← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick council extends data center moratorium, approves zoning waiver

2026-11-16 · 3h 42m · Source: 2026.11.16 Regular Town Council Meeting (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:05] Chair McDonald: good evening everyone and welcome to the november 16th 2026 town council meeting i'm officially calling us to order we have all counselors present except for counselor anderson was this meeting properly noticed town manager yes it was beautiful as a reminder for our counselors to silence your electronic devices at this point i'll remind our audience when they arrive for the regular meeting and I would first on our agenda here we have our executive session one MRSA 4056C acquisition of real property or economic development I am looking for a motion to enter into executive session we got a motion by Councillor Wilson seconded by Councillor Ecker any discussion not seeing any I'll call the vote Councillor Ellis yes Councillor Ecker yes Councillor Peralt yes. Councillor Hicks. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Yes. The chair is a yes. That is unanimous of the council present. We will enter into executive session and be back at 6.30. Good evening, everyone, and welcome back to our November 16th, 2026 regular town council meeting. Just so you are aware, this meeting has been properly noticed. We did this earlier. We have all members present except for Councillor Anderson. Anderson. As a reminder for our audience to please silence your electronic devices at this time. I'll give you a second to do so if you haven't done so yet. And then please rise if you're willing and able for the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all thank you everyone i ask that as chair that while we hold this space together we treat each other with compassion and respect as we work to improve our town are there any adjustments to the agenda not seeing any are there any announcements of council counselor [1:03:23] Town Manager: timmy hopefully [1:03:26] Councillor Perrault: i am not getting in front of the town manager on this one but on thursday at 5 30 Murrah is going to be having the final meeting on their airport master plan here in Council Chambers. So if anybody has thoughts and opinions on how the plan at the former base should go, take a look at their website, look at their plan, and come out to the meeting and let them know. [1:03:55] Councillor Ellis: Councillor Perrault. all? This coming Saturday from 9 to 11 at the Cook's Corner Fire Department, there will be a free car seat check. [1:04:10] Councillor Teemee: Councillor Ellis. Because I seem to be on holiday duty these last couple meetings, I would remind people that on November 28th, 2026, from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. on the Brunswick Town Mall, we will be having our annual tree lighting ceremony, which is always a lovely a festivity that we are often just driving back into town to see further [1:04:31] Chair McDonald: announcements of council not seeing any i'm going to just give a reminder to folks at the top of the meeting here that if you are here to speak on an item that is to set a public hearing we will not take public comment at that time we'll take public comment at the meeting where the public hearing is so we won't take public comment to set it we'll take public comment at it so if you're here for that item I don't want you to be expecting in that way. Great. Let's move to public comment. As a reminder, public comment is for non-agenda items only. You'll have three minutes per speaker. We'll have 30 minutes at the beginning of this meeting. If we need more time at the end, we'll have another 30-minute session. Please follow the code of conduct that's posted on either side of the room, and please say your name, town, and pronouns if you'd like. [1:05:22] Paul Whitcomb: Hi, my name's Paul Whitcomb. I'm from Brunswick, and I'd like to talk about the proposed development at 53 to 69 Main Street. The DEP project manager, Michael Mars, is deficient in three major categories here as far as his knowledge goes. He has no experience with dry cleaners. He has no experience in this type of operation. I think that should be a red flag to everyone. I talked to him today. He does not know where all of this contaminated soil is going to go. And it seems as though he doesn't care. That should be completely unacceptable to all of us. And he does not know where, okay, the Environmental Protection Agency estimates that an average neighborhood dry cleaner produces 560 gallons of contaminated liquid per year. year. He does not know where any of this contaminated waste currently is. He doesn't know, and apparently he doesn't care either. J&J cleaners, there's no record of it at DEP, and there doesn't need to be. These are considerations. What I'm getting at, the main thing here is that the town has to, I think, hire their own environmental consultant to understand exactly the scope and nature of the contamination at that site and not depend on the VRAP or this TRC corporation that did a limited subsurface investigation earlier this year. As a matter of fact, we need to take into consideration something called following the plume. if field instruments detect contamination at the bottom of the boring drilling must continue deeper to find the vertical boundary where the contamination stops thank you is there anybody [1:08:31] Chair McDonald: else in the room that would like to speak feel free to line up good [1:08:44] Carolyn Eklund: evening counselors town Manager, Town Clerk, I'm Carolyn Eklund. I'm a resident of Brunswick. I just wanna thank you all for an election conducted in our town that we can all be proud of. As always, it was smooth running, organized, and inspired confidence. Congratulations to all who won our election. And thank you to those who lost because they put themselves forward. And that is something that I admire, should be admired. We heard from candidates about their most important issues, their comments helped us focus on what's important to them, to us and our families and our town. We might not agree with all the comments all the time, but we stay in conversation and we listen. That's what I experience here at town council meetings. meetings. I attend town council meetings because it's important to me that I hear the deliberations of our elected leaders and the voices of their constituents, including mine, my voice. So thank you for a free opportunity to speak, and that's why I come so often. Let me shift briefly to one of the most important issues, most threatening issues of our town for me. I'll quote a member of our Maine delegation to Congress as she communicated clearly to her constituents during the election. Shelley Pingree, the representative in Washington for Maine District 1, said, and I wholeheartedly agree, and I quote, I oppose any increase in ICE's presence in Maine. I'm echoing calls of community leaders for DHS to withdraw the additional personnel immediately and close the Scarborough facility. I know that's not Brunswick, the Scarborough facility. I continue. This cruel, chaotic, and out of control agency needs to be abolished, and we need ICE out of Maine, period. Yes, I would concur with that statement. We do need ICE out of Maine, period. Thank you so much for listening. [1:10:54] Ralph Keys: My name is Ralph Keys, he, him. I'm a resident of Brunswick. I want to speak about a MIRA issue. It's not the airport development plan. Is that permissible? I wish for the Brunswick Town Council, in consultation with the town manager, town planner, town economic development director, to reach out to ask our elected state representatives, our state senator and the governor, and ask them to take a look at the main regional redevelopment authority, MIRA. Is MIRA operating and functioning according to its mission, goals, and guiding principles? Or do these need to be revised to reflect changes over the past 20 years in our communities and our communities' wishes for the redevelopment of the former naval air base? And to reflect changes in our understanding of the issues that we face in the redevelopment process? I'm not a lawyer or historian or scholar of state government, but as I understand it from doing a little research into the statute that formed MIRA, and I can refer you to the source of this, It was Statute 13083G, Midcoast Regional Redevelopment Authority established goals. There are four of them, and goal four is stated as environmental stewardship, engage in environmental stewardship to protect against harm to the environment and residents of the primary impact community. community. The primary in-pact community is defined as including the municipalities of Bath, Bowdoin, Bowdenham, Brunswick, Freeport, Harpswell, Lisbon Falls, and Thompson. Surprisingly, I didn't notice West Bath in that listing. If MIRA is meeting this goal, if, I should say, is MIRA meeting this goal, or do we have to redefine its mission so it serves us all well and prioritizes environmental stewardship as one of its four goals equal to the others they're numbered one through four there's no statement that 's a rank order so i'm urging the town to initiate a relook at mira and its structure and are they serving us well still 20 years after they formed thank you very much thank you and i can give i can pass down a copy for the [1:13:09] Chair McDonald: record where we i see the hand on zoom we'll get you after you we get to the folks in the room my [1:13:18] Peggy Siegel: name is Peggy Siegel, and I have lived in Brunswick for nearly 25 years. I now live at the Sandpiper Residences on the landing about a half mile from where the record-breaking chemical spill of PFAS occurred three weeks after I moved there. Since that time, I've read everything I could about PFAS, about the Superfund site details, after the Navy left the Brunswick Naval Air Station, about the cleanup after the August 2024 spill, and yes, I've read the Mira Airport master plan, a very interesting book-length master plan about very significant expansion. I remember how proud I was in September 2024 that I lived in a town that took protecting its citizens so seriously that at a town meeting we heard about a list of demands that the council drafted for Mira's leadership so we could move forward. Protected in the knowledge that there would be remediation and care taken to protect the environment, our waterways adjacent to the landing, the residents of Brunswick and our state legislators went to work in the statehouse to ensure the same. Over two years has gone by. Many Brunswick friends and residents say to me, oh, that's all cleaned up now, right? They also are so trusting that we will be protected. This Thursday's final public meeting to explain the master plan for that airport was not well publicized and many residents living in the airport's shadow have not had time to read an extensive report and plan. They also rely on the town council to protect them from anything that would not be healthy for people, for wildlife, for our watersheds and air. There is considerable work to be done to resolve problems in oil-water separators and in the groundwater. There are yet to be measured PFAS levels in the soil. There is a failed stormwater system yet to be resolved. Further development is a risk. I hope after Thursday's MIRA meeting in these council chambers, we can again rely on the town council to set firm zoning demands and demands for priorities that will protect brunswick residents just as you did in september of 2024 and thank you for doing that thank you good [1:16:19] Bruce Kantner: evening council members my name is bruce kantner i'm a resident of brunswick i'm here to speak a little bit about the time bomb that Mira has just dropped here on the expansion plan, but in doing the research, I got all my archives and files since the spill two years ago. I had 500 pages plus of documents all about this, and I just realized the quantity, the acronyms, the complexity of this project, The charges that were given to MIRA back in 2005, 2006, 2007, it's just really overwhelming. And I thought I'd write it down tonight. I just couldn't. I couldn't get it all in there. And this brings up another question, you know, how to race against that clock in these three-minute comment periods. I was heartened at the candidates' night in the library. the three council members present, all suggested offering workshops in this next calendar year and perhaps getting some office hours back again. We need other ways to have conversations, workshops, to communicate it. I'm just saying that because of the enormity of this particular issue coming up on Thursday. And I'll say a couple things about that. that I went back to the original document that the town was involved in. There were 200 citizens out of a population of 20,000 who participated over three sessions in developing the original document for the transfer of the base from the Navy. And MIRA was created out of that. And a number of people said they don't want an airport. That was one of the scenarios that was offered. You don't hear that very often. If you look at Mira's website, you can't even find the results of that survey. I searched it again today. I went to the Navy. I know it's up in the library because I read it two years ago. There's 30 volumes, three-ring notebooks up in that library in one of the meeting rooms. It's the archives for the Navy. And you look through that, you can imagine it's a daunting task. ask. So going right back to the origins, Mira's charge was never a full blast thing, go for economic development, but that's how it's turned out. And that's where it's heading now. The expansion plan, I hope people get informed. It's very hard to really catch up with it. places for 12 Boeing 707s 25 or 22 new hangars a new access road what this is going to do to the noise the air pollution the whole atmosphere of Cook's Corner in the whole town of Brunswick is hard to imagine there's so much to say here I just ask that we have a chance after this meeting at the meeting also somehow to meet with you counselors you are the safeguard and I'll end with a quote from Suzanne Johnson who wrote you a letter she says it's time for Brunswick to get the house in order it's time for Brunswick to manage this property the landing with a clear knowledge that one day all this property becomes the town's obligation Mira can't manage this job now and nobody will be able to manage this disaster in the future Brunswick residents and residents of the Mid-Coast need you to act on this. [1:19:54] Jane Champ: Good evening. My name is Jane Champ. I live on [street] in Brunswick. I am here again to talk about Jordan Ave. I was here on September 8th, most recently. At that time, I requested some help with speed enforcement, amongst other things, for those who do not regularly walk on Jordan Ave or bike on Jordan Ave, which is even more terrifying the sidewalks are extremely narrow so that any car traveling on Jordan Ave is about here from you every week I see a new pole strike the poles are the same place a human being would have their body on the sidewalk a couple weeks ago somebody lost a mirror hitting a pole you could see the glass and you could see exactly where it happened so you can understand how as a human being with a five-year-old, I had these same complaints and concerns when my son was four. I'm still here, coming back. I would like some help. I am powerless on the street. Every morning, every evening, I run into friends who say, wow, did you see that near collision? Did you see that person just about get run over? Did you see that car pass that family that was trying to make a left turn on their bike and just about get creamed please i would like some enforcement we need the police i have not seen them almost at all this year they used to at least come through last year during the school hour and i'm focusing on the school hour because that is the most consequential time the speeding is constant on georg nav as a pedestrian as someone who lives there but the school hour is when a very small person could get killed right so let's not mince words here this is a recipe for disaster it maintains that way it is not fixing itself also the school light the flashing light we first when you drive down towards the school from federal it tells you it's the school hour and that you're now in a school zone it has been non-functional since September of 2025 when we first started reporting it. It worked correctly for about a week or two this year. It's again non-functional. The only light that flashes is not visible because of the bridge. So we have a situation where we're into our second school year where people don't even know they're in the school zone. It's not marked and they don't know the school hours. Please, can we do something about this? I know the contractor is going to move the non-visible sign, but that's not slated until 2027. So are we just supposed to continue every single day and say, it's fine. I love having a car coming 40 miles an hour next to me. It's supposed to be 15. I don't know what else to say except, like, please help it's really bad out there it's also now dark you can't see anything drivers can't see people we just something needs to be done and i would like a follow-up this time i will sign the book again i know i'm out of time thanks thank you good [1:23:20] Robert McKeown: evening my name is robert mckeown i live on princess point road in brunswick and after that lady's plea, I kind of feel