the questions that were brought up by the board. Again, what we're looking to do is try to progress this process. We heard the concerns of the board. We have heard the concerns of the abutters. We have made the efforts to try to meet with them and understand more what we can do to help try to bridge that gap i think we've gotten as far down that road as we're going to get i don't think that we're going to find more alignment and at the end of the day the goal here is to adhere to the ordinance you know i fear there becomes a precedent now of more involvement from outside sources and deviating away from the actual ordinances that we are required to prove and provide so we just ask that the board takes into consideration our application against the actual conditional use requirements as they review it group would
[1:14:27] Speaker N (unidentified): like to speak is
[1:14:28] Speaker A (unidentified): that it yeah because this is the applicants opportunity to speak so if there's any additional presentation by the applicant it should be done now okay
[1:14:37] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay, thank you. I think we're good. Okay, thank you.
[1:14:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Board members, does anyone want to start with, does anyone have questions? I'm happy to start. Go ahead. So this is a question to the applicant if you want to stand to the podium. As you saw, there are several comments in opposition to the new plan. I do appreciate the significant efforts that you have made with respect to revisions. I have a couple of questions for you that came up as a result of my review of the different public comments submitted. And they mostly relate to the view. So, I think it's with respect to abutter A, which I think is the Keppelmans, they contend that they have views from the basement, the first floor, and the second floor, if I understand that correctly. Yes. Okay. So, does your viewshed analysis show view impacts to all three of those views? I could not find that in the application yes so that would be so under the
[1:16:14] Speaker K (unidentified): overlay study we have so the initial plan we submitted the overlay study should have taken all three I don't know if I have everything printed out but
[1:16:34] Speaker A (unidentified): under I also note by the way that there's a potential mislabeling so when we're looking at the overlay view shed plan, you've got a butter A, but then highlighted in red, but then the side photo.
[1:16:57] Speaker K (unidentified): I see it says a butter B. A butter B.
[1:16:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm assuming these are a butter A views? Yes, correct. Okay.
[1:17:02] Speaker K (unidentified): So this first one, and so these two views are taken from the first floor and also the basement. the second floor view was submitted under previous applications that i don't believe
[1:17:14] Speaker A (unidentified): made it into this package okay so there's nothing in this package about the second floor view when
[1:17:19] Speaker K (unidentified): we met with the abutter they gave us these two primary views as the views that they would like to see the view overlays taken from so that is what we have submitted in this application okay,
[1:17:35] Speaker A (unidentified): with respect to view overlays for a butter sea, which I think is Ms. Oakley, the view shed photos show full foliage. I'm just curious whether there was any simulations of when there is no foliage.
[1:18:13] Speaker K (unidentified): You mean with the tree foliage and surrounding? yes no we do not have any simulation for no foliage okay a
[1:18:25] Speaker A (unidentified): butter see provides photos of water views from other areas of the house that I don't believe that the applicant included overlays so I'm just curious I think it's a butter sees second floor bedrooms showed views we did not
[1:18:47] Speaker K (unidentified): have access to the inside of their property okay so when we met we told them we would take photos from their first floor exterior deck and the side of the house where there are currently windows but we did not gain access
[1:18:59] Speaker A (unidentified): inside of their property is there technology out there such as drone or lidar where you would have been able to simulate those views we could get a
[1:19:07] Speaker K (unidentified): drone I think I would still need the appropriate permission from the land owner to fly a drone and take those photographs okay thank you I
[1:19:22] Speaker A (unidentified): think that's all my questions at the moment do any other board members have questions okay thank you thank you all right we're gonna move to public comment period John do you want to act as timer thank you can
[1:20:11] Speaker O (unidentified): you hear me have a little bit of a laryngitis. I'm going to make it through this though. Okay. You're going to be my Vanna.
[1:20:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Given that you only have three minutes, I would ask that you highlight your most important objections or comments that you want to make because we do have your written submittals as well. Okay.
[1:21:08] Speaker O (unidentified): I'm Sandy Kerpelman and I live at [address], a direct abutter behind 241 A Forsyth Road. I am here tonight to address the request for a conditional use permit for property in the Waterview Overlay District. Section 19-119E asks one fundamental question. Will this project have a significant adverse impact on Waterview's from adjacent properties? The burden of proof falls entirely on the applicant and they have failed to meet it. The application is factually deficient. Requirement 5 mandates an elevation overlay study, which was not provided. Instead, the applicant submission consists of two unscaled, unmeasured images taken from our basement and second floor, completely ignoring our main first floor living space. So with that, please refer to the chart on the left, which shows you that greater than 75% of our water view would be gone with this new construction. To get an objective measurement of our view impact, we hired ViewShed, an independent engineering firm based in Yarmouth. Using LIDAR projections, GIS spatial mapping, and the applicant's own scaled architectural drawings overlaid on his scaled survey, ViewShed calculated the exact impact. These images taken from the ViewShed report show our view from the first floor today contrasted with our view with the proposed house in place. The objective result, this project will cause a 75% total obstruction of our view to the bay. The full viewshed report is in Appendix A of our objection letter. Now, kindly refer to the chart on the right. Here we show that the applicant's photos directly contradict the Owen Haskell survey he included in his application. The entire view study the applicant submitted consists only of the image on the upper left. Not only is it an invalid view study, but it's also misleading in that it contradicts the applicant's own survey and site plan as evident on the right side. The photo the applicant provided suggests the construction barely enters our view corridor, whereas survey clearly shows that the corridor narrows sharply. This is further confirmed by the view shed rendering on the bottom left. When Photoshop pictures contradict a scaled survey and a proper engineering analysis, the survey and engineering study win. win. Furthermore, the applicant admits in the application that this submission does not reflect final construction calculations. He is essentially asking the Board for a blank check to deviate later. Look, a 75 percent view obstruction is the very definition of a significant adverse impact. I respectfully ask the Board to deny this application. Thank
[1:24:19] Speaker A (unidentified): you. Thank you very much.
