← Back to MaineScanner

Brunswick Shellfish Committee votes on winter conservation closures and harvest limits

2026-11-12 · 49m · Source: 2026.11.12 Shellfish Committee (Town of Brunswick (TV3 Cablecast))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. I'd like to officially call the November 12th, 2026 Shelfish Committee meeting to order. And we'll start with our roll call of members. I'll start over here to the right. [0:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Emily Stone, Coastal Resource Technician. [0:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Jason Serenello, Commercial Harvester. [0:29] Speaker D (unidentified): Laura DiBiase, Resident Non-Licensed. [0:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Lisa Trombley, Resident Non-Licensed. [0:35] Speaker E (unidentified): Chris Blosser, Shelfish Warden. [0:38] Speaker F (unidentified): Audrey Kubler, resident, recreational harvester. Max Purtis, commercial harvester. [0:44] Speaker G (unidentified): And on Zoom is Kathy Wilson, representative from the town council. [0:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Welcome, Kathy, and welcome, Audrey. Glad to have another member. We're missing Marco, and we're missing Dan, and we're missing Fran. So under the confirming that the notice of the meeting was properly noted, We don't have her in here to confirm that but I did see it noticed on the on the public On our site and okay, and I'm being told by staff that it was Okay, and we have no Warden report Under the coastal resource office update there is an update on the ordinance language But I 'm gonna I'm gonna bump that for a minute because I'm not seeing that language here and I'm gonna have to dig for it Town clerk update, none. A couple of upcoming meetings, the Milford Aquaculture Seminar held in Shelton, Connecticut, January 11th to 13th. If anybody wants any more information on this or the next meeting, the Interstate Shelfers Sanitation Conference biannual meeting in Newport, Rhode Island, January 24th to 29th. You can reach out to Dan. in. Our October 6th meetings of the minute. I also don't have those because Franny is not here so we will defer those to the next meeting. Does anybody have any adjustments to our very lengthy meeting? Oh it should be pretty short sweet. Oh Marco's here. Marco Melendi. Thank you so much for joining us. He snuck in behind me. Do we have any public comment and non-agenda item? Are you guys all here to talk about the agenda item all right so item number 67 the committee will discuss possible conservation closures and before we get into the nuts and bolts of this i just want to kind of point out that i've kind of heard some word on the street that there are some people that are upset about this and i know sometimes this committee can take a lot of flack for being in control of these openings and closures. For the record, we had no meeting scheduled for this month. We didn't have anything for an agenda and this meeting was brought to order because of harvester input. A few harvesters had been talking with Max Burtis about possibly wanting some conservation. So that's what brings us here tonight. I'm going to turn it over to Max, to give us some of the information that he received, and then I have some information here on some proposed options for us, and then we can also write down any others that anybody else has, and then we can go from there. Does that sound all right with everybody? All right. Max, you're up. [3:38] Speaker F (unidentified): Thank you, Chair. So, yeah, a couple of harvesters approached me, and, yeah, definitely concerned about the amount of product that's out there. And if it would last as hard as we're working it, and if it would last all the way through the winter, and into the summer, like, are we going to get good digging come June, July, August when the price is up where most of us really count on that for the bulk of our income or are we going to smoke it before then? And the other the other thought was all right if we don't do conservation some sort of conservation measure are we going to have to roll back licenses and folks don't want to lose their license and so that's what I heard from folks we've tossed around a couple different options I think we'll be discussing those a little bit later but just my personal thoughts from what I can see I think some sort of conservation measure is in order yeah to see if we can make what we have last a little bit longer hopefully into next season and then also yeah not have to cut licenses we don't want ideally not to do that I mean that is a conservation measure we can do. We've done it in the past, but yeah, it would be great to do other conservation measures so we don't have to take people's livelihoods away. [5:20] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, thank you for that. Unfortunately, since I can't seem to find the update on the ordinance language, unless staff has that, do you have that with you? [5:30] Speaker B (unidentified): So Outlook crashed, like, all day, and I was trying to get the most updated version of the agenda that Dan had sent out, It was on Outlook. I couldn't get it, so I went into our folder. This was the most recently saved version, but I think the one Dan sent out, we removed that and pushed it to the next meeting in December. [5:50] Speaker A (unidentified): I just think it's important to note that the language that we're discussing here, at least some of it, has to do with that line item that Dan put in there to allow us to bypass the surveys next year and leave licensing as is. So next year, 2027's licenses are not immediately in danger of being reduced. I believe DMR had signed off on this proposal. We shouldn't