small. Obviously, that's way more important than what I'm going to talk about. The EPA first declared Brunswick Naval Air Station as a Superfund site in 1987 because of soil and water contamination from the military activities, including cleaning solvents, petroleum, hydrocarbons, volatile organic compounds, and fire suppression foam. In the near 40 years since that declaration, we have realized the real dangers of PFAS in our water and our soil. The Navy is conducting remedial investigation into the extent of PFAS on the base. This has been going on since before the sort the spill in August of 24 but the Navy has not revealed any real conclusions and doesn't seem to be in a hurry to do this meanwhile Mira is continuing to develop projects on the base property as if there was no PFAS problem at all the Verity Stark and Monlicky projects are examples of their negligence. On Thursday, November 19th, MIRA is having the final meeting for public comment on their airport expansion plan, after which they will submit this plan to the FAA for approval. The full details of the plan were not released until late October, so this being called a final meeting on it is really a farce. It's the first real meeting of it. I intended the earlier meetings and they had nothing but the original boilerplate from some earlier version of the proposal. Anyway, there hasn't been any other real opportunity for the residents of Brunswick or any of the surrounding communities to be heard in this process at this late date I doubt of any confident doubt I have any confidence that the public input will be heated by mirror anyway I am really concerned about mirrors disregard for the effects of their development plans on the town in the area it seems that they are only concerned with making more money for themselves. I strongly object to this airport expansion plan and think the town and the state need to step up to gain control of any new development on the base property before it is too late. I don't understand why Mira can go ahead with projects without having to answer to the town and state governments. Someday in the future, when the Navy and MIRA are long gone, it will fall on the town of Brunswick and maybe the state to deal with any problems they have left behind. On a more personal note, I live less than two miles away from the end of the runway on the southern approach to the airport. Port. Planes flying in will be 1,000 feet directly above my property, producing noise levels equivalent to a jackhammer operating 100 feet away. The expansion makes no provision for infrastructure to handle increased traffic to and from the base on state and town roads. Traffic on route one and back in the bath road is already very heavy and the expansion of the airport will only exacerbate that [1:27:31] Chair McDonald: Thank you. Thank you Is there anybody else in the room that would like to speak? Not seeing anyone in the room. I'm gonna go to zoom. We have Jennifer Navarro [1:27:45] Jennifer Navarro: Yes, good evening Jennifer Navarro Brunswick resident and I wanted to address a growing concern about the Planning Board and development and how brunswick oversees the development enforces its ordinances and hold its planning board and professional staff accountable development standards are not suggestions they are requirements financial capacity infrastructure adequacy stormwater management traffic safety parking and compliance with zoning ordinances are supposed to be evaluated before development approvals are granted yet we continue to see projects return for amendments modifications qualifications, waivers, extensions, and additional financing arrangements, which come after initial approvals. At what point does this become a pattern of piecemeal decision-making rather than comprehensive planning? And who is responsible for ensuring the original approval standards were actually satisfied? If a development is found to have adequate capacity of any approval at the time of approval but later requires substantial additional public financial support or a waiver to remain feasible, shouldn't that raise questions about the original findings and shouldn't the public be entitled to an explanation of what changed, when it changed, and whether those circumstances should have identified during the original review? Financial capacity should be demonstrated through the approval process, not simply assumed and addressed afterwards. We also need to examine the appearance of selective enforcement and the same standards applied to every are the same standards applied to every applicant are waivers and exceptions supported by documented findings are developers held to the same requirements as ordinary residents. Now consider Cook's Corner. Infrastructure improvements in this area have been discussed since at least 1998 Cook's Corner Master Plan. Brunswick established the Cook's Corner Tax Increment Financing District in 2018. In 2025, the town appropriated $200,000 from that district for revitalization. And the town's 2026-2027 budget projects approximately $1.28 million in annual Cook's Corner TIF revenue and a $3.5 million year-end district balance. Yet, long-standing concerns remain about roads, drainage, traffic, and infrastructure capacity. If Cook's Corner has been generating substantial TIF revenues while infrastructure improvements have been discussed since 1998, Where is the public accounting showing what has been accomplished, what remains unfinished, and why development approvals continue ahead of these improvements? How much TIF revenue has gone towards the infrastructure improvements and how much has been committed to other development-related incentives? When public financial assistance becomes necessary after development approval, residents deserve to understand whether the town is responding to genuinely changed circumstances or addressing feasibility questions that should have been addressed earlier. These decisions cannot be evaluated in isolation. Every additional commitment has implications for infrastructure priorities, future revenues, and taxpayers. I'm asking the Council to examine the Planning Board oversight, the consistency of ordinance enforcement, and adequacy of written findings and accountability for professional staff recommendations. I am also requesting a comprehensive public accounting of Cook's Corner TIF revenues, expenditures, and commitments in outstanding infrastructure needs. needs. Good planning must come before approval. Financial accountability must come before public commitments, and the same standards must apply to everyone. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anybody [1:31:18] Chair McDonald: else on Zoom that would like to speak? It looks like we have Donna. [1:31:30] Donna Chael: I wanted to make a big thank you to Fran Smith, Allie Burnett, Susan Carnes, and all the town clerk staff. Donna, can I have [1:31:40] Chair McDonald: of you, just restate your name and town. I think you were muted at the beginning. [1:31:44] Donna Chael: Okay. Sorry. Donna Chael Brunswick. Thank you. Okay. So I'll just say it again. I'm happy to say it again. I wanted to thank Fran Smith, Allie Burnett, Susan Carnes, and all the town clerk staff. They worked so hard and put in so many hours to make sure our residents had easy access to free and fair elections. And I appreciate their work. Thank you. Thank you. [1:32:11] Chair McDonald: That's all of our attendees on Zoom. So with that, I will close public comment, and I'm going to turn it over to the manager to perform the manager's report. [1:32:20] Town Manager: Thank you, Chair McDonald. So I'll start quickly with the financial reports from October. Things look pretty much in line with what we would expect. Our two largest loan property tax revenues, state revenue sharing, a little bit lower than last year by about $16,000 for the month. but above the anticipated budget, so excise tax was also lower than last year, just for the month, but both of those revenues are ahead of where we hope to be for the budget year to date. On the expenditures report, there were, in October, $12.8 million in expenditures. This gives you an idea of the total cost of our town. three and a half million was debt service payments because we do make our debt service payments right at the end of october because they're due november 1st 5.7 million was the school department and 3.6 million was municipal departments 73 percent of the municipal expenditures were for wages and benefits which is a typical ratio and again this time i put some pie charts into the manager's report because I know some people appreciate looking at it graphically as opposed to just numbers on a page. I'll also just tell everyone that on November 3rd, the Finance Committee received a draft unaudited annual comprehensive financial report. That is our big financial report. The Finance Committee was able to take a look at that and also heard a report from the auditor on the audit process. The audit process is not finished. That report is under review right now. We are pushing them to finish looking at it. So hopefully that will be soon. So next, election. [1:34:21] Town Clerk: We had an election. It's over. No. No. We had a record-breaking turnout for a governor's race. We had a total of 13,653 voters, of which 60% of those folks absentee voted. So it was around a little over 8,000 people absentee voted, which, again, is a record number. The only other times that we've had more people participate were the last two presidential elections. So overall, of our active voters, we had an 81% turnout, which I'm willing to bet is probably pretty much, unless you're in a town of 300, one of the leadings in the states. I think it just shows how engaged the people are in this community. And again, I can't thank my staff enough. They put a lot of hours in. Allie put in 67 hours in extra in one month, along with other staff. and obviously our many, election workers and those who help with the absentee processing and all of that stuff. There's just absolutely no way that four people could process 8,000 absentee ballots. So we hope to, again, always continue to be a leader, and we're looking forward to a quiet June next year in anticipation of what we'll be following after that. [1:35:42] Town Manager: Thank you, Clerk Smith. And once again, Councilor Timmy, stole my thunder please always i mean we've heard a lot about the airport master plan update public meeting it is this thursday at 5 30 right here there you can there's a zoom option and but it will also be televised just like these council meetings 5 30 on thursday this [1:36:09] Councillor Ellis: this thursday you have a question counselor pearl i have i have a couple questions because it's asked a lot and brought up kind of tonight, what can the town of Brunswick actually say to Mira about their choices? My understanding from the very beginning was that they were in charge and that Brunswick didn't have any say as to what was going to happen, but that Mira was, like, years ago, back when it was established and stuff. But I'm just curious, like, what actually can we do to influence? That's question one. [1:36:53] Town Manager: So the town has the zoning authority, right? I mean, I'm looking at our planning and our economic development. So any building that happens there does have to go through the town development process. So that is where it is. I mean, the plan is one thing. but when they actually want to build something that is in the plan it does have to come to the town just [1:37:20] Councillor Teemee: to add on it does that include on the executive airport portion of it which i know is cordoned off as sort of a separate unit yes continue council parole so my second question [1:37:31] Councillor Ellis: is more about as they're planning this expansion and with the knowledge that eventually Julie Brunswick is going to be given back the property and it will become part of our community they're supposed to be making upgrades and repairs to certain things the biggest one that I could mention is the roads and they don't seem to be doing that oh sorry thanks Nathan they don't seem to be doing that and now they're asking for a big expansion which potentially could add to other but it certainly pulls their focus and their financial commitment away from doing what we're expecting so what kind of recourse do we have on that besides saying to them well we won't accept the property when it comes time but is there something that we can do to ensure that they're actually doing what they're supposed to be doing and not just thinking about expanding and adding more items that they need to pay attention to rather than the infrastructure there. [1:38:47] Town Manager: So there are two parts to this. One, the airport is distinct from the rest of Brunswick Landing. I don't think the town intends to ever take over as the airport authority. So that's one thing. There's what happens on the airport, and that's what this airport master plan is about. It's really about that area. Your bigger question is, what about Brunswick Landing, where we do expect someday that all of those roads will become the responsibility of the town. Mid-coast regional redevelopment authority was never intended to stay forever. The control that this council has is the TIF revenues. Because those that Mira does not have taxing authority. The majority of their capital funding comes from TIF revenues, and they come to the town each year, the council, and they make a request of a certain amount, and they tell the council what they want to spend it on, and the council approves it. And we can insist that they spend it on that. Historically, it has been on capital. They have always brought their capital improvement program. They've used TIF revenues to upgrade the sewer so that the Brunswick sewer district would take it over. I Completely agree with you about the roads and our executive director Stevenson also really agrees about the roads So but that's what I would say That's how we have a way to say you have to spend this money on this and that is a big chunk of money [1:40:25] Councillor Wilson: council record On that note, typically by now we would have gotten that budget. Is there any update from MIRA on when we will see that? [1:40:36] Town Manager: I'm expecting it any time. Of course, once the letter comes, then we have to convene the TIF committee. The TIF committee goes in depth with MIRA and then brings a recommendation to the council. So at this point, it's probably not going to get to the council until January. just the way scheduling goes. But, yes, you're right. Normally it would come in September or October. [1:41:01] Councillor Wilson: And just one other perhaps suggestion to get into the queue is to have the executive director come report to the council here. That's been done in the past, and that's been very helpful to actually have the opportunity for the council to ask him questions in public about numerous issues. [1:41:20] Town Manager: Yes, thank you. I need to get that on the calendar. [1:41:23] Councillor Wilson: If I give one final thing here, there's one way we also have some influences through the board and board members. And I don't know if there's any update on where the nominees are that were outstanding that we helped put together or if we can get an update on that as well. [1:41:47] Town Manager: I'll ask. the last time I asked of course the legislature isn't in session and so that you know they there was nothing and but I'll see what I can find out what the [1:41:58] Councillor Teemee: plan is thank you councillor Ellis I was gonna add another point of and I'll use the word quite frankly of leverage that we have with them is not only in the annual approval of the budgets that they come to and how you know their budget will be set up in using the TIF dollars but it's my understanding that we're We're fast approaching the cap in which the original agreement called for, expiring potentially within the next two years, three years. And when it hits $15 million, there's nothing that requires us to extend that. And so if we don't feel like we're getting movement on the money that we're putting forward to resolve the issues that need to be resolved out there, that's another point of leverage that there's nothing that says we have to keep giving them half of the TIF revenue out there. Now, I'm not foolish enough to think that creates a better financial situation for us because then we own it, but if we believe that they're mismanaging that part of the project of rehabbing this facility to be able to have it turned over, certainly we don't want money being wasted towards that. And I want to make crystal clear that I'm not saying that related to the economic development. I think that they've really focused on that, and you just need to look around to other base redevelopments that have happened in the past. this one I think has gone well in that regard but some of the key issues that we have again how it's going to be turned over but also how specific issues such as PFAS are being handled within their management and I think that it is also a point of leverage for whatever influence that they have over the executive airport and how that development process is going to be working, they need to recognize that, yeah, we don't have any material. We don't have a vote at the table on this, but we do hold the purse strings by which they pay their bills. And so it would be wise for them to collaborate with us, I think, would be my advisement. Councilor Teamie. [1:43:55] Councillor