[1:24:38] Speaker L (unidentified): Dan Kerpelman, also 10 Powerhouse Road. This is the sixth time the projects come before the board, yet the application still doesn't sufficiently demonstrate compliance with town law. Sanity show non-compliance with condition 19119E on water views, and I'll address 19119D on neighboring property values, also supported by expert analysis. The applicant's own appraisal says views only carry a premium when they're legally protected. Well that's exactly our situation. The Water View Overlay District and the Conditional Use Standards legally protect our views from significant adverse impact and RE Max by the Bay also emphasized these protections when they sold us the property late last year. Because the application offers insufficient objective evidence, we commissioned LM them appraisals licensed experienced appraisers to provide it their full report is an appendix B of our objection letter and is summarized in the leftmost chart the chart compares recent comparable sales within a few miles of our home and group them by water view on the left in gray our properties with no water view of the bay in the middle and blue our seasonal or partial views of the bay in the center, and on the right are comparable properties with significant year-round views such as ours in green. The graph shows the average property values for each grouping. This project would drop our home from the top category on the right to the middle one, and at an average of $105 less per square foot, that is a loss of over $300,000 to our home alone based on the latest sale prices. Add 12 Old Powerhouse Road and 241 Forsyth Road and the neighborhood's aggregate loss is significantly greater yet. A very specific example is the case depicted in the rightmost chart comparing 10 Old Powerhouse Road and 239A Forsyth Road. As you can see in the upper right, these are identical adjoining condos, built at the same time, and they sold one month apart in late 2025. However, ours sold for $240,000 more. The difference? The view. As the chart shows, we have six to ten times more visible water measured from the same vantage point of each house, thus the $240,000 premium at risk. In conclusion, although the burden of proof is on the applicant, it has not been met. In its place, we've provided to the best of our ability objective professional evidence that this project would block 75% of the view from our main living space, as Sandy showed, and cost us over $300,000 of property value, as I've shown, with further harm to our neighbors. The application is not compliant, and I also respectfully request that the Board deny it. Finally, at the July meeting, Chair Verville, you mentioned concern for the owners' ability to realize a return on their investment. As such, we've communicated to the current owners that if the existing contingent offer should fall through for any reason, we'd buy the lot. This would afford them a reasonable return on their investment while protecting our neighbors and ours. Thank you for your service to the community.
[1:28:23] Speaker P (unidentified): I'm Elizabeth Oakleaf, owner of 12 Old Powerhouse Road. My home is the closest to 241A. I'm only going to speak to one point because it's the most important one, which is my water views. I have the same corridor that the Kerpelmans do at a slighter angle. The views are smaller. I've not claimed I have sweeping views, but I do have water views, and the ordinance doesn't say anything about the size of the views. And I also want to say that Mr. Coyne said that he didn't have access to my house. At the end of the meeting on September 16th, the group of us were there. They asked me if I would give them permission. I said yes. They didn't ask me what pictures to take. I went home waiting for them to knock on my door. They never knocked on my door. They didn't make that choice. They took pictures from the outside of the house where they chose to take pictures. And in my objection, I showed the pictures that I would like to have them look at. and this one is from off of our patio which you've seen before and so I do have water views and I think that taking pictures of from my lot of minimal or no water views doesn't prove that I don't have water views they're just taking pictures from there they wanted to so I don't believe there haven't been any overlays from my house I use the overlays they did from ten to kind of show. I put arrows in showing an angle of the water views that I have. So it really hasn't been done at all. So it looks to me from what the Kerpelmans did that they're going to completely eliminate my view, as has always been the case. And I understand that some views, we all understand that we're not going to have 100 percent of our views. But the ordinance doesn't say it says substantial. So if they're eliminating my views, it's substantial. So they're not complying in terms of my house with you know 119 e and i agree with what they're saying about the appraisals and sort of other things one other thing i did talk to them about was drainage my the side of my house and i talked to them about at the meeting on september 16th i have basement grade windows that are 10 feet from the property line and i would just like some assurances that water isn't going to back up and flood my basement when they're when they're building and afterwards and they've not addressed that either so i'll leave it at that
[1:30:44] Speaker A (unidentified): for today thank you thank you very much good
[1:30:56] Speaker Q (unidentified): evening my name is matthew guida 241 foreside road speaking on behalf of my family my wife two children i'm just going to make three points that directly impact us first i had submitted information on shadows and how that impacts property value and the applicant did include some study however only showed 9 a.m and noon and at 9 and noon this the sun is in the south east and the south and my windows face northwest so there's no chance that shadow at that time would ever enter those windows conveniently second as Betsy mentioned drainage my property is downhill from this one my property when it rains heavily has sometimes up to an inch of groundwater in the basement in places in the basement not the full thing but the applicants document says the final system will be refined through civil engineering during the permitting phase and I feel it so the board is being asked to find there won't be drainage problems without a real drainage design plan third this is in my written objection but the much of the information on the history of this property i feel is mischaracterized misrepresented and i'll just leave it at that as others mentioned we're not asking the board to punish anyone we're asking it to hold the application to the standard the ordinance sets affirmative findings on complete evidence on this record those findings can't be made due to the numerous times this has been tabled the numerous applications and ample time for the applicant to come up with a proposal which actually meets the ordinances we ask that you deny the application thank you thank you next.
[1:33:01] Speaker N (unidentified): Oscar Pena, 239A Foreside Road, a Butter Bee. We bought the house last year, and at that time, the view easement was signed in as part of the sale. Page 82 of the packet, or 25 of their application, shows two large yellow boxes that would be in direct violation of the view easement as well as a potential temporary construction fence which i believe could also be argued to be in violation so i just asked the board to that our view easement is respected my family and i spend a lot of time on that front lawn and would like to continue enjoying that. Okay.