have any problem getting it passed to town council that all current harvesters will be allowed to have their license next year. But I think we're all aware that we need to look beyond that, right? Like this is a very delicate matter. If we don't handle it properly, the future licenses could be at risk. And I don't know about the rest of you, but I don't have a crystal ball to see what the future brings, how Mother Nature may help us, et cetera, or hurt us. And it's kind of an uncomfortable conversation for us to have, honestly. I don't think anybody wants to be responsible for taking anybody's bread and butter away for the winter or screw it up for the future. So that's why we're here. Before I open it up to you gentlemen. I just want to throw out the current proposals or suggestions that have been brought up thus far. Dan had sent out his suggestions and one of them was a complete closure from January 1st to March 31st and I need to point out that this is in reference to soft shell clams only. Quahogs would not be impacted by any ordnance change or closure that we make tonight. The other suggestion that he made was a four-day harvest Monday through Thursday which would start December 1st and go through to the end of April or to the end of May. We obviously we have the no action option. My husband suggested that perhaps that there rather than closing the number of harvest days, we think about closing particular bays to protect those bays. He suggested Catlin, Penneville, McQuaid, and Bunganet. I worry that if we close specific bays that we may be pushing all the harvesters to the open bays and stressing those, so we need to discuss that. And then a fifth one that was kind of punted around between me and Jason and my husband, off the record was to do a four-day harvest week, Monday through Thursday, up until the 1st of January, and then in January do a three-month closure on a couple of bays like Catlin and Penneville. I'm not sure why you guys didn't mention McQuaid on that. I think McQuaid's been hit the hardest, so I would think that would be an area of focus. But again, we're all here to brainstorm and see what, if anything, needs to be done to try to conserve the valuable resource that we had out there. So I will now open it up to the floor, and we'll see if we can get any other ideas, and then we'll go from there. [9:01] Speaker G (unidentified): I can't see anybody except for you, Lisa, on the Zoom, other than the people on Zoom, but I can't see anybody else when they're speaking. Okay, nobody [9:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Nobody had stepped up yet. We just had our first one to the podium. But I couldn't even see even one of the other committee members. Oh, the other committee members. Okay. [9:18] Speaker G (unidentified): Jim's working on it. All right. Just it's good to see who's chatting. All right. You're welcome. [9:29] Speaker A (unidentified): So, Kathy, he just advised me that they're doing some swap over of equipment or software, and this is going to be what we have to work with tonight, and it won't be fixed until midweek. [9:39] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay. Sorry about that. Oh, I understand. Okay. No problem. I'll deal with it. All right. I should have come. [9:52] Speaker H (unidentified): Go ahead, Lee. Blaine, Commercial Harvester. I think what I would do is just I'd probably shut down from Simpsons Point to Coffins Point, which is Cal and Shore. You know, everything that's really the only place that's really been getting dug pretty hard and give that time to heal. The four days, shutting it down to four days a week. I think it's kind of dumb. I mean, how many days? I just had four or five days off. I mean, light is doing its job on that right now. So I think the most that really needs rest is Middle Bay. I haven't been over to Pennville, but I would think we've got to leave some options for people to harvest if you shut down all this area. And McQuaid Bay and Bunganut, I don't think that needs to be shut down. There's not a lot of product over there, so you might be able to scratch some up and maybe some people that are trying to get out and harvest can find something if we do close Middle Bay down. [11:09] Speaker A (unidentified): So, Blaine, for those of us who are not out on the water all the time, would you be able to give me a better idea? You said from Simpsons to Coffin. What common bay names would I be including? [11:24] Speaker H (unidentified): I mean, it's Middle Bay. Okay. But I'm pretty sure Pentonville is included in Middle Bay, isn't it? So [11:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Middle Bay and then these are like clear coves, right? [11:34] Speaker H (unidentified): So basically Simpsons Point. I don't even know what's in Clay Cove. I mean, I don't even know if that needs to be closed. But basically, from Miller Point to Coffins Point, but you could close. play Cove because I did get it hard. That's just what I'm thinking. I don't know. There's a few other guys that are in here that can get up and speak and say their opinions. [12:02] Speaker F (unidentified): Chair, may I ask a follow-up question? Sure. How long would you close it? [12:08] Speaker H (unidentified): I would do what you're recommending. January 1st, April, May-ish. And maybe just through the winter, if it's mild, just check back in on it. but we're definitely going to want something for summer. Yeah. [12:27] Speaker I (unidentified): Marco, go ahead. I'd like to ask a follow-up question to Blaine. When you say that you don't know if they need to be protected, is that because you don't feel the resource was hurt that bad in that particular location, or you don't feel there's