Perrault: So I know that a number of residents have reached out about airplane noise, some specific types but also just generally and in digging into that at the time I know that our options for regulating an existing airport are very limited but what I did see repeatedly was you know new builds expansions things like that under zoning that is our opportunity to do that so if we are facing now you know a proposal to expand the airport I think that it would very It very much makes sense for the town to figure out whether that's the people reaching out to the council or the council itself, figuring out what we think about that and whether we want to try to have some influence on any potential airport expansion within our zoning rules of what is allowed within Brunswick. because it definitely sounds like there's a substantial number of people who are, you know, either personally impacted or just unhappy about the impacts that Murrah is having on our community. [1:45:07] Chair McDonald: Great. And the airport specifically. Thank you, everyone, for your candor and questions, and we'll continue on the report. [1:45:16] Town Manager: So the next thing is also on Brunswick Landing, but a little happier. beer. The mark ribbon coating, this is the Midcoast Athletic and Recreation Complex on Wednesday November 18th at 4.45pm and deliberately just as it's getting dark because it's the sports lighting. So come and play basketball under the lights. This is to celebrate the new basketball courts and the lighting that's on the pickleball courts, the basketball courts and the skate park. And so this is just a quick little ribbon-cutting, and I think they're going to have some games, some pick-up basketball games and that kind of thing. There's a flyer attached here to the council. Anyway, 445, Wednesday, November 18th, out at Brunswick Landing. [1:46:05] Councillor Teemee: Councilor Ellis. Will they have EMT crews out there, just in case some people get the foolish idea to come in? Are you planning something? something. [1:46:15] Town Manager: So I also have done a general update, but in the interest of time, I'm not going to talk about too many of these. I did want to give a quick update on Morse Court. As you remember, this was a road that the town has been taking care of for years and many decades but doesn't actually own and so the council in april agreed to the staff should do the work necessary the legal work to actually acquire that property the survey has been done with councilor pearl's help the and all of the property owners have agreed to the transfer of property and now we just have to write up the legal documents So, that should be coming back to the council before too long. Budgeting and assessing workshop. So, we don't usually plan workshops in January for a council that isn't sitting yet, but we do have penciled in on Monday, January 11th at 6.30 p.m., a workshop to talk about how the assessor is doing updates to the assessments every year. I mean, his goal is, and many other municipalities do this as well, is not to get into the situation where you haven't had a revaluation in 10 years and it is very painful. And so it's small adjustments each year. And so we really wanted to talk about that and also use it as an opportunity to kick off the budget season. So we'll talk about how the tax assessments relates to the tax rate Because this and how that all is affected by the budget Because that is always good to review. So that's January 11th, which is a Monday at 6 30 p.m That's penciled in at this point. That's a council workshop [1:48:09] Councillor Ellis: council roll That good. Okay Just curious about if because last year about this time I'm the counselor Lex got invited to like a co-meeting with the school board and just curious [1:48:26] Chair McDonald: if that is in the work yeah so I can actually provide that update so counselor vice chair Hicks and I met with the school board leadership the chair and vice chair and we currently are planning for that in January we talked a little bit we've done it for the for folks who don't know or who might not have seen it before, over the past at least two years, we have had a joint school board and town council meeting where we get together as a unified body, set up the ground rules for some of the things, the ways that we're going to interact with one another to understand the legal requirements, but also to talk about the future budget ahead of us. Councillor Hicks and I met with the school board leadership and we thought that we liked the idea wanted to keep it going but thought it would be prudent to move it to january after the new council is seated just because it was kind of an awkward time frame in november to have an outgoing council making decisions when an ongoing council is kind of like sitting in the audience and like being part of the conversation but not necessarily part of any decision making process so we do have a tentative date on that i'm not gonna say it now just because it hasn't been confirmed because we literally met this past saturday so we but yes it is going to move forward just keep your eye out because as soon as we confirm with the superintendent and with the town manager that the schedule is all set then we'll send an email out yeah so [1:49:54] Town Manager: one last thing i'm i'm going to skip some other things so we're talking about pfas and game animals so last week we received the results of testing for pfas and game animals conducted by IFNW and USDA. Police report that the results were non-detect for PFAS or any analyte. They sampled game on two town properties, Cape Furbish and the McCoy Bay Conservation Area, which is off Bunganuck Road. They sampled seven deer and two turkeys on Cape Furbish and two deer on the McCoy Bay Road. They also apparently sampled two deer and two turkeys from one other private property and those results were also negative. So IFNW told us because those results showed no detectable PFAS, they will not be issuing an advisory, but we have posted those maps and the results in the kiosks in those areas for the information of hunters because there is hunting allowed loud on Cape Furbish and the McCoy Bay Conservation Area. And that's all I have. [1:51:06] Councillor Hicks: Councillor Hicks, question? Yeah, I didn't know if you had any updates about your investigation in curbside pickup for LEAF. So we have talked to two vendors, asked for quotes, [1:51:19] Town Manager: still waiting for quotes, but I've talked to two vendors. It keeps moving, okay. Yeah,, sorry, slow. Councilor Weems? [1:51:29] Councillor Wilson: Yes, I'd like to go back just briefly to the question of zoning provisions relating to the airport. The discussion is basically that our, quote, leverage, end quote, rests on our zoning provisions. And I think it would be useful to have at least a summary presentation about what those provisions are. For example, if there's a table that says American do airport-related projects on the airport, that's one thing. If there are more specific requirements that are in the zoning code that actually give us some say about what happens under the master plan, it would be good to have a sense of what that is. And we don't have that as we sit here tonight. [1:52:33] Chair McDonald: The manager has made note to do the research. [1:52:37] Councillor Ellis: Councilor Perl. Sorry, one last thing. just i guess like with all of this coming up and stuff it made it dawned on me that like since joining like we haven't had like a real update on any communications that you're having with mira regarding the pfas cleanup and is there still like regular communication on there what are they doing in regards to this i'm not expecting you to answer it right now but maybe to insert that back into your managers report just I mean even if there hadn't been anything in two weeks you know it's okay to say that but maybe some regular because we're all aware that the cleanup is going to be decades cleanup and but just to know like what are they doing in regards to that noted [1:53:36] Chair McDonald: all right moving us along here because i know we got some fine folks in the audience that want to talk about some of the things on our agenda today so i'm going to move us along to our public hearings this is item number 130 the town council will hear public comments to adopt amendments to appendix a zoning ordinance of municipal code of ordinances chapter 4 section 4.2.5.b to allow planning board to waive or modify the maximum impervious service coverage requirement for municipal facilities and we'll take any appropriate action I'm going to open the public hearing and turn this over to our planning and development deputy director dealman to introduce the item thank you it's good to be back in person [1:54:16] Staff Planner: so I'll have my slide deck pulled up momentarily we'll get started so good evening tonight staff are introducing proposed zoning amendments that would allow the Planning Board to waive or modify the maximum impervious surface coverage requirement for municipal facilities when specific criteria is met next slide to recap these zoning amendments are being proposed because existing municipal sites often have limited space which can which they can outgrow as they expand their operational needs these amendments would provide a way for these facilities to seek zoning relief from the Planning Board when these site constraints occur. A recent example of a municipal project needing flexibility is the Brunswick Police Station, which is currently seeking to provide additional parking needed for its department operations, but the site has reached its maximum impervious surface coverage allowed in the GR6 district. Next slide. So next, I'd like to follow up on the November 2nd council discussion about the proposed amendments. First, the council had asked for clarification on what it means for stormwater impacts to be adequately addressed in the waiver criteria. Second, the council asked what measures the town would use to manage additional runoff if the planning board allowed for more impervious coverage on a municipal site. and there was also discussion raised with concerns that the amendment could create two sets of standards one for the town and one for private developers so over the next few slides I'll walk through the staff's response and the changes we've proposed to the draft amendment excellent the updated zoning amendment drafts you have in front of you tonight includes several changes the first change narrows the scope of the waiver. Staff wanted to focus on municipal sites where space for improvements may be limited. So under the revised drafts, only municipal facilities within the town's designated growth area would be eligible for the waiver. We also moved the proposed language to section 4.2.5b, which speaks to the variations and exceptions conceptions to dimensional standards, more of an administrative change on that. So to give you a sense of how much land we're talking about, we worked with our GIS administrator to identify properties within the designated growth area that contain active municipal facilities. Those properties are shown on this map in blue. together they account for about one 1.1% of land within the designated growth area and we can pull up this map after the presentation if you want to zoom in but these are just kind of a high level kind of showing you where they where they are in the designated growth area next slide so again instead of proposing a broad exception to the zoning requirements the waiver from the Planning board would only be possible if two criteria are met. The draft amendments were updated so that the first criteria now clarifies what adequately address adequately addressing the stormwater impacts means. Staff have expanded the language to identify the specific types of impacts that the town engineer would review and provide a recommendation about to the planning board. Those include finding that the downstream water quality impacts have been assessed and stormwater control measures are put in place and that the stormwater runoff would not cause or worsen off-site flooding ponding erosion and not exceed the capacity of any receiving storm drainage system and to answer the question that was raised at the last meeting about what kinds of approaches the town could use to address greater stormwater impact i've listed out some examples here on the right in blue so for example to prevent downstream water quality impacts storm water could be rooted through a soil filter vegetated buffer or other filtered media for preventing off-site flooding and ponding some techniques could include directing storm water to a landscaped basin or an underground storage system using permeable pavers or providing a retention basin or a wet pond for detention and to prevent erosion a vegetated swale or stabilizing slopes or other potential approaches so i'll mention i will also mention that the town engineer is currently out on medical leave so staff consulted a stormwater engineer at the cumberland county soil and water conservation district regarding the proposed amendment language he noted that chlorides from road salts are a major factor in the impairment of water quality of our streams and he recommended that we include language about assessing the downstream stream impacts so tonight the modified language in front of you is provided to help promote improved water quality in our urban impaired streams and help prevent future stream impairments and the second criteria is essentially unchanged and the draft which describes the planning board needing to determine based on an alternatives analysis submitted by submitted with a development application that no reasonable alternative would accommodate the municipal use or facility on the lot next slide and finally the council had asked or had raised a concern about creating a waiver available only to the town staff wanted to tonight to reiterate that under the current zoning ordinance private developers can apply for contract zoning to request relief from zoning requirements. However, the town's attorney has advised that the town should not use that process for its own projects. And so the proposed waiver tonight would give the planning board limited authority to waive or modify impervious surface coverage requirements for municipal facilities, specifically within the designated growth area, provided that those two criteria are met. excellent and again on october 13th the planning board reviewed the proposed amendments for consistency with the town's comprehensive plan and found they were consistent several provisions of the comprehensive plan support the proposed amendment including the plan's vision of improving access to necessary public services and facilities one example is key policy area h which encourages is the town to maintain and improve its municipal facilities and plan for future needs the amendment advances that policy by allowing the town to improve existing sites without acquiring or developing additional property last slide so tonight it is requested that the town council review and adopt the updated draft of the proposed zoning amendments that's been shared with the council this evening and julia and i are happy to answer any questions thank you questions of [2:02:10] Chair McDonald: council councillor [2:02:13] Councillor Teemee: ellis so i'm just in case anyone is worried which i'm sure you're not i'm better with the rules for the not for me issue because again it just didn't looking at it really is no great feasible way and what you pointed out with the thing there is a path so i appreciate the follow-up on that but i'm better with that scenario i did have a question from the notes that you provided which were great of the meeting that you had the staff review on this taylor the code enforcement officer referenced specifically language that addressed the minimum necessary to achieve this and i noted on the final draft in section 4.2.5 11 b11 whatever that minimal amount necessary is no longer a part of that language And again, his comment in here was, I guess my third concern is already addressed, too, because it basically says limited to the minimum necessary to accommodate municipal use of the facility. That's no longer the language. So my question is, was that purposefully removed? Was it – does it get covered somewhere else? Is it – [2:03:21] Staff Planner: I don't think it was purposely removed. I think we just – in the iterations of the draft, we started to fine-tune it. And I think the alternatives analysis may have been where we kind of went towards that direction to make sure that there was a justified effort put forward before the planning board to justify that number versus, you know, describing a minimum, which is more kind of a vaguer approach. [2:03:48] Councillor Teemee: Okay. And then with the, I noted there were, this whole thing is based on the fact that the town is going to be responsible for the remediation of this on the go forward, right? Like that's part of why we feel more comfortable with doing this. What's the feeling, understanding, position related to some of our quasi-governmental organizations that we also seem to be granting this to, be it the sewer district or the water district, I think, that maybe falls into this? I mean, do we have those same protections if we're extending that to them? Because, I mean, I know they have their own capital budgets, their own capital projects. [2:04:26] Staff Planner: Yeah, I think there's still property