Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): First of all, we'd like all of you to know that the meeting is being recorded by Zoom, and we'll be using an AI program to help us produce the minutes. Just before we begin, I want all the board members to just identify themselves by their first name so that the Zoom gods will know who we are. So Sally.
[0:18] Speaker B (unidentified): Sally Farneth. Just your first name. Oh, Sally. Donna. Brian. Sue. Kyle. Dave.
[0:37] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm Brian Knobloch, President of the Family Historic Society. I'd like to welcome you to the 60th Annual Meeting. This includes those of you here in person as well as those of you joining us from Zoom land. There will be time at the end of the meeting for questions and comments. Please hold your questions until then. We ask that those of you who are joining us via Zoom, please mute your microphone now. And I call this meeting to order. Board Secretary Suzanne Farnham will open the meeting.
[1:05] Speaker C (unidentified): I am Suzanne Farnham, Secretary of the Society. I declare a quorum is present for this annual meeting of the members and the meeting to be open. The minutes of last year's annual meeting were approved by the board, so we will dispense with the reading. Minutes for the annual meeting and board meetings along with reports and presentation slides are posted online at the Society website, that is thefhs.org, under Society Documents below the About FHS tab. If you're thinking about becoming more involved in the Society and want to check us out. All the details are there for you to view. We encourage our members and the community to attend any of our board meetings. The calendar is posted on the Society website. Our board and committees meet regularly using Zoom meetings. Send an email to the society mailbox that is info at thefhs.org and we'll send you the zoom link i asked the board members to introduce themselves we'll begin with our two board members who are joining us via zoom betsy
[2:29] Speaker A (unidentified): you're muted betsy can't hear you okay
[2:42] Speaker D (unidentified): sorry i'm betsy what come on vice president
[2:50] Speaker C (unidentified): and now those present in the chamber
[2:53] Speaker E (unidentified): sally farnes donna brian knobloch president
[3:01] Speaker C (unidentified): sue farm against the secretary kyle lucas director dave farnham acting treasurer
[3:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Suzanne. All of our board, volunteer board, appreciate the support the members have given us over the years and for your participation in this meeting. Without you, there would be no Historic Society. This annual meeting gives us the opportunity to update you on what's been going on at the Society this year, and there's a lot to talk about. out. On screen is the agenda for the meeting. Throughout the meeting, we'll tell you about the changes we've made, the ones we're planning, and about some of our visitors. Following the business meeting, Dr. Patrick Outwin will tell the tale of Falmouth from fortune to misfortune. And now, on to business. Next, David Farnham will present the Treasurer's
[3:54] Speaker F (unidentified): report here is a summary of our financial condition on a single slide closer look closer than that okay here is the summary of our financial condition on a single slide it tells us that the society is solvent that we stuck to our budget and that our income exceeded our expenses thanks to the wonderful generosity of our members we finished our fiscal year which ended on June 30th in the black. We hope you will be just as generous when we send out our annual appeal next month. For more details about our financial condition, please refer to our details Treasurer's report on the Society website.
[4:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks Dave. We make every effort to keep our operational expenses as low as possible. In fact, 80% of our budget goes to provide programming, which is considered an excellent ratio in the nonprofit world. Nearly all of our income comes from memberships and donations, and we use the money you give us wisely to support projects, research, programs, and to run the museum itself, and we are grateful for your continued support through membership donations. Secretary Suzanne Farnham will update us on membership and merchandise sales.
[5:07] Speaker C (unidentified): Happily, our membership continues to grow slowly but steadily, with a net increase of five members this year although we had an increase overall our overall our membership has remained at about 125 we hope that when you learn at tonight's meeting what you learn at tonight's meeting will encourage you to renew or perhaps upgrade your membership and tell others about the society so they might become members too okay over the last year we sold one thousand four hundred and two dollars worth of merchandise our newest product is a circa plaque giving the name and approximate date of construction for your home it comes with a short history called from research into our collections where can you purchase our Falmouth-related books in our Falmouth-themed merchandise? During the summer, you can always stop by the new museum bookstore on Tuesdays when we are open. Throughout the year, there is a display case at Town Hall filled with our merchandise. When we set up a table at a public event, we usually bring our merchandise with us, including our coloring book, cookbooks, in our attractive and amazingly warm beanies or any of the other items in our catalog. You can order merchandise directly through our website under the Heritage Museum tab. We will deliver locally in Falmouth and nearby. We also provide mail order to U.S. addresses. The coloring books, cookbooks, and Falmouth-themed merchandise, that is the beanies, totes, and throws, make great Christmas presents. presence.
[7:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks, Sue. As you saw in the newsletter, the biggest change we made this year at the museum was in the exhibit space, which we divided into different areas with large posters telling family stories. We've added information sheets to many objects, giving their history or telling how they were used. Visitors are now engaged with the display, spending 20 to 30 minutes exploring the museum. As you can see in this slide, we had a slight increase in museum visitors this year. We're hoping our updated exhibit space will attract more visitors, including you, next year. If you haven't been to the museum in a long time, please stop by. I think you'll be pleased with our work. Next, we'll hear from Sally Formaneth, the chair of the Education Committee.
[7:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Education is a primary goal for the society, and for the last four years, in early June, the second grade classes from Falmouth Elementary School have come to the museum to see...
[7:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Move the microphone closer a little bit.
[7:59] Speaker B (unidentified): How our artifacts and learn what life was like for a child of seven more than a century ago. Over two days, students spend ten minutes with their adult guides in four display areas, the kitchen and front room of the museum, the barn, and books.
[8:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Dave, change the slides, please.
[8:28] Speaker B (unidentified): Then also displays of hand tools that children would have used for their chores outside. And lastly, cooking implements and butter molds. And there are some of the tables they see. Inside the museum, I showed the children the floor plan of the building and a picture of the two boys that once lived in this house. And I explained the chores that children their age would have been expected to do to help their family. I asked the students, what is the same in their home and what is missing? They seemed to realize that in our museum a long time ago, there would have been no bathroom, no electricity, or central heating. I have pictures of clothing and some real pieces of clothing from long ago. The fact that the boys wore dresses until age seven and the girls were only allowed to wear dresses, never blue jeans or shorts, generally bring loud moans and comments. The adults cover a lot of information in a short amount of time. Hopefully, we have intrigued the children enough that they will want to explore the lives of their ancestors who worked hard just to survive, and give us all what we take for granted nowadays. This is a slide that is the Falmouth Historical Society also sponsors a $5,000 scholarship on behalf of the Perkins family for a deserving Falmouth High School graduate. This year the scholarship was awarded to Katrina Pivaronis and please join me in thanking Ron Perkins and the family for their generosity and support of the society and Falmouth students.