any resource left to protect? [12:41] Speaker H (unidentified): There's no resource. I mean, there's resource. You can poke around and get some, but, I mean, most diggers are going to go where they can make the most they can, and that's probably not the area. But if they want to run out and get 30 pounds, they might probably can scratch that up. [12:59] Speaker I (unidentified): I was hoping you were going to identify some areas that may not have been hit so bad, but wishful thinking. [13:05] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't think there's too many of that, unfortunately. [13:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other harvesters have any suggestions they'd like to share? [13:22] Speaker J (unidentified): Kevin Rogers, Brunswick Digger. I was just wondering, is there anybody who'd want to close it for a couple months until, like, March 8th? and then go to a five-day work week. I mean, there's some clams out there, but, I mean, it'd be nice to give it a break. That's just my opinion. [13:47] Speaker A (unidentified): I think a lot of times people are like, well, winter's coming and Mother Nature will give us that break, but we've had milder winters, so there's no guarantee, right? Or between. Right. Kevin, you, so I think what they were saying made it a little hard for me to hear. Could you just repeat what your very first part was? What was your closing from January 1st till like March 8th? And your recommendation would be like everything during that time? Yeah, okay, all right, thank you, Brian. [14:29] Speaker K (unidentified): Toothaker shellfish harvester, I kind of agree with Kevin because I mean if you just close certain bays down you're going to put a lot of pressure on the other bays. So if you just do like a all closure then there's no pressure and then five day work week mostly people probably go to Catlin Shore because that's where the majority of the clams are. But if you shut like that just that bay down everybody will go to the places they can go. Did are you going to leave co-hogging open year-round was or just was this just soft shells [15:01] Speaker A (unidentified): you were talking about or the whole thing. So this particular discussion we're having around soft off shelves whether or not we want to change anything on those but the standing quahog ordinance would be the same and so we lose that the end of December okay yeah and then I'm I would [15:17] Speaker K (unidentified): start if the full closure probably in January to March and then you could kind of see the die off of the quahogs too whether they whether they make it or not and then kind of decide but five-day work week after that probably sounds good. Yeah, I kind of agree with that. So, yep. [15:38] Speaker A (unidentified): I wish somebody here had a calendar of all the harvest days and stuff. I don't know how the committee is thinking about this. I'm not saying I disagree with it. We do have to look out for the resource and protect that. I do worry, though, that there's, what, 66 licensed harvesters, and we have five, six, seven here in the room with us tonight. I know there's probably some that are not going to be able to go three months without a paycheck. So I'm wondering if we have other options. Jason? [16:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, it is hard to get through the winter, and we're heading towards Christmas. And I think that we have to keep some flats open for the harvesters to harvest. And did I understand that DMR wasn't going to allow us to shut the entire down? [16:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I was going to elaborate on that, too. I didn't look into the validity of it, so I don't know if our staff member here has any information on that, but I had heard that Ari's on here. Ari, do you know if there is a DMR ruling that prevents the town from closing all the flats down? [16:50] Speaker L (unidentified): I think this is a unique situation because the circumstances surrounding the bloom, that would ultimately be probably Ben's decision. I don't know if there would be something preventing a complete townwide closure. Sure, but I can certainly, I'm taking notes, so I can add that to my to-do list and get back to you. [17:19] Speaker A (unidentified): I would appreciate an answer regardless of how we choose tonight so that we know in the future. Sure. Thank you. I appreciate that. I don't know. I honestly don't feel comfortable about closing downtown wide. I don't know if anybody supports me on that, but to tell individuals, I mean, I know there could be the argument, well, you should have dug hard this summer. You should have this, you should have that, but I'm not here to try to figure out people's bills are and what they need and what they did or didn't save. I just know the people need to eat, they need to stay warm, on if there's absolutely zero opportunity for them to go out and do that, I think, I think that's pretty harsh. So I'm kind of hoping that maybe we can come up with some hybrid model of this. You guys can help me with that. [18:07] Speaker C (unidentified): I think a good hybrid model would be to shut our heaviest seed sets and our harvestable flats for January, February, and March. But having it be our most valuable set, I think it should be monitored somehow by the harvesters, maybe open one day a week, so that if we notice a lot of mortality or something going on, that we can come back to the committee and see if it can be opened. Because we don't want to lose it to anything, and if we notice it being [18:46] Speaker A (unidentified): How does everybody feel about, I originally had read off some of the options we had here, and one that had been thrown out