development standards that any project of a certain scale or reaching a certain threshold is subject to meeting treatment and stormwater runoff quantity standards. So, there's a number of different layers that, you know, larger projects would be subject to. So, I, and given that there's pretty robust criteria now embedded into this language, I think we're comfortable with how things will be evaluated. [2:04:58] Councillor Teemee: Okay. But they would have access to the same exception, if you will. Right. That's right. Okay. And then the other thing, and this is just more technical nuance. We very explicitly write in here that one of the requirements is that the town engineer, does that cover us in situations when the town engineer is not available like we have now, or is that the language that we would use, or do we have to put or designee or something along that line? [2:05:21] Staff Planner: I don't know how. I think we would default to a designee, but I think staff support adding that language in or designee to the draft presented this evening. [2:05:32] Councillor Teemee: Oh, I didn't see that in there. [2:05:33] Staff Planner: Or no, I mean we're supportive right now, like responding to your comment. [2:05:37] Councillor Teemee: Yeah, and again, I really appreciate that you reached out to somebody who was knowledgeable, who wasn't even on staff, because you're fulfilling the intent of the requirement, which is good. Councilor Ecker. [2:05:50] Councillor Wilson: Yes, thank you, Deputy Director Dielman, for taking into account the comments from the planning board and the council feedback. back. Question, the draft that we were given tonight and what you said earlier about the input from Cumberland County Soil and Water Conservation about addressing degradation of the receiving body. So when I read 11A, it says that the downstream water quality impacts have been assessed and stormwater control measures are put in place and then it goes on to talk about what to me are stormwater quantity issues that are being addressed so how is the chloride issue being addressed or [2:06:38] Staff Planner: not degrading water quality I think the big takeaway that we had from our speaking with the stormwater engineer was essentially to make sure that was an aspect being considered. It's kind of a newer territory or a more nuanced thing to evaluate. So the big recommendation was to just make sure that the town engineer was integrating that into the review somehow. And I think the town certainly could in the future take a more specified approach on how to evaluate that but given that there really isn't much of a frame framework for evaluating you know the salts being shed into the urban impaired streams at this point we just wanted it at this point make sure that it was incorporated into his the things informing his recommendation okay just to follow up there i think i read someplace else in the [2:07:46] Councillor Wilson: packet that notwithstanding what i just said it doesn't take away the authority of or any of the rules related to the regulation of the receiving bodies in other words if there are standards in place in the receiving body then we'd still have to meet those is that correct that's right yeah [2:08:04] Staff Planner: i wouldn't supersede any anything else it would just be in addition to yep [2:08:10] Councillor Wilson: okay all right thank [2:08:13] Chair McDonald: Further questions of council? Councilor Hicks. [2:08:16] Councillor Hicks: I was curious if a private developer wanted a waiver, and they would go through a contract zoning process. Would this ordinance be a template, or basically a set of suggestions, and what's being required of municipal entity when trying to get a waiver? Would this be used in the same way? or would this be referenced when asking the developer for certain benefits or certain steps to take to address stormwater? [2:08:53] Staff Planner: I think that would be staff's expectation is to recommend that as a minimal thing to incorporate into their application for a contract zone to make sure that 's incorporated either during the rezoning or during the development review process that it's a condition. I think having language set into our ordinance will give more weight to being able to ask for those kind of things later in a contract zoning review. [2:09:24] Councillor Hicks: Just having more specific requests, requirements in the ordinance anywhere probably helps. Oh, yeah. ensure that maybe we have a unified approach to this. So, thank you. Councillor Teemee? [2:09:41] Councillor Perrault: So, the instigating event here that brought this to us is obviously the parking at the police station. Do you have any idea of how much pressure there is on the short term for that? I'm just thinking about, you know, we're going to be considering at some point here whether to consider this an emergency and waive our rules if somebody decides to make a motion to vote on it is there a staff opinion on whether this is an emergency or whether this is just something that we should be addressing [2:10:21] Staff Planner: within our zoning ordinances I think normally planning our department's preference is to try to wait for you know recode this however was something more of a priority operation for operations to continue and they it was more of a like an urgent priority for them so that's why we felt it was necessary to bring it for you in advance of that but that said during the recode process we can certainly you know look into obtain the public's feedback and try to have more detail a detailed approach in the future but for now this would be at least a stopgap measure to ensure municipal projects had a path forward.
Public Comment
[2:11:08] Chair McDonald: Further questions before I move to the public comment? Not seeing any questions, I will open the floor to public comment on this item. Just like always, you'll have three minutes to speak. Say your name, town of residence, pronouns if you'd like, and please follow the code of conduct posted on either side of the room. [2:11:32] Paul Whitcomb: Hi, my name is Paul Whitcomb. I'm from Brunswick. I would caution the council on using any kind of exception in this case because it seems to me that there's been no discussion of exactly, precisely what the problem is with parking behind the police station. It could very well be that this is a policy issue and not an infrastructure one. Until we know exactly what the problem is, we can't arrive at a solution. I think that's about all I need to say right now. Now, I've kind of lost my train of thought, but I would really caution the town council about using contract zoning, or this type of exception, when it's very possible that there could be a policy change that could rectify the situation and we don't have to go paving more land that has some inherent beauty in it, and I just see the town council approving this all too often where paving and development happens when it doesn't really need to. So I think you really need to ascertain exactly what the problem is and approach it from a perspective of policy change. Thank you. Thank you [2:13:41] Chair McDonald: Sir, anybody else in the room that would like to speak on this item not seeing anyone getting up. I'm going to go to zoom We have Jennifer Navarro [2:13:53] Jennifer Navarro: Yes, good evening Jennifer Navarro Brunswick resident and I'm speaking in opposition to item 130 Which would authorize the planning board to waive or modify maximum impervious surface coverage requirements for municipal facilities My concern is not simply about impervious surfaces My concern is about accountability, oversight, and the continued expansion of discretionary authority without sufficient checks and balances. The Planning Board already exercises considerable authority over development in Brunswick. It reviews site plans, grants, condition approvals, considers modification, and determines whether projects meet our ordinance standards. Yet I have repeatedly raised concerns about how those standards are being applied, how decisions are documented, and whether applicants are being held to consistent requirements. We have seen development approvals followed by subsequent amendments, extensions, and requests for additional accommodations. We have also seen questions raised about whether original approval conditions were adequately addressed before projects moved forward. When residents challenge those decisions, they face a complicated and often expensive appeals process. So I have a very simple question. Who is holding the planning board accountable? Before council delegates yet another waiver authority, shouldn't we first examine how the board is exercising the authority it already possesses? Impervious surface limits exist for a reason. They help manage stormwater runoff, drainage, flooding, and the environmental impacts on development. They are not arbitrary restrictions. And at Cook's Corner, where infrastructure needs have been discussed for decades, including concerns dating back to the early 1990s, these questions deserve particular attention. We continue to discuss economic development, TIFs, public investments, yet residents deserve to know what measurable infrastructure improvements have already been delivered. Are we addressing the underlying infrastructure deficiencies, or are we continuing to make exceptions that accommodate development without resolving the larger problem? I also question why municipal facilities should receive additional flexibility without clearly establishing safeguards. government should be setting the example for compliance with its own development standards not creating the appearance of a separate standard for itself in my opinion there have been enough concerning planning board's decisions after the fact modifications and unanswered questions about consistency to warrant a serious review of the approval process i am not suggesting that every waiver is inappropriate i'm saying that discretion without transparent findings measurable standards and meaningful oversight creates opportunities for inconsistent treatment. Before granting this authority, I ask Council to establish clear eligibility criteria, require written findings supported by evidence, examine cumulative stormwater impacts, and provide a meaningful process for public scrutiny. Most importantly, I ask Council to examine whether our existing development standards are being consistently enforced. Accountability should come before expanded authority. The Planning Board should not be given broader discretion simply because doing so would make municipal projects easier to approve. The public deserves confidence that the rules are applied fairly. These exceptions are justified in that someone is independently examining whether the system is working as intended. And I question if we should create an annual waiver log for the end of the year review that public could see what waivers have been granted, how many times, and what contract zonings were suggested or implemented, and any such sort of waiver for the like. Thank you for hearing my comment. [2:17:26] Chair McDonald: Seeing no one else in the room coming up to the podium and no one else on Zoom, I'm going to officially close the public hearing. Tonight, we have the option to waive our rules to vote on this evening. For a show of hands, if you would like to waive our rules to vote on this, please show your hands. We got one, two, three, four, five, six. Okay, that's majority. So I would entertain a motion. [2:17:48] Councillor Wilson: Councilor Weems. Yes, thank you, Chair. I'd like to make a motion to adopt amendments to Appendix A, Zoning Ordinance of the Municipal Code of Ordinances, Chapter 4, Section 4.2.5.B. To allow the planning board to waive or modify the maximum impervious surface coverage requirement for municipal facilities. [2:18:12] Chair McDonald: Motion by Councilor Weems, seconded by Councilor Wilson. Do we need to add language to that motion that says as presented? [2:18:18] Staff Planner: As presented would be good. Yeah, because the draft tonight is what we're seeking to be approved. [2:18:24] Councillor Wilson: That's exactly as I meant to say it. Great. [2:18:27] Chair McDonald: So we got an okay from as presented from the motioner. Same thing with the seconder. Are you okay with that language? Yes, I am. Okay. Great. Discussion? [2:18:39] Councillor Ellis: Councilor Peral. A few things. One is that I still see this as a rule for the not for me kind of issue that to make an exception for municipal facilities and not for the general development in the town sets a precedent and I think we as a community or our planning we do offer a lot of waivers and we have rules for a reason and I think that we need to follow those rules and if we need and in some instances if we don't think that is serving the community well then we need to change the whole rule, not for just a specific thing. One other thing, my husband, well, two other things, actually. One thing is my husband pointed out, we keep talking about impervious surfaces. Why aren't we looking at an option of a pervious surface in this option to stay within the ordinance and not make an exception to it? The other thing is that not that long ago, this council approved a project for downtown that everybody dismissed the parking issues. And now we're basically giving an exception to municipal facilities to have more parking. But we did not hold that same standard to our downtown. And part of the reason was because there was a noticeable going back to a parking study about downtown, which, again, anybody that has driven downtown during the peak hours knows that there are very few parking spaces. But observationally, I have driven by the police department multiple times during the day and see available parking. So I'm not sure that we have actually truly assessed whether or not this is a necessary thing. Mr. Whitcomb He laughs he would be so happy that I'm referring to That he pointed out that are we actually assessing? What the needs are and how is it going to be best to service those needs? I just I think it's a really bad precedent for us to separate us from public development [2:21:17] Councillor Wilson: Councillor Weems. Yes, thank you, Chairman McDonald. I'd like to address that specifically, Councillor Peralta. First of all, I want to say at the outset, I am a very, strong supporter of the impervious service limitations in our zoning ordinance. I think that's a really important environmental provision that we need to hold people's feet to. nonetheless there are always there are sometimes reasons to look at some flexibility and the possibility of a waiver or an alteration on those provisions and i'm very encouraged by the work that the planning and development department did to require the strict alternatives analysis, as a condition here, I think that's a very important element in limiting when a waiver or alteration would occur, because I think in many cases there will be an alternative that will turn up and be proven to be practical. So I think that is a very key element here that makes me support this idea. And then next, the discussion about the contract zone avenue for a private developer, I think, is significant in that it basically levels the playing field and allows this provision to be accessed by both municipal and private development interests, particularly if the image that was put forth earlier about applying the same kind of criteria to a contract zone application are applied. I think that takes care of that fairness provision pretty adroitly. And lastly, I would point out that this is restricted to the designated growth area of the community, which is a minor and specific area that we've said we want to funnel our development into. So that's when these kind of provisions are more likely to come up and deserve some flexibility and an alternative analysis in the process. that's been described here. So I'm very comfortable with both the fairness, the limitations, and the specific nature of this proposal and will be planning to support it. Councillor Ellis? [2:23:56] Councillor Teemee: This is not intended to convince you one way or the other on anything, but as you know, I was in a very same place last week. But the one thing, and I think I'd ask whether I'm correct in this finding or not, but one of the big reasons why you don't want to make it completely even, And I would argue that even though it is available to come through contract zoning, part of the decision or discussion, I would believe part of the reason why we're putting in this in the growth district is because the paths for remediation through our stormwater system are there. And from reading on this, some of the reasons why municipal being able to do this is because of the scope and scale of what municipal would impact on this stormwater system. If you look, you guys highlighted just six or seven or eight buildings in there. If this were open broadly to the public, it's a capacity issue, I think, of the stormwater system program that is the greater concern, like if you made this broadly available. And so even though it is available on exception-type basis through contract zoning, I would think that wouldn't mean that we would approve it for everybody, even if they came up with the same stormwater remediations, because we only have certain capacities within our stormwater system. Is that an accurate component of why municipal is often thought of as separate? [2:25:13] Staff Planner: Yeah, I think contract zoning would be very