[1:34:03] Speaker L (unidentified): Hello again. I'm Paul Richards. I'm Betsy's husband, 12-0 Powerhouse Road. I couldn't help but notice that the Hanleys had to have their attorney write a three-page letter correcting the numerous factual errors and inconsistencies in this latest submission, which is effectively the same submission submitted two years ago. He cast aspersions on the motivations and legitimacy of the concerns of the neighbors, while trivializing the Hanleys' role in creating their problem. The Hanleys purchased the property with full knowledge of the obligations and restrictions of conditional use. They chose to further encumber the property for their sole benefit and now want to avoid having to adhere to ordinance provisions which may limit their financial gain. And I'd like to reference Michael Coyne's comment about the project they're presenting would not be, it would be unfeasible, read economically unfeasible. None of the neighbors object to a conforming development, but that's not what had been put before you.
[1:35:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there anybody else in the room that would like to comment?
[1:35:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Good evening. Marjorie Goetz, 33 Old Powerhouse Road. When I practiced law, whenever there was controversy, we considered the intent of the words that were used in the law or the ordinance. And the question was just always asked, what was the intent of the ordinance? For background, I've lived on Old Powerhouse for 33 years. So I've also used the road regularly for over 50 years because I'm the longest standing member of the Portland Yacht Club. In fact, beginning in 1979, I was legal counsel for the Yacht Club, and I handled all their right-of-way issues on Old Powerhouse Road and their real estate issues. And so I don't think it's an exaggeration to say that I'm probably the one in this room that knows more about the history of that road than anybody else. So when the applicant's attorney said that this has been long recognized as a separate lot, that's just factually incorrect. He really doesn't know what he's talking about there. there. He also, as Paul Richards mentioned, stated that our objections are self-serving. I can't see this piece of property from my home. I don't have frontage on old Powerhouse Road, so it's—I'm not here for that. I'm here solely because I believe ordinances exist for a reason, and I believe that they ought to be upheld. And the key issue here, even though it keeps—the applicant keeps referring to this as having been a buildable lot or a building lot, it was really the backyard of what's now Mr. Guida's home. And the former owner of Mr. Guida's home, who was using the property solely as a short-term rental, carved out that lot during that brief three-year period of ill-considered zoning changes that were almost immediately seen as flawed and were quickly repealed by the town council. The citizens of Falmouth spoke out and rejected that zoning at a public hearing at the elementary school. in February 2019. Nearly 100% of the citizens there spoke out for repeal. 900 more people signed a petition calling for a repeal of that dense zoning in the RA district to end, and the town council unanimously voted to repeal it on May 29, 2019. In fact, the council has found that squeezing such houses in on such inappropriate lots had historically not been that had historically not been built there was really abhorrent and that in that they made the repeal of the law retroactive the town council recognized at that time that this that ordinance that had been in place for such a short period of time was really not working and was doing real harm to the communities that it was being applied in so I feel that there's really a moral responsibility here, an ethical responsibility to the citizens of the town that soundly rejected this law that was in place for less than three years and the principles that were expressed by the leaders in the town council and uphold their intentions at the time that they repealed the ordinance that made that law severable at that time. So I think that, you know, just be sure to consider the intent behind the zoning rules, what the town council's intent was when they voted to disallow the building on these kinds of lots. And I do want to just recognize that, you know, we've all made investment mistakes. Can you wrap it up? You're well over the three minutes. Okay. Thank you. In that case, I'll just thank you for your time. And I hope that you'll consider what I've said. Thank you very much.
[1:39:16] Speaker R (unidentified): Good evening. I'll try and be brief. Andrew Drew Sawyer. I'm at 243 Forsyth Road. I'm in a butter. I don't have view easement issues. I am also the treasurer of the Portland Yacht Club. I just make the comment to the committee here that the Portland Yacht Club has experienced projects on old powerhouses in the past. All the construction vehicles come down the road. They go all the way down to the bottom and they turn around in the Portland Yacht Club parking lot. The road is falling apart. Our parking lot is falling apart and it becomes problematic. So the Portland Yacht Club has great concerns about more construction projects, particularly long-duration projects as we come into boating season next summer.
[1:40:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else in the room?
[1:40:11] Speaker S (unidentified): Good evening. David Banks from Remax by the Bay Real Estate. A little back history, when the property sold just beyond this lot they received an extra buffer because they knew that was a buildable lot. So when that family bought that property, they knew a property that was a buildable lot and something could be built there. So a consideration was made in that transaction to give an extra ten foot setback. so just one comment i want to mention history here there was a very large hedge which i have a picture of i think it's been passed in it this hedge was probably eight or nine feet high that limited the opposite the left inside of this buildable lot for some of their water views that hedge was taken down by the previous owner and everyone got used to the wide open views and The limitation of that hedge went away. When this property was going to be built on previously, all the neighbors had come to a verbal agreement they were going to buy it so it would never be built on. The day of closing, one of the neighbors in the blue house beyond the lot changed their mind, and then everyone else said we can't make up the difference. and the handlers went ahead and bought the lot because it was a situation on that day of closing they had backed out. There have been many discussions in the past that the neighbors could buy it, and nothing we built there. Just leave it as open space, and no one proceeded with that opportunity. What's very difficult is I've been involved in every transaction. Everyone knew, the two sales that happened that we talked about, the difference of the $250,000. The original, the developer, the Richards, excuse me, Betsy and Paul. Their unit was much better than the unit on the other side, and so, and I know my-
[1:42:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Excuse me, are you advocating on behalf of the applicant? applicant? Yes. Okay. The applicant had its opportunity, which I mentioned at the beginning of the hearing, to present.
[1:42:47] Speaker S (unidentified): I'm talking from the public then. Okay. Okay. But I want to clarify, they say that they're losing money. The appraisal came out over there asking price. We were the brokers on it we priced it that way knowing something could happen there part of the contract was do you do diligence do you review and there's no dispute that they had that time to do it they chose to go forward and the quality of the construction on their unit was much better that are more finished space in the basement, just it was a much higher kitchen. Everything was bathrooms, so I just want to clarify that. The reason it cost, it was difference in price mainly was the upgrade to the unit. So, thank you very much.
[1:43:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else in the room like to comment? Okay, I don't have a very good view of, okay. Okay. So it looks like there's one hand raised to comment. All right. Can Sharon promote her? Okay. Charlotte, are you muted? Can you hear me? If you could speak a little louder, please.
