Cape Elizabeth Building Committee Reviews 1934 Building Renovation Plan
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:12] Speaker A (unidentified): we're recording whenever you want to start okay yeah i know almost not coming i don't know about laura is this are these did i'm going to help you get you fine plans yeah we get this started yeah [Speaker B (unidentified): great all] right so why don't we get started at six o'clock we start the day before early committee for october 26 2026 so thanks to everybody for being here and it's been kind of a break but i think we were able to get some great information from pat and go through with us and then i did have some information with regards to the commercial value they'll talk about that when you get to that part of the agenda so right now i don't have it on the agenda but usually we take public comment but we have no public so yeah we have a forum i think the only people that are missing are for brigham and ahmed and yeah so if the people have a chance to look at the minutes does anybody have a motion on the events or any changes all right there's a motion to accept them as drafted we have a second so if you take kevin then he put his hand up before you make sure everything don't think i'm ignoring you any discussion on them all right all in favor so why don't we get right down to the presentation i'm assuming this is probably hi laura thanks yeah i see what you mean about the roll call for our voices they didn't think about how long it's been so long so laura if you're walking in the room why don't you start us out with saying your voice so the AI can pick it up.
[2:22] Speaker C (unidentified): Hi, I'm Laura Grist, committee member. Jim Rowe. Kevin Giemont. Brian Harris. Andy Patton. Cameron Brown. Jonathan Sargato. Penny Jordan. Pat Cox. Susanna Mazzell-Hubbs.
[2:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so now that it's got a pass, what is that you want to talk to us about? Go ahead. Laura, do you have one of these? I just got one.
[2:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. So I will run through, Let me thank, Amit's not here, but I'm just thanking for, he was able to pull together some plans, but didn't have them in AutoCAD and the drafting format, and he helped out with getting these square footages and flat around some of the spaces and stuff. So he put some extra time into it with a big help on just getting these numbers down for what kind of areas we're looking at.
[3:09] Speaker A (unidentified): And Pat, when you're done, remind the two, you know, Amit's points that he made in that email.
[3:16] Speaker B (unidentified): mail oh yeah yep so the task is to scroll down one time was to explore the use of the 1934 building as a municipal offices for town hall and school administration as well as identifying remaining spaces available for community programs or gathering spaces so going through that exercise we really look at the floor plans of each floor the three floors of the 1834 building so you can see what i would call first floor or main floor you can see the columns on the bottom of the diagram or the columns out in front facing spot liar road if you remember though that entrance does not have ada accessibility because inside the first threshold it doesn't really show it here but you've got right here you do have a set of stairs before you go through this circuit so ADA access to this main level does remain along the back of the building to the elevator space here and then a set of stairs here and a set of stairs here so the focus was that we looked at it looked at the programmed areas another exercise I don't show is the floor plan we took the floor plan in this building and actually put it into our code enforcement software that actually lets you scale drawings up and down to so we double checked with a combination of actually pulling tape in certain office spaces against the original drawings of this building matched everything up and adjustments where we had to so what we ended up with was a spreadsheet of every single employee space in this building and then when it looked at what would we need in the 1934 building some went up some went down we based the 1934 building office spaces on a properly laid out what would someone need if their office was laid out the right way so a lot of them the square footage actually went down but the practical use of those spaces went up so the 1934 building use for office spaces is actually slightly less than what we occupy in office spaces here even though we built in three or four extra workstations across departments that are likely to grow over the next several you know several decades is that one gross or beautiful what's that was just this was just gross and usable but i'm just saying if you if i add up all of the spaces that are not hallways like if i just go into people's workspaces here we added up what do you have right now so take the superintendent's office and it's like okay you've got a desk over here but he's got a conference table what does he have now what would we have what is the we looked at layouts of a lot of newer buildings that were either town halls my experience with public works and i told you most of why i think i could do this exercise because i recently went through all of these exercises with architects and space planning so i tried to go back to some of those plans and say okay i can picture this 100 square foot office in my head i know it functions well because i worked within that building for four or five years and i just took that and said okay we might not need 120 or 140, if it's 100 and it's laid out right. And that's where, even though we added some office spaces, the overall square footage came out different or lower. So it wasn't likely we'd have to grow those using the usual spaces considerably. So the goal here was to say, could we, one assumption was, would it be nice to put all core municipal functions related to payments, permits, and public facing transactions? So anything someone just walks in the door to do on a daily basis whether it's a building permit or they're sent down the hall to see the assister or they're sent from one office where they wanted to know what their taxes would be to another finance counter where they pay the taxes all of that could happen with this main level of 1934 building so on it just added some shading to kind of show spaces that we weren't really building in how big a hallway had to be because we're assuming we're just going to stay with the existing hallways so that's where gross versus so like usable area of his 5538 is the blue shaded area and not really the yellow the yellow area because you know the hallway is probably slightly wider than we would build in a new building there's no reason to move those walls that's going to get more expensive so those are some of the assumptions we tried to kind of make as we went through we did not do individual office layout now certainly we just start getting and if we ever get to that point you can get into how you exactly lay out each one of these boxes but you can start to pretty easily see okay this classroom could take all of the assessing planning and codes that's grouped together now could fit in this space but we didn't do the
[8:05] Speaker C (unidentified): individual office layouts did you want to talk about the accessibility of that the covering
[8:14] Speaker B (unidentified): him with that yeah ahmed has a comment that will come up later i think but we what we looked at was like how i asked him like what would it you know what are we really looking at it costs if we wanted to get the elevator out of this location and bring it over to the front or over to the parking or whatever and it just without exact numbers it does seem like if you can get people to the existing elevator it just makes a lot of sense money-wise not to mention if you were to get it from outside this building the top story is in is in from there so you can't just truly tack it onto the outside of the building because you still won't get to the top floor
[8:50] Speaker A (unidentified): so my only thought in that regard is that the two different entrances one for an elevator one for the pedestrian the stairs you might have to i think this space would have to be a little shared
[9:02] Speaker B (unidentified): or yes the best of you love here yeah so one idea that my idea is that we bounced around where Obviously, out here, and I apologize if anyone watches this after and can't see the presentation laser pointer, but I'm just pointing to the rear of the building to show well off of the building is where the athletic fields will be. But between the building and the new athletic field, you could potentially come down this back area with a covered walkway of sorts. And I could actually picture, if you were to do like a glassed-in breezeway, A, you don't have winter maintenance for your ADA access and also if there were a sporting event and it started raining and some parents wanted to come in there were like kind of windows where you could just lean and watch a sporting event going it could be kind of a nice look for the back of the building
[9:50] Speaker D (unidentified): charge but the parking lot seems gonna be on the left if you look at the
[9:59] Speaker A (unidentified): existing parcel it'd be to me it'd be an easy access the parking lot that got
[10:05] Speaker B (unidentified): got built as a part of this project come way back here, that all goes away because of the ball field space. So only the front half of the parking lot stays, which gets you into like this area. But either way, you have to come along the back of the building and to get someone in the winter months to this doorway for ADA, I think looking at some sort of covered feature.
[10:29] Speaker A (unidentified): It would be nice if it was kind of put glass cover because we wouldn't want to take away from the windows on them in the basement and we'll probably get to that yeah because if you did do something that was completely like it would it would basically make it so no daylight would get into the which kind of what they have
[10:51] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah although when we get yeah when we get to the lower level we were thinking maybe this back space more in your storage as well as and then the front area it's okay so that was the plan for services and yes they fit within those sort of usable blue boxes looking at the second floor just to put into perspective this the red box in the bottom right corner is approximately I did when I dropped it in here I'm not within i was not i'm not within the software i'm not within the scale software so it might be a little bit off if anything i tried to show it's probably showing a little wider than our actual but this would be our town hall chambers now so with a little bit narrower or longer design you could see where this front corner of the building or even this end whichever end maybe this ends is closer to the elevator who knows but you could certainly on this front side fit a chamber as well as perhaps a retractable wall so you've got a chamber space or a planning board space for small meetings you open the retractable wall to another conference room that could be used separately by other groups during the day and you could have it for larger meetings like a public hearing or something like that so and that would allow the back of the on the top floor to be some of the back end central service central office services or the school administration because it would be up above looking over the school campus so the back part of that building and again you get some great sunlight coming in this back end of the building if you think of the majority of the time we're using chamber and common times it's at night so it's not quite you know some of that sunlight for working spaces and quite as critical so this floor seemed to have enough room for council chambers meeting spaces that can be reserved for all different functions throughout the building and administrative offices we did build it up in for you know a couple of like positions that are scattered through the schools if you know if the superintendent's office truly had the superintendent a couple of director level positions with the assistant superintendent there was room within our space allocation with that as well is that what it seemed like it would be an example of one that doesn't have to be on the person there's actually so much room on the first floor with those two extra things that they could end up there but they could potentially end up something that was brought up at one of the tours of the
[13:31] Speaker A (unidentified): building too bottom left corner and the bottom right there's no windows and they're dead-end spaces for code they couldn't use those for the school they couldn't use those quickly think it was put in there yeah so if you that wall opening it up and adding it on to this chamber
[13:50] Speaker B (unidentified): would allow it to be well one of these ends almost naturally becomes the ab room that we have in the back of our council chambers as well as long as you have a second means back out into the chamber or something one thing on it brought up and i did talk to our phone enforcement officer a little bit is once you get into something the size of our chamber you're talking assembly space so it increases your bathrooms a little bit but looking at it quickly you're it's not like it increases the bathrooms because it's designated assembly space but if you look at how bathrooms are i mean we're not talking council meetings are not a high use it's not like going to a you're not going to hockey game or something you're not going to sporting event the usage is not like we're gonna so we have to build to code but we don't really have to have so for code the bathrooms that accommodated the assembly space can be within one floor. So it allows us to basically build the bathrooms we would need for town hall and still meet the assembly because everything would be within two floors. So it doesn't get outrageous when we're building a lot of extra bathrooms. So I think we had seven individual restrooms planned, you know, a combination of men's, women's, and even sex individual restrooms. So we factored that into when we started doing the space.