case-by-case basis, and I think anything could be looked at as part of that review process. So it's a high bar to meet to receive a contract zone. So, yeah, certainly that's part of what's being factored in. [2:25:32] Councillor Teemee: And if we had every big-box store in town asking for that variance, we might, again, because the contract zones would come before us, we might render judgment that it's too much for the town collectively, right? Not just on a one-by-one basis. Is that? [2:25:46] Staff Planner: Right. I think that's like during a contract zoning review, if there's question about its stormwater impact, you could certainly ask for more information to justify an increase in intensity on a particular property. So, yeah, and I think Councilor Hicks' point about any contract zoning could, you know, look at this language also and as a model for what's expected. And I think that would be our staff's recommendation. If there's exceptions to the impervious surface for private developers going forward through contract zoning, that this would be a place to start. [2:26:27] Councillor Teemee: Okay, thank you. Councilor Hicks? [2:26:30] Councillor Hicks: Yeah, I was just going to add on that. I support this mostly because I believe that, you know, there's only 1% of our growth area has municipal properties. It's a blip. It does seem like it's going to create a little bit more, some more efficiencies. I also think that town staff would not recommend a waiver for something that was going to add pressure on a stormwater system that our town manages. So I think we, as a town, when we're making changes to our own properties, we know that we will be the ones maintaining those properties in a certain way or dealing with the impacts that our properties are creating. and then we pay that cost as well and so I think there's just it's just more insular and I think that it's just a different animal than a private developer that doesn't really have a lot of skin in the game when it comes to infrastructure beyond what's on their property and I just think if this is what is needed for us to also grow within the growth area and eliminate the need to go outside of the growth area to get some sort of relief, I support that as well. Councilor Ecker? [2:27:51] Councillor Wilson: Yeah, so I'll just say that as a rule, I don't like exempting the government from standards it imposes on everyone else. But in this case, in this specific case, we're looking for a reprieve for the impervious a surface standard, but still, if I understand it right, they have to meet the engineering standard of not exceeding pre-development runoff levels. Is that correct? That's right, [2:28:19] Staff Planner: unless they request a waiver. So there is a high bar to meet this and the property development standards as well. Okay. [2:28:33] Councillor Wilson: I'm just reading this that unless they request a waiver, because it may be waived, but they still need to meet 11A, if I read it right. They're getting a waiver from the impervious standard, but not the runoff requirement. [2:28:53] Staff Planner: Let me just brush up on the zoning ordinance to make sure I'm not misspeaking here. [2:29:07] Chair McDonald: Well, hold for a second. [2:29:10] Councillor Wilson: Go to commercial. So they're requesting a waiver from the impervious surface standard, But they have to they have to meet that they're not going to worsen or cause downstream [2:29:34] Councillor Teemee: So there [2:29:41] Staff Planner: is there's I mean the requirement for comparing the pre and post rates For a 25 year 24 hour stormwater event can't be waived studies and calculations Being reviewed by the town engineer or assigned third party reviewer that can't can't be waived So under D3, developments that cannot control peak runoff rates through its pre-development conditions may submit a request for waiver to the review authority. And then there's three pretty – there's three thorough standards on what you need to do in order to be granted that waiver. so that would that would be in addition to the standards we're looking at this evening but what you're reading from is that for everybody that's for [2:30:37] Councillor Wilson: everybody okay yeah but again if I'm reading that what we got handed here we're just waving the impervious surface standard we're not waving because a says right in it that it won't cause or worsen off-site flooding ponding erosion or exceed the capacity of any storm drainage system so that's not being weighed [2:31:01] Staff Planner: that's that's separate and that would still be in place yeah okay so given that given [2:31:09] Councillor Wilson: that these facilities are limited given that there is a pathway through the contract zoning for a developer to do it i can get on board with this i'm hoping that during the recode process that will look at this harder so we can even the playing grounds so these kind of things don't have to come to the council to get approved and this applies to the designated growth zone which is where we want growth so if we can meet the standards and grow denser in the growth zone which is where we want it then if that's on deck down the road here then I'm satisfied. [2:31:55] Staff Planner: Yeah, we can certainly. That's one of the big things we'll look at during a recode is taking a much more analytical approach to the different areas, watershed areas. Councilor Teemee. [2:32:07] Councillor Perrault: So conceptually, I think this makes sense to me. But I was wondering about under B where it's talking about alternatives, like directly across the street from the police station is a town-owned lot that isn't being used for anything. Do we know if that's been examined as a potential alternative for more parking for the police station? [2:32:28] Staff Planner: I think the assistant town manager may have spoken it to it at the last meeting or somebody did that Operationally for a police station. I think usually there any of their vehicles need to be located on the same lot Because it needs to be a secure securely maintained Facility so I don't think in this case that would be a feasible option But that's my offhand understanding of it. [2:32:56] Chair McDonald: I'll just add into that understanding, too, that part of the reason that parcel was purchased is because the state, hypothetically, is going to be doing something to that intersection and is going to need that land to be able to fix it. Hypothetically. Hypothetically, yeah. Hypothetically. i'm gonna add i'm gonna add two cents into here which i think i suppose is kind of contrary to like initial thought around this process or the policy has outlined or the ordinance has outlined is talking about a waiver for the town to from or what's being perceived as a waiver for the town to not fulfill like an obligation that we are asking other people able to do. And for me, I the way that I'm looking at it is like, it's kind of doing the opposite, because currently, any developer can do contract zoning, contract zoning goes through the planning process, and then comes to us for ultimate decision making. So if the town wanted to seek relief from one of these issues, it would have to go through contract zoning, as well or change the ordinance is that i know that 's the why we don't want to do contract zoning because then we're saying hey we're in contract with ourselves and so we're going to approve whatever we want where like for me what this does is saying hey we realize that we need relief in this area and we need somebody who's an adjudicatory body that's not ourselves to do this we don't have say over the planning board the planning board makes a lot of decisions that people may or may not agree with. And whether or not we agree with it, that doesn't mean that we can change their decision-making process. So for me, it's giving an avenue for the town to actually seek relief, like a developer would have through a contract zone, through an actual, like a fair and impartial process, because it's a different adjudicatory body saying yes or no, rather than ourselves saying yes to something we want. So that's how I'm framing it in my brain, at least. at least that's how i see it is that currently we don't have that ability and if we do have that ability it is not it is a flawed system in which we approve whatever we want where this gives authority to another independent body to make a decision for the town that is not us so that's how [2:35:17] Councillor Ellis: why i'm supporting it counselor pearl just trying to wrap my brain around everything that you just said but the problem is that the Planning Board regularly issues waivers against the rules that we establish so the Town Council is responsible for the rules that the Planning Board is supposed to follow and waivers are given on a regular basis against things that we have established and so I don't think I 'm just concerned if we're we're encouraging more waivers to the process instead of less and I appreciate that we're going through a recode and that might clear up some of the waivers that are happening currently but the problem is that we should not be giving avenues to encourage more waivers and that is a big problem in our town is the waivers that happen and like I know we're not talking about rural but like a big reason why the rural moratorium building moratorium happened was because there were potential waivers that were going to be given to certain developers and that happens on a regular basis and so you have to start question, why do we have the rules that we have if we're just going to give waivers against them? And that is my problem with this, is it literally gives the town a waiver to not follow its own rules. [2:37:01] Chair McDonald: Any further discussion before we take a vote? Not seeing any, I'll call the vote. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Peralta. No. Councillor Hicks. Yes. Councillor Teemee. No. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Yes. the chair is a yes that the motion passes seven no six to two we're down one person thank you thanks moving on to item number 131 the town council will hear public comments to extend the data center moratorium and we'll take any appropriate action i'm going to turn this over to the planning development director erdman to introduce the item good evening i want to i'm officially opening the public hearing sorry okay make sure i say that i just want to take a few [2:37:50] Staff Planner: minutes to walk through where we are with the data center moratorium and why staff is recommending that the council extend it for a little background on june 1st 2026 the town council adopted a 180 day moratorium on new expanded or enlarged data centers with an electrical capacity of one megawatt or greater. The intent of the moratorium was to give the town, excuse me, give the town time to better understand the potential impacts of these facilities and determine what type of regulations might be appropriate. Some of the primary concerns included the demands that these facilities could place on our electrical and water infrastructure, noise, and other potential environmental impacts. On August 3rd, the Council held a workshop to discuss data centers and potential approaches to regulating them. At that meeting, staff presented a preliminary draft of possible zoning regulations. The purpose of that draft was not to present a finished set of regulations, but rather to give Council something concrete to react to and to help frame the policy discussion. We wanted to begin exploring some important questions, such as whether data centers should be allowed in Brunswick at all and if so what types and sizes of facilities might be appropriate. During that discussion it became apparent that a majority of counselors were leaning towards an outright prohibition of major data centers rather than developing regulations that would allow them under certain conditions. The town attorney has advised staff that if the council wishes to pursue an outright right prohibition, we will need to undertake a more in-depth analysis of the potential impacts of these facilities to help support that approach. At this point, staff has not yet identified a consultant available to perform that work. We continue to endeavor to do so. Staff will also be reaching out to other Maine communities currently under a data center moratorium. I think there's around 23 of them currently, to see how they are addressing this issue. And just a side note, North Berwick took this issue to the voters last week and approved a permanent ban on data centers at their local election rather than waiting for town meeting to discuss a moratorium. We'll reach out to them, too, to see what type of research was involved in that, in crafting their ordinance. So why are staff requesting a moratorium extension? extension. We simply need more time to do this work properly. An extension would allow staff to identify and retain a qualified consultant to evaluate potential electrical grid impacts and other infrastructure considerations, as well as further evaluate the potential environmental and community impacts of major data centers. Staff recommends that the Council vote to extend the existing moratorium to provide the time needed to complete this work. Ultimately, staff wants to bring something back to the council that is well-informed, legally supportable, and consistent with the direction that the council wants to take. So with that I [2:41:04] Chair McDonald: will answer any questions you might have. Thank you so much. Questions of council? [2:41:09] Councillor Ellis: Councillor Perl. I'm just curious because in the recent election it seemed like several other states put it to a statewide vote about banning data centers and I know that you guys are having a problem finding the consultant and so just if you're thinking about I know it would be there are different issues for different states and stuff like that but is that another maybe a potential outreach to try to find someone to help with our moratorium and... [2:41:48] Staff Planner: Potentially. There is the main data center advisory council. We can... It seems like they're not looking at any kind of outright prohibition and just regulating even larger data centers than what we're looking at, but I could have a discussion with them about it. Okay. Also, I was going to reach out to the Midcoast Council of Governments to see if there's anything we can do regionally. Maybe they've been working on that. [2:42:18] Councillor Ellis: I know Representative Arford is in the audience, and she and I were just talking a couple days ago, and she might be able to give an update on where the state stands and potentially what's going to happen on the statewide level. A [2:42:37] Chair McDonald: question that I have around the auditorium. I'm presuming that the reason that we need more time to execute this is due to the fact that our council wants to go above and beyond the state template that we had that is correct okay I'm just making sure Councillor [2:43:00] Councillor Teemee: Ellis this is a little tangential but that's me as I'm reading through this I wholly support us supporting you and extending this and would encourage you to continue down through the specific bands. But some of the things that are popping off of this, because we're looking to remediate noise and environmental impacts, two of the big ones that are coming through with this, and I can't help but draw parallels to the conversation we were having earlier with the manager's report about expansion at the executive airport and wondering what level of controls do we have and are those similar to the same oppositions that we might have to data centers in regards to airport expansion. And so I know that, again, tangent, not meant to get an answer, but something I'll be following up to see, again, what levers we have in that regards to ensure Brunswick develops as the people of Brunswick would like it to develop. [2:43:53] Chair McDonald: Further questions of counsel before we turn it over to the public comment? Not seeing any. [2:44:04] Councillor Ellis: Just really quick. Would you like Representative Arford to talk before public comment about what's going on? [2:44:12] Chair McDonald: Sure. Would you like to speak? I don't want to pull you up here unless you would like to. Of course. Come on up and give us an update. [2:44:29] Peggy Siegel: So I am Representative Poppy Arford. I am currently serving my third term representing Statehouse District 101, and I have the significant privilege of having been elected to serve a fourth term. So I will be with you for another two years as one of your local state representatives. And for that, I'm very grateful, by the way. But what I want to say, so the state is working their way through their own evaluation process. I think all of you are aware of that. And the most important thing I could share with you in the public right now is the name, it's called the Maine Data Center Advisory Council. And if anybody Googles that, it will bring you to the page, I just did it, where all the information that you need or would want to know about this, But importantly, they're coming around to closure of this process, which was designed to report out to the upcoming 133rd legislature in January. So on December 10th, and I will send this link to whoever needs to get it so that you can put it in your minutes, et cetera. But on December 10th, they're going to have their public hearing on their draft recommendations. So this is excellent timing. Actually, my