[1:44:18] Speaker T (unidentified): Hello? Okay. Thank you. We can hear you. Hi. I'm Charlotte Ryan. I'm Oscar Pena's wife at 239A foresight. I just want to clarify, and hopefully you all saw this in the various documentation, that we have evidence footage that those hedges came down in 2021. And so the notion that the view should be, the consideration of those views should be made based on hedges that were gone long before the sales of our homes. I hope you would consider that in your review as something
[1:44:50] Speaker A (unidentified): that should not be warranted okay thank you very much is there anyone else on zoom who would like to comment on 241 a four-side road no okay public comment period is now closed okay who would like to start nobody I know okay I will first of all I just want to say I appreciate all the public commenters respecting our time limits I appreciate that it doesn't always happen and I also appreciate the conduct of everybody within this public meeting because sometimes when there is controversy it does not go quite as smoothly so I just want to thank you all for your respect for everybody's opinions and for the board and I also want to thank the applicant for putting forth a revised proposal and a very thorough job in trying to address all of the comments that have been raised over the past couple years so I let's see I think what I'm going to do is start out by focusing on the adverse impacts on water views. And as we know, the project cannot have a significant adverse impact on water views from adjacent and nearby properties and public's rights of way. way. I will say that I find the information as far as when the hedge was removed is frankly irrelevant. We are dealing here today with the views that exist today. And with respect to these views, there will now be a, those views exist and they existed when these owners bought their properties and so really the question is you know not whether they had a view before but what they have now there is a lot of conflicting evidence I think both in the in the application versus the commenters as to exactly what the impact of views are I'm having a hard time really being able to figure out how significant the impact to the view is with respect to abutters a and a butter c the burden of proof is on the applicant to provide that and i don't find complete information in the record addressing all of the water views that could or could not be impacted affected. With respect to significant result in significant flood hazards or flood damage drainage problems, ground or surface water contamination or soil erosion, I don't find that there will be result in significant flood hazards, flood damage drainage problems I mean there are already drainage problems with respect to old powerhouse Road and there's no question that the addition of additional new impervious surface can exacerbate what is already a problem I don't I don't see anything in the record that shows me that there would be a significant increase in what is already an existing problem so that so that criteria does not concern me as much as others with respect to construction impacts you know we were with that goes to both be but criteria B and not B sorry with criteria C a significant detrimental effect on the use and peaceful enjoyment of a broadening property as a result of noise, vibrations, fumes, odor, dust, light, or glare. When you take into construction and significant hazard, also criterion F, significant hazards to pedestrian or vehicular traffic or significant traffic congestion, I know that the construction impacts although incredibly annoying will be temporary I don't find it quite as concerning that a complete construction impact analysis or I should say construction plan has been presented because it's a little somewhat premature for that because the required the drawings needed for a building permit I think, would need to be developed, and at that point, it's when the construction details become more laid down. Having said that, I do know that the applicant is going to have to exercise extreme surveillance, oversight over the contractors, because often what's in the plans, we've all experienced it with construction projects, between subcontractors, workers, et cetera, that communication can often fall apart. And so I urge the applicant that its plan contains more than the ordinary construction oversight. site and then with respect to will not have a significant adverse effect on adjacent or nearby property values again there's conflicting evidence and given that there's conflicting evidence and I'm having a hard time assessing the whether the impact on water views is significant it's very hard to at the same time then be able to assess the significant impact the impact on values on adjacent property values so right now my leaning is that i would vote to deny based on adverse impacts at minimum to water views and probably to property values so
[1:52:09] Speaker E (unidentified): sarah i agree with much of what you said i think the only point where i am less persuaded is on the property values it does seem to me that based on what's in the record properties likely trade i mean this has been a known buildable lot for a number of years at this point so i would have to assume that was taken into account by the market when those properties traded the view is difficult because there is conflicting evidence i will say looking at some of the materials presented by both the applicant and the public i am concerned that if you i'm not sure how you develop this lot without a impact to view of course then the question is how significant some of the materials suggest it would be very difficult if near impossible to develop this lot which i don't think you know going back to the comment about the intent i if it was intended to be a buildable lot, it seems to me you ought to be able to build on it. So I'm struggling with that piece of it.
[1:53:12] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I agree with Kevin to that aspect. I mean, it's not the applicant's fault that the town created a lot, the town set the setbacks, the town ultimately determined that is a buildable lot. So if you were to build anything on that lot, you are going to have some impact, and most likely an adverse impact, to the water views that are there present now. to say otherwise would then say that it's not a buildable lot because even if you were to build a single-story house the entire length you're still going to have a substantive impact to the water views so it either is it's a buildable lot or it's not but no matter what you build on that you're going to have an adverse impact to some point to the views and that like kevin said that's been known for some time is regardless of whether the town council reversed this and so forth and said you can no longer subdivide lots and create that I mean the fact remains this lot still does exist it has a buildable envelope and it is set I think that the view aspect even the way it's written within the guidance I mean it is it is completely subjective I mean there is no delineation as to what is a substantive impact it's not like they define a percentage they don't define a it's it's completely subjective to those that are evaluating it to a person that doesn't have a view I mean it's irrelevant to those that have a full view I mean carving out 10% may be a substantive impact so it's all it's it's it's a tough position to be in I
[1:54:50] Speaker H (unidentified): would agree I think it's a buildable lot if it was not geographically where it is if it was on the west side of Falmouth or someplace else that we didn't have water views it would be a perfectly fine line it would be built on but we do have the ordinance and we do have that protection for those residents I thought the site visit was very insightful there was clearly you would have adverse impact on water views for some of those particular butters and consistency is what I lean on during my brief tenure here three years with water views and that is it's how much of an impact is it on your water view so if you have a vast water view and we've seen some that people have enjoyed vast water views and they lost some of those and we've approved those because it was not substantial or significant they still retain good water views but if you only have a six percent view and you lose all six percent that is significant and it is our job to help, in my opinion, promote development, not be an obstacle to development, but also we need to protect people who have developed previously. My feelings when I saw that lot was it's going to be extremely difficult for anyone to build on this. The only way that it would happen is through the cooperation of the neighbors. And we've seen that before where some neighbors have acquiesced, if you will, and said for whatever reason i support this and it's gone through and i think that may be the only path that i see other than build building underground which no one wants to do but right now i feel that my greater responsibility is to protect those people who've already invested and protect those water views and then and personally at this point i just don't see how i could support this going forward seeing that the impact that i saw on at least two or three units that were rebutters. Well,
[1:56:59] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm just going to pretty much mirror what everyone else said. And just to put a little finer point on it, being a buildable lot, things like construction headaches, unfortunately, are just the way it's going to be. Obviously, you can't have people using horse-drawn carriage. so the biggest thing of course is the is the is the views I 'm I'm unclear as well as to what the actual impact is I am I'm noticing that the project has scaled back I think this will be the second or third time the envelope of the house in order to take the butter's concerns into consideration so I don't think that should be I don't think that should be taken for granted and it does seem like the house is getting smaller and smaller and there is going to be a point where it just becomes not feasible to put a home on that property I'm not sure what else they can do so again is it a buildable lot or is it not a buildable lot that's not for us to say as of now it's considered a buildable lot I think they should be able to put a building on it
[1:58:34] Speaker E (unidentified): Justin I had one question for you so the comment was made by one of the members that no one would object to a conforming development it from a setback perspective just so I'm correct. This does conform with the setbacks, et cetera. Correct. Height, setback, everything else. Correct. It really just comes down to the view question.