[10:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Sally. Betsy Jo Whitcomb chairs the Museum Operations and Exhibits Committee and she's going to introduce you to one of our visitors this year. Betsy's on Zoom today.
[10:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Hi, I would like to introduce you to Mary Elizabeth Whitney Knowles, better known as Betty. Her grandfather, Gorham Whitney, owned the Elmwood Dairy in West Valley, and we have the dairy's milk wagon in the museum barn. In July, Betty and her daughter-in-law, Marlene, visited the museum. In the barn, Betty saw the milk wagon and paused briefly and said, I used to ride in that wagon when I was a little girl. she also told us that Marlene's husband used the wagon for deliveries into the 1950s when Betty walked through the exhibit room of the museum and stopped at the school section she looked at the graduation picture from the West Falmouth elementary school class of 1939 and hesitated for a moment Betty then pointed to the picture and said that's me that's my friend Sally was her maid of honor when she was married in 1948 we enjoyed meeting other people who have lived in the quote Leighton house as the museum was known in the past a highlight of their visit is often the childhood growth marks on the door jam in the kitchen closet. These stories, these connections are why the Historical Society exists. We connect the past and the present and tell the stories that weave them together. We could not do this work without your support.
[12:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks Betsy Jo. In addition to education at the museum, we also go out into the community with presentations and bus tours. We didn't do as much outreach this year compared to previous years because we focused much of our attention within the museum itself. We plan to get back on track with these projects next year. We've made a lot of changes to the research room this season as well. Director Donna Knobloch will bring us up to date.
[13:11] Speaker E (unidentified): The second major change we made at the museum this year was in the research room and our collections. To make space for the large table we moved from the exhibit room, we reorganized and consolidated files brought in some new filing cabinets and reduced the clutter files relating to the same subject were in different cabinets or locations in the room they're now all together making them easier to find and ensuring that our team can access everything related to the same subject quickly we also have a dedicated desk with good lighting where visitors who are researching their home or family can work comfortably We've cleaned out and organized the second floor storage area with new shelving and a complete inventory, including the location of everything in the collection. This will make it easier for us to find items that our researchers or visitors are looking for or that we may want to use to create new displays.
[14:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks, Donna. Ron Scorsone is co-chair of the Collections Committee and will walk us through our transition to a web-based archive management system. Go ahead, Ron. Thanks, Brian.
[14:25] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm Ron Scorsolo, co-chair of the Collections Committee, and a board member who is responsible for cataloging our museum collection. One of the roles of our society is to collect, maintain, and display the artifacts, documents, and objects that embody the history of Falmouth. To do that well, we need to register, accession, and catalog each of the items donated to our collection. We have a multi-step system to register and catalog our inventory. We use a series of index cards and a logbook to identify and cross-reference each item that comes into our collection. We write the name and description of the item, who is donating it or loaning it, and as much history as they are able to provide to us. These documents serve as paper backups. The real workforce of the system, however, is the online catalog. For online cataloging, we use Past Perfect, a museum software used by many other museums and societies and also the main historical society. It has a menu-driven series of screens which enable us to accession items into one of four different catalogs. Archives, library, objects, or photos. Cataloging the software involves working through a series of screens where we enter the item name and the description, add it to a particular collection, such as farm equipment perhaps, enter any data information, identify its category according to the lexicon established by the Library of Congress, lists, add the location where it will be housed in the museum, and add as much background information and description as we can gather, either from the donor or from other sources that may be relevant to the item. While the software was designed for museum staff to build a functional catalog of the items in the collection, the benefit for society members and the public is the online public catalog. It enables anyone to access information about all the accessions items in the collection either by scrolling through the items in any of the individual catalogs, by searching for a particular item by name, or by just adding random search terms, like postcards, for example, or using people's names. Getting the extension items in the collection to the public catalog managed by PastPerfect used to require a multi-step process that took several hours to complete. For several years we used the single user desktop version of PastPerfect software, which was installed on one computer. This meant that only one person was able to catalog all the items in the collection to that point and only one person was able to populate the public catalog. This year, we were able to upgrade to the online version of the Past Perfect software. That upgrade involved an intensive several-month-long multi-step process where each catalog was backed up, then locked down so no new entries could be made. Then all the data in the files was printed out in spreadsheets, and a cross-check and manual review of the editing process was conducted to identify and fix any updates, errors, inconsistencies, omissions, or duplications. Not yet. All of these can happen when different individuals donate items to the collection over different years. One more.
[18:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Back one more? No, up one. Okay. Okay. What slide am I supposed to be on? I'm having trouble finding it with this. The next one.
[18:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Sorry. Okay. Sorry, Ron. Are you finished?
[18:31] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I'm just waiting for the slide. So with the multi-step process for moving this stuff online, once the review and editing was completed, the entire catalog was then backed up again and then uploaded to Past Perfect. and their team then built a public catalog in the online software. The online version of Past Perfect streamlines the data entry process somewhat, a little bit more than it used to be, but its value lies in two major benefits. The first is that multiple users can be logged in at any time. This allows several people to catalog new items, add photographs and or media to the collection. The second benefit is that once an item is entered in the system, it can be immediately available in the public catalog eliminating the multi-step process that was needed for uploading this is a major time saver for our limited staff we were able to redesign the color of the look and look and screen of i'm sorry look and feel of the screens they've got using our film with blue background adding our color logo and streamlining the on-screen instructions for searching and using the catalog. It has a nice look and feel to it. If you haven't looked at the public catalog for a while or actually are new to it, check it out. Let us know what you think. Many new items have been added to the collection. The existing link on our web page will take you right to the new version.