sense is that extending your moratorium another six months will allow you time to participate, if you want to, in the state's process and learn from it, their recommendations now, which will be made public. And if you have any desire to do parallel recommendations or use what the state is evolving as their recommendations to support where we end up going, the timing is perfect. If you were to end the moratorium now, you'd be missing out on the richness of all the work that the state's doing because people would go ahead and do whatever they want to do without a moratorium here. Remember, there is no moratorium at the state level now. The bill that would have done that did not pass. This is just a study commission that will be reporting out to the legislature in January. So at that point, at the state level, I'm thinking there will be a number of bills that will be considered in the upcoming session again. I'm happy to share that information with you as a council. You can all participate in the public hearings. There will be a lot of information. and the governor you know we have a brand new governor who's known for her environmental her proclivity to supporting our environment and I'm quite sure that she will also be she in her office will be very involved with this process so there's a lot of good things that are coming ahead and so by extending this moratorium another six months we're positioning Brunswick to take advantage of all this so I highly encourage you to do that and I know there's other people who would like to testify but I will send along the link to the to all this information so you and the public can participate especially in the public hearing and again that date is December 10th thank [2:47:33] Chair McDonald: you very much thank you so much okay without any further questions of counsel I will open the floor to public comment if you would like to make a comment on this item please come up you'll have three minutes say your name town of residence i [2:48:07] Carolyn Eklund: am carolyn ecklund i live in brunswick and i just want to say i'm in wholehearted favor of extending the data center moratorium we know from other states we know we know the data there's overuse of water electricity contamination of the air there's you know pollution and sound pollution So I just want to say I can't imagine pristine, beautiful Maine and delightfully livable town of Brunswick ever, considering a data center here in Brunswick. So I just urge you to expand the moratorium and even urge a ban. [2:48:48] Chair McDonald: Anybody else in the room that would like to speak on this item? Not seeing anyone going to the podium and not seeing anybody's hands on Zoom. I will close the public hearing and I'm going to bring it back to council does council wish to waive our rules to vote on this motion time show of hands if he would like to that is unanimous or majority at least so I will entertain a motion counselor Hicks a motion to extend the data center moratorium motion by counselor Hicks seconded by counselor Wilson I know that you're trying to get in there but got to diversify a little bit. Discussion on the motion. I'll start with Counselor Ecker and then we'll go [2:49:31] Councillor Wilson: to Counselor Peral. So Chair, I'd like to learn more about your comment that you made that we may be going above and beyond or our attorney may be going above and beyond. So I'd like to [2:49:43] Chair McDonald: understand the background to that. Yeah, I guess my context or at least the reason I made that statement is that when we first broached this conversation, we brought forth the state legislation. And that had a, I believe, two megawatt, 20 megawatt ban above 20 megawatts was their buffer. And when we had a discussion here at town council level about that, we decided that was too big for our town. And so we are kind of sculpting, I suppose, more specialty rules than a template that we already kind of have ready to go to be signed. So we're drafting pretty much our own to tailor for our town where there are some other places that are passing ones but they're all different levels different types of functionings and we also at our town from have a couple of small scale data centers so we have to kind of tailor our i guess whatever ordinance that we're going to be put forward to accommodate or factor those pieces of information because saying that we're going to ban yeah there's just there's there's there's other pieces where like if we decided to just move forward with what the state had presented we would already have a ban in place is my is the reason i say i could just respond to that i mean i think [2:51:01] Councillor Wilson: that our pathway or if i were to give guidance on this it's it's for our staff to do enough work that they feel satisfied but not overdo it because i think it's inevitable we're going to pass some kind of severe restriction de facto. And I just hate to see a lot of consulting time or, you know, staff time, which can be used on other items to spend too much time on this. [2:51:33] Chair McDonald: Yeah, I hear you. I agree. I just wanted to make sure to raise that point because we could hypothetically have a ban in place that was the state template already. But, you know, we're just trying to make sure it better fits our community. It wasn't like a judgment either way. [2:51:47] Councillor Ellis: Council Peralta you were next and I'll go yeah just curious I know I've been a part of a few moratoriums now but just thinking ahead if this isn't if this next six months isn't enough time to complete where we want to go like how many moratoriums are we allowed to enact [2:52:09] Town Manager: okay so yes we can just keep going I'll say that on the mic [2:52:16] Chair McDonald: essentially each time we pass one it has us the maximum we can do is six months [2:52:23] Councillor Perrault: counselor teeny and then counselor hicks so first of all a little more context on the state situation the state proposal was not actually a ban it was also a moratorium as a state moratorium so just using their structure would not necessarily have fixed the issue because we're also talking about a moratorium right now, but the other thing I just wanted to bring up, and I guess, actually, let me start with a question that I'm totally going to spring on the town clerk here. Do you know what the cutoff date would be to put something on the June ballot? There is an election in June, right, this next coming year? Yes, there is. Working [2:53:05] Town Clerk: backwards, it would probably be 60 days before the election, so I don't remember off the top of my I have what the June election is, but it would be probably come to the council early March. It'd be settled by early April, so I would have enough time to produce ballots. [2:53:21] Councillor Perrault: That is absolutely enough clarity, so thank you so much. I just would love to say that I think it would be a great idea for us, if we have things ready by then, to send what we have to the voters in brunswick because i think you know we're facing a lot of political divide and something that can be very helpful is to have every because everybody's kind of in agreement on this i mean when we had it here we had people who are very conservative very liberal all sorts of different people speaking against the idea of having data centers and I think it brings people together to see their neighbors who they may not agree with on all issues in definite agreement about something they feel strongly about. So just something to put out there. But I very much support us extending the moratorium another six months. Councillor Hicks. [2:54:16] Councillor Hicks: I was just wondering if this moratorium covers existing data centers that might be incrementally adding to their facility. It does. Yeah. Anything over one megawatt. Okay. And so, and that includes any place that doesn't have to be a data center, any facility, any company that's using, that's adding that much that wants to add [2:54:42] Staff Planner: that much will not be able to do that. I would say yes. If it's, if they have a data center, that's accessory to their principal use that exceeds that wattage, then yes. [2:54:56] Councillor Hicks: Yeah. And then And I guess my other is the whole sneakiness of, well, it may not be one large unit. It's several smaller units that add up to more than that limit. Will this also prevent? I can't imagine what that would look like, and I don't know enough about this. But I just, it's like the same principle of, like, a large landowner that will subdivide so that they're not under the same ordinance because they have smaller parcels. and they're able to get through, you know, it's a loophole. [2:55:28] Staff Planner: I think if they're all on the same lot or the same parcel, if they were divided off of, like, a mother parcel and they're all essentially together, then, yes, it would apply. It's all the same project. [2:55:44] Councillor Teemee: Councillor Ellis. I believe you referenced the North Berwick vote in your thing, and it was pretty convincing in a community that's very different than Brunswick, I would say. It was, like, a 78% vote. So does that manifest itself in it now that is the law, or does that manifest it in now staff has to go and figure out how to implement the law? [2:56:04] Staff Planner: I believe they already drafted their ordinance. [2:56:07] Councillor Teemee: So it was done before, so they were voting on that ordinance. Okay. And is it a possibility to have the ordinance take the approach of, again, if we didn't have any data centers, I love what North Barwick's done, which is just to ban them outright. right, but we have a data center and some smaller ones in town. Is there any way to approach it as a ban on future development with grandfathering in for existing facilities? Is that a potential possibility? Because I'm not looking to throw people out of town, but again, I think that the general sentiment, if I'm reading it correctly, is we just really don't want that type of business [2:56:47] Staff Planner: here? That is a possibility. We're installing some kind of threshold, which is something else that we've been trying to determine what would be the proper threshold, you know, what would be allowable. There certainly are lots of companies that have data centers within their business. They use smaller, like, server rooms, which I don't know that we would want to ban that further [2:57:16] Chair McDonald: discussion not seeing oh yeah counselor weems and then timmy okay [2:57:28] Councillor Perrault: very quick question isn't do we have the i mean not that i'm saying i want to do this but like as far as i understand it we can't just like pass zoning to shut down the existing data center anyway right like if something's already been built like zoning is about when you build new things correct we could it would potentially make it very frustrating if they couldn't make relatively small changes to their current setup but there is really no process here where we're going to be like you know sending people there to shut them down right counselor weems yes thank you and i [2:58:06] Councillor Wilson: i'm just gonna echo the comment i think came from the chair about not making this too complex keeping it keeping it fairly safe maybe it's council record but i'm looking forward to the alternatives to come out of this for us to consider hopefully the outright ban is except for people are already here is one of those alternatives but i don't think we need to spend a lot of money on consultants to look at grid you know loading technology whether or not whether or not we'll empty out our aquifers by the water required to take care of the cooling requirements, whether or not we'll have some sort of an analysis of the possibility of creating heat hotspots because of the heat generated. Let's get something simple and workable and get it done here within the next six months. [2:59:07] Chair McDonald: Further discussion? Not seeing any, I'll call the vote. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Peral. Yes. Councillor Hicks. [2:59:15] Paul Whitcomb: Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Most definitely, yes. The chair is a yes.
New Business
[2:59:21] Chair McDonald: The motion passes unanimously of the council present. Moving on to new business, item 132, the town, as a reminder to folks in the audience, if it is an item to set up public hearing, we won't be taking public comment. We'll be taking it at our next meeting if this is set up. so item number 132 the town council will consider setting public hearing for december 7th 2026 to adopt amendments to part two municipal code of ordinances chapter 11 article 3 shellfishing and we'll take any appropriate action i'm going to turn this over to clerk smith to introduce yeah [2:59:53] Town Clerk: thank you i'll do a quick introduction dan devil will be at the next meeting to provide additional information but essentially every year we come to the town council with our housekeeping amendments. The vast majority of these amendments are that. For example, we're just requiring people who get a commercial license to be at least 14 years of age. We're changing the age for a bushel license from 62 to 60, things of that nature. But the one substantial change that we are making, which kind of came out of the bloom or recommending to be made, is new language which allows for some flexibility around setting license numbers due to, you know, circumstances like the bloom that we had. Typically, we do a, we, not staff, do a survey every year. They start in the summer, go out to the fall to get numbers, and that's what we, there's formulas that we use, and that's how we base how we're going to establish how many licenses that we will recommend to the committee, then the committee will recommend to the council, then the council will adopt. But with the bloom that happened in September and into October, we saw a lot of die-off with no opportunity to actually resurvey that in time to give an accurate number. So if we were to look at the numbers prior to the bloom, the recommendation would be a much higher number than it would be after the bloom. So this allows the flexibility for the committee and the council to look at those circumstances and say, yeah, maybe this is what we're going to do with the licenses this year because we knew we didn't have the proper time to do the surveying. And just so you know, we did run this by the town attorney, and we also ran this. We had a conversation with the Department of Marine Resources, as you probably may or may not be aware of. The council can enact an ordinance around shell fishing, but ultimately the state has to approve it. So we always like to be on top of that and get their pre-approval, even though it's not formal, until after the council approves it. We had a nice conversation, and they liked the idea that we were putting forth and were supportive of it. So what action we're asking tonight is just for the council to start a public hearing for the next meeting, because all ordinance changes when it comes to licensing, we try to have in place by the beginning of the calendar year because that's when we begin the licensing process. So we will be at that meeting, obviously asking you to waive your rules so that we don't need to do it on an emergency basis, but we would like to have it in place within those 30 days. Questions? [3:02:37] Councillor Teemee: Councillor Ellis. Just more. Before we move to approve or vote on the public hearing, not there's one typo in there that i would recommend that we correct on page 24 of 25 of the printed document section 11.142 you have a strikeout that begins harvest of shellfish i think the word the should be included of that so the sentence would read a harvester holding a commercial license or bushel license who aids or abets any other person in the violation of this article so there 's a thought in there that would be okay would you mind just quickly emailing [3:03:13] Town Clerk: that just so i get the right sections yeah we can certainly make that correction [3:03:19] Councillor Perrault: further questions counselor timmy so one small change that i noticed in here that i just wanted to know a little more about is that it appears that and this is probably an edge case but secondary educate like so if somebody goes to like thornton academy and they therefore have their residence outside of brunswick for a chunk of the year but they maintain their residence in brunswick for the rest of it has added it looks like post-secondary as a modifier for educational institution outside of brunswick so this is page two of three in the definition for residence so it looks as though that theoretical person could not have a student's, harvester license. Am I understanding it correctly? And if so, what's the thought process [3:04:11] Town Clerk: behind it? yeah, thank you. we're just, this is talking again about, if for people resident wise, normally what a resident is, you have to live here in the community, right? when it comes to students, we often see that students don't, especially college students, whether they're or they're going or whether they're going to a private high school or whether they're going to college so we added this language in there to allow for that to be considered when somebody is doing their license right but it looks like it own that it looks like that's [3:04:49] Councillor Perrault: only the case for post-secondary educational institutions and not like secondary ones because you said 14 