[1:59:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Any other discussion? All right. Would anybody like to make a motion one way or the other? and by the way when whatever the motion is we should address whether it meets or doesn't meet each of the requirements in sections 19 119 and 19-123 it
[1:59:50] Speaker D (unidentified): might be a worthwhile exercise to approve each item I believe we've done that before to make
[2:00:01] Speaker A (unidentified): it clear well when you when whoever not approve or vote on each yes we can we can do that or you can
[2:00:08] Speaker D (unidentified): yes and do we do we have to make a motion for the whole application first yes okay
[2:00:24] Speaker I (unidentified): i'm just a suggestion it may be helpful to straw poll comes to mind but i wouldn't go that far i believe the ordinance says all of the items need to be met right having a discussion about which individual items an individual either does or doesn't feel meat may give you a better idea of what a vote is going to look like if you're trying to do that
[2:00:47] Speaker D (unidentified): without actually putting a motion forward that exactly yeah so let's
[2:00:52] Speaker A (unidentified): continue the discussion okay sounds good should we look at 119 yep section 119 and we will go through criteria by criteria and everybody can express their opinion 119 a will meet the definition and specific requirements sets forth in this ordinance for such particular use are there any concerns with respect to this criterion no okay criterion B will be compatible with the general character of the neighborhood with regard to design scale and bulk are there any concerns with this particular criterion?
[2:01:37] Speaker D (unidentified): I have no concerns, no.
[2:01:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Criterion C will not have a significant detrimental effect on the use and peaceful enjoyment of a budding property as a result of noise, vibrations, fumes, odor, dust, light, or glare. I have no concerns. No concerns. No concerns. concerns criterion E excuse me criterion D will not have a significant adverse effect on adjacent or nearby property values as
[2:02:10] Speaker E (unidentified): I stated I don't have a concern with that right I don't either
[2:02:13] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't either no concern I do have some concern E will not have a significant adverse impact on water views from adjacent and nearby properties and public rights of way well that's the one isn't it I don't feel it meets that okay F will not result in significant hazards to pedestrian or vehicular traffic or significant traffic congestion no concerns other than that will be some temporary impact G will not result in significant fire danger no concerns H will not result in significant flood hazards or flood damage, drainage problems, ground or surface water contamination, or soil erosion? Nope. Nope. Okay. I will be served adequately by, but will not overburden, existing public services and facilities, including fire protection services, sanitary, sewers, roads, water, and storm drainage. Nope. No concerns. Okay. Okay. All right. All right, we are gonna go to 19.123. Glad I printed this out today. 19.123A, must meet the following criteria. Proposal must include any special screening, fencing, or other buffer necessary to set off the subject property from abutting uses or to ensure the continued enjoyment of abutting uses. no concerns no concerns proposal must adequately provide for drainage through and for preservation of existing topography within its location particularly in minimizing any cut fill or paving no concerns no concern my only comment there would be that I'm assuming that there will be drainage plans submitted as part of the construction project is that correct that typically
[2:04:30] Speaker I (unidentified): is correct i would just say that if you have concerns with that you know i wouldn't i wouldn't rely solely on a building permit to accomplish what you may want to do okay so my feeling on
[2:04:43] Speaker A (unidentified): that one would be to require that detailed plans for managing stormwater drainage be a plan be filed does anyone have any concerns with that requirement no that seems reasonable agreed okay proposal must not create or increase any fire hazard or any hazards to save convenient pedestrian or vehicular flow no okay again I would ask that there be some sort of plan submitted particularly with respect to emergency services access during the construction period. Proposal must prevent or avoid the creation of any nuisance affecting adjacent property. The proposal must include provision for adequate lawful sewage disposal and healthful domestic water supplies. otherwise. Okay. The proposal should not have a significantly adverse effect on adjacent or nearby property values. I think we've already talked about this one. And let's see. The appellant must be found to have adequate financial and technical capacity to satisfy the foregoing criteria. No concerns. no concern all right having said all that would anyone like to make a motion one way or the other I
[2:06:23] Speaker H (unidentified): would like to make a motion I would move that we deny the request for conditional use under section 19 119 to construct a single family dwelling at 241 a four-side Road by Michael Coyne and why my concerns are the significant impact on the abutters views of the water does
[2:06:50] Speaker D (unidentified): anyone want to discuss is there a second I think before we vote to deny the application would we like to give the applicant another opportunity to provide the information as it is incumbent upon them to provide the that seems to be what the just the not disagreement is but what the kerfuffle is here that we didn't really get is that a better word is that we didn't get what we feel was an adequate representation of what the field of view was so would we I feel I've been
[2:07:26] Speaker A (unidentified): adequately educated okay I would agree I think this proposal has been before us many times it is a revised proposal I think the concerns were well known okay But feel free not to vote on the motion or to not approve the motion. That's fine. Okay. Does anybody else want to weigh in on Chris's point? Okay. All right. Is there a second to Peter's motion? Does anybody want to revise the motion? I would revise. I mean, you look like you're saying you want to say something. I want to get home.
