Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Unfinished Business
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. Welcome to the October 27th, 2026 meeting of the Cape Elizabeth Zoning Board of Appeals. This meeting will come to order. This is a public proceeding, and unless the board specifically votes to go into executive session, you have the right to hear everything that's being said and to look at all the exhibits that are offered. Please notify the chairperson, myself, if you're unable to hear or see. This board works from a prepared agenda and will be considering tonight's items in the following order, which is roll call, approval of minutes from June 23rd, old business, of which there is none, new business, followed by adjournment. As for the new business being considered, the burden is upon the applicant to demonstrate compliance with the provisions of the applicable ordinance or ordinances. After the board votes on the merits of each project application, it will prepare a written opinion. Because the written opinion may substantially affect any appeal rights and also as a matter of courtesy, the board asks that those attending the meeting with regard to a specific project not leave until the board has taken the second vote adopting the written opinion. Generally speaking, appeals from adverse decisions must be filed with a superior court except as otherwise provided by law within 45 days of this board's decision. Also, to be certain that you preserve your individual right to file any such appeal, You must be certain that this board's record evidences your appearance this evening and the basis for your support or opposition. This is a public proceeding. You have the right to hear and see what is happening. All persons speaking will be asked to first state their name and address or affiliation at the lectern. Are there any questions? All right.
[1:42] Speaker B (unidentified): Let's call the roll. Kevin Just, present.
[1:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Chair Barberi, present.
[1:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Adam Foster-Webster, present.
[1:51] Speaker D (unidentified): Colin Powers, present.
[1:52] Speaker E (unidentified): Chris Gorski, present.
[1:54] Speaker F (unidentified): Michael Bryman, present.
[1:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Looks like Gretchen is... Oh, she's no longer... Oh, that's right. Okay. So we have a quorum. All right. Let's take a look at minutes from last session all the way back in June.
[2:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Just a quick point of order. It looks like we have three people in the waiting room. I don't know if they have given the requisite information or if I'm the only one hearing. It sounds like feedback.
[2:35] Speaker E (unidentified): I can hear it. The humming, you mean? Yeah. It
[2:40] Speaker D (unidentified): sounds like a generator running.
[2:42] Speaker A (unidentified): I think it's an air mover or something.
[2:48] Speaker B (unidentified): I didn't have any comments on the minutes. Okay.
[2:51] Speaker E (unidentified): I am referred to as Christ. Really? You may want to correct that.
[2:56] Speaker A (unidentified): We can correct that. Is that, page two? [Speaker D (unidentified): Page two.] Oh yeah, there we go. Chris Gorski. I don't have any notes.
[3:23] Speaker B (unidentified): Other than that friendly amendment, I would make a motion that we adopt the minutes as written.
New Business
[3:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Alright, we have a motion that's been seconded. All in favor? It's unanimous. the minutes are approved. Alright, first order of business, I would like to propose switching the order of new business. And here, the request of Emanuele Porcelli. Emanuele Porcelli, before the request of Cole and Marjorie Kelly. The request for variance will take a lot longer, and this will be less burdensome for the other applicant. All in favor? Are there any objections, I guess?
[4:22] Speaker B (unidentified): I think it makes all the sense in the world, yep.
[4:24] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, I don't think we actually have to vote on that. All right, so we will start with item B. To hear the request of Emanuela Porcelli, co-owner of the property at 9 Katahdin Road. Map U12, lot 97 for conditional use permit for home business for Pilates classes based on section 19-5-5 of the zoning ordinance. Ben, do you have any insights for us?
[4:52] Speaker G (unidentified): Not very much. Ms. Porcelli came to me a couple months ago with a request to be able to do this from her home. I visited her home, did an inspection there, talked to her about this process, and here we are.
[5:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Fantastic. Emanuela, would you like to take the lectern and walk us through your application, please?
[5:13] Speaker H (unidentified): So,
[5:19] Speaker I (unidentified): good evening everybody. So, my name is Emanuela Porcelli and I live at Show Acres. Thank you for giving this opportunity to present my request to operate this appointment-only Pilates studios in my home. I am a Pilates instructor. I work in two different places. I work at Cape Elizabeth Community Center, I work at the Scarborough Pilates, and I would like to offer some functional movement, private session in my home. The scale of the business is going to be small, it's about up to ten clients a week. So I would think maybe two clients a day, sometimes it might be four, and then the rest of the week will be less so and it's a one-hour session one-on-one so that's not a class it's just one person coming to me and getting functional movement advice and learning otherwise so yes so the property itself doesn't require any changes so not exterior or interior I do have a driveway and that way the client who's going to visit me is going to can't be able to park at the driveway and not on the street yeah so our neighborhood is family-friendly it's nice and quiet I think that my home business is compatible with all the culture that is around and it's not going to change anything on that point yes so that's all thank you for coming here and listening and i just ask respectfully for an approval for my home
[7:18] Speaker A (unidentified): business thank you we may have some questions so yes they have some questions thank you if you'd say at the lectern do
[7:39] Speaker E (unidentified): you have any questions do you have any plans on growing the business past the limits in this document no I don't have time I work on two other places
[7:54] Speaker C (unidentified): what would be your hours of operation excuse me what would be your hours of operation during what period of the day well I work already
[8:07] Speaker I (unidentified): three days and well it depends maybe in the morning and then maybe one an the evening depending on the client so I don't know like Tuesday maybe coming a client at 10 o'clock and then maybe at 1 o'clock I don't think so that people would like to come after 6 so I would say like later afternoon I should maybe say yeah would you be operating on weekends maybe sometimes if a client cannot come because it's just 10 clients a week and i mean it's up to 10 clients it's going to take me time to go to 10 clients a week so depending what their schedule is yeah my
[8:53] Speaker C (unidentified): schedule would there be any signs would you have any signage on the property i have signs no i
[9:14] Speaker F (unidentified): think you may have answered but do you expect that being that it's one person at a time
[9:20] Speaker I (unidentified): correct yes there is place for two but it's just one client who's coming so there's plenty of space any
[9:53] Speaker A (unidentified): other questions for the applicant no questions here no questions all right you may have a seat and we'll deliberate and if we have any further questions we might ask you to come back up okay all right thank Wait, go on as a question. Oh, okay, Ben.