[20:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks, Ron. Change the slide, Dave. As you can see, we have a lot of items in our collection, and keeping track of them involves much more than putting them on a shelf or in a bin. Ron and Don have both done a great job of organizing the collection and making the transition to the modern web-based system. Change. Last fall, we received a $3,500 grant from the Morton Kelly Charitable Trust to buy digital scanning equipment. Our first project was to scan 800, change, age, 800 1941 civil defense cards which were filled out by all adults in Maine after Pearl Harbor. Information included their name, address, education, training, skills, and what jobs they may be able to do as a volunteer. This card is from William Lunt, Jr. and provides a wealth of personal and demographic information for researchers. The cards are posted on the Digital Maine Repository and a link to the repository is on our website. site. We also scan 110 years of Falmouth Town reports. These scans are also on the repository and are text searchable. To date, there have been nearly 5,000 downloads of these two collections from 130 countries around the world, showing that the society's reach extends far beyond the Falmouth Town line. In addition to being active treasurer, Dave Farnham is our researcher extraordinaire and as co-chair of the local history committee and dave we
[21:41] Speaker F (unidentified): say that our research is community driven because we respond to a steady stream of requests seeking information about the history of our town its people and its places the nature of these requests continues to evolve in the past we'd receive a question do the research and provide an answer now the requests are more detailed and often lead to a continuing dialogue about town history. This is good. It shows that the people of our town are really interested in history. Our website is the front door to our digital museum and the best place to find historical information about Falmouth. Our web pages point to online repositories where the digital copies of reference material can be found. Brian just told you about how we've taken the next step by publishing Falmouth unique content on the digital main repository these documents can be accessed through links under the research tab on our website or Google search the level of activity our website on our website is the same as last year the pattern of activity is also the same online visitors are drawn by the volume of historical content on the website thanks
[22:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Dave as a board we keep we keep we make every effort to keep our members up to date on our activities. Our prime vehicle is the quarterly newsletter, newly renamed Compass. Until this summer, the newsletter was printed and mailed to our members. Costs for paper, envelopes, ink, and postage for the newsletters were about $200 per edition, which represented a significant expense to our modest operating budget. It was also a substantial time commitment for the volunteers who print and distribute it. We have made the decision to transition to digital distribution by mail, by email. mail. But any member who prefers a printed copy can send us a message to info at thefhs.org and we will continue to send you a printed copy in the mail. As for social media, we'd love to increase our Facebook postings, but we really need a volunteer with Facebook experience to help us compose and publish occasional updates in between newsletters. We're also still on the hunt for a bookkeeper with non-profit experience to pay the bills, process memberships, maintain the ledgers, etc. As I mentioned before, the need to fill the volunteer roles of bookkeeper and treasurer are critical. We have advertised for volunteers with no success. Paying an outside company to perform these tasks would be an unsustainable expense for us. Please use your network to help us find people who are willing to work with us on our finances. Kyle Lucas will update us on the museum's buildings and grounds following our appeal in the last
[24:32] Speaker H (unidentified): newsletter for some help mowing the lawn member Brad fog stepped up and parked his riding lawn mower at the museum and did some occasional mowing given the drought conditions in southern Maine the grass hasn't grown that much but we grace greatly appreciate Brad's mower and his mowing the board volunteers will also use the mower as needed inside the museum we've reinforced the flooring under the exhibit room and this winter we are planning on removing the cabinets in the kitchen area to make it a proper reception and office area more on that as the plans develop
[25:03] Speaker A (unidentified): thanks hal i've been talking about the changes we've made at the museum this year and i've saved the best for last even though we're closed in the winter we must still heat the museum to about 40 degrees using very expensive baseboard electric heating also on hot summer days it can be brutal in the building with only window fans to provide cooling We recently received a grant of $13,600 from the Davis Family Foundation to install heat pumps, and we've contracted with Revision Energy in Portland to install a Mitsubishi system. This will lower our winter heating costs and provide air conditioning when needed in the summer. We may also be able to extend our open season on both ends. The grant didn't pay for the entire project, but main state rebates and contributions from all board members made up the difference. Unfortunately, due to the high demand for heat pumps, the system won't be installed until mid-winter, so we won't realize the full benefit until the next heating season. But we will still receive savings this year. I'd like to take a moment to recognize our generous corporate sponsors. The support of these local businesses is critical for small nonprofits such as ours. The sponsors are Ocean View at Falmouth, Magico Roofing, the Falmouth Lions Club, Hancock Doc Lumber, Hannafords, Linda McDonald Associates, Shaw's, Fox Pest Control, Bath Savings, Berman and Simmons, and Leawood Fine Gardening. Please join me in thanking them for their support. Next. At the beginning of this meeting, I mentioned that this is the 60th anniversary of the Falmouth Historic Society. society, that's quite an achievement for a small organization such as ours. Like all of those who have come before us, the volunteer board members here tonight are only temporary stewards of the museum, the collections, and our town's history. According to our bylaws, most of the members of this board will term out in a few years, having had their terms extended already several times, or they may retire from the board. The bylaws allow for up to six additional board members who serve in addition to the four officers. The board members are drawn from the membership. Your membership in the society shows that you have an interest in preserving the history of Falmouth. We are asking that you step forward now and demonstrate that support by volunteering to serve on the board. The duties include a monthly zoo board meeting, participation in discussions about project and help implementing them, volunteering at some events, a reminder that all of the work of the society, administration programming projects and building maintenance is done by your volunteer board and we are at the limit of what we can do this society your society needs your energy your enthusiasm your passion and your time as a board member or volunteer to expand our volunteers and continue that to serve the community please help us create the board's next generation to ensure that the Falmouth Historic Society will continue for another 60 years. In tonight's meeting, we've shown you what we've accomplished over the past year and the progress we've made over many fronts. We're building momentum. You've seen how we're increasing our activity and making changes to benefit both members, visitors, and the community. We hope that you'll acknowledge our work by renewing your membership and contributing to the society during this year's Giving Tuesday annual appeal next month. We'd also like to know what you think we should be doing. What programs should we develop? What exhibits or events should we create? And most importantly, what can we do to get you more involved in our activities and operations? Do you do genealogy or house history research? We can use your skills. This board is a part of the society, not apart from the society. Tell us what you think. Contact me, president at BFHS.org, and let me know what you're interested in, what you'd like to talk about and what we can do to serve you better. We'll now open the meeting for questions or comments. For those of you in the chamber, please come to the microphone and say your name so you can be heard. If you are participating via Zoom, please raise your hand on the Zoom panel, unmute your microphone, and then wait to be acknowledged before speaking, and then say your name. Your comments will be audio only. When you're finished, please mute your microphone again. Do we have any comments from the in the in the room? Please go to the microphone, please Not