[15:06] Speaker A (unidentified): We talked a little bit about the drop ceiling that exists now, whether or not that could be looked at. Yeah.
[15:13] Speaker B (unidentified): So interestingly, you can kind of see, yeah, there are windows here. So when we access up above, this is all clear stands. Many of these walls here are pretty sacrificial, which is nice when you're trying to open up for a chamber or something like that. You don't even have to keep this hallway wall like we would on the first floor. You could move it over and narrow. narrow. You can kind of see on it just showing more like a five foot corridor to show that like even this wall over here right now could come over another five feet to make your chamber wider and it feels like a narrower corridor. But if you poke your head out, there's a chance you could open some space up to the natural sort of ceiling elevation and actually be one of those end path windows like right over the end of the chamber, which would be kind of a... So there were some neat architectural things that you could bring in to highlight I like that you're using an old space and it's not just a built-out box, so that was kind of interesting. Obviously, you might not open up the whole thing for energy considerations and whatnot and different things like that, but there was the possibility of it going.
[16:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Was there a discussion about whether the staircases' width and capacity to accommodate the center was used?
[16:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Not right down to every... I think the only thing that... The only thing that it lacks i believe is just the railing height which would have there's a question
[16:33] Speaker C (unidentified): i would guess given the numbers
[16:38] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah but what worked for students as an existing use hope you have to meet you code when you renovate buildings and change even if you renovated it as a school you might have to change it to be 48 or 60 based on the sprung code of what you sound like
[17:04] Speaker B (unidentified): the idea was to have at least at least one or two small conference rooms on each floor okay so that we're reduced we're not just putting meeting space in other offices we're just making it so it's more like you reserve you reserve but we have a few more options than they do here, I think. If we get a couple of small ones, one or two small spaces, and then also try to use, somewhere I'd love to do the retractable wall thing because once I had to build it with that, it was amazing how useful it was. Because you very rarely needed that big, space. So it's just, to be able to compartmentalize it and actually still have some private space for two different groups, can cut down a lot on this. Just to think of something like elections,
[17:50] Speaker A (unidentified): they could be permanently set up in half of that
[17:52] Speaker B (unidentified): and you can still use the whole other half or something yeah especially if you look at your next several council meetings you don't have those and not to mention we have new for the really big you know if it's a hot topic where you really truly think you're going to get 100 or 200 people the new middle school has two rooms that are it has a stage in two different rooms that are perfectly set up to accommodate some of those two so there's no reason to ignore there's no reason to over build this and ignore the fact that there's going to be brand new space elsewhere and talent doesn't exist today so i think there's a lot of them as it went through any sort of preliminary design or space planning to make great use of that and take advantage
[18:33] Speaker C (unidentified): of the new space that's being built right now before you move on my understanding would have been that there was a need for more space like this about you know kind of like this Yeah. Is that accommodated in the retractable wall, or is that just in here? Yes.
[18:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Like, I could see, like, this remains, like, the conference room that's kind of like what we're sitting in now. And then this is at least two spaces, like a retractable, you know, a council chamber that's three-quarters of it and a retractable space that can be an addition to the chamber or treated separately. separately. And then you have, you know, a school administrative suite. And I mean, honestly, on the town administration side, I tend to, I mean, right now I share admin with other departments. I don't have quite as much, just not as many people or dollars for the edge. So therefore, I mean, I would assume, so I'd go get less space for, say, a town administration.
[19:34] Speaker C (unidentified): But things like the planning department, which today are on the second floor, would be more
[19:38] Speaker A (unidentified): on the first floor yep the really nice thing about the division of public versus well public day use almost in public night use is that you could have doors at the staircase on the second floor that lock yes so that people aren't wandering through town hall at six o'clock at night and you know there's security issues there's there's all kinds of public record issues yeah election issues all sorts of things so you can shut that second floor down
[20:06] Speaker E (unidentified): at night let people circulate upstairs yep and the folding petition allows for confidential or dangerous sessions particularly so to be honest the in the
[20:17] Speaker B (unidentified): brand new built building that I was in before I came here the most soundproof wall in the entire building was our petition our moving petition yeah it actually compared to a sheetrock wall with just interior sheetrock walls today they you could hear everything like the first day in that office I first day in my office I had a fairly private meeting in my office space and three people said just you know the future reference so we and our division wall is between a 20 or 30 person conference room and a public works lunch room your sound transfer for even during the lunch hour of a 30 person public works group. So yeah, that's what it is. Yeah, so those are actions from Matt's standpoint, probably better than today's spaces. We'll come back to any of these, there's not that many slides, so.
[21:23] Speaker A (unidentified): In terms of the chamber size, it's just two people have been quite involved, both you know are in the chambers a lot how often is that chamber full with public and council members like is that size adequate if it needs to be bigger with smaller workers i think we no
[21:46] Speaker C (unidentified): longer discuss them in the school even so without their names so i hope during the school was an example of when yeah i just don't typically have a huge amount of people or anything in my life yes
[22:02] Speaker B (unidentified): so i think for when i did the community rundown just of total square footage used in the new i reduced it by a couple hundred square feet at least for just the initial planning [Speaker A (unidentified): but] so that brings to what was the most interesting level was kind of that lower I'm going to call it lower level, hopefully everybody, I don't, I don't think, I don't think a redone space, given the size of the windows it had, I think it feels like a lower level. It's maybe not, yeah, I mean, then again, it's not a basement. I think it feels like it's certainly far more substantial a space than that. So I just call it the lower level. But this level is interesting because it's, you know, you figure it's the size of that it's the size of that main floor that we're putting all of our services on there's a lot of room where i could picture one of these back side of the building so this would be like an example of a space that does space into what could be that covered walkway area that being storage so we just minimized all we're minimizing file storage in the future anyway we're digitizing all of the majority of the files that take up most room or everything that's in the building code and assessing office, those are all being digitized in the next year. So permanent record storage versus digital record storage, we'll be going through a pretty robust like how much do we really often have in paper in a building, but this could serve as like a central storage space that's locked down with different compartments for different departments if needed for different key access that have different controls over different sets of our permanent records. So, this could be storage, another one of these spaces could be a small space and all of this could be open, all the front of the building could be open for larger space. One thing that I've noticed is an awful lot of events spill over into the fire department's large kind of meeting room because they're just aren't, especially during day hours because you can't have people you can't have senior program walking through a school when the
[24:14] Speaker A (unidentified): school's back here or i will say i went on three fire calls this week so i was like a slaughtered
[24:19] Speaker B (unidentified): week and then meeting every day which is an issue yeah it really is yeah so one thing that space does have that i've seen utilized for a couple different things we utilized it for our employee appreciation days it does have a nice like kitchen food prep food storage area and there is no question, I don't know a community event that doesn't go better when it has a little bit of refreshments or some snacks or something. So to actually give all of the community events a space like over here to build out as not, we're not talking a commercial kitchen that's gonna churn out food, but just someplace to actually eat stuff up, prep stuff, have some trays, have some platters and stuff. I think that'll go a long way to, if senior programming went down to this floor, Or you could then, you know, you could then have some little luncheons for senior programming.
[25:13] Speaker C (unidentified): Similar to the community services kitchen?
[25:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, something, or, I mean, a lot like what that fire department kitchen looks like, because you've got a giant counter space. You're not talking to them unless you get into Bigfoot systems and stuff. You're not talking to them a lot. Like layout space.
[25:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, most people bring their parents there.
[25:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Plug in a few crock pots or something for a community service.
