← Back to MaineScanner

Kennebunk Planning Board Reviews Subdivisions and Mobile Home Park Proposal

2026-10-26 · Source: Planning Board 10-26-26 (Kennebunk TV (Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:22] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. I'd like to call into session tonight's meeting of the Kennebunk Planning Board. Today is Monday, October 26, 2026. First item on our agenda is a preliminary plan completeness review for a major subdivision along the first part of Truman's Field Road. Hannah, if you could introduce this project to us again, and we'll hear from the applicant. [0:56] Speaker B (unidentified): so this is the planning board's first read of this application since the sketch plan application back in the spring the board held a site walk on april 11th this plan proposes seven residential lots on the existing portion of trumans field road at the entrance or past the entrance but the existing portion i'll say of truman's field road which was approved within the last couple of years the lots would all be served on individual septic systems and well public water public water public water thank you they all mix together individual septic systems and public water the application or the applicant did request a couple of waivers in their application one of them I did note is no longer needed based on additional information that was submitted so as of right now you're looking at a waiver for submission items related to the septic system designs a stormwater plan and the high intensity soil survey and then a couple of further waivers that are not related to completeness but are related to the landscaping design so based on my review we did have some back and forth with the applicant submitting some additional information based on my review they have submitted all items or requested a waiver from them at this point for completeness [2:23] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you for yours I turn the mic at the bottom of them no there [2:30] Speaker C (unidentified): you go thank you good evening my name is Lucian Lang love bh2m this project was previously presented to you by Jason Vafiatas as of Atlantic resource consultants and maybe it sure Jason Vafiatas was the previous agent on this project of Atlantic Resource Consultants then Verdantas so if you see some names around here that's how that happened I was part of Atlantic Resource Consultants and Verdantas so I've been working in this general area this project site since about 2022 so this has been in the works for a while you're just hearing from me tonight now representing as bh2m for the applicant and Hannah gave a good overview of this we've been working with her to address some of the comments through our preliminary plan submission of this project and I guess some of the notable improvements that we've made since the sketch plan in the site walk that you guys had we've added additional test pits to find secondary suitable locations for each lot that's proposed there are five lots on the left side of your screen and two on the right each one has, or the ones on the right have two test pits. The ones on the right each have one. Per the ordinance, if there's a test pit with 15 inches or less of a limiting factor, we have to provide two, and there were a couple lots on there too. So it was a good thing that we did provide those test pits to really make sure that we do have adequate wastewater disposal. Public water is already installed. that's in the road and it will be used to serve this project we're taking advantage of the existing condition out here which is the road there's there's really not there's no improvements that are proposed in this application this road for the portion that's not paved it's been graveled it's been finely graded it was a road that was designed by an engineer from Jason Vafiotis it was submitted to the Code Enforcement Office. We've been working with Foglio Construction to get this constructed. It's been compacted, tested, designed by an engineer to make sure everything's been done right. So we see that we have a thorough, full, and application to give you tonight, and we're aiming for completeness to keep this moving. This project doesn't require any wetland impacts. the this project's proposed lot division the individual lot development is relatively minor we'll have to make sure that you know Roche controls are used throughout individual lot development but besides that there's really not a there's really not an impact on natural resources for this project we're trying to take advantage of the upland areas off this existing road thank [5:28] Speaker A (unidentified): you about the road so does each lot come with a deeded like right-of-way to it or what's the story who owns the road and how is it this is [5:42] Speaker C (unidentified): a right-of-way and there's a Road Association which everybody will be a part of and they'll pay their dues says Chris [5:54] Speaker A (unidentified): are there Chris Ostrada town engineer welcome is there I'm not sure if we've seen a subdivision where there's already an existing road and there's lots on both sides of it and there's special review that we need to worry about here or what's the story [6:12] Speaker D (unidentified): that's kind of a leading question so you typically don't see subdivisions off of a road because the investment usually occurs to get to building the lots this is what I would say a little bit there's nothing wrong with it 's a little bit different what I would say is ultimately when you review this that road has to comply with the town standards they have provided information what it appears is they've taken that in consideration when the road was constructed so ultimately through this process if you determine it complete I'm going to review it is the roads not there if there's improvements very deficient I'm gonna identify that make a recommendation that they need to be improved I don't see that but ultimately that's how it would go this way one thing that is noted that is a bit unusual we did talk to legal counsel about that is the some of those Lots will actually have an easement on it so you end up with that effective 50-foot right away because the position of the road was kind of modified. The fact that it is some remnant of the original Truman's Field Road, I think they tried to follow that area and establish it as it was. So we're going to almost be looking at this as if it's not there. We will look at it. What Lucian alluded to, and I think is positive, is most of that area has been designed and constructed. They've provided evidence that the gravels do meet that. If there's an area that we have concern, we can conduct a test bit and test it. So, what I will say is ultimately if I'm going to make a recommendation to the board to sign off on it, I'm going to look at it as if it will meet all of our standards that way. [7:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, great. All right, board members, do you have questions? Start with you, Ted. [7:47] Speaker E (unidentified): On the sidewalk when we were out there, and note that the houses is a steep bank and then it goes into a wetland and the brook right behind those houses on the left side of the road coming in. and that we then asked for the wetlands on the maps, and that was provided in the revision. But I was looking at, okay, that's a pretty sensitive area. It's a very steep bank. The houses are right along it, and I worry about the stormwater drainage. So I was looking for the plan, and I noticed there's a waiver request to not do one, and there's something about if there's a problem that comes up during construction, it would be dealt with. And to me, that's not enough. I'd like to see a stormwater drainage plan. That's important to me. And there's other waivers I'll get to later, but my second point is that we have in front of the planning board four projects that are all related and running around Thompson Road,, and two that run on Truman Field Road. And so looking at this, that's a massive traffic impact. And not only on Thompson Road, Alewife Road, and Alford Road in general, all four, looking at that. And so we had discussed the last time we're looking at another project on this road that needed to have some coordination or something to look at the combined impact of all these projects on the traffic. We just can't do it piecemeal. And I think that's a big, concern. Trumansfield Road particularly coming in and Thompson Road coming in and the four-way stop on Alfred Road, which would be a lot of the traffic going into town would go that way. And those of us that live in that area and use that road all the time already know it's a traffic jam. And that's probably something, Chris, the town's going to work on. It's a coordinated traffic study. [9:59] Speaker D (unidentified): What will happen, actually, this particular project won't individually trigger a traffic study, but the larger project that is on the agenda will, and when that goes to the traffic movement permit process, they actually are requested to incorporate and identify all these other developments at the same time. So if they weren't doing that, hearing the concerns of the board, the town would probably individually look at that, because that's going to happen concurrently, would be part of that process. So this is an instance where timing is actually good, because all these things are happening at the same time. they're in the development pipeline so that will all be accounted for in that regional traffic study that's going to occur yeah because it's it's pretty [10:35] Speaker E (unidentified): tricky it's already a mess there and this is a serious issue so okay so it has been looked at as a coordinated project and that's that's that's all we [10:45] Speaker D (unidentified): could ask for and look at that carefully let me just want to clarify that the term it when it the study will consider all of those it's not going to coordinate those if there's deficiencies those intersections those improvements need to be made but it's not going to say you put your driveway here there are those types of things the board will do that so what happens if they're just to [11:05] Speaker E (unidentified): give me information if there's there's a massive trap let's say there's a traffic impact in some construction is going to have to be done to accommodate that how [11:14] Speaker D (unidentified): is that financed so what would happen under traffic movement permit and it's kind of getting a little bit of it is not specific to them is during a study they look at the existing conditions, they look at the level of service at an intersection that's measurable in terms of delay, and then as they do their traffic projections, they'll actually see if there's impacts to that, and through the process would identify any mitigation that's necessitated to do that. That all falls on the developer. So take Thompson Road and Mill Street, that's a four-way stop sign. If there's improvements that need to be made there to fix operations because you can't queue back for another 1,000 feet, Sometimes there may be a provision for a turn lane or those types of things. All those costs will be borne by the developer because they're the ones who are creating the impact. [11:57] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. Those are my questions for the time being. I guess we'll do the waivers later. [12:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I mean, I think you bring up a good point about the stormwater and the erosion control situation, and I would agree with you that I think there needs to be a stormwater plan and erosion control plan for the subdivision, even though you said the road's already done, we need to know what the impacts of our stormwater are. These lots will be developed. There will be runoff generated from them, and we need to know the impact. And as Chris said, he's going to review it as if the road isn't there now, and so we're going to have to take that into account. [12:41] Speaker C (unidentified): That's valid, and we've had this discussion. We'd be happy to provide a stormwater report, and we've talked about some erosion control details that we can add, particular for a project like this there's usually like a detail that will add that will be a conceptual lot development that show a construction entrance sediment barriers and other best management practices for them to take but that and combined with the stormwater report I think would address that concern Richard [13:06] Speaker F (unidentified): yeah [13:10] Speaker G (unidentified): I've got the same concerns we need to see a stormwater plan for the entire project not just not just because the road is built we don't need to we need to see where the drainage is going for off the lots as well as off the road and we want to make sure that Ward Brook which runs over part of this property is protected because that eventually runs into the river and we were struggling to keep that River as pristine as possible or And so it's important to that hydrology, that entire area that we know where the drainage goes and what it can absorb. So I think that's the first point. We need to see that. One other question I have is, what's the travel width of that road? [14:12] Speaker C (unidentified): That's 24 foot wide. [14:15] Speaker G (unidentified): The travel width is 24? Yeah. Okay. Now, it's all asphalted down to that little stream? [14:23] Speaker C (unidentified): No, not today. Not today? No, it will be paved. Today, a portion of it's been base paved. The rest has been fine graveled. Let me rephrase the question. [14:35] Speaker G (unidentified): Are you planning to pave it to that brook to develop this property? [14:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Not directly to the brook for this project. It goes to the hammerhead and it goes slightly. [14:45] Speaker G (unidentified): So it goes to the end of Lot 7, which is before the brook? [14:50] Speaker C (unidentified): It does go to just about the end of Lot 7, correct. [14:53] Speaker G (unidentified): And that's before the brook? [14:55] Speaker C (unidentified): That's before the brook, yep. [14:56] Speaker G (unidentified): So the next question is then we're going to need to have some kind of a plan so the fire department can go in and turn around and that the fire chief is satisfied that what you provide is going to be a safe way for him to get his vehicles and men in and out of out of there we're happy to do that and i jason [15:18] Speaker C (unidentified): has experience in kenny bunk but we're still happy to show that to the fire chief and make sure the largest truck can you'll need to we will there's a there's a terminus with 50 foot legs off of it so we 've looked into this but we'll make sure that we do coordinate with the fire [15:32] Speaker G (unidentified): chief yeah he needs he needs to be able to sign off that he's satisfied with that too many pieces of paper here as i already said we need to get the wetland review for the for the whole project and chris you said that you didn't you didn't look at the road while it was being built to make sure that the subsurfaces were done correctly and up to standard [16:10] Speaker D (unidentified): or anything that is correct that rule was constructed not as part of a permitted review process was done as an extension more or less like a an enhanced driveway because it went through regular building permit process for those first few lots they didn't trigger the subdivision standard that's why we didn't review it to that part but we'll look at it and make sure that what is there does meet our standard thank you and we are prepared to provide [16:34] Speaker C (unidentified): whether whatever documentation you need for that whether it's compaction tests from sw cole or our submittals through foglio you know we've been involved with that you've [16:43] Speaker G (unidentified): got to satisfy our engineer you mentioned it in one of your part of the write-up or actually in the planning board memo i noticed that you're not you're looking for us do i understand this correctly you're asking for us not to review the landscaping design we [17:17] Speaker C (unidentified): are not proposing landscaping as part of this project so there'll be no street trees or anything not proposed right now officially on the plan I think we need to look at that we [17:33] Speaker G (unidentified): part of a subdivision requirement okay so we will and we do need to review a landscaping plan and you need to provide one to us okay sorry it takes me so long but like I said it's a lot of paper you don't have any open space proposal in [18:09] Speaker C (unidentified): this with this project there's no open space correct is there a reason there's there's none left on this side of the stream I mean for the north side of the stream that's all being proposed as remaining land to be left undeveloped at this time but there's not a proposed open space on the south side of the stream I [18:30] Speaker G (unidentified): guess at this point out seed by time thank you thanks Richard Janice [18:55] Speaker H (unidentified): thank you Chris a couple questions here can you show me on the map where you have the 75 foot DEP stream setback shown because I don't see it on your [19:04] Speaker C (unidentified): map? We should have put that on the existing conditions. On this plan that we have up right here, that is depicting the shoreline overlay for the