[29:57] Speaker I (unidentified): used to speaking in microphones How many people what's your name? What's that? What's your name? Dan pride? Okay, how many people here? Know where the name none such River came from in Scarborough
[30:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Any idea I guess no one
[30:17] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay. I want to recommend a book to you as a source for more stuff on Falmouth than you might suspect. It's published by the British Parliament. It's an official document of the British Parliament. It's called Cromwell's Buffoon. It's about Lord Pride and the founding of the British Navy and the Civil War and a lot of other stuff. Anyway, I think you might find this interesting. thing. Lord Pride was a major general in the Civil War. At the end of the Civil War, the Parliament wouldn't pay his soldiers. He demanded a royal estate that had been seized called Nonsuch Palace and the force that went with it. He retrained his troops as loggers and masters, and they quickly logged 6,000 masts off the Nonsuch Forest. As they finished it, the Dutch blew the masts off the ships with chainshot, their new weapon. And in an emergency, they came here to get masts. Now, this is 1652. Lord Pride died in 1658. So his soldiers, who fought for him through the Civil War and after the Civil War, became loggers, named the—River in Scarborough is one of the finest massing sites on the whole East Coast. coast so they named that for the house that Lord pride lived in and the forest where they recovered from the war and did all that stuff but you'll find it 's a you can get it on Amazon as I said it's it's really a very interesting read and a lot of the things with Lord pride in the Navy have a lot more impact here when you're trying to date the mass thing and the date like we had an argument about the date of mast road it's pretty clear that his crews came through here and they left the
New Business
[32:25] Speaker A (unidentified): name thank you thank you thank you yeah sorry thank you sorry we have a he's a board member any are there any comments from people on zoom anybody wishing to speak. I don't see any hands raised. Okay. All right. We'll close the public portion, the comment portion of the meeting. Is there any new business from anyone? No? All right. I'd like to thank everyone for attending tonight's meeting. If you're not a member, I hope you've discovered that you should become one. On behalf of the society's board of members, I'd like to thank the town of Falmouth and town manager now Nathan poor for providing the states for the space for tonight's meeting I'd also like to thank Mike McDade up in the control room for managing the video audio and zoom facilities for the meeting I'd like a motion to adjourn the meeting of the Falmouth Historic Society so moved second all in favor aye okay, the meeting is adjourned.
[33:35] Speaker I (unidentified): I have a quick addendum and commission. The name none said.
[33:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. We'll now take a five-minute break before our guest speaker, Dr. Patrick Outwin, will tell us about how Falmouth quickly went from fortune to misfortune. So don't go away. We'll be back in a couple of minutes. Are you all set? Okay. Okay, we're back. Dr. Patrick Outwin is what used to be called a renaissance man. He's a historian, author, professor, and composer, among other things. He's a cathedral historian at St. Luke's and has written extensively about Portland's history, its people, and its culture. Tonight, he'll tell us how Falmouth, Portland, went from the height of economic prosperity to the depths of financial ruin and back again. Patrick, take it away.
[38:51] Speaker J (unidentified): Thank you very much, Brian. As he said, my name is Charles Patrick Outwin. That's where the confusion comes at. As you can see, Charles P. M. Outwin. My parents got carried away. would. But it's Charles Patrick. My reading public generally knows me as Charles. I want to thank Brian for the invitation to take part in the 50th anniversary celebrations of this august institution and to also give me the opportunity to get back into the swing of things. I've been I will not hide from you, I've been mostly out of circulation for the past 10 years due to illness, hospitalization, accidents, all sorts of other factors, none of which had to do anything with COVID. So I guess I'm blessed in that particular respect. But I'm very glad to be back in the swing of things and to be here speaking to you tonight with this little talk entitled Fortune and Misfortune. Colonial Falmouth in Casco Bay at the peak of its prosperity, its sudden calamitous plunge into ruin and poverty, and the first emergence of the modern city of Portland, Maine, and of the present-day town of Falmouth in the same state circa 1765 through 1786. By the way, if you pump that name at the bottom of the screen into your Google search engine, Charles, PM out, and you're going to get an awful lot of hits, even though I've been and there's a number of my articles that are still available online, and I will be referring to some of those as we go on. Now, it's important for you to realize that in spite of this extremely fancy sort of Jane Austen-ish, fortune and misfortune, Jane Austen-ish title, it's not going to be complicated. It really isn't. And I'm not going to have a lot of detail in it. And it's the principal thing that I want you to remember throughout this entire talk and to carry away with you just one item. And that is that in the summer of 1775, the port and town of Falmouth in Casco Bay, perhaps by then the most important forest products entrepot for naval stores in the entire British Empire, was rich. rich, and by that I mean cold, hard cash, especially coinage in silver and gold, as well as other lesser metals, and plenty of it. Now, for any of you who are familiar with colonial American history, you will realize that there's several problems with this declaration. immigration. Number one amongst these is where did all that money come from? All that specie, all that coinage. Well, that's an interesting point. If you cast your mind back, you'll find that a lot of the business that was carried on in places like Boston, like New York, like Philadelphia, like Savannah, was not carried on in cash. But we'll get to that in a few minutes. Most Americans' knowledge of Portland begins and, frankly, ends with documents such as this century-old tourist map, which is, in fact, not entirely inaccurate. [Speaker I (unidentified): Pardon me? me?] Yes, that reminds me, if you could please hold your questions and comments. We'll have a question and comment period at the end of the presentation, if we've got enough time. I love this map. I really do. It's so colorful. I've seen maps like this from Cape Cod, from Cape May, from Florida, all sorts of other places, up in beautiful frames on people's walls in their summer houses and even in their winter houses. It's so colorful. I have no objection to tourist literature at all. When I go traveling, the first place I go to, I beetle off to the tourist information stand and grab stuff exactly like this. there's nothing wrong with it except that this is often all that people know about it there's and a lot of it is for is for effect and for humor if you look at the map up in the upper right hand corner next to that map there's a little picture of a log building and the caption I don't think you can see that on. It says, Portland's first hotel. Log cabin, a door, no windows. Clearly meant to reinforce the whole idea of quaintness, of simplicity. What the tourists were coming up here for, to get away from the rush in places like Philadelphia, in Boston, in New York. And they were looking for this sort of thing. But as a document for historical accuracy, it's not wonderful. But down there in the lower left-hand corner, the next map over from the emblem to the left of the emblem is actually a copy of William Willis' map of colonial Portland as it existed in 1775. five. Very well and good. That's information. And then the panorama to the right of the emblem is actually from an engraving made in the early 19th century that showed the town shortly after it had been rebuilt. Now, once again, appealing to your, once again,, we're dealing with basic history here that most people would accept or what they've been told. For most people who have studied a little bit of colonial history, you'll recognize that this is a bill of exchange. Really, bills of exchange were a glorified type of barter. Really, bills of exchange were a glorified type of barter. They would state what the owner of a particular block of goods thought those goods were worth. They would find somebody who was willing to exchange with them for a bill of exchange stating this amount, and then the trade would take place.
