← Back to MaineScanner

Cape Elizabeth Council Discusses Gullcrest Arena Lease and Public Engagement Tools

2026-11-04 · 3h 9m · Source: Town Council Workshop & Meeting - November 4, 2026 (Town of Cape Elizabeth (CETV Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): great thank you all right we're going to get going welcome to the town council workshop meeting on wednesday november 4th 2026 we have two items on our workshop agenda tonight first we'll have a discussion about the gulcrest open space use and second we're going to have a discussion about our public engagement tools. So first item on the agenda, meetings regarding the proposed ice arena project at Gullcrest have brought to the forefront broader use discussions at the Gullcrest complex. Tonight the council will discuss the current uses of the facilities, the fields, the trails, the open space, traffic circulation, parking and sidewalks on Gullcrest Drive and any future open space planning needed for this property. Before the council dives in and we have a presentation from town manager Pat Fox, are there any members of the public either in the chamber or online that wish to comment on this item? please approach the podium and give us your name and address you know the drill [1:24] Speaker B (unidentified): thank you so much thank you let's see wrong side of the page don't start the timer yet okay my name is rachel stem yeshkin i reside at [address] you our town councillors consider a plan for Goldcrest, I would like to ask you to remember and seriously consider the value of peaceful, natural, open spaces to area citizens and our residents who do not have their own voice, animals, insects, birds, and plants. The trails and natural areas at Goldcrest have provided opportunities for passive recreation to a very broad variety of Cape citizen users. There's an active bluebird trail that provides nesting spots for this bird that was once nearing extinction. Now you can see flocks of bluebirds at Goldcrest. The high school, middle school, cross-country teams run the trails as do individual runners. Many people enjoy the peaceful nature of the trails and walk there enjoying wild blue flag iris in the spring and expansive views restful to the eyes and soul year-round. Our snowfalls bring out the cross-country skiers and we have wonderful group of citizen volunteers who groom the trails for all of us skiers to enjoy. Last year I saw whole families with kids on sleds outside enjoying gliding along the trails. This area also provides an important link as part of a contiguous natural corridor of habitat that's important to our wildlife. Fragmented natural areas have greatly diminished value to wildlife in general. Also Goldcrest is one of the places in Cape Elizabeth where, when the lights are turned off, you can still see the Milky Way, Aurora Borealis, and bats darting through the sky. And when you get up in the morning at 4 a.m. in the summer, when the sun has risen but most humans are still asleep, you can easily come across the local mammals, including red and silver foxes, voles, mice, possums, and newly reintroduced cottontails. Goldcrest as a natural space is a true treasure to Cape Area residents of all types for passive of recreation that is so important to our health and well-being these and other spaces is one of the unique and wonderful things about cape elizabeth there's no price that can be put on nature and when it is gone it is gone i'm asking you to please keep these very important considerations in mind as you consider a plan for further development of the gold crest area thank you [3:53] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you good [4:04] Speaker C (unidentified): evening kurt chapin 193 fallow road i come as a neighbor to the gulcrest area our property it neighbors the gulcrest area and i echo some of the concerns of the previous speaker in regards to my family my neighbors use the trails there Unfortunately, I was not able to be here on the last meeting, but there's been some conversations with other Fowler neighbors that there is conversations about having weddings, concerts. The idea of putting pickleball in that is really disturbing for the neighbors of the property. and I just want to I hope that the council will take the neighbors in consideration when thinking about the use of that property as well I will say the arena group has been great to work with we have had some issues with the lighting and I know in their plans of building the arena that they've taken that lighting into consideration and make sure that the lighting is pointed down instead of outward, which has really impacted a lot of the neighbors along Fowler Road at night. And so I think what they're planning to do is great. I wanna make sure that I say that. We're backers of everything that they're doing, but the idea that we're gonna take that and expand that, and please make sure just to take the neighbors into consideration as well. Thank you. Hi, [6:00] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm Nancy Delamatera. I'm at 8 Blueberry Road. I am a member of the Accessibility and Inclusion Committee for the Town of Cape Elizabeth, though I'm speaking individually because our committee didn't have an opportunity to vote on officially submitting comment, but we did confer by email. As you know, the Accessibility and Inclusion Committee's purpose is to advocate for welcoming accessible and inclusive place and for to make cape elizabeth a welcoming accessible inclusive place to live work and visit and one of our two charges is to recommend best practices in universal design and inclusivity for town resources communications events and facilities with that in mind i wanted to highlight two of the committee's recent endeavors and flag our committee as a resource to the town as it moves forward in planning for future use at Goldcrest. The first project is an events and programs best practices compendium which we shared a couple months ago. It references a wide variety of opportunities for ensuring accessibility and inclusivity in programming and while many of the recommendations apply to events many can be hardwired into programs and facilities and a couple of examples include signage and wayfinding, thinking about providing high-contrast large print signs for accessible entrances, tactile and braille, those kinds of things. Another example is staffing for programming, assigning staff and volunteers whose responsibility it is to manage accessibility and troubleshooting issues for people during use of the facility or the event to ensure accommodations and accessibility. A second project I'd like to highlight is our committee's work to seed explicitly inclusive and accessible programming at the ice arena, where I also volunteer. And while our committee's remit isn't to put on events, we've done some events over the past couple of years to try and demonstrate what's possible. And so we've had inclusion skates that feature designated quiet spaces and activities for children and adults who experience sensory overload, offering a wheelchair-accessible ice entrance, which is the Zamboni door right now, offering skates for use by the public, among other features of the event. And I can also just offer from personal experience that it can be hard for families with members with differing needs to attend events and programs and use public spaces together and when the town can offer these programs and spaces and events it is tremendously meaningful and it really feels like an embrace so speaking individually as a member of the committee the accessibility and inclusion committee is really a great resource to the council to help widen that embrace in the future planning for Gullcrest. [9:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Hi, [9:15] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm Muzzy Barton. I reside at [address]. I kind of want to echo what a lot has already been said, but I think the importance of maintaining some open space here in Cape Elizabeth, and unfortunately I worry about, you know, I understand that we need multi-use of this area, but I fear at times that there may be become too much of a dominance by one particular group. And I'm supportive of all the groups that are interested up there. I come from a cross country ski background and I was very involved with the development of the Cape Nordic trails at Goldcrest. And that's been a great facility. We'd like to have more snow every year like we did last year. But I hope that remains a big part of what's going on at Goldcrest. and I hope the availability of parking and use of those trails is kept in mind and, foremost, just maintaining the great, beautiful outdoor space we have out there and keep it for everybody. Are [10:36] Speaker A (unidentified): there any other members of the public that wish to speak at this time? Let [10:53] Speaker F (unidentified): me just ask if anyone online. [10:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody online wish to speak at this time? Okay. thanks everybody i'm going to hand it over to town manager pat fox all [11:17] Speaker F (unidentified): right thank you so many people here i'm sure have been following the discussions about the hockey arena and that project has gone through the planning board perhaps this more holistic conversation could have happened at a different time but here we are and this is a good time to revisit some of the things that have been said along the way of what gulcrest is and what it isn't and maybe what's in place for documents or agreements at this time there really are not as many there's been a lot of reference to master plans or what was the intent of different things so i'm going to walk through what we've pieced together for sort of background where what the current uses are what some of the stressors are on the infrastructure and where we go from here so there are two there are two properties so the landfill you know landfill transfer station side of the of the property falls within the 1977 64 acre portion of the parcel the 113 acres purchased in 1998 was the second parcel that is where from 1999 to 2003 the public works facility and the existing recreation parking lots and playing fields were built out and constructed in 2002 the closest thing to a gulcrest master plan was the only formal plan constructed was a trail master plan so it was kind of specific to the drawing you see or the map that you see serving as a hub to connect a lot of the Greenbelt trails within Gulf Crest and beyond. The 2019 comprehensive plan, while it does make a couple references to Gulf Crest, it really just speaks to the increase in use of the facility after the trails connected to other trail networks beyond the Gulf Crest property. So no real comprehensive or thought out future plan or exactly how many users of each different amenity at the facility would utilize so it is a good time to sort of just visit what the current uses are and how it's being used today and where what we want to do in the future [13:39] Speaker G (unidentified): yes when was the when were the community gardens put in what kind of planning took place what year were the community gardens put in do you remember i'm sorry and [Speaker B (unidentified): okay] and did the town council at that time take into consideration any i was just kind of interested in what kind of planning took [14:06] Speaker F (unidentified): place there other than the project other than the build out of the facility going through the planning board records which i didn't pull those or try to summarize whatever planning board approvals occurred in 1999. I don't have those details if you want to visit that further. [14:22] Speaker G (unidentified): I mean, were you there involved, Rachel? I mean, was there a committee that came forth to the town with a plan, kind of like what the arena people are? Go [14:40] Speaker H (unidentified): on, go on, Bobby. Hey, Tim, we can't hear what's being said, so can someone just repeat what's being said in the crowd for those of us online? Oh, sorry, John. [14:50] Speaker G (unidentified): I was just asking the town manager, when did the community gardens come to be in place and what kind of a process, if any, and it doesn't sound like it was much of a process. It wasn't a committee. It doesn't sound like a committee came forth with a plan. We looked at that particular parcel. It looks like it butts up pretty closely to probably some protected areas. is, I just was wondering what kind of a process took place to set aside that piece of property for the community gardens. [15:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Ma'am, Rachel, the reason I'm asking you to stop is because, and it's fine, we love to hear your input, but nobody can hear you online if you're not speaking into the, so if you're going to answer a question, it would be, and it's helpful. We appreciate it. [15:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Is it okay? Kate, you'll- I think it's- Yeah, I think this is what we can- [15:49] Speaker A (unidentified): A little information never hurts. Okay. [15:51] Speaker B (unidentified): So I've been managing that garden for about 20 years. So I joined it about 20 years ago, and I've been managing it for some time since then. I wouldn't make the assumption that the person who was driving it was Nancy Miles, and I wouldn't make the assumption that there wasn't a committee or a plan that came before the council. I just think that we haven't discovered that, so I wouldn't assume just because we don't know what it is that it didn't happen. [16:24] Speaker G (unidentified): While you're there, Rachel, has the garden expanded at all? Was it initially a smaller garden and did it expand in the last 20 years while you've been there? No. It was original design? Yes. It's the same. [16:38] Speaker B (unidentified): Okay. In the last 20 years, yeah. [16:41] Speaker I (unidentified): I think what happened is that they were outgrowing the garden, and Nancy approached the town to see if they could do something at Gullcrest. [16:53] Speaker J (unidentified): So this [16:59] Speaker F (unidentified): is just simply the very, this was the first of many sheets, but this is just the cover sheet of the 1999 approved project. So you can see there were some connections to the existing transfer station landfill site, but it was the newly constructed public works sitting exactly as it does today, same paved areas, fuel station for all town departments, overflow gravel storage and parking areas. You can see the upper, I'll call it the upper and lower parking lot within Gullcrest. so this was the approved plan when that when that got built out again no deep dive into the if the idea is to go further in any direction after tonight we'll do a deeper dive into the documents from 1999 but just want to give you the general background so then you look at what exists out there today from sort of an infrastructure standpoint five plus miles of trails 40 plots, 39 or 40, I saw conflicting numbers, but 39 plots, 5,700 square feet of community garden space, 1.9 mile groomed ski loop, there was a second phase of that, my understanding was that was not built, but there are 1.9 miles. We have the ice rink operating from November to March, 4.25 acres of sports fields, which accommodates up to four or five different layouts, depending on age group and sport. And an acre of parking with 83 spaces, I believe, was the exact line-striped spaces right now. That's not including the parking on one side of the roadway. So that's kind of the infrastructure in place. And I'll just keep moving through this unless I get questions. but so talking with a lot of different groups use the facility sorry for that doesn't that background's not great for that slide looks better it looks better on a computer but so in the spring this was taken mostly from most of the sports get reserved through our facilities department so you've got youth and middle school lacrosse soccer games private rental of the fields for soccer-related activities. Ultimate Frisbee, you'll see touches on spring, summer, and fall. There are different races on the trails, both school and club. And then the summer, you see more camps, clinics, and games related to lacrosse, soccer, and football. There's some football kickoff activities for different age groups. Some school learning opportunities that extend summer through really all seasons. There's some scout activities. All of these vary. Most of it is weekday afternoons and weekends with, as you can imagine, during most seasons, daytime being quieter. Again, I didn't list out. These are the activities scheduled on the sports fields. obviously community garden activities extend spring summer fall and then winter you've got the ice arena Nordic skiing and some family programming and then I don't know how many years I know last year I stopped by the Special Olympic event that the schools worked to host there was it was a great winter activity out on the fields and they had several different activities so I assume some version of that will occur on either an annual or will occur on occasion and that was during school hours and on school days so that's sort of the that's the rough idea of just how many different sort of competing interests there are in using the fields one thing that we probably lack right now is just when you hear about some of the different stresses on the infrastructure there is sort of a capacity and number of teams in every single one of these events. I'm not sure that 's really been a focal point of some of the scheduling is to capture exactly how many people are using it for each individual rental. [Speaker J (unidentified): So, and] that brings us to one item that sort of circles back to the recent planning board approval of the ice rink project moving forward from a temporary to a more permanent structure is you know the town is technically the applicant for that project the town sort of passed along the right to apply and go through the process to the arena group but the planning board did approve the project to move forward and for the town and arena group to work together on whatever the structure was to create some pedestrian connections between the, I'm still going to go with upper and lower parking lot, unless anyone has better names for that, but the small upper parking lot to have that be able to have safe pedestrian connection down to the lower parking lot. So one of the items I thought might get some discussion tonight, you can see just a quick screenshot of GoCrest Drive itself, does not very well accommodate traffic on both sides but that is certainly not specific to you saw all those list of activities I think just last weekend our police department was called because of parking congestion on Gulf Crest Drive and had to issue some tickets because there is parking allowed on one side not the other and cars for lack of space were just parked on both sides so that