[25:37] Speaker A (unidentified): have a exhaust and all that with it no theirs is pretty small there's a pretty small sound
[25:43] Speaker B (unidentified): fiction i who knows but maybe something between that and what the fire department is somewhere
[25:47] Speaker A (unidentified): it used to be twice a month and now it's three or four days a week because it's a great space it is it is a real good space but you have employees over there evils is back again it's it's a tough balance there are also some context issues because
[26:05] Speaker B (unidentified): you're bringing all different members of the public through an active working space and if the firefighters are on your 23rd hour and all these calls and they're just trying to get a minute of rest but then the resident snapshot is oh they were just sitting there it's not a lot of fire operations are not meant to be walked through by the general public or the rest of town staff 20 minutes like what could be in the air 24th hour and noon for us so there can
[26:29] Speaker A (unidentified): be some spicy language which isn't appropriate for some of the guests that building so it's just it's just sometimes it's going i think there could be a high demand for that at many different
[26:41] Speaker C (unidentified): patrons and across the across the community yeah you see there's a lot of new programs have been looking through some of the space that we've used that iron partner before community services space not really set up to do some of those things even i don't know back to your you were expressing a question about the emergency shelter at some point
[27:05] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah like for a warming shelter if we had a power outage for a long time this would be great like i go back to when i had kids and you were i used the fire station with my kids for like a soccer game you know you could get together and have italian sandwiches i mean this may be great because it ties into the fields and schools i think that might be a high demand huge but to your point, I was talking to someone who works with the state and shelters have historically been a, or sorry, schools have been historically a place that uses a shelter during storms. And the state is really trying to get away from that because what happens is Monday rolls around, they want to reopen the school, but there's 20 families in the gym and it creates a really big issue then. so to have space that can be flexible and relieve the pressure on the school to serve that
[27:58] Speaker B (unidentified): role it's like the community center in south orleans it's great it's an excellent school but it's not here and what and gone are the days used to be you set up and try to have one big shelter and you turn the keys over in the red cross brand the shelter for you as long as it met certain standards and you became a regional chapter everybody pretty much does their own thing now and i would say the majority of community sheltering is warming centers and charging centers so someone can go warm up charge their phone like during a polonka storm or something
[28:28] Speaker A (unidentified): like that 's the majority of sheltering nowadays but yeah it impacted one i don't know what i'm sure a lot changed in 94 but that used to be the cafeteria so they had a kitchen downstairs it was on the south side of the building and so i don't know there's set up slimes things along those yeah that one's a little cafeteria and then there would still
[28:51] Speaker B (unidentified): probably be room for you know i could see potentially once if we went further down this road the consolidation of all of our you know the library offers some senior programming and services community services those i could see a little bit of a senior service hub forming where someone actually has an office down there which kind of keeps that sort of level of control over the whole space even if there's different user groups but someone's sort of home base just down there that might be in a different building now which would then free up more space in community services or the library for other for future growth and those so then we
[29:24] Speaker C (unidentified): get into accessibility so let's see a conversation about how it would be elevated yeah okay elevator
[29:35] Speaker B (unidentified): i think it does yeah i serviced that okay you had me wondering into it because we didn't take i didn't take the elevator down to that floor so i was i mean it is it's here okay but i wasn't i just wasn't sure if the door opened on that level but yeah it's been a while since i was in
[29:52] Speaker A (unidentified): the building i can't figure in this on this floor because there's the window like a fire what's the best space in terms of a usable space for an all-function community function something and what's the space that's really comfortable working this is the best space okay there's a lot of
[30:12] Speaker B (unidentified): windows they're just not showing there's a lot of windows here it does because of probably added duct work or whatever like the ceiling the ceiling actually angles down so if you're back in the middle of the open space you don't see the full window i'm not sure we could i don't think it would be a lot of bang for the buck to kind of redeem that space because there's a bunch of new things in it but that 's but this i would this is the space that gets all of this the natural light from the front this side just stays this side just stays purely mechanical
[30:48] Speaker A (unidentified): and then this outside this building currently connects to this building in the two sections it's not in the middle right it's not in the middle no there's open space where those windows are now and when the building first opened the whole it was symmetrical and then in the 50s when they built the breezeway that went to the new gym the we're just looking at this angle the right side of the building which is on the top of the picture they lost a lot of the doors and I think a lot of the wind or a few windows and I'm looking at Jim he's correcting me on this but yeah so that's and then it actually in 94 it expanded the that breezeway actually got larger and then on the left side of the building from this diagram that also expanded too but they have that little courtyard in the middle which and i think the south side has bigger windows than the north side the north side's pretty much only like three foot windows but i think the south side just because the grade definitely goes down. So there's probably more natural light on the south side. Yeah, because I don't think you're going to get too much natural light from the north side. And I have to imagine there probably was a cleaner window line across, but that elevator in the elevator machine room also closed off some of it too. Not much to get back from getting that elevator.
[32:18] Speaker E (unidentified): What is the IT on the second floor and the rest of the professionals there?
[32:25] Speaker B (unidentified): They could go on all three from the audience. iTunes is not a big, this is probably, I'm realizing I'm gonna go to the next slide only because I probably should have actually just done that. I probably should have kind of started with this one, but we did the layouts, but this was kind of the programming spaces and I thought that diagram just sort of showed how much space we kind of try to, Accommodate just for meeting spaces because of the nature of what we do produce some other facilities that might be the same size. This is not on that. No, this is a program for this would be This would be for the new. Oh, it was like I said, total square footage wasn't much different for usable spaces like that. It's ACP code. Yeah, assessing So the idea was that admin support that they share works out really, well. If we started segmenting them, we're going to have to add more admin support because they do all get walk-ins, they do all get people looking at cinema files.
[33:27] Speaker A (unidentified): And this is, this would be usable square footage here. So if you were to lay this in a brand new building, you'd need a...
[33:34] Speaker B (unidentified): So you still have to tap out on the 11-ounce square. You still have to tap on hallways. It was all those things that you can kind of, why measure every nook and cranny hallway here? Just assume, yes, we're going to need a hallway there, but like I said, we might need to just change the hallway alignments to meet what's already there versus redo them just because we want it a foot wide or a little bit more. Central office, just to define that a little bit more for you, is the, so we have the, you'll hear referred to as the one town concept where we share things between the town schools that's not typical most of our neighboring communities don't do that but we do so it's a nice bang for the buck cost savings but we've got so the central office would be we have two people that they're processing invoices from the school department to school accounts down in the town tax central office is sort of being those shared resources cable hr and some auditing the internal auditing of our financials and our finger processing school admin which really being one of the upper level of management team schools IT education is an office in the 1934 version of town hall but she doesn't have here basically so I can find so finance does mean our finance director but also finance also means the three people that you would go see when you register your vehicle and how much space is sort of seated with them file you know file storage some break a break room of varying size something at least to kind of separate from yeah i think the break room becomes the most important for the admin shared service people that are just front and center all day long just a place to kind of at least not have to eat right and just kind of
[35:27] Speaker A (unidentified): keep those transactions turning so the planning department is going to need a lot less file space
[35:33] Speaker B (unidentified): which is what we took yeah so that's that's kind of greatly reduced from this the
[35:39] Speaker E (unidentified): dual square footage space calculations assume what super invented ideal searching circumstances centers would like to see and that is to have his assistant superintendent there essentially we just
[35:54] Speaker B (unidentified): called it like director level so whatever programs he whatever program your superintendent has to assume that the ones that span all of his buildings he might want in here right and the 8735
[36:06] Speaker E (unidentified): also assumes that there's additional space for expansion as you mentioned
[36:14] Speaker B (unidentified): I can show you after we pull this down. I'll just show you the quick spreadsheet. I didn't, it's one of those things, I can show you how kind of where I arrived at it. It's one of those things the numbers could definitely move by each little office. I think it was pretty good.
[36:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Even just based on these plans, the first floor and second floor,, the total is 789 square feet above that number. So there is rooms within just those two floors, not talking about the lower level.
[36:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, but this list right here that I have does not have, yeah, this list right here does not have, so obviously we would move some of the storage down onto the bottom floor, but what this doesn't have is hallways and bathrooms.
[36:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, but I'm looking at usable for first floor, usable for second floor is 9,500. hundred and minus eighty seven made you with seven hundred eighty nine that's that's not programmed yet on the first and second floor yeah not including circulation before the two to the car that i just wanted to get into what ahmed sent with regards to his comments he mentioned that mechanical space would be assumed to be located in the basement floor to serve all floors which would basically be turning the 1934 building back to what it originally was and then he wrote in the event that the base the lower level serves another function other than town hall that the study is required to provide ada access either with a ramp or to the west side of the building which is by the playground or managing the elevator access and i actually asked them about whether or not doing that breezeway might be a good way to kind of maintain that ada access and he said that could be a intended solution and then he also wrote that to be verified by the bed the code enforcement that the chamber would be considered assembly space and if so that this would require a significant number of bathrooms as discussed the square footage in the program felt appropriate for this to be given the early stage so which i did you know because i did
[38:28] Speaker B (unidentified): verify impairment yes it was going to be i can't remember what that square footage special was but it would need it but it really just from the bathrooms i sort of just i already assumed that we would want in the building given the different services on different levels we just tapped on like one end for the rest of everyone
[38:46] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah and then just talking more about the ada access from the parking lots and the best approach to making sure that 's provided for and so i think i think we're i think we're One thought, and maybe it's too nuanced, but because you're essentially ripping off the building in the back, it's going to be a construction site, and you do have to max the grade to the insomniac field to some extent, you're only a half story above or below grade, so there's also a chance you could bring a grade outside the building up or down to the lower level or up to the first level so that you're not walking at a top story a full story the lower level used to be that way the cafeteria walked right out oh yeah although that was on the
[39:39] Speaker B (unidentified): west side of the building yeah it'll be interesting to see what the yeah well the west
[39:45] Speaker A (unidentified): side would be easier 25 steps up you just grade that down and set the grade down yeah
[39:55] Speaker B (unidentified): But we know those ADA thresholds for a ramp bring you, know, you start to try to make up four feet. Yeah. Four feet out. So that's where we're... Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Good idea. Certainly worth, I imagine, if this progresses and keeps going in this direction, at least looking at the grading of that field before it's truly built, even though, yes, it's been awarded. Yes, it's designed, but you know if there's any grading changes coming off the proposed site that's been accommodated something here
[40:30] Speaker A (unidentified): But I'm also realizing and looking at it, but there's actually no room past the stairs to circulate that grade. If you look at it You come in. Stairs are here. Yeah, so even if you meet at this grade, the stairs have a jump. Do you need to cut us That's Pat Halloway next to the stairs. Yeah, there's definitely some challenge. Yeah.