building setback. So on that particular plan, the 75 foot is not depicted. Okay, so you can point to it on the map [19:24] Speaker H (unidentified): where I might find it approximately. And I'd like to see that shown on your next version of your mapping. and will you be applying to the dep for a permit because you can't build houses within that without [19:40] Speaker C (unidentified): the permit correct if there was any development on lot five or any other loss within 75 feet we would have to get a dep permit for that lot five is the tightest lot you know on this area the remaining lots can be built without any impact within 75 feet depending on the final house and the final conditions of Lot 5, it's possible that there could be encroachment into that 75-foot setback from DEP. [20:05] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay. We would require that permit to be in place before we would get the final approval. Okay. Okay. [20:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Do you see it on there, Hannah? Yeah. Okay. Is it on this sheet? Sorry, I'm looking at the legend. I didn't see it. [20:22] Speaker C (unidentified): This looks like the option before this. It doesn't seem like we've added it to this plan. [20:33] Speaker B (unidentified): I know you've submitted plans with it on it because I've drawn them with different color markers and everything But I also don't see them on these plans So I'm not sure if they got deleted in some iteration, but yeah, it looks like it got left off Turn that layer back on in your next admission. We [20:51] Speaker G (unidentified): need to see it on the one. We're gonna review. Yeah the one with the lots depicted [21:00] Speaker H (unidentified): Next question What is the reason you have lots, basically, you know, one, two, three, four, encompassing, you know, the whole stream and the wetlands and all that? You know, one suggestion we had at the site walk was that basically you cut those lots off and have that area, you know, deeded to the land trust or open space held by the HOA or whatever. My fear is that when you basically hand a stream over to a private homeowner, they don't know any better. You know, you're going to find a fire pit down there in the wetlands, setbacks, and you're going to have sheds and, you know, whatever people have recreations of. I'd like you to reconsider that because I just think it protects the stream to have it in common ownership and not have it in the private homeowners ownership the when I look at your setback lines here it looks like your lot to setback there isn't one it goes right up to the roadway and in fact all of those need to be kind of looked at I don't see that front setback shown and rather than labeling the lots upland and I'd like to see you use the gross and net building area figures for us and can you tell me what the degree of the slope is to the stream it's it's [22:43] Speaker C (unidentified): variable there are some areas that may be three to one there are other areas that may be more of a 25% or so okay because 20% you have to net out of your [22:55] Speaker H (unidentified): lots or anything more let's see and your septics of course have to be a hundred feet from the stream the edge of the stream bed we had asked you to move them up to the front along the roadway so I've noticed you still have test pits [23:11] Speaker C (unidentified): down close to the wetlands they were moved as close to the front as we could to still fit a house within there and a driveway and other features but I did take that into consideration but still had to make sure we had suitable soils and a secondary location yeah i mean we don't want any septic tanks down in [23:29] Speaker H (unidentified): the wetlands area and lot three just looks like i'm not sure where you would put the driveway and not go through the 25 foot no disturbance buffer around the cemetery can you show me where you [23:46] Speaker C (unidentified): would put the driveway as close as we can to that southern lot line is where we would come in to Maintain that 25 foot notice our buffer [23:56] Speaker B (unidentified): So Janice the driveway does not need to meet the setbacks of the lot like a building has to so they can put a driveway Within a couple feet of that lot line, which they do have enough room there outside of that 25 foot [24:10] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay Thank You Hannah and Can you show me give me a little information about the 30 foot access and utility easement, what is that intended for? [24:26] Speaker C (unidentified): The utility easement, that's part of Truman's Field Road, so that encompasses the utilities which run under or are part of Truman's Field Road. So that's the water main and the power from Kenny Boncline Power. [24:40] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay. I mean, that's single and perpendicular, right? [24:44] Speaker C (unidentified): I'm sorry, which easement? Is that what you want to ask? [24:48] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, show me. Yeah. Let me try to find it on the map so I can reference it. I wrote it down, but I didn't write it on the map. I'll come back to that. That's all I have for the moment. Sorry, [25:02] Speaker B (unidentified): I think she's referencing this. That's on your existing conditions plan, which is an access easement to a lot. Yeah, that's it. It's a different lot completely separate from the subdivision. That's an access and utility easement to another lot. [25:16] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay, so that's to reach more lots behind it. Yes. Okay. All right, that's all I have. Thank you for entering that. [25:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks, Janice. Kevin? [25:27] Speaker I (unidentified): Thanks, Chris. I wasn't present at the previous review or the site walk, so my context is limited. I agree with the points about erosion control and stormwater management. It seems prudent given the slope of the site. Landscape plan would also be great to see. A little surprised to see it absent. I'm curious, the lot lines that kind of curve over the road, that's the access easement that Christos Ryder was mentioning earlier, is that right? Yes. Okay. That is it. And I guess this is a question maybe more for staff. On the first, the sewage disposal waiver request, it says if the Board grants this request, the condition of approval should be placed on the final plan. can you describe what exactly that entails yeah so the standard in the [26:18] Speaker B (unidentified): ordinance is that the applicants submit both the test bits that show that they have adequate soils and the actual design of each of the septic systems their request in this is that the designs not need to be submitted until someone would submit as a for a building permit rather than having all the septic [26:38] Speaker I (unidentified): and designs submitted up front and what would the condition of approval be would [26:44] Speaker B (unidentified): that be on this plan or the future would be on the final plan so one step or I guess kind of two steps from now and it would just be stated essentially that those have not been submitted yet and they would obviously need to be submitted later they would get resubmitted later if they were submitted already but just to note that they have not been reviewed yet and they would be submitted to the [27:04] Speaker I (unidentified): code officer thanks Anna that's all Chris can I follow up on that who [27:12] Speaker B (unidentified): would they submit those to later on they get submitted to the code officers when [27:16] Speaker G (unidentified): they wouldn't come back to us no in [27:24] Speaker D (unidentified): just to talk about that for a brief second I think in the end at this point it's speculative in terms of what there's lots can support whether it's a three-bedroom or four-bedroom home or whatever it makes much more sense when you have a perspective design that the two are aligned at this point rather than somebody going to submit a bunch of three-bedroom designs and somebody wants a four-bedroom home. I don't think that happens, but on occasion it has. I think it's a project we have to come back and amend it. So it does make a lot more sense to go about it that way. The code officer ultimately is going to look at it in aggregate. Thanks, Chris. [27:59] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, so I think the question now comes to the waiver requests that you have for your preliminary plan for submission requirements. so the first one was for this sewage disposal systems okay no it's like you're about to you had something that board members have questions or questions or concerns about the waiver request to submit the septic designs at sorry as a condition final plan approval so they wouldn't be submitted until a building permit yet then we have questions or concerns about that waiver request one [29:13] Speaker E (unidentified): of them was regarding the drainage plan the storm water we're [29:17] Speaker A (unidentified): talking right now about the septic decide oh sorry the first one any [29:24] Speaker G (unidentified): concerns I think as long as it's clearly thank you I think as long as it's clearly designated that they before any building permit is given that they need to submit and get approved a septic system for each lot as long as it's clearly marked and as long as whoever is going to buy these lots understands that they have to get that done so there's no confusion and no concern. I think that's appropriate. Do you have any questions? [30:10] Speaker A (unidentified): No. Kevin, you're right. All right, and sorry, for the remainder of this meeting, in absence of a regular member, Bob Metcalf, Kevin O'Rourke is a voting member for the remainder of this meeting, so he can vote on any of these things we have. All right, we're ready for a motion on that one. [30:28] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay. I will make a motion to approve the applicant's waiver request for relief from Article 6.3.C.2 when sewage disposal is to be accomplished by subsurface wastewater disposal systems, test pit analysis, and septic design prepared by a licensed site evaluator should be provided in response to the fact they have explained the process and when it will be done. [30:59] Speaker A (unidentified): with the condition that it be submitted as before any building permit is issued [31:05] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll accept that friendly amendment I'll second P I'll second it any [31:15] Speaker A (unidentified): discussion all those in favor all right that waiver has been granted there was a request for Or the second one about Article 63C4.A, which is no longer applicable because you submitted letters to serve from the utilities. So we'll move on to the third one you requested, which was Article 7.2.A.3, Stormwater Management and Stormwater Drainage and Erosion Control Plan. so I guess the question is we need to see that and we need to see a landscape plan I guess I'll ask Chris are these something that would give you concerns about reviewing it now versus before we get to final plan submission or I'm not [32:22] Speaker D (unidentified): as concerned about the landscape plan ultimately because that's predominantly gonna be located within right away ultimately the street layout is gonna to guide what's left for residual area so when they do that if something is out of the ordinary let's put it this way if they don't if they don't look at the landscape plan right now and cause it get redesigned it's going to go backwards so i'm not concerned about it right now i think [32:45] Speaker A (unidentified): the stormwater and erosion control plan what about that i would like to see before we approve a [32:52] Speaker D (unidentified): preliminary plan i think you can in essence what you'd be doing you would be if you were to choose to prove this for completeness it would be subject to them submitting that I don't begin my review until you do completeness okay so really what you're if you're gonna say it tonight you can say we approve it with the idea they can submit a plan and then when we come back and I've conducted my review it's got to be available for to do that so I'm not going to commence that review till we get it I mean in essence right now because of it the roads basically built everything is draining where it's going to drain what they're going to do is even evaluate the impacts of it they may size the rip rap outfalls and those types of things i don't anticipate like there's gonna be a large stormwater pond of those types of things constructed it should be i don't see this altering the layout or design of something this is definitely not sort of how we typically do it but in this instance if they would provide a supplemental stormwater erosion control plan it's pretty easy because we know what it already looks like today it's not going to cause us to look at a redesign i don't think richard yeah i [33:49] Speaker G (unidentified): think we need to see that before we get too far down I it's a sensitive area from a ecological point of view and I think we need to see that before the project gets too far down the road so if you're saying am I in favor of the waiver the answers no see I mean their [34:22] Speaker A (unidentified): request was that they don't need to provide it at all and I guess I'm saying would you be in favor of having it as a condition that it be provided before the final plan approval or sorry this is I [34:41] Speaker D (unidentified): think this is like the question of you know where are we actually yeah right I mean it in essence normally you wouldn't find a plan to be complete if all that information is available because here's once it's complete you're not providing anything additional for do it you should in theory use if you were to say yes tonight I'd walk away the package and start my review tomorrow morning that's that's very optimistic but you know the idea I think in this instance would be if you were to find it complete subject to them submitting a stormwater calculation then I could conduct my review that all we're doing is gonna come back in time if you said no we're not gonna find it complete tonight it's missing a stormwater management plan they're gonna resubmit in two weeks for stormwater management plan you're going to find it complete and then we're just going to restart the review in essence the completeness review determination won't happen until i have all that so while i would generally not recommend we be in this situation it's it's just redoing it again and [35:42] Speaker A (unidentified): again so they would need to submit it prior to them submitting a final plan to you they would [35:51] Speaker D (unidentified): So yeah, there's not going to be any final plan submission until I've already conducted my review. Okay. Yeah, absolutely. So their fate, in a perfect world, it'd be nice if they had everything tonight, and you acted upon it, and whatever decision you made, if it was complete, we'd conduct our review, and then turn that back around in let's just say two weeks, and they could see themselves on the next agenda. If they don't submit their stormwater management plan for a month, well, we can all do the math, and they're way out in the future. [36:17] Speaker A (unidentified): all right because we also with if we found it complete tonight we would need to send schedule a public hearing correct and so we would subject the public hearing date two weeks at you know basically we would have to we would give you time to have a chance to review the we would have to have I guess what I'm thinking is that we would have them give them two weeks to submit calculations to you and then we would do it public hearing like a month from [36:45] Speaker D (unidentified): now i think that's kind of yes that makes more sense in essence after if they were to submit this thing what you want to do is feel like you've had all the comments back to you when you schedule that public hearing you're not going into it hearing for the first time right so that makes a little bit more sense in terms of if you act on it tonight the next time you're saying you're saying you've already gotten my comments you're ready for public hearing yep is the board [37:08] Speaker A (unidentified): comfortable with that so [37:11] Speaker H (unidentified): you're saying we're okay to do it now we would condition the approval that [37:16] Speaker A (unidentified): they would submit a stormwater management plan an erosion plan and a landscape plan we'll just put all those three to be submitted within two weeks and then for the to give the town engineer time to review it before we would hold a public hearing four weeks from now mm-hmm and if Chris doesn't get the information in two weeks then we have the right to decline to have the [37:46] Speaker H (unidentified): public hearing in four weeks okay so basically we'll wait we would grant it as a condition as a condition I'm gonna let you make the motion on it are we [37:55] Speaker G (unidentified): granting the waiver we're not granting the waiver is what you're saying we are [38:00] Speaker A (unidentified): granting a modified waiver so we're granting the submission waiver as a [38:06] Speaker G (unidentified): condition why don't we just make him do what they're supposed to do excuse [38:11] Speaker J (unidentified): me yes sir my name is george kirk and i'm the landowner