gets into some of the future activity planning and maybe getting a better handle of how many people can be anticipated for certain events. [23:11] Speaker I (unidentified): So has there been, because I like that chart about all the activities are going on across seasons, has there been an assessment of any sort that says what is the maximum or I guess the best number of parking spaces to accommodate the peak seasons because it looks like there are peaks across probably fall and maybe summer and so if we look at here are all the things happening here's what space we have recognizing I agree with Rachel open space and you know habitat is important. So do we take the time to look at what parking is needed to accommodate the activities that are occurring at maximum use of the seasons? [24:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah. I don't know, without going through all of the proceedings of the planning board in 1999, I don't know if they touched on capacity when they were initially putting in the ballfields. I do know just from raising children that did cross-country and soccer that I don't remember any place in southern Maine that I went and they had enough parking for the largest events that they hosted during the year, if that's a regional cross-country meet or those once- or twice-a-year soccer tournaments. Parking was always overflowing onto streets, into neighborhoods, on roadways, and that's kind of... [24:53] Speaker I (unidentified): You've got the extremes. So you've got the low end, and of course, you've got tournaments and things like that. But the norm of activities that are happening across those seasons, recognizing it's not always all tournaments, what should we be able to accommodate? [25:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think there's a lot of factors to that. Because if it's a school team, they may have gotten bussed up there from the school. Whereas if it's parent drop-off or age dependent, you might see parents and grandparents at certain events depending on age. So that's probably a much deeper dive into each of those different, if I can jump back for a second, each of these different activities, where are the pressure points? [25:43] Speaker I (unidentified): Isn't that the assessment that needs to be done is what are the parking needs? I know logically that, yeah, there's buses, there's cars, there's this, there's bikes, there's this, but this has been in existence for many, years. And I think why we're here is saying, do we step back and now look at it and develop that master plan and strategy that says, if Goldcrest is our community asset for activities that are for our schools and our community, what does it need to, what needs to be in place to make that accommodate all of the things that are happening there, recognizing you can't have 2,000 parking spaces, but you can have a normal number of parking spaces that accommodate what our vision is for Gold Cross. That's kind of where I'm coming from. I'm not asking you to answer the question right now. I'm saying that if I were going to step back, I would look at what is this complex going to be and what do we need to have there in order to support all of the things that could occur there. [27:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, there's one thing that's really impacting those fields right now also is we lost that really highly utilized field next to the middle school. because of the construction, and I think some of the activities that were regularly there, probably you're going to see that gall crest for at least the next three or four years. You're going to see a real uptick in utilization for that. And so I think that's one. I don't know if that's why they had such a, if it was a football game or some kind of a soccer thing that ended up with all those people parking on both sides of the street this weekend, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was somewhat impacted by that Yeah, because those fields are going to be really highly utilized for the next few years. [27:58] Speaker I (unidentified): So is this an anomaly? I'm just... [28:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Hopefully it's temporary. Yeah,. [28:06] Speaker G (unidentified): But it's going to be at least the next few years. [28:09] Speaker A (unidentified): But Penny's point is well made, and I'm thinking that it's appropriate to look at what kind of parking does Gulf Crest accommodate now, and what does it need to accomplish what we as a as a town see it doing for us right so like there 's obviously a difference there we've seen it right so and it's and it's more than [28:40] Speaker I (unidentified): And I mean, parking is just one thing. The other thing is that what usage, what uses do we envision at Goldcrest? And what are the maximum number of uses that complex could accommodate? Because there, I mean, to Rachel's point, is a natural resource thing that we have to also see as an important part of Goldcrest. So if we were to take Goldcrest and say what are the priority the priority uses for that area and develop a plan based on this is how we see it from a priority perspective as a town asset, and then build out a plan from there that is then printed and available, and we aren't digging for information. I think we could then set our vision for Goldcrest for the next 20 years. [29:59] Speaker G (unidentified): And just to address one of Mr. Barton's concerns, there isn't any plan to make any changes at this point to any of the trails that have been set aside for the so I don't I don't think there's any anybody's making any plan to do any anything that it would affect that as far as I know yeah [30:22] Speaker H (unidentified): I think all these points are really well made and I think Penny's point about figuring out the parking I think one resource in town that would be pretty useful for looking into that would be community services because I believe that if people want to rent out the field for a tournament or for lacrosse or soccer or cross country during the spring or the fall that I think they have to go through community services in order to do that. And so figuring out what those numbers would be would probably make sense. And I don't, I understand what Pat's saying about sometimes you do get these anomalies of larger tournaments where you really can't predict the amount of parking. And I think that we'd be kind of cutting off our nose to spite our face if we're going to just build out as much parking as possible to accommodate what could happen. I think we would kind of be doing a disservice to the natural habitat and what Goldcrest is now by taking that step. At the same time, though, we do want to make sure that there are safety measures in place if those types of events are going to happen. And so really kind of getting our heads around what we're looking at for parking purposes, I think, would be a good, at least a good first step to take on figuring this out. [31:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Quick correction. [31:46] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I would say it's a bit of an internal workflow. If someone called community services looking to rent out this space, they'd probably be diverted over to the facilities department who would schedule it, assure that they have the proper insurance and add the town as additionally insured, and then they would have the space reserved. But that's more of just an internal workflow, and we're still working on the best way to have a scheduling software for all fields. So, the only thing with regard to future use that I think is worth stating is that, sure, a lot of scenarios, I think, have been thrown around in public comment or in looking at the ice rink as far as what would the structure potentially be used for, but the planning board approval was just for the ice rink operation during the winter hours. So, anything beyond that is going to take additional planning board approval and more discussion by the council. So, no immediate concerns there, and this figure is probably worth showing. Everything that you see highlighted, give everybody a second to get their bearings, you can kind of see the dark green area, it's zoomed way out, but this is the entire Gullcrest property, and this is just the recreation sort of side of it, but you can see all of the areas that have been mapped out that are wetlands. So, there shouldn't be a concern of, like, a large, -scale build-out of the entire property because you can see we're pretty much occupying the area that's usable without getting into significant wetland impacts so just thought that graphic was worth sharing so that people don't worry about this being a larger conversation than it is at this point or the steps that it would take to do anything more significant so two things maybe worth talking about and you'll be bringing up you can address it further in the business meeting later would be so the blue line on this diagram here that connects the two parking lots would be roughly where a sidewalk needs to go per planning board discussions and approvals and that would bring people down to the approved project of the arena and the redone lower parking lot as part of the arena project the funding of that sidewalk is still left to be discussed or determined so I'll just throw that out there, whether that makes it into the lease document or is addressed completely separate prior to construction. That's just worth noting, and I'd welcome anybody from the arena group to comment on that if they'd like. [34:38] Speaker K (unidentified): Andrew Davis My name is Andrew Davis. With my wife, Megan. Megan's been on the board of the Cape Arena, and we help them with some legal matters and everything. And I'm here today to start getting involved with this project. You know, I love everything that's been said by everybody, and I think it's all great considerations in this project, and I think the sidewalk is absolutely necessary, because it can really get treacherous over there, particularly in the wintertime, as we all know Maine is. So I think we talked about, I believe the town and the group has sort of agreed on what the price may or may not be, if I understand that correctly. Do I understand that correctly? [35:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think a price in the $60,000 range is fairly accurate. [35:23] Speaker K (unidentified): And with an agreement for us to participate in that process. And I think the group has no problem participating in that process, helping guide it, taking instruction. But unfortunately, I think the financial burden should not fall on us squarely. I mean, as you see in the chart, there's a significant amount of usage in Goldcrest. So I think it'd be unfair to have us be burdened with the $60,000, and frankly, I don't think it's something that the community group could do right now and continue this project forward. So that's my only comment. [36:00] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm really dense here. Can you clarify what we're talking about? Are we talking about the town funding $60,000 for sidewalk? [36:10] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm talking about the planning board approval. Town is the applicant, the community arena group was tasked with doing the application themselves or the town gave them permission to. The approval of the project went from the scope that they originally submitted and intended to include because of connectivity, safety, and a lot of things pointed out during the process that a sidewalk connection should happen between the upper and lower parking lot and as the person helped facilitate the conversation the lease agreement it was brought up will the town participate in that and I said well you can ask so this would be the initial ask does the town given the benefits to the other user groups and want to participate in the sidewalk portion of the five million dollar plus arena project. But they're getting a land lease for 40 [37:13] Speaker I (unidentified): years for a dollar. And I am a firm supporter of the arena. I truly am. But when we talk about public benefit, the fact that we're leasing land for 40 years for a dollar, I guess I would just have to have a bit more of a conversation about it. [37:45] Speaker K (unidentified): And I apologize. I'm pretty new to this, so I don't know if there's data on what the Garden Club pays for rent or the ski trails pays for rent. I'm kind of ignorant on that right now. I would be happy to look at it and discuss it, but we don't view this as like a commercial development. You know, this is a small town and it's not an improvement on a commercial property where you typically see a tenant Come in and outfit the commercial space as they would a business, right? I don't see that as this is more of a joint project with the town To improve community use that was spoken to earlier for everyone, you know I have although I'm not up to date on all the data. I have been down there a lot Helping with tournaments in the morning supervising skating's and I can say the wide variety of and it's not just hockey players There's people exercising, grandparents watching kids, learning. I think it's a really great development. But one concern I've always had is when it gets icy and you have someone coming down to go Nordic skiing, but the tournament started earlier, so they have to start up here. And maybe, I don't know where you can see them, they're a Nordic ski. But anybody that's using that property, when there is a hockey thing going on or whatever, 's there this weekend, the last thing that we want to do as a group is put people at risk. however we also think it's the town's land and this is not a commercial development and we just can't show that cost that's that's sort of the point [39:06] Speaker J (unidentified): that we're bringing up yeah sorry I was just about to call on you that's okay I [39:14] Speaker H (unidentified): just want to remind the council as well that this rig group is putting up 1.4 million dollars of their own money for phase one of this project to improve the lower lot and if they're asking for us to put up 60 grand i think that if we're gonna if we set a precedent a couple meetings ago when we gave fifty thousand dollars to the cape land trust for four hundred thousand project four hundred thousand dollar project that they were doing with their parking lot along shore road i think that this arena provides a significant public benefit but this 501c3 if they're they're willing to put up 1.4 million for phase one and ultimately I think it'll be a four to five million dollar project in total that they'll be raising money for I think a $60,000 sidewalk that needs to be put in anyway would be something that I would completely support the town doing and I just think that it would be unfair to the rink when just two meetings ago we put up 50 grand for the Cape land trust who also provides a significant community benefit if we're not if we're gonna do one for we're gonna do something for one but not something for the other I think that raises a issue with me and I would have full support with providing the funds for this sidewalk that again I think is already way past due for the [40:43] Speaker K (unidentified): the town to be providing yeah and just to piggyback on jonathan really quickly i mean this would not just serve the hockey community obviously would serve right now last weekend you know it's always walking on the side of that road is always a problem irrespective of the time of year so i think us having to burden it because it's wintertime and it's an ice ring just seems [41:05] Speaker G (unidentified): tough that's all tim did you have something to add well on one of pat's previous slides he You actually showed the little blue line that went down. Obviously, we knew we needed to build that upper smaller lot to accommodate everything that was going on down there. So we probably at that same time should have been considering a sidewalk at that time to connect. I mean, the people, we've got a parking lot for them up there. Without that parking lot, we now recognize it's pretty, especially when people are parking on both sides of it, But it's not all that safe for them to walk from that upper one down to the bottom when they have to reverse and go back up. So I think it makes sense for the town to be looking at that regardless. I think this whole arena process has brought some of these things to our attention. Clearly, I think whoever pays for that, and I'm with Jonathan, I think we should pay at least some of it. I don't think the arena folks should be needing to be paying for that, what is clearly a safety issue one way or the other. People are going to those fields down there and they're walking down that road without a sidewalk. It's unsafe now, and I think we need to recognize that, put the sidewalk in, and I'd be in favor of paying for it. [42:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Before you move on, I think I just want to chime in, and I really want to carefully separate the responsibility piece, whether or not I believe the town is responsible for paying and that sort of thing. I feel a pretty high degree of concern to hear that if the arena had to spend $50,000, that would be a financial deal breaker. That's really worrisome. That feels like not a huge amount of money in the grand scheme. And so I guess I just really, I feel like a caution flag about that, not about that the sidewalk is necessary or who should pay. Like that's not, I'm already on board with that. I think the sidewalk is necessary. And I'm already on board with the willingness to have a conversation about responsibility. responsibility but just that part of it really raises a do you know what do you understand yeah and i'm glad you brought that up because i'm okay i'm trying to be really clear yeah an argument [43:42] Speaker K (unidentified): about sidewalk that's not i don't think it's the amount of 50 000 it is more of the funding projects here and there like we can't just go around shouldering financial burden just because we're asking to rent the town that we don't think it's fair for us to show the financial burden We're obviously donating a significant amount of money, and I'm going to turn it over to Julie here. So the $50,000 is not a financial break. It's just more of the principle of having to fund things that we shouldn't fund, frankly. [44:12] Speaker L (unidentified): So for those who don't know, Julie Furt, 14 Running Tide Road, and also the chairperson for the 501c3. I think the practical reality is that we are looking at taking out a construction loan for phase one. And so we would have to take on additional debt and burden if we were to have to fund this on our own. It's not something that we had anticipated in our original design. We are working really hard to leave Goldcrest in a better place at the end of every phase. And so we're really