[40:54] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it's doable, but it's not something that I'll do off the top of my head. I'll show the next one if you'd like. So we had tossed around numbers in the cost per square foot much higher than this. And those were kind of the ones I had in my head from our early meetings, but we took those from mahoney concept number who knows what so i did try to talk to i mean you can like just type in ai if you want and say and you're going to land down with that like two to three hundred dollars a square foot the owner rep is worth mentioning that when we walk through the building before i finalize this the owner rep from turner townsend that's our owner rep for the school project not chops that was involved early on during design but dennis was actually on site for them and just construction projects done construction projects for decades all over new england he walked through and commented on some spaces with us superintendent so what he needed to do and i had to say yeah and he had copies of the plans and copies of some stuff they had looked at separately so he was towards the lower end at first just to say oh you could reuse this space but when i started saying like look we only get in our municipal world the other way i look at it is either you do it right once you don't you're not going back to the voters about that building again if you do go to the voters about it so you do almond flooring you do you do some things that you don't want to just have to start layering into your capital plan within the first five or ten years so that was how we got to the so that 450 even though it seems reduced from what we talked about a few months ago i double checked it i mean in a very broad brush sense with contractors engineers and a couple of people that are just in the business of doing this and they thought that was more than the last thing i want to do is sit here and put start putting a number out publicly that i don't feel like i feel like all of a sudden last thing we want is to for that number to jump significantly so i feel like after people saw the space or heard what we wanted to do and what we were going to work within for constraints to kind of stay within certain parameters those numbers seem pretty good see if the rest of the process proves that to be but that's you know that's building only i don't know if any level of perimeter site work is built into those general numbers that would
[43:27] Speaker A (unidentified): probably be for me we're still we're still waiting for the number of budget lines on what the what's in the school project now for the work that they're going to do on the south side of the building when they remove the middle school i know i have the scope i don't know well i
[43:44] Speaker B (unidentified): i don't know if it's buried in all of the different emails it's not in one line item so the question is i mean unless we're looking to i think that it's going to have to be i mean i don't know how i don't know how much time you want me to spend or having them do i just don't know you just have a number because yeah i don't think it is because some of the brick restoration work on the back gets tied in with maybe other brick or like i think they're in some big broader lump sum numbers i mean maybe it's not much i
[44:19] Speaker A (unidentified): mean maybe it's 50 grand and i'm not saying 50 grand is a lot of money but in the scheme of
[44:25] Speaker B (unidentified): those numbers yeah i don't think any timing of the two projects would work in a way that would allow given what they're doing i don't know that i don't know that there would ever be an opportunity for a sizable number to say oh don't do this because we might do i think the time
[44:44] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah the reason i was looking forward because obviously if this building was new or this building isn't going to be given back over to the town you gotta decide what to do and that's i assume once they've removed the existing middle school and then they want to do that work how much would that basically be taken off that number right there it's not because it's already budgeted for and it's bottom that's that's so but again it might not be significant that it's going to put a debt to that number so it might not even be worth much of a conversation with
[45:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, how does the parking factor that was given to where parking would be, what is the cost, etc., is that part of this cost?
[45:28] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it's not part of this cost. So the big question remains, because parking was a very robust lengthy discussion during the planning board of what the school needed by ordinance or by numbers versus what they go to use on a daily basis. so I think that really has to be revisited as soon as on to because that parking lot that just got built the remainder part of that will go away on the final phase of the new school but a lot of it remains and if that could just be purposed for this that there's plenty of parking depending on what portion of it needs to be allocated to both teachers and administration or something that's where would there have to be supplemental parking or just parking yourself to be shifted to other areas of the campus that are underutilized
[46:19] Speaker A (unidentified): also the superintendent preferred to have everyone at fungo in the middle school be able to park up on the peninsula the upper area but they are expanding the lot that's between the baseball diamond and the high school that lot's getting expanded and that's going to be very close to the new middle school so once things get filled there's a good chance that lot's going to actually work quite well certain teachers will park there and walk into the middle school the junior parking lot so they come with all the boots on that one no not that one the one the other one after you make that turn and you're heading down towards the tennis court yeah it's stacked for a minute oh yeah the price is not fully utilized and what came up from the planning board it's essentially not only does the school property have more than zoning requires but the planning director went out there and on a on a regular day i think they measured 140 spaces that weren't used in a given day it was mostly about allocation of where people are parking yeah you know put them down by the pool people aren't parking during in school day much but then it gets used different times right i'm thinking about this more from
[47:39] Speaker C (unidentified): cat qualities and it's daytime time hall uses but that is also the theme of town that's experience which are also heavily used after working hours so just wondering how that
[47:52] Speaker A (unidentified): would all they would do that's that remaining town hall and the sports game going on yeah but that
[47:58] Speaker B (unidentified): So the parking lot that remains is larger than any parking we've conducted.
[48:04] Speaker A (unidentified): And it's also not, it's much bigger than what was there before. You probably remember that small little parking lot that had like 20 spots.
[48:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Right. I think it's about 50? Yeah,
[48:19] Speaker A (unidentified): it's laid out better than the current one with the triangle shape too. Initially they had a sign that was again triangle shaped, but they changed it to a rectangular so it will work well to pull in and you'll be able to find a spot versus going to two different slots yeah so it would be interesting to really present this
[48:38] Speaker C (unidentified): concept to that enough we can get to that point if you're able to say yes there's parking here that was designated for the school but we do think it could also be you know that would help
[48:48] Speaker B (unidentified): i know that parking lot was designed all the way through the process to supplement some level of the reuse of the 1934 program but without a quantified use or exactly what that busy times at the top of my head the conflict time that i think would be right now like during absentee voting during that election season when we have more workers here because of the election workers that would be like the one period of time where there's sort of a spike in our day part here other than that but it does depend on how we want to pursue the use of the lower level community space because that would probably likely trigger more of an overlap with day parking constraints town hall day parking is pretty minimal i mean you're only talking 30
[49:37] Speaker A (unidentified): cars here at the time maybe good yeah but it unfolds all the teachers wanted to park it up a
[49:44] Speaker B (unidentified): lot that's where it's more controlled at all people yeah i think there would have to be some
[49:49] Speaker A (unidentified): some sort of recognition that, okay, let's lay, let's organize how and where people are in the park.
[49:58] Speaker B (unidentified): I did in this, I can't say that I want to point it out, but because later on under cross modeling or affecting thresholds that, you know, the town council believes are a community benefit or what the community might be willing to support from a dollar value, there is always the possibility I layered these so that this green bar at the top is the lower level. So you get to these costs of 6.5 to 9.8 total. But if you were to remove, if you were to say, we're not going to do as much finish of the lower level and we're going to save that for some future thing, you could still take care of town hall functionality for four to six million. here so i just tried to show i would it's not a project i would suggest phasing because i think it'd be a hard building to work on once some of it's occupied and i think you've overall spent
[50:54] Speaker A (unidentified): more work to do it that way but i think you have to be careful doing it on the dollar for dollar as well because a big chunk whether or not you renovate the lower level is mechanical i know i know right so that'll eat up a big chunk and then the minutia of putting up the office
[51:12] Speaker B (unidentified): it was smaller i felt like i should mention it in case someone wanted to look at it that way in any kind of phasing but i it's not that i would somewhere ask me i wouldn't i certainly recommend
[51:20] Speaker C (unidentified): it but yeah exactly do the recommendations say this here's a potential rumor but i wouldn't
[51:27] Speaker B (unidentified): recommend i wouldn't i wouldn't even recommend that the committee get into a phasing recommendation but i just wanted you to just kind of see that i did do it by floor in case of well just for
[51:38] Speaker A (unidentified): clarification of course brian just made me think about this mechanical stuff really isn't designated one floor because that's for the whole no you're going to have to do all that no matter what yes
[51:52] Speaker B (unidentified): that's where you'd have to see that's where you'd have to subtracting just square footage to brian's point doesn't bring the cost down linearly the building is going to cost you
[52:05] Speaker A (unidentified): I just want to make sure we're clear on this that six to nine million dollar mark right now that's for renovation is there going to be a three million dollar and then you have to throw on top of that for or to make this yourself that should that should include the mechanic
[52:22] Speaker B (unidentified): it should okay I just want to make sure some of the people I ran it by I made sure they do like there is no this building will not come with any material right so you highlighted that okay
[52:34] Speaker A (unidentified): as long as long as you know i just want to make sure i mean by no means like i told you
[52:39] Speaker B (unidentified): this was going to be very this is one of these this is one of these projects we could have hired and paid 30 000 for so you're getting that you're getting the penny and that's fine
[52:49] Speaker A (unidentified): just a little bit thought i didn't want to make sure all of a sudden they'd be like oh wait we forgot to put in heating so pat would you be able to go to that's a lot of the problems
[52:57] Speaker C (unidentified): with the basics square footage times the renovation cost yeah it's just square footage
[53:04] Speaker B (unidentified): times the high and low range right and i just i left it by floor but we already had it sort of
[53:10] Speaker C (unidentified): that rating but technically as brian's pointing out and if i understood right it actually would you couldn't really do that if that is a mechanical
[53:20] Speaker B (unidentified): Not to exactly those numbers.
[53:22] Speaker C (unidentified): I might suggest for future sharing with the broader problem, they might actually confuse people. That's going to be a hard concept for people to graph.
[53:32] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean, that graph could quickly just graph total costs. You know, in our, really doesn't even have to be a graph.
[53:37] Speaker E (unidentified): Would that include contingencies and working awards and all that stuff?
[53:42] Speaker B (unidentified): so certainly when you get to the 450 it should i mean it's nasty yeah something else that i
[53:54] Speaker A (unidentified): basically said i just thought if the project is moving forward and doing it all in one package that includes the lower level there has to be some sense of what that's going to be. And so that's an interesting question because I think there's been talk of this group might be able to use it, this group might be able to use the funds to spend the money to fit out spaces, to buy spaces with heating, circulation, everything and not actually know what it's going to be. It's not money we want to spend. So that's, I think as this goes forward if the concept is to move town hall into this building i think we need to get pretty specific in terms of what that lower level is because you can't build it out until you know
[54:48] Speaker C (unidentified): what it is yeah so i'm kind of down that road it's like so then conceptually i think what i feel is that we're kind of feeling heading in this direction to say to the council do we continue to travel this road? That's really the question to the docs. Because we're at this level. Now, the question is, okay, do we continue to peel the onion and determine whether it is feasible from a numberless perspective? Because it seems feasible from a space of
[55:26] Speaker B (unidentified): use perspective. Yeah. But I mean, that bottom space obviously changes drastically if somebody says, yep, and the lower level can be a daycare or the lower level can serve seniors or I mean we know there'll be some storage needs the kitchen just seems to be a practical idea but it's not necessary if that doesn't accommodate any of the other uses but that general use space won't change much for senior programming community group meetings but you know literally holding the board meeting there I mean that isn't gonna change much just gonna be what kind of furniture do you buy like this that slides around and is easily... So I guess what I'm asking is
[56:05] Speaker C (unidentified): how many more questions do we need to answer before besides the what could we get for selling
[56:16] Speaker B (unidentified): it at all? I'm just going to put it on my last slide just a little bit with the other question which would be like kind of like how do you pay for it? What are the fiscal ideas surrounding it?