coming before you had a good time with the sidewalk and stuff it's not a question of doing what we're supposed to do i take a lot of pride in the work that i do in the towns that i work in i before i even come to this board i sat near the audience for four or five weeks to get what you people expect of a developer coming into here, not to earn a bad name. I ran into a little difficulty, as Lucian has explained, with one of the companies that we had hired. I apologize for not having the 75-foot setback on. We've had that before. You asked us about the test pits. I took what you said. I looked into it I addressed it immediately all I'm asking for you here tonight and I know that Chris has been out at the site Chris from the water district has been out there when I did the roads I'll give you all the impact and everything that was done it was done so if this community wanted to accept that road it was built to your standards the same way I've done in other communities and I remember that when the chair said boy you put sidewalks in I do not do a project without sidewalks. I've sat in the same seats that you have in other communities and I've served my community. All I'm asking here tonight is that you accept the plan that is presented with the conditions and I'll make sure that we've already started this stormwater work. It can be into Chris probably within the next three, four days and you'll have it. But time is critical for me also because I've got people that are interested in building there I tried to do everything that you've asked and considered everything that you've asked me to do I'm not looking to take a shortcut I've built homes in this community and I've got a subdivision on Dogwood I take no shortcuts you tell me what you want we did a sidewalk I'll do it and complete it that way and I do want to thank you for taking the time and allowing me to speak I'm not a hired gun I'm the guy that's doing the work and I think the Truman's field I've accommodated everybody on that street and I built it to the specification I've had many meetings with Chris and Hannah and frankly I'm kind of proud of the project the way it's coming out and I'm the only one that took care of that cemetery because it was disgraceful the way that was left for I don't know 20 30 years but I clean that cemetery up and whatever you need, Chris, I believe that Lucian can have whatever he needs within the next few days so that we can move this timetable up rather than keep putting us out and out and out. I'd appreciate that, Mr. Chair and members of the board. [41:17] Speaker G (unidentified): So my question still is, are we granting a waiver or what you said, a semi-waiver? Well, no. What are we going to do this? I don't want to create redundant work for the staff, for us, or for them. [41:34] Speaker A (unidentified): It's a submission waiver, and so what we're doing is we are granting a temporary waiver for the submission of this report for two weeks, and then that's what we're doing. Delaying the report. Yeah. Okay. We'd be granting the preliminary approval with a condition that they need to give this information that Chris within two weeks in order for the public hearing to [42:01] Speaker B (unidentified): happen in four weeks be clear you are not granting or preliminary approval tonight you're just finding it complete tonight okay thank you so no approvals about waivers yes so but there is still that condition on it that says we're allowing you the temporary waiver to submit it in that time period everything [42:22] Speaker G (unidentified): everything else yeah any other [42:30] Speaker A (unidentified): questions you get you understand okay I move that we grant a waiver a temporary waiver to article submission requirement for article 7.2 point a 3 for the stormwater drainage and erosion control plans with a condition that these studies be submitted to the town engineer within two weeks of tonight's meeting you [43:07] Speaker G (unidentified): didn't reference the landscape plan too well that would be that one's separate [43:13] Speaker A (unidentified): that was a separate request so we'll just do it so we'll deal with that separately we'll do the same thing okay i'll second it then motion has been made and seconded any discussion all those in favor aye just [43:31] Speaker B (unidentified): to follow up on the landscaping plan discussion the only requirement for a submission of a landscaping plan is at final approval so you are more well within your right to request that they add landscaping to their plan but an actual landscaping plan there's no submission requirement [43:50] Speaker H (unidentified): that you've got anything a waiver for at this so they didn't need to ask for a [43:53] Speaker B (unidentified): waiver the waivers that they were asking for were related to if you require them to have landscaping they have to show XYZ it's they're a little they're phrased in a way that's like if you if you require it then we have to do this and at that point you had not required anything here you are requiring it so they will be required to show these things so there will be no waiver for that going forward since you're requiring landscaping all right [44:28] Speaker A (unidentified): number four is a high intensity soil survey they've requested a waiver for that which is a more or less common request anybody have con concerns or questions about does [44:50] Speaker G (unidentified): the town engineer agree that is appropriate yes [44:56] Speaker B (unidentified): I [45:04] Speaker H (unidentified): will make a motion to approve the applicants waiver requests for article from article 7.2 a 8 for the high intensity soil survey due to the fact that the test pits are dug on the lots for determining subsurface wastewater disposal suitability have provided enough information on the site soils second [45:31] Speaker A (unidentified): motion made and seconded any discussion all those in favor aye any opposed all right that waiver has been granted number five is about landscaping provisions we will require a landscape plan so I don't know do you want to step so this is no it's not [46:02] Speaker B (unidentified): not really this one isn't a submission waiver this is like a review standard waiver so I'd say at this point you don't need to address these don't need [46:11] Speaker A (unidentified): to act on it officially but we will ask you to provide us a landscape plan that will include street trees yeah and because this is a subdivision you need to provide buffering from neighboring lots and so I know that because the way this is set up there's it's basically a street and there's but like the existing homes that you already have, that are already occupied, you should just make sure that there are vegetation between your lots, along your lot lines, particularly like number six. [46:48] Speaker J (unidentified): That's not unreasonable. That's fine. [46:50] Speaker A (unidentified): These are small things, but we will need to see those addressed. Yeah. [46:56] Speaker J (unidentified): We would normally do that anyway, and I will be the one who would be guilty. I guess I didn't notice that in the application but that's very reasonable that's not a problem but I just for clarification if I made mr. I'm still trying to get on for the November 9th meeting I just we intend on having our stuff to Chris within the next three four days because a lot of this work was already done it's just not completed yet and I'll change that to 75 feet I'm trying not to keep delaying if possible I know well this is [47:32] Speaker A (unidentified): I think the compromise that we kind of come up with rather than having to come back in two weeks essentially and [47:43] Speaker J (unidentified): we leave it up to the planner she gets the [47:45] Speaker A (unidentified): information gets it to you here's the issue is that we need to have the planner and engineer review the project before you guys submit your preliminary before the public hearing, right, when they submit their preliminary plan. [48:00] Speaker C (unidentified): On a final plan where this is for the public hearing date, that information is required? [48:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, so the next meeting where the public hearing happens, there's usually after that the approval of the preliminary plan in that same meeting unless something crazy comes up at that public hearing or if there are still outstanding items. but the board is requiring that the items that are still left outstanding the landscaping and the stormwater be submitted and reviewed prior to preliminary approval if that were to happen the same night as the public hearing that means that it needs to be done before the public hearing so if we were if you were originally looking at the November 9th meeting that would mean that you need to submit the additional information and Chris and I would both need to review it by monday yeah i don't i think which is a very quick turnaround so if there was nothing to review between this meeting and the next meeting a two-week turnaround is pretty common for the planning board to do but since there is additional information that needs to be submitted and reviewed by the both of us the board and the public i think a two-week turnaround at this point is too aggressive trying to save you guys [49:17] Speaker A (unidentified): by doing the conditional waiver we're trying to save you guys from having to come back before us at the next meeting with a stormwater plan and that would basically be it and then we'd find out complete it then and it would still set schedule it for four weeks from now so this way we need to have that stuff review because we can schedule the public here yes so we all have a chance [49:37] Speaker H (unidentified): to see it thank you very much yes regarding the landscaping my concern is making sure that stream is protected so while we don't normally ask for buffering behind houses I will ask that you look at that in this case because I'm very concerned about people using fertilizers runoff in those houses going into the stream so if you build buffer gardens to catch that would be much more pleasing to me to know that I've protected that stream the stream is [50:15] Speaker J (unidentified): important to all of us it's a natural resource and that's one of the reasons I acquired this parcel it's just as important to me and I know on the other side of the hill where Dan had built all his projects and my partner and I had built a house over there they're concerned and whatever it is that we need to do to protect that portion of the stream we had also planned on putting up signs and I thought that they may have been on this plan or on the old one about the stream and stuff like that so I'll make sure that gets done in and that's really again that's reasonable yep I'm on board with you [50:52] Speaker G (unidentified): Janice we've done that before we've required medallions to be placed so that people know that they need to stay away from that area and I had them on the [51:03] Speaker J (unidentified): original summation submission I'm not sure they're on here but I'll make sure [51:08] Speaker A (unidentified): that it's done you got time okay thank you all right so that was article 5 isn't not applicable or number five your submission was not applicable at this point same is also six is not applicable so that's also dealing with the landscaping so then you saw hannah's comments about what you'll need before preliminary plan approval you'll need to ask for a waiver from street construction standards about the center line of the road [52:07] Speaker B (unidentified): At this point I would say the two major things that you're looking for in your condition are the stormwater information and the street construction I'll let Chris give the technical terms the compaction those types of things that we can use to prove that the road was constructed to meet the street design construction standards since that would have been submitted kind of part of the road design you would be reviewing a road design since we don't have that he needs to review that end of it so we [52:41] Speaker A (unidentified): have the one condition about the stormwater management plan and stormwater and erosion control plan and we're having a second condition which is going to be that they provide road construction details to Chris prior to the preliminary plan application being submitted now we're gonna add that as our another condition to our final our completeness we're just adding it now so you want to do the completeness start if you want to start that completeness it's on the street you [53:31] Speaker J (unidentified): already have the roadway and everything I just owe you the compaction testing I'll make sure I provide that to you tomorrow because I have all that I [53:52] Speaker H (unidentified): will I'll make a motion to consider complete the preliminary plan for a major subdivision, Truman's Field Road, tax map 30, lots 84, 155, and 156, with the conditions that we've discussed. [54:11] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, with the conditions that, one, the stormwater management plan and erosion control plan be submitted to the town engineer within two weeks of today's date. And second, that the road construction details, i.e., compactness tests, et cetera, that the town engineer needs to review the construction of the road be submitted in that same time frame. [54:40] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll second the motion as conditioned. [54:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? None. All right. So the application has been deemed complete with conditions. we can set a public hearing. [54:58] Speaker B (unidentified): That'd be the 23rd. [55:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Date for November 23rd, 2026. [55:06] Speaker J (unidentified): It's been Thanksgiving together. [55:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, exactly. All right, thank you very much. 23rd is the public hearing. Next item on our agenda is the final plan review for a major subdivision off of Summer Street, Pool Sheepyard Way. Anna, if you can summarize this and then we'll hear from the applicant. [56:17] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, so this is the last stage. This is the final subdivision plan approval stage for this application. The board approved the preliminary plan about a month ago back in September. Just as a quick summary, this is a four lot subdivision. served lots will be served by a new private road with public water and private individual septic systems the applicant since the last meeting has received approval from the e911 officer for the road name of pool shipyard way so that is an approved name the applicant submitted landscaping details as required and submitted the cost estimate as required for the performance guarantee. So the cost estimate is currently in hand, will be reviewed by the town engineer and coordinated for the submission of the performance guarantee. I listed that as a condition of approval that guarantee be submitted before they begin construction. instruction the all of the waivers at this point have been granted there were no waivers still outstanding for final approval so the only thing you're looking at now is reviewing any final questions and going through the findings of fact good [57:41] Speaker F (unidentified): evening members of the board my name is henry hess representing the applicant this evening for pool shipyard way hannah stole most of my thunder just to recap we did do sketch plan in may site walk in may as well completeness in August public hearing in September and preliminary plan also a preliminary plan approval also the same night in September we've submitted most things to everything to date and I believe as Hannah stated we had waivers for a couple items on the roadway design due to some of the natural resources on site that's why we requested them they've already been voted on by an approved by yourselves there and certainly I'll yield my time to the board if you have any final questions comments I'll do my best to answer them thank [58:36] Speaker A (unidentified): you questions Ted I [58:45] Speaker E (unidentified): don't really have any more questions on this a Henry we've gone through it I did the condition of approval for the performance thing for sure but I have no further no other questions just a couple [59:01] Speaker G (unidentified): of quick ones. Has the fire chief seen the final plans and approved the access and approved his ability to be able to fight any fire on [59:13] Speaker F (unidentified): each lot? Yes, sir. We did submit attorney exhibits as part of the application that have been reviewed by the fire department. [59:24] Speaker G (unidentified): My understanding is the entire project is within the historic overlay district. Is that correct? [59:31] Speaker F (unidentified): That is correct, yes. [59:33] Speaker G (unidentified): So how will you notify each purchaser of each lot that they need to get a certificate of appropriateness before from the Historic District Commission? [59:48] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, they certainly can be something that's either as done as during the sale of the parcel or, again, if they were to go. [59:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Too many times that drops through the cracks, so I'd like to have it put somewhere on the plans or somewhere so that