looking at if we end up having to fund this, there's something else that we'll have to go out and fundraise for, or we'll have to make a tradeoff on something else. And so, the ask is really to be partners as we've been all along in this journey and to consider whether or not that additional burden is something that the town can help us with. [45:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you for having that conversation. I appreciate hearing from you. Absolutely. Are we okay with Pat moving on? Okay. [45:15] Speaker F (unidentified): The last slide was just sort of questions from a staff level to council if you want. it's not a voting not a voting meeting but if you want some of these things pursued and i actually think penny went ahead and asked these questions probably three or four slides ago but you know are there capacity you know do we feel there are enough capacity issues at gulcrest related to current activity levels to pursue some more data or some engine do we want to go as far in the coming budget year to pursue any study design or improvement funding with at the existing complex and are there any other uses at gulcrest that council would want us to explore if we do go down those paths so just open questions so i have a little direction to bring something more back to [46:06] Speaker G (unidentified): The [46:08] Speaker M (unidentified): second one, yes, second bullet item, absolutely. [46:14] Speaker G (unidentified): And as far as the last bullet, are there any other uses for Goldcrest? Not this side of Goldcrest, but Stephanie and I were both on the Housing Diversity Committee a while ago. And there was some pretty strong feelings. Cynthia Dale had done a lot of work on possibly doing some housing on the other side of Goldcrest. And so that might be something that would be worthwhile to look into some affordable housing possibilities on the other side of Goldcrest. [46:48] Speaker N (unidentified): Where would that be? Do we see the map again, Pat? [46:53] Speaker G (unidentified): I don't think that map showed where. [46:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, the other, so this is the second deeded area of the property, essentially. Let me switch to this little laser pointer so you can actually see it on the screen. Up in this area is where you have the transfer station, the landfill, and then you'd have to be up in the top corner here. Up in that direction would be on the original owned parcel. I left that out, knowing that just getting through the recreation area would be probably [47:37] Speaker G (unidentified): enough for our hour-long- And the only reason I'm raising it is that if you are looking at that entire property, you may want to take a look at some of the work that the housing developed, diversity, along with what the citizens, Cynthia Dill had done a fair amount of work on. that [48:08] Speaker A (unidentified): concludes this portion of the workshop for tonight do you feel like you have enough information to move forward to do the investigations and come back sure nobody [48:27] Speaker B (unidentified): online can hear you when you're sitting there's one more use and that is snowmobilers and that when the trails were developed they there was a requirement that they be developed for multi-purpose including snowmobiling so i don't know how that affects the sidewalk walk they might be able to just go faster i [48:50] Speaker A (unidentified): know when my kids were out cross-country skiing when they were younger they enjoyed actually when the snowmobiles had been through because it made it easier to use their nordic skis all right so we're going to move on to communications so as a part of a continued effort to improve citizen engagement and feedback staff will present a few potential public engagement tools for consideration and feedback from the town council. Before we move forward, are there any members of the public that wish to comment on this item, either in this space or online? All right, seeing none, we're going to just go ahead, and this is a conversation for the council, to just start thinking about what are some potential future flash vote survey topics that come to mind and this is just a brainstorming session so what are do people have any thoughts about uses of gold crafts there's a thought i'm [50:04] Speaker I (unidentified): sure there's a lot of questions you [50:12] Speaker G (unidentified): know maybe affordable housing you know again based on the work that we did on the committee What we found is as wide open as it feels and as much land as we've been able to successfully set aside with the land trust, what we found is there's not very many places where we can do any kind of housing. How serious is our town trying to do whatever we can to come up with some affordable housing possibilities? [50:47] Speaker I (unidentified): everybody's really excited about the one next door I would say the expansion of the tax relief program all [51:12] Speaker G (unidentified): the different community services that we do between the library there's a way of getting feedback from the from the community I know Stephanie's very closely been working with them and they feel like they need some expansion. What are the thoughts of the community on that? What are the thoughts of how all the services that are being provided by community services, maybe getting some kind of a flash vote on what more could we be doing and how much do they like what we're already doing? That could be another good one. [51:49] Speaker I (unidentified): I'll let Jonathan speak on this, but I think there's probably a couple of questions down the road in the next year that'll come out of that 1934 building recommendations. [52:05] Speaker H (unidentified): I agree, Penny. We can't give a preview of our report, though, can we? [52:10] Speaker J (unidentified): We don't want to spoil it for people. [52:17] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't mean to interrupt the brainstorming because this is fantastic, but it looks like also Susanna might have a little bit of discussion around flash vote for us. [52:28] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, the topic for the agenda was, can you speak into the microphone? Yes, I can. Sorry. The topic for tonight's agenda, this portion of it, were public engagement tools. And I thought the first two, flash vote, and then other options for things we already have. So flash vote we have, and we should fully utilize that. the other the other option it's part of our website and we could go as simple as right now people can get notified of alerts through email but we could just for a little bit more add mobile messaging but that would have to be you know something based on like website news or alerts like weather or town closures. So there's that simple option right now. But having been to a conference in September, I know Pat just returned from one, you get bombarded by all these different vendors and all these different products and tools that municipalities can think about. And this is the other portion of this topic discussion on the eve of, you know, when budget discussion begins, it's a good time to start introducing. And these slides, these aren't really slides, actually, they're just a document. It's more for you to just get a visual. Sometimes seeing a company logo is easier to remember than details about it. But these are just revised as the one we have. That's our website. This is what an e-notify would look like. Right now we currently have the e-mail subscription, but you could opt in for text messaging. And then a new one that we will soon be having a demonstration with that both Pat and I have talked to individually, it's called Rept. And one of the popular communication slash engagement techniques right now are to create more informational videos. And one thing that rep does is they created AI module right on your website so that if someone comes to the website and has a question, they're scanning your whole website content and provide you information. You also have the option of having an informational video from a department head, a real live video. I've seen the back room work of how that is developed. They create the content and the text based on your policies or your ordinances. And someone who is brave enough to do that video would just read basically a script and answer the question, which is a pretty cool new thing that I've never seen. Falmouth currently is using it. That's why that's there. I would recommend just going onto their website to see what it looks like. We don't have time tonight, but CityStream is another one for, I don't know too much about this, but it's about record management and FOA helping assisting the clerk and citizen requests for information streamlining that it could also Pat I'm not sure if it could help with ordinances did you meet with CityStream [56:01] Speaker F (unidentified): or no that's upcoming but yeah most of that most of CityStream would not be sort of a public engagement piece that we're talking about with some of the other ones it would be more of the internal ADA compliance on electronic documents better ordinance consolidation and searching and a lot of the components that the clerk's office has to contend with okay and then this other [56:28] Speaker O (unidentified): one text mygov this is more interactive this is not something that our website currently offers but recommends if you wanted to go to a more robust messaging system with phones citizens could submit a question on their phone and they would get an answer back also alerts could go out there you could also break it up into specific topics or specific geographic areas so that's an option and then clear gov just met with them today they are a whole sort of budget focused capital improvement planning backbone but for our purposes today we looked at their capacity for making the budget book a digitally ABA accessible which by 2028 the spring of 2028 it will have to be so these are tools out there I think we just wanted you to be aware of what options there are and if it if it generates any other ideas of products or vendors you've heard of certainly let Pat know and go from there. I don't know if you have any questions. [57:40] Speaker I (unidentified): Annie? I don't really have a question, having just come down off getting at least 27 texts a day, which probably everybody else did as well. But anyway, I think that there are several tools out there that we could leverage and that would really be impactful and that we could get information from and to people throughout the town. I'm going to go back to a suggestion that I had several months ago that kind of was the impetus for our communications committee. I think that there needs to be, just like the traffic safety, there needs to be a group pulled together that says here are the tools we want here's how we want to use them here's how they integrate and then we can use flash vote to test the effectiveness of them or something that was a joke but anyway that's what I would propose because there's a lot out there and I think we should start taking advantage of some of them I [59:06] Speaker A (unidentified): think as we approach budget season it would be really appropriate to see what recommendations are coming from you and Pat in particular and where you see the bang for the buck and that way we can make you know be prepared to make some of those decisions as well so yeah we could I mean this was a pretty short [59:30] Speaker F (unidentified): item just to kind of get everybody thinking about it well ahead of the budget season but we can when you have your communication policy discussion in the next month or two we can sort of revisit and do a deeper dive on a couple of these i think in general it would be nice to have you know to explore some tools that let us reach more residents without formal mailings like we have you know a public hearing you do a formal mailing you meet you know state and local requirements for that but there's so many things that we'd like to be able to let a neighborhood know we're discussing at a public meeting and we just don't have an effective tool we don't have every single person's email address we don't have that so there are some tools out there that would let us get to neighborhoods or specific groups about certain topics that you're visiting in a meeting further [1:00:21] Speaker A (unidentified): questions thank you okay we're going to close the workshop at this time and get organized give ourselves a minute and then we're going to move into our business meeting okay moving into the business meeting welcome to the town council regular town council regular meeting for wednesday november 4th 2026. may i have a roll call please [1:04:04] Speaker O (unidentified): Andrew Swayze. Here. Stephanie Anderson. Here. Caitlin Harriman. Here. Thank you. Penny Jordan. Here. Tim Thompson. Here. Jonathan Saarbeck. Chair Seifried. Here. [1:04:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Would you all please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance. At this time are there any members of the public either in the chamber or online that wish to comment on items not on the agenda tonight if so please approach the podium and please give your name and address and you'll have three minutes i'm [1:05:30] Speaker P (unidentified): krisha parker and i live at [address] packets aren't as fancy as the last ones that i gave out but the front of wind proved the point this is a safety issue i'm not sure how it could be denied as anything but a safety issue I provided a lot of information with the last packet, giving you the width of the road, emergency response, safety concerns, ecological footprint, carrying capacity, comparative study on open space through Cape Elizabeth of the cars per acre, which, by the way, average in Cape Elizabeth open space is 0.7 cars per acre. Yet on June 13th, Reef Road, Chundi Point experienced 6.7 cars per acre. We want to be on the agenda, and we're still not on the agenda. We want to know when we will be. [1:06:33] Speaker Q (unidentified): Good evening, Council President, members of the Town Council. Thank you for your time tonight. My name is Connie Pacillo. I've been before you before, and I am a 30-year resident of Shore Acres. I live on [street]. My house is about seven houses away from Trinity Point Beach. I and my fellow taxpaying neighbors are here tonight because we're concerned that despite having followed all proper administrative channels, as well as having provided comprehensive empirical data regarding the issues affecting our neighborhood, we're still not on the council's agenda or any other committee's agenda. agenda. For many years, the ongoing Trundy Point beach issues have been brought before this council, and still, today, there has been little redress to these items that so directly impact our daily lives, our safety, and the livability of our neighborhood on a regular basis. We've done the groundwork, we've documented the facts, submitted the data, and worked respectfully through the established processes. We know the wheels of justice move slowly yet still we have received no follow-up or notification of what a clear path toward resolution would look like or any update on when this would be added to your agenda we recognize the many competing priorities before this council but years of inaction on this issue that so greatly impacts the taxpayers of this neighborhood takes a heavy toll on us we respectfully ask tonight for the following. What specific steps are required to place this item on an upcoming agenda, and when? When can the residents of Shore Acres and Reef Road expect a formal discussion and hearing on this matter? When can we expect final resolution? Thank you for your time, your public service, and your attention to this urgent neighborhood concern. We look forward to your response. [1:08:37] Speaker A (unidentified): typically we have started having a sign-in sheet for public comment and I'm not sure if it's up there or not it would be fantastic if you both could leave your email addresses so that you have asked specific questions and we'd like a way to actually answer those questions so I did leave my email the last meeting when I spoke and I did I was able to get that okay great it's never hurts to repeat and I appreciate that very much thank you and I know that this is [1:09:17] Speaker I (unidentified): public comment and we usually don't travel down this road but I just got to throw this out people have been here several times and they're feeling as though we as a council are not demonstrating any action around the issue that they keep raising. And so I will put it out there as you chair that I think we need to start demonstrating some actions. These are citizens in our town that we're here to serve. And they keep asking the same question over and over and over again. And so I'll leave it at that. But I really think we gotta prove that we're here to do something and not just sit here. [1:10:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you, Councillor Jordan. I believe that this conversation will be very relevant during our report from the Traffic Safety Committee. They haven't heard that. Correct. They haven't heard it yet. [1:10:22] Speaker I (unidentified): No, they have not heard anything about their issue being important to the work that is being done. Are [1:10:36] Speaker A (unidentified): there any other members of the public that wish to speak at this time on items that are not on the agenda? Seeing none, we will move on to town council reports and correspondence. Do we have any updates from committees or other council happenings? [1:11:05] Speaker G (unidentified): The one thing I mentioned briefly with Penny, I've been on the county budget committee for the last couple of years, and I'm not going to be on the county budget committee moving forward. And I talked with Commissioner Patty Smith yesterday at the polls. She's in a position to appoint somebody. To be on that committee, you've got to be an elected official. So the first budget meeting is coming up on December 4th. So I don't know if there is a council member that would be interested in that, who could maybe communicate with Pat, who could communicate with Patty, Commissioner Smith. I think it's been a real value having somebody from Cape on that committee, bringing that information back. It certainly was an eye opener for me to see how much Cape Elizabeth contributes to the county budget. I think I've told you guys there's only three towns that can contribute more than we do, Portland, South Portland, and Scarborough. But it was very valuable for me. You sit there and every department head comes forward and presents their budget, and I really would encourage somebody if they've got... I know you're all busy and you're all on many committees already, but if somebody could step forward, and I'm sure Commissioner