[56:27] Speaker C (unidentified): Right. Right. Right. But conceptually, we want to go in this direction. So how many more questions, besides these, do we need to answer before we go, here, town council, this is what we're thinking?
[56:43] Speaker A (unidentified): i think one thing that might help kind of focus it a little bit with the lower level as well is we just have to grow square footage doesn't it but we know that floor has a lot of components that reduce what we can actually use so mechanical space has to be down there it's heats up space the elevator machine room some of the what looks like maybe we can't hold up a ride that has a low ceiling fire involved so in actuality we might be looking at four thousand square feet to program there not 5500 not so yeah i'd say even maybe lower yeah so that number yeah three thousand square feet somewhere yeah and getting yeah there a little bit might give us a better idea of okay what's the use in town what how do we get the fire station meeting room that has to come over and then at the end of the day we might only be talking about two spaces that are yet programmed right and maybe that's an okay number to say okay that's good enough to move forward but i didn't love the idea of having the whole floor they just spend the money fitting out and you don't actually know where you're using it yeah well you know you're going to have a community center or meeting to take the place of the fire but there's one thing they could have the other side they're comfortable small of them I think too if you put in I wrote a grant years ago I bet you could get a FEMA grant for about a hundred grand if you're going to do a community like a like a warming and we talked early on in this meeting that the only The only municipal use of block grant funds is ADA compliance for municipal buildings.
[58:38] Speaker B (unidentified): So for that area, that's the deal. Yeah.
[58:40] Speaker A (unidentified): There might be block grant money in for that.
[58:46] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah. That would be sort of in the fiscal strategy section would be like, okay, what are these – what do we have to do to this building to bring in some grant – I mean, some of the future use of the lower level could just be sponsored in a way to meet certain grant obligations as well.
[59:02] Speaker C (unidentified): But I think what I'm trying to say is that we don't want to, we don't need to at this point, get into the nitty gritty specifics because 1st, you're going to run this concept by the council. Decide that's what they want to do, and if they do that, I understand
[59:20] Speaker A (unidentified): that. I think that's kind of our final report. Right? Not just like, I think we are done when we come up with the recommendation that we give to the council and we have until March. but that's not to say we can't be done by December if we really wanted to.
[59:36] Speaker C (unidentified): But the council doesn't necessarily need us to say 2,462 square feet are going to be specific for this.
[59:45] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, it's not all functions in community space. But I think someone along the line, and we can steer this, or the town council can steer this, or staff, but like what Windham did I thought was really good if people looked at that website it's talking about the process they had a whole website and dedicated to it talking about why these functions should work well in this space and someone asked at some point but synthesized information it's something that's it's resident facing so that people are just speculating in there and they're not trying to dig through some minutes from this meeting there's something a clean presentation that's on their november ballot right yeah i think if you get that far you turn to the guy to the right here and you have a historical couple pictures of where the buildings were used and then you can use architectural design and show what our vision is i mean like you can do some creative things and say this is the vision i came from historically of this and i think you can tell if it's still because there's some components that i think are really strong reason to get town hall and the superintendent onto the campus i mean to have all the beautiful functions of firing the sanding anything in one parcel of the superintendent next to the school rather than two buildings away across the street because we build up this area next door and behind it makes even more sense so one speaking of which i so brandon mitchell y'all saw he indicated to me that he was going to get this study but unfortunately something personal happened and very like it's fine but in a scary weekend and that or scary end of the week that went into the weekend he told me that he believes in the commercial value with this parcel would be between one and one and a half million dollars so that was built he didn't have the comps he's going to get those to me but i'll get everything to you but that's what's his spoiler with regards to maybe if we have questions on that we can have him put this into the next video for yes for tom i mean it's if you think about what these locks sold for vacant and what but they weren't astronomical numbers. This building itself, I don't know if the building adds that much value to the land. And so if you really just look at it as a land parcel compared to what these sold for or this sold for, it's. Yeah, and I don't know if you could do something, if you could build another building off that. I think that if this is, if you could divide it, I don't know, but anyway, he will hopefully be able to get those numbers for us. If we get, we want as a community that i'm at the next meeting to talk about that but again i think that kind of kind of leads into what we want to do next on our next steps and sort of maybe we it's okay with you all well maybe not maybe we could do this for the next meeting i don't know but it's kind of what are our thoughts on this i don't know how much more information or how much more studying things along that line we can do before we kind of come to the consensus census among this group on where we want what we want to recommend to the council you had you had mentioned that each of us kind of keeping yeah that's that's definitely something that I think once I think where we're going to probably go is maybe we kind of do a little straw hole here and just see what people are thinking and then we I think we'll probably get into the point where we're going to be close to a final report that will kind of obviously do with the committee and see that and then yeah i do if people want to do it i don't think there's an obligation but i think it would be nice at the end of the report whichever way would go or whatever recommendations or information we're giving to the town council that everybody gets an opportunity to just kind of write their own personal views that would be part of this document i don't want to put anybody's spot if people don't want to do it that's fine but i just think that there's value I remember watching the housing diversity committee and there was kind of there was some I don't want to say contention because I wasn't part of the group so I don't know that would be the right word but there was it seemed to be I remember hearing a lot of the term minority report that people who were sort of out of the majority were wanting to make sure that their voices were heard and that's fine but I just really think that this kind of gives us all an opportunity to say our parts and again i think not everybody on in town is going to know all of us but they'll probably know one or two of us and they might be interested to know what that person's thoughts were and if they have this in the report it could go to the end and say hey this is what jim thought about this whole thing it just would give everybody an opportunity to have their specific voice be part of this the part of this report so again i don't want to put people on the spot if they don't want to do that 's fine but i do i do think it gives a nice opportunity for people to kind of chime in so if we if we do a
[1:05:09] Speaker C (unidentified): strong relationship to where people are getting in this direction yes and then they prep for the next meeting people can kind of prepare their thinking you know and then that august as i hear brian say some things that i really love on paper which could then get pulled into the report just like definitely i just wanted to step back with a quick process question because i missed the last meeting so maybe that i missed this one i didn't see it in the minutes we had emails to go and i'm not saying we should go to it 's kind of backwards in some ways but there had been a discussion about setting up a matrix i thought cat you and your staff were going to kind of create a matrix with some values and have them took the different uses
[1:06:06] Speaker A (unidentified): is and it kind of i don't know i think you missed that need i can send it to you we basically had the pros and cons of the use of the 1934 building when we and i'm looking at this because it's in this sort of report graph that i have about performing arts center non-public schools small business remote working space i mean the checklist so there was some like we did all the
[1:06:32] Speaker C (unidentified): stuff on the walls and the punks and all that but then there was discussion of kind of creating a
[1:06:37] Speaker A (unidentified): matrix for the yeah we did do that no i don't i don't think we did i think there was a talk about i thinking that information and going through the same kind of grading system that was done for the sidewalks that i don't think we could i proposed it early on but then i think
[1:06:56] Speaker B (unidentified): similar to the sidewalk but i think when we got into the discussions and the pros and cons it started to lose its, I thought we at least had a discussion that it was starting to lose its value that we initially thought it might have because it was trying to put a rating to things that we never ever, that the committee never ever wanted to actually put forward across the board. Nobody wanted to put it forward as a recommendation to sort of try to spend a lot of time quantifying its value to never actually even consider it. So that's
[1:07:27] Speaker A (unidentified): where i've got it yeah to me and i think you didn't have to put it in a way because i think when we talked about the pros and cons of the use of the 1934 building went through those specific uses that a lot of that conversation came into that like yes we could do it but would it be practical would it get used yeah i think the matrix i think at one point it's not like the
[1:07:51] Speaker C (unidentified): because it's been a useful tool i'm really a little concerned about how we're going to share this all to the community because we've had a lot of discussion here but i'm not sure that will be cleared to the community that we've oh we explored that you're supposed you know this is where we ended up on it so i felt like the matrix would be a way for us to I guess I'm worried about it. Well, maybe that and I haven't looked at your most recent draft. Maybe it may have did work its way into the draft, but just. It feels backwards now because we should have done it.
[1:08:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I don't think I think Laura, I think Laura, 1 of the things that you just said, and I think this is important is, I think that should probably be part of our report. or if we are going to and we might want to make recommendations from the town council about how we get this information to the community well one step further i think to your point part of the recommendation and the communication to the community is talking about what we thought about but didn't move forward on and that the kind of saying i you know we thought about this and this is why we don't think it's the right fit right but without saying that someone will say what about this and then you get lost yeah that's where the matrix felt at the time when we're having that
[1:09:29] Speaker C (unidentified): discussion like a way to possibly consolidate all these many different
[1:09:36] Speaker B (unidentified): discussions non-municipal reuse potential I had all these categories I did test it out on staff just to let you know it for different staff members randomly and the scoring was like just kind of wildly all over the place so I think if you're all heading in one direction it was and I tried to use categories but it's just like the value to you know taxpayer savings likelihood of implementation community support compatible with town school campus value added to town the scoring across four employees that are pretty in tune already with the stuff that's gone up
[1:10:18] Speaker A (unidentified): was wildly kind of okay so i appreciate we tested it out but i did i knew i had drafted one yeah
[1:10:24] Speaker B (unidentified): i knew i drafted and i got into housing retail shops community-based organizations and a lot that stuff through the pros and cons list was like a non-starter anyway so yeah i think that
[1:10:37] Speaker C (unidentified): there's something being said about having a rationale for why we did not select something which we went through all of these kind of groupings so what's the rationale for why we did not select a maker's whatever building or whatever it might be or to let people know that we considered those options so we consider these here's the and we did the pros and cons and so then if we take it and we look at pros and cons and we then hear the group kind of synthesize and go this is why we should we wouldn't do this or we wouldn't recommend this so that is what i keep saying really needs to be within our report so we can explain to people, we thought about it and this is why we didn't move forward with it.