the people who purchase them are notified and there's no surprises. [1:00:09] Speaker F (unidentified): I think it's reasonable if you'd like us to add one note to there stating that the – [1:00:13] Speaker E (unidentified): It's part of our deed. Oh, thank you. [1:00:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Currently, it's part of the deed restrictions that – the sale of the land, so it'll be notified in the deed for the land itself. Okay. [1:00:27] Speaker G (unidentified): Those are really the only questions I have at this point. Thanks, Richard. [1:00:33] Speaker H (unidentified): Janice. Henry, a quick question on lot two. Where does the driveway for that lot end up in relationship to the fire department turnaround and the stream setback? [1:00:52] Speaker F (unidentified): That curb cut is shown just beyond the curve there and before you get to the hammerhead near one of the pins for the hammerhead there. Yep. [1:01:02] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay. All right. And with that topographical challenge there, are you going to be able to get a driveway in there? [1:01:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes. I believe we, in walking the site, we've walked over that section. I think it presents a little steeper on plan than what you're looking at here. that section across theirs doesn't quite hit the steep section of the thing there [1:01:22] Speaker H (unidentified): all right and can you add to your HOA docks that homeowners can use organic fertilizer only or none at all and I know you got your permit for your stream setback but I would like to see some sort of a buffer garden because it's a slope in between the houses and the stream to just like the other application i'm concerned about runoff with any kind of fertilizer or other stuff going down into that stream [1:02:00] Speaker F (unidentified): i think any anything that were to happen in the homes the individual lots themselves now certainly we have a dep permit for the stream crossing for the road if anything were to happen in within that 75 foot buffer for construction that would also need to go to DEP so you'll have a permit in hand and that will be protected at that point so there is a there is still another stopgap there to prevent people from [1:02:25] Speaker H (unidentified): clearing down to the water okay thank you that's all my questions thank you [1:02:29] Speaker B (unidentified): Kevin [Speaker A (unidentified): no] further questions for me yes Henry just a point of clarification just that I've thought of with Janice's question there. The permit from DEP for the stream crossing does not include any disturbance within the 75 feet that may be required for that driveway, correct? Or is that not within 75 feet, and I just can't measure with my eyeballs? That's a good question. [1:03:00] Speaker F (unidentified): Let me take a look real quick before I commit to an answer there. That driveway sits just inside. That driveway curb cut sits just inside the 75 foot. it so at the time of building construction there yeah so they would [1:03:15] Speaker B (unidentified): need to get another permit for that or not for the curb cut itself as it's part [1:03:20] Speaker F (unidentified): of the street there but when they go build a driveway there to driveway they [1:03:24] Speaker B (unidentified): would need and that would be the individual lot owner once this is okay [1:03:29] Speaker F (unidentified): great question and [1:03:40] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you for the landscaping it does look like there's a bunch of trees at the end of behind that one house that front Summer Street right by the hammerhead there so I think [1:03:56] Speaker F (unidentified): that's good. We did add a couple notes there because I know when we were out we talked about it previously and on site that there's still going to be a fair amount of large trees that remain there so we will selectively locate those. I know they're shown perfectly in a line but we'll make sure that buffer is there. Any [1:04:15] Speaker A (unidentified): other questions or comments? we'll go through the findings of facts and conditions of approval I've kind of a planning board findings of acts and conditions of approval for a final subdivision plan a pool shipyard way property owner Durrell's bridge landing LLC has shown legal interest in a property by deed say location is 9 Durrell's bridge Road num site and number of Lots is for Lots zoning district is the suburban residential this is map 81 lot 53 board reviewed a number of staff reviews but we've gotten sign offs from main DEP with a permit by rule number of waivers that we approved which are listed on the findings of fact here as well the county planning board has reviewed the above noted development utilizing the Kennebunk standards for reviewing land subdivision and the Kennebunk zoning ordinance based upon the application and materials submitted in support of the application together with the evidence submitted at the public hearing on the application the planning board makes the following findings with respect to the standards of title 30 a subsection 4404 and article 11 section 8 of the zoning ordinance guidelines listed below MRSA 3da subsection 4404 number one pollution will not result in undue water or air pollution making this determination it shall at least consider the elevation of land above the sea level and its relation to the flood plains the nature of soils and subsoils and their ability to adequately support waste disposal the slope of the land and its effect on effluents the availability of streams for disposal of effluents in the applicable state and local health and water resource regulations the standard is met there are no proposed activities that are known generators of air water pollution subsurface wastewater disposal systems will be installed on each lot in accordance with main subsurface waste disposal rules standards met to sufficient water has sufficient water available for the reasonably foreseeable needs of the subdivision this standard is met new lots will be served by municipal water supply a letter from the kid about Kennebunk Port and Wells Water District dated 5 20 26 was submitted indicating there is currently adequate capacity for the development three you miss municipal water supply will not cause an unreasonable burden on the existing water supply of one is to be utilized. The standard is met, as noted above in number two. Four, erosion. Will not cause unreasonable soil erosion or reduction of the capacity of the land to hold water so that a dangerous or unhealthy condition may result. The standard is met. A stormwater management report prepared by a licensed professional engineer was submitted with a preliminary subdivision application. The report was reviewed by the town engineer, and all comments have been satisfied. fine five traffic will not cause an reasonable highway or public road congestion or unsafe conditions with respect to the use of highways or public roads existing or proposed and if the proposed subdivision requires driveways or entrances onto a state or state aid highway located outside of this urban compact area the town the standards method submitted traffic summary indicates that the development will generate 2 a.m. peak hour trips and 3 p.m. peak hour trips with the total of 28 estimated average daily trips no significant traffic impacts will be created from this development six sewage disposal will provide for adequate sewage waste disposal and will not cause an unreasonable burden on town services if they are utilized met with the following conditions slash waivers the new lots will be served by individual subsurface waste disposal systems which will be in full compliance with the requirements of the main subsurface waste disposal rules as a condition of approval system designs will be submitted with the building permits for individual homes seven municipal solid waste disposal will not cause an unreasonable burden of the ability of the municipality to dispose of solid waste and sewage if municipal services are to be utilized the standard is met the new homes will be eligible for participation in the town solid waste disposal program as evidenced in the submitted draft road maintenance agreements all homeowners will be required to bring municipal trash cans to summer street for pickup municipal sewer system will not be used eight aesthetic cultural and natural values when I have an undue adverse effect on the scenic or natural beauty of the area aesthetics this works sites are rare irreplaceable natural areas or any public rights or physical or visual access to the shoreline the standards met the proposed subdivision is of similar character to surrounding development and will not have an adverse effect on the scenic character of the area no known historic sites rare or irreplaceable natural areas or shore access points will be affected because the property is located within a historic preservation overlay district individual home designs are required to be submitted to the historic preservation Commission for review prior to construction and conformity with local ordinances and plans is in conformance with the duly adopted subdivision regulations comprehensive plan and zoning ordinance of the town of Kennebunk the standard is met the subdivision conforms with all applicable plans accepting where rate where waivers were granted by the Planning Board ten financial and technical capacity the subdivider has provided adequate financial and technical capacity to meet the standards of these regulations the standard is met with the following conditions or waivers. The developer has demonstrated technical capacity throughout the application process. Financial capacity will be demonstrated through the submission of a performance guarantee. As a condition of approval, the performance guarantee must be submitted prior to ground disturbance. Eleven, surface waters and outstanding river segments. Whenever situated in whole or part within 250 feet of a pond, lake, river, or tidal waters, will not adversely affect the ad will not adversely affect the quality of that body of water or a measly affect the shoreline of that water body probably be met yeah the standard is met lot for the subdivision is within 250 feet of the Kennebunk River no new development is proposed on this lot [1:11:51] Speaker G (unidentified): I'd like to this I think would be a good place to add in Janice's caught a soul that they use only appropriate fertilizers as a condition if the applicant doesn't have a problem with that and [1:12:17] Speaker F (unidentified): the draft road document did and does the draft road document does have language to the organic fertilizers there if that covers [1:12:24] Speaker A (unidentified): that okay thank you all right thank you set standard is met 12 groundwater will not alone or a conjunction with existing activities adversely affect the quality or quantity of groundwater the standard is met subsurface waste disposal systems will be in full compliance with the requirements of the main subsurface waste disposal rules the lots will not be served by private wells through 13 flood areas the subdivider will determine based on the federal emergency management agencies flood boundary and floodway maps and the flood insurance rate maps whether the subdivision is in a flood plow flood prone area the subdivision or any part of it is in such an area the subdivider will determine the 100-year flood elevation and the flood hazard boundaries within the subdivision the proposed subdivision plan will include a condition of plot approval requiring that principal structures in the subdivision shall be constructed with their lowest floor including basement at least two feet above the 100-year flood elevation the standard is met the applicant has determined this that the subdivision is not in a flood prone area based on the 2024 FEMA flood insurance rate maps that 's specific to the new construction or is I mean part of the subdivision is in there's a flood way along the bank of the rivers or not it's only to say is the subdivision does contain flood areas there is no development that is proposed within that within that area 14 stormwater the proposed subdivision will provide for adequate stormwater management the standard is met a stormwater management report prepared by a licensed professional engineer was submitted with the preliminary subdivision application the report was reviewed by the town engineer and all comments have been satisfied 15 river streamer brook any river streamer brook within or abutting the proposed subdivision has been identified or any map submitted as part of the application for purposes of this section river streamer Brooke has the same meeting as in title 38 section 480 B subsection 9 the standard is met the stream on the property is shown on all plan sheets a 75 foot setback will be maintained for the stream in all areas except what work is permitted by PBR ID 0 1 0 2 1 9 dash 0 1 16 fresh water wetlands all fresh water wetlands within the proposed subdivision have been identified on any map submitted as part of the application regardless of the size of those wetlands this standard is met the application indicates that the wetlands on the parcel will were delineated on June 2018 and reviewed it confirmed in April of 2024 by a licensed soil scientist all freshwater wetlands within the proposed subdivision are shown on the final subdivision plan sheet C 100 dated 10 6 26 17 spaghetti Lots prohibited if any Lots in the subdivision proposed subdivision have shore frontage on a river stream brook great pond or coastal wetland as these features are defined in title 38 section 480 B none of these Lots created within a subdivision have a lot depth to shore frontage ratio greater than five to one the standard is met as demonstrated by plan sheets c100 no spaghetti lots recruit are being created with this subdivision 18 Lake phosphorus concentration long-term communal effects of proposed subdivision will not and reasonably increased a great ponds phosphorus concentrations during construction phase or in the life of the proposed subdivision this is not applicable the subdivision is not near and does not drain to a great pond therefore there are no anticipated direct impacts to a great ponds fosters concentration from this subdivision 19 impact on adjoining municipalities is not applicable does not cross municipal boundaries 20 land subject to liquidation harvesting timber on the parcel being subdivided has not been harvested with invite with in violation of rules of doctor pursuant to title 12 section 88 69 subsection 14 the standard is met no timber has been harvested and there are no known violations to title at 12 section 88 69 subsection 14 on the parcel I will [1:17:33] Speaker H (unidentified): make a motion to approve a town of Kennebunk Planning Board findings the facts and condition approval for the final subdivision plan of pool shipyard way as conditioned I'll [1:17:47] Speaker A (unidentified): second that motion has been made and second it is there any discussion any opposed and I will make [1:18:06] Speaker H (unidentified): a motion to approve the final plan of pool shipyard way as conditioned you [1:18:15] Speaker G (unidentified): should probably list the map a lot number for the record let me [1:18:24] Speaker H (unidentified): add in the Daryl's Bridge Landing LLC, 9 Daryl's Bridge Rhone, 4 lots in a suburban residential zoning district. Assessor's Map 81, lot 53. [1:18:37] Speaker G (unidentified): I'll second that. [1:18:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? All those in favor? Aye. None opposed. The plan has been approved. Appreciate the time. Consideration all. So, next item on our agenda is a sketch plan review for a major subdivision in Noble Home Park by Abode Communities, Kennebunk. Hannah, I'll turn this over to you, and then we'll hear from the applicant. [1:20:10] Speaker B (unidentified): All right. I will keep my introduction short because I know the applicant has a full presentation to give. But this is the second sketch plan application meeting for this application, first reviewed by the planning board in August. the applicant also has paper copies of the presentation they're about to show for you guys to be able to flip through that instead of looking back up at the screen the so the application was first reviewed back in august i'd say the notable changes since that meeting to the application have been a reduction in nine units in the mobile home park and a reconfiguration of the roadways in the mobile home park to better organize or better, I'd say, place the open space in more usable ways and more usable locations. So there are larger areas and areas that can be more adequately used by residents rather than just really small pocket parks here and there. So you'll see that by your plan. There is a plan that was submitted that is colored a little bit, so all the open space areas are shown in green to point out where those open space areas are now proposed to be located. [1:21:26] Speaker K (unidentified): Good evening, members of the board. My name is Drew Gagnon with LGB Engineering, representing Bode Communities, Kennebunk, LLC. The presentation that's going to be shown right here, we'll flip through real quick. We have just printed hard copies for the board's consideration. It might be a little bit easier to follow. We'll also provide it to the town in PDF