was the age cut off so i'm just thinking about like high schoolers who are going to a boarding high school but might want to have their harvester you know ability [3:05:06] Town Clerk: to harvest shellfish yeah great point we had never kind of thought of that but because you know we often think of maybe someone goes to chevros but they probably come home at night i don't know if they have a dorm there but there are obviously high schools or even younger schools where people go and with student licenses they are only the summer so we can change that to post-secondary [3:05:36] Chair McDonald: Further questions? Not seeing any. As a reminder, we will not have public comment on this. So I will take a motion. Councilor Wilson. [3:05:48] Councillor Costello: I would like to make a motion to set a public hearing for December 7, 2026 to adopt amendments to part 2, municipal code of ordinance, chapter 11, article 3, shell fishing. [3:06:00] Chair McDonald: Motion made by Councillor Wilson. Is there a second? Seconded by Councillor Hicks. Any further discussion on the motion? Not seeing any, I will call the vote. Councillor Ellis. Yes. Councillor Ecker. Yes. Councillor Peralta. Yes. Councillor Hicks. Yes. Councillor Teemee. Yes. Councillor Weems. Yes. Councillor Wilson. Yes. The chair is a yes. The is unanimous of the council present. The motion passes. question for the manager in between here maybe something to put on a future manager's report in either i'm assuming probably january at this point would be an update on some of the bloom efforts that are going on i know that the coastal manager resources manager came in and talked quite a bit about you know there's some partnerships going on and it was going to [3:06:53] Town Clerk: take time to figure out what was going on i think he plans on being at the next meeting anyway so if we could maybe we can maybe ask him to provide that update because I'm sure there's been a lot that's been going on. [3:07:03] Chair McDonald: Yeah. Great. Just because I know that this is kind of like it is our standard operating, but we're making adjustments related to that, I think it'd be good for us to be apprised. Great. Moving on to item number 133. The town council will consider setting a public hearing for December 7th, 2026 to adopt a resolution authorizing the manager to enter into a credit enhancement agreement with P.O.L.L.L.C. and will take any appropriate action, I am going to turn this over to the Economic and Community Development Director Costello to introduce. Thank you, Chair McDonald. Sally [3:07:34] Councillor Costello: Costello, Director of Economic and Community Development. Before I get started, I'm just going to pass out the credit enhancement agreement. There's two small, and I identified where, changes that I will review. Thank you. Okay, so I'm here to talk to you all about the Golic Affordable Housing Application for Credit Enhancement Agreement. And next slide, please. Just a little bit of the project background. I want to orient everybody to where this site is. It's kind of a long, skinny, half-acre site on Thomas Point Road, 23 Thomas Point Road. And back in October of 2024, Representative Golic came to the housing committee. She and her team at the time, Genesis, was the development consultant. Salton, now it is Doriard with Carol Wuerlber here in the audience, came to the housing committee to talk about this affordable housing project and to request support from our affordable housing support fund, specifically $100,000 that would help them score well on an application domain housing for funding. THE HOUSING COMMITTEE REVIEWED THIS APPLICATION AND APPROVED IT AND RECOMMENDED IT TO THE TOWN COUNCIL WHO APPROVED THE GRANT AGREEMENT IN DECEMBER OF 2024. SO THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR A FEW YEARS. and the program is to develop the site for 14 affordable housing units and specifically for workforce housing at 80% area median income. Next slide, please. So this is just a rendering of the project. And you saw that first slide was also a photo of another project that is similar. It's manufactured housing and this product has been done in other communities very successfully it as I said is 14 workforce housing units and main housing is the primary source of funding here and they require that the that the project remain affordable for 45 years our affordable housing support fund requires 30 years so we really I'll just defer to the longer time frame with that. And it's deed restricted, so it runs with the land. So if it is sold, again, or there's an assignment, that restriction will remain active. And the other thing that's really interesting is you probably know that there's a lot of discussion about vouchers and how our landlords aren't required to accept vouchers. Main housing doesn't require that their projects put this in their documents for closing, but they do encourage the projects that they provide funding to really think about accepting these vouchers. And I think Representative Golick has indicated that she's really willing to do that. So I think it's a really good step in the right direction there. Next slide, please. So this is the site plan. I hope this is a little small that you can see. But I just wanted to show it's a long, narrow site with two buildings. And it's called Rosa's Mainway, Main's Way, after your mother or your grandmother? Grandmother. And the one thing I wanted to mention here is that, you know, we've had some discussion. We did bring this to the Finance Committee. And one of the things a couple of them had a little bit of concern about the density here just because it's not typical to see this much density. But the one thing the state is really trying to encourage is more housing and affordable housing. And so this is in the GM4 growth mix zone. And the state statute title 30A section 4364 allows for projects to construct housing units that meet the definition of affordability to receive an additional density of 2.5 times the allowable density on the property. and so this is a half an acre so it's allowed to have about seven units so two and a half times that would actually be like 17 units and they're proposing 14 so it does meet that requirement that threshold rather and again I just to reinforce about the deed restriction for 45 years next slide please so what were the reasons or what are the reasons for this request well there has been extreme project costs have been rising because of the many issues, but partially because of the long time frame in getting this project designed and approved. There was a two-year pre-development period. There were project delays both on the soft and hard side because there were some changing requirements that both the state and local governments put into place. There was, again, I talked about the rising materials, but also operating costs. And then once they get their application approved, there's a locked-in subsidy amount. That's really important here because they do need to have additional funding, but the subsidy amount does not change. So they need to have a higher loan amount, which, of course, has a higher debt service. service. So what we talked about with the Finance Committee was really that this project, when you request a credit enhancement agreement, there are multiple reasons for it. But this one really does fit the but-for situation. As I mentioned, the primary source is affordable housing. Of course, Representative Golick is donating the land as part of this or putting in the land as part of the project. And then we do have the Affordable Housing Support fund 100,000 that's set aside has not been distributed until this closes and is all ready to go but we do have that set aside for this project should it move forward and so what it really does need is to have additional funds from main housing on the loan side the paying debt side but also a reduction in their operating so we have analyzed their performa and all of their financials to do see that they do need this additional reduction on their taxes because a credit enhancement agreement is a negotiated tax reduction, and so it's a reimbursement, so you pay full value and then you get reimbursed. So it is needed for this to be financially feasible at this point. Next slide, please. So the summary of the terms, it's pretty simple. They're requesting a 20-year credit enhancement agreement term. And the TIF revenue split they are requesting is 75% reimbursement to the owner, and 25% would stay with the town. So the total TIF investment over the 20 years is about $833,000, and the average yearly investment is $41,000. So this is all based on the current mill rate of 13.50 cents, which, of course, you know, is an estimate that could change and probably will. And then also, the other thing that we look at for this is, since this is located in a TIF district, this value, this new value is protected, is sheltered, rather, from showing up in our valuation that allows us to get, it affects our state aid to education, so the amount that we receive for that, and then the amount that we pay in county taxes. So that's a pretty big value there of $565,000 that we wouldn't realize if this project doesn't go forward. They did go to planning, obviously got their planning board final development plan review you in June 23 of 2026, then they also had an amendment that had to go back to the planning board. And that amendment was approved in September the 22nd of 2026. So the other thing I wanted to really mention is just the partnership with Maine Housing. Maine Housing has been a great partner with the town in providing a community solutions grant. And this really fits the niche of what those funds are for. This is 100% affordable. And sometimes some of the projects we give are not quite 100%. 100% is a very hard thing to do, especially when you don't have the economies of scale and there aren't that many units. So this project is really a tight project. project and then again I will just you know can't stress that enough that this project will not go forward if it does not have two things it's going to need the credit enhancement agreement but it's also going to need additional funding from main housing so main housing you know has been very supportive of the project thus far and I think you know the credit enhancement agreement will be the thing that really pulls them over the finish line. Next slide, please. So the request is that we set a public hearing for December the 7th on this proposed CEA. And the two minor changes that were in there that were actually the property site said that it was – excuse me, let me just get my glasses on so I can read it properly. really? I marked it for you, but just to say that, so POL is obviously the LLC that is the ownership entity, but the place of business is in Brunswick, Maine, and I think we had Augusta, I think we were thinking about the owner specifically and not the entity. So that's a change. And then the other change is that there was just a typo. It said lot 137, and it's lot lap 37. So we did make those changes and post that to the website, but I wanted you to have the accurate document before you decided to move forward with setting the public hearing. [3:17:56] Chair McDonald: Great. Questions? Thank you. Questions of council? Not seeing any questions. As a reminder, we don't have public comment because we are setting the public hearing. We'll have public comment at the public hearing. So with no questions, I will entertain a motion. councillor Weems [3:18:25] Councillor Wilson: Your mics not on councillor Weems. Thank you. Pardon my manners here. I moved a set of public hearing for December 7th 2026 to adopt a resolution authorizing the town manager to enter into a credit enhancement agreement with pol [3:18:46] Chair McDonald: LLC Motion by councillor Weems councillor Timmy. Do you want to second that because I saw that you're also motion. Okay seconded by councillor Timmy Any further discussion? [3:18:57] Councillor Teemee: President, we'll have opportunity for discussion on why we either support or don't support this next meeting. [3:19:03] Chair McDonald: Correct. So this is setting the public hearing. So at the public hearing, we'll take public comment. We can have full debate. We can do whatever. If you want to say anything now, you may. I'll save my comments until then. [3:19:10] Councillor Teemee: I generally support this, but I just wanted to have opportunity to speak to why I support it. Yeah. Yeah. [3:19:16] Chair McDonald: Further discussion? The only two cents that I'll add, which I will also echo during the public hearing, is appreciation for any housing provider that will take a voucher. All too long there is a stigma around housing vouchers. We run into it all the time in the domestic violence world where we get some folks into shelter, we secure them a voucher, and then we can't get them an apartment because no one will take them. So this is both a public service. This will be my bigger pitch that I make next time but this is a public service for affordable housing But it's also a extreme public service and ensuring that people have housing most definitely I'll call the vote councillor Ellis. Yes councillor Acker. Yes councillor Peralta. Yes councillor Hicks. Yes councillor Timmy yes councillor Weems yes councillor Wilson. Yes, the chair is a yes. There's unanimous of the council the public's hearing is set moving on to item number 134 the town council will consider approving the town manager to work with global montello group corporation to execute a donation agreement to accept a land donation for 101 bath road and will take any appropriate action i'm going to turn this back over to the economic and community development director costello to introduce the item thank you chair mcdonald well [3:20:37] Councillor Costello: Well, I am very happy to be here. It's been a long process working to get this donation agreement. Larry, can you pull up the slideshow? Yeah. Just want to give a little overview for the public. I know a lot of you know this is for the 101 Bath Road vacant gas station, but just thought I would take the public through this. Next slide, please. So this is part of our placemaking. You know, we have the three sites I've been talking about for the last year or so. The first one there at Jordan Avenue, that is 87 Bath. The one we're talking about right now is number two. That is 101 Bath Road. And the third one, you know, this is a little bit further down, but that is where the jug handle is when you come out of Brunswick Landing. Next slide, please. Okay, so you can see the condition that it's in right now. It's been vacant for more than a decade. and in very kind of dilapidated and hazardous lighted condition. You can see the little, hopefully you can see that little red peg of where it is, but that is a site that's owned by the Global Montello Group Corporation through Alliance Retail. Next slide, please. And we have been working, staff has been working with multiple departments and staff, I should say, have been working with a consultant to come up with a concept for turning this into a public park. The 87 Bath Road, which I talked to you about before, is the site that we have a long-term lease with MIRA, the Midcoast Regional Redevelopment Authority, that will connect and terminate in this pocket park. The idea is to keep it pretty rustic, reuse the canopy, but kind of clad it with, you know, like a wood kind of, I can't think of the word, wood cladding, I guess you would say. Have some seating and some space for, like, a shade structure for gathering. And then just to have some area in the back, I'm going to show you a more fulsome kind of concept in the next slide, please. so you can kind of see there are the different zones there so coming from the 87 bath you'll be walking through a meadow and there will be hopefully what we're talking about is having some equipment exercise equipment that's along the path like you would see in Portland there's a site in Portland that has a similar thing that back is going to be more of a it's not going to be a lawn it's going to be native plants so maybe a clover kind of a material or something we've been working with our arborist but also aceto is a landscaping design firm so they are recommending a whole host of native plants that have been vetted also by our arborist and then underneath is the gathering space and then the active space would be where people can walk and bring their bikes and leave them there. We had gone back and forth between whether or not we were going to allow vehicles in there, but I think we decided that we are not going to do that. But we would like to have a future pedestrian crossing there. So, you know, at the Jordan and Bath, we're going to have the pedestrian hybrid beacon that's being done by MDOT. We would like to have a second one here because from what I learned is that because of the connection,, the perimeter trail, people will see that and try to jump over and get over there. And we want this to be safe and we want it to be connected. And we did not want to build an island. We want people to be able to use it and use it safely. So that's something that we talked about, you know, maybe going back to MDOT and seeing if that's a possibility to partner with them on that. And then you can kind of just see that's just the planting plan with, you know, kind of the different trees and such, and we'll come back on all the specifics on that, but it should be pretty nice. We actually just had a staff meeting. We