[1:11:33] Speaker A (unidentified): And there might be flexibility in the future. I mean, I think of someone like the land trust. Let's say they need a little office space, they do something different with their building, it would be out of the realm of possibility that the town rents an office from a lower level right then right you know similar to how we're rent we did rent space to edward jones
[1:11:57] Speaker E (unidentified): so and so workforce housing bumped up obviously with the council and i think we better be real clear about what we say about workforce housing completes by our teachers there was some discussion by some of the members here saying it would be you know from a security standpoint point maybe I think we need to really unpack that one a little bit more because that view is held by at least some of the council because affordable housing that kind of stuff is important so I think either we review the work that was done during that session and cite the reasons why workforce housing isn't in the cards here or that kind of stuff I think we need to be ready for.
[1:12:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Does that work, Jonathan? Because that could be at our next meeting, we could go through that. Because I think we're toward the end, so let's kind of wrap up those.
[1:12:56] Speaker A (unidentified): I would like to figure out what the process is to get from the information we've gathered to distilling it into something follow-facing, like Window did. I think that's going to be the council. Because our charge is simply to recommend, get information to the council, and then the council decides where to go. Because in theory, the council might say, you guys got it wrong, according to us, and we're going to go a whole different direction. Who knows? And so I definitely hear what you're saying, Brian, but I think that goes beyond what our commitment is. Because I think once it goes to the council, if the council is smart, it would go in the direction that you're saying like get that information out how are we going to sell this
[1:13:41] Speaker C (unidentified): to the community if this is something we really want but we have to distill it to a certain point in order to get it to the council so that it's easily digestible yes so it's not first
[1:13:55] Speaker D (unidentified): trust in our committee you know we've got some great talent in this room and i think it's incumbent upon the public to trust our committee and I also think it's incumbent upon the public to be accountable all our meetings are open to the public how many how many people we have online you
[1:14:19] Speaker A (unidentified): hey don't give them credit for that yeah being accountable like what interests me is how we're going to sell this physically, you know? I mean, you write down here, say we can get a million, a million and a half for the building or the lot. But I like this as far as the tax revenue. How can we justify the cost? And if we could somehow, to me, it's important that we show the people in this town that we looked at the cost and we don't want to just keep on dumping stuff because they're going to say why are the town people why is why is the town hall why do you have to have this nice big beautiful historic building right why do we have to pay for whatever so we can somehow at least
[1:15:09] Speaker B (unidentified): make it i can provide you so i just jotted down for the fiscal model that i like to use if you want it as part of your report yeah i can provide you a draft of it what i do is i started so total a project costs 10 million dollars sale of existing property 1.5 so we're really long-term borrowing whether we have to come up with a short-term mechanism or not long-term borrowing we're borrowing 8.5 so that is going to give us an annual bond payment or whatever and i'll plug in that now but then from that annual bond payment we're going to subtract the annual tax payment of this property which i'm going to assume the project on this side of this building is going to be paying about a hundred thousand dollars in taxes a year and project gopax would be paying about 200 000 so assume 100 for this price so now you've got an annual payment of 500 000 but you've got 100 000 sort of as an offsetting revenue and then you build the little cost table if you own this house in this bracket this is your impact and you'll replace 30 years i think there's
[1:16:12] Speaker A (unidentified): one more line you subtract which is potential cost savings operationally there would be a note
[1:16:19] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah that's the other thing is like okay here's what this would cost us but you do have to prevent people from thinking the alternative is zero because you also have to then say oh and by the way you don't have to do it but you don't get away with saving this tax dollar you then have to put program 3 million into this building in a 10-year capital plan versus a 30-year borrowing guess what it all of a sudden starts to cost you more so but well I
[1:16:46] Speaker A (unidentified): don't like that it seems like we have quite a bit agreement about potential
[1:16:55] Speaker C (unidentified): use and how it will work but we all know the elephant in the rooms how are you
[1:16:59] Speaker A (unidentified): going to pay for it especially in this community i like where you went and i was i like that he said on a window i'm very connected to south portland and i would call it their missed steps along the path yeah they're gonna have their bond next week defeated by a lot and why you gotta step back and say why is that 84 million dollars for police and fire station gonna be blown out of the water it isn't even gonna be close because they didn't do this they didn't do what patches talked about and I think one of our biggest assets to come out of this is we're reducing our footprint not increasing it no they're taking they got they own Mahoney they bought a drugstore they're gonna tear down a police and fire station and separate them instead of consolidating you're doing everything we tried to do in the late 90s consolidation and blow out of the water we're not doing it we're actually reducing the town's footprint I think that's a big plus to the community when they say why penny didn't you think about this well I think it's important to get everything over there you mentioned it Wow I think the cost of doing business but back to what you're saying is then we sell to them you're gonna put something back on the tax for commercial that doesn't happen right off on this town in the area where we're trying exactly we're trying to encourage housing and development and stuff so i think there's a lot of yeah there's a lot of good things i got a ton of notes that i just think there's a lot of good things i loved your idea of the walkway in the back of that but it sounds stupid
[1:18:34] Speaker B (unidentified): but it makes it part of the school part of what i'm good at
[1:18:42] Speaker A (unidentified): no and the number doesn't scare me that number Better than $84 million that they're voting on in the city to still own more buildings. That number doesn't scare me, and I'm cheap. To Andy's point, too, though, in terms of someone just saying something very direct of what about workforce housing, what about housing period, we went through some of this stuff early on and there was some pretty big there was some pros there was some pretty big cons and we have to just be really clear about them you have to subdivide the property and sell off a piece of the school campus you know you 're here to have a third party potentially operating on the school instead of this parking lot that we're talking about that can be used for the school and town hall you then have to figure out how to separate that parking lot or build another parking lot in the property because if you have residents living there they're going to want their own little spot you know there's all those things that we need to be pretty clear on where how those yeah how those things went into artisan yeah resident occupation on a school
[1:19:59] Speaker B (unidentified): property the shortest answer is you are doing it you're just doing it on this property instead of that are your initiative is providing more housing potentially workforce or affordable that's the market world they are a
[1:20:19] Speaker A (unidentified): walkable community we're actually maximizing the money we spent on the sidewalks and the lighting and everything on scott.edu all right so let me just ask the scary question are we as a group at that point where we have an agreement on what we would recommend to the town council from a very high level does anybody not think that we're moving in the direction of moving municipal uses of the town hall to the 1934 building and then also having in that 1934 building the opportunity for community studies i think it's a little shoddy i don't want one person to feel silent and so i'll admit coming into this i was pretty wide open i could see why demolition would make sense i could see why reuse would make sense i didn't see sale making sense right from the beginning but I don't I recognize demolition it's very hard sell and I don't think it's the right solution anymore I do think this is the right solution what do you think that was my
[1:21:34] Speaker D (unidentified): own non-negotiable well the interview for this committee was that the building shouldn't be taken down and that was the only non-negotiable I had yeah I was
[1:21:44] Speaker A (unidentified): I was looking at it from a non sentimental standpoint of saying you know there's potential to reuse the land to better orient sports fields and maybe we're demolishing two-thirds of the building it doesn't make sense to just take it all down at once that's the way i was looking at it so let me ask you jim what other thoughts do you have i
[1:22:05] Speaker D (unidentified): mean i'll tell you i don't talk about these meetings obviously but i listen and i think the meeting will make up the violations we didn't get very far but that's how i grow as a person and after each meeting or at least after each meeting where there's been substantive change i write myself a position paper how do i feel how did i feel as if what's changed and i wrote one for tonight and i had two needs which were both addressed the cost and the space usage of the 1930s building so i'm i'm closing and i'm just about there
[1:22:48] Speaker C (unidentified): floor i feel very comfortable with this proposal here i personally feel quite strongly that we should build out fully not lead spaces it just doesn't seem cost effective to me so i would want to see the ground floor built out fully with community uses i'm very comfortable with the current level of flexibility in here right now i don't feel this that at the moment I need to know more than that these would be flex spaces that would be used for so I feel very comfortable with this proposal particularly as linked to it's not just really that you're creating this at the town hall a new town hall but you are also opening this space up for other uses which I personally think ideally I'd love to see some affordable housing but I can I'm comfortable with the idea of being open to finding out what developers might propose with the community having some say over. I wouldn't want to see us just sell the land and let anything happen there. But yes, overall I'm very supportive. Kevin?
[1:23:58] Speaker A (unidentified): I concur with both. I think we've got to where we need to get flushed out of a lot of issues, see a lot outside for the town i look at it long term i don't mind spending money if i think i'm getting an investment out of it but i get to say i the one thing i've said about the last three meetings i feel like at the community now that we're investing what we are in the schools we need to protect it and i could be sold the best answer might be tearing it down to protect it but the best answer but i don't see it commercially use compromising that canvas but i think i drove back the other night i stopped by a road and you see the sidewalks and there was a woman pushing a baby carriage and that's our leash in our community and i really think now the traffic i'm still my jury is still out on the new center of town i'm not sure if it's good or bad we'll let you know in a year but i think after the hammer opened yeah but i just think that the library with the basketball court tied to town hall with the schools sidewalks lighting i think it makes a lot of sense and again i go back to the people that are more conservative in the town we're taking we're actually reducing our footprint and getting to we could open this up for housing or whatever this area is going to do that's whether you like it or not that's upcoming in this area of the town i think it makes sense to get us all over there you don't have teachers walking across the street with a flag out front and everybody's over there so i just think there's more i think it's a good idea okay and just for your information i like what's going on over there because the lighting and all that i walk my dogs at night around me because of the lights you know it's like a nice little community but at first i was all in as far as putting that building into you know workforce whatever apartments whatever available portable apartments but overall, the discussion, I could see the issues that we're going to have. And I'm all in with this. I think this is a great opportunity for us to feel good about what we're trying to do. And the fact that we can take this and quasi have affordable housing is something that we can make money from. Yeah.