Smith would really like to see one of us, one of you, stepping forward and taking over that responsibility. So that's the only thing I wanted to share. are [1:12:41] Speaker A (unidentified): there any other updates all right so on saturday the 24th counselor swayze and i held another coffee with counselors at the library at 10 o'clock in the morning and it was quite well attended early on there was discussion around speed limits through town and a couple of people that were very happy to see that the islands were gone because of signs being placed in the islands that really disrupted sight lines, so that was interesting, and some conversation around what was going on in town center and the decision to do what was called squaring off versus a rotary or roundabout. However, the primary conversation came from a fairly large group of residents that abut the Blue Meadow development on the former Bothell property, and so they had a significant number of questions and frustrations, and they really were trying to understand what role the town can play at this point in a private development. They just asked quite a bit of questions, and they had concerns around safety and security. They had questions around, you know, building permit check-ins and deadlines and other mechanisms. So that was really important for the council to hear and also for us to be able to find out what role does the town play once a development has gone through planning board, has gone through all the steps, and is now where they are. So, I brought these concerns to Pat. He's going to do some investigation and then I think it'll be informative for the council just really to understand what our role is and what the town does and what we can and can't do and what we know about and what we just don't know about. there was a question about property assessment when is the next property assessment going to be what is going on with that process and understanding and then some final conversation around the spurwink marsh culvert and the cost of doing nothing around the road abandonment. So we had, it was fruitful discussion, a lot of conversation, and we thank everybody that came out to speak with us, have a little coffee, and we will absolutely do this again. [1:15:47] Speaker I (unidentified): Do you think that was the, because that sounds like it was a good time for people to get [1:15:54] Speaker A (unidentified): out is that do we think more about that time i will tell you so that's the third one we've done we've done two on saturday morning and one in the afternoon the afternoon one was not well attended right four people right it was not well attended we initially we wanted to just try to offer right different time maybe different group but both times we offered the saturday morning right when that library opened the first time we got at least 12 people this time probably between 12 and 14 people wow so that's great i think we've we may have found but i mean i just i hate to limit but i agree i think saturday morning might be the Thank you and thank you councillor Swayze. That was fun. It was. I would definitely do that again. Yeah it was really fun and nice to interact with people. So I just want to double check there haven't been any there aren't any committee reports or anything that anybody needs to say before we move on. Thank you. Town manager's report. Court. [1:17:15] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, thank you. Just one day after the election, I wanted to start off with a thank you to our election workers in Clerk's Office for getting through what was a very busy election season. A lot of long training hours on the state software, the voting machines, followed by really high absentee voting numbers and new staff members in multiple positions. They just came together as a team and pulled off a very busy election it was also with the help of very strong support from public works police and our finance staff that actually switches over to help at the polls due to our election staffing numbers so they did a great job and i think produced a positive and trusted experience for our voters this time of year we're always looking for new volunteers for many boards and committees that we have throughout the town just a reminder that this is not no one needs to be an expert to participate on these and you really don't need endless amounts of time available so you know your participation as a resident each of these staffs are each of these committees are staffed the staff is there to help you help the town in the most efficient way possible and not have to put a lot of your own extra time into it so please consider one of these roles i think many of them find them very fulfilling we're looking for applications by november 19th and then the appointments committee will be doing interviews to appoint people to the committee that they're most interested in and would be a good fit for one update for council recently you heard of the casino beach outfall project that we had been looking one direction at a new outfall that was becoming more and more expensive and more and more sort of obtrusive to the beach environment surrounding it so we were able to secure the contracts to just clean out and retrofit the existing culvert so that will be happening or outfall pipe that'll be happening in the coming weeks we have a couple of bids out right now the we have a road paving project on a section of Shore Road it's not the section you would think it's the section back towards town so it's a lighter pavement treatment we were able to get state funding for that so that is out to bid and that will happen in spring of 27 and the other bid that we have is we've had a longtime consulting consultant helping us with ms4 which is our stormwater compliance through with the main Department of Environmental protection and we are looking for that person is retiring looking we have a bid out for a new consulting new consultant for the next five-year permit to help us with much of the data collection and reporting that's required of every community our size throughout the state so those are out to bid right now and as with all other municipal bids they're located on the business section of our website under bids and RFPs all I have tonight thank you so [1:20:31] Speaker A (unidentified): I have a quick update we do not have draft minutes to approve tonight they will be at our next voting meeting our town clerk has been a little busy and so they will be at our Next voting meeting. So moving on to item 8A, the Cape Community Arena Group-Gullcrest Ground Lease Agreement. On October 20th, 2026, the Planning Board approved the construction of an open-air arena and related site improvements located at the end of Gullcrest Drive. Before construction can begin, the Town Council and the Cape Community Arena Group must reach a ground lease agreement for the project to proceed. A draft agreement has been provided to allow this discussion to continue, and at this time, are there any members of the public that wish to comment on this item? If so, yep, please approach the podium, name and address, and you'll have three minutes. [1:21:37] Speaker R (unidentified): you. Hi, Chris Gorski, 36 Cliff Avenue. I would say when I was canvassing for this office, I would talk to a lot of people about the arena, and people were very excited. They enjoy skating there. I think there's a lot of confusion about why a lease is necessary in the terms of the lease, and so questions that were asked to me were, why do we have a lease? Why do we have a lease for such a long term if we've been operating it on a year-to-year basis why can't we continue to do that why can't the town contract with the cape arena group instead of form a permanent lease why can't community services do it and so i think it would be helpful with respect to the public and maybe even strengthening the agreement with Cape Arena to have some more explanation and context around the lease itself and why we're doing it. [1:22:47] Speaker S (unidentified): Good evening. Mary Kay Cooney, 25 Wildwood. So I just want to address the lease as well and so these are sort of more comments I want to make sure that we're thinking about. One is, I'm not sure if CAPE has had a lease with a 501c3 before. I was thinking maybe something at Fort Williams with the Goddard Mansion Group. My only point being that this is an unbelievably significant commitment for the town to take on with sizable exposure. Forty years is a very long time. I don't think I'll be here. I certainly won't be skating. I just ask that you know to please be careful and cautious and I think what the prior gentleman just brought up were also important points I'm also want to make sure reiterate that the town residents need to be aware of this town commitment in this lease it's you know this is a very important town owned asset and again 40 years is a very long time there's a lot of details in that again going back to the point about whether the town has dealt with a lease of this kind before to make sure that all the details and those leases are full of all kinds of details and I'm curious as to what the land value of the Goldcrest parcel is if that's ever been sort of figured out you know is it greater than a million less than a million just going back to the idea that I think if there's isn't there something about if the town is investing in something over a million it should be made aware to the citizens of the town in any case I also was thinking I agree with I think penny Jordan had indicated this to maybe put this in a flash vote some of these kinds of comments around strategic uses of Goldcrest. Thank you. Thank you. [1:24:58] Speaker T (unidentified): Good evening. My name is Debbie Fisher. I'm a 31-year resident of Cape Elizabeth, and I live at [address]. I've taken a look at the ground lease agreement, and I'm especially concerned with Section 7F, which is the tenant termination right portion of the agreement. This appears to be quite one-sided it in favor of the tenant. My question is, has the town's corporate council reviewed the lease? I have three concerns. One, the tenant can terminate if the term determines any condition that the tenant's engineers, not the town's, not an independent third party reviewing engineer, that would have a material adverse effect upon the proposed construction or use. What could be considered an adverse effect? This should be defined more specifically. Two, the tenant can terminate if they are unable to secure satisfactory financing. This is exceptionally vague and subjective. The tenant needs to provide a spreadsheet that shows all anticipated costs to complete the project in its entirety throughout the preliminary period including the standard 10% additional cushion thirdly the tenant can walk if they are able to secure if they are unable to secure approved plans or all required permits that's the purpose of this meeting and the town council, and the planning board approval process before any construction can even begin? For instance, what would prohibit the tenant from asking for relief from the approved project within the preliminary period, and if the relief isn't satisfactory to them, they determine that through their good faith effort that it isn't met, so they can walk. My argument is how will the council ensure that this project will not become a financial albatross to Cape taxpayer payers by having to complete maintain and operate it if the tenant leaves. Thank you. Thank you. Are [1:27:35] Speaker A (unidentified): there any other members of the public either online or in the chamber that wish to comment? Okay [Speaker J (unidentified): Okay, seeing] none, may have a motion, so we may get discussion going. Do we have to close it? It's not a public hearing. Okay. So, just need a motion so we can start discussion. Just [1:28:05] Speaker G (unidentified): read it, right? Ordered the Cape Elizabeth Town Council authorizes a town manager to enter into a ground lease agreement with the Cape Community Arena Group for the construction of an open air ice arena at Gullcrest. following review of the final lease agreement by the town attorney [1:28:29] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm gonna [1:28:39] Speaker I (unidentified): say right up front I'm not a lawyer and I did read all of these pages the sections that, and I'm assuming our lawyers reviewed this whole thing, the sections that pop out to me are sections 20, 21, and 23, and the impression I get from these sections is that if the arena group, if they go for financing and that the land that the building is sitting on is considered in part of that lending, understanding that the lender, in essence, can impact the town's ability to negotiate changes to the lease, that they can, if there was a default in anything to the town of how the arena operated, that the lender could say, sorry, you can't do that town. So as I look at these sections, and I could go through them in excruciating detail, which I did. If you look at section 20, item number B2, the question becomes, in this instance, does the town lose the land? That's my question. If we go down to the section 21 toward the end of that first paragraph there's the term called assignment or there's a reference that could mean assignment and I recognize that I'm only a farmer but I've done lots of leases relative to my land and assignment often creates a little bit of angst for me. There's also in this section where it says that the landlord and tenant without prior consent in writing from... So the lender needs to be giving consent. So basically, if we look at... And you look at Section 23, Section 23, which is the tenant default, it has a strong relationship to Section 21. So if you look at 21, it says these sections, the tenant can lease the mortgage. The town cannot freely change or terminate the lease. the lender can prevent actions. If you look at Section 23 and it says if the lender may add additional power over anything in 23, which has to do with the, sorry, turn my pages. I've watched Stephanie turn pages for years. So that's the tenant default. I think these sections, 20, 21, and 23, need to be scrutinized a little more, because what I'm seeing, and I know you guys have heard it a thousand times, I'm sitting here to protect the town, and to protect the town 10 years out, 5 years out, 7 years out, 30 years out. And what I'm feeling is that we keep moving this down the road without having really looked at what can happen to that land, which is we're leasing for 40 years for $1 and there is the potential that a third party can swoop in and say sorry you can't negotiate this lease or changes in this lease and what I've been keep being told is don't worry penny don't worry penny we'll be able to fix things and I'm not feeling comfortable that we will so that's kind of where I'm at this point in time and I would like to hear what the lawyer our lawyer says about these sections and I said it a thousand times whenever I have entered into a having to do a business plan in order to get financing, I have to be able to say, what is your exit strategy? I wanna see an exit strategy documented just like I have to do when I enter into an agreement. [1:35:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Caitlin, do you have the ability to speak? Hear me? Yep, thank you. [1:35:12] Speaker U (unidentified): i was going to raise a similar concern with the way the motion is presented i don't know why we aren't reviewing the final draft of the agreement after the attorney has reviewed it and as penny has pointed out if we have such questions why aren't we having an executive session with our attorney to discuss some parts of this very long, very important lease. And I mean long as in years, not long as in many pages. But I would like to sit down with the attorney and make sure we're going over it, at least make sure we all understand it. Thank [1:36:00] Speaker M (unidentified): you. Yeah, I'm gonna echo those concerns too. I would rather talk to the attorney first before I promise to this. I too was kind of concerned about 7F where I looked at it. I was like that's a very generous termination although I know it applies to the preliminary period which is the first 12 months from the commencement date and the commencement date I assume is whatever date gets entered into the top of this document yes so [1:36:33] Speaker F (unidentified): yes but the preliminary period is actually intended to cover preliminary period is intended to cover the work that they've already gone through so really if we have entered into this lease agreement prior to them the cape arena group pursuing planning board approval that's really the preliminary period it's the due diligence period we already did that however leading it from this document didn't make a lot of sense because if they did have to pare back or revisit the project or go back for a planning board approval they'd be back sort of in that preliminary period sometimes projects get approved that don't actually get built that way that could bring them back to what would be the preliminary period but essentially the preliminary period because they have planning board approval for a design if they move forward with that design, it really moves into the termination within the contract during construction. So essentially the preliminary period if they move forward with the design as approved has already gone by. It's during the due diligence period. It's a lot of what, a lot of these parameters, a lot of this was based on the two ranks in Falmouth. Our attorney did draft this. Certainly, there is plenty of room to have an executive session discussion directly with the attorney, but that would be what the preliminary period was really intended for in the document. With regard to a lot of the other stuff, think back to a lot of the concessions or discussions or where we ended up with... I know we're talking about a very different use, but it's not that much different than the... In some ways, it's not much different than the landfill refill lease we did with the solar company to put solar panels on there were a lot of conditions in the lease they needed for financing purposes that we wouldn't necessarily have put in on our end and I think there's still some back and forth to occur depending on what the financing is that the Cape Arena group has to secure for different phases I don't think for this project that's as cookie cutter or as laid out as it was for a corporate entity to come in and [1:38:44] Speaker M (unidentified): lease our landfill cap so in this case a lot of this language might be designed to assist the arena group in getting financing well for instance the 40-year [1:38:57] Speaker F (unidentified): term if they are building something eventually told in total worth five million dollars whatever percentage of that they have to borrow on if they're of borrowing for a 20 or 30 year period much like we would if we were