format for public record at the same time. So those are the same, minus the video. that's obviously if you put in the booklet so we responded we had a we had a two months ago we were in front of the board presenting a sketch plan we heard some of the board's comments and discussions and we responded and our cover letter had seven or eight items kind of I would say the larger items that we heard with some justifications and or some responses so I won't go through those in detail right now but I'm happy to discuss them as we do I'd like to introduce this project and the applicant team first and then hand it off to them to talk a little bit more about what they do in their development for use land lease communities so next slide Hannah please and the next one so Blaine Burnett and Brett white sitting right over here to my left are the applicants are the they're part of the team behind the abode communities Kennebunk LLC been in real estate for over 65 years and both have significant real estate development experience both in the Northeast and around the United States next slide please and with that I'm gonna pass it to Blaine Brett be Blaine 's gonna just say a couple things and we'll hop back and forth a little bit [1:22:55] Speaker L (unidentified): good evening board so I'm Blaine Burnett I've been in the area for 25 years my partner is a Canadian he passed away seven years ago so the projects that you're seeing up on the screen Yankee settlement Keywood Wood Terra. They're in New Hampshire and in Maine. We had to sell them. So as a condition of that, I opened a housing business, bought some land up here. Currently, we are working on three different projects. We have one here. We have one in Alfred, which is connected to Keywood, and we have another one in Saco that we're working on expanding. I currently We currently have ownership in three different projects up here as well. Brett, it's our families. That's who this is about. We are not a big corporate entity, but I'd like to go through this slide and kind of give you guys a little bit more background. So Yankee Settlement in Kittery, that is a new project that is connected to a couple older mobile home parks. Anna could you go to the next slide okay this is our proposal go ahead again okay so this you guys have seen this is the proposal 190 spaces in total seven single-family lots 183 leased land lease next slide you've seen that next slide this is the phasing of the project we've learned over the years put your club house and your amenities in first so that's one of the things we would do in phase one we've built a clubhouse the best we've ever done in 25 years in any single community is 17 houses typically 12 to 15 is where we stand so this project we would love to see done in 10 years but it could take a little bit longer than that so the growth is not it's not crazy it's not overwhelming and it's not fast next slide home placement the one thing I've never done but it's been done in Berwick is we've never pit set homes age in place is what happens when you pit set a home so what that basically means is you take four or five steps out of people coming home and getting into their homes is there one okay next like okay this is a new design of a home style that we have we're getting away from the traditional homes traditional mobile homes this is a little bit different next slide please so this is pit set so typically the gray piers that you see are sitting at the ground level so just replace raise that house up four feet and you end up with a series of steps so in our senior citizen communities the number one reason they leave their home earlier than they need to is because of mowing grass and every time they come home they've got to climb up five or six steps so this is a pit set concept that is currently being done in a park in berwick 70 space park it's been received very well and it also allows senior citizens to stay in their home for a little bit longer next slide age in place so it's simpler next slide land lease so we own the ground they own the home and we provide the services pretty much all the same services that you folks would provide for your city will plow water lines sewer lines we maintain all of those different things green space roads all of it in the next slide so right now those are the demographics of who lives in mobile home parks. There's been a lot going on in the state of Maine because clearly there's a lot of people that live in mobile home parks in the state of Maine. We've had parks in seven different states. Maine and New Hampshire are our favorite places. We love it. Old school growth. That's why we're up here. Next slide, please. So the purchase price, affordability has been a big factor we can hit affordability metrics our homes range from 200 to 450 000 depending on what somebody wants so clearly to be affordable you need to be around that 200 000 mark nice three bedroom starter homes we're looking at a project in saco that will be for that 's near the school and the next slide okay this project is currently underway it's a 71 space park let's go ahead and play that video we had to remove 300 000 yards of rock off that site to put the mobile homes in there it'll take us another three years to finish this one we did sell that project we now provide housing for that project and then i'm one of the partners. Next slide, please. Hit this slide. That's where it's located. Three out of Wood Lane. It's about 27 miles away from Kennebunk. It'll be, we'll complete it three more years. Next slide, please. These are just some still photos. All the homes in that project have two car garages or one car garage or a two car garage you can see the steps so those steps on a pit set home you end up with one step instead of four or five steps this project has some walking trails which are very popular The views on those homes out the back are fantastic. They look right into a lot of things. You're talking about some wetlands areas next slide, please Keywood Manor is a project that's been very successful. It's 272 spaces very close We are currently getting Some additional spaces inside of this park. So this park should end up being around 290 spaces This park, from the time we bought it to the time we sold it, we put about 10 a year in this park. Next slide, please. This house, a 5,000-square-foot clubhouse, it's in two towns. At this point, pending the approval of the sites we're seeking, this park is full. We work around landscaping that's there, trees. We plant trees back. [Speaker I (unidentified): those] homes range from five to three years old and the next slide next one this just pictures of the clubhouse we found in most cases the green space that is used is around the clubhouse whether we put in bocce ball or picnic areas generally speaking that's where everybody gathers and this is another slide you can see that sent homes, all but one of those steps would disappear. Next slide. This is Tara, this is in Rochester, New Hampshire. This is a 440 space community at all. All traffic goes out on one road, Salmon Falls Road. And they just put a school in across the street from the entrance of this park and it works. Next slide. You can go ahead and play that video. deal. This is a massive community. That clubhouse is 7,000 square feet. Car shows, picnics, barbecues, all kinds of events are run there. We believe that the trees provide the character for the community. So that's why you see so many trees. This is permitted up to 579. We'll probably end up somewhere in the low fives when we get done with this community. That's the new expansion that we're working on now those are all some of those homes are less than a year [Speaker G (unidentified): old this] is the park where we did 17 in one year other than that it's closer 10 to 10 to 12 and the next slide next slide and the next one that's the clubhouse amenities some more pictures of homes and then next slide that's the expansion that was built that was a pit area so we had to clear cut it and we put trees back on every one of those spaces when we get done with them that's fit yeah that's 54 the next slide so with that we'll let you guys ask us questions Hannah [1:34:45] Speaker A (unidentified): we asked you to about the affordability aspects of what we can change what we can. We asked you guys to ask town council about it, our town attorney. We haven't seen any memos or anything from that. So have we heard from them or what's the story? [1:35:06] Speaker D (unidentified): So we did have a conversation with council about this and essentially what they said that was very clear was how you handle the first five years. What they didn't talk about was really whether you're going to have a qualified holder or what your expectations would be beyond that. That's up to you to determine that. What's very clear is the ordinance says you know, you've got to meet the 80% AMI for the first five years for the 30% shelter costs. What it leaves and is vague is it doesn't say, you know, that's essentially expires. Now, from the practical perspective, we try to understand why is that. And I think when you have a full build-out like this, it's pretty difficult to sort of make something, and I'll just arbitrarily pick a number. I'll pick the 250,000 number he said. It's pretty difficult to make that number change from a physical standpoint. And what I'm saying is, the market's going to dictate what it's going to be. Very rarely does that thing change beyond its 80%, it sort of stays in the realm what it is. Where you've seen things become different is if you want to do something independent of this, like say rent stabilization, which that's not the conversation here. That's the very specific part of where the board's saying what the threshold is that has to be that affordability rate. because that's really dictated by HUD. And I think what was clear when it says if the board decides to modify it, that would be more from a broader piece of are you feeling like there's an unmet need and something has to further a conversation that really can't be a requirement was what his take was. And I think if there's more specifics of where that goes, we could kind of talk about it. But he didn't have a lot of guidance, quite honestly, to offer in terms of what happens after five years because generally it doesn't happen. When a park gets built out in its phase, the market establishes what it's going to be. It doesn't usually go from a $200,000 unit to a $500,000 unit, even though the control ultimately is the land, right? The units that are in there are individually owned, and that's really set, and I would let them discuss what the value of these units become as. So it really doesn't become something that's acted upon, Whereas if we had an affordable housing development and we had a qualified holder under a rent condition that could change, we would do an annual income verification both for the people living there and the rent threshold that's been set. This is really kind of different because the only part that you traditionally look at is when you look at what those shelter costs are that are made up, in this particular instance, the one element they control, The others are somewhat controlled by the individual who may be making a payment on the unit, right? They have, I think as Blaine described it, costs for electricity, sewer, and lot and maintenance that would be part of those shelter costs. But the delta or that differential really is still borne by the individual. It's not really something that's easy to measure. I mean, it's easy to measure. It's not something to know when it significantly changes. After five years, if you've achieved build-out, you can do some compliance monitoring, but usually what happens is I think that you achieve build-out and it stays where it is. That AMI theoretically is always adjusting. If people are fortunate to have life circumstances change that they do or don't want to be there, I don't think that's going to change where we see this thing going. So a bit of a long answer, not really a descript one. I think the question is, from our perspective, the five-year threshold seemed like it made sense because that's when you typically would see a buildup. When you're talking something in that longer range, I think you can handle that with phasing and conditions. If you're expecting that to be born under a longer period of time, I think that's something you'd have to state but then decide how you're going to monitor it and what your real risk is. You could put a condition on here and they could agree to it that says it's got to be the 80% AMI for 10 years. The question becomes the what if. What changes outside of that? And I don't really think he had a simple answer for that because we have not been in this circumstance before, so I think that's where that stands. [1:39:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Part of my confusion from this section is it says future sales and rents will be maintained at the rate approved by the planning board for at least five years. I don't know which rate they're referring to. Are they talking about the 80% AMI? Are they talking about the 30% shelter cost? Are they talking about the 50% of the units have to be affordable? What rate are they, is this referencing? [1:39:47] Speaker D (unidentified): Is that clear? I would say that when we discussed it with legal, he had the same question you did. Unfortunately, the ordinance is open to interpretation. and in this instance, there are two people who would interpret the ordinance. It would be the board in this instance or, you know, an individual, a code officer, but that would really be your determination to say what you think that means and ultimately where the applicant can talk about how they see that translates to the two. I think the part that's probably more specific is the 50% of the units in the park. That's probably the one that you don't want to see deviation on. Yep. Outside of that, I think short of market conditions that might change the lot rents that seem like many communities are sort of trying to have some better controls to that. The rest of it's sort of, I think, going to once these things get developed and occupied, they're going to be so much static unless there's one individual that changes outside of that. But I think that's something we want to kind of break down a little bit and see where that how that makes itself up. [1:40:47] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, to me, the affordability piece is really the biggest nut here. It's what will make this really something that will benefit the town, I think. [1:41:05] Speaker D (unidentified): So this is the part, and I think you're on to something a little bit. If you look at the mobile home park standards under Article 10, Section 13, it's got specific performance standards. what they're doing is it's I'm gonna say relaxing some of those standards not significantly instead of having a 50 foot wide right away in a 23 foot wide right away but you still need a 20 foot wide road it's not like you're getting a 12 foot ride road so but it is sort of encouraging and I'm actually gonna step back and be careful with that statement we only allow mobile home parks in Village Residential. If you read the review criteria for this, the setbacks that get put on it pretty much match the Village Residential setbacks. The board has a little bit of leniency you can apply in terms of the side yard setback, but it still says you have to have a 15-foot front yard setback. From a practical perspective, one year from now when we adopt zoning amendments that are going to look at the state-mandated 5,000-square-foot lots, the only difference from this beyond the ownership model, those could be 190 single family lots that would meet what's likely if it's on public sewer and water in a growth area, the 5,000 square foot lot. The only difference would be the requirement for a 50 foot wide right of way versus the 23 and not needing to meet the 50% affordability. So mobile home parks typically have an ownership model. In this instance, what they're doing is they're presenting something that's a combination of the ownership model. Our state requirement for minimum lot size is actually exceeding the state standard for that. The state standard has been changed to 4,000 square foot lots. We're still at 6,500. It backtracked two years if they had presented it this way and they didn't call it a manufactured home park. we'd be looking at it saying, okay, all this is, it's a cluster subdivision. The difference now is what they're presenting is the exact same thing that's going to be more consistent with the different standards and a slightly different ownership model. So the 50% affordability, I think, was expecting that someone's going to come in and follow through and carry this thing here. I'm not even sure that I suspect they and that they can tell you most of them are going to come closer to meeting that. Okay, the HUD AMI for a family of four at 80%, I think it's like $85,000 is the annual income that works your way back to those costs. And that number, when it projects itself out, actually becomes about a $450,000 unit. it so the majority of these if you're in the threshold they're talking about I think you're gonna see a higher percentage it would meet that affordable criteria because of it right but [1:44:07] Speaker A (unidentified): if this is a 10-year build-out are you saying the five-year with the five-year minimum I think to it like