[10:14] Speaker D (unidentified): This isn't section 19-1-3, is that right?
[10:23] Speaker B (unidentified): This is 19-5-5, right?
[10:27] Speaker A (unidentified): In the additional findings of fact.
[10:29] Speaker D (unidentified): That's definitions as far as I can tell.
[10:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, complies with the definition of home business.
[10:34] Speaker G (unidentified): Oh, I see, yeah, I get it.
[10:44] Speaker A (unidentified): I can give some thoughts. I think this is exactly what the ordinance was designed for right it's a small very low impact the kind of thing most people wouldn't bother coming before a board to get approval for right it's exactly the kind of thing that one would do as a hobby or in their own home or with friends but in this case it's a business and as such I think the applicant is doing the right thing by coming before the board and I don't see anything in the application that would give me reason to vote against it. Yeah I agree
[11:31] Speaker B (unidentified): completely this was the entire intent of this ordinance for exactly this sort of thing we probably should just make sure there's no public comment just it's a good thing yeah has there
[11:41] Speaker G (unidentified): there been any public comment? I haven't received any public comments. Any questions from the
[11:48] Speaker A (unidentified): members of the public here? Yes. Yes, please.
[12:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Hi, my name is Kimberly Cripps. I live at [address], kind of diagonally across from Manuela. When I got the notice, I have it here. I wasn't sure what to do, but I guess my concern was, you know, how many cars at a time would this entail? So I guess I'm understanding that it's private lessons, one person per lesson. That part of Katahdin is very short before it comes to Pilot Point. It's also on the downhill slope of Katahdin, which kind of has limited visibility, so cars and parking were a concern that I had in my family. But hearing that it's one client at a time, it kind of makes me feel a little more relieved. I'm just trying to think if there's anything else. that was my main concern the fact that block of Katahdin is short there's not a lot of room for things we do have a stop sign at Katahdin and Pilot but I can tell you a lot of people kind of breeze through it and our neighborhood does have a lot of kids so I was just worried about the impact of more cars coming into the neighborhood because Katahdin is kind of like a thoroughfare to get to pilot point. If you're familiar with the map of the area and that's that's all I have to say. Thank you.
[13:59] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean in regards to that I believe the ordinance specifically states no more than 10 trips a day each client being two trips. So if the maximum is four clients a day you would be under that limit. So there is there is a language in the ordinance that addresses this specifically if that makes you feel any better and then you know parking
[14:25] Speaker C (unidentified): street Joe yeah I mean I agree good project my only question even before he spoke was whether we do want to impose conditions on the amount of car traffic. I know it's written in, but we are entitled to impose conditions. It just seems that as a matter of safety, I guess, both in terms of traffic safety, I suppose, in terms of enforceability, that we should consider limiting this to 10 car trips per
[15:17] Speaker A (unidentified): You think we should add that in? Yes. I mean, even further, do we want to put something in about individual, like separate, non-contiguous visits? Or is there, I don't know what time. So you wouldn't have three clients showing up at once. It would be individual. Is that as written now? I mean obviously the intent isn't but if people are concerned about traffic we could write that into the into the approval
[15:53] Speaker B (unidentified): the ordinance is already though
[15:55] Speaker A (unidentified): ten trips a day right and trips the ordinance is no more than ten trips a day period that's in the ordinance but I was saying we could add a my brain is not working so long day the non-concurrent some language about single use at a time, if we wanted to.
[16:15] Speaker G (unidentified): I don't know if that would. You could say, sorry, no more than one client at a time and no more than five clients per day. Yeah. That would cover both of those things. I
[16:27] Speaker C (unidentified): think I heard something.
[16:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Did one of the- You wanna ask them? Yeah, does anyone joining remotely have any comments or questions?
[16:45] Speaker B (unidentified): I would just say that I don't, I would keep it at the ordinance for trips per day. And some of that is just, you know, generally, I mean, twofold, my thought process. The first is I want to encourage people to actually get the appropriate approvals. And I think that the trips per day was an attempt to kind of keep traffic down. and just thinking how this gets applied if somebody has a sewing class in their home for two people or they're potentially back-to-back appointments or music teacher that is doing a couple piano lessons at a time. I think we're trying to make sure we solve for the traffic issue in all of our neighborhoods, not just this neighborhood. I do have the benefit of walking by both your homes multiple times a day with my dog, because I live in Broad Cove. So I hear you on Katahdin, I see the landscape trucks, especially, just sort of blowing through that stop sign all the time. So I think the traffic is the issue, more so to me than whether it's one person, two people, if they're back-to-back appointments and they show up a few minutes, you know. Now, I think kind of the town council at the policy level solved that. I'm not sure I feel the need to add any more restrictions.