building it as a municipality or if you were taking out a mortgage buying a house your lease has to extend beyond that period of the borrowing so that's really where the term of the lease comes from it wasn't a set number of the ring's going to run for 40 years and go away or something it's just to build an asset of that value you do need to have the terms extend out and they have the rights to be there for that [1:39:33] Speaker M (unidentified): length of time or you can't secure the financing i still have reservations about the financial [1:39:44] Speaker F (unidentified): solidity of all of this so the draft motion was simply there as this was the last scheduled business meeting of the current council so there is a motion to at least start with certainly can be tabled amended or moved into an executive session or extend into the next [1:40:01] Speaker A (unidentified): term of the new council Jonathan I want to make sure you're able to speak I have [1:40:07] Speaker F (unidentified): to just hang on we just don't have one of the usual buttons available so I need [1:40:12] Speaker H (unidentified): to should be able to unmute now Jonathan okay Jonathan no thanks I mean I'm totally fine I assumed that our town attorney had already looked over this and drafted it and didn't have any concerns with regards to it but I definitely understand that members might have questions for her and having an executive session to go over this would make sense at the same time I'm not really too concerned with what's been mentioned I mean section 20 deals with eminent domain we are the town we are usually the ones who deal with eminent domain if ever necessary but we have an understanding that both the town excuse me the state and the federal government could step in so that's just basically a contingency that's usually put in probably most leases that deal with municipalities and land that's held the leasehold mortgages from what I've heard from the arena group through the many meetings that we've had and from the minute meetings that I've watched them in front of the planning board I don't believe that they have any anticipation of getting a mortgage on this property. So I don't think that would have any sort of bearings on what the reality is on the ground. But at the same time, I think having it in the lease would make sense. And especially I get what Pat's saying that you definitely would want to have a lease that extends a long period of time. If this group is going to be putting in a $5 million facility that's going to be raised to a charitable organization from donations and fundraising that they're going to be doing. So having a lease that's a lesser amount of time really doesn't make too much sense if somebody is wanting to give and put this sort of investment into the town. and then the tenant default I'd be happy to kind of go over any concerns with the our town attorney that people have on that but from my from what I've heard from the arena group I know initially they indicated that they were thinking that they were gonna build this and give it over to the town but I know that they have sort of done a 180 on that and now they are very reluctant to hand this over to the town that they want to hold on to the control and the management of this so i don't think that there is any plan by the arena group and maybe somebody there might be able to verify that they are going to be wanting to sort of hand this over to the town i think that they want to keep this within their control so again i'm happy and i think it would probably be the best step for the town to speak to our town attorney in executive session but I don't really have too many concerns about this lease. [1:43:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Stephanie? Oh I'm sorry Stephanie, Tim actually. [1:43:11] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah I don't, my concern with the with the 40-year lease isn't the fact that it's 40 years, I understand why there needs to be a significant amount of time beyond the amount of time something has to be mortgaged or borrowed. But my concern is this is really significant. It's a very significant project that the town and the Cape Arena Group are undergoing. And I also would like the idea of having a workshop with our attorney. I know we talked about Section 15 at the last meeting, and I didn't bring my notes, and I should have, but I thought that some of these provisions in the covenants, I thought we had agreed certain ones concerning the rate per hour really wasn't up to the town council. I'm concerned that, you know, it says public skating will be available to residents a minimum of three days per week. But is that like one hour or six hours? I mean, what are we getting? What public benefit are we actually getting here? I think that needs to be spelled out. And I do also, I've stated this before, but I really think it's important that a member of the town council is on the governing board. This says not less than 25% of the members of the governing board shall be residents of the town of Cape Elizabeth. I don't know why it's so low, 25%, maybe there's a good reason. And I know I asked last time, and there was an answer, but I forgot what it was. But I really think that, you know, we are, the town is really undertaking, there's a big risk. I mean, there's a big risk on both sides. But I think it's important that a town council member be on the governing board. And there's a few other little things, too. I think they can be ironed out. I don't think any of these things are deal breakers to both parties being able to be happy with this lease agreement. But I do think it does need a little more work, and I would not be comfortable voting in favor of this lease tonight. [1:45:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Tim, did you have comments? [1:45:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, I just think as a town council, we did vote to authorize our town manager to work with this lease to make people that might be watching this, the arena people didn't put this lease together. Our town manager working with our town attorney put this lease together. Is that correct? [1:46:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Yep. We utilized, I think we've been very transparent, we utilized the Falmouth sort of model, brought it into the format for Cape Elizabeth. I sat down with a member of the Cape Arena group board, tried to take the feedback I heard from you last time and incorporate as best I could while still taking into account their comments and needs. So yeah, it's very much a work in progress. It's not easy to negotiate a public lease when you do part of it here and part of it trying to meet with the one member of the board. They would still have to, the member I met with was trying to convey their needs as best he could but he's still going to have to go back and get the approval of his full board so yeah it's it's a process but that's that's how it that's how we got to where we are today it did it did it was drafted through our attorney okay it had some familiarity with the falmouth rink and its operation over the last i want to say 15 or 20 years or something okay i [1:47:20] Speaker I (unidentified): think i think the piece that we really need to think about is we are okay maybe there is a group of people that this lease is associated with that group of people may not exist by it may have morphed into a different group of people and so I have to take the people out of it because I trust where they're coming from. The passion they put into putting that arena in place, I am in awe. But I have to say that's a group of passionate people who believe in their project and our town. Now let's look at the lease. Let's say six years from now there are other people and yeah, Jonathan, maybe this group doesn't have to go for financing. In six years it might have to be a financing thing that occurs because something happens. happens. We don't know what is going to happen. And so when you create a lease that is about your land, having done this several times, you make sure your land is protected. You make sure your business is protected. And I truly feel, I trust Pat to the nth degree. But in the past, we would have sat as a council with our attorney and kicked the tires and said, what about this? What about that? And I truly believe that is the step that needs to happen. And yes, we have two outgoing councillors, two income, that should not be a determining factor of whether we take this to the next step before [1:49:41] Speaker A (unidentified): I add my opinion and kind of repeat back what I think I've heard from the council and suggest next steps are there more comments so I too have concerns I am not wanting to be obstructionist to this process I believe in this partnership I want this to happen however i agree with everything that has been said and we are here at this table to protect the town and so i think that it what i'm hearing is that we need to table this what i'm hearing is that we need to meet an executive session with our attorney ask our questions get the lease to a point where the council feels very comfortable before it can go forward. [1:50:43] Speaker I (unidentified): Is there a way that we could have a meeting with our attorney before the two outgoing counselors leave? It'll have to happen in November, and we're only at the beginning of November. [1:51:09] Speaker A (unidentified): November 16th is already on our calendar for a workshop and then caucus which doesn't usually take a lot of time so would the we could reach out to council and find out if they're available I think that's a workable I'm sorry Caitlin has her hand up yeah hang on Caitlin we got to unmute [1:51:36] Speaker U (unidentified): mute you okay my only question to that strategy is wouldn't we want the new counselors at the meeting with the attorney if they're going to be the ones voting good point on the lease [1:51:51] Speaker A (unidentified): mm-hmm and doing it on the 16th wouldn't preclude that because we have a caucus with them on the 16th but they won't they haven't been oh they won't be allowed to be in it because they won't be sworn in thank you caitlin thank you that's a good point caitlin they will not be sworn in until early december can't we invite people so i think i think it is actually appropriate that we wait for the swearing in and then schedule the executive session with council and so that's what i'm going to suggest and i 'm i'm open but that's what i'm hearing is that we need to table this i don't hear anybody feeling ready to move forward with this tonight myself included i'm hearing from everybody that we want to have this executive session with the attorney so it sounds like if [1:52:58] Speaker F (unidentified): i could just suggest in your there's no discussion once the tabling motion hits the floor so if you could just put in your tabling motion on until an executive session can be scheduled with the town attorney not date certain because we'll try for probably the sixth [1:53:14] Speaker I (unidentified): but there may be scheduling conflicts can i ask a stupid question hey caitlyn and haven't we had executive sessions where other parties have been invited in to have involved in the conversation? Let [1:53:35] Speaker M (unidentified): me just, she should be able to unmute. [1:53:38] Speaker U (unidentified): I think, sorry, I can't unmute unless Pat lets me. We, that's a tough question. I don't know if we've always brought in related parties. [1:53:52] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm going back to paper streets. [1:53:54] Speaker U (unidentified): The only thing it does is it, like, makes it less confidential, I guess, because you're bringing in an outside party. Okay. But we don't even know, like, we wouldn't even know if the attorney is available on November 16th any more than we know if the attorney is available on December 6th. [1:54:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Okay. So for the motion, the table, whoever makes that motion has to please say, what do I? [1:54:29] Speaker F (unidentified): Just to provide tabling until when, so it's not indefinite. Just tabling until an executive session with the town attorney can be scheduled. [1:54:37] Speaker I (unidentified): So move the table in order that we have executive session with our town attorney regarding the lease, the Cape Arena. Is that it? [1:54:50] Speaker N (unidentified): it i'll second it [1:54:59] Speaker O (unidentified): counselor swayze yes counselor anderson yes counselor harriman yes counselor jordan yes counselor thompson no counselor sarbeck yes chair cypress yes. [1:55:23] Speaker A (unidentified): So Pat will work on scheduling with the town attorney. And now to item 8B, Shore Road Parking District. We're going to get a report from the Traffic Safety Working Group. The town council requested a review and report from the Traffic Safety Working Group on the safety aspects of the first summer season of the Shore Road Parking District ordinance changes that took effect on May 1st, 2026. The Traffic Safety Working Group held a public meeting on October 14th, 2026. The working group discussion results and public feedback are provided to Council for review and to inform any further changes to the traffic ordinance. ordinance. You will notice that we are not voting on anything tonight, but we will have [1:56:27] Speaker J (unidentified): the... Unless you wanted to accept the report. [1:56:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, correct, but we're not sending anything to ordinance tonight. I just want to make that clear to the public. Are there any members of the public that wish to comment on this item tonight in the chamber or online? Chris [1:56:55] Speaker R (unidentified): Gorski, 36 Cliff Avenue. I will say that in our neighborhood, I live in this neighborhood and I think there's agreement amongst most of the neighbors that they're very happy with the progress that's been made on that road and they've also seen or they've also had a bunch of opinions on things that could be improved. for instance people mentioned that hey in Portland we have signs that say commercial vehicles only from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. could we put that on shore road so that commercial vehicles could park other than that I think the biggest concern on that road is the area near Rosemont and the cookie jar I think there was a girl maybe two years ago she had a skull fracture from an accident on that road that area of the road there's a problem with speeding cars coming around a corner from South Portland and I think that will require some coordination with the city of South Portland and addressing that problem I don't think that it's something that Cape Elizabeth can do alone so but thank you for the work that you've done the situation with the beach and safety on that road has improved and everyone's appreciative in that in that area. Okay [1:58:18] Speaker J (unidentified): thank you. Thank you. [1:58:28] Speaker V (unidentified): Hello again. Tom McColka for Mountain View Road. I'd like to say the same thing that Mr. Gorski said that the change that we've seen in those neighborhoods has really been fantastic this year. The kind of the change in the safety, the amount of traffic moving through the neighborhoods. So we really believe that we should leave things the way they are I did read through this deck that was put together by the committee and there was some mention of a town council member or two interested in parking on Shore Road I would really caution that adding back any parking to Shore Road is just going to create the competition that we saw for parking just with a smaller number of spots and so you'll have people driving out of Portland or other towns to find the five slots, let's say, that you might consider putting on Shore Road, and they're just going to compete for those five slots. And so all the dangerous activities that we saw happening when it was 70 cars or 50 cars will now be concentrated around a small center of slots. The people that drive out to find those slots and find them full are just going to find a way to try and park in the neighborhoods, and then we're going to be calling the police to come take care of those things. So I really think that opens Pandera's box if we try and put parking again back on Shore Road. I did see, if there is going to be some discussion from the council members on putting parking back on Shore Road, I'd like to understand a little bit more where that's coming from. What's the data behind that? there's a slide that shows kind of five areas that people emailed the council about but there's really no indication of the amount of feedback from each one of those areas it looks like they're all treated the same and so it's hard to tell from that slide what's what's the major message coming out of out of the neighborhoods because there's no data there. And then lastly, I know there was looking at expanding the resident parking only area. I do think some of the streets that are outside of the area that was created are now seeing the impact of people parking in those areas because they can't park in the areas that they used to. I think we should also be protecting that part of our town as well and adding the same residence only parking signs in that part in those parts of the neighborhood so thank you for your time i look forward to seeing what this discussion looks [2:01:10] Speaker A (unidentified): like thank you are there any other members of the public that would like to speak on this item [2:01:31] Speaker W (unidentified): hi cynthia triano 8 charles road i want to start by saying i'm absolutely appalled by the lack of leadership and accountability regarding cliff house beach and the safety of our neighborhood At a recent town council meeting, Chair Seyfried, you introduced the idea or mentioned that you were wondering if there was a possibility to bring groups of five or so cars safely back up into Shore Road. It appears that you don't really have a full understanding of why the ordinance was passed in the first place. It's because it was a major safety hazard. I feel that comment should have been shut down immediately. Immediately, instead, that very same idea was regurgitated a few weeks later at the Traffic Safety Working Group, ironically right after everyone in the audience said how much safer Shore Road is. So let's get this straight. We've spent four years trying to get the town's attention. We finally do. The Shore Road 1 ordinance gets passed, and now eight months later, we have two town officials floating the idea of putting parking back up onto Shore Road. Are we running a town government here? Are we actively trying to tank the safety of our own neighborhoods? I've never witnessed town officials more tone deaf. How many times is the town going to shift the problem around instead of solving it? It