had our sort of initial pre-development meeting, and so we had all of the staff that we typically have in these meetings, like fire and planning and engineering, as well as economic development, of course. And so we're kind of on the path to taking that through. planning and development. Next slide, please. So that is kind of a picture of what we hope it will look like and we think it will look like once completed. And you've got the donation agreement in front of you. This is a donation agreement that we prepared for by doing the following kind of due diligence. We had a phase one. We did the phase one twice because it took so long to get them to agree and your phase one lapses after six months. We did get that done for free because we got a grant from MDOT twice. And then we also, as you recall, the site has a convenience store and we want to demolish that. And so we have to do what's called an HBMI, hazardous building materials inventory. And we've had our environmental consultant out there with this asbestos person. And we don't think we're going to see asbestos, but you still have to do it anyway before you can demolish something and remove. So that would be sort of the next step in this process once we receive the donation. So with that, I will take any questions. [3:26:21] Chair McDonald: Questions of council? Councilor Ellis. [3:26:23] Councillor Teemee: In your renderings you had there, not the renderings, but I guess the overhead maps, you sort of stopped short on the Bath Road side. yeah i'm assuming there's going to be an opening also developed on the currently existing fence so [3:26:36] Councillor Costello: that people yeah we'll have to well i mean this is just our concept on that piece we'll yeah we will definitely have a landing just like we did in fact we just went to mira and got those parcels pieces of land for the two landing parts at jordan and bath so we'll we'd have to do the same thing there okay yeah so there'll be a clear path for people to get over and be able to [3:26:58] Councillor Teemee: bike excellent and this has been i know you're originally from the baltimore this has been brunswick's blight for decades and so i so appreciate you taking this on and moving this because it has been bath road is a very heavily trafficked road everyone gets to drive by and see this thing completely graffitied for the last however many decades and it's it's great that we're moving on this so i really do support your actions on this thank you council parole [3:27:30] Councillor Ellis: a couple things one is with its location to the end of the runway i know there's some restrictions which is why that area which used to have stores yeah it's over an aquifer so both of [3:27:47] Councillor Costello: those cannot be developed so really that well my more my question is like you're developing it into [3:27:54] Councillor Ellis: a gathering place is there a restriction for that like to not be located at the end of a runway [3:28:00] Councillor Costello: no ease of emergency yeah we did take it through you know mira that i had to go to their board several times and we did take it and they had to go to the faa and make sure that was okay. We had to have heights because I didn't show that the drawings of the other one, but we were going to have a really neat sign that you can kind of walk up. That's like 14 feet tall that you can watch the planes. It says Cook's Corner. And yeah, so we had to take all that to [3:28:26] Councillor Ellis: the board. Perfect. Yeah. And the other is, I'm thinking about moms and their kids being there and it kind of seems like a area unto itself. And I'm just worried about like more like safety, not like traffic safety more like safety from and whether or not is it going to be fully visible from the road or are some of the plantings going to be blocking it i don't think the plantings will [3:28:56] Councillor Costello: be blocking we tried to move the trail back to a little bit further so it's not so it's not close to the road it's more a little i'm more thinking about like making sure that things are [3:29:07] Councillor Ellis: visible so that you know i worry if being blunt i don't want women and children and men to be attacked by someone because there's like tree planting or bush planting that is blocking [3:29:23] Councillor Costello: visibility from the road making it an unsafe area yeah no that's a good point and that's why we wanted to have some lighting under the under the shade structure but it's actually going to be a meadow so i mean we're gonna that's really what's gonna be all the way from jordan till you get to this site and then this site will have some trees around the periphery and some other plantings but we'll i'll make sure i you know bring that back to the team yeah question and then i'll grab you [3:29:51] Chair McDonald: just for point of logistics here so what we're debating tonight is just to accept the property i'm assuming that project i understand that 's directly related to that project but that project will come back to council for approval or is that already been approved in the cip i believe [3:30:07] Councillor Costello: well we'll come back because we don't have pricing right we 're i mean we'll have final pricing because we're going through planning and development but yeah today we're just asking for you to give the town manager the authority to move to continue on with the negotiation and then [3:30:18] Chair McDonald: execute the document perfect just making sure the scope of what we're talking about tonight [3:30:22] Councillor Perrault: counselor teamie and then hicks just from a safety standpoint it is right next to a house and then like the dairy bar right after it so it's not you know like completely out on its own and i think access wise is probably more visible than large swaths of the henderscoggin bike path although that also can be occasionally a comfortable concerning area just from that, like, solitariness of it. My question about the project, which I know this is a piece of, is, like, that area is often very dry. Like, it's a very hot area. I assume that would be why the drought seemed to affect it quite a lot. So we're talking about, like, you know, a grassy sort of area not just kind of the natural meadow type piece although i'm sure that's what's going to be around the path you're walking down but are we going to have to do like irrigation and stuff to keep it nice or like i think that the plants that are being chosen are going to be very [3:31:29] Councillor Costello: very low maintenance you know we are the parks and rec department has agreed to take it on excuse me for maintenance we were going to have a stone dust path but i think that the team decided that we should pave because that way more people can use it and they can also snow plow it in case I guess people may who knows cross-country ski whatever but that we would get more use out of it yeah I think there's one more slide I'm sorry and maybe I've already said what it was most of it but just that the due diligence and next step so I think I think I just mostly mentioned that the things that we did on the due diligence were the environmental phase one the opinion of value, the code site visit. We had to have actually codes come out there and make a determination about it's being blighted and not in good condition. And then we're advancing design and construction docs and then executing the donation agreement. That's all in red because that's all either behind us or that's happening today. Then, as I mentioned, we'll do the phase two, which is the HBMI survey. We'll be in planning and development review. That will take some several months. And then we will come back, Councilor Teamie, you're right, you know, with the authorization for the project for the proposed construction summer, fall of 2027 is what we hope to do. [3:32:50] Chair McDonald: Councilor Hicks, did you have a question? [3:32:52] Councillor Hicks: So at this point, there's been no, any of the expenses associated with this donation have been covered by MDOT money and there's no cost to the, any cost related to the donation transfer? [3:33:06] Councillor Costello: nothing with the with the donation we spent money on the design but that's come out on the design but yeah but the but with the on the site no we've got that as grants right and so the is there [3:33:19] Councillor Hicks: normally a cost to transferring the property that this company is donating that as well are they covering costs that we would ordinarily be covering that's a good point about the about [3:33:32] Town Manager: the transfer you know so there may be some minimal closing costs mostly title and that sort of thing to date we've been able to use the cooks corner revitalization money for all of these for the design of all of these projects [3:33:51] Councillor Hicks: so that's being covered by that tell me and that fund is that's not TIF that's [3:33:56] Town Manager: is it is cooks corner TIF money that has been previously appropriated for the [3:34:01] Councillor Hicks: the revitalization project as part of like this the design standard process as well is that all tied in yeah i mean this is coming out of that yeah because a lot of those sketches are coming out of that design standard document that was created well this is like this was one of the [3:34:16] Councillor Costello: specific things that came out of the cook's corner revitalization plan was activating these sites that are blighted or underutilized so these are three sites we picked to move forward [3:34:25] Councillor Hicks: yeah i think for the hearing actually if it's okay if you can refresh us i'm sorry [3:34:34] Chair McDonald: there isn't a hearing because we're just adopting a donation sorry yeah we're just [3:34:39] Councillor Hicks: at some point i think if we could get access to or just refresh us where that document is for the revival the cook's corner revitalization document because this has come up in cip and I was there for that, but that was a long time ago when we passed that revitalization document. It was a whole three years ago. So I think it's time to revisit that, too. Sure. Anyway, and tying in into this donation. All right. [3:35:06] Chair McDonald: I'm going to grab Counselor Ellis, and then I'm going to open the floor to public comment for this. [3:35:11] Councillor Teemee: Never mind. I was just going to offer to make a motion. [3:35:13] Chair McDonald: We got public comment on it. Very good. So without further ado, I'll open public comment. If anyone would like to speak on this item, same rules that I've been saying all night, three minutes, name and town of residence. Not seeing anyone sprinting up to the podium with glee and not seeing any hands going up on Zoom. I'm going to bring it back here to council for a motion, and I'll look over to Councillor Ellis for that. [3:35:37] Councillor Teemee: I'd like to make a motion to approve the town manager to work with Global Montello Group Corporation to execute a donation agreement to accept a land donation for 101 Bath Road. [3:35:46] Chair McDonald: Motion by Councillor Ellis, seconded by Councillor Ecker. or any further discussion on this motion? [3:35:52] Councillor Teemee: Councillor Ellis. Only just to set expectations. Having grown up in that area down off Jordan Avenue, I'll tell you that grass is always brown. It's a sand plain grass, and it's on a glaciated thing that goes back to the Ice Age. And so no matter how much you water that, you're not going to get green grass over there. So it'll probably stay the same. And I'm sure if Councillor Walker was here, he'd be able to tell us about the birds that love that type of thing. But I don't have that depth. [3:36:18] Donna Chael: Strangely enough, it used to be Pine Spring Water Company there. [3:36:21] Councillor Teemee: And they used to sell bottled soda. It was very nice. [3:36:24] Paul Whitcomb: Bottled soda, yes. I remember that well. [3:36:26] Chair McDonald: A beautiful walk down memory lane here. Any further discussion on this motion? Not seeing any. The two cents I'll throw in is, as the project ends up coming to fruition, which I hope it does because I think this is a great use of that space, is i would just be mindful and look at what parking bans on old bath road are because if there isn't going to be parking on site people might start parking on the side of the road there so something to keep them up yeah something to keep in mind as you keep going down that journey but that's a discussion for another you know day so i'll call the vote councillor ellis yes councillor ecker yes councillor perot yes councillor hicks yes councillor teamy yes councillor ween yes councillor wilson yes the chair is a yes that is unanimous of the council the motion passes thank you thank you moving on to consent agenda are there any questions about any of the items on the consent agenda counselor [3:37:23] Councillor Hicks: hicks just a quick question i don't know if there's anybody here who can answer this but how often or how rare is it to permit a holding tank for properties in brunswick so my understanding is it's pretty rare like i've never [3:37:41] Town Manager: ever seen it is sort of last resort this is because there's no better option it's better [3:37:48] Councillor Hicks: than what's currently happening i just noticed its location is right in buttermilk cove and it seems like a really tenuous place for that but i don't know what the rules are in maine or how like if there's a you know a certain amount of pump out that has to happen And so I'll do my due diligence and learn more about what we require, what the state requires. I'm sure it's a state requirement of how to manage that. Yeah, absolutely. [3:38:18] Chair McDonald: Okay, thanks. Any further questions about any of the items on the consent agenda? Not seeing any, I'll take a motion to approve the consent agenda. Counselor Teeming? Oh, yeah. It's just motion to approve the consent agenda. [3:38:35] Councillor Perrault: Oh, well, then, great. I motion to approve the consent agenda. [3:38:38] Chair McDonald: nailed it is there a second by counselor wilson this one's a show of hands all those in favor that is unanimous of the council present the motion passes the consent agenda is adopted i suppose before we adjourn i'm gonna do one last check-in just because we have a couple audience members here i'm just ensuring did any of you wish to speak for public comment i know we already had one speak for a couple did you hope to speak tonight oh do you want to you want to you want to tell us about the holding tank she's a what we did just to prove it yeah come on up here people are curious make sure to give your name and town of residence also the microphone is [3:39:32] Kristen Riccadoni: like not on sorry it should have a green light start all over good evening I'm Kristen Riccadoni I'm currently a resident of Greenville I actually spend a good portion of my life in Brunswick though. I know it well. I'm very fond of it. So I work on behalf of my husband, who's the agent of DERP LLC, the owner of Buttermilk. This has been a very special project to us. So I'm not a holding tank expert, except that in your consent decree, you do have a letter from our land use attorney, who is spelling out for you sort of why we believe this is in compliance. It's currently an unoccupied property cabins a house great potential beautiful spot but it's dilapidated and it's been just run down and derp llc's interest is to rehabilitate it 's currently the discharge that goes off board so and our site evaluator i believe this to be true and i can always verify given the way the cabins are situated and the land behind it, I don't think it had the potential option to do like septic field. So it's either the cabins continue to just sort of fall down on the shore or we take advantage of these development opportunities and we believe we are well within all the rules. We worked closely with Mike and Taylor and Code and so I believe we've checked all the boxes. So that's my basic understanding of why I do here. it's probably unusual but I think it's the uniqueness of the property and the weakness of the ability to do holding tank versus a full septic field I hope [3:41:08] Councillor Hicks: that's helpful yeah I'm curious and so it's being used for it says seasonal so does that mean like a summer they're seasonal that's how they were and that's that there's like multiple units multiple structures or just one [3:41:21] Kristen Riccadoni: there's multiple this application for this permit is just for one cabin and There are other cabins there. [3:41:30] Councillor Hicks: That don't have a whole, they're not going to be occupied because they don't have a, or they do have some sort of septic system. [3:41:37] Kristen Riccadoni: They do not either. Okay. So it's likely you see me back here another day with another application or two or three or four potentially. [3:41:45] Councillor Hicks: But it's a summer cottage. It's not for full-time residents. Correct. Okay. You're welcome. [3:41:53] Chair McDonald: Thank you so much for sticking it out for the night with us, just so you could answer these two-minute primetime questions. [3:42:01] Kristen Riccadoni: Thank you for having me. [3:42:03] Chair McDonald: So thank you for coming up to the podium. I will now entertain a motion to adjourn. Motion by Councilor Wilson. Is there a second? Second. Oh, gosh. We'll go with Councilor Ellis. All those in favor, show of hands. That is unanimous of Council presence. Good night, everyone.