[18:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, and I want to note that it's not in here, but I believe I did look up what the annual average daily traffic is on that section of road, and it was somewhere between like 60 and 120, so somewhere in that zone is a ballpark figure. So I think that if we look at either of these 10 trips a day or 2%, these are small numbers compared to what the traffic is on that road. So I don't see an issue as far as just looking at trips per day. It doesn't seem significant to me. All right. I've
[19:21] Speaker G (unidentified): never received a comment on here. I don't know where they come in. are they willing to say it
[19:36] Speaker J (unidentified): so the comment is for me i just added the comment my name is mary lou nesbitt i live on algonquin road just below katahdin but it just seems that because it's a tight corridor being specific about limits per day number of cars parked would be helpful so that if it does get tight, there's a way that the neighbors can take questions forward, just so that the neighbors know how to take concerns forward because there are a tremendous number of children on that street. I mean, they come from other streets, but it's become a very popular street for scooters and bikes and children of middle school age-ish. ish so any specific limits would be helpful so that the neighbors have a guide if something has been exceeded that's all well
[20:39] Speaker A (unidentified): the ordinance does have a specific limit of 10 okay then 10 trips meaning one in one out which is five clients total it's five clients total
[20:50] Speaker J (unidentified): So that means that the neighbors would need to identify if the same or different five clients are going there per day?
[21:01] Speaker E (unidentified): So according to the application, they put six in. So you should not see more than three individual, three unique cars per day, according
[21:13] Speaker J (unidentified): to the application. And scheduled so that there's a time space between clients so that parking isn't extended out into the street.
[21:26] Speaker G (unidentified): There is room in the driveway for if people overlapped by five minutes, there is room in the driveway for those cars.
[21:38] Speaker J (unidentified): And how many cars can that driveway hold?
[21:43] Speaker G (unidentified): It holds at least two additional from what they have there, is what I observed and what was put in the application.
[21:51] Speaker J (unidentified): And then the owner must have cars, too, I guess is what I'm trying to...
[21:55] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, in addition to the owner's cars is what I said.
[22:00] Speaker J (unidentified): So the driveway can hold four cars, or does the cars have to be in the garage? I don't know, is it a one- or two-car garage? I don't know.
[22:09] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, there's a garage with two cars, and presumably that would be the owner's cars, and then there were two cars in the driveway. Okay.
[22:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Emanuela, did you wish to make a comment? Just take the lecture and, yeah.
[22:36] Speaker B (unidentified): The only way it gets recorded.
[22:38] Speaker I (unidentified): Oh, okay. I just wanted to add, if people are concerned about one client coming and the next coming, those sessions will not be put like one hour after the other so if I have one client I will have a 30-minute break under the next come is coming so that I can prepare for the other so there will be never two cars coming into my driveway just wanted to kind of clarify that
[23:11] Speaker F (unidentified): would you be comfortable with a condition that all parking be off street in your driveway excuse me would you be comfortable if we put in a condition that all parking be off street in your driveway it sounds like that's the plan right there would there be any issue with us conditioning approval on parking being in your driveway only not on the street
[23:28] Speaker I (unidentified): yes of course yeah there's space enough for two cars in the driveway so if i have a client
[23:34] Speaker D (unidentified): it can just be on the driveway yeah do you is there parking on the street where you live
[23:42] Speaker I (unidentified): If there's parking. Is there on-street parking? I don't really know. We never park on the street there. We always...
[23:50] Speaker B (unidentified): Just from observation, there's ample and regular on-street parking there.
[23:56] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm just really cautious about putting stuff in there. We don't want sending Ben down to enforce parking restrictions.
[24:04] Speaker B (unidentified): I would tend to agree with that. I mean, it's, you know, the homeowners allowed... Obviously, it's public parking.
[24:09] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm allowed to park there.
[24:11] Speaker B (unidentified): It's not like, I don't think we want to encourage it necessarily, but the homeowner could park cars on the street and as long as it's not overnight between December 1st and whatever.
[24:25] Speaker D (unidentified): I think my point is, the town has already has mechanisms to deal with this stuff and I'm not sure we want to wade that far into the weeds. I would agree.
[24:40] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I think along those lines you wind up in a slippery slope wherein any car that's parked in front of the house suddenly becomes a burden on the homeowner and they do have parking rights. They're either property rights and public use rights that are involved. So I think specific language could wind up impinging on those rights whereas as Colin said there's already very clear mechanisms for this enforcement.
[25:11] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, that and also with the, she's placed limits on herself and her applications. Yeah.
[25:19] Speaker E (unidentified): I think it's notable that she's placed such low limits on the application because she could have requested the maximum, but she's only requested six and that's actually only three customer visits. Right. And
[25:34] Speaker G (unidentified): what's on the application is enforceable and what she's said here this evening is on record and enforceable, so I think that's pretty limiting what we already have in front of us.
[25:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Any other questions? Can I sit down? Oh, sorry. Yeah. Joe has one. Oh, okay. Just put it on the record. Are you saying that you will not have more than 10 car trips per day during the operation
[26:08] Speaker I (unidentified): of the business? Yeah. I cannot, yeah. I'm not going to do five per day, so it's a lot. so if I can fit if I've nice would be two day two clients every business day sometimes maybe some clients cannot and will come on you know three or four on one business day but five I don't get it in my workday I have kids so I have to be done in a certain time one
[26:44] Speaker F (unidentified): more question how does someone find you if they're interested in Pilates classes. Do you have a website? It's just through word of mouth.
[26:50] Speaker I (unidentified): I don't have a website yet. I teach at the community center, and I've been asked by people. I have elderly adults Pilates movement functioning, and so they've been asking if they could come, and that's how my idea arised, that I could teach some of them at home, but just limited because I have two other jobs that I would like to continue.
[27:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Thank you. I was just curious. I'm curious. Yeah. Any
[27:24] Speaker A (unidentified): further questions? You may have a seat, I think. Okay. All right. Colin Powers.
[27:30] Speaker D (unidentified): I'll make a motion to approve the request of Emanuela Porcelli, co-owner of the property at 9 Katahdin Road, map U12, lot 97, to establish a home business to conduct private Pilates classes based on section 19-5-5 of the zoning ordinance.