there, option number five, was that we run a four-day week from now until the end of the year, and then after that do some closures of some areas, or we could do, we could still, we could implement closures of some of those areas that you're recommending now to have the best seed set to protect those now, and do a four-day, you know, work for what's, what's open, what's remaining, Blaine. Looks like he might have come up with an [19:24] Speaker H (unidentified): idea. No, I just wanted to question the four-day, four-day week work, like with how limited time we have, are we even getting that already? So if we go to four days a week, you might only end up getting two days in one week when you could have got four. Mm-hmm. So has anybody looked at the tide chart to really make a definite answer [19:48] Speaker A (unidentified): for that? I could have sworn that Dan had provided something. Wasn't it like 91 [19:53] Speaker B (unidentified): days? So Outlook is working on my phone. I don't know, I wasn't working on my computer, but I'm looking at Dan's email that he had sent out earlier in the week. If we do the four-day harvest, he did Monday through Thursday. He said it would eliminate 72 qualifying tides and 65 harvestable days, representing approximately a 40% reduction in available low tide opportunities. It would retain 106 qualifying tides across 93 harvestable days, and that was a time period if we did it, if we transitioned to that four-day harvest, four-day, four-day harvest weeks, from December 1st through May 15th. [20:42] Speaker H (unidentified): Right, yes, that's what I was thinking, but how does that give Middle Bay a break if we do that? I thought, were we just talking about going to four days a week from now till January 1st? Is that what you were saying, or were you saying in general from now till March? [21:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Anything is on the floor right now. I think I'm hearing that we'd like to pick a couple of areas for full closure at some point. Maybe not now, but at least by January. And then we still have the potential of, rather than shutting everything down, at least giving some opportunity for the guys to pray for the sun to come out and be able to go out there and chip it away a little bit, something. So I mean, boy, it's, it's tough, I mean, right, like we want something in the spring, but summer would be well, right, well, we need, I say spring because I know that's when they're gonna start to wake up and reproduce and, you know, come back to life, and we start seeing those numbers. That we need, but yes, summer is when, you know, you guys really make bank, so the, I mean, we could, somebody help remind me, are we still digging Sundays right now? Sundays are open, right? I think so. We could go, if nobody likes the four day. [22:09] Speaker D (unidentified): We could always do a five day. Laura, I would like to propose a complete closure starting January 1st to March 1st, with a provision that we would revisit somewhere around March 1st and see if it. [22:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Needs to continue to be closed. Hey guys, can you keep it down, please? Just, thank you. All right, so you're saying a full closure from January 1st to March 30th, to March 1st, not the 31st, just March. [22:38] Speaker D (unidentified): 1st, right, okay, and then revisiting close to March 1st to see if there needs to be continued closure or if, you know, we can open things back up again. So it would be closed January and February, the. [22:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Entire flats, and no conservation from now until then, is your proposal. Does anybody feel comfortable giving a second on that one? I would just wonder if Laura would. [23:04] Speaker F (unidentified): Consider adding a weekend closure after that. We do want a crop there to harvest in the summer. And if we are reducing effort a little bit in the spring, I think it. [23:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Could really help harvest for the summer. So you would say adding on to this proposal that once it reopens March 1st, it would only open for five days a week. [23:31] Speaker D (unidentified): I think that's acceptable. [23:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody want to give that a second for a vote or do we want to continue to hash this around? [23:45] Speaker F (unidentified): I can second it. [23:48] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion on this motion? [23:52] Speaker C (unidentified): I would like to make clear you want to have a full closure of Brunswick, all the flats for January and February. [24:03] Speaker A (unidentified): We also have to take in consideration if this is what we determined to do, we are not even sure we are within DMR's rights to do so. [24:12] Speaker F (unidentified): I am not inclined to want to close. [24:16] Speaker A (unidentified): That many months so we get what we'll do is we'll I'll listen to Brian it's kind of a little out of order here but I'll go ahead and let Brian speak it's fine and then we'll take a vote on this one and if it doesn't pass then we'll throw something else at the at the problem okay. [24:31] Speaker K (unidentified): Brian go ahead the other option too is in the spring is putting more pressure on if the co-hogs live through the winter is putting more pressure on the co-hogs and then maybe closing the clams in the springtime and then opening them in the summertime because you get the price of clams go the more up like a quahogs you know 20 cents 22 cents there's not much of a difference in a harvest between that and 26 cents but when you get a like you know 110 to 160 170 it's a lot more