[46:49] Speaker A (unidentified): just look out that way
[46:51] Speaker J (unidentified): oh look out that way I'm sorry as I said if you find that I am drifting here do call me back I will respond in any case to the problem with bills of exchange is that they were mostly handwritten scribbled on pieces of scrap paper If you look carefully at this slide, at this image, you'll see a crease going across a piece of paper that bisects the signature at the end. The contents of it are really not important here. What I'm trying to get you to look at is the material that it's made of and how it's written. That crease that goes through there indicates that this is a part of an old envelope. So that's how business was carried on. Occasionally, bills of exchange were printed up. Can you all hear me well enough? Oh, good,, good. Hang on just a moment, please. So there's not many of these bills of exchange left around. There's a couple of fragments at the Maine Historical Society on Congress Street in Portland. but really they're in even worse condition than this they're torn it's they fall apart instantly in Bermuda I was speaking to the archivist down there and she said they used to have a great many of these but they literally fell apart because of the humidity down there the stuff would rot away way. Here we go. And here we get to the last piece of information that people know about Portland. And it's really not that much. The mass trade. Here is a mass chip. It looks rather small, and it is relatively small. A flute. But as we will find out, for many Any of the pieces that are associated with the mass trade, much of the merchandise, was much smaller than a regular mast. Most of it consisted of booms and spars and could be easily loaded through a stern hatch. If you look at this diagram carefully, you'll see that the stern of the boat, the transom, has folded down on massive iron hinges, and they're loading the materials into the boat from that angle. You could also load them in through a hatchway, or you could load them in through a portal in the deck of the boat. But generally speaking, it was kept simple like this. And that's about it for the mass trade, from what most people knew. How do you get a cash? Here's a question for you. How do you get a cash-wealthy community to emerge out of a posited single-crop economy, in this case, masks? The answer is, and any economist will tell you this, you can't, especially if that trade is conducted almost exclusively, also as positive before, in debatable and fragile bills of exchange. And yet, in the first slide, I said to you, Falmouth was rich, and it remained rich right up to, it was increasing in prosperity, it was increasing in population density, immigration,, everything, right up to the day that it was destroyed on October 18th, 1775. Most histories of Falmouth and Portland, however, only offer the information that A, the mass trade was the basis of colonial Falmouth's economy. Okay, good enough as far as it goes. and that B, in 1775, the port was destroyed in an attack by the Royal Navy. But that's about all that you get. I remember when I was a child hearing that Falmouth in Massachusetts was attacked and destroyed by the Royal Navy, And I said to myself, being familiar with Cape Cod, because we vacationed up there, who would want to attack Falmouth on Cape Cod, fishing village? You know, what was the big deal? The fact is that it wasn't. And there is, as Dave here and I have discussed, a tremendous amount of misinformation about Falmouth that is out there because there is so little actual hard evidence. This was one of the great difficulties I encountered in writing my dissertation, the paucity of hard information. I had to go wide and I had to go far abroad in order to get the information I did. I can tell you that this idea that Falmouth was a poor place that was dealing only in mass is completely misleading regarding the complexity and vitality of society there, and of the thriving, diversified economy at Falmouth and Casco Bay just before the outset of the war for independence. So how did Falmouth get to be the way it was by 1775? Like I said, rich. In answering that question, we have to back off a little bit. This is another map from William Willis's wonderful history of Portland, one of the earliest representations, as it is in this case, Falmouth Neck in 1698. In fact, through most of the 17th century and into the 18th, this is all that Falmouth consisted of. There were a few people who had tried to settle in the interior parts of the town, including New Casco, which became the current town of Falmouth. But for the most part, for the whole 17th century, it was just this. A track along the water, which eventually became 4th Street, with a few buildings on it, mostly shacks. tracks, a track that led up the hill that eventually was grandly named King Street, and then another one at right angles at the top of the hill, which was named Queen Street, about 100 feet on either side of the end of King Street. And that was it. The houses were not big. There was a track over the hill, down to a ferry over the top of Munjoyville, down to a ferry that would carry you over to New Casco. But really, there was nothing there. And if that looks like one of the poorer fishing villages that still exist along the coast of Maine, you're not wrong. You're not wrong at all. But things began to change for Falmouth in 1727 when Colonel Westbrook moved the Royal Mast Agency from Portsmouth, New Hampshire, to Portland, to Falmouth. The reason he did so was really quite straightforward. His actual gig was as a real estate developer. And he knew that there were enormous groves, particularly as other people have mentioned, enormous groves of Mr. Pride, I believe, enormous groves of white pines right in the immediate vicinity of what is now Portland, particularly down in Dunstan. There was a huge grove of them down there. And you can see from this wonderful diagram of the beastie to the left here, the Pinus or Pinus strobus, the great eastern white pine, that what they were after was that lower part. That was your mast right there, nice and straight. Now, in the terms of the growing habit, in order to get that, if you've tried to plant a white pine out in front of your house, as I did in our house in Cape Elizabeth back in the day, what you get is that bushy bit on top immediately,. immediately. In order to get this growth pattern, it has to be growing in a grove of white pines where it has to search, as it had for the previous 60 million years of its evolution, to try and find sunlight. Then it would go straight up, drop the unnecessary branches,, and hey presto, you've got that lovely long straight trunk. Over on the right-hand side here, we have a fairly typical arrangement for a mast. This design is a little bit later than when we're talking about because this is what is called a segmented mast, but the outlay of it is generally the same. and you see the amount of wood that is necessary in it. This will become a little more important as this talk goes on. Here is a moderately typical mast landing on the coast of Massachusetts' main district in the late colonial era. Note that although the branches have been removed from the trunks, the bark is still attached to them. them those would be depart and other processing done at the mast house in falmouth now we get into the nitty-gritty here i promise you this is the only chart with any figures on it the only one i want you to take a look at is the top one for the king's tree and note how much it was worth in, oh dear, that's been obscured by that red arrow, well, $64,000 in 2020 dollars. A translation using a complicated formula from the pounds that you see there. What I want you to, however, pay attention to here is that the Royal Navy required more