[27:51] Speaker A (unidentified): I second. All right. We have a motion by Colin Powers and Chris Gorski is seconded. All in favor? All right. It's a unanimous approval. On to the findings of fact. One, the property is a non-conforming lot in the RA zone. The property contains a single family dwelling. Classes will be conducted from within the existing dwelling. Additional findings of fact, the applicant has demonstrated that the proposal complies with the definition of home business in section 19 dash 1 dash 3 of the zoning ordinance to the applicant has demonstrated that the proposal complies with the standards of conditional use approval found in section 19 dash 5 dash 5 dot B of the zoning ordinance do we feel we want to add any additional language or conditions regarding the traffic or just the I think it's yeah I think it's it's all in the in the ordinance everyone
[29:01] Speaker B (unidentified): happy with say let's let's do this I'll make a motion that we approve those findings of fact and additional findings of fact as is and if someone wants to add a condition they can propose it and we can go from there
[29:17] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Kevin Just is moved. Cullen Powers second. All in favor? All right. It's unanimous. We've approved the findings of fact and additional finding of fact. Congratulations. All right. Now on to the next item. To hear the request of Cole and Marjorie Kelly, owners of the property at 9 Overlook Lane, map U12, lot 43, for variance to add a first floor bedroom and covered parking based on section 19-5-4 of the zoning ordinance. Ben, can you give us any background?
[30:06] Speaker G (unidentified): Sure, I've been discussing this project with Cole and Margie Kelly for 13 years. And more recently, we've talked about doing addition on one side of the house and addition on the other side of the house. We have a letter in the file from LP Murray about why it's nearly impossible to do an addition on the rear of the house. It's a sloped lot and it's just more difficult over there. another point the zoning board did approve a variance in 2013 for something very similar to this application for 14 feet to the side setback on this lot Margie and Cole's plans changed at that time and they decided not to build but now they now they would like to build this again so they are back in front of us with a with a similar application all right margie
[31:23] Speaker A (unidentified): yes all right would you like to walk us through your application please i would be glad to good
[31:27] Speaker K (unidentified): evening y'all i'm margie kelly nine overlook lane cape elizabeth the shore acres cottage that we call home it was built in 1909 and it overlooks people's cove decades ago from our porch All the way down to the water was nothing but fields growing cabbage and lettuce. How that has changed. In 1996, we winterized the cottage. We discovered there was a car jack holding up the southwest corner of our house. And the engineers said it was a miracle that the refrigerator had not gone through the floor. So we flash forward to 2026. And my husband and I are the ones falling apart at the seams. As Ben said, in 2013 the zoning board approved the request for a 14-foot variance. We should have completed the project then, but we didn't. So here we are tonight. Our application shows the plan for a first floor bedroom, bath, and laundry room within the 25-foot sideline and the 25-foot front line of the property. The addition includes an exterior door with a hallway with a chairlift so that we could get from ground level up to the first floor and be able to do that safely coming in from bad weather. We ask your permission to build that covered yet open-sided parking shed that would allow us to move in safely. And we'd like to build this project before my husband and I have to have hip replacement surgeries. As you've read Skip Murray's letter about the severe elevation changes at 9 Overlook, this is really the only feasible spot to build a bedroom, a parking spot, and a way to enter without braving the elements. And my husband and I appreciate Ben's sage advice once again to organize our application and our thanks go to our neighbors that wrote letters of support. And I'm happy to answer any questions you have. So
[33:52] Speaker B (unidentified): the first question this might be for Ben too. So this is substantially similar to the 2013 proposal. Yes. Unfortunately, I should have asked for it beforehand. We don't have that approval as part of this. How does it differ, if at all, or is it exactly the same?
[34:09] Speaker K (unidentified): It's slightly different, ever so slightly, and it includes the parking shed.
[34:15] Speaker B (unidentified): Got it. So the parking shed was not part of the 2030. Correct.
[34:19] Speaker K (unidentified): Originally, the built-in space went all the way to the 14-foot line. Okay.
[34:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Question for Adam. Do you have the L.P. Murray letter in your packet? We do not overhear.
[34:32] Speaker A (unidentified): We don't have any of the letters in our packets. I think they're all emailed.
[34:38] Speaker G (unidentified): Would you like me to read the LP Murray letter? Yes, please. It's dated October 1st, 2026. I'm writing about Margie Cole Kelly Residence located at Overlook Lane. After meeting with the Kellys and their architect, I have a few thoughts on the location of the proposed addition. The west and north sides of the property would require 15 to 20 foot high cement walls due to the severe drop off with a one to one slope around two sides of the proposed addition. This is clearly in my opinion, extremely difficult, if not impossible to construct physically and financially. In my professional opinion, the only logical place for the addition is on the east side of the property. To attempt to construct in any other location but the east side would be a true hardship ownership for the owners. In addition to that, we received emails of support from Lori and Foster Stewart at 11 Overlook Lane, Caitlin and Brandon Sweet at 13 Overlook Lane, Stefan Mett and Stephanie Boggs at 5 Overlook Lane, Renee and Andrew Fallon at 36 Trundy.
[35:55] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes, Jim. Do you currently have a garage on the property? Yes, we do. Is the garage functional?
[36:03] Speaker K (unidentified): The garage is functional. It is 30 feet from our front door and seven steps up.
[36:09] Speaker C (unidentified): But it is usable, though? Yes. Are there other properties in the neighborhood that have both a garage and a carport?
[36:21] Speaker K (unidentified): We have that right now. You
[36:25] Speaker C (unidentified): only have a garage right now?
[36:27] Speaker K (unidentified): No, we have a garage with a shed to the left of our cottage. Okay. The shed is 40 feet from our front door.