of a difference so. maybe we could look if there's not much of a die-off and put the pressure on the quahogs in the spring but I you know I had agreed with trying to close more in the winter if you could but leaving December 's you know a relatively good price I just don't want to close things open them in the spring and dig them for nothing to for clams I don't mind digging quahogs lower because like I said the swings are not as much there with the price but the clams are you make way more in the summer than you Do. [25:37] Speaker A (unidentified): In the spring. Well a couple other things to take into consideration too is one is that no matter what we vote on tonight we can come back next month if we need to. We can come back in January if we need to and come back in February. We can continue to monitor the search situation and we can change it as needed. And the other thing too is I wouldn't automatically assume that clams are going to be a lower price in the spring. Hey guys. Really hard to hear up here. Okay, you know, the entire eastern seaboard was hit by this bloom, right? So clams have been hit everywhere, not just Brunswick. So I expect that there's a, it's going to be a higher price on clams overall. They're just going to be that much harder to get. So let's not jump ahead to, you know, making those sorts of observations. We got a motion on the board on the floor. [26:34] Speaker I (unidentified): Can I ask one question about the comment you just made about we can come back every month and reassess? What's the reaction time? Let's say we decide to, in a month, change things. How long does it take to, since we need DMR? [26:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, as we found with this bloom, DMR was pretty responsive to us. We asked for a closure, and we had it within 48 hours, I think it was, maybe even less. And then the reopening was surprisingly quick, too. I was told six to ten days, and I think, again, we had it within 48 to 72 hours tops. They turned it around pretty quick. So shutting things down, opening things up don't seem to be that complicated. They're being done on an emergency basis. Yes, go ahead. Sorry. [27:16] Speaker L (unidentified): All right. Yeah. The, I don't know if that timeline would apply for future closures and reopenings, given that the bloom, you know, has essentially ended. So if you were to come back, you know, in the middle of February or something and want an opening, my instinct is that the normal timeline would apply and that would be 20 days notice before closure or an opening. [27:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Well, that is good to know. Then I should never make assumptions, should I? Thank you for that, Ari. Yeah. All right. Well, let's get to the motion that's on the table. I'd like to see if this is going to pass, which was a complete closure. You want me to just reiterate what the... [28:00] Speaker I (unidentified): I'm sorry, I just wanted to go on the record and say I understand the impetus behind this, but I'm just a little concerned about the potential for shutting some harvesters that maybe did plan on harvesting and then having now no source of, you know, zero source of income from that. I just don't want to, I'm concerned about that potential hardship. That's okay. [28:23] Speaker A (unidentified): We'll just take the vote. If it doesn't pass, we'll put our heads back together and see if we can come up with something else. So the motion that Laura made was a complete closure townwide from January 1st until March 1st. All those in favor, raise your hand. Oh, I'm sorry. And adding upon the opening, yes, upon opening it back up in March, we would do a five-day harvest week. Anybody in favor of that? [28:51] Speaker F (unidentified): We might need to put an end to the five-day harvest week as well. Like five days. [28:57] Speaker A (unidentified): For how long? Yeah, maybe till June 1st. All right, are you, would you like to amend that to be the five day of harvest week until June 1st? Yes, okay. Is anybody in favor of that proposal? Okay, opposed? Okay, so that one didn't pass. So let's scratch out some other things. I mean, I feel personally we should leave some flats in town open year round, at least in some capacity. I mean, even if we're, this is, this is really detrimental. Leave it open two or three days a week, give a guy a chance to go out and make a few bucks. I think, I don't think that we should be able to sit here and determine somebody else's livelihood if there is still some product out there, if we can, If we can make this work, if we can accommodate allowing the need to harvest a little over the winter and still saving our resource, that's what I hope to bring out of this meeting. [29:59] Speaker H (unidentified): Blaine? I would just recommend what I said from Miller Point or Simpsons Point right down to Coffins Point. That leaves plenty of options for people to go find some clams. Clams, it's our most resourceful bay right now, so to protect that one area for prime time digging, I would say that's what I would do. I mean, there's, there's other digging out there. Are you including [30:24] Speaker E (unidentified): middle bay in that, like to the Harpswell line? You just keep saying Simpson's, well, Simpson's Point [30:30] Speaker H (unidentified): south. Okay, so that would have Miller Point in it, all the way down, everything down. Yeah. Yep. And then, I mean, we have this whole side of town. We have Bull Rock open in the 15th, which there's not a lot, but it will spread some people out for a few days. There's some clams in Bunganot. There's, I don't know about McQuaid. I haven't been over there. But there's still a lot of area left