[1:26:18] Speaker E (unidentified): I think I'm in support of the building, you know, moving the whole municipal campus over there. I think it's really important to have both senior executives, the town manager, and the superintendent under one such communication as it became a lot of this. i think i think from a work a workplace standpoint this building has wonderful history and everything is not adequate for what i'm hearing from the town manager i think that my biggest concern is so i 'm in support of that i'm also heartened to hear some of the concerns that some of the members here in this committee have talked about in terms of safety and keeping you know keeping the team together over there in terms of instead of having shall we say you know a different outside element wherever they are which you might get with workforce housing i think that 's warms the heart the thing that i'm worried about and i'll support it i'll support it the thing that i'm concerned about is what our dear friend and colleague Brian has taught us and that is municipal buildings that sit empty are not a good thing and he's got plenty of experience in New England where there's been empty municipal buildings I think it'd be wonderful to have some great you know second new use for this building but when and how that will come off I really don't know and I'm somewhat concerned about what the flash flow told us and that is people are sensitive around the financial piece. I know the school department is also extremely grateful for what the town has already done so far and so you know dropping in more additional costs and stuff like that in terms of bonding is something that may be necessary but helpful to offset it with, you know, some fixed plan about how we can get some revenue out of this goal. So that would be my biggest concern. But I'm very supportive of the process and seeing all those folks, you know, working on it.
[1:28:52] Speaker C (unidentified): I already sent mine. I'm excited to get this answer.
[1:28:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, and I think it goes without saying that I'm with everybody here. I think it would be a great opportunity for Town Hall to go over there with a renovated building that would we feel comfortable about the next 50 years. Obviously, it's going to cost something, which is not uncomfortable, but that's the reality and those numbers I thought were manageable as well. And I think with Pat being able to kind of put the information out there with the town hall, with the current town hall being able to possibly be a revenue generator, even for the concept of it being taken off the town's hands, and all of a sudden, because I didn't actually think about that until Pat mentioned it, that this would now then be a taxable property, which it's not right now. So as Kevin brought up tonight, which I also didn't have a thought about is that we'd actually be shrinking our town government footprint So I think that's a very good point. I still think there's a long way to go. I Don't anticipate what the town council will think about this But my hope is that once we put all this on pen and paper and people can actually see it in two versions It's a final report and then a summary report that people will really kind of understand what we've been doing over the last the last few six months now basically but also i just want to take this opportunity it's going to be great i think these discussions are some of the best i have on town government and obviously ahmed's not here but we'll get his thoughts as well but yeah so i think and correct me if i'm wrong but i think what we probably want to do is really kind of put this into a beef up the report draft that i've been doing and then circulate that around and obviously it's not it wouldn't be a final version i think it'll probably take us a couple weeks to actually get through it and i don't think going wordsmithing it together is probably the best practice but maybe that's something we have to do but yeah i think that would probably be the next step to the
[1:31:13] Speaker C (unidentified): next meeting did we talk about the other ideas that you had that were pros and cons to kind of come up with that somebody this is why we ruled it out if we wanted to do that
[1:31:30] Speaker A (unidentified): i mean the only i guess i don't know the reason i believe the thing is in this report right now i have basically the bosses of pros and cons I think the summary would just simply be what's in the con box so I don't mean I think maybe what we do is when we go through the report draft next month if someone says you know we need a summary of why this argument don't think this will work then we just we that will be
[1:31:57] Speaker C (unidentified): in the next draft right so i think that's what i'm saying but i agree let's not get into words
[1:32:04] Speaker A (unidentified): something that the superintendent brought up in the groundbreaking and how you've alluded to this he said one of the nice things about the middle school project helping or not starting is that now the school can focus their capital program plan on the high school and the and so it's no longer dealing with this really the trouble of a building is okay now we can deal with invest in our buildings that are in a little bit better shape i feel the same way about the 1934 building if this were to move forward you can look at it from a capital standpoint on the municipal level and say we're investing in a in a building it's going to be renovated it's going to have new systems we can take our capital through a plan on the municipal level and hopefully be keeping our good buildings versus keeping before building standing you know so now it's you're going over to the police
[1:33:00] Speaker B (unidentified): department to deal with the project actually put new doors on the fire station instead of screwing new hinges in where the metals not break yeah so we
[1:33:20] Speaker A (unidentified): can start because you know you hear about municipal buildings needing to be your place because if they're leaving whatever army thinks maybe we shouldn't let it leak in the first place you know and so once we have this new building we can dedicate that capital to keeping up the buildings we have and not these really difficult buildings to maintain but brian
[1:33:42] Speaker E (unidentified): three to five years out are you worried that this building will be empty that this building would be empty and we'll all be over across the street in that brand new 1934 more building is there a possibility not producing income not producing income which is what some of
[1:34:00] Speaker B (unidentified): the residents we've asked oh no this will i mean this will sell i mean one of the things we just i don't want to try down there but one of the things we just did one of the things we did yeah but one of the things we did was flex we just were you know we're submitting the application to the state right now to flex our use of tif funds to actually help things responsibly great to the point of like we've got to help some of these projects along sometimes but at the same time do you have to stop your focus is gonna look when you have a brand new building there and a new building out back and you've all of a sudden inserted a little vitality to the local businesses see these restaurants I'm taking on by that much there Friday this becomes a very
[1:34:45] Speaker A (unidentified): the other elephant in the neighborhood across the street jerry harry's at some point it's going to become available and the town will have to make a decision okay i'm just saying surrounding like the school the fire that's coming that's not 10 years away that's some of them yeah i think i think andy to your point though if this building isn't selling or if it's let's say this building is abandoned it's probably going to be because the town council took some steps to almost interfere with this the marketability of it yeah more restrictions yeah if you can't you can't touch it then yeah it's probably not going to settle but the town council and this is way beyond our committee but if the town council is smart about it and says look we might want to keep the front facade but anything can do but i do think the first moment being abandoned is if the time comes all of a sudden doesn't want it you can't you can't touch it you can't do it or if somebody decides maybe we should keep it in just in case and the other thing that does can happen is it can sell valve and then the end user doesn't move on it i mean i have the next door yeah i was looking at
[1:36:25] Speaker D (unidentified): pictures full pictures of this building that's another full story yeah and i and you know it's a beautiful building no question so i went to sleep i woke up in the middle of the night
[1:36:36] Speaker A (unidentified): as people your age
[1:36:41] Speaker D (unidentified): private residence and i went back to sleep but you know i mean this is he goes around yeah look at this building yeah another half a million to fix it the way they want or
[1:37:11] Speaker E (unidentified): My only point was if you send a $10 million bond to the voters, they're going to say, what are we going to get for town hall? Yeah.