[36:36] Speaker C (unidentified): Okay, and the shed is used for? Parking. Parking as well. Are there other properties in the neighborhood that have garages and carports? I do not know. Have you considered, instead of a carport, just putting in like a gravel patch or concrete or anything like that?
[37:00] Speaker K (unidentified): Well, that kind of defeats the purpose. If you've just had surgery and you're coming in on a walker, if you don't have cover over your head and it's snowing or icing, it's rather difficult to get into a house safely. We would like to age in place. there's
[37:36] Speaker C (unidentified): no claim of any disability that was there is there is anybody claiming to be disabled and
[37:42] Speaker K (unidentified): require well as we my husband has to have hip replacement surgery I have to have hip replacement surgery my husband is 80 years old I'm 73 so with age and in a lot of use of our bodies, things are going to happen. So there is a chance that, yes, we will be wheelchair-bound at some point in time. My arthritis is that serious. I've just had fusion on my spine because the spinal fluid was being blocked, and I was very close to paralysis.
[38:24] Speaker E (unidentified): Question. Yes. Consider putting the carport between the covered entry and the hallway, way so it looks very similar in width so it's 12 feet in width and it looks like you have more than 12 feet on the other side on
[38:42] Speaker K (unidentified): the other side of the cottage yes so well so if you're looking at
[38:47] Speaker E (unidentified): let's say you're looking at the front of the existing house yes you see the covered entry to the right of that why not put the cardboard there yeah
[38:59] Speaker C (unidentified): sure so
[39:02] Speaker K (unidentified): in this area okay
[39:11] Speaker D (unidentified): so it's an
[39:13] Speaker E (unidentified): architectural choice but not a financial choice
[39:37] Speaker C (unidentified): what's your what is your factual but do you Do you believe that you've suffered a significant economic injury, would, do you believe that you would suffer an economic injury if this variance were not granted? The
[40:02] Speaker K (unidentified): economic injury would come from our not having a safe access to our home. And I don't know how you quantify that in dollars.
[40:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Also not in the
[40:20] Speaker C (unidentified): the shoreline, so I don't think that's as- Well, it falls within the definition of practical difficulty. Okay. I mean, Ben obviously will correct me if I'm wrong. There's a requirement that they show inability to use the property and a significant economic injury, which our ordinance defines in a very specific way where you have to look to finding ten property owners who are better off than you are. Of course, I don't remember what it was, but it's very specific and so I'm asking to see whether the applicant complies with that very specific criteria. That's accurate
[41:18] Speaker G (unidentified): what you're saying it's on the third page of the variance application that defines significant economic injury looking at ten of the nearest property owners and there is a bit of an analysis of that in the application
[41:40] Speaker C (unidentified): there's well there's two components to it there's comparing the neighbors for significant economic injury purposes and then there's comparing it for side-back encroachments. And I think that her evidence was to show that there are other side-back encroachments that she pretty much followed in the name of others.
[42:09] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, it basically says that someone will suffer significant economic injury if they're unable able to have something comparable to the majority of their neighbors so if the majority of their neighbors have similar structures in similar proximity to the property line then they are at then they have an economic injury by not being able to do it themselves i think that's that's That's my interpretation of it. So
[42:49] Speaker D (unidentified): that's what these pictures with the tape measure are for, is how the neighbors are, this is their proximity to their sidelines, if I understand correctly?
[42:58] Speaker K (unidentified): Yes, ten examples showing non-conforming lots with structures in our neighborhood. Some of the structures are as close as six inches to the sideline.
[43:19] Speaker D (unidentified): We can conclude that at least ten of your neighbors have this, like a better term, condition. Right? Is that what you're saying? Yes.
[43:31] Speaker K (unidentified): And I ask their permission to go on their property to measure and to record it and deliver it to you. That's always a good thing. I didn't want to get shot. And
[43:50] Speaker B (unidentified): I hate to put you on the spot like this. Do you have the 2013 approval in a place where you could kind of read us those findings of fact?
[44:02] Speaker E (unidentified): Does that approval matter, though, in this case?
[44:05] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm just curious if they addressed some of these. I don't think this part of the ordinance has changed. And if they addressed it in a specific way, it's not precedent, but it might be illuminating. I mean part of the struggle and we're not even at our deliberation stage is the standard for a variance is extraordinarily high as you can probably tell and I don't necessarily love how it's written but it is written the way it's written and so if somebody else has already done some of the hard work I'm more than happy to crib off of what they've done even though we'd have to come to the same conclusion ourselves at this point may i share this with you please thank you for keeping such great notes just
[45:03] Speaker D (unidentified): just so i'm clear in my head we're not looking at building in between the garage and the existing house because of the slope that's where the slope issue is okay yeah
[45:16] Speaker B (unidentified): this is just so read it out loud and this is from August 27th, 2013. The findings of fact, variance request for map U12 lot 43, 9 Overlook Lane, applicant Colton Margie Kelly. Additional findings of fact, Colton Margie Kelly are the owners of record. I'm abbreviating a little bit. I don't think you need to repeat that. Two, 9 Overlook Lane is a nonconforming lot. The required setbacks are what they are, 25,, and 20. Three, in order to construct an addition on the side of the house, The applicant is requesting a variance that allows a side setback of 14 feet on the easterly side of the property Conclusion there's no substantial departure from the intent in the ordinance and a literal enforcement would cause a practical difficulty is defined by 30 a.m. RSA section 4353 4c and It was approved 6-0 Read that for the record. I Unless somebody else wants a copy of it.