or less 12,000 mass trees per year. So for masts alone, that might have represented an annual layout of the equivalent of $73,200,000 or more in today's money, just for the masts. With the additional purchase of spars and other supplies by the Royal Navy, as well as sales to private mariners and supply of Cumberland County's ship and boat yards, of which Dave told me there were at least two here on the Presumpt Scott River, the total profit would have been worth several hundred million dollars in 226 USD. That is no chump change. And it was probably a lot more once you added in other factors that I'll be talking about in a moment. So here's where the private profit came in. Silver and gold coins were familiar in Falmouth in Casco Bay around 1775. The Royal Navy insisted in paying its debts in specie. In fact, it was required to by law. A great boon for Falmouth. Now, this could have gone very wrong if there had been dishonest men in connection here. On the left there you see the Mexican 8 real piece, also known as the Spanish dollar, which could be and was often divided up into eight pieces a quarter of it being divided into therefore we get the name two bits from that a slang for a quarter dollar nowadays that was the more common of these two coins but the gold coins that the British gold guinea which is worth a hundred pounds was also available and was used as we will see this is the Tate house the headquarters of the Royal Mast agency as it appeared in 1931 just before it was acquired by the colonial dames if you look carefully at it you can see each one of the sets that's two windows, is decorated differently. It was divided up. It was either a boarding house or apartments. George Tate, the senior royal mast agent until 1775, did not try to enrich himself through graft, but did a very good job of spreading the wealth around coastal Cumberland County and adjacent areas. areas. The lumber, the lumberjacks were paid on time. The specialists in mass preparation were paid on time. The Oxwain operators were paid on time. All ships of the British Royal Navy carried multiple spare spars, booms, and eventually mast segments, as well as extra and other grades of line, blocks and assorted tackle, hardware and sundry items needed by the ship's carpenter for maintenance of the vessel, as well as fabrics such as canvas and sailcloth. All of these could be attained in Falmouth. Now, this superstructure that you see in the illustration to the side, Generally, the spares remained below decks. When they went into battle, they'd build one of these gallows, as they called them, to store the spare booms and mast parts so that they could be easily accessed, to repair the masts and spars that had been blown away. But the thing is accessibility and that they were always on board the ship. Here's a nice diagram of logging in Cumberland County in the late 18th, early 19th century. I wish we had time to go over this in detail. But you can see there that there were methods that they had for measuring the height of trees, lovely double-bit axe and the cross-cut saws, methods which you have all used at one time or another for cutting down a tree. These wonderful axes and spuds in the central bit here that were used for clearing off the branches and the bark from the trees. Various wains here by which you could twitch the logs out of the woods. And I want you to remember that picture down in the lower right-hand corner. That is of a log jam up in the White Mountains. It has a great deal to do with what happened to Falmouth and southern Maine in the days following October 18, 1775. You actually see mass trees every day. Over there on the left side, that's a mass tree. I know it's a telephone pole, but it's a mastery, and they use it for the same reason all the way up to today. They have not been replaced for the simple reason, A, they're cheap, B, they're flexible, and they remain flexible for decades so that if there's a high wind, If there's ice on the poles or ice on the lines, they do not bend and break. Most of the time, if you see a broken telephone pole, it's because some idiot in an internal combustion vehicle has run into it. Nowadays, most of these are what we would call mass pines. White pines, as you might suspect, requiring that growing environment for their habit of going straight up, are not suitable for telephone piles nowadays. This is a plantation of loblolly pines in one of the Carolinas. Most of the trees that are used for this, but you could still use them for masks. You could still prep them the same way. The Royal Masthouse in Portland, in Falmouth, stood on Clark's or Bramhall's Point at the very southernmost tip of Falmouth Neck. If you think of going – if you're heading southwest on Commercial Street and you come up on that curve towards where it connects with the road that's going to go out over the bridge to South Portland, off to the side here on the left-hand side, you can see an area down there where there's warehouses and something else. that's where the mast house was. And it probably did not look like the ones here pictured from England at Blackpool or at Chatham, but more like the one from France, which is the second from the bottom. You also have different types of shaves there. Once again, that flute ship and three-man hoist for moving logs around. They had these all over the waterfront. I do have a point that I'm getting to with all of this, and that you'll see in a few minutes. Here's some wonderful, pictures of the way that ships were built in the 17th century. That ship's railway over to the right in the upper left-hand corner was recently discovered in the Thames when it reached low water in one of the past two years. And they were able to chart it. And in all fact, it's very typical of what there was in those days for building and launching a ship. Next to that, to the right, you can see a riveter busily at work on the transom of the ship. A couple of his tools down below. The broad-axe is still used, one of the oldest and most useful of the ship's carpenter's tools. tools. Further to the right, you have various ship designs, riveting hammers, and boat designs. Down below, you have two boats. I have to tell you that all this activity took place in Falmouth, and all of everything I've shown you so far and will be showing you is money producing activity and could all be or could all be traded for money for hard cash this is what part of what held other parts of the country back the types of ships and boats that were familiar in Falmouth the only one that would not have been built here, all of the others would have been, is the one in the center at the top. That's an East India man. But I include that because we did have an East India man here, which was bought by the extremely rich merchant, Robert Pagan, who was also important in Canadian history. He brought it here and renamed it the Falmouth. They had plans for the big shipyard, which was to the east of the foot of India Street as it is now. they had plans to build big ships there didn't quite get to it all sorts of things were planned in 1775 and i will be getting to these in a moment here's a recreation i made of one of the two biggest blacksmithies on the waterfront they were supplying flying very large hardware to the ships, joining bands, those huge iron hinges. The Pettengill brothers, I include this because they were also landowners in New Casco and Freeport. And that consideration becomes important. They lived down there in Falmouth near their business, naturally enough, but they also owned land and houses up there. This becomes an important consideration. Many of the people in Falmouth did own land and houses and farms elsewhere in coastal Cumberland County. Can you still understand me? I'm getting kind of worse here. Some more artifacts of