[2:08:16] Speaker E (unidentified): I would revise the note I would put forth a motion to approve the application for conditional use under 19 119 for Michael coin via Brad Mull at 241 Forsyth Road Falmouth. Okay, so
[2:08:30] Speaker A (unidentified): we have two different motions And no seconds. I would second the approval Okay, so we have a second any discussion
[2:08:42] Speaker H (unidentified): My discussion is I'm not sure you could vote to approve this with the significant views that have been demonstrated we've been there we've seen it we've sat in people's houses we've been in their living rooms we've been on their decks the reality is this building will block significant views of some of those units and i feel that it is our responsibility to protect those the ordinance is clear on that whether this lot ever becomes developed is not up to us it's not our concern whether it gets divided up and sold to the abutters whether it just stays a vacant field forever is not the issue in front of us the issue in front of us is do we feel protection is needed for the abutters or do we feel that the impact is not significant enough in no protection is warranted I
[2:09:37] Speaker D (unidentified): would like to propose that we also do owe the applicant a bit of protection too as they are paying taxes on what they thought was a buildable lot and if we're going this route we're saying this is not a buildable lot i don't think we're saying that i think we're saying that this
[2:09:51] Speaker H (unidentified): particular plan does not meet the requirements it's not up to us to say that there'll ever be a plan there could be a plan proposed that you approach the butters and say will you agree to this in whatever concessions that the two parties make up that's private to them but i could foresee a path forward where this is either divided up and it's not a buildable lot anymore which is fine or that somebody actually has a design and wins over the hearts and minds of the abutters and goes forward with it I think the idea that you know we're stamping this is a non buildable odd I don't think is a valid point well this
[2:10:29] Speaker D (unidentified): goes back to my do we want to give the applicant a chance to revise this to revise what to revise the plan as we are we're all it does not it does not it does not satisfy one of the criteria that I mean I would agree with Chris to
[2:10:51] Speaker B (unidentified): that to guard I mean it 's not like they came back with the exact same application no I mean the building is smaller they did provide views they did provide pitch it's not like they came back with nothing I think they should
[2:11:03] Speaker H (unidentified): know more they also admitted that they've they've gone up to the line that they feel that there is no further compromise and although that they've stated that there's no further compromise. They've done the best they can. I think the abutters have provided a solid argument that they're being significantly impacted still.
[2:11:25] Speaker E (unidentified): Peter, let me toss out a hypothetical. If in your scenario where they come up with a plan that wins over the hearts and minds of the abutters, and that plan were to come before us, and one of the criteria still comes down to significant impact, does it matter what the—I mean, in that scenario,, wouldn't we still, under your thought process, have the same obligation?
[2:11:45] Speaker H (unidentified): No. To me, it's the owner who helps define the significant impact. And if the owner says that is insignificant to me, then I feel that they're not looking for the protection. They're not
[2:11:58] Speaker B (unidentified): looking for me to intervene on their behalf. But the ordinance doesn't say to the owner. The ordinance just says a significant impact to the view. So, I mean, we're to be abstract in the view of what is significant relative to the specific properties. It's not because a person comes forth and raises a claim that all of a sudden we're evaluating. You're right. To that
[2:12:15] Speaker H (unidentified): point, then I guess it's all up to us as individuals and disregard the public comment and the abutters. So we just personally go out and look. And I did that. And I don't see how you can go there and say, I went there and I see no significant impact. There was clearly significant impact. You're putting a building in front of the ocean and now I can't see the ocean anymore.
[2:12:37] Speaker A (unidentified): How do you say that's not significant? I would also argue that I don't think that the applicant took into account all of the impacts to view. And so I don't feel that the applicant satisfied its burden of proof with respect to significant adverse impact. And it is its burden it is its burden of proof so we if there's not any more discussion we have a motion on the table to approve we have a second on that motion we've discussed the motion is the board ready to vote on the motion albeit
[2:13:19] Speaker B (unidentified): if not giving them another opportunity to present whatever so if that's where we're at then it's been seconded well we can are you looking like you want to say something?
[2:13:30] Speaker I (unidentified): We always go through the list of things and their potential consequences at this point in time, typically. I'll just say out loud, you can approve, you can approve with conditions, you can deny, you can table, and the applicant has the ability to also withdraw. Typically, the biggest hurdle in the denial is that the application cannot come back before you without some significant alterations to it I think the risk here is that if there is that view or that extra bit of information that might be needed that does or doesn't change the argument if the application is denied they would have to argue that it is a different application I will stop talking okay
[2:14:24] Speaker A (unidentified): we can either vote on the motion as is, we can take a straw poll, see how people are gonna vote before we take the vote. We can go back to Chris's suggestion with respect to tabling or asking the applicant to withdraw again to see if they can come back with a better proposal. What is the board's feelings?
[2:14:58] Speaker E (unidentified): I made the motion, so I'm in favor of moving ahead with the vote, but I'm just one of five I would favor I
[2:15:14] Speaker H (unidentified): would favor allowing the applicant to withdraw because that's always an option for them or should be but we've been down that road and I don't know if we've done any further than that I don't know
[2:15:27] Speaker B (unidentified): if tabling provides us any relief yeah so I mean tabling they're not gonna get enough stuff done in a week to get it submitted next month so it's either withdrawal or vote Chris
[2:15:40] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm in favor of giving them the opportunity to
[2:15:44] Speaker A (unidentified): withdraw all right I 'm not in favor of that but it does seem to be a three to two decision here so I'm gonna I'm gonna take a straw poll if you want on which aspect well the seconding of the motion the seconding of the motion you
[2:16:07] Speaker B (unidentified): You said we could take a straw poll before we officially vote.