[46:18] Speaker E (unidentified): I think where I'm struggling is I understand the spirit of the application, and I see a potential possibility to grant this, but when I look at the application, I'm trying to figure out the story between how the unique circumstances make it impossible to do what you want to do. So, you know, we looked at the issue of putting the carport where I showed you, and we see that 's an architectural decision, not a financial decision. And then it looks like, you know, there might be another possibility of putting the carport possibly in the front at another angle. It's hard to tell from these drawings within the application itself because there's no topo map. There's no topological map. So it's hard to, in my opinion, and theirs may differ, for me to build the story up that there's no other way to do this. So that's where I'm looking for something in the application that you could point me to where I could say, well, you definitely couldn't do it here, you definitely couldn't do it there,, you definitely couldn't put a covered walkway in. That might, you know, do the same thing.
[47:46] Speaker K (unidentified): I wonder if you might refer to Section 1, pages 1 and 2 in the application. They show some of the elevation changes.
[48:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Just note, I'm reading the minutes from the 2013 meeting. I have them in front of me right now. There's not a lot of substance there that I think is going to take you to where you want to be. They're relatively short. But I'd be happy to read them or share them with the
[48:59] Speaker A (unidentified): board. Yeah, I don't think reading those will be useful. useful. Along the line of Chris's questioning, I see the elevations, but there's no elevation for the area between the existing garage and the house.
[49:25] Speaker K (unidentified): Seven steps down from the house. Right, but I don't see it here. We were not advised that you needed that.
[49:37] Speaker E (unidentified): I think it's just that the bar is so high for us to grant a variance that it's the application in front of us ideally in my mind would be that read the application and I am compelled to think there is no other way to grant this variance and then I ask you clarifying questions the problem is I'm at the point where I'm not even at the clarifying questions point I'm because if I look at this I look at this application just without talking to anyone it seems to me there are a lot of possibilities and so I'm struggling it's not that I don't I'm not doubting you it's just the back to fight you know it's the fact of the law and the paperwork so I'm trying to find a path in here in this paperwork along with the evidence that's submitted where I can see that it's the requirements to grant the variance, that 's where I'm struggling right now. Is there, are there any other maps, like topo maps or anything else that anyone might've put together or any other?
[50:48] Speaker K (unidentified): I'm sorry, I did not bring them. Okay.
[50:56] Speaker B (unidentified): Just to be clear, I'm not making a motion, but in the past we have from time to time tabled an application to get some additional information. So that is an option. I know it's probably not the preferred option, but should we feel like collectively we need more information?
[51:13] Speaker A (unidentified): It is something. I was thinking along those lines because I'm having, I've come to a similar sort of impasse mentally in that, like, the pass is a smell test, but we need to see, you know, it's on, the burden is on the applicant, right, and it's very clear. And I love saying yes to things. but it's you know it's exactly as Chris said it's it's sounds compelling but we're not seeing the missing pieces I was thinking in the moment do we want to see if there's any public comment we'll move on to public comment for the time being and possibly discuss our other options in a moment. Thank you Margie. Margie. Thank you. You like Margie? Margie. Margie. Thank you. And we may call you back up. Are there any comments or questions from members of the public?
[52:21] Speaker L (unidentified): Good evening. Foster Stewart, 11 Overlook Lane, immediately adjacent to the subject property. And just want to express my support for what Margie and Cole are doing. They're a tremendous asset to the neighborhood. They're a tremendous asset to Cape Elizabeth, and we'd love to see them be able to build renovations to their home to allow them to age in place. Your predecessors having previously approved that and found that it was necessary, I'm hopeful that you will do the same. Thank you. Thank you.
[53:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Jim, Mr. Mora, do you have any comments or questions for the board? I guess not. Okay. And so I guess we deliberate for a moment. Yeah. Yeah. So, oh, go ahead. What's your thoughts? Yeah.
[53:42] Speaker C (unidentified): Every time we have one of these variance matters, it takes me like an hour to kind of reread the statute and see how all the interlocking parts work together and it takes like another four hours to for my headache to subside just i don't want to quibble with ben but this shows how confusing this all is with i was saying that there's there are two separate criteria regarding looking at 10 neighbors one goes to the undesirable characteristics of the neighborhood and that's the one that in the definitions you look at the ten nearest properties and you average together how close they are to the site setback with regard to significant economic injury that's the one where they have to show that they other ten 10 other neighbors, by virtue of lot size or other factors, have it better off than they do. So there are those two separate things here. And the pictures go to the first issue of whether the desirability factor. And it seems like they've kind of met that, it's not given that there's all these other site encroachments that they're encroachment per se it's not a problem but doesn't and that's that aspect of it does kind of inch enter into your if this doesn't make any sense it's not completely my fault that analysis in part enters into whether there's been a significant economic injury but it looks at it at a host of other things and a lot of it is do they have what I don't have and you know as you know like as I was getting at one of the things that she would have and that they don't have is both a carport shed or whatever and a garage so it's not like we're trying to equalize herself to them she actually wants something in addition so that's that's one thing that's troublesome to me that's not necessarily going to be answered by getting more information. Again, with regards to the significant economic injury, I think the applicant has acknowledged that she hasn't made any effort, not intentionally, I'm not suggesting that, but hasn't done the homework to make that case as that term is defined in the statute. Another one of the things that is troublesome to me, I understand the reason why the applicant wants this project. Of course, I'm not unsympathetic to that, but I was asking about disability, because this ordinance actually deals with people who actually have a disability, and it says that we can be very generous in our interpretation of the variance ordinance, but they have to, do at the end of their disability or if they sell the property or heaven forbid die, then conditions can attach that makes you go back to where you started. What the applicant here is actually asking for something better than if she came in under a disability plea. plea so I just you know again I'm sympathetic I think we all are to and we you know support the need for aging in place we understand some serious physical illness they've had but we have you know we have this very strict ordinance to deal with and I've just you know pointed out at least in my mind some of the things that I'm struggling with I
[57:39] Speaker E (unidentified): would say for me going back to that kind of narrative that I would like to build for myself to be convinced that this is the only way. So we talked about that space between the covered entry and the hall for a carport. Now, I'm guessing, you know, I have no idea what the actual situation is, but, you know, if the builder or the architect, for instance, thought, you know, oh, here's a reason, here's a very specific reason not just architecturally but you know there's also a physical reason or financial reason or it's very obvious that this whole area you can't build because of a slope reason or there's you know it's very like basically i look at this document i look at the drawings and i think wow like you really you just really can't do it so the problem is, looking at these drawings, I see a ton of options. And so what I'm guessing is the case, maybe, is that there's just not enough clarification, right? There just has to be the builder, the architect, whoever has to add that additional info in just so that when I read it, I say, oh, I can see why nothing could fit between the covered entry and the hall, for instance. So, that's kind of how I, like to go from the application, I see a solid application and then I can ask clarifying questions. I think it would be hard for me right now to approve this based solely on the application and the materials available, but I would be open to tabling it.