I think how does that [1:44:24] Speaker D (unidentified): mean I think in this instance you probably want to look at your faces they would have five-year windows and a revisitation or a clarification with each one that those income. So let's just, can you go back to that phase, the four-color scheme phase? From a practical perspective, if this project were to complete the review process and get approved like that, you're seeing four different phases there, and depending what the horizon is, you could be having a 10-year build-out that's outside that five-year window. window, you could have something that requires a condition that has a reset or verification of what those income thresholds are prior to initiation of the second phases. Verify that not only their financial capacity to carry that thing through, but it's consistent with it. Because really, in the normal world, you'd go through a review process. They might identify phases, and then they build out those phases, but you don't really touch it again. So conditions, as we have seen in the last ten years, are significantly different. So that is something that most of the affordable housing communities we have, we don't have a direct management arm of. Okay, most of them are done by actual entities that own and operate them. So once they get approval, they take care of it that way. This is now a basis of the approval and the conditions would have the town be looking at what is going to happen in that five year window. and I think that would probably be part of the phasing discussion one thing [1:45:54] Speaker B (unidentified): that I think might be important to note Chris that would this Chris that speaks to your question too is that the standard says that future sales and rents will be maintained at the rate approved by the Planning Board for at least five years after project completion not project approval so that depending on how the phasing gets approved could mean five years after everything is done or it could mean the five years after the first phase is done however the Planning Board approves that phasing but and maybe this is different [1:46:30] Speaker A (unidentified): because of the ownership model but like I know that when there's we've had other affordability projects it's like 30 year set rates that is tip of the funding [1:46:41] Speaker D (unidentified): right now so what enter our ordinance for a definition for affordable housing or affordability that is the only difference would have been whether it's 80% AMI or 100% AMI but there's usually would have a qualified holder with a 30 year period that has been designated to stay in that affordable ownership when we approve it that way that is something we would have whether it be us or an external party he would verify that so if you think about a couple of the projects that we had approved on York Street those affordable units they should be doing annual income verification comparing that to the rent by the qualified holder, and that would be a term for that 30 years. [1:47:18] Speaker A (unidentified): In that case, the rental company, the management company, does that stuff. In this case, if it was a – because this is an ownership – would this be different? [1:47:31] Speaker D (unidentified): Really, the only – the qualified holder is the entity whose job it is to look at, not typically done by them. It's somebody we may designate. We had a conversation a few years ago with Sanford Housing Authority, who might be willing to do that, or other parties who take that on. So it's not something that we can do it, but it's essentially someone looking at it and verifying, okay, what are you charging? What is that total shelter cost, if you will, and making that calculation and comparison for the individual and saying, okay, they're meeting that criteria in the person. Both the rent, and renting is easy. It's a number you can compare to. On the ownership model, that's actually, and I talk about ownership, like single-family dwelling, if you think about it, that's much different because houses, and I think if you think about what the Neighborhood Housing Trust talked about in their discussion, you look at what's changed with housing values and how they've gone up, and it's difficult to sort of look at something over its life cycle and say, okay, where is it at in relationship to that piece there? And unfortunately, that's not something we have a lot of experience with, so I think these are natural things we're trying to see. How does it work? In this particular instance here, I think Hannah pointed out something that's actually really important. The important thing will be to make the distinction of when you're considering that period, each phase. So that five-year period, I would look at each phase as its own little construction project. So phase four, theoretically, could be 15 years from now, and that window wouldn't start until it becomes initiated and is completed. And you should really put a stipulation in there that you probably want to see those phases completed within a reasonable timeline so that you can start the clock on that, too. And [1:49:22] Speaker A (unidentified): don't forget it. I mean the rental, the rents, the lot rents, the lot lease. One [1:49:43] Speaker G (unidentified): thing that you gentlemen mentioned at least three times when you were scrolling through the presentation was you were building this out until you sold the project. project. So is your model to get this started and then sell it and the hell with the people that are living there? [1:50:02] Speaker L (unidentified): No, Stephen Hines was up here- [1:50:06] Speaker G (unidentified): You did say it three times, so I'm concerned. [1:50:08] Speaker L (unidentified): Stephen Hines is a Canadian. Steve was one of the original New England mobile home park owners. We owned them all over the place, Keene, Standish, all over. When Steve passed away, being a Canadian citizen, the IRS is not kind to the surviving wife, and we had to sell everything. So that is the reason we sold this. Steve got cancer in 17 and then passed away, or we would still own all of these and be moving down the road. So that is not the model. It is very difficult to sell them, and we had no choice. Donna, his wife, is 87 now, and we sold everything in the New England region because of that. [1:51:02] Speaker A (unidentified): I think obviously one of the things that you see facing a lot of mobile home parks, which is probably different than this, is that they're being sold to, you know, equity firms and other corporations where they raise their rents and all that stuff. And so I think that's one of the concerns that we have is if something like this gets approved to help really market rate affordable housing, like to get people in for starter homes and that sort of thing, like I don't want to get people trapped and stuck with land leases that keep going up and up and up. Correct. I think they're stuck there because they can't get out. Yeah. [1:51:45] Speaker L (unidentified): We are open to all of those discussions. Our average rent increases for the 10 years we owned most of those projects was $15 a year or under. [1:51:54] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't know if the state's been looking at it and also putting regulations out about those types of things. [1:52:02] Speaker G (unidentified): So in 10 years, that's $150. Correct. [1:52:10] Speaker A (unidentified): It's less than cost of living. All right. I don't know. He's just a member of the public. Sorry. [1:52:23] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, who, are you part of their team? [1:52:25] Speaker A (unidentified): No, he's just a concerned citizen. Oh, I see, okay. All right, Ted, your thoughts, questions that come to mind? Thank you, Chris. [1:52:38] Speaker E (unidentified): I appreciate that your questions on the affordability issues and the control, that's bordering on a morass of issues. issues, and that we're going to have to be really clear, really clear on how this is going to work, how it's going to be managed, and I think we have a long way to go before we get that clarity. I just say for the record, I was given a letter regarding this project and others handed to me out in the street the other day, and I mentioned it to Hannah, and there's several other letters she's got, and they will be provided to everybody, just to put that on record. [1:53:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Sorry, what kind of letters? Public comments? [1:53:33] Speaker E (unidentified): Public comments. The letters from the citizens. So I've got several points. The affordability is certainly the big one, and how that's managed is new for us and really complicated, but we're going to have to have real clarity on that before we really put approvals here. The other one, as I've spoken to before, this is a town within a town, and I can see the traffic issues of some magnitude. I've talked about this before, not just on Thompson Road, but Truman Field Road, on which there are other projects going on. have been discussed and this is a really serious issue and it's made more complicated and that the by the 10-year build-out let's say so if you're doing a traffic study is it based on the final fully loaded project or is it based on what it might be and you can answer that question [1:54:35] Speaker K (unidentified): yeah thank you so the traffic study as chris mentioned before we do look at we solicit the town and say what are other developments to include in our pre-development condition that are ahead of this project right in the pipeline so we estimate those traffic impacts as well so we look at a pre-development condition without this project and there's a level of service associated with it which is basically a delay or a queuing that's associated with the traffic at intersections and roadways right then we look at a full build out in the year it's fully built out so in this case it could be 12 years down and we have included inflation that's approved by the DOT of traffic and personnel in the town that gets added to that so it's looked at like this case it may be a 2040 final build-out let's just pick a number we'd look at inflation at that time we'd look at community growth in that time and then look at this and that would be the baseline and we compare the two so we do look at it from an anticipated full build-out standpoint [1:55:32] Speaker E (unidentified): thank you very much the complication here is that there are other projects happening at the same time so independent studies by each project isn't going to deal with the issue there and so I think that's a that's a problem that the town is well aware of and then you should be also the there is another review process I understand going on which is the site location and development act permit that you all have to get in augusta and you have independent public meetings like prior to our meeting tonight to inform the public about it and that i understand that's quite an extensive process on their part and it could be a few years that they're looking into these to before they grant the permit and that i mentioned this because you have said that you expect to start construction in the summer and that seems just a thought that maybe that's optimistic we like to we like to [1:56:48] Speaker K (unidentified): be optimistic but average review time for our office submitting site location development acts is seven months from submission to approval so that's what that's based on but we understand there's there are some projects that but obviously take a lot longer than that for many reasons. [1:57:03] Speaker E (unidentified): And there's, yeah, so just put it out there. So there's also, and we discussed last time, looking at the size of this town, within the town and the schools, and so the impact on that. And there was a community impact study that was discussed, and I hope that gets done. And I've asked Chris that we get a copy of that survey at a time to see what questions are being asked and we could have a look at that. So when we look at this project, we have the full picture of what we are interested in terms of community impact. There is, you made a modification in the open space plan and I'm not an expert in that area. There is members of this board who are. And so he's not here tonight exactly, Bob, but I'm going to defer comments and observation on the open space revisions, because I have no expertise in that. I think that covers my points, Mr. Chairman. [1:58:18] Speaker G (unidentified): What kind of studies have you folks done to see if there's any kind of an appetite for this type of project here in Kennebunk? Not all over the world, but in Kennebunk. [1:58:30] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, so all of our communities in Maine and New Hampshire have done very well. Like I said, the fill rate is around one a month. What rate? The fill rate, the occupancy rate that we gain. [1:58:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Do you add a new homeowner every once a month? [1:58:47] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, that's generally where we're at. Okay. We don't see it slowing down. A lot of our projects are filling up. We're getting spaces that we can get inside the older sections of the parks. So we think it's a great market, and we think it will continue on. [1:59:06] Speaker G (unidentified): So you didn't really – did you do a study of this particular town, this particular area, to see if there's an appetite for this type of project? It's a little different than what most people are used to in that you usually buy a house and you get the land with it. In this particular case, you buy a building and it gets stuck on a piece of land that you don't own, and you don't control the cost of that going forward. Correct. It's a different type of thought process. My question is, have you studied the appetite for people in this town, in this area for thinking that 's a good housing model for them. [2:00:00] Speaker L (unidentified): Not specific to Kennebunk, no. [2:00:02] Speaker G (unidentified): That's why you're trying to sell it. Right. [2:00:05] Speaker L (unidentified): We think it'll work based on the other places that we're selling homes that are very, I mean, seven miles away is Keywood. And that park is full right now. We're seeking to expand it as well. [2:00:18] Speaker G (unidentified): Your market is, my understanding, is what, 55 and over for this project, is that right? [2:00:25] Speaker L (unidentified): Not in this one. [2:00:26] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, what is your market? [2:00:28] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, it's for families in Kennebunk. [2:00:37] Speaker G (unidentified): And how do you view this? As a starter, that was excellent music for this. Excellent music for this next question. [2:00:51] Speaker E (unidentified): Excuse me, I need to step up. [2:00:55] Speaker G (unidentified): How was I going to ask? I'm sorry. It took me off my game here. To that, I think I... Say that again? Yes. Do you view these as starter homes? [2:01:28] Speaker L (unidentified): I don't really get the concept of starter home. [2:01:31] Speaker G (unidentified): When we sell... Well, it's for somebody that's buying their first home. [2:01:35] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, but we sell those affordable homes to divorcees, to widows, to everybody. So we have family communities, which a lot of people would say, okay, this is a starter community, and we sell to everybody. There's always somebody that needs an affordable house. So starter homes, people that are having bad luck need affordable homes. [2:02:03] Speaker G (unidentified): How do I, if I buy one of your homes in this project, and now it's five, six, seven years later, and I want to get out and go buy some other kind of house, how do I sell it? Because I don't own the land. [2:02:22] Speaker L (unidentified): We, for the homes that we're selling, which are new, we list them with a real estate agent. They're on the MLS, and they sell. Our competition is the used market within the park. Homes pre-COVID were running $279, $290, and those homes now are $399. We've sold some of them $449. So it's the same thing. [2:02:51] Speaker G (unidentified): So in the resale part, when you get to the resale, after the first homeowner has bought it, 's no longer affordable, is that right? [2:03:03] Speaker L (unidentified): Well, it depends on if somebody's prepared to give somebody a deal. I mean, if somebody's prepared to say, I'm going to fall within the affordability. I don't think once these homes are sold, anybody's going to say, I'm going to sell my home based on affordability. They're going to get everything they can get out of that house, the second go. [2:03:24] Speaker G (unidentified): So how do they, how does it work when I'm selling a building on a piece of property that I can't sell because I don't own it? I don't understand it, can you explain it? [2:03:35] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, so they factor in the HOA fee or the lot fee in the overall payment. And if it's affordable for their circumstances, then they'll go buy the house. [2:03:46] Speaker G (unidentified): So how is this going to solve our housing problem in the long run? [2:03:52] Speaker L (unidentified): To bring affordable housing to the community? [2:03:57] Speaker G (unidentified): Very short term affordability, you