went from Seaview, Glen, and Crescent to Shore, then to Preble, and now over the line into South Portland neighborhoods. All three of those streets, Seaview, Glen, and Crescent, are protected streets in the deed that the town, you, agreed to maintain as safe and passable, which they are not. Just because the problem has now been funneled onto Preble Street doesn't change the town's duty to honor the restrictive covenant and the deed. The problem originated on protected streets and it's now been forced onto non-protected streets. It's the exact same identical problem caused by the exact same identical people, non-residents and tourists. The town spends countless hours worrying about where non-residents are going to park when you should be worrying about how the hell you're going to fix this mess. By allowing this madness to continue, you, the town is doing the exact opposite of what the grantor intended. You've changed the historical access from foot and bike traffic to hundreds of cars. You've changed the original intended scope of use from a neighborhood asset to a free-for-all for hundreds of non-residents and tourists who land on our residential side streets that simply cannot handle them. Just because the problem now happens to be on Preble, because you failed to include Preble Street and Woodland Road in the ordinance doesn't change the town's duty to honor and uphold the restrictive covenant in the deed the problem originated on protected streets it's now been forced onto non-protected streets it's the exact same identical problem caused by the exact same identical people non-residents and tourists as i previously pointed out the town agreed to maintain these streets as safe and passable when accepted this parcel of land and you are in breach of that duty because they are not safe or passable. This summer, Preble Street was a disaster. You know it was a disaster because I provided the town council with countless videos showing that it was a disaster. Yet, somehow, the Traffic Safety Working Group can't unanimously agree to recommend to the town council to make the east side of Preble Street resident-only parking. I'm very confused by this. At that meeting, they had no problem agreeing that the emergency no parking ban on the west side of Preble needed to be permanent, but you couldn't agree to protect the residential east side where all the inconvenience residents actually live. How is that even possible? Protecting the side of the street where no one lives. More than three minutes. [2:05:16] Speaker X (unidentified): Tony Owens, 19 Seaview Avenue. A little more than four hours ago, if you look at this picture, I was biking on the right lane heading in towards South Portland as I do many days of the year. A few years ago, I had an accident just a little further towards Fort Williams that resulted in a fracture of my neck on my bicycle. The improvements that have been made on Shore Road have made it infinitely safer. You imagine putting a car on the right hand lane here, and I'm biking there, and I come up to the car. First of all, I have to move into the travel lane to get around the car. and then what happens if that person opens the door while I'm trying to stay close to the car and not get in too far in the travel lane I'd end up in the front seat of that car I don't need any more accidents last month at the traffic safety meeting the Jay Reynolds presented data I believe showing the monitoring of speed on Shore Road, and I think he said that 85% of the cars comply with the speed limit, 15% of the cars go too fast, and I ask you to pick up your copy of the Cape Courier and see the last time we issued a speeding ticket on Shore Road. It just doesn't happen. One of the things in addition to parking that we could do to make this road even safer still is to enforce the speed limit on Shore Road. if you leave this meeting tonight and you drive back towards the cookie jar at 30 miles an hour you'll have a lot of cars behind you it happens to me every time I'm on Shore Road so I think we should go back to public safety and say enforce the speed limit write some tickets you wrote over 200 parking tickets for people parking but not one speeding ticket on Shore Road so I would I would maintain no parking on Shore Road, as we have. It was wonderfully safe, and everybody's been happy about that, you've heard from. And also, I would get back to the town public safety people about enforcing the speed limit on Shore Road, which just doesn't happen. [2:07:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Are there any other members of the public, either in the chamber or online, that wish to speak on this item? Seeing none, I'm going to ask to. either Pat or counselor, okay, yeah, take it away. All right so [2:08:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Essentially, so we did have a traffic safety working group meeting notices went out to the Shore Road District regarding that meeting it was during daytime hours, but it was fairly well attended I'm gonna run through that I adapted that presentation to sort of be the report to council But recognizing that this would still get referred to ordinance committee, have public meetings there, come back to council, have a public hearing. I'm going to go pretty quickly through this. I will stop on any slide, but I'm going to hit the highlight from sort of each slide and try to summarize where the Traffic Safety Working Group ended up. So stop me if I am going too fast, but what we did, Traffic Safety Working Group looked We looked at the timeline of the infrastructure improvements before and after the setup of this, the resident parking zone, looked at the permitting that we had put in place, some enforcement, some safety data from signs and state available materials, a feedback summary, which we'll get to, and then the next steps that the Traffic Safety Working Group wanted to recommend to the council. So we tried to lay out the timeline of everything that happened between June of 2025 and June of 2026 regarding temporary stripings and repaving just so those milestones would be captured to compare to the speed data to see what potentially had different influences on speed. We did issue 220 homes the two guest passes each per the new ordinance those were mailed out we'll probably stick with that process each year just so council is aware just because it does keep the residents of that district from having to come to town hall an extra time and it does keep staff can just kind of get them all out at one time versus interrupting daily duties to issue them the provision we put in for the 10 the guest passes of the sorry event passes that residents within the area would be able to get for say a birthday party a graduation any sort of event at their home we kind of thought that would be a heavy heavily utilized tool I think when we put it in place however only ten people took advantage of that so that was not that was one outcome of this first year was that was not a heavily utilized tool within the district only ten people did that we are looking since recycling center stickers are kind of becoming more and more important they get you into the recycling center but they also get you park in at fort williams they get you parking within this zone and any zone set up in the future for other neighborhoods we will be updating those to make sure that everyone that has those should have them there are people who move out of town they still have them on their car they haven't been updated in quite a while so we've been looking at new stickers in 2027 and a way to distribute those and keep them on a sort of two or three year cycle to get a new color so that it stays relevant we did summarize there were 650 calls for service you can see that really it was Seaview Ave or Cliff House Beach referenced in the call for service and then it sort of went out and the further you get from the beach the less calls per actual specific roadway which kind of kind of makes sense I think if we if we think about how that would work The police department walked through and talked about their, they did issue 225 tickets. They had far more actual interactions. This was done through four-hour parking overtime shifts. It's really not something that can be accommodated within all of the services that the limited staff have to cover during their normal shifts. so those 28 shifts totaled about an additional $7,800 in cost to the police department operating budget just for future reference if we either expand to multiple zones or want to do more or less enforcement we can discuss that during I imagine when this ordinance gets revisited or during the budget cycle these were set up sort of on a weekly basis looking at tide schedules, weather forecast for the coming week, tried to make sure there was no predictability. It wasn't done at the same time every week so that someone could just say, oh, the police are gone, they won't be back for the next four days. So it was tied to weather and expected beach use, as well as some randomness thrown in. Most of them did fall on the weekends. So luckily, the police staffing did allow for them to fill these overtime shifts. So, then we looked at crash and accident history. Those come through the state. I mean, they do rely on local police reports, but then they get tied to data locations throughout the state and throughout the region. We looked at traffic volumes, which are measured annually. Our speed sign measures traffic volumes and speeds, as well as the state tries to get around to major road networks and update traffic data so 2024 25 and 26 you can see 24 there were there were four total accidents three in 25 one that has been entered into the system as of 26 Some of these have data points on them of locations of the accidents within the district as they were reported through the state system. Traffic volumes, these are some of the data points that were available on Shore Road as well as Preble and I think a couple other side streets. So on Shore Road you can see, I mean, we always hear sort of feedback on what traffic has done over the years, but you can see traffic volume has actually stayed, I would say, fairly consistent since 2010, and actually in the most recent one dropped below a couple of the higher years. This doesn't take into account size or type of vehicle or anything like that, just total vehicle count. this was just some more detail on the traffic volume and direction of flow and time of day what's hard to quantify is how much seasonal when you go back to either the count or the time of day is not knowing exactly how much seasonality plays into that so it's kind of you know at a moment of time and then you apply some factors to try to account for seasonality Preble Street You can see, I'm not sure what traffic patterns really changed in that interior neighborhood or perhaps getting over to SMCC area, but you can see traffic volumes on that road actually have dropped over the last decade or more. And then we did have some on Cottage Farm Road, but it was just a single, so you can see 368 vehicles a day. That was just a single traffic count. so 85th percentile, the reason we put this slide in is just a lot of people say, why don't you lower the speed limit? Why don't you raise the speed limit? Whatever it might be. The state's general, the state and a lot of like federal highway guidance is they will often take into account if 85% of whatever the speed, the 85th percentile speed is that's traveling the road safely will often be factored into what the speed limit is set at. so i have seen speed limits you don't just get to set an artificially low speed limit for a road because you want people to go 25 if the road is designed to accommodate 35 or 40 then that's kind of what that's what it's going to be set to so just that was just put in kind of as informational because when people do their own research or come across how speed limits are set you'll see this 85th percentile referenced often so this was interesting this was from the speed sign that gives you the thumbs up when you're doing well and makes you feel good and sometimes blinks at you or yells at you a little bit if you're not so we had date ranges before and after the summer tried to use the same period the summer before the new ordinance went into effect and this summer with the ordinance into effect so you can see speeds did go up slightly not that unusual if you clear a roadway out and make it feel wider because it's not as congested or there's not as many cars or people or bikes, cars are going to just naturally drive faster. So to get back to those speeds, you have to look at some artificial sort of traffic calming. That's where islands, bump outs, painting lanes narrower, those type of things come into play. But vehicles parked on the side of the road is a natural deterrent to higher travel speeds. You can see total vehicle counts were similar. What was the second? I'm just looking at the lower. That was a one and two month. So one was just a longer duration. So you got a one month on the upper one and the two month totals, but similar patterns. This slide, as I said, at the traffic safety group was full disclosure. This was taking the 100, 150 plus emails that have come in related to this to either the council or the traffic safety group and just allowing Gemini AI to just give me the top five topics if you could put all of these emails into topics. These are the things that were said to a residence point earlier. No, it doesn't have the number of each because some emails referenced sort of a mix of these, but I felt like it was still relevant to the things that we were hearing. Support for parking restrictions and the safety improvements that have come from it. Concerns over displacement to other streets, which we all had throughout all of the discussions regarding this. Requests for enforcement and signage changes. Those were mostly early on. That was signs in front of someone's window, maybe blocking an area that they typically park or have a visitor park in front of their house. and then just enforcement of various components of the new ordinance we know as we had public meetings on the concerns over limited commercial and contractor access that was certainly conveyed to staff as well during some of the visits for permits or to get passes and there were some sprinkled in they were not as widely spread as the ones of the, you know, glad that we had implemented it, but there were still people that would occasionally say, I would like a more balanced approach of not having blanket vans on Shore Road. There were a number of residents initially that came in to the code office to get passes that thought that if they had a pass, it meant that they could park on Shore Road. So that was just sort of a education piece for those that owned on Shore Road that didn't that wasn't a pass to park on Shore Road these were some items we discussed at the meeting at the traffic safety meeting was just mailing the guest passes Seemed to work well for staff and for customers so we would continue and for the residents that would work well to continue that practice. Event passes were not heavily utilized. If you do look to rewrite the ordinance, you may want to see if that's worth keeping in or if that needs some revisions. Overtime shifts would still be necessary to continue the level of enforcement we did this year next year. Better delineation of the crosswalk parking buffer is certainly recognized as a need, so we need to get some more line striping. We did a lot of line striping week to week to sort of adapt to what we were seeing for driver behavior. We would not have expected the cars to block driveways quite the way they did. They don't do it in other areas, so that was a little bit of a surprise. Led us to have to do some more line striping. So I think we have a better idea of heading into the spring what we would want to add for line striping unless the ordinance changes again. in contractors one thing that might address that staff bounced around that might address parking issues within the neighborhood streets would be if you wanted to consider issuing some passes with a building permit because i did get direct calls from contractors saying where can i park can i pay a permit fee can i pay a fee to park on the road like what do i what do i do and one or two not many but one or two said well i'm just gonna have to tell the client that i'll be back after october and that's the only time i could get their project done so we all know how hard it is to find a contractor but i didn't hear that was very early on in the process i didn't hear a lot of that throughout the whole summer and we didn't hear any of that at the traffic safety meeting from residents so but that would be one way to maybe attach it to some building permits or something for major renovations so comments at i mean again this is a quick summary there were probably 25 or 30 people roughly that sound about right to anyone that was there on the 14th or about 25 i don't have the exact count but there were say 25 or 30 people there a lot of comments a lot of agreement on the safety and visibility improvements at crosswalks driveways and side streets bicycle and pedestrian hazards people are still certainly prioritizing the non-motorized vehicle or means of transportation and how important it is to keep addressing the safety issues they even though the cars were gone there were still issues with those modes of transportation and I think there were some interesting points of just, like, this isn't necessarily, that road doesn't see the bike traffic, it's not a major, like, professional biking route, if you will, it gets a lot of tourists, it gets a lot of people maybe renting a bike, or borrowing a bike, or that aren't necessarily biking this area on a regular basis, so that is an interesting sort of, I think, demographic observation, that being the high tourist route to Fort Williams, it does get less experienced bikers than some routes might a lot of requests for traffic enforcement and speed control as we see throughout the community in the region parking regulation adjustments I would say the general feedback of the during the traffic safety meeting was positive and took on a more negative and cautionary tone when we got into potentially adding any parking back on Shore Road expansion of the district boundaries several people did there were several comments looking to making requests to extend those to other streets within Cape Elizabeth on the South Portland line this was just a slide that we had in the original thing so that people would understand what it was that the council was tasking the traffic safety group with versus what is more of a council level decision and then we due to the council requests we showed what a section of like the shore what a section of shore road would look like with engineered design parking bays this goes back to the design that is not being