[59:35] Speaker B (unidentified): Kind of give my two cents because I think I'm, pick up a little bit of both of these. I, like Joe, every time a variance comes before us, the criteria for our variances are just so incredibly high. Your property was built in 1906. There are a couple, at least one of the ten properties here was one of the farmhouses that was in Shore Acres. You know, we came along in whatever, the 50s or 60s, and mapped all these properties into our fancy zones with the required setbacks. And we've seen this throughout town and lots of other neighborhoods. I think something like 75% of our lots are nonconforming. And so to get to Joe's point, the first part of the test, the 10 nearest neighbors, if that was the only prong of the test, we'd probably give a lot of variances in a lot of neighborhoods to let people get closer to those side setbacks because they actually are a lot less than the existing setbacks. And I think if this were in the RC zone, you'd be able to approve it, right? Can't you go down to 10 feet on a side setback? For a non-conforming route. So, you know, some of it's the sort of just how it was done in the past. This is a really hard one for me regardless. But I think, I mean, I try to get to yes from what I think I'd like to understand is a little more information on sort of that, what's in between the two the two existing structures the garage and the house and then you know if you're if your architect has looked at it and said it is just economically infeasible to move this to the sorry I think it's you're proposing to the east side so if it's economically infeasible to move it to the west side because whatever it is there's a chimney that's not where the utilities are whatever the reasons are if that's the case that would help me to say okay this really is the only possible place to do it and even then it's really just the standard for approval to get the carport on the side is it's a high bar i'm not sure i'm there yet i have formulated a few different kind of almost public policy sorts of ways to frame the economic side of it. But I would, you know, my support would be to table it at this point, get a little bit more information and try to understand, okay, is this absolutely the only way? And then, you know, think about that part of the argument a little bit more.
[1:02:20] Speaker E (unidentified): And I think we should also note that when we get evidence from experts that carries, in my opinion, a lot more weight than a message from the homeowner themselves. So when we have someone who's an expert in their field, they're saying, this is the case, these are all the situations that don't work, that carries more weight often than the homeowner saying, no, this is how I would like to do it. I'm
[1:03:01] Speaker A (unidentified): of a mind to probably table it at this point too I agree with Chris in that there's it's almost certainly the case that it's impractical to build in the space in front of the house or in between the garage but it's just not demonstrated and it's again very high bar for variances well hang on I'm this wasn't a question. A couple thoughts along the line. Joe mentioned that there's broad latitude in the event of a disability, and you can put conditions. The carport, in my mind, could become conditional. It's not, I mean, is the plan to have a full foundation? No. So it could become a conditional structure, right, upon the end of use or end of disability it could be removed it's just a thought I'm not table
[1:04:16] Speaker B (unidentified): it exactly yeah I'm there is I guess that would bring up the question that the extra curb cut is that intended to be paved part of the driveway so that's the gravel but
[1:04:35] Speaker A (unidentified): it's just a rumination of mine
[1:04:44] Speaker K (unidentified): Margie, I'm happy to get the information for you. The architect has worked with us for months. This is what he thought worked best, as well as what Skip Murray thought worked best. You have a letter from Skip Murray, will that suffice? Now, you would like me to add a letter from the architect saying that this is the best plan, even though he's drawn it as the best plan.
[1:05:16] Speaker E (unidentified): I think what we're looking for is a compelling story. So looking at these drawings and thinking there's absolutely no way to do anything the way you are proposing to do it. And so I would say that if the architect is going to provide a letter, they would need to provide something that addresses all of those concerns. So like some of the questions that we asked you about possible placement, all of those things potentially would need to be addressed.
[1:05:48] Speaker K (unidentified): So you would like a letter from the architect saying that this is basically the only spot that it's feasible to build this particular plan on our property?
[1:05:57] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, I wouldn't say that we can't guarantee anything, but I would say that having a letter from an architect would be a strong piece of evidence if it adequately addresses all of our questions about the issues on the lot.
[1:06:11] Speaker K (unidentified): And your issues were specifically, I just want to be real clear, which issues you'd like him to address. I
[1:06:20] Speaker G (unidentified): mean no feasible alternative there's the section of no feasible alternative and I and I think that's pretty much the crux of the one you're getting after and then we have a significant economic injury I mean I understand where both of you are coming from I you know I'll be able to meet with you Margie and you know further communicate those standards and
[1:06:50] Speaker B (unidentified): I mean I might just add a couple more pictures especially in of the of the front sort of the of the path not taken yeah so we just have these four pictures of the property and I think I think some other some other visual aids I don't know if it's and the actual topography Yeah, if you have the topography map, great, please, I would love to see that, and some additional pictures.