industry in Falmouth, and I'm just scraping the surface here, folks, just scraping the surface. Over there on the upper left-hand side is a brick kiln. There were a lot of brickyards in coastal Cumberland County. Much to my surprise, there is a lot of red clay suitable for the making of bricks. That's a good example of a brick kiln. Over here to the right on the top is an example, a reconstruction by me, of a pine tar and turpentine kiln. Well, they call it a kiln because it did heat up, but there was never a fire in it. What they would do is take scraps of the wood. You've heard of fatwood from the Carolinas, which they say everybody in this room knows that there's something that burns better than that. And it's white pine, white pine scraps. Oh, give me white pine twigs any day to start a fire. Well, that's what they'd load up into that pile there, into the main part of the kiln. And it was all through decay. And the liquids would come down off of the decaying through a grate down in the bottom in a catchment, delivered by a tube to that catchment basement. Down in the bottom of it would be pitch. Up in the top of it would be turpentine. Both of them tremendously useful accoutrements, not only for shipbuilding, but in home building and turpentine in medicine. Some of the medicines that we still use today are based on turpentine. Down below, the sash sawmill, probably invented in Maine in the 17th century. Once again, because of the lack of labor, the lack of available labor. In England, over on the right-hand side, you'll see that there's a pit sawyer using a pit saw, as there is down on the lower end. The sash sawmill imitated that motion. ocean. And there were many of them in coastal Cumberland County, particularly out in Sakarapa, now Westbrook. Excuse me. Oh, here's another artifact you'll see on many of the old representations, particularly that wonderful impression made of Falmouth burnt by Moet, M-O-E-T, that there is a windmill up on the top of the hill there, and it's the only one in town there. It was constructed not for the grinding of corn, which we had plenty of growing here in Cumberland County, but for wheat that was imported from the Delaware and Chesapeake Peninsula, now known as the Delmarva. Wrap it up? Speed it up a little bit. Speed it up a little bit. I'm trying to. The reason we didn't have wheat here is because of a nasty bug called Ustilago Nigra, the black smut which rotted the wheat heads from the inside out. Here's the Perkins wonderful tidal gristmill down in Kennebunk, another victim of an act of arson in 1994. But that large opening in the left-hand building down below, that's where the wheel at the title wheel was. Things that they were spending money on. Surgeons. There were as many as six physicians in this little town, whose population was never more than 5,000. The leading of these was a man who was trained in London. His name was Nathaniel Coffin. He's important for other considerations. He would have had a surgeon's kit like that one to the left, which is probably made of silver. His wife, Elizabeth Foster Coffin, would have run the apothecary that was attached to his doctor's office. There were at least three apothecaries in Falmouth. More things that people spent their money on. I got that picture on the left from a collection down in the south, But what I want you to do is compare the embroidery on the waistcoat that you see there, including that detail over on the far right, with the embroidery on the lady's dress. That wonderful waistcoat was worn by the patriot leader Samuel Freeman at his wedding in 1786, but was probably made before 1775. More consumer goods, the famous silver tankard, which is at the Maine Historical Society, created by the silversmith John Butler, whose silversmithy was at the foot of what is now India Street. Right next door to the shop of Robert Pagan, who had wonderful trade goods from England, including things like this green-glazed creamware teapot. There was a tremendous amount to be had, there was a tremendous amount to be sold, and a tremendous amount of money to pass around. People also spent money on their houses. This is the famous Tate House out in Stroudwater, as I said, the headquarters of the Royal Mast Agency. It is actually a very good replica of a London townhouse. Both Mr. and Mrs. Tate came from London, and they wanted a London townhouse. And there's the entire interior of the sitting room. Down below, you've got two other fancy houses. which survived the burning of Falmouth. One is the Arthur Savage House on the right. And that thing up on the top is actually a naval observatory. It would sit a boy up there with a spyglass, and they would spot ships that were coming in. The one to the left is even more famous because Samuel Adams, our second president, who was then the king's advocate for the district, was a frequent visitor there. And when he visited Richard Codman in his house, he said that, I felt like I had gotten into the house of a nobleman. And he also had splendid dinners there, which I cover in one of my articles called Very Noble Suppers. Slavery was also a part of Falmouth's wealth. I include this because this issue touches a lot of raw nerves. I will suffice it to say that the woman on the left is indeed a slave. We have the documentation for that. Her name is Phyllis, and that is a dummy board, a full-length dummy board portrait of her. The objection being raised by Maine historians is that she doesn't look African. She doesn't look like a slave. The only person in these pictures who looks like a slave is the boy Isaac in the middle of those three photographs. But trust me when I say that the boy Charlie, who looks like he's got brown hair or even dark blonde hair, was a slave. The drop sinister refers to the fact that you were traced back seven generations. That's correct? Seven generations. Seven generations. generations. And if you had any, ancestors in that time who were slaves, and this was all covered, this was all part of the structure of slave law, which I cover in my, I'm going to do a little bragging here, my article, Securing the Leg Irons, which has been referenced by studies all over the world. I'm very pleased to present you with this chart, which has also been referenced all over the world. This is fairly easy to follow. This is the slave trade routes going to Falmouth. The size of the lettering of these places shows the relative demand for slaves. The largest demand in the British dominions was Jamaica. Next was Charleston. Next, believe it or not, was New York, New York. The largest slave market in North America was not in Charleston, however. It was in Newport, Rhode Island, and you can still see it there. And from there, various items would dribble out. Now, Phyllis was born and raised, born, I should say, and bred and trained in Barbados and found her way to Falmouth as a trained lady's maid. There were other slaves in town who were trained as medical assistants or as carpenter's assistants. These were the most expensive slaves. And I have to tell you, in all cases, going back one, at all times in the history of slavery, you have to remember the most expensive slaves, the equivalent of hundreds of thousands of dollars in today's currency, were pink people. They had pink skins, and they were also highly trained, and it's something that a lot of people have a hard time swallowing. So we've gotten to population density and settlement density in Falmouth, in Casco Bay. This, as opposed to Willis's representation of the same area, is accurate. I had hoped to bring in with me copies of the map to distribute, but my life gets in the way of me. But you can access this map online. I believe, David, you said you have this map on your – I hereby grant you –
[1:25:15] Speaker F (unidentified): No, not that one.