[2:16:10] Speaker A (unidentified): But before the approval of the motion. You've seconded. Correct. Okay.
[2:16:14] Speaker D (unidentified): All right. Or we can let them withdraw. Would you like to know where I would stand if we were voting on? Yes. I would not be able to approve this application if I was to be asked to.
[2:16:25] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. John? I would vote to approve it.
[2:16:29] Speaker H (unidentified): I would vote to deny.
[2:16:31] Speaker A (unidentified): I would vote to deny. So our question is to the applicant. would you like to come forward based
[2:16:47] Speaker K (unidentified): on that we'd like to withdraw and question for whether or not we could get a site walk staking out the building physically to help maybe showcase that better in person to take full advantage of all views if the board would be open to that I mean does something have to be before
[2:17:07] Speaker B (unidentified): the board for us to do a site walk
[2:17:11] Speaker K (unidentified): yes so we're assuming we have to withdraw and then put in put forth a new application and request the site walk ahead of the board i am yeah i am not i don't think
[2:17:26] Speaker I (unidentified): there's anything that would technically require it to be heard by the board and then a site walk happened that's typically how we do it but i don't think that is necessary but we could table it into
[2:17:39] Speaker H (unidentified): do a site walk correct and then withdrawal and then that's always an option but at this point we would kick the can down the road another month and give us we would schedule a site walk for the next for next month and then put it on the agenda for the for that evening and then they would withdraw unless they did a straw poll and they found out that it was in their favor well i just
[2:18:01] Speaker B (unidentified): mean because they'd have to submit whatever new information visuals photographs because this
[2:18:07] Speaker I (unidentified): needs one more wrinkle next month's meeting is one week prior there is no 21 day deadline that is
[2:18:14] Speaker E (unidentified): today for new info anyway okay would the only new info be the sidewalk itself perhaps or visuals
[2:18:21] Speaker D (unidentified): from every single potential i mean that is my biggest hang up with this is because this is to me a significant change in the plan i would like to see how it lines up as compared to what it was before I know it was mentioned oh we've already been out there and seen it but we have not seen it as it is presented so I think I think it's fair and I don't think we ever saw it staked
[2:18:49] Speaker B (unidentified): before there was a stake there somewhere in the middle of the property but it was never staked
[2:18:54] Speaker I (unidentified): before what it would look like I would suggest if there's concern about timing and a sidewalk were required or contemplated I would suggest bumping to December if this were something that were tabled to December with the idea of a site walk at that time that would satisfy the ability to get new information in the meantime and plenty of time to advertise for a sidewalk well I and that's I mean I could move the question just force it yeah i just see november being a there's too many complications for that to go off smoothly and certainly if you withdraw and resubmit it you end up with this difficulty in trying to review new information without having a meeting and then immediately be in a site walk is
[2:19:58] Speaker A (unidentified): the applicant willing to table until December
[2:20:07] Speaker I (unidentified): yeah that good with that just to clarify that would be a December 15th scheduled meeting that is also one month bumped due to holiday week okay but I
[2:20:19] Speaker B (unidentified): would kind of look at that as like submit everything by what's the up the
[2:20:25] Speaker A (unidentified): The submittal deadline is sometime in November.
[2:20:28] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, 21 days prior. Yeah, I can look it up, but yes.
[2:20:32] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, because you actually have a month. Effectively.
[2:20:35] Speaker K (unidentified): So we would resubmit, I guess, just to gain clarity.
[2:20:38] Speaker B (unidentified): So it's a tabling, it's not a withdrawal. It's tabling until the December meeting. So the 21 days prior, you would need to submit all documentation, everything. And then at that December meeting, we would also have the site walk to look at whatever's staked out. okay so if you're gonna make any revisions to building size or whatever I mean make that so that it's staked out at that time yep and then be able to visually represent every potential impact to every view in the world for
[2:21:05] Speaker K (unidentified): that property yeah so we would put forth our new application with the meeting
[2:21:13] Speaker B (unidentified): no you're it's taste so it's not an application sorry no it's not a new app you're literally just submitting supplemental information for the
[2:21:18] Speaker K (unidentified): the current application the site walk would happen after that but prior to the hearing
[2:21:23] Speaker B (unidentified): it'll happen before the hearing on the december meeting same day all right that's what i was usually meet it well like probably be a little early because it'll be dark yeah so we'll submit
[2:21:32] Speaker K (unidentified): supplemental information by the deadline date correct have the site walk ahead of this board
[2:21:37] Speaker B (unidentified): meeting and then we'll go straight into that meeting and understood can't profess what the future will hold but a decision will be made likely that day okay yeah and we should decide
[2:21:47] Speaker I (unidentified): out on it now four o'clock is the earliest i think we usually do it but given how dark it gets
[2:21:54] Speaker H (unidentified): i mean we can like three thirds it's almost the longest the shortest day by seven days so i am
[2:22:01] Speaker I (unidentified): available but i am open what date is it 's the 15th i know this is a burden on working
[2:22:09] Speaker A (unidentified): folks but are is anyone in are people available during the middle of the day i'm wide open that
[2:22:16] Speaker D (unidentified): day yeah actually it would be preferable i'm open i bet all the day is better for me
[2:22:22] Speaker I (unidentified): i don't think there's any yeah limitation okay all right do we want to do a motion to table
[2:22:30] Speaker B (unidentified): until the december 15th meeting of which we will have a site walk first and then we will kick it to the rest of the so it'll be first on the agenda that day
[2:22:41] Speaker H (unidentified): you already seconded all right peter how do you vote i vote to approve the table
[2:22:50] Speaker A (unidentified): cabin proof chris vote to table john vote to approve okay i vote to table as well thank you very much everyone for your patience with us and we will see you in december Okay, next item on the agenda, I think, I know that, I mean, we can take a break.
[2:23:19] Speaker I (unidentified): We've got other business. Yeah, let's take maybe a three-minute break, if that's okay.
[2:23:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, three-minute break. Other business, I know, Justin, you wanted to talk about the schedule for next year.