proposed in full but it was an example of sections of shore road that would if you did introduce parking bays creating bump outs or islands to keep them still further away from driveways or crosswalks we didn't get into if the council we didn't get in there are some stretches where you have more visibility than others we agreed that if any parking bays went back it would likely be on the sidewalk side being sort of the wider side with less access points but we didn't define one or make a recommendation that you do add one back again the consideration of woodland and prebble does have did have parking on both sides to start the season the myself and the police chief just put in the 90-day order to eliminate parking on the inland non-ocean side which did improve traffic flow one of our recommendations is to make sure you keep that in place if you make ordinance changes so that it's a permanent change for safety purposes whether the vehicles parked on the other side of the road are resident or non-resident did not seen within the purview of traffic safety as long as the driveways and crosswalks are better marked for to make sure cars leave the space that is appropriate so final recommendations from the committee were to make pebble street a temporary no parking permanent on the west side the committee would not advise adding more crosswalk locations back to that crossing shore road unless some other sidewalk network changes are made or some traffic calming steps within shore road but not just paint lines back where they used to be at non-compliant crosswalks and expansion of the district use of resident parking on additional streets is really not a primary not primarily a traffic safety within the neighborhood streets because we still do allow cars to park there so just i would understand i think the whole committee would understand if the council went down the path of designating a few more streets it just wasn't really the purview of the traffic safety group so that was it hopefully that is some useful information for whatever next steps you take stephanie [2:27:33] Speaker N (unidentified): could we go back to the parking bay so what is what is a parking bay [2:27:44] Speaker F (unidentified): let me when i say a parking bay i mean so here you have a road access and let's just say this one's a driveway access i can't read it on my screen as well but between this bump out and this bump out here you have this indented area where you could fit four or five cars that's a very typical more urban layout in an area where you have curb on both sides of the road and sidewalks and crosswalks to what it does is the bump outs shorten any crosswalk distance that you do put in and the parking bay gives some protection if you wanted to put those back obviously with the level of biking on there you'd want to say could you still maintain a travel lane and a bike lane or are you actually sacrificing a bike lane to get the parking in there are places where you could probably accommodate both the bike lane and parking but you couldn't do that along the whole stretch so again could they be engineered to fit sure anytime you mix there was a lot of comment and there is a lot of any time if you remove cars pedestrians or bikes any road becomes safer for the other modes of transportation so there's no question that when we get into is it safer with or without cars i mean we all know the when you increase volume and you increase multimodal transportation you're increasing the risk for any mode of that of transportation so but can it be done can it be engineered is it done other places sure is it the highest and best use of this roadway i'm not sure that it's i can't say that from a traffic safety standpoint we'd recommend yes put cars back but you could put them back i guess it's the only way to put it yeah it seems that it's just [2:29:41] Speaker N (unidentified): unraveling the decision that we already made right I mean a parking bay I mean they're parking spaces basically same thing yeah just yeah it's just parking [2:29:54] Speaker F (unidentified): spaces if you were gonna put parking spaces in you'd want to sort of protect them or keep them exactly where you want them and not have it spill over so that's where you might do some of the traffic calming stuff like islands or [2:30:06] Speaker G (unidentified): bump outs as you call them you not only do questioning where we would ever want to do that from a safety standpoint but when you look at the kind of financial challenges we have facing us in the next few years that wouldn't be cheap either to do those with a path to accommodate you know to do a bump out to put in four parking spots probably wouldn't be too [2:30:32] Speaker F (unidentified): inexpensive no whatever we do for a permanent design along shore road is going to be expensive I mean, it still needs some traffic calming. It still needs ways to accommodate people crossing the street safer. So it needs a major treatment in the coming years. [2:30:48] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah, I agree with that. [2:30:54] Speaker M (unidentified): Andrew? Yeah, while I think that these recommendations are going to have to go to ordinance, I think we should also begin to have the discussion about what the Finance Committee needs to do in regards to that section of Shore Road. in particular traffic calming I've had a lot of discussions with people about why can't we put in a crosswalk state law says we have to have a landing for either end of the crosswalk so while we have a sidewalk on the Atlantic side of the road we don't have one on the inland side of the road there's no there's no landing for the sidewalk to land on so and ADA compliance and all those other things so you have to have a spot where there's a ramp and all that other stuff so until we can start to discuss what we're going to do with that section financially to get a sidewalk in on the inland side yeah we're not going to be able to do any of the other traffic calming and safety improvements that we want so yeah we should start approaching that topic big [2:32:04] Speaker G (unidentified): it's big at the last few mma meetings this is a big conversation because all the towns are being asked to do this and nobody has any money for it so trying to get any grants there's going to be a lot of competition going after any kind of state grant money for this because everybody's trying to figure out how they're going to pay for it i [2:32:27] Speaker F (unidentified): may because it's it's related and i just want to convey that i have been trying to send this message is with regard to some of the requests from trundy that has been on a traffic safety working group agenda and we did try to make some temporary no parking much like what we did on one side of prebble to ease the traffic flow and i have urged my suggestion i guess to residents in that area that have approached me was we're just finishing up the first year of the shore road parking why don't you wait and see what comes of that and then before it goes through the full ordinance change try to have if you're going to make ordinance changes and you want to add another neighborhood rather than go through the three meeting process to change the ordinance twice change it once so now would be the time this is the time i sort of kept pointing to from about mid july late july early august on to start addressing now that we've sort of figured out what shore road is and what it isn't what it did what it didn't do what it solved what it didn't solve now would be the time to say do you want to do the same thing in another neighborhood [2:33:44] Speaker A (unidentified): i'm gonna if you are wanting to still talk about this report before we maybe talk about Traffic safety needing to talk about Trundy and I'm certainly not trying to add a new agenda item [2:34:01] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm just saying like if when you refer it to ordinance committee or if you want to bring it back You'd probably want to do it in this round of ordinance changes not Complete that a hundred percent through all the public hearings and then start again [2:34:14] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay, I guess What actually I know what I was going to say. I don't guess what I was going to say Number one, this is about accepting the report. Number two, we had talked about, once we had data, we were going to look at what ordinance changes we might want to tweak around here. Number three is, you said probably about an hour and a half ago that Reef Road and Trundy and Shore Acres would come up here in this conversation. I think my question is, so where does it come up because so far, unless what we're saying is what we've learned here can be extrapolated and overlaid with the happenings in Shore Acres. So that's a question. So [2:35:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm going to just chime in on this particular report and then let Pat try to answer some questions. I want people to understand that sometimes we have to do exercises in order to see what works and doesn't work. And so I think it's only fair, and it feels frustrating to some people, I think I did ask to see what it would look like it didn't mean that this is what i want it means that in order to make an informed decision we have to ask the question and look at the answers and look at what does it mean what could the cost be right counselor thompson brings that up what you know what is it what are the safety impacts what are the what are the other impacts it was a suggestion of residents from Preble frankly who were saying you know if you had a little parking back on shore it would perhaps ease our burden so it's not it's not out of nowhere doesn't mean that the council is supporting it means that we were we asked a question and so I just need the public to understand that we need to investigate it's it's our duty so that's part of the issue, which I appreciate that Traffic Safety did what we asked them to do. And then we're going to accept this report and reflect on it. And then we're going to make our suggestions and refer it to ordinance. So the one thing that about this particular set of ordinances that is concerning to me, and it's something that newly elected Councillor Gorski brought up, is currently we have an ordinance that does not allow for commercial plates, essentially, for people who are doing business on Shore Road to park there. And what we're doing is we're telling the police to ignore the ordinance. And I am not comfortable with doing that for another day. And I don't think it's appropriate to say that we welcome business, that we're supporting business owners, and then we say, but you can't park here. So I think we have to sort that one out. I think we figured it, or it sounds like we figured it out for the side streets to a degree, and I'm hopeful that there's that option for them to register and get, you know, when other building permits are coming that maybe they get, you know, a permit for parking on the side streets as necessary. We have to figure something out for Shore Road and those business owners. And hopefully when we do refer it to ordinance, we will charge ordinance with, like, this has to be solved. You know, there was a suggestion by Mr. Gorski that, you know, there's a time limit. That's a possibility. I don't know if a big, long trailer is parked close to the end of a road that all of a sudden changes the sight line. So maybe there needs to be, like, a commercial zone. I don't know, but there is an issue there, and that is an issue that I think a lot of other counselors agree with as far as these are businesses that need to conduct business in those homes and aren't always able to get into the driveway. So that's sort of where my thinking is. But again, we need to reflect on this, think about it, come back. We will have a motion coming soon to send it to ordinance. And then I'm going to refer back to what Manager Fox just said, which is when we change ordinances in general, it's a pretty involved process. There are multiple meetings, there are public hearings, and that's even at the ordinance level, and it comes to the town council, we have public hearings, whatever, so it's a pretty involved process. So I am hopeful, and it is my understanding that traffic safety will be looking at, am I correct, that traffic safety will be looking at the Trundy Reef Road area in an upcoming meeting before we... [2:39:54] Speaker F (unidentified): And we, and Councillor Swayze, correct me if I'm wrong, we did and we talked through it and we made some changes on Reef Road from a traffic safety standpoint to make it so cars could get through. It was a temporary action, so that would have to be. but as far as whether it's residents or the number of cars you want parked on trundy due to the use of the preserve and the and the natural area at some point it's just a policy decision and not a traffic safety right because so traffic safe we have roads that narrow that have cars parked on one side i probably would not i wouldn't advise having cars parked on both sides but it's you know there is there are roads that have parking on one side when they're 20 feet wide we allow it several neighborhoods so I don't know if you want traffic safety to do something with it we certainly can try as a working group but it's when you get into the resident component of it that's more of [2:41:04] Speaker A (unidentified): a no and i understand policy level parking is not a safety issue because it's a car it's parked it doesn't matter who drove it there but i think it would be appropriate if there is any more investigation or commentary to come from traffic safety from that perspective that would be good for the council to hear before we make a policy decision about caring who has parked the car as a where they live right I'm just trying to be mindful comes from traffic safety right I said the safety side of this issue comes hopefully from traffic [2:41:43] Speaker M (unidentified): safety I mean I could tell you right now that Pat and Chief Fenton would almost certainly say okay go to ordinance oh yeah the photos that I saw from trinity point are just nuts and when i've seen it in person it's just nuts and then we got that letter from the self director saying it's nuts so i mean yeah from a traffic safety like yeah it's cars can't get through but it's still going to be an ordinance change to say you can't park here at all so i'm not sure what else we would say other than a recommendation go to ordinance so with you know i don't know about that 's where i won't speak for chief fenton [2:42:41] Speaker A (unidentified): or anybody but you know that's all i'm saying that's my point right the recommendation hasn't come to us yet that's all i'm saying we can yeah we can add it i'm trying to be mindful of [2:42:52] Speaker F (unidentified): there are a lot of residents that have done a lot of work, approached you, approached traffic safety, gone to traffic safety meeting that we had. If we start sending out 200 notices for them to come to a traffic safety meeting when all we're going to say is the road would be safer with cars on one side and not both, but how many cars and whether you want to limit it by residency really then falls separate. I'm just trying to maybe help streamline that one since we're talking a lot of the same themes as we've already addressed in the other zone when you're talking about large amounts of cars trying to access a small coastal beach or preserve area I just don't know that we would set reasonable expectations I don't know that the traffic safety working group is going to arrive at an outcome that is going to either better inform the council or help the residents reach a resolution so in the interest of streamlining it the chief is available i'm available the other kind of public works is i just don't know that running it back through that and having us public notice a meeting is going to get us to a place that's any different than just tackling it make [2:44:03] Speaker A (unidentified): sure that the residents feel heard i it felt like they hadn't been heard at traffic safety [2:44:09] Speaker I (unidentified): and so can someone summarize what the action is you guys had a bunch of conversation can somebody synthesize it as to what the action is relative to trending? [2:44:22] Speaker G (unidentified): Would it need to be an ordinance change for us to just basically say that we're going to treat that similar to how we've treated the side streets off of shore? Yes. So that would... [2:44:34] Speaker F (unidentified): You'd have to set up a new parking district. The template's there. And that's why I was saying, like, the closer our shore road one is to Dunn in the way that we feel like we want to leave it for several years... then you now have a template to apply to. So we have Shore Road Parking District 1. You could quickly duplicate that with a different map, different limits, and create your trendy parking zone. [2:45:00] Speaker G (unidentified): With a similar kind of May 1 to October, whatever it is, resident-only parking. [2:45:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think that was the stuff to work through that is sort of at a place where I think heading towards, like, yes, that's how we want to keep it. Now you can roll that into other neighborhoods if you choose to. I just don't think the traffic safety working group has a big role in that and I don't want to. That would be ordinance right? It's just yeah it's just the ordinance changed to say I want to create this district over here as well and then it comes down to the limits of it because what you're gonna do is you're gonna set a limit and we now know from Shore Road that cars are gonna park beyond that limit in front of new houses that haven't had cars park in front of them before and it's gonna have that same ripple effect it's what it's what we've watched happen down there with every iteration it's going to happen wherever you do it so the question is do you just keep making the zone big enough that no one will walk to the resource or and those are the things that are just not they're just not something but we can [2:45:56] Speaker G (unidentified): use our experience that we've had on shore road and all those side roads treat it treat that whole trendy area similarly yeah and i think that they would certainly feel like we've made a major step forward if we went ahead and said let's send this to ordinance and have them come up with some kind of a guidance I mean the ordinance committee people are on that in this group so they've got a pretty good idea of what we'd like to what the outcome could look like and the outcome should look similar to how we've [2:46:24] Speaker A (unidentified): treated Shore Road Jonathan thanks yeah [2:46:34] Speaker H (unidentified): my request would be for the next meeting that we have an item on the agenda that sends