around. I mean, I talked to Dan. I came in the other day and talked to him, and he said he was all for just shutting Middle Bay down. So I don't know. I told him I would leave options open for other people to dig, and he was like, this sounds good. I think that's pretty simple. And then do what Max said, five days a week or whatever. And then if price gets good and the clamming looks decent, go open it back up to maybe six days. [31:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, go ahead, Jason. Blaine, I don't know if you know, but I've heard that there was a seed set in Pentaville. Do you think that shutting down from Pentaville in Middle Bay right through to Coffin? [31:50] Speaker H (unidentified): I mean, there is a good amount of clams up in there. You could shut Pentaville down too, but if people want to dig clams, they're going to find some. I don't know. Pentaville is an option. It's too bad there's not more people in here to really say what they would think about it. I'm down for shutting it down right for the winter. [32:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Jason, yeah, I think that Penneville has a set in it. I don't think it's ready yet, so I think that including it could help. [32:28] Speaker C (unidentified): I'd have a proposal. I think that we should shut Penneville and Middle Bay down for January, February, and March as long and leave the rest of the town open the four-day work week, but allow the harvesters to go out on Fridays to Middle Bay and to Penneville to monitor the clams that are out there if the tides work and if the weather works. I [33:03] Speaker F (unidentified): like that. I might even be inclined to, I mean, like, I'd love to save that whole shore for prime time, you know, if we can't prime time digging, you know, come it like extended a little bit further into the into the spring to, so we know we have something for June, July, August, right? And I agree, but I think that monitor because [33:30] Speaker C (unidentified): yeah, I've had my license since 2020, and in those six years I've seen two vital plankton blooms and milky ribbon worms, blood worms, green crabs that can take it over, and if there's no harvesters, they're monitoring at all, yeah, then we could just be losing it to any of those things and sitting on the shore looking [33:51] Speaker F (unidentified): looking at it, especially if, yeah, if we do extend it a little bit further into the spring, then those risks increase, and you really need to have, you know, good tabs on it. You're saying if [34:02] Speaker A (unidentified): nobody's out there, no eyes on it, yeah. So originally we talked about Catlin in this and then Bunganuck. I know sometimes you guys interchange names, so somebody want to want to tell me if we want to, I consider Penn, yeah, Penneville, Middle Bay, Catlin, and Bunganuck. [34:25] Speaker C (unidentified): I don't think there's a need to close Bunganuck or McCoy. There's not a lot of harvestable product there right now. [34:32] Speaker A (unidentified): And what about Catlin? I know it's been getting hit pretty hard. [34:34] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, we would include Catlin in that. That's my understanding of the proposal. That would be included in that from Miller Point to Coffin Point that Blaine had talked about. [34:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Man, I should have brought a map. Okay, so make sure you understand yours, Jason. You would be, you're making a proposal right, of to close Middle Bay, Pennaville, and Calin, and is there other little coves in between Miller and Coffin that Blaine was talking about, just kind of that area? Okay, so that area for the months of January, February, and March, and from now until then we're going to leave every, everything else open. [35:24] Speaker C (unidentified): On a four day, is that what you're proposing? My proposal is Middle Bay and Pennaville on a one day a week from just from December 1st to March 1st, so that it can be monitored by the harvesters, and then the rest of the town open Monday through Friday, so Middle Bay and Pennaville would only be open Fridays. Does [35:59] Speaker A (unidentified): anybody want to second that one? This one sounds complicated. [36:06] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, so I just want to be clear, so by opening Fridays in the bay it's open to harvesting, not just monitoring, right? Yeah. [36:16] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm not sure the guys would want to just go out there and just poke around, right? You've got to get someone to go out there and kind of see what's out there and maybe pick up a bushel or two. Yes, go ahead. I will say, [36:27] Speaker B (unidentified): and Chris, feel free to jump in too, we do, as the Coastal Resource Office, do spring mortality assessments when we're going out and poking around in each of the coves to look for winter mortality, and we do a real rough estimate of populations and size distribution in that too, and that happens starting in April. [36:46] Speaker A (unidentified): So yeah, it was, he's, he's proposing something between December and March, and you guys don't go out during that time period, right? So he's just thinking some eyes out on those bays from the harvesters, and I mean, if they, if you guys want to go out and do that, I don't see a reason unless [37:03] Speaker C (unidentified): somebody else wants to throw something out. It may be very few days too, because first the tides have work and the weather. So we'd be lucky if we got [37:14] Speaker I (unidentified): one, maybe two a month. So if Jason's motion is on [37:18] Speaker A (unidentified): The table, I'll second it. You'll