[2:25:33] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I know it can be very brief. my only thought was the was it thanks why did I change December Thanksgiving holiday I'm sorry my brains fry month or next year next year I believe Thanksgiving there was a conflict just because it's in the week and I know You know, holiday weeks for that week and Christmas tend to be a little rough to get quorum. I think bumping it another week prior, like we normally do, would be my suggestion. I'm happy to do a revision on this and everyone take a look at it and just get your thoughts. If I've missed something, you can hit it then, too.
[2:26:23] Speaker A (unidentified): No, I mean, that's fine. So you're saying November 23rd is what, the Tuesday before Thanksgiving?
[2:26:29] Speaker I (unidentified): no i think i didn't actually make the adjustment but let me double check it real quick here because it looks like you did i did i modify it already so the meeting would be what [Speaker B (unidentified): the 16th be] the 16th yes the 23rd is the fourth tuesday so i haven't modified it okay but it would be the 16th which would be the third week instead of the fourth okay 24th is a wednesday for 2027
[2:26:58] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah 23rd is a tuesday that's what he's saying yeah so it's the week of thanks that's what i'm
[2:27:04] Speaker I (unidentified): saying move it to the 16th week prior that's fine yeah okay let's plan on that i will revise it and look at the week of christmas which is christmas is on the saturday and the board meeting would be on the 28th the next tuesday i mean i'm happy to it's kind of in between so
[2:27:26] Speaker B (unidentified): So you're talking the 21st or the 14th?
[2:27:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, right now it's scheduled for the week between Christmas and New Year's.
[2:27:34] Speaker B (unidentified): The 28th? Yeah, I would do it the 21st.
[2:27:37] Speaker I (unidentified): 21st is also fine. Yeah, I didn't, whichever week says.
[2:27:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I really want to spend pre-Christmas with you guys.
[2:27:44] Speaker M (unidentified): That sounds terrible.
[2:27:46] Speaker B (unidentified): It's on the record now.
[2:27:48] Speaker D (unidentified): Who the hell is going to submit anything for the 28th?
[2:27:50] Speaker B (unidentified): No, we're going to have nothing.
[2:27:53] Speaker I (unidentified): I will modify for the 21st. And if you see any other conflicts, let me know. But that's all I have.
[2:28:01] Speaker B (unidentified): I think we should discuss at a future meeting last-minute data requests. It feels like three years ago. It's creating a very bad precedence, I would say. Because if we allow some and deny others...
[2:28:15] Speaker I (unidentified): What I would think about in that, because I definitely had the same thought all month, we can have a talk about how to address those as like wrote and I try to preempt applicants with this I am relatively gentle about it but make them very aware of what might happen I can be less so and I can be very blunt and if there is a standard practice even a guideline you might want to put in about how we deal with that sort of thing now it's completely up to your discretion so if someone says I've got a traffic study I thought we did do a guideline we did but it's still relatively open I think your policy is to be pretty limiting. Like, if you want to clarify that measurement, excellent. If you want to submit 20 pages of new documents, absolutely not.
[2:29:06] Speaker B (unidentified): Or even a completely new thing that wasn't even a part of the application. I mean, that's a bad precedence to be going down that route.
[2:29:12] Speaker I (unidentified): And I think that, yeah, this month was a reign-it-in type of month. And, again, I feel for the situation. I mean, I saw what happened, but I get it.
[2:29:22] Speaker B (unidentified): But, I mean, generally, I would say allow revisions or potentially corrections to what was submitted, but not all new.
[2:29:28] Speaker H (unidentified): Substantial or substantive information.
[2:29:30] Speaker E (unidentified): It's just too hard to review it as you're sitting here.
[2:29:33] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah. I asked for a pool, but I'm going to add an ADU.
New Business
[2:29:37] Speaker I (unidentified): Typically, you know, it's been easy to differentiate between a clarification and a change. And a clarification of something, great. Great. But the change or the new info of something, yeah, I completely agree. If you want, I can add it to new business next time and we can really hone down a little bit.
[2:29:57] Speaker B (unidentified): What do we have for next month?
[2:29:59] Speaker I (unidentified): Actually, we're not going to meet, so it's going to be December. There's nothing on next month.
[2:30:02] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't want to meet just to do that.
[2:30:04] Speaker B (unidentified): No,, no, I'm not. But if it was one item, I would say, like, throw it on. I don't know if we want to throw it on the December because that's going to be a lengthy one.
[2:30:10] Speaker I (unidentified): I will triple check with Erica, but I don't think anything came in. What I can do is, in the meantime, get some options for you, whether it's a guideline revision or just a change of practice, and see what might be palatable.
[2:30:23] Speaker H (unidentified): Why don't we have Joel draft something up since he's not here?
[2:30:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. I think it would be great.
[2:30:30] Speaker E (unidentified): Can I make a motion for that? Just circulate it. The way that it played out tonight, the first one was pretty minor, but then it just sort of snowballed. But after we had said yes to the first, It's harder to say no to the third, right? It's like, and we had no idea what was coming down the pike.
[2:30:45] Speaker D (unidentified): You feel bad because these people go to Kinko's.
[2:30:48] Speaker I (unidentified): So I'm going to look at the planning board guidelines as well because I think they might have something that allows them to pull it pre-meeting and just tell the applicant, no, you've lacked that piece. You're done. And we could look into something like that. We haven't been quite so hard-nosed.
[2:31:05] Speaker H (unidentified): I mean, it's not fair to the abutters.
[2:31:07] Speaker B (unidentified): No, because they don't have a chance to actually evaluate.
[2:31:10] Speaker H (unidentified): Right, they don't know whether I want to drag my butt down there or not. And all of a sudden, oh, I didn't know they were going to do that.
[2:31:15] Speaker I (unidentified): Let me dive into it, see what the options are. I'll get back to you.
[2:31:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Sounds good. Any other new business? Nope. All right. Motion to adjourn this. Second?
[2:31:25] Speaker D (unidentified): Approved. Not done yet. Approved. Oh, you're done. Yeah, I was a little overdone before I got here.
[2:31:32] Speaker I (unidentified): All right, let me do one more clear.