[1:25:16] Speaker J (unidentified): I hereby grant you permission to put it up on your website, okay? There we go. Yeah, I'm almost done. What do you mean, just wrap it up? I'm wrapping it up here. Okay. I want to point out to you that for all that beautiful development there, everything, I had hoped to go over this with you, But everything on the waterfront and everything, almost everything on the right-hand side of that chart there was burnt, was burnt. Why,, why, if Falmouth was so very important to the Royal Navy, why then was it to be summarily destroyed by forces of that very same institution? The answer is both simple and brutal. It was, in fact, governed by a string of spectacular procedural blunders characterized by some of the very worst strategic decisions made in all of British history. You may recognize the man on the left. That's Lieutenant Henry Mowat. Be very correct. Correct. He was always a lieutenant at this point. He was never a captain. For those of you who may have read the Patrick O'Brien books, it was a courtesy to call a lieutenant who got his first command a captain, but that in fact was not it. By 1775, he was deeply frustrated because by that At that time, he had been for 21 years a lieutenant and was looking at what he was afraid was a perpetual lieutenancy. But he is not the villain of this case. John Montague, the fourth Earl of Sandwich, first Lord of the Admiralty in 1775, active politician, friend of George III, Third, avid exponent of the coercive acts, handsome, vain. He had multiple portraits painted of himself, an inveterate gambler, maybe even a gambling addict, a womanizer and woman abuser, as well as a drunkard. Still, he has many defenders in British academia because, in many ways, he was a very clever and capable administrator. Nevertheless, the responsibility for the directive that Henry Mowat followed, with which you may be familiar, is that you shall chastise the coastal towns of New England. And Mowat thought that by carrying this out to the letter that he could get a post-captaincy. Here is a representation of the Canseau. I wanted to go into this in more detail, but the man who drew this was a naval draftsman, and that's probably a pretty accurate representation. The ship itself only had a keel of 60 feet 11 inches. It was not big. It was a sloop, three-masted, no stern castle, as you can see. And it was not a ship of war. It was His Majesty's armed vessel. That's what the HMAV stands for. It had six 12-pound carriage guns, referred to by some historians as pea shooters, and then eight swivel guns, which were mounted towards the back there. It was, these were not intended as offensive weapons. There you have a model of a 12-pounder. Those balls are about the size of a softball. They did not do much damage to the town. Here is something that did do damage to the town, a naval mortar with its shell or bomb. This is a proper bomb ship. They called it a bomb because of the shells that were loaded into the mortar, which were called bombs. They had shrapnel and gunpowder inside them. They had a superstructure underneath where the gun was mounted to absorb and distribute the recoil from the gun. What happened in Falmouth, however, is that they had they had a converted catch and they had mounted the gun directly on the keel of the boat and they fired it off once. Oh, well, it's leaking a little bit. Not too bad. Fired it off twice, began to sink. So they didn't get much out of these out of these mortars. But one of them did land between Pagan's shop and John Butler's silversmithy and destroyed both of them. There's no reason to believe that the Marines who went ashore in Falmouth were not dressed like this, although there were certain patriotic writers in the 19th century who insisted that they were dressed ragtag. They were probably dressed like this. Howe would have seen to that down in Boston. To your right there is a typical naval torch, a piece of hardwood, line coiled around it and secured with tacks or nails. When you went ashore, you would dip it into a bucket of pitch, light it of blaze. It was not for light. It was an incendiary device. Most discussions of the burning of Falmouth end up with a very dramatic picture of fire. This, I think, gives a much better idea. This picture is actually from California a few years ago. But you have the scorched trees. You have the crumbling chimneys. You have the ground littered with a layer of ash and debris and black skies behind it because the evening of the destruction a storm came in and every even though it put what put out the lingering embers of the fire what was left was a complete uninhabitable morass now the people were refugees from the town went shuffling out some of them were lucky and had houses already or places they could go to. Remember the Pettengills who had the blacksmithy? They owned property in New Casco, now Falmouth, and in Freeport. Other people had houses and farms they could go to. Others were out of luck and they fled led as soon as possible in two directions. The Loyalists went north, first to Castine and then to St. Andrews. If you ever get an opportunity to go see it at St. Andrews, that was supposed to be a perfected version of Falmouth. The others went south to places where they'd come from in Massachusetts. Massachusetts, and the ones who were able to stay here, they were the lucky ones, but anyone who didn't have a place to stay found doors slammed in their faces. This was because of something that I call the town and country dichotomy. This is an area of study in American colonial history. That's still under development. The issue of mass PTSD in a single population, as well as individual PTSD, and it caused people to be very angry and very sick, and there was always this hatred between the rural people and the town people, because the rural people thought they were being cheated from the prosperity that they saw in town. This is the Whipple Farm here on the campus of Ocean View and it is a fairly typical example of the 18th century farmsteads that existed in town so to conclude I'd like to quote from the gospel of St. Matthew the sermon on the mount as I'm sure the Episcopalians whose church was destroyed in town would certainly have quoted this to one another because it is there in the Book of Common Prayer. Lay not up for yourselves treasures on earth where moth and dust doth corrupt and where thieves break through and steal, but rather lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven where moth and dust doth not corrupt and where thieves break not through nor steal. deal. For where your treasure is, your heart will be oh so. And if your treasure has been burned to a crisp, what is there left for you? Thank you. Thank you, Patrick.
[1:36:11] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Thank you very much, Patrick. I think we've run kind of long here, so I think we'll close for the evening. And if you're here, of course, talk to Patrick. He'll do is after the meeting so thank you very much everyone and good night yes and i'm open
[1:36:28] Speaker J (unidentified): to questions from any