the information that we received around the shore road parking area send that to the ordinance committee as well as the trendy area send that to the ordinance committee as well it sounds like the traffic safety group has done a great job addressing this hearing from the public and as andrew said it's sort of there's really not too much more that they can do from a traffic safety standpoint that is coming to a policy decision and as we know the ordinance committee kind of looks at it first before sending a recommendation back to the council so I hope would be for the next meeting that we'd have both items as a referral to the ordinance [2:47:19] Speaker J (unidentified): committee yeah thank you noted all right there [2:47:30] Speaker A (unidentified): is a possible motion to accept this report so would we like to accept the report all right this is written all right any further discussion we need a roll call [2:47:49] Speaker O (unidentified): Councilor Sweeney? Councilor Anderson? Yes. Councilor Harriman? Yes. Councilor Jordan? [2:47:59] Speaker I (unidentified): Sorry, you mean Harriman. [2:48:02] Speaker O (unidentified): I said Harriman and you answered for Harriman. [2:48:04] Speaker I (unidentified): I thought you said Jordan, sorry. [2:48:07] Speaker O (unidentified): Councilor Harriman? I'm here. Okay. Yes. Councilor Thompson? Yes. Councilor Sarbeck? Yes. Chair Seifried? Yes. [2:48:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, moving on to item 8C, Cumberland County Emergency Management Mutual Aid Agreement. The Cumberland County Emergency Management Agency has established a mutual aid agreement for participating municipalities to utilize during localized or regional emergencies that exceed the capabilities of a single jurisdiction. Are there any members of the public, either online or in the chamber, that wish to speak on this item? Okay. Seeing none, may I have a motion, please? Tim. [2:49:02] Speaker G (unidentified): I order that Cape Elizabeth Town Council authorizes the town manager to enter into the mutual aid agreement managed by the Cumberland County Emergency Management Agency. Second. [2:49:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Jonathan, second. Pat, would you be willing to give us just a quick little background on this? [2:49:22] Speaker E (unidentified): [2:49:24] Speaker F (unidentified): yes this is just this is kind of a way to memorialize things that already happen you know communities trying to share resources it just offers a little protection to that community that's willing to share a front-end loader when the neighboring community had a disaster that they might not have had and they don't need that resource at that exact time so pretty standard for counties to kind of step in and say hey we'll we'll help be that facilitator to get resources where they need to go so it's it's great for us especially when you consider we're a small community with limited staffs compared to our neighbors so we're more likely probably to benefit from receiving services from communities that about us then actually having to send services to communities that about us so I think it's a great agreement to have so everybody knows what the what the rules are to the game when it happens any questions or discussion [2:50:21] Speaker N (unidentified): just click we didn't have a written agreement before i don't i don't know if there's older [2:50:28] Speaker F (unidentified): versions of this but this was circulated and several municipalities have adopted it within the last year or so and we just hadn't we hadn't formalized this yet here so [2:50:45] Speaker A (unidentified): any further discussion or questions all right you may have a roll call please counselor swayze yes counselor anderson [2:50:52] Speaker O (unidentified): yes counselor harriman can [2:50:59] Speaker J (unidentified): she speak you [2:51:04] Speaker U (unidentified): keep forgetting about me yes i usually only have to [2:51:08] Speaker O (unidentified): push the button once counselor jordan yes counselor thompson yes counselor starbeck [2:51:16] Speaker H (unidentified): he's forgetting about me too caitlin yes [2:51:21] Speaker A (unidentified): chair syphries yes okay item 8d at the october 19th 2026 meeting the town council held a public hearing on the paper reduction amendments recommended by the planning board to reduce the volume of paper submissions are there any members of the public either online or in the chamber that wish to speak on this item okay seeing none may have a motion please i move [2:51:56] Speaker N (unidentified): that it's ordered that the cape elizabeth town council approve the paper reduction amendments to [2:52:03] Speaker A (unidentified): chapter 16 and 19 of the town ordinances second any discussion or questions be ready to unmute Mute Caitlin. Roll call, please. Councillor Swayze. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Herrmann. [2:52:22] Speaker O (unidentified): Yes. Councillor Jordan. Yes. Councillor Thompson. Yes. Councillor Sarbeck. Yes. Chair Seyfried. Yes. [2:52:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Item 8E. At the August 10th, 2026 meeting, the Cape Elizabeth Town Council referred to the Planning Board preparation of housing amendments to update the zoning and subdivision ordinances with the state mandatory land use law changes. The Planning Board is also reviewing the 2019 Comprehensive Plan and recommending limited amendments to better align with land use regulations. Located in MRS Title 30-A, Section 4324, are the state minimum requirements for a comprehensive plan. The last section, amendments to adopted plans, requires the same process for citizen participation, public notice, and public hearing for comprehensive plan amendments, as would be followed for a new comprehensive plan. Section 4324 also requires designation of a planning committee to prepare a plan and explicitly allows the planning board to be the designated planning committee. Are there any members of the public either online or in the chamber that wish to speak on this item? Okay. Seeing none, may I have a motion, please? [2:53:50] Speaker M (unidentified): Ordered the Cape Elizabeth Town Council in accordance with MRS Title 30A, Section 4324, designates the Cape Elizabeth Planning Board as the planning committee to prepare limited amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan as a companion to the housing amendments for [2:54:08] Speaker J (unidentified): council consideration i'll second lots of seconds anderson all [2:54:17] Speaker A (unidentified): right discussion or questions about [Speaker I (unidentified): this okay] seeing none we're going to need a roll call counselor swayze yes counselor anderson yes [2:54:33] Speaker O (unidentified): counselor harriman yes counselor jordan yes counselor thompson yes counselor sarbeck [2:54:41] Speaker A (unidentified): yes chair cypress yes thank you okay item 8f the town council referred housing amendments to the planning board at the august 10th 2026 meeting the main office of community affairs housing opportunity program is now accepting grant applications for round three which is the last round from municipalities undertaking ordinance revisions to comply with LD 1829, LD 2173, LD 427, and LD 997. Municipalities are eligible to apply for grants of up to $10,000 to cover the cost of developing ordinance amendments. Are there any members of the public either in the chamber or online that wish to speak on this item seeing none may have a motion please [2:55:39] Speaker M (unidentified): ordered the cape elizabeth town council authorizes staff to submit a grant application for up to ten thousand dollars to the main office of community affairs housing opportunity program for costs associated with the adoption of amendments to comply with state mandated zoning changes in ld 1829 ld 2173 ld L.D. 427 and L.D. 997. Second. [2:56:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Questions or discussion? Yeah, question. [2:56:10] Speaker N (unidentified): I just wonder what the grant application would be for up to $10,000. What would we be asking for, example? [2:56:21] Speaker F (unidentified): For example, if we had to bring on any of our consultants or do any mapping services for, like, if we make any zoning changes,, reprinting ordinances, mostly updates to maps, I would say, and some consulting just to keep us eligible, and we haven't taken advantage of that in the other rounds, I don't believe, so it was just a way to kind of cover those in-house costs. I think we can even submit staff time and get reimbursement, so we would get reimbursed not just for stuff that's going to go directly out to a third party, but for our in-house services as well, I believe, correct? Yeah. I got a head nod from the audience, so yes. [2:57:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Be prepared. Jonathan has his hand up, so he'll be unmuted, and then we'll go to Tim. [2:57:15] Speaker H (unidentified): So, Pat, thanks for that explanation. I think that was a good question from Stephanie. Is this state money that we're applying for? [2:57:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Yep, it's state funds. So this was put together as part of their requiring us to update these ordinances. They put together these small grant packages to assist. Okay. [2:57:38] Speaker G (unidentified): I know we've been very successful. I know Marcy's been really successful at the school side getting some of these grants and I think David's been pretty successful. Do you have staff support to do something like this? Do we have somebody that's kind of becoming a grant specialist? [2:57:55] Speaker F (unidentified): We don't have anyone that has the kind of time to be the grant specialist, but fortunately we have a lot of people that Rachel's really good at the library. Melissa's done it for our safety and wellness program. Maureen does it on a regular basis for culvert environmental, this planning study money. Jay does it for the road paving project we're doing on Shore Road. So it's a collective approach, but, yeah, we're trying to consolidate our resources as best we can. [2:58:25] Speaker G (unidentified): It's really great, yeah. Roll call, please. [2:58:30] Speaker O (unidentified): Councillor Swayze. Yes. Councillor Anderson. Yes. Councillor Harriman. Yes. Councillor Jordan. Yes. Councillor Thompson. Yes. Councillor Sauerbeck. Yes. Councillor, Chair Seifried's side. [2:58:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, thank you. And so, before we adjourn, I think it's really important to take a moment to recognize the contributions of our departing counselors this is our last voting meeting and i really want to pay our respects to our counselors so i want to thank tim for channeling the outstanding experience and talent of our community members and thoughtfully placing volunteers on our boards and committees through your work on appointments as well as for your long-term representation of Cape Elizabeth with the Maine Municipal Association. And Stephanie, thank you for giving your time and formidable writing skills to update council ethics, craft and amend ordinances, help draft policies. Your work to improve policies and procedures through clear, concise communication will leave a lasting mark on this council. there are, there's, there's some counselors that also would like to speak to your contribution. So I'm going to call on Jonathan right now. I know, be ready. [3:00:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Jonathan, I don't know if you can speak. We just got to get Pat quicker on that draw. I know, I know. Yeah. so, counselor Thompson, Tim, I apologize. I couldn't be there tonight, to say this in person but I will say that you're going to be missed a lot on this council I don't think there's many people in this community that care about that give them as much time as you do looking at what you've done in the past you chaired the comprehensive planning committee you were on the housing diversity committee you were on the town facility study committee back many years ago and just your support for this town that's been from coaching your kids to being involved with everything and everything anything that you can get your hands on really demonstrates what community service and public service means and so i hope you understand the respect that all of us have for you and for what you've done and you are going to be missed. As you know, we haven't always seen eye to eye on every single issue, but that doesn't mean that we couldn't ever have a discussion or a laugh after discussions about those topics. So I'm going to miss it next year, and obviously we'll see each other very soon, but I wanted to just make sure you understood how much you're going to be missed and how much I respect you. And just so you know, because I'm sure you're probably wondering, drink the girls soccer team i just got word did win tonight they beat yarmouth unfortunately the boys lost in pks earlier this evening but i figured you would care a lot about that so [3:01:44] Speaker A (unidentified): thanks tim for everything thank you jonathan all right thanks jonathan and now i'm asking [3:01:51] Speaker I (unidentified): counselor jordan i feel so honored to be doing this and i'm going to try not to cry when i do it so stephanie anderson what a ride we have had when you arrived on the town council three years ago things were a bit dicey to say the least and we certainly had some interesting challenges ahead of us ld 2003 housing in the town center schools taxes and a few more i learned early on that you would come to every meeting prepared, having done your homework on every topic on the agenda. And I learned something else, that you're a bulldog. You dig into issues, ask tough questions, and uncover things others might not see. But what I appreciate most is that you are willing to listen, even when someone sees things differently. We certainly haven't agreed on everything. but I come to respect you as one of the best councillors I have worked with. You care deeply about Cape Elizabeth, its residents, its employees. You bring a combination of pragmatism, empathy, fiscal responsibility to the table. I think the expansion of the Senior Tax Relief Program is a wonderful example of those qualities, recognizing that we need to help people stay in their homes while being responsible to our taxpayer dollars. But beyond all the work, one of the things I value most is that we became friends. And that's something I will always cherish. Stephanie, you've made a difference in Cape Elizabeth, and I know you aren't finished making a difference. I fully expect you to keep asking questions, challenging assumptions, and keeping all of us on our toes. And while your seat at the table may be changing, I hope it isn't empty for too long. Thank you, Stephanie, for your service, for your friendship, and for always putting Cape Elizabeth first. [3:04:23] Speaker F (unidentified): it's hard to follow those words to each of you but stephanie and tim i do want to thank you on behalf of staff for your service and time on the council stephanie i'll always associate my memories of working with you as your level of preparedness for every agenda item and it made me be more prepared so i greatly appreciate that and tim the passion you bring to the table is second to none and it just shows your overall love of the community so greatly appreciate working with both of you 'll always be a couple of those counselors that hired me and someday i'll probably be sitting with the i could be sitting with a table of without anyone here that hired me so thank you for that thank you for the opportunity you both went way above and beyond to serve cape elizabeth so i hope you feel fulfilled and enjoyed the journey, and will continue to participate in this great community. So thank you. We have a couple small tokens of our appreciation. They certainly don't measure up to the level of effort you put in, but please accept them. [3:05:55] Speaker I (unidentified): Well, what is it? Do you use some crawl? Oh, nice. I like that. That's nice. [3:06:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Finally, are there any citizens, any members of the public in the chamber or online that would like to speak on items not on the agenda. [3:06:36] Speaker P (unidentified): Christian Parker, 33 Reef Road. I always get very nervous when I have to do public speaking. No matter what, I just... I just wanted to make sure that it was all covered, that the other book I gave was very definitive with all the information, that wasn't collected back in 22 when the police were asked to go through. I've read the memorandum multiple times. There was three occasions, there was over 20 cars. It didn't make any sense. I spent my entire summer, much to my husband's dismay, just working on this. Car capacity, I went and spoke to the rangers at all the parks. Crescent State Beach only hit maximum capacity at three times, and they have 600 parking spots. What's going on at Trinity is just horrible. The defecation happening down there, dog poop all over the place, the garbage, the nudity. people going to i mean we're a nice neighborhood and it went from just that cut out to all of a sudden the wild west it doesn't work for us i mean we're not happy about it but i just wanted to make sure in there i just explained on the one side about my contact points what i was doing where i was trying to go i was following the path that i was told to i get very upset when it goes well i had to talk by october 1st in order to get rounded up into chapter 13 and then i'm told no now we have to wait for new council to come on and that starts at ground zero again where i have to start explaining myself all over again which is super frustrating but in here is also the letter of support from self i've had multiple conversations with david and the land trust is appalled at what's going on there too and people need to understand this is not a public beach is a nature preserve that is completely enclosed in a small neighborhood one way in one way out and it's not working for us i just want to make sure i'm very clear about i provided all the information on so many fronts how this just doesn't work and not being addressed it gets worse every year so that's all thank you all [3:08:49] Speaker A (unidentified): right may have the last motion of the night please [3:08:53] Speaker I (unidentified): caitlin you're on mute motion [3:09:00] Speaker U (unidentified): to adjourn thank you pat second. [3:09:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Everybody seconded. Okay, we're going to need a roll call. [3:09:09] Speaker O (unidentified): Okay. Councillor Swayze? Yes. Councillor Anderson? Yes. Councillor Harriman? Yes. Councillor Jordan? Yes. Councillor Thompson? Yes. Councillor Sarbeck? Yes. Chair Seifried? Yes. [3:09:26] Speaker U (unidentified): Good night, everyone. Good night, thanks.