[1:37:24] Speaker A (unidentified): To me, I envision, and I don't know my future on the council, but I envision that the discussions among the town council is going to go way beyond just the 1934. There is going to probably be discussions about, okay, we're going to put this money or we're asking the voters to approve this money so we can move town hall functions over to the 1934 building and also community space. face what's going to happen with the town hall I would hope that the town council will be talking about yes we're going to then take this step as part of that process I would hope so I would also I'm expecting I would be shocked if we get if we get mired in well let's have a project well also I kind of feel like part even though it's going beyond our charge I do think that there's value of us having these discussions about the current town hall so that we don't have to have a town hall building committee you know like that maybe we maybe the council will decide to do that i don't know but i think what we're doing now is helpful for saving time and resources in the future about what 's happening yeah so are you envisioning then that in terms
[1:38:43] Speaker C (unidentified): of the this document that's evolving yeah that something like this information would be included
[1:38:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Absolutely. And in fact, I'm going to add 5% so I can just be lazy and do 5%
[1:38:53] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll probably, we'll have this version because it's the minutes for today's meeting. I think the version in the report, what I'm hearing is I'd probably just remove the phasing because it does. I got to just change the little depiction versus the phasing because then it does get into that whole other thing about square footage per floor systems. systems so that's the only takeaway i had for like a change to it and then add in the financial modeling at the end of just around numbers 10 million one and a half hundred thousand dollars in taxes and make them all work and see what it looks like and maybe cip fund savings cip savings yeah because you figure you're gonna have to put a few million dollars over 10 years even just capital plan that would come out of the general fund so that offsets what you're paying your debt
[1:39:38] Speaker A (unidentified): so I'll try to and is there any debt coming off but I think the fact that this group has a decent amount of clarity about this site is pretty unique because I think the challenge that most have run into is Mahoney which is beautiful building we're going to keep it but we don't really know how it's going to work and what it's going to be but in then they go through it and they still aren't selling it mahoney will probably sell in 10 years you know that it will be sell for five hundred thousand dollars and someone will have to put a lot of money into that fellow to me it was just it's selfish for these people themselves without even thinking of what we did because they just don't care to me that's how it felt like something in some portland worked for 28 years and jim gailey and i would have this discussion i actually saw jeff jordan on an airplane the other day you and i had this discussion we've been very fortunate in this town would have consistent leadership right or wrong on my right and i can say something but i won't but so portland we would get two new counselors every year there was a revolving door and they have an agenda their agenda may be a bike path their next person's agenda may be a sidewalk in red bank the next time there's no consistent leadership our town council does not turn over that often our town manager was the same town manager for many years which served us quite well the consistent leadership and jim gailey would do it i know pat would do it for no half a while i would he would come to me as fire chief and say this is next year is your year for a truck you can't have anything this year because we got to buy school buses or we got to buy we've had good leadership out here for many years and this is i think an example that mahoney is a terrible example because you get people on the council brand new the poor town manager gets hit by the mayor because they want to do something at willard beach or they want to do it's just a different animal let's say plus they approved a bank shop across from the middle so i can tell you the fire station so when i left i had two hundred thousand dollars of capital money every year to repair my buildings at five hours that money went away when i left because they took it put it in a jug and said we're going to now it's just different it's a different leadership and it changes where we're it's kind of always been like that well i think but the other layer here is that it's these finite two buildings moving one and it's clear that this building once that happens if that happens is not needed and i think what happens in a lot of towns is we built this new thing we moved this thing but maybe we need that we don't there's very little clarity and that's when you get into trouble that's when it sits you keep it heated you keep spending money in repairs and then 10 years down the line you sell it for a dollar the biggest political mess in south portland is itself and you don't see how many units are down there you see that risk here in people one of empty buildings i think i think the i think this will sell i think the risk is what's have potentially happening here is people do buy properties and they wait for their financials to line up with so they'll buy this saying it's a great site I think I can do housing, they can't get their numbers to work, they can't get their numbers to work, they can't get the financing line in far enough, and it might take that end user four or five years to pull it off. I think if the town's willing to sell it, I think it'll transact, and I think we'll be able to get some money for it. It's not clear to me whether the end user, especially right now where interest rates are, that someone would be able to put the financing package together right away to get
[1:43:40] Speaker B (unidentified): it off the ground lessons learned from the parcel next door the one restriction finite back then to the council when it gets there is that you put some ties on the sale of this right do you think that yeah you put time just like some communities have ties to okay you get a project through planning board you have a year started and five years to finish it's hard to put an end on it but you didn't give it what's happened that story the number of years that passed you sell this or even if it costs you $500,000 on your selling price you sell it with some numbers baked in that basically we're going to get it back inside somebody else if you don't take actions a B and C within a certain
[1:44:22] Speaker A (unidentified): period of time or you require them to carry on because we saw it like downtown Boston if you ever went down there when the filings got bulldozed there was a hole in the ground in the middle of downtown and no one could do anything about it because their financing fell apart it couldn't build because the city didn't require a bond on the site a bond would have said okay this bond is now due now we now we can recoup the bond or we can be ownership
[1:44:55] Speaker E (unidentified): something I think the message of Marion is different than what position is this building is not going to significantly in good scheme of the bond to do across the street
[1:45:10] Speaker A (unidentified): well i think it was it really had much of the quarter i mean 105 over okay six million well 1.5 plus if it's a hundred thousand okay for taxes okay and the tax record now that's That's in 10 years, that's a million dollars, so. I just say to Jim, if you match the parking rates at Fort Williams as they have in Portland now, you pay 40 a year. What'd you say, Rob? You should go to the Fort Williams advisory committee
[1:45:42] Speaker C (unidentified): with that. and it'll probably sell fairly quickly, so you'll get the one in 1.5 million. And then long-term, there's maybe 100,000 in tax revenues, but it might take several years depending on the market it and how you know you can't fully control when a private developer develops so it may be that you start collecting that hundred thousand immediately or it might take three or four years once it kicks
[1:46:03] Speaker A (unidentified): in though it's a long-term revenue but also we don't have a ca we don't have the money that we have to put into this building each year as well we'll be branding building that in theory will lower operating costs and lower capital every year okay
[1:46:20] Speaker C (unidentified): okay on terms of the draft i know it's been evolving and you've been working on it would you mind if we're going to discuss it next meeting yeah would you mind sending it out to us maybe a week ahead of time that's what i've yep that's
[1:46:33] Speaker A (unidentified): actually what i was going to bring up next when do we want to have our next meeting because next week is the election and then the week after that is kind of a weird week because not because Veterans Day is in the middle of the week. So it's kind of one of those like chopped up weeks. We could do the summertime during the week of the 16th. I just want to make sure people would have enough time to go over it and probably want to stay away from the week of the 23rd because that's Thanksgiving. Yeah. So I was actually thinking maybe the 30th might be a good time for a news meeting. Yeah, it's a Monday. Or we could try to maybe do, we could do the 17th or 18th of November. It looks like that we did the 16th if so it makes sense. Yeah I mean I don't I was thinking probably before Thanksgiving would be a little bit better to try. I think it would be the 18th.
[1:47:35] Speaker C (unidentified): I can't do the 18th and it's a Wednesday which we've never done before. Can you do the 17th? Yeah typically our days have been
[1:47:44] Speaker A (unidentified): mondays and tuesdays so yeah that's 16th or 17th work for people okay let's aim for 17th as well what about monday the third day of the match Yeah, that's the Monday after Thanksgiving. Yeah, sorry everyone. Thanksgiving's over at like 3.30 in the afternoon. I can do the 23rd.
[1:48:33] Speaker C (unidentified): We're talking about that? That's before Thanksgiving.
[1:48:37] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, I could do the 23rd. I just wanted to see if people wanted to kind of stay away from the Thanksgiving week, but that would work for me. Works for me. Works for me. Okay. okay i think most of our losses actually come it works for everybody yeah yay 23rd yep six o'clock great and yes and i will try to get that more to people beforehand and then what is me all right if i said this to you guys too okay has it changed since the last time you sent it out i've added it in from last meeting oh cool okay tonight too yeah do you have time to get you're going to add stuff to it yeah okay i'm going to try to add what pat said to us cool in fact do you think it
[1:49:37] Speaker C (unidentified): would be possible to get a little additional information on the parking as it fits in with the school is that is there a place to resolve that issue i feel like that could come up like
[1:49:48] Speaker B (unidentified): i feel like it's going to be a like first phase of conceptual design to have everything on that like that would be like post council i actually put in some resources to it i we are so much when i'm doing so many back and forth i know you follow that probably close to the nine-year digestion i would catch it just from my office proximity to planning all of the certain all of the discussions of circulation or parking it's worth reading the climbing board planning board
[1:50:26] Speaker A (unidentified): presentation for the approval of the school because it really it lays down all the parking on the campus and the code requirement or the zoning requirements and then the usage and it laid it all out so at least you can get your head around the counts and then you
[1:50:45] Speaker C (unidentified): can sexually say to the council this is what we think we should do it's not involved here I would think as a council member and one of my questions would be is there do we have the space to do market how many spaces do we need and do
[1:50:59] Speaker A (unidentified): we have the space to do it so Laura yeah I think the answer is right as if it's know brian the plane board basically like they really kind of steered the school the school districts with regards to park because there was a potential lot that they actually took out of the plants for parking that was kind of abutting the neighborhood over there because they realized that they had more than enough parking and i think i remember correctly that the 1934 use was it was considered when it came to the size of the parking lot alongside that so i 'm sure the information is in the quality of vinyl probably the night that the planning board approved it because it definitely changed through the process so the sense is that there's adequate parking already being provided in the existing school plan yes there it exceeds zoning requirements and it exceeds usage as play is proposed so
[1:52:10] Speaker E (unidentified): jonathan for this next meeting
[1:52:12] Speaker A (unidentified): exactly you'll get part exactly the space i think what it's going to be yeah my hope is that i can send out the draft couple weeks before people can tweak it and maybe send changes to me and i can actually incorporate them in and then in theory if i get some changes and i can send out another final or a second draft to the committee before our meeting and just see where every because i don't yeah i don't i don't know everyone here is going to submit a lot of changes to it but i can try to incorporate everybody's changes like because i think the last time i did it i got changes from you and changes from you and i incorporated those into the draft that we then looked at the
[1:53:01] Speaker E (unidentified): meeting are you going to try and take a stab at the writing a some concluding remarks and looking for the recommendation on the communities and then you know yeah you want to pick it apart
[1:53:12] Speaker A (unidentified): my hope is that from you kind of heard what everybody says my hope from these meeting minutes is that this ai thing is going to kind of spit out what we all talk about going around the room and i my hope would be that i'd be able to kind of formulate that into this is the view of the committee at this point you know the way you were smith yes actually right before we would get yeah it was like andy was wearing a tuxedo you gave your thoughts in the middle of the night jim's going to come on record saying that he wants to become a private resident All right. Laura, do you have anything? You have this look on your face, like, I'm just comfortable day. I just can't see a lot. I'm not sure. You're going to get that level of detail. I kind of think the same, but I'm going to say it's on. But, yes, I think it's good. I got it.
[1:54:11] Speaker C (unidentified): As opposed to having individual. Individual commentary from everybody in the crane, as opposed to that, since about since. Yeah, as opposed to.
[1:54:26] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, since we all, I guess we'll just see what the. That thing spits out when we look at the minutes, because I think that there's, I mean, we all kind of are of the same mindset. So it's not like, it's.
[1:54:40] Speaker C (unidentified): no the only reason i ask is going back to where i forgot who said it but like trust in the committee you know it's going to be it's going to be so valuable and if you're reflecting individual views especially if they all are unified that could be very powerful yeah
[1:54:57] Speaker A (unidentified): not so true and the one thing i was going to say about ai i think it's a decent amount of work is you do want to tell it what type of language you say technical because it comes back when i use it sometimes and it has this very like this is a wonderful pound to live i can't put that in a appraisal i can say the population is this and then so for and i think most of the report or should not be opinion it should be it should be terrible information data points and then at the end is our opinion of what do you all this with all this data what do we believe should happen and so i just be careful with that because it does like this it does like this it does like to add some colorful language because i'd like to swear yeah no i can't tell them the one yeah can we get a drunken version of that sailor version of a pirate voice
[1:55:57] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah we're in front of this and we reach carefully what people have said about it yeah absolutely it's really a good time today by the way oh good
[1:56:12] Speaker A (unidentified): timing anybody else have anything for this evening motion to adjourn second and all in favor all right thanks