second that. Alright, so everybody understands and make sure that I understand this correctly, that beginning December 1st, we would go to a four-day harvest week, Monday through Thursday, and close Penneville, Middle Bay, and Catlin Shore and that would be, it's being proposed to go through to March 1st. Is that correct? And then after March 1st revert back to what we have right now or we can just, we can assess it and see if it needs to be changed? [37:56] Speaker C (unidentified): I believe that we should be able to assess it at that [37:58] Speaker A (unidentified): point and hopefully we've, the harvest have been out there. And keep in mind that we as Ari is saying we need about a 20 day window to open it back up. All right so we have Jason's and Marco has second that I have a question yeah are we scratching the Friday one day a week idea no I just omitted that see I said we need to be all on the same page so December 1st to March 1st closure of Pennville Middle Bay Catlin Shore Monday through Thursday harvesting, with the exception of Fridays, can go to Penneville, Middle Bay, or Catlin Shore. Now, am I correct? [38:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. Could I try to simplify it a little bit and say Harpswell town line in Middle Bay, in Penneville, all the way along that shore to where on our harvest area map, when we're reporting our harvest, where that Catlin Shore, Miller Creek zone ends, which is Coffin Point, what we've been calling Coffin Point, that would be the closure area. [39:10] Speaker A (unidentified): When we start to get down into nitty-gritty, I don't know about you, Laura, and some of us that don't dig, but I think this would have to be maybe a Chris and Dan thing. [39:21] Speaker I (unidentified): We just need to be able to defend the lines. [39:25] Speaker E (unidentified): This is all Middle Bay. That includes Barnes, Clay Cove, Miller Creek. There's Catlin Shore that's the point [39:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Alright so pretty definitive now I'll let you get a visual on that but so long as Chris and Dan and everybody feel comfortable with those lines okay so we have that proposal motion rather and Marco has seconded it is there any more discussion [39:50] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm sorry I think I need to see this written down can you repeat it again and I'll just type it down so I can like look at this and make sure I'm fully understanding it [39:58] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, I'll try one more time. Beginning December 1st and through March 1st, the motion is to close Penneville, Middle Bay, and Catlin Shore with the adjustments of the lines that you proposed to be determined by our resource officer with a four-day harvest week of Monday through Thursday. And Fridays, you would be able to go in and harvest in Penneville, Middle Bay, and Catlin. [40:32] Speaker F (unidentified): So there's like an exception to that full shutdown in that area for Fridays through that time frame. And then the rest of the town will be open four days a week. [40:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Correct. Gotcha. So that is the motion that we have now. Is there any more discussion or would we like to vote on this option? [40:55] Speaker C (unidentified): I mean, if anybody thought that a January, February, March time frame would work better and leave December open before Christmas and the holidays, I don't know if that might be better for the harvesters. [41:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Go ahead, Audrey. Yeah, I'm all for shrinking the time frame if it was January instead of December. I would, I still think that it's a really valuable, like I think December is a really valuable month, can be, weather's still good, get a little bit of boost in price, but I think I would want to trade that month and actually push, take that month and add it to the end of March, so we, so we close all of January, February, and March except Fridays and then in those areas. And then the rest of town, because, yeah, I think, especially if we don't get ice, that it could use the rest in the month of March. [41:52] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, so there's food for thought. But we do have Jason's motion on the table, so we would need to actually not vote that through. If anybody's thinking they prefer, or did you want to amend yours? [42:03] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah, I'd like to amend that. If we shut down Middle Bay and Pentaville January, February, and March, right? [42:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, instead of December through March. You're now amending it to say January, February, March. Yeah, open Fridays only. Marco, are you still willing to second that motion? Okay? [42:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, and with the four-day harvest, so Monday through Thursday for the rest of the town during that same time frame. Okay, I think we're all on the same page. [42:35] Speaker E (unidentified): Does it make sense to make the rest of the town Monday through Friday? So that Friday is not everybody's going back to these areas. We're trying to conserve. Right. It's a good idea. Yeah, Friday technically by that, the way that's worded, you can only dig in those areas on Fridays. [42:50] Speaker I (unidentified): Or open or change the Friday to a Thursday. So you still have that shortened week, rather that rather than carving out Middle Bay on Friday. I like that a lot. [43:02] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, Marco if we Sophie Jason, what do you think of that? So to switch your Friday to a Thursday? [43:08] Speaker A (unidentified): That actually does, excuse me, that actually does make sense, Jason, because say if you're like I'll go out to Middle Bay and see if there's anything out there, and you're picking around and there's nothing, you're like well I'm going to pick up and go to Catlin while Catlin's technically closed because we're on a Monday through Thursday rotation, I [43:25] Speaker C (unidentified): would really like to see a five-day work week for the harvesters. Somehow I feel like, you know, have the whole town open Monday through Friday, but you're able to dig Middle Bay if you can get out there and weather and tides permit on Fridays, but still have five day work week for the harvesters so they can dig anywhere in town [43:46] Speaker A (unidentified): monday through friday monday thursday you proposed your motion was anywhere's money through thursday and then on friday you would only be able to go to those three areas okay so [44:00] Speaker C (unidentified): So could I amend that one more time? [44:02] Speaker A (unidentified): You can, or you can stick with what you've got. [44:05] Speaker C (unidentified): I'd like to leave Harveston open Monday through Friday throughout the whole town with the ability to go to Middle Bay and Pentaville on Fridays to harvest and monitor by the harvesters. [44:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Is Marco still on board for that? Because I think Marco thought he was seconding a four-day work week. [44:27] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, so that essentially means we're just removing one day. [44:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, we would be removing four days a week from the proposed closure areas. That would be the gist of the nuts and bolts. [44:43] Speaker I (unidentified): I think the difference between the two isn't huge for me, and so if there's a practical benefit for the harvesters to go with the five-day, as long as essentially the Middle Bay and Penneville, as was defined, is closed, I'm still fine with that. [45:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so I think we've achieved the bulk of what we wanted to do. So we've changed dates and we've changed. So let me see if I get this right. Jason, your motion is for the months of January, February, and March to have a five-day Monday through Friday harvest week, with Friday being the only day that you can harvest in Penneville, Middle Bay, and Catlin. Yes. And Marco, you're still on board with that? Yep. Okay. And I'm just going to say area to be defined by marine resources. Does this sound all right? Everybody okay with that? We've got it all recorded. We've got all our notes. They'll define the exact markers and get the information to the harvesters if we choose to go with this. We all right with that? Any more discussion? All right, all those in favor of this motion raise your hand. [46:00] Speaker J (unidentified): Those.
Unfinished Business
[46:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Opposed. That one passes. Okay, nothing's going to be perfect, I don't think, no matter what we come up with. I'm sure we're going to please everybody, but we do have, we do have the ability to continue to monitor and bring it back if we need to and go from there. Hopefully the town can get some additional sampling before things freeze up for the winter. Move on real quick to anybody have anything in a new business title it 68. No old business. I was going to try to picket this a little bit, but since we don't have Dan or Fran here, I'm not going to bring it up for a discussion. I just want to let everybody know I have not forgotten that we still have this potential desire to be able to change our licenses so that they can move out of town. And I think we need to make a decision as a committee as to whether or not we are going to pursue that avenue or if we're going to just shut it down. Because if we're going to pursue it, I'd like to do that over the winter and get going on that. Anyway, having said that, I'll ask Franny to put that on the agenda for next month to discuss. And if now is not a good time on the heels of this boom, I still think it's worthy of a discussion. We don't necessarily have to implement it now. But we could find out the task force if we decide to get that together, just determining whether or not we're going to have enough ammunition to even make it worthy to continue, I guess, is the way that I'm looking at it. So item 70, setting the December meeting agenda. Does anybody have anything that they'd like to see on that? [47:58] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think there's a chance that we might want to continue the weekend closure into the spring a little bit more. So I just, I would like to discuss that a little bit. There's a chance that in that discussion that we find that we want to wait and see as well. But I'd like to just keep it on the, on the table as a conservation measure for the, for the spring. [48:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Would it be good to just maybe have a line item on our agenda every month for us to just discuss findings? Anybody wants to bring it up in the various areas? We can discuss it. Like if guys are out there poking around at Penneville and whatever on those Fridays, then we could just, or maybe Franny has some landings reports that we can, maybe we could just make a little line item there for a quick report. Anybody think that would be beneficial? Okay, I'll ask her to do that. All right, well if there's nothing else I guess we have a motion to adjourn. I'll second it. All right, everybody in favor? Opposed? All right, have a good night and thank you for all those who zoomed in. Thank you.