[1:07:23] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes. Where the garage is. Yeah.
[1:07:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, I think Ben just pulled up a topography map in the north, but I'd love for it to be in the application and not just spoken of. So I think my biggest point of illumination would be specifically the area between the existing garage and the house, because I think it would speak to both of those, both of the prevailing issues, one being feasibility and two being economic damage. Because if that garage is so far away and so far down that's existing, the value and the utility is much, less. Especially, you know, you say seven steps and there's seven steps and there's seven steps. Be great to see those. That would make, that would make the decision tree a lot easier for us.
[1:08:24] Speaker K (unidentified): So in review, I haven't done my homework. I need to have an architect's letter saying that there are no feasible alternatives other than this plan. I need to show significant injury financially. financially. It's the second aspect. And the third, a topography map with additional photos showing the distance between the garage floor and the bottom of the first floor of the house, the disparate space. Can y'all make any other suggestions in order to ask our request?
[1:09:01] Speaker E (unidentified): A declaration of infeasibility is something, but if an explanation of infeasibility is a whole a much better level so if the architect so i would excuse me excuse me change from no feasibility alternative to well what i would say is that if the architect the architect should look at the lot as someone in our position and analyze is there any way that some it could be done another way and then address every possible argument that it could not be done another way so simply saying it can't be done in my mind is not sufficient I
[1:09:45] Speaker B (unidentified): would I would just get as specific as they possibly can for example the kitchen is on that side of the property is there is putting is building on that side disturbing enough that you'd have to you know you know create an economic hardship by redoing a kitchen or relocating the kitchen within the home I don't know if that's true I'm not putting words in your mouth or their mouth no I would get as granular as you possibly that's what I would like to
[1:10:13] Speaker K (unidentified): know specifically so that I can be more on point the next time I meet with you
[1:10:17] Speaker D (unidentified): folks I would volunteer that you know one of the things we're trying to do is where else could this work and really what's missing in this application is anything in regards to what's between the garage and the house. There's no pictures, topographical, etc. So it makes it hard for us to say well
[1:10:40] Speaker K (unidentified): that's not gonna work. And I understand you can't take my word for it. Yeah we
[1:10:44] Speaker D (unidentified): have to have something in the file.
[1:10:49] Speaker K (unidentified): I'll be happy to provide that.
[1:10:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Along those lines also if you know if LP Murray could give a couple specifics about you know, not just extreme slope, but, you know, they want to specifically speak to topography between those two structures.
[1:11:09] Speaker K (unidentified): So add another letter from Skip Murray.
[1:11:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Just see if Skip could just clarify, like, you know, what the grade is. I thought his letter was pretty complete in terms of going back, like in terms of building off the back. It gave high differential how much the rotating wall's expensive. very difficult etc so just something along those lines specifically for that space or the curve for the space we are suggesting just the space so this when we look at the application if you look at the site plan the space between the house and the garage looks like a natural fit for right and so we just need to hear why no like really hold us by the nose and walk us through it and that's what makes it easier for us to say yes because our you know or as colin said our whole role here is to find that determine whether there is any other possible way to do
[1:12:12] Speaker B (unidentified): it i'm very confident that you will have some discussions with ben and he'll be able to help i think i think he's probably has a good sense of what we're all looking for at this point too yeah
[1:12:25] Speaker C (unidentified): sorry
[1:12:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Go staring at me.
[1:12:28] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, no, I don't want to imply that this would necessarily assuage my concerns. The thing that troubles me is it seems a little too applicant-dependent that it's based on a legitimate physical hardship. Let's say if Adam were making this application, would we have the same concerns about trying to find a way to make it work when there's a perfectly good garage there so I'm concerned about that because I mean for one thing they could get this approval and turn around sell the house tomorrow to a couple of 35 year olds so I don't I'm not saying they're being bamboozled into this I'm saying if this is just for their needs and I would be more interested if we're going to try to look at this another way to ask Ben to see if there's some way they can apply as disabled people in which case, it gives us a lot more leeway in getting around some of the variation limitations and openly tells us that we should time condition that kind of a project.
[1:13:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Without the carport, it's conforming, right? Or it's legal money. Right.
[1:13:47] Speaker G (unidentified): Without the carport, it's conforming. And, you know, to answer your question, what Joe said is he thought we should explore the idea, the path of a disability variance for it. And we can. We can discuss that. You know, we can discuss that.
[1:14:06] Speaker K (unidentified): I'm happy to have our physicians write letters. Yeah.
[1:14:09] Speaker G (unidentified): We can discuss all these options moving forward.
[1:14:18] Speaker A (unidentified): So it feels like if someone were to make a motion to table.
[1:14:23] Speaker B (unidentified): We should probably make sure everybody's. Are we good with? Yeah, everybody in mind with that. All right. I'll move. I'll move to table this application until either our next meeting or when the applicant is ready to come back.
[1:14:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. All right. All in favor. it's unanimous the application is tabled until in our next meeting is December 3rd December 3rd
[1:14:53] Speaker B (unidentified): okay it's December 4th when is this is the weird one that's after Thanksgiving 9th 10th what did we decide we just we decide our meetings at the beginning of the year and
[1:15:07] Speaker G (unidentified): then I'll forget it's December 9th Wednesday December 9th is our next meeting
[1:15:12] Speaker K (unidentified): and when would this information need to be in hand to
[1:15:21] Speaker G (unidentified): Tuesday the 24th November
[1:15:24] Speaker K (unidentified): 24th end of day 430 p.m. all right thank you I'll have the information for you
[1:15:31] Speaker A (unidentified): all right Thank You Margie all right we are adjourned