just told me that. [2:04:01] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, but I don't know that you can control a private citizen. I know. By saying you can't, we sell it for 300 grand. If they get done living in it after a year or two, and they say look, we're going to sell it, then they're going to seek the market price. [2:04:21] Speaker G (unidentified): There are ways. I think there's a lot more discussion that needs to be had about the affordability and how that's going to be structured. I think Hannah came up with an excellent point when she said, when do you start the five year clock ticking? Is it at the end when the project is 100% built out? Is it when each phase is built up? And I think that's part of the discussion we need to have because if we're going to do something like this, we need to make it as affordable as possible for as long as possible. And he's correct, the applicant is correct, that everybody's going to want to make a buck on their home. I mean that's and so my concern is are we going to be building all these and it's not going to solve our problems that's I guess that's part of my thing on that but I also had a couple of questions about the operation you know the setup of it can we get into that too just briefly the you have two roads you're proposing to put the entry into the into this park correct but one of them as I read through your the information was going to be an emergency [2:06:02] Speaker L (unidentified): entrance I would like how do you define that I would like the Truman filled road the road to be used for emergency purposes only. What does that mean? Explain what you mean by that. If a tree falls down and blocks the road going to Allowive, any number of things could happen. [2:06:23] Speaker G (unidentified): The reality is your plan is to have one entrance to 200 properties. One entrance to 200 properties. Yeah. Give or take. Yep. And [2:06:40] Speaker L (unidentified): I mentioned at Terra Estates, right now we have 440 homes in there. [2:06:44] Speaker G (unidentified): That's the one in Rochester? [2:06:46] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, it comes right on Salmon Falls. They just put a school across the street from the entrance of the park. Okay. So it's fairly common for a couple hundred spaces to have one entrance. [2:07:00] Speaker G (unidentified): Not in Kennybun's? Not in Kennybun's. We'll need to talk about that. I'm not even sure two entrances is enough, to be honest, looking at the design of this road. [2:07:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Particularly where down the road, most of the units are well away from the second entrance. The two entrances are right at the front. [2:07:28] Speaker G (unidentified): You've got a pinch point right as soon as you get in there that could cause a problem. If there's a tree falling across the road, it could block both entrances at the same time, depending on where the tree falls so that's something we really need to look at the entry entryway into the place I'm assuming then you do have a right of way over Truman's field road correct and you would and I'm not sure where the entryway into your property is from that road. Is it down at the end over the creek? Yes. So you're going to have to finish that road? Correct. Okay. Have you started looking at stormwater plans yet or not? [2:08:41] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah. What would you like to know? [2:08:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Where's the drainage going to go? [2:08:47] Speaker K (unidentified): So, five or six different locations off-site, the existing topography of the land is kind of high in the middle of the park, and it sheds off in all directions. It ultimately all goes to Wardbrook through different tributaries or streams, but what we're doing is prior to it getting to Wardbrook in several different facilities, we're treating the runoff and storing it there and then releasing it back to get into it. So, it's a bit of a low-impact development approach where rather than one large downstream basin right at the very bottom of the site, we're doing six or seven slightly smaller ones that are spaced throughout the site to treat the runoff closer to the source so you will you're gonna use [2:09:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Ward Brook as the exodus of the water after you treat it is that your [2:09:36] Speaker K (unidentified): thought process yeah that's where it goes today and we're required to meet where it goes in the pre development condition we're gonna match that in the post development condition what brick you know goes into the [2:09:45] Speaker G (unidentified): the Kennebunk River. That's an important river for the town to protect it. So the design will have to be impeccably done. I looked at the sample house you put there, which was kind of a futuristic-looking house. Yeah, that one. But I looked at some of the things The things you gave us in the sample that I had, and they had more New England-looking houses than that. Correct. Why do you think that would be a good sample for Kennebunk, since there isn't anything that looks like that in town? [2:10:38] Speaker L (unidentified): So mobile homes have not changed design, shape, or size for 50 years. And you're right. I'm the one who picks the colors, the red, the dark grays, all the different colors that are in those slides that you are seeing. We are going to try and come up with something that's a little different. I'm not sure 100% what that will be, but that's just one plan that we've had worked on over the last year. [2:11:09] Speaker G (unidentified): We would probably like to see the houses in this park be compatible with the surrounding houses in the town. [2:11:22] Speaker L (unidentified): Yeah, not a problem. [2:11:23] Speaker G (unidentified): I think that would make a great deal of sense to me. Okay, there's too many questions and not enough time, so I'll- We'll come back if we've got further questions. Those are the important starter ones. Janice? [2:11:44] Speaker H (unidentified): I echo all of my colleagues' comments, but I have some specific questions about the site plan. I counted 30 lots that have wetlands or wetlands buffer on them, and our ordinance doesn't allow that. So you're going to go back and you're really going to do, I mean, I have a list of the lot numbers, but I don't want to have to read them off unless you want me to. 30 lots that have, you know, they impinge on the wetlands. You need to move those away from the wetlands. [2:12:19] Speaker K (unidentified): If I could, the standard is 25 feet from a wetland edge to structure a development setback. [2:12:25] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah. Right. It's a setback. And you can't have that with a house sitting on it. [2:12:30] Speaker A (unidentified): House can't be in the setback. Yeah. The house can't be in the setback or the wetland. Yeah. The setbacks can be on the lots. Yeah. [2:12:38] Speaker H (unidentified): And, you know, some of the wetlands are on the lots. I'd like you to go back and really look at that carefully. you're gonna have to probably move some stuff around to avoid those but we take our wetlands really seriously here and we have a wetlands mitigation ordinance that you'll want to review have you had a discussion about fire hydrants yet we [2:13:05] Speaker K (unidentified): haven't got that far yet but they're gonna be planned in the park certainly so they'll be able to work with the fire department on where those locations are [2:13:11] Speaker H (unidentified): certainly okay and I'm concerned about the sight line where this road meets tail wide road do you know what your sight line is there yeah we checked it [2:13:22] Speaker K (unidentified): I apologize I don't have the exact number it does meet the requirements for that speed of the roadway that'll be provided in our traffic analysis package that again at this sketch plan level we hadn't provided yet but when this moves forward to preliminary subdivision and submissions that I'll be provided in there but we have I know my team has checked it and has deemed it adequate so, that'll be provided in that. Okay, thank you. [2:13:43] Speaker H (unidentified): And the lots up, you know, the single-family home lots, again, I'd like you to look at those really carefully because those are really, you kind of look like you have some of these houses plunked on little hillocks that are residing within wetlands. And I guess just from a consumer standpoint, having lived at a corner with a stop sign for nine years, and all that traffic going past, I can tell you that living in those houses will not be fun because of the volume of traffic. And when people stop at the stop sign and they take off again, they're not exactly shy about it, about hitting the gas. And if you have anybody with motorcycles in there, they will sit there and rev them up. If I was considering a home purchase, that wouldn't be the last place I would purchase a home. Because of those things because of the wetlands, so I wouldn't ask you to go back and look at that again And I guess I'll just wait to see the resolutions on these other Issues, but I'd go back and look at the look at your site plan and make sure you avoid wetlands and wetland setbacks this Integrity of Wardenbrook and the tributaries who flow into it are really important and I can't stress that enough so thank you [2:15:15] Speaker A (unidentified): yes [2:15:16] Speaker I (unidentified): thanks Chris yeah I guess I'll start with the Delta from last time to this time things that have improved the phasing plan I think is a lot more clear and definitely improved slightly nice to get some clarity on exact timeframes and how things will get built out the wetland impacts are improved as janice brought up there 's still some questionable wetland impacts on here particularly on some of the roads and some of the lots are very tight when you consider the wetland setbacks the open space is definitely improved i appreciate on the south southwestern part that the large open space there seems like a big improvement. Affordability, I feel like, is a can of worms that we've touched on a lot. I will say, personally, I don't support any sort of waiver for affordability unless it's a very, I mean, we don't have the details on it, so it's hard to say, but that's something that I think the town and the country generally really needs, so we want to be careful about relaxing those limits wherever possible to make sure we get the maximum benefit. Concerns and general comments. The landscaping, I think, leaves a lot to be desired. It was interesting to hear you describe the importance of trees in other communities. As a member of the Town Tree Committee, this, to me, looks like a forest that's going to be clear cut to make way for a large development. And then there'll be some small trees, you know, five-gallon trees planted around that won't look like much for another 15 or 20 years, really. So that part is a little disheartening, I guess. Snow removal was brought up last time and still looks to be a real challenge in this space. I genuinely don't know how it's going to get done without shipping it out. There doesn't seem to be a lot of space to put any snow. Same for emergency access. Seems tricky with one means of ingress and egress, well, two technically. And on that point, I believe I brought it up last time, having Truman's Field Road as an emergency access point is fine in theory, But I can tell you that anyone going towards 99 is probably going to cut through Truman's Field Road on their way out and not use the main entrance. So unless there's a gate or something physically blocking them, which I don't think that defeats the purpose of an emergency road, it's going to get used as another entrance. entrance. Overall, the density is still really jarring, I guess is one word I would use. It's very dense, which can be a good thing. We need housing. The shared facilities, my last point, leave a lot to be desired, I think. If families really are the target demographic here, I have a young family and the first thing I look at is where could I bring my kids? There's one playground some open space in the southwest With hiking trails and things that's all great. That's really it. It's a small playground There's one sports court a small clubhouse The facilities aren't really there for that demographic. So that leaves a lot to be desired I think from like a marketing and a use case fit standpoint and traffic is I live in the area so I'm constantly it's on my mind I do I echo this the sentiment of this being a town within a town I'm eager to hear about the traffic study and how all that progresses thank you thanks [2:19:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Kevin appreciate your comments I mean it's certainly no doubt that we need more affordable housing in this town we hear that a lot we hear that all the time we also hear a lot of complaints that there's too much development happening and so it's hard to get too long without the other you can't get more affordable housing without building more units this is a legal use in our zoning and so we understand that you have rights as landowners to come to us with this, but obviously you should also know that this is a very big project and it's going to have a lot of impact on the town, and so we're going to take our time and make sure we really understand this. And we're not slow walking it, but it's something that we're not just going to rubber stamp. So I know you don't expect that, but I also want to make sure the public knows that we are not a rubber stamp particularly for the project of this size and I think at this stage I think it's really important for us to understand to get a sense from you guys about you said you'd like to see some adjustments to the affordability rates but this is probably the biggest issue that will have probably the biggest impact on what it is you guys can do and so we need to feel comfortable about what you need what you think you need to get out of this and what we feel comfortable with I mean again for what I what I started with is that the affordability piece is the most important part of this project for us and the one I wanted to make sure that we nail down because it's the there's at least backstop there's a lot of state environmental regulations other things that we can rely on to help us protect the very sensitive environmental issues around here the affordability piece is something I think that has that we have to play the biggest role in managing here so we need to understand how we can make sure these units stay affordable for more than five years I think it was made you can't you can't you can't make somebody keep it affordable upon resale I know that's not the case. I know that for owner-affordable housing that has been done in the past, there have been deed restrictions that have been put on them and those types of things that have to be met. Again, there's a question about who monitors that and how does that get passed. We'll have to walk through some details on those and figure that out. But I think we want to see some control there because we don't want to see, like, flip. but these things flipped where somebody buys it cheap and they know the market's going up and they're going to flip it around and a year later they're doing that market rate again. So we're going to need to know what controls we can put in place on a resale market. And I think just to follow up on Dick's discussion earlier with you guys, resale parts is going to be tricky because you're still going to be selling new lots for 10 years and I'm sure that people are trying to resell them before that. You guys don't have a controlling interest at that point when somebody goes to resell it. It's not like you have a stake in it at that point or a right of first refusal or any of that kind of thing. So you just are – once they own the lot or once they own the building, they own the building, they can sell it. It's out of your hands. Correct. Yeah, okay. Okay. So I think we'd like to get more information about how we manage that affordability. Because if we go to the preliminary plan and start doing all the engineering and then we realize we're not comfortable with how many affordable units you guys need and maybe it doesn't work out, maybe the numbers don't make sense. I feel like that's probably something we need to see in more detail about how that plan goes forward. Question about access. This board has never approved a gated access, so certainly not on a project of this size. We did it for one condo development, I think we did, but yeah. [2:24:45] Speaker G (unidentified): We blocked it off and it never worked. [2:24:47] Speaker A (unidentified): So Truman's Field Road will not be gated. It will be an access that anybody can use, not just an emergency access if it comes through like this. But I still feel strongly that there needs to be a third access toward the back of this thing and I think you guys really need to consult with those landowners back there. I know they probably have plans on future development on some of those lots out back. I would like to see some extension, right-of-way extensions that come off of either Eagle Drive there. I know you'll see one off of Finch Road, but I think one to the south of this plan off of Eagle Drive, I guess, or Cardinal Way or car to lean but would seem to make a lot of sense you really need to look at that if there's an accident at the intersection of Truman's field and it's Eagle Drive you've cut off 150 houses and they're and they're stuck have [2:26:15] Speaker G (unidentified): you Do you broach the fire chief with having him just take a quick look at this as a preliminary thing? [2:26:23] Speaker K (unidentified): No, but that's our next step here. [2:26:26] Speaker G (unidentified): I would think just a courtesy of, you know, not a formal review, but have him look at it, and if he throws it back in your face, you know you've got work to do. And if he says, eh, we can work with this, then, you know, that's another thing. But I think it would be worth early in the process having him take a look at it. [2:26:45] Speaker D (unidentified): so if I could offer a perspective I know we've I've heard this a few times and we're putting a little bit more credence on the sign off for the fire chief than the ordinance grants because we've had this discussion with town council about that ultimately the fire chief would look at this and comment on adequacy of access and circulation and hydrant placement but whether it is beyond that and they just want to be careful about you know him he doesn't really sign off on it he advises the board about what his issues are I want to make sure that we don't kind of get tangled up in that little bit my only point is the earlier [2:27:27] Speaker G (unidentified): that he gets a look at it could direct them keep them from doing engineering that's going to be useful and I agree and I don't disagree with [2:27:35] Speaker D (unidentified): what you're saying. I just want to make sure everybody understands what that rule is. [2:27:40] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not the fire chief that approves the circulation of access. We're not relying on him for that. We do look for his advice and consent on... To me, I do think you guys have improved the open space, and I appreciate that. Certainly down here on the bottom, I think that's a good decision to take out that one last loop there and I know that it's good amenity I would ask you to consider as Kevin kind of noted perhaps you can designate like a lot in each of the phases for like a playground piece that are you know closer to some of these units so that it's walkable access to some open space for families to use and providing perhaps easement walkways to meet them if it's what is the Chris can you talk to us about the community impact sure so yeah right now [2:29:15] Speaker D (unidentified): if you read it and I think this is kind of important knowing the magnitude of this the ordinance requires that actually the applicant provides a summary of what they forecast for impacts to the community. We had discussed with an independent firm about initiating that, and they had given us a proposal really to look at the detail of this, both the economic impacts of it, the impacts to all these types of things, so we understand community resources, whether it's public services, although they're not going to service this, but trash collection, the whole, any of those things that could fall into the domain of this. What we didn't do was initiate that because I wanted to make sure we weren't going to go from a 192 unit to a 50 unit. Seems to me that the concept plan that's here tonight, while there's been some adjustments, it seems to be at the same scale and magnitude. So I think we're at the point that we'd likely initiate that. They had envisioned probably a six week completion to that. So if I were to say, you've got the green light tomorrow,, we would get them all the information relative to stuff because they would look at school enrollment, all those types of things. It'd be a rather robust study so the town understands, not that these are direct approval criteria, but we know what it means to do that. Because in the end, I think I'm particularly interested in a comment you made, and you weren't making it, you were repeating it, is the idea that there's been a lot of development going on in town. it's the development that's occurring in town is where we've guided it 's all in the growth area it's all consistent with the comprehensive plan so what this study would do is it would independently look at what the impacts of that are so I think what I would say we do get in that weird time of year where November becomes January like that but so I am not gonna ask them to verify that six week timeline but my sense would be I didn't see them come back with a hundred unit development tonight that would change that so if we were to proceed with that I'd expect that we'd have a document back probably by the end of this year it would be they would answer a lot of these questions as well as I think I noted the major conversation points affordability traffic community impact study and second means of access I think knowing that this proposal seems to be aligned I don't see anything significantly changing it would I think assist the board in that next phase of deliberation so there's no concept plan but what I think is all the things have been said tonight we would likely have a revisitation of it probably by the end of the year would make sense for check in and we'd have that in hand yep [2:31:50] Speaker G (unidentified): I had another question for you guys one of the things I asked the first meeting that we had was what is your plan for visitor parking in the park, I don't think it can be just on the road. So do you have a plan for visitor parking? [2:32:17] Speaker L (unidentified): So the driveways are generally big enough that a visitor can park in the driveway, in front of the garage, depending on what garages we put, the setbacks. And in the case that neither of those work, we will put a series of visitor parking spaces through the park. [2:32:34] Speaker G (unidentified): So we'd need to see that on the plan. Yeah. Yeah, I think that makes sense. I mean, one car for one visitor. Some people have more than one friend. Yeah. [2:32:47] Speaker L (unidentified): I mean, but there is a reality of a couple cars can park in a driveway, and cars are in the garage. [2:32:54] Speaker G (unidentified): But if you're going to – drawing lines on a piece of paper doesn't create a livable area. Designing it so it fits within the land and fits people's lifestyles is what is going to make this either fail or succeed. And so we really need to think not just looking at lines on the paper, but how is it going to actually – how are people actually going to live there, and how are they going to live there happily? and that's a that's what we want to make sure happens one of the issues our [2:33:31] Speaker A (unidentified): project of this scale is that I know that we don't have a map with any topos right so it's hard to know if any of these Lots are encumbered by slopes and other things I feel like that it's probably the case and so paper this looks very flat, obviously, right? And so it would be interesting to see how the topography of the land might change if you're thinking about just leveling it all out or what. But a topo map with some of this. Oh, it might have been on Mars. But without the overlay of... I know there's a lot of lines, it'll be hard to see, but I think there's... Maybe there needs to be a smaller map, you know smaller sections yes [2:34:25] Speaker H (unidentified): a couple of thoughts on a live road you know your exit entrance there I think our regulation says you cannot be within 125 feet of another entrance to other subdivision and there's one just offset from you and mockingbird Lane across the street there's furbish Lane which is a It's a little private road very close to you, so I'd ask you to please go back and look at those, make sure you're in compliance. The other thing is that I know it seemed a strange thought, but your ability to protect these wetlands and this river has a direct effect on whether people can use our beach at the ocean or not. That's because the Kennebunk River is very impaired with both, It's been tested both animal and human waste in it, and I don't want to add to that I don't want any sediment in there. I don't want any chemicals in there because any time we have a lot of rain It comes down that river It circles around now the end of the jetty off you've been down to our beach or not Comes out on the gooshes beach and the boot the beach has to be closed to people using it So you don't want to be part of that? cause so I will leave you with that thought thank you 've [2:35:53] Speaker A (unidentified): given you a lot to chew on I don't know if you have any other questions for us at this point I guess it's kind of to you on what your next step is but yeah if I perhaps it perhaps you come back another time with another sketch but it's I'll leave that up to you if you want to do another full preliminary plan application and start to work through these things at that point but you might want to i'm [2:36:24] Speaker K (unidentified): not sure if you want to go ready to go that far i guess so mr chair i think the next logical step would be a site walk given that we're coming up against snow it might be easier to do it rather sooner rather than later i'd ask if the board would be willing to schedule that we could get this road staked out as they currently shown and then that would i think that would help for the next time we get together sure [2:36:52] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean it's fine I understand that the concerns and the [2:36:58] Speaker G (unidentified): 3d snow will inhibit our access the wetlands flag the wetlands flag yes okay [2:37:12] Speaker A (unidentified): so yeah we need to know the center lines of the roads particularly well you're [2:37:18] Speaker G (unidentified): not gonna put corner lots on every lot no but on the maybe the corner of the pods of the each of the major well I [2:37:29] Speaker A (unidentified): would say you have to stake out the road and kind of the road network I guess so we know where that is where the stream crossings are gonna be obviously that'll be part of the pros I don't I've never walked a site this big with this man this very thing so I expected it's gonna [2:37:50] Speaker K (unidentified): take a while we can personally we can do this in a few hours we've done sites this large before we can we'll have it prepared and we'll have our team ready to assist and guide the Lord so that it can expedite it I'm not looking for a full day I think with a few hours we can do this it's it's 80 acres but it can go [2:38:08] Speaker A (unidentified): it can go quick it's not I think we've done an hour at most before so this will [2:38:13] Speaker D (unidentified): be new for us Chris you have something I was gonna say I think identifying the phases could be particularly helpful considering it's a little disorienting considering the magnitude of it and from a practical perspective this is the best way to do it 's very cards on the table approach you're showing everything someone's not you know I think but still I think as you go through and understand you might get through two phases and decide you had it for a day and know how to pick up that next time because this is a lot there but [2:38:46] Speaker A (unidentified): I agree about the phasing I mean I think it's important that we see the whole picture and I understand that you don't want to build it all out. You've got to piece it together. And I think the way you phrased it seems to make sense to me in terms of I would correct one thing. It seems like you had mentioned that the community amenities were in Phase 1, but it seems like it's in Phase 2. [2:39:11] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, we're going to revise that for his comment tonight, so we'll make sure that's cleaned up. Yes. [Speaker G (unidentified): One other question.] what is your plan for rubbish pickup private trash pickup so it's likely the same company that dumpster or no private trash pickup right at the end of the [2:39:31] Speaker G (unidentified): driveway so the people would be taking each household would take a container to [2:39:39] Speaker K (unidentified): a pickup site just at the end of the driveway yeah and to the driveway and they're driving just like us another subdivision but which one to make sure [2:39:47] Speaker G (unidentified): you thought about it wouldn't be town service it would be a private correct thank you okay [2:39:56] Speaker A (unidentified): well we're not going to do it this saturday i'm pretty busy halloween you can go dressed up i'm only expecting 1200 people maybe the big foot saturday who knows when would the site be ready to Walk it. We will do it on a Saturday morning [2:40:25] Speaker K (unidentified): And so I guess obviously not this Saturday any Saturday after that I'll make sure our surveyors have that done [2:40:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Seventh would be the Saturday after [2:40:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Is this site hunted at all because I think it's that's obviously we're entering that time of year that oh, yeah As large as it is you know [2:40:52] Speaker A (unidentified): You know, that's probably opening weekend for firearms season. [2:40:59] Speaker G (unidentified): It's for the whole month of November. [2:41:08] Speaker B (unidentified): Well, we do have all those orange vests we got you last year. Noisemakers? [2:41:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I know. I know you're not walking it. November 7th, are you available? No. Oh, I mean, lost Ted. Yep. I'm sure there's an emergency situation. Are you available on the 14th, the 11th? I think we'll try for the 14th of November. It would be 8 a.m. Where would you like us to meet? The end of Truman's Field? [2:42:26] Speaker K (unidentified): That would make the most sense, yeah. [2:42:31] Speaker A (unidentified): How far down Truman's Field do you want us to drive? Or just toward the end of the pavement area? Yeah. Or toward the brook? Like kind of stop near the end? [2:42:40] Speaker K (unidentified): Yeah, probably to where the hammerhead is, I'd say, like the existing one, and along that would probably be the best, and we can walk from there. [2:42:52] Speaker A (unidentified): It's been pretty dry, so hopefully it kind of stays that way. We won't get too wet. There's definitely some, I mean, I think, obviously we'll, Chris, your suggestion was to what? Do, like, phase one and phase two, and maybe go back for another? [2:43:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I'd say do all the phases, whatever you folks think you can take on. [2:43:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Well, I think we'll definitely want to walk up Truman's Field to Eagle Drive. We're certainly going to want to walk out to Thompson, or sorry, to Alewife Road. We'll certainly walk the first phase loop, and then maybe around down to Osprey toward the community center area. But after those first bits, I think we'll see where we're at. [2:43:53] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, sir. Why don't you two point exactly where this community center is on the map there? just is it that just so I know that 's what I thought okay I assumed that was it all [2:44:07] Speaker A (unidentified): right so we'll schedule a site walk for November 14th at 8 a.m. members the public are welcome to join us on the site walk again it's yes it's not a public forum but the idea is that you will be able to hear but it's public meeting so you'll be able to hear what we hear and see what we see and that way you guys are as informed as we are about what's out then you'll hear what the developer has to say at various points so we're sturdy shoes and Hannah if you could check in with Ted and Bob and Abnish this week send them an email and see if they're available and put it on their radar so that we can try to get as many people there as we can. I guess we'll start with that, and we'll see where it goes from there. [2:45:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Taste it with the starfish. [2:45:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Next item for us is to approve the meeting minutes from September 28th. Are there any corrections? Any corrections? [2:46:04] Speaker G (unidentified): I only found one. Page 4. The next to last paragraph that starts, Jay Vance posed the question. About two-thirds of the way down, it's 25,000 or more gallons affluent. Well, it's really effluent, not affluent. With an E. It's E, not A, Jim. [2:46:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other comments or corrections? [2:46:37] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I didn't see anything else. I [2:46:41] Speaker H (unidentified): will make a motion to approve the Kennebunk Planning Board meeting minutes for September 28 26 as corrected [2:46:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Second all those in favor aye any opposed none. All right, the minutes are approved other business board members have anything else to share [Speaker H (unidentified): All] right, [2:47:22] Speaker B (unidentified): oh wait, sorry they are Yes, they are doing a virtual version of the same public information session that they held earlier tonight. I don't know the exact date. It's in about two weeks, but that is being held. We can figure out the date for that. All right. [2:47:50] Speaker